{ "Summary": "The paper presents SepFormer, a novel transformer-based model for spectral domain image classification, demonstrating promising results on various datasets.", "Strengths": [ "Introduces a new architecture (SepFormer) tailored to spectral image processing.", "Shows competitive performance on multiple datasets." ], "Weaknesses": [ "Limited analysis on generalization capabilities.", "Potential limitations in real-world scenarios are not thoroughly addressed." ], "Originality": 4, "Quality": 3, "Clarity": 4, "Significance": 4, "Questions": [ "How does SepFormer perform on unseen or real-world spectral data?", "What are the potential limitations and how can they be mitigated?" ], "Limitations": "The paper should provide more analysis on generalization capabilities and potential limitations in real-world scenarios.", "Ethical Concerns": false, "Soundness": 3, "Presentation": 4, "Contribution": 4, "Overall": 19, "Confidence": 4, "Decision": "accept with conditions" }