Nice, coherent and progressive model, but...
From hello to let's smash, haha.
Perhaps an "anti NSFW" system prompt to stir responses away from that a bit could help, but it's gonna depend a lot in the Character you are using, so maybe introducing some anti-NSFW more clearly in the character itself is a good idea.
Maybe testing with Virt-io's Alpaca presets could make a difference?
Have the newer Llama-3 or Mistral NeMo models performed better for your roleplay style?
Well, yelling rape was working until the crowd started to cheer {{char}} on~
I'm the modding type really. I don't really play games, my entertainment comes from modding them. So, I've been making characters using my own prompt that specifically instructs the bot to make incremental advancements to the end goal. Side thought: Ideally, it'd be cool to have a long term storage for stages. Permanently store boolean for reachedSecondBase or homeRun, lol and alter the reservation of {{char}} to match progression.
That said, to answer your question, here's my overall arching experience (many of your models and using my 'balanced' formatting):
Eris_PrimeV4.69-Vision-32k-7B-Q8_0-imat.gguf
L3-8B-Stheno-v3.3-32K-Q8_0-imat.gguf
fireblossom-32K-7B-Q8_0-imat.gguf
llama3-8B-DarkIdol-2.3-Uncensored-32K-Q8_0-imat.gguf
rogue-enchantress-32k-7B-Q8_0-imat.gguf
Stheno, like users have reported, good but accuracy not quite there.
fireblossom: Really, really good at giving SD1111/flux promps and under the right conditions have given the best progressions the story without going 0-60 in 2.5sec, I need more experimentation but might be my daily driver
DarkIdol: Very very good. It keeps a dark atmosphere without going complete psycho, how unholy does. Needs more experimentation but, so far, I like what I'm seeing. Definitely a viable successor to Unholy.
Rouge-enchantress: I'm up in the air about. The sojiki character from chub.ai had literally the most interesting opening, I wish I wrote it down, but the character basically is an Oneesan that's been possessed by an oni, you come home to a dilapidated house. With rouge, I came home to {{user}}'s oneesan cooking him meet, that was overcooked, blood splattering the walls, claw marks, description of a werewolf movie, and of course Oneesan offers {{user}} the burnt meat saying that it's her job to take care of her little brother... {{user}} of course not knowing where that meat came from. Unlike the other models, this model immediately created a dark story and put you in the role of The Winchester brothers from Supernatural, where as the others, just played it super generic anime style. Otherwise, I haven't seen it outperform DarkIdol or fireblossom after that one opening.
Of course Eris_Prime: Great dialogue, but yeah, I need to wear a chastity belt to make to the third response.