Unnamed: 0.1
int64
0
41k
Unnamed: 0
int64
0
41k
author
stringlengths
9
1.39k
id
stringlengths
11
18
summary
stringlengths
25
3.66k
title
stringlengths
4
258
year
int64
1.99k
2.02k
arxiv_url
stringlengths
32
39
info
stringlengths
523
3.18k
embeddings
stringlengths
16.9k
17.1k
600
600
['Lili Mou', 'Rui Yan', 'Ge Li', 'Lu Zhang', 'Zhi Jin']
1512.06612v2
Recent language models, especially those based on recurrent neural networks (RNNs), make it possible to generate natural language from a learned probability. Language generation has wide applications including machine translation, summarization, question answering, conversation systems, etc. Existing methods typically learn a joint probability of words conditioned on additional information, which is (either statically or dynamically) fed to RNN's hidden layer. In many applications, we are likely to impose hard constraints on the generated texts, i.e., a particular word must appear in the sentence. Unfortunately, existing approaches could not solve this problem. In this paper, we propose a novel backward and forward language model. Provided a specific word, we use RNNs to generate previous words and future words, either simultaneously or asynchronously, resulting in two model variants. In this way, the given word could appear at any position in the sentence. Experimental results show that the generated texts are comparable to sequential LMs in quality.
Backward and Forward Language Modeling for Constrained Sentence Generation
2,015
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1512.06612v2
Title Backward Forward Language Modeling Constrained Sentence Generation Summary Recent language model especially based recurrent neural network RNNs make possible generate natural language learned probability Language generation wide application including machine translation summarization question answering conversation system etc Existing method typically learn joint probability word conditioned additional information either statically dynamically fed RNNs hidden layer many application likely impose hard constraint generated text ie particular word must appear sentence Unfortunately existing approach could solve problem paper propose novel backward forward language model Provided specific word use RNNs generate previous word future word either simultaneously asynchronously resulting two model variant way given word could appear position sentence Experimental result show generated text comparable sequential LMs quality Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.0713164359331131, 0.04077165201306343, -0.00351351173594594, 0.009156038984656334, -0.050216205418109894, -0.03484518453478813, -0.01834772154688835, 0.015102071687579155, -0.011920073069632053, -0.04726139456033707, 0.04541974887251854, -0.043521977961063385, 0.005748002789914608, 0.04906434938311577, 0.02093552052974701, -0.0617520697414875, 0.012091116048395634, -0.0003824518935289234, 0.006529804784804583, 0.018153807148337364, 0.03634461760520935, 0.023164376616477966, 0.006394251249730587, 0.022860191762447357, -0.011217191815376282, -0.0017505510477349162, -0.0065090954303741455, -0.03963528200984001, -0.017528150230646133, -0.03505204617977142, 0.020724624395370483, 0.034956879913806915, 0.01218841876834631, -0.0073411548510193825, 2.2052013264328707e-06, -0.025556452572345734, -0.01994924806058407, -0.04536274075508118, 0.05848872661590576, -0.03234023228287697, 0.02876202017068863, -0.009170372039079666, 0.00019812672690022737, 0.04545331746339798, -0.04284241050481796, 0.03152504935860634, 0.034301578998565674, 0.053680166602134705, 0.06223846226930618, 0.053191665560007095, -0.005659147631376982, -0.029921293258666992, 0.019566893577575684, -0.035769518464803696, 0.018479911610484123, -0.025403667241334915, 0.02048638090491295, -0.012068475596606731, -0.005651638377457857, 0.013658301904797554, 0.004616899881511927, 0.039503708481788635, 0.04435045272111893, -0.026981908828020096, -0.036992497742176056, 0.029527606442570686, 0.018101058900356293, -0.024192551150918007, -0.02861212007701397, 0.05968238413333893, -0.0077597107738256454, -0.035707008093595505, 0.010535337030887604, -0.012420456856489182, -0.02412029355764389, -0.002017275197431445, -0.039315324276685715, 0.06641506403684616, -0.018285702913999557, 0.024934418499469757, 0.023773929104208946, 0.050027236342430115, 0.014258578419685364, 0.0213366337120533, 0.027680251747369766, 0.027614643797278404, 0.023002613335847855, -0.035127487033605576, -0.04344072565436363, -0.001501670223660767, 0.004405449144542217, -0.05255270004272461, 0.03675411641597748, 0.06602617353200912, -0.00884565431624651, 0.02578633651137352, -0.05705910176038742, -0.06397981196641922, 0.04846308380365372, -0.09512776136398315, 0.005570539738982916, 0.0014568993356078863, 0.015545129776000977, -0.007625083439052105, -0.016246572136878967, 0.04534566029906273, 0.0022324505262076855, -0.04264068603515625, -0.03289160132408142, 0.03382602334022522, -0.018552513793110847, -0.05755417421460152, -0.03827714920043945, 0.06339921057224274, -0.045962173491716385, -0.06397237628698349, -0.072577103972435, 0.009282360784709454, 0.03541877865791321, -0.03736459091305733, 0.0389595627784729, 0.04395902529358864, -0.04740738496184349, -0.015022977255284786, -0.024506285786628723, -0.02113504521548748, 0.011873275972902775, 0.010100282728672028, 0.009496117010712624, -0.02593199908733368, 0.014091896824538708, 0.029805801808834076, -0.015129294246435165, 0.010047824122011662, -0.05248139426112175, 0.059962160885334015, -0.006310790311545134, 0.046826668083667755, -0.04647350311279297, -0.04842737317085266, -0.03639194369316101, -0.057058557868003845, 0.011772180907428265, -0.06479840725660324, -0.01903592236340046, -0.016307763755321503, -0.04635950177907944, -0.01632598415017128, 0.05237029120326042, 0.05748913809657097, -0.02256527915596962, 0.05036750063300133, 0.019665591418743134, -0.011678433045744896, 0.04089236631989479, 0.008885675109922886, 0.10973659157752991, 0.03503507375717163, 0.06080501526594162, 0.0360623374581337, -0.009889800101518631, 0.03473522141575813, 0.020405789837241173, 0.05660160258412361, -0.009105965495109558, -0.02254650369286537, -0.06358744204044342, -0.027915962040424347, 0.03279779106378555, 0.04096734896302223, -0.013776769861578941, 0.07388466596603394, 0.004193193279206753, 0.02409338764846325, 0.04472896084189415, 0.02011996880173683, 0.05237368494272232, 0.05531156063079834, 0.057025182992219925, 0.0286339670419693, -0.034699030220508575, 0.04796355962753296, -0.003121700370684266, 0.05150744318962097, -0.011998355388641357, 0.03696862608194351, 0.02379664033651352, 0.013848836533725262, -0.01922805979847908, -0.05628301948308945, 0.026320796459913254, -0.026779046282172203, 0.027434594929218292, -0.045390646904706955, 0.04837518930435181, 0.049525536596775055, -0.07845768332481384, 0.02733951434493065, 0.01030692458152771, -0.03547496721148491, 0.007251875475049019, -0.022723589092493057, -0.022663405165076256, 0.05249869450926781, 0.04787459969520569, -0.004398165736347437, 0.004590807948261499, 0.0017232120735570788, -0.01698807254433632, 0.10965775698423386, 0.03081637993454933, 0.028415389358997345, -0.017599793151021004, -0.04538732394576073, 0.007715551182627678, 0.016328053548932076, -0.00212352117523551, 0.01794123835861683, -0.021375564858317375, 0.03309372067451477, 0.07909230142831802, 0.04893941804766655, -0.03352341800928116, 0.042367469519376755, -0.04604656249284744, -0.002773870015516877, 0.025043481960892677, -0.010716909542679787, -0.011347318068146706, 0.004658984486013651, 0.003298134310171008, 0.05832437425851822, 0.03576552867889404, -0.03453286364674568, -0.03755763918161392, 0.018865536898374557, -0.10021659731864929, -0.0730317085981369, 0.02184654399752617, -0.014431382529437542, 0.0592985525727272, 0.01768924668431282, -0.0073553272522985935, -0.06934842467308044, 0.0664515420794487, -0.0157499797642231, 0.022351030260324478, -0.05949918180704117, 0.02340584620833397, 0.032422106713056564, -0.013248896226286888, -0.02705506607890129, 0.0587727315723896, -0.008885905146598816, 0.03454836830496788, 0.0007316385745070875, -0.027908029034733772, 0.01797473430633545, -0.0679972693324089, -0.014771085232496262, -0.02188625931739807, -0.010727030225098133, 0.016620885580778122, 0.03622283786535263, 0.05968788266181946, -0.010303007438778877, -0.040372055023908615, -0.03284674510359764, 0.0063948482275009155, -0.0023699356243014336, -0.005436272826045752, 0.027656009420752525, 0.04373486340045929, 0.008082734420895576, -0.03463618457317352, -0.0829649269580841, 0.005727478303015232, 0.06225389614701271, -0.009006854146718979, 0.06478918343782425, 0.04331348463892937, -0.0158917848020792, -0.06171473488211632, -0.007710154168307781, -0.008406641893088818, 0.01267453096807003, 0.05712815374135971, -0.03268996626138687, -0.05662333220243454, 0.046739161014556885, -0.0314582884311676, 0.04383428767323494, -0.0017780230846256018, -0.041296422481536865, -0.019806629046797752, -0.024638043716549873, 0.051111891865730286, -0.02243146114051342, 0.033917974680662155, -0.0060483836568892, 0.012042402289807796, -0.01177986804395914, -0.015874264761805534, 0.0010528045240789652, -0.06786447763442993, 0.021493082866072655, 0.02309098094701767, -0.02312600612640381, 0.017642753198742867, 0.04047424718737602, 0.05840148404240608, 0.001561537035740912, -0.03167551010847092, 0.027516648173332214, -0.010975762270390987, -0.0030660827178508043, -0.020670678466558456, -0.027473673224449158, -0.0338713675737381, 0.013101376593112946, -0.021558430045843124, -0.021300802007317543, 0.06052763760089874, -0.03360706567764282, 0.04068252816796303, -0.06347672641277313, -0.034394770860672, -0.01880495995283127, 0.03611818701028824, 0.016478780657052994, 0.036707110702991486, 0.0269770585000515, -0.0032899247016757727, -0.046538375318050385, 0.007900310680270195, -0.020102068781852722, -0.03319728374481201, -0.004663510248064995, -0.048474933952093124, 0.013652446679770947, -0.01691429130733013, -0.036860108375549316, -0.04057996720075607, -0.08094754070043564, 0.023161768913269043, 0.01750059612095356, 0.026343263685703278, -0.0020842088852077723, 0.01854761131107807, 0.03919931873679161, -0.02944902703166008, 0.04294529929757118, -0.04920021444559097, 0.008319860324263573, -0.010639000684022903, 0.03792170062661171, 0.0817398950457573, -0.03501763939857483, -0.032301317900419235, 0.0009678301285021007, 0.02125462517142296, 0.007908154278993607, 0.007297209929674864, 0.025166137143969536, -0.030189014971256256, -0.0032447960693389177, -0.011836622841656208, -0.02374192699790001, -0.03939514607191086, 0.04597197473049164, 0.009987927973270416, -0.07618258148431778, -0.007896802388131618, 0.10016962885856628, 0.023328380659222603, -0.014097019098699093, -0.013995637185871601, -0.005086884368211031, 0.015301999635994434, 0.00859103910624981, 0.04969055950641632, -0.05646165460348129, 0.005109320394694805, -0.017770670354366302, -0.0014552080538123846, -0.020203569903969765, -0.042866893112659454, -0.058809928596019745, -0.09410995244979858, -0.0010147106368094683, 0.0037130387499928474, -0.03241308778524399, -0.015607845969498158, 0.003529197769239545, -0.060718804597854614, 0.035489801317453384, -0.028070151805877686, 0.04564272239804268, 0.010181551799178123, 0.016826411709189415, 0.029695382341742516, -0.06186859309673309, 0.004768028389662504, -0.02836553379893303, -0.031592875719070435, 0.023632219061255455, 0.05663084611296654, 0.02587927132844925, -0.017583774402737617, -0.022345712408423424, 0.02063409797847271, -0.02736668474972248, -0.0031562303192913532, -0.0009016203111968935, 0.01743861474096775, 0.0036347785498946905, -0.006460045464336872, -0.042412322014570236, 0.011931661516427994, -0.004621653351932764, 0.018403703346848488, 0.01592976227402687, 0.03976741060614586, -0.009813327342271805, -0.007118102628737688, -0.04877638816833496, 0.07315026223659515, 0.06414015591144562, 0.037016674876213074, 0.012713439762592316, -0.058447305113077164, -0.06429022550582886, -0.037315405905246735, 0.030932771041989326, -0.10451722145080566, -0.011977641843259335, -0.046185556799173355, -0.007555142976343632, -0.015612144023180008, -0.12857118248939514, -0.0525391586124897, -0.03070787526667118, 0.021519333124160767, 0.0390021838247776, 0.04811444878578186, 0.03335172310471535, -0.01912061683833599, -0.03153962641954422, -0.07707147300243378, 0.01214688178151846, -0.004690146539360285, -0.04689469560980797, 0.013224308378994465, 0.04953395575284958, -0.05467098206281662, -6.842271250206977e-05, 0.006123227998614311, -0.08627109229564667, -0.0648982971906662, -0.01715352199971676, 0.03601891174912453, 0.015614972449839115, 0.010858834721148014, -0.038282476365566254, -0.03451438248157501, 0.0039491355419158936, 0.030100887641310692, -0.003693333128467202, -0.0027715975884348154, 0.001947649521753192, 0.0481891930103302, -0.0010146454442292452, 0.01764591410756111, -0.03628996014595032, 0.01180763728916645, -0.015525315888226032, 0.05631531774997711, -0.018415875732898712, -0.08680398762226105, 0.020475216209888458, -0.012824563309550285, 0.009609973058104515, -0.04239475727081299, 0.01220919843763113, -0.030588610097765923, -0.00316401245072484, -0.037340424954891205, -0.014940363354980946, -0.06001301109790802, 0.05094509199261665, 0.0391891747713089, -0.002417847514152527, 0.004464919678866863, -0.03810761496424675, -0.022004051133990288, 0.005837629083544016, 0.006516657769680023, 0.0011847082059830427, 0.0325089730322361, 0.018861262127757072, -0.003145650029182434, -0.012342059053480625, -0.014329414814710617, -0.005578844342380762, -0.02274038828909397, 0.02695811167359352, -0.03188559412956238, 0.05709243193268776, 0.015581239014863968, -0.018257029354572296, -0.02764098532497883, -0.011872580274939537, -0.027330266311764717, 0.012118504382669926, -0.05040586367249489, 0.052927568554878235, 0.05936121568083763, 0.0034392348024994135, 0.01590348593890667, -0.00456725899130106, 0.020913181826472282, -0.0260685496032238, 0.07596059888601303, 0.003703829599544406, -0.0311906598508358, 0.026697460561990738, -0.0067109582014381886, -0.02499776892364025, 0.005727197974920273, 0.0970853790640831, 0.06254662573337555, 0.004323699977248907, 0.0176706500351429, -0.028556780889630318, -0.0341978594660759, -0.004377258475869894, 0.0004469677805900574, 0.009272902272641659, 0.0037170443683862686, 0.01955394260585308, -0.027453402057290077, -0.04083562269806862, 0.027153734117746353, 0.0422293022274971, 0.05510508269071579, 0.004250144120305777, 0.04024442285299301, 0.02652537263929844, -0.015340560115873814, 0.011090544983744621, -0.0740644708275795, 0.04978960379958153, 0.020548181608319283, -0.0463811531662941, -0.06046627089381218, -6.0790962185843226e-33, -0.027231527492403984, -0.02360745146870613, 0.016268007457256317, 0.004569694399833679, -0.031222153455018997, -0.02823169343173504, -0.04399457201361656, -0.014098106883466244, 0.010380466468632221, 0.010522441938519478, -0.018391231074929237, -0.009836985729634762, 0.011352184228599072, 0.052635788917541504, 0.026755135506391525, 0.006058847531676292, 0.02648858167231083, -0.03829202428460121, 0.014094412326812744, 0.02175428345799446, 0.03939049318432808, 0.05912581458687782, 0.0395018495619297, -0.00021064173779450357, 0.0180943813174963, -0.0582827590405941, -0.025908196344971657, 0.035969506949186325, 0.020086823031306267, 0.02650514431297779, -0.03213591128587723, 0.01907220110297203, 0.03718671575188637, -0.0460621602833271, -0.06398821622133255, 0.07752067595720291, -0.03585082292556763, -0.05555083975195885, 0.007574453949928284, -0.00763949379324913, -0.032836489379405975, -0.009427908807992935, 0.05377954989671707, -0.01683165319263935, -0.007900056429207325, 0.06210484355688095, 0.05379587039351463, -0.022458983585238457, -0.021644510328769684, -0.05143818259239197, -0.031291838735342026, -0.003553128568455577, 0.0035676227416843176, -0.023990068584680557, -0.015135135501623154, 0.04061966761946678, -0.03109096735715866, -0.026172414422035217, -0.05308699607849121, 0.04313655570149422, 0.007428463082760572, 0.06154945492744446, 0.03567907214164734, 0.039487794041633606, -0.0036532077938318253, 0.03054489567875862, -0.034804970026016235, -0.04847055673599243, -0.0402824841439724, 0.042996570467948914, -0.008649907074868679, 0.018636353313922882, 0.0347416028380394, 0.027018902823328972, 0.025925448164343834, -0.04136425256729126, -0.07018665224313736, 0.02469003200531006, 0.0017226950731128454, 0.017681792378425598, 0.05245986208319664, -0.01792730763554573, -0.011413023807108402, -0.04589344561100006, -0.01727999746799469, 0.010456913150846958, -0.0077967108227312565, -0.025023050606250763, 0.027116261422634125, 0.03439425304532051, -0.015229660086333752, -0.03648095577955246, 0.004246861208230257, -0.025524955242872238, -0.018269596621394157, 0.03020801953971386, -0.031962815672159195, -0.007149695884436369, -0.01852816343307495, 0.014280036091804504, -0.07096488773822784, 0.01454445905983448, 0.016946474090218544, 0.05244570970535278, -0.029641777276992798, 0.005079227965325117, 0.01980254426598549, 0.004694607108831406, -0.03338148817420006, 0.00738913519307971, -0.0238330215215683, 0.017707347869873047, 0.0401163250207901, 0.03963826969265938, 0.0007695377571508288, -0.0204757172614336, -0.018888168036937714, 0.03038117289543152, 0.026631629094481468, -0.02863558568060398, -0.018106358125805855, -0.01716206967830658, 0.04386671259999275, 0.04671124368906021, -0.0658065527677536, 0.016303885728120804, -0.025988640263676643, 0.0630636140704155, 0.0211994219571352, -0.04707596078515053, -0.019536828622221947, 0.03866506367921829, 2.756380865776009e-07, 0.02274993248283863, 0.0025320970453321934, 0.047492869198322296, -0.007741174660623074, 0.02951878495514393, 0.006215468980371952, -0.0032574806828051805, 0.04642881453037262, 0.003187971655279398, 0.04135363548994064, 0.0018265857361257076, -0.02071678452193737, 0.023735688999295235, -0.01984027400612831, -0.10941292345523834, 0.003888288512825966, -0.09547028690576553, 0.018425937741994858, -0.019143695011734962, -0.015156961977481842, 0.0987776592373848, 0.05866453796625137, 0.028648806735873222, -0.00978869665414095, -0.02129255048930645, -0.05893144756555557, 0.050904836505651474, 0.015593549236655235, -0.028468217700719833, 0.009906057268381119, 0.017752984538674355, 0.03645522892475128, -0.02160383015871048, -0.046122126281261444, -0.021548638120293617, 0.017272165045142174, 0.009004121646285057, 0.04076693579554558, 0.007450454402714968, -0.04039137810468674, 0.05519474670290947, 0.021448900923132896, 0.0042742458172142506, -0.028916010633111, 0.041697707027196884, -0.023131584748625755, -0.014718511141836643, -0.01095761451870203, 0.024460898712277412, -0.004995065741240978, 0.01044758502393961, -0.013910779729485512, -0.04632654786109924, -0.02019968442618847, 0.004533190745860338, -0.0063473074696958065, 0.0016662993002682924, -0.04458761587738991, -0.04537848010659218, -0.019592618569731712, -0.05236297845840454, 0.02191598154604435, -0.049593400210142136, -0.004671240691095591, 0.006866659969091415, -0.03465566411614418, -0.0016356169944629073, 2.802195090956758e-34, 0.03659055009484291, -0.029292263090610504, -0.03352271392941475, 0.002364503685384989, -0.0073448531329631805, 0.01440648827701807, 0.0047616600058972836, 0.05346359685063362, 0.025468632578849792, -0.06827469915151596, -0.06868084520101547]
601
601
['Kyuyeon Hwang', 'Minjae Lee', 'Wonyong Sung']
1512.08903v1
In this paper, we propose a context-aware keyword spotting model employing a character-level recurrent neural network (RNN) for spoken term detection in continuous speech. The RNN is end-to-end trained with connectionist temporal classification (CTC) to generate the probabilities of character and word-boundary labels. There is no need for the phonetic transcription, senone modeling, or system dictionary in training and testing. Also, keywords can easily be added and modified by editing the text based keyword list without retraining the RNN. Moreover, the unidirectional RNN processes an infinitely long input audio streams without pre-segmentation and keywords are detected with low-latency before the utterance is finished. Experimental results show that the proposed keyword spotter significantly outperforms the deep neural network (DNN) and hidden Markov model (HMM) based keyword-filler model even with less computations.
Online Keyword Spotting with a Character-Level Recurrent Neural Network
2,015
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1512.08903v1
Title Online Keyword Spotting CharacterLevel Recurrent Neural Network Summary paper propose contextaware keyword spotting model employing characterlevel recurrent neural network RNN spoken term detection continuous speech RNN endtoend trained connectionist temporal classification CTC generate probability character wordboundary label need phonetic transcription senone modeling system dictionary training testing Also keywords easily added modified editing text based keyword list without retraining RNN Moreover unidirectional RNN process infinitely long input audio stream without presegmentation keywords detected lowlatency utterance finished Experimental result show proposed keyword spotter significantly outperforms deep neural network DNN hidden Markov model HMM based keywordfiller model even le computation Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.006053483579307795, 0.017226427793502808, 0.04451555758714676, 0.04900750890374184, 0.017928095534443855, -0.02497158572077751, -0.008989205583930016, 0.008729066699743271, -0.047539252787828445, -0.03288761526346207, -0.03752556070685387, -0.04293350502848625, 0.030366219580173492, 0.09057103842496872, 0.0018292726017534733, -0.026361951604485512, 0.02118067629635334, -0.020096585154533386, 0.021795613691210747, 0.011767691001296043, 0.04983307793736458, -0.000725301681086421, -0.07543598115444183, 0.05388583987951279, -0.024119606241583824, 0.0026588672772049904, -0.022132033482193947, -0.013130977749824524, -0.03294053301215172, -0.033538952469825745, 0.022247618064284325, 0.023582061752676964, 0.03554543852806091, 0.04667842388153076, 1.9452363630989566e-06, -0.0021476303227245808, -0.008268868550658226, 0.002121211728081107, -0.011654953472316265, 0.007692254614084959, 0.009583890438079834, 0.03335791081190109, -0.04499897360801697, 0.05737846717238426, 0.022687751799821854, 0.010440907441079617, 0.053717657923698425, 0.056700341403484344, -0.022433124482631683, 0.026454251259565353, 0.0013674567453563213, -0.06366630643606186, 0.04511597380042076, -0.028289860114455223, 0.02600451186299324, -0.05796552076935768, -0.006610575597733259, -0.049260322004556656, 0.0006500063464045525, -0.04737909883260727, -0.007180214859545231, 0.03584124520421028, -0.04695296660065651, -0.028998246416449547, 0.04663722217082977, 0.01586773246526718, -0.04705264791846275, -0.019783861935138702, -0.009471587836742401, 0.06579209864139557, -0.03108121082186699, 0.006188357248902321, 0.008062218315899372, -0.012348863296210766, -0.02701292186975479, -0.024110259488224983, 0.014121342450380325, 9.757480438565835e-05, -0.03435579314827919, -0.02407575584948063, -0.02410910837352276, 0.02060253545641899, 0.024636834859848022, 0.008850104175508022, 0.010305240750312805, -0.0028875882271677256, 0.037659622728824615, -0.04600812494754791, -0.03016277216374874, -0.04641066491603851, -0.016007600352168083, -0.028895178809762, 0.05495116114616394, 0.018216311931610107, -0.029745737090706825, 0.018584977835416794, 0.02033041976392269, -0.03433571755886078, 0.010086520574986935, -0.08045655488967896, 0.016717638820409775, 0.004535533022135496, -0.03640443831682205, 0.006153503432869911, 0.006935952231287956, 0.03477185219526291, -0.020013608038425446, -0.03138237074017525, 0.039642658084630966, -0.008961217477917671, -0.013619637116789818, -0.017832603305578232, -0.021794676780700684, 0.04024779051542282, 0.021552108228206635, -0.02684777043759823, -0.04446673393249512, -0.01482311449944973, 0.015524829737842083, -0.033724095672369, -0.010789567604660988, 0.021617336198687553, -0.04735025763511658, -0.009062903933227062, 0.02781001664698124, 0.023410484194755554, -0.0019468680256977677, 0.02073540911078453, -0.03955995291471481, -0.026122720912098885, 0.02813025191426277, 0.020760146901011467, 0.0737626850605011, -0.0013658730313181877, 0.01284230686724186, 0.02697426825761795, 0.012088770046830177, -0.0399080328643322, -0.007031699176877737, 0.009019057266414165, -0.047195859253406525, 0.05949908122420311, -0.045015476644039154, -0.08038001507520676, -0.022700652480125427, -0.06197478994727135, -0.01927667111158371, 0.020440155640244484, 0.03040025569498539, 0.042242538183927536, 0.028331143781542778, 0.08405349403619766, -0.0033584614284336567, -0.005971546750515699, 0.019122309982776642, -0.008126779459416866, 0.048644665628671646, 0.01667318120598793, 0.06381814926862717, 0.03424115851521492, 0.040357716381549835, -0.04352857917547226, 0.022546103224158287, 0.04573938250541687, -0.0394737645983696, -0.022091716527938843, -0.08620502799749374, -0.047638967633247375, 0.0031310582999140024, 0.06337694823741913, 0.012273105792701244, 0.028971945866942406, 0.02919938415288925, 0.04012436792254448, 0.05759609118103981, 0.07956746965646744, 0.08136893063783646, 0.017769239842891693, -0.02623715251684189, 0.040700092911720276, -0.03087148256599903, 0.004345300141721964, 0.018105503171682358, -0.004710229579359293, -0.005156953819096088, -0.00817243941128254, -0.008723587729036808, -0.03350956737995148, 0.007683177478611469, -0.014392117038369179, -0.019820908084511757, -0.0016016216250136495, -0.06562259048223495, -0.008132961578667164, 0.09027368575334549, -0.024172484874725342, -0.07167182862758636, -0.0011318752076476812, 0.017607668414711952, -0.037755563855171204, 0.012538024224340916, -0.035142045468091965, 0.011407963931560516, 0.05034701153635979, 0.06050459295511246, -0.026024073362350464, -6.056531492504291e-05, -0.06410487741231918, -0.02146921120584011, 0.07189793884754181, -0.028507813811302185, -0.014385254122316837, 0.011734520085155964, -0.06437984853982925, -0.009406046941876411, 0.037563204765319824, 0.007459043990820646, 0.045820094645023346, -0.03422395512461662, 0.042982202023267746, -0.0009134484571404755, -0.004333493299782276, 0.04008170962333679, 0.014030640944838524, 0.014128021895885468, -0.019237739965319633, 0.005716957151889801, 0.02057722955942154, 0.024711698293685913, 0.032320015132427216, -0.03387771546840668, 0.010328592732548714, 0.0042222836054861546, -0.04356144741177559, 0.02400536648929119, 0.01718970388174057, -0.04116956144571304, 0.015843942761421204, 0.036095067858695984, -0.018144503235816956, 0.04233413562178612, 0.04555495083332062, 0.02899632789194584, -0.047076281160116196, 0.01233269926160574, -0.004857196006923914, 0.06668250262737274, -0.04121031239628792, 0.024155762046575546, -0.03443426638841629, 0.06767041236162186, 0.032607730478048325, 0.03782675787806511, -0.0131808090955019, -0.0001285736361751333, 0.0014677948784083128, 0.014938672073185444, -0.015766745433211327, -0.04593981057405472, -0.033526863902807236, 0.014371737837791443, -0.02272884175181389, 0.002540519693866372, 0.005859339609742165, -0.013686107471585274, -0.00931524857878685, -0.007716597057878971, -0.005398210603743792, 0.006080601364374161, -0.023006705567240715, -0.014838063158094883, 0.00920531339943409, 0.02591249719262123, 0.010501503013074398, -0.008588246069848537, -0.025838542729616165, -0.02851070836186409, -0.01395007036626339, -0.005966016557067633, -0.011353276669979095, -0.020568180829286575, -0.030504029244184494, -0.05666312575340271, -0.014515086077153683, -0.01697836071252823, -0.03342652693390846, 0.03129855543375015, -0.11325915157794952, 0.009697713889181614, 0.02062029205262661, 0.07296450436115265, 0.041382987052202225, 0.02193155139684677, -0.034111786633729935, 0.006124732084572315, -0.0028362919110804796, 0.0010846486547961831, 0.02509850449860096, 0.05067482590675354, -0.014621591195464134, -0.01814904995262623, -0.022779431194067, -0.00782955251634121, 0.006101482547819614, 0.06113879755139351, 0.03817684203386307, 0.011176441796123981, 0.009995869360864162, 0.006278039887547493, 0.05071418732404709, 0.004135504364967346, 0.058019425719976425, 0.0034026463981717825, -0.05866185575723648, -0.029999729245901108, -0.02415354736149311, -0.06954320520162582, -0.015785368159413338, -0.08859755098819733, -0.0003137377498205751, 0.00823008082807064, -0.0034745661541819572, -0.005244813393801451, -0.04606400802731514, -0.030994269996881485, -0.04259905591607094, -0.052429500967264175, -0.005872179754078388, -0.002812194637954235, -0.03200775384902954, -0.023709798231720924, -0.022840088233351707, -0.08934071660041809, 0.01150908600538969, -0.013885460793972015, 0.011578069999814034, -0.058416299521923065, 0.052502527832984924, 0.018445968627929688, -0.011470177210867405, -0.0142489243298769, 0.011419112794101238, -0.06848140060901642, -0.02113788202404976, -0.04606913402676582, -0.027705246582627296, 0.03011111356317997, -0.04299255460500717, 0.05099790543317795, 0.07870569080114365, -0.01122073084115982, 0.06461549550294876, 0.035627156496047974, 0.025320369750261307, -0.019597237929701805, 0.07440926134586334, 0.04753861948847771, 0.001210191985592246, -0.016731465235352516, 0.02432538941502571, 0.04911382868885994, -0.010631994344294071, 0.0255671888589859, -0.00981904286891222, -0.004594918806105852, -0.028805013746023178, 0.018569836392998695, 0.002919487887993455, -0.0416579432785511, 0.03525243327021599, -0.001883468241430819, -0.060443490743637085, -0.006171205546706915, 0.08364209532737732, -0.0023014734033495188, -0.08896569162607193, -0.019321167841553688, 0.026317646726965904, -0.028463413938879967, 0.019608182832598686, -0.013574650511145592, -0.03985592722892761, -0.03798994421958923, 0.055267203599214554, 0.047891873866319656, 0.012676841579377651, -0.022541332989931107, -0.04099058359861374, -0.06460915505886078, 0.014501363970339298, -0.02549912966787815, -0.02667948231101036, -0.03361796587705612, -0.01655328832566738, 0.0023848118726164103, -0.00553828664124012, 0.02576015144586563, 0.018494490534067154, -0.025747666135430336, -0.03469480574131012, 0.012985858134925365, -0.08015938848257065, -0.02703603357076645, 0.03883575275540352, -0.0720876157283783, 0.04982554167509079, 0.06643117964267731, 0.04586144909262657, -0.0772671326994896, -0.013005749322474003, 0.0371289886534214, 0.011376279406249523, -0.008620789274573326, 0.027181832119822502, -0.031247757375240326, -0.03308971971273422, -0.02984773740172386, 0.003987227566540241, 0.019724007695913315, -0.03655035421252251, 0.03897276148200035, 0.007741233799606562, 0.008060744032263756, 0.013976671732962132, -0.001026137382723391, -0.007794084958732128, 0.0451042540371418, 0.031242050230503082, 0.030093390494585037, 0.0038025048561394215, -0.05087031051516533, -0.015081374906003475, 0.026282809674739838, 0.06429015845060349, -0.04133068770170212, -0.024245401844382286, -0.02534075640141964, -0.00486281793564558, -0.04110037535429001, -0.07031460851430893, -0.010880881920456886, -0.02131134457886219, 0.004010569769889116, 0.017155684530735016, 0.08496569097042084, -0.01117196399718523, 0.027617748826742172, -0.025182723999023438, -0.032534535974264145, 0.031957417726516724, 0.043337203562259674, -0.10638675838708878, 0.015447931364178658, 0.0240944717079401, -0.054812319576740265, 0.005449489690363407, 0.007397624664008617, -0.04187813028693199, -0.007397803012281656, 0.043744511902332306, -0.059057559818029404, -0.0014035900821909308, 0.03079189546406269, -0.07533115148544312, -0.08923222124576569, 0.023994004353880882, -0.01507303025573492, -0.006523373071104288, 0.005918100941926241, 0.06451806426048279, 0.01211737934499979, -0.019321832805871964, 0.015417423099279404, -0.06858852505683899, 0.007550851441919804, -0.06149737909436226, -0.00913927610963583, -0.004311087541282177, -0.046716321259737015, -0.018649693578481674, -0.040521372109651566, 0.04873473942279816, -0.02523612417280674, 0.009733766317367554, -0.08326179534196854, 0.02757573314011097, 0.050175443291664124, 0.02159859612584114, -0.03566109016537666, 0.03122934140264988, 0.031352147459983826, -0.014802453108131886, -0.008993365801870823, 0.017366040498018265, 0.0019463793141767383, -0.04409141466021538, 0.02664642035961151, 0.09774720668792725, 0.054138343781232834, -0.0058780238032341, 0.017847899347543716, 0.007156636565923691, -0.010400205850601196, 0.06764186918735504, 0.013689312152564526, 0.053681131452322006, 0.00389644643291831, 0.023790450766682625, -0.04201420024037361, -0.05096737667918205, 0.03592817485332489, -0.007678288035094738, 0.0014205111656337976, 0.04486921802163124, -0.04851966351270676, 0.03952227160334587, 0.10315468162298203, -0.01871129684150219, -0.025308141484856606, 0.006120741367340088, 0.021316006779670715, -0.03353835642337799, 0.03296417370438576, -0.05895954743027687, 0.008993458934128284, 0.04217595234513283, 0.02963096834719181, -0.020030783489346504, 0.01713154837489128, 0.059106696397066116, 0.04980025067925453, 0.03394514322280884, 0.038612380623817444, -0.0018351461039856076, -0.013950726017355919, 0.026204073801636696, 0.0012142823543399572, 0.06763803958892822, -0.036584243178367615, 0.019987870007753372, 0.010446188040077686, -0.06760922819375992, 0.04612952098250389, -0.04026630520820618, 0.025168368592858315, -0.0024436581879854202, -0.026824036613106728, -0.006807099096477032, -0.0006841688882559538, 0.036631420254707336, -0.011582390405237675, -0.0011989575577899814, 0.02533775568008423, -0.013767325319349766, 0.0006643409142270684, -5.56836229025127e-33, 0.0012196932220831513, -0.03810558468103409, -0.024905936792492867, 0.0023637134581804276, -0.005175213795155287, 0.03456302732229233, 0.004615429323166609, 0.0025984488893300295, -0.01424724142998457, -0.010340262204408646, -0.030600739642977715, 0.0763605609536171, 0.018680060282349586, 0.009517237544059753, 0.004037061706185341, -0.029086828231811523, 0.04840610548853874, -0.007884695194661617, 0.041762981563806534, 0.005883282516151667, 0.035146068781614304, 0.0626109167933464, 0.08365223556756973, -0.026869675144553185, -0.012732645496726036, -0.022215088829398155, 0.01668360084295273, 0.003608848201110959, 0.024415865540504456, 0.03688148036599159, -0.042229704558849335, 0.03799157962203026, -0.017565445974469185, -0.01065982785075903, -0.004956916440278292, 0.04628836736083031, -0.052792247384786606, 0.03742754086852074, -0.026735816150903702, 0.0586637519299984, 0.04335574060678482, -0.01073451153934002, 0.06326420605182648, 0.008763346821069717, -0.004868974443525076, 0.04426487535238266, 0.05593587085604668, -0.03518805652856827, -0.07137291878461838, -0.03587586432695389, -0.04621673747897148, 0.06830429285764694, 0.016202079132199287, -0.03448347747325897, 0.02034161239862442, -0.020678894594311714, 0.02704409696161747, -0.03826407343149185, -0.10880190134048462, 0.01586909592151642, 0.021286804229021072, 0.02577640675008297, 0.00252373144030571, 0.06984572857618332, -0.002409248147159815, 0.0344141460955143, 0.018474102020263672, -0.04321235790848732, 0.02780904993414879, -0.013765613548457623, 0.030831389129161835, -0.001568353152833879, 0.028479231521487236, 0.008710313588380814, 0.06699146330356598, -0.0184065792709589, -0.026622580364346504, -0.01934662275016308, 0.03979149088263512, 0.011488624848425388, 0.03841781988739967, 0.0242574755102396, -0.09448953717947006, 0.00014422740787267685, -0.010725066997110844, 0.006362453103065491, -0.043769415467977524, -0.017057187855243683, 0.02351749874651432, 0.023862585425376892, -0.006908169947564602, -0.004767808131873608, 0.033380746841430664, -0.03119177743792534, 0.025708388537168503, -0.013532905839383602, 0.04838477075099945, -0.002181063173338771, -0.007100492715835571, 0.030528787523508072, -0.049396105110645294, 0.024121196940541267, 0.03184763342142105, 0.02929524891078472, 0.01045362651348114, -0.0001423587091267109, -0.01462401170283556, 0.022746169939637184, -0.032066620886325836, -0.004938130732625723, 0.009529728442430496, -0.03657018020749092, 0.02470138855278492, 0.05949614942073822, 0.02475629933178425, -0.0736752599477768, -0.008913632482290268, 0.07484594732522964, 0.017286065965890884, 0.02927423268556595, 0.013099023140966892, -0.05320146679878235, -0.02501497231423855, 0.014414684846997261, -0.04907511919736862, 0.015402435325086117, -0.01859983615577221, 0.03675925359129906, 0.04530257359147072, -0.014709781855344772, -0.007045145146548748, 0.008745979517698288, 2.5760905941751844e-07, -0.004940195009112358, -0.004750651773065329, 0.058961912989616394, -0.058712348341941833, 0.026914753019809723, 0.008979284204542637, 0.015157446265220642, -0.01499485969543457, -0.03123287297785282, 0.008622072637081146, 0.014490911737084389, -0.057338863611221313, 0.02312248945236206, 0.015668900683522224, -0.08029381185770035, -0.03955903649330139, -0.10111954063177109, 0.05899316444993019, -0.008656222373247147, -0.005324120633304119, 0.018378188833594322, 0.0940687507390976, 0.003983298782259226, -0.06520427763462067, -0.0006113167037256062, -0.035153478384017944, 0.0029448240529745817, 0.006667044013738632, 0.007054747082293034, -0.03789236396551132, 0.0001924035750562325, 0.04234739765524864, -0.0382874421775341, -0.039907388389110565, -0.038403477519750595, 0.042625267058610916, 0.04875430092215538, 0.021408619359135628, -0.027804017066955566, -0.044587355107069016, 0.004809122532606125, 0.009442267939448357, -0.03396697714924812, -0.005354718305170536, 0.07453597337007523, 0.03447809815406799, -0.033413395285606384, -0.07430039346218109, 0.03959004208445549, -0.015906471759080887, -0.012253465130925179, -0.03318346291780472, -0.002978614764288068, -0.033157333731651306, -0.023847199976444244, -0.05000275745987892, -0.049718327820301056, -0.0620664544403553, -0.022677075117826462, -0.014240967109799385, -0.013495360501110554, 0.003902731230482459, -0.03953149914741516, -0.07551880180835724, -0.007292351685464382, 0.013224701397120953, 0.029394667595624924, 2.027789284950872e-34, 0.019954556599259377, -0.0043072826229035854, -0.030196180567145348, 0.038628216832876205, 0.012881007976830006, 0.001489455928094685, 0.025513801723718643, -0.00016285880701616406, 0.0316217765212059, -0.03934754058718681, -0.0347258523106575]
602
602
['Zhenhao Ge', 'Yufang Sun']
1602.07393v1
Authorship attribution refers to the task of automatically determining the author based on a given sample of text. It is a problem with a long history and has a wide range of application. Building author profiles using language models is one of the most successful methods to automate this task. New language modeling methods based on neural networks alleviate the curse of dimensionality and usually outperform conventional N-gram methods. However, there have not been much research applying them to authorship attribution. In this paper, we present a novel setup of a Neural Network Language Model (NNLM) and apply it to a database of text samples from different authors. We investigate how the NNLM performs on a task with moderate author set size and relatively limited training and test data, and how the topics of the text samples affect the accuracy. NNLM achieves nearly 2.5% reduction in perplexity, a measurement of fitness of a trained language model to the test data. Given 5 random test sentences, it also increases the author classification accuracy by 3.43% on average, compared with the N-gram methods using SRILM tools. An open source implementation of our methodology is freely available at https://github.com/zge/authorship-attribution/.
Domain Specific Author Attribution Based on Feedforward Neural Network Language Models
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1602.07393v1
Title Domain Specific Author Attribution Based Feedforward Neural Network Language Models Summary Authorship attribution refers task automatically determining author based given sample text problem long history wide range application Building author profile using language model one successful method automate task New language modeling method based neural network alleviate curse dimensionality usually outperform conventional Ngram method However much research applying authorship attribution paper present novel setup Neural Network Language Model NNLM apply database text sample different author investigate NNLM performs task moderate author set size relatively limited training test data topic text sample affect accuracy NNLM achieves nearly 25 reduction perplexity measurement fitness trained language model test data Given 5 random test sentence also increase author classification accuracy 343 average compared Ngram method using SRILM tool open source implementation methodology freely available httpsgithubcomzgeauthorshipattribution Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.049107592552900314, 0.05301670730113983, -0.03609152138233185, 0.024805482476949692, -0.05954847112298012, -0.019497159868478775, 0.10058499872684479, -0.013518590480089188, 0.01585269533097744, -0.027639785781502724, 0.015150275081396103, -0.0017323875799775124, 0.024015109986066818, 0.03368305042386055, 0.025010712444782257, 0.005749876145273447, -0.01660652458667755, 0.03377573564648628, 0.056472618132829666, 0.010509959422051907, -0.0033283683005720377, 0.006017879117280245, 0.033981435000896454, 0.05001802742481232, 0.017707904800772667, -0.05196252092719078, 0.04275485500693321, -0.01791570335626602, 0.007707878015935421, -0.006201888434588909, 0.02750314585864544, 0.0506947822868824, -0.015128332190215588, 0.04844236001372337, 1.8026819361693924e-06, -0.0269990973174572, 0.0022550993598997593, -0.010728901252150536, 0.040316831320524216, -0.011057483032345772, 0.06148158758878708, 0.040232766419649124, -0.015255363658070564, 0.023060690611600876, -0.01834111288189888, -0.03127650171518326, 0.01554399449378252, 0.07966834306716919, 0.021730516105890274, 0.06329382956027985, -0.008119175210595131, -0.08767203986644745, 0.04595331847667694, 0.00372414686717093, -0.0012819338589906693, -0.012719918042421341, 0.04345124587416649, -0.006139674689620733, -0.024455254897475243, 0.04097158461809158, -0.016092555597424507, 0.040387801826000214, -0.03435139358043671, -0.027406815439462662, 0.044194210320711136, 0.020927252247929573, -0.0009288887376897037, 0.02921527810394764, 0.04352470487356186, 0.01444409228861332, 0.024501442909240723, -0.01398720033466816, 0.027041206136345863, 0.026124104857444763, -0.014085911214351654, 0.047293148934841156, -0.00042210498941130936, 0.017549702897667885, -0.06439217925071716, -0.04283446818590164, 0.020132947713136673, 0.05174613744020462, -0.004796999040991068, 0.034061189740896225, 0.02707630954682827, 0.005630782805383205, -0.01458088681101799, -0.005598411895334721, -0.00710381381213665, -0.04525500535964966, 0.029251456260681152, -0.06023741140961647, 0.0673876702785492, 0.01882796734571457, 0.03707679733633995, -0.0004418168100528419, -0.004994027782231569, -0.07546982914209366, 0.035626452416181564, -0.07947894930839539, 0.007894067093729973, -0.03342369943857193, 0.008906613104045391, 0.0034717365633696318, -0.015605499967932701, 0.007645900826901197, 0.022495880722999573, -0.0109010711312294, -0.00371172116138041, -0.010362585075199604, -0.07233087718486786, -0.021584654226899147, -0.020923638716340065, 0.025068555027246475, 0.02332417294383049, -0.009284752421081066, -0.09766479581594467, -0.02065405063331127, 0.013892199844121933, -0.006384681910276413, 0.013395669870078564, 0.04747730866074562, -0.005880095064640045, 0.012759275734424591, -0.010168570093810558, -0.00394038250669837, -0.004087939392775297, 0.01912369206547737, -0.03612777963280678, 0.020720060914754868, 0.033075228333473206, 0.019131463021039963, 0.025691252201795578, -0.018523771315813065, 0.03850467875599861, 0.02312430739402771, 0.027923494577407837, -0.047310419380664825, -0.058587003499269485, -0.026314597576856613, -0.004399322438985109, -0.006406710017472506, -0.05206834897398949, -0.05501140281558037, 0.010863684117794037, -0.010436945594847202, -0.026699500158429146, -0.09320784360170364, -0.023761017248034477, 0.04038482531905174, -0.043602097779512405, 0.031880177557468414, -0.01346231997013092, 0.008024216629564762, 0.08524930477142334, 0.0018473806558176875, 0.06465548276901245, -0.03515639901161194, 0.04332001507282257, 0.027875397354364395, 0.01801133342087269, 0.02812889590859413, 0.03313121572136879, -0.006904172245413065, -0.020393328741192818, -0.026520777493715286, 0.01661752164363861, -0.0002807286218740046, -0.007106533274054527, 0.03456905484199524, -0.013111548498272896, 0.06361763179302216, 0.000659726734738797, 0.01520992536097765, 0.06412512809038162, 0.08475533872842789, 0.050496671348810196, 0.05442844331264496, 0.03821714594960213, 0.010246405377984047, 0.05285528674721718, -0.036314405500888824, 0.0011307505192235112, 0.008704019710421562, 0.003244989551603794, -0.01178975310176611, -0.03928891196846962, 0.04070384055376053, -0.01307608187198639, -0.014722687192261219, 0.02142948843538761, -0.007659976836293936, 0.03987222909927368, -0.010542730800807476, 0.06092670559883118, 0.008005572482943535, -0.0057691545225679874, -0.02362905442714691, -0.011786352843046188, -0.032491911202669144, -0.004381727892905474, -0.011977153830230236, -0.03871365636587143, 0.009378492832183838, 0.035675887018442154, -0.01159888319671154, -0.0017767214449122548, -0.06595104187726974, 0.00907556526362896, 0.027104638516902924, -0.03428962454199791, -0.0009971456602215767, -0.007977784611284733, -0.022126181051135063, 0.002971661975607276, 0.018799034878611565, 0.003428700380027294, 0.047108422964811325, -0.009757106192409992, 0.05465513467788696, 0.04947283864021301, 0.023609217256307602, -0.061949096620082855, 0.03949890658259392, -0.06088472530245781, -0.02942165732383728, 0.03424915671348572, 0.007161103654652834, 0.02877906896173954, 0.05780637264251709, -0.008407915942370892, -0.0077539002522826195, 0.011283199302852154, -0.059854764491319656, -0.04927196353673935, 0.017205212265253067, 0.014605102129280567, -0.006160150282084942, 0.028346247971057892, -0.022432155907154083, 0.045213717967271805, 0.014754819683730602, -0.002539779292419553, -0.05601594224572182, 0.0527745857834816, -0.009752867743372917, -0.01120392419397831, -0.026707248762249947, 0.022246336564421654, -0.04437793046236038, 0.0036403005942702293, -0.07305295020341873, 0.07272852957248688, 0.022655218839645386, 0.044566038995981216, -0.045551568269729614, -0.0228476170450449, 0.044503550976514816, 0.005124255083501339, -0.03502969816327095, -0.05314325541257858, -0.00012436293764039874, 0.01965392380952835, 0.003865579143166542, -0.013793774880468845, -0.0001717153936624527, -0.04577438533306122, -0.020443439483642578, -0.004011404234915972, 0.013894074596464634, 0.01239971537142992, -0.033195532858371735, 0.004722996149212122, 0.0058628227561712265, 0.0047723837196826935, -0.041935231536626816, -0.023594196885824203, -0.028844326734542847, -0.03261246532201767, 0.04573102295398712, 0.010694478638470173, -0.012037994340062141, -0.017105067148804665, -0.016511721536517143, -0.04096870496869087, 0.045052677392959595, 0.0830855742096901, -0.03952541947364807, -0.046922892332077026, 0.019561491906642914, -0.02476910874247551, 0.0156666599214077, -0.014051985926926136, -0.028167102485895157, -0.019734056666493416, 0.010632702149450779, -0.023523487150669098, 0.030918510630726814, -0.008321483619511127, -0.007982044480741024, 0.004772495944052935, -0.0041347588412463665, 0.006950398441404104, -0.004510960541665554, -0.001611379673704505, 0.05077551305294037, 0.013991341926157475, -0.04701291397213936, 0.024002086371183395, 0.0067934016697108746, 0.020825449377298355, -0.044556159526109695, 0.007198678329586983, 0.042024627327919006, -0.001492571085691452, 0.029714493080973625, 0.024763155728578568, -0.02351565472781658, 0.0038812647107988596, -0.002943424042314291, 0.00967848114669323, -0.00846267119050026, 0.05261804163455963, -0.041358206421136856, 0.02375982142984867, -0.08354023098945618, -0.028814520686864853, -0.045324135571718216, 0.03702125698328018, 0.012416417710483074, 0.028880072757601738, 0.051465243101119995, -0.053424667567014694, 0.000883967150002718, 0.00888325646519661, 0.03865596652030945, -0.0011952790664508939, 0.010013136081397533, 0.03122168406844139, -0.013072622939944267, 0.0036278534680604935, 0.009298240765929222, -0.03337731584906578, -0.07120589166879654, -0.009253041818737984, 0.009110849350690842, 0.025607455521821976, -0.02822323702275753, -0.008348061703145504, 0.006508582271635532, 0.04636416211724281, 0.016897981986403465, -0.05324140936136246, -0.009682264178991318, -0.006031032186001539, -0.0022091169375926256, 0.04459603130817413, -0.055443018674850464, -0.0461711511015892, 0.033038899302482605, -0.013115991838276386, -0.029057079926133156, -0.05756733939051628, 0.013601234182715416, -0.07431020587682724, -0.0514882430434227, -0.011983293108642101, -0.09570901840925217, -0.05700157955288887, 0.017339836806058884, 0.017143361270427704, -0.03826216235756874, 0.018368113785982132, 0.1078210100531578, 0.016151299700140953, -0.08084937930107117, -0.045114822685718536, -0.02687959559261799, -0.05659867823123932, 0.022174330428242683, 0.07455385476350784, -0.01705957017838955, 0.018915824592113495, -0.02485620602965355, -0.0163875762373209, -0.01834665983915329, -0.044577062129974365, -0.027603192254900932, -0.02879483811557293, -0.012868541292846203, -0.023327477276325226, -0.06342471390962601, 0.01475709117949009, -0.02522909641265869, -0.052210915833711624, 0.0103908721357584, -0.03484220802783966, 0.0037165442481637, -0.009159834124147892, 0.009433833882212639, 0.005617748945951462, -0.023104261606931686, -0.04209758713841438, 0.02414311282336712, -0.07481025904417038, 0.04356600344181061, 0.053056750446558, 0.08595272153615952, -0.058180276304483414, -0.012637859210371971, -0.03783520683646202, -0.024055490270256996, 0.0024582736659795046, -0.024133943021297455, 0.09864738583564758, -0.05277155339717865, 0.032394006848335266, -0.04736409708857536, 0.030419446527957916, -0.006467869970947504, 0.03372088819742203, 0.06503695249557495, 0.019071869552135468, -0.0036412423942238092, 0.032234326004981995, -0.055831339210271835, 0.042313892394304276, 0.025782223790884018, 0.01637130044400692, 0.003731938311830163, -0.05489112064242363, -0.03107297606766224, -0.011011645197868347, 0.04183100536465645, -0.02186141535639763, -0.016574935987591743, -0.0047839623875916, -0.039682537317276, -0.06332085281610489, -0.06566425412893295, -0.024350054562091827, -0.03886466845870018, 0.042044129222631454, 0.07564877718687057, 0.10903657227754593, 0.043040867894887924, -0.024315940216183662, -0.026511240750551224, -0.028465282171964645, 0.009759253822267056, 0.03727426379919052, -0.012293563224375248, 0.034663841128349304, 0.09341354668140411, -0.04999751225113869, 0.005732894875109196, -0.05370669811964035, -0.021670615300536156, -0.021456405520439148, -0.005390516482293606, 0.0008392583695240319, 0.015010126866400242, 0.017206648364663124, -0.036912813782691956, -0.10878977179527283, 0.013188938610255718, 0.006046025548130274, -0.0018842900171875954, -0.009719187393784523, 0.011289430782198906, 0.01741245947778225, -0.03386397659778595, 0.01273278146982193, -0.01798301376402378, 0.03794652968645096, 0.03385663777589798, -0.06321191787719727, 0.012298704124987125, -0.007553785108029842, -0.020220942795276642, 0.012187384068965912, 0.0286583099514246, -0.02771974727511406, 0.019804315641522408, -0.012627904303371906, 0.006258864421397448, -0.04954047501087189, -0.007047762628644705, -0.025815505534410477, 0.004655345343053341, 0.04480581358075142, -0.000463411066448316, -0.03461414575576782, -0.056440193206071854, -0.012652418576180935, 0.031737808138132095, -0.017801471054553986, 0.0549149326980114, -0.013548190705478191, 0.06720465421676636, -0.04629429057240486, -0.005000245291739702, 0.0019095535390079021, -0.04048752784729004, 0.026473939418792725, 0.03373446315526962, -0.01740020141005516, 0.009167184121906757, 0.006176397204399109, 0.023371415212750435, -0.07604730129241943, 0.04872304946184158, -0.036653485149145126, 0.0379711277782917, -0.002140570431947708, -0.019344745203852654, 0.05254829302430153, -0.0005811468581669033, 0.010079204104840755, 0.011514357291162014, 0.03066447377204895, -0.002902740379795432, 0.0597391277551651, -0.0034048398956656456, 0.010018190369009972, -0.019911447539925575, -0.006877835839986801, -0.023873839527368546, -0.006518911104649305, 0.06830225884914398, 0.06830202043056488, -0.07141094654798508, 0.025586919859051704, -0.09792354702949524, -0.012282361276447773, 0.008015885017812252, 0.013272586278617382, 0.04541588947176933, -0.0063058920204639435, -0.02271559275686741, -0.04020882397890091, -0.023768438026309013, 0.059298720210790634, -0.00368832447566092, 0.021665511652827263, -0.0007018782198429108, 0.010095161385834217, 0.04883197322487831, 0.026292232796549797, -0.036198511719703674, -0.06033507362008095, 0.022851506248116493, 0.01111636497080326, -0.03692031279206276, -0.011178734712302685, -4.7368440351024776e-33, -0.012952357530593872, -0.03670576959848404, 0.009902880527079105, 0.04035075381398201, -0.017981665208935738, -0.004901824984699488, -0.03391629830002785, -0.032535698264837265, -0.024071544408798218, 0.011831370182335377, -0.05355674400925636, 0.014457466080784798, 0.009279189631342888, 0.03588039055466652, 0.04512838274240494, 0.035865798592567444, 0.015183605253696442, -0.0034549597185105085, 0.013781736604869366, 0.03590966761112213, 0.016859780997037888, 0.05116254836320877, 0.032088737934827805, -0.08386644721031189, 0.05209731683135033, -0.04314330220222473, -0.01320691965520382, -0.016630567610263824, 0.021519379690289497, 0.010997490026056767, 0.005223016254603863, 0.018117573112249374, 0.027935832738876343, -0.027463851496577263, 0.027851121500134468, -0.00565181253477931, -0.09802975505590439, -0.05018455162644386, -0.008419068530201912, 0.006951938848942518, 0.049715377390384674, -0.030141759663820267, 0.07265208661556244, -0.01322854869067669, -0.020666679367423058, 0.03619559109210968, 0.12516704201698303, -0.014902411960065365, -0.028980940580368042, -0.0706985741853714, -0.040583010762929916, 0.008928526192903519, 0.041775722056627274, 0.040390241891145706, -0.006438643671572208, -0.017318526282906532, -0.03231918066740036, 0.010355421341955662, -0.08760028332471848, -0.03476013243198395, -0.005323344375938177, 0.0125472042709589, -0.02919163554906845, 0.08028288930654526, 0.010272650979459286, 0.018070189282298088, 0.032020844519138336, 0.019443022087216377, -0.009327775798738003, 0.017759613692760468, 0.03796302154660225, -0.01813814602792263, 0.04088987037539482, 0.05713484808802605, 0.007329346612095833, -0.05838797241449356, -0.06448553502559662, 0.06348026543855667, 0.02147713676095009, -0.016724437475204468, 0.016282398253679276, -0.041793350130319595, -0.04430728778243065, -0.06305065751075745, 0.013375100679695606, -0.021240923553705215, -0.01571919210255146, -0.050682831555604935, -0.01552027277648449, -0.03233926743268967, -0.008324719965457916, -0.021739326417446136, -0.009611580520868301, -0.07125642895698547, -0.037048038095235825, 0.028395414352416992, -0.015552987344563007, 0.04206889867782593, -0.009719581343233585, 0.013326171785593033, -0.02505517192184925, -0.014428899623453617, -0.05812252685427666, 0.040314752608537674, 0.021176066249608994, -0.013814207166433334, 0.06199704855680466, 0.0028441024478524923, -0.032200515270233154, -0.03069542720913887, 0.04087035357952118, -0.028928672894835472, 0.014216689392924309, 0.06718584895133972, -0.04948950186371803, 0.007663379888981581, 0.015672780573368073, 0.020666297525167465, 0.06918925046920776, -0.017646603286266327, -0.011794805526733398, -0.025754131376743317, 0.06633580476045609, -0.006175782065838575, -0.05826970562338829, 0.003134767524898052, -0.007447039242833853, 0.027422579005360603, 0.029688013717532158, -0.04446336254477501, -0.008702926337718964, -0.03627663105726242, 2.44125089920999e-07, 0.0612272210419178, 0.0024731080047786236, -0.008982999250292778, -0.027925169095396996, 0.018579859286546707, 0.024058302864432335, 0.025313017889857292, 0.02231609635055065, -0.0290567334741354, 0.05063186585903168, 0.02896612510085106, -0.017188381403684616, 0.0010377774015069008, 0.008491266518831253, -0.12510472536087036, -0.025377603247761726, -0.050255969166755676, 0.017322149127721786, -0.05308480188250542, 0.031058870255947113, 0.029292190447449684, 0.03580526262521744, 0.06287173181772232, -0.02415439672768116, -0.02358449622988701, -0.05285247042775154, 0.007207871880382299, 0.01631985604763031, -0.0009518859442323446, 0.06033742427825928, 0.019907178357243538, -0.0002888187882490456, -0.02096777781844139, 0.008794794790446758, -0.018545003607869148, 0.05116431042551994, -0.008730253204703331, 0.054135873913764954, -0.034985799342393875, 0.025307953357696533, 0.03309749439358711, -0.03029674105346203, 0.0008239521994255483, -0.02070840448141098, 0.035515107214450836, 0.02162308059632778, -0.05771366134285927, 0.0059309834614396095, 0.019962623715400696, -0.03858853504061699, 0.031150061637163162, 0.0006120284087955952, 0.0002771512954495847, 0.017083384096622467, 0.0005930826300755143, -0.05196700617671013, 0.0023127144668251276, -0.06426350027322769, -0.009686813689768314, 0.011187768541276455, -0.012370194308459759, 0.011651715263724327, 0.009207264520227909, -0.00831613689661026, 0.059834931045770645, -0.0769817903637886, 0.05586600303649902, 2.6442169154008966e-34, 0.01862369291484356, 0.01880348101258278, -0.025702327489852905, 0.0072648851200938225, -0.01576775126159191, 0.015644142404198647, -0.03237824887037277, 0.04977595433592796, -0.003642216557636857, -0.021654784679412842, -0.013685645535588264]
603
603
['Liang Lu', 'Lingpeng Kong', 'Chris Dyer', 'Noah A. Smith', 'Steve Renals']
1603.00223v2
We study the segmental recurrent neural network for end-to-end acoustic modelling. This model connects the segmental conditional random field (CRF) with a recurrent neural network (RNN) used for feature extraction. Compared to most previous CRF-based acoustic models, it does not rely on an external system to provide features or segmentation boundaries. Instead, this model marginalises out all the possible segmentations, and features are extracted from the RNN trained together with the segmental CRF. In essence, this model is self-contained and can be trained end-to-end. In this paper, we discuss practical training and decoding issues as well as the method to speed up the training in the context of speech recognition. We performed experiments on the TIMIT dataset. We achieved 17.3 phone error rate (PER) from the first-pass decoding --- the best reported result using CRFs, despite the fact that we only used a zeroth-order CRF and without using any language model.
Segmental Recurrent Neural Networks for End-to-end Speech Recognition
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1603.00223v2
Title Segmental Recurrent Neural Networks Endtoend Speech Recognition Summary study segmental recurrent neural network endtoend acoustic modelling model connects segmental conditional random field CRF recurrent neural network RNN used feature extraction Compared previous CRFbased acoustic model rely external system provide feature segmentation boundary Instead model marginalises possible segmentation feature extracted RNN trained together segmental CRF essence model selfcontained trained endtoend paper discus practical training decoding issue well method speed training context speech recognition performed experiment TIMIT dataset achieved 173 phone error rate PER firstpass decoding best reported result using CRFs despite fact used zerothorder CRF without using language model Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.01909462735056877, 0.029673578217625618, 0.037180881947278976, 0.03395266830921173, 0.002734440378844738, -0.03491126373410225, -0.0002440836833557114, 0.007297059986740351, -0.08068285882472992, -0.017752185463905334, -0.02081473171710968, -0.013872994109988213, 0.03581831231713295, 0.017155731096863747, -0.023370908573269844, -0.08939522504806519, -0.005255244672298431, -0.004004042595624924, 0.018761832267045975, 0.007463439833372831, 0.03923661261796951, 0.01829269900918007, -0.030413055792450905, 0.03692750260233879, -0.02414429932832718, 0.024458030238747597, -0.012449754402041435, -0.011443160474300385, 0.001044213306158781, -0.05851898714900017, 0.014090112410485744, 0.016911925747990608, 0.008144536055624485, -0.007549658417701721, 2.4147520889528096e-06, -0.023092135787010193, -0.03675500303506851, 0.008008996024727821, -0.024302823469042778, -0.04954027384519577, 0.04296180233359337, 0.022729260846972466, -0.024512574076652527, 0.01584881730377674, 0.0027527378406375647, -8.280780457425863e-05, 0.034950803965330124, 0.09594564139842987, 0.013460353948175907, 0.06004227697849274, -0.004854917526245117, -0.08488953858613968, 0.011426703073084354, -0.005397001747041941, 0.023822816088795662, -0.017432723194360733, -0.02251213602721691, -0.015591691248118877, -0.0038023232482373714, -0.06141972541809082, -0.007048589177429676, -0.0006777562666684389, 0.012911789119243622, 0.028835583478212357, 0.017629969865083694, 0.010409333743155003, -0.05081743374466896, -0.038573671132326126, -0.010592689737677574, 0.07245921343564987, -0.025045383721590042, -0.01595114730298519, 0.024194220080971718, 0.033897168934345245, -0.0724954828619957, -0.06142066791653633, -0.05971021577715874, 0.03289586678147316, -0.03594505786895752, 0.002703228499740362, -0.021975144743919373, 0.061680879443883896, 0.031696662306785583, 0.00195739371702075, -0.050984229892492294, 0.007702733390033245, 0.014269008301198483, -0.03637557104229927, -0.007874060422182083, -0.08628693968057632, 0.014466232620179653, -0.03905609995126724, 0.034935906529426575, 0.02725066989660263, 0.011873988434672356, 0.011970150284469128, -0.025668678805232048, -0.07283744215965271, 0.013170629739761353, 0.008002536371350288, -0.023254109546542168, 0.025371011346578598, -0.02780930884182453, -0.02004668116569519, -0.0004950588918291032, -0.008217886090278625, -0.020009201020002365, 0.004735842347145081, -0.028234755620360374, 0.003840099088847637, -0.02817070484161377, 0.022472752258181572, -0.03012724593281746, 0.040611349046230316, -0.01685374416410923, -0.017662839964032173, -0.07853072881698608, -0.015519573353230953, 0.00954811368137598, -0.012105092406272888, 0.059290409088134766, 0.03862183913588524, -0.04696425423026085, -0.016918456181883812, 0.02333599142730236, 0.017681855708360672, -0.011450721882283688, 0.04844626411795616, -0.006894420366734266, -0.029674720019102097, 0.0409548319876194, 0.013164084404706955, 0.027584971860051155, 0.016863230615854263, -0.005173149518668652, 0.025673778727650642, 0.04000091552734375, -0.013859424740076065, -0.055827561765909195, -0.0284366887062788, -0.0026500707026571035, -0.06190440058708191, -0.0184918399900198, -0.059440337121486664, 0.002829497680068016, -0.00846951175481081, 0.012541865929961205, 0.06169724464416504, 0.014153952710330486, -0.004381043836474419, 0.0317135751247406, 0.06642799079418182, -0.022103289142251015, 0.024460365995764732, 0.060909733176231384, -0.01117280125617981, 0.07853440195322037, 0.003803945379331708, 0.062357526272535324, -0.024761170148849487, 0.0009038522839546204, -0.0406380221247673, -0.02773226425051689, 0.032418567687273026, -0.016988374292850494, -0.027064744383096695, -0.047483041882514954, -0.011059512384235859, 0.03818485513329506, 0.0400635227560997, 0.033291127532720566, 0.024000609293580055, 0.009379643015563488, -0.00560056883841753, 0.020224519073963165, 0.07406322658061981, 0.06972359120845795, 0.027448153123259544, -0.01293086726218462, 0.027126872912049294, -0.012757797725498676, -0.019208429381251335, 0.01606232300400734, 0.004082498140633106, -0.011453782208263874, 0.036520231515169144, 0.023356333374977112, 0.0005675173015333712, -0.01600513607263565, -0.019959399476647377, -0.002114458940923214, -0.03932815045118332, -0.014501715078949928, 0.0032705534249544144, 0.0935172289609909, 0.026783011853694916, -0.02522597648203373, -0.020455660298466682, 0.002395500661805272, -0.06144223362207413, -0.01629854366183281, -0.049334559589624405, 0.0390651635825634, 0.006409789435565472, 0.019047820940613747, -0.04223870113492012, -0.0016567035345360637, -0.019004864618182182, -0.013978037051856518, -0.008474601432681084, -0.023441530764102936, 0.00328373396769166, 0.03824076056480408, -0.07813351601362228, -0.009240761399269104, 0.0732230618596077, -0.0026943201664835215, 0.02661561407148838, -0.04624783247709274, 0.025149257853627205, 0.010924343019723892, -0.036000050604343414, -0.0023613907396793365, 0.011470314115285873, 0.04251334071159363, 0.020161280408501625, 0.001764757325872779, 0.0372583344578743, 0.03187427669763565, 0.04492168128490448, 0.011586595326662064, -0.00929958838969469, 0.0506826750934124, -0.005826007574796677, 0.026084834709763527, 0.035043057054281235, -0.05047797039151192, -0.022274009883403778, -0.002199221635237336, -0.013636713847517967, 0.040087632834911346, 0.019718363881111145, -0.009484496898949146, -0.07893791794776917, 0.055936720222234726, 0.011449226178228855, 0.12004926055669785, -0.036525413393974304, 0.032074980437755585, 0.03140798583626747, -0.012998770922422409, 0.036652300506830215, 0.0005134186358191073, -0.010912473313510418, 0.00878599751740694, 0.018282566219568253, -0.02194519340991974, 0.011941944248974323, -0.09167837351560593, -0.005191722419112921, 0.017278429120779037, -0.07665232568979263, -0.01446540653705597, -0.032063454389572144, 0.019174713641405106, -0.0445537343621254, -0.014716521836817265, -0.06880054622888565, -0.0023084052372723818, -0.023921379819512367, -0.0022338200360536575, -0.01066089328378439, 0.038378167897462845, 0.02273215353488922, -0.024553705006837845, -0.0014033849583938718, -0.0013432035921141505, 0.031918857246637344, -0.02795792557299137, -0.024203656241297722, 0.005360142793506384, -0.037089936435222626, -0.012160279788076878, -0.011835405603051186, 0.0030338901560753584, 0.005176518578082323, 0.028109705075621605, -0.08870492875576019, 0.002281858818605542, -0.004363480489701033, 0.03625275567173958, 0.03964740410447121, 0.006562273483723402, -0.047118425369262695, 0.0012280516093596816, -0.0410902202129364, -8.505830192007124e-05, 0.0325307734310627, -0.00867412704974413, -0.019117139279842377, -0.033232271671295166, -0.008746333420276642, -0.03030383214354515, -0.005259228404611349, -0.02202741801738739, 0.027821173891425133, -0.010638292878866196, -0.026194637641310692, -0.03172414004802704, 0.048211563378572464, 0.029664015397429466, 0.06100095435976982, -2.9787712264806032e-05, -0.03803158178925514, -0.0536460280418396, -0.03990522399544716, 0.00025645369896665215, -0.04100284352898598, -0.012340694665908813, 0.05286038666963577, 0.005108135286718607, -0.014948106370866299, -0.00401743408292532, -0.035684734582901, -0.022622812539339066, -0.0398787185549736, -0.0497511550784111, -0.02273542247712612, -0.004627058282494545, -0.014343427494168282, -0.0021436677780002356, 0.05415525659918785, -0.08296193182468414, 0.028880706056952477, -0.0032085939310491085, -0.03257682919502258, -0.02402081899344921, 0.02881884016096592, 0.0015661980723962188, -0.007158038206398487, -0.010753042064607143, -0.02612040936946869, -0.03907429426908493, 0.0040589296258986, -0.005671510007232428, 0.0023012070450931787, -0.012167511507868767, -0.056593529880046844, 0.03259838744997978, 0.06380682438611984, -0.013798690401017666, 0.05811427906155586, -0.033988118171691895, 0.020227225497364998, -0.0014386767288669944, 0.051103681325912476, 0.04976262152194977, 0.02691568247973919, -0.052746668457984924, 0.010394067503511906, 0.012300781905651093, -0.010784215293824673, 0.06422965228557587, 0.0008704154752194881, -0.09424076229333878, -0.014308183453977108, -0.012058598920702934, -0.014567953534424305, 0.0009296088828705251, 0.03737529367208481, 0.037458036094903946, -0.09583014994859695, 0.01436010841280222, 0.06760402768850327, -0.019008250907063484, -0.04909314587712288, -0.038202762603759766, -0.013288384303450584, -0.03904399275779724, 0.024896299466490746, -0.008663637563586235, -0.010975994169712067, -0.015732217580080032, 0.053798675537109375, 0.0675148293375969, 0.014761282131075859, -0.006392000708729029, -0.0006971659604460001, -0.08332780003547668, 0.0717257633805275, -0.007374829147011042, -0.10562114417552948, -0.026754632592201233, -0.033824775367975235, -0.039967071264982224, -0.008586287498474121, 0.01025928184390068, 0.0023566875606775284, -0.021416030824184418, -0.038279980421066284, 0.06164289638400078, -0.1110122799873352, 0.0072187078185379505, 0.022958699613809586, -0.0477948896586895, 0.031222017481923103, 0.09822294861078262, 0.009793123230338097, -0.029745880514383316, -0.012796560302376747, 0.05567103624343872, -0.010283824987709522, 0.015921248123049736, -0.03649970889091492, 0.0009434036328457296, 0.021745098754763603, -0.014764863066375256, 0.009083278477191925, 0.06501810252666473, 0.007243239786475897, 0.027358341962099075, 0.012124811299145222, 0.05325254052877426, -0.003877202747389674, 0.03575599566102028, -0.048562292009592056, 0.055605705827474594, 0.036888327449560165, 0.010229809209704399, -0.0069547388702631, -0.016414228826761246, -0.022430360317230225, 0.01878979615867138, 0.051887594163417816, -0.04242449998855591, 0.06380485743284225, -0.005307559389621019, 0.006260371301323175, -0.055107902735471725, -0.03414905443787575, -0.03914656117558479, 0.0070273382589221, 0.04988311231136322, 0.04984090104699135, 0.008731159381568432, 0.023600775748491287, 0.04622913524508476, -0.04697031155228615, -0.00905708596110344, 0.022923694923520088, 0.031095381826162338, -0.08235029876232147, 0.044183243066072464, 0.014512820169329643, -0.0773991048336029, 0.003341138595715165, -0.0585789829492569, -0.020506124943494797, -0.009978190064430237, 0.042711034417152405, 0.014293051324784756, 0.0211652759462595, 0.05533561110496521, -0.06326261907815933, -0.051667340099811554, 0.0067476537078619, -0.03651685267686844, -0.048132725059986115, 0.019092010334134102, 0.07362212985754013, 0.057486120611429214, 0.00841627735644579, -0.0021405830048024654, -0.05373755842447281, 0.03723384067416191, -0.008409416303038597, 0.012241590768098831, -0.05361916869878769, -0.06311813741922379, 0.002281733090057969, -0.0038871346041560173, 0.05154548957943916, 0.008957160636782646, 0.021274445578455925, -0.06411782652139664, 0.05393596738576889, 0.03644480183720589, 0.05321359261870384, -0.01030975766479969, 0.021280525252223015, 0.0418597050011158, 0.04605806991457939, 0.022170929238200188, -0.019868573173880577, 0.005261883605271578, -0.013892005197703838, 0.03687094897031784, 0.08994413167238235, 0.03198708966374397, 0.02862650528550148, -0.022569982334971428, 0.002690464025363326, -0.018824202939867973, 0.022730998694896698, 0.02068108692765236, 0.044892530888319016, -0.006459933239966631, 0.07899697870016098, -0.0071488190442323685, -0.008980202488601208, -0.02320900373160839, 0.014522234909236431, 0.03169403597712517, 0.015197012573480606, -0.05734174698591232, -0.009961008094251156, -0.011056383140385151, -0.015410552732646465, 0.003723567584529519, -0.0012099394807592034, 0.02554791420698166, -0.04230072721838951, 0.04771627113223076, -0.05865592136979103, 0.007110462058335543, 0.06487970799207687, 0.0075147743336856365, -0.02309488132596016, 0.006674645934253931, -0.02747044898569584, 0.022038495168089867, 0.0041360496543347836, -0.005378062836825848, -0.0021572911646217108, -0.024735990911722183, -0.025520484894514084, 0.014393373392522335, 0.018068671226501465, -0.044698335230350494, -0.003654720261693001, -0.02129059098660946, -0.02943120151758194, 0.05339978262782097, -0.0020973782520741224, 0.030871542170643806, -0.02213364653289318, -0.004561419133096933, -0.011498959735035896, -0.0040967767126858234, 0.026156309992074966, 0.003949790261685848, -0.04275495931506157, 0.01489016879349947, -0.026856420561671257, -0.010286637581884861, -6.608383121193197e-33, 0.02080826833844185, 0.006716049276292324, -0.012289250269532204, -0.059377238154411316, -0.06069861352443695, 0.009705654345452785, -0.015393218025565147, 0.003242198145017028, 0.016084101051092148, -0.032213740050792694, -0.031249063089489937, -0.02102973870933056, 0.042679313570261, 0.03973002731800079, 0.02843223512172699, -0.0035872594453394413, 0.07592589408159256, -0.020551450550556183, 0.06582145392894745, -0.03517027199268341, 0.05808005854487419, 0.06189187616109848, 0.04705206677317619, -0.052596963942050934, -0.02417287603020668, -0.0024200803600251675, -0.031505558639764786, -0.004859450738877058, 0.023947322741150856, 0.03168831765651703, -0.025979919359087944, -0.031216248869895935, -0.00791845377534628, -0.04800257831811905, -0.014426132664084435, 0.046565208584070206, -0.15128973126411438, 0.024007931351661682, -0.032979417592287064, 0.04776185750961304, -0.03681180998682976, 0.0357133150100708, 0.08253224194049835, 0.009679214097559452, 0.0006619158666580915, 0.02583179995417595, 0.04683772101998329, -0.04469925910234451, -0.031634457409381866, -0.024669690057635307, -0.05550261214375496, 0.032055895775556564, 0.002759183757007122, -0.00839183572679758, 0.06579548120498657, 0.02009202353656292, -0.04353013262152672, -0.022323930636048317, -0.08780591189861298, 0.016699444502592087, -0.00402770796790719, 0.016798235476017, 0.04183858633041382, 0.034445200115442276, -0.01835952140390873, -0.03269965946674347, 0.06782100349664688, -0.08885977417230606, 0.027542458847165108, 0.002524894429370761, 0.016314780339598656, 0.05216403305530548, 0.02114730142056942, -0.01508303638547659, 0.05434781685471535, -0.03155354782938957, -0.05254668742418289, 0.009020012803375721, 0.014178818091750145, 0.03204398974776268, -0.008399572223424911, 0.00864817202091217, -0.06802704930305481, 0.004794043023139238, -0.005579414311796427, -0.041521765291690826, -0.03256019577383995, -0.011951844207942486, 0.05162031203508377, 0.005029591731727123, 0.05149661377072334, -0.01691567525267601, 0.02601475641131401, -0.015792468562722206, 0.06481203436851501, -0.048757582902908325, 0.027635948732495308, 0.016649095341563225, -0.018252594396471977, -0.009587269276380539, -0.0626564621925354, 0.013867039233446121, 0.013531440868973732, 0.0309318657964468, -0.00087933917529881, -0.012404641136527061, 0.02973037026822567, 0.029029380530118942, -0.02456188201904297, 0.0026552581693977118, -0.0012975225690752268, 0.020416850224137306, 0.008514159359037876, 0.10802722722291946, 0.03331979736685753, -0.03685213252902031, -0.012944689951837063, 0.06997841596603394, -0.007996371947228909, 0.04169834777712822, -0.024784069508314133, -0.018870273604989052, 0.03370428457856178, 0.0342465341091156, -0.07520803809165955, 0.002565201371908188, -0.008034562692046165, 0.008436275646090508, 0.0333867222070694, 0.027523748576641083, -0.015559661202132702, 0.061287153512239456, 2.9434562520691543e-07, -0.03706613555550575, -0.03933051601052284, 0.040948644280433655, 0.0012927510542795062, -0.017438223585486412, 0.003371157916262746, -0.009156681597232819, -0.007411818485707045, -0.0004239060799591243, 0.02772734872996807, 0.03655330836772919, -0.04652686044573784, 0.05787188559770584, -0.0031581888906657696, -0.1169281005859375, -0.007450489327311516, -0.06070125102996826, -0.010976405814290047, -0.01720181480050087, 0.04051709920167923, -0.011926251463592052, 0.10950514674186707, 0.035039760172367096, -0.04179026931524277, 0.0325399711728096, 0.008314487524330616, -0.021358786150813103, 0.0014730963157489896, 0.03680310398340225, -0.007500161416828632, 0.0002809723373502493, 0.010256964713335037, -0.03272094950079918, -0.015925660729408264, -0.02572518400847912, 0.013146692886948586, 0.02465459518134594, 0.019001759588718414, -0.028961660340428352, -0.05691980570554733, 0.03691922128200531, 0.04984186217188835, -0.009168408811092377, -0.01809128373861313, 0.038904912769794464, -0.0024799522943794727, 0.0004632485506590456, -0.011951819993555546, -0.0050251972861588, 0.01927199214696884, -0.023603085428476334, -0.019514311105012894, 0.04371654987335205, -0.027697185054421425, -0.0033699776977300644, -0.044178035110235214, -0.026957979425787926, -0.04859727621078491, 0.016766810789704323, 0.028590137138962746, -0.032176245003938675, -0.024884287267923355, -0.017330199480056763, 0.014794467948377132, 0.029277479276061058, -0.012426505796611309, -0.02899344637989998, 2.826426575384265e-34, 0.018031137064099312, -0.022331444546580315, -0.014088954776525497, 0.006032966542989016, -0.009100503288209438, -0.009459943510591984, -0.008192532695829868, 0.019815873354673386, -0.007922153919935226, -0.05082617327570915, -0.061688125133514404]
604
604
['Lili Mou', 'Zhao Meng', 'Rui Yan', 'Ge Li', 'Yan Xu', 'Lu Zhang', 'Zhi Jin']
1603.06111v2
Transfer learning is aimed to make use of valuable knowledge in a source domain to help model performance in a target domain. It is particularly important to neural networks, which are very likely to be overfitting. In some fields like image processing, many studies have shown the effectiveness of neural network-based transfer learning. For neural NLP, however, existing studies have only casually applied transfer learning, and conclusions are inconsistent. In this paper, we conduct systematic case studies and provide an illuminating picture on the transferability of neural networks in NLP.
How Transferable are Neural Networks in NLP Applications?
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1603.06111v2
Title Transferable Neural Networks NLP Applications Summary Transfer learning aimed make use valuable knowledge source domain help model performance target domain particularly important neural network likely overfitting field like image processing many study shown effectiveness neural networkbased transfer learning neural NLP however existing study casually applied transfer learning conclusion inconsistent paper conduct systematic case study provide illuminating picture transferability neural network NLP Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.0072393398731946945, 0.044481221586465836, -0.004846601746976376, 0.06205492094159126, -0.013320247642695904, -0.012743615545332432, 0.0037230942398309708, 0.002024505054578185, -0.02883164770901203, -0.030240140855312347, -0.04762844368815422, 0.05009543523192406, -0.008013979531824589, 0.06258271634578705, 0.020630905404686928, -0.1019604280591011, -0.0030245205853134394, 0.03410252183675766, -0.011907411739230156, 0.028123825788497925, -0.0026091132313013077, -0.0207354836165905, -0.005240297876298428, 0.03292924910783768, -0.04246203228831291, 0.0010079985950142145, 0.01843104511499405, -0.021580895408988, 0.02538573183119297, -0.0008934197248890996, 0.009376716800034046, 0.011689748615026474, 0.043396737426519394, -0.017433205619454384, 2.484049673512345e-06, 0.008999456651508808, -0.06145665794610977, -0.006164070218801498, 0.007590544410049915, -0.04350920021533966, 0.07498116791248322, -0.03949885070323944, -0.005383653100579977, -0.021889852359890938, -0.013340087607502937, 0.010467049665749073, 0.08526274561882019, 0.084352508187294, 0.06724880635738373, 0.07123442739248276, -0.04978194460272789, -0.027867455035448074, 0.060555506497621536, 0.024591252207756042, 0.0007008123793639243, -0.07638943940401077, 0.029843922704458237, 0.030989117920398712, -0.005457662045955658, -0.018807057291269302, -0.03450101613998413, 0.0564911887049675, -0.008523188531398773, -0.04688418284058571, 0.033109571784734726, -0.012754758819937706, -0.02638193778693676, 0.019682254642248154, -0.015965763479471207, 0.07473396509885788, -0.038531702011823654, 0.025122221559286118, -0.018320664763450623, -0.028451714664697647, -0.005972468294203281, 0.032584454864263535, -0.06101028621196747, 0.004405297338962555, 0.030297251418232918, 0.0585087351500988, -0.07222647219896317, 0.054353710263967514, 0.00394988851621747, 0.012756038457155228, 0.005635248031467199, 0.023030979558825493, 0.008321271277964115, 0.02986859902739525, 0.02281057834625244, 0.026899190619587898, 0.015513812191784382, -0.005380365997552872, 0.025840982794761658, 0.010897960513830185, 0.013889176771044731, 0.03157911077141762, -0.03687489777803421, -0.045121654868125916, -0.03737780451774597, -0.015856491401791573, 0.07330482453107834, -0.04285107180476189, -0.04196798801422119, 0.03749122470617294, -0.07527623325586319, 0.017981944605708122, -0.033285729587078094, 0.025748221203684807, -0.014223652891814709, -0.056096699088811874, -0.11129775643348694, -0.01458668615669012, -0.03598521649837494, 0.07428014278411865, -0.01925428956747055, -0.07042545080184937, -0.07543744146823883, -0.027910657227039337, -0.036665432155132294, -0.030777782201766968, 0.03808189556002617, 0.061133649200201035, -0.011617674492299557, -0.01564813405275345, -0.009336283430457115, 0.03862367942929268, 0.02884712629020214, 0.05733054131269455, -0.0002879979438148439, -0.027504844591021538, 0.03927793726325035, 0.03867560997605324, 0.02764499932527542, -0.0013714476954191923, -0.020858248695731163, 0.06267032772302628, -0.017150530591607094, 0.008157302625477314, -0.04913831502199173, 0.031079614534974098, 0.026921730488538742, -0.011663091368973255, 0.0454302579164505, -0.044162578880786896, 0.01388787105679512, -0.05606065317988396, 0.005086108110845089, -0.052781328558921814, -0.02339240536093712, 0.01351663563400507, -0.05227280780673027, 0.09873007982969284, -0.03674636036157608, 0.009229030460119247, 0.025068482384085655, -0.01122176181524992, -0.0032950658351182938, 0.0263812392950058, 0.04324478283524513, 0.014796094037592411, 0.012340505607426167, -0.04064159840345383, 0.0006145169609226286, -0.013310162350535393, 0.0061128828674554825, -0.04248146340250969, -0.027077356353402138, -0.06047774851322174, -0.01131256390362978, 0.005077532026916742, 0.03331278637051582, 0.03113972209393978, 0.008878912776708603, 0.0005626237252727151, 0.054185666143894196, 0.056936345994472504, 0.07312817126512527, 0.031094057485461235, 0.039367593824863434, 0.034040700644254684, -0.035749226808547974, -0.008932600729167461, -0.008267492987215519, 0.08360502123832703, -0.0006782347918488085, -0.04398094117641449, -0.05796847492456436, -0.015270828269422054, -0.032151833176612854, -0.014399634674191475, 0.05257133021950722, -0.01919379085302353, 0.012946626171469688, -0.049137182533741, 0.05788169056177139, 0.0693187490105629, -0.025633201003074646, 0.03425820171833038, -0.003945712931454182, -0.004915929865092039, 0.009161806665360928, -0.03916654735803604, -0.010689942166209221, 0.02647201158106327, -0.02496710792183876, -0.0011188429780304432, -0.0033019701950252056, 0.015516670420765877, -0.014122501946985722, -0.007551598362624645, 0.0059109944850206375, -0.006592950318008661, 0.03685227036476135, -0.04399329796433449, -0.01705397665500641, -0.029003188014030457, 0.02101389318704605, 0.038595326244831085, -0.03550172597169876, 0.046505678445100784, 0.021009350195527077, 0.028921620920300484, -0.011100998148322105, 0.0440666601061821, -0.006226292811334133, -0.020992640405893326, 0.03696749731898308, 0.029652876779437065, 0.0036348910070955753, -0.001765271881595254, 0.006206085905432701, -0.005501729901880026, -0.008969970047473907, -0.01730671338737011, -0.052769821137189865, 0.018091673031449318, -0.044460978358983994, -0.00963504333049059, -0.013820115476846695, -0.048473864793777466, 0.07513466477394104, 0.02850535698235035, -0.050838373601436615, -0.025180233642458916, 0.042171914130449295, 0.01759008876979351, -0.0007182025001384318, 0.002326837508007884, 0.023905575275421143, 0.00985225010663271, 0.07685687392950058, -0.011301452293992043, 0.031322211027145386, 0.05605238676071167, -0.018102843314409256, -0.022557511925697327, -0.0204617939889431, 0.02549956925213337, -0.010093347169458866, -0.0028600285295397043, 0.0003283175465185195, -0.021820398047566414, 0.009892066940665245, -0.04683703929185867, 0.018794283270835876, -0.03836867958307266, 0.027949132025241852, -0.00017476007633376867, -0.016808897256851196, 0.02804693393409252, -0.008552932180464268, 0.022664526477456093, -0.021901393309235573, 0.023944949731230736, -0.011845273897051811, -0.03947371989488602, 0.10384886711835861, -0.001387694850564003, -0.023712262511253357, 0.05482375621795654, 0.016167692840099335, 0.03207157179713249, -0.010426493361592293, -0.025999018922448158, 0.0167058277875185, 0.06642383337020874, -0.014215784147381783, -0.08144298195838928, -0.05378620699048042, 0.03282637149095535, 0.023663047701120377, 0.0165775828063488, 0.023224210366606712, -0.02390284650027752, -0.03968387097120285, -0.014698948711156845, -0.07663831859827042, 0.017461556941270828, -0.012917304411530495, -0.019264748319983482, -0.02663339674472809, -0.020553018897771835, -0.026819277554750443, -0.02119397185742855, -0.005203437525779009, 0.01802317053079605, 0.01480154413729906, -0.00952827837318182, 0.002228484721854329, -0.007335531059652567, -0.012735326774418354, -0.011439248919487, -0.014473333954811096, 0.035124521702528, -0.028702614828944206, -0.015735961496829987, -0.05847853794693947, 0.015617454424500465, 0.029089361429214478, -0.020476829260587692, 0.010003370232880116, -0.018472500145435333, 0.009711705148220062, 0.0011397767812013626, 0.01754295825958252, -0.01650710217654705, -0.048594292253255844, -0.034450165927410126, 0.026960885152220726, -0.0007217360544018447, 0.02550698257982731, 0.028772709891200066, -0.015248197130858898, -0.021325718611478806, -0.0371500626206398, 0.02455918677151203, 0.019895566627383232, 0.01839400641620159, -0.02610965631902218, -0.001918485970236361, -0.052110813558101654, 0.003985332790762186, -0.04156533256173134, 0.01966654136776924, 0.011811849661171436, 0.02889743447303772, -0.006625349633395672, -0.0033861338160932064, -0.02024167589843273, 0.02986142225563526, 0.012497984804213047, 0.029897786676883698, 0.005044491961598396, -0.010309580713510513, 0.00913827121257782, 0.07760945707559586, 0.038685381412506104, 0.011381261050701141, -0.03207137808203697, 0.055193379521369934, -0.0050659324042499065, 0.029417864978313446, -0.0709613487124443, 0.008221768774092197, -0.09792139381170273, 0.056237924844026566, 0.0017303171334788203, -0.010406969115138054, -0.02153502032160759, 0.0024447909090667963, 0.04502376914024353, -0.07706131041049957, 0.009010457433760166, 0.016985038295388222, -0.01853516511619091, -0.03006967157125473, -0.015582320280373096, 0.006758693140000105, -0.08647238463163376, -0.012106096372008324, 0.04205624386668205, 0.00028005102649331093, -0.030383680015802383, -0.03902840241789818, -0.019712992012500763, -0.0014940649271011353, -0.06199091300368309, -0.05819454416632652, -0.08699992299079895, 0.03289651498198509, -0.020997488871216774, -0.05869050696492195, -0.07037118822336197, 0.012677057646214962, 0.017690202221274376, -0.02069235034286976, 0.005432199686765671, -0.05081218108534813, -0.009644248522818089, -0.01798294112086296, 0.035313621163368225, -0.04314836487174034, -0.04524271562695503, 0.00024932718952186406, -0.045206207782030106, 0.03683967888355255, 0.05018206685781479, 0.050086069852113724, -0.03640773519873619, -0.046952083706855774, 0.0032590290065854788, -0.01986374892294407, 0.015488903038203716, -0.0001646021264605224, 0.09410372376441956, 0.0030380862299352884, -0.022569939494132996, 0.033436525613069534, 0.030246324837207794, -0.02050289511680603, -0.010985505767166615, 0.00203405087813735, 0.06097380444407463, 0.05114343762397766, -0.06054088473320007, -0.052137937396764755, 0.005845893174409866, 0.05259380862116814, 0.010055583901703358, 0.0011369152925908566, -0.038030948489904404, -0.014135829173028469, 0.010304303839802742, -0.015952344983816147, -0.03050035983324051, -0.004733814857900143, 0.04693421348929405, -0.03612542897462845, -0.0345994308590889, -0.10143556445837021, 0.008793383836746216, -0.02048422396183014, 0.05320223793387413, 0.043385978788137436, 0.006845739204436541, 0.05968741327524185, 0.0004774855333380401, -0.03871726617217064, 0.005101713351905346, 0.006373459007591009, 0.010512124747037888, -0.019534073770046234, 0.03198900818824768, 0.032090749591588974, -0.01796652004122734, 0.008708988316357136, -0.060910627245903015, -0.012604901567101479, 0.003898609196767211, -0.044900644570589066, 0.0431637242436409, 0.004809392150491476, -0.0329778678715229, -0.037287600338459015, -0.04601483419537544, 0.01538819819688797, 0.031035391613841057, -0.015273499302566051, -0.058180633932352066, 0.05086413770914078, -0.01535523310303688, 0.0005077722016721964, 0.007428054232150316, -0.006086508743464947, 0.06412053108215332, 0.040979158133268356, -0.0438976064324379, 0.05063224583864212, -4.6124085201881826e-05, -0.0034692236222326756, -0.007177406456321478, 0.004353725351393223, 0.06461603939533234, -0.023387359455227852, -0.04193906858563423, 0.0014298100722953677, 0.0014400779036805034, 0.020514830946922302, -0.0758969783782959, 0.0035165613517165184, 0.05269647762179375, 0.05756993591785431, -0.005995671730488539, -0.05654573068022728, 0.03667687252163887, -0.04472959041595459, 0.006902530789375305, 0.03630869463086128, 0.017283905297517776, 0.03283737972378731, -0.05441117286682129, 0.039145708084106445, 0.0025397443678230047, -0.05038553848862648, 0.02025688625872135, 0.04557447135448456, -0.03925371915102005, 0.034256745129823685, 0.0051940493285655975, 0.006963778752833605, -0.04247967153787613, 0.03925697132945061, 0.01529733743518591, 0.01190386526286602, -0.05237364396452904, 0.00900223944336176, 0.04414203390479088, -0.052722468972206116, 0.006285627838224173, -0.009475111961364746, 0.021788598969578743, -0.021530499681830406, 0.07125353813171387, -0.003246230073273182, 0.007267515175044537, 0.01914336159825325, -0.023359568789601326, 0.015924515202641487, -0.0026360671035945415, 0.010732854716479778, -0.009798546321690083, -0.02110368013381958, -0.01967150717973709, -0.03912689536809921, -0.026875551789999008, 0.03886529803276062, 0.01696905680000782, -0.04002232849597931, 0.007149070035666227, 0.06896664947271347, 0.024529749527573586, -0.044834285974502563, 0.008287101984024048, -0.05748266726732254, 0.03939943015575409, 0.02330406755208969, 0.010244091041386127, 0.029013201594352722, 0.045460719615221024, -0.003746901173144579, -0.026665113866329193, -0.018683835864067078, 0.02150076813995838, 0.03196746110916138, -0.030206408351659775, -6.605996132977058e-33, -0.01663956418633461, -0.031103534623980522, 0.026878811419010162, -0.028759431093931198, -0.018914658576250076, -0.0046432046219706535, -0.0156438946723938, -0.05022247135639191, -0.03296811878681183, 0.025280870497226715, -0.008669767528772354, -0.004753125831484795, 0.017755748704075813, 0.04647649824619293, 0.010767162777483463, 0.008414793759584427, 0.0038132343906909227, 0.012975884601473808, 0.018360096961259842, -0.002879809821024537, 0.024865398183465004, 0.06173514202237129, 0.10315469652414322, -0.0979664996266365, -0.05305647850036621, 0.09348732233047485, 0.017952827736735344, -0.03794166073203087, 0.0418042354285717, 0.0015877241967245936, -0.013708913698792458, 0.012991263531148434, 0.05305003002285957, -0.06245427951216698, -0.03609810397028923, 0.026405945420265198, -0.03976540267467499, -0.02140331268310547, -0.03243979439139366, 0.04897360876202583, -0.0094688031822443, -0.015385734848678112, 0.0792626366019249, -0.039145588874816895, 0.018542008474469185, -0.016713082790374756, 0.04406626895070076, -0.07480227947235107, -0.00885410513728857, 0.01346561685204506, -0.08670800924301147, 0.009195145219564438, 0.003660034853965044, 0.010303365997970104, 0.04748721048235893, 0.007495351601392031, -0.04299956560134888, 0.008203969337046146, -0.0858267992734909, -0.005966588854789734, -0.023110581561923027, 0.02431543543934822, 0.06759840250015259, -0.0034568067640066147, -0.0035236969124525785, 0.01211062353104353, 0.01591343805193901, -0.057067375630140305, 0.02548731490969658, -0.02389756217598915, 0.01283714547753334, 0.10079141706228256, 0.06690375506877899, 0.008216443471610546, 0.04616410657763481, -0.07025782018899918, -0.02967241033911705, 0.009527630172669888, -0.04459473863244057, 0.015142111107707024, 0.007281879894435406, 0.03804105892777443, 0.010683459229767323, -0.026059778407216072, 0.007932865992188454, -0.028620554134249687, 9.435772517463192e-05, -0.05012882500886917, 0.017554569989442825, -0.03233085945248604, 0.0031217425130307674, 0.03955512493848801, 0.02038397826254368, -0.05239211767911911, -0.022655202075839043, -0.025046851485967636, -0.01729399897158146, 0.0010868252720683813, 0.0017629427602514625, -0.010614429600536823, -0.09382333606481552, -0.030149850994348526, -0.00030560040613636374, 0.049559853971004486, 0.059818655252456665, 0.0007881426718086004, 0.052258387207984924, 0.02867182530462742, -0.009219295345246792, -0.03481902927160263, -0.018664298579096794, -0.0026893611066043377, 0.011257314123213291, 0.07453498244285583, -0.014586995355784893, -0.030606016516685486, -0.045881811529397964, 0.015341521240770817, -0.0034678708761930466, -0.032215990126132965, 0.017945576459169388, -0.01949913054704666, 0.03142434358596802, 0.0012575797736644745, -0.07920903712511063, 0.0023474711924791336, -0.05863450840115547, 0.034138403832912445, 0.04401717334985733, -0.03508031740784645, -0.020516512915492058, 0.04796724393963814, 3.072377410262561e-07, 0.04082806408405304, 0.006828748621046543, -0.02859678864479065, -0.04723447933793068, 0.004514249041676521, 0.016367917880415916, -0.053411226719617844, 0.05433296412229538, -0.014130944386124611, 0.026255378499627113, -0.003603963414207101, 0.010250288993120193, 0.04292910173535347, 0.00549698481336236, -0.04553165286779404, -0.062320828437805176, -0.0013829035451635718, -0.0070311021991074085, -0.01458288449794054, 0.0035311486572027206, 0.05738365650177002, 0.06697282940149307, 0.05664648860692978, -0.01726868934929371, 0.06212487071752548, -0.003307450795546174, -0.011168490163981915, -0.039722900837659836, 0.0572049655020237, -0.008616140112280846, -0.003569793188944459, 0.03332645073533058, -0.03439510613679886, 0.04349089413881302, -0.015314051881432533, 0.029887227341532707, 0.07114741206169128, 0.02084897831082344, -0.014215086586773396, 0.0011020742822438478, -0.009750007651746273, -0.00272364541888237, 0.01561915036290884, -0.019655609503388405, 0.04308612644672394, -0.08601738512516022, -0.06339328736066818, -0.012123066931962967, -0.009741788730025291, 0.02870660275220871, -0.005121962632983923, 0.019645748659968376, 0.023810874670743942, -0.034827977418899536, 0.03165878728032112, -0.004302011802792549, -0.06621701270341873, -0.061711013317108154, 0.0346258282661438, -0.0019694806542247534, 0.0006263081450015306, 0.0030970205552875996, -0.03652779757976532, -0.050568513572216034, 0.04284881427884102, -0.012047426775097847, 0.011351924389600754, 2.4697372787178867e-34, -0.04917849972844124, 0.007703477516770363, 0.025782182812690735, 0.0017432791646569967, -0.01601865515112877, 0.01018489059060812, -0.015222286805510521, 0.016717148944735527, -0.03816040977835655, -0.01859063282608986, -0.002476625144481659]
605
605
['Wei-Ning Hsu', 'Yu Zhang', 'James Glass']
1603.07044v1
We apply a general recurrent neural network (RNN) encoder framework to community question answering (cQA) tasks. Our approach does not rely on any linguistic processing, and can be applied to different languages or domains. Further improvements are observed when we extend the RNN encoders with a neural attention mechanism that encourages reasoning over entire sequences. To deal with practical issues such as data sparsity and imbalanced labels, we apply various techniques such as transfer learning and multitask learning. Our experiments on the SemEval-2016 cQA task show 10% improvement on a MAP score compared to an information retrieval-based approach, and achieve comparable performance to a strong handcrafted feature-based method.
Recurrent Neural Network Encoder with Attention for Community Question Answering
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1603.07044v1
Title Recurrent Neural Network Encoder Attention Community Question Answering Summary apply general recurrent neural network RNN encoder framework community question answering cQA task approach rely linguistic processing applied different language domain improvement observed extend RNN encoders neural attention mechanism encourages reasoning entire sequence deal practical issue data sparsity imbalanced label apply various technique transfer learning multitask learning experiment SemEval2016 cQA task show 10 improvement MAP score compared information retrievalbased approach achieve comparable performance strong handcrafted featurebased method Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.028209848329424858, 0.039999667555093765, -0.011160486377775669, 0.06346011161804199, -0.007395118474960327, -0.006305999588221312, 0.0022823307663202286, -0.00979146920144558, -0.008441049605607986, -0.039311543107032776, 0.01076226495206356, 0.0029576115775853395, 0.0028488426469266415, 0.030060268938541412, -0.0033332975581288338, -0.07016128301620483, 0.020173730328679085, 0.03163319081068039, 0.009480039589107037, 0.05739779397845268, 0.01889016665518284, 0.02289513126015663, 0.044715579599142075, 0.05431496724486351, -0.005152391269803047, -0.008510975167155266, 0.0013533440651372075, -0.009642750956118107, 0.01655266247689724, -0.07314231991767883, 0.0335361510515213, 0.025596391409635544, 0.01374801155179739, 0.023274924606084824, 2.1673399714927655e-06, -0.025388212874531746, -0.017326069995760918, -0.045934975147247314, 0.03944747522473335, -0.0432424321770668, 0.022035229951143265, -0.016817986965179443, 0.034463122487068176, 0.03284770995378494, -0.0400182381272316, -0.01823253557085991, 0.03668569028377533, 0.08284801244735718, 0.03861226886510849, 0.06837580353021622, -0.009842289611697197, -0.04829709231853485, -0.023107904940843582, -0.027746757492423058, 0.04524199292063713, -0.03141015022993088, 0.012257363647222519, -0.01587172970175743, -0.00441757682710886, 0.0030841745901852846, -0.010371155105531216, 0.04885533079504967, 0.03278311342000961, -0.018394140526652336, 0.03268665075302124, 0.027524493634700775, 0.014485420659184456, -0.010274667292833328, 0.015150201506912708, 0.1101200133562088, -0.06216520071029663, -0.006365214474499226, -0.006231627892702818, 0.03136591240763664, -0.01351466029882431, -0.01711389422416687, -0.06160593777894974, 0.016355479136109352, -0.01873212680220604, 0.01251721940934658, 0.0015939369332045317, 0.04396050423383713, 0.014366108924150467, -0.004769316408783197, -0.02925415337085724, 0.04897681996226311, -0.0062113553285598755, -0.022013861685991287, -0.017937829717993736, 0.0022657569497823715, 0.02850249595940113, -0.04758581891655922, 0.034183986485004425, 0.0774523988366127, 0.013398230075836182, -0.01482130866497755, -0.0028063044883310795, -0.056671906262636185, 0.020093699917197227, -0.06936438381671906, 0.023882437497377396, -0.013562447391450405, -0.03998850658535957, 0.0364546924829483, 0.024395182728767395, 0.034660451114177704, 0.0028597291093319654, 0.0099021689966321, -0.027880314737558365, -0.025682346895337105, -0.050907135009765625, -0.005940618924796581, -0.03432850167155266, 0.04468727111816406, -0.01773596927523613, -0.022471318021416664, -0.02563956007361412, -0.024930423125624657, 0.0017133669462054968, -0.0207065362483263, 0.0331205390393734, 0.06786752492189407, -0.03834453225135803, -0.0019240158144384623, -0.01467125304043293, 0.040152620524168015, -0.061396338045597076, 0.006305495742708445, 0.0007507376139983535, -0.02256571501493454, -0.008725862018764019, 0.048122528940439224, 0.02954419143497944, -0.014802317135035992, -0.020838504657149315, 0.06592682003974915, 0.02201593481004238, -0.001545614912174642, -0.033575039356946945, -0.009835551492869854, 0.01346116978675127, -0.04937925189733505, -0.010857249610126019, -0.05821690708398819, 0.03189999982714653, -0.03795068711042404, -0.04727833718061447, -0.023895710706710815, 0.0197468139231205, 0.037305887788534164, -0.0013033082941547036, 0.08308641612529755, 0.0030372431501746178, 0.002466153586283326, 0.051120854914188385, 0.01086294837296009, 0.04161984100937843, 0.02456287108361721, 0.0481608584523201, 0.03258073329925537, 0.002883279463276267, -0.00802050530910492, 0.0350312665104866, -0.000310829229420051, -0.006651562638580799, -0.05664019659161568, 0.002124312799423933, -0.003967864438891411, -0.005660515744239092, 0.04134231060743332, 0.029133426025509834, 0.03466229513287544, 0.021107017993927002, -0.0014110550982877612, 0.01863177865743637, 0.06467846781015396, 0.02639716863632202, 0.03783605992794037, 0.0059992289170622826, 0.0014682819601148367, -0.02955850213766098, -0.016882233321666718, -0.04234161227941513, 0.07164360582828522, 0.018163934350013733, -0.0039237807504832745, -0.008962210267782211, 0.00528993783518672, -0.04225669056177139, -0.01887190341949463, 0.013145232573151588, -0.008918626233935356, 0.009524945169687271, -0.007414153311401606, 0.03544163703918457, 0.011874157004058361, -0.02687644772231579, 0.00566711975261569, -0.0024040353018790483, -0.014278641901910305, 0.009342549368739128, -0.01458923239260912, 0.007080518174916506, 0.02628863975405693, -0.000726000580471009, -0.04230731725692749, -0.027270928025245667, -0.034607481211423874, -0.006414510775357485, 0.017031438648700714, 0.0019248869502916932, 0.002068039495497942, -0.015723327174782753, -0.07005556672811508, -0.013747850432991982, 0.017105430364608765, -0.03017578274011612, 0.02606588788330555, -0.03605856001377106, 0.061258915811777115, 0.0662015974521637, 0.026642460376024246, -0.047914281487464905, 0.052619997411966324, 0.011607861146330833, -0.03945428505539894, 0.025290176272392273, 0.04214473441243172, 0.013988429680466652, 0.024709731340408325, 0.03574957698583603, 0.025267118588089943, 0.05629079043865204, -0.07326640188694, -0.015534632839262486, 0.008453826420009136, -0.030918193981051445, -0.06395978480577469, 0.028507644310593605, -0.05593085289001465, -0.007713038939982653, 0.05015121400356293, -0.05094093829393387, -0.051730286329984665, 0.0370478518307209, -0.03388790041208267, 0.02195645309984684, -0.01451944187283516, -0.007264379411935806, 0.027301711961627007, 0.0411466546356678, -0.03244128078222275, 0.04940756410360336, -0.019423972815275192, 0.034787096083164215, -0.0019114150200039148, -0.039830438792705536, -0.00045760261127725244, -0.05693795904517174, 0.0022576495539397, 0.012014049105346203, -0.02628982625901699, 0.0036062649451196194, 0.01323533896356821, 0.045056648552417755, -0.037067968398332596, -0.005250154063105583, -0.04561098292469978, 0.00513861607760191, -0.02652089297771454, -0.002119382144883275, 0.007343627512454987, 0.023432709276676178, 0.013782413676381111, -0.044734563678503036, -0.08452257513999939, -0.007681796792894602, 0.011099863797426224, 0.013398743234574795, 0.07203134894371033, -0.002375942189246416, 0.018702756613492966, -0.04878271743655205, -0.023632649332284927, 0.002943598898127675, 0.04690520092844963, 0.03962200880050659, -0.09393653273582458, -0.020961696282029152, -0.032047051936388016, -0.021963495761156082, 0.021131077781319618, 0.015442606061697006, -0.05058831721544266, -0.0032099816016852856, -0.021376658231019974, 0.022828463464975357, 0.052913911640644073, 0.01483419630676508, 0.020683305338025093, 0.01719876006245613, -0.01286348607391119, -0.02262737601995468, 0.03534882143139839, -0.024825802072882652, 0.012240131385624409, 0.04601498320698738, -0.004809587728232145, 0.014129208400845528, 0.029228391125798225, -0.011425639502704144, 0.019704047590494156, -0.014169291593134403, 0.006466536317020655, -0.01714066043496132, 0.01061677373945713, -0.032335225492715836, 0.007057934533804655, -0.005342688877135515, 0.04668230563402176, -0.009338993579149246, 0.002497839042916894, 0.04819158837199211, 0.036768026649951935, -0.0019913555588573217, -0.07283046096563339, -0.014100546948611736, -0.053937822580337524, 0.044933464378118515, -0.020795883610844612, 0.020741155371069908, 0.003964051604270935, -0.07267812639474869, -0.007749847136437893, -0.021665671840310097, -0.05350416153669357, -0.023016860708594322, 0.044422633945941925, 0.013812955468893051, -0.009743336588144302, -0.030022410675883293, -0.010124820284545422, -0.04528510943055153, 0.019842932000756264, -0.01977907121181488, -0.004848453216254711, -0.020654790103435516, -0.006204759702086449, -0.05091720446944237, 0.007206229493021965, -0.0034095286391675472, 0.030239051207900047, -0.020863719284534454, -0.0005018126685172319, 0.020054809749126434, 0.08338548988103867, 0.06500250101089478, 0.04481475055217743, -0.018251320347189903, 0.02461128868162632, -0.006927638314664364, 0.04914524778723717, -0.01904566027224064, -0.004151489585638046, -0.04295077547430992, -0.016373148187994957, 0.005553878378123045, -0.038346223533153534, 0.012787946499884129, 0.018179910257458687, 0.005518960766494274, -0.09461898356676102, -0.03593173623085022, 0.10699218511581421, 0.016884513199329376, -0.062342748045921326, -0.007535445038229227, -0.019672051072120667, -0.01940922997891903, 0.0319264754652977, 0.044891465455293655, -0.02662767469882965, -0.027358105406165123, -0.014182970859110355, 0.017956336960196495, 0.03865831717848778, -0.05142128840088844, -0.006855232175439596, -0.09557510167360306, 0.022046959027647972, -0.04996537044644356, -0.08747650682926178, -0.09123361855745316, -0.029138080775737762, -0.013374247588217258, -0.002157126786187291, -0.020373115316033363, 0.029034307226538658, 0.02140059508383274, -0.021784884855151176, 0.027658412232995033, -0.06445804238319397, -0.010534918867051601, 0.0364987887442112, -0.04235425591468811, 0.01710328459739685, 0.05332913622260094, 0.060979604721069336, -0.028288980945944786, -0.057668935507535934, 0.00015311424795072526, -0.022158551961183548, -0.012586916796863079, -0.016987254843115807, 0.04577869921922684, -0.007832137867808342, -0.009518720209598541, -0.023037541657686234, 0.01579984463751316, -0.07610911875963211, 0.015063508413732052, 0.04017556086182594, 0.0841979831457138, -0.01814289577305317, -0.023355886340141296, -0.10240204632282257, 0.014153876341879368, 0.04865705221891403, 0.04549233242869377, 0.04863257706165314, -0.026693422347307205, -0.042605165392160416, -0.02469654008746147, -0.0032120118848979473, -0.06844214349985123, -0.04228099063038826, 0.010306348092854023, 0.020284824073314667, -0.06348291784524918, -0.12694717943668365, -0.0754600539803505, 0.006267616059631109, 0.03467763215303421, 0.018369160592556, -0.024665458127856255, 0.040904343128204346, -0.011078303679823875, -0.04989603906869888, 0.0110408840700984, 0.010804050602018833, -0.007124804425984621, -0.0456952303647995, 0.03562093898653984, 0.015111740678548813, 0.003849310800433159, 0.0009509274386800826, -0.013798211701214314, -0.06427546590566635, -0.02870100364089012, -0.008668539114296436, 0.0351814366877079, 0.009627711027860641, 0.013167692348361015, -0.06354421377182007, -0.027193233370780945, -0.006032936740666628, -0.003916495945304632, -0.026890574023127556, -0.036742184311151505, 0.02369455061852932, 0.019174950197339058, -0.009577538818120956, 0.024769220501184464, -0.05343662574887276, 0.055689070373773575, -0.0032942169345915318, 0.0009775274666026235, -0.01566452905535698, -0.03838137164711952, 0.004913627170026302, -0.020754313096404076, 0.04808760806918144, 0.04659976810216904, 0.007856530137360096, -0.03585430607199669, 0.017104851081967354, 0.00792638584971428, -0.01360443513840437, -0.04735930263996124, -0.0005278235767036676, 0.014535496942698956, 0.009581592865288258, 0.002827298128977418, -0.03426098823547363, -0.002445746213197708, -0.022509921342134476, -0.00975150614976883, 0.04515141248703003, -0.0044168634340167046, 0.03703809157013893, -0.02500748075544834, 0.00850843358784914, -0.027423039078712463, -0.014712448231875896, 0.006590479053556919, 0.07890166342258453, -0.0231675673276186, 0.02312365546822548, 0.019025355577468872, 0.01401535328477621, -0.022837329655885696, -0.004996203817427158, -0.026243532076478004, -0.012958820909261703, -0.03608788549900055, 0.007581586018204689, 0.044948942959308624, -0.057601023465394974, 0.004988791421055794, 0.038361527025699615, 0.017864232882857323, -0.024201955646276474, 0.05957565829157829, -0.008740408346056938, -0.015967464074492455, 0.03205285221338272, -0.01246622670441866, -0.033352069556713104, -0.023739183321595192, 0.07127514481544495, 0.011704927310347557, -0.010137076489627361, 0.026848336681723595, -0.019014816731214523, -0.016211505979299545, 0.021880699321627617, 0.01645413599908352, 0.0050552659668028355, -0.01818215101957321, 0.043048687279224396, -0.005028828512877226, -0.05465610325336456, 0.048866622149944305, -0.03099043481051922, 0.013217683881521225, 0.020082829520106316, 0.036022085696458817, 0.027696646749973297, 0.0274799857288599, -0.002750735031440854, -0.04470398277044296, 0.039003126323223114, -0.0075796968303620815, -0.06018851324915886, -0.07068473100662231, -6.689069788117608e-33, -0.003435855731368065, -0.055211007595062256, -0.01457731332629919, -0.028665924444794655, -0.03300449997186661, -0.0004520611255429685, -0.06964115798473358, -0.03745928779244423, -0.03873494639992714, 0.003787304274737835, -0.025667425245046616, 0.020627442747354507, 0.007164657581597567, 0.053172871470451355, 0.0771750658750534, -0.026028387248516083, 0.011011588387191296, 0.039584189653396606, 0.04901621490716934, 0.022529784590005875, 0.04028045013546944, 0.06673936545848846, 0.07351748645305634, -0.05906486138701439, 0.015282999724149704, -0.018340066075325012, 0.021168194711208344, 0.020008163526654243, 0.03139842674136162, 0.05377599224448204, -0.005418569780886173, 0.03573160246014595, 0.043050866574048996, -0.05851643159985542, -0.012046012096107006, 0.04542403295636177, -0.08777893334627151, -0.08601279556751251, -0.05880720913410187, -0.00012904561299365014, -0.030642786994576454, -0.017525002360343933, 0.06433531641960144, 0.004660492297261953, 0.034616854041814804, -0.02258859947323799, 0.07554104924201965, -0.0088526401668787, -0.03875342011451721, -0.02194143272936344, -0.06876620650291443, -0.0010576394852250814, -0.012729540467262268, 0.005993562750518322, 0.009644493460655212, 0.052439507097005844, -0.00383730954490602, 0.047149933874607086, -0.10539329797029495, -0.007195587735623121, -0.023385051637887955, 0.06440945714712143, 0.05420602858066559, 0.03383845090866089, -0.03203185275197029, 0.005566060543060303, -0.04387041553854942, 0.0024373382329940796, -0.04745003208518028, 0.03060394711792469, 0.0008572596125304699, 0.0385051965713501, 0.06837309896945953, -0.005395258776843548, 0.042982179671525955, -0.014987555332481861, -0.10376720130443573, 0.023903051391243935, -0.01486401166766882, 0.09833664447069168, -0.009441182017326355, -0.002392126712948084, -0.023967726156115532, 0.005595584399998188, 0.03415198624134064, 0.026647187769412994, -0.04002415016293526, -0.02822709083557129, 0.030676772817969322, -0.009365594014525414, 0.0016592590836808085, 0.0337289534509182, 0.010226506739854813, -0.04242614656686783, -0.0047536869533360004, 0.010720115154981613, 0.02280282787978649, -0.010899546556174755, 0.014199892058968544, 0.010364491492509842, -0.051435597240924835, 0.024319376796483994, -0.0019567557610571384, 0.021687177941203117, 0.00236222380772233, 0.005020917393267155, 0.059984926134347916, 0.0020670690573751926, -0.04585137590765953, -0.041822124272584915, 0.004262799397110939, -0.0059626754373312, -0.01658865064382553, 0.08899010717868805, -0.008698389865458012, 0.0035541991237550974, -0.006871217396110296, 0.07385297119617462, 0.03298000618815422, -0.013023641891777515, -0.05330456793308258, -0.0325218141078949, 0.057806748896837234, 0.009061524644494057, -0.058251768350601196, -0.0002195624401792884, -0.05820214003324509, 0.018577951937913895, 0.02210468426346779, -0.02725847251713276, -0.027652038261294365, 0.022761445492506027, 2.8442141797313525e-07, 0.05065372586250305, 0.017177779227495193, 0.023391621187329292, 0.0038872715085744858, -0.014250689186155796, 0.004782672505825758, 0.0044437735341489315, 0.055469807237386703, 0.005592566914856434, 0.004033992066979408, 0.027241768315434456, 0.004576114472001791, 0.04573763161897659, 0.008285843767225742, -0.12747664749622345, -0.05017509311437607, -0.08101049065589905, -0.012799154035747051, -0.03740701079368591, 0.00879763811826706, 0.08522704988718033, 0.14131604135036469, 0.031812913715839386, -0.006903649773448706, 0.024383066222071648, -0.009338581934571266, -0.008468449115753174, 0.01849202997982502, 0.011262070387601852, 0.0017588462214916945, 0.01851278729736805, 0.012891882099211216, -0.02981816977262497, -0.043261900544166565, -0.02791762351989746, 0.002147741848602891, 0.024271594360470772, 0.03368673473596573, -0.03951874002814293, -0.04846368730068207, 0.007044424768537283, 0.014156157150864601, 0.03021194040775299, -0.06362878531217575, 0.06057954579591751, -0.031198235228657722, -0.020043572410941124, -0.019645931199193, 0.01684456691145897, 0.02297419309616089, 0.052279673516750336, -0.002162355463951826, -0.009603193961083889, -0.0052654072642326355, 0.04078017920255661, -0.04892745614051819, -0.021807491779327393, -0.08664222061634064, -0.009623318910598755, -0.008608740754425526, -0.015052402392029762, 0.03611913323402405, -0.03223775699734688, -0.010970155708491802, 0.047094110399484634, -0.018392065539956093, 0.011109952814877033, 2.5144581806932033e-34, 0.003213672898709774, 0.012031626887619495, -0.009619033895432949, 0.052035119384527206, 0.006550159305334091, -0.021846028044819832, -0.03737270459532738, 0.016885001212358475, 0.028061626479029655, -0.056668661534786224, -0.02369050122797489]
606
606
['Saurabh Kataria']
1603.07646v1
We consider the problem of learning distributed representations for tags from their associated content for the task of tag recommendation. Considering tagging information is usually very sparse, effective learning from content and tag association is very crucial and challenging task. Recently, various neural representation learning models such as WSABIE and its variants show promising performance, mainly due to compact feature representations learned in a semantic space. However, their capacity is limited by a linear compositional approach for representing tags as sum of equal parts and hurt their performance. In this work, we propose a neural feedback relevance model for learning tag representations with weighted feature representations. Our experiments on two widely used datasets show significant improvement for quality of recommendations over various baselines.
Recursive Neural Language Architecture for Tag Prediction
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1603.07646v1
Title Recursive Neural Language Architecture Tag Prediction Summary consider problem learning distributed representation tag associated content task tag recommendation Considering tagging information usually sparse effective learning content tag association crucial challenging task Recently various neural representation learning model WSABIE variant show promising performance mainly due compact feature representation learned semantic space However capacity limited linear compositional approach representing tag sum equal part hurt performance work propose neural feedback relevance model learning tag representation weighted feature representation experiment two widely used datasets show significant improvement quality recommendation various baseline Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.046709440648555756, -0.005000155884772539, -0.046266429126262665, 0.02858760952949524, 0.001003048848360777, 0.0013018466997891665, -0.013201013207435608, -0.004298039246350527, 0.05208227410912514, -0.023654785007238388, -0.025690404698252678, -0.0348496213555336, 0.024195024743676186, 0.07179399579763412, 0.014678412117064, -0.00562423188239336, 0.028939049690961838, -0.010827668942511082, 0.05229843035340309, -0.003132255980744958, 0.04234648495912552, 0.01432371698319912, 0.0189591646194458, 0.06554217636585236, -0.03476925566792488, -0.014525850303471088, 0.01438379380851984, -0.0340668223798275, -0.05298751965165138, -0.05609634891152382, 0.04664561524987221, 0.008161813020706177, 0.023381978273391724, 0.04932016134262085, 2.0072423012607032e-06, 0.006309128366410732, -0.04144792631268501, -0.04382455721497536, 0.05473414063453674, -0.004138731863349676, 0.05515944957733154, -0.01597612351179123, -0.0018262299709022045, 0.04094761237502098, -0.04122501611709595, -0.021544434130191803, 0.053397271782159805, 0.08081687241792679, 0.028626535087823868, 0.03788512945175171, -0.03436165302991867, -0.07925524562597275, 0.0167990792542696, -0.043475281447172165, 0.01714923046529293, -0.017025386914610863, 0.009748752228915691, 0.007382465060800314, 0.027547363191843033, 0.03563899174332619, -0.024327635765075684, 0.012844789773225784, 0.005976303480565548, -0.04716597869992256, 0.037714481353759766, 0.03718751668930054, -0.020391881465911865, -0.003533195238560438, 0.013321539387106895, 0.06640510261058807, 0.022938722744584084, -0.011251142248511314, -0.026298506185412407, 0.0033163956832140684, -0.009850365109741688, -0.02976986952126026, -0.03217661380767822, 0.0018384059658274055, 0.00522463396191597, 0.04702003672719002, 0.0226010549813509, -0.004961198195815086, 0.042229022830724716, -0.013412142172455788, 0.004992385394871235, 0.09572342038154602, 0.025887534022331238, -0.011355596594512463, -0.007469587959349155, 0.01801444962620735, -0.007777102291584015, -0.028167739510536194, 0.0368279330432415, 0.01801949180662632, 0.0005787691916339099, 0.036022622138261795, -0.019823040813207626, -0.06977908313274384, 0.020674219354987144, -0.07304510474205017, 0.030948376283049583, 0.006522306241095066, 0.011681274510920048, 0.009628752246499062, -0.05877865478396416, 0.026195621117949486, -0.02917458303272724, -0.01924443244934082, -0.035631079226732254, -0.022948240861296654, -0.06047651171684265, -0.03614509850740433, -0.009468069300055504, 0.06503555178642273, 0.00505923293530941, -0.0342983715236187, -0.02504255250096321, 0.012321274727582932, -0.03222285583615303, -0.009588079527020454, 0.009318436495959759, 0.04692014306783676, -0.010290727019309998, 0.013544286601245403, -0.045427318662405014, 0.019459687173366547, -0.03820151090621948, 0.044182419776916504, -0.007422235794365406, -0.0003583843936212361, 0.002925222273916006, 0.02777169831097126, -0.03809656575322151, -0.010172124020755291, -0.011249103583395481, 0.03221055492758751, 0.020872430875897408, -0.011351161636412144, -0.05706789717078209, 0.0065125455148518085, -0.014087527990341187, -0.0045633865520358086, 0.03262368589639664, -0.06059703975915909, 0.00795817095786333, -0.01924937032163143, -0.020318806171417236, -0.04970318078994751, -0.004554067738354206, 0.024781296029686928, -0.04516355320811272, 0.06909680366516113, -0.051851727068424225, -0.0024607619270682335, 0.042316921055316925, 0.026957087218761444, 0.03776634484529495, 0.05296803638339043, 0.02687923051416874, 0.04159325733780861, 0.022473711520433426, 0.004132925067096949, -0.033106908202171326, -0.011709184385836124, -0.012202263809740543, -0.0038896878249943256, -0.050806913524866104, -0.014973617158830166, 0.059325408190488815, 0.0016471354756504297, 0.042689066380262375, 0.05650946870446205, 0.0005816873745061457, -0.03448817878961563, 0.029280956834554672, 0.055654969066381454, 0.0320516973733902, 0.043084051460027695, 0.007377698551863432, -0.02796221524477005, 0.016567714512348175, 0.011951204389333725, -0.0016345143085345626, 0.05009972304105759, -0.03409424424171448, -0.03271455317735672, 0.013068442232906818, 0.006807568948715925, -0.05676335468888283, 0.004961732309311628, -0.0018136005382984877, -0.018255973234772682, 0.06224682182073593, -0.0773620530962944, 0.03209971636533737, -0.003925370052456856, -0.03486311435699463, -0.0024696458131074905, 0.050677403807640076, -0.0005660781171172857, -0.005395244341343641, -0.037895236164331436, 0.019789602607488632, 0.04585782811045647, 0.03756324201822281, -0.02526026964187622, -0.01600811257958412, 0.026378652080893517, -0.012074449099600315, -0.0005191252566874027, 0.031354013830423355, -0.04530404135584831, -0.026086265221238136, -0.051899634301662445, -0.019715486094355583, -0.010019554756581783, -0.0010649069445207715, 0.044082868844270706, -0.053309932351112366, 0.012540205381810665, 0.03968155011534691, 0.02144952118396759, -0.03812960162758827, 0.047535158693790436, -0.0159313827753067, -0.03034353442490101, 0.03675844520330429, -0.011880780570209026, 0.004702804610133171, -0.0066859908401966095, 0.0005016499198973179, 0.017734793946146965, 0.03026127815246582, -0.02308892272412777, -0.007823972962796688, -0.04009642452001572, -0.043817583471536636, 0.0038102895487099886, 0.053635917603969574, -0.03063337691128254, 0.022945506498217583, 0.047449301928281784, -0.031807027757167816, -0.036279164254665375, 0.07334306091070175, -0.06835218518972397, 0.03678503632545471, -0.05516306310892105, 0.008592881262302399, -0.04298659786581993, 0.02028266154229641, -0.007113267667591572, 0.040472835302352905, 0.021364927291870117, 0.03478622063994408, -0.022482099011540413, 0.021914981305599213, 0.04138318449258804, 0.02881442941725254, -0.08159070461988449, -0.008664372377097607, 0.005092059262096882, -0.0022976004984229803, 0.024339178577065468, 0.005226812791079283, -0.026376349851489067, 0.0018389135366305709, -0.08250828087329865, -0.0017119840485975146, 0.010698797181248665, 0.022004256024956703, -0.0018260795623064041, -0.00027527945348992944, 0.029787685722112656, -0.02588173933327198, -0.052176788449287415, 0.03664296492934227, -0.030344989150762558, 0.022238902747631073, 0.026861531659960747, 0.006165561731904745, 0.020044011995196342, -0.03622038662433624, -0.04977427423000336, -0.026216093450784683, 0.04718360677361488, 0.030740994960069656, -0.0547749325633049, -0.02320631965994835, -0.030357228592038155, -0.0498233437538147, 0.029737722128629684, 0.011631926521658897, -0.06061958149075508, 0.016333168372511864, -0.029398171231150627, 0.041129689663648605, -0.00544125447049737, 0.00038731942186132073, -0.016237786039710045, 0.04907095059752464, 0.029987607151269913, -0.03430425748229027, -0.02763301134109497, -0.021976158022880554, 0.026368992403149605, 0.004113478120416403, -0.0035983934067189693, 0.00179549609310925, 0.09372454881668091, -0.0038491985760629177, -0.014207200147211552, -0.020610136911273003, -0.011152375489473343, -0.0069388640113174915, 0.0283169224858284, -0.03675171360373497, -0.022280577570199966, 0.0038930687587708235, 0.020657971501350403, -0.024023661389946938, -0.042074576020240784, 0.07166651636362076, -0.012103651650249958, -0.0012760957470163703, -0.08291835337877274, -0.043797679245471954, -0.0496334433555603, 0.05663113668560982, 0.015873011201620102, 0.015544064342975616, 0.039658643305301666, -0.044938672333955765, -0.03795429319143295, 0.01079289149492979, -0.020964447408914566, -0.020362254232168198, 0.004094562493264675, 0.014846224337816238, 0.029126206412911415, 0.017937712371349335, 0.03258363530039787, -0.03560536354780197, -0.018627271056175232, -0.017780033871531487, 0.037053968757390976, 0.03295798599720001, 0.013529375195503235, 0.0011736421147361398, -0.01101259421557188, 0.00582096679136157, 0.03125905990600586, -0.03642165660858154, -0.00858225580304861, 0.034172821789979935, 0.045781880617141724, 0.04582980275154114, -0.05275791510939598, 0.01288170088082552, 0.017900265753269196, -0.016955893486738205, 0.052467066794633865, -0.0031371358782052994, 0.002274999860674143, -0.0917116105556488, 0.019442927092313766, 0.042538657784461975, -0.04810517281293869, -0.027628885582089424, 0.00904642604291439, -0.019261395558714867, -0.05112222209572792, -0.00019658234668895602, 0.09336551278829575, 0.05084482952952385, -0.11892705410718918, 0.012436052784323692, -0.019300196319818497, 0.014736524783074856, 0.0336289256811142, 0.043799497187137604, 0.002754797227680683, -0.004250919446349144, -0.00236864504404366, -0.011429375037550926, 0.010816521942615509, -0.03551333397626877, 0.005145606584846973, -0.10513237118721008, -0.018019268289208412, -0.026798104867339134, 0.030782639980316162, -0.013035018928349018, -0.06772216409444809, -0.010678652673959732, 0.032807011157274246, -0.021116837859153748, 0.012186318635940552, 0.010414929129183292, -0.010047492571175098, 0.022214749827980995, -0.05471684783697128, 0.005546439904719591, 0.02508869208395481, -0.02315695956349373, 0.09277204424142838, 0.08755628019571304, 0.05015263333916664, -0.03333161398768425, -0.02626723051071167, 0.030622050166130066, -0.013180810026824474, -0.006523823831230402, -0.03535318374633789, 0.03904848173260689, 0.015777330845594406, -0.0013255431549623609, -9.664997924119234e-05, -0.04248248040676117, -0.050540145486593246, 0.013587066903710365, -0.009677490219473839, 0.12070439755916595, -0.016419367864727974, 0.002166933612897992, -0.060802560299634933, 0.007704266346991062, 0.014711139723658562, 0.030560500919818878, 0.044764891266822815, -0.026616988703608513, -0.013956261798739433, 0.008795459754765034, 0.022417880594730377, -0.01863533817231655, 0.01918499916791916, 0.0451948456466198, -0.02769104763865471, -0.02324238419532776, -0.10445430874824524, -0.03511665761470795, 0.014018511399626732, 0.0010562136303633451, 0.026450330391526222, 0.03747100755572319, -0.026151765137910843, -0.06606409698724747, -0.05529051274061203, -0.00824761763215065, 0.03643844276666641, 0.015452521853148937, -0.0025524208322167397, -0.0037904412019997835, 0.056282900273799896, 0.008386881090700626, -0.033507779240608215, -0.047524549067020416, -0.047574516385793686, -0.03038983978331089, -0.028706789016723633, 0.03835630789399147, 0.008857423439621925, -0.013818847946822643, -0.05518963932991028, -0.09964210540056229, -0.0020763755310326815, -0.03309321403503418, -0.057244591414928436, -0.0189090296626091, -0.008670482784509659, -0.012148711830377579, 0.01436035055667162, 0.03806474804878235, -0.057337719947099686, 0.055629972368478775, -0.019015144556760788, 0.02066820301115513, 0.03717425838112831, -0.02723224274814129, -0.015601744875311852, 0.005687660071998835, 0.013400601223111153, 0.008534034714102745, 0.03126724436879158, -0.032906804233789444, -0.005649864207953215, -0.041088514029979706, 0.007893883623182774, -0.029025236144661903, 0.03186934441328049, 0.04221690818667412, -0.00035383892827667296, -0.011037481017410755, -0.03389657661318779, -0.021757254377007484, 0.07710517197847366, 0.03003828600049019, 0.039113543927669525, -0.0005830597365275025, -0.011644670739769936, -0.04475566744804382, 0.06943023204803467, 0.01373054925352335, -0.054879095405340195, 0.025564610958099365, 0.013303253799676895, -0.03334891051054001, 0.04177514836192131, 0.007131193298846483, 0.03244778513908386, -0.017400426790118217, 0.034671600908041, -0.023685067892074585, -0.005627408158034086, -0.010731417685747147, -0.003869382431730628, 0.002864072099328041, -0.03895857557654381, -0.004582985769957304, 0.00853484496474266, 0.02104547992348671, -0.03222417086362839, 0.04099234566092491, -0.05643684044480324, -0.027073627337813377, 0.02447754703462124, -0.0004026537644676864, -0.03660086169838905, -0.004465767648071051, 0.09538595378398895, 0.009465692564845085, -0.02521156705915928, 0.010768461972475052, -0.029413731768727303, 0.01721973903477192, 0.0016997335478663445, 0.009123062714934349, 0.04895536229014397, -0.058614976704120636, 0.011847897432744503, -0.010897057130932808, -0.06467290967702866, 0.007844537496566772, -0.025528892874717712, 0.017170343548059464, 0.016616148874163628, 0.05281239002943039, 0.018540961667895317, 0.039862729609012604, 0.0379888080060482, -0.028908470645546913, -0.03013431653380394, -0.02698923833668232, -0.02873203717172146, -0.04883540794253349, -5.720250854056895e-33, -0.016554592177271843, -0.023289423435926437, 0.0068501499481499195, -0.024893853813409805, -0.030340204015374184, 0.00534833176061511, -0.037824541330337524, -0.025929704308509827, -0.030729487538337708, 0.001141666783951223, -0.004734136629849672, 0.02720322273671627, -0.01301974430680275, 0.03633095324039459, 0.05085713788866997, 0.03299030661582947, 0.00424701813608408, -0.002565171103924513, 0.05966123938560486, 0.031387824565172195, 0.01903643272817135, 0.05655263736844063, 0.053236521780490875, -0.033855944871902466, 0.0003680121444631368, 0.007964426651597023, 0.0038919600192457438, -0.007413169834762812, 0.07441074401140213, 0.054798513650894165, -0.03621426224708557, 0.04127570614218712, 0.03020589053630829, -0.03271530196070671, -0.01802453212440014, 0.021088000386953354, -0.07460284978151321, -0.07831088453531265, -0.027334270998835564, -0.0038434811867773533, 0.0015886480687186122, 0.030329031869769096, 0.03203410655260086, -0.01318321656435728, 0.00029735028510913253, 0.01607632264494896, 0.07089347392320633, -0.016471805050969124, -0.06143198534846306, -0.022768406197428703, -0.046248335391283035, 0.01462334580719471, 0.021109776571393013, 0.03925565630197525, 0.025029409676790237, 0.014194854535162449, 0.013691980391740799, 0.05587034672498703, -0.08511342108249664, 0.006373212672770023, -0.05604952201247215, 0.05940503627061844, 0.005468915216624737, 0.006279194727540016, 0.025386303663253784, 0.08367577940225601, 0.014787556603550911, 0.03977756202220917, -0.018260953947901726, 0.02661600522696972, 0.03491993993520737, -0.016485463827848434, 0.0482463538646698, -0.02806546539068222, 0.03636673837900162, -0.046750862151384354, -0.06646377593278885, 0.053836774080991745, 0.024356499314308167, 0.05118078738451004, 0.00041463872184976935, 0.008357650600373745, -0.022996751591563225, -0.022305654361844063, 0.01013363990932703, -0.01817210577428341, -0.048306383192539215, -0.11113259941339493, -0.03104836493730545, -0.02765362337231636, 0.027393365278840065, 0.023675989359617233, -0.0017651345115154982, -0.07845159620046616, 0.029098976403474808, 0.0014273695414885879, -0.03595602884888649, 0.008495750837028027, 0.039592187851667404, 0.06685059517621994, -0.06155062094330788, -0.02710607834160328, -0.011679038405418396, -0.0005227536312304437, 0.0018037082627415657, 0.012143398635089397, 0.032689061015844345, 0.002743577118963003, -0.04026573523879051, -0.022943731397390366, -0.021459069103002548, -0.07303053885698318, 0.02712729200720787, 0.06022528186440468, -0.02001948282122612, 0.022815139964222908, -0.006091824732720852, 0.06023659557104111, 0.07283094525337219, 0.049236614257097244, 0.010277054272592068, -0.06664184480905533, 0.02172749862074852, 0.020740121603012085, -0.06187335029244423, -0.02622167579829693, -0.06046995148062706, 0.05494391545653343, 0.04885885864496231, -0.05162762477993965, -0.03601343184709549, 0.005289653781801462, 2.702441008750611e-07, 0.03153454139828682, 0.009875296615064144, -0.01865125633776188, -0.042603470385074615, 0.03099019266664982, 0.039347872138023376, -0.002810480073094368, 0.06507311761379242, -0.01328650675714016, -0.017620932310819626, -0.026111388579010963, -0.017037460580468178, 0.008549529127776623, 0.02795237861573696, -0.09623351693153381, 0.04160776361823082, -0.059427857398986816, 0.01757659763097763, -0.005946002434939146, -0.019421769306063652, 0.039298541843891144, 0.10512921959161758, 0.04578094184398651, -0.05472518876194954, -0.018729276955127716, -0.015340507961809635, 0.04548639804124832, 0.025279780849814415, -0.024288330227136612, 0.02135755494236946, 0.015857774764299393, 0.07049589604139328, -0.017816580832004547, -0.01528314221650362, -0.038626376539468765, 0.022183643653988838, -0.020573459565639496, -0.009610634297132492, -0.05536453053355217, -0.05123142898082733, 0.03703371807932854, -0.02664756402373314, 0.003399802837520838, -0.02573271468281746, 0.06182577461004257, -0.0037776220124214888, -0.050739552825689316, -0.002759617753326893, -0.0026870539877563715, 0.018523702397942543, 0.016944756731390953, -0.028370724990963936, 0.015423853881657124, 0.00591164268553257, -0.018982570618391037, -0.04551459848880768, -0.018133051693439484, -0.08139979094266891, 0.014272750355303288, 0.006959795486181974, -0.008938731625676155, 0.004155647475272417, -0.02830721251666546, 0.005725950468331575, 0.05678572505712509, -0.049306899309158325, 0.057461563497781754, 2.1522727591705097e-34, 0.012172529473900795, -0.01922052726149559, -0.016582371667027473, 0.0657132938504219, -0.023256629705429077, -0.01542849000543356, -0.04422714561223984, 0.028132721781730652, 0.040900588035583496, -0.0680902898311615, -0.041754208505153656]
607
607
['Rohit Prabhavalkar', 'Ouais Alsharif', 'Antoine Bruguier', 'Ian McGraw']
1603.08042v2
We study the problem of compressing recurrent neural networks (RNNs). In particular, we focus on the compression of RNN acoustic models, which are motivated by the goal of building compact and accurate speech recognition systems which can be run efficiently on mobile devices. In this work, we present a technique for general recurrent model compression that jointly compresses both recurrent and non-recurrent inter-layer weight matrices. We find that the proposed technique allows us to reduce the size of our Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) acoustic model to a third of its original size with negligible loss in accuracy.
On the Compression of Recurrent Neural Networks with an Application to LVCSR acoustic modeling for Embedded Speech Recognition
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1603.08042v2
Title Compression Recurrent Neural Networks Application LVCSR acoustic modeling Embedded Speech Recognition Summary study problem compressing recurrent neural network RNNs particular focus compression RNN acoustic model motivated goal building compact accurate speech recognition system run efficiently mobile device work present technique general recurrent model compression jointly compress recurrent nonrecurrent interlayer weight matrix find proposed technique allows u reduce size Long ShortTerm Memory LSTM acoustic model third original size negligible loss accuracy Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.01828327216207981, -0.004037776961922646, 0.015006584115326405, 0.054580144584178925, -0.012824430130422115, -0.023773901164531708, 0.027628332376480103, 0.022657198831439018, -0.06416162848472595, 0.023214837536215782, -0.03965678811073303, -0.013697794638574123, 0.04727723076939583, -0.015872197225689888, 0.007471926510334015, -0.001838129130192101, 0.005701861809939146, 0.00877582747489214, 0.00800557341426611, 0.008378888480365276, 0.028014590963721275, -0.010744377039372921, 0.011782201007008553, 0.05349387228488922, 0.004868357442319393, -0.0012191010173410177, -0.008090320974588394, 0.020205121487379074, -0.03764826059341431, -0.04638095945119858, -0.003041474847123027, 0.003497287631034851, 0.049422815442085266, 0.03341308608651161, 2.1559117158176377e-06, 0.03493695706129074, 0.021522799506783485, -0.006784701719880104, -0.020840127021074295, 0.018297478556632996, 0.04149886220693588, 0.03616129606962204, -0.012549487873911858, 0.0533788688480854, -0.012174582108855247, -0.05714081972837448, 0.027762001380324364, 0.06356613337993622, 0.017116254195570946, 0.021224604919552803, 0.011033426970243454, -0.03202139586210251, 0.001617011846974492, -0.01961689442396164, 0.00421923166140914, -0.0236044954508543, -0.026025589555501938, -0.04367014020681381, -0.015460196882486343, -0.002812773222103715, 0.011924625374376774, 0.021679578348994255, 0.03153100609779358, 0.022139396518468857, -0.017186155542731285, -0.020448848605155945, -0.009368580766022205, -0.0009512317483313382, 0.00453996891155839, 0.04187634587287903, -0.021684983745217323, -0.035759180784225464, 0.007556222844868898, 0.03257487714290619, -0.028254957869648933, -0.09230124205350876, -0.053723130375146866, 0.021656548604369164, -0.008075607009232044, 0.001560254255309701, -0.061028990894556046, 0.03965040296316147, 0.05770739167928696, -0.03668150678277016, -0.01189513225108385, -0.02521289326250553, -0.01452602632343769, -0.007049907930195332, -0.03486112505197525, -0.06297478824853897, 0.030072402209043503, -0.047899436205625534, 0.04845333844423294, 0.0301646888256073, 0.020098069682717323, -0.02129504270851612, -0.012602080591022968, -0.08567860722541809, -0.008848367258906364, -0.06788140535354614, 0.03399210423231125, 0.02363288216292858, 0.00340576795861125, -0.018502533435821533, -0.014941424131393433, 0.043932486325502396, -0.013314375653862953, -0.05228901281952858, -0.013383524492383003, -0.014010636135935783, -0.01340402103960514, -0.012249709106981754, -0.03421543911099434, 0.06533077359199524, -0.024489445611834526, -0.01697472669184208, -0.05698881298303604, -0.03549879789352417, -0.0029699967708438635, -0.018117431551218033, 0.00794670544564724, 0.04144297167658806, -0.01066061295568943, -0.021451491862535477, 0.020909247919917107, 0.03909963369369507, 0.004868413787335157, 0.042726051062345505, -0.011035086587071419, -0.05589469522237778, -0.003653185209259391, 0.03165481239557266, 0.025052282959222794, 0.022755777463316917, -0.02343071810901165, 0.04402686282992363, 0.04630111902952194, -0.0023228067439049482, -0.03967219963669777, 0.007228437811136246, 0.010368358343839645, -0.025720400735735893, -0.012489071115851402, -0.08139816671609879, 0.040672048926353455, -0.057346735149621964, -0.024946678429841995, 0.0036389504093676805, 0.026514558121562004, 0.034140992909669876, -0.025459634140133858, 0.05350053682923317, 0.009611112996935844, -0.009600812569260597, 0.06758762151002884, 0.012916399165987968, 0.07507046312093735, 0.006053235847502947, 0.08946654945611954, 0.004725268110632896, -0.006395328789949417, -0.07211146503686905, -0.015157324261963367, 0.01288924552500248, 0.044654395431280136, -0.052999600768089294, -0.051089562475681305, -0.02485881932079792, -0.025154532864689827, 0.07029205560684204, 0.0027345537673681974, 0.05175592005252838, -0.012287801131606102, -0.025022627785801888, 0.027988580986857414, 0.07833858579397202, 0.06228886544704437, 0.06252972781658173, -0.004625075962394476, -0.000204509575269185, -0.00012647190305870026, -0.01931413821876049, -0.007431879639625549, 0.06500519067049026, -0.025659708306193352, 0.005028798244893551, 0.017497681081295013, 0.0144535256549716, -0.02993684820830822, -0.054149892181158066, -0.014308968558907509, -0.05519644170999527, 0.02390539087355137, 0.02007787674665451, -0.0030364454723894596, -0.0068770479410886765, -0.035596299916505814, 0.032858651131391525, -0.008204719983041286, -0.04793832078576088, -0.03442387655377388, -0.036810074001550674, 0.010862568393349648, -0.003004197496920824, 0.008965019136667252, -0.0030535084661096334, -0.03669296205043793, -0.025745155289769173, -0.036303408443927765, -0.016203854233026505, -0.031406469643116, 0.008787082508206367, 0.04338282346725464, -0.08895272761583328, -0.011612853035330772, 0.050968144088983536, -0.021587364375591278, 0.04658597707748413, -0.03951443359255791, 0.042897772043943405, 0.042212992906570435, 0.005361135583370924, -0.021118849515914917, -0.013601579703390598, -0.008492420427501202, -0.03460168093442917, 0.0672844648361206, 0.02706179767847061, 0.05449632927775383, 0.01903911866247654, 0.03903311491012573, -0.006088783498853445, 0.07991839200258255, -0.0651112049818039, 0.00770923588424921, -0.012704162858426571, -0.07101920247077942, -0.04040800780057907, 0.020360067486763, 0.0025235749781131744, 0.08151161670684814, 0.07028419524431229, 0.006932950112968683, -0.0869731456041336, 0.0690738633275032, -0.01649462804198265, 0.057970210909843445, -0.03245843946933746, 0.011750156059861183, 0.019349217414855957, 0.03146570920944214, 0.02082447148859501, -0.022626103833317757, -0.005509847775101662, 0.027668610215187073, 0.04789917171001434, 0.016732975840568542, 0.01025417447090149, -0.041287459433078766, -0.03659408539533615, 0.040304034948349, -0.05228604003787041, -0.008425690233707428, 0.009665912948548794, -0.007021158467978239, 0.027765322476625443, -0.03144832327961922, -0.06266243755817413, 0.019605789333581924, 0.0008450777386315167, -0.008320833556354046, -0.004105475731194019, 0.057410940527915955, 0.040530502796173096, -0.027896828949451447, -0.01849437691271305, -0.002068969653919339, -0.007850303314626217, -0.009727627038955688, -0.0057813129387795925, -0.0032194654922932386, -0.01091543398797512, -0.014989292249083519, -0.031011251732707024, 0.02607698366045952, 0.022642042487859726, -0.04808244854211807, -0.02323657087981701, -0.00901819858700037, -0.023156646639108658, -0.01592017523944378, 0.027672432363033295, 0.03172913193702698, -0.07609644532203674, -0.011929203756153584, 0.014251128770411015, 0.029471037909388542, 0.041002847254276276, 0.018312223255634308, 0.005743986461311579, 0.029869018122553825, 0.01696956530213356, -0.02851269394159317, 0.01807904615998268, -0.0007223151624202728, 0.017024781554937363, -0.007258427329361439, -0.022859830409288406, -0.04883687198162079, 0.08132351189851761, 0.029701951891183853, 0.03288429230451584, -0.02339041791856289, -0.061492644250392914, -0.013972258195281029, -0.02057238668203354, -0.017915191128849983, -0.014281408861279488, 0.00036280538188293576, 0.002995394868776202, 0.008888278156518936, -0.01195794902741909, -0.017427176237106323, -0.05110497027635574, 0.0020950930193066597, -0.027759559452533722, -0.06838119775056839, -0.034354522824287415, 0.044488903135061264, -0.00568597624078393, 0.009331593289971352, -0.004390510730445385, -0.014448684640228748, 0.020453570410609245, -0.004350291099399328, -0.02133120782673359, -0.05169573426246643, -0.014697965234518051, 0.013211880810558796, -0.030095364898443222, -0.0366017185151577, -0.023425620049238205, 0.00865135807543993, 0.004098177887499332, -0.01864326186478138, -0.010977276600897312, 0.0024352031759917736, -0.0137019706889987, -0.0005623316974379122, 0.05785186216235161, 0.031063571572303772, 0.027782322838902473, 0.016946053132414818, 0.0422137975692749, 0.005012068897485733, 0.0461922287940979, 0.002230485435575247, 0.049502525478601456, 0.00023210421204566956, 0.07663825899362564, 0.056514427065849304, -0.0037930579856038094, 0.0386931374669075, 0.03750241920351982, -0.1101280227303505, -0.014171507209539413, 0.01368777733296156, 0.031280212104320526, -0.046979524195194244, 0.0645890086889267, 0.029796404764056206, -0.10081834346055984, 0.02542131394147873, 0.05654911696910858, -0.004735291935503483, -0.043953072279691696, -0.015322687104344368, 0.00696598133072257, 0.03865618258714676, 0.013044225983321667, 2.4763574401731603e-05, 0.012325906194746494, -0.01917549967765808, 0.025026315823197365, 0.001019479357637465, 0.013699157163500786, 0.0007570890011265874, -0.051773931831121445, -0.06875946372747421, 0.02849534898996353, 0.02849099040031433, -0.014195960015058517, -0.036952562630176544, -0.031320348381996155, -0.05784209072589874, 0.0032231914810836315, 0.02436225675046444, 0.018234236165881157, 0.021281125023961067, -0.023603180423378944, 0.05978086590766907, -0.13500599563121796, -0.0032084223348647356, 0.00937889888882637, -0.009864691644906998, 0.03725534304976463, 0.05794398859143257, 0.03111382946372032, -0.012713272124528885, -0.041265957057476044, 0.0023190479259938, -0.01484263502061367, 0.02397395856678486, -0.03279583528637886, -0.04324272647500038, 0.052654240280389786, -0.016180837526917458, 0.016375591978430748, 0.06378089636564255, -0.04535503312945366, 0.03802056983113289, -0.0011136401444673538, 0.07205204665660858, 0.030479300767183304, -0.0026859936770051718, -0.06186980381608009, 0.011969181708991528, -0.009134573861956596, 0.05631867051124573, 0.04501326382160187, 2.239912464574445e-05, -0.02497844025492668, 0.01965666376054287, 0.005327078979462385, -0.03638505935668945, 0.008934210985898972, 0.025120031088590622, 0.03938603028655052, -0.03808382526040077, -0.04512770101428032, -0.032879218459129333, -0.024679630994796753, 0.023640330880880356, 0.012403483502566814, 0.034841977059841156, 0.030016202479600906, 0.05319255590438843, -0.07672274857759476, -0.03154217451810837, 0.010602232068777084, 0.02674962393939495, -0.05571551248431206, 0.062044963240623474, 0.03309299424290657, -0.037969887256622314, 0.018589366227388382, -0.01946868747472763, -0.08690736442804337, -0.013106227852404118, -0.0042137689888477325, 0.00021156696311663836, 0.013660021126270294, 0.04935264214873314, -0.023425981402397156, -0.008177545852959156, 0.0191340334713459, -0.0192590169608593, -0.04455196112394333, 0.04050422087311745, 0.044802866876125336, -0.012318974360823631, 0.020248347893357277, 0.03008062206208706, -0.03690417855978012, 0.04692572355270386, -0.024863626807928085, 0.001466732588596642, -0.014290153048932552, -0.06046926975250244, 0.002462317468598485, 0.005616659764200449, 0.033657997846603394, 0.03008688986301422, 0.007067251019179821, 0.0008745145751163363, 0.06213073804974556, 0.007188390474766493, 0.051645003259181976, -0.04697073623538017, 0.034507669508457184, 0.0032437657937407494, 0.004498054273426533, 0.010238321498036385, -0.03518553823232651, 0.06926507502794266, -0.051679376512765884, 0.05226150155067444, 0.05486058071255684, -0.019362246617674828, 0.008516529574990273, -0.011052158661186695, 0.023372158408164978, -0.044494494795799255, 0.003707470837980509, 0.0059491368010640144, 0.011492199264466763, -0.030939538031816483, -0.012563930824398994, -0.012190140783786774, 0.01589791290462017, -0.014413834549486637, 0.028144320473074913, 0.013773799873888493, 0.0022671823389828205, -0.011146260425448418, 0.008261332288384438, 0.021242015063762665, -0.0024008704349398613, -0.05081067606806755, 0.02082349918782711, 0.04790911078453064, -0.03756532445549965, 0.05085250735282898, -0.034769609570503235, 0.035098716616630554, 0.04548167064785957, 0.01526294182986021, -0.04769061133265495, 0.013942597433924675, 0.03672649711370468, 0.05715372785925865, 0.025317611172795296, 0.01926564984023571, 0.013127525337040424, -0.0027845518197864294, -0.006412452552467585, 0.0151680214330554, 0.0390874482691288, -0.013180971145629883, -0.026814397424459457, 0.0010031841229647398, -0.045127350836992264, 0.07074954360723495, -0.013485590927302837, 0.06463371962308884, -0.062156714498996735, 0.028626075014472008, -0.019497690722346306, 0.018677765503525734, 0.055717747658491135, 0.0466705746948719, -0.030240589752793312, -0.022330638021230698, -0.03130186349153519, -0.026257578283548355, -5.8183252864818756e-33, -0.01584269292652607, 0.024825897067785263, 0.00889755878597498, -0.03266584500670433, -0.04751453921198845, 0.01768912561237812, -0.022328665480017662, -0.01878129132091999, -0.020591700449585915, -0.031427398324012756, -0.03201959282159805, 0.009446589276194572, 0.01779296062886715, 0.03489750251173973, 0.012054616585373878, 0.008363903500139713, 0.06657600402832031, -0.018421601504087448, 0.04607582464814186, 0.02558116801083088, 0.04271480441093445, 0.03445420786738396, 0.020261891186237335, -0.019676756113767624, -0.08267919719219208, -0.0030612435657531023, 0.027226464822888374, -0.0290492195636034, 0.02725478820502758, 0.0227447971701622, -0.029346179217100143, -0.006292089354246855, -0.016394054517149925, -0.03993590548634529, -0.0070479633286595345, 0.04890316352248192, -0.08581431955099106, -0.03788164630532265, -0.02064947970211506, 0.02382710762321949, -0.019733095541596413, -0.025233259424567223, 0.08454155921936035, 0.026398533955216408, -0.04170430824160576, 0.006624454166740179, 0.004004353657364845, -0.025914132595062256, -0.09567611664533615, -0.07415087521076202, 0.001037158421240747, 0.01882617361843586, -0.00939116533845663, -0.018736205995082855, 0.024806294590234756, -0.01433318480849266, -0.07867904007434845, 0.009589985944330692, -0.11043453216552734, 0.001658124034292996, -0.033100806176662445, 0.07029800862073898, 0.02114897035062313, -0.012798543088138103, 0.029094839468598366, -0.016514969989657402, 0.0375550240278244, -0.03331257775425911, -0.04657934606075287, 0.03949129581451416, -0.014530858024954796, 0.03942958265542984, 0.06330189108848572, 0.009956992231309414, 0.104742132127285, -0.07165403664112091, -0.05155497416853905, -0.0016512699658051133, 0.011400410905480385, 0.0555899441242218, 0.013896717689931393, 0.027010660618543625, -0.021340135484933853, -0.009965470992028713, -0.025239480659365654, 0.019042043015360832, -0.02021491527557373, -0.044473785907030106, 0.025477027520537376, -0.011157862842082977, 0.017813676968216896, -0.024283215403556824, 0.01739318110048771, -0.025793809443712234, 0.04549209028482437, -0.009826221503317356, 0.04628453776240349, -0.0016446812078356743, -0.0005861148820258677, 0.004287010990083218, -0.03130809962749481, -0.006109882146120071, 0.003399541834369302, 0.014024428091943264, 0.009189058095216751, 0.008070159703493118, 0.020861567929387093, 0.07313338667154312, -0.033666595816612244, -0.04953928291797638, -0.009746687486767769, 0.0019455357687547803, -0.00993211381137371, 0.042952973395586014, 0.04465695843100548, -0.0426359586417675, 0.0212485883384943, 0.05357571318745613, -0.0221225805580616, -0.01003676000982523, 0.0022211831528693438, -0.03847132623195648, 0.04716004058718681, 0.042486775666475296, -0.052905045449733734, -0.009894181042909622, -0.06966573745012283, 0.006262829527258873, 0.03515017405152321, -0.018240060657262802, -0.013890141621232033, 0.045903053134679794, 2.74854983217665e-07, -0.12024050205945969, -0.025781862437725067, -0.0037937413435429335, -0.05686601623892784, 0.034059811383485794, 0.014393206685781479, 0.02143128030002117, 0.015623057261109352, -0.025445636361837387, -0.004587929230183363, 0.01288481242954731, -0.011330022476613522, 0.05623846873641014, -0.005092776846140623, -0.0811537355184555, -0.01845909096300602, -0.09721051901578903, 0.011362320743501186, 0.017439715564250946, 0.021397655829787254, -0.00013121009396854788, 0.1188090518116951, 0.013725899159908295, -0.04020150378346443, 0.0176591444760561, -0.013492505997419357, -0.004974383395165205, 0.0032472657039761543, 0.038695983588695526, -0.058351218700408936, 0.032886721193790436, 0.017112432047724724, -0.05480805039405823, -0.05860273912549019, -0.02137538231909275, 0.005269051529467106, -0.01690518856048584, 0.01865541562438011, -0.023542307317256927, -0.043009672313928604, 0.013440840877592564, 0.0032532799523323774, -0.03670515492558479, 0.029421314597129822, 0.007991453632712364, 0.03854968771338463, -0.030685558915138245, -0.04896962270140648, 0.02359679527580738, -0.010728850960731506, -0.035268183797597885, 0.006783944554626942, 0.06405076384544373, -0.05296199023723602, -0.022099383175373077, -0.05593152344226837, 0.0033711306750774384, -0.06815214455127716, 0.013969998806715012, 0.014148806221783161, -0.014468743465840816, 0.01176765002310276, -0.04840525984764099, 0.007250556256622076, 0.0770789384841919, -0.010966104455292225, -0.023263337090611458, 2.542237499926034e-34, -0.003513943636789918, -0.06394774466753006, 0.00922155100852251, 0.05747455731034279, -0.028611188754439354, -0.03153003752231598, 0.006470601540058851, 0.02686765231192112, -0.015098655596375465, -0.06991777569055557, -0.07333378493785858]
608
608
['Caglar Gulcehre', 'Sungjin Ahn', 'Ramesh Nallapati', 'Bowen Zhou', 'Yoshua Bengio']
1603.08148v3
The problem of rare and unknown words is an important issue that can potentially influence the performance of many NLP systems, including both the traditional count-based and the deep learning models. We propose a novel way to deal with the rare and unseen words for the neural network models using attention. Our model uses two softmax layers in order to predict the next word in conditional language models: one predicts the location of a word in the source sentence, and the other predicts a word in the shortlist vocabulary. At each time-step, the decision of which softmax layer to use choose adaptively made by an MLP which is conditioned on the context.~We motivate our work from a psychological evidence that humans naturally have a tendency to point towards objects in the context or the environment when the name of an object is not known.~We observe improvements on two tasks, neural machine translation on the Europarl English to French parallel corpora and text summarization on the Gigaword dataset using our proposed model.
Pointing the Unknown Words
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1603.08148v3
Title Pointing Unknown Words Summary problem rare unknown word important issue potentially influence performance many NLP system including traditional countbased deep learning model propose novel way deal rare unseen word neural network model using attention model us two softmax layer order predict next word conditional language model one predicts location word source sentence predicts word shortlist vocabulary timestep decision softmax layer use choose adaptively made MLP conditioned contextWe motivate work psychological evidence human naturally tendency point towards object context environment name object knownWe observe improvement two task neural machine translation Europarl English French parallel corpus text summarization Gigaword dataset using proposed model Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.0698966532945633, 0.012464814819395542, 0.01565462164580822, 0.032125454396009445, 0.0012413514778017998, 0.0022937203757464886, -0.005260268691927195, 0.0024114649277180433, -0.021239766851067543, -0.04228523001074791, 0.010414793156087399, -0.006894045043736696, 0.017795942723751068, 0.015037612058222294, 0.04137621074914932, -0.06338874995708466, 0.01658269762992859, 0.0032354884315282106, 0.0038570764008909464, 0.025359151884913445, 0.023244231939315796, 0.02298750728368759, 0.00364408316090703, 0.036311522126197815, -0.01529789250344038, -0.00606272928416729, -0.010460696183145046, 0.0027063926681876183, 0.022003980353474617, -0.059117842465639114, 0.03509192168712616, 0.058906540274620056, 0.005357619374990463, 0.07367117702960968, 1.9831766167044407e-06, -0.03731357306241989, -0.02618248201906681, -0.04973100870847702, 0.029451100155711174, -0.075132355093956, 0.025056183338165283, -0.06052258610725403, 0.0006655926699750125, -0.005314208567142487, -0.010060480795800686, -0.0037934104911983013, 0.04520302265882492, 0.09226619452238083, -0.013514356687664986, 0.05314142629504204, -0.0006754809874109924, -0.04948265105485916, -0.02232232689857483, -0.0050405520014464855, 0.02128259651362896, -0.038149937987327576, 0.001501461025327444, -0.03325692191720009, -0.01685231178998947, 0.033986546099185944, -0.012993481010198593, 0.03949530050158501, -0.04515887796878815, 0.0010056840255856514, 0.066684290766716, 0.05510789155960083, -0.02606402151286602, -0.01912880688905716, 0.0011344891972839832, 0.09824566543102264, -0.06729978322982788, -0.014986184425652027, 0.01263729389756918, -0.009082960896193981, -0.0009863388258963823, -5.173515455680899e-05, -0.03970705717802048, 0.027247373014688492, -0.014856578782200813, 0.004656941629946232, 0.02287835255265236, 0.03529489412903786, -0.015278258360922337, 0.002910410054028034, 0.014708169735968113, 0.026798998937010765, -0.007916402071714401, -0.025033513084053993, 0.020668836310505867, -0.010442620143294334, -0.012190442532300949, -0.08739815652370453, 0.061113279312849045, 0.027594784274697304, -0.0026854064781218767, 0.018702594563364983, 0.007946575991809368, -0.054422132670879364, 0.062427498400211334, -0.10165273398160934, 0.06298355013132095, -0.02521798573434353, -0.04033348336815834, 0.04098980501294136, -0.008463926613330841, -0.00877686683088541, -0.0011804630048573017, -0.021225156262516975, -0.03462577238678932, 0.01349864061921835, -0.011258712038397789, -0.008320693857967854, -0.031067106872797012, 0.0001883277582237497, -0.013181736692786217, -0.03192612901329994, -0.03361647203564644, -0.01611759513616562, 0.030142422765493393, -0.014549915678799152, 0.005832278169691563, 0.06285928934812546, -0.02171536535024643, -0.011648123152554035, 0.005558964796364307, 0.04323355108499527, -0.06391112506389618, 0.02171671949326992, -0.02344544604420662, -0.00140087166801095, 0.016666922718286514, 0.030399838462471962, 0.030085595324635506, 0.0005314291920512915, 0.018250199034810066, 0.04385082796216011, 0.022160576656460762, -0.057480428367853165, -0.03834792226552963, -0.04380452632904053, -0.031421735882759094, -0.028200596570968628, -0.008868384175002575, -0.07409784942865372, -0.023680290207266808, -0.014443171210587025, -0.02619463950395584, 0.001250719535164535, 0.012225977145135403, 0.07973810285329819, -0.04205790534615517, 0.05428071692585945, -0.005833895411342382, -0.010566845536231995, 0.0413648895919323, 0.0017712556291371584, 0.05236917361617088, 0.029203567653894424, -0.007351643871515989, 0.055041756480932236, 0.0396561361849308, 0.022106481716036797, 0.05235176160931587, -0.004784755874425173, -0.02884860895574093, -0.022482508793473244, -0.00453603221103549, -0.014892528764903545, -0.03946727514266968, 0.047682106494903564, 0.015501845628023148, 0.051825106143951416, 0.03229496255517006, 0.0018760350067168474, 0.03686143085360527, 0.11432712525129318, 0.0007604847778566182, -0.01650712639093399, -0.01955319195985794, -0.0004066585679538548, -0.03848206251859665, -0.00974748283624649, -0.028199506923556328, 0.02094840072095394, -0.05181952938437462, -0.0026244819164276123, -0.004395447671413422, 0.00021389208268374205, -0.01233703177422285, -0.016540732234716415, -0.02477326989173889, 0.011126427911221981, -0.01733238995075226, -0.0269100870937109, 0.060036398470401764, 0.008738716132938862, -0.036409176886081696, -0.023944012820720673, 0.004907668102532625, -0.021924572065472603, -0.030359849333763123, 0.014807778410613537, 0.01843571849167347, -0.0021552173420786858, -0.0018472014926373959, -0.03778078407049179, -0.02315264195203781, -0.038359031081199646, 0.03196334093809128, 0.06691926717758179, 0.0017617682460695505, -0.006423137150704861, -0.023590585216879845, -0.03740720450878143, -0.020729195326566696, 0.05547351390123367, -0.008868563920259476, 0.01324896328151226, -0.048393089324235916, 0.022332727909088135, 0.0388958714902401, 0.0012454375391826034, -0.03558105230331421, 0.056886058300733566, 0.033490218222141266, -0.011782377026975155, -0.009822288528084755, 0.028397632762789726, -0.036201003938913345, 0.05318496376276016, 0.04170206934213638, 0.014431057497859001, 0.040598683059215546, -0.022005636245012283, -0.016250137239694595, 0.006835822016000748, -0.011588784866034985, -0.021124297752976418, 0.0158928744494915, -0.06282444298267365, 0.015704140067100525, 0.014820904470980167, 0.008961466141045094, -0.04911890625953674, -0.0079825883731246, -0.02674412727355957, 0.035536494106054306, 0.009415768086910248, 0.03852548822760582, 0.020850233733654022, 0.046300601214170456, -0.0727454349398613, 0.07942349463701248, -0.008380181156098843, 0.06840064376592636, 0.0007196128135547042, -0.0384894460439682, 0.017774026840925217, -0.07764647156000137, -0.04469709470868111, -0.010261960327625275, 0.018726684153079987, -0.0090880636125803, 0.04860208183526993, 0.020533276721835136, -0.05417371541261673, 0.022420017048716545, -0.05601517856121063, -0.017092693597078323, -0.01745644211769104, -0.0036722200457006693, 0.014308677054941654, 0.005730609409511089, -0.018802303820848465, -0.05006198585033417, -0.054799556732177734, 0.032514285296201706, 0.014249863103032112, 0.021346358582377434, 0.06893623620271683, -0.012905623763799667, 0.008190830238163471, -0.05207466706633568, -0.010411227121949196, -0.009402669034898281, 0.029850101098418236, 0.09172231703996658, -0.050869155675172806, -0.07449402660131454, 0.07427020370960236, -0.0033863154239952564, 0.05317515879869461, 0.026331616565585136, 0.0027337376959621906, 0.005108181852847338, -0.007452831603586674, 0.0037387998308986425, 0.061294831335544586, 0.003395797684788704, -0.015016690827906132, 0.017940226942300797, -0.012272429652512074, -0.022505953907966614, -0.023838691413402557, -0.024756399914622307, 0.020529164001345634, 0.0221819207072258, -0.0019303490407764912, 0.007869717665016651, 0.006970465183258057, 0.03875177353620529, -0.007475853897631168, 0.0006267642020247877, 0.036321453750133514, -0.04018532484769821, 0.00928556453436613, -0.05225442349910736, -0.008196290582418442, -0.010703540407121181, 0.04863839969038963, 0.0005348651320673525, -0.008050802163779736, 0.046469833701848984, -0.016166141256690025, 0.013887726701796055, -0.03595971316099167, -0.005250244867056608, -0.007283773273229599, 0.03389960154891014, 0.017568135634064674, 0.03592056781053543, -0.007391950115561485, -0.06616757810115814, -0.01886780560016632, 0.02475893683731556, -0.02808677963912487, -0.007995805703103542, 0.03648482263088226, -0.0058784871362149715, 0.019346436485648155, -0.017429688945412636, -0.020541798323392868, -0.04592752456665039, -0.028826341032981873, -0.03739471733570099, -0.012373893521726131, 0.031193984672427177, -0.018689483404159546, -0.011504599824547768, 0.05908149853348732, 0.02226509153842926, 0.04992246255278587, 0.007088057231158018, -0.031642165035009384, -0.005648937541991472, 0.005633365362882614, 0.06163256615400314, 0.00424967473372817, 0.008201788179576397, 0.01598295569419861, -0.03832953795790672, 0.07113263756036758, 0.002128139603883028, -0.005736243445426226, -0.051284030079841614, -0.017781170085072517, 0.04277399554848671, -0.06365510821342468, -0.0505310520529747, -0.031357500702142715, 0.030317038297653198, -0.06484133005142212, -0.022930340841412544, 0.09847769886255264, 0.03385810926556587, -0.0968785285949707, 0.002943515544757247, 0.003751348005607724, -0.04309064522385597, 0.002669508568942547, 0.04288304224610329, -0.052280254662036896, -0.02359168790280819, -0.022800663486123085, 0.02132999338209629, -0.014713826589286327, -0.05699227750301361, -0.0035870466381311417, -0.11312875151634216, -0.008567841723561287, -0.04331867769360542, -0.04547009617090225, -0.04223140329122543, -0.05250542610883713, 0.0026048978324979544, -0.017449993640184402, -0.016047289595007896, 0.022357871755957603, 0.0013858007732778788, -0.005754267331212759, -0.0035790507681667805, -0.026345811784267426, -0.014851247891783714, 0.018670832738280296, -0.05910110846161842, 0.020566528663039207, 0.05456950515508652, 0.05641765519976616, -0.01950785331428051, -0.01972489431500435, 0.006899270229041576, -0.005026594270020723, 0.024195173755288124, -0.013184547424316406, 0.05349375307559967, -0.03976215422153473, 0.012161768041551113, -0.030784355476498604, 0.03481960669159889, -0.05074112117290497, 0.014365171082317829, 0.0111841494217515, 0.04492953419685364, -0.01036535669118166, 0.03622758388519287, -0.060063522309064865, 0.03716706112027168, 0.024821266531944275, 0.0341513529419899, 0.0007810808601789176, -0.024850856512784958, 0.00175337097607553, -0.017181724309921265, 0.015900595113635063, -0.0003041245508939028, -0.032650187611579895, -0.003541337326169014, -0.02379300817847252, -0.04380368813872337, -0.10794124007225037, -0.06393057107925415, 0.02314775623381138, 0.05052360147237778, 0.05566193908452988, 0.046133413910865784, -0.012293834239244461, 0.003849754109978676, -0.038524556905031204, 0.018189072608947754, 0.05884559825062752, 0.021513843908905983, -0.0552198626101017, 0.03575685992836952, 0.0648685097694397, 0.0017605312168598175, -0.012382300570607185, -0.0011916483053937554, -0.04667716100811958, -0.05739481374621391, -0.0005845836130902171, -0.0014790401328355074, 0.020553581416606903, 0.008414979092776775, -0.055390864610672, -0.08156490325927734, -0.004919372498989105, -0.015143442898988724, 0.0004533416940830648, -0.019264694303274155, -0.01600816287100315, 0.04422073811292648, 0.003342169104143977, 0.0240904800593853, -0.016932658851146698, 0.04326625168323517, 0.01833031140267849, -0.0014353288570418954, -0.05621618032455444, -0.05359520763158798, 0.0014945989241823554, -0.011644621379673481, 0.08712691068649292, -0.03379189223051071, -0.011961039155721664, -0.053877245634794235, -0.02391074039041996, -0.0038252542726695538, -0.022458532825112343, -0.01731668785214424, 0.030162813141942024, 0.01428299956023693, -0.015649057924747467, -0.03200599551200867, -0.025882884860038757, -0.04843957722187042, -0.017017077654600143, -0.060112521052360535, 0.046529192477464676, 0.02309921570122242, -0.004555510822683573, -0.020324675366282463, -0.0009091123938560486, -0.01079562772065401, 0.03734438493847847, -0.007869765162467957, 0.07566431909799576, -0.007700592745095491, 0.03489548712968826, 0.02964569441974163, -0.03675272315740585, -0.033150751143693924, 0.020502150058746338, -0.024000084027647972, 0.01603374071419239, -0.058574773371219635, 0.03601650893688202, 0.06602650880813599, -0.11505245417356491, 0.01552432682365179, 0.024143893271684647, 0.01280211191624403, 0.01691538468003273, 0.04088753089308739, -0.028374629095196724, -0.032015684992074966, 0.013426564633846283, 0.008893405087292194, 0.010354078374803066, -0.0011295056901872158, 0.048374030739068985, -0.0049888975918293, -0.03335954621434212, 0.03606720268726349, -0.053753770887851715, -0.02642621472477913, 0.06772245466709137, 0.04294707626104355, 0.01947120763361454, -0.01720597967505455, 0.05045768991112709, -0.047328852117061615, -0.04156264662742615, 0.014842442236840725, -0.006715813186019659, 0.035020023584365845, 0.028310397639870644, 0.06689976900815964, 0.023475082591176033, 0.007799976505339146, -0.013785800896584988, -0.0630151778459549, 0.022177966311573982, 0.013725084252655506, -0.032182879745960236, -0.06823330372571945, -6.1213416488429525e-33, 0.00664443289861083, -0.06155615299940109, -0.02135986089706421, -0.012629400007426739, -0.016380995512008667, -0.00014654319966211915, -0.01644921489059925, 0.01194828748703003, -0.022983580827713013, 0.01871335133910179, -0.038094405084848404, 0.02016167901456356, 0.02148059755563736, 0.030416453257203102, 0.030063774436712265, 0.010978765785694122, -0.017008047550916672, 0.012933158315718174, -0.009431690908968449, -0.010782836936414242, 0.0750892162322998, 0.06898386031389236, 0.11557590216398239, -0.059380341321229935, 0.032204046845436096, -0.02059037610888481, 0.0038955260533839464, 0.023383580148220062, 0.03546149283647537, 0.017561811953783035, -0.029039684683084488, 0.011832124553620815, 0.02002147026360035, -0.041002918034791946, -0.005718635395169258, 0.04802184924483299, -0.004740627482533455, -0.04501935839653015, -0.04272044822573662, 0.05913389474153519, 0.01569480076432228, 0.017084192484617233, 0.07509304583072662, -0.013639586977660656, 0.004472461529076099, 0.059520162642002106, 0.08485524356365204, -0.04288453981280327, -0.044354479759931564, -0.022603116929531097, -0.06520348787307739, 0.03535952419042587, 0.011679423972964287, -0.009332532994449139, 0.04536407068371773, 0.005938358139246702, 0.012365071102976799, -0.020858969539403915, -0.092284195125103, 0.015292496420443058, 0.023329509422183037, 0.061089932918548584, 0.05367454141378403, 0.05772964656352997, -0.022503407672047615, 0.03921154513955116, 0.030510004609823227, -0.011385527439415455, -0.021472226828336716, 0.012321696616709232, 0.014259797520935535, 0.019310152158141136, 0.0501134991645813, 0.010852840729057789, 0.0526563934981823, 0.0230560265481472, -0.05395136773586273, 0.024191923439502716, -0.034691549837589264, 0.027796417474746704, 0.029733015224337578, -0.012078927829861641, -0.0665275901556015, -0.02309039980173111, 0.002754079643636942, -0.01757580041885376, -0.024538777768611908, 0.013064309023320675, 0.011159941554069519, -0.0025666221044957638, -0.0036214455030858517, 0.00691852206364274, -0.0003152574645355344, 0.0026249520014971495, -0.033474210649728775, -0.01214155275374651, 0.03921269252896309, 0.022083882242441177, -0.011651929467916489, 0.0007019355543889105, -0.07501954585313797, 0.014021946117281914, -0.04528319835662842, 0.050450630486011505, 0.011628858745098114, -0.00016002899792511016, 0.016995349898934364, -0.025412097573280334, -0.06355731934309006, -0.022246627137064934, 0.015057481825351715, -0.05967763811349869, 0.014391080476343632, 0.04414869472384453, 0.021586399525403976, -0.05717627704143524, -0.017960986122488976, 0.09781692922115326, 0.043994929641485214, -0.008347021415829659, -0.01584775559604168, -0.03592674806714058, 0.027592221274971962, 0.006542089395225048, -0.06634543091058731, 0.008695846423506737, 0.015288478694856167, 0.057630255818367004, 0.06690573692321777, -0.05686573311686516, -0.008631288073956966, 0.017215600237250328, 2.659319306985708e-07, 0.05796342343091965, 0.006997612304985523, 0.01889069192111492, -0.0027231373824179173, -0.034673482179641724, 0.01306394673883915, 0.03487969562411308, 0.04327305406332016, -0.021819548681378365, -0.00037341887946240604, 0.032171547412872314, -0.017522325739264488, -0.02933073788881302, -0.003508448600769043, -0.13793377578258514, -0.03644999489188194, -0.019261304289102554, 0.027581246569752693, -0.03307007625699043, -0.01010317262262106, 0.008805549703538418, 0.0958944782614708, 0.0076032113283872604, -0.025769131258130074, -0.007706945296376944, -0.016888540238142014, -0.015194402076303959, 0.007893698289990425, 0.03384692966938019, -0.009261216968297958, 0.08938717097043991, 0.016083547845482826, -0.04775122180581093, 0.0045912982895970345, -0.01690579019486904, -0.0013667496386915445, 0.06689658761024475, -0.0038827573880553246, -0.046359170228242874, -0.006624252535402775, 0.03355880454182625, -0.025861967355012894, 0.020029425621032715, -0.03280307352542877, 0.03471798449754715, -0.044119298458099365, -0.009252732619643211, 0.010407038033008575, 0.0008936548256315291, -0.002488817321136594, 0.03289143368601799, -0.00996339414268732, -0.03160203993320465, -0.00555022619664669, 0.017585450783371925, -0.024462081491947174, -0.029327671974897385, -0.0766512006521225, -0.02016979083418846, 0.02664245292544365, 0.009061978198587894, 0.017205171287059784, 0.017671065405011177, -0.0429253876209259, -0.021741190925240517, -0.0531226210296154, -0.03343745321035385, 2.4972569330853308e-34, 0.025881430134177208, 0.013665235601365566, -0.05705859139561653, -0.014026064425706863, 0.003457003738731146, -0.011631136760115623, 0.025372188538312912, 0.017990609630942345, 0.04214593395590782, -0.07049593329429626, -0.06229843571782112]
609
609
['Zhenyao Zhu', 'Jesse H. Engel', 'Awni Hannun']
1603.09509v2
Deep learning has dramatically improved the performance of speech recognition systems through learning hierarchies of features optimized for the task at hand. However, true end-to-end learning, where features are learned directly from waveforms, has only recently reached the performance of hand-tailored representations based on the Fourier transform. In this paper, we detail an approach to use convolutional filters to push past the inherent tradeoff of temporal and frequency resolution that exists for spectral representations. At increased computational cost, we show that increasing temporal resolution via reduced stride and increasing frequency resolution via additional filters delivers significant performance improvements. Further, we find more efficient representations by simultaneously learning at multiple scales, leading to an overall decrease in word error rate on a difficult internal speech test set by 20.7% relative to networks with the same number of parameters trained on spectrograms.
Learning Multiscale Features Directly From Waveforms
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1603.09509v2
Title Learning Multiscale Features Directly Waveforms Summary Deep learning dramatically improved performance speech recognition system learning hierarchy feature optimized task hand However true endtoend learning feature learned directly waveform recently reached performance handtailored representation based Fourier transform paper detail approach use convolutional filter push past inherent tradeoff temporal frequency resolution exists spectral representation increased computational cost show increasing temporal resolution via reduced stride increasing frequency resolution via additional filter delivers significant performance improvement find efficient representation simultaneously learning multiple scale leading overall decrease word error rate difficult internal speech test set 207 relative network number parameter trained spectrogram Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.033016979694366455, 0.059531424194574356, 0.01716112531721592, 0.058574970811605453, 0.017842482775449753, 5.215239434619434e-05, 0.06738042831420898, 0.010663111694157124, -0.023073263466358185, 0.011679023504257202, -0.08431396633386612, -0.05607355386018753, 0.037901535630226135, 0.06979480385780334, 0.009736104868352413, -0.07163964956998825, -0.02279752492904663, -0.039039891213178635, -0.018424030393362045, -0.007215558551251888, 0.019212113693356514, -0.004787637386471033, -0.0387989841401577, 0.025836393237113953, -0.06769516319036484, 0.020400039851665497, -0.033447813242673874, -0.012483497150242329, 0.021688977256417274, -0.005209012422710657, 0.011873412877321243, 0.00817199982702732, 0.046172842383384705, 0.045087505131959915, 2.3912530195957515e-06, 0.008990656584501266, -0.020145146176218987, -0.016365444287657738, 0.023189526051282883, 0.000332712777890265, 0.011683523654937744, 0.00985515583306551, -0.06725240498781204, 0.005861144978553057, -0.004872421268373728, 0.007425189018249512, 0.021989189088344574, 0.07225046306848526, -0.011751826852560043, 0.035167839378118515, -0.004768902901560068, -0.058756593614816666, 0.004767315927892923, 0.009630722925066948, -0.06351350992918015, 0.015050104819238186, -0.048455022275447845, -0.0314851813018322, -0.04501401633024216, -0.0018217392498627305, 0.0026480932720005512, 0.038559067994356155, -0.00285827973857522, 0.004410179797559977, 0.02562151663005352, 0.003371972357854247, -0.039659593254327774, -0.03573420271277428, 0.025959568098187447, 0.08041933923959732, -0.030694734305143356, 0.0005067565361969173, -0.0042105866596102715, 0.006309288088232279, -0.0066428170539438725, -0.0039036227390170097, -0.015800079330801964, 0.006572662387043238, 0.011858743615448475, 0.008782845921814442, -0.04576491564512253, 0.012586863711476326, -0.004083140753209591, -0.009293889626860619, -0.0069293431006371975, 0.006878092885017395, -0.03748229146003723, 0.02000545524060726, -0.0014033041661605239, -0.07257286459207535, -0.03847040608525276, 0.05896412208676338, 0.0508899986743927, 0.01133347861468792, -0.010339608415961266, -0.0325750857591629, -0.02683582343161106, -0.03700690716505051, 0.03617386147379875, -0.0724816545844078, 0.013169171288609505, -0.007810142356902361, -0.07364246994256973, -0.022547779604792595, 0.006383324973285198, 0.056455858051776886, -0.06818903237581253, -0.050333913415670395, -0.030841192230582237, -0.009168166667222977, -0.024039234966039658, -0.004033956676721573, -0.04035830497741699, 0.060538362711668015, -0.016466371715068817, -0.0036780862137675285, -0.06386017799377441, -0.05234549567103386, -0.013631952926516533, -0.023333976045250893, 0.02339305356144905, 0.049938153475522995, -0.053170546889305115, -0.0008485857397317886, 0.012595831416547298, 0.07524679601192474, -0.01264954824000597, 0.0542546883225441, -0.014309179037809372, -0.048056524246931076, 0.02918541245162487, 0.01264327485114336, 0.038111910223960876, 0.021484913304448128, 0.034456126391887665, 0.048808563500642776, 0.008451630361378193, -0.020657196640968323, -0.027954010292887688, -0.01598934829235077, -0.04712545499205589, -0.01588462106883526, -0.016247693449258804, -0.06716251373291016, 0.0492633618414402, -0.009085682220757008, -0.004700789228081703, 0.04394405335187912, 0.013265589252114296, 0.00910217221826315, 0.044699862599372864, 0.06433533132076263, -0.05837491154670715, -0.022794198244810104, 0.08855355530977249, -0.006994067225605249, 0.018549425527453423, 0.027705460786819458, 0.07345913350582123, -0.011504787020385265, -0.050317101180553436, -0.09182093292474747, -0.03194861859083176, 0.03581233695149422, -0.02533295750617981, -0.019259555265307426, -0.035355448722839355, -0.05138575658202171, 0.031225204467773438, 0.0371062196791172, 0.0610651895403862, 0.03705478832125664, 0.014077379368245602, -0.009979710914194584, 0.042126644402742386, 0.07364615797996521, 0.028743939474225044, 0.05664420500397682, 0.0003800004196818918, 0.017220649868249893, 0.017194055020809174, -0.0049820467829704285, 0.035555385053157806, 0.007166445255279541, 0.053495489060878754, -0.0070687560364604, -0.014182044193148613, -3.4285574656678364e-05, 0.0009888147469609976, -0.00787079706788063, 0.011235328391194344, -0.012506757862865925, -0.026030343025922775, 0.0011461225803941488, 0.04558292776346207, -0.014549986459314823, -0.024273093789815903, 0.03335538133978844, 0.027501145377755165, -0.02206345833837986, -0.0004421723715495318, -0.03901147469878197, -0.05341358855366707, 0.02409399300813675, -0.002722716424614191, -0.03327557072043419, 0.048348914831876755, -0.033942509442567825, -0.03464936092495918, -0.010238108225166798, 0.017041390761733055, -0.021776603534817696, 0.010923516005277634, -0.06307855248451233, -0.031827304512262344, 0.0032524769194424152, -0.046890825033187866, 0.03672236576676369, -0.049060337245464325, 0.005635120905935764, 0.012438765726983547, -0.02194346860051155, -0.01577433943748474, -0.031026391312479973, 0.053608860820531845, -0.04589119926095009, 0.03258146345615387, 0.05725672468543053, 0.07299686968326569, 0.040489744395017624, 0.013428607024252415, -0.017617134377360344, 0.0373162217438221, -0.037676356732845306, -0.0032980276737362146, -0.017680993303656578, -0.0779561847448349, -0.006501264404505491, 0.036807235330343246, -0.00131985975895077, 0.06731143593788147, 0.05294547230005264, 0.0144289406016469, -0.07866491377353668, 0.034879863262176514, 0.013515587896108627, 0.01229504868388176, -0.009711391292512417, 0.03462681174278259, 0.007114157546311617, 0.04813992604613304, -0.005331022664904594, 0.006280534900724888, 0.02027227357029915, -0.005641262978315353, 0.01831105910241604, 0.005350274033844471, 0.010454842820763588, -0.012158220633864403, -0.005027069244533777, 0.05679618939757347, -0.01450146734714508, 0.011066345497965813, 0.0025282984133809805, -0.03737777844071388, -0.026964757591485977, 0.00043290710891596973, -0.06283417344093323, -0.006099689286202192, 0.009316409938037395, 0.006975522730499506, -0.02767002210021019, -0.001444126944988966, 0.04682896286249161, -0.0410095639526844, -0.04868128523230553, 0.01371122058480978, -0.007418524008244276, -0.024531561881303787, -0.00962959136813879, 0.006293927785009146, -0.004091630689799786, 0.006872535217553377, -0.022319115698337555, -0.009687717072665691, 0.03505351021885872, -0.029524076730012894, -0.053452085703611374, 0.004134249407798052, -0.04097631573677063, 0.02760719135403633, 0.055918995290994644, 0.005570223089307547, -0.030552634969353676, 0.004708229098469019, -0.012090560048818588, 0.030000444501638412, 0.03280949592590332, 0.04281526803970337, 0.018269380554556847, 0.007263312581926584, 0.03987869620323181, -0.034444183111190796, 0.041546206921339035, 0.01955724135041237, 0.049119703471660614, -0.014621834270656109, 0.05974956601858139, -0.07361982762813568, 0.04670858755707741, 0.06325646489858627, 0.06851477921009064, 0.01298018079251051, -0.03119223564863205, -0.013463952578604221, 0.005784926004707813, -0.023672377690672874, -0.03016829304397106, -0.018095193430781364, -0.04944987595081329, 0.026291899383068085, -0.047389257699251175, -0.0015136196743696928, -0.029624411836266518, -0.023136930540204048, -0.01872887648642063, -0.08255312591791153, -0.00316825439222157, 0.045695263892412186, -0.021163571625947952, 0.016413139179348946, -0.026027407497167587, -0.07052051275968552, 0.009862600825726986, -0.03236153721809387, 0.009262442588806152, -0.05831366404891014, 0.030160797759890556, -0.009801688604056835, -0.029345137998461723, -0.06349017471075058, -0.0023669651709496975, -0.05148934945464134, 0.05799683928489685, -0.028441142290830612, 0.014874127693474293, -0.015623250976204872, -0.008078825660049915, -0.04395909979939461, 0.04652382805943489, 0.04600982367992401, 0.0350247286260128, -0.016267569735646248, 0.007074126973748207, -0.011344113387167454, 0.1043994277715683, -0.003106484655290842, 0.040895383805036545, 0.025828629732131958, 0.02229897677898407, 0.048224177211523056, 0.011525548063218594, 0.03750632703304291, -0.014217543415725231, -0.08685453236103058, 0.004619435407221317, 0.01307880412787199, -0.000202273135073483, -0.057808324694633484, 0.01266030315309763, 0.054564833641052246, -0.11914043873548508, 0.037336476147174835, 0.047042116522789, -0.023352855816483498, -0.029495134949684143, 0.008773569948971272, 0.041949428617954254, -0.01683669537305832, 0.014607802033424377, -0.019902167841792107, 0.012615968473255634, -0.015102388337254524, 0.035053785890340805, -0.006724695675075054, 0.04705136641860008, 0.025213172659277916, -0.004078079015016556, -0.007548708468675613, 0.05862695351243019, 0.03758387640118599, 0.010144024156033993, -0.04252796247601509, -0.03482013940811157, -0.02992120012640953, 0.0205328818410635, 0.036379870027303696, 0.0019047576934099197, -0.0067253028973937035, -0.05418547987937927, 0.07234210520982742, -0.059512995183467865, 0.021897466853260994, 0.003437959821894765, -0.04389883950352669, 0.0014202813617885113, 0.017569268122315407, 0.031669486314058304, -0.045802414417266846, -0.05524589493870735, 0.0022912139538675547, 0.0040498035959899426, 0.04064549133181572, -0.01085617020726204, 0.011627699248492718, 0.033729396760463715, -0.007890989072620869, 0.0016946922987699509, 0.06699569523334503, -0.028677279129624367, 0.003187746973708272, -0.005274999886751175, 0.03652764484286308, -0.038343288004398346, -0.010969508439302444, -0.040178269147872925, -0.0033892898354679346, -0.00849270448088646, -0.021210839971899986, -0.00903664343059063, -0.02778155729174614, 0.017355820164084435, -0.0066281883046031, 0.04172990098595619, -0.0022604702971875668, -0.04032374918460846, 0.049481578171253204, 0.06362457573413849, -0.012556292116641998, -0.015146652236580849, -0.00668834475800395, -0.032943885773420334, 0.0483676940202713, 0.008468001149594784, -0.001173966913484037, 0.05093151703476906, 0.04231061786413193, -0.02310114912688732, 0.028146211057901382, -0.004813075996935368, 0.02211964875459671, -0.04761376231908798, 0.0047707282938063145, 0.050487808883190155, -0.06015939265489578, 0.011308528482913971, -0.0596541129052639, -0.043833453208208084, 0.009534688666462898, -0.005994996055960655, -0.04544149339199066, -0.009334344416856766, 0.01984529010951519, 0.005985335446894169, -0.01641455851495266, 0.06627697497606277, -0.011718198657035828, -0.028525209054350853, -0.008993350900709629, 0.04300275072455406, -0.020630503073334694, -0.04377346485853195, 0.013789554126560688, -0.03444958105683327, 0.05715698376297951, -0.05062245577573776, 0.013306944631040096, 0.010716953314840794, -0.0373147688806057, 0.032944630831480026, -0.0490371435880661, 0.06854774802923203, 0.010533914901316166, -0.0023873725440353155, -0.030878927558660507, 0.02691936120390892, 0.04634074121713638, 0.023119522258639336, -0.019647173583507538, 0.01062738336622715, 0.001019825809635222, 0.010032734833657742, 0.010157069191336632, -0.005686501041054726, 0.03230081871151924, -0.08092009276151657, 0.05225842446088791, 0.09761282801628113, -0.015230442397296429, -0.04006008058786392, -0.04619811475276947, 0.003856795374304056, -0.01722390577197075, 0.04868040233850479, 0.03795187920331955, 0.02784140408039093, -0.0004717557749245316, 0.006088985595852137, -0.021989937871694565, 0.011668463237583637, -0.025558797642588615, -0.004271293990314007, 0.020638450980186462, -0.008518213406205177, -0.045645978301763535, -0.01735217496752739, 0.05393754318356514, -0.01722160540521145, -0.011725756339728832, 0.01812596246600151, 0.009447715245187283, -0.00829300656914711, 0.01653403230011463, -0.025873906910419464, 0.04181171953678131, 0.0640917420387268, -0.01421307772397995, -0.01802375353872776, 0.0013373671099543571, 0.038351308554410934, 0.024594664573669434, 0.0012385818408802152, 0.014004367403686047, 0.02363668754696846, -0.03974444046616554, -0.052313148975372314, -0.045274339616298676, 0.026126569136977196, -0.04360843077301979, 0.015220058150589466, 0.03917771205306053, -0.038093287497758865, 0.021007204428315163, -0.03678429499268532, 0.012577688321471214, -0.06691358983516693, 0.04053089767694473, -0.01161946076899767, -0.019062675535678864, -0.002302146051079035, 0.02384711243212223, -0.04667152836918831, 0.0583781935274601, 0.007174481637775898, 0.009585431776940823, -5.936873157078334e-33, 0.026880275458097458, 0.02191046252846718, -0.02423577755689621, 0.011778651736676693, -0.0006300745299085975, 0.035752709954977036, 0.03269555792212486, 0.029248377308249474, -0.0221273023635149, 0.005775962956249714, -0.016854839399456978, -0.007079135160893202, 0.04224177449941635, 0.024573609232902527, 0.026234420016407967, -1.5994584828149527e-05, 0.04482674226164818, -0.06514524668455124, 0.04506500065326691, 0.014316407963633537, 0.036014068871736526, 0.02915753796696663, 0.0968930646777153, -0.02220008708536625, -0.08396792411804199, 0.03032635897397995, -0.0027891136705875397, -0.03651128336787224, 0.010261042043566704, 0.016099173575639725, -0.02000795118510723, 0.03899918869137764, -0.025034591555595398, -0.02919699065387249, 0.0004056706093251705, 0.03125628083944321, -0.07759393006563187, 0.0333060584962368, -0.03795596584677696, 0.07299399375915527, -0.03265923261642456, -0.01801995187997818, 0.06227698177099228, 0.011398608796298504, -0.018912971019744873, -0.032628875225782394, 0.018780136480927467, -0.03256765753030777, -0.006116005126386881, -0.1005212590098381, -0.01196941640228033, 0.028141485527157784, -0.014431273564696312, -0.0020611893851310015, 0.0531185045838356, 0.0381476990878582, -0.05656919255852699, -0.04554324224591255, -0.09118666499853134, 0.0390581451356411, 0.04544717073440552, 0.042405981570482254, 0.012252023443579674, 0.02852461487054825, -0.027574442327022552, 0.01811816915869713, 0.039420660585165024, -0.0351986400783062, 0.05502138286828995, -0.0367446132004261, 0.060268335044384, 0.05285988003015518, 0.008272653445601463, -0.008195917122066021, 0.051155317574739456, -0.04853358492255211, -0.0484793446958065, -0.005174444988369942, 0.019375966861844063, -0.019023897126317024, -0.004408845212310553, -0.00865062978118658, -0.03851309418678284, 0.001777560100890696, -0.03460755571722984, 0.016855021938681602, -0.027249695733189583, 0.0065374053083360195, 0.01528641302138567, -0.018303735181689262, 0.03871648386120796, -0.027715016156435013, 0.04426297917962074, -0.016466539353132248, 0.019436189904808998, -0.021670661866664886, 0.002539314329624176, 0.0006655295146629214, 0.02276991307735443, -0.02814122661948204, -0.014380845241248608, -0.05987820774316788, 0.028900159522891045, 0.013080492615699768, 0.023093098774552345, 0.0007329224608838558, 0.01983942836523056, 0.039542704820632935, -0.0221914891153574, -0.02150261588394642, 0.016946541145443916, -0.03173436224460602, 0.03578426316380501, 0.02666681818664074, 0.04851599782705307, -0.04493945091962814, 0.013015213422477245, 0.07581236958503723, -0.04495938867330551, -0.00843757577240467, -0.014260495081543922, 0.014437743462622166, 0.02272241935133934, 0.08402622491121292, -0.04928809776902199, 0.024851500988006592, -0.09429657459259033, -0.022445937618613243, 0.049103524535894394, -0.017652329057455063, -0.035907164216041565, 0.027306614443659782, 2.998373815898958e-07, -0.05456411466002464, -0.01053035818040371, 0.019615182653069496, -0.021415090188384056, -0.0009619865450076759, 0.042877763509750366, 0.0165758915245533, -0.009197625331580639, -0.018720658496022224, 0.016853483393788338, 0.038186248391866684, -0.008695358410477638, 0.03669939562678337, 0.05553646758198738, -0.06710648536682129, -0.05996619537472725, -0.045834772288799286, -0.00838154461234808, -0.012196329422295094, 0.04421577975153923, -0.008842585608363152, 0.10501042753458023, -0.04251718148589134, -0.08377847075462341, 0.054895736277103424, 0.05909876897931099, 0.03146422654390335, 0.055930089205503464, 0.02275506779551506, -0.01772407814860344, -0.07257159799337387, 0.003857840783894062, -0.02350016124546528, 0.045978255569934845, -0.06578151136636734, 0.010763409547507763, 0.0016223103739321232, 0.017610443755984306, -0.033822692930698395, -0.0412299819290638, 0.025821376591920853, 0.03176622837781906, 0.01220701728016138, 0.007364725228399038, 0.029559334740042686, 0.02757299318909645, -0.04428059607744217, -0.05121523141860962, -0.00410540122538805, -0.01169314980506897, -0.014317667111754417, -0.011145803146064281, 0.021544495597481728, -0.03677811473608017, -0.014771093614399433, -0.054611027240753174, -0.05231080949306488, -0.044385816901922226, -0.0020178332924842834, 0.05859356001019478, -0.02332361973822117, -0.0050538163632154465, -0.02322472259402275, -0.10254397243261337, 0.07822024077177048, 0.03647899627685547, -0.025912152603268623, 2.532605333911503e-34, -0.011572476476430893, -0.008061698637902737, 0.008726959116756916, -0.0184229277074337, -0.043729763478040695, -0.03433805704116821, 0.00922382716089487, -0.008973297663033009, 0.0177936889231205, -0.029909852892160416, -0.05941149592399597]
610
610
['Petr Baudis', 'Silvestr Stanko', 'Jan Sedivy']
1605.04655v2
We consider the problem of Recognizing Textual Entailment within an Information Retrieval context, where we must simultaneously determine the relevancy as well as degree of entailment for individual pieces of evidence to determine a yes/no answer to a binary natural language question. We compare several variants of neural networks for sentence embeddings in a setting of decision-making based on evidence of varying relevance. We propose a basic model to integrate evidence for entailment, show that joint training of the sentence embeddings to model relevance and entailment is feasible even with no explicit per-evidence supervision, and show the importance of evaluating strong baselines. We also demonstrate the benefit of carrying over text comprehension model trained on an unrelated task for our small datasets. Our research is motivated primarily by a new open dataset we introduce, consisting of binary questions and news-based evidence snippets. We also apply the proposed relevance-entailment model on a similar task of ranking multiple-choice test answers, evaluating it on a preliminary dataset of school test questions as well as the standard MCTest dataset, where we improve the neural model state-of-art.
Joint Learning of Sentence Embeddings for Relevance and Entailment
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1605.04655v2
Title Joint Learning Sentence Embeddings Relevance Entailment Summary consider problem Recognizing Textual Entailment within Information Retrieval context must simultaneously determine relevancy well degree entailment individual piece evidence determine yesno answer binary natural language question compare several variant neural network sentence embeddings setting decisionmaking based evidence varying relevance propose basic model integrate evidence entailment show joint training sentence embeddings model relevance entailment feasible even explicit perevidence supervision show importance evaluating strong baseline also demonstrate benefit carrying text comprehension model trained unrelated task small datasets research motivated primarily new open dataset introduce consisting binary question newsbased evidence snippet also apply proposed relevanceentailment model similar task ranking multiplechoice test answer evaluating preliminary dataset school test question well standard MCTest dataset improve neural model stateofart Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.06912939995527267, 0.0009819197002798319, -0.000473639986012131, 0.045569971203804016, -0.05108325555920601, 0.03289928287267685, -0.02245612069964409, -0.008449180983006954, 0.021231716498732567, -0.041814446449279785, 0.0102603854611516, 0.051032230257987976, -0.028879690915346146, 0.03999879211187363, -0.0005955322994850576, -0.0022109083365648985, 0.05179540440440178, 0.06443808227777481, 0.042847760021686554, 0.0069030956365168095, 0.024571461603045464, 0.04140663146972656, 0.006217925809323788, 0.05774360150098801, 0.00650520995259285, -0.0010907771065831184, 0.0252655241638422, -0.009319644421339035, 0.04201086610555649, -0.003570557339116931, 0.03612643852829933, 0.021164407953619957, 0.06119010969996452, -0.0055373189970850945, 1.87096100034978e-06, -0.06269678473472595, -0.018783429637551308, -0.02079063095152378, -0.024642912670969963, -0.040141358971595764, 0.0005407866556197405, -0.01403321884572506, 0.051190100610256195, 0.016604693606495857, -0.0508691631257534, 0.02647814154624939, 0.028294874355196953, 0.07345174998044968, 0.0523674339056015, 0.033346161246299744, -0.007443893700838089, -0.021581551060080528, 0.02444573864340782, -0.005178785417228937, 0.024893222376704216, 0.006366817746311426, 0.03432464599609375, 0.023583820089697838, -0.022845419123768806, 0.03861680626869202, 0.01944712921977043, 0.019230306148529053, 0.04627247527241707, -0.02612198516726494, -0.011942057870328426, 0.005821476224809885, -0.037077292799949646, 0.005701000802218914, 0.03587134927511215, 0.07044171541929245, 0.012793358415365219, -0.043540049344301224, -0.024588344618678093, 0.015410689637064934, 0.01149743888527155, 0.032370906323194504, -0.010000272653996944, 0.032249368727207184, -0.028920771554112434, 0.01992654800415039, 0.05243641883134842, 0.013456225395202637, 0.018268393352627754, 0.023255523294210434, -0.03901224210858345, 0.08171126246452332, -0.0061746942810714245, -0.04657554253935814, 0.03473406657576561, 0.02985008992254734, -0.05126362293958664, -0.034890081733465195, 0.056604962795972824, 0.027516406029462814, 0.010227954015135765, 0.0023287900257855654, -0.03826054558157921, -0.047714963555336, 0.04747408255934715, -0.07462533563375473, -0.014021893963217735, 0.006881679408252239, -0.0019867937080562115, 0.04265092685818672, -0.03163008764386177, -0.004752006381750107, 0.009261354804039001, 0.016522986814379692, -0.06057218834757805, -0.03368902578949928, -0.04818665608763695, -0.021116532385349274, -0.05126940459012985, 0.034839924424886703, -0.006363331340253353, -0.031588055193424225, -0.010572421364486217, 0.012510716915130615, 0.008167805150151253, 0.009623936377465725, -0.015388600528240204, 0.010035378858447075, -0.03721573203802109, -0.012341628782451153, -0.030555089935660362, 0.015970099717378616, -0.04896575212478638, 0.0638575479388237, -0.03577793762087822, 0.005228535272181034, -0.003418876323848963, 0.03918159380555153, 0.03527824208140373, -0.02589469961822033, 0.03871306777000427, -0.007211756426841021, 0.01774006523191929, -0.048209596425294876, -0.030868928879499435, -0.0494631864130497, -0.018511289730668068, -0.03307955712080002, -0.023050794377923012, -0.03724556416273117, 0.002917531179264188, -0.025187445804476738, -0.020472684875130653, 0.028040630742907524, -0.003369481535628438, 0.0715632438659668, -0.02412254735827446, 0.06598134338855743, 0.019904423505067825, -0.03467462584376335, 0.024609044194221497, 0.01869848743081093, 0.05306301265954971, 0.021298587322235107, 0.029000675305724144, 0.046416036784648895, 0.026032840833067894, 0.036878008395433426, -0.0374477319419384, -0.05074814707040787, 0.031850919127464294, -0.0009216028265655041, -0.006769783794879913, 0.054304782301187515, 0.024582836776971817, 0.040305763483047485, -0.039753299206495285, 0.026001518592238426, -0.025354625657200813, 0.0002893566561397165, 0.01812400482594967, 0.033123403787612915, 0.07222200185060501, -0.040566351264715195, 0.04839378595352173, 0.012438979931175709, -0.017490098252892494, 0.012387190945446491, -0.04275890067219734, 0.024287741631269455, -0.04447520524263382, -0.008715701289474964, 0.01927848346531391, 0.0025316858664155006, -0.011326774954795837, -0.05516641214489937, -0.00776964146643877, 0.0044923326931893826, -0.006643833126872778, 0.006668520160019398, 0.032284773886203766, 0.030473604798316956, -0.025498174130916595, -0.051300372928380966, 0.027088481932878494, -0.033810101449489594, -0.010771490633487701, -0.010681773535907269, 0.038913652300834656, -0.012518827803432941, 0.02316899783909321, -0.029571818187832832, -0.02996404469013214, -0.014687225222587585, -0.01735152304172516, 0.016503416001796722, -0.017709238454699516, -0.009153698571026325, 0.02479902096092701, -0.04516422376036644, -0.028097176924347878, -0.03309701755642891, 0.007798400707542896, -0.012138132005929947, -0.03616422787308693, 0.03845622017979622, 0.04282614588737488, -0.008614243939518929, 0.01696557179093361, 0.0687917172908783, -0.012770984321832657, 0.0011677953880280256, 0.021714694797992706, 0.042583294212818146, 0.029084092006087303, 0.02054130658507347, 0.0026228027418255806, 0.018892550840973854, 0.053404565900564194, -0.041903622448444366, -0.04449739679694176, -0.03145584091544151, -0.04673287644982338, -0.08458992093801498, 0.005976451560854912, -0.06303797662258148, -0.0022750357165932655, 0.0069345892407000065, -0.024066496640443802, -0.04713725298643112, -0.03233199194073677, -0.03257926180958748, -0.008198411203920841, -0.05874666944146156, -0.043859515339136124, -0.01162407360970974, 0.008384314365684986, -0.04604588449001312, 0.06440209597349167, 0.007031809072941542, 0.039640944451093674, -0.04072413221001625, -0.028658710420131683, 0.043332163244485855, 0.00643586553633213, -0.0497509241104126, -0.014976452104747295, -0.014187084510922432, -0.014586308039724827, 0.043246250599622726, 0.020989542827010155, -0.029407411813735962, -0.02091580256819725, -0.11091230809688568, 0.016194509342312813, -0.020518766716122627, -0.0046800714917480946, 0.020015869289636612, -0.0018431823700666428, 0.015301178209483624, -0.03101055882871151, -0.039241496473550797, -0.016412999480962753, 0.003881022334098816, 0.036211565136909485, 0.06502030789852142, 0.008969681337475777, 0.02940461039543152, -0.033654212951660156, -0.033639632165431976, -0.034860849380493164, 0.048365816473960876, 0.03298819065093994, -0.028458191081881523, -0.014791881665587425, 0.012631156481802464, -0.04274211451411247, -0.005699328146874905, 0.0008375122561119497, -0.006959180347621441, 0.013510365970432758, 7.39570168661885e-05, 0.03907552734017372, 0.040819842368364334, 0.008406774140894413, 0.004677690099924803, 0.06182922050356865, 0.021323267370462418, -0.04460929334163666, 0.03831171244382858, -0.03609594330191612, 0.04528983309864998, 0.019213272258639336, -0.03887997940182686, 0.02870982140302658, -0.005066519603133202, 0.04023982957005501, -0.04627707973122597, -0.042216360569000244, -0.004063241649419069, 0.006213245447725058, -0.00033013071515597403, -0.07032578438520432, -0.045127443969249725, 0.03187573701143265, 0.04189159721136093, -0.021870359778404236, -0.03001910075545311, 0.0903407409787178, -0.015021313913166523, 0.006131467409431934, -0.08503077179193497, -0.073921799659729, -0.04457734152674675, 0.08074133843183517, -0.006110601592808962, 0.016518080607056618, 0.026035116985440254, -0.00016170904564205557, -0.012349242344498634, 0.0015946021303534508, 0.01476430892944336, -0.031285516917705536, 0.04835789278149605, -9.039550059242174e-05, 0.011051084846258163, -0.016078531742095947, -0.003352666739374399, -0.017321251332759857, -0.0456821583211422, -0.005768787115812302, -0.018904702737927437, -0.030499285086989403, 0.009093422442674637, -0.042779237031936646, -0.004889544565230608, 0.017922282218933105, 0.007686440367251635, -0.030051788315176964, -0.03101586550474167, -0.011520893312990665, -0.004569166339933872, 0.06932596117258072, 0.03026673197746277, -0.02292012982070446, 0.005033715162426233, 0.0024590417742729187, 0.025578698143363, -0.06147634610533714, -0.0021784352138638496, -0.02818697690963745, -0.010852488689124584, 0.004271219484508038, -0.027683407068252563, -0.02083653211593628, -0.014290260151028633, 0.016901863738894463, -0.053087398409843445, 0.0017813134472817183, 0.07139495760202408, 0.025693340227007866, -0.054342132061719894, -0.011482452042400837, -0.04610753431916237, -0.01285987813025713, 0.021547913551330566, 0.019845856353640556, -0.06977290660142899, -0.03619813919067383, 0.012737957760691643, -0.015132220461964607, -0.01645214483141899, -0.014718510210514069, -0.03697345405817032, -0.05704034864902496, 0.019185863435268402, -0.041095051914453506, 0.005659786053001881, -0.051583558320999146, -0.0456930547952652, 0.002081670332700014, 0.0037912263069301844, 0.02737458422780037, -0.0007656434900127351, 0.0049082026816904545, 0.02615884318947792, -0.0151609992608428, -0.016017146408557892, -0.011854526586830616, 0.025531139224767685, -0.056853439658880234, 0.012359020300209522, 0.022149628028273582, 0.0483868382871151, 0.0059765297919511795, -0.00925075076520443, -0.033892933279275894, -0.04696884751319885, -0.028957217931747437, -0.02145935222506523, 0.05240240320563316, -0.035482876002788544, 0.03658122196793556, -0.05965485796332359, 0.02758333832025528, -0.045694220811128616, 0.011717882938683033, 0.061024293303489685, 0.06288234889507294, -0.03378326818346977, -0.0023901192471385, -0.07939399033784866, 0.04176544025540352, -0.011366819031536579, 0.07147616893053055, 0.005708032753318548, 0.0024219187907874584, -0.004975431133061647, 0.0008961681742221117, -0.003708550473675132, -0.012706253677606583, -0.011130992323160172, 0.00498294597491622, -0.020930271595716476, 0.021623026579618454, -0.08005192130804062, -0.04965377226471901, 0.0002725910453591496, 0.031890660524368286, -0.0029529458843171597, 0.04794444888830185, -0.021092329174280167, -0.038586344569921494, -0.043382927775382996, 0.005732967983931303, -0.0014760755002498627, 0.021479276940226555, -0.006410886533558369, 0.09127070754766464, 0.01321991253644228, -0.004018183331936598, -0.04345586523413658, -0.03470428287982941, -0.0028440009336918592, -0.009809493087232113, -0.04518958926200867, -0.009965518489480019, 0.0010822268668562174, 0.025505470111966133, -0.053627923130989075, -0.031297944486141205, 0.01946958154439926, 0.030300524085760117, -0.018657783046364784, -0.004802454262971878, 0.05107896775007248, -0.00680138822644949, 0.003636304521933198, 0.03861120715737343, -0.04999922588467598, 0.04532843083143234, -0.004417142365127802, 0.025252968072891235, 0.0020992192439734936, -0.042844321578741074, 0.04996364936232567, 0.0034026019275188446, 0.05297384411096573, 0.04985344409942627, -0.014658943749964237, -0.04634823650121689, 0.019008928909897804, -0.0016125349793583155, -0.04554998129606247, -0.030571382492780685, 0.048943523317575455, 0.025289272889494896, -0.0023942207917571068, -0.016964590176939964, -0.029507074505090714, -0.011783961206674576, 0.02911190316081047, -0.01909647136926651, 0.014562135562300682, 0.017046231776475906, 0.048164598643779755, -0.05675281211733818, -0.014721834100782871, -0.04798431694507599, -0.0020353745203465223, -0.01633046567440033, 0.025732234120368958, -0.029982326552271843, 0.0209953635931015, 0.03864498436450958, 0.005044236779212952, 0.001398045802488923, 0.014479129575192928, -0.07278624922037125, 0.05343029275536537, -0.024420764297246933, 0.0045975735411047935, 0.035292670130729675, -0.018096936866641045, -0.017760446295142174, -0.0027766714338213205, 0.021320797502994537, 0.011870373971760273, 0.05346149578690529, -0.015841467306017876, -0.011698161251842976, 0.06186598166823387, -0.005202670115977526, -0.03025243990123272, -0.003255089744925499, 0.019050322473049164, -0.013281796127557755, 0.02805616706609726, 0.031634096056222916, -0.06287005543708801, -0.024794671684503555, -0.044420503079891205, 0.037464484572410583, 0.08191514015197754, -0.03715146332979202, 0.03969408944249153, 0.009361699223518372, -0.018536411225795746, -0.012170614674687386, 0.03193921595811844, -0.01747439242899418, 0.017235204577445984, 0.004251786973327398, 0.0452018603682518, 0.04039868339896202, -0.046874865889549255, -0.03592419996857643, 0.019094085320830345, -0.01872287690639496, -0.019621528685092926, -0.03435748070478439, -6.0646706988478254e-33, -0.031045693904161453, -0.007764378562569618, 0.009306821972131729, -0.045642103999853134, -0.0002529905759729445, 0.03429039567708969, -0.02027057483792305, -0.04782159626483917, -0.09552237391471863, 0.04157477617263794, 0.012420189566910267, 0.05748233199119568, -0.002826885087415576, 0.016398554667830467, 0.019353821873664856, -0.000813749385997653, -0.007340777665376663, 0.03667668253183365, 0.013670849613845348, 0.020898917689919472, 0.06736071407794952, 0.01403145119547844, 0.054041147232055664, -0.06263551861047745, 0.051153551787137985, -0.017159491777420044, -0.016235770657658577, 0.04084159806370735, -0.040182437747716904, 0.03753770887851715, -0.022803550586104393, 0.03760046511888504, 0.06491009145975113, 0.003237453056499362, 0.026136983186006546, 0.053116172552108765, -0.10097409039735794, -0.09870871156454086, 0.0285356305539608, -0.05937448516488075, -0.0754011794924736, -0.0023303551133722067, 0.023051241412758827, -0.004438730888068676, 0.03530992195010185, 0.003188104135915637, 0.0808284729719162, 0.0037271950859576464, -0.010133042931556702, -0.04535767808556557, -0.07997306436300278, 0.01493861898779869, 0.0104998629540205, -0.0005010173772461712, -0.04586007446050644, 0.08261941373348236, 0.01606314815580845, 0.0456668883562088, -0.04570038616657257, 0.005132848862558603, -0.05837658792734146, 0.015797017142176628, -0.010021868161857128, -0.029567932710051537, -0.026539670303463936, 0.04891908913850784, -0.0555168017745018, -0.051286470144987106, -0.04306131601333618, -0.02572094090282917, 0.04364602267742157, 0.036198634654283524, 0.06280621886253357, 0.050437044352293015, 0.06822420656681061, 0.031253714114427567, -0.09277965128421783, 0.03495754674077034, 0.015694282948970795, 0.04508162662386894, 0.030139967799186707, -0.009035967290401459, -0.06097962334752083, -0.020704345777630806, -0.028911396861076355, 0.02728794701397419, -0.04026335850358009, -0.017077598720788956, 0.01895054429769516, 0.002751956693828106, -0.02370922826230526, -0.003612323198467493, 0.000602740328758955, -0.05381942540407181, 0.028625011444091797, 0.045851271599531174, -0.006045212969183922, -0.03349272906780243, 0.03182540461421013, 0.0701482817530632, -0.050166331231594086, 0.007991221733391285, 0.023551154881715775, 0.004651927854865789, -0.013751288875937462, -0.00708966376259923, 0.09825611114501953, -0.027440160512924194, -0.010153635405004025, -0.036780159920454025, 0.017446208745241165, -0.023183465003967285, -0.052892811596393585, 0.011761236004531384, 0.014062130823731422, 0.056647930294275284, -0.004417646676301956, 0.0465753898024559, 0.031678277999162674, 0.004457677714526653, -0.056448373943567276, -0.0607096366584301, 0.010523021221160889, 0.016132939606904984, -0.01501234620809555, 0.01863672211766243, -0.040967658162117004, 0.011863460764288902, 0.007024751976132393, -0.054190173745155334, 0.0024619444739073515, 0.04367249831557274, 2.5249065060961584e-07, 0.065615214407444, -0.003107381984591484, 0.002252526581287384, -7.233225187519565e-05, -0.03325944393873215, 0.03246493265032768, 0.023053327575325966, 0.05481354519724846, 0.0027322859968990088, 0.016545481979846954, 0.03932210057973862, 0.029139047488570213, 0.013674723915755749, 0.015909284353256226, -0.029232652857899666, -0.018492192029953003, -0.08492401242256165, -0.06557801365852356, -0.044371552765369415, 0.013435328379273415, 0.11986662447452545, 0.08585187792778015, 0.05852989852428436, -0.017845595255494118, -0.002430801512673497, -0.07748693227767944, 0.006857961881905794, -0.018494553864002228, 0.02605699561536312, 0.004434733185917139, 0.012472915463149548, 0.031104005873203278, 0.015040552243590355, 0.03266407176852226, 0.01412863191217184, 0.057512152940034866, -0.0040602614171803, 0.0347258523106575, 0.002324986970052123, 0.017302123829722404, -0.021734079346060753, -0.002114960690960288, 0.033452387899160385, -0.06732190400362015, 0.11692188680171967, -0.04879886656999588, -0.030270960181951523, -0.04078788310289383, 0.01033825147897005, -0.020121335983276367, 0.07410669326782227, 0.006034362595528364, -0.02156452089548111, -0.020782383158802986, 0.035458434373140335, -0.02186831273138523, -0.015707900747656822, -0.09913968294858932, 0.002759236376732588, 0.038555797189474106, -0.030955202877521515, 0.025717418640851974, -0.0320252887904644, -0.015838298946619034, 0.05009128153324127, -0.08566990494728088, -0.0038718562573194504, 2.6909444229672653e-34, 0.021145392209291458, -0.03443676605820656, 0.009334652684628963, -0.032522089779376984, 0.027288727462291718, 0.037294309586286545, -0.0453278087079525, 0.00552258500829339, 0.03166072443127632, -0.09235657751560211, -0.00871990155428648]
611
611
['Xiaodong Gu', 'Hongyu Zhang', 'Dongmei Zhang', 'Sunghun Kim']
1605.08535v3
Developers often wonder how to implement a certain functionality (e.g., how to parse XML files) using APIs. Obtaining an API usage sequence based on an API-related natural language query is very helpful in this regard. Given a query, existing approaches utilize information retrieval models to search for matching API sequences. These approaches treat queries and APIs as bag-of-words (i.e., keyword matching or word-to-word alignment) and lack a deep understanding of the semantics of the query. We propose DeepAPI, a deep learning based approach to generate API usage sequences for a given natural language query. Instead of a bags-of-words assumption, it learns the sequence of words in a query and the sequence of associated APIs. DeepAPI adapts a neural language model named RNN Encoder-Decoder. It encodes a word sequence (user query) into a fixed-length context vector, and generates an API sequence based on the context vector. We also augment the RNN Encoder-Decoder by considering the importance of individual APIs. We empirically evaluate our approach with more than 7 million annotated code snippets collected from GitHub. The results show that our approach generates largely accurate API sequences and outperforms the related approaches.
Deep API Learning
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1605.08535v3
Title Deep API Learning Summary Developers often wonder implement certain functionality eg parse XML file using APIs Obtaining API usage sequence based APIrelated natural language query helpful regard Given query existing approach utilize information retrieval model search matching API sequence approach treat query APIs bagofwords ie keyword matching wordtoword alignment lack deep understanding semantics query propose DeepAPI deep learning based approach generate API usage sequence given natural language query Instead bagsofwords assumption learns sequence word query sequence associated APIs DeepAPI adapts neural language model named RNN EncoderDecoder encodes word sequence user query fixedlength context vector generates API sequence based context vector also augment RNN EncoderDecoder considering importance individual APIs empirically evaluate approach 7 million annotated code snippet collected GitHub result show approach generates largely accurate API sequence outperforms related approach Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.022035649046301842, 0.08039530366659164, -0.022920427843928337, 0.05839980021119118, -0.023591330274939537, -0.025041567161679268, -0.018716687336564064, 0.004967098589986563, 0.017906080931425095, -0.03410175442695618, 0.015619850717484951, 0.014092438854277134, 0.019767960533499718, 0.09026051312685013, 0.00809093751013279, -0.029618408530950546, 0.02686324343085289, 0.022160092368721962, 0.028574297204613686, 0.04676632583141327, -0.006205743178725243, 0.0231785885989666, 0.0011919037206098437, 0.07382648438215256, 0.013242696411907673, -0.030732223764061928, -0.013543633744120598, -0.02011832408607006, -0.031664006412029266, -0.05675055459141731, 0.0297867339104414, 0.008916952647268772, 0.0175943486392498, 0.05066949501633644, 2.082985247398028e-06, -0.03347163274884224, -0.018307693302631378, 0.021017232909798622, -0.0075560701079666615, -0.05186420679092407, 0.006850735284388065, 0.012495582923293114, 0.040222618728876114, 0.0324508436024189, -0.05351243540644646, -0.059931375086307526, 0.05269080400466919, 0.011367241851985455, 0.07164140045642853, 0.037472113966941833, 0.001191645278595388, -0.0958012267947197, 0.025127382948994637, -0.009550525806844234, -0.003044176148250699, -0.03942740336060524, 0.012527693063020706, -0.045080747455358505, 0.03627537563443184, 0.026927119120955467, 0.005048802588135004, -0.0011326671810820699, 0.02666109800338745, 0.0036049974150955677, 0.025056365877389908, 0.024182507768273354, -0.06597916036844254, -0.0507262758910656, 0.009138909168541431, 0.06277390569448471, -0.023221634328365326, 0.013182070106267929, 0.023984793573617935, 0.0018073453102260828, -0.02787003666162491, -0.06639225035905838, -0.029104990884661674, -0.006459854543209076, 0.018764518201351166, -0.004481767304241657, 0.008246934041380882, 0.019825497642159462, 0.012331340461969376, -0.007251369301229715, 0.004134004935622215, 0.030352184548974037, -0.0011092796921730042, -0.007056753151118755, 0.0024265155661851168, -0.035246364772319794, 0.03503601253032684, -0.05006161704659462, 0.012456903234124184, 0.04218348115682602, -0.018407674506306648, 0.013728399761021137, -0.02369828149676323, -0.0854930579662323, 0.033375997096300125, -0.02780376933515072, 0.015791451558470726, 0.005755110643804073, -0.04716964438557625, 0.006146454717963934, -0.0033839920070022345, 0.03342821076512337, 0.0010810724925249815, 0.005691442638635635, -0.012442924082279205, -0.017648473381996155, -0.06097001954913139, -0.02775287628173828, -0.034382570534944534, 0.10405788570642471, -0.044473301619291306, -0.01360104139894247, -0.04451758414506912, 0.01429880503565073, 0.00720010744407773, 0.009374537505209446, -0.031217586249113083, 0.03851025179028511, -0.048359815031290054, 0.004805309697985649, -0.03713502734899521, 0.01605209894478321, -0.015713423490524292, -0.010187185369431973, 0.018363194540143013, -0.05010216683149338, 0.032495856285095215, -0.011320289224386215, 0.02107326313853264, 0.013033052906394005, 0.01665695756673813, 0.090471550822258, 0.021425552666187286, -0.00579936383292079, -0.06551790237426758, -0.03316850587725639, 0.06544099748134613, 0.00230652978643775, -0.015328370034694672, -0.08564508706331253, 0.017289893701672554, -0.02325931377708912, -0.04861368611454964, -0.013433589600026608, -0.007870558649301529, 0.03138669952750206, -0.034309886395931244, 0.06350009143352509, -0.041662849485874176, -0.0008622661116532981, 0.06943640112876892, 0.02609396167099476, 0.04598908871412277, 0.053745292127132416, 0.02381359599530697, 0.03132075443863869, 0.041931863874197006, -0.00409144489094615, 0.012485412880778313, -0.006294777151197195, -0.02839626371860504, -0.035539817065000534, 0.011222455650568008, 0.017282281070947647, 0.0015882247826084495, 0.052090421319007874, -0.01350697223097086, 0.02691764198243618, 0.013221021741628647, -0.017648419365286827, -0.011970022693276405, 0.0958319753408432, 0.042937420308589935, 0.031214475631713867, 0.04028080776333809, 0.023505108430981636, -0.007902123965322971, -0.0543670691549778, -0.03461312875151634, 0.03428100422024727, 0.020826134830713272, -0.009261400438845158, 0.004190610721707344, 0.015766823664307594, -0.02093847095966339, -0.0639173835515976, 0.03880847617983818, -0.046162452548742294, -0.04041430354118347, -0.02145719714462757, 0.019090628251433372, 0.025692762807011604, -0.03561871498823166, -0.021755000576376915, 0.005110303871333599, 0.008985508233308792, 0.00683988444507122, -0.04434431716799736, -0.01974189467728138, 0.020310407504439354, 0.03545983135700226, -0.07149302214384079, -0.03834749013185501, -0.001996705075725913, -0.032344311475753784, 0.04100560396909714, 0.0018729025032371283, -0.02081887051463127, 0.037868380546569824, -0.047816161066293716, 0.0063295383006334305, -0.0004137669166084379, 0.00045048585161566734, 0.010407155379652977, -0.017541011795401573, 0.03583367168903351, 0.022791927680373192, 0.0019124379614368081, -0.04207294061779976, 0.046716298907995224, -0.024192729964852333, -0.04895268380641937, 0.04874958097934723, 0.032459814101457596, 0.005651077255606651, 0.03176138177514076, 0.01731943152844906, 0.021400216966867447, 0.024432580918073654, -0.03435750678181648, -0.025883816182613373, -0.010898769833147526, -0.039983972907066345, 0.0028453662525862455, 0.017541026696562767, -0.018810443580150604, -0.013642426580190659, 0.08737202733755112, -0.044570039957761765, -0.024837268516421318, 0.029584798961877823, -0.029345788061618805, 0.042344946414232254, 0.030623435974121094, 0.004333640448749065, 0.0036830862518399954, 0.026386503130197525, -0.02200189419090748, 0.02205691672861576, 0.009494435973465443, 0.025773804634809494, -0.038251642137765884, 0.041213538497686386, 0.024561868980526924, 0.017750563099980354, -0.03408186882734299, 0.040128983557224274, -0.04997028410434723, 0.0397314727306366, 0.023882735520601273, 0.04028867557644844, -0.03979675471782684, 0.018609745427966118, -0.060624636709690094, 0.024314716458320618, -0.0015149143291637301, -0.0005654628039337695, 0.0019986960105597973, 0.06568552553653717, 0.024012019857764244, -0.038107287138700485, -0.0627688467502594, 0.01382081676274538, -0.015735458582639694, 0.015028124675154686, 0.06105632334947586, 0.033885106444358826, -0.040232423692941666, -0.03726829215884209, -0.019944431260228157, -0.04139770567417145, 0.04666175693273544, 0.009462584741413593, -0.028141770511865616, -0.007265066262334585, -0.042527224868535995, -0.012440302409231663, 0.03988652676343918, -0.004614876117557287, -0.058485183864831924, -0.003228838322684169, -0.030741499736905098, -0.0380089171230793, 0.04095446318387985, -0.014852709136903286, 0.019319575279951096, -0.003926883451640606, 0.03424167260527611, -0.023479407653212547, 0.018783656880259514, -0.004305840004235506, -0.005647244863212109, 0.025999542325735092, 0.01947666145861149, 0.05279626324772835, 0.04745898395776749, -0.002974351868033409, 0.012649220414459705, -0.024278223514556885, -0.001904594129882753, -0.011620775796473026, -0.0003241341619286686, 0.01045063603669405, -0.0030403113923966885, -0.00634099543094635, 0.03693588078022003, -0.012931717559695244, -0.05120880529284477, 0.06813035160303116, 0.0030673586297780275, -0.02014000341296196, -0.09605026245117188, -0.05164201557636261, -0.02861853875219822, 0.09384377300739288, 0.007992553524672985, 0.038775213062763214, -0.009847952052950859, -0.0750989019870758, -0.021008439362049103, -0.012494043447077274, -0.04937200993299484, -0.046914439648389816, 0.0696151927113533, -0.034863486886024475, 0.0077917068265378475, -0.018651777878403664, -0.021044796332716942, -0.03909199312329292, 0.007247693836688995, -0.02397097460925579, 0.027501920238137245, -0.0008076803642325103, -0.013914133422076702, 0.0017147980397567153, -0.019926713779568672, -0.0036012756172567606, 0.0715959370136261, 0.01706075854599476, -0.029109345749020576, -0.010815126821398735, -0.011777659878134727, 0.048652924597263336, -0.008746189065277576, -0.05413148179650307, 0.09361015260219574, -0.003063569311052561, -0.007862554863095284, 0.017970789223909378, 0.0011050536995753646, -0.10312692821025848, 0.0048523941077291965, 0.011079946532845497, -0.07470279186964035, -0.031219912692904472, 0.051313892006874084, -0.03437386453151703, -0.05738956481218338, -0.021563829854130745, 0.04373522847890854, 0.03284443914890289, -0.07111793011426926, -0.008331052027642727, -0.018771208822727203, -0.021750835701823235, 0.04648302122950554, 0.041688933968544006, -0.07159464061260223, -0.03357439488172531, -0.024600915610790253, 0.0266782995313406, 0.00344859529286623, -0.03682713583111763, -0.021087372675538063, -0.11640380322933197, 0.013935918919742107, -0.04383525624871254, -0.07456555217504501, -0.04664068669080734, -0.05561976507306099, -0.011617857031524181, 0.010335817001760006, -0.020680835470557213, 0.017048802226781845, 0.015128765255212784, -0.01784401759505272, 0.008475103415548801, -0.07366621494293213, -0.017293516546487808, 0.024234119802713394, -0.06814000755548477, 0.017819294705986977, 0.0943540558218956, 0.054696619510650635, -0.0199960358440876, -0.02203936129808426, 0.028485549613833427, -0.013906916603446007, -0.01882115937769413, -0.03352055698633194, 0.039076682180166245, -0.02832818403840065, -0.02523707039654255, 0.020794875919818878, 0.025461046025156975, -0.07510426640510559, 0.018144072964787483, -0.02665974199771881, 0.07022448629140854, -0.03964325040578842, 0.04916750639677048, -0.08781769126653671, -0.0028372686356306076, 0.0410393662750721, -0.009167205542325974, 0.019623925909399986, -0.011437684297561646, -0.04676300659775734, -0.018993372097611427, 0.02097524143755436, -0.06671667098999023, -0.011990169994533062, 0.011809248477220535, -0.03410355746746063, -0.047597017139196396, -0.08168232440948486, -0.011386556550860405, -0.008301292546093464, 0.04236568138003349, 0.03286192566156387, 0.038328807801008224, 0.04898704215884209, 0.015664847567677498, -0.07571680098772049, -0.029400469735264778, 0.007233842276036739, -0.001562558813020587, -0.010321454145014286, -0.020613696426153183, 0.08637365698814392, 0.034504301846027374, -0.030091499909758568, 0.008476942777633667, -0.025698347017169, -0.0531347431242466, 0.004789833910763264, 0.05077594146132469, 0.020907357335090637, 0.01640155352652073, -0.035401295870542526, -0.05751324072480202, -0.04916498810052872, 0.09443473815917969, -0.017927778884768486, -0.05150904506444931, 0.010417522862553596, 0.025294143706560135, -0.004049456212669611, 0.025387810543179512, -0.08453600108623505, -0.0094391368329525, -0.039837177842855453, -0.022171007469296455, 0.02070109359920025, -0.008007621392607689, 0.021815083920955658, 0.04453219100832939, 0.01123792864382267, 0.03322418034076691, -0.003142384812235832, -0.019152861088514328, 0.0035509944427758455, 0.009365219622850418, -0.028673632070422173, -0.03275439515709877, 0.00832695234566927, -0.0021362232510000467, 0.006245679687708616, 0.042244818061590195, -0.0010276292450726032, 0.0236689243465662, 0.009819709695875645, 0.024802464991807938, 0.05140332505106926, 0.0074935294687747955, 0.056383755058050156, -0.012985123321413994, -0.004991941154003143, -0.032506830990314484, -0.04412027820944786, -0.006706991698592901, 0.06980115175247192, -0.07739701122045517, -0.007715468294918537, 0.0066035049967467785, 0.03110533021390438, -0.027308620512485504, 0.026543065905570984, -0.014598299749195576, -0.0841132178902626, 0.0013576287310570478, -0.024434130638837814, 0.004473057575523853, -0.052033744752407074, -0.04452036693692207, -0.009224098175764084, 0.04664919525384903, -0.001733414945192635, 0.06526999920606613, -0.023003755137324333, 0.0002644109190441668, 0.010779098607599735, 0.004278157837688923, -0.0209590345621109, -0.04911044239997864, 0.08853617310523987, -0.00953260250389576, -0.0024727561976760626, 0.013772792182862759, -0.017698010429739952, -0.047236956655979156, -0.00987919420003891, 0.06481128185987473, 0.024168211966753006, -0.03051433525979519, -0.02419857680797577, 0.004218957386910915, -0.021941056475043297, 0.018228832632303238, -0.00467600766569376, 0.03431146964430809, 0.033628806471824646, 0.03437473997473717, 0.09788981080055237, 0.05954062193632126, -0.03219727799296379, -0.036851827055215836, 0.005312713328748941, -0.04684195667505264, -0.04149096831679344, -0.016545496881008148, -5.76801082218882e-33, -0.011123054660856724, -0.016642604023218155, 0.012957426719367504, 0.008075171150267124, -0.03266113996505737, -0.0008777679759077728, -0.0240777600556612, -0.020194191485643387, -0.017293812707066536, -0.037694986909627914, -0.0014401189982891083, 0.00036067728069610894, 0.012008358724415302, 0.03499896451830864, 0.045040201395750046, -0.02533729188144207, -0.010743052698671818, 0.012652154080569744, 0.02540031634271145, 0.036195527762174606, 0.0002880317042581737, 0.02623545378446579, 0.030063582584261894, -0.059451304376125336, -0.02359456941485405, 0.011847435496747494, 0.07661967724561691, 0.01608223095536232, 0.032796118408441544, 0.03492628037929535, 0.003953577019274235, 0.023107970133423805, 0.041907668113708496, -0.029271181672811508, -0.0088828569278121, 0.03663426637649536, -0.06245163083076477, -0.06322801113128662, -0.0022407176438719034, 0.04154593497514725, -0.04275846853852272, -0.004480072297155857, 0.09021899849176407, 0.0012778507079929113, 0.026977727189660072, 0.02132539078593254, 0.06256251037120819, -0.008542163297533989, -0.03733723983168602, -0.01758156344294548, -0.054167307913303375, -0.002794562606140971, -0.019200831651687622, 0.021325351670384407, -0.0027794199995696545, -0.005186784081161022, 0.016453344374895096, 0.053333934396505356, -0.0779593214392662, -0.035384245216846466, -0.01798339933156967, 0.07246115058660507, 0.023479513823986053, 0.04705999419093132, 0.022284775972366333, 0.03334544971585274, 0.016953447833657265, -0.000918846286367625, 0.020052025094628334, 0.04945070669054985, 0.053181178867816925, 0.05791241675615311, 0.005636621732264757, 0.012736876495182514, 0.0496184416115284, -0.027627883478999138, -0.04299572482705116, 0.04040718078613281, -0.022463016211986542, 0.02365741692483425, -0.0033654856961220503, 0.03627607598900795, -0.01843584142625332, 0.002878042869269848, -0.007182657718658447, -0.012094556353986263, -0.033847369253635406, 0.009731783531606197, -0.0021336479112505913, 0.002846278017386794, 0.02411271072924137, 0.04765169322490692, 0.0051173316314816475, -0.04884429648518562, 0.02145969495177269, -0.0028674413915723562, -0.0030719179194420576, 0.019706500694155693, -0.011215228587388992, 0.013023623265326023, -0.024121379479765892, -0.02888922020792961, -0.048321839421987534, 0.03141847625374794, 0.06161109358072281, -0.0002683345228433609, 0.019239161163568497, 0.001781048602424562, -0.04755156487226486, -0.008800888434052467, -0.026306524872779846, -0.010309896431863308, 0.005357056390494108, 0.04353638365864754, -0.008271780796349049, -0.008868629112839699, 0.0027265201788395643, 0.08052708208560944, 0.016563035547733307, 0.0029427618719637394, -0.03822819143533707, -0.0072864084504544735, 0.016727866604924202, -0.010889889672398567, -0.06603404134511948, -0.022728046402335167, -0.04368308559060097, 0.020432764664292336, 0.042912114411592484, -0.031515564769506454, -0.026088736951351166, 0.027346372604370117, 2.7104897526442073e-07, -0.0009600597550161183, -0.0018597673624753952, 0.06305462121963501, 0.006696848198771477, -0.0038944780826568604, 0.04778369516134262, 0.014085623435676098, 0.04222279414534569, -0.04232940822839737, -0.01806383579969406, -0.01245458796620369, -0.04346063733100891, 0.022707294672727585, 0.018118778243660927, -0.10482680052518845, 0.0040321652777493, -0.03619604930281639, 0.01805097609758377, -0.08628148585557938, -0.0024711848236620426, 0.06581200659275055, 0.09419065713882446, 0.030244916677474976, -0.021172137930989265, -0.005177437327802181, -0.04705626145005226, -0.023398075252771378, 0.04790985956788063, 0.045597583055496216, 0.05438477173447609, -0.02030021697282791, 0.09202978760004044, 0.0017018902581185102, -0.04052527993917465, -0.05714584141969681, -0.014513744972646236, 0.017264744266867638, 0.04619455710053444, -0.029943017289042473, -0.0018611998530104756, 0.033840812742710114, -0.030724992975592613, 0.004820073489099741, -0.031169338151812553, 0.022311056032776833, -0.032564397901296616, -0.04293783754110336, -0.008229043334722519, -0.00023202273587230593, 0.0112437903881073, -0.007941333577036858, -0.006450667046010494, 0.005819872487336397, 0.003942816983908415, 0.03220764175057411, -0.06668262928724289, -0.015483669936656952, -0.08304161578416824, 0.008313050493597984, 0.03809240832924843, 0.0015361260157078505, 0.032867349684238434, -0.04785829409956932, -0.02361764758825302, 0.02761130966246128, -0.005694378633052111, 0.014053751714527607, 2.707229611500962e-34, -0.020834367722272873, -0.01503844279795885, 0.011069459840655327, 0.05254471302032471, 0.01172587275505066, -0.001490419963374734, 0.04575055465102196, 0.03920497000217438, -0.0037063942290842533, -0.005882419180124998, -0.014693318866193295]
612
612
['Ozan Caglayan', 'Walid Aransa', 'Yaxing Wang', 'Marc Masana', 'Mercedes García-Martínez', 'Fethi Bougares', 'Loïc Barrault', 'Joost van de Weijer']
1605.09186v4
This paper presents the systems developed by LIUM and CVC for the WMT16 Multimodal Machine Translation challenge. We explored various comparative methods, namely phrase-based systems and attentional recurrent neural networks models trained using monomodal or multimodal data. We also performed a human evaluation in order to estimate the usefulness of multimodal data for human machine translation and image description generation. Our systems obtained the best results for both tasks according to the automatic evaluation metrics BLEU and METEOR.
Does Multimodality Help Human and Machine for Translation and Image Captioning?
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1605.09186v4
Title Multimodality Help Human Machine Translation Image Captioning Summary paper present system developed LIUM CVC WMT16 Multimodal Machine Translation challenge explored various comparative method namely phrasebased system attentional recurrent neural network model trained using monomodal multimodal data also performed human evaluation order estimate usefulness multimodal data human machine translation image description generation system obtained best result task according automatic evaluation metric BLEU METEOR Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.0539010725915432, 0.0076685454696416855, 0.01904091238975525, 0.06651923060417175, -0.01815539225935936, 0.015360726043581963, 0.03222649171948433, -0.017729010432958603, -0.015600577928125858, -0.06154349073767662, -0.04799551144242287, -0.04930960759520531, 0.044641319662332535, 0.01870400458574295, 0.05114663019776344, -0.12137944996356964, -0.008208474144339561, 0.014843277633190155, -0.05475116893649101, 0.013135846704244614, 0.03395809978246689, 0.001351851038634777, 0.002852005884051323, 0.04664399102330208, -0.01186451967805624, 0.0009665701072663069, -0.008108331821858883, 0.022291826084256172, -0.010236233472824097, -0.05419794097542763, -0.007955470122396946, 0.06352532655000687, 0.028880348429083824, 0.0075585427694022655, 2.4705423129489645e-06, -0.03537595272064209, 0.01678609289228916, -0.0035614504013210535, 0.09085781872272491, -0.056004758924245834, 0.0880112498998642, -0.057108595967292786, 0.011318858712911606, 0.010285957716405392, 0.012118509970605373, 0.020002884790301323, 0.05456124246120453, 0.07185572385787964, 0.07702138274908066, 0.01931505836546421, -0.022972216829657555, -0.0607546828687191, -0.020695706829428673, -0.008957887999713421, 0.008317057974636555, -0.024527840316295624, -0.03578329086303711, 0.0006938748992979527, -0.0035316557623445988, -0.010511908680200577, -0.03330199047923088, 0.05515812337398529, -0.021655229851603508, -0.002111918991431594, -0.016390124335885048, 0.034266069531440735, -0.016601737588644028, -0.04254497215151787, -0.018069108948111534, 0.11810072511434555, 0.02146287076175213, 0.045883361250162125, -0.03096400760114193, 0.027847379446029663, -0.018702706322073936, 0.000966580118983984, -0.04828963428735733, 0.09045597165822983, -0.024792097508907318, -0.018330896273255348, -0.0554940290749073, 0.05940352752804756, -0.0035781969781965017, 0.01826394908130169, 0.022492259740829468, -0.04437794163823128, 0.024842120707035065, 0.01595074124634266, -0.027245061472058296, -0.02726006507873535, -0.01832888461649418, -0.033159635961055756, 0.020816069096326828, 0.008204478770494461, 0.027338264510035515, 0.003976134583353996, -0.0363943912088871, -0.0748668760061264, 0.05193085968494415, -0.0861770287156105, 0.046343348920345306, 0.01834719628095627, -0.05561940371990204, 0.06796559691429138, -3.383947114343755e-05, 0.019940104335546494, -0.01737372763454914, 0.0249728225171566, -0.05291746184229851, 0.00668867863714695, -0.028919532895088196, 0.00784660130739212, -0.044427961111068726, 0.014969242736697197, -0.028721854090690613, -0.04136132076382637, -0.07180262356996536, 0.0047389911487698555, 0.01331281941384077, -0.011791182681918144, 0.0073116011917591095, 0.024004196748137474, -0.04984103888273239, -0.03157680854201317, -0.037087954580783844, 0.030233236029744148, 0.006422324106097221, -0.020968778058886528, -0.014895472675561905, -0.032284390181303024, 0.016623159870505333, 0.08445057272911072, -0.01242267619818449, -0.0006213629967533052, -0.04874832183122635, 0.07494509965181351, -0.00864133145660162, -0.023392362520098686, 0.012741482816636562, -0.029721662402153015, -0.045628178864717484, -0.03248574212193489, 0.018949037417769432, -0.02644151635468006, 0.07043717056512833, -0.00048010656610131264, -0.0020167557522654533, 0.00924341194331646, 0.01919492706656456, 0.03767954930663109, 0.014944309368729591, 0.11172167211771011, -0.03128737956285477, -0.0043077473528683186, 0.06519893556833267, 0.000821891357190907, 0.017464129254221916, 0.025423631072044373, 0.05224844440817833, 0.04967214912176132, 0.01503065973520279, -0.014838449656963348, 0.012885453179478645, 0.01084078848361969, -0.036099959164857864, -0.003997760359197855, -0.01160028763115406, -0.019626455381512642, 0.024413660168647766, 0.03764697536826134, 0.015210060402750969, 0.0763230174779892, 0.002016226528212428, 0.015073523856699467, 0.05334992706775665, 0.036658309400081635, -0.012498540803790092, 0.04007222130894661, 0.02662196196615696, 0.029176242649555206, -0.0008962591527961195, 0.015633007511496544, -0.008847041986882687, 0.08037448674440384, 0.0024730090517550707, 0.013949679210782051, 0.04549197107553482, 0.0182693749666214, -0.011675961315631866, -0.01994304358959198, -0.000779182359110564, -0.010433340445160866, 0.023494312539696693, -0.04198369383811951, 0.03662862628698349, 0.004576805047690868, -0.06956759840250015, 0.006742089055478573, 0.005342395044863224, -0.017323631793260574, -0.014223861508071423, -0.010477366857230663, -0.04953772574663162, 0.04444505646824837, 0.021845007315278053, 0.018277958035469055, 0.0034584880340844393, -0.04780033975839615, 0.05628092959523201, 0.041876453906297684, 0.025868048891425133, 0.02777203358709812, 0.0005413588951341808, -0.06780175864696503, -0.049065764993429184, -0.008785881102085114, -0.011982309632003307, 0.012265336699783802, -0.06571889668703079, -0.014519943855702877, 0.04768872633576393, 0.07029380649328232, -0.0682687982916832, 0.04007062315940857, 0.08234021812677383, -0.010957257822155952, 0.0048967148177325726, 0.032635752111673355, 0.01702478900551796, 0.013501820154488087, -0.010301683098077774, 0.020406294614076614, -0.008744393475353718, -0.008642161265015602, -0.012896141037344933, 0.08417962491512299, -0.03127200901508331, -0.036890048533678055, 0.006405073683708906, -0.0630188137292862, 0.010093946941196918, -0.000247646908974275, -0.015938792377710342, -0.05589383468031883, 0.020529543980956078, -0.06774366647005081, -0.01774892769753933, -0.049282561987638474, 0.04242753982543945, 0.02620525099337101, 0.061013057827949524, -0.01835593394935131, 0.02483087219297886, -0.045797888189554214, -0.0210654865950346, -0.014824438840150833, -0.020383790135383606, 0.014072185382246971, -0.03077390231192112, -0.0536201111972332, 0.010757297277450562, -0.007933206856250763, 0.05129758268594742, 0.0054286024533212185, 0.021412722766399384, -0.04192756488919258, -0.014668894000351429, -0.09587249904870987, -0.009047231636941433, -0.0025981988292187452, -0.015020967461168766, 0.010700345039367676, 0.006991250440478325, 0.027787411585450172, -0.02252805605530739, 0.005516418255865574, 0.025226471945643425, -0.0054111238569021225, 0.007120515685528517, 0.05632925033569336, 0.005516405683010817, 0.0460403673350811, -0.015310700982809067, -0.005992624443024397, -0.0031772314105182886, 0.0700918510556221, 0.06133347749710083, -0.07096061110496521, -0.023735200986266136, -0.030190739780664444, -0.023531291633844376, -0.03157953917980194, 0.02238968200981617, -0.05045691505074501, 0.005997832864522934, 0.018593477085232735, 0.05657786875963211, 0.025285933166742325, 0.024462776258587837, 0.007046069484204054, 0.009646768681704998, -0.000671920832246542, 0.012695863842964172, -0.0028350548818707466, 0.009983532130718231, -0.042299240827560425, 0.07150895148515701, -0.021407069638371468, 0.0044108242727816105, 0.01008713897317648, 0.02724929340183735, 0.05301877483725548, -0.028005503118038177, 0.012096703983843327, -0.01896807923913002, -0.0268934927880764, -0.05425051599740982, 0.0400950126349926, -0.02425612509250641, -0.022300152108073235, -0.015793105587363243, -0.03531776741147041, 0.007511112838983536, -0.014178121462464333, -0.026599928736686707, -0.026067735627293587, 0.0023315995931625366, -0.021612120792269707, 0.05999748781323433, -0.019941749051213264, 0.039803940802812576, 0.0012113323900848627, -0.016715312376618385, -0.007168559357523918, -0.020841293036937714, 0.01758292317390442, -0.008090679533779621, 0.029186947271227837, -0.04381042346358299, -0.009587070904672146, -0.057074323296546936, -0.016773993149399757, -0.008830533362925053, -0.005874847061932087, -0.020691782236099243, -0.02567226067185402, -0.01184928510338068, 0.027843642979860306, -0.029452422633767128, 0.06038479134440422, 0.050671014934778214, 0.0045889876782894135, -0.0284949392080307, -0.00965997576713562, -0.009075426496565342, 0.0423123724758625, 0.03154120594263077, 0.021440988406538963, -0.0740576833486557, -0.02798527665436268, 0.004004536662250757, -0.006480731535702944, -0.04856438189744949, 0.005506094545125961, -0.06040890887379646, -0.0005970997153781354, -0.008150584995746613, 0.016273293644189835, -0.02020391821861267, -0.009334525093436241, 0.06283809244632721, -0.05201854929327965, 0.06663816422224045, 0.04590892046689987, -0.004949986003339291, -0.06697521358728409, -0.021860376000404358, 0.013119413517415524, -0.04284403845667839, 0.01774750091135502, 0.008341128006577492, -0.03959483653306961, -0.0416690930724144, -0.02216041274368763, -0.000354600022546947, 0.031624604016542435, -0.011950335465371609, -0.060209982097148895, -0.003225295338779688, 0.03462270647287369, 0.0105062834918499, -0.06660710275173187, -0.053490050137043, 0.03410974517464638, -0.04777885600924492, 0.021654844284057617, -0.020537419244647026, 0.0004876200982835144, 0.02064419724047184, -0.028588226065039635, 0.012620173394680023, 0.01944645121693611, -0.0358077809214592, -0.019929630681872368, -0.05653718486428261, 0.0017088064923882484, 0.05423884093761444, 0.04306759685277939, -0.025648346170783043, -0.05504898726940155, 0.008561433292925358, 0.046523913741111755, 0.028489993885159492, -0.012088030576705933, 0.030267704278230667, -0.024881917983293533, -0.01974223181605339, -0.02125692181289196, 0.021458161994814873, 0.029032716527581215, 0.030410129576921463, 0.016370674595236778, 0.006875792983919382, -0.015132254920899868, 0.016465961933135986, -0.0742303654551506, 0.04513988271355629, 0.003022212302312255, 0.00039052084321156144, -0.006498518865555525, -0.06092539057135582, -0.013539109379053116, -0.02192135900259018, 0.0008937782840803266, -0.06746898591518402, 0.00914742425084114, 0.004938947502523661, -0.04822142794728279, -0.019187401980161667, -0.10398194938898087, -0.03670747950673103, 0.012068997137248516, 0.03906688466668129, 0.025755664333701134, -0.009325401857495308, 0.0017453719628974795, 0.0466528944671154, -0.05977776646614075, 0.02144349366426468, 0.0030666689854115248, 0.01685214973986149, -0.0350281186401844, 0.007241370156407356, 0.05931680649518967, -0.028598081320524216, 0.02812638133764267, 0.00977225974202156, -0.03738883510231972, 0.0030609318055212498, -0.050077229738235474, 0.05412253364920616, -0.0006271536112762988, -0.0025336523540318012, 0.013271824456751347, -0.07496489584445953, -0.023855140432715416, -0.008836880326271057, 0.037326451390981674, -0.019780756905674934, 0.0008677808218635619, 0.05356597900390625, -0.03474060818552971, 0.0008949325419962406, -0.015665436163544655, -0.01664132811129093, -0.024015771225094795, 0.014702044427394867, 0.020303091034293175, -0.05434378609061241, 0.0172564834356308, 0.004757123999297619, 0.002089951653033495, -0.057969167828559875, -0.0036739129573106766, -0.010406546294689178, -0.009213631972670555, 0.018631944432854652, -0.03759467601776123, -0.03606259822845459, 0.04195353016257286, 0.0013088943669572473, -0.013407605700194836, 0.016520624980330467, -0.03773116320371628, -0.006713770795613527, -0.04131857305765152, 0.05055304989218712, 0.05454583838582039, -0.009795748628675938, -0.016301864758133888, -0.05613972619175911, 0.026808656752109528, -0.03157508373260498, 0.01931913010776043, -0.020818250253796577, 0.016213810071349144, -0.006395431701093912, 0.07911735028028488, -0.014621442183852196, -0.0118446946144104, -0.008868101052939892, 0.06638742983341217, 0.07394994050264359, 0.062116555869579315, -0.08260790258646011, 0.0319148451089859, 0.07620203495025635, 0.00888743344694376, 0.01597062684595585, 0.015453878790140152, 0.0007083631935529411, -0.01323455385863781, 0.08052115887403488, -0.03556555137038231, -0.025796853005886078, 0.056617073714733124, -0.002951329341158271, 0.0017163495067507029, -0.02064439281821251, 0.031792666763067245, -0.0037698503583669662, -0.028513319790363312, 0.026282792910933495, -0.026007352396845818, -0.06628625094890594, 0.009701906703412533, 0.01070789247751236, -0.00045538175618276, -0.015808826312422752, 0.029935339465737343, -0.029096972197294235, -0.04656682536005974, 0.02128647267818451, 0.030710501596331596, 0.04087073728442192, 0.04255281016230583, 0.03968874737620354, 0.03269176185131073, 0.016677753999829292, -0.04173562303185463, -0.05576042830944061, 0.00016955695173237473, -0.006445301230996847, 0.0295255146920681, -0.0322832427918911, -6.543395916007987e-33, -0.020188141614198685, -0.05405972898006439, 0.005019708536565304, -0.058115798979997635, -0.03762427344918251, -0.023805921897292137, -0.04783859848976135, 0.04102481156587601, 0.022032493725419044, -0.00013739439600612968, 0.026933735236525536, -0.043594054877758026, 0.01405125018209219, 0.03875971585512161, 0.037022724747657776, 0.03393939882516861, -0.0012816613307222724, -0.011538137681782246, -0.015530870296061039, 0.004646976478397846, 0.011705959215760231, 0.01797354407608509, 0.07519406080245972, -0.08064386993646622, 0.014608613215386868, -0.019390590488910675, -0.03200441971421242, -0.010962271131575108, 0.049104638397693634, 0.004370835609734058, -0.04221381992101669, -0.008764911442995071, 0.01780635304749012, -0.022892188280820847, -0.023349301889538765, 0.025543078780174255, -0.02566329389810562, 0.005714111495763063, 0.011693266220390797, 0.03959835693240166, -0.05072890594601631, -0.004003614652901888, 0.056621938943862915, -0.05036171153187752, 0.01470964215695858, 0.00019332318333908916, 0.043769266456365585, -0.04603671282529831, -0.010767999105155468, 0.0006435606628656387, -0.07432510703802109, 0.02793091908097267, -0.0037844586186110973, -0.024096757173538208, 0.026810036972165108, 0.03823072090744972, -0.005188324488699436, 0.024419615045189857, -0.08254462480545044, 0.031101061031222343, -0.024881621822714806, -0.0217717494815588, 0.10883834213018417, 0.0365334190428257, -0.008680745027959347, -0.002290058182552457, -0.016878601163625717, -0.0018943113973364234, -0.020680854097008705, 0.02675427682697773, 0.01339219231158495, 0.05421862006187439, 0.04460981860756874, 0.04887107014656067, 0.003403904614970088, -0.010975240729749203, 0.0008721317281015217, 0.06907445192337036, -0.05044938623905182, 0.039562441408634186, 0.03307073190808296, -0.014860871247947216, -0.02760171890258789, 0.026115836575627327, -0.009916028939187527, -0.003349027130752802, -0.04411226511001587, -0.05644768103957176, 0.019371498376131058, -0.0079066576436162, -0.008634304627776146, 0.022924840450286865, 0.04035542905330658, -0.02694551646709442, 0.02723461575806141, -0.05749306082725525, 0.014921541325747967, 0.02898355759680271, -0.01884106546640396, -0.017132917419075966, -0.0007699428242631257, -0.017392821609973907, 0.024668868631124496, 0.054718371480703354, 0.02792211063206196, -0.030302315950393677, 0.027375590056180954, -0.0015545586356893182, 0.013766590505838394, 0.005738343112170696, 0.0023910976015031338, -0.038513705134391785, -0.010474463924765587, 0.0455598458647728, -0.003561391495168209, -0.01706031709909439, -0.0596860833466053, 0.030253468081355095, 0.004084615036845207, -0.02922523021697998, -0.03651426360011101, -0.04599640890955925, 0.03621289134025574, 0.0509166419506073, -0.06764186173677444, 0.053786374628543854, -0.03421313688158989, -0.015721436589956284, 0.02887576073408127, -0.03446391969919205, -0.04458100348711014, 0.045926641672849655, 3.0292525821096206e-07, 0.028284722939133644, 0.056128211319446564, 0.018930936232209206, -0.001226057531312108, 0.001693921280093491, 0.03535071387887001, -0.04174274951219559, 0.05026828870177269, -0.03210678696632385, -0.0009076744900085032, 0.04750286787748337, -0.01788671873509884, 0.03888244926929474, -0.02887580730021, -0.05072818696498871, -0.03787117823958397, -0.034495338797569275, 0.03379620611667633, -0.03133692592382431, 0.013245820999145508, 0.115751251578331, 0.09184649586677551, -0.026777880266308784, -0.0055235098116099834, -0.010188529267907143, -0.036276720464229584, 0.05783809721469879, 0.02327553741633892, -0.013088577426970005, -0.02256854809820652, 0.0114694619551301, 0.0342167504131794, -0.0638229176402092, -0.01821013167500496, -0.010316493920981884, -0.030992794781923294, 0.0893908366560936, 0.035516396164894104, -0.028376009315252304, -0.005454081576317549, 0.0029987823218107224, 0.018758505582809448, -0.005382829811424017, -0.04421110451221466, 0.03841283172369003, -0.047956373542547226, -0.06141975522041321, -0.01685519330203533, 0.05329670011997223, 0.039836179465055466, 0.038630932569503784, -0.05783374607563019, -0.037138231098651886, 0.0064943633042275906, 0.04318078234791756, -0.036053549498319626, -0.024547617882490158, -0.06161517649888992, -0.0026449612341821194, -0.013752743601799011, -0.014037419110536575, 0.015069122426211834, -0.036859773099422455, -0.060845181345939636, 0.044644616544246674, -0.025483746081590652, -0.012804912403225899, 2.5022422229942673e-34, 0.03843781352043152, -0.04557172954082489, -0.000661821395624429, -0.017151065170764923, 0.019404640421271324, -0.009449243545532227, -0.030629174783825874, 0.008584326133131981, 0.004961126483976841, -0.0378742553293705, -0.03617698326706886]
613
613
['Alexis Conneau', 'Holger Schwenk', 'Loïc Barrault', 'Yann Lecun']
1606.01781v2
The dominant approach for many NLP tasks are recurrent neural networks, in particular LSTMs, and convolutional neural networks. However, these architectures are rather shallow in comparison to the deep convolutional networks which have pushed the state-of-the-art in computer vision. We present a new architecture (VDCNN) for text processing which operates directly at the character level and uses only small convolutions and pooling operations. We are able to show that the performance of this model increases with depth: using up to 29 convolutional layers, we report improvements over the state-of-the-art on several public text classification tasks. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time that very deep convolutional nets have been applied to text processing.
Very Deep Convolutional Networks for Text Classification
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1606.01781v2
Title Deep Convolutional Networks Text Classification Summary dominant approach many NLP task recurrent neural network particular LSTMs convolutional neural network However architecture rather shallow comparison deep convolutional network pushed stateoftheart computer vision present new architecture VDCNN text processing operates directly character level us small convolution pooling operation able show performance model increase depth using 29 convolutional layer report improvement stateoftheart several public text classification task best knowledge first time deep convolutional net applied text processing Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.060872286558151245, 0.024899516254663467, 0.0042010704055428505, 0.07925429940223694, -0.017536798492074013, 0.012691543437540531, 0.03025246411561966, 0.02713078074157238, 0.017733626067638397, -0.07143654674291611, -0.014239005744457245, -0.006598727311939001, -0.004835042171180248, 0.044520456343889236, -0.008369509130716324, -0.05190165713429451, 0.01772454008460045, 0.035216204822063446, 0.021472163498401642, 0.03738377243280411, 0.011142811737954617, 0.029498137533664703, 0.03985057771205902, 0.05112925171852112, -0.00846274383366108, -0.011175544932484627, 0.027283934876322746, -0.0026210015639662743, -0.0203599464148283, -0.03990819305181503, 0.04837192967534065, 0.05944285914301872, 0.023488888517022133, 0.06599850207567215, 2.277084831803222e-06, 0.01171105820685625, -0.011732305400073528, -0.027900686487555504, -0.00440441956743598, 0.011275489814579487, 0.04252849146723747, -0.02739846520125866, 0.004142317920923233, 0.008989913389086723, -0.02884584106504917, -0.01785239949822426, 0.0009098672890104353, 0.09636915475130081, 0.009359062649309635, 0.07657093554735184, -0.01986861787736416, -0.049407944083213806, 0.010615458711981773, -0.022849082946777344, -0.009285330772399902, -0.035134878009557724, 0.029866531491279602, -0.03382692113518715, -0.015800246968865395, 0.020155787467956543, -0.008837293833494186, 0.04805165156722069, -0.001308295875787735, -0.024585427716374397, 0.03235143423080444, 0.054881446063518524, -0.015388788655400276, -0.018035059794783592, 0.011844106949865818, 0.07136296480894089, -0.038913544267416, -0.015706390142440796, 0.009963157586753368, -0.006470527499914169, -0.04538751393556595, -0.042848918586969376, 0.002512717619538307, -0.005228769965469837, -0.014822868630290031, 0.016959263011813164, -0.02995544858276844, 0.02046021819114685, 0.016423845663666725, 0.06261792778968811, -0.010767687112092972, -0.010824318043887615, -0.030404454097151756, -0.01731991581618786, 0.007190098520368338, 0.00392006104812026, 0.020271023735404015, -0.09283261001110077, 0.04944629594683647, 0.010192988440394402, 0.02513452246785164, -0.03341273218393326, -0.025643346831202507, -0.09898340702056885, 0.03146184980869293, -0.07381594181060791, 0.007192018907517195, -0.03393198177218437, -0.04016605392098427, 0.01747102662920952, -0.016542676836252213, 0.03343581780791283, -0.014024464413523674, 0.020431868731975555, -0.0007499883649870753, 0.03123818337917328, -0.04359849914908409, -0.022300561890006065, -0.01034034788608551, 0.0355786494910717, -0.015044557861983776, -0.026701010763645172, -0.05888815224170685, -0.01858450472354889, -0.0031060618348419666, -0.006137842312455177, -0.016814306378364563, 0.06724904477596283, -0.007554709445685148, 0.002769789192825556, -0.009716411121189594, 0.021999994292855263, -0.021803386509418488, 0.03884062543511391, -0.01743920147418976, -0.005738628562539816, 0.029017914086580276, 0.031336259096860886, 0.05590316280722618, 0.0017409129068255424, 0.037563420832157135, 0.024894321337342262, -0.003587534883990884, -0.04983017221093178, -0.02681151032447815, 0.00020211038645356894, -0.01940111443400383, -0.03646009787917137, -0.02818479761481285, -0.06793704628944397, 0.0035987559240311384, -0.03358165919780731, -0.02497394196689129, 0.001401211484335363, 0.016575507819652557, 0.03304454684257507, -0.032671619206666946, 0.08425575494766235, -0.014245593920350075, -0.028439689427614212, 0.11631232500076294, 0.005844995845109224, 0.05999071151018143, 0.0044050500728189945, 0.03065141849219799, 0.08813485503196716, 0.027911748737096786, -0.012254592962563038, 0.010850858874619007, 0.008950394578278065, -0.01831485889852047, -0.03904525563120842, -0.023804910480976105, 0.006569317076355219, -0.05627940967679024, 0.032980576157569885, -0.02211812324821949, 0.034379992634058, 0.011946910060942173, 0.007912728935480118, 0.04387425631284714, 0.08407241851091385, 0.033177707344293594, 0.048686180263757706, 0.0003574537404347211, 0.04314635321497917, 0.021622667089104652, -0.03156324103474617, -0.016345955431461334, -0.003984161652624607, -0.008855335414409637, -0.05226752907037735, -0.02981937676668167, -0.022337742149829865, -0.022124845534563065, -0.041368838399648666, 0.007571268826723099, -0.03809383511543274, 0.0008140226127579808, -0.02432028390467167, 0.042430464178323746, -0.0018929427023977041, -0.019773978739976883, -0.049964386969804764, 0.01273970678448677, 0.006226236466318369, -0.042012013494968414, -0.053901106119155884, 0.017307138070464134, 0.03572823852300644, 0.026846224442124367, -0.042671773582696915, 0.02323509193956852, -0.03340880200266838, 0.025506211444735527, 0.004807706456631422, 0.006218807306140661, 0.0100177600979805, -0.008618367835879326, -0.06414606422185898, -0.008291498757898808, 0.008896609768271446, -0.01505871582776308, 0.026925038546323776, -0.04027479887008667, 0.035173721611499786, 0.029527751728892326, 0.060163795948028564, -0.03573960065841675, 0.044120196253061295, 0.050744395703077316, -0.04662230238318443, 0.040669962763786316, 0.033103156834840775, 0.0012155522126704454, 0.03310393914580345, -0.010220201686024666, -0.003119693836197257, 0.04534921050071716, -0.031620584428310394, -0.06163078546524048, -0.03435917943716049, -0.025671938434243202, -0.015340571291744709, -0.030993344262242317, -0.03853315860033035, 0.012172160670161247, 0.05269652232527733, -0.03930310904979706, -0.03166927024722099, 0.008834762498736382, -0.00924928393214941, 0.0222455020993948, -0.024508221074938774, 0.0031599150970578194, -0.014758914709091187, 0.01053712423890829, -0.046344466507434845, 0.07659527659416199, 0.009843225590884686, 0.01970464549958706, -0.023357611149549484, -0.0034609802532941103, 0.04920486360788345, -0.010358178988099098, -0.01350348349660635, 0.013907014392316341, -0.04390238597989082, 0.014436022378504276, 0.011619542725384235, 0.022064289078116417, -0.01184798777103424, -0.020029166713356972, -0.059458177536726, 0.028513658791780472, -0.011544150300323963, -0.010516650974750519, -0.014198747463524342, -0.003872393164783716, 0.008306486532092094, -0.035480696707963943, -0.04123702272772789, 0.036441098898649216, -0.0017442726530134678, -0.010991248302161694, 0.053391046822071075, -0.0009371196501888335, 0.05540582537651062, -0.028259728103876114, -0.027964551001787186, -0.020181218162178993, 0.043193113058805466, 0.040077514946460724, -0.08446662127971649, 0.0024247164838016033, 0.0013158853398635983, -0.00740464311093092, 0.028709866106510162, 0.01000145822763443, -0.06809873133897781, -0.02054666168987751, -0.010498404502868652, -0.011840068735182285, 0.06477545946836472, 0.035968631505966187, 0.03993267938494682, -0.02165031246840954, 0.05047313868999481, 0.015197455883026123, 0.026096777990460396, -0.0023853571619838476, 0.05463005602359772, -0.009367456659674644, 0.008935609832406044, -0.006615821737796068, 0.017059769481420517, 0.021791882812976837, 0.01838788576424122, 0.0016512819565832615, 0.0014425653498619795, -0.020987194031476974, 0.002191997366026044, -0.05091157555580139, -0.02104085125029087, -0.01886560022830963, 0.012499283067882061, -0.0019953770097345114, -0.0409923680126667, 0.0213227029889822, 0.02005075104534626, -0.01769890822470188, -0.0632527619600296, -0.06984370946884155, -0.02599976770579815, 0.08857659250497818, 0.009404998272657394, 0.007694356143474579, -0.0022017548326402903, -0.04204094037413597, -0.008797287940979004, -0.001260741613805294, -0.021589072421193123, -0.043825145810842514, 0.060587018728256226, 0.0012036148691549897, -0.007004973478615284, -0.04742550849914551, -0.037767864763736725, -0.04115019366145134, -0.04737354442477226, -0.06609591096639633, -0.022991757839918137, 0.025855688378214836, -0.0349331833422184, -0.014329462312161922, -0.022005876526236534, 0.003877008566632867, 0.05413383990526199, -0.03161659836769104, -0.002324205357581377, -0.03186017647385597, 0.07335162162780762, 0.02224377728998661, -0.0030492632649838924, -0.031704381108284, 0.025061605498194695, -0.002090862952172756, 0.08442170917987823, -0.0490446537733078, 0.0347299762070179, -0.043667715042829514, -0.019503364339470863, 0.0027046282775700092, -0.020473001524806023, -0.035054340958595276, -0.015583259053528309, 0.019674839451909065, -0.08915040642023087, -0.007098021451383829, 0.09118028730154037, 0.0423913449048996, -0.09996207803487778, -0.011925543658435345, 0.02493368275463581, -0.025875085964798927, 0.016533199697732925, 0.03162737935781479, -0.03909121826291084, -0.033950306475162506, -0.017030004411935806, -0.007448463700711727, -0.02610713243484497, -0.01830529049038887, -0.02424163930118084, -0.03523803874850273, 0.015342279337346554, -0.05287556350231171, -0.01644309237599373, -0.013423883356153965, -0.03463873267173767, -0.016085729002952576, 0.008409600704908371, -0.026157259941101074, -0.026806950569152832, 0.015932584181427956, -0.0378878153860569, 0.03173457831144333, -0.06330212205648422, -0.0034879245795309544, 0.044463884085416794, -0.01292143389582634, -0.015835823491215706, 0.0651274248957634, 0.09962722659111023, -0.05208009108901024, -0.01069211307913065, 0.028393885120749474, -0.03490131348371506, -0.004598358180373907, -0.02263752929866314, 0.11046722531318665, -0.010439522564411163, 0.007766135036945343, -0.02688736282289028, 0.038522377610206604, -0.015299459919333458, 0.008450200781226158, 0.015186727046966553, 0.037538956850767136, -0.02776072546839714, -0.029497180134058, -0.04481424391269684, 0.023997673764824867, 0.008096892386674881, 0.015724487602710724, 0.0033401346299797297, -0.05432532727718353, -0.046356201171875, -0.03173050656914711, 0.025015000253915787, -0.06318356096744537, -0.03091580606997013, 0.013662264682352543, -0.007545738015323877, -0.047607384622097015, -0.06970945000648499, -0.03011496737599373, 0.006721922662109137, 0.014141404069960117, 0.003974102437496185, 0.00967097282409668, 0.007971472106873989, -0.026081372052431107, -0.036399874836206436, -0.012208507396280766, 0.04175085201859474, 0.050112660974264145, -0.03926897421479225, 0.022951113060116768, 0.04360644519329071, -0.031331341713666916, -0.01799110136926174, -0.02402556873857975, -0.08744727075099945, -0.03679942339658737, -0.02414969727396965, 0.011055240407586098, 0.006031815428286791, -0.03955432027578354, -0.034768663346767426, -0.09588588774204254, 0.04007705673575401, 0.0231083445250988, -0.02923186682164669, -0.029951520264148712, 0.021647412329912186, -0.024213898926973343, -0.02771301195025444, 0.01810416765511036, -0.01573004573583603, 0.06507539004087448, -0.00047968956641852856, -0.08606281876564026, -0.013745349831879139, -0.033818092197179794, -0.012901012785732746, -0.030305657535791397, 0.05229262635111809, 0.01924119144678116, -0.025970017537474632, -0.03946252539753914, 0.029223093762993813, -0.01899666152894497, -0.015859045088291168, -0.013820899650454521, -0.008640789426863194, 0.02533642388880253, -0.006013421807438135, -0.04187355935573578, 0.0031662723049521446, 0.03364689275622368, 0.003976041916757822, -0.014637685380876064, 0.0687180683016777, 0.03185275197029114, 0.05830958113074303, 0.0023016093764454126, 0.010225527919828892, -0.0050291335210204124, 0.015483140014111996, 0.02068602852523327, 0.04302855208516121, -0.019425801932811737, 0.010756932199001312, 0.02034059166908264, -0.015113349072635174, -0.04075076803565025, 0.027992112562060356, -0.04365786164999008, 0.006717773154377937, -0.024123553186655045, 0.018792154267430305, 0.06596066057682037, -0.07424730807542801, -0.012671707198023796, -0.023188605904579163, 0.007460503373295069, -0.015364284627139568, 0.04230191931128502, -0.0278820488601923, -0.000271885801339522, 0.010112660937011242, -0.01688532717525959, -0.021944385021924973, -0.003544432111084461, 0.033813830465078354, 0.022791460156440735, 0.009805737063288689, 0.0627688467502594, -0.05025934427976608, -0.039002545177936554, 0.015868550166487694, 0.01357412151992321, 0.062481172382831573, -0.007160522975027561, 0.020931532606482506, -0.008851074613630772, -0.01927144266664982, 0.05945056304335594, -0.04475145787000656, 0.03875342383980751, -0.02382448874413967, 0.007480792235583067, 0.023774223402142525, 0.03721268102526665, -0.019099224358797073, -0.05045634135603905, 0.03140058368444443, 0.011766575276851654, -0.01318761520087719, -0.06517717987298965, -6.552646321864989e-33, 0.0373387485742569, -0.06631886959075928, -0.011250478215515614, -0.01920561119914055, -0.028769519180059433, 0.06293930858373642, -0.005978123284876347, -0.02195313200354576, 0.0010117464698851109, 0.02687104046344757, -0.025187263265252113, 0.023316064849495888, 0.009265010245144367, 0.03522670641541481, 0.013664422556757927, 0.020415866747498512, 0.011899392120540142, -0.017958296462893486, 0.05401647090911865, 0.01541326567530632, 0.018120700493454933, 0.05493195727467537, 0.08088844269514084, -0.0719977542757988, -0.002611470641568303, -0.0066671473905444145, 0.0055709900334477425, -0.013062261044979095, 0.032065991312265396, 0.021209871396422386, -0.02634255774319172, 0.03175012767314911, 0.051822297275066376, -0.006086444016546011, 0.0051532103680074215, 0.053318146616220474, -0.0514344684779644, -0.03846631571650505, -0.07237593084573746, 0.027783721685409546, -0.02797451987862587, 0.03328389301896095, 0.04096587747335434, 0.014405041001737118, 0.004031323827803135, -0.016408689320087433, 0.07611938565969467, -0.0002453303022775799, -0.022177180275321007, -0.024232536554336548, -0.05414584279060364, 0.03652700409293175, 0.005898821633309126, 0.0033052219077944756, 0.04035284370183945, -0.0004054635646753013, 0.033025071024894714, 0.03859204798936844, -0.08614736795425415, -0.004620634485036135, -0.005059225019067526, 0.04278150573372841, 0.013128628954291344, 0.02456311695277691, -0.04722670093178749, 0.03487361967563629, 0.004656291101127863, 0.026142042130231857, -0.06719356775283813, 0.009003839455544949, 0.014371226541697979, 0.06393932551145554, 0.06457478553056717, 0.032685283571481705, 0.07091785222291946, -0.05640002340078354, -0.07865863293409348, 0.027918115258216858, 0.021606242284178734, 0.01007044780999422, -0.013674388639628887, 0.021931618452072144, -0.059735510498285294, 0.014985869638621807, 0.019323300570249557, 0.005709088873118162, -0.017143383622169495, -0.01953558251261711, 0.00609977450221777, 8.648447692394257e-05, 0.014714784920215607, 0.05724555253982544, -0.015517789870500565, -0.056672219187021255, -0.021628757938742638, -0.009307111613452435, -0.0020185704343020916, 0.040984779596328735, 0.008482175879180431, 0.0007826126529835165, -0.06598680466413498, -0.02214795909821987, -0.0049364748410880566, 0.030614271759986877, 0.013167859986424446, 0.009122008457779884, 0.04493620991706848, -0.011171783320605755, -0.05746389552950859, -0.01625802554190159, 0.025384575128555298, -0.008322144858539104, 0.029547004029154778, 0.10368449240922928, -0.03792472183704376, -0.019154734909534454, 0.019785752519965172, 0.051495809108018875, 0.037319064140319824, 0.01071010623127222, -0.025960374623537064, -0.06087499111890793, 0.02754654921591282, 0.00921377632766962, -0.03740525245666504, -0.01851322501897812, -0.051264312118291855, 0.01023166161030531, 0.038872335106134415, -0.07226615399122238, -0.00716050760820508, 0.0014049871824681759, 2.732765551627381e-07, 0.04940663278102875, 0.049397677183151245, 0.02085692621767521, -0.03731217607855797, 0.0024018646217882633, 0.027742255479097366, 0.02696121297776699, 0.06648395210504532, -0.05012067034840584, 0.02430698648095131, 0.04133350029587746, -0.009609499014914036, 0.053244128823280334, 0.02764391526579857, -0.09875968098640442, 0.012600930407643318, -0.08494025468826294, 0.01747460663318634, -0.045445747673511505, -0.004575343802571297, 0.07407046854496002, 0.12300215661525726, 0.023036962375044823, -0.03767310082912445, 0.04606986045837402, -0.02384849824011326, 0.007271492853760719, 0.011756210587918758, 0.04131767526268959, 0.029534345492720604, 0.006012751720845699, 0.008998684585094452, -0.031110502779483795, -0.007707514334470034, -0.07198679447174072, 0.01117091253399849, 0.045908648520708084, 0.03941485285758972, -0.0637437179684639, 0.006666326429694891, 0.02018752507865429, -0.003369939047843218, 0.017569493502378464, -0.031189706176519394, 0.07909516245126724, 0.015888923779129982, -0.03838057070970535, -0.04167332500219345, 0.04230925440788269, 0.0010645866859704256, 0.06929822266101837, 0.006867881398648024, -0.008162325248122215, 0.018710283562541008, 0.0247662216424942, -0.062480226159095764, -0.010365989059209824, -0.11850105971097946, 0.006020731292665005, 0.001312779146246612, -0.03381151705980301, 0.04774362966418266, -0.046305518597364426, -0.016298213973641396, 0.06054425612092018, -0.028441863134503365, 0.01742332987487316, 2.8419942991042273e-34, -0.011294984258711338, -0.0029415874741971493, -0.02643081173300743, 0.011877643875777721, -0.02183055318892002, 0.02527753636240959, 0.03620171174407005, -0.004712443798780441, -0.0019645895808935165, -0.04631296172738075, -0.004346540663391352]
614
614
['Marco Dinarelli', 'Isabelle Tellier']
1606.02555v1
In this paper we study different types of Recurrent Neural Networks (RNN) for sequence labeling tasks. We propose two new variants of RNNs integrating improvements for sequence labeling, and we compare them to the more traditional Elman and Jordan RNNs. We compare all models, either traditional or new, on four distinct tasks of sequence labeling: two on Spoken Language Understanding (ATIS and MEDIA); and two of POS tagging for the French Treebank (FTB) and the Penn Treebank (PTB) corpora. The results show that our new variants of RNNs are always more effective than the others.
Improving Recurrent Neural Networks For Sequence Labelling
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1606.02555v1
Title Improving Recurrent Neural Networks Sequence Labelling Summary paper study different type Recurrent Neural Networks RNN sequence labeling task propose two new variant RNNs integrating improvement sequence labeling compare traditional Elman Jordan RNNs compare model either traditional new four distinct task sequence labeling two Spoken Language Understanding ATIS MEDIA two POS tagging French Treebank FTB Penn Treebank PTB corpus result show new variant RNNs always effective others Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.04753683879971504, -0.0005172011442482471, 0.02614475227892399, 0.044264134019613266, -0.04098315164446831, -0.0019576717168092728, 0.0019845752976834774, -0.02557271532714367, -0.016920369118452072, -0.029783299192786217, -0.01887935772538185, -0.037809696048498154, 0.026239173486828804, 0.026845987886190414, 0.013257039710879326, -0.08246904611587524, 0.040392737835645676, -0.005852145608514547, 0.03809579089283943, 0.0573384091258049, 0.014684685505926609, -0.003804353764280677, -0.03288399800658226, 0.010867934674024582, -0.007082437630742788, 0.004785855300724506, 0.0028908380772918463, -0.041049275547266006, 0.004939747974276543, -0.09282729029655457, 0.03284886106848717, 0.05101950466632843, -0.017182182520627975, 0.03756655007600784, 2.0455411231523613e-06, -0.004074010066688061, 0.008921652100980282, -0.027213845402002335, 0.025565721094608307, -0.019727244973182678, 0.02395201474428177, 0.010946894064545631, -0.007329230196774006, 0.024735495448112488, -0.0244724340736866, -0.019099906086921692, 0.05120781436562538, 0.0829537957906723, 0.028659246861934662, 0.08804544806480408, 0.02217010036110878, -0.06446975469589233, 0.022809281945228577, -0.04797601327300072, 0.02625155635178089, -0.03879143297672272, 0.022762984037399292, -0.00514790415763855, 0.033930178731679916, 0.005411196034401655, 0.008354967460036278, 0.03633724898099899, 0.026869861409068108, -0.022449176758527756, -0.0020319249015301466, 0.020565707236528397, 0.006914329249411821, -0.02856471575796604, 0.019729405641555786, 0.08791494369506836, -0.03584802523255348, 0.024633899331092834, 0.014511040411889553, 0.00980765838176012, -0.02941323071718216, -0.08751476556062698, -0.0118036437779665, 0.036080241203308105, -0.021503616124391556, -0.005710387136787176, 0.008029324002563953, 0.061282772570848465, 0.05006830394268036, 0.025148767977952957, -0.008896706625819206, 0.02963964082300663, 0.01868298649787903, -0.03954241797327995, -0.020545894280076027, -0.05152392014861107, 0.022181754931807518, -0.07872618734836578, 0.03606632724404335, 0.05542515590786934, -0.00891458336263895, 0.03235694766044617, 0.004247455857694149, -0.058848895132541656, 0.00592939043417573, -0.02868969365954399, 0.017367688938975334, 0.011714858002960682, -0.02114121988415718, 0.006162370089441538, -0.006797694601118565, 0.04980882629752159, 0.003868705127388239, 0.006135386414825916, -0.017289411276578903, -0.004234663676470518, -0.06769070029258728, -0.029715539887547493, -0.01876702718436718, 0.06273957341909409, -0.016972841694951057, -0.0264463871717453, -0.08381922543048859, -0.021432658657431602, 0.005899940617382526, -0.006692330818623304, 0.03473532199859619, 0.012401283718645573, -0.039295315742492676, 0.0019680550321936607, -0.02079789713025093, 0.024064721539616585, -0.028534026816487312, -0.004474299494177103, -0.008977923542261124, -0.04588453471660614, 0.0075686415657401085, 0.036353904753923416, 0.02333753928542137, -0.004951086826622486, -0.04058464244008064, 0.03772091493010521, 0.030017221346497536, -0.014671734534204006, -0.045711785554885864, -0.014679650776088238, -0.037545084953308105, -0.031627215445041656, -0.021954629570245743, -0.05183840170502663, -0.0064291092567145824, -0.04323187097907066, -0.0508691668510437, -0.002700132317841053, 0.0239047072827816, 0.02315020188689232, 0.003763561137020588, 0.07445114850997925, -0.03627094253897667, -0.030367450788617134, 0.03831341862678528, 0.011627597734332085, 0.061459001153707504, -0.023171311244368553, 0.06190195307135582, 0.03342853859066963, 0.03328174725174904, -0.0028741350397467613, 0.07649855315685272, 0.037937622517347336, -0.013583811931312084, -0.07552368938922882, -0.02700071595609188, -0.058827586472034454, 0.03077111579477787, 0.05854783579707146, 0.024299802258610725, 0.041620030999183655, 0.010466357693076134, 0.004685084335505962, 0.03346627205610275, 0.02828328125178814, 0.03107800893485546, 0.03672539070248604, 0.010387076996266842, -0.0059908428229391575, 0.010397573933005333, 0.011959046125411987, -0.003996479324996471, 0.05899714678525925, 0.017163388431072235, 0.036365482956171036, -0.01649976149201393, -0.02644476108253002, -0.030543528497219086, -0.03860725089907646, -0.022761443629860878, -0.013376343064010143, -0.013372913934290409, -0.020084887742996216, 0.0319669172167778, 0.020751962438225746, -0.0746176540851593, -0.01929272711277008, -0.00593487499281764, -0.033937253057956696, 0.0032056602649390697, -0.0044727507047355175, -0.009037764742970467, 0.00246533309109509, 0.010688358917832375, -0.03470263257622719, -0.07189447432756424, -0.006052699405699968, -0.02275923825800419, 0.043802257627248764, 0.01836414448916912, -0.0226593054831028, 0.008623591624200344, -0.0817398726940155, -0.014126550406217575, 0.029069969430565834, -0.020784858614206314, 0.044009409844875336, -0.03974740952253342, -0.0008347583352588117, 0.047258179634809494, 0.01534623559564352, -0.06399337202310562, 0.04379498213529587, -0.032815683633089066, -0.0388348214328289, 0.03531903028488159, 0.023739587515592575, 0.03852970153093338, 0.056069668382406235, 0.032235607504844666, 0.028684642165899277, 0.026413841173052788, -0.015406765043735504, 0.02094707265496254, -0.00015456101391464472, -0.07198657095432281, -0.06065521016716957, 0.028586141765117645, -0.0024925856851041317, -0.03407588228583336, 0.047205451875925064, -0.052987948060035706, -0.06693928688764572, 0.02521524578332901, 0.008154142647981644, 0.001895235967822373, -0.02463887259364128, 0.026128485798835754, 0.05293940007686615, 0.005620679818093777, -0.015744129195809364, 0.0443190261721611, -0.019501052796840668, 0.02901846170425415, 0.03965819627046585, -0.009638667106628418, 0.009629301726818085, -0.043297089636325836, -0.05601232126355171, 0.04199698194861412, -0.00831747055053711, -0.03249834105372429, 0.007761713117361069, -0.006732321809977293, -0.05615362152457237, -0.016188938170671463, -0.020130226388573647, 0.018242478370666504, -0.005359993781894445, 0.047549013048410416, 0.024098766967654228, 0.014842739328742027, 0.022527432069182396, -0.043638888746500015, -0.07489413022994995, -0.014321496710181236, -0.012608575634658337, -0.0010983904357999563, 0.044502682983875275, 0.06643988192081451, -0.03858510032296181, -0.030369317159056664, -0.009491022676229477, -0.0058952802792191505, -0.0043942066840827465, 0.012018900364637375, -0.09994909167289734, -0.022054119035601616, -0.029809745028614998, 0.0003996830200776458, 0.007664943113923073, -0.004859382752329111, -0.043432265520095825, -0.028587160632014275, 0.009036164730787277, 0.03348250314593315, -0.008538594469428062, 0.02053982950747013, 0.003782529616728425, -0.01854042522609234, -0.006950369570404291, 0.017871828749775887, 0.010060559026896954, -0.032158464193344116, 0.014726904220879078, 0.030326377600431442, -0.03330177441239357, 0.024505050852894783, 0.06845849007368088, 0.00035590140032581985, 0.050662025809288025, 0.016634076833724976, -0.016800640150904655, -0.01949681155383587, 0.011447932571172714, -0.026079446077346802, -0.02167532965540886, -0.04688708484172821, -0.019161531701683998, -0.017172755673527718, 0.011916319839656353, 0.05505901947617531, -0.023872841149568558, -0.019849112257361412, -0.08074228465557098, -0.04131389409303665, -0.0400356650352478, 0.021747946739196777, 0.00808123592287302, -0.023570487275719643, 0.04468817263841629, -0.09007817506790161, 0.002623228123411536, -0.022675106301903725, -0.0008892865153029561, -0.03209194540977478, 0.030708827078342438, -0.004409342538565397, -0.0064468481577932835, -0.04705526679754257, 0.0015980914467945695, -0.03162596374750137, 0.020183898508548737, -0.016271470114588737, 0.021873177960515022, -0.012630557641386986, -0.016029568389058113, -0.023811649531126022, 0.047229278832674026, 0.03701372817158699, 0.05214251950383186, -0.039504989981651306, 0.031852707266807556, -0.004225119948387146, 0.07219026982784271, 0.02092951536178589, -0.010279039852321148, 0.002045653760433197, 0.04201921820640564, 0.015859823673963547, -0.005939665250480175, -0.022076187655329704, 0.010011167265474796, -0.07591908425092697, -0.013485297560691833, 0.008883419446647167, -0.06033313274383545, -0.03953205794095993, 0.03856134042143822, -0.01756584644317627, -0.09399480372667313, 0.0009820109698921442, 0.13148871064186096, 0.003421367844566703, -0.057554420083761215, -0.014772099442780018, 0.012061341665685177, -0.006256850901991129, 0.03198126330971718, -0.0005700389156118035, -0.029893629252910614, -0.03016413375735283, 0.0031974860467016697, 0.03980342298746109, 0.008596480824053288, -0.07392869889736176, -0.01946360617876053, -0.09240495413541794, 0.02751198783516884, -0.011363731697201729, -0.08344405889511108, -0.0252434853464365, -0.00960870087146759, -0.017788946628570557, -0.017495878040790558, 0.009671546518802643, 0.0006407436449080706, 0.0198979452252388, 0.003914950415492058, 0.06942224502563477, -0.06665103137493134, -0.03632783144712448, -0.030431551858782768, -0.058514371514320374, 0.03660784289240837, 0.06555604934692383, 0.035791244357824326, -0.027125446125864983, -0.0405166856944561, 0.043482813984155655, -0.0012553565902635455, -0.013508635573089123, -0.00784118752926588, 0.0020744651556015015, -0.018851663917303085, -0.026789894327521324, -0.018445514142513275, 0.0016598551301285625, -0.037754207849502563, 0.03815709799528122, -0.0028487504459917545, 0.051901668310165405, 0.02149665541946888, 0.01390241552144289, -0.03178270906209946, 0.03338756784796715, 0.031392768025398254, 0.023396063596010208, 0.01631012372672558, 0.002119328361004591, -0.00960507895797491, -0.008370581082999706, 0.03573506325483322, -0.08983775973320007, -0.015008225105702877, 0.0037541452329605818, -0.03894670307636261, -0.06427427381277084, -0.11828554421663284, -0.06706856936216354, 0.005840119905769825, 0.04288877174258232, 0.03462837263941765, 0.014478567987680435, 0.04387161508202553, 0.006507780868560076, -0.0287790410220623, -0.03250331059098244, 0.030381325632333755, -0.01799928955733776, -0.08291986584663391, 0.007647036109119654, 0.06124899163842201, 0.026576070114970207, 0.008987955749034882, -0.008384446613490582, -0.04597480595111847, -0.030833140015602112, 0.01564093679189682, 0.012777755968272686, 0.004332178272306919, 0.023370411247015, -0.021023157984018326, -0.04966604709625244, -0.021780505776405334, 0.0030850323382765055, 0.027566630393266678, -0.021080367267131805, 0.02274669148027897, 0.026200395077466965, -0.033399417996406555, 0.004149443935602903, -0.031542737036943436, 0.05218798294663429, -0.0021125043276697397, 0.0404491163790226, -0.0024232370778918266, -0.03224511444568634, -0.005816961172968149, -0.012987552210688591, 0.06432881206274033, 0.003149614902213216, -0.029233846813440323, -0.030261145904660225, 0.030568301677703857, 0.019325582310557365, -0.022290052846074104, -0.010075989179313183, 0.03496114909648895, 0.041893672198057175, 0.0069515821523964405, -0.014084523543715477, 0.017781974747776985, 0.027913043275475502, -0.03032682090997696, 0.022074313834309578, 0.05064506456255913, 0.012477925047278404, 0.04421251267194748, -0.07502132654190063, 0.006261683534830809, -0.02886640466749668, 0.016988949850201607, 0.030419111251831055, 0.06180720403790474, -0.02723712846636772, 0.045432209968566895, 0.01749255508184433, 0.01115014124661684, 0.012550211511552334, 0.042092762887477875, -0.0011950568296015263, 0.015491917729377747, -0.05629255250096321, 0.011781083419919014, 0.06935767829418182, -0.008957557380199432, -0.006722778547555208, 0.0012909471988677979, 0.008791384287178516, -0.028103183954954147, 0.05481116846203804, -0.028271352872252464, -0.02464279718697071, 0.0437895692884922, 0.008455552160739899, -0.04546666517853737, -0.0074058049358427525, 0.05600172281265259, 0.028185700997710228, -0.0094512440264225, 0.04991954192519188, -0.02735249325633049, -0.004101703409105539, 0.003081931034103036, 0.006961904000490904, -0.002183775883167982, -0.035569727420806885, 0.013074680231511593, -0.006194497458636761, -0.043290115892887115, 0.06478289514780045, -0.0018602627096697688, 0.04069121927022934, 0.014599744230508804, 0.03476124629378319, -0.0036855603102594614, 0.0388215146958828, 0.014529600739479065, -0.03223593533039093, 0.007566729560494423, 0.021023713052272797, -0.06030738353729248, -0.05345859006047249, -6.252145884756656e-33, -0.012221910990774632, -0.03154510632157326, -0.006416413001716137, -0.03310738131403923, -0.018485425040125847, -0.006397489923983812, -0.0532650463283062, -0.00907502043992281, 0.01052527129650116, -0.00866018421947956, -0.0003329352766741067, -0.006142965983599424, 0.034281179308891296, 0.055139895528554916, 0.03847263753414154, -0.032519590109586716, 0.05395670235157013, 0.01619560830295086, -0.01519237644970417, -0.0024403787683695555, 0.018857575953006744, 0.05504613742232323, 0.11162988841533661, -0.05832195281982422, -0.004244221840053797, -0.02529890276491642, 0.01467239111661911, -0.006322076078504324, 0.05564764514565468, 0.051680609583854675, -0.02066069468855858, -0.022093066945672035, 0.04070993885397911, -0.09486296027898788, -0.028585588559508324, 0.048937130719423294, -0.1165342628955841, -0.03295142203569412, -0.018510261550545692, 0.04178043082356453, -0.03487485274672508, -0.024169178679585457, 0.03189357742667198, -0.011242302134633064, 0.01596708782017231, 0.051143549382686615, 0.041311923414468765, -0.01851828210055828, -0.03669621795415878, -0.02351302281022072, -0.04232560470700264, 0.034502554684877396, 0.01227304432541132, 0.011627201922237873, 0.028640178963541985, 0.0013532444136217237, -0.007786872796714306, 0.015362984500825405, -0.1299639791250229, -0.021278196945786476, -0.011781541630625725, 0.0939333513379097, 0.04626762866973877, 0.07276629656553268, -0.025625325739383698, -0.003100198693573475, 0.009917142800986767, 0.0005461860564537346, 0.027547379955649376, 0.033673398196697235, -0.032062828540802, -0.0040519218891859055, 0.0708758607506752, 0.008119399659335613, 0.0688636526465416, -0.008195089176297188, -0.0505199059844017, 0.028493676334619522, 0.008315550163388252, 0.04174140840768814, 0.005162558984011412, 0.008834981359541416, -0.029812809079885483, 0.01701861061155796, 0.011772248893976212, 0.025280380621552467, -0.038984742015600204, -0.025502067059278488, 0.038485072553157806, -0.001571385539136827, 0.021079624071717262, 0.04255280643701553, -0.004500711336731911, -0.002999168122187257, -0.00625739386305213, -0.013669478707015514, 0.053083136677742004, 0.04496200382709503, -0.02930399402976036, -0.0006466720369644463, -0.06438552588224411, 0.0013807931682094932, 0.01777609810233116, 0.030463149771094322, 0.017468737438321114, -0.012220446020364761, 0.07541278004646301, -0.01073515135794878, -0.022709600627422333, -0.009802146814763546, 0.00442732498049736, 0.029554104432463646, 0.0146947605535388, 0.0604022778570652, -0.008364138193428516, -0.039908621460199356, -0.0038051502779126167, 0.08604685217142105, 0.008048949763178825, -0.016141707077622414, -0.0004624849825631827, -0.04663648456335068, 0.05554182827472687, 0.015702256932854652, -0.04538685455918312, -0.015547312796115875, -0.017779290676116943, 0.05403418838977814, -0.016704007983207703, -0.015578565187752247, -0.013203469105064869, 0.06268986314535141, 2.773651885945583e-07, -0.004598856903612614, -0.016203435137867928, 0.08093838393688202, -0.03559865429997444, 0.0020966818556189537, 0.013173556886613369, -0.022440526634454727, 0.01853695884346962, -0.020996324717998505, -0.010212228633463383, 0.018329370766878128, -0.0738975927233696, 0.023984819650650024, -0.041049450635910034, -0.10334185510873795, -0.06188293546438217, -0.08861719071865082, 0.01828443817794323, -0.015552601777017117, 0.025411034002900124, 0.06332866847515106, 0.12233224511146545, 0.02391516976058483, 0.005721091292798519, -0.023159580305218697, -0.021927403286099434, -0.028176164254546165, 0.03135790675878525, -6.459661108237924e-06, 0.016432004049420357, 0.035823430866003036, 0.04516975209116936, -0.04245707765221596, -0.04575972631573677, -0.04399550333619118, 0.004719145130366087, 0.009688425809144974, 0.033593785017728806, 0.003219515085220337, -0.035799745470285416, -0.009528713300824165, 0.03517044335603714, 0.021272476762533188, 0.007138283457607031, 0.023152530193328857, -0.008431637659668922, -0.047631505876779556, 0.01514193695038557, -0.00595403416082263, 0.01816718839108944, -0.016784828156232834, -0.01947501115500927, -0.019005775451660156, 0.0010586397256702185, 0.026235895231366158, -0.04698267579078674, -0.03078501857817173, -0.07522276788949966, 0.0071383025497198105, 0.010511924512684345, -0.004293990321457386, 0.021878603845834732, -0.028136901557445526, -0.014323055744171143, 0.02897089533507824, -0.013235202990472317, -0.004061785526573658, 2.4528744449133564e-34, 0.013960221782326698, -0.011996259912848473, -0.04401717334985733, 0.07332523912191391, 0.005469461437314749, 0.01052165124565363, -0.052121151238679886, 0.02998177334666252, 0.013333954848349094, -0.02348914183676243, -0.04178282245993614]
615
615
['Marek Rei', 'Ronan Cummins']
1606.03144v1
We investigate the task of assessing sentence-level prompt relevance in learner essays. Various systems using word overlap, neural embeddings and neural compositional models are evaluated on two datasets of learner writing. We propose a new method for sentence-level similarity calculation, which learns to adjust the weights of pre-trained word embeddings for a specific task, achieving substantially higher accuracy compared to other relevant baselines.
Sentence Similarity Measures for Fine-Grained Estimation of Topical Relevance in Learner Essays
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1606.03144v1
Title Sentence Similarity Measures FineGrained Estimation Topical Relevance Learner Essays Summary investigate task assessing sentencelevel prompt relevance learner essay Various system using word overlap neural embeddings neural compositional model evaluated two datasets learner writing propose new method sentencelevel similarity calculation learns adjust weight pretrained word embeddings specific task achieving substantially higher accuracy compared relevant baseline Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.06661763787269592, 0.027093369513750076, 0.0011273910058662295, 0.0300119798630476, -0.040839653462171555, 0.011714022606611252, 0.019872717559337616, -0.019970372319221497, -0.0007985280826687813, -0.04079223424196243, -0.019642191007733345, -0.009494829922914505, 0.015323278494179249, 0.013418403454124928, -0.006818411871790886, -0.05108259618282318, 0.0116432411596179, 0.06263358891010284, -0.0018818300450220704, 0.027913883328437805, 0.040608733892440796, 0.006526469718664885, 0.014263838529586792, 0.068914994597435, 0.014219125732779503, -0.037457581609487534, 0.029032761231064796, -0.0050143287517130375, 0.03798631578683853, 0.009714676067233086, 0.06289159506559372, 0.07743819057941437, 0.04969647526741028, 0.018979664891958237, 2.200222297688015e-06, -0.016688700765371323, 0.0031295008957386017, -0.04020411893725395, 0.03679035231471062, -0.019333897158503532, 0.07360895723104477, 0.024461625143885612, 0.02292517200112343, 0.025036880746483803, -0.03758504241704941, 0.008001205511391163, 0.03445873782038689, 0.08706123381853104, 0.027804240584373474, 0.03433132916688919, -0.017657754942774773, -0.021821292117238045, 0.035417281091213226, 0.010389246977865696, 0.0325259268283844, -0.03214716538786888, 0.025564080104231834, -0.0024821984115988016, -0.010248194448649883, 0.021745238453149796, -0.0056840344332158566, 0.018840160220861435, 0.04261186346411705, -0.03770354762673378, 0.02839307114481926, 0.018224813044071198, -0.015053289011120796, 0.03741630166769028, 0.025770030915737152, 0.04201527312397957, 0.01727559231221676, -0.06021694839000702, -0.012376542203128338, 0.007277253083884716, -0.01099917571991682, 0.010332927107810974, -0.05191469192504883, 0.0011838773498311639, -0.011730552650988102, 0.025821002200245857, 0.029062090441584587, 0.05886764079332352, 0.006482161581516266, 0.04727979004383087, 0.01789170689880848, 0.023685738444328308, 0.029507432132959366, -0.044054917991161346, -0.004126592073589563, 0.009503912180662155, 0.02962210774421692, -0.06595336645841599, 0.041681528091430664, 0.010907930321991444, -0.02087664231657982, -0.031209671869874, -0.06121043488383293, -0.05810767039656639, 0.03199915215373039, -0.06891834735870361, 0.08031237125396729, 0.01393161341547966, 0.002972566755488515, -0.0069666095077991486, -0.00034408483770675957, 0.02814166247844696, 0.009628674015402794, -0.00645811390131712, -0.06012110412120819, -0.0086767403408885, -0.05403014272451401, -0.03834930434823036, -0.021469494327902794, 0.05011998116970062, 0.02091318927705288, -0.051284465938806534, -0.04413505271077156, -0.012227993458509445, -0.009280562400817871, -0.03138572350144386, -0.06342082470655441, 0.014161135070025921, -0.019220886752009392, 0.010280792601406574, -0.005182341206818819, 0.0141152860596776, -0.047445379197597504, 0.0408613383769989, -0.015248124487698078, 0.0017586109461262822, -0.0004529567377176136, 0.028314387425780296, 0.019770599901676178, -0.027718452736735344, 0.00866949837654829, -0.03670680150389671, -0.0027395011857151985, -0.06361129134893417, -0.022874007001519203, -0.021881548687815666, 0.015504513867199421, -0.018072083592414856, -0.023797867819666862, -0.09287632256746292, 0.021496545523405075, -0.0202744472771883, -0.007974543608725071, -0.03413102775812149, -0.016737721860408783, 0.07686025649309158, -0.010698400437831879, 0.03712853044271469, 0.02454056590795517, 0.003682537004351616, 0.043973296880722046, 0.023327114060521126, 0.07313033193349838, -0.015638211742043495, 0.014888078905642033, 0.03474077582359314, 0.02493033930659294, 0.03869064897298813, 0.007040805649012327, -0.036594778299331665, -0.035772014409303665, -0.030331967398524284, 0.0021185618825256824, 0.0013109439751133323, -0.011847146786749363, 0.06285983324050903, 0.0028575328178703785, 0.03012119047343731, -0.014825266785919666, 0.006243123207241297, 0.06805986911058426, 0.0813855454325676, 0.036664847284555435, 0.00880509801208973, 0.04261699318885803, 0.04753979668021202, 0.013745123520493507, 0.06669732183218002, -0.0005187892820686102, 0.02784052863717079, 0.0033155365381389856, -0.010595735162496567, 0.019088217988610268, -0.001544969156384468, -0.04758869856595993, -0.039383403956890106, -0.00154593784827739, -0.0024584282655268908, -0.00735373143106699, -0.014838319271802902, -0.0065262638963758945, 0.016154399141669273, -0.029087712988257408, -0.008885360322892666, 0.03412582725286484, -0.06929705291986465, -0.004169735126197338, 0.013272798620164394, -0.0027074117679148912, 0.02006775513291359, 0.02257692813873291, -0.02031926065683365, -0.019566142931580544, -0.013741163536906242, 0.057371653616428375, 0.04269254580140114, 0.025736812502145767, -0.005348867736756802, -0.009627352468669415, -0.04447071626782417, -0.0261515025049448, -0.056997478008270264, 0.008344432339072227, -0.012203368358314037, -0.013406316749751568, 0.02983671985566616, 0.03820980340242386, 0.018066732212901115, -0.049060314893722534, 0.07497389614582062, -0.013316815719008446, -0.0010328635107725859, 0.014581931754946709, 0.03424862027168274, -0.008151672780513763, 0.021998556330800056, -0.003854589071124792, 0.04304042458534241, 0.0056753274984657764, -0.06162722781300545, -0.05809507146477699, -0.01972571760416031, -0.0606335885822773, -0.02978106215596199, 0.0017598944250494242, -0.10324107855558395, 0.00500106904655695, 0.058325719088315964, -0.017149118706583977, -0.02433297410607338, -0.012322618626058102, -0.019241930916905403, -0.007605686318129301, -0.04950408637523651, 0.003338973969221115, -0.05484709516167641, 0.011747220531105995, -0.030712716281414032, 0.04638156294822693, 0.004501345567405224, 0.0730639323592186, 0.004816962871700525, 0.018222523853182793, 0.044618893414735794, -0.009097199887037277, -0.04692959412932396, -0.03731686249375343, 0.005628580693155527, 0.0022278502583503723, 0.033587243407964706, 0.005962884519249201, -0.02507237158715725, -0.04456035792827606, -0.10957903414964676, 0.012310677208006382, -0.007848200388252735, 0.0026718745939433575, 0.0434332937002182, 0.018967531621456146, 0.007771494798362255, -0.009990938939154148, -0.02450169250369072, -0.013260317035019398, -0.035837382078170776, 0.033964890986680984, 0.06248203292489052, -0.023023318499326706, 0.0467144176363945, -0.04585816338658333, -0.01986612193286419, -0.04004611819982529, 0.0589139424264431, 0.042499471455812454, -0.04438874498009682, -0.00858739297837019, 0.040503427386283875, -0.033931806683540344, -0.024927152320742607, 0.008359619416296482, -0.03853753209114075, 0.01642320677638054, 0.028972309082746506, 0.06986873596906662, 0.052012890577316284, 0.06305502355098724, 0.005704096052795649, 0.0664186030626297, 0.033468544483184814, 0.006630697287619114, -0.013999136164784431, -0.021968161687254906, 0.03065577894449234, 0.016473893076181412, -0.04009295627474785, 0.04011654853820801, 0.024829016998410225, 0.038181208074092865, -0.019441034644842148, -0.024648867547512054, 0.04470754787325859, -0.021893342956900597, 0.018856355920433998, -0.06257466971874237, -0.014994422905147076, -0.012816861271858215, -0.021803652867674828, -0.035344917327165604, -0.00130732252728194, 0.06086522713303566, -0.01667550764977932, 0.026363728567957878, -0.06764883548021317, -0.033064499497413635, -0.04965125769376755, 0.06026242673397064, -0.010103345848619938, 0.02262546494603157, -0.023295201361179352, -0.009244916029274464, -0.04415278136730194, 0.017516177147626877, 0.0029052034951746464, -0.016870232298970222, 0.03192945942282677, 0.012153825722634792, -0.011809269897639751, -0.007095891050994396, -0.028012573719024658, -0.026199640706181526, -0.0607326440513134, 0.0058776941150426865, 0.006217236630618572, -0.016332795843482018, 0.005461317952722311, -0.03556068241596222, -0.030561473220586777, 0.004127471707761288, 0.03883006423711777, -0.05870639160275459, -0.017856158316135406, -0.013163797557353973, 0.05166387930512428, 0.07360797375440598, -0.0039663417264819145, -0.03675879165530205, 0.012188144959509373, 0.04978227615356445, 0.03148879483342171, -0.02358824945986271, 0.030983196571469307, -0.03713402897119522, -0.025127995759248734, 0.010320194996893406, -0.05589478462934494, -0.000780267349909991, 0.0008095755474641919, 0.018515555188059807, -0.055754054337739944, -0.030058078467845917, 0.10131505876779556, 0.02860444411635399, -0.06394387036561966, 0.0033796275965869427, -0.048466164618730545, 0.0018306511919945478, 0.035279031842947006, 0.03803233802318573, -0.016469307243824005, -0.02507900632917881, 0.005283139180392027, 0.0037820455618202686, -0.01766876131296158, -0.02780982479453087, -0.03604869544506073, -0.06045454367995262, -0.008664046414196491, -0.039988428354263306, -0.026683304458856583, -0.04030013456940651, -0.009271462447941303, -0.007526970002800226, 0.0410432405769825, 0.002618104685097933, -0.002829568227753043, -0.011364893987774849, -0.005189700983464718, -0.004259510897099972, -0.028215723112225533, -0.017190204933285713, 0.0071050929836928844, -0.0662931278347969, 0.007723870687186718, 0.00998967606574297, 0.07510682195425034, -0.007028175517916679, 0.0023644661996513605, 0.0020121915731579065, -0.04507521167397499, -0.01664692722260952, 0.0015993491979315877, 0.03988008573651314, -0.022811997681856155, 0.03275547921657562, -0.07487019896507263, 0.0563119538128376, -0.0014290167018771172, 0.0004960384103469551, 0.03174265846610069, 0.04485104978084564, -0.03378861024975777, -0.04083801060914993, -0.07078816741704941, 0.06724373251199722, 0.022451892495155334, 0.09088544547557831, 0.066909059882164, -0.03908674046397209, -0.013707766309380531, 0.003756703110411763, 0.03464093804359436, -0.03733397647738457, -0.012257058173418045, 0.016401197761297226, 0.00383150321431458, 0.033105719834566116, -0.1001492515206337, -0.06677267700433731, -0.03821614012122154, -0.011655825190246105, 0.0051541198045015335, 0.07677203416824341, -0.043283700942993164, -0.0673677995800972, -0.04506769776344299, -0.011605339124798775, 0.043529629707336426, 0.02917376533150673, -0.015473551116883755, 0.00870685838162899, 0.012800706550478935, -0.022367799654603004, -0.0386640727519989, -0.07126476615667343, -0.06868823617696762, -0.018477829173207283, -0.011406872421503067, -0.01871824637055397, -0.008812781423330307, 0.0013949042186141014, -0.013148780912160873, -0.07526932656764984, 0.02872985042631626, 0.03249316290020943, 0.02027139812707901, 0.017374498769640923, -0.008507509715855122, -0.02323482558131218, 0.012728676199913025, 0.02956940419971943, -0.02830786630511284, 0.03517109528183937, 0.03298809379339218, 0.027455728501081467, 0.056864045560359955, -0.024955956265330315, 0.012734034098684788, -0.03503946587443352, 0.023394785821437836, 0.04422822967171669, -0.004519965033978224, -0.071869857609272, 0.003298030234873295, -0.009796081110835075, -0.03432437777519226, -0.03380313143134117, 0.007409858517348766, 0.011747119016945362, 0.017987050116062164, -0.03294318541884422, -0.023114385083317757, -0.03150792047381401, 0.027124036103487015, -0.04748089984059334, 0.035588912665843964, 0.0009406714816577733, 0.054104916751384735, -0.06870295852422714, 0.008626959286630154, -0.053967852145433426, 0.02345224842429161, -0.015070771798491478, -0.008287791162729263, -0.006491241976618767, 0.012508489191532135, 0.0330861397087574, -0.013744953088462353, 0.004085239954292774, 0.054259978234767914, -0.07486508041620255, 0.022576579824090004, -0.03275478631258011, 0.009486014023423195, 0.04606564715504646, -0.06328650563955307, -0.015851425006985664, -0.02188660204410553, 0.023949922993779182, -4.031617572763935e-05, 0.05578097328543663, -0.02271854132413864, -0.01878168433904648, 0.021055981516838074, 0.00017441986710764468, 0.008948189206421375, -0.011469131335616112, 0.055152036249637604, 0.00010882628703257069, 0.00335463578812778, 0.05058009922504425, -0.059420403093099594, 0.011568054556846619, -0.014711027964949608, 0.052634332329034805, 0.07590629905462265, -0.019695740193128586, -0.008968869224190712, -0.010101264342665672, -0.008916869759559631, 0.026731230318546295, 0.00874240230768919, -0.0215692687779665, 0.01577943004667759, 0.03342336043715477, 0.05818060413002968, -0.024404259398579597, -0.0037404089234769344, -0.06890836358070374, 0.03245837241411209, -0.0037525759544223547, -0.05387597158551216, -0.04833091422915459, -6.017262644337178e-33, -0.02021808922290802, -0.02237987332046032, -0.01112352591007948, 0.02877647988498211, -0.03875826671719551, 0.04836089164018631, -0.051217563450336456, -0.022184576839208603, -0.021830350160598755, 0.05195898935198784, 0.002676922595128417, 0.04358672723174095, -0.00809386931359768, 0.028161173686385155, 0.011224580928683281, 0.015261729247868061, 0.04692286252975464, 0.015917396172881126, 0.0033057332038879395, 0.005458836443722248, 0.027028530836105347, 0.044843122363090515, 0.0601046048104763, -0.014818216674029827, 0.0272995438426733, -0.05613178014755249, 0.036072343587875366, -0.011531650088727474, 0.027504321187734604, 0.04016905277967453, -0.013899167068302631, 0.069176085293293, 0.059597790241241455, 0.005753652658313513, -0.010289314202964306, 0.07106216251850128, -0.04702455922961235, -0.10069756209850311, -0.021088140085339546, -0.04642244055867195, -0.00978394690901041, -0.020965581759810448, 0.047597188502550125, -0.012775152921676636, -0.020882809534668922, -0.022406872361898422, 0.08781497925519943, 0.005432302597910166, 0.01731792278587818, -0.031183257699012756, -0.08552456647157669, 0.004305459558963776, 0.029480844736099243, 0.001689433236606419, -0.027798833325505257, 0.031729232519865036, 0.00449231406673789, 0.04262318089604378, -0.04175964370369911, 0.031068038195371628, -0.058001015335321426, 0.0401388518512249, -0.006245605181902647, -0.03514236956834793, -0.017712078988552094, 0.07315602898597717, -0.021792670711874962, -0.01465427316725254, 0.00483889551833272, -0.00038871870492585003, 0.04674074426293373, -0.00964701920747757, 0.046349212527275085, 0.057381629943847656, 0.04301220551133156, 0.006608211435377598, -0.04410295933485031, 0.07667698711156845, 0.004384816624224186, 0.02696850150823593, 0.05624451860785484, -0.03313646465539932, -0.02860603854060173, -0.039889827370643616, -0.03656536340713501, 0.016464298591017723, -0.03640228882431984, -0.03275446966290474, 0.03581264615058899, -0.029452763497829437, -0.00048329902347177267, -0.01967335119843483, 0.0006031037191860378, -0.04159760847687721, -0.003202936379238963, 0.01880502514541149, -0.0298555176705122, 0.0016792913665995002, 0.019364267587661743, 0.03012782335281372, -0.026644887402653694, -0.0016116981860250235, -0.006761953700333834, 0.034568317234516144, 0.008794031105935574, -0.022231094539165497, 0.07876692712306976, -0.02509385347366333, -0.02261081337928772, -0.023178650066256523, 0.007486123591661453, -0.07551756501197815, -0.013957894407212734, 0.03519068658351898, -0.02488059364259243, 0.019737405702471733, -0.0035090716555714607, 0.05762944743037224, 0.05480911582708359, -0.018180644139647484, -0.045364655554294586, -0.08541856706142426, 0.010899833403527737, 0.018502039834856987, 0.0009596218587830663, 0.02567749097943306, -0.06967156380414963, 0.033029522746801376, 0.002490971004590392, -0.033086229115724564, -0.01772787794470787, -0.012105853296816349, 2.707170096982736e-07, 0.03362042084336281, -0.01084048394113779, -0.004531444516032934, -0.029992789030075073, -0.009231134317815304, 0.010806290432810783, 0.00334874726831913, 0.05411125347018242, -0.045778125524520874, 0.06951200217008591, 0.033440183848142624, 0.005169916432350874, 0.03371160849928856, -0.00881812535226345, -0.08571931719779968, 0.0007859859033487737, -0.12819097936153412, -0.018809035420417786, -0.07241126894950867, -0.009445185773074627, 0.08017789572477341, 0.033173851668834686, 0.026459962129592896, -0.03670218214392662, -0.004557787906378508, -0.025687025859951973, 0.03236854076385498, -0.02436860091984272, 0.00021612281852867454, 0.021502600982785225, 0.0205000638961792, 0.0032460906077176332, 0.02272946760058403, -0.005080969072878361, -0.02407933585345745, 0.021815579384565353, 0.053883474320173264, 0.001377383596263826, -0.008358918130397797, -0.010755687952041626, 0.013900426216423512, 0.011555369012057781, -0.0015423980075865984, -0.10779237747192383, 0.07633195072412491, -0.03407089039683342, -0.02763158269226551, -0.08924242109060287, 0.04324844479560852, 0.008481986820697784, 0.05731653794646263, 0.007474634796380997, -0.027104921638965607, -0.010110135190188885, 0.027705447748303413, -0.023737967014312744, -0.010575076565146446, -0.03926801681518555, -0.030177295207977295, 0.003696921980008483, -0.021093081682920456, 0.018191928043961525, -0.08742186427116394, -0.021191202104091644, 0.024844780564308167, -0.06533501297235489, 0.012927397154271603, 2.767806141476696e-34, -0.005465550813823938, 0.005881850607693195, 0.0232828501611948, -0.027866659685969353, 0.0010506168473511934, 0.037448663264513016, -0.01044829934835434, 0.012035572901368141, -0.011115279980003834, -0.06359747052192688, -0.005523483734577894]
616
616
['Hwaran Lee', 'Geonmin Kim', 'Ho-Gyeong Kim', 'Sang-Hoon Oh', 'Soo-Young Lee']
1606.03207v2
Convolutional neural networks (CNNs) with convolutional and pooling operations along the frequency axis have been proposed to attain invariance to frequency shifts of features. However, this is inappropriate with regard to the fact that acoustic features vary in frequency. In this paper, we contend that convolution along the time axis is more effective. We also propose the addition of an intermap pooling (IMP) layer to deep CNNs. In this layer, filters in each group extract common but spectrally variant features, then the layer pools the feature maps of each group. As a result, the proposed IMP CNN can achieve insensitivity to spectral variations characteristic of different speakers and utterances. The effectiveness of the IMP CNN architecture is demonstrated on several LVCSR tasks. Even without speaker adaptation techniques, the architecture achieved a WER of 12.7% on the SWB part of the Hub5'2000 evaluation test set, which is competitive with other state-of-the-art methods.
Deep CNNs along the Time Axis with Intermap Pooling for Robustness to Spectral Variations
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1606.03207v2
Title Deep CNNs along Time Axis Intermap Pooling Robustness Spectral Variations Summary Convolutional neural network CNNs convolutional pooling operation along frequency axis proposed attain invariance frequency shift feature However inappropriate regard fact acoustic feature vary frequency paper contend convolution along time axis effective also propose addition intermap pooling IMP layer deep CNNs layer filter group extract common spectrally variant feature layer pool feature map group result proposed IMP CNN achieve insensitivity spectral variation characteristic different speaker utterance effectiveness IMP CNN architecture demonstrated several LVCSR task Even without speaker adaptation technique architecture achieved WER 127 SWB part Hub52000 evaluation test set competitive stateoftheart method Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.006704570259898901, -0.0024397079832851887, 0.002484459662809968, 0.047621820122003555, -0.01375389751046896, -0.014747148379683495, 0.04437816143035889, 0.00294478889554739, -0.07536257058382034, 0.023285526782274246, -0.07044918090105057, -0.013373246416449547, 0.03883817791938782, 0.020465411245822906, 0.004897863604128361, -0.03407517075538635, -0.010263723321259022, 0.025215255096554756, 0.010145358741283417, -0.02199825830757618, 0.029807396233081818, -0.036734215915203094, -0.07203567028045654, 0.01403614692389965, -0.023149121552705765, -0.005807599984109402, -0.017666801810264587, -0.010625863447785378, 0.040038395673036575, 0.015633475035429, 0.016399109736084938, -0.009822217747569084, 0.03152431547641754, 0.028076007962226868, 2.1704620394302765e-06, 0.03536481410264969, -0.036317046731710434, -0.01503050047904253, 0.003215271979570389, -0.014112305827438831, -0.00361642031930387, 0.03999407961964607, -0.06793589890003204, 0.01469707116484642, -0.02468073181807995, -0.004660549573600292, 0.0004369759699329734, 0.03880911320447922, 0.0010354205733165145, 0.05528324469923973, 0.0007383170886896551, -0.029424170032143593, -0.025619864463806152, -0.007024771999567747, -0.045509520918130875, -0.06546502560377121, -0.030654439702630043, -0.026057668030261993, -0.044680867344141006, -0.03510456532239914, -0.025477958843111992, 0.039080288261175156, 0.014368051663041115, 0.017410384491086006, 0.06220465525984764, -0.02055467665195465, -0.05407772213220596, -0.0371355302631855, -0.01579943113029003, 0.08502888679504395, -0.008785613812506199, -0.0002787367848213762, 0.0021682472433894873, 0.03250367194414139, 0.006662892643362284, -0.008485467173159122, -0.025144770741462708, -0.012139125727117062, 0.030360016971826553, -0.02162293531000614, -0.08975164592266083, 0.03778832033276558, -0.006691706832498312, -0.02108558639883995, -0.030323851853609085, -0.03046346642076969, 0.009974023327231407, 0.012342134490609169, -0.005608558189123869, -0.04752611368894577, -0.019054841250181198, 0.005772903095930815, 0.026255717501044273, 0.027588415890932083, -0.025663932785391808, -0.05119605362415314, -0.04522453993558884, -0.07621289044618607, -0.0011747204698622227, -0.027954401448369026, 0.012927121482789516, 0.00547480583190918, -0.09542132169008255, -0.010874771513044834, 0.0308153685182333, 0.037783652544021606, -0.05292356386780739, 0.01413611602038145, -0.012316158972680569, -0.039670560508966446, -0.011526190675795078, 0.0165609922260046, -0.0007992095779627562, 0.007940758019685745, 0.020698942244052887, -0.003855922957882285, -0.04423961788415909, -0.006658510304987431, -0.051499176770448685, 0.0058601778000593185, -0.04296087473630905, 0.04554571583867073, -0.0364663302898407, -0.03787502646446228, 0.017141491174697876, 0.05895242840051651, -0.006176825147122145, 0.07742687314748764, -0.03958546370267868, -0.06753144413232803, 0.0202825628221035, 0.036877650767564774, 0.03813936188817024, 0.013931361958384514, 0.02832314930856228, 0.05978257209062576, 0.025488976389169693, 0.029459210112690926, -0.03783250227570534, 0.013377219438552856, -0.0012504137121140957, -0.019190894439816475, -0.006155829876661301, -0.06827834248542786, 0.04112795367836952, -0.020370790734887123, -0.0022274937946349382, 0.025402195751667023, -0.027999071404337883, -0.014406961388885975, 0.04229983314871788, 0.04853863641619682, -0.020091334357857704, 0.019420655444264412, 0.1090523824095726, -0.009975269436836243, 0.049569711089134216, 0.029229318723082542, 0.06630135327577591, -0.08135109394788742, -0.009857254102826118, -0.06444273889064789, -0.025284448638558388, 0.020648377016186714, -0.003196575678884983, -0.004781914409250021, -0.06438925862312317, -0.040400560945272446, -0.013071537017822266, 0.02786637470126152, 0.021583938971161842, 0.013375394977629185, -0.003675331361591816, -0.06723183393478394, 0.035840775817632675, 0.047148436307907104, 0.0495598241686821, 0.03585450351238251, 0.009424181655049324, 0.01737876422703266, 0.004887827206403017, 0.01888333261013031, 0.002817027037963271, 0.06907512992620468, 0.0170205757021904, -0.019697217270731926, -0.04656023532152176, 0.0025112254079431295, -0.01810593158006668, -0.029009917750954628, -0.006894528865814209, -0.0009378882241435349, -0.003533286741003394, 0.01809990406036377, 0.0036672395654022694, 0.019620511680841446, 0.030236558988690376, 0.04731633886694908, -0.009037716314196587, -0.025646358728408813, -0.0018519654404371977, -0.01692228578031063, -0.0077355410903692245, 0.022893913090229034, -0.04567603021860123, -0.013773552142083645, 0.0019182958640158176, -0.05597853288054466, 0.025743311271071434, 0.0033811377361416817, 0.02296200580894947, 0.0049408539198338985, 0.043894775211811066, -0.05644410103559494, -0.03251945599913597, 0.008381160907447338, -0.05241229012608528, 0.025159716606140137, -0.043122779577970505, 0.019269129261374474, 0.006726640276610851, 0.0014028024161234498, 0.04360947385430336, -0.03073214180767536, -0.002176330890506506, -0.004715397953987122, -0.011790900491178036, 0.03968457505106926, 0.06807000190019608, 0.03556390479207039, -0.010487392544746399, 0.011196550913155079, 0.04259176924824715, -0.025999659672379494, -0.0421508327126503, 0.03773471713066101, -0.038025740534067154, -0.0035265597980469465, 0.034866541624069214, -0.048622529953718185, 0.03673581779003143, 0.029933154582977295, 0.004225943703204393, -0.06446544080972672, 0.06771653145551682, 0.015211307443678379, 0.04649130627512932, -0.01004087459295988, 0.013160577043890953, 0.019313570111989975, 0.025401730090379715, 0.023916402831673622, -0.03712908551096916, 0.026865284889936447, -0.011147337034344673, 0.005430492106825113, 0.07301744073629379, -2.5592096335458336e-06, -0.06994060426950455, 0.017244413495063782, 0.08461251854896545, -0.025081735104322433, -0.0301883015781641, -0.03522530570626259, -0.0242508165538311, -0.031148668378591537, 0.0006792045314796269, -0.07627931237220764, 0.01864527352154255, -0.02337827906012535, -0.0370955765247345, -0.01487646158784628, -0.0015116241993382573, 0.019563322886824608, -0.035390499979257584, -0.05860007181763649, 0.03199273720383644, -0.02867460437119007, -0.007830741815268993, -0.021189039573073387, -0.018416952341794968, -0.011075682938098907, 0.003695146879181266, -0.016840891912579536, 0.01721905916929245, 0.003638480557128787, -0.025071129202842712, -0.06066533178091049, 0.02635256014764309, -0.056596893817186356, 0.023803221061825752, 0.016214367002248764, 0.033603932708501816, -0.03605411946773529, -0.03773759305477142, 0.03826330974698067, 0.007267639506608248, 0.028020339086651802, 0.06559861451387405, 0.01688144914805889, -0.021092871204018593, 0.012471583671867847, -0.02256052941083908, 0.04075222089886665, 0.026632487773895264, 0.020645931363105774, -0.018587861210107803, 0.08634386956691742, -0.05156964808702469, 0.004874334204941988, 0.056989315897226334, 0.049438007175922394, -6.032828878232976e-06, -0.030294625088572502, -0.0512344166636467, -0.024327578023076057, -0.007394370622932911, -0.028101742267608643, -0.003417408559471369, -0.05731867253780365, -0.015214215964078903, -0.03228500857949257, -0.00645153084769845, -0.023788318037986755, -0.0447453036904335, -0.064058817923069, -0.10258564352989197, -0.021947495639324188, -0.0047421762719750404, -0.049545302987098694, -0.006693642120808363, 0.004516758024692535, -0.013604143634438515, -0.021570203825831413, -0.01815521903336048, -0.00012722291285172105, -0.04495196044445038, 0.05162755772471428, -0.016023356467485428, -0.03394167497754097, -0.04250027611851692, 0.02078070491552353, -0.04780912399291992, 1.8703858586377464e-05, -0.010063327848911285, 0.003255966817960143, -0.01751326210796833, -0.02173515036702156, 0.019900264218449593, 0.0023185359314084053, 0.03500743210315704, 0.01911437325179577, -0.017038291320204735, 0.02399364300072193, -0.008403388783335686, 0.05718838423490524, 0.03390220180153847, 0.07253211736679077, -0.004461008124053478, 0.043654948472976685, 0.060525909066200256, -0.03501255810260773, -0.0010863158386200666, 0.02504604123532772, -0.09341251850128174, 0.060864418745040894, -0.0033399579115211964, 0.007246294058859348, -0.02230159565806389, -0.003685403848066926, 0.030492499470710754, -0.04725930094718933, 0.06936229765415192, 0.02323034219443798, -0.020403286442160606, -0.07972276955842972, 0.026149120181798935, 0.03172605112195015, -0.04004114866256714, -0.006042212713509798, -0.03441353887319565, -0.012821707874536514, -0.009327328763902187, 0.049011774361133575, -0.017871800810098648, 0.02243003621697426, 0.04716358333826065, -0.050340987741947174, -0.016963614150881767, 0.04590342566370964, 0.04581664130091667, -0.02167101763188839, -0.00878301914781332, -0.010484958067536354, -0.020354732871055603, -0.009717687964439392, 0.09964853525161743, -0.001729740877635777, 0.011691452004015446, -0.05894497036933899, 0.08146107941865921, -0.049292366951704025, -0.0009166752570308745, -0.015131327323615551, -0.045252736657857895, 0.019858084619045258, 0.03734774887561798, 0.04890628159046173, -0.039394669234752655, -0.054153360426425934, 0.03413907811045647, -0.024691114202141762, 0.005768624134361744, -0.01350051537156105, 0.04082366079092026, 0.015651319175958633, -0.019032539799809456, 0.03805560991168022, 0.0795975923538208, -0.02619132585823536, 0.029438579455018044, 0.011264286935329437, -0.0029052074532955885, -0.0007778510334901512, 0.05613258108496666, -0.05809389799833298, 0.04358503594994545, -0.003798495279625058, 0.020632890984416008, 0.002099754521623254, -0.007786313071846962, 0.036544155329465866, 0.0032432570587843657, 0.018085019662976265, -0.05349363386631012, -0.005210599396377802, 0.007889030501246452, 0.034912463277578354, -0.0653044655919075, -0.004615688230842352, -0.014119879342615604, -0.05217479541897774, 0.02135152369737625, 0.013552727177739143, -0.03398267552256584, 0.006661343388259411, 0.04133309796452522, -5.265379877528176e-05, 0.010494601912796497, 0.0020626357290893793, 0.08491039276123047, -0.01489882729947567, -0.002147875027731061, 0.031953174620866776, -0.035438619554042816, 0.021056534722447395, -0.004041346721351147, -0.07232911139726639, -0.027008280158042908, 0.01783292181789875, -0.06287262588739395, 0.0036811651661992073, 0.0794079452753067, -0.0431327149271965, 0.007188777439296246, 0.030546503141522408, -0.05238477885723114, -0.04715574160218239, 0.030295707285404205, 0.05669627711176872, -0.012500700540840626, 0.002493841340765357, 0.03348415717482567, -0.06664356589317322, 0.0716140866279602, -0.013014133088290691, -0.011921156197786331, 0.03154556453227997, -0.035005297511816025, 0.01484636776149273, -0.051949065178632736, 0.050430189818143845, 0.06715136766433716, 0.016449222341179848, 0.007521210703998804, 0.06375935673713684, 0.012432846240699291, 0.012389621697366238, -0.026953110471367836, -0.018552076071500778, 0.017409520223736763, 0.020906176418066025, -0.0051955971866846085, 0.03842395544052124, 0.04483383521437645, -0.03339259698987007, 0.07875983417034149, 0.11588679999113083, -0.017936808988451958, -0.017811095342040062, -0.042608968913555145, 0.02450082078576088, 0.0032382316421717405, 0.024887217208743095, 0.017424410209059715, 0.01926046796143055, 0.04831904545426369, 0.01290365681052208, 0.0011053900234401226, -0.032397009432315826, 0.008697155863046646, 0.022738933563232422, -0.007562010549008846, -0.006700864527374506, -0.011904862709343433, -0.015481309033930302, 0.03880411759018898, -0.021204521879553795, 0.017647534608840942, 0.0507807657122612, 0.030296333134174347, 0.0024638986214995384, -0.012469357810914516, -0.04118102043867111, 0.06253200769424438, 0.07383906841278076, -0.018401218578219414, -0.02506658248603344, -0.002821272937580943, 0.013068713247776031, 0.03645045682787895, 0.0015441237483173609, -0.033452559262514114, 0.039711058139801025, -0.01580185443162918, 0.005497423000633717, -0.06405419856309891, 0.00038299543666653335, 0.005872041918337345, -0.00886364933103323, 0.022442370653152466, -0.033689938485622406, 0.06972350925207138, -0.04143723100423813, 0.05715133622288704, -0.018734129145741463, -0.004067952279001474, 0.02103622630238533, -0.011123817414045334, -0.010147470980882645, 0.023784363642334938, -0.043556153774261475, 0.043268706649541855, -0.015154017135500908, -0.024937322363257408, -6.194093361557328e-33, -0.018918056041002274, 0.008694213815033436, 0.00043929117964580655, -0.02675338089466095, -0.026293715462088585, 0.012621527537703514, 0.009884139522910118, -0.008356383070349693, -0.03410568833351135, -0.002176308538764715, -0.008023402653634548, 0.042768556624650955, 0.040689777582883835, 0.00941606517881155, 0.01295821275562048, -0.028347104787826538, 0.06312242150306702, -0.04595786705613136, 0.05764135345816612, -0.02255398966372013, 0.042892612516880035, 0.023618092760443687, 0.050416793674230576, -0.028464756906032562, -0.11114369332790375, 0.03610125184059143, 0.013163531199097633, -0.03471493348479271, -0.010235478170216084, 0.015995798632502556, 0.01778819039463997, 0.04078974947333336, -0.022326070815324783, -0.01884339191019535, -0.0011172967497259378, 0.007346623577177525, -0.09811627864837646, -0.019343767315149307, -0.0584321953356266, 0.09656327217817307, 0.017096180468797684, -0.011599467135965824, 0.07011893391609192, 0.012624614872038364, -0.039254505187273026, -0.06814411282539368, 0.021627306938171387, -0.036055341362953186, 0.006427590735256672, -0.027814602479338646, 0.0010205538710579276, 0.043945278972387314, -0.008527264930307865, -0.02047126367688179, 0.011430256068706512, 0.02748950757086277, -0.03915179520845413, -0.0020194435492157936, -0.09021911770105362, 0.04064808040857315, -0.019254721701145172, 0.030110888183116913, 0.02363492175936699, 0.023354435339570045, 0.011335063725709915, 0.007397189270704985, 0.040206506848335266, -0.037079572677612305, 0.027856016531586647, -0.04194923862814903, 0.016527364030480385, 0.04902279004454613, 0.03983848914504051, -0.003570736385881901, 0.050857413560152054, -0.05224158242344856, -0.011260136030614376, -0.003537947777658701, 0.007338720839470625, 0.011927586980164051, -0.039567988365888596, 0.0647682175040245, -0.022605817764997482, 0.01618962734937668, -0.0078013683669269085, -0.00805493351072073, -0.04171956703066826, -0.021065302193164825, 0.035242218524217606, -0.04344341903924942, 0.06805531680583954, 0.019711198285222054, 0.02526691183447838, -0.030631069093942642, 0.033034585416316986, 0.02101639285683632, -0.028922230005264282, -0.00293878186494112, 0.03685878962278366, -0.021675322204828262, -0.016980299726128578, -0.021147122606635094, 0.06868477910757065, 0.026747848838567734, -0.003319627372547984, -0.03372635319828987, 0.05586489289999008, 0.09113570302724838, -0.005720615852624178, -0.05090104788541794, 0.014860210940241814, -0.032058656215667725, 0.05645710602402687, 0.04655491188168526, 0.013672860339283943, -0.008748075924813747, -0.008639693260192871, 0.0456102192401886, -0.02989303693175316, 0.010403268970549107, -0.017293887212872505, -0.027868298813700676, -0.0024131867103278637, 0.06380443274974823, -0.06949906051158905, 0.018232841044664383, -0.012087260372936726, -0.03813154995441437, 0.038878317922353745, -0.033995337784290314, -0.0280957892537117, -0.01657884567975998, 2.9584759886347456e-07, -0.08202849328517914, -0.044729284942150116, 0.04486202821135521, -0.07754761725664139, 0.014194004237651825, -0.008720127865672112, -0.01234013494104147, 0.014027330093085766, -0.007808458060026169, 0.017775608226656914, 0.018391650170087814, -0.00278203166089952, 0.038656096905469894, 0.04746951907873154, -0.02618977427482605, -0.02593280002474785, -0.056477587670087814, 0.00990072637796402, -0.00404101749882102, 0.03869868442416191, 0.02453012578189373, 0.08317288011312485, 0.011655979789793491, -0.05557704344391823, 0.05742083862423897, -0.002725974889472127, -0.012680049985647202, 0.028054166585206985, 0.011893698945641518, -0.025101104751229286, 0.0023697514552623034, 0.01867140643298626, -0.022920282557606697, 0.019323091953992844, -0.039513472467660904, 0.040276288986206055, 0.02547460049390793, -0.005829124245792627, -0.030018096789717674, -0.0681595578789711, 0.003694149199873209, 0.047056328505277634, -0.015326866880059242, 0.05140072479844093, 0.07296402752399445, 0.005310394801199436, -0.03267951309680939, -0.07598801702260971, -0.036886949092149734, 0.010797088965773582, 0.027979929000139236, 0.028268611058592796, 0.013864441774785519, -0.024150628596544266, 0.006126870401203632, -0.014504370279610157, -0.0432550311088562, -0.04012784734368324, -0.013588584959506989, 0.05744871869683266, -0.0593608096241951, -0.007131599355489016, -0.054258354008197784, -0.07501234114170074, 0.06635373085737228, 0.02903454378247261, -0.04480209946632385, 2.0406503870103177e-34, -0.023638147860765457, 0.0008598496206104755, 0.005787629168480635, -0.007746945600956678, -0.04680721461772919, -0.01673074997961521, 0.010026567615568638, 0.0155641445890069, -0.015562620013952255, -0.004083762876689434, -0.04649147763848305]
617
617
['Dimitrios Alikaniotis', 'Helen Yannakoudakis', 'Marek Rei']
1606.04289v2
Automated Text Scoring (ATS) provides a cost-effective and consistent alternative to human marking. However, in order to achieve good performance, the predictive features of the system need to be manually engineered by human experts. We introduce a model that forms word representations by learning the extent to which specific words contribute to the text's score. Using Long-Short Term Memory networks to represent the meaning of texts, we demonstrate that a fully automated framework is able to achieve excellent results over similar approaches. In an attempt to make our results more interpretable, and inspired by recent advances in visualizing neural networks, we introduce a novel method for identifying the regions of the text that the model has found more discriminative.
Automatic Text Scoring Using Neural Networks
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1606.04289v2
Title Automatic Text Scoring Using Neural Networks Summary Automated Text Scoring ATS provides costeffective consistent alternative human marking However order achieve good performance predictive feature system need manually engineered human expert introduce model form word representation learning extent specific word contribute text score Using LongShort Term Memory network represent meaning text demonstrate fully automated framework able achieve excellent result similar approach attempt make result interpretable inspired recent advance visualizing neural network introduce novel method identifying region text model found discriminative Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.03240957856178284, -0.006253769621253014, -0.019459666684269905, 0.02273603342473507, -0.02264132909476757, -0.011064781807363033, 0.018832484260201454, 0.024143334478139877, 0.0169227197766304, -0.059367869049310684, -0.016813043504953384, 0.010927054099738598, 0.061029329895973206, 0.0573597326874733, 0.007465907372534275, -0.03169374540448189, -0.010010731406509876, 0.02612670138478279, 0.02460837922990322, 0.03335961699485779, 0.03129490092396736, 0.00426724087446928, 0.01212682668119669, 0.029731139540672302, -0.026713350787758827, -0.005650108680129051, 0.022880861535668373, -0.04777051880955696, 0.020106922835111618, -0.029628241434693336, 0.009162906557321548, 0.05440618842840195, -0.028390824794769287, 0.009083354845643044, 2.283526328028529e-06, -0.016384590417146683, -0.0196900125592947, -0.035268377512693405, 0.04507741332054138, 0.006980569567531347, 0.049547020345926285, 0.020338650792837143, 0.0016066370299085975, -0.007133593782782555, -0.04499923065304756, 0.005172079429030418, 0.026069533079862595, 0.054065726697444916, 0.07299970090389252, 0.0402798056602478, -0.008439105935394764, -0.039301130920648575, 0.01853150688111782, 0.038129307329654694, -0.0024886038154363632, -0.03062565065920353, 0.0035334632266312838, 0.032017841935157776, 0.005129703786224127, 0.013950088992714882, -0.011921362020075321, 0.0671728327870369, -0.0009526778594590724, -0.06098712980747223, 0.0549943782389164, 0.04150523617863655, 0.0005878977826796472, 0.018020998686552048, 0.003465938614681363, 0.05104491487145424, 0.0011233522091060877, -0.0049764905124902725, -0.0021358169615268707, -0.001489850226789713, -0.03593536093831062, -0.017591511830687523, -0.021588845178484917, -0.0005715165170840919, -0.037408310920000076, -0.008957778103649616, -0.0038891530130058527, 0.07391687482595444, -0.0029721108730882406, 0.04695910960435867, 0.029169833287596703, -0.004401329904794693, -0.011299042962491512, -0.03128267079591751, -0.010911685414612293, -0.010607102885842323, 0.002120784018188715, -0.04256138578057289, 0.08995616436004639, 0.07067054510116577, 0.007577046751976013, -0.01321674045175314, 0.0007052386063151062, -0.07702261209487915, 0.06057808920741081, -0.07634767144918442, 0.04948045313358307, -0.013851589523255825, -0.006407591048628092, 0.02945352904498577, -0.0487729050219059, 0.049504220485687256, 0.04651698097586632, -0.001376587082631886, -0.01293165422976017, 0.02892407961189747, -0.04425618052482605, -0.04526462033390999, -0.034394100308418274, 0.026209985837340355, 0.01581815630197525, -0.010652600787580013, -0.10210707038640976, -0.04989919438958168, -0.019816573709249496, 0.006660080049186945, 0.04791725426912308, 0.07564122974872589, -0.011879290454089642, -0.0074744801968336105, -0.001954152947291732, -0.013481349684298038, -0.06286539137363434, 0.008888233453035355, -0.03278981149196625, 0.04830608144402504, 0.03775722533464432, 0.043593429028987885, 0.039181649684906006, 0.041143689304590225, 0.017975039780139923, 0.044015757739543915, 0.012935525737702847, -0.005106284748762846, -0.018221016973257065, -0.043865349143743515, -0.026814736425876617, -0.006959743332117796, -0.0405949130654335, -0.021049587056040764, -0.017345566302537918, -0.01658834144473076, -0.02819199487566948, -0.012280961498618126, -0.002067290246486664, 0.056231312453746796, -0.0031066748779267073, 0.056196630001068115, -0.02383345365524292, -0.01723221316933632, 0.05844353511929512, 0.010486584156751633, 0.038151346147060394, -0.027889328077435493, 0.060227908194065094, 0.07885783165693283, 0.04867761954665184, 0.004574172664433718, 0.04888907074928284, 0.032902467995882034, -0.017154505476355553, -0.037856727838516235, -0.03888977691531181, -0.008277161978185177, 0.007989504374563694, 0.037038348615169525, -0.031188493594527245, 0.04352673888206482, 0.02783259004354477, -0.004188596736639738, 0.060152567923069, 0.09304268658161163, 0.047590818256139755, 0.029197674244642258, 0.007039389573037624, -0.007745336275547743, 0.00941183976829052, -0.019088618457317352, 0.005722117610275745, 0.03259974345564842, -0.043999914079904556, -0.00970774982124567, -0.014110494405031204, 0.007808445021510124, -0.004493097309023142, -0.06523533165454865, -0.0022884185891598463, -0.003473057644441724, 0.018694108352065086, -0.031387005001306534, 0.07217321544885635, -0.007368467282503843, -0.029139172285795212, -0.04348045587539673, -0.02901490591466427, -0.00246409117244184, 0.01980622112751007, -0.03110211156308651, -0.01201458740979433, 0.05046713352203369, 0.049739960581064224, -0.05396861955523491, 0.05372165888547897, -0.024904530495405197, -0.0035172412171959877, 0.01744667999446392, -0.013811693526804447, -0.02696261927485466, -0.04611731693148613, -0.07915731519460678, -0.00921450462192297, 0.041857365518808365, -0.013729071244597435, -0.0031212030444294214, -0.0362933911383152, 0.04125314578413963, 0.026759911328554153, 0.042445410043001175, -0.08610095083713531, 0.041913922876119614, 0.014029447920620441, -0.014789784327149391, -0.00352042680606246, 0.012648370116949081, -0.018105454742908478, 0.050336677581071854, 0.01747448928654194, 0.012590671889483929, 0.027034711092710495, -0.02632005885243416, -0.0397801548242569, -0.041238054633140564, -0.0415608212351799, 0.0014445652486756444, 0.01374892145395279, -0.03919271379709244, 0.015610218979418278, 0.019727259874343872, 0.0011970432242378592, -0.033969536423683167, -0.012311677448451519, -0.04090423509478569, -0.030769402161240578, -0.030895154923200607, 0.042558882385492325, -0.016029365360736847, -0.02868829295039177, -0.07798708975315094, 0.062538281083107, 0.011120202951133251, 0.05559240281581879, -0.054806869477033615, -0.04453505575656891, 0.04492487385869026, -0.009334774687886238, -0.031150447204709053, -0.03290620446205139, -0.007900841534137726, 0.029398251324892044, 0.007053534034639597, 0.02219834178686142, -0.040463391691446304, -0.02723998948931694, -0.07154176384210587, -0.0027290345169603825, 0.002215166110545397, -0.007327839732170105, 0.03125159814953804, -0.03251948580145836, 0.01702376827597618, -0.029993653297424316, -0.05044843256473541, 0.008637621998786926, 0.030746370553970337, -0.04079653322696686, 0.0721483901143074, 0.003323314245790243, 0.018909702077507973, -0.0369180291891098, -0.019323963671922684, -0.034956399351358414, 0.04812856391072273, 0.11506444960832596, -0.09115850180387497, -0.06853285431861877, 0.03230773285031319, 0.00408207718282938, 0.0028854464180767536, 0.02412165328860283, -0.062178388237953186, 0.0049216775223612785, 0.011407892219722271, -0.01599087193608284, 0.07774394005537033, 0.02257165126502514, 0.020884376019239426, 0.01938285119831562, -0.0206211619079113, 0.0032670951914042234, -0.01762906089425087, -0.02798011526465416, 0.07958202809095383, 0.027862543240189552, -0.04761744663119316, -0.0017723430646583438, 0.02298831194639206, 0.05439695343375206, 0.0027439335826784372, 0.004795073065906763, 0.042516302317380905, -0.05890648439526558, 0.013916602358222008, -0.08344114571809769, -0.009228023700416088, -0.004502924159169197, 0.022380013018846512, -0.0012449900386855006, -0.03764359652996063, 0.04166501760482788, -0.007898475043475628, 0.031159808859229088, -0.07836174964904785, -0.0118567431345582, -0.025440871715545654, 0.06403762102127075, 0.0038249269127845764, 0.0144315455108881, -0.017556678503751755, -0.034153763204813004, -0.0021394186187535524, -0.025421231985092163, 0.012094254605472088, -0.030062224715948105, 0.03083469532430172, -0.007775416132062674, -0.006516930181533098, -0.012480304576456547, -0.010061756707727909, -0.014012962579727173, -0.010522588156163692, -0.01758452318608761, 0.016584189608693123, 0.03866712749004364, -0.0032707732170820236, -0.008845897391438484, 0.04011005163192749, 0.028959471732378006, 0.02831077016890049, -0.06143013387918472, -0.008694810792803764, 0.015353554859757423, 0.06568129360675812, 0.007968387566506863, -0.04935907945036888, -0.0431034155189991, -0.002955435076728463, -0.016833214089274406, 0.021319538354873657, -0.07155556231737137, 0.02898150496184826, -0.0350656621158123, 0.0042545488104224205, 0.008246163837611675, -0.05323905125260353, -0.009566155262291431, -0.01021032128483057, 0.029573539271950722, -0.07447776943445206, 0.013203167356550694, 0.10776422917842865, 0.06112115830183029, -0.06164009869098663, -0.03218463808298111, -0.012997748330235481, -0.07923133671283722, -0.00814073160290718, 0.03660455718636513, -0.02401682734489441, 0.002592439064756036, -0.030765866860747337, 0.013099013827741146, -0.018275417387485504, -0.03288043662905693, -0.01672475039958954, -0.027323272079229355, 0.005620506592094898, -0.010736020281910896, -0.058897342532873154, -0.01777178980410099, 0.006091999355703592, -0.020788557827472687, -0.004985264968127012, -0.05209318920969963, 0.01595025137066841, 0.01831272803246975, -0.012901299633085728, -0.0018602019408717752, -0.06034885346889496, 0.013363650068640709, 0.03475189208984375, -0.04690631851553917, 0.04844257980585098, 0.07277487218379974, 0.09532085061073303, -0.0334298275411129, -0.05071397125720978, -0.008515173569321632, -0.002239760709926486, 0.017594076693058014, -0.025995176285505295, 0.09807935357093811, -0.016005421057343483, 0.007833581417798996, -0.07209738343954086, -0.011913326568901539, 0.01631692424416542, 0.023498300462961197, 0.02598409913480282, 0.035955626517534256, -0.0049878512509167194, 0.018738504499197006, -0.0372481606900692, 0.06162136793136597, 0.005395059939473867, -0.013973718509078026, -0.00655395956709981, -0.05693577975034714, -0.027538908645510674, -0.04152695834636688, 0.03737112134695053, -0.06089978292584419, -0.04774382710456848, 0.023779889568686485, -0.0469634123146534, -0.05234118923544884, -0.0962262824177742, -0.05883290246129036, 0.025103295221924782, 0.029117384925484657, 0.05663183704018593, 0.025922834873199463, -0.00873534195125103, -0.00656903674826026, -0.036210108548402786, -0.047777727246284485, 0.01035422831773758, 0.011440252885222435, -0.03523404896259308, 0.047119140625, 0.07192941009998322, -0.032451022416353226, -0.0051308441907167435, -0.026202766224741936, 0.010081739164888859, -0.0029379921033978462, 0.021832125261425972, 0.023013019934296608, 0.0123825678601861, -0.0375775508582592, -0.043343231081962585, -0.08992457389831543, 0.044683460146188736, -0.01725650206208229, -0.0063649616204202175, -0.036778539419174194, -0.022294016554951668, 0.016049765050411224, -0.0139000304043293, -0.0022645811550319195, -0.0012114301789551973, 0.05074519291520119, 0.020711062476038933, -0.02369903400540352, -0.009137459099292755, -0.012981141917407513, 0.00497837970033288, -0.003757315455004573, 0.04578794538974762, -0.009669813327491283, -0.039176274091005325, -0.019623877480626106, -0.002660313853994012, -0.018025504425168037, -0.03441745787858963, 0.013455512002110481, -0.008591514080762863, 0.04227061569690704, -0.017958665266633034, -0.041941188275814056, 0.009305947460234165, -0.0027639439795166254, 0.024215232580900192, -0.009347896091639996, 0.06268300116062164, 0.01645875908434391, 0.06189628690481186, -0.06286531686782837, 0.002983672311529517, -0.009701116941869259, -0.004218786023557186, -0.0003015585243701935, 0.04926522821187973, -0.008770656771957874, 0.045329198241233826, 0.011308809742331505, -0.020174896344542503, -0.045168135315179825, 0.061448901891708374, 0.0022019934840500355, 0.04801087826490402, -0.0581105500459671, 0.01805867813527584, 0.05431050434708595, -0.024982810020446777, -0.032671455293893814, 0.018705591559410095, 0.009832962416112423, 0.0027096227277070284, 0.03789646551012993, -0.006871463730931282, 0.0012480978621169925, -0.00952933356165886, -0.004190386272966862, 0.0028658651281148195, -0.022490330040454865, 0.013820549473166466, -0.003092801896855235, -0.04896153509616852, 0.030291207134723663, -0.10573378950357437, -0.028316479176282883, 0.03353725001215935, 0.040827423334121704, -0.0027207934763282537, -0.028597155585885048, -0.009732168167829514, -0.025544093921780586, -0.01256790291517973, 0.052920181304216385, 0.04342179000377655, 0.020343482494354248, 0.03496382385492325, -0.002784618642181158, 0.02504511922597885, 0.008573897182941437, -0.012938066385686398, -0.056704334914684296, 0.018144911155104637, -0.03487878665328026, -0.03178059309720993, -0.05876527354121208, -6.087734265352943e-33, -0.01309165358543396, -0.09766724705696106, 0.011183938942849636, 0.004151750355958939, -0.017170222476124763, 0.006211006548255682, -0.001463690074160695, -0.025416556745767593, 0.015131273306906223, 0.02947237528860569, -0.006358529441058636, -0.001661990536376834, 0.014600117690861225, 0.015636179596185684, 0.037208713591098785, -0.014246738515794277, -0.006354868412017822, -0.01469966396689415, 0.02374330349266529, 0.006334324367344379, 0.027511777356266975, 0.04515189304947853, 0.07283442467451096, -0.06779066473245621, 0.056661538779735565, -0.007006126921623945, -0.029955938458442688, -0.013072934933006763, 0.037003569304943085, 0.02440442517399788, -0.010907518677413464, 0.006228226236999035, 0.04417047277092934, -0.03314089775085449, 0.008861207403242588, 0.035654034465551376, -0.05664642155170441, -0.03478696942329407, -0.03173710033297539, 0.02957117184996605, 0.00016728752234485, 0.0026001334190368652, 0.054104555398225784, -0.01665407605469227, -0.03196778893470764, 0.02526002749800682, 0.10289344936609268, -0.024806542322039604, -0.02840283513069153, -0.0632089376449585, -0.053928691893815994, 0.03563505783677101, 0.015298734419047832, 0.011600226163864136, -0.0010761214653030038, -0.010601285845041275, 0.008907141163945198, 0.021937208250164986, -0.0909779816865921, -0.0031614426989108324, 0.011113641783595085, 0.047813013195991516, 0.035914380103349686, 0.06484288722276688, -0.02338983118534088, 0.04379795119166374, 0.009574267081916332, 0.000710255466401577, -0.0019516217289492488, -0.03647296503186226, 0.020425591617822647, -0.028544465079903603, 0.1172238439321518, -0.001910062157548964, 0.021253839135169983, -0.041957829147577286, -0.062554270029068, 0.08118084073066711, -0.018204251304268837, 0.03301361948251724, 0.014855319634079933, -0.02649545669555664, -0.07373528182506561, -0.01468829344958067, 0.007933204062283039, -0.017223943024873734, -0.037315260618925095, -0.04243442043662071, 0.011187921278178692, -0.011871524155139923, 0.0007807129295542836, -0.003822197439149022, -0.034670669585466385, -0.047551464289426804, 0.020942624658346176, -0.03576825186610222, 0.026916254311800003, 0.044785045087337494, -0.03600107505917549, -0.00985915306955576, -0.0119800865650177, 0.02529188059270382, -0.038033485412597656, 0.0471406988799572, 0.014003145508468151, -0.011422296054661274, 0.028318123891949654, -0.008366123773157597, -0.04052716866135597, -0.0101452162489295, 0.03644281253218651, -0.04221059009432793, 0.022737612947821617, 0.046999361366033554, -0.03060102090239525, -0.028999464586377144, -0.013309319503605366, 0.05586501210927963, 0.0198528915643692, -0.00287582166492939, -0.009584072977304459, -0.05970218405127525, 0.046128541231155396, 0.0022628004662692547, -0.06792698055505753, 0.03321954607963562, -0.02236386016011238, 0.02998492307960987, -0.003382134484127164, -0.040145087987184525, 0.010565436445176601, 0.019385389983654022, 2.690189262466447e-07, 0.08952275663614273, 0.07161244004964828, 0.026991551741957664, -0.021441496908664703, -0.019779596477746964, 0.0023780870251357555, 0.009400755167007446, 0.018827831372618675, -0.0013989484868943691, 0.01673307456076145, 0.04501127451658249, -0.03322690725326538, 7.595271017635241e-05, 0.0397610180079937, -0.10946433246135712, -0.014798793941736221, -0.03882486745715141, -0.02546672709286213, -0.019798247143626213, 0.014453043229877949, 0.09612409770488739, 0.043958645313978195, 0.02257457748055458, -0.00889508705586195, 0.0025721131823956966, -0.06395569443702698, 0.014151312410831451, 0.01084897294640541, 0.0018105090130120516, 0.013875984586775303, 0.053942929953336716, -0.014849435538053513, -0.03135541081428528, 0.025000086054205894, -0.029672907665371895, 0.010426750406622887, 0.05080842599272728, 0.046352118253707886, -0.04671381786465645, 0.022581560537219048, 0.017835695296525955, -0.02989865280687809, 0.021665196865797043, -0.03899049758911133, 0.02880236506462097, -0.003624064614996314, -0.022445404902100563, -0.009884675033390522, 0.037438735365867615, -0.01648375391960144, 0.0554046630859375, -0.02009449154138565, -0.016666000708937645, 0.025248808786273003, -0.007058783899992704, -0.023190533742308617, 0.0020962953567504883, -0.07253540307283401, -0.018450619652867317, -0.009578490629792213, 0.010149245150387287, -0.0032375820446759462, -0.013251197524368763, -0.01459522731602192, 0.012612412683665752, -0.07038244605064392, -0.0006390573689714074, 2.7833343759333104e-34, 0.02793474867939949, -0.031162599101662636, -0.026010842993855476, -0.014499547891318798, 0.018452391028404236, 0.02532704919576645, 0.0018654626328498125, 0.016866782680153847, 0.02474437840282917, -0.06746185570955276, -0.026756152510643005]
618
618
['Albert Zeyer', 'Patrick Doetsch', 'Paul Voigtlaender', 'Ralf Schlüter', 'Hermann Ney']
1606.06871v2
We present a comprehensive study of deep bidirectional long short-term memory (LSTM) recurrent neural network (RNN) based acoustic models for automatic speech recognition (ASR). We study the effect of size and depth and train models of up to 8 layers. We investigate the training aspect and study different variants of optimization methods, batching, truncated backpropagation, different regularization techniques such as dropout and $L_2$ regularization, and different gradient clipping variants. The major part of the experimental analysis was performed on the Quaero corpus. Additional experiments also were performed on the Switchboard corpus. Our best LSTM model has a relative improvement in word error rate of over 14\% compared to our best feed-forward neural network (FFNN) baseline on the Quaero task. On this task, we get our best result with an 8 layer bidirectional LSTM and we show that a pretraining scheme with layer-wise construction helps for deep LSTMs. Finally we compare the training calculation time of many of the presented experiments in relation with recognition performance. All the experiments were done with RETURNN, the RWTH extensible training framework for universal recurrent neural networks in combination with RASR, the RWTH ASR toolkit.
A Comprehensive Study of Deep Bidirectional LSTM RNNs for Acoustic Modeling in Speech Recognition
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1606.06871v2
Title Comprehensive Study Deep Bidirectional LSTM RNNs Acoustic Modeling Speech Recognition Summary present comprehensive study deep bidirectional long shortterm memory LSTM recurrent neural network RNN based acoustic model automatic speech recognition ASR study effect size depth train model 8 layer investigate training aspect study different variant optimization method batching truncated backpropagation different regularization technique dropout L2 regularization different gradient clipping variant major part experimental analysis performed Quaero corpus Additional experiment also performed Switchboard corpus best LSTM model relative improvement word error rate 14 compared best feedforward neural network FFNN baseline Quaero task task get best result 8 layer bidirectional LSTM show pretraining scheme layerwise construction help deep LSTMs Finally compare training calculation time many presented experiment relation recognition performance experiment done RETURNN RWTH extensible training framework universal recurrent neural network combination RASR RWTH ASR toolkit Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.018957188352942467, -0.0008593597449362278, 0.02219080552458763, 0.09828613698482513, -0.019801892340183258, -0.0029993506614118814, 0.02846546471118927, -0.02588002383708954, -0.02469421923160553, -0.025839192792773247, -0.06362873315811157, -0.053315840661525726, 0.0055857026018202305, 0.011284314095973969, 0.002963716397061944, -0.06338094174861908, 0.02271326817572117, -0.01159366499632597, 0.025907250121235847, -0.02943272516131401, 0.019504381343722343, -0.003977259621024132, -0.03640259802341461, 0.006037823855876923, -0.02446216158568859, 0.011647827923297882, -0.004289936274290085, 0.03163193166255951, -0.009579434059560299, -0.059319138526916504, 0.023572605103254318, 0.05195038393139839, 0.0472676157951355, 0.017889684066176414, 2.2143949536257423e-06, 0.0011508642928674817, -0.020183103159070015, -0.009587817825376987, -0.02918618731200695, -0.012232351116836071, -0.024019179865717888, 0.03861464560031891, 0.007970763370394707, 0.058215975761413574, -0.03716547414660454, -0.05260726436972618, 0.020784761756658554, 0.07145771384239197, 0.026283252984285355, 0.06284767389297485, 0.0033679238986223936, -0.07854070514440536, 0.017725110054016113, -0.006839251145720482, -0.0036115192342549562, -0.0431881807744503, -0.005413023754954338, -0.05631449818611145, -0.02707039937376976, -0.004996361676603556, -0.026447393000125885, 0.02495533972978592, 0.03387612849473953, 0.02846204861998558, 0.006595843471586704, 0.03782183304429054, -0.01150842197239399, -0.015367239713668823, -0.025914674624800682, 0.08944043517112732, 0.00015806160809006542, -0.01813613437116146, 0.012498833239078522, 0.011618168093264103, -0.06603848934173584, -0.04024624824523926, 0.0008191255619749427, 0.0049036829732358456, -0.011860365979373455, -0.008247371762990952, -0.016916435211896896, 0.027508625760674477, 0.04055778682231903, 0.018530195578932762, -0.009343418292701244, -0.023274172097444534, -0.009708455763757229, -0.039536021649837494, -0.0376017764210701, -0.07556179165840149, 0.016436247155070305, -0.05063743144273758, 0.053670160472393036, 0.03735215216875076, -0.0012369933538138866, 0.002576438942924142, 0.020322874188423157, -0.07592762261629105, 0.024827124550938606, -0.04960225522518158, -0.007943584583699703, -0.0068668280728161335, -0.05925434082746506, 0.014578691683709621, -0.02834847941994667, 0.03143834322690964, 0.0012913091341033578, -0.012338705360889435, 0.0018924977630376816, -0.0014312096172943711, -0.015311477705836296, -0.011175721883773804, -0.0005520182894542813, 0.05524338409304619, -0.003343154676258564, -0.01685144193470478, -0.04808935523033142, -0.04615101218223572, -0.006914421916007996, -0.02211919054389, 0.06370445340871811, 0.02695169486105442, -0.028364775702357292, -0.03944913670420647, 0.024452142417430878, 0.030524615198373795, -0.01222324650734663, 0.048410072922706604, -0.06007719784975052, -0.04069358855485916, 0.0029695455450564623, 0.03591170907020569, 0.024847418069839478, 0.0017854515463113785, 0.001508826040662825, 0.08765869587659836, 0.03353011608123779, -0.02829555794596672, -0.056459855288267136, 0.011495254002511501, 0.005890894681215286, -0.04861525818705559, -0.005983682814985514, -0.05799365043640137, 0.017363404855132103, -0.022068563848733902, -0.029379859566688538, -0.009583658538758755, 0.029608139768242836, -0.014254787005484104, 0.014148096553981304, 0.07606372982263565, -0.005159628111869097, 0.0016969935968518257, 0.03404063358902931, 0.002817316446453333, 0.05784032493829727, 0.014652356505393982, 0.09391535818576813, 0.002991721034049988, -0.009306157939136028, -0.060404084622859955, 0.010499099269509315, 0.03197255730628967, 0.010885550640523434, -0.03956971690058708, -0.032089963555336, 0.004183466080576181, 0.017877059057354927, 0.04391753673553467, 0.03992451727390289, 0.07199686765670776, 0.003582566976547241, -0.021145522594451904, 0.03738852217793465, 0.044860560446977615, 0.0898435190320015, 0.04744657129049301, 0.02411477454006672, 0.008027628064155579, -0.017024537548422813, -0.03059467114508152, -0.021751295775175095, 0.029460087418556213, 0.009199623949825764, 0.01129891350865364, 0.004688472952693701, -0.02664821781218052, -0.02183038927614689, 0.008630285039544106, -0.010954728350043297, -0.05047071352601051, -0.025947067886590958, 0.0024196587037295103, 0.03960787132382393, 0.0014361344510689378, -0.0621122308075428, 0.051716599613428116, -0.007785255089402199, -0.03138389810919762, 0.01337714958935976, -0.029952676966786385, 0.031979333609342575, -3.869143620249815e-05, 0.029165983200073242, -0.03052932396531105, -0.05119713023304939, -0.0470903180539608, -0.03403085470199585, 0.04084433615207672, 0.006887615658342838, 0.03159762918949127, 0.02369457297027111, -0.09237152338027954, -0.013271745294332504, 0.06379668414592743, -0.03173601254820824, 0.06858859956264496, -0.03397868946194649, 0.04427029564976692, 0.03914128988981247, 0.03200392425060272, -0.0005886611761525273, 0.016137156635522842, -0.04699929803609848, -0.02540835738182068, 0.03279073163866997, 0.0456947386264801, 0.06665503978729248, 0.056363046169281006, 0.0013355055125430226, -0.003777499543502927, 0.06713999062776566, -0.03684929758310318, -0.009104679338634014, 0.011732393875718117, -0.10097335278987885, -0.04420853033661842, 0.020137619227170944, 0.021759377792477608, 0.0649305135011673, 0.030943328514695168, 0.006678719539195299, -0.08108106255531311, 0.036158423870801926, 0.008390968665480614, 0.06264005601406097, -0.03720002993941307, 0.04133450984954834, 0.05164846405386925, 0.014852755703032017, 0.027275510132312775, 0.007038281764835119, -0.0015287840506061912, -0.00383140635676682, -0.014431924559175968, 0.00303093483671546, 0.021165091544389725, -0.060553595423698425, -0.053828395903110504, 0.045388951897621155, -0.025376077741384506, 0.0021424046717584133, -0.022712821140885353, 0.019538724794983864, -0.03359093517065048, -0.005387722514569759, -0.03691480681300163, -0.004454863257706165, 0.00499659962952137, 0.019968653097748756, -0.04889145866036415, 0.03113875351846218, 0.002612431300804019, -0.019406111910939217, 0.003929567523300648, -0.010998294688761234, -0.019249968230724335, -0.03750001639127731, -0.01083284616470337, 0.005443638190627098, -0.02369801513850689, -0.04187296703457832, 0.005367951933294535, -0.0134115070104599, -0.014588292688131332, 0.003950906451791525, -0.049723315984010696, 0.006541649345308542, 0.032549746334552765, 0.02166222408413887, 0.04259146377444267, -2.494448381185066e-05, -0.0821881890296936, -0.037839632481336594, -0.027626581490039825, 0.032592155039310455, -0.01390132587403059, 0.02582833729684353, -0.05657756328582764, -0.019632037729024887, -0.001045073033310473, -0.015524295158684254, 0.03980468586087227, 0.025298379361629486, 0.03744806721806526, 0.015184189192950726, 0.004226526711136103, -0.05083093419671059, 0.04245306923985481, 0.032924894243478775, 0.03727056458592415, 0.0032530694734305143, -0.03741518035531044, -0.0029094088822603226, 0.0006803544820286334, 0.015517093241214752, -0.02569735050201416, -0.03942270204424858, -0.008935349062085152, -0.0169820599257946, 0.01566315069794655, 0.012666428461670876, -0.03390217572450638, -0.014171008951961994, -0.058086249977350235, -0.030842652544379234, -0.04000923037528992, 0.051465000957250595, -0.003551929024979472, -0.024438904598355293, -0.0406004823744297, -0.06730011850595474, 0.012388713657855988, -0.05157024785876274, -0.006425031460821629, -0.0757494643330574, 0.020133495330810547, 0.006153738126158714, 0.0037642125971615314, -0.04033816605806351, -0.019885875284671783, -0.041777703911066055, -0.003043570090085268, -0.029603900387883186, -0.01245188806205988, -0.009993609972298145, -0.022313406690955162, 0.042245376855134964, 0.05493231490254402, 0.029188122600317, 0.05165277048945427, -0.006491147913038731, 0.07300887256860733, -0.015544422902166843, 0.061071932315826416, 0.03020229935646057, 0.00925087183713913, -0.037711989134550095, 0.05346741899847984, 0.050591841340065, -0.018153904005885124, 0.011113805696368217, 0.0005407801363617182, -0.09206356853246689, -0.025929972529411316, 0.0012527194339782, -0.025154966861009598, -0.02036941610276699, 0.020086433738470078, 0.018664497882127762, -0.10545263439416885, 0.026198383420705795, 0.07864091545343399, -0.010688013397157192, -0.07286955416202545, -0.03889467194676399, 0.006588590797036886, -0.02665962651371956, 0.012654518708586693, -0.008769775740802288, -0.02315862663090229, -0.03363455832004547, 0.007654991932213306, 0.004104775842279196, 0.028543006628751755, -0.006233007647097111, -0.009243790991604328, -0.07767335325479507, 0.015552147291600704, -0.02016391232609749, -0.07284337282180786, -0.03415178880095482, -0.0371784009039402, -0.032519545406103134, -0.011740894056856632, 0.019726358354091644, 0.03348608314990997, -0.012675566598773003, -0.04485694691538811, 0.05585641413927078, -0.09483949095010757, -0.014300080947577953, 0.03868784382939339, -0.09935712069272995, 0.042286477982997894, 0.0599990151822567, 0.042335301637649536, -0.07817322760820389, -0.0032937563955783844, 0.01163453422486782, -0.025534996762871742, 0.015526038594543934, -0.023670364171266556, 0.0038480921648442745, -0.012213829904794693, -0.010243345983326435, -0.00044646396418102086, 0.03127976134419441, -0.05218633636832237, 0.030780473724007607, 0.03075634129345417, 0.05302565172314644, 0.0017823921516537666, -0.007014949340373278, -0.025489240884780884, 0.018069911748170853, 0.011717656627297401, 0.05972721800208092, 0.009998785331845284, 0.006453938782215118, -0.020641349256038666, 0.044395811855793, 0.03399387374520302, -0.051447462290525436, 0.020293502137064934, -0.02787015028297901, -0.0068077705800533295, -0.029985785484313965, -0.042169537395238876, -0.046800509095191956, -0.011371334083378315, 0.022587211802601814, 0.04422241821885109, 0.05704524740576744, 0.024421541020274162, 0.019125714898109436, -0.04917711392045021, 0.00949542410671711, 0.019810328260064125, 0.05878522992134094, -0.06809934228658676, 0.0061392225325107574, 0.07180379331111908, -0.07386066019535065, 0.011538070626556873, -0.03621663153171539, -0.0412144735455513, -0.013067280873656273, -0.003950936254113913, 0.017649894580245018, 0.005614288151264191, 0.0413171723484993, -0.01686903089284897, -0.03619949892163277, 0.04749840870499611, 0.03617255762219429, -0.03889526426792145, -0.011462108232080936, 0.07700993120670319, 0.028853723779320717, -0.018320653587579727, 0.009661410003900528, -0.04669547453522682, 0.06027030572295189, -0.0022337771952152252, 0.014609409496188164, -0.012895102612674236, -0.029944386333227158, -0.01628199964761734, 0.001781795872375369, 0.06833503395318985, 0.026864346116781235, -0.014901325106620789, -0.06869518011808395, 0.05504050850868225, 0.019771765917539597, 0.054314009845256805, -0.01764189824461937, 0.028840307146310806, 0.01807236298918724, 0.032110150903463364, -0.03497655317187309, -0.06211090460419655, 0.005167270544916391, -0.05707720294594765, 0.010540075600147247, 0.08624101430177689, 0.01345042698085308, -0.0004608037997968495, -0.023050542920827866, 0.01023407094180584, -0.028204549103975296, -0.0065724533051252365, 0.034628380089998245, 0.02260725386440754, 0.010029909200966358, 0.01640324667096138, -0.01314662117511034, 0.008729022927582264, -0.004216463770717382, 0.0199737586081028, 0.035260893404483795, -0.005737460684031248, -0.03252224251627922, 0.017707690596580505, 0.06745463609695435, -0.04010966792702675, 0.0019410679815337062, 0.014726648107171059, 0.056911006569862366, -0.011489944532513618, 0.031974319368600845, -0.06353551894426346, 0.03000240959227085, 0.0551394484937191, 0.014608615078032017, -0.014965100213885307, 0.019533008337020874, 0.02772562950849533, 0.015804864466190338, 0.04832087829709053, 0.03441969305276871, 0.010100437328219414, -0.011596390046179295, -0.008600983768701553, 0.02758294902741909, 0.026108769699931145, -0.04019459709525108, 0.023362668231129646, 0.0067240456119179726, -0.08903425931930542, 0.043866485357284546, -0.022756529971957207, 0.0693872943520546, -0.0544351302087307, 0.03286710008978844, -0.0048773749731481075, 0.010711152106523514, 0.04497101902961731, 0.008488472551107407, -0.01166525948792696, 0.007566152140498161, -0.007797034457325935, -0.057314954698085785, -6.76026286879119e-33, -0.01563723012804985, -0.008290587924420834, 0.020312145352363586, -0.011641303077340126, -0.0591893345117569, 0.017964720726013184, -0.038697097450494766, -0.014264942146837711, -0.036108702421188354, -0.014005757868289948, -0.020380878821015358, 0.02012043446302414, 0.004792094696313143, 0.015152913518249989, 0.03878292441368103, -0.02017664909362793, 0.04564231261610985, -0.01510315015912056, 0.07629217207431793, 0.00012610023259185255, 0.024829702451825142, 0.06595318019390106, 0.07909680902957916, -0.06000562384724617, -0.06465597450733185, -0.04730932042002678, 0.016409192234277725, 0.01205255277454853, -0.01297411322593689, 0.03026372194290161, -0.036622773855924606, -0.0033728559501469135, 0.013362916186451912, -0.031759075820446014, 0.022325415164232254, -0.012429075315594673, -0.08562376350164413, -0.028803586959838867, -0.006063738372176886, 0.005347074009478092, -0.01642979308962822, 0.01705913431942463, 0.0750030130147934, 0.03655996173620224, -0.022490017116069794, 0.020719008520245552, 0.020955346524715424, -0.000825048889964819, -0.017592644318938255, -0.027643878012895584, -0.0302694384008646, 0.030630050227046013, -0.0052069369703531265, -0.05548493191599846, 0.051243044435977936, -0.014879776164889336, -0.024935780093073845, 0.0027427629102021456, -0.09792360663414001, -0.0014111349591985345, 0.004242324270308018, 0.007989982143044472, 0.05511140450835228, 0.04191727563738823, -0.00934239849448204, 0.005309322848916054, 0.038695648312568665, -0.03555454686284065, -0.009692131541669369, -0.01521715335547924, -0.011546092107892036, 0.03440413996577263, 0.031200846657156944, -0.007416639011353254, 0.09953197836875916, 0.008616050705313683, -0.04371988773345947, -0.019322507083415985, 0.04177877679467201, 0.05607195571064949, 0.03463517129421234, 0.029129037633538246, -0.05340730398893356, 0.008442171849310398, -0.004738307558000088, -0.023888420313596725, -0.03455707058310509, -0.04864998534321785, 0.031072445213794708, 0.006062597036361694, 0.021467778831720352, -0.027356494218111038, 0.02092096582055092, 0.008207684382796288, 0.03940834477543831, -0.0013909556437283754, 0.028870031237602234, -0.01466835755854845, 0.003239512210711837, 0.04007437825202942, -0.07136447727680206, -0.02769770845770836, 0.0057182773016393185, 0.03993287310004234, -0.012551302090287209, 0.020734012126922607, 0.007873495109379292, 0.010873164981603622, 0.006547429598867893, -0.010700627230107784, -0.00044878735207021236, -0.004082893021404743, 0.0022198210936039686, 0.04652024060487747, 0.018003378063440323, -0.012135623954236507, 0.012342493049800396, 0.0978839248418808, 0.025134356692433357, 0.0039530424401164055, -0.018685312941670418, -0.017335839569568634, 0.023135380819439888, 0.019770577549934387, -0.03237830474972725, -0.01739594340324402, -0.019491303712129593, 0.0047528394497931, 0.006336440797895193, -0.06380271911621094, -0.007227340713143349, 0.010937293991446495, 2.8816782560170395e-07, -0.03859810531139374, -0.009683193638920784, 0.036578305065631866, 0.0257257092744112, 0.01455460675060749, -0.0012784342980012298, -0.006174285430461168, -0.005817752797156572, 0.01513957791030407, 0.026352670043706894, 0.01699676737189293, 0.006821423303335905, 0.03422653302550316, -0.0003473485994618386, -0.11208371073007584, -0.019321918487548828, -0.12868407368659973, 0.02688693441450596, -0.021821850910782814, 0.01278924010694027, 0.05551588535308838, 0.09703969955444336, 0.020632952451705933, -0.03342341259121895, 0.013995833694934845, 0.01256090123206377, 0.0060903639532625675, -0.006453108973801136, 0.02037961035966873, -0.03224344551563263, 0.007469377480447292, -0.007061684504151344, -0.028609061613678932, -0.005632666405290365, -0.038534317165613174, 0.06415756046772003, 0.010445899330079556, -0.0034863261971622705, -0.014771751128137112, -0.06745793670415878, 0.048103347420692444, 0.058560535311698914, 0.015826426446437836, 0.018895182758569717, 0.04586014896631241, 0.01929319277405739, -0.032348476350307465, 0.006847139913588762, -0.039820969104766846, 0.007515267003327608, 0.01197600644081831, -0.015107264742255211, 0.024952838197350502, -0.030253760516643524, -0.014809925109148026, -0.06362929195165634, -0.04622387886047363, -0.0755704864859581, 0.02831508405506611, -0.020345011726021767, -0.05578553304076195, 0.01856127567589283, -0.01750543713569641, -0.010323666036128998, 0.03765492141246796, -0.01212527696043253, -0.0018381959525868297, 2.497466318016571e-34, 0.04876890406012535, -0.03627115488052368, -0.021585768088698387, 0.056482721120119095, 0.004492864944040775, -0.02204817347228527, -0.038653772324323654, 0.023171178996562958, 0.012135463766753674, -0.08350840955972672, -0.06221261993050575]
619
619
['Yoon Kim', 'Alexander M. Rush']
1606.07947v4
Neural machine translation (NMT) offers a novel alternative formulation of translation that is potentially simpler than statistical approaches. However to reach competitive performance, NMT models need to be exceedingly large. In this paper we consider applying knowledge distillation approaches (Bucila et al., 2006; Hinton et al., 2015) that have proven successful for reducing the size of neural models in other domains to the problem of NMT. We demonstrate that standard knowledge distillation applied to word-level prediction can be effective for NMT, and also introduce two novel sequence-level versions of knowledge distillation that further improve performance, and somewhat surprisingly, seem to eliminate the need for beam search (even when applied on the original teacher model). Our best student model runs 10 times faster than its state-of-the-art teacher with little loss in performance. It is also significantly better than a baseline model trained without knowledge distillation: by 4.2/1.7 BLEU with greedy decoding/beam search. Applying weight pruning on top of knowledge distillation results in a student model that has 13 times fewer parameters than the original teacher model, with a decrease of 0.4 BLEU.
Sequence-Level Knowledge Distillation
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1606.07947v4
Title SequenceLevel Knowledge Distillation Summary Neural machine translation NMT offer novel alternative formulation translation potentially simpler statistical approach However reach competitive performance NMT model need exceedingly large paper consider applying knowledge distillation approach Bucila et al 2006 Hinton et al 2015 proven successful reducing size neural model domain problem NMT demonstrate standard knowledge distillation applied wordlevel prediction effective NMT also introduce two novel sequencelevel version knowledge distillation improve performance somewhat surprisingly seem eliminate need beam search even applied original teacher model best student model run 10 time faster stateoftheart teacher little loss performance also significantly better baseline model trained without knowledge distillation 4217 BLEU greedy decodingbeam search Applying weight pruning top knowledge distillation result student model 13 time fewer parameter original teacher model decrease 04 BLEU Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.042545102536678314, 0.07262073457241058, 0.002678351476788521, 0.030915237963199615, -0.016466815024614334, -0.013895583339035511, 0.00313385808840394, 0.009221713058650494, -0.07044472545385361, -0.038467105478048325, 0.016061589121818542, -0.0013897559838369489, 0.025277916342020035, 0.02924548089504242, 0.024057792499661446, -0.09509803354740143, 0.00010619321255944669, -0.003774982877075672, 0.0033694463782012463, 0.010634184814989567, -0.015091586858034134, -0.0218366589397192, 0.004443194251507521, 0.05092628672719002, 0.008645713329315186, -0.020892100408673286, -0.04331497475504875, 0.019792931154370308, -0.0036487076431512833, -0.042194440960884094, 0.03670717030763626, 0.05446472391486168, 0.04815080016851425, 0.032703980803489685, 2.598516175567056e-06, 0.003366653574630618, -0.03761155530810356, -0.022200409322977066, -0.012943237088620663, 0.0325995534658432, -0.00668629864230752, -0.05868804454803467, 0.021878408268094063, -0.00577244209125638, -0.04040590673685074, 0.012779011391103268, 0.02194443717598915, 0.014855798333883286, 0.07896890491247177, 0.0718739777803421, 0.0046867430210113525, -0.0631784200668335, 0.025603774935007095, -0.022655438631772995, 0.03656332939863205, -0.06571453809738159, -0.0014361721696332097, 0.015414237976074219, -0.03648807853460312, 0.043909378349781036, -0.04748450219631195, 0.07463466376066208, -0.006327544339001179, -0.013749138452112675, 0.002031350042670965, 0.01820896565914154, 0.003345706732943654, -0.01907154731452465, 0.008747774176299572, 0.07765240222215652, -0.013927655294537544, 0.033822979778051376, 0.023611854761838913, 0.01903444528579712, -0.02768428809940815, -0.02135276421904564, -0.039615530520677567, -0.006073748227208853, -0.025246087461709976, 0.00840076431632042, 0.008718866854906082, 0.06857024878263474, -0.0008047762094065547, -0.013584263622760773, -0.021279271692037582, 0.008405367843806744, 0.009200582280755043, -0.06269622594118118, -0.013569718226790428, -0.019564291462302208, 0.008104725740849972, -0.03187612444162369, 0.04217413812875748, 0.009297909215092659, 0.041258253157138824, 0.039087504148483276, -0.023257840424776077, -0.06733044981956482, 0.006068306975066662, -0.06899350881576538, 0.0007705723983235657, 0.05044383183121681, 0.03424655273556709, 0.006062511820346117, 0.017853641882538795, 0.07754155248403549, -0.0067756385542452335, 0.014447782188653946, -0.0636679008603096, 0.0328676775097847, -0.07599915564060211, -0.0065447986125946045, -0.010089943185448647, 0.03961014375090599, -0.025262488052248955, 0.00802586879581213, -0.06381511688232422, -0.041229333728551865, 0.01792553998529911, -0.02964361570775509, 0.02265194244682789, 0.034549593925476074, -0.05524304881691933, 0.005558839533478022, -0.022322148084640503, 0.11108309030532837, -0.006664227694272995, -0.03872522711753845, 0.01569710113108158, -0.00374333537183702, -0.010368406772613525, -0.0008802390657365322, -0.02549964003264904, 0.006691231392323971, -0.006227017380297184, 0.07814452052116394, -0.02381773665547371, -0.022024570032954216, -0.027522826567292213, -0.049979180097579956, -0.042278558015823364, -0.05749589949846268, 0.017000166699290276, -0.07544532418251038, 0.05391257628798485, -0.013476896099746227, -0.010933686047792435, -0.05185819789767265, 0.013719695620238781, 0.003989976365119219, -0.024892432615160942, 0.04305822774767876, -0.0028055557049810886, -0.01585901714861393, 0.05120265856385231, 0.052621208131313324, 0.018293743953108788, 0.01893555000424385, 0.04527889937162399, 0.029583266004920006, 0.0001655850646784529, -0.020344998687505722, -0.035877108573913574, 0.01287397276610136, 0.018755367025732994, -0.027534017339348793, -0.02597268670797348, -0.034632839262485504, -0.00410060677677393, 0.04854608327150345, 0.026611503213644028, 0.030253956094384193, -0.016219353303313255, 0.023152604699134827, 0.06906447559595108, 0.05763654038310051, 0.055746592581272125, 0.03441654518246651, 0.008986787870526314, 0.035415105521678925, 0.01181861013174057, 0.04252344369888306, 0.007303604390472174, 0.021817145869135857, -0.003964017145335674, 0.00941768754273653, 0.029586773365736008, 0.042522892355918884, 0.0034834500402212143, -0.06678243726491928, 0.011865749955177307, 0.005656070541590452, -0.01081407442688942, -0.045303232967853546, 0.026240212842822075, 0.00617933226749301, -0.03930141404271126, 0.055731773376464844, 0.014659726992249489, -0.03912374749779701, 0.024903273209929466, -0.011343971826136112, -0.038936253637075424, 0.018486322835087776, 0.025179730728268623, -0.0005388782592490315, -0.0438147634267807, -0.0019566856790333986, -0.02973511442542076, 0.04661628603935242, 0.02020740881562233, 0.0072522396221756935, 0.0021183649078011513, -0.055016107857227325, -0.026773013174533844, 0.003874874208122492, 0.022765394300222397, -0.0031602145172655582, -0.01828283816576004, 0.0446060448884964, 0.06538139283657074, -0.02271340601146221, -0.06350468099117279, 0.04259965568780899, -0.04710923135280609, -0.05512610077857971, -0.009867937304079533, 0.027703268453478813, 0.02644474059343338, 0.028757484629750252, 0.0050090462900698185, 0.000817223044577986, 0.01624724641442299, -0.02982858568429947, -0.049939483404159546, -0.04830063134431839, -0.09009412676095963, -0.12518532574176788, 0.014508003368973732, -0.056889019906520844, 0.03372771665453911, 0.014727428555488586, -0.05599287897348404, -0.05093434453010559, 0.013152116909623146, -0.010126053355634212, 0.011137902736663818, 0.0024481196887791157, 0.04847606271505356, 0.0182634349912405, -0.0006279335357248783, -0.04849834367632866, 0.06817988306283951, -0.02342779003083706, -0.021924717351794243, -0.012582278810441494, -0.06541726738214493, 0.014063001610338688, -0.007890202105045319, -0.029988041147589684, 0.034846607595682144, -0.014531739056110382, 0.01958252489566803, 0.009289180859923363, 0.047728218138217926, -0.02557990886271, -0.02189951390028, -0.01828167960047722, 0.019505081698298454, 0.009517932310700417, 0.0075697582215070724, 0.03091106005012989, 0.03895305469632149, 0.02245922200381756, -0.002319245832040906, -0.03154394403100014, 0.034277673810720444, -0.010596050880849361, -0.03647051751613617, -0.004122661426663399, 0.02049839496612549, 0.035459451377391815, -0.028341371566057205, -0.02785303443670273, -0.033279940485954285, 0.07376329600811005, 0.0022426857613027096, -0.04971747845411301, -0.049913909286260605, 0.06753113120794296, -0.05360407009720802, 0.02808426134288311, -0.002748341066762805, -0.04932674765586853, 0.0012568830279633403, -0.03037174791097641, 0.01308890338987112, 0.029052836820483208, 0.02454451471567154, 0.002023550681769848, 0.023368651047348976, 0.0008138898992910981, -0.060578349977731705, 0.031450629234313965, -0.01623070053756237, 0.013179625384509563, -0.007546036504209042, -0.029063088819384575, 0.007656412199139595, 0.10064977407455444, 0.05972627177834511, 0.005092771258205175, -0.03459583595395088, 0.0012494054390117526, -0.029131505638360977, -0.004736939445137978, -0.0854904055595398, 0.0049030412919819355, 0.0010339799337089062, 0.009392187930643559, 0.00968015193939209, -0.004102058708667755, 0.08406306058168411, -0.01354388240724802, 0.01945723034441471, -0.06691852957010269, -0.017568284645676613, -0.011065547354519367, 0.0425657257437706, -0.04232076555490494, 0.0239662304520607, 0.008817620575428009, -0.019865533336997032, -0.04949454963207245, -0.003498111618682742, -0.02595941722393036, -0.02812676690518856, 0.05649365484714508, -0.047459926456213, -0.04065115749835968, -0.040330711752176285, -0.007693345192819834, -0.03922368958592415, 0.017412638291716576, 0.03400720655918121, 0.012672477401793003, 0.0461776927113533, -0.02011439949274063, -0.04544036462903023, 0.030389277264475822, 0.0034095733426511288, 0.07078792154788971, -0.02943732775747776, -0.01046716794371605, -0.03993980959057808, 0.057079922407865524, 0.00561843765899539, -0.027426384389400482, -0.009395703673362732, -0.02372041530907154, 0.04581960663199425, 0.04672076180577278, -0.04396304488182068, -0.010498793795704842, -0.0310334675014019, -0.011993921361863613, 0.01939675211906433, -0.023142008110880852, -0.02594541199505329, 0.022374818101525307, 0.008477503433823586, -0.10403721034526825, 0.006341957952827215, 0.10322783887386322, -0.0015333254123106599, -0.05164268985390663, -0.007467462681233883, 0.00913780927658081, 0.02075577899813652, -0.009275393560528755, 0.030548756942152977, -0.038682423532009125, -0.017767230048775673, -0.014675911515951157, 0.0635441392660141, 0.05828477442264557, -0.04543588310480118, -0.03583825007081032, -0.04517433047294617, -0.016230806708335876, 0.0300774984061718, -0.04131205007433891, -0.04590886831283569, -0.002625976921990514, -0.06433732062578201, 0.012780904769897461, -0.004054136574268341, 0.03718896210193634, -0.0001101636080420576, 0.03115406632423401, 0.03445443511009216, -0.032516639679670334, -0.06165720149874687, 0.02734428271651268, -0.03411703184247017, 0.03177623823285103, 0.057671137154102325, 0.06776679307222366, -0.00764848617836833, -0.021614370867609978, -0.027180515229701996, -0.0031808086205273867, 0.024271788075566292, -0.016713427379727364, 0.045549191534519196, -0.025582095608115196, -0.003492773976176977, 0.004493627231568098, 0.019058460369706154, -0.0361003577709198, 0.04296935349702835, 0.04236522316932678, 0.07918239384889603, -0.0001454499870305881, -0.018387099727988243, -0.04651062935590744, 0.022726641967892647, 0.013157742097973824, 0.04999489337205887, 0.03918899595737457, -0.010275579057633877, 0.016574524343013763, -0.03274323791265488, 0.012715642340481281, -0.035136088728904724, -0.022865263745188713, 0.017611844465136528, -0.04313619062304497, -0.0034713249187916517, -0.10656595230102539, -0.030034292489290237, -0.018183546140789986, 0.03828687220811844, 0.034162234514951706, 0.010153098963201046, 0.05336455628275871, -0.00975830852985382, -0.04593702778220177, -0.007772921118885279, 0.024928828701376915, -0.022500738501548767, -0.03873196244239807, 0.0029481176752597094, 0.005942470394074917, -0.004804528784006834, -0.028106555342674255, -0.00748974597081542, -0.07024053484201431, -0.05573046952486038, -0.015263685025274754, 0.0800364762544632, 0.019183356314897537, 0.017983393743634224, 0.006968826521188021, -0.02655171789228916, 0.07150569558143616, -0.0037864844780415297, -0.00664601381868124, -0.009157263673841953, 0.04060822352766991, -0.021186836063861847, -0.011358487419784069, 0.014798138290643692, 0.0009510328527539968, 0.008460912853479385, 0.002014092169702053, 0.05397185683250427, 0.004629777278751135, -0.025267966091632843, 0.037689801305532455, -0.007192167453467846, 0.06476400792598724, -0.02290165238082409, -0.06039220467209816, -0.013200574554502964, 0.02573326602578163, -0.02020469307899475, -0.004257884807884693, -0.06958611309528351, -0.013852900825440884, 0.04470708593726158, 0.05398523807525635, -0.003079585265368223, -0.0021137611474841833, 0.034048885107040405, -0.012224792502820492, 0.010097889229655266, 0.03680542856454849, -0.031223252415657043, 0.013320275582373142, 0.020890431478619576, -0.0014730636030435562, -0.00636841356754303, 0.029212607070803642, -0.016034502536058426, 0.02046719193458557, -0.037461649626493454, 0.05001534894108772, 0.01802859641611576, 0.043600596487522125, 0.008253098465502262, 0.03678660839796066, -0.0354531928896904, -0.054826389998197556, -0.04190542921423912, -0.011767602525651455, 0.05323972925543785, 0.018660156056284904, 0.03295821323990822, -0.002188552636653185, 0.020511245355010033, 0.00922872219234705, 0.04116026312112808, -0.026081733405590057, 0.007100242190063, 0.0265383068472147, 0.0043538473546504974, 0.02309277094900608, -0.01714242808520794, 0.09783729165792465, -0.0063104890286922455, -0.0004284116148483008, 0.0033927205950021744, -0.009914509952068329, -0.019632240757346153, 0.00462008360773325, 0.03151951730251312, 0.02202690578997135, -0.012090898118913174, -0.01760157197713852, -0.040819332003593445, -0.04485958442091942, 0.00034831854281947017, 0.007306631654500961, 0.01607517898082733, -0.008210496045649052, 0.04918045550584793, 0.04644171893596649, -0.03462504222989082, -0.04212266951799393, -0.05341104045510292, 0.011639743112027645, -0.00039404057315550745, -0.04206196963787079, -0.049166932702064514, -6.740039957853232e-33, -0.04848403483629227, 0.0036679955665022135, 0.014500862918794155, -0.00019519912893883884, -0.05886510759592056, 0.02866560034453869, -0.04863820597529411, -0.028721675276756287, -0.001498249126598239, 0.006588255520910025, -0.025745490565896034, 0.030013199895620346, 0.009718510322272778, 0.018847491592168808, 0.04073035717010498, 0.038718871772289276, 0.05317509174346924, -0.016001850366592407, -0.0031508593820035458, 0.01946505531668663, 0.03946586698293686, 0.07358042150735855, 0.12860071659088135, -0.04629892110824585, 0.015145368874073029, 0.0043600574135780334, 0.027173304930329323, -0.018637847155332565, -0.011934024281799793, -0.028867000713944435, -0.031424183398485184, 0.016450844705104828, 0.012288035824894905, -0.056052517145872116, -0.035183846950531006, -0.028834132477641106, -0.05461646988987923, -0.03466495871543884, -0.023411599919199944, -0.005485969595611095, -0.006466840859502554, -0.028648437932133675, 0.09036938846111298, -0.011070862412452698, -0.01734323613345623, -0.02520839497447014, 0.03829373046755791, -0.01614556647837162, -0.04429227113723755, -0.04616839438676834, -0.06789401173591614, 0.010302087292075157, -0.027521390467882156, -0.02326258271932602, -0.003901743097230792, 0.012895549647510052, -0.005683195311576128, -0.028708944097161293, -0.11738625913858414, 0.018214857205748558, 0.058498039841651917, 0.10504121333360672, 0.050442278385162354, 0.027265166863799095, -0.01953814923763275, 0.033354587852954865, 0.03969457745552063, 0.018805695697665215, 0.015567594207823277, 0.001266987295821309, 0.05682286620140076, 0.011882628314197063, 0.06023835763335228, -0.011128148064017296, 0.08733192086219788, -0.01345883123576641, -0.06695716828107834, 0.061584923416376114, -0.020604269579052925, 0.044270217418670654, -0.022910399362444878, 0.002589193871244788, -0.03977089747786522, -0.023828016594052315, -0.022984717041254044, -0.034263718873262405, -0.004721423611044884, -0.051375892013311386, 0.008074743673205376, -0.0064860256388783455, -0.017346609383821487, -0.03620465472340584, 0.03429458290338516, -0.04377400875091553, 0.048986051231622696, 0.014260776340961456, -0.011185280047357082, -0.028587277978658676, -0.012914254330098629, 0.019800471141934395, -0.03084414266049862, -0.015339822508394718, 0.02215767465531826, 0.014222667552530766, 0.026830457150936127, 0.0034423659089952707, 0.029485538601875305, 0.023252662271261215, -0.010981720872223377, -0.011770805343985558, -0.02387348935008049, -0.04131890833377838, 0.0445483922958374, 0.03434675931930542, 0.01172782015055418, -0.023685457184910774, -0.00827591959387064, 0.025366855785250664, 0.05698314681649208, 0.0029817717149853706, -0.023350287228822708, 0.02535790018737316, 0.055844713002443314, 0.036546047776937485, -0.05450619012117386, -0.002745978534221649, -0.057223863899707794, -0.011841123923659325, 0.03900596871972084, -0.047872621566057205, -0.029564956203103065, 0.015302585437893867, 3.176172924668208e-07, 0.040955591946840286, 0.033053502440452576, 0.000710885738953948, -0.029393251985311508, 0.013627242296934128, 0.020894382148981094, -0.029295552521944046, 0.03149145469069481, -0.015143905766308308, 0.008154836483299732, 0.046366818249225616, -0.011261030100286007, 0.04961134493350983, 0.014495760202407837, -0.1353221833705902, -0.046876683831214905, -0.053901273757219315, -0.024026209488511086, -0.052185025066137314, -0.023813819512724876, 0.08506124466657639, 0.06680015474557877, 0.020790765061974525, -0.02379666082561016, 0.012339322827756405, -0.01078200526535511, 0.01915677636861801, 0.063487209379673, 0.005444420035928488, 0.01682746410369873, 0.04259588569402695, -0.0241656843572855, -0.03552147001028061, 0.014173547737300396, -0.04417961835861206, 0.006776545196771622, 0.01917080767452717, 0.08245018124580383, 0.005670730024576187, 0.007595526985824108, 0.034827444702386856, 0.01905682310461998, -0.007088049780577421, -0.06046600639820099, 0.02823522314429283, -0.057930152863264084, -0.013782715424895287, 0.038712698966264725, -0.018261192366480827, -0.007565740961581469, 0.017191899940371513, 0.00955948792397976, 0.011255494318902493, 0.009295394644141197, -0.002176037523895502, -0.00814533606171608, -0.01549222506582737, -0.04465014860033989, -0.021403441205620766, -0.015408402308821678, -0.02130729705095291, -0.037876199930906296, -0.01887252740561962, -0.024244287982583046, 0.01819622702896595, -0.036644887179136276, -0.004507689271122217, 3.3863971866274627e-34, 0.007062653545290232, 0.00474740844219923, 0.013811115175485611, -0.019867246970534325, 0.0012833885848522186, -0.008899519219994545, -0.07190907001495361, 0.015241238288581371, -0.0077409762889146805, -0.05760622397065163, -0.05327000468969345]
620
620
['Madhusudan Lakshmana', 'Sundararajan Sellamanickam', 'Shirish Shevade', 'Keerthi Selvaraj']
1608.00466v2
The state-of-the-art CNN models give good performance on sentence classification tasks. The purpose of this work is to empirically study desirable properties such as semantic coherence, attention mechanism and reusability of CNNs in these tasks. Semantically coherent kernels are preferable as they are a lot more interpretable for explaining the decision of the learned CNN model. We observe that the learned kernels do not have semantic coherence. Motivated by this observation, we propose to learn kernels with semantic coherence using clustering scheme combined with Word2Vec representation and domain knowledge such as SentiWordNet. We suggest a technique to visualize attention mechanism of CNNs for decision explanation purpose. Reusable property enables kernels learned on one problem to be used in another problem. This helps in efficient learning as only a few additional domain specific filters may have to be learned. We demonstrate the efficacy of our core ideas of learning semantically coherent kernels and leveraging reusable kernels for efficient learning on several benchmark datasets. Experimental results show the usefulness of our approach by achieving performance close to the state-of-the-art methods but with semantic and reusable properties.
Learning Semantically Coherent and Reusable Kernels in Convolution Neural Nets for Sentence Classification
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1608.00466v2
Title Learning Semantically Coherent Reusable Kernels Convolution Neural Nets Sentence Classification Summary stateoftheart CNN model give good performance sentence classification task purpose work empirically study desirable property semantic coherence attention mechanism reusability CNNs task Semantically coherent kernel preferable lot interpretable explaining decision learned CNN model observe learned kernel semantic coherence Motivated observation propose learn kernel semantic coherence using clustering scheme combined Word2Vec representation domain knowledge SentiWordNet suggest technique visualize attention mechanism CNNs decision explanation purpose Reusable property enables kernel learned one problem used another problem help efficient learning additional domain specific filter may learned demonstrate efficacy core idea learning semantically coherent kernel leveraging reusable kernel efficient learning several benchmark datasets Experimental result show usefulness approach achieving performance close stateoftheart method semantic reusable property Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.028136268258094788, 0.0006274341722019017, 0.009030177257955074, 0.08677586168050766, 9.5728573796805e-05, -0.03109797276556492, -0.007404872216284275, -0.012728176079690456, -0.003021592739969492, -0.06996281445026398, 0.011573974043130875, 0.06878609210252762, -0.01573127880692482, 0.03351372852921486, 0.001849544234573841, -0.0626978874206543, 0.03168894723057747, 0.03635402023792267, -0.011909960769116879, 0.03382045775651932, 0.020528189837932587, 0.011809577234089375, -0.002124663209542632, 0.05366473272442818, -0.0642668753862381, -0.043148986995220184, 0.015554247424006462, 0.017620496451854706, 0.002102878410369158, -0.023131756111979485, 0.06771115213632584, 0.020985746756196022, 0.010984664782881737, -0.014473939314484596, 2.3379973299597623e-06, -0.02995295077562332, -0.05145945027470589, -0.036033354699611664, -0.007204580586403608, 0.0020719387102872133, 0.005065198056399822, -0.009944661520421505, 0.012071344070136547, -0.0023968350142240524, -0.02039571851491928, 0.03990072384476662, 0.009075932204723358, 0.11792167276144028, 0.021992238238453865, 0.03806087374687195, -0.02377239800989628, -0.08470762521028519, -0.01399683766067028, 0.013536163605749607, -0.01911139115691185, -0.025925207883119583, 0.0034739524126052856, 0.025561396032571793, 0.0026815729215741158, 0.013685595244169235, -0.06423091143369675, 0.06174393370747566, 0.0348949208855629, -0.03407131880521774, 0.07929372042417526, 0.03151366859674454, -0.07781656831502914, -0.011912532150745392, 0.022837743163108826, 0.10062208026647568, -0.055635686963796616, -0.0019143903627991676, 0.01775985024869442, -0.01833365485072136, 0.002609679941087961, -0.006110126152634621, -0.004537088330835104, -0.038732223212718964, 0.007010153029114008, 0.05177772417664528, 0.010699757374823093, 0.0147454384714365, 0.008104695938527584, 0.01751132309436798, -0.009176173247396946, 0.04245809465646744, -0.033970944583415985, 0.0002743411750998348, 0.01852590963244438, 0.03571092709898949, -0.08782114088535309, -0.03317676857113838, -0.013179253786802292, 0.024727046489715576, -0.006229087244719267, 0.008811871521174908, -0.06832931190729141, -0.025338800624012947, 0.01848003827035427, -0.07919300347566605, 0.00927099958062172, -0.013024845160543919, -0.06741906702518463, 0.003473853226751089, -0.015264132060110569, 0.00865971576422453, 0.0006955712451599538, 0.045952387154102325, -0.04844837635755539, -0.02488541603088379, -0.08511600643396378, -0.01472780853509903, -0.05671701952815056, 0.06964029371738434, 0.02096976339817047, -0.042427778244018555, -0.059760041534900665, 0.03891070932149887, -0.010079105384647846, -0.003008348634466529, -0.014488567598164082, 0.02662297710776329, 0.011695463210344315, 0.024206548929214478, -0.018809404224157333, 0.013211118057370186, -0.021669510751962662, 0.011862991377711296, -0.048934660851955414, -0.03795882314443588, 0.014849497005343437, 0.04131736978888512, 0.03859219327569008, -0.009847810491919518, -0.014008945785462856, 0.011336908675730228, -0.016706615686416626, -0.050154827535152435, -0.07112888991832733, -0.07548434287309647, -0.05353670194745064, -0.03640362247824669, -0.06075379624962807, -0.05340632423758507, -0.02604822814464569, -0.009932588785886765, 0.009088687598705292, -0.03833182156085968, 0.0027677929028868675, 0.006134917493909597, -0.047908589243888855, 0.04348018392920494, 0.04665786772966385, -0.016662966459989548, 0.05834938958287239, 0.015681913122534752, 0.06942921131849289, 0.034302789717912674, 0.01275920495390892, 0.019505884498357773, 0.027527067810297012, -0.01798839122056961, -0.00567154074087739, -0.03844696655869484, -0.022286519408226013, -0.04357488825917244, -0.02980092354118824, 0.014036623761057854, 0.00707528879866004, 0.027879886329174042, 0.002493802225217223, 0.04228600859642029, 0.005140792578458786, -0.006519719958305359, 0.029110077768564224, 0.060238417237997055, 0.06412006169557571, -0.010795818641781807, 0.04380705952644348, 0.04887666925787926, -0.0014109985204413533, 0.029237452894449234, -0.014036860316991806, 0.01690734550356865, 0.002890517935156822, 0.006789409089833498, 0.00026362811331637204, -0.04008626937866211, -0.02428058534860611, -0.07559657096862793, -0.017415648326277733, -0.018147876486182213, -0.03744226321578026, 0.004661120939999819, 0.028586966916918755, 0.005058499053120613, -0.023044412955641747, -0.008248701691627502, 0.022355111315846443, -0.029476363211870193, 0.005783291533589363, -0.007062623742967844, 0.028378888964653015, 0.03584367781877518, 0.028311647474765778, -0.03651867061853409, -0.0001546938146930188, -0.024340597912669182, 0.025856323540210724, -0.0018411946948617697, 0.026393882930278778, -0.014375605620443821, 0.007004284765571356, -0.04394843429327011, 0.0010669672628864646, -0.03028082475066185, -0.0050056735053658485, -0.04338574782013893, -0.03191017359495163, 0.05104579031467438, 0.037359245121479034, 0.04069652408361435, -0.002991419518366456, 0.034609321504831314, 0.09504580497741699, 0.024070776998996735, 0.014287070371210575, 0.043967004865407944, 0.014380821026861668, 0.03947952017188072, -0.0023032904136925936, 0.003139177802950144, 0.04823776334524155, -0.04116414114832878, -0.042077768594026566, 0.01605021394789219, -0.037568483501672745, -0.05265473574399948, -0.0311613567173481, -0.0319751501083374, -0.027003290131688118, 0.0056146434508264065, -0.03183789551258087, -0.04693683236837387, 0.039698276668787, -0.017202135175466537, 0.033717647194862366, -0.042628828436136246, 0.004323417320847511, 0.004308503586798906, 0.05488079413771629, -0.024779831990599632, 0.046180225908756256, 0.016109606251120567, 0.018039174377918243, -0.04209648817777634, 0.0023771824780851603, 0.012762960977852345, -0.02951144054532051, 0.008436686359345913, 0.008310089819133282, -0.009657276794314384, 0.011254989542067051, 0.02590935491025448, -0.025835411623120308, -0.036872293800115585, -0.015532884746789932, -0.035634323954582214, -0.01891137659549713, -0.038880083709955215, -0.02646998129785061, -0.005098688416182995, -0.009771841578185558, 0.03239522874355316, -0.034930452704429626, -0.007487043272703886, 0.06480919569730759, 0.0018758696969598532, -0.026316655799746513, 0.0565260574221611, -0.027536295354366302, -0.009210237301886082, -0.032472655177116394, -0.008729474619030952, 6.576047599082813e-05, 0.06373876333236694, 0.011020246893167496, -0.08189970254898071, -0.03871140629053116, 0.02233903668820858, -0.01141507737338543, 0.014131917618215084, 0.02522587776184082, -0.037884727120399475, -0.014501405879855156, 0.02353500947356224, 0.018656477332115173, 0.042343731969594955, 0.03562888503074646, 0.06199061870574951, 0.02469300851225853, 0.0303393192589283, 0.018109863623976707, 0.03585804998874664, -0.0076436749659478664, 0.03130176663398743, -0.024704568088054657, 0.022097067907452583, 0.0046845693141222, 0.013332412578165531, 0.06072961166501045, 0.004215066321194172, -0.035520363599061966, -0.04866842180490494, -0.05408032611012459, -0.015306278131902218, -0.09705998003482819, -0.004020636901259422, 0.019673677161335945, -0.011828171089291573, -0.0046494812704622746, -0.005101851653307676, 0.04968709498643875, 0.010360528714954853, -0.018197473138570786, -0.05574444308876991, -0.06203785911202431, -0.027759090065956116, 0.0472981259226799, 0.018564440310001373, 0.024633878841996193, 0.05047256872057915, 0.002943918574601412, -0.008552840910851955, -0.04307156056165695, -0.024020040407776833, -0.003221477149054408, 0.08966708183288574, -0.012392837554216385, 0.005408077035099268, -0.0157387126237154, -0.03636416792869568, -0.06173338741064072, -0.07490283995866776, -0.044376008212566376, 0.005644071381539106, -0.026461925357580185, 0.005701743997633457, -0.02906201034784317, -0.010372769087553024, 0.01655065082013607, -0.01296628825366497, -0.005061465315520763, -0.018524646759033203, -0.004740026313811541, 0.06690191477537155, 0.0705326646566391, 0.045216236263513565, -0.05568185821175575, 0.024025950580835342, 0.02556062676012516, 0.09244207292795181, -0.03455830737948418, -0.0145352091640234, -0.035010963678359985, -0.009389604441821575, -0.011158877983689308, -0.024710113182663918, -0.03634125366806984, 0.014838850125670433, 0.0289602130651474, -0.06626340746879578, 0.025600476190447807, 0.08497042953968048, -9.733819024404511e-05, -0.004798433743417263, 0.030531860888004303, 0.03817233815789223, -0.01257655955851078, 0.012779636308550835, 0.02046836167573929, -0.0216339360922575, -0.06673984229564667, -0.022113177925348282, -0.0038278482388705015, 0.017188794910907745, 0.021806135773658752, -0.006470190826803446, -0.050967611372470856, 0.036627396941185, -0.025990264490246773, -0.016790803521871567, -0.0007457322790287435, -0.01769224740564823, -0.02386620081961155, -0.009953096508979797, -0.026198431849479675, -0.027918903157114983, 0.003581206314265728, -0.008170480839908123, 0.009347908198833466, -0.030853882431983948, 0.023663420230150223, 3.660978836705908e-05, -0.005313483532518148, 0.022088846191763878, 0.025064485147595406, 0.038628678768873215, -0.027942130342125893, -0.048510532826185226, 0.015283224172890186, -0.08086294680833817, 0.0039912941865623, 0.006300665903836489, 0.07259614765644073, -0.025279972702264786, -0.02041422389447689, 0.0036759625654667616, 0.05257745459675789, -0.05153444781899452, -0.03820508345961571, 0.01500138733536005, 0.03441692143678665, -0.03929250314831734, -0.004448621068149805, -0.038357123732566833, 0.028115589171648026, -0.026626678183674812, 0.07361291348934174, 0.029357142746448517, -0.028605768457055092, -0.04033590853214264, -0.001996663399040699, -0.0021591167896986008, -0.03715124726295471, -0.004586437717080116, 0.006057516671717167, -0.0030151824466884136, 0.002254517748951912, -0.062469612807035446, -0.07838904857635498, -0.0008788357372395694, -0.00354816229082644, -0.0006568434182554483, 0.059509117156267166, 0.021047741174697876, -0.022785132750868797, -0.0813433900475502, 0.014985672198235989, 0.025695184245705605, 0.05212694779038429, -0.07916831970214844, 0.007404451724141836, 0.04378647357225418, -0.023813433945178986, -0.026637159287929535, -0.03566215559840202, -0.021969826892018318, -0.05237627774477005, 0.013414538465440273, -0.034579817205667496, -0.007519514765590429, 0.023083114996552467, -0.03408847749233246, -0.029675129801034927, 0.038158535957336426, -0.021248633041977882, -0.04533883184194565, 0.0570971742272377, 0.019567003473639488, 0.0046725342981517315, 0.005492568947374821, 0.05579620599746704, -0.035161931067705154, 0.04730236530303955, 0.0043300180695950985, -0.03716329485177994, 0.004593182820826769, -0.06080611050128937, -0.005258630495518446, -0.0327470488846302, 0.0525674894452095, 0.032478224486112595, 0.04980584233999252, -0.03841371089220047, 0.010951148346066475, 0.009157458320260048, -0.026898039504885674, -0.01384949591010809, 0.016334060579538345, 0.004152305424213409, 0.0004404329229146242, -0.03852616623044014, 0.01835114136338234, -0.034407395869493484, -0.004461884964257479, 0.04474863037467003, 0.03308158740401268, -0.009357360191643238, -0.022565608844161034, -0.04404134303331375, 0.012464032508432865, -0.017894962802529335, -0.013549180701375008, -0.001238116528838873, 0.012351609766483307, 0.00020032723841723055, 0.03167800232768059, -0.010500584729015827, 0.014552894979715347, -0.062197111546993256, 0.05059140920639038, -0.05773697793483734, 0.03387827426195145, 0.006342741195112467, 0.03452380746603012, 0.06581175327301025, -0.07203871011734009, 0.03237109258770943, 0.002402497921139002, -0.005696336273103952, -0.029153458774089813, 0.08521221578121185, 0.011008245870471, -0.013880395330488682, 0.0445089153945446, 0.004608906339854002, -0.034698642790317535, -0.034391243010759354, 0.05920705571770668, -0.029884520918130875, 0.005896443035453558, 0.040332112461328506, -0.01585170067846775, -0.02945386804640293, 0.01353378128260374, -0.002159564523026347, 0.026343226432800293, -0.024200357496738434, 0.0413680300116539, -0.0032950425520539284, -0.039168067276477814, 0.05604429170489311, -0.030039483681321144, 0.028910990804433823, 0.025673046708106995, 0.03324921801686287, 0.023460516706109047, 0.08370235562324524, -0.022835606709122658, -0.0753362849354744, -0.015164821408689022, 0.023517437279224396, -0.044363945722579956, -0.01135540846735239, -6.814605237945736e-33, 0.03908195719122887, -0.012094497680664062, -0.03242392838001251, 0.012956514954566956, -0.027113229036331177, 0.056908078491687775, -0.023551637306809425, -0.009043591096997261, -0.01953335478901863, 0.032787829637527466, 0.00974747259169817, 0.0501711331307888, 0.011741518042981625, 0.05623174086213112, 0.005318543873727322, -0.018092690035700798, 0.05365317314863205, 0.02958797663450241, 0.028064753860235214, -0.0012925256742164493, 0.08274950087070465, 0.04340497404336929, 0.062017086893320084, -0.04361489787697792, -0.004406404681503773, 0.0011498798849061131, 0.035379886627197266, -0.005081704817712307, 0.05965597555041313, 0.03664134442806244, -0.021908214315772057, 0.06956105679273605, 0.05476249009370804, -0.01911408267915249, 0.008366324938833714, 0.03037337400019169, -0.07518602162599564, -0.041947681456804276, -0.03362767770886421, 0.009091939777135849, -0.08012661337852478, -0.024123741313815117, 0.04775189608335495, -0.0054885451681911945, 0.03363707289099693, -0.011637791059911251, 0.07921892404556274, 0.01609973981976509, -0.024908170104026794, 0.04174847528338432, -0.0830073133111, 0.01149739883840084, -0.043939009308815, -0.000934673473238945, 0.043369997292757034, -0.0018728309078142047, 0.019626937806606293, -0.005769312847405672, -0.014409139752388, -0.014645054005086422, -0.08098234236240387, 0.030111296102404594, 0.008680151775479317, 0.02447522059082985, -0.03284327685832977, 0.0670960545539856, -0.023700883612036705, -0.02504795603454113, -0.027103260159492493, -0.0019548977725207806, -0.01791900023818016, 0.050593096762895584, 0.03206087276339531, 0.051782093942165375, 0.06191416084766388, -0.05681472271680832, -0.0786505937576294, 0.008658708073198795, -0.06740453839302063, 0.022283071652054787, 0.022085877135396004, -0.007887973450124264, -0.05472352355718613, 0.0033864136785268784, 0.020557381212711334, 0.03417655825614929, -0.02452854812145233, -0.019698703661561012, 0.009751517325639725, -0.009759299457073212, -0.018396545201539993, 0.021902412176132202, -0.0033053129445761442, -0.018840761855244637, 0.03295576572418213, -0.00534692220389843, 0.007994009181857109, 0.00832440610975027, 0.031608954071998596, -0.00646123755723238, -0.0346037894487381, -0.010908485390245914, 0.012224983423948288, 0.02973352000117302, 0.01542661339044571, -0.007350304163992405, 0.09355812519788742, 0.005516048055142164, -0.0031831676606088877, -0.007014980539679527, -0.005958937108516693, -0.037827905267477036, -0.049055419862270355, 0.010515040718019009, -0.020509297028183937, 0.05424207076430321, -0.03676285594701767, 0.017710015177726746, 0.0006675397744402289, -0.010930254124104977, -0.014520381577312946, -0.05220561847090721, 0.04091981425881386, 0.02962633967399597, -0.008650870062410831, 0.005976493936032057, -0.01995840296149254, 0.04176816716790199, 0.05758969858288765, -0.08235645294189453, 0.011327828280627728, 0.009188558906316757, 2.940243177818047e-07, 0.06892615556716919, -0.037780940532684326, -0.02147616632282734, -0.04230201244354248, -0.001745157758705318, 0.012402258813381195, 0.006233058404177427, 0.06872942298650742, -0.0805337205529213, 0.003451589262112975, 0.021795930340886116, 0.041635580360889435, 0.0440826453268528, -0.01597428508102894, -0.06234799697995186, 0.0032311435788869858, -0.041786078363657, -0.02429305762052536, -0.03773310407996178, 0.002628631191328168, 0.1349603235721588, 0.09394878894090652, 0.03849926218390465, -0.02141573838889599, 0.02686857432126999, -0.004360816907137632, -0.014260065741837025, 0.008095151744782925, 0.02783319726586342, 0.001631367253139615, -0.0008745242957957089, 0.03489071503281593, 0.02126895822584629, 0.0015681771328672767, -0.029737286269664764, -0.0015857672551646829, 0.04368110001087189, 0.014956838451325893, -0.010710405185818672, -0.02178862877190113, -0.00721149705350399, 0.011112529784440994, 0.019816376268863678, -0.024950090795755386, 0.08621147274971008, -0.02915334701538086, -0.043776534497737885, -0.007193208672106266, 0.04953055456280708, 0.021037645637989044, 0.0545390360057354, 0.017123358324170113, -0.029737377539277077, 0.0036129169166088104, 0.022572601214051247, -0.060865368694067, -0.026349538937211037, -0.09386295080184937, -0.03741276264190674, -0.0020339475013315678, -0.013033566996455193, 0.053939007222652435, -0.04060995578765869, -0.040220219641923904, 0.07045818865299225, -0.020387697964906693, -0.018771909177303314, 2.3188942620360206e-34, 0.01497318223118782, 0.01840776763856411, -0.026268329471349716, -0.00996330101042986, 0.0010245863813906908, -0.01786484196782112, -0.02864930033683777, -0.027828238904476166, -0.030859505757689476, -0.03974149748682976, -0.020296810194849968]
621
621
['Patrick Doetsch', 'Albert Zeyer', 'Paul Voigtlaender', 'Ilya Kulikov', 'Ralf Schlüter', 'Hermann Ney']
1608.00895v2
In this work we release our extensible and easily configurable neural network training software. It provides a rich set of functional layers with a particular focus on efficient training of recurrent neural network topologies on multiple GPUs. The source of the software package is public and freely available for academic research purposes and can be used as a framework or as a standalone tool which supports a flexible configuration. The software allows to train state-of-the-art deep bidirectional long short-term memory (LSTM) models on both one dimensional data like speech or two dimensional data like handwritten text and was used to develop successful submission systems in several evaluation campaigns.
RETURNN: The RWTH Extensible Training framework for Universal Recurrent Neural Networks
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1608.00895v2
Title RETURNN RWTH Extensible Training framework Universal Recurrent Neural Networks Summary work release extensible easily configurable neural network training software provides rich set functional layer particular focus efficient training recurrent neural network topology multiple GPUs source software package public freely available academic research purpose used framework standalone tool support flexible configuration software allows train stateoftheart deep bidirectional long shortterm memory LSTM model one dimensional data like speech two dimensional data like handwritten text used develop successful submission system several evaluation campaign Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.0106066158041358, 0.029567375779151917, 0.012187649495899677, 0.03967103362083435, -0.01368166133761406, -0.000895736156962812, 0.040856894105672836, 0.004182773642241955, -0.016622059047222137, -0.004811123013496399, -0.03874160349369049, -0.042976900935173035, 0.032456908375024796, 0.055932242423295975, 0.013795134611427784, -0.09457926452159882, 0.02969491109251976, 0.000405861996114254, 0.008971660397946835, 0.00343511370010674, 0.0411161370575428, -0.00864721741527319, -0.04822713881731033, 0.046510960906744, -0.026086624711751938, 0.0003953887789975852, -0.029513249173760414, 0.0006836220272816718, 0.007229903247207403, -0.06493997573852539, 0.03178686276078224, 0.03955358266830444, 0.0511084608733654, 0.03680330514907837, 2.194143007727689e-06, -0.006094250828027725, -0.010222919285297394, -0.05121560022234917, 0.036014899611473083, -0.031413909047842026, 0.057133544236421585, -0.020056964829564095, -0.0037887510843575, 0.05010857433080673, -0.03879030793905258, -0.027458246797323227, 0.04827968403697014, 0.06697840988636017, 0.052814677357673645, 0.07077444344758987, -0.004543839953839779, -0.030540067702531815, -0.006071170791983604, -0.05440054461359978, 0.016904139891266823, 0.001840358367189765, 0.004851367324590683, -0.057515956461429596, -0.00625574728474021, -0.029398346319794655, -0.01426648534834385, 0.028811445459723473, 0.021407736465334892, 0.05045195296406746, 0.02679266966879368, 0.043969884514808655, -0.005058930721133947, -0.02692025527358055, -0.017792189493775368, 0.046452101320028305, 0.00020656094420701265, -0.0022894409485161304, 0.022520434111356735, 0.017805054783821106, -0.04705044999718666, -0.036107394844293594, -0.04531168192625046, 0.029962806031107903, -0.0033994056284427643, 0.014050781726837158, -0.04031424969434738, -0.001958562759682536, 0.043080028146505356, 0.021165918558835983, 0.03506053611636162, -0.00513105746358633, 0.00271710567176342, -0.022265352308750153, -0.01336428988724947, -0.024191269651055336, 0.039683856070041656, -0.056343600153923035, 0.014169265516102314, 0.05051559954881668, 0.0062454259023070335, -0.01374584436416626, -0.043631430715322495, -0.07628105580806732, 0.028462670743465424, -0.051089923828840256, 0.05939573049545288, 0.009011754766106606, -0.00935857929289341, -0.0025277170352637768, -0.0019142277305945754, 0.02408328838646412, -0.018989838659763336, -0.013865224085748196, 0.017978502437472343, 0.02943306602537632, -0.05649018660187721, 0.005896506365388632, -0.014680598862469196, 0.03324595466256142, -0.01074135024100542, -0.016867656260728836, -0.08563784509897232, -0.022707786411046982, -0.02326531521975994, -0.00695804925635457, 0.0171150341629982, 0.07512477785348892, -0.0705307126045227, -0.004490940365940332, -0.007503384258598089, 0.055590130388736725, -0.023678358644247055, 0.06352564692497253, -0.012756988406181335, -0.041072554886341095, -0.002405911684036255, 0.04867814481258392, 0.007130037993192673, 0.034753669053316116, 0.0002940029662568122, 0.07638021558523178, 0.02427557483315468, -0.004721369128674269, -0.057426221668720245, 0.015695447102189064, 0.010262136347591877, -0.05217182636260986, 0.004574693739414215, -0.07956597954034805, 0.013002444989979267, -0.05716670677065849, -0.0001581394171807915, -0.0062179723754525185, 0.007089650724083185, -0.01844974420964718, 0.039740901440382004, 0.08207430690526962, -0.005078092683106661, -0.01958541013300419, 0.10056031495332718, 0.003876208793371916, 0.053079720586538315, 0.03025016188621521, 0.06851037591695786, 0.02619369514286518, -0.012665894813835621, -0.0221756212413311, 0.02091333456337452, 0.03602084890007973, -0.0010463388171046972, -0.03925840184092522, -0.03542233258485794, -0.03070693463087082, 0.0005129409255459905, 0.07849499583244324, 0.011276395991444588, 0.009781202301383018, -0.00333597999997437, -0.018652327358722687, 0.03747725486755371, 0.07170060276985168, 0.064438596367836, 0.043792758136987686, -0.0063585033640265465, -0.024503903463482857, 0.005761538166552782, -0.05005642771720886, -0.04803324490785599, 0.049720700830221176, 0.02995692752301693, -0.005429413635283709, -0.048580680042505264, 0.011047548614442348, -0.04510267451405525, -0.030642084777355194, 0.0008828024729155004, -0.06808262318372726, 0.014527319930493832, -0.038839735090732574, 0.0633975937962532, -0.015491525642573833, -0.03475875034928322, 0.010948104783892632, -0.0014389733551070094, -0.055535342544317245, -0.008168400265276432, -0.013840144500136375, 0.02768634632229805, 0.05556134879589081, -0.009763150475919247, -0.04748868569731712, -0.01841806434094906, -0.03903480991721153, -0.009733770042657852, 0.06534630805253983, -0.012569433078169823, 0.014277520589530468, 0.07678410410881042, -0.09379350394010544, 0.0028696029912680387, 0.016025282442569733, -0.016707606613636017, 0.054579075425863266, -0.03327685967087746, 0.036407966166734695, 0.011048509739339352, 0.06258109956979752, -0.02864944562315941, 0.029457123950123787, -0.03268423676490784, -0.048359256237745285, 0.01297114696353674, 0.035243820399045944, 0.04381966590881348, 0.0008060920517891645, 0.010345912538468838, -0.019897444173693657, 0.060338906943798065, -0.06922785192728043, -0.01589975878596306, 0.002850594464689493, -0.039945848286151886, -0.00031744592706672847, 0.007668268401175737, -0.014136113226413727, 0.03695821762084961, 0.07192741334438324, -0.06952559947967529, -0.07436578720808029, 0.052972760051488876, -0.03147314861416817, 0.035939235240221024, -0.04047483950853348, -0.005642682313919067, 0.028254665434360504, 0.013099958188831806, 0.0023060492239892483, -0.009451477788388729, 0.008363736793398857, -0.0158952958881855, -0.023945381864905357, 0.0013069865526631474, -0.004148863721638918, -0.06637021154165268, -0.014068194665014744, 0.017516793683171272, -0.037998609244823456, 0.02615283988416195, -0.005494016222655773, 0.03358613699674606, -0.049364518374204636, -0.014975509606301785, -0.07713566720485687, 0.04442577436566353, 0.0033884106669574976, 0.0022127795964479446, 0.012807641178369522, 0.01407600473612547, 0.002845864510163665, -0.05201304331421852, -0.027440587058663368, 0.01483070757240057, 0.0030856886878609657, -0.01618182472884655, 0.020513447001576424, 0.009541977196931839, 0.022587617859244347, -0.03126923739910126, -0.017045356333255768, 0.01673426292836666, -0.002217425499111414, -0.004449916537851095, -0.07176532596349716, 0.019840463995933533, 0.02299533411860466, -0.032915156334638596, 0.060844842344522476, 0.0021156526636332273, -0.06195104122161865, -0.0067724124528467655, -0.008075199089944363, 0.01107820961624384, 0.06408863514661789, 0.05593143403530121, -0.04876634478569031, -0.021286744624376297, 0.014958959072828293, -0.023288438096642494, 0.01478151697665453, -0.02142990380525589, 0.013306542299687862, -0.007154526188969612, 0.0035550976172089577, -0.042935047298669815, 0.028872430324554443, 0.03656499832868576, 0.06912719458341599, -0.02620120719075203, -0.019107306376099586, -0.013738391920924187, 0.004297591745853424, -0.034020718187093735, -0.022473907098174095, -0.013105601072311401, -0.020716968923807144, -0.0008359106141142547, -0.05479989945888519, 0.012872494757175446, -0.01506563276052475, -0.015159107744693756, -0.010227004066109657, -0.056139059364795685, -0.03870243579149246, 0.02334396168589592, -0.026133326813578606, -0.01359952799975872, 0.0006485977210104465, -0.02881353348493576, -0.014681665226817131, -0.03460973501205444, -0.001669790712185204, -0.0500534251332283, 0.02284226380288601, -0.013893764466047287, -0.018544122576713562, -0.034344740211963654, -0.058949608355760574, -0.043658409267663956, 0.0419578030705452, -0.02763262949883938, -0.03711332008242607, -0.052036333829164505, -0.02852167934179306, 0.005580642260611057, 0.013251146301627159, 0.024216094985604286, 0.08446764200925827, -0.05520080029964447, 0.01190319936722517, 0.014329995028674603, 0.06307090073823929, 0.04604191333055496, 0.03096257895231247, -0.035135239362716675, 0.0011619074502959847, 0.01469713356345892, 0.026405099779367447, 0.005612670443952084, 0.013124484568834305, -0.10877615213394165, -0.003050515428185463, -0.02287924662232399, -0.019239263609051704, 0.006124941632151604, 0.027356034144759178, 0.03551500290632248, -0.11067967116832733, 0.011623295955359936, 0.07877637445926666, -0.0012656566686928272, -0.06309271603822708, -0.050944287329912186, -0.00662822974845767, 0.012310145422816277, 0.019523214548826218, -0.01642039231956005, -0.043675441294908524, -0.01319829747080803, -0.010739476419985294, 0.06779945641756058, 0.012327992357313633, -0.017364779487252235, 0.02184358611702919, -0.027909446507692337, 0.04583698883652687, 0.0035655891988426447, -0.09002715349197388, -0.039516597986221313, -0.05865539610385895, -0.0229034461081028, -0.02990065887570381, 0.007145499810576439, 0.0029140899423509836, -0.02410881780087948, 0.002987875835970044, 0.05370479077100754, -0.07637809216976166, 0.004898648709058762, 0.004918191581964493, -0.06551147997379303, 0.015123441815376282, 0.06970010697841644, 0.02068125270307064, -0.03153795376420021, -0.04546986147761345, -0.0032261109445244074, -0.012598173692822456, 0.017474155873060226, -0.02876516990363598, 0.04818956181406975, 0.0077031576074659824, -0.006410182919353247, -0.03565399721264839, 0.07646667212247849, -0.04320192337036133, 0.022591929882764816, 0.022985603660345078, 0.05578012764453888, -0.010142638348042965, 0.021526707336306572, -0.023980770260095596, 0.004901651758700609, 0.044424671679735184, 0.03019389882683754, 0.011792001314461231, -0.01866544410586357, -0.054506927728652954, 0.0007256821845658123, 0.0048227813094854355, -0.07035652548074722, -0.029711024835705757, -0.0204913429915905, 0.020233236253261566, -0.04867785423994064, -0.08352570980787277, -0.05978718400001526, 0.009594268165528774, 0.011547970585525036, 0.023051563650369644, 0.017220154404640198, 0.04428643360733986, 0.004643603693693876, -0.08275102823972702, 0.02698288857936859, 0.005952315405011177, 0.03481683507561684, -0.04118742048740387, -0.00949584599584341, 0.023692438378930092, -0.024737857282161713, 0.033424872905015945, 0.01375479344278574, -0.06274063885211945, -0.017374187707901, 0.012470467947423458, 0.05285564810037613, 0.020703572779893875, 0.06701315939426422, -0.02573348768055439, -0.020251087844371796, 0.07344906777143478, 0.007863471284508705, -0.03039606474339962, 0.04951545596122742, 0.07277316600084305, 0.03099238872528076, 0.00016006843361537904, 0.005181481596082449, -0.015387951396405697, 0.0759536400437355, -0.0030620316974818707, -0.014348228462040424, -0.008263462223112583, -0.020153013989329338, -0.014871703460812569, -0.0345754474401474, 0.061920177191495895, 0.007707876618951559, -0.018996447324752808, -0.055231694132089615, 0.03061138652265072, 0.014577285386621952, 0.0505644716322422, -0.039256736636161804, 0.03341608867049217, 0.033608678728342056, 0.024071097373962402, 0.002521442947909236, -0.04449789226055145, 0.040842149406671524, -0.030165687203407288, -0.011035619303584099, 0.05681641027331352, 0.00406868988648057, 0.044930826872587204, -0.023709623143076897, 0.050251126289367676, -0.009708904661238194, 0.025744283571839333, -0.02964606322348118, 0.025697121396660805, -0.007607619743794203, 0.08712171763181686, 0.0164768286049366, 0.012658326886594296, -0.0037575666792690754, 0.025420470163226128, -0.010038122534751892, -0.04463161155581474, -0.07537005841732025, 0.03209405392408371, 0.048343971371650696, -0.023442625999450684, 0.024771101772785187, -0.004399570170789957, 0.012306314893066883, -0.02065460756421089, 0.06061344966292381, -0.03326953202486038, 0.02993200160562992, 0.028220294043421745, -0.013365203514695168, -0.02420123480260372, 0.013242627494037151, 0.02738620527088642, -0.00489320233464241, 0.03654896467924118, 0.03794776648283005, 0.008212047629058361, -0.03250233083963394, -0.02531113103032112, 0.015403538942337036, -0.008079761639237404, -0.038031384348869324, -0.011759448796510696, -0.008370721712708473, -0.061307311058044434, 0.07440637797117233, 0.017989737913012505, 0.012947351671755314, -0.04081716015934944, 0.0556841641664505, -0.006433648057281971, -0.015569040551781654, 0.012852328829467297, 0.0034196979831904173, 0.03280883654952049, -0.0029725865460932255, -0.03242136165499687, -0.056983254849910736, -6.33273998150094e-33, -0.034083787351846695, 0.0164561215788126, 0.002113017253577709, -0.007015688344836235, -0.058293551206588745, 0.03479594737291336, -0.035918984562158585, -0.003149400232359767, 0.006839749403297901, -0.029560906812548637, 0.006241325289011002, 0.01802022010087967, 0.017702020704746246, 0.03766433149576187, 0.057169560343027115, -0.0008760232012718916, 0.028659971430897713, -0.03378918021917343, 0.006779828108847141, 0.004141903482377529, 0.06907506287097931, 0.02634655311703682, 0.08066792786121368, -0.06567420065402985, -0.05294956639409065, -0.0012209259439259768, -0.007114928215742111, -0.005100000184029341, 0.008173566311597824, 0.01843152940273285, -0.04665754735469818, 0.0034529876429587603, 0.014832704328000546, -0.04505566135048866, 0.008308193646371365, 0.045263927429914474, -0.08596193045377731, -0.03169049695134163, -0.024620160460472107, 0.005519654136151075, -0.09226533025503159, 0.01748487912118435, 0.06526491791009903, 0.017298994585871696, -0.010375496931374073, 0.03038516454398632, 0.03477218747138977, -0.024467390030622482, -0.018765391781926155, 0.00040960736805573106, -0.04926158860325813, 0.008340525440871716, -0.013983706943690777, -0.01707359589636326, 0.017619188874959946, 0.011181248351931572, -0.04571016877889633, 0.00038277305429801345, -0.10427417606115341, -0.0012246181722730398, -0.0003003717865794897, 0.042385999113321304, 0.01595916971564293, 0.03425769880414009, 0.01577114500105381, 0.031105851754546165, 0.03203513100743294, -0.022165978327393532, -0.02671039290726185, -0.0003557207528501749, 0.022440362721681595, 0.029615744948387146, 0.09613949805498123, 0.011092237196862698, 0.061416804790496826, -0.032054852694272995, -0.0447370745241642, 0.020594991743564606, 0.0075287590734660625, 0.06397917866706848, -0.0028035372961312532, 0.0034242109395563602, -0.009288596920669079, 0.026216283440589905, 0.025065438821911812, -0.0012083071051165462, -0.010043414309620857, -0.03726036846637726, 0.01612226851284504, 0.041873954236507416, 0.05189039558172226, 0.007977357134222984, 0.005939403548836708, -0.01196008175611496, 0.06077292189002037, -0.0039601316675543785, 0.0426190048456192, 0.0077945091761648655, 0.023435192182660103, -0.00974895991384983, -0.04740765318274498, -0.014968031086027622, 0.009925106540322304, 0.05818237364292145, 0.025508791208267212, -0.014893331564962864, 0.03650776669383049, 0.039969008415937424, -0.04154673591256142, -0.01587015390396118, -0.012749090790748596, 0.060794245451688766, 0.011785075068473816, 0.04938584193587303, 0.0017107228050008416, -0.027228353545069695, 0.004702331963926554, 0.07122400403022766, -0.020092714577913284, -0.006710851565003395, -0.04617990180850029, -0.04629140719771385, 0.03254258260130882, 0.0428585447371006, -0.05196389555931091, -0.009624832309782505, -0.06905656307935715, 0.0043256813660264015, 0.007368330843746662, -0.06688353419303894, 0.004557881038635969, 0.029745278880000114, 2.9078498187118385e-07, -0.049984417855739594, 0.010358130559325218, 0.03032292053103447, -0.026112835854291916, 0.04042010009288788, 0.004333650693297386, -0.03924504294991493, 0.031095361337065697, -0.004862107336521149, 0.0008534194785170257, 0.026601074263453484, 0.021963445469737053, 0.058637019246816635, -0.0011940640397369862, -0.07221023738384247, -0.038159046322107315, -0.06811849027872086, 0.023569248616695404, -0.02012018673121929, 0.012315239757299423, 0.01318582147359848, 0.1068253442645073, 0.04740974307060242, -0.026810811832547188, 0.050257593393325806, 0.021769637241959572, 0.030695192515850067, -0.0027157480362802744, 0.04221057891845703, -0.04607304558157921, -0.007000635843724012, -0.004083933308720589, -0.024011770263314247, -0.02503442019224167, -0.03959444910287857, 0.006209462881088257, -0.022982144728302956, 0.04793228954076767, -0.043724365532398224, -0.04849102348089218, 0.02581610530614853, 0.03215840458869934, -0.008037219755351543, -0.0161456186324358, 0.02055727131664753, -0.01821994036436081, -0.021989844739437103, -0.02278999425470829, -0.015126841142773628, 0.038087259978055954, 0.035240717232227325, -0.020721260458230972, 0.0014350881101563573, -0.013305163010954857, -0.015420535579323769, -0.03664427995681763, -0.015390288084745407, -0.05390897020697594, 0.00728466734290123, -0.00371419545263052, -0.05164779722690582, 0.007399746682494879, -0.07468938082456589, 0.01292400248348713, 0.015208830125629902, -0.04918257147073746, -0.020747143775224686, 2.370556549988439e-34, 0.007062642369419336, -0.01500662136822939, -0.016231950372457504, 0.0326831229031086, -0.01587042771279812, -0.0028207385912537575, -0.003830995876342058, 0.014500685036182404, 0.004263332113623619, -0.059492308646440506, -0.039672356098890305]
622
622
['Kyuyeon Hwang', 'Wonyong Sung']
1609.03777v2
Recurrent neural network (RNN) based character-level language models (CLMs) are extremely useful for modeling out-of-vocabulary words by nature. However, their performance is generally much worse than the word-level language models (WLMs), since CLMs need to consider longer history of tokens to properly predict the next one. We address this problem by proposing hierarchical RNN architectures, which consist of multiple modules with different timescales. Despite the multi-timescale structures, the input and output layers operate with the character-level clock, which allows the existing RNN CLM training approaches to be directly applicable without any modifications. Our CLM models show better perplexity than Kneser-Ney (KN) 5-gram WLMs on the One Billion Word Benchmark with only 2% of parameters. Also, we present real-time character-level end-to-end speech recognition examples on the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) corpus, where replacing traditional mono-clock RNN CLMs with the proposed models results in better recognition accuracies even though the number of parameters are reduced to 30%.
Character-Level Language Modeling with Hierarchical Recurrent Neural Networks
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1609.03777v2
Title CharacterLevel Language Modeling Hierarchical Recurrent Neural Networks Summary Recurrent neural network RNN based characterlevel language model CLMs extremely useful modeling outofvocabulary word nature However performance generally much worse wordlevel language model WLMs since CLMs need consider longer history token properly predict next one address problem proposing hierarchical RNN architecture consist multiple module different timescales Despite multitimescale structure input output layer operate characterlevel clock allows existing RNN CLM training approach directly applicable without modification CLM model show better perplexity KneserNey KN 5gram WLMs One Billion Word Benchmark 2 parameter Also present realtime characterlevel endtoend speech recognition example Wall Street Journal WSJ corpus replacing traditional monoclock RNN CLMs proposed model result better recognition accuracy even though number parameter reduced 30 Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.03231010586023331, 0.066754549741745, 0.01192980632185936, 0.039426058530807495, -0.03793578967452049, 0.006929038558155298, 0.048987630754709244, 0.01880742609500885, -0.0144269410520792, -0.035498570650815964, -0.007920471951365471, -0.05754922702908516, 0.032995760440826416, 0.03209879249334335, 0.004534644540399313, -0.08438754081726074, 0.02680325135588646, -0.03831161931157112, 0.001213796902447939, -0.003520174417644739, -0.004208665806800127, -0.00021489299251697958, -0.0059348419308662415, 0.05079992488026619, 0.015615003183484077, -0.015601640567183495, -0.003488902933895588, -0.00516456738114357, -0.028147650882601738, -0.04483399912714958, 0.017779821529984474, 0.04358696937561035, 0.07862851023674011, 0.06480931490659714, 2.3092145511327544e-06, 0.00035942281829193234, 0.011727733537554741, -0.009805308654904366, -0.011204146780073643, 0.004829745274037123, 0.06451333314180374, -0.00148369453381747, -0.004850615281611681, 0.03293484449386597, 0.011436310596764088, -0.014172050170600414, 0.03536356985569, 0.054438114166259766, 0.016710897907614708, 0.030087726190686226, 0.008328024297952652, -0.09074308723211288, 0.02654944732785225, -0.04581591859459877, -0.006521511822938919, -0.048329148441553116, 0.012135190889239311, -0.004533178173005581, 0.007990741170942783, -0.006029680371284485, -0.011307447217404842, 0.0036443385761231184, 0.0009354549110867083, 0.0064133838750422, 0.009869193658232689, 0.03403277322649956, 0.014894720166921616, 0.013625147752463818, 0.012493722140789032, 0.04363585636019707, -0.03762131929397583, -0.03550003841519356, -0.005100256763398647, 0.025436684489250183, -0.05417003482580185, -0.05125471577048302, -0.003774453653022647, 0.023807892575860023, -0.023806210607290268, 0.009912566281855106, 0.005466850008815527, 0.0341058112680912, 0.033631399273872375, 0.019058354198932648, 0.002615569159388542, 0.014811968430876732, 0.026488171890378, -0.03565732389688492, -0.02991122379899025, -0.04820679500699043, 0.04542063921689987, -0.06507838517427444, 0.015110045671463013, 0.057797372341156006, -0.005902584176510572, 0.02420674078166485, 0.005418870598077774, -0.04242634028196335, 0.04742990434169769, -0.08045605570077896, -0.0010950674768537283, -0.006358294747769833, 0.014500608667731285, 0.008100321516394615, -0.0010800560703501105, 0.041358061134815216, -0.023417415097355843, -0.03729884326457977, 0.006418268196284771, -0.02072846330702305, -0.0336882509291172, -0.029933838173747063, -0.008896764367818832, 0.039944157004356384, -0.016910849139094353, -0.0014553689397871494, -0.0769626572728157, -0.017105115577578545, 0.05116623640060425, -0.024941418319940567, 0.006413780152797699, 0.022543244063854218, -0.050646938383579254, -0.01766631007194519, -0.02039659582078457, 0.03915134817361832, 0.0021001158747822046, 0.0013017792953178287, -0.020365428179502487, -0.030860794708132744, 0.02123720943927765, 0.028483228757977486, -0.008698142133653164, 0.008226602338254452, -0.010293946601450443, 0.08823508024215698, 3.83863844035659e-05, 0.0037718366365879774, -0.06713137030601501, 0.01985870860517025, -0.01768367551267147, -0.03928340598940849, -0.023758109658956528, -0.09773938357830048, 0.0011346203973516822, -0.027899764478206635, -0.028355153277516365, 0.00010890566773014143, 0.007718201261013746, 0.03092346340417862, -0.04968058690428734, 0.031241711229085922, -0.014158275909721851, -0.0030781030654907227, 0.07065841555595398, -0.01046170387417078, 0.06666796654462814, -0.008035206235945225, 0.07413256168365479, 0.04384172707796097, -0.0009659840143285692, -0.03753597289323807, -0.005665038712322712, 0.0484815388917923, -0.051521290093660355, -0.0565190352499485, -0.07297708839178085, -0.03528120741248131, -0.0003092654806096107, 0.07559364289045334, 0.0410294234752655, 0.06501365453004837, 0.01344548910856247, -0.0050566834397614, 0.05591188743710518, 0.086813785135746, 0.04527392238378525, 0.03660232946276665, 0.022234449163079262, -0.006277886684983969, 0.01890268363058567, -0.012556684203445911, -0.00359124387614429, 0.019419454038143158, 0.010365089401602745, -0.002677830634638667, -0.031478725373744965, 0.017398828640580177, -0.026532061398029327, -0.01648922823369503, -0.009752699173986912, -0.022525181993842125, -0.033062711358070374, -0.02239948883652687, 0.06279613822698593, -0.01566760614514351, -0.05712547153234482, -0.02254941128194332, 0.03901844471693039, -0.0318809412419796, 0.028987852856516838, -0.013492311351001263, -0.005689302459359169, 0.07585012167692184, 0.03816951438784599, -0.009668662212789059, 0.010927845723927021, -0.006509745493531227, -0.021943585947155952, 0.06670942157506943, -0.009485047310590744, 0.0012333771446719766, 0.019775042310357094, -0.06875163316726685, 0.01573212444782257, 0.05784254148602486, -0.005572177469730377, 0.048796724528074265, -0.04926687106490135, 0.009610027074813843, 0.0024495141115039587, -0.0024926087353378534, -0.04646487534046173, 0.029841827228665352, -0.03479575365781784, 0.016054779291152954, 0.0046721710823476315, 0.02589986100792885, 0.020418640226125717, 0.015005487948656082, -0.01652473397552967, -0.007845360785722733, 0.02436980977654457, -0.05303456261754036, 0.0014980215346440673, -0.0208432599902153, -0.0853036567568779, -0.03562448173761368, 0.00018038235430140048, 0.00020437163766473532, 0.029912997037172318, 0.039200302213430405, -0.017239214852452278, -0.02800409123301506, 0.04538332670927048, -0.030888069421052933, 0.06797898560762405, -0.04973674938082695, 0.014123919419944286, -0.008969183079898357, 0.024775108322501183, -0.033985018730163574, 0.07992006093263626, -0.023949475958943367, 0.005334500223398209, 0.006190678104758263, -0.004407001659274101, 0.004719693213701248, -0.06920458376407623, -0.03260798007249832, 0.00870539341121912, -0.016681034117937088, -0.006961492821574211, -0.02163579687476158, 0.018394621089100838, 0.005314882379025221, -0.030009251087903976, -0.017488447949290276, -0.021016689017415047, -7.513090622524032e-06, -0.02320145256817341, -0.004084006417542696, 0.011711208149790764, 0.021390089765191078, -0.02218846045434475, -0.03855106234550476, 0.016367232427001, 0.008569594472646713, -0.018721483647823334, 0.052711572498083115, -0.02062244713306427, 0.001398157561197877, -0.04873976111412048, -0.04429003596305847, -0.021995386108756065, 0.046004146337509155, 0.01890418864786625, -0.06721283495426178, 0.007602470926940441, -0.01428386103361845, 0.01045936532318592, 0.06008414551615715, 0.0007258963887579739, -0.04538232833147049, -0.02622380666434765, -0.01098288781940937, 0.03794156387448311, 0.032725829631090164, 0.05201205983757973, -0.01185785885900259, -0.0005145129980519414, -0.01336675975471735, -0.015296084806323051, 0.012243381701409817, 0.014483470469713211, 0.029472123831510544, 0.007340955547988415, 0.004627200774848461, -0.014645492658019066, 0.0951056033372879, 0.012748876586556435, 0.04150458797812462, -0.005101964343339205, -0.029994918033480644, -0.030358191579580307, 0.01477731578052044, -0.021136507391929626, -0.014241630211472511, -0.05161895230412483, -1.2504958249337506e-05, -0.0131193483248353, -0.021975375711917877, 0.03599504008889198, -0.04964851960539818, -0.008857429027557373, -0.026875056326389313, -0.03689362108707428, -0.03577764332294464, 0.022981546819210052, 0.012350591830909252, 0.016976675018668175, 0.01365561131387949, -0.08089656382799149, -0.004952500108629465, -0.004245729651302099, -0.04008958488702774, -0.025996115058660507, 0.053024325519800186, -0.0008589319768361747, -0.028198618441820145, -0.0327875129878521, -0.035541679710149765, -0.04534240812063217, -0.008443409577012062, -0.03153015300631523, 0.004927357193082571, 0.02802099473774433, -0.03346256539225578, -0.022825192660093307, 0.06124475598335266, -0.008247124031186104, 0.0735095739364624, -0.0010025661904364824, 0.010491034016013145, -0.012970149517059326, 0.056178685277700424, 0.04451163113117218, 0.026737039908766747, -0.008231103420257568, 0.029153786599636078, 0.041028283536434174, -0.00859646312892437, -0.03774506226181984, -0.003121419809758663, -0.0742795318365097, 0.003874986432492733, 0.023174410685896873, -0.03611346334218979, -0.00944836437702179, 0.03149593994021416, -0.0017205984331667423, -0.08892971277236938, 0.0006132596754468977, 0.11153285205364227, -0.0068495506420731544, -0.07540296018123627, -0.010290895588696003, -0.017782654613256454, 0.0192631334066391, 0.0009565868531353772, 0.02620864100754261, -0.020140616223216057, -0.0010768555803224444, 0.012221486307680607, 0.027354726567864418, 0.006524160038679838, -0.0533902570605278, 0.009198489598929882, -0.07754000276327133, 0.02572539635002613, -0.007929286919534206, -0.07175461947917938, -0.030786119401454926, -0.018626507371664047, -0.03233751282095909, 0.028527745977044106, 0.01475362479686737, 0.060045160353183746, -0.018171003088355064, -0.05786195024847984, 0.05464339628815651, -0.14706754684448242, -0.015681616961956024, 0.0617842935025692, -0.07201102375984192, 0.042654793709516525, 0.03809012100100517, 0.044093839824199677, -0.05072876811027527, -0.006550668738782406, -0.016588151454925537, 0.006885194219648838, 0.02761896513402462, -0.011397224850952625, -0.005720177199691534, -0.0007516653859056532, -0.011825920082628727, -0.05153084546327591, 0.03218954801559448, -0.022780124098062515, 0.018323728814721107, -0.013276769779622555, 0.035788439214229584, 0.0040820022113621235, -0.003695828840136528, -0.04201008006930351, 0.06163701415061951, 0.0023901392705738544, 0.030059853568673134, 0.012927266769111156, -0.04676415026187897, -0.03431002050638199, 0.010079377330839634, 0.03279630094766617, -0.05930812284350395, 0.014238178730010986, -0.0029792010318487883, 0.006916321814060211, -0.040672045201063156, -0.08364927023649216, -0.02690267004072666, -0.0533372238278389, -0.00013947524712421, 0.03426239639520645, 0.05125286802649498, 0.03215557709336281, 0.01600155234336853, -0.029098277911543846, -0.04056878760457039, -0.007460527587682009, 0.01585441641509533, -0.08040034025907516, -0.00039720526547171175, 0.04116079956293106, -0.030482860282063484, -0.02294844761490822, -0.003948178142309189, -0.03667724132537842, -0.024724029004573822, 0.02975914627313614, 0.013787723146378994, 0.0077314614318311214, 0.00803190004080534, -0.02642577886581421, -0.10621073096990585, 0.021315667778253555, -0.033348411321640015, 0.01495309080928564, 0.006766028236597776, 0.018698355183005333, 0.009623577818274498, -0.015795744955539703, 0.011902978643774986, -0.03993416205048561, 0.05588828772306442, -0.016014177352190018, -0.02136418968439102, -0.011908619664609432, -0.04054916277527809, -0.009023673832416534, -0.04217001795768738, 0.048600081354379654, 0.013293134048581123, -0.003750401549041271, -0.04315497353672981, 0.03409048914909363, -0.023849785327911377, 0.012045275419950485, -0.01837318018078804, -0.00042067631147801876, 0.046911392360925674, 0.03292250633239746, -0.01185561716556549, -0.05856553465127945, 0.04748982936143875, -0.009743484668433666, 0.062480390071868896, 0.05991218611598015, 0.00473537715151906, 0.055710189044475555, -0.02112741209566593, 0.014951510354876518, -0.04015922173857689, -0.014874719083309174, -0.036694254726171494, 0.03529832884669304, -0.04049156233668327, 0.02052389830350876, -0.02002573199570179, 0.013927252031862736, -0.028952214866876602, 0.021297622472047806, 0.0006256403867155313, 0.009593557566404343, -0.03939056396484375, -0.008493172004818916, 0.09982277452945709, 0.007665547542273998, -0.03499361872673035, -0.018453510478138924, 0.03629006817936897, -0.051113203167915344, 0.02728399820625782, -0.006711712572723627, -0.004482967779040337, 0.03673970699310303, 0.020838532596826553, -0.039259716868400574, 0.017514819279313087, 0.05869098752737045, 0.08874361962080002, 0.019465191289782524, 0.04162096232175827, 0.006553067360073328, -0.01092082541435957, 0.020327813923358917, 0.0037514599971473217, 0.03857797384262085, -0.05029084533452988, -0.02669025957584381, -0.051080863922834396, -0.04684631898999214, 0.08205276727676392, 0.00726707000285387, 0.04465382918715477, -0.0020091875921934843, 0.010616365820169449, 0.004215220455080271, 0.020210161805152893, -0.0018696669721975923, -0.03264382854104042, 0.0339951254427433, 0.04506135731935501, -0.029574079439044, -0.06141284480690956, -6.21725794710822e-33, -0.012584034353494644, -0.005778331309556961, 0.005394279956817627, 0.01642862893640995, -0.03778142109513283, 0.0157527606934309, -0.04047144204378128, -0.007493566256016493, -0.03269674628973007, -0.02467339299619198, -0.047739725559949875, -0.006432584952563047, 0.0195942223072052, 0.04880427569150925, 0.03607358783483505, 0.018407585099339485, 0.037453074008226395, -0.022303080186247826, 0.03058900497853756, -0.0013592293253168464, 0.06436390429735184, 0.05188741534948349, 0.0918053388595581, -0.023571280762553215, -0.03698858246207237, -0.045255474746227264, 0.04026377946138382, 0.02074521780014038, 0.03554516285657883, 0.01545080915093422, -0.06667156517505646, 0.030361441895365715, 0.038312073796987534, -0.027188170701265335, 0.007395877502858639, 0.05134672299027443, -0.11810877919197083, 0.0029480415396392345, -0.00977235659956932, 0.018813472241163254, 0.01812278851866722, -0.017772234976291656, 0.060908038169145584, 0.006742711644619703, -0.03657373785972595, 0.018371598795056343, 0.03674567863345146, -0.020544467493891716, -0.05461575463414192, -0.04446655884385109, -0.05447734519839287, 0.04377692937850952, 0.014118758030235767, 0.004849300719797611, -0.02069062739610672, -0.014909564517438412, -0.0054055689834058285, 0.029015686362981796, -0.09737134724855423, -0.002187512582167983, 0.0030614053830504417, 0.05182343348860741, 0.02544950693845749, 0.06335526704788208, -0.004319899249821901, 0.042318008840084076, 0.03409754857420921, 0.00906616635620594, -0.01597040705382824, 0.045934323221445084, 0.04391293227672577, 0.010361708700656891, 0.040511906147003174, 0.019240371882915497, 0.06417340785264969, -0.04055112972855568, -0.09835619479417801, 0.019341513514518738, 0.050770703703165054, 0.07379105687141418, 0.01834270916879177, 0.017197325825691223, -0.04561048373579979, -0.00038983405102044344, 0.00257804780267179, -0.013900099322199821, -0.020846452564001083, -0.04289412125945091, 0.008663016371428967, -0.01627490483224392, 0.03522101417183876, -0.008626006543636322, 0.025428803637623787, -0.012592937797307968, 0.010860251262784004, -0.005133723374456167, 0.05973648279905319, -0.00010181016841670498, -0.00867367908358574, 0.028913022950291634, -0.04910224303603172, -0.01731072925031185, -0.0012050585355609655, 0.025926578789949417, 0.005195111967623234, 0.010790128260850906, 0.007783052045851946, 0.011689828708767891, -0.03488234430551529, 0.00027613990823738277, 0.009889570064842701, -0.024868424981832504, 0.016707297414541245, 0.09446768462657928, 0.020327989012002945, -0.07359477877616882, 0.020140189677476883, 0.05801873654127121, -0.013401970267295837, -0.017098139971494675, -0.014182290062308311, -0.003909203223884106, 0.04353664815425873, 0.023881973698735237, -0.0277315191924572, 0.003111573401838541, -0.04332531988620758, 0.0015590469120070338, 0.04508461430668831, -0.022587787359952927, -0.0013747209450230002, 0.043616361916065216, 2.8755712833117286e-07, 0.0018685528775677085, 0.0319889634847641, 0.062383245676755905, -0.04215928539633751, 0.05225968733429909, -0.017310574650764465, 0.008257611654698849, 0.019958650693297386, -0.036913905292749405, 0.03466882184147835, 0.0016890011029317975, -0.059488918632268906, 0.04967062920331955, -0.005081790499389172, -0.10401160269975662, -0.014992251060903072, -0.13430273532867432, 0.014065934345126152, -0.02597198821604252, -0.007452583871781826, 0.033610813319683075, 0.1241903305053711, 0.014633377082645893, -0.03908457234501839, 0.007126831449568272, -0.021634867414832115, 0.021160319447517395, 0.02224261313676834, -0.00856446847319603, 0.0058433897793293, -0.0005061060073785484, 0.025224095210433006, -0.03209768235683441, -0.0082540363073349, -0.01544947735965252, 0.04582267627120018, 0.011506929993629456, 0.04588018357753754, -0.02929471805691719, -0.03741789981722832, 0.030357297509908676, -0.00992637500166893, -0.02788686938583851, -0.03492359817028046, 0.0376993790268898, -0.01000977773219347, -0.03629158437252045, -0.026845639571547508, 0.022225994616746902, 0.031999919563531876, -0.0013545226538553834, -0.015305629000067711, -0.037814490497112274, 0.00040206752601079643, 0.008213522844016552, -0.041379041969776154, -0.015036890283226967, -0.06485030800104141, 0.01113034226000309, -0.014128577895462513, -0.04311085492372513, -0.010057508014142513, -0.022875141352415085, -0.03181589022278786, 0.05895455554127693, -0.016377052292227745, 0.015448297373950481, 2.849112927588914e-34, 0.009061223827302456, -0.034325625747442245, -0.040459778159856796, 0.03922838345170021, 0.00506375590339303, 0.0015631034038960934, 0.01825059950351715, 0.03766631335020065, 0.00537018571048975, -0.08955083787441254, -0.018182877451181412]
623
623
['Zhiyuan Tang', 'Lantian Li', 'Dong Wang']
1609.08337v1
Research on multilingual speech recognition remains attractive yet challenging. Recent studies focus on learning shared structures under the multi-task paradigm, in particular a feature sharing structure. This approach has been found effective to improve performance on each individual language. However, this approach is only useful when the deployed system supports just one language. In a true multilingual scenario where multiple languages are allowed, performance will be significantly reduced due to the competition among languages in the decoding space. This paper presents a multi-task recurrent model that involves a multilingual speech recognition (ASR) component and a language recognition (LR) component, and the ASR component is informed of the language information by the LR component, leading to a language-aware recognition. We tested the approach on an English-Chinese bilingual recognition task. The results show that the proposed multi-task recurrent model can improve performance of multilingual recognition systems.
Multi-task Recurrent Model for True Multilingual Speech Recognition
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1609.08337v1
Title Multitask Recurrent Model True Multilingual Speech Recognition Summary Research multilingual speech recognition remains attractive yet challenging Recent study focus learning shared structure multitask paradigm particular feature sharing structure approach found effective improve performance individual language However approach useful deployed system support one language true multilingual scenario multiple language allowed performance significantly reduced due competition among language decoding space paper present multitask recurrent model involves multilingual speech recognition ASR component language recognition LR component ASR component informed language information LR component leading languageaware recognition tested approach EnglishChinese bilingual recognition task result show proposed multitask recurrent model improve performance multilingual recognition system Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.011886225081980228, -0.02644840069115162, 0.0017623017774894834, 0.07945913821458817, -0.020982034504413605, 0.03868953511118889, 0.042908940464258194, -0.020795507356524467, 0.008639167994260788, -0.023615295067429543, -0.09359521418809891, -0.06473927199840546, 0.04473632946610451, 0.0031332438811659813, -0.006202876567840576, -0.04437415301799774, 0.011135815642774105, -0.038439564406871796, -0.005476691760122776, -0.014281493611633778, 0.007499278988689184, 0.026607366278767586, -0.014276327565312386, 0.024796579033136368, 0.006360833998769522, 0.0185051579028368, 0.014225514605641365, -0.017102008685469627, 0.0018448889022693038, -0.003951056394726038, 0.0029353834688663483, 0.01772587187588215, -0.0005480413674376905, 0.045374322682619095, 2.2241817987378454e-06, -0.022707518190145493, -0.015018713660538197, -0.016729719936847687, -0.0021361801773309708, -0.07242513447999954, 0.04150700941681862, -0.005500410683453083, -0.005916834343224764, 0.039093416184186935, -0.006350123323500156, -0.004666411317884922, 0.06427313387393951, 0.05792367085814476, -0.016384439542889595, 0.017487306147813797, -0.010520536452531815, -0.06815137714147568, 0.0032643245067447424, 0.012697068974375725, -0.04108606278896332, -0.042597394436597824, 0.01274225302040577, 0.0033123514149338007, -0.027454674243927002, -0.04139595106244087, -0.014403445646166801, 0.017730407416820526, 0.0009173005819320679, 0.034025438129901886, -0.05688564106822014, 0.008053386583924294, 0.004637690726667643, -0.04850044846534729, -0.0026871697045862675, 0.03440236672759056, -0.045015256851911545, -0.02073645032942295, 0.02179691754281521, 0.020551713183522224, -0.04825712367892265, -0.010346310213208199, -0.014122853055596352, 0.019425706937909126, -0.046022262424230576, -0.004722832702100277, 0.06289698928594589, 0.01174207590520382, 0.015446996316313744, -0.013199757784605026, -0.021275436505675316, 0.010218249633908272, -0.02513081580400467, -0.015982063487172127, 0.002373949158936739, 0.004845434334129095, 0.05917869880795479, 0.005028961692005396, 0.06270051002502441, 0.011141680181026459, -0.024678654968738556, 0.013512995094060898, -0.02853863127529621, -0.1189359724521637, -0.0037202248349785805, -0.07510080933570862, 0.013667718507349491, 0.02084275707602501, -0.04963428154587746, 0.028781626373529434, -0.0412115752696991, 0.042772021144628525, 0.0002605282352305949, 0.0035555213689804077, -0.03688032180070877, -0.05072814226150513, -0.03483420982956886, -9.210464486386627e-05, -0.014332165010273457, 0.05253073573112488, 0.006395171396434307, -0.030324051156640053, -0.03248238563537598, 0.00658879429101944, 0.0012590836267918348, -0.02570957876741886, 0.03990907222032547, -0.031154779717326164, -0.03789222240447998, 0.006522218696773052, 0.03946283459663391, 0.0532459020614624, 0.026628607884049416, 0.0252737607806921, -0.06045227497816086, -0.053927015513181686, 0.041100308299064636, 0.022722816094756126, 0.006360161583870649, 0.0021873435471206903, -0.004110716283321381, 0.06505024433135986, 0.015562881715595722, -0.016400843858718872, -0.04662241414189339, 0.018914632499217987, -0.0013627904700115323, -0.06888040900230408, -0.014684397727251053, -0.07266931235790253, 0.06624604016542435, 0.026534581556916237, 0.01569286175072193, 0.03005562350153923, -0.0022983907256275415, -0.03423852473497391, 0.0019413820700719953, 0.07400952279567719, 0.027894319966435432, 0.023664895445108414, 0.06578550487756729, -0.027543216943740845, 0.040121808648109436, 0.09473682194948196, 0.03136860951781273, -0.012769771739840508, 0.013728524558246136, -0.02563563920557499, -0.02591879852116108, 0.05590987950563431, -0.05901496857404709, -0.021538635715842247, 0.025981159880757332, -0.04672585427761078, 0.03579845651984215, -0.0204024575650692, 0.01937602087855339, 0.022204365581274033, -0.013852921314537525, 0.023563604801893234, 0.0020714288111776114, 0.03980004042387009, 0.05631742253899574, 0.01601318269968033, 0.010789046064019203, 0.011972052045166492, -0.019611623138189316, 0.025268500670790672, 0.013102658092975616, 0.02531931735575199, -0.003428334603086114, -0.01623019017279148, -0.03914596885442734, 0.042158499360084534, -0.030498258769512177, 0.008872777223587036, 0.006553299725055695, -0.0634024515748024, 0.03106354922056198, 0.04354735091328621, 0.06671376526355743, -0.02804345078766346, -0.0475863553583622, 0.008687887340784073, 0.02203238196671009, -0.026269927620887756, 0.027621284127235413, -0.04074982553720474, -0.02564285881817341, 0.05999957025051117, -0.01942821405827999, -0.027218259871006012, -0.037116073071956635, -0.019269488751888275, -0.005757605191320181, 0.004162461031228304, -0.00078691536327824, -0.011664173565804958, 0.06484059244394302, -0.07471625506877899, -0.014083060435950756, 0.05259908735752106, -0.031103672459721565, 0.08035069704055786, -0.0649116113781929, 0.04632633551955223, 0.014768004417419434, 0.048222001641988754, -0.021199477836489677, -0.002146586077287793, -0.007244971580803394, 0.01788651943206787, 0.03655780479311943, 0.040416013449430466, 0.04252589866518974, 0.033941566944122314, -0.018392961472272873, -0.024581728503108025, 0.03297354653477669, -0.03169040381908417, 0.03578300029039383, 0.0779310017824173, -0.05151407793164253, -0.02199399285018444, 0.041388679295778275, 0.009218880906701088, 0.012116720899939537, 0.028879733756184578, 0.018138471990823746, -0.09665919840335846, 0.014119286090135574, -0.0023379684425890446, 0.022119630128145218, -0.030746735632419586, 0.043623361736536026, -0.014338990673422813, 0.04533730074763298, 0.011487330310046673, 0.013387054204940796, 0.019950471818447113, 0.011636961251497269, 0.0016790945082902908, -0.02475995384156704, 0.036872927099466324, -0.048190318048000336, -0.05118102580308914, 0.061586782336235046, 0.01226484589278698, 0.0017281012842431664, 2.006496833928395e-05, 0.016784487292170525, 0.012982018291950226, -0.05266326665878296, -0.07055744528770447, -0.011909023858606815, -0.04451952129602432, 0.010584289208054543, -0.0038440919015556574, 0.014378517866134644, 0.023524250835180283, -0.05471858009696007, -0.03757457807660103, 0.012357774190604687, 0.026205221191048622, 0.03589063882827759, -0.02543611079454422, -0.015883669257164, 0.02146233431994915, 0.026623014360666275, -0.018939556553959846, 0.03386858105659485, -0.011088477447628975, 0.00012800778495147824, -0.09570519626140594, -0.06971198320388794, -0.01138833537697792, 0.029478801414370537, 0.02779991179704666, 0.020575188100337982, 0.006991556845605373, -0.017016952857375145, 0.026652812957763672, 0.05702778697013855, 0.027281666174530983, -0.03140882030129433, -0.014685890637338161, 0.016579696908593178, -0.005269322544336319, -0.005622949916869402, -0.009630989283323288, 0.019210457801818848, 0.03489312902092934, -0.025063691660761833, 0.012422888539731503, -0.033265311270952225, 0.028977643698453903, 0.02605057880282402, 0.027951855212450027, -0.02034972794353962, -0.07331658154726028, -0.06897387653589249, -0.021249646320939064, -0.023065557703375816, -0.022174125537276268, -0.04907220974564552, -0.016548825427889824, 0.0031372751109302044, -0.01141195185482502, 0.03332715108990669, -0.018532223999500275, -0.038207534700632095, -0.07304300367832184, -0.02482658065855503, -0.03843000903725624, 0.03704860806465149, -0.032199926674366, 0.014404697343707085, -0.0333966426551342, -0.10933507233858109, -0.021056359633803368, 0.02219742350280285, 0.006010103039443493, -0.062032490968704224, 0.04370447248220444, -0.011884430423378944, -0.010838242247700691, -0.054039791226387024, -0.037766676396131516, -0.012679744511842728, 0.06995426118373871, -0.04753350839018822, 0.015079108066856861, -0.02244466170668602, -0.007616689894348383, -0.016403837129473686, 0.051748983561992645, 0.05808058753609657, 0.04189211130142212, -0.0026942926924675703, 0.054064806550741196, -0.008294238708913326, 0.043405625969171524, 0.0459514744579792, 0.03955797478556633, -0.0506058968603611, -0.014807925559580326, 0.0038623183500021696, -0.023034289479255676, 0.02299591153860092, -0.01978943683207035, -0.027502823621034622, -0.017949411645531654, 0.06948351860046387, 0.000626994064077735, -0.06098473444581032, 0.003631878411397338, -0.0018243762897327542, -0.054488830268383026, 0.05344359949231148, 0.05662250146269798, -0.029542971402406693, -0.08767750859260559, -0.052212752401828766, -0.04623712971806526, -0.04239027947187424, 0.029784005135297775, 0.01086835004389286, -0.028016624972224236, -0.018713338300585747, 0.0017314138822257519, -0.025136960670351982, 0.028325490653514862, 0.0019923150539398193, -0.0026973935309797525, -0.06302247941493988, 0.008864067494869232, 0.0012499097501859069, -0.06573332101106644, -0.042939282953739166, -0.027122996747493744, -0.02477063238620758, -0.03708342835307121, 0.026183102279901505, -0.00997344683855772, 0.03256978839635849, -0.057056356221437454, 0.04442616552114487, -0.044209640473127365, -0.035625699907541275, 0.013526915572583675, -0.03778117522597313, 0.023209095001220703, 0.05375923216342926, 0.050806675106287, -0.038858287036418915, -0.031313274055719376, -0.01831023208796978, -0.02224489487707615, 0.008368399925529957, -0.030810929834842682, -0.02286638878285885, -0.007588135078549385, -0.023043617606163025, 0.015834463760256767, -0.00035853730514645576, -0.027119453996419907, 0.032839782536029816, 0.02725169062614441, 0.06057566776871681, -0.00516898138448596, 0.026099959388375282, 0.016619568690657616, -0.01771598495543003, 0.03531966730952263, 0.03166787326335907, -0.014100447297096252, -0.03910774365067482, -0.028041383251547813, 0.008524572476744652, 0.001375348772853613, -0.0517481304705143, 0.019240865483880043, 0.009814088232815266, -0.011731383390724659, -0.04498349130153656, -0.038751084357500076, -0.020637106150388718, 0.012204300612211227, 0.01624944619834423, 0.05673173815011978, 0.10125409066677094, 0.015561397187411785, 0.008985173888504505, -0.01521783322095871, -0.04547366499900818, 0.007429024670273066, 0.04276579990983009, -0.06002208963036537, -0.008201561868190765, 0.0009431089274585247, -0.06035983934998512, 0.013750119134783745, -0.008490215986967087, -0.07234365493059158, -0.03786401078104973, 0.007648345548659563, -0.004469935316592455, 0.005552997812628746, 0.034922707825899124, -0.05206768587231636, -0.05832082778215408, -0.013819408603012562, -0.032444361597299576, -0.025020761415362358, -0.007898085750639439, 0.07544663548469543, 0.002965617459267378, -0.020572010427713394, 0.013382069766521454, -0.044564761221408844, -0.008195984177291393, -0.0033866201993077993, -0.03582038730382919, -0.03325125575065613, -0.01780722849071026, -0.0299396812915802, 0.017731385305523872, 0.024416163563728333, -0.03649621456861496, 0.02162110060453415, -0.06745059043169022, 0.024164536967873573, 0.011897210031747818, 0.033294305205345154, -0.01602049171924591, 0.030475107952952385, 0.044106338173151016, -0.01366528868675232, 0.01501467451453209, -0.011266874149441719, 0.03463538736104965, -0.09223242849111557, 0.02258470095694065, 0.08262297511100769, 0.005789644084870815, 0.0157984159886837, -0.0077245221473276615, 0.01391911692917347, -0.0461597703397274, 0.0235441904515028, 0.06969206035137177, 0.019532106816768646, -0.01713881641626358, 0.014981506392359734, -0.019184190779924393, -0.027110379189252853, 0.005185224581509829, 0.04313862323760986, 0.03898423910140991, -0.023253731429576874, -0.02543671242892742, 0.01438053511083126, 0.07220272719860077, -0.021907703951001167, 0.053104378283023834, -0.00822350662201643, 0.03144644573330879, -0.0468401238322258, 0.04315605387091637, -0.024058157578110695, -0.0017120217671617866, 0.021401891484856606, -0.015907522290945053, -0.026435181498527527, 0.001317515503615141, 0.07954362034797668, 0.006714044138789177, -0.014500778168439865, -0.001391768571920693, 0.012338696047663689, -0.022128485143184662, -0.034303922206163406, -0.006274599116295576, 0.028916046023368835, -0.06288499385118484, 0.007653094362467527, -0.0018535024719312787, -0.037105053663253784, 0.04536839947104454, -0.031053196638822556, 0.050072960555553436, -0.02394288033246994, -0.009537152014672756, 0.04024576023221016, 0.010766902938485146, 0.02657560259103775, -0.044349052011966705, -0.034769997000694275, 0.04414116218686104, 0.02252250351011753, -0.0005047756130807102, -5.8067492385201685e-33, 0.010631784796714783, 0.008788150735199451, 0.0017417334020137787, -0.013240672647953033, -0.011821714229881763, 0.011963704600930214, 0.006836898159235716, 0.02057919278740883, -0.026652198284864426, -0.05997444689273834, -0.017384687438607216, -0.010758642107248306, 0.05492689460515976, 0.0026650282088667154, 0.03729963302612305, -0.0013742505107074976, 0.032892171293497086, 0.013595393858850002, 0.03889429196715355, 0.020265785977244377, 0.06224226951599121, 0.061193935573101044, 0.12256137281656265, -0.0671391412615776, -0.013944010250270367, -0.0033319510985165834, 0.043358951807022095, -0.04209854081273079, -0.000350076996255666, 0.05079653859138489, -0.018944691866636276, 0.05279025435447693, 0.037159621715545654, -0.07542596012353897, -0.032073553651571274, 0.030584432184696198, -0.07686664909124374, -0.008919407613575459, 0.012092499062418938, 0.09094475954771042, -0.041086211800575256, 0.008861308917403221, 0.03516346216201782, 0.012951894663274288, -0.00549346674233675, 0.03944170102477074, 0.032270584255456924, -0.045107707381248474, -0.04262750595808029, 0.021908245980739594, -0.05822994187474251, 0.02838185429573059, 0.02957923151552677, 0.015510283410549164, 0.1051829382777214, 0.0451832115650177, -0.025232315063476562, -0.013325375504791737, -0.11134977638721466, 0.028150975704193115, -0.04581472650170326, 0.025452028959989548, 0.049439799040555954, 0.07679638266563416, 0.011607911437749863, 0.003908973187208176, 0.011601610109210014, -0.003585173049941659, 0.02368086762726307, -0.003306945087388158, 0.02010682038962841, 0.027163879945874214, 0.018630700185894966, 0.03847378492355347, 0.033286772668361664, -0.07377463579177856, -0.025265900418162346, -0.020167704671621323, 0.05997179076075554, 0.006348874885588884, 0.057119712233543396, -0.00952321756631136, -0.04294510558247566, -0.017659904435276985, -0.022062228992581367, 0.02368539571762085, -0.02444607764482498, -0.026012126356363297, 0.027729352936148643, -0.006921803113073111, 0.0075845904648303986, 0.03084947168827057, 0.07327812910079956, -0.02698632702231407, 0.003178614191710949, 0.013051033020019531, 0.011365395039319992, -0.0035209960769861937, -0.017298780381679535, 0.025280512869358063, -0.07983436435461044, -0.04988004267215729, -0.02502204105257988, 0.016311442479491234, -0.010588487610220909, 0.021624235436320305, 0.04635753110051155, 0.001885262201540172, -0.007483418565243483, 0.006966190878301859, -0.003587445942685008, -0.0009848803747445345, 0.04922264441847801, 0.09078963845968246, 0.03986949846148491, -0.04990493878722191, -0.0035853988956660032, 0.055175893008708954, 0.03397144749760628, -0.05319841951131821, -0.03279907628893852, -0.05681873485445976, 0.01726308837532997, 0.03208383172750473, -0.04620382562279701, 0.012979320250451565, -0.03376385569572449, -0.030863817781209946, 0.028436660766601562, -0.0009141729096882045, -0.010493439622223377, 0.028970874845981598, 2.73242278581165e-07, -0.014000792056322098, -0.016421660780906677, 0.0047822496853768826, -0.0366048589348793, 0.008635088801383972, 0.007041393779218197, -0.010800176300108433, 0.030389953404664993, -0.013255097903311253, 0.04899797961115837, -0.03525993227958679, -0.01646074838936329, 0.061898715794086456, 0.023326601833105087, -0.09699264913797379, -0.02812735177576542, -0.035287369042634964, 0.058595333248376846, -0.022820809856057167, 0.07891436666250229, 0.004311076365411282, 0.1000588908791542, 0.0026100946124643087, -0.020287293940782547, -0.0008442759863100946, 1.9175049601471983e-05, 0.016291186213493347, 0.005768910050392151, 0.028283778578042984, -0.014302198775112629, -0.007313919253647327, 0.03300543501973152, -0.02061810903251171, 0.022372355684638023, -0.042796894907951355, 0.030477233231067657, 0.041093822568655014, 0.009473903104662895, -0.0380355641245842, -0.004574175458401442, 0.04914269596338272, -0.008943647146224976, -0.044218093156814575, -0.014705989509820938, 0.060080386698246, 0.025535115972161293, -0.032422374933958054, -0.021091651171445847, 0.04489334300160408, 0.0003086168726440519, 0.009816989302635193, 0.002062507439404726, -0.004676381591707468, 0.016364723443984985, 0.019121965393424034, -0.05337037146091461, -0.03965410217642784, -0.03732612356543541, 0.013188880868256092, 0.01122372131794691, -0.03115876019001007, 0.007802867796272039, 0.004942465573549271, -0.06491211801767349, 0.03049217350780964, -0.027192536741495132, 0.010622130706906319, 2.0713156367099133e-34, -0.003026530845090747, -0.011912201531231403, 0.020861566066741943, 0.0661788210272789, -0.01149789895862341, -0.04858190193772316, -0.04732773080468178, 0.028784507885575294, -0.019661501049995422, -0.01944543980062008, -0.0508800745010376]
624
624
['A. Hassan', 'M. R. Amin', 'N. Mohammed', 'A. K. A. Azad']
1610.00369v2
Sentiment Analysis (SA) is an action research area in the digital age. With rapid and constant growth of online social media sites and services, and the increasing amount of textual data such as - statuses, comments, reviews etc. available in them, application of automatic SA is on the rise. However, most of the research works on SA in natural language processing (NLP) are based on English language. Despite being the sixth most widely spoken language in the world, Bangla still does not have a large and standard dataset. Because of this, recent research works in Bangla have failed to produce results that can be both comparable to works done by others and reusable as stepping stones for future researchers to progress in this field. Therefore, we first tried to provide a textual dataset - that includes not just Bangla, but Romanized Bangla texts as well, is substantial, post-processed and multiple validated, ready to be used in SA experiments. We tested this dataset in Deep Recurrent model, specifically, Long Short Term Memory (LSTM), using two types of loss functions - binary crossentropy and categorical crossentropy, and also did some experimental pre-training by using data from one validation to pre-train the other and vice versa. Lastly, we documented the results along with some analysis on them, which were promising.
Sentiment Analysis on Bangla and Romanized Bangla Text (BRBT) using Deep Recurrent models
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1610.00369v2
Title Sentiment Analysis Bangla Romanized Bangla Text BRBT using Deep Recurrent model Summary Sentiment Analysis SA action research area digital age rapid constant growth online social medium site service increasing amount textual data status comment review etc available application automatic SA rise However research work SA natural language processing NLP based English language Despite sixth widely spoken language world Bangla still large standard dataset recent research work Bangla failed produce result comparable work done others reusable stepping stone future researcher progress field Therefore first tried provide textual dataset includes Bangla Romanized Bangla text well substantial postprocessed multiple validated ready used SA experiment tested dataset Deep Recurrent model specifically Long Short Term Memory LSTM using two type loss function binary crossentropy categorical crossentropy also experimental pretraining using data one validation pretrain vice versa Lastly documented result along analysis promising Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.05192713811993599, 0.027055339887738228, -0.0023078983649611473, 0.05712750926613808, -0.03185954689979553, 0.005102986469864845, -0.018143607303500175, 0.008185272105038166, -0.0019556041806936264, -0.05489837005734444, -0.005273478105664253, -0.059093259274959564, 0.01299042534083128, 0.07535676658153534, -0.02079404518008232, -0.02774219401180744, 0.020425191149115562, 0.04429235681891441, 0.04130254685878754, 0.013419744558632374, 0.02149060368537903, 0.03603823482990265, 0.024941446259617805, -0.011377941817045212, -0.023053839802742004, 0.013209517113864422, 0.022273996844887733, -0.017501002177596092, -0.031634245067834854, -0.0572226382791996, 0.048398327082395554, 0.03825613483786583, 0.008035510778427124, 0.024325022473931313, 2.1539708541240543e-06, -0.027911512181162834, -0.012795040383934975, -0.03912472352385521, 0.055878885090351105, -0.010346325114369392, 0.04567280411720276, -0.024556031450629234, -0.0035134581848978996, 0.04260005056858063, -0.060248102992773056, -0.025693243369460106, 0.02922612428665161, 0.10392932593822479, 0.026197241619229317, 0.08419729769229889, -0.0048396652564406395, -0.07402116060256958, -0.018832417204976082, -0.013812313787639141, 0.02606073021888733, 0.019987458363175392, 0.011423659510910511, -0.04488920792937279, -0.02775547094643116, 0.0036151865497231483, -0.02268523909151554, 0.0016977712512016296, -0.019431790336966515, -0.01156291738152504, 0.0020468116272240877, -0.01997339352965355, 0.036068011075258255, -0.03492999076843262, 0.035284750163555145, 0.0358026921749115, -0.00949961319565773, -0.019355272874236107, 0.005493820179253817, 0.017053525894880295, -0.059093549847602844, -0.06556177139282227, -0.019649477675557137, 0.00949086807668209, -0.012909206561744213, 0.04058245196938515, -0.002379806712269783, 0.030804691836237907, 0.014012551866471767, 0.021241163834929466, 0.017253026366233826, -0.001265104510821402, -0.02517622709274292, -0.047710008919239044, -0.007590828463435173, 0.013780849054455757, 0.06399752199649811, -0.022278673946857452, 0.02933511883020401, 0.0004251350474078208, -0.004236586857587099, 0.027064446359872818, 0.01504267007112503, -0.05025259405374527, 0.034701790660619736, -0.06203369423747063, 0.012503961101174355, 0.005130769684910774, -0.016259780153632164, -0.012088296934962273, -0.003745069494470954, -0.00461508147418499, -0.009309794753789902, -0.008062097243964672, 0.013381307013332844, 0.017141133546829224, -0.04056892171502113, -0.01590949483215809, 0.024725401774048805, 0.05668213218450546, -0.009573003277182579, 0.008618536405265331, -0.08749526739120483, -0.002044887514784932, -0.009998936206102371, -0.018953833729028702, 0.011968199163675308, 0.019930081441998482, 0.0011083687422797084, 0.003914454486221075, -0.04377857595682144, 0.04650987312197685, -0.026212606579065323, 0.023192202672362328, -0.03588174656033516, -0.03747854754328728, 0.04583989083766937, 0.019041281193494797, 0.033765826374292374, -0.0013115154579281807, 0.017712173983454704, 0.04879041761159897, 0.030216675251722336, -0.022379038855433464, -0.10032247751951218, -0.004874068312346935, -0.001677268068306148, -0.06591379642486572, -0.041201647371053696, -0.07858389616012573, 0.030011016875505447, -0.02472495473921299, -0.04512178525328636, 0.030266594141721725, 0.012698815204203129, 0.03128810599446297, -0.022361256182193756, 0.05648830160498619, -0.03586095944046974, -0.017947830259799957, 0.022616764530539513, 0.006322186440229416, 0.10361769050359726, 0.03826362267136574, 0.0017382641090080142, 0.055985379964113235, 0.017466748133301735, -0.01059139147400856, -0.002025884808972478, -0.003930292092263699, 0.0035924711264669895, -0.029818451032042503, -0.039379071444272995, 0.008538986556231976, -0.042975038290023804, 0.022419026121497154, 0.0033472529612481594, 0.04148010537028313, 0.022022267803549767, 0.038941703736782074, 0.041798461228609085, 0.0439351461827755, 0.03304756432771683, 0.08445265144109726, -0.03542804718017578, 0.008396411314606667, 0.009404808282852173, -0.031014656648039818, 0.00686133187264204, 0.021967025473713875, -0.0035889276769012213, -0.019509170204401016, 0.013892736285924911, 0.00729374261572957, -0.022923527285456657, -0.04216428101062775, -0.004139379132539034, -0.04091059789061546, 0.017666686326265335, -0.02513629011809826, 0.06093340739607811, 0.012160662561655045, -0.050303518772125244, -0.029080918058753014, 0.029511982575058937, -0.058740485459566116, -0.0062284525483846664, -0.032878030091524124, 0.054221261292696, 0.040986642241477966, -0.015121052041649818, -0.002220185473561287, -0.005245270673185587, -0.04623048007488251, 0.002617096994072199, 0.04145926609635353, 0.01214485801756382, 0.022373953834176064, -0.015204834751784801, -0.04393738508224487, 0.02935008704662323, 0.03966850787401199, -0.020541444420814514, 0.032146353274583817, -0.04711771011352539, 0.06566501408815384, -0.0016874438151717186, 0.08301163464784622, -0.03896942362189293, 0.007879042997956276, 0.027122024446725845, 0.0050897072069346905, 0.018937738612294197, 0.01815740577876568, 0.03524875268340111, 0.043289560824632645, 0.005472930613905191, -0.009538624435663223, 0.036275144666433334, -0.02181987650692463, -0.07868701964616776, 0.02468959614634514, -0.01965785026550293, -0.03912532702088356, 0.00312404683791101, -0.03307666257023811, 0.015112681314349174, 0.040132250636816025, -0.01668895222246647, -0.035236943513154984, 0.07795816659927368, -0.004561351612210274, 0.04610615223646164, -0.015229055657982826, 0.007032488472759724, -0.044999733567237854, 0.0031706865411251783, -0.0021171667613089085, 0.046434786170721054, -0.006953648757189512, 0.02213815599679947, -0.035405233502388, -0.03402268514037132, 0.04302968457341194, -0.016416920349001884, -0.060635749250650406, 0.03688443452119827, -0.005281098652631044, 0.03629264980554581, 0.01906534656882286, 0.044101741164922714, -0.032661862671375275, -0.015521654859185219, -0.08278165012598038, 0.014354177750647068, -0.017283907160162926, -0.00012048349162796512, -0.005294451490044594, 0.035952355712652206, -0.002205994911491871, -0.019934117794036865, -0.04059974476695061, -0.0022008356172591448, 0.016080321744084358, 0.030333196744322777, 0.07524772733449936, 0.019143277779221535, 0.05964518338441849, -0.03879835084080696, -0.008182461373507977, -0.01850173994898796, -0.0039186375215649605, 0.04460614547133446, -0.06843278557062149, 0.006292036268860102, 0.013625417836010456, -0.02807188592851162, 0.026222463697195053, 0.009238408878445625, -0.07725423574447632, -0.028464628383517265, -0.020854240283370018, 0.006606866605579853, 0.005229243542999029, 0.0359075553715229, 0.024123890325427055, -0.03892550989985466, 0.0128242876380682, 0.007569330744445324, 0.016922013834118843, -0.01947084255516529, 0.009283632040023804, 0.014984828419983387, -0.015586650930345058, -0.01243353821337223, 0.03967370465397835, 0.03845967724919319, 0.0030748583376407623, -0.023876488208770752, -0.03940197452902794, -0.04441889747977257, 0.009408450685441494, -0.017601443454623222, -0.0026369679253548384, -0.01795257069170475, 0.028721055015921593, 0.02343706786632538, -0.007812059484422207, 0.027533184736967087, 0.02355952374637127, 0.006829203572124243, -0.08624255657196045, -0.028838688507676125, -0.026017799973487854, 0.025691866874694824, -0.029728848487138748, 0.010716699063777924, -0.02994939126074314, -0.028807858005166054, 0.0007457369938492775, -0.009876739233732224, -0.039566151797771454, -0.04213093966245651, 0.027069970965385437, 0.0023408173583447933, 0.004956968128681183, -0.0212223120033741, -0.013054816983640194, 0.009445318952202797, -0.0142195550724864, -0.029632775112986565, -0.06475627422332764, 0.03534945845603943, -0.01801464892923832, 0.04603642597794533, 0.010966038331389427, -0.017776403576135635, -0.03746876120567322, -0.029658932238817215, -0.001718216110020876, 0.021782776340842247, 0.015692971646785736, 0.04108987748622894, -0.04506635665893555, -0.005242701154202223, 0.029598666355013847, -0.03551020473241806, 0.015062508173286915, -0.025184135884046555, 0.00797209981828928, -0.09266139566898346, -0.01771322265267372, -0.008948092348873615, -0.015410065650939941, -0.024716593325138092, -0.025055184960365295, 0.0063781337812542915, -0.06340641528367996, 0.021952643990516663, 0.09815451502799988, -0.0004596482904162258, -0.05719469487667084, -0.03696981817483902, -0.008982297964394093, -0.03738706186413765, 0.008992495015263557, 0.009523378685116768, -0.05739728361368179, -0.01889844425022602, -0.054914798587560654, -0.02674378827214241, -0.0023658499121665955, -0.03343713656067848, -0.017001314088702202, -0.08337675034999847, -0.019678235054016113, -0.05477491766214371, -0.024142038077116013, -0.06272240728139877, -0.03972863405942917, -0.03204122185707092, -0.02083958499133587, 0.006640002131462097, -0.01349970418959856, -0.021077612414956093, -0.018620340153574944, 0.033817108720541, -0.06670992076396942, -0.031318917870521545, 0.04436354711651802, -0.031098498031497, 0.01527227833867073, 0.04104331135749817, 0.08103400468826294, -0.06108669191598892, 0.005897367373108864, 0.0016023406060412526, -0.02828771248459816, 0.004324513953179121, -0.03586158528923988, 0.06388123333454132, -0.023659219965338707, -0.017656251788139343, -0.014920990914106369, -0.011403406970202923, -0.05881809443235397, 0.0663921982049942, -0.004087537527084351, 0.0404248908162117, 0.0050298478454351425, -0.04705604910850525, -0.04988488927483559, 0.052307020872831345, 0.045602947473526, 0.025011053308844566, 0.005255671683698893, -0.06370057165622711, -0.03781674802303314, 0.0066623929888010025, -0.009004831314086914, -0.055349115282297134, -0.0356881208717823, -0.024435291066765785, -0.03172292560338974, -0.05694851279258728, -0.07121970504522324, -0.06643584370613098, -0.005176090169698, 0.009940605610609055, 0.006848467979580164, 0.05819884315133095, 0.01746298372745514, -0.01935659348964691, -0.03512955456972122, -0.013260484673082829, 0.0281507670879364, 0.029252110049128532, -0.04429807513952255, 0.003106627846136689, 0.05533479154109955, 0.02436310052871704, 0.01832796074450016, -0.08020549267530441, -0.07160090655088425, -0.029202677309513092, 0.019798222929239273, 0.004462992772459984, 0.016171829774975777, -0.020982809364795685, -0.035173144191503525, -0.0494009405374527, 0.050957199186086655, -0.013278217054903507, -0.014582395553588867, -0.016301743686199188, 0.06081331893801689, 0.07646405696868896, 0.005224442109465599, 0.03002476505935192, -0.0054644872434437275, 0.04892664775252342, -0.0138357849791646, -0.06962314248085022, -0.0021266343537718058, -0.01417524367570877, -0.01795942336320877, 0.0027365998830646276, 0.04111968353390694, 0.021847283467650414, -0.04943961277604103, -0.03182777762413025, -0.006003557704389095, 0.01188821904361248, -0.023322878405451775, -0.015645718201994896, -0.015467413701117039, 0.04644922539591789, 0.018177451565861702, -0.03494115546345711, -0.02806507609784603, -0.011062192730605602, -0.0129617378115654, -0.008919970132410526, 0.09504076838493347, 0.038108836859464645, 0.06314775347709656, -0.0012446651235222816, 0.03594262897968292, -0.011251603253185749, -0.011350350454449654, 0.025631776079535484, 0.02562589943408966, -0.02914484404027462, 0.020280607044696808, -0.007281240541487932, -0.010853213258087635, 0.009640231728553772, 0.04656767472624779, 0.037003763020038605, 0.01209405530244112, -0.02361525222659111, -0.006613454315811396, 0.011030574329197407, -0.05277438834309578, 0.03164495527744293, 0.003958168905228376, 0.03637430816888809, -0.005904016084969044, 0.07498113811016083, -0.06551486998796463, 0.025766218081116676, 0.03737500682473183, -0.02156529575586319, -0.05058526620268822, 0.00976263452321291, 0.048842478543519974, -0.0074877189472317696, 0.00817035511136055, 0.0617779865860939, -0.011741173453629017, -0.02512114867568016, 0.03470476344227791, 0.06516330689191818, 0.01957615092396736, 0.0034901765175163746, 0.002438601106405258, -0.03235795348882675, -0.04204173758625984, 0.08222081512212753, -0.04820236936211586, 0.048458024859428406, 0.022208647802472115, 0.036380380392074585, 0.04753238335251808, 0.06067465618252754, 0.0916217789053917, -0.0418999120593071, 0.01714996062219143, 0.018755726516246796, -0.03898880258202553, -0.044805023819208145, -6.436697028467817e-33, 0.014784070663154125, -0.010945014655590057, -0.018220355734229088, -0.03481033071875572, -0.047561757266521454, 0.012420578859746456, -0.026097310706973076, 0.007183734327554703, -0.031213415786623955, 0.01018636953085661, -0.0444529727101326, 0.03397679328918457, 0.009590880014002323, 0.04742490500211716, 0.07499875128269196, -0.03369761258363724, 0.017114445567131042, 0.023093732073903084, 0.042906928807497025, 0.029903514310717583, 0.05444472283124924, 0.059312134981155396, 0.080477274954319, -0.06628312170505524, 0.04869748651981354, -0.014610480517148972, -0.0458822175860405, -0.007912710309028625, 0.02978367917239666, 0.04184320196509361, -0.04243246093392372, 0.07227116823196411, 0.04550362005829811, -0.02302737906575203, -0.011921558529138565, 0.03960667550563812, -0.010344999842345715, -0.03914033994078636, -0.007800025399774313, 0.03935782238841057, -0.03777896985411644, 0.022874854505062103, 0.03345724567770958, 0.031085196882486343, -0.02536511979997158, 0.03974362835288048, 0.03853223845362663, -0.006303043104708195, 0.009138219989836216, -0.04043952003121376, -0.06755945086479187, 0.021780218929052353, 0.013923359103500843, 0.030709173530340195, 0.010631494224071503, 0.009820139966905117, -0.005190618336200714, 0.044145114719867706, -0.09842132776975632, 0.01633012667298317, 0.0005543844890780747, 0.0340123176574707, 0.015461031347513199, -0.01986885257065296, -0.018302466720342636, 0.0037146916147321463, -0.009916136972606182, -0.008714891970157623, 0.018149858340620995, 0.036638084799051285, 0.019999980926513672, 0.008349736221134663, 0.015700388699769974, 0.07134658098220825, 0.055678099393844604, -0.0802665650844574, -0.04509153217077255, 0.023330550640821457, 0.062318939715623856, 0.028885504230856895, 0.0315738208591938, 0.021512920036911964, -0.036514293402433395, -0.03490781411528587, 0.054572366178035736, -1.8382766938884743e-05, -0.02502010017633438, -0.043216969817876816, 0.0011074403300881386, -0.013963350094854832, 0.003311066422611475, 0.016908938065171242, -0.0060260118916630745, -0.03897865116596222, -0.006316392216831446, 0.0075627476908266544, -0.025047337636351585, 0.028026308864355087, -0.004233718849718571, 0.008861063979566097, -0.05414766073226929, -0.02458329312503338, -0.057094283401966095, 0.038011882454156876, -0.009501807391643524, 0.009019673801958561, 0.04048120975494385, 0.019899044185876846, -0.08266394585371017, -0.026288820430636406, 0.002755651716142893, -0.013469891622662544, 0.0339537188410759, 0.08191556483507156, -0.057176653295755386, -0.023374371230602264, -0.020655779168009758, 0.08186539262533188, 0.032897964119911194, 0.03661751002073288, -0.02509969472885132, -0.038558561354875565, 0.019441930577158928, -0.029997454956173897, -0.05942452698945999, -0.02226312644779682, -0.030400456860661507, 0.005644535645842552, 0.011295239441096783, -0.06956633925437927, -0.008296884596347809, -0.015525945462286472, 2.82055964362371e-07, 0.02311856858432293, 0.045234594494104385, 0.015924379229545593, -0.031185781583189964, -0.005438582506030798, 0.050338152796030045, 0.03249405696988106, 0.036164384335279465, -0.034288063645362854, 0.03470521792769432, 0.019813701510429382, -0.025308895856142044, 0.004809483885765076, 0.02827831730246544, -0.11968012899160385, -0.012113982811570168, -0.07942164689302444, -0.0028583130333572626, -0.026893025264143944, 0.011047459207475185, 0.04104338958859444, 0.134337916970253, 0.0511077418923378, -0.02780933864414692, -0.01599554531276226, 0.01447930559515953, 0.010867578908801079, -0.018855981528759003, -0.019448870792984962, 0.01329029817134142, 0.008866311982274055, 0.024392079561948776, -0.03738564997911453, -0.05409994348883629, -0.0393671840429306, 0.02293270081281662, 0.009124858304858208, 0.002207266166806221, -0.006636221893131733, -0.012416950426995754, 0.057232487946748734, 0.012634769082069397, 0.0052406806498765945, -0.0018630881095305085, 0.04968215152621269, 0.0011156474938616157, -0.056526582688093185, -0.05793188884854317, 0.03301163390278816, -0.0016706117894500494, 0.07079152762889862, -0.022116728127002716, -0.03382333368062973, -0.011125139892101288, 0.003228234127163887, -0.05850456282496452, -0.06101047620177269, -0.0562293604016304, 0.046183738857507706, 0.01761268451809883, -0.008452075533568859, 0.0018477863632142544, 0.016917629167437553, 0.03257433697581291, 0.060389820486307144, -0.045444730669260025, 0.043994951993227005, 2.5792814136000234e-34, 0.07811890542507172, -0.010057508014142513, 0.01303835678845644, 0.019877463579177856, 0.022203873842954636, 0.003924994263797998, -0.021000994369387627, -0.011653346009552479, 0.022935325279831886, -0.027463333681225777, -0.026538563892245293]
625
625
['Marek Rei', 'Gamal K. O. Crichton', 'Sampo Pyysalo']
1611.04361v1
Sequence labeling architectures use word embeddings for capturing similarity, but suffer when handling previously unseen or rare words. We investigate character-level extensions to such models and propose a novel architecture for combining alternative word representations. By using an attention mechanism, the model is able to dynamically decide how much information to use from a word- or character-level component. We evaluated different architectures on a range of sequence labeling datasets, and character-level extensions were found to improve performance on every benchmark. In addition, the proposed attention-based architecture delivered the best results even with a smaller number of trainable parameters.
Attending to Characters in Neural Sequence Labeling Models
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1611.04361v1
Title Attending Characters Neural Sequence Labeling Models Summary Sequence labeling architecture use word embeddings capturing similarity suffer handling previously unseen rare word investigate characterlevel extension model propose novel architecture combining alternative word representation using attention mechanism model able dynamically decide much information use word characterlevel component evaluated different architecture range sequence labeling datasets characterlevel extension found improve performance every benchmark addition proposed attentionbased architecture delivered best result even smaller number trainable parameter Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.061423782259225845, 0.026141155511140823, 0.010138444602489471, 0.027237990871071815, 0.009262291714549065, 0.022990919649600983, 0.0010185353457927704, -0.012745029293000698, 0.026322072371840477, -0.007542262319475412, -0.021471505984663963, -0.05359182134270668, 0.028383905068039894, 0.04412228241562843, 0.0492861308157444, -0.07764638215303421, 0.04427860304713249, 0.011284268461167812, 0.039824314415454865, 0.04457029700279236, 0.03612712025642395, -0.005421402398496866, 0.02461155503988266, 0.03994985297322273, -0.011699538677930832, -0.003978439141064882, 0.00473231915384531, -0.01176653616130352, 0.029012631624937057, -0.06534940004348755, 0.03440696746110916, 0.06460767984390259, 0.039477258920669556, 0.035418424755334854, 2.1667838154826313e-06, 0.006055465899407864, -0.025450028479099274, -0.02266189269721508, -0.004723924212157726, -0.029673179611563683, 0.042443156242370605, 0.017977185547351837, -0.008402010425925255, 0.02596464194357395, 0.033303402364254, -0.036802276968955994, 0.06258328258991241, 0.09435997158288956, 0.021629443392157555, 0.03810827434062958, -0.004828551784157753, -0.10548581928014755, 0.023249678313732147, -0.04789423570036888, 0.004448548424988985, -0.03591284155845642, 0.02344374917447567, -0.025170816108584404, 0.024027030915021896, 0.02254997380077839, -0.03472786024212837, 0.030159922316670418, 0.001961932284757495, -0.014194059185683727, 0.04223722964525223, 0.06366419792175293, -0.00812675803899765, 0.006436177529394627, 0.014009484089910984, 0.12433211505413055, -0.037716228514909744, -0.017475809901952744, -0.0006116509321145713, 0.014918987639248371, 0.01188389491289854, -0.03904195874929428, -0.016840854659676552, 0.020597493276000023, -0.017414364963769913, -0.002222091890871525, 0.04745831340551376, 0.07741385698318481, 0.018386250361800194, 0.006520168390125036, -0.01413710881024599, -0.023527787998318672, 0.02569996938109398, -0.03970152139663696, -0.03341858088970184, -0.04169602319598198, -0.012664321810007095, -0.06797012686729431, 0.06236918643116951, 0.04897896572947502, 0.011937298811972141, 0.042165257036685944, -0.03376969322562218, -0.06636110693216324, 0.024506371468305588, -0.0817188024520874, 0.017681309953331947, 0.008849111385643482, -0.024583732709288597, 0.006274767220020294, -0.029424374923110008, 0.03847413882613182, 0.0021983834449201822, 0.01827126182615757, -0.009962714277207851, -0.003167298622429371, -0.012705947272479534, -0.036813072860240936, -0.05179326608777046, 0.03951170668005943, -0.010458255186676979, -0.03915367275476456, -0.018967991694808006, 0.004104633815586567, 0.02056133560836315, 0.0014410585863515735, -0.010359936393797398, 0.019072167575359344, -0.01783844269812107, -0.01478416845202446, -0.0001802251790650189, -0.011850564740598202, -0.07934023439884186, -0.03199826553463936, 0.010754565708339214, -0.0017383734229952097, -0.008889596909284592, 0.028234699741005898, 0.03139234706759453, -0.010419299826025963, 0.013122365809977055, 0.0713353380560875, 0.02719205990433693, -0.08386141806840897, -0.009060184471309185, 0.006396363954991102, -0.04021728038787842, -0.0037419649306684732, -0.05322418361902237, -0.0459308885037899, 0.03332484886050224, -0.03536592051386833, -0.020250603556632996, -0.013426987454295158, 0.035744525492191315, 0.06986751407384872, -0.047410011291503906, 0.07659227401018143, -0.005721214693039656, -0.029679929837584496, 0.020157048478722572, 0.034886959940195084, 0.07221253216266632, -0.05371946096420288, 0.042297158390283585, 0.039792414754629135, 0.022385144606232643, -0.008283030241727829, 0.0582418218255043, 0.0223906971514225, -0.008180487900972366, -0.04874558001756668, -0.010907585732638836, 0.0008995477692224085, 0.025761326774954796, 0.05264238640666008, -0.006679576355963945, 0.05671660974621773, 0.0008859095978550613, -0.07939239591360092, 0.029812529683113098, 0.08930796384811401, -0.0076217446476221085, 0.01989063248038292, -0.01734944060444832, 0.0028297363314777613, -0.004205277189612389, 0.01023222878575325, -0.014886191114783287, 0.0595722459256649, 0.03247246518731117, 0.008579378016293049, -0.018279261887073517, -0.019792405888438225, -0.02993174083530903, -0.0018916234839707613, 0.0031704604625701904, 0.010008301585912704, -0.02571488358080387, -0.02338569611310959, 0.0056947809644043446, 0.015101628378033638, -0.09362473338842392, -0.01910346932709217, 0.029123688116669655, -0.03745948150753975, -0.01041306834667921, 0.004233215469866991, -0.017060065641999245, 0.04448913410305977, 0.06400441378355026, -0.03583546355366707, -0.052284855395555496, -0.017510131001472473, -0.011659268289804459, 0.040076844394207, 0.004370553884655237, -0.03849634528160095, -0.013486448675394058, -0.07498376071453094, 0.018370069563388824, 0.03505357727408409, -0.039640750735998154, 0.03404033184051514, -0.04270903021097183, -0.011423022486269474, 0.02285030111670494, 0.030711563304066658, -0.07556513696908951, 0.06630823016166687, -0.016010191291570663, -0.047586437314748764, -0.026027413085103035, 0.017858324572443962, 0.01423107273876667, 0.01935003325343132, -0.015877394005656242, 0.018616629764437675, 0.03888760879635811, -0.02156512625515461, 0.03871269151568413, 0.021364429965615273, -0.05518906190991402, -0.045243896543979645, 0.019955504685640335, -0.05326506495475769, -0.01808778941631317, 0.020077960565686226, -0.00658874586224556, -0.053655195981264114, -0.0015349253080785275, -0.04652027413249016, 0.012510216794908047, -0.033101242035627365, 0.04683813825249672, 0.009171263314783573, 0.04186119884252548, -0.056344740092754364, 0.08395962417125702, -0.0346110574901104, 0.021215910091996193, -0.01308773085474968, 0.025357533246278763, 0.030026670545339584, -0.05871572718024254, -0.04117092117667198, 0.023107636719942093, 0.016903650015592575, -0.038689251989126205, 0.025476647540926933, -0.04387722164392471, -0.022728469222784042, -0.02312125824391842, -0.023679783567786217, -0.015441239811480045, 0.0024190947879105806, 0.011111786589026451, 0.011526764370501041, 0.018643854185938835, -0.007136724889278412, -0.040303826332092285, -0.0611308254301548, 0.016145456582307816, -0.030227385461330414, -0.025835366919636726, 0.062174174934625626, 0.021729659289121628, -0.015420057810842991, -0.05561971664428711, -0.01911824755370617, -0.020098112523555756, 0.04023698717355728, 0.04098312929272652, -0.08399304747581482, -0.026362590491771698, -0.027495210990309715, 0.0038512975443154573, 0.02019253373146057, -0.012529709376394749, -0.03877333179116249, -0.007630017586052418, 0.023643316701054573, 0.02186753787100315, 0.008033255115151405, 0.03340958058834076, -0.009845557622611523, 0.014801690354943275, -0.005513764917850494, 0.025917664170265198, 0.02062227576971054, 0.0024642765056341887, 0.05308404564857483, 0.029101723805069923, -0.007318736519664526, 0.01739344373345375, 0.07486818730831146, -0.00795974675565958, 0.022493958473205566, -0.029420899227261543, -0.026227854192256927, 0.030331214889883995, 0.0012337476946413517, -0.03984472528100014, 0.003885268932208419, -0.06093699112534523, -0.04308845475316048, -0.04951608180999756, -0.006388766225427389, 0.05045121908187866, -0.037171002477407455, -0.03874131292104721, -0.07319996505975723, 0.010905220173299313, -0.026738371700048447, 0.06276194751262665, 0.03062615729868412, 0.023014986887574196, -0.023461831733584404, -0.09148020297288895, 0.00839122012257576, 0.04444846883416176, -0.04943712055683136, -0.04249539226293564, 0.029851553961634636, 0.02953818067908287, -0.018889328464865685, -0.011291730217635632, 0.03038025088608265, -0.059359028935432434, -0.026289328932762146, -0.02125117927789688, -0.012071746401488781, 0.016711590811610222, -0.022244004532694817, -0.06197188049554825, 0.04154885560274124, 0.013648910447955132, 0.0635858029127121, 0.012726966291666031, 0.004582126624882221, -0.01395166665315628, 0.04106299579143524, 0.031387560069561005, -0.00557623291388154, -0.017767110839486122, 0.013466828502714634, 0.022508198395371437, 0.005790806841105223, -0.010430321097373962, -0.003152780933305621, 0.009665016084909439, -0.020794833078980446, 0.04760363698005676, -0.06265899538993835, 0.010389912873506546, 0.004691210575401783, -0.009189332835376263, -0.09549538791179657, -0.017327720299363136, 0.1111406460404396, 0.040258217602968216, -0.08875564485788345, 0.02050003781914711, 0.0024962679017335176, -0.008727784268558025, 0.02885100618004799, 0.030341261997818947, -0.016706557944417, -0.012977649457752705, -0.0005518231191672385, 0.016870930790901184, 0.0014849035069346428, -0.05807405337691307, -0.015700960531830788, -0.06427124887704849, 0.02553645335137844, -0.01264914870262146, -0.0687200129032135, -0.04354184865951538, -0.007462792098522186, 0.02267451398074627, 0.024300796911120415, 0.018121585249900818, 0.05119531974196434, 0.01378712896257639, -0.039080433547496796, 0.003170841606333852, -0.03629792481660843, -0.0071175298653542995, -0.01116492971777916, -0.07285761088132858, 0.041753388941287994, 0.042340248823165894, 0.05551687255501747, -0.024034900590777397, -0.012782909907400608, -0.04436502605676651, 0.008015590719878674, -0.006558972876518965, -0.011064751073718071, 0.0798306092619896, -0.03815777599811554, -0.0317494198679924, -0.08024979382753372, 0.016063394024968147, -0.017286038026213646, -0.00268738716840744, -0.015291259624063969, 0.03968379646539688, 0.023120641708374023, 0.0032698630820959806, -0.04652281850576401, 0.043062724173069, -0.021775420755147934, 0.032084837555885315, 0.03277355432510376, -0.014232154935598373, -0.00048359710490331054, -0.004712073598057032, 0.04040876403450966, -0.05374244228005409, 0.0036368314176797867, 0.028601357713341713, -0.03472711145877838, -0.060485392808914185, -0.07336675375699997, -0.05290527641773224, -0.00534554198384285, 0.03527642413973808, 0.040122900158166885, 0.03584960103034973, -0.0011835616314783692, -0.03081260435283184, -0.03447992727160454, -0.03312632814049721, 0.01943533681333065, 0.005263670813292265, -0.07070738077163696, -0.007712235674262047, 0.054426368325948715, -0.018799731507897377, -0.01975703239440918, 0.005045247729867697, -0.005637321155518293, -0.031645167618989944, 0.0007849217508919537, -0.007219875231385231, -0.005262030754238367, 0.014267010614275932, -0.052201032638549805, -0.08887487649917603, -0.016012689098715782, -0.05812196806073189, 0.04641728475689888, -0.021140942350029945, -0.007065766025334597, -0.004576883744448423, -0.012564379721879959, 0.008448749780654907, -0.004063613712787628, 0.04833648353815079, 0.01608302630484104, 0.003922035451978445, -0.007684445008635521, -0.009695128537714481, 0.01445795875042677, 0.0013206109870225191, 0.0026762830093503, 9.472654346609488e-05, 0.020074578002095222, -0.06474673748016357, 0.02020353637635708, 0.011070982553064823, -0.020367398858070374, -0.010234829038381577, -0.003227832028642297, 0.0607103668153286, -0.017972303554415703, -0.038119323551654816, -0.04679694399237633, -0.025141319260001183, -0.007919549010694027, 0.0015951062086969614, 0.07415901869535446, -0.005526527762413025, 0.0541781485080719, -0.047748684883117676, 0.015731755644083023, 0.002971634501591325, 0.0038847497198730707, -0.018592707812786102, 0.0598655566573143, -0.0073109823279082775, 0.0045948326587677, 0.011188110336661339, -0.01321262214332819, -0.003422970650717616, 0.040902890264987946, 0.001580346142873168, 0.01938210241496563, -0.05693985894322395, 0.051101502031087875, 0.03971773758530617, -0.057688359171152115, -0.03890660032629967, 0.003024771809577942, 0.019203461706638336, -0.007074485998600721, 0.02198772504925728, -0.06062176451086998, -0.0358630046248436, 0.0007305872277356684, 0.028539419174194336, -0.00807319674640894, -0.046929553151130676, 0.06693169474601746, 0.03490053862333298, 0.005065415054559708, 0.028073927387595177, -0.041716206818819046, -0.011803069151937962, 0.05722954869270325, 0.03398168832063675, 0.0515560582280159, -0.043717026710510254, 0.031101476401090622, -0.030937422066926956, -0.034279320389032364, 0.022172220051288605, -0.02919537015259266, 0.04640596732497215, 0.06809632480144501, 0.017032485455274582, -0.014003515243530273, 0.022822542116045952, -0.0019547799602150917, -0.014918494038283825, 0.03792233765125275, 0.04514015465974808, -0.06872501224279404, -0.025699613615870476, -6.225620120046382e-33, -0.02108658105134964, -0.014273867942392826, -0.009165987372398376, -0.0321543887257576, -0.028111301362514496, 0.009058627299964428, -0.04820074513554573, -0.017806362360715866, -0.002370342379435897, 0.004886813461780548, -0.017634060233831406, 0.018050186336040497, 0.014188314788043499, 0.022986968979239464, 0.007707901298999786, -0.02873973920941353, 0.029712004587054253, 0.029452167451381683, 0.009476992301642895, 0.021771585568785667, 0.03500709682703018, 0.07024257630109787, 0.12274809926748276, -0.06525899469852448, 0.0015838849358260632, -0.041763778775930405, 0.04228166118264198, -0.011758637614548206, 0.037693459540605545, 0.03298486769199371, -0.03391440212726593, -0.003258412005379796, 0.02092253603041172, -0.030869297683238983, -0.025324877351522446, 0.06214301660656929, -0.11089855432510376, -0.024767352268099785, -0.032793015241622925, 0.011283340863883495, 0.021965201944112778, -0.0442596971988678, 0.04144366830587387, -0.031174730509519577, 0.02324586734175682, 0.02785385586321354, 0.04817570745944977, -0.005549838300794363, -0.016935179010033607, 0.04481428861618042, -0.0698443129658699, 0.04806346446275711, 0.035464297980070114, 0.0037833070382475853, 0.01840781979262829, -0.008457344025373459, 0.022405661642551422, 0.02871537022292614, -0.05845916271209717, -0.011490380391478539, -0.0018135887803509831, 0.011847225949168205, 0.0022910432890057564, 0.06713002920150757, -0.02337077260017395, 0.04219625145196915, 0.028507011011242867, -0.016029667109251022, -0.003061668248847127, 0.017435597255825996, 0.007973091676831245, 0.02091238647699356, 0.05539249628782272, -0.014301609247922897, 0.0608438141644001, -0.014160881750285625, -0.053960368037223816, 0.02762984298169613, 0.005159052554517984, 0.033910930156707764, 0.04281513765454292, -0.003215536242350936, -0.08020032197237015, -0.0049609653651714325, 0.004636169411242008, 0.006381527055054903, -0.02304326929152012, -0.002006784314289689, 0.010047484189271927, 0.0017285047797486186, -0.0273935254663229, 0.019071632996201515, 0.0072309221141040325, -0.025315236300230026, 0.018682029098272324, -0.0015843611909076571, 0.05014269798994064, 0.01617581583559513, 0.002906592795625329, 0.030179651454091072, -0.06384523957967758, -0.016674699261784554, -0.0035366611555218697, -0.007720062509179115, -0.00687433360144496, -0.025453874841332436, 0.042996570467948914, -0.03436164930462837, -0.022423800081014633, -0.014421961270272732, 0.021707650274038315, -0.030587337911128998, 0.017327548936009407, 0.043667905032634735, 0.009109945967793465, -0.034657713025808334, -0.013365520164370537, 0.04380594566464424, 0.025271574035286903, -0.014236876741051674, -0.025155240669846535, -0.03103935718536377, 0.013905370607972145, 0.0159760769456625, -0.024472815915942192, 0.03129272907972336, -0.011522127315402031, 0.01600106619298458, 0.013989380560815334, -0.06847523897886276, 0.00254386686719954, 0.031538136303424835, 2.773249150322954e-07, 0.035346124321222305, 0.004862404894083738, 0.08044973760843277, -0.023796914145350456, 0.004123804625123739, -0.021839812397956848, 0.01763749308884144, 0.06657271832227707, -0.04852825030684471, 0.01043359749019146, 0.03591998293995857, -0.013211697340011597, -0.004528340883553028, -0.029221439734101295, -0.09039463102817535, -0.03087887354195118, -0.08385329693555832, 0.007028651889413595, -0.016743846237659454, -0.011873558163642883, 0.041497569531202316, 0.11064468324184418, 0.01758974976837635, 0.002053367905318737, 0.020673688501119614, -0.037695057690143585, 0.011733071878552437, 0.017690755426883698, 0.010369358584284782, 0.015997398644685745, 0.04193379357457161, 0.03805204853415489, -0.04546753317117691, 0.0037088023964315653, -0.006269535515457392, 0.053799714893102646, 0.06795966625213623, 0.008692570962011814, -0.056886348873376846, -0.0140454126521945, 0.020797673612833023, 0.008663839660584927, -0.00591996731236577, -0.04918067902326584, 0.04172716662287712, -0.004036741331219673, -0.029166268184781075, 0.0013809535885229707, 0.016211558133363724, 0.04356519505381584, -0.009549938142299652, 0.0004768506914842874, -0.04267667979001999, 0.022683240473270416, 0.03830146789550781, -0.06357474625110626, -0.009038778953254223, -0.10160906612873077, 0.00790441408753395, 0.0190088152885437, 3.200601349817589e-05, 0.02662995457649231, -0.07065613567829132, -0.05136803537607193, 0.0151891577988863, -0.03152003139257431, -0.0007598033989779651, 2.9149116830536723e-34, 0.0036446398589760065, -0.020463839173316956, -0.061954397708177567, 0.03812308609485626, 0.004645626991987228, -0.01842416636645794, 0.023132087662816048, 0.026690537109971046, 0.03249580040574074, -0.0734260156750679, -0.05049758404493332]
626
626
['Volkan Cirik', 'Eduard Hovy', 'Louis-Philippe Morency']
1611.06204v1
Curriculum Learning emphasizes the order of training instances in a computational learning setup. The core hypothesis is that simpler instances should be learned early as building blocks to learn more complex ones. Despite its usefulness, it is still unknown how exactly the internal representation of models are affected by curriculum learning. In this paper, we study the effect of curriculum learning on Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) networks, which have shown strong competency in many Natural Language Processing (NLP) problems. Our experiments on sentiment analysis task and a synthetic task similar to sequence prediction tasks in NLP show that curriculum learning has a positive effect on the LSTM's internal states by biasing the model towards building constructive representations i.e. the internal representation at the previous timesteps are used as building blocks for the final prediction. We also find that smaller models significantly improves when they are trained with curriculum learning. Lastly, we show that curriculum learning helps more when the amount of training data is limited.
Visualizing and Understanding Curriculum Learning for Long Short-Term Memory Networks
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1611.06204v1
Title Visualizing Understanding Curriculum Learning Long ShortTerm Memory Networks Summary Curriculum Learning emphasizes order training instance computational learning setup core hypothesis simpler instance learned early building block learn complex one Despite usefulness still unknown exactly internal representation model affected curriculum learning paper study effect curriculum learning Long ShortTerm Memory LSTM network shown strong competency many Natural Language Processing NLP problem experiment sentiment analysis task synthetic task similar sequence prediction task NLP show curriculum learning positive effect LSTMs internal state biasing model towards building constructive representation ie internal representation previous timesteps used building block final prediction also find smaller model significantly improves trained curriculum learning Lastly show curriculum learning help amount training data limited Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.003692563623189926, -0.04951534792780876, -0.04816649109125137, 0.01879819668829441, 0.009423155337572098, 0.03182114660739899, 0.018345246091485023, -0.05829724669456482, -0.017054418101906776, -0.014998605474829674, -0.0012486756313592196, 0.014945280738174915, 0.03155054897069931, 0.0015359147218987346, 0.04603245481848717, -0.04778693616390228, 0.03205198422074318, -0.020732667297124863, -0.013541754335165024, 0.03361818194389343, 0.009672281332314014, -0.01847689598798752, -0.028895365074276924, 0.06463489681482315, 0.01154881902039051, -0.06876202672719955, -0.027880245819687843, -0.03319990262389183, 0.021596068516373634, -0.053005117923021317, 0.02180899865925312, 0.007406133692711592, 0.06387494504451752, 0.025434687733650208, 2.60017259279266e-06, -0.032787006348371506, -0.04260896518826485, -0.04138078913092613, -0.005017760209739208, -0.017018180340528488, 0.030500223860144615, 0.0529332272708416, -0.0046502333134412766, 0.02494232729077339, -0.034542229026556015, 0.04855206608772278, 0.02865569293498993, 0.015247178263962269, 0.03981221467256546, 0.013208718970417976, -0.004290797747671604, -0.03530365601181984, -0.03195526823401451, -0.0001358149602310732, 0.023163145408034325, 0.0021151788532733917, 0.006029496900737286, 0.018043482676148415, 0.015933610498905182, 0.00530828395858407, -0.0415046364068985, 0.0009273049072362483, 0.011093748733401299, -0.003918446600437164, 0.06977424770593643, 0.04175304248929024, 0.019970115274190903, 0.01924164406955242, 0.008591443300247192, 0.027685444802045822, -0.02672707661986351, 0.021601218730211258, 0.004159943200647831, -0.0038801077753305435, 0.022956782951951027, -0.04719897359609604, -0.07337676733732224, 0.02578331157565117, -0.014797711744904518, 0.0168613288551569, 0.007746287155896425, 0.0001328652142547071, -0.017346294596791267, 0.0012947882059961557, -0.007421925198286772, -0.029506569728255272, -0.012163233011960983, -0.02938687428832054, -0.006426501087844372, -0.006791678257286549, 0.019710423424839973, -0.014669544994831085, 0.018438713625073433, 0.0869932621717453, -0.01258431188762188, 0.020067719742655754, 0.006003809627145529, -0.022091852501034737, 0.01929161138832569, -0.031598158180713654, 0.06402813643217087, 0.006936600431799889, -0.046994905918836594, 0.0007483565132133663, -0.03661297634243965, 0.10673834383487701, -0.015162606723606586, 0.06109827756881714, -0.0071767112240195274, 0.0824543684720993, -0.0948789194226265, -0.03489192575216293, -0.0034416334237903357, 0.032074522227048874, 0.018596015870571136, 0.0027380664832890034, -0.08269666135311127, 0.006393651477992535, -0.039039768278598785, 0.03860314190387726, 0.04331308975815773, 0.05581483989953995, -0.003186800517141819, 0.0627111941576004, -0.07854212820529938, 0.043361224234104156, -0.012217956595122814, 0.019847165793180466, -0.020941654220223427, 0.06828804314136505, 0.022032808512449265, 0.0023845985997468233, 0.0005288363317959011, 0.03473315387964249, -0.0066476366482675076, 0.051241375505924225, -0.008080169558525085, 0.00549838412553072, -0.09708517789840698, -0.026831192895770073, -0.029623886570334435, 0.019456997513771057, 0.06831827759742737, -0.0648050308227539, -0.04598485305905342, -0.01421122532337904, -0.0054620192386209965, 0.005119315814226866, -0.002766820602118969, 0.022141678258776665, -0.021408334374427795, -0.0051153358072042465, -0.0024716276675462723, -0.02411661110818386, 0.033482011407613754, 0.010339044965803623, 0.06768214702606201, -0.013215691782534122, 0.05361577495932579, 0.04770398139953613, -0.009078139439225197, -0.0512135811150074, 0.004874333273619413, 0.0040823109447956085, -0.007466617040336132, -0.03427162021398544, -0.0478011779487133, -0.0333327017724514, 0.003909524064511061, 0.052183836698532104, 0.013642803765833378, -0.02741203084588051, -0.019816571846604347, 0.0011335975723341107, 0.022145768627524376, 0.05377925932407379, 0.03773759305477142, -0.01784832775592804, 0.00225051399320364, 0.030989207327365875, 0.04550294578075409, 0.016152475029230118, -0.023881377652287483, 0.08649792522192001, 0.018922409042716026, 0.0018158559687435627, -0.05494486168026924, 0.022504154592752457, -0.0016178371151909232, -0.07265520840883255, -0.014295482076704502, -0.026820829138159752, -0.02952711470425129, -0.024327509105205536, 0.017558639869093895, 0.014913544990122318, -0.03368004411458969, -0.032795462757349014, 0.0032261828891932964, 0.016164032742381096, -0.011232745833694935, -0.04324467107653618, 0.005904722958803177, 0.09333464503288269, 0.0004700665595009923, -0.04716694355010986, -0.1038287803530693, -0.010237911716103554, 0.0009218904306180775, 0.011297742836177349, 0.019701821729540825, -0.023562872782349586, -0.019789719954133034, -0.028840672224760056, -0.03000362031161785, -0.05510334670543671, -0.005410521756857634, 0.048119839280843735, -0.031118622049689293, 0.0068260980769991875, -0.014833592809736729, 0.047496404498815536, -0.06406494230031967, 0.02303091250360012, -0.06117353215813637, -0.04387284070253372, -0.0046022855676710606, 0.05173823609948158, -0.01978950761258602, 0.009877517819404602, 0.014461308717727661, 0.01746165193617344, 0.030920686200261116, 0.002854197518900037, 0.004650401882827282, -0.019084477797150612, -0.11239955574274063, -0.04191754758358002, 0.004456672817468643, -0.00592783885076642, -0.03202611953020096, 0.005655817687511444, -0.04455355554819107, -0.04304216057062149, 0.04295267164707184, -0.020797688513994217, 0.0010641912231221795, 0.029338421300053596, 0.02152147702872753, -0.004208240192383528, -0.015501752495765686, -0.05799487978219986, 0.0324263796210289, 0.0033386952709406614, 0.011166765354573727, 0.029895981773734093, 0.03674021735787392, 0.010320911183953285, -0.014063196256756783, -0.01294630579650402, -0.01686704345047474, -0.032168205827474594, -0.0189095139503479, -0.035299066454172134, 0.018542302772402763, -0.10527655482292175, 0.0005862523103132844, -0.07942087948322296, -0.023580431938171387, 0.02023100107908249, -0.022184055298566818, -0.006483688950538635, -0.06232210621237755, 0.0027583157643675804, -0.020259961485862732, -0.04055364429950714, 0.03404582664370537, 0.0048592109233140945, 0.00838007777929306, 0.06945934891700745, 0.038136765360832214, -0.01413697935640812, -0.05495176464319229, -0.005804539192467928, -0.04674425348639488, 0.04289151728153229, 0.030466578900814056, -0.0013897017342969775, -0.038266103714704514, 0.008516981266438961, 0.023824546486139297, 0.022724222391843796, 0.005363063421100378, -0.04843219742178917, 0.039448101073503494, -0.03474821522831917, 0.029621006920933723, 0.06670387089252472, 0.024200333282351494, 0.03903958946466446, 0.05196432024240494, 0.01791224256157875, -0.03724824637174606, 0.008952116593718529, -0.0016985019901767373, 0.006537784356623888, 0.005161357577890158, 0.013651465997099876, -0.0396186001598835, 0.06683259457349777, 0.0649128332734108, -0.005740910768508911, -0.0034905471839010715, 0.0477076955139637, -0.004289129748940468, 0.042065270245075226, -0.08676549792289734, -0.058391496539115906, -0.004245465621352196, -0.013246757909655571, -0.007714278530329466, -0.01783258467912674, 0.02763386256992817, 0.012814588844776154, 0.04872499406337738, -0.029636582359671593, -0.019112173467874527, -0.026099253445863724, 0.04154052585363388, 0.012288826517760754, -0.021856773644685745, -0.005367692094296217, -0.04552466422319412, -0.08011063188314438, -0.007785024121403694, 0.004006866365671158, -0.04211990535259247, 0.01365270372480154, -0.04297049716114998, -0.06444935500621796, -0.01814022660255432, -0.004274830222129822, -0.06866278499364853, 0.04471990093588829, 0.021747494116425514, -0.011372482404112816, 0.06427671760320663, 0.0032620341517031193, 0.0031458160374313593, -0.04663427546620369, 0.045897677540779114, 0.02548326551914215, -0.03378022089600563, -0.020088883116841316, 0.008181126788258553, 0.01746874861419201, 0.020129477605223656, -0.005486954469233751, 0.004537046421319246, -0.028372447937726974, 0.04051540791988373, 0.05332905799150467, 0.0354258269071579, -0.01575399376451969, -0.09043662250041962, 0.03909822553396225, -0.011632358655333519, -0.035314347594976425, -0.019623974338173866, 0.03740953654050827, -0.023761481046676636, -0.0818641260266304, -0.00139519979711622, 0.0927521362900734, 0.0017477762885391712, -0.0909191370010376, 0.00601575430482626, -0.0023787468671798706, -0.05791677162051201, 0.05476522445678711, 0.017657684162259102, -0.007922365330159664, 0.02380741387605667, -0.04935382306575775, -0.0045564486645162106, -0.011189973913133144, -0.046150144189596176, -0.002879898529499769, -0.043659258633852005, -0.010988208465278149, 0.011864641681313515, -0.056180067360401154, 0.01176867913454771, -0.0127438148483634, -0.058554232120513916, 0.027415266260504723, -0.010561496019363403, 0.008105781860649586, -0.04028819873929024, 0.0024557483848184347, 0.0745675191283226, -0.06243935227394104, -0.011610900983214378, 0.04216364771127701, -0.01365366019308567, 0.019510986283421516, 0.019549677148461342, 0.019969597458839417, -0.04965982586145401, -0.007733821868896484, 0.026027439162135124, 0.036119818687438965, 0.05570719391107559, 0.016933873295783997, 0.05839162319898605, -0.0029820033814758062, -0.004491226281970739, -0.005866218823939562, 0.010823913849890232, -0.007197806611657143, 0.01051024254411459, 0.03696639835834503, 0.08432969450950623, -0.010026799514889717, -0.004887249320745468, -0.054913610219955444, 0.00988019723445177, -0.009576236829161644, -0.01837460696697235, 0.038959212601184845, -0.03292841091752052, 0.006798612419515848, -0.009838433004915714, 0.0025036833249032497, -0.02806657738983631, -0.04241209477186203, 0.012954238802194595, 0.0332266166806221, 0.04005281254649162, -0.04003218561410904, -0.03205125406384468, 0.04511280730366707, 0.03535706177353859, 0.028634870424866676, 0.00745515339076519, 0.023248815909028053, -0.012424536049365997, -0.062103021889925, 0.005284586455672979, 0.03214924782514572, -0.00329110911116004, -0.05864599347114563, 0.000637984718196094, 0.014553217217326164, -0.0271597933024168, -0.028106454759836197, -0.0791703537106514, -0.08432602137327194, 0.007735344115644693, 0.00790664367377758, 0.052778348326683044, 0.011715244501829147, 0.011361870914697647, 0.06875649839639664, -0.03226558491587639, 0.05374867841601372, -0.006562876049429178, 0.025434594601392746, -0.05133593827486038, -0.004131244961172342, 0.010419683530926704, -0.005993327125906944, -0.04057896137237549, -0.011727306060492992, 0.029869353398680687, 0.014556278474628925, -0.043262019753456116, 0.04134846851229668, 0.07581886649131775, -0.007805636152625084, -0.009780957363545895, 0.07476530224084854, 0.031282249838113785, -0.02919475920498371, -0.061335161328315735, 0.009838108904659748, -0.008148182183504105, -0.013435174711048603, 0.021014681085944176, -0.03475615009665489, 0.04375125467777252, 0.024083295837044716, -0.024487346410751343, -0.058685798197984695, 0.06498786807060242, -0.019936203956604004, -0.03249472752213478, 0.05161136016249657, -0.027763184159994125, 0.03487079590559006, -0.006152757443487644, 0.028301771730184555, -0.05832425877451897, 0.014056350104510784, -0.0017634497489780188, 0.023840267211198807, 0.006411281414330006, 0.06557469815015793, -0.005786290857940912, 0.0476975291967392, 0.011286646127700806, 0.03293395787477493, -0.018641028553247452, -0.035425323992967606, -0.026450468227267265, -0.0005385860567912459, 0.040122415870428085, -0.09465320408344269, -0.0273783840239048, -0.0010414434364065528, 0.048009078949689865, 0.007703942712396383, -0.018640482798218727, -0.0371776781976223, -0.017945168539881706, 0.04656895622611046, 0.006423060782253742, 0.02517777308821678, -0.05131598562002182, 0.05514074116945267, 0.03595630079507828, 0.004694613628089428, -0.0016165929846465588, -0.01069332379847765, -0.01246714312583208, -0.002655405318364501, 0.04412924125790596, 0.020694846287369728, -0.004333738703280687, 0.005221792496740818, -0.014679250307381153, -0.027326853945851326, 0.03378549963235855, 0.007628222461789846, 0.04188917949795723, -0.032566990703344345, 0.013207498006522655, 0.041848793625831604, 0.012994334101676941, -0.0025384228210896254, 0.01969236321747303, -0.000900439394172281, 0.01882794313132763, -0.04107896238565445, -0.02981390431523323, -6.358057191081775e-33, -0.02826601266860962, -0.06941518932580948, 0.06997938454151154, 0.009322313591837883, 0.014784066006541252, -0.005136293824762106, -0.02636200748383999, 0.015182515606284142, -0.02054373174905777, 0.009026273153722286, -0.03014991618692875, 0.023627011105418205, -9.645506361266598e-05, 0.030512668192386627, 0.10075660049915314, 0.024035990238189697, 0.018254315480589867, -0.0029681369196623564, 0.037337321788072586, 0.04626311734318733, 0.0572330467402935, 0.03074464574456215, 0.0922500491142273, -0.023192279040813446, -0.011826706118881702, 0.03387671336531639, 0.055552929639816284, -0.042257487773895264, -0.007453307509422302, 0.04663766548037529, -0.016616331413388252, 0.03299442306160927, 0.03713148832321167, -0.06429066509008408, -0.022707294672727585, -0.03221242129802704, -0.030302152037620544, -0.10677431523799896, -0.009258328005671501, -0.02116592787206173, -0.022152673453092575, -0.04570598900318146, 0.05275409668684006, 0.01772157847881317, -0.024627339094877243, -0.03530501574277878, 0.0502881184220314, -0.027138078585267067, 0.009242133237421513, -0.03151983395218849, -0.07010487467050552, 0.000747299927752465, -0.030956486240029335, 0.03492627292871475, -0.01254621334373951, 0.014248264953494072, -0.0029970197938382626, 0.024156587198376656, -0.05615587159991264, 0.060794051736593246, -0.008419864811003208, 0.06117687374353409, 0.0402848944067955, 0.020699406042695045, -0.013842142187058926, 0.0814124271273613, -0.010852467268705368, 0.07787086069583893, -0.02101757749915123, -0.023673394694924355, 0.022190120071172714, 0.06844867020845413, 0.0542193278670311, -0.025251921266317368, 0.055886298418045044, -0.04719911888241768, -0.04774674400687218, 0.01573815569281578, -0.0027207075618207455, 0.057109419256448746, 0.012284407392144203, -0.03385043144226074, -0.02197209931910038, -0.010585026815533638, 0.004427681677043438, 0.01515197567641735, -0.014208298176527023, 0.0015888294437900186, 0.03321574628353119, -0.03273381292819977, 0.007804520428180695, 0.009304232895374298, -0.023404603824019432, -0.029346147552132607, 0.036064572632312775, 0.047613244503736496, 0.0038123978301882744, 0.012274214066565037, 0.014359652996063232, -0.005519567523151636, -0.08283150941133499, -0.031130671501159668, -0.02240867167711258, -0.02036004327237606, 0.044806256890296936, 0.06565201282501221, 0.0826801061630249, -0.01483271736651659, -0.02987782657146454, -0.050881125032901764, -0.012208220548927784, -0.0026818772312253714, 0.019451042637228966, -0.043494436889886856, 0.002062872052192688, -0.008174150250852108, -0.03327653929591179, 0.05104072019457817, 0.0053137303330004215, -0.04434834420681, -0.005244464613497257, -0.06354270875453949, 0.01697685942053795, 0.02178358845412731, 0.0033229582477360964, -0.03182225674390793, -0.06448854506015778, 0.043695539236068726, 0.0179216880351305, -0.08079031109809875, -0.005591024644672871, -0.0016018494497984648, 3.0469203693428426e-07, -0.007732064928859472, 0.04853801056742668, 0.018092671409249306, -0.018777983263134956, 0.04956119507551193, -0.0336976982653141, -0.0458252914249897, 0.008907493203878403, 0.008234667591750622, 0.011324204504489899, -0.0016697117825970054, 0.025175848975777626, 0.0077909366227686405, -0.003942748997360468, -0.028695285320281982, -0.042357489466667175, -0.0399889200925827, -0.0011569552589207888, -0.03390037640929222, 0.016020316630601883, 0.08672751486301422, 0.03172256797552109, 0.01063778530806303, -0.017120949923992157, -0.01445081178098917, 0.010518832132220268, 0.0033555689733475447, 0.013832364231348038, 0.0701652318239212, -0.024609385058283806, 0.004195237997919321, 0.0005543218576349318, -0.00799590814858675, 0.0076079764403402805, -0.007662165444344282, 0.004360389430075884, -0.0414382740855217, 0.01683657243847847, 0.018580051138997078, -0.006556258536875248, 0.04405287653207779, 0.019255327060818672, 0.002528241602703929, -0.04800228774547577, 0.026626480743288994, -0.08783311396837234, 0.008210905827581882, 0.0037185153923928738, 0.0032527686562389135, -0.009617875330150127, 0.02899819239974022, 0.0213975477963686, 0.004444226622581482, -0.029375702142715454, -0.031235184520483017, -0.054384056478738785, 0.007552153430879116, -0.05255074054002762, 0.024346111342310905, 0.04481985419988632, -0.014295406639575958, -0.013459023088216782, -0.020123939961194992, -0.011392015963792801, 0.026608120650053024, -0.015826735645532608, -0.028411170467734337, 3.0791560241011337e-34, 0.02254362963140011, -0.01816532202064991, 0.05361277610063553, -0.03255666047334671, -0.004789496771991253, -0.021100392565131187, 0.0517483614385128, 0.03555968031287193, 0.019671466201543808, -0.04954523593187332, -0.08765897899866104]
627
627
['Tom Sercu', 'Vaibhava Goel']
1611.09288v2
In computer vision pixelwise dense prediction is the task of predicting a label for each pixel in the image. Convolutional neural networks achieve good performance on this task, while being computationally efficient. In this paper we carry these ideas over to the problem of assigning a sequence of labels to a set of speech frames, a task commonly known as framewise classification. We show that dense prediction view of framewise classification offers several advantages and insights, including computational efficiency and the ability to apply batch normalization. When doing dense prediction we pay specific attention to strided pooling in time and introduce an asymmetric dilated convolution, called time-dilated convolution, that allows for efficient and elegant implementation of pooling in time. We show results using time-dilated convolutions in a very deep VGG-style CNN with batch normalization on the Hub5 Switchboard-2000 benchmark task. With a big n-gram language model, we achieve 7.7% WER which is the best single model single-pass performance reported so far.
Dense Prediction on Sequences with Time-Dilated Convolutions for Speech Recognition
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1611.09288v2
Title Dense Prediction Sequences TimeDilated Convolutions Speech Recognition Summary computer vision pixelwise dense prediction task predicting label pixel image Convolutional neural network achieve good performance task computationally efficient paper carry idea problem assigning sequence label set speech frame task commonly known framewise classification show dense prediction view framewise classification offer several advantage insight including computational efficiency ability apply batch normalization dense prediction pay specific attention strided pooling time introduce asymmetric dilated convolution called timedilated convolution allows efficient elegant implementation pooling time show result using timedilated convolution deep VGGstyle CNN batch normalization Hub5 Switchboard2000 benchmark task big ngram language model achieve 77 WER best single model singlepass performance reported far Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.01365703996270895, 0.03957163169980049, 0.006407111417502165, 0.04693054407835007, -0.008529930375516415, -0.023427637293934822, 0.06719914823770523, 0.002023087115958333, -0.053115736693143845, -0.005807191599160433, -0.014297999441623688, -0.03579714149236679, 0.032626617699861526, 0.06886547803878784, 0.017840595915913582, -0.11167633533477783, 0.0028774964157491922, -0.013305512256920338, 0.0166360791772604, 0.005274661350995302, 0.01632332243025303, -0.014410513453185558, -0.02259630337357521, 0.06132602319121361, -0.03220260143280029, 0.008454009890556335, -0.0436377115547657, -0.03416052833199501, 0.00860811211168766, -0.05260571464896202, 0.011341417208313942, 0.08864737302064896, 0.02367248386144638, 0.027473459020256996, 2.2617020931647858e-06, 0.01218945812433958, -0.00444153742864728, -0.028926437720656395, -0.017155516892671585, 0.006837446708232164, -0.033251091837882996, 0.02314210869371891, -0.014913285151124, 0.02794552780687809, -0.03722727298736572, -0.02918900176882744, 0.0201044213026762, 0.0217767134308815, -0.02636794000864029, 0.04829494282603264, -0.019556941464543343, -0.02950013428926468, -0.0057883416302502155, -0.01984260603785515, -0.02439839392900467, -0.04728172346949577, -0.020666180178523064, -0.00417183805257082, 0.006629913579672575, -0.029768243432044983, -0.00786635186523199, 0.04807369038462639, 0.02035505883395672, -0.03092610090970993, 0.038047902286052704, 0.056270401924848557, -0.06590931862592697, -0.06184761971235275, -0.05473746359348297, 0.07877781987190247, -0.046438705176115036, 0.008701745420694351, 0.011414236389100552, -0.008110487833619118, -0.029348503798246384, -0.05990273132920265, -0.02804112248122692, 0.00806877575814724, 0.00813204888254404, 0.008132300339639187, -0.04983274266123772, 0.06919945031404495, 0.019057705998420715, 0.006200670730322599, 0.017861567437648773, 0.017043007537722588, -0.00033403903944417834, 0.011744419112801552, -0.05300126597285271, -0.00786700937896967, -0.008717521093785763, -0.08983008563518524, 0.03250535577535629, 0.0504988431930542, 0.005555196665227413, -0.012641459703445435, -0.03121945448219776, -0.041577547788619995, -0.006911054253578186, -0.015412505716085434, -0.02110307663679123, -0.006277676206082106, -0.03888804465532303, 0.004114836920052767, -0.010153674520552158, 0.03457818180322647, 0.019445225596427917, 0.009126213379204273, -0.027421312406659126, 0.02425367943942547, -0.007335075177252293, 0.022779935970902443, -0.030235962942242622, 0.03177417814731598, -0.00678031612187624, -0.028553348034620285, -0.07630584388971329, -0.022904224693775177, -0.01094100158661604, -0.004595118574798107, 0.02001035585999489, 0.04763348400592804, -0.01558716967701912, -0.032919928431510925, 0.007834110409021378, 0.03116743266582489, -0.0021625349763780832, 0.04462197422981262, -0.0012846651952713728, -0.06330380588769913, 0.013834075070917606, 0.047408685088157654, 0.01007617823779583, 0.02023627609014511, 0.00785768497735262, 0.051398638635873795, -0.008663689717650414, -0.03599049896001816, -0.07179346680641174, -0.009082986041903496, -0.07000188529491425, -0.007745685987174511, -0.023181132972240448, -0.08730947971343994, -0.033585891127586365, -0.032657504081726074, 0.0023639013525098562, 0.015213033184409142, 0.010226553305983543, 0.004844089969992638, 0.03708547353744507, 0.04781046882271767, -0.004112666938453913, -2.575719918240793e-05, 0.07964447140693665, 0.018016628921031952, 0.08693744987249374, 0.029984649270772934, 0.04492975026369095, 0.0356605127453804, 0.01324534509330988, -0.05648752674460411, -0.015016204677522182, 0.0549691766500473, 0.0005109337507747114, -0.026476750150322914, -0.07917589694261551, -0.03973057121038437, 0.021847859025001526, 0.03552871569991112, 0.028614573180675507, 0.02332608588039875, 0.025990979745984077, -0.024181701242923737, 0.030609095469117165, 0.04617315158247948, 0.008257432840764523, -0.017577368766069412, 0.042020346969366074, -0.02546079270541668, 0.005595076363533735, 0.012154435738921165, -0.010444371029734612, 0.05529020354151726, 0.016588980332016945, -0.013318311423063278, 0.02560989186167717, 0.000102997750218492, -0.04125403240323067, -0.053732261061668396, 0.006466313730925322, -0.02102615125477314, -0.006124761421233416, -0.01573694311082363, 0.01965716853737831, 0.005595672409981489, -0.05902525410056114, 0.024598510935902596, 0.003680962836369872, 0.01635834015905857, -0.026503928005695343, -0.012761027552187443, -0.0006165584200061858, 0.025103388354182243, -0.0034692019689828157, -0.025692079216241837, -0.0661405622959137, -0.019830450415611267, 0.011908119544386864, 0.019694222137331963, -0.019206827506422997, -0.028055470436811447, 0.00856071524322033, -0.0628703162074089, -0.003182660322636366, 0.05363402143120766, -0.04170114919543266, 0.05227184668183327, -0.007855106145143509, 0.06096246838569641, 0.020823467522859573, 0.04270228371024132, 0.0012680814834311604, 0.02264588139951229, 0.03436553478240967, -0.052227046340703964, 0.02169019915163517, 0.046213917434215546, 0.046816132962703705, 0.036724645644426346, 0.012360408902168274, -0.0007549392175860703, 0.07829396426677704, -0.027509205043315887, -0.023005764931440353, 0.009895293042063713, -0.11507417261600494, -0.050295259803533554, 0.045586276799440384, 0.030979247763752937, 0.015735454857349396, 0.006356365047395229, -0.03344493731856346, -0.05417289584875107, 0.03296766057610512, 0.01870027743279934, 0.03145674243569374, -0.02235148288309574, 0.044988881796598434, 0.034781672060489655, 0.029149767011404037, -0.011511015705764294, -0.003172921249642968, -0.029205825179815292, 0.02045186422765255, 0.04291005805134773, 0.023171409964561462, 0.027836913242936134, -0.030331479385495186, -0.003724210662767291, 0.05517807975411415, -0.043999843299388885, -0.029854359105229378, 0.006519613321870565, -0.0071054804138839245, -0.028153125196695328, 0.021344689652323723, -0.06369491666555405, -0.034786488860845566, -0.012794841080904007, -0.007367056328803301, -0.03577444702386856, -0.024132246151566505, 0.010405155830085278, -0.06790444254875183, -0.029654543846845627, 0.021583067253232002, 0.02662467584013939, -0.04873893782496452, 0.008181517012417316, 0.02005773037672043, -0.038522638380527496, -0.022698601707816124, -0.01351474691182375, 0.009853375144302845, 0.024388782680034637, -0.030940111726522446, -0.09249287098646164, -0.012111188843846321, -0.00042275452869944274, 0.018833408132195473, 0.04864920675754547, 0.007368112448602915, -0.03369874507188797, -0.006077652331441641, 0.004396046511828899, 0.029304077848792076, 0.031138183549046516, 0.05874525010585785, 0.013523357920348644, -0.001165694440715015, 0.012850110419094563, 0.050095606595277786, 0.018954822793602943, -0.020499741658568382, -0.0016446281224489212, -0.0037375353276729584, 0.011605332605540752, -0.059929899871349335, 0.07305483520030975, 0.0040684049017727375, 0.06530759483575821, -0.05321257933974266, -0.017158757895231247, -0.023915855213999748, -0.0371863953769207, -0.03949013352394104, -0.0018824068829417229, -0.022161325439810753, 0.028890982270240784, 0.005837016273289919, -0.08555153012275696, 0.0314093716442585, -0.03501071408390999, -0.052519507706165314, 0.006660758517682552, -0.06590025871992111, 0.0038486558478325605, 0.07926045358181, 0.009149722754955292, -0.0016458051977679133, -0.0037043492775410414, -0.03444315493106842, -0.05746440216898918, 0.010992297902703285, -0.019437991082668304, -0.04323717579245567, 0.022516898810863495, -0.03719805181026459, -0.020995305851101875, -0.015660108998417854, -0.010177143849432468, -0.07983925193548203, -0.029688837006688118, -0.06045443192124367, 0.0011646592756733298, -0.04117956757545471, -0.011570326052606106, 0.0034768437035381794, 0.03251110389828682, -0.05664099007844925, 0.01992793194949627, -0.014078116044402122, 0.038019031286239624, 0.00843803584575653, 0.08936985582113266, 0.05742024630308151, 0.02820594049990177, -0.03764687478542328, 0.06431946903467178, 0.08644792437553406, 0.02150229923427105, -0.012892097234725952, 0.04171191155910492, -0.10342688858509064, -0.009473352693021297, 0.009476019069552422, -0.014757990837097168, -0.04301631823182106, 0.04922199249267578, 0.03770589455962181, -0.07317511737346649, 0.058466166257858276, 0.08621782064437866, -0.009028579108417034, -0.06817333400249481, 0.006560610141605139, 0.019099457189440727, 0.021645089611411095, 0.0266795102506876, -0.020561067387461662, 0.0007268203189596534, -0.039139945060014725, 0.021322881802916527, -0.00561365345492959, 0.0014525562291964889, 0.004698675591498613, -0.008616320788860321, -0.06794624030590057, 0.048541098833084106, 0.009880725294351578, 0.005696647800505161, 0.014655044302344322, -0.028414286673069, -0.03532140329480171, 0.015907708555459976, 0.03167673200368881, -0.012369362637400627, 0.012295003049075603, -0.017329102382063866, 0.0781780257821083, -0.051191896200180054, 0.029038675129413605, 0.047512829303741455, -0.011373940855264664, 0.06256813555955887, 0.044363200664520264, 0.04578018561005592, -0.027637870982289314, -0.06306544691324234, 0.012526731938123703, -0.022204091772437096, 0.0133488355204463, -0.00794130377471447, 0.02400852181017399, 0.008157990872859955, -0.012798942625522614, 0.026305126026272774, 0.054074399173259735, -0.002988982480019331, -0.006117997225373983, 0.041878070682287216, 0.06340621411800385, 0.006454484071582556, -0.02619173191487789, -0.05722961202263832, 0.058618444949388504, 0.025568915531039238, 0.01451999880373478, -0.005262655671685934, -0.0204562246799469, -0.004179449286311865, 0.040763214230537415, 0.02758348174393177, -0.04348968714475632, -0.03932257369160652, 0.012759095057845116, -0.0053360480815172195, -0.06076734885573387, -0.04732169210910797, -0.034046024084091187, -0.016154000535607338, 0.048099812120199203, 0.015019026584923267, 0.002166571794077754, 0.005016594659537077, 0.04046345874667168, -0.07509581744670868, -0.013150961138308048, 0.05228361859917641, 0.06819203495979309, -0.09432732313871384, 0.02900475449860096, 0.016865519806742668, -0.007666633464396, -0.01783941499888897, 0.04834194481372833, -0.07643937319517136, -0.03898562863469124, 0.009151787497103214, 0.01953132450580597, -0.004532078746706247, 0.02303760126233101, 0.013557984493672848, -0.01670423150062561, 0.06975099444389343, -0.010301078669726849, 0.016485700383782387, 0.001767285750247538, 0.038908202201128006, -0.008443181402981281, -0.04278407245874405, 0.018756574019789696, -0.020511576905846596, 0.08154983818531036, -0.03652924299240112, -0.06634865701198578, -0.043017540127038956, -0.07203497737646103, -0.015631558373570442, -0.026162369176745415, 0.10351177304983139, -0.009576820768415928, 0.022299576550722122, -0.004492879845201969, 0.03734701871871948, 0.02421124279499054, 0.03760543093085289, -0.015306271612644196, 0.00047567530418746173, 0.03312120959162712, 0.010459491983056068, 0.0019587127026170492, -0.01771668903529644, -0.011932114139199257, -0.1018957570195198, 0.04679921641945839, 0.07499483227729797, -0.016566554084420204, 0.04229000583291054, -0.03318513184785843, 0.010557662695646286, 0.023775111883878708, 0.02463664673268795, 0.023281313478946686, 0.04946444556117058, 0.008863070048391819, 0.007460274733603001, 0.011603799648582935, 0.04049921780824661, 0.0008115668315440416, 0.010787134990096092, -0.004625942092388868, -0.0070743439719080925, -0.05675572529435158, 0.000697925454005599, 0.019820496439933777, -0.06057412549853325, -0.016074268147349358, 0.008084967732429504, 0.013877385295927525, -0.03396026790142059, 0.035914383828639984, -0.05221620574593544, 0.005629363935440779, 0.06413951516151428, -0.011099051684141159, -0.039853911846876144, 0.01195591315627098, 0.05700121447443962, 0.029448730871081352, 0.014651048928499222, 0.06598848849534988, -0.00022846953652333468, -0.027855873107910156, -0.0038856910541653633, -0.05162305757403374, 0.01136944442987442, 0.0018036218825727701, 0.011159843765199184, 0.0030285208486020565, -0.06099531427025795, 0.05807327851653099, -0.027525121346116066, 0.048624418675899506, 0.006074677221477032, 0.01720372401177883, -0.0058390297926962376, -0.0032595149241387844, 0.012208327651023865, -0.020079419016838074, -0.008653534576296806, 0.02775120921432972, -0.02592867612838745, -0.03171910345554352, -6.456183051384604e-33, -0.0321999117732048, -0.05133797973394394, 0.020199710503220558, 0.023375259712338448, -0.02478410117328167, 0.05562284216284752, -0.015385797247290611, 0.02370455674827099, 0.012091010808944702, 0.0190154816955328, -0.024927882477641106, 0.0049771410413086414, 0.02704060822725296, 0.022603141143918037, 0.03382714465260506, -0.011800453998148441, 0.045825351029634476, -0.04080326110124588, 0.03878922387957573, 0.02890430949628353, 0.01990508660674095, 0.026399707421660423, 0.06462237238883972, -0.04416578635573387, -0.04858076944947243, 0.027682647109031677, -0.007211480755358934, -0.010887740179896355, 0.061853423714637756, -0.0033833289053291082, -0.024084972217679024, 0.008945440873503685, 0.010020336136221886, -0.049572549760341644, -0.015475301072001457, 0.041416753083467484, -0.06903274357318878, -0.001371236052364111, -0.04326639696955681, 0.07459404319524765, -0.04977717623114586, 0.01499566063284874, 0.020539995282888412, -0.009268814697861671, -0.042010996490716934, -0.02004588581621647, 0.04353707283735275, -0.014011787250638008, -0.038729049265384674, -0.007793637923896313, -0.036383748054504395, 0.053786750882864, -0.04079512506723404, -0.03628205880522728, 0.07634224742650986, 0.04279932379722595, 0.002398161217570305, -0.0013634123606607318, -0.041427552700042725, 0.03343534469604492, -0.033492058515548706, 0.0973554328083992, 0.06269024312496185, 0.02362474612891674, 0.0024223974905908108, 0.03223695233464241, 0.04630991816520691, -0.03993403539061546, -0.024305952712893486, 0.011084687896072865, -0.001955302432179451, 0.05673283711075783, 0.05475142225623131, -0.021869594231247902, 0.07471060007810593, -0.06283566355705261, -0.02676943503320217, 0.02350589632987976, -0.005646232981234789, 0.009864198043942451, -0.008202217519283295, 0.010861847549676895, 0.0030436867382377386, 0.014114434830844402, -0.005149669945240021, -0.039632104337215424, 0.013507531024515629, -0.025792308151721954, 0.01770208403468132, 0.0061858235858380795, 0.028454219922423363, 0.03256328031420708, 0.03624957054853439, -0.003951692953705788, 0.028854407370090485, -0.030859967693686485, -0.018572751432657242, 0.0009403505246154964, 0.01969863474369049, 0.029850546270608902, -0.05353572964668274, -0.03259803354740143, 0.04394280165433884, 0.02591695822775364, 0.006913899909704924, -0.016200441867113113, 0.020920418202877045, 0.030394693836569786, -0.03800826892256737, -0.019767703488469124, -0.004749946296215057, 0.00545333418995142, 0.036447376012802124, 0.017143625766038895, 0.037224944680929184, -0.03126386180520058, -0.007038746494799852, 0.019570162519812584, -0.012185048311948776, -0.034309517592191696, -0.0003253105969633907, -0.03474459424614906, 0.03325949236750603, 0.04508587345480919, -0.06492932885885239, -0.014896364882588387, -0.03395988792181015, -0.02373947575688362, 0.035534635186195374, -0.028660984709858894, -0.023447096347808838, -0.001287922146730125, 2.9436742465804855e-07, -0.03150850161910057, -0.0072622401639819145, 0.0269877128303051, -0.019339391961693764, -0.00429068598896265, -0.01024201326072216, -0.0002776596520561725, 0.011417181231081486, -0.04846913367509842, -0.029133353382349014, 0.041941817849874496, -0.04500351473689079, 0.042033568024635315, 0.005069872364401817, -0.06151047348976135, -0.05290123447775841, -0.07921172678470612, 0.03740405663847923, -0.016295816749334335, 0.004703278187662363, 0.0019522957736626267, 0.10277954488992691, 0.007856396958231926, -0.04650651663541794, 0.0695844292640686, -0.0018377823289483786, -0.02472996897995472, 0.04415390267968178, 0.03793061524629593, -0.01715414971113205, 0.013726484961807728, 0.007543484680354595, -0.020047368481755257, 0.002391718327999115, -0.0596453994512558, 0.003489908529445529, 0.05890186131000519, 0.012494821101427078, -0.055324994027614594, -0.03521425649523735, -0.014270098879933357, 0.03381926193833351, -0.011709188111126423, -0.00037728247116319835, 0.029773728922009468, 0.0402861014008522, -0.02962271310389042, -0.0628616139292717, -0.0014783836668357253, 0.02895510196685791, 0.04569326341152191, 0.03604675829410553, 0.02505265362560749, 0.019593162462115288, 0.021122736856341362, -0.034307848662137985, -0.0355248861014843, -0.08031508326530457, 0.004483774304389954, 0.01143317949026823, -0.042918745428323746, 0.026537222787737846, -0.06708540767431259, -0.03537650406360626, 0.01881667971611023, 0.0038649553898721933, -0.03284608945250511, 2.4220973854971884e-34, -0.0014197378186509013, -0.016398195177316666, -0.021563857793807983, 0.004620208404958248, -0.04216287285089493, -0.03532620891928673, 0.00490289693698287, -0.0013222384732216597, 0.0086903665214777, -0.03411737456917763, -0.05152063071727753]
628
628
['Kartik Audhkhasi', 'Andrew Rosenberg', 'Abhinav Sethy', 'Bhuvana Ramabhadran', 'Brian Kingsbury']
1701.04313v1
End-to-end (E2E) systems have achieved competitive results compared to conventional hybrid hidden Markov model (HMM)-deep neural network based automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems. Such E2E systems are attractive due to the lack of dependence on alignments between input acoustic and output grapheme or HMM state sequence during training. This paper explores the design of an ASR-free end-to-end system for text query-based keyword search (KWS) from speech trained with minimal supervision. Our E2E KWS system consists of three sub-systems. The first sub-system is a recurrent neural network (RNN)-based acoustic auto-encoder trained to reconstruct the audio through a finite-dimensional representation. The second sub-system is a character-level RNN language model using embeddings learned from a convolutional neural network. Since the acoustic and text query embeddings occupy different representation spaces, they are input to a third feed-forward neural network that predicts whether the query occurs in the acoustic utterance or not. This E2E ASR-free KWS system performs respectably despite lacking a conventional ASR system and trains much faster.
End-to-End ASR-free Keyword Search from Speech
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1701.04313v1
Title EndtoEnd ASRfree Keyword Search Speech Summary Endtoend E2E system achieved competitive result compared conventional hybrid hidden Markov model HMMdeep neural network based automatic speech recognition ASR system E2E system attractive due lack dependence alignment input acoustic output grapheme HMM state sequence training paper explores design ASRfree endtoend system text querybased keyword search KWS speech trained minimal supervision E2E KWS system consists three subsystem first subsystem recurrent neural network RNNbased acoustic autoencoder trained reconstruct audio finitedimensional representation second subsystem characterlevel RNN language model using embeddings learned convolutional neural network Since acoustic text query embeddings occupy different representation space input third feedforward neural network predicts whether query occurs acoustic utterance E2E ASRfree KWS system performs respectably despite lacking conventional ASR system train much faster Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.019321588799357414, 0.02940099500119686, 0.027120331302285194, 0.0550609789788723, -0.006799870170652866, -0.020971085876226425, 0.003670979058369994, 0.0041054971516132355, -0.023339271545410156, -0.05908973887562752, -0.03312704339623451, 0.004711388610303402, -0.012850308790802956, 0.06760329753160477, 0.0077787828631699085, -0.021992921829223633, 0.013645962812006474, -0.02099149115383625, -0.022030867636203766, -0.007816349156200886, 0.036515507847070694, 0.01192342396825552, -0.04159444943070412, 0.06292224675416946, -0.0067679500207304955, 0.049717728048563004, -0.05341858044266701, -0.001381352893076837, -0.011909904889762402, -0.0340031161904335, -0.02056206203997135, -0.003451048629358411, 0.06503652781248093, 0.049297310411930084, 2.169518438677187e-06, -0.004015985410660505, -0.02176981419324875, -0.0063461000099778175, -0.04594295471906662, -0.031562287360429764, 0.010389051400125027, 0.02294057235121727, 0.008105624467134476, 0.044777773320674896, 0.008699705824255943, -0.011825494468212128, 0.033930785953998566, 0.053281888365745544, 0.00943442527204752, 0.05541223660111427, -0.006371302995830774, -0.08642164617776871, 0.03176316246390343, -0.007285475730895996, 0.003012836677953601, -0.04590785130858421, -0.0019729656632989645, -0.07505367696285248, 0.029609357938170433, -0.004498242400586605, 0.0013495682505890727, 0.03412751853466034, -0.012267001904547215, -0.014009390026330948, 0.027914265170693398, 0.018752792850136757, -0.041839126497507095, -0.033897943794727325, -0.017965707927942276, 0.07906898856163025, 0.0031921793706715107, -0.0349235013127327, 0.016787150874733925, -0.003794049145653844, -0.0503283254802227, -0.004912198521196842, 0.010106737725436687, 0.029081957414746284, -0.008471457287669182, -0.0050363074988126755, -0.01770709827542305, 0.04468076303601265, 0.0326005294919014, -0.007433713413774967, -0.008752361871302128, 0.04270049184560776, 0.005699911154806614, -0.04256646707653999, -0.02085961028933525, -0.09708873927593231, 0.043232306838035583, -0.028025591745972633, 0.0595858171582222, 0.024145392701029778, 0.012959924526512623, 0.0164648424834013, 0.0004729123611468822, -0.054139602929353714, 0.012606526724994183, -0.05942355468869209, -0.005932074971497059, 0.0402594730257988, -0.024064484983682632, -0.0025956821627914906, -0.008385330438613892, 0.07093977928161621, 0.014623302035033703, 0.0006015184917487204, -0.025812147185206413, -0.011900702491402626, -0.027334602549672127, -0.008944212459027767, -0.07087447494268417, 0.039464112371206284, -0.009920377284288406, -0.06483564525842667, -0.021386584267020226, 0.001009878353215754, 0.048066847026348114, -0.014142864383757114, 0.035828977823257446, 0.03725580498576164, -0.02385488897562027, -0.004007092211395502, 0.01691138558089733, 0.011510595679283142, 0.0002604419132694602, 0.03675529360771179, -0.023559367284178734, -0.0035837863106280565, 0.012644804082810879, 0.03005409985780716, 0.06848065555095673, -0.0158192478120327, -0.009568899869918823, 0.052155569195747375, 0.03617040812969208, -0.03665119409561157, -0.05425729230046272, 0.045608941465616226, -0.013449335470795631, 0.012429756112396717, -0.02744167111814022, -0.02078847959637642, 0.042677756398916245, -0.029689790681004524, -0.026678625494241714, 0.026525292545557022, 0.03528314828872681, 0.024594826623797417, 0.02671607956290245, 0.07903541624546051, 0.014984920620918274, -0.0018372336635366082, 0.0542798712849617, -0.020428301766514778, 0.051191363483667374, 0.026377979665994644, 0.06624853610992432, 0.012357189320027828, 0.01579352281987667, -0.0488177053630352, -0.03932369500398636, 0.022982221096754074, -0.04838794842362404, -0.02760709822177887, -0.03289785236120224, 0.008009192533791065, -0.02691328153014183, 0.07105731219053268, 0.01897004246711731, 0.048742253333330154, 0.00929681770503521, -0.01914185844361782, -0.0014785021776333451, 0.08130067586898804, 0.059999607503414154, 0.027239855378866196, 0.0030356217175722122, 0.021288953721523285, -0.045285627245903015, -0.029700564220547676, 0.027346257120370865, -0.004037946928292513, -0.023961134254932404, -0.013551928102970123, 0.02063509076833725, -0.053435876965522766, -0.013084369711577892, -0.025541989132761955, -0.026790184900164604, 0.005506387446075678, -0.034270621836185455, 0.021203098818659782, 0.07565527409315109, -0.005708542186766863, -0.06261245906352997, 0.0018034871900454164, -0.017218321561813354, -0.04933725297451019, 0.0187109112739563, -0.04284648597240448, -0.004186827689409256, 0.03294222429394722, 0.03845555707812309, -0.05103534460067749, 0.018742380663752556, -0.04814884811639786, -0.05687953159213066, 0.028688112273812294, -0.023153156042099, -0.001300552161410451, 0.006591706071048975, -0.08698924630880356, -0.033687639981508255, 0.048639927059412, -0.00914420373737812, 0.04913081228733063, -0.07377971708774567, 0.051436979323625565, 0.030701419338583946, -0.007894092239439487, 0.028136085718870163, 0.016045983880758286, 0.002695506438612938, -0.012356918305158615, 0.0016180041711777449, 0.045750997960567474, 0.05663127824664116, 0.02624964900314808, -0.008544397540390491, -0.0017767436802387238, 0.05583346262574196, -0.008993684314191341, -0.015951108187437057, 0.01867385022342205, -0.07265793532133102, -0.04566441848874092, 0.014331714250147343, -0.01751861907541752, 0.0669921413064003, 0.04187381640076637, 0.024337874725461006, -0.07771866023540497, 0.009304158389568329, -0.024549199268221855, 0.06774014234542847, -0.02848050743341446, 0.047828804701566696, 0.012092368677258492, -0.0011402824893593788, -0.015806065872311592, -0.0054269032552838326, 0.010676019825041294, 0.029687825590372086, -0.022911900654435158, -0.010523614473640919, 0.03727424889802933, -0.08805884420871735, -0.036297187209129333, 0.030267398804426193, -0.002199894282966852, 0.0024488901253789663, 0.007822754792869091, -0.040745679289102554, -0.016934091225266457, -0.01997588947415352, -0.061153046786785126, -0.017871759831905365, -0.02377954311668873, -0.0077939722687006, 0.009818345308303833, 0.05273200944066048, 0.02280782163143158, -0.027575673535466194, -0.03358360752463341, -0.01879960112273693, 0.005125283729285002, -0.02372777834534645, -0.019259808585047722, 0.012336544692516327, -0.01312513742595911, -0.02063898555934429, -0.01794220134615898, -0.022325437515974045, 0.009494396857917309, 0.01582290232181549, -0.06053677946329117, -0.025595126673579216, 0.00563293369486928, 0.02968263253569603, 0.050284720957279205, -0.004319288302212954, -0.0330859050154686, 0.00010139583173440769, -0.036484166979789734, 0.010711784474551678, 0.007608094718307257, 0.01363512221723795, -0.0032040970399975777, 0.002415386727079749, 0.006116389762610197, -0.041641660034656525, 0.02473011054098606, 0.007819313555955887, 0.06923392415046692, 0.011490855365991592, 0.016046131029725075, -0.026062503457069397, -0.00019642795086838305, 0.034482985734939575, 0.043143779039382935, -0.019176088273525238, -0.037578243762254715, -0.01073792390525341, -0.026697976514697075, -0.05753559619188309, -0.04732583835721016, -0.03540028631687164, 0.007126610726118088, -0.005120689049363136, 0.01803538203239441, 0.011903066188097, -0.05222049728035927, -0.03733604773879051, -0.07055158168077469, -0.05290544778108597, -0.02037685364484787, 0.016730977222323418, 0.002976558171212673, 0.01602410152554512, 0.005825095344334841, -0.07416703552007675, 0.01943512074649334, 0.01597834751009941, -0.00263281911611557, -0.041019730269908905, 0.01775180734694004, 0.04449668899178505, 0.033136121928691864, -0.0006260745576582849, 0.0013998944777995348, -0.05184407904744148, -0.0038901136722415686, -0.03828737512230873, 0.030584020540118217, 0.0050026592798531055, -0.04386131837964058, -0.015203735791146755, 0.07782745361328125, 0.017355959862470627, 0.06304152309894562, 0.0012019512942060828, 0.021808478981256485, -0.032117076218128204, 0.04585759714245796, 0.058763522654771805, 0.029336968436837196, -0.03506148234009743, 0.04409797862172127, 0.04642792046070099, -0.01570300944149494, 0.05117390304803848, -0.026492958888411522, -0.06178886815905571, -0.008246595039963722, 0.02400381490588188, -0.016015315428376198, -0.0017440087394788861, -0.0009028916829265654, -0.02148452214896679, -0.06009511277079582, -0.008640254847705364, 0.07584929466247559, 0.010192271322011948, -0.03673907741904259, -0.039402205497026443, -0.013082415796816349, -0.0022039334289729595, 0.028741570189595222, 0.004381278064101934, -0.0008699526078999043, -0.019580550491809845, 0.04921569675207138, 0.05046607181429863, 0.030333198606967926, 0.015930648893117905, -6.898084393469617e-05, -0.09899017959833145, 0.03359929844737053, -0.0020246964413672686, -0.06608079373836517, -0.03881970793008804, -0.05392096936702728, -0.021325478330254555, -0.014067704789340496, 0.04718143120408058, 0.03112792782485485, -0.0011996913235634565, -0.038479629904031754, 0.028774451464414597, -0.05744778364896774, -0.026210179552435875, 0.008921710774302483, -0.042472414672374725, 0.05236004292964935, 0.08998531103134155, 0.051404982805252075, -0.0439017154276371, -0.03586159273982048, -0.003883498953655362, -0.0066504934802651405, 0.03061157837510109, -0.02041609026491642, -0.0017211512895300984, -0.007708542514592409, -0.01017609890550375, 0.01567724719643593, 0.016667768359184265, -0.023654235526919365, 0.049769144505262375, 0.002474152483046055, 0.06423362344503403, -0.03291911631822586, 0.009981038980185986, -0.020933723077178, 0.020485037937760353, 0.005004157777875662, 0.029319554567337036, -0.01454467885196209, 0.02122356742620468, -0.022701364010572433, 0.012982390820980072, 0.06837939471006393, -0.01923367753624916, 0.022577090188860893, 0.024440322071313858, 0.007328919135034084, -0.014531210064888, -0.028922591358423233, -0.03824985772371292, -0.0031862712930887938, 0.02066808007657528, 0.040729861706495285, 0.05297204479575157, 0.02625659480690956, 0.02150239422917366, -0.04694386571645737, -0.02253318391740322, 0.013795020058751106, 0.025823229923844337, -0.06180042028427124, 0.024877192452549934, 0.05910918861627579, -0.07206332683563232, -0.013209694065153599, -0.06766101717948914, 0.012247182428836823, -0.04290387034416199, -0.00027742981910705566, -0.033438943326473236, 0.005478728096932173, 0.02009236440062523, -0.0632893294095993, -0.0674905776977539, 0.03268769010901451, -0.026025280356407166, -0.0499659962952137, -0.024958550930023193, 0.04313084855675697, 0.012374438345432281, -0.014947600662708282, 0.0022409718949347734, -0.05992717668414116, 0.021969156339764595, -0.04508280009031296, 0.03246915340423584, 0.0068644261918962, -0.06754649430513382, 0.009252920746803284, 0.028525007888674736, 0.0560273677110672, 0.0003306888975203037, 0.016005264595150948, -0.06804299354553223, 0.04575506970286369, 0.003365384414792061, 0.04113395884633064, -0.02666730247437954, 0.06326223164796829, 0.01583082415163517, 0.02676943875849247, -0.0069450815208256245, -0.02058507315814495, -0.030039608478546143, -0.06792061775922775, 0.013282119296491146, 0.12821224331855774, 0.04962955042719841, 0.012564856559038162, 0.01622943766415119, 0.02315657213330269, -0.01661192625761032, 0.052987419068813324, 0.0401218980550766, 0.0505354069173336, -0.018164679408073425, 0.014461076818406582, 0.003444691188633442, -0.02080199308693409, 0.003245296888053417, 0.027477717027068138, -0.020601140335202217, 0.02162284217774868, -0.026282310485839844, 0.03848707675933838, 0.0638531893491745, -0.017505822703242302, -0.04446547105908394, 0.032335713505744934, 0.04220781475305557, -0.051512643694877625, 0.03683599457144737, -0.04745929315686226, 0.0016805656487122178, 0.05296320468187332, 0.023295223712921143, -0.024103889241814613, 0.03336527571082115, -0.0054373666644096375, 0.04593687877058983, 0.05245661735534668, 0.008750466629862785, 0.007371875457465649, -0.041114307940006256, 0.008102236315608025, 0.014433787204325199, 0.07934597879648209, -0.05395966395735741, -0.006901567801833153, 0.02183019556105137, -0.05758386850357056, 0.029320115223526955, -0.020366337150335312, 0.02392156794667244, -0.02715497650206089, 0.015607400797307491, -0.009606251493096352, 0.0033812487963587046, 0.031627871096134186, -0.00014942754933144897, -0.017724767327308655, -0.016945473849773407, -0.0384751595556736, -0.021624354645609856, -6.0752505153472106e-33, 0.01638755016028881, 0.020458491519093513, -0.00880950503051281, -0.04907301440834999, -0.03749639913439751, -0.0036098810378462076, -0.0027628655079752207, -0.023810477927327156, -0.011995854787528515, -0.024924766272306442, -0.02978563867509365, -0.0013493631267920136, 0.018342824652791023, 0.011751760728657246, 0.015690675005316734, -0.02667868509888649, 0.0361555851995945, -0.021301979199051857, 0.054106615483760834, -0.026677649468183517, 0.0598367378115654, 0.08768510073423386, 0.03147271275520325, -0.009765883907675743, -0.08477962762117386, -0.016261205077171326, 0.018879279494285583, -0.005051678977906704, -0.01784750260412693, 0.03429930657148361, -0.017606200650334358, 0.03181474283337593, -0.016493406146764755, 0.00521887419745326, -0.002532933373004198, 0.0285427775233984, -0.10353793948888779, 0.0039009207393974066, -0.05289129540324211, 0.0633794441819191, 0.015526829287409782, 0.021305691450834274, 0.09017419070005417, -0.02746834047138691, -0.01844973675906658, 0.043539244681596756, 0.05317920073866844, 0.0010680090636014938, -0.05118248239159584, -0.050582125782966614, -0.016655929386615753, 0.024472342804074287, 0.010142011567950249, -0.02320355921983719, 0.076115183532238, 0.03949201852083206, 0.018236158415675163, -0.005845680367201567, -0.08301940560340881, 0.004527333192527294, -0.025505581870675087, 0.016808144748210907, 0.007214195095002651, 0.06903183460235596, 0.005704615730792284, 0.02864498645067215, 0.04756668582558632, -0.07835792750120163, -0.007761724758893251, -0.008491606451570988, 0.03981485217809677, 0.032509543001651764, 0.022079860791563988, -0.04165581986308098, 0.0591794028878212, -0.018335940316319466, -0.056699324399232864, -0.0070155044086277485, 0.018121032044291496, 0.015391391701996326, 0.014613299630582333, 0.03158186748623848, -0.1128554716706276, -0.006578679196536541, -0.054822321981191635, -0.005109549965709448, -0.06072395294904709, -0.017975173890590668, 0.0715547502040863, 0.008008264005184174, 0.02342923730611801, -0.01519168820232153, 0.01311422698199749, -0.04394090920686722, 0.0137548316270113, -0.002932859817519784, 0.023854777216911316, -0.027267977595329285, -0.019998744130134583, 0.05018143355846405, -0.04771820455789566, -0.008321322500705719, 0.03169453144073486, 0.035946499556303024, -0.014389527961611748, -0.03532964736223221, -0.022730974480509758, 0.06411965191364288, -0.024903489276766777, -0.029748035594820976, 0.007676602806895971, -0.030265795066952705, 0.01884300634264946, 0.03143003210425377, 0.005393759347498417, -0.041856057941913605, 0.011393706314265728, 0.049433376640081406, 0.00023811410937923938, 0.012680589221417904, -0.036706678569316864, -0.035398468375205994, 0.029131373390555382, 0.028729893267154694, -0.037957362830638885, 0.016162993386387825, -0.011464288458228111, 0.03722119703888893, 0.04030757024884224, -0.023009922355413437, 0.003097556298598647, 0.041631054133176804, 2.840510262558382e-07, -0.025883454829454422, -0.013306117616593838, 0.04761087894439697, -0.026332519948482513, -0.02297346480190754, 0.00584177253767848, -0.0038883122615516186, -0.012487400323152542, -0.020590180531144142, 0.02279566414654255, 0.027602987363934517, -0.03904721513390541, 0.030972253531217575, 0.006503990385681391, -0.11243483424186707, -0.03031552955508232, -0.08872968703508377, 0.012146816588938236, -0.01724901981651783, 0.020893903449177742, 0.04987727850675583, 0.09806576371192932, 0.04356006532907486, -0.033477384597063065, 0.009050034917891026, -0.05187718942761421, 0.007496790960431099, 0.029882587492465973, 0.048173561692237854, -0.03104984015226364, -0.014605291187763214, 0.006184815429151058, -0.039331186562776566, 0.012346492148935795, -0.024270102381706238, 0.07947562634944916, 0.03188887611031532, -0.004044945817440748, -0.052853796631097794, -0.08067472279071808, 0.03382892534136772, 0.030843153595924377, -0.023443596437573433, -0.013471242971718311, 0.047054968774318695, 0.01259005069732666, -0.012436128221452236, -0.026558836922049522, -0.007959369570016861, -0.007791540119796991, -0.004263426177203655, -0.00030918364063836634, 0.007117909379303455, -0.025596365332603455, 0.009122841991484165, -0.05802958831191063, -0.010770287364721298, -0.09356456249952316, 0.03024701029062271, -0.01688458025455475, -0.058552078902721405, 0.023887671530246735, -0.04443854093551636, -0.012045013718307018, 0.01875222660601139, 0.028059005737304688, -0.03569260612130165, 2.395734169615114e-34, 0.02787022665143013, -0.01774325780570507, -0.04354829713702202, 0.019392307847738266, 0.008111115545034409, -0.021504808217287064, 0.03229725733399391, 0.020499220117926598, 0.01772426813840866, -0.08911135792732239, -0.07968071848154068]
629
629
['Sam Wiseman', 'Sumit Chopra', "Marc'Aurelio Ranzato", 'Arthur Szlam', 'Ruoyu Sun', 'Soumith Chintala', 'Nicolas Vasilache']
1702.04770v1
While Truncated Back-Propagation through Time (BPTT) is the most popular approach to training Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs), it suffers from being inherently sequential (making parallelization difficult) and from truncating gradient flow between distant time-steps. We investigate whether Target Propagation (TPROP) style approaches can address these shortcomings. Unfortunately, extensive experiments suggest that TPROP generally underperforms BPTT, and we end with an analysis of this phenomenon, and suggestions for future work.
Training Language Models Using Target-Propagation
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1702.04770v1
Title Training Language Models Using TargetPropagation Summary Truncated BackPropagation Time BPTT popular approach training Recurrent Neural Networks RNNs suffers inherently sequential making parallelization difficult truncating gradient flow distant timesteps investigate whether Target Propagation TPROP style approach address shortcoming Unfortunately extensive experiment suggest TPROP generally underperforms BPTT end analysis phenomenon suggestion future work Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.022913193330168724, 0.018226375803351402, -0.0020813068840652704, 0.01972082257270813, -0.017786908894777298, -0.022440539672970772, 0.020408382639288902, -0.02054072543978691, -0.09643825143575668, -0.04322342947125435, -0.044961269944906235, -0.05960092693567276, 0.041636064648628235, 0.0011985463788732886, 0.03546528518199921, -0.08096082508563995, 0.030793769285082817, -0.016537252813577652, -0.03309694305062294, 0.0030266325920820236, 0.027762040495872498, 0.01902022957801819, -0.030151275917887688, 0.08310636878013611, 0.01576603204011917, -0.013845248147845268, 0.0018557304283604026, -0.01980227418243885, -0.01451935339719057, -0.021864987909793854, 0.013048043474555016, 0.039297789335250854, 0.03330616652965546, 0.029641732573509216, 2.0165186924714362e-06, -0.00957415346056223, 0.015345537103712559, -0.04331998527050018, 0.006744501180946827, 0.03527074307203293, 0.05522184073925018, -0.02236000820994377, -0.011401728726923466, 0.047365833073854446, -0.017964616417884827, -0.07599113136529922, 0.042362477630376816, 0.05540063977241516, 0.042026586830616, 0.0596979595720768, 0.0072895558550953865, -0.032266441732645035, 0.02293342538177967, -0.04391653835773468, -0.010358692146837711, -0.05117492750287056, 0.008707687258720398, -0.0390373170375824, -0.012687485665082932, 0.007176849991083145, -0.018437683582305908, 0.005105697084218264, 0.0033263941295444965, 0.03572916239500046, -0.011292742565274239, 0.05336786061525345, 0.014364231377840042, -0.009839600883424282, -0.018953392282128334, 0.05744976922869682, -0.0390985906124115, -0.0441134087741375, 0.00818667747080326, 0.010980208404362202, -0.05759681388735771, -0.04118724167346954, -0.024510418996214867, 0.025374246761202812, 0.010965167544782162, 0.03845933824777603, 0.02770831808447838, -3.691351230372675e-05, 0.05398574471473694, -0.0010232743807137012, -0.003308592364192009, 0.019694466143846512, 0.01602436974644661, -0.03875727951526642, 0.003064625198021531, -0.0069074127823114395, 0.014574717730283737, -0.046933505684137344, -0.01750430278480053, 0.026571126654744148, 0.02023301087319851, 0.033499881625175476, -0.035634931176900864, -0.03457615524530411, 0.005928711965680122, -0.01998710446059704, 0.07152079045772552, 0.050579071044921875, -0.0172395221889019, -0.018075358122587204, -0.027197659015655518, 0.04917031154036522, -0.027389876544475555, -0.01982348971068859, -0.01634029485285282, 0.013651642948389053, -0.08142026513814926, -0.01183087658137083, -0.03591255098581314, 0.025917474180459976, -0.0011916765943169594, -0.010423563420772552, -0.0681810975074768, -0.0007542598759755492, 0.008776157163083553, -0.05521952360868454, -0.004561504814773798, -0.014411992393434048, -0.07114993780851364, -0.007494010962545872, 0.015026997774839401, 0.07924997061491013, -0.0060472385957837105, 0.007558641489595175, -0.03340703248977661, -0.051357679069042206, -0.006779290735721588, -0.0011278243036940694, 0.00013940827921032906, -0.003842841135337949, -0.0055612302385270596, 0.07010775059461594, 0.009246950969099998, -0.03933732956647873, -0.07634010165929794, 0.027137717232108116, -0.02832704223692417, -0.05298462137579918, -0.013027062639594078, -0.08822671324014664, -0.005302193108946085, -0.039622846990823746, -0.03489125519990921, -0.02035514824092388, 0.018324092030525208, 0.0420195609331131, 0.008067627437412739, 0.04130689427256584, 0.02140551246702671, -0.002341913292184472, 0.03778328001499176, -0.001240293961018324, 0.041582394391298294, 0.06642264872789383, 0.054143764078617096, 0.007304736413061619, -0.03643433749675751, -0.0060393004678189754, -0.023580264300107956, 0.06150352209806442, 0.04149969667196274, 0.002904633292928338, -0.07202257215976715, -0.034470848739147186, 0.023809779435396194, 0.040311384946107864, 0.04424548149108887, 0.05366731435060501, -0.03316815197467804, 0.009619091637432575, 0.05999608710408211, 0.035243622958660126, 0.027401849627494812, 0.05693246051669121, 0.0520915612578392, -0.023661641404032707, -0.01787913776934147, 0.015645407140254974, -0.010828018188476562, -0.016431691125035286, -0.014344599097967148, 0.006904254201799631, -0.041536394506692886, 0.019589614123106003, -0.03919420763850212, -0.012583496980369091, -0.007282726000994444, -0.012057214044034481, -0.009241382591426373, -0.007430137600749731, 0.08319971710443497, 0.056395407766103745, -0.05346532538533211, 0.02711385488510132, 0.03666529431939125, -0.01955966278910637, 0.00837769079953432, -0.020934587344527245, -0.025911159813404083, 0.024815283715724945, 0.017865389585494995, -0.02767852507531643, -0.03381216526031494, -0.02523280307650566, -0.0018154473509639502, 0.03214273601770401, 0.041920509189367294, -0.013913048431277275, 0.010413730517029762, -0.059107132256031036, 0.04486696049571037, 0.005206302739679813, 0.008630617521703243, 0.03848136588931084, -0.014943506568670273, -0.004124994855374098, 0.008729271590709686, 0.042329151183366776, -0.043728116899728775, 0.06438516825437546, -0.01915772818028927, -0.0252589862793684, 0.026009326800704002, 0.032045766711235046, 0.031973693519830704, 0.011993980966508389, 0.017199000343680382, -0.0154190668836236, 0.019572237506508827, -0.052535586059093475, -0.009170831181108952, 0.02025524713099003, -0.039640240371227264, -0.05162534490227699, 0.06704222410917282, -0.021836481988430023, 0.013106057420372963, 0.05691094696521759, -0.012261108495295048, -0.061648543924093246, 0.08796783536672592, -0.04195018112659454, 0.04544674605131149, -0.035040803253650665, 0.052067823708057404, -0.017887132242321968, 0.021595584228634834, -0.024172110483050346, 0.01930091343820095, -0.004978128708899021, 0.02072637900710106, -0.001780051039531827, -0.0012358191888779402, 0.01972189173102379, -0.03771257400512695, -0.03324217349290848, 0.041842442005872726, -0.0012228612322360277, 0.0008803036180324852, -0.012338412925601006, 0.02435525506734848, -0.019105995073914528, -0.020610066130757332, -0.051054809242486954, 0.032534487545490265, -0.029725024476647377, 0.017323551699519157, 0.00211936398409307, 0.03509637713432312, 0.016620945185422897, -0.010277541354298592, -0.0398191399872303, 0.0070962184108793736, -0.01854611560702324, 0.023177925497293472, 0.04320315644145012, 0.04647994786500931, -0.008410337381064892, -0.05244794860482216, -0.030649954453110695, -0.01238773763179779, 0.0420895554125309, -0.034281905740499496, -0.03887734189629555, -0.019095567986369133, 0.017651423811912537, 0.016617046669125557, 0.06393283605575562, -0.007850049063563347, -0.048027414828538895, 0.008749253116548061, -0.0084519749507308, 0.07076899707317352, 0.016938937827944756, -0.02093241550028324, 0.019121605902910233, 0.019104313105344772, 0.0013758682180196047, -0.0385311134159565, 0.0033480857964605093, -0.05217541754245758, -0.007667912635952234, -0.017239563167095184, -0.04551314935088158, -0.01997213624417782, 0.09852172434329987, 0.006887235213071108, 0.012915117666125298, -0.0612475723028183, -0.019555073231458664, -0.04278690367937088, 0.003348754020407796, -0.03504284471273422, -0.01996399275958538, -0.012544496916234493, 0.00637047179043293, -0.0216881912201643, -0.018673812970519066, 0.06292296946048737, -0.06919917464256287, -0.007705777417868376, -0.07067149132490158, -0.03830307349562645, -0.042041052132844925, 0.03939090669155121, 0.023630622774362564, -0.0018984376220032573, -0.023291584104299545, -0.0668993592262268, -0.04066247493028641, 0.015194926410913467, -0.018320050090551376, -0.005113021470606327, 0.058893702924251556, -0.02598954737186432, -0.019433528184890747, -0.006692287977784872, -0.02540559694170952, -0.03991210088133812, -0.0389898456633091, -0.007287757005542517, -0.0010909828124567866, -0.01346857100725174, -0.026580100879073143, -0.00609436072409153, 0.043088749051094055, 0.004669996444135904, 0.05370594188570976, -0.04024451971054077, -0.0038903793320059776, -0.013398239389061928, -0.012559237889945507, 0.05041267350316048, -0.05275668203830719, -0.012399828992784023, -0.0032616755925118923, -0.01778578758239746, 0.01789700612425804, 0.06520169973373413, 0.030160346999764442, -0.10649244487285614, -0.024936748668551445, 0.014686849899590015, -0.04546911641955376, -0.030380193144083023, 0.027122218161821365, 0.007329740095883608, -0.09955821186304092, -0.016419483348727226, 0.08901496231555939, 0.0077377064153552055, -0.038982685655355453, 0.0022597704082727432, 0.026858976110816002, 0.013049241155385971, 0.012163853272795677, 0.016379062086343765, -0.022745883092284203, -0.014076505787670612, -0.008340392261743546, 0.020726395770907402, -0.0013575045159086585, -0.008136004209518433, -0.020878875628113747, -0.1292862594127655, -0.013886985369026661, -0.004554317332804203, -0.07862627506256104, -0.016639772802591324, -0.06491760164499283, -0.017826536670327187, -0.005623928736895323, 0.03710482269525528, 0.033217303454875946, -0.03680465742945671, -0.00491612171754241, 0.04593385383486748, -0.06957396119832993, -0.03895752876996994, 0.015721188858151436, -0.05648301541805267, 0.057221267372369766, 0.11892987787723541, 0.015174145810306072, -0.019146351143717766, -0.013960285112261772, 0.033837221562862396, -0.03179611265659332, -0.006317244376987219, -0.02367234043776989, 0.0006679968209937215, -0.012732007540762424, -0.009149906225502491, 0.03675908222794533, 0.035072486847639084, -0.03603591397404671, 0.04207850620150566, -0.010508615523576736, 0.06327710300683975, -0.019056038931012154, -0.014059728942811489, 0.008733456023037434, 0.0496215857565403, 0.005303584039211273, 0.03628387302160263, 0.0430760383605957, -0.054171785712242126, -0.03305589407682419, 0.004059667699038982, 0.003218055469915271, -0.054624371230602264, -0.04704619571566582, 0.0425272099673748, 0.006188770290464163, -0.07237393409013748, -0.10822556167840958, -0.05109306052327156, 0.01642373576760292, 0.055272556841373444, 0.03145087882876396, 0.009198040701448917, 0.02308037132024765, 0.006031406577676535, -0.025076240301132202, 0.02368900738656521, 0.008257383480668068, 0.018452418968081474, -0.032976336777210236, 0.004358369391411543, 0.03559226170182228, -0.02713458240032196, 0.006049639545381069, 0.0025281172711402178, -0.0909593403339386, -0.054491035640239716, 0.0003810680645983666, 0.026553034782409668, 0.01881205476820469, 0.014145292341709137, -0.035524047911167145, -0.06320914626121521, 0.004242802504450083, -0.023269224911928177, 0.01343454048037529, 0.013543685898184776, 0.0422312393784523, -0.003391448175534606, 0.012817942537367344, 0.0114517193287611, -0.02803792618215084, 0.0640486404299736, 0.016406046226620674, 0.00544580677524209, 0.01408255472779274, 0.021351264789700508, 0.02426322177052498, -0.01746230572462082, 0.07659337669610977, 0.007713142316788435, -0.030417559668421745, -0.051268093287944794, 0.006289949174970388, -0.012717674486339092, 0.04588277265429497, -0.034385159611701965, 0.01461938675493002, 0.04302706941962242, 0.038887687027454376, 0.00626082019880414, -0.0979171097278595, -0.020032798871397972, -0.0007087813573889434, -0.009638222865760326, 0.059441741555929184, -0.000268835254246369, 0.041118863970041275, 0.011551212519407272, 0.04537621885538101, -0.039539631456136703, 0.00772394984960556, 0.0007113597821444273, 0.012054108083248138, -0.017232554033398628, 0.0260300412774086, 0.038095541298389435, 0.018909525126218796, -0.02961358241736889, -0.006098651327192783, -0.04068972170352936, 0.011930950917303562, -0.017641272395849228, -0.008180777542293072, 0.0893169492483139, -0.016938917338848114, 0.04615207016468048, -0.03462464362382889, 0.029783573001623154, -0.011908487416803837, 0.03318071365356445, -0.0401105135679245, -0.015378059819340706, 0.0482737198472023, 0.005388322751969099, -0.015683595091104507, 0.002237016335129738, 0.07662584632635117, 0.04087323695421219, 0.05639248341321945, 0.060180943459272385, 0.04235629737377167, -0.02437443472445011, -0.03499837964773178, -0.05136457830667496, 0.03673894703388214, -0.02097759023308754, 0.011908336542546749, -0.023286642506718636, -0.04406576231122017, 0.02579965442419052, 0.0011636983836069703, 0.025188108906149864, -0.032029252499341965, 0.03350246325135231, 0.0473305843770504, 0.005560006946325302, 0.014039220288395882, -0.05290811508893967, 0.007288399152457714, 0.020542606711387634, -0.02722540684044361, -0.05833195894956589, -5.847139591756407e-33, -0.024434540420770645, 0.005367486737668514, 0.04065747186541557, 0.014215459115803242, -0.07588084042072296, 0.01656063087284565, -0.01990998536348343, -0.0019303727895021439, -0.000823005975689739, -0.014116553589701653, -0.023198707029223442, 0.006800450850278139, 0.011279630474746227, 0.04222554713487625, 0.005653827451169491, -0.0029180783312767744, 0.05205162614583969, -0.010149292647838593, 0.021227184683084488, -0.01130466628819704, 0.04562505707144737, 0.050977401435375214, 0.07646415382623672, -0.022999318316578865, -0.014940513297915459, -0.023648498579859734, -0.011087944731116295, 0.008426926098763943, 0.029272912070155144, 0.05074118822813034, -0.02005474828183651, 0.047314323484897614, 0.019725849851965904, -0.05542735755443573, -0.025829331949353218, 0.015020702965557575, -0.08012167364358902, -0.010800715535879135, 0.022643517702817917, 0.04049564525485039, -0.021661706268787384, 0.005481209605932236, 0.07573144882917404, -0.008215171284973621, 0.0007794949924573302, 0.018683793023228645, 0.01722121238708496, -0.03278985992074013, -0.04557780548930168, 0.0012218571500852704, -0.08352101594209671, 0.008321891538798809, 0.013025100342929363, 0.004409582354128361, 0.05047411099076271, -0.0011164454044774175, -0.04703876003623009, -0.006456403527408838, -0.1053825169801712, 0.01788855716586113, 0.00808437168598175, 0.08016465604305267, 0.026138190180063248, 0.050654951483011246, 0.04641959071159363, 0.02438591793179512, 0.06216353923082352, -0.004414448980242014, 0.010715825483202934, -0.003769747680053115, 0.08631696552038193, -0.012364414520561695, 0.05269176512956619, -0.015968499705195427, 0.049662597477436066, -0.021531125530600548, -0.08047634363174438, -0.014853253960609436, 0.07410731911659241, 0.028909189626574516, 0.03547560051083565, -0.0063311378471553326, -0.04792660102248192, -0.017509905621409416, -0.023257235065102577, -0.027232594788074493, -0.0044811926782131195, -0.051727768033742905, -0.0008161139558069408, 0.015052633360028267, 0.04309757798910141, 0.04559357091784477, 0.015880510210990906, 0.0005095861270092428, 0.01680847816169262, -0.009689613245427608, -0.027519358322024345, 0.03258553147315979, -0.015565430745482445, 0.04918763041496277, -0.08416781574487686, -0.010531293228268623, -0.025074239820241928, 0.010782199911773205, 0.017069898545742035, 0.031922005116939545, 0.05185536667704582, 0.018107030540704727, -0.055326081812381744, -0.02373438887298107, -0.04373525455594063, 0.04504573717713356, 0.006479285191744566, 0.06927282363176346, 0.034987665712833405, -0.02314266748726368, -0.010835319757461548, 0.06980346888303757, 0.02689889445900917, -0.029789190739393234, -0.012548007071018219, 0.02160762995481491, 0.019717790186405182, 0.042331475764513016, -0.05111059173941612, -0.01155932992696762, -0.015879802405834198, 0.029409917071461678, 0.03324997425079346, -0.054517414420843124, -0.03213236853480339, 0.020654844120144844, 2.650751014243724e-07, -0.0067739589139819145, 0.028670156374573708, 0.030592208728194237, 0.018790829926729202, 0.017797935754060745, -0.0035908017307519913, -0.002495766384527087, 0.012187818996608257, -0.008317261002957821, 0.02712375670671463, 0.017445404082536697, -0.0002143186138710007, 0.06180620938539505, 0.02172606810927391, -0.10281077027320862, -0.024742960929870605, -0.08090325444936752, 0.021627584472298622, -0.0352683961391449, -0.003777604317292571, -0.019239572808146477, 0.10976541042327881, 0.025155434384942055, -0.026370836421847343, 0.007911944761872292, 0.03340737894177437, 0.05587846413254738, 0.0053717331029474735, -0.02369200997054577, 0.019352268427610397, 0.021200593560934067, 0.0036680439952760935, -0.019447069615125656, -0.009417051449418068, -0.022812943905591965, 0.05914583057165146, -0.04417482390999794, 0.03454950824379921, -0.012814007699489594, -0.045181721448898315, 0.045459769666194916, 0.005271549802273512, -0.0403585210442543, -0.01594247668981552, 0.018243666738271713, -0.030491244047880173, -0.03745962679386139, -0.01331486739218235, 0.024578671902418137, 0.022061344236135483, -0.01539621315896511, -0.03980427235364914, -0.006356776226311922, 0.006242990028113127, 0.015318823978304863, -0.04419203847646713, -0.02712223306298256, -0.06545022130012512, 0.008113699033856392, 0.03283907473087311, -0.025929830968379974, -0.0012301073875278234, -0.026439128443598747, 0.009195185266435146, 0.027626661583781242, -0.02445256896317005, -0.01531422883272171, 2.719879262330504e-34, 0.025951284915208817, -0.028251515701413155, 0.0036190636456012726, 0.003716222709044814, -0.00676996074616909, 0.01452485378831625, 0.0023920275270938873, 0.009490064345300198, 0.01726379431784153, -0.0705697238445282, -0.031691428273916245]
630
630
['Sercan O. Arik', 'Mike Chrzanowski', 'Adam Coates', 'Gregory Diamos', 'Andrew Gibiansky', 'Yongguo Kang', 'Xian Li', 'John Miller', 'Andrew Ng', 'Jonathan Raiman', 'Shubho Sengupta', 'Mohammad Shoeybi']
1702.07825v2
We present Deep Voice, a production-quality text-to-speech system constructed entirely from deep neural networks. Deep Voice lays the groundwork for truly end-to-end neural speech synthesis. The system comprises five major building blocks: a segmentation model for locating phoneme boundaries, a grapheme-to-phoneme conversion model, a phoneme duration prediction model, a fundamental frequency prediction model, and an audio synthesis model. For the segmentation model, we propose a novel way of performing phoneme boundary detection with deep neural networks using connectionist temporal classification (CTC) loss. For the audio synthesis model, we implement a variant of WaveNet that requires fewer parameters and trains faster than the original. By using a neural network for each component, our system is simpler and more flexible than traditional text-to-speech systems, where each component requires laborious feature engineering and extensive domain expertise. Finally, we show that inference with our system can be performed faster than real time and describe optimized WaveNet inference kernels on both CPU and GPU that achieve up to 400x speedups over existing implementations.
Deep Voice: Real-time Neural Text-to-Speech
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1702.07825v2
Title Deep Voice Realtime Neural TexttoSpeech Summary present Deep Voice productionquality texttospeech system constructed entirely deep neural network Deep Voice lay groundwork truly endtoend neural speech synthesis system comprises five major building block segmentation model locating phoneme boundary graphemetophoneme conversion model phoneme duration prediction model fundamental frequency prediction model audio synthesis model segmentation model propose novel way performing phoneme boundary detection deep neural network using connectionist temporal classification CTC loss audio synthesis model implement variant WaveNet requires fewer parameter train faster original using neural network component system simpler flexible traditional texttospeech system component requires laborious feature engineering extensive domain expertise Finally show inference system performed faster real time describe optimized WaveNet inference kernel CPU GPU achieve 400x speedup existing implementation Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.009917370043694973, 0.047601792961359024, 0.015423452481627464, 0.02271011844277382, 0.007447405252605677, -0.04852304980158806, 0.039579831063747406, 0.010334247723221779, -0.051909007132053375, -0.01405063085258007, -0.04730913043022156, -0.025458768010139465, 0.044778551906347275, 0.0770290419459343, 0.02070579119026661, -0.09342982620000839, 0.00865989364683628, 0.00978696346282959, -0.008598297834396362, 0.0008433366310782731, 0.04130696877837181, 0.015381861478090286, -0.04702473059296608, 0.04706841707229614, -0.04751865193247795, -0.00938128400593996, -0.0171790961176157, -0.013458960689604282, 0.0024759641382843256, -0.016237663105130196, -0.013960258103907108, -0.02264305390417576, 0.036243755370378494, 0.03347386419773102, 2.094481260428438e-06, -0.004419752862304449, -0.023938585072755814, -0.0018130753887817264, 0.004419195000082254, -0.014940446242690086, 0.038649383932352066, 0.03268763795495033, -0.049342431128025055, 0.05114816874265671, -0.002295762300491333, 0.057081930339336395, 0.0496356226503849, 0.0579092837870121, 0.014158021658658981, 0.05692031979560852, -0.026057716459035873, -0.03464021906256676, 0.03789803385734558, 0.003684994764626026, -0.0029999057296663523, 0.004294644109904766, -0.041259728372097015, -0.016635997220873833, 0.005783403292298317, -0.050467878580093384, 0.022161815315485, 0.0420108288526535, 0.023855796083807945, -0.018618876114487648, -0.01771843060851097, 0.03252965211868286, -0.0532284714281559, -0.05043013393878937, 0.02365192212164402, 0.07225793600082397, -0.03131283447146416, 0.003874225774779916, 0.0364360511302948, 0.015059028752148151, -0.0030984741169959307, -0.059316426515579224, 0.00926582794636488, 0.026823241263628006, -0.029127663001418114, -0.002441643038764596, -0.051123443990945816, 0.057464808225631714, 0.009608919732272625, -0.04512856900691986, 0.04536451771855354, -0.01856069266796112, 0.016969170421361923, -0.003990787547081709, -0.01791284792125225, -0.022286931052803993, -0.005731409415602684, -0.021234668791294098, 0.05740521475672722, 0.014029256999492645, -0.023110942915081978, 0.002025560475885868, -0.04786263033747673, -0.059891220182180405, -0.0032503146212548018, -0.05790555849671364, 0.0018472609808668494, 0.02482498250901699, -0.04027557000517845, -0.05039422959089279, -0.010882285423576832, 0.006810895167291164, -0.003674390958622098, -0.05992911383509636, -0.036130089312791824, -0.02162332460284233, 0.009438729844987392, -0.00991056114435196, -0.060476597398519516, 0.0272584967315197, -0.01698320545256138, -0.04692002013325691, -0.0641108974814415, -0.033682048320770264, -0.025257889181375504, -0.019442692399024963, 0.05075903609395027, 0.06158110499382019, -0.05871699005365372, -0.03499799594283104, 0.022003907710313797, -0.004555506631731987, -0.012951558455824852, 0.07474477589130402, -0.03482011705636978, -0.04251791164278984, 0.03853877633810043, 0.03344419226050377, 0.03795214742422104, 0.04838353022933006, 0.03763444721698761, 0.031909361481666565, -0.030591368675231934, 0.02815796434879303, -0.03699745982885361, -0.031277842819690704, -0.0028090232517570257, -0.014068003743886948, -0.029947953298687935, -0.08357549458742142, 0.026327555999159813, -0.03373454138636589, -0.03914817422628403, 0.05067698284983635, 0.005558482836931944, 0.022898342460393906, 0.05402423068881035, 0.0220318716019392, -0.02677600271999836, 0.01342577114701271, 0.10167241096496582, -0.005726655013859272, 0.033327121287584305, 0.03226551413536072, 0.09480985999107361, -0.008172850124537945, -0.003088231896981597, -0.024937547743320465, -0.03179175779223442, 0.04667998105287552, 0.00787271000444889, -0.023842813447117805, -0.07866795361042023, -0.038558002561330795, -0.011314431205391884, 0.0689057856798172, 0.018496951088309288, 0.04713957756757736, -0.000623932050075382, 0.015508651733398438, 0.04037421941757202, 0.057663824409246445, 0.04992983490228653, 0.051829881966114044, 0.02610454522073269, 0.013131537474691868, 0.01481726672500372, -0.03372623026371002, 0.022762907668948174, 0.022151712328195572, 0.02359546534717083, 0.01851590909063816, 0.024247759953141212, -0.01718963496387005, -0.02343689277768135, -0.037920836359262466, 0.026424214243888855, -0.026810595765709877, -0.03249531611800194, -0.017687827348709106, 0.01861310750246048, 0.03788692504167557, -0.055412303656339645, 0.04129403829574585, -0.0016077557811513543, -0.03512895479798317, -0.016368059441447258, -0.025793224573135376, 0.007685958873480558, 0.010870479978621006, 0.0008844218100421131, -0.04896784573793411, 0.025398747995495796, -0.052298638969659805, -0.016394324600696564, 0.04799574613571167, -0.0129672447219491, -0.025655971840023994, 0.00977830309420824, -0.06962087005376816, 0.011313777416944504, 0.06316161900758743, -0.024221369996666908, 0.040885984897613525, -0.005110861733555794, 0.03762844577431679, 0.021369928494095802, 0.012179877609014511, 0.02735380083322525, -0.0057897563092410564, -0.005187561269849539, -0.0064305891282856464, -0.00922099407762289, 0.014254889450967312, 0.02614453062415123, 0.030451182276010513, 0.0006581360357813537, -0.002866687485948205, -0.010633081197738647, -0.058973778039216995, 0.00625351257622242, 0.006740208249539137, -0.09577517956495285, -0.021323036402463913, 0.01422166358679533, -0.060634102672338486, 0.053777437657117844, 0.07899784296751022, 0.02802058681845665, -0.08448274433612823, 0.045424092561006546, -0.007465398404747248, 0.036973267793655396, 0.005278501659631729, 0.010732164606451988, 0.007847549393773079, 0.02806083671748638, 0.03636603802442551, -0.011074790731072426, 0.038400955498218536, -0.011974304914474487, 0.05580246448516846, 0.05747148022055626, -0.017256716266274452, -0.06137759983539581, -0.018730970099568367, 0.018775377422571182, -0.030426355078816414, -0.011305862106382847, -0.028177563101053238, -0.024553291499614716, -0.04275659844279289, -0.0010905629023909569, -0.07533124089241028, 0.015175135806202888, -0.000171486142789945, -0.005123451352119446, 0.012800338678061962, 0.0013952365843579173, 0.015722723677754402, -0.048598434776067734, -0.06164393201470375, 0.021283326670527458, 0.005259228404611349, -0.051813043653964996, 0.001001958386041224, -0.025885367766022682, -0.017393654212355614, -0.04270900785923004, -0.019557200372219086, 0.0007895860471762717, 0.012578661553561687, 0.011890108697116375, -0.07700804620981216, -0.019760016351938248, -0.002104648854583502, 0.025651074945926666, 0.07086232304573059, 0.030478326603770256, -0.03465723991394043, -0.010141612961888313, 0.028318051248788834, 0.04473937675356865, 0.017246123403310776, 0.02701791375875473, -0.03507186472415924, -0.0152725325897336, 0.03250831738114357, -0.01998181827366352, 0.018245643004775047, 0.021725723519921303, 0.05922183394432068, -0.01893649250268936, -0.003488187910988927, -0.03181552514433861, 0.0015441766008734703, 0.04924004524946213, 0.038887664675712585, -0.0025890201795846224, -0.02294662967324257, -0.028817642480134964, -0.003950551152229309, 0.017059626057744026, -0.03108830563724041, -0.04443663731217384, -0.04158686101436615, 0.002877146005630493, -0.051161158829927444, -0.02854970470070839, -0.022224988788366318, -0.03506120666861534, -0.05154707282781601, -0.08406204730272293, 0.005033470224589109, 0.05139800161123276, -0.0030029963236302137, 0.026189273223280907, -0.03173452988266945, -0.05462678521871567, -0.02437555603682995, 0.01839294657111168, -0.015274605713784695, -0.04463690519332886, 0.022349216043949127, 0.01635579764842987, -0.017019718885421753, -0.037029411643743515, 0.0021539535373449326, -0.06944078952074051, 0.0428563617169857, -0.028475316241383553, 0.024436159059405327, 0.03375949338078499, -0.03932513669133186, 0.053395237773656845, 0.04703938588500023, 0.006044309586286545, 0.06973738223314285, 0.004943083040416241, 0.01672968454658985, -0.024032535031437874, 0.040561120957136154, 0.0567726232111454, -0.01734473742544651, -0.024833863601088524, 0.04415678605437279, 0.09200644493103027, -0.0008670990937389433, 0.02753157913684845, 0.015262286178767681, -0.07106570154428482, -0.025125127285718918, 0.0025790161453187466, -0.007822711020708084, -0.016717273741960526, 0.021997841075062752, 0.01763644441962242, -0.07396732270717621, 0.034573912620544434, 0.050917115062475204, 0.0030794194899499416, -0.04326246306300163, -0.012996913865208626, 0.02125965990126133, -0.01825576089322567, 0.0010940622305497527, 0.023398377001285553, -0.014186639338731766, -0.010596302337944508, 0.0591912567615509, 0.021387800574302673, -0.003658940317109227, 0.01775829866528511, -0.05999968573451042, -0.06234734505414963, 0.01565626449882984, -0.007303877733647823, -0.012624301016330719, -0.014224672690033913, -0.009783507324755192, -0.0242339838296175, 0.03504980355501175, 0.015536757186055183, 0.03178660571575165, 0.005352975334972143, -0.051658809185028076, 0.04450215399265289, -0.10858418792486191, 0.03994588926434517, 0.02263706550002098, -0.03388014808297157, 0.058354541659355164, 0.04639154672622681, 0.060042854398489, -0.02180180326104164, -0.04976523667573929, 0.035589076578617096, 0.023420527577400208, 0.009348180145025253, 0.026599831879138947, 0.021918274462223053, 0.039828646928071976, -0.006670328322798014, 0.014112569391727448, 0.08743929862976074, -0.02855321764945984, 0.052979085594415665, 0.006339802872389555, 0.03285962715744972, 0.023882359266281128, -0.0048455409705638885, -0.04743540287017822, 0.06043373420834541, 0.0023920147214084864, 0.003746606642380357, -0.043236590921878815, -0.03956235572695732, -0.02900816686451435, 0.03760864958167076, 0.024261565878987312, -0.058587584644556046, -0.027869245037436485, 0.03486042469739914, 0.00014873086183797568, -0.05714390054345131, -0.03377629071474075, 0.02165145054459572, -0.021366547793149948, 0.0690402165055275, 0.03347957879304886, 0.025302300229668617, 0.024152914062142372, 0.03987051919102669, -0.02125655487179756, -0.024503398686647415, 0.022989844903349876, 0.04482262209057808, -0.04551073536276817, 0.008953935466706753, 0.044343896210193634, -0.0928969755768776, 0.011811183765530586, -0.011698746122419834, -0.0446932315826416, -0.02117280103266239, -0.022772666066884995, -0.0506417341530323, 0.011850210838019848, 0.044445399194955826, -0.03782538324594498, -0.02167998068034649, 0.04014042764902115, 0.005223848856985569, -0.0156381968408823, -0.016797039657831192, 0.05844820290803909, 0.032905250787734985, -0.0043782563880085945, 0.021745778620243073, -0.04893786460161209, 0.0658387616276741, -0.031115876510739326, -0.01342001836746931, -0.006385917775332928, -0.04408140107989311, -0.010255417786538601, -0.014491482637822628, 0.025415755808353424, 0.006600684951990843, 0.06705895811319351, -0.08100339025259018, 0.017394516617059708, 0.002229419769719243, 0.057230833917856216, -0.05271368473768234, 0.05975367873907089, 0.022336149588227272, 0.017350343987345695, 0.010769379325211048, -0.05189059302210808, 0.034882158041000366, -0.05802776664495468, 0.044651295989751816, 0.07049667090177536, 0.015093263238668442, 0.037154488265514374, 0.020116332918405533, -0.024522656574845314, -0.009297719225287437, 0.0055511509999632835, -0.007832163013517857, 0.029611332342028618, -0.008085506968200207, 0.019699398428201675, -0.012206108309328556, -0.02431187592446804, -0.021694209426641464, 0.003676247550174594, 0.005927862133830786, 0.004434296395629644, -0.05878462642431259, 0.026244420558214188, 0.030037812888622284, -0.005210597533732653, 0.0036703674122691154, 0.00126257527153939, 0.030851885676383972, 0.009114283137023449, 0.03853737190365791, -0.05081215128302574, 0.0039755236357450485, 0.016121242195367813, -0.020039578899741173, -0.04614337533712387, -0.012865208089351654, 0.006135862786322832, 0.003551130648702383, 0.019884204491972923, -0.0037441542372107506, -0.013957285322248936, -0.01556428987532854, 0.000857769453432411, -0.010654835030436516, 0.010797426104545593, -0.040277156978845596, 0.01077690627425909, 0.02174094319343567, -0.055301375687122345, 0.019142257049679756, -0.013284426182508469, 0.028140468522906303, -0.02406805008649826, 0.021564530208706856, -0.023161448538303375, -0.0036863372661173344, 0.026836249977350235, 0.012165886349976063, 0.003057484282180667, 0.03379227593541145, 0.0032875232864171267, -0.004051600582897663, -5.6813397869927696e-33, 0.014687185175716877, 0.021578775718808174, -0.00478841969743371, -0.026770683005452156, -0.061914488673210144, 0.019183415919542313, 0.012128016911447048, -0.005601071286946535, 0.004783565178513527, -0.0017329637194052339, -0.03948948532342911, 0.01879948563873768, 0.025147125124931335, 0.034301530569791794, -0.025210438296198845, -0.0012470613000914454, 0.07799781113862991, -0.03445318341255188, 0.07061454653739929, 0.031119659543037415, 0.04422358423471451, 0.04481909051537514, 0.049694981426000595, -0.02021944709122181, -0.050928305834531784, -0.01464321929961443, -0.0007108962745405734, -0.03780949115753174, 0.029626494273543358, -0.004758884664624929, -0.008682962507009506, 0.029458869248628616, -0.022644750773906708, -0.0425761379301548, -0.002703247359022498, 0.048480626195669174, -0.08065155893564224, -0.027147289365530014, -0.047959983348846436, 0.0508122444152832, -0.028640249744057655, 0.000908021698705852, 0.06700678914785385, 0.04321381449699402, -0.03754640370607376, 0.0007502051303163171, 0.042732421308755875, -0.02808660827577114, -0.009230495430529118, -0.09025733917951584, -0.047585368156433105, 0.043321337550878525, 0.002341351006180048, -0.02408747188746929, 0.02427339367568493, 0.06749016791582108, -0.02137628197669983, -0.05678621307015419, -0.11011745035648346, 0.021228237077593803, 0.00421483488753438, 0.020920690149068832, 0.023495623841881752, 0.028493087738752365, 0.002823928836733103, 0.027197768911719322, 0.050961386412382126, -0.06426852196455002, 0.0024516794364899397, 0.023200055584311485, 0.032944563776254654, 0.042571209371089935, 0.04878498986363411, -0.026728635653853416, 0.05611716955900192, -0.07203551381826401, -0.021391451358795166, -0.0004395329160615802, -0.005829645786434412, -0.07806306332349777, 0.04391485080122948, 0.021661529317498207, -0.04784316569566727, 0.0034617427736520767, -0.01769430562853813, 0.0015633126022294164, -0.014792115427553654, -0.024142641574144363, 0.030461683869361877, 0.010204063728451729, 0.030607614666223526, -0.021964887157082558, 0.02194582112133503, -0.01751643233001232, 0.05210892856121063, -0.042126111686229706, -0.04698431119322777, -0.01218142919242382, -0.0028536133468151093, -0.0007288085180334747, -0.04599824920296669, -0.036163341253995895, 0.04149702191352844, 0.07241138070821762, 0.026896800845861435, 0.008819674141705036, 0.0025474175345152617, 0.05830392241477966, -0.03911997005343437, -0.0008411514572799206, 0.016025714576244354, 0.032274357974529266, 0.03152115270495415, 0.06585896015167236, 0.019899411126971245, -0.04267614334821701, -0.009126650169491768, 0.05113261938095093, -0.02436359040439129, -0.0157544557005167, -0.010816738940775394, -0.024424158036708832, -0.004180597141385078, 0.021025311201810837, -0.08983281254768372, 0.03286462649703026, -0.03322304040193558, 0.0195839311927557, 0.05763934925198555, -0.04703053832054138, -0.02388455905020237, 0.004636416677385569, 2.76124836773306e-07, -0.0455811433494091, -0.04680921137332916, 0.03327680006623268, -0.022747568786144257, 0.011749908328056335, -0.0034822532907128334, 0.03541913628578186, 0.026985011994838715, -0.02129644900560379, 0.029528912156820297, 0.021663431078195572, -0.06461180746555328, 0.05561458319425583, 0.04784512519836426, -0.10612991452217102, -0.04946824163198471, -0.09195791929960251, 0.018821803852915764, -0.010039818473160267, 0.04809732362627983, 0.03518454357981682, 0.07729444652795792, 0.0082232765853405, -0.07404246181249619, 0.04674556478857994, 0.02620036154985428, -0.017481960356235504, 0.029514335095882416, 0.036361213773489, -0.017655981704592705, 0.043287381529808044, -0.018318597227334976, -0.02168026752769947, -0.0128998514264822, -0.05007554590702057, 0.02342865988612175, 0.03773912414908409, 0.012847360223531723, -0.023316115140914917, -0.030946411192417145, 0.0135341826826334, 0.012115678749978542, -0.01544619258493185, 0.007588074076920748, 0.031290698796510696, 0.030788665637373924, -0.02508595585823059, -0.05747328698635101, 0.02904842235147953, 0.007048888131976128, -0.027695000171661377, -0.005246711894869804, 0.04263276234269142, -0.03134835138916969, -0.008770469576120377, -0.035969823598861694, -0.019509203732013702, -0.05415754392743111, -0.036032721400260925, -0.0012883342569693923, -0.05084909498691559, -0.0281070489436388, -0.04393690079450607, -0.003747859038412571, 0.024944860488176346, 0.020174778997898102, -0.0009937759023159742, 2.252973824538853e-34, -0.009098043665289879, -0.025210266932845116, -0.00349601567722857, -0.009415645152330399, -0.007572721689939499, -0.00017632436356507242, 0.06761715561151505, 0.00684734620153904, 0.011046973057091236, -0.019540837034583092, -0.09088446199893951]
631
631
['Zichao Yang', 'Zhiting Hu', 'Ruslan Salakhutdinov', 'Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick']
1702.08139v2
Recent work on generative modeling of text has found that variational auto-encoders (VAE) incorporating LSTM decoders perform worse than simpler LSTM language models (Bowman et al., 2015). This negative result is so far poorly understood, but has been attributed to the propensity of LSTM decoders to ignore conditioning information from the encoder. In this paper, we experiment with a new type of decoder for VAE: a dilated CNN. By changing the decoder's dilation architecture, we control the effective context from previously generated words. In experiments, we find that there is a trade off between the contextual capacity of the decoder and the amount of encoding information used. We show that with the right decoder, VAE can outperform LSTM language models. We demonstrate perplexity gains on two datasets, representing the first positive experimental result on the use VAE for generative modeling of text. Further, we conduct an in-depth investigation of the use of VAE (with our new decoding architecture) for semi-supervised and unsupervised labeling tasks, demonstrating gains over several strong baselines.
Improved Variational Autoencoders for Text Modeling using Dilated Convolutions
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1702.08139v2
Title Improved Variational Autoencoders Text Modeling using Dilated Convolutions Summary Recent work generative modeling text found variational autoencoders VAE incorporating LSTM decoder perform worse simpler LSTM language model Bowman et al 2015 negative result far poorly understood attributed propensity LSTM decoder ignore conditioning information encoder paper experiment new type decoder VAE dilated CNN changing decoder dilation architecture control effective context previously generated word experiment find trade contextual capacity decoder amount encoding information used show right decoder VAE outperform LSTM language model demonstrate perplexity gain two datasets representing first positive experimental result use VAE generative modeling text conduct indepth investigation use VAE new decoding architecture semisupervised unsupervised labeling task demonstrating gain several strong baseline Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.031139275059103966, 0.08634331822395325, -0.017654934898018837, 0.04814178869128227, -0.019941547885537148, 0.008397197350859642, 0.024982603266835213, -0.0009738968801684678, -0.06876417994499207, -0.0027986273635178804, -0.01723877340555191, -0.04735134541988373, -0.016995685175061226, 0.08497116714715958, 0.029974274337291718, -0.06995140016078949, 0.008329715579748154, 0.00674284715205431, -0.005609680898487568, -0.03268841654062271, 0.016469867900013924, -0.004548820201307535, 0.007043746300041676, 0.017710164189338684, 0.005214586853981018, 0.013783304020762444, -0.014526110142469406, 0.012323245406150818, 0.015920981764793396, 0.010783822275698185, 0.03183920681476593, 0.06901846081018448, 0.0625222772359848, 0.018903465941548347, 2.5080673822230892e-06, 0.012891294434666634, -0.02094847522675991, -0.017994150519371033, -0.03729454055428505, -0.0008012294420041144, 0.10372312366962433, -0.05937838926911354, -0.005108989775180817, 0.013266172260046005, -0.016769712790846825, -0.08309315145015717, 0.033979497849941254, 0.02991972491145134, 0.013537682592868805, 0.061586085706949234, -0.01871965453028679, -0.05986759811639786, 0.04589246213436127, -0.07229270786046982, 0.04907158762216568, -0.07332761585712433, 0.040541648864746094, 0.01923757791519165, -0.018510624766349792, 0.0378594845533371, -0.06115810200572014, 0.04422842711210251, 0.07821913808584213, -0.011051985435187817, 0.024416927248239517, 0.046165116131305695, 0.031881608068943024, -0.025674181059002876, -0.018504738807678223, 0.04681706055998802, 0.010624002665281296, -0.04108541086316109, -0.011927491053938866, -0.009603410959243774, -0.060437992215156555, -0.01052068267017603, -0.020466098561882973, 0.05053577572107315, 0.01858457922935486, 0.0051940144039690495, 0.0004831048718187958, 0.05531202256679535, 0.00981959979981184, 0.014659014530479908, -0.00078078598016873, -0.03403932601213455, 0.06063734367489815, -0.023318607360124588, -0.03375452384352684, 0.009012839756906033, -0.01804550550878048, -0.045736875385046005, 0.03438669443130493, -0.005535887088626623, 0.005221501924097538, 0.0013012568233534694, -0.055994048714637756, -0.1144595518708229, 0.003266002982854843, -0.00625543761998415, 0.004023335408419371, 0.010057030245661736, -0.039811328053474426, 0.006886247545480728, -0.01870020665228367, 0.034451618790626526, -0.03993465006351471, 0.036665551364421844, -0.06950479000806808, -0.025751786306500435, 0.0015027244808152318, -0.01294388435781002, -0.02876211516559124, -0.0050377314910292625, -0.03892975673079491, -0.06572358310222626, -0.05093074217438698, -0.001618679496459663, 0.009055224247276783, -0.0014595285756513476, 0.008225786499679089, 0.05450672283768654, -0.04974399134516716, -0.027357609942555428, 0.02600971981883049, 0.017392577603459358, -0.047028835862874985, 0.03858324512839317, -0.016230730339884758, -0.021380949765443802, 0.01512905303388834, 0.03704836964607239, 0.05480939894914627, -0.0373929888010025, -0.007002322934567928, 0.024789579212665558, -0.017404571175575256, -0.01671442948281765, -0.028671344742178917, 0.026410125195980072, -0.04846211150288582, -0.00497558806091547, -0.017898574471473694, -0.06563858687877655, 0.006691968999803066, -0.0033351117745041847, 0.013109620660543442, -0.033701036125421524, -0.022045599296689034, -0.004511404316872358, -0.028516096994280815, 0.08823873847723007, -0.01637841761112213, -0.0009190451237373054, 0.07293564081192017, 0.009681381285190582, 0.11269768327474594, 0.014683103188872337, 0.031223563477396965, 0.04556610435247421, 0.00039417107473127544, -0.009267949499189854, 0.004003199283033609, 0.054757654666900635, 0.021465735509991646, -0.025065939873456955, -0.0744732916355133, -0.026092160493135452, -0.037030331790447235, -0.006281419191509485, 0.05992184579372406, 0.06946054846048355, -0.03947041183710098, -0.012935864739120007, 0.042688287794589996, 0.03202785179018974, 0.010906577110290527, 0.023538246750831604, 0.03386649489402771, 0.019372418522834778, -0.012910029850900173, 0.0016449845861643553, 0.014257646165788174, 0.03930802270770073, 0.015356463380157948, 0.009739537723362446, 0.01938845030963421, -0.021383844316005707, -0.017562268301844597, -0.04436736926436424, 0.006145075429230928, -0.024198757484555244, 0.0476049967110157, -0.022822709754109383, 0.06033524125814438, 0.036155711859464645, -0.047315310686826706, -0.01824515499174595, 0.0216448325663805, -0.015332701615989208, 0.01404485385864973, -0.011315422132611275, 0.006911823991686106, 0.04327387362718582, 0.07240098714828491, 0.03293560445308685, 0.004316139966249466, -0.020789511501789093, -0.02470441535115242, 0.052328865975141525, 0.02871246635913849, -0.000767944089602679, -0.015161641873419285, -0.0789380744099617, -0.035159043967723846, -0.03214132413268089, 0.03131381794810295, 0.02754559926688671, -0.01640588790178299, 0.017347490414977074, 0.03935331106185913, -0.012513905763626099, 0.021627141162753105, 0.05308832973241806, -0.020249951630830765, -0.005120919551700354, 0.027230137959122658, 0.013875840231776237, 0.01627763733267784, 0.027194438502192497, -0.027819665148854256, 0.014985863119363785, 0.033581558614969254, -0.0751025527715683, -0.03485485538840294, -0.012403784319758415, -0.05229589343070984, -0.07791366428136826, -0.015563332475721836, -0.046632081270217896, 0.013180715031921864, 0.015489572659134865, -0.03614359721541405, -0.049800481647253036, 0.03688754886388779, -0.0266904104501009, -0.001432235585525632, -0.03902469947934151, -0.018990661948919296, -0.000973059213720262, 0.006501949392259121, -0.02131342701613903, 0.05832616239786148, -0.02382522076368332, 0.03030957654118538, 0.0022919694893062115, 0.05919963866472244, 0.04521981626749039, -0.011472336016595364, -0.019004834815859795, -0.027527524158358574, -0.011706485413014889, -0.0034819741267710924, 0.028488557785749435, 0.008940820582211018, 0.011976022273302078, -0.011376194655895233, -0.09036103636026382, -0.007942994125187397, -0.03500667214393616, -0.01325147319585085, 0.031014366075396538, 0.05057142674922943, 0.0030549156945198774, -0.0021662041544914246, -0.016943400725722313, 0.006573969963937998, 0.013040606863796711, -0.005843308754265308, 0.02045099064707756, -0.018152784556150436, 0.03958911821246147, -0.032064903527498245, -0.03390807285904884, 0.017866434529423714, 0.03477931767702103, 0.006927446462213993, -0.035551317036151886, 0.0017115747323259711, 0.0286165289580822, 0.01204594224691391, 0.002456552581861615, -0.011436562053859234, -0.05881510302424431, -0.01100490428507328, -0.027475936338305473, 0.07409201562404633, 0.024568308144807816, 0.04080921411514282, 0.026803208515048027, 0.006633118260651827, 0.03544703498482704, -0.028677163645625114, 0.020752593874931335, -0.05823223665356636, -0.008798673748970032, -0.024816161021590233, -0.04550947993993759, 0.012946831993758678, 0.062329404056072235, 0.054748356342315674, 0.029135454446077347, -0.05396172031760216, 0.017903078347444534, -0.02121935598552227, -0.03434906527400017, -0.008810916915535927, -0.01063851173967123, -0.02428758330643177, 0.05152491107583046, -0.037462685257196426, -0.01098725851625204, 0.04644171521067619, 0.003183146705850959, -0.01875988207757473, -0.06153290718793869, 0.012761727906763554, -0.01706845313310623, 0.0486169196665287, 0.05923433601856232, 0.030109137296676636, -0.016474036499857903, -0.013191468082368374, -0.020363520830869675, 0.048745471984148026, 0.0015066292835399508, 0.0008409543079324067, 0.04112423583865166, -0.003933988977223635, 0.0033814520575106144, 0.015362078323960304, -0.024325715377926826, -0.06250633299350739, -0.03979036211967468, 0.001155401929281652, -0.0029903135728091, 0.09751014411449432, -0.003392576240003109, -0.02291707694530487, 0.011268270201981068, -0.0013833624543622136, 0.07075978815555573, -0.02949516847729683, 0.019414979964494705, -0.006439971271902323, 0.06241971254348755, 0.09275653958320618, -0.02685837633907795, -0.04518962651491165, -0.03581840172410011, -0.03278186172246933, 0.03423985838890076, -0.01982308179140091, 0.023879969492554665, -0.02908421866595745, 0.01913008652627468, 0.01769605651497841, -0.003272963222116232, 0.011241298168897629, 0.012719199061393738, 0.03336907923221588, -0.04199545085430145, -0.02582656592130661, 0.11610660701990128, 0.012878680601716042, -0.09087862074375153, -0.00302272941917181, -0.04807114228606224, 0.034563083201646805, -0.001196398981846869, 0.004320768639445305, -0.07467924803495407, -0.018027454614639282, -0.03211085498332977, 0.01593986712396145, 0.008703205734491348, 0.006145615596324205, -0.010761067271232605, -0.06613172590732574, 0.030611947178840637, -0.006601245142519474, -0.007461951579898596, 0.0033473114017397165, -0.03497118502855301, -0.027029870077967644, -0.03538407012820244, 0.015493243932723999, -0.000544940703548491, 0.037072643637657166, 0.010318826884031296, 0.035458799451589584, 0.011692807078361511, -0.06844314187765121, -0.04301910474896431, -0.04389747977256775, 0.06085949391126633, 0.08989942073822021, 0.017311930656433105, -0.050189413130283356, -0.01961054839193821, 0.0031405796762555838, -0.0509490892291069, -0.02289687655866146, -0.01634911261498928, 0.08367177844047546, -0.01759820245206356, 0.001950578298419714, -0.009690972045063972, 0.05765123665332794, -0.035966165363788605, -0.015335222706198692, -0.006085959728807211, -0.02886039949953556, 0.006363098509609699, -0.033892903476953506, -0.053629178553819656, -0.021121297031641006, -0.017680365592241287, 0.05274813994765282, 0.048004500567913055, -0.033971887081861496, -0.0027965870685875416, -0.03222180902957916, 0.05775437131524086, -0.07353562116622925, -0.030391162261366844, -0.014893291518092155, 0.011612785048782825, -0.08893442153930664, -0.06005644425749779, -0.022188499569892883, -0.027518529444932938, 0.0034968324471265078, -0.0003413122904021293, 0.014967183582484722, 0.021553220227360725, -0.04300718754529953, -0.048600006848573685, -0.05091017857193947, 0.030240444466471672, 0.03172910585999489, -0.034015804529190063, -0.005372324027121067, 0.013224137015640736, -0.0560089573264122, -0.02225220948457718, -0.0289390180259943, -0.10862759500741959, -0.02078106626868248, 0.0020488693844527006, 0.043885860592126846, 0.010995956137776375, 0.06170528382062912, -0.04785814881324768, -0.05525656044483185, 0.023338066413998604, 0.0019041894702240825, 0.003805760061368346, 0.009838373400270939, -0.018269646912813187, -0.010401299223303795, 0.010509917512536049, 0.011231149546802044, -0.02109597623348236, 0.05368724465370178, 0.008587704040110111, 0.011159127578139305, -0.013447992503643036, -0.0341336689889431, -0.009443029761314392, -0.04502397030591965, 0.0029298074077814817, -0.011265725828707218, 0.020781828090548515, -0.047970257699489594, 0.016270725056529045, -0.018575863912701607, -0.004040769301354885, -0.0561477430164814, 0.004406541585922241, 0.07440009713172913, 0.026556581258773804, -0.04537707194685936, 0.01503652986139059, 0.008115931414067745, 0.034493107348680496, -0.027075063437223434, 0.04480084031820297, 0.00855474267154932, 0.034635547548532486, -0.001726361457258463, 0.010305378586053848, -0.009797313250601292, 0.010804117657244205, 0.001099772984161973, 0.05644720792770386, -0.029669564217329025, 0.026900436729192734, 0.016575930640101433, -0.020333370193839073, -0.015032513998448849, 0.03358814865350723, -0.035931143909692764, -0.0068223378621041775, -0.07600243389606476, 0.026991819962859154, 0.013524780981242657, -0.024595893919467926, 0.060446206480264664, -0.03685365617275238, 0.014134231023490429, -0.03180713206529617, 0.024137074127793312, -0.009037713520228863, -0.0335715189576149, 0.036189399659633636, 0.0007632508059032261, 0.001901758834719658, -0.028649911284446716, 0.07213319838047028, 0.050727877765893936, 0.01949678733944893, -0.004080991260707378, -0.036529675126075745, -0.04336678236722946, 0.027259906753897667, -0.004708849824965, 0.04992659017443657, -0.02478325180709362, 0.03057936765253544, 0.0006072151591069996, -0.05614861845970154, 0.006874380633234978, 0.004163401201367378, 0.04662688449025154, -0.023119917139410973, 0.016359874978661537, 0.027202347293496132, -0.0277359951287508, -0.017710987478494644, -0.019524769857525826, 0.03158493712544441, 0.01995152421295643, -0.04277985915541649, -0.06029760465025902, -7.176831618099716e-33, -0.015272383578121662, -0.024295633658766747, -0.006304244045168161, -0.10158053785562515, -0.02037855237722397, 0.02995116077363491, -0.07947231084108353, -0.021632974967360497, 0.008808174170553684, 0.021199136972427368, 0.02228316105902195, 0.005898450966924429, 0.010720353573560715, 0.07114706188440323, 0.030712217092514038, -0.013974159955978394, 0.05565490946173668, -0.017963692545890808, 0.035221900790929794, 0.019238250330090523, -0.0344218946993351, 0.048135776072740555, 0.05662469565868378, -0.06516534090042114, 0.025673866271972656, -0.007154427003115416, 0.00926914531737566, -0.005702261347323656, 0.04555360972881317, 0.03995346650481224, -0.0414099395275116, 0.012871766462922096, 0.020102484151721, -0.015352854505181313, -0.02096698060631752, -0.025365201756358147, -0.08817468583583832, -0.027086907997727394, -0.016770891845226288, 0.029127512127161026, -0.03726411983370781, 0.00962093099951744, 0.060431208461523056, -0.003598681651055813, 0.0033074079547077417, 0.025364086031913757, 0.05175615847110748, -0.025433329865336418, -0.025725698098540306, -0.03789143264293671, -0.08491672575473785, 0.034228935837745667, 0.00629616342484951, -0.017340412363409996, 0.03948255628347397, -0.034054625779390335, -0.013378010131418705, 0.05014442652463913, -0.05213227868080139, 0.007081460207700729, 0.019865047186613083, 0.029192840680480003, 0.05415479838848114, 0.02629151940345764, -0.008304329589009285, 0.010911940596997738, 0.016251806169748306, -0.008443234488368034, -0.08125025779008865, -0.014340158551931381, 0.035980984568595886, 0.04075923189520836, 0.033691901713609695, 0.05125921219587326, 0.06310507655143738, -0.02641231380403042, -0.03683356195688248, 0.04652098938822746, -0.04241805151104927, 0.025606054812669754, 0.03721657395362854, 0.04325577989220619, -0.033240217715501785, -0.03603172302246094, -0.011837356723845005, -0.037814829498529434, -0.02313816361129284, -0.023447711020708084, 0.0075874729081988335, 0.0006114153657108545, -0.029920803382992744, -0.025665178894996643, 0.013883966021239758, -0.03210468217730522, -0.009300553239881992, 0.036357276141643524, -0.013402917422354221, 0.04983874410390854, -0.000423533987486735, 0.015023772604763508, -0.07556723803281784, 0.004475052934139967, 0.03046656772494316, 0.011060996912419796, -0.04057743772864342, 0.009052492678165436, 0.02137778326869011, 0.000627927016466856, -0.011597268283367157, -0.02075350284576416, -0.022168157622218132, -0.02795133739709854, 0.02053202874958515, 0.061743900179862976, 0.008772945031523705, 0.018831506371498108, -0.0205752681940794, 0.05915234610438347, 0.044257573783397675, 0.004379505291581154, -0.012900954112410545, -0.053173333406448364, 0.0651869922876358, 0.034988317638635635, -0.04932707920670509, -0.006316880229860544, -0.016013605520129204, 0.007917792536318302, 0.03415350615978241, -0.07155987620353699, -0.004468762315809727, 0.012381162494421005, 2.93186815270019e-07, 0.0900454968214035, 0.03283306211233139, 0.06677398830652237, 4.7718760470161214e-05, 0.024895794689655304, 0.02577287331223488, 0.008632308803498745, 0.03726488724350929, -0.03471897542476654, -0.02664763480424881, 0.03208819404244423, 0.023236943408846855, 0.04442005231976509, -0.011966506950557232, -0.010514694266021252, 0.02471219189465046, -0.048047758638858795, -0.0052872407250106335, -0.018301695585250854, 0.004684122279286385, 0.08002365380525589, 0.08188047260046005, 0.018823105841875076, -0.02393478900194168, 0.06184937804937363, 0.019901959225535393, 0.0485767237842083, -0.006643061991780996, 0.011231173761188984, 0.0374230332672596, 0.0024033691734075546, 0.00014644506154581904, -0.010091014206409454, -0.00828932598233223, -0.023858077824115753, -0.0028029554523527622, 0.038895491510629654, 0.03141390532255173, -0.021604355424642563, -0.03033834882080555, -0.011627611704170704, -0.012629078701138496, 0.001988957868888974, -0.06578914821147919, 0.05411149188876152, -0.01038574893027544, -0.0199907124042511, 0.0012698570499196649, -0.03482899069786072, 0.059112463146448135, 0.022867728024721146, -0.01293457206338644, -0.03610894829034805, 0.0021304104011505842, 0.03187752887606621, 0.0019955227617174387, -0.04563845694065094, -0.06449149549007416, -0.00830095075070858, -0.024875719100236893, -0.06112797185778618, 0.018816137686371803, -0.06660360097885132, 0.01584167405962944, 0.03617085516452789, -0.003401785157620907, -0.013225737027823925, 3.0831504090065255e-34, 0.029723219573497772, 0.025791259482502937, -0.03678163141012192, 0.016828220337629318, -0.007579268887639046, -0.007764045614749193, 0.02156667225062847, 0.010815481655299664, -0.03377331420779228, -0.08352956175804138, -0.05649135634303093]
632
632
['Hairong Liu', 'Zhenyao Zhu', 'Xiangang Li', 'Sanjeev Satheesh']
1703.00096v2
Most existing sequence labelling models rely on a fixed decomposition of a target sequence into a sequence of basic units. These methods suffer from two major drawbacks: 1) the set of basic units is fixed, such as the set of words, characters or phonemes in speech recognition, and 2) the decomposition of target sequences is fixed. These drawbacks usually result in sub-optimal performance of modeling sequences. In this pa- per, we extend the popular CTC loss criterion to alleviate these limitations, and propose a new loss function called Gram-CTC. While preserving the advantages of CTC, Gram-CTC automatically learns the best set of basic units (grams), as well as the most suitable decomposition of tar- get sequences. Unlike CTC, Gram-CTC allows the model to output variable number of characters at each time step, which enables the model to capture longer term dependency and improves the computational efficiency. We demonstrate that the proposed Gram-CTC improves CTC in terms of both performance and efficiency on the large vocabulary speech recognition task at multiple scales of data, and that with Gram-CTC we can outperform the state-of-the-art on a standard speech benchmark.
Gram-CTC: Automatic Unit Selection and Target Decomposition for Sequence Labelling
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1703.00096v2
Title GramCTC Automatic Unit Selection Target Decomposition Sequence Labelling Summary existing sequence labelling model rely fixed decomposition target sequence sequence basic unit method suffer two major drawback 1 set basic unit fixed set word character phoneme speech recognition 2 decomposition target sequence fixed drawback usually result suboptimal performance modeling sequence pa per extend popular CTC loss criterion alleviate limitation propose new loss function called GramCTC preserving advantage CTC GramCTC automatically learns best set basic unit gram well suitable decomposition tar get sequence Unlike CTC GramCTC allows model output variable number character time step enables model capture longer term dependency improves computational efficiency demonstrate proposed GramCTC improves CTC term performance efficiency large vocabulary speech recognition task multiple scale data GramCTC outperform stateoftheart standard speech benchmark Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.029830938205122948, 0.04454585537314415, 0.034033939242362976, 0.027482159435749054, -0.016133543103933334, 0.0429430790245533, 0.019833918660879135, 0.0166368018835783, -0.020888321101665497, -0.02717079408466816, -0.000637555553112179, -0.029659390449523926, 0.0503210611641407, 0.0027869197074323893, -0.012183088809251785, -0.03943726047873497, 0.013752523809671402, -0.019913941621780396, -0.021907595917582512, 0.03690272197127342, 0.007233833894133568, 0.016051357612013817, -0.03217029944062233, 0.040275655686855316, -0.03643817454576492, 0.007531440816819668, 0.024126436561346054, -0.022279221564531326, -0.0033315070904791355, -0.07730484008789062, 0.033075012266635895, 0.04281480982899666, -0.02325807511806488, 0.03863067179918289, 2.2163881112646777e-06, -0.04109713062644005, -0.03972133994102478, 0.001470579532906413, -0.05386749655008316, 0.007226557936519384, 0.04307315871119499, 0.009228148497641087, -0.03542586788535118, 0.01924523524940014, -0.017181385308504105, 0.01285176444798708, 0.06305620074272156, 0.05357668548822403, -0.01713162288069725, 0.08459905534982681, -0.0190589539706707, -0.10144446790218353, -0.038821280002593994, -0.015182636678218842, -0.03737727925181389, -0.017383741214871407, -0.004037439823150635, 0.03143744543194771, 0.0171222947537899, -0.008704768493771553, 0.017974333837628365, 0.03241588547825813, -0.04852309823036194, -0.03472425788640976, 0.008264390751719475, 0.033978529274463654, -0.02065012976527214, -0.05848734453320503, 0.014372467994689941, 0.03641394525766373, -0.0053227245807647705, -0.0029566583689302206, 0.04400046914815903, 0.021329252049326897, -0.01285506971180439, -0.04412108659744263, -0.05337284505367279, -0.023051658645272255, -0.017024381086230278, 0.015180593356490135, 0.030013801530003548, 0.05073154717683792, -0.013553290627896786, -0.019036173820495605, -0.01670197769999504, -0.0024397196248173714, -0.008875961415469646, -0.021563824266195297, 0.006501307711005211, -0.01644974946975708, -0.039783649146556854, -0.02808820642530918, 0.04573182389140129, 0.0011574423406273127, -0.026399219408631325, -0.019539209082722664, -0.003522187005728483, -0.0709846243262291, 0.010427427478134632, -0.07046053558588028, -0.0007950094877742231, 0.0024337470531463623, 0.015070071443915367, 0.04049241542816162, -0.007234215270727873, 0.04077480360865593, 0.020239602774381638, -0.03137936443090439, -0.05270461365580559, -0.009181231260299683, -0.05697528272867203, -0.005431785713881254, -0.046901896595954895, 0.09409911185503006, 0.024280477315187454, -0.006223168224096298, -0.07682245224714279, -0.028118936344981194, 0.05467401444911957, 0.003217075252905488, 0.06737878918647766, -0.016590379178524017, -0.017047837376594543, -0.013868115842342377, 0.05877435579895973, 0.015373424626886845, -0.034683454781770706, 0.007477357052266598, -0.03324321284890175, -0.04441508278250694, -0.02163541503250599, 0.023652123287320137, 0.02737291343510151, 0.004070822149515152, 0.03116527386009693, 0.057897839695215225, -0.01784357987344265, -0.0726078674197197, -0.04068560153245926, -0.026874015107750893, -0.05750827118754387, -0.0298098623752594, -0.07093295454978943, -0.046580083668231964, -9.9052136647515e-05, 0.01263074018061161, 0.0027997998986393213, 0.018928708508610725, 0.007796765770763159, -0.02137233316898346, 0.0028012983966618776, 0.07926290482282639, 0.02065751515328884, -0.021970007568597794, 0.07647326588630676, 0.010081672109663486, 0.0652213916182518, 0.024226726964116096, 0.02620439976453781, 0.016166307032108307, 0.0378841757774353, -0.033153265714645386, -0.018472760915756226, 0.0415610633790493, -0.024091437458992004, -0.04992208257317543, -0.01637655682861805, -0.03652985394001007, 0.050103895366191864, 0.0192817784845829, 0.035245317965745926, 0.06878804415464401, 0.0016980738146230578, -0.015176700428128242, 0.04184916988015175, 0.06250829249620438, 0.02823646552860737, 0.010039497166872025, -0.0023609353229403496, 0.014159373007714748, 0.003636513836681843, 0.011081079952418804, 0.019709067419171333, -0.02299310266971588, -0.028163013979792595, -0.010670271702110767, 0.019671857357025146, -0.01189176645129919, -0.011793216690421104, -0.03632068634033203, -0.03005053661763668, -0.0381530299782753, 0.00962603185325861, -0.04542597010731697, 0.044053349643945694, 0.025590455159544945, -0.05136307701468468, 0.03353869542479515, 0.011139711365103722, -0.04837490990757942, -0.044875506311655045, -0.0011407771380618215, 0.011198137886822224, -0.03640686348080635, 0.06929029524326324, -0.04839928448200226, -0.010992065072059631, -0.03523335978388786, -0.026675065979361534, 0.017557714134454727, 0.02832954376935959, -0.048455629497766495, -0.004425056744366884, -0.09849769622087479, 0.02625400759279728, 0.08968713134527206, -0.038024332374334335, 0.0034206463024020195, -0.01277083344757557, 0.046545661985874176, 0.021129852160811424, 0.030237631872296333, -0.0034555967431515455, 0.02610708959400654, 0.032316941767930984, -0.08328143507242203, 0.020259100943803787, -0.013497879728674889, 0.06818193197250366, 0.04092187061905861, 0.007218923885375261, -0.0006968512898311019, 0.02926524542272091, -0.016805129125714302, 0.020888417959213257, -0.0026825570967048407, -0.09666577726602554, -0.07027648389339447, 0.05089177191257477, 0.007026452571153641, 0.0012811063788831234, 0.05603207275271416, 0.019386185333132744, -0.06226867437362671, 0.0008559148409403861, -0.03876414895057678, 0.010923105292022228, -0.027339033782482147, 0.09056685864925385, 0.010463783517479897, 0.020337063819169998, 0.0048301643691957, 0.029667478054761887, 0.007043073885142803, -0.02011140249669552, 0.011201058514416218, -0.002378882607445121, 0.00431448919698596, -0.0277672428637743, -0.025937246158719063, 0.0574447363615036, -0.009048141539096832, -0.039095304906368256, -0.0015516298590227962, 0.01192685030400753, -0.003355950117111206, -0.011363978497684002, -0.09082459658384323, -0.007662166375666857, -0.0032930581364780664, 0.018779713660478592, -0.02527388371527195, -0.0005970592610538006, 0.030582360923290253, -0.027590952813625336, -0.017265185713768005, 0.017864316701889038, -0.006596386898308992, -0.01674513705074787, -0.004538505803793669, -0.0023009013384580612, -0.03621823713183403, -0.05066791549324989, -0.00851527601480484, 0.014079699292778969, 0.06265585124492645, 0.00924654956907034, -0.10746978223323822, -0.04166974499821663, 0.03429783508181572, 0.03082488290965557, 0.032369475811719894, -0.002887001261115074, -0.035066455602645874, -0.02937927655875683, -0.008593620732426643, 0.010760574601590633, -0.0010926115792244673, 0.03132941201329231, 0.023422161117196083, -0.023526344448328018, -0.0006240405491553247, 0.014080960303544998, -0.03171011433005333, -0.012520515359938145, 0.06586635112762451, -0.015249725431203842, 0.012277690693736076, 0.007060130592435598, 0.13622093200683594, 0.01503527071326971, 0.06021210923790932, -0.0012002321891486645, -0.04203072190284729, -0.06676901876926422, -0.005880279932171106, -0.031465984880924225, -0.01831810362637043, -0.04979351535439491, -0.046984244138002396, 0.0326865129172802, -0.008778728544712067, 0.02893878147006035, -0.06769007444381714, -0.07449053227901459, -0.07565724104642868, -0.0544419139623642, -0.02503425069153309, 0.05905657634139061, 0.006685046479105949, 0.011868149042129517, -0.014733051881194115, -0.07359661161899567, -0.012710227631032467, 0.021184297278523445, 0.013386871665716171, -0.059207938611507416, 0.04785433039069176, -0.022984912618994713, 0.011484958231449127, -0.024338848888874054, -0.02558033913373947, 0.008596633560955524, 0.010466834530234337, -0.03798016905784607, 0.04594612866640091, 0.04318321868777275, -0.01581641100347042, -0.025373931974172592, 0.0634780079126358, 0.008536946028470993, 0.0605059452354908, -0.006544873584061861, 0.021822107955813408, 0.002111959969624877, 0.10104487836360931, 0.04150288924574852, 0.003333735978230834, -0.01376821007579565, 0.026939380913972855, 0.038446880877017975, 0.032946523278951645, -0.013615522533655167, 0.03203731030225754, 0.008652836084365845, -0.025321852415800095, 0.019496003165841103, -0.04531713202595711, -0.04476258531212807, -0.00012071651872247458, 0.031013458967208862, -0.04709845781326294, -0.013420730829238892, 0.10052453726530075, 0.02267717383801937, -0.05720367282629013, -0.02013598568737507, 0.00789897982031107, 0.03262331336736679, -0.027671711519360542, -0.035662874579429626, 0.013546335510909557, -0.030185146257281303, 0.009232242591679096, 0.0494760163128376, -0.003092395141720772, -0.011885852552950382, -0.008766017854213715, -0.06027975305914879, 0.045899905264377594, 0.03204749897122383, -0.028712067753076553, -0.021693522110581398, -0.05051868408918381, -0.029323911294341087, -0.035253044217824936, 0.003555970499292016, 0.04331224784255028, -0.0009502581087872386, -0.05360262468457222, 0.05431419610977173, -0.08917123824357986, -0.03386832773685455, -0.006259102839976549, -0.007654963992536068, 0.05487291142344475, 0.044852763414382935, 0.04867379367351532, 0.007624515797942877, -0.026906030252575874, 0.07247992604970932, -0.01053761225193739, -0.015300769358873367, -0.04331142455339432, 0.02815314009785652, 0.010132772848010063, -0.007089875638484955, 0.0046500409953296185, 0.02791512757539749, -0.020381992682814598, 0.01644541695713997, 0.011227799579501152, 0.03038880042731762, 0.005370220635086298, 0.033047184348106384, -0.00651992904022336, 0.054939284920692444, 0.007143423892557621, 0.03864309564232826, 0.01560830045491457, -0.03727244585752487, -0.034634288400411606, -0.01819661259651184, 0.005843367427587509, -0.01904497668147087, -0.0470539815723896, 0.019013339653611183, 0.007685604505240917, -0.07697316259145737, -0.06322775781154633, -0.02949422039091587, 0.022476624697446823, 0.03750579431653023, 0.02065006084740162, 0.05763771012425423, -0.010931508615612984, 0.019611842930316925, -0.023619394749403, -0.05685421824455261, 0.008976036682724953, -0.02079697884619236, -0.1133497804403305, 0.009495488367974758, 0.02210591919720173, -0.014553681015968323, -0.009032588452100754, 0.032433055341243744, -0.040753673762083054, -0.06957552582025528, 0.04441246762871742, 0.0024299875367432833, 0.012048585340380669, 0.0029222534503787756, -0.009998245164752007, -0.0792003944516182, 0.0054437569342553616, 0.0021156235598027706, 0.00639280304312706, 0.025961238890886307, 0.013395024463534355, 0.006947604939341545, -0.057090990245342255, 0.008304864168167114, -0.008918696083128452, 0.04551353678107262, -0.019884470850229263, 0.02483528107404709, -0.037968218326568604, -0.00032622029539197683, 0.0012446610489860177, 0.005003403406590223, 0.04469389468431473, 0.00039420431130565703, 0.06889529526233673, -0.03860127925872803, 0.03445717319846153, 0.01474163681268692, 0.03309611603617668, -0.008490875363349915, 0.018756603822112083, 0.029619354754686356, 0.00850646011531353, -0.0490870401263237, -0.033151835203170776, -0.05173386633396149, -0.023884844034910202, 0.024880003184080124, 0.08712229132652283, -0.00016160935047082603, 0.03885507956147194, 0.025428511202335358, -0.05277050659060478, 0.005529541987925768, 0.029806118458509445, 0.03968735784292221, 0.025101331993937492, -0.012715921737253666, 0.030262578278779984, 0.0016685656737536192, 0.019232066348195076, 0.018270188942551613, 0.0496969036757946, 0.025676138699054718, 0.04645070806145668, -0.0708976462483406, -0.012130571529269218, 0.037479467689991, -0.0458015538752079, 0.058152128010988235, -0.01015308778733015, 0.015177838504314423, -0.02889416180551052, 0.01936289854347706, -0.0240340419113636, 0.007886245846748352, 0.0012950855307281017, 0.0013716431567445397, -0.047702573239803314, 0.00011741572961909696, 0.051788050681352615, 0.022046662867069244, -0.021133847534656525, 0.024830089882016182, -0.021271059289574623, -0.03358250483870506, -0.0003901588497683406, -0.019257906824350357, -0.019774429500102997, -0.028200984001159668, 0.017018985003232956, -0.03682181239128113, -0.015334445051848888, 0.031400855630636215, -0.02052978053689003, 0.03512401506304741, -0.006576047278940678, 0.04280969500541687, -0.01577061414718628, -0.01907755807042122, 0.012446561828255653, -0.014212232083082199, -0.012960292398929596, 0.011134418658912182, -0.04040908440947533, -0.01563342660665512, -6.057492836468117e-33, -0.025741098448634148, -0.041805900633335114, -0.03453059121966362, -0.0010369400260969996, -0.011549392715096474, 0.02244384028017521, -0.00760436337441206, 0.037384405732154846, 0.05235745385289192, -0.024602442979812622, -0.01134696789085865, 0.004637077916413546, 0.04057776555418968, 0.004083652514964342, 0.025061486288905144, 0.025059860199689865, 0.05779888853430748, -0.01966889575123787, 0.00032682434539310634, 0.0071642124094069, 0.02748643048107624, 0.04606037586927414, 0.09408736974000931, -0.10000988095998764, -0.03389600291848183, 0.01306961104273796, 0.03778063878417015, -0.046665653586387634, 0.06051626428961754, 0.03923848271369934, 0.0012285008560866117, -0.018755467608571053, 0.006832117214798927, -0.06797424703836441, -0.008118333294987679, 0.02533719688653946, -0.08653964847326279, -0.010089032351970673, -0.024211350828409195, 0.041497621685266495, 0.02726195752620697, -0.012890930287539959, -0.030462652444839478, 0.0031438961159437895, -0.03009278140962124, 0.02280132845044136, 0.006474375259131193, -0.012804640457034111, -0.04927120730280876, -0.03151953965425491, -0.015103386715054512, 0.07277767360210419, 0.0013332454254850745, 0.015147868543863297, 0.07763195782899857, 0.00809408538043499, -0.005916739348322153, -0.00942254438996315, -0.02717479132115841, 0.011961795389652252, 0.026219571009278297, 0.10090368986129761, 0.003398242639377713, 0.028297215700149536, -0.03553823381662369, 0.019170420244336128, 0.04293830692768097, -0.03473372757434845, 0.0013788804644718766, -0.028183717280626297, -0.02168852649629116, -0.006210077553987503, 0.053650762885808945, 0.004865572787821293, 0.04045594483613968, -0.06253129243850708, -0.019432561472058296, 0.05423919856548309, 0.032198257744312286, -0.018880153074860573, 0.014834294095635414, 0.02696424536406994, -0.054957907646894455, 0.01272493228316307, 0.019299764186143875, -0.029200883582234383, -0.011829052120447159, -0.01640930213034153, 0.05439167469739914, -0.0125147495418787, -0.01421427447348833, 0.022903285920619965, 0.057515863329172134, 0.016447773203253746, -0.014605918899178505, -0.014078257605433464, 0.010833321139216423, 0.007949303835630417, -0.0347384475171566, 0.0020050588063895702, -0.0624963752925396, -0.052955128252506256, 0.04954734817147255, 0.002463938668370247, 0.024253325536847115, -0.0467594675719738, 0.017964564263820648, 0.01696271263062954, -0.04691334813833237, -0.0015643684891983867, 0.03509277477860451, 0.011337775737047195, 0.007309212815016508, 0.05307691544294357, 0.013998132199048996, -0.04478713497519493, 0.031233742833137512, 0.02336893044412136, 0.042215198278427124, -0.05499660223722458, -0.03057323768734932, -0.010290274396538734, 0.012884194031357765, 0.012813822366297245, -0.038632314652204514, 0.026226449757814407, -0.0034069090615957975, 0.05035462975502014, 0.03752715513110161, -0.010040126740932465, -0.0028803215827792883, 0.01603911630809307, 2.786582342650945e-07, -0.016681693494319916, 0.0317811518907547, -0.0020101882982999086, -0.04377498850226402, 0.015392383560538292, 0.006099203135818243, 0.0029008248820900917, 0.007159017492085695, -0.04959826171398163, 0.006604002323001623, 0.06796373426914215, -0.06313515454530716, 0.06573596596717834, 0.0358232781291008, -0.10811463743448257, -0.03265831992030144, -0.059783630073070526, 0.04176899790763855, -0.05957501754164696, 0.009851829148828983, -0.011437417939305305, 0.08687368780374527, -0.008096669800579548, -0.036037102341651917, -0.01436680369079113, -0.008290084078907967, -0.023550374433398247, 0.0006369099719449878, -0.005599577445536852, -0.013990025967359543, 0.040678877383470535, -0.009193737991154194, -0.055850353091955185, -0.025226743891835213, -0.03143572062253952, 0.04924415796995163, 0.08542776852846146, 0.04754772409796715, -0.03345416858792305, -0.0394950732588768, 0.036807239055633545, 0.020310474559664726, -0.015259815379977226, -0.030704816803336143, 0.04629005864262581, 0.06455972790718079, -0.01923471689224243, -0.032478880137205124, 0.020439183339476585, 0.0037581867072731256, -0.011058726347982883, -0.0009714830084703863, -0.0003396966785658151, 0.022005321457982063, 0.03271683305501938, -0.03252715989947319, -0.019821038469672203, -0.06758806109428406, 0.02866087295114994, 0.03039741888642311, 0.008193152956664562, -0.011373731307685375, -0.013281700201332569, 0.018331220373511314, 0.022409629076719284, -0.018375461921095848, -0.02654349058866501, 2.736078584675293e-34, -0.0035752991680055857, -0.046635404229164124, 0.006049976218491793, 0.048569582402706146, 0.0043713985942304134, -0.02065809816122055, 0.025612356141209602, 0.04391518607735634, 0.0001106871641241014, -0.06733634322881699, -0.03505892679095268]
633
633
['Govardana Sachithanandam Ramachandran', 'Ajay Sohmshetty']
1703.03939v1
We examine Memory Networks for the task of question answering (QA), under common real world scenario where training examples are scarce and under weakly supervised scenario, that is only extrinsic labels are available for training. We propose extensions for the Dynamic Memory Network (DMN), specifically within the attention mechanism, we call the resulting Neural Architecture as Dynamic Memory Tensor Network (DMTN). Ultimately, we see that our proposed extensions results in over 80% improvement in the number of task passed against the baselined standard DMN and 20% more task passed compared to state-of-the-art End-to-End Memory Network for Facebook's single task weakly trained 1K bAbi dataset.
Ask Me Even More: Dynamic Memory Tensor Networks (Extended Model)
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1703.03939v1
Title Ask Even Dynamic Memory Tensor Networks Extended Model Summary examine Memory Networks task question answering QA common real world scenario training example scarce weakly supervised scenario extrinsic label available training propose extension Dynamic Memory Network DMN specifically within attention mechanism call resulting Neural Architecture Dynamic Memory Tensor Network DMTN Ultimately see proposed extension result 80 improvement number task passed baselined standard DMN 20 task passed compared stateoftheart EndtoEnd Memory Network Facebooks single task weakly trained 1K bAbi dataset Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.01754993386566639, -0.01755429059267044, -0.037438519299030304, 0.00472089322283864, -0.007093632128089666, 0.03203025832772255, 0.011884788051247597, -0.020065026357769966, -0.010369201190769672, -0.016145899891853333, -0.0012571010738611221, -0.04139208793640137, -0.013332019560039043, 0.0303955115377903, 0.04763966426253319, -0.0967307910323143, 0.01506795920431614, -0.02696680836379528, 0.008611982688307762, 0.002184249460697174, -0.0076439217664301395, -0.012440175749361515, -0.010187981650233269, -0.004347670823335648, -0.023720620200037956, -0.014595185406506062, -0.041439373046159744, 0.009979501366615295, 0.052272725850343704, -0.024827448651194572, 0.03530227765440941, 0.05046798661351204, 0.03586718067526817, -0.013045492582023144, 2.1525797819776926e-06, -0.010809888131916523, 0.021806392818689346, -0.05802387371659279, 0.010696199722588062, -0.04790087416768074, -0.00042829071753658354, 0.010212586261332035, 0.013742849230766296, 0.01089946087449789, -0.04199409484863281, -0.020743591710925102, 0.0390840508043766, 0.04199209436774254, 0.044890012592077255, 0.041016798466444016, -0.020990898832678795, 0.0038416460156440735, 0.003322821808978915, -0.028190486133098602, 0.015624401159584522, -0.03409551829099655, 0.03312047943472862, -0.013316953554749489, -0.04185359925031662, -0.01315311249345541, 0.02001035213470459, 0.034632377326488495, 0.03234389051795006, 0.03922438994050026, 0.03661408647894859, 0.10163231939077377, -0.033241692930459976, 0.0074384440667927265, -0.01838321052491665, 0.09925800561904907, -0.01202352438122034, -0.0026590924244374037, 0.023122329264879227, 0.013324758037924767, 0.001995287137106061, -0.024550534784793854, -0.056042443960905075, -0.002453659661114216, 0.007796590216457844, 0.024519015103578568, -0.005019481293857098, 0.06243541091680527, 0.0185489971190691, -0.0042803012765944, -0.013541245833039284, -0.012953675352036953, 0.01075800321996212, -0.019690588116645813, -0.04023228585720062, -0.043270304799079895, 0.0083172507584095, -0.05430283769965172, 0.03364862874150276, 0.02961413376033306, 0.024109037593007088, -0.006303004454821348, -0.01880522444844246, -0.10745497792959213, 0.04585522785782814, -0.12517625093460083, 0.06767275929450989, 0.015490210615098476, -0.06308568269014359, 0.029975129291415215, -0.02472393773496151, 0.0484783798456192, -0.05393466725945473, -0.0002452707849442959, 0.006266007665544748, 0.04129974916577339, -0.037047069519758224, -0.01048904936760664, -0.023575635626912117, 0.04071768373250961, 0.0295149777084589, -0.025621600449085236, -0.04897629842162132, 0.01257552020251751, -0.025572996586561203, -0.0202272217720747, -0.005427660420536995, 0.0669572576880455, -0.02763214148581028, 0.006734294351190329, -0.017036987468600273, -0.0011207466013729572, -0.04683598875999451, -0.0015151818515732884, -0.015728889033198357, -0.0004945857799611986, 0.003663262352347374, 0.03327004984021187, -0.012261785566806793, -0.031922537833452225, -0.004019788466393948, 0.14652931690216064, 0.012455306015908718, -0.03994239121675491, -0.040996965020895004, 0.01994951441884041, 0.01681699976325035, -0.06332257390022278, 0.035555656999349594, -0.04195409640669823, 0.03250369802117348, -0.03024514764547348, -0.020399564877152443, -0.006608431227505207, -0.0004934748285450041, 0.005767112132161856, -0.050871945917606354, 0.028068020939826965, 0.062042236328125, -0.009769304655492306, 0.05118967965245247, -0.0014768211403861642, 0.02808910794556141, 0.004759913310408592, 0.046979110687971115, 0.04237666726112366, 0.011209248565137386, 0.0009436417603865266, 0.045070141553878784, 0.0008178606512956321, 0.005853808484971523, -0.004334380850195885, -0.05333421379327774, -0.025280654430389404, 0.03258289024233818, 0.05460360273718834, -0.004124021157622337, 0.0376700796186924, -0.013789287768304348, -0.02377123385667801, 0.08099966496229172, 0.03792966529726982, 0.03839842602610588, 0.03309159353375435, 0.04720965027809143, -0.05952521413564682, -0.02329324744641781, 0.034260522574186325, -0.08880163729190826, 0.1036047413945198, 0.03365996107459068, 0.005112853366881609, -0.01770845055580139, -0.00121109199244529, -0.04955354332923889, -0.004737772047519684, 0.01226250920444727, -0.009419867768883705, 0.009123247116804123, -0.026607373729348183, 0.07100656628608704, -0.010969080962240696, -0.03541669249534607, 0.06627491116523743, -0.02821972221136093, 0.02480228990316391, -0.0215020552277565, -0.024869637563824654, -0.004423920065164566, 0.010696624405682087, 0.004613147117197514, -0.04989199340343475, -0.07613839954137802, 0.007831104099750519, -0.004997885320335627, -7.947163976496086e-05, 0.014197477139532566, 0.028950637206435204, 0.032864365726709366, -0.05776319280266762, 0.016480563208460808, -0.05161266773939133, 0.009410337544977665, 0.00125588767696172, -0.035298362374305725, 0.04286627843976021, 0.0074356915429234505, 0.02883945032954216, -0.010870224796235561, 0.029786689206957817, -0.030982065945863724, -0.05730259791016579, 0.01751076430082321, 0.016602614894509315, -0.0031810046639293432, 0.0006817003595642745, 0.017056727781891823, -0.0005580763099715114, 0.06254726648330688, -0.04270767793059349, -0.00787289347499609, 0.01679021678864956, -0.07598592340946198, -0.003953664097934961, 0.0292435921728611, -0.01834476739168167, -0.028286349028348923, -0.0033285804092884064, -0.044796381145715714, -0.06329620629549026, 0.08199074119329453, -0.03274388983845711, -0.0033035085070878267, -0.01288590393960476, 0.0004518974747043103, 0.02966248244047165, 0.028530508279800415, 0.0030743444804102182, 0.0780334547162056, -0.039420802146196365, 0.0020023456308990717, 0.003916895017027855, -0.024058200418949127, 0.01305737067013979, -0.06828395277261734, 0.007736113388091326, 0.012570405378937721, -0.012422146275639534, -0.04443911090493202, -0.01793254353106022, -0.008163286373019218, -0.04508556053042412, 0.023130256682634354, -0.034730084240436554, 0.018193891271948814, -0.01745251938700676, -0.01988251693546772, 0.040159620344638824, 0.0058195018209517, -0.00871970970183611, -0.019186990335583687, -0.03514458239078522, 0.04219859838485718, 0.011145785450935364, -0.024896984919905663, 0.03335078805685043, 0.019617684185504913, 0.012463999912142754, -0.02549782767891884, -0.031457897275686264, -0.002969980938360095, 0.0590210035443306, 0.014753851108253002, -0.08393561840057373, 0.004641490522772074, -0.0014213680988177657, -0.032594386488199234, 0.060991693288087845, -0.0053746444173157215, -0.04378466680645943, 0.005713753867894411, -0.03785422816872597, 0.05830206722021103, 0.07187933474779129, 0.028351588174700737, -0.009401477873325348, 0.04540299251675606, -0.026339750736951828, 0.003415418090298772, 0.026584627106785774, -0.038700904697179794, 0.017627861350774765, 0.007315833121538162, -0.037192050367593765, -0.048596903681755066, 0.08011391013860703, 0.036656204611063004, 0.027788497507572174, -0.021482210606336594, -0.019122065976262093, 0.00631076842546463, -0.006225185468792915, -0.036268312484025955, -0.002241369104012847, -0.04179637134075165, 0.035110004246234894, -0.009189627133309841, -0.027988556772470474, 0.08571495860815048, 0.041415080428123474, 0.015313863754272461, 0.007106175180524588, 0.010604987852275372, 0.009084844961762428, 0.024269653484225273, -0.003852018155157566, 0.03802737221121788, 0.01677393913269043, -0.04751800373196602, -0.04833897575736046, -0.011349574662744999, -0.019721221178770065, -0.026456719264388084, 0.023267680779099464, -0.01936003938317299, -0.046279292553663254, -0.010259563103318214, -0.019742008298635483, -0.057080890983343124, 0.029487190768122673, 0.020363900810480118, 0.007812784053385258, -0.07759153097867966, -0.008651308715343475, -0.05917559936642647, -0.005950091406702995, 0.015336059033870697, 0.059571489691734314, -0.02524872124195099, -0.013700599782168865, 0.004688205663114786, 0.09569493681192398, 0.04538051411509514, 0.01293252408504486, -0.010930904187262058, 0.0008458169759251177, 0.019566610455513, 0.06950850039720535, 0.06907624751329422, 0.007608228363096714, -0.06537480652332306, -0.013586526736617088, -0.010409924201667309, -0.02419273555278778, -0.0021680952049791813, 0.017065798863768578, -0.039440881460905075, -0.06536568701267242, -0.018627621233463287, 0.056051164865493774, 0.00618119677528739, -0.0643036887049675, -0.00027862758724950254, 0.008142576552927494, -0.043024126440286636, 0.025511812418699265, 0.01433577761054039, -0.03869707137346268, 0.017803005874156952, -0.012721523642539978, 0.026338810101151466, 0.0015117585426196456, -0.02855616994202137, 0.027941059321165085, -0.05005660653114319, 0.0217299647629261, -0.019375430420041084, 0.005396667867898941, -0.017452768981456757, -0.023618515580892563, 0.00020013656467199326, 0.021760961040854454, 0.00869742315262556, -0.0009752025944180787, 0.051757726818323135, -0.03600998967885971, 0.026613134890794754, 0.01992969587445259, 0.00018225119856651872, 0.0677090659737587, -0.042524125427007675, 0.03473195806145668, 0.02771117351949215, 0.05197317153215408, -0.036000367254018784, -0.04684046655893326, 0.025830436497926712, 0.006820168346166611, 0.034372225403785706, 0.02504194900393486, 0.06192528456449509, -0.024785757064819336, -0.0009387392201460898, -0.062410902231931686, 0.07214909046888351, -0.04205504059791565, -0.005101990886032581, -0.025820160284638405, 0.0664404034614563, -0.006718601565808058, -0.022082164883613586, -0.07702081650495529, 0.02513575740158558, -0.0035412097349762917, 0.023711198940873146, 0.026034362614154816, -0.04325297474861145, -0.012298526242375374, 0.04906043782830238, 0.03618785738945007, -0.050957225263118744, -0.007800506427884102, -0.004249778110533953, 0.012182217091321945, -0.04549890756607056, -0.0762040764093399, 0.0053701321594417095, -0.01730436086654663, 0.052884094417095184, 0.006576815154403448, -0.02271057479083538, 0.008525707758963108, -0.040917545557022095, -0.03589315712451935, 0.03675657510757446, 0.01898687519133091, -0.008505823090672493, -0.003756658174097538, 0.011965014971792698, 0.024852097034454346, 0.012483921833336353, 0.01107844803482294, 0.01675785705447197, -0.09735841304063797, -0.040421806275844574, 0.013382491655647755, 0.08850961923599243, 0.013845513574779034, 0.011826837435364723, -0.021244237199425697, -0.03049420565366745, 0.043750397861003876, -0.03154561668634415, -0.03813597932457924, 0.02950250171124935, 0.03362586349248886, -0.022562047466635704, -0.012174839153885841, 0.004985426086932421, -0.016367681324481964, 0.03051992505788803, 0.06360048800706863, -0.020290590822696686, -0.016706762835383415, 0.0016868817619979382, 0.01951534114778042, -0.048146188259124756, 0.076933853328228, 0.001860070158727467, 0.01783917471766472, -0.05014269798994064, 0.01966300792992115, 0.042091935873031616, -0.007355701643973589, -0.012528320774435997, 0.011680183000862598, 0.01195941586047411, 0.038630880415439606, -0.04050075635313988, -0.0736156478524208, -0.007555002812296152, -0.0312834158539772, -0.00237168837338686, -0.01958642341196537, 0.008290055207908154, 0.013495760038495064, -0.012166259810328484, 0.020530404523015022, -0.04927542433142662, -0.0022892351262271404, -0.046150144189596176, 0.04766442999243736, 0.0039320215582847595, 0.07638846337795258, 0.014161846600472927, -0.0037170075811445713, -0.025648321956396103, -0.005660812836140394, -0.0007264915620908141, -0.04631752893328667, -0.030301997438073158, 0.008792604319751263, 0.02899101749062538, -0.03099430538713932, -0.0230739563703537, -0.004048604518175125, 0.019897010177373886, -0.009698338806629181, 0.0025049191899597645, -0.04812304303050041, 0.0037263943813741207, 0.0028965750243514776, -0.0010332458186894655, 0.014827714301645756, 0.024748681113123894, 0.03648126497864723, -0.019556038081645966, 0.01474699005484581, -0.012125492095947266, -0.007641696836799383, -0.011544989421963692, 0.018140528351068497, -0.00675760954618454, 0.054133348166942596, -0.003058618400245905, 0.0128470528870821, -0.03275980055332184, -0.07389239221811295, 0.014850210398435593, 0.007639340590685606, 0.03679333254694939, -0.04348614439368248, 0.025022655725479126, -0.0015804130816832185, 0.03611670807003975, 0.0054391217418015, 0.0007989266305230558, 0.01082077156752348, 0.02792307361960411, -0.03292670473456383, -0.09928754717111588, -6.27575715816086e-33, 0.003653958672657609, -0.013317473232746124, -0.0013018655590713024, -0.046922001987695694, -0.05674432963132858, 0.022067517042160034, -0.08096681535243988, -0.044258471578359604, -0.017249781638383865, -0.0007307297782972455, -0.024690978229045868, 0.020011605694890022, -0.0026531629264354706, 0.00993888359516859, 0.07213268429040909, -0.00019982815138064325, -0.039415206760168076, -0.02906782180070877, 0.02935667708516121, 0.06799650192260742, 0.08243701606988907, 0.05394701287150383, 0.0889769122004509, -0.083766870200634, -0.00023239631264004856, -0.01542353443801403, 0.0027001891285181046, 0.01877555623650551, -0.0026943704579025507, 0.013182908296585083, -0.06518030911684036, -0.0383613184094429, 0.03489546477794647, -0.05405396223068237, -0.010275385342538357, 0.004846644122153521, -0.08453740924596786, -0.05335325375199318, -0.044213924556970596, -0.047356415539979935, -0.040742889046669006, -0.010339472442865372, 0.04214204102754593, 0.0060885874554514885, 0.025761177763342857, -0.014235245063900948, 0.04758508503437042, 0.003961202222853899, -0.016152380034327507, -0.0200184378772974, -0.04870643839240074, 0.014143493957817554, -0.011843254789710045, 0.008845345117151737, -0.03310595452785492, 0.03227066993713379, -0.02788064442574978, 0.022272080183029175, -0.08340311050415039, 0.020791582763195038, -0.03512761369347572, -0.007117932196706533, 0.03179646283388138, 0.012030982412397861, 0.05873861908912659, 0.05342640355229378, 0.00912422128021717, 0.00764002138748765, -0.01612498052418232, -0.04231010749936104, -0.01950727216899395, 0.046065475791692734, 0.06667149066925049, -0.013888946734368801, 0.05435322970151901, -0.004666048567742109, -0.04202887415885925, -0.044390685856342316, -0.001278912415727973, 0.05451026186347008, 0.0481572262942791, 0.018401268869638443, -0.00787674356251955, 0.006425193510949612, 0.00960626546293497, 0.044972315430641174, -0.0387023389339447, -0.031049787998199463, 0.0058646053075790405, 0.011909736320376396, -0.011711323633790016, -0.009491302073001862, 0.019676627591252327, -0.0344761498272419, 0.0984811782836914, -0.008222110569477081, 0.00690273055806756, 0.05135826766490936, 0.024798866361379623, -0.010564702562987804, -0.03991786763072014, -0.03169364482164383, -0.010129537433385849, 0.014273143373429775, 0.02746572345495224, 0.037467505782842636, 0.010877278633415699, 0.014726818539202213, 0.004342953208833933, -0.03724208474159241, -0.005831112619489431, 0.01458192802965641, 0.021839309483766556, 0.02292853407561779, 0.0064356825314462185, -0.018850106745958328, -0.022763103246688843, -0.005230684764683247, 0.03564764931797981, -0.003251313930377364, -0.04389071464538574, 0.0018062734743580222, 0.019418803974986076, 0.07215146720409393, -0.020814694464206696, -0.014592028222978115, -0.07437869906425476, -0.01467122696340084, 0.03734545409679413, -0.03418547287583351, -0.005654273089021444, 0.04228516295552254, 2.97201808052705e-07, -0.01742691546678543, -0.01610667258501053, 0.029039323329925537, -0.030746974050998688, 0.04219372197985649, 0.020037941634655, -0.014035585336387157, 0.07622617483139038, 0.040455419570207596, -0.007144142407923937, 0.06084065139293671, 0.03639091178774834, -0.002966278698295355, 0.004485900513827801, -0.06422857195138931, -0.029449013993144035, -0.05251505970954895, 0.006770891137421131, -0.03686574473977089, -0.01213749684393406, 0.007030606269836426, 0.07794083654880524, 0.06712242215871811, -0.012454326264560223, 0.01756540685892105, -0.042753834277391434, 0.04177243635058403, -0.001314387540332973, 0.05626451596617699, -0.02446891739964485, 0.03080293908715248, 0.001309988903813064, -0.05880273878574371, 0.021687397733330727, -0.025738200172781944, 0.005915494170039892, -0.029796363785862923, 0.026730619370937347, 0.014002439565956593, -0.06299552321434021, 0.04225313290953636, -0.012793498113751411, 0.04155224189162254, -0.0639849379658699, 0.052768122404813766, -0.07996821403503418, -0.04065847769379616, -0.010939660482108593, -0.0037286567967385054, 0.020706767216324806, 0.04295245185494423, -0.019932415336370468, -0.0007035253802314401, 0.036799974739551544, -0.0038490414153784513, 0.008635517209768295, 0.00319155165925622, -0.12049718201160431, 0.013583880849182606, 0.04394984990358353, -0.06312098354101181, 0.0013096455950289965, -0.038783010095357895, -0.02196447178721428, 0.0588684156537056, -0.04729815572500229, -0.009303600527346134, 2.2840640429969197e-34, -0.011256854981184006, 0.011512788012623787, -0.04629058763384819, 0.03448803722858429, -0.013210640288889408, -0.04206356778740883, -0.02011624537408352, 0.02147829718887806, 0.039457809180021286, -0.0423097163438797, -0.047906678169965744]
634
634
['Lior Fritz', 'David Burshtein']
1703.10356v2
A simplified speech recognition system that uses the maximum mutual information (MMI) criterion is considered. End-to-end training using gradient descent is suggested, similarly to the training of connectionist temporal classification (CTC). We use an MMI criterion with a simple language model in the training stage, and a standard HMM decoder. Our method compares favorably to CTC in terms of performance, robustness, decoding time, disk footprint and quality of alignments. The good alignments enable the use of a straightforward ensemble method, obtained by simply averaging the predictions of several neural network models, that were trained separately end-to-end. The ensemble method yields a considerable reduction in the word error rate.
Simplified End-to-End MMI Training and Voting for ASR
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1703.10356v2
Title Simplified EndtoEnd MMI Training Voting ASR Summary simplified speech recognition system us maximum mutual information MMI criterion considered Endtoend training using gradient descent suggested similarly training connectionist temporal classification CTC use MMI criterion simple language model training stage standard HMM decoder method compare favorably CTC term performance robustness decoding time disk footprint quality alignment good alignment enable use straightforward ensemble method obtained simply averaging prediction several neural network model trained separately endtoend ensemble method yield considerable reduction word error rate Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.026127465069293976, 0.040844596922397614, 0.02768903411924839, 0.027729712426662445, 0.0038226251490414143, 0.022259080782532692, 0.006353217642754316, -0.0174814872443676, -0.0220170971006155, -0.013572930358350277, -0.042083434760570526, -0.01985441893339157, 0.07458272576332092, 0.010344461537897587, -0.018603907898068428, -0.029162060469388962, 0.030020106583833694, 0.0035121890250593424, -0.025505851954221725, -0.017866773530840874, 0.017608750611543655, 0.011661186814308167, -0.0655086562037468, 0.05291207879781723, -0.014391973614692688, 0.0008889735327102244, -0.018549617379903793, -0.057586148381233215, -0.014362383633852005, -0.05204789340496063, -0.003844739403575659, 0.04056219756603241, 0.02550218626856804, 0.0208231583237648, 2.42992905441497e-06, -0.017232751473784447, 0.007835191674530506, -0.015342146158218384, -0.036789875477552414, -0.027853691950440407, 0.010703997686505318, 0.022939329966902733, 0.0017885592533275485, 0.049702394753694534, -0.019851576536893845, -0.011053751222789288, 0.07509148120880127, 0.052239060401916504, -0.005361435003578663, 0.068923719227314, -0.0068098921328783035, -0.019926944747567177, 0.048014819622039795, 0.022437937557697296, -0.027635978534817696, -0.019489027559757233, -0.005102704279124737, -0.02432863414287567, -0.0058620525524020195, -0.05212881416082382, 0.01802213490009308, 0.04157591238617897, -0.002412103582173586, -0.00281310360878706, 0.03210553526878357, 0.03781133517622948, 0.02887899987399578, -0.019934946671128273, -0.05247008055448532, 0.05935855954885483, 0.04422095790505409, -0.02660367451608181, -0.0060485913418233395, 0.0296601764857769, -0.04712609574198723, -0.01907346583902836, -0.001966780750080943, 0.00870669074356556, -0.012710277922451496, 0.009992657229304314, 0.025446007028222084, 0.056925687938928604, 0.017426948994398117, 0.02810593508183956, -0.02021566592156887, 0.019393518567085266, -0.01599171571433544, -0.03993643447756767, 0.030993392691016197, -0.05005588382482529, 0.024121254682540894, -0.004568514879792929, 0.03154526650905609, 0.024118971079587936, 0.0012900750152766705, -0.002545077819377184, 0.01098384615033865, -0.0788014754652977, 0.02212669886648655, -0.07165998965501785, 0.019268978387117386, 0.021618524566292763, 0.005706611089408398, 0.0012607988901436329, 0.01610712707042694, 0.054847944527864456, 0.024357788264751434, -0.0021318048238754272, -0.007547477725893259, 0.008201459422707558, -0.056608837097883224, 0.0058895982801914215, -0.014391617849469185, 0.048920173197984695, 0.0011395028559491038, -0.035618189722299576, -0.09051258862018585, -0.0063157593831419945, 0.0009497407008893788, -0.033198706805706024, 0.04393870383501053, 0.018903490155935287, -0.039096586406230927, -0.006520044058561325, 0.004305639769881964, 0.038579635322093964, 0.003115791827440262, 0.06939936429262161, -0.007285893429070711, -0.062048546969890594, 0.006415039766579866, 0.016017545014619827, 0.017434053122997284, 0.02517535723745823, 0.014727752655744553, 0.05730453133583069, -0.0018308961298316717, -0.02379636839032173, -0.06086142733693123, 0.029186250641942024, -0.0013170719612389803, -0.010340223088860512, -0.027076708152890205, -0.050022002309560776, 0.04392905905842781, -0.01715303771197796, 0.004097737837582827, 0.007642757147550583, -0.0038260319270193577, -0.031040672212839127, -0.0013577858917415142, 0.08446409553289413, -0.03640756011009216, -0.005522357765585184, 0.08395960927009583, -0.0062490906566381454, 0.060799241065979004, 0.047166913747787476, 0.07293832302093506, -0.015557490289211273, -0.005461124237626791, -0.02624533325433731, -0.02784574031829834, 0.03274889290332794, -0.023751309141516685, -0.004149469081312418, -0.04148631915450096, -0.019690658897161484, -0.0045587122440338135, 0.045480191707611084, 0.025693058967590332, 0.03744562342762947, 0.01165551133453846, 0.017626745626330376, 0.06697695702314377, 0.08053034543991089, 0.03928644210100174, 0.008996495045721531, 0.0023493394255638123, 0.03325794264674187, 0.011627165600657463, -0.07222152501344681, 0.020789043977856636, 0.0036328951828181744, -0.03394627943634987, -0.0020261199679225683, 0.003935843240469694, 0.0051995329558849335, -0.02693036198616028, -0.02579880878329277, -0.0003297791990917176, -0.0637584924697876, -0.0188834797590971, -0.00022688705939799547, 0.08484062552452087, -0.014055944979190826, -0.04413410276174545, -0.00427249725908041, 0.028285233303904533, -0.020887643098831177, 0.0005117123364470899, -0.03912254050374031, 0.009393432177603245, 0.020802849903702736, 0.004755526315420866, -0.028844604268670082, -0.024226287379860878, -0.0449366569519043, -0.03612248972058296, 0.02917022816836834, -0.007040053606033325, -0.007640032563358545, 0.025642281398177147, -0.09708014130592346, 0.014955458231270313, 0.11493231356143951, -0.002006181515753269, 0.07019863277673721, -0.03400682285428047, 0.053289830684661865, 0.0038960606325417757, 0.04953722283244133, -0.0024244857486337423, 0.0134055744856596, 0.00881213415414095, -0.0194991584867239, 0.012318373657763004, 0.03209884464740753, 0.07903920114040375, 0.032330963760614395, -0.015900714322924614, -0.02612820640206337, 0.050289902836084366, -0.011145008727908134, -0.012915020808577538, 0.041373249143362045, -0.07763759046792984, -0.027698813006281853, 0.03168286010622978, 0.02292392961680889, 0.06396137177944183, 0.05313679948449135, 0.02144460380077362, -0.08113213628530502, 0.011587242595851421, -0.019976433366537094, 0.043422166258096695, -0.05732683092355728, 0.06881524622440338, 0.007640385068953037, -0.01074959896504879, 0.015018685720860958, 0.008868597447872162, -0.05636416748166084, -0.013283922336995602, -0.002775157568976283, -0.011247128248214722, 0.02004523202776909, -0.07676278054714203, -0.030543455854058266, 0.07576167583465576, -0.02086976170539856, 0.002846492687240243, -0.03950093314051628, 0.005597957409918308, -0.024716157466173172, -0.017385639250278473, -0.09938202798366547, -0.016848308965563774, -0.003373611019924283, 0.03480341285467148, -0.02209899201989174, 0.022490374743938446, 0.011054830625653267, -0.01937876082956791, 0.003291019005700946, 0.030255578458309174, 0.008248982951045036, -0.0426480770111084, -0.007113903295248747, 0.01143160555511713, -0.0032901023514568806, -0.008936476893723011, -0.0008440181263722479, -0.027037540450692177, 0.03927874192595482, 0.005411055404692888, -0.09496592730283737, -0.023381579667329788, -0.013777238316833973, 0.020429592579603195, 0.042626187205314636, 0.008144266903400421, -0.06010929495096207, 0.0010357726132497191, -0.007225529290735722, 7.032324356259778e-05, 0.01948978751897812, 0.04434170946478844, 0.012270517647266388, -0.00587827805429697, 0.027688398957252502, -0.05128777399659157, 0.009385442361235619, 0.038841597735881805, 0.04454021900892258, -0.022920522838830948, -0.009364740923047066, -0.02434142306447029, 0.07524294406175613, 0.016934329643845558, 0.07869541645050049, -0.019539475440979004, -0.009568801149725914, -0.04998110234737396, -0.024042291566729546, -0.019580760970711708, -0.015874506905674934, -0.04412422329187393, -0.008713009767234325, 0.01615232229232788, -0.013358051888644695, 0.014906528405845165, -0.056132666766643524, -0.015289349481463432, -0.04406271129846573, -0.08698242157697678, -0.01662110723555088, 0.0033968661446124315, -0.04791569337248802, -0.005692492239177227, -0.000881561019923538, -0.08798182755708694, 0.015793411061167717, -0.022326460108160973, -0.010732767172157764, -0.041303519159555435, 0.019339295104146004, -0.01409325934946537, 0.006164416205137968, -0.025428609922528267, -0.034297868609428406, -0.03083718754351139, 0.00441506365314126, -0.008996078744530678, 0.0031459080055356026, 0.0063407844863832, -0.03204215317964554, 0.0028641929384320974, 0.02785440720617771, -0.02300128899514675, 0.04369138181209564, -0.0248175710439682, 0.023231266066432, 0.0020547963213175535, 0.06036357209086418, 0.038306303322315216, 0.02573462761938572, -0.03333393856883049, 0.019212188199162483, 0.052110765129327774, 0.008448313921689987, 0.04354197159409523, 0.0034093251451849937, -0.11279912292957306, -0.027946777641773224, 0.04490974172949791, -0.029796870425343513, 0.008284947834908962, 0.02915087155997753, 0.027628904208540916, -0.05540977045893669, 0.009418579749763012, 0.07862792909145355, -0.010748052038252354, -0.08070848882198334, -0.0451139435172081, 0.032764092087745667, -0.009908410720527172, -0.016842443495988846, -0.015835260972380638, -9.864469029707834e-05, -0.015574821271002293, 0.024163052439689636, 0.057723160833120346, -0.027623139321804047, 0.008943479508161545, -0.022384503856301308, -0.06323704868555069, 0.008507664315402508, 0.013189959339797497, -0.06175226718187332, -0.033165715634822845, -0.06233450025320053, -0.04323023557662964, -0.019565720111131668, 0.051943693310022354, 0.024242840707302094, -0.003517445409670472, -0.045827481895685196, 0.050446078181266785, -0.09281345456838608, -0.06541916728019714, 0.018461015075445175, -0.03921448066830635, 0.0888202115893364, 0.07389592379331589, 0.021633867174386978, -0.062029581516981125, -0.017881501466035843, 0.03354264795780182, -0.03464018926024437, 0.017335543408989906, -0.04369230568408966, 0.038182370364665985, -0.009345345199108124, 0.0005284870276227593, 4.2429750465089455e-05, 0.04336927458643913, 0.00032432048465125263, 0.03648011386394501, 0.027071982622146606, 0.06018226593732834, -0.04765365645289421, 0.032819557934999466, 0.0032803353387862444, 0.04641403257846832, 0.025241268798708916, 0.021859023720026016, 0.007700073067098856, -0.04257528483867645, 0.00013733764353673905, 0.011002535000443459, 0.02903793379664421, -0.04067647084593773, 0.02406291477382183, 0.00963506568223238, 0.008426336571574211, -0.04767555370926857, -0.05178520455956459, -0.07401925325393677, -0.001702809357084334, 0.030252674594521523, 0.06336729228496552, 0.027690336108207703, 0.02318824827671051, 0.032498717308044434, -0.04981600493192673, -0.00466762762516737, 0.034523990005254745, 0.019558649510145187, -0.08439464122056961, 0.02217951975762844, 0.03127387911081314, -0.03353486210107803, 0.006824774201959372, -0.05731220915913582, -0.03916522487998009, -0.04983393847942352, -0.030230479314923286, 0.011748170480132103, 0.01795506291091442, 0.046162404119968414, -0.04217730462551117, -0.06225705146789551, 0.0537988506257534, 0.00013461099297273904, -0.01881241798400879, -0.018239056691527367, 0.07853299379348755, 0.026518698781728745, -0.012599382549524307, 0.0019836360588669777, -0.0325457826256752, 0.042752839624881744, -0.02071952447295189, -0.020190522074699402, -0.04168684035539627, 0.004284851718693972, 0.015522700734436512, 0.005956108681857586, 0.04470638558268547, 0.009189682081341743, 7.540915248682722e-05, -0.06707123667001724, 0.020585225895047188, 0.009924579411745071, 0.046782366931438446, 0.0007426110096275806, 0.028494277969002724, 0.04527198523283005, 0.0472596101462841, -0.014451593160629272, -0.029680725187063217, 0.028331439942121506, -0.06608574092388153, 0.00913921557366848, 0.10257869958877563, -0.015171670354902744, 0.046723295003175735, -0.01433045044541359, 0.008285397663712502, -0.05901230499148369, 0.00711444579064846, 0.020163336768746376, 0.015137079171836376, -0.010758664458990097, 0.07135140150785446, -0.0065849232487380505, -0.003916183020919561, -0.0018760452512651682, 0.024696333333849907, 0.01138712652027607, 0.011499847285449505, -0.05316813290119171, 0.03535725548863411, 0.061785515397787094, -0.015646062791347504, 0.013952263630926609, 0.0034409579820930958, 0.03876499459147453, -0.03955122083425522, 0.052975643426179886, -0.06182665005326271, 0.0332060381770134, 0.03570864722132683, -0.005591191817075014, -0.02538318932056427, -0.015416954644024372, 0.02553432621061802, -0.015064980834722519, 0.0016094815218821168, 0.009886536747217178, 0.025421692058444023, -0.05144479498267174, -0.01822594739496708, -0.02229956164956093, 0.04363185539841652, -0.06136235594749451, -0.0037617741618305445, 0.018643250688910484, -0.017872896045446396, 0.03501139581203461, -0.013905281201004982, 0.04927508533000946, -0.016802610829472542, 0.0013452203711494803, -0.02806820534169674, -0.02030481956899166, 0.031099071726202965, -0.010736986994743347, -0.030609548091888428, 0.0029876946937292814, -0.008960545063018799, -0.060831110924482346, -6.690154916340211e-33, -0.01809806190431118, -0.00803221296519041, 0.009758521802723408, -0.0052677118219435215, -0.04911547526717186, 0.02574741654098034, 0.004590892232954502, -0.005705162417143583, -0.027141425758600235, -0.026189669966697693, -0.028611240908503532, -0.0018919366411864758, 0.02216515503823757, 0.018088117241859436, 0.026077570393681526, 0.020909827202558517, 0.024898359552025795, -0.028386078774929047, 0.02953389845788479, -0.03997083380818367, 0.05977405607700348, 0.07885611057281494, 0.08996214717626572, -0.06112784147262573, -0.03725823387503624, 0.026903968304395676, -0.0012978548184037209, -0.0064350576139986515, 0.010689405724406242, 0.020892083644866943, -0.012111919932067394, 0.01323548424988985, 0.01949223130941391, -0.02521677128970623, 0.017872432246804237, 0.006907655857503414, -0.10348401218652725, 0.015654832124710083, -0.0450073704123497, 0.05268149450421333, -0.005077797453850508, -0.004547123797237873, 0.052546266466379166, -0.004087858833372593, -0.06596262753009796, -0.0056248013861477375, 0.04200311005115509, -0.026438990607857704, -0.01854853145778179, -0.04186910763382912, -0.010804534889757633, 0.027874790132045746, -0.004050821531563997, 0.00269286148250103, 0.04917576164007187, 0.03825625777244568, -0.02148410491645336, -0.011167976073920727, -0.08387002348899841, 0.04706572741270065, -0.015359303914010525, -0.006554814986884594, 0.034005604684352875, 0.04441023990511894, 0.021136492490768433, 0.03166939318180084, 0.04213770851492882, -0.05838825926184654, -0.004501502960920334, -0.026027394458651543, 0.03393653780221939, 0.005433317273855209, 0.040395140647888184, -0.026250431314110756, 0.0783938392996788, -0.05713033676147461, -0.0316336527466774, 0.01784185692667961, 0.07001455873250961, 0.006725999526679516, -0.002100687474012375, 0.0016011123079806566, -0.10005935281515121, 0.0009370234329253435, -0.023375531658530235, -0.03307998925447464, -0.022588787600398064, -0.027912544086575508, 0.04562010616064072, 0.005486996378749609, 0.03754878789186478, -0.023201530799269676, 0.014831861481070518, -0.011213616468012333, 0.059417761862277985, -0.0090663842856884, 0.04394485428929329, -0.004904709756374359, -0.01937437802553177, -0.004587779752910137, -0.06156381964683533, -0.025347506627440453, -0.0045623937621712685, 0.007876419462263584, 0.026937073096632957, -0.0016720789717510343, 0.019480466842651367, 0.012915033847093582, -0.0386628583073616, -0.016100605949759483, 0.008498243987560272, -0.0056094522587955, 0.051516950130462646, 0.02764606662094593, 0.024171024560928345, -0.06485911458730698, 0.010317645967006683, 0.050424523651599884, 0.0016824033809825778, 0.031177636235952377, -0.01617373898625374, -0.0512639544904232, 0.008188441395759583, 0.036412447690963745, -0.05108379200100899, 0.01627514697611332, -0.031677041202783585, 0.032746683806180954, 0.013172902166843414, -0.0197833850979805, -0.006469137966632843, 0.028213445097208023, 2.976086079797824e-07, -0.02994399145245552, 0.016738273203372955, 0.012077909894287586, -0.005523471627384424, -0.020119817927479744, -0.007082182914018631, -0.043667398393154144, -0.015692131593823433, -0.009346640668809414, 0.06218060106039047, 0.02702397108078003, -0.035514820367097855, 0.07517871260643005, 0.02568177506327629, -0.11173416674137115, -0.0865350067615509, -0.08640950173139572, 0.04708341509103775, -0.03163321688771248, 0.02898622490465641, 0.020078934729099274, 0.0877140536904335, 0.02915489301085472, -0.01959301345050335, -0.01130310632288456, -0.029263097792863846, 0.025471525266766548, -0.025107113644480705, 0.01323680765926838, 0.0004375288845039904, 0.01739192195236683, -0.024211756885051727, -0.034778811037540436, 0.012641257606446743, -0.04816479980945587, 0.04711033031344414, -0.028900012373924255, 0.01791275106370449, -0.0513746403157711, -0.0502835288643837, 0.05501854419708252, 0.03216299042105675, -0.024015244096517563, 0.028006361797451973, 0.010328931733965874, -0.0054415808990597725, -0.05007914453744888, -0.05185007303953171, -0.015742352232336998, 0.00754932127892971, 0.007258355617523193, -0.002151868073269725, 0.043339043855667114, -0.029254155233502388, -0.0006187405670061707, -0.051622577011585236, -0.023158451542258263, -0.04112830013036728, 0.04070352762937546, 0.03126736730337143, -0.03449550271034241, -0.02558244951069355, -0.00655111949890852, -0.009420622140169144, 0.0434139110147953, -0.02137441188097, -0.016501760110259056, 2.9095450462469397e-34, 0.001273749745450914, -0.03956656903028488, 0.005249224603176117, 0.04705473408102989, 0.024263232946395874, -0.04363642632961273, 0.028732435777783394, 0.009607321582734585, -0.010358111932873726, -0.04583806172013283, -0.02658134512603283]
635
635
['Alec Radford', 'Rafal Jozefowicz', 'Ilya Sutskever']
1704.01444v2
We explore the properties of byte-level recurrent language models. When given sufficient amounts of capacity, training data, and compute time, the representations learned by these models include disentangled features corresponding to high-level concepts. Specifically, we find a single unit which performs sentiment analysis. These representations, learned in an unsupervised manner, achieve state of the art on the binary subset of the Stanford Sentiment Treebank. They are also very data efficient. When using only a handful of labeled examples, our approach matches the performance of strong baselines trained on full datasets. We also demonstrate the sentiment unit has a direct influence on the generative process of the model. Simply fixing its value to be positive or negative generates samples with the corresponding positive or negative sentiment.
Learning to Generate Reviews and Discovering Sentiment
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1704.01444v2
Title Learning Generate Reviews Discovering Sentiment Summary explore property bytelevel recurrent language model given sufficient amount capacity training data compute time representation learned model include disentangled feature corresponding highlevel concept Specifically find single unit performs sentiment analysis representation learned unsupervised manner achieve state art binary subset Stanford Sentiment Treebank also data efficient using handful labeled example approach match performance strong baseline trained full datasets also demonstrate sentiment unit direct influence generative process model Simply fixing value positive negative generates sample corresponding positive negative sentiment Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.04611093923449516, 0.05558440461754799, -0.005580800119787455, 0.02697698585689068, -0.04319903999567032, 0.011704379692673683, -0.022924331948161125, 0.0033520604483783245, -0.012462098151445389, -0.06253533810377121, 0.004261876456439495, -0.01009831391274929, -0.013715391047298908, 0.09788276255130768, -0.023839350789785385, -0.033560965210199356, 0.028832318261265755, 0.05521506071090698, 0.03502810001373291, -0.011933837085962296, 0.017634710296988487, 0.02746134251356125, 0.023842578753829002, 0.006851478014141321, -0.005904749967157841, 0.0038663458544760942, 0.01734299398958683, -0.006789231672883034, -0.039065878838300705, -0.048155527561903, 0.033038828521966934, 0.03453065827488899, 0.0010524479439482093, 0.008296774700284004, 2.17775846067525e-06, -0.011957451701164246, -0.01704253815114498, -0.04586036503314972, 0.05801549181342125, -0.03743843361735344, 0.08357296139001846, -0.05351417139172554, 0.004492538515478373, 0.0319305919110775, -0.0517239011824131, -0.04980283975601196, 0.01329498179256916, 0.0674804225564003, 0.04783235117793083, 0.053972046822309494, -0.01648610644042492, -0.04844776540994644, -0.037394072860479355, -0.01908375322818756, 0.02633834257721901, 0.030770769342780113, -0.0073411064222455025, 0.012371388264000416, -0.03258102014660835, 0.011199616827070713, -0.023509597405791283, -0.03420833498239517, -0.011768191121518612, -0.02594597637653351, 0.02709752693772316, 0.007815878838300705, 0.01453116349875927, -0.005519509315490723, 0.0032858161721378565, 0.057952459901571274, 0.01965581253170967, -0.04286131262779236, -0.002589652081951499, 0.023331210017204285, -0.0563722625374794, -0.019333403557538986, -0.012368492782115936, 0.023407069966197014, -0.006242887582629919, 0.059618521481752396, -0.006264971569180489, 0.04556112736463547, 0.027554240077733994, -0.00045382604002952576, 0.03810861334204674, 0.020443322136998177, -0.014287863858044147, -0.04888486862182617, 0.014709950424730778, 0.03598557412624359, 0.059680476784706116, -0.04136553406715393, 0.0034012787509709597, -0.0020888703875243664, 0.01982821151614189, 0.004006682429462671, 0.013930735178291798, -0.044766854494810104, 0.03448393568396568, -0.10573109984397888, 0.015007316134870052, -0.015784569084644318, 0.02842552401125431, 0.02426239848136902, -0.009609018452465534, -0.020353220403194427, 0.0260809063911438, -0.021416228264570236, -0.0034349632915109396, 0.031117748469114304, -0.06544800102710724, -0.011817247606813908, 0.026961611583828926, 0.07892286032438278, -0.0026460483204573393, 0.0024150873068720102, -0.05879076570272446, -0.025547433644533157, -0.014108885079622269, -0.0005397672648541629, 0.00172611721791327, 0.0337284579873085, -0.0011422944953665137, 0.015594429336488247, -0.04312138631939888, 0.04768383502960205, -0.045482125133275986, 0.027940141037106514, -0.038130082190036774, 0.017896810546517372, 0.013905743137001991, 0.027028454467654228, 0.012571564875543118, 0.016652045771479607, 0.01655922271311283, 0.04843044653534889, 0.04265458881855011, -0.004300304688513279, -0.04331239312887192, -0.045036617666482925, -0.011341957375407219, -0.04321850836277008, -0.019461192190647125, -0.08191298693418503, 0.010732590220868587, -0.011654311791062355, -0.029685478657484055, 0.025330016389489174, 0.01501427497714758, 0.02169676683843136, -0.016126161441206932, 0.05094704404473305, -0.06268641352653503, -0.011726333759725094, -0.013091931119561195, -0.0014472552575170994, 0.08285106718540192, 0.04313917085528374, 0.005244328174740076, 0.08036206662654877, 0.03880816325545311, -0.010027392767369747, 0.015705840662121773, -0.03225948289036751, 0.02521461993455887, -0.03677067905664444, -0.04461212456226349, -0.02215556427836418, -0.05831602215766907, -0.0050585586577653885, 0.011941276490688324, 0.03473528102040291, 0.016762549057602882, 0.01009853184223175, 0.045449282974004745, 0.01130181085318327, -0.018293824046850204, 0.07346159219741821, -0.004649360664188862, 0.019807960838079453, -0.015456188470125198, -0.01633770763874054, -0.005031904671341181, 0.04333362728357315, 0.003126297378912568, -0.006500478833913803, 0.0008563112351112068, -0.010947083123028278, -0.013458989560604095, -0.03511696308851242, 0.005018776748329401, -0.024016598239541054, 0.011173593811690807, -0.041052401065826416, 0.057852424681186676, 0.039218053221702576, -0.04718095064163208, -0.039864327758550644, 0.06006426736712456, -0.06377851963043213, 0.003144522663205862, -0.02758442424237728, 0.03672405332326889, 0.07124815136194229, 0.008465259335935116, 0.020113695412874222, 0.00965665839612484, -0.02627950720489025, -0.023277942091226578, 0.022265493869781494, 0.022360026836395264, -0.014675919897854328, -0.011928685940802097, -0.03630007430911064, 0.003960269968956709, -0.011777706444263458, 0.01953604817390442, -0.00871946383267641, -0.04529348015785217, 0.030479304492473602, -0.004622673150151968, 0.015465098433196545, -0.04813385009765625, 0.009793106466531754, 0.05003505200147629, 0.005739913322031498, 0.03616127744317055, 0.019182702526450157, 0.03521624207496643, 0.05419183149933815, -0.01297023519873619, 0.010405713692307472, 0.0469152107834816, -0.027249855920672417, -0.09439680725336075, 0.02462105266749859, -0.010174299590289593, -0.04829807206988335, -0.01738513819873333, -0.04739997908473015, 0.013853543438017368, 0.05391181632876396, -0.030703045427799225, -0.039568640291690826, 0.06692510098218918, -0.020249709486961365, 0.04830855131149292, -0.009143661707639694, -0.0211267601698637, -0.012885237112641335, 0.0019825375638902187, -0.0015916044358164072, 0.0634738951921463, -0.031185263767838478, 0.02067491039633751, -0.06631917506456375, -0.03393835946917534, 0.030314330011606216, 0.03320494294166565, -0.042805448174476624, 0.017913278192281723, -0.0035630487836897373, -0.0024461722932755947, 0.03806038573384285, 0.029879610985517502, -0.026654940098524094, -0.027234133332967758, -0.08025716990232468, -0.0047121066600084305, -0.003862410318106413, 0.009599223732948303, 0.038096070289611816, -0.017718542367219925, 0.029783962294459343, -0.003985806833952665, -0.029209572821855545, -0.005659888032823801, 0.019662000238895416, 0.012285618111491203, 0.03869342431426048, -0.0036031161434948444, 0.03419094160199165, -0.044863320887088776, -0.012737822718918324, -0.03454789146780968, 0.018016304820775986, 0.04468699172139168, -0.06153304502367973, 0.007125291973352432, 0.022347642108798027, -0.030310191214084625, 0.0073509858921170235, 0.0101720429956913, -0.06139463931322098, -0.0030533401295542717, -0.01730174943804741, 0.013800141401588917, 0.033212319016456604, 0.03687022998929024, 0.03936103358864784, 0.01707342080771923, 0.004833522252738476, 0.0003296647628303617, 0.006997871212661266, -0.057560015469789505, 0.011231258511543274, 0.022144300863146782, -0.022910507395863533, 0.003500338876619935, 0.08026187866926193, 0.04257277771830559, -0.005672148894518614, -0.02709745429456234, 0.00036905394517816603, -0.035298243165016174, -0.0008543091244064271, -0.01644030213356018, -0.009244401007890701, 0.01786981150507927, 0.02800826169550419, -0.015165964141488075, -0.03772652894258499, 0.04909811168909073, 0.029008975252509117, 0.010096830315887928, -0.0706879049539566, -0.010154267773032188, -0.0023154534865170717, 0.07160644978284836, -0.008660073392093182, 0.028900492936372757, -0.04362546280026436, 0.01048129890114069, 0.004527301527559757, -0.008397497236728668, -0.00443928362801671, -0.015145414508879185, -0.0051131765358150005, -0.019433310255408287, -0.005193336401134729, -0.006015402730554342, -0.03204219043254852, 0.02452525869011879, -0.022091569378972054, -0.027847912162542343, -0.036726273596286774, 0.056778911501169205, -0.020171530544757843, 0.007350921630859375, 0.004746878985315561, -0.024378489702939987, -0.02203396148979664, -0.02076229825615883, -0.021326055750250816, 0.028894446790218353, 0.005063912365585566, 0.07791439443826675, -0.04156896099448204, -0.006102577783167362, 0.0016830957029014826, 0.0033228774555027485, 0.05239126831293106, -0.031263165175914764, 0.00975990854203701, -0.05744108930230141, -0.018519682809710503, 0.011426116339862347, 0.006412420887500048, 0.003140426008030772, -0.03150410205125809, 0.02803594432771206, -0.05179008096456528, -0.010633218102157116, 0.09145577251911163, 0.02344895526766777, -0.0868866816163063, -0.01239216048270464, 0.00699956901371479, -0.006912246812134981, 0.042532965540885925, -0.006027968600392342, -0.05618732422590256, -0.01285315491259098, -0.04805527254939079, 0.01415879838168621, -0.01082809641957283, -0.025777621194720268, -0.007136325817555189, -0.1188463568687439, -0.011901111342012882, -0.027832213789224625, -0.004185120575129986, -0.06181886047124863, -0.05801418796181679, -0.04612695053219795, -0.012590459547936916, -0.03187619149684906, 0.013003972359001637, 0.0005980653804726899, 0.025003671646118164, 0.0028255244251340628, -0.06297599524259567, 0.006015225313603878, 0.049477141350507736, -0.023591700941324234, 0.05075649917125702, 0.07906285673379898, 0.06951980292797089, -0.026401041075587273, 0.014032640494406223, -0.005429401528090239, -0.023797249421477318, -0.01345514040440321, -0.0453697107732296, 0.08865270018577576, -0.017100811004638672, -0.014470626600086689, -0.04238053038716316, 0.027512144297361374, -0.05425773933529854, 0.055346470326185226, 0.004578738007694483, 0.02929779328405857, -0.0069609698839485645, -0.04407650604844093, -0.06529250741004944, 0.0691429153084755, 0.033841121941804886, 0.03615559637546539, 0.0031078821048140526, -0.06699429452419281, -0.04619539901614189, 0.0005927064921706915, 0.022471288219094276, -0.05585087463259697, -0.03495873510837555, -0.05024946853518486, 0.012179174460470676, -0.030873028561472893, -0.12100648134946823, -0.037672579288482666, -0.02981262281537056, 0.028788473457098007, 0.014948775060474873, 0.02745615877211094, 0.01497246976941824, -0.022221354767680168, -0.04044996574521065, -0.03301554173231125, 0.0529397688806057, 0.002743289340287447, -0.03076406754553318, -0.06295128166675568, 0.09335775673389435, 0.023250864818692207, -0.01276119239628315, -0.05327405035495758, -0.03308210149407387, -0.032426703721284866, -0.0038121931720525026, 0.0734250396490097, 0.0108475461602211, -0.01969974674284458, -0.013963747769594193, -0.023318735882639885, 0.0012398752151057124, 0.009372360073029995, -0.040627527981996536, -0.012600984424352646, 0.021071307361125946, 0.0599537268280983, 0.011457493528723717, 0.02014041133224964, -0.029069337993860245, 0.07053738087415695, -0.0031310992781072855, -0.03232099115848541, -0.034007590264081955, 0.011269849725067616, 0.025924725458025932, -0.034870874136686325, 0.06447859108448029, 0.01661362312734127, 0.00597827322781086, -0.005337866488844156, 0.019653400406241417, -0.0565626434981823, -0.019104549661278725, -0.0427619032561779, 0.015497439540922642, 0.03566574305295944, 0.029224539175629616, -0.04478992149233818, -0.018372097983956337, -0.002910736482590437, 0.03968694433569908, 0.00985149946063757, 0.056747645139694214, 0.023198561742901802, 0.03423522040247917, -0.013597098179161549, 0.023781955242156982, -0.021816108375787735, -0.014530242420732975, 0.020673630759119987, 0.004139777738600969, 0.0009601995698176324, 0.03167298808693886, 0.0050004953518509865, 0.012805843725800514, -0.025115033611655235, 0.0230240561068058, -0.012324745766818523, 0.009933662600815296, -0.03620820865035057, -0.0025144238024950027, -0.0036564504262059927, -0.012809441424906254, 0.028030864894390106, -0.00011426176934037358, 0.008981110528111458, 0.013408824801445007, 0.047937165945768356, -0.04964366555213928, -0.008301318623125553, 0.033307187259197235, -0.009896526113152504, -0.03231181204319, -0.00981973297894001, 0.08651023358106613, -0.0328628346323967, 0.0024194512516260147, 0.03175102546811104, 0.006009997799992561, -0.02525067701935768, 0.02592054195702076, 0.02266630530357361, 0.017402956262230873, 0.03012426197528839, 0.041041746735572815, -0.05188250541687012, -0.024253126233816147, 0.04072132706642151, -0.004788799677044153, 0.09492915123701096, 0.011296464130282402, 0.050974588841199875, 0.07015585899353027, 0.025559764355421066, 0.03572482243180275, -0.06061497703194618, 0.006373024079948664, -0.00941311102360487, -0.024523191154003143, -0.058954838663339615, -6.456165418969342e-33, -0.013043683022260666, -0.038830067962408066, -0.04745565727353096, 0.028185337781906128, -0.0037290339823812246, -0.008693127892911434, -0.04649285599589348, 0.031374771147966385, -0.0008223595796152949, 0.040712788701057434, -0.0005903088604100049, 0.0241691917181015, -0.011995580047369003, 0.03566550090909004, 0.06238601729273796, 0.002001036424189806, 0.05086394399404526, -0.023990539833903313, 0.02745218575000763, 0.05955756455659866, 0.06022705137729645, 0.019041478633880615, 0.030318308621644974, -0.09910394251346588, 0.025701703503727913, -0.006295779719948769, -0.060682058334350586, -0.002077912911772728, 0.009980905801057816, 0.016055604442954063, -0.01861334778368473, 0.052243709564208984, 0.03194072097539902, -0.018119802698493004, -0.014776195399463177, 0.011167175136506557, -0.046955835074186325, -0.036415960639715195, -0.02366841584444046, -0.018100034445524216, -0.013621477410197258, 0.023195898160338402, 0.0488843098282814, 0.0226527638733387, -0.023047883063554764, 0.0346280001103878, 0.04324690252542496, -0.014918026514351368, -0.011145063675940037, -0.11821401864290237, -0.07362659275531769, 0.0032331948168575764, 0.0058365571312606335, 0.018759509548544884, -0.017772560939192772, 0.015359131619334221, -0.00027621802291832864, 0.052690982818603516, -0.07114999741315842, 0.03549768030643463, -0.018844911828637123, 0.06337475776672363, 0.014409211464226246, -0.02313830330967903, 0.022587576881051064, 0.07787787169218063, 0.011056377552449703, 0.04938676580786705, -0.015068122185766697, 0.07335691154003143, 0.0033306642435491085, 0.005759240593761206, 0.041574954986572266, 0.05307209864258766, 0.04630016162991524, -0.08406655490398407, -0.04561980441212654, 0.017190614715218544, 0.05550936236977577, 0.006182659417390823, 0.0397842675447464, -0.015091989189386368, -0.014834865927696228, -0.01048852689564228, 0.02604779042303562, -0.03373797982931137, -0.013091674074530602, -0.05937687307596207, -0.02586125023663044, 0.013428532518446445, -0.035869039595127106, -0.037125203758478165, -0.028350340202450752, -0.060553692281246185, -0.027363575994968414, 0.016235625371336937, -0.021225543692708015, 0.016633011400699615, 0.009101919829845428, -0.034444719552993774, -0.07100694626569748, -0.002268887124955654, -0.05085519701242447, 0.044966258108615875, 0.0008547533070668578, 0.011935578659176826, 0.04803071543574333, 0.023780588060617447, -0.09903748333454132, -0.01581323705613613, 0.01678180694580078, 0.014815020374953747, 0.017046870663762093, 0.06356575340032578, -0.008103887550532818, -0.020569488406181335, -0.020239444449543953, 0.0728079304099083, -6.050835509086028e-05, 0.05967451632022858, -0.012996329925954342, 0.009670847095549107, -0.006666170433163643, 0.011837019585072994, -0.056538037955760956, -0.03928929939866066, -0.03334265947341919, -0.03523072972893715, 0.013968982733786106, -0.05730903893709183, -0.01580304466187954, 0.010864685289561749, 2.8776241833838867e-07, 0.014219138771295547, 0.04668198525905609, -0.0175345279276371, -0.051263950765132904, 0.043011441826820374, 0.0511195994913578, 0.015653952956199646, 0.004588075447827578, -0.009170315228402615, -0.018280936405062675, 0.0062024472281336784, -0.03419598564505577, 0.0076002939604222775, 0.014102530665695667, -0.13116508722305298, 0.048475153744220734, -0.06164894998073578, -0.029176022857427597, -0.010849916376173496, -0.0033694468438625336, 0.06574074923992157, 0.11295808851718903, 0.025524761527776718, 0.0026692524552345276, 0.009065594524145126, -0.0007830443209968507, 0.030599774792790413, -0.007296273950487375, -0.014446658082306385, -0.00017255255079362541, -0.014889861457049847, -0.011148013174533844, -0.054042961448431015, -0.045904044061899185, -0.05599737912416458, 1.6645512005197816e-05, -0.03342621773481369, 0.030918624252080917, 0.008118088357150555, -0.03559550270438194, 0.03348921611905098, 0.020996397361159325, 0.01471258606761694, -0.011004152707755566, 0.0567835308611393, -0.054583847522735596, -0.05588419735431671, -0.10593162477016449, 0.022192100062966347, 0.026553036645054817, 0.031859103590250015, -0.014190702699124813, -0.025526436045765877, 0.01693587750196457, -0.010719017125666142, -0.024426618590950966, -0.0180829931050539, -0.053331177681684494, 0.010052064433693886, 0.024440642446279526, 0.012060954235494137, -0.02874068170785904, 0.035783037543296814, 0.035870056599378586, 0.006820992100983858, 0.00669087702408433, 0.031380489468574524, 2.7078850873547895e-34, 0.08303382992744446, -0.033188145607709885, -0.008173440583050251, -0.002638265723362565, 0.024144554510712624, -0.030723702162504196, -0.05116807296872139, -0.002377905650064349, 0.020822929218411446, -0.009430011734366417, -0.014342228882014751]
636
636
['Marek Rei']
1704.07156v1
We propose a sequence labeling framework with a secondary training objective, learning to predict surrounding words for every word in the dataset. This language modeling objective incentivises the system to learn general-purpose patterns of semantic and syntactic composition, which are also useful for improving accuracy on different sequence labeling tasks. The architecture was evaluated on a range of datasets, covering the tasks of error detection in learner texts, named entity recognition, chunking and POS-tagging. The novel language modeling objective provided consistent performance improvements on every benchmark, without requiring any additional annotated or unannotated data.
Semi-supervised Multitask Learning for Sequence Labeling
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1704.07156v1
Title Semisupervised Multitask Learning Sequence Labeling Summary propose sequence labeling framework secondary training objective learning predict surrounding word every word dataset language modeling objective incentivises system learn generalpurpose pattern semantic syntactic composition also useful improving accuracy different sequence labeling task architecture evaluated range datasets covering task error detection learner text named entity recognition chunking POStagging novel language modeling objective provided consistent performance improvement every benchmark without requiring additional annotated unannotated data Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.05621160566806793, -0.00344303366728127, 0.021400338038802147, 0.00940660759806633, -0.03424806892871857, 0.039948977530002594, -0.0034205468837171793, -0.040986593812704086, 0.03295162692666054, -0.06236645206809044, -0.036111000925302505, -0.030893437564373016, -0.014165043830871582, 0.058400969952344894, 0.01943737082183361, -0.052354954183101654, 0.039066560566425323, 0.020366022363305092, 0.04352416843175888, 0.07139609754085541, 0.02075180970132351, 0.01671265996992588, -0.03536085784435272, 0.02953844889998436, -0.033540431410074234, 0.008906759321689606, -0.009975653141736984, -0.04188281670212746, 0.01716105453670025, -0.069365955889225, 0.046424489468336105, 0.0683969035744667, 0.016252215951681137, 0.02558234892785549, 2.1479572751559317e-06, -0.027288099750876427, -0.06259122490882874, -0.02580859325826168, -0.036548011004924774, -0.06916322559118271, 0.028434082865715027, -0.015314439311623573, -0.006376487202942371, -0.005596490111202002, -0.0440155453979969, -0.02466677315533161, 0.06643703579902649, 0.05563616007566452, 0.03742750734090805, 0.06501518189907074, -0.01654769666492939, -0.019730841740965843, -0.00017391501751262695, -0.0037255845963954926, -0.009101767092943192, -0.03140690177679062, 0.02818818762898445, 0.02460983768105507, 0.02519896999001503, -0.003295936156064272, -0.005597343202680349, 0.03050994500517845, -0.005976990330964327, -0.023589488118886948, -0.009335312992334366, 0.037645913660526276, -0.0006211491418071091, -0.048966147005558014, 0.003137438790872693, 0.08274705708026886, -0.015655413269996643, 0.000662431470118463, 0.03610740229487419, -0.0011892897309735417, -0.036808229982852936, -0.023873141035437584, -0.019653454422950745, 0.020159734413027763, -0.036350201815366745, -0.022058116272091866, 0.03174537047743797, 0.02340814284980297, 0.0064955102279782295, 0.012595267966389656, -0.024836789816617966, 0.03306769207119942, -0.006482783239334822, -0.029902063310146332, -0.014425676316022873, 0.008234472014009953, -0.003248017281293869, -0.04881611466407776, 0.08400117605924606, 0.017252923920750618, -0.03810679167509079, 0.03590213507413864, -0.0423438586294651, -0.11493012309074402, 0.013057337142527103, -0.03585332632064819, 0.014741654507815838, -0.011669152416288853, -0.029653873294591904, 0.0280444473028183, 0.00024131110694725066, -0.0062736705876886845, 0.020586838945746422, 0.01782127283513546, -0.02952595427632332, -0.0014074462233111262, -0.07848017662763596, -0.0038755792193114758, -0.03699762746691704, 0.05562227591872215, -0.002584486035630107, -0.01589474081993103, -0.0674256905913353, -0.005939407739788294, 0.011883808299899101, 0.008426913991570473, 0.012918313965201378, -0.009232775308191776, -0.0458451546728611, -0.008557574823498726, 0.012611043639481068, -0.017115654423832893, -0.01295759342610836, 0.025741636753082275, -0.007261327467858791, -0.026021618396043777, -0.004023738671094179, 0.03285996615886688, 0.03675588220357895, -0.022621678188443184, 0.0049780597910285, 0.05644015222787857, 0.009748470038175583, -0.062157802283763885, -0.034267108887434006, -0.0457862988114357, -0.03510896861553192, -0.03359345346689224, -0.053814295679330826, -0.02623605728149414, 0.027784502133727074, -0.018670465797185898, -0.017164891585707664, 0.011925416998565197, 0.024920834228396416, 0.012614346109330654, -0.01453726552426815, 0.08973857015371323, -0.04201411083340645, -0.029905959963798523, 0.01790625974535942, 0.00947520136833191, 0.05859125405550003, 0.02602389268577099, 0.04194191098213196, 0.04106198623776436, 0.05409418046474457, -0.007389819249510765, 0.017499303445219994, 0.023573072627186775, -0.01620952971279621, -0.05283678323030472, 0.010905579663813114, -0.007244609296321869, 0.06874877959489822, -0.016279058530926704, -0.004578660242259502, 0.036842357367277145, 0.02528495527803898, 0.02025889791548252, 0.016454806551337242, 0.06386196613311768, -0.01926436275243759, -0.01558877993375063, 0.04105302691459656, 0.049701448529958725, -0.025186194106936455, 0.014398082159459591, 0.0038602903950959444, 0.020432129502296448, 0.0227003563195467, 0.020106201991438866, 0.0045913150534033775, -0.02286684140563011, -0.0019784190226346254, -0.023813189938664436, -0.01036038901656866, -0.03257272392511368, -0.005365901160985231, -0.00462774932384491, 0.0802006796002388, 0.015260925516486168, -0.08648832887411118, -0.005300873424857855, 0.0013380064629018307, -0.024288902059197426, -0.008608534932136536, 0.002658597193658352, -0.018694058060646057, 0.0355556458234787, 0.02289157174527645, -0.059438660740852356, -0.06134311109781265, -0.02913212962448597, 0.024637432768940926, -0.012224902398884296, -0.00754934037104249, -0.053388260304927826, 0.012988157570362091, -0.06982260197401047, -0.02314361184835434, 0.031838905066251755, -0.03068201057612896, -0.0018204360967501998, -0.028733687475323677, -0.021479805931448936, 0.036345139145851135, 0.025076180696487427, -0.0317428819835186, 0.06735025346279144, -0.02795560285449028, -0.04628182575106621, 0.02287844382226467, 0.027294360101222992, 0.02932910807430744, 0.051758963614702225, -0.013982614502310753, 0.018210183829069138, 0.04048791900277138, -0.016008054837584496, 0.016306668519973755, 0.016168594360351562, -0.019439851865172386, -0.025570260360836983, 0.009887950494885445, 0.009541505016386509, -0.04265955463051796, 0.01115733478218317, -0.02942718006670475, -0.08363446593284607, -0.0401623509824276, -0.010279381647706032, -0.02543964795768261, -0.016206447035074234, 0.03489965200424194, 0.054445791989564896, 0.012971506454050541, -0.04087800532579422, 0.03507533669471741, 0.014956168830394745, 0.03048750013113022, -0.01869879849255085, -0.022908460348844528, -0.0007421220652759075, -0.029651470482349396, -0.0025750368367880583, 0.015667449682950974, -0.02757817506790161, -0.0524614118039608, 0.009774452075362206, -0.012765400111675262, -0.07358383387327194, -0.0011248934315517545, -0.05326126888394356, 0.016742289066314697, -0.009440498426556587, 0.06780091673135757, 0.0016443765489384532, 0.005334370769560337, -0.01497019175440073, -0.04694341868162155, -0.021138712763786316, -0.002772164298221469, 0.012130617164075375, -0.022613950073719025, 0.04277484491467476, 0.024769246578216553, 0.0030670033302158117, -0.04358328878879547, 0.0012664395617321134, -0.033742353320121765, 0.008793188259005547, 0.02844000793993473, -0.1028783842921257, -0.02840549312531948, -0.003342290176078677, 0.009065929800271988, 0.013287234120070934, 0.010129825212061405, 0.0015497540589421988, -0.01332910731434822, 0.0009736091597005725, 0.028752397745847702, 0.010437814518809319, 0.015902135521173477, 0.0025272532366216183, 0.03104998730123043, -0.030552424490451813, 0.021827731281518936, 0.010779282078146935, -0.0182355847209692, 0.05965171754360199, 0.01902523823082447, -0.026900524273514748, 0.008039113134145737, 0.09259694814682007, -0.006967345718294382, 0.01117422804236412, -0.0033925273455679417, -0.04286598414182663, -0.010483991354703903, -0.02230001613497734, -0.018194682896137238, -0.0092274509370327, -0.022126881405711174, -0.0031896873842924833, -0.023224089294672012, -0.03122168593108654, 0.051982566714286804, -0.011326650157570839, -0.04988391324877739, -0.08466200530529022, -0.017422957345843315, -0.007827285677194595, 0.10394026339054108, 0.0014673133846372366, -0.0018544078338891268, 0.03469505533576012, -0.05627364292740822, 0.016070779412984848, 0.02852444536983967, -0.0019665558356791735, -0.027742797508835793, 0.015531301498413086, -0.06307370960712433, 0.016245752573013306, -0.04592295363545418, 0.00261006411164999, -0.030325312167406082, 0.012643096037209034, -0.029450740665197372, 0.0009137901361100376, 0.020403053611516953, 0.019087037071585655, -0.036243245005607605, 0.020581120625138283, 0.0053076609037816525, 0.055863093584775925, -0.0024035663809627295, 0.004825538024306297, -0.01819402538239956, 0.05242209881544113, 0.05067269504070282, -0.005116682033985853, -0.0495348758995533, 0.00015672216250095516, -0.01601678878068924, 0.03627614676952362, 0.01835555210709572, -0.015064364299178123, 0.021881423890590668, -0.026936063542962074, 0.03810757398605347, -0.076433926820755, -0.036355406045913696, 0.006022399757057428, 0.027468305081129074, -0.06668785959482193, -0.003979337401688099, 0.1048712283372879, 0.03476978838443756, -0.04470699653029442, -0.000987039296887815, 0.00503059197217226, -0.05800246447324753, 0.024553416296839714, 0.03041190095245838, -0.06512800604104996, -0.02599024586379528, 0.0013880308251827955, 0.015642086043953896, -0.011498929932713509, -0.05579063668847084, -0.03493403643369675, -0.06913849711418152, 0.03767155855894089, -0.029024695977568626, -0.06376056373119354, 0.015855489298701286, -0.04641890525817871, -0.024233471602201462, -0.02440733276307583, -0.05560179054737091, -0.016901763156056404, 0.008112091571092606, -0.00900750607252121, 0.05378161743283272, -0.04287584125995636, -0.054130859673023224, -0.008593540638685226, -0.04087439551949501, 0.030873455107212067, 0.042156822979450226, 0.04851119592785835, -0.0162820927798748, -0.0010895384475588799, 0.0013407750520855188, -0.01359253004193306, -0.039765749126672745, -0.026301663368940353, 0.06083280220627785, -0.05869941785931587, -0.010780556127429008, -0.04324595257639885, 0.026767505332827568, -0.01673107035458088, -0.006550660356879234, 0.02110975608229637, 0.024685770273208618, -0.011452442035079002, 0.04146316647529602, -0.022956857457756996, 0.0077979676425457, 0.04488593712449074, 0.006286080926656723, -0.006292686797678471, -0.010141436010599136, -0.004213469568639994, -0.032728858292102814, 0.01422236580401659, -0.06010742112994194, 0.009899171069264412, -0.019934242591261864, -0.06540771573781967, -0.04257579147815704, -0.07469894737005234, -0.03901493549346924, 0.06073348969221115, 0.05756470933556557, 0.0429757758975029, 0.05359889939427376, 0.00637277914211154, -0.014766807667911053, -0.0929654985666275, -0.03562469780445099, 0.03283587843179703, 0.03022695891559124, -0.07962678372859955, -0.035831328481435776, 0.058862168341875076, 0.011209453456103802, 0.003571227425709367, 0.008795901201665401, -0.06203068047761917, -0.04733738303184509, -0.012607480399310589, 0.0426415354013443, -0.001805808860808611, 0.0012138846796005964, -0.009171823970973492, -0.02686140686273575, -0.021666934713721275, 0.016168147325515747, -0.03459763899445534, -0.0721932128071785, 0.03349585086107254, -0.013318169862031937, -0.023732265457510948, 0.006741707678884268, -0.013315092772245407, 0.050566334277391434, -0.0018976150313392282, 0.026823455467820168, -0.011852285824716091, -0.008513327687978745, 0.011346914805471897, 0.007767926435917616, 0.07567046582698822, -0.011232527904212475, 0.006783996243029833, -0.06899537146091461, 0.01480067614465952, 0.0014354385202750564, -0.030215105041861534, -0.0060459161177277565, 0.042375385761260986, 0.03806353732943535, -0.00489161629229784, -0.005781019572168589, 0.07923310250043869, -0.022502833977341652, 0.0004016153689008206, 0.017050279304385185, 0.08109066635370255, -0.014390877448022366, 0.04129999503493309, -0.0365447923541069, -0.009120052680373192, -0.003500020829960704, -0.019246160984039307, 0.06089125946164131, 0.07563025504350662, 0.007187481503933668, 0.03870907425880432, 0.012291193939745426, 0.024903958663344383, 0.020250841975212097, 0.06070404499769211, 0.006264502182602882, 0.05424897000193596, -0.053350355476140976, 0.020383846014738083, 0.06769704073667526, -0.05837250128388405, 0.04394960403442383, -0.0147227318957448, 0.01046088244765997, -0.019811896607279778, 0.07206068187952042, -0.03384684398770332, -0.028460074216127396, 0.016342319548130035, -0.0012706526322290301, -0.02874160371720791, -0.0021218005567789078, 0.081267349421978, 0.019118942320346832, 0.021958105266094208, 0.061846453696489334, -0.03217116370797157, -0.04762788861989975, -0.007290289271622896, 0.006606648210436106, 0.03638983145356178, -0.04472262039780617, 0.006857967469841242, -0.003944283816963434, -0.03277847170829773, 0.011896474286913872, -0.015810033306479454, 0.02359112724661827, 0.012057388201355934, 0.02337651699781418, 0.004944466520100832, 0.016722839325666428, 0.004850415978580713, -0.05940602719783783, -0.00785444863140583, 0.050535399466753006, -0.022685818374156952, -0.022969210520386696, -5.764516665231001e-33, -0.02981497347354889, -0.07346873730421066, 0.01897639036178589, -0.018041275441646576, 0.0159837044775486, 0.023768659681081772, -0.026547865942120552, 0.01088806800544262, 0.04228803142905235, -0.020299194380640984, 0.00440765218809247, -0.026289967820048332, 0.042818255722522736, 0.023897744715213776, 0.059416454285383224, 0.005793239455670118, 0.035288672894239426, 0.010690532624721527, 0.011668055318295956, -0.007713547442108393, 0.035447925329208374, 0.061874136328697205, 0.1532358080148697, -0.09369439631700516, 0.062395986169576645, 0.02714557945728302, 0.02994609996676445, -0.020534908398985863, 0.046888090670108795, 0.029485102742910385, -0.029850494116544724, -0.0054217674769461155, 0.02691255323588848, -0.06516456604003906, -0.03350615128874779, 0.05112971365451813, -0.08566983044147491, -0.003648490644991398, -0.026046786457300186, 0.01588287763297558, -0.025163328275084496, -0.02728845924139023, -0.002469872124493122, 0.003226892789825797, -0.00010657466191332787, 0.04614592343568802, 0.057002805173397064, -0.029888680204749107, -0.022893119603395462, -0.01977981999516487, -0.08585446327924728, 0.052180200815200806, -0.015351857990026474, -0.027835918590426445, 0.08702012151479721, 0.043769437819719315, 0.0281464122235775, -0.02177116461098194, -0.04770531505346298, 0.028506696224212646, -0.04311689734458923, 0.041395265609025955, 0.07279530167579651, 0.047622065991163254, 0.001419902895577252, 0.03821662813425064, 0.017226427793502808, 0.019235115498304367, 0.006631071213632822, 0.005760765168815851, -0.025465011596679688, 0.018913518637418747, 0.02321069873869419, -0.012344532646238804, 0.04083126038312912, 0.010856060311198235, -0.04152844846248627, 0.0569283626973629, 0.003067192155867815, 0.008453636430203915, 0.0027893634978681803, 0.010580979287624359, -0.038249656558036804, 0.01990387588739395, 0.012675494886934757, 0.031141025945544243, 0.0009235251927748322, -0.018481211736798286, 0.02168363705277443, 0.006618978921324015, -0.026981744915246964, 0.05285702645778656, 0.003884870558977127, -0.011627517640590668, -0.03833850845694542, -0.0528748519718647, 0.03805001825094223, 0.005995601881295443, -0.01887688972055912, -0.0032459658104926348, -0.09927864372730255, -0.04249515011906624, 0.020675016567111015, 0.02825932204723358, 0.02206527628004551, -0.006086647976189852, 0.04348907619714737, -0.010256150737404823, -0.03173738345503807, 0.009638405404984951, 0.013690752908587456, 0.01612052693963051, 0.032010484486818314, 0.06312278658151627, 0.04196103662252426, -0.04712611064314842, -0.014739657752215862, 0.08172910660505295, 0.03816565126180649, -0.04973223805427551, -0.004269796423614025, -0.023149017244577408, 0.01275912206619978, 0.007094135973602533, -0.015461629256606102, 0.005609062500298023, -0.055580392479896545, -0.012731892988085747, -0.014619668014347553, -0.019261522218585014, 0.01652376726269722, 0.021944241598248482, 2.6892342930295854e-07, 0.04298330843448639, 0.052794940769672394, 0.07557450979948044, -0.014674382284283638, -0.02121509425342083, 0.006497214548289776, -0.020891251042485237, 0.061597514897584915, -0.05913787707686424, 0.016664521768689156, 0.01647157035768032, -0.060866132378578186, 0.04395047575235367, 0.01234775222837925, -0.10767029970884323, -0.06471440941095352, -0.04486207291483879, 0.012723986059427261, -0.05642613396048546, 0.0371653214097023, 0.07418354600667953, 0.0932510644197464, -0.0013590218732133508, 0.013598999008536339, 0.007641985546797514, -0.03202320635318756, -0.000699241238180548, 0.001841842313297093, 0.013221312314271927, 0.022916149348020554, 0.004769830033183098, 0.021006302908062935, -0.05507335811853409, 0.03557981923222542, -0.05368683859705925, -0.006182611454278231, 0.030380472540855408, 0.056161802262067795, -0.014608735218644142, 0.007296076510101557, 0.01792951114475727, 0.02526254393160343, 0.02303159050643444, -0.010773149318993092, 0.0588134303689003, -0.006047248840332031, -0.06319835036993027, 0.0012635191669687629, 0.016719389706850052, 0.020604128018021584, -0.02227979525923729, -0.002243389142677188, 0.01419543195515871, 0.02861841581761837, 0.032431866973638535, -0.04845864698290825, -0.03807953745126724, -0.06895098835229874, -0.005498271435499191, 0.01647893898189068, 0.014772499911487103, 0.029204702004790306, -0.022702202200889587, -0.01894805021584034, 0.017618825659155846, -0.028388842940330505, -0.020606771111488342, 2.615486180427869e-34, 0.002911344636231661, -0.006372912786900997, -0.030559903010725975, 0.05098775029182434, -0.0063189794309437275, -0.007130210753530264, -0.05247252807021141, 0.026215460151433945, -0.017992379143834114, -0.03860092535614967, -0.03615851700305939]
637
637
['Danhao Zhu', 'Si Shen', 'Xin-Yu Dai', 'Jiajun Chen']
1705.01346v1
Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) has been widely applied for sequence modeling. In RNN, the hidden states at current step are full connected to those at previous step, thus the influence from less related features at previous step may potentially decrease model's learning ability. We propose a simple technique called parallel cells (PCs) to enhance the learning ability of Recurrent Neural Network (RNN). In each layer, we run multiple small RNN cells rather than one single large cell. In this paper, we evaluate PCs on 2 tasks. On language modeling task on PTB (Penn Tree Bank), our model outperforms state of art models by decreasing perplexity from 78.6 to 75.3. On Chinese-English translation task, our model increases BLEU score for 0.39 points than baseline model.
Going Wider: Recurrent Neural Network With Parallel Cells
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1705.01346v1
Title Going Wider Recurrent Neural Network Parallel Cells Summary Recurrent Neural Network RNN widely applied sequence modeling RNN hidden state current step full connected previous step thus influence le related feature previous step may potentially decrease model learning ability propose simple technique called parallel cell PCs enhance learning ability Recurrent Neural Network RNN layer run multiple small RNN cell rather one single large cell paper evaluate PCs 2 task language modeling task PTB Penn Tree Bank model outperforms state art model decreasing perplexity 786 753 ChineseEnglish translation task model increase BLEU score 039 point baseline model Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.009379123337566853, 0.025332294404506683, -0.024564344435930252, 0.029763156548142433, -0.04892450571060181, 0.014327235519886017, 0.052719030529260635, -0.021398676559329033, -0.05949936434626579, -0.007525046821683645, 0.010927753522992134, -0.06231151521205902, 0.04505552724003792, 0.01007845439016819, 0.02437165006995201, -0.04486626759171486, 0.05186132341623306, 0.011581246741116047, 0.0022229759488254786, -0.006073246710002422, 0.0030552346725016832, -0.004447569139301777, 0.005545635707676411, 0.05057355761528015, 0.005529013462364674, -0.039320237934589386, -0.019162919372320175, -0.01830454170703888, -0.01222191657871008, -0.08996676653623581, -0.0035455545876175165, 0.04542246833443642, 0.028490278869867325, 0.07118690013885498, 2.53276834882854e-06, -0.01862136647105217, -0.007362012751400471, -0.006460186559706926, 0.02114890143275261, 0.04958353191614151, 0.027378715574741364, 0.019744550809264183, 0.011875126510858536, 0.02131892926990986, -0.023987509310245514, -0.02074255421757698, 0.06279663741588593, 0.04006199166178703, 0.027209805324673653, 0.0486317053437233, -0.00546224182471633, -0.03344298526644707, 0.016001421958208084, -0.04393845051527023, 0.023622117936611176, -0.03772951662540436, 0.0261963102966547, 0.004151111003011465, 0.012565209530293941, -0.041929978877305984, -0.026694146916270256, 0.03401423245668411, 0.047312699258327484, 0.022708607837557793, -0.002770742168650031, 0.029607752338051796, 0.030885230749845505, -0.0486709289252758, -0.02581080049276352, 0.02402709238231182, -0.08123867213726044, 0.0026370768900960684, -9.763662092154846e-05, -0.020685331895947456, -0.025044282898306847, -0.019068550318479538, -0.06068001314997673, 0.029044589027762413, -0.034960370510816574, 0.005720652639865875, -0.002842911286279559, 0.0037545489612966776, 0.06818465888500214, -0.015563602559268475, -0.01990232616662979, -0.018165884539484978, 0.00659922556951642, -0.03976067528128624, -0.024401379749178886, -0.010108690708875656, 0.011365799233317375, -0.050732653588056564, 0.03287052735686302, 0.03014804981648922, 0.019681071862578392, 0.033262308686971664, 0.0055180927738547325, -0.09274479746818542, 0.04034117981791496, -0.06795081496238708, 0.08500508964061737, 0.010686907917261124, 0.0001930536818690598, -0.011875586584210396, -0.02645592950284481, 0.04878859594464302, -0.03777196258306503, -0.008924063295125961, -0.022733131423592567, 0.025045229122042656, -0.06458251923322678, -0.002462751464918256, 0.012223607860505581, 0.04140623286366463, -0.040485769510269165, -0.03895986080169678, -0.07444361597299576, 5.29225253558252e-05, -0.011033061891794205, -0.03363996744155884, 0.03614179790019989, 0.039421241730451584, -0.015432555228471756, 0.02347707748413086, 0.020641371607780457, 0.06067992374300957, -0.018147725611925125, 0.012069759890437126, -0.014881707727909088, -0.03349018469452858, -0.034564029425382614, -0.013931879773736, -0.02285696379840374, 0.02281971089541912, -0.019144844263792038, 0.06813184916973114, 0.02348281256854534, -0.005514919757843018, -0.0514165535569191, 0.008438813500106335, -0.03192831575870514, -0.04759827256202698, -0.00884849950671196, -0.07824307680130005, 0.00048229616368189454, -0.03906942531466484, -0.007316922768950462, 0.01702110469341278, 0.010873110964894295, 0.007421193178743124, 0.0034396369010210037, 0.060101449489593506, 0.0003863968886435032, -0.01483191829174757, 0.07017119228839874, 0.01479842234402895, 0.039912328124046326, 0.027482682839035988, 0.058619264513254166, 0.012322717346251011, 0.01029291283339262, -0.046040140092372894, -0.011633629910647869, 0.02835908532142639, -0.003966765943914652, -0.05612732842564583, -0.039888523519039154, -0.05460507050156593, 0.025177082046866417, 0.06934252381324768, -0.0070520746521651745, 0.016127148643136024, -0.013300571590662003, -0.005767740309238434, 0.04728969186544418, 0.07291123270988464, 0.02193409949541092, 0.0756935179233551, 0.014808387495577335, -0.021232832223176956, 0.01132485456764698, 0.013237874023616314, -0.0009999634930863976, 0.06544239819049835, -0.004918105900287628, 0.03189830482006073, -0.026154005900025368, 0.025618355721235275, -0.025196829810738564, -0.041051775217056274, -0.013177352957427502, -0.015873676165938377, -0.005047322250902653, -0.016478130593895912, 0.03967743739485741, 0.010213111527264118, -0.04284452646970749, -0.011500340886414051, 0.025104131549596786, -0.03630021587014198, -0.017345380038022995, -0.026465173810720444, -0.006076463498175144, 0.0440334714949131, 0.005197794642299414, -0.01105585042387247, -0.039154574275016785, -0.033113766461610794, -0.0470060296356678, 0.03917895630002022, 0.02265702746808529, 0.006903721019625664, 0.011401085183024406, -0.07677701115608215, -0.0012177957687526941, 0.014802452176809311, -0.012755852192640305, 0.047735828906297684, -0.012124733068048954, 0.019336799159646034, 0.018080949783325195, 0.04892079159617424, -0.04473356157541275, 0.0367862805724144, -0.04082199186086655, 0.01208288874477148, 0.030267314985394478, 0.01029585674405098, 0.02441040240228176, 0.01071846205741167, 0.017306987196207047, 0.012441369704902172, 0.07564130425453186, -0.029296353459358215, -0.016651785001158714, 0.007748601026833057, -0.11462709307670593, -0.053074952214956284, 0.023547938093543053, 0.03781753405928612, 0.02336801029741764, 0.048398975282907486, -0.026298757642507553, -0.054359178990125656, 0.04913454130291939, -0.052097387611866, 0.043984003365039825, -0.02458965964615345, 0.058315303176641464, -0.010214170441031456, 0.022400768473744392, -0.03289077430963516, 0.020033178851008415, -0.025180213153362274, 0.04041464254260063, 0.028986986726522446, -0.006862899288535118, 0.010789806954562664, -0.05133386328816414, -0.02120388112962246, 0.006503690965473652, -0.019396591931581497, -0.0023174299858510494, -0.023995809257030487, 0.014692788012325764, -0.019325895234942436, -0.0012197897303849459, -0.03948293998837471, 0.003941679373383522, 0.021220164373517036, 0.000614662712905556, 0.017373887822031975, -6.099575330154039e-05, 0.027916159480810165, -0.013628293760120869, -0.039798106998205185, 0.059351030737161636, 0.01495170034468174, 0.009827212430536747, 0.02889091894030571, -0.0015996021684259176, -0.03795825317502022, -0.03224552050232887, -0.03245900571346283, 0.0058698495849967, 0.08014336973428726, 0.016988860443234444, -0.08078650385141373, -0.01191607117652893, -0.014891168102622032, 0.006107894238084555, 0.03179410099983215, 0.009883382357656956, -0.0534166619181633, 0.006757640745490789, -0.02226031757891178, 0.04060222953557968, 0.05137312412261963, 0.011729284189641476, 0.015473012812435627, 0.005750848911702633, -0.006586117669939995, -0.016608422622084618, -0.0018516769632697105, -0.015284701250493526, 0.030294222757220268, 0.013888327404856682, -0.025594402104616165, -0.03802591562271118, 0.10137264430522919, 0.021828195080161095, 0.029298191890120506, -0.02970058098435402, 0.0029731099493801594, -0.01486645732074976, -0.0318293496966362, -0.032399263232946396, -0.03413806110620499, -0.026373814791440964, 0.0040527936071157455, -0.011875038966536522, -0.028020210564136505, 0.049091387540102005, -0.009601985104382038, 0.017537884414196014, -0.06303630024194717, -0.03986158221960068, -0.028774995356798172, 0.04470370337367058, 0.004839582368731499, 0.0005825592670589685, 0.008039826527237892, -0.011874651536345482, -0.029096893966197968, 0.021434376016259193, -0.06360050290822983, -0.008018001914024353, 0.03290938958525658, -0.04284731298685074, -0.04550771042704582, -0.005696437321603298, -0.037961702793836594, -0.03884795680642128, -0.0015330605674535036, 0.005019674077630043, 0.00690489262342453, 0.03722859546542168, -0.05460759997367859, -0.032765042036771774, 0.03679966926574707, 0.014540702104568481, 0.05355188250541687, -0.04944292828440666, 0.015136517584323883, -0.002285921946167946, 0.06814704835414886, 0.012158838100731373, 0.009830850176513195, 0.011788398027420044, -0.010706601664423943, 0.05719936266541481, 0.017269674688577652, -0.008453556336462498, 0.016045713797211647, -0.0853266790509224, 0.016317110508680344, -0.014375793747603893, -0.032901886850595474, -0.040128741413354874, 0.022815588861703873, -0.010418400168418884, -0.13395936787128448, -0.027299337089061737, 0.08157278597354889, 0.0060706548392772675, -0.07232868671417236, -0.005910210777074099, -0.033502496778964996, -0.024091560393571854, 0.009370973333716393, 0.0018302787793800235, 0.0003059871669393033, 0.002729250816628337, -0.015062040649354458, -0.001466298010200262, -0.00324315601028502, -0.02252156101167202, -0.032677412033081055, -0.08121099323034286, -0.004676823038607836, 0.007674231193959713, -0.0996832549571991, -0.02921137772500515, -0.041727252304553986, -0.04535260796546936, 0.003712048754096031, -0.002824638271704316, 0.03125055506825447, 0.006139679346233606, -0.012281605042517185, 0.05220379680395126, -0.06510589271783829, 0.022321779280900955, 0.020303720608353615, -0.05127502605319023, 0.010491370223462582, 0.07816801965236664, 0.003543645842000842, -0.000825264083687216, -0.05736060068011284, -0.0002920636034104973, -0.014440387487411499, 0.02349052019417286, -0.01119057647883892, 0.0037806660402566195, 0.04973674938082695, -0.01840933784842491, -0.015355809591710567, 0.0021907652262598276, -0.04886142909526825, 0.017605869099497795, 0.0172224473208189, 0.06597182154655457, 0.008204370737075806, -0.02438802644610405, -0.02853931114077568, 0.04688064381480217, -0.0010009761899709702, 0.029302597045898438, 0.04974352940917015, -0.03243526071310043, -0.03598547726869583, -0.0004093177558388561, 0.013636087998747826, -0.10842616111040115, 0.04352963715791702, -0.003591489978134632, 0.013100371696054935, -0.04397794231772423, -0.09269146621227264, -0.019052833318710327, -0.0036494487430900335, 0.02466614544391632, 0.04374242201447487, 0.03753605857491493, 0.04354853183031082, -0.0020139554981142282, -0.04868080094456673, -0.02110506221652031, 0.032362744212150574, 0.014895794913172722, -0.02958609163761139, 0.003263721941038966, 0.03187182918190956, -0.016388777643442154, -0.011820491403341293, -0.014950575307011604, -0.1061353087425232, -0.04605565592646599, 0.02609430067241192, 0.048826467245817184, 0.012383237481117249, 0.020890522748231888, 0.029658740386366844, -0.031137855723500252, 0.003554820315912366, -0.0064266338013112545, -0.03089175932109356, 0.01218810211867094, 0.02046518214046955, -0.0011797052575275302, -0.01283513754606247, -0.0032700069714337587, 0.01733131892979145, 0.05507124960422516, 0.023605994880199432, 0.010215407237410545, -0.04783331975340843, -0.06934870779514313, -0.00585416704416275, -0.00857392605394125, 0.05146646872162819, 0.03254365175962448, 0.0028202193789184093, -0.014867187477648258, 0.06749974936246872, 0.004272751044481993, 0.021868281066417694, -0.029631732031702995, -0.03501739352941513, 0.04430506378412247, 0.021282484754920006, -0.014341595582664013, -0.038928426802158356, 0.06562282890081406, -0.04913382977247238, -0.019923772662878036, 0.02935148775577545, -0.008162363432347775, 0.03556545823812485, -0.03885353356599808, 0.029690714552998543, -0.02790006808936596, 0.03826422616839409, -0.02892250567674637, 0.009517396800220013, -0.04161253571510315, 0.05035436153411865, -0.010248799808323383, 0.03320605680346489, -0.015288682654500008, 0.02597888931632042, -0.04232339933514595, -0.02743932232260704, -0.029788443818688393, 0.02670307271182537, 0.08052974939346313, -0.008016734384000301, 0.024889623746275902, 0.007980751805007458, 0.023545686155557632, -0.031508006155490875, 0.022627338767051697, -0.010532214306294918, 0.02204579859972, 0.040312640368938446, 0.03062422387301922, -0.02348846010863781, -0.041982926428318024, 0.07586600631475449, 0.051311105489730835, 0.028408972546458244, 0.0017112410860136151, -0.01605960540473461, -0.012186202220618725, -0.003965380601584911, 0.010238397866487503, 0.043973371386528015, -0.028423957526683807, -0.02312948741018772, -0.020318256691098213, -0.04001550003886223, 0.065325528383255, 0.033899061381816864, 0.06713759154081345, -0.02433493547141552, 0.023653993383049965, 0.009322864934802055, -0.0035520519595593214, 0.008942315354943275, 0.0024991121608763933, 0.054686907678842545, 0.030220113694667816, -0.02894514612853527, -0.04899609833955765, -6.733311722062713e-33, -0.002538158092647791, -0.02887214906513691, 0.013055874966084957, 0.000136704693431966, -0.046160224825143814, 0.01776721514761448, -0.05586345121264458, -0.03370329737663269, 0.02729913964867592, -0.014767280779778957, -0.01316052209585905, 0.02805471047759056, 0.014618965797126293, 0.01984543539583683, 0.07336921989917755, 0.02408495917916298, 0.059551902115345, 0.0003634066379163414, 0.06458794325590134, -0.008044539019465446, 0.05767252668738365, 0.05222553014755249, 0.05688510090112686, -0.016184911131858826, -0.03723779693245888, -0.03169550374150276, 0.013446435332298279, -0.04103349521756172, -0.027462579309940338, 0.031585756689310074, -0.012342440895736217, 0.01261265017092228, 0.03410057723522186, -0.06697818636894226, -0.03908161446452141, 0.0012920662993565202, -0.0707668587565422, -0.009816320613026619, -0.01907416433095932, 0.020282238721847534, -0.06046633794903755, -0.007236090023070574, 0.09026437252759933, -0.006904988549649715, 0.004833642393350601, 0.04005319997668266, 0.028399119153618813, -0.03449602052569389, -0.05808621644973755, -0.0058687771670520306, -0.049737028777599335, 0.00471099466085434, 0.0028025703504681587, 0.00638178875669837, 0.028943901881575584, -0.016649849712848663, -0.04378427937626839, 0.03321759030222893, -0.0712866485118866, -0.002124262508004904, 0.008681394159793854, 0.07726282626390457, 0.042959198355674744, 0.059234581887722015, 0.028355583548545837, 0.008902790024876595, 0.03371236473321915, -0.012876269407570362, -0.007177590858191252, 0.0018628693651407957, 0.00026545056607574224, 0.01460564136505127, 0.12460649758577347, 0.011652295477688313, 0.09089818596839905, -0.0511302724480629, -0.09460215270519257, 0.017899515107274055, 0.04485638067126274, 0.06215877830982208, 0.02075994573533535, 0.009846971370279789, 0.015182556584477425, -0.004585701506584883, 0.02284756302833557, -0.00848263967782259, -0.04545444995164871, -0.03487737849354744, 0.020882902666926384, -0.016391707584261894, 0.03897130861878395, 0.03727336972951889, -0.011942836456000805, -0.031368449330329895, 0.06725725531578064, 0.017119839787483215, 0.021438801661133766, 0.01732480712234974, 0.01724809780716896, -0.003966174088418484, -0.07825957238674164, -0.01575540564954281, -0.010340707376599312, 0.035313334316015244, 0.004484049044549465, 0.009900287725031376, 0.04533526301383972, -0.02123577706515789, -0.033640533685684204, -0.019608335569500923, -0.027016378939151764, 0.012725266627967358, 0.03927021846175194, 0.0693846344947815, 0.02528388239443302, -0.03254329040646553, -0.015331197530031204, 0.03590650483965874, 0.031175361946225166, -0.04281240329146385, -0.019739752635359764, -0.021968670189380646, 0.01051071472465992, 0.04476044327020645, -0.030176851898431778, -0.013700510375201702, -0.04218924045562744, 0.03197631612420082, 0.008529610931873322, -0.05884520709514618, -0.031638216227293015, 0.060432616621255875, 3.08327969378297e-07, -0.017750084400177002, 0.01672210730612278, 0.01679181307554245, -0.015184609219431877, 0.04343937337398529, -0.02366717904806137, -0.0444415882229805, -0.0011888555018231273, -0.015493372455239296, 0.012437473051249981, 0.03574293479323387, -0.016972288489341736, 0.052507512271404266, 0.0008066940936259925, -0.08653753250837326, -0.04303940385580063, -0.12692682445049286, 0.085574209690094, -0.011627370491623878, 0.02968703582882881, 0.0355529710650444, 0.0842156931757927, 0.027654875069856644, -0.032292239367961884, -0.0027851813938468695, -0.0015726928832009435, 0.020475978031754494, 0.010695873759686947, 0.024481618776917458, 0.0026859575882554054, -0.04546055570244789, 0.020128654316067696, -0.03630309924483299, 0.03736913204193115, -0.025271689519286156, 0.008291433565318584, -0.0007571543683297932, 0.02064802683889866, 0.001930947182700038, -0.034984927624464035, 0.04899714142084122, 0.012986114248633385, -0.011423286981880665, -0.06161170452833176, 0.01971866749227047, -0.041721515357494354, -0.020059235394001007, -0.02826627343893051, 0.04119114950299263, 0.01962456665933132, 0.06149822473526001, -0.015624508261680603, -0.016167107969522476, 0.0019931988790631294, -0.027645839378237724, -0.039591941982507706, 5.7341141655342653e-05, -0.03671829402446747, -0.0002087378379656002, -0.011572134681046009, -0.03044840879738331, -0.008992834016680717, -0.06462819874286652, -0.006789647974073887, 0.03575606271624565, -0.01187765784561634, -0.04714915156364441, 3.1933631063006923e-34, 0.0070493752136826515, -0.0615626759827137, -0.005856491159647703, 0.05972228944301605, -0.029488351196050644, -0.023038534447550774, -0.018820304423570633, 0.006840914953500032, -0.01706569828093052, -0.07274805754423141, -0.06128991022706032]
638
638
['Zhiyuan Tang', 'Dong Wang', 'Yixiang Chen', 'Lantian Li', 'Andrew Abel']
1705.03151v3
Deep neural models, particularly the LSTM-RNN model, have shown great potential for language identification (LID). However, the use of phonetic information has been largely overlooked by most existing neural LID methods, although this information has been used very successfully in conventional phonetic LID systems. We present a phonetic temporal neural model for LID, which is an LSTM-RNN LID system that accepts phonetic features produced by a phone-discriminative DNN as the input, rather than raw acoustic features. This new model is similar to traditional phonetic LID methods, but the phonetic knowledge here is much richer: it is at the frame level and involves compacted information of all phones. Our experiments conducted on the Babel database and the AP16-OLR database demonstrate that the temporal phonetic neural approach is very effective, and significantly outperforms existing acoustic neural models. It also outperforms the conventional i-vector approach on short utterances and in noisy conditions.
Phonetic Temporal Neural Model for Language Identification
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1705.03151v3
Title Phonetic Temporal Neural Model Language Identification Summary Deep neural model particularly LSTMRNN model shown great potential language identification LID However use phonetic information largely overlooked existing neural LID method although information used successfully conventional phonetic LID system present phonetic temporal neural model LID LSTMRNN LID system accepts phonetic feature produced phonediscriminative DNN input rather raw acoustic feature new model similar traditional phonetic LID method phonetic knowledge much richer frame level involves compacted information phone experiment conducted Babel database AP16OLR database demonstrate temporal phonetic neural approach effective significantly outperforms existing acoustic neural model also outperforms conventional ivector approach short utterance noisy condition Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.010538937523961067, 0.051746804267168045, 0.009194403886795044, 0.02748473547399044, -0.019157063215970993, 0.004291570279747248, 0.04313242807984352, -0.024848293513059616, -0.01615096442401409, 0.013568012043833733, -0.02703378163278103, -0.058014191687107086, 0.07893027365207672, 9.135649634117726e-06, 0.017817990854382515, -0.010379272513091564, 0.010510406456887722, -0.02412528544664383, 0.04761709272861481, -0.020860640332102776, 0.01400195062160492, -0.002854152349755168, -0.06147179380059242, 0.039242781698703766, -0.0011090937769040465, 0.010672642849385738, -0.037190794944763184, -0.0010226190788671374, -0.028323817998170853, -0.00479820417240262, 0.01116038579493761, 0.04790126532316208, -0.014775773510336876, 0.07711134105920792, 1.8530726038079592e-06, -0.004074469208717346, -0.0162252988666296, -0.04936863109469414, -0.06521497666835785, -0.002266206545755267, 0.007713919971138239, 0.026997890323400497, -0.0205992478877306, 0.0043601482175290585, 0.021661385893821716, -0.06362643092870712, 0.07531151175498962, -0.012084473855793476, 0.004174517001956701, 0.029817204922437668, 0.010127685964107513, -0.04008335620164871, 0.02976892702281475, 0.005397597327828407, 0.0025330744683742523, -0.03726889565587044, 0.015339645557105541, -0.041115015745162964, 0.008935848250985146, -0.08690924197435379, -0.00012087105278624222, 0.04937833547592163, -0.024362269788980484, 0.01765463501214981, -0.03636936470866203, 0.01426756102591753, -0.026857126504182816, -0.04441192373633385, 0.010112783871591091, 0.06079062446951866, -0.018051082268357277, -0.02734849974513054, 0.010328416712582111, 0.044043201953172684, -0.05174264684319496, -0.04181400313973427, 0.02149951457977295, -0.013898632489144802, -0.01662323996424675, -0.017443083226680756, 0.028181271627545357, 0.058863040059804916, 0.010144492611289024, 0.0031263832934200764, -0.02665288746356964, 0.028028899803757668, -0.0021318471990525723, 0.008550258353352547, -0.025709453970193863, -0.05530161410570145, 0.0700903907418251, -0.0280170775949955, 0.04476168006658554, 0.05777415260672569, 0.012372308410704136, -0.007055548019707203, 0.06583939492702484, -0.04703845828771591, 0.0013236270751804113, -0.009764639660716057, 0.001168600283563137, 0.019920898601412773, -0.07915820181369781, -0.01822718046605587, -0.03683401271700859, 0.058140430599451065, -0.015964454039931297, -0.035195089876651764, -0.019386032596230507, -0.015881691128015518, -0.026368502527475357, -0.025836974382400513, -0.005796854384243488, 0.00346713257022202, 0.04547381401062012, 0.031368009746074677, -0.03912878781557083, -0.018600063398480415, 0.0012528320075944066, -0.019708512350916862, -0.021381132304668427, -0.004950645845383406, -0.025142570957541466, -0.02058708854019642, 0.01553916186094284, 0.030838390812277794, 0.0029020654037594795, 0.032435230910778046, -0.08262048661708832, -0.0822388157248497, 0.019194765016436577, 0.06097665801644325, 0.0222183670848608, 0.029777996242046356, 0.009651408530771732, 0.03567865863442421, -0.01867612637579441, 0.0044498504139482975, -0.04920531436800957, 0.005924557335674763, -0.02716343104839325, -0.018075641244649887, -0.013879300095140934, -0.08080342411994934, 0.02570704184472561, -0.030229710042476654, -0.017019333317875862, -0.022705234587192535, -0.004457109607756138, -0.009003033861517906, 0.04386449605226517, 0.04055749997496605, 0.018116317689418793, 0.03578280285000801, 0.07579504698514938, 0.008847519755363464, 0.0763925090432167, 0.012063305824995041, 0.017355365678668022, -0.0028894739225506783, -0.01047811470925808, -0.037981871515512466, -0.0027687635738402605, 0.05133002996444702, -0.014156472869217396, -0.015123841352760792, -0.07417415082454681, -0.045592326670885086, 0.002432401292026043, 0.035147473216056824, -0.018236519768834114, 0.06223490461707115, 0.03422076627612114, -0.008093567565083504, 0.04676690325140953, 0.07400786131620407, 0.04458557441830635, 0.026787247508764267, 0.012544268742203712, -0.004804909694939852, 0.022671831771731377, -0.006557513028383255, 0.026217937469482422, 0.0036835602950304747, -0.03174533322453499, 0.0043556042946875095, -0.05012683570384979, 0.012774347327649593, -0.04041113704442978, -0.005047121550887823, -0.014279786497354507, -0.03572772443294525, -0.0402313657104969, 0.018485769629478455, 0.05131567642092705, -0.022384729236364365, 0.0023990750778466463, 0.044155292212963104, 0.013877789489924908, 0.04539148136973381, 0.018143773078918457, -0.02604749985039234, 0.06518565863370895, 0.009863781742751598, -0.008178710006177425, -0.03307085111737251, -0.03813723474740982, -0.04383312165737152, -0.027549048885703087, 0.039457790553569794, -0.011150687001645565, -0.020782815292477608, 0.0491163432598114, -0.050573475658893585, 0.009470909833908081, 0.09961357712745667, 0.0021896520629525185, 0.047522760927677155, -0.023404590785503387, 0.05444907397031784, 0.013980959542095661, -0.01759604923427105, 0.019316265359520912, 0.0034448117949068546, -0.03981243818998337, -0.028872517868876457, 0.024233520030975342, 0.03856738656759262, 0.01672552339732647, 0.044610947370529175, 0.015910163521766663, -0.015356451272964478, -0.00318005308508873, -0.014816215261816978, 0.05361298844218254, 0.034525658935308456, -0.047533247619867325, -0.026297854259610176, 0.04295120760798454, 0.007306275423616171, -0.0009932806715369225, 0.030265340581536293, 0.02669871598482132, -0.05498681962490082, 0.07483267039060593, 0.012705247849225998, 0.039261605590581894, -0.04103948175907135, 0.03347967937588692, -0.017219148576259613, 0.035028792917728424, 0.018801268190145493, 0.01715688221156597, 0.012231224216520786, -0.008037149906158447, 0.03943071886897087, 0.0025342823937535286, 0.021400073543190956, -0.10711218416690826, -0.0782555416226387, 0.0317334309220314, -0.03368525579571724, -0.02316112257540226, -0.04979122430086136, 0.013914594426751137, -0.007557159289717674, -0.022605255246162415, -0.03476083651185036, -0.04117283225059509, -0.025394700467586517, 0.013338361866772175, -0.05323292687535286, 0.017985068261623383, 0.010955044068396091, -0.03965745493769646, -0.03145265206694603, -0.006856344174593687, 0.004338255617767572, -0.018117958679795265, -0.022174952551722527, 0.014548218809068203, -0.02838880941271782, -0.049687400460243225, -0.028286011889576912, -0.028309259563684464, 0.021090809255838394, 0.009484914131462574, -0.09701422601938248, -0.013337493874132633, -0.04403086006641388, -0.002676998730748892, 0.06499996781349182, 0.027535604313015938, -0.02131863310933113, -0.017962798476219177, -0.03188778832554817, 0.021387862041592598, -0.010053109377622604, -0.04005133733153343, -0.03414883464574814, 0.013390136882662773, -0.02505015954375267, -0.003618465503677726, -0.0006131849950179458, -0.007243478205054998, 0.05306472256779671, -0.021909965202212334, -0.02906692959368229, -0.03695466369390488, 0.029665343463420868, 0.010438521392643452, 0.032808106392621994, 0.014555037021636963, -0.015213917009532452, -0.04779846966266632, 0.013326370157301426, -0.04597461596131325, -0.007163061294704676, -0.035474445670843124, 0.020408721640706062, -0.015859685838222504, -0.02544580213725567, 0.035566236823797226, -0.05531715974211693, -0.04844021797180176, -0.011475581675767899, -0.06562702357769012, -0.019449926912784576, 0.02630859985947609, -0.005363770294934511, 0.007635836955159903, 0.021005192771553993, -0.08455152064561844, 0.0024837274104356766, 0.03399967774748802, -0.027148474007844925, -0.03930094838142395, 0.018337881192564964, -0.012356908991932869, -0.009183394722640514, -0.008052079938352108, -0.012548350729048252, -0.05214885249733925, -0.020827364176511765, -0.03845062851905823, 0.019508421421051025, -0.03291909396648407, -0.007001081015914679, 0.049876075237989426, 0.06310596317052841, -0.0028888818342238665, 0.028153249993920326, 0.021252227947115898, 0.05460893362760544, -0.008050462231040001, 0.05458994209766388, 0.014583728276193142, 0.011807391420006752, 0.0017337517347186804, 0.03389301896095276, 0.04680492728948593, -0.05432309955358505, 0.022804563865065575, 0.01666468195617199, -0.06470870226621628, -0.004011144395917654, 0.014481665566563606, 0.004767498932778835, 0.0010160228703171015, 0.027937494218349457, -0.03263971954584122, -0.014613369479775429, 0.016052182763814926, 0.07771626114845276, -0.016627389937639236, -0.06746407598257065, -0.02673887088894844, 0.02919374406337738, -0.027405565604567528, -0.025504695251584053, 0.032391507178545, -0.002033836441114545, 0.004008101765066385, 0.0270319115370512, -0.0014409513678401709, 0.0040376451797783375, -0.008631699718534946, -0.029822826385498047, -0.07011009752750397, -0.029887771233916283, 0.023171819746494293, -0.014045433141291142, 0.006241310387849808, 0.01003864873200655, 0.01155858114361763, -0.008517078123986721, 0.007619118317961693, 0.04200601205229759, 0.013334034942090511, -0.0689304992556572, 0.05060313269495964, -0.08679171651601791, -0.054974980652332306, 0.04516002908349037, -0.048355307430028915, 0.06282391399145126, 0.003892354667186737, 0.0059997932985424995, -0.0868091732263565, -0.03541978821158409, 0.01840697042644024, -0.00947157945483923, -0.005006059538573027, -0.010544699616730213, 0.007326019927859306, 0.03604608029127121, -0.008078751154243946, 0.007285069674253464, 0.0020496980287134647, -0.019962294027209282, 0.042822517454624176, -0.0021198962349444628, 0.05907732620835304, 0.006114176940172911, 0.015595347620546818, 0.041037946939468384, 0.049319133162498474, 0.014265286736190319, 0.02840293198823929, 0.02815142273902893, -0.04509471356868744, 0.008458329364657402, 0.010728669352829456, 0.03341899439692497, -0.028819002211093903, -0.015127655118703842, 0.034993451088666916, 0.02564707025885582, -0.09649504721164703, -0.03296641632914543, 0.004738752730190754, -0.07205652445554733, 0.008333099074661732, 0.08581210672855377, 0.037007782608270645, 0.03511715307831764, 0.012932264246046543, -0.018293000757694244, 0.01424575224518776, 0.02620825357735157, 0.04189588129520416, -0.07040491700172424, 0.015756437554955482, 0.06593561172485352, -0.07551360130310059, 0.019242873415350914, -0.010595425963401794, -0.06537409126758575, -0.02223447524011135, 0.046080581843853, -0.05937813222408295, 0.016648294404149055, 0.04114716127514839, -0.07151161134243011, -0.07795543223619461, 0.040206316858530045, -0.039195574820041656, 0.034052204340696335, -0.028632741421461105, 0.03958822041749954, -0.001262088306248188, -0.01814868301153183, 0.007417046464979649, -0.03164798393845558, 0.033331647515296936, 0.010513296350836754, -0.04400953650474548, -0.048631079494953156, -0.0214273352175951, 0.005330300889909267, -0.005001695826649666, 0.05631137639284134, 0.019586795940995216, 0.02576344460248947, -0.07401897758245468, -0.0028078174218535423, 0.06506717950105667, 0.061167746782302856, 0.014220083132386208, -0.032137181609869, 0.0626295655965805, 0.03827803581953049, -0.01711656153202057, -0.0455169640481472, 0.037826474756002426, -0.03986193239688873, 0.00908456277102232, 0.07480542361736298, 0.006260715890675783, 0.04276710003614426, -0.01523483358323574, 0.010194135829806328, -0.04368984326720238, 0.08279971033334732, -0.007213989272713661, 0.04625991731882095, -0.017648769542574883, 0.0015303009422495961, -0.015399263240396976, -0.02278008684515953, -0.01646038517355919, 0.009823217988014221, 0.054362278431653976, 0.01559483353048563, -0.009310035966336727, -0.03505394607782364, 0.07619580626487732, -0.03308744728565216, -0.009291856549680233, 0.023192524909973145, 0.03212134912610054, -0.046625204384326935, -0.010678688995540142, -0.041934411972761154, 0.0009625775855965912, 0.035126008093357086, 0.0005499711260199547, -0.026578610762953758, 0.016291825100779533, 0.025463398545980453, 0.046902675181627274, 0.01490626111626625, 0.010782758705317974, -0.005282113328576088, -0.007373449392616749, 0.00371237238869071, -0.03910236805677414, -0.004597071558237076, -0.09116173535585403, -0.013584550470113754, -0.009736393578350544, -0.09184300899505615, 0.027659932151436806, -0.021843649446964264, 0.08106488734483719, 0.0044402675703167915, -0.022571997717022896, -0.0004019645566586405, 0.031623538583517075, 0.028685811907052994, 0.005260561127215624, -0.010087712667882442, 0.04574152082204819, -0.012940097600221634, -0.03757045790553093, -5.713410946303048e-33, -0.0015684276586398482, -0.0036515584215521812, -0.0025872597470879555, -0.00515337847173214, -0.007642766926437616, -0.012425069697201252, -0.043225474655628204, 0.009223653934895992, -0.03549817204475403, -0.018271569162607193, -0.0014576741959899664, 0.004634293727576733, 0.022627294063568115, 8.607236850366462e-06, 0.0028863116167485714, 0.003831251058727503, 0.03045145981013775, -0.005097307730466127, 0.051109153777360916, -0.008524353615939617, 0.046525198966264725, 0.049167387187480927, 0.06234104931354523, -0.038925401866436005, -0.040092647075653076, -0.022750085219740868, 0.010255333036184311, 0.0206118356436491, 0.0011409481521695852, 0.03464430570602417, -0.04435097426176071, 0.020690793171525, -0.005311664193868637, 0.0061782593838870525, 0.0031220868695527315, 0.012971372343599796, -0.08650669455528259, -0.04058351740241051, -0.023074999451637268, 0.07306259870529175, 0.022289767861366272, -0.029703015461564064, 0.03881772607564926, -0.012102633714675903, -0.044932771474123, 0.02690618671476841, 0.035318102687597275, -0.027551740407943726, 0.013562016189098358, -0.04769011214375496, -0.027882512658834457, 0.04366627335548401, -0.0009073209366761148, -0.019170882180333138, 0.10032523423433304, 0.04084685817360878, -0.019029686227440834, -0.016552245244383812, -0.09536955505609512, 0.03152935951948166, -0.0029399774502962828, 0.009328661486506462, 0.030524518340826035, 0.06661540269851685, -0.026152873411774635, -0.014370113611221313, 0.09620077162981033, -0.05888281390070915, 0.01059384923428297, 0.011267563328146935, 0.07980293780565262, -0.029439259320497513, 0.05228380858898163, -0.04732981324195862, 0.0411762110888958, -0.04062753915786743, -0.0376632995903492, -0.01441896054893732, 0.0713130459189415, -0.01327928714454174, 0.01727398857474327, 0.001072892569936812, -0.05265484005212784, -0.007524569518864155, -0.006826551165431738, -0.06784196197986603, -0.03216823935508728, -0.0021143679041415453, 0.028531305491924286, -0.018570344895124435, 0.042479000985622406, -0.009522655047476292, 0.05140610784292221, -0.013255251571536064, 0.0649796575307846, -0.050734929740428925, 0.020789438858628273, -0.01417489629238844, 0.007885723374783993, 0.0599975660443306, -0.0581362321972847, -0.02905968762934208, 0.006560542620718479, 0.005707112140953541, 0.02859695628285408, -0.013187745586037636, 0.0361519381403923, 0.0563637837767601, 0.001263427664525807, 0.003615006571635604, -0.00853247195482254, -0.026573505252599716, 0.049084942787885666, 0.04599245265126228, 0.03283984214067459, -0.028227128088474274, 0.0009189306292682886, 0.01772327348589897, 0.05234210193157196, 0.036696139723062515, -0.0019651795737445354, -0.035756584256887436, 0.0056819976307451725, 0.04428273066878319, -0.07990464568138123, -0.00034162666997872293, 0.0031867942307144403, 0.03896322101354599, 0.00659790076315403, 0.014381133951246738, 0.02948256954550743, 0.03936738893389702, 2.5279308601966477e-07, -0.047702133655548096, -0.04788796976208687, 0.05324361100792885, -0.008993485942482948, 0.04095422849059105, -0.049465809017419815, -0.032482169568538666, -0.026207007467746735, -0.009957855567336082, 0.027336355298757553, 0.023311816155910492, -0.04158172756433487, 0.08436360955238342, 0.02219305746257305, -0.09480764716863632, -0.021951528266072273, -0.08126696944236755, 0.04808253049850464, -0.03868737816810608, 0.034909509122371674, 1.2347867368589505e-06, 0.10822436958551407, 0.012803864665329456, -0.06510470807552338, 0.002107995795086026, -0.03786018490791321, 0.008835037238895893, 0.004691449925303459, 0.012252339161932468, 0.0164045263081789, 0.06491757184267044, -0.005667774472385645, -0.00585466343909502, -0.029541313648223877, -0.03915619105100632, 0.06018000468611717, 0.002839517779648304, 0.011892998591065407, -0.010333935730159283, -0.004657919518649578, 0.03851420804858208, 0.0399879515171051, -0.024336859583854675, -0.00889109168201685, 0.041180409491062164, 0.04486970230937004, -0.029036926105618477, 0.019503306597471237, 0.04407091066241264, -0.01819116435945034, 0.0071934242732822895, -0.006797497160732746, 0.0033081448636949062, 0.013806563802063465, 0.0008139609708450735, -0.06323529779911041, -0.03343812748789787, -0.022196343168616295, -0.01268287654966116, 0.00722105335444212, -0.055481694638729095, 0.0230129174888134, 0.05251528322696686, -0.06481288373470306, -0.006730434950441122, -0.009748995304107666, 0.014602892100811005, 2.1213864155139137e-34, -0.03239970654249191, -0.01422326359897852, -0.02222006767988205, 0.010129553265869617, -0.0023297977168112993, 0.0009001697180792689, 0.0018064986215904355, 0.024492256343364716, 0.00747304130345583, -0.045434076339006424, -0.04121065139770508]
639
639
['Hamed Zamani', 'W. Bruce Croft']
1705.03556v2
Learning a high-dimensional dense representation for vocabulary terms, also known as a word embedding, has recently attracted much attention in natural language processing and information retrieval tasks. The embedding vectors are typically learned based on term proximity in a large corpus. This means that the objective in well-known word embedding algorithms, e.g., word2vec, is to accurately predict adjacent word(s) for a given word or context. However, this objective is not necessarily equivalent to the goal of many information retrieval (IR) tasks. The primary objective in various IR tasks is to capture relevance instead of term proximity, syntactic, or even semantic similarity. This is the motivation for developing unsupervised relevance-based word embedding models that learn word representations based on query-document relevance information. In this paper, we propose two learning models with different objective functions; one learns a relevance distribution over the vocabulary set for each query, and the other classifies each term as belonging to the relevant or non-relevant class for each query. To train our models, we used over six million unique queries and the top ranked documents retrieved in response to each query, which are assumed to be relevant to the query. We extrinsically evaluate our learned word representation models using two IR tasks: query expansion and query classification. Both query expansion experiments on four TREC collections and query classification experiments on the KDD Cup 2005 dataset suggest that the relevance-based word embedding models significantly outperform state-of-the-art proximity-based embedding models, such as word2vec and GloVe.
Relevance-based Word Embedding
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1705.03556v2
Title Relevancebased Word Embedding Summary Learning highdimensional dense representation vocabulary term also known word embedding recently attracted much attention natural language processing information retrieval task embedding vector typically learned based term proximity large corpus mean objective wellknown word embedding algorithm eg word2vec accurately predict adjacent word given word context However objective necessarily equivalent goal many information retrieval IR task primary objective various IR task capture relevance instead term proximity syntactic even semantic similarity motivation developing unsupervised relevancebased word embedding model learn word representation based querydocument relevance information paper propose two learning model different objective function one learns relevance distribution vocabulary set query classifies term belonging relevant nonrelevant class query train model used six million unique query top ranked document retrieved response query assumed relevant query extrinsically evaluate learned word representation model using two IR task query expansion query classification query expansion experiment four TREC collection query classification experiment KDD Cup 2005 dataset suggest relevancebased word embedding model significantly outperform stateoftheart proximitybased embedding model word2vec GloVe Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.055417437106370926, 0.007513559889048338, 0.005542187485843897, 0.029102232307195663, -0.034605324268341064, -0.012237999588251114, -0.03458545729517937, 0.024213548749685287, -0.010251839645206928, -0.06271302700042725, -0.033824384212493896, 0.0020126882009208202, -0.013109618797898293, 0.021384557709097862, 0.006791483610868454, -0.014157348312437534, 0.059138283133506775, 0.06290602684020996, -0.021255219355225563, 0.03214097023010254, 0.032962895929813385, 0.04196041449904442, 0.030590491369366646, 0.040349092334508896, -0.0024027321487665176, 0.013841175474226475, 0.01666322536766529, -0.013141490519046783, -0.017584895715117455, -0.003505125641822815, 0.029253333806991577, 0.05586973577737808, 0.08440645784139633, 0.01639486849308014, 1.8008813640335575e-06, -0.02611377276480198, -0.05740779638290405, -0.0019098742632195354, 0.01393703743815422, -0.024081017822027206, 0.07798497378826141, -0.021749407052993774, 0.04657775163650513, 0.03106783702969551, -0.043316785246133804, -0.01296605821698904, 0.038480859249830246, 0.055250026285648346, 0.008872756734490395, 0.013329172506928444, 0.0012288487050682306, -0.04670611023902893, 0.02471788041293621, -0.020462751388549805, 0.03965570405125618, -0.03892495855689049, 0.01911681331694126, -0.02570093423128128, 0.020158225670456886, 0.07471276819705963, -0.03311878442764282, -0.006598867010325193, -0.047555990517139435, -0.04682167246937752, 0.047877054661512375, 0.034275587648153305, -0.028981443494558334, 0.038215696811676025, 0.053574856370687485, 0.07328419387340546, -0.014143869280815125, -0.02513362281024456, -0.026651892811059952, 0.04565731808543205, -0.031278155744075775, 0.03655482083559036, -0.03167131915688515, -0.020368974655866623, 0.026143455877900124, 0.020326152443885803, -0.008196142502129078, 0.031045418232679367, 0.0028994563035666943, 0.023314233869314194, -0.010237244889140129, 0.019163763150572777, 0.006929187569767237, -0.04871566966176033, -0.016914572566747665, -0.013954171910881996, -0.02576827071607113, 0.0070002879947423935, 0.01777688041329384, -0.017092088237404823, 0.0014919036766514182, 0.022687282413244247, -0.030561532825231552, -0.011853231117129326, 0.05381477251648903, -0.09609487652778625, -0.004218374378979206, -0.016840675845742226, -0.003023264231160283, 0.04303409159183502, -0.03199884667992592, 0.0038366559892892838, 0.007443748414516449, 0.010424102656543255, -0.044697344303131104, -0.018652573227882385, -0.06604086607694626, -0.027239874005317688, -0.015716033056378365, 0.051108259707689285, 0.002888239687308669, -0.06408903002738953, -0.028614399954676628, 0.022599095478653908, 0.0011997362598776817, -0.049097999930381775, -0.014873902313411236, 0.05382493510842323, -0.024181677028536797, 0.0037631364539265633, -0.02976752631366253, -0.02039317414164543, -0.029294554144144058, 0.04112992808222771, -0.0486922487616539, -0.007323744241148233, 0.03803476691246033, 0.026849720627069473, 0.04239484667778015, -0.010743619874119759, 0.004626867361366749, -0.007048989646136761, 0.027689915150403976, -0.08176607638597488, -0.020980199798941612, -0.005699940957129002, 0.028481675311923027, 0.011931023560464382, -0.04740564525127411, -0.043101437389850616, 0.032233208417892456, -0.027698419988155365, -0.05492689833045006, -0.0009885076433420181, -0.004252874758094549, 0.052952636033296585, -0.034176088869571686, 0.11617278307676315, -0.014583376236259937, -0.01876901090145111, 0.05746765062212944, 0.020406169816851616, 0.07145410031080246, 0.025858864188194275, -0.022767869755625725, 0.0006845236057415605, 0.05345305800437927, -0.012764845974743366, -0.0240775179117918, -0.05501263588666916, 0.00558369280770421, -0.030150031670928, -0.038074832409620285, 0.05120300129055977, 0.005529325921088457, 0.04937872290611267, 0.021961241960525513, 0.04234762489795685, -0.004775720648467541, -0.0251163300126791, -0.002186075784265995, 0.10386745631694794, 0.07013861835002899, -0.0085093192756176, 0.015349822118878365, 0.07182510197162628, -0.050191331654787064, -0.002990335924550891, -0.03435168415307999, 0.016996921971440315, 0.00555277056992054, -0.009077097289264202, 0.04508494213223457, -0.0285883117467165, -0.0369543693959713, -0.0019180699018761516, 0.012413257732987404, -0.0009234118042513728, -0.014876600354909897, -0.029449403285980225, 0.018385611474514008, -0.016025103628635406, -0.021528204903006554, 0.023642005398869514, 0.020870015025138855, -0.004528280347585678, 0.020523646846413612, -0.03839895874261856, 0.001836020965129137, 0.007655398454517126, 0.05565081164240837, -0.05772731453180313, 0.0033482222352176905, -0.019907841458916664, -0.003402400529012084, 0.010067936964333057, 0.012094840407371521, -0.024962985888123512, -0.03407542034983635, -0.0370202511548996, -0.053032178431749344, -0.0055090636014938354, -0.0033909250050783157, -0.0077473800629377365, -0.026673607528209686, 0.04268377274274826, 0.06048273295164108, -0.028527675196528435, 0.02213308773934841, 0.05955955386161804, 0.024034256115555763, -0.022752545773983, 0.025500457733869553, 0.011580602265894413, -0.002015421399846673, 0.0176120363175869, -0.015015005134046078, 0.022247428074479103, 0.054041363298892975, -0.01002754271030426, -0.01936543546617031, -0.047378309071063995, -0.05209651589393616, -0.022402487695217133, 0.019835347309708595, -0.010385638102889061, 0.07261527329683304, 0.04287882521748543, -0.0053206621669232845, -0.010858975350856781, -0.0015738665824756026, -0.029302986338734627, 0.05450979992747307, -0.059338830411434174, 0.02560843713581562, -0.05540498346090317, 0.049640074372291565, -0.056942008435726166, 0.06567909568548203, -0.013638211414217949, 0.061812881380319595, -0.008145704865455627, 0.026730889454483986, 0.007027479819953442, -0.00020103594579268247, -0.028725488111376762, 0.008121219463646412, -0.010222532786428928, 0.019558774307370186, 0.019617697224020958, 0.002601367887109518, -0.023500151932239532, 0.006124734878540039, -0.07324331253767014, 0.0055165160447359085, 0.011545765213668346, -0.006147264502942562, 0.013082346878945827, 0.011061637662351131, 0.008775119669735432, -0.015381567180156708, -0.04127711430191994, -0.008155872114002705, -0.027256274595856667, 0.025618301704525948, 0.027338024228811264, 0.014990023337304592, 0.01194779109209776, -0.07064879685640335, -0.03449738398194313, 0.007650308310985565, 0.034632015973329544, 0.01625007949769497, -0.009955581277608871, -0.007426673546433449, 0.02114957943558693, -0.03913934901356697, 0.027294950559735298, 0.014118085615336895, -0.0049607292748987675, -0.01775594800710678, -0.05611254647374153, 0.018568599596619606, 0.016992097720503807, 0.06234608218073845, -0.0009695220505818725, 0.0350177176296711, 0.04320694878697395, -0.05774984508752823, -0.003136606886982918, -0.06756199896335602, 0.03152266517281532, 0.025766203179955482, -9.538973245071247e-05, 0.010992641560733318, -0.03848523274064064, 0.0331977978348732, -0.01824483647942543, -0.026467688381671906, 0.01355654001235962, -0.000634511758107692, -0.001723121153190732, -0.07095211744308472, 0.014650478959083557, -0.0036398875527083874, -0.006752809975296259, -0.01121449749916792, -0.02190094068646431, 0.0334453247487545, 0.004580569453537464, 0.019981155171990395, -0.05127700790762901, -0.04187813028693199, -0.037944283336400986, 0.04938650131225586, -0.037861380726099014, 0.007393027655780315, -0.05760340392589569, -0.03087339922785759, -0.014088500291109085, 0.005621309392154217, -0.008750208653509617, -0.04577451944351196, 0.03350680321455002, 0.042767275124788284, 0.022295309230685234, 0.012469038367271423, -0.006310657132416964, -0.011672730557620525, -0.0666801854968071, 0.024290800094604492, 0.008098786696791649, 0.03782665729522705, -0.014748216606676579, -0.032344210892915726, 0.032457634806632996, -0.021887710317969322, 0.008910923264920712, -0.004627469461411238, -0.053653374314308167, 0.011780965141952038, 0.031602706760168076, 0.06494896113872528, -0.015592610463500023, -0.020325487479567528, 0.09038517624139786, 0.020178459584712982, 0.03612903878092766, 0.0009125910000875592, -0.03360920399427414, -0.02636611834168434, -0.006100212223827839, 0.035395026206970215, -0.05681898072361946, -0.020241910591721535, -0.03519849106669426, -0.02426849491894245, 0.02282661385834217, -0.02484290488064289, 0.09268885850906372, 0.04840310290455818, -0.07823377102613449, -0.001786477747373283, -0.058507226407527924, -0.02401958964765072, 0.05923681706190109, 0.044542327523231506, 0.02059592679142952, 0.005262073129415512, -0.010350524447858334, 0.0278460830450058, 0.010832480154931545, -0.032038215547800064, -0.017698369920253754, -0.10068456828594208, 0.01851607859134674, -0.03363563492894173, 0.02476911060512066, -0.02900433912873268, -0.0480014942586422, 0.021351052448153496, 0.005866005551069975, -0.027839194983243942, 0.01405459176748991, -0.00016079952183645219, -0.02228200063109398, -0.0048998380079865456, -0.0031592079903930426, -0.036412980407476425, 0.03843645378947258, -0.03978244215250015, -0.00788835808634758, 0.034833576530218124, 0.06810460984706879, -0.0008673711563460529, -0.013252109289169312, -0.01178740244358778, -0.045690521597862244, -0.008486459031701088, -0.04416979104280472, 0.05413861200213432, -0.04805668443441391, 0.02619188092648983, -0.04093765839934349, -0.019066426903009415, -0.0179463941603899, 0.03673303499817848, -0.0007558048819191754, 0.0917741060256958, -0.03509202599525452, 0.02622915245592594, -0.0926695466041565, 0.005000364035367966, 0.005937924608588219, 0.03385038673877716, 0.006633001379668713, -0.015922896564006805, 0.015376945957541466, 0.02658437006175518, 0.042970024049282074, 0.021100793033838272, -0.03155090659856796, -0.042757730931043625, -0.05054578557610512, -0.007273652590811253, -0.07293298840522766, -0.02822907641530037, -0.012985126115381718, 0.02341338060796261, -0.002655579010024667, 0.06906253099441528, -0.07598301023244858, -0.025204109027981758, -0.04391951113939285, -0.032696910202503204, 0.03211279585957527, 0.018818162381649017, -0.03680232912302017, 0.03308304026722908, 0.06894207745790482, -0.02094760164618492, -0.047119829803705215, -0.08496582508087158, 0.006966497749090195, -0.01154087483882904, -0.04360952600836754, -0.0005662572802975774, -0.0038597991224378347, 0.0160533357411623, -0.04551146551966667, -0.060143519192934036, 0.04325810819864273, 0.02145826630294323, -0.042224280536174774, -0.03456928953528404, 0.02045992575585842, -0.014694134704768658, -0.019016865640878677, 0.029681595042347908, -0.057868655771017075, 0.044021863490343094, -0.01610741950571537, 0.014139656908810139, 0.011053493246436119, -0.05083542689681053, 0.02635285258293152, -0.02249923348426819, 0.07167448103427887, 0.03811632841825485, 0.008259407244622707, -0.04946098476648331, -0.010502823628485203, -0.019261347129940987, -0.024095220491290092, -0.023993343114852905, 0.029459115117788315, 0.04657316952943802, -0.021823640912771225, -0.022423315793275833, -0.02621513232588768, -0.02801302634179592, 0.024157468229532242, -0.009455464780330658, 0.03699305281043053, 0.013328042812645435, 0.034190185368061066, -0.03667046129703522, 0.05049307644367218, -0.01572377420961857, -0.02396525628864765, -0.014258141629397869, 0.0021896441467106342, -0.06190373748540878, 0.0072684516198933125, -0.029131503775715828, -0.01939130388200283, -0.007458298932760954, 0.035051509737968445, -0.04056943953037262, 0.008315876126289368, -0.036497149616479874, 0.021064257249236107, 0.03132544085383415, -0.0563964806497097, -0.0702381506562233, 0.02604994736611843, 0.007587700616568327, -0.015604362823069096, 0.035933271050453186, -0.018732160329818726, -0.03149678558111191, 0.04495394974946976, 0.022743910551071167, -0.016876721754670143, 0.01053644809871912, 0.036726631224155426, 0.014252488501369953, 0.0025343820452690125, -0.016076909378170967, -0.07152234762907028, -0.007405577227473259, 0.01112720463424921, 0.058710407465696335, 0.10223231464624405, -0.034705765545368195, 0.04494903236627579, -0.002032427815720439, -0.015367547050118446, 0.04625266417860985, -0.039976172149181366, -0.03905891254544258, 0.02915360778570175, 0.043970514088869095, 0.06966353952884674, 0.006288269534707069, -0.006072937045246363, -0.06126987561583519, 0.016292838379740715, -0.0238169115036726, -0.022594789043068886, -0.017419515177607536, -6.040426127862116e-33, -0.0005498135578818619, -0.004282492212951183, -0.01893066242337227, -0.05232655629515648, -0.02632424607872963, 0.03661124408245087, 0.01073157787322998, -0.04391235485672951, -0.07011209428310394, -0.013419581577181816, -0.02127631939947605, 0.03144725039601326, -0.013403038494288921, -0.012435047887265682, -0.0033349567092955112, 0.0036785549018532038, -0.009281364269554615, 0.009342935867607594, 0.04476039856672287, 0.03999846428632736, 0.06057678908109665, 0.080024853348732, 0.054533954709768295, -0.07348804920911789, 0.007432050071656704, -0.038023725152015686, 0.022927651181817055, 0.03204716742038727, 0.02580917999148369, 0.06446336954832077, -0.035024650394916534, 0.059955671429634094, 0.03994171321392059, -0.019360017031431198, -0.0024489029310643673, 0.016666032373905182, -0.04608685523271561, -0.07104676961898804, -0.02074839547276497, -0.0266888327896595, -0.01660667546093464, 0.03395038843154907, 0.029365135356783867, -0.003987643402069807, -0.006085274741053581, -0.006450376007705927, 0.0785139873623848, -0.005850252695381641, -0.08317667245864868, 0.03409953415393829, -0.044856324791908264, 0.007870456203818321, 0.015337558463215828, 0.011610522866249084, 0.02107655629515648, 0.02675357460975647, 0.04166381061077118, 0.04262985661625862, -0.033167220652103424, -0.0012002554722130299, -0.07112625241279602, 0.062457695603370667, 0.022595632821321487, 0.014975260943174362, 0.006583466660231352, 0.0629633441567421, -0.019760437309741974, -0.049235183745622635, 0.03058703988790512, -0.03403964638710022, 0.013440636917948723, 0.05289314687252045, 0.025584738701581955, 0.054135825484991074, 0.04276209697127342, -0.03499386087059975, -0.019043374806642532, 0.0382080040872097, -0.01667802780866623, 0.041277144104242325, 0.0337960422039032, 0.020254746079444885, -0.0765979140996933, -0.021868349984288216, -0.014408163726329803, 0.04020197317004204, -0.055633313953876495, -0.052801307290792465, 0.03419004753232002, 0.017476482316851616, -0.0133128110319376, 0.009882799349725246, 0.015318309888243675, -0.027543269097805023, -0.013453267514705658, 0.05202025920152664, 0.0013891506241634488, -0.0212225541472435, 0.0006654506432823837, -0.0050455862656235695, -0.02212105505168438, -0.02418660931289196, -0.02080480381846428, -0.05235769972205162, -0.03927860036492348, -0.025893649086356163, 0.02097437158226967, -0.009685559198260307, -0.009660000912845135, -0.019203389063477516, 0.02295706793665886, -0.06968460232019424, -0.015001350082457066, 0.0315115749835968, -0.021138833835721016, 0.015463593415915966, 0.007263627834618092, 0.06881482899188995, 0.08622156083583832, -0.014377318322658539, 0.015152135863900185, -0.09036263823509216, 0.006765782833099365, 0.022671571001410484, -0.027867615222930908, 0.029688149690628052, -0.03659052401781082, 0.029915377497673035, 0.02162362076342106, -0.056018710136413574, -0.01572316698729992, 0.009074009954929352, 2.564212877587124e-07, 0.06434766203165054, -0.004692928399890661, -0.025807039812207222, -0.017971079796552658, -0.028008032590150833, 0.0044585419818758965, 0.03320681303739548, 0.06616707891225815, -0.04449562355875969, 0.05393560975790024, 0.030502023175358772, -0.005685433279722929, -0.005836656782776117, -0.017837896943092346, -0.06232428550720215, 0.01261939574033022, -0.08892317861318588, -0.01016806811094284, -0.02638024277985096, -0.006303982809185982, 0.09570460766553879, 0.12162274122238159, 0.03130587562918663, -0.015158901922404766, -0.04679092764854431, -0.07001398503780365, 0.011206514202058315, -0.02882847934961319, 0.014875280670821667, 0.02156110666692257, 0.0021210061386227608, 0.03776295483112335, -0.0017261662287637591, -0.00549119571223855, -0.040132973343133926, 0.049797527492046356, 0.05852784961462021, 0.01495001558214426, -0.03072725050151348, 0.00880457367748022, 0.008395267650485039, -0.015405404381453991, 0.02926529385149479, -0.0418088473379612, 0.08901512622833252, 0.02878163941204548, -0.016948115080595016, -0.03200376406311989, 0.00326934945769608, 0.008595937862992287, 0.040749337524175644, -0.03777046874165535, -0.02968921884894371, -0.01904904842376709, 0.016784561797976494, -0.006294450256973505, -0.013248195871710777, -0.10649284720420837, 0.02698306366801262, 0.018912192434072495, -0.008358601480722427, 0.034370306879282, -0.015246198512613773, 0.006727932021021843, 0.04720006510615349, -0.0005059436080045998, 0.011922004632651806, 2.366963715789998e-34, -0.0036278488114476204, 0.031770940870046616, -0.00555714126676321, 0.0017220833105966449, 0.009205777198076248, 0.018185779452323914, 0.04059522971510887, 0.013839604333043098, 0.037343643605709076, -0.08487334847450256, -0.017760977149009705]
640
640
['Tao Lei', 'Wengong Jin', 'Regina Barzilay', 'Tommi Jaakkola']
1705.09037v3
The design of neural architectures for structured objects is typically guided by experimental insights rather than a formal process. In this work, we appeal to kernels over combinatorial structures, such as sequences and graphs, to derive appropriate neural operations. We introduce a class of deep recurrent neural operations and formally characterize their associated kernel spaces. Our recurrent modules compare the input to virtual reference objects (cf. filters in CNN) via the kernels. Similar to traditional neural operations, these reference objects are parameterized and directly optimized in end-to-end training. We empirically evaluate the proposed class of neural architectures on standard applications such as language modeling and molecular graph regression, achieving state-of-the-art results across these applications.
Deriving Neural Architectures from Sequence and Graph Kernels
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1705.09037v3
Title Deriving Neural Architectures Sequence Graph Kernels Summary design neural architecture structured object typically guided experimental insight rather formal process work appeal kernel combinatorial structure sequence graph derive appropriate neural operation introduce class deep recurrent neural operation formally characterize associated kernel space recurrent module compare input virtual reference object cf filter CNN via kernel Similar traditional neural operation reference object parameterized directly optimized endtoend training empirically evaluate proposed class neural architecture standard application language modeling molecular graph regression achieving stateoftheart result across application Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.014733297750353813, 0.04007579758763313, -0.02269957773387432, 0.011624796316027641, -0.007425493560731411, -0.0345165878534317, 0.004953464493155479, 0.03830841928720474, 0.024719465523958206, 0.001643794821575284, 0.05051158741116524, -0.012354633770883083, -0.002367529785260558, 0.09574262797832489, 0.03041026182472706, 0.009375378489494324, 0.01775435358285904, 0.013290539383888245, -0.024228984490036964, -0.02653355710208416, 0.02356850728392601, -0.0071320789866149426, 0.03764327988028526, 0.027376465499401093, -0.03788759559392929, 0.006301058456301689, 0.014251671731472015, -0.017857136204838753, -0.032383840531110764, -0.06534314900636673, 0.03700237348675728, -0.0030020507983863354, 0.03528294339776039, 0.05239839851856232, 2.03805348064634e-06, -0.022923314943909645, -0.023169761523604393, -0.008346992544829845, 0.006551601458340883, -0.0037912745028734207, 0.011991781182587147, 0.006409213412553072, 0.042433686554431915, -0.013466965407133102, -0.02024739794433117, -0.005081658251583576, 0.07512200623750687, 0.025449981912970543, -0.005885809659957886, 0.03983960300683975, 0.0027348517905920744, -0.05724014341831207, 0.04163137078285217, -0.03415654972195625, 0.031212782487273216, -5.656498979078606e-05, 0.03841265290975571, 0.025098031386733055, 0.026076870039105415, -0.0390872023999691, -0.0025253277271986008, 0.062221817672252655, 0.02206329256296158, 1.6380068700527772e-05, 0.06394470483064651, 0.017826247960329056, 0.04149799793958664, -0.0690840408205986, -0.001128548290580511, 0.05798013135790825, -0.03911161422729492, -0.02021678164601326, 0.011269687674939632, 0.015138361603021622, -0.008514516986906528, -0.040052298456430435, -0.017573721706867218, -0.040315791964530945, -0.015355492010712624, 0.0008620204753242433, -0.003128042910248041, -0.010135496035218239, 0.061346329748630524, -0.048782214522361755, 0.012631822377443314, 0.02680264040827751, -0.015287750400602818, 0.004168262705206871, 0.002405657898634672, -0.040790703147649765, 0.006847579963505268, -0.036605942994356155, 0.01889035291969776, 0.01974472403526306, 0.0034083425998687744, -0.01747848466038704, 0.042122140526771545, -0.016439247876405716, 0.07098501175642014, -0.05467028543353081, 0.04938528686761856, -0.04903446137905121, 0.035139136016368866, -0.014963604509830475, -0.02256208285689354, -0.0008126171305775642, -0.0667470246553421, 0.04861941561102867, -0.0016448319656774402, 0.05107016861438751, -0.09177500009536743, 0.024573059752583504, 0.025873763486742973, 0.06709342449903488, 0.017687946557998657, 0.01020866259932518, -0.06039363518357277, -0.00819691363722086, -0.002956204582005739, -0.026300819590687752, 0.007274762261658907, 0.08894716203212738, 0.022823026403784752, 0.06395244598388672, -0.020069580525159836, 0.039009030908346176, 0.00311265722848475, 0.0201250147074461, 0.005988705437630415, -0.028957197442650795, 0.0072719631716609, -0.014402341097593307, 0.015008244663476944, 0.014487715438008308, -0.023729385808110237, 0.08756572753190994, 0.029283490031957626, -0.03535785898566246, 0.007871982641518116, -0.03662141412496567, -0.028481975197792053, -0.03676500543951988, 0.013147090561687946, -0.06942234188318253, 0.028303617611527443, -0.0178473312407732, -0.01699090376496315, -0.012149692513048649, 0.02298867702484131, -0.08339466154575348, -0.0435897596180439, 0.08667837828397751, 0.016955681145191193, -0.028134750202298164, 0.06301093101501465, -0.0031539935152977705, 0.013135123997926712, -0.034814562648534775, 0.023671170696616173, 0.015901552513241768, 0.007732063066214323, -0.010336381383240223, 0.011149991303682327, -0.0012067887000739574, 0.002620094921439886, -0.08100957423448563, -0.009443064220249653, -0.03320293501019478, -0.01767796277999878, 0.04266931861639023, -0.04247972369194031, -0.021835017949342728, 0.010945379734039307, -0.02342933788895607, 0.041065335273742676, 0.05236343666911125, 0.06046406924724579, 0.04223133623600006, 0.001181765110231936, -0.013752439990639687, -0.005205895286053419, -0.019880350679159164, -0.018841266632080078, 0.05469276383519173, -0.02659318409860134, 0.010899159125983715, -0.017577841877937317, 0.008676477707922459, -0.008373420685529709, -0.02425060234963894, 0.0018407374154776335, -0.004171533044427633, 0.0007405405049212277, -0.07249687612056732, 0.02831893227994442, -0.03694316744804382, -0.05550646409392357, -0.03974785655736923, 0.00815658364444971, -0.015137671492993832, -0.013343322090804577, -0.011870047077536583, 0.0039004783611744642, 0.009471100755035877, 0.01125540491193533, -0.029564449563622475, -0.045241352170705795, -0.0038575127255171537, -0.09403692185878754, -0.029746195301413536, -0.00731915095821023, -0.012794915586709976, 0.02315082959830761, -0.009808074682950974, 0.01737825572490692, 0.025278747081756592, 0.0029414489399641752, 0.025744425132870674, -0.05865731090307236, 0.006999770645052195, 0.01490243524312973, 0.028015419840812683, -0.03125423565506935, -0.009823808446526527, -0.0069931610487401485, -0.012415166944265366, 0.00824808981269598, 0.013615597039461136, 0.04247933253645897, 0.017679087817668915, 0.012622162699699402, -0.00040097953751683235, 0.08145197480916977, -0.055116165429353714, -0.015507202595472336, -0.053815823048353195, 0.01103377528488636, -0.012892603874206543, -0.0015122544718906283, -0.022562114521861076, 0.008736732415854931, 0.030797814950346947, -0.06274151802062988, -0.04299061745405197, 0.07030553370714188, -0.019281379878520966, 0.011749602854251862, 0.0037832907401025295, 0.0027850717306137085, -0.010700440965592861, 0.015882132574915886, -0.02982824295759201, 0.004735651891678572, 0.00930162612348795, -0.0027143254410475492, -0.01411446463316679, -0.04717513918876648, 0.023304179310798645, -0.03956244885921478, 0.03339695930480957, 0.004498239606618881, -0.020352032035589218, -0.009471023455262184, 0.024834761396050453, -0.010451756417751312, -0.021921679377555847, 0.03051110915839672, -0.006871109362691641, 0.025402888655662537, 0.021267449483275414, 0.04218721389770508, -0.01871444098651409, -0.0051866564899683, 0.022009849548339844, -0.03704692795872688, -0.06809145957231522, 0.08637436479330063, -0.017190394923090935, -0.03500285744667053, 0.054946597665548325, 0.0006666062981821597, -0.06015846133232117, -0.07111302763223648, -0.06848165392875671, -0.06060681492090225, 0.07290427386760712, 0.040887944400310516, -0.1199910044670105, 0.03383147716522217, -0.004308228846639395, -0.029274318367242813, 0.04817933216691017, -0.0066943601705133915, -0.05133587867021561, -0.005286010913550854, 0.00028742096037603915, 0.0031291982159018517, 0.051376450806856155, -0.007443651556968689, -0.03470950201153755, 0.013126014731824398, 0.05088576301932335, 0.025255564600229263, -0.003011680906638503, -0.05533292144536972, 0.008330699056386948, 0.03230167180299759, -0.022930312901735306, -0.030185146257281303, 0.05666470527648926, 0.008516076020896435, 0.013024418614804745, -0.03827408701181412, 0.0019573187455534935, 0.036390651017427444, -0.012930603697896004, -0.04111243784427643, -0.00472951028496027, -0.004899151157587767, -0.006508184131234884, 0.013259274885058403, -0.04128650575876236, 0.06445018947124481, 0.029004108160734177, 0.018263602629303932, -0.01021216157823801, -0.02621537074446678, 0.02710147388279438, 0.0012105797650292516, 0.06282886862754822, 0.020909329876303673, 0.046634070575237274, -0.002401418052613735, -0.016200987622141838, -0.010807706043124199, -0.023360269144177437, -0.04860960319638252, 0.03848873823881149, -0.009419958107173443, -0.009410766884684563, 0.019736452028155327, -0.008209601044654846, -0.021812181919813156, 0.07485712319612503, -0.0079186474904418, 0.04512973502278328, 0.002392475726082921, -0.04501751437783241, -0.015353454276919365, 0.019089113920927048, 0.00045700359623879194, 0.018135467544198036, -0.03263590484857559, 0.01826363056898117, -0.015724776312708855, 0.04498757794499397, 0.017341919243335724, -0.06346646696329117, 0.003503218060359359, 0.029262829571962357, 0.07083889842033386, -0.0005718809552490711, -0.036224767565727234, 0.02459014765918255, -0.060639914125204086, 0.02565186657011509, -0.04333031177520752, 0.01482968870550394, -0.029019078239798546, 0.024663440883159637, -0.015814825892448425, -0.04785572737455368, -0.003465663641691208, 0.03496817871928215, 0.004211811814457178, -0.06628500670194626, -0.00819422397762537, 0.034912388771772385, -0.045357588678598404, -0.005810855887830257, 0.056450314819812775, -0.09046921133995056, 0.0030917017720639706, -0.054778289049863815, -0.0129304314032197, -0.020314060151576996, -0.03169918805360794, 0.002380466554313898, -0.005219427403062582, 0.028667056933045387, 0.014611294493079185, -0.06400797516107559, -0.030762730166316032, -0.1395457237958908, -0.049710463732481, -0.03779979422688484, -0.062157753854990005, 0.02485164999961853, 0.01920919120311737, -0.018702160567045212, 0.02919863350689411, -0.03682703524827957, 0.009962314739823341, 0.026098303496837616, -0.035799670964479446, -0.027581214904785156, 0.057086165994405746, 0.040694709867239, 0.014478126540780067, -0.0017114814836531878, 0.011290613561868668, -0.0063920654356479645, 0.005074901506304741, -0.058292604982852936, 0.0965033769607544, 0.048992034047842026, -0.022908596321940422, -0.033968761563301086, 0.035704463720321655, -0.05850140005350113, 0.032584115862846375, -0.02550865150988102, 0.10056734830141068, 0.019123025238513947, -0.046235859394073486, -0.03166665881872177, 0.0044877114705741405, -0.004548522178083658, 0.020508361980319023, 0.037163473665714264, 0.010975976474583149, -0.07970426976680756, -0.023714978247880936, 0.03962358832359314, -0.055940430611371994, -0.017610089853405952, 0.026268772780895233, -0.03395655006170273, -0.009651638567447662, -0.06198888272047043, 0.006548132281750441, -0.024706970900297165, 0.006284751929342747, 0.028736844658851624, 0.01613750122487545, 0.044289480894804, -0.08983657509088516, -0.06367706507444382, -0.013114585541188717, 0.07965031266212463, 0.02832467295229435, -0.0407518669962883, -0.03847966343164444, 0.04156341403722763, 0.023435009643435478, -0.015364645048975945, 0.01062796264886856, -0.04795198515057564, -0.09238570928573608, -0.0418257936835289, 0.06155795976519585, 0.018410423770546913, -0.02331574447453022, 0.0022179947700351477, -0.0394737608730793, 0.06315287202596664, 0.0213985126465559, 0.04352035000920296, -0.041296835988759995, 0.011504915542900562, -0.0598897822201252, -0.027474505826830864, 0.007940108887851238, -0.022240400314331055, 0.07224493473768234, 0.02341274730861187, -0.01545531116425991, 0.0022679029498249292, -0.01685483381152153, 0.030331501737236977, 0.024833915755152702, 0.039963673800230026, 0.04782664775848389, -0.007859138771891594, -0.029007263481616974, 0.029645713046193123, 0.01190479751676321, -0.017844313755631447, -0.029471641406416893, -0.0321032740175724, 0.019337089732289314, 0.05188198760151863, -0.014277458190917969, -0.054354820400476456, 0.017411572858691216, 0.006241487804800272, -0.025334719568490982, 0.020258020609617233, 0.00840295385569334, 0.02364998124539852, 0.023099036887288094, 0.03617233410477638, -0.007223010528832674, -0.0003582629142329097, -0.022843172773718834, 0.04470713809132576, -0.010911083780229092, -0.0051001133397221565, -0.018531499430537224, 0.04794900864362717, -0.06182442232966423, 0.01555983442813158, -0.014307708479464054, 0.021753748878836632, -0.015164277516305447, 0.01613972894847393, 0.04997558891773224, -0.04001552611589432, 0.04587074741721153, 0.02278944104909897, 0.051801104098558426, -0.06189792975783348, 0.03927998244762421, -0.04914870485663414, 0.05103456974029541, 0.04761902242898941, 0.02171611413359642, -0.023583151400089264, -0.032305117696523666, 0.07271301001310349, 0.07027585059404373, 0.0013185401912778616, -0.023690147325396538, -0.026063619181513786, -0.01224491186439991, 0.021597757935523987, 0.019948655739426613, -0.01036563515663147, -0.02469002641737461, -0.027182575315237045, -0.017335519194602966, -0.03958301991224289, 0.06100925803184509, 0.033350538462400436, 0.054432760924100876, 0.026792895048856735, 0.011640646494925022, -0.014829223044216633, 0.046835340559482574, -0.08911637961864471, 0.005943511612713337, -0.0051820240914821625, -0.011152159422636032, -0.046314168721437454, -0.0349213108420372, -6.226495128653776e-33, 0.023925218731164932, -0.018654048442840576, -0.02828405611217022, 0.04627382755279541, -0.03665829822421074, 0.04243065044283867, -0.09230407327413559, -0.02023220621049404, -0.010447411797940731, 0.048443857580423355, 0.007706519681960344, 0.010213514789938927, -0.004238181281834841, 0.0020735743455588818, 0.0454983189702034, 0.0013439434114843607, 0.017568282783031464, 0.02459169179201126, 0.038854654878377914, 0.017755690962076187, 0.061867937445640564, 0.08637086302042007, 0.03606930375099182, 0.026242626830935478, -0.021856170147657394, 0.025682104751467705, 0.042266733944416046, -0.008185962215065956, -0.023256059736013412, 0.04365723952651024, -0.010691111907362938, 0.024229377508163452, -0.008483091369271278, -0.010003003291785717, 0.001111636753194034, 0.01654837653040886, -0.06938161700963974, 0.0015489767538383603, -0.022948306053876877, -0.02569456212222576, -0.032881204038858414, -0.006113994400948286, 0.09158336371183395, -0.016166657209396362, -0.018690045922994614, 0.008217019960284233, 0.06839011609554291, -0.009946690872311592, -0.05594122037291527, -0.00274838344193995, -0.02695271000266075, -0.015619154088199139, 0.008843181654810905, 0.02460138313472271, 0.021291781216859818, 0.0003811432106886059, -0.015234721824526787, 0.024160072207450867, -0.02310832403600216, 0.031208867207169533, -0.03012525849044323, 0.04798847436904907, 0.03501639515161514, 0.058841705322265625, 0.04083370789885521, 0.03128105774521828, 0.001173417898826301, -0.02118689753115177, -0.004309366922825575, -0.0075707039795815945, -0.03948001563549042, 0.052313171327114105, 0.0833670049905777, -0.03422003611922264, 0.05494952201843262, -0.04514293745160103, -0.12920673191547394, 0.01857077144086361, -0.03638041391968727, 0.02792213298380375, -0.05736643821001053, 0.019866764545440674, 0.035358816385269165, 0.004950799513608217, 0.021153245121240616, -0.04630057513713837, -0.024958841502666473, -0.03689238801598549, -0.015383654274046421, -0.054671511054039, -0.010903551243245602, 0.04796192795038223, 0.005472403485327959, -0.06240507587790489, 0.03167751058936119, 0.0035355149302631617, 0.034987643361091614, 0.0010280752321705222, 0.0029056272469460964, 0.023187022656202316, -0.05150068178772926, -0.021289929747581482, -0.015592583455145359, -0.0001656657987041399, 0.005886987783014774, -0.014992444775998592, 0.024637799710035324, -0.0011997863184660673, 0.012406302616000175, -0.023736031726002693, -0.05549178645014763, -0.03539858013391495, 0.017688462510704994, 0.011133759282529354, -0.007302973419427872, 0.0021712956950068474, -0.0007992878090590239, 0.09178822487592697, 0.05950067937374115, -0.010527118109166622, -0.0032709622755646706, 0.00891364086419344, 0.010353350080549717, 0.03285444155335426, -0.0795595720410347, -0.029912065714597702, -0.07246869802474976, 0.04154591262340546, -0.019297119230031967, -0.04551241174340248, -0.044371023774147034, -0.012066621333360672, 2.808599788295396e-07, 0.022689811885356903, -0.008063297718763351, 0.05421782657504082, -0.030416706576943398, 0.014652344398200512, -0.005450021009892225, 0.006042557302862406, 0.03682728111743927, -0.07192309945821762, -0.05507586523890495, 0.06474911421537399, -0.02613123320043087, 0.026658186689019203, -0.02681325189769268, -0.015614420175552368, 0.0010468346299603581, -0.051177214831113815, -0.007774780038744211, -0.013330046087503433, 0.000277089886367321, 0.016292214393615723, 0.06683721393346786, 0.0559949092566967, -0.014530448243021965, 0.026000918820500374, -0.01680087111890316, -0.012316304259002209, 0.014200150035321712, 0.017258774489164352, 0.009888538159430027, -0.03571917861700058, -0.029378626495599747, -0.010195313952863216, 0.04640336334705353, -0.032456304877996445, -0.009357498958706856, -0.0262459609657526, -0.0010949353454634547, -0.03726360201835632, -0.02065691165626049, 0.044036660343408585, 0.026499571278691292, 0.05694378539919853, -0.02887365035712719, -0.012588843703269958, -0.011370672844350338, -0.0643395408987999, 0.017705027014017105, 0.006545360200107098, -0.01771681010723114, 0.06064809858798981, 0.009407496079802513, 0.030706064775586128, 0.04080098122358322, -0.011463184840977192, -0.031447041779756546, 0.023766526952385902, -0.026925118640065193, 0.014308609999716282, 0.022502660751342773, -0.0038337253499776125, 0.010791052132844925, -0.03139254450798035, 0.0077728708274662495, 0.03949878364801407, 0.05339081585407257, -0.026805594563484192, 2.5723898483795873e-34, 0.016356823965907097, -0.02682262845337391, 0.005662670359015465, 0.028359834104776382, 0.023261329159140587, -0.005097190849483013, -0.022912267595529556, 0.010784842073917389, -0.012303879484534264, -0.06911806762218475, -0.06455893069505692]
641
641
['Michał Zapotoczny', 'Paweł Rychlikowski', 'Jan Chorowski']
1705.10209v1
We show that a recently proposed neural dependency parser can be improved by joint training on multiple languages from the same family. The parser is implemented as a deep neural network whose only input is orthographic representations of words. In order to successfully parse, the network has to discover how linguistically relevant concepts can be inferred from word spellings. We analyze the representations of characters and words that are learned by the network to establish which properties of languages were accounted for. In particular we show that the parser has approximately learned to associate Latin characters with their Cyrillic counterparts and that it can group Polish and Russian words that have a similar grammatical function. Finally, we evaluate the parser on selected languages from the Universal Dependencies dataset and show that it is competitive with other recently proposed state-of-the art methods, while having a simple structure.
On Multilingual Training of Neural Dependency Parsers
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1705.10209v1
Title Multilingual Training Neural Dependency Parsers Summary show recently proposed neural dependency parser improved joint training multiple language family parser implemented deep neural network whose input orthographic representation word order successfully parse network discover linguistically relevant concept inferred word spelling analyze representation character word learned network establish property language accounted particular show parser approximately learned associate Latin character Cyrillic counterpart group Polish Russian word similar grammatical function Finally evaluate parser selected language Universal Dependencies dataset show competitive recently proposed stateofthe art method simple structure Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.01944381557404995, 0.052187707275152206, 0.013219852931797504, 0.08311734348535538, -0.046065762639045715, 0.02014671266078949, 0.0015334389172494411, -0.010520074516534805, -0.010884782299399376, -0.013641287572681904, 0.007354326080530882, -0.037044864147901535, 0.016053467988967896, -0.0013310664799064398, 0.008907009847462177, -0.06741923838853836, 0.005824755411595106, 0.0059600044041872025, -0.023764073848724365, 0.006599707528948784, 0.035204727202653885, 0.024933306500315666, -0.027640653774142265, 0.019578205421566963, -0.04759589582681656, -0.00891587883234024, 0.02804730273783207, -0.0009466815390624106, -0.01612360216677189, -0.04143253341317177, 0.031117288395762444, 0.03232939541339874, 0.0024683803785592318, 0.03251085802912712, 2.189599854318658e-06, -0.054610077291727066, -0.03646460548043251, -0.035908181220293045, 0.04499112442135811, -0.021721351891756058, 0.023023542016744614, -0.10232706367969513, -0.020645754411816597, -0.01477152667939663, -0.029538651928305626, -0.027904529124498367, 0.03183146193623543, 0.06661515682935715, 0.01909564435482025, 0.06394850462675095, -0.023710861802101135, -0.07641789317131042, 0.03698326274752617, -0.0026698859874159098, -0.056519147008657455, -0.024126727133989334, 0.0010555231710895896, 0.01753378100693226, -0.05058032274246216, -0.03428167104721069, -0.011651686392724514, 0.01397180650383234, 0.011950111016631126, -0.003155881306156516, -0.03642980754375458, 0.01008423138409853, -0.005444888956844807, 0.005708563141524792, 0.015375991351902485, 0.06216366961598396, -0.009589849039912224, -0.010181176476180553, 0.0016397155122831464, -0.006405362393707037, -0.003723211120814085, 0.011939438059926033, -0.01685040071606636, 0.03703584522008896, -0.020882809534668922, 0.03246734291315079, 0.08584830164909363, 0.02674480900168419, -0.00532239954918623, 0.017401641234755516, -0.009059419855475426, 0.10840693861246109, -0.005541917402297258, -0.0346575565636158, 0.015643663704395294, 0.0056442259810864925, -0.00906829908490181, -0.015666639432311058, 0.0684603899717331, -0.027599239721894264, 0.019745945930480957, 0.02229892835021019, -0.032154496759176254, -0.09966926276683807, 0.023293372243642807, -0.1003139317035675, -0.011499850079417229, -0.0036856376100331545, -0.0602046400308609, 0.01035968866199255, -0.024794870987534523, 0.021625520661473274, -0.007978389970958233, -0.0434594489634037, 0.006545675452798605, 0.012818736955523491, -0.04257001355290413, -0.0022940149065107107, -0.053693026304244995, 0.03360624611377716, -0.0574580542743206, 0.009665080346167088, -0.031771086156368256, -0.024305982515215874, 0.0004926692927256227, -0.0056630754843354225, 0.02530517987906933, 0.04109058901667595, -0.0005832102033309639, 0.006471013650298119, -0.008871139958500862, 0.06301891058683395, -0.04596947878599167, -0.004482616670429707, -0.06044929102063179, -0.045514676719903946, 0.03903188183903694, 0.03819163888692856, 0.007170140277594328, -0.015269915573298931, 0.009047016501426697, 0.03960235416889191, 0.014626632444560528, -0.018918342888355255, -0.023141155019402504, -0.00462287338450551, -0.00031552190193906426, -0.03516388311982155, -0.01807362027466297, -0.08857818692922592, -0.004468858242034912, -0.0014379976782947779, 0.019032279029488564, -0.04651642218232155, 0.013851569034159184, 0.022451363503932953, -0.014527751132845879, 0.05742044746875763, 0.005637818947434425, -0.05238023400306702, 0.02575043961405754, -0.02143198996782303, 0.042552389204502106, 0.048698823899030685, 0.014765397645533085, -0.012787319719791412, 0.016167491674423218, -0.024732867255806923, -0.02601882815361023, 0.015617900528013706, -0.05400676280260086, -0.037072185426950455, -0.012869490310549736, -0.008683748543262482, -0.016512185335159302, 0.03541542589664459, 0.027285799384117126, 0.06271126121282578, -0.011495145969092846, 0.011819628067314625, -0.012990118935704231, 0.05213990435004234, 0.038654688745737076, 0.039169080555438995, 0.039444755762815475, 0.008340670727193356, -0.0018555924762040377, 0.06324413418769836, -0.0350775271654129, 0.0026498513761907816, 0.03528502956032753, -0.018199831247329712, -0.08737745881080627, 0.018745314329862595, 0.026934444904327393, -0.028826609253883362, 0.014514469541609287, -0.044036321341991425, -0.006052972283214331, -0.06138797849416733, 0.05219327285885811, 0.022299710661172867, -0.02890647016465664, 0.03366338834166527, 0.07525055855512619, -0.030232910066843033, -0.019256293773651123, 0.02370424009859562, -0.0162565466016531, 0.03746982663869858, -0.00320989266037941, -0.01924830488860607, -0.014784866012632847, 0.02208910882472992, -0.026384461671113968, 0.01863143965601921, -0.013040369376540184, -0.006765753962099552, 0.020492171868681908, -0.05552205443382263, 0.03261355683207512, 0.02385627292096615, 0.0067309848964214325, 0.05782375484704971, -0.09123728424310684, -0.0010605460265651345, 0.03525364026427269, 0.08808301389217377, -0.04146062582731247, 0.029155155643820763, -0.0031213946640491486, 0.023801999166607857, 0.028940770775079727, 0.03665955364704132, 0.018497705459594727, 0.05035366490483284, -0.0087257269769907, 0.03163580223917961, 0.024929022416472435, -0.0733594074845314, 0.022439878433942795, 0.028922097757458687, -0.07425810396671295, -0.051788460463285446, 0.012640085071325302, -0.04513511061668396, -0.005732388235628605, 0.022472290322184563, 0.000529102107975632, -0.03168514743447304, 0.04394558072090149, 0.0010985088301822543, 0.045131128281354904, -0.002379870042204857, -0.0007422119379043579, 0.01583075150847435, 0.046096526086330414, -0.003348410362377763, 0.07442730665206909, -0.025407567620277405, 0.03636540472507477, -0.04934683069586754, 0.021701494231820107, 0.028301561251282692, 0.00011534428631421179, -0.0363180935382843, 0.031805671751499176, 0.0061905113980174065, -0.054705552756786346, -0.005328052211552858, 0.02690022997558117, -0.011505293659865856, -0.007169547490775585, -0.07161188125610352, -0.012570898048579693, -0.028862319886684418, 0.03518792241811752, 0.014099670574069023, 0.007962945848703384, 0.012364145368337631, -0.03254871815443039, -0.024765482172369957, 0.033050838857889175, 0.014981064945459366, -0.017775913700461388, 0.023525910452008247, 0.0023179484996944666, 0.03598956763744354, -0.017047345638275146, -0.025162307545542717, -0.031384412199258804, 0.014992459677159786, 0.029067926108837128, -0.06479636579751968, -0.04316946864128113, 0.03656359389424324, -0.02587820589542389, 0.051168251782655716, 0.02355230040848255, -0.06061214208602905, 0.02336203306913376, -0.01551367249339819, 0.024932511150836945, 0.00843591894954443, -0.028525931760668755, -0.040264859795570374, 0.04397893324494362, -0.023880193009972572, -0.012085123918950558, -0.016776181757450104, 0.03810153901576996, 0.09571696072816849, -0.018724186345934868, -0.005050812382251024, -0.041743822395801544, 0.027313681319355965, 0.0195698793977499, -0.015234135091304779, -0.011714506894350052, -0.016210658475756645, -0.06405524909496307, -0.009196615777909756, 0.017174813896417618, -0.012967903167009354, -0.019745271652936935, -0.008655544370412827, -0.0014946466544643044, 0.014690603129565716, 0.06763549149036407, -0.03278720751404762, -0.013373385183513165, -0.07437940686941147, -0.04629642143845558, -0.04933008551597595, 0.04936911165714264, 0.031182480975985527, -0.004031580872833729, 0.009539840742945671, -0.06779412180185318, -0.018761729821562767, 0.004812689498066902, 0.005738384556025267, 0.01995539851486683, 0.039613451808691025, -0.05274653807282448, 0.001255217008292675, -0.026844000443816185, -0.04306643456220627, -0.010292346589267254, -0.015959618613123894, -0.019353030249476433, 0.011165285483002663, 0.01734248362481594, -0.016028188169002533, 0.04522223398089409, -0.0014659969601780176, 0.0003322238626424223, 0.04693225771188736, -0.028193453326821327, 0.02350069396197796, -0.019250184297561646, 0.032020844519138336, 0.020428823307156563, -0.011936978437006474, -0.0048095849342644215, 0.04339912533760071, 0.015422464348375797, 0.03452706336975098, 0.027229171246290207, -0.019614316523075104, -0.06392942368984222, -0.01813879981637001, 0.0030501552391797304, 0.012413659133017063, -0.047854289412498474, -0.05028492957353592, -0.03575853258371353, -0.07094183564186096, 0.02119666524231434, 0.06567832827568054, 0.011122911237180233, -0.0603092797100544, 0.00879291258752346, -0.02358686737716198, 0.003975237719714642, 0.01835070177912712, 0.022786470130085945, -0.07216492295265198, -0.008554111234843731, 0.006004807073622942, -0.0063264877535402775, -0.015301571227610111, -0.05558783560991287, 0.01965221017599106, -0.08898978680372238, -0.03132052719593048, -0.019107820466160774, -0.011454615741968155, -0.016772642731666565, -0.013558263890445232, -0.06342115253210068, -0.052094440907239914, 0.0034530723933130503, 0.020249096676707268, 0.002937490353360772, -0.03261011466383934, 0.026896242052316666, -0.061953410506248474, -0.044528596103191376, -0.012710082344710827, -0.0478496178984642, 5.0301168812438846e-05, 0.028659284114837646, 0.02950277552008629, -0.07526600360870361, 0.010519412346184254, 0.025080667808651924, -0.018101071938872337, -0.003717305138707161, -0.017276691272854805, 0.02911572903394699, 0.019463740289211273, -0.017971154302358627, -0.02760802023112774, 0.009591708891093731, -0.00609222799539566, 0.03437178581953049, 0.014228303916752338, 0.03859284520149231, -0.003099234774708748, 0.017937058582901955, 0.027203816920518875, -0.007283281534910202, 0.030191695317626, 0.010685783810913563, -0.010092229582369328, -0.01325047668069601, -0.02212359383702278, -0.025039345026016235, 0.008756735362112522, -0.09012315422296524, -0.008193113841116428, 0.038000136613845825, -0.02682282030582428, -0.054799117147922516, -0.1103799045085907, -0.07014308869838715, 0.014558280818164349, 0.02905314788222313, -0.006300825159996748, 0.01602303236722946, 0.011530368588864803, -0.014818208292126656, 0.004673350602388382, 0.026071233674883842, 0.07660651206970215, -0.012565459124743938, -0.06019581854343414, 0.0008406717097386718, 0.0789995938539505, 0.002064183820039034, 0.00607054540887475, -0.010687517933547497, -0.02109117992222309, -0.03985292464494705, 0.01800394058227539, 0.03525379300117493, -0.0026032296009361744, 0.001149811316281557, -0.02148403972387314, -0.077157162129879, -0.040289897471666336, 0.006859822664409876, -0.03856516629457474, -0.023974718526005745, 0.031078357249498367, -0.010091565549373627, 0.01259584166109562, 0.0217523705214262, 0.02545727789402008, 0.0254504531621933, -0.05653008446097374, 0.008675327524542809, -0.01270926371216774, 0.022225312888622284, 0.055264078080654144, -0.0005902874399907887, 0.030554400756955147, -0.00306397071108222, 0.018343403935432434, -0.0717957392334938, 0.039797473698854446, -0.06646134704351425, -0.03525827080011368, -0.009012683294713497, 0.044152963906526566, 0.04400638863444328, 0.008223985321819782, 0.0081745320931077, -0.06694413721561432, 0.00898090098053217, -0.02410149574279785, 0.014445367269217968, 0.08857787400484085, 0.05799032375216484, 0.039897672832012177, 0.008027805015444756, 0.006578423082828522, -0.03146270662546158, -0.003037999849766493, 0.010313905775547028, 0.03556343913078308, -0.05608382448554039, -0.000760359107516706, 0.004739201162010431, -0.030098596587777138, -0.011306374333798885, 0.0003279962984379381, 0.028792129829525948, 0.06463880091905594, 0.029771262779831886, -0.006662387400865555, 0.11096877604722977, -0.07403614372015, 0.08792624622583389, -0.02089306153357029, 0.031817156821489334, 0.026852786540985107, 0.028064211830496788, -0.02280932106077671, -0.003942440263926983, 0.015278639271855354, -0.024425456300377846, -0.006292534526437521, -0.008641046471893787, 0.06434588879346848, -0.0006641164654865861, 0.02407807484269142, 0.025724416598677635, 0.0027723913080990314, -0.020057007670402527, -0.0019281128188595176, -0.02499103732407093, 0.021531928330659866, -0.07059749960899353, 0.032050445675849915, -0.01615799218416214, -0.015219788067042828, -0.03466959670186043, 0.019287949427962303, -0.007841362617909908, 0.012692205607891083, 0.0304860956966877, 0.03867209702730179, 0.036931466311216354, -0.016483241692185402, -0.040794745087623596, 0.026392202824354172, -0.0025339429266750813, -0.04678083956241608, -0.012569253332912922, -6.263657647871053e-33, 0.009893699549138546, 0.006963551975786686, -0.012210232205688953, -0.013788958080112934, 0.015492361038923264, -0.00024786792346276343, -0.015174904838204384, 0.001054871710948646, -0.03237590566277504, 0.00671930518001318, -0.016613055020570755, -0.017503034323453903, 0.018825171515345573, 0.04350731149315834, 0.06145576760172844, -0.0005266769439913332, -0.020337266847491264, -0.003998773638159037, 0.04684393107891083, -0.018273843452334404, 0.10403656959533691, 0.07120449841022491, 0.13139262795448303, -0.03888804838061333, 0.022352125495672226, -0.026560131460428238, 0.027558645233511925, 0.030285315588116646, -0.00733004929497838, 0.030622955411672592, -0.004453667905181646, -0.015364974737167358, 0.04110947623848915, 0.004493433982133865, 0.004506860394030809, 0.0027816963847726583, -0.08274032175540924, -0.03737310320138931, -0.005281452089548111, 0.03545638173818588, -0.05501721426844597, 0.004546403419226408, 0.07786264270544052, 0.0016021248884499073, 0.013316367752850056, 0.08511027693748474, 0.02354508265852928, -0.027414092794060707, 0.02434825338423252, 0.03191080316901207, -0.08523517102003098, 0.04651084169745445, -0.0037047199439257383, 0.04346701502799988, 0.05558636784553528, 0.06968817114830017, -0.0014874800108373165, -0.027420535683631897, -0.05266570299863815, 0.006646864116191864, -0.05800633504986763, 0.07020590454339981, 0.009742223657667637, -0.007890620268881321, -0.023253515362739563, 0.03618324175477028, 0.003003795864060521, -0.04457759112119675, -0.005066545680165291, 0.03071991354227066, 0.011316733434796333, 0.01740804687142372, 0.03905294090509415, 0.01993805728852749, 0.046678874641656876, -0.02676686830818653, -0.0928037017583847, -0.0008607612107880414, 0.07265979051589966, 0.05096970126032829, -0.040063969790935516, -0.015034468844532967, -0.029203731566667557, -0.015224949456751347, 0.039077360183000565, -0.028706014156341553, -0.005832218565046787, -0.050962042063474655, -0.009878778830170631, -0.042956672608852386, 0.0011759947519749403, 0.010823319666087627, 0.007317501585930586, -0.008874205872416496, -0.030598793178796768, 0.010747344233095646, 0.009322477504611015, 0.02996361069381237, -0.020516538992524147, 0.03563625365495682, -0.037142910063266754, -0.04003806412220001, -0.04788026586174965, 0.011125331744551659, 0.05548827350139618, 0.009219269268214703, 0.08727321773767471, -0.026177426800131798, -0.02110569179058075, 0.013469069264829159, -0.02308519557118416, -0.012567892670631409, 0.007749447599053383, 0.08125724643468857, 0.009200401604175568, -0.011300343088805676, -0.02225162275135517, 0.0268798116594553, 0.06529725342988968, -0.0011847532587125897, -0.04145628213882446, -0.04264155775308609, 0.015146216377615929, 0.03234327584505081, -0.0490046925842762, 8.931691263569519e-05, -0.03336542099714279, 0.038826584815979004, 0.046115946024656296, -0.007853010669350624, 0.0035304033663123846, 0.03316717594861984, 2.908068097440264e-07, 0.03236565738916397, 0.03138558939099312, 0.01398471463471651, -0.05964793637394905, 0.01625226065516472, -0.007291264832019806, -0.04182679206132889, 0.03683606535196304, -0.04877978190779686, 0.021113110706210136, 0.0022927788086235523, -0.046207841485738754, 0.03056292049586773, 0.042706310749053955, -0.1283286064863205, -0.05503121763467789, -0.04875633120536804, -0.04876880347728729, -0.03362157568335533, 0.01275347638875246, 0.04452185705304146, 0.09806281328201294, 0.02054107002913952, -0.01463756337761879, -0.03925212100148201, 0.011590943671762943, -0.014247973449528217, 0.03950575366616249, -0.0002824947005137801, -0.017647497355937958, 0.002752159256488085, -0.009498984552919865, -0.01927630603313446, 0.009550240822136402, -0.016299370676279068, 0.05641529709100723, 0.0028105108067393303, 0.0019426989601925015, -0.0006562580238096416, 0.009632511995732784, 0.067380890250206, 0.008583559654653072, -0.029257073998451233, -0.04034936800599098, 0.05971621349453926, 0.005632469896227121, -0.016603952273726463, 0.011312429793179035, -0.002251348225399852, 0.03318732976913452, 0.015218505635857582, -0.005244276951998472, -0.034975815564394, 0.009060469456017017, 0.014331597834825516, -0.07762730121612549, -0.06326377391815186, -0.024298878386616707, -0.020846307277679443, 0.04723194241523743, 4.8554848035564646e-05, 0.031254202127456665, 0.014167193323373795, -0.05005386099219322, 0.010447747074067593, 0.006043763365596533, 0.006167035084217787, 2.318774187124794e-34, -0.011201772838830948, 0.022168640047311783, 0.015177012421190739, 0.017813201993703842, 0.026812558993697166, -0.002905130386352539, -0.0731930211186409, 0.06622587144374847, -0.02539338357746601, -0.041473664343357086, -0.003452453063800931]
642
642
['Marian Tietz', 'Tayfun Alpay', 'Johannes Twiefel', 'Stefan Wermter']
1706.02124v2
Ladder networks are a notable new concept in the field of semi-supervised learning by showing state-of-the-art results in image recognition tasks while being compatible with many existing neural architectures. We present the recurrent ladder network, a novel modification of the ladder network, for semi-supervised learning of recurrent neural networks which we evaluate with a phoneme recognition task on the TIMIT corpus. Our results show that the model is able to consistently outperform the baseline and achieve fully-supervised baseline performance with only 75% of all labels which demonstrates that the model is capable of using unsupervised data as an effective regulariser.
Semi-Supervised Phoneme Recognition with Recurrent Ladder Networks
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1706.02124v2
Title SemiSupervised Phoneme Recognition Recurrent Ladder Networks Summary Ladder network notable new concept field semisupervised learning showing stateoftheart result image recognition task compatible many existing neural architecture present recurrent ladder network novel modification ladder network semisupervised learning recurrent neural network evaluate phoneme recognition task TIMIT corpus result show model able consistently outperform baseline achieve fullysupervised baseline performance 75 label demonstrates model capable using unsupervised data effective regulariser Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.008167542517185211, 0.0533309131860733, 0.02403194271028042, 0.020374435931444168, 0.018757058307528496, -0.005465107969939709, 0.037153396755456924, -0.020483996719121933, 0.0333324559032917, 0.033537209033966064, -0.05731246620416641, -0.034057050943374634, 0.019655730575323105, 0.0464630089700222, 0.018118418753147125, -0.0799979642033577, -0.0025356162805110216, 0.003036073874682188, 0.014822909608483315, -0.010807536542415619, 0.002677864395081997, -0.011338485404849052, -0.03964697942137718, 0.007254239171743393, -0.05642402917146683, 0.015051816590130329, 0.006903624627739191, 0.0096899950876832, -0.03621714934706688, -0.047479309141635895, 0.008180445991456509, 0.03895394131541252, 0.004199220333248377, 0.0839885026216507, 2.3201628209790215e-06, -0.013158533722162247, -0.01829085312783718, -0.03684191405773163, -0.043068286031484604, -0.07301412522792816, 0.015054129995405674, 0.020054996013641357, -0.06894365698099136, 0.0026947518344968557, 0.016718843951821327, -0.026184625923633575, 0.08825276792049408, 0.00029721413739025593, 0.02429771050810814, 0.052379101514816284, -0.005147833842784166, -0.04097374901175499, 0.014351114630699158, -0.020938631147146225, -0.020126687362790108, -0.044925712049007416, 0.012961764819920063, 0.02785184606909752, -0.006525709759443998, -0.04948294907808304, -0.014224546030163765, 0.028056880459189415, 0.005792040843516588, -0.0038162400014698505, 0.02223481982946396, 0.027492456138134003, 0.02508973702788353, -0.04510960355401039, 0.024142112582921982, 0.05886480584740639, -0.05386079475283623, -0.021928761154413223, 0.008792729116976261, 0.030484266579151154, -0.044483572244644165, -0.016019701957702637, -0.011806434020400047, -0.00529401283711195, -0.026529645547270775, -0.004755419213324785, -0.05140408128499985, 0.05345727130770683, 0.016836771741509438, -0.014574836939573288, -0.014232766814529896, -0.0052330223843455315, -0.007540236692875624, -0.026684686541557312, -0.020258409902453423, -0.03140472248196602, 0.0760805606842041, -0.02642170898616314, 0.07849839329719543, 0.04617933928966522, 0.012688802555203438, -0.005769507959485054, 0.04450404271483421, -0.10045155137777328, 0.019584478810429573, -0.06867580860853195, 0.022035082802176476, -0.0007915667374618351, -0.023728780448436737, -0.003287105355411768, -0.014865348115563393, 0.015394147485494614, -0.006989823188632727, -0.02057305909693241, -0.04577857255935669, -0.0021826711017638445, -0.031119339168071747, -0.005590321030467749, -0.013736806809902191, 0.017583252862095833, 0.00930311344563961, -0.018746819347143173, -0.06446924060583115, -0.04085642099380493, 0.006935305893421173, -0.030741918832063675, -0.007813990116119385, 0.04593187943100929, -0.020393790677189827, -0.020696930587291718, 0.03522771596908569, 0.023838607594370842, 0.0033167563378810883, 0.014881724491715431, -0.0410614050924778, -0.03671756759285927, 0.008566463366150856, 0.020636966452002525, 0.035850875079631805, 0.03975667804479599, 0.004707316402345896, 0.023170309141278267, -0.027029801160097122, -0.012707119807600975, -0.01934613287448883, 0.01752176322042942, -0.024529634043574333, -0.05812189728021622, -0.023033900186419487, -0.05439664050936699, 0.013698969967663288, -0.03944060206413269, 0.028866376727819443, -0.0016660657711327076, 0.005071168765425682, -0.011210175231099129, 0.01701579988002777, 0.08557702600955963, -0.02733517251908779, 0.0022655948996543884, 0.08350419253110886, -0.012340409681200981, 0.058515626937150955, 0.01671331375837326, 0.0459449402987957, 0.032476894557476044, 0.0010750462533906102, -0.04926469549536705, 0.031069226562976837, 0.0462745726108551, -0.02493233233690262, -0.07181833684444427, -0.02580941654741764, -0.07774469256401062, -0.00858657993376255, 0.02195964753627777, 0.02656954526901245, -0.004884200636297464, 0.028422463685274124, -0.04040432348847389, 0.00899400096386671, 0.09775916486978531, 0.09106378257274628, 0.033637192100286484, 0.026481863111257553, -0.0005120402202010155, 0.020856792107224464, 0.008705804124474525, 0.0284725334495306, -0.008354561403393745, -0.009864761494100094, -0.002257572254166007, -0.02982230670750141, -0.01367818471044302, -0.05210549756884575, -0.010443899780511856, -0.008560116402804852, -0.025595588609576225, -0.03320853412151337, 0.01343225035816431, 0.061272043734788895, 0.005230080336332321, -0.0003519694728311151, -0.03939399495720863, -0.037360791116952896, -0.020203836262226105, -0.02492583356797695, -0.03062797337770462, 0.01658538170158863, 0.051035378128290176, 0.011213197372853756, -0.031016165390610695, -0.012403993867337704, 0.00025947627727873623, -0.003805384272709489, 0.050572168081998825, -0.028118796646595, 0.0015589249087497592, 0.0219615139067173, -0.06934523582458496, 0.0012601956259459257, 0.08240747451782227, -0.007838763296604156, 0.04236920550465584, -0.04670139029622078, 0.013393078930675983, 0.016766240820288658, -0.0141338175162673, -0.012505227699875832, 0.010713431984186172, 0.007066022604703903, -0.02714407630264759, 0.02313992753624916, 0.025877749547362328, 0.022991327568888664, 0.007936878129839897, -0.016093695536255836, 0.00485545489937067, 0.018495259806513786, -0.02158525586128235, -0.006387416273355484, -0.017598481848835945, -0.05503051355481148, -0.025847837328910828, 0.009965957142412663, 0.005267668515443802, 0.03276342898607254, 0.02922184392809868, 0.01915791817009449, -0.07486371695995331, 0.05701552331447601, -0.01672435738146305, 0.040534671396017075, -0.06079726293683052, 0.04560818150639534, 0.044779740273952484, 0.057819999754428864, 0.008775792084634304, 0.022006569430232048, 0.02073514461517334, 0.00885242410004139, -0.04519079253077507, 0.027702894061803818, 0.0109643479809165, -0.037424348294734955, -0.025722794234752655, 0.05293763428926468, -0.05621093884110451, -0.005391578655689955, -0.033257000148296356, 0.024766478687524796, -0.022474225610494614, 0.009953238070011139, -0.053262803703546524, -0.015281707048416138, -0.017420602962374687, 0.012368183583021164, -0.06321649998426437, 0.0043831211514770985, 0.00015078343858476728, -0.0767187550663948, -0.004263963550329208, 0.009389548562467098, 0.008868749253451824, -0.022297263145446777, 0.004024326801300049, -0.02974197454750538, 0.0016583921387791634, -0.04565849155187607, -0.026768647134304047, 0.017862072214484215, 0.05183849856257439, -0.008708901703357697, -0.1093883290886879, 0.0037064128555357456, -0.017323002219200134, -0.008592817932367325, 0.0438908152282238, 0.025212634354829788, -0.05406354367733002, -0.0157039575278759, 0.030943680554628372, 0.055148907005786896, -0.017566734924912453, 0.017885928973555565, -0.00317274103872478, -0.024448007345199585, 0.029443247243762016, -0.026461821049451828, -0.011813630349934101, -0.006405903026461601, -0.00040210335282608867, 0.049955595284700394, -0.0005713091231882572, -0.052597835659980774, 0.045804549008607864, -0.002090718597173691, 0.0578104704618454, 0.014905666932463646, -0.057388484477996826, -0.03663736209273338, -0.05004502087831497, -0.03769034147262573, -0.01991257630288601, -0.037488896399736404, 0.021835898980498314, -0.017995180562138557, -0.03570523485541344, 0.00927848368883133, -0.010983198881149292, -0.04109242931008339, -0.01971300318837166, -0.057784270495176315, -0.026510845869779587, 0.03640163317322731, 0.025845644995570183, 0.005437138490378857, 0.0054442486725747585, -0.05980084091424942, 0.022399337962269783, -0.028557224199175835, 0.005969883408397436, -0.04575987532734871, -0.021459512412548065, -0.006834498140960932, 0.021684760227799416, -0.023508166894316673, -0.033467620611190796, -0.04687513783574104, 0.0036285470705479383, -0.0008037342340685427, 0.0007344271871261299, -0.0534084215760231, 0.0030978911090642214, 0.03719300776720047, 0.06870701909065247, -0.015040512196719646, 0.04750310629606247, 0.027002785354852676, 0.014806772582232952, -0.0003382460563443601, 0.08937305212020874, 0.016956022009253502, 0.00849138293415308, -0.0242573544383049, 0.043202560395002365, 0.07277392596006393, 0.009745338931679726, 0.02753647416830063, 0.017475970089435577, -0.05863957479596138, 0.005686223041266203, -0.0022160548251122236, -0.01169702410697937, 0.003646485973149538, -0.00545083312317729, 0.016875937581062317, -0.059348903596401215, 0.03436553478240967, 0.06936008483171463, -0.016304926946759224, -0.0361211895942688, -0.014912794344127178, -0.02268810197710991, -0.03859899193048477, -0.0053195348009467125, 0.013310149312019348, -0.017583094537258148, 0.017093168571591377, 0.013515828177332878, -0.01525835320353508, 0.0029213111847639084, -0.01856306381523609, -0.014415533281862736, -0.07301624119281769, 0.04264640435576439, 0.012810934334993362, -0.03248366713523865, 0.006004113703966141, -0.02376064471900463, 0.010943333618342876, 0.010206623002886772, -0.050298403948545456, 0.01995134726166725, -0.011212103068828583, -0.07753721624612808, 0.05685749650001526, -0.1186116561293602, 0.00384313752874732, -0.00034822666202671826, -0.07099678367376328, 0.0017360367346554995, 0.033901289105415344, 0.03665429726243019, -0.03261764720082283, -0.015425091609358788, 0.028522636741399765, -0.04055137187242508, 0.01164130587130785, -0.028835123404860497, 0.037057798355817795, 0.01664154604077339, -0.02555263414978981, 0.018082698807120323, 0.024621782824397087, 2.335126555408351e-05, 0.02370784431695938, 0.009777163155376911, 0.07236947119235992, 0.012659735046327114, 0.0064643751829862595, -0.03330530971288681, 0.06913425028324127, -0.0005104525480419397, 0.018829405307769775, 0.028571609407663345, -0.020150676369667053, -0.005015706643462181, 0.01396195963025093, 0.05165133997797966, -0.0055103846825659275, -0.004006675444543362, 0.004458523355424404, -0.009151821956038475, -0.10071452707052231, -0.02867412194609642, -0.01801576279103756, -0.029863830655813217, 0.07424982637166977, 0.026739519089460373, 0.024426331743597984, 0.003783753840252757, 0.019200298935174942, -0.04397131875157356, 0.015229799784719944, -0.004532680381089449, 0.04288758337497711, -0.053792860358953476, -0.02076377160847187, 0.04759129136800766, -0.045739129185676575, 0.016427982598543167, -0.08900503069162369, -0.03608384355902672, -0.0005901481490582228, -0.023062804713845253, -0.0008076630183495581, 0.016045287251472473, 0.03261127322912216, -0.05663803592324257, -0.04712008312344551, 0.05215116962790489, 0.010826323181390762, -0.04431319236755371, -0.044312816113233566, 0.06797362118959427, -0.052804626524448395, -0.016561690717935562, 0.010659255087375641, -0.011915010400116444, 0.09782209992408752, 0.0006436020485125482, -0.0309592392295599, -0.04819491133093834, -0.04758056253194809, -0.00962020643055439, -0.06369085609912872, 0.07870785146951675, 0.012965671718120575, -0.0013030105037614703, -0.06846016645431519, 0.015841402113437653, 0.04948170855641365, 0.06462521106004715, 0.006283196620643139, 0.025676291435956955, 0.04806021600961685, 0.05606916919350624, -0.019263725727796555, -0.038851555436849594, -0.0055192806757986546, -0.007172172889113426, 0.02617597207427025, 0.05987780913710594, -0.03352269530296326, 0.010367182083427906, -0.0558929368853569, -3.174792436766438e-05, -0.00450690696015954, 0.06893610209226608, 0.028181057423353195, 0.031291015446186066, 0.04187324643135071, 0.030682921409606934, -0.00044996527140028775, 0.0481904037296772, -0.008168448694050312, 0.04020675644278526, 0.03302894905209541, -0.022075451910495758, -0.0824371874332428, 0.03651822730898857, 0.06844451278448105, -0.009542685933411121, -0.03136632964015007, 0.02310039848089218, 0.02586524561047554, -0.013611184433102608, -0.018293216824531555, -0.04675036668777466, -0.013651303946971893, 0.023089248687028885, 0.00993776973336935, -0.045505668967962265, 0.01996912620961666, 0.018189717084169388, 0.03366886079311371, 0.021958328783512115, 0.010323169641196728, -0.009127669036388397, -0.04128945991396904, -0.035204723477363586, -0.003031548811122775, 0.01495716255158186, -0.021826956421136856, 0.024241937324404716, -0.02012060210108757, -0.10816391557455063, 0.0030817710794508457, -0.011221812106668949, 0.052167199552059174, 0.01247071847319603, 0.02222076803445816, -0.006846249103546143, 0.008890443481504917, 0.0902172327041626, -0.00010284371091984212, -0.04487999901175499, 0.051575373858213425, -0.0009433661471121013, -0.009702960960566998, -6.33920813916634e-33, -0.012173761613667011, -0.023993806913495064, 0.012903118506073952, 0.02691059000790119, -0.027242690324783325, 0.018831342458724976, -0.019078774377703667, 0.016131488606333733, -0.013782802037894726, -0.04187589883804321, -0.016473978757858276, -0.024186844006180763, 0.04056587442755699, 0.009570162743330002, 0.024050995707511902, 0.014296089299023151, 0.05259089544415474, 0.010664020664989948, 0.043522462248802185, -0.04195796325802803, 0.026898305863142014, 0.06535562127828598, 0.06864463537931442, -0.0637650117278099, -0.05289555713534355, 0.04796499013900757, -0.005790087394416332, -0.011243362911045551, 0.05087873339653015, 0.03257710859179497, -0.05658827722072601, 0.012466978281736374, 0.009037138894200325, -0.029817357659339905, 0.01173397433012724, 0.03710196167230606, -0.13378210365772247, -0.0072962515987455845, -0.02265830710530281, 0.07561460882425308, -0.0138405105099082, 0.019291773438453674, 0.053140196949243546, -0.025481007993221283, -0.059860117733478546, 0.030202247202396393, 0.02818811684846878, -0.052385710179805756, -0.014212979935109615, -0.03517584130167961, -0.057822369039058685, 0.03453660383820534, 0.003961366135627031, -0.06479978561401367, 0.06109154224395752, 0.012875416316092014, -0.029712822288274765, -0.01896555908024311, -0.05947105213999748, 0.029681967571377754, -0.011503759771585464, 0.011554239317774773, 0.06392020732164383, 0.06939586251974106, -0.017043033614754677, 0.03483607620000839, 0.07540645450353622, -0.06460071355104446, -0.02092689834535122, -0.017076406627893448, 0.005486418958753347, -0.0032612152863293886, 0.06573010981082916, -0.05023789405822754, 0.09399621933698654, -0.05182702839374542, -0.026686402037739754, 0.022731097415089607, 0.03978949785232544, 0.00856789294630289, -0.008634385652840137, 0.038282398134469986, -0.037869859486818314, 0.00832017045468092, 0.024843329563736916, -0.030688857659697533, -0.017392929643392563, -0.0633460059762001, 0.02118961326777935, -0.021018076688051224, 0.009714294224977493, 0.04510705545544624, 0.0433192178606987, -0.005524267442524433, 0.00014768613618798554, -0.04762154445052147, 0.055371351540088654, -0.015401673503220081, 0.031051449477672577, 0.01701223850250244, -0.0612182654440403, -0.003516641678288579, 0.029349585995078087, 0.06444398313760757, -0.01135324314236641, 0.005371596198529005, 0.031590163707733154, 0.0073254345916211605, -0.03663299232721329, -0.024611612781882286, -0.023762516677379608, -0.024103816598653793, 0.0160487312823534, 0.09345042705535889, 0.05311756208539009, -0.03355918824672699, -0.01662151888012886, 0.0670040175318718, -0.016197778284549713, 0.003871433436870575, 0.009679832495748997, 0.02968415804207325, -0.016613321378827095, 0.03680267184972763, -0.04217637702822685, 0.004178320989012718, -0.048745304346084595, -0.03216804563999176, -0.021152254194021225, -0.026715299114584923, 0.014757886528968811, 0.029211562126874924, 2.9853899263798667e-07, -0.02630390226840973, -0.030280370265245438, 0.04457806050777435, -0.027673041447997093, 0.044941630214452744, -0.006817136891186237, -0.030606914311647415, 0.01461462490260601, -0.0013826648937538266, 0.014685090631246567, 0.03863241523504257, -0.03437250852584839, 0.06895474344491959, 0.004303575959056616, -0.0995471403002739, -0.022224050015211105, -0.055291272699832916, 0.013361087068915367, -0.051043551415205, 0.008328534662723541, 0.029366806149482727, 0.09512003511190414, 0.009648068808019161, -0.06518175452947617, 0.038234006613492966, -0.022473620250821114, 0.016090547665953636, 0.0064821261912584305, 0.012995478697121143, -0.01640227437019348, 0.019973469898104668, 0.024324525147676468, -0.020659178495407104, -0.0003271115419920534, -0.01430060900747776, 0.03997793793678284, 0.06497730314731598, -0.014509925618767738, -0.03811901807785034, 0.006107761990278959, 0.01576364040374756, 0.04923240840435028, 0.0022768634371459484, 0.0037903159391134977, 0.042238157242536545, 0.008893492631614208, -0.03781502693891525, -0.015715228393673897, 0.011944159865379333, 0.028180386871099472, 0.04415372014045715, -0.022680822759866714, -0.016368374228477478, 0.033548448234796524, 0.02661415934562683, -0.05433706194162369, -0.03614688664674759, -0.019473228603601456, 0.03119506686925888, 0.0461575947701931, -0.04242711514234543, 0.0050763632170856, 0.0046874457038939, 0.015377696603536606, 0.016650525853037834, 0.019591573625802994, -0.023708704859018326, 2.2780524914184176e-34, 0.0072149899788200855, -0.02625950798392296, -0.002025611000135541, 0.004730522632598877, -0.022777043282985687, -0.02442924678325653, 0.01170718390494585, 0.015027282759547234, 1.829201755754184e-05, -0.00948958657681942, -0.022203605622053146]
643
643
['Junbo', 'Zhao', 'Yoon Kim', 'Kelly Zhang', 'Alexander M. Rush', 'Yann LeCun']
1706.04223v2
While autoencoders are a key technique in representation learning for continuous structures, such as images or wave forms, developing general-purpose autoencoders for discrete structures, such as text sequence or discretized images, has proven to be more challenging. In particular, discrete inputs make it more difficult to learn a smooth encoder that preserves the complex local relationships in the input space. In this work, we propose an adversarially regularized autoencoder (ARAE) with the goal of learning more robust discrete-space representations. ARAE jointly trains both a rich discrete-space encoder, such as an RNN, and a simpler continuous space generator function, while using generative adversarial network (GAN) training to constrain the distributions to be similar. This method yields a smoother contracted code space that maps similar inputs to nearby codes, and also an implicit latent variable GAN model for generation. Experiments on text and discretized images demonstrate that the GAN model produces clean interpolations and captures the multimodality of the original space, and that the autoencoder produces improve- ments in semi-supervised learning as well as state-of-the-art results in unaligned text style transfer task using only a shared continuous-space representation.
Adversarially Regularized Autoencoders
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1706.04223v2
Title Adversarially Regularized Autoencoders Summary autoencoders key technique representation learning continuous structure image wave form developing generalpurpose autoencoders discrete structure text sequence discretized image proven challenging particular discrete input make difficult learn smooth encoder preserve complex local relationship input space work propose adversarially regularized autoencoder ARAE goal learning robust discretespace representation ARAE jointly train rich discretespace encoder RNN simpler continuous space generator function using generative adversarial network GAN training constrain distribution similar method yield smoother contracted code space map similar input nearby code also implicit latent variable GAN model generation Experiments text discretized image demonstrate GAN model produce clean interpolation capture multimodality original space autoencoder produce improve ments semisupervised learning well stateoftheart result unaligned text style transfer task using shared continuousspace representation Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.003998361993581057, 0.10605769604444504, -0.023995626717805862, 0.047150611877441406, 0.011567512527108192, -0.005254093091934919, 0.02776133269071579, 0.010005134157836437, -0.03373934328556061, 0.008464936167001724, -0.037195928394794464, 0.001652729930356145, -0.002006764989346266, 0.05625103786587715, 0.0657661110162735, -0.09693030267953873, -0.010911847464740276, 0.021240882575511932, -0.00797034241259098, -0.04581284895539284, 0.037520259618759155, -0.008772514760494232, 0.0013690533814951777, 0.020922278985381126, -0.03474530205130577, 0.008530628867447376, -0.025498250499367714, 0.009054114110767841, 0.03550288453698158, -0.026688992977142334, 0.02646789513528347, 0.03830118477344513, 0.047581762075424194, -0.00019598662038333714, 2.4981677597679663e-06, 0.01514508482068777, 0.0012679904466494918, -0.03287685289978981, 0.030451519414782524, 0.015259107574820518, 0.010529367253184319, -0.05916213616728783, -0.023340974003076553, -0.0152105912566185, -0.03577036038041115, -0.08231937140226364, 0.05026966705918312, 0.027781911194324493, 0.0496569499373436, 0.03825144097208977, -0.044899821281433105, -0.05991378799080849, 0.022696856409311295, -0.053649649024009705, -0.010520067065954208, -0.05506955087184906, 0.008167535066604614, 0.021730544045567513, -0.02089100144803524, 0.021271349862217903, -0.059230104088783264, 0.03295828774571419, 0.039600953459739685, -0.030332917347550392, 0.04117346554994583, 0.05289028212428093, 0.01477099023759365, -0.0011691334657371044, -0.028604675084352493, 0.07007773220539093, -0.054056767374277115, -0.00908621959388256, -0.03222925215959549, 0.006278767716139555, -0.01987677812576294, -0.013796779327094555, -0.0435141958296299, 0.005397547967731953, -0.021434955298900604, 0.022946996614336967, -0.09158341586589813, 0.0031643081456422806, -0.0031605230178683996, -0.00266224960796535, -0.018713127821683884, -0.007724354043602943, 0.02293829806149006, 0.011470275931060314, -0.060214221477508545, -0.0198264941573143, -0.037288255989551544, -0.029252704232931137, 0.0622427798807621, 0.02902226895093918, 0.0302231777459383, -0.05193532258272171, -0.0634026825428009, -0.04829730466008186, 0.011046439409255981, 0.0021871929056942463, 0.06606163084506989, -0.026493048295378685, -0.011779628694057465, -0.0035743340849876404, -0.04241402447223663, 0.043760158121585846, -0.0272689089179039, 0.03619057312607765, -0.021165376529097557, -0.004078397527337074, -0.003688968950882554, -0.023862546309828758, -0.028359059244394302, 0.007011031731963158, -0.004666171036660671, -0.06730818748474121, -0.046875499188899994, -0.03101971372961998, -0.008023134432733059, 0.02511049248278141, 0.01772438734769821, 0.07693346589803696, -0.06956048309803009, -0.03263682872056961, 0.02613471820950508, -0.013302057050168514, -0.049707673490047455, 0.05352835729718208, 0.020256463438272476, 0.028074365109205246, 0.007983135059475899, 0.02091667614877224, 0.054083678871393204, 0.007737432140856981, -0.03223984315991402, 0.07936529070138931, -0.025523580610752106, 0.08137676864862442, -0.015230878256261349, -0.004372937139123678, -0.02680143713951111, -0.011349712498486042, 0.005421601701527834, -0.04467729479074478, 0.0004027033573947847, -0.021271085366606712, -0.013782570138573647, -0.05856485292315483, -0.006833989638835192, -0.01703321747481823, 0.01945720799267292, 0.11293981224298477, -0.029012005776166916, -0.03588752821087837, 0.0766870528459549, 0.017600154504179955, 0.04776933044195175, 0.0006489442894235253, 0.051447492092847824, 0.06339410692453384, -0.006854865700006485, -0.018061988055706024, -0.008561846800148487, 0.049373265355825424, 0.03376542031764984, -0.010645112954080105, -0.05348767712712288, -0.050954438745975494, 0.01371375098824501, 0.016163524240255356, 0.06755409389734268, 0.05066162347793579, 0.0029228113126009703, -0.026602471247315407, 0.03787381574511528, 0.006315578706562519, 0.05208686366677284, 0.03998471051454544, 0.026866767555475235, 0.03576650097966194, -0.007839309051632881, 0.02837606519460678, 0.016942491754889488, 0.05908656865358353, 0.005848362576216459, 0.000943801598623395, 0.0101338354870677, 0.04356509447097778, -0.02933402918279171, -0.03387594595551491, 0.04809139668941498, -0.00725239934399724, 0.01304167602211237, -0.056170981377363205, 0.016472304239869118, 0.023319022729992867, -0.0413459911942482, -0.06643587350845337, 0.011901339516043663, -0.012617785483598709, -0.001956989523023367, 0.005220700986683369, 0.025174004957079887, 0.00927662942558527, 0.0258697047829628, 0.009836653247475624, 0.010658345185220242, -0.038446541875600815, -0.02780085988342762, -0.01168198324739933, -0.023329131305217743, -0.029499836266040802, 0.009813258424401283, -0.06688553094863892, -0.0554676428437233, 0.007341041229665279, -0.010868217796087265, 0.049836885184049606, -0.045932069420814514, 0.03419404849410057, 0.02168978750705719, 0.031846411526203156, 0.02489045448601246, 0.040398336946964264, 0.0086800092831254, -0.023523502051830292, 0.020257456228137016, 0.03184351325035095, 0.011530687101185322, 0.007687542587518692, -0.03313468024134636, -0.006235403474420309, 0.019576212391257286, -0.07573788613080978, -0.044203147292137146, -0.02682449296116829, -0.061201028525829315, -0.07177667319774628, -0.015015016309916973, -0.05255819112062454, 0.014480607584118843, 0.05106290802359581, -0.02877022884786129, -0.02343100495636463, 0.014968207105994225, 0.0172426775097847, -0.04193887114524841, -0.01963437721133232, -0.011872134171426296, 0.0251457616686821, 0.03592388704419136, -0.012419184669852257, 0.032292794436216354, -0.005311592016369104, -0.012901486828923225, 0.017677629366517067, 0.0346280038356781, 0.049029625952243805, 0.011819741688668728, 0.006709403824061155, 0.016006220132112503, -0.006823814939707518, -0.0003860115830320865, 0.033060044050216675, 0.009364180266857147, 0.003119393717497587, 0.028754232451319695, -0.006592310033738613, -0.02207287959754467, 0.0002696836309041828, -0.025976162403821945, 0.013429922983050346, 0.043047502636909485, 0.008530664257705212, -0.026880396530032158, -0.038862377405166626, 0.045625463128089905, -0.009045947343111038, -0.053379397839307785, 0.05778155475854874, -0.00037621724186465144, 0.03689894825220108, -0.022808058187365532, -0.00994117371737957, 0.0043916660360991955, 0.04662388190627098, 0.017081331461668015, -0.06203487142920494, -0.03317372873425484, 0.013861927203834057, 0.00838572345674038, 0.04603997617959976, 0.002551727695390582, -0.10506924986839294, 0.0011140635469928384, -0.02203037589788437, 0.035549528896808624, 0.08094464242458344, 0.025854093953967094, 0.012054483406245708, -0.0265226811170578, 0.025175081565976143, -0.036304086446762085, -0.0030948736239224672, -0.014390680007636547, 0.03441788628697395, 0.005767446011304855, 0.016711760312318802, -0.014467841014266014, 0.046878255903720856, 0.06015150621533394, 0.03518277034163475, -0.01887405849993229, 0.03464334458112717, 0.008043765090405941, -0.028284501284360886, -0.023747127503156662, 0.010803116485476494, -0.0012657903134822845, 0.004775822162628174, -0.05078998953104019, -0.04946748539805412, 0.031139468774199486, 0.00483380863443017, -0.014960750937461853, 0.013885010965168476, -0.009013024158775806, 0.025329584255814552, 0.040375638753175735, 0.015090172179043293, 0.04776524379849434, 0.0033629313111305237, -0.017237553372979164, -0.03302929550409317, 0.00343726365827024, 0.042111918330192566, 0.023787839338183403, 0.0016195649513974786, 0.003553926246240735, -0.01950010284781456, -0.021432500332593918, -0.021369824185967445, -0.052233513444662094, -0.011245213449001312, 0.0207266453653574, 0.0037678785156458616, 0.033598948270082474, -0.01730242744088173, 0.0009710706071928144, 0.002108316170051694, -0.025932425633072853, 0.04022826626896858, -0.03351731225848198, 0.01807711459696293, -0.0015338881639763713, 0.11330047249794006, 0.03592540696263313, -0.0441010408103466, -0.08103802800178528, 0.012222729623317719, 0.025141872465610504, 0.04957786574959755, -0.05293743312358856, 0.04686852917075157, -0.04102933034300804, 0.004388747736811638, -0.01837990991771221, 0.0515611432492733, 0.018439024686813354, 0.012846598401665688, 0.06454657018184662, -0.04940113425254822, -0.004300916567444801, 0.03325236216187477, -0.011135447770357132, -0.03984915465116501, 0.01800243929028511, 0.006460989359766245, 0.04985208809375763, 0.014157998375594616, 0.015251540578901768, -0.04098528251051903, -0.008049322292208672, -0.048139072954654694, -0.011199044063687325, 0.0343528613448143, 0.0034544069785624743, 0.002605867339298129, -0.06663211435079575, 0.030097274109721184, 0.034014925360679626, 0.017230119556188583, -0.025580652058124542, 0.01045586634427309, 0.015445439144968987, 0.01410493440926075, -0.026095593348145485, 4.875183367403224e-05, 0.052490368485450745, -0.006808789446949959, 0.04334508255124092, -0.022649776190519333, -0.046860143542289734, -0.054680805653333664, -0.04131805896759033, 0.03681112453341484, 0.05242491886019707, 0.052435554563999176, -0.02561589889228344, -0.0575992576777935, 0.0024556051939725876, 0.037471409887075424, 0.008153783157467842, -0.030380016192793846, 0.07762271165847778, 0.01665487326681614, -0.0023083642590790987, 0.03314927965402603, 0.07741094380617142, -0.00022326601902022958, 0.036113884299993515, 0.04509730264544487, -0.020632212981581688, -0.010152882896363735, -0.025143973529338837, -0.06151749938726425, -0.0017662040190771222, 0.037783149629831314, -0.021737031638622284, 0.03409632667899132, -0.01003778725862503, -0.040369391441345215, -0.05689944326877594, 0.04750974476337433, -0.05870172381401062, -0.03205612301826477, -0.006206995341926813, 0.011062192730605602, -0.02197958715260029, -0.07257246971130371, -0.02545768767595291, -0.0058963242918252945, 0.051932986825704575, 0.003126329043880105, -0.04666614159941673, -0.022695643827319145, -0.017304426059126854, -0.046785105019807816, -0.06635532528162003, 0.03936862573027611, 0.024001484736800194, 0.02434499002993107, -0.02831161767244339, 0.04924793168902397, -0.03063048981130123, -0.0005387378623709083, -0.027504296973347664, -0.062137212604284286, -0.011108797043561935, -0.016759224236011505, 0.0481523759663105, -0.0014358568005263805, 0.0456891730427742, -0.020793920382857323, -0.009444477036595345, 0.05661654472351074, 0.013713235035538673, -0.028387896716594696, -0.035772837698459625, 0.039590463042259216, 0.0037131246645003557, -0.0053381226025521755, 0.012928376905620098, -0.012325551360845566, 0.09595310688018799, -0.012373946607112885, -0.0122532919049263, -0.0027373782359063625, -0.007772338576614857, 0.004427091218531132, -0.05885632336139679, -0.0012209793785586953, -0.02489783614873886, 0.01320164930075407, -0.047314032912254333, 0.01335945539176464, -0.03208254650235176, 0.0064016408286988735, -0.07294321805238724, 0.007211081217974424, 0.03811237961053848, 0.02635360322892666, -0.00782211497426033, -0.022293424233794212, 0.03574768826365471, 0.030259478837251663, -0.0654398575425148, 0.02742752805352211, 0.032368432730436325, 0.04636518657207489, -0.03564196079969406, 0.02824055776000023, 0.016584675759077072, 0.012268584221601486, 0.02151419408619404, 0.03550919517874718, -0.02857819013297558, 0.01967066153883934, 0.037870220839977264, 0.02350005693733692, -0.01823464222252369, 0.02769552730023861, -0.014926913194358349, -0.006597677245736122, -0.0895581841468811, 0.0006345794536173344, 0.05558984354138374, -0.005062257871031761, 0.01836385577917099, 0.022170985117554665, 0.010069377720355988, -0.030027998611330986, 0.036122340708971024, -0.022517362609505653, -0.05581870675086975, 0.05750120431184769, -0.03179016709327698, 0.012888831086456776, -0.03650089353322983, 0.09137881547212601, 0.027026640251278877, 0.01634904369711876, -0.044238463044166565, -0.03014964796602726, -0.061487745493650436, 0.010427483357489109, 0.07360902428627014, -0.007947748526930809, 0.025296399369835854, 0.04119797423481941, 0.05757353454828262, -0.0478990338742733, -0.0030682673677802086, -0.03696887195110321, 0.012887437827885151, 0.0018066425109282136, 0.0567828044295311, -0.0023377062752842903, -0.026395617052912712, 0.005045538302510977, 0.003975544590502977, -0.0036791132297366858, 0.030242696404457092, -0.02845381759107113, -0.04042157530784607, -6.982057346956248e-33, -0.019406577572226524, -0.03041548654437065, -0.05984089523553848, -0.08317035436630249, -0.03629548102617264, -0.016146495938301086, -0.05509873852133751, -0.039494726806879044, 0.03315340727567673, 0.011441104114055634, 0.011474073864519596, -0.0035245197359472513, -0.010142561979591846, 0.05972839519381523, 0.04105281084775925, 0.006996618118137121, 0.04597218334674835, -0.0258141178637743, 0.016739608719944954, 0.031018566340208054, -0.018001291900873184, 0.06679610908031464, 0.032186005264520645, -0.09045782685279846, -0.01733810268342495, 0.007008635438978672, -0.02860497310757637, -0.06791525334119797, 0.05535588413476944, 0.012996207922697067, -0.017461517825722694, 0.009480555541813374, -0.006557171698659658, -0.008579417131841183, -0.016636285930871964, -0.0009654304594732821, -0.07440809905529022, -0.03704950585961342, -0.07504094392061234, 0.01855863258242607, -0.05826305225491524, -0.019098279997706413, 0.03557097539305687, -0.05590395629405975, 0.00511096091940999, -0.032185982912778854, 0.07633624225854874, -0.03352971374988556, -0.014177064411342144, -0.0633637085556984, -0.08252169191837311, 0.010242464020848274, -0.03170537203550339, -0.02320946380496025, 0.0013555274344980717, -0.010481107048690319, 0.0195410568267107, 0.016851093620061874, -0.058094337582588196, 0.012431591749191284, -0.00015276081103365868, 0.07355459779500961, 0.044304560869932175, 0.013754894025623798, 0.04438884183764458, 0.02849896438419819, 0.00294287595897913, -0.041260093450546265, -0.057346414774656296, 0.04055873677134514, 0.023654066026210785, 0.03484095260500908, 0.03001910075545311, 0.03980034962296486, 0.07032153010368347, -0.04140347242355347, -0.045899584889411926, 0.045500852167606354, -0.033747598528862, 0.03586701303720474, -0.02869388461112976, 0.06456463783979416, 0.007460076827555895, -0.040637824684381485, 0.01498201210051775, -0.10115140676498413, 0.00919151958078146, -0.04487856104969978, 0.015918606892228127, -0.015378163196146488, -0.031349796801805496, -0.0036356321070343256, 0.02526959218084812, -0.04551570490002632, -0.0435301810503006, -0.0034258237574249506, -0.02371911145746708, 0.011358522810041904, 0.015227372758090496, -0.000633675663266331, -0.026350732892751694, -0.014047378674149513, 0.04809613898396492, 0.04477309808135033, 0.0028997536282986403, 0.019151505082845688, 0.044650617986917496, 0.06484349071979523, -0.014786233194172382, -0.04907416179776192, -0.03214312344789505, -0.004198394250124693, 0.05306448042392731, 0.044987425208091736, -0.006120199337601662, -0.008986372500658035, -0.017798282206058502, 0.03683292493224144, 0.012884696945548058, -0.008107373490929604, -0.017409274354577065, -0.038940299302339554, 0.002217106521129608, 0.03533777594566345, -0.06518466770648956, -0.03394458070397377, -0.04963455721735954, -0.04564350098371506, 0.0527615062892437, -0.09575768560171127, -0.025226876139640808, -0.011456785723567009, 2.981791169531789e-07, -0.004539303481578827, -0.003465726040303707, 0.04716150835156441, -0.03007632866501808, 0.01093051116913557, -0.003777924459427595, -0.029209131374955177, 0.07031920552253723, -0.043266985565423965, -0.010472938418388367, 0.015442218631505966, 0.02502865344285965, 0.03268378973007202, 0.02565486542880535, -0.012621824629604816, 0.04020664468407631, -0.027300234884023666, 0.004292698577046394, -0.031049756333231926, 0.02325044386088848, 0.048557620495557785, 0.08519553393125534, -0.021818581968545914, -0.014686904847621918, 0.09390437602996826, 0.01963796094059944, 0.03373733535408974, 0.03561875596642494, 0.05122021213173866, 0.011678637936711311, -0.030367298051714897, 0.01376517117023468, -0.04032959043979645, -0.028196102008223534, -0.02862236090004444, -0.009688621386885643, 0.06493502110242844, 0.030437005683779716, -0.04500134661793709, 0.0049636089242994785, -0.015132222324609756, -0.007409716956317425, 0.01911657676100731, -0.036631520837545395, 0.034489694982767105, -0.024081604555249214, -0.03107156790792942, 0.005872674286365509, 0.02004181407392025, 0.016583839431405067, 0.0297145526856184, -0.029135841876268387, -0.008832632564008236, -0.011071055196225643, 0.05279615521430969, 0.009274471551179886, -0.009610206820070744, -0.047485969960689545, 0.003557553980499506, -0.038671303540468216, -0.04185866191983223, 0.038474831730127335, -0.03913560509681702, 0.013042312115430832, 0.028287895023822784, 0.0187065452337265, -0.005567437503486872, 2.65271123961803e-34, -0.03475023806095123, 0.004650396294891834, -0.02449479140341282, -0.0009126323275268078, -0.012072784826159477, -0.01908715069293976, 0.06435595452785492, 0.003489966504275799, 0.014062341302633286, -0.028720267117023468, -0.06394772976636887]
644
644
['Marek Rei', 'Helen Yannakoudakis']
1707.05227v1
We investigate the utility of different auxiliary objectives and training strategies within a neural sequence labeling approach to error detection in learner writing. Auxiliary costs provide the model with additional linguistic information, allowing it to learn general-purpose compositional features that can then be exploited for other objectives. Our experiments show that a joint learning approach trained with parallel labels on in-domain data improves performance over the previous best error detection system. While the resulting model has the same number of parameters, the additional objectives allow it to be optimised more efficiently and achieve better performance.
Auxiliary Objectives for Neural Error Detection Models
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1707.05227v1
Title Auxiliary Objectives Neural Error Detection Models Summary investigate utility different auxiliary objective training strategy within neural sequence labeling approach error detection learner writing Auxiliary cost provide model additional linguistic information allowing learn generalpurpose compositional feature exploited objective experiment show joint learning approach trained parallel label indomain data improves performance previous best error detection system resulting model number parameter additional objective allow optimised efficiently achieve better performance Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.053201671689748764, 0.03163161873817444, 0.020694365724921227, 0.008173013105988503, 0.015069123357534409, 0.03954949602484703, 0.004487816710025072, 0.004229953978210688, -0.010595637373626232, -0.049160826951265335, 0.0034147666301578283, -0.036453258246183395, 0.029932990670204163, 0.0006174460286274552, 0.005157488863915205, -0.01047626230865717, 0.06456518173217773, 0.02054833061993122, 0.07033975422382355, 0.01739024557173252, 0.001876484602689743, -0.029372865334153175, -0.016014203429222107, 0.03145461902022362, -0.0896243155002594, 0.011422066017985344, -0.015706168487668037, -0.0087082264944911, -0.00409860210493207, -0.07641302794218063, 0.07432547956705093, 0.04553740844130516, -0.004294905345886946, 0.07898368686437607, 2.0938309717166703e-06, -0.010748752392828465, -0.018019260838627815, -0.03674241155385971, 0.006683467887341976, -0.007644594181329012, 0.01879124715924263, 0.017319079488515854, -0.018604302778840065, 0.024552810937166214, 0.02658853493630886, -0.04803610220551491, 0.078733429312706, 0.06941521167755127, 0.032763779163360596, 0.07071986049413681, -0.00041664057062007487, 0.0010845548240467906, 0.018511611968278885, -0.005097572226077318, -0.01802293211221695, -0.027859104797244072, 0.05020834133028984, -0.012161079794168472, -0.013633595779538155, -0.014594999141991138, -0.006160994525998831, 0.04002382233738899, 0.024730389937758446, -0.012890079990029335, -0.03562874719500542, 0.008847101591527462, 0.04117788374423981, -0.05990808084607124, -0.01961631141602993, 0.03892102092504501, -0.037533629685640335, 0.021617170423269272, 0.007161041256040335, -0.021687252447009087, 0.026649735867977142, -0.03731865435838699, 0.022329119965434074, 0.043268512934446335, -0.05654800310730934, -0.013284210115671158, 0.03878743574023247, 0.000499142159242183, 0.028684740886092186, -0.023905927315354347, -0.019994141533970833, 0.03450910001993179, -0.01803300902247429, -0.05033114179968834, 0.021840175613760948, 0.015868589282035828, -0.0024889102205634117, -0.06021322309970856, 0.058996330946683884, 0.01207464188337326, -0.028599483892321587, 0.013413825072348118, -0.05066508799791336, -0.10536561161279678, 0.03268704563379288, -0.0971473827958107, 0.03024951182305813, -0.02436125837266445, -0.040127672255039215, -0.006509189028292894, -0.00541696697473526, 0.04977256804704666, 0.02075534500181675, 0.06837336719036102, -0.01013394258916378, 0.0264478400349617, -0.016250640153884888, -0.010097052901983261, -0.03737323358654976, 0.05795566365122795, 0.006890205666422844, -0.019218795001506805, -0.05043196305632591, -0.009278835728764534, -0.016217084601521492, 0.03135126456618309, 0.023813214153051376, 0.015492676757276058, -0.020994283258914948, 0.008748272433876991, 0.008208896033465862, 0.0014507907908409834, -0.006827380042523146, 0.043979741632938385, 0.007989541627466679, -0.04544282332062721, -0.014176618307828903, 0.03943214938044548, -0.01067107543349266, 0.004494296852499247, 0.010411377996206284, 0.057114481925964355, 0.02933454141020775, -0.05793480947613716, -0.05267845094203949, -0.008699857629835606, -0.04277653992176056, 0.012883855029940605, -0.029701322317123413, -0.04805925488471985, -0.005392775405198336, -0.05127820372581482, 0.009263948537409306, -0.027451269328594208, 0.0328102707862854, -0.012483634054660797, -0.009656514972448349, 0.0411333367228508, -0.09440238028764725, -0.032096344977617264, 0.041159581393003464, 0.02022363245487213, 0.06976445019245148, 0.03367516025900841, 0.04076892510056496, -0.008854350075125694, 0.0522078238427639, -0.0038910917937755585, 0.03539383038878441, 0.006025457754731178, -0.0021472140215337276, -0.05839715898036957, -0.03219497576355934, -0.056131891906261444, 0.026343919336795807, 0.028006458654999733, 0.02246694639325142, 0.05403117835521698, 0.011507962830364704, -0.03536446765065193, 0.029442591592669487, 0.02731313370168209, 0.024502864107489586, -0.023308563977479935, 0.01952432096004486, -0.03570012003183365, -0.013402280397713184, 0.020657235756516457, 0.0009798586834222078, 0.017911158502101898, -0.02607596293091774, -0.005434228107333183, 0.025787746533751488, -0.021755166351795197, -0.014519277960062027, -0.08038120716810226, -0.05273225158452988, -0.013894367963075638, -0.04868582263588905, -0.04035563766956329, 0.05740285664796829, 0.016857927665114403, -0.052369363605976105, 0.013230216689407825, 0.0025707713793963194, -0.01675056666135788, -0.01843453012406826, -0.03775262460112572, 0.0038463110104203224, 0.0003090954851359129, 0.00899487640708685, -0.03992800787091255, -0.04366139695048332, -0.033308640122413635, -0.031471166759729385, 0.006608936935663223, 0.03413361310958862, -0.026546526700258255, 0.004248705226927996, -0.06427177786827087, -0.009548643603920937, 0.051125507801771164, 0.027482615783810616, -0.0073969499208033085, -0.018424145877361298, -0.008755414746701717, 0.0230316910892725, 0.03605179861187935, -0.0889866054058075, 0.0386950746178627, -0.0004390161775518209, -0.05955159291625023, 0.0023533806670457125, 0.014881500974297523, 0.04050315171480179, 0.025946397334337234, -0.005550430156290531, 0.012374737299978733, 0.04047397896647453, 0.0299328975379467, -0.053687162697315216, -0.01981237903237343, -0.023510988801717758, -0.0518341064453125, 0.05999067798256874, 0.0034801156725734472, -0.03682123124599457, 0.004301122389733791, -0.05322789400815964, -0.05732184275984764, -0.040187444537878036, -0.07413390278816223, -0.013826943002641201, -0.018623163923621178, 0.057386770844459534, 0.016179945319890976, -2.7516973204910755e-05, -0.0009319771197624505, 0.0173848494887352, -0.022757595404982567, 0.02998908795416355, -0.024458153173327446, -0.007081219460815191, 0.016978314146399498, -0.07890820503234863, -0.0515998937189579, 0.014919549226760864, -0.029375320300459862, -0.007570737507194281, -0.0017205290496349335, 0.012575341388583183, -0.037756457924842834, 0.005880608223378658, -0.02868264727294445, -0.011498846113681793, -0.003938146401196718, 0.021328777074813843, 0.011398020200431347, -0.018534086644649506, 0.012564889155328274, -0.05004662275314331, -0.0018011158099398017, 0.04536766558885574, 0.01484765950590372, -0.03653581440448761, 0.06328482925891876, 0.01861507259309292, -0.03227958083152771, -0.030800538137555122, -0.013250174932181835, -0.029270941391587257, 0.042048610746860504, 0.05040006339550018, -0.08537981659173965, -0.07482096552848816, 0.000965982093475759, -0.011509813368320465, 0.04117384925484657, 0.03625297546386719, -0.05580681189894676, -0.023902462795376778, -0.019589204341173172, -0.0381246916949749, -0.007706889417022467, 0.004392870236188173, 0.01026254054158926, -0.004050633404403925, -0.02439316175878048, 0.005616491194814444, 0.0016656521474942565, -0.04087015613913536, 0.02493450418114662, 0.016699885949492455, -0.03626450523734093, 0.00017066024884115905, 0.11343100666999817, -0.010302484966814518, 0.022960493341088295, 0.0032104691490530968, -0.0014994068769738078, 0.0006916885613463819, -0.014182359911501408, -0.018115025013685226, -0.03252583369612694, -0.003920641727745533, 0.014837277121841908, -0.011447647586464882, -0.027227474376559258, 0.051017630845308304, 0.018918784335255623, -0.006126273423433304, -0.041009027510881424, -0.035711869597435, 0.003491464303806424, -0.009497887454926968, 0.0005133727099746466, -0.0022660738322883844, 0.04153062775731087, -0.07188468426465988, 0.001376440399326384, 0.006833748426288366, -0.022636260837316513, -0.01509417500346899, 0.02737385407090187, -0.052542537450790405, 0.008527771569788456, -0.001598418690264225, 0.008013821206986904, -0.03630237281322479, 0.0005065433215349913, 0.010218825191259384, -0.020687775686383247, 0.00018496011034585536, -0.006420346908271313, -0.03729148581624031, 0.008525332435965538, -0.01704949140548706, 0.07690034061670303, 0.0003214218304492533, 0.0010875501902773976, -0.0024775383062660694, 0.06496165692806244, -0.018371812999248505, -0.017002632841467857, 0.029569212347269058, -0.024613022804260254, 0.027227869257330894, 0.03177441656589508, -0.021867899224162102, 0.03543032705783844, -0.03389199823141098, 7.683246803935617e-05, 0.015771569684147835, -0.029230531305074692, -0.03572199493646622, 0.025547489523887634, -0.011903378181159496, -0.08735260367393494, -0.04087550938129425, 0.08989191800355911, 0.029726998880505562, -0.057457584887742996, -0.010696659795939922, -0.0019740131683647633, -0.03678625077009201, -0.0002766447141766548, -0.008475280366837978, 0.002177773043513298, -0.003928859252482653, 0.03553660959005356, 0.04279567673802376, -0.03706246614456177, 0.00047272976371459663, -0.014051146805286407, -0.08234595507383347, 0.027560444548726082, 0.024796370416879654, -0.07231855392456055, -0.040042199194431305, -0.007354673929512501, -0.006703436374664307, -0.00448203831911087, 0.04232634976506233, 0.05919429287314415, 0.027199381962418556, -0.03341487795114517, 0.08823026716709137, -0.044641248881816864, -0.08963857591152191, -0.05768870189785957, -0.03855537623167038, 0.06493460386991501, 0.03492654860019684, 0.01875617355108261, -0.018585730344057083, -0.02938520349562168, 0.08808788657188416, -0.006399326026439667, -0.006526344455778599, -0.026147721335291862, 0.05920121446251869, 0.0005006753490306437, -0.020382652059197426, -0.02553485706448555, -0.009104751981794834, -0.05158981680870056, 0.014738052152097225, -0.0061059435829520226, 0.05965587869286537, 0.009275726974010468, 0.004243445582687855, -0.0004859718319494277, 0.04928207024931908, 0.017687400802969933, -0.027966637164354324, 0.027091749012470245, -0.021608714014291763, 0.004727249499410391, -0.024564871564507484, 0.026210181415081024, -0.07036307454109192, 0.034392811357975006, 0.04122386872768402, -0.037418242543935776, -0.07973069697618484, -0.0906233936548233, -0.06635311990976334, -0.013275179080665112, 0.051910147070884705, 0.05747094750404358, -0.02024105191230774, -0.0009274535113945603, -0.006475465837866068, -0.012547280639410019, -0.03650224581360817, 0.06751459836959839, -0.013206417672336102, -0.08220017701387405, 0.06615857779979706, 0.004172852728515863, 0.024027297273278236, -0.01327474694699049, 0.008792765438556671, -0.06635206192731857, -0.05470002815127373, 0.02344846911728382, 0.05021103098988533, 0.005102645140141249, -0.03356804698705673, -0.03745974600315094, -0.06118561699986458, -0.03466873615980148, 0.08073083311319351, 0.03469810634851456, -0.005695510655641556, 0.0629931166768074, -0.06087145581841469, -0.0253891721367836, -0.002574586309492588, 0.00484818872064352, 0.025663528591394424, -0.0013814875856041908, 0.04080162197351456, -0.02994086593389511, -0.050747040659189224, 0.046074096113443375, 0.012223171070218086, 0.06556470692157745, -0.005316614639014006, -0.017959389835596085, -0.048613786697387695, 0.04001248627901077, 0.027477966621518135, -0.03201069310307503, -0.01279000286012888, 0.05279862508177757, 0.009444735012948513, 0.011012649163603783, -0.012692446820437908, -0.023007908836007118, -0.002567859599366784, -0.02066771872341633, 0.02911883220076561, 0.05044928565621376, -0.014136279933154583, 0.07551435381174088, -0.0333290658891201, -0.00043252407340332866, -0.009138821624219418, 0.014711854048073292, 0.06222112476825714, 0.045135851949453354, -0.01670188643038273, 0.03891288861632347, 0.03506237268447876, 0.0182711873203516, 0.024257266893982887, -0.0036714563611894846, 0.011405044235289097, 0.0073403711430728436, -0.07609830051660538, 0.006646406836807728, 0.09062578529119492, -0.01097145676612854, 0.0344923734664917, -0.0012618883047252893, 0.016807422041893005, -0.03706912323832512, 0.0474369190633297, -0.03076048009097576, -0.010935983620584011, 0.01834452711045742, 0.01825583539903164, -0.013607661239802837, -0.05835503712296486, 0.052422840148210526, 0.022554870694875717, 0.02663528174161911, -0.03532935678958893, -0.046531934291124344, -0.0031172712333500385, -0.002770080463960767, 0.016331637278199196, -0.008042380213737488, -0.05855988338589668, -0.00643417751416564, -0.005223647691309452, -0.047479573637247086, 0.0001886010868474841, 0.05649733170866966, 0.08639464527368546, 0.027649566531181335, 0.015440401621162891, -0.005164047237485647, 0.01890920102596283, 0.008465714752674103, -0.014559805393218994, -0.012126860208809376, 0.024555053561925888, -0.016558147966861725, -0.010850636288523674, -6.004246983137698e-33, -0.06313291192054749, -0.08967919647693634, -0.020719163119792938, -0.046908628195524216, -0.026398811489343643, 0.021981684491038322, -0.005113235209137201, -0.017430078238248825, 0.06529436260461807, 0.012000764720141888, 0.023738525807857513, 0.027191562578082085, 0.020489366725087166, -0.0029617538675665855, 0.06175711750984192, 0.011465521529316902, 0.04357518255710602, 0.008099415339529514, 0.025491386651992798, -0.05807546153664589, 0.06009889766573906, 0.058439310640096664, 0.11273597180843353, -0.08149781823158264, 0.028425175696611404, 0.04364122822880745, -0.010520503856241703, -0.013265079818665981, -0.010905228555202484, 0.027680866420269012, 0.025767380371689796, -0.017990536987781525, 0.008694280870258808, -0.014412587508559227, -0.030060159042477608, -0.008512956090271473, -0.07206739485263824, -0.050368309020996094, -0.03687958046793938, 0.055391356348991394, -0.01718946546316147, 0.0020781729836016893, 0.0751679465174675, -0.02288009040057659, -0.030817914754152298, 0.02497623860836029, 0.04308221489191055, -0.026427526026964188, -0.022654317319393158, 0.01619895175099373, -0.03521990403532982, 0.025372754782438278, 0.01868276484310627, 0.03936012089252472, 0.02520660310983658, 0.03875132277607918, -0.015363020822405815, -0.019744450226426125, -0.08378191292285919, -0.005084838252514601, -0.004734011832624674, 0.033646196126937866, 0.014487216249108315, 0.03110692836344242, -0.04468175768852234, 0.034077972173690796, 0.0456501841545105, -0.0077211251482367516, 0.03212973475456238, -0.014193383976817131, -0.03264864161610603, -0.04022115468978882, 0.10725592076778412, -0.004525976721197367, 0.07636882364749908, -0.03037955053150654, -0.06052606552839279, 0.024523349478840828, -0.03197893500328064, 0.005611969158053398, 0.007332229055464268, 0.0016599425580352545, -0.03664441034197807, 0.0028620362281799316, 0.0024624329525977373, -0.01576559618115425, -0.0340789370238781, -0.02508411556482315, 0.03231329470872879, 0.03098670206964016, 0.03471052646636963, 0.026779143139719963, -0.014124694280326366, -0.002300701104104519, 0.019309381023049355, -0.0668150782585144, 0.03403080999851227, 0.021043146029114723, -0.04080279916524887, -0.013978437520563602, -0.03761985898017883, -0.03588719666004181, 0.001996316248551011, 0.02742510661482811, 0.03690635412931442, -0.004854109138250351, 0.05501933768391609, 0.009826375171542168, -0.03828638792037964, 0.014792066067457199, 0.011531036347150803, 0.007488719653338194, 0.04430209472775459, 0.023779936134815216, 0.04236317798495293, -0.04200823977589607, -0.0212554894387722, 0.08083703368902206, 0.039233699440956116, -0.01903400383889675, -0.02522817999124527, -0.013173781335353851, -0.007991907186806202, 0.028366347774863243, -0.03348018229007721, 0.0008852295577526093, -0.010159984230995178, 0.008436478674411774, -0.035033054649829865, -0.02951359562575817, -0.011293746531009674, 0.011106417514383793, 2.7820038894788013e-07, -0.00466459384188056, 0.03026352822780609, 0.0520402267575264, -0.002861135173588991, 0.001285117119550705, -0.0006854869425296783, -0.04023806378245354, 0.014997950755059719, -0.041878972202539444, 0.05648752301931381, 0.06561070680618286, -0.07726564258337021, 0.02720862254500389, 0.03443285822868347, -0.03826579824090004, -0.0862651839852333, -0.06317956745624542, 0.028369372710585594, 0.0034179924987256527, 0.016680698841810226, 0.07460145652294159, 0.061384376138448715, 0.046890679746866226, -0.031232358887791634, 0.005893326830118895, -0.02136518619954586, 0.003943470772355795, 0.026102323085069656, 0.03143106400966644, 0.004372760653495789, 0.00845743902027607, 0.03521791473031044, -0.0070375180803239346, 0.04795762524008751, -0.02857314795255661, -0.01357867382466793, 0.02306654304265976, -0.006644728593528271, -0.029828978702425957, -0.001363453222438693, 0.05789921060204506, 0.06000378727912903, 0.021248774603009224, -0.03537104278802872, -0.010994108393788338, 0.006182636134326458, -0.01674262061715126, 0.01377849467098713, 0.01939910091459751, -0.0011133196530863643, 0.01205328106880188, -0.019902918487787247, 0.011725816875696182, -0.01395947951823473, -0.002762519521638751, 0.01744570955634117, -0.0017068278975784779, -0.052183203399181366, 0.034592896699905396, 0.04115669056773186, 0.0042582605965435505, -0.02840849757194519, -0.012653801590204239, 0.05012666806578636, 0.019092386588454247, -0.018179448321461678, -0.034146133810281754, 2.838173483286574e-34, 0.015894053503870964, -0.031095579266548157, -0.028574781492352486, 0.0412011593580246, -0.000629149901214987, 0.0036466934252530336, -0.06136209890246391, 0.013571166433393955, 0.007241361774504185, 0.004707638174295425, -0.03586278855800629]
645
645
['Youmna Farag', 'Marek Rei', 'Ted Briscoe']
1707.06841v1
We propose a novel word embedding pre-training approach that exploits writing errors in learners' scripts. We compare our method to previous models that tune the embeddings based on script scores and the discrimination between correct and corrupt word contexts in addition to the generic commonly-used embeddings pre-trained on large corpora. The comparison is achieved by using the aforementioned models to bootstrap a neural network that learns to predict a holistic score for scripts. Furthermore, we investigate augmenting our model with error corrections and monitor the impact on performance. Our results show that our error-oriented approach outperforms other comparable ones which is further demonstrated when training on more data. Additionally, extending the model with corrections provides further performance gains when data sparsity is an issue.
An Error-Oriented Approach to Word Embedding Pre-Training
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1707.06841v1
Title ErrorOriented Approach Word Embedding PreTraining Summary propose novel word embedding pretraining approach exploit writing error learner script compare method previous model tune embeddings based script score discrimination correct corrupt word context addition generic commonlyused embeddings pretrained large corpus comparison achieved using aforementioned model bootstrap neural network learns predict holistic score script Furthermore investigate augmenting model error correction monitor impact performance result show errororiented approach outperforms comparable one demonstrated training data Additionally extending model correction provides performance gain data sparsity issue Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.009240753017365932, 0.028996504843235016, 0.02859247289597988, 0.041179753839969635, 0.01521011721342802, 0.008262046612799168, -0.022857774049043655, 0.0456257164478302, 0.02617158554494381, -0.0855959951877594, -0.03694905713200569, -0.012926281429827213, 0.02177080698311329, 0.04429576173424721, 0.03244822472333908, -0.005561791360378265, 0.04159867763519287, 0.04831725358963013, -0.00410118093714118, 0.014294748194515705, 0.030215244740247726, 0.03474147617816925, 0.029350535944104195, 0.03736894577741623, -0.04771669954061508, 0.012220156379044056, 0.023319996893405914, 0.008878177031874657, 0.01714104413986206, -0.05885319784283638, 0.03271478787064552, 0.06615793704986572, 0.05524684116244316, 0.041489288210868835, 2.2494712084153434e-06, -0.021776601672172546, -0.027119804173707962, -0.02787887305021286, -0.00513062346726656, -0.012295632623136044, 0.06773494184017181, -0.015615822747349739, -0.01680608093738556, 0.05027671158313751, -0.0016311221988871694, -0.04731928929686546, 0.05527382344007492, 0.07300926744937897, 0.014662306755781174, 0.07802827656269073, -0.03046060912311077, -0.03301122039556503, 0.02467283234000206, -0.017027832567691803, -0.009408648125827312, -0.036684952676296234, 0.007159387227147818, 0.02638905867934227, -0.010811883956193924, 0.009444848634302616, -0.043370213359594345, 0.006347441114485264, -0.014980862848460674, -0.036900002509355545, 0.031178131699562073, 0.008882355876266956, -0.014824739657342434, 0.008485952392220497, 0.009315605275332928, 0.056371062994003296, 0.009535214863717556, -0.02894900180399418, -0.047935884445905685, -0.011176595464348793, -0.017391426488757133, 0.00045663758646696806, -0.002693080110475421, 0.01801411062479019, 0.03115321695804596, 0.02515474520623684, 0.04391675442457199, 0.04214709624648094, 0.06460047513246536, 0.03846301510930061, 0.010670256800949574, 0.007928182370960712, 0.030691202729940414, -0.039541229605674744, 0.006670089438557625, 0.01233526412397623, 0.00435607461258769, -0.021463096141815186, 0.025433287024497986, 0.027508556842803955, -0.0053463587537407875, 0.0067418357357382774, -0.06427008658647537, -0.05355207622051239, 0.02056385576725006, -0.04798279330134392, 0.08563890308141708, 0.00909626204520464, -0.015558511950075626, 0.011454382911324501, -0.03134575113654137, 0.021579116582870483, 0.04556383937597275, -0.012766280211508274, 0.009744839742779732, 0.059556908905506134, -0.014149014838039875, -0.01738714799284935, -0.0392468087375164, 0.020356997847557068, -0.008734113536775112, -0.03656005859375, -0.03719496726989746, 0.013614914380013943, -0.008978331461548805, -0.00031353216036222875, -0.0035578375682234764, 0.0072599733248353004, -0.03151218220591545, -0.005936304107308388, 0.0007810810348019004, -0.017108703032135963, -0.020895082503557205, 0.02625744603574276, -0.01774338074028492, -0.025752738118171692, -0.0005952926585450768, 0.03418591246008873, 0.023510586470365524, 0.010617394000291824, 0.04584100842475891, 0.03213254734873772, 0.013201157562434673, -0.08922768384218216, -0.026549022644758224, -0.0021432305220514536, -0.03044273890554905, 0.0008612810051999986, -0.06333424896001816, -0.07447180896997452, 0.05004167929291725, -0.036868005990982056, -0.001549549400806427, -0.005004198290407658, 0.026990173384547234, 0.022825421765446663, -0.030446039512753487, 0.07543407380580902, -0.04242578521370888, -0.025001589208841324, 0.02680300548672676, 0.022656358778476715, 0.08108711242675781, 0.020659063011407852, 0.03430652990937233, 0.0005614866386167705, 0.037358250468969345, 0.001273925299756229, -0.00590148288756609, 0.010350617580115795, -0.029173728078603745, -0.01165024098008871, -0.027476413175463676, -0.009333260357379913, -0.0017666119383648038, 0.07141834497451782, 0.0022322535514831543, 0.04250703006982803, 0.00411843229085207, 0.014744263142347336, 0.00875324010848999, 0.039642952382564545, 0.03271801024675369, -0.005629180930554867, 0.03131897374987602, 0.00046948116505518556, -0.0017152581131085753, -0.02401142381131649, -0.020262662321329117, -0.03140995278954506, -0.020373012870550156, -0.009537705220282078, 0.0017892159521579742, -0.01506741065531969, -0.010272393003106117, -0.020032498985528946, -0.030747301876544952, -0.027394425123929977, -0.008566626347601414, -0.05614139512181282, 0.02686077170073986, 0.016893567517399788, -0.08780400454998016, -0.04877717047929764, 0.03762740269303322, -0.037730760872364044, 0.02236255258321762, -0.010980598628520966, 6.951552495593205e-05, 0.04502590000629425, 0.09764594584703445, -0.030736489221453667, -0.02955223247408867, -0.03612767904996872, -0.03607013449072838, 0.01516934484243393, 0.011272050440311432, -0.03395555540919304, -0.023191310465335846, -0.0642021968960762, 0.007187546230852604, 0.003498233389109373, 0.018780453130602837, 0.018428022041916847, -0.015010355040431023, 0.011969163082540035, 0.034788526594638824, 0.016147274523973465, -0.02979837730526924, 0.08003299683332443, -0.034615930169820786, -0.05536527931690216, -0.03159680217504501, 0.0140600074082613, 0.02222198247909546, 0.018490446731448174, -0.04714129865169525, -0.006348182447254658, 0.02204795368015766, -0.010899658314883709, -0.03406663239002228, -0.030650552362203598, -0.07382698357105255, -0.06412400305271149, 0.02593274600803852, -0.0025592532474547625, 0.021090643480420113, 0.045921579003334045, -0.004207003861665726, -0.03931688517332077, -0.05841020122170448, -0.015476340427994728, 0.035777896642684937, -0.062374867498874664, 0.03835614025592804, -0.02971252240240574, 0.022496720775961876, -0.04481327533721924, 0.03107760101556778, -0.011534164659678936, 0.041561998426914215, -0.04193538427352905, 0.04665321111679077, 0.014351153746247292, -0.007869808934628963, -0.04408620297908783, 0.03355712816119194, -0.006124117411673069, 0.029757091775536537, 0.016984131187200546, 0.007799452170729637, -0.026785636320710182, -0.00986520852893591, -0.08229232579469681, -0.006091074086725712, -0.0011642990866675973, -0.026459047570824623, 0.04099712520837784, -0.012097176164388657, -0.003438899526372552, -0.01637011393904686, -0.020024850964546204, 0.01645158976316452, 0.0357784703373909, -0.016577836126089096, 0.03353075310587883, -0.015481201931834221, 0.027313724160194397, -0.040453989058732986, -0.00977848656475544, -0.037541601806879044, 0.041077643632888794, 0.025787660852074623, -0.022077379748225212, -0.04279777407646179, 0.08114086836576462, 0.035619717091321945, 0.009923267178237438, 0.01720869354903698, -0.03749902546405792, -0.024627946317195892, 0.00573372608050704, 0.03660563752055168, 0.012569932267069817, 0.0032629771158099174, 0.05530432239174843, 0.05668306723237038, -0.00988137535750866, 0.04309604689478874, -0.053239792585372925, -0.012845734134316444, 0.017179420217871666, 0.003396101761609316, -0.027116304263472557, -0.015472257509827614, 0.04347136244177818, 0.02876218967139721, 0.003526593092828989, -0.04167472571134567, -0.01594669185578823, -0.029126454144716263, 0.03514557704329491, -0.024307452142238617, -0.040578391402959824, -0.029911227524280548, -0.0018322973046451807, 0.015346000902354717, -0.011346795596182346, 0.05090491101145744, -0.024091487750411034, -0.003203795524314046, -0.07312551140785217, -0.021759705618023872, 0.005672616418451071, 0.01886901631951332, -0.001153527875430882, 0.039479970932006836, -0.025574790313839912, -0.037698227912187576, -0.05558750778436661, -0.018960075452923775, -0.00480527663603425, -0.03007366880774498, 0.030467772856354713, 0.03366042673587799, -0.008319992572069168, -0.02015279233455658, -0.003810003399848938, -0.041063737124204636, -0.07165716588497162, -0.011414128355681896, 0.0052431728690862656, 0.019879739731550217, -0.019332772120833397, 0.024355536326766014, 0.0030161389149725437, -0.0356801301240921, 0.05688077211380005, -0.010886700823903084, -0.029247337952256203, -0.03103119321167469, 0.021874329075217247, 0.009385221637785435, -0.03443128615617752, -0.010269482620060444, -0.001036471570841968, 0.06442119181156158, 0.02492854930460453, -0.031718071550130844, -0.004697679542005062, -0.04777045175433159, -0.008932464756071568, 0.028688520193099976, -0.034435465931892395, -0.014954550191760063, -0.017209963873028755, 0.04849778488278389, -0.06217142939567566, -0.0320328064262867, 0.11858224123716354, 0.026394527405500412, -0.05528167262673378, -0.0022963183000683784, 0.011371105909347534, -0.0184602253139019, 0.02802131511271, 0.033983323723077774, -0.023595385253429413, -0.020010510459542274, 0.02823890931904316, 0.034995999187231064, 0.009327813051640987, -0.015752850100398064, 0.0029789695981889963, -0.10603847354650497, 0.016811121255159378, 0.016731105744838715, -0.002720735501497984, -0.053774867206811905, -0.007224051281809807, -0.03199505805969238, -0.0013320535654202104, 0.0016433126293122768, 0.010820944793522358, -0.00930716097354889, -0.023108728229999542, -0.009138253517448902, -0.02674783580005169, -0.06258143484592438, 0.019956078380346298, -0.03792211040854454, 0.04936988651752472, 0.052827127277851105, 0.05019036680459976, -0.04499701410531998, 0.011293507181107998, -0.006035906728357077, -0.04477556049823761, -0.02957402542233467, -0.008517351001501083, 0.07435116171836853, -0.03302862122654915, -0.010070059448480606, -0.03526772931218147, -0.0007645873702131212, -0.029636837542057037, -0.026154370978474617, -0.04103850573301315, 0.07674171775579453, -0.041381169110536575, 0.0004080980725120753, -0.006741462275385857, 0.04169074073433876, 0.00603470578789711, 0.022279556840658188, -0.0004059893835801631, -0.029885075986385345, -0.0026302924379706383, -0.017059002071619034, 0.037187762558460236, -0.03283397853374481, 0.01345612108707428, 0.017116468399763107, -0.04875518009066582, -0.010119566693902016, -0.09909788519144058, -0.0730694830417633, -0.00589790241792798, 0.07216288894414902, 0.04913078993558884, -0.006568185053765774, -0.03440225496888161, -0.031755317002534866, -0.05548040196299553, -0.04514813423156738, 0.03609336167573929, 0.011682520620524883, -0.07732823491096497, 0.013123007491230965, 0.03966457024216652, -0.00206656102091074, 0.013279185630381107, -0.07212889939546585, -0.011356709524989128, -0.050693608820438385, 0.01243501529097557, 0.002588201081380248, -0.00036234204890206456, -0.0017739769537001848, -0.06424342840909958, -0.06916496157646179, 0.05683521926403046, 0.01994449831545353, -0.03296108543872833, 0.010427838191390038, 0.04507741704583168, -0.0035743156913667917, -0.029678093269467354, 0.028672076761722565, -0.02844107896089554, 0.04706517606973648, -0.02431114949285984, 0.009993857704102993, -0.0055237459018826485, -0.013831713236868382, 0.01860787160694599, -0.006441040430217981, 0.03182638809084892, -0.05306995287537575, 0.024179799482226372, -0.08446509391069412, -0.035928696393966675, -0.04226577281951904, -0.026224011555314064, -0.009323700331151485, 0.03168761357665062, 0.059868358075618744, -0.003943168558180332, -0.01697971113026142, 0.008106005378067493, -0.02548776939511299, -0.0028948993422091007, -0.01820901781320572, 0.06661209464073181, 0.05296031013131142, 0.04356274753808975, 0.004384012892842293, 0.050555821508169174, -0.03568055480718613, 0.004506876692175865, -0.033718787133693695, 0.0313737690448761, -0.032121580094099045, 0.056536171585321426, 0.0006563650676980615, -0.021434180438518524, -0.011010591872036457, 0.046432577073574066, 0.018907224759459496, 0.0501389242708683, -0.053680483251810074, 0.014604042284190655, 0.054554328322410583, -0.09351465851068497, 0.010746441781520844, -0.035952117294073105, 0.0021289598662406206, -0.009826406836509705, 0.039441194385290146, -0.024620136246085167, -0.021301837638020515, 0.05937619134783745, 0.01996646262705326, -0.027963753789663315, 0.00024749196018092334, 0.03615099564194679, 0.022003741934895515, 0.025955229997634888, 0.03770547732710838, -0.032652150839567184, -0.029597532004117966, 0.02532450295984745, 0.06027841940522194, 0.05763518437743187, -0.04782799258828163, 0.03011099435389042, -0.0333048552274704, -0.08401598781347275, -0.018987631425261497, -0.0029789158143103123, 0.004897745791822672, 0.037873029708862305, -0.007194038014858961, 0.040290042757987976, 0.012606040574610233, 0.049291085451841354, -0.056107573211193085, 0.03283276408910751, 0.0017693046247586608, -0.02456316165626049, -0.011472530663013458, -6.331963420545428e-33, -0.056119248270988464, -0.03124319203197956, -0.02433915250003338, -0.026052214205265045, -0.035785991698503494, 0.013294822536408901, -0.027186473831534386, -0.004419164266437292, -0.007985131815075874, 0.03815438970923424, -0.015998614951968193, 0.014148654416203499, 0.0003813391667790711, 0.011210705153644085, -0.009868119843304157, 0.028176376596093178, 0.0080317547544837, 0.009807724505662918, -0.013334003277122974, -0.012546761892735958, 0.07990480214357376, 0.07085897773504257, 0.10454224050045013, -0.04943862929940224, 0.008256551809608936, -0.025888212025165558, -0.03015975095331669, 0.006410157773643732, 0.06505843997001648, 0.01673622988164425, -0.05082325264811516, 0.038971301168203354, 0.026636948809027672, 0.021904492750763893, 0.004576875362545252, 0.045293718576431274, -0.02632385492324829, -0.03536000847816467, -0.04219885915517807, 0.043566614389419556, -0.00595733942463994, 0.01914861425757408, 0.007913608103990555, -0.052333682775497437, -0.02446817047894001, 0.0035284371115267277, 0.022504491731524467, -0.015463358722627163, -0.003318032482638955, 0.010492228902876377, -0.11454135924577713, 0.0460207425057888, 0.0437767393887043, -0.03252995014190674, 0.016898907721042633, -0.012541627511382103, 0.033359263092279434, 0.019746869802474976, -0.0718962773680687, -0.011950942687690258, -0.04491324722766876, 0.041289690881967545, 0.006536674220114946, 0.048845790326595306, -0.062050603330135345, 0.07877031713724136, -0.04523652791976929, -0.02280070260167122, 0.015212291851639748, 0.03203904256224632, 0.0419929176568985, -0.02347622625529766, 0.05605783686041832, 0.06599611043930054, 0.06726785004138947, -0.037308208644390106, -0.057935383170843124, 0.0256861113011837, -0.0013133069733157754, -0.00632820138707757, 0.03941534832119942, -0.002063214546069503, -0.060485657304525375, -0.03728197142481804, -0.006843015551567078, -0.019582383334636688, 0.001113265985623002, -0.04722175747156143, 0.029287276789546013, 0.005815568845719099, -0.009700475260615349, 0.022080576047301292, 0.020847581326961517, -0.069722019135952, 0.01732107810676098, 1.0814959750859998e-05, -0.04415728524327278, 0.02867918461561203, -0.00800815224647522, 0.04353170469403267, -0.014028344303369522, -0.021074164658784866, 0.0005440827226266265, 0.002214267151430249, 0.007275229319930077, -0.009994558990001678, 0.05974221229553223, 0.027117639780044556, -0.087453193962574, -0.005091257393360138, 0.01884208433330059, -0.04168486222624779, 0.04747511073946953, 0.02617476135492325, -0.010285323485732079, -0.023105595260858536, 0.0024213658180087805, 0.0782693475484848, 0.08082970231771469, 0.0070211635902523994, -0.004475983791053295, -0.044903647154569626, -0.004748341627418995, 0.016557766124606133, -0.020319553092122078, 0.020736418664455414, -0.014965455047786236, 0.028810756281018257, 0.029217731207609177, -0.057735804468393326, -0.009845449589192867, -0.048296865075826645, 2.840951367488742e-07, 0.07379563897848129, 0.02882925048470497, -0.0031590964645147324, -0.0589718259871006, -0.023474637418985367, 0.03321439400315285, -0.007913092151284218, 0.06057015061378479, -0.05361103639006615, 0.04102902114391327, 0.024840090423822403, -0.0295320563018322, 0.04378204792737961, 0.02191811613738537, -0.04800224304199219, -0.02197263203561306, -0.08150052279233932, 0.030344579368829727, -0.021236861124634743, -0.009231777861714363, 0.046050723642110825, 0.12882043421268463, 0.029123801738023758, -0.025693250820040703, 0.005372664425522089, -0.03270014375448227, 0.044750869274139404, -0.0030038715340197086, -0.025090569630265236, -0.003962873015552759, -0.03600643575191498, 0.04633486643433571, -0.01409603189677, 0.007012318819761276, -0.06351731717586517, 0.03744576871395111, 0.03415002301335335, 0.016431346535682678, -0.05447656661272049, 0.027992773801088333, 0.033563461154699326, 0.004045747220516205, 0.008220572955906391, -0.05181950330734253, 0.050604019314050674, 0.047219209372997284, -0.05319635197520256, -0.07415103912353516, 0.01101198885589838, 0.005215145647525787, 0.06919001042842865, -0.029968122020363808, -0.035901520401239395, -0.017687128856778145, 0.03092384897172451, -0.021078303456306458, -0.010880887508392334, -0.09381243586540222, -0.0028582303784787655, 0.08156543225049973, 0.011499887332320213, 0.01085302047431469, -0.006051385775208473, -0.06657514721155167, 0.0665656253695488, -0.03457522392272949, 0.020246153697371483, 3.398559190972406e-34, 0.024951806291937828, -0.005792112089693546, 0.01750796101987362, -0.0018025885801762342, 0.023313788697123528, 0.019978443160653114, 0.028480835258960724, 0.02327304147183895, 0.03223441541194916, -0.04268702492117882, -0.012984204106032848]
646
646
['Kartik Goyal', 'Graham Neubig', 'Chris Dyer', 'Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick']
1708.00111v2
Beam search is a desirable choice of test-time decoding algorithm for neural sequence models because it potentially avoids search errors made by simpler greedy methods. However, typical cross entropy training procedures for these models do not directly consider the behaviour of the final decoding method. As a result, for cross-entropy trained models, beam decoding can sometimes yield reduced test performance when compared with greedy decoding. In order to train models that can more effectively make use of beam search, we propose a new training procedure that focuses on the final loss metric (e.g. Hamming loss) evaluated on the output of beam search. While well-defined, this "direct loss" objective is itself discontinuous and thus difficult to optimize. Hence, in our approach, we form a sub-differentiable surrogate objective by introducing a novel continuous approximation of the beam search decoding procedure. In experiments, we show that optimizing this new training objective yields substantially better results on two sequence tasks (Named Entity Recognition and CCG Supertagging) when compared with both cross entropy trained greedy decoding and cross entropy trained beam decoding baselines.
A Continuous Relaxation of Beam Search for End-to-end Training of Neural Sequence Models
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1708.00111v2
Title Continuous Relaxation Beam Search Endtoend Training Neural Sequence Models Summary Beam search desirable choice testtime decoding algorithm neural sequence model potentially avoids search error made simpler greedy method However typical cross entropy training procedure model directly consider behaviour final decoding method result crossentropy trained model beam decoding sometimes yield reduced test performance compared greedy decoding order train model effectively make use beam search propose new training procedure focus final loss metric eg Hamming loss evaluated output beam search welldefined direct loss objective discontinuous thus difficult optimize Hence approach form subdifferentiable surrogate objective introducing novel continuous approximation beam search decoding procedure experiment show optimizing new training objective yield substantially better result two sequence task Named Entity Recognition CCG Supertagging compared cross entropy trained greedy decoding cross entropy trained beam decoding baseline Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.03741150721907616, 0.030471503734588623, 0.03220384195446968, 0.025864267721772194, 0.0011311826528981328, 0.03016337752342224, -0.016953421756625175, 0.013072589412331581, 0.004709469620138407, 0.01821279339492321, -0.028442755341529846, -0.03348269686102867, 0.00608800770714879, -0.007798672188073397, -0.009676429443061352, -0.052162881940603256, 0.05853249877691269, 0.017096830531954765, 0.0262697022408247, 0.011824813671410084, -0.002892004791647196, -0.046552449464797974, -0.03222626447677612, 0.03613229840993881, 0.007465008180588484, 0.01185867004096508, -0.04416728764772415, -0.019999952986836433, -0.0003846357867587358, -0.09264062345027924, 0.02482091635465622, 0.026021471247076988, 0.004297921899706125, 0.004468593280762434, 2.2293240817816695e-06, 0.006432151887565851, -0.03357316553592682, -0.01859624683856964, -0.026722585782408714, 0.010007737204432487, 0.014794424176216125, -0.05420761927962303, 0.012356472201645374, 0.015015402808785439, -0.03591495007276535, -0.06645586341619492, 0.04403678700327873, 0.05461861565709114, 0.06376913189888, 0.08348987251520157, 0.021135732531547546, -0.05671413987874985, 0.039548393338918686, -0.03230990469455719, 0.04735219478607178, -0.10932602733373642, 0.017982596531510353, -0.0022446606308221817, 0.03490285947918892, 0.042700573801994324, -0.034816838800907135, 0.048764631152153015, 0.014696246013045311, 0.012860535643994808, 0.006407780107110739, 0.038980912417173386, 0.002741267904639244, -0.02007686160504818, 0.013046019710600376, 0.044007156044244766, -0.0032636907417327166, -0.00947493501007557, 0.05749228224158287, 0.0053964038379490376, -0.026071084663271904, -0.05271325260400772, -0.031128786504268646, 0.003850232809782028, -0.044279344379901886, 0.008066640235483646, 0.045565493404865265, 0.05115416646003723, 0.005350434221327305, 0.007652384229004383, -0.03798001632094383, 0.007206040434539318, -0.037301722913980484, -0.036430902779102325, -0.0014685520436614752, -0.01598621904850006, -0.017750238999724388, -0.04449399188160896, 0.04887695983052254, 0.026717636734247208, 0.0014476134674623609, 0.033465757966041565, -0.06168733164668083, -0.06259480863809586, 0.0012707876740023494, -0.018536655232310295, -0.026546690613031387, 0.03385331854224205, 0.027829041704535484, 0.0170280784368515, -0.03179668262600899, 0.03485122323036194, -0.017874175682663918, 0.024696558713912964, -0.0766403004527092, -0.00947270356118679, -0.06195623055100441, -0.003957123961299658, -0.04497816413640976, 0.051209840923547745, -0.017507869750261307, -0.06565755605697632, -0.09731464087963104, -0.01288045197725296, 0.05965626239776611, -0.005086175631731749, 0.017708977684378624, 0.010310339741408825, -0.002061208477243781, 0.03383566439151764, 0.02491322159767151, 0.02835686318576336, 0.008917137049138546, -0.031591176986694336, 0.006534850224852562, -0.02545684576034546, -0.021825380623340607, 0.004234508611261845, -0.019806066527962685, -0.019873088225722313, 0.0122754517942667, 0.05013689026236534, 0.01969352550804615, -0.06778176128864288, -0.051746636629104614, -0.0008507447200827301, -0.00847257673740387, -0.03030584380030632, 0.027467133477330208, -0.018391937017440796, 0.04826544597744942, 0.018505588173866272, -0.0321083627641201, 0.005106788128614426, 0.04561040550470352, -0.0022779975552111864, -0.04001792147755623, 0.07590615749359131, -0.011939161457121372, -0.00920962542295456, 0.05855210870504379, 0.015111139975488186, 0.055656787008047104, 0.018782058730721474, 0.02518867328763008, 0.017693566158413887, 0.010728335939347744, -0.030206680297851562, -0.008155330084264278, 0.02500627003610134, 0.014908715151250362, -0.06969072669744492, 0.018834665417671204, -0.025567295029759407, 0.03306128829717636, 0.028798086568713188, 0.04567719250917435, 0.02676606923341751, -0.022906189784407616, -0.007060831878334284, 0.01981171779334545, 0.0340709313750267, 0.0695173591375351, -0.031768620014190674, -0.006238039117306471, 0.003941961098462343, 0.010655968450009823, 0.03846003860235214, 0.019886257126927376, 0.027334440499544144, -0.01451926864683628, 0.012533150613307953, 0.01801588200032711, -0.00943535566329956, -0.018441809341311455, -0.01818922348320484, 0.008187759667634964, 0.006762066390365362, -0.008601127192378044, -0.019943686202168465, 0.04675471410155296, 0.007055959198623896, -0.09530031681060791, 0.025197595357894897, 0.03909015655517578, -0.0023078317753970623, 0.00011092338536400348, 0.0027993498370051384, -0.020366307348012924, 0.013493583537638187, 0.06221846118569374, -0.010363318957388401, -0.02361726388335228, 0.01419916097074747, -0.012154713273048401, -0.004424686543643475, 0.03165169432759285, -0.002505798824131489, -0.010908428579568863, -0.06043485179543495, -0.0011442750692367554, 0.08441159874200821, 0.0024458165280520916, 0.0025241938419640064, -0.02448846586048603, 0.013033101335167885, 0.015366552397608757, 0.04405222833156586, -0.04535503685474396, 0.05165994167327881, -0.05537320673465729, -0.030412646010518074, 0.009647071361541748, -2.460144787619356e-05, 0.03837502747774124, 0.04123561829328537, -0.0024174076970666647, 0.0239286907017231, 0.07810632139444351, -0.03652926906943321, -0.009253240190446377, 0.001269542844966054, -0.07543538510799408, -0.07491541653871536, -0.0040319631807506084, 0.005157882813364267, 0.028520705178380013, 0.0008346443064510822, -0.021769391372799873, -0.022729113698005676, -0.001285839593037963, -0.011001445353031158, 0.03794330358505249, -0.032029010355472565, 0.0397007018327713, 0.04954659193754196, 0.009782485663890839, -0.05388621240854263, 0.04578903689980507, -0.03258909285068512, 0.04355587065219879, -0.046531207859516144, -0.020937947556376457, 0.013511261902749538, -0.07514289766550064, 0.001391086378134787, 0.06995756179094315, -0.05116758123040199, -0.03218993917107582, -0.018090467900037766, 0.027560606598854065, -0.006394530180841684, 0.0049182153306901455, -0.057860396802425385, 0.013263607397675514, 0.024916965514421463, 0.053523268550634384, -0.009464085102081299, 0.03027513064444065, -0.009283737279474735, -0.03012649156153202, 0.005473879165947437, 0.028485137969255447, 0.0077294413931667805, -0.024829532951116562, 0.020924502983689308, 0.055326204746961594, -0.004374545067548752, -0.030056940391659737, -0.04001876339316368, -0.02183283306658268, 0.06078396737575531, -0.008904271759092808, -0.11035598069429398, -0.0635630413889885, 0.06364767998456955, 0.042756158858537674, 0.044518038630485535, -0.006297777406871319, -0.05811132490634918, 0.0005989365745335817, -0.01875934563577175, -0.02948775887489319, 0.053899552673101425, 0.051206424832344055, -0.008658996783196926, -0.06080364063382149, -0.00839237030595541, -0.03531251847743988, 0.005196418147534132, -0.049842655658721924, 0.04748208820819855, 0.0029959187377244234, -0.020867185667157173, 0.048183318227529526, 0.09525381028652191, 0.01612822711467743, 0.0500127412378788, -0.028391247615218163, -0.020945928990840912, -0.030296549201011658, -0.024764785543084145, -0.020882446318864822, -0.029368536546826363, -0.02579495497047901, -0.00875391997396946, -0.004877269268035889, 0.044668763875961304, 0.03480939567089081, -0.035007577389478683, -0.00672583281993866, -0.06527073681354523, -0.025478476658463478, -0.01630890928208828, 0.01315458957105875, 0.017267774790525436, 0.018952256068587303, 0.03861299529671669, -0.07624688744544983, 0.03025001846253872, 0.04983798786997795, -0.027213580906391144, -0.020304176956415176, -0.0107858432456851, 0.01068191695958376, 0.004514247179031372, -0.05945046246051788, -0.008362249471247196, -0.05543415993452072, -0.002944999374449253, 0.025909394025802612, -0.012062574736773968, 0.024653643369674683, -0.0056943390518426895, -0.04123416915535927, 0.03691432997584343, 0.006835877429693937, 0.03633521497249603, -0.040208928287029266, 0.02301366813480854, -0.03908250108361244, 0.09728649258613586, -0.006667729467153549, -0.03874516859650612, 0.019860686734318733, -0.014012855477631092, -0.054542917758226395, 0.032320357859134674, 0.03495551273226738, 0.0252523310482502, -0.03308150917291641, -0.0438535138964653, 0.024317435920238495, -0.0827365517616272, -0.018016153946518898, -0.0032879088539630175, 0.02579304203391075, -0.07870019227266312, 0.04154457896947861, 0.07166852802038193, 0.0037395707331597805, -0.04253549501299858, 0.013202100060880184, 0.05018380284309387, -0.03948651999235153, -0.010275994427502155, 0.015201441012322903, -0.0515364408493042, -0.03168471157550812, -0.003957035951316357, 0.04159507155418396, 0.0111252935603261, -0.06306856125593185, -0.016084840521216393, -0.10183271765708923, 0.00178236560896039, -0.002896679565310478, 5.167444396647625e-05, -0.02908000349998474, -0.016227805987000465, -0.017703671008348465, -0.009061595425009727, -0.03878261148929596, 0.05143443122506142, -0.007252820301800966, 0.0171990767121315, 0.05456061661243439, -0.015911519527435303, -0.056694451719522476, -0.015325566753745079, -0.06342463940382004, 0.047463368624448776, 0.07046986371278763, 0.01417650654911995, 0.006500910501927137, -0.010665112175047398, 0.014525395818054676, -0.09736351668834686, 0.008517391979694366, -0.05051314830780029, 0.02352924831211567, -0.036978352814912796, -0.029859596863389015, -0.003020284231752157, 0.009882177226245403, -0.013387725688517094, 0.024814898148179054, 0.00019734790839720517, 0.030327944085001945, -0.010397572070360184, -0.0047602904960513115, -0.028078287839889526, 0.03399231284856796, 0.022665726020932198, 0.04224763065576553, 0.004744649399071932, -0.014634569175541401, -0.015965277329087257, -0.01563115231692791, 0.033619921654462814, -0.050306450575590134, -0.020600389689207077, 0.019557474181056023, -0.016972634941339493, -0.040496982634067535, -0.06024450436234474, -0.05794235318899155, -0.008150340057909489, 0.03896426036953926, 0.0040833535604178905, 0.023146091029047966, 0.015119272284209728, -0.025304250419139862, -0.06432311981916428, -0.00893651694059372, 0.033266857266426086, -0.008564176969230175, -0.05366101861000061, 0.020752670243382454, 0.038045622408390045, 0.00017452258907724172, -0.03644974157214165, -0.002071808557957411, -0.035666774958372116, -0.044241875410079956, 0.024094007909297943, 0.014170436188578606, 0.015204962342977524, -0.004473868757486343, -0.03050338290631771, -0.033368341624736786, 0.00031160961952991784, 0.0267779678106308, -0.09349788725376129, 0.012034131214022636, 0.02767544984817505, -0.009850456379354, -0.03290737420320511, -0.02637009136378765, 0.014912771992385387, 0.046174559742212296, -0.0010768634965643287, 0.06051216274499893, -0.03911440446972847, -0.03760601952672005, 0.03403807431459427, 0.0027550372760742903, 0.008565912954509258, -0.0005347631522454321, -0.03856377676129341, -0.013834305107593536, 0.05274399369955063, 0.046619392931461334, 0.0323391817510128, -0.008731558918952942, -0.03510798513889313, 0.028973229229450226, 0.010368909686803818, 0.003957473207265139, 0.008399076759815216, 0.019232675433158875, 0.016614876687526703, -0.018358023837208748, 0.06065991148352623, -0.007618338335305452, 0.04772695526480675, -0.01631871797144413, -0.03472450003027916, 0.019043443724513054, 0.021683761849999428, 0.03490922227501869, 0.042777806520462036, -0.07805722206830978, 0.0354209765791893, 0.02810480073094368, 0.044311799108982086, 0.017551816999912262, 0.047544680535793304, -0.009476597420871258, 0.0177033431828022, -0.043222539126873016, -0.0027073808014392853, 0.06819751858711243, 0.026055732741951942, 0.006950464099645615, 0.01032169908285141, 0.02304200269281864, -0.025556489825248718, 0.02497626654803753, -0.04715326800942421, 0.02574147842824459, 0.023966109380126, 0.03179669380187988, -0.0032691326923668385, -0.055630892515182495, 0.0683068260550499, -0.026781614869832993, 0.0519772507250309, 0.03060165047645569, -0.021765585988759995, -0.04862034320831299, -0.0003160767664667219, 0.030682886019349098, -0.0019118771888315678, -0.052092570811510086, -0.013532979413866997, -0.010851362720131874, 0.01701340824365616, 0.04358000308275223, 0.0014427566202357411, 0.015643374994397163, 0.0004326065245550126, 0.04805562272667885, -0.000592464697547257, 0.008591185323894024, -0.011061429977416992, -0.021669430658221245, 0.003143130335956812, -0.007650731597095728, -0.03398250788450241, -0.02933175303041935, -6.585046619593497e-33, -0.060596950352191925, -0.02154449373483658, 0.03312099725008011, 0.0042716083116829395, -0.06419020146131516, -0.00791215244680643, -0.04704096540808678, -0.018887275829911232, 0.0003149869153276086, -0.05777152627706528, -0.011034522205591202, -0.019367866218090057, 0.03261102735996246, -0.014937526546418667, 0.033183954656124115, 0.0013237313833087683, 0.03655378520488739, 0.007348249666392803, 0.02978062443435192, -0.0022462578490376472, 0.011129370890557766, 0.08979867398738861, 0.11273366957902908, -0.08279836922883987, -0.01236736960709095, 0.032852500677108765, 0.018302444368600845, -0.03587905317544937, 0.05241551995277405, 0.042555417865514755, -0.05424405261874199, -0.02379094436764717, 0.015324007719755173, -0.07005315274000168, 0.004499990493059158, -0.0026599394623190165, -0.12542393803596497, 0.02575281448662281, -0.03351067751646042, 0.049020957201719284, -0.014253266155719757, -0.058969028294086456, 0.016347691416740417, -0.030486594885587692, -0.04974670335650444, 0.05379930138587952, 0.014222017489373684, -0.016268504783511162, -0.025877002626657486, -0.04621831327676773, -0.023995520547032356, 0.031785402446985245, 0.013227672316133976, 0.020540708675980568, 0.030236588791012764, 0.006516765803098679, 0.0011247744550928473, 0.020106971263885498, -0.06847502291202545, 0.008981871418654919, 0.031094113364815712, 0.09428486973047256, 0.014720186591148376, -0.01824001781642437, 0.02787991799414158, 0.033377744257450104, 0.04913710802793503, -0.06691808998584747, 0.02949407696723938, 0.017300134524703026, 0.045746203511953354, -0.00481938011944294, 0.03238159790635109, -6.908338400535285e-05, 0.08584938943386078, -0.02969176508486271, -0.04766863211989403, 0.01791696809232235, 0.01925818994641304, 0.06153062358498573, 0.009310142137110233, 0.005042984616011381, -0.020758237689733505, 0.015982428565621376, 0.01958145946264267, -0.054510701447725296, -0.009146200492978096, -0.05101019889116287, 0.029159413650631905, 0.040876660495996475, -0.004152931272983551, 0.028063151985406876, 0.05723511055111885, -0.023074420168995857, 0.0250695813447237, 0.013733476400375366, 0.02258841134607792, 0.009772089309990406, -0.021328873932361603, 0.004967157728970051, -0.07315133512020111, -0.042041677981615067, 0.021477796137332916, -0.04279658943414688, 0.005875406786799431, -0.01246662251651287, 0.029603036120533943, -0.020384231582283974, 0.005193796474486589, -0.016429690644145012, 0.0024509336799383163, 0.024270616471767426, -0.011073881760239601, 0.049881160259246826, 0.05042920261621475, -0.00679481215775013, -0.012867274694144726, 0.036482736468315125, 0.042268816381692886, 0.016405561938881874, -0.05882355570793152, -0.00019245725707150996, 0.079030841588974, 0.06687002629041672, -0.0013042977079749107, 0.025621365755796432, -0.042121633887290955, -0.002310962649062276, -0.020800603553652763, -0.044798851013183594, -0.013875430449843407, 0.06883850693702698, 2.822295357418625e-07, 0.003548786975443363, 0.021597890183329582, 0.04064051806926727, 0.03790848329663277, -0.01496307086199522, 0.00608624704182148, -0.0021735932677984238, 0.04204579070210457, -0.05518127977848053, -0.00814889371395111, -0.008402508683502674, -0.0379316546022892, 0.018591074272990227, -0.022666171193122864, -0.11882112920284271, -0.042161788791418076, -0.01310641784220934, 0.011007627472281456, -0.051008403301239014, 0.02527180314064026, 0.037965111434459686, 0.08710024505853653, -0.02767218090593815, -0.015456805936992168, 0.0039424472488462925, -0.00915522687137127, 0.020243462175130844, 0.05207807943224907, -0.030938168987631798, 0.018629206344485283, -0.024733616039156914, 0.020600583404302597, -0.03962917998433113, -0.0024337454233318567, -0.02214892767369747, 0.0003665579715743661, 0.010245554149150848, 0.004403674975037575, 0.012778423726558685, -0.05551648512482643, 0.037809666246175766, 0.03533797338604927, 0.002071533352136612, 0.013717053458094597, 0.04234088212251663, -0.029154807329177856, 0.0029897557105869055, 0.020871683955192566, -0.008769786916673183, -0.0002938836987596005, -0.023835469037294388, -0.0013549685245379806, 0.02775651030242443, 0.011500843800604343, 0.04012944921851158, -0.016986610367894173, -0.02365412376821041, -0.05935833975672722, 0.023733096197247505, -0.003994033206254244, -0.012291111052036285, 0.020271118730306625, -0.020444286987185478, 0.03484804928302765, 0.020817991346120834, -0.06818363070487976, -0.02659917250275612, 3.245795205299655e-34, -0.010914535261690617, -0.009329221211373806, -0.03732132166624069, 0.06005122885107994, -0.022905506193637848, -0.008741124533116817, -0.09076285362243652, 0.041117794811725616, -0.020105401054024696, -0.07128138840198517, -0.03389911726117134]
647
647
['Stephen Merity', 'Nitish Shirish Keskar', 'Richard Socher']
1708.02182v1
Recurrent neural networks (RNNs), such as long short-term memory networks (LSTMs), serve as a fundamental building block for many sequence learning tasks, including machine translation, language modeling, and question answering. In this paper, we consider the specific problem of word-level language modeling and investigate strategies for regularizing and optimizing LSTM-based models. We propose the weight-dropped LSTM which uses DropConnect on hidden-to-hidden weights as a form of recurrent regularization. Further, we introduce NT-ASGD, a variant of the averaged stochastic gradient method, wherein the averaging trigger is determined using a non-monotonic condition as opposed to being tuned by the user. Using these and other regularization strategies, we achieve state-of-the-art word level perplexities on two data sets: 57.3 on Penn Treebank and 65.8 on WikiText-2. In exploring the effectiveness of a neural cache in conjunction with our proposed model, we achieve an even lower state-of-the-art perplexity of 52.8 on Penn Treebank and 52.0 on WikiText-2.
Regularizing and Optimizing LSTM Language Models
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1708.02182v1
Title Regularizing Optimizing LSTM Language Models Summary Recurrent neural network RNNs long shortterm memory network LSTMs serve fundamental building block many sequence learning task including machine translation language modeling question answering paper consider specific problem wordlevel language modeling investigate strategy regularizing optimizing LSTMbased model propose weightdropped LSTM us DropConnect hiddentohidden weight form recurrent regularization introduce NTASGD variant averaged stochastic gradient method wherein averaging trigger determined using nonmonotonic condition opposed tuned user Using regularization strategy achieve stateoftheart word level perplexity two data set 573 Penn Treebank 658 WikiText2 exploring effectiveness neural cache conjunction proposed model achieve even lower stateoftheart perplexity 528 Penn Treebank 520 WikiText2 Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.03623424842953682, 0.055790528655052185, 0.004418463911861181, 0.06507393717765808, -0.03167427331209183, -0.003000459400936961, 0.013029449619352818, 0.016414618119597435, -0.02476254291832447, -0.019145308062434196, -0.03168972209095955, -0.07381616532802582, 0.05584363266825676, 0.011357031762599945, 0.006464107893407345, -0.05264847353100777, 0.03119942732155323, 0.0034407218918204308, -0.01738889329135418, -0.0015936113195493817, 0.023708553984761238, -0.01693808101117611, 0.034965626895427704, 0.03739149495959282, 0.019810790196061134, 0.007770095020532608, 0.007366071920841932, 0.02478107623755932, -0.008455920964479446, -0.04193762317299843, 0.024408452212810516, 0.06790778785943985, 0.039589542895555496, 0.06205121800303459, 2.368969944654964e-06, -0.024519475176930428, -0.0143443513661623, -0.038015492260456085, 0.002235631924122572, 0.0003783092543017119, 0.06058220937848091, -0.038032274693250656, 0.003697192994877696, 0.03933631628751755, -0.05678952857851982, -0.017776085063815117, 0.05518143251538277, 0.021361930295825005, 0.05740080401301384, 0.07577653229236603, 0.005113677121698856, -0.06936439871788025, 0.008792680688202381, -0.06294461339712143, 0.03827396407723427, -0.09781384468078613, 0.01832224614918232, -0.012920621782541275, -0.037514034658670425, -0.006249290890991688, -0.059891778975725174, 0.02590673230588436, 0.006320306099951267, 0.008594279177486897, -0.011097146198153496, 0.020522087812423706, 0.0023896864149719477, -0.013974160887300968, -0.009576651267707348, 0.07051639258861542, -0.038589946925640106, -0.010861946269869804, -0.00415786961093545, 0.02011866308748722, -0.054606035351753235, -0.03379533812403679, -0.034532468765974045, -0.007856984622776508, 0.0053520663641393185, 0.037499718368053436, 0.012054749764502048, -0.014033723622560501, 0.046671923249959946, 0.02688390575349331, -0.020761316642165184, 0.005330669693648815, 0.019423818215727806, -0.017998434603214264, -0.030383020639419556, -0.03861800953745842, -0.0014903370756655931, -0.06919047981500626, 0.02530275098979473, 0.0609637014567852, 0.005451986100524664, 0.035423874855041504, -0.010671022348105907, -0.08246327936649323, 0.006422622594982386, -0.03939194604754448, 0.026295175775885582, 0.02063976787030697, 0.015476534143090248, 0.01830769143998623, -0.01725083962082863, 0.05287439376115799, -0.02869250811636448, -0.025298085063695908, -0.037802696228027344, 0.013030130416154861, -0.03651958331465721, -0.015260043554008007, -0.021784232929348946, 0.025832055136561394, -0.010447872802615166, -0.023073716089129448, -0.07224565744400024, -0.04241417720913887, 0.01853317953646183, -0.02618846856057644, 0.020928943529725075, 0.022946743294596672, -0.043510206043720245, -0.030550848692655563, -0.008800025098025799, 0.06364186108112335, 0.0032507821451872587, 0.0005641771131195128, -0.017994733527302742, -0.007888354361057281, -0.008277724497020245, 0.030399354174733162, 0.03073851764202118, -0.0008646664791740477, 0.005589412525296211, 0.06261070817708969, 0.012605340220034122, 0.0047563244588673115, -0.05365537852048874, -0.0019738832488656044, -0.015847990289330482, -0.06239219382405281, -0.043765708804130554, -0.08398844301700592, 0.03161655366420746, -0.019955765455961227, -0.01001760270446539, -0.04080161824822426, 0.012997480109333992, 0.03291573002934456, -0.041657570749521255, 0.045366864651441574, -0.017247023060917854, -0.01602323167026043, 0.024547019973397255, 0.01929803378880024, 0.08739137649536133, 0.043142400681972504, 0.06267126649618149, 0.050449833273887634, 0.004813662264496088, -0.012934873811900616, -0.024401506409049034, 0.03989546746015549, 0.009022929705679417, 0.007910761050879955, -0.06960619240999222, -0.04522295668721199, -0.0027198302559554577, 0.045000866055488586, 0.05336989089846611, 0.0719166249036789, -0.029650207608938217, 0.004994626622647047, 0.04676581919193268, 0.0665561854839325, 0.051150575280189514, 0.040885984897613525, 0.018805211409926414, 0.0008169646607711911, 0.004787623882293701, 0.03454301878809929, 0.007672335486859083, 0.026395831257104874, -0.017085766419768333, -0.0195254385471344, 0.005171250551939011, 0.010045256465673447, -0.017161337658762932, -0.04598105698823929, -0.03803562372922897, -0.0673467218875885, 0.046973034739494324, -0.013134821318089962, 0.046364523470401764, 0.0070471977815032005, -0.053778938949108124, 0.04429040104150772, -0.008885310031473637, -0.021062107756733894, 0.0060593062080442905, -0.02544431760907173, -0.025768019258975983, 0.03244242072105408, 0.017942415550351143, -0.0006385959568433464, -0.03918307647109032, -0.012177308090031147, -0.02519257366657257, 0.05589883029460907, 0.02521788887679577, 0.02016095630824566, 0.015600779093801975, -0.09127261489629745, -0.007492062635719776, 0.04823223501443863, -0.002354404656216502, 0.043512795120477676, -0.04179585725069046, 0.042177099734544754, 0.04629157483577728, 0.019176725298166275, -0.045562744140625, 0.025102432817220688, -0.042505841702222824, -0.03241998329758644, 0.024550490081310272, 0.013752120546996593, 0.018062537536025047, 0.008425142616033554, 0.017270119860768318, 0.007515548728406429, 0.012391656637191772, -0.03419730067253113, -0.054287854582071304, -0.012648975476622581, -0.0710204616189003, -0.06050681695342064, 0.019563157111406326, 0.028833970427513123, 0.038901280611753464, 0.031528279185295105, -0.031974125653505325, -0.07325485348701477, 0.06671147048473358, -0.03676259517669678, 0.046599164605140686, -0.04043518006801605, 0.023005159571766853, 0.005422618705779314, 0.03919646888971329, -0.04713353514671326, 0.04551222175359726, -0.02470710314810276, 0.039344046264886856, -0.00911444891244173, 0.004579958505928516, 0.05944794416427612, -0.04936831817030907, -0.0407143197953701, 0.018530551344156265, -0.015948623418807983, 0.02768983691930771, 0.01597052626311779, 0.0543440505862236, -0.016021160408854485, -0.021626833826303482, -0.05713675543665886, 0.010926419869065285, -0.00770279485732317, -0.0017818420892581344, -0.0062407320365309715, 0.0497550442814827, 0.025631027296185493, -0.014816854149103165, -0.03367384895682335, 0.02363516390323639, 0.016682809218764305, -0.0027300657238811255, 0.03152521699666977, 0.024120543152093887, -0.0016785891493782401, -0.07920030504465103, -0.024905549362301826, -0.005433268379420042, 0.04325014725327492, -0.0028907875530421734, -0.02764703519642353, -0.02995580993592739, 0.024190356954932213, -0.05519572272896767, 0.044340308755636215, 0.003676346270367503, -0.07336410135030746, -0.011217689141631126, -0.013661234639585018, 0.03644150123000145, 0.030619170516729355, 0.0189451202750206, -0.020365608856081963, 0.0003446701157372445, 0.01624707691371441, -0.030920064076781273, 0.026113787665963173, -0.0030188250821083784, -0.0028006634674966335, -0.023819249123334885, -0.011307667940855026, -0.007011020556092262, 0.11035888642072678, 0.047371041029691696, 0.0011006692657247186, -0.014004455879330635, 0.007494017947465181, -0.019012922421097755, 0.017104364931583405, -0.01626521907746792, -0.012351580895483494, -0.020072080194950104, 0.03596378117799759, -0.016467615962028503, -0.0625048354268074, 0.05428669974207878, -0.020658647641539574, -0.001353353844024241, -0.07109153270721436, -0.016792872920632362, -0.072161003947258, 0.028023716062307358, 0.001829391811043024, 0.021034225821495056, -0.07109387218952179, -0.037479985505342484, -0.02333705499768257, -0.026014018803834915, -0.028342723846435547, -0.051873158663511276, 0.04777253046631813, -0.005654426757246256, 0.00865241326391697, -0.030701247975230217, -0.0009412338840775192, -0.03663681074976921, -0.003389783436432481, -0.042483482509851456, -0.04273274540901184, 0.05551284924149513, -0.022081052884459496, -0.0039125727489590645, 0.0301084965467453, 0.0061022876761853695, 0.05251820385456085, -0.030126942321658134, 0.026179850101470947, -0.0005032113986089826, 0.04577825590968132, 0.0717225968837738, -0.029780084267258644, -0.013871629722416401, 0.004766420926898718, 0.05253353342413902, 0.025295203551650047, 0.003192564705386758, 0.010948698967695236, -0.06729777157306671, 0.01250122394412756, 0.03708707168698311, -0.01805189624428749, -0.02785280905663967, 0.014779643155634403, -0.0179494246840477, -0.08224907517433167, -0.0034121035132557154, 0.12175449728965759, 0.028756828978657722, -0.10330316424369812, -0.009981467388570309, -0.025363866239786148, 0.03421151265501976, 0.016855111345648766, 0.00448963837698102, -0.05102284252643585, -0.03510146215558052, -0.03499695286154747, -0.003043082542717457, 0.024366481229662895, -0.03318218141794205, -0.03903873637318611, -0.07648095488548279, -0.03219832479953766, 0.012728147208690643, -0.05688293278217316, -0.0017849854193627834, -0.02208600379526615, -0.010335993953049183, 0.007735843304544687, 0.042982056736946106, 0.025327984243631363, -0.0003934759006369859, -0.020591072738170624, 0.022013718262314796, -0.06934212148189545, -0.017125355079770088, 0.01733313873410225, -0.05746754631400108, 0.006852089427411556, 0.0938335433602333, 0.05772078409790993, -0.04468963295221329, -0.048727765679359436, 0.04693862050771713, 0.009942246600985527, 0.005601191893219948, -0.038603417575359344, 0.011900623328983784, 0.009646585211157799, -0.02141803689301014, -0.0064278896898031235, 0.009237353689968586, -0.03099687583744526, 0.029983431100845337, -0.03715033829212189, 0.04539243131875992, -0.008165815845131874, -0.027283601462841034, -0.013652925379574299, 0.015641486272215843, 0.015693198889493942, 0.037085115909576416, 0.029459016397595406, -0.058400362730026245, -0.027126815170049667, -0.006664850749075413, 0.02930305525660515, -0.057117756456136703, -0.019452828913927078, 0.0036784156691282988, 0.016148872673511505, -0.03387940675020218, -0.09456771612167358, -0.028022104874253273, -0.03325094282627106, 0.024380948394536972, 0.010582419112324715, 0.10172382742166519, 0.017365844920277596, -0.021020038053393364, -0.01713746041059494, 0.0012457899283617735, 0.01139090396463871, 0.008981408551335335, -0.04618227854371071, 0.01963333785533905, 0.03704382851719856, -0.015067999251186848, -0.008353435434401035, -0.00022099140915088356, -0.129464253783226, -0.048470769077539444, -0.0020159026607871056, 0.0037826714105904102, 0.021489204838871956, 0.007894975133240223, -0.018579836934804916, -0.07403861731290817, -0.007318071089684963, -0.010955048725008965, 0.03179587051272392, -0.007531059440225363, 0.0285017229616642, 0.003508958499878645, -0.005962836556136608, 0.04183780401945114, -0.02096066251397133, 0.03376326709985733, 0.009664969518780708, 0.03306504338979721, 0.014102230779826641, -0.04186606407165527, -0.00953761674463749, -0.012358888052403927, 0.05277543514966965, -0.006257511209696531, -0.019505714997649193, -0.003475555218756199, 0.021998371928930283, 0.011858252808451653, 0.008825630880892277, -0.03984040766954422, -0.005312574096024036, 0.04103502258658409, 0.002608876908197999, -0.02477952465415001, -0.06490146368741989, 0.01521281711757183, -0.037524763494729996, 0.002699579345062375, 0.05542173236608505, -0.03795771300792694, -0.0030178637243807316, -0.004637190140783787, 0.004366997163742781, -0.035311874002218246, 0.013535050675272942, 0.001976342871785164, 0.0079413540661335, -0.03338353708386421, 0.026026492938399315, 0.0014098333194851875, 0.016529934480786324, -0.028388310223817825, 0.031960342079401016, -0.006628165487200022, -0.0297186728566885, -0.02773495763540268, -0.024187728762626648, 0.11247602105140686, -0.026632392778992653, 0.028923971578478813, 0.02279527112841606, 0.02411895990371704, -0.010764759965240955, 0.03497491404414177, -0.006614147685468197, -0.010675868950784206, 0.042916759848594666, 0.008206005208194256, -0.024128472432494164, 0.039980996400117874, 0.09732095897197723, 0.042487312108278275, 0.009369274601340294, 0.03192024305462837, -0.02216121181845665, -0.00011355978494975716, 0.031573060899972916, 0.007376842200756073, 0.019419856369495392, -0.03264569863677025, 0.0018887855112552643, -0.018901148810982704, -0.08578695356845856, 0.06277230381965637, 0.002120264573022723, 0.03795604780316353, 0.0014353450387716293, 0.04463672265410423, 0.04371630400419235, -0.025023264810442924, 0.03338612988591194, -0.022478800266981125, 0.010493949055671692, 0.01796501874923706, -0.05093208700418472, -0.04243961349129677, -6.999039566905783e-33, -0.0024182109627872705, -0.014040307141840458, 0.008153123781085014, -0.0085785873234272, -0.03682776540517807, -0.0024071987718343735, -0.04412056505680084, -0.021563531830906868, -0.032712213695049286, -0.015058647841215134, -0.03859458491206169, 0.0209371205419302, 0.0019465123768895864, 0.02504710480570793, 0.02763301506638527, 0.009266410954296589, 0.013987360522150993, 0.016402486711740494, 0.037114232778549194, 0.004902833141386509, 0.017813872545957565, 0.06367912143468857, 0.11348183453083038, -0.02614419162273407, -0.0030378710944205523, -0.0024904469028115273, 0.014743718318641186, 0.019464805722236633, 0.01526111364364624, 0.017942681908607483, -0.041523564606904984, 0.018780378624796867, 0.03189409524202347, -0.03998534008860588, -0.028731048107147217, -0.007418191060423851, -0.010115541517734528, -0.05383249372243881, 0.016722453758120537, -0.011272966861724854, -0.019165685400366783, 0.00403805635869503, 0.0645885169506073, 0.0035486870910972357, -0.031876031309366226, 0.030630290508270264, 0.018064934760332108, -0.016773968935012817, -0.05212046578526497, -0.017908910289406776, -0.05732550844550133, 0.04397149384021759, 0.021941863000392914, 0.011847980320453644, -0.014081425033509731, -0.021274564787745476, -0.03407308831810951, 0.037549033761024475, -0.07132700085639954, -0.019301781430840492, -0.002178825670853257, 0.09349816292524338, 0.05569414049386978, 0.039506278932094574, -0.018391061574220657, 0.014778080396354198, 0.033746279776096344, 0.017368121072649956, -0.002800827380269766, 0.02278798446059227, 0.049560632556676865, 0.01741194538772106, 0.06292793154716492, 0.011893454939126968, 0.08225017786026001, -0.04746909439563751, -0.08237525075674057, 0.021677644923329353, -0.00031328588374890387, 0.09024228155612946, 0.0287045706063509, 0.03759579733014107, -0.02946464531123638, -0.02610274963080883, -0.03138873353600502, 0.00495522515848279, -0.04017515107989311, -0.04904332756996155, -0.013802911154925823, 0.023570694029331207, 0.014129973016679287, -0.005076723638921976, 0.026894520968198776, -0.018224434927105904, 0.0116706732660532, 0.01578359305858612, 0.021281886845827103, -0.00921388529241085, 0.0046035838313400745, 0.050909873098134995, -0.013048337772488594, -0.018108636140823364, -0.025232113897800446, 0.02013503946363926, 0.0069390516728162766, -0.005119824782013893, 0.0065170107409358025, 0.001802306855097413, -0.03971942141652107, -0.015919238328933716, -0.023254241794347763, -0.018363624811172485, -0.015052923932671547, 0.04352406784892082, 0.03380615636706352, -0.02032308466732502, -0.013858496211469173, 0.09554664045572281, 0.029027633368968964, -0.02793012000620365, -0.051674988120794296, -0.03332939371466637, 0.050461601465940475, 0.027947980910539627, -0.05112891271710396, -0.006159424781799316, -0.015979118645191193, 0.01580156572163105, 0.028691362589597702, -0.05571369081735611, -0.01652027666568756, 0.027782926335930824, 3.082087971506553e-07, 0.023534206673502922, 0.019130771979689598, 0.0031788747292011976, -0.006565005984157324, 0.010840531438589096, -0.02011045254766941, -0.03484402969479561, 0.015259361825883389, -0.012479424476623535, 0.03427020460367203, 0.009317326359450817, -0.0053668152540922165, 0.03859138488769531, 0.005281943362206221, -0.08785086125135422, -0.015495430678129196, -0.0879870057106018, 0.04684363678097725, -0.02927515283226967, -0.01681215688586235, 0.017372440546751022, 0.12771442532539368, 0.01926061511039734, -0.043119292706251144, 0.020709315314888954, -0.030754001811146736, 0.0391455739736557, 0.008109877817332745, -0.0009100225870497525, 0.025557899847626686, 0.049652762711048126, 0.022856812924146652, -0.0003869529173243791, -0.05080774053931236, -0.04814412444829941, 0.05527879670262337, 0.02505621686577797, 0.04371102526783943, -0.042922161519527435, -0.0481528639793396, 0.03982769697904587, 0.010018197819590569, -0.006896286737173796, -0.046692121773958206, 0.04057006537914276, -0.004703850485384464, -0.020656753331422806, -0.010846561752259731, 0.04468799754977226, -0.0005257814773358405, 0.04459959268569946, -0.023103004321455956, -0.04538939148187637, 0.025666022673249245, 0.026855600997805595, -0.032868511974811554, -0.030236581340432167, -0.07442757487297058, -0.027429990470409393, 0.009224386885762215, -0.052014581859111786, -0.010511772707104683, -0.02747364155948162, 0.008800463750958443, 0.03348355367779732, -0.019922522827982903, -0.00319757591933012, 3.2594066033627117e-34, 0.04911813884973526, -0.02622675895690918, -0.009611338376998901, 0.03837898373603821, 0.040321338921785355, 0.002543318783864379, -0.017222288995981216, 0.03358340263366699, 0.003546543186530471, -0.0983009785413742, -0.04283380135893822]
648
648
['DeLiang Wang', 'Jitong Chen']
1708.07524v1
Speech separation is the task of separating target speech from background interference. Traditionally, speech separation is studied as a signal processing problem. A more recent approach formulates speech separation as a supervised learning problem, where the discriminative patterns of speech, speakers, and background noise are learned from training data. Over the past decade, many supervised separation algorithms have been put forward. In particular, the recent introduction of deep learning to supervised speech separation has dramatically accelerated progress and boosted separation performance. This article provides a comprehensive overview of the research on deep learning based supervised speech separation in the last several years. We first introduce the background of speech separation and the formulation of supervised separation. Then we discuss three main components of supervised separation: learning machines, training targets, and acoustic features. Much of the overview is on separation algorithms where we review monaural methods, including speech enhancement (speech-nonspeech separation), speaker separation (multi-talker separation), and speech dereverberation, as well as multi-microphone techniques. The important issue of generalization, unique to supervised learning, is discussed. This overview provides a historical perspective on how advances are made. In addition, we discuss a number of conceptual issues, including what constitutes the target source.
Supervised Speech Separation Based on Deep Learning: An Overview
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1708.07524v1
Title Supervised Speech Separation Based Deep Learning Overview Summary Speech separation task separating target speech background interference Traditionally speech separation studied signal processing problem recent approach formulates speech separation supervised learning problem discriminative pattern speech speaker background noise learned training data past decade many supervised separation algorithm put forward particular recent introduction deep learning supervised speech separation dramatically accelerated progress boosted separation performance article provides comprehensive overview research deep learning based supervised speech separation last several year first introduce background speech separation formulation supervised separation discus three main component supervised separation learning machine training target acoustic feature Much overview separation algorithm review monaural method including speech enhancement speechnonspeech separation speaker separation multitalker separation speech dereverberation well multimicrophone technique important issue generalization unique supervised learning discussed overview provides historical perspective advance made addition discus number conceptual issue including constitutes target source Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.038107819855213165, 0.01861475221812725, 0.027826201170682907, 0.046899646520614624, 0.004771906416863203, -0.03258495032787323, 0.07156315445899963, -0.01173003576695919, -0.0398559495806694, -0.00904389750212431, -0.06965471059083939, -0.01244617160409689, 0.0264066644012928, 0.004790692590177059, -0.023088771849870682, -0.07378953695297241, -0.0031380208674818277, -0.013153448700904846, 0.03867945075035095, 0.008185058832168579, 0.01816372387111187, -0.024763235822319984, -0.04087904468178749, -0.010271807201206684, -0.03701338544487953, 0.010137955658137798, -0.002678859978914261, -0.026131704449653625, -0.026041001081466675, 0.007524233311414719, 0.033948637545108795, -0.01682792231440544, 0.01769060082733631, 0.05036246031522751, 1.757491872922401e-06, -0.006360874976962805, -0.021784400567412376, 0.00613542553037405, 0.003998729400336742, -0.06428078562021255, -0.015108393505215645, 0.0490591786801815, -0.006154850125312805, 0.010356470942497253, 0.010661905631422997, -0.005433348938822746, 0.018077267333865166, 0.04519595205783844, 0.04732498899102211, 0.029919520020484924, -0.013831484131515026, -0.043736740946769714, -0.004586882423609495, -0.0009549397509545088, -0.016343507915735245, -0.021050643175840378, -0.007096247747540474, -0.0325750932097435, -0.023399420082569122, -0.048584625124931335, 0.015812423080205917, 0.0610005185008049, -0.02203409932553768, 0.013879452832043171, 0.027165841311216354, 0.019302770495414734, -0.04245927184820175, -0.08126140385866165, -0.03016999550163746, 0.0870780423283577, -0.012884175404906273, 0.04712667316198349, 0.02924806997179985, -0.001446518232114613, -0.020168520510196686, -0.05498366430401802, -0.029444046318531036, 0.002819663845002651, -0.0204317606985569, -0.010816987603902817, -0.02015804685652256, 0.021616121754050255, 0.0036545710172504187, -0.04037616401910782, -0.03416585177183151, 0.028171248733997345, -0.03028641641139984, -0.02571973390877247, 0.01198176946491003, -0.003233757335692644, 0.017934856936335564, 0.014834349043667316, 0.06150401011109352, 0.01039397343993187, -0.051023561507463455, -0.02409556321799755, -0.023804565891623497, -0.11224042624235153, -0.05361896753311157, -0.01371821854263544, -0.019976412877440453, -0.02400866523385048, -0.04666459932923317, -0.03315526619553566, 0.036750469356775284, -0.0013158530928194523, -0.017247186973690987, -0.0034747745376080275, 0.012453568167984486, 0.005483919754624367, -0.003110124496743083, 0.030003491789102554, 0.009447026997804642, 0.07228661328554153, -0.04691338539123535, -0.005788934417068958, -0.02156510204076767, -0.027264021337032318, -0.06928007304668427, -0.015455847606062889, 0.033476054668426514, 0.02219255641102791, -0.051765378564596176, -0.026051655411720276, 0.056566428393125534, 0.005513567011803389, -0.01963941566646099, 0.08268624544143677, -0.013809343799948692, -0.05212068930268288, 0.03324555605649948, 0.04765474051237106, 0.0629403293132782, 0.017472894862294197, 0.006752628367394209, 0.053896546363830566, 0.018988823518157005, 0.027075080201029778, -0.04485959932208061, 0.01739650033414364, 0.03357689455151558, -0.0422092005610466, 0.017100172117352486, -0.06697981804609299, 0.02989078499376774, -0.024122199043631554, -0.01589426025748253, -0.0007111136219464242, -0.00041311318636871874, -0.0405622199177742, 0.0013424300123006105, 0.032852690666913986, -0.04770003631711006, -0.0035052362363785505, 0.12416990101337433, -0.010372371412813663, -0.03447187691926956, 0.03082249127328396, 0.04162713140249252, -0.0623704232275486, 0.042791903018951416, -0.04644235596060753, -0.010369065217673779, 0.03807647526264191, -0.042600929737091064, -0.0812971368432045, -0.013198770582675934, -0.041478388011455536, -0.013088522478938103, -0.017897017300128937, -0.016057616099715233, 0.012929561547935009, 0.020178819075226784, 0.035141680389642715, 0.010088962502777576, 0.04533678665757179, 0.04340791702270508, 0.05364035442471504, 0.004992688074707985, 0.017899034544825554, -0.012251353822648525, 0.06758230924606323, 0.03995977342128754, -0.032808925956487656, -0.04517067223787308, -0.015922125428915024, -0.013191672042012215, -0.017427435144782066, -0.020412543788552284, -0.04256462678313255, 0.05837471783161163, -0.03593479469418526, -0.016185736283659935, 0.005656186956912279, 0.05860525742173195, -0.035300515592098236, -0.00048474507639184594, -0.004680065903812647, 0.007015921641141176, -0.06072953715920448, -0.019485728815197945, -0.0032035771291702986, 0.01061769388616085, -0.013078692369163036, -0.05765204504132271, -0.06040685996413231, -0.03052416816353798, -0.07048213481903076, -0.00822249986231327, 0.028216427192091942, -0.05024867504835129, 0.005625714082270861, 0.07662937790155411, -0.048197802156209946, -0.027096398174762726, 0.008901191875338554, -0.02916712686419487, -0.01752692461013794, -0.03057631105184555, -0.038546137511730194, 0.013399197719991207, 0.08759955316781998, 0.05012151598930359, 0.010682555846869946, -0.0005329678533598781, 0.003215719712898135, -0.005542847793549299, 0.031727034598588943, 0.08635450154542923, 0.04250510036945343, -0.005315138027071953, -0.0058818841353058815, 0.01720896176993847, -0.038710735738277435, 0.008996625430881977, -0.001527925138361752, -0.008316250517964363, -0.014132390730082989, 0.044336460530757904, -0.019257036969065666, 0.013732358813285828, 0.05858687683939934, 0.011676990427076817, -0.05494255945086479, 0.02630089595913887, 0.03586912155151367, 0.026929182931780815, -0.013668766245245934, 0.03212527930736542, 0.034154415130615234, 0.029723430052399635, 0.00672835623845458, 0.00242347433231771, 0.044390931725502014, -0.02281107008457184, 0.0017265424830839038, 0.01960175298154354, -0.0030586940702050924, -0.03508733585476875, 0.014099153690040112, 0.019151054322719574, -0.02398320473730564, 0.004858484026044607, -0.03427978605031967, 0.031241824850440025, -0.0361521914601326, -0.006076823454350233, 0.0095225740224123, 0.0391479916870594, -0.04988166689872742, -0.03960631787776947, -0.03044997528195381, 0.01731400191783905, 0.02768990397453308, -0.02583150379359722, -0.01800866238772869, 0.013932334259152412, 0.008295804262161255, -0.06129187345504761, -0.028779566287994385, 0.018381722271442413, 0.0002487381862010807, -0.025862837210297585, -0.008486190810799599, 0.029871061444282532, -0.007928334176540375, -0.016719674691557884, -0.0916498601436615, 0.019564639776945114, 0.0011530780466273427, -0.0036355892661958933, 0.09408846497535706, 0.038116686046123505, 0.005239134654402733, -0.005013825371861458, -0.010861029848456383, 0.03119765594601631, 0.02283533662557602, 0.006965429522097111, -0.01194192748516798, 0.015754248946905136, 0.0009914071997627616, -0.016076305881142616, 0.017643481492996216, 0.03531159460544586, 0.07329761236906052, 0.0015752919716760516, 0.06719686836004257, -0.02972303330898285, -0.015515527687966824, 0.04778856411576271, 0.04331225901842117, 0.006022687070071697, -0.016849597916007042, -0.02755817398428917, -0.061323441565036774, -0.0440712533891201, -0.012822093442082405, -0.02629188448190689, -0.02501518465578556, -0.012746555730700493, 0.03271083906292915, -0.01094526331871748, -0.010898696258664131, -0.01855982281267643, -0.05189918726682663, -0.11030229926109314, 0.014873574487864971, -0.03076600283384323, -0.05134902894496918, -0.004202059470117092, -0.04519512504339218, -0.05370986461639404, -0.011039803735911846, -0.003843211103230715, -0.008672590367496014, -0.052624594420194626, 0.010567683726549149, -0.030826402828097343, -0.02390432544052601, -0.008894417434930801, 0.029696248471736908, -0.05476091429591179, 0.009904581122100353, -0.019777603447437286, 0.001997177256271243, 0.014766321517527103, 0.003857620758935809, 0.026435187086462975, 0.031094513833522797, 0.018094193190336227, 0.03936318680644035, 0.00026514349156059325, 0.05543641373515129, -0.04247012361884117, 0.10418107360601425, 0.022591013461351395, -0.008325719274580479, -0.022785909473896027, 0.009713217616081238, 0.047044649720191956, -0.0317525677382946, 0.01747642084956169, -0.02741004154086113, -0.060650784522295, -0.011298725381493568, -0.03348464518785477, -0.012017893604934216, -0.0323130264878273, -0.0044736419804394245, 0.02232392504811287, -0.05195371434092522, 0.04350488260388374, 0.06596077978610992, 0.005440238397568464, -0.05126073211431503, -0.03207138553261757, 0.004967703949660063, -0.07275192439556122, -0.007583205588161945, -0.03741217404603958, 0.056279197335243225, 0.0038002340588718653, 0.04326852038502693, 0.016023531556129456, 0.02309742011129856, 0.03116237372159958, -0.056320223957300186, -0.0737750306725502, 0.011592036113142967, 0.010330799035727978, -0.043962933123111725, -0.07057514786720276, -0.021057285368442535, 0.013139459304511547, 0.00523264380171895, 0.05263146385550499, 0.0010414129355922341, 0.024453559890389442, -0.05179542675614357, 0.055532366037368774, -0.10118184983730316, 0.007999078370630741, -0.0750310868024826, -0.05354940518736839, 0.03168381750583649, 0.005261141341179609, 0.024196717888116837, -0.050211433321237564, 0.012127717025578022, 0.027475247159600258, 0.007096967659890652, -0.022551245987415314, -0.0300352293998003, 0.03799326345324516, 0.016644427552819252, -0.007723208051174879, 0.03488509729504585, 0.043678682297468185, -0.0019582989625632763, 0.03649764508008957, 0.05951827019453049, 0.019482359290122986, -0.010039271786808968, -0.012160250917077065, -0.023999081924557686, 0.06072862446308136, 0.028611991554498672, 0.03986089676618576, 0.01655188761651516, -0.015589362010359764, 0.0055893599055707455, 0.02803715690970421, 0.04280974715948105, 0.005177496001124382, 0.04496602714061737, -0.008645135909318924, -0.0326211154460907, -0.04555302858352661, -0.011529515497386456, -0.03943281248211861, -0.02043878845870495, 0.03300042450428009, 0.02703704684972763, 0.06429789960384369, -0.004146795719861984, 0.047017134726047516, 0.007366842124611139, -0.017880553379654884, 0.04499877244234085, 0.004792886786162853, -0.027383113279938698, -0.0001717862323857844, 0.031480323523283005, -0.02826804295182228, 0.003884218167513609, 0.008399355225265026, 0.004425660707056522, -0.040557947009801865, 0.016291022300720215, -0.07038010656833649, 0.0008430093876086175, 0.05938781425356865, -0.021413972601294518, -0.055344197899103165, -0.0006282616523094475, -0.017599033191800117, -0.01578519679605961, -0.009917432442307472, 0.12211008369922638, -0.022119248285889626, -0.012382222339510918, 0.027493136003613472, -0.029533136636018753, 0.07704835385084152, -0.004141183570027351, -0.02664363384246826, -0.0876058042049408, -0.0013106061378493905, -0.02224031835794449, 0.010599058121442795, 0.06646677106618881, 0.05650634691119194, 0.026178253814578056, -0.06529231369495392, 0.027391765266656876, -0.021458899602293968, 0.029512900859117508, -0.03213226795196533, 0.012884190306067467, -0.0017398002091795206, -0.013193238526582718, -0.0118331927806139, 0.0033514979295432568, 0.026889726519584656, -0.015316948294639587, 0.0165884867310524, 0.08021163195371628, 0.00997562613338232, 0.009125541895627975, -0.06534674763679504, 0.020983273163437843, 0.0006312350160442293, 0.03808634728193283, 0.09988502413034439, -0.006462762597948313, -0.0036287892144173384, 0.01881164312362671, -0.007402821909636259, -0.02252994105219841, 0.0003246650449000299, -0.003121639834716916, 0.020392926409840584, 0.010449819266796112, -0.004801442380994558, 0.057764746248722076, -0.0035709685180336237, -0.024408815428614616, -0.011239900253713131, 0.06391754746437073, 0.00659161014482379, -0.017220329493284225, 0.012689601629972458, -0.0211937315762043, 0.04634140804409981, -0.010434671305119991, -0.02128094621002674, -0.026161618530750275, 0.0011962117860093713, 0.04410252720117569, 2.9072765755699947e-05, 0.0034197152126580477, -0.01454854104667902, -0.01909070461988449, -0.063445083796978, 0.0014771162532269955, 0.012630498968064785, -0.0007406143704429269, -0.0005584214814007282, 0.018511759117245674, 0.046077847480773926, -0.021497663110494614, -0.00010634358477545902, -0.04293730854988098, 0.07525128126144409, -0.007026923354715109, -0.0030249732080847025, -0.014269826002418995, -0.05105573683977127, 0.007467505056411028, 0.020328668877482414, -0.04035843536257744, 0.0641743391752243, -0.005914726760238409, 0.006461752578616142, -5.429472489913832e-33, -0.006276947911828756, 0.05970031023025513, -0.04017782211303711, 0.009043361991643906, -0.026124954223632812, 0.014086265116930008, 0.01905370131134987, 0.015550406649708748, 0.00810640025883913, 0.003543565049767494, -0.004493624437600374, 0.04750928282737732, 0.030029520392417908, -0.027507256716489792, 0.0017192666418850422, 0.014708247035741806, 0.09004724025726318, -0.03666523098945618, 0.04122026637196541, 0.019233308732509613, 0.03560618311166763, 0.08444174379110336, 0.029970647767186165, -0.07398360967636108, -0.028658701106905937, -0.0010361580643802881, -0.009101701900362968, -0.046843256801366806, 0.012394549325108528, 0.005105221644043922, -0.004097299184650183, 0.01364696491509676, -0.01600581966340542, -0.02650400437414646, -0.014017253182828426, 0.060415033251047134, -0.06798110902309418, -0.03162698075175285, -0.05731530860066414, 0.034909483045339584, -0.041267216205596924, -0.03187083825469017, 0.10449859499931335, 0.05487419664859772, -0.030509691685438156, -0.011459870263934135, 0.045979224145412445, -0.028056500479578972, 0.009184328839182854, -0.03907497972249985, 0.013702653348445892, 0.020516235381364822, -0.014548092149198055, -0.01856621913611889, 0.09697117656469345, 0.0028166542761027813, -0.03723663464188576, -0.021156011149287224, -0.06575129926204681, 0.05281716212630272, 0.04353988170623779, 0.020558765158057213, -0.008696815930306911, 0.05060978978872299, -0.011352146975696087, 0.016059791669249535, 0.043379805982112885, -0.04630456492304802, 0.04578668251633644, -0.026946617290377617, 0.011385585181415081, 0.10017317533493042, 0.05938570201396942, -0.04551022872328758, 0.045309025794267654, -0.053552623838186264, -0.10259657353162766, 0.010665131732821465, 0.03336213156580925, -0.035299647599458694, -0.00032536074286326766, 0.01584438979625702, -0.019862214103341103, 0.03393584489822388, -0.004411494825035334, -0.024095715954899788, -0.017909293994307518, -0.005320366472005844, -0.003901623422279954, -0.016935791820287704, -0.019975654780864716, -0.02509213238954544, 0.05165083706378937, -0.029639966785907745, 0.05747112259268761, 0.011564464308321476, -0.014152112416923046, -0.028012963011860847, 0.03133019804954529, -0.030626293271780014, -0.046376194804906845, -0.02661479078233242, 0.04907822608947754, 0.06388549506664276, 0.006944919936358929, -0.039236340671777725, -0.0022090559359639883, 0.03140348941087723, 0.009298386983573437, -0.02358141355216503, 0.006183724384754896, 0.020826442167162895, 0.009241212159395218, 0.07812806963920593, -0.000564788409974426, -0.03752271831035614, 0.0020770214032381773, 0.05287696421146393, 0.014633097685873508, 0.012448767200112343, 0.02419351227581501, -0.00397508405148983, 0.027671562507748604, 0.01907072588801384, -0.04426991939544678, 0.006476529408246279, -0.017032602801918983, -0.037818543612957, 0.07589476555585861, -0.018512189388275146, 0.0027729151770472527, -0.03746988996863365, 2.355229469230835e-07, -0.08224830776453018, -0.016823191195726395, -0.003156478749588132, -0.0622217133641243, 0.02354521118104458, 0.00020553094509523362, -0.0024841397535055876, -0.038731012493371964, 0.00288283359259367, -0.02213640697300434, 0.045677654445171356, -0.02689797803759575, 0.02061275951564312, 0.007851245813071728, -0.025636101141572, -0.05380680039525032, -0.056605275720357895, -0.024128781631588936, -0.010850546881556511, 0.04559485614299774, 0.01792210526764393, 0.05979250743985176, -0.005780389998108149, -0.06678995490074158, 0.005257816053926945, 0.03227408230304718, -0.04249952360987663, 0.017443547025322914, -0.0024223567452281713, -0.023444410413503647, 0.05236823856830597, 6.28162088105455e-05, 0.0022599869407713413, -0.008979572914540768, -0.023830099031329155, 0.029402729123830795, 0.058434706181287766, 0.04356870427727699, -0.03349700942635536, -0.00807409081608057, 0.048435796052217484, 0.08209146559238434, -0.0030463063158094883, 0.08662299811840057, 0.05585160851478577, 0.028563523665070534, -0.006919024977833033, -0.04889008402824402, -0.028859799727797508, 0.027940280735492706, -0.020130449905991554, 0.00923094991594553, 0.037032704800367355, -0.061313655227422714, -0.0321078784763813, -0.012857234105467796, -0.03616483509540558, 0.001818458316847682, -0.022016428411006927, 0.02777576446533203, -0.043274905532598495, 0.015585644170641899, 0.05355115979909897, -0.043183501809835434, -0.020377296954393387, 0.020806685090065002, 0.023119062185287476, 1.5382489228324203e-34, -0.0037992484867572784, 0.009097211062908173, -0.01169517356902361, 0.006339623127132654, -0.02331765741109848, -0.03223270922899246, -0.03581549599766731, 0.021822791546583176, -0.027141112834215164, 0.018449753522872925, -0.022926893085241318]
649
649
['Marek Rei', 'Luana Bulat', 'Douwe Kiela', 'Ekaterina Shutova']
1709.00575v1
The ubiquity of metaphor in our everyday communication makes it an important problem for natural language understanding. Yet, the majority of metaphor processing systems to date rely on hand-engineered features and there is still no consensus in the field as to which features are optimal for this task. In this paper, we present the first deep learning architecture designed to capture metaphorical composition. Our results demonstrate that it outperforms the existing approaches in the metaphor identification task.
Grasping the Finer Point: A Supervised Similarity Network for Metaphor Detection
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1709.00575v1
Title Grasping Finer Point Supervised Similarity Network Metaphor Detection Summary ubiquity metaphor everyday communication make important problem natural language understanding Yet majority metaphor processing system date rely handengineered feature still consensus field feature optimal task paper present first deep learning architecture designed capture metaphorical composition result demonstrate outperforms existing approach metaphor identification task Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.05495205149054527, 0.00798508059233427, -0.023405704647302628, 0.03188026323914528, -0.017655406147241592, 0.023375147953629494, -0.003949107602238655, -0.014763303101062775, -0.01064575556665659, -0.025932954624295235, 0.009613321162760258, -0.0046531278640031815, 0.022552382200956345, 0.010603792034089565, 0.018367839977145195, -0.07821357250213623, -0.01387422438710928, 0.06291278451681137, -0.025848262012004852, 0.0014535896480083466, -0.03327808901667595, 0.055554281920194626, 4.3630789150483906e-05, 0.09705198556184769, -0.006062924396246672, -0.03301816061139107, 0.018306097015738487, 0.01676638424396515, -0.007568773347884417, -0.021967539563775063, 0.01013687439262867, 0.007737162057310343, 0.022417083382606506, 0.019427234306931496, 2.3777706701366697e-06, -0.030992833897471428, 0.035855937749147415, -0.05754249542951584, 0.037241991609334946, -0.035267386585474014, 0.12412765622138977, 0.014607532881200314, 0.022159429267048836, 0.011263813823461533, 0.003194924211129546, -0.006188421510159969, 0.029789220541715622, 0.08806609362363815, 0.004707988351583481, 0.011093009263277054, 0.0011494692880660295, -0.06609412282705307, -0.047455862164497375, 3.56608179572504e-05, -0.008799184113740921, -0.0031549755949527025, 0.021682122722268105, 0.007280996069312096, 0.028520239517092705, -0.04329927638173103, -0.051047712564468384, 0.026892412453889847, 0.034083250910043716, 0.043887440115213394, -0.023305894806981087, 0.04318740591406822, 0.003551372792571783, 0.01089001540094614, 0.019083814695477486, 0.07491284608840942, 0.016574257984757423, -0.04159896820783615, -0.01109889056533575, -0.00785489659756422, -0.010463889688253403, 0.048947837203741074, -0.02285991795361042, 0.003653497900813818, 0.012051619589328766, 0.05160348117351532, -0.006894005462527275, 0.03343254700303078, 0.0012394239893183112, 0.027721893042325974, -0.027012137696146965, -0.04905920475721359, -0.010087314061820507, 0.009618817828595638, 0.00669645331799984, -0.059383876621723175, -0.002923930762335658, -0.07135393470525742, 0.030612895265221596, 0.0066899824887514114, 0.008873111568391323, 0.0033153039403259754, -0.028833970427513123, -0.05841278284788132, 0.026743780821561813, -0.07822287082672119, 0.05423930659890175, 0.016847582533955574, -0.02931704930961132, 0.026320282369852066, 0.0001808979723136872, -0.013416536152362823, -0.027906376868486404, 0.06346222013235092, -0.06377611309289932, -0.03143317624926567, -0.0836346447467804, -0.028995724394917488, -0.03981003537774086, 0.04370519146323204, 0.006463025230914354, -0.06789810955524445, -0.035772185772657394, -0.0012044982286170125, -0.031041566282510757, -0.02653198502957821, -0.04345954954624176, 0.07422765344381332, -0.02859383635222912, 0.0001628826285013929, -0.04801524430513382, -0.015338653698563576, -0.06995273381471634, 0.04031016677618027, -0.030337873846292496, -0.05542074143886566, 0.03479596599936485, 0.017013169825077057, 0.013725394383072853, -0.006296215578913689, 0.009958602488040924, 0.035016704350709915, 0.02601252868771553, -0.02470621094107628, -0.024087414145469666, -0.03651993349194527, 0.01581750251352787, 0.008826548233628273, -0.027032136917114258, -0.04825057461857796, 0.02521783858537674, -0.052253130823373795, 0.01634010300040245, -0.05405063554644585, -0.0034856342244893312, 0.02121107466518879, -0.041059140115976334, 0.08780098706483841, -0.03695445880293846, -0.007120619993656874, 0.020639384165406227, 0.030776286497712135, -0.007129281293600798, 0.008557026274502277, 0.043494876474142075, 0.027365069836378098, 0.02189400978386402, 0.002841741079464555, -0.012187817133963108, -0.033811625093221664, -0.03388462960720062, -0.04563243314623833, -0.04741061478853226, -0.031609613448381424, -0.03846178203821182, 0.0928574800491333, -0.005795926786959171, 0.03552936762571335, -0.00991042423993349, -0.022111549973487854, 0.03953435271978378, 0.11221904307603836, 0.0006090124952606857, 0.07469960302114487, 0.05002213269472122, 0.05130670219659805, -0.0022799160797148943, 0.041856374591588974, 0.02934693545103073, 0.018311962485313416, 0.03779104724526405, -0.023936744779348373, -0.029051195830106735, 0.025246934965252876, -0.03872847929596901, 0.020502859726548195, -0.016813024878501892, -0.029673751443624496, -0.0367189384996891, -0.027461295947432518, 0.024731112644076347, 0.017599301412701607, 0.007264143321663141, 0.01661822572350502, 0.025855574756860733, -0.014029893092811108, -0.02500773034989834, 0.007723009213805199, -0.014464350417256355, 0.05387149751186371, 0.021793683990836143, -0.02258925698697567, -0.0052086482755839825, -0.049485478550195694, 0.034354984760284424, 0.031020095571875572, -0.026294218376278877, 0.01386528741568327, -0.021988119930028915, -0.022720569744706154, 0.03339371085166931, -0.04319852590560913, 0.009028955362737179, 0.03455699607729912, -0.07792765647172928, 0.05076783150434494, 0.010235516354441643, 0.016851071268320084, -0.008596648462116718, 0.042254459112882614, 0.003158114617690444, 0.014588624238967896, 0.009233053773641586, 0.04604969546198845, 0.018869685009121895, 0.026235882192850113, -0.019049927592277527, 0.004774408880621195, 0.018078822642564774, -0.06844906508922577, -0.04205382615327835, 0.09878766536712646, -0.06455880403518677, 0.029855474829673767, 0.036646950989961624, -0.11763747036457062, 0.003495307406410575, 0.04630773141980171, 0.011485384777188301, -0.018904883414506912, 0.058614518493413925, -0.03292852267622948, 0.06514067947864532, -0.0311245396733284, -0.013940587639808655, -0.02821565791964531, 0.042247213423252106, 0.02988170087337494, 0.03451522812247276, 0.008335046470165253, 0.03654712811112404, -0.026148688048124313, -0.00472443038597703, 0.010717750526964664, 0.04636014625430107, 0.00790282804518938, 0.016407761722803116, -0.004177285358309746, 0.002285565249621868, -0.02906559407711029, -0.03913802653551102, -0.06413048505783081, 0.01605883426964283, -0.07339312881231308, 0.010733136907219887, 0.00015060232544783503, -0.04491295665502548, 0.042148407548666, -0.020631741732358932, -0.03414054214954376, -0.0072366041131317616, -0.00469551095739007, 0.00813040416687727, -0.03748283162713051, -0.007100741844624281, 0.029864776879549026, -0.034438394010066986, -0.01177171990275383, -0.01099509559571743, 0.018530812114477158, -0.046480998396873474, 0.08353053033351898, 0.006486454512923956, -0.0005634172121062875, 0.03690161928534508, -0.015451285056769848, -0.03127596154808998, -0.011292978189885616, 0.0009639084455557168, -0.043835751712322235, 0.015184236690402031, 0.03802007809281349, 0.04841795563697815, 0.011102856136858463, 0.04371466860175133, 0.03549961373209953, 0.05627082660794258, -0.014685362577438354, -0.015745490789413452, -0.015937862917780876, 0.01588357239961624, 0.005210635252296925, -0.0014194779796525836, -0.032843854278326035, -0.003901527263224125, 0.03220671787858009, 0.043346647173166275, 0.0008429315639659762, -0.024743393063545227, 0.06423778086900711, -0.014678152278065681, -0.009259666316211224, -0.010965753346681595, 0.018145445734262466, -0.023382753133773804, 0.006418278440833092, -0.000510211568325758, 0.03901907801628113, 0.049954988062381744, 0.008244658820331097, -0.004664639011025429, -0.013749906793236732, -0.04529779776930809, -0.02322559431195259, 0.06707218289375305, -0.037478864192962646, 0.03359400853514671, 0.04567157104611397, -0.01259827334433794, -0.0017280004685744643, -0.034612152725458145, -0.003557358169928193, -0.014966288581490517, 0.029720410704612732, -0.01655450277030468, -0.012023720890283585, 0.0024005197919905186, -0.004612787161022425, -0.019163040444254875, -0.02829708717763424, -0.03522701933979988, 0.011207250878214836, -0.0060385786928236485, 0.001219285186380148, -0.037894316017627716, -0.02990896813571453, -0.0034955397713929415, -0.003964611794799566, 0.006477415096014738, -0.032059479504823685, -0.03165348619222641, 0.042296480387449265, 0.05448760837316513, 0.008598328568041325, 0.0031836098060011864, 0.03430305793881416, 0.028249133378267288, 0.02835642732679844, -0.07652472704648972, 0.005080406554043293, -0.0738544687628746, 0.017535317689180374, -0.0029856576584279537, -0.061060357838869095, 0.03126007691025734, -0.007339418865740299, 0.025255611166357994, -0.053440503776073456, -0.008284811861813068, 0.0641074925661087, 0.04128478839993477, -0.0077806320041418076, 0.040725093334913254, -0.001954753417521715, -0.011976168490946293, 0.03678521141409874, -0.003766085486859083, -0.08213118463754654, -0.03988291695713997, 0.005065936595201492, -0.022190069779753685, -0.01472497172653675, -0.0579100139439106, -0.024416182190179825, -0.0654657632112503, -0.001772101386450231, -0.01918722130358219, -0.03692987561225891, -0.02246393822133541, 0.014766049571335316, -0.028367582708597183, 0.016746386885643005, -0.0021431453060358763, -0.04695936664938927, -0.024652687832713127, -0.006237287539988756, 0.005482343956828117, -0.006360155064612627, -0.015225004404783249, 0.01762738637626171, -0.0680244192481041, 0.0456702820956707, -0.06748823821544647, 0.08872291445732117, -0.023482268676161766, -0.012164504267275333, -0.04044885188341141, -0.02766077220439911, -0.014413443394005299, 0.0018756870413199067, -0.010672793723642826, -0.014525863341987133, 0.005997678730636835, -0.0315527468919754, 0.04181067645549774, -0.04473651573061943, -0.021241014823317528, 0.01415871363133192, 0.06601928919553757, -0.0048089162446558475, -0.019891032949090004, -0.07612328231334686, 0.03646578639745712, -0.010906265117228031, 0.053066618740558624, 0.07367175817489624, -0.030037542805075645, 0.006353486329317093, -0.009623213671147823, -0.006158971693366766, -0.008032985031604767, -0.001604112796485424, -0.031730182468891144, -0.0324753038585186, 0.03373017534613609, -0.04184200242161751, -0.039367303252220154, -0.006044092122465372, 0.030256612226366997, 0.04002401977777481, -0.011630655266344547, -0.04537595808506012, -0.03001878410577774, -0.08133392781019211, 0.02314046211540699, -0.004005823750048876, 0.031335532665252686, 0.022421052679419518, -8.118480036500841e-05, 0.06395718455314636, -0.02720831334590912, -0.021565986797213554, 0.012147458270192146, -0.029360776767134666, -0.04116453975439072, -0.02694675698876381, -0.012423690408468246, 0.0034745968878269196, 0.008297965861856937, 0.008027708157896996, -0.05586868152022362, 0.047686781734228134, 0.041737377643585205, -0.01836329884827137, 0.016144337132573128, 0.008372895419597626, 0.01835007406771183, 0.013549109920859337, 0.03737594187259674, 0.0024237215984612703, 0.042298898100852966, -0.003906543366611004, -0.016446316614747047, -0.01566721871495247, 0.01830006018280983, 0.013858537189662457, -0.04472046718001366, -0.02196931466460228, 0.020633462816476822, -0.0586712546646595, -0.04569542035460472, -0.015493705868721008, 0.003261820413172245, -0.02821579948067665, -0.017527244985103607, 0.00110744615085423, 0.05738528072834015, 0.019715048372745514, -0.04262180253863335, -0.0633033812046051, -0.006817403249442577, 0.032972101122140884, 0.0669354498386383, 0.011983719654381275, 0.018492812290787697, 0.02736685425043106, -0.0656842514872551, 0.005247633904218674, -0.02769812010228634, -0.030667433515191078, -0.019354164600372314, 0.02524888515472412, 0.0034767240285873413, 0.0077767097391188145, 0.034784793853759766, -0.009948854334652424, -0.03574659302830696, 0.03718214109539986, 0.04689783602952957, -0.06596506386995316, -4.883176734438166e-05, 0.053201913833618164, 0.05995164439082146, -0.07120098918676376, -0.026013454422354698, 0.005948656238615513, 0.017196351662278175, 0.01758463867008686, 0.02703009359538555, -0.06875260174274445, -0.011635923758149147, 0.0253883246332407, -0.017452538013458252, -0.007361362222582102, -0.016234222799539566, -0.031068600714206696, -0.061436206102371216, 0.044488295912742615, 0.04404914751648903, -0.027091361582279205, -0.008845524862408638, 0.02257469855248928, 0.031949568539857864, 0.049687739461660385, 0.0205409936606884, 0.0509759895503521, -0.0619746670126915, -0.044564004987478256, 0.05784841999411583, 0.010920235887169838, 0.032100971788167953, 0.03655317425727844, 0.039236459881067276, 0.022419555112719536, 0.026422174647450447, 0.00023720241733826697, -0.020715143531560898, 0.009772137738764286, -0.03234397619962692, 0.0018702863017097116, -0.021618742495775223, -6.360511770223086e-33, -0.04343121126294136, -0.029228366911411285, -0.00646628625690937, -0.02271704562008381, -0.04968732222914696, 0.01831088773906231, -0.04341078922152519, -0.014042677357792854, 0.0006717267096973956, 0.039479147642850876, 0.024302709847688675, -0.004684625659137964, -0.005563066340982914, -0.008538687601685524, 0.02339259348809719, 0.01848519593477249, 0.013143478892743587, 0.01752837747335434, -0.010199492797255516, -0.017068278044462204, 0.06228923052549362, 0.0341511033475399, 0.0696297287940979, -0.05894337221980095, -0.0516464039683342, 0.027261311188340187, 0.020272264257073402, -0.03328753262758255, 0.06666170060634613, 0.024137062951922417, -0.024103665724396706, 0.03692316263914108, 0.025682765990495682, 0.029541321098804474, 0.004018669482320547, 0.02303129993379116, -0.052581656724214554, -0.07521520555019379, 0.015131514519453049, -0.008115467615425587, -0.007845715619623661, -0.01224604994058609, 0.07812899351119995, -0.003095781896263361, 0.016031481325626373, -0.018855687230825424, 0.08033747225999832, 0.006519659422338009, 0.011150275357067585, -0.028466390445828438, -0.08594344556331635, -0.005922168493270874, -0.03532641381025314, -0.03472526744008064, 0.015371362678706646, 9.559113095747307e-05, -0.00994912814348936, 0.07222254574298859, -0.0810241773724556, 0.01138745341449976, -0.042759157717227936, -0.011863501742482185, 0.0009883642196655273, -0.016339758411049843, 0.02298133634030819, 0.10917574912309647, 0.02225300669670105, -0.04013309255242348, -0.04419313371181488, 0.013738822191953659, 0.055974215269088745, 0.02472209930419922, 0.029260745272040367, 0.01691005565226078, 0.07343314588069916, -0.04194865748286247, -0.012098560109734535, -0.0021663799416273832, 0.023515857756137848, 0.01699872501194477, 0.02574850246310234, -0.007680296897888184, -0.02277711033821106, 0.021077286452054977, -0.024906637147068977, -0.017013249918818474, -0.012221827171742916, -0.044429078698158264, 0.005627946928143501, -0.050964925438165665, 0.0006200740463100374, 0.04691431298851967, -0.017112696543335915, -0.03463725000619888, -0.017194034531712532, -0.05706286430358887, 0.0047744219191372395, 0.009660787880420685, 0.013415340334177017, 0.011004623025655746, -0.03392023220658302, -0.02503984048962593, -0.004352486226707697, 0.010759701952338219, 0.041750844568014145, 0.006457007955759764, 0.03367718309164047, -0.008948278613388538, -0.04719388857483864, -0.032480496913194656, -0.01467931643128395, -0.06949146836996078, -0.01944095455110073, -0.010042764246463776, 0.00636606989428401, 0.03749806806445122, -0.017643114551901817, 0.009158806875348091, 0.028711451217532158, -0.032100021839141846, -0.047946225851774216, 0.029732897877693176, -0.03243217244744301, 0.04438989236950874, -0.044649552553892136, 0.0006378748803399503, -0.07284056395292282, -0.03207181394100189, 0.061484210193157196, -0.07569517940282822, -0.01794872060418129, -0.025052418932318687, 2.9856317951271194e-07, 0.006773542147129774, 0.01515558548271656, 0.018717782571911812, 0.004129110369831324, -0.005795698147267103, 0.028448030352592468, 0.007916758768260479, 0.05869535729289055, -0.0350443534553051, -0.0036801209207624197, 0.02638416551053524, 0.026145024225115776, -0.007400090340524912, 0.00903657078742981, -0.1236947551369667, 0.08410372585058212, -0.07722645252943039, -0.007629901170730591, -0.05588775500655174, -0.02200516127049923, 0.07324741780757904, 0.05862890183925629, 0.08333227783441544, -0.01957610994577408, 0.02310909889638424, -0.032134927809238434, 0.024856748059391975, -0.06488122045993805, 0.05011320486664772, 0.012640029191970825, 0.029474280774593353, 0.013463000766932964, -0.018557561561465263, -0.013712714426219463, 0.05712929368019104, 0.01758326217532158, 0.03181346133351326, -0.029429379850625992, -0.019939469173550606, -0.017378732562065125, -0.015177357941865921, -0.0459538958966732, -0.01282172929495573, -0.07320530712604523, 0.03239348158240318, -0.06054004281759262, -0.04436424747109413, -0.05616845190525055, 0.04858638346195221, 0.03229561075568199, 0.0862039104104042, 0.020705752074718475, -0.03237564116716385, 0.004241918213665485, 0.029346084222197533, -0.01114103477448225, 0.00892788078635931, -0.08275946229696274, 0.06694886833429337, 0.03493758663535118, -0.022880729287862778, 0.04782208427786827, -0.005342212971299887, -0.017572809010744095, 0.0031304501462727785, -0.07773392647504807, -0.002483404939994216, 2.1774173180185677e-34, -0.003810233436524868, 0.013739476911723614, 0.0003513903357088566, 0.03908475860953331, 0.023311546072363853, 0.004395054653286934, 0.05304417759180069, 0.0065538156777620316, 0.0030126639176160097, 0.001258627395145595, -0.01722635142505169]
650
650
['Danushka Bollegala', 'Kohei Hayashi', 'Ken-ichi Kawarabayashi']
1709.06671v1
Distributed word embeddings have shown superior performances in numerous Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks. However, their performances vary significantly across different tasks, implying that the word embeddings learnt by those methods capture complementary aspects of lexical semantics. Therefore, we believe that it is important to combine the existing word embeddings to produce more accurate and complete \emph{meta-embeddings} of words. For this purpose, we propose an unsupervised locally linear meta-embedding learning method that takes pre-trained word embeddings as the input, and produces more accurate meta embeddings. Unlike previously proposed meta-embedding learning methods that learn a global projection over all words in a vocabulary, our proposed method is sensitive to the differences in local neighbourhoods of the individual source word embeddings. Moreover, we show that vector concatenation, a previously proposed highly competitive baseline approach for integrating word embeddings, can be derived as a special case of the proposed method. Experimental results on semantic similarity, word analogy, relation classification, and short-text classification tasks show that our meta-embeddings to significantly outperform prior methods in several benchmark datasets, establishing a new state of the art for meta-embeddings.
Think Globally, Embed Locally --- Locally Linear Meta-embedding of Words
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1709.06671v1
Title Think Globally Embed Locally Locally Linear Metaembedding Words Summary Distributed word embeddings shown superior performance numerous Natural Language Processing NLP task However performance vary significantly across different task implying word embeddings learnt method capture complementary aspect lexical semantics Therefore believe important combine existing word embeddings produce accurate complete emphmetaembeddings word purpose propose unsupervised locally linear metaembedding learning method take pretrained word embeddings input produce accurate meta embeddings Unlike previously proposed metaembedding learning method learn global projection word vocabulary proposed method sensitive difference local neighbourhood individual source word embeddings Moreover show vector concatenation previously proposed highly competitive baseline approach integrating word embeddings derived special case proposed method Experimental result semantic similarity word analogy relation classification shorttext classification task show metaembeddings significantly outperform prior method several benchmark datasets establishing new state art metaembeddings Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.012094358913600445, 0.01215886790305376, 0.007214866112917662, 0.071959488093853, -0.008110486902296543, -0.003673032158985734, 0.007556939963251352, -0.031710900366306305, -0.05535687133669853, -0.05274314433336258, -0.04593686759471893, 0.07059600949287415, 0.0120661910623312, -0.016054438427090645, 0.02952653542160988, -0.054155588150024414, 0.027520086616277695, 0.0687524825334549, -0.03847990557551384, -0.007229850627481937, 0.02593708038330078, 0.010260580107569695, 0.01372524257749319, 0.054249830543994904, 0.0244582686573267, 0.014551742933690548, 0.04114609956741333, -0.05394567549228668, 0.03178246691823006, -0.021196089684963226, -0.010299570858478546, 0.01729658804833889, 0.05197672173380852, 0.0156265776604414, 2.1971488877170486e-06, -0.009509229101240635, 0.0057255784049630165, -0.01755269430577755, 0.017231334000825882, -0.055211227387189865, 0.03795146569609642, -0.049385130405426025, 0.0126753319054842, 0.027386663481593132, -0.039277490228414536, -0.09930738806724548, 0.061431411653757095, 0.031363870948553085, 0.0003192841832060367, 0.02308405190706253, -0.02134069800376892, -0.03746712580323219, -0.029340988025069237, -0.01644863374531269, -0.02170565165579319, 0.028138846158981323, 0.003046612022444606, -0.019069137051701546, 0.016876831650733948, 0.012470810674130917, -0.056963976472616196, 0.01534261368215084, -0.018048299476504326, -0.00373400142416358, 0.03262459486722946, 0.0572250559926033, -0.013290498405694962, 0.020976535975933075, 0.005954942665994167, 0.11478602886199951, -0.03329076990485191, -0.008791434578597546, -0.02803352102637291, -0.01948390156030655, -0.02154574915766716, 0.05106699839234352, -0.018535984680056572, 0.010072334669530392, 0.00870531890541315, 0.047284048050642014, -0.016105899587273598, 0.04950636997818947, 0.05778941139578819, 0.019260099157691002, -0.03791685402393341, 0.05479031428694725, 0.03383301943540573, -0.0448886938393116, -0.0018082576571032405, -0.016219142824411392, -0.03935166075825691, 0.03266952931880951, -0.010444317013025284, 0.0005132677033543587, 0.007306536193937063, 0.020165689289569855, -0.034745633602142334, -0.06857972592115402, 0.0240700151771307, -0.07291606813669205, 0.08347001671791077, 0.018435141071677208, -0.009463750757277012, 0.05333857610821724, -0.04515568166971207, 0.020399410277605057, -0.0004138935182709247, 0.042160384356975555, -0.04475774988532066, -0.00469051580876112, -0.07227998971939087, -0.0005452524637803435, -0.0014611295191571116, 0.039222974330186844, -0.03526608273386955, -0.04991690069437027, -0.027966054156422615, 0.029224036261439323, -0.005785409826785326, 0.027208790183067322, 0.02162313461303711, 0.017388373613357544, 0.024650704115629196, -0.017884567379951477, 0.008899401873350143, 0.008167673833668232, -0.07691196352243423, 0.008911545388400555, -0.0533410869538784, 0.008889492601156235, 0.011962532065808773, 0.020458605140447617, 0.01472937036305666, -0.035606760531663895, -0.0004978924407623708, 0.0447252057492733, 0.06022459641098976, -0.07434316724538803, 0.01397263165563345, 0.03568705916404724, 0.004367142915725708, -0.017961397767066956, 0.010093116201460361, -0.05004127696156502, 0.037917360663414, -0.05023784190416336, -0.022133633494377136, 0.014997344464063644, 0.0006601969944313169, 0.0227226410061121, -0.017295705154538155, 0.12433348596096039, -0.051599714905023575, -0.020408902317285538, 0.014638889580965042, 0.009319295175373554, 0.029109284281730652, 0.020416175946593285, 0.03290940821170807, -0.0254666768014431, 0.046146001666784286, -0.03808687627315521, -0.010908760130405426, -0.02492314949631691, 0.02061239629983902, -0.03749948740005493, -0.018825095146894455, -0.0037019497249275446, 0.04233050346374512, 0.042929742485284805, 0.013114606030285358, 0.04580865427851677, -0.021260108798742294, -0.01862901635468006, 0.022121332585811615, 0.07411452382802963, 0.015616600401699543, -0.028269989416003227, 0.043957680463790894, 0.03595031425356865, -0.027136916294693947, -0.004852809943258762, -0.05635923892259598, 0.007918459363281727, -0.0037344719748944044, 0.0004621340485755354, 0.04250839352607727, 0.032277677208185196, -0.04344306141138077, 0.0199353639036417, -0.013443240895867348, -0.03032880276441574, -0.013324185274541378, -0.032439932227134705, 0.003892312292009592, 0.006479972042143345, -0.024386415258049965, -0.02051275037229061, 0.04993090406060219, -0.04865819215774536, -0.024504970759153366, 0.012292076833546162, -0.0004168945597484708, 0.011200767010450363, 0.04392130672931671, -0.02781796082854271, -0.017780160531401634, -0.03273539990186691, -0.004559991881251335, 0.05673127993941307, 0.004080077633261681, -0.02795475348830223, 0.007095262873917818, -0.0582883395254612, -0.023275062441825867, -0.015427577309310436, 0.0015191783895716071, 0.010205726139247417, -0.022181082516908646, 0.012740230187773705, 0.037311144173145294, -0.023310935124754906, 0.03011639602482319, 0.05728858709335327, -0.02780121937394142, -0.026987768709659576, 0.01794694922864437, 0.04891523718833923, 0.006209115032106638, -0.009863781742751598, -0.006093761418014765, 0.02020857483148575, 0.039160050451755524, -0.06327594816684723, -0.04116923734545708, 0.05140674114227295, -0.029126429930329323, -0.07539993524551392, 0.044624052941799164, -0.05309809371829033, 0.03565794229507446, 0.02665591612458229, -0.03010871447622776, -0.027311518788337708, -0.028836242854595184, 0.0021818894892930984, 0.07465878129005432, -0.039337433874607086, 0.012415117584168911, -0.03151621297001839, 0.05372846871614456, -0.029211608693003654, 0.06736091524362564, -0.0350455716252327, 0.0543588288128376, -0.009106502868235111, 0.0015457827830687165, 0.05135035142302513, 0.045315008610486984, -0.0475851334631443, 0.045099686831235886, 0.026178522035479546, 0.019124483689665794, 0.016431545838713646, -0.004163072444498539, -0.03125902637839317, -0.005928477738052607, -0.0638553574681282, 0.008819974958896637, 0.008912409655749798, 0.009288673289120197, 0.025851359590888023, 0.016634682193398476, -0.006289233919233084, -0.012559168040752411, 0.010593809187412262, 0.010759659111499786, -0.00048675990547053516, 0.05324971675872803, 0.06022307649254799, -0.007528169080615044, 0.00545646483078599, -0.05714760720729828, -0.026653386652469635, -0.002124316757544875, 0.08337870240211487, -0.03547562658786774, -0.020635340362787247, 0.00901468563824892, -0.023870417848229408, -0.023893997073173523, -0.005591189954429865, -0.012102503329515457, -0.021627599373459816, -0.015239989385008812, -0.04329362511634827, 0.052100878208875656, -0.007095111068338156, 0.023746926337480545, -0.0110060665756464, 0.07183421403169632, 0.01961149089038372, -0.0312472116202116, -0.024353966116905212, -0.005058431997895241, 0.0454709529876709, -0.006545792333781719, 0.053758908063173294, -0.043170347809791565, 0.035715654492378235, 0.030178727582097054, -0.01212177611887455, -0.033226583153009415, 0.04697748273611069, -0.022097628563642502, -0.01497464720159769, -0.04292037710547447, 0.015452194027602673, -0.02343916893005371, -0.021618757396936417, -0.031130963936448097, -0.0336492545902729, 0.04859823361039162, 0.0078009008429944515, 0.0015317278448492289, -0.040402792394161224, -0.03089890629053116, -0.01498999260365963, 0.0393972285091877, -0.03691259026527405, 0.012872478924691677, -0.05240326747298241, -0.011946283280849457, -0.020212186500430107, -0.03698620945215225, 0.023921487852931023, -0.029254106804728508, 0.013286723755300045, 0.027490107342600822, -0.0015380250988528132, -0.02053106389939785, -0.039371732622385025, -0.03886251151561737, -0.07698284089565277, -0.026649674400687218, -0.011426286771893501, 0.010545176453888416, -0.015963375568389893, -0.02528425119817257, -0.0155383525416255, -0.0231630839407444, -0.004721612203866243, -0.004737455397844315, -0.0029999963007867336, -0.00639029685407877, 0.026789670810103416, 0.04742841422557831, -0.010493269190192223, -0.016454748809337616, 0.06280846148729324, 0.04000743851065636, 0.014857769943773746, 0.02991490624845028, -0.008508491329848766, -0.053904786705970764, -0.03089234046638012, -0.013810344971716404, -0.053001195192337036, -0.0140676936134696, -0.030962591990828514, -0.016594259068369865, -0.021243421360850334, 0.01576283387839794, 0.10656939446926117, 0.05726761370897293, -0.04680045694112778, 0.009229561313986778, -0.014530345797538757, -0.02872857078909874, 0.03757109493017197, 0.018797677010297775, -0.02556268684566021, -0.02358352206647396, -0.014409923925995827, -0.023622862994670868, 0.03286082670092583, -0.02379673160612583, -0.008938467130064964, -0.09117602556943893, -0.012080502696335316, -0.009489450603723526, -0.012163928709924221, -0.057697150856256485, -0.058670543134212494, -0.002721050987020135, 0.013595315627753735, -0.0011081906268373132, -0.027119996026158333, -0.013675731606781483, -0.004866585601121187, -0.02815208211541176, -0.03983296826481819, -0.035288456827402115, 0.02573171816766262, -0.06555214524269104, 0.04653428867459297, 0.02618430182337761, 0.07515433430671692, -0.018857687711715698, -0.04771587625145912, 0.02093018963932991, -0.019113842397928238, -0.06476926058530807, -0.04586813226342201, 0.06755708158016205, -0.02418958768248558, -0.0010194723727181554, -0.01885220967233181, -0.007372228894382715, -0.04202181473374367, 0.011542696505784988, -0.00960356742143631, 0.09151014685630798, -0.004316350445151329, -0.010158966295421124, -0.06022186949849129, 0.010388169437646866, 0.016937410458922386, 0.02772100269794464, 0.028676366433501244, -0.025342518463730812, -0.002678408520296216, 0.02796838991343975, -0.03973086178302765, 0.03199579939246178, -0.03397193178534508, 0.01123838685452938, 0.010868783108890057, 0.035063181072473526, -0.09108734130859375, -0.060592252761125565, 0.023195523768663406, 0.05063403770327568, 0.022181905806064606, 0.019082142040133476, -0.035156555473804474, -0.04259364679455757, -0.10491636395454407, -0.021244311705231667, -0.006443486548960209, 0.01072773989289999, 0.012954605743288994, 0.03137652948498726, 0.09572490304708481, 0.009418658912181854, -0.017889000475406647, -0.0534871481359005, -0.026213370263576508, -0.027759160846471786, -0.05772440880537033, 0.027681702747941017, -0.010241440497338772, 0.015196964144706726, -0.049879733473062515, -0.011584877967834473, 0.09546343237161636, 0.010579944588243961, -0.021286603063344955, -0.017011113464832306, 0.07423242181539536, -0.008428609929978848, 0.016472626477479935, 0.025597339496016502, -0.014286892488598824, 0.031274162232875824, 0.014161104336380959, -0.0033378342632204294, 0.03930220752954483, -0.002755919238552451, 0.02097928896546364, -0.031243354082107544, 0.04245269298553467, -0.009585857391357422, 0.007036479189991951, -0.0616053082048893, -0.0509805865585804, -0.016662199050188065, -0.03222598508000374, -0.014726832509040833, 0.015348859131336212, 0.04356898367404938, 0.004581973422318697, -0.0009478930151090026, -0.019974207505583763, -0.03670461103320122, 0.00514714140444994, 0.04772087559103966, 0.059618156403303146, 0.0009421193972229958, 0.03295845165848732, -0.0421508364379406, 0.0716974288225174, -0.027963787317276, -0.025571905076503754, 0.004001469351351261, -0.01939963363111019, -0.0463283397257328, -0.0014096617233008146, 0.0066377222537994385, -0.02798435091972351, -0.04917362332344055, 0.062413107603788376, -0.029668521136045456, 0.03580767288804054, 0.005871830508112907, 0.049810990691185, 0.06585130840539932, -0.048208512365818024, -0.02007199078798294, 0.009215384721755981, 0.002482003066688776, -0.011721494607627392, 0.032359711825847626, -0.048133254051208496, -0.014007707126438618, 0.05608607456088066, -0.0004088928981218487, -0.041509006172418594, -0.017055822536349297, 0.05656009912490845, -0.0314023494720459, 0.0215286985039711, 0.04198209568858147, 0.0030480632558465004, -0.042465418577194214, 0.012318788096308708, -0.013645433820784092, 0.07213807851076126, -0.03376037999987602, 0.05809757858514786, -0.038790538907051086, -0.042831432074308395, 0.017747150734066963, 0.017899712547659874, -0.054877471178770065, 0.06531472504138947, -0.0076625654473900795, 0.020682314410805702, 0.016957813873887062, 0.0018308969447389245, -0.03951101377606392, 0.030741268768906593, 0.024118155241012573, -0.045038867741823196, -0.019379904493689537, -6.016086047960402e-33, -0.025706978514790535, -0.02633601240813732, 0.010304322466254234, -0.019196506589651108, -0.023611752316355705, -0.0013294897507876158, -0.016646074131131172, -0.011547884903848171, -0.044834770262241364, 0.026471847668290138, -0.02511763945221901, 0.02291981875896454, -0.00833863951265812, 0.01683419570326805, 0.013756057247519493, -0.03481560945510864, 0.006600575055927038, 0.01381104439496994, 0.011867031455039978, -0.016583390533924103, 0.0328129418194294, 0.05950888991355896, 0.07233480364084244, -0.05773784592747688, 0.012645120732486248, 0.017539918422698975, 0.03591340407729149, -0.004742009099572897, 0.02868684008717537, 0.05337619036436081, -0.04117961972951889, 0.08060566335916519, 0.032384857535362244, 0.02164524607360363, -0.029935775324702263, 0.01326540857553482, -0.04391412436962128, -0.059319790452718735, 0.006380046252161264, -0.03107459470629692, -0.03724738210439682, 0.009947323240339756, 0.008399296551942825, -0.0036806880962103605, 0.009441173635423183, -0.014053963124752045, 0.06754894554615021, -0.003376035951077938, -0.06220211833715439, 0.07104582339525223, -0.08172739297151566, 0.02294599637389183, 0.019373217597603798, 0.007905888371169567, 0.05768092721700668, -0.026651078835129738, 0.02769995667040348, 0.013598689809441566, -0.0380401574075222, 0.020734846591949463, -0.06384465843439102, 0.02451120875775814, 0.0016795133706182241, 0.014015940017998219, 0.050990380346775055, 0.07176278531551361, -0.0007318329880945385, -0.01085637602955103, 0.017683105543255806, 0.02013641968369484, 0.035340115427970886, 0.02595510706305504, 0.025078319013118744, 0.07674261182546616, 0.04698062688112259, -0.014762152917683125, -0.00544415507465601, 0.0043812645599246025, -0.0002281988417962566, 0.009699171409010887, 0.002951669041067362, 0.01849624514579773, -0.04430455341935158, -0.019155843183398247, -0.025528065860271454, -0.02225690893828869, -0.007092865649610758, -0.041167352348566055, 0.02329844795167446, 0.004847424104809761, -0.0038881744258105755, 0.01220725104212761, -0.004889362026005983, -0.045353420078754425, 0.009126083925366402, 0.04259830340743065, -9.849038178799674e-05, -0.031409941613674164, 0.012371666729450226, -0.0036748265847563744, -0.046213794499635696, -0.019390318542718887, -0.012653788551688194, 0.018560856580734253, -0.014504111371934414, 0.0029490049928426743, 0.0531347282230854, -0.005422599148005247, -0.06883615255355835, -0.010638699866831303, -0.0009184029186144471, -0.08615469187498093, -0.011955751106142998, -0.02141507714986801, 0.010591338388621807, 0.02762363664805889, -0.009384524077177048, 0.06084197014570236, 0.05295277386903763, -0.031835030764341354, 0.014428069815039635, -0.010745976120233536, 0.017737414687871933, 0.02474328689277172, 0.013659357093274593, 0.016550768166780472, -0.05666200444102287, 0.03460308909416199, 0.06727290898561478, -0.08176301419734955, 0.0012524011544883251, -0.06246769428253174, 2.824440059612243e-07, 0.04187355563044548, 0.003444322384893894, 0.020308012142777443, -0.04829803854227066, -0.024541212245821953, 0.010704098269343376, -0.007398271933197975, 0.04831907898187637, -0.061506640166044235, 0.026174204424023628, 0.04192259907722473, 0.019185185432434082, 0.015911057591438293, 0.0023623108863830566, -0.06051035225391388, 0.05746898055076599, -0.0862206220626831, -0.0038338506128638983, -0.027066050097346306, -0.03270617499947548, 0.049041830003261566, 0.10119389742612839, 0.07350181043148041, 0.006801998242735863, -0.031202703714370728, -0.05793406441807747, 0.03278178721666336, -0.03792168200016022, -0.014849454164505005, -0.01906447671353817, -0.07303968071937561, 0.013538113795220852, 0.004715433809906244, -0.013329369947314262, -0.028615741059184074, 0.06633984297513962, 0.06018195301294327, 0.02990621142089367, -0.0070548951625823975, 0.01875789277255535, -0.005075718741863966, -0.02665032632648945, 0.01520585734397173, 0.032139528542757034, 0.057557959109544754, -0.01885281875729561, -0.02771816775202751, -0.0697377398610115, 0.008155211806297302, 0.019414981827139854, 0.087583526968956, -0.032335925847291946, -0.009198825806379318, -0.009761683642864227, 0.0511392317712307, -0.016676727682352066, -0.013645083643496037, -0.1134430468082428, -0.02561800926923752, 0.014018789865076542, -0.025958215817809105, 0.011973442509770393, 0.0020259362645447254, -0.008705838583409786, 0.09618682414293289, -0.03533336892724037, 0.020536137744784355, 2.453422473236679e-34, 0.0040972186252474785, 0.023049281910061836, 0.009321531280875206, -0.0022382233291864395, -0.0018625268712639809, -0.023695752024650574, -0.01895824633538723, -0.044402047991752625, 0.04748939350247383, -0.04077793285250664, 0.003927875310182571]
651
651
['Bin Bi', 'Hao Ma']
1709.09749v1
Previous studies have demonstrated the empirical success of word embeddings in various applications. In this paper, we investigate the problem of learning distributed representations for text documents which many machine learning algorithms take as input for a number of NLP tasks. We propose a neural network model, KeyVec, which learns document representations with the goal of preserving key semantics of the input text. It enables the learned low-dimensional vectors to retain the topics and important information from the documents that will flow to downstream tasks. Our empirical evaluations show the superior quality of KeyVec representations in two different document understanding tasks.
KeyVec: Key-semantics Preserving Document Representations
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1709.09749v1
Title KeyVec Keysemantics Preserving Document Representations Summary Previous study demonstrated empirical success word embeddings various application paper investigate problem learning distributed representation text document many machine learning algorithm take input number NLP task propose neural network model KeyVec learns document representation goal preserving key semantics input text enables learned lowdimensional vector retain topic important information document flow downstream task empirical evaluation show superior quality KeyVec representation two different document understanding task Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.04206375405192375, -0.0009373161592520773, 0.021352212876081467, 0.03221099078655243, -0.022413088008761406, 0.015619372017681599, -0.0132781146094203, 0.039899419993162155, -0.010965495370328426, -0.0836675688624382, 0.008697493001818657, 0.010289817117154598, -0.008964930661022663, 0.0367455892264843, 0.0169996228069067, -0.04665815457701683, 0.06096040830016136, 0.018946092575788498, -0.028824424371123314, -0.0025549819692969322, 0.020083874464035034, 0.02290051430463791, 0.02128179371356964, 0.025916898623108864, -0.01457150001078844, -0.05768032371997833, -0.046986520290374756, -0.044817060232162476, -0.02462063357234001, 0.006525038275867701, -0.0047007957473397255, 0.004472361411899328, 0.03450607508420944, -0.0012963158078491688, 2.022685748670483e-06, 0.02581983059644699, -0.02654467336833477, -0.014858771115541458, 0.007122983690351248, 0.038106802850961685, 0.056090060621500015, -0.06426507979631424, 0.005391333252191544, 0.0033638067543506622, -0.03157849237322807, -0.06923108547925949, 0.03146476671099663, 0.09890659898519516, 0.055227771401405334, 0.04461638629436493, -0.027408696711063385, -0.07760005444288254, 0.047631654888391495, -0.004200498573482037, 0.004326913971453905, -0.03583689406514168, 0.006079816725105047, 0.006255489774048328, -0.007607309613376856, 0.04953572154045105, -0.013506528921425343, 0.047194454818964005, -0.0062153819017112255, -0.020937016233801842, 0.07036186754703522, 0.04712040722370148, -0.042778823524713516, -0.006014135666191578, 0.0016012025298550725, 0.07711213082075119, -0.02863745205104351, -0.0016051906859502196, 0.0008734569419175386, -0.00554650230333209, -0.03072146140038967, 0.05139909312129021, -0.04802973195910454, -0.032565128058195114, 0.007851086556911469, -0.002304568188264966, 0.03970444202423096, 0.004964932333678007, 0.011067790910601616, 0.005376315210014582, -0.0030667786486446857, -0.03848215937614441, -0.0015043300809338689, -0.0425909161567688, -0.018793271854519844, -0.03542904928326607, -0.0623607374727726, -0.0240167248994112, 0.0654527023434639, 0.01047716848552227, 0.05212900787591934, 0.019244857132434845, -0.007432965096086264, -0.055284880101680756, 0.030735231935977936, -0.16060058772563934, 0.0346868634223938, -0.022219153121113777, -0.014745227061212063, 0.033532172441482544, -0.06784038245677948, 0.045901574194431305, -0.015423718839883804, 0.042552947998046875, 0.0017830436117947102, 0.02567288838326931, -0.07098814100027084, -0.03775041177868843, -0.0020460747182369232, 0.08605417609214783, 0.023297755047678947, -0.05461907759308815, 0.013877707533538342, 0.04944530501961708, 0.021723229438066483, 0.05189364030957222, 0.012613780796527863, 0.0430251881480217, 0.020511459559202194, -0.014823965728282928, 0.0401122085750103, 0.04305236414074898, -0.048680875450372696, 0.016650758683681488, -0.04984813183546066, 0.016772305592894554, 0.022776994854211807, 0.012885738164186478, 0.040162548422813416, 0.027734961360692978, -0.024545961990952492, 0.022578854113817215, 0.025723962113261223, -0.003188157919794321, -0.04176852107048035, -0.03290463984012604, 0.01562926359474659, 5.134204911882989e-05, -0.006664539687335491, -0.04517723247408867, 0.028409132733941078, 0.006991386879235506, -0.03405149281024933, -0.008181167766451836, -0.025743573904037476, 0.017945671454072, -0.06749014556407928, 0.10607048124074936, 0.01342888455837965, -0.005683346651494503, 0.06633023917675018, 0.024303223937749863, 0.03738696873188019, 0.0031887725926935673, -0.0007335304981097579, 0.04160340875387192, 0.03623213246464729, -0.04603186249732971, -0.0029234637040644884, -0.03324580937623978, 0.023567697033286095, -0.04076819494366646, 0.01346847414970398, 0.01356888934969902, 0.013608591631054878, 0.04632755368947983, -0.004190351814031601, 0.05453033745288849, -0.01109912060201168, -0.03446444123983383, 0.056037455797195435, 0.11934066563844681, 0.042193200439214706, 0.04085814952850342, -0.02271171472966671, 0.03466694802045822, -0.00019295571837574244, 0.01814468577504158, -0.01983858272433281, 0.009598340839147568, 0.015792828053236008, -0.02370312623679638, -0.0053953309543430805, -0.04431905969977379, -0.027341380715370178, 0.009994293563067913, -0.0013785629998892546, -0.018657753244042397, -0.003374936291947961, -0.06089072301983833, 0.03984428569674492, -0.007313048467040062, -0.04638082906603813, 0.03863833099603653, 0.00678193848580122, -0.009541108272969723, -0.0031319279223680496, 0.01595531590282917, 0.020094281062483788, -0.005164371337741613, 0.0739721804857254, -0.008323964662849903, 0.005695524159818888, -0.052579570561647415, 0.0030384790152311325, -0.027691563591361046, 0.04529448598623276, -0.04821255803108215, -0.009764203801751137, -0.050722431391477585, -0.0188334658741951, -0.02317899838089943, -0.011300083249807358, 0.012871071696281433, -0.07242445647716522, 0.017417684197425842, 0.04871102795004845, -0.014165288768708706, 0.03538508713245392, 0.051788415759801865, 0.008555612526834011, -0.046464383602142334, -0.00793091207742691, 0.02773716300725937, 0.03486291691660881, 0.04719813913106918, 0.011281582526862621, 0.010260424576699734, 0.049068838357925415, -0.02706148847937584, -0.020522553473711014, -0.018884830176830292, -0.05478818342089653, -0.015612148679792881, 0.03144867345690727, -0.033977728337049484, 0.02973710559308529, 0.06254397332668304, -0.009138602763414383, -0.016748633235692978, 0.022874685004353523, -0.021746255457401276, 0.03458886966109276, -0.020916718989610672, 0.0018236527685075998, -0.0336618572473526, 0.021634722128510475, -0.0009930807864293456, 0.04779958724975586, -0.010638106614351273, 0.03198954090476036, -0.06612850725650787, -0.02675440162420273, 0.03081495687365532, 0.030877359211444855, -0.0033901275601238012, 0.057034626603126526, 0.01625024899840355, 0.024587078019976616, 0.006169138476252556, -0.015427062287926674, 0.0059740603901445866, 0.009710635058581829, -0.047168660908937454, 0.004970051348209381, -0.0005401617963798344, 0.0217971783131361, 0.03423255309462547, 2.8005386411678046e-05, 0.04468384012579918, -0.017457425594329834, -0.07295716553926468, -0.012673540972173214, -0.009957266971468925, 0.011773697100579739, 0.011630556546151638, 0.002039583632722497, 0.029160385951399803, 0.0023422434460371733, -0.028365109115839005, -0.0325859971344471, 0.05734127014875412, -0.011732775717973709, -0.042233362793922424, -0.038127318024635315, 0.052889902144670486, 0.0013097176561132073, 0.002259769942611456, 0.015964362770318985, -0.013396128080785275, -0.020023345947265625, -0.03308042138814926, 0.00011811427248176187, 0.021763883531093597, 0.027130575850605965, 0.013524504378437996, 0.03122788295149803, 0.0007816755096428096, -0.05464852601289749, -0.03339266777038574, -0.03939921036362648, 0.07588405907154083, 0.002623149426653981, 0.05502871796488762, 0.009993193671107292, 0.020458310842514038, 0.02885860949754715, 0.01476574782282114, -0.03133225440979004, -0.006971972994506359, -0.036378223448991776, -0.00398210296407342, -0.07936767488718033, -0.012471981346607208, 0.0019527208060026169, -0.027244562283158302, 0.005067930556833744, -0.006446714513003826, 0.062336720526218414, -0.004359922371804714, 0.01177795510739088, -0.06802286207675934, -0.022969065234065056, -0.0070375073701143265, 0.04041343554854393, -0.01737307943403721, 0.024651428684592247, -0.04304908588528633, -0.04352613911032677, -0.03847241401672363, 0.02612949348986149, 0.01294108759611845, -0.030403202399611473, 0.048301100730895996, 0.034541767090559006, 0.014401244930922985, -0.03133893758058548, -0.019625067710876465, -0.01593577116727829, -0.09017854183912277, -0.004634163808077574, -0.003290230641141534, 0.01386798731982708, 0.011409715749323368, -0.028295541182160378, 0.07165709882974625, -0.005899745970964432, 0.01795118860900402, -0.03449549153447151, -0.018625376746058464, -0.01639554835855961, 0.06522639095783234, 0.026074949651956558, -0.041495732963085175, -0.011906400322914124, 0.02162041887640953, 0.017833193764090538, 0.055365413427352905, 0.0036679753102362156, -0.010418380610644817, -0.039276089519262314, 0.0242511797696352, 0.00020549062173813581, -0.061493925750255585, -0.05111837759613991, -0.046622976660728455, -0.020286884158849716, -0.04010159149765968, 0.024149306118488312, 0.06934390217065811, 0.04365421459078789, -0.12241916358470917, -0.011178798973560333, -0.05205627158284187, -0.028233254328370094, -0.017781129106879234, 0.025303436443209648, -0.056097064167261124, 0.0028928322717547417, -0.005312829278409481, 0.026396745815873146, 0.03902005776762962, -0.041932813823223114, -0.0010788829531520605, -0.06253503262996674, 0.011440427973866463, 0.015627000480890274, 0.006584706716239452, -0.07433938980102539, -0.08383845537900925, -0.025622379034757614, 0.004769498482346535, 0.025889070704579353, 0.008716906420886517, 0.0055090757086873055, -0.01954798586666584, -0.001896425150334835, -0.019107703119516373, -0.027434810996055603, 0.014252755790948868, -0.04083392396569252, 0.046960752457380295, 0.04548083245754242, 0.06702522933483124, 0.008945231325924397, -0.022544212639331818, -0.018644247204065323, 0.011097929440438747, -0.027336282655596733, -0.027783136814832687, 0.03508727252483368, -0.037692226469516754, 0.028081081807613373, 0.006388408597558737, 0.03206879273056984, -0.05384725704789162, 0.0019573834724724293, -0.0041572959162294865, 0.08102717995643616, -0.04421146214008331, -0.02356858178973198, -0.04606373608112335, -0.016691792756319046, -0.01044602133333683, 0.041316330432891846, 0.032262496650218964, 0.00037048853118903935, -0.04430759325623512, -0.008520465344190598, 0.06890230625867844, 0.01313917525112629, -0.028823301196098328, 0.006070393603295088, -0.03265899419784546, -0.006367863621562719, -0.05861187353730202, -0.04366089031100273, 0.0027674303855746984, 0.003479868406429887, -0.0024445068556815386, 0.030141370370984077, 0.030184106901288033, -0.04599757865071297, -0.034014299511909485, -0.033600594848394394, 0.019591234624385834, 0.006012000143527985, 0.002340719336643815, 0.021951021626591682, 0.04746982455253601, 0.0006648502894677222, -0.010386674664914608, -0.05017302557826042, -0.015696296468377113, -0.02273118495941162, 0.010441424325108528, 0.0038154954090714455, 0.0036926385946571827, 0.019503001123666763, -0.03417370468378067, -0.09801793098449707, 0.05120151489973068, -0.0032652311492711306, -0.0691952109336853, -0.017430009320378304, 0.0006043522153049707, -0.006613725330680609, -0.008474952541291714, 0.027852308005094528, -0.03740478307008743, 0.016417086124420166, -0.04085414856672287, -0.017875822260975838, -0.014169341884553432, -0.011810151860117912, 0.01246311329305172, -0.010597347281873226, 0.0017961810808628798, 0.01672493666410446, 0.03568620979785919, -0.046397432684898376, 0.007311338093131781, -0.03227050602436066, -0.00501585379242897, -0.01821502484381199, 0.040543291717767715, 0.029234642162919044, -0.0319267101585865, -0.009324231185019016, -0.009877083823084831, 0.007939420640468597, 0.014160292223095894, 0.0013273959048092365, 0.041466835886240005, 0.059016820043325424, -0.001569574000313878, -0.008920599706470966, 0.03491424024105072, -0.0324348621070385, -0.013637937605381012, -0.015472264029085636, 0.02234506607055664, -0.07229704409837723, -0.002948714653030038, 0.018984060734510422, -0.020213698968291283, -0.04600970819592476, 0.03958478197455406, -0.07408776879310608, -0.03353570029139519, 0.003156183287501335, 0.004679601173847914, 0.05271488428115845, -0.033779777586460114, -0.030444331467151642, -0.015029916539788246, -0.012243618257343769, -0.017805060371756554, 0.025399556383490562, 0.012907265685498714, 0.0036432258784770966, 0.009193247184157372, 0.029212022200226784, -0.005188272800296545, -0.007291983813047409, 0.05472169816493988, 0.021884819492697716, 0.027672315016388893, -0.010571501217782497, -0.04150952771306038, -0.05491173639893532, 0.062221281230449677, 0.04255417361855507, 0.07728397846221924, -0.03621245175600052, 0.005968455690890551, -0.020690862089395523, -0.027878621593117714, 0.03473690152168274, -0.025633491575717926, -0.020367462188005447, 0.0250047966837883, 0.0028278694953769445, 0.04382729530334473, 0.03110072948038578, -0.015855230391025543, -0.07270064204931259, 0.02630847692489624, -0.04910237342119217, -0.05351279675960541, -0.03212667256593704, -5.560259093412274e-33, 0.002827704418450594, -0.0019252834608778358, -0.03607134521007538, 0.03517472743988037, 0.005956246517598629, 0.03348885104060173, -0.03730079531669617, -0.03718755021691322, -0.023738229647278786, 0.0065707010217010975, -0.03737325221300125, 0.029242685064673424, 0.003721152665093541, -0.028272809460759163, 0.03685219958424568, -0.0069212531670928, 0.02206600084900856, -0.03657202795147896, 0.03395804762840271, 0.039391569793224335, 0.04761956259608269, 0.03828935697674751, 0.07532186061143875, -0.09291338920593262, 0.035098686814308167, -0.00732117285951972, 0.022599024698138237, -0.04259626939892769, 0.057832736521959305, 0.026715878397226334, -0.03673641383647919, 0.03048490174114704, 0.05703083053231239, -0.028751013800501823, -0.040894147008657455, 0.057145506143569946, -0.07634390145540237, -0.02650570496916771, -0.02409566380083561, 0.025441167876124382, -0.01700776256620884, -0.023423681035637856, 0.05319390445947647, -0.0010659312829375267, 0.042994800955057144, 0.006389541085809469, 0.047599855810403824, 0.010687502101063728, -0.099542997777462, -0.01865995302796364, -0.04211416468024254, 0.035013023763895035, -0.016179250553250313, 0.01135038211941719, 0.04734600707888603, -0.0025610649026930332, 0.04340681806206703, 0.0056280652061104774, -0.0792977511882782, -0.013536940328776836, -0.046134378761053085, 0.029651692137122154, 0.013726519420742989, 0.012091981247067451, 0.008772410452365875, 0.05619579181075096, 0.026494594290852547, -0.02793094888329506, -0.03234933316707611, 0.04075486585497856, 0.028633765876293182, 0.028391072526574135, 0.0404818132519722, 0.04648361727595329, 0.04280424490571022, -0.048667602241039276, -0.02965906448662281, 0.025282159447669983, 0.029393907636404037, 0.03610759228467941, 0.015020379796624184, 0.03534834459424019, -0.04014114663004875, -0.016361352056264877, -0.01636049710214138, -0.008502911776304245, -0.02793651632964611, -0.04668265953660011, -0.0036204911302775145, -0.02042987383902073, -0.012951337732374668, 0.005616718903183937, 0.03268257901072502, -0.07319913059473038, -0.017267899587750435, 0.04889839515089989, 0.009078062139451504, 0.019911522045731544, -0.014263744466006756, -0.014830720610916615, -0.05372612178325653, -0.029600143432617188, -0.010515015572309494, -0.029955487698316574, 0.00832122191786766, -0.01063318457454443, 0.016553550958633423, -0.006308752112090588, -0.022806953638792038, -0.0336378812789917, 0.018437184393405914, -0.08188456296920776, 0.022484013810753822, 0.05663694813847542, 0.0344836600124836, -0.022449824959039688, 0.02542208507657051, 0.03379793465137482, 0.03973203897476196, 0.020188452675938606, 0.034105733036994934, -0.050295110791921616, 0.024851690977811813, 0.04480684921145439, -0.02877045050263405, -0.0014538440154865384, -0.07480566203594208, 0.011390783824026585, 0.0748792290687561, -0.03198238089680672, 0.007285011000931263, 0.008360653184354305, 2.5212975174326857e-07, 0.03812805563211441, 0.04316700994968414, 0.0089905159547925, -0.04754571616649628, -0.004372232593595982, 0.03549150004982948, 0.019538886845111847, 0.05513051152229309, -0.05468109995126724, -0.04641386866569519, 0.031852904707193375, 0.005611431319266558, 0.02896891161799431, 0.029303686693310738, -0.09965164214372635, -0.017722567543387413, -0.09281294047832489, 0.027938425540924072, -0.03703014552593231, 0.022665400058031082, 0.07710463553667068, 0.08596165478229523, 0.028306089341640472, -0.008759429678320885, -0.00583958625793457, -0.014794454909861088, 0.020613238215446472, 0.021656742319464684, -0.005219599232077599, -0.017982015386223793, 0.020595431327819824, 0.018714506179094315, -0.004081623163074255, -0.013010785914957523, -0.0288641769438982, 0.0450170561671257, 0.02139306254684925, 0.05004660412669182, -0.04536890983581543, -0.006865240167826414, -0.013891561888158321, -0.06440997123718262, -0.007035501766949892, -0.03989217430353165, 0.08247178792953491, -0.0030356254428625107, -0.04773150011897087, -0.06719832867383957, -0.0047281221486628056, 0.00646068062633276, 0.012898817658424377, 0.015549941919744015, -0.006718003191053867, 0.026877081021666527, 0.004606201313436031, -0.05455588921904564, 0.017789706587791443, -0.10238815099000931, 0.0034800907596945763, 0.013301881030201912, 0.009429723024368286, 0.033884529024362564, -0.019961940124630928, 0.013130582869052887, 0.10549841076135635, -0.0051642125472426414, -0.0017191186780110002, 2.215171579255339e-34, 0.017429407685995102, -0.01346274558454752, -0.01192000787705183, 0.061160068958997726, -0.00902376789599657, -0.0445539765059948, 0.01877523958683014, 0.019764937460422516, 0.01305399090051651, -0.05670899897813797, -0.02560482732951641]
652
652
['Shuai Tang', 'Hailin Jin', 'Chen Fang', 'Zhaowen Wang', 'Virginia R. de Sa']
1710.10380v2
Context information plays an important role in human language understanding, and it is also useful for machines to learn vector representations of language. In this paper, we explore an asymmetric encoder-decoder structure for unsupervised context-based sentence representation learning. As a result, we build an encoder-decoder architecture with an RNN encoder and a CNN decoder. We further combine a suite of effective designs to significantly improve model efficiency while also achieving better performance. Our model is trained on two different large unlabeled corpora, and in both cases transferability is evaluated on a set of downstream language understanding tasks. We empirically show that our model is simple and fast while producing rich sentence representations that excel in downstream tasks.
Exploring Asymmetric Encoder-Decoder Structure for Context-based Sentence Representation Learning
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1710.10380v2
Title Exploring Asymmetric EncoderDecoder Structure Contextbased Sentence Representation Learning Summary Context information play important role human language understanding also useful machine learn vector representation language paper explore asymmetric encoderdecoder structure unsupervised contextbased sentence representation learning result build encoderdecoder architecture RNN encoder CNN decoder combine suite effective design significantly improve model efficiency also achieving better performance model trained two different large unlabeled corpus case transferability evaluated set downstream language understanding task empirically show model simple fast producing rich sentence representation excel downstream task Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.031040281057357788, 0.012019283138215542, -0.020153719931840897, 0.10539435595273972, -0.011638340540230274, 0.0379156768321991, 0.016123764216899872, -0.021891169250011444, -0.071658194065094, -0.08328808844089508, -0.021733807399868965, -0.017984628677368164, -0.016857003793120384, 0.02559058926999569, -0.009070992469787598, -0.052885863929986954, 0.016558922827243805, 0.0006990280235186219, 0.0052687725983560085, -0.0011254975106567144, 0.0477183572947979, 0.010371913202106953, 0.007536375895142555, 0.04041743651032448, 0.01008067186921835, -0.0069245705381035805, -0.005994732957333326, 0.017464203760027885, 0.004165902268141508, -0.02893676981329918, 0.05466657131910324, 0.0349360853433609, 0.06263050436973572, -0.019124481827020645, 2.311928028575494e-06, -0.02766508236527443, -0.04160553589463234, -0.046190135180950165, -0.028559453785419464, -0.02814994566142559, 0.04388139024376869, -0.0895518884062767, -0.01451073493808508, 0.008780207484960556, -0.009782296605408192, 0.022404354065656662, 0.022758420556783676, 0.07684361189603806, 0.012720894068479538, 0.03612323850393295, -0.02017701230943203, -0.08662824332714081, -0.031268514692783356, -0.014025929383933544, -0.027089200913906097, -0.040789756923913956, 0.017623430117964745, -0.007554459385573864, -0.022384870797395706, 0.047528475522994995, -0.05281252786517143, 0.005786140915006399, 0.04977652430534363, -0.0010472893482074142, 0.011577224358916283, 0.034771811217069626, -0.00848443154245615, -0.00014954207290429622, -0.009536413475871086, 0.08284731209278107, -0.006828703451901674, -0.015500015579164028, -0.005905386991798878, 0.0023566519375890493, -0.007773237302899361, -0.02411189116537571, -0.018518934026360512, 0.05908483639359474, 0.002626235131174326, 0.046998150646686554, 0.02121974341571331, 0.05431797727942467, 0.007719242945313454, 0.016389399766921997, -0.005510910414159298, 0.013947835192084312, -0.005848018452525139, -0.017332660034298897, -0.029700295999646187, -0.00034144712844863534, -0.011576161719858646, -0.04607877880334854, 0.04063009098172188, 0.0052474853582680225, -2.093202419928275e-05, 0.005417997483164072, -0.017593350261449814, -0.05279276892542839, 0.02839062362909317, -0.09641177207231522, -0.042550839483737946, 0.010744419880211353, -0.03624056652188301, 0.01125898864120245, -0.011933687143027782, 0.06673948466777802, 0.008103099651634693, 0.017400039359927177, -0.06652320176362991, -0.01598416641354561, -0.04848828911781311, -0.0229936596006155, -0.062291596084833145, 0.05439987778663635, -0.06838801503181458, -0.04300090670585632, -0.06005930155515671, 0.017039427533745766, -0.017379682511091232, -0.04661902040243149, 0.0014731884002685547, 0.03536757081747055, -0.027470164000988007, 0.039741333574056625, 0.00973069854080677, 0.030837874859571457, -0.036313656717538834, 0.00892267283052206, 0.005470732226967812, -0.01922747679054737, 0.03492746502161026, 0.022034121677279472, 0.009225426241755486, -0.022587887942790985, -0.024360012263059616, 0.012179332785308361, 0.010278038680553436, -0.0305329579859972, -0.029327690601348877, -0.0024360509123653173, -0.05099257454276085, -0.039457812905311584, -0.013887133449316025, -0.049926191568374634, 0.016745850443840027, 0.00868401862680912, -0.015485910698771477, -0.002830101177096367, -0.014241109602153301, -0.00045968228369019926, 0.00549201900139451, 0.08141251653432846, 0.0010498757474124432, -0.02650008536875248, 0.010442572645843029, 0.011042909696698189, 0.08177562803030014, 0.07427012920379639, 0.02077617309987545, 0.02084451913833618, 0.01975930482149124, -0.0015991496620699763, -0.033646028488874435, -0.023696977645158768, -0.0016548880375921726, -0.037319883704185486, -0.038922931998968124, 0.0004592175828292966, 0.02810765616595745, 0.03204044699668884, 0.046978991478681564, 0.024038497358560562, -0.012867845594882965, 0.00900608766824007, -0.017129946500062943, 0.03319087252020836, 0.03402867540717125, 0.019860342144966125, 0.007904493249952793, 0.03229047358036041, -0.020403096452355385, 0.003019982250407338, -0.03219425305724144, 0.02364422380924225, -0.0026501312386244535, -0.02203325740993023, -0.037589557468891144, -0.0046542673371732235, -0.012877151370048523, -0.007913080975413322, 0.008717053569853306, -0.006380542181432247, 0.010095694102346897, 0.005475105717778206, 0.020348574966192245, 0.001823499915190041, -0.042098697274923325, -0.000780032598413527, 0.016887957230210304, -0.05406524986028671, -0.007382245268672705, 0.016362860798835754, -0.007503041531890631, 0.04418336600065231, 0.008053136989474297, -0.00948732253164053, 0.006766245700418949, -0.0018330131424590945, -0.012014485895633698, 0.019050000235438347, 0.003115295898169279, -0.016222454607486725, 0.031659819185733795, -0.07509279996156693, -0.02451297454535961, -0.02806798182427883, 0.010563439689576626, 0.024308744817972183, -0.06993737816810608, 0.017438432201743126, 0.024098088964819908, -0.007973099127411842, 0.00812508724629879, 0.03273351490497589, 0.018626179546117783, -0.005844880826771259, 0.03549300134181976, 0.0311790369451046, 0.025767939165234566, 0.032270144671201706, 0.006516460329294205, -0.012499788776040077, 0.04445703327655792, -0.05304927006363869, -0.0056123933754861355, 0.04132452607154846, -0.10491456091403961, -0.10644511133432388, -0.009866808541119099, -0.026696298271417618, 0.00390815082937479, 0.03613899275660515, -0.02439800277352333, -0.05615212395787239, 0.026318755000829697, -0.018608201295137405, 0.0842277780175209, -0.03833666443824768, 0.011797417886555195, 0.009218452498316765, 0.06160704046487808, -0.024320056661963463, 0.06933797150850296, 0.014114923775196075, 0.014912150800228119, -0.001453233533538878, 0.029572416096925735, 0.02438587322831154, -0.033761776983737946, 0.0022316735703498125, 0.012107450515031815, -0.018056223168969154, -0.028502579778432846, 0.034624192863702774, -0.03804245591163635, -0.018666880205273628, 0.016430234536528587, -0.08403974771499634, 0.0008498418028466403, -0.03307851031422615, 0.01314821932464838, 0.05502407252788544, 0.025380127131938934, 0.01238572783768177, -0.01631982997059822, -0.030140550807118416, 0.013666210696101189, -0.0009491686359979212, -0.007391809020191431, 0.03685193508863449, 0.009150627069175243, -0.04447918385267258, -0.007318784482777119, 0.0006354019278660417, -0.025101501494646072, 0.06146330013871193, 0.007464273367077112, -0.05868961289525032, -0.038768913596868515, 0.0660708025097847, 0.047359757125377655, -0.001430467702448368, -0.014937439002096653, -0.04837239906191826, -0.015807803720235825, 0.009278845973312855, 0.020793575793504715, 0.01486884243786335, 0.024516602978110313, 0.08862432837486267, 0.011242632754147053, 0.019958248361945152, -0.0012520139571279287, -0.0070769391022622585, -0.018034644424915314, 0.03553246706724167, -0.022459950298070908, 0.010168524459004402, 0.0020079214591532946, 0.041396431624889374, 0.02949182130396366, 0.020498001947999, -0.04040775075554848, -0.01243533007800579, -0.004081506282091141, -0.008876413106918335, -0.10161609947681427, -0.023040173575282097, -0.01580924354493618, 0.058728497475385666, -0.022332651540637016, 0.014985023997724056, 0.017292942851781845, 0.00023733434500172734, 0.0002831170568242669, -0.06830073148012161, -0.041580330580472946, -0.036028459668159485, 0.03916746377944946, 0.006921903695911169, 0.043851081281900406, 0.008585763163864613, -0.061428844928741455, -0.011851928196847439, 0.013856752775609493, -0.016371244564652443, -0.00853287149220705, 0.014917969703674316, -0.019489523023366928, 0.02017042227089405, -0.017942611128091812, -0.03843030333518982, -0.053778018802404404, -0.02819181978702545, -0.022883255034685135, 0.05509734898805618, 0.039876896888017654, 0.00010009462857851759, 0.021358661353588104, 0.006556787993758917, -0.02602386847138405, 0.009070695377886295, -0.016068752855062485, 0.012187954038381577, -0.0190261397510767, 0.051225464791059494, 0.03469831496477127, 0.018405519425868988, 0.007559158373624086, 0.00978825706988573, 0.036911677569150925, 0.054791975766420364, -0.03631773591041565, 0.029201123863458633, -0.03670663759112358, 0.0312734916806221, 0.01889725588262081, -0.029276302084326744, -0.021209629252552986, 0.020605236291885376, 0.03637801110744476, -0.05219229683279991, -0.025608735159039497, 0.09659618139266968, 0.026810558512806892, -0.07588305324316025, 0.03461938351392746, -0.004025093279778957, -0.03860843554139137, 0.032488688826560974, 0.01714932546019554, -0.09438224881887436, -0.04724705591797829, 0.007645667064934969, 0.007341133896261454, 0.004568203818053007, -0.023110730573534966, -0.0012714107288047671, -0.07826976478099823, 0.015246114693582058, 0.0010681033600121737, -0.08909966051578522, -0.06499481946229935, -0.00794420950114727, -0.03297001123428345, 0.016203556209802628, 0.045900650322437286, 0.04113191366195679, 0.01462390087544918, -0.009070628322660923, 0.016443945467472076, -0.030627917498350143, -0.06281408667564392, 0.02939959429204464, -0.033915672451257706, 0.044356074184179306, 0.04214151203632355, 0.03783350810408592, -0.001628137077204883, -0.010576595552265644, -0.006798698566854, -0.06658060103654861, 0.012690043076872826, -0.011446807533502579, 0.03115640953183174, -0.009794638492166996, -0.015299271792173386, -0.04867001995444298, 0.02940984256565571, -0.0940207690000534, -0.05036395788192749, 0.00046925345668569207, 0.037329334765672684, -0.034608144313097, -0.009386972524225712, -0.038832638412714005, -0.01708245277404785, 0.016285942867398262, 0.07881061732769012, 0.011588159017264843, -0.004858395550400019, -0.04896656423807144, -0.02859959751367569, 0.0491216704249382, -0.06956788152456284, 0.0026375912129878998, 0.02048187330365181, 0.007574960123747587, -0.015911372378468513, -0.0698479637503624, -0.06929799914360046, 0.004353390075266361, 0.027870576828718185, 0.0019519008928909898, 0.014395414851605892, -0.005906311795115471, -0.014894244261085987, -0.056317541748285294, -0.04199032858014107, 0.025726106017827988, 0.034132249653339386, -0.02076486311852932, 0.01221705786883831, 0.03487879037857056, -0.01983940787613392, -0.024519484490156174, -0.02744067832827568, -0.03340986743569374, -0.031114106997847557, 0.015148315578699112, -0.025677064433693886, -0.0009530638926662505, 0.04147612676024437, -0.00015076808631420135, -0.030529728159308434, 0.03583480790257454, 0.02329975739121437, -0.031029514968395233, 0.012463274411857128, 0.018429486081004143, 0.031895529478788376, 0.007502898573875427, 0.02283860370516777, -0.05273323133587837, 0.05094067379832268, -0.0040901657193899155, 0.04192190244793892, -0.05407710745930672, -0.022973738610744476, 0.04652723670005798, -0.018067333847284317, 0.04089577868580818, 0.0059152645990252495, -0.03057476133108139, -0.023086192086338997, 0.01558428443968296, -0.040473341941833496, -0.00042022025445476174, -0.04197230562567711, 0.016034593805670738, 0.025481324642896652, 0.007975073531270027, -0.0018152002012357116, 0.008242280222475529, 0.005240173079073429, -0.023004673421382904, 0.010583783499896526, 0.06653637439012527, 0.011905044317245483, 0.05184594541788101, -0.027374431490898132, 0.05449570715427399, -0.0015080907614901662, -0.0006692082970403135, 0.017771776765584946, 0.05192938446998596, -0.02553737722337246, 0.04026224464178085, 0.027507895603775978, -0.01173163577914238, -0.028034009039402008, 0.02525635063648224, -0.05544280260801315, 0.07493229955434799, -0.016866954043507576, 0.0030095551628619432, 0.04266508296132088, -0.04985315725207329, 0.01778477057814598, 0.008677377365529537, 0.02164963074028492, -0.0030169168021529913, 0.06753997504711151, -0.03209616243839264, -0.027483850717544556, 0.10104581713676453, -0.0012525010388344526, -0.014238429255783558, -0.0361158661544323, 0.0547352135181427, -0.017418712377548218, 0.02988193929195404, 0.01979033276438713, -8.362148946616799e-05, -0.036825068295001984, 0.02384014055132866, 0.010609467513859272, 0.06694657355546951, -0.003740136045962572, 0.043033041059970856, 0.0020709962118417025, -0.05264671891927719, -0.005199115723371506, -0.020529042929410934, 0.047902386635541916, -0.010245291516184807, 0.034930188208818436, -0.0006715136114507914, -0.0010322949383407831, -0.06018872186541557, -0.031333114951848984, 0.028014013543725014, -0.033540599048137665, -0.005218266975134611, -0.05131373926997185, -6.687226466038725e-33, -0.00714053213596344, -3.409430428291671e-05, -0.032603878527879715, -0.04563123360276222, -0.013518167659640312, 0.021723201498389244, -0.028523318469524384, -0.013272566720843315, -0.0053408038802444935, 0.02666482888162136, 0.021023903042078018, 0.01877855509519577, 0.0055074566043913364, 0.05136300250887871, 0.012451069429516792, -0.030391890555620193, 0.03387173265218735, -0.01055248361080885, 0.05061021447181702, 0.018916036933660507, 0.054237741976976395, 0.05976959317922592, 0.09465257078409195, -0.09968819469213486, -0.023977115750312805, -0.006522657349705696, -0.01017714198678732, 0.027602531015872955, 0.05133012682199478, 0.029148392379283905, -0.02130655013024807, 0.04844588413834572, 0.0397849939763546, -0.055840976536273956, -0.015049879439175129, 0.05108223855495453, -0.08813942223787308, -0.0577632412314415, -0.015583842061460018, 0.06340499222278595, -0.03182892128825188, -0.06429103761911392, 0.06143505871295929, -0.009743758477270603, -0.01486119907349348, 0.03364162519574165, 0.037872664630413055, -0.014097030274569988, -0.0100874537602067, -0.03332290053367615, -0.041856128722429276, -0.008728922344744205, -0.03790285065770149, 0.02091181091964245, 0.036176394671201706, 0.022168615832924843, -0.008733391761779785, 0.037479836493730545, -0.06147867068648338, -0.020288245752453804, -0.045792534947395325, 0.03766292333602905, 0.03581306338310242, 0.02471756935119629, 0.030845239758491516, 0.05401051416993141, 0.04578510671854019, -0.03873318433761597, -0.05058573558926582, 0.0003504119231365621, 0.02041715942323208, 0.03021889738738537, 0.015280008316040039, 0.06150359287858009, 0.07311675697565079, -0.02557900920510292, -0.07555268704891205, 0.005137045867741108, -0.004104673862457275, 0.01862100139260292, 0.01649104431271553, 0.04080084711313248, -0.04010869190096855, -0.05187792330980301, 0.015736009925603867, -0.0698217824101448, 0.0027217331808060408, -0.02180362492799759, 0.05631745606660843, -0.02067558281123638, -0.011011160910129547, 0.01833193562924862, 0.020150408148765564, -0.09121131896972656, -0.020376794040203094, 0.03952386602759361, -0.0007758581195957959, 0.004049424547702074, 0.03307780995965004, 0.008850696496665478, -0.04511036351323128, -0.01597188040614128, 0.015094567090272903, 0.0344473235309124, 0.000481913099065423, -0.004262065980583429, 0.062415171414613724, -0.020541902631521225, -0.021663403138518333, -0.002795708831399679, -0.027495287358760834, -0.029895074665546417, -0.025744397193193436, 0.03285040706396103, -0.01902240887284279, 0.01754346862435341, -0.01808580756187439, 0.051509056240320206, 0.024453548714518547, -0.009710918180644512, -0.03302258998155594, -0.0421094074845314, 0.0037571436259895563, 0.06194181367754936, -0.05477549508213997, -0.03384292870759964, -0.004027978982776403, 0.03646722063422203, 0.09981600940227509, -0.06527245044708252, -0.01925504393875599, 0.020787619054317474, 2.8600487667063135e-07, 0.05872249975800514, 0.00432683527469635, 0.04693083465099335, -0.03574351966381073, 0.026226656511425972, 0.032323841005563736, 0.032208073884248734, 0.052302200347185135, 0.0029937901999801397, 0.001469214796088636, 0.0028756174724549055, 0.01387556828558445, 0.0028541458304971457, -0.019159018993377686, -0.09417661279439926, 0.022067978978157043, -0.061076827347278595, -0.0022996882908046246, -0.0014011698076501489, 0.06477640569210052, 0.11274020373821259, 0.1066686362028122, -0.016222825273871422, -0.0178809966892004, 0.007678317837417126, -0.0023327996022999287, 0.017386140301823616, -0.057471904903650284, 0.05806279927492142, -0.0006433019298128784, -0.09227699041366577, 0.002256302861496806, -0.010563582181930542, 0.03164253756403923, 0.009609702043235302, 0.035779863595962524, -0.015390034765005112, 0.018308093771338463, -0.04462790861725807, -0.033572182059288025, -0.0009648122359067202, 0.010444682091474533, 0.014122904278337955, -0.05519098415970802, 0.06913731247186661, -0.03354145213961601, -0.03733959048986435, -0.05736618861556053, -0.03001280687749386, 0.025222424417734146, -0.011409664526581764, 0.06550402194261551, -0.021517297253012657, -0.0015430862549692392, 0.02498549222946167, -0.032274238765239716, -0.015291155315935612, -0.09524374455213547, 0.002220503054559231, 0.025063958019018173, -0.02985292673110962, 0.05663090571761131, -0.03056756965816021, 0.004454160109162331, 0.06491578370332718, -0.02896534837782383, 0.006043816916644573, 2.6116052123602324e-34, -0.008687247522175312, 0.03270385041832924, -0.003970884718000889, 0.03292594105005264, -0.016741089522838593, -0.030900195240974426, -0.004583269357681274, 0.015458543784916401, 0.019188174977898598, -0.05667438358068466, -0.022674797102808952]
653
653
['Qiming Chen', 'Ren Wu']
1712.09662v1
The Convolution Neural Network (CNN) has demonstrated the unique advantage in audio, image and text learning; recently it has also challenged Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs) with long short-term memory cells (LSTM) in sequence-to-sequence learning, since the computations involved in CNN are easily parallelizable whereas those involved in RNN are mostly sequential, leading to a performance bottleneck. However, unlike RNN, the native CNN lacks the history sensitivity required for sequence transformation; therefore enhancing the sequential order awareness, or position-sensitivity, becomes the key to make CNN the general deep learning model. In this work we introduce an extended CNN model with strengthen position-sensitivity, called PoseNet. A notable feature of PoseNet is the asymmetric treatment of position information in the encoder and the decoder. Experiments shows that PoseNet allows us to improve the accuracy of CNN based sequence-to-sequence learning significantly, achieving around 33-36 BLEU scores on the WMT 2014 English-to-German translation task, and around 44-46 BLEU scores on the English-to-French translation task.
CNN Is All You Need
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1712.09662v1
Title CNN Need Summary Convolution Neural Network CNN demonstrated unique advantage audio image text learning recently also challenged Recurrent Neural Networks RNNs long shortterm memory cell LSTM sequencetosequence learning since computation involved CNN easily parallelizable whereas involved RNN mostly sequential leading performance bottleneck However unlike RNN native CNN lack history sensitivity required sequence transformation therefore enhancing sequential order awareness positionsensitivity becomes key make CNN general deep learning model work introduce extended CNN model strengthen positionsensitivity called PoseNet notable feature PoseNet asymmetric treatment position information encoder decoder Experiments show PoseNet allows u improve accuracy CNN based sequencetosequence learning significantly achieving around 3336 BLEU score WMT 2014 EnglishtoGerman translation task around 4446 BLEU score EnglishtoFrench translation task Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.023207545280456543, 0.055911850184202194, -0.016193347051739693, 0.03825205937027931, 0.010565239936113358, -0.011192799545824528, 0.031835008412599564, 0.025277020409703255, -0.055737681686878204, -0.008467582054436207, -0.018891112878918648, -0.024584462866187096, 0.026755500584840775, -0.0033087453339248896, 0.010294949635863304, -0.06995046883821487, 0.00495947478339076, 0.036176834255456924, -0.015096744522452354, 0.0012970060342922807, -0.011441408656537533, -0.013236022554337978, -0.04033711552619934, 0.015675222501158714, -0.0008131514769047499, 0.01755235157907009, -0.031115030869841576, 0.008992300368845463, 0.054446153342723846, -0.051057569682598114, 0.02536749839782715, 0.04593487083911896, 0.04539678990840912, 0.059590477496385574, 2.3076479465089506e-06, 0.013023212552070618, -0.006798227783292532, -0.010323131456971169, 0.048505816608667374, -0.003300850512459874, -0.04644056782126427, -0.03642535209655762, -0.04691212996840477, 0.016324948519468307, -0.046194642782211304, 0.017635202035307884, 0.041237253695726395, 0.0345165841281414, 0.0022872553672641516, 0.10042122006416321, -0.01576297916471958, -0.045291341841220856, 0.01281113363802433, -0.054625947028398514, 0.038091983646154404, -0.023427410051226616, -0.03227997571229935, -0.012487059459090233, -0.009990478865802288, 0.043540626764297485, -0.051597047597169876, 0.07126016914844513, 0.041081756353378296, 0.010550281964242458, -0.030639640986919403, 0.03991541266441345, -0.018162855878472328, -0.013230758719146252, -0.004631807096302509, 0.05851389467716217, -0.05392253398895264, 0.008095767349004745, -0.008653576485812664, -0.00930100865662098, 0.023071153089404106, -0.05130913481116295, -0.05613502115011215, 0.03498391807079315, 0.004878067411482334, -0.00797714851796627, -0.054434631019830704, 0.043990105390548706, 0.018642952665686607, 0.020619170740246773, 0.02816755510866642, -0.011386152356863022, -0.010348827578127384, -0.022144917398691177, -0.04885726422071457, -0.026164043694734573, 0.012009978294372559, -0.02630610577762127, 0.05627883970737457, 0.013207515701651573, -0.000811814097687602, -0.011895665898919106, 0.0019966159015893936, -0.08164825290441513, 0.03236214071512222, -0.06565240770578384, -0.008539066649973392, 0.026828501373529434, -0.040637772530317307, -0.00630364753305912, -0.032006312161684036, 0.08600623905658722, -0.05075565353035927, -0.001198131823912263, -0.03624327480792999, 0.04555892199277878, -0.010497900657355785, -0.009476264007389545, 0.01661265641450882, 0.014368725940585136, -0.019448209553956985, -0.03917006030678749, -0.04434879124164581, -0.020929411053657532, -0.003999132197350264, -0.004730510991066694, -0.005226952955126762, 0.08405786007642746, -0.0471721887588501, -0.03676600754261017, 0.022462910041213036, 0.05497002601623535, -0.004916697274893522, 0.050780054181814194, 0.002053330186754465, 0.009247726760804653, 0.019666003063321114, 0.011158842593431473, 0.040539033710956573, 0.02446637861430645, 0.020392639562487602, 0.007891901768743992, 0.0063844225369393826, -0.012618510983884335, 0.017816711217164993, 0.0237076748162508, -0.026162970811128616, -0.03402400761842728, -0.002230188110843301, -0.07998879998922348, -0.017207104712724686, -0.008625025860965252, -0.02238309010863304, -0.014633621089160442, 0.024717280641198158, 0.012597228400409222, 0.012754806317389011, 0.06080791726708412, 0.005446529481559992, -0.029189791530370712, 0.05668152868747711, 0.026699503883719444, 0.07677103579044342, 0.016260171309113503, 0.042566604912281036, 0.03567085787653923, 0.022300036624073982, -0.016113901510834694, -0.024149717763066292, 0.028571611270308495, -0.011561249382793903, -0.02088061347603798, -0.016692593693733215, -0.03652985766530037, -0.013279742561280727, 0.05795276165008545, 0.0051078894175589085, 0.021226786077022552, 0.017005890607833862, -0.03563668206334114, 0.058520328253507614, 0.0426766574382782, 0.0433158241212368, 0.009008319117128849, -0.00938398577272892, 0.010821797885000706, -0.02419217675924301, -0.006220636889338493, -0.014573340304195881, 0.08149704337120056, 0.03586511313915253, -0.006767699494957924, -0.001673086197115481, 0.008878116495907307, -0.0017775141168385744, -0.04422751069068909, 0.020100466907024384, -0.025351786985993385, 0.0009672730811871588, -0.009116223081946373, -0.014664852060377598, 0.014963352121412754, -0.04892837628722191, 0.03326289355754852, -0.04616423696279526, -0.04203115776181221, -0.0517130084335804, 0.015197553671896458, -0.027664195746183395, 0.017891544848680496, -0.02164478227496147, -0.046512309461832047, -0.044641684740781784, -0.03603155165910721, -0.01013944111764431, 0.03978453204035759, -0.008915789425373077, 0.02514476142823696, 0.016054432839155197, -0.059211697429418564, -0.029086966067552567, 0.03980770707130432, -0.016218679025769234, 0.044132985174655914, -0.0022576069459319115, 0.06035589799284935, 0.042879000306129456, 0.04919954389333725, 0.003224969143047929, -0.0007546009146608412, 0.011705371551215649, -0.022683685645461082, 0.019418546929955482, 0.03830811381340027, 0.027251645922660828, 0.044655974954366684, -0.0005830321460962296, 0.0005902769626118243, 0.06645413488149643, -0.04175412654876709, 0.004519315902143717, -0.007025687023997307, -0.09010643512010574, -0.036365386098623276, 0.03826352208852768, -0.01750212535262108, 0.02198834903538227, 0.07036446779966354, -0.03437935188412666, -0.06034431234002113, 0.018968332558870316, 0.017700573429465294, -0.0016889044782146811, 0.014173292554914951, 0.012654976919293404, 0.032989710569381714, 0.028034068644046783, -0.002689593005925417, 0.008220263756811619, -0.023675233125686646, 0.029537353664636612, 0.02364576980471611, 0.03586339205503464, 0.0369834341108799, -0.050041764974594116, -0.020212067291140556, 0.05203494429588318, -0.02701571397483349, 0.02414027415215969, 0.045948565006256104, -0.009640753269195557, -0.029088851064443588, 0.006775734480470419, -0.06045198440551758, 0.019256368279457092, -0.012106635607779026, -0.005749061703681946, -0.0009673854219727218, 0.015630843117833138, 0.011385914869606495, -0.06175084784626961, -0.05731620639562607, 0.03344595059752464, 0.009139043278992176, -0.01759100891649723, 0.02305329591035843, 0.007421079557389021, -0.010350950062274933, -0.019190622493624687, -0.016212748363614082, 0.017537327483296394, -0.009314540773630142, -0.015934297814965248, -0.0738755315542221, 0.004567299969494343, 0.008420580998063087, 0.023538650944828987, 0.04332279786467552, 0.010472278110682964, -0.062187373638153076, 0.0007513629388995469, -0.003918781410902739, -0.011875242926180363, 0.06816230714321136, 0.05517316237092018, 0.011292867362499237, -0.024429138749837875, 0.037860482931137085, -0.014040332287549973, 0.02198970876634121, -0.01708076149225235, 0.03354532644152641, -0.012886054813861847, 0.030450832098722458, -0.06314639747142792, -5.063957360107452e-05, 0.026052221655845642, 0.01743590086698532, -0.019869400188326836, -0.033276960253715515, -0.025059565901756287, -0.015225228853523731, -0.031238442286849022, -0.016714854165911674, -0.039590414613485336, 0.014565150253474712, 0.006676037795841694, -0.03667445108294487, -0.009571290574967861, 0.013642481528222561, -0.0075504663400352, -0.024250619113445282, -0.043254394084215164, -0.027467496693134308, 0.06638030707836151, 0.02676163800060749, 0.013515034690499306, -0.005201763939112425, -0.048398006707429886, -0.06800638139247894, 0.004808378405869007, 0.004279818385839462, -0.06375110894441605, 0.021199673414230347, -0.0014023048570379615, -0.028689008206129074, -0.06088963523507118, -0.04872540384531021, -0.0516827218234539, 0.006406310014426708, 0.013418045826256275, 0.0017429100116714835, -0.015215703286230564, -0.047995563596487045, -0.002803501673042774, -0.01903870515525341, 0.005920549388974905, 0.05036856234073639, -0.014500276185572147, 0.02737860381603241, -0.0083925761282444, 0.07886402308940887, 0.0034327127505093813, 0.04038648679852486, -0.029016442596912384, 0.03640954568982124, 0.015254815109074116, 0.05410915985703468, -0.03905702009797096, -0.004539764951914549, -0.09112891554832458, 0.03532729670405388, 0.01153776329010725, -0.014739090576767921, -0.06261221319437027, 0.02817150205373764, -0.0049276938661932945, -0.08601540327072144, 0.0034207087010145187, 0.05015834420919418, 0.02170659601688385, -0.05022518336772919, -0.009799315594136715, 0.05204624682664871, -0.02569306083023548, 0.02126404084265232, -0.003469775663688779, -0.04341985285282135, 0.006929310038685799, -0.012259257957339287, -0.00018129248928744346, 0.03168649971485138, -0.000523097871337086, -0.01186511293053627, -0.06655820459127426, 0.03183826804161072, 0.00018293429457116872, -0.07303915172815323, -0.039777204394340515, -0.004200741183012724, -0.05312778428196907, 0.03691178187727928, 0.024229248985648155, 0.006804430857300758, 0.034386470913887024, -0.017133105546236038, 0.05679597705602646, -0.05871967226266861, -0.018888473510742188, -0.02517516352236271, -0.051446009427309036, 0.0034815988037735224, 0.08533889800310135, 0.06813667714595795, -0.05108068883419037, -0.05525830760598183, 0.0007220578845590353, 0.009661073796451092, 0.019401485100388527, 0.020149949938058853, 0.05207306519150734, 0.013723763637244701, -0.0051387702114880085, 0.02439986914396286, 0.04435165226459503, -0.04151364043354988, -0.0012924388283863664, 0.0010614676866680384, 0.008001003414392471, -0.0018247194821015, 0.05317003279924393, -0.05506972223520279, 0.033632878214120865, -0.010206541046500206, -0.019987935200333595, -0.003245234489440918, -0.018905503675341606, 0.0067347753793001175, -0.033631838858127594, 0.044077321887016296, -0.10909951478242874, -0.007461081258952618, -0.007653555367141962, 0.02934638038277626, -0.059295494109392166, -0.09240934997797012, -0.012055610306560993, -0.06132497265934944, 0.0393579825758934, 0.028138529509305954, 0.03420066460967064, 0.005645706783980131, 0.001912177656777203, -0.08212307095527649, -0.032451339066028595, 0.08732215315103531, 0.05456211790442467, -0.049706559628248215, 0.022050896659493446, 0.038851868361234665, -0.027858344838023186, 0.007381218019872904, -0.03942249342799187, -0.06496215611696243, -0.035699453204870224, -0.010796978138387203, 0.03616786003112793, 0.005841889418661594, 0.0557214617729187, -0.010115626268088818, -0.016299961134791374, 0.006320970598608255, 0.06121149659156799, -0.016713468357920647, -0.018815835937857628, 0.04670855030417442, -0.04797901585698128, -0.020652182400226593, -0.004241426941007376, -0.04774150252342224, 0.02436225675046444, -0.014253508299589157, -0.005637320224195719, 0.01244551781564951, -0.051229652017354965, 0.013977070339024067, -0.040468718856573105, 0.056129515171051025, -0.007985532283782959, 0.005945262033492327, -0.026742324233055115, 0.052260540425777435, -0.008490338921546936, 0.006526236422359943, -0.022806735709309578, -0.009369676001369953, 0.06971704959869385, 0.01658354327082634, -0.0021911850199103355, 0.0260472372174263, 0.06108716502785683, -0.08643317967653275, -0.0054231975227594376, 0.07295417785644531, -0.012477410025894642, 0.01994534209370613, -0.0027146553620696068, 0.013068588450551033, -0.017367912456393242, 0.03391868621110916, 0.024535249918699265, 0.05990871787071228, -0.02493806555867195, 0.028240401297807693, 0.022839117795228958, 0.02723478525876999, -0.01767740026116371, 0.057058315724134445, -0.02811022847890854, 0.017913896590471268, -0.05732304975390434, 0.0065348283387720585, 0.11332615464925766, -0.08140141516923904, 0.02277543395757675, 0.004772217944264412, 0.015399192459881306, -0.005141463130712509, 0.03685877472162247, -0.030370278283953667, -0.009790831245481968, 0.03198843449354172, -6.610662239836529e-05, 0.01967971958220005, 0.03304828330874443, 0.036715731024742126, -0.005767224822193384, -0.024180132895708084, 0.015825320035219193, -0.02731744386255741, 0.00043521192856132984, 0.007097932044416666, -0.01957586780190468, 0.0039027833845466375, -0.019422536715865135, 0.027098068967461586, 0.03639739379286766, -0.0645725354552269, 0.02534240484237671, 0.012285212986171246, 0.035202138125896454, -0.025543347001075745, 0.05313863977789879, 0.012246217578649521, 0.006034703925251961, -0.007706060074269772, -0.04906152933835983, -0.029974162578582764, -0.0027439354453235865, -0.019671287387609482, -0.07277703285217285, -6.06259962473847e-33, -0.0031726083252578974, -0.03612206131219864, -0.011280989274382591, -0.018243972212076187, -0.04159054905176163, 0.02861262857913971, -0.01655108854174614, -0.005196659360080957, 0.013452482409775257, 0.01969403773546219, -0.01744256727397442, 0.035245828330516815, 0.019190452992916107, 0.04037931561470032, 0.02206447534263134, 0.027893181890249252, 0.025199275463819504, -0.018077626824378967, 0.027281126007437706, -0.028489060699939728, 0.05430076643824577, 0.03891271725296974, 0.06524547189474106, -0.04310085251927376, -0.04558763653039932, -0.003770910669118166, 0.021082015708088875, -0.04722318425774574, -0.0064779240638017654, 0.025830896571278572, 0.02039112150669098, -0.0087259067222476, 0.006796531844884157, -0.07312697172164917, 0.0038643204607069492, 0.018403468653559685, -0.09261436015367508, -0.006174790672957897, -0.06836483627557755, 0.08307329565286636, -0.0181853249669075, -0.023511240258812904, 0.06588318943977356, -0.02205684408545494, -0.028034571558237076, -0.011057219468057156, 0.02966657280921936, -0.050524111837148666, -0.05601012706756592, -0.07474038004875183, -0.04343610629439354, 0.014256082475185394, -0.04368309676647186, -0.013499199412763119, 0.025865672156214714, 0.016768740490078926, 0.006829080171883106, -0.03431347757577896, -0.09283355623483658, 0.026715559884905815, -0.00964555237442255, 0.09722767770290375, 0.0520821139216423, 0.02223169431090355, -0.035370923578739166, 0.0043019019067287445, 0.014700634405016899, -0.055113937705755234, 0.019733499735593796, 0.03152699023485184, -0.00985604990273714, 0.04492868483066559, 0.07839581370353699, -0.0037839137949049473, 0.08834677189588547, -0.038543153554201126, -0.05496687442064285, 0.04667706415057182, -0.05534040182828903, 0.0042702374048531055, 0.006273962091654539, 0.05493518337607384, -0.03436794504523277, 0.008290902711451054, -6.613226287299767e-05, 0.025249989703297615, 0.012126713991165161, -0.0456165187060833, 0.04267293959856033, -0.01305799838155508, 0.043977078050374985, 0.03135767951607704, 0.040688272565603256, -0.05950692296028137, 0.017819872125983238, 0.008676985278725624, -0.024363404139876366, 0.016646571457386017, 0.0059313587844371796, 0.013865876011550426, -0.03322463855147362, -0.001538631273433566, 0.04051031172275543, 0.03577767685055733, -0.0030601334292441607, -0.018170567229390144, 0.04411468282341957, 0.029767470434308052, -0.0433543361723423, -0.01663885824382305, 0.015393620356917381, -0.002669022884219885, 0.0337376706302166, 0.06726211309432983, 0.0022504618391394615, -0.03218698129057884, 0.003896871581673622, 0.0912318304181099, 0.003941272851079702, -0.025609111413359642, -0.03368087857961655, -0.03909755125641823, -0.0015547515358775854, 0.025699863210320473, -0.056344904005527496, -0.005190996453166008, -0.045185238122940063, 0.06371810287237167, 0.015032272785902023, -0.07499168813228607, -0.0335579514503479, 0.04991617426276207, 2.940085153113614e-07, 0.014791257679462433, -0.022596390917897224, 0.04373937472701073, -0.030726835131645203, 0.01958785578608513, -0.004247598350048065, -0.0321492962539196, 0.015295589342713356, -0.022262828424572945, 0.0492398776113987, 0.052303213626146317, -0.012183750979602337, 0.025353118777275085, 0.011288979090750217, -0.07962727546691895, -0.024426085874438286, -0.08502424508333206, 0.05910171568393707, -0.024854348972439766, 0.03668903186917305, 0.04435284063220024, 0.10484311729669571, -0.026968812569975853, -0.03291173279285431, 0.06085866689682007, -0.007356073707342148, 0.004235055297613144, 0.020826658234000206, 0.062434036284685135, -0.04618294537067413, 0.025677332654595375, 0.02665211632847786, -0.06035703048110008, -0.042832329869270325, -0.06881111860275269, 0.013013162650167942, 0.03504655510187149, -0.008932024240493774, -0.014078746549785137, -0.03632782772183418, 0.012827024795114994, 0.01892530918121338, 0.021780483424663544, -0.038230713456869125, 0.039159148931503296, -0.013324295170605183, -0.025689221918582916, 0.013882610015571117, -0.0513993464410305, 0.008668693713843822, 0.02046727016568184, 0.011386288329958916, 0.0032135199289768934, -0.04795515164732933, 0.019794940948486328, -0.027231574058532715, -0.028458822518587112, -0.07327830791473389, -0.02537005953490734, 0.005732192192226648, -0.0037701749242842197, 0.019443146884441376, -0.046023979783058167, -0.014288733713328838, 0.024881761521100998, 0.01667299121618271, -0.04257996380329132, 2.38553055722574e-34, -0.012024846859276295, -0.028610073029994965, 0.01556144468486309, 0.02272902801632881, -0.03158684819936752, -0.017890872433781624, -0.01673487015068531, 0.02094917744398117, -0.007691935636103153, 0.003983268979936838, -0.05761298909783363]
654
654
['Tim Rocktäschel']
1712.09687v1
The current state-of-the-art in many natural language processing and automated knowledge base completion tasks is held by representation learning methods which learn distributed vector representations of symbols via gradient-based optimization. They require little or no hand-crafted features, thus avoiding the need for most preprocessing steps and task-specific assumptions. However, in many cases representation learning requires a large amount of annotated training data to generalize well to unseen data. Such labeled training data is provided by human annotators who often use formal logic as the language for specifying annotations. This thesis investigates different combinations of representation learning methods with logic for reducing the need for annotated training data, and for improving generalization.
Combining Representation Learning with Logic for Language Processing
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1712.09687v1
Title Combining Representation Learning Logic Language Processing Summary current stateoftheart many natural language processing automated knowledge base completion task held representation learning method learn distributed vector representation symbol via gradientbased optimization require little handcrafted feature thus avoiding need preprocessing step taskspecific assumption However many case representation learning requires large amount annotated training data generalize well unseen data labeled training data provided human annotator often use formal logic language specifying annotation thesis investigates different combination representation learning method logic reducing need annotated training data improving generalization Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.04245384782552719, -0.010935433208942413, -0.00979213509708643, 0.019917266443371773, -0.03041921928524971, 0.02238231897354126, -0.009313097223639488, 0.012592816725373268, 0.06660055369138718, -0.09160167723894119, 0.018299521878361702, 0.04960286617279053, 0.0038200649432837963, 0.05390718951821327, 0.012001699768006802, -0.0878070667386055, 0.0390266552567482, 0.04444265365600586, 0.02872171811759472, 0.014048948884010315, 0.030047113075852394, 0.023747825995087624, 0.0043891966342926025, 0.04384391009807587, -0.017339464277029037, -0.013452853076159954, 0.012074800208210945, -0.04796392098069191, 0.0016177804209291935, -0.01871483586728573, -0.004767722450196743, 0.035163216292858124, 0.03162211552262306, 0.0006350650801323354, 2.156365326300147e-06, -0.05236626788973808, -0.04519254341721535, 0.0254057664424181, 0.028429953381419182, -0.05994020402431488, 0.031945981085300446, -0.01253126747906208, 0.002154642716050148, 0.0350826196372509, -0.07641416788101196, -0.05082963779568672, 0.035391610115766525, 0.10623524338006973, 0.06219733506441116, 0.054723192006349564, -0.009655613452196121, -0.06297460943460464, 0.019434617832303047, 0.019103774800896645, -0.029534034430980682, -0.0004874970472883433, 0.025051536038517952, 0.052155617624521255, 0.017792563885450363, -0.020436568185687065, 0.008643999695777893, -0.0017162393778562546, -0.0338750034570694, -0.01995844393968582, -0.0026332149282097816, 0.011290023103356361, -0.03496507555246353, 0.020891664549708366, -0.002146853366866708, 0.06993144005537033, -0.003571123816072941, -0.0014939851826056838, 0.009694463573396206, 0.017363114282488823, 0.013954581692814827, -0.044856444001197815, -0.007558922283351421, 0.009014330804347992, -0.03720748424530029, 0.022375939413905144, 0.02975098229944706, 0.0026546025183051825, 0.0054343082010746, -0.014434495940804482, -0.04304385185241699, 0.09195846319198608, -0.015905767679214478, -0.021893858909606934, 0.008424363099038601, -0.027941998094320297, -0.033797189593315125, -0.0642583817243576, -0.012913411483168602, 0.018991028890013695, -0.008557499386370182, 0.013733846135437489, -0.042792726308107376, -0.06243504583835602, 0.023376701399683952, -0.059571072459220886, 0.0348099060356617, 0.02029155194759369, 0.016515687108039856, 0.01870066486299038, -0.053196098655462265, 0.025673089548945427, 0.02036549337208271, 0.062377817928791046, -0.03531808406114578, -0.0035900615621358156, -0.07713714987039566, -0.02870464324951172, -0.03601854294538498, 0.08743125945329666, -0.01825321651995182, -0.033289797604084015, -0.048432301729917526, 0.028561729937791824, -0.02612786367535591, 0.01889071986079216, -0.008657930418848991, 0.010754656046628952, 0.02043941058218479, 0.0014055363135412335, -0.05227655917406082, 0.03840659558773041, -0.049030549824237823, 0.02292557619512081, -0.026729384437203407, -0.023774098604917526, 0.049659326672554016, 0.028655527159571648, 0.0023494898341596127, 0.02084965631365776, -0.016500601544976234, 0.06895806640386581, 0.025487501174211502, 0.024198099970817566, -0.0541398786008358, -0.04988910257816315, 0.04111822322010994, -0.04241872951388359, -0.00036192702827975154, -0.07463648170232773, -0.017774775624275208, -0.010274745523929596, -0.023349421098828316, -0.032516952604055405, 0.006592891179025173, 0.018608201295137405, -0.0015412740176543593, 0.06950398534536362, -0.08508508652448654, -0.04204504191875458, 0.025080649182200432, -0.021068694069981575, -0.01171733159571886, 0.07361149042844772, 0.027741730213165283, 0.004988356027752161, -0.006717350799590349, 0.0018387289019301534, -0.031893473118543625, -0.028361601755023003, -0.0026262146420776844, -0.057391125708818436, -0.03159962594509125, 0.016149338334798813, -0.00937922578305006, 0.01188099104911089, -0.004320889711380005, 0.05989795923233032, -0.035202622413635254, 0.015451415441930294, -0.026111098006367683, 0.07178407162427902, 0.06071069464087486, 0.00967513769865036, 0.0157986618578434, 0.05194592848420143, 0.037700995802879333, 0.006851751822978258, -0.023154234513640404, 0.003622067626565695, -0.04864373803138733, -0.01791539415717125, -0.07045550644397736, 0.0015714586479589343, 0.004301576875150204, -0.06943928450345993, -0.006197272799909115, -0.04447496682405472, 0.04380244016647339, -0.005510715767741203, 0.0436808280646801, 0.023875972256064415, -0.034209657460451126, 0.020790262147784233, 0.03528427705168724, 0.00020394811872392893, -0.02861199341714382, -0.03685583546757698, 0.01709340699017048, 0.011255968362092972, -0.029965126886963844, -0.07463480532169342, -0.02629496343433857, -0.04946405813097954, -0.04954175651073456, -0.0005471094627864659, 0.016539493575692177, -0.024977613240480423, -0.04594508558511734, -0.04046647250652313, -0.015468692407011986, 0.008249304257333279, 0.029802825301885605, 0.024534037336707115, -0.04738658294081688, -0.009859579615294933, 0.022234531119465828, 0.012410956434905529, -0.010758580639958382, 0.04824501648545265, 0.059374477714300156, 0.018708935007452965, 0.021083010360598564, 0.020876765251159668, 0.04228544235229492, 0.01841873675584793, -0.0003672251186799258, 0.03414556756615639, 0.03406095877289772, -0.026762964203953743, -0.0684165358543396, 0.029673868790268898, -0.022352201864123344, -0.04855728894472122, 0.058298394083976746, -0.02643406391143799, 0.006402888335287571, -0.02199612930417061, -0.042838044464588165, -0.040205299854278564, 0.023528721183538437, -0.049698568880558014, 0.031244363635778427, -0.031708694994449615, -0.022322697564959526, 0.0021775655914098024, -0.01986033469438553, -0.03739933297038078, 0.10960134863853455, 0.021989639848470688, -0.01093197800219059, -0.005642903037369251, -0.023249847814440727, 0.07073561102151871, -0.008445956744253635, 0.021100739017128944, 0.005013849586248398, -0.019559338688850403, 0.029084771871566772, 0.03722429648041725, -0.004742898978292942, -0.03607722744345665, -0.003872219007462263, -0.08880170434713364, 0.010865333490073681, -0.0002830977027770132, 0.007178901229053736, 0.017415696755051613, 0.0007701609865762293, 0.019353266805410385, -0.021502388641238213, -0.039097532629966736, 0.009265894070267677, 0.02235576882958412, -0.0015994173008948565, 0.018633712083101273, 0.018960289657115936, 0.007492510136216879, -0.0026870660949498415, -0.0088370181620121, -0.05563414841890335, 0.033109400421381, 0.027648836374282837, -0.03918692469596863, -0.040895380079746246, -0.01585407182574272, -0.02320478856563568, 0.046738527715206146, 0.012560803443193436, 0.0029954975470900536, 0.0035099200904369354, -0.033390600234270096, -0.03455880656838417, 0.002034478820860386, 0.004144179169088602, 0.013594255782663822, 0.054400552064180374, 0.022900592535734177, -0.03878926858305931, 0.01615655981004238, -0.0036974637769162655, 0.05845653638243675, -0.04370089992880821, 0.03870479762554169, -0.02994319424033165, -0.014376252889633179, 0.02541937306523323, -0.018480228260159492, -0.043076008558273315, 0.0029010025318711996, -0.031100492924451828, -0.01692381501197815, -0.05604805797338486, -0.02121870592236519, -0.007230882998555899, 0.0390152782201767, -0.001864869613200426, -0.03507914021611214, 0.06716550141572952, 0.029607392847537994, 0.0016152614261955023, -0.06663625687360764, -0.03538188338279724, -0.033435359597206116, 0.0634642019867897, 0.0005132707883603871, 0.039195649325847626, -0.011501154862344265, -0.07561337202787399, -0.019231293350458145, -0.0193877425044775, 0.010175321251153946, -0.030764466151595116, 0.021899258717894554, -0.013538483530282974, 0.02844047173857689, -0.0008049521129578352, 0.0011129456106573343, -0.04826229810714722, -0.0017130824271589518, -0.05758681148290634, 0.03192726522684097, -0.04700298234820366, -0.006803604308515787, -0.012475118972361088, -0.0012408113107085228, -0.025969281792640686, 0.002524890238419175, 0.017079530283808708, -0.010297492146492004, -0.010344338603317738, -0.04192366078495979, 0.025961944833397865, -0.005359407979995012, -0.03926282003521919, 0.06803648918867111, 0.011501478031277657, 0.026685504242777824, -0.013122308999300003, -0.0009197657345794141, -0.06562379747629166, 0.027004458010196686, 0.01955707184970379, -0.07020674645900726, -0.0554828867316246, 0.03932981938123703, -0.026926960796117783, -0.06206301599740982, 0.07107573747634888, 0.11132117360830307, 0.02640441805124283, -0.028735339641571045, 0.0003801329294219613, -0.013388989493250847, -0.03750148415565491, 0.03192802891135216, 0.05177106708288193, -0.08588574081659317, -0.019395966082811356, -0.01680728606879711, -0.00589405233040452, 0.0032552669290453196, -0.051810234785079956, 0.0005542098078876734, -0.09091340750455856, 0.0006627452676184475, 0.0016372505342587829, -0.062172867357730865, -0.033696532249450684, -0.05668468773365021, -0.02129281312227249, -0.019717300310730934, -0.023159561678767204, -0.01584762893617153, -0.008576123975217342, -0.01630079373717308, 0.017367921769618988, -0.05486641079187393, -0.0237745214253664, 0.006563839502632618, -0.05753399804234505, 0.014020544476807117, 0.06775803118944168, 0.08617815375328064, -0.00363487983122468, -0.044420719146728516, -0.04716407135128975, 0.03902727738022804, 0.0029669483192265034, -0.06052662804722786, 0.04582848772406578, -0.014948715455830097, 0.007062177173793316, -0.014625675976276398, 0.026710817590355873, -0.03356321156024933, 0.013321107253432274, -0.00687800208106637, 0.10716979205608368, -0.01503280084580183, 0.026322072371840477, -0.06071379780769348, -0.0045298077166080475, -0.006798708811402321, 0.017273487523198128, -0.014411495998501778, 0.000792986829765141, -0.019962556660175323, -0.02090628072619438, 0.010527655482292175, 0.0062974803149700165, -0.02941625751554966, 0.026187466457486153, -0.03357749059796333, -0.0564081072807312, -0.10537004470825195, -0.02411746047437191, 0.03779592365026474, 0.06153023988008499, 0.013945497572422028, 0.07535502314567566, 0.047345004975795746, -0.0060447026044130325, -0.058996956795454025, -0.022040940821170807, 0.01606041193008423, 0.02806251309812069, 0.01387135498225689, 0.023819707334041595, -0.009399746544659138, 0.022406581789255142, -0.05316920205950737, -0.027514507994055748, 0.003727633971720934, -0.0710068792104721, -0.02582492120563984, 0.04353422671556473, 0.013429714366793633, -0.005066406447440386, -0.029138844460248947, -0.01981186307966709, -0.013386663980782032, 0.017674796283245087, 0.003566339612007141, -0.05586380138993263, 0.04671940207481384, -0.026942411437630653, 0.008737077936530113, 0.01866014674305916, -0.03036380372941494, 0.016567520797252655, -0.028266670182347298, -0.01053580641746521, -0.052935559302568436, 0.011284650303423405, 0.057130489498376846, 0.03201000764966011, 0.008089983835816383, 0.005235394462943077, -0.03322457894682884, -0.03432619571685791, -0.01083641778677702, -0.05491785332560539, -0.0685773491859436, -0.04526016488671303, 0.04351206496357918, 0.01255886722356081, -0.02625294215977192, 0.020879974588751793, -0.03451072797179222, 0.00550458300858736, -0.006906441878527403, 0.0402354933321476, 0.043966278433799744, 0.03626075014472008, 0.02489454485476017, -0.02284354902803898, 0.009597172960639, -0.025169825181365013, -0.02783927507698536, 0.02103770524263382, 0.0028057582676410675, -0.036369819194078445, 0.009835192002356052, 0.009244625456631184, -0.005856985691934824, -0.02863096445798874, -0.014182530343532562, 0.022455893456935883, -0.05742377042770386, 0.01437743753194809, 0.06936680525541306, 0.07271230220794678, -0.030232029035687447, 0.024681949988007545, -0.013723531737923622, 0.009739197790622711, -0.014728358946740627, 0.050080664455890656, -0.009189828298985958, -0.027979614213109016, 0.04026997461915016, -0.008820733986794949, -0.021683428436517715, -0.06659527122974396, 0.05792772397398949, -0.026562146842479706, 0.046065445989370346, -0.024265876039862633, -0.045250725001096725, -0.0429106242954731, -0.013669758103787899, 0.02401595003902912, 0.048433803021907806, -0.012263125739991665, 0.03851843252778053, -0.025746814906597137, -0.043345846235752106, 0.028305629268288612, 0.0032083597034215927, 0.0031810440123081207, 0.011358179152011871, 0.05385302007198334, 0.02879917062819004, 0.04126337170600891, -0.05583234503865242, -0.05924070253968239, -0.02774071879684925, 0.014752193354070187, -0.024433206766843796, -0.03273165598511696, -5.374896858599046e-33, -0.03298909217119217, -0.020686164498329163, 0.01336264330893755, -0.032088976353406906, -0.022665832191705704, -0.01672852784395218, 0.024230990558862686, 0.013108618557453156, -0.014215842820703983, 0.025542888790369034, 0.000526557385455817, 0.009912358596920967, 0.009595595300197601, -1.7614422631595517e-06, -0.0060964310541749, 0.010952755808830261, 0.013172219507396221, -0.011990311555564404, 0.04549388960003853, -0.0011809344869107008, 0.06739575415849686, 0.03977658599615097, 0.06372303515672684, -0.11559005826711655, 0.02443670481443405, 0.038988277316093445, 0.008579317480325699, 0.019607648253440857, -0.010332556441426277, 0.04634172469377518, 0.002164021134376526, 0.024660827592015266, 0.026086676865816116, 0.00968994852155447, -0.03950098901987076, 0.01855539344251156, -0.06766508519649506, -0.07052785158157349, 0.031813591718673706, 0.034049615263938904, -0.03992674872279167, 0.0023899804800748825, 0.05995219573378563, -0.00930155348032713, 0.021614419296383858, 0.007045690901577473, 0.06495221704244614, -0.040126580744981766, -0.013543929904699326, -0.012750976718962193, -0.0780976340174675, 0.03305531293153763, 0.010213484987616539, 0.060303203761577606, 0.016344165429472923, -0.0159956943243742, 0.02322550304234028, -0.037443216890096664, -0.06191794574260712, -0.00998794287443161, -0.02335282787680626, 0.01799439638853073, 0.022031456232070923, 0.011863211169838905, 0.023839155212044716, 0.04877736046910286, -0.015233982354402542, -0.011821075342595577, -0.017216084524989128, 0.04289637878537178, 0.014967984519898891, 0.09136281162500381, 0.018735961988568306, 0.016031846404075623, 0.05967117100954056, -0.023676468059420586, -0.08823124319314957, 0.019604064524173737, 0.01902368851006031, 0.07377073913812637, -0.021767642349004745, 0.02583758905529976, -0.03242426738142967, -0.0055124456994235516, -0.046905335038900375, 0.029200419783592224, 0.0012372405035421252, -0.04930538311600685, -0.009579393081367016, -0.0035429676063358784, -0.026213690638542175, 0.023442624136805534, -0.012686223722994328, -0.049108754843473434, -0.023835333064198494, -0.010569754987955093, 0.04191027209162712, -0.0018071765080094337, 0.008471974171698093, 0.036354485899209976, -0.03232019394636154, -0.026401447132229805, -0.009211269207298756, -0.04022333770990372, 0.031034426763653755, 0.0017262238543480635, 0.047691863030195236, 0.006158526986837387, -0.0375845693051815, 0.034583091735839844, 0.021347979083657265, -0.05109437555074692, 0.018756194040179253, 0.037301454693078995, 0.03538303077220917, 0.02911892719566822, -0.0019322456791996956, 0.0020101782865822315, 0.010506084188818932, -0.01495390199124813, -0.0012743587139993906, -0.017775461077690125, 0.034660790115594864, 0.024324625730514526, -0.025289082899689674, -0.023217665031552315, -0.0477452389895916, 0.003916230518370867, 0.06566151976585388, -0.012350660748779774, -0.002464094664901495, 0.019374145194888115, 2.7610877850747784e-07, 0.055007413029670715, 0.001141084125265479, -0.0010507166152819991, 0.04748344421386719, -0.004493381828069687, 0.03387627378106117, 0.05379730090498924, 0.03797277435660362, 0.02953517995774746, 0.010160444304347038, -0.014243059791624546, -0.017690841108560562, -0.0051977201364934444, 0.03681699186563492, -0.0812196284532547, -0.031053846701979637, 0.026977822184562683, -0.01916159689426422, -0.012896274216473103, 0.05668256804347038, 0.12892572581768036, 0.08268937468528748, 0.05670449137687683, -0.005059727933257818, 0.013541195541620255, -0.03985926881432533, 0.03289875015616417, 0.01237538829445839, 0.04435715079307556, 0.03085559792816639, 0.051442284137010574, 0.03872990608215332, 0.003322390839457512, 0.02700141817331314, 0.01222573034465313, 0.022762391716241837, 0.02020568586885929, 0.023068303242325783, -0.04538222402334213, 0.05276639387011528, 0.025611713528633118, -0.0363445021212101, 0.011778275482356548, 0.017296116799116135, 0.06908727437257767, -0.03202090784907341, -0.05511649698019028, -0.04020174965262413, -0.008376131765544415, -0.009556951001286507, 0.01188513170927763, 0.019597411155700684, -0.012296267785131931, 0.017538750544190407, 0.021449774503707886, -0.04951031133532524, 0.0153009919449687, -0.06362207978963852, -0.006977566983550787, 0.0375971756875515, -0.006800878327339888, 0.0011357200564816594, 0.014235683716833591, 0.0333290733397007, 0.05434182286262512, -0.07257264107465744, 0.0073990728706121445, 3.0471430884954195e-34, -0.013950705528259277, 0.010352842509746552, 0.002934351796284318, 0.07624340802431107, 0.03668254241347313, 0.003408170538023114, -0.010286697186529636, 0.012395092286169529, 0.01066416222602129, -0.049195438623428345, -0.013138965703547001]
655
655
['Dietmar Volz']
1308.1603v4
It will be shown that according to theorems of K. Menger, every neuron grid if identified with a curve is able to preserve the adopted qualitative structure of a data space. Furthermore, if this identification is made, the neuron grid structure can always be mapped to a subset of a universal neuron grid which is constructable in three space dimensions. Conclusions will be drawn for established neuron grid types as well as neural fields.
A Note on Topology Preservation in Classification, and the Construction of a Universal Neuron Grid
2,013
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1308.1603v4
Title Note Topology Preservation Classification Construction Universal Neuron Grid Summary shown according theorem K Menger every neuron grid identified curve able preserve adopted qualitative structure data space Furthermore identification made neuron grid structure always mapped subset universal neuron grid constructable three space dimension Conclusions drawn established neuron grid type well neural field Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.018376406282186508, 0.009212622418999672, -0.02799879014492035, 0.002389247063547373, -0.012164520099759102, 0.007206049747765064, 0.07893484085798264, -0.014987609349191189, 0.008515902794897556, 0.027642400935292244, -0.05880561098456383, 0.001487764879129827, 0.009216845966875553, 0.04748561978340149, 0.0694875493645668, -0.04110242798924446, 0.0032810568809509277, 0.041805051267147064, -0.08111754804849625, -0.025633901357650757, -0.010962549597024918, -0.041088685393333435, -0.016716260462999344, 0.013896897435188293, -0.032284513115882874, -0.0124886529520154, 0.0020542582497000694, -0.04939540475606918, 0.017695967108011246, -0.038157109171152115, 0.018549935892224312, -0.006123099476099014, 0.00273296725936234, -0.005496425554156303, 2.0136831153649837e-06, -0.002646960085257888, 0.006343511864542961, 0.012135287746787071, 0.027954496443271637, 0.0009529913659207523, 0.006811018567532301, 0.010113098658621311, -0.0028652616310864687, -0.05157040059566498, 0.00040174805326387286, 0.023540997877717018, 0.04524022340774536, 0.06647975742816925, 0.0036758598871529102, 0.03408946469426155, -0.021816998720169067, -0.050228551030159, 0.062361814081668854, 0.02113797888159752, 0.006300569511950016, 0.027745991945266724, -0.002657288685441017, 0.039316073060035706, -0.007330720312893391, -0.0521605908870697, -0.014878015965223312, 0.029095744714140892, 0.012404517270624638, -0.0185091495513916, 0.0779951959848404, -0.008649107068777084, 0.01886342279613018, -0.006990557070821524, -0.01952405460178852, 0.014973261393606663, -0.02702307142317295, -0.026172321289777756, -0.004177659284323454, 0.02202962152659893, 0.0004371994873508811, -0.03703134134411812, -0.0635114461183548, 0.0012801035773009062, -0.013069860637187958, -0.0028924064245074987, -0.018764860928058624, 0.0018067678902298212, 0.02602875605225563, -0.04009493440389633, -0.014110252261161804, 0.04255860298871994, 0.04293815419077873, 0.005078843329101801, -0.05182172730565071, -0.0646577849984169, -0.04863448813557625, 0.03512907773256302, 0.06019377335906029, 0.00027383980341255665, 0.014032469131052494, -0.04419983923435211, 0.030716242268681526, -0.04843894764780998, 0.03864173963665962, -0.0016945007955655456, 0.0668872520327568, 0.008939842693507671, 0.04483218118548393, -0.017116738483309746, -0.03151116147637367, 0.023602986708283424, -0.08316583931446075, 0.09591326117515564, 0.011712268926203251, 0.004739047028124332, -0.05334199592471123, 0.03330601751804352, 0.010074133053421974, 0.06190919503569603, 0.07122639566659927, -0.04133263975381851, -0.015581568703055382, 0.08498772978782654, 0.007138948887586594, -0.05962333083152771, -0.005175084341317415, 0.02965111844241619, 0.04900746047496796, 0.014016739092767239, -0.005060742609202862, 0.0031800076831132174, -0.019480597227811813, 0.0381888672709465, -0.0012160332407802343, 0.06271133571863174, 0.01162927970290184, 0.010374569334089756, -0.048318058252334595, 0.010109908878803253, -0.013293663039803505, 0.04938777536153793, 0.04093856364488602, 0.018192598596215248, -0.07126352190971375, 0.024212157353758812, -0.01516261138021946, 0.035850655287504196, 0.016550816595554352, 0.003334693145006895, 0.0019506277749314904, -0.02992730587720871, -0.04294673353433609, 0.006568741984665394, -0.01563839428126812, -0.04509199410676956, -0.005561775527894497, 0.005395662970840931, -0.08463622629642487, -0.01389613188803196, 0.07849907875061035, -0.0013096131151542068, -0.028197897598147392, -0.09382466226816177, 0.01573716476559639, 0.036449965089559555, 0.037786222994327545, -0.020553942769765854, 0.02061152085661888, -0.032477591186761856, 0.046007558703422546, -0.06560201197862625, -0.015594341792166233, -0.06188979372382164, 0.043668560683727264, -0.00956149585545063, -0.004066383931785822, 0.021334081888198853, -0.03107900358736515, -0.054351165890693665, 0.021929282695055008, 0.07688121497631073, 0.05374424532055855, 0.056172460317611694, -0.0628390982747078, -0.07209444046020508, 0.027382416650652885, -0.005136424209922552, 0.006856867112219334, 0.08245615661144257, 0.0033583305776119232, -0.014648121781647205, -0.034941233694553375, 0.0054644630290567875, 0.0210364181548357, -0.04809490963816643, 0.028304317966103554, -0.009846768341958523, -0.012028339318931103, -0.049876343458890915, 0.01688186451792717, 0.021160781383514404, 0.0018626090604811907, -0.01871163584291935, -0.008276786655187607, -0.009761638939380646, -0.011189217679202557, -0.014587905257940292, 0.014799701981246471, -0.07067494094371796, -0.03458641469478607, -0.01741316169500351, -0.059203486889600754, -0.0370098277926445, -0.046510182321071625, 0.03946594521403313, -0.008932196535170078, -0.015069842338562012, -0.004624471068382263, -0.03677016496658325, 0.008463689126074314, 0.003590800566598773, 0.01356598362326622, 0.016141820698976517, -0.016869621351361275, -0.023869942873716354, -0.023958778008818626, 0.002357397461310029, -0.024218278005719185, 0.005349636543542147, 0.013885204680263996, 0.033245284110307693, 0.015204348601400852, 0.01272069662809372, 0.009417375549674034, 0.015791665762662888, 0.026688605546951294, -0.010219919495284557, 0.04484457150101662, -0.014911677688360214, 0.010690303519368172, -0.05824046581983566, -0.07546723634004593, 0.038679562509059906, 0.030734021216630936, 0.027083007618784904, 0.045318301767110825, -0.01236500684171915, 0.04867855831980705, -0.015694787725806236, 0.015195870772004128, 0.023657742887735367, 0.0015437128022313118, -0.04547979682683945, 0.01959993690252304, -0.026634391397237778, 0.015708044171333313, -0.01827012561261654, 0.0063585443422198296, 0.03440745547413826, -0.009845300577580929, 0.0056044259108603, -0.015141668729484081, 0.05776569992303848, -0.03577163442969322, -0.03656931594014168, 0.05663640797138214, -0.035068709403276443, 0.02218099869787693, -0.007447684649378061, -0.002456215675920248, 0.016647422686219215, -0.01559244655072689, -0.03580582141876221, -0.012599744834005833, 0.04421555995941162, 0.018902692943811417, 0.00870230421423912, -0.05349459499120712, 0.030643245205283165, -0.0008804191020317376, 0.01756523735821247, 0.07173816114664078, 0.0073784468695521355, -0.03259680047631264, 0.04592716321349144, 0.013275275006890297, -0.00011938046372961253, -0.02050967328250408, -0.027700159698724747, -0.031103959307074547, 0.06639699637889862, 0.0024891055654734373, -0.06078175827860832, -0.005541364196687937, 0.020891666412353516, -0.026510579511523247, 0.04346238821744919, 0.0037386908661574125, -0.01892193593084812, 0.0006351651391014457, 0.04162240028381348, -0.03529152274131775, 0.08723538368940353, 0.014428900554776192, -0.027205131947994232, -0.03902698680758476, 0.07182526588439941, 0.024479227140545845, 0.0007781707099638879, -0.05918120592832565, 0.060360074043273926, 0.0035526975989341736, 0.026250747963786125, 0.03664727881550789, -0.01427758764475584, 0.058597177267074585, -0.016651159152388573, 0.003143387846648693, 0.0038029381539672613, -0.006342522334307432, 0.012399932369589806, -0.027545567601919174, -0.020885609090328217, -0.027277924120426178, -0.00864133145660162, -0.025351006537675858, 0.008624679408967495, 0.010812883265316486, 0.019700614735484123, 0.021448496729135513, -0.016623852774500847, -0.02121385745704174, 0.013091569766402245, 0.009098418056964874, 0.03656269609928131, 0.02622130513191223, 0.006995607633143663, -0.018155785277485847, -0.00478401780128479, -0.039735324680805206, -0.06447968631982803, 0.006055713631212711, -0.03931539133191109, -0.002694712020456791, -0.044671978801488876, 0.002825436880812049, -0.01085712667554617, -0.039461977779865265, 0.10302960127592087, 0.06497466564178467, 0.04203815758228302, 0.017606941983103752, -0.02452906034886837, 0.03508764132857323, 0.020845506340265274, 0.05575903505086899, 0.0031965277157723904, -0.06676851212978363, 0.023783963173627853, -0.009448793716728687, 0.05824423208832741, -0.016340279951691628, 0.010670623742043972, 0.0007912401342764497, 0.025872852653265, -0.021144820377230644, -0.025870613753795624, -0.08531773835420609, 0.05532967671751976, -0.05024312064051628, 0.011668751947581768, -0.051172886043787, 0.02902180701494217, -0.026494748890399933, -0.03659486770629883, -0.000996823189780116, 0.003902754280716181, 0.05032303184270859, -0.009066327475011349, -0.010718706995248795, -0.07251200824975967, -0.03196060657501221, -0.032774392515420914, -0.06979913264513016, -0.00035766392829827964, -0.001965832430869341, 0.050579413771629333, 0.049696579575538635, -0.040692269802093506, -0.04740050807595253, 0.0052856034599244595, -0.006056030746549368, 0.02882269397377968, 0.010664695873856544, -0.01723168045282364, 0.03879636526107788, -0.09888237714767456, 0.021200031042099, 0.006647106725722551, 0.0005555604002438486, 0.01696840673685074, -0.027796808630228043, 0.03527895733714104, -0.00271653407253325, -0.009541945531964302, 0.019392475485801697, 0.005553225986659527, 0.053839415311813354, -0.018851572647690773, -0.03442054241895676, 0.03266111761331558, -0.003469896735623479, 0.032079603523015976, -0.012966372072696686, -0.09555988758802414, 0.030699847266077995, 0.06535632908344269, 0.03289205953478813, -0.05229415372014046, 0.03262006863951683, 0.07684128731489182, -0.01991802453994751, -0.02716176211833954, 0.05050928518176079, -0.024804480373859406, 0.04719172418117523, -0.07688035070896149, 0.049910761415958405, 0.010289774276316166, 0.02987416461110115, -0.04686421900987625, -0.0046327002346515656, -0.03818196430802345, -0.033973123878240585, 0.01649162732064724, -0.03664517402648926, -0.05373939126729965, 0.010346845723688602, 0.0347561314702034, -0.049562498927116394, -0.01921587809920311, 0.011485760100185871, -0.012628300115466118, -0.05432874709367752, -0.04196462407708168, 0.04281029477715492, -0.017739666625857353, 0.05166579782962799, 0.06555215269327164, -0.04860396310687065, 0.026597848162055016, -0.09173096716403961, -0.03707372769713402, -0.04724225774407387, 0.045420363545417786, -0.013144104741513729, -0.033998943865299225, -0.0006014367681927979, 0.042278170585632324, -0.01739523559808731, -0.023923780769109726, -0.06611279398202896, 0.06519109755754471, -0.01994992047548294, 0.04310348629951477, 0.05784473940730095, 0.0014795551542192698, -0.04838874936103821, 0.007687244564294815, 0.011451697908341885, 0.02430860698223114, 0.05275745317339897, -0.0009389320039190352, 0.06330183893442154, 0.028971435502171516, 0.04147999733686447, -0.03483893349766731, -0.00344113539904356, 0.008451987989246845, 0.030475974082946777, -0.02308781072497368, -0.027301622554659843, -0.03379657492041588, 0.006145636085420847, -0.006250664126127958, -0.011141377501189709, 0.07278987765312195, 0.07315349578857422, 0.03395277261734009, -0.014023125171661377, -0.01611163839697838, 0.060120824724435806, 0.008255599066615105, 0.002680054400116205, -0.028415605425834656, 0.08837532997131348, 0.03903713449835777, -0.013406233862042427, -0.03465969115495682, 0.08539922535419464, 0.0036725786048918962, 0.04577035456895828, -0.04107934981584549, 0.0077139572240412235, 0.045695751905441284, -0.06407435238361359, 0.05148763209581375, -0.038072820752859116, 0.033051203936338425, -0.02797805145382881, 0.02306443266570568, -0.007961953990161419, -0.0008959771366789937, -0.0024288746062666178, -0.030875517055392265, -0.0425603985786438, 0.04371311143040657, -0.016460567712783813, -0.009973048232495785, -0.04961218684911728, 0.00033687817631289363, 0.013399004936218262, 0.07397765666246414, 0.0374227836728096, 0.024179480969905853, -0.007632808294147253, -0.006482805125415325, -0.01299094595015049, 0.0057534766383469105, 0.014194431714713573, 0.03746609389781952, -0.026996180415153503, 0.014264484867453575, -0.07997842878103256, -0.010738510638475418, 0.03778258338570595, -0.03857569023966789, -0.013389707542955875, -0.04275381937623024, 0.008585155941545963, 0.03770110756158829, 0.021801413968205452, -0.03083566017448902, -0.00788009725511074, -0.04631292074918747, -0.018149521201848984, 0.0025304134469479322, 0.07485697418451309, 0.05425504967570305, 0.006367976311594248, 0.025821831077337265, -0.0055389623157680035, -0.03816401585936546, 0.035281792283058167, -0.05397763103246689, 0.04082242026925087, -0.023087028414011, 0.0022835833951830864, -0.024812001734972, -0.05608901008963585, -5.42002776014696e-33, 0.00734394695609808, -0.027724340558052063, 0.020733598619699478, 0.0282604843378067, -0.07840650528669357, -0.03283899277448654, -0.010618357919156551, 0.006267189979553223, -0.056324031203985214, -0.030471237376332283, -0.02294219471514225, -0.009399285539984703, -0.018848031759262085, 0.0017837000777944922, 0.0007925291429273784, 0.027141697704792023, -0.03671809658408165, -0.01950172707438469, 0.0037592127919197083, 0.005912725813686848, 0.04259990155696869, 0.019558632746338844, 0.050673097372055054, -0.0858890488743782, -0.05490368977189064, 0.0006346749141812325, 0.013959496282041073, 0.023349398747086525, -0.06393593549728394, -0.00767386332154274, -0.04075603187084198, -0.014782777987420559, 0.003603843506425619, 0.01984739676117897, -0.014635392464697361, -0.028057947754859924, -0.01615051180124283, -0.005175700876861811, -0.016983142122626305, -0.008069869130849838, -0.026925545185804367, -0.032224319875240326, 0.049324970692396164, -0.020987827330827713, 0.013059391640126705, 0.03902476280927658, 0.016210980713367462, -0.044786952435970306, -0.010437757708132267, 0.022477006539702415, 0.017967360094189644, -0.01634575054049492, 0.01685933582484722, -0.0033011960331350565, 0.0034926815424114466, -0.02487463504076004, -0.0399906300008297, -0.009818797931075096, -0.07129310071468353, 0.039488863199949265, 0.0005272437701933086, 0.031459879130125046, -0.016873516142368317, 0.02546367049217224, 0.09276647865772247, 0.01855779066681862, 0.057565510272979736, 0.010160407982766628, -0.01610592007637024, -0.07455379515886307, 0.014394378289580345, 0.05034240707755089, 0.04853026196360588, -0.018693728372454643, 0.07767075300216675, -0.09140890836715698, -0.037066299468278885, 0.034147508442401886, -0.035819731652736664, 0.04172655940055847, -0.031864047050476074, 0.036174431443214417, 0.0288982056081295, -0.015377026982605457, 0.0555475689470768, -0.07193570584058762, -0.048782069236040115, 0.0063435290940105915, 0.014778769575059414, -0.07182303071022034, -0.003160662017762661, 0.019930705428123474, -0.03610517084598541, -0.03370135650038719, 0.07637269794940948, 0.03499912843108177, 0.02856166660785675, 0.012709186412394047, 0.042547453194856644, -0.027850300073623657, 0.03211187571287155, -0.0041440133936703205, -0.08629699796438217, 0.05782463401556015, 0.017319882288575172, -0.031626999378204346, -0.0024797634687274694, 0.05938800424337387, 0.035267192870378494, -0.0038203175645321608, 0.006515756715089083, -0.063045933842659, 0.07047387212514877, 0.01018165610730648, -0.03198278322815895, -0.06554608047008514, -0.0037784241139888763, 0.03959466889500618, 0.014012069441378117, 0.006506284233182669, -0.0046083964407444, 0.0008993060328066349, -0.01817724108695984, 0.04428151249885559, -0.027299068868160248, -0.008620119653642178, -0.016217311844229698, 0.0788458064198494, 0.001354294829070568, -0.04698748141527176, -0.006523640360683203, 0.04275282472372055, 2.731655115439935e-07, -0.02247357927262783, 0.016195503994822502, 0.012145505286753178, 0.015858611091971397, 0.04270963743329048, -0.019869141280651093, -0.0012962294276803732, 0.0007822337793186307, -0.045086801052093506, -0.018242375925183296, -0.012425936758518219, -0.007893604226410389, -0.013217348605394363, -0.0018895970424637198, -0.03118574246764183, -0.014937256462872028, -0.01211606990545988, 0.03815704584121704, 0.0036481174174696207, 0.013558580540120602, 0.05723002925515175, -0.00967284757643938, 0.005353095475584269, -0.004118757788091898, 0.02402338944375515, -0.010079772211611271, 0.017566654831171036, 0.02937094122171402, 0.08279252797365189, 0.021226916462183, -0.03727194666862488, -0.018646687269210815, -0.019792465493083, -0.007467627990990877, 0.029314348474144936, 0.0019205550197511911, -0.03329743444919586, -0.023418506607413292, 0.017712736502289772, -0.006434142589569092, 0.025918731465935707, -0.01654689572751522, 0.03821506351232529, -0.02667398564517498, -0.022066842764616013, -0.032452818006277084, -0.03960961103439331, 0.007493179757148027, 0.029820971190929413, 0.019812729209661484, 0.05496127903461456, -0.042942583560943604, 0.003728506388142705, -0.06321635842323303, -0.03289506956934929, -0.04201892763376236, 0.03815238177776337, 0.0247897207736969, 0.03347453102469444, 0.05294625461101532, -0.017530329525470734, -0.010017779655754566, -0.00919136218726635, -0.013690490275621414, 0.04395812004804611, -0.024334384128451347, -0.020190685987472534, 2.8866366817303288e-34, -0.001882105483673513, -0.046798355877399445, 0.03380737453699112, 0.001209127134643495, -0.019840961322188377, 0.014032614417374134, 0.07207844406366348, -0.0860564112663269, -0.0395999476313591, -0.022260067984461784, -0.06007206067442894]
656
656
['Louis Yuanlong Shao']
1210.8442v3
One conjecture in both deep learning and classical connectionist viewpoint is that the biological brain implements certain kinds of deep networks as its back-end. However, to our knowledge, a detailed correspondence has not yet been set up, which is important if we want to bridge between neuroscience and machine learning. Recent researches emphasized the biological plausibility of Linear-Nonlinear-Poisson (LNP) neuron model. We show that with neurally plausible settings, the whole network is capable of representing any Boltzmann machine and performing a semi-stochastic Bayesian inference algorithm lying between Gibbs sampling and variational inference.
Linear-Nonlinear-Poisson Neuron Networks Perform Bayesian Inference On Boltzmann Machines
2,012
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1210.8442v3
Title LinearNonlinearPoisson Neuron Networks Perform Bayesian Inference Boltzmann Machines Summary One conjecture deep learning classical connectionist viewpoint biological brain implement certain kind deep network backend However knowledge detailed correspondence yet set important want bridge neuroscience machine learning Recent research emphasized biological plausibility LinearNonlinearPoisson LNP neuron model show neurally plausible setting whole network capable representing Boltzmann machine performing semistochastic Bayesian inference algorithm lying Gibbs sampling variational inference Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.04433208703994751, 0.0404491052031517, -0.029001904651522636, 0.02259504236280918, -0.025148529559373856, 0.007500724866986275, 0.043871693313121796, -0.01455585565418005, -0.03772580251097679, -0.005837182514369488, -0.030823180451989174, 0.01564974896609783, 0.004207680933177471, 0.05848691985011101, 0.0803089365363121, -0.020722821354866028, -0.019703267142176628, 0.007237229496240616, -0.0013636249350383878, -0.05285084992647171, -0.002536566462367773, -0.019920306280255318, -0.05486674606800079, 0.005044419784098864, 0.018038688227534294, 0.01056581549346447, 0.02077222242951393, -0.04539313167333603, 0.017737042158842087, 0.04712957888841629, -0.045354846864938736, -0.02221488766372204, -0.00792655348777771, -0.0056810565292835236, 1.8560266425993177e-06, -0.01750905252993107, 0.024729585275053978, -0.01769948936998844, -0.0029595140367746353, -0.0430905856192112, 0.004808047786355019, -0.017292724922299385, -0.016211986541748047, -0.029586169868707657, -0.00026706288917921484, -0.04673589766025543, 0.05440307781100273, 0.07043354958295822, -0.03389642387628555, 0.0528949573636055, -0.0007957543130032718, -0.041758209466934204, 0.04529256373643875, -0.003970334772020578, 0.08752258867025375, -0.003519729245454073, -0.009626300074160099, -0.020233022049069405, 0.00827273353934288, -0.018325315788388252, -0.034769441932439804, 0.04235267639160156, 0.05166131258010864, 0.010557317174971104, 0.04586377739906311, 0.0801171064376831, 0.05551498383283615, -0.006557146552950144, -0.0022523868829011917, -0.004876702558249235, -0.01704530231654644, 0.007578698452562094, -0.012885588221251965, 0.0009445195901207626, -0.019636768847703934, 0.011306642554700375, -0.05465912073850632, 0.03794444724917412, -0.026787402108311653, 0.02484351210296154, 0.0024615395814180374, -0.009664926677942276, 0.07625975459814072, -0.015454946085810661, 0.022367127239704132, 0.03368989750742912, 0.032604459673166275, 0.04263176769018173, -0.013732662424445152, 0.002896444173529744, -0.01570744998753071, 0.005433598533272743, 0.004710081033408642, 0.013480180874466896, 0.05355450138449669, 0.011026870459318161, 0.017123328521847725, 0.005974268075078726, 0.017013022676110268, -0.025580596178770065, 0.003893428249284625, -0.02071555331349373, -0.009975124150514603, -0.020007457584142685, -0.04376617819070816, -0.02381087839603424, -0.07959295809268951, 0.022923070937395096, 0.013332401402294636, 0.018343385308980942, -0.04680677130818367, -0.019378961995244026, 0.06075803562998772, 0.02648385427892208, 0.008233443833887577, -0.01870344579219818, -0.05331447347998619, 0.03880824148654938, 0.008328895084559917, -0.06338738650083542, -0.03376537188887596, 0.03167649731040001, 0.027802687138319016, -0.0077986386604607105, -0.03465734422206879, 0.010773918591439724, 0.0028789762873202562, 0.05842870473861694, 0.006060292944312096, -0.03804478049278259, 0.01268031820654869, 0.004492838867008686, -0.009464104659855366, 0.022923912853002548, -0.0006771741900593042, 0.07445534318685532, 0.015402968972921371, 0.030357809737324715, -0.04546844959259033, 0.040896784514188766, -0.020309314131736755, 0.02705458179116249, 0.00722185242921114, -0.07920137047767639, -0.000651428708806634, 0.002745529403910041, -0.03314898535609245, -0.014250324107706547, -0.004110348876565695, -0.02968433126807213, -0.010238222777843475, 0.043648481369018555, 0.00848307553678751, -0.03012794628739357, 0.09350749105215073, -0.00990220159292221, 0.030791418626904488, 0.01362603809684515, 0.06729131191968918, -0.02340218611061573, 0.0020307244267314672, -0.02098521776497364, 0.018637103959918022, 0.011997120454907417, 0.004325313027948141, -0.033370647579431534, -0.042987026274204254, -0.10746511071920395, 0.018619297072291374, 0.0466715544462204, 0.037895411252975464, 0.00033136922866106033, -0.02429388090968132, -0.06390752643346786, 0.03867098689079285, 0.02251410111784935, 0.04477587714791298, 0.05299726873636246, 0.019310185685753822, -0.06887595355510712, 0.02152336575090885, 0.007647159043699503, -0.006264192052185535, 0.0761379599571228, -0.047904521226882935, 0.007815546356141567, 0.013073124922811985, -0.027792608365416527, -0.04294847324490547, -0.07299453020095825, 0.01509389840066433, -0.025279980152845383, -0.03401729464530945, -0.03643139451742172, 0.06706534326076508, -0.034664127975702286, 0.001702041714452207, -0.034614529460668564, -0.0025673750787973404, 0.05483056977391243, 0.02172616869211197, -0.02802673727273941, 0.0009605309460312128, -0.026683926582336426, -0.029030021280050278, 0.0022338982671499252, 0.00046304333955049515, -0.015814706683158875, -0.07540184259414673, -0.02157008647918701, -0.021897833794355392, 0.04126627370715141, 0.0477970652282238, -0.003955428954213858, 0.024655800312757492, -0.016948802396655083, 0.016765940934419632, 0.060238067060709, -0.0808916687965393, -0.015968214720487595, 0.003885912708938122, 0.021017959341406822, -0.032506201416254044, -0.02192225307226181, -0.07418472319841385, 0.027980590239167213, 0.04146302118897438, 0.01373261958360672, 0.021281275898218155, -0.004735665395855904, -0.00634878920391202, 0.01926124095916748, 0.01120687834918499, -0.06119144707918167, -0.024919910356402397, -0.01660810224711895, -0.0016578120412304997, -0.03922523185610771, -0.02711954154074192, -0.0051382179372012615, 0.045407623052597046, -0.011617876589298248, 0.0003888863429892808, -0.031559355556964874, 0.037740372121334076, 0.013641121797263622, -0.01788824051618576, -0.018582912161946297, 0.0010932587319985032, 0.023128600791096687, 0.04067925363779068, 0.00939722079783678, -0.008500872179865837, 0.05178195238113403, 0.00907118245959282, -0.01712080091238022, 0.041425518691539764, 0.0024273372255265713, -0.06771533191204071, -0.062041960656642914, 0.001465548062697053, 0.027647677809000015, -0.029932547360658646, -0.02035428397357464, -0.006514818873256445, 0.03581330180168152, 0.011242336593568325, -0.022785155102610588, 0.0347619503736496, 0.02970529906451702, -0.004716051742434502, -0.018806079402565956, 0.0061730253510177135, 0.012521772645413876, 0.04598991572856903, -0.04503823071718216, 0.09873258322477341, 0.05830716714262962, -0.011741184629499912, 0.04419659450650215, -0.006490545812994242, 0.00822913832962513, -0.005222224164754152, -0.05500296875834465, -0.034169770777225494, 0.054226718842983246, 0.05031220242381096, -0.01981639675796032, 0.016712095588445663, 0.0578150674700737, -0.048991985619068146, 0.03057067096233368, 0.015589882619678974, -0.015707088634371758, -0.00836319662630558, -0.047571249306201935, -0.024150066077709198, 0.0693654716014862, 0.024655669927597046, -0.04745461046695709, -0.009190503507852554, 0.08203645795583725, 0.030396779999136925, -0.023188762366771698, -0.06265512853860855, 0.03402382880449295, 0.00785929337143898, -0.011776757426559925, -0.03607605770230293, 0.028482913970947266, 0.04093012586236, -0.004567085299640894, 0.015884777531027794, 0.044051993638277054, 0.04665539413690567, -0.018438279628753662, -0.031841181218624115, 0.01977921649813652, -0.00871168915182352, 0.036229152232408524, -0.011671820655465126, -0.037528980523347855, 0.08119285851716995, 0.061644624918699265, 0.007858107797801495, -0.003387494944036007, -0.018105456605553627, 0.004974700510501862, 0.020054150372743607, 0.10758938640356064, 0.009733450599014759, -0.005989860277622938, -0.03901180252432823, -0.012807974591851234, -0.00029709600494243205, -0.0413929708302021, 0.01833057962357998, 0.021182402968406677, -0.007807693909853697, -0.0309324711561203, 0.021286863833665848, 0.004207137506455183, -0.013022501021623611, 0.03794916719198227, -0.024075953289866447, 0.005910188425332308, 0.002273241290822625, -0.020182393491268158, 0.026640135794878006, -0.010281087830662727, 0.014718329533934593, 0.02163497731089592, -0.03518993407487869, -0.02501760609447956, -0.02217019908130169, -0.0034355835523456335, 0.029342688620090485, -0.013872050680220127, 0.05443556234240532, 0.027521707117557526, 0.021935326978564262, 0.009125969372689724, -0.04775330796837807, 0.05059153959155083, -0.0785292312502861, 0.007602343801409006, -0.051471106708049774, 0.014861565083265305, -0.04076379910111427, 0.020827973261475563, -0.043745219707489014, 0.00041025265818461776, 0.0011670944513753057, 0.03343960642814636, -0.06386205554008484, -0.08759685605764389, -0.0223537664860487, -0.019405042752623558, -0.0700431540608406, -0.03691841661930084, 0.023924510926008224, -0.06073841080069542, -0.016245217993855476, -0.05318443104624748, -0.03743923455476761, -0.01745358668267727, -0.02354651503264904, 0.02139219641685486, -0.033438000828027725, 0.017984436824917793, 0.023746630176901817, -0.03258145973086357, 0.0248092208057642, -0.06380266696214676, -0.01796143315732479, -0.040483955293893814, -0.015354139730334282, -0.008323450572788715, 0.040153369307518005, 0.007135110907256603, 0.004916905891150236, -0.0014125278685241938, -0.03903749957680702, 0.02801884338259697, -0.0789741724729538, 0.06556039303541183, 0.054877083748579025, -0.0070420075207948685, -0.07189079374074936, -0.014694852754473686, 0.003106675809249282, -0.029824336990714073, 0.012995588593184948, -0.028948673978447914, 0.023922612890601158, 0.038347724825143814, -0.026165632531046867, -0.018675094470381737, 0.09054847061634064, -0.04946346580982208, 0.05509277060627937, -0.01738407276570797, 0.02277194894850254, -0.03206588700413704, -0.03253988176584244, -0.040387485176324844, 0.024375440552830696, -0.009960140101611614, 0.02794472686946392, 0.01520808320492506, -0.041208915412425995, -0.07169835269451141, -0.023329677060246468, 0.0017564354930073023, 0.0003235348267480731, -0.05351722240447998, 0.025898844003677368, 0.016764115542173386, -0.12962743639945984, -0.02715393528342247, 0.01938495971262455, -0.028052624315023422, 0.05770501494407654, 0.029260605573654175, -0.015723558142781258, 0.03928499296307564, -0.06977373361587524, 0.02143966220319271, -0.03183674439787865, 0.07264842092990875, -0.02151702530682087, -0.027957743033766747, 0.010341212153434753, 0.05766909942030907, -0.06056716665625572, 0.005865731742233038, -0.051126521080732346, -0.042802419513463974, -0.006758079864084721, 0.0014979287516325712, 0.054401688277721405, 0.011687563732266426, 0.004586998838931322, -0.005761574022471905, -0.027958925813436508, -0.012946573086082935, 0.061346594244241714, 0.03910002112388611, 0.04284010827541351, -0.005695681553333998, 0.025366872549057007, 0.002395598916336894, 0.01836976781487465, 0.0009077807189896703, 0.07279739528894424, 0.004767834674566984, -0.031046533957123756, -0.01708698645234108, -0.0027952147647738457, -0.004423161968588829, -0.00622761994600296, 0.0653400719165802, 0.03127742186188698, -0.02941112406551838, -0.025816434994339943, -0.024268830195069313, 0.021289559081196785, 0.057359497994184494, -0.035192374140024185, -0.019322438165545464, 0.05101746693253517, 0.07243179529905319, 0.004871527198702097, -0.06329429894685745, 0.06425417214632034, 0.003709255950525403, 0.01977325789630413, -0.01480608619749546, 0.04659046232700348, -0.0027117396239191294, -0.07093372195959091, 0.010151620022952557, -0.018333211541175842, 0.009396613575518131, -0.01605551689863205, 0.025960855185985565, 0.0012390456395223737, 0.023130685091018677, 0.01003466360270977, -0.004607906565070152, -0.0761546939611435, -0.021678293123841286, -0.07432441413402557, 0.008552772924304008, 0.028603937476873398, 0.014046546071767807, 0.02336454577744007, 0.002599185798317194, 0.00017864833353087306, -0.058798450976610184, 0.02424764260649681, -0.042357295751571655, 0.015782557427883148, -0.013860061764717102, 0.03685073181986809, 0.03638201951980591, 0.027272962033748627, 0.030923670157790184, -0.05261005088686943, 0.03460581973195076, 0.02885602042078972, 0.0005776176112703979, 0.007717648521065712, 0.0018247965490445495, 0.02314387448132038, 0.017525654286146164, -0.027770763263106346, -0.012955051846802235, -0.01519808266311884, -0.010015161707997322, -0.008208326995372772, -0.011502156034111977, 0.022524230182170868, 0.029261795803904533, 0.04160567373037338, -0.023549910634756088, -0.0062006935477256775, 0.04939846321940422, 0.014887772500514984, -0.024174267426133156, 0.0005946735618636012, 0.03896564990282059, 0.023214392364025116, -0.005834151059389114, -0.020640555769205093, -5.278356078959904e-33, 0.03984000161290169, -0.02482755482196808, 0.00948302261531353, 0.03383932635188103, 0.00880048330873251, 0.008116467855870724, -0.011384849436581135, 0.006322977598756552, -0.010706240311264992, -0.015821708366274834, 0.004366622772067785, 0.017421642318367958, -0.0014971877681091428, 0.036200523376464844, 0.04499729350209236, -0.030420847237110138, -0.035637203603982925, -0.01546834222972393, 0.07057438790798187, 0.008421365171670914, 0.05540761351585388, 0.012219234369695187, 0.03702833130955696, -0.019338831305503845, -0.02101333811879158, -0.0026871217414736748, -0.01560161728411913, -0.0024977370630949736, -0.03458019345998764, 0.02347979135811329, -0.025389112532138824, 0.021423451602458954, 0.010981503874063492, -0.035259757190942764, 0.005645411554723978, -0.021345537155866623, 0.00462691392749548, 0.00738257821649313, 0.0005865750717930496, -0.016466444358229637, -0.018269019201397896, -0.033686745911836624, 0.1045343279838562, 0.002299192827194929, -0.027186576277017593, -0.003396788612008095, 0.024186279624700546, -0.07550796866416931, -0.018842533230781555, -0.015581219457089901, -0.019084954634308815, -0.02045522816479206, -0.016153721138834953, 0.035391904413700104, 0.0186750628054142, -0.03665162995457649, -0.07075340300798416, 0.015326562337577343, -0.06973746418952942, 0.04335140436887741, 0.04318993166089058, 0.02903134562075138, 0.013304910622537136, 0.046669576317071915, 0.09762439876794815, 0.04590459540486336, 0.13564617931842804, -0.019815703853964806, -0.09418651461601257, -0.0034695731010288, 0.024589985609054565, 0.014092701487243176, 0.040477216243743896, 0.021314458921551704, 0.10656864941120148, -0.008286766707897186, -0.08491635322570801, 0.034466128796339035, 0.03030632808804512, 0.0043332804925739765, 0.0075976187363266945, 0.002447923179715872, 0.013875743374228477, -0.017743205651640892, 0.02066161297261715, -0.06106101721525192, -0.023325130343437195, -0.04324181377887726, -0.038882460445165634, -0.0869159996509552, 0.04640985280275345, 0.027462705969810486, -0.003396704327315092, -0.0006168052786961198, 0.038596607744693756, -0.0035065419506281614, 0.043549545109272, 0.02964632213115692, 0.03995649889111519, 0.0018169053364545107, -0.015501497313380241, -0.012569083832204342, -0.06733229756355286, 0.015485916286706924, -0.002119966084137559, 0.051576245576143265, -0.019449397921562195, 0.030529333278536797, 0.04006406292319298, -0.024070587009191513, -0.02103482373058796, -0.07917425036430359, 0.06399974972009659, 0.028596067801117897, 0.024152373895049095, -0.07763680070638657, 0.008524796925485134, 0.06359345465898514, -0.004780953750014305, 0.033490102738142014, 0.0019017609301954508, 0.032916221767663956, -0.017277473583817482, 0.056814905256032944, -0.06522113084793091, -0.03546642139554024, -0.018201660364866257, 0.002627976704388857, -0.03275587782263756, -0.08258068561553955, -0.006349617149680853, 0.028156736865639687, 2.589876544334402e-07, -0.011734047904610634, -0.053963616490364075, -0.00637228274717927, -0.0396246537566185, 0.06892065703868866, 0.004856645129621029, 0.014285868033766747, -0.01977117918431759, 0.0011896216310560703, -0.06910736858844757, 0.035409826785326004, 0.018772201612591743, -0.019847385585308075, -0.0049613770097494125, -0.06133565679192543, -0.03451726213097572, 0.005359482951462269, 0.049717940390110016, 0.026056811213493347, -0.023857537657022476, 9.205699461745098e-05, 0.04584242403507233, 0.011352544650435448, -0.037117935717105865, 0.06797027587890625, 0.017314674332737923, 0.02741270326077938, 0.014505226165056229, 0.00688982754945755, -0.010120101273059845, 0.006010967306792736, -0.029459552839398384, 0.02439401112496853, 0.02554301917552948, 0.022490354254841805, -0.008099944330751896, -0.029360806569457054, -0.006142309866845608, -0.004397188313305378, -0.004576030652970076, 0.02458902820944786, -0.0011815628968179226, 0.028187403455376625, 0.017876306548714638, 0.020367322489619255, -0.023946300148963928, -0.0791807696223259, -0.01003960520029068, -0.005399409215897322, -0.006743220146745443, 0.06129475682973862, -0.015736065804958344, 0.0011020221281796694, -0.05789520591497421, -0.0228031687438488, -0.058728523552417755, 0.02461695857346058, 0.004596891812980175, 0.021222896873950958, 0.046815939247608185, -0.032920923084020615, -0.0068562873639166355, -0.04588044062256813, -0.03559000790119171, 0.10207489132881165, -0.01792418211698532, -0.049779556691646576, 2.2505989586082073e-34, -0.009865264408290386, 0.00826900266110897, -0.014724977314472198, 0.022534847259521484, -0.04378708824515343, -0.01255311444401741, -0.031385697424411774, -0.04817363619804382, -0.00989531073719263, -0.050056036561727524, -0.06493177264928818]
657
657
['Enmei Tu', 'Nikola Kasabov', 'Jie Yang']
1603.05594v1
This paper proposes a new method for an optimized mapping of temporal variables, describing a temporal stream data, into the recently proposed NeuCube spiking neural network architecture. This optimized mapping extends the use of the NeuCube, which was initially designed for spatiotemporal brain data, to work on arbitrary stream data and to achieve a better accuracy of temporal pattern recognition, a better and earlier event prediction and a better understanding of complex temporal stream data through visualization of the NeuCube connectivity. The effect of the new mapping is demonstrated on three bench mark problems. The first one is early prediction of patient sleep stage event from temporal physiological data. The second one is pattern recognition of dynamic temporal patterns of traffic in the Bay Area of California and the last one is the Challenge 2012 contest data set. In all cases the use of the proposed mapping leads to an improved accuracy of pattern recognition and event prediction and a better understanding of the data when compared to traditional machine learning techniques or spiking neural network reservoirs with arbitrary mapping of the variables.
Mapping Temporal Variables into the NeuCube for Improved Pattern Recognition, Predictive Modelling and Understanding of Stream Data
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1603.05594v1
Title Mapping Temporal Variables NeuCube Improved Pattern Recognition Predictive Modelling Understanding Stream Data Summary paper proposes new method optimized mapping temporal variable describing temporal stream data recently proposed NeuCube spiking neural network architecture optimized mapping extends use NeuCube initially designed spatiotemporal brain data work arbitrary stream data achieve better accuracy temporal pattern recognition better earlier event prediction better understanding complex temporal stream data visualization NeuCube connectivity effect new mapping demonstrated three bench mark problem first one early prediction patient sleep stage event temporal physiological data second one pattern recognition dynamic temporal pattern traffic Bay Area California last one Challenge 2012 contest data set case use proposed mapping lead improved accuracy pattern recognition event prediction better understanding data compared traditional machine learning technique spiking neural network reservoir arbitrary mapping variable Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.03617202118039131, -0.012301030568778515, -0.032941706478595734, -0.005760688800364733, 0.004749706480652094, 0.016142960637807846, 0.019739855080842972, -0.02388072945177555, -0.021417731419205666, 0.01587310992181301, 0.03027486428618431, -0.020441768690943718, 0.025372151285409927, 0.1118316650390625, 0.029465314000844955, -0.05357062444090843, 0.04698621481657028, 0.009946172125637531, -0.0012183724902570248, 0.05517353117465973, 0.003249236149713397, -0.021191101521253586, -0.010970903560519218, 0.03754293918609619, -0.010916518047451973, -0.006553465034812689, -0.02853785641491413, -0.06253370642662048, 0.04403528943657875, -0.09198286384344101, 0.014810135588049889, -0.012845564633607864, -0.005950761027634144, 0.02138247713446617, 2.081934098896454e-06, -0.01658465713262558, 0.014011222869157791, -0.009067043662071228, 0.029191985726356506, -0.055950894951820374, -0.011876663193106651, -0.024241190403699875, 0.03222633898258209, 0.0015164430951699615, -0.05531545728445053, 0.03461018204689026, 0.06893327832221985, 0.056438133120536804, 0.0005924878641963005, 0.04139057546854019, -0.03470131754875183, -0.0042992252856493, 0.025457283481955528, 0.0017010582378134131, 0.05115741491317749, 0.022555459290742874, 0.01664559356868267, -0.018937844783067703, 0.028066759929060936, -0.06822171807289124, -0.017913036048412323, 0.004352887626737356, 0.0139734772965312, 0.014904830604791641, 0.09632722288370132, 0.07254534959793091, -0.014462480321526527, 0.001013382337987423, -0.030854208394885063, 0.03208429366350174, -0.021941237151622772, 0.01569296233355999, 0.04056309536099434, 0.03465156629681587, -0.0511375293135643, -0.03544669970870018, -0.040324367582798004, -0.06539393216371536, 0.0006884059403091669, -0.00186575623229146, 0.006004903465509415, 0.04992605373263359, 0.017455147579312325, 0.012031901627779007, 0.01322618406265974, 0.021024880930781364, -0.01870773360133171, 0.02991466037929058, -0.02088123932480812, -0.02690819650888443, 0.016539141535758972, -0.02216940186917782, 0.04506922513246536, 0.02827550284564495, -0.057676762342453, -0.022647839039564133, -0.02167816087603569, -0.01978336274623871, -0.012443925254046917, -0.07024897634983063, 0.056629057973623276, 0.02224413864314556, 0.03466331586241722, -0.017202671617269516, -0.03531084209680557, 0.029030751436948776, -0.03835628926753998, 0.04175476357340813, -0.011228460818529129, 0.02242273837327957, -0.07969627529382706, 0.02676725573837757, 0.03769193962216377, 0.031191084533929825, 0.02314949780702591, -0.011121891438961029, -0.081575907766819, 0.03532988950610161, -0.0038411859422922134, -0.057001739740371704, -0.03535349667072296, 0.05859893932938576, 0.03546174615621567, 0.02735566720366478, -0.03285783529281616, 0.02162783406674862, -0.0007686012540943921, 0.0444314144551754, -0.012654846534132957, 0.009251367300748825, 0.00025874999118968844, -0.0181256290525198, -0.010611085221171379, 0.029090948402881622, -0.0310190599411726, 0.005255177151411772, -0.0024232598952949047, 0.01739509403705597, -0.09569597244262695, 0.028871124610304832, 0.032743580639362335, 0.034151654690504074, -0.012986106798052788, -0.04306701570749283, 0.002251284196972847, -0.010745268315076828, -0.05142053961753845, 0.024210793897509575, 0.01216090377420187, -0.05382506921887398, -0.011596711352467537, 0.058457180857658386, -0.03255500644445419, -0.0014397883787751198, 0.05239512398838997, -0.013479063287377357, 0.0028457073494791985, 0.004179093055427074, 0.08247683197259903, 0.009730977937579155, -0.02264360524713993, -0.013574388809502125, 0.0036277147009968758, -0.03275812044739723, 0.004888603929430246, -0.0793849527835846, -0.062071431428194046, -0.02461848594248295, -0.015841756016016006, 0.011916643008589745, 0.03579244762659073, 0.0035622185096144676, 0.013380628079175949, -0.023213380947709084, 0.03775712475180626, 0.022226562723517418, -0.010833585634827614, 0.0037668789736926556, -0.007194411009550095, -0.03577427566051483, -0.036444686353206635, -0.08052823692560196, -0.004572583362460136, 0.11950258165597916, 0.0029876569751650095, -0.044355154037475586, -0.05460106208920479, 0.008483204059302807, -0.009988993406295776, -0.046355605125427246, 0.02367720752954483, -0.011667583137750626, -0.006074061151593924, -0.0074619110673666, 0.013538481667637825, -0.041498586535453796, 0.010940136387944221, 0.03597145155072212, -0.02751077152788639, 0.09682252258062363, -0.007931780070066452, -0.031752169132232666, -0.027744615450501442, 0.031252749264240265, -0.0067206439562141895, -0.0037566348910331726, -0.055925194174051285, -0.05056452006101608, -0.00882708840072155, -0.021169239655137062, -0.008366063237190247, 0.015013053081929684, 0.061030302196741104, -0.04724294692277908, 0.003336864523589611, 0.03378598764538765, -0.0029036703053861856, 0.010510402731597424, -0.04421807825565338, 0.05526989698410034, 0.005187600385397673, 0.04665594920516014, -0.056198976933956146, 0.00019765445904340595, -0.08439648896455765, 0.0032161525450646877, 0.03909512236714363, 0.007431386969983578, 0.027358565479516983, -0.024910954758524895, 0.026337755843997, 0.0066011035814881325, 0.01838310807943344, -0.044845327734947205, 0.00414865231141448, 0.04414066672325134, -0.014937948435544968, 0.0014901503454893827, 0.005664670839905739, 0.02761927805840969, 0.026913410052657127, 0.03591705858707428, -0.03545312583446503, -0.058214183896780014, 0.01953108422458172, -0.03677627816796303, 0.01757023110985756, -0.009384574368596077, 0.02619975060224533, 0.02331412024796009, 0.025366388261318207, 0.008426763117313385, 0.0022485197987407446, -0.006400764919817448, -0.005521814804524183, -0.015219376422464848, 0.020404430106282234, 0.02446460910141468, -0.054502539336681366, -0.02973002940416336, 0.015640299767255783, -0.06370334327220917, -0.0611485131084919, -0.032907817512750626, -0.027177663519978523, -0.021876703947782516, 0.008752932772040367, -0.03304227814078331, -0.001358264358714223, 0.04068208485841751, -0.0025255735963582993, -0.021011514589190483, -0.014293626882135868, -0.011510537937283516, -0.05660929158329964, -0.012794369831681252, 0.06643553078174591, -0.015369323082268238, -0.007176037412136793, 0.033725619316101074, 0.0437118224799633, -0.01988132856786251, -0.008081651292741299, 0.019719021394848824, -0.05580194666981697, 0.018308322876691818, 0.0362662710249424, -0.11383113265037537, -0.006984667386859655, 0.013164255768060684, 0.00802200473845005, -0.004561171401292086, 0.012045622803270817, -0.012215282768011093, -0.010586412623524666, 0.008280695416033268, 0.0087912417948246, 0.025814957916736603, 0.07282315939664841, -0.030144264921545982, -0.0068247574381530285, -0.03448206186294556, 0.044718142598867416, 0.04213244467973709, -0.01728135347366333, 0.06994328647851944, 0.0004574317135848105, -0.01634899154305458, -0.01509757898747921, 0.026326492428779602, 0.04888949170708656, 0.001974021317437291, 0.014073223806917667, 0.014169517904520035, -0.008074862882494926, -0.009342088364064693, -0.059942834079265594, 0.01289910264313221, -0.016363799571990967, 0.002113541355356574, -0.021265510469675064, -0.04591625928878784, 0.0019412300316616893, 0.0673254132270813, 0.030137069523334503, -0.003341204021126032, -0.03903939202427864, -0.015132409520447254, 0.020644960924983025, 0.004580381792038679, 0.015827178955078125, -0.04167596250772476, -0.04579636827111244, 0.010058584623038769, -0.02688557654619217, -0.05248470604419708, -0.027528291568160057, -0.004712010268121958, -0.03555305674672127, -0.014246665872633457, -0.009232253767549992, -0.029726093634963036, -0.06250244379043579, 0.01541716419160366, 0.014593088068068027, -0.03227744996547699, -0.008507765829563141, 0.004888872615993023, -0.019961707293987274, 0.06243784353137016, -0.019969984889030457, 0.021147461608052254, -0.05071315914392471, -0.05038531497120857, -0.0015381976263597608, 0.04319264739751816, 0.0853443592786789, 0.049809202551841736, -0.0046644969843328, 0.04022151976823807, 0.007158174179494381, 0.018805190920829773, -0.008596157655119896, 0.04953688010573387, -0.12181974947452545, 0.017824111506342888, -0.042701806873083115, -0.012283978052437305, -0.012316697277128696, 0.013458752073347569, -0.012584743089973927, -0.0444130003452301, 0.03528568521142006, 0.05276067554950714, 0.033895883709192276, -0.05497746169567108, -0.009516410529613495, -0.015425893478095531, -0.026487598195672035, -0.026639413088560104, 0.02488846145570278, 0.022926343604922295, 0.025289516896009445, -0.04501379653811455, -0.005867799744009972, -0.031187547370791435, -0.02054683119058609, -0.016422417014837265, 0.03142751380801201, 0.06284583359956741, 0.025553107261657715, -0.06512486934661865, -0.011179155670106411, -0.05600571259856224, 0.025103511288762093, -0.039213452488183975, -0.021697282791137695, -0.04906865581870079, 0.029277227818965912, -0.02159011922776699, 0.06563001871109009, -0.04410921782255173, -0.04659891501069069, 0.02854537032544613, -0.040172088891267776, 0.07644706219434738, 0.029665829613804817, 0.06898914277553558, -0.02762594260275364, -0.007558027282357216, -0.01384017150849104, 0.05750541761517525, 0.03895990923047066, -0.020122697576880455, 0.02144276350736618, 0.07072238624095917, 0.0033489027991890907, -0.04218217730522156, 0.05911716818809509, -0.009321669116616249, 0.014751285314559937, 0.003845342667773366, 0.06890895962715149, -0.0581706203520298, 0.02247443050146103, -0.09183532744646072, 0.025787681341171265, 0.040117476135492325, -0.00011425283446442336, -0.027457069605588913, -0.01343374140560627, -0.0487307533621788, 0.015480432659387589, 0.02335749939084053, -0.02314094826579094, -0.024108391255140305, -0.027959637343883514, 0.028656959533691406, -0.05872231721878052, -0.0028705080039799213, -0.016802053898572922, -0.03989435359835625, 0.043266601860523224, 0.03906669095158577, 0.08085056394338608, 0.08817770332098007, -0.02831011451780796, -0.019930295646190643, 0.0005391192389652133, 0.06005541980266571, 0.027409594506025314, -0.04736703261733055, -0.022643916308879852, -0.019306831061840057, -0.018674589693546295, -0.005527183413505554, -0.00046596137690357864, -0.061972204595804214, 0.014163700863718987, 0.021350910887122154, 0.007852970622479916, 0.008043630048632622, 0.021421991288661957, -0.028615249320864677, 0.014394925907254219, 0.05599058419466019, 0.05730540305376053, 0.05222473666071892, -0.015752365812659264, -0.014922521077096462, 0.02912290021777153, -0.024167565628886223, -0.026670459657907486, 0.01520899124443531, 0.06078958138823509, -0.022630691528320312, -0.03197165206074715, -0.0005420419620350003, 0.027061574161052704, -0.030843369662761688, 0.0013816716382279992, 0.09116937220096588, 0.04738173261284828, 0.012237065471708775, -0.03391260653734207, -0.0206193495541811, -0.007550636772066355, 0.0517180971801281, -0.0017280029132962227, -0.04163484647870064, 0.04837590828537941, 0.03364568576216698, -0.03320314362645149, -0.05032516270875931, 0.0416075624525547, -0.12248185276985168, -0.040121641010046005, -0.009884320199489594, 0.021571047604084015, 0.007658091839402914, -0.0632835403084755, 0.047821931540966034, 0.01765715703368187, -0.014897715300321579, 0.027571815997362137, 0.017889680340886116, -0.01754825748503208, 0.049611400812864304, 0.0027654594741761684, -0.001807874534279108, -0.028992492705583572, 0.021421082317829132, -0.0494520366191864, 0.03896839916706085, 0.0050724949687719345, -0.051665179431438446, 0.014549422077834606, -0.022815078496932983, 0.003655410837382078, -0.00366547261364758, 0.036783602088689804, -0.04941423609852791, 0.049895912408828735, -0.037839893251657486, 0.035144463181495667, 0.03221585601568222, -0.008457347750663757, -0.019658371806144714, -0.03219430521130562, -0.006901344750076532, 0.014637215994298458, -0.02643820084631443, 0.03519527241587639, -0.05838541314005852, -0.006621449254453182, 0.049360767006874084, 0.01446967851370573, -0.04411596804857254, -0.041188448667526245, 0.00863003171980381, -0.018986620008945465, 0.038183197379112244, 0.08954905718564987, -0.04253857210278511, 0.031038906425237656, -0.006163293495774269, 0.018603824079036713, -0.010569431819021702, -0.028142664581537247, -0.03325757756829262, -0.014093070290982723, -0.009370064362883568, -0.008795090019702911, -0.0503910630941391, -0.06545940041542053, -5.787805412372698e-33, -0.016815315932035446, -0.0324011966586113, 0.023219479247927666, 0.003024470526725054, -0.023898756131529808, 0.040029797703027725, -0.027302725240588188, -0.005279057193547487, -3.343202479300089e-05, -0.02890520915389061, -0.02778914012014866, 0.02111939527094364, 0.022143132984638214, 0.005202149040997028, 0.06493912637233734, -0.023868802934885025, 0.0028011109679937363, -0.012530435808002949, 0.044288601726293564, 0.005098150111734867, 0.03815355896949768, 0.029635220766067505, 0.05271584540605545, -0.08867104351520538, -0.0658997967839241, 0.07154543697834015, 0.008863935247063637, -0.029503000900149345, 0.03446027263998985, 0.007687303703278303, -0.03232553228735924, 0.013334051705896854, 0.02050190418958664, -0.008304608054459095, -0.008420420810580254, -0.01768261380493641, -0.04386378452181816, -0.0496223159134388, -0.029256310313940048, -0.019964491948485374, -0.014470009133219719, -0.011056351475417614, 0.06632856279611588, -0.021837826818227768, 0.004535358864814043, 0.009234867990016937, 0.038755860179662704, -0.03094238042831421, -0.0008784749661572278, -0.009490610100328922, -0.004227512050420046, 0.027523329481482506, -0.02238384261727333, 0.0014100089902058244, -0.010527600534260273, 0.015733985230326653, -0.05259852111339569, -0.002240994246676564, -0.12897762656211853, 0.058701902627944946, 0.004262060858309269, 0.036908600479364395, -0.025790778920054436, 0.04614564776420593, 0.08853955566883087, 0.03667348250746727, 0.0303622018545866, -0.011298911646008492, -0.025884592905640602, 0.037961896508932114, 0.027632633224129677, 0.05713043361902237, 0.009689506143331528, -0.0017898759106174111, 0.0947640985250473, -0.08672191202640533, -0.038935888558626175, 0.057320285588502884, 0.021924683824181557, 0.012995048426091671, 0.034035056829452515, -0.022050194442272186, -0.04257836937904358, 0.0027333106845617294, 0.06504150480031967, 0.009871411137282848, -0.01064616534858942, -0.012347390875220299, 0.027970626950263977, -0.010216420516371727, 0.059737611562013626, 0.024929460138082504, 0.0033975918777287006, -0.034863244742155075, 0.05962660163640976, -0.0191684290766716, 0.0324673056602478, -0.007737054955214262, 0.060177095234394073, -0.007775148376822472, -0.03394760936498642, -0.00354642141610384, -0.0034107377287000418, -0.029981642961502075, 0.05447961390018463, -0.028331538662314415, -0.0023149719927459955, 0.06513276696205139, 0.029082518070936203, -0.02953323721885681, 0.012397220358252525, -0.02331649139523506, 0.04203649237751961, -0.008565874770283699, 0.021210871636867523, -0.0716300755739212, 0.008083716966211796, 0.02593294531106949, -0.004419920966029167, 0.04714260622859001, 0.0002525115560274571, -0.004041808657348156, -0.0037479845341295004, 0.043257348239421844, -0.011814501136541367, 0.026410430669784546, -0.08152645826339722, 0.02193504571914673, -0.03502625972032547, -0.052154541015625, -0.009127913974225521, 0.02479637786746025, 2.8987335554120364e-07, -0.03794309124350548, 0.03413990139961243, -0.0069466037675738335, 0.00685496162623167, 0.06394506245851517, -0.026576438918709755, 0.009524382650852203, 0.015720609575510025, 0.00044875359162688255, 0.009116512723267078, 0.04148833081126213, -0.03055036999285221, 0.05663350597023964, 0.04855778068304062, -0.02975781261920929, -0.09585165232419968, -0.005527936387807131, 0.038264043629169464, -0.018351994454860687, -0.01454500388354063, 0.008657480590045452, 0.05129691958427429, 0.04019198939204216, -0.011655713431537151, 0.047039762139320374, -0.022085340693593025, 0.012763909995555878, 0.011942606419324875, 0.01666724868118763, -0.014128871262073517, 0.008498536422848701, -0.006622471380978823, -0.009706603363156319, 0.013482163660228252, -0.011124351061880589, 0.03479255735874176, -0.02597118355333805, -0.00833445880562067, -0.047286830842494965, -0.03700685501098633, 0.026697665452957153, 0.01581559330224991, 0.031181607395410538, -0.04181257262825966, 0.029961997643113136, -0.02756630629301071, -0.05711015313863754, -0.009677734225988388, 0.005442595575004816, 0.05142386257648468, 0.08861489593982697, -0.00026940766838379204, -0.03600398078560829, -0.0193941593170166, 0.024678751826286316, -0.04018489643931389, -0.0003823495062533766, 0.002939861034974456, -0.007114916108548641, -0.0043415590189397335, -0.014798576012253761, 0.004837803542613983, -0.05324167013168335, 0.001762829371728003, 0.06224678456783295, 1.9472594431135803e-05, -0.02012559026479721, 2.4322782686012633e-34, -0.03706083446741104, -0.017726590856909752, -0.03792128711938858, -0.00913998857140541, -0.006333477329462767, 0.01275560725480318, 0.008513904176652431, 0.005020901560783386, -0.021273409947752953, -0.0391988568007946, -0.04439183697104454]
658
658
['Jörn Hees', 'Rouven Bauer', 'Joachim Folz', 'Damian Borth', 'Andreas Dengel']
1607.07249v3
Efficient usage of the knowledge provided by the Linked Data community is often hindered by the need for domain experts to formulate the right SPARQL queries to answer questions. For new questions they have to decide which datasets are suitable and in which terminology and modelling style to phrase the SPARQL query. In this work we present an evolutionary algorithm to help with this challenging task. Given a training list of source-target node-pair examples our algorithm can learn patterns (SPARQL queries) from a SPARQL endpoint. The learned patterns can be visualised to form the basis for further investigation, or they can be used to predict target nodes for new source nodes. Amongst others, we apply our algorithm to a dataset of several hundred human associations (such as "circle - square") to find patterns for them in DBpedia. We show the scalability of the algorithm by running it against a SPARQL endpoint loaded with > 7.9 billion triples. Further, we use the resulting SPARQL queries to mimic human associations with a Mean Average Precision (MAP) of 39.9 % and a Recall@10 of 63.9 %.
An Evolutionary Algorithm to Learn SPARQL Queries for Source-Target-Pairs: Finding Patterns for Human Associations in DBpedia
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1607.07249v3
Title Evolutionary Algorithm Learn SPARQL Queries SourceTargetPairs Finding Patterns Human Associations DBpedia Summary Efficient usage knowledge provided Linked Data community often hindered need domain expert formulate right SPARQL query answer question new question decide datasets suitable terminology modelling style phrase SPARQL query work present evolutionary algorithm help challenging task Given training list sourcetarget nodepair example algorithm learn pattern SPARQL query SPARQL endpoint learned pattern visualised form basis investigation used predict target node new source node Amongst others apply algorithm dataset several hundred human association circle square find pattern DBpedia show scalability algorithm running SPARQL endpoint loaded 79 billion triple use resulting SPARQL query mimic human association Mean Average Precision MAP 399 Recall10 639 Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.05303521826863289, 0.0714755430817604, -0.023572899401187897, -0.0002667703665792942, 0.0017019326332956553, -0.007072402164340019, 0.00022472212731372565, 0.00924236886203289, 0.014618105255067348, -0.013973248191177845, 0.010560072027146816, 0.06168920919299126, -0.004193740896880627, 0.08381201326847076, -0.006917405873537064, -0.007000985089689493, 0.026194240897893906, 0.03719426691532135, -0.031228482723236084, 0.009213998913764954, 0.016036102548241615, 0.03854157030582428, 0.01250026561319828, -0.018678192049264908, 0.012241319753229618, 0.013571578077971935, 0.00909850001335144, -0.026597026735544205, 0.01931796967983246, -0.032444603741168976, 0.027168763801455498, 0.04161755368113518, 0.0009234434110112488, 0.06933701783418655, 2.021239197347313e-06, -0.07883226126432419, -0.05359455943107605, -0.006098070181906223, 0.03239601477980614, -0.02246849238872528, 0.029804550111293793, 0.0460035465657711, 0.026105783879756927, 0.02480342984199524, -0.05007339268922806, -0.030067328363656998, 0.027430947870016098, 0.031853966414928436, 0.04159974679350853, 0.03434532508254051, -0.004028612747788429, -0.05803491547703743, 0.01401972770690918, -0.00638025626540184, 0.06410562992095947, 0.019412850961089134, 0.031131206080317497, -0.01965170167386532, 0.009492950513958931, -0.0002470151521265507, -0.015325774438679218, -0.03256266191601753, -0.05725574865937233, 0.0031264859717339277, 0.059507254511117935, 0.014605560339987278, 0.0007057657930999994, -0.003071641316637397, 0.021665479987859726, 0.014994697645306587, 0.027745820581912994, -0.009098542854189873, 0.0771079957485199, 0.06066044047474861, -0.030374793335795403, 0.03958768770098686, -0.009610933251678944, -0.03441910445690155, -0.06382352113723755, -0.007466383744031191, -0.013709238730370998, -0.011237284168601036, -0.023069683462381363, 0.01494851429015398, -0.013669933192431927, 0.03529050573706627, -0.0044470843859016895, 0.00851550605148077, 0.005953902378678322, -0.06217189505696297, 0.04769771173596382, -0.02611888386309147, 0.059630461037158966, 0.00690461928024888, -0.021987194195389748, 0.014726905152201653, -0.029177680611610413, -0.0042539420537650585, 0.0743112787604332, 0.001486715511418879, 0.00823203008621931, -0.015072764828801155, 0.05701316148042679, 0.03396221622824669, 0.0022524625528603792, -0.07317530363798141, -0.016115635633468628, 0.01841605082154274, -0.0064520756714046, 0.03343084827065468, -0.09405716508626938, 0.025639716535806656, -0.010161981917917728, 0.05324858799576759, 0.03620034456253052, -0.014385011047124863, -0.048245299607515335, 0.020256003364920616, 0.01081551518291235, 0.012953408993780613, 0.007728104013949633, 0.04301135614514351, 0.032313670963048935, 0.009531809017062187, -0.07905632257461548, -0.005289965774863958, -0.025936376303434372, 0.024159152060747147, -0.04534951597452164, 0.019566817209124565, 0.05535124987363815, -0.015894543379545212, 0.06548789888620377, -0.011265399865806103, 0.026772690936923027, 0.022770479321479797, 0.04450857266783714, -0.022946976125240326, -0.10090189427137375, -0.03136754035949707, 0.0547400526702404, 0.026469314470887184, -0.0015860239509493113, -0.06278397142887115, 0.026242470368742943, -0.01469530537724495, -0.02701479196548462, -0.03068634867668152, -0.01127009280025959, 0.020977303385734558, -0.08155032247304916, 0.04439098387956619, -0.0870867371559143, 0.02140108495950699, 0.07586544007062912, 0.003078419016674161, 0.06321971118450165, 0.024335354566574097, -0.018128100782632828, 0.013779251836240292, 0.04523463547229767, 7.517294579884037e-05, -0.049936551600694656, -0.004110816866159439, -0.018073871731758118, 0.013957488350570202, 0.07267962396144867, 0.04743395000696182, -0.020704587921500206, 0.03770223259925842, 0.02251986227929592, 0.04291091486811638, -0.02497611753642559, -0.04686863347887993, 0.01806575059890747, 0.07992155849933624, 0.023251738399267197, 0.060711570084095, -0.01375091727823019, 0.016182679682970047, -0.01986577734351158, -0.03682570531964302, -0.01855524815618992, 0.022278208285570145, -0.006982945837080479, -0.02057866007089615, -0.0032748139929026365, 0.03475641831755638, -0.016560610383749008, -0.02117835357785225, -0.01168091967701912, 0.029884913936257362, -0.016879674047231674, -0.01397453248500824, 0.022004585713148117, 0.046442437916994095, 0.009925724938511848, 0.022799348458647728, 0.04622670263051987, 0.0029266977217048407, 0.010126572102308273, -0.027117842808365822, 0.023848628625273705, 0.041613657027482986, 0.05098541080951691, -0.027214957401156425, -0.009120137430727482, -0.031241051852703094, -0.04089117422699928, 0.0005420372472144663, -0.0033658219035714865, -0.010651598684489727, -0.03928934782743454, -0.012516289949417114, -0.03346149995923042, 0.06691612303256989, 0.003976723644882441, 0.00439833989366889, -0.005437543150037527, 0.026522094383835793, -0.004775176290422678, 0.038493018597364426, -0.016429198905825615, 0.041044436395168304, -0.04387908801436424, 0.030019359663128853, 0.018780024722218513, -0.01759311743080616, 0.04282386228442192, 0.0397590734064579, 0.005241677165031433, 0.012507074512541294, 0.047881219536066055, -0.0013288625050336123, -0.06118062883615494, 0.029622115194797516, 0.07376139611005783, 0.03419160097837448, 0.017350271344184875, -0.08145735412836075, -0.023028777912259102, 0.011295769363641739, -0.01099412702023983, 0.0003022300952579826, 0.02643544413149357, -0.07670552283525467, 0.07754506170749664, 0.008425678126513958, 0.0055472953245043755, -0.012565432116389275, -0.03871430829167366, -0.006320272106677294, 0.06444282084703445, -0.01212799921631813, 0.007274589966982603, -0.042635366320610046, -0.04291461035609245, 0.040014177560806274, -0.03384409844875336, 0.01215412002056837, -0.07576950639486313, -0.01477179303765297, -0.002629323862493038, 0.023081883788108826, 0.04056417569518089, -0.1013374924659729, 0.01436823233962059, -0.054180167615413666, 0.016405239701271057, 0.03176609054207802, 0.03897485509514809, 0.022781847044825554, -0.020261960104107857, -0.011112918145954609, -0.01332787610590458, -0.057401761412620544, 0.04802728071808815, -0.05242849513888359, 0.01015540026128292, 0.04778594151139259, 0.024199189618229866, -0.01679626666009426, -0.025859162211418152, -0.012434910982847214, -0.058007534593343735, 0.028292274102568626, 0.061784528195858, 0.024260513484477997, -0.00641561858355999, 0.035491690039634705, -0.06901619583368301, 0.01257846225053072, 0.011916425079107285, -0.004729853477329016, -0.01969173364341259, -0.009351760149002075, -0.008181773126125336, 0.013124692253768444, 0.05270567163825035, 0.0012423532316461205, -0.011012788861989975, 0.030497821047902107, 0.00915222242474556, -0.007461263332515955, -0.025600440800189972, 0.059056323021650314, 0.026609867811203003, -0.03295503556728363, 0.07213360071182251, -0.00926440954208374, 0.019565347582101822, -0.012832297012209892, 0.010203959420323372, 0.043937887996435165, 0.016552813351154327, -0.008269619196653366, -0.042957112193107605, -0.039268702268600464, 0.02518823742866516, 0.04318573325872421, 0.0007337238057516515, -0.002904860768467188, 0.054612163454294205, 0.05785451829433441, 0.0761709213256836, -0.05368915945291519, -0.009501025080680847, -0.0321677140891552, 0.0364241898059845, 0.01939535327255726, 0.05112692341208458, -0.03420208394527435, -0.02406490407884121, -0.02361212857067585, -0.005931197665631771, 0.033025749027729034, -0.027079036459326744, -0.025231502950191498, 0.010699835605919361, -0.01679578423500061, 0.04284733161330223, -0.0026568355970084667, -0.012069118209183216, 0.03081216663122177, 0.004386617802083492, -0.02451549470424652, 0.039252717047929764, -0.026717130094766617, -0.02991621010005474, -0.019494373351335526, -0.02094600535929203, -0.001573546207509935, 0.008404102176427841, -0.04242231324315071, 0.022102393209934235, 0.014666786417365074, 0.08837147802114487, -0.061830174177885056, -0.04727046936750412, 0.003963489085435867, -0.05997292697429657, 0.06125631555914879, -0.024678919464349747, -0.04729440435767174, -0.030229059979319572, 0.03242962062358856, 0.02959423139691353, -0.070421501994133, -0.008429187349975109, -0.0260082446038723, -0.06907308846712112, -0.0008200471056625247, 0.04381762817502022, 0.04944724962115288, 0.057322487235069275, -0.059785839170217514, 0.011380117386579514, -0.042266350239515305, -0.000575815502088517, 0.03922484442591667, 0.05160119757056236, -0.09382325410842896, 0.0091456463560462, -0.060704369097948074, 0.0009979612659662962, -0.019112858921289444, -0.11289069801568985, 0.009920019656419754, -0.0793604627251625, -0.017359426245093346, -0.02158130705356598, -0.0805496945977211, 0.005763367284089327, -0.11131535470485687, -0.015472903847694397, -0.07405458390712738, -0.07235535979270935, 0.017726456746459007, -0.023329108953475952, -0.014526654034852982, 0.014783377759158611, -0.0225625429302454, 0.005253300070762634, 0.028152890503406525, -0.06843019276857376, 0.026553161442279816, 0.035155896097421646, 0.0855882465839386, -0.010347829200327396, -0.05676430091261864, -0.046607986092567444, 0.012029764242470264, -0.008632497861981392, -0.050341732800006866, 0.10508861392736435, -0.014539079740643501, 0.032605137676000595, -0.05349511653184891, 0.025830436497926712, -0.03569597378373146, 0.040414273738861084, 0.038351673632860184, 0.06177022308111191, 0.0015670026186853647, 0.02592441812157631, -0.0698242262005806, 0.008130955509841442, -0.01402448769658804, -0.005774037446826696, -0.016843631863594055, -0.022774843499064445, -0.0119332829490304, -0.001396560575813055, 0.00892765261232853, -0.01191286277025938, -0.029430324211716652, 0.028824521228671074, -0.06687036901712418, -0.05490095540881157, -0.08341743797063828, 0.007967168465256691, 0.010284153744578362, 0.03370540589094162, 0.024697644636034966, 0.012101694010198116, -0.01394773367792368, -0.014309496618807316, -0.0522761307656765, -0.013677298091351986, 0.03612358495593071, 0.007341635879129171, -0.03599750995635986, -0.016014060005545616, 0.03596658259630203, -0.018116038292646408, -0.008473780937492847, -0.047032833099365234, -0.043077051639556885, -0.03939610347151756, 0.027001578360795975, 0.028964892029762268, 0.030332298949360847, -0.007079442963004112, -0.012733587063848972, -0.044490985572338104, 0.014574308879673481, 0.019024211913347244, -0.05098125711083412, -0.03398711234331131, -0.04666486755013466, -0.0015768667217344046, -0.014443020336329937, 0.002763459924608469, -0.02253665216267109, 0.022210530936717987, -0.03626732528209686, -0.042135462164878845, -0.035456497222185135, -0.039451662451028824, 0.025758177042007446, 0.05864374712109566, -0.010731377638876438, 0.010610987432301044, -0.010115296579897404, -0.01565532200038433, -0.004906018730252981, 0.001472447533160448, -0.017717456445097923, 0.024434417486190796, -0.028092876076698303, 0.017485598102211952, 0.01818823255598545, -0.0011558069381862879, -0.0367119275033474, -0.009727994911372662, 0.017813993617892265, -0.022168852388858795, 0.02035786770284176, 0.0035447292029857635, 0.01565900631248951, -0.0033817323856055737, -0.009254228323698044, 0.0033844553399831057, -0.03637132793664932, 0.020310327410697937, 0.055558156222105026, -0.029180143028497696, 0.015667196363210678, -0.007916005328297615, 0.001656017848290503, -0.013585723005235195, 0.028254451230168343, -0.02932790480554104, -0.06375452131032944, -0.01232254970818758, -0.037536490708589554, -0.01085825264453888, -0.0010879533365368843, -0.0033531298395246267, -0.0008071159245446324, 0.001236326526850462, 0.008192911744117737, -0.001495438627898693, -0.07751177251338959, 0.012647050432860851, 0.013224233873188496, 0.03436083719134331, 0.0023933597840368748, -0.008563164621591568, 0.055142566561698914, 0.011513795703649521, -0.0003349963517393917, 0.0016106943367049098, -0.09109324216842651, -0.018369531258940697, 0.031981438398361206, 0.035542991012334824, 0.016220202669501305, -0.017619196325540543, -0.03507494553923607, -0.041996702551841736, -0.02372879721224308, 0.009041277691721916, 0.010056856088340282, 0.04383807256817818, 0.03894646838307381, 0.07453569024801254, 0.025466429069638252, 0.008331830613315105, -0.01977754384279251, -0.03637823835015297, -0.0040953503921628, -0.023380344733595848, -0.062291644513607025, 0.003019079566001892, -5.984366802271401e-33, 0.02382020838558674, -0.0694340318441391, 0.036903563886880875, 0.0033437968231737614, -0.04807485640048981, -0.04763876274228096, 0.005445318296551704, -0.025043772533535957, -0.005271009169518948, 0.0025465465150773525, -0.013052661903202534, 0.00501506170257926, -0.006550824269652367, -0.013335616327822208, 0.030044615268707275, 0.016246866434812546, -0.0033505097962915897, 0.028714880347251892, 0.03521093353629112, -0.00533421291038394, 0.053021956235170364, 0.032386135309934616, -0.027800550684332848, -0.026703491806983948, -0.02517157420516014, 0.02826984040439129, -0.004059867933392525, 0.02482627145946026, 0.03479674831032753, 0.04108447581529617, 0.012406745925545692, 0.029509255662560463, 0.006571929901838303, 0.03591529652476311, 0.026161540299654007, -0.07038332521915436, -0.10392304509878159, -0.06053215265274048, -0.024411512538790703, -0.0029620975255966187, 0.015320283360779285, 0.02461894229054451, 0.032522331923246384, 0.01813996583223343, -0.018751036375761032, -0.0085857342928648, 0.09035652875900269, -0.00663198484107852, -0.021358467638492584, -0.03917597979307175, -0.0005889509920962155, 0.02341284230351448, -0.019151141867041588, 0.032637376338243484, -0.05207520350813866, -0.034051161259412766, -0.0059176236391067505, 0.03357647731900215, -0.053964488208293915, 0.041378553956747055, -0.03664448857307434, 0.031004702672362328, 0.015780756250023842, -0.001307631959207356, 0.04248225688934326, 0.025024380534887314, -0.01580316573381424, 0.004099504556506872, 0.07063689082860947, 0.02353276126086712, -0.011261550709605217, 0.05789459869265556, -0.015723906457424164, -0.00048498736578039825, 0.040096465498209, -0.0548572912812233, -0.0385567769408226, 0.07799190282821655, 0.012790626846253872, 0.018280843272805214, -0.04176044464111328, 0.012251749634742737, -0.019660551100969315, -0.019257517531514168, 0.013989442028105259, 0.045043207705020905, -0.037635624408721924, -0.05369318649172783, -0.022072870284318924, -0.01720890775322914, 0.005015618167817593, 0.011170076206326485, -0.046854548156261444, -0.04252810403704643, -0.021544860675930977, 0.009868086315691471, -0.012822276912629604, -0.0342252217233181, -0.014372280798852444, -0.021888546645641327, -0.04451317340135574, -0.03914777189493179, -0.02590230479836464, -0.02154012769460678, 0.01332304161041975, -0.009674489498138428, 0.024207493290305138, -0.028496086597442627, -0.06455397605895996, -0.014065093360841274, 0.038190148770809174, -0.02946183644235134, 0.019321488216519356, -0.019935403019189835, -0.017959795892238617, 0.0086067421361804, 0.0005445602000690997, 0.024782618507742882, 0.10931188613176346, 0.03581162169575691, -0.055373478680849075, -0.013945340178906918, -0.008886613883078098, -0.011908519081771374, -0.0232332032173872, -0.02106384001672268, -0.01625140570104122, 0.005128272343426943, 0.01874963939189911, -0.1001485139131546, -0.032092247158288956, -0.0386105552315712, 2.767376656720444e-07, 0.04383499547839165, 0.02591397799551487, 0.00509031442925334, -0.010776189155876637, 0.005556718446314335, -0.002525628311559558, 0.018445665016770363, 0.0894097238779068, -0.01563042402267456, 0.026810554787516594, 0.017439015209674835, -0.020424822345376015, -0.007299239747226238, 0.06407936662435532, -0.08127593994140625, 0.003171168267726898, -0.05927686393260956, -0.051702022552490234, -0.058979205787181854, 0.0212559811770916, 0.017325513064861298, 0.018546337261795998, 0.044460076838731766, -0.006644668057560921, 0.0031503653153777122, -0.009520207531750202, -0.005285567604005337, 0.01139952801167965, -0.0026564786676317453, 0.04805226996541023, 0.014652621932327747, -0.07671727240085602, -0.045194052159786224, 0.020189102739095688, -0.047954682260751724, 0.008434364572167397, -0.023811867460608482, -0.007844263687729836, -0.04534296318888664, 0.05316171795129776, 0.05525916442275047, -0.02948279306292534, 0.01733342371881008, -0.024353519082069397, 0.04128577560186386, 0.008616672828793526, -0.031242184340953827, 0.08709143102169037, -0.028456320986151695, -0.019258055835962296, 0.006097752135246992, -0.021107066422700882, -0.028423888608813286, 0.03717300295829773, 0.0107421251013875, -0.004734153859317303, 0.007896358147263527, -0.02056240662932396, 0.053116392344236374, 0.015596487559378147, -0.006982579827308655, -0.06328796595335007, 0.03281639516353607, 0.03104620799422264, 0.03242926672101021, -0.010962816886603832, -0.0017046078573912382, 2.568799769246031e-34, 0.013382651843130589, 0.0392390638589859, -0.029818367213010788, 0.008851719088852406, 0.042669788002967834, -0.028133925050497055, 0.03365591540932655, 0.04020067676901817, 0.05476953461766243, -0.036951884627342224, -0.030751613900065422]
659
659
['Anthony L. Caterini', 'Dong Eui Chang']
1608.04374v2
In this paper, a geometric framework for neural networks is proposed. This framework uses the inner product space structure underlying the parameter set to perform gradient descent not in a component-based form, but in a coordinate-free manner. Convolutional neural networks are described in this framework in a compact form, with the gradients of standard --- and higher-order --- loss functions calculated for each layer of the network. This approach can be applied to other network structures and provides a basis on which to create new networks.
A Geometric Framework for Convolutional Neural Networks
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1608.04374v2
Title Geometric Framework Convolutional Neural Networks Summary paper geometric framework neural network proposed framework us inner product space structure underlying parameter set perform gradient descent componentbased form coordinatefree manner Convolutional neural network described framework compact form gradient standard higherorder loss function calculated layer network approach applied network structure provides basis create new network Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.0062927547842264175, 0.02175666019320488, -0.01843675784766674, 0.05009322240948677, 0.00307169440202415, 0.0009931556414812803, 0.06940880417823792, -0.007466486655175686, -0.00551449041813612, 0.02989242784678936, 0.01591523550450802, 0.00019580336811486632, 0.0005112610524520278, 0.043925248086452484, 0.03991241380572319, -0.08972707390785217, -0.05634613335132599, 0.0014608943602070212, -0.024962952360510826, -0.04891306534409523, 0.013774219900369644, -0.002522833412513137, 0.003975750412791967, 0.028851643204689026, -0.11029233783483505, 0.02112988568842411, -0.009697823785245419, 0.01724216714501381, -0.0004837320593651384, -0.03937288373708725, 0.052862498909235, -0.008841609582304955, 0.006912387441843748, 0.020191051065921783, 2.128216010532924e-06, 0.01747131161391735, 0.01610902138054371, -0.002867755014449358, 0.06784303486347198, 0.01877089962363243, 0.007473847828805447, -0.009215564467012882, -0.049288470298051834, -0.056879881769418716, -0.04035182297229767, -0.036950189620256424, 0.01567109115421772, 0.07592377811670303, 0.041223570704460144, 0.07566038519144058, -0.027023300528526306, -0.06840034574270248, 0.024530118331313133, -0.05011377111077309, -0.030470678582787514, -0.04945413023233414, 0.00826447457075119, -0.00882620457559824, -0.08211664110422134, -0.017192693427205086, -0.010690244846045971, 0.08914578706026077, 0.039092522114515305, 0.03717109560966492, 0.05317091941833496, 0.04798610135912895, -0.01811707764863968, -0.01644068770110607, -0.026907792314887047, 0.05747193098068237, -0.05323689430952072, 0.016760870814323425, 0.03070138953626156, -0.0040143742226064205, -0.015106741338968277, -0.01112431101500988, -0.051825232803821564, 0.02802652306854725, -0.01686340756714344, -0.010526889935135841, -0.11222443729639053, -0.005357344634830952, 0.010983584448695183, 0.0018858988769352436, -0.01529604196548462, 0.01876313053071499, 0.019008660688996315, 0.03701671585440636, -0.0799737349152565, -0.03421498090028763, -0.022323396056890488, -0.006607888266444206, 0.0316975936293602, 0.008901400491595268, 0.045109305530786514, -0.03529325872659683, 0.02654639445245266, -0.028538720682263374, 0.006825590971857309, -0.07519828528165817, 0.09763605892658234, -0.024605361744761467, 0.014918806031346321, 0.030777201056480408, -0.07859442383050919, 0.04372517764568329, -0.08683747053146362, 0.05189333111047745, -0.035989731550216675, 0.017617838457226753, 0.008133109658956528, 0.015192050486803055, -0.0125456303358078, 0.04687592014670372, 0.009228253737092018, -0.007576798088848591, -0.030473414808511734, -0.012974883429706097, -0.032390981912612915, -0.026202449575066566, -0.009396570734679699, 0.09756896644830704, 0.005656247027218342, -0.03926648199558258, 0.018853677436709404, 0.012815160676836967, 0.006326088681817055, 0.017263684421777725, 0.002652772469446063, 0.0028836107812821865, 0.029874606058001518, 0.03832840174436569, 0.007021596655249596, 0.035392653197050095, 0.012561110779643059, 0.036612194031476974, 0.05376701429486275, -0.006234412081539631, -0.04092888534069061, 0.00030192191479727626, -0.009849011898040771, -0.020718682557344437, 0.030565137043595314, -0.05255249887704849, 0.03196408972144127, -0.05807099491357803, -0.008950164541602135, -0.005749799776822329, 0.00125145073980093, -0.0068461657501757145, -0.0152573361992836, 0.053257305175065994, 0.014073090627789497, -0.020091185346245766, 0.11988358199596405, -0.0041360631585121155, 0.010716266930103302, 0.024961132556200027, 0.029714170843362808, 0.06511284410953522, -0.022129913792014122, -0.02494262158870697, -0.024940621107816696, -0.0051431371830403805, 0.004887791816145182, -0.03522714599967003, -0.07672707736492157, -0.05386095866560936, -0.04140281304717064, 0.048832207918167114, -0.016688350588083267, 0.035853076726198196, -0.03786524385213852, -0.037090104073286057, 0.0011832317104563117, 0.08746019750833511, 0.03364390879869461, 0.054886121302843094, 0.03703973814845085, -0.01061591412872076, -0.0010002964409068227, -0.06463081389665604, -0.0012157339369878173, 0.05602235347032547, -0.03170530125498772, -0.05990029126405716, -0.11282450705766678, -0.015057242475450039, -0.046514879912137985, -0.031362149864435196, 0.04553314298391342, -0.05040372163057327, 0.005835776682943106, -0.028218669816851616, 0.05160963907837868, -0.012855739332735538, -0.001510570989921689, -0.01853693462908268, -0.03217066451907158, -0.041005849838256836, -0.03857790306210518, 0.0168222114443779, 0.005622449796646833, -0.05708618089556694, -0.02380373142659664, -0.015607626177370548, -0.03292233124375343, -0.002817687811329961, 0.02354542538523674, -0.013939698226749897, 0.007342166732996702, -0.01003605592995882, 0.03548583388328552, -0.040360864251852036, -0.01403750665485859, 0.04334384202957153, 0.020108170807361603, 0.0019209954189136624, 0.009875752031803131, -0.030708540230989456, 0.03365686163306236, 0.025831473991274834, -0.022975033149123192, -0.0007204623543657362, 0.015276039019227028, -0.0003867585037369281, 0.009319012053310871, 0.052191320806741714, 0.0065999710932374, 0.012746614404022694, 0.058508653193712234, -0.036417655646800995, 0.0709947869181633, -0.071903295814991, -0.01281830109655857, -0.02014102041721344, -0.023671863600611687, 0.0021698458585888147, 0.022854486480355263, -0.03682279586791992, 0.01573537476360798, 0.01675296388566494, -0.011385869234800339, -0.05863533541560173, 0.04704327881336212, 0.008867097087204456, 0.018829258158802986, -0.022091349586844444, -0.012200552970170975, -0.003673321334645152, 0.012447104789316654, -0.038128044456243515, -0.0109999505802989, -0.0025210571475327015, 0.0375947430729866, 0.011646753177046776, 0.01505583431571722, 0.013729853555560112, -0.006697264965623617, -0.014542950317263603, -0.0009372937493026257, -0.036750197410583496, -0.007238185498863459, 0.010348116047680378, 0.03723318874835968, 0.03824105113744736, -0.004351680167019367, -0.02557387948036194, -0.005498453043401241, 0.00526594091206789, -0.028009071946144104, 0.0247094314545393, -0.017385931685566902, -0.0004843600618187338, -0.020657038316130638, 0.0206226147711277, 0.09006867557764053, -0.02162017859518528, -0.06532265245914459, 0.022354677319526672, 0.01610986702144146, -0.023235654458403587, 0.009925183840095997, -0.06378336995840073, -0.004628554452210665, 0.03646879270672798, 0.059764787554740906, -0.04175828397274017, -0.0007089239661581814, -0.026228042319417, -0.028994020074605942, 0.04417768493294716, -0.01821376010775566, -0.06070671230554581, -0.028451375663280487, -0.04088710993528366, -0.036356378346681595, 0.10977766662836075, 0.025685187429189682, 0.005730574019253254, 0.0014256727881729603, 0.09323328733444214, -0.01420547254383564, 0.011263690888881683, -0.07661554217338562, 0.01741393655538559, 0.02545625902712345, -0.033661361783742905, -0.015062056481838226, 0.011442214250564575, 0.015940971672534943, 0.03997134789824486, -0.012848319485783577, 0.02369406819343567, -0.0006549269892275333, -0.004200794734060764, -0.059619393199682236, -0.01082812249660492, 0.009548639878630638, 0.003011375665664673, -0.017538614571094513, -0.050044137984514236, -0.020208338275551796, 0.03578324615955353, 0.009067452512681484, 0.0199163556098938, 0.0003577226016204804, -0.02734728530049324, -0.01457380410283804, 0.02852695621550083, 0.014773997478187084, -0.004902801010757685, -0.02705659158527851, -0.008856551721692085, 0.029944811016321182, 0.030300255864858627, -0.019188031554222107, -0.020425740629434586, -0.040711574256420135, -0.012141010724008083, -0.00952408742159605, -0.022078024223446846, -0.05696936696767807, 0.036487020552158356, 0.030702780932188034, 0.019339544698596, -0.055300597101449966, -0.042696740478277206, 0.04153018444776535, 0.019969621673226357, -0.008983812294900417, 0.04327249154448509, -0.015972455963492393, 0.01288694329559803, -0.008244149386882782, 0.08007825165987015, 0.004690155386924744, 0.018728699535131454, -0.04220539331436157, 0.04409637674689293, 0.016503233462572098, 0.017736520618200302, -0.0415896438062191, 0.06422118097543716, -0.10085047781467438, 0.03544897586107254, -0.004344479646533728, 0.041622817516326904, -0.019404659047722816, 0.011600001715123653, 0.01609225571155548, -0.02240189164876938, -0.004357661120593548, 0.020643407478928566, -0.007497529033571482, -0.09273296594619751, -0.048656802624464035, 0.02832134999334812, -0.04266791045665741, 0.017565371468663216, -0.017315944656729698, 0.032825518399477005, 0.019071321934461594, -0.007452232763171196, -0.0300601739436388, 0.02433675341308117, -0.025475945323705673, 0.05225023999810219, -0.007804518565535545, 0.022987795993685722, -0.0051996419206261635, -0.03940625861287117, -0.03635239601135254, -0.01816517300903797, 0.006440516095608473, -0.00855956319719553, -0.05042753368616104, -0.014395400881767273, 0.01790042035281658, -0.054099373519420624, 0.05617310106754303, -0.031057175248861313, 0.03749508410692215, -0.006290351040661335, -0.07994150370359421, -0.05087675526738167, 0.021670540794730186, 0.0401344895362854, -0.029593108221888542, -0.0529160350561142, 0.006824856158345938, -0.024786951020359993, -0.005734459962695837, -0.012934905476868153, 0.026162613183259964, 0.06402847915887833, -0.013021315447986126, 0.01891854964196682, 0.0673975795507431, -0.07402919232845306, 0.03540042042732239, 0.012808648869395256, 0.05441102385520935, 0.042050834745168686, 0.031751394271850586, -0.053173113614320755, 0.007600490469485521, -0.015534990467131138, -0.021527886390686035, -0.010942762717604637, -2.603060238470789e-05, -0.04354793578386307, 0.004532238934189081, 0.05771881341934204, -0.04450787603855133, 0.0038623919244855642, -0.012269111350178719, 0.04940073564648628, -0.030888009816408157, -0.05389972776174545, 0.03390997275710106, -0.04103751853108406, 0.0491240918636322, 0.025602582842111588, -0.08623695373535156, 0.048570625483989716, -0.020347831770777702, -0.05239781737327576, 0.04018986597657204, 0.05324269086122513, 0.06726139783859253, -0.0018610142869874835, 0.05907571688294411, 0.02443448081612587, -0.02933107316493988, 0.0027304659597575665, 0.010845386423170567, -0.06335709989070892, -0.018991801887750626, -0.018342183902859688, 0.05951516702771187, -0.0022883370984345675, 0.022775275632739067, -0.04610496386885643, 0.01671464368700981, -0.006470934022217989, -0.00598284462466836, 0.015485506504774094, 0.03954668715596199, 0.04796799644827843, -0.009898665361106396, -0.006166006904095411, 0.016102010384202003, 0.02737225405871868, 0.06977247446775436, -0.007754502817988396, -0.02921805903315544, -0.019864266738295555, -0.03072456456720829, 0.012881148606538773, -0.04093703627586365, 0.09835882484912872, 0.05450122058391571, 0.03062283992767334, -0.055746711790561676, 0.028066368773579597, 0.021940411999821663, 0.02262379415333271, -0.03498594090342522, 0.012485961429774761, 0.021675821393728256, 0.0008062300621531904, 0.005813303869217634, -0.007696604356169701, 0.09850918501615524, -0.0041129556484520435, -0.029191484674811363, 0.05163106694817543, -0.013581092469394207, -0.0034630578011274338, -0.014487583190202713, 0.04021002724766731, 0.006597850471735001, 0.00837775319814682, -0.03499068319797516, -0.007832584902644157, -0.009414476342499256, 0.0013253508368507028, 0.004994635004550219, 0.012958576902747154, -0.04317634180188179, 0.00523987365886569, -0.02151152864098549, -0.048880577087402344, -0.0807216688990593, 0.015038156881928444, 0.06326857954263687, -0.019163144752383232, -0.009132958948612213, -0.026035895571112633, -0.012686499394476414, -0.028218897059559822, 0.03079131990671158, -0.033476367592811584, 0.025835495442152023, 0.0783986747264862, -0.004632783122360706, 0.0006589044933207333, -0.023015333339571953, 0.006558891851454973, -0.003275894792750478, 0.0033262609504163265, -0.03273634612560272, 0.02675551362335682, -0.008144899271428585, 0.022512096911668777, -0.010702662169933319, 0.049266912043094635, -0.017437689006328583, 0.010140550322830677, 0.008633732795715332, -0.04649686440825462, 0.02310582809150219, 0.009942269884049892, 0.05350794270634651, 0.018156271427869797, 0.03382958099246025, 0.011922500096261501, -0.028869662433862686, 0.014396979473531246, -0.004691094160079956, -0.015926705673336983, -0.010397622361779213, 0.0014117230894044042, -0.0369781032204628, -5.523190613743062e-33, 0.03232559934258461, -0.003125356510281563, -0.04822179675102234, 0.013003433123230934, -0.06732596457004547, 0.04173419624567032, -0.005584860686212778, -0.034053701907396317, -0.01790599524974823, -0.03161810338497162, -0.009499930776655674, 0.013905522413551807, -0.00623677484691143, 0.007278239354491234, 0.003542291698977351, 0.004056703764945269, -0.015533516183495522, -0.02223588153719902, 0.05382515490055084, 0.01311818789690733, 0.013107618317008018, 0.048614487051963806, 0.01716117188334465, -0.03690172731876373, -0.07078555226325989, 0.005882874596863985, 0.008181661367416382, -0.0018297000788152218, 0.0019178874790668488, 0.024454306811094284, -0.025794893503189087, -0.01074242778122425, 0.01010582223534584, 0.0006247072014957666, 0.03064136393368244, -0.009560025297105312, -0.051086392253637314, 0.008921931497752666, -0.07091367244720459, 0.03429516777396202, -0.0724739357829094, 0.03531753271818161, 0.06729307770729065, -0.03379761800169945, -0.046805936843156815, 0.012757383286952972, 0.0301319919526577, -0.01450012344866991, -0.045433785766363144, 0.005463019944727421, -0.00798510666936636, 0.03179534152150154, -0.04007675498723984, -0.03951726853847504, 0.025449950248003006, -0.007093047723174095, -0.007783924229443073, 0.010972468182444572, -0.004202981945127249, 0.040233541280031204, -0.06529691815376282, 0.046390555799007416, -0.00781616847962141, 0.03590661287307739, 0.0285347830504179, 0.0248840544372797, 0.07905937731266022, -0.05861656367778778, -0.047907304018735886, -0.04645048454403877, 0.01790275052189827, 0.005495494231581688, 0.06514055281877518, -0.04225720092654228, 0.046926964074373245, -0.07490677386522293, -0.04711940139532089, -0.008636419661343098, -0.047030165791511536, 0.04319813847541809, -0.05088203027844429, 0.01144558284431696, -0.02483908087015152, 0.004316499922424555, 0.019357001408934593, -0.05836966261267662, -0.01596263237297535, 0.008607849478721619, 0.0012767004081979394, 0.024629900231957436, 0.00010061565990326926, 0.039098192006349564, -0.052974194288253784, -0.03330114483833313, 0.0641973614692688, -0.005751386750489473, 0.020224062725901604, 0.06033899262547493, 0.05398210883140564, 0.00824002455919981, -0.019337385892868042, 0.024934768676757812, -0.055920667946338654, -0.011159023270010948, 0.018495282158255577, 5.343815064406954e-05, 0.032718125730752945, 0.060098644345998764, 0.042025718837976456, -0.06922352313995361, -0.044549357146024704, -0.023308981209993362, 0.026780568063259125, 0.04944886639714241, 0.0324331633746624, -0.0003562937490642071, 0.012014170177280903, 0.0909620076417923, -0.004134169779717922, 0.02252565510571003, -0.03408696874976158, -0.01662725955247879, 0.0011440019588917494, 0.056059762835502625, -0.04091405123472214, -0.020774656906723976, -0.020423853769898415, 0.003987359348684549, 0.03475560247898102, -0.08525824546813965, -0.04105816036462784, 0.0076850662007927895, 2.790178541545174e-07, -0.015195936895906925, 0.02933666668832302, 0.023253824561834335, -0.0006713657057844102, -0.0028235078789293766, -0.014028272591531277, 0.0009672670275904238, 0.033459968864917755, -0.046194229274988174, 0.006683463230729103, 0.010194770060479641, -0.020795417949557304, 0.0041426015086472034, -0.015738308429718018, -0.08711390197277069, 0.05935301631689072, -0.018197031691670418, 0.019878892228007317, 0.03502268344163895, 0.030064668506383896, 0.032000962644815445, 0.027731072157621384, 0.022724878042936325, -0.031169140711426735, 0.026191821321845055, 0.05856649950146675, 0.006090338807553053, -0.0041915131732821465, 0.06151900812983513, -0.024359581992030144, 0.008564094081521034, -0.016363633796572685, -0.007379857823252678, 0.02149844355881214, -0.009433227591216564, 0.030630575492978096, 0.058978188782930374, 0.014150222763419151, -0.006336558144539595, -0.0046292818151414394, 0.031699515879154205, -0.0035317016299813986, -0.003351157996803522, -0.02393905259668827, 0.02603304386138916, -0.004174990579485893, -0.022568030282855034, -0.06313090026378632, 0.004332183860242367, 0.08383965492248535, 0.05215061083436012, -0.009229740127921104, -0.011170179583132267, -0.026356693357229233, 0.007992872036993504, -0.03881373628973961, 0.014898472465574741, -0.03855537995696068, 0.03014557994902134, 0.04902684688568115, -0.008152260445058346, 0.028431396931409836, -0.021105408668518066, 0.012059228494763374, 0.05390414595603943, 0.01214017253369093, -0.05864439532160759, 2.303426868595611e-34, -0.06079209968447685, 0.004522171337157488, -0.0022129861172288656, 0.03563367575407028, -0.06689102947711945, -0.0033180813770741224, 0.0028016299474984407, 0.01635713130235672, -0.013997772708535194, 0.005277751479297876, -0.03149879723787308]
660
660
['Anthony Caterini', 'Dong Eui Chang']
1610.01549v2
Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) have become very popular for prediction in many areas. Their strength is in representation with a high number of parameters that are commonly learned via gradient descent or similar optimization methods. However, the representation is non-standardized, and the gradient calculation methods are often performed using component-based approaches that break parameters down into scalar units, instead of considering the parameters as whole entities. In this work, these problems are addressed. Standard notation is used to represent DNNs in a compact framework. Gradients of DNN loss functions are calculated directly over the inner product space on which the parameters are defined. This framework is general and is applied to two common network types: the Multilayer Perceptron and the Deep Autoencoder.
A Novel Representation of Neural Networks
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1610.01549v2
Title Novel Representation Neural Networks Summary Deep Neural Networks DNNs become popular prediction many area strength representation high number parameter commonly learned via gradient descent similar optimization method However representation nonstandardized gradient calculation method often performed using componentbased approach break parameter scalar unit instead considering parameter whole entity work problem addressed Standard notation used represent DNNs compact framework Gradients DNN loss function calculated directly inner product space parameter defined framework general applied two common network type Multilayer Perceptron Deep Autoencoder Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.04897966608405113, 0.018185332417488098, -0.04835548624396324, 0.03892781585454941, 0.01695767045021057, -0.028132939711213112, 0.06393872946500778, -0.034992609173059464, -0.01274050772190094, -0.003143599722534418, -0.04479924961924553, -0.010154358111321926, 0.009778140112757683, 0.01962733082473278, 0.026690669357776642, -0.06988711655139923, -0.006819447036832571, 0.03607569634914398, -0.0420084223151207, -0.018033383414149284, 0.02333003096282482, -0.008422343991696835, 0.029220547527074814, 0.0475727915763855, -0.07167615741491318, 0.03198855742812157, 0.007483326364308596, -0.02586699090898037, 0.021586386486887932, -0.029994284734129906, 0.04165743291378021, -0.003164447145536542, 0.05564933270215988, 0.01580720767378807, 2.4664075226610294e-06, 0.001157750259153545, -0.0006001950241625309, -0.017928918823599815, 0.028396043926477432, 0.049018435180187225, 0.021124297752976418, -0.035561397671699524, -0.03130381181836128, -0.014133027754724026, -0.03367183357477188, -0.03850138187408447, 0.013081595301628113, 0.05292579159140587, 0.06227518245577812, 0.03852332755923271, 0.011553612537682056, -0.053521059453487396, 0.04200858250260353, -0.015310999937355518, -0.019677838310599327, 9.422419680049643e-05, -0.008535918779671192, -0.002237302251160145, -0.05388842523097992, 9.826461609918624e-05, -0.0202966146171093, 0.055282656103372574, 0.07103320956230164, 0.001848627463914454, 0.033974789083004, 0.0221340823918581, -0.0031591374427080154, 0.02006302960216999, 0.0172513946890831, 0.05120279639959335, -0.05617136135697365, 0.0023160765413194895, -0.021259207278490067, -0.02646571584045887, -0.03259784355759621, -0.03582160919904709, -0.02252308838069439, -0.0010583184193819761, 0.04404740408062935, -0.008106845431029797, -0.0725475326180458, 0.06555792689323425, 0.0417025163769722, -0.010299918241798878, -0.0325234979391098, 0.0034839343279600143, -0.027011040598154068, 0.03492797538638115, -0.0644112229347229, -0.0913134217262268, -0.05959221348166466, 0.005217352416366339, 0.026918534189462662, -0.0008736724266782403, -0.002234013518318534, -0.027314696460962296, -0.00989273376762867, -0.09153623878955841, 0.04731753468513489, -0.04739111661911011, 0.05512964352965355, 0.001684265793301165, -0.030465077608823776, -0.006845655385404825, -0.06765634566545486, 0.09505312889814377, -0.0696122944355011, 0.006674476433545351, -0.008050677366554737, -0.010048815049231052, -0.02831033244729042, -0.017922885715961456, -0.023140883073210716, 0.0681445300579071, 0.028271086513996124, -0.029139738529920578, -0.06294560432434082, -0.025696171447634697, -0.07722725719213486, -0.037983812391757965, 0.04545259475708008, 0.08496628701686859, -0.014669173397123814, -0.01149299181997776, -0.018053289502859116, 0.03915960714221001, -0.047458212822675705, 0.036570824682712555, 0.013921381905674934, -0.008670272305607796, 0.026436535641551018, 0.012039448134601116, 0.016148146241903305, 0.031693167984485626, 0.019652556627988815, 0.06662369519472122, 0.05714237689971924, 0.02660379931330681, -0.029557738453149796, -0.01733948476612568, -0.007759736385196447, -0.025269636884331703, -0.016986984759569168, -0.06222577765583992, 0.039338696748018265, -0.0360632985830307, -0.03334932401776314, -0.023757293820381165, 0.01331791840493679, -0.013878961093723774, 0.03508235141634941, 0.04344438761472702, -0.03395231440663338, -0.014156168326735497, 0.10108603537082672, 0.007242641877382994, 0.003142281901091337, 0.02724762074649334, 0.05724503844976425, 0.07125632464885712, -0.005619943607598543, -0.0010283133015036583, -0.020899053663015366, 0.001607198966667056, 0.020114608108997345, -0.05393218621611595, -0.04352458938956261, -0.057521115988492966, -0.031546711921691895, 0.03758055344223976, 0.013490277342498302, 0.005994834471493959, 0.0025924574583768845, -0.05288593843579292, 0.017530016601085663, 0.03682734817266464, 0.06713607907295227, 0.04200093075633049, 0.015256310813128948, 0.0013485356466844678, -0.018324440345168114, -0.07060305029153824, 0.012272156774997711, 0.03618673235177994, 0.013294283300638199, -0.029574837535619736, -0.009921696037054062, -0.015827739611268044, -0.02793889306485653, -0.029115406796336174, 0.05907048285007477, -0.055110104382038116, -0.013943015597760677, -0.013910789974033833, 0.050347696989774704, 0.005995575338602066, -0.010454103350639343, 0.014106585644185543, 0.02017403021454811, 0.0321853868663311, -0.00962960347533226, -0.003049982013180852, -0.006394952069967985, -0.06396669894456863, -0.02144942618906498, -0.018553413450717926, -0.026876354590058327, -0.011462327092885971, -0.021958595141768456, -0.0807366743683815, 0.019175702705979347, -0.010144945234060287, 0.02668284997344017, -0.05549268051981926, -0.002820191904902458, -0.028482714667916298, 0.01845439337193966, 0.04659619927406311, -0.06626895070075989, 0.015134194865822792, 0.07201750576496124, -0.00040173993329517543, -0.01292783860117197, -0.002636023797094822, 0.03137803450226784, -0.010917143896222115, 0.06139128655195236, 0.05244295671582222, -0.001801034901291132, 0.019622525200247765, 0.05028653144836426, -0.009355491027235985, 0.027416827157139778, -0.06276286393404007, -0.046401556581258774, -0.05117768794298172, -0.07244516909122467, -0.007423900067806244, 0.0014169957721605897, -0.023968057706952095, 0.041843149811029434, 0.028346527367830276, 0.002719380659982562, -0.05338888242840767, 0.04546662047505379, -0.01188700646162033, -0.002786320401355624, -0.01120341382920742, -0.013600336387753487, -0.03809020295739174, 0.029533833265304565, -0.0007874693837948143, 0.030561063438653946, -0.0030109139624983072, -0.0022377786226570606, 0.01582081988453865, 0.02990080416202545, 0.05571125075221062, -0.015190774574875832, -0.01962791569530964, -0.023760443553328514, -0.04030328989028931, 0.002029665047302842, 0.015071716159582138, 0.013971501961350441, 0.022797655314207077, 0.017353832721710205, -0.013291871175169945, 0.024329189211130142, -0.023955341428518295, -0.029214346781373024, 0.01155442837625742, 0.018532782793045044, 0.025900959968566895, -0.01375687774270773, -0.03502075746655464, 0.07217640429735184, -0.006378775928169489, -0.05820421874523163, 0.02763824164867401, 0.03700711950659752, 0.017679603770375252, -0.016123423352837563, -0.06035294383764267, -0.03500371798872948, 0.043219659477472305, 0.035865701735019684, -0.023728959262371063, 0.014978419058024883, 0.015065258368849754, 0.007894795387983322, 0.04512042924761772, -0.005821689032018185, -0.08775003999471664, -0.009843382053077221, -0.039746206253767014, -0.006783579010516405, 0.048850297927856445, 0.021487746387720108, 0.010515576228499413, 0.014321754686534405, 0.060164932161569595, -0.07425487041473389, 0.008232545107603073, -0.05257060378789902, 0.05710385739803314, 0.0211337860673666, -0.005609612911939621, -0.0336117222905159, -0.002948206849396229, 0.04503786936402321, 0.013146619312465191, 0.02344835177063942, 0.01696079410612583, 0.0016889373073354363, 0.012463632971048355, -0.02358141914010048, -0.013726972043514252, 0.03154276683926582, 0.00816644262522459, 0.010401311330497265, -0.028287198394536972, -0.007012829650193453, 0.03459520265460014, 0.00791282020509243, 0.015317751094698906, -0.03685065358877182, -0.021551039069890976, 0.020499208942055702, 0.012142365798354149, 0.02598540298640728, -0.05749136209487915, -0.051461342722177505, -0.005618257448077202, 0.030544795095920563, 0.00020481993851717561, -0.010245438665151596, -0.016982797533273697, 0.04071039333939552, -0.04989808425307274, 0.00817695539444685, -0.012172726914286613, -0.05238957330584526, 0.028802527114748955, 0.019410602748394012, 0.02675333432853222, -0.02143772877752781, 0.00253016478382051, -0.02788521535694599, 0.0070283119566738605, 0.02664763666689396, 0.03999810293316841, -0.017311235889792442, 0.02320103347301483, -0.026888975873589516, 0.009070436470210552, 0.00466291094198823, -0.0061911470256745815, -0.015245471149682999, 0.03356026113033295, 0.05154797062277794, -0.00016494996089022607, -0.021806780248880386, 0.050220247358083725, -0.1351163387298584, 0.009820694103837013, -0.02123652584850788, 0.020330054685473442, -0.005135100334882736, 0.024735087528824806, 0.033825553953647614, -0.0783376470208168, 0.0375145748257637, 0.0365167073905468, -0.01335784513503313, -0.09712935984134674, 0.014609431847929955, 0.0008453754126094282, -0.05298038572072983, -2.5683175408630632e-05, 0.014325089752674103, -0.012572751380503178, 0.012035715393722057, -0.02851402945816517, -0.0228694137185812, -0.004070698283612728, -0.023365499451756477, 0.020855529233813286, -0.039251893758773804, -0.0005502827116288245, 0.015826111659407616, -0.0009684660471975803, -0.09277669340372086, -0.014492603950202465, -0.013066096231341362, 0.005174458026885986, -0.009204594418406487, -0.016931621357798576, 0.05360894650220871, -0.04373354837298393, 0.02340608276426792, -0.0708061084151268, 0.002420671982690692, -0.0013437534216791391, -0.08091683685779572, -0.005823458544909954, 0.043505117297172546, 0.022786272689700127, -0.026820091530680656, -0.03941185772418976, -0.001897686393931508, -0.0019929262343794107, 0.01109173335134983, -0.03231889754533768, 0.028834454715251923, 0.04050751030445099, -0.010442006401717663, 0.041000667959451675, 0.06842168420553207, -0.0488814115524292, 0.02205517888069153, 0.003764218417927623, 0.053338587284088135, -0.006511383224278688, 0.006890741176903248, -0.08565642684698105, -0.023081380873918533, 0.028097325935959816, -0.028030527755618095, 0.03542783483862877, -0.0029452352318912745, -0.0013071466237306595, 0.0026815272867679596, 0.041480425745248795, -0.004490769933909178, -0.02399325743317604, 0.01012940052896738, 0.041807107627391815, -0.03146704286336899, -0.04090020805597305, 0.017330462113022804, -0.02599935047328472, 0.036201998591423035, 0.02848048508167267, -0.04474981874227524, 0.030507147312164307, -0.014316174201667309, -0.016419371590018272, -0.015316636301577091, 0.06803856045007706, 0.016427917405962944, -0.004235144704580307, 0.0199740007519722, 0.06092330068349838, -0.02457399293780327, 0.014737579971551895, -0.07901928573846817, -0.0491446852684021, 0.004035459831357002, -0.007712559774518013, 0.06573010981082916, -0.003675286192446947, -0.030456457287073135, -0.040796518325805664, -0.061978571116924286, 0.06505915522575378, 0.0025724556762725115, -0.03159712627530098, -0.03444085642695427, 0.027114350348711014, -0.006298430729657412, -0.009201659820973873, 0.019696874544024467, -0.020047085359692574, 0.10373933613300323, -0.03237839415669441, -0.012789548374712467, -0.010127111338078976, -0.015280666761100292, 0.01603171043097973, -0.02414499782025814, 0.029291128739714622, 0.062036287039518356, 0.014934778213500977, -0.06110681593418121, 0.02586120367050171, -0.017260920256376266, 0.006348483730107546, -0.0140836825594306, 0.04030264541506767, 0.0355919674038887, -0.008524367585778236, 0.017992738634347916, -0.04170791432261467, 0.09550462663173676, -0.04114902764558792, -0.0007085916586220264, 0.048555124551057816, 0.016660260036587715, 0.03622101992368698, -0.06317181140184402, 0.055782780051231384, -0.013227096758782864, -0.028439659625291824, 0.0282229483127594, 0.0072083743289113045, -0.027465559542179108, -0.02223793976008892, -0.0053298743441700935, -0.012916631996631622, -0.07408217340707779, 0.02314702607691288, 0.016767961904406548, -0.025915104895830154, -0.057908374816179276, 0.003118752036243677, 0.011450488120317459, 0.009115004912018776, -0.05541563779115677, -0.0036362071987241507, 0.0203262809664011, -0.046155545860528946, 0.04945710301399231, -0.028954338282346725, 0.032752640545368195, 0.04141893610358238, -0.00612568249925971, -0.013116453774273396, -0.007027798797935247, 0.022828638553619385, 0.008112362585961819, -0.01826765574514866, -0.02904834970831871, 0.01721412129700184, -0.01627940870821476, 0.03822347894310951, 0.030451064929366112, 0.07108768820762634, -0.032480478286743164, 0.006354332901537418, 0.012899345718324184, -0.029808957129716873, 0.009097532369196415, -0.010863900184631348, 0.02002694085240364, 0.007110901642590761, 0.02447952702641487, -0.011358698830008507, -6.586538074770942e-05, -0.0013813432306051254, 0.018643558025360107, -0.00751399714499712, -0.020520884543657303, 0.03534485772252083, -0.032040588557720184, -6.191449233951948e-33, 0.018857304006814957, -0.0072819534689188, -0.06719081103801727, -0.06259872764348984, -0.04405587911605835, 0.058641113340854645, -0.013440536335110664, -0.02918178029358387, -0.008931159041821957, -0.016599105671048164, -0.005869781598448753, 0.011440545320510864, -0.010840530507266521, 0.025500407442450523, 0.040592920035123825, -0.007426348514854908, 0.0012115826830267906, -0.009918083436787128, 0.04722043499350548, 0.01269377302378416, 0.024305427446961403, 0.04258664324879646, 0.05174647644162178, -0.0811326652765274, -0.03273261711001396, 0.025038229301571846, -0.023227674886584282, -0.04219263046979904, -0.018439514562487602, 0.02794320322573185, 0.0005048901657573879, 0.04841255024075508, -0.004853690974414349, -0.005195895209908485, -0.018270427361130714, -0.002799627371132374, -0.002662074053660035, -0.07051558792591095, -0.10236436873674393, 0.010742112062871456, -0.06402274966239929, -0.00944073311984539, 0.08607729524374008, -0.011604034341871738, -0.008325069211423397, -0.004206470679491758, 0.050611577928066254, 0.020387671887874603, -0.007116060238331556, -0.04453231021761894, -0.014984263107180595, 0.005732371937483549, -0.02310336008667946, 0.005856293719261885, 0.014118829742074013, -0.0023243818432092667, -0.008159616962075233, 0.025343749672174454, -0.09036464244127274, 6.782815762562677e-05, 0.008082438260316849, 0.043281517922878265, 0.013182107359170914, 0.0007559405057691038, 0.05005459487438202, 0.04547685384750366, 0.05922779440879822, 0.009099175222218037, -0.009910606779158115, -0.03446251153945923, 0.028525980189442635, 0.05758599564433098, 0.02868734300136566, 0.002136632101610303, 0.09128820896148682, -0.07638225704431534, -0.06367012858390808, 0.02863631583750248, 0.013060051947832108, 0.04464314132928848, -0.029462125152349472, -0.0039070891216397285, -0.0012217616895213723, -0.00839601457118988, 0.00986773706972599, -0.04434386268258095, -0.008313734084367752, -0.050154704600572586, 0.007977013476192951, -0.03447217866778374, -0.010883535258471966, 0.038614630699157715, -0.03576236218214035, -0.058597344905138016, 0.07394584268331528, -0.006920830346643925, 0.029410017654299736, 0.04213399067521095, 0.04605231061577797, 0.01204586774110794, -0.006423361133784056, -0.03951846808195114, -0.03764420375227928, 0.015313602983951569, 0.03444662317633629, 0.03176365792751312, 0.022702299058437347, 0.03869491070508957, 0.010541982017457485, -0.04599034786224365, 0.002168660517781973, -0.06594777852296829, 0.023013263940811157, 0.05163002759218216, 0.020023727789521217, -0.024135693907737732, 0.013722574338316917, 0.01893814280629158, 0.006431499496102333, -0.007655350025743246, 0.0008762167999520898, 0.007867216132581234, 0.02011164464056492, 0.05017916113138199, -0.044188447296619415, -0.045870743691921234, -0.07925350964069366, -0.0022579405922442675, 0.02735109068453312, -0.05853680148720741, -0.020029360428452492, -0.009685060940682888, 3.0793916039328906e-07, -0.022461168467998505, 0.002010798780247569, -0.0042681400664150715, -0.015389794483780861, 0.03220990300178528, 0.0059620351530611515, 0.02704094909131527, 0.05624042823910713, -0.04336991533637047, -0.014980927109718323, 0.045771948993206024, -0.02827267535030842, -0.017680920660495758, -0.013269356451928616, -0.05640142410993576, 0.04599926993250847, -0.041374240070581436, 0.03888102248311043, -0.012507678009569645, 0.03682517260313034, 0.01759948581457138, 0.10538163781166077, 0.03146498650312424, -0.022132333368062973, 0.07114775478839874, 0.050574738532304764, 0.032127853482961655, -0.00011356829054420814, 0.05090092495083809, 0.0013550961157307029, 0.016260121017694473, 0.04734188690781593, -0.016480494290590286, -0.002324604894965887, -0.0006227759295143187, 0.0889582633972168, 0.04874680936336517, 0.008326835930347443, -0.019458670169115067, -0.046692486852407455, 0.03646049648523331, -0.0015733864856883883, 0.02321147918701172, 0.004333745688199997, 0.033015720546245575, -0.009106607176363468, -0.046292148530483246, -0.06484300643205643, 0.043197471648454666, 0.024313515052199364, 0.05110954865813255, -0.040181729942560196, 0.010528529062867165, -0.03764910250902176, -0.01056114211678505, -0.06384104490280151, 0.0022959685884416103, -0.05522548779845238, 0.040989965200424194, 0.004272310063242912, -0.025767024606466293, 0.022582754492759705, 0.003453312674537301, -0.007677787449210882, 0.1180211529135704, 0.008129560388624668, -0.005734144244343042, 2.929400339693778e-34, -0.05547548830509186, -0.002415725262835622, -0.02277257665991783, 0.05054054409265518, -0.03748147189617157, -0.012498907744884491, 0.0018317209323868155, 0.007774822413921356, 0.0128509271889925, -0.01643412746489048, -0.076305091381073]
661
661
['Ardavan Salehi Nobandegani', 'Thomas R. Shultz']
1701.05004v1
Humans are not only adept in recognizing what class an input instance belongs to (i.e., classification task), but perhaps more remarkably, they can imagine (i.e., generate) plausible instances of a desired class with ease, when prompted. Inspired by this, we propose a framework which allows transforming Cascade-Correlation Neural Networks (CCNNs) into probabilistic generative models, thereby enabling CCNNs to generate samples from a category of interest. CCNNs are a well-known class of deterministic, discriminative NNs, which autonomously construct their topology, and have been successful in giving accounts for a variety of psychological phenomena. Our proposed framework is based on a Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) method, called the Metropolis-adjusted Langevin algorithm, which capitalizes on the gradient information of the target distribution to direct its explorations towards regions of high probability, thereby achieving good mixing properties. Through extensive simulations, we demonstrate the efficacy of our proposed framework.
Converting Cascade-Correlation Neural Nets into Probabilistic Generative Models
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1701.05004v1
Title Converting CascadeCorrelation Neural Nets Probabilistic Generative Models Summary Humans adept recognizing class input instance belongs ie classification task perhaps remarkably imagine ie generate plausible instance desired class ease prompted Inspired propose framework allows transforming CascadeCorrelation Neural Networks CCNNs probabilistic generative model thereby enabling CCNNs generate sample category interest CCNNs wellknown class deterministic discriminative NNs autonomously construct topology successful giving account variety psychological phenomenon proposed framework based Markov Chain Monte Carlo MCMC method called Metropolisadjusted Langevin algorithm capitalizes gradient information target distribution direct exploration towards region high probability thereby achieving good mixing property extensive simulation demonstrate efficacy proposed framework Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.00014280565665103495, 0.09656462073326111, -0.032682426273822784, 0.012405757792294025, -0.03379938006401062, 0.002445181366056204, 0.053696729242801666, -0.02378443256020546, -0.009187174960970879, 0.014752513729035854, -0.0019390084780752659, 0.034141041338443756, 0.009422731585800648, 0.023686226457357407, -0.011698721908032894, -0.0854855477809906, 0.01972358301281929, 0.008159610442817211, -0.04826315492391586, -0.002359313890337944, -0.003393653780221939, -0.01748698763549328, -0.021164070814847946, 0.028511829674243927, -0.05368562042713165, -0.026272952556610107, -0.015021550469100475, -0.003449410432949662, -0.0012402330758050084, 0.012692229822278023, 0.0173720121383667, 0.031300995498895645, 0.029610643163323402, 0.010223137214779854, 2.2081981114752125e-06, -0.04157130420207977, -0.0034233867190778255, 0.006152692716568708, 0.038348760455846786, -0.05450000986456871, -0.016963111236691475, 0.02653719112277031, 0.013534869998693466, -0.009144817478954792, -0.02987147681415081, -0.00952388346195221, 0.05947978049516678, 0.03849613666534424, -0.013318846002221107, 0.006295059807598591, -0.020506728440523148, -0.0495796836912632, 0.038110870867967606, -0.028231490403413773, 0.02889900468289852, -0.036205608397722244, 0.03457643836736679, 0.03850038722157478, -0.03195883706212044, -0.035090371966362, -0.04055071249604225, 0.017129290848970413, 0.03848965838551521, 0.005823546089231968, 0.07668334990739822, 0.028236428275704384, 0.008082057349383831, -0.02014542557299137, 0.016795689240098, 0.024012338370084763, -0.02775753103196621, -0.011972899548709393, 0.006825062911957502, 0.020105861127376556, -0.01845240779221058, 0.014848696067929268, -0.017949441447854042, -0.01304264273494482, -0.023975735530257225, 0.037509262561798096, -0.02651682123541832, 0.07687132805585861, -0.027415072545409203, -0.012518059462308884, 0.013346628285944462, -0.007416523993015289, 0.018619878217577934, 0.017956925556063652, 0.003986631985753775, -0.0021246462129056454, 0.05575111508369446, -0.03257594257593155, 0.053793132305145264, 0.006642701104283333, 0.007783539593219757, -0.014054609462618828, -0.009720811620354652, 0.016154121607542038, 0.022862115874886513, -0.024415094405412674, 0.020988455042243004, -0.019406212493777275, -0.019809938967227936, 0.04363609105348587, -0.054876212030649185, 0.0163001399487257, -0.07404822111129761, -0.04233846440911293, -0.029806198552250862, -0.010744237340986729, -0.09212971478700638, -0.005321875214576721, -0.01051100343465805, 0.004219271242618561, 0.04746276140213013, -0.012956319376826286, -0.09620284289121628, -0.025190439075231552, 0.006916047539561987, -0.02743532508611679, 0.009984755888581276, 0.09559616446495056, -0.022993378341197968, -0.02239808812737465, -0.0033451588824391365, 0.009824300184845924, -0.0025373673997819424, 0.04112241789698601, 0.018381265923380852, 0.010255909524857998, 0.04552746191620827, 0.03983404114842415, 0.007227892987430096, 0.02831396460533142, -0.006659713573753834, 0.06152842193841934, -0.0042791664600372314, 0.009120958857238293, -0.058460719883441925, 0.003120324108749628, -0.021695779636502266, 0.0178107637912035, 0.04259560629725456, -0.07101625204086304, -0.032701246440410614, -0.03833164647221565, -0.020128414034843445, -0.01835465617477894, 0.005847525782883167, -0.04057358577847481, -0.03068588301539421, 0.04653675854206085, -0.03104066476225853, -0.012820430099964142, 0.08727831393480301, -0.01440734788775444, 0.007329277694225311, 0.018171871080994606, 0.08059290796518326, 0.059583328664302826, -0.0005714044091291726, -0.027698779478669167, 0.057838357985019684, -0.009841498918831348, -0.03677428141236305, -0.07372480630874634, -0.05635221302509308, -0.05253696069121361, -0.029502473771572113, 0.013882692903280258, 0.04694486781954765, 0.03829047083854675, 0.019868992269039154, -0.01647011935710907, 0.021079381927847862, -0.020260008051991463, 0.02850528247654438, 0.009297370910644531, 0.033518120646476746, -0.0538761131465435, -0.020317012444138527, 0.021796340122818947, 0.011032719165086746, 0.09712863713502884, -0.042465582489967346, -0.021303657442331314, -0.038836702704429626, 0.025748591870069504, -0.05152824893593788, -0.0541972853243351, 0.033306289464235306, -0.02984345331788063, -0.008067639544606209, -0.02942000888288021, 0.08363648504018784, 0.027192307636141777, 0.019077882170677185, -0.06395908445119858, 0.0129131730645895, 0.01297732349485159, -0.005369159858673811, -0.09761456400156021, 0.006391226779669523, 0.008120882324874401, -0.014843009412288666, 0.007474103476852179, 0.02951657772064209, 0.004113210365176201, -0.02281888574361801, 0.024747643619775772, -0.03160621598362923, -0.013832292519509792, 0.005831527523696423, -0.038507185876369476, -0.029826199635863304, 0.06954743713140488, 0.019665366038680077, 0.014173595234751701, 0.0005145632894709706, 0.004705275408923626, 0.02686120942234993, 0.030840372666716576, 0.0338401235640049, 0.022173602133989334, -0.01162467896938324, 0.002366362139582634, 0.07567296177148819, 0.030846649780869484, 0.016966309398412704, -0.03157446160912514, 0.021294159814715385, 0.007221640553325415, 0.008889543823897839, -0.061155855655670166, -0.04655592888593674, 0.01628480665385723, -0.029163431376218796, -0.022827334702014923, -0.03218034282326698, -0.040126219391822815, 0.010282794944941998, -0.05956427752971649, -0.025253867730498314, -0.03801466524600983, 0.04743087664246559, -0.0032587966416031122, 0.010786458849906921, -0.01378811988979578, 0.014811279252171516, 0.005312156397849321, 0.03338686749339104, -0.013594846241176128, 0.057224955409765244, 0.018864141777157784, -0.005892660468816757, -0.03105274960398674, -0.0032269260846078396, 0.03693867474794388, -0.018906891345977783, 0.033195868134498596, -0.06199892982840538, -0.025805320590734482, -0.022818712517619133, -0.008856525644659996, 0.02601918950676918, -0.044108517467975616, -0.06255897879600525, -0.007643166929483414, 0.0002687736414372921, 0.035171933472156525, 0.0023036173079162836, -0.014383656904101372, -0.02947896346449852, -0.0026418068446218967, -0.016944970935583115, -0.02781635709106922, 0.11018805205821991, -0.03474810719490051, -0.0008380790241062641, 0.03865605592727661, -0.026580024510622025, -0.055703990161418915, -0.01773722842335701, -0.030261080712080002, 0.009653657674789429, 0.06980840116739273, 0.01613732986152172, -0.05028738081455231, -0.011108273640275002, 0.031291477382183075, 0.0097832465544343, 0.004769191145896912, 0.016931485384702682, -0.01886424422264099, 0.0059224520809948444, -0.035208627581596375, 0.05590689182281494, 0.08790871500968933, 0.03155664727091789, 0.0023693335242569447, 0.014350618235766888, 0.005541802849620581, 0.0009310776367783546, -0.004826187621802092, -0.010503032244741917, -0.03645852953195572, 0.06301137804985046, -0.04836830124258995, -0.06513481587171555, 0.0341339036822319, 0.04212302342057228, -0.039589010179042816, -0.00444755470380187, -0.013146040961146355, 0.024830253794789314, -0.010145391337573528, -0.07211101800203323, -0.02603236772119999, 0.007401581387966871, 0.0043439120054244995, -0.01410471647977829, -0.03463331237435341, 0.02300139144062996, 0.03954627737402916, 0.029268909245729446, 0.00815765280276537, -0.05579490214586258, 0.013330222107470036, 0.025281736627221107, 0.0423516221344471, -0.004189280327409506, 0.02727361023426056, -0.017944538965821266, -0.06702832132577896, 0.007364728022366762, -0.0007542346138507128, -0.027481894940137863, -0.0430537685751915, -0.02527432143688202, -0.0031472013797611, 0.0017425863770768046, -0.0038848193362355232, -0.07145966589450836, 0.038549017161130905, 0.026170503348112106, 0.019829468801617622, -0.03048473782837391, 0.0029824324883520603, 0.005600858945399523, 0.006137620657682419, -0.0021128917578607798, 0.04055850952863693, -0.03047138638794422, -0.024891605600714684, 0.024518294259905815, 0.11408255994319916, 0.06270363926887512, -0.023959930986166, -0.0054602245800197124, 0.024296892806887627, 0.009612582623958588, 0.040226321667432785, -0.00717502785846591, 0.060036513954401016, -0.08945205062627792, 0.009784102439880371, -0.0475778728723526, 0.0005458119558170438, -0.015177213586866856, 0.023954467847943306, -0.03715086728334427, -0.03919888287782669, -0.0027749112341552973, 0.031077789142727852, 0.0059752860106527805, -0.10643628984689713, -0.02024330012500286, 0.0030856281518936157, -0.03329971805214882, 0.018699344247579575, 0.011883329600095749, 0.01200459897518158, 0.01101665385067463, 0.004717997275292873, -0.017633067443966866, -0.022645696997642517, -0.03193160891532898, 0.028383901342749596, -0.026491165161132812, 0.0236551184207201, 0.0006497143767774105, -0.06209254264831543, -0.043556928634643555, -0.04526687040925026, 0.003521934151649475, 0.013839717023074627, -0.010712583549320698, 0.007271660026162863, 0.025408849120140076, -0.0058041722513735294, 0.041402142494916916, -0.038954298943281174, -0.018046734854578972, -0.014724095351994038, -0.04406873881816864, 0.04861624538898468, 0.08125254511833191, 0.019454658031463623, -0.005072313826531172, -0.03445927053689957, -0.007470782846212387, -0.0884544774889946, 0.04804065451025963, 0.01046278327703476, 0.02459755353629589, 0.058193389326334, -0.001642826246097684, -0.01579081267118454, 0.05597735941410065, -0.011724641546607018, -0.004390895366668701, 0.027757160365581512, 0.010113531723618507, 0.010369697585701942, -0.03387479856610298, -0.08019822835922241, 0.03234311193227768, 0.04723364859819412, 0.007314011920243502, 0.05319082364439964, -0.05289571359753609, 0.010444512590765953, -0.009703310206532478, 0.024795878678560257, -0.031089838594198227, 0.02996647357940674, 0.03105531819164753, 0.040058620274066925, -0.0757235735654831, -0.07880514860153198, 0.039557527750730515, -0.022102275863289833, 0.06696122884750366, 0.001364049268886447, -0.00799674540758133, 0.018846414983272552, -0.03811429813504219, -0.03181952238082886, -0.009970073588192463, 0.033159319311380386, -0.03695206344127655, -0.04522063955664635, 0.025439921766519547, 0.0748528465628624, -0.059808120131492615, -0.027455227449536324, -0.05803929269313812, -0.04906840994954109, -0.007840142585337162, 0.011703265830874443, 0.07904115319252014, 0.015197210013866425, -0.008182689547538757, -0.020957574248313904, -0.03382323682308197, -0.005419430788606405, 0.10421212017536163, 0.05347694829106331, 0.009473240002989769, -0.03965456038713455, 0.009532329626381397, -0.03631007671356201, -0.016020938754081726, -0.029635164886713028, 0.08413875848054886, 0.02024475298821926, -0.03620652109384537, -0.04293088987469673, -0.028136027976870537, -0.006185097619891167, -0.048521459102630615, 0.07533203810453415, -0.06991297751665115, 0.011509185656905174, -0.02537011168897152, 0.02613811567425728, 0.008804909884929657, 0.024654582142829895, -0.02083144709467888, -0.04792368412017822, 0.0774192065000534, 0.04917600005865097, -0.026893962174654007, -0.03739636763930321, 0.056594256311655045, 0.009201370179653168, 0.003784836269915104, -0.030887797474861145, -0.015581569634377956, 0.06756240874528885, -0.04435621574521065, 0.005804824642837048, -0.01632721908390522, 0.014545060694217682, 0.01940116100013256, 0.02628140337765217, -0.016605379059910774, 0.045295313000679016, 0.006290464662015438, 0.009886933490633965, -0.056097276508808136, 0.018739785999059677, -0.022293640300631523, 0.06188074126839638, -0.04970080032944679, 0.08426353335380554, 0.07141870260238647, -0.021955465897917747, 0.004726020619273186, -0.0018477183766663074, -0.0030896689277142286, -0.02125626988708973, 0.057942163199186325, 0.0006347608286887407, 0.010488096624612808, 0.016549333930015564, -0.00989294983446598, 0.01096623670309782, -0.006183485966175795, 0.02837657928466797, 0.00600294629111886, -0.03723091632127762, 0.000195046333828941, 0.00042836659122258425, -0.002631651470437646, 0.036654867231845856, 0.02323109470307827, -0.03546376898884773, -0.007356110494583845, 0.03927887976169586, -0.012962584383785725, -0.03044900856912136, 0.00251767341978848, 0.017771827057003975, 0.07913447171449661, 0.011799025349318981, 0.03532590717077255, 0.006317849736660719, -0.02309694141149521, -0.04687591269612312, -0.012199015356600285, 0.016167020425200462, 0.01660618931055069, -0.008151852525770664, -0.025077344849705696, -6.19140662228173e-33, -0.03542091324925423, -0.04158739373087883, -0.02652992680668831, 0.021091410890221596, -0.006918490864336491, -0.028481505811214447, -0.0066479891538619995, -0.017910970374941826, 0.006004846189171076, 0.00702534057199955, -0.02989783324301243, 0.011911021545529366, 0.01660749688744545, 0.03729885071516037, 0.05853438749909401, 0.033269207924604416, -0.005759394261986017, -0.03483394905924797, 0.07562325149774551, 0.03228331357240677, 0.03628302738070488, 0.019673846662044525, 0.015344694256782532, -0.1212160512804985, -0.08550287783145905, 0.03729555755853653, -0.028738437220454216, 0.007899446412920952, -0.00996242742985487, 0.01367094088345766, -0.025083791464567184, 0.02734985388815403, 0.02689806930720806, 0.03457332402467728, 0.028272630646824837, -0.01688370853662491, -0.10499096661806107, -0.014018876478075981, -0.06717433035373688, 0.01448729820549488, -0.017978155985474586, -0.02934807911515236, 0.07748287171125412, 0.00692481966689229, 0.0036096025723963976, -0.01873665861785412, 0.06723204255104065, -0.05796059966087341, -0.017003487795591354, -0.07278592139482498, -0.04618978872895241, -0.005109745543450117, -0.013404257595539093, -0.007086033467203379, -0.017251696437597275, -0.007733066566288471, -0.04404766112565994, 0.03427409008145332, -0.06164451315999031, 0.023096200078725815, -0.031048879027366638, 0.02955678664147854, 0.004022825974971056, 0.07309774309396744, 0.059492360800504684, 0.03167535364627838, 0.059522874653339386, -0.008828864432871342, -0.037815384566783905, -0.0025872522965073586, 0.03014281392097473, 0.014162654057145119, 0.05010230094194412, 0.05450199171900749, 0.0916394367814064, -0.030286861583590508, -0.09836212545633316, 0.07191473245620728, -0.018775761127471924, -0.018645768985152245, -0.03403095528483391, 0.00857989676296711, -0.0014811053406447172, 0.0018712872406467795, 0.027272328734397888, -0.046811383217573166, -0.01536642573773861, -0.026265306398272514, 0.0013026702217757702, -0.014685415662825108, -0.007063635624945164, -0.02762363664805889, -0.0014994821976870298, -0.004337033722549677, -0.01511048711836338, -0.02668864279985428, 0.020151639357209206, 0.03243926540017128, 0.03486675024032593, 0.010584771633148193, -0.02262577973306179, -0.041765350848436356, 0.018956873565912247, 0.02112165279686451, 0.017596634104847908, 0.06950116157531738, 0.039263565093278885, 0.00782953854650259, -0.014972181059420109, -0.008697887882590294, 0.023548763245344162, -0.009203788824379444, 0.027006899937987328, -0.014834562316536903, -0.030559062957763672, -0.03951480612158775, 0.005766330286860466, 0.05313799902796745, 0.006691169925034046, 0.05138256773352623, 0.016754774376749992, -0.011226116679608822, 0.009299825876951218, 0.06895125657320023, -0.0043356409296393394, 0.013671120628714561, -0.04818804934620857, -0.00433206046000123, 0.020525533705949783, -0.06818810105323792, -0.01460085716098547, 0.034329526126384735, 2.900370930092322e-07, -0.0025897971354424953, -0.0002422072138870135, -0.006716138683259487, -0.04572860151529312, 0.06537134945392609, 0.005743382498621941, -0.03528427705168724, 0.002397285308688879, 0.024777086451649666, -0.0555255226790905, 0.016191113740205765, 0.008982505649328232, 0.012961726635694504, 0.018768932670354843, -0.049875207245349884, -0.005590667016804218, 0.020582599565386772, 0.02676556073129177, -0.007046069484204054, 0.01195197831839323, 0.05325841158628464, 0.0392327718436718, 0.027185751125216484, -0.024340616539120674, 0.06667467951774597, 0.017895102500915527, 0.007104761432856321, 0.015278940089046955, 0.04673674330115318, 0.0019030922558158636, -0.014962686225771904, -0.025513848289847374, -0.00026618328411132097, 0.06941662728786469, -0.008136032149195671, -0.007905707694590092, 0.01159100141376257, -0.033473558723926544, -0.03325127065181732, 0.006640068721026182, 0.011837054044008255, 0.057751718908548355, 0.046232789754867554, -0.042927637696266174, 0.06753737479448318, -0.07333000749349594, -0.005373154766857624, -0.041240084916353226, -0.044803813099861145, 0.03703180328011513, 0.027690831571817398, 0.01043288316577673, -0.02780083753168583, -0.02331727370619774, -0.017240140587091446, 0.007565849926322699, -0.005768452771008015, -0.03017139807343483, 0.017111122608184814, -0.014271685853600502, -0.0757802426815033, -0.017062999308109283, 0.004369040951132774, 0.0040647839196026325, 0.054878417402505875, 0.035180091857910156, -0.03169091418385506, 2.5284417421044402e-34, -0.02663400210440159, 0.020801054313778877, 0.010583845898509026, -0.03358762711286545, -0.042918261140584946, -0.008379874750971794, -0.0777973160147667, 0.00034141153446398675, 0.021623121574521065, -0.031443461775779724, -0.0389653742313385]
662
662
['Ludvig Ericson', 'Rendani Mbuvha']
1701.05130v1
Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs) have received increasing attention in recent years with applications that span a wide range of disciplines including vital domains such as medicine, network security and autonomous transportation. However, neural network architectures are becoming increasingly complex and with an increasing need to obtain real-time results from such models, it has become pivotal to use parallelization as a mechanism for speeding up network training and deployment. In this work we propose an implementation of Network Parallel Training through Cannon's Algorithm for matrix multiplication. We show that increasing the number of processes speeds up training until the point where process communication costs become prohibitive; this point varies by network complexity. We also show through empirical efficiency calculations that the speedup obtained is superlinear.
On the Performance of Network Parallel Training in Artificial Neural Networks
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1701.05130v1
Title Performance Network Parallel Training Artificial Neural Networks Summary Artificial Neural Networks ANNs received increasing attention recent year application span wide range discipline including vital domain medicine network security autonomous transportation However neural network architecture becoming increasingly complex increasing need obtain realtime result model become pivotal use parallelization mechanism speeding network training deployment work propose implementation Network Parallel Training Cannons Algorithm matrix multiplication show increasing number process speed training point process communication cost become prohibitive point varies network complexity also show empirical efficiency calculation speedup obtained superlinear Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.00465263519436121, -0.006094884127378464, -0.03394026309251785, 0.025037458166480064, 0.006173739209771156, 0.01080020610243082, 0.08450014889240265, -0.028840018436312675, -0.03439641743898392, -0.01235903799533844, -0.002023539040237665, 0.02701936475932598, 0.008542477153241634, -0.019386006519198418, 0.023082798346877098, -0.012857578694820404, 0.023524314165115356, 0.039177488535642624, 0.006207180675119162, -0.035279568284749985, 0.03117060661315918, -0.007178247440606356, -0.055672597140073776, 0.05279412493109703, -0.04134548082947731, 0.02183009311556816, 0.0068088374100625515, -0.03935588151216507, 0.040403109043836594, -0.055058181285858154, 0.03862244263291359, -0.039504535496234894, 0.033066436648368835, 0.029579050838947296, 2.315560095667024e-06, 0.004930849652737379, 0.010034396313130856, -0.0005185935297049582, 0.050964366644620895, 0.020853806287050247, 0.009641837328672409, -0.0033400626853108406, 0.0027613018173724413, 0.028132084757089615, -0.01389469113200903, -0.009242638945579529, 0.03628944233059883, 0.03091428428888321, 0.012148111127316952, 0.059720057994127274, -0.0012529048835858703, -0.03967719525098801, 0.018556764349341393, 0.0015140632167458534, -0.08084183931350708, -0.07277532666921616, -0.005910044070333242, 0.020117949694395065, -0.01765531301498413, -0.024586454033851624, 0.0068664089776575565, 0.0621301531791687, 0.05108029395341873, 0.03373176231980324, 0.042202290147542953, 0.038012996315956116, 0.02474062703549862, 0.013402904383838177, -0.044775061309337616, 0.014371281489729881, -0.05948979780077934, 0.007766359951347113, 0.007284549064934254, -0.011757972650229931, -0.02060316875576973, -0.0383271723985672, -0.02439311519265175, 0.003985049203038216, -0.006283017806708813, 0.021736828610301018, -0.03091537579894066, 0.01581493206322193, 0.04435255751013756, 0.0069003175012767315, 0.006929168943315744, 0.013759410940110683, -0.025268753990530968, 0.0290878526866436, 0.02484016679227352, -0.039108987897634506, -0.03237586468458176, 0.011912726797163486, 0.02454589121043682, 0.02658447064459324, -0.07046803086996078, -0.011141914874315262, -0.003977935295552015, -0.105008065700531, 0.059200964868068695, -0.10755188018083572, 0.05331842601299286, 7.188466406660154e-05, 0.025443419814109802, -0.023568034172058105, -0.03407946974039078, 0.06935040652751923, -0.02016661874949932, 0.049696069210767746, -0.035168979316949844, -0.0021367690060287714, -0.04191657528281212, 0.013425254262983799, -0.039699066430330276, 0.03563451021909714, 0.016483569517731667, -0.014806287363171577, -0.09931853413581848, 0.017372922971844673, -0.00012583583884406835, -0.01584969274699688, 0.004736967850476503, 0.05315924808382988, 0.01880437694489956, -0.007215883582830429, 0.018198953941464424, -0.0035775494761765003, -0.0136489262804389, 0.05623310059309006, -0.024120351299643517, -0.024021469056606293, -0.0032603272702544928, -0.0006369277834892273, -0.03952248394489288, 0.04450451210141182, -0.004560777917504311, 0.07198511064052582, -0.002118527889251709, -0.016169758513569832, -0.0963682010769844, 0.04166122153401375, 0.007893734611570835, -0.011723587289452553, -0.012229932472109795, -0.04043249040842056, 0.028264647349715233, -0.01924561709165573, -0.003772621275857091, 0.01618729531764984, 0.00842721201479435, 0.001337589928880334, 0.010572375729680061, 0.05333176255226135, -0.062426675111055374, -0.020432978868484497, 0.10918238759040833, 0.004454859998077154, 0.013052786700427532, 0.014806126244366169, 0.035151831805706024, -0.011745794676244259, -0.0011348414700478315, -0.03586351126432419, -0.035237908363342285, -0.0014808214036747813, -0.0036805912386626005, -0.07290542125701904, -0.016634520143270493, -0.04147683084011078, 0.017055034637451172, 0.07584982365369797, -0.02930023893713951, 0.023476945236325264, -0.022331271320581436, -0.039872873574495316, 0.010219579562544823, 0.0008121943101286888, 0.012089254334568977, 0.03207404911518097, 0.014978084713220596, -0.006850897800177336, -0.0006393685471266508, -0.043225351721048355, 0.039061855524778366, 0.056104760617017746, -0.0017114590154960752, -0.0362694188952446, -0.024996580556035042, 0.0034001402091234922, -0.06138620153069496, -0.033503539860248566, 0.020428838208317757, -0.04408777505159378, -0.022552767768502235, -0.040998056530952454, 0.04563653841614723, -0.011125274002552032, -0.041624367237091064, -0.02438548021018505, 0.07045134156942368, 0.03339667245745659, -0.04092661291360855, -0.0371442511677742, -0.05196790397167206, -0.02612563967704773, -0.013489160686731339, -0.00563060911372304, -0.06787750869989395, -0.010881890542805195, -0.026578325778245926, -0.05806809291243553, -0.0028807937633246183, 0.015537448227405548, 0.02869374491274357, -0.06365465372800827, 0.017703920602798462, 0.01659611240029335, -0.00851327646523714, 0.030512167140841484, 0.00703992648050189, 0.0270917396992445, 0.024810591712594032, 0.07904583215713501, -0.036884043365716934, 0.02297419309616089, -0.03888264298439026, 0.027019023895263672, 0.04011286795139313, 0.024976924061775208, 0.030501030385494232, 0.010479594580829144, 0.023580053821206093, -0.04311466962099075, 0.03857897222042084, -0.03826095908880234, -0.022706476971507072, -0.038361288607120514, -0.02747458405792713, 0.005883103236556053, 0.03590045124292374, -0.005614369176328182, 0.049566637724637985, 0.04143771156668663, -0.0019368201028555632, -0.0515797883272171, -0.03927931189537048, -0.021091429516673088, -0.006454535759985447, -0.013742064125835896, 0.029134120792150497, 0.006966132204979658, 0.012390032410621643, -0.006101137027144432, -0.011110308580100536, 0.0035876131150871515, 0.010750485584139824, -0.0257148165255785, 0.009617258794605732, 0.06425701081752777, -0.006731923203915358, -0.04210059344768524, -0.02442392148077488, -0.04211479052901268, -0.022327296435832977, -0.03622334450483322, -0.01057081762701273, 0.034455880522727966, 0.004613447468727827, -0.03725879266858101, 0.024604707956314087, -0.007104279939085245, -0.0035366800148040056, 0.000640986836515367, 0.00866791419684887, 0.03058960847556591, -0.03195358067750931, -0.004456448834389448, 0.11886662244796753, -0.023824632167816162, -0.06676817685365677, 0.0318756103515625, 0.03719949722290039, -0.015386802144348621, 0.010020621120929718, -0.0422450453042984, -0.015462116338312626, 0.012338022701442242, 0.07214245945215225, -0.011499705724418163, -0.021580591797828674, -0.03689851984381676, 0.024362454190850258, 0.030313560739159584, -0.013813587836921215, -0.07771103829145432, 0.008035752922296524, 0.01300760917365551, -0.05876706540584564, 0.027086907997727394, 0.051295652985572815, -0.05673539265990257, 0.04614885151386261, 0.08030813187360764, -0.02691001445055008, 0.02853529155254364, -0.019635586068034172, 0.023756299167871475, 0.014402384869754314, 0.01580713503062725, -0.023536106571555138, 0.02716742269694805, 0.026800869032740593, 0.03808186203241348, 0.0176057331264019, -0.013282128609716892, -0.0174417607486248, -0.036291833966970444, -0.07504919916391373, 0.0031110038980841637, -0.005528212524950504, -0.07542390376329422, 0.046066634356975555, -0.013947243802249432, 0.01589876227080822, 0.022878896445035934, 0.015857728198170662, -0.035760197788476944, -0.07542690634727478, 0.012728685513138771, -0.027312278747558594, 0.01794542744755745, 0.02747783064842224, -0.03262816369533539, -0.004900646395981312, 0.04788622632622719, 0.033410876989364624, -0.05489899590611458, -0.00017806827963795513, -0.0030112562235444784, 0.040527768433094025, -0.007047307211905718, -0.01727217808365822, -0.040392059832811356, -0.06569010019302368, -0.040985237807035446, 0.003822163213044405, 0.0007854895666241646, -0.018662303686141968, -0.05170081928372383, 0.02822510525584221, 0.0084144975990057, 0.008245843462646008, 0.04950440302491188, -0.03629090636968613, 0.001511672860942781, -0.02301948331296444, 0.030199497938156128, 0.01714099571108818, -0.06347602605819702, 0.03163078427314758, 0.03591451421380043, 0.03235773369669914, 0.00510551780462265, -0.005128996912389994, 0.021955475211143494, -0.14840662479400635, -0.027844823896884918, -0.03975261002779007, -0.02553531713783741, 0.008595388382673264, -0.004176620859652758, -0.02122366614639759, -0.033095914870500565, 0.03717668727040291, 0.03047279641032219, 0.021447371691465378, -0.06520726531744003, -0.01126569602638483, 0.03405558317899704, -0.07225736975669861, -0.016647791489958763, 0.005675218068063259, -0.010490369983017445, 0.0011646754574030638, -0.0025799290742725134, -0.006840513087809086, -0.05453913286328316, -0.0060869003646075726, -0.01962265744805336, -0.042294811457395554, 0.006705207750201225, -0.009049355052411556, -0.07610707730054855, -0.028421442955732346, -0.019701560959219933, 0.0010295334504917264, -0.029349435120821, 0.0669044777750969, 0.025852970778942108, 0.02852877788245678, -0.011578033678233624, 0.049787361174821854, -0.023121917620301247, 0.005818018689751625, -0.021554043516516685, -0.07058464735746384, 0.049876146018505096, -0.02010023221373558, -0.013904950581490993, -0.05224985256791115, -0.04172980412840843, 0.003024000907316804, 0.025892863050103188, 0.024362897500395775, -0.032671865075826645, 0.03780660405755043, 0.046341560781002045, -0.05704657360911369, -0.0029966358561068773, 0.03633428364992142, -0.010512230917811394, 0.03927777707576752, 0.020654236897826195, 0.04129263013601303, -0.04092703387141228, 0.008917117491364479, -0.043373458087444305, 0.00924006663262844, 0.01544402725994587, -0.010964129120111465, -0.014283471740782261, -0.027296682819724083, 0.016149744391441345, 0.03532049059867859, -0.0011263953056186438, -0.04401179403066635, 0.04961918666958809, 0.006793824024498463, -0.014685451053082943, -0.05086403712630272, -0.054758790880441666, -0.002394896000623703, -0.017751412466168404, 0.010312787257134914, 0.0372835248708725, -0.0024613894056528807, 0.04447340592741966, 0.020149070769548416, -0.016754910349845886, -0.040399886667728424, 0.06165511906147003, 0.008988576009869576, 0.005758386105298996, 0.02343892864882946, 0.05846954882144928, -0.014229463413357735, -0.012640656903386116, -0.014816809445619583, -0.0365460105240345, 0.022721948102116585, 0.008946041576564312, 0.027801617980003357, -0.014318712055683136, 0.009969531558454037, -0.05071035400032997, -0.04326363280415535, 0.015449417755007744, 0.0022041164338588715, -0.029288267716765404, -0.006788352038711309, 0.0038075875490903854, -0.02108173444867134, 0.024539588019251823, 0.005093587562441826, 0.031918834894895554, 0.07040762901306152, 0.022031202912330627, -0.05777810886502266, -0.032078709453344345, 0.0005007059080526233, 0.012906472198665142, 0.02643938735127449, 0.03942601755261421, 0.0417754240334034, 0.03087940812110901, -0.037940122187137604, 0.0652988851070404, 0.019296258687973022, 0.03989686816930771, -0.046080321073532104, 0.010631554760038853, 0.015380922704935074, 0.031990014016628265, -0.001556387054733932, -0.06202862039208412, 0.12133514136075974, -0.11339998245239258, 0.011853104457259178, 0.030855868011713028, -0.0006378788384608924, 0.062314216047525406, -0.06474744528532028, 0.03899380564689636, -0.015166370198130608, -0.029056014493107796, 0.038556817919015884, -0.010931087657809258, -0.06197769567370415, 0.04152399301528931, 0.016154328361153603, -0.006358569487929344, -0.022258419543504715, 0.01706027053296566, 0.01725687086582184, -0.017840806394815445, 0.005839697550982237, 0.055624354630708694, 0.05642350763082504, 0.03402619808912277, -0.040575847029685974, -0.02049153670668602, 0.030508877709507942, -0.02370413951575756, 0.016580820083618164, -0.05125393345952034, 0.08959202468395233, 0.009597326628863811, -0.0022323201410472393, 0.004885242786258459, 0.017326606437563896, 0.017709489911794662, -0.02608443610370159, 0.007425279356539249, 0.007268794812262058, 0.008788159117102623, -0.014936736784875393, 0.040967490524053574, -0.01768466643989086, 0.05088501796126366, -0.01704014465212822, -0.008010457269847393, 0.06683271378278732, -0.0034679146483540535, 0.028139634057879448, 0.024039139971137047, 0.03151228651404381, -0.018087198957800865, 0.03207783028483391, -0.019300192594528198, 0.008355651050806046, -0.019307630136609077, -0.0007436926243826747, -0.009989271871745586, -0.012228282168507576, 0.011612032540142536, -0.010171021334826946, -6.145372059451622e-33, 0.017737505957484245, 0.004121567588299513, 0.010306104086339474, -0.0010790979722514749, -0.05372776836156845, 0.035305678844451904, 0.007437737658619881, -0.024090813472867012, -0.01983918435871601, -0.017500391229987144, -0.018980447202920914, 0.034531693905591965, 0.00612096581608057, 0.014952078461647034, 0.03822961822152138, 0.009793736971914768, -0.009052450768649578, -0.005252006463706493, 0.0684424564242363, -0.008625068701803684, 0.029585421085357666, 0.06452075392007828, 0.03513634204864502, -0.06204812973737717, -0.07108257710933685, -0.00825018621981144, -0.025189552456140518, -0.021168695762753487, -0.06598330289125443, -0.004096524324268103, -0.013042761944234371, 0.02145497500896454, 0.027013350278139114, -0.039993997663259506, -0.003358752466738224, -0.021703481674194336, -0.042370568960905075, -0.0063256314024329185, -0.043391305953264236, 0.04555553197860718, -0.07585024833679199, -0.004607846029102802, 0.10853656381368637, -0.041979752480983734, -0.06949671357870102, 0.043609701097011566, 0.019764654338359833, -0.005080573260784149, 0.012417854741215706, 0.02059628814458847, 0.006636078469455242, -0.0006719827651977539, -0.013928030617535114, 0.04317403584718704, 0.03431583195924759, -0.003487050998955965, -0.05237911641597748, -0.022636471316218376, -0.06536181271076202, -0.014291355386376381, -0.008727552369236946, 0.030648287385702133, -0.06901510059833527, 0.02570038102567196, 0.045635122805833817, 0.00862257182598114, 0.06426101177930832, -0.04453666880726814, 0.011024822480976582, 0.0102625023573637, -0.021388690918684006, 0.05256922170519829, 0.08533260971307755, -0.012794718146324158, 0.08515268564224243, -0.10855155438184738, -0.11678842455148697, 0.025978632271289825, -0.00014115810336079448, 0.005789016839116812, 0.013542775064706802, -0.030514299869537354, -0.03932715952396393, 0.024024723097682, 0.05076969787478447, -0.019040264189243317, -0.019392799586057663, -0.03281649574637413, 0.0017922979313880205, -0.009997634217143059, 0.02493632212281227, 0.03310459479689598, -0.03797217831015587, -0.06587795168161392, 0.11647836863994598, 0.0013484187657013535, 0.04257958382368088, 0.030166354030370712, 0.03345555067062378, -0.02052907645702362, -0.05092126876115799, -8.29957498353906e-05, -0.06320454180240631, -0.004849929362535477, 0.02513212151825428, 0.03380672633647919, 0.05348913371562958, -0.008846839889883995, 0.02460775151848793, -0.029384609311819077, 0.014448454603552818, -0.015349552035331726, 0.022826658561825752, -0.004651007708162069, 0.034239210188388824, -0.014732008799910545, -0.004479468800127506, 0.03454618155956268, 0.0206861924380064, -0.02740698680281639, -0.011099778115749359, -0.03610390052199364, 0.0099638057872653, -0.004626327659934759, -0.055056195706129074, -0.0067557115107774734, -0.018821951001882553, 0.030467774718999863, -0.045399975031614304, -0.0677514523267746, -0.023556573316454887, -0.0018732884200289845, 2.8441570520953974e-07, -0.023710498586297035, 0.004411359317600727, -0.024005452170968056, -0.02540992945432663, 0.016784753650426865, -0.023401310667395592, -0.008474067784845829, 0.03267620876431465, -0.037803325802087784, 0.044834237545728683, 0.052135758101940155, -0.02143098972737789, 0.005950054619461298, -0.00010078674677060917, -0.07320509105920792, -0.034668371081352234, -0.04929859936237335, 0.06641267240047455, 0.0034279206302016973, 0.04702198877930641, 0.02913687191903591, 0.049290746450424194, 0.06444232910871506, -0.04412664845585823, 0.027344554662704468, 0.022945523262023926, -0.012308916077017784, 0.04029042273759842, 0.026440009474754333, -0.020985117182135582, -0.012309398502111435, 0.050762031227350235, -0.011684353463351727, 0.05995342880487442, 0.0049362387508153915, 0.04781430959701538, 0.005211533047258854, 0.014293120242655277, 0.0010933022713288665, 0.008144227787852287, 0.07337352633476257, 0.012899323366582394, 0.01316460594534874, 0.009512169286608696, 0.05505184456706047, 0.007416673004627228, -0.03597794100642204, -0.057659972459077835, 0.03611958771944046, 0.019297493621706963, 0.06134454160928726, 0.007856086827814579, 0.021730681881308556, -0.03914123773574829, -0.00982870813459158, -0.04409245401620865, -0.011641232296824455, -0.036783911287784576, 0.006989981513470411, 0.038465533405542374, -0.014144744724035263, -0.018380476161837578, -0.004395037889480591, 0.021059716120362282, 0.07384317368268967, 0.010122992098331451, -0.01220046728849411, 2.146544060920174e-34, -0.04649762064218521, -0.021989088505506516, 0.013239516876637936, 0.05709485337138176, -0.026139939203858376, 0.007060070056468248, -0.019921481609344482, -0.02355504408478737, -0.04463393986225128, -0.02347017452120781, -0.030147040262818336]
663
663
['Misha Denil', 'Sergio Gómez Colmenarejo', 'Serkan Cabi', 'David Saxton', 'Nando de Freitas']
1706.06383v1
We build deep RL agents that execute declarative programs expressed in formal language. The agents learn to ground the terms in this language in their environment, and can generalize their behavior at test time to execute new programs that refer to objects that were not referenced during training. The agents develop disentangled interpretable representations that allow them to generalize to a wide variety of zero-shot semantic tasks.
Programmable Agents
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1706.06383v1
Title Programmable Agents Summary build deep RL agent execute declarative program expressed formal language agent learn ground term language environment generalize behavior test time execute new program refer object referenced training agent develop disentangled interpretable representation allow generalize wide variety zeroshot semantic task Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.015608362853527069, 0.04042176902294159, -0.008841241709887981, 0.021490028128027916, -0.04310496523976326, 0.0172731876373291, 0.004734480753540993, -0.02396218851208687, -0.006850042380392551, -0.029864156618714333, 0.027934923768043518, 0.06956136226654053, -0.03755027800798416, 0.12334099411964417, -0.005062830168753862, -0.09316246211528778, 0.03376861289143562, -0.02087225578725338, 0.010665388777852058, -0.010320911183953285, 0.006503866985440254, -0.009932335466146469, -0.00046552540152333677, 0.03976757824420929, 0.007386387325823307, -0.039003077894449234, -0.07063357532024384, -0.021237049251794815, -0.005370518658310175, -0.011985902674496174, -0.0016123892273753881, 0.00986599363386631, 0.07994677126407623, 0.06351140141487122, 2.4347227736143395e-06, -0.0195428766310215, -0.024290114641189575, -0.007604870479553938, -0.0193005558103323, -0.0799880400300026, -0.004179790616035461, -0.048710837960243225, 0.00883385632187128, -0.013869712129235268, -0.021754495799541473, -0.07039391994476318, 0.05923449993133545, 0.011825691908597946, 0.045615147799253464, 0.06784722954034805, -0.0036453346256166697, -0.05743497982621193, 0.008638103492558002, 0.0016527066472917795, 0.024605106562376022, -0.03651171922683716, -0.003755554324015975, 0.03412169963121414, -0.002045318018645048, -0.0032853614538908005, -0.05372430011630058, -0.015493123792111874, 0.036026835441589355, -0.011866997927427292, 0.013838879764080048, 0.01616540364921093, -0.009939635172486305, -0.06367814540863037, 0.020207479596138, 0.06229075789451599, -0.0021965322084724903, -0.0047437651082873344, 0.018070856109261513, 0.028856974095106125, -0.010022726841270924, -0.03822594881057739, 0.0014162326697260141, 0.03732072561979294, 0.008351420983672142, 9.029044304043055e-05, -0.000945361505728215, 0.03963172063231468, -0.010500353761017323, 0.007988839410245419, -0.03174447640776634, 0.06326164305210114, -0.014682671055197716, -0.0007583494298160076, -0.020120617002248764, -0.014835508540272713, 0.06445974111557007, -0.05548327416181564, -0.020036151632666588, 0.030183469876646996, -0.044632792472839355, 0.012168115936219692, -0.04024622589349747, -0.039809733629226685, -0.008193660527467728, -0.02990107424557209, 0.017538921907544136, 0.002612491836771369, 0.02199583128094673, 0.02789686992764473, -0.04668281972408295, 0.06946001201868057, -0.01653205417096615, 0.0822238028049469, -0.02596336416900158, -0.01575816422700882, -0.07618498802185059, -0.004195725079625845, -0.0623161680996418, 0.09252037107944489, -0.004707590211182833, -0.02452445775270462, -0.053446460515260696, 0.05562973767518997, -0.033027585595846176, 0.028916163370013237, -0.04845767840743065, 0.029545478522777557, -0.05948292836546898, 0.005848281551152468, -0.0677494928240776, 0.013385574333369732, -0.06296242773532867, -0.01467723399400711, 0.010921742767095566, -0.033193621784448624, 0.0053863232024014, 0.01257921289652586, 0.000531251891516149, -0.0036722507793456316, -0.01406419649720192, 0.0992967039346695, -0.01589576154947281, -0.00045195568236522377, -0.019316015765070915, -0.04158256947994232, 0.06319350749254227, -0.03977494686841965, -0.007202481850981712, -0.08237242698669434, -0.0002745481033343822, -0.026865556836128235, -0.004811340942978859, -0.045635707676410675, -0.025410732254385948, -0.02501523494720459, 0.01172664575278759, 0.08981877565383911, -0.041275981813669205, -0.009650509804487228, 0.01274503767490387, 0.014766664244234562, 0.025026926770806313, 0.07487289607524872, -0.0009909814689308405, 0.051882851868867874, -0.006696211639791727, 0.001391859259456396, 0.03363534063100815, -0.03915569931268692, -0.01551844272762537, -0.006442256271839142, -0.012592395767569542, -0.007725242059677839, -0.009411836043000221, 0.024393996223807335, 0.01456369087100029, -0.00934118963778019, -0.019612327218055725, -0.020972609519958496, 0.0049996282905340195, 0.07063847780227661, 0.038825616240501404, 0.030948439612984657, 0.0661676898598671, 0.02674151211977005, -0.03992893919348717, -0.0344177670776844, -0.03977997601032257, 0.08518213033676147, 0.0028152139857411385, 0.014293627813458443, -0.0912049263715744, 0.01004928257316351, -0.0555524080991745, -0.05964245647192001, 0.05341355875134468, -0.03243986517190933, 0.05320698767900467, -0.012950915843248367, 0.07024859637022018, 0.02656741812825203, -0.05397569760680199, -0.044344838708639145, -0.006361066829413176, -0.005507795140147209, -0.02996411919593811, -0.09372200071811676, 0.017270445823669434, 0.05232100561261177, -4.944257852912415e-06, -0.06174960359930992, -0.020748905837535858, -0.009390242397785187, 0.003726939670741558, 0.07057462632656097, 0.014791690744459629, -0.018419619649648666, 0.028733670711517334, -0.004716000985354185, -0.03157326579093933, -0.02407616376876831, 0.01813199557363987, 0.08922881633043289, -0.02314997836947441, 0.012483407743275166, -0.017192378640174866, 0.04012882336974144, 0.03306214511394501, 0.02481282874941826, -0.00883675180375576, -0.03534013777971268, 0.002796898828819394, 0.021098293364048004, 0.036039408296346664, 0.004450087435543537, -0.004626477602869272, -0.001134354854002595, 0.0257844477891922, 0.0033789437729865313, -0.062233392149209976, -0.0042106350883841515, 0.01473440695554018, -0.005879552569240332, -0.013294274918735027, -0.05706324428319931, 0.02340186946094036, 0.055969588458538055, -0.031978532671928406, -0.03635251894593239, 0.06520358473062515, -0.0023191459476947784, 0.05375592038035393, 0.016184821724891663, -0.0020031353924423456, -0.011409247294068336, 0.012465611100196838, -0.00933991838246584, 0.04080608859658241, 0.014888389967381954, -0.027521420270204544, -0.0018529712688177824, -0.002173313172534108, 0.019335085526108742, -0.021036576479673386, -0.0034759489353746176, 0.024948660284280777, -0.011288190260529518, 0.04080633074045181, 0.028141282498836517, 0.0318697988986969, -0.021883942186832428, 0.013531294651329517, 0.004005731083452702, -0.016703570261597633, -0.0030350969173014164, -0.03998271003365517, 0.01533222384750843, -0.006198483053594828, 0.019672805443406105, -0.03946082666516304, -0.02125496231019497, 0.04907923936843872, 0.0032250096555799246, 0.0046029831282794476, 0.03201952576637268, 0.026207705959677696, -0.05149667710065842, -0.03264452517032623, -0.016788113862276077, -0.0071967849507927895, 0.010895838029682636, 0.010625177063047886, -0.035915542393922806, -0.016611197963356972, 0.012524534948170185, -0.02964196354150772, 0.04680260643362999, -0.010147932916879654, -0.08232849836349487, 0.017498532310128212, -0.039341360330581665, -0.08688443899154663, 0.09484168142080307, -0.03729885444045067, 0.08240607380867004, 0.04408697783946991, 0.025604352355003357, -0.05528721585869789, 0.018264150246977806, -0.0255460012704134, -0.0016701428685337305, 0.00277889147400856, 0.01609759032726288, -0.009524047374725342, 0.06651543825864792, 0.008733680471777916, 0.023650776594877243, -0.04306226223707199, 0.029791729524731636, 0.02888248674571514, -0.06926712393760681, -0.02394549734890461, -0.0016154141630977392, -0.0023589765187352896, 0.051906269043684006, -0.029881613329052925, -0.03473217785358429, 0.10995367914438248, 0.0471077561378479, -0.0067275031469762325, -0.03095269203186035, -0.05657949671149254, 0.0036386344581842422, 0.07886093854904175, 0.02550029382109642, 0.024686340242624283, -0.017585476860404015, -0.016695862635970116, -0.023447927087545395, -0.018212467432022095, 0.020494995638728142, 0.00975379440933466, 0.06100720539689064, -0.03863988816738129, 0.0012152181006968021, -0.004696034360677004, -0.016819536685943604, -0.054715488106012344, 0.025488998740911484, -0.030257631093263626, 0.039290137588977814, -0.009165752679109573, -0.023465342819690704, -0.03384353965520859, -0.015215261839330196, 0.02596443146467209, 0.0239619929343462, -0.009997803717851639, -0.032660529017448425, -0.054017286747694016, -0.08490768820047379, 0.04653508961200714, -0.027417905628681183, -0.061374831944704056, -0.007469092030078173, 0.0775931179523468, 0.023315507918596268, -0.043353188782930374, -0.045694660395383835, -0.09874264150857925, 0.018474891781806946, 0.009199142456054688, -0.02367490902543068, 0.002378044882789254, 0.00861755944788456, 0.029723266139626503, -0.06340084224939346, -0.0032554420176893473, 0.06412756443023682, -0.014673495665192604, -0.05381422117352486, 0.004926063120365143, -0.029569493606686592, 0.03085767850279808, 0.04198279231786728, 0.05739516019821167, -0.07546984404325485, -0.040720097720623016, -0.03981867805123329, -0.008605371229350567, -0.010559391230344772, -0.039096131920814514, -0.004334065597504377, -0.06068841367959976, 0.015567578375339508, 0.00017949400353245437, -0.06443701684474945, -0.03689028322696686, -0.010280026122927666, -0.01468042004853487, -0.02888319455087185, -0.0030339858494699, 0.030865347012877464, 0.021403662860393524, -0.01894228532910347, -0.005091177299618721, -2.6924693884211592e-05, 0.0215012114495039, 0.0339905209839344, -0.03269750997424126, 0.025227606296539307, 0.09273874014616013, -0.0026710047386586666, -0.031362347304821014, -0.018604617565870285, -0.05161258950829506, 0.03711606189608574, 0.00699903117492795, -0.012914306484162807, 0.031599897891283035, 0.0034776576794683933, -0.03192862123250961, -0.008380202576518059, 0.018467098474502563, -0.02027040347456932, 0.005567340645939112, -0.006852227263152599, 0.054301775991916656, -0.017066609114408493, -0.010866466909646988, -0.07131781429052353, -0.008083000779151917, 0.008677039295434952, 0.009518156759440899, -0.033309582620859146, -0.01798962615430355, -0.07990472763776779, -0.03768031671643257, -0.0030323504470288754, -0.053703732788562775, -0.04709716886281967, -0.012288816273212433, -0.03157396987080574, -0.07361918687820435, -0.06745359301567078, -0.031580641865730286, 0.044956374913454056, 0.03842780366539955, -0.0007772374083288014, -0.04047524929046631, 0.023728756234049797, 0.01093956921249628, -0.05104376748204231, -0.022076068446040154, 0.014873961918056011, 0.011664334684610367, -0.02928515523672104, -0.04950259253382683, 0.019363097846508026, -0.04276850447058678, 0.00570122292265296, -0.0408262275159359, -0.02842581272125244, -0.03486091271042824, 0.02855415642261505, 0.09544782340526581, 0.02662499062716961, 0.03486906364560127, -0.011486656032502651, 0.006483195815235376, 0.012640004977583885, -0.004204662516713142, -0.012211109511554241, -0.021553851664066315, 0.04761972650885582, 0.01727554015815258, 0.000640414422377944, 0.03127492219209671, -0.06365401297807693, 0.06355562806129456, -0.0320424921810627, -0.03851333633065224, -0.04900570586323738, 0.01000147219747305, 0.05744263157248497, -0.009000410325825214, 0.0004738213901873678, 0.047592464834451675, 0.00038821797352284193, -0.004125954117625952, -0.008810203522443771, -0.03803941607475281, 0.003388475626707077, -0.06515775620937347, 0.016025813296437263, 0.008342375978827477, 0.021440504118800163, 0.08836483210325241, -0.027708930894732475, -0.0054902248084545135, -0.012345129624009132, 0.01755794882774353, 0.02294737845659256, 0.02783985435962677, 0.047079429030418396, -0.012957234866917133, 0.0476294606924057, -0.02308386191725731, 0.04412422329187393, -0.018063126131892204, 0.053624942898750305, -0.013038269244134426, 0.04393903538584709, 0.024647951126098633, 0.05253896862268448, -0.05432025343179703, 0.0013595514465123415, -0.02891756407916546, -0.06141364201903343, 0.04053204506635666, 0.046342723071575165, 0.05043250694870949, 0.025507090613245964, -0.008942941203713417, -0.0375138595700264, 0.03175847604870796, 0.011897848919034004, 0.0642734244465828, -0.010378757491707802, -0.04308100417256355, 0.028204625472426414, 0.043354909867048264, 0.023041140288114548, -0.061745479702949524, 0.05154888331890106, 0.0089305080473423, 0.01613190583884716, 0.018499771133065224, -0.0029653289820998907, -0.03779531642794609, 0.004035823047161102, 0.02448112890124321, 0.03968862071633339, 0.009805090725421906, -0.013542571105062962, -0.035014986991882324, -0.04532356560230255, -0.03902500495314598, 0.046685006469488144, 0.014858460053801537, 0.007051886059343815, 0.03697625547647476, 0.02368306741118431, 0.03698355704545975, -0.061541277915239334, -0.044932056218385696, -0.008076386526226997, 0.023935003206133842, -0.019973795861005783, -0.0026734706480056047, -6.1033033206876e-33, -0.02901996299624443, -0.01842292584478855, 0.023328162729740143, -0.02644120343029499, -0.020021095871925354, 0.007708441466093063, -0.02734980173408985, 0.005220129154622555, -0.039680466055870056, 0.029121853411197662, 0.01722947508096695, 0.019218431785702705, 0.005174736492335796, 0.005912663880735636, 0.03501904010772705, -0.024560043588280678, 0.005311883520334959, -0.014387364499270916, 0.032889045774936676, -0.010863864794373512, 0.0366826094686985, -0.010408909991383553, 0.06202733889222145, -0.050958871841430664, 0.01661127433180809, 0.0191655233502388, -0.0037624984979629517, -0.0026100482791662216, -0.047455862164497375, 0.03394712880253792, 0.01976793445646763, 0.016211271286010742, 0.004287287592887878, -0.00986109022051096, -0.05008774623274803, -0.00686268787831068, -0.06060208007693291, -0.04411051422357559, -0.029257602989673615, 0.02643630839884281, -0.07830881327390671, -0.019763633608818054, 0.0459197573363781, -0.010632582008838654, 0.005692877806723118, -0.012611868791282177, 0.05516691133379936, -0.030209043994545937, 0.005102246534079313, 0.012524034827947617, -0.09187688678503036, -0.004564517643302679, -0.008874546736478806, -0.025119317695498466, 0.035021550953388214, -0.014584049582481384, -0.017795320600271225, 0.012615999206900597, -0.03898795694112778, 0.009670479223132133, 0.009891650639474392, -0.002457293914631009, 0.05658359080553055, 0.03828845173120499, 0.05538056045770645, 0.04347771778702736, 0.03921603783965111, 0.02795419655740261, -0.03039761260151863, 0.01551379356533289, 0.02423652820289135, 0.07187449932098389, 0.016682639718055725, 0.044285230338573456, 0.05468948930501938, 0.013943859376013279, -0.052822403609752655, 0.002220079069957137, 0.0453755222260952, 0.053711846470832825, -0.002563850488513708, 0.03182318061590195, -0.025846628472208977, -0.016588415950536728, 0.00913806352764368, 0.02634521573781967, 0.001004073885269463, -0.06035022810101509, 0.007218403276056051, -0.015583228319883347, 0.009926248341798782, -0.04378212243318558, 0.0010089091956615448, -0.054237861186265945, 0.03583037480711937, 0.0023783326614648104, -0.013838492333889008, 0.01861886866390705, -0.012086735107004642, 0.017862336710095406, -0.0005209840019233525, -0.04655647277832031, -0.007524479180574417, 0.023634571582078934, 0.04057370498776436, 0.04970870167016983, -0.02217629924416542, 0.02598155289888382, 0.00834968127310276, -0.005231417249888182, -0.0435468815267086, -0.01202567107975483, 0.03614950180053711, 0.0444994680583477, -0.007509747985750437, -0.02580912597477436, -0.013903208076953888, 0.049377117305994034, -0.012136738747358322, -0.07344337552785873, -0.026076894253492355, 0.020956672728061676, 0.011873642913997173, 0.04028688371181488, -0.05258332937955856, -0.023511487990617752, -0.09416484087705612, 0.005389440804719925, 0.05106920748949051, -0.04077279567718506, -0.000381588120944798, -0.0009359008399769664, 2.9599078743558493e-07, -0.02969585545361042, 0.006182043347507715, 0.040113769471645355, 0.04687993973493576, -0.002648294437676668, 0.061777662485837936, 0.0050409575924277306, 0.07678017020225525, -0.021898971870541573, -0.03169284388422966, 0.002332237781956792, 0.022249924018979073, -0.01002776250243187, 0.007041221018880606, -0.07874714583158493, 0.0006412990624085069, 0.015118633396923542, 0.0034811552613973618, -0.041290897876024246, -0.014845088124275208, 0.06252670288085938, 0.08953490108251572, 0.057801127433776855, 0.003739094128832221, 0.047156933695077896, 0.004321991465985775, -0.01535178255289793, 0.010626916773617268, 0.036363039165735245, 0.00961003266274929, -0.0434994250535965, 0.01234158780425787, 0.009319842793047428, 0.03479836881160736, 0.02342929132282734, -0.018112193793058395, -0.016099976375699043, 0.07831134647130966, -0.056612931191921234, -0.003883619327098131, 0.005922403186559677, -0.015633059665560722, 0.00018432344950269908, -0.007261510938405991, 0.05695004761219025, -0.0490783154964447, -0.03242005035281181, 0.03674531355500221, -0.028619961813092232, 0.02376171387732029, -0.03665384277701378, 0.0022683972492814064, -0.0014000087976455688, 0.006450246553868055, 0.0021041748113930225, -0.02066309005022049, -0.013168714940547943, -0.029620414599776268, 0.019178763031959534, -0.0270729660987854, -0.01509200967848301, 0.004344903863966465, -0.014902757480740547, 0.007090962491929531, 0.04684668034315109, -0.013828425668179989, -0.01847705990076065, 2.924656577139737e-34, 0.014883686788380146, 0.023398401215672493, 0.004715025424957275, 0.03243087977170944, 0.016232214868068695, -0.017199333757162094, -0.012685789726674557, 0.024645548313856125, 0.050603557378053665, -0.000862903892993927, -0.04131035506725311]
664
664
['Wojciech Samek', 'Thomas Wiegand', 'Klaus-Robert Müller']
1708.08296v1
With the availability of large databases and recent improvements in deep learning methodology, the performance of AI systems is reaching or even exceeding the human level on an increasing number of complex tasks. Impressive examples of this development can be found in domains such as image classification, sentiment analysis, speech understanding or strategic game playing. However, because of their nested non-linear structure, these highly successful machine learning and artificial intelligence models are usually applied in a black box manner, i.e., no information is provided about what exactly makes them arrive at their predictions. Since this lack of transparency can be a major drawback, e.g., in medical applications, the development of methods for visualizing, explaining and interpreting deep learning models has recently attracted increasing attention. This paper summarizes recent developments in this field and makes a plea for more interpretability in artificial intelligence. Furthermore, it presents two approaches to explaining predictions of deep learning models, one method which computes the sensitivity of the prediction with respect to changes in the input and one approach which meaningfully decomposes the decision in terms of the input variables. These methods are evaluated on three classification tasks.
Explainable Artificial Intelligence: Understanding, Visualizing and Interpreting Deep Learning Models
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1708.08296v1
Title Explainable Artificial Intelligence Understanding Visualizing Interpreting Deep Learning Models Summary availability large database recent improvement deep learning methodology performance AI system reaching even exceeding human level increasing number complex task Impressive example development found domain image classification sentiment analysis speech understanding strategic game playing However nested nonlinear structure highly successful machine learning artificial intelligence model usually applied black box manner ie information provided exactly make arrive prediction Since lack transparency major drawback eg medical application development method visualizing explaining interpreting deep learning model recently attracted increasing attention paper summarizes recent development field make plea interpretability artificial intelligence Furthermore present two approach explaining prediction deep learning model one method computes sensitivity prediction respect change input one approach meaningfully decomposes decision term input variable method evaluated three classification task Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.004354760050773621, 0.025785479694604874, -0.040497828274965286, 0.008426116779446602, 0.0018225862877443433, 0.011091730557382107, 0.017602263018488884, 0.015021657571196556, -0.03170483559370041, 0.016350071877241135, 0.003045437391847372, 0.02138860709965229, -0.0071899862959980965, 0.0925000011920929, 0.01675647497177124, -0.07915414124727249, 0.007252785377204418, -0.0005768569535575807, 0.021138545125722885, 0.022198164835572243, -0.002819204004481435, -0.003419130574911833, -0.005663387011736631, 0.07347802072763443, -0.014384422451257706, -0.023765461519360542, -0.024863163009285927, -0.0332467295229435, -0.01639321818947792, -0.028017841279506683, -0.02325536496937275, -0.03224686160683632, 0.03967837616801262, 0.02042374573647976, 2.3951461116666906e-06, -0.039078034460544586, -0.04647313803434372, -0.008006472140550613, -0.05752754211425781, -0.005306755658239126, -0.014327498152852058, -0.03478701040148735, 0.040959432721138, 0.019457975402474403, -0.041217874735593796, 0.010607700794935226, 0.044323015958070755, 0.0678025558590889, 0.021286336705088615, 0.000968514068517834, -0.008179117925465107, -0.04518871009349823, 0.006563536822795868, -0.0012221088400110602, -0.0052550965920090675, -0.034266214817762375, -0.025527721270918846, -0.011275356635451317, -0.05006543919444084, -0.033492639660835266, -0.01940678432583809, 0.008456159383058548, 0.02899225242435932, -0.04437453672289848, 0.06996012479066849, -0.0018370398320257664, 0.049395602196455, -0.04118262603878975, -0.0037822676822543144, 0.040075380355119705, -0.03884020447731018, -0.007446471601724625, -0.020559972152113914, -0.014845805242657661, 0.005500940140336752, -0.007537626661360264, -0.04654626175761223, -0.020645800977945328, 0.01845891773700714, 0.017253035679459572, -0.01042401883751154, 0.05449606478214264, 0.03894761577248573, 0.011662970297038555, -0.021872980520129204, 0.04030753672122955, -0.05188816040754318, 0.01946764811873436, -0.022400055080652237, -0.01582047902047634, 0.019741283729672432, -0.023136604577302933, 0.014985540881752968, 0.04449586197733879, -0.05185481160879135, 0.0026647113263607025, 0.035653941333293915, -0.04322715848684311, -0.003690719371661544, -0.0420239083468914, 0.0717221200466156, -0.011812792159616947, -0.01811283268034458, 0.01240536104887724, -0.005630343686789274, 0.07869375497102737, -0.042911216616630554, 0.00776304816827178, -0.013291208073496819, 0.004389070440083742, -0.0607072152197361, -0.033104926347732544, -0.015874331817030907, 0.024029701948165894, -0.0050378721207380295, -0.01322702132165432, -0.06907583028078079, -0.010144543834030628, -0.07081037759780884, -0.0037906505167484283, 0.003222558181732893, 0.074485182762146, 0.007424753624945879, -0.014497959986329079, -0.06407146900892258, 0.016504134982824326, -0.045695286244153976, 0.048247329890728, -0.018130045384168625, -0.01345942635089159, 0.03494120016694069, 0.019422519952058792, 0.007698266301304102, 0.021106723695993423, -0.010358565486967564, 0.09257882088422775, 0.041364070028066635, 0.054296694695949554, -0.03912528231739998, -0.06230197101831436, 0.002255226019769907, -0.019283641129732132, 0.008917334489524364, -0.008631563745439053, -0.02239810861647129, -0.024870872497558594, -0.01699799858033657, -0.019857877865433693, -0.024761687964200974, -0.03159373626112938, 0.0014340195339173079, 0.09159160405397415, -0.028791340067982674, -0.008776066824793816, 0.03482023626565933, 0.005580907221883535, -0.011872969567775726, 0.005665614269673824, 0.04531483352184296, 0.025641698390245438, 0.009117496199905872, -0.061994023621082306, 0.02893032319843769, -0.036617740988731384, 0.010140886530280113, -0.04799281433224678, -0.02277686819434166, -0.03715714067220688, -0.0747346580028534, 0.03983599692583084, 0.006836231332272291, -0.02753439173102379, 0.03955074027180672, -0.007059468422085047, -0.004506963770836592, 0.037597790360450745, 0.07867875695228577, 0.030993681401014328, 0.006772344000637531, 0.02587418630719185, -0.007768849842250347, 0.024354003369808197, -0.009599271230399609, 0.07445796579122543, -0.006739216856658459, -0.03591744974255562, -0.05724618583917618, -0.009677649475634098, -0.006471984554082155, -0.08390810340642929, 0.009518499486148357, -0.019165370613336563, -0.00246758246794343, 0.015886299312114716, 0.0632423385977745, 0.013329993933439255, -0.013062630780041218, 0.00010573576582828537, 0.04209178686141968, 0.027317285537719727, -0.005510341376066208, -0.09976629912853241, 0.016761725768446922, 0.04019642621278763, -0.01894005574285984, -0.029638683423399925, 0.007209742441773415, -0.017183680087327957, -0.022245410829782486, -0.03136114031076431, -0.007293786387890577, 0.01795644499361515, 0.011349523440003395, -0.010860801674425602, -0.054941024631261826, -0.039417002350091934, 0.010323993861675262, 0.004824316594749689, -0.058353230357170105, -0.016990436241030693, 0.010492206551134586, -0.003569921012967825, -0.020944170653820038, 0.012519643642008305, 0.002823364920914173, -0.00268897064961493, 0.034707099199295044, 0.0596572607755661, 0.04166591912508011, 0.056594979017972946, 0.029034722596406937, 0.01180429570376873, 0.03613004833459854, -0.022247999906539917, -0.037703853100538254, 0.0014666114002466202, -0.008829502388834953, 0.027685318142175674, -0.015795469284057617, -0.03269030153751373, 0.02886478416621685, 0.024971581995487213, -0.04695882275700569, -0.04799482226371765, 0.035538654774427414, -0.03537735342979431, 0.0068594915792346, 0.020846033468842506, -0.020875876769423485, -0.0209248885512352, 0.039139777421951294, -0.012133654206991196, 0.01892913319170475, 0.0037865242920815945, -0.043039463460445404, -0.00893180351704359, -0.0016492544673383236, 0.053968895226716995, 0.00581450667232275, 0.038196858018636703, 0.00907000433653593, -0.0598251074552536, -0.017950106412172318, 0.0078071122989058495, 0.005169135984033346, -0.01718076691031456, 0.05212660878896713, -0.003354136599227786, -0.010332927107810974, -1.9100154986517737e-06, -0.012040856294333935, 0.0006100239115767181, -0.015478713437914848, 0.03062751516699791, -0.03543663024902344, -0.025411007925868034, 0.05283106118440628, 0.01142875012010336, -0.01962227188050747, 0.06435427814722061, 0.0236323531717062, 0.0010031735291704535, -0.0136699378490448, -0.020844925194978714, -0.04500900208950043, 0.07099662721157074, 0.08408960700035095, -0.03960129991173744, -0.027591228485107422, -0.023119565099477768, 0.024616820737719536, -0.013207808136940002, 0.011648781597614288, -0.0643790066242218, 0.004772979766130447, -0.009833748452365398, -0.039446983486413956, 0.03976397588849068, 0.012968102470040321, 0.10200490057468414, 0.006894209422171116, 0.0907176211476326, -0.013032190501689911, 0.0064840978011488914, -0.022095665335655212, 0.018710419535636902, -0.006312060169875622, -0.01814829744398594, -0.021006109192967415, 0.027291592210531235, 0.039554938673973083, -0.01464098785072565, -0.02471117675304413, 0.061743348836898804, 0.0019392796093598008, -0.0007166818832047284, -0.06341201066970825, -0.041950128972530365, 0.014454944059252739, 0.06157191842794418, 0.0016752616502344608, -0.06396014988422394, 0.06581061333417892, 0.03019241988658905, 0.03901132568717003, 0.009030844084918499, -0.07792968302965164, -0.01985895074903965, 0.0805472806096077, -0.006552005186676979, 0.011071019805967808, -0.0022684906143695116, -0.030661365017294884, -0.011799872852861881, -0.02309488318860531, -0.009335904382169247, -0.017806988209486008, -0.0013620873214676976, -0.02900727279484272, -0.06190304458141327, 0.023464439436793327, 0.011913771741092205, -0.024466145783662796, -0.0010348479263484478, -0.030098434537649155, 0.012435239739716053, 0.01974261738359928, -0.009845742955803871, 0.010744158178567886, 0.006262796465307474, 0.028730789199471474, -0.01712941564619541, -0.010400011204183102, -0.012677079997956753, 0.01322304829955101, -0.0017701260512694716, 0.03362208604812622, 0.02071203477680683, 0.020214302465319633, -0.012198236770927906, 0.04787099361419678, 0.012138972990214825, -0.012846318073570728, 0.03595207631587982, -0.10441772639751434, 0.02759946882724762, -0.05056694895029068, 0.0014473957708105445, -0.011599474586546421, 0.0025167949497699738, -0.006334836129099131, -0.08887467533349991, 0.05882828310132027, 0.054519299417734146, -0.010454884730279446, -0.04972907900810242, 0.042306069284677505, 0.0008671171963214874, -0.06529568880796432, 0.003843042766675353, 0.0009358911192975938, -0.028165563941001892, -0.015927905216813087, -0.026814939454197884, -0.00015932292444631457, -0.007748692762106657, -0.024982284754514694, 0.015547506511211395, -0.012149892747402191, 0.01919136755168438, -0.02931319735944271, -0.03724411875009537, -0.06285369396209717, -0.0427803210914135, -0.0386463925242424, -0.021926984190940857, 0.015489907935261726, -0.04292638972401619, 0.06069151684641838, 0.0033170413225889206, 0.03429768607020378, -0.0664081797003746, -0.01534535177052021, 0.04656604304909706, -0.04530448839068413, 0.015794644132256508, 0.057792261242866516, 0.07788503170013428, -0.04621909558773041, -0.00907624140381813, -0.03158864006400108, 0.046883802860975266, 0.07016123086214066, -0.005975362844765186, 0.09214583039283752, 0.05362451449036598, -0.014595205895602703, -0.021692538633942604, 0.04261767491698265, 0.0016370810335502028, 0.034286439418792725, -0.005826660897582769, 0.07161414623260498, -0.04618709534406662, -0.03572767227888107, -0.07134559750556946, 0.00966538954526186, 0.013870502822101116, 0.02364231087267399, 0.028776057064533234, -0.027107924222946167, -0.028723204508423805, -0.015079708769917488, 0.04221304506063461, -0.04683633893728256, -0.04054468497633934, 0.03130648657679558, 0.020090602338314056, -0.04917006567120552, -0.014611811377108097, -0.0033880670089274645, -0.013271186500787735, 0.02193463407456875, 0.009406632743775845, 0.0374113954603672, 2.5794732209760696e-05, -0.014734157361090183, -0.029544103890657425, 0.02101919613778591, 0.08566458523273468, 0.006486835889518261, 0.01554021518677473, -0.005362441297620535, 0.03928360342979431, -0.05672137811779976, -0.044911064207553864, -0.03747144341468811, 6.885365291964263e-05, 0.02731200121343136, -0.011215209029614925, 0.03983757272362709, 0.023080870509147644, 0.002458948642015457, -0.008263501338660717, -0.08112335205078125, 0.019426673650741577, -0.01477455347776413, 0.00901018362492323, -0.07716748863458633, 0.032273489981889725, 0.00577230378985405, -0.009287584573030472, 0.01700211688876152, -0.005954443942755461, 0.02386607974767685, -0.024853484705090523, -0.09169309586286545, -0.039438556879758835, -0.003049118909984827, 0.009351774118840694, -0.00349063565954566, 0.07202523201704025, 0.029665827751159668, -0.0732104629278183, -0.010971098206937313, 0.009457584470510483, 0.005819769110530615, -0.0023273879196494818, -0.04582526162266731, -0.022277340292930603, 0.06004069373011589, -0.01869977079331875, 0.03573630377650261, -0.039276059716939926, 0.01869867742061615, -0.08574408292770386, -0.013401376083493233, 0.07568056881427765, 0.02776612900197506, 0.03051975555717945, -0.035550590604543686, 0.0506901741027832, 0.005386351142078638, 0.0034333588555455208, -0.009120607748627663, 0.004495597910135984, 0.017845766618847847, 0.02523275837302208, -0.01461113803088665, -0.00843010377138853, -0.026962362229824066, 0.02688927762210369, -0.03538991138339043, -0.051300883293151855, 0.02492230199277401, 0.024582726880908012, 0.014366419985890388, -0.03746771439909935, -0.005232660099864006, 0.020192833617329597, 0.028719531372189522, -0.00010682221181923524, 0.08307234942913055, -0.01404494047164917, -0.0017847447888925672, 0.040916964411735535, -0.01963048428297043, -0.019479945302009583, -0.03319953754544258, 0.07320042699575424, 0.0501001812517643, -0.018502091988921165, -0.002553509548306465, -0.026710910722613335, -0.0023325160145759583, 0.03346819803118706, 0.030743176117539406, 0.05567953363060951, -0.018008548766374588, 0.0477730855345726, -0.02318795956671238, -0.041222088038921356, 0.011675004847347736, -0.03278135135769844, 0.03252745792269707, -0.03613358736038208, 0.014503351412713528, 0.059132304042577744, -0.0015074361581355333, -0.05045522004365921, -0.02598521113395691, 0.01731759123504162, -0.015492117032408714, -0.009520061314105988, -0.025529056787490845, -6.161442536595301e-33, 0.0288984514772892, -0.09540504962205887, -0.011748640798032284, -0.04184325039386749, 0.003212885931134224, 0.03690653294324875, -0.04769881069660187, -0.03551802411675453, -0.04279163479804993, 0.048065345734357834, 0.0017173445085063577, 0.022937318310141563, -0.002311438089236617, 0.04593498259782791, 0.032581817358732224, -0.037191201001405716, 0.009130056016147137, 0.0040794056840240955, 0.07064489275217056, 0.0365280881524086, 0.026065116748213768, 0.04760914668440819, 0.04617384448647499, -0.1218017190694809, 0.01496339775621891, 0.04442920908331871, -0.03187290579080582, -0.013722768053412437, -0.026846615597605705, 0.05314171686768532, -0.009913952089846134, 0.027934648096561432, 0.03433266282081604, -0.050436437129974365, -0.01669842191040516, -0.0006793636130169034, -0.012652554549276829, -0.011286505497992039, -0.030452832579612732, 0.030145492404699326, -0.06049513816833496, -0.02256084978580475, 0.07082781940698624, -0.0035212470684200525, 0.0009377719252370298, -0.04252305626869202, 0.0670892521739006, -0.035388655960559845, -0.011873635463416576, -0.027593787759542465, -0.021808989346027374, 0.012721574865281582, -0.06327861547470093, 0.008227888494729996, 0.031158166006207466, 0.04441390931606293, -0.004445291589945555, 0.04779773950576782, -0.04520685225725174, -0.0006898656138218939, 0.025563359260559082, -0.007198600564152002, 0.06479552388191223, 0.011096819303929806, 0.016658948734402657, 0.027343399822711945, 0.036621641367673874, -0.003478808095678687, -0.05238392949104309, -0.020375093445181847, -0.027758510783314705, 0.11966917663812637, 0.08405402302742004, 0.0026589201297611, 0.05445325747132301, -0.04740987345576286, -0.08909639716148376, 0.028981024399399757, -0.006681468337774277, 0.023645399138331413, -0.00024323533580172807, 0.01292389165610075, -0.06512264907360077, 0.0014226629864424467, 0.015689387917518616, -0.04887188598513603, -0.019977761432528496, -0.02872483991086483, -0.0019032482523471117, -0.07281836122274399, -0.019634908065199852, 0.0167367123067379, -0.023544762283563614, -0.0688159316778183, 0.04204842075705528, 0.003525187959894538, 0.04638069123029709, 0.03702479973435402, 0.026040542870759964, -0.007728577591478825, 0.01703978143632412, -0.011715574190020561, -0.04124460369348526, 0.003956994507461786, 0.05988707393407822, 0.03112366795539856, 0.031081195920705795, -0.011858461424708366, 0.03212891146540642, -0.026070132851600647, -0.02087923139333725, -0.07053813338279724, -0.0073502566665410995, 0.0193265900015831, 0.0010910069104284048, -0.003147868439555168, -0.03625418245792389, 0.04885116592049599, 0.021465163677930832, 0.04711085930466652, 0.0212409570813179, -0.0454254150390625, -0.034119658172130585, 0.012314636260271072, -0.04369634762406349, -0.047475751489400864, -0.06814577430486679, -0.030207211151719093, 0.04178990051150322, -0.06894008815288544, -0.04011917486786842, -0.007052168250083923, 2.937115368695231e-07, 0.06030450388789177, 0.022633112967014313, 0.00922517478466034, -0.009982424788177013, 0.02110549435019493, 0.050617195665836334, 0.023795465007424355, 0.006477606948465109, -0.02048378251492977, -0.0023719726596027613, 0.03199567273259163, -0.0028778142295777798, 0.023561879992485046, -0.0028295412193983793, -0.014378801919519901, -0.04546932503581047, -0.03452694043517113, -0.010163613595068455, -0.02635832130908966, 0.052668247371912, 0.08199704438447952, 0.08326743543148041, 0.025752507150173187, -0.03624018654227257, 0.04590995982289314, -0.007535499986261129, -0.01889648288488388, -0.04121854901313782, 0.060697682201862335, -0.011565575376152992, 0.02008608542382717, 0.0014765363885089755, 0.006180514115840197, 0.0013474947772920132, -0.03286684304475784, 0.0020214926917105913, -0.008850999176502228, 0.023834891617298126, -0.03642167150974274, 0.007815083488821983, 0.016743341460824013, -0.008782642893493176, 0.05400644242763519, -0.05093422532081604, 0.05784536898136139, -0.005376752000302076, -0.07453867048025131, -0.05353993922472, 0.02368634007871151, -0.00469351327046752, 0.04896186292171478, -0.010748771019279957, 0.02268783375620842, 0.0013306732289493084, -0.02415618486702442, -0.06458020955324173, -0.0012920030858367682, -0.04014754667878151, -0.016352610662579536, 0.00604392820969224, -0.02562536671757698, 0.06796644628047943, -0.010950801894068718, -0.02754872292280197, 0.10932774096727371, -0.02656581439077854, -0.0017980103148147464, 2.7539320938946275e-34, 0.005455618258565664, 0.017281269654631615, 0.017857950180768967, 0.002589192008599639, 0.03985202684998512, 0.015968728810548782, 0.01299236249178648, 0.008056823164224625, 0.030717356130480766, -0.015503597445786, -0.04326745867729187]
665
665
['Maithra Raghu', 'Alex Irpan', 'Jacob Andreas', 'Robert Kleinberg', 'Quoc V. Le', 'Jon Kleinberg']
1711.02301v3
Deep reinforcement learning has achieved many recent successes, but our understanding of its strengths and limitations is hampered by the lack of rich environments in which we can fully characterize optimal behavior, and correspondingly diagnose individual actions against such a characterization. Here we consider a family of combinatorial games, arising from work of Erdos, Selfridge, and Spencer, and we propose their use as environments for evaluating and comparing different approaches to reinforcement learning. These games have a number of appealing features: they are challenging for current learning approaches, but they form (i) a low-dimensional, simply parametrized environment where (ii) there is a linear closed form solution for optimal behavior from any state, and (iii) the difficulty of the game can be tuned by changing environment parameters in an interpretable way. We use these Erdos-Selfridge-Spencer games not only to compare different algorithms, but test for generalization, make comparisons to supervised learning, analyse multiagent play, and even develop a self play algorithm.
Can Deep Reinforcement Learning Solve Erdos-Selfridge-Spencer Games?
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1711.02301v3
Title Deep Reinforcement Learning Solve ErdosSelfridgeSpencer Games Summary Deep reinforcement learning achieved many recent success understanding strength limitation hampered lack rich environment fully characterize optimal behavior correspondingly diagnose individual action characterization consider family combinatorial game arising work Erdos Selfridge Spencer propose use environment evaluating comparing different approach reinforcement learning game number appealing feature challenging current learning approach form lowdimensional simply parametrized environment ii linear closed form solution optimal behavior state iii difficulty game tuned changing environment parameter interpretable way use ErdosSelfridgeSpencer game compare different algorithm test generalization make comparison supervised learning analyse multiagent play even develop self play algorithm Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.00046241149539127946, 0.012712793424725533, -0.039370663464069366, 0.024848148226737976, -0.035569336265325546, -0.009846172295510769, 0.011720039881765842, 0.0038367644883692265, -0.031720489263534546, 0.046587537974119186, 0.00973449181765318, 0.033039599657058716, -0.055030446499586105, 0.05365367978811264, 0.004801297560334206, -0.026107098907232285, 0.015109318308532238, -0.01615874469280243, 0.013515086844563484, -0.01908649131655693, 0.006724271457642317, -0.04591314494609833, -0.022237427532672882, 0.03048056550323963, -0.014538779854774475, 0.03805333375930786, -0.035929109901189804, -0.018673136830329895, 0.04594283550977707, -0.08887840062379837, 0.07511408627033234, 0.0008071299525909126, 0.04859226569533348, 0.05724358558654785, 2.5277370241383323e-06, -0.04394524171948433, -0.04524681344628334, -0.05702442303299904, 0.03683091327548027, -0.044978536665439606, 0.03221416100859642, -0.03975221887230873, 0.007997997105121613, 0.0007203411660157144, -0.01409499067813158, -0.04434993863105774, 0.06128375604748726, 0.061379384249448776, 0.024501273408532143, 0.047791220247745514, 0.018946444615721703, -0.05001036450266838, 0.010640067979693413, -0.024204334244132042, 0.026854047551751137, -0.028408091515302658, 0.029818568378686905, -0.019644562155008316, 0.0016189515590667725, -0.0825793519616127, -0.029414527118206024, -0.03855544328689575, 0.02562624029815197, 0.023592989891767502, 0.021011294797062874, 0.03937431424856186, 0.043714962899684906, -0.0015566271031275392, -0.013859380036592484, 0.04035203158855438, -0.039750613272190094, 0.0335988886654377, 0.040933430194854736, -0.011391142383217812, -0.00875161774456501, -0.0375913567841053, 0.018454404547810555, 3.4603926906129345e-05, -0.011384444311261177, -0.012039686553180218, -0.01828138343989849, 0.06454972177743912, -0.003783995984122157, 0.018009375780820847, 0.004160681739449501, 0.05148841068148613, -0.029660584405064583, 0.016598738729953766, 0.009928627870976925, -0.01245769951492548, 0.01854286715388298, -0.037620555609464645, 0.022727569565176964, -0.0011541960993781686, -0.0727272778749466, -0.039935797452926636, -0.007700675167143345, -0.06919831782579422, 0.0334835909307003, 0.010317530483007431, 0.03583815321326256, -0.009084747172892094, 0.05832323059439659, 0.007646249607205391, 0.011868796311318874, 0.010572494007647038, -0.04869377613067627, 0.0010983539978042245, 0.003490380011498928, 0.06321847438812256, -0.0577053464949131, 0.01366792805492878, -0.028167759999632835, 0.02492184191942215, 0.015862980857491493, -0.021592529490590096, -0.04435773566365242, -0.00801442377269268, -0.020759157836437225, -0.0016350883524864912, 0.01905367709696293, 0.0988062173128128, 0.004230589140206575, 0.0289824940264225, -0.07639709115028381, -0.008601169101893902, -0.09985871613025665, 0.02224559336900711, 0.03485916182398796, 0.034242577850818634, 0.021018940955400467, -0.04190453886985779, -0.022639498114585876, -0.01870393194258213, 0.03396196290850639, 0.09166360646486282, 0.033869896084070206, 0.018680620938539505, 0.01705983281135559, -0.0030117605347186327, -0.003791416296735406, -0.06174353510141373, 0.003600729862228036, -0.10038430988788605, 0.017164545133709908, -0.06794636696577072, -0.009958493523299694, -0.01869535632431507, 0.011759051121771336, -0.03773916885256767, 0.00716592138633132, 0.08523625135421753, 0.021428346633911133, 0.002037222031503916, 0.05956362560391426, 0.003751116106286645, -0.024565793573856354, 0.04490632191300392, 0.05061865225434303, 0.00048032213817350566, -0.0027362473774701357, -0.0072878035716712475, 0.01812172494828701, -0.006180903874337673, -0.00716302590444684, -0.005211369134485722, 0.04745561629533768, -0.0322439968585968, -0.037110354751348495, 0.09510838985443115, 0.0004389861423987895, -0.035834331065416336, -0.04982411488890648, -0.04335122928023338, 0.026737546548247337, 0.015008262358605862, 0.01746954396367073, 0.049130260944366455, -0.01692936196923256, -0.009248419664800167, -0.03826472908258438, -0.02297060564160347, 0.0019635858479887247, 0.0658765658736229, 0.004983843769878149, -0.05086151883006096, -0.04100881144404411, -0.022214733064174652, -0.028377195820212364, -0.03832187131047249, 0.07361365854740143, -0.04529242217540741, 0.04247772693634033, -0.013807268813252449, 0.030513478443026543, -0.041405171155929565, -0.013228668831288815, -0.05143480375409126, 0.0019479891052469611, 0.0360589474439621, -0.034147050231695175, -0.05477844923734665, 0.0344199612736702, 0.007436517626047134, -0.013699871487915516, -0.05329461023211479, -0.04841087758541107, -0.03067014366388321, -0.03459278494119644, -0.062043387442827225, -0.007588796783238649, 0.011867738328874111, 0.06458083540201187, -0.008257200941443443, -0.026806222274899483, -0.028419254347682, 0.024565812200307846, 0.06476880609989166, -0.019435783848166466, -0.012613783590495586, -0.04623705893754959, 0.08522608131170273, 0.03622455894947052, 0.013188856653869152, -0.050022076815366745, -0.05444354936480522, 0.0380958691239357, 0.0280351173132658, 0.03808724507689476, -0.04611563682556152, 0.026089712977409363, -0.014271698892116547, -0.005110809113830328, 0.007624165620654821, 0.008153839036822319, -0.0483664907515049, 0.0036568203940987587, 0.0020220023579895496, -0.03440814092755318, -0.054717157036066055, -0.004887072369456291, 0.04904583469033241, -0.00406661769375205, -0.004644104279577732, 0.0046784840524196625, -0.025802940130233765, 0.03952791169285774, 0.03189506754279137, -0.012560185045003891, 0.014959821477532387, -0.000860187690705061, -0.009383615106344223, 0.07215902209281921, 0.022276047617197037, 0.011627516709268093, -0.053049154579639435, -0.022562144324183464, 0.045697491616010666, -0.1110682412981987, 0.016558879986405373, -0.047780781984329224, -0.039409808814525604, -0.02724006026983261, 0.06028513237833977, 0.08909931778907776, -0.011545192450284958, -8.20100394776091e-05, -0.02685563452541828, 0.03886454924941063, -0.003904166864231229, -0.045984867960214615, -0.037212714552879333, -0.030492719262838364, -0.009377759881317616, -0.016077477484941483, -0.0021331056486815214, 0.05567493289709091, 0.027584293857216835, -0.018712935969233513, 0.01940213143825531, 0.020897017791867256, -0.02679705247282982, -0.01513427123427391, -0.01986820623278618, -0.008272519335150719, 0.006572848651558161, 0.01978902518749237, -0.0058811684139072895, -0.012289763428270817, -0.007630848325788975, -0.04936971887946129, 0.03966943174600601, -0.009790231473743916, -0.04752485081553459, 0.005207624286413193, -0.01273530162870884, 0.013277191668748856, 0.06270015239715576, 0.003245668951421976, 0.05693763121962547, 0.007658297661691904, 0.030587542802095413, -0.05830524116754532, 0.049144160002470016, -0.047149814665317535, -0.03687829524278641, -0.021589137613773346, -0.016275281086564064, -0.004391851369291544, 0.03953633829951286, 0.006759371608495712, 0.018593119457364082, -0.03455782309174538, 0.04675345495343208, 0.04256401211023331, -0.05562881752848625, -0.03430008515715599, -0.027310576289892197, -0.015796033665537834, 0.0034817729610949755, -0.015662044286727905, -0.014051775448024273, 0.09353804588317871, 0.095684714615345, 0.00042333605233579874, -0.005000738427042961, -0.014138962142169476, 0.022401094436645508, 0.031532373279333115, 0.03669242188334465, 0.02647031471133232, -0.036192387342453, -0.026124438270926476, -0.03970135748386383, -0.04408697411417961, 0.047747544944286346, -0.032649651169776917, 0.013411391526460648, 0.0026109006721526384, -0.015102884732186794, -0.008373314514756203, -0.07046178728342056, -0.039408326148986816, 0.06081054359674454, -0.023338956758379936, -0.026281727477908134, 0.012518094852566719, -0.027830755338072777, -0.04085695371031761, -0.03348299860954285, 0.05062883719801903, -0.012012957595288754, -0.020148690789937973, -0.026938989758491516, -0.01138059701770544, 0.032482970505952835, 0.05211333557963371, -0.014244535006582737, 0.0059130568988621235, -0.030806884169578552, 0.046425677835941315, 0.035840943455696106, -0.011201909743249416, -0.022615443915128708, -0.09086859226226807, 0.06732048839330673, -0.030032118782401085, -0.024182505905628204, -0.018552379682660103, 0.012760705314576626, 0.0029857181943953037, -0.051347021013498306, -0.008023331873118877, 0.01426265761256218, -0.002883174456655979, -0.04837026447057724, 0.011823294684290886, -0.021017054095864296, 0.032598309218883514, -0.013870087452232838, 0.022960998117923737, -0.03505690023303032, -0.023259924724698067, -0.020956862717866898, -0.003886203980073333, -0.004242756403982639, -0.04660448431968689, 0.03382617235183716, -0.10239385068416595, 0.039736323058605194, -0.03324683755636215, -0.06997892260551453, -0.06753265112638474, -0.010584665462374687, -0.02533489651978016, -0.05401349067687988, -0.012820284813642502, 0.03179417923092842, 0.02044968493282795, -0.04992847517132759, 0.026581192389130592, 0.0205000601708889, 0.03270292282104492, 0.03803273290395737, -0.11832863837480545, 0.030322197824716568, 0.0373435877263546, 0.029006190598011017, -0.030221613124012947, -0.04061408340930939, -0.06915915012359619, 0.022234926000237465, -0.02005954459309578, -0.008963927626609802, 0.05055234581232071, 0.02262030728161335, 0.008489701896905899, -0.019482843577861786, 0.03777562081813812, 0.0205391813069582, -0.026104675605893135, 0.04266632720828056, 0.047157928347587585, 0.00782614666968584, -0.025646373629570007, -0.030160903930664062, -0.010236147791147232, 0.0773969441652298, 0.010060732252895832, -0.07272455841302872, -0.0003412570513319224, -0.05490139126777649, -0.015513263642787933, -0.0023309877142310143, -0.0921633392572403, -0.015071690082550049, -0.030380642041563988, 0.04737946018576622, 0.009376591071486473, -0.043594762682914734, -0.004805166274309158, -0.007818140089511871, 0.06057165563106537, -0.02147330529987812, -0.03797481954097748, -0.04529593512415886, 0.04868720471858978, -0.016551874577999115, -0.02301095239818096, 0.023039519786834717, 0.004055734723806381, -0.007582155056297779, -0.006930580362677574, 0.011561605148017406, -0.003053198102861643, 0.007688934914767742, -0.02506394311785698, -0.011545591056346893, 0.004174933768808842, -0.032289572060108185, 0.11792881041765213, 0.013721318915486336, 0.02482178807258606, -0.012548757717013359, -0.012783470563590527, 0.04209093004465103, -0.0051042623817920685, -0.017316287383437157, -0.009846160188317299, 0.05592876300215721, -0.007226125802844763, -0.010004463605582714, 0.03126773610711098, -0.03309617191553116, 0.04968398064374924, 0.013357255607843399, 0.023823436349630356, -0.032909270375967026, -0.02480706013739109, 0.025963451713323593, -0.03839166462421417, 0.048706624656915665, -5.6722856243140996e-05, 0.011739877983927727, -0.00943669956177473, 0.0075424243696033955, 0.006811446975916624, 0.0012297190260142088, -0.029895244166254997, -0.008639311417937279, -0.015563315711915493, 0.013159602880477905, 0.02808617427945137, -0.008611304685473442, 0.0766744464635849, -0.024179259315133095, -0.008007015101611614, 0.05884528532624245, 0.0715605840086937, 0.04695427790284157, 0.0013600756647065282, 0.039747536182403564, 0.0221480131149292, 0.03361688181757927, 0.019342752173542976, 0.034131571650505066, 0.00502608809620142, 0.009503655135631561, 0.053015366196632385, 0.0018142404733225703, -0.03254450857639313, -0.009044748730957508, 0.03437722846865654, -0.01528188120573759, 0.01179029606282711, 0.0019157336791977286, 0.06498614698648453, -0.036169104278087616, -0.02783631719648838, -0.03474302962422371, 0.013646996580064297, -0.00872859824448824, -0.010037317872047424, -0.04571572318673134, 0.022845711559057236, 0.015784870833158493, 0.019281214103102684, -0.0014854519395157695, 0.03412984684109688, 0.026902519166469574, 0.045985057950019836, 0.04002683609724045, -0.02372201718389988, 0.019062718376517296, -0.012612951919436455, 0.002089837333187461, 0.05431565269827843, 0.028894733637571335, -0.030269933864474297, -0.025674521923065186, 0.018415847793221474, -0.014619284309446812, 0.00010965247201966122, 0.06406529247760773, 0.03069191612303257, 0.02924354188144207, 0.05504623055458069, -0.01926342211663723, -0.015590299852192402, -0.020266808569431305, -0.01215276587754488, 0.012712938711047173, -0.055190641433000565, -0.02398385852575302, -0.021275803446769714, -6.427884494256496e-33, 0.00791457761079073, -0.03522939234972, 0.010355253703892231, -0.0387195460498333, -0.030644956976175308, -0.014233994297683239, -0.03137968108057976, -0.0006020447472110391, 0.012542635202407837, 0.01918928511440754, -0.011279269121587276, -0.018568329513072968, 0.004119119141250849, 0.0010770030785351992, 0.04566332697868347, -0.06233466789126396, -0.03304251283407211, -0.009687871672213078, -0.008146441541612148, 0.0035648366902023554, -0.03461948037147522, 0.017496393993496895, 0.03885297849774361, -0.02341863512992859, -0.04270923510193825, 0.01758013665676117, -0.0241689570248127, 0.018243467435240746, -0.040227435529232025, 0.02603561244904995, 0.004682088270783424, -0.025170162320137024, -0.0002933343348558992, -0.0828678235411644, 0.024672990664839745, -0.004395526833832264, -0.09965243935585022, -0.03467589616775513, -0.06688990443944931, -0.05354517325758934, -0.09582652151584625, -0.012557548470795155, 0.0845777615904808, 0.03022516891360283, -0.019507957622408867, 0.014378797262907028, 0.038671690970659256, -0.015509407967329025, 0.003463760018348694, 0.00841019582003355, 0.010390101000666618, 0.0052619921043515205, -0.02560509368777275, -0.005183510947972536, -0.0009236792102456093, 0.03249172866344452, -0.011395645327866077, -0.006164781283587217, -0.028931884095072746, 0.03463006392121315, -0.024717258289456367, -0.007295372895896435, -0.013838718645274639, 0.04331114515662193, 0.07098937779664993, 0.03935854509472847, -0.004623712971806526, -0.01859058067202568, -0.037725139409303665, -0.021609444171190262, -0.009596590884029865, 0.07212318480014801, 0.04859456047415733, 0.04011999070644379, 0.03145992010831833, -0.0027287560515105724, -0.0989285558462143, 0.03328629210591316, 0.03345158323645592, 0.05935807153582573, -0.013287348672747612, 0.021365925669670105, -0.04660577327013016, 0.04630797728896141, 0.015042856335639954, -0.007421907968819141, -0.009163190610706806, -0.06006655842065811, 0.015988964587450027, 0.01051240786910057, -0.024577751755714417, -0.017058854922652245, 0.024518568068742752, -0.03887099772691727, 0.013730752281844616, -0.003817065618932247, 0.0741487368941307, 0.028462504968047142, 0.009897490963339806, -0.020459482446312904, 0.006989024579524994, -0.046247344464063644, -0.030002014711499214, -0.01848655194044113, 0.04866410791873932, 0.041122280061244965, -0.022744813933968544, 0.004084142856299877, -0.012252332642674446, 0.020563021302223206, 0.0041221873834729195, 0.015770496800541878, 0.008796284906566143, 0.014689681120216846, 0.02460807003080845, -0.04221142828464508, 0.02957112342119217, 0.03797948360443115, 0.013566217385232449, -0.03817438334226608, -0.03002394177019596, 0.01394696906208992, 0.004544073715806007, 0.029545143246650696, -0.00869772769510746, 0.006950415670871735, -0.09442698955535889, 0.01773369126021862, -0.04502245411276817, -0.033504970371723175, 0.010473428294062614, -0.06969327479600906, 3.1014135970508505e-07, -0.07229290902614594, 0.04731563478708267, 0.025363335385918617, -0.0011627047788351774, -0.011012244038283825, 0.04835120961070061, -0.036509595811367035, 0.04911596700549126, -0.022351060062646866, -0.01369486004114151, 0.09327127039432526, 0.01818503625690937, 0.01827406883239746, 0.01199823897331953, -0.04793845862150192, 0.008892370387911797, -0.03141767904162407, 0.07349463552236557, -0.02074684016406536, -0.015795156359672546, 0.013632149435579777, 0.08716332167387009, 0.07685739547014236, -0.008426429703831673, 0.03993862867355347, -0.00643018027767539, -0.01956867054104805, -0.011308854445815086, 0.04737677797675133, -0.018451355397701263, -0.022189080715179443, 0.012104484252631664, -0.047703202813863754, -0.0009513097465969622, -0.030758779495954514, 0.02343123033642769, -0.029114926233887672, 0.05489039048552513, -0.01448884792625904, -0.032102447003126144, 0.018311578780412674, 0.008709796704351902, 0.022471260279417038, -0.006502126343548298, 0.045186299830675125, -0.0376872681081295, 0.006480665877461433, 0.03872084990143776, -0.002269524848088622, -0.02873951755464077, 0.05120458826422691, -0.006268692668527365, -0.038156215101480484, -0.02768987976014614, 0.0007988086435943842, 0.024518651887774467, 0.022524965927004814, -0.042157772928476334, 0.02367899939417839, 0.04174705967307091, -0.016227038577198982, 0.019847344607114792, -0.004839207511395216, 0.06785431504249573, 0.02488057129085064, -0.01584221050143242, -0.03707825019955635, 2.7314551266212188e-34, -0.02022639662027359, -0.01952029950916767, -0.0326874777674675, -0.0536341592669487, 0.024878444150090218, 0.005310647655278444, 0.013658316805958748, 0.024009499698877335, 0.08639169484376907, 0.016616471111774445, -0.022282039746642113]
666
666
['Christopher J. Cueva', 'Xue-Xin Wei']
1803.07770v1
Decades of research on the neural code underlying spatial navigation have revealed a diverse set of neural response properties. The Entorhinal Cortex (EC) of the mammalian brain contains a rich set of spatial correlates, including grid cells which encode space using tessellating patterns. However, the mechanisms and functional significance of these spatial representations remain largely mysterious. As a new way to understand these neural representations, we trained recurrent neural networks (RNNs) to perform navigation tasks in 2D arenas based on velocity inputs. Surprisingly, we find that grid-like spatial response patterns emerge in trained networks, along with units that exhibit other spatial correlates, including border cells and band-like cells. All these different functional types of neurons have been observed experimentally. The order of the emergence of grid-like and border cells is also consistent with observations from developmental studies. Together, our results suggest that grid cells, border cells and others as observed in EC may be a natural solution for representing space efficiently given the predominant recurrent connections in the neural circuits.
Emergence of grid-like representations by training recurrent neural networks to perform spatial localization
2,018
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1803.07770v1
Title Emergence gridlike representation training recurrent neural network perform spatial localization Summary Decades research neural code underlying spatial navigation revealed diverse set neural response property Entorhinal Cortex EC mammalian brain contains rich set spatial correlate including grid cell encode space using tessellating pattern However mechanism functional significance spatial representation remain largely mysterious new way understand neural representation trained recurrent neural network RNNs perform navigation task 2D arena based velocity input Surprisingly find gridlike spatial response pattern emerge trained network along unit exhibit spatial correlate including border cell bandlike cell different functional type neuron observed experimentally order emergence gridlike border cell also consistent observation developmental study Together result suggest grid cell border cell others observed EC may natural solution representing space efficiently given predominant recurrent connection neural circuit Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.0009491996024735272, 0.018944118171930313, -0.03762098774313927, -0.005847285035997629, 0.01585310883820057, 0.039605412632226944, 0.015460417605936527, -0.018404824659228325, -0.020391466096043587, 0.03385598212480545, -0.029813308268785477, -0.029472600668668747, 0.022981125861406326, 0.05065745860338211, 0.08331341296434402, 0.012007235549390316, -0.0067926496267318726, 0.012850956059992313, -0.04785844683647156, -0.016045721247792244, -0.021484628319740295, -0.039772480726242065, -0.03356622904539108, 0.039747338742017746, -0.024842308834195137, 0.0020243912003934383, -0.004813479725271463, -0.012420615181326866, -0.002722638426348567, -0.06714355200529099, 0.01911652646958828, -0.013591321185231209, 0.0659821629524231, 0.06288883835077286, 1.8649787989488686e-06, 0.007736159488558769, 0.017169145867228508, -0.02199595794081688, 0.0589509978890419, -0.003734507132321596, 0.0015905620530247688, -0.03882312402129173, -0.010170715861022472, -0.043117817491292953, -0.013877571560442448, -0.005930909886956215, 0.03559838980436325, 0.032300595194101334, -0.008133112452924252, 0.023819677531719208, -0.025825969874858856, -0.05528101697564125, 0.034118007868528366, -0.013483657501637936, 0.013562352396547794, 0.036099955439567566, 0.0036031848285347223, -0.020890627056360245, -0.026434099301695824, -0.02762708067893982, -0.017160220071673393, 0.022454969584941864, 0.03978859260678291, 0.022673349827528, 0.06497550755739212, 0.055995628237724304, 0.04771188646554947, -0.004506302531808615, -0.013213642872869968, -0.01650562696158886, -0.05586239695549011, -0.027910474687814713, 0.022053813561797142, 0.04123815521597862, 0.039679449051618576, -0.014214585535228252, -0.05725959315896034, 0.014901147224009037, -0.02917172759771347, 0.01162627711892128, -0.040382616221904755, -0.004538985900580883, 0.019650928676128387, -0.05106193199753761, 0.008159061893820763, 0.017756175249814987, 0.04062050208449364, 0.0029954996425658464, -0.08534752577543259, -0.0240748580545187, 0.00899974349886179, -0.0005062789423391223, 0.006543802563101053, 0.05624670907855034, 0.011878601275384426, 0.01736394315958023, 0.04069041088223457, 0.0063747321255505085, 0.014228473417460918, -0.004549830686300993, 0.03527094051241875, 0.009832086972892284, 0.029110586270689964, -0.026237010955810547, -0.021630842238664627, 0.0464218370616436, -0.08883040398359299, 0.07634340226650238, 0.015881046652793884, 0.024099187925457954, -0.0059127286076545715, 0.018908623605966568, -0.010612374171614647, 0.019806886091828346, 0.03668229654431343, -0.04737815633416176, -0.01972578465938568, 0.04631685093045235, 0.008352525532245636, -0.027188939973711967, -0.040467798709869385, 0.05081454664468765, 0.05793452635407448, 0.03240048512816429, 0.0063328612595796585, -0.007208008784800768, -0.0295981727540493, 0.014801304787397385, 0.010695374570786953, 0.044373851269483566, 0.0025971089489758015, 0.024507924914360046, -0.05838664993643761, 0.024006402119994164, -0.0294946376234293, 0.03274168074131012, 0.024661274626851082, 0.009457607753574848, -0.05304115265607834, 0.01941593363881111, 0.015211221762001514, 0.04580024629831314, 0.05639337748289108, -0.06701718270778656, -0.006872345227748156, 0.0189675185829401, -0.09047911316156387, -0.008561954833567142, -0.01144344825297594, -2.0750156181748025e-05, -0.014791802503168583, 0.014506086707115173, -0.06443528085947037, -0.010313104838132858, 0.10523009300231934, 0.022299738600850105, 0.03470177203416824, -0.06081334128975868, 0.07968922704458237, 0.06448535621166229, -0.02239559404551983, 0.026441609486937523, 0.0075249806977808475, 0.006278859451413155, 0.010734905488789082, -0.0205108392983675, -0.05596599355340004, -0.06937249004840851, 0.03691957890987396, 0.06272491812705994, 0.01630421169102192, -0.001039657392539084, -0.032296787947416306, -0.008844416588544846, 0.017589451745152473, 0.13216914236545563, 0.01653863489627838, 0.043535467237234116, 0.008310533128678799, -0.0748685747385025, -0.019924893975257874, -0.022229883819818497, -0.02697977051138878, 0.08638712018728256, 0.03867810592055321, -0.032351020723581314, -0.01178250927478075, 0.010170905850827694, 0.0015003493754193187, -0.03705976903438568, 0.031599726527929306, 0.008128983899950981, -0.02910899929702282, -0.016949396580457687, -0.011829890310764313, -0.011988135054707527, -0.005382580682635307, -0.05469726398587227, -0.01049640029668808, 0.0197378471493721, -0.028447041288018227, 0.02200283855199814, 0.009579102508723736, -0.05533658713102341, -0.008927813731133938, -0.01785060577094555, -0.04443773999810219, -0.051137715578079224, -0.031582705676555634, 0.015645351260900497, -0.0012419676641002297, 0.01340970117598772, -0.011798704974353313, -0.02438526414334774, -0.03494349867105484, 0.036786552518606186, -0.020380264148116112, 0.0397832989692688, -0.026054050773382187, -0.016054952517151833, -0.009670755825936794, 0.005476422142237425, -0.047942083328962326, 0.03638123348355293, 0.03432271629571915, 0.04347887262701988, 0.0162541251629591, 0.0023190947249531746, -0.01633770763874054, -0.020356113091111183, 0.017837094143033028, 0.008531625382602215, 0.038510169833898544, -0.02443632297217846, 0.02011541835963726, -0.015646927058696747, -0.07328387349843979, -0.03826848044991493, 0.01529607642441988, 0.06326302140951157, 0.01383235678076744, 0.0019755091052502394, 0.04323926195502281, -0.004496866371482611, 0.03547759726643562, -0.0068412949331104755, -0.015231737866997719, -0.02545332722365856, 0.003212909447029233, -0.017391642555594444, 0.015420223586261272, -0.0452561117708683, 0.015677494928240776, 0.008472491055727005, -0.0012971864780411124, -0.01987692341208458, 0.005019366275519133, 0.04108533635735512, -0.010983150452375412, -0.04399959370493889, -0.007929105311632156, 0.0027361183892935514, 0.005455068778246641, -0.012092786841094494, 0.014904417097568512, 0.0008832535822875798, -0.007295684888958931, 0.001191010233014822, 0.03531529754400253, 0.034279245883226395, -0.024937346577644348, -0.009224350564181805, -0.07834973931312561, 0.012415819801390171, -0.021294046193361282, -0.015593819320201874, 0.06176458299160004, 0.03620539605617523, -0.012315268628299236, 0.059354640543460846, -0.010927044786512852, -0.030669189989566803, -0.020694848150014877, -0.05004894360899925, -0.04011796414852142, 0.03521137684583664, 0.040062181651592255, -0.0618155300617218, -0.013428687117993832, -0.010944856330752373, -0.008612937293946743, 0.03458790481090546, 0.010826611891388893, -0.023827379569411278, 0.03169754520058632, -0.031749580055475235, -0.03844716027379036, 0.05895506590604782, 0.010194486938416958, 0.009864955209195614, -0.01282467506825924, 0.025519592687487602, 0.026635823771357536, -0.030134985223412514, -0.04296938329935074, 0.056542206555604935, -0.007880309596657753, -0.0035411263816058636, 0.019447166472673416, 0.03510522469878197, 0.01874765194952488, -0.025824645534157753, 0.003914367873221636, -0.007441468071192503, 0.02336648851633072, 0.018187517300248146, -0.06385920941829681, -0.005193870980292559, -0.032644473016262054, 0.0359102338552475, -0.03207318112254143, 0.0047163767740130424, 0.0009679107461124659, 0.011339299380779266, 0.02717607654631138, 0.004265543073415756, 0.024219881743192673, -0.008626863360404968, -0.008068044669926167, 0.04242607578635216, -0.0004526631673797965, 0.009160822257399559, -0.04420694708824158, 0.02902456559240818, -0.013290944509208202, -0.09928280860185623, 0.005325189791619778, -0.0156656876206398, -0.019455738365650177, -0.025668330490589142, 0.012129600159823895, 0.007383659482002258, -0.0585036538541317, 0.07926170527935028, 0.05419269949197769, 0.0333559550344944, 0.003400788176804781, -0.014758185483515263, 0.012100336141884327, -0.013159411959350109, 0.07692571729421616, -0.001971089281141758, -0.05857296288013458, 0.004582395777106285, -0.021052738651633263, 0.047680675983428955, 0.011229309253394604, 0.06519824266433716, 0.023968413472175598, -0.00835420936346054, -0.005408098921179771, 0.008778579533100128, -0.07141263037919998, 0.05317975580692291, -0.061499301344156265, 0.06015167385339737, -0.009860296733677387, 0.035547856241464615, -0.04655555635690689, 0.024801166728138924, 0.04262366145849228, -0.032420724630355835, -0.041797950863838196, 0.02941025048494339, 0.004016727674752474, -0.038045115768909454, -0.03803737834095955, -0.03226605802774429, 0.010484405793249607, 0.04662005975842476, 0.005727666430175304, 0.07822445780038834, 0.04917159304022789, -0.030839337036013603, -0.05176926031708717, 0.021469250321388245, 0.005529089830815792, 0.044530801475048065, -0.006597612984478474, 0.0403265506029129, 0.020816916599869728, -0.11402773857116699, -0.016423115506768227, 0.039516206830739975, -0.03123766928911209, 0.06810251623392105, -0.05439202859997749, 0.013982264325022697, 0.03285069763660431, 0.0115143908187747, 0.03408048301935196, 0.01768116094172001, 0.05806552246212959, -0.008716177195310593, -0.059408899396657944, 0.04818356782197952, 0.0012070448137819767, 0.023512717336416245, -0.019589092582464218, -0.06480176746845245, -0.02137773483991623, 0.0464862659573555, 0.009116687811911106, -0.008717955090105534, 0.006791383493691683, 0.06945940107107162, 0.003834828268736601, -0.00832750741392374, 0.019221697002649307, -0.05908042564988136, 0.033636003732681274, -0.050394799560308456, 0.02718072198331356, -0.010578378103673458, 0.055270034819841385, -0.03926587477326393, 0.019015494734048843, -0.028556514531373978, -0.04292501136660576, 0.04626937583088875, 0.012742963619530201, -0.06316418200731277, -0.014544982463121414, 0.04564576968550682, -0.03763089329004288, -0.041552502661943436, 0.022929098457098007, 0.04103698208928108, -0.04748908057808876, -0.03838873282074928, 0.012106847949326038, -0.011299485340714455, 0.05249302461743355, 0.04902595654129982, -0.025420576333999634, 0.02084597386419773, -0.07760697603225708, -0.017074882984161377, -0.010555712506175041, 0.03043466806411743, -0.003731938311830163, -0.015748463571071625, 0.014278770424425602, 0.012787828221917152, -0.04935391992330551, -0.0192986112087965, 0.005204565357416868, -0.020464720204472542, -0.022990012541413307, 0.016856724396348, 0.023393334820866585, -0.0015686058904975653, 0.00547605799511075, -0.01727909967303276, 0.031201209872961044, 0.03152630850672722, -0.034088097512722015, 0.03760268911719322, 0.04071512445807457, -0.0020730174146592617, 0.03670518845319748, -0.03333771601319313, -0.024158135056495667, -0.0007427100208587945, 0.01878471113741398, -0.004910729825496674, -0.013710696250200272, -0.03871015086770058, 0.02425338886678219, -0.010692229494452477, -0.07515767961740494, 0.09109192341566086, 0.04171833023428917, 0.02717013657093048, -0.005634893663227558, -0.01870417781174183, 0.017901698127388954, 0.0468025803565979, -0.015255059115588665, -0.039686933159828186, 0.06744497269392014, 0.05647227168083191, -0.011725367046892643, -0.01721283607184887, 0.10671035945415497, -0.014902539551258087, 0.025913404300808907, -0.037267327308654785, -0.04818060249090195, 0.0066462173126637936, -0.0729539543390274, 0.032383032143116, -0.02582070417702198, 0.06942588835954666, -0.019100459292531013, 0.03122926503419876, 0.0037671509198844433, 0.006179493851959705, 0.019976645708084106, 0.04760923609137535, -0.03329214081168175, 0.018998675048351288, -0.06802830845117569, -0.04576145485043526, 0.004564112517982721, -0.011490609496831894, 0.0625133067369461, 0.001863719429820776, 0.01823006570339203, 0.015110853128135204, 0.0019305652240291238, 0.009883228689432144, -0.04412032291293144, -0.04003292694687843, -0.012269238941371441, 0.059823378920555115, -0.0021213223226368427, 0.01571991853415966, -0.07158518582582474, 0.02392861247062683, 0.03524641692638397, 0.01046774908900261, -0.017200401052832603, -0.016704652458429337, -0.001499990583397448, 0.03363700956106186, 0.04136350378394127, 0.004323550499975681, -0.03896293044090271, -0.007144377566874027, 0.021352196112275124, -0.010916901752352715, 0.03648664057254791, 0.02123330347239971, -0.006986482068896294, -0.010966365225613117, 0.029257340356707573, -0.013699417933821678, 0.011949315667152405, -0.023713892325758934, 0.007622715551406145, -0.011529416777193546, 0.013474985025823116, -0.06437613070011139, -0.06942067295312881, -5.2480705690369214e-33, 0.030312318354845047, -0.021547341719269753, 0.03908896446228027, -0.0021525451447814703, -0.031316857784986496, -0.0586288757622242, -0.0076330117881298065, -0.004796656314283609, -0.036076806485652924, -0.023761864751577377, -0.00014889273734297603, 0.0215863399207592, -0.017551826313138008, 0.02306375466287136, 0.04153537377715111, 0.011936437338590622, -0.060823652893304825, -0.04497411474585533, 0.037630341947078705, -0.012375261634588242, 0.053603753447532654, 0.018722765147686005, 0.03819948807358742, -0.1060180738568306, -0.08091526478528976, -0.03475641831755638, 0.019199414178729057, 0.0043073249980807304, -0.06696856021881104, -0.03276699408888817, -0.03944159671664238, -0.03193702921271324, -0.004296163097023964, -0.06940522789955139, -0.012015688233077526, -0.020399445667862892, -0.001871419372037053, -0.019112061709165573, -0.05606554448604584, 0.005446534138172865, -0.057007208466529846, -0.014468240551650524, 0.11124193668365479, -0.042770784348249435, 0.005840118043124676, 0.06633630394935608, 0.02143874019384384, -0.028420889750123024, -0.029570680111646652, 0.013595402240753174, -0.04696420952677727, -0.019091734662652016, -0.02791024185717106, -0.03437858074903488, 0.008455432951450348, -0.03935140743851662, -0.00890302937477827, 0.016988134011626244, -0.059156399220228195, 0.036218613386154175, -0.005047966260462999, 0.059531595557928085, -0.03760592266917229, 0.0392935611307621, 0.06759358942508698, 0.01490270160138607, 0.10369279235601425, -0.009263014420866966, -0.031430043280124664, -0.030132576823234558, 0.01564999856054783, -0.025551704689860344, 0.03202284500002861, -0.04517480358481407, 0.07801088690757751, -0.05531225726008415, -0.051348086446523666, 0.021260490640997887, -0.04198184609413147, 0.017505014315247536, -0.01618517003953457, -0.024210941046476364, 0.012157409451901913, -0.00045659736497327685, 0.07790955901145935, -0.06395820528268814, -0.030340764671564102, -0.01179648656398058, 0.0056147794239223, -0.0395953543484211, 0.09349673986434937, 0.021084509789943695, -0.042387429624795914, 0.0009433929808437824, 0.06333545595407486, 0.015946034342050552, 0.023868702352046967, 0.03711662068963051, 0.05481226369738579, -0.015952028334140778, 0.0005737327155657113, 0.027405280619859695, -0.06713946163654327, -0.00589073495939374, 0.013028704561293125, 0.023618657141923904, 0.022171111777424812, 0.0033512490335851908, 0.046507176011800766, -0.011256028898060322, -0.011902136728167534, -0.04514956846833229, 0.06715108454227448, -0.028808293864130974, -0.014385045506060123, -0.06850133836269379, -0.003990969154983759, 0.02325502596795559, -0.002846868010237813, -0.004891623742878437, -0.019291577860713005, -0.03068249672651291, -0.03643357381224632, 0.05634491145610809, -0.030086427927017212, -0.027093306183815002, -0.050912536680698395, 0.08271733671426773, -0.01078930776566267, -0.05338666960597038, -0.03844950720667839, 0.022569546476006508, 2.848230451490963e-07, -0.030336497351527214, 0.030635274946689606, 0.04903501272201538, 0.00575936259701848, 0.05145447701215744, -0.03165779635310173, 0.008870566263794899, 0.006288931239396334, 0.0005175235564820468, -0.07988711446523666, 0.016545116901397705, 0.04000755026936531, -0.026769254356622696, -0.00036358111537992954, -0.025381222367286682, -0.01560632511973381, -0.03773470222949982, 0.03704322129487991, 0.01891542784869671, 0.04061970114707947, 0.03860406205058098, 0.010450540110468864, 0.0028568024281412363, -0.04405040666460991, 0.028350139036774635, 0.026265181601047516, 0.01075792033225298, 0.026748163625597954, 0.08336249738931656, 0.018044549971818924, -0.05803831294178963, -0.001961570233106613, -0.04029092937707901, -0.035200197249650955, 0.023089319467544556, 0.009655782021582127, -0.036793243139982224, -0.050846803933382034, 0.008288096636533737, -0.026388542726635933, 0.03231216222047806, -0.0037662636023014784, 0.019033631309866905, -0.05847136676311493, -0.002315478166565299, -0.046551413834095, -0.020629864186048508, 0.0255234707146883, 0.06564079970121384, -0.0028717443346977234, 0.011781635694205761, -0.021313102915883064, -0.015434248372912407, -0.0798502117395401, -0.021854804828763008, -0.02781865745782852, 0.037595875561237335, -0.0008363124798052013, 0.012737448327243328, 0.05786067619919777, -0.028789829462766647, 0.03955395892262459, -0.034014031291007996, -0.011094652116298676, 0.024174069985747337, 0.039904963225126266, -0.032126180827617645, 2.3797878540622403e-34, -0.016599316149950027, -0.04011249169707298, 0.019834285601973534, -0.013278285972774029, 0.0003122171910945326, 0.0058120680041611195, -0.019071757793426514, -0.04636451601982117, 0.006333746016025543, 0.018461627885699272, -0.05277695879340172]
667
667
['Dasika Ratna Deepthi', 'Sujeet Kuchibhotla', 'K. Eswaran']
0712.0932v1
In this paper, we present a Mirroring Neural Network architecture to perform non-linear dimensionality reduction and Object Recognition using a reduced lowdimensional characteristic vector. In addition to dimensionality reduction, the network also reconstructs (mirrors) the original high-dimensional input vector from the reduced low-dimensional data. The Mirroring Neural Network architecture has more number of processing elements (adalines) in the outer layers and the least number of elements in the central layer to form a converging-diverging shape in its configuration. Since this network is able to reconstruct the original image from the output of the innermost layer (which contains all the information about the input pattern), these outputs can be used as object signature to classify patterns. The network is trained to minimize the discrepancy between actual output and the input by back propagating the mean squared error from the output layer to the input layer. After successfully training the network, it can reduce the dimension of input vectors and mirror the patterns fed to it. The Mirroring Neural Network architecture gave very good results on various test patterns.
Dimensionality Reduction and Reconstruction using Mirroring Neural Networks and Object Recognition based on Reduced Dimension Characteristic Vector
2,007
http://arxiv.org/pdf/0712.0932v1
Title Dimensionality Reduction Reconstruction using Mirroring Neural Networks Object Recognition based Reduced Dimension Characteristic Vector Summary paper present Mirroring Neural Network architecture perform nonlinear dimensionality reduction Object Recognition using reduced lowdimensional characteristic vector addition dimensionality reduction network also reconstructs mirror original highdimensional input vector reduced lowdimensional data Mirroring Neural Network architecture number processing element adalines outer layer least number element central layer form convergingdiverging shape configuration Since network able reconstruct original image output innermost layer contains information input pattern output used object signature classify pattern network trained minimize discrepancy actual output input back propagating mean squared error output layer input layer successfully training network reduce dimension input vector mirror pattern fed Mirroring Neural Network architecture gave good result various test pattern Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.024565834552049637, 0.008700142614543438, -0.027781834825873375, 0.06486279517412186, -0.012282852083444595, 0.009073599241673946, 0.050775375217199326, 0.015378891490399837, -0.05731024965643883, 0.012595757842063904, -0.0018333224579691887, 0.008624824695289135, 0.029290223494172096, 0.02354268915951252, 0.03453419730067253, -0.07182392477989197, -0.012179616838693619, 0.07027961313724518, -0.08042944967746735, -0.051331162452697754, -0.008345916867256165, -0.028735103085637093, 0.0030090725049376488, 0.021816162392497063, -0.041652534157037735, 0.04634781554341316, -0.023039504885673523, -0.009782486595213413, -0.047132473438978195, -0.054940175265073776, 0.003734994912520051, -0.01165170967578888, 0.04240119829773903, 0.004310397431254387, 2.304010649822885e-06, -0.023190699517726898, 0.014098668470978737, -0.012328357435762882, 0.012498866766691208, -0.009430312551558018, 0.024977264925837517, -0.03756140172481537, -0.00827461015433073, 0.009431187994778156, 0.0143752321600914, -0.092972032725811, 0.02803901955485344, 0.1083524078130722, 0.019525978714227676, 0.0208401121199131, 0.005917926784604788, -0.08435684442520142, 0.054501645267009735, 0.003961818292737007, -0.057698849588632584, 0.02401665225625038, 0.0007246725726872683, -0.0020537187810987234, -0.04402907192707062, 0.04210624843835831, 0.019694359973073006, 0.034617431461811066, 0.013818943873047829, 0.045807529240846634, -0.024956202134490013, 0.012909408658742905, 0.022657552734017372, -0.002642073668539524, -0.006458525080233812, 0.0117880180478096, -0.02456609718501568, 0.020063064992427826, -0.009432661347091198, -0.0036010434851050377, -0.00821356475353241, 0.034220773726701736, -0.01148204691708088, -0.015033315867185593, 0.042345140129327774, 0.003796940902248025, -0.07640866935253143, 0.0055590420961380005, -0.027774909511208534, -0.03155552223324776, 0.02342585287988186, -0.05905676260590553, -0.008158768527209759, 0.03749988228082657, -0.07473006844520569, -0.0518156923353672, 0.01409050915390253, 0.05121100693941116, -0.008801469579339027, -0.027948575094342232, 0.030112044885754585, -0.014516145922243595, 0.03217625990509987, -0.14065255224704742, 0.025849206373095512, -0.013767830096185207, 0.019891951233148575, 0.006653737276792526, -0.07374119013547897, -0.012502335011959076, -0.06305957585573196, 0.08945217728614807, -0.03401051461696625, 0.07544336467981339, -0.0750720426440239, -0.020242197439074516, -0.0021970048546791077, 0.007543433923274279, -0.003143262816593051, 0.05074315518140793, 0.007859046570956707, -0.02088865637779236, -0.01812509261071682, -0.018461303785443306, 0.01983666606247425, -0.00694746058434248, -0.025004317983984947, 0.0547027625143528, 0.018280543386936188, -0.00872467365115881, -0.0026429155841469765, 0.001583451172336936, 0.020957745611667633, 0.007176413666456938, -0.018242618069052696, -0.006918397732079029, 0.014009346254169941, 0.006923028267920017, 0.009382884949445724, 0.01606672815978527, 0.03482729196548462, 0.06338836252689362, 0.013949154876172543, -0.023563431575894356, -0.01785510964691639, 0.027052270248532295, -0.0025681713595986366, 0.009977062232792377, 0.05978597328066826, -0.03689850866794586, -0.016817061230540276, -0.031095003709197044, -0.03066864237189293, 0.011935372836887836, 0.02556474320590496, -0.0005636804853565991, -0.020663348957896233, 0.038659632205963135, -0.01422174647450447, -0.048753779381513596, 0.07709118723869324, -0.006885807029902935, -0.0100999865680933, -0.047289084643125534, 0.0005358612979762256, 0.018107125535607338, -0.029637031257152557, -0.03876560181379318, 0.029631221666932106, -0.00034905632492154837, -0.02200431190431118, -0.0384632870554924, -0.07943565398454666, -0.04777248203754425, 0.029045885428786278, 0.03565048798918724, 0.04040984436869621, 0.045093681663274765, -0.025574637576937675, -0.05049344524741173, -0.00434140907600522, 0.08315181732177734, 0.0012296271743252873, 0.08760345727205276, -0.04317343607544899, 0.02840731106698513, -0.022397831082344055, 0.03428949788212776, 0.0059325494803488255, 0.07256753742694855, -0.000270090124104172, -0.04962857812643051, -0.0817369818687439, -0.006901780143380165, -0.07493336498737335, -0.0181892067193985, 0.005955098196864128, -0.045367419719696045, 0.0070436191745102406, -0.013088330626487732, 0.07809416204690933, -0.016173312440514565, 0.015846770256757736, 0.03336166590452194, 0.03278978541493416, 0.005603143945336342, -0.06042291596531868, -0.04291774332523346, -0.0033951846417039633, -0.027527347207069397, 0.022596118971705437, -0.021067894995212555, -0.02571680024266243, 0.029431359842419624, -0.006566312629729509, -0.05503533408045769, 0.01022428646683693, 0.001997340237721801, -0.01153554767370224, 0.008336246944963932, -0.011217143386602402, -0.0051630400121212006, 0.02682432346045971, 0.021826736629009247, -0.018509481102228165, -0.051620859652757645, 0.02061973325908184, 0.056507401168346405, -0.014494720846414566, 0.025456873700022697, 0.008029849268496037, 0.030935168266296387, 0.0677277147769928, 0.04825502634048462, 0.010520384646952152, 0.0001364929776173085, 0.04092847928404808, -0.015899304300546646, 0.03568963706493378, -0.01695285737514496, 0.002081515034660697, 0.035314396023750305, -0.001695434097200632, -0.037113167345523834, 0.046906519681215286, -0.04930321127176285, 0.051944300532341, 0.11326263099908829, 0.04604508355259895, -0.06310246884822845, 0.04309004917740822, -0.04214111715555191, -0.027451088652014732, -0.04382719844579697, 0.055308301001787186, -0.04806673526763916, 0.05623362958431244, -0.02450062334537506, 0.005669387523084879, -0.020688822492957115, 0.012259199284017086, -0.028896482661366463, 0.0054228887893259525, 0.03279077261686325, -0.0414121113717556, -0.01730908267199993, -0.027864713221788406, -0.03943570330739021, 0.027157949283719063, 0.013398699462413788, -0.000937448930926621, 0.02987697720527649, -0.02578289806842804, 0.09024600684642792, -0.04712340608239174, 0.009352765046060085, -0.02246757037937641, -0.005146337673068047, 0.0020312971901148558, 0.04690353572368622, -0.04137140512466431, -0.00964695867151022, 0.12326011061668396, -0.0011331134010106325, -0.05072697252035141, 0.03132014349102974, 0.029326248914003372, -0.005916299764066935, 0.025439832359552383, -0.014992238022387028, -0.01515390444546938, 0.011287095956504345, 0.021609880030155182, 0.01935739628970623, -0.026571515947580338, 0.02839064970612526, 0.013305969536304474, 0.027439406141638756, -0.01159585826098919, -0.04052536562085152, 0.000850820739287883, -0.049521613866090775, -0.07709471136331558, 0.008945941925048828, 0.04150478541851044, -0.05650831013917923, 0.03475530445575714, 0.0689530000090599, -0.050108764320611954, -0.011895646341145039, -0.036636147648096085, 0.028466805815696716, 0.05357569456100464, 0.007029462140053511, -0.007527966983616352, -0.0648534968495369, -0.002970597241073847, 0.014224202372133732, 0.0025637734215706587, -0.013183489441871643, 0.04012279212474823, -0.003978889901190996, -0.05120265483856201, -0.0021768503356724977, -0.02278497815132141, -0.06943618506193161, 0.003642720403149724, -0.00720820901915431, -0.05622413381934166, -0.004288587719202042, 0.0017421407392248511, -0.0035796945448964834, 0.025108996778726578, 0.0075710127130150795, 0.01796606369316578, 0.04460294917225838, 0.02435433864593506, -0.005024668760597706, -0.02495487779378891, -0.0052111586555838585, 0.03880816325545311, 0.007828276604413986, -0.0007772406679578125, -0.031644996255636215, -0.04068920761346817, -0.03034445270895958, -0.03317876160144806, -0.050727929919958115, -0.03896317631006241, -0.05410071462392807, 0.02596326358616352, 0.011800730600953102, -0.04767543077468872, -0.007158856838941574, -0.02300635725259781, 0.023042989894747734, 0.002014612080529332, 0.06833303719758987, 0.01253354363143444, 0.0125117814168334, -0.012685061432421207, 0.03743809834122658, 0.02258351631462574, 0.041689928621053696, 0.04266693815588951, 0.0455252006649971, 0.053384363651275635, -0.015203086659312248, 0.038983430713415146, 0.001015380141325295, -0.10891849547624588, -0.0018842327408492565, 0.01449110172688961, 0.03852980211377144, -0.033494774252176285, 0.0016335659893229604, -0.0720948576927185, -0.006381703075021505, 0.0010773438261821866, 0.013658764772117138, -0.03326462209224701, -0.11018610000610352, -0.021229999139904976, 0.009809568524360657, -0.11072584241628647, -0.0046149203553795815, 0.022959426045417786, 0.005124786403030157, 0.016805797815322876, -0.0024043701123446226, -0.04157751798629761, 0.003937836736440659, -0.029304983094334602, 0.0014700301690027118, -0.04179593175649643, 0.006207008846104145, -0.0003985248622484505, -0.02914375253021717, -0.08755659312009811, 0.006291795056313276, 0.004671039525419474, -0.014252787455916405, 0.03142702206969261, -0.002503566211089492, 0.00582608487457037, -0.03389691933989525, 0.007737230975180864, -0.038717154413461685, 0.03163091838359833, 0.02123977243900299, -0.06593392789363861, -0.023300962522625923, 0.027940064668655396, 0.03006570227444172, -0.011952473782002926, -0.01670435443520546, -0.02037746086716652, 0.016176505014300346, 0.03828798234462738, -0.00929930154234171, 0.052471984177827835, 0.0562136285007, -0.006120818667113781, 0.022106213495135307, 0.05428469181060791, 0.028894023969769478, 0.037523433566093445, -0.040693286806344986, 0.022317856550216675, 0.005389568395912647, 0.04405101016163826, -0.02146253176033497, -0.05530674755573273, -0.03146414831280708, -0.03010714240372181, -0.0105265649035573, 0.020597074180841446, 0.006125325802713633, 0.03043154627084732, 0.036673761904239655, 0.013247977010905743, 0.00844251923263073, 0.02171785570681095, 0.029231538996100426, -0.030990740284323692, -0.03806956112384796, 0.03437677025794983, -0.022519031539559364, 0.05720756947994232, 0.003460235893726349, -0.04790499061346054, 0.018404193222522736, 0.008534157648682594, -0.001502849394455552, -0.018012193962931633, 0.03374567627906799, -0.000525655981618911, -0.022701282054185867, 0.037314124405384064, 0.04143345355987549, -0.05926753208041191, 0.00281237019225955, -0.10659759491682053, 0.007421150803565979, 0.02352232113480568, 0.031612228602170944, 0.024489887058734894, -0.013844425790011883, 0.008830166421830654, -0.02167128399014473, -0.03166133910417557, -0.02839762344956398, -0.051944851875305176, 0.007181140128523111, -0.006942951586097479, -0.022863786667585373, 0.015106297098100185, -0.01359629724174738, 0.026254666969180107, 0.021241016685962677, 0.015621259808540344, 0.006536129396408796, -0.07701263576745987, -0.01690022088587284, -0.02829073742032051, -0.017542559653520584, 0.014213367365300655, 0.06512085348367691, 0.04644608125090599, 0.02588471956551075, -0.009968806058168411, 0.03245311230421066, 0.017462823539972305, 0.024648262187838554, -0.011123954318463802, 0.013157669454813004, 0.002498721471056342, -0.005856044590473175, -0.02755122445523739, -0.057919494807720184, 0.07269635796546936, -0.051788296550512314, -0.03981281816959381, -0.011392748914659023, -0.06038331985473633, -0.0020480372477322817, -0.09376447647809982, 0.028097111731767654, -0.014909316785633564, -0.032811038196086884, 0.01677396334707737, 0.04168928042054176, -0.017239868640899658, -0.02943119965493679, 0.020653575658798218, -0.00983915664255619, -0.08057443797588348, 0.03464553877711296, 0.04271089285612106, -0.01584831438958645, -0.04755984619259834, 0.024002954363822937, 0.04469982534646988, -0.020113740116357803, -0.023953258991241455, -0.00043672428000718355, 0.0228229109197855, -0.03501506522297859, 0.020379435271024704, -0.02912214957177639, -0.015909161418676376, 0.01707187108695507, 0.010656478814780712, 0.022031398490071297, -0.044449545443058014, 0.008654464036226273, 0.004774115514010191, -0.01652330532670021, -0.00982396025210619, 0.0456402562558651, -0.014281226322054863, 0.040270861238241196, 0.009198937565088272, 0.021480632945895195, -0.0030163077171891928, 0.013719712384045124, 0.03368155285716057, -0.010239419527351856, -0.010925636626780033, -0.03166528046131134, 0.04331061616539955, -0.006156467366963625, 0.023674312978982925, -0.015398315154016018, 0.015978114679455757, -0.020875032991170883, 0.03591692075133324, -0.014201984740793705, 0.031559329479932785, 0.039442237466573715, -0.024662122130393982, -5.2258904600048434e-33, 0.05343402549624443, -0.00848691537976265, 0.012087534181773663, -0.025871362537145615, -0.003222572850063443, -0.011554522439837456, 0.004321136977523565, 0.0005685189389623702, -0.023276569321751595, -0.019739801064133644, -0.03502670302987099, 0.011935189366340637, 4.686249667429365e-05, 0.04041804373264313, 0.051208991557359695, 0.015365315601229668, 0.019449269399046898, -0.0639839619398117, 0.04157311096787453, -0.027948202565312386, 0.04178853705525398, 0.03289062902331352, 0.02395205944776535, -0.04924545809626579, -0.09070413559675217, 0.04404578357934952, 0.0594305619597435, 0.01287420466542244, 0.024417033419013023, -0.04425926133990288, -0.010375705547630787, -0.04774549975991249, 0.020050426945090294, -0.04222613945603371, -0.026652246713638306, -0.004169488325715065, -0.02103186957538128, -0.005188235081732273, -0.07057996094226837, 0.07012411952018738, 0.017008323222398758, -0.006130584981292486, 0.030710959807038307, -0.04012792557477951, -0.05183001235127449, 0.0017916467040777206, 0.011290531605482101, -0.04925430938601494, 0.009823302738368511, 0.08180312067270279, 0.00984476413577795, 0.014479206874966621, -0.011107119731605053, -0.03343740850687027, 0.07119408249855042, -0.048413291573524475, -0.023505179211497307, -0.0254499614238739, -0.0042257956229150295, 0.046358171850442886, -0.03384729474782944, 0.00611895602196455, -0.012567736208438873, 0.03250959515571594, 0.018166784197092056, 0.05920017883181572, 0.07487305253744125, -0.08789438009262085, -0.020555222406983376, -0.0257995817810297, 0.005220326595008373, 0.04217194765806198, 0.10038910806179047, 0.023099152371287346, 0.06705617904663086, -0.07066009193658829, -0.02533590793609619, 0.05081961676478386, -0.0061326525174081326, 0.04433247819542885, -0.0019675048533827066, -0.03648914024233818, -0.03188750520348549, -0.013036582618951797, 0.02489398419857025, 0.030282795429229736, -0.02438359707593918, -0.004456811118870974, 0.0004741990996990353, -0.0138151366263628, -0.04280995577573776, 0.0038688667118549347, 0.0018746854038909078, -0.026797417551279068, 0.01910986565053463, 0.013542692176997662, 0.04318039491772652, 0.0109492726624012, 0.031537316739559174, -0.027991823852062225, -0.0301706213504076, -0.0004844580253120512, -0.009629527106881142, 0.058083076030015945, -0.005870509427040815, 0.02352031320333481, 0.0356794036924839, 0.04140394181013107, 0.02681075595319271, 0.006977243348956108, 0.011361915618181229, -0.07614253461360931, 0.03983991593122482, -0.000955341209191829, -0.007078349124640226, -0.006901250220835209, 0.0605618879199028, 0.01181012112647295, -0.0019091606372967362, -0.023737050592899323, -0.03513329476118088, -0.015295632183551788, 0.027324112132191658, -0.018702499568462372, -0.03857772797346115, -0.008473188616335392, -0.04442644119262695, -0.04844105988740921, 0.04434379190206528, 3.355894659762271e-05, 0.017881358042359352, 0.00027983271866105497, 2.862334724795801e-07, -0.04370993748307228, -0.0024918995331972837, 0.03250782936811447, -0.05666337162256241, -0.024158090353012085, 0.006685095839202404, 0.018911657854914665, 0.036777131259441376, -0.02358861267566681, 0.0763339251279831, 0.04109608009457588, -0.025616269558668137, -0.029416194185614586, -0.0007274915697053075, -0.024192212149500847, 0.0625709816813469, -0.005988867953419685, 0.041750986129045486, 0.028767652809619904, 0.03328801319003105, 0.0032451655715703964, 0.012571335770189762, 0.0024409473408013582, -0.0026831955183297396, -0.019304636865854263, 0.04733942076563835, -0.009044047445058823, 0.018519723787903786, 0.05064769834280014, -0.019570112228393555, 0.01315787248313427, 0.05416131392121315, -0.005988229997456074, -0.01566523313522339, 0.010122477076947689, 0.06472626328468323, -0.00960365030914545, -0.053486235439777374, -0.016541017219424248, 8.384789543924853e-05, 0.042961232364177704, 0.016328955069184303, -0.013541549444198608, 0.011670130304992199, 0.00448558060452342, -0.03783669322729111, -0.004601618740707636, -0.07870171219110489, -0.01685301586985588, -0.006837982218712568, -0.01836644485592842, 0.017344867810606956, 0.007121295668184757, -0.004923264030367136, -0.0011445508571341634, -0.08541500568389893, 0.04755834862589836, -0.05353826656937599, 0.03507150709629059, -0.012028270401060581, -0.050613611936569214, 0.05473814532160759, -0.00991247408092022, 0.008910155855119228, 0.08588101714849472, 0.008200396783649921, -0.0010705461027100682, 2.0855655210600084e-34, -0.06556408107280731, 0.05558886006474495, -0.026606660336256027, 0.049330055713653564, -0.062277957797050476, -0.011366531252861023, 0.00869231577962637, 0.015013279393315315, -0.017066558822989464, -0.02050848677754402, -0.03723090887069702]
668
668
['Yongnan Ji', 'Pierre-Yves Herve', 'Uwe Aickelin', 'Alain Pitiot']
1004.3708v1
Inter-subject parcellation of functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) data based on a standard General Linear Model (GLM)and spectral clustering was recently proposed as a means to alleviate the issues associated with spatial normalization in fMRI. However, for all its appeal, a GLM-based parcellation approach introduces its own biases, in the form of a priori knowledge about the shape of Hemodynamic Response Function (HRF) and task-related signal changes, or about the subject behaviour during the task. In this paper, we introduce a data-driven version of the spectral clustering parcellation, based on Independent Component Analysis (ICA) and Partial Least Squares (PLS) instead of the GLM. First, a number of independent components are automatically selected. Seed voxels are then obtained from the associated ICA maps and we compute the PLS latent variables between the fMRI signal of the seed voxels (which covers regional variations of the HRF) and the principal components of the signal across all voxels. Finally, we parcellate all subjects data with a spectral clustering of the PLS latent variables. We present results of the application of the proposed method on both single-subject and multi-subject fMRI datasets. Preliminary experimental results, evaluated with intra-parcel variance of GLM t-values and PLS derived t-values, indicate that this data-driven approach offers improvement in terms of parcellation accuracy over GLM based techniques.
Parcellation of fMRI Datasets with ICA and PLS-A Data Driven Approach
2,010
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1004.3708v1
Title Parcellation fMRI Datasets ICA PLSA Data Driven Approach Summary Intersubject parcellation functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging fMRI data based standard General Linear Model GLMand spectral clustering recently proposed mean alleviate issue associated spatial normalization fMRI However appeal GLMbased parcellation approach introduces bias form priori knowledge shape Hemodynamic Response Function HRF taskrelated signal change subject behaviour task paper introduce datadriven version spectral clustering parcellation based Independent Component Analysis ICA Partial Least Squares PLS instead GLM First number independent component automatically selected Seed voxels obtained associated ICA map compute PLS latent variable fMRI signal seed voxels cover regional variation HRF principal component signal across voxels Finally parcellate subject data spectral clustering PLS latent variable present result application proposed method singlesubject multisubject fMRI datasets Preliminary experimental result evaluated intraparcel variance GLM tvalues PLS derived tvalues indicate datadriven approach offer improvement term parcellation accuracy GLM based technique Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.00980097334831953, 0.022604599595069885, -0.043833956122398376, -0.005876052659004927, 0.012391098774969578, 0.04289724677801132, 0.06515447795391083, 0.04038946330547333, 0.009628823027014732, 0.06108696386218071, -0.06843267381191254, -0.038438066840171814, 0.05879276618361473, 0.02290216088294983, 0.05226622149348259, -0.06737923622131348, -0.011226901784539223, 0.004002697300165892, 0.02177552878856659, -0.015874752774834633, 0.018517063930630684, -0.031263843178749084, -0.014535726979374886, -0.002543242648243904, -0.028952259570360184, -0.029964806511998177, 0.034177519381046295, -0.013850249350070953, 0.012625813484191895, 0.015981798991560936, 0.00813510175794363, 0.06534382700920105, 0.0458398163318634, -0.027072787284851074, 2.3858840449975105e-06, -0.03123302385210991, -0.030620820820331573, 0.042434338480234146, 0.04362388700246811, 0.021786248311400414, 0.057394661009311676, 0.057392437011003494, 0.038644902408123016, -0.016163434833288193, -0.027167052030563354, -0.0452745221555233, 0.034820109605789185, 0.07101521641016006, -0.018837597221136093, -0.02260192297399044, -0.03968938812613487, 0.03159020468592644, -0.043341610580682755, -0.03013712912797928, 0.012121093459427357, 0.05686603859066963, 0.008950411342084408, 0.01812809705734253, -0.01762152649462223, -0.0017218870343640447, -0.05611967667937279, 0.02696988917887211, 0.014826381579041481, 0.041312385350465775, -0.015527266077697277, 0.07076939195394516, 0.010598368011415005, 0.003880331525579095, 0.011639970354735851, 0.00843074545264244, 0.06210620701313019, 0.01693309098482132, 0.045711956918239594, 0.038989149034023285, -0.0008435992640443146, 0.027464734390378, -0.06197010353207588, 0.005255673546344042, 0.02291914075613022, -0.028195610269904137, -0.012466637417674065, 0.021229984238743782, 0.006963036023080349, -0.07711968570947647, 0.006255478598177433, -0.005621461663395166, -0.00046102801570668817, 0.011718901805579662, 0.0046683019027113914, -0.006309193093329668, -0.07962148636579514, 0.005940924398601055, -0.007951123639941216, -0.04108455404639244, -0.0037906081415712833, -0.01740241050720215, 0.006164358463138342, -0.040521055459976196, 0.05219634622335434, -0.009741134941577911, -0.030084138736128807, -0.011512874625623226, -0.0192749984562397, -0.0486670657992363, 0.01657828502357006, 0.00996573269367218, -0.08432931452989578, 0.08668504655361176, -0.04017063230276108, -0.002255252795293927, -0.020739760249853134, -0.0015188230900093913, 0.007207436952739954, 0.016920289024710655, -0.0415361113846302, -0.02681301161646843, -0.03302420303225517, 0.04100494459271431, 0.023557109758257866, -0.08389614522457123, 0.001396810170263052, 0.04087347537279129, 0.024315141141414642, 0.025936994701623917, 0.031562916934490204, 0.018506668508052826, -0.022931015118956566, 0.040787823498249054, -0.024510309100151062, 0.02517501823604107, -0.003747624345123768, 0.026902208104729652, -0.02507065422832966, -0.007141780573874712, -0.038587912917137146, 0.01796531490981579, 0.013470791280269623, 0.05128864198923111, -0.06103237345814705, 0.008398974314332008, 0.02059730887413025, -0.02005630172789097, 0.01550283469259739, -0.05828151851892471, 0.04026447609066963, 0.03045443817973137, -0.03481738641858101, 0.03217694163322449, -0.03274095803499222, -0.028184790164232254, 0.017873508855700493, 0.019640909507870674, -0.060000643134117126, -0.022181738168001175, 0.10020224004983902, -0.009045125916600227, 0.0038966224528849125, -0.036643002182245255, 0.04681883007287979, 0.028044452890753746, 0.00348236714489758, -0.009298326447606087, -0.04556926712393761, -0.01344755757600069, -0.0616946779191494, -0.009542259387671947, -0.027544524520635605, -0.018684526905417442, 0.019462333992123604, -0.0028839251026511192, 0.002101739402860403, 0.0224388986825943, 0.006057274527847767, 0.032711587846279144, 0.00691588968038559, 0.046123165637254715, 0.005801680963486433, 0.0011124006705358624, -0.02540828473865986, -0.012041231617331505, -0.032681480050086975, 0.004582544323056936, 0.019605513662099838, 0.060160648077726364, -0.0022698617540299892, 0.001335644512437284, -0.009121440351009369, 0.002517431741580367, 0.016693679615855217, -0.030288873240351677, 0.0033341525122523308, -0.013267776928842068, 0.006294908933341503, 0.026771293953061104, 0.03790152817964554, -0.03481247276067734, 0.05942963436245918, -0.04447576776146889, 0.045572713017463684, 0.019027194008231163, -0.019043179228901863, 0.030541077256202698, -0.013406304642558098, -0.09185320138931274, 0.0037239808589220047, -0.02048795111477375, -0.026767225936055183, -0.01929396390914917, 0.0671464130282402, -0.01237324345856905, -0.03250093013048172, 0.013859967701137066, 0.02896524965763092, -0.03581598401069641, 0.004513788037002087, -0.004796623717993498, -0.008933622390031815, -0.004999761935323477, -0.04126753658056259, -0.01609058305621147, -0.04768454656004906, -0.05153336375951767, 0.03672105818986893, 0.032128769904375076, -0.04365787282586098, 0.051844097673892975, 0.04829094186425209, 0.010011953301727772, 0.03681417182087898, -0.074018195271492, -0.004671827889978886, -0.04749137908220291, 0.005853608716279268, 0.010000377893447876, -0.02968665584921837, -0.0018999945605173707, 0.0699632540345192, -0.015336547046899796, -0.037055451422929764, 0.0181435476988554, 0.01586855947971344, -0.00531745795160532, -0.0254143625497818, -0.004249666351824999, 0.014745148830115795, -0.012270154431462288, -0.04669778048992157, -0.021612346172332764, 0.002506091259419918, -0.050837524235248566, 0.04040307179093361, -0.0408429317176342, -0.02731155790388584, 0.00992401223629713, -0.0162814948707819, -0.005220748949795961, 0.00019827031064778566, 0.053270626813173294, -0.019294828176498413, -0.05751914158463478, -0.010164028033614159, -0.062441181391477585, -0.07157772779464722, -0.0034754823427647352, 0.0007877303869463503, -0.002119200536981225, -0.0005903211422264576, -0.029687361791729927, 0.017946086823940277, 0.062255166471004486, -0.007509635761380196, 0.025449808686971664, -0.005391561891883612, -0.005791538394987583, 0.008520823903381824, 0.008215752430260181, 0.016733957454562187, 0.04985548555850983, 0.032442327588796616, 0.048008646816015244, -0.04576217383146286, -0.016398578882217407, -0.026206135749816895, 0.020063595846295357, 0.019674032926559448, 0.002553571481257677, -0.008622881956398487, -0.07972923666238785, 0.026231106370687485, -0.009513887576758862, -0.022119324654340744, 0.019462205469608307, 0.018528053537011147, 0.001306071295402944, -0.062141306698322296, 0.016972381621599197, 0.030974430963397026, 0.059108901768922806, 0.008266896940767765, 0.00492606358602643, 0.031947582960128784, 0.010137801058590412, 0.03832618147134781, -0.015112318098545074, -0.013385554775595665, 0.04210478812456131, 0.010305743664503098, -0.023444470018148422, 0.06049896031618118, 0.0383063368499279, 0.11783211678266525, 0.04591178894042969, 0.03232122212648392, 0.016260018572211266, -0.05731746554374695, 0.016353286802768707, -0.03599567338824272, 0.012081032618880272, -0.024545328691601753, 0.006471139844506979, -0.06098563224077225, -0.03928355872631073, 0.034502044320106506, -0.007970909588038921, -0.01398850604891777, -0.004003606736660004, -0.0030533773824572563, -0.004321844317018986, -0.024800632148981094, -0.013722307980060577, 0.005341181997209787, -0.001075110980309546, -0.023038387298583984, -0.0016040882328525186, 0.03718305379152298, -0.008009159006178379, 0.008642160333693027, -0.008608633652329445, -0.014299930073320866, -0.0015065826009958982, 0.05059809610247612, 0.010749888606369495, -0.022554680705070496, 0.06153483688831329, 0.10430224984884262, -0.050396066159009933, 0.024315807968378067, 0.013171863742172718, -0.003417487256228924, 0.02487039938569069, 0.025319810956716537, -0.03152903541922569, -0.09949599951505661, -0.005123920738697052, -0.01112427283078432, 0.04876045510172844, -0.0013468763791024685, -0.0036038646940141916, -0.032826587557792664, -0.045044612139463425, -0.04025372117757797, 0.022536789998412132, -0.018819954246282578, 0.016652844846248627, -0.036993082612752914, -0.006247694604098797, -0.047197096049785614, 0.0054838284850120544, -0.008712735958397388, -0.046841103583574295, 0.0332128182053566, 0.037549033761024475, -0.015429217368364334, 0.042659834027290344, -0.005847734399139881, -0.0645861104130745, -0.038792453706264496, -0.04522818326950073, 0.03431646153330803, -0.010469036176800728, 0.005778017453849316, 0.048212308436632156, 0.050174497067928314, -0.025254372507333755, 0.011178364977240562, 0.042910799384117126, 0.027606593444943428, 0.023619795218110085, 0.04459445923566818, 0.05423901230096817, -0.015262449160218239, -0.108748659491539, -0.0029635592363774776, -0.013524259440600872, 0.008680135942995548, 0.013731539249420166, -0.0027494430541992188, -0.035979826003313065, 0.005200997926294804, -0.019172562286257744, 0.05244580656290054, -0.025146901607513428, -0.009149260818958282, -0.005489795934408903, -0.03560926765203476, 0.06645645201206207, -0.02877524122595787, -0.01321706734597683, -0.012849602848291397, -0.015852464362978935, -0.00990490522235632, 0.012096698395907879, -0.021373657509684563, -0.056386012583971024, 0.05585991218686104, 0.0809546634554863, 0.04599302262067795, -0.06377112865447998, 0.07562581449747086, -0.020352493971586227, 0.013518077321350574, -0.01740874908864498, 0.0435873419046402, -0.05095667019486427, 0.030149122700095177, -0.026759862899780273, 0.05320558324456215, 0.01504124328494072, -0.062481168657541275, 0.004735774360597134, -0.006722841877490282, 0.044179823249578476, 0.014758632518351078, 0.041113387793302536, 0.044790517538785934, 0.018807128071784973, -0.03328101336956024, -0.06263262778520584, 0.012884709052741528, -0.052486635744571686, 0.04136178269982338, 0.021067406982183456, 0.024743210524320602, 0.014215268194675446, 0.00529053620994091, 1.3674796718987636e-05, -0.06823226809501648, -0.026118576526641846, 0.008341656997799873, 0.02939143404364586, -0.023580702021718025, 0.0038730273954570293, -0.017725110054016113, -0.007920758798718452, -0.019758114591240883, -0.0017172704683616757, -0.03497254475951195, -0.0726255550980568, 0.002665194682776928, 0.039387986063957214, 0.04344239830970764, -0.007439404260367155, -0.0062157767824828625, -0.04222855716943741, -0.014992552809417248, 0.06371723860502243, -0.04137811064720154, -0.022692948579788208, 0.07834289968013763, -0.025730198249220848, -0.0019406377105042338, -0.002854651305824518, -0.021680761128664017, -0.01700661890208721, 0.06165163591504097, 0.025749603286385536, -0.015153579413890839, 0.047296278178691864, 0.053400248289108276, -0.0010790256783366203, 0.0185626819729805, 0.09116554260253906, 0.008458823896944523, 0.002466329839080572, -0.03262371942400932, -0.04830385744571686, -0.030148029327392578, 0.04287151247262955, 0.02753703109920025, -0.021669501438736916, 0.04242141172289848, 0.0663595050573349, -0.05521862208843231, -0.014547000639140606, -0.02303881198167801, -0.009751749224960804, 0.05393827334046364, -0.03217529505491257, -0.043541427701711655, -0.015044531784951687, -0.0408412404358387, 0.09073857218027115, -0.013747337274253368, 0.015755848959088326, 0.023452801629900932, -0.0127127505838871, 0.02325323410332203, 0.019493674859404564, 0.0016322153387591243, 0.05768279358744621, -0.06183195486664772, 0.021454432979226112, 0.015693340450525284, -0.015447232872247696, 0.025863446295261383, -0.051172856241464615, 0.007782016880810261, -0.004293916746973991, 0.059611815959215164, 0.04549885541200638, 0.044706400483846664, -0.05828046426177025, -0.003303908510133624, -0.015944279730319977, 0.016705594956874847, 0.025452138856053352, -0.059192955493927, 0.015500844456255436, -0.02920488454401493, 0.04864846542477608, -0.03817027434706688, -0.06179163604974747, -0.02339763194322586, -0.05517849326133728, -0.03850178420543671, -0.010133382864296436, 0.0459294393658638, -0.04840078204870224, -0.07471563667058945, -0.025634009391069412, 0.035300113260746, 0.013860132545232773, 0.0011018605437129736, -0.03647024184465408, -0.0012090709060430527, 0.003241636324673891, -0.029752377420663834, 0.019257789477705956, -0.024716118350625038, -0.029162075370550156, 0.02755114436149597, -0.055657800287008286, 0.001968289725482464, -0.06982666999101639, -0.02534499764442444, -5.683485431525005e-33, -0.02384786680340767, 0.024034762755036354, -0.0033355574123561382, 0.039061203598976135, -0.044109247624874115, 0.0026626528706401587, -0.047251131385564804, 0.019483590498566628, 0.08735482394695282, 0.012295029126107693, -0.009106275625526905, -0.03921590372920036, 0.02117469161748886, 0.051788732409477234, 0.06997738778591156, 0.028819816187024117, -0.057111043483018875, -0.025325162336230278, 0.02470424771308899, -0.007395204622298479, 0.03741512820124626, -0.006057772319763899, 0.07247281819581985, -0.08027389645576477, -0.059103939682245255, 0.02992403879761696, -0.009811846539378166, -0.014688895083963871, -0.049015920609235764, -0.010328708216547966, 0.004433688707649708, 0.010433584451675415, 0.020564613863825798, 0.01960558071732521, 0.014510081149637699, -0.01649358682334423, -0.008429555222392082, -0.0025871596299111843, 0.036080632358789444, -0.03592655062675476, -0.010368267074227333, 0.03164991736412048, 0.043266087770462036, -0.02130723185837269, 0.047112125903367996, 0.04173780605196953, 0.07543031126260757, -0.0014412762830033898, 0.04600236192345619, 0.007175660692155361, -0.027996499091386795, -0.030806126073002815, -0.03177334740757942, 0.009179044514894485, -0.0031072692945599556, 0.05161655321717262, -0.07648904621601105, 0.006137100514024496, -0.06231573224067688, 0.005110894795507193, -9.610538836568594e-05, 0.015230708755552769, -0.04021557793021202, 0.01649703085422516, 0.10556833446025848, 0.0248845424503088, 0.06666985154151917, -0.01181779894977808, -0.029949961230158806, 0.06208287924528122, 0.03987390920519829, 0.03918186575174332, 0.00942204799503088, 0.02242443710565567, 0.020983217284083366, -0.014638906344771385, -0.03125252574682236, 0.04753323271870613, -0.0443999283015728, 0.004410650581121445, -0.037964776158332825, -0.022619428113102913, 0.03000224381685257, -0.029899483546614647, 0.024615192785859108, -0.029749149456620216, -0.04205672815442085, -0.035703398287296295, 0.0013999097282066941, -0.06156892701983452, -0.008657949045300484, -0.05500775948166847, 0.03697315976023674, 0.01798800192773342, 0.045850254595279694, -0.0944821834564209, 0.040358059108257294, 0.015942107886075974, 0.0491369366645813, 0.014246322214603424, 0.0021352965850383043, 0.0011571237118914723, 0.047345515340566635, -0.030880039557814598, 0.038059301674366, -0.03718828409910202, -0.015190856531262398, -0.01325242780148983, 0.004003257490694523, 0.018625149503350258, 0.058550361543893814, -0.05330156162381172, 0.011202300898730755, 0.044100794941186905, -0.04066187143325806, -0.0563567578792572, -0.038610927760601044, 0.010962658561766148, 0.03652634844183922, 0.033196866512298584, -0.06478092074394226, 0.01505319681018591, -0.01890573836863041, 0.021516039967536926, 0.01586190052330494, 0.007406617980450392, -0.048422105610370636, -0.07754433155059814, 0.029188163578510284, -0.05297151207923889, -0.02233608067035675, -0.04232014715671539, 2.9792158784403e-07, -0.019383545964956284, 0.03739073500037193, 0.010225529782474041, -0.008615958504378796, 0.016359400004148483, -0.03440225124359131, -0.04188723489642143, 0.03396883234381676, -0.002826956333592534, 0.009067971259355545, 0.02518525719642639, 0.02961507998406887, -0.02314141020178795, 0.004101313650608063, -0.012846624478697777, -0.006798577029258013, -0.02810520865023136, 0.03784751147031784, -0.026458533480763435, -0.053937625139951706, -0.03102879785001278, -0.04829989746212959, -0.019850216805934906, -0.07087557762861252, 0.010006572119891644, 0.08658201992511749, 0.016865257173776627, -0.011588084511458874, -0.014400104060769081, 0.017468160018324852, -0.05039564147591591, -0.10352274030447006, 0.02352980151772499, 0.0031921572517603636, 0.022790035232901573, -0.054441966116428375, -0.007716262713074684, -0.028684495016932487, -0.008072280324995518, -0.02511397749185562, 0.07168020308017731, 0.03958865627646446, 0.015917262062430382, -0.0008401556988246739, -0.014937339350581169, -0.046017829328775406, -0.043434593826532364, 0.019194358959794044, 0.007448626682162285, 0.025626208633184433, 0.07883864641189575, -0.04786614701151848, 0.005692480131983757, 0.009056750684976578, 0.018698077648878098, -0.0024695033207535744, 0.0570068284869194, 0.041429221630096436, 0.07037575542926788, 0.0012251617154106498, -0.053797438740730286, 0.04529081657528877, 0.058093391358852386, -0.015253580175340176, 1.257481471839128e-05, 0.04301495850086212, -0.013515613973140717, 3.063011573465299e-34, -0.011525695212185383, 0.018894853070378304, 0.0015423813601955771, -0.03411497175693512, 0.011113805696368217, -0.02955646626651287, -0.01962113194167614, -0.003785104490816593, -0.07197577506303787, -0.05361552909016609, -0.002448532497510314]
669
669
['N. Popescu-Bodorin', 'V. E. Balas', 'I. M. Motoc']
1110.6483v2
The main topic discussed in this paper is how to use intelligence for biometric decision defuzzification. A neural training model is proposed and tested here as a possible solution for dealing with natural fuzzification that appears between the intra- and inter-class distribution of scores computed during iris recognition tests. It is shown here that the use of proposed neural network support leads to an improvement in the artificial perception of the separation between the intra- and inter-class score distributions by moving them away from each other.
Iris Codes Classification Using Discriminant and Witness Directions
2,011
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1110.6483v2
Title Iris Codes Classification Using Discriminant Witness Directions Summary main topic discussed paper use intelligence biometric decision defuzzification neural training model proposed tested possible solution dealing natural fuzzification appears intra interclass distribution score computed iris recognition test shown use proposed neural network support lead improvement artificial perception separation intra interclass score distribution moving away Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.010166543535888195, 0.02445843070745468, -0.03575289249420166, 0.02355828322470188, 0.008509612642228603, 0.006906767375767231, 0.0847771093249321, 0.030097832903265953, 0.028248466551303864, 0.035606518387794495, 0.008046114817261696, -0.011559037491679192, 0.0764433741569519, 0.045154646039009094, -0.002299973974004388, -0.044191960245370865, -0.0064063058234751225, -0.015319681726396084, 0.02864830195903778, 0.0124406972900033, 0.017730649560689926, -0.013651871122419834, 0.026545165106654167, 0.06482759118080139, -0.06095396354794502, 0.012752416543662548, -0.0019963581580668688, 0.0032228862401098013, -0.0019924056250602007, 0.010462896898388863, 0.015371860936284065, -0.003212614683434367, -0.029613368213176727, -0.0009846281027421355, 2.156889195248368e-06, -0.026772113516926765, 0.0025181237142533064, -0.01730990596115589, 0.007736006751656532, -0.045086029917001724, 0.03264158219099045, 0.020847206935286522, 0.013134617358446121, -0.036723144352436066, -0.04578198865056038, -0.00938749872148037, 0.0643070787191391, 0.09324321150779724, 0.006499306298792362, 0.029677141457796097, 0.012113765813410282, -0.00727307703346014, 0.016566790640354156, 0.010963525623083115, 0.0074116806499660015, -0.006924412678927183, 0.009642734192311764, -0.03990219160914421, -0.0592145174741745, -0.06460819393396378, 0.014375601895153522, 0.04344823211431503, 0.03399243205785751, -0.03665770962834358, -0.0018692325102165341, 0.049946434795856476, -0.024258973076939583, -0.02431165799498558, 0.0028610650915652514, 0.0191155057400465, -0.06604061275720596, -0.0018366823205724359, -0.031075283885002136, 0.0304337777197361, -0.015770236030220985, 0.002868570853024721, 0.011857581324875355, -0.011718053370714188, -0.03550267219543457, 0.0054350802674889565, -0.034551721066236496, 0.044423069804906845, 0.014581652358174324, -0.01631963439285755, -0.0505136214196682, -0.05736304447054863, -0.023917000740766525, 0.01404601614922285, 0.012609053403139114, -0.018633397296071053, 0.03814114257693291, 0.02460123598575592, -0.01244188193231821, -0.01211506873369217, 0.033402275294065475, -0.041212234646081924, -0.009675869718194008, 0.00671820342540741, 0.0171294454485178, -0.008990236558020115, 0.048926692456007004, -0.0036826380528509617, -0.002600724110379815, -0.030636509880423546, -0.05190659314393997, 0.01849801279604435, 0.040773503482341766, 0.02656060829758644, -0.009300852194428444, 0.011142881587147713, -0.028851354494690895, -0.001379676046781242, 0.019259024411439896, -0.034667231142520905, 0.0672730877995491, 0.032891981303691864, -0.10225074738264084, -0.031133431941270828, -0.00421628775075078, -0.05028265342116356, 0.010601992718875408, 0.03550713136792183, 0.020109353587031364, 0.036485131829977036, -0.010850816033780575, -0.027785608544945717, 0.04682782292366028, -0.04258330911397934, -0.05206499248743057, -0.05006751790642738, 0.017232321202754974, 0.0017553973011672497, -0.03305353969335556, 0.039747290313243866, 0.005254771094769239, 0.0012045757612213492, 0.0028748856857419014, -0.016585836187005043, -0.0553111806511879, 0.07264557480812073, 0.014937812462449074, 0.007688760757446289, 0.03809692710638046, -0.01809290237724781, 0.0040750447660684586, -0.0360933281481266, -0.014038157649338245, -0.035800281912088394, 0.01752280257642269, -0.007867943495512009, 0.010764924809336662, 0.03325306251645088, -0.05602487176656723, -0.005706691183149815, 0.0526789166033268, -0.006102541461586952, 0.0954214483499527, -0.006349905859678984, 0.0320434533059597, -0.06816313415765762, 0.032094016671180725, -0.07129331678152084, 0.08240490406751633, -0.006368947681039572, -0.0068881940096616745, -0.0521063506603241, 0.000862048240378499, -0.016605405136942863, 0.004903282970190048, -0.026336323469877243, 0.0576239749789238, -0.0026917289942502975, -0.0016633274499326944, -0.030668070539832115, 0.003116039792075753, 0.07316356152296066, 0.028889797627925873, -0.00026733067352324724, -0.008914276026189327, -0.01568518951535225, -0.009074768982827663, -0.00022930958948563784, -0.0016247510211542249, 0.05074163153767586, -0.009122400544583797, -0.031216666102409363, -0.04508925974369049, 0.017579255625605583, -0.02081044390797615, -0.03815251216292381, 0.001982768066227436, -0.051343124359846115, 0.019116200506687164, -0.01387680135667324, 0.0034896782599389553, -0.028598472476005554, 0.04535197466611862, -0.04040738195180893, 0.0035819625481963158, 0.005230962298810482, -0.04887444153428078, -0.10061969608068466, 0.0012107777874916792, -0.012770445086061954, -0.03989797458052635, 0.0010965131223201752, 0.050140541046857834, -0.02755053900182247, -0.09667649120092392, -0.053616736084222794, 0.011935548856854439, -0.022823957726359367, 0.059109870344400406, -0.07268306612968445, -0.0013404499040916562, 0.07184524089097977, -0.02949848398566246, -0.015472754836082458, -0.025507748126983643, 0.02180604822933674, 0.05986423417925835, 0.05358108505606651, -0.06318564713001251, -0.01328197866678238, -0.02277582883834839, 0.01013252791017294, 0.03011716529726982, 0.031956784427165985, 0.022592483088374138, -0.015529295429587364, 0.0021994933485984802, -0.036619123071432114, 0.003464351873844862, -0.0098886052146554, 0.05774799361824989, -0.06226690486073494, 0.019150108098983765, 0.03936484828591347, 0.04441317543387413, -0.010508800856769085, 0.012539411894977093, -0.013724731281399727, -0.016346504911780357, -0.018509257584810257, 0.0053844572976231575, -0.043541502207517624, -0.029856374487280846, -0.04455285519361496, 0.06841009855270386, -0.009926920756697655, -0.02057184837758541, -0.013626889325678349, 0.020203299820423126, -0.0029208234045654535, 0.012935217469930649, -0.0762680396437645, -0.09135773777961731, 0.0875241607427597, -0.08636230230331421, 0.024762434884905815, 0.01025638822466135, -0.021128956228494644, 0.029497932642698288, 0.008299964480102062, 0.09553967416286469, -0.012761356309056282, -0.031615715473890305, -0.03421509638428688, -0.043922968208789825, 0.028410183265805244, -0.05264781042933464, -0.031094204634428024, -0.01750655472278595, 0.027330845594406128, -0.02843649312853813, -0.03919314593076706, -0.0025649031158536673, -0.03011881187558174, -0.0458340123295784, 0.012695674784481525, 0.003351632971316576, -0.0003705907438416034, 0.04073430597782135, -0.042903777211904526, -0.04905960336327553, 0.04875928536057472, 0.07779677212238312, -0.04197341203689575, 0.023120805621147156, -0.016278427094221115, -0.011559189297258854, 0.026704739779233932, -0.0182315856218338, -0.009357471950352192, 0.040721964091062546, -0.0071686930023133755, -0.04355571046471596, 0.04409116506576538, 0.020479900762438774, -0.05233241990208626, -0.005337930750101805, 0.05496125668287277, 0.01153391133993864, -0.0014335645828396082, 0.027944302186369896, 0.0442209392786026, 0.012204485014081001, -0.0583747923374176, -0.04187168553471565, -0.05395606905221939, -0.0019143372774124146, -0.017896374687552452, 0.0034478933084756136, 0.07142588496208191, 0.032442688941955566, -0.005249970592558384, -0.06640983372926712, -0.00473489286378026, 0.005232218187302351, 0.030170174315571785, -0.003271014429628849, -0.058588676154613495, 0.013674499467015266, -0.007946381345391273, 0.02405543066561222, -0.03272218629717827, -0.02964446134865284, 0.04289396107196808, -0.014027785509824753, -0.00589981721714139, 0.042770203202962875, -0.0037236465141177177, -0.03756127506494522, -0.01592918671667576, -0.014202491380274296, -0.03720708563923836, -0.03882352635264397, -0.009138493798673153, 0.007604674901813269, -0.04521763324737549, -0.06082369014620781, -0.008966885507106781, -0.01276694517582655, 0.005125611554831266, 0.016527779400348663, -0.016560204327106476, -0.022682461887598038, -0.03149191290140152, 0.06698727607727051, 0.035589754581451416, 0.03737591579556465, 0.03958521783351898, -0.03188397362828255, -0.020787950605154037, -0.006559925619512796, 0.016954677179455757, -0.004546111449599266, -0.016579976305365562, 0.01969866454601288, 0.016462361440062523, -0.04675620049238205, 0.017732735723257065, -0.01258175354450941, 0.01861656829714775, -0.09466755390167236, -0.021385518833994865, 0.0073858886025846004, 0.024809477850794792, -0.03521477058529854, -0.006572682876139879, 0.028636669740080833, -0.021439962089061737, 0.057554733008146286, 0.022922812029719353, -0.0016612455947324634, -0.09332653880119324, -0.01398001704365015, -0.03075653500854969, -0.1046232059597969, 0.015739358961582184, -0.018304580822587013, 0.02576468512415886, 0.010145863518118858, 0.003507751040160656, 0.0404086597263813, -0.0545426607131958, -0.04354449734091759, 0.0361427403986454, 0.003265008330345154, 0.030117597430944443, 0.03231271356344223, -0.0015715989284217358, -0.08605032414197922, 0.017491869628429413, 0.011857269331812859, 0.051938656717538834, -0.002191508188843727, 0.02277013473212719, 0.0033431751653552055, 0.00649188831448555, -0.002797058317810297, -0.010881197638809681, 0.02226182445883751, 0.024346351623535156, -0.03984776511788368, -0.07932821661233902, 0.02998911775648594, 0.04044375568628311, 0.010476401075720787, -0.024442018941044807, -0.019563110545277596, -0.07353997230529785, 0.028650783002376556, -0.03549416363239288, 0.0684790089726448, -0.0034256144426763058, -0.0065045664086937904, -0.018857114017009735, 0.04496404528617859, 0.02947147935628891, 0.05848187208175659, 0.03993730992078781, -0.052865028381347656, -0.0068726567551493645, -0.020041801035404205, -0.024947503581643105, -0.039163775742053986, -0.026711883023381233, -0.03791381046175957, 0.042203888297080994, -0.0034114134032279253, -0.026322269812226295, -0.00713154673576355, 0.04770034924149513, -0.0015722650568932295, -0.02901695854961872, 0.0005467797163873911, 0.047144170850515366, -0.051543816924095154, -0.01771293208003044, -0.0107966847717762, -0.04597792401909828, 0.07218887656927109, 0.0283257607370615, -0.03639565408229828, 0.026591481640934944, 0.0036579088773578405, -0.0008075775112956762, 0.009379983879625797, 0.03413987159729004, -0.0007475099409930408, -0.01740572787821293, 0.05215943232178688, -0.02295851707458496, 0.022232571616768837, -0.011711115017533302, 0.028505051508545876, 0.07872235774993896, 0.035059843212366104, 0.005783658009022474, 0.026209326460957527, 0.012590770609676838, -0.027266528457403183, -0.055896226316690445, -0.07941453903913498, 0.01641824282705784, -0.012552482075989246, 0.0685800239443779, -0.00791983027011156, 0.01125741470605135, -0.014973164536058903, -0.0005790528375655413, -0.0088445283472538, 0.039118047803640366, -0.004891159012913704, 0.021609436720609665, -0.11666109412908554, -0.09704979509115219, -0.07467100024223328, -0.010745079256594181, 0.013244865462183952, 0.04488299787044525, 0.016276177018880844, 0.05396489053964615, 0.018681801855564117, 0.035908088088035583, 0.012266010977327824, 0.0151829207316041, 0.033188045024871826, -0.06510709226131439, 0.029021158814430237, 0.07797733694314957, -0.013709156773984432, -0.050303176045417786, 0.022936714813113213, -0.062397997826337814, -0.005220339633524418, 0.02003634348511696, 0.04950932413339615, 0.03114999458193779, -0.04427400976419449, -0.012958379462361336, -0.01008245162665844, -0.04178539663553238, 0.020918939262628555, 0.027256803587079048, 0.012651360593736172, 0.07297386974096298, -0.01152045652270317, -0.033783163875341415, 0.012800845317542553, 0.03758414834737778, 0.03339768201112747, 0.006380753591656685, 0.006010576616972685, 0.009248577058315277, -0.01885102316737175, 0.039295744150877, -0.07818905264139175, 0.01967509463429451, 0.0027771347668021917, -0.028371673077344894, 0.044861480593681335, -0.03564462438225746, 0.0354880727827549, 0.03484220430254936, 0.03204590454697609, -0.06845983862876892, 0.01926460489630699, 0.01130638923496008, -0.009816975332796574, -0.040755145251750946, -0.06160726770758629, -0.031335510313510895, -0.01266910508275032, 0.040985364466905594, 0.045094866305589676, -0.0017022821120917797, -0.028945831581950188, -0.0006460086442530155, -0.006799790542572737, -0.016649868339300156, 0.07126989960670471, 0.03041675128042698, 0.045009393244981766, 0.04150788113474846, 0.011229154653847218, -0.022014493122696877, -0.00943833775818348, -0.024538664147257805, 0.0063173118978738785, -0.025272628292441368, -0.007587885949760675, 0.002739311894401908, -0.06427444517612457, -5.822880327091312e-33, 0.006097417790442705, 0.02197650447487831, -0.01773488149046898, -0.014490798115730286, -0.010826921090483665, 0.007213241886347532, -0.006085481960326433, 0.017897019162774086, -0.038968801498413086, -0.021106230095028877, 0.009462240152060986, 0.04118211194872856, 0.003967541269958019, 0.02824169211089611, -0.022259658202528954, -0.010599048808217049, -0.00022995173640083522, 0.0008978046826086938, 0.008097557350993156, -0.013192088343203068, 0.04904356971383095, -0.0076325153931975365, 0.019301654770970345, -0.08312671631574631, -0.026114633306860924, 0.04013950377702713, -0.009023911319673061, -0.017053455114364624, -0.01219122763723135, -0.0242031030356884, -0.011420533992350101, 0.003168594092130661, 0.01092811394482851, 0.0469878613948822, 0.04382312670350075, 0.03103863261640072, 0.003936321008950472, 0.002139975782483816, -0.05899307504296303, 0.03137777000665665, 0.01793469488620758, -0.08595968782901764, 0.06992689520120621, -0.03758332505822182, -0.07271574437618256, 0.016123270615935326, 0.011482053436338902, -0.021961532533168793, -0.010444664396345615, -0.027992399409413338, 0.06982671469449997, 0.0041768974624574184, 0.007025646511465311, 0.016960958018898964, -0.01280423253774643, -0.0008607079507783055, -0.033453941345214844, -0.015856871381402016, -0.051167767494916916, 0.02262253314256668, 0.0036950132343918085, -0.016557792201638222, -0.02864665538072586, 0.01728450134396553, 0.045699577778577805, 0.006282892543822527, 0.07198848575353622, -0.09733003377914429, 0.01829540729522705, -0.06957806646823883, 0.03829040005803108, -0.015830378979444504, 0.06729485094547272, 0.01616724766790867, -0.006472880952060223, -0.08055566996335983, -0.037017352879047394, 0.03065594844520092, 0.04376433789730072, 0.02495315857231617, -0.035760026425123215, -0.0096943574026227, -0.06957380473613739, 0.00161085301078856, 0.06793701648712158, -0.09414331614971161, 0.006124451290816069, 0.028644166886806488, 0.016870010644197464, -0.05756812170147896, -0.000825389928650111, 0.06523539125919342, 0.01224547903984785, -0.05041209235787392, 0.04637222737073898, -0.005297974217683077, 0.029231566935777664, 0.024266494438052177, 0.03973032906651497, -0.01323180366307497, -0.00889403186738491, -0.0499642938375473, 0.05908050760626793, -0.014806185849010944, 0.043622978031635284, -0.003988972865045071, 0.05226626247167587, -0.009595423005521297, -0.028110096231102943, -0.005730795674026012, 0.04803374037146568, 0.006825713906437159, 0.04118172824382782, 0.07181413471698761, 0.007545921485871077, -0.03390834107995033, 0.01616411842405796, -0.04954062029719353, 0.03810317814350128, -0.0070447553880512714, -0.014479856006801128, 0.013246231712400913, 0.013992061838507652, 0.024206796661019325, -0.00962856411933899, 0.022580502554774284, -0.058268770575523376, 0.005053374450653791, -0.037267498672008514, -0.02118617296218872, -0.007694727275520563, 0.038004204630851746, 2.7531839918992773e-07, -0.05186624452471733, -0.006114779505878687, 0.01589905470609665, -0.04140461981296539, 0.006647954694926739, 0.030260970816016197, -0.007164291571825743, 0.012016872875392437, 0.030873144045472145, 0.006059423089027405, -0.008617679588496685, -0.02005322277545929, -0.0027874913066625595, -0.020038744434714317, 0.009913666173815727, -0.010398400016129017, 0.09638495743274689, 0.025201644748449326, 0.003592374734580517, 0.08473480492830276, -0.01352684572339058, 0.06708794832229614, -0.0033047485630959272, -0.031892094761133194, 0.060522571206092834, -0.05900129675865173, -0.01695074699819088, 0.02231404185295105, 0.014393270015716553, -0.0012343361740931869, 0.044338952749967575, 0.015074808150529861, 0.026636041700839996, 0.07435207068920135, 0.00208282726816833, 0.03660950809717178, 0.02457672730088234, 0.010869563557207584, -0.04850751906633377, 0.056948672980070114, 0.009376090951263905, 0.018108269199728966, 0.015048093162477016, -0.029417742043733597, 0.06768842041492462, 0.06032951921224594, -0.028437374159693718, 0.002545235911384225, -0.006367507390677929, 0.003431855235248804, 0.013874492608010769, -0.02045562118291855, -0.01299014501273632, 0.057240989059209824, 0.010798460803925991, -0.0377567782998085, 0.009714396670460701, -0.004429230000823736, 0.01831216551363468, -0.025790555402636528, 0.027072018012404442, -0.015063976868987083, 0.01963942125439644, 0.03276761993765831, 0.08994987607002258, 0.03516821563243866, -0.009260069578886032, 2.349470431304343e-34, -0.038894135504961014, -0.009537123143672943, 0.011444855481386185, 0.0013951059663668275, 0.012626015581190586, -0.03126504272222519, -0.06483004242181778, 0.0026907213032245636, 0.024727990850806236, 0.018924979493021965, 0.0011649543885141611]
670
670
['Harris Georgiou']
0910.3348v1
Medical Informatics and the application of modern signal processing in the assistance of the diagnostic process in medical imaging is one of the more recent and active research areas today. This thesis addresses a variety of issues related to the general problem of medical image analysis, specifically in mammography, and presents a series of algorithms and design approaches for all the intermediate levels of a modern system for computer-aided diagnosis (CAD). The diagnostic problem is analyzed with a systematic approach, first defining the imaging characteristics and features that are relevant to probable pathology in mammo-grams. Next, these features are quantified and fused into new, integrated radio-logical systems that exhibit embedded digital signal processing, in order to improve the final result and minimize the radiological dose for the patient. In a higher level, special algorithms are designed for detecting and encoding these clinically interest-ing imaging features, in order to be used as input to advanced pattern classifiers and machine learning models. Finally, these approaches are extended in multi-classifier models under the scope of Game Theory and optimum collective deci-sion, in order to produce efficient solutions for combining classifiers with minimum computational costs for advanced diagnostic systems. The material covered in this thesis is related to a total of 18 published papers, 6 in scientific journals and 12 in international conferences.
Algorithms for Image Analysis and Combination of Pattern Classifiers with Application to Medical Diagnosis
2,009
http://arxiv.org/pdf/0910.3348v1
Title Algorithms Image Analysis Combination Pattern Classifiers Application Medical Diagnosis Summary Medical Informatics application modern signal processing assistance diagnostic process medical imaging one recent active research area today thesis address variety issue related general problem medical image analysis specifically mammography present series algorithm design approach intermediate level modern system computeraided diagnosis CAD diagnostic problem analyzed systematic approach first defining imaging characteristic feature relevant probable pathology mammogram Next feature quantified fused new integrated radiological system exhibit embedded digital signal processing order improve final result minimize radiological dose patient higher level special algorithm designed detecting encoding clinically interesting imaging feature order used input advanced pattern classifier machine learning model Finally approach extended multiclassifier model scope Game Theory optimum collective decision order produce efficient solution combining classifier minimum computational cost advanced diagnostic system material covered thesis related total 18 published paper 6 scientific journal 12 international conference Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.021188486367464066, 0.012472002767026424, -0.03954780101776123, 0.0048455409705638885, -0.020418690517544746, 0.026509681716561317, 0.04262324795126915, 0.07307633012533188, -0.034143172204494476, 0.020297590643167496, 0.10182428359985352, -0.00038924592081457376, 0.05464025214314461, 0.07057800889015198, -0.015152454376220703, -0.03704557567834854, -0.048385392874479294, 0.03186063840985298, -0.022001201286911964, -0.032473672181367874, 0.015432574786245823, -0.03593624010682106, -0.00158055336214602, 0.047059547156095505, -0.04993397742509842, 0.05862877145409584, 0.029019486159086227, -0.049145448952913284, 0.01645667664706707, -0.029004864394664764, 0.0034596542827785015, -0.052158840000629425, -0.039636559784412384, 0.03736771270632744, 2.358751771680545e-06, -0.07328397035598755, -0.014880380593240261, 0.0028990632854402065, 0.03631081432104111, 0.008447297848761082, 0.02762913890182972, -0.02184263803064823, -0.003619810566306114, -0.03784427046775818, 0.0004813359410036355, -0.011440195143222809, 0.02417737804353237, 0.04822249338030815, 0.016374891623854637, 0.04746278002858162, -0.020962845534086227, -0.006339245941489935, 0.039387840777635574, 0.007010303903371096, -0.0396745428442955, 0.010803681798279285, 0.024003028869628906, 0.027643965557217598, 0.030643437057733536, -0.024498330429196358, 0.00020594759553205222, 0.06283676624298096, 0.0033465262968093157, -0.013003440573811531, -0.015318797901272774, 0.061107587069272995, 0.02959693782031536, -0.06093117967247963, -0.028688322752714157, -0.005741736851632595, -0.02873249538242817, -0.004869828000664711, 0.0025165865663439035, -0.016404422000050545, -0.023442625999450684, -0.0024971526581794024, 0.0016349202487617731, 0.004762857221066952, -0.02185405045747757, 0.011568224988877773, 0.0008447298314422369, 0.01817108690738678, -0.009981969371438026, -0.022652622312307358, -0.015348353423178196, 0.005568651482462883, -0.003814841853454709, 0.024002769961953163, 0.009414971806108952, 0.00961272045969963, -0.030254153534770012, -0.01119073387235403, 0.04214012622833252, 0.04182993248105049, -0.06348025053739548, -0.035088520497083664, 0.0016403448535129428, -0.062400031834840775, 0.07867223024368286, -0.047049667686223984, -0.003427332965657115, -0.020964261144399643, 0.005204133689403534, 0.03323397785425186, -0.017215518280863762, -0.013064105994999409, -0.05375122278928757, 0.06589387357234955, -0.07098917663097382, 0.06788789480924606, 0.002805083291605115, 0.027231356129050255, -0.00869388971477747, 0.036413632333278656, 0.060710661113262177, -0.009900671429932117, -0.05796461179852486, -0.0006430957582779229, 0.01323791779577732, -0.013065988197922707, 0.030396882444620132, 0.06709055602550507, 0.039799537509679794, 0.04251964017748833, 0.005375829990953207, 0.011414897628128529, 0.011904758401215076, -0.018546415492892265, -0.0228993222117424, 0.006480222102254629, 0.04709731042385101, -0.0030879045370966196, -0.004671923816204071, 0.04663756117224693, 0.022761322557926178, 0.014111639931797981, -0.006651385687291622, 0.027191344648599625, 0.005787903442978859, 0.011061678640544415, 0.0006231477600522339, -0.010634497739374638, -0.02018211968243122, -0.010249091312289238, -0.0221564918756485, 0.020951129496097565, 0.036215052008628845, 0.07199649512767792, 0.022513287141919136, -0.0009916237322613597, -0.007557205855846405, 0.034811753779649734, -0.028479421511292458, -0.01407237071543932, 0.10534495115280151, 0.03537643328309059, 0.01898994855582714, -0.020986896008253098, 0.030033202841877937, -0.03848941996693611, -0.022461438551545143, -0.07362460345029831, -0.003234728006646037, -0.013511713594198227, -0.03803692385554314, -0.053008485585451126, -0.03631284460425377, -0.020316388458013535, -0.021872514858841896, 0.024342039600014687, -0.004153154790401459, 0.020782042294740677, 0.04231328144669533, 0.01096806675195694, -0.03227916359901428, 0.014552668668329716, 0.05782919004559517, -0.005918120965361595, 0.021033935248851776, -0.014077693223953247, -0.018402738496661186, 0.0059937601909041405, 0.08116888254880905, -0.00019123146194033325, -0.04476667195558548, -0.06398721039295197, -0.07107452303171158, -0.012141194194555283, -0.029088977724313736, -0.07755983620882034, -0.025722002610564232, -0.02012544497847557, -0.03222467377781868, -0.020593494176864624, 0.04433385282754898, -0.03268301114439964, 0.0035449061542749405, -0.061689600348472595, 0.0373559407889843, 0.038963720202445984, -0.08038065582513809, -0.08262483030557632, 0.02709495648741722, -0.03868841007351875, -0.01115085557103157, -0.07525606453418732, 0.007850505411624908, -0.009458611719310284, -0.04126567021012306, -0.0894409790635109, -0.035836122930049896, 0.03345198556780815, 0.008425215259194374, -0.0180587787181139, 0.0009630253189243376, 0.07777512818574905, 0.01975957676768303, -0.0019734082743525505, -0.030958261340856552, 0.05159628763794899, -0.018107866868376732, 0.05791735276579857, -0.008366881869733334, 0.004799460992217064, 0.02964460477232933, 0.012718893587589264, 0.040848258882761, 0.025103801861405373, 0.009384130127727985, -0.015399967320263386, 0.0152195505797863, -0.022318754345178604, 0.028777940198779106, -0.012644626200199127, -0.050814587622880936, -0.012782890349626541, 0.013530047610402107, 0.0007072501466609538, 0.002920920727774501, -0.02729870192706585, -0.0271360632032156, -0.03662050515413284, -0.03070719726383686, -0.01221536286175251, 0.0023311981931328773, -0.05972014740109444, -0.009800588712096214, -0.023103060200810432, 0.031460586935281754, 0.01164187304675579, -0.0023869641590863466, 9.73659916780889e-05, 0.04067855700850487, -0.01522586215287447, -0.007207863964140415, 0.043010126799345016, -0.06321994960308075, 0.03066595271229744, -0.024560710415244102, -0.016825275495648384, 0.00397125631570816, -0.049570322036743164, -0.004861750174313784, 0.0019504048395901918, 0.04425812512636185, -0.003142602974548936, -0.015487711876630783, 0.009513475932180882, -0.04254990816116333, 0.033109426498413086, -0.04506954178214073, 0.01200112234801054, 0.001630680519156158, 0.032268065959215164, -0.06036808341741562, -0.013475440442562103, 0.027090277522802353, 0.038488857448101044, -0.047341618686914444, 0.05426942929625511, 0.046493783593177795, -0.0018334155902266502, 0.013519581407308578, -0.025297779589891434, -0.02139519900083542, 0.023170577362179756, 0.038694482296705246, -0.04839729145169258, -0.0020959319081157446, 0.02621746063232422, 0.012816540896892548, 0.005111547652631998, 0.028162071481347084, -0.04479459673166275, -0.032001104205846786, -0.03393647074699402, -0.10032081604003906, 0.08567274361848831, 0.02415577322244644, 0.02752147987484932, 0.010957197286188602, 0.07192164659500122, 0.029931126162409782, 0.015228653326630592, 0.0005208014626987278, 0.029823999851942062, 0.06411271542310715, -0.02480560541152954, -0.012585652992129326, 0.005326990503817797, -0.014523872174322605, 0.016748232766985893, 0.020753271877765656, -0.00788841675966978, -0.021647846326231956, -0.00321729714050889, -0.06901224702596664, 0.0054831127636134624, 0.0026501952670514584, 0.0009632251458242536, 0.01504492573440075, -0.03197989985346794, 0.05716947093605995, 0.05201070383191109, 0.00702680554240942, -0.025897670537233353, -0.07495574653148651, 0.02499532699584961, -0.060290612280368805, 0.01667456515133381, 0.06226831302046776, -0.033267635852098465, -0.01123107597231865, 0.03028183802962303, -0.00028612857568077743, 0.04276658967137337, -0.07108499854803085, -0.04230824485421181, 0.013940595090389252, -0.01575670950114727, 0.0002876338257919997, -0.009874205105006695, -0.049504127353429794, 0.027460966259241104, 0.014468724839389324, -0.0402684211730957, -0.05541089549660683, 0.0416773222386837, -0.026079801842570305, 0.047052692621946335, -0.0510854534804821, 0.00016812268586363643, 0.018222207203507423, 0.00199337606318295, 0.0024379254318773746, 0.05888219177722931, 0.008486497215926647, -0.0400005541741848, -0.08131737262010574, 0.027223555371165276, 0.05105273053050041, 0.010647271759808064, -0.08846963196992874, 0.052848778665065765, -0.08851808309555054, 0.01015706080943346, -0.02843170240521431, 0.03763454407453537, -0.038879409432411194, -0.02612338587641716, -0.03690407797694206, 0.003304640296846628, 0.07519354671239853, -0.0036757676862180233, 0.006118816323578358, -0.06285029649734497, -0.033228375017642975, 0.014995678327977657, -0.08490826189517975, -0.0164236668497324, -0.0032645484898239374, -0.002214112551882863, 0.029594119638204575, -0.01569267176091671, -0.043527379631996155, -0.0540047250688076, 0.006178906187415123, 0.03427133336663246, 0.011802416294813156, 0.030573934316635132, 0.0034364410676062107, -0.03570941463112831, -0.005792946554720402, -0.03320661559700966, -0.012199634686112404, -0.023519326001405716, -0.03934018313884735, -0.022102126851677895, 0.02223530411720276, -0.041185103356838226, 0.013795028440654278, -0.08881331980228424, -0.021574709564447403, -0.003549315268173814, 0.007555115967988968, -0.0697983056306839, -0.00038775638677179813, 0.019624803215265274, -0.04370252788066864, -0.06125044450163841, -0.032230447977781296, 0.02826666459441185, 0.035192493349313736, -0.032113898545503616, 0.032552316784858704, 0.04331722855567932, -0.00963442213833332, -0.01399536244571209, 0.059976913034915924, 0.05537861958146095, 0.07344324141740799, -0.0022087558172643185, 0.03794790059328079, -0.008104966953396797, -0.003146303351968527, -0.06315887719392776, 0.027699217200279236, 0.023433910682797432, -0.043691255152225494, -0.02532217837870121, -0.020997410640120506, -0.06140102073550224, 0.047281716018915176, 0.08620432764291763, 0.030792025849223137, 0.0289398655295372, 0.03336429223418236, -0.0029227028135210276, -0.08212839812040329, -0.020919812843203545, 0.03380316123366356, -0.021514473482966423, 0.048788607120513916, 0.04158926382660866, 0.015644289553165436, -0.01991243287920952, 0.021272920072078705, -0.046640925109386444, -0.008112335577607155, 0.08347246050834656, 0.029669716954231262, -0.05326159670948982, 0.011202366091310978, -0.014126691967248917, -0.04323287308216095, -0.016976268962025642, -0.021903064101934433, 0.001197166508063674, 0.024118132889270782, -0.0023876118939369917, 0.05585101991891861, 0.007448044139891863, -0.05296662077307701, -0.0574391670525074, -0.0042352816089987755, 0.05761273577809334, -0.016717752441763878, 0.03546474128961563, 0.008231639862060547, -0.013806945644319057, -0.06092345342040062, -0.013849933631718159, -0.03386908397078514, 0.029045086354017258, 0.046750523149967194, 0.002354718279093504, -0.0699964314699173, -0.0621093325316906, -0.006134025752544403, 0.02947334013879299, 0.041311342269182205, 0.05415841192007065, 0.011724487878382206, -0.001112584606744349, 0.040198493748903275, 0.05699916556477547, 0.021578839048743248, 0.007060639560222626, -0.005309829954057932, -0.008294963277876377, -0.00018771002942230552, -0.01298306230455637, -0.003032499458640814, -0.042811036109924316, 0.01435068342834711, -0.09903992712497711, 0.022322330623865128, 0.04809137433767319, 0.049271244555711746, 0.015659717842936516, 0.008196242153644562, 0.0032886825501918793, 0.006518964190036058, -0.07201351225376129, 0.051802437752485275, 0.039275508373975754, 0.015936849638819695, 0.03517835587263107, -0.007080393843352795, 0.030394474044442177, -0.012218659743666649, 0.02934967167675495, 0.03131788596510887, 0.0439402312040329, 0.005029758438467979, 0.015828514471650124, 0.059945203363895416, -0.028668945655226707, -0.037592820823192596, -0.0012624460505321622, 0.004158598370850086, -0.039003048092126846, 0.058705296367406845, -0.04840238019824028, 0.047394488006830215, 0.00881473533809185, -0.008362491615116596, 0.024646291509270668, 0.019429102540016174, 0.014741386286914349, -0.04052519053220749, -0.005499442107975483, -0.033083658665418625, -0.046103574335575104, -0.03478994593024254, 0.08455637842416763, 0.0709005743265152, 0.02571396715939045, -0.027536122128367424, 0.012141006998717785, -0.014181173406541348, 0.011465802788734436, 0.00642511248588562, -0.02675752341747284, 0.044761672616004944, -0.018684785813093185, 0.009449763223528862, 0.0034404832404106855, -0.005216624587774277, -0.0006971302791498601, -0.005552520975470543, -0.01773849129676819, -0.028858814388513565, 0.008633101359009743, 0.02455352433025837, -5.786642774991338e-33, 0.023638740181922913, -0.04992873966693878, -0.004314728081226349, 0.005615578964352608, -0.008402603678405285, 0.1114281415939331, 0.038711756467819214, 0.013475569896399975, 0.043689433485269547, -0.02265201136469841, -0.012124656699597836, -0.020017744973301888, 0.014795470051467419, 0.026012593880295753, -0.010336082428693771, 0.01832084357738495, -0.01812712475657463, 0.015747778117656708, 0.018448548391461372, -0.03604872152209282, -0.006046154070645571, 0.009791056625545025, -0.005058205220848322, -0.04745441675186157, -0.04641687870025635, 0.0689493790268898, -0.03588803857564926, -0.060685329139232635, -0.08055828511714935, 0.013388115912675858, 0.003714765654876828, 0.008123905397951603, 0.0005553610390052199, 0.007212910335510969, 0.03158770874142647, 0.0066774701699614525, -0.04681682586669922, -0.01215517520904541, -0.0129723334684968, 0.049348827451467514, -0.023519495502114296, -0.00013112372835166752, 0.04977191984653473, -0.04527977481484413, -0.0148201584815979, 0.03722558170557022, 0.02800888568162918, -0.03920792415738106, 0.02617044374346733, -0.004009523894637823, 0.0342094749212265, 0.03708583489060402, -0.016815468668937683, 0.009863474406301975, 0.009210638701915741, -0.05191274359822273, -0.04566691443324089, 0.02032875455915928, 0.002834899351000786, 0.05403532460331917, 0.06709863245487213, 0.013628443703055382, -0.021253308281302452, -0.03723648935556412, 0.02046780101954937, -0.0017037184443324804, 0.045857153832912445, -0.09291635453701019, -0.005167331546545029, -0.00271984888240695, -0.06889514625072479, 0.026104899123311043, 0.020501064136624336, -0.010523229837417603, 0.08984879404306412, -0.06028170883655548, -0.06740514189004898, 0.03993876650929451, -0.030884861946105957, 0.03576554358005524, -0.04195636138319969, -0.02133994922041893, -0.05055782571434975, 0.0076812817715108395, 0.06337901949882507, -0.009846851229667664, -0.012654353864490986, -0.018016314134001732, 0.0170708317309618, 0.019397053867578506, -0.04368313401937485, 0.07059278339147568, -0.0423072874546051, -0.01758163794875145, 0.049125030636787415, -0.09844629466533661, 0.05940217152237892, 0.01915397122502327, 0.0118861123919487, -0.015372472815215588, 0.019510412588715553, -0.03974568098783493, 0.01606874167919159, -0.04202137887477875, 0.026436682790517807, 0.005812980234622955, 0.005630111787468195, 0.02077508345246315, -0.006433296948671341, 0.002347727073356509, 0.05093064531683922, -0.02748234011232853, -0.03316320851445198, -0.014050120487809181, 0.02001447044312954, -0.03153064846992493, 0.003144247690215707, 0.036580268293619156, -0.010654307901859283, -0.016871098428964615, -0.04314856976270676, -0.06901758164167404, -0.018166454508900642, 0.0087251216173172, -0.04622994363307953, -0.03580901399254799, -0.011549361050128937, -0.016267351806163788, 0.031577225774526596, -0.0003289970045443624, -0.03350694850087166, -0.016878463327884674, 2.968764079014363e-07, 0.01945837400853634, 0.025946298614144325, 0.000650873058475554, -0.06065284460783005, 0.01802629418671131, -0.021115528419613838, -0.038326364010572433, -0.014935887418687344, -0.0007671676576137543, 0.008775480091571808, 0.04779406636953354, -0.06670845299959183, -0.04246830195188522, -0.015365183353424072, 0.021274924278259277, -0.018472034484148026, 0.015783118084073067, 0.01477841753512621, 0.022560277953743935, 0.03511328250169754, 0.07590927183628082, 0.004386113490909338, 0.015154784545302391, -0.07710328698158264, 0.014090778306126595, 0.006332464050501585, 0.00888920295983553, -0.0007039101328700781, 0.05158710107207298, -0.058236438781023026, -0.007875543087720871, -0.011310047470033169, 0.05150383710861206, 0.07182962447404861, 0.02510593645274639, -0.01834247261285782, 0.02544473111629486, 0.014980261214077473, -0.057087209075689316, 0.05197205767035484, 0.00462854839861393, 0.04340602457523346, 0.038970645517110825, -0.006075010634958744, 0.06011863425374031, 0.024351852014660835, -0.03146854043006897, -0.06615521758794785, 0.011717995628714561, -0.02370944805443287, 0.08232969045639038, -0.011940552853047848, -0.03624945133924484, 0.011236384510993958, -0.009447320364415646, 0.00046502414625138044, 9.035089169628918e-05, -0.007711824495345354, 0.02195541001856327, -0.008487552404403687, 0.02926281839609146, -0.016794856637716293, 0.05322341248393059, 0.023103900253772736, 0.06327062100172043, -0.024086065590381622, -0.03588946536183357, 2.5015529975956016e-34, -0.00023849985154811293, 0.006835061125457287, -0.008869047276675701, 0.017261961475014687, -0.05572796240448952, -0.0024332976900041103, -0.01052247267216444, -0.005584073252975941, -0.003440571017563343, 0.02452629618346691, 0.0036555901169776917]
671
671
['Anh Nguyen', 'Jason Yosinski', 'Jeff Clune']
1412.1897v4
Deep neural networks (DNNs) have recently been achieving state-of-the-art performance on a variety of pattern-recognition tasks, most notably visual classification problems. Given that DNNs are now able to classify objects in images with near-human-level performance, questions naturally arise as to what differences remain between computer and human vision. A recent study revealed that changing an image (e.g. of a lion) in a way imperceptible to humans can cause a DNN to label the image as something else entirely (e.g. mislabeling a lion a library). Here we show a related result: it is easy to produce images that are completely unrecognizable to humans, but that state-of-the-art DNNs believe to be recognizable objects with 99.99% confidence (e.g. labeling with certainty that white noise static is a lion). Specifically, we take convolutional neural networks trained to perform well on either the ImageNet or MNIST datasets and then find images with evolutionary algorithms or gradient ascent that DNNs label with high confidence as belonging to each dataset class. It is possible to produce images totally unrecognizable to human eyes that DNNs believe with near certainty are familiar objects, which we call "fooling images" (more generally, fooling examples). Our results shed light on interesting differences between human vision and current DNNs, and raise questions about the generality of DNN computer vision.
Deep Neural Networks are Easily Fooled: High Confidence Predictions for Unrecognizable Images
2,014
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1412.1897v4
Title Deep Neural Networks Easily Fooled High Confidence Predictions Unrecognizable Images Summary Deep neural network DNNs recently achieving stateoftheart performance variety patternrecognition task notably visual classification problem Given DNNs able classify object image nearhumanlevel performance question naturally arise difference remain computer human vision recent study revealed changing image eg lion way imperceptible human cause DNN label image something else entirely eg mislabeling lion library show related result easy produce image completely unrecognizable human stateoftheart DNNs believe recognizable object 9999 confidence eg labeling certainty white noise static lion Specifically take convolutional neural network trained perform well either ImageNet MNIST datasets find image evolutionary algorithm gradient ascent DNNs label high confidence belonging dataset class possible produce image totally unrecognizable human eye DNNs believe near certainty familiar object call fooling image generally fooling example result shed light interesting difference human vision current DNNs raise question generality DNN computer vision Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.010116065852344036, 0.09094808995723724, -0.03562874346971512, 0.05571739003062248, -0.002176515059545636, 0.0061898017302155495, 0.055231500416994095, -0.015633421018719673, -0.032679539173841476, -0.002561143832281232, -0.01845097541809082, 0.036392152309417725, 0.026111774146556854, 0.05467673018574715, 0.050291649997234344, -0.039153728634119034, 0.04569327458739281, 0.02811971679329872, -0.02883998304605484, -0.04123438894748688, -0.011443031951785088, -0.0542345829308033, 0.03187256306409836, 0.025127768516540527, -0.015686778351664543, -0.023402662947773933, 0.011830435134470463, 0.009620263241231441, 0.016937891021370888, 0.012645609676837921, 0.04882112145423889, 0.0017707700608298182, -0.014188781380653381, 0.11003582179546356, 2.204969177910243e-06, -0.019569003954529762, -0.003032691078260541, -0.022270411252975464, 0.009253187105059624, 0.008966459892690182, 0.00920845940709114, 0.0076285903342068195, -0.023198898881673813, -0.00382039207033813, -0.014913490042090416, -0.042759429663419724, 0.023311935365200043, 0.09578551352024078, 0.008026343770325184, 0.04950308799743652, 0.01271272823214531, -0.03032967820763588, 0.040545616298913956, -0.006328115239739418, 0.012298060581088066, -0.030133016407489777, 0.0034877979196608067, -0.01966508850455284, -0.07093023508787155, -0.04178881272673607, -0.004476655274629593, 0.03271067142486572, 0.020288271829485893, 0.00017009954899549484, -0.0032733858097344637, 0.02808401733636856, -0.027378182858228683, -0.04544065520167351, 0.0027853986248373985, 0.04315114766359329, -0.11358083784580231, 0.01574462279677391, -0.03251698985695839, 0.0029123343992978334, -0.008434469811618328, 0.010299228131771088, 0.006535867229104042, 0.02249239943921566, 0.010512236505746841, 0.015813829377293587, -0.08053796738386154, 0.011575255542993546, 0.04333587735891342, 0.03262808546423912, -0.02655261568725109, -0.034580767154693604, 0.008393226191401482, 0.03172214701771736, 0.0032895714975893497, -0.017842089757323265, 0.006342036183923483, -0.06192048639059067, 0.006158214993774891, -0.00679762102663517, -0.03935784101486206, -0.009172487072646618, -0.06063351035118103, -0.0330016054213047, 0.026468170806765556, -0.024946456775069237, 0.04445986822247505, -0.02962196245789528, -0.08243653923273087, 0.009675406850874424, -0.06716516613960266, 0.0708208903670311, -0.06981564313173294, 0.08461940288543701, -0.011798426508903503, 0.014809220097959042, -0.022064534947276115, 0.03222231939435005, 0.006412616930902004, -0.014076446183025837, 0.022399159148335457, -0.02970210090279579, -0.062314048409461975, -0.03766273334622383, -0.05121258646249771, 0.024255666881799698, -0.03108055144548416, 0.07292699068784714, -0.039476342499256134, 0.003339469898492098, -0.004917691927403212, -0.0004998862859793007, 0.05752142518758774, 0.016342822462320328, 0.024684129282832146, -0.05474833399057388, 0.02094285748898983, 0.013366488739848137, -0.02125929296016693, 0.020515283569693565, 0.026197828352451324, 0.06297256052494049, -0.020681053400039673, -0.02096073143184185, -0.03156565874814987, 0.017797593027353287, -0.04940326139330864, -0.007529649417847395, 0.04017043858766556, -0.05788983404636383, -0.053435929119586945, -0.06697410345077515, 0.0022229922469705343, -0.03795076906681061, 0.001433110679499805, -0.013836984522640705, -0.058259110897779465, 0.0816163644194603, -0.06737025827169418, -0.035203512758016586, 0.07252014428377151, 0.02501526102423668, -0.004561559297144413, 0.011475788429379463, 0.008457953110337257, 0.05103079974651337, 0.025824427604675293, -0.007801966741681099, 0.04322994127869606, -0.026613105088472366, -0.0017594220116734505, -0.0034682301338762045, -0.02209225296974182, -0.045399270951747894, -0.013665950857102871, 0.04128706455230713, 0.005769809707999229, 0.023201506584882736, 0.01941619999706745, -0.05514718219637871, 0.0686606839299202, -0.0015045052859932184, 0.02301497757434845, 0.029301024973392487, -0.005022821947932243, -0.008209547959268093, -0.0013122673844918609, 0.03275616466999054, -0.053856395184993744, 0.010863003320991993, -0.05848662927746773, -0.005668640602380037, -0.04217230901122093, 0.018003830686211586, -0.03188476338982582, -0.04914047196507454, 0.010658236220479012, -0.043823741376399994, -0.035800982266664505, 0.01267804205417633, 0.048303574323654175, 0.02313990145921707, -0.029722843319177628, -0.07494660466909409, 0.005543460603803396, 0.04129885137081146, -0.028791021555662155, -0.10434471815824509, 0.047642000019550323, -0.010056184604763985, -0.02275952324271202, 0.00020240033336449414, 0.013791723176836967, -0.010077601298689842, -0.005919238086789846, -0.0015437675174325705, -0.015782061964273453, 0.03547513484954834, 0.03432139754295349, -0.0027236565947532654, -0.013874279335141182, -0.03779557719826698, 0.0141920056194067, 0.02747342921793461, -0.01861182413995266, 0.014241845346987247, 0.024309517815709114, 0.004210137762129307, -0.019145166501402855, 0.031512901186943054, 0.01904945820569992, 0.023183953016996384, 0.023477576673030853, 0.029954154044389725, 0.022186871618032455, 0.0026373518630862236, 0.009822898544371128, -0.0037720222026109695, 0.03333032503724098, -0.015830647200345993, -0.04010513052344322, -0.04903057962656021, 0.015536852180957794, -0.0107752475887537, 0.008917205967009068, -0.10088779032230377, -0.011976655572652817, 0.0500934012234211, -0.041550952941179276, -0.008671136572957039, 0.053372398018836975, -0.005615568719804287, -0.03348742425441742, -0.02378481812775135, 0.0039824252016842365, -0.017149562016129494, 0.050506241619586945, 0.01029908750206232, 0.03324751555919647, 0.003324950812384486, -0.015910575166344643, -0.03293053060770035, -0.014502380974590778, 0.04805576801300049, -0.03635738790035248, -0.0220954492688179, 0.0028991689905524254, -0.013016732409596443, 0.0002797792840283364, -0.050303708761930466, 0.03775178641080856, 0.0023421149235218763, 0.0187614094465971, 0.026206061244010925, -0.013194993138313293, -0.034849077463150024, -0.05473558232188225, -0.003454534336924553, -0.04964907839894295, 0.020523536950349808, -0.01894195005297661, -0.03578748553991318, 0.09569696336984634, 0.0159811582416296, -0.007117995526641607, 0.031044496223330498, 0.011877886950969696, -0.02735619805753231, -0.009897144511342049, -0.026617687195539474, 0.025887681171298027, 0.05954970419406891, 0.0013055925955995917, -0.024493364617228508, -0.036569684743881226, 0.008592232130467892, 0.01056455634534359, 0.05778229236602783, -0.001035683904774487, -0.049784284085035324, 0.008570197969675064, 0.011789596639573574, -0.08402834087610245, 0.06853234767913818, 0.012271128594875336, 0.016534186899662018, 0.0027969300281256437, 0.11857450753450394, 0.002996255410835147, -0.04923682659864426, 0.015369272790849209, -0.061525531113147736, 0.03057808429002762, -0.03449418395757675, -0.0355655737221241, 0.01300338190048933, 0.015113970264792442, -0.027109893038868904, 0.019128721207380295, 0.06018363684415817, 0.0019116455223411322, -0.048218511044979095, -0.03127320110797882, -0.0411306731402874, 0.021681230515241623, 0.04622215777635574, -0.0057097855024039745, -0.05139269307255745, 0.05000126361846924, 0.0008538728579878807, 0.013144957832992077, 0.027422696352005005, -0.038743894547224045, 0.037995584309101105, 0.02077239379286766, 0.036011967808008194, 0.04280449077486992, 0.03488821163773537, -0.016143985092639923, -0.05106247588992119, -0.02128429338335991, 0.0010657643433660269, -0.005644873715937138, 0.026313623413443565, -0.03684834763407707, -0.019849445670843124, -0.019783243536949158, -0.022337257862091064, -0.05774429813027382, -0.01676982454955578, -6.787622987758368e-05, -0.0010264880256727338, 0.004287512507289648, 0.005205333232879639, -0.02890276350080967, -0.020448876544833183, -0.017684517428278923, 0.034115053713321686, 0.0007820138707756996, -0.008791564032435417, -0.014122435823082924, 0.02710851840674877, 0.028626415878534317, -0.009602456353604794, 0.046946655958890915, -0.012059315107762814, 0.008293738588690758, 0.035086896270513535, -0.03595456853508949, 0.024855323135852814, -0.12515729665756226, 0.0019516414031386375, 0.007924214005470276, 0.019923610612750053, 0.0064081959426403046, 0.0027949416544288397, 0.005808093119412661, -0.025950666517019272, -0.0027137286961078644, 0.022565415129065514, -0.029206009581685066, -0.06615104526281357, 0.018224919214844704, 0.0263542328029871, -0.05915696918964386, -0.007322479970753193, 0.0062650819309055805, -0.028224727138876915, -0.021012987941503525, 0.005197303835302591, 0.0046152579598128796, -0.03875785693526268, -0.026164289563894272, 0.01961318962275982, -0.031107135117053986, 0.049637340009212494, 0.012682603672146797, -0.04732298478484154, -0.05636342987418175, 0.025113821029663086, -0.029642704874277115, -0.05088537558913231, 0.04827824607491493, -0.0019141050288453698, 0.04261987656354904, -0.008072338066995144, -0.013166403397917747, 0.03341900184750557, -0.012909850105643272, 0.01022658497095108, -0.04139779508113861, 0.013813293538987637, 0.052735935896635056, 0.012833401560783386, -0.02425008825957775, -0.08199804276227951, 0.020451268181204796, 0.003298590425401926, 0.050791796296834946, 0.028431182727217674, 0.07938051223754883, -0.010917598381638527, -0.021326124668121338, 0.013487405143678188, 0.04756925255060196, -0.022961782291531563, 0.01780460961163044, -0.004469839856028557, -0.03895406052470207, -0.0015771941980347037, -0.06422891467809677, -0.06589057296514511, 0.0024300513323396444, 0.026334501802921295, -0.007601040415465832, 0.02124195545911789, -0.021866096183657646, -0.02306443266570568, -0.007524217013269663, 0.08351252228021622, 0.012834726832807064, -0.013793463818728924, 0.08158567547798157, 0.026368530467152596, -0.035202741622924805, -0.051905471831560135, 0.006140568293631077, -0.042429808527231216, 0.031103497371077538, 0.03647017851471901, -0.07388538867235184, 0.02211340144276619, 0.016661442816257477, -0.024462850764393806, 0.02464725635945797, 0.030470021069049835, 0.030403997749090195, -0.033564262092113495, 0.025006819516420364, 0.03161938861012459, -0.025282496586441994, -0.012852278538048267, -0.01618887670338154, -0.03673664852976799, 0.014781275764107704, 0.03136538714170456, 0.02714255452156067, 0.022115157917141914, 0.0023426294792443514, -0.01958993449807167, -0.07037898153066635, 0.037463247776031494, 0.007996546104550362, 0.0737944170832634, -0.028037918731570244, 0.0470297634601593, -0.037427958101034164, -0.0163690447807312, 0.028801918029785156, 0.004436874762177467, 0.06437867879867554, 0.05081596598029137, -0.09070773422718048, -0.03145840764045715, -0.00633801007643342, 0.0019624298438429832, -0.009498356841504574, 0.10037253797054291, -0.05475000664591789, 0.020944200456142426, 0.003952825907617807, 0.0390215627849102, 0.06340818852186203, 0.031799811869859695, -0.03253660351037979, -0.03799227252602577, 0.05284600704908371, 0.03366602584719658, 0.003942353185266256, -0.0007179718231782317, 0.024450626224279404, -0.029943281784653664, -0.028577443212270737, 0.005121502559632063, 0.04908732697367668, 0.05115683004260063, -0.030081458389759064, 0.0054433527402579784, -0.00645592762157321, 0.03918936848640442, 0.018518542870879173, 0.04298999533057213, 0.028040779754519463, 0.016682730987668037, 0.022639421746134758, -0.02040896564722061, -0.04073213413357735, 0.011452751234173775, -0.016972020268440247, -0.05423455312848091, -0.05083868280053139, 0.06918475031852722, 0.06542126089334488, -0.016244150698184967, -0.051807381212711334, 0.020174210891127586, -0.01157933659851551, -0.033388081938028336, -0.003986121155321598, 0.006102795712649822, 0.018011894077062607, 0.02591366320848465, -0.006590257398784161, 5.635517300106585e-05, -0.006428436376154423, 0.03254987671971321, 0.016880201175808907, -0.0011375838657841086, -0.04604693874716759, -0.02551129460334778, -0.020401298999786377, 0.016442829743027687, 0.04360898956656456, 0.030386608093976974, -0.006393470801413059, -0.008504632860422134, 0.006438562646508217, -0.060207389295101166, -0.006667059846222401, 0.03784920275211334, 0.07537609338760376, 0.02465399168431759, -0.02754734456539154, 0.030314255505800247, 0.047855909913778305, -0.024589458480477333, -0.005149947479367256, 0.016831280663609505, 0.018624359741806984, -0.0004924462991766632, -0.020770035684108734, -6.189564034886816e-33, 0.050226807594299316, -0.0233142152428627, -0.046434346586465836, -0.048378121107816696, 0.016499662771821022, 0.0422605499625206, -0.008205750957131386, -0.02359386533498764, -0.054431892931461334, 0.04673929139971733, -0.029867416247725487, 0.03147542476654053, 0.0037865531630814075, 0.04618525132536888, -0.026157347485423088, -0.03190188482403755, 0.007931454107165337, -0.036044422537088394, 0.009914228692650795, -0.01897343434393406, 0.01014022994786501, 0.03150143846869469, 0.03114013373851776, -0.1111297458410263, -0.001957730855792761, 0.014897414483129978, -0.019123729318380356, -0.017440758645534515, -0.03482326492667198, -0.013113461434841156, -0.006674117874354124, 0.029440078884363174, 0.0029831002466380596, -0.01063019409775734, -0.03199712932109833, -0.04390512779355049, -0.00867175217717886, 0.02580282650887966, -0.07553716003894806, 0.029762694612145424, -0.05700615793466568, -0.007687279023230076, 0.09318911284208298, -0.040614236146211624, -0.03262564167380333, 0.009754158556461334, 0.054325249046087265, -0.039755892008543015, -0.009236251935362816, -0.015615854412317276, -0.014634564518928528, 0.005617114249616861, 0.004626414272934198, -0.008114801719784737, -0.012276758439838886, -0.00888469535857439, -0.010049613192677498, 0.02253490313887596, -0.09899568557739258, 0.003979240544140339, 0.018918482586741447, -0.018285585567355156, 0.05361758545041084, 0.04121904447674751, -0.0013646978186443448, 0.0588766448199749, 0.12105050683021545, 0.012153503485023975, 0.009436140768229961, -0.06363382190465927, 0.011483635753393173, 0.04692011699080467, 0.1137063279747963, 0.03587004169821739, 0.07535185664892197, -0.06486046314239502, -0.05782247707247734, 0.004835010971873999, -0.022768719121813774, -0.02648628130555153, -0.01876215636730194, 0.037993524223566055, -0.014616730622947216, -0.007253002375364304, 0.009998921304941177, -0.0491737499833107, -0.026158394291996956, 0.030930694192647934, 0.00405479408800602, -0.024318277835845947, 0.005310039967298508, 0.05523211136460304, -0.019016418606042862, -0.0783504843711853, 0.029094858095049858, -0.061029113829135895, 0.05278247222304344, 0.011035440489649773, 0.03194580227136612, 0.006623219233006239, -0.011066491715610027, -0.03883369266986847, 0.028565678745508194, 0.046104829758405685, 0.029896346852183342, 0.010044539347290993, 0.06340133398771286, 0.012165640480816364, 0.010668114759027958, 0.01180307473987341, -0.017428521066904068, -0.014180167578160763, 0.037525858730077744, 0.00344448653049767, 0.02426464483141899, -0.05522312968969345, 0.00874327588826418, -0.035342611372470856, 0.021301791071891785, 0.029798604547977448, -0.031179431825876236, 0.04302821308374405, -0.017487242817878723, 0.026471653953194618, -0.06432516127824783, -0.026669906452298164, -0.017581503838300705, 0.015195589512586594, 0.01736535131931305, -0.0718710869550705, -0.018018824979662895, 0.006072206888347864, 2.8987980726924434e-07, -0.04911024868488312, -0.014187040738761425, -0.02223839983344078, -0.03809870406985283, 0.03566311299800873, 0.05696641281247139, -0.013067066669464111, 0.013456624001264572, -0.0173072200268507, -0.014931516721844673, 0.016777481883764267, -0.023026900365948677, 0.0013437584275379777, -0.02177693322300911, -0.006198139861226082, -0.018549498170614243, 0.03509318456053734, 0.03859452158212662, -0.006736231502145529, 0.018869364634156227, 0.02151823230087757, 0.07268251478672028, 0.013671391643583775, -0.04492553323507309, 0.0661008432507515, -0.06334109604358673, -0.015380606055259705, 0.000460202107205987, 0.06440151482820511, -0.020283004269003868, 0.051659490913152695, 0.044655680656433105, -0.015500667504966259, 0.02874060347676277, -0.008756703697144985, -0.01174013502895832, 0.038366686552762985, -0.0341549888253212, -0.0317327119410038, 0.010220114141702652, -0.03260170668363571, 0.01814480498433113, 0.04413340985774994, -0.035993874073028564, 0.052087392657995224, -0.039810024201869965, -0.05125119537115097, -0.04056059941649437, -0.03215125575661659, -0.01087997667491436, 0.050056926906108856, -0.008239234797656536, 0.006603703834116459, 0.03209357336163521, -0.027829017490148544, -0.004383033607155085, -0.01543445885181427, -0.032007671892642975, 0.03833887726068497, -0.0021593919955193996, -0.050969384610652924, 0.00015614330186508596, -0.028672069311141968, 0.006805017590522766, 0.08563385158777237, 0.006406518165022135, -0.05119423195719719, 2.294842775180983e-34, -0.0112550538033247, 0.003447562688961625, 0.013407060876488686, -0.05460427701473236, -0.0027770891319960356, 0.013603982515633106, 0.05014849826693535, -0.03428126499056816, 0.005387657321989536, 0.021257035434246063, -0.035362936556339264]
672
672
['Xinyu Wu', 'Vishal Saxena', 'Kehan Zhu']
1506.01072v2
A neuromorphic chip that combines CMOS analog spiking neurons and memristive synapses offers a promising solution to brain-inspired computing, as it can provide massive neural network parallelism and density. Previous hybrid analog CMOS-memristor approaches required extensive CMOS circuitry for training, and thus eliminated most of the density advantages gained by the adoption of memristor synapses. Further, they used different waveforms for pre and post-synaptic spikes that added undesirable circuit overhead. Here we describe a hardware architecture that can feature a large number of memristor synapses to learn real-world patterns. We present a versatile CMOS neuron that combines integrate-and-fire behavior, drives passive memristors and implements competitive learning in a compact circuit module, and enables in-situ plasticity in the memristor synapses. We demonstrate handwritten-digits recognition using the proposed architecture using transistor-level circuit simulations. As the described neuromorphic architecture is homogeneous, it realizes a fundamental building block for large-scale energy-efficient brain-inspired silicon chips that could lead to next-generation cognitive computing.
Homogeneous Spiking Neuromorphic System for Real-World Pattern Recognition
2,015
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1506.01072v2
Title Homogeneous Spiking Neuromorphic System RealWorld Pattern Recognition Summary neuromorphic chip combine CMOS analog spiking neuron memristive synapsis offer promising solution braininspired computing provide massive neural network parallelism density Previous hybrid analog CMOSmemristor approach required extensive CMOS circuitry training thus eliminated density advantage gained adoption memristor synapsis used different waveform pre postsynaptic spike added undesirable circuit overhead describe hardware architecture feature large number memristor synapsis learn realworld pattern present versatile CMOS neuron combine integrateandfire behavior drive passive memristors implement competitive learning compact circuit module enables insitu plasticity memristor synapsis demonstrate handwrittendigits recognition using proposed architecture using transistorlevel circuit simulation described neuromorphic architecture homogeneous realizes fundamental building block largescale energyefficient braininspired silicon chip could lead nextgeneration cognitive computing Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.053706616163253784, -0.03694482147693634, -0.052267879247665405, 0.05803336948156357, 0.012484094128012657, 0.00016219884855672717, 0.010011780075728893, -0.00529831787571311, 0.0475807823240757, -0.001519152894616127, -0.042839165776968, 0.001372783095575869, -0.004398516844958067, 0.05477315932512283, 0.03150581941008568, 0.01080513559281826, 0.09416055679321289, 0.02448844164609909, -0.02356087416410446, -0.06233393773436546, 0.041953183710575104, -0.08414249867200851, -0.027044985443353653, 0.006799532100558281, 0.007331642787903547, 0.04114565998315811, -0.018109600991010666, -0.044691961258649826, 0.020376941189169884, -0.020534338429570198, 0.0031771324574947357, -0.029723167419433594, -0.012623201124370098, 0.03714907914400101, 1.5033415365905967e-06, 0.015113407745957375, 0.030193299055099487, 0.0008668058435432613, -0.004480050411075354, -0.05371036380529404, -0.03398337587714195, 0.0014488265151157975, -0.06478288769721985, -0.025741104036569595, 0.014615743421018124, -0.01980656571686268, 0.1141599491238594, -0.0011564483866095543, -0.009077684953808784, 0.031488243490457535, -0.005309093743562698, -0.0514911524951458, 0.08037624508142471, 0.024654490873217583, 0.06750804930925369, 0.053262896835803986, -0.02142886258661747, -0.018845420330762863, 0.0512053519487381, -0.035778701305389404, -0.03180716186761856, 0.00940653495490551, 0.019973769783973694, 0.04287593066692352, 0.04890083894133568, 0.006147945299744606, -0.00815476942807436, 0.04662419483065605, -0.0016382288886234164, -0.004669142421334982, -0.023086706176400185, 0.01666751690208912, 0.016732612624764442, 0.0171152725815773, -0.055454399436712265, -0.04266015812754631, 0.016892854124307632, -0.0052704778499901295, -0.025809796527028084, 0.01625768281519413, -0.009175203740596771, -0.03173390030860901, 0.05404321476817131, 0.011347448453307152, 0.031369443982839584, 0.02896365337073803, -0.011949826031923294, 0.008701764978468418, 0.013636871241033077, -0.018453918397426605, 6.280033994698897e-05, 0.05721817910671234, 0.03379896655678749, 0.01720389351248741, -0.02045370824635029, -0.011674076318740845, -0.0554421991109848, -0.06893043220043182, -0.024987345561385155, -0.06972053647041321, 0.029819415882229805, 0.005837779026478529, 0.012094246223568916, -0.0043426211923360825, -0.028356697410345078, 0.014464061707258224, -0.021290283650159836, 0.0496315062046051, -0.03312251344323158, 0.025558654218912125, -0.0453086718916893, 0.016842912882566452, 0.023017730563879013, 0.07578963041305542, 0.07499474287033081, -0.04945771023631096, -0.07638947665691376, 0.029781153425574303, -0.012527530081570148, 0.003370176302269101, -0.0422128401696682, -0.02846221998333931, 0.04600895568728447, -0.006792646832764149, -0.043969642370939255, -0.01559775322675705, 0.05532566085457802, -0.013596787117421627, 0.0027710464783012867, 0.002255416242405772, -0.008621320128440857, -0.005423544906079769, 0.008064353838562965, 0.050124816596508026, 0.0048220534808933735, 0.06702964007854462, -0.02513398602604866, -0.04372785612940788, -0.11020850390195847, 0.1039569079875946, 0.029325976967811584, 0.05609789863228798, 0.006625325419008732, -0.03304087370634079, 0.022638753056526184, 0.012758713215589523, -0.04798115789890289, -0.04457051679491997, 0.03240196779370308, 0.004264829680323601, 0.0020165126770734787, 0.08447383344173431, -0.009847927838563919, -0.07071180641651154, 0.08099982887506485, -0.04460635408759117, -0.05367568880319595, 0.05267301946878433, 0.062476810067892075, 0.018643857911229134, 0.026235193014144897, 0.005282768048346043, -0.013548961840569973, -0.031711336225271225, 0.015516330488026142, -0.04359143599867821, -0.011379036121070385, -0.08498116582632065, 0.014790826477110386, 0.018631091341376305, 0.02414037473499775, 0.02681177854537964, -0.0010925345122814178, -0.0018425079761072993, 0.04996810108423233, 0.02900157868862152, -0.02383325807750225, 0.006181714590638876, -0.011672679334878922, -0.04943419247865677, 0.005608971696346998, -0.037593234330415726, -0.017191043123602867, 0.08124836534261703, -0.01601647399365902, -0.025127125903964043, -0.031336087733507156, -0.0014147383626550436, -0.05222421884536743, -0.005984238348901272, 0.01799422688782215, -0.032474108040332794, 0.0003221849910914898, 0.02736188843846321, 0.00751912547275424, -0.04490659758448601, 0.02228393405675888, 0.025893397629261017, -0.013821287080645561, 0.05351731553673744, -0.007452990394085646, -0.04536283016204834, 0.03170892968773842, -0.014264680445194244, -0.006272368133068085, -0.04511045664548874, 0.011257314123213291, 0.039765458554029465, -0.08618545532226562, 0.016626494005322456, -0.03760036826133728, 0.005845421925187111, 0.024136701598763466, -0.041102368384599686, 0.01489063911139965, 0.003153142984956503, 0.020939325913786888, 0.03486262634396553, 0.014342820271849632, 0.0061003766022622585, 0.012407162226736546, 0.10282028466463089, -0.024554140865802765, -0.039872825145721436, -0.03325505182147026, 0.029083888977766037, 0.042853500694036484, -0.00911287497729063, 0.028548525646328926, -0.03725668787956238, 0.01743066869676113, -0.00045738156768493354, -0.007621242199093103, -0.07123827934265137, 0.01212479081004858, -0.007523156702518463, -0.07270904630422592, 0.004960145801305771, 0.0018349888268858194, -0.017236938700079918, 0.052357979118824005, 0.002491024788469076, 0.01747056469321251, -0.05269685015082359, 0.011610623449087143, -0.023902952671051025, 0.03656424209475517, -0.038108620792627335, 0.042041316628456116, 0.03358803316950798, 0.003487845417112112, 0.0036772668827325106, 0.03326333686709404, 0.0059685795567929745, 0.002769047860056162, -0.014106172136962414, 0.026931259781122208, -0.014595694839954376, -0.01757333241403103, -0.04269547387957573, -0.016686653718352318, -0.016338923946022987, 0.0077524445950984955, -0.05319048836827278, -0.05211315304040909, -0.01196901872754097, -0.013374729081988335, -0.012922451831400394, 0.003780429484322667, 0.02660357393324375, -0.002715060953050852, -0.016455411911010742, 0.002673419425264001, 0.04074835032224655, 0.022520020604133606, -0.026310626417398453, 0.06669304519891739, -0.02917897142469883, -0.006726492661982775, 0.03537729009985924, 0.02768913097679615, 0.03669417276978493, 0.005808501038700342, -0.040190063416957855, -0.013042458333075047, 0.006185117177665234, -0.021395692601799965, -0.003580060787498951, -0.017388883978128433, 0.022067787125706673, 0.028365205973386765, 0.041387930512428284, -0.0144241563975811, 0.001527917105704546, 0.028904758393764496, 0.008650227449834347, -0.02642410434782505, 0.0760410875082016, 0.043935831636190414, 0.010970521718263626, 0.012040210887789726, 0.008932763710618019, 0.06939004361629486, -0.0028725166339427233, 0.028137998655438423, 0.09985697269439697, 0.016976438462734222, 0.04987473040819168, -0.05316278710961342, 0.01251510065048933, 0.023594869300723076, 0.028971722349524498, -0.01693386770784855, 0.00015409612387884408, 0.00395757332444191, 0.004759395029395819, -2.9088589144521393e-05, 0.005855801049619913, -0.008875793777406216, -0.03642673045396805, -0.024859817698597908, -0.025853466242551804, 0.021333858370780945, 0.03624238446354866, 0.03490173816680908, -0.0019430129323154688, -0.0008924083667807281, 0.007654292043298483, -0.007300075143575668, 0.05459105968475342, 0.04818565025925636, -0.02276742272078991, 0.034264396876096725, 0.03252601623535156, -0.029590491205453873, -0.026258883997797966, 0.0029120505787432194, 0.008183189667761326, -0.010766270570456982, -0.011035112664103508, -0.02698563225567341, -0.012140204198658466, -0.012072397395968437, 0.04863062873482704, -0.02153109759092331, -0.011070171371102333, 0.047070395201444626, -0.03590972721576691, -0.01330579724162817, -0.007800462655723095, 0.06617553532123566, 0.01841430738568306, -0.0037843480240553617, -0.012464107014238834, -0.06874251365661621, 0.024460017681121826, 0.004600707441568375, -0.013706537894904613, 0.025311386212706566, 0.02212529629468918, 0.016261698678135872, 0.011223986744880676, 0.03383593633770943, -0.007131360471248627, -0.10323432832956314, 0.006528647616505623, -0.010406237095594406, 0.03446093201637268, 0.0013476626481860876, -0.02359456941485405, -0.008136948570609093, -0.0010445424122735858, 0.021484380587935448, 0.0062205553986132145, -0.034142933785915375, -0.05698623135685921, -0.04353461414575577, 0.00725583266466856, -0.04519357159733772, -0.007925949059426785, 0.022669024765491486, 0.014805653132498264, -0.0023258686996996403, -0.03499334678053856, -0.02062942460179329, -0.020911715924739838, 0.005852990318089724, -0.08332459628582001, -0.017861351370811462, 0.009780692867934704, 0.01712489314377308, -0.017908789217472076, 0.03144468739628792, 0.006073546130210161, -0.017010565847158432, 0.014445564709603786, 0.004471770022064447, 0.005371041130274534, -0.0002438157971482724, -0.007211257703602314, -0.03957870975136757, -0.04015205800533295, 0.029792459681630135, 0.01332785002887249, -0.019417965784668922, 0.017081277444958687, 0.004200075287371874, -0.06969897449016571, -0.03302349895238876, -0.02628965675830841, 0.00851907767355442, -0.016270793974399567, 0.017812354490160942, -0.02548021450638771, -0.03221030905842781, 0.04373422637581825, -0.06997958570718765, -0.0320664644241333, 0.011598486453294754, 0.014532104134559631, -0.014006677083671093, -0.0337924100458622, 0.020331338047981262, -0.05098896101117134, 0.007599917706102133, 0.012649549171328545, -0.007450710516422987, -0.017587006092071533, -0.023679643869400024, -0.018471892923116684, -0.02740524336695671, -0.03897799924015999, 0.007807011716067791, -0.0207816231995821, -0.0792723074555397, 0.005653302650898695, 0.0007528330897912383, 0.01041153259575367, -0.037432026118040085, 0.008491366170346737, -0.02890009991824627, -0.04027857258915901, 0.048844605684280396, 0.011478427797555923, -0.019185233861207962, 0.09720756113529205, -0.016774168238043785, 0.005680927541106939, -0.018405761569738388, 0.0008393671596422791, -0.013071505352854729, -0.10759022831916809, -0.012578904628753662, 0.033088568598032, -0.041347503662109375, 0.0025960246566683054, -0.018594438210129738, -0.054370149970054626, -0.02613845281302929, 0.019787896424531937, 0.0205958541482687, -0.006819215137511492, -0.002253165701404214, 0.07134690135717392, 0.03321327269077301, 0.051560577005147934, 0.038740374147892, 0.025460906326770782, 0.027045341208577156, 0.027188828215003014, -0.004818580579012632, -0.023819128051400185, 0.022466639056801796, 0.04372023791074753, 0.05185231193900108, 0.018297335132956505, -0.03345588967204094, -0.07649461179971695, 0.02506563812494278, 0.0030891932547092438, 0.019240286201238632, 0.04482869431376457, 0.0634249597787857, 0.08994211256504059, -0.03783312439918518, 0.025640929117798805, 0.020818395540118217, 0.08533628284931183, -0.035715196281671524, -0.03403780981898308, 0.006450791377574205, -0.02466720901429653, 0.005751030519604683, -0.08857420086860657, 0.09493566304445267, -0.03622205927968025, 0.03714604675769806, 0.011942231096327305, 0.0062213498167693615, 0.06978222727775574, -0.06047016754746437, -0.016770632937550545, -0.028706271201372147, 0.05155480280518532, -0.019618993625044823, 0.050140246748924255, -0.04729621857404709, 0.049972038716077805, 0.0037948840763419867, -0.03567592054605484, -0.05021904036402702, 0.04838184639811516, 0.013780917972326279, -0.04880521446466446, 0.013604214414954185, 0.020969795063138008, 0.04066600650548935, 0.0264785997569561, -0.010695596225559711, -0.011762457899749279, -0.003898878348991275, -0.029414894059300423, 0.019487809389829636, 0.010954339988529682, 0.027125580236315727, 0.01914815418422222, 0.033809028565883636, 0.0437370128929615, -0.04861605539917946, -0.009323750622570515, -0.03394648805260658, -0.01888205111026764, 0.04629656672477722, 0.025296108797192574, 0.00837950874119997, 0.005017702467739582, -0.025225041434168816, 0.00015974162670318037, 0.0044143288396298885, -0.04248534142971039, 0.020459985360503197, 0.028530871495604515, 0.10112183541059494, 0.014701100997626781, 0.029967017471790314, -0.04131833091378212, 0.015374956652522087, -0.01570042036473751, 0.03275055065751076, -0.03135870024561882, 0.030091147869825363, 0.00283877388574183, 0.03537963703274727, -0.0010431153932586312, -0.005399146117269993, -4.643428601068584e-33, -0.030355632305145264, 0.04268786683678627, 0.048813432455062866, 0.03608689457178116, 0.00019655164214782417, -0.0015498544089496136, 0.006945990491658449, 0.026152852922677994, -0.011681738309562206, -0.09033442288637161, -0.06479325890541077, -0.005479215178638697, 0.019639983773231506, 0.021839838474988937, 0.05360834300518036, -0.022282863035798073, -0.03875139728188515, -0.005597258452326059, 0.07534672319889069, -0.009138068184256554, 0.05557173863053322, -0.02826528251171112, 0.055650047957897186, -0.0424044206738472, -0.048805609345436096, 0.027881696820259094, 0.0114930784329772, -0.06681812554597855, -0.007227927912026644, -0.01553348172456026, -0.07022865861654282, 0.030756525695323944, -0.0024319582153111696, 0.016479846090078354, 0.01223367266356945, -0.0011102334829047322, -0.0498913899064064, 0.02861906588077545, -0.0128293726593256, -0.03348397836089134, -0.010901863686740398, -0.043715499341487885, 0.05615096166729927, -0.00223349966108799, -0.06910646706819534, 0.028140507638454437, 0.003253683215007186, -0.06483282148838043, 0.030327454209327698, -0.002482788171619177, 0.02813972719013691, -0.0015091447858139873, 0.03927377238869667, 0.039242472499608994, -0.011405052617192268, -0.040172819048166275, -0.07565177232027054, 0.03126932308077812, -0.09313306212425232, 0.037908077239990234, -0.03177173063158989, 0.07871165126562119, -0.024842051789164543, 0.053492043167352676, 0.05884493514895439, 0.006346265319734812, 0.03720210865139961, 0.025314701721072197, 0.03140239417552948, 0.02961917407810688, 0.011044847778975964, 0.0032515176571905613, 0.03874890133738518, 0.015908952802419662, 0.08535654842853546, -0.07830642908811569, 0.009327257983386517, 0.040067218244075775, 0.0811060220003128, 0.016161875799298286, 0.028801636770367622, 0.012071159668266773, -0.09069566428661346, -0.013799319043755531, 0.042580440640449524, 0.0438532680273056, -0.024353351444005966, -0.04101796820759773, -0.01500069722533226, -0.019834740087389946, -0.004488011356443167, 0.004177306313067675, -0.022468753159046173, -0.010380889289081097, 0.059095460921525955, -0.0371207669377327, 0.05982675030827522, 0.007772726938128471, 0.01610071025788784, -0.02178151160478592, -0.0378154031932354, -0.06050524488091469, -0.04693349450826645, -0.015301242470741272, -0.04394668713212013, 0.031103452667593956, -0.02086750604212284, 0.07440415769815445, 0.008193046785891056, -0.01044290978461504, -0.008679903112351894, -0.043124664574861526, 0.03241308405995369, 0.013261020183563232, -0.03548566251993179, -0.026028702035546303, -0.009797115810215473, 0.013823144137859344, -0.06538975238800049, -0.004769872408360243, -0.011784846894443035, 0.03249428793787956, -0.0099373459815979, 0.06932378560304642, 0.008336232043802738, 0.009570470079779625, -0.03802576661109924, 0.04175847768783569, -0.05980939790606499, -0.10082834959030151, 0.01859552040696144, 0.007155043072998524, 2.3324302844685008e-07, -0.06824122369289398, -0.03441906347870827, -0.006890350021421909, -0.03085811622440815, 0.04380356892943382, -0.005948210135102272, 0.027379898354411125, -0.009426302276551723, -0.019827382639050484, -0.04380085691809654, 0.026107829064130783, 0.016292132437229156, -0.00860225036740303, 0.022816799581050873, -0.04273489490151405, -0.026651006191968918, 0.019826281815767288, 0.0564705990254879, 0.02675342559814453, 0.019451048225164413, 0.014459164813160896, 0.015817051753401756, 0.03975263610482216, -0.018235299736261368, 0.016791580244898796, -2.6097243335243547e-06, 0.04784711077809334, 0.02336994744837284, 0.04227995127439499, -0.046067774295806885, -0.04701584577560425, -0.07194235175848007, -0.04354438558220863, 0.02814757078886032, 0.03337358683347702, -0.010227862745523453, -0.03671993687748909, -0.02479865960776806, -0.007610519882291555, -0.01617281511425972, 0.018249521031975746, 0.009344463236629963, -0.03345758467912674, -0.015305508859455585, 0.040543343871831894, -0.029860667884349823, -0.030030041933059692, -0.059434618800878525, 0.001713354024104774, -0.040391940623521805, 0.021610042080283165, -0.006805754732340574, -0.00018805517174769193, -0.0441780723631382, -0.03935186192393303, -0.05274335294961929, 0.03092268854379654, 0.0020519534591585398, 0.032887328416109085, 0.029111549258232117, -0.012638364918529987, 0.030309123918414116, -0.06860867887735367, -0.000169824663316831, 0.041066985577344894, 0.01703663542866707, -0.030410081148147583, 1.392714571800337e-34, 0.014033744111657143, -0.0055941017344594, -0.00904729962348938, -0.006109609268605709, -0.02586047723889351, 0.014438283629715443, 0.031194373965263367, -0.06760088354349136, -0.0355510450899601, 0.010395437479019165, -0.048826590180397034]
673
673
['Ven Jyn Kok', 'Mei Kuan Lim', 'Chee Seng Chan']
1511.06586v1
Although the traits emerged in a mass gathering are often non-deliberative, the act of mass impulse may lead to irre- vocable crowd disasters. The two-fold increase of carnage in crowd since the past two decades has spurred significant advances in the field of computer vision, towards effective and proactive crowd surveillance. Computer vision stud- ies related to crowd are observed to resonate with the understanding of the emergent behavior in physics (complex systems) and biology (animal swarm). These studies, which are inspired by biology and physics, share surprisingly common insights, and interesting contradictions. However, this aspect of discussion has not been fully explored. Therefore, this survey provides the readers with a review of the state-of-the-art methods in crowd behavior analysis from the physics and biologically inspired perspectives. We provide insights and comprehensive discussions for a broader understanding of the underlying prospect of blending physics and biology studies in computer vision.
Crowd Behavior Analysis: A Review where Physics meets Biology
2,015
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1511.06586v1
Title Crowd Behavior Analysis Review Physics meet Biology Summary Although trait emerged mass gathering often nondeliberative act mass impulse may lead irre vocable crowd disaster twofold increase carnage crowd since past two decade spurred significant advance field computer vision towards effective proactive crowd surveillance Computer vision stud y related crowd observed resonate understanding emergent behavior physic complex system biology animal swarm study inspired biology physic share surprisingly common insight interesting contradiction However aspect discussion fully explored Therefore survey provides reader review stateoftheart method crowd behavior analysis physic biologically inspired perspective provide insight comprehensive discussion broader understanding underlying prospect blending physic biology study computer vision Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.002358394907787442, 0.015343783423304558, -0.02958426997065544, -0.014622044749557972, -0.010780510492622852, -0.021123582497239113, -0.0009222599328495562, 0.007528827525675297, -0.02057489939033985, 0.004340232815593481, 0.039204876869916916, 0.007756952196359634, -0.018435323610901833, 0.006776188500225544, 0.06967302411794662, -0.04676717519760132, -0.014992190524935722, -0.014454408548772335, -0.02882702462375164, 0.023137828335165977, 0.03667465224862099, -0.021968502551317215, 0.03130348399281502, 0.015307876281440258, -0.02058524265885353, 0.027323609218001366, -0.02061658538877964, -0.03539487347006798, 0.08710070699453354, -0.0429670475423336, 0.02157978154718876, -0.009887276217341423, 0.0916924774646759, 0.05405465140938759, 2.207316128988168e-06, -0.0243823379278183, 0.005049058236181736, -0.0007026494131423533, 0.02362864464521408, -0.0408320315182209, 0.026001224294304848, -0.021594928577542305, -0.005618381779640913, -0.010214454494416714, -0.009823319502174854, 0.0018162926426157355, -0.010702935978770256, -0.022804543375968933, -0.007075841538608074, 0.022468434646725655, -0.008556135930120945, -0.06179709732532501, 0.018422314897179604, 0.01596737653017044, 0.015296552330255508, 0.030176296830177307, 0.0014159886632114649, -0.044788166880607605, 0.03546157106757164, -0.04259784519672394, -0.01674342341721058, 0.0032874939497560263, -0.03622184321284294, -0.020551234483718872, 0.06651797890663147, 0.027323538437485695, -0.05133264139294624, -0.06507978588342667, -0.023682963103055954, 0.016319718211889267, -0.03615213558077812, -0.018136054277420044, 0.041960250586271286, 0.007989698089659214, -0.015074019320309162, 0.029721083119511604, -0.03360770642757416, -0.0003354548243805766, 0.010169212706387043, -0.04476015642285347, -0.08443313091993332, 0.106744185090065, 0.0063981362618505955, 0.04100367799401283, 0.026742830872535706, -0.04681878909468651, 0.0015276980120688677, 0.03126775845885277, -0.06678875535726547, -0.02580283023416996, -0.027161715552210808, -0.00996986124664545, 0.009228209033608437, 0.05084680765867233, -0.03419807553291321, -0.035490699112415314, 0.040999360382556915, -0.06251832842826843, 0.05082746595144272, -0.06887270510196686, 0.025794923305511475, -0.029406096786260605, 0.05372622609138489, 0.03466964140534401, 0.04111113399267197, -0.0010221496922895312, -0.03773766756057739, -0.018581701442599297, 0.02802322991192341, 0.04650903865695, -0.05195865407586098, 0.04089638590812683, 0.021401118487119675, -0.021479148417711258, 0.02631387487053871, -0.01802043244242668, -0.0021299838554114103, 0.003531449707224965, -0.00466127647086978, -0.07141749560832977, -0.08309551328420639, 0.03434610366821289, 0.07382797449827194, -0.0180189311504364, 0.061235830187797546, -0.003791733179241419, -0.017787080258131027, -0.002576867351308465, 0.007823662832379341, -0.02289881743490696, -2.000739550567232e-05, -0.0076276869513094425, 0.012195750139653683, 0.05120645463466644, -0.04558004438877106, 0.014904085546731949, 0.02527802251279354, 0.010865620337426662, -0.05539487674832344, -0.009157771244645119, 0.02594546228647232, 0.007949375547468662, -0.01930627040565014, -0.05803893879055977, 0.060950908809900284, -0.027277959510684013, -0.02069510705769062, 0.09807667136192322, 0.0205508004873991, -0.004545913077890873, -0.014239956624805927, 0.06201452016830444, -0.055997468531131744, 0.02195347286760807, 0.023510923609137535, 0.01740221120417118, 0.04897669702768326, 0.017968444153666496, 0.013875891454517841, -0.025078317150473595, 0.03545573353767395, -0.018510712310671806, 0.09434490650892258, -0.03641481325030327, 0.013396188616752625, 0.012803674675524235, 0.004504664335399866, 0.00018406769959256053, -0.06564144045114517, -0.038473378866910934, 0.031343720853328705, -0.03505278751254082, -0.005348151549696922, 0.036344461143016815, 0.007231072057038546, 0.041678640991449356, -0.09979882091283798, -0.017245102673768997, -0.049990639090538025, 0.02578580193221569, -0.06486470252275467, -0.01280134916305542, -0.0006260938243940473, 0.05356715992093086, -0.07882861793041229, -0.01574905775487423, -0.003915089648216963, 0.03252397105097771, -0.03475811704993248, -0.00203899503685534, -0.03604444861412048, -0.003909736406058073, -0.00024279204080812633, -0.028734467923641205, -0.011801335960626602, -2.4128426957759075e-05, 0.035344306379556656, -0.0667877122759819, 0.01932767778635025, -0.03625115007162094, -0.002440862590447068, -0.020050501450896263, 0.03605862706899643, -0.020803742110729218, -0.02153395302593708, 0.0017880606465041637, -0.0003987315867561847, -0.02528824843466282, -0.006167246028780937, -0.050435639917850494, -0.010737685486674309, 0.005141844041645527, -0.029122529551386833, -0.0157577283680439, 0.034245721995830536, 0.06731515377759933, 0.01609271578490734, -0.029028967022895813, -0.013385415077209473, 0.011863552033901215, 0.021252945065498352, 0.09367365390062332, -0.029300786554813385, 0.026458682492375374, 0.00871814414858818, 0.05530204996466637, -0.03283816948533058, -0.020471371710300446, 0.048877932131290436, -0.02270565740764141, -0.020466964691877365, -0.005887317005544901, 0.048345956951379776, 0.014012045226991177, 0.012660620734095573, 0.04318780452013016, 0.07965212315320969, 0.04485863819718361, 0.003908989019691944, -0.005622799973934889, -0.04265004023909569, -0.0013332986272871494, 0.010775838978588581, 0.015250122174620628, 0.0026929329615086317, -0.01073088776320219, -0.01974751241505146, 0.0010030883131548762, -0.01570793054997921, -0.009451687335968018, -0.002469640225172043, 0.02403697930276394, 0.014503097161650658, 0.028827590867877007, -0.03429736569523811, -0.012275811284780502, 0.028737714514136314, 0.05359642580151558, 0.0018140067113563418, -0.02771790698170662, -0.06746149808168411, 0.007857117801904678, 0.019577940925955772, 0.016516318544745445, 0.013096518814563751, -0.01853417418897152, 0.047728389501571655, 0.029371218755841255, 0.002832113765180111, -0.02043890208005905, -0.03958766534924507, -0.00022532424191012979, -0.01711229234933853, 0.0054391217418015, 0.021236687898635864, 0.027549108490347862, 0.06408550590276718, 0.003169192234054208, -0.029694292694330215, 0.01558314636349678, -0.060987312346696854, -0.05516154691576958, -0.02057957649230957, 0.024036256596446037, -0.030941784381866455, -0.01974274404346943, 0.10935457795858383, -0.09916563332080841, 0.024607131257653236, -0.019976766780018806, -0.02587093412876129, 0.013227147050201893, -0.02811628021299839, -0.0731276348233223, 0.0002363623061683029, 0.009996809996664524, 0.04556657373905182, 0.018131418153643608, 0.06536799669265747, 0.03446931019425392, -0.015369215980172157, 0.08666235953569412, 0.03366466611623764, -0.02683994174003601, -0.04488702490925789, 0.01697567291557789, -0.006184886209666729, -0.013200044631958008, 0.02628355100750923, 0.011049460619688034, -0.037521541118621826, -0.024936921894550323, -0.013580376282334328, -0.012859263457357883, -0.02954348362982273, -0.021567758172750473, -0.05770342797040939, -0.022865399718284607, -0.020911982282996178, 0.022510867565870285, 0.018753794953227043, -0.002099168486893177, -0.012765037827193737, 0.07774724066257477, -0.008285929448902607, 0.04915522411465645, 0.009377428330481052, 0.024486321955919266, 0.03345432132482529, 0.06556237488985062, 0.005485062953084707, 0.003503991523757577, 0.04166525974869728, 0.045962732285261154, -0.031878139823675156, -0.05233167111873627, -0.021293524652719498, -0.052158188074827194, -0.02911255694925785, 0.007377964444458485, -0.014723006635904312, -0.016996057704091072, 0.007491500582545996, -0.02744557149708271, 0.007916159927845001, -0.014249837026000023, 0.0019839645829051733, -0.0460786372423172, 0.005614839494228363, 0.02851678431034088, 0.06531333923339844, -0.059122227132320404, 0.008911444805562496, 0.0016720517305657268, -0.0018673876766115427, 0.04245903342962265, 0.032245852053165436, 0.04247492551803589, 0.07680226862430573, -0.07828326523303986, -0.03199430927634239, 0.07051894813776016, 0.05397924408316612, -0.02583223581314087, -0.057051900774240494, 0.03551368787884712, 0.024835973978042603, 0.04541979730129242, 0.002030591946095228, 0.01122712716460228, 0.09433477371931076, -0.03261999040842056, 0.05535564571619034, 0.009289606474339962, 0.009122801013290882, -0.025066809728741646, 0.019661372527480125, -0.029878348112106323, 0.011161983013153076, -0.01650093123316765, -0.0037234192714095116, 0.05311338230967522, 0.03455739468336105, -0.004928447771817446, -0.013698574155569077, -0.025891924276947975, 0.0005589017528109252, 0.018827946856617928, -0.029019556939601898, 0.07782557606697083, 0.0031603400129824877, -0.049658987671136856, -0.02548641338944435, -0.015806565061211586, 0.049429573118686676, -0.02524236962199211, 0.017105862498283386, 0.0066962153650820255, 0.06388185173273087, -0.012374571524560452, -0.011305679567158222, -0.07443695515394211, 0.049755390733480453, 0.003840527730062604, -0.0882459282875061, 0.05222798511385918, 0.017475958913564682, 0.06063883379101753, -0.045814547687768936, -0.05492305010557175, -0.007667877711355686, -0.023060690611600876, 0.043199677020311356, -0.011813313700258732, 0.01669100672006607, 0.009468554519116879, 0.013169029727578163, -0.016169292852282524, 0.005817425437271595, -0.03205471858382225, -0.005020283628255129, 0.023124143481254578, -0.003287616651505232, 0.005902200937271118, -0.043407537043094635, -0.090270034968853, 0.002571887569501996, 0.0008399827056564391, -0.018535783514380455, 0.002409025328233838, -0.0197676420211792, -0.004834520164877176, -0.0238332636654377, 0.013610604219138622, -0.02231944352388382, -0.06203658878803253, -0.057294927537441254, 0.0335678867995739, -0.08996615558862686, -0.03363998979330063, 0.0031531760469079018, 0.013336408883333206, 0.03460519015789032, -0.004417442250996828, -0.011392597109079361, 0.03312801569700241, -0.003314656438305974, 0.040281180292367935, 0.009377670474350452, 0.043360937386751175, -0.006688931491225958, -0.02654724009335041, 0.034574635326862335, -0.013243335299193859, 0.05229165032505989, -0.01430489867925644, 0.021365437656641006, -0.04669973999261856, -0.05588098242878914, 0.04296952486038208, 0.06347397714853287, 0.0034687896259129047, 0.03172999992966652, -0.03364615514874458, -0.013548236340284348, 0.019973868504166603, -0.024180885404348373, 0.03809630125761032, 0.019736619666218758, -0.04255953058600426, -0.012173826806247234, -0.026160284876823425, 0.018702274188399315, 0.053984206169843674, 0.060500722378492355, -0.018043994903564453, -0.05463754013180733, -0.13115836679935455, -0.011827073991298676, -0.009168373420834541, -0.02465580590069294, 0.034530118107795715, -0.01684410683810711, -0.01797187700867653, 0.023061567917466164, -0.021442051976919174, 0.007874748669564724, -0.02128458209335804, -0.013396558351814747, -0.07109086215496063, -0.021686287596821785, -0.0011872297618538141, -0.03747968375682831, 0.019064556807279587, -0.015424668788909912, -0.030916286632418633, -0.012151542119681835, 0.06715326756238937, 0.06909256428480148, -0.03487655520439148, 0.013315687887370586, 0.006025857292115688, 0.05859768018126488, 0.017307888716459274, -0.028275141492486, 0.013144483789801598, 0.03844568878412247, -0.05236152186989784, 0.0205784160643816, -0.02357441745698452, 0.02209181897342205, 0.002648361725732684, -0.014040167443454266, -0.04484366253018379, 0.018988871946930885, 0.021497035399079323, -0.032465409487485886, 0.0043048616498708725, 0.045004624873399734, -0.019032953307032585, -0.01221251580864191, -0.03588845580816269, 0.006093363277614117, -0.049966491758823395, 0.03412741795182228, 0.023914052173495293, 0.03064071014523506, -0.010832438245415688, 0.015803875401616096, 0.03265244886279106, -0.0009110909886658192, -0.044762466102838516, 0.025363430380821228, 0.009087150916457176, -0.002695355098694563, 0.08142779767513275, 0.058763712644577026, -0.02811475656926632, 0.0408276692032814, 0.01990419812500477, -0.029476771131157875, 0.012996465899050236, 0.015208057127892971, -0.0009520823368802667, 0.015390529297292233, 0.016522377729415894, 0.03994505852460861, -0.0450558066368103, -0.04580770432949066, -0.03031245991587639, 0.013648717664182186, -0.0070756711065769196, -0.055159393697977066, 0.004092557821422815, -0.0011397713096812367, -6.116739955801468e-33, 0.0005641026073135436, -0.0625758096575737, -0.024797962978482246, -0.03941808268427849, -0.041724856942892075, -0.01541669387370348, 0.0036730465944856405, -0.020515816286206245, -0.03202862665057182, 0.008695424534380436, -0.022790003567934036, 0.025087324902415276, -0.025029849261045456, -0.013987983576953411, 0.025002315640449524, -0.010756504721939564, -0.0009468793286941946, -0.04607871547341347, 0.04389043524861336, -0.008253910578787327, 0.012685381807386875, 0.013042732141911983, -0.047384295612573624, -0.035424474626779556, -0.024322591722011566, 0.005241009406745434, -0.029455086216330528, -0.023629048839211464, 0.003963311668485403, -0.0559120811522007, 0.009803783148527145, -0.05878154933452606, 0.009791618213057518, 0.005459635052829981, -0.012769178487360477, 0.07833440601825714, 0.06024504452943802, -0.008662848733365536, -0.06392504274845123, 0.010348121635615826, -0.02093539945781231, 0.00564221478998661, 0.053238194435834885, -0.06200747564435005, -0.026551503688097, -0.005122866947203875, 0.050598639994859695, -0.003213637974113226, 0.030863448977470398, 0.008350525982677937, -0.03285500779747963, 0.0006108882953412831, -0.02899358421564102, -0.007502697873860598, -0.005921860691159964, 0.0059480369091033936, -0.01461657416075468, 0.05644834041595459, -0.09052648395299911, 0.0501595139503479, -0.014259579591453075, -0.011878971941769123, -0.013799936510622501, 0.061502765864133835, 0.06993656605482101, -0.008700123988091946, -0.006170777603983879, 0.0075363460928201675, -0.03962387889623642, -0.02084331400692463, -0.04948318749666214, 0.10580319166183472, 0.07331889122724533, 0.029987597838044167, 0.06050395593047142, -0.07422488927841187, -0.0014667056966573, 0.0311638992279768, -0.035380490124225616, -0.019778748974204063, -0.0072220703586936, 0.020080214366316795, -0.017083415761590004, 0.008891547098755836, 0.12589159607887268, -0.019892435520887375, 0.0038181201089173555, 0.03247394412755966, -0.061327625066041946, -0.03783535957336426, -0.011084314435720444, -0.03693680092692375, 0.015733929350972176, 0.012450965121388435, -0.004792768973857164, -0.030705776065587997, 0.05081428587436676, 0.039035797119140625, 0.04547097161412239, -0.009754753671586514, -0.05886527895927429, 0.01788247376680374, -0.03455473482608795, 0.027402903884649277, 0.026474105194211006, 0.02489437721669674, -0.004376454744488001, 0.016475608572363853, 0.018062075600028038, -0.004742285702377558, 0.060324519872665405, -0.01800408586859703, 0.049452103674411774, -0.041399210691452026, 0.048829566687345505, -0.04738202318549156, -0.000873290584422648, -0.05739220231771469, 0.030785704031586647, -0.007128447759896517, 0.023693503811955452, 0.0821564793586731, -0.1147967204451561, 0.019425177946686745, -0.007832505740225315, 0.007965129800140858, -0.05871063843369484, 0.014522528275847435, -0.018404051661491394, -0.038815438747406006, -0.03214731812477112, -0.03293243423104286, 2.783207548873179e-07, -0.0442478209733963, 0.05453108251094818, 0.011130078695714474, -0.04660189524292946, 0.02510150708258152, 0.029382023960351944, -0.020870542153716087, 0.04463456571102142, 0.020350340753793716, -0.06502102315425873, 0.014799807220697403, 0.031056301668286324, -0.013010554946959019, 0.011069097556173801, -0.01927492581307888, 0.014283603057265282, -0.0029108545277267694, 0.016563523560762405, -0.008012088015675545, 0.05266483128070831, -0.04568607732653618, 0.003988254349678755, 0.006014494225382805, 3.801393904723227e-05, 0.028134804219007492, -0.014718911610543728, 0.01754574477672577, -0.054020848125219345, -0.01791500486433506, 0.01582188345491886, -0.02227611653506756, 0.013334494084119797, -0.058828406035900116, -0.013695231638848782, -0.008234654553234577, -0.008803155273199081, 0.0035433440934866667, -0.019627373665571213, -0.03264569491147995, 0.020730335265398026, 0.01474361028522253, 0.01988929510116577, 0.03936690092086792, -0.04000147432088852, 0.0614500418305397, 0.017004502937197685, -0.010017644613981247, -0.025670180097222328, 0.006374531891196966, -0.007923669181764126, 0.03312753140926361, 0.024429013952612877, 0.01897549256682396, -0.0017982486169785261, 0.01357286237180233, -0.03399716317653656, -0.011168534867465496, -0.00600022217258811, 0.020195720717310905, -0.04160946607589722, -0.024833261966705322, -0.0303819477558136, -0.013408846221864223, 0.0009449278586544096, 0.02147347666323185, 0.08756057918071747, -0.06195740029215813, 2.2507750531720903e-34, 0.04384050518274307, -0.004766680300235748, -0.0321517214179039, -0.0404377318918705, 0.000843614456243813, 0.009346777573227882, -0.08439608663320541, 0.0036494729574769735, 0.04302654042840004, 0.03515912592411041, -0.00867006927728653]
674
674
['Vlado Menkovski', 'Zharko Aleksovski', 'Axel Saalbach', 'Hannes Nickisch']
1512.05986v1
Convolutional neural networks demonstrated outstanding empirical results in computer vision and speech recognition tasks where labeled training data is abundant. In medical imaging, there is a huge variety of possible imaging modalities and contrasts, where annotated data is usually very scarce. We present two approaches to deal with this challenge. A network pretrained in a different domain with abundant data is used as a feature extractor, while a subsequent classifier is trained on a small target dataset; and a deep architecture trained with heavy augmentation and equipped with sophisticated regularization methods. We test the approaches on a corpus of X-ray images to design an anatomy detection system.
Can Pretrained Neural Networks Detect Anatomy?
2,015
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1512.05986v1
Title Pretrained Neural Networks Detect Anatomy Summary Convolutional neural network demonstrated outstanding empirical result computer vision speech recognition task labeled training data abundant medical imaging huge variety possible imaging modality contrast annotated data usually scarce present two approach deal challenge network pretrained different domain abundant data used feature extractor subsequent classifier trained small target dataset deep architecture trained heavy augmentation equipped sophisticated regularization method test approach corpus Xray image design anatomy detection system Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.014294211752712727, 0.06194915249943733, -0.008607087656855583, 0.014003215357661247, 0.02963629737496376, 0.034846555441617966, 0.02385333739221096, 0.03210815414786339, 0.0029922490939497948, 0.022602366283535957, -0.048182617872953415, -0.0062265945598483086, 0.025089100003242493, 0.026192206889390945, 0.01063295267522335, -0.039213646203279495, -0.025880232453346252, 0.0574624203145504, -0.020232675597071648, -0.024425409734249115, 0.015635136514902115, -0.026697784662246704, -0.02849324606359005, 0.049248818308115005, -0.020592395216226578, 0.07767082750797272, 0.014530516229569912, -0.019640684127807617, 0.004279319662600756, -0.017848826944828033, -0.00040528448880650103, 0.026914680376648903, 0.0014189821667969227, -0.00782410055398941, 2.400156290605082e-06, -0.031882744282484055, 0.000367833417840302, 0.0067876349203288555, -0.009602079167962074, 0.031150367110967636, 0.030656656250357628, -0.03861953318119049, -0.0008851231541484594, -0.014769219793379307, -0.021195072680711746, -0.06309245526790619, 0.02609505131840706, 0.08045406639575958, -0.007027994375675917, 0.05746574327349663, -0.00734404381364584, 0.003184193978086114, 0.04624940827488899, 0.0010850338730961084, -0.007491916883736849, -0.05622949078679085, -0.03128887340426445, 0.006371756084263325, -0.015303142368793488, 0.011646074242889881, -0.0037805046886205673, 0.08258868008852005, 0.014204873703420162, -0.006494493689388037, 0.027791503816843033, 0.06907575577497482, 0.003099149791523814, -0.07049582898616791, 0.0013319128192961216, 0.02741805464029312, -0.01712837629020214, 0.02461269125342369, -0.02934877574443817, -0.03013612888753414, 0.001928304904140532, -0.03278045356273651, 0.03829658031463623, 0.002344908658415079, 0.018395736813545227, -0.001347505021840334, -0.02557561919093132, -0.0327945314347744, 0.015311920084059238, 0.024654923006892204, -0.019671039655804634, -0.0663471594452858, -0.0035677803680300713, 0.03753124922513962, 0.03675452619791031, 0.015027288347482681, 0.015310827642679214, -0.029153648763895035, 0.01384954433888197, 0.06648215651512146, -0.023405922576785088, -0.013515600003302097, -0.03943328559398651, -0.12011753767728806, 0.06056587025523186, -0.04081866890192032, 0.03590710833668709, -0.03720443323254585, -0.08190521597862244, 0.04031318053603172, -0.03684466704726219, 0.0007055566529743373, -0.07839600741863251, 0.07342769205570221, -0.010086351074278355, 0.03579818084836006, 0.030678510665893555, 0.006881892681121826, -0.029898326843976974, -0.005817047785967588, 0.033684927970170975, -0.015895115211606026, -0.028613029047846794, -0.022606465965509415, 0.030542414635419846, -0.03524733707308769, 0.004637987352907658, 0.10662779211997986, -0.019864846020936966, 0.026775110512971878, 0.014711358584463596, -0.002829793142154813, 0.02195686846971512, 0.038150638341903687, -0.025767406448721886, 0.004884576424956322, 0.010557280853390694, 0.03743239492177963, 0.012961245141923428, 0.020840438082814217, 0.009934933856129646, 0.06958884000778198, -0.00556762982159853, -0.03017224743962288, 0.017889834940433502, 0.006125845480710268, -0.008748306892812252, 0.0293972659856081, 0.05623888596892357, -0.012628251686692238, -0.00984128750860691, -0.02003558911383152, 0.008728167973458767, 0.048143960535526276, 0.007428696379065514, -0.03073919378221035, 0.011936782859265804, 0.03828050568699837, -0.05775158852338791, -0.038904622197151184, 0.05394527316093445, 0.00728754373267293, 0.01514839380979538, -0.023592887446284294, 0.02353578433394432, -0.0011734343133866787, -0.03376647084951401, -0.04860994219779968, -0.03390350937843323, -0.0008349862764589489, -0.05755668133497238, -0.045258574187755585, -0.010355054400861263, -0.027865830808877945, 0.00968910101801157, 0.07861699908971786, -0.003060312010347843, 0.011266155168414116, 0.012941326946020126, -0.018149398267269135, -0.04989488795399666, 0.10557550191879272, 0.02810889482498169, 0.01769498735666275, 0.02198132686316967, -0.012716999277472496, 0.03556978330016136, -0.005056984256953001, 0.036167897284030914, 0.0026235184632241726, 0.021914267912507057, -0.03828319534659386, -0.0802687406539917, -0.004949127323925495, -0.03584644943475723, -0.032027747482061386, -0.006865786854177713, -0.049560755491256714, -0.05698850378394127, -0.004063232336193323, 0.06474344432353973, -0.019694507122039795, -0.029245827347040176, -0.031242940574884415, 0.016628172248601913, 0.032908499240875244, -0.04977880045771599, -0.06504953652620316, -0.002214938635006547, -0.0433955043554306, -0.023015329614281654, -0.07616646587848663, -0.01053562480956316, 0.002603484084829688, 0.03077196516096592, -0.006928558461368084, 0.0017222145106643438, 0.018809540197253227, 0.06292036920785904, -0.031989384442567825, -0.009132797829806805, 0.02554527297616005, 0.035383082926273346, -0.01704823412001133, -0.011423174291849136, 0.02061927318572998, 0.00011978947441093624, 0.00692936172708869, 0.014676079154014587, 0.031953420490026474, -0.06142235919833183, 0.001989346230402589, 0.002245584037154913, 0.006324371322989464, -0.004021440166980028, -0.05062154307961464, -0.036331336945295334, -0.011983218602836132, 0.00018646761600393802, 0.008033089339733124, -0.009858678095042706, -0.01062457263469696, -0.035117257386446, -0.004565519746392965, 0.027801228687167168, -0.04310520365834236, -0.02510334923863411, 0.007263198494911194, -0.03717116639018059, 0.01191129069775343, -0.013952569104731083, -0.025336969643831253, 0.020945994183421135, -0.0009761140681803226, 0.009954888373613358, 0.0198413897305727, -0.01014301273971796, 0.00832400843501091, 0.010079102590680122, 0.03151413053274155, -0.035438891500234604, 0.01742413267493248, -0.047627080231904984, 0.054231204092502594, -0.030914202332496643, -0.04560090973973274, -0.019267229363322258, -0.014443726278841496, -0.004351274110376835, -0.03900551050901413, 0.07022494822740555, -0.018187157809734344, 0.011138999834656715, -0.016016552224755287, -0.02358383871614933, 0.03729364275932312, -0.04161318019032478, 0.04385155439376831, -0.03449637442827225, 0.05373115837574005, -0.056443169713020325, -0.01795073412358761, 0.02265133336186409, 0.044817179441452026, -0.023563485592603683, 0.06016022339463234, -0.005521014798432589, 0.05891365185379982, -0.056467119604349136, -0.03035178780555725, 0.0012064364273101091, -0.019661713391542435, 0.0807487741112709, -0.09430363029241562, 0.05290934443473816, 0.043075863271951675, 0.015462673269212246, 0.04366746172308922, 0.02184099517762661, -0.07437823712825775, 0.013157065026462078, 0.006030831020325422, -0.08212247490882874, 0.09555395692586899, 0.01616636849939823, -0.003595920978114009, -0.014349912293255329, 0.05352913588285446, 0.05317661911249161, -0.040186841040849686, -0.02560114860534668, -0.012916237115859985, -0.008966023102402687, 0.006711083929985762, 0.00036161704338155687, 0.0023373246658593416, -0.02156778983771801, 0.004830366000533104, 0.004211795516312122, -0.04538457840681076, -0.025182221084833145, 0.001461852458305657, -0.0702822133898735, -0.009319081902503967, -0.015333334915339947, 0.025279009714722633, -0.0006875797407701612, -0.015384010039269924, 0.04011641815304756, 0.03888438642024994, 0.03788074478507042, -0.006665462162345648, -0.030498672276735306, -0.0023762111086398363, -0.016666648909449577, 0.006038947030901909, 0.03562907502055168, 0.005567101761698723, -0.02640240639448166, -0.005169019568711519, 0.03910432755947113, -0.0046140532940626144, -0.061700452119112015, -0.05716118961572647, 0.0319230780005455, -0.002491522580385208, -0.012001057155430317, -0.026570353657007217, -0.061105336993932724, 0.011806839145720005, -0.01861385628581047, -0.021169472485780716, 0.0024519215803593397, -0.008833082392811775, -0.01092674769461155, 0.007336849812418222, -0.03428226336836815, 0.05047514662146568, 0.002228887053206563, 0.02594546228647232, -0.038973692804574966, 0.09183526039123535, -0.015301878564059734, 0.04344316944479942, -0.013778284192085266, 0.0013898656470701098, 0.0009513035183772445, 0.027735285460948944, -0.10266833007335663, -0.021138010546565056, -0.043975457549095154, -0.029062477871775627, -0.015040026046335697, 0.037153925746679306, 0.02857052907347679, -0.03910680115222931, 0.04666292667388916, -0.01091412641108036, -0.008783133700489998, 0.035751137882471085, -0.008661394007503986, -0.0733938217163086, -0.02297268621623516, 0.030069150030612946, -0.08655291050672531, -0.04108912870287895, 0.00960971787571907, -0.06623215973377228, -0.023160068318247795, 0.008194338530302048, -0.05982870236039162, -0.0038558668456971645, -0.002768199658021331, -0.0012390498304739594, 0.0068353586830198765, 0.046278636902570724, -0.015468423254787922, -0.04852025583386421, -0.027257822453975677, -0.01193245593458414, 0.0014783903025090694, -0.024939313530921936, 0.0003315756912343204, -0.01998775266110897, 0.020177055150270462, -0.02445836178958416, -0.005874331574887037, -0.005336814559996128, -0.028324667364358902, 0.013502941466867924, -0.0256575345993042, -0.06737130880355835, 0.03631874546408653, 0.04778169468045235, -0.048687636852264404, -0.033135220408439636, 0.033812157809734344, -0.0025300090201199055, 0.012329796329140663, 0.03599444031715393, 0.10324069112539291, 0.018971268087625504, -0.00959080271422863, -0.009719454683363438, 0.06097547709941864, 0.029304418712854385, 0.06339087337255478, -0.017377808690071106, 0.002949355635792017, -0.03126787021756172, 0.0218291487544775, -0.07045170664787292, 0.0135911013931036, -0.002289847005158663, -0.04920811951160431, 0.016867807134985924, -0.024232281371951103, -0.04604481905698776, 0.006821194663643837, 0.08495527505874634, 0.003589075757190585, 0.009065628051757812, 0.031565021723508835, -0.011054938659071922, -0.05433725565671921, -0.02026449888944626, 0.007749700918793678, -0.012577634304761887, -0.018498791381716728, 0.06262250989675522, -0.009836515411734581, 0.0015914965188130736, -0.03963766247034073, -0.04803936183452606, 0.061161257326602936, 0.05885148048400879, 0.019393987953662872, -0.03962190821766853, -0.02900671772658825, 0.07276146113872528, -0.031293969601392746, -0.008983023464679718, -0.027900733053684235, -0.017843734472990036, 0.03309670835733414, -0.011803758330643177, -0.00036836741492152214, -0.01318623311817646, -0.03168310225009918, -0.08355216681957245, -0.05004151910543442, 0.022851990535855293, 0.021337997168302536, -0.005290210712701082, 0.010006140917539597, 0.074510857462883, -0.09785463660955429, -0.0011229148367419839, -0.003873127046972513, 0.01791519671678543, 0.045371655374765396, -0.003853361587971449, -0.09035767614841461, -0.02374953031539917, -0.030754175037145615, 0.026769015938043594, 0.014317097142338753, 0.06201208755373955, 0.0036353447940200567, -0.018009919673204422, -0.02119802124798298, 0.024332527071237564, 0.04895096644759178, 0.04118403419852257, -0.02493930421769619, 0.036175355315208435, 0.069078728556633, -0.00492631271481514, 0.0042401645332574844, -0.025389274582266808, 0.025776628404855728, -0.004873192403465509, -0.009090671315789223, 0.0759204551577568, 0.03602670505642891, -0.04003898426890373, -0.005824579391628504, -0.002373830648139119, 0.0017471503233537078, -0.030020402744412422, -0.01472510676831007, 0.003805316984653473, 0.035806141793727875, -0.03740421682596207, 0.006354315672069788, 0.03387560695409775, 0.0009796146769076586, 0.042701881378889084, 0.03248490393161774, 0.004716359078884125, -0.03461691737174988, 0.016699867323040962, 0.05255652591586113, -0.05929987505078316, -0.03712507337331772, 0.032764121890068054, -0.021087320521473885, 0.026309294626116753, 0.04159903898835182, -0.07582270354032516, 0.007272437680512667, 0.04497779160737991, 0.0016426648944616318, 0.04967539757490158, -0.01839323900640011, 0.04948415607213974, 0.0005019346135668457, 0.0017720786854624748, 0.003127447562292218, -0.021482329815626144, -0.020318176597356796, 0.007094665430486202, 0.04215952754020691, 0.0023374168667942286, -0.020276837050914764, 0.04212033003568649, 0.05716196447610855, -0.04469388350844383, -0.01255482342094183, -0.016854990273714066, -0.03192799538373947, -0.00142791704274714, 0.014536313712596893, -0.017689090222120285, 0.02606809325516224, -0.04854169487953186, -0.006703512277454138, 0.0051673585548996925, 0.03112814947962761, 0.016330650076270103, 0.007926897145807743, -6.007970728835912e-33, 0.034267961978912354, -0.011201824061572552, 0.029585804790258408, -0.0531683973968029, -0.006005571689456701, 0.07150900363922119, -0.017894355580210686, -0.0009210293646901846, -0.03712337091565132, 0.04372166469693184, -0.002448535757139325, -0.00672139972448349, 0.012151850387454033, 0.06056412681937218, 0.013950815424323082, 0.004983110819011927, -0.019988829270005226, -0.03734845668077469, 0.015088839456439018, -0.0019322665175423026, -0.01651136949658394, 0.028940027579665184, 0.07594877481460571, -0.11095767468214035, -0.07622935622930527, 0.038067527115345, 0.034457556903362274, -0.03105425275862217, -0.03085457719862461, -0.015797214582562447, -0.03981881961226463, -0.043632008135318756, -0.01728362776339054, 0.003259391989558935, 0.006156653165817261, -0.04477769881486893, -0.026005076244473457, 0.011532362550497055, -0.025992456823587418, 0.07483909279108047, -0.05304311588406563, 0.028544263914227486, 0.058623477816581726, -0.06843174248933792, 0.007781321182847023, 0.004517285618931055, 0.06075392663478851, -0.03864405304193497, 0.014187954366207123, -0.027174705639481544, -0.022825704887509346, 0.05283549800515175, 0.010763115249574184, -0.01027878187596798, 0.027944231405854225, -0.0023413877934217453, -0.028614578768610954, 0.05301716551184654, 0.012461106292903423, 0.006915734149515629, 0.07962318509817123, 0.039835862815380096, -0.007829220034182072, -0.01316303201019764, 0.019322751089930534, 0.07580645382404327, 0.04826652631163597, -0.0579671673476696, -0.01751818135380745, 0.03389088809490204, -0.04258324205875397, 0.03299587965011597, 0.06451019644737244, -0.021336937323212624, 0.056686773896217346, -0.05995018035173416, -0.0626792386174202, 0.003533025970682502, -0.06704899668693542, 0.037763360887765884, -0.009820154868066311, -0.0383702851831913, -0.013500486500561237, 0.027278263121843338, 0.05315302684903145, -0.054066598415374756, 0.03950003534555435, -0.016702955588698387, -0.01798914186656475, -0.0014384861569851637, 0.023346152156591415, 0.02421743795275688, -0.0068267895840108395, -0.005342018324881792, 0.032899342477321625, -0.024498973041772842, 0.04983319714665413, 0.00953427143394947, -0.011719055473804474, 0.0071112909354269505, -0.017429092898964882, -0.050443533807992935, 0.00747860549017787, -0.011485905386507511, 0.03576166182756424, 0.003298205556347966, 0.029451830312609673, 0.004033065401017666, 0.012129531241953373, -0.012976876460015774, -0.014340415596961975, -0.039077144116163254, 0.02138327807188034, 0.07808703929185867, 0.058322593569755554, -0.005918626673519611, -0.0066503072157502174, 0.05742081627249718, 0.0014020378002896905, -0.003711169585585594, -0.05554009974002838, -0.04231855645775795, -0.05101128667593002, -0.01563691906630993, -0.04235772415995598, -0.07490174472332001, -0.02198837324976921, -0.015517661347985268, 0.03630072996020317, -0.06303422898054123, -0.01948271319270134, 0.011654550209641457, 2.915732579822361e-07, 0.033408816903829575, -0.025178667157888412, 0.01598738320171833, -0.041793275624513626, 0.009338951669633389, -0.012927020899951458, -0.015255156904459, 0.0016804356127977371, -0.01003650575876236, -0.035352349281311035, 0.03909721598029137, 0.04355328530073166, -0.03682375326752663, 0.0028297933749854565, -0.025139516219496727, -0.015935001894831657, -0.03790678456425667, -0.0040651303716003895, 0.03413030877709389, -0.02391044795513153, -0.00221096514724195, 0.07123325765132904, -0.02311655506491661, -0.08672475069761276, 0.038604799658060074, 0.0009457821724936366, -0.0026360368356108665, -0.04466694965958595, 0.049863919615745544, -0.022748947143554688, -0.012566489167511463, 0.01889544166624546, 0.0036670472472906113, 0.042887669056653976, 0.005934847518801689, 0.017314890399575233, -0.0036830673925578594, 0.029308713972568512, -0.0531778521835804, 0.009267142042517662, 0.057231057435274124, 0.05793987587094307, 0.028557423502206802, 0.028892457485198975, 0.034967947751283646, -0.018076354637742043, -0.02473038248717785, -0.09651178121566772, 0.0629599317908287, -0.0005695320433005691, 0.061386268585920334, -0.03154170140624046, 0.024983000010252, 0.01112998928874731, 0.02739127166569233, -0.027802327647805214, -0.03151138126850128, -0.08303620666265488, 0.00968819111585617, 0.032484270632267, -0.00854531116783619, -0.012725568376481533, 0.04152381792664528, -0.02302537113428116, 0.041448429226875305, -0.05423903465270996, -0.019921984523534775, 2.4288094123226356e-34, 0.010524475947022438, -0.008821832947432995, -0.015445384196937084, 0.07102609425783157, -0.027337612584233284, 0.03376984968781471, 0.08124992996454239, -0.034161198884248734, -0.0029446647968143225, 0.006924418266862631, -0.028713250532746315]
675
675
['L. M. Rasdi Rere', 'Mohamad Ivan Fanany', 'Aniati Murni Arymurthy']
1610.01925v1
A typical modern optimization technique is usually either heuristic or metaheuristic. This technique has managed to solve some optimization problems in the research area of science, engineering, and industry. However, implementation strategy of metaheuristic for accuracy improvement on convolution neural networks (CNN), a famous deep learning method, is still rarely investigated. Deep learning relates to a type of machine learning technique, where its aim is to move closer to the goal of artificial intelligence of creating a machine that could successfully perform any intellectual tasks that can be carried out by a human. In this paper, we propose the implementation strategy of three popular metaheuristic approaches, that is, simulated annealing, differential evolution, and harmony search, to optimize CNN. The performances of these metaheuristic methods in optimizing CNN on classifying MNIST and CIFAR dataset were evaluated and compared. Furthermore, the proposed methods are also compared with the original CNN. Although the proposed methods show an increase in the computation time, their accuracy has also been improved (up to 7.14 percent).
Metaheuristic Algorithms for Convolution Neural Network
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1610.01925v1
Title Metaheuristic Algorithms Convolution Neural Network Summary typical modern optimization technique usually either heuristic metaheuristic technique managed solve optimization problem research area science engineering industry However implementation strategy metaheuristic accuracy improvement convolution neural network CNN famous deep learning method still rarely investigated Deep learning relates type machine learning technique aim move closer goal artificial intelligence creating machine could successfully perform intellectual task carried human paper propose implementation strategy three popular metaheuristic approach simulated annealing differential evolution harmony search optimize CNN performance metaheuristic method optimizing CNN classifying MNIST CIFAR dataset evaluated compared Furthermore proposed method also compared original CNN Although proposed method show increase computation time accuracy also improved 714 percent Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.02029944397509098, 0.006519587244838476, -0.013802915811538696, 0.011240843683481216, -0.024036340415477753, -0.01870868168771267, 0.038991380482912064, -0.0033244576770812273, -0.07844418287277222, -0.0439758226275444, 0.003446210641413927, 0.030755717307329178, 0.011416098102927208, 0.026213426142930984, 0.0012278028298169374, -0.01054716482758522, 0.005024521145969629, 0.03585605323314667, -0.03613224998116493, -0.03386656939983368, -0.012796617113053799, -0.04870080202817917, -0.013880397193133831, 0.01888449676334858, -0.013183142989873886, 0.030416544526815414, -0.015108829364180565, -0.007879097014665604, 0.06114486977458, -0.02095833607017994, 0.03358476608991623, -0.008150926791131496, -0.03682146593928337, 0.04869984835386276, 2.337817022635136e-06, -0.022056637331843376, -0.00785408727824688, -0.02375059388577938, 0.037548527121543884, -0.013274488970637321, 0.0471932590007782, 0.0156397745013237, -0.023875385522842407, 0.021014830097556114, -0.019401060417294502, 0.02461051754653454, 0.029814181849360466, 0.054241180419921875, 0.016005482524633408, 0.03328899294137955, 0.0038176903035491705, -0.051408182829618454, 0.0216678436845541, 0.008832148276269436, -0.045847177505493164, -0.03016488440334797, 0.002750012557953596, -0.014407048933207989, -0.03924216702580452, -0.036872003227472305, -0.00018219252524431795, 0.04413231462240219, 0.037730518728494644, -0.020077509805560112, -0.003163805464282632, -0.008123181760311127, -0.06095871701836586, -0.02982321009039879, -0.0027794332709163427, 0.04197092726826668, -0.062206994742155075, -0.0042501469142735004, -0.00020712362311314791, -0.014390922151505947, -0.01713324710726738, -0.00308875716291368, 0.0264399666339159, 0.037020862102508545, -0.02702927403151989, -0.011129414662718773, -0.08095366507768631, 0.021763654425740242, 0.006047367583960295, 0.03401847556233406, 0.02425343729555607, 0.04808514937758446, -0.010954954661428928, 0.02620207518339157, 0.039664413779973984, -0.06249971315264702, -0.0036058223340660334, -0.0006206354591995478, 0.027246832847595215, 0.002554143313318491, -0.022129587829113007, -0.044095173478126526, -0.010037395171821117, -0.0897383838891983, 0.014978486113250256, -0.031687427312135696, 0.025368861854076385, 0.022696558386087418, 0.0009116202127188444, -0.00547575019299984, 0.0009309073211625218, 0.014518843963742256, -0.05893741175532341, 0.04398784041404724, -0.016246497631072998, -0.013072352856397629, -0.0578603558242321, -0.002233699429780245, -0.024339860305190086, 0.04085274040699005, -0.007000827230513096, -0.0026562914717942476, -0.07965312898159027, 0.005167461931705475, 0.015000215731561184, -0.07138670980930328, 0.010109003633260727, 0.02817167155444622, 0.02004340849816799, 0.0072481874376535416, -0.006484590470790863, -0.030472515150904655, -0.04961710795760155, 0.022245299071073532, -0.01605118252336979, 0.020062075927853584, 0.0766024962067604, 0.010296132415533066, -0.01250440999865532, 0.00823849719017744, 0.009780967608094215, 0.019476165995001793, 0.00812237337231636, 0.011043288744986057, -0.04338584840297699, 0.04750236123800278, 0.024291174486279488, -0.03821225091814995, 0.00026294763665646315, -0.02062239870429039, -0.018068527802824974, -0.0867665484547615, -0.038996316492557526, 0.03649546205997467, -0.026284679770469666, -0.031811438500881195, 0.025088751688599586, 0.031255874782800674, -0.05743876472115517, -0.030113527551293373, 0.12365872412919998, 0.017361806705594063, 0.027603015303611755, 0.035241320729255676, 0.01845627650618553, 0.04795040562748909, -0.040961284190416336, -0.07181983441114426, -0.01469816081225872, -0.05147332698106766, 0.011715847998857498, -0.031285762786865234, 0.00025196612114086747, -0.024349858984351158, -0.0401257649064064, 0.0576968714594841, -0.02788366936147213, 0.011705601587891579, -0.03973589092493057, -0.014781751669943333, -0.0012100267922505736, 0.024282893165946007, 0.03672689571976662, 0.047836076468229294, 0.0010761503363028169, 0.03332887962460518, 0.022806301712989807, -0.041583605110645294, -0.011513345874845982, 0.07619696855545044, -0.08240937441587448, -0.08251731842756271, -0.0381467267870903, -0.022215869277715683, -0.03528280928730965, -0.0422624796628952, 0.06151677668094635, -0.011298049241304398, -0.026100164279341698, -0.011557459831237793, -0.014106483198702335, 0.01918499730527401, -0.028874250128865242, -0.03795306012034416, 0.009678619913756847, 0.012154672294855118, -0.05920350179076195, -0.050562627613544464, 0.0026460231747478247, -0.005014341790229082, -0.007649010978639126, -0.023174481466412544, -0.048040714114904404, -0.0017563225701451302, 0.011240559630095959, 0.0005528797046281397, 1.2577447705552913e-05, 0.00944044254720211, 0.01736167073249817, -0.04329109191894531, 0.003727555740624666, 0.01073197741061449, -0.026279671117663383, 0.0137442322447896, -0.03597044199705124, 0.0027384187560528517, 0.0317765548825264, 0.015555272810161114, 0.0039364672265946865, -0.0032030746806412935, 0.017001254484057426, 0.013724502176046371, 0.05826965719461441, 0.06316658109426498, 0.018067840486764908, 0.0033637017477303743, 0.04981284216046333, -0.03153577446937561, 0.0008596855914220214, -0.02281779795885086, -0.08609284460544586, -0.021535350009799004, 0.018872380256652832, 0.01575624942779541, 0.04674289748072624, -0.05881865322589874, 0.037241581827402115, 0.05597138777375221, -0.03756897151470184, -0.07127482444047928, 0.012363389134407043, -0.01234170887619257, 0.03447592630982399, -0.01226193830370903, 0.013673185370862484, -0.0334177240729332, 0.028538499027490616, -0.040799908339977264, 0.033404480665922165, 0.014289387501776218, -0.025672489777207375, -0.009759608656167984, 0.00434437021613121, 0.05277390405535698, -0.013455876149237156, -0.006426913198083639, 0.05251030996441841, -0.046449288725852966, 0.02667178027331829, 0.03537779301404953, 0.021870223805308342, -0.016519315540790558, -0.004257461056113243, -0.03898731246590614, 0.026116274297237396, -0.007652721833437681, -0.02126344107091427, 0.010734567418694496, -0.030623706057667732, 0.028946736827492714, -9.664591198088601e-05, -0.002836239757016301, 0.11111048609018326, -0.05667826905846596, -0.033584870398044586, 0.06125263124704361, 0.02511114999651909, 0.029206935316324234, -0.04035677760839462, -0.06543141603469849, -0.005504028871655464, 0.03976663574576378, 0.03196919709444046, 9.719143417896703e-05, 0.020705657079815865, -0.00453335652127862, 0.0068294876255095005, 0.014488369226455688, 0.008820360526442528, -0.04450831189751625, -0.04428081959486008, 0.009198346175253391, -0.003802504623308778, 0.035333212465047836, 0.04675062745809555, -0.06342895328998566, -0.01704910211265087, 0.10831853002309799, -0.029767390340566635, 0.04846383258700371, 0.0010166154243052006, -0.01805856078863144, 0.015214823186397552, 0.031937625259160995, -0.008827089332044125, 0.012931711971759796, -0.011450770311057568, 0.02179768495261669, -0.019482824951410294, 0.022418586537241936, 0.016646286472678185, -0.03389090672135353, -0.050662215799093246, 0.02990248054265976, 0.013889415189623833, 0.0171199981123209, 0.024828333407640457, -0.013628227636218071, 0.03184294328093529, 0.0543392077088356, 0.01756722666323185, -0.033044394105672836, -0.0187647957354784, -0.00867710541933775, -0.04268902912735939, -0.027937356382608414, 0.036323729902505875, 0.004399281460791826, -0.0002878248051274568, -0.018103716894984245, 0.001950382604263723, 0.03284737467765808, -0.017095059156417847, -0.014881416223943233, 0.06065826117992401, -0.023746410384774208, -0.035192374140024185, -0.01438499428331852, -0.046750180423259735, -0.02276476100087166, 0.008011462166905403, -0.02400578185915947, 0.004136630333960056, -0.011879444122314453, -0.026595093309879303, 0.007135468069463968, -0.013135545887053013, 0.025748077780008316, -0.017469000071287155, 0.009193363599479198, 0.0036017312668263912, 0.022616470232605934, 0.056216735392808914, -0.01023625023663044, 0.0015380462864413857, 0.10270757228136063, 0.0951836109161377, -0.01028981152921915, -0.04855628311634064, 0.04674794524908066, -0.08046822249889374, 0.02092643827199936, -0.0003049362276215106, -0.02713426761329174, -0.030345115810632706, 0.004575818311423063, -0.06976976990699768, -0.0377521850168705, 0.08172447979450226, 0.01194687932729721, 0.018538694828748703, -0.07242471724748611, -0.023317521438002586, -0.03547895699739456, -0.03101494535803795, 0.01400016900151968, 0.013002783991396427, 0.0040905228815972805, -0.013823075219988823, -0.014782910235226154, 0.009232825599610806, -0.010866251774132252, -0.056548651307821274, 0.02066987007856369, -0.04325838014483452, -0.008386691100895405, -0.026881253346800804, -0.051285699009895325, -0.007977575063705444, -0.03816431015729904, -0.009987345896661282, -0.04395605996251106, 0.010221119970083237, 0.015284847468137741, 0.023009303957223892, -0.03369959816336632, 0.007944752462208271, -0.006576002109795809, -0.008939778432250023, -0.010863721370697021, -0.03641767054796219, -0.028753191232681274, 0.06548348069190979, 0.05179964378476143, -0.021768834441900253, -0.012763290666043758, 0.09174161404371262, 0.018371224403381348, -0.0007575959316454828, -0.051112037152051926, 0.07101517915725708, 0.009539793245494366, 0.00791145395487547, 0.0046692779287695885, 0.031927987933158875, -0.03141043335199356, 0.021975096315145493, 0.01426326297223568, 0.03861645236611366, -1.3374627769735525e-06, 0.027154723182320595, -0.06530813872814178, -0.0061507378704845905, 0.02198546938598156, -0.035595204681158066, -0.00024248160480055958, -0.05692228674888611, -0.038168128579854965, 0.012121852487325668, 0.01603671722114086, -0.04428178444504738, 0.036477938294410706, 0.037688203155994415, 0.06363143771886826, -0.028137246146798134, -0.05587548017501831, -0.005016835872083902, -0.0149101996794343, 0.07011501491069794, 0.045561399310827255, -0.02448536828160286, 0.03102233074605465, 0.04022199288010597, -0.07886691391468048, -0.0522691085934639, 0.05203796923160553, 0.0037223538383841515, -0.06891069561243057, 0.03323905169963837, 0.06632227450609207, -0.07233555614948273, 0.020397139713168144, -0.05183405429124832, -0.05571812391281128, 0.006869292818009853, -0.056058432906866074, 0.03952367231249809, -0.009576552547514439, -0.01469720620661974, -0.02999941073358059, -0.06380070745944977, 0.007472303230315447, -0.029520241543650627, 0.060757238417863846, -0.05441027134656906, 0.0634855404496193, -0.03651634231209755, -0.011285442858934402, 0.02403125911951065, -0.010274375788867474, 0.06360620260238647, 0.020938660949468613, -0.03299760818481445, -0.015105183236300945, 0.013308300636708736, 0.04989999905228615, 0.040465958416461945, 0.04714250937104225, -0.010892701335251331, -0.01450775284320116, 2.2087873730924912e-05, 0.013573398813605309, 0.062246523797512054, -0.007974435575306416, 0.01532292552292347, 0.025196174159646034, 0.049181342124938965, -0.005103992763906717, 0.04860778525471687, -0.0025670144241303205, 0.09471925348043442, -0.09100300818681717, 0.08299541473388672, 0.10996398329734802, -0.040771227329969406, 0.08950831741094589, -0.026316581293940544, 0.054877474904060364, 0.01028453279286623, 0.008652273565530777, 0.06275206059217453, 0.030449876561760902, -0.018252205103635788, 0.015516328625380993, 0.006756438873708248, -0.019374318420886993, -0.06392914056777954, 0.029583996161818504, 0.0010510609718039632, -0.0008017679210752249, -0.013329839333891869, 0.030292654410004616, 0.0787639245390892, 0.02018415741622448, -0.04356837272644043, 0.004801101051270962, 0.008668700233101845, -0.01620417647063732, 0.018341312184929848, -0.0242109727114439, 0.04505205899477005, -0.00321832112967968, -0.0004962009261362255, -0.028335733339190483, -0.023787112906575203, 0.02273191511631012, -0.00815438013523817, -0.03210220858454704, 0.011336389929056168, 0.0444195531308651, -0.03467216715216637, 0.03973650187253952, -0.06412523239850998, 0.04270501434803009, 0.005003823433071375, 0.01339874416589737, 0.008433976210653782, 0.012348898686468601, 0.06569766998291016, -0.01607106253504753, 0.057812128216028214, 0.010615024715662003, 0.0326445996761322, -0.009607817977666855, 0.004021303728222847, -0.016003156080842018, -0.01846516691148281, -0.021830324083566666, 0.014109154231846333, 0.04756351187825203, -0.0027744737453758717, -5.9507226845829284e-33, 0.02840137854218483, -0.02182689495384693, -0.005580076016485691, -0.001465588342398405, -0.023073919117450714, 0.011611471883952618, -0.0007481102948077023, 0.001012694207020104, -0.04094145819544792, -0.009714893065392971, -0.03411244973540306, 0.020211009308695793, 0.003953565377742052, 0.00937036331743002, -0.007142598740756512, -0.018877940252423286, -0.025483939796686172, -0.026432599872350693, -0.010067139752209187, -0.020915977656841278, -0.03424729034304619, 0.036201804876327515, 0.014362931251525879, 0.005655067041516304, -0.12686552107334137, 0.03910835459828377, 0.005395850166678429, 0.02626495249569416, -0.04693780094385147, -0.009946300648152828, 0.009419477544724941, 0.013130334205925465, -0.006891269236803055, -0.03261523321270943, 0.02125963382422924, -0.022370200604200363, -0.002402201062068343, -0.0332597941160202, -0.013328362256288528, 0.029934726655483246, -0.049105945974588394, -0.011754118837416172, 0.04298954829573631, 0.019100356847047806, -0.057617589831352234, 0.038378067314624786, 0.021402426064014435, -0.02012246660888195, -0.04776812344789505, -0.01539083756506443, -0.03251678869128227, 0.02575526013970375, -0.024990545585751534, 0.023883802816271782, 0.06591913849115372, 0.020269319415092468, -0.039658769965171814, 0.022031791508197784, -0.03071117214858532, 0.03874410316348076, -0.012198842130601406, 0.027330920100212097, 0.0057306792587041855, 0.02838849648833275, 0.031100424006581306, -0.024480221793055534, 0.07423467189073563, 0.03678373247385025, 0.01848846860229969, -0.002541501773521304, 0.006512526422739029, 0.023165466263890266, 0.007110303733497858, 0.05812336131930351, 0.07987545430660248, -0.1228080615401268, -0.01872965320944786, -0.001478578895330429, -0.02185700088739395, -0.03326134383678436, -0.028413841500878334, -0.011675355024635792, -0.017192384228110313, 0.0077616507187485695, 0.005204737652093172, -0.008154358714818954, -0.024060644209384918, -0.020752158015966415, 0.0033698342740535736, -0.008773538284003735, -0.016621291637420654, 0.035255514085292816, -0.015883851796388626, -0.026254184544086456, 0.12665778398513794, 0.04823625460267067, -0.012115216813981533, 0.046103768050670624, 0.050730880349874496, -0.0012708412250503898, -0.0247246902436018, -0.04028637334704399, -0.046627480536699295, 0.002112588845193386, 0.008476410992443562, -0.006878645159304142, 0.02249368652701378, 0.02760339342057705, 0.010539400391280651, 0.015779390931129456, 0.015406426042318344, -0.02193850837647915, 0.035066135227680206, -0.009142997674643993, -0.0330585315823555, -0.0347399041056633, 0.015229344367980957, 0.010972465388476849, 0.027394570410251617, -0.04537220299243927, -0.05920930951833725, -0.0034420820884406567, 0.03677450865507126, 0.002020130632445216, 0.0028832138050347567, 0.008831270970404148, -0.02602693811058998, 0.03842293098568916, -0.015672747045755386, -0.09058140963315964, -0.04257805272936821, 0.016104750335216522, 2.908663532252831e-07, 0.0017653326503932476, 0.050092097371816635, -0.02449018880724907, -0.07402390986680984, -0.008487996645271778, -0.014599940739572048, 0.004036494065076113, -0.04529949650168419, -0.027490543201565742, 0.033798348158597946, 0.08592015504837036, -0.05163276195526123, 0.017931882292032242, -0.0037609159480780363, -0.006511170417070389, -0.005009590182453394, -0.012133157812058926, 0.06453432142734528, 0.038863662630319595, 0.05113551393151283, -0.0010392048861831427, 0.061872515827417374, 0.0215251874178648, -0.040352463722229004, 0.03907078877091408, -0.0015068609500303864, -0.021116014569997787, 0.027279773727059364, 0.06528167426586151, 0.0635373592376709, -0.05560975521802902, 0.011956878937780857, -0.03370623663067818, -0.012863571755588055, -0.007349840365350246, 0.02959655597805977, 0.040506236255168915, -0.002590880496427417, -0.03084677644073963, -0.061187323182821274, 0.03522954508662224, 0.00515811238437891, 0.016019398346543312, 0.02974751964211464, 0.008777475915849209, 0.0261059757322073, -0.04907251521945, -0.055337004363536835, 0.01483277790248394, -0.0009933767141774297, 0.06101292371749878, -0.04051388427615166, 0.015411926433444023, -0.022780604660511017, -0.042046237736940384, -0.04672904685139656, 0.002254967810586095, -0.010439443401992321, 0.0056642950512468815, 0.04524616524577141, -0.0278707817196846, -0.014900467358529568, -0.008259166032075882, -0.028102470561861992, 0.12828710675239563, 0.03146016225218773, 0.008967996574938297, 2.152532194447156e-34, 0.025532525032758713, -0.006900380831211805, 0.033002760261297226, 0.01268432941287756, -0.06860668957233429, 0.027526846155524254, -0.023940663784742355, -0.06973245739936829, -0.005465417634695768, 0.029776938259601593, -0.031106265261769295]
676
676
['Jin-Hwa Kim', 'Kyoung-Woon On', 'Woosang Lim', 'Jeonghee Kim', 'Jung-Woo Ha', 'Byoung-Tak Zhang']
1610.04325v4
Bilinear models provide rich representations compared with linear models. They have been applied in various visual tasks, such as object recognition, segmentation, and visual question-answering, to get state-of-the-art performances taking advantage of the expanded representations. However, bilinear representations tend to be high-dimensional, limiting the applicability to computationally complex tasks. We propose low-rank bilinear pooling using Hadamard product for an efficient attention mechanism of multimodal learning. We show that our model outperforms compact bilinear pooling in visual question-answering tasks with the state-of-the-art results on the VQA dataset, having a better parsimonious property.
Hadamard Product for Low-rank Bilinear Pooling
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1610.04325v4
Title Hadamard Product Lowrank Bilinear Pooling Summary Bilinear model provide rich representation compared linear model applied various visual task object recognition segmentation visual questionanswering get stateoftheart performance taking advantage expanded representation However bilinear representation tend highdimensional limiting applicability computationally complex task propose lowrank bilinear pooling using Hadamard product efficient attention mechanism multimodal learning show model outperforms compact bilinear pooling visual questionanswering task stateoftheart result VQA dataset better parsimonious property Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.0004682496073655784, 0.014315168373286724, -0.02317340485751629, 0.02531825192272663, -0.029307929798960686, 0.017951473593711853, 0.04475909471511841, 0.023417161777615547, 0.02642686665058136, -0.04970598593354225, 0.0156943928450346, -0.0571695975959301, -0.01680913008749485, 0.017787916585803032, 0.0564383789896965, -0.09668026119470596, 0.014020562171936035, 0.020539548248052597, 0.008755335584282875, -0.04364711418747902, 0.032997675240039825, -0.020918628200888634, -0.02396223694086075, 0.02988833747804165, -0.0044812047854065895, -0.00732383644208312, -0.039443835616111755, -0.026128800585865974, 0.0031592596787959337, -0.013458057306706905, -0.03771952539682388, 0.0479285791516304, 0.03752826154232025, -0.03488185256719589, 2.6875334242504323e-06, -0.04304282367229462, -0.039729900658130646, -0.02976173162460327, 0.022580962628126144, -0.03199528157711029, -0.008476675488054752, -0.011028880253434181, 0.03249184787273407, -0.005266379099339247, -0.0037955832667648792, -0.02047780342400074, 0.06080785393714905, 0.08110404759645462, 0.06533949822187424, 0.003314388683065772, -0.015604537911713123, -0.018043752759695053, 0.03771162033081055, 0.0037625900004059076, -0.0019559883512556553, -0.028634976595640182, 0.0167878158390522, 0.04489200934767723, 0.013868548907339573, -0.003414420410990715, -0.04950054734945297, 0.05291162058711052, 0.005823081824928522, 0.05396462231874466, 0.07921557873487473, 0.06200876086950302, -0.011748244985938072, -0.0018035408575087786, -0.02143174596130848, 0.11292515695095062, -0.0974796786904335, -0.011179018765687943, -0.0035587504971772432, -3.5858131013810635e-05, 0.0038410723209381104, 0.018357256427407265, -0.059378329664468765, 0.009382914751768112, -0.011511927470564842, -0.011461671441793442, -0.049739956855773926, -0.004515055101364851, -0.007554883603006601, 0.0021370439790189266, -0.014698497951030731, -0.047968242317438126, -0.009364037774503231, -0.0028791246004402637, -0.027774689719080925, 0.005221757106482983, -0.07235527038574219, -0.03125361353158951, 0.01723332516849041, 0.029773930087685585, 0.03451980650424957, -0.013857454061508179, -0.008912332355976105, -0.07854609191417694, -0.0013812534743919969, -0.042153991758823395, 0.04015062376856804, -0.026930099353194237, -0.09536495804786682, 0.05889634042978287, -0.023722359910607338, 0.04672560468316078, -0.06463712453842163, 0.030282139778137207, -0.024873454123735428, 0.03877388313412666, -0.007731244899332523, 0.00814204290509224, -0.02943374589085579, 0.03780703619122505, -0.020983098074793816, -0.057295866310596466, -0.006640757899731398, 0.0006034463876858354, -0.004577851854264736, -0.040925417095422745, 0.00462373299524188, 0.018264899030327797, 0.031323302537202835, -0.018503746017813683, -0.025775209069252014, 0.014514257200062275, -0.033553749322891235, 0.0413171723484993, -0.027650464326143265, -0.034516431391239166, 0.0015694925095885992, 0.03307708352804184, 0.031151315197348595, -0.024959146976470947, 0.009553668089210987, 0.05851123854517937, -0.017612000927329063, -0.04978623986244202, -0.05454884096980095, -0.020162051543593407, -0.019990580156445503, -0.00771940965205431, 0.056512296199798584, -0.02943253703415394, 0.09213946014642715, -0.03578001260757446, 0.019395312294363976, 0.004357785917818546, -0.011841444298624992, -0.003245959524065256, -0.010353636927902699, 0.09140240401029587, 0.011262492276728153, 0.015222761780023575, 0.03375609964132309, -0.0031527604442089796, 0.06324059516191483, 0.04680399224162102, 0.04465591534972191, 0.04756913334131241, 0.027253631502389908, -0.03080069273710251, 0.01135398168116808, 0.003204725682735443, -0.002027533482760191, -0.04192228987812996, -0.05619923397898674, 0.005805443972349167, -0.019892487674951553, 0.035187143832445145, -0.0014772103168070316, 0.020252540707588196, -0.027050195261836052, -0.0021167851518839598, 0.04535108059644699, 0.05955694615840912, 0.036261916160583496, 0.04848603531718254, -0.03194943442940712, -0.028807956725358963, -0.0032743720803409815, -0.000329275120748207, 0.007182955741882324, 0.10627749562263489, 0.03351922705769539, -0.03415841981768608, 0.026810964569449425, -0.005253445822745562, -0.025620147585868835, -0.022689640522003174, 0.0075352988205850124, -0.01695612445473671, -0.020276429131627083, 0.029729695990681648, 0.05485309287905693, -0.009883315302431583, -0.042121436446905136, 0.02818993665277958, 0.003163855290040374, 0.007529868744313717, -0.02903333120048046, -0.06277786940336227, 0.07362498342990875, -0.00017804562230594456, 0.010216095484793186, -0.025037387385964394, 0.02992251329123974, -0.027892397716641426, 0.02450557053089142, -0.036189768463373184, -0.02958984114229679, 0.007803145796060562, -0.007092279382050037, -0.059885650873184204, -0.0198132935911417, -0.017208218574523926, -0.008485338650643826, 0.009606264531612396, -0.03541083261370659, -0.014000053517520428, -0.023819999769330025, -0.014037233777344227, 0.059612125158309937, 0.025646774098277092, 0.04893208295106888, 0.020736325532197952, -0.005793347489088774, 0.0533897764980793, -0.006952513474971056, -0.009633539244532585, 0.027444886043667793, 0.02457914687693119, 0.01889992691576481, -0.06451471149921417, -0.0047075459733605385, -0.029916686937212944, -0.02952009253203869, -0.042909905314445496, -0.01415644958615303, -0.021411102265119553, 0.03775188326835632, 0.03848602622747421, -0.013219892047345638, -0.013583228923380375, 0.011223787441849709, -0.015966104343533516, -0.03649898245930672, -0.04974529892206192, 0.009937157854437828, 0.03558163717389107, 0.0302524883300066, -0.06985504180192947, 0.07393007725477219, -0.06225740909576416, -0.0019974070601165295, -0.058629270642995834, -0.018766382709145546, 0.022263681516051292, -0.04936870187520981, -0.043906282633543015, 0.08437491208314896, -0.04911955073475838, 0.009257487021386623, -0.05641915276646614, -0.006621398497372866, -0.05567822605371475, 0.01699201948940754, -0.052525367587804794, 0.013386745937168598, -0.0103699816390872, -0.017682867124676704, 0.013619605451822281, -0.00837615318596363, 0.016819987446069717, -0.010895802639424801, -0.05639806389808655, 0.030214989557862282, -0.010650125332176685, 0.011852932162582874, 0.024018820375204086, -0.004881338216364384, 0.04530336707830429, 0.006543455645442009, -0.004856127314269543, -0.014483331702649593, 0.046445295214653015, 0.010743428952991962, -0.043258823454380035, -0.003410276724025607, 0.03169945999979973, -0.038938555866479874, 0.03850620612502098, 0.012041362002491951, -0.018395455554127693, -0.0019821899477392435, -0.07658546417951584, 0.08678622543811798, 0.09610260277986526, 0.0022134953178465366, 0.008359800092875957, 0.014845630154013634, 0.014223601669073105, -0.021333295851945877, 0.015169811435043812, -0.009863543324172497, 0.04246446490287781, 0.05171043053269386, 0.03865651786327362, -0.011118670925498009, 0.007303349208086729, 0.020223084837198257, 0.005072390660643578, -0.022491715848445892, -0.008400540798902512, 0.0014843953540548682, -0.006790535524487495, -0.11059492826461792, -0.01369223091751337, -0.01377888210117817, 0.04092440381646156, -0.05522867292165756, -0.03413694351911545, 0.00461116898804903, 0.009693003259599209, 0.001546461833640933, 0.0061950478702783585, 0.02074330858886242, -0.02061156928539276, 0.03404415771365166, 0.020796293392777443, 0.025042004883289337, -0.028810953721404076, -0.020408378913998604, -0.0544513575732708, 0.00801043026149273, -0.056633975356817245, -0.04309209808707237, 0.03802414610981941, -0.007357124239206314, -0.00010465976811246946, -0.01857590675354004, -0.010565736331045628, -0.04661434888839722, 2.9082608307362534e-05, -0.007955927401781082, -0.004330125171691179, -0.013288076035678387, 0.04259771108627319, -0.03835824877023697, 0.051697034388780594, 0.02284845896065235, 0.010737874545156956, -0.008041986264288425, -0.004396382253617048, -0.004570782650262117, 0.1263340264558792, 0.047203753143548965, 0.04749199375510216, -0.02280195616185665, -0.024048825725913048, 0.030368249863386154, 0.08268189430236816, 0.04803615063428879, -0.012651766650378704, -0.05244942009449005, 0.017978928983211517, 0.040961895138025284, 0.035329531878232956, 0.0003318672825116664, 0.01060473918914795, 0.03151737153530121, -0.027867799624800682, 0.017969295382499695, 0.04338853806257248, 0.013261553831398487, -0.09505005925893784, -0.005265749525278807, -0.03870972618460655, -0.05041488632559776, 0.014879060909152031, -0.0029899226501584053, -0.042228586971759796, -0.03910311311483383, -0.022468551993370056, -0.023122064769268036, 0.01579803228378296, -0.04227912425994873, 0.01679784432053566, -0.0681830644607544, 0.032331399619579315, -0.030020667240023613, -0.06414803117513657, -0.011782554909586906, -0.017170347273349762, 0.009844581596553326, 0.008749490603804588, -0.06280719488859177, 0.006910914555191994, 0.0020892119500786066, -0.03523316979408264, 0.04356203228235245, 0.004248214419931173, 0.0267659779638052, 0.047722019255161285, -0.044450290501117706, -0.030184771865606308, 0.061508066952228546, 0.04740406572818756, -0.004780664574354887, -0.07096067070960999, 0.029668211936950684, -0.03642275184392929, -0.0008787090191617608, -0.005463595502078533, 0.017827903851866722, -0.020666399970650673, -0.02402045950293541, -0.019547002390027046, 0.03870934247970581, 0.021375494077801704, 0.02212391421198845, -0.00043828587513417006, 0.07465390861034393, -0.01346573792397976, 0.002739765215665102, -0.046359747648239136, 0.008395825512707233, -0.006204291712492704, -0.0014087471645325422, 0.03751146048307419, -0.020244857296347618, -0.009813744574785233, 0.03813819959759712, 0.027549413964152336, -0.0356086827814579, -0.05932817980647087, -0.003272749949246645, 0.01979931630194187, -0.01072243694216013, -0.07146680355072021, -0.008124158717691898, 0.04939493164420128, 0.058503519743680954, -0.010857404209673405, -0.048744067549705505, 0.010950910858809948, 0.007648023776710033, -0.013788449577987194, 0.042076632380485535, 0.0016234023496508598, 0.03414458408951759, -0.03064054623246193, 0.0040978919714689255, 0.013722879812121391, -0.046811822801828384, -0.03306771069765091, -0.0071812644600868225, -0.06711161136627197, 0.013512806035578251, -0.03031804785132408, 0.04757268354296684, 0.004324689507484436, -0.04765981063246727, -0.00735003175213933, -0.05806244909763336, -0.027542712166905403, 0.00849937554448843, 0.005326759535819292, 0.00607316242530942, -0.03638821467757225, -0.004099818877875805, -0.024100614711642265, 0.014512826688587666, -0.010187850333750248, 0.04818599298596382, 0.015403944067656994, 0.0031760435085743666, -0.058946117758750916, -0.0020158225670456886, -0.012069049291312695, 0.029288996011018753, 0.08269279450178146, 0.039028771221637726, 0.0008059143438003957, -0.032231979072093964, 0.029585881158709526, 0.05582108348608017, 0.007934571243822575, -0.05471346527338028, 0.015970027074217796, 0.009906033053994179, -0.0015033738454803824, -0.005201777443289757, -0.02413346990942955, 0.05523884296417236, -0.03699803352355957, -0.011206013150513172, 0.00255011348053813, 0.01837168075144291, -0.015733815729618073, -0.054617322981357574, 0.037586018443107605, -0.01429226528853178, -0.009243810549378395, 0.021566687151789665, 0.04951491206884384, 0.03338691219687462, 0.10313807427883148, -0.0011969899060204625, -0.04072979837656021, -0.03383706510066986, 0.067856065928936, -0.0015029096975922585, -0.05371394753456116, -0.019181402400135994, 0.04043667018413544, 0.031009722501039505, -0.025158027186989784, -0.037306707352399826, 0.05713507533073425, -0.014704277738928795, -0.032836463302373886, 0.05628550425171852, -0.027491658926010132, -0.03093775548040867, 0.08124618232250214, 0.03486480191349983, 0.022507663816213608, -0.05157345160841942, 0.04924377053976059, 0.019277537241578102, 0.006405593827366829, -0.01193971373140812, 0.009363827295601368, -0.051647257059812546, -0.012338580563664436, 0.03571876138448715, 0.05389085412025452, 0.015822188928723335, 0.043307770043611526, -0.036312516778707504, -0.03532208874821663, -0.011508729308843613, -0.0040528178215026855, 0.04346476495265961, 0.011914779432117939, 0.009931213222444057, 0.06717610359191895, -0.00045362053788267076, -0.021367104724049568, -0.03403497487306595, 0.02663770131766796, -0.017780598253011703, -0.010655838064849377, -0.012034829705953598, -6.89860239083565e-33, -0.022876376286149025, -0.021675115451216698, 0.011269038543105125, -0.11985807865858078, -0.06461052596569061, 0.015047839842736721, -0.01279678288847208, 0.028225982561707497, -0.05187147855758667, -0.029885511845350266, 0.00366468564607203, -0.03825337439775467, -0.002465001307427883, 0.003024944569915533, 0.026683008298277855, -0.03968503698706627, -0.01298891007900238, 0.008479914627969265, 0.021182764321565628, 0.034161049872636795, 0.04549965634942055, 0.013267782516777515, 0.044353727251291275, 0.009409790858626366, -0.06068825721740723, 0.0010845126817002892, -0.028955474495887756, 0.037769194692373276, -0.00027896801475435495, 0.02677043341100216, -0.04986995831131935, 0.008800090290606022, 0.053752172738313675, -0.03918289765715599, -0.009078431874513626, 0.03478522226214409, -0.07800375670194626, -0.011659453622996807, 0.012226828373968601, -0.005928300321102142, -0.09153474867343903, 0.010111651383340359, 0.03735420107841492, 0.035154007375240326, 0.04157349839806557, -0.03566936403512955, 0.051989004015922546, -0.03022223711013794, -0.029653050005435944, 0.01377773005515337, 0.004910555202513933, 0.01303604431450367, -0.02813439816236496, -0.026419421657919884, 0.03514568507671356, 0.031163569539785385, 0.005790323484688997, 0.06729941815137863, -0.05879201740026474, 0.0415366031229496, -0.032738056033849716, -0.025862621143460274, 0.05517151206731796, 0.03160012885928154, 0.00545958848670125, 0.03639554604887962, 0.008099156431853771, -0.05161794647574425, -0.025784892961382866, -0.0032133557833731174, 0.016512416303157806, 0.08483478426933289, 0.05912069231271744, -0.010865751653909683, 0.0033152091782540083, 0.024477465078234673, -0.05228381231427193, 0.02288944087922573, -0.02618885226547718, 0.059546422213315964, -0.01723930612206459, 0.005572143476456404, -0.02385815605521202, 0.012076398357748985, 0.03548683971166611, 0.018964990973472595, -0.05526071414351463, 0.005873565096408129, 0.03777522221207619, -0.007170586381107569, -0.028923174366354942, 0.04209282621741295, 0.057103004306554794, -0.021958108991384506, 0.029818590730428696, -0.021697118878364563, 0.014751879498362541, 0.05060078203678131, 0.025354014709591866, -0.010930974036455154, -0.05015551671385765, 0.015392270870506763, 0.016177944839000702, -0.012564239092171192, -0.01650938391685486, 0.035508301109075546, 0.03702259808778763, -0.04442260041832924, -0.040335189551115036, -0.03066812828183174, -0.04410996288061142, -0.04215314984321594, -0.0018062986200675368, 0.10595422983169556, -0.014645463787019253, 0.007703625597059727, -0.0052653709426522255, 0.07702840864658356, -0.0045376368798315525, -0.018733957782387733, -0.030775144696235657, -0.014826315455138683, -0.020350640639662743, 0.04747414216399193, -0.03331025689840317, -0.014405681751668453, -0.05627921223640442, -0.025131523609161377, 0.024671878665685654, -0.06998006999492645, -0.027238186448812485, -0.0068199834786355495, 3.2763551871539676e-07, -2.1267725969664752e-05, -0.0017575016245245934, -0.035674236714839935, -0.028711851686239243, 0.006154694128781557, 0.016674797981977463, -0.00977687630802393, 0.08570875227451324, 0.0007242931169457734, -0.03919043019413948, 0.0003292399924248457, 0.054454684257507324, 0.0042953756637871265, -0.035625699907541275, -0.05582278594374657, 0.010147462598979473, -0.010909833945333958, 0.024744007736444473, -0.040829651057720184, -0.00808764435350895, 0.08105392009019852, 0.05150701105594635, 0.0007433231803588569, -0.004210344981402159, 0.018295086920261383, 0.002711678622290492, 0.03937353193759918, 0.009839261882007122, 0.0015656319446861744, -0.009278977289795876, 0.002227142918854952, 0.034150008112192154, -0.032972607761621475, 0.028036605566740036, 0.007368671242147684, 0.007196021731942892, 0.06480672955513, 0.028699183836579323, -0.009133265353739262, -0.049294229596853256, 0.020524902269244194, 0.04604173079133034, -0.008535115979611874, -0.051967088133096695, 0.10222120583057404, -0.0211067833006382, -0.04970578849315643, -0.04773725941777229, -0.010889825411140919, 0.011146679520606995, 0.032639339566230774, 0.02784961462020874, -0.01048845425248146, 0.008137810975313187, -0.011809362098574638, -0.061526164412498474, 0.045995764434337616, -0.05198036506772041, 0.022083453834056854, -0.028537826612591743, -0.033241741359233856, -0.00607472937554121, -0.022586356848478317, -0.02145330049097538, 0.036016594618558884, -0.009717652574181557, -0.07093094289302826, 2.7442840862570094e-34, -0.003791307331994176, 0.025356126949191093, 0.012501699849963188, 0.04379478842020035, -0.015173041261732578, -0.04257161542773247, -0.009329442866146564, -0.030528241768479347, -0.0031651591416448355, -0.07475542277097702, -0.017121100798249245]
677
677
['Aojun Zhou', 'Anbang Yao', 'Yiwen Guo', 'Lin Xu', 'Yurong Chen']
1702.03044v2
This paper presents incremental network quantization (INQ), a novel method, targeting to efficiently convert any pre-trained full-precision convolutional neural network (CNN) model into a low-precision version whose weights are constrained to be either powers of two or zero. Unlike existing methods which are struggled in noticeable accuracy loss, our INQ has the potential to resolve this issue, as benefiting from two innovations. On one hand, we introduce three interdependent operations, namely weight partition, group-wise quantization and re-training. A well-proven measure is employed to divide the weights in each layer of a pre-trained CNN model into two disjoint groups. The weights in the first group are responsible to form a low-precision base, thus they are quantized by a variable-length encoding method. The weights in the other group are responsible to compensate for the accuracy loss from the quantization, thus they are the ones to be re-trained. On the other hand, these three operations are repeated on the latest re-trained group in an iterative manner until all the weights are converted into low-precision ones, acting as an incremental network quantization and accuracy enhancement procedure. Extensive experiments on the ImageNet classification task using almost all known deep CNN architectures including AlexNet, VGG-16, GoogleNet and ResNets well testify the efficacy of the proposed method. Specifically, at 5-bit quantization, our models have improved accuracy than the 32-bit floating-point references. Taking ResNet-18 as an example, we further show that our quantized models with 4-bit, 3-bit and 2-bit ternary weights have improved or very similar accuracy against its 32-bit floating-point baseline. Besides, impressive results with the combination of network pruning and INQ are also reported. The code is available at https://github.com/Zhouaojun/Incremental-Network-Quantization.
Incremental Network Quantization: Towards Lossless CNNs with Low-Precision Weights
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1702.03044v2
Title Incremental Network Quantization Towards Lossless CNNs LowPrecision Weights Summary paper present incremental network quantization INQ novel method targeting efficiently convert pretrained fullprecision convolutional neural network CNN model lowprecision version whose weight constrained either power two zero Unlike existing method struggled noticeable accuracy loss INQ potential resolve issue benefiting two innovation one hand introduce three interdependent operation namely weight partition groupwise quantization retraining wellproven measure employed divide weight layer pretrained CNN model two disjoint group weight first group responsible form lowprecision base thus quantized variablelength encoding method weight group responsible compensate accuracy loss quantization thus one retrained hand three operation repeated latest retrained group iterative manner weight converted lowprecision one acting incremental network quantization accuracy enhancement procedure Extensive experiment ImageNet classification task using almost known deep CNN architecture including AlexNet VGG16 GoogleNet ResNets well testify efficacy proposed method Specifically 5bit quantization model improved accuracy 32bit floatingpoint reference Taking ResNet18 example show quantized model 4bit 3bit 2bit ternary weight improved similar accuracy 32bit floatingpoint baseline Besides impressive result combination network pruning INQ also reported code available httpsgithubcomZhouaojunIncrementalNetworkQuantization Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.02954309619963169, 0.0442105196416378, 0.0049345605075359344, 0.053062520921230316, 0.03744306415319443, -0.01931591145694256, 0.034151557832956314, 0.03957200050354004, -0.053639624267816544, 0.000521279638633132, 0.009054725989699364, 0.016831547021865845, -0.01895867846906185, 0.02614227496087551, 0.031029893085360527, -0.022945625707507133, 0.022413527593016624, 0.03818542882800102, 0.012361647561192513, -0.010275392793118954, 0.03548687696456909, -0.02684422768652439, 0.010712271556258202, -0.004747739993035793, -0.029147805646061897, -0.008645609952509403, -0.002901245839893818, 0.03897269442677498, 0.007319515570998192, -0.00361616094596684, 0.04304955154657364, 0.008142801932990551, 0.042411919683218, 0.0027565392665565014, 2.4715163817745633e-06, 0.021626068279147148, -0.01850428804755211, -0.02668001689016819, -0.040381159633398056, 0.005452295765280724, -0.009597696363925934, 0.017141137272119522, -0.01544205378741026, -0.0024009563494473696, -0.015962019562721252, 0.0008546558092348278, 0.03476613759994507, 0.04779338091611862, 0.035107385367155075, 0.05142408609390259, 0.007935806177556515, -0.03802843764424324, 0.027789495885372162, 0.0012234264286234975, -0.01584627293050289, -0.021503053605556488, -0.03353353217244148, 0.08026910573244095, -0.06272121518850327, -0.02637306973338127, -0.014068115502595901, 0.000689451233483851, 0.06197956204414368, 0.006366085726767778, -0.029456578195095062, 0.018963849171996117, -0.028785301372408867, 0.0007487848633900285, -0.003524456638842821, 0.02997007593512535, -0.11095204204320908, 0.002400602912530303, -0.047658830881118774, -0.014317270368337631, -0.003202610881999135, -0.12578503787517548, -0.028635717928409576, -0.005230354145169258, 0.024765847250819206, 0.041770629584789276, -0.10446054488420486, 0.03232426196336746, 0.01692516729235649, 0.04441598057746887, -0.017430758103728294, 0.006577522959560156, -0.03185475617647171, 0.05112568289041519, -0.0293277520686388, -0.02994810789823532, -0.09566377103328705, -0.03528701141476631, -0.003118565073236823, 0.00664026103913784, 0.018325848504900932, -0.04037921130657196, -0.06916197389364243, -0.035599105060100555, -0.003091070568189025, -0.045042943209409714, -0.028486860916018486, 0.04252411052584648, -0.0063423048704862595, -0.028828592970967293, -0.015766385942697525, 0.030158687382936478, -0.027331136167049408, 0.05322623252868652, -0.035587552934885025, 0.03528923913836479, 0.01608467847108841, 0.0019494681619107723, -0.04774560406804085, 0.07507975399494171, -0.01059842947870493, -0.016765573993325233, -0.06503861397504807, -0.019181732088327408, -0.05048977956175804, -0.051232125610113144, 0.012740648351609707, 0.0719313845038414, -0.004299855791032314, -0.038850560784339905, 0.026664653792977333, 0.018375338986516, -0.014040754176676273, 0.025479568168520927, 0.03316739946603775, -0.0340210497379303, 0.013529769144952297, 0.011939121410250664, 0.016042795032262802, 0.010856788605451584, 0.04408176615834236, 0.003156035440042615, -0.0016592611791566014, -0.014438473619520664, -0.029477380216121674, -0.00799920316785574, 0.009984264150261879, -0.022256283089518547, -0.022367577999830246, -0.0662984624505043, -0.016809877008199692, -0.033293697983026505, -0.002356376964598894, -0.03613433614373207, -0.009503440000116825, 0.01020786538720131, -0.00029340997571125627, 0.04193849861621857, -0.04662683978676796, -0.03544379770755768, 0.043192218989133835, 0.006143069826066494, 0.04430454969406128, 0.04437641799449921, 0.07860606163740158, 0.04673817753791809, -0.010158819146454334, 0.0068503026850521564, -0.06885944306850433, -0.018467938527464867, 0.036550138145685196, -0.050481636077165604, -0.07823287695646286, -0.04135051369667053, -0.0316271036863327, 0.02294771745800972, 0.06254000961780548, 0.03839629888534546, -0.0635373517870903, -0.05263494700193405, -0.010709961876273155, -0.018754206597805023, 0.05613952502608299, 0.03298763930797577, -0.0075609409250319, -0.017642054706811905, 0.014428636059165001, -0.028277738019824028, -0.03416372463107109, 0.04833518713712692, -0.00504400534555316, -0.0534684881567955, 0.016509436070919037, 0.013981846161186695, -0.05015995725989342, -0.047904785722494125, 0.014694951474666595, -0.01973663829267025, 0.010781108401715755, -0.004500557202845812, 0.022885719314217567, 0.026697954162955284, 0.016940420493483543, 0.06633352488279343, 0.006805088371038437, -0.025346674025058746, 0.009147287346422672, -0.04643726348876953, -0.018546033650636673, -0.036737110465765, -0.002139589050784707, 0.003482616040855646, 0.019831884652376175, 0.03133709356188774, 0.03250015154480934, -0.07677818834781647, -0.024900145828723907, 0.004266536794602871, -0.0021260578650981188, -0.05906376615166664, -0.011442790739238262, 0.009315517731010914, -0.028645049780607224, -0.022194020450115204, 0.0027212677523493767, 0.014422169886529446, 0.015444197691977024, -0.02319498546421528, -0.0014665506314486265, 0.0015333216870203614, 0.06716655194759369, -0.0025871542748063803, 0.04001496359705925, 0.007800231222063303, 0.010801093652844429, 0.029647886753082275, 0.029492339119315147, -0.03142046555876732, 0.03773379698395729, -0.030462415888905525, -0.013885324820876122, -0.08551622927188873, -0.024947810918092728, -0.04759921506047249, 0.05021392181515694, 0.029813354834914207, 0.09073442220687866, 0.019966861233115196, -0.04543020948767662, -0.032102376222610474, 0.03145390748977661, 0.02458280138671398, -0.0003908324579242617, -0.019164850935339928, -0.0006627074908465147, 0.013195138424634933, 0.02809804305434227, -0.02784060128033161, 0.010623237118124962, 0.00889306329190731, 0.01859262026846409, -0.028227491304278374, 0.019696900621056557, 0.016223695129156113, -0.034152526408433914, -0.015588968992233276, -0.013292944990098476, -0.042048048228025436, 0.030047105625271797, 0.0085471011698246, 0.013260021805763245, 0.021093234419822693, 0.0006119312020018697, -0.06927728652954102, 0.03420499339699745, -0.030312085524201393, 0.029012586921453476, 0.011714794673025608, 0.046252232044935226, 0.028396068140864372, -0.02501421608030796, -0.004716377705335617, 0.059514403343200684, -0.03591255098581314, -0.04950758442282677, 0.009351808577775955, -0.008386592380702496, 0.04584074765443802, 3.733039920916781e-05, -0.057232391089200974, 0.01600201614201069, 0.0519852451980114, -0.009108318015933037, -0.06480046361684799, -0.058746371418237686, 0.013677116483449936, -0.03000107780098915, 0.03364561125636101, 0.0012555076973512769, -0.07273563742637634, -0.007142537273466587, -0.0037407495547086, -0.032038286328315735, 0.05873415991663933, 0.030774619430303574, 0.018074704334139824, 0.015322770923376083, 0.0714017003774643, -0.04916011542081833, 0.04257757589221001, -0.005195663310587406, -0.05150797963142395, 0.019520461559295654, 0.04046419635415077, -0.05933833867311478, 0.010768676176667213, -0.03271951898932457, 0.004989766515791416, -0.014414137229323387, 0.03953166678547859, -0.0005364478565752506, 0.008997354656457901, -0.027179677039384842, 0.03119407594203949, -0.005623046308755875, -0.013233240693807602, 0.01219314057379961, -0.01402250211685896, -0.044507771730422974, 0.026723084971308708, -0.015371658839285374, 0.005079502705484629, -0.03291089087724686, 0.03428215906023979, 0.008365756832063198, 0.0727274939417839, 0.062248364090919495, -0.00435472559183836, -0.009263458661735058, -0.07477858662605286, 0.00036685506347566843, -0.029983216896653175, -0.014790046960115433, 0.032875362783670425, 0.039425306022167206, 0.034996453672647476, -0.04677288234233856, 0.006090573500841856, -0.02876504883170128, 0.014860343188047409, 0.0361696258187294, 0.04757053777575493, -0.013378771021962166, -0.0023552202619612217, 0.06011779606342316, 0.03110048733651638, -0.020542940124869347, 0.022173337638378143, -0.027708545327186584, -0.001954571111127734, -0.014338675886392593, 0.014420093968510628, -0.02199610508978367, -0.01981557533144951, 0.026134932413697243, 0.06609061360359192, 0.015896456316113472, 0.03528730198740959, -0.025076840072870255, 0.05683062598109245, -0.08947708457708359, 0.0008661040919832885, -0.03178298473358154, 0.015439345501363277, 0.0033811607863754034, 0.013872381299734116, 0.07309117168188095, -0.031166136264801025, 0.05678015574812889, -0.013756852596998215, -0.0028496694285422564, -0.08202460408210754, 0.007796379271894693, 0.010687083005905151, -0.028808584436774254, 0.019028423354029655, 0.0032464670948684216, -0.07461685687303543, -0.01797577552497387, 0.004711690824478865, -0.02343711256980896, -0.00346968462690711, -0.01722382940351963, -0.02680348977446556, -0.03283034265041351, 0.003766040550544858, 0.04134049639105797, 0.0127071812748909, 0.023470066487789154, 0.03958588093519211, 0.0008635937119834125, -0.026745304465293884, 0.03945290669798851, 0.042374443262815475, 0.025612203404307365, -0.004570025019347668, 0.05638294667005539, -0.01139252819120884, -0.018466822803020477, -0.02446839027106762, -0.045667074620723724, -0.005966734606772661, 0.00478243175894022, 0.013327197171747684, -0.04064306244254112, 0.013184254989027977, 0.04315587133169174, -0.032900530844926834, -0.025641826912760735, -0.012186265550553799, 0.04564296454191208, 0.06140907481312752, -0.0364559069275856, 0.05250959098339081, 0.037318069487810135, -0.011004490777850151, 0.0030760839581489563, -0.004649663344025612, -0.007727242074906826, -0.00019438911112956703, 0.007375113666057587, -0.020973455160856247, -0.0433771088719368, -0.013087065890431404, -0.03706478700041771, 0.007196239195764065, -0.011153110302984715, 0.002395557938143611, -0.010354715399444103, 0.031697385013103485, -0.035993874073028564, 0.018090128898620605, 0.0006537599838338792, -0.002905692206695676, -0.05373980849981308, -0.026904713362455368, 0.00939987599849701, -0.023563049733638763, 0.039298005402088165, -0.02694418653845787, -0.05971284583210945, 0.043643031269311905, 0.01812751591205597, -0.09127778559923172, -0.02037820965051651, 0.013150999322533607, 0.020624814555048943, -0.024026991799473763, 0.019136477261781693, 0.012193935923278332, -0.008979055099189281, -0.006838275585323572, -0.10235602408647537, -0.06745996326208115, 0.006852456368505955, -0.031080346554517746, 0.04055832326412201, -0.008098023012280464, 0.010511821135878563, -0.008563380688428879, -0.03146370127797127, 0.057552289217710495, 0.03916503116488457, 0.02889893390238285, 0.01519326027482748, 0.016337119042873383, -0.027707085013389587, -0.01103818416595459, 0.03614891692996025, -0.0020072078332304955, 0.0852745920419693, 0.010540287010371685, 0.012855708599090576, -0.06028248369693756, -0.01686732843518257, 0.0029848928097635508, -0.011840466409921646, 0.052540507167577744, 0.03175801411271095, 0.019852126017212868, -0.0008366726688109338, 0.026302332058548927, 0.017140498384833336, 0.019967323169112206, -0.0595538392663002, 0.004327080212533474, 0.008423847146332264, 0.032384611666202545, 0.004818412009626627, -0.022952497005462646, 0.08936135470867157, -0.07524596154689789, 0.10498838126659393, -0.004768286366015673, -0.08954273164272308, 0.1096825823187828, -0.012150457128882408, 0.021886706352233887, -0.05021234601736069, -0.03407825157046318, 0.020034771412611008, 0.010738146491348743, -0.0455147922039032, -0.011575691401958466, 0.02377292700111866, 0.009947972372174263, -0.08276580274105072, 0.05228397250175476, 0.07156716287136078, 0.00645946292206645, -0.07006999105215073, -0.008996248245239258, 0.005153018049895763, 0.046494197100400925, -0.03689130023121834, 0.020957322791218758, 0.016465844586491585, -0.02879837341606617, 0.004665278363972902, 0.013454211875796318, 0.014413498342037201, 0.02133607491850853, 0.009868443943560123, -0.017234906554222107, -0.024808399379253387, 0.0024806249421089888, -0.02958681806921959, -0.010024698451161385, -0.04674593731760979, -0.0008494817302562296, 0.026997268199920654, 0.0011575245298445225, -0.07316122949123383, 0.03808446601033211, 0.044235244393348694, 0.016625147312879562, 0.0819464921951294, 0.02184395305812359, 0.016503458842635155, 0.03198392316699028, 0.0352037139236927, 0.0017715977737680078, 0.02953336201608181, -0.007222557440400124, -0.005480078049004078, -0.04230928793549538, 0.0038989305030554533, -0.060662806034088135, 0.024423422291874886, 0.029547782614827156, -0.019848208874464035, -6.392611582208166e-33, -0.0033952936064451933, 0.008228848688304424, 0.0258207768201828, -0.007179001346230507, -0.05069614574313164, 0.04385753348469734, 0.016776232048869133, -0.017117522656917572, -0.028624676167964935, -0.015331914648413658, -0.013322475366294384, 0.02903965301811695, 0.010954231023788452, 0.0071664596907794476, -0.011482291854918003, -0.0036650795955210924, 0.04685065895318985, -0.014089607633650303, 0.04684847220778465, 0.03867897018790245, 0.01499886717647314, 0.012278977781534195, 0.05515226349234581, 0.017437830567359924, -0.07519636303186417, 0.05561235547065735, -0.02466123178601265, 0.011758387088775635, 0.029460769146680832, -0.006678305100649595, 0.005555535666644573, 0.01280873641371727, 0.027262713760137558, 0.023479187861084938, -0.0006149786058813334, -0.049176786094903946, -0.08450882881879807, -0.021280396729707718, -0.045892782509326935, 0.07193565368652344, 0.013842655345797539, -0.023379281163215637, 0.09538264572620392, -0.0075926510617136955, -0.05219736695289612, -0.04693710803985596, 0.008984435349702835, -0.00396216195076704, -0.023904649540781975, -0.020923543721437454, -0.009434645064175129, 0.021358739584684372, 0.03087552823126316, 0.019539514556527138, 0.006605277769267559, -0.0027430749032646418, -0.028210921213030815, -0.049777552485466, -0.09286944568157196, -0.02672775648534298, 0.01588476076722145, 0.06837330758571625, -0.018704446032643318, 0.02430146187543869, 0.00975759793072939, 0.0075950282625854015, 0.04477953165769577, -0.03442453593015671, -0.030927009880542755, 0.030482562258839607, 0.03617735952138901, 0.011247138492763042, 0.05442754551768303, 0.01920239068567753, 0.15121279656887054, -0.0734562948346138, -0.06437234580516815, -0.00017628354544285685, -0.06041514873504639, 0.011540812440216541, -0.019603097811341286, 0.049843281507492065, 0.016243310645222664, -0.025751465931534767, 0.03326049819588661, -0.03901353105902672, -0.01731610670685768, -0.10177712887525558, -0.015618185512721539, 0.00719864759594202, -0.012652534060180187, 0.04255985468626022, 0.0035719864536076784, -0.04712353274226189, 0.011361604556441307, -0.026332557201385498, 0.03548569977283478, 0.032294392585754395, 0.029857294633984566, -0.005520030856132507, 0.011638998985290527, -0.016888374462723732, -0.01615682803094387, -0.00277717225253582, 0.00865291990339756, 0.016855889931321144, 0.06332802772521973, 0.07059823721647263, 0.04062735289335251, -0.0506795197725296, -0.008189431391656399, -0.0558323934674263, 0.010564702562987804, 0.06259909272193909, 0.00045734370360150933, 0.023328660055994987, 0.01085926778614521, 0.0524321123957634, -0.016447648406028748, -0.026849357411265373, -0.017396409064531326, -0.02341645397245884, 0.06382474303245544, 0.06929823011159897, -0.0705001950263977, -0.033353619277477264, -0.024831587448716164, 0.059915632009506226, -0.005774775054305792, -0.08088488131761551, -0.033705830574035645, 0.03348121419548988, 3.14183751015662e-07, 0.0013048927066847682, -0.05482209473848343, -0.028223982080817223, -0.07227234542369843, -0.02871924266219139, -0.025381101295351982, 0.03848723694682121, 0.022485900670289993, -0.03714330866932869, -0.004917338024824858, 0.019045136868953705, -0.003504397114738822, -0.03446057438850403, 0.0034966478124260902, -0.016998009756207466, 0.006858560256659985, 0.02162913791835308, 0.00851215235888958, 0.02007109858095646, 0.0067583476193249226, 0.04451528564095497, 0.04834618419408798, 0.0352044403553009, -0.023222774267196655, 0.08113788068294525, 0.014727029018104076, -0.020515158772468567, 0.05346158891916275, 0.03740888088941574, 0.00707900570705533, 0.041224222630262375, 0.020341986790299416, 0.022105185315012932, -0.04659634456038475, 0.018182052299380302, 0.004056863021105528, -0.011877581477165222, -0.0034893283154815435, -0.07257618755102158, 0.023272473365068436, -0.011023185215890408, 0.009283564984798431, 0.010495735332369804, 0.024133339524269104, 0.029213447123765945, -0.04282821714878082, -0.014087790623307228, -0.05621914938092232, 0.00857640989124775, -0.021226266399025917, -0.00015773285122122616, 0.012018954381346703, 0.00746886944398284, -0.00037152369623072445, 0.021564774215221405, -0.0183207206428051, -0.032674193382263184, -0.06924537569284439, 0.02843664400279522, 0.06387724727392197, -0.007947943173348904, -0.024194639176130295, -0.03131194785237312, -0.025744643062353134, 0.04895713925361633, 0.02359379641711712, -0.026509253308176994, 2.5580557049617673e-34, -0.0323820598423481, -0.014727299101650715, 0.013587296940386295, 0.00889972411096096, -0.04205838963389397, -0.011677274480462074, -0.003634202992543578, -0.010288700461387634, -0.05209960788488388, 0.03955403342843056, -0.05970942974090576]
678
678
['Dhanesh Ramachandram', 'Terrance DeVries']
1703.03372v3
We present a method for skin lesion segmentation for the ISIC 2017 Skin Lesion Segmentation Challenge. Our approach is based on a Fully Convolutional Network architecture which is trained end to end, from scratch, on a limited dataset. Our semantic segmentation architecture utilizes several recent innovations in particularly in the combined use of (i) use of atrous convolutions to increase the effective field of view of the network's receptive field without increasing the number of parameters, (ii) the use of network-in-network $1\times1$ convolution layers to add capacity to the network and (iii) state-of-art super-resolution upsampling of predictions using subpixel CNN layers. We reported a mean IOU score of 0.642 on the validation set provided by the organisers.
LesionSeg: Semantic segmentation of skin lesions using Deep Convolutional Neural Network
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1703.03372v3
Title LesionSeg Semantic segmentation skin lesion using Deep Convolutional Neural Network Summary present method skin lesion segmentation ISIC 2017 Skin Lesion Segmentation Challenge approach based Fully Convolutional Network architecture trained end end scratch limited dataset semantic segmentation architecture utilizes several recent innovation particularly combined use use atrous convolution increase effective field view network receptive field without increasing number parameter ii use networkinnetwork 1times1 convolution layer add capacity network iii stateofart superresolution upsampling prediction using subpixel CNN layer reported mean IOU score 0642 validation set provided organiser Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.03243638575077057, -0.0013901983620598912, 0.012587620876729488, 0.012158333323895931, 0.03590473160147667, 0.008580729365348816, 0.02405596151947975, 0.016792617738246918, -0.015188582241535187, 0.024354035034775734, 0.021119659766554832, 0.024920549243688583, -0.012242786586284637, 0.035538893193006516, -0.005660500843077898, -0.04895271733403206, -0.01784798502922058, 0.05402134731411934, 0.009135732427239418, -0.021510815247893333, 0.03556530922651291, -0.021952729672193527, 0.017599578946828842, 0.07858692109584808, -0.09312640875577927, 0.011038034223020077, 0.04546112194657326, 0.010660200379788876, -0.016303062438964844, -0.07358961552381516, 0.02589031495153904, -0.04783903807401657, 0.036786045879125595, 0.014146128669381142, 2.4008095351746306e-06, -0.04521014913916588, -0.0038144115824252367, -0.02133997343480587, 0.009983777068555355, -0.03501001372933388, 0.046083346009254456, -0.04153607413172722, -0.00197413912974298, -0.0720500648021698, 0.014752647839486599, 0.010284951888024807, -0.0013066729297861457, 0.09481298923492432, 0.02598683536052704, 0.0749075636267662, -0.0072893560864031315, -0.021476024761795998, 0.056939609348773956, 0.04767386242747307, 0.018369801342487335, -0.048329491168260574, -0.010555149987339973, 0.017815491184592247, -0.07747461646795273, -0.09406264871358871, 0.0001246520405402407, 0.06284043192863464, 0.029719440266489983, -0.01219514012336731, 0.07260283827781677, 0.04466257244348526, -0.02935834601521492, -0.08276192098855972, -0.005202172324061394, 0.010272866114974022, -0.03055194765329361, 0.03176633641123772, -0.034978050738573074, 0.0008578823762945831, -0.030153827741742134, -0.05376758798956871, -0.0005035290378145874, 0.04840925708413124, 0.026440730318427086, 0.00907828938215971, -0.042502786964178085, 0.04803295433521271, 0.054401837289333344, 0.009649157524108887, -0.005863249767571688, 0.02846507355570793, 0.00354010914452374, 0.08083634823560715, -0.005060623399913311, -0.029951751232147217, -0.019015884026885033, -0.010061955079436302, 0.009921329095959663, 0.04612182080745697, -0.05662406235933304, -0.04581119492650032, -0.030277766287326813, -0.008639228530228138, 0.057295724749565125, 0.007227665279060602, 0.03231479600071907, -0.033323984593153, -0.06339327245950699, 0.04203302785754204, 0.00027274645981378853, -0.011125527322292328, -0.06498590856790543, 0.10762006789445877, -0.03455369547009468, -0.028795208781957626, 0.04973935708403587, -0.003331742947921157, -0.018532223999500275, 0.020239099860191345, 0.030027106404304504, -0.011106421239674091, -0.050294890999794006, -0.046111978590488434, -0.009849109686911106, -0.023315032944083214, 0.02154066041111946, 0.06234509497880936, -0.07393801212310791, -0.025616571307182312, -0.043225523084402084, -0.0265772994607687, 0.02132665365934372, 0.011520002968609333, -0.005425342824310064, 0.00514206662774086, 0.05331802740693092, 0.017258191481232643, -0.03435587137937546, -0.002623106585815549, 0.0033609685488045216, 0.03232676535844803, -0.0036339634098112583, 0.010010969825088978, -0.020010342821478844, 0.05302499979734421, 0.019039589911699295, -0.005843232851475477, 0.0074513256549835205, -0.03860758617520332, -0.024348970502614975, -0.046640507876873016, 0.05199937894940376, -0.0030099679715931416, -0.0015641116769984365, -0.024879740551114082, 0.008567363023757935, 0.037537410855293274, -0.059348586946725845, -0.03866364806890488, 0.06832992285490036, 0.038383081555366516, 0.019916338846087456, -0.043438129127025604, 0.08760499954223633, -0.0034662908874452114, 0.016247965395450592, -0.014432757161557674, -0.050213634967803955, -0.04909471794962883, -0.04081443324685097, -0.049781303852796555, -0.05299484357237816, -0.048522818833589554, 0.02535249851644039, 0.03162824362516403, -0.038650933653116226, 0.02552412822842598, 0.008283660747110844, -0.03630826994776726, -0.07471003383398056, 0.04317512735724449, 0.009316401556134224, 0.02877519652247429, -0.02583547867834568, 0.015429642982780933, -0.02582443691790104, -0.04073098674416542, 0.025589916855096817, 0.015528697520494461, 0.01890546642243862, -0.0041168080642819405, -0.004231880884617567, -0.007174178492277861, -0.02839040569961071, -0.048229530453681946, -0.017560603097081184, -0.039120662957429886, 0.032982535660266876, -0.030676979571580887, 0.009749866090714931, -0.0008613346726633608, -0.006626476068049669, -0.04977735877037048, 0.017750240862369537, 0.03681612387299538, -0.039194256067276, -0.08568966388702393, -0.0035918266512453556, -0.016622276976704597, 0.0033539847936481237, -0.029373036697506905, -0.029062539339065552, 0.014638461172580719, 0.017397340387105942, 0.0022019497118890285, -0.019904926419258118, 0.0015114772832021117, 0.0633528083562851, -0.048519592732191086, 0.02383885718882084, -0.004354896489530802, 0.00595585722476244, -0.0068493555299937725, 0.0020466328132897615, -0.02856048382818699, 0.019982581958174706, 0.01537478156387806, 0.04093483090400696, 0.04074452444911003, -0.006111379712820053, -0.0031259427778422832, -0.026206450536847115, -0.024221833795309067, 0.02013149857521057, -0.044984932988882065, -0.019937735050916672, -0.04474262148141861, 0.013038938865065575, -0.03131236881017685, -0.018479734659194946, -0.04174426198005676, -0.025508929044008255, -0.02994091995060444, 0.023559238761663437, -0.04013359546661377, -0.04294730722904205, 0.043776124715805054, -0.013241561129689217, -0.0017267586663365364, -0.010939385741949081, 0.03245771303772926, -0.043430693447589874, 0.01775374822318554, -0.027134723961353302, 0.042589448392391205, -0.020921779796481133, -0.024252543225884438, 0.02723054401576519, 0.03687214478850365, -0.054842766374349594, 0.025848940014839172, -0.00874068308621645, -0.025754665955901146, -0.03545866906642914, -0.018165428191423416, -0.0028415205888450146, -0.05043715611100197, -0.02394278533756733, -0.02626686915755272, 0.03868468850851059, -0.013767930679023266, -0.01571725308895111, -0.01806713081896305, 0.033749498426914215, 0.0009618920157663524, -0.07904689759016037, 0.003454010235145688, 0.02316637896001339, 0.029105016961693764, -0.06677869707345963, 0.013004963286221027, 0.05665397271513939, 0.015890929847955704, -0.021672498434782028, 0.04077000543475151, 0.01888967864215374, -0.0013338716235011816, -0.05465860664844513, -0.01265930850058794, 0.031044144183397293, -0.014886274002492428, 0.05901644378900528, -0.03127337247133255, 0.054432839155197144, 0.010176743380725384, -0.057642776519060135, 0.02444104477763176, 0.0159185491502285, -0.07538358122110367, -0.023114511743187904, -0.025251679122447968, -0.08530035614967346, 0.030551452189683914, 0.04422222822904587, 0.03953061252832413, -0.01796603761613369, 0.030512459576129913, 0.00955912470817566, -0.022109389305114746, -0.034663427621126175, -0.02376876398921013, 0.0045861429534852505, -0.01409993041306734, 0.0006818530382588506, 0.01789674162864685, 0.017581654712557793, 0.01812588982284069, 0.042560528963804245, -0.027039412409067154, -0.025033121928572655, -0.01883307285606861, -0.03324054181575775, 0.014850652776658535, -0.05159415304660797, 0.01698938012123108, -0.016371650621294975, -0.03658747673034668, 0.007542960345745087, 0.08770284801721573, 0.012405517511069775, -0.024026496335864067, -0.04538028687238693, 0.0004020193009637296, -0.02071703039109707, 0.02045132778584957, 0.027750905603170395, -0.06824620068073273, -0.017956282943487167, -0.013674057088792324, 0.021543951705098152, 0.02195725217461586, -0.012804350815713406, -0.0077655683271586895, 0.04261339083313942, -0.00653965026140213, 0.005109642166644335, -0.002015480073168874, -0.050837136805057526, -0.005653198808431625, 0.013555078767240047, 0.01971120946109295, 0.0014108812902122736, 0.04398611932992935, 0.05729084089398384, -0.02245628461241722, -0.014704816974699497, 0.08943404257297516, 0.010738910175859928, 0.0038748241495341063, -0.009503540582954884, 0.06191705912351608, -0.013384496793150902, -0.0008778704795986414, -0.05843750759959221, 0.06922946870326996, 0.05468875169754028, 0.054619211703538895, -0.05531018599867821, 0.009473156183958054, -0.09253496676683426, -0.011888021603226662, -0.056095100939273834, 0.0013645023573189974, 0.016629764810204506, -0.017707426100969315, 0.04259172081947327, -0.04015751928091049, -0.0031603777315467596, 0.05705583468079567, 0.018106894567608833, -0.058730874210596085, 0.015810377895832062, -0.0033318446949124336, -0.08632674813270569, -0.0022338491398841143, -0.02940318174660206, -0.00045614049304276705, -0.018503429368138313, 0.02559801936149597, -0.06677864491939545, 0.02006377838551998, 0.009181881323456764, 0.016934186220169067, 0.10803341865539551, 0.07149279862642288, -0.007385978940874338, -0.06639565527439117, -0.02600320801138878, 0.03589891269803047, 0.02607731707394123, 0.0316915400326252, -0.030541494488716125, 0.02448798343539238, 0.05392872914671898, -0.05719205364584923, 0.005157440900802612, -0.011212983168661594, -0.008866057731211185, 0.030137035995721817, 0.015406221151351929, -0.06122228130698204, 0.03838581219315529, 0.057662080973386765, -0.0018480842700228095, -0.005734242033213377, 0.08654456585645676, -0.027415364980697632, 0.013275418430566788, -0.03487910330295563, 0.09948723018169403, 0.028430119156837463, 0.002913036150857806, 0.015163143165409565, 0.08282854408025742, 0.009618334472179413, 0.047441206872463226, 0.026811782270669937, 0.002723188139498234, 0.013925387524068356, 0.03991645947098732, -0.03648451343178749, 0.0020501648541539907, 0.005974185653030872, -0.030907664448022842, 0.004480305593460798, 0.029322702437639236, -0.050966762006282806, -0.03231261670589447, 0.07093817740678787, 0.004965079482644796, -0.0005610068328678608, 0.07436195015907288, 0.0029838501941412687, -0.09705664217472076, -0.010752971284091473, -0.006424261722713709, -0.0074895452708005905, -0.023696621879935265, 0.05464277043938637, -0.0014825357357040048, -0.009304581210017204, -0.013083473779261112, -0.05635922774672508, 0.03889557719230652, 0.03721890598535538, 0.016956906765699387, 0.009329235181212425, 0.019299374893307686, 0.04967361316084862, 0.007829731330275536, 0.011711062863469124, -0.047294847667217255, -0.03929588943719864, -0.00776235107332468, 0.04861174523830414, 0.0005146548501215875, 0.003268473083153367, -0.003413523780182004, -0.09092744439840317, -0.0512365885078907, 0.003305169753730297, -0.012307684868574142, -0.037211667746305466, -0.016757680103182793, 0.03714944049715996, -0.04391861706972122, 0.044600214809179306, 0.042412515729665756, 0.0025010297540575266, 0.0801224634051323, -0.00955873541533947, -0.010103528387844563, -0.028127839788794518, -0.01181186642497778, 0.0393102802336216, 0.019576337188482285, 0.0760546401143074, 0.023604389280080795, 0.03691965714097023, -0.022433143109083176, 0.03595035523176193, 0.04590991884469986, 0.015275448560714722, -0.04023176431655884, 0.030469493940472603, 0.011796444654464722, -0.005312912166118622, 0.0105443075299263, -0.03552208095788956, 0.04667486995458603, 0.006741619668900967, 0.00515037402510643, 0.05009930953383446, 0.042804326862096786, 0.013809741474688053, 0.0498877689242363, 0.01854509301483631, 0.002747179474681616, -0.006812450010329485, -0.009321779944002628, 0.012836537323892117, 0.05108494684100151, -0.0010956419864669442, 0.039280928671360016, -0.0076367356814444065, -0.04282516613602638, 0.013791095465421677, 0.020908541977405548, 0.02667601965367794, -0.031607355922460556, 0.030783239752054214, 0.009691458195447922, -0.03196074068546295, -0.004972820635885, 0.04896846413612366, -0.0019647395238280296, -0.010764716193079948, 0.08821427822113037, -0.06887160986661911, -0.0777881070971489, 0.04828163981437683, 0.009587643668055534, 0.0023578153923153877, -0.01808713562786579, 0.022592563182115555, -0.02169341780245304, -0.06731287389993668, -0.00020184142340440303, -0.005562206730246544, -0.07279636710882187, 0.03467809036374092, 0.012813829816877842, 0.010399609804153442, -0.014231890439987183, 0.03746866062283516, 0.03688773512840271, -0.07218123972415924, -0.03642779961228371, -0.015250029042363167, 0.03871387243270874, -0.007758609019219875, -0.014675618149340153, -0.024928107857704163, 0.013219368644058704, -0.09876865893602371, 0.005775037221610546, 0.041728999465703964, -0.0012928374344483018, -0.009927392937242985, 0.0036583365872502327, -5.999161500702453e-33, 0.020391352474689484, 0.027802957221865654, 0.02031952701508999, -0.020269712433218956, -0.04801994189620018, 0.030424894765019417, -0.02570410817861557, -0.011241857893764973, 0.016383549198508263, 0.033546797931194305, 0.018376626074314117, -0.004776820540428162, 0.016153989359736443, 0.04838187247514725, -0.005133139900863171, -0.020786894485354424, -0.00149291823618114, -0.008419721387326717, -0.005718681495636702, 0.032971519976854324, -0.03466875106096268, 0.022138318046927452, 0.07101437449455261, -0.05205782502889633, -0.08613570034503937, 0.025486087426543236, -0.02187286503612995, -0.003423105925321579, -0.020497145131230354, 0.01644178479909897, -0.025902297347784042, -0.03448003530502319, 0.020958267152309418, -0.00498763145878911, 0.023530228063464165, -0.0883261114358902, -0.04268180578947067, -0.05630345270037651, -0.08630355447530746, 0.07977896928787231, -0.05699426308274269, 0.009471706114709377, -0.019357262179255486, -0.039787981659173965, 0.05912189558148384, 0.0018353317864239216, 0.024068864062428474, -0.024187054485082626, -0.028265727683901787, -0.004944331012666225, -0.017006969079375267, 0.06819549202919006, 0.010445942170917988, -0.017638467252254486, 0.01611255668103695, -0.05592052638530731, -0.012907811440527439, 0.037941526621580124, -0.08410924673080444, -0.019965441897511482, 0.010176736861467361, -0.010845018550753593, 0.01882781647145748, 0.012189771980047226, -0.042773690074682236, 0.0296869445592165, -0.003514947136864066, -0.03187393397092819, -0.015359082259237766, 0.02840321883559227, -0.05163192376494408, 0.04471839964389801, 0.0024852105416357517, -0.017870962619781494, 0.05441020801663399, -0.025938306003808975, -0.03821741044521332, -0.00015015515964478254, -0.06368853151798248, 0.03811020031571388, -0.030065283179283142, 0.010356724262237549, -0.022542297840118408, 0.03094322606921196, 0.030213898047804832, -0.0010111271403729916, 0.04148053750395775, -0.038956791162490845, 0.0009719115914776921, -0.027257798239588737, -0.018446844071149826, 0.06067507341504097, -0.03661937266588211, 0.00889787171036005, 0.056074824184179306, -0.039457935839891434, 0.017608853057026863, 0.023217251524329185, -3.884090619976632e-05, -0.02376464381814003, -0.02582751214504242, 0.030847277492284775, -0.052104659378528595, 0.01868167333304882, 0.011074148118495941, 0.014982041902840137, 0.015993310138583183, -0.012140625156462193, -0.006362652871757746, -0.0019682992715388536, 0.0032372386194765568, -0.018560616299510002, 0.001858580973930657, 0.06392761319875717, 0.015614012256264687, -0.028881538659334183, -0.028400687500834465, 0.07301857322454453, 0.006641664542257786, -0.00011973436630796641, -0.008578683249652386, -0.040650319308042526, -0.0029373092111200094, -0.0036679734475910664, -0.07122332602739334, 0.0007532527670264244, -0.04901367798447609, -0.03550191596150398, 0.04524436593055725, -0.02482699230313301, -0.011177599430084229, 0.013599967584013939, 2.87067422277687e-07, -0.02463003620505333, -0.020315390080213547, -0.000313738506520167, -0.03426593169569969, -0.00265599531121552, 0.010970616713166237, 0.02886662632226944, -0.05539119988679886, -0.03634956479072571, -0.038909077644348145, 0.020167244598269463, 0.02715127542614937, -0.04720267280936241, 0.05289672315120697, 0.026714099571108818, 0.017376525327563286, 0.031499553471803665, 0.011256380937993526, 0.02389434725046158, 0.024053383618593216, 0.0021415629889816046, 0.05069684237241745, 0.03734169527888298, -0.0641077533364296, 0.04802650958299637, 0.008249765262007713, -0.026920253410935402, -0.03300182521343231, -0.006901534739881754, -0.005407500080764294, 0.007262708619236946, 0.027221471071243286, -0.004491489380598068, 0.047387346625328064, 0.022687939926981926, -0.036989860236644745, -0.003926074597984552, 0.02356591261923313, -0.012803759425878525, 0.06547617167234421, -0.009174755774438381, 0.06218406558036804, 0.02615928091108799, -0.022319862619042397, 0.037830792367458344, -0.011950033716857433, -0.03359202295541763, -0.07159287482500076, 0.06830903142690659, 0.03399107605218887, 0.042669475078582764, -0.05069198086857796, -0.023661978542804718, -0.001596401329152286, 0.005821154918521643, -0.04916135594248772, -0.017535924911499023, -0.035655803978443146, 0.0036998691502958536, -0.026969823986291885, 0.005083498079329729, -0.0027159929741173983, 0.019287101924419403, 0.00586901418864727, -0.0007866396335884929, -0.03138185665011406, -0.0005218717269599438, 2.143566754134732e-34, 0.009009388275444508, 0.007392251398414373, -0.03879900649189949, 0.01389900129288435, -0.05347688868641853, 0.024135790765285492, 0.03608756884932518, -0.02789049968123436, -0.029345275834202766, 0.028022337704896927, -0.03490655496716499]
679
679
['Priyadarshini Panda', 'Gopalakrishnan Srinivasan', 'Kaushik Roy']
1703.03854v2
Brain-inspired learning models attempt to mimic the cortical architecture and computations performed in the neurons and synapses constituting the human brain to achieve its efficiency in cognitive tasks. In this work, we present convolutional spike timing dependent plasticity based feature learning with biologically plausible leaky-integrate-and-fire neurons in Spiking Neural Networks (SNNs). We use shared weight kernels that are trained to encode representative features underlying the input patterns thereby improving the sparsity as well as the robustness of the learning model. We demonstrate that the proposed unsupervised learning methodology learns several visual categories for object recognition with fewer number of examples and outperforms traditional fully-connected SNN architectures while yielding competitive accuracy. Additionally, we observe that the learning model performs out-of-set generalization further making the proposed biologically plausible framework a viable and efficient architecture for future neuromorphic applications.
Convolutional Spike Timing Dependent Plasticity based Feature Learning in Spiking Neural Networks
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1703.03854v2
Title Convolutional Spike Timing Dependent Plasticity based Feature Learning Spiking Neural Networks Summary Braininspired learning model attempt mimic cortical architecture computation performed neuron synapsis constituting human brain achieve efficiency cognitive task work present convolutional spike timing dependent plasticity based feature learning biologically plausible leakyintegrateandfire neuron Spiking Neural Networks SNNs use shared weight kernel trained encode representative feature underlying input pattern thereby improving sparsity well robustness learning model demonstrate proposed unsupervised learning methodology learns several visual category object recognition fewer number example outperforms traditional fullyconnected SNN architecture yielding competitive accuracy Additionally observe learning model performs outofset generalization making proposed biologically plausible framework viable efficient architecture future neuromorphic application Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.0192340686917305, 0.00753026083111763, -0.027655042707920074, 0.07184738665819168, 0.02239409275352955, -0.022748205810785294, 0.03357100859284401, -0.01638604700565338, 0.025535887107253075, 0.027913639321923256, -0.05634466931223869, 0.04285196214914322, 0.0009294417104683816, 0.09864293038845062, 0.028742263093590736, 0.005380721762776375, 0.08856036514043808, 0.038651157170534134, -0.013179244473576546, -0.049469877034425735, 0.03801804035902023, -0.055948976427316666, -0.03615342825651169, 0.04427333548665047, -0.004911986645311117, -0.007356162648648024, -0.01674761064350605, -0.02423158288002014, -0.003937115892767906, -0.021881574764847755, 0.03297605738043785, -0.02170531079173088, 0.009573012590408325, 0.05556219071149826, 1.912927473313175e-06, 0.01788673736155033, 0.054979853332042694, 0.019888674840331078, -0.011251826770603657, -0.01918894425034523, -0.05633549392223358, -0.0131072998046875, -0.03515266999602318, -0.008163000456988811, -0.0067845541052520275, -0.013690740801393986, 0.09429259598255157, 0.029309019446372986, -0.037097226828336716, 0.03132812678813934, -0.017461638897657394, -0.04514780268073082, 0.06225205957889557, 0.01517398003488779, 0.05274178832769394, 0.021763531491160393, -0.04224834963679314, -0.012837251648306847, 0.03436417505145073, -0.03961275890469551, -0.07423444837331772, -0.014940427616238594, 0.020196089521050453, 0.0015771412290632725, 0.07354167848825455, 0.03699490800499916, -0.07420941442251205, -0.00763692194595933, -0.03221293166279793, 0.012628572061657906, -0.0456160269677639, 0.008952259086072445, 0.00463557755574584, 0.019376374781131744, -0.05885577201843262, -0.04270037263631821, -0.019857462495565414, -0.04250876232981682, -0.036028459668159485, 0.038649678230285645, -0.03688590228557587, -0.016331618651747704, 0.034548986703157425, -0.009693704545497894, 0.05277165025472641, 0.015145539306104183, -0.009610596112906933, 0.026300739496946335, -0.009911165572702885, -0.0288421381264925, -0.018597707152366638, 0.0421307273209095, 0.01394572388380766, 0.0097074955701828, -0.02614010125398636, -0.028210295364260674, -0.08465586602687836, -0.027301177382469177, 0.009724522940814495, -0.048730380833148956, 0.018835272639989853, 0.02471362240612507, -0.017446495592594147, 0.00113262003287673, -0.027267737314105034, 0.018675506114959717, -0.06594846397638321, 0.07082465291023254, -0.02871646359562874, 0.01401733048260212, -0.08201035857200623, 0.01759413070976734, 0.025849521160125732, 0.040171001106500626, 0.03980540111660957, -0.024655282497406006, -0.08314945548772812, 0.0458553209900856, -0.008467542938888073, -0.004124882631003857, -0.052320364862680435, 0.010011132806539536, 0.015878885984420776, -0.004184153396636248, -0.045291315764188766, -0.02009904757142067, 0.0475228987634182, -0.027314046397805214, -0.005684366915374994, 0.001494804979301989, -0.0025404978077858686, 0.015052231028676033, -0.003466516500338912, 0.0293963011354208, 0.010341661982238293, 0.049371957778930664, -0.0278072077780962, -0.03222079947590828, -0.09310615062713623, 0.0673820972442627, 0.021480660885572433, 0.06053071841597557, 0.009627426974475384, -0.04789910465478897, 0.023254629224538803, 0.004706147592514753, -0.05342794209718704, -0.01732475310564041, 0.002576947445049882, -0.016517920419573784, -0.011381973512470722, 0.053942665457725525, -0.04457572475075722, -0.028059551492333412, 0.07362697273492813, -0.025632616132497787, -0.042383018881082535, 0.0247099157422781, 0.05995035171508789, 0.012612396851181984, 0.0010872429702430964, -0.003440996864810586, 0.00046542921336367726, -0.00801237765699625, 0.01298791915178299, -0.023091109469532967, -0.022053532302379608, -0.06943753361701965, 0.03270609304308891, -0.007229126989841461, 0.047707077115774155, 0.026365727186203003, -0.02457643300294876, -0.024127408862113953, 0.016615159809589386, 0.031669940799474716, -0.004338265862315893, 0.042771607637405396, 0.005009916145354509, -0.016954153776168823, 0.01806623488664627, -0.01774199679493904, -0.017434319481253624, 0.08927150815725327, 0.006740329787135124, -0.022984595969319344, -0.07073717564344406, 0.001458736602216959, -0.03942674398422241, -0.02759576216340065, 0.018255112692713737, -0.04441157728433609, 0.009332566522061825, 0.033476416021585464, 0.037118252366781235, -0.029121404513716698, -0.0004602846165653318, 0.012919524684548378, -0.024390487000346184, 0.0750206708908081, -0.006514814216643572, -0.034986190497875214, -0.006584197282791138, -0.0026145693846046925, 0.012416346929967403, -0.02641664817929268, 0.0008532081265002489, 0.012136807665228844, -0.04951588809490204, 0.021298855543136597, -0.024912254884839058, -0.00029343360802158713, 0.07179825007915497, -0.03436499461531639, -0.0010265418095514178, -0.001984940143302083, -0.00944922398775816, 0.023916127160191536, 0.0027893497608602047, -0.00040752821951173246, 0.024705104529857635, 0.07111337780952454, -0.0175704974681139, -0.00824837014079094, -0.005964591167867184, 0.009185167960822582, 0.028515389189124107, -0.037954166531562805, 0.00830407440662384, -0.045795876532793045, 0.021524561569094658, 0.003947152756154537, 0.0034770863130688667, -0.05533026158809662, 0.05941540747880936, -0.029731817543506622, -0.035633668303489685, -0.001983813475817442, 0.004078630357980728, 0.024284780025482178, 0.04335113242268562, 0.00624110596254468, -0.005272070411592722, -0.054974764585494995, 0.01425853930413723, 0.016225039958953857, 0.05562615394592285, -0.02902040258049965, 0.03373398631811142, 0.0049801236018538475, 0.010599978268146515, 0.0029785344377160072, 0.016132554039359093, 0.03189483657479286, -0.004805600270628929, -0.03559627756476402, 0.016978396102786064, 0.045701734721660614, -0.0614287368953228, -0.020304547622799873, 0.02536587603390217, -0.05284835770726204, -0.012744514271616936, -0.03873120993375778, -0.03196316957473755, -0.013081158511340618, 0.015264189802110195, -0.031187869608402252, -0.02147171087563038, 0.023928551003336906, -0.017060086131095886, -0.03273075819015503, -0.002298968145623803, 0.03548001870512962, 0.00079199398169294, -0.018731098622083664, 0.07532519102096558, -0.0330151692032814, -0.0008346978574991226, 0.03476237505674362, 0.028533415868878365, 0.02564702183008194, -0.026317061856389046, -0.04402067884802818, -0.026047157123684883, 0.034632787108421326, -0.010278373025357723, -0.054255131632089615, 0.0031499164178967476, 0.04043007642030716, 0.020361818373203278, 0.03523334115743637, -0.0032182710710912943, -0.029063358902931213, 0.033234674483537674, 0.03199591115117073, 0.016522180289030075, 0.05434781312942505, 0.03990062698721886, -0.02698095329105854, 0.017404327169060707, 0.022838713601231575, 0.04314153268933296, 0.018221376463770866, -0.00759637076407671, 0.031286656856536865, -0.0082315132021904, 0.05352289229631424, -0.019508985802531242, 0.006956031080335379, 0.05003523454070091, 0.008020668290555477, -0.032464783638715744, -0.006475868169218302, 0.003004736267030239, -0.01618502475321293, -0.015131978318095207, -0.010655841790139675, -0.016956007108092308, -0.021859169006347656, -0.024187076836824417, -0.03390016034245491, 0.008767872117459774, 0.05880152806639671, 0.04220001772046089, -0.0019798963330686092, -0.0176699198782444, -0.009168476797640324, 0.007385984994471073, 0.07951153814792633, 0.0445137619972229, -0.0006330383475869894, 0.01740947924554348, -0.03945223614573479, -0.01085949782282114, -0.007735059130936861, 0.015228956006467342, 0.012794429436326027, 0.008146167732775211, -0.017502637580037117, -0.024171624332666397, -0.014510869048535824, -0.05142398178577423, 0.010332132689654827, 0.0028675750363618135, -0.005867921747267246, 0.01163099892437458, -0.02503202110528946, 0.04058394581079483, -0.03825938329100609, 0.03752291575074196, 0.05522484332323074, -0.01272736769169569, -0.028489740565419197, -0.034597527235746384, 0.03806958347558975, 0.018425798043608665, -0.021612297743558884, -0.019138524308800697, 0.042367033660411835, 0.021294787526130676, 0.038779422640800476, -0.007666826713830233, 0.012382827699184418, -0.1119852215051651, 0.025993086397647858, -0.030172545462846756, 0.03081369400024414, -0.01052829809486866, -0.006390355993062258, 0.007952365092933178, -0.012552670203149319, 0.004164543934166431, 0.0015784185379743576, -0.00325220450758934, -0.07640308886766434, 0.0007027983665466309, -0.01821083575487137, -0.025128329172730446, 0.011456994339823723, 0.027727270498871803, 0.023075783625245094, -0.004910743795335293, -0.058738935738801956, -0.0229694452136755, -0.010790811851620674, 0.014463510364294052, -0.010524673387408257, 0.02439991943538189, 0.025323189795017242, -0.002216905588284135, 0.0024804824497550726, 0.003711647354066372, 0.01845843903720379, -0.03596862778067589, 0.005808042827993631, -0.046906229108572006, 0.04086187109351158, 0.019029760733246803, 0.013590321876108646, 0.024512527510523796, 0.009880105033516884, -0.019508635625243187, 0.019093617796897888, -0.04830586165189743, 0.045793600380420685, 0.06482256948947906, -0.02938813529908657, -0.041889578104019165, -0.027957970276474953, 0.01208711601793766, -0.007705086376518011, 0.016591783612966537, -0.027376515790820122, 0.004829146899282932, 0.06762971729040146, -0.05462883785367012, -0.014151119627058506, 0.07261946052312851, 0.019053803756833076, -0.053282562643289566, -0.048678796738386154, 0.012970507144927979, -0.019520120695233345, 0.023609241470694542, -0.03236449137330055, -0.025475425645709038, 0.000902792380657047, -0.003995017148554325, -0.004330059047788382, -0.05603791028261185, -0.01787646673619747, 0.011505951173603535, -9.570226393407211e-05, -0.05495661869645119, -0.02280317060649395, 0.02417333796620369, 0.04138139262795448, -0.04066312313079834, -0.02280339039862156, 0.003532346338033676, -0.05513421446084976, 0.04438177868723869, 0.00515315355733037, -0.004078463651239872, 0.02279292233288288, 0.0028845546767115593, -0.018722236156463623, -0.014972081407904625, 0.045834895223379135, -0.02943822741508484, -0.10082956403493881, -0.033134303987026215, 0.0321287102997303, -0.01543482206761837, 0.004722601734101772, -0.03816413879394531, -0.042631834745407104, -0.003407610347494483, 0.03866955637931824, 0.02292826771736145, -0.0065573155879974365, -0.008857055567204952, 0.0076173897832632065, -0.0008128642220981419, 0.0665828138589859, 0.05914834141731262, 0.021368760615587234, 0.026231346651911736, -0.0054773446172475815, 0.01760404370725155, -0.02217474766075611, 0.0058969720266759396, -0.008004802279174328, 0.06322772800922394, 0.0034609497524797916, -0.019198300316929817, -0.03603214770555496, 0.03255236893892288, 0.020839352160692215, -0.012953022494912148, 0.040644168853759766, 0.03727693855762482, 0.10342010855674744, -0.01799866557121277, 0.014606037177145481, 0.07344793528318405, 0.10208152234554291, -0.029680326581001282, -0.042345643043518066, 0.026726946234703064, -0.002484635217115283, -0.005581923760473728, -0.07685744017362595, 0.08156614750623703, -0.05433753505349159, 0.05272882804274559, -0.016117695719003677, -0.006872247904539108, 0.0193901676684618, -0.06631803512573242, 0.028246605768799782, -0.016973622143268585, 0.025110023096203804, -0.025696001946926117, 0.005160038359463215, -0.024605875834822655, 0.03491794317960739, 0.02870737574994564, -0.005769331939518452, -0.07945360243320465, 0.031235504895448685, 0.006443175021559, -0.000769540318287909, 0.011123665608465672, 0.00682343915104866, 0.021114561706781387, 0.015377833507955074, -0.04385478049516678, -0.003354820189997554, -0.00010751031368272379, -0.0426330491900444, 0.040610421448946, 0.0017450368031859398, 0.027454692870378494, 0.00508821802213788, 0.04360412061214447, 0.028179379180073738, -0.06944400072097778, 0.01531982608139515, 0.022069836035370827, -0.025235841050744057, 0.043830934911966324, -0.0023712203837931156, 0.030134592205286026, 0.023198917508125305, -0.059789326041936874, -0.02719016745686531, -0.015040368773043156, -0.0220063216984272, 0.014802529476583004, 0.01564892753958702, 0.09476311504840851, 0.008393272757530212, 0.07150605320930481, -0.006358084734529257, 0.0027423116844147444, 0.005647574085742235, 0.03766424208879471, -0.045411616563797, 0.005480929743498564, -0.04868437349796295, 0.06575378030538559, -0.047035250812768936, -0.03994413837790489, -5.270219086658321e-33, 0.019601773470640182, -0.003927886486053467, 0.02769506350159645, 0.03487279638648033, 0.022122275084257126, -0.0015309712616726756, -0.0015253167366608977, 0.010273669846355915, -0.015115178190171719, -0.06470748782157898, -0.05587802827358246, 0.028396926820278168, 0.01165553368628025, 0.011230859905481339, 0.055677380412817, -0.024171730503439903, -0.05007967725396156, -0.016744080930948257, 0.07038149982690811, -0.0198065135627985, 0.06873175501823425, -0.010971665382385254, 0.06915964931249619, -0.04216749593615532, -0.07752592116594315, 0.051643069833517075, 0.025091925635933876, -0.07076575607061386, 0.022099662572145462, -0.012216073460876942, -0.07581677287817001, 0.036668404936790466, 0.02083524502813816, 0.02252134494483471, 0.022589078173041344, -0.04734291508793831, -0.04550030827522278, 0.01884113810956478, -0.05131157860159874, -0.0343908965587616, -0.018759194761514664, -0.015704574063420296, 0.04862985014915466, -0.03690232336521149, -0.04598994925618172, 0.040239159017801285, 0.01919460855424404, -0.05612688511610031, -0.015742817893624306, -0.008962131105363369, -0.03055586852133274, -0.0012366726296022534, 0.03765234723687172, 0.02642088010907173, -0.004887514282017946, 0.021213730797171593, -0.06222381815314293, 0.03027418814599514, -0.08526703715324402, 0.0013906460953876376, -0.011861497536301613, 0.08323264122009277, -0.04836902767419815, 0.06585823744535446, 0.07590509951114655, 0.004667303524911404, 0.043101128190755844, 0.013440861366689205, 0.002349552698433399, 0.017766809090971947, 0.04895760491490364, 0.022334769368171692, 0.03858500346541405, 0.04496796429157257, 0.10462787002325058, -0.098745197057724, -0.06328461319208145, 0.00812467373907566, 0.031453538686037064, 0.006024215370416641, 0.01838212087750435, 0.035244058817625046, -0.04642976075410843, -0.03396174684166908, 0.04808683693408966, 0.04954846203327179, -0.014037096872925758, -0.043892279267311096, -0.003910749685019255, -0.021454982459545135, -0.007916564121842384, 0.03121359273791313, -0.003709775861352682, -0.016043156385421753, 0.07470937818288803, -0.031056832522153854, 0.027784714475274086, 0.02495957352221012, 0.05566876754164696, -0.01006394810974598, -0.07071410119533539, 0.0003223356034141034, -0.033667322248220444, -0.02604692056775093, 0.00649323221296072, 0.028286714106798172, -0.030698467046022415, 0.08521036058664322, 0.04806450754404068, -0.01235183421522379, -0.02904755249619484, -0.052418556064367294, 0.05807861313223839, 0.0008631600649096072, -0.03880505636334419, -0.04458114132285118, -0.004555804654955864, -0.009192558005452156, -0.04991037771105766, 0.0172827560454607, -0.03443481773138046, 0.010949959047138691, 0.020650889724493027, 0.05870798975229263, 0.024703338742256165, 0.003920174203813076, -0.05459343641996384, 0.05644002929329872, -0.03970979526638985, -0.087379589676857, 0.011369727551937103, 0.011760352179408073, 2.7361278398529976e-07, -0.07397804409265518, -0.035527072846889496, -0.028862468898296356, -0.02702784538269043, 0.05869893357157707, 0.00319052510894835, 0.051059115678071976, 0.02857932820916176, -0.045359980314970016, -0.07905548065900803, 0.009376982226967812, 0.037012722343206406, -0.014706647023558617, 0.018305225297808647, -0.02413579449057579, -0.03159665688872337, 0.03892664238810539, 0.06442676484584808, 0.02306303009390831, -0.030956987291574478, -0.023515617474913597, 0.012058841995894909, 0.041186437010765076, -0.025759056210517883, 0.06575577706098557, 0.02471429854631424, 0.055142924189567566, 0.025119563564658165, 0.019982893019914627, -0.01796840690076351, -0.023029157891869545, -0.03604578971862793, -0.00826195627450943, 0.030239766463637352, 0.021266546100378036, -0.046571556478738785, -0.024668892845511436, -0.08454112708568573, -0.03480847179889679, -0.02912544459104538, -0.013079219497740269, 0.0011851725867018104, -0.019047413021326065, 0.02159121073782444, 0.040098682045936584, -0.02825927920639515, -0.06845723092556, -0.006106503773480654, 0.008238585665822029, -0.0035306522622704506, 0.017597956582903862, -0.01821313612163067, -0.023265177384018898, -0.04503745213150978, -0.03743179887533188, -0.048106078058481216, -0.0039391061291098595, -0.008648301474750042, 0.02182633802294731, 0.024097608402371407, -0.02838146686553955, 0.03280390799045563, -0.11222337931394577, -0.0368075966835022, 0.03562413528561592, 0.032686907798051834, -0.014546328224241734, 1.7491050587210913e-34, -0.023404346778988838, -0.012621442787349224, 0.0023145535960793495, 0.008843671530485153, -0.026527324691414833, 0.006057008169591427, 0.012620083056390285, -0.05092613771557808, -0.013500546105206013, 0.02255968563258648, -0.04704815521836281]
680
680
['Shumeet Baluja', 'Ian Fischer']
1703.09387v1
Multiple different approaches of generating adversarial examples have been proposed to attack deep neural networks. These approaches involve either directly computing gradients with respect to the image pixels, or directly solving an optimization on the image pixels. In this work, we present a fundamentally new method for generating adversarial examples that is fast to execute and provides exceptional diversity of output. We efficiently train feed-forward neural networks in a self-supervised manner to generate adversarial examples against a target network or set of networks. We call such a network an Adversarial Transformation Network (ATN). ATNs are trained to generate adversarial examples that minimally modify the classifier's outputs given the original input, while constraining the new classification to match an adversarial target class. We present methods to train ATNs and analyze their effectiveness targeting a variety of MNIST classifiers as well as the latest state-of-the-art ImageNet classifier Inception ResNet v2.
Adversarial Transformation Networks: Learning to Generate Adversarial Examples
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1703.09387v1
Title Adversarial Transformation Networks Learning Generate Adversarial Examples Summary Multiple different approach generating adversarial example proposed attack deep neural network approach involve either directly computing gradient respect image pixel directly solving optimization image pixel work present fundamentally new method generating adversarial example fast execute provides exceptional diversity output efficiently train feedforward neural network selfsupervised manner generate adversarial example target network set network call network Adversarial Transformation Network ATN ATNs trained generate adversarial example minimally modify classifier output given original input constraining new classification match adversarial target class present method train ATNs analyze effectiveness targeting variety MNIST classifier well latest stateoftheart ImageNet classifier Inception ResNet v2 Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.02422841638326645, 0.03188668191432953, -0.02534564398229122, 0.036693260073661804, -0.010438768193125725, -0.04462973400950432, 0.057960670441389084, -0.024842381477355957, -0.05617695674300194, -0.027730831876397133, -0.02204558625817299, 0.06027965992689133, 0.011222568340599537, 0.022123096510767937, 0.05982523038983345, -0.042375411838293076, 0.00494662718847394, 0.04537256434559822, -0.09608642011880875, -0.026640651747584343, -0.01748872548341751, -0.02719542756676674, 0.015959663316607475, 0.01929156482219696, -0.024003081023693085, 0.02274348773062229, -0.0017483314732089639, 0.028029071167111397, 0.021424587815999985, 0.007913850247859955, 0.046073541045188904, -0.01010171603411436, -0.020823856815695763, 0.08776433765888214, 2.358613755859551e-06, -0.015840165317058563, -0.008146530948579311, 0.008279371075332165, 0.023012658581137657, -0.0035578489769250154, 0.022300871089100838, -0.03896710276603699, -0.013430963270366192, 0.01164591871201992, -0.0428558848798275, -0.024754151701927185, 0.008461837656795979, 0.0830574482679367, 0.060083724558353424, 0.08802061527967453, -0.008325956761837006, -0.06232065334916115, 0.04720211401581764, -0.011248053051531315, -0.005151656921952963, 0.004397800657898188, 0.00561924884095788, -0.04392983764410019, -0.05933135747909546, 0.010227939113974571, -0.010849958285689354, 0.03932875394821167, 0.03309758007526398, -0.007414590567350388, 0.00022818079742137343, 0.019102459773421288, -0.022915707901120186, -0.032966140657663345, 0.01929815113544464, 0.03308029845356941, -0.11218404769897461, 0.021472208201885223, -0.01737920194864273, 0.008938727900385857, 0.0054649123921990395, -0.006071045063436031, -0.021767709404230118, 0.005005232524126768, 0.01956827938556671, 0.013145428150892258, -0.08248358964920044, 0.050592731684446335, 0.005712531972676516, 0.00909399800002575, -0.0007839548634365201, -0.06454534828662872, -0.0005932225612923503, 0.013026749715209007, -0.038684554398059845, -0.054083261638879776, 0.0053011453710496426, -0.0030985185876488686, 0.024027692154049873, 0.002218803856521845, -0.0034753140062093735, -0.023720167577266693, -0.059484802186489105, -0.0809442400932312, 0.02833227440714836, -0.04987898841500282, 0.08377610146999359, -0.03273164853453636, -0.05773269012570381, 0.00150083820335567, -0.061779651790857315, 0.04423670843243599, -0.07453227043151855, 0.06779663264751434, -0.019012248143553734, 0.007084766402840614, -0.03542327880859375, -0.000211997379665263, -0.020717745646834373, -0.010130048729479313, 0.006667561829090118, -0.0018904467578977346, -0.06049086153507233, -0.003983734641224146, -0.01959318108856678, 0.026511041447520256, -0.016586774960160255, 0.10554271191358566, -0.043137189000844955, -0.01794850267469883, 0.011130373924970627, -0.010875931940972805, 0.005961863789707422, 0.018258020281791687, 0.01314819697290659, -0.0341150239109993, 0.0042697167955338955, 0.024664588272571564, -0.0345875546336174, -0.003024329198524356, 0.021658265963196754, 0.11247199773788452, -0.0026094019412994385, 0.03331584483385086, -0.03507419303059578, 0.011979572474956512, -0.009057004004716873, -0.0026163693983107805, 0.02191862091422081, -0.031243275851011276, -0.028140157461166382, -0.05242900177836418, -0.026157019659876823, -0.022076085209846497, 0.001409643911756575, 0.0034430997911840677, -0.024837996810674667, 0.07637961208820343, 0.022109024226665497, -0.03818393126130104, 0.10205113142728806, 0.018488282337784767, 0.00766553170979023, 0.032508496195077896, 0.022059176117181778, 0.05633516237139702, 0.010077724233269691, -0.04887782409787178, -0.013159088790416718, 0.007907799445092678, 0.02652774378657341, 0.000758085458073765, -0.03349048271775246, -0.02840576507151127, 0.0007336144335567951, 0.03708985820412636, -0.00382796092890203, 0.025524819269776344, -0.0006486453930847347, -0.08343356847763062, 0.07137004286050797, -0.009308402426540852, 0.02891257032752037, 0.0974099189043045, 0.004938666708767414, -0.0006301491521298885, -0.024645427241921425, 0.007988465949892998, -0.0173384677618742, 0.060866449028253555, -0.07719497382640839, -0.0470435731112957, -0.048082251101732254, 0.06272518634796143, -0.05214952677488327, -0.05739830061793327, 0.05170588940382004, -0.012814446352422237, -0.00699362438172102, -0.04386194795370102, 0.04008248448371887, 0.10402406007051468, -0.019106004387140274, -0.0243472158908844, -0.014553508721292019, -0.002098118420690298, -0.04566424340009689, -0.0897129699587822, -0.046100106090307236, -0.03806464374065399, 0.006570820696651936, -0.013552065007388592, -0.0037372454535216093, -0.04455772787332535, -0.04004128649830818, 0.0048349034041166306, 0.019997049123048782, 0.01172612514346838, -0.016969626769423485, -0.0548243522644043, 0.009177973493933678, -0.04347486421465874, -0.002675255760550499, 0.0404614619910717, 0.023630796000361443, 0.015088268555700779, 0.019249362871050835, -0.002301666419953108, -0.01675517112016678, 0.02187957987189293, 0.009013595059514046, -0.016594108194112778, 0.07615654170513153, 0.0494888611137867, -0.0033761835657060146, 0.005230184644460678, 0.019818101078271866, -0.019723553210496902, 0.022947514429688454, -0.04124445840716362, -0.03487180173397064, -0.012856431305408478, 0.012608978897333145, 0.0030362149700522423, -0.01567927561700344, -0.08502950519323349, 0.03849983215332031, 0.050505779683589935, -0.03281421214342117, -0.020373402163386345, 0.05432426184415817, 0.011797275394201279, -0.03500772640109062, -0.0005840279627591372, -0.013822191394865513, -0.014030384831130505, 0.06286082416772842, -0.02909330651164055, 0.015546636655926704, 0.02623295597732067, -0.014575471170246601, -0.022524267435073853, 0.02003750205039978, 0.04575337469577789, 0.007043291348963976, -0.013707170262932777, 0.02433260902762413, -0.05216844007372856, -0.005817113909870386, -0.03383134305477142, 0.021654022857546806, -0.0030775077175348997, -0.02871328592300415, 0.03244956210255623, 0.010336633771657944, -0.02513720653951168, -0.04127220809459686, 0.012685100547969341, 0.0094174575060606, 0.026886891573667526, -0.022808769717812538, -0.048880018293857574, 0.08261465281248093, -0.045232269912958145, -0.026803918182849884, 0.04925831779837608, 0.05252194032073021, 0.013316527009010315, 0.003562654834240675, -0.026691090315580368, -0.004227304831147194, 0.0714588314294815, 0.020299337804317474, -0.011203227564692497, -0.0035303491167724133, 0.006101156119257212, 0.0327310785651207, 0.05827822536230087, -0.01808568276464939, -0.08785975724458694, -0.007852926850318909, 0.005480058491230011, 0.0030378198716789484, 0.09323468804359436, 0.06866476684808731, 0.060557130724191666, -0.01539301872253418, 0.09822455793619156, -0.033230990171432495, -0.005031423177570105, -0.023057563230395317, -0.01767909899353981, 0.031072046607732773, -0.002671675058081746, -0.005639377981424332, 0.0014179832069203258, 0.02876281552016735, -0.01023927889764309, 0.008492378517985344, 0.04977216571569443, 0.00869764108210802, -0.046192146837711334, -0.03517457842826843, 0.011200753040611744, 0.003038897877559066, -0.053123749792575836, 0.0026923962868750095, -0.03466799855232239, 0.0109056131914258, 0.01643972471356392, -0.00042480259435251355, -0.002727941842749715, -0.049623146653175354, 0.041425492614507675, 0.03317330777645111, 0.03276949003338814, 0.03174952417612076, 0.04436204954981804, 2.7124544430989772e-05, -0.0208425410091877, -0.0022566812112927437, 0.023702546954154968, -0.016176678240299225, 0.028799433261156082, 0.020786354318261147, -0.061199069023132324, -0.03983817249536514, -0.0032864699605852365, -0.08019153773784637, -0.04507656395435333, 0.056352648884058, 0.020165935158729553, -0.015803305432200432, -0.0352744460105896, -0.015497771091759205, -0.03717324510216713, -0.0034885371569544077, 0.040848203003406525, -0.05085461959242821, -0.007116353139281273, 0.007280091289430857, 0.04594199359416962, 0.02319563739001751, -0.04284518584609032, -0.02882775478065014, 0.03515099734067917, 0.04237668216228485, 0.03725312277674675, -0.06201040372252464, -0.02104581519961357, -0.1273261308670044, -0.022472891956567764, -0.025071870535612106, -0.003897332353517413, -0.008691119961440563, -0.00618892814964056, 0.035298679023981094, -0.03238966315984726, 0.016032978892326355, 0.004755036905407906, -0.014432058669626713, -0.018247636035084724, 0.016816888004541397, 0.016639865934848785, -0.04234917834401131, 0.03215508162975311, 0.03971301019191742, -0.029971152544021606, 0.01697375439107418, -0.03930941969156265, -0.004357613623142242, -0.03159763291478157, -0.026115192100405693, -0.016042353585362434, -0.04942914471030235, 0.02254289574921131, 0.0025140447542071342, -0.05921019986271858, -0.02224196493625641, 0.04010460153222084, -0.01944088563323021, -0.0244100634008646, 0.012359661050140858, -0.008421248756349087, 0.033505965024232864, -0.028373615816235542, 0.027133150026202202, 0.012184466235339642, 0.002285049296915531, -0.008068259805440903, -0.03664596751332283, -0.021351568400859833, 0.07001233845949173, 0.03172479569911957, -0.05572384223341942, -0.03439317271113396, 0.009526945650577545, 0.01768004149198532, 0.046064138412475586, 0.010186051949858665, 0.09230592101812363, 0.03397500142455101, 0.004412640351802111, 0.06661106646060944, 0.06077167019248009, 0.0014774835435673594, 0.018089331686496735, 0.015141750685870647, -0.004436964634805918, -0.003820982528850436, -0.023769564926624298, -0.056926313787698746, -0.0033806038554757833, 0.03188523277640343, -0.01799354888498783, 0.009258006699383259, -0.03822508454322815, -0.002572346245869994, -0.0329611673951149, 0.03129759803414345, -0.07376201450824738, -0.03741765394806862, 0.05290665477514267, 0.014039266854524612, -0.05292549356818199, -0.05756477639079094, 0.012177841737866402, -0.03753785043954849, 0.06481818109750748, 0.017926380038261414, -0.05348629876971245, -0.014544486068189144, 0.010190741159021854, -0.015246924012899399, -0.013600562699139118, 0.06359869986772537, 0.01087777130305767, 0.026368997991085052, -0.009703574702143669, 0.06949996203184128, -0.05623593181371689, 0.009805416688323021, -0.04126148670911789, -0.00861568097025156, -0.028033943846821785, 0.0004345352645032108, 0.03870953246951103, 0.011609023436903954, 0.02360238879919052, -0.04023570939898491, -0.00995005015283823, 0.03194105625152588, 0.043711405247449875, 0.05095180869102478, -0.044124141335487366, 0.07271631062030792, -0.029078783467411995, -0.011271301656961441, 0.010105770081281662, 0.002197115682065487, 0.08997742086648941, 0.018092449754476547, -0.09173307567834854, -0.05224233493208885, 0.021595794707536697, 0.01850436069071293, -0.02430577203631401, 0.0766570121049881, -0.009697053581476212, 0.014080729335546494, 0.015003773383796215, 0.05360402166843414, 0.02113094925880432, 0.020218376070261, -0.015761205926537514, -0.03118562325835228, 0.03790276125073433, 0.008728114888072014, 0.026554297655820847, 0.005189824383705854, 0.04610106348991394, -0.014378264546394348, -0.020515112206339836, 0.045475881546735764, -0.008330083452165127, 0.057381439954042435, -0.018979551270604134, 0.049748510122299194, 0.00894180778414011, 0.006127086002379656, 0.04968522489070892, 0.02467653527855873, -0.02323247492313385, 0.019031673669815063, 0.026024309918284416, 0.04364218935370445, -0.038660693913698196, 0.03203776106238365, 0.0010252038482576609, 0.0037675858475267887, -0.07199504971504211, 0.02467340975999832, 0.04175715893507004, -0.01611766591668129, -0.027168693020939827, -0.0038535362109541893, 0.006069497670978308, -0.0009631423745304346, 0.04349173232913017, -0.006948175374418497, -0.006649522110819817, 0.04163483530282974, -0.016905834898352623, 0.01953989826142788, -0.020689481869339943, 0.038923922926187515, 0.015595150180161, 0.019815614446997643, -0.009492401033639908, -0.0009857570985332131, -0.03713802248239517, 0.0023347907699644566, 0.011743512935936451, -0.04035916179418564, 0.031690869480371475, -0.019862521439790726, 0.04742930084466934, -0.02848224714398384, -0.0024455247912555933, 0.019594693556427956, 0.06567937135696411, 0.024661824107170105, 0.016773447394371033, 0.019871842116117477, 0.016114797443151474, 0.009454998187720776, -0.00750725669786334, 0.0025909561663866043, 0.03222174197435379, -0.0420941598713398, 0.012480628676712513, -6.495807496582885e-33, 0.01818302646279335, -0.006979550700634718, -0.025340845808386803, -0.03161850571632385, 0.0016699086409062147, -0.007826178334653378, -0.007127560209482908, -0.04122078791260719, -0.009038463234901428, 0.022953664883971214, -0.03025616705417633, -0.004573188256472349, -0.0012531770626083016, 0.03134856000542641, 0.004899606108665466, -0.02060360088944435, 0.030102692544460297, -0.029396994039416313, 0.025144310668110847, 0.016733545809984207, 0.00651702843606472, -0.006797171197831631, 0.020755913108587265, -0.06613057851791382, -0.05065114423632622, 0.02055131457746029, -0.057797323912382126, -0.05738334357738495, -0.04217160865664482, 0.001429094118066132, 0.043579936027526855, 0.015163804404437542, 0.008963385596871376, -0.032858651131391525, -0.021412456408143044, -0.025195449590682983, -0.038305431604385376, -0.002249104203656316, -0.06890109926462173, 0.061267316341400146, -0.07487796992063522, -0.019628100097179413, 0.058133192360401154, -0.024228768423199654, -0.0067622666247189045, 0.0044968100264668465, 0.03200524300336838, -0.03829034045338631, 0.011801970191299915, -0.011982950381934643, -0.04461147263646126, 0.0054624960757792, -0.03573629632592201, -0.0028028255328536034, 0.0012376625090837479, -0.03517892211675644, 0.006213044282048941, -0.02948964573442936, -0.08141913264989853, 0.017875464633107185, 0.0284090805798769, 0.021216418594121933, 0.030437760055065155, 0.02992897666990757, 0.008029808290302753, 0.015342974103987217, 0.019125837832689285, -0.027541786432266235, 0.02144227921962738, -0.023468811064958572, 0.01906309835612774, 0.08156673610210419, 0.09847918897867203, 0.0538395494222641, 0.08358803391456604, -0.10135464370250702, -0.04028388857841492, 0.031177233904600143, -0.014755889773368835, -0.011982441879808903, 0.008010164834558964, -0.005096456967294216, -0.005197996273636818, -0.0019677928648889065, 0.02537277340888977, -0.07611007988452911, -0.010119273327291012, -0.04335543513298035, 0.030461831018328667, -0.006252211984246969, -0.0013293230440467596, 0.045449722558259964, -0.024918977171182632, -0.06832266598939896, 0.06082345172762871, -0.015474279411137104, -0.01648867502808571, 0.014398927800357342, 0.019089266657829285, -0.019020600244402885, -0.0012578523019328713, -0.028612803667783737, 0.015308967791497707, 0.036739785224199295, 0.023580878973007202, 0.04790174588561058, 0.0643860250711441, 0.029146969318389893, -0.002050932263955474, -0.010534006170928478, 0.007070891093462706, 0.0440039187669754, 0.02567650005221367, -0.008456285111606121, -0.040194083005189896, -0.05201634764671326, -0.014915555715560913, 0.004032114986330271, 0.007037010043859482, -0.003122845431789756, -0.057364773005247116, -0.008700069040060043, 0.0024511173833161592, 0.029043909162282944, -0.09427890181541443, -0.006910030730068684, -0.0034169666469097137, -0.03926822170615196, 0.04444177821278572, -0.08281209319829941, -0.032032374292612076, -0.028362220153212547, 3.0562122788069246e-07, -0.026596836745738983, 0.020601188763976097, 0.0024079340510070324, -0.05119354650378227, 0.005609920248389244, 0.02842974290251732, -0.015953773632645607, 0.07111915946006775, -0.04564215615391731, -0.016857188194990158, -0.005985092371702194, -0.012805266305804253, 0.014603675343096256, 0.01754719950258732, -0.010762062855064869, -0.004437057767063379, -0.010681123472750187, 0.04928784817457199, 0.0003581714991014451, 0.016279330477118492, 0.023061130195856094, 0.08963438123464584, 0.01700647920370102, -0.026145750656723976, 0.04442203417420387, 0.012905723415315151, 0.011579361744225025, 0.01308906264603138, 0.0338338203728199, -0.00181067013181746, -0.0023434737231582403, 0.026103928685188293, 0.002666434971615672, -0.00729023152962327, -0.05102331191301346, -0.01943792961537838, 0.0033173325937241316, -0.016541771590709686, -0.030948583036661148, -0.019151436164975166, -0.017883064225316048, -0.014742900617420673, 0.01936117187142372, -0.025991812348365784, 0.03423432260751724, -0.034440696239471436, -0.04191702976822853, -0.03759029135107994, -0.007202894892543554, 0.03682709112763405, 0.032091427594423294, -0.030796842649579048, 0.02257370576262474, -0.035118915140628815, 0.014486010186374187, 0.00757593335583806, 0.008432811126112938, -0.03788553178310394, 0.04441911727190018, 0.005099286790937185, -0.028354721143841743, 0.002338098594918847, -0.014651079662144184, 0.007106191944330931, 0.07450678199529648, 0.07634401321411133, -0.055755674839019775, 2.8430366319856205e-34, -0.024801690131425858, 0.01587078906595707, 0.011443750001490116, -0.02505332976579666, -0.04599699378013611, 0.004657544661313295, 0.010204631835222244, 0.008824151940643787, -0.006609021220356226, -0.003243398619815707, -0.07774174958467484]
681
681
['Devinder Kumar', 'Graham W Taylor', 'Alexander Wong']
1709.01574v1
Deep learning has been shown to outperform traditional machine learning algorithms across a wide range of problem domains. However, current deep learning algorithms have been criticized as uninterpretable "black-boxes" which cannot explain their decision making processes. This is a major shortcoming that prevents the widespread application of deep learning to domains with regulatory processes such as finance. As such, industries such as finance have to rely on traditional models like decision trees that are much more interpretable but less effective than deep learning for complex problems. In this paper, we propose CLEAR-Trade, a novel financial AI visualization framework for deep learning-driven stock market prediction that mitigates the interpretability issue of deep learning methods. In particular, CLEAR-Trade provides a effective way to visualize and explain decisions made by deep stock market prediction models. We show the efficacy of CLEAR-Trade in enhancing the interpretability of stock market prediction by conducting experiments based on S&P 500 stock index prediction. The results demonstrate that CLEAR-Trade can provide significant insight into the decision-making process of deep learning-driven financial models, particularly for regulatory processes, thus improving their potential uptake in the financial industry.
Opening the Black Box of Financial AI with CLEAR-Trade: A CLass-Enhanced Attentive Response Approach for Explaining and Visualizing Deep Learning-Driven Stock Market Prediction
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1709.01574v1
Title Opening Black Box Financial AI CLEARTrade CLassEnhanced Attentive Response Approach Explaining Visualizing Deep LearningDriven Stock Market Prediction Summary Deep learning shown outperform traditional machine learning algorithm across wide range problem domain However current deep learning algorithm criticized uninterpretable blackboxes cannot explain decision making process major shortcoming prevents widespread application deep learning domain regulatory process finance industry finance rely traditional model like decision tree much interpretable le effective deep learning complex problem paper propose CLEARTrade novel financial AI visualization framework deep learningdriven stock market prediction mitigates interpretability issue deep learning method particular CLEARTrade provides effective way visualize explain decision made deep stock market prediction model show efficacy CLEARTrade enhancing interpretability stock market prediction conducting experiment based SP 500 stock index prediction result demonstrate CLEARTrade provide significant insight decisionmaking process deep learningdriven financial model particularly regulatory process thus improving potential uptake financial industry Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.040640443563461304, 0.016146590933203697, -0.05602003633975983, -0.03990969434380531, 0.028110221028327942, -0.006837813183665276, 0.04842669889330864, 0.03750529885292053, -0.010637651197612286, 0.01545463316142559, 0.03076239489018917, 0.022501042112708092, -0.0024728206917643547, 0.1408827304840088, 0.021433502435684204, -0.0375167541205883, 0.009902089834213257, -0.0012582563795149326, 0.04305077716708183, -0.007074963767081499, 0.01827889494597912, -0.032255515456199646, 0.035527005791664124, 0.02797553688287735, -0.025198429822921753, -0.017164502292871475, -0.026921778917312622, -0.028132569044828415, 0.004709956701844931, -0.05609931796789169, 0.003644767450168729, -0.05390285700559616, 0.018125087022781372, 0.051397595554590225, 2.2277517928159796e-06, -0.019691327586770058, -0.01669570617377758, -0.01640339381992817, -0.029591813683509827, -0.00031227365252561867, -0.060221944004297256, -0.02002524770796299, 0.06444837898015976, 0.010577927343547344, -0.0748099535703659, 0.009728866629302502, 0.05727735534310341, 0.08425778895616531, 0.02890945039689541, -0.006632470525801182, -0.003921994008123875, -0.046148836612701416, 0.020080681890249252, -0.04613499343395233, -0.017484253272414207, -0.07161350548267365, -0.002821737201884389, 5.8594330766936764e-05, -0.048942726105451584, -0.025202836841344833, -0.04080357030034065, 0.026913300156593323, 0.04076586291193962, 0.0011821954976767302, 0.07725665718317032, 0.004424134269356728, 0.04074925184249878, -0.020204829052090645, -0.04171193391084671, 0.05169602856040001, -0.0052792890928685665, 0.03278227522969246, -0.02624034322798252, -0.03176139295101166, 0.0029821775387972593, 0.00687370216473937, -0.0437641367316246, 0.016484055668115616, -0.014949108473956585, 0.01846781000494957, 0.0037823813036084175, 0.023896262049674988, 0.014365050941705704, 0.00345209171064198, -0.020018646493554115, 0.000679814605973661, -0.056449711322784424, -0.0028656728100031614, 0.03965602442622185, -0.011555952951312065, 0.018455399200320244, -0.026222025975584984, 0.02648865431547165, 0.022780535742640495, -0.037101827561855316, -0.006308564450591803, 0.027707703411579132, -0.04387323930859566, -0.015442995354533195, -0.03895127773284912, 0.015388640575110912, -0.018975282087922096, -0.016963070258498192, 0.04331523925065994, -0.035001639276742935, 0.0517328716814518, -0.024040525779128075, -0.022748121991753578, 0.01477071363478899, -0.01680839993059635, -0.024739695712924004, -0.010735418647527695, -0.04696275293827057, 0.06654594838619232, -0.002822423353791237, -0.025926200672984123, -0.09110738337039948, -0.0241509098559618, -0.06788770109415054, 0.00893687829375267, -0.0007612304762005806, 0.047550734132528305, 0.010645581409335136, 0.015040578320622444, -0.04451264441013336, -0.019544752314686775, -0.0730937048792839, 0.030559342354536057, -0.01561057846993208, 0.009332511574029922, 0.030912112444639206, -0.015906792134046555, -0.03574231639504433, 0.012635362334549427, 0.00938356015831232, 0.05756712704896927, 0.05071200802922249, 0.010485551320016384, -0.05129094049334526, -0.046660326421260834, 0.03052542917430401, 0.005168756935745478, -0.02035757154226303, 0.0032489721197634935, -0.04394828528165817, -0.06703291088342667, -0.0208238884806633, 0.01749134436249733, -0.0041464464738965034, -0.029290294274687767, -0.006424737628549337, 0.07498719543218613, -0.015870576724410057, -0.03199770674109459, 0.029173560440540314, -0.0239716786891222, 0.0011608279310166836, -0.004956455901265144, 0.026482678949832916, 0.024958528578281403, 0.022133316844701767, -0.04587888345122337, 0.017847353592514992, -0.005019274074584246, 0.0037893224507570267, -0.07300896942615509, -0.034198734909296036, -0.009933981113135815, -0.0799780786037445, -0.009615900926291943, -0.00259823864325881, -0.0352768637239933, 0.007771759293973446, -0.010769380256533623, 0.0287570059299469, 0.026863815262913704, 0.09008903801441193, 0.035765618085861206, 3.863725214614533e-05, 0.020388683304190636, 0.011061737313866615, -0.030124124139547348, 0.005713792517781258, 0.05124100670218468, -0.01233851257711649, -0.015975752845406532, -0.0816986933350563, 0.0018567563965916634, -0.04426078125834465, -0.04089779406785965, 0.039165202528238297, -0.025396207347512245, -0.0010788625804707408, -0.008479546755552292, 0.014382326044142246, -0.03689393401145935, -0.03676215559244156, 0.013568255119025707, 0.03657608851790428, 0.0739959329366684, -0.03361741453409195, -0.05803491547703743, 0.03536275029182434, 0.0239301398396492, -0.01595558598637581, -0.0142402658239007, 0.027266481891274452, -0.029794249683618546, -0.017254190519452095, -0.004807104356586933, 0.033058762550354004, 0.01970227062702179, -0.0558260940015316, -0.03508159890770912, -0.036228079348802567, -0.00011668426304822788, 0.0002840536180883646, 0.012938007712364197, -0.06350505352020264, 0.016298336908221245, -0.0056546530686318874, 0.030878262594342232, 0.019721996039152145, 0.026440661400556564, 0.029275838285684586, -0.013550889678299427, 0.04128300026059151, 0.028216348960995674, 0.029282735660672188, 0.0370650514960289, 0.03313324227929115, -0.034458909183740616, 0.01835639216005802, -0.02040434628725052, -0.03808853402733803, -0.007079599425196648, -0.04317879676818848, 0.06583339720964432, -0.05132267624139786, -0.0393231138586998, 0.013628020882606506, 0.0808631181716919, -0.01926357112824917, -0.019957013428211212, 0.005186552181839943, -0.04149036109447479, 0.0029523710254579782, -0.022215427830815315, -0.02777894027531147, -0.006754034198820591, 0.062027473002672195, -0.0019639802630990744, 0.04003354161977768, 0.0032862527295947075, -0.013279659673571587, -0.007357333321124315, -0.0006420761928893626, 0.04719477891921997, 0.02108536846935749, 0.07206696271896362, -0.01578833907842636, -0.06767313182353973, 0.0015364913269877434, 0.020751619711518288, -0.0052756136283278465, 0.0157417431473732, 0.060828063637018204, 0.009948831051588058, -0.024244509637355804, -0.003865836188197136, -0.01516648568212986, 0.0013708005426451564, 0.025768591091036797, -0.008232568390667439, -0.05431182309985161, -0.026194710284471512, 0.04753384366631508, -0.009485389105975628, -0.033770766109228134, 0.06127607822418213, 0.006298448890447617, -0.0021296758204698563, -0.003640415845438838, -0.023652007803320885, -0.02406374365091324, 0.034231193363666534, 0.0927300676703453, -0.03658198565244675, 0.0014209644868969917, -0.022495441138744354, 0.025426257401704788, 0.01097419485449791, -0.008696752600371838, 0.017615631222724915, -0.0013073618756607175, 0.001726960064843297, -0.05556865409016609, 0.049606457352638245, 0.026231873780488968, 0.07780866324901581, -0.03757908567786217, 0.06066122278571129, -0.026182962581515312, 0.048390138894319534, -0.0006828363984823227, 0.05428289994597435, -0.00227530300617218, 0.005122368223965168, 0.004467163234949112, -0.012127954512834549, 0.011438878253102303, 0.0048719896003603935, -0.046971969306468964, 0.06199250742793083, 0.01547003723680973, 0.006363179534673691, -0.07968425005674362, -0.006145829800516367, -0.028405601158738136, 0.06291907280683517, 0.012693092226982117, -0.07409397512674332, 0.022303828969597816, 0.03825003281235695, -0.008586334995925426, 0.022497141733765602, -0.053108010441064835, -0.03892653435468674, 0.039503999054431915, -0.042458564043045044, -0.008927618153393269, -0.03930888697504997, -0.03747240826487541, -0.020554019138216972, -0.024378836154937744, -0.032305050641298294, -0.01717127487063408, 0.00430482579395175, -0.021964633837342262, -0.05329899489879608, 0.00673089362680912, 0.023676401004195213, -0.029830632731318474, -0.06843449920415878, -0.01822204701602459, 0.021681008860468864, 0.06579160690307617, -0.027931462973356247, 0.0030840623658150434, 0.01788550801575184, 0.006625031121075153, -0.016653915867209435, -0.002180966781452298, -0.052352871745824814, 0.03653804585337639, 0.005446534138172865, 0.05758432298898697, -0.01301775872707367, 0.047703295946121216, -0.026187820360064507, 0.0854751318693161, -0.018443835899233818, -0.01143101416528225, 0.03647403419017792, -0.07938864082098007, 0.02429605834186077, -0.05664239823818207, 0.0119261359795928, 0.010066531598567963, 0.014298981055617332, -0.039287932217121124, -0.057946085929870605, 0.05013720318675041, 0.04160021245479584, 0.0001861787895904854, 0.01647397130727768, 0.02635863982141018, 0.007816518656909466, -0.01642937771975994, -0.02070714347064495, 0.002637513680383563, -0.06789954751729965, -0.018893687054514885, -0.020757952705025673, 0.016981225460767746, 0.016769450157880783, -0.06738611310720444, -0.016020530834794044, -0.07424478232860565, 0.05470285937190056, -0.029085982590913773, -0.027968939393758774, -0.023688729852437973, -0.0544218085706234, -0.02800091914832592, -0.04168195649981499, 0.017138246446847916, -0.005001716315746307, 0.025732167065143585, 0.0076166014187037945, 0.03373600170016289, -0.09501302987337112, 0.04135485738515854, 0.027899984270334244, -0.04180259630084038, -0.04607538878917694, 0.0218877624720335, 0.03646215796470642, -0.07491593062877655, 0.03040127642452717, -0.09148364514112473, -0.002304184716194868, 0.04262535274028778, 0.01309870183467865, 0.09972294420003891, 0.04677220806479454, -0.04661790654063225, -0.008286279626190662, 0.05806842818856239, 0.0035651978105306625, 0.08987316489219666, 0.03306317329406738, 0.016433093696832657, -0.04129655286669731, -0.06832006573677063, -0.04740423336625099, 0.015567217953503132, -0.03136740252375603, 0.0058066872879862785, 0.009936920367181301, -0.02518926002085209, -0.04955894500017166, -0.024406246840953827, 0.04844561219215393, -0.09010791033506393, -0.007629995234310627, 0.03624206408858299, 0.017445746809244156, -0.036460746079683304, -0.019586388021707535, -0.04001779481768608, -0.0385676771402359, 0.030568156391382217, 0.008493409492075443, 0.04722050949931145, 0.017112456262111664, -0.01346586737781763, -0.009498330764472485, -0.004918282851576805, 0.05350702255964279, 0.031642310321331024, 0.02216285467147827, 0.037858568131923676, -0.005136982537806034, -0.02743668109178543, -0.047322828322649, 0.02109427936375141, -0.020922530442476273, 0.01613435707986355, 0.013248045928776264, -0.00033166672801598907, 0.017894843593239784, -0.016902146860957146, -0.014913367107510567, 0.010992743074893951, 0.03425073251128197, 0.0030436369124799967, 0.011497282423079014, -0.09572609513998032, 0.016311848536133766, -0.018220657482743263, -0.013072101399302483, 0.020982900634407997, -0.011629481799900532, 0.02037910930812359, -0.033533696085214615, -0.06651578843593597, -0.040863096714019775, 0.03991999849677086, -0.01420215331017971, -0.0019948724657297134, 0.05534777790307999, 0.049127113074064255, -0.06629910320043564, 0.008234439417719841, 0.0017482314724475145, 0.03843548893928528, 0.013244411908090115, -0.008224285207688808, -0.015338925644755363, 0.057726819068193436, -0.02036166563630104, -0.00029751297552138567, 0.03782830759882927, 0.06897621601819992, -0.10256564617156982, -0.02972196787595749, 0.06669270247220993, -0.008997811004519463, 0.04703721031546593, -0.022311430424451828, 0.009478308260440826, 0.04166049137711525, -0.00528281694278121, 0.051766861230134964, 0.0014432233292609453, 0.033593181520700455, 0.027498595416545868, -0.024080371484160423, 0.020016852766275406, -0.006716777104884386, -0.022206492722034454, -0.01492207683622837, -0.06668337434530258, 0.04196605831384659, 0.03918363153934479, 0.0016536894254386425, -0.03308866545557976, -0.058734312653541565, -0.016195185482501984, 0.048010095953941345, 0.03136162459850311, 0.02758326753973961, -0.019965384155511856, 0.004180568270385265, 0.03574450686573982, -0.019249744713306427, -0.05653928965330124, -0.02207174338400364, 0.06738331913948059, 0.0529671311378479, 0.014524740166962147, -0.060533154755830765, -0.001429387484677136, -0.019187791272997856, 0.015173555351793766, 0.08016054332256317, 0.04901988059282303, 0.015306771732866764, 0.016482194885611534, -0.03337618708610535, -0.023258348926901817, 0.04663216695189476, -0.03204074874520302, 0.04298672080039978, -0.014215941540896893, 0.013994967564940453, 0.03563566133379936, -0.0052596190944314, 0.0016252317000180483, 0.03612464666366577, 0.0029284488409757614, -0.004412258975207806, 0.009980959817767143, -0.10075951367616653, -5.658515727461632e-33, 0.008953120559453964, -0.06948326528072357, 0.005774695426225662, 0.007040170952677727, -0.009901131503283978, 0.031252820044755936, -0.030053505674004555, -0.023242374882102013, -0.01746336743235588, 0.019807780161499977, 0.002077581360936165, 0.03407031297683716, -0.0019974217284470797, 0.03538813069462776, 0.048775721341371536, -0.016067175194621086, 0.007167196366935968, -0.023253044113516808, 0.043647684156894684, -0.0055002132430672646, 0.006189701613038778, 0.07458318024873734, -0.0005996039253659546, -0.021852966398000717, -0.0007726895855739713, 0.011137912981212139, -0.04235563799738884, -0.040921468287706375, 0.003638617228716612, 0.04818444699048996, 0.01093805581331253, 0.03565693646669388, 0.021374717354774475, -0.08906932175159454, -0.017243539914488792, 0.014013302512466908, -0.00692845368757844, -0.04785995930433273, -0.023910384625196457, 0.03974941372871399, -0.05837138742208481, 0.020461305975914, 0.07304293662309647, 0.007344136480242014, 0.01629999838769436, 0.00035223053419031203, 0.04551175236701965, 0.0004743683966808021, 0.0035251255612820387, -0.03306746855378151, -0.03280695900321007, 0.003840896300971508, -0.0517343208193779, 0.046064406633377075, 0.024595553055405617, 0.08910837024450302, 0.02098085917532444, 0.019896050915122032, -0.022542662918567657, 0.014890221878886223, 0.042487602680921555, -0.041864264756441116, -0.014776396565139294, 0.029052358120679855, 0.002703679958358407, 0.03361092507839203, 0.0026983055286109447, -0.02068828046321869, -0.012273267842829227, -0.005738928914070129, 0.00537272822111845, 0.08366872370243073, 0.05106395110487938, 0.0022938470356166363, 0.033868081867694855, -0.07279710471630096, -0.08581039309501648, 0.03707697242498398, -0.003918927628546953, 0.019168920814990997, -0.008681409992277622, -0.005062009207904339, -0.03334777429699898, -0.012836451642215252, 0.04711326211690903, -0.005934408865869045, 0.012359701097011566, 0.01115748006850481, 0.02411985956132412, -0.023960445076227188, 0.00024065184697974473, 0.06374482065439224, -0.007586799096316099, -0.06112508848309517, -0.0045793792232871056, 0.0008534629596397281, 0.042511504143476486, 0.040854934602975845, 0.04329681769013405, -0.045418236404657364, 0.009631185792386532, -0.02425960637629032, -0.036188408732414246, -0.014022608287632465, 0.023311536759138107, -0.011466247960925102, 0.047405097633600235, -0.01195409893989563, -0.005638293456286192, -0.016930554062128067, 0.004442991688847542, -0.017488932237029076, 0.03327091410756111, -0.0016822753241285682, -0.016865359619259834, -0.010392371565103531, -0.014218303374946117, 0.007225409150123596, 0.018325963988900185, 0.050837449729442596, 0.006978751625865698, -0.0678265392780304, -0.0037162909284234047, -7.032073335722089e-05, -0.007887774147093296, -0.026224780827760696, -0.02214059978723526, 0.020107557997107506, 0.037760328501462936, -0.06710080802440643, -0.040025413036346436, 0.03235411271452904, 2.6741898295767896e-07, 0.049419235438108444, 0.046217065304517746, -0.0026943692937493324, 0.011448587290942669, 0.031249072402715683, 0.05683411285281181, -0.013898961246013641, 0.004521391354501247, -0.04120156168937683, 0.010511542670428753, 0.06638487428426743, -0.008810287341475487, 0.04119981452822685, 0.023009398952126503, -0.03981735557317734, -0.07507813721895218, -0.03309951350092888, 0.02126069739460945, -0.06174563243985176, 0.05223789066076279, 0.026626624166965485, 0.06273233890533447, 0.023664724081754684, -0.062041185796260834, 0.05648382008075714, -0.027977824211120605, -0.002961517311632633, -0.026454463601112366, 0.035270191729068756, -0.017676714807748795, 0.006722192745655775, 0.029410891234874725, -0.03876623883843422, 0.02888009138405323, -0.01097367238253355, 0.011846558190882206, 0.004452515859156847, -0.009224049746990204, -0.021828368306159973, 0.02894781157374382, 0.024593807756900787, -0.01653612032532692, 0.037344951182603836, -0.030687717720866203, 0.02912740595638752, -0.027714837342500687, -0.0612313486635685, -0.058280717581510544, -0.022910140454769135, 0.0462726466357708, 0.0646086186170578, 0.010227276012301445, 0.016079602763056755, -0.020071685314178467, -0.019948018714785576, -0.0577833354473114, 0.034093037247657776, -0.018464498221874237, -0.017346100881695747, 0.010382026433944702, -0.036408498883247375, 0.07496092468500137, -0.04729878157377243, 0.009266180917620659, 0.06348659843206406, -0.01308827381581068, 0.013545016758143902, 2.3148541889712902e-34, 0.046686772257089615, -0.04270828142762184, 0.004981781356036663, 0.02111111767590046, 0.03873518481850624, -0.0035388534888625145, 0.026721395552158356, 0.02596588246524334, 0.005643938668072224, -0.02712543122470379, -0.03831395506858826]
682
682
['Mohammad Javad Shafiee', 'Brendan Chywl', 'Francis Li', 'Alexander Wong']
1709.05943v1
Object detection is considered one of the most challenging problems in this field of computer vision, as it involves the combination of object classification and object localization within a scene. Recently, deep neural networks (DNNs) have been demonstrated to achieve superior object detection performance compared to other approaches, with YOLOv2 (an improved You Only Look Once model) being one of the state-of-the-art in DNN-based object detection methods in terms of both speed and accuracy. Although YOLOv2 can achieve real-time performance on a powerful GPU, it still remains very challenging for leveraging this approach for real-time object detection in video on embedded computing devices with limited computational power and limited memory. In this paper, we propose a new framework called Fast YOLO, a fast You Only Look Once framework which accelerates YOLOv2 to be able to perform object detection in video on embedded devices in a real-time manner. First, we leverage the evolutionary deep intelligence framework to evolve the YOLOv2 network architecture and produce an optimized architecture (referred to as O-YOLOv2 here) that has 2.8X fewer parameters with just a ~2% IOU drop. To further reduce power consumption on embedded devices while maintaining performance, a motion-adaptive inference method is introduced into the proposed Fast YOLO framework to reduce the frequency of deep inference with O-YOLOv2 based on temporal motion characteristics. Experimental results show that the proposed Fast YOLO framework can reduce the number of deep inferences by an average of 38.13%, and an average speedup of ~3.3X for objection detection in video compared to the original YOLOv2, leading Fast YOLO to run an average of ~18FPS on a Nvidia Jetson TX1 embedded system.
Fast YOLO: A Fast You Only Look Once System for Real-time Embedded Object Detection in Video
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1709.05943v1
Title Fast YOLO Fast Look System Realtime Embedded Object Detection Video Summary Object detection considered one challenging problem field computer vision involves combination object classification object localization within scene Recently deep neural network DNNs demonstrated achieve superior object detection performance compared approach YOLOv2 improved Look model one stateoftheart DNNbased object detection method term speed accuracy Although YOLOv2 achieve realtime performance powerful GPU still remains challenging leveraging approach realtime object detection video embedded computing device limited computational power limited memory paper propose new framework called Fast YOLO fast Look framework accelerates YOLOv2 able perform object detection video embedded device realtime manner First leverage evolutionary deep intelligence framework evolve YOLOv2 network architecture produce optimized architecture referred OYOLOv2 28X fewer parameter 2 IOU drop reduce power consumption embedded device maintaining performance motionadaptive inference method introduced proposed Fast YOLO framework reduce frequency deep inference OYOLOv2 based temporal motion characteristic Experimental result show proposed Fast YOLO framework reduce number deep inference average 3813 average speedup 33X objection detection video compared original YOLOv2 leading Fast YOLO run average 18FPS Nvidia Jetson TX1 embedded system Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.014544973149895668, 0.03064371645450592, -0.000905121210962534, 0.0811096802353859, 0.007861118763685226, 0.009515101090073586, 0.03478757292032242, 0.019740769639611244, -0.017672598361968994, -0.0129587696865201, 0.027494484558701515, 0.031310345977544785, 0.007866637781262398, 0.054129812866449356, -0.022458000108599663, -0.023402849212288857, -0.00515155540779233, 0.030064979568123817, -0.021910227835178375, 0.0035495178308337927, 0.04336351528763771, -0.02556874416768551, 0.015927361324429512, 0.02232549339532852, -0.05161408334970474, 0.023773254826664925, -0.03499962389469147, -0.019677679985761642, 0.043310269713401794, -0.012452171184122562, 0.01454696711152792, 0.006313292309641838, 0.02479591593146324, 0.07442917674779892, 2.1168473267607624e-06, -0.007583754602819681, 0.007858650758862495, -0.01977313868701458, 0.02135404944419861, -0.029555168002843857, -3.201077925041318e-05, -0.015291158109903336, -0.037477876991033554, -0.006421251222491264, -0.036583054810762405, -0.06403761357069016, 0.04250334948301315, 0.022104140371084213, -0.006964210420846939, 0.017403949052095413, -0.013166911900043488, -0.033896833658218384, 0.041564323008060455, 0.007586219348013401, -0.007959196344017982, -0.01649888977408409, -0.010634414851665497, -0.02720099873840809, 0.003521670587360859, -0.056108418852090836, -0.009669083170592785, 0.01751042529940605, 0.05256359279155731, -0.008567138575017452, 0.03438165783882141, 0.004002103116363287, -0.06176966801285744, -0.01348772644996643, -0.017776787281036377, 0.02291273884475231, -0.10495061427354813, -0.006994317751377821, 0.038585465401411057, 0.006318662315607071, -0.011153869330883026, -0.06021399796009064, 0.0029477220959961414, 0.04938383772969246, -0.02809811942279339, -0.020200226455926895, -0.026416609063744545, 0.011748034507036209, -0.010363764129579067, -0.00805170089006424, 0.02378908544778824, -0.013929426670074463, 0.023433271795511246, 0.08107022196054459, -0.05318949371576309, 0.0034258905798196793, -0.05078870803117752, -0.04890584573149681, 0.036571044474840164, 0.009976653382182121, -0.010381197556853294, -0.04108089953660965, -0.07478205114603043, -0.01769024133682251, -0.02130846492946148, -0.08900606632232666, 0.017582226544618607, -0.02361082099378109, -0.04668357968330383, 0.03587694093585014, -0.009857125580310822, 0.03816456347703934, -0.08226945251226425, -0.04441700503230095, -0.01819741167128086, 0.016828346997499466, -0.01498379372060299, -0.00418931944295764, -0.01827789843082428, 0.008288001641631126, -0.014947579242289066, -0.03318505361676216, -0.024329898878932, 0.022440912202000618, -0.016448434442281723, -0.04766271635890007, -0.0496516153216362, 0.072104312479496, 0.04664986580610275, -0.040075261145830154, 0.013109385967254639, -0.011358296498656273, -0.019240589812397957, 0.0040093595162034035, -0.013998541049659252, -0.06741735339164734, 0.059285085648298264, 0.05166568607091904, 0.04032249003648758, 0.027307860553264618, 0.015214971266686916, 0.030244916677474976, -0.004216310568153858, -0.02697453275322914, -0.03681055083870888, 0.05682629346847534, 0.021434880793094635, 0.015996120870113373, 0.0249211136251688, -0.07863300293684006, -0.03695724532008171, -0.04731196537613869, 0.0015434485394507647, -0.00011481854016892612, 0.007649349048733711, 0.034327827394008636, 0.006337077356874943, 0.01380962785333395, -0.03707341104745865, -0.019148483872413635, 0.009122735820710659, 0.0029385455418378115, 0.06537419557571411, 0.05019008740782738, 0.0240364708006382, 0.004358284175395966, -0.0037184685934334993, 0.006653980817645788, 0.015186029486358166, -0.01176498830318451, -0.08504201471805573, -0.003096932079643011, -0.022707806900143623, -0.018298914656043053, -0.04019778221845627, 0.05741121247410774, 0.019177747890353203, -0.010001874528825283, 0.02471124567091465, -0.02558685839176178, 0.00655188737437129, 0.0001804300263756886, -0.008159068413078785, -0.0041389972902834415, -0.011206138879060745, -0.0025240688119083643, -0.019003581255674362, -0.047935016453266144, -0.010493389330804348, 0.08734910935163498, -0.013046512380242348, -0.0701083242893219, -0.059002023190259933, 0.017266640439629555, -0.04119662195444107, -0.0148850679397583, -0.0033185817301273346, -0.015284712426364422, -0.03701183944940567, -0.0036091727670282125, 0.03449711576104164, -0.02523065358400345, -0.012711902149021626, -0.03261585906147957, 0.009002604521811008, 0.05359521135687828, -0.037723083049058914, -0.09162259101867676, 0.047445740550756454, -0.02184804528951645, -0.007281946483999491, 0.010054859332740307, -0.008340125903487206, 0.0011630397057160735, 0.03557964414358139, 0.018836015835404396, -0.014974071644246578, -0.0091709578409791, 0.047126203775405884, -0.003817293094471097, -0.010618549771606922, 0.017707040533423424, 0.007302304729819298, 0.03530191630125046, -0.016752632334828377, 0.037026021629571915, 0.01892704889178276, 0.07441043108701706, 0.053325168788433075, 0.04072682559490204, 0.03342191129922867, 0.05008934810757637, -0.0016743267187848687, 0.051435988396406174, 0.0013486921088770032, -0.012975449673831463, -0.0032420968636870384, -0.03587052971124649, 0.043300047516822815, -0.023100903257727623, 0.04489456117153168, -0.00995771773159504, -0.021979352459311485, -0.01892808824777603, 0.04381246119737625, -0.037279337644577026, 0.00946193840354681, 0.04367240145802498, -0.005919169168919325, -0.024022243916988373, 0.00996977835893631, -0.035664595663547516, -0.018483534455299377, 0.0024645081721246243, 0.031018437817692757, -0.04291807860136032, 0.03627520427107811, -0.02101513370871544, 0.01589897833764553, 0.02055438421666622, -0.009630236774682999, 0.04671023041009903, 0.009301085025072098, 0.0664374902844429, -0.025319987908005714, 0.01076149009168148, 0.0008979470003396273, -0.05900442972779274, -0.029428701847791672, 0.007613695226609707, 0.02713019959628582, -0.008301225490868092, 0.03725997731089592, 0.0007103322423063219, 0.034051313996315, -0.03854416310787201, -0.029284533113241196, 0.01015601959079504, -0.005519850179553032, 0.008918172679841518, -0.013992995023727417, -0.007883939892053604, 0.10501205921173096, 0.004795226268470287, -0.03306538611650467, -0.007320336066186428, -0.0022516201715916395, -0.009726295247673988, -0.0035964350681751966, -0.008894093334674835, 0.015181113965809345, 0.003813833696767688, 0.027777807787060738, -0.0030637732706964016, -0.003865698119625449, -0.07241497188806534, 0.007812718860805035, 0.0804414376616478, 0.027651192620396614, -0.0466376356780529, -0.014841119758784771, -0.01149771548807621, 0.0105931106954813, 0.13204547762870789, 0.02708742767572403, 0.008397404104471207, -0.00527977803722024, 0.013722104951739311, 0.04571288824081421, 0.002241258742287755, 0.027416232973337173, 0.03129368647933006, -0.0027200644835829735, 0.03534703329205513, -0.05206641927361488, -0.0007309410138987005, -0.02250875160098076, 0.018394794315099716, -0.022896718233823776, 0.019168969243764877, 0.0066850208677351475, -0.029813025146722794, -0.00987490825355053, 0.021066760644316673, -0.03497452661395073, -0.022700110450387, -0.01960672251880169, -0.047143373638391495, -0.02527763321995735, 0.04279685392975807, -0.03360937163233757, 0.027518531307578087, -0.01766350120306015, -0.021915409713983536, 0.03177298977971077, 0.053313545882701874, 0.02467973902821541, -0.02651294134557247, -0.012803775258362293, -0.028863422572612762, 0.039438098669052124, -0.042416926473379135, -0.012239398434758186, 0.005267575848847628, -0.00598629517480731, -0.018370434641838074, -0.04966137558221817, -0.011292815208435059, -0.05043155699968338, 0.036489780992269516, -0.06921645253896713, -0.014343317598104477, -0.03415839374065399, -0.029275856912136078, 0.0034805601462721825, 0.023576825857162476, -0.034020308405160904, 0.07803555577993393, 0.00432496378198266, 0.00263650412671268, -0.024231264367699623, 0.016791222617030144, 0.08688855916261673, -0.03747158125042915, -0.002242175629362464, 0.0464523546397686, 0.08273264020681381, 0.06319088488817215, 0.006535672582685947, -0.041464295238256454, -0.15289445221424103, 0.03727535903453827, 0.04356701299548149, 0.007411058060824871, -0.043315473943948746, -0.019165262579917908, 0.015587611123919487, -0.039387162774801254, -0.0027410818729549646, 0.006569976452738047, -0.019761599600315094, -0.018792856484651566, 0.00564871309325099, -0.0033887296449393034, 0.019075000658631325, 0.020081892609596252, 0.003414303995668888, -0.00949383620172739, -0.05284557864069939, 0.02637646719813347, -0.037956662476062775, -0.023302841931581497, -0.021307265385985374, 0.029183989390730858, -0.025348320603370667, 0.034334976226091385, -0.03023325465619564, -0.028397107496857643, -0.07215265929698944, 0.035647910088300705, 0.026708200573921204, -0.03475154563784599, -0.021584535017609596, 0.03758759796619415, -0.0012853206135332584, -0.03584900125861168, -0.014425069093704224, -0.026234904304146767, 0.0859585702419281, 0.049028605222702026, -0.058282483369112015, -0.038981787860393524, 0.030814234167337418, 0.022386733442544937, 0.0010513904271647334, -0.03878971189260483, 0.003312980057671666, -0.007497022859752178, -0.0057773771695792675, -0.0063583506271243095, 0.012749433517456055, 1.2721860002784524e-05, -0.014929492026567459, 0.0008381325169466436, 0.048779476433992386, -0.02932562120258808, 0.01754302717745304, -0.012454813346266747, 0.01217914093285799, 0.0357435867190361, 0.006197585258632898, -0.10307148098945618, -0.03396930545568466, 0.004465831909328699, -0.03239731118083, -0.041129063814878464, -0.020885951817035675, -0.04000013694167137, 0.041709594428539276, -0.05084344372153282, -0.010227389633655548, -0.000970739871263504, -0.021649526432156563, -0.006358716636896133, -0.09170554578304291, -0.020837897434830666, 0.0032055939082056284, 0.001840766635723412, 0.07967489212751389, -0.015482034534215927, -0.024156702682375908, -0.02952892705798149, 0.046280454844236374, -0.04814080521464348, 0.02415402978658676, 0.03433777764439583, 0.020402459427714348, -0.06855158507823944, 0.056078385561704636, 0.03339860215783119, -0.017638126388192177, -0.001548238331452012, 0.03609703108668327, -0.035985883325338364, -0.013088350184261799, -0.018698586151003838, 0.04966410622000694, 0.004877488128840923, 0.004229515325278044, -0.03144708648324013, -0.016079049557447433, -0.003621351905167103, -0.009871840476989746, 0.05931674689054489, -0.023681320250034332, 0.0009210332063958049, -0.07242952287197113, -0.002797770779579878, 0.01925375871360302, -0.008625900372862816, 0.018465105444192886, 0.018448270857334137, -0.08335249871015549, 0.00569993956014514, -0.000418003968661651, 0.004056775942444801, -0.053243134170770645, 0.06785345822572708, 0.019324885681271553, 0.057499270886182785, -0.030846798792481422, 0.015556680969893932, 0.0574444979429245, 0.02903970330953598, -0.08139386028051376, 0.013178917579352856, 0.0012304793344810605, 0.012469884008169174, 0.002336031524464488, 0.035088397562503815, 0.09149032831192017, -0.0679689422249794, 0.016751807183027267, 0.03675016760826111, 0.03026341274380684, 0.039689332246780396, -0.02765079401433468, 0.0177358016371727, 0.028980547562241554, -0.001959597459062934, 0.0007559088408015668, 0.05339497700333595, -0.02353685162961483, 0.020930534228682518, 0.0011560668935999274, -0.0709158331155777, -0.01142223458737135, 0.008681866340339184, 0.053654495626688004, -0.0013733417727053165, -0.04937657713890076, 0.053286269307136536, 0.0852968841791153, -0.05448061227798462, 0.010291139595210552, -0.0007464062073267996, -0.0029094440396875143, -0.050653863698244095, 0.04296157881617546, -0.03285721689462662, -0.041866105049848557, 0.044877272099256516, 0.011827734299004078, 0.0011327601969242096, -0.008110527880489826, -0.011437435634434223, 0.0727253258228302, 0.003706056624650955, 0.02793944627046585, -0.015233759768307209, -0.033049244433641434, 0.06635226309299469, 0.05469048395752907, -0.014486653730273247, -0.0202268548309803, 0.04187830537557602, 0.0461050383746624, -0.02785140834748745, -0.00977113377302885, 0.014602242037653923, 0.029889436438679695, 0.0161870289593935, 0.039717234671115875, -0.008667873218655586, 0.02540680579841137, -0.09038736671209335, -0.003250338137149811, 0.008206064812839031, -0.013681815937161446, 0.01712767779827118, -0.005858791992068291, -5.710644861158769e-33, 0.021081991493701935, 0.020867418497800827, -0.004495145287364721, -0.07180886715650558, -0.018113235011696815, 0.008090639486908913, 0.024680733680725098, 0.04482823610305786, -0.06012233719229698, 0.011770196259021759, -0.011517110280692577, 0.035916611552238464, 0.0043044122867286205, 0.0020011893939226866, 0.01200843509286642, -0.022330446168780327, 0.005493661854416132, -0.016059376299381256, 0.024790145456790924, -0.03765716403722763, 0.0008829575381241739, 0.013106752187013626, 0.04898655042052269, -0.012719453312456608, -0.09067176282405853, 0.028285477310419083, 0.01900753192603588, 0.008501006290316582, 0.01596531644463539, -0.005113536491990089, -0.009773959405720234, -0.011250903829932213, 0.014736696146428585, -0.00904210563749075, -0.00946007389575243, 0.02202845923602581, -0.07284562289714813, 0.018110087141394615, -0.030318966135382652, 0.11900644749403, -0.058166712522506714, -0.00620313873514533, 0.05237806960940361, 0.014464943669736385, -0.01351938582956791, -0.0012108355294913054, 0.0366850271821022, -0.06963587552309036, -0.004170372150838375, 0.014028052799403667, -0.04888095334172249, 0.03937505558133125, 0.0012187936808913946, -0.036579545587301254, 0.03299829736351967, -0.05635906755924225, 0.00763343833386898, -0.02393491566181183, -0.03218184411525726, -0.014274803921580315, -0.01964252069592476, 0.029049880802631378, 0.014135833829641342, 0.05182104930281639, 0.04714798554778099, 0.02486318349838257, 0.015291390009224415, -0.06352332979440689, 0.00012065481132594869, 0.022103693336248398, 0.035504866391420364, 0.06731535494327545, 0.04530036449432373, -0.006989501882344484, 0.07422513514757156, -0.03636091575026512, -0.09965343028306961, 0.002612419193610549, -0.006789062172174454, 0.040915194898843765, -0.011815057136118412, 0.001299873343668878, -0.01798260770738125, 0.03525901213288307, 0.06411310285329819, -0.012732551433146, -0.012212403118610382, -0.016314232721924782, 0.032676246017217636, 0.05411412939429283, -0.053519152104854584, 0.017949730157852173, 0.015939245000481606, -0.031386010348796844, 0.08952493220567703, 0.027500543743371964, -0.00013521993241738528, 0.03023429587483406, 0.05416426062583923, 0.01955471746623516, -0.05517878383398056, -0.011404738761484623, -0.03485948592424393, 0.007613621652126312, -0.012560730800032616, 0.027721697464585304, 0.01671210676431656, 0.04921333119273186, -0.017269477248191833, -0.00037038157461211085, -0.01514825876802206, 0.003639872884377837, 0.014675445854663849, 0.03134447708725929, 0.009888136759400368, -0.050893206149339676, 0.03940216824412346, 0.04086516797542572, -0.031516510993242264, -0.04576808959245682, -0.053331855684518814, 0.01014711894094944, 0.005737878382205963, 0.0022960982751101255, -0.034685127437114716, -0.048214808106422424, -0.07426603883504868, 0.002745895879343152, 0.013991810381412506, -0.06352828443050385, -0.010074862278997898, -0.03642544522881508, 2.789971631500521e-07, -0.05395861342549324, -0.025259656831622124, 0.0021204007789492607, -0.06383846700191498, -0.027932656928896904, 0.009580043144524097, 0.019529102370142937, 0.04694339260458946, 0.0025885007344186306, -0.01182494405657053, 0.005686176475137472, -0.02826518565416336, 0.008974652737379074, -0.033550143241882324, -0.01837225630879402, 0.001885400852188468, 0.03479066118597984, 0.04764938727021217, -0.025177210569381714, 0.02108115702867508, -0.009498300030827522, 0.12468995898962021, 0.03460400179028511, -0.01663849875330925, 0.05805322900414467, -0.009282460436224937, -0.029305649921298027, 0.03830735385417938, 0.0486924946308136, -0.03893664851784706, 0.004428503569215536, 0.07829888164997101, -0.024835381656885147, -0.013530914671719074, 0.007185367867350578, 0.04130227491259575, 0.024447498843073845, 0.020249519497156143, -0.033889129757881165, 0.028758356347680092, 0.02551296353340149, -0.03032073564827442, -0.010095760226249695, -0.010953602381050587, 0.08285219222307205, -0.008465826511383057, -0.0375782772898674, -0.11552891135215759, -0.017485441640019417, -0.005340950563549995, -0.0127872284501791, 0.04060529172420502, -0.0002755016030278057, -9.160330228041857e-05, 0.011383342556655407, -0.09353318810462952, -0.05424995720386505, -0.03046012483537197, 0.015300857834517956, -0.006407619919627905, -0.035695839673280716, 0.016964437440037727, -0.05627835541963577, 0.008084513247013092, 0.0688152089715004, 0.0586494579911232, -0.07097171247005463, 2.174436108224539e-34, -0.029148349538445473, -0.006090973969548941, -0.011203416623175144, -0.00036907001049257815, -0.0015022651059553027, 0.021534161642193794, 0.017168713733553886, 0.03250688314437866, -0.0015837495448067784, 0.02552248351275921, -0.02483530342578888]
683
683
['Xiaoliang Dai', 'Hongxu Yin', 'Niraj K. Jha']
1711.02017v2
Neural networks (NNs) have begun to have a pervasive impact on various applications of machine learning. However, the problem of finding an optimal NN architecture for large applications has remained open for several decades. Conventional approaches search for the optimal NN architecture through extensive trial-and-error. Such a procedure is quite inefficient. In addition, the generated NN architectures incur substantial redundancy. To address these problems, we propose an NN synthesis tool (NeST) that automatically generates very compact architectures for a given dataset. NeST starts with a seed NN architecture. It iteratively tunes the architecture with gradient-based growth and magnitude-based pruning of neurons and connections. Our experimental results show that NeST yields accurate yet very compact NNs with a wide range of seed architecture selection. For example, for the LeNet-300-100 (LeNet-5) NN architecture derived from the MNIST dataset, we reduce network parameters by 34.1x (74.3x) and floating-point operations (FLOPs) by 35.8x (43.7x). For the AlexNet NN architecture derived from the ImageNet dataset, we reduce network parameters by 15.7x and FLOPs by 4.6x. All these results are the current state-of-the-art for these architectures.
NeST: A Neural Network Synthesis Tool Based on a Grow-and-Prune Paradigm
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1711.02017v2
Title NeST Neural Network Synthesis Tool Based GrowandPrune Paradigm Summary Neural network NNs begun pervasive impact various application machine learning However problem finding optimal NN architecture large application remained open several decade Conventional approach search optimal NN architecture extensive trialanderror procedure quite inefficient addition generated NN architecture incur substantial redundancy address problem propose NN synthesis tool NeST automatically generates compact architecture given dataset NeST start seed NN architecture iteratively tune architecture gradientbased growth magnitudebased pruning neuron connection experimental result show NeST yield accurate yet compact NNs wide range seed architecture selection example LeNet300100 LeNet5 NN architecture derived MNIST dataset reduce network parameter 341x 743x floatingpoint operation FLOPs 358x 437x AlexNet NN architecture derived ImageNet dataset reduce network parameter 157x FLOPs 46x result current stateoftheart architecture Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.04225454106926918, 0.045149169862270355, -0.055379170924425125, 0.027144653722643852, -0.03237073868513107, -0.04498456418514252, 0.04806896671652794, -0.011014611460268497, 0.014655706472694874, 0.025836342945694923, 0.0127420574426651, 0.005657525733113289, 0.005699627101421356, 0.08892931044101715, 0.020837491378188133, 0.020776737481355667, 0.02576286345720291, 0.017086198553442955, -0.03137562423944473, -0.007807583548128605, -0.025805853307247162, 0.00770382396876812, 0.017959238961338997, 0.03321022540330887, -0.05907519906759262, 0.003943974617868662, -0.020622925832867622, 0.02127785049378872, -0.0015265606343746185, -0.024555228650569916, 0.04882334917783737, 0.001446272013708949, 0.006860008463263512, 0.024216797202825546, 2.231648750239401e-06, -0.011531314812600613, 0.05891392379999161, 0.0026293881237506866, 0.014207754284143448, 0.008992871269583702, 0.08743660151958466, -0.00884112436324358, -0.023683639243245125, 0.02550792507827282, -0.020288685336709023, -0.03310335800051689, 0.024172332137823105, 0.025806928053498268, 0.05306854099035263, 0.05416358262300491, -0.00533162709325552, -0.08241411298513412, 0.04619039222598076, -0.014594499953091145, -0.008035453036427498, 0.012744412757456303, 0.02600165270268917, 0.0065492806024849415, -0.0029682694002985954, -0.029624873772263527, -0.0019353196257725358, 0.01993473805487156, 0.07190586626529694, -0.02669009193778038, 0.05712796747684479, 0.045787569135427475, 0.006972372531890869, -0.06612355262041092, -0.013416669331490993, 0.027220310643315315, -0.07818790525197983, 0.02604256197810173, 0.0074623264372348785, -0.029445823282003403, -0.01954316534101963, -0.1219632476568222, -0.001216869568452239, -0.02612418122589588, -0.0036329259164631367, 0.010587414726614952, -0.04305942356586456, -0.007520163431763649, 0.014192071743309498, 0.014788608998060226, 0.019672006368637085, 0.007287473883479834, -0.007238314021378756, 0.07088904827833176, -0.037284042686223984, -0.030922936275601387, 0.0091356560587883, -0.026091795414686203, 0.03603814169764519, 0.01912008412182331, -0.012078243307769299, -0.009785182774066925, -0.02140735276043415, -0.05653154104948044, 0.023249046877026558, -0.08393611013889313, 0.04631265625357628, -0.012083488516509533, 0.0010693458607420325, 0.0030993253458291292, -0.08555804938077927, 0.015636878088116646, -0.040346067398786545, -0.07025377452373505, -0.018188925459980965, 0.010019983164966106, 0.009127519093453884, 0.0304593276232481, -0.02209434285759926, 0.07282194495201111, -0.024100204929709435, -0.04653768613934517, -0.07299557328224182, -0.004575725644826889, -0.02932320162653923, 0.0013111531734466553, -0.0006068578222766519, 0.07142467796802521, 0.023927943781018257, -0.010724341496825218, 0.0075140963308513165, -0.0007529114955104887, -0.0063326978124678135, 0.04277699813246727, 0.011797023937106133, -0.028665848076343536, 0.009403888136148453, 0.007566637359559536, 0.008626779541373253, 0.05032525211572647, 0.03031175024807453, 0.07678215950727463, 0.030920548364520073, 0.0315253846347332, -0.07434382289648056, -0.0012545125791803002, -0.005411745514720678, -0.015893667936325073, -0.010440328158438206, -0.050148461014032364, 0.02375323325395584, -0.09039337188005447, -0.06460749357938766, -0.020565688610076904, -0.001340353861451149, 0.009466527961194515, -0.01874668151140213, -0.009317372925579548, -0.07290720194578171, -0.03594373166561127, 0.06896057724952698, -4.4258278649067506e-05, 0.04111609235405922, 0.04485950618982315, 0.047745656222105026, 0.06609427183866501, -0.000636923243291676, -0.011550623923540115, -0.08087940514087677, 0.010480204597115517, 0.05115862190723419, -0.04930325597524643, -0.03756742551922798, -0.0439312681555748, -0.08802937716245651, 0.032512206584215164, -0.002517007291316986, 0.022653454914689064, -0.003643511328846216, -0.017174333333969116, 0.00917823612689972, 0.03518381342291832, 0.026256250217556953, 0.09078291058540344, 0.023856470361351967, -0.00927927065640688, -0.019610784947872162, -0.06395389884710312, -0.009413346648216248, 0.05117751657962799, -0.05001302808523178, -0.053175680339336395, -0.046073053032159805, 0.03902912884950638, -0.040029287338256836, -0.06524977087974548, 0.020668698474764824, -0.03943687304854393, -0.02410660870373249, -0.01931842416524887, 0.0258319228887558, 0.034043919295072556, -0.03074256144464016, 0.0038648995105177164, 0.03292129933834076, -0.004597121383994818, -0.008033150807023048, -0.04249691963195801, -0.003956790082156658, -0.03470677509903908, -0.03024892881512642, 0.00020206013869028538, -0.03831709921360016, 0.022581016644835472, -0.08052222430706024, -0.011338642798364162, -0.01580549217760563, -0.003777953563258052, 0.053345415741205215, -0.058250583708286285, 0.03856031224131584, 0.00777776911854744, 0.014303551986813545, 0.0029606493189930916, -0.020049281418323517, 0.040023934096097946, 0.0391690619289875, 0.01942151039838791, -0.02878476493060589, 0.018300849944353104, -0.02415657974779606, 0.015321820043027401, 0.06792998313903809, -0.013162155635654926, 0.012611625716090202, 0.025694873183965683, 0.03796909749507904, -0.030154824256896973, 0.04026282951235771, -0.02437189593911171, -0.04950664937496185, -0.06566358357667923, -0.07657133787870407, -0.0018375370418652892, 0.022252609953284264, 0.004863858222961426, 0.06679223477840424, 0.004269806202501059, -0.04600968956947327, -0.04636930301785469, 0.07327592372894287, -0.029744751751422882, -0.014225853607058525, -0.02929016388952732, -0.022855907678604126, -0.026408731937408447, 0.029849205166101456, 0.017109373584389687, 0.048671502619981766, 0.009644570760428905, 0.005708759184926748, -0.030429938808083534, -0.00034905283246189356, 0.0024379452224820852, -0.00016462377971038222, 0.0054916925728321075, -0.031191840767860413, -0.04531088471412659, -0.014282100833952427, -0.011135736480355263, 0.05518961697816849, 0.017112255096435547, -0.000504960014950484, -0.04716421291232109, 0.03754158690571785, -0.029086673632264137, 0.01963936537504196, 0.0073729208670556545, 0.019423209130764008, 0.015075077302753925, -0.02791832573711872, -0.03166002407670021, 0.08938015252351761, -0.013352949172258377, -0.050195734947919846, 0.034772589802742004, 0.006467022001743317, -0.05596448853611946, 0.0011342877987772226, -0.07528048753738403, 0.011679702438414097, 0.04461997002363205, 0.055732984095811844, -0.00300544872879982, -0.001058480003848672, -0.0005211639800108969, -0.024272339418530464, 0.029728854075074196, -0.013968212530016899, -0.027227016165852547, -0.029395975172519684, -0.015451722778379917, -0.013338470831513405, 0.05722134932875633, 0.0489002950489521, -0.01645655930042267, 0.00870751217007637, 0.07428229600191116, -0.012458235025405884, 0.02906172350049019, -0.02156369760632515, 0.02275124378502369, 0.03552650660276413, 0.017185091972351074, -0.025326699018478394, 0.026384849101305008, -0.009598775766789913, -0.013705994933843613, -0.031744398176670074, 0.007651421707123518, 0.011007078923285007, 0.009295251220464706, -0.040170155465602875, -0.009543956257402897, 0.005425788927823305, 0.0015557107981294394, 0.0183468759059906, -0.03402828425168991, -0.034906137734651566, -0.005865524522960186, -0.01171914953738451, -0.013216168619692326, -0.0679149329662323, -0.01588587276637554, 0.009306838735938072, 0.05229983106255531, 0.012305743992328644, -0.018071843311190605, -0.003829212160781026, -0.01521846279501915, 0.017348188906908035, -0.005008267238736153, -0.018741978332400322, -0.0006131493137218058, -0.0042630513198673725, 0.009202670305967331, -0.016557250171899796, -0.03633834421634674, -0.04744202271103859, 0.03330683335661888, 0.008149158209562302, -0.006018099375069141, 0.006037075072526932, -0.03545993193984032, 0.05725730583071709, -0.020220521837472916, 0.0006550631369464099, 0.056370045989751816, 0.008686559274792671, -0.006932804360985756, 0.007134520448744297, 0.007510720752179623, 0.02308795414865017, -0.01714705117046833, 0.02687021531164646, 0.031160874292254448, 0.041463740170001984, 0.004680718295276165, -0.017130659893155098, 0.04489896446466446, -0.11774135380983353, 0.025683412328362465, -0.018667932599782944, 0.023777641355991364, -0.009390955790877342, 0.030968235805630684, 0.048638515174388885, -0.03821210935711861, 0.03791741654276848, 0.0008215149282477796, -0.021150464192032814, -0.0516936369240284, 0.006703692954033613, -0.010823833756148815, 0.033058419823646545, 0.008043615147471428, 0.03415680304169655, -0.022542933002114296, 0.029291978105902672, -0.010629416443407536, -0.002815870102494955, -0.027634548023343086, -0.04201560840010643, -0.02958039380609989, -0.10004980862140656, 0.0335053950548172, 0.008800552226603031, -0.04320031777024269, -0.027256349101662636, -0.028817346319556236, 0.012708849273622036, -0.014744316227734089, 0.004493134096264839, 0.020764978602528572, 0.007750371936708689, -0.031027818098664284, 0.030140366405248642, -0.03802766650915146, -0.00806036964058876, -0.0010671514319255948, -0.08064360171556473, -0.01473428774625063, -0.03153461962938309, 0.0014092660276219249, -0.014660865999758244, -0.03164913132786751, 0.04387633875012398, 0.016577910631895065, 0.02093031071126461, -0.045482851564884186, 0.020485766232013702, 0.06387892365455627, -0.01460860762745142, -0.027674956247210503, 0.055797893553972244, -0.0338224321603775, 0.016282087191939354, 0.012406525202095509, 0.04003819823265076, 0.0225974228233099, -0.018054183572530746, -0.06180315092206001, 0.03566139191389084, 0.00350242224521935, -0.027943039312958717, 0.022252559661865234, -0.026323972269892693, -0.02403395064175129, 0.02617444284260273, 0.012153579853475094, -0.0830448791384697, -0.02942933328449726, 0.049430426210165024, 0.018646955490112305, -0.02402469515800476, -0.04382527992129326, 0.04419898986816406, -0.03405465558171272, 0.052718374878168106, 0.029598230496048927, -0.034078847616910934, 0.05205945670604706, 0.01373342052102089, -0.01928810402750969, -0.023577634245157242, 0.04096611216664314, -0.022330250591039658, -0.017823316156864166, 0.04816284030675888, 0.0816718339920044, -0.010580195114016533, 0.00456615723669529, -0.0483521893620491, -0.08141686022281647, -0.003125016111880541, 0.0018830012995749712, 0.0537998266518116, 0.005273748654872179, 0.010372848249971867, -0.0007919493364170194, -0.010404586791992188, 0.05704647675156593, 0.03559637814760208, 0.009930300526320934, 0.004161988850682974, 0.017822282388806343, -0.05782973766326904, -0.03364089876413345, 0.024257885292172432, 0.0005207795766182244, 0.09377279877662659, -0.0011967699974775314, -0.034605398774147034, 0.030295442789793015, 0.005618834402412176, -0.027279257774353027, 0.005158599931746721, 0.010431269183754921, 0.02304127626121044, 0.013044209219515324, -0.03321811929345131, 0.042879167944192886, 0.013750207610428333, 0.047454338520765305, -0.05364537239074707, 0.017549602314829826, -0.001026131329126656, 0.03855882212519646, -0.007161474321037531, -0.04079066589474678, 0.1027560755610466, -0.03705268353223801, 0.013108070008456707, 0.06139678508043289, -0.009294693358242512, 0.03919477015733719, -0.005956261418759823, 0.032766979187726974, -0.06619861721992493, -0.00725744990631938, 0.013957938179373741, 0.04610484093427658, -0.05269309878349304, 0.00152724445797503, -0.0014713588170707226, 0.0008749480475671589, -0.061146583408117294, 0.025929775089025497, 0.04445068910717964, -0.050678372383117676, -0.06022133305668831, -0.003719532862305641, 0.05407789349555969, 0.016523828729987144, -0.038246866315603256, -0.03164518624544144, 0.02231939695775509, -0.034361936151981354, 0.04728524386882782, -0.015241613611578941, -0.006631254218518734, -0.011813757941126823, -0.007323192898184061, -0.030494103208184242, -0.031785547733306885, 0.011583858169615269, 0.05576561763882637, 0.002911579329520464, 0.00011134301166748628, 0.05281857028603554, -0.010777710936963558, 0.014241587370634079, -0.022181905806064606, 0.057243913412094116, 0.018864301964640617, -0.005952805280685425, -0.018112728372216225, -0.03684980049729347, -0.03321525454521179, 0.04034655913710594, 0.06283015012741089, -0.007035512942820787, 0.04126767814159393, -0.020161569118499756, 0.019802596420049667, -0.027508901432156563, 0.04100014641880989, -0.02008286863565445, -0.029849600046873093, 0.009214074350893497, -0.034396205097436905, -6.090843447910868e-33, 0.01579943671822548, 0.009390268474817276, 0.000322885753121227, 0.0054926504381000996, -0.045931749045848846, 0.04862726479768753, -0.021870721131563187, -0.04073027893900871, -0.05016755685210228, -0.044706251472234726, -0.04611823335289955, 0.026112478226423264, 0.003107402240857482, 0.02872486039996147, 0.03160721808671951, -0.0017315112054347992, 0.05135045573115349, -0.018168801441788673, 0.04570264369249344, 0.04283585026860237, 0.0016583205433562398, 0.007769473362714052, 0.013202456757426262, -0.033052727580070496, -0.08788342028856277, 0.024880295619368553, 0.012239446863532066, -0.01806214265525341, -0.0413907915353775, -0.02501661889255047, 0.019215811043977737, 0.05907347798347473, 0.01711433380842209, 0.020585021004080772, -0.019492236897349358, -0.039203036576509476, -0.045805588364601135, -0.04812312126159668, -0.02487371489405632, -0.01393316499888897, -0.07087808102369308, 0.012922273017466068, 0.09578129649162292, 0.012001518160104752, -0.058054368942976, 0.010387958027422428, 0.02162301540374756, 0.01120559312403202, -0.008496587164700031, -0.024692228063941002, -0.01319112628698349, 0.022192008793354034, 0.037047162652015686, 0.026710057631134987, -0.019225191324949265, -0.04059441015124321, -0.025030218064785004, -0.024614842608571053, -0.06676848977804184, -0.00864843837916851, 0.012178187258541584, 0.030583245679736137, 0.0010714337695389986, 0.04369611293077469, 0.044498275965452194, 0.05637865141034126, 0.09829270094633102, 0.03803285211324692, -0.04066891595721245, 0.015758445486426353, 0.05286027491092682, 0.05888800323009491, 0.09536167979240417, -0.0023455293849110603, 0.08498291671276093, -0.08116530627012253, -0.06524955481290817, -0.0003262458194512874, 0.04917056858539581, 0.03282041475176811, -0.02392992563545704, -0.003276895498856902, 0.03258323296904564, -0.009460503235459328, 0.03600098565220833, -0.050502896308898926, -0.019602790474891663, -0.03058643639087677, -0.00908526312559843, 0.025851156562566757, -0.03133069723844528, -0.012537820264697075, -0.018761565908789635, -0.024552838876843452, 0.0786995217204094, 0.020988525822758675, 0.03202890604734421, 0.022238826379179955, 0.05999619886279106, -0.010883806273341179, -0.019841186702251434, -0.039625782519578934, -0.03446674719452858, 0.03666311129927635, 0.042745109647512436, 0.002469457220286131, -0.017022578045725822, 0.03753627836704254, 0.004241414368152618, -0.03353729844093323, -0.006689116824418306, 0.020404605194926262, 0.02492026425898075, -0.0029029040597379208, -0.004159368574619293, -0.005624543875455856, 0.0036990828812122345, 0.048753876239061356, 0.013792653568089008, 0.02588166855275631, -0.036236558109521866, 0.032906901091337204, 0.023801235482096672, 0.04278289154171944, -0.058613307774066925, -0.022087188437581062, -0.03560078144073486, 0.05567000433802605, 0.03873714059591293, -0.10508609563112259, -0.02996855601668358, 0.052977390587329865, 2.997025774220674e-07, -0.0372350849211216, 0.0183250829577446, 0.010349561460316181, -0.030361749231815338, 0.05050136148929596, 0.0075650946237146854, 0.03007029928267002, 0.0059978351928293705, -0.03807678818702698, -0.00599515438079834, 0.004878557752817869, -0.059851180762052536, 0.003047280479222536, 0.018781794235110283, -0.03475191816687584, -0.03088553249835968, -0.03353508189320564, 0.04191865026950836, -0.0020705752540379763, 0.018093682825565338, 0.038115281611680984, 0.07802673429250717, 0.021820364519953728, -0.04071766510605812, 0.041240617632865906, 0.009739440865814686, -0.023009179159998894, 0.005039571784436703, 0.05325381085276604, -0.022936126217246056, -0.03887927159667015, 0.04009423032402992, -0.0038067663554102182, 0.0084752282127738, -0.008921977132558823, 0.014053693041205406, -0.03660615161061287, 0.022046778351068497, -0.018879424780607224, 0.019567467272281647, 0.027130750939249992, 0.027118006721138954, -0.008229137398302555, -0.06135217472910881, 0.03877860680222511, -0.032781802117824554, -0.03445005044341087, -0.054381102323532104, 0.029383737593889236, 0.012878501787781715, 0.006721809972077608, 0.0011784164234995842, 0.002723298966884613, 0.01302268449217081, -0.005605427548289299, -0.042501963675022125, -0.0026067113503813744, -0.051987454295158386, 0.021543722599744797, 0.07778459787368774, -0.031211791560053825, 0.011077586561441422, -0.027568111196160316, -0.001386934774927795, 0.07754084467887878, 0.0569131076335907, -0.017665106803178787, 2.747459298536672e-34, -0.06049616262316704, -0.04664693772792816, -0.003970176447182894, 0.008431202732026577, -0.05257439240813255, 0.021673288196325302, 0.02723083272576332, 0.009172561578452587, -0.031481608748435974, -0.00626347353681922, -0.07560854405164719]
684
684
['Filipe Rolim Cordeiro', 'Wellington Pinheiro dos Santos', 'Abel Guilhermino da Silva Filho']
1712.07312v1
Breast cancer is already one of the most common form of cancer worldwide. Mammography image analysis is still the most effective diagnostic method to promote the early detection of breast cancer. Accurately segmenting tumors in digital mammography images is important to improve diagnosis capabilities of health specialists and avoid misdiagnosis. In this work, we evaluate the feasibility of applying GrowCut to segment regions of tumor and we propose two GrowCut semi-supervised versions. All the analysis was performed by evaluating the application of segmentation techniques to a set of images obtained from the Mini-MIAS mammography image database. GrowCut segmentation was compared to Region Growing, Active Contours, Random Walks and Graph Cut techniques. Experiments showed that GrowCut, when compared to the other techniques, was able to acquire better results for the metrics analyzed. Moreover, the proposed semi-supervised versions of GrowCut was proved to have a clinically satisfactory quality of segmentation.
Analysis of supervised and semi-supervised GrowCut applied to segmentation of masses in mammography images
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1712.07312v1
Title Analysis supervised semisupervised GrowCut applied segmentation mass mammography image Summary Breast cancer already one common form cancer worldwide Mammography image analysis still effective diagnostic method promote early detection breast cancer Accurately segmenting tumor digital mammography image important improve diagnosis capability health specialist avoid misdiagnosis work evaluate feasibility applying GrowCut segment region tumor propose two GrowCut semisupervised version analysis performed evaluating application segmentation technique set image obtained MiniMIAS mammography image database GrowCut segmentation compared Region Growing Active Contours Random Walks Graph Cut technique Experiments showed GrowCut compared technique able acquire better result metric analyzed Moreover proposed semisupervised version GrowCut proved clinically satisfactory quality segmentation Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.016599994152784348, -0.0029411392752081156, -0.023990413174033165, 0.001886810059659183, -0.05486414209008217, -0.0001775944692781195, 0.03415572643280029, 0.037300389260053635, 0.02353079617023468, 0.031302161514759064, 0.07191748917102814, 0.01975228823721409, -0.01802855171263218, 0.07661595195531845, -0.02419896423816681, -0.04990557208657265, -0.07463978230953217, -0.002934993477538228, -0.03860204666852951, -0.024571917951107025, 0.001499780802987516, -0.04105520248413086, -0.005922118201851845, 0.006533666979521513, -0.09653737396001816, 0.05174132063984871, 0.031165067106485367, 0.01629890874028206, -0.012562835589051247, -0.009366370737552643, -0.005914679728448391, -0.07415473461151123, -0.07938043028116226, 0.015259398147463799, 2.5192091470671585e-06, -0.09730590134859085, 0.0008373007294721901, 0.002181185409426689, 0.02547401934862137, -0.018005860969424248, 0.012056001462042332, -0.01640986278653145, -0.023110048845410347, -0.09477515518665314, 0.025701377540826797, 0.045133691281080246, -0.0315551683306694, 0.05622391775250435, 0.0315137580037117, 0.06901534646749496, -0.015841137617826462, -0.0522468201816082, -0.013488803058862686, 0.0023590598721057177, -0.06910578906536102, -0.0009995129657909274, -0.003370775608345866, 0.016665905714035034, -0.0655689463019371, -0.03766383230686188, -0.02668347768485546, 0.07590901106595993, 0.024332551285624504, -0.03388696536421776, -0.012574165128171444, 0.06265909969806671, 0.017726020887494087, -0.06876764446496964, 0.023594405502080917, 0.008418788202106953, -0.00960509292781353, 0.02169198729097843, 0.015814315527677536, -0.029503582045435905, -0.02710132487118244, 0.04876004531979561, -0.029196925461292267, 0.023616258054971695, 0.0050242505967617035, 0.023085737600922585, -0.06170181185007095, 0.00913294032216072, 0.0018219271441921592, -0.04858774319291115, -0.017893945798277855, 0.03474539518356323, -0.008989040739834309, 0.02453889697790146, -0.014735282398760319, -0.014771545305848122, -0.008914252743124962, 0.025053825229406357, 0.0912923589348793, 0.01776386797428131, 0.037680793553590775, -0.034565262496471405, -0.01382653322070837, -0.004724209196865559, 0.05960137024521828, -0.020779812708497047, -0.044712428003549576, -0.06255480647087097, -0.052099063992500305, 0.015881173312664032, -0.021639149636030197, -0.04111994057893753, -0.012482194229960442, 0.11158916354179382, -0.06231803819537163, 0.02826779894530773, -0.018005836755037308, 0.022819921374320984, 0.017876602709293365, 0.04186158627271652, 0.021313786506652832, -0.01536380872130394, -0.06595008820295334, -0.011572949588298798, -0.032148849219083786, -0.033785704523324966, 0.07712887227535248, 0.042879071086645126, 0.0028156829066574574, -0.006070321425795555, -0.0006227356498129666, -0.02714582160115242, -0.03166484087705612, -0.029960421845316887, -0.010822714306414127, -0.002334998222067952, 0.017085887491703033, 0.02530411258339882, 0.006577115505933762, 0.029209114611148834, 0.02666892297565937, -0.013898181729018688, -0.014550178311765194, 0.004496689885854721, -0.05885852500796318, 0.025290969759225845, -0.01810683310031891, -0.04565277695655823, 0.002803190378472209, -0.008096521720290184, -0.05795806646347046, -0.05125084146857262, 0.03127656504511833, 0.09060738235712051, -0.006344977300614119, -0.011173918843269348, -0.014200453646481037, -0.007777789607644081, 0.0009861092548817396, -0.0008749299449846148, 0.1249753087759018, 0.012774214148521423, 0.062269967049360275, 0.0035895812325179577, 0.03933921083807945, 0.002727535553276539, 0.023317990824580193, -0.028917141258716583, -0.018574781715869904, -0.017184613272547722, -0.007953532971441746, -0.0539570190012455, -0.05030931532382965, -0.038086868822574615, -0.07868053764104843, -0.028214776888489723, 0.016767468303442, 0.03011307679116726, 0.04225639998912811, 0.0035134039353579283, -0.028860226273536682, 0.03600344806909561, 0.051411401480436325, 0.02997191809117794, 0.016683274880051613, -0.018670925870537758, -0.03275343030691147, 0.022052377462387085, 0.03350052237510681, -0.0300035011023283, -0.06657234579324722, -0.01268727332353592, -0.015673303976655006, -0.0017355288146063685, -0.008666783571243286, -0.0353451669216156, -0.0029907687567174435, 0.006829088553786278, 0.0158123467117548, -0.011716721579432487, 0.05679582059383392, 0.020177951082587242, 0.018041152507066727, -0.10760099440813065, -0.0054894196800887585, 0.024420419707894325, -0.05784982070326805, -0.07581982761621475, -0.029959840700030327, -0.06867074966430664, 0.011057121679186821, -0.02486789971590042, 0.028475133702158928, 0.0557209812104702, 0.003857739269733429, -0.06309732049703598, -0.01674276404082775, 0.015048570930957794, -0.015495849773287773, -0.008547757752239704, 0.023791508749127388, 0.03791814669966698, -0.014052053913474083, -0.032948922365903854, 0.0072074211202561855, 0.07312320917844772, 0.004930370487272739, -0.02474786341190338, 0.027647368609905243, -0.008413024246692657, 0.07682616263628006, 0.032824087888002396, -0.028780803084373474, 0.019614605233073235, -0.0029075692873448133, -0.013198697939515114, -0.012455477379262447, -0.04042704403400421, 0.016617750748991966, 0.009366760961711407, 0.003473961725831032, 0.009366081096231937, 0.015633825212717056, -0.015668770298361778, -0.001462988555431366, -0.005588729865849018, -0.032102685421705246, -0.05010165274143219, 0.011526528745889664, -0.017323890700936317, 0.0003982443013228476, -0.001152029843069613, 0.0005237445002421737, -0.020592764019966125, 0.025851042941212654, 0.0044756983406841755, 0.0027083256281912327, -0.021394748240709305, 0.07100305706262589, -0.02401674911379814, -0.05253109708428383, -0.0005406865966506302, -0.02406439743936062, -0.03991018235683441, 0.007487920578569174, 0.011718407273292542, 0.03550345078110695, -0.02406461164355278, 0.0093033816665411, -0.0257002841681242, 0.04337584599852562, -0.017082860693335533, -0.018464235588908195, -0.018801135942339897, -0.03279562667012215, -0.004059480503201485, -0.014218269847333431, 0.037739962339401245, -0.007670740131288767, 0.0033202236518263817, -0.03747895359992981, 0.03595740348100662, 0.011226928792893887, 0.007381557486951351, -0.050665441900491714, 0.03954671323299408, 0.017325857654213905, 0.05151095241308212, -0.017159737646579742, -0.02004832774400711, 0.021616708487272263, -0.004437402356415987, 0.0781395360827446, -0.03363578021526337, 0.02811557985842228, 0.026817016303539276, -0.012593275867402554, -0.012495624832808971, 0.023307187482714653, -0.019768688827753067, -0.045238956809043884, -0.008149961940944195, -0.01845555752515793, 0.07492624223232269, 0.03228061646223068, 0.0395657941699028, -0.0056295497342944145, 0.03891695663332939, 0.03420383483171463, -0.014418544247746468, -0.022197065874934196, 0.03011130541563034, 0.008098717778921127, -0.06091133877635002, 0.012487969361245632, -0.025496110320091248, 0.008256481029093266, -0.0160265751183033, 0.037425696849823, -0.058939091861248016, -0.04094946011900902, -0.0005314679583534598, -0.007258881814777851, 0.022850368171930313, -0.042781904339790344, -0.02081337571144104, 0.015684522688388824, -0.01770060695707798, 0.05502071604132652, 0.030276348814368248, -0.0019022582564502954, -0.017079535871744156, -0.046567559242248535, 0.030684059485793114, -0.026280149817466736, 0.08493122458457947, 0.03486168384552002, -0.05846249312162399, 0.01412890013307333, 0.00328474841080606, 0.002135232789441943, 0.03675354644656181, -0.0064228917472064495, -0.007566388696432114, 0.033378127962350845, 0.023035630583763123, 0.043120358139276505, 0.036620113998651505, -0.023006999865174294, 0.03710164502263069, 0.038575008511543274, -0.01270329486578703, 0.06698688864707947, 0.01509311143308878, 0.033104944974184036, 0.04854842647910118, -0.030779285356402397, 0.04440935328602791, 0.0013378269504755735, -0.0027145647909492254, 0.015731332823634148, 0.05079522356390953, 0.04274236783385277, -0.05590367317199707, -0.09416370093822479, 0.004988986067473888, 0.028834722936153412, 0.01739378646016121, -0.0833275094628334, -0.029581105336546898, -0.03387561812996864, 0.022258397191762924, -0.051907315850257874, 0.010562298819422722, 0.01370335090905428, -0.011907612904906273, 0.048381105065345764, 0.004777278285473585, 0.017873603850603104, 0.0069696553982794285, 0.022772349417209625, -0.032029081135988235, -0.02798296883702278, -0.016739074140787125, -0.046292249113321304, 0.015053781680762768, 0.017534073442220688, 0.051921334117650986, 0.026615826413035393, 0.011257781647145748, 0.002294825157150626, -0.013336333446204662, -0.0017619162099435925, 0.033337902277708054, -0.022914033383131027, 0.07321720570325851, 0.00025721878046169877, -0.02752242237329483, 0.04104556888341904, -0.028676403686404228, -0.006326204165816307, 0.0036460428964346647, -0.09260085970163345, -0.0033862802665680647, -0.019891126081347466, -0.05529029667377472, 0.010850080288946629, -0.05789130553603172, 0.022726548835635185, -0.03878575935959816, -0.027297165244817734, -0.08713643997907639, -0.02153562195599079, 0.029651431366801262, -0.03331891819834709, 0.01859344355762005, 0.05020683631300926, 0.03945377469062805, 0.01782880909740925, -0.043803513050079346, 0.08687160164117813, 0.04818815737962723, 0.016518304124474525, -0.013709246180951595, 0.05426821485161781, 0.09810631722211838, 0.0396714024245739, 0.04909675568342209, 0.009648222476243973, 0.015026022680103779, -0.02473815344274044, -0.05484330654144287, 0.03292038291692734, -0.03439973667263985, -0.07121657580137253, 0.019060678780078888, 0.0144722368568182, -0.03994598984718323, 0.014522941783070564, 0.09177583456039429, -0.0024342553224414587, 0.04455690085887909, -0.0003417849657125771, -0.007655424065887928, -0.0459609180688858, -0.031508855521678925, 0.0004038898041471839, -0.018776599317789078, 0.06819535791873932, 0.03616335615515709, -0.019194146618247032, -0.02991570718586445, -0.006875484250485897, -0.04785921797156334, 0.009615365415811539, 0.009130017831921577, -0.02618878148496151, -0.03007519245147705, -0.036527641117572784, 0.003443837398663163, -0.005304734688252211, 0.005400484427809715, -0.04193516820669174, -0.04659729078412056, 0.013626170344650745, -0.07909013330936432, 0.061123598366975784, 0.000601372099481523, -0.02003844641149044, -0.0671946182847023, -0.008882207795977592, 0.07467273622751236, -0.048364147543907166, 0.033149782568216324, -0.022294608876109123, -0.0031869274098426104, -0.03905332833528519, -0.0007484792149625719, -0.015169495716691017, 0.05931015685200691, 0.048327598720788956, 0.020914511755108833, -0.04032963141798973, -0.05639563500881195, 0.005652902647852898, -0.027867164462804794, 0.016432594507932663, 0.06626751273870468, 0.04939918592572212, 0.07300543785095215, -0.023672452196478844, 0.04256840795278549, -0.0027704827953130007, -0.001995969796553254, 0.017606575042009354, 0.013066645711660385, -0.008659700863063335, 0.05600036308169365, 0.01311453152447939, -0.04012666642665863, -0.012280958704650402, -0.08030570298433304, 0.010761536657810211, 0.009067971259355545, 0.028882183134555817, -0.015233743004500866, 0.00457242876291275, -0.0034157345071434975, 0.017766667529940605, -0.10348345339298248, 0.044028718024492264, 0.013980024494230747, 0.04812115058302879, 0.020738717168569565, -0.019543452188372612, 0.012042902410030365, -0.03185344114899635, 0.030125217512249947, 0.03517623618245125, 0.016352977603673935, -0.041312575340270996, 0.04977656528353691, 0.015846753492951393, -0.045716773718595505, -0.048868294805288315, -0.004667037166655064, 0.009664851240813732, -0.01638527400791645, 0.042765259742736816, -0.006294954568147659, -0.03225600719451904, -0.007673843298107386, -0.004785671830177307, 0.026897594332695007, 0.02563231624662876, -0.006567527074366808, -0.009803163819015026, -0.02236274443566799, -0.02813800238072872, -0.013036832213401794, -0.07479649782180786, 0.014523000456392765, 0.008251465857028961, 0.0031301432754844427, -0.009086230769753456, 0.020340317860245705, 0.0007686183671467006, -0.009370610117912292, 0.009001629427075386, 0.000707147060893476, 0.03480895608663559, 0.005935530178248882, 0.0138396630063653, 0.0037545403465628624, -0.012295256368815899, -0.02355751022696495, -0.053144410252571106, -0.018812909722328186, 0.04739144816994667, 0.01619507558643818, 0.03852185234427452, -6.528157835801484e-33, 0.03737487643957138, -0.0008279464673250914, 0.004159498959779739, -0.0021585964132100344, -0.03224817290902138, 0.023145131766796112, -0.004711305722594261, 0.011714070104062557, 0.032262880355119705, -0.0031544710509479046, -0.005392148159444332, -0.015025263652205467, 0.009788546711206436, 0.039130233228206635, -0.05372701957821846, -0.021223008632659912, 0.008246663957834244, 0.00871547032147646, 0.011545813642442226, -0.007088492624461651, -0.04710531234741211, 0.013815909624099731, 0.008226712234318256, 0.01350017823278904, -0.04904010519385338, 0.04399847239255905, -0.022855505347251892, -0.04456610605120659, -0.05016045644879341, -0.03611631691455841, 0.03909231722354889, -0.014492099173367023, -0.0034584111999720335, 0.023369308561086655, 0.008039862848818302, -0.0575082004070282, 0.03659164905548096, -0.010322146117687225, -0.0331137515604496, 0.07013057917356491, -0.047359708696603775, 0.01865510083734989, 0.02946924790740013, -0.03641971945762634, 0.03352576121687889, 0.0575227327644825, 0.042571134865283966, 0.0071284351870417595, -0.008150693960487843, 0.03228176385164261, 0.019488388672471046, 0.03657235577702522, -0.010809426195919514, 0.004496266599744558, 0.046706218272447586, -0.09304101020097733, -0.03233871981501579, 0.0026925376150757074, -0.00990321859717369, 0.04195936769247055, 0.0858297273516655, -0.020289774984121323, 0.0012423621956259012, 0.0034340200945734978, 0.018385546281933784, -0.014237302355468273, 0.02337850257754326, -0.09036736190319061, -0.005890191998332739, 0.018924476578831673, -0.04935724288225174, 0.01941806636750698, -0.04060545936226845, -0.044284116476774216, 0.03670679032802582, -0.04535568505525589, -0.020018311217427254, 0.01904040016233921, -0.083960622549057, 0.02433917112648487, -0.05819203704595566, 0.023017046973109245, -0.02946537546813488, 0.0037673618644475937, 0.10384310036897659, -0.049349017441272736, -0.00088983349269256, 0.006199474446475506, -0.005132216028869152, -0.0030048845801502466, -0.054409489035606384, 0.02757461741566658, -0.06771058589220047, -0.009000609628856182, 0.021552274003624916, -0.05649940297007561, 0.01498324517160654, 0.030323656275868416, -0.0023359875194728374, -0.04965558275580406, 0.009026328101754189, 0.0014362887013703585, -0.014335311949253082, -0.029247475787997246, 0.00245074275881052, 0.02034088969230652, -0.004602330271154642, -0.005366959609091282, 0.02724488638341427, -0.004460603930056095, 0.021599089726805687, -0.019148577004671097, -0.017962222918868065, 0.04209977760910988, -0.002889975905418396, -0.030482588335871696, -0.007335555274039507, 0.08349664509296417, 0.01785970851778984, -0.009355425834655762, -0.04508490115404129, 0.011443563736975193, -0.0014837533235549927, -0.0017770283157005906, -0.06056489050388336, 0.00818435288965702, 0.007405817974358797, -0.0012366495793685317, 0.029492557048797607, -0.056527286767959595, -0.013130697421729565, 0.018657712265849113, 3.0820558549748966e-07, 0.019933996722102165, 0.04304799437522888, -0.004893667995929718, -0.08122707158327103, -0.005101216956973076, -0.020398778840899467, -0.04416699334979057, -0.05411329120397568, -0.018288390710949898, -0.0008890270837582648, 0.04775609076023102, -0.018924424424767494, -0.02293267473578453, -0.00030604383209720254, 0.012186067178845406, 0.03823583945631981, 0.03390378877520561, -0.013485410250723362, 0.01574152521789074, 0.025676770135760307, -0.015547727234661579, -0.026553617790341377, 0.03793874755501747, -0.05169299244880676, 0.06291795521974564, -0.007398114539682865, -0.0019114932511001825, -0.029700780287384987, 0.048672959208488464, -0.0680123046040535, -0.016624927520751953, 0.048642367124557495, 0.03200424090027809, 0.02897515892982483, 0.008067208342254162, -0.035800084471702576, 0.030419157817959785, 0.0540689118206501, 0.01432915311306715, 0.059647172689437866, 0.039477478712797165, 0.07241105288267136, 0.040985628962516785, -0.001717233913950622, 0.028146568685770035, 0.01908916048705578, -0.0076097301207482815, -0.02768651209771633, 0.03969845548272133, 0.014232752844691277, 0.04146968573331833, -0.05871165916323662, -0.03922129049897194, 0.05571500211954117, 0.0112618962302804, -0.0031449601519852877, 0.02484573796391487, 0.02726408839225769, 0.030442042276263237, -0.03342863544821739, -0.0038606186863034964, -0.009907127358019352, 0.046819932758808136, 0.04551868513226509, 0.03560739383101463, 0.0769788920879364, -0.034989409148693085, 2.4470651610151423e-34, 0.004839374218136072, 0.032167643308639526, -0.005166979506611824, 0.013384444639086723, -0.05608029663562775, 0.028875520452857018, -0.0014737049350515008, -0.04354941099882126, -0.056002192199230194, 0.037191130220890045, -0.021487204357981682]
685
685
['Shumeet Baluja']
1801.05156v1
We present extensive experiments training and testing hidden units in deep networks that emit only a predefined, static, number of discretized values. These units provide benefits in real-world deployment in systems in which memory and/or computation may be limited. Additionally, they are particularly well suited for use in large recurrent network models that require the maintenance of large amounts of internal state in memory. Surprisingly, we find that despite reducing the number of values that can be represented in the output activations from $2^{32}-2^{64}$ to between 64 and 256, there is little to no degradation in network performance across a variety of different settings. We investigate simple classification and regression tasks, as well as memorization and compression problems. We compare the results with more standard activations, such as tanh and relu. Unlike previous discretization studies which often concentrate only on binary units, we examine the effects of varying the number of allowed activation levels. Compared to existing approaches for discretization, the approach presented here is both conceptually and programatically simple, has no stochastic component, and allows the training, testing, and usage phases to be treated in exactly the same manner.
Empirical Explorations in Training Networks with Discrete Activations
2,018
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1801.05156v1
Title Empirical Explorations Training Networks Discrete Activations Summary present extensive experiment training testing hidden unit deep network emit predefined static number discretized value unit provide benefit realworld deployment system memory andor computation may limited Additionally particularly well suited use large recurrent network model require maintenance large amount internal state memory Surprisingly find despite reducing number value represented output activation 232264 64 256 little degradation network performance across variety different setting investigate simple classification regression task well memorization compression problem compare result standard activation tanh relu Unlike previous discretization study often concentrate binary unit examine effect varying number allowed activation level Compared existing approach discretization approach presented conceptually programatically simple stochastic component allows training testing usage phase treated exactly manner Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.012845207937061787, 0.0042851511389017105, -0.014024388045072556, 0.0053544011898338795, 0.03046133928000927, -0.0171323474496603, 0.07774453610181808, -0.008793994784355164, -0.017757412046194077, 0.0006350188632495701, 0.010669970884919167, -0.01071455143392086, -0.007712224032729864, 0.038528744131326675, 0.021989526227116585, -0.0014435453340411186, 0.056896716356277466, 0.021851638332009315, -0.007016770076006651, -0.004927333444356918, -0.004695456475019455, -0.02329760417342186, -0.036733563989400864, 0.026833495125174522, -0.038969844579696655, -0.00021144076890777797, -0.013252509757876396, -0.04239794611930847, 0.02143731899559498, -0.07183142751455307, 0.0331881009042263, 0.002155766822397709, 0.05358842760324478, 0.038676101714372635, 2.379364104854176e-06, -0.025826219469308853, -0.022635407745838165, -0.028284285217523575, -0.056460797786712646, -0.008733225055038929, -0.017837468534708023, -0.021842004731297493, 0.0003169141127727926, 0.012185795232653618, -0.011562018655240536, -0.04251043498516083, 0.04703348129987717, 0.055667757987976074, 0.02079187147319317, 0.04615058749914169, -0.009053826332092285, -0.06123632937669754, 0.05012950673699379, -0.00914244819432497, -0.04438622295856476, 0.016613848507404327, 0.004035645164549351, 0.03975900262594223, -0.04845893010497093, 0.0009074335684999824, 0.0033519347198307514, -0.016001814976334572, 0.0751664787530899, 0.026495477184653282, 0.04951409623026848, 0.05980730056762695, 0.015519792214035988, -0.011266669258475304, -0.017313137650489807, 0.036729846149683, -0.027816016227006912, 0.00377884553745389, 0.0066627636551856995, -0.004847317468374968, -0.016168607398867607, -0.0673554316163063, -0.019220804795622826, 0.0037546490784734488, 0.027484720572829247, 0.01796688139438629, -0.04948604106903076, 0.050059687346220016, 0.012902358546853065, -0.013494657352566719, -0.01486940123140812, -0.0015239337226375937, -0.032292887568473816, -0.016273226588964462, 0.03251589089632034, -0.035644009709358215, -0.008931180462241173, -0.01993110403418541, -0.000323152489727363, 0.03623524680733681, 0.001860302989371121, -0.01763150282204151, -0.023941652849316597, -0.05385788902640343, 0.0575762577354908, -0.05109500139951706, 0.07213044911623001, 0.015841033309698105, 0.010133306495845318, 0.007595926523208618, -0.06243881210684776, 0.0852929875254631, 0.010972379706799984, -0.005545309744775295, -0.0008004661649465561, 0.046407148241996765, -0.04917791113257408, -0.016952689737081528, -0.025491727516055107, 0.10471072047948837, 0.06568293273448944, -0.016813423484563828, -0.09655926376581192, -0.010545309633016586, -0.014052532613277435, -0.009549831971526146, 0.00033009349135681987, 0.040765173733234406, -0.05422409996390343, 0.023327834904193878, -0.014603078365325928, 0.0304721649736166, -0.036370813846588135, 0.021384626626968384, -0.009428123943507671, -0.05328189209103584, 0.0191902294754982, -0.04159512743353844, -0.0007757302955724299, 0.007667968515306711, -0.0020951165352016687, 0.032182011753320694, -0.01705780066549778, 0.016470395028591156, -0.06994127482175827, -0.041749708354473114, 0.04149971157312393, -0.021273598074913025, 0.0013127881102263927, -0.09333346039056778, -0.027674812823534012, -0.025592561811208725, 0.0005734455771744251, 0.0037319299299269915, 0.026599235832691193, -0.007756656501442194, 0.03875913843512535, 0.0538976676762104, -0.015735618770122528, -0.016375308856368065, 0.03915347903966904, -0.014598597772419453, 0.07896594703197479, 0.07695462554693222, 0.05005742982029915, 0.032669976353645325, -0.013896297663450241, -0.023898765444755554, -0.006320076994597912, 0.007345389574766159, 0.030695945024490356, -0.029503872618079185, -0.047083523124456406, -0.044921353459358215, -0.010723751969635487, 0.03261833265423775, 0.04245588183403015, -0.013088636100292206, -0.02838166058063507, -0.0318913608789444, 0.028472304344177246, 0.004557397216558456, 0.037340015172958374, 0.08729858696460724, -0.002164223464205861, -0.004104808438569307, 0.010347838513553143, -0.025706477463245392, -0.006887570023536682, 0.04283447563648224, 0.004021144472062588, -0.02225726656615734, -0.04435720667243004, -0.015532842837274075, -0.0437382236123085, -0.05866134166717529, 0.025133367627859116, -0.024745803326368332, 0.05790285766124725, -0.025723658502101898, 0.07577776163816452, 0.012916242703795433, -0.031344715505838394, 0.04465090110898018, -0.010626993142068386, 0.018563536927103996, -0.03217504918575287, -0.04348645359277725, -0.012229787185788155, -0.015297911129891872, 0.007566105108708143, -0.05120602250099182, -0.01768006570637226, -0.0256417915225029, -0.01080127339810133, -0.052930016070604324, 0.020031016319990158, -0.014935269020497799, 0.01689789444208145, -0.059873297810554504, 0.017990579828619957, -0.00512369628995657, 0.013133428059518337, 0.03357981517910957, -0.003715748433023691, 0.029613042250275612, -0.010305657051503658, 0.03088311105966568, -0.022556308656930923, 0.02151266485452652, 0.02607004903256893, -0.05883779004216194, 0.058124784380197525, 0.026163466274738312, 0.004732897039502859, 0.0054311854764819145, 0.023308761417865753, -0.037593066692352295, 0.037763118743896484, -0.04227563738822937, -0.02953641675412655, -0.04818567633628845, -0.04464423283934593, -0.005636093206703663, 0.05328741297125816, 0.03147203475236893, 0.030999336391687393, 0.05698768422007561, -0.0406285785138607, -0.03416484594345093, 0.0156618170440197, -0.06136881560087204, 0.0008079622057266533, -0.01806812174618244, -0.004243111237883568, -0.0024418905377388, 0.0133023327216506, -0.00033585188793949783, 0.0006984713836573064, -0.024680472910404205, -0.018036987632513046, -0.054203059524297714, -0.020748291164636612, 0.08423881232738495, -0.015772372484207153, -0.014571230858564377, -0.007209223695099354, -0.05515772104263306, 0.028312118723988533, -0.00817994773387909, -0.017924144864082336, -0.016277357935905457, 0.031586892902851105, -0.0812162235379219, -0.017951302230358124, -0.019609032198786736, -0.0008504987345077097, 0.001271889777854085, 0.004670676775276661, 0.0690360888838768, -0.02278258092701435, -0.04639056324958801, 0.04273783788084984, -0.006006743758916855, 0.003323033917695284, 0.0447504036128521, 0.020300619304180145, -0.01994103379547596, -0.016748646274209023, -0.05227255821228027, -0.03664897754788399, 0.024698037654161453, 0.04022214934229851, -0.03260008618235588, -0.017890565097332, 0.0229824036359787, 0.033295582979917526, 0.027735479176044464, -0.037672363221645355, -0.10504047572612762, 0.008754619397222996, -0.00860984344035387, 0.005364117678254843, 0.05262333154678345, 0.009135639294981956, 0.0413309708237648, 0.028551749885082245, 0.061103951185941696, -0.04966343194246292, 0.011691507883369923, -0.04479947313666344, -0.013288144953548908, 0.011781345121562481, -0.005285685881972313, -0.04085662588477135, 0.04613703116774559, 0.029310759156942368, 0.03559257835149765, 0.0036907121539115906, -0.008285741321742535, -0.001880188938230276, -0.02378479577600956, -0.07542990148067474, 0.00993918627500534, 0.013722916133701801, 0.008787025697529316, 0.020947961136698723, -0.020271940156817436, 0.020765788853168488, 0.03564145788550377, -0.007533926982432604, -0.03945536911487579, -0.015373088419437408, 0.02721385657787323, 0.01263037882745266, 0.040431227535009384, 0.02334819734096527, 0.02981259673833847, -0.02625187486410141, -0.022907106205821037, 0.008710628375411034, -0.031682781875133514, -0.040575042366981506, 0.032041434198617935, 0.00707459868863225, -0.011151586659252644, -0.03830212354660034, -0.003054210916161537, -0.05215959995985031, 0.021751055493950844, 0.028931578621268272, 0.059861939400434494, -0.03852710872888565, 0.0007057691691443324, 0.006560941226780415, 0.02001996710896492, 0.031503044068813324, 0.051085252314805984, -0.016186708584427834, -0.014390521682798862, -0.007366490550339222, 0.03382895886898041, 0.011483981274068356, 0.008273129351437092, -0.014352792873978615, 0.01977059431374073, -0.000767303688917309, 0.020590364933013916, -0.022897612303495407, 0.0419025681912899, -0.1273859441280365, -0.014282744377851486, -0.013829009607434273, -0.018674472346901894, 0.02434789389371872, -2.502392999303993e-05, 0.013165611773729324, -0.11093351989984512, 0.015069331973791122, 0.02242356725037098, 0.0005353951710276306, -0.058350685983896255, 0.011915013194084167, 0.010894854553043842, -0.020513582974672318, 0.013543807901442051, 0.002826273674145341, -0.04342300444841385, 0.0048490664921700954, -0.04379408806562424, -0.019981132820248604, -0.04520295932888985, -0.023397495970129967, 0.0132822310552001, -0.10079139471054077, 0.01060835923999548, 0.0130998520180583, 0.005242086946964264, -0.04156368598341942, -0.04196007922291756, -0.017341269180178642, -0.007978411391377449, 0.001030149171128869, 0.013558601029217243, 0.04161100462079048, -0.023798875510692596, 0.06333168596029282, -0.06324248760938644, -0.03915509954094887, 0.015428295359015465, -0.048232294619083405, 0.010458063334226608, 0.07762494683265686, 0.02722167782485485, -0.05057050287723541, -0.03707391023635864, 0.020203588530421257, 0.025072408840060234, 0.006193523760885, 0.012690315023064613, 0.03811638429760933, 0.04836286976933479, 0.01298388373106718, 0.04273794963955879, 0.044432297348976135, 0.0023310643155127764, 0.028682101517915726, 0.001135762082412839, 0.04828802868723869, 0.004582210909575224, 0.003123743925243616, -0.03982200101017952, -0.015468734316527843, 0.03422234207391739, -0.02987912856042385, 0.008824415504932404, -0.010334212332963943, -0.03233746439218521, 0.008133133873343468, 0.03686918318271637, -0.016699299216270447, -0.02456684410572052, -0.003877347568050027, 0.0004981003003194928, -0.057961605489254, -0.06722111254930496, -0.015458834357559681, -0.003297726856544614, 0.04116849601268768, 0.02321964129805565, -0.01738922670483589, 0.03414246067404747, 0.030786676332354546, -0.03752273693680763, -0.021088415756821632, 0.04060690477490425, 0.04053526744246483, -0.01912711188197136, 0.0038193310610949993, 0.030040588229894638, -0.026154721155762672, 0.010863018222153187, -0.08054669201374054, -0.05619358643889427, 0.004337485879659653, -0.002515802625566721, 0.031869757920503616, 0.00824468582868576, -0.0039366744458675385, -0.026977503672242165, -0.06183164566755295, 0.06782199442386627, 0.015812519937753677, -0.03395547717809677, -0.004389176145195961, 0.04788504168391228, -0.0005414570914581418, 0.003737759543582797, -0.005115315783768892, -0.00438099866732955, 0.0787767842411995, -0.013252528384327888, -0.016615422442555428, -0.07863793522119522, 0.033872026950120926, 0.011181317269802094, -0.021807866171002388, 0.027822347357869148, 0.042687270790338516, 0.007115637883543968, -0.03317788243293762, 0.06692301481962204, 0.016164185479283333, 0.024380693212151527, -0.03726915270090103, 0.014750520698726177, 0.030832570046186447, 0.044215328991413116, -0.01086003240197897, -0.07549218088388443, 0.1035534217953682, -0.06105901673436165, 0.04734249785542488, 0.017889944836497307, 0.029842128977179527, 0.05774661526083946, -0.0005218267906457186, 0.012943422421813011, -0.049527909606695175, -0.012155836448073387, -0.0015066835330799222, 0.02756558731198311, 0.0026733125559985638, 0.050713587552309036, 0.0160613264888525, 0.013594691641628742, -0.05991709977388382, 0.028860745951533318, 0.06002126634120941, -0.010385271161794662, -0.03729721158742905, -0.027772633358836174, 0.036956384778022766, 0.03297567740082741, -0.05748001113533974, -0.04302522912621498, 0.013401065953075886, -0.0316450372338295, -0.02357308194041252, -0.045373450964689255, 0.05702744796872139, 0.012433119118213654, 0.03112952783703804, -0.02357359230518341, 0.049096111208200455, 0.02637430652976036, 0.013901243917644024, 0.006077761296182871, -0.035177286714315414, 0.015441392548382282, -0.005747225601226091, 0.03911534696817398, -0.0061204456724226475, 0.06477664411067963, -0.0007707119220867753, -0.009061633609235287, 0.013701330870389938, -0.030240729451179504, 0.02790696918964386, 0.014249294996261597, 0.08056103438138962, -0.04606303200125694, 0.04608166590332985, 0.020669948309659958, -0.024565931409597397, 0.030952757224440575, -0.022129250690340996, -0.02183672785758972, 0.0031750935595482588, -0.0029817912727594376, -0.07668250054121017, -6.0191122112298e-33, -0.006495045032352209, -0.02583150379359722, 0.014784812927246094, -0.01329546608030796, -0.047039370983839035, 0.00791691243648529, -0.021170638501644135, 0.003558230586349964, 0.0017374602612107992, -0.011388037353754044, -0.017246773466467857, -0.022043609991669655, 0.003604573430493474, -0.0018740859813988209, 0.04014128819108009, -0.0009240905637852848, 0.049968570470809937, -0.04259384423494339, 0.0032050455920398235, 0.008526679128408432, 0.049759700894355774, 0.018251938745379448, 0.04573309049010277, -0.08961240202188492, -0.059251848608255386, 0.045072149485349655, -0.021067041903734207, -0.0288617555052042, -0.023336458951234818, 0.023804185912013054, -0.03668316826224327, 0.014604410156607628, 0.024630265310406685, -0.05702371150255203, -0.004519983660429716, 0.014898709021508694, -0.08710509538650513, -0.013447662815451622, -0.05524199828505516, 0.04510931298136711, -0.018844718113541603, -0.015535752288997173, 0.09039346873760223, -0.032328762114048004, -0.012238510884344578, 0.016368603333830833, 0.05385642871260643, -0.009287933818995953, -0.029196467250585556, -0.0815352275967598, -0.045272812247276306, 0.005671245511621237, 0.011764437891542912, 0.03637849912047386, 0.005520337726920843, -0.03813021630048752, -0.053889017552137375, 0.01129582617431879, -0.1426871120929718, 0.0007470172131434083, 0.027031386271119118, 0.05579085275530815, -0.024180272594094276, 0.011502969078719616, 0.05441538244485855, 0.0341581329703331, 0.05653868988156319, 0.004226126242429018, -0.023282423615455627, 0.017037123441696167, 0.03869563713669777, 0.0050845579244196415, 0.07281672954559326, 0.011897047981619835, 0.18117079138755798, -0.04592462629079819, -0.067153200507164, -0.009842576459050179, 0.010103774257004261, -0.020110441371798515, 0.009740017354488373, 0.006554106716066599, -0.027626072987914085, 0.004088501445949078, 0.03515864908695221, 0.03172220662236214, -0.02237533964216709, -0.06990841031074524, 0.013719476759433746, 0.0014148041373118758, 0.003054699394851923, 0.004305582959204912, 0.003108538454398513, -0.04966754838824272, 0.01856284774839878, -0.02241821400821209, 0.054141923785209656, 0.060349538922309875, 0.010949000716209412, -0.02780618891119957, -0.06696711480617523, -0.03582822531461716, -0.03957859426736832, -0.003092516679316759, 0.04185771942138672, 0.04952475428581238, 0.03734574466943741, 0.04239528253674507, -0.00524509372189641, -0.013204808346927166, 0.009665618650615215, -0.025468749925494194, 0.01919477805495262, 0.08920976519584656, -0.01051633246243, -0.041913602501153946, -0.0028455210849642754, 0.02705756202340126, -0.00823799055069685, -0.024793893098831177, -0.04016624018549919, 0.015941135585308075, -0.017172755673527718, 0.03442205488681793, -0.03661736845970154, -0.049517467617988586, -0.06395263969898224, 0.009379603900015354, -0.007194049656391144, -0.029431724920868874, 0.0024976013228297234, 0.023679625242948532, 3.039289140360779e-07, -0.07391183823347092, 0.00024193729041144252, -0.03133479878306389, -0.0488005056977272, 0.04477885738015175, 0.01688721403479576, 0.03208469599485397, 0.01897086389362812, 0.019282858818769455, -0.009254754520952702, 0.050544727593660355, -0.009189625270664692, -0.010174262337386608, 0.020648153498768806, -0.06902073323726654, -0.03134210780262947, 0.02737184800207615, 0.04286449775099754, -0.025137975811958313, 0.017963310703635216, -0.027346225455403328, 0.08714723587036133, 0.06068555638194084, -0.017071938142180443, 0.06496754288673401, 0.011456447653472424, 0.00017971714260056615, 0.05224597826600075, 0.06737188249826431, 0.007119365036487579, 0.02586956135928631, 0.03781130909919739, -0.031580131500959396, -0.0010735405376181006, -0.01531264465302229, 0.05614190548658371, -0.027122939005494118, 0.04135427251458168, -0.0370609275996685, -0.030912380665540695, 0.03431134670972824, -0.027022598311305046, 0.020090339705348015, 0.00279005104675889, 0.03922653570771217, -0.028209060430526733, -0.03343954309821129, 0.02439897693693638, 0.03247803449630737, -0.007080004550516605, 0.007856041193008423, -0.007725985255092382, -0.002702801488339901, -0.013825700618326664, -0.012367705814540386, -0.04111973196268082, 0.0009566684602759778, -0.057115983217954636, 0.05009181424975395, -0.00562812015414238, -0.02719540148973465, -0.05362822860479355, -0.0077040111646056175, 0.001915528206154704, 0.02474156580865383, 0.01579897105693817, -0.019551876932382584, 2.9992807237852784e-34, -0.016968628391623497, -0.02623235434293747, 0.01218469813466072, 0.04672521725296974, -0.021282484754920006, -0.005375152453780174, 0.00810998398810625, 0.01102564949542284, 0.03238343447446823, -0.021140748634934425, -0.04442602023482323]
686
686
['Esteban Real', 'Alok Aggarwal', 'Yanping Huang', 'Quoc V Le']
1802.01548v3
The effort devoted to hand-crafting image classifiers has motivated the use of architecture search to discover them automatically. Reinforcement learning and evolution have both shown promise for this purpose. This study employs a regularized version of a popular asynchronous evolutionary algorithm. We rigorously compare it to the non-regularized form and to a highly-successful reinforcement learning baseline. Using the same hardware, compute effort and neural network training code, we conduct repeated experiments side-by-side, exploring different datasets, search spaces and scales. We show regularized evolution consistently produces models with similar or higher accuracy, across a variety of contexts without need for re-tuning parameters. In addition, evolution exhibits considerably better performance than reinforcement learning at early search stages, suggesting it may be the better choice when fewer compute resources are available. This constitutes the first controlled comparison of the two search algorithms in this context. Finally, we present new architectures discovered with evolution that we nickname AmoebaNets. These models achieve state-of-the-art results for CIFAR-10 (mean test error = 2.13%), mobile-size ImageNet (top-1 accuracy = 75.1% with 5.1 M parameters) and ImageNet (top-1 accuracy = 83.1%). This is the first time evolutionary algorithms produce state-of-the-art image classifiers.
Regularized Evolution for Image Classifier Architecture Search
2,018
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1802.01548v3
Title Regularized Evolution Image Classifier Architecture Search Summary effort devoted handcrafting image classifier motivated use architecture search discover automatically Reinforcement learning evolution shown promise purpose study employ regularized version popular asynchronous evolutionary algorithm rigorously compare nonregularized form highlysuccessful reinforcement learning baseline Using hardware compute effort neural network training code conduct repeated experiment sidebyside exploring different datasets search space scale show regularized evolution consistently produce model similar higher accuracy across variety context without need retuning parameter addition evolution exhibit considerably better performance reinforcement learning early search stage suggesting may better choice fewer compute resource available constitutes first controlled comparison two search algorithm context Finally present new architecture discovered evolution nickname AmoebaNets model achieve stateoftheart result CIFAR10 mean test error 213 mobilesize ImageNet top1 accuracy 751 51 parameter ImageNet top1 accuracy 831 first time evolutionary algorithm produce stateoftheart image classifier Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.022280516102910042, 0.049255795776844025, -0.04031810164451599, 0.014892525039613247, -0.008276914246380329, -0.026720911264419556, 0.013798962347209454, 0.031990114599466324, -0.031773824244737625, 0.028270630165934563, -0.0018290071748197079, 0.04984038323163986, -0.015239505097270012, 0.04911781847476959, -0.008846188895404339, -0.07620415836572647, -0.01969800516963005, 0.02555813267827034, 0.0005164230824448168, -0.0397561676800251, 0.04722403734922409, -0.04682931303977966, 0.04722122848033905, 0.04059943929314613, -0.012749580666422844, 0.06976362317800522, -0.07670973241329193, 0.03350481390953064, 0.055297285318374634, -0.042766645550727844, 0.030994314700365067, 0.00012514596164692193, 0.02170371823012829, 0.07456713914871216, 2.4304854377987795e-06, -0.09171910583972931, -0.009791802614927292, -0.032546017318964005, 0.03363534063100815, -0.03818301483988762, 0.050486039370298386, -0.007792939431965351, -0.03139731287956238, -0.05160189047455788, -0.008702471852302551, -0.03481430187821388, 0.07603392750024796, 0.0666733905673027, 0.04046757519245148, 0.06658097356557846, -0.0086726238951087, -0.039182085543870926, 0.022944197058677673, -0.020496658980846405, 0.02528243698179722, -0.047564323991537094, 0.03525572270154953, -0.012103952467441559, 0.013619034551084042, -0.03716607764363289, -0.056194696575403214, 0.0003399525012355298, 0.01454926934093237, 0.03384287282824516, -0.01023155078291893, 0.01008976623415947, -0.004350634291768074, -0.04164202883839607, -0.05321427062153816, 0.013143169693648815, -0.08114422857761383, 0.02554360404610634, 0.01645650528371334, 0.0035815774463117123, 0.009905694983899593, -0.012255323119461536, 0.017078334465622902, 0.0010618732776492834, -0.04727131500840187, 0.005927169229835272, -0.023660976439714432, 0.014940044842660427, -0.022861074656248093, 0.028829272836446762, 0.0003945704665966332, -0.0040651834569871426, -0.001877453876659274, -0.006887985859066248, -0.007970198057591915, 0.001817281823605299, 0.0015953084221109748, -0.022259918972849846, 0.06055165454745293, 0.02763441763818264, 0.004213412292301655, -0.023590311408042908, -0.043048277497291565, -0.027347996830940247, 0.03746262192726135, -0.03716691955924034, 0.02632669173181057, -0.02704344131052494, -0.009879563935101032, 0.0067551014944911, -0.03794227913022041, 0.027858758345246315, -0.06840819120407104, 0.05619281902909279, -0.03623027727007866, 0.03777256980538368, -0.04959013685584068, 0.030303888022899628, -0.022999096661806107, 0.043003592640161514, 0.04963643103837967, -0.0419977642595768, -0.06533574312925339, 0.00604600552469492, 0.0071473512798547745, -0.00047814741265028715, -0.0016642293194308877, 0.06531691551208496, -0.014066386967897415, 0.026645801961421967, -0.03015216626226902, -0.037182338535785675, -0.015755660831928253, 0.005341249983757734, 0.01609240286052227, 0.029002847149968147, 0.05488254129886627, -0.015810372307896614, 0.026341227814555168, 0.030214449390769005, 0.04033990204334259, 0.04726634547114372, 0.006244412623345852, 0.0013538157800212502, -0.049627985805273056, 0.03145259991288185, -0.008420877158641815, -0.0021015829406678677, -0.03400086238980293, -0.012911898083984852, 0.03145745396614075, -0.07059399038553238, -0.040957167744636536, 0.015080387704074383, 0.010867542587220669, -0.047748323529958725, -0.02469555102288723, 0.06807016581296921, -0.09080064296722412, -0.0019303492736071348, 0.08386793732643127, 0.012024667114019394, -0.005432456731796265, 0.04653920978307724, 0.025179073214530945, 0.015673432499170303, 0.02852502651512623, -0.01765781082212925, -0.02959597483277321, 0.01103704422712326, -0.045237090438604355, -0.015635043382644653, 0.011261050589382648, -0.04828843101859093, -0.027621064335107803, 0.05274234339594841, 0.026843063533306122, -0.007395646069198847, -0.027077414095401764, -0.015877991914749146, -0.0035724458284676075, 0.016220638528466225, 0.05254587531089783, 0.03370602801442146, 0.010549351572990417, 0.022967306897044182, -0.015440900810062885, -0.00086074328282848, 0.028790298849344254, 0.033202409744262695, -0.048236142843961716, -0.052526429295539856, -0.04036341980099678, -0.015555343590676785, -0.04095667600631714, -0.05568370595574379, 0.03041326254606247, -0.04334842041134834, -0.012796136550605297, -0.011747278273105621, 0.04845087230205536, 0.014924700371921062, -0.007547921966761351, -0.05979418754577637, 0.0130848353728652, 0.023057665675878525, -0.06295011192560196, -0.08167558163404465, 0.07455017417669296, 0.00412884633988142, -0.009061870165169239, -0.02720501832664013, -0.021939318627119064, 0.02243625372648239, -0.04182557389140129, 0.006216757465153933, 0.02238711528480053, 0.008208487182855606, 0.008691107854247093, -0.03182058408856392, -0.0483488105237484, 0.014077489264309406, -0.015835531055927277, 0.034091975539922714, -0.01181509904563427, 0.03309306502342224, 0.0006707785069011152, 0.08639425039291382, -0.01895427331328392, 0.020641807466745377, -0.015873773023486137, -0.013821988366544247, 0.058110613375902176, 0.03641277551651001, 0.0018034280510619283, -0.052473634481430054, -0.0005981291178613901, -0.047607194632291794, 0.01854940876364708, -0.0029406643006950617, -0.019484009593725204, -0.00813630037009716, -0.033956192433834076, 0.013577130623161793, 0.02790108695626259, -0.023884348571300507, 0.017925377935171127, -0.005765500012785196, -0.03913082554936409, -0.023150427266955376, -0.00976032204926014, -0.0187852643430233, 0.048420242965221405, -0.012282832525670528, 0.022626057267189026, -0.01892101764678955, 0.055103469640016556, -0.022956741973757744, 0.04512810334563255, 0.010248136706650257, -0.01404159888625145, -0.014333408325910568, -0.03612731397151947, 0.05450531840324402, -0.023207563906908035, -0.025965150445699692, -0.010383308865129948, -0.03807564079761505, 0.0036980528384447098, 0.005244725849479437, 0.10409711301326752, 0.009373802691698074, 0.0209552813321352, 0.014416552148759365, 0.012175474315881729, 0.00747600058093667, -0.03821701183915138, 0.025421136990189552, 0.009376180358231068, 0.019265038892626762, -0.011128623969852924, -0.0007141618407331407, 0.11858441680669785, -0.02196519449353218, -0.07374236732721329, 0.019870370626449585, 0.011728054843842983, -0.01436070166528225, -0.03776690736413002, -0.024176858365535736, 0.018682073801755905, 0.02798367850482464, 0.05220732465386391, 0.036292050033807755, -0.0800108015537262, -0.028484899550676346, -0.03196784853935242, 0.04075922071933746, 0.03134048730134964, -0.04345875233411789, -0.03056594356894493, -0.03026421181857586, -0.03036580979824066, 0.05606597661972046, 0.048122305423021317, -0.01992257870733738, -0.02257646806538105, 0.09908410161733627, -0.020672475919127464, 0.04015008360147476, 0.0071460651233792305, -0.03301539272069931, -0.005376928951591253, 0.0020405349787324667, -0.020156603306531906, 0.03074689209461212, -0.024288658052682877, 0.006878091488033533, -0.023732265457510948, 0.017907511442899704, 0.03172477334737778, -0.030239906162023544, -0.03599265590310097, 0.02373260073363781, -0.01342814415693283, 0.003597093978896737, -0.05134651064872742, -0.027452576905488968, 0.026396818459033966, 0.09784527868032455, 0.02193647436797619, -0.009201237931847572, -0.039259105920791626, 0.008959378115832806, 0.010428652167320251, 0.008504580706357956, 0.04959586635231972, -0.05344293639063835, 0.015584597364068031, -0.008401067927479744, -0.019749747589230537, -0.0008217333815991879, -0.018029743805527687, -0.00032963763806037605, -0.011050252243876457, -0.016552118584513664, -0.005437358748167753, -0.04494108632206917, -0.06947872042655945, 0.03277658671140671, -0.011311403475701809, -0.03297354280948639, -0.037943288683891296, -0.005637708585709333, 0.006554982624948025, 0.016530847176909447, -0.020379194989800453, 0.024637766182422638, -0.02276785485446453, -0.020416853949427605, 0.005871061235666275, 0.062247712165117264, 0.056604672223329544, -0.021841416135430336, -0.05450698733329773, 0.019046522676944733, 0.08750033378601074, 0.041144389659166336, -0.00996254663914442, -0.035003628581762314, -0.09707972407341003, 0.031298283487558365, 0.00024156743893399835, -0.01845378801226616, -0.02073470875620842, 0.001535313786007464, -0.0028731157071888447, -0.0338892862200737, 0.022736897692084312, 0.0020572899375110865, -0.0029666342306882143, -0.06293822824954987, -0.008565961383283138, -0.042734451591968536, 0.02045479416847229, 0.028837725520133972, 0.035619545727968216, 0.0026797361206263304, 0.00512019032612443, -0.019658910110592842, -0.020521067082881927, -0.0182056725025177, -0.02466747537255287, 0.029836924746632576, -0.03503816947340965, 0.025280509144067764, -0.017286691814661026, -0.05404471233487129, 0.01603875495493412, 0.0011036018840968609, 0.01555621437728405, 0.0037308281753212214, -0.021711423993110657, 0.05816261097788811, 0.05430588871240616, -0.06340109556913376, 0.00043527569505386055, -0.0031976276077330112, 0.040937136858701706, 0.015527511015534401, -0.057530440390110016, -0.07751604169607162, 0.05234811455011368, 0.021207498386502266, -0.02540573850274086, -0.0701548382639885, -0.005442172288894653, 0.040859997272491455, 0.04948330670595169, -0.03437555208802223, 0.05534813553094864, 0.04478878900408745, -0.008751817978918552, -0.0060289883986115456, 0.0369982086122036, 0.0613868422806263, 0.02872573584318161, 0.05613547936081886, 0.017965255305171013, 0.02206604555249214, -0.012264633551239967, -0.05538487434387207, -0.022911423817276955, 0.011099726893007755, -0.06152127683162689, -0.023146983236074448, -0.09073169529438019, -0.061587315052747726, -0.0021622278727591038, -0.020815372467041016, -0.08775154501199722, -0.006547221913933754, 0.0072966814041137695, -0.007744077127426863, -0.052982211112976074, -0.026195811107754707, 0.07641267776489258, -0.032927244901657104, 0.057567209005355835, 0.005252625793218613, -0.03884265571832657, -0.009375624358654022, -0.0019615835044533014, -0.05539475008845329, -0.04375657066702843, 0.057405684143304825, -0.009966505691409111, -0.0159347802400589, -0.01764063909649849, 0.026913031935691833, -0.03511717543005943, -0.01128186285495758, -0.037301067262887955, -0.030024370178580284, -0.0008404285763390362, -0.016576441004872322, 0.08859983086585999, 0.0012146865483373404, -0.02356264740228653, -0.029424702748656273, -0.05919094756245613, 0.029288291931152344, -0.01851242035627365, 0.057703129947185516, -0.034225791692733765, 0.02233920805156231, 0.006494201719760895, -0.022095076739788055, 0.004973527975380421, -0.007738769054412842, 0.05424076318740845, 0.019962899386882782, -0.029801076278090477, 0.017628556117415428, 0.008698206394910812, -0.006862447131425142, -0.004838142078369856, 0.03774970769882202, -0.04481532424688339, -0.0166343804448843, 0.023161474615335464, 0.01961582526564598, 0.04995448514819145, -0.003371288999915123, -0.01179212424904108, -0.0069266995415091515, 0.04125606268644333, 0.03638474643230438, 0.014494020491838455, -0.05552893877029419, 0.045493319630622864, -0.053542327135801315, -0.044187698513269424, 0.031150689348578453, 0.015991225838661194, 0.02566092275083065, -0.01859542354941368, 0.008539657108485699, 0.040700722485780716, -0.004118956159800291, 0.07503845542669296, 0.029076162725687027, -0.041226353496313095, 0.04691174998879433, 0.0015280988300219178, 0.023563256487250328, -0.016204312443733215, 0.039778538048267365, 0.019751325249671936, 0.00543530797585845, -0.02934609353542328, 0.07721415907144547, 0.05789363384246826, -0.025169314816594124, -0.03034166991710663, 0.034233443439006805, -0.02088901214301586, -0.013076371513307095, 0.009916430339217186, -0.06170407682657242, -0.04128626734018326, 0.06417415291070938, -0.00039873391506262124, 0.010246068239212036, 0.047071557492017746, 0.010808841325342655, 0.007265763822942972, -0.008909206837415695, -0.03969231992959976, 0.0071221827529370785, -0.04881882295012474, 0.0722297802567482, 0.04591212794184685, 0.004053956363350153, -0.002980350749567151, 0.00889643095433712, 0.03154216334223747, -0.00311476388014853, 0.027611829340457916, 0.02816133014857769, 0.05481032282114029, 0.03711537644267082, 0.016311412677168846, -0.02913716994225979, -0.041684042662382126, -0.027011554688215256, 0.003549559973180294, -0.062306247651576996, -0.020605383440852165, 0.01470273733139038, 0.005684223026037216, -6.420256270603629e-33, 0.03423675149679184, -0.0049504912458360195, -0.019080454483628273, -0.04978030174970627, -0.022113902494311333, 0.004817066714167595, 0.007409573532640934, -0.02300562895834446, 0.021268527954816818, -0.03886011242866516, -0.0016909081023186445, -0.04322612285614014, -0.009542208164930344, 0.008366882801055908, 0.040129076689481735, -0.010193338617682457, -0.02443673089146614, -0.006766099017113447, 0.04469795152544975, -0.014996908605098724, -0.03264699503779411, 0.035299401730298996, 0.04410183057188988, -0.07913056761026382, -0.0991537868976593, 0.07883623987436295, 0.003107004566118121, -0.05545444041490555, -0.028176235035061836, 0.01830495521426201, 0.03513527289032936, 0.030639151111245155, -0.005319383926689625, -0.013688633218407631, 0.01729443483054638, -0.05248315632343292, -0.030409403145313263, -0.020708294585347176, -0.0665699914097786, 0.0188168752938509, -0.07906458526849747, 0.003411010606214404, 0.05850115418434143, 0.006308973301202059, -0.06711405515670776, 0.037772756069898605, 0.06834881007671356, -0.03539502993226051, 0.005730639677494764, -0.028834044933319092, -0.028816310688853264, 0.007971670478582382, 0.0019298829138278961, 0.011154771782457829, -0.024054305627942085, -0.011098547838628292, -0.026178520172834396, -4.2207215301459655e-05, 0.012956780381500721, 0.023273728787899017, 0.03540119156241417, -0.012659711763262749, -0.02119113691151142, 0.06324686110019684, 0.058420050889253616, -0.04048266261816025, 0.04999338462948799, -0.037316013127565384, 0.03344615548849106, -0.008849531412124634, 0.03363621607422829, 0.07185162603855133, 0.020613163709640503, 0.01730985939502716, 0.04839831590652466, -0.08712457865476608, -0.004302108194679022, 0.0429624542593956, 0.03088490292429924, 0.01558153610676527, -0.020595546811819077, 0.020548351109027863, -0.016635693609714508, 0.024002747610211372, 0.04432633891701698, -0.04563779756426811, -0.014463736675679684, -0.0433306060731411, 0.011569461785256863, 0.038936734199523926, -0.00725408922880888, 0.01124892570078373, -0.005186691880226135, -0.05098884552717209, 0.043104734271764755, -0.05653306841850281, -0.021911218762397766, 0.028698934242129326, 0.06188990920782089, -0.026780584827065468, -0.006888414267450571, -0.04496484249830246, -0.001729851239360869, -0.011287320405244827, -0.007306820712983608, 0.009596595540642738, 0.005840379744768143, 0.010070614516735077, -0.0089576356112957, 0.01947607845067978, 0.015812793746590614, -0.01174705196171999, 0.029234737157821655, -0.002796418033540249, -0.012226192280650139, -0.024518415331840515, -0.00022593823086936027, 0.053888414055109024, 0.042233292013406754, -0.04668283835053444, -0.06828343868255615, -0.017727218568325043, 0.03513657674193382, 0.00616619223728776, -0.05461970344185829, 0.036478012800216675, -0.025823254138231277, -0.03246743604540825, -0.05703403055667877, -0.08957555145025253, -0.017498336732387543, 0.01386362873017788, 3.07337444382938e-07, -0.05596986040472984, 0.03306203335523605, -0.006086781620979309, -0.06671007722616196, -0.004084896761924028, -0.013643134385347366, -0.023600272834300995, -0.00901021808385849, -0.03915512189269066, 0.01528441533446312, 0.06935569643974304, -0.007013489492237568, 0.007900291122496128, -0.02585648186504841, -0.01186144258826971, 0.012090541422367096, -0.006924064829945564, 0.07260143011808395, -0.04392647370696068, 0.0377960279583931, 0.01856372505426407, 0.08521399646997452, 0.03859228268265724, -0.021324634552001953, 0.08340401202440262, 0.0013244786532595754, -0.00839303806424141, -0.0017477204091846943, 0.06695906817913055, -0.02754015289247036, -0.026654601097106934, 0.05821126326918602, -0.022928349673748016, -0.03537754714488983, -0.0030732816085219383, 0.026398364454507828, -0.012511933222413063, 0.032261427491903305, -0.047327086329460144, 0.0015323749976232648, 0.06347383558750153, 0.05771930515766144, 0.039630040526390076, -0.04174220561981201, 0.06059306487441063, 0.008850833401083946, 0.00020246958592906594, -0.06505422294139862, 0.008490461856126785, 0.013752653263509274, 0.02131681889295578, -0.016248667612671852, -0.016222063452005386, 0.005287547130137682, 0.01630602777004242, -0.03125075250864029, -0.029176734387874603, -0.04675488919019699, 0.06501128524541855, 0.02481812611222267, -0.006731349043548107, 0.013470272533595562, -0.029670188203454018, 0.04446027800440788, 0.06241370737552643, 0.037528131157159805, -0.02369781583547592, 2.4698849042779607e-34, -0.03498118743300438, -0.017277134582400322, 0.025218317285180092, -0.03825898468494415, -0.023289574310183525, 0.020454872399568558, 0.0289576668292284, 0.010076355189085007, 0.023219101130962372, 0.008478728123009205, -0.039391182363033295]
687
687
['Alexander Wong', 'Mohammad Javad Shafiee', 'Francis Li', 'Brendan Chwyl']
1802.06488v1
Object detection is a major challenge in computer vision, involving both object classification and object localization within a scene. While deep neural networks have been shown in recent years to yield very powerful techniques for tackling the challenge of object detection, one of the biggest challenges with enabling such object detection networks for widespread deployment on embedded devices is high computational and memory requirements. Recently, there has been an increasing focus in exploring small deep neural network architectures for object detection that are more suitable for embedded devices, such as Tiny YOLO and SqueezeDet. Inspired by the efficiency of the Fire microarchitecture introduced in SqueezeNet and the object detection performance of the single-shot detection macroarchitecture introduced in SSD, this paper introduces Tiny SSD, a single-shot detection deep convolutional neural network for real-time embedded object detection that is composed of a highly optimized, non-uniform Fire sub-network stack and a non-uniform sub-network stack of highly optimized SSD-based auxiliary convolutional feature layers designed specifically to minimize model size while maintaining object detection performance. The resulting Tiny SSD possess a model size of 2.3MB (~26X smaller than Tiny YOLO) while still achieving an mAP of 61.3% on VOC 2007 (~4.2% higher than Tiny YOLO). These experimental results show that very small deep neural network architectures can be designed for real-time object detection that are well-suited for embedded scenarios.
Tiny SSD: A Tiny Single-shot Detection Deep Convolutional Neural Network for Real-time Embedded Object Detection
2,018
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1802.06488v1
Title Tiny SSD Tiny Singleshot Detection Deep Convolutional Neural Network Realtime Embedded Object Detection Summary Object detection major challenge computer vision involving object classification object localization within scene deep neural network shown recent year yield powerful technique tackling challenge object detection one biggest challenge enabling object detection network widespread deployment embedded device high computational memory requirement Recently increasing focus exploring small deep neural network architecture object detection suitable embedded device Tiny YOLO SqueezeDet Inspired efficiency Fire microarchitecture introduced SqueezeNet object detection performance singleshot detection macroarchitecture introduced SSD paper introduces Tiny SSD singleshot detection deep convolutional neural network realtime embedded object detection composed highly optimized nonuniform Fire subnetwork stack nonuniform subnetwork stack highly optimized SSDbased auxiliary convolutional feature layer designed specifically minimize model size maintaining object detection performance resulting Tiny SSD posse model size 23MB 26X smaller Tiny YOLO still achieving mAP 613 VOC 2007 42 higher Tiny YOLO experimental result show small deep neural network architecture designed realtime object detection wellsuited embedded scenario Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.00894768163561821, -0.015540339052677155, -0.010371421463787556, 0.09251029044389725, -0.0014948333846405149, -0.029780378565192223, 0.06379145383834839, -0.010930354706943035, -0.016195353120565414, -0.026631584390997887, 0.03221234679222107, 0.03448629751801491, -0.0014456340577453375, 0.029058344662189484, 0.0144201023504138, 0.0354696623980999, 0.04513229802250862, 0.04847210273146629, -0.0370873287320137, 0.023214323446154594, 0.06582820415496826, -0.04070296511054039, 0.020555313676595688, 0.05346081405878067, -0.05613924190402031, 0.02539745345711708, -0.04111499711871147, 0.012346738018095493, 0.01653248444199562, -0.008878550492227077, -0.008291143923997879, 0.008390531875193119, 0.030185936018824577, 0.05334673449397087, 1.8464747881807853e-06, 0.020180732011795044, 0.0142489243298769, -0.025427918881177902, -0.03249408304691315, -0.04276692867279053, -0.003104046219959855, -0.016192151233553886, -0.04268484190106392, 0.01934768259525299, -0.014550995081663132, -0.04776924476027489, 0.05769531428813934, 0.03479788824915886, -0.02029639482498169, -0.0005675645661540329, -0.01193150319159031, -0.00975324772298336, -0.02309788577258587, -0.0016788317589089274, -0.016126910224556923, -0.008848676458001137, -0.04729856550693512, -0.021964451298117638, -0.02045673131942749, 0.006853572558611631, -0.0099043482914567, 0.018379027023911476, 0.04961546137928963, 0.036603666841983795, 0.03654445335268974, 0.030166130512952805, -0.08781522512435913, 0.008649716153740883, 0.0039991894736886024, 0.00018531734531279653, -0.07664205878973007, -0.0010053470032289624, 0.013785628601908684, -0.0008707825909368694, -0.0063217016868293285, -0.059995707124471664, -0.007586662657558918, -0.003482671221718192, 0.0015224682865664363, -0.006236603483557701, -0.0752592608332634, -0.016687514260411263, 0.010557543486356735, 0.041630059480667114, -0.0030233552679419518, -0.04217333719134331, -0.02232099510729313, 0.07253289222717285, -0.040759455412626266, 0.0039381543174386024, -0.033294595777988434, -0.05205446854233742, 0.04311509430408478, 0.04456121474504471, -0.015498458407819271, -0.03073355183005333, -0.062383461743593216, -0.03470196574926376, -0.010428979061543941, -0.05959691107273102, -0.0017868380527943373, -0.02728714980185032, -0.03479081019759178, 0.03828780725598335, -0.022200128063559532, 0.02394922263920307, -0.03038054332137108, 0.008673948235809803, -0.02825920097529888, 0.055188652127981186, -0.005040980875492096, 0.0011207074858248234, -0.04614230617880821, 0.02142498269677162, 0.018377503380179405, -0.04699387773871422, -0.01845156028866768, -0.021347926929593086, 0.008972609415650368, -0.02776901237666607, -0.05229991674423218, 0.07374830543994904, -0.012891823425889015, -0.007813602685928345, 0.06856558471918106, 0.005347473081201315, -0.00039072922663763165, 0.016052335500717163, 0.030140597373247147, -0.0322805792093277, -0.010189233347773552, 0.028705965727567673, 0.05765495449304581, 0.021400248631834984, -0.009127093479037285, -0.017058691009879112, 0.010404800996184349, -0.07730992138385773, -0.05198400467634201, 0.053420066833496094, 0.005742732901126146, 0.03947484865784645, 0.009276430122554302, -0.0825769454240799, 0.00984808336943388, -0.04512409493327141, 0.018885506317019463, 0.005712556187063456, 0.03407327085733414, 0.023985639214515686, -0.009190747514367104, 0.04423130676150322, -0.008680556900799274, -0.03923657909035683, 0.030214734375476837, -0.004526733886450529, 0.05991820991039276, 0.03730486333370209, 0.06589411199092865, 0.03882962837815285, 0.01881617307662964, 0.00876797828823328, 0.014135650359094143, 0.0025423429906368256, -0.03193088620901108, -0.012360957451164722, -0.022721994668245316, -0.01635919138789177, -0.09691783785820007, 0.03667931631207466, -0.002735448768362403, -0.026619650423526764, 0.04242642968893051, -0.00411278335377574, -0.0015487965429201722, 0.05451859161257744, -0.007363094016909599, -0.00905897282063961, -0.028549300506711006, 0.01160900853574276, -0.012792143039405346, -0.041355278342962265, -0.004142278339713812, 0.07659084349870682, -0.014940337277948856, -0.062389541417360306, -0.0671192929148674, -0.023373236879706383, -0.045582108199596405, -0.031324613839387894, -0.027251984924077988, -0.03241650387644768, -0.04504070803523064, 0.006338322069495916, 0.03545668348670006, -0.03305099904537201, 0.017331434413790703, 0.01194971613585949, -0.036994583904743195, 0.03602103143930435, -0.05793191120028496, -0.09535058587789536, 0.01808507926762104, -0.01313253864645958, -0.030397672206163406, -0.018779972568154335, -0.02927384339272976, 0.02563769742846489, 0.0003302035038359463, -0.005173369310796261, -0.003940241411328316, -0.002142332959920168, 0.03938966616988182, 0.012764462269842625, -0.0032532087061554193, 0.007230670657008886, -0.0019570710137486458, 0.011368793435394764, -0.007686914876103401, 0.034420110285282135, 0.013845652341842651, 0.03685324639081955, 0.04151620343327522, 0.02562803030014038, 0.04393836483359337, 0.007316046394407749, 0.024216681718826294, 0.058044757694005966, -0.02835129387676716, -0.007850523106753826, -0.0001958368520718068, -0.028962573036551476, 0.0737573504447937, -0.037039466202259064, 0.030026990920305252, -0.01763358898460865, -0.019490595906972885, -0.021756796166300774, 0.018303515389561653, -0.019776904955506325, 0.05490827560424805, 0.06573731452226639, -0.033905137330293655, -0.024504534900188446, 0.009678217582404613, -0.03376493602991104, -0.0039180126041173935, 0.007287987042218447, 0.005433191079646349, -0.019200995564460754, 0.014377244748175144, -0.01551867462694645, -0.005990809295326471, 0.002136909170076251, -0.010631079785525799, -0.0044672321528196335, 0.012987392954528332, 0.07963475584983826, -0.002836477244272828, -0.002564484952017665, -0.055141232907772064, -0.07210037857294083, 0.009607656858861446, 0.008069583214819431, 0.03029363416135311, 0.00491101061925292, 0.03768365830183029, -0.006681618746370077, 0.04890485852956772, -0.0413687564432621, -0.005354262422770262, -0.01965470053255558, 0.029881738126277924, 0.05336824059486389, -0.03555993363261223, -0.031939588487148285, 0.06884414702653885, 0.0038363917265087366, -0.02705884911119938, -0.0035617314279079437, 0.0211284589022398, 0.026275523006916046, -0.025479823350906372, -0.009851356968283653, 0.02898881956934929, 0.005221519619226456, -0.0031726984307169914, -0.023660648614168167, -0.012464048340916634, 0.005537352059036493, 0.004707043990492821, 0.04769902303814888, 0.016541223973035812, -0.04797323793172836, 0.028174854815006256, -0.021106746047735214, -0.003442986635491252, 0.1303664743900299, 0.002612518845126033, 0.007693081628531218, 0.01574086584150791, 0.047030214220285416, 0.008492049761116505, -0.007098531350493431, 0.03526662662625313, 0.01015364471822977, -0.014260928146541119, 0.06131567433476448, -0.06928850710391998, 0.0037723705172538757, -0.047843366861343384, 0.012861447408795357, -0.0023966787848621607, 0.006122165825217962, -0.01683986745774746, -0.0467991977930069, -0.05358090251684189, 0.02083601988852024, -0.020780105143785477, 0.010514205321669579, -0.02061423286795616, -0.046941809356212616, -0.05018548667430878, 0.028978226706385612, -0.010804546996951103, 0.045517563819885254, -0.04130525514483452, -0.02219410426914692, 0.05320346727967262, 0.027612626552581787, 0.027309423312544823, -0.03006811998784542, 0.006998831406235695, -0.023967081680893898, 0.006125552114099264, -0.05520880967378616, -0.00818647537380457, 0.018311968073248863, 0.0013344045728445053, -0.011545554734766483, -0.07857418060302734, -0.03798564895987511, -0.023092444986104965, -0.025494229048490524, -0.04301035776734352, -0.0013711185893043876, -0.03816632926464081, -0.027362195774912834, 0.018480774015188217, 0.03682209923863411, 0.0018050268990918994, 0.0721096619963646, 0.044290460646152496, -0.011248227208852768, -0.008088222704827785, 0.03102635033428669, 0.04958706349134445, -0.0011079148389399052, 0.03700985386967659, 0.05673868954181671, 0.03302300348877907, 0.08763940632343292, -0.002259446308016777, 0.017685694620013237, -0.14417734742164612, 0.025937821716070175, 0.01596413552761078, 0.03741553798317909, -0.023378880694508553, -0.010898268781602383, 0.06322262436151505, -0.06368795037269592, -0.03387806937098503, 0.002465003402903676, -0.003019669558852911, -0.029117941856384277, 0.025760499760508537, 0.024522148072719574, -0.03167764097452164, 0.022882597520947456, 0.005839691963046789, -0.030949298292398453, -0.037116508930921555, 0.033534109592437744, -0.03676610067486763, -0.045139066874980927, -0.001268233172595501, -0.012245330959558487, -0.031410276889801025, 0.014614900574088097, -0.003083361079916358, -0.033741485327482224, -0.04253104329109192, 0.05134490132331848, -0.006023359019309282, 0.0021133592817932367, -0.00785042904317379, 0.0009419785346835852, 0.025326306000351906, -0.0256146602332592, -0.015245623886585236, -0.035375554114580154, 0.06733223795890808, 0.011964199133217335, -0.052979398518800735, -0.033543460071086884, 0.00532537093386054, 0.016578111797571182, 0.0112923514097929, 0.0016396900173276663, -0.00250983820296824, -0.007097206078469753, 0.012050418183207512, -0.0035916112828999758, 0.007486829534173012, 0.009401517920196056, -0.03140222653746605, 0.029715679585933685, 0.007392974104732275, -0.017444418743252754, 0.0013055185554549098, -0.01896640658378601, 0.0055982088670134544, 0.03535355627536774, 0.028755201026797295, -0.07401590794324875, -0.0364721417427063, -0.014092891477048397, -0.032980915158987045, 0.0009771494660526514, 0.0012753757182508707, -0.04538848623633385, 0.023483868688344955, -0.00568527402356267, -0.029592866078019142, 0.004126188810914755, 0.022609025239944458, 0.011052081361413002, -0.0751708596944809, -0.0004377424484118819, -0.02247563563287258, 0.02753644995391369, 0.0647563487291336, -0.0017531579360365868, -0.036716993898153305, -0.0036590967793017626, 0.06754593551158905, -0.05182381719350815, -0.007224649656563997, 0.025923103094100952, 0.018477505072951317, -0.02920585125684738, 0.09518323838710785, 0.02802378684282303, -0.0348675362765789, -0.011772955767810345, 0.02852274477481842, -0.09107419103384018, -0.0027631567791104317, -0.012441877275705338, 0.006544670555740595, 0.0066864765249192715, -0.02071373350918293, -0.016563668847084045, -0.02728746272623539, 0.005526769440621138, 0.01123085618019104, 0.004774198401719332, -0.0011296422453597188, 0.03841511532664299, -0.06753874570131302, 0.002576621016487479, 0.03239382058382034, -0.015267154201865196, 0.058647677302360535, -0.012411867268383503, -0.057856906205415726, -0.04969016835093498, -0.013228848576545715, 0.007918650284409523, -0.04778110608458519, 0.07745078206062317, 0.03266018256545067, 0.06169245392084122, -0.016155341640114784, 0.06929612159729004, 0.06859467923641205, 0.03147028014063835, -0.08662533760070801, -0.01349021214991808, 0.006723773665726185, -0.03144046664237976, 0.024339552968740463, 0.0010037879692390561, 0.0931636318564415, -0.004422621335834265, 0.019881300628185272, -0.00046632852172479033, 0.03691181540489197, 0.02389293536543846, -0.043231211602687836, 0.03035970777273178, -0.020459746941924095, 0.014354679733514786, 0.01683940552175045, 0.030592171475291252, -0.051759690046310425, 0.005357641261070967, 0.022188646718859673, -0.03953276947140694, -0.05111660063266754, 0.043393462896347046, 0.03562915325164795, 0.009354176931083202, -0.02336488477885723, 0.0481715090572834, 0.05034831538796425, -0.04383609816431999, -0.03483005613088608, 0.01082422211766243, 0.0020394951570779085, -0.04208923131227493, 0.0560685470700264, -0.016061503440141678, -0.020763572305440903, 0.021737264469265938, 0.05140098184347153, 0.008402024395763874, 0.022689275443553925, -0.007800934836268425, 0.04235100746154785, -0.01920257695019245, 0.02759355865418911, -0.017112629488110542, -0.03903865069150925, 0.056472811847925186, 0.03251153603196144, 0.013958846218883991, 0.02054522931575775, 0.02667558565735817, -0.0008736005984246731, -0.03420107066631317, -0.03422877565026283, 0.011117380112409592, 0.03841862455010414, -0.0176584143191576, -0.010222403332591057, -0.011897960677742958, 0.059322696179151535, -0.07831066101789474, 0.03156498447060585, -0.0015185842057690024, -0.009009125642478466, 0.015120166353881359, -0.05166949704289436, -4.809541748545113e-33, 0.012168641202151775, -0.03656193986535072, 0.007579389493912458, -0.040888141840696335, -0.020416202023625374, 0.038489025086164474, 0.014600507915019989, 0.03028898313641548, -0.05373894423246384, -0.012876218184828758, -0.06416408717632294, 0.04116293042898178, 0.019558636471629143, -0.005129170138388872, 0.0033819691743701696, -0.017769763246178627, 0.041748568415641785, -0.03200610354542732, 0.04337426275014877, -0.054564468562603, 0.014936336316168308, 0.002878418192267418, 0.03864964842796326, 0.0008000711095519364, -0.07345711439847946, 0.018052730709314346, -0.004412527661770582, -0.00818575918674469, -0.003955825697630644, 0.015400719828903675, -0.01889922469854355, -0.007444598246365786, 0.009296538308262825, 0.0007552638417109847, -0.0024979563895612955, 0.052953191101551056, -0.06951630860567093, -0.004313257057219744, -0.05498560890555382, 0.09809346497058868, -0.035923704504966736, 0.00039036566158756614, 0.06845723092556, -0.012549987994134426, -0.016207152977585793, -0.010511801578104496, 0.004539554938673973, -0.046516116708517075, -0.02765929512679577, 0.0049664718098938465, -0.025236964225769043, 0.028325272724032402, 0.01507139764726162, -0.04023570194840431, 0.04331875219941139, -0.032280586659908295, -0.022066796198487282, -0.019098324701189995, -0.03754564747214317, -0.013940167613327503, -0.03038712963461876, 0.05652289465069771, 0.000189773112651892, 0.05033599212765694, 0.00907736737281084, 0.04530620947480202, 0.009695208631455898, -0.018084120005369186, 0.005077822133898735, -0.006245024036616087, 0.03509436175227165, 0.0653146505355835, 0.05558706074953079, 0.023363610729575157, 0.10758379846811295, -0.029069548472762108, -0.05611293017864227, -0.02796509861946106, 0.0005012999754399061, 0.03600819781422615, -0.007580906618386507, -0.0021249460987746716, -0.0513046532869339, 0.024472283199429512, 0.041267164051532745, -0.0009519989253021777, -0.004518717993050814, -0.01900876872241497, 0.023752249777317047, 0.05964100733399391, -0.05501778796315193, 0.041050639003515244, 0.010047271847724915, -0.038324132561683655, 0.0848981961607933, -0.02359691634774208, 0.049156785011291504, 0.012774334289133549, 0.04058283939957619, 0.003902505151927471, -0.052262187004089355, -0.018676161766052246, -0.01047724112868309, 0.03424781560897827, -0.016710223630070686, 0.04386473819613457, 0.04799974337220192, 0.07191923260688782, -0.009542052634060383, -0.01624072529375553, -0.044528134167194366, -0.007849070243537426, -0.01732902228832245, 0.036915991455316544, 0.018113499507308006, -0.04376252368092537, 0.03811725974082947, 0.04288852959871292, -0.030297325924038887, -0.06754428148269653, -0.0016723752487450838, -0.016214704141020775, 0.006102098152041435, 0.01416977122426033, -0.04940277710556984, -0.061357494443655014, -0.09624087810516357, 0.026880845427513123, 0.06154990568757057, -0.07423150539398193, -0.02161792293190956, -0.024077748879790306, 2.500837581465021e-07, -0.06740296632051468, -0.027504710480570793, -0.021891795098781586, -0.04882242903113365, -0.0092299934476614, 0.02165726013481617, 0.026302874088287354, 0.053128231316804886, -0.02155202254652977, 0.012785526923835278, 0.047392092645168304, -0.007943257689476013, 0.0009737448999658227, -0.009079248644411564, -0.043420642614364624, 0.04279274493455887, 0.015690086409449577, 0.06319314241409302, -0.007895422168076038, 0.02306392416357994, 0.01953134499490261, 0.13643349707126617, 0.027393678203225136, -0.045237645506858826, 0.052881114184856415, -0.03815862163901329, -0.033613644540309906, 0.038440052419900894, 0.052444200962781906, -0.0458703339099884, -0.004933631978929043, 0.09372668713331223, -0.024995701387524605, -0.005412657745182514, 0.018705718219280243, -0.001921444432809949, -0.00452673714607954, 0.017914576455950737, -0.08624568581581116, 0.012457621283829212, -0.0049832104705274105, -0.037360452115535736, -0.017882028594613075, -0.0195621345192194, 0.06599362194538116, -0.027723360806703568, -0.008167196065187454, -0.08030062168836594, 0.01322958990931511, -0.0026233855169266462, -0.038744792342185974, 0.02970784716308117, 0.023086726665496826, -0.03321860730648041, 0.002762395655736327, -0.07079336047172546, -0.013061188161373138, -0.03018425777554512, 0.0012124880449846387, 0.0016955839237198234, 0.011485405266284943, 0.01965242251753807, -0.041344333440065384, 0.012341945432126522, 0.0686272531747818, 0.035188544541597366, -0.0975271463394165, 1.9153889513438514e-34, -0.03908070921897888, -0.018501440063118935, -0.005640316754579544, 0.026936126872897148, -0.03442683070898056, 0.006092780269682407, 0.010351376608014107, 0.006598772015422583, -0.012323040515184402, 0.025095514953136444, -0.04300747066736221]
688
688
['Tobias Hinz', 'Stefan Wermter']
1803.02627v1
Combining Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) with encoders that learn to encode data points has shown promising results in learning data representations in an unsupervised way. We propose a framework that combines an encoder and a generator to learn disentangled representations which encode meaningful information about the data distribution without the need for any labels. While current approaches focus mostly on the generative aspects of GANs, our framework can be used to perform inference on both real and generated data points. Experiments on several data sets show that the encoder learns interpretable, disentangled representations which encode descriptive properties and can be used to sample images that exhibit specific characteristics.
Inferencing Based on Unsupervised Learning of Disentangled Representations
2,018
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1803.02627v1
Title Inferencing Based Unsupervised Learning Disentangled Representations Summary Combining Generative Adversarial Networks GANs encoders learn encode data point shown promising result learning data representation unsupervised way propose framework combine encoder generator learn disentangled representation encode meaningful information data distribution without need label current approach focus mostly generative aspect GANs framework used perform inference real generated data point Experiments several data set show encoder learns interpretable disentangled representation encode descriptive property used sample image exhibit specific characteristic Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.03528452292084694, 0.12660232186317444, -0.018537303432822227, 0.07999861240386963, 0.01150921918451786, 0.03174477815628052, -0.004988578148186207, 0.017566945403814316, -0.007421194110065699, 0.03771132230758667, -0.01803317666053772, 0.05032367631793022, -0.010365442372858524, 0.03543653339147568, 0.06172604486346245, -0.08216636627912521, -0.01403383444994688, 0.021129725500941277, -0.04058736562728882, -0.0323559008538723, 0.017009196802973747, -0.021326933056116104, 0.00406910665333271, 0.018920423462986946, -0.027589038014411926, 0.0002733043802436441, -0.0204454492777586, 0.011871473863720894, 0.034429412335157394, -0.02150152251124382, 0.0040621827356517315, 0.013605329208076, 0.0508461520075798, -0.00432587368413806, 2.3975612748472486e-06, -0.0013971893349662423, -0.010605962947010994, -0.02676997520029545, -0.0031264747958630323, -0.017324378713965416, -0.02952338196337223, -0.04716629162430763, -0.010627449490129948, -0.005511381663382053, -0.028128232806921005, -0.08786807209253311, 0.03749282658100128, 0.03843763843178749, 0.039752598851919174, 0.02899930253624916, -0.03137814253568649, -0.0639878585934639, 0.006800414994359016, -0.05084451660513878, -0.002065759850665927, -0.010040581226348877, 0.006845138501375914, 0.035811156034469604, -0.058150529861450195, -0.011361568234860897, -0.07910528033971786, 0.024881355464458466, 0.048630036413669586, 0.0320606604218483, 0.01438943576067686, 0.04630495235323906, -0.003618094837293029, -0.001692635822109878, 0.017236800864338875, 0.042864538729190826, -0.05222088098526001, -0.013898361474275589, -0.020484546199440956, -0.001174482866190374, 3.765243309317157e-05, 0.011081905104219913, -0.012597590684890747, -0.020044660195708275, -0.01692659594118595, 0.048706527799367905, -0.059867460280656815, 0.06015089526772499, 0.012203906662762165, -0.01979127712547779, -0.05069389566779137, -0.008557917550206184, 0.024096470326185226, 0.05757543817162514, -0.06462368369102478, -0.02189057320356369, -0.06153620034456253, -0.01657407358288765, -0.00567662063986063, -0.027025502175092697, 0.012675761245191097, -0.03447975590825081, -0.03972717002034187, -0.02316434122622013, -0.01987379789352417, 0.025930210947990417, 0.028423812240362167, -0.03411028906702995, -0.022208284586668015, 0.024634530767798424, -0.008673951961100101, 0.02771042473614216, -0.043958622962236404, 0.043706536293029785, -0.027161838486790657, -0.06769952923059464, -0.027592072263360023, -0.03327450901269913, -0.0005057932576164603, -0.003694987390190363, -0.03251758590340614, -0.034599386155605316, -0.027294199913740158, -0.02154664508998394, -0.026440700516104698, 0.015842610970139503, -0.018742896616458893, 0.06728838384151459, -0.03968268632888794, -0.01547119952738285, -0.010353381745517254, -0.0037878674920648336, -0.04512884095311165, 0.026997506618499756, 0.008514991030097008, -0.034902334213256836, 0.0123174749314785, 0.04369413107633591, 0.016321483999490738, 0.013781330548226833, 0.015491349622607231, 0.07793582230806351, -0.03366687148809433, 0.03616931289434433, -0.03830495476722717, 0.012956713326275349, 0.010005328804254532, -0.02843909151852131, 0.03008943982422352, -0.05010581389069557, 0.028596308082342148, -0.004161571618169546, -0.013821051456034184, -0.06620831042528152, -0.004054814577102661, -0.029543986544013023, 0.0014423980610445142, 0.09916213154792786, -0.02839086949825287, -0.030413351953029633, 0.03911170735955238, 0.022797206416726112, 0.025957847014069557, 0.005026019178330898, 0.009929276071488857, 0.10034048557281494, -0.01446403469890356, 0.0031898408196866512, 0.04164363443851471, 0.008559192530810833, 0.033192455768585205, -0.00412999140098691, -0.03568577393889427, -0.011456100270152092, 0.03365681320428848, -0.04447806626558304, -0.0006893309764564037, 0.04859769344329834, -0.01826956309378147, -0.018962353467941284, 0.03362957388162613, 0.02157936803996563, 0.037826601415872574, 0.02215268276631832, -0.05285703390836716, 0.024716069921851158, -0.01722590997815132, -0.002255355706438422, 0.0024479858111590147, 0.10001199692487717, 0.027552872896194458, -0.019826285541057587, 0.0026170883793383837, 0.025366345420479774, -0.04747994616627693, -0.055606573820114136, 0.029358653351664543, -0.011162536218762398, -0.02687053009867668, 0.007257431745529175, 0.030977044254541397, 0.04131784662604332, 0.012807292863726616, -0.05714457482099533, 0.013100938871502876, 0.037701111286878586, 0.024853290989995003, -0.01576828584074974, 0.0005437426152639091, 0.0006113252020440996, 0.028233304619789124, 0.02130473405122757, 0.026513749733567238, -0.019232850521802902, -0.03038235940039158, -0.004436840303242207, -0.09386806935071945, -0.013016547076404095, 0.03975440561771393, -0.026083970442414284, -0.06879531592130661, -0.028259048238396645, 0.01385448407381773, 0.011359802447259426, -0.014788861386477947, -0.022810162976384163, 0.02608663961291313, 0.001892043394036591, 0.0318559929728508, 0.006160056218504906, 0.0032847134862095118, -0.0066876220516860485, 0.06564529985189438, 0.02817229926586151, 0.04450303316116333, -0.016920404508709908, 0.006258593872189522, -0.035115424543619156, 0.009099503047764301, -0.032478924840688705, -0.033684343099594116, -0.003348453901708126, -0.0006763340788893402, -0.09424515813589096, -0.05996926873922348, -0.10556820034980774, 0.010893532074987888, -0.009034254588186741, -0.03965334594249725, -0.029401587322354317, 0.02013213001191616, -0.013285201042890549, -0.03300771489739418, -0.02468077279627323, -0.03613998740911484, -0.0064954194240272045, 0.03837575018405914, 0.0004342128522694111, 0.0625125914812088, -0.036045800894498825, -0.03538847342133522, 0.019609753042459488, 0.06372984498739243, 0.02459648624062538, 0.01625349000096321, -0.01772490330040455, 0.012630950659513474, -0.008454007096588612, -0.020213359966874123, 0.00024829772883094847, -0.023985449224710464, 0.022209495306015015, 0.028081949800252914, 0.028543878346681595, 0.00496023939922452, -0.016028286889195442, -0.02156928926706314, 0.04037533700466156, 0.019110839813947678, 0.0028212873730808496, -0.0435667522251606, -0.04071245715022087, 0.03514580428600311, 0.008543133735656738, -0.04346281290054321, 0.035694610327482224, -0.0004957127966918051, 0.030874527990818024, 0.014920545741915703, 0.028133157640695572, 0.02197960391640663, 0.04587530344724655, 0.005650718230754137, -0.061618026345968246, -0.010409616865217686, 0.001419672742486, 0.0015652123838663101, 0.025799663737416267, -0.003382803173735738, -0.06813257932662964, 0.010926817543804646, -0.006330810021609068, 0.019423549994826317, 0.05923640355467796, -0.010486578568816185, 0.00880435761064291, -0.007899508811533451, 0.01379750482738018, -0.015805941075086594, -0.024074319750070572, -0.025876278057694435, 0.044169798493385315, 0.02422385662794113, 0.003953434061259031, -0.013980911113321781, -0.0033927885815501213, 0.05947311967611313, 0.008211275562644005, -0.003964587114751339, 0.0445815771818161, 0.015857700258493423, -0.0214268546551466, -0.07153914868831635, 0.058316461741924286, 0.02987596206367016, 0.027995388954877853, -0.061768826097249985, -0.06821886450052261, 0.03247428312897682, 0.024309324100613594, -0.03473406285047531, 0.017958447337150574, -0.001797049306333065, 0.016035940498113632, 0.059371467679739, 0.034709829837083817, 0.025355340912938118, 0.005695623345673084, -0.012770269997417927, -0.028816817328333855, 0.01722312718629837, 0.028306882828474045, -0.0009496844722889364, -0.00833946280181408, 0.0022451449185609818, -0.02014748379588127, 0.018290262669324875, 0.008097908459603786, -0.0692286491394043, -0.006877189036458731, 0.06743710488080978, 0.013978308998048306, 0.0033612200058996677, -0.014243625104427338, -0.016485797241330147, -0.04050607979297638, -0.008060257881879807, 0.00906401313841343, -0.022087978199124336, 0.016909215599298477, -0.030834883451461792, 0.08782658725976944, 0.04320862889289856, -0.07133586704730988, -0.04919588193297386, -0.012120641767978668, 0.011069847270846367, 0.04135381430387497, -0.123005710542202, 0.014005144126713276, -0.07092612981796265, 0.0021375666838139296, -0.017515748739242554, 0.07602149248123169, 0.022835349664092064, 0.01607031375169754, 0.018878130242228508, 0.0019485135562717915, -0.018079468980431557, 0.004408383741974831, -0.03676513209939003, -0.045684121549129486, 0.0291882511228323, 0.06853017210960388, -0.011679581366479397, 0.03318532183766365, 0.025331944227218628, -0.051530785858631134, -0.021683281287550926, -0.03888693451881409, -0.0076114884577691555, 0.049361713230609894, 0.020384525880217552, 0.012698316015303135, -0.03464094176888466, 0.06171790137887001, 0.01713528111577034, 0.007138191722333431, -0.06709891557693481, 0.011210676282644272, 0.007862229831516743, -0.039032865315675735, -0.0036483854055404663, -0.014703198336064816, 0.05813533440232277, 0.037536513060331345, 0.010915063321590424, 0.029964175075292587, -0.05104538053274155, -0.026658501476049423, -0.025168437510728836, 0.014637480489909649, 0.06153266876935959, 0.02003706432878971, 0.019169248640537262, -0.07276193052530289, -0.07524217665195465, -0.012036096304655075, -0.030010351911187172, -0.022124042734503746, 0.12406566739082336, 0.031120700761675835, -0.016552362591028214, -0.02676130086183548, 0.10556389391422272, -0.019006334245204926, 0.03973555564880371, 0.015693362802267075, -0.024593045935034752, -0.05632716789841652, -0.00262215593829751, -0.015291381627321243, -0.0635765939950943, 0.0403442457318306, -0.02167896181344986, 0.017999760806560516, 0.013359962962567806, -0.03161563724279404, -0.03330467641353607, 0.05274784564971924, -0.02396523393690586, 0.012510533444583416, 0.020847870036959648, 0.021182775497436523, -0.03557661920785904, -0.07447421550750732, 0.017277689650654793, -0.013738076202571392, 0.05656866356730461, -0.007950231432914734, -0.015760252252221107, -0.03476942330598831, -0.037686463445425034, -0.02973834052681923, -0.03610549122095108, 0.040400199592113495, -0.028703097254037857, 0.02424652874469757, -0.06191754341125488, 0.05967143177986145, -0.007197887171059847, -0.019385484978556633, -0.019072439521551132, -0.030884716659784317, -0.014927064068615437, -0.022580644115805626, 0.058364562690258026, -0.005765852518379688, 0.06954114139080048, -0.009326946921646595, 0.012347700074315071, 0.05837055295705795, 0.029348546639084816, 0.012323151342570782, -0.0569804422557354, -0.002191723557189107, 0.03624860942363739, -0.016226939857006073, -0.00190789345651865, 0.0033208562526851892, 0.1204078271985054, 0.02252715453505516, -0.05986948311328888, -0.042349107563495636, -0.000892586715053767, 0.035300951451063156, -0.03144986927509308, 0.03765583038330078, 0.007283902261406183, 0.020716199651360512, -0.01735086180269718, -0.0012891482328996062, 0.011222402565181255, 0.00859169103205204, -0.054343100637197495, 0.011978823691606522, 0.04028153792023659, 0.019323742017149925, 0.004923845641314983, 0.03728003427386284, 0.07124108076095581, -0.004619485232979059, -0.04612959921360016, -0.023817265406250954, 0.005226988345384598, 0.041425950825214386, -0.0873279869556427, 0.03102654404938221, 0.030946223065257072, 0.02024688385426998, 0.03620890527963638, 0.044571321457624435, -0.008478355593979359, -0.00019391643581911922, 0.033535186201334, 0.011009205132722855, -0.040240578353405, 0.01210671104490757, -0.004461064003407955, 0.00872383825480938, -0.060929715633392334, 0.03936190903186798, 0.06150222197175026, 0.01867896504700184, -0.0004693492082878947, 0.013507071882486343, 0.03315816819667816, -0.024577992036938667, 0.05228668823838234, 0.007224809378385544, -0.028075803071260452, 0.0319390743970871, -0.02811235375702381, 0.0028736689127981663, -0.08819462358951569, 0.06707257777452469, 0.03416883572936058, -0.007426010444760323, -0.056211862713098526, -0.015845874324440956, -0.039049919694662094, 0.00220814673230052, 0.03381645306944847, -0.016797808930277824, 0.009867335669696331, 0.09772009402513504, 0.0513976626098156, -0.009138885885477066, -0.11692988872528076, 0.002771735889837146, 0.029015755280852318, 0.023273007944226265, 0.03735260292887688, -0.011876765638589859, -0.010002193041145802, -0.08809038251638412, -0.005302754230797291, -0.024177435785531998, 0.01662534661591053, 0.001052153529599309, -0.007126237265765667, -6.699469974386508e-33, -0.00013996513735037297, -0.014434759505093098, -0.0344601571559906, -0.07105405628681183, 0.03438473120331764, -0.030051885172724724, -0.035215314477682114, -0.06596049666404724, 0.025659475475549698, -0.015142119489610195, 0.0034176234621554613, 0.03521757200360298, -0.019980652257800102, 0.06187979504466057, 0.022176068276166916, 0.008181607350707054, 0.03598839417099953, 0.013819949701428413, 0.0024608406238257885, 0.03938616067171097, 0.04338805004954338, 0.01720454730093479, 0.02916545793414116, -0.07474736869335175, -0.052731744945049286, -0.040408454835414886, -0.03697509691119194, -0.02538364566862583, -0.0021179800387471914, -0.021506112068891525, -0.008119704201817513, -0.02574758417904377, 0.004620254039764404, -0.01665659435093403, -0.03345010057091713, -0.034437526017427444, -0.07204068452119827, -0.02518625743687153, -0.04176630824804306, 0.01378690730780363, -0.04446732997894287, -0.026392238214612007, 0.02063378319144249, -0.03877310827374458, -0.0025537738110870123, -0.03150973841547966, 0.05349895730614662, -0.027000341564416885, 0.04961373656988144, -0.033403266221284866, -0.025353219360113144, 0.015840137377381325, -0.025309214368462563, -0.008852465078234673, 0.03877560421824455, 0.017556820064783096, -0.008783414028584957, -0.003500729100778699, -0.06705010682344437, 0.010079613886773586, 0.02791721187531948, 0.0461462028324604, 0.07770572602748871, 0.06479082256555557, 0.05901436135172844, 0.03414890170097351, 0.01196483988314867, -0.047633931040763855, -0.03850666806101799, -0.007865123450756073, -0.01641709916293621, 0.05694189295172691, 0.008761478587985039, 0.03615391626954079, 0.08810587972402573, -0.042974475771188736, -0.05047895386815071, 0.05035771429538727, -0.03432972729206085, 0.013323914259672165, -0.003950775600969791, 0.044342655688524246, 0.005994430743157864, -0.043842680752277374, 0.00548590999096632, -0.06842166185379028, 0.03597642481327057, -0.05538314953446388, 0.025161022320389748, 0.004064411856234074, -0.06908580660820007, 0.010552083142101765, 0.028018049895763397, -0.05623042583465576, 0.00461919791996479, 0.0167201180011034, 0.0036437921226024628, 0.006501634605228901, 0.03910846263170242, -0.0044136145152151585, -0.011485518887639046, -0.01968843676149845, 0.07630808651447296, 0.04240213707089424, -0.001328164478763938, 0.022705862298607826, 0.034868039190769196, -0.0016721371794119477, 0.03174252435564995, -0.017531897872686386, -0.038935545831918716, -0.0013529568677768111, -0.0038600601255893707, -0.020712679252028465, -0.008007291704416275, -0.005638679023832083, -0.01605028472840786, 0.0012073660036548972, 0.003378011053428054, 0.05306120216846466, -0.015419377014040947, -0.012000071816146374, -0.010090856812894344, 0.029294608160853386, -0.024677986279129982, -0.012942305766046047, -0.04711995646357536, -0.051977310329675674, 0.0660150945186615, -0.048899225890636444, -0.006120087578892708, 0.013032205402851105, 2.986961646911368e-07, -0.009974194690585136, -0.025690507143735886, 0.014383429661393166, -0.019082246348261833, 0.020443148910999298, -0.0028712539933621883, -0.022240450605750084, 0.027406951412558556, -0.030768411234021187, -0.04417799413204193, 0.020553087815642357, 0.026708416640758514, 0.009294405579566956, 0.036487702280282974, -0.009469031356275082, 0.07364886999130249, -0.010188676416873932, 0.01602526381611824, -0.02523607574403286, 0.012148821726441383, 0.03279079124331474, 0.08592942357063293, 0.007418131921440363, 0.009387122467160225, 0.0898548886179924, 0.051557861268520355, 0.028520779684185982, -0.0023174795787781477, 0.042317114770412445, -0.0034311311319470406, -0.03338819742202759, 0.03917587175965309, 0.013275589793920517, 0.011116285808384418, -0.007958478294312954, 0.0071752965450286865, 0.03556692600250244, -0.005112460348755121, -0.005898077040910721, 0.012877365574240685, -0.035117946565151215, 0.044214073568582535, 0.019289789721369743, -0.045995380729436874, 0.05657263472676277, -0.07350317388772964, -0.06824164092540741, 0.016835737973451614, -0.013752528466284275, 0.030644265934824944, 0.0026445568073540926, 0.00338796922005713, -0.012209906242787838, -0.022844664752483368, 0.026264134794473648, -0.019960666075348854, 0.013136557303369045, -0.017076142132282257, 0.009587579406797886, -0.017377689480781555, -0.04651189222931862, 0.0037891629617661238, -0.016359621658921242, -0.02288912609219551, 0.03158709406852722, 0.01745581068098545, -0.02356388419866562, 2.3967138247703792e-34, -0.06340155005455017, 0.03697691485285759, -0.01775498129427433, -0.015290587209165096, -0.0049218242056667805, -0.033498577773571014, 0.015171279199421406, -0.002276788232848048, 0.019320590421557426, -0.010302631184458733, -0.05337810516357422]
689
689
['Erik Berglund', 'Joaquin Sitte']
0705.0199v2
The Parameter-Less Self-Organizing Map (PLSOM) is a new neural network algorithm based on the Self-Organizing Map (SOM). It eliminates the need for a learning rate and annealing schemes for learning rate and neighbourhood size. We discuss the relative performance of the PLSOM and the SOM and demonstrate some tasks in which the SOM fails but the PLSOM performs satisfactory. Finally we discuss some example applications of the PLSOM and present a proof of ordering under certain limited conditions.
The Parameter-Less Self-Organizing Map algorithm
2,007
http://arxiv.org/pdf/0705.0199v2
Title ParameterLess SelfOrganizing Map algorithm Summary ParameterLess SelfOrganizing Map PLSOM new neural network algorithm based SelfOrganizing Map SOM eliminates need learning rate annealing scheme learning rate neighbourhood size discus relative performance PLSOM SOM demonstrate task SOM fails PLSOM performs satisfactory Finally discus example application PLSOM present proof ordering certain limited condition Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.03741709142923355, -0.0019337277626618743, 0.001419220701791346, -0.015870966017246246, 0.009401226416230202, -0.022940117865800858, 0.03638525679707527, -0.050921302288770676, 0.029635833576321602, 0.007876950316131115, -0.0322907380759716, 0.07134104520082474, 0.0012333877384662628, 0.015537651255726814, 0.017399752512574196, -0.012058038264513016, 0.025699123740196228, 0.0007561423117294908, -0.07261399924755096, -0.039356932044029236, -0.0605381578207016, -0.03903006762266159, -0.0076848468743264675, -0.023624593392014503, -0.006122431252151728, -0.036829691380262375, -0.05651455000042915, 0.003512778552249074, -0.006194432266056538, -0.0019692794885486364, -0.0148325739428401, 0.006464743055403233, -0.025267155840992928, 0.03375204652547836, 2.1877051494811894e-06, -0.015002982690930367, -0.02153317630290985, -0.019413577392697334, 0.041625071316957474, 0.04745059832930565, 0.029571155086159706, 0.03276737406849861, -0.0580858439207077, 0.003009875537827611, -0.027790190652012825, 0.0033755898475646973, 0.06697173416614532, 0.025972703471779823, 0.07954257726669312, 0.021585706621408463, -0.014159074053168297, -0.06518319994211197, 0.019907036796212196, -0.009952197782695293, -0.03317258507013321, 0.015548303723335266, 0.018971605226397514, -0.02003606967628002, -0.032768383622169495, -0.019401807337999344, 0.005599529482424259, 0.06197402998805046, 0.01863519661128521, -0.011347783729434013, 0.040743637830019, 0.02861042134463787, 0.03106895089149475, -0.029156548902392387, -0.004128423519432545, 0.0049665458500385284, -0.06388336420059204, -0.0011163552990183234, 0.032087650150060654, -0.007027666084468365, -0.004571245983242989, 0.003903091885149479, 0.0059641506522893906, 0.01672809012234211, 0.007996708154678345, -0.005367712117731571, -0.029422832652926445, 0.06499847024679184, -0.008192524313926697, -0.011883534491062164, -0.0537070631980896, 0.07891077548265457, -0.02176349237561226, 0.017183922231197357, -0.05797405168414116, -0.07269634306430817, -0.0002822393726091832, 0.004251368809491396, 0.027248790487647057, 0.06871432811021805, 0.047778066247701645, -0.026281537488102913, -0.008423969149589539, -0.019821682944893837, 0.03717688098549843, -0.10047946870326996, 0.07035648822784424, -0.03160366415977478, 0.021960442885756493, 0.02033417858183384, -0.04565436765551567, 0.0006180731579661369, -0.06660310924053192, 0.059941407293081284, -0.023764735087752342, 0.013471479527652264, -0.028319042176008224, 0.026534948498010635, -0.04234880208969116, 0.09157714992761612, 0.016722053289413452, 0.0018509522778913379, -0.019092578440904617, 0.021078558638691902, 0.010558153502643108, -0.035298895090818405, 0.018020054325461388, 0.014685316942632198, 0.006079063285142183, -0.011213887482881546, -0.005046573933213949, -0.03524615615606308, -0.022354599088430405, -0.0016221754485741258, -0.021223710849881172, 0.05341261997818947, 0.021094849333167076, -0.010418134741485119, 0.005139383487403393, 0.0668734610080719, -0.031029339879751205, 0.07774735987186432, 0.0030185284558683634, 0.03628340736031532, -0.1264714002609253, 0.012687860056757927, -0.0011090735206380486, -0.0014813359593972564, 0.028521817177534103, -0.03528432548046112, -0.011191747151315212, -0.04200034961104393, -0.025167053565382957, -0.004880704917013645, -0.01880009099841118, -0.017865139991044998, -0.029380692169070244, 0.051724255084991455, -0.04015902057290077, 0.03760611638426781, 0.09422606229782104, -0.004467970225960016, 0.017531653866171837, 0.010448050685226917, 0.02544628456234932, 0.04335165396332741, -0.004920411389321089, -0.03885004669427872, 0.031117210164666176, -0.013412750326097012, -0.002351208822801709, -0.05652307718992233, 0.007311530876904726, -0.054473720490932465, 0.002216112334281206, 0.018826138228178024, 7.265559543156996e-05, -0.017256416380405426, 0.01993817649781704, -0.0590546578168869, 0.01787516474723816, 0.0475441999733448, 0.07414931803941727, 0.09965109080076218, -0.03797178715467453, 0.07204046100378036, -0.02421199157834053, -0.019028253853321075, 7.546984852524474e-05, 0.06495844572782516, -0.01728539913892746, -0.04270603507757187, -0.013943329453468323, -0.005260574631392956, -0.04901810362935066, -0.03799932822585106, 0.019391650334000587, -0.01222165022045374, -0.009556330740451813, -0.07026620209217072, 0.011527169495821, 0.0485958531498909, -0.01898454874753952, -0.020492011681199074, 0.007866425439715385, -0.02821749448776245, -0.049975067377090454, -0.017940010875463486, 0.004765080288052559, -0.04129701852798462, 0.0026823505759239197, -0.04931709170341492, -0.07214044034481049, 0.030931033194065094, 0.021476896479725838, 0.01641823910176754, -0.01084921695291996, 0.030254866927862167, 0.04351721704006195, -0.035252708941698074, 0.011641005985438824, 0.054583899676799774, -0.011466276831924915, 0.005972844548523426, -0.059389010071754456, -0.02503885142505169, -0.0037860858719795942, 0.023638982325792313, -0.013764550909399986, 0.019585777074098587, 0.0019382204627618194, -0.014300916343927383, 0.06071287766098976, 0.04562906548380852, 0.012656478211283684, 0.025809284299612045, 0.027451293542981148, -0.01422309223562479, 0.07735041528940201, -0.02182222157716751, -0.013254327699542046, -0.028005938977003098, -0.07190355658531189, -0.015898186713457108, -0.003209965070709586, 0.01195460744202137, 0.0002868084120564163, 0.019548889249563217, 0.008395545184612274, -0.07959914207458496, 0.05528099089860916, 0.00031200656667351723, -0.027031853795051575, -0.020863406360149384, 0.019273923709988594, 0.007450282573699951, 0.04150807112455368, 0.010088157840073109, 0.0009586967062205076, 0.02496831864118576, -0.017763879150152206, -0.04473036155104637, 0.04305446520447731, 0.008915815502405167, 0.01696048676967621, -0.019022857770323753, -0.0012491358211264014, -0.05326961725950241, -0.015992676839232445, -0.025013620033860207, 0.003568832064047456, 0.03415821120142937, -0.042769331485033035, -0.01134905032813549, -0.032139770686626434, 0.03084334172308445, -0.001293585286475718, 0.02748677134513855, -0.02938804216682911, 0.03796197101473808, -0.05455546826124191, -0.01584625616669655, 0.0922764241695404, -0.008059091866016388, -0.06870594620704651, 0.06607209891080856, -0.019659433513879776, -0.02346472255885601, -0.009991535916924477, -0.036190006881952286, -0.022870628163218498, -0.008092818781733513, 0.03522319346666336, -0.019704945385456085, -0.06549321115016937, -0.002851674798876047, -0.023862255737185478, 0.05819400027394295, 0.009942807257175446, -0.05757131800055504, -0.01720517687499523, -0.044261641800403595, -0.02036380022764206, 0.06750081479549408, 0.038631949573755264, -0.07649478316307068, 0.023424530401825905, 0.023016834631562233, 0.004397645127028227, 0.006882377900183201, -0.04130779206752777, 0.0146056292578578, 0.07610582560300827, 0.02738916501402855, 0.017205245792865753, 0.0020448334980756044, 0.012999196536839008, 0.003274451708421111, -0.0019334964454174042, 0.017314469441771507, -0.01741800084710121, -0.015446548350155354, -0.030001912266016006, 0.00968521274626255, 0.020603526383638382, -0.011122831143438816, -0.024485312402248383, 0.0038520973175764084, 0.01984972320497036, -0.01872853934764862, -0.012704350985586643, 0.026914307847619057, -0.01352122612297535, -0.005178398918360472, 0.0029403013177216053, 0.018963750451803207, 0.05899757146835327, 0.018848655745387077, -0.03963052108883858, 0.014653028920292854, -0.007560227066278458, -0.039200566709041595, -0.009141102433204651, -0.0009466631454415619, 0.014096110127866268, 0.01705726981163025, 0.00025645465939305723, -0.006356018595397472, -0.03980778902769089, 0.0008083591237664223, 0.11242834478616714, -0.009677018038928509, 0.014843069016933441, -0.006507800426334143, 0.027132824063301086, 0.05093656852841377, 0.006259585730731487, 0.06274344027042389, -0.043330464512109756, -0.004280533641576767, 0.0028378264978528023, -0.009816724807024002, -0.024556197226047516, 0.06761043518781662, 0.006862407550215721, 0.06138913333415985, 0.057825811207294464, 0.009318921715021133, 0.02605034038424492, 0.023387350142002106, -0.09967929869890213, 0.024896327406167984, -0.025835543870925903, -0.051746416836977005, -0.0016651477199047804, -0.04449812322854996, -0.010236772708594799, -0.017183084040880203, 0.00902947224676609, 0.04339991882443428, 0.02362600341439247, -0.06870327144861221, -0.019088001921772957, -0.042351461946964264, -0.06354860961437225, -0.002813349012285471, 0.01703164167702198, 0.04912833124399185, 0.022796018049120903, -0.04062497988343239, -0.013904501684010029, -0.008373354561626911, -0.03166298568248749, 0.016649218276143074, -0.054028913378715515, 0.044208675622940063, 0.030112801119685173, -0.05053073540329933, -0.014110613614320755, -0.023127347230911255, -0.0012277951464056969, -0.03240077942609787, -0.0649571493268013, 0.04571397230029106, -0.031497880816459656, -0.06908850371837616, -0.004181656986474991, -0.022440828382968903, 0.06945107132196426, -0.05457575246691704, -0.06870231032371521, 0.05787324905395508, -0.02283729799091816, 0.019911162555217743, 0.0068590533919632435, -0.0013316972181200981, 0.045788902789354324, 0.01707659289240837, 0.00645057950168848, -0.029773348942399025, 0.005848274566233158, 0.04202825576066971, 0.0026805235538631678, 0.02100214548408985, -0.0014883122639730573, -0.07255250215530396, 0.07352083921432495, 0.002753652399405837, 0.010472009889781475, 0.011407671496272087, 0.05014726519584656, -0.043516695499420166, 0.04192175716161728, -0.03829871490597725, -0.010393849574029446, -0.023168399930000305, 0.01632000505924225, -0.024258198216557503, -0.0037747162859886885, 0.04734044894576073, 0.008446160703897476, -0.007270754314959049, -0.0027097398415207863, -0.005470152013003826, -0.02114739641547203, -0.06354987621307373, -0.013884513638913631, -0.03200676292181015, 0.06840594112873077, 0.07254389673471451, 0.00037062462070025504, 0.08966637402772903, -0.018910342827439308, -0.018236299976706505, -0.061017632484436035, 0.010485791601240635, -0.07264301925897598, -0.050335146486759186, 0.0286781657487154, 0.0708451122045517, -0.017776040360331535, 0.02210521511733532, -0.022073859348893166, 0.012182334437966347, -0.029245449230074883, 0.07992587983608246, 0.04917973652482033, 0.005065437406301498, -0.0021829146426171064, -0.046892404556274414, -0.010327509604394436, 0.044642865657806396, -0.0003830515779554844, 0.001814350369386375, 0.0255692470818758, 0.027227479964494705, 0.009019630029797554, -0.012573943473398685, 0.02307172119617462, 0.001553383539430797, 0.09555577486753464, -0.03901989758014679, -0.045895498245954514, -0.027008816599845886, 0.04582344368100166, -0.01618161052465439, -0.024699194356799126, 0.04392029345035553, 0.060729920864105225, 0.010482672601938248, -0.03847979009151459, 0.01744406670331955, -0.012253363616764545, 0.031255610287189484, -0.015581204555928707, 0.07857949286699295, -0.0066983457654714584, 0.040215495973825455, 0.012926862575113773, -0.07681992650032043, 0.05126521736383438, -0.04077643156051636, 0.07849258184432983, -0.028804969042539597, -0.02249693125486374, 0.01959061436355114, -0.0950566977262497, 0.03413243964314461, -0.02406681329011917, 0.04484997317194939, 0.02896934002637863, -0.0028053238056600094, -0.026745812967419624, 0.04110576957464218, 0.012538112699985504, 0.046630606055259705, -0.07815055549144745, 0.05492066219449043, -0.0075705163180828094, -0.033726755529642105, -0.03207030147314072, 0.01977045275270939, 0.055129196494817734, 0.04557418450713158, 0.02455848827958107, 0.017387494444847107, 0.03700370341539383, 0.00038993818452581763, -0.004539710469543934, -0.04963438957929611, 0.07021722197532654, -0.009218917228281498, 0.00030697291367687285, -0.016229383647441864, -0.0144271869212389, -0.025448709726333618, 0.03277105093002319, -0.04556625708937645, 0.005038519389927387, 0.033094968646764755, -0.023321406915783882, 0.059113357216119766, -0.041848331689834595, 0.01908758096396923, -0.028537116944789886, -0.01869046315550804, 0.03787912055850029, 0.011050346307456493, -0.014176062308251858, 0.059538137167692184, 0.03413999453186989, 0.0014409722061827779, 0.02445300482213497, -0.017107844352722168, -0.008717047050595284, 0.00794929638504982, -0.00222011492587626, -0.02346765622496605, 0.0029222145676612854, -0.005006933119148016, 0.006239152979105711, -6.472941192723514e-33, -0.03656207025051117, -0.021815156564116478, -0.01460228394716978, 0.02391701377928257, -0.0026144650764763355, -0.052188605070114136, 0.022428546100854874, 0.02094123885035515, -0.017967723309993744, -0.0244255643337965, -0.036318399012088776, 0.013131125830113888, 0.0034187682904303074, 0.022358236834406853, 0.039601415395736694, 0.01603289693593979, 0.024711400270462036, -0.02678556554019451, 0.0032587782479822636, 0.006930957082659006, 0.0035053109750151634, 0.03608696535229683, -0.011794425547122955, -0.0054556033574044704, -0.06831824779510498, 0.018338443711400032, -0.0011328866239637136, 0.004233814310282469, -0.016207000240683556, -0.014505458064377308, 0.006919322535395622, -0.003950970247387886, -0.004400690086185932, -0.001871459768153727, -0.017769211903214455, -0.01053497102111578, -0.08193792402744293, -0.0670112892985344, -0.06454150378704071, 0.025423936545848846, -0.0478992834687233, 0.011941357515752316, 0.08792498707771301, -0.002013889607042074, -0.06408646702766418, 0.038885243237018585, 0.04502933844923973, 0.03508370369672775, 0.001205594278872013, 0.08084728568792343, -0.0007753103272989392, 0.005412350408732891, 0.01996399275958538, -0.04561052471399307, 0.06576960533857346, -0.020205210894346237, -0.02068682387471199, -0.012306633405387402, -0.0720633938908577, 0.0180710107088089, 0.011360353790223598, 0.056949060410261154, -0.01033727079629898, 0.022071681916713715, 0.04906613007187843, -0.006356638856232166, 0.06516128033399582, -0.00020242731261532754, -0.021627729758620262, -0.005444172769784927, -0.016872001811861992, 0.003447800874710083, 0.0337381474673748, -0.08215378224849701, 0.056863460689783096, -0.02753320150077343, -0.004939866717904806, 0.038748666644096375, -0.03170457482337952, -0.03237239271402359, -0.024351373314857483, -0.020855091512203217, -0.027508869767189026, -0.012631592340767384, 0.035036344081163406, -0.09025395661592484, -0.03971240669488907, -0.0091090127825737, 0.017991384491324425, -0.013702885247766972, -0.039495568722486496, 0.013935505412518978, -0.03347637131810188, -0.02107084169983864, 0.024222789332270622, -0.021777451038360596, 0.020054256543517113, 0.019304435700178146, 0.014694049954414368, 0.003915316425263882, -0.05198424682021141, -0.029757848009467125, -0.030643856152892113, 0.015387298539280891, -0.003598166862502694, 0.033528730273246765, -0.07244669646024704, 0.04965381696820259, -0.010552702471613884, -0.011885948479175568, 0.04665679857134819, -0.010408679023385048, -0.00409991480410099, -0.03586616739630699, 0.02337109111249447, -0.05694044381380081, 0.03289194777607918, 0.05337435379624367, 0.030278431251645088, 0.00640732329338789, 0.006420621648430824, 0.025244737043976784, -0.018657231703400612, 0.028933629393577576, 0.004280701745301485, 0.00018382824782747775, -0.018171600997447968, 0.003613832639530301, 0.02658660151064396, -0.07547679543495178, -0.025221211835741997, 0.035624150186777115, 2.8938754326190974e-07, -0.020091934129595757, 0.0721660852432251, 0.027202917262911797, -0.049242518842220306, 0.009943914599716663, 0.01380985789000988, -0.014648144133388996, 0.023554159328341484, -0.05406556650996208, 0.012648995034396648, 0.006413470022380352, -0.011252854019403458, -0.018575187772512436, -0.007172508165240288, -0.06846471130847931, -0.023314576596021652, -0.024431515485048294, 0.09492361545562744, 0.008117797784507275, 0.004889177158474922, -0.005281610414385796, 0.050460658967494965, 0.0033317713532596827, -0.010146628133952618, 0.0087633291259408, -0.0016990541480481625, -0.03014785796403885, 0.03918964043259621, 0.054752930998802185, -0.005910963751375675, -0.021089017391204834, -0.007391936145722866, -0.04654485359787941, -0.02838888205587864, 0.009356440044939518, 0.05125037953257561, -0.026210276409983635, 0.01133096031844616, -0.008870843797922134, -0.03564441576600075, 0.07436764985322952, 0.015237146057188511, 0.03464439511299133, -0.02813144214451313, 0.0024923307355493307, -0.07972272485494614, -0.03710430487990379, 0.020391464233398438, 0.046327196061611176, 0.06028297170996666, 0.03171472251415253, -0.012015407904982567, -0.027664657682180405, -0.008373626507818699, 0.006408206187188625, -0.06072549521923065, 0.0436490997672081, -0.010906447656452656, 0.030908504500985146, -0.009771154262125492, -0.00025918486062437296, 0.020494306460022926, -0.0022372484672814608, 0.003263604361563921, 0.08837971091270447, -0.010970339179039001, -0.0468684546649456, 2.4661919693887075e-34, -0.02638518251478672, -0.06389544904232025, 0.000814070284832269, -0.0009318324737250805, -0.046851493418216705, 0.022811220958828926, -0.0006859759450890124, -0.007122911978513002, -0.047104425728321075, 0.010497888550162315, -0.04313763976097107]
690
690
['Christian Napoli', 'Giuseppe Pappalardo', 'Emiliano Tramontana', 'Zbigniew Marszałek', 'Dawid Połap', 'Marcin Woźniak']
1412.6464v1
In order to identify an object, human eyes firstly search the field of view for points or areas which have particular properties. These properties are used to recognise an image or an object. Then this process could be taken as a model to develop computer algorithms for images identification. This paper proposes the idea of applying the simplified firefly algorithm to search for key-areas in 2D images. For a set of input test images the proposed version of firefly algorithm has been examined. Research results are presented and discussed to show the efficiency of this evolutionary computation method.
Simplified firefly algorithm for 2D image key-points search
2,014
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1412.6464v1
Title Simplified firefly algorithm 2D image keypoints search Summary order identify object human eye firstly search field view point area particular property property used recognise image object process could taken model develop computer algorithm image identification paper proposes idea applying simplified firefly algorithm search keyareas 2D image set input test image proposed version firefly algorithm examined Research result presented discussed show efficiency evolutionary computation method Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.00666049076244235, -0.007869566790759563, -0.003758190432563424, 0.035692159086465836, -0.020446600392460823, -0.0026361218187958, 3.1921383197186515e-05, 0.037386175245046616, 0.006876166444271803, -0.03355340287089348, 0.014403634704649448, 0.05032142996788025, 0.02732980065047741, -0.0015734510961920023, 0.003372750012204051, -0.04399307817220688, -0.04577961936593056, 0.014932246878743172, -0.009439398534595966, 0.00260493578389287, 0.05614076927304268, -0.05433954671025276, 0.03141295164823532, -0.018458139151334763, -0.04392598569393158, 0.012387044727802277, -0.0471278578042984, -0.026661928743124008, 0.09728733450174332, -0.01529128011316061, 0.004858111031353474, 0.012330455705523491, -0.034243084490299225, 0.05022239685058594, 2.117094481945969e-06, -0.04964103177189827, -0.03452523052692413, 0.014187508262693882, 0.09107588231563568, 0.04233654588460922, 0.054615966975688934, 0.040003105998039246, -0.012249717488884926, -0.0628441646695137, 0.01675141416490078, 0.005550950299948454, 0.0555545948445797, 0.06091713160276413, 0.02219337970018387, 0.012037733569741249, 0.008843332529067993, -0.11310049891471863, -0.002592826960608363, 0.05838087201118469, 0.02551153115928173, -0.003472902113571763, -0.032856155186891556, -0.02873310074210167, 0.00038265998591668904, -0.03385452926158905, -0.002212602412328124, 0.03456709906458855, -0.04212304949760437, -0.013864019885659218, 0.031213073059916496, 0.004178052302449942, -0.08683272451162338, -0.026794487610459328, -0.00592817272990942, -0.003189496463164687, -0.048657774925231934, -0.02550547942519188, 0.010722906328737736, 0.006087787915021181, -0.013801433145999908, 0.029361240565776825, 0.024407122284173965, 0.01869809441268444, -0.054882343858480453, -0.011389796622097492, -0.0336935818195343, -0.013355311006307602, -0.027613960206508636, -0.02978912927210331, 0.024682939052581787, -0.021619105711579323, 0.01242740172892809, 0.0013599180383607745, -0.005196212790906429, -0.053125735372304916, -0.030685218051075935, -0.03773842379450798, 0.06374163925647736, 0.031152872368693352, 0.06997787207365036, -0.0075065563432872295, 0.007737993262708187, -0.05354540795087814, 0.04737113043665886, -0.026246758177876472, 0.07619787007570267, -0.01134188286960125, 0.017912475392222404, 0.030904879793524742, -0.05707788094878197, 0.007147066295146942, -0.01813015714287758, 0.01936505362391472, -0.005389762111008167, -0.01605965755879879, -0.040689434856176376, -0.008516709320247173, -0.019187385216355324, 0.004185236059129238, 0.08237560838460922, -0.010751399211585522, -0.037844546139240265, -0.0033087069168686867, -0.002976971911266446, -0.04832109808921814, 0.0024616739246994257, 0.01047562900930643, 0.015902763232588768, 0.016829485073685646, -0.02316795475780964, -0.04208960756659508, 0.009493118152022362, -0.05179202929139137, -0.004262118600308895, 0.03135595843195915, 0.0697687417268753, 0.06758230924606323, 0.029994037002325058, 0.027679041028022766, 0.012990698218345642, 0.019379517063498497, -0.01597503386437893, -0.03255645930767059, -0.053801681846380234, 0.0371759757399559, -0.01124677062034607, 0.048588577657938004, 0.03859533369541168, -0.011951664462685585, -0.03410971537232399, -0.07369159907102585, -0.03525492921471596, 0.061384256929159164, 0.02305133454501629, 0.009389440529048443, -0.014422142878174782, 0.03606604039669037, -0.0928429365158081, 0.01696854829788208, 0.02804870530962944, 0.010373560711741447, 0.012134900316596031, -0.03452515974640846, 0.02862340770661831, 0.0119465421885252, 0.009725207462906837, -0.05080114305019379, 0.0451505184173584, -0.03328895568847656, -0.04404371604323387, 0.026595504954457283, 0.023730197921395302, -0.026649856939911842, -0.006205772515386343, -0.01613394357264042, -0.02528105303645134, -0.03298638388514519, 0.025575142353773117, 0.017088361084461212, -0.012599391862750053, 0.04489700868725777, 0.008236326277256012, 0.038409337401390076, -0.004535035230219364, 0.0852913185954094, -0.012120094150304794, -0.007392413914203644, 0.0420183427631855, 0.07145756483078003, -0.06487935036420822, -0.05035950243473053, -0.02303219959139824, -0.01660703308880329, -0.018954643979668617, -0.04428694397211075, 0.025853481143712997, 0.025077110156416893, 0.02352982573211193, -0.04279405251145363, 0.005368387326598167, 0.003502540523186326, 0.005894828122109175, -0.0123407868668437, 0.01047113910317421, 0.040246088057756424, -0.08511632680892944, -0.02588614635169506, 0.0169539637863636, -0.021641379222273827, 0.02397223934531212, -0.027154020965099335, -0.003235240699723363, 0.05426681414246559, 0.024933265522122383, -0.050273556262254715, -0.033736445009708405, 0.021177232265472412, -0.03595179319381714, -0.01807960867881775, -0.02995583973824978, 0.05499747768044472, -0.01427221205085516, 0.014805730432271957, -0.00623305793851614, -0.03070981614291668, 0.03199782595038414, 0.054871875792741776, -0.04527347534894943, 0.0051910290494561195, 0.02618831768631935, 0.035470470786094666, 0.0031353372614830732, 0.04669659212231636, 0.0040580700151622295, -0.03939150646328926, 0.043124161660671234, -0.004531259182840586, 0.014187876135110855, 0.0396852046251297, 0.03395289182662964, 0.016704795882105827, 0.08492764830589294, 0.04349462315440178, 0.05592973530292511, -0.0174208115786314, -0.015397407114505768, 0.033585745841264725, 0.005711830221116543, 0.0047259884886443615, -0.0026134257204830647, -0.048199985176324844, -0.006555162835866213, -0.0053238822147250175, 0.05913040041923523, -0.047516435384750366, -0.03728025034070015, 0.007620631717145443, 0.0396488755941391, 0.01832807995378971, -0.007134286221116781, -0.0720682442188263, 0.020616821944713593, 0.02542915940284729, -0.07598530501127243, 0.0274098739027977, -0.05552350729703903, -0.03853106126189232, 0.04295773804187775, -0.02329794131219387, 0.08166373521089554, -0.02369983121752739, 0.02961575984954834, 0.0272945798933506, -0.033755604177713394, 0.019415318965911865, -0.06022723764181137, 0.010286937467753887, -0.08309248834848404, 0.007649688981473446, -0.013893237337470055, -0.019689900800585747, 0.09161999821662903, -0.03492520749568939, -0.07723444700241089, 0.026867913082242012, -0.04875016584992409, -0.024480057880282402, -0.03332129120826721, -0.029147088527679443, -0.03148914501070976, 0.017365416511893272, 0.1068057045340538, -0.03244868665933609, -0.028035791590809822, 0.1037496030330658, -0.05804989114403725, 0.017640218138694763, 0.022244567051529884, -0.03513389080762863, 0.0017851460725069046, -0.0069047026336193085, -0.09691738337278366, 0.04781613126397133, 0.029497267678380013, -0.036138251423835754, 0.016499118879437447, 0.043509673327207565, 0.02470742166042328, 0.02709406614303589, 0.022351639345288277, 0.051301851868629456, 0.06434900313615799, 0.0025929014664143324, 0.05773719400167465, -0.05400802940130234, -0.034276824444532394, -0.0038912042509764433, 0.007961688563227654, 0.038321755826473236, 0.03923380747437477, 0.031970273703336716, -0.025266675278544426, 0.01636679284274578, -0.007159052416682243, 0.008111031726002693, -0.06210678815841675, -0.021866977214813232, 0.004785972181707621, 0.028593560680747032, 0.032905738800764084, -0.0069327522069215775, 0.06329666078090668, 0.059755731374025345, -0.01927793398499489, 0.017934242263436317, 0.04566851630806923, 0.013203090988099575, 0.028849801048636436, 0.007380891125649214, 0.01548495702445507, 0.03859037533402443, -0.018646908923983574, -0.0007569916779175401, 0.03703148290514946, 0.007633413653820753, -0.013945164158940315, -6.337502418318763e-05, -0.05076800659298897, 0.022452127188444138, 0.004927420523017645, -0.0192427858710289, -0.051005616784095764, -0.009568416513502598, -0.008153853937983513, 0.014284539967775345, 0.03869260475039482, -0.02273985743522644, 0.03256162628531456, -0.009270989336073399, -0.005418798886239529, 0.051305919885635376, 0.019137253984808922, -0.04167983680963516, -0.018346739932894707, 0.06167754530906677, 0.018129993230104446, 0.015934128314256668, 0.013317003846168518, -0.031915467232465744, -0.016985490918159485, 0.019093329086899757, -0.03709466755390167, -0.006574045866727829, 0.009168035350739956, -0.01923043094575405, 0.05505649745464325, 0.01774570159614086, 0.03495637699961662, -0.02969099022448063, 0.0036908751353621483, -0.033920276910066605, -0.005773611832410097, -0.04330805689096451, -0.0936424657702446, 0.034956954419612885, 0.038198646157979965, -0.021730689331889153, -0.018345706164836884, 0.0027467587497085333, -0.004308899398893118, -0.04720982536673546, -0.0022230208851397038, 0.030882246792316437, -0.003442003857344389, 0.018784062936902046, 0.0044679599814116955, -0.030640777200460434, -0.09007629007101059, 0.013464154675602913, 0.0501493476331234, 0.004476443864405155, -0.09685768187046051, 0.05373017117381096, 0.016120536252856255, -0.030086157843470573, -0.011860830709338188, 0.0643351599574089, 0.07767117023468018, 0.027670789510011673, -0.05753732845187187, -0.10716534405946732, 0.02875618264079094, 0.028457753360271454, 0.03669692948460579, -0.01699688471853733, -0.0740460753440857, -0.023178990930318832, 0.021170124411582947, -0.01236539613455534, -0.007068783976137638, 0.03823651000857353, -0.010446603409945965, -0.02424640581011772, 0.005252520553767681, 0.021140364930033684, 0.011172138154506683, 0.032959431409835815, -0.022552844136953354, 0.05276995897293091, -0.007203361019492149, -0.058448176831007004, -0.019059082493185997, -0.03791751340031624, -0.04358448460698128, 0.02225452847778797, 0.0025441099423915148, -0.02839922159910202, -0.023746591061353683, 0.02278558909893036, -0.01841527782380581, -0.03826938942074776, 0.037829525768756866, 0.01365196518599987, -0.04151983931660652, -0.028252052143216133, 0.028480958193540573, 0.0008527719182893634, 0.06401903927326202, 0.013386186212301254, -0.039204031229019165, -0.0067409672774374485, 0.010743748396635056, 0.006478058639913797, -0.03452111408114433, 0.011979049071669579, -0.03244305029511452, -0.036700982600450516, -0.01715613715350628, 0.007953670807182789, 0.006894121877849102, -0.012692548334598541, 0.04320937767624855, -0.0491909384727478, 0.004755321424454451, -0.029849562793970108, 0.07052319496870041, -2.3303348370973254e-06, -0.03715241327881813, -0.050286464393138885, 0.02528005838394165, -0.03756185248494148, -0.055992573499679565, 0.07920271158218384, -0.035354916006326675, -0.01206861063838005, 0.00645135622471571, 0.0006528524099849164, 0.009035466238856316, 0.013886031694710255, 0.020766250789165497, 0.028903262689709663, -0.018549103289842606, -0.06662845611572266, -0.01659497804939747, 0.0320529043674469, 0.058258309960365295, 0.020824499428272247, 0.020220745354890823, 0.021418552845716476, 0.035165879875421524, -0.020650360733270645, 0.04611566662788391, -0.04118041321635246, -0.0013328666100278497, -0.006586918607354164, -0.043583087623119354, -0.0012742788530886173, 0.039461493492126465, -0.06095917522907257, 0.05129135027527809, -0.062408871948719025, 0.039776697754859924, 0.016301875934004784, 0.009750807657837868, -0.036109380424022675, -0.05554104596376419, -0.015673929825425148, 0.029153862968087196, -0.017866747453808784, 0.019958214834332466, 0.03101522848010063, 0.017071500420570374, 0.02263498678803444, 0.006375045981258154, -0.04505053535103798, -0.0382179357111454, 0.0035527304280549288, 0.07703635841608047, 0.041291140019893646, -0.016258450224995613, 0.018679877743124962, 0.07145930826663971, -0.02329098805785179, -0.03849511966109276, -0.008274720050394535, 0.0021945214830338955, -0.0454399511218071, 0.01233062706887722, -0.04032115265727043, -0.01688031479716301, 0.029182489961385727, 0.02873591147363186, -0.0025426375214010477, -0.007148473523557186, 0.011991037987172604, 0.015239357948303223, -0.03984854370355606, 0.003951116930693388, -0.009645299054682255, -0.02816759981215, 0.10513759404420853, 0.017701946198940277, -0.0014139998238533735, -0.02186465449631214, 0.017279572784900665, 0.014256228692829609, -0.011572151444852352, 0.008543970063328743, -0.02096170000731945, 0.0709480568766594, 0.03728557750582695, 0.054559092968702316, 0.0008236832218244672, -0.003012770786881447, -0.0080978162586689, -0.00017025218403432518, -0.03516432270407677, -0.0384281761944294, 0.027915561571717262, -0.030422747135162354, -5.7306958560479204e-33, 0.038090940564870834, -0.07372027635574341, -0.05108927935361862, -0.003092850325629115, 0.03895935043692589, -0.05423910915851593, 0.014174911193549633, 0.0463220477104187, -0.008180961944162846, -0.05918639525771141, -0.00994001142680645, 0.008063577115535736, -0.007588021457195282, -0.009138671681284904, -0.01865791529417038, -0.00768809299916029, -0.04064854979515076, 0.0008975542732514441, -0.022508110851049423, -0.04806060343980789, 0.0014444945845752954, 0.01869090646505356, -0.031242378056049347, 0.009189271368086338, -0.09483107179403305, 0.0266385767608881, -0.004064627923071384, -0.02337999828159809, -0.03287709131836891, -0.01002356968820095, -0.010021697729825974, -0.02393426187336445, -0.0011112153297290206, -0.027188001200556755, 0.0449257493019104, 0.008547195233404636, 0.0015074489638209343, -0.0026972778141498566, -0.05906683951616287, 0.04052611440420151, 0.022794242948293686, -0.048054639250040054, 0.07050661742687225, -0.054000165313482285, -0.03104320727288723, -0.026046022772789, 0.04830533266067505, -0.06075634807348251, -0.022433701902627945, 0.026795770972967148, -0.04717618599534035, -0.009501844644546509, 0.004691087640821934, -0.020921489223837852, 0.036106694489717484, -0.004569484386593103, 0.011441469192504883, 0.010727857239544392, -0.01754954271018505, 0.026179209351539612, 0.05296963080763817, 0.0045682587660849094, -0.02668146602809429, 0.049235474318265915, 0.09042008221149445, -0.0117630735039711, 0.03798019886016846, -0.03871150314807892, 0.020991895347833633, -0.013154128566384315, -0.0050843385979533195, 0.029019828885793686, 0.04371001571416855, -0.016333654522895813, 0.022631820291280746, -0.023929713293910027, 0.012496924959123135, 0.04197828844189644, -0.062285542488098145, 0.009553082287311554, -0.0560552179813385, -0.02053077518939972, -0.033919207751750946, 0.023158397525548935, 0.08312969654798508, -0.016853725537657738, -0.024756353348493576, -0.006737064570188522, -0.0007290602661669254, -0.021874798461794853, -0.04568827524781227, 0.009002537466585636, -0.05694034323096275, -0.010141873732209206, 0.05621783807873726, -0.06876415759325027, 0.007237913552671671, 0.05955568701028824, 0.002731302520260215, -0.025041047483682632, 0.017203882336616516, -0.027916936203837395, -0.014840543270111084, -0.0001426205417374149, 0.016280004754662514, -0.0092961136251688, 0.011946539394557476, -0.02856910601258278, 0.04080289974808693, 0.013558846898376942, 0.028682762756943703, -0.05051347240805626, 0.010974619537591934, -0.0036825300194323063, -0.003773294622078538, -0.025199469178915024, 0.0049600787460803986, 0.001070298021659255, 0.02634281851351261, -0.045755498111248016, -0.05452783778309822, -0.007127760443836451, -0.044067636132240295, -0.009612353518605232, -0.05706368386745453, 0.02588004246354103, -0.06351595371961594, 0.027522636577486992, -0.05934524908661842, -0.017104152590036392, -0.05000193417072296, 0.019104566425085068, 2.6718180379248224e-07, -0.014824056066572666, 0.05034791678190231, 0.0113963158801198, -0.02067558653652668, -0.04325750470161438, 0.01750345341861248, -0.027027880772948265, 0.006749001331627369, -0.0014823456294834614, -0.012493387795984745, 0.016281671822071075, -0.06064508855342865, 0.0041970666497945786, -0.03328271210193634, -0.008321917615830898, -0.0005802363739348948, 0.04249921441078186, 0.02907922863960266, -0.004684428684413433, 0.10016810894012451, 0.0007973728352226317, 0.06105979159474373, 0.04870744049549103, 0.0053731417283415794, 0.01672951877117157, -0.0017939240206032991, -0.00016665698785800487, 0.016462817788124084, 0.031618379056453705, -0.002493396634235978, -0.011980690062046051, 0.06792012602090836, -0.05943543463945389, 0.007672308944165707, -0.010610446333885193, 0.014278609305620193, 0.028592128306627274, -0.04148133099079132, -0.01907644048333168, 0.05630796402692795, 0.05682928487658501, 0.03276059031486511, 0.037276800721883774, -0.044002678245306015, 0.025775905698537827, 0.0026141470298171043, -0.06357064843177795, 0.04240979254245758, 0.010083815082907677, 0.01603027433156967, -0.08129995316267014, 0.005225454457104206, -0.06238527595996857, -0.017907263711094856, -0.024882610887289047, -0.03101649321615696, 0.012681592255830765, -0.004942998290061951, 0.05334848165512085, 0.0125203188508749, 0.016926122829318047, 0.03420604392886162, -0.025613611564040184, -0.026843823492527008, 0.0798524022102356, 0.04227456450462341, -0.014201601967215538, 1.8857585728915862e-34, -0.03012530319392681, 0.030943194404244423, -0.035043999552726746, -0.010593662038445473, -0.017845865339040756, 0.026818586513400078, -0.012527051381766796, -0.013735650107264519, 0.015143678523600101, 0.033163052052259445, -0.017119014635682106]
691
691
['Sue Han Lee', 'Chee Seng Chan', 'Paul Wilkin', 'Paolo Remagnino']
1506.08425v1
This paper studies convolutional neural networks (CNN) to learn unsupervised feature representations for 44 different plant species, collected at the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, England. To gain intuition on the chosen features from the CNN model (opposed to a 'black box' solution), a visualisation technique based on the deconvolutional networks (DN) is utilized. It is found that venations of different order have been chosen to uniquely represent each of the plant species. Experimental results using these CNN features with different classifiers show consistency and superiority compared to the state-of-the art solutions which rely on hand-crafted features.
Deep-Plant: Plant Identification with convolutional neural networks
2,015
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1506.08425v1
Title DeepPlant Plant Identification convolutional neural network Summary paper study convolutional neural network CNN learn unsupervised feature representation 44 different plant specie collected Royal Botanic Gardens Kew England gain intuition chosen feature CNN model opposed black box solution visualisation technique based deconvolutional network DN utilized found venation different order chosen uniquely represent plant specie Experimental result using CNN feature different classifier show consistency superiority compared stateofthe art solution rely handcrafted feature Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.006776423193514347, 0.017540596425533295, -0.013493082486093044, 0.09937453269958496, -0.015553660690784454, -0.001622108044102788, 0.02896924503147602, 0.015895109623670578, -0.029217569157481194, 0.021072691306471825, 0.00834373477846384, 0.033706702291965485, -0.00636943057179451, 0.03164862096309662, -0.004153152462095022, -0.01186476182192564, -0.03399576246738434, 0.027491280809044838, 0.02510054223239422, -0.0332333967089653, -0.006542478688061237, 0.004884540569037199, 0.005666360259056091, 0.0405256524682045, -0.09127219766378403, -0.010085362941026688, -0.013601613231003284, 0.04156212881207466, 0.028146130964159966, -0.0036231130361557007, 0.02483411878347397, -0.0012811803026124835, -0.018415285274386406, 0.0451512411236763, 1.8308194285054924e-06, -0.018171237781643867, -0.01907123625278473, -0.0028632055036723614, 0.0040632388554513454, -0.004215434193611145, -0.035590313374996185, 0.05321534723043442, -0.026334550231695175, -0.06383898109197617, 0.004177014343440533, -0.007491494528949261, 0.06279248744249344, 0.05102607235312462, -0.033484820276498795, 0.00402085529640317, 0.014659000560641289, -0.04375249147415161, 0.017756866291165352, -0.006665039341896772, -0.014666981995105743, -0.03308500349521637, 0.02058234252035618, -0.004259007051587105, -0.038909055292606354, 0.02380361035466194, -0.04375622048974037, 0.06708824634552002, 0.023845648393034935, -0.037059083580970764, 0.01909494400024414, 0.020782042294740677, -0.0063403295353055, -0.045160625129938126, 0.0261567123234272, 0.07458464801311493, -0.08007664233446121, -0.0013424501521512866, -0.003502817125990987, -0.009449212811887264, -0.06702098995447159, -0.02602401189506054, -0.012763912789523602, 0.03363146632909775, 0.03683779761195183, -0.05085198953747749, -0.02152399718761444, 0.04916379228234291, -0.020033134147524834, -0.0007445670198649168, -0.006273466628044844, -0.022378774359822273, 0.006861263886094093, 0.02821780927479267, 0.008434111252427101, -0.08880451321601868, 0.015023946762084961, -0.04731401056051254, 0.007272784598171711, 0.010560685768723488, -0.03657953441143036, -0.035121120512485504, 0.04734089970588684, -0.03571118786931038, 0.06475506722927094, 0.02031926065683365, 0.02369651198387146, 0.0180146973580122, -0.09528999030590057, 0.02226313017308712, -0.05397404357790947, 0.06743238121271133, -0.03302784264087677, 0.07455721497535706, 0.0065558296628296375, 0.0002427397994324565, -0.06321750581264496, -0.022479157894849777, -0.00315764918923378, 0.020289815962314606, -0.015028867870569229, 0.0019933818839490414, 0.014412390999495983, -0.03489508107304573, -0.03993204981088638, 0.004560573026537895, 0.0027059055864810944, 0.051180437207221985, -0.02939828298985958, 0.0289913360029459, -0.020628582686185837, 0.053649742156267166, -0.003720305161550641, -0.022052081301808357, 0.0318317785859108, -0.03148511052131653, 0.018363306298851967, 0.027718650177121162, 0.020471511408686638, 0.01089097373187542, 0.02610885538160801, 0.0062148720026016235, 0.044999390840530396, -0.03521658852696419, 0.028534555807709694, -0.05698293074965477, 0.018488841131329536, -0.033444084227085114, 0.014046398922801018, 0.0039232391864061356, 0.011993791908025742, -0.04194846749305725, 0.021655267104506493, -0.02366744913160801, -0.021451761946082115, -0.049265775829553604, 0.007622189354151487, 0.08807983994483948, 0.006074597127735615, 0.008366155438125134, 0.05274935066699982, -0.025578513741493225, 0.01133822463452816, -0.0085914246737957, -0.029903186485171318, 0.12298595160245895, -0.027365028858184814, -0.044834479689598083, 0.012357210740447044, -0.036912113428115845, -0.05663721635937691, -0.04720544070005417, -0.022803645581007004, -0.009311114437878132, -0.005777419079095125, 0.000953418668359518, -0.0480559878051281, 0.020295051857829094, 0.024879613891243935, 0.00883010309189558, 0.004033834207803011, 0.10630101710557938, 0.048102665692567825, -0.004681981168687344, 0.056338220834732056, 0.029318561777472496, -0.006406447384506464, -0.033517707139253616, -0.03857536241412163, 0.05873657763004303, -0.05082876980304718, -0.0005143141024746001, -0.10038473457098007, -0.03541339188814163, -0.011655952781438828, -0.05364784225821495, -0.01109454594552517, -0.042150359600782394, -0.04419593885540962, 0.006373168900609016, 0.032353293150663376, 0.012025546282529831, 0.01903463900089264, -0.05306052789092064, -0.01607825793325901, 0.0007706703618168831, -0.04518841207027435, -0.02623051404953003, 0.07162400335073471, -0.019144635647535324, -0.013686680234968662, -0.06014363840222359, 0.03831162676215172, 0.034122396260499954, -0.011543569155037403, 0.03704483062028885, -0.006725266110152006, -0.05931929871439934, -0.003957927227020264, 0.012496977113187313, -0.005842947401106358, -0.005419813096523285, -0.04622534289956093, 0.029037976637482643, -0.030003109946846962, -0.01504585612565279, 0.01817435212433338, 0.023960690945386887, 0.03945649787783623, 0.010815521702170372, 0.04009455069899559, -0.059195179492235184, 0.015076476149260998, 0.03806842863559723, 0.002306110691279173, 0.006795415189117193, 0.0185617133975029, 0.008514723740518093, 0.051563192158937454, 0.007527846843004227, -0.011602133512496948, -0.03438638150691986, 0.025776004418730736, 0.02945503406226635, 0.022497721016407013, 0.0015640213387086987, -0.03788347542285919, 0.026218261569738388, -0.028286246582865715, -0.03284478187561035, 0.013516891747713089, 0.02027544006705284, 0.021187931299209595, -0.008758911862969398, 0.05683870241045952, -0.031020401045680046, -0.02312549576163292, -0.004817554261535406, 0.02313762716948986, 0.003540225327014923, 0.04520973563194275, -0.023808466270565987, -0.054938726127147675, 0.009637363255023956, -0.017259346321225166, -0.0014283392811194062, -0.023105591535568237, -0.07626987248659134, 0.00925812590867281, -0.010153909213840961, 0.053071342408657074, -0.01277555525302887, 0.009934630244970322, -0.0017220770241692662, -0.002390434266999364, 0.005987207405269146, -0.062343571335077286, -0.0009917495772242546, -0.016433697193861008, 0.038097988814115524, -0.03279909864068031, -0.007372260559350252, 0.10413020849227905, -0.06399243324995041, -0.03801751136779785, 0.05949050933122635, -2.80036692856811e-05, -0.024433190003037453, -0.045912135392427444, -0.00950692780315876, -0.007245998363941908, 0.05117917060852051, 0.00826782826334238, -0.05343910679221153, 0.031679168343544006, 0.015335106290876865, 0.024035092443227768, 0.05507393181324005, 0.03381648659706116, -0.030160758644342422, 0.011980541050434113, 0.0010660135885700583, -0.05224594101309776, 0.04121217876672745, -0.005547761917114258, -0.0004472557338885963, 0.037660978734493256, 0.08244780451059341, -0.007775759324431419, -0.0002026650618063286, -0.01259725634008646, 0.04511695355176926, 0.07064416259527206, 0.01325281336903572, -0.010033804923295975, 0.005543465260416269, -0.028100090101361275, -0.014097431674599648, 0.04932528734207153, 0.011546842753887177, 0.03570805490016937, 0.08937698602676392, -0.04329565167427063, 0.0021739599760621786, 0.04765148088335991, 0.011311965063214302, -0.023233961313962936, -0.0640937015414238, -0.012902859598398209, -8.817863999865949e-05, -0.001714453799650073, -0.07131949067115784, -0.051111385226249695, 0.0557287223637104, 0.07197722047567368, 0.025245632976293564, 0.027691667899489403, 0.025880027562379837, 0.026868261396884918, -0.016020921990275383, 0.02678442746400833, -0.021733161062002182, -0.03762882575392723, 0.008636489510536194, -0.022264854982495308, 0.024765070527791977, -0.05419041961431503, 0.0011058110976591706, -0.020707489922642708, -0.03681063652038574, -0.013951355591416359, 0.03953117877244949, 0.012391596101224422, 0.007296939380466938, 0.029706375673413277, 0.03150034323334694, -0.002664883155375719, 0.009062258526682854, -0.010710600763559341, 0.019167166203260422, -0.054462239146232605, 0.07337858527898788, 0.015870405361056328, -0.027876263484358788, -0.024788258597254753, 0.06624578684568405, 0.057516347616910934, -0.01259315013885498, -0.08604560792446136, 0.006734008900821209, -0.03422177955508232, -0.014921207912266254, -0.051174961030483246, 0.006144750397652388, 0.004364021588116884, -0.0024355235509574413, 0.018472881987690926, -0.01485593430697918, 0.013754992745816708, 0.03320661559700966, -0.013433198444545269, -0.06668834388256073, 0.0015850794734433293, -0.015404810197651386, -0.05409637838602066, 0.04329535365104675, 0.010621937923133373, 0.02643566019833088, 0.005740166641771793, -0.015873068943619728, -0.06157092750072479, -0.02673746645450592, -0.017275718972086906, -0.021278556436300278, -0.04632245749235153, -0.024504652246832848, -0.033839523792266846, -0.038219112902879715, -0.01524894218891859, -0.005969308316707611, -0.02618960291147232, 0.004254886880517006, -0.002605919260531664, 0.00880830641835928, 0.022248636931180954, -0.013354641385376453, 0.045196209102869034, 0.01834557205438614, 0.0311855748295784, 0.006450749468058348, -0.04046643525362015, -0.03717841953039169, 0.04809540882706642, 0.025631286203861237, -0.002909085014835, -0.02563498169183731, 0.046871308237314224, -0.008481050841510296, 0.013284054584801197, -0.010856589302420616, 0.053792085498571396, 0.05726327374577522, 0.00024470704374834895, 0.03250310942530632, 0.0007904419908300042, 0.015655694529414177, -0.013024358078837395, -0.016701528802514076, 0.057675860822200775, 0.040061213076114655, 0.001945076510310173, -0.036460116505622864, 0.015311131253838539, 0.02189669944345951, -0.03759217634797096, 0.08051177859306335, -0.004877678584307432, -0.08855815976858139, -0.011694750748574734, 0.039254117757081985, -0.0035931195598095655, 0.007488617207854986, 0.04123148322105408, -0.030103735625743866, -0.02586553990840912, -0.024859998375177383, 0.014110606163740158, 0.017277901992201805, 0.048022281378507614, -0.00011284120409982279, -0.01749645732343197, -0.024133574217557907, -0.05896363407373428, -0.018734939396381378, 0.013969166204333305, 0.059763360768556595, 0.01567137986421585, -0.020912593230605125, -0.016901502385735512, 0.09815242886543274, 0.015093399211764336, 0.014138776808977127, -0.052118562161922455, -0.06325937807559967, 0.018230004236102104, -0.008971277624368668, 0.01834704913198948, 0.002431218745186925, -0.030590247362852097, -0.021606678143143654, -0.07992120832204819, -0.017464905977249146, -0.04790501296520233, -0.0002498689864296466, -0.005770111456513405, -0.014300815761089325, -0.07142113149166107, -0.011155730113387108, 0.0227119792252779, 0.0047387899830937386, 0.07499103248119354, 0.05635669827461243, -0.027028346434235573, -0.0009364048019051552, -0.005054575856775045, 0.04213465377688408, 0.03436677157878876, 0.06301195174455643, 0.06530728191137314, 0.04331933706998825, 0.02562779374420643, 0.02898436412215233, 0.044010236859321594, -0.032894983887672424, 0.05636204779148102, -0.05298009142279625, -0.0036857742816209793, 0.027218561619520187, 0.0006743614794686437, -0.047761235386133194, 0.04460352286696434, -0.010537954047322273, 0.029009228572249413, -0.006923026405274868, 0.024344906210899353, 0.03672773018479347, -0.06097472831606865, 0.0017574289813637733, 0.012166991829872131, -0.0043113576248288155, 0.01509099081158638, 0.06344505399465561, -0.010845493525266647, -0.02539229393005371, -0.01969701424241066, -0.02091350220143795, -0.08262329548597336, 0.01566130481660366, 0.04240009933710098, -0.020187560468912125, -0.02433328703045845, -0.0027880638372153044, 0.032087523490190506, -0.0900367945432663, -0.01782028190791607, 0.04409688338637352, 0.01495086494833231, -0.02015937864780426, -0.010964400134980679, 0.0008386924164369702, -0.005909704603254795, 0.07284921407699585, 0.010474483482539654, -0.0065850792452692986, -0.008673334494233131, 0.02011072263121605, 0.055367741733789444, -0.05558526888489723, -0.009692816063761711, 0.004026707261800766, -0.013048973865807056, 0.06502784788608551, -0.014733095653355122, -0.002954453229904175, 0.014877434819936752, 0.00010110690345754847, 0.02621612511575222, -0.03354251757264137, 0.014490444213151932, 0.022942695766687393, 0.07277622073888779, 0.02478686161339283, -0.03934696689248085, -0.004845726769417524, 0.026474319398403168, -0.09152665734291077, -0.003358118701726198, -0.01649164780974388, -0.012346869334578514, -0.018821528181433678, -0.030893998220562935, -5.429048209921582e-33, 0.03568015247583389, -0.06248116120696068, -0.04550836235284805, -0.05010389909148216, 0.01935998909175396, 0.054071590304374695, 0.0027677647303789854, -0.02677043154835701, -0.005742221605032682, 0.04017753526568413, 0.03485875949263573, -0.001802291488274932, 0.015854723751544952, -0.009409347549080849, 0.03809675574302673, 0.001209554960951209, -0.001978326356038451, 0.013289263471961021, 0.019071362912654877, 0.028289588168263435, 0.029517019167542458, 0.024148067459464073, 0.06934018433094025, -0.060160551220178604, -0.022932346910238266, 0.0011296923039481044, 0.030246686190366745, -0.01753629744052887, -0.029610976576805115, 0.018447820097208023, 0.011774335987865925, -0.005841102451086044, -0.00367620843462646, -0.020707957446575165, -0.025333372876048088, -0.021468162536621094, -0.036297429352998734, -0.021885601803660393, -0.08405346423387527, 0.018078749999403954, -0.025000905618071556, -0.003744079265743494, -0.004355969373136759, -0.05134959518909454, 0.007648786995559931, -0.05243661627173424, 0.05964008718729019, -0.04215406998991966, -0.01574051007628441, -0.06807836890220642, -0.032136134803295135, 0.011818851344287395, -0.03153848648071289, -0.002576021011918783, 0.05369718372821808, -0.019711164757609367, 0.015160239301621914, 0.03390365093946457, 0.010206871666014194, 0.011833542957901955, 0.037225835025310516, 0.006495878100395203, 0.018690655007958412, 0.07797420024871826, 0.007146122865378857, 0.008036354556679726, 0.04202885925769806, -0.0513404905796051, -0.01755271665751934, -0.05892494320869446, -0.04641834646463394, 0.03886640444397926, 0.10260087996721268, -0.0324036180973053, 0.06306002289056778, -0.04744388163089752, -0.024693915620446205, 0.03752932697534561, -0.04469859227538109, 0.011210961267352104, -0.042884912341833115, 0.024617992341518402, 0.009985433891415596, 0.02526063658297062, 0.02578539215028286, -0.007858938537538052, -0.017095215618610382, -0.02260214276611805, 0.025517839938402176, -0.05388396233320236, -0.01721430942416191, -0.019056696444749832, -0.04681667685508728, -0.06426697969436646, 0.04576947167515755, -0.029452553018927574, -0.03050890564918518, 0.05680856853723526, 0.00691869854927063, -0.013820509426295757, -0.024772310629487038, -0.03363804146647453, 0.004599766805768013, 0.04963383823633194, 0.002576547907665372, 0.03770899772644043, 0.03269235044717789, 0.025497114285826683, -0.0013720656279474497, -0.025178229436278343, 0.006540908012539148, -0.06727368384599686, 0.014772261492908001, 0.010227651335299015, -0.020252522081136703, -0.04404524713754654, 0.023158596828579903, 0.04871772974729538, 0.05961139500141144, -0.0008525045122951269, 0.006797892972826958, -0.026704218238592148, 0.030496668070554733, -0.008580496534705162, -0.06110437959432602, -0.0013699069386348128, -0.036599885672330856, 0.032478172332048416, -0.013539325445890427, 0.013599816709756851, 0.03226541355252266, 0.008270060643553734, 2.569423429577e-07, 0.0002992157533299178, -0.034350018948316574, 0.059180352836847305, -0.05340487137436867, -0.02690964937210083, -0.03165289759635925, -0.02351422607898712, -0.020464865490794182, -0.11719883233308792, -0.04132338613271713, 0.07266584038734436, -0.07094626128673553, 0.021083246916532516, -0.041501305997371674, -0.019453855231404305, -0.005294065922498703, -0.032566510140895844, 0.00874719675630331, -0.04190097376704216, 0.02333703264594078, -0.008164082653820515, 0.08912153542041779, -0.0012845194432884455, -0.011389471590518951, 0.022285273298621178, 0.03525393828749657, -0.0026178976986557245, -0.08507579565048218, 0.05043886974453926, -0.0059166098944842815, 0.027227018028497696, -0.07060454785823822, 0.007971364073455334, 0.03541766107082367, -0.0013822208857163787, 0.06776167452335358, 0.00822890643030405, 0.005120610818266869, -0.05059894919395447, 0.029157191514968872, 0.029057908803224564, -0.004977780394256115, 0.07107183337211609, -0.05402439460158348, 0.02139921300113201, 0.039596281945705414, -0.035019416362047195, -0.03576289489865303, 0.03774695098400116, 0.04902053624391556, 0.03401552513241768, -0.01075687725096941, -0.010865478776395321, -0.008818701840937138, -0.007860754616558552, -0.06279729306697845, 0.006369422189891338, -0.04021123796701431, 0.07119036465883255, -0.009110191836953163, -0.020929453894495964, 0.012985353358089924, -0.0008037033840082586, -0.040406618267297745, 0.05096583813428879, 0.027997039258480072, -0.03669093921780586, 2.1848034173858145e-34, -0.0414060540497303, 0.013794785365462303, -0.003685746341943741, 0.006466348189860582, -0.06358367949724197, 0.030191201716661453, 0.04633427411317825, -0.003358877496793866, -0.02003134973347187, -0.0057188537903130054, -0.05067458376288414]
692
692
['Joshua C. Peterson', 'Joshua T. Abbott', 'Thomas L. Griffiths']
1608.02164v1
Deep neural networks have become increasingly successful at solving classic perception problems such as object recognition, semantic segmentation, and scene understanding, often reaching or surpassing human-level accuracy. This success is due in part to the ability of DNNs to learn useful representations of high-dimensional inputs, a problem that humans must also solve. We examine the relationship between the representations learned by these networks and human psychological representations recovered from similarity judgments. We find that deep features learned in service of object classification account for a significant amount of the variance in human similarity judgments for a set of animal images. However, these features do not capture some qualitative distinctions that are a key part of human representations. To remedy this, we develop a method for adapting deep features to align with human similarity judgments, resulting in image representations that can potentially be used to extend the scope of psychological experiments.
Adapting Deep Network Features to Capture Psychological Representations
2,016
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1608.02164v1
Title Adapting Deep Network Features Capture Psychological Representations Summary Deep neural network become increasingly successful solving classic perception problem object recognition semantic segmentation scene understanding often reaching surpassing humanlevel accuracy success due part ability DNNs learn useful representation highdimensional input problem human must also solve examine relationship representation learned network human psychological representation recovered similarity judgment find deep feature learned service object classification account significant amount variance human similarity judgment set animal image However feature capture qualitative distinction key part human representation remedy develop method adapting deep feature align human similarity judgment resulting image representation potentially used extend scope psychological experiment Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.013091064058244228, 0.07363045960664749, -0.03308088704943657, 0.0372568815946579, -0.01791868545114994, 0.02727382630109787, 0.03783806413412094, 0.00030163361225277185, -0.021288791671395302, -0.01098821684718132, -0.06715395301580429, -0.002083749743178487, 0.015625564381480217, 0.05016550421714783, 0.012282148003578186, -0.09944529831409454, -0.03597528114914894, 0.08667001873254776, -0.012709474191069603, -0.0013389369705691934, -0.013358726166188717, -0.004933038726449013, 0.030816858634352684, 0.03767271339893341, -0.03956177085638046, -0.02107463963329792, 0.008218344300985336, -0.0027796588838100433, 0.01501582469791174, -0.03080097958445549, 0.0031006154604256153, 0.002922167768701911, 0.04808451980352402, 0.0074972608126699924, 2.3048598905006656e-06, -0.07287618517875671, 0.011118989437818527, -0.022056862711906433, 0.02089664340019226, -0.04928738251328468, 0.024704046547412872, -0.029917357489466667, 0.009277462027966976, -0.03680087998509407, -0.03031570464372635, -0.012624514289200306, 0.06509172916412354, 0.10709630697965622, -0.0196470245718956, 0.014365572482347488, -0.026917723938822746, -0.06252194195985794, 0.01023604441434145, 0.0005736347520723939, -0.009962907060980797, 0.025498637929558754, 0.017376331612467766, -0.015671316534280777, -0.033238913863897324, -0.08342365175485611, -0.04994425177574158, -0.008307266980409622, 0.0168051328510046, 0.04752710089087486, 0.04006306827068329, 0.04170992597937584, -0.016246534883975983, -0.03866573050618172, -0.007582962512969971, 0.05253602936863899, -0.05574697256088257, 0.005870269611477852, -0.00911726988852024, -0.0038418304175138474, -0.014813489280641079, 0.009869535453617573, -0.022070057690143585, -0.0035051582381129265, 0.009332753717899323, 0.02477763220667839, -0.04461142048239708, 0.04407859593629837, -0.007313889916986227, 0.014629562385380268, -0.010224918834865093, -0.00997510738670826, 0.01640458032488823, 0.011170882731676102, 0.022856028750538826, -0.013396321795880795, -0.021287014707922935, -0.036047037690877914, 0.02593214437365532, -0.021372631192207336, -0.008009707555174828, -0.03562391176819801, -0.0142583716660738, -0.03263917937874794, 0.010284258984029293, -0.036978933960199356, 0.05083277076482773, -0.001391016412526369, -0.10763371735811234, 0.0042236121371388435, -0.01868920587003231, 0.10228932648897171, -0.06434223800897598, 0.050613414496183395, -0.05984578654170036, 0.025362323969602585, -0.07890259474515915, -0.00435528764501214, 0.012231717817485332, 0.009730502963066101, 0.041117675602436066, -0.041228558868169785, -0.05367310345172882, -0.017879251390695572, -0.05527980625629425, -0.015045123174786568, -0.06117234006524086, 0.080136738717556, -0.017647625878453255, 0.01157468743622303, -0.033875785768032074, 0.020291035994887352, -0.05056535825133324, 0.03762820363044739, -0.01654946058988571, -0.00807290431112051, 0.0710759088397026, 0.025499554350972176, 0.010246321558952332, -0.009728950448334217, 0.034263573586940765, 0.06137663498520851, 0.009568060748279095, 0.0072926608845591545, -0.024506865069270134, -0.0207419041544199, 0.024019496515393257, -0.0076349410228431225, 0.06593909859657288, -0.03689888119697571, 0.00029744196217507124, -0.052775751799345016, -0.010285603813827038, -0.02390904910862446, -0.05378669127821922, -0.02789619378745556, -0.030772048979997635, 0.09447283297777176, -0.028506651520729065, -0.02096310630440712, 0.06485692411661148, 0.007943310774862766, 0.02657332643866539, 0.002680045086890459, 0.0216095931828022, 0.04408721625804901, 0.0011934279464185238, -0.009631683118641376, -0.020586349070072174, -0.03345926105976105, -0.04319010674953461, -0.0434870645403862, -0.026171715930104256, -0.028741655871272087, -0.017217596992850304, 0.07428407669067383, 0.023385439068078995, 0.025120608508586884, -0.004506224300712347, -0.023869100958108902, 0.034430406987667084, 0.09884385019540787, 0.034829165786504745, 0.0843440592288971, -0.0004535304906312376, 0.004503697622567415, -0.011278502643108368, 0.05350460857152939, -0.04864225909113884, 0.07978492230176926, 0.01058623194694519, -0.02275141142308712, -0.06543819606304169, 0.02886473946273327, -0.028790811076760292, -0.019683808088302612, 0.02885274589061737, -0.035640742629766464, 0.013269813731312752, -0.005145838484168053, 0.030588002875447273, 0.0158188845962286, 0.01784251257777214, -0.037550538778305054, 0.008350473828613758, 0.01641579531133175, -0.028344493359327316, -0.0666116252541542, 0.028281565755605698, 0.009472248144447803, -0.009361162781715393, -0.017253147438168526, 0.017541930079460144, -0.006106446497142315, -0.019786324352025986, -0.020811745896935463, 0.035768140107393265, 0.02219892293214798, -0.012224572710692883, -0.008313195779919624, -0.04709535837173462, -0.00804744753986597, 0.01341969147324562, 0.03591025993227959, -0.04267174005508423, -0.0023718110751360655, 0.024369189515709877, 0.04368574172258377, 0.011991669423878193, 0.05716902017593384, 0.030135156586766243, 0.02631961554288864, 0.01035929936915636, 0.05151207000017166, 0.02296026423573494, 0.030420532450079918, 0.011511968448758125, 0.01895255222916603, 0.016558481380343437, -0.01404489018023014, -0.004777624737471342, 0.01660277508199215, -0.04493161290884018, 0.052034877240657806, 0.0063251592218875885, -0.08325126022100449, 0.012258853763341904, 0.0620088055729866, -0.004877543076872826, -0.01133211050182581, 0.04057444632053375, -0.023379378020763397, 0.015048719011247158, -0.004398688208311796, 0.001295542810112238, -0.020416423678398132, 0.04610341787338257, 0.003712780773639679, 0.051566753536462784, 0.018551243469119072, -0.028846552595496178, -0.027012402191758156, -0.02837301976978779, 0.02808542735874653, -0.019692348316311836, 0.007905921898782253, -0.002983260666951537, -0.01666129194200039, -0.008330829441547394, -0.013929114677011967, 0.03697303682565689, -0.05106886476278305, 0.04962662607431412, -0.05482792481780052, 0.00022047467064112425, 0.0075052338652312756, -0.0384930856525898, -7.843329512979835e-05, -0.05834559351205826, 0.02797471359372139, -0.01824711076915264, -0.05688946694135666, 0.07495737075805664, -0.021725719794631004, 0.04904031753540039, 0.04461054131388664, 0.003438571235165, -0.027812613174319267, -0.03358078747987747, -0.02345459721982479, 0.0030323017854243517, 0.060917630791664124, 0.04629147797822952, -0.06027699634432793, -0.0239908155053854, 0.018325025215744972, -0.03650258481502533, 0.02470601350069046, 0.027064893394708633, -0.04765132814645767, 0.03906392678618431, -0.014668560586869717, -0.005533468443900347, 0.10187754780054092, 0.024567391723394394, 0.01669321581721306, 0.04790826514363289, 0.07106362283229828, -0.014985605143010616, -0.05586010590195656, 0.014422794803977013, -0.00999677274376154, 0.028622251003980637, 0.00596699258312583, -0.0020877167116850615, -0.031064698472619057, 0.007505903486162424, -0.006691287737339735, -0.018740924075245857, 0.06699114292860031, 0.036873966455459595, -0.05245542526245117, -0.05381283164024353, -0.04197730869054794, 0.010235605761408806, 0.022822581231594086, -0.028377722948789597, -0.029783353209495544, 0.04466628283262253, 0.05046673119068146, 0.0022613611072301865, 0.024948328733444214, 0.006243374198675156, 0.028449783101677895, 0.054137419909238815, 0.03350906819105148, 0.03451945260167122, -0.0029979266691952944, -0.007943718694150448, -0.07431557029485703, -0.016451595351099968, 0.004936585668474436, -0.012686364352703094, 0.010607215575873852, -0.030970478430390358, -0.03214060515165329, -0.016200052574276924, -0.03319497033953667, -0.05170084163546562, 0.02899639867246151, -0.038832154124975204, 0.026840880513191223, -0.06190522760152817, 0.015762710943818092, -0.014609040692448616, -0.018043745309114456, 0.02256714552640915, 0.011117829009890556, -0.004688948392868042, -0.010114763863384724, 0.021599458530545235, 0.01887013018131256, 0.056743793189525604, 0.026111099869012833, 0.009143861010670662, 0.022831549867987633, 0.018845807760953903, 0.051505591720342636, -0.028156911954283714, -0.005951120518147945, -0.10882119089365005, 0.06580755114555359, -0.020747419446706772, 0.014460323378443718, -0.012749074026942253, -0.0024349999148398638, 0.019840583205223083, -0.022723816335201263, 0.022074535489082336, 0.03775018826127052, -0.0002962766448035836, -0.0956529825925827, 0.02957197278738022, -0.01972896233201027, -0.06675591319799423, 0.011060424149036407, 0.009194626472890377, 0.0035513287875801325, -0.0035596045199781656, -0.010685412213206291, -0.029285838827490807, -0.012657711282372475, -0.040312472730875015, 0.020839255303144455, -0.0236656591296196, 0.006538896355777979, -0.0022711066994816065, -0.05076005682349205, -0.0648874044418335, 0.014137198217213154, 0.013978838920593262, -0.007634415291249752, -0.03118007257580757, -0.03797844052314758, 0.01935657113790512, -0.03738532215356827, 0.03158578649163246, 0.005068632308393717, 0.032507963478565216, 0.04227883368730545, -0.09373439103364944, -0.004415611270815134, 0.0793791115283966, 0.05309567227959633, -0.007123914081603289, -0.08962245285511017, -0.027669686824083328, 0.03641987964510918, 0.04985189810395241, -0.0061105722561478615, 0.06666901707649231, -0.018775364384055138, 0.00514946598559618, 0.003055742010474205, 0.06814247369766235, -0.011394796893000603, 0.02156829833984375, -0.002033341908827424, 0.0035712027456611395, -0.01775689423084259, -0.00889012310653925, -0.07250338792800903, 0.0005011691246181726, -0.011967936530709267, 0.008139550685882568, 0.02916412055492401, -0.03192130848765373, -0.016155963763594627, 0.014692368917167187, 0.03926160931587219, 0.026119155809283257, -0.03213270381093025, 0.011761587113142014, -0.034809719771146774, -0.013496317900717258, -0.07316751778125763, 0.010858642868697643, 0.00021273098536767066, 0.025011660531163216, 0.028849255293607712, -0.08479463309049606, 0.0017481608083471656, -0.0028382213786244392, -0.047212984412908554, 0.043102994561195374, 0.03693198785185814, 0.010577190667390823, 0.030734164640307426, 0.01805277168750763, 0.06752365082502365, -0.04668763279914856, -0.004673946648836136, -0.06738386303186417, -0.014136344194412231, 0.008984031155705452, 0.03222694247961044, 0.030224060639739037, 0.010979227721691132, 0.028069136664271355, 0.03137984126806259, -0.0692865327000618, -0.0018170633120462298, 0.00784902274608612, 0.02609103173017502, -0.012816735543310642, -0.013687205500900745, 0.011411342769861221, -0.016081560403108597, 0.005622615572065115, -0.013009634800255299, 0.06780225783586502, 0.014447316527366638, -0.08072555810213089, -0.012483897618949413, -0.06334934383630753, 0.0023649130016565323, -0.005663870833814144, 0.04524322226643562, -0.015601863153278828, 0.017609989270567894, -0.026865091174840927, -0.03051862120628357, 0.036676134914159775, 0.021323703229427338, -0.04434658959507942, -0.07724165171384811, 0.01562533900141716, 0.02320036292076111, -0.016235830262303352, -0.04925830289721489, 0.01345129031687975, -0.00041917437920346856, -0.028622809797525406, -0.012668919749557972, -0.009029078297317028, 0.0318644754588604, -0.06799815595149994, 0.04359600692987442, -0.034281063824892044, -0.019089791923761368, -0.003992857877165079, 0.057513248175382614, 0.00901815202087164, 0.02039562538266182, 0.02588922716677189, -0.0032798673491925, -0.05939827114343643, 0.032662201672792435, -0.00184945622459054, -0.07138330489397049, -0.05137769877910614, 0.02969788946211338, 0.040865592658519745, -0.08245516568422318, -0.033325180411338806, -0.001877286471426487, 0.0126792686060071, -0.008781790733337402, 7.764609472360462e-05, -0.032736681401729584, 0.021428698673844337, 0.047277871519327164, 0.0032725741621106863, 0.019389914348721504, -0.05053432285785675, -0.0050465865060687065, -0.017087120562791824, 0.00311585352756083, -0.041012074798345566, -0.02910483628511429, -0.011389677412807941, 0.04103950411081314, 0.046789880841970444, 0.028649672865867615, -0.011577065102756023, -0.00029719978920184076, 0.01597915031015873, -0.04752415046095848, 0.004813579376786947, 0.0026794900186359882, 0.04561329260468483, 0.03179203346371651, 0.047049906104803085, 0.014740606769919395, -0.003396382322534919, -0.07056590169668198, 0.05469429865479469, 0.0009626479586586356, 0.001071576145477593, -0.0020298545714467764, -0.0282998476177454, -6.079035607156858e-33, 0.020009106025099754, -0.013183730654418468, -0.018592938780784607, -0.033206623047590256, -0.03230076655745506, -0.028274331241846085, -0.004693977534770966, -0.022835321724414825, -0.03284010663628578, 0.05270528793334961, 0.0023794304579496384, -0.0012515627313405275, 0.008527381345629692, 0.0014571482315659523, 0.041352950036525726, -0.005215637851506472, 0.03234267607331276, -0.04818910360336304, 0.042272716760635376, -0.03989853337407112, -0.00649899011477828, 0.008086303249001503, 0.058425188064575195, -0.12312343716621399, -0.05964221805334091, 0.01634705625474453, 0.02152007818222046, -0.02975749783217907, 0.015520183369517326, -0.0003851632936857641, -0.027538882568478584, 0.002448662417009473, 0.03612733632326126, 0.015281613916158676, -0.020175201818346977, 0.045362602919340134, -0.047520022839307785, -0.030979357659816742, -0.032021358609199524, 0.008252243511378765, -0.020542141050100327, 0.006826389580965042, 0.07727264612913132, -0.01790599897503853, 0.014488322660326958, -0.019341791048645973, 0.07280343025922775, -0.05727529898285866, 0.013361758552491665, 0.001870806678198278, -0.016435440629720688, -0.02794451080262661, -0.0004904333618469536, -0.0002399111690465361, 0.04291608929634094, 0.017879901453852654, -0.034046947956085205, 0.027706606313586235, -0.06911957263946533, 0.04097845032811165, -0.025709711015224457, -0.021651525050401688, 0.03508339449763298, 0.04485607147216797, 0.03786880522966385, 0.06541375815868378, 0.0681857168674469, -0.03727537393569946, -0.013319171965122223, -0.0482180193066597, 0.015617037191987038, 0.056836873292922974, 0.04726720228791237, 0.03532610833644867, 0.06600514054298401, -0.03714480623602867, -0.02994859218597412, 0.020989028736948967, -0.028468772768974304, 0.026952892541885376, -0.028285609558224678, 0.04348793625831604, -0.002671116031706333, 0.018611690029501915, 0.04146512225270271, -0.014527668245136738, -0.039009273052215576, -0.03571002557873726, 0.008320261724293232, -0.05421864241361618, 0.006369662471115589, 0.04287417232990265, -0.008836686611175537, -0.05634281411767006, 0.0727471113204956, -0.07730059325695038, 0.01606392115354538, 0.03060312010347843, 0.033250149339437485, -0.045227330178022385, -0.04393903166055679, -0.031885065138339996, 0.02432124689221382, 0.044985536485910416, 0.04785393178462982, 0.026798563078045845, 0.025032788515090942, -0.0257578045129776, 0.027974994853138924, -0.0340690091252327, 0.018479853868484497, -0.07074899226427078, 0.04076177254319191, -0.010597972199320793, -0.021162474527955055, -0.009254006668925285, -0.00943179801106453, -0.02748376503586769, 0.02730642259120941, -0.03200162202119827, -0.05347930267453194, -0.008940895088016987, 0.015020946972072124, 0.045349106192588806, -0.03788883239030838, -0.01729384809732437, -0.07300069183111191, -0.04609442874789238, 0.04357016086578369, -0.03791944682598114, -0.02146594040095806, -0.0060046655125916, 2.9731774020547164e-07, -0.04822137951850891, -0.012852898798882961, 0.03792775794863701, -0.05774619057774544, 0.02817717380821705, 0.042123593389987946, 0.02632514387369156, 0.056612011045217514, 0.005661004688590765, -0.04457847774028778, 0.039760906249284744, 0.01926254667341709, -0.019586123526096344, -0.00375922629609704, 0.011391401290893555, -0.00311815133318305, 0.009840917773544788, 0.018464431166648865, -0.023864973336458206, 0.03695764020085335, 0.06495603173971176, 0.04035785049200058, 0.02168489247560501, -0.025815997272729874, 0.036813899874687195, 0.01401281263679266, -0.003327294485643506, -0.03869115933775902, 0.04827437177300453, -0.041968971490859985, 0.018239589408040047, 0.017094992101192474, -0.012093516066670418, 0.056681424379348755, 0.010666287504136562, -0.01426004059612751, 0.033285267651081085, -0.04565200209617615, -0.030242614448070526, -0.006719985976815224, 0.012579469941556454, 0.05568697676062584, 0.02347831055521965, -0.03412061929702759, 0.04090232029557228, -0.06547006219625473, -0.05121495947241783, -0.03946797549724579, -0.0021022302098572254, -0.002130280714482069, 0.03775324672460556, 0.018951507285237312, -0.001997876213863492, 0.0050349454395473, 0.009184258058667183, 0.016586938872933388, -0.018545622006058693, -0.0600411593914032, 0.03431781381368637, 0.011583167128264904, -0.05370873585343361, 0.02619570679962635, -0.01605251058936119, -0.044254228472709656, 0.05755963176488876, -0.00896549504250288, -0.04291541501879692, 2.1463066661626058e-34, -0.04279438778758049, 0.0551217757165432, 0.03260485455393791, -0.038371067494153976, -0.018162788823246956, 0.012996378354728222, -0.01367834210395813, 0.005581142846494913, 0.03649415820837021, -0.018744884058833122, -0.026605207473039627]
693
693
['Esteban Real', 'Sherry Moore', 'Andrew Selle', 'Saurabh Saxena', 'Yutaka Leon Suematsu', 'Jie Tan', 'Quoc Le', 'Alex Kurakin']
1703.01041v2
Neural networks have proven effective at solving difficult problems but designing their architectures can be challenging, even for image classification problems alone. Our goal is to minimize human participation, so we employ evolutionary algorithms to discover such networks automatically. Despite significant computational requirements, we show that it is now possible to evolve models with accuracies within the range of those published in the last year. Specifically, we employ simple evolutionary techniques at unprecedented scales to discover models for the CIFAR-10 and CIFAR-100 datasets, starting from trivial initial conditions and reaching accuracies of 94.6% (95.6% for ensemble) and 77.0%, respectively. To do this, we use novel and intuitive mutation operators that navigate large search spaces; we stress that no human participation is required once evolution starts and that the output is a fully-trained model. Throughout this work, we place special emphasis on the repeatability of results, the variability in the outcomes and the computational requirements.
Large-Scale Evolution of Image Classifiers
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1703.01041v2
Title LargeScale Evolution Image Classifiers Summary Neural network proven effective solving difficult problem designing architecture challenging even image classification problem alone goal minimize human participation employ evolutionary algorithm discover network automatically Despite significant computational requirement show possible evolve model accuracy within range published last year Specifically employ simple evolutionary technique unprecedented scale discover model CIFAR10 CIFAR100 datasets starting trivial initial condition reaching accuracy 946 956 ensemble 770 respectively use novel intuitive mutation operator navigate large search space stress human participation required evolution start output fullytrained model Throughout work place special emphasis repeatability result variability outcome computational requirement Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.011365228332579136, 0.07445085048675537, -0.04380756616592407, 0.036304619163274765, 0.010352357290685177, 0.0017203945899382234, 0.03758206218481064, 0.03093908540904522, -0.012030882760882378, 0.019904321059584618, 0.005386252887547016, 0.03029400296509266, -0.007501552812755108, 0.0726308524608612, 0.022112620994448662, -0.017253298312425613, -0.014833632856607437, 0.028817193582654, -0.06813610345125198, -0.02956106886267662, 0.02470865286886692, -0.03570472449064255, 0.04504650458693504, 0.023100724443793297, -0.018178163096308708, 0.03337155282497406, -0.04116322100162506, -0.0011235940037295222, 0.0165798831731081, 0.02867855504155159, 0.028907090425491333, 0.014359323307871819, 0.022969407960772514, 0.08557233214378357, 2.0837753709201934e-06, -0.07271531969308853, -0.006423109211027622, -0.03072381764650345, 0.001493375631980598, 0.022025881335139275, 0.044409725815057755, 0.03021881729364395, -0.0444454587996006, -0.03789839148521423, -0.010841362178325653, -0.02477934956550598, 0.04913909360766411, 0.03369363769888878, 0.050913579761981964, 0.044418223202228546, -0.0013433408457785845, -0.06857752799987793, -0.0004306935297790915, -0.007807327900081873, -0.000244220340391621, 0.0018256729235872626, 0.028784027323126793, -0.017676012590527534, -0.016560563817620277, -0.02847740240395069, -0.0045868284069001675, 0.0495358444750309, 0.020143896341323853, -0.001389015349559486, 0.011816037818789482, 0.03420109674334526, -0.028954120352864265, -0.03517775237560272, -0.004189149476587772, 0.03986537829041481, -0.08427828550338745, -0.005809091962873936, 0.014794361777603626, 0.0010984071996062994, 0.001712416997179389, -0.04091161862015724, 0.007586653809994459, 0.0015862650470808148, -0.04624846950173378, 0.011452212929725647, -0.046531762927770615, -0.004255290143191814, -0.012352453544735909, 0.0311608724296093, -0.034208595752716064, -0.025035865604877472, -0.0028043610509485006, 0.012070320546627045, -0.017031146213412285, -0.04963662475347519, -0.04552583768963814, -0.0037927483208477497, 0.06527847796678543, 0.025026658549904823, 0.013028571382164955, -0.026833103969693184, -0.04469878226518631, -0.055025745183229446, 0.056273918598890305, -0.0682775229215622, 0.04062140733003616, -0.021811312064528465, -0.020850883796811104, 0.06335275620222092, -0.04848165065050125, 0.012028270401060581, -0.07818499207496643, -0.017764881253242493, -0.013189170509576797, 0.033280398696660995, -0.05633493512868881, 0.028193268924951553, -0.009401648305356503, 0.01092467363923788, 0.0002472928026691079, -0.017580721527338028, -0.040430083870887756, 0.02048412337899208, 0.016335681080818176, -0.01979806087911129, 0.022254835814237595, 0.05955255776643753, 0.03310960531234741, 0.02168554626405239, -0.016518978402018547, -0.0005258112214505672, 0.05654584616422653, -0.02005736529827118, -0.030768055468797684, 0.01552825141698122, 0.053968705236911774, 0.016146736219525337, 0.008333254605531693, 0.061032962054014206, 0.0346326045691967, 0.0339539609849453, 0.022829758003354073, -0.019989395514130592, -0.032738614827394485, 0.011739397421479225, -0.05509563535451889, 0.03061194159090519, -0.003637295449152589, 0.017039883881807327, 0.01200840063393116, -0.06998991966247559, -0.0541573241353035, 0.013219195418059826, -0.010760141536593437, -0.014151467941701412, -0.019926290959119797, 0.07454179227352142, -0.06243465468287468, 0.003622133284807205, 0.08843685686588287, 0.010846168734133244, 0.011537285521626472, 0.017909159883856773, 0.015546996146440506, 0.01984569989144802, 0.01793348230421543, -0.04236720874905586, 0.00561156589537859, 0.01006252784281969, -0.05651682987809181, -0.017200946807861328, 0.035260770469903946, -0.00928291492164135, 0.008342108689248562, 0.02438567951321602, 0.03307013586163521, -0.002495714696124196, 0.005469843279570341, -0.0560675710439682, 0.039091452956199646, 0.037139564752578735, 0.06127260625362396, 0.06619877368211746, 0.015060524456202984, 0.0068215057253837585, -0.02923751063644886, -0.09865779429674149, 0.04867478460073471, 0.037660565227270126, -0.05883214995265007, -0.051112253218889236, -0.05209330841898918, -0.0027707493863999844, -0.02782835252583027, -0.04304325208067894, 0.02567070908844471, -0.001074343454092741, -0.03313911706209183, -0.02551800012588501, 0.04947572946548462, -0.006925980094820261, 0.004789402708411217, -0.03938952088356018, -0.00126160541549325, 0.00273474701680243, -0.07180560380220413, -0.07796566933393478, 0.04995434731245041, 0.004440195392817259, -0.002165751764550805, 0.008311605080962181, -0.005102829076349735, 0.043846938759088516, 0.01767907105386257, -0.004565696232020855, 0.012776133604347706, 0.02118852362036705, -0.01171122770756483, -0.062264472246170044, -0.01669095829129219, 0.010397226549685001, -0.016032269224524498, 0.005710480269044638, 0.009905974380671978, 0.022006956860423088, 0.002746331738308072, 0.039232976734638214, -0.028040561825037003, 0.028156187385320663, 0.012938081286847591, 0.018714770674705505, 0.0834098756313324, 0.05192812904715538, 0.011145017109811306, -0.035447072237730026, 0.02164667658507824, -0.04808351770043373, 0.01540151797235012, -0.011253577657043934, -0.04808976501226425, 0.0020811143331229687, 0.00481169018894434, 0.016489604488015175, 0.027501167729496956, -0.005591137800365686, -0.007727809250354767, -0.054043419659137726, -0.02872966229915619, 0.013623925857245922, 0.00934064295142889, -0.041992928832769394, 0.019557494670152664, -0.039215315133333206, 0.05501498281955719, -0.03728262335062027, 0.033810559660196304, -0.052988842129707336, 0.06567255407571793, 0.01978231780230999, -0.0357513353228569, -0.0354720763862133, -0.013380683027207851, 0.05766668915748596, -0.03625145182013512, -0.026710012927651405, 0.004760399926453829, -0.007313580252230167, -0.022205045446753502, -0.03164784237742424, 0.09034033119678497, 0.0034197315108031034, -0.022005409002304077, 0.004292103927582502, 0.012101298198103905, 0.04071170091629028, 0.010187859646975994, 0.03021067939698696, -0.030965235084295273, 0.032417334616184235, 0.011003771796822548, 0.0031371794175356627, 0.11322875320911407, 0.009171975776553154, -0.06269291788339615, 0.022192398086190224, -0.017338210716843605, -0.024014737457036972, -0.01607881300151348, -0.02468598261475563, -0.01682600937783718, 0.06268399208784103, 0.07693348824977875, -0.019769754260778427, -0.0861048772931099, -0.00492590107023716, -0.02474026568233967, 0.055860623717308044, 0.0036839612293988466, -0.030729463323950768, -0.03730279207229614, -0.0328051894903183, -0.04444403573870659, 0.09223514795303345, 0.04114441201090813, -0.01360580138862133, 0.013083848170936108, 0.10082533210515976, 0.0014187742490321398, 0.006437929347157478, -0.007172726094722748, -0.004611168056726456, -0.005666124168783426, -0.00409798976033926, -0.011618290096521378, -0.00901259295642376, -0.045677121728658676, 0.015748776495456696, -0.00025681726401671767, 0.04426014423370361, 0.008622922003269196, -0.0059203109703958035, -0.01928480714559555, -0.034567367285490036, 0.02788720279932022, -0.023901330307126045, -0.03427114337682724, -0.02288602665066719, 0.0229816697537899, 0.06301546096801758, -0.011493002064526081, -0.012172415852546692, -0.02778664603829384, -0.02609139122068882, 0.040293674916028976, -0.003749858820810914, 0.034711457788944244, 0.02878277190029621, 0.022497879341244698, 0.0142155596986413, 0.010170606896281242, 0.005034101661294699, -0.046444352716207504, -0.019825629889965057, -0.04291243851184845, 0.0066715264692902565, -0.014239982701838017, -0.07570477575063705, -0.05085849016904831, 0.007021768484264612, 0.02166006900370121, -0.011927404440939426, -0.01294444128870964, -0.029521595686674118, -0.019314419478178024, 0.04295680299401283, 0.017100121825933456, 0.016536563634872437, -0.0038058918435126543, -0.010356280952692032, 0.0031338108237832785, 0.040021415799856186, 0.025161195546388626, 0.036494962871074677, -0.006580878980457783, 0.008189487271010876, 0.06564710289239883, 0.033588945865631104, -0.031337760388851166, -0.013434769585728645, -0.11147762089967728, 0.043642908334732056, -0.00015520041051786393, 0.011394290253520012, -0.019224198535084724, -0.07982180267572403, 0.020540067926049232, -0.05374641716480255, 0.012326029129326344, 0.014542635530233383, -0.013597192242741585, -0.07546946406364441, -0.016416238620877266, 0.004909347742795944, -0.05609355494379997, 0.020730940625071526, 0.024580765515565872, 0.002692339476197958, 0.00029681503656320274, -0.02100970782339573, -0.012315170839428902, -0.03837239369750023, -0.057447802275419235, 0.022972822189331055, -0.05409448593854904, 0.050208043307065964, 0.011134296655654907, -0.02950827032327652, 0.011157194152474403, -0.003685840405523777, 0.013098006136715412, -0.03637687861919403, -0.062295492738485336, 0.04081347957253456, 0.03739599883556366, -0.031508490443229675, 0.010975642129778862, 0.020555347204208374, 0.01361307967454195, 0.028709053993225098, -0.0718524158000946, -0.07163576781749725, 0.06748693436384201, -0.0019914479926228523, 0.011721859686076641, -0.06981775909662247, 0.06339026242494583, -0.03696434572339058, 0.035482436418533325, -0.027397124096751213, 0.04052416980266571, 0.034094858914613724, -0.026387039572000504, -0.027207575738430023, 0.05202088505029678, -0.008668431080877781, 0.05556732416152954, 0.05667062848806381, 0.019900327548384666, 0.011496618390083313, -0.0022269512992352247, -0.060627780854701996, -0.03254958614706993, -0.020329199731349945, -0.020781857892870903, 0.025251789018511772, -0.08596980571746826, -0.03895522654056549, 0.02872135303914547, -0.01063489355146885, -0.03203391656279564, -0.016445761546492577, 0.04408968985080719, 0.013055427931249142, -0.04417041689157486, -0.050908684730529785, 0.06286022812128067, 0.012736412696540356, 0.06506329029798508, -0.004592785146087408, -0.09459048509597778, 0.00016870339459273964, 0.00025448689120821655, -0.053410809487104416, 0.02061278000473976, 0.053133733570575714, -0.022821316495537758, -0.0453609898686409, 0.046969711780548096, 0.0746857225894928, -0.03053913824260235, 0.008775722235441208, -0.011998173780739307, -0.08615753054618835, -0.014959979802370071, -0.016652561724185944, 0.07552169263362885, 0.002019879873842001, -0.027288833633065224, -0.028035033494234085, -0.07005640864372253, 0.06576258689165115, 0.01566293090581894, 0.08628159761428833, 0.02013978734612465, -0.000528227596078068, -0.007436701562255621, -0.025376297533512115, 0.0023055369965732098, 0.005052649416029453, 0.025817343965172768, 0.03727519139647484, -0.04519224911928177, -0.02565043978393078, -0.01707003451883793, -0.004276045132428408, -0.001858448376879096, -0.015019606798887253, 0.011702809482812881, -0.027981359511613846, 0.004175934474915266, 0.03580935299396515, 0.07616844773292542, -0.011347012594342232, -0.02750980295240879, -0.03376118838787079, 0.006550214719027281, 0.015893561765551567, 0.011481226421892643, -0.014887413941323757, 0.08103088289499283, -0.029004080221056938, -0.03207316994667053, 0.037604235112667084, 0.008835317566990852, 0.020354172214865685, -0.05541934445500374, 0.015526361763477325, 0.0017973531503230333, 0.023555373772978783, 0.036798857152462006, 0.029612397775053978, -0.011610208079218864, 0.04547397419810295, 0.0070563447661697865, -0.005611399654299021, -0.06598886102437973, 0.05220451578497887, 0.017530342563986778, -0.000985224498435855, -0.03343901038169861, 0.06738701462745667, 0.07460297644138336, -0.01244435366243124, -0.029523318633437157, 0.007042997982352972, -0.047177135944366455, -0.019005268812179565, -0.001770197181031108, -0.03639829531311989, -0.005039369687438011, 0.03924666345119476, 0.011042061261832714, -0.015724025666713715, 0.024528229609131813, -0.02481864020228386, -0.007621040567755699, -0.013610481284558773, -0.03264108672738075, -0.013912489637732506, -0.021537484601140022, 0.04577961936593056, -0.020233456045389175, -0.02848600596189499, 0.004810965154320002, -0.0027269700076431036, 0.00478707579895854, -0.0053772106766700745, -0.0029377886094152927, 0.03501122072339058, 0.03370450809597969, 0.061498403549194336, -0.009746355004608631, 0.015485276468098164, 0.0034041607286781073, -0.0705995112657547, 0.0019399767043069005, -0.039412446320056915, -0.01290576159954071, 0.016349615529179573, -0.013546951115131378, -5.50252174963576e-33, 0.04445912316441536, -0.012098608538508415, -0.00919369701296091, 0.014277255162596703, -0.020706884562969208, 0.033798910677433014, 0.012945210561156273, -0.06071162223815918, -0.01838071271777153, -0.03176785632967949, -0.0048826620914042, -0.015972599387168884, -0.014302593655884266, 0.0017767740646377206, 0.0332428403198719, 0.023335015401244164, -0.015445495955646038, -0.016177108511328697, 0.020534321665763855, 0.010313577018678188, 0.017051810398697853, 0.01863081194460392, 0.006213348358869553, -0.039566926658153534, -0.09682344645261765, 0.0703464224934578, 0.015344911254942417, -0.01722591556608677, -0.03817550465464592, 0.006009288597851992, -0.0026883319951593876, 0.0028343675658106804, -0.014609974808990955, -0.005075280088931322, 0.009084794670343399, -0.08166183531284332, -0.021122945472598076, 0.019860142841935158, -0.09694554656744003, 0.009840266779065132, -0.034136053174734116, 0.00031997449696063995, 0.11153772473335266, -0.0026716506108641624, -0.05517411231994629, 0.022820334881544113, 0.0509411096572876, -0.03722052648663521, 0.010576155036687851, -0.03547290340065956, 0.035368483513593674, 0.008644044399261475, 0.0016135749174281955, -0.013689395971596241, -0.02435922622680664, -0.056030649691820145, 0.008455077186226845, -0.015433521009981632, -0.043005771934986115, 0.04062537103891373, 0.038462720811367035, -0.0372869111597538, 0.02391926571726799, 0.04068777710199356, 0.09659823775291443, -0.014446623623371124, 0.08811788260936737, 0.0014427178539335728, 0.04305163025856018, -0.07780366390943527, 0.004438233096152544, 0.036510761827230453, 0.03589065745472908, 0.005955440923571587, 0.008632445707917213, -0.05479965731501579, -0.01898740604519844, 0.024307623505592346, 0.0040334356017410755, -0.004008677788078785, -0.027975644916296005, 0.01037149503827095, -0.007278058212250471, 0.021714387461543083, 0.06788107752799988, -0.026640795171260834, -0.011329678818583488, -0.0033845887519419193, 0.013355146162211895, 0.000980307231657207, -0.02416381426155567, 0.04952963814139366, -0.010612639598548412, -0.04272403568029404, 0.06247353553771973, -0.057482365518808365, 0.023190606385469437, 0.03610129654407501, 0.0665755644440651, 0.012425962835550308, 0.017503170296549797, -0.03681134060025215, -0.007279098965227604, 0.008113925345242023, 0.013134103268384933, 0.009361324831843376, 0.008750512264668941, 0.018653051927685738, 0.009256940335035324, 0.017035983502864838, -0.01151593029499054, -0.045426610857248306, 0.0018175133736804128, -0.0007954262546263635, 0.020893869921565056, -0.013950291089713573, 0.017950398847460747, 0.011295781470835209, 0.03320683538913727, -0.002446176018565893, -0.04136265814304352, -0.015356441959738731, 0.03497425094246864, 0.032258082181215286, -0.0573958083987236, 0.018444443121552467, -0.007733735255897045, 0.023007653653621674, -0.046049702912569046, -0.07671155780553818, -0.01647028513252735, 0.012546248733997345, 2.856659477856738e-07, -0.005271321628242731, 0.03728035092353821, -0.028750048950314522, -0.06547612696886063, 0.01051039807498455, 0.002867263276129961, -0.031861819326877594, -0.013967994600534439, -0.02648061141371727, 0.03463238477706909, 0.0516621433198452, -0.01136111095547676, 0.012910988181829453, -0.045631684362888336, -0.013901883736252785, 0.018195677548646927, -0.014202474616467953, 0.02083914540708065, -0.05681048333644867, 0.03375152871012688, 0.009791006334125996, 0.06827983260154724, 0.04506341367959976, -0.041524603962898254, 0.05772258713841438, -0.028495164588093758, 0.022107569500803947, 0.007727236486971378, 0.05307638645172119, -0.04492753744125366, -0.0499955378472805, 0.03033274970948696, -0.050426069647073746, 0.006470261141657829, 0.00524456612765789, 0.03418554365634918, -0.014323759824037552, 0.010261601768434048, 0.0021721345838159323, 0.020312579348683357, 0.05767865106463432, 0.05828269198536873, 0.024915382266044617, -0.054781436920166016, 0.05241553485393524, -0.03932919725775719, -0.021331746131181717, -0.016216393560171127, 0.004127104766666889, -0.03130236640572548, 0.011363931931555271, -0.018800169229507446, 0.009915294125676155, 0.008930844254791737, -0.038656704127788544, -0.0641375258564949, -0.017141275107860565, -0.07102733850479126, 0.06131459027528763, 0.015337563119828701, -0.048529915511608124, -2.2021366021363065e-05, -0.025164013728499413, 0.010744718834757805, 0.10468276590108871, 0.027938585728406906, -0.005191850941628218, 2.478916236558878e-34, -0.06806634366512299, 0.015595220029354095, 0.019995201379060745, -0.024291958659887314, -0.03108248859643936, 0.04046010226011276, 0.020391779020428658, -0.030262263491749763, 0.011132375337183475, -0.03289741277694702, -0.03401690348982811]
694
694
['Chunpeng Wu', 'Wei Wen', 'Tariq Afzal', 'Yongmei Zhang', 'Yiran Chen', 'Hai Li']
1703.04071v4
Recently, DNN model compression based on network architecture design, e.g., SqueezeNet, attracted a lot attention. No accuracy drop on image classification is observed on these extremely compact networks, compared to well-known models. An emerging question, however, is whether these model compression techniques hurt DNN's learning ability other than classifying images on a single dataset. Our preliminary experiment shows that these compression methods could degrade domain adaptation (DA) ability, though the classification performance is preserved. Therefore, we propose a new compact network architecture and unsupervised DA method in this paper. The DNN is built on a new basic module Conv-M which provides more diverse feature extractors without significantly increasing parameters. The unified framework of our DA method will simultaneously learn invariance across domains, reduce divergence of feature representations, and adapt label prediction. Our DNN has 4.1M parameters, which is only 6.7% of AlexNet or 59% of GoogLeNet. Experiments show that our DNN obtains GoogLeNet-level accuracy both on classification and DA, and our DA method slightly outperforms previous competitive ones. Put all together, our DA strategy based on our DNN achieves state-of-the-art on sixteen of total eighteen DA tasks on popular Office-31 and Office-Caltech datasets.
A Compact DNN: Approaching GoogLeNet-Level Accuracy of Classification and Domain Adaptation
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1703.04071v4
Title Compact DNN Approaching GoogLeNetLevel Accuracy Classification Domain Adaptation Summary Recently DNN model compression based network architecture design eg SqueezeNet attracted lot attention accuracy drop image classification observed extremely compact network compared wellknown model emerging question however whether model compression technique hurt DNNs learning ability classifying image single dataset preliminary experiment show compression method could degrade domain adaptation DA ability though classification performance preserved Therefore propose new compact network architecture unsupervised DA method paper DNN built new basic module ConvM provides diverse feature extractor without significantly increasing parameter unified framework DA method simultaneously learn invariance across domain reduce divergence feature representation adapt label prediction DNN 41M parameter 67 AlexNet 59 GoogLeNet Experiments show DNN obtains GoogLeNetlevel accuracy classification DA DA method slightly outperforms previous competitive one Put together DA strategy based DNN achieves stateoftheart sixteen total eighteen DA task popular Office31 OfficeCaltech datasets Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.012206400744616985, 0.05085603520274162, -0.028635334223508835, 0.0407564640045166, -0.010684553533792496, 0.003392936196178198, 0.05592728778719902, 0.02588380128145218, -0.03154008463025093, 0.02351333387196064, -0.022899260744452477, 0.01830415055155754, 0.018779441714286804, 0.07889341562986374, 0.006151669658720493, -0.039001889526844025, 0.003882533870637417, 0.061072126030921936, -0.027974063530564308, -0.020122306421399117, 0.013457974418997765, -0.019436096772551537, 0.029109179973602295, 0.05027345195412636, 0.005416254512965679, 0.014515701681375504, -0.03722741827368736, 0.037935882806777954, 0.003998583182692528, 0.022141041234135628, 0.009029445238411427, 0.015809061005711555, 0.06837053596973419, 0.03276633098721504, 2.235076408396708e-06, 0.003262039041146636, -0.016809768974781036, -0.012556065805256367, -0.08269611746072769, 0.00175917474552989, 0.03505287691950798, 0.012877453118562698, 0.0005351224099285901, -0.002446769969537854, -0.024754565209150314, -0.05975862964987755, 0.0762832760810852, 0.09269530326128006, 0.02456650882959366, 0.03473138064146042, -0.01248524896800518, -0.06783401966094971, 0.005639386363327503, -0.06802468001842499, -0.048292871564626694, -0.03258201479911804, -0.013458771631121635, 0.035534463822841644, -0.023985346779227257, -0.007886034436523914, -0.04493330791592598, 0.023873228579759598, 0.0553848035633564, 0.04361044988036156, 0.005658307112753391, 0.03699750080704689, -0.04018878936767578, -0.016207357868552208, 0.03132396563887596, 0.008623342961072922, -0.055668167769908905, 0.002010513097047806, -0.023663505911827087, -0.005714354570955038, 0.028497643768787384, -0.013924207538366318, -0.020492732524871826, -0.04154091700911522, 0.02770163305103779, 0.02721468172967434, -0.09147181361913681, 0.06277546286582947, 0.0035997533705085516, 0.0014609078643843532, -0.026728132739663124, -0.035890351980924606, -0.01662004180252552, 0.0340929739177227, -0.0105477599427104, 0.012712817639112473, -0.028074122965335846, -0.007894027046859264, -0.032348666340112686, -0.04373743757605553, 0.019999636337161064, -0.02975037693977356, -0.07223977148532867, -0.04140359163284302, 0.008321752771735191, -0.034851957112550735, 0.007628200575709343, -0.024290304630994797, -0.032418619841337204, -0.023600878193974495, -0.015240661799907684, 0.07748182862997055, -0.0449681282043457, 0.011578596197068691, -0.019128983840346336, -0.0018917645793408155, -0.034319765865802765, -0.003383628325536847, -0.0286113191395998, 0.06343948096036911, 0.025743428617715836, -0.03601110354065895, -0.04937159642577171, -0.030607115477323532, 0.027384065091609955, -0.011098009534180164, -0.023542804643511772, 0.07552879303693771, -0.04256172105669975, 0.011210297234356403, 0.006996961776167154, 0.002019154606387019, -0.03616798296570778, 0.08073761314153671, 0.055385950952768326, -0.028142280876636505, -0.015314634889364243, 0.030605332925915718, 0.032353635877370834, 0.008431009016931057, 0.031209630891680717, 0.01903207041323185, -0.00766712287440896, -0.012019003741443157, -0.037536658346652985, -0.003070206381380558, 0.01707942970097065, -0.0023934475611895323, 0.011931382119655609, -0.07868390530347824, 0.02924066223204136, -0.0414927713572979, -0.010266952216625214, -0.06610087305307388, -0.011388876475393772, -0.028833234682679176, -0.03274510055780411, 0.010603534989058971, -0.010745708830654621, -0.051226116716861725, 0.05268489941954613, 0.00017588911578059196, 0.013051401823759079, 0.04013291001319885, 0.03003201261162758, 0.08654408156871796, 0.003277137642726302, 0.002612393582239747, -0.010113743133842945, 0.0048821959644556046, 0.027572941035032272, -0.030742652714252472, -0.03294055163860321, -0.037217698991298676, -0.034436244517564774, 0.007040086667984724, 0.03002234175801277, -0.01582978665828705, -0.008982213214039803, -0.0713721290230751, 0.03229203447699547, 0.028531119227409363, 0.06042949855327606, 0.05712706223130226, -0.024610327556729317, -0.016062835231423378, -0.003404842456802726, 0.02856501378118992, -0.030325500294566154, 0.04195571318268776, 0.012274762615561485, -0.023041248321533203, -0.019775206223130226, 0.018368767574429512, -0.050956252962350845, -0.04936894029378891, 0.018718456849455833, -0.028152888640761375, 0.028726451098918915, 0.013561088591814041, 0.037798941135406494, 0.008843758143484592, 0.013537426479160786, 0.02852366678416729, 0.006836398504674435, 0.022133151069283485, -0.027194442227482796, -0.05513611063361168, -0.03192851319909096, -0.06840257346630096, -0.00676068477332592, 0.019206194207072258, -0.048087168484926224, 0.007388809230178595, -0.028384318575263023, -0.016742350533604622, -0.002962155267596245, 0.01440868154168129, 0.016825607046484947, -0.0609326995909214, -0.02133001759648323, -0.0031822696328163147, 0.009209840558469296, 0.003046872792765498, 0.004465895239263773, 0.021072592586278915, 0.047120582312345505, -0.02483559213578701, 0.024149948731064796, 0.02690262533724308, 0.022576823830604553, -0.043613504618406296, 0.04663298279047012, 0.021435348317027092, 0.040779341012239456, -0.03741299733519554, -0.031433213502168655, -0.052845317870378494, 0.038498617708683014, -0.0484904907643795, -0.036116864532232285, -0.06937514245510101, -0.056407470256090164, -0.03165885806083679, 0.0037863990291953087, -0.038172781467437744, 0.07287577539682388, 0.06516244262456894, -0.06009938195347786, -0.031676340848207474, 0.05252398923039436, 0.0024255511816591024, -0.02657463029026985, -0.021587174385786057, -0.05687173455953598, -0.0051247794181108475, 0.0971655622124672, 0.02691170945763588, 0.030183203518390656, 0.0015191490529105067, -0.027956927195191383, -0.02023915760219097, -0.0022896048612892628, 0.027766738086938858, 0.0072369505651295185, 0.01634385623037815, -0.0003498889273032546, -0.05678707733750343, 0.003280447795987129, 0.01869431883096695, 0.016006048768758774, 0.017118779942393303, 0.026882650330662727, 0.00371441594325006, 0.02238778956234455, -0.03431512787938118, -0.008889426477253437, 0.0012474787654355168, 0.038221221417188644, 0.007315077818930149, -0.04889391362667084, -0.028707047924399376, 0.08682075887918472, -0.0185292586684227, -0.03278660029172897, 0.016825368627905846, 0.04192978888750076, 0.029248179867863655, -0.010515121743083, -0.05779307335615158, 0.030614327639341354, 0.07177747786045074, -0.016870738938450813, -0.05594050884246826, 0.02882474474608898, 0.04045405238866806, -0.0391111820936203, 0.043068766593933105, 0.0014675373677164316, -0.06156650930643082, -0.04356110095977783, -0.026775918900966644, -0.0324251651763916, 0.06488512456417084, 0.02090344950556755, -0.03075220249593258, 0.03792157769203186, 0.06005201116204262, -0.026393789798021317, 0.0006606315728276968, -0.02857114002108574, -0.019490592181682587, -0.0033019224647432566, 0.02887621708214283, -0.032632987946271896, 0.01717549003660679, 0.005318382754921913, 0.0029218154959380627, -0.03408028930425644, -0.009237684309482574, -0.0013452848652377725, -0.0019088851986452937, -0.05262467637658119, 0.038080278784036636, 0.0022672791965305805, 0.02492939680814743, -0.006013011559844017, -0.04257760941982269, 0.005265834741294384, 0.017366569489240646, -0.0213788989931345, 0.0005610406515188515, -0.0649394541978836, -0.014682753942906857, 0.05435755476355553, 0.01512729562819004, 0.04107332602143288, 0.07445240765810013, -0.004373644944280386, -0.07135844975709915, -0.003208621172234416, -0.008182116784155369, -0.011846906505525112, 0.05343636870384216, 0.010276584886014462, -0.013369057327508926, -0.061142150312662125, -0.022494852542877197, -0.05023481324315071, -0.026512159034609795, 0.026578057557344437, 0.04149286076426506, -0.013678616844117641, -0.013690450228750706, -0.014930952340364456, -0.006386598572134972, -0.02622021920979023, 0.053489383310079575, 0.00035989758907817304, 0.01465987041592598, 0.034983377903699875, 0.04476005584001541, 0.03619617596268654, 0.07200023531913757, 0.013327219523489475, 0.036967966705560684, 0.01191524975001812, 0.022654104977846146, -0.04329962655901909, 0.018104111775755882, -0.0913476049900055, 0.01038279291242361, -0.0026652568485587835, 0.03247688338160515, -0.022941935807466507, 0.030289920046925545, 0.03064870834350586, -0.07336083054542542, 0.006938078440725803, 0.04248965531587601, -0.02901487611234188, -0.0431487001478672, -0.005694787483662367, 0.008169978857040405, 0.03289000689983368, 0.016860779374837875, 0.012464740313589573, 0.0020229865331202745, -0.034304000437259674, -0.008222850039601326, 0.003317270427942276, 0.011857187375426292, -0.0019356816774234176, 0.002774639055132866, -0.0285316314548254, 0.03622537851333618, 0.004563378635793924, 0.009581753052771091, -0.01953529752790928, 0.0090992022305727, 0.032048169523477554, -0.000925295171327889, -0.0131054213270545, -0.033681511878967285, 0.05796321853995323, -0.05170804634690285, 0.05428424850106239, -0.032220955938100815, -0.04646836593747139, -0.013891383074223995, -0.020844196900725365, 0.008038768544793129, 0.040215034037828445, -0.00596991740167141, -0.04944351315498352, -0.02435944974422455, 0.03514761105179787, 0.018139459192752838, 0.024751687422394753, -0.031135814264416695, 0.09225055575370789, 0.047308314591646194, 0.011004426516592503, 0.06411901861429214, 0.0398368313908577, -0.031299520283937454, 0.018465954810380936, 0.00940697267651558, 0.03665981441736221, 0.00754379341378808, -0.027126384899020195, -0.06298533827066422, -0.022463198751211166, -0.045462287962436676, -0.031487494707107544, 0.044538337737321854, -0.012081870809197426, -0.018580982461571693, 0.010265185497701168, -0.014127729460597038, -0.009744597598910332, -0.039068397134542465, 0.03575441986322403, 0.04067029058933258, -0.08958689868450165, -0.012104092165827751, 0.03798059746623039, -0.053979724645614624, 0.011465704999864101, 0.002302741864696145, -0.062156639993190765, 0.03051389381289482, 0.0383288599550724, -0.03958446905016899, -0.02671980857849121, 0.03321712836623192, -0.01772911660373211, -0.020233727991580963, 0.04651942476630211, 0.03218982741236687, -0.044576387852430344, -0.028510799631476402, 0.0027723407838493586, -0.03321968391537666, 0.014359029941260815, -0.0020466367714107037, 0.024259289726614952, 0.00872882641851902, -0.004495111294090748, -0.0070900809951126575, -0.022437164559960365, 0.02066459134221077, 0.05213996395468712, 0.021889973431825638, 0.005632382817566395, 0.05562582239508629, -0.1112465113401413, -0.005331054329872131, 0.014804063364863396, -0.037162113934755325, 0.08395259082317352, 0.01719430834054947, -0.06990796327590942, -0.039476703852415085, -0.020816298201680183, -0.00575097044929862, -0.03395640105009079, 0.07244545966386795, 0.024756107479333878, 0.005711785051971674, -0.012754128314554691, 0.03466755524277687, 0.06646951287984848, 0.02862604707479477, -0.059882912784814835, -0.02125656045973301, 0.018813731148838997, 0.038586828857660294, 0.029092634096741676, -0.0003752394113689661, 0.08325111865997314, -0.018848685547709465, 0.00961992610245943, 0.0005310471751727164, -0.007256292272359133, 0.01744537428021431, -0.012461937963962555, 0.04602208361029625, -0.027783144265413284, -0.056982334703207016, 0.0491979643702507, 0.012607960030436516, -0.041648879647254944, 0.009975789114832878, 0.018880924209952354, 0.02091696858406067, -0.0549381822347641, 0.05283735319972038, -0.028019994497299194, -0.008678240701556206, -0.031429242342710495, 0.0007010523113422096, 0.033371224999427795, -0.03246699273586273, -0.048708122223615646, -0.00845425110310316, 0.03737517073750496, -0.07460016757249832, 0.016068482771515846, 0.01990441232919693, 0.00963306613266468, 0.06026297062635422, -0.03218567743897438, -0.01990470103919506, -0.024333178997039795, 0.04545612260699272, 0.009247558191418648, -0.005171691067516804, -0.026703516021370888, 0.002477572998031974, -0.04017999395728111, 0.00924901943653822, 0.0004975421470589936, 0.025202328339219093, 0.01255209743976593, 0.01618378609418869, 0.014148371294140816, -0.04749555140733719, -0.0076841143891215324, -0.017960768193006516, 0.07727066427469254, 0.023113936185836792, 0.039120711386203766, 0.01963363215327263, 0.023713402450084686, -0.02794821560382843, 0.024700578302145004, -0.041026849299669266, -0.014946026727557182, 0.024475261569023132, -0.014380345121026039, -6.048056555566891e-33, 0.006092362571507692, 0.04119809716939926, -0.03442569449543953, -0.047217223793268204, -0.026133587583899498, 0.036949899047613144, -0.01242011971771717, 0.0008144876919686794, -0.039618462324142456, -0.025323672220110893, -0.045757975429296494, 0.0017135506495833397, 0.0036846143193542957, 0.0419304333627224, -0.0014267403166741133, -0.003622869262471795, 0.07968366891145706, -0.018319308757781982, 0.03740668669342995, 0.03587106615304947, 0.0022639005910605192, 0.013523499481379986, 0.0025703522842377424, -0.0712210014462471, -0.09917094558477402, -0.0019384620245546103, -0.009302770718932152, -0.04753976687788963, 0.016290463507175446, 0.012309983372688293, -0.019083671271800995, 0.04114655777812004, 0.008010822348296642, -0.052127398550510406, -0.04330059513449669, 0.01891200803220272, -0.07462302595376968, -0.04437893256545067, -0.06578677147626877, 0.004268594551831484, -0.006135424133390188, -0.0446561798453331, 0.06441600620746613, 0.010482353158295155, -0.025502927601337433, -0.033089399337768555, 0.03341800719499588, -0.017967982217669487, -0.017151033505797386, -0.04743853956460953, 0.002512287814170122, 0.024377914145588875, -0.00034885003697127104, -0.029615940526127815, 0.008740722201764584, 0.038981400430202484, -0.036844540387392044, 0.026604147627949715, -0.05514019727706909, -0.003942242357879877, -0.04269646853208542, 0.07372789829969406, 0.0065337312407791615, 0.018938645720481873, 0.011436489410698414, 0.03765566274523735, -0.021296704187989235, -0.01895330473780632, -0.030350958928465843, -0.026871157810091972, 0.03936167433857918, 0.05863276124000549, 0.05642528831958771, 0.04087190702557564, 0.12219386547803879, -0.09420108795166016, -0.08158469200134277, 0.012152197770774364, -0.00752296531572938, 0.013333718292415142, -0.029590673744678497, 0.03329694643616676, 0.011304636485874653, -0.004113712813705206, 0.01965521089732647, -0.010922050103545189, 0.01590300165116787, -0.04429680109024048, 0.005608084611594677, 0.013392733410000801, -0.005772455129772425, 0.034707024693489075, 0.020366262644529343, -0.09395468235015869, 0.03685508295893669, -0.014031050726771355, -0.002741474425420165, 0.02517230436205864, 0.07752286642789841, -0.010939343832433224, -0.034201864153146744, -0.026643414050340652, 0.02407236397266388, 0.02620614878833294, 0.01900102011859417, 0.0018721616361290216, 0.042820148169994354, 0.04597599804401398, -0.014609197154641151, -0.0317392498254776, 0.0055067278444767, -0.028846343979239464, 0.03179706260561943, 0.03223187103867531, -0.007726235315203667, -0.011972625739872456, 0.013798111118376255, 0.021949952468276024, -0.0010582514805719256, -0.02547183819115162, -0.0023808551486581564, -0.014346152544021606, 0.05311667546629906, 0.01417673658579588, -0.055022455751895905, -0.03437164053320885, -0.05945560336112976, 0.0174998939037323, 0.033794499933719635, -0.0383487343788147, -0.02976527437567711, 0.019114024937152863, 2.9961606173856126e-07, -0.019915437325835228, -0.008930007927119732, -0.03082749992609024, -0.06322598457336426, 0.03292597085237503, 0.049282174557447433, 0.02502148039638996, 0.03891230374574661, -0.034472107887268066, 0.004799018148332834, 0.02676461823284626, 0.006406546104699373, 0.017770923674106598, 0.029247289523482323, -0.026396889239549637, 0.031578436493873596, 0.009642320685088634, 0.009979868307709694, 0.003908462356775999, 0.01577289029955864, 0.07645577192306519, 0.1337563693523407, -0.0020198135171085596, -0.026270000264048576, 0.061115264892578125, -0.006745172198861837, -0.010941687971353531, 0.00018176218145526946, 0.061939507722854614, -0.02000400237739086, 0.0040702419355511665, 0.0723230317234993, -0.04970290884375572, 0.00110843766015023, -0.011768273077905178, 0.020629921928048134, -0.005009530112147331, 0.014487742446362972, -0.014011074788868427, -0.01792413555085659, 0.015873506665229797, 0.014114150777459145, 0.011355428956449032, -0.05910797417163849, 0.055822569876909256, -0.003056097310036421, -0.04366547241806984, -0.06223816052079201, 0.03638656064867973, 0.02008061856031418, 0.012572522275149822, 0.024426331743597984, 0.014752513729035854, -0.01647093892097473, 0.008066592738032341, -0.04816288501024246, -0.04044768959283829, -0.07495598495006561, 0.04582672938704491, 0.02310357801616192, -0.047031864523887634, 0.018077977001667023, -0.037100523710250854, 0.009062983095645905, 0.09908906370401382, 0.05111996456980705, -0.017586644738912582, 2.476542977749415e-34, -0.06038999930024147, 0.01440479513257742, 0.0010263884905725718, 0.019782884046435356, -0.08774702250957489, -0.029364826157689095, 0.024689359590411186, -0.013374222442507744, -0.018708260729908943, 0.0036841833498328924, -0.04080436751246452]
695
695
['Mandar Haldekar', 'Ashwinkumar Ganesan', 'Tim Oates']
1706.04215v1
Traditional approaches to building a large scale knowledge graph have usually relied on extracting information (entities, their properties, and relations between them) from unstructured text (e.g. Dbpedia). Recent advances in Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN) allow us to shift our focus to learning entities and relations from images, as they build robust models that require little or no pre-processing of the images. In this paper, we present an approach to identify and extract spatial relations (e.g., The girl is standing behind the table) from images using CNNs. Our research addresses two specific challenges: providing insight into how spatial relations are learned by the network and which parts of the image are used to predict these relations. We use the pre-trained network VGGNet to extract features from an image and train a Multi-layer Perceptron (MLP) on a set of synthetic images and the sun09 dataset to extract spatial relations. The MLP predicts spatial relations without a bounding box around the objects or the space in the image depicting the relation. To understand how the spatial relations are represented in the network, a heatmap is overlayed on the image to show the regions that are deemed important by the network. Also, we analyze the MLP to show the relationship between the activation of consistent groups of nodes and the prediction of a spatial relation. We show how the loss of these groups affects the networks ability to identify relations.
Identifying Spatial Relations in Images using Convolutional Neural Networks
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1706.04215v1
Title Identifying Spatial Relations Images using Convolutional Neural Networks Summary Traditional approach building large scale knowledge graph usually relied extracting information entity property relation unstructured text eg Dbpedia Recent advance Convolutional Neural Networks CNN allow u shift focus learning entity relation image build robust model require little preprocessing image paper present approach identify extract spatial relation eg girl standing behind table image using CNNs research address two specific challenge providing insight spatial relation learned network part image used predict relation use pretrained network VGGNet extract feature image train Multilayer Perceptron MLP set synthetic image sun09 dataset extract spatial relation MLP predicts spatial relation without bounding box around object space image depicting relation understand spatial relation represented network heatmap overlayed image show region deemed important network Also analyze MLP show relationship activation consistent group node prediction spatial relation show loss group affect network ability identify relation Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.04092583432793617, 0.046911127865314484, -0.0037572721485048532, 0.0848197489976883, -0.026717787608504295, 0.005975028499960899, 0.010528143495321274, 0.008887460455298424, 0.015241685323417187, -0.03622554987668991, -0.016750892624258995, 0.05479459837079048, -0.003973840735852718, 0.024060949683189392, 0.031492460519075394, -0.09592059999704361, -0.002098993631079793, 0.04270000383257866, -0.02278096415102482, 0.0024609765969216824, 0.012407885864377022, 0.018409306183457375, -0.008526010438799858, 0.02137463539838791, -0.09136335551738739, 0.0016018572496250272, 0.01627080701291561, 0.017210455611348152, 0.022270772606134415, -0.03129272162914276, 0.018620675429701805, 0.01670057885348797, 0.03892366960644722, -0.013094617053866386, 2.1564446797128767e-06, -0.0029121157713234425, -0.026954807341098785, -0.0035478698555380106, 0.026139913126826286, -0.0215823482722044, -0.04241928458213806, -0.05375999957323074, 0.026152461767196655, -0.051589999347925186, -0.04102073237299919, -0.021777143701910973, 0.047742344439029694, 0.07731413096189499, 0.008917395025491714, -0.002590370597317815, -0.031046345829963684, -0.057866428047418594, 0.014387874864041805, -0.019487712532281876, 0.019152995198965073, -0.006508559919893742, 0.009477087296545506, 0.003894014284014702, -0.032544929534196854, -0.011127235367894173, -0.04809778928756714, 0.057464636862277985, 0.022312896326184273, -0.0363713875412941, 0.06570545583963394, 0.07402871549129486, -0.04398299381136894, 0.008489344269037247, -0.00029178065597079694, 0.098429836332798, -0.0492175929248333, 0.010775771923363209, 0.009983341209590435, -0.002104491228237748, -0.024697894230484962, 0.046190522611141205, 0.0023519122041761875, -0.01892603188753128, -0.011091061867773533, 0.0020743589848279953, -0.10056333988904953, 0.043758902698755264, -0.007077609188854694, 0.027228083461523056, -0.011409584432840347, 0.02400924079120159, -0.0005416176863946021, 0.0028740244451910257, -0.036106500774621964, -0.01502519752830267, 0.0008692692499607801, -0.04511529207229614, 0.0380156934261322, 0.0449540950357914, 0.008304485119879246, 0.020841538906097412, 0.010826745070517063, 0.0003736285725608468, -0.01008657831698656, -0.07219845801591873, -0.008076130412518978, -0.03535252809524536, -0.054243385791778564, 0.07279636710882187, -0.057191912084817886, 0.03891979902982712, -0.06194814667105675, 0.04348159208893776, -0.021255144849419594, -0.00713239423930645, -0.03619464486837387, -0.007478845771402121, -0.034578751772642136, 0.038185812532901764, -0.031200628727674484, -0.03179480507969856, -0.024744657799601555, -0.04273717850446701, -0.048324327915906906, 0.05056769400835037, -0.018649570643901825, 0.10658703744411469, 0.014536725357174873, -0.022721314802765846, -0.002784269629046321, 0.011733699589967728, -0.012069689109921455, -0.0009769907919690013, -0.07661602646112442, -0.0018557212315499783, 0.06799391657114029, 0.02815522626042366, 0.05974699929356575, -0.007033479865640402, -0.009710531681776047, 0.040566422045230865, 0.02334420196712017, -0.008074448443949223, -0.04980862885713577, -0.03746814280748367, 0.007792158052325249, -0.033374685794115067, 0.07397850602865219, -0.04229435697197914, 0.017436163499951363, -0.04697481915354729, -0.03176296874880791, -0.0002693639835342765, 0.006727293599396944, -0.04195694252848625, -0.06491895020008087, 0.05282103642821312, -0.025424305349588394, 0.0020911365281790495, 0.07781165093183517, 0.01671566814184189, 0.0627829059958458, 0.0012955700512975454, 0.04241255670785904, 0.0400066040456295, 0.010870919562876225, -0.01383076049387455, -0.023951459676027298, 0.0012880874564871192, 0.02898583374917507, -0.027013210579752922, -0.044190455228090286, 0.038071002811193466, -0.029310069978237152, -0.009084912948310375, -0.019788457080721855, 0.032876964658498764, -0.00342807499691844, -0.011610766872763634, 0.02581271156668663, 0.04846784099936485, 0.0028645058628171682, 0.044138018041849136, 0.0054581561125814915, 0.029605872929096222, -0.00307546928524971, 0.006482385564595461, -0.0396290197968483, 0.07381919026374817, 0.01831635646522045, -0.029775237664580345, -0.05493658781051636, 0.006621466483920813, -0.030001629143953323, -0.012865051627159119, 0.025299593806266785, 0.005076603498309851, 0.010825429111719131, 0.004990382120013237, 0.06629594415426254, 0.00987218040972948, -0.007312987465411425, 0.011381101794540882, 0.005877822637557983, 0.05982561409473419, -0.03148847818374634, -0.0015171653358265758, -0.0010437446180731058, -0.006105434149503708, 0.005054486449807882, -0.013423082418739796, -0.03389643877744675, 0.011261731386184692, 0.03205795958638191, -0.0010982429375872016, -0.01752787083387375, -0.005379184149205685, 0.003625920508056879, -0.01662364788353443, -0.05379623547196388, 0.010509297251701355, -0.004940065089613199, 0.006421124096959829, 0.03648609668016434, 0.006214112509042025, 0.04850427806377411, 0.03803907707333565, 0.03553822636604309, 0.02341814525425434, 0.06688186526298523, 0.02953226864337921, -0.010788284242153168, 0.05976215377449989, 0.0020742740016430616, 0.026468126103281975, -0.0018329198937863111, -0.008735607378184795, 0.057855043560266495, -0.03008272685110569, 0.016253182664513588, 0.034767311066389084, -0.028448965400457382, -0.0004002992936875671, -0.001830001943744719, -0.04091041907668114, -0.02546418271958828, -0.024524107575416565, -0.030192939564585686, -0.007416477892547846, 0.0463356114923954, -0.011930316686630249, 0.05118544399738312, 0.01837192475795746, -0.04162546992301941, 0.02120159938931465, 0.013950897380709648, -0.027195189148187637, 0.07719685882329941, -0.01163468137383461, -0.00168659130576998, -0.03713664412498474, -0.024166135117411613, 0.025585632771253586, 0.0022104629315435886, 0.020298156887292862, -0.08261708170175552, -0.042523905634880066, -0.0022499202750623226, -0.01791282743215561, 0.02347565069794655, -0.02265254780650139, 0.038666341453790665, -0.03778466209769249, -0.012959914281964302, 0.014056953601539135, -0.03239299729466438, 0.0016159315127879381, -0.04322446510195732, 0.004506702534854412, -0.06383264809846878, -0.011643831618130207, 0.061875030398368835, -0.0303301140666008, -0.022095808759331703, 0.04480604827404022, -0.013365441933274269, 0.011715665459632874, -0.014350329525768757, -0.023700613528490067, -0.017708012834191322, 0.05244963988661766, 0.0679510086774826, -0.09271656721830368, 0.020430704578757286, 0.029069608077406883, -0.031594399362802505, 0.060267068445682526, 0.014736820012331009, -0.021693333983421326, -1.9817965949187055e-05, -0.028285520151257515, -0.028862498700618744, 0.02333742566406727, -0.0015007928013801575, 0.039718519896268845, -0.020718442276120186, -0.01190918032079935, -0.037013277411460876, 0.021185191348195076, -0.01962808333337307, 0.047641389071941376, 0.06368381530046463, -0.0023396972101181746, -0.05053127557039261, -0.02646295540034771, 0.031681858003139496, -0.015479205176234245, 0.008414078503847122, -0.004220758099108934, -4.458966213860549e-05, 0.014523041434586048, -0.059596989303827286, -0.02997591160237789, 0.05956338346004486, -0.005949249491095543, -0.07914750277996063, -0.032446980476379395, -0.019939547404646873, 0.012019464746117592, 0.011944051831960678, 0.018426869064569473, 0.018380755558609962, 0.000465953053208068, 0.11090885102748871, 0.034194350242614746, 0.029653020203113556, -0.003439530497416854, 0.006739202421158552, -0.015798011794686317, -0.04233487695455551, -0.014151637442409992, 0.009818090125918388, 0.0027054075617343187, -0.07030253112316132, 0.021148700267076492, -0.00024401403788942844, -0.030356956645846367, -0.04569724202156067, -0.011131939478218555, 0.007262391038239002, 0.009105869568884373, -0.014333028346300125, -0.024077769368886948, 0.06303957849740982, 0.023890908807516098, -0.01602233573794365, 0.0044356342405080795, -0.015699300915002823, -0.008184117265045643, -0.010144851170480251, 0.10863512754440308, 0.06680348515510559, 0.0063856723718345165, -0.04314176365733147, 0.03654315322637558, -0.038976509124040604, 0.05995777249336243, -0.08102889358997345, 0.0030836055520921946, -0.07604745775461197, 0.013386019505560398, -0.020546725019812584, -0.0014486813452094793, 0.007240526843816042, -0.013900788500905037, 0.03548923879861832, -0.061820145696401596, -0.0028194524347782135, 0.02503354474902153, 0.03279735520482063, -0.07126890122890472, -0.010266989469528198, 0.03752211481332779, -0.06468978524208069, 0.03942304849624634, 0.0262703076004982, -0.040431682020425797, 0.009106921963393688, -0.040159717202186584, -0.09860628843307495, 0.010573424398899078, -0.05154478922486305, -0.009129269048571587, -0.06969056278467178, 0.031180450692772865, -0.015257885679602623, -0.0799444317817688, -0.07286267727613449, -0.010717424564063549, -0.0032891305163502693, 0.012981679290533066, -0.043006885796785355, -0.034564536064863205, 0.028699560090899467, -0.02761044166982174, 0.015842406079173088, 0.00819754134863615, 0.02912423573434353, 0.00296461652033031, -0.09992895275354385, 0.014895015396177769, 0.01110138650983572, 0.06273150444030762, -0.01352910790592432, -0.022437434643507004, -0.006897356361150742, 0.03642658144235611, 0.0279210414737463, -0.036162119358778, 0.09145507216453552, 0.010957879945635796, 0.0002447235747240484, -0.020634783431887627, -0.0003630485152825713, -0.004562607500702143, 0.036190785467624664, 0.012150957249104977, 0.026514336466789246, -0.00933831837028265, 0.02169993706047535, -0.054297566413879395, 0.03791391849517822, 0.03697850927710533, -0.028273949399590492, 0.009341566823422909, 0.02400541678071022, -0.04572170600295067, -0.009867724031209946, 0.0646355152130127, -0.03419194743037224, 0.024779677391052246, 0.017190957441926003, -0.04369734972715378, 0.02266041748225689, -0.036795563995838165, 0.009081218391656876, 0.03952692076563835, 0.011909348890185356, 0.026502735912799835, -0.025483576580882072, 0.02582351490855217, -0.03321978449821472, -0.09504590928554535, 0.009211975149810314, 0.010275950655341148, 0.03549513220787048, 0.04886613413691521, 0.021017493680119514, 0.0514761246740818, -0.030095843598246574, -0.011332887224853039, -0.037945568561553955, -0.07769928872585297, 0.010677830316126347, -0.019473891705274582, 0.06178565323352814, 0.006290815770626068, 0.009083476848900318, -0.01980062760412693, -0.02405182458460331, -0.002159378258511424, 0.003281400306150317, -0.04986046627163887, -0.0429292656481266, -0.01687169447541237, -0.037613239139318466, -0.0173199400305748, -0.005250854883342981, -0.01845746859908104, 0.05145188048481941, 0.044193945825099945, -0.05852079764008522, -0.06056248024106026, -0.046362776309251785, -0.026642221957445145, -0.03734707459807396, 0.060883209109306335, 0.01490034069865942, 0.004744440782815218, -0.028159189969301224, 0.012167482636868954, -0.004136279691010714, 0.00519126933068037, -0.03969424590468407, -0.009444007650017738, 0.028902802616357803, 0.029186030849814415, -0.012032510712742805, -0.04129524528980255, 0.04884635657072067, 0.006212236825376749, 0.014811470173299313, -0.0035891400184482336, 0.019231753423810005, -0.018209580332040787, 0.003723317990079522, 0.04390062764286995, -0.020973477512598038, 0.023396117612719536, 0.008015220053493977, 0.04201140254735947, 0.007321205921471119, -0.018994411453604698, 0.029605725780129433, -0.025968482717871666, -0.07846906781196594, 0.030359268188476562, 0.030533157289028168, -0.013532184064388275, -0.021679352968931198, 0.02658700756728649, 0.08727438002824783, -0.04243093356490135, -0.0021914979442954063, -0.002380641410127282, 0.0029849964193999767, 0.02480068989098072, 0.0471789613366127, -0.03668362647294998, -0.02128739282488823, 0.057693056762218475, -0.007691399194300175, 0.025362830609083176, 0.013248316012322903, 0.025284841656684875, 0.04277939721941948, 0.0007743267924524844, 0.046102821826934814, -0.055733468383550644, -0.024639640003442764, 0.02784535102546215, 0.01749112643301487, 0.00770789897069335, -0.008945678360760212, 0.03638586029410362, -0.02938881143927574, -0.03876474127173424, -0.018769901245832443, -0.017243189737200737, 0.0032368372194468975, 0.06584113091230392, 0.025410104542970657, -0.02216462232172489, 0.04085085913538933, -0.05497439205646515, -0.018904902040958405, 0.00034879695158451796, -0.012609920464456081, -0.018884623423218727, -0.023948268964886665, -5.8918645804113026e-33, 0.005954810418188572, -0.10889562964439392, 0.024193111807107925, -0.01693347841501236, -0.04843306168913841, 0.03559606149792671, -0.03902820497751236, -0.06698103249073029, -0.06707409769296646, 0.03605634719133377, -0.022416802123188972, 0.001039704424329102, 0.01844966970384121, 0.01976291835308075, 0.01906461827456951, -0.006473343353718519, -0.011714997701346874, -0.009563800878822803, 0.06970316171646118, 0.02098730206489563, 0.001806800253689289, 0.03041324019432068, 0.05136382207274437, -0.10811152309179306, -0.042856909334659576, 0.023066207766532898, 0.0262093897908926, 0.02519206516444683, -0.011379136703908443, 0.005625514313578606, -0.03796267881989479, -0.016434606164693832, 0.036943383514881134, -0.005321314558386803, 0.005437637213617563, 0.0033546036574989557, -0.10819083452224731, -0.025080392137169838, -0.04956498742103577, 0.03362882882356644, -0.0291528832167387, 0.023836646229028702, 0.03553002327680588, 0.0074456362053751945, 0.05637820437550545, -0.04776732251048088, 0.07384917885065079, -0.003347221529111266, -0.04812498390674591, -0.02199268713593483, -0.032594308257102966, 0.02873470075428486, -0.02142822928726673, -0.009677322581410408, 0.05724670737981796, -0.043923068791627884, 0.030698135495185852, 0.02873067930340767, -0.06922415643930435, 0.03246750310063362, -0.015457062050700188, 0.009776011109352112, 0.021269364282488823, 0.030833547934889793, 0.012736656703054905, 0.050797782838344574, 0.023839693516492844, -0.018290074542164803, -0.03979172185063362, -0.0036504992749542, 0.007040000986307859, 0.08419548720121384, 0.02328554354608059, -0.012121100910007954, 0.05339657887816429, -0.022638892754912376, -0.05516154319047928, -0.00041791261173784733, -0.06071000173687935, 0.04019279032945633, -0.06471356004476547, -0.005075045395642519, -0.008631370961666107, -0.0069329808466136456, 0.05071451887488365, -0.030820051208138466, -0.02536783553659916, -0.037212975323200226, 0.007117771543562412, -0.023628655821084976, -0.0015491156373172998, 0.07129974663257599, 0.00563304778188467, -0.04851101338863373, -0.009053860791027546, 0.0068333568051457405, 0.03407087177038193, 0.043866440653800964, 0.012694057077169418, 0.012287886813282967, -0.049865759909152985, -0.025931231677532196, 0.0025284590665251017, 0.012650156393647194, 0.0166986882686615, 0.05333062261343002, 0.06535382568836212, 0.00480246776714921, 0.024560976773500443, -0.019537992775440216, -0.024889858439564705, -0.05816161260008812, 0.0032301126047968864, 0.00819691363722086, -0.018096350133419037, 0.0027729568537324667, -0.007490142248570919, 0.040167905390262604, 0.05583833158016205, 0.017884748056530952, 0.030108215287327766, 0.0030882232822477818, 0.0009552057017572224, 0.019185654819011688, 0.014701653271913528, -0.01248534768819809, -0.0737437754869461, -0.02281995676457882, 0.02420673705637455, -0.0619746632874012, -0.0008292568381875753, 0.00975900236517191, 2.7351600806468923e-07, 0.02747833915054798, 0.015087719075381756, 0.07648008316755295, 0.006649307440966368, -0.0015804733848199248, -0.00621921056881547, 0.028242701664566994, 0.02671194262802601, -0.07404550909996033, 0.010478383861482143, 0.0491289347410202, 0.02786117233335972, 0.017390115186572075, 0.035560932010412216, -0.05869206041097641, 0.010518408380448818, -0.04141664877533913, -0.04966631531715393, -0.041805192828178406, -0.002691156230866909, 0.06682199984788895, 0.017985230311751366, 0.03783371299505234, -0.023729482665657997, 0.002626978326588869, -0.013996212743222713, -0.011619582772254944, -0.022800201550126076, 0.06882602721452713, 0.02489238604903221, 0.016530927270650864, -0.034327201545238495, -0.04919413477182388, 0.059048015624284744, -0.02135547250509262, -0.017062515020370483, 0.01299204584211111, -0.01921134442090988, -0.016173407435417175, 0.022183645516633987, 0.013723891228437424, -0.013208462856709957, 0.018168702721595764, -0.08116541802883148, 0.06613989919424057, -0.043903425335884094, 0.015060335397720337, 0.02120177634060383, 0.028034644201397896, 0.026827191933989525, 0.006757452618330717, -0.007123880088329315, 0.001871203538030386, -0.01614277996122837, 0.009617699310183525, -0.058416325598955154, -0.01860637031495571, -0.07081760466098785, -0.008919291198253632, 0.021117746829986572, -0.0034870514646172523, 0.04420623555779457, 0.010491983965039253, -0.05189218744635582, 0.04368729889392853, 0.03214104101061821, -0.05059363692998886, 2.2712020225825123e-34, -0.03843355551362038, 0.026586458086967468, -0.00632169283926487, 0.027982037514448166, -0.014688941650092602, -0.025258176028728485, -0.06853948533535004, 0.008366093039512634, -0.015240766108036041, 0.005317480769008398, -0.012107760645449162]
696
696
['Adam R. Kosiorek', 'Alex Bewley', 'Ingmar Posner']
1706.09262v2
Class-agnostic object tracking is particularly difficult in cluttered environments as target specific discriminative models cannot be learned a priori. Inspired by how the human visual cortex employs spatial attention and separate "where" and "what" processing pathways to actively suppress irrelevant visual features, this work develops a hierarchical attentive recurrent model for single object tracking in videos. The first layer of attention discards the majority of background by selecting a region containing the object of interest, while the subsequent layers tune in on visual features particular to the tracked object. This framework is fully differentiable and can be trained in a purely data driven fashion by gradient methods. To improve training convergence, we augment the loss function with terms for a number of auxiliary tasks relevant for tracking. Evaluation of the proposed model is performed on two datasets: pedestrian tracking on the KTH activity recognition dataset and the more difficult KITTI object tracking dataset.
Hierarchical Attentive Recurrent Tracking
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1706.09262v2
Title Hierarchical Attentive Recurrent Tracking Summary Classagnostic object tracking particularly difficult cluttered environment target specific discriminative model cannot learned priori Inspired human visual cortex employ spatial attention separate processing pathway actively suppress irrelevant visual feature work develops hierarchical attentive recurrent model single object tracking video first layer attention discard majority background selecting region containing object interest subsequent layer tune visual feature particular tracked object framework fully differentiable trained purely data driven fashion gradient method improve training convergence augment loss function term number auxiliary task relevant tracking Evaluation proposed model performed two datasets pedestrian tracking KTH activity recognition dataset difficult KITTI object tracking dataset Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.01399760227650404, 0.014225639402866364, 0.017151782289147377, 0.07335303723812103, 0.02937290258705616, -0.009481535293161869, -0.004146979656070471, -0.015994062647223473, -0.03165788576006889, -0.03880343213677406, 0.004369891248643398, -0.02563496306538582, -0.006857514381408691, 0.0307307206094265, 0.03230918198823929, -0.08862744271755219, -0.003939707763493061, 0.02110210992395878, -0.033294133841991425, 0.05790888890624046, 0.051366034895181656, -0.015129084698855877, 0.040983788669109344, 0.024187417700886726, -0.02749510668218136, 0.010362939909100533, -0.004238788969814777, -0.00805742759257555, 0.0454367995262146, -0.06833846122026443, 0.062420524656772614, -0.00412568636238575, 0.042478855699300766, 0.024481141939759254, 1.9647031876957044e-06, 0.009026020765304565, 0.04478118196129799, -0.022588340565562248, 0.01913752593100071, -0.09602528065443039, -0.029178058728575706, -0.013126207515597343, 0.023430418223142624, 0.025802597403526306, 0.008192886598408222, 0.012403236702084541, 0.02026735432446003, 0.023386120796203613, 0.015935515984892845, 0.012402660213410854, -0.004067013040184975, -0.03713598474860191, 0.05140051990747452, -0.03600617125630379, 0.04561660438776016, -0.026061423122882843, 0.02550974301993847, -0.04256756231188774, -0.032766424119472504, 0.0120136933401227, -0.040305767208337784, 0.005028259940445423, 0.0034604871179908514, 0.018766263499855995, 0.08334255963563919, 0.011164483614265919, 0.0055291359312832355, -0.01996920257806778, 0.026514166966080666, 0.06811914592981339, -0.052336353808641434, 0.004079829901456833, 0.013804182410240173, 0.01988786831498146, -0.017343662679195404, -0.0603024959564209, -0.03160301595926285, 0.0035696292761713266, -0.01947180926799774, 0.005087277386337519, -0.04103248193860054, 0.040504854172468185, -0.0008003145921975374, 0.017474861815571785, 0.023561924695968628, -0.04460320621728897, -0.021781228482723236, -0.0024175012949854136, -0.01715206913650036, 0.017513325437903404, 0.05538560822606087, -0.049288637936115265, 0.01920497417449951, 0.007741845212876797, 0.002854681573808193, -0.01880093291401863, -0.03641116991639137, -0.05936252325773239, -0.019865894690155983, -0.04564359411597252, 0.026712695136666298, -0.0018482435261830688, -0.00570276565849781, 0.035917043685913086, 0.036367010325193405, 0.05789342150092125, -0.11139276623725891, -0.026814252138137817, 0.016492372378706932, 0.006037365645170212, -0.05932941660284996, 0.04136441648006439, -0.019206199795007706, 0.024616597220301628, 0.002174919005483389, -0.005530305206775665, -0.003799088066443801, 0.014212059788405895, 0.006480487063527107, -0.04211568832397461, -0.03127449378371239, 0.03783882036805153, -0.03436920419335365, -0.013510594144463539, 0.030138162896037102, 0.010364007204771042, -0.031495943665504456, 0.022130217403173447, -0.01122260745614767, 0.007465347182005644, 0.005463195964694023, 0.0702459067106247, 0.017965465784072876, 0.007544040679931641, -0.01761447638273239, 0.04289398342370987, 0.019752880558371544, -0.02068512514233589, -0.05501128360629082, 0.06288304179906845, 0.03490418940782547, -0.04911472648382187, 0.02016321010887623, -0.03623593598604202, 0.001538046752102673, -0.0449761301279068, -0.046272750943899155, -0.019011374562978745, 0.00021135457791388035, -0.006354768294841051, -0.03397104889154434, 0.016717225313186646, -0.03805788233876228, -0.029359888285398483, 0.02830021269619465, -0.03421428054571152, 0.01658649370074272, 0.04077717661857605, 0.048486486077308655, 0.04462451487779617, -0.045713357627391815, 0.001829886925406754, 0.04499857872724533, -0.027812793850898743, -0.037408195436000824, 0.0010043331421911716, -0.053924810141325, -0.010132553987205029, -0.042670778930187225, 0.01213174406439066, 0.03382797911763191, 0.014366338029503822, 0.019996825605630875, -0.00407879613339901, 0.02824416197836399, 0.017320983111858368, -0.006425298750400543, 0.010916330851614475, 0.010308364406228065, -0.0049318731762468815, -0.03961191326379776, -0.016895754262804985, -0.03788672387599945, 0.0761137455701828, -0.002520339097827673, -0.03154567629098892, -0.06919533759355545, -0.0009204355301335454, -0.044573958963155746, -0.013379430398344994, 0.014757795259356499, 0.0043291933834552765, 0.03225076198577881, 0.017881816253066063, 0.06703916937112808, 0.0032134572975337505, -0.01686338521540165, -0.021810995414853096, -0.020488260313868523, 0.01662774384021759, -0.015207729302346706, -0.014844544231891632, 0.04307004436850548, 0.02174449898302555, -0.019622888416051865, -0.020485496148467064, -0.019399192184209824, -0.06542739272117615, 0.04873274266719818, 0.0032462396193295717, -0.07201217859983444, 0.015677766874432564, 0.02814103290438652, -0.0685998871922493, -0.05702622979879379, 0.010814731009304523, 0.013353372924029827, -0.006223724689334631, -0.012907166965305805, -0.04722798615694046, 0.034135852009058, 0.05909613147377968, -0.003902914235368371, 0.0746585875749588, 0.05117090791463852, 0.05093064904212952, -0.028278296813368797, 0.029624834656715393, 0.04898197948932648, 0.01411005761474371, 0.018273746594786644, -0.03317056596279144, 0.04470278322696686, -0.033907413482666016, 0.04511691629886627, -0.05936729535460472, 0.05091102421283722, -0.0010033861035481095, 0.02835076116025448, -0.01090268511325121, -0.03198857605457306, 0.03113786317408085, -0.025159329175949097, -0.035087086260318756, -0.0004471086722332984, -0.06177923083305359, -0.002665703883394599, 0.0025976281613111496, 0.007865376770496368, 0.04318500682711601, 0.01010342687368393, -0.011685749515891075, 0.0400521419942379, -0.03910655528306961, -0.021139074116945267, 0.01707031950354576, 0.022478220984339714, 0.045876361429691315, -0.04679148271679878, 0.010305451229214668, -0.023271899670362473, -0.03097439929842949, -0.008578776381909847, -0.010497954674065113, 0.04684668034315109, -0.018082518130540848, -0.0012397445971146226, 0.06161712855100632, 0.001254251692444086, -0.06932566314935684, -0.008255830965936184, -0.038566868752241135, -0.016431882977485657, 0.018459441140294075, -0.06925846636295319, -0.03778659552335739, 0.047954995185136795, -0.04928088188171387, -0.024287957698106766, 0.03353276476264, 0.010788683779537678, -0.01927577517926693, -0.03573695197701454, 0.029984161257743835, 0.02509124204516411, -0.009436641819775105, 0.013714736327528954, -0.05822138488292694, 0.006472190376371145, 0.0101102814078331, -0.005589134059846401, 0.06261493265628815, -0.006587706506252289, -0.03382889926433563, -0.011709236539900303, 0.012120567262172699, 0.02745863050222397, 0.09234607964754105, 0.020496385172009468, 0.014110966585576534, -0.04334969446063042, 0.006243493407964706, 0.016290239989757538, 0.011503491550683975, 0.005502053536474705, 0.01756250485777855, -0.012304558418691158, 0.022097434848546982, -0.04284891486167908, 0.01779368706047535, -0.027716422453522682, 0.03322472795844078, -0.031751926988363266, -0.04210157319903374, -0.015146948397159576, -0.005815662909299135, -0.05327625572681427, 0.01613604836165905, -0.018654152750968933, 0.03378482908010483, -0.01358979195356369, -0.028676124289631844, -0.020785285159945488, 0.023717595264315605, -0.03525806590914726, 0.032636478543281555, 0.005348647944629192, 0.015521185472607613, 0.01284101977944374, 0.03962421417236328, 0.011352804489433765, -0.0221058689057827, -0.01322219055145979, -0.0137858921661973, -0.014274814166128635, -0.032012470066547394, 0.0011633464600890875, 0.04438569024205208, -0.028338603675365448, 0.0008630598895251751, -0.009160834364593029, -0.02988594025373459, -0.013956128619611263, -0.006370484363287687, -0.022307364270091057, -0.02410486340522766, -0.07230072468519211, 0.011156135238707066, -0.04685778170824051, -0.00014118554827291518, 0.015195654705166817, 0.07083063572645187, 0.015151523053646088, -0.0025739208795130253, 0.022988906130194664, 0.004054323770105839, 0.048191964626312256, 0.02307293564081192, -0.047771476209163666, -0.036077890545129776, -0.013026355765759945, 0.052161894738674164, -0.005510027054697275, -0.02771671675145626, -0.0693957582116127, 0.01417952124029398, 0.005356980953365564, 0.021972287446260452, -0.03635750710964203, 0.040368568152189255, 0.04853181913495064, -0.07363162189722061, -0.003791502444073558, 0.016082141548395157, -0.023624960333108902, -0.039122793823480606, -0.01443998608738184, 0.03943760693073273, -0.0018514040857553482, 0.04877812787890434, -0.011662646196782589, 0.0035970325116068125, -0.01182213518768549, -0.005335880909115076, 0.04672807827591896, 0.038743406534194946, -0.017533784732222557, 0.012942162342369556, 0.011567559093236923, 0.0628194808959961, 0.00804971344769001, -0.11323150247335434, -0.0432022288441658, 0.016986815258860588, 0.007874648086726665, -0.038265276700258255, -0.04058599844574928, 0.030208900570869446, -1.8902719602920115e-05, -0.04071453958749771, 0.02232094667851925, -0.05970637872815132, 0.02715853974223137, 0.011980597861111164, -0.05021464452147484, 0.03208145126700401, 0.05112095922231674, 0.03234529122710228, -0.015877068042755127, -0.021857570856809616, -0.05684230476617813, -0.01152679044753313, 0.005867621395736933, -0.008286220952868462, 0.008958421647548676, -0.06289365142583847, -0.01974661648273468, -0.03761344403028488, 0.08427713811397552, -0.03846636787056923, 0.011546989902853966, 0.01027064397931099, 0.011350668966770172, -0.029392855241894722, 0.01450044009834528, -0.06729964911937714, -0.03704266995191574, 0.041425615549087524, 0.014217937365174294, -0.009627539664506912, -0.028996633365750313, -0.006739101838320494, -0.014039848931133747, -0.04014330729842186, -0.003326213685795665, -0.033996738493442535, 0.001008843071758747, -0.06106379255652428, -0.03689034655690193, -0.03772599622607231, -0.0532090961933136, 0.017863379791378975, 0.03668444976210594, -0.00504903681576252, -0.013204079121351242, 0.017125144600868225, -0.016368990764021873, -0.011099527589976788, 0.03944702446460724, 0.04006177932024002, 0.008286794647574425, -0.03226166218519211, -0.0018104860791936517, 0.020942818373441696, -0.00512657081708312, 0.0273069366812706, 0.010516948066651821, -0.08169189840555191, 0.03645450994372368, 0.026558339595794678, 0.0546148344874382, 0.006656411569565535, 0.07568234205245972, -0.027677493169903755, -0.023096881806850433, -0.08038963377475739, -0.09163565188646317, 0.02770662121474743, 0.004623684100806713, 0.03282174468040466, -0.05319959670305252, -0.026791036128997803, 0.0035210021305829287, -0.04348341003060341, 0.08510437607765198, 0.034674644470214844, -0.047549158334732056, -0.11408454924821854, 0.009578418917953968, -0.02575540915131569, -0.05516097694635391, 0.0852157473564148, -0.017987310886383057, -0.015734389424324036, -0.017667926847934723, 0.016053494065999985, 0.03432475030422211, 0.00229299976490438, -0.07590388506650925, 0.005316581577062607, 0.01887362077832222, 0.012888343073427677, -0.004110579378902912, -0.018065042793750763, 0.05111934617161751, -0.06821929663419724, -0.0334361307322979, 0.02864467166364193, -0.06364850699901581, 0.05630652979016304, -0.03078470006585121, 0.019515689462423325, -0.006102869752794504, 0.028900951147079468, 0.019211607053875923, 0.05668396130204201, 0.05535605177283287, 0.04936864972114563, 0.0389043390750885, 0.02263723686337471, -0.025397200137376785, -0.00603617075830698, -0.0010043435031548142, 0.05558127164840698, -0.062302831560373306, 0.05194288492202759, 0.0457492433488369, -0.028826793655753136, -0.008452069945633411, 0.050680506974458694, -0.0013383104233071208, -0.031416166573762894, 0.08859005570411682, 0.0017446918645873666, -0.025563320145010948, 0.006293017882853746, -0.0028644059784710407, -0.03575420752167702, -0.014617865905165672, 0.046400561928749084, 0.09187863022089005, -0.022955704480409622, 0.023091265931725502, 0.0005344083765521646, -0.027622424066066742, 0.011609458364546299, 0.04475737363100052, 0.05032298341393471, 0.002617668127641082, 0.03246266767382622, 0.002805605297908187, -0.027959922328591347, -0.0022146047558635473, -0.029859555885195732, 0.03652622550725937, 0.01304328441619873, 0.03863086923956871, -0.013696734793484211, -0.02483385242521763, -0.030906585976481438, -0.016118893399834633, -0.05372093245387077, 0.018919548019766808, 0.0003913915134035051, -0.04590830206871033, -5.743311114484151e-33, -0.023081732913851738, -0.009169957600533962, -0.019642919301986694, 0.013526254333555698, -0.06038794293999672, -0.0028441809117794037, -0.057729341089725494, -0.0008472523768432438, -0.027467520907521248, -0.016020698472857475, 0.016295133158564568, 0.02979091741144657, -0.0008343821973539889, 0.05028705671429634, 0.0512600876390934, -0.003725784132257104, 0.02998383715748787, -0.015535739250481129, 0.03568968549370766, -0.0074225012212991714, 0.03949476405978203, 0.017974918708205223, 0.03255912661552429, -0.0890430212020874, -0.009591386653482914, -0.047643162310123444, -0.009674693457782269, 0.0349711999297142, -0.0012536677531898022, 0.026717230677604675, -0.019594630226492882, -0.02432134747505188, 0.021153423935174942, -0.01847061887383461, -0.02936409041285515, 0.041033945977687836, -0.03331858292222023, -0.003203968284651637, -0.05191957205533981, 0.01698540523648262, -0.05535867437720299, -0.013511914759874344, 0.06194373965263367, -0.008824639022350311, 0.04275619611144066, 0.006339299958199263, 0.06129327416419983, -0.055218279361724854, -0.03604506328701973, -0.006969914305955172, -0.005729145370423794, 0.021489355713129044, -0.04533310607075691, -0.014608966186642647, 0.0381166897714138, -0.022276243194937706, -0.0005596664268523455, -0.008362041786313057, -0.10526599735021591, -0.013055947609245777, -0.0447896271944046, 0.011015032418072224, 0.02062530815601349, 0.07100750505924225, 0.012361254543066025, 0.026597045361995697, 0.023852011188864708, 0.01500010211020708, -0.034354399889707565, -0.05986238643527031, -0.018291089683771133, 0.07443990558385849, 0.07855459302663803, -0.009234923869371414, 0.007942266762256622, 0.017615925520658493, -0.09419772773981094, 0.00426848279312253, -0.027969524264335632, 0.07432132959365845, -0.04902536794543266, 0.054065246134996414, -0.04533472657203674, 0.022273268550634384, 0.07859667390584946, 0.015447153709828854, 0.005660892929881811, -0.029852556064724922, 0.027898019179701805, 0.005451600532978773, 0.002180793322622776, 0.019950956106185913, 0.015605762600898743, -0.008549530990421772, 0.0713622197508812, -0.03631483390927315, 0.042771439999341965, 0.04403398558497429, 0.01975386030972004, 0.01428943406790495, -0.055015966296195984, -0.015009959228336811, 0.03014908730983734, 0.00536636495962739, -0.02284037321805954, 0.043679676949977875, 0.059633318334817886, -0.0060322158969938755, 0.00882382970303297, -0.00543398130685091, 0.009050805121660233, -0.01443236693739891, 0.00014233883121050894, 0.09624330699443817, 0.02722831815481186, -0.06186985597014427, 0.015083350241184235, 0.12519939243793488, -0.02107131853699684, -0.030662143602967262, -0.018259042873978615, 0.008938314393162727, 0.05763090401887894, 0.020567694678902626, -0.004394485615193844, -0.02728855423629284, -0.0667475238442421, -0.04506276175379753, 0.021094460040330887, -0.011377327144145966, 0.005064396187663078, 0.03940490633249283, 2.6638807071321935e-07, -0.014422436244785786, -0.02354881353676319, 0.04474260285496712, -0.0780540481209755, -0.006628507282584906, 0.01889900676906109, -0.014541716314852238, 0.05673651024699211, -0.034236546605825424, -0.021754905581474304, 0.02457304485142231, 0.007816496305167675, 0.0286579392850399, -0.013611680828034878, -0.044810835272073746, -0.007332070730626583, -0.008803765289485455, 0.0032886583358049393, -0.03969433158636093, 0.021671945229172707, -0.010690688155591488, 0.12100286781787872, 0.05271553248167038, 0.022291813045740128, 0.05389370769262314, 0.012941849417984486, 0.0018701569642871618, 0.026064753532409668, 0.011494431644678116, -0.03448486328125, -0.013116620481014252, 0.06342540681362152, -0.07190284878015518, 0.0033002218697220087, -0.0384519100189209, 0.02096439339220524, 0.028694722801446915, 0.05961892381310463, -0.09725037217140198, 0.010337993502616882, -0.007673732936382294, 0.01922091655433178, 0.03181910514831543, -0.020086519420146942, -0.004330227617174387, -0.028961803764104843, -0.025063330307602882, 0.031070685014128685, 0.030335407704114914, 0.022104302421212196, 1.4080243090575095e-05, 0.020541846752166748, 0.01640523225069046, -0.06817695498466492, 0.01955283246934414, -0.04707050696015358, -0.04339740052819252, -0.0584004782140255, -0.009292871691286564, -0.029220152646303177, -0.05142127349972725, 0.029264284297823906, -0.016444839537143707, 0.012424606829881668, 0.05826185271143913, 0.051317233592271805, -0.0398593433201313, 1.5665956706371372e-34, 0.02367769367992878, 0.019602350890636444, -0.03222308307886124, 0.00966580305248499, 0.01618530973792076, 0.002889912575483322, -0.04776804521679878, 0.013237250968813896, 0.023297663778066635, -0.014081085100769997, 0.017166979610919952]
697
697
['Seungkyun Hong', 'Seongchan Kim', 'Minsu Joh', 'Sa-kwang Song']
1711.10644v2
Predicting unseen weather phenomena is an important issue for disaster management. In this paper, we suggest a model for a convolutional sequence-to-sequence autoencoder for predicting undiscovered weather situations from previous satellite images. We also propose a symmetric skip connection between encoder and decoder modules to produce more comprehensive image predictions. To examine our model performance, we conducted experiments for each suggested model to predict future satellite images from historical satellite images. A specific combination of skip connection and sequence-to-sequence autoencoder was able to generate closest prediction from the ground truth image.
PSIque: Next Sequence Prediction of Satellite Images using a Convolutional Sequence-to-Sequence Network
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1711.10644v2
Title PSIque Next Sequence Prediction Satellite Images using Convolutional SequencetoSequence Network Summary Predicting unseen weather phenomenon important issue disaster management paper suggest model convolutional sequencetosequence autoencoder predicting undiscovered weather situation previous satellite image also propose symmetric skip connection encoder decoder module produce comprehensive image prediction examine model performance conducted experiment suggested model predict future satellite image historical satellite image specific combination skip connection sequencetosequence autoencoder able generate closest prediction ground truth image Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.018754642456769943, 0.09524159133434296, -0.001475048717111349, 0.04831339046359062, 0.0031933083664625883, 0.010652001947164536, -0.0016888133250176907, -0.025227637961506844, -0.002432959619909525, 0.02826281450688839, 0.0632391944527626, -0.02445962280035019, 0.020399456843733788, 0.09698973596096039, 0.029526859521865845, -0.08901099115610123, 0.04014236852526665, 0.007683932781219482, -0.014587911777198315, 0.0007967465207912028, -0.0017560902051627636, -0.06161316856741905, 0.02388901077210903, 0.027978168800473213, -0.011459281668066978, 0.025240987539291382, -0.057429954409599304, -0.01725281961262226, 0.013180147856473923, -0.08397924900054932, 0.020835142582654953, 0.0469062514603138, 0.06209072098135948, 0.020279578864574432, 2.3096388304111315e-06, 0.01275598630309105, 0.011525350622832775, -0.05817379802465439, 0.009358960203826427, -0.022285761311650276, -0.036600470542907715, -0.03124067932367325, 0.0033970095682889223, -0.00853211060166359, -0.06798326969146729, 0.014631266705691814, 0.04839529097080231, 0.0027237602043896914, 0.04993246868252754, 0.037241194397211075, 0.00016184001287911087, -0.05692192167043686, 0.04664870351552963, 0.0013533149613067508, 0.01510560791939497, -0.007330930791795254, 0.027581503614783287, 0.006760126445442438, -0.056754861027002335, -0.01542947068810463, -0.008651688694953918, 0.05041629821062088, 0.05593611299991608, 0.030131259933114052, -0.021077778190374374, 0.0640132799744606, -0.022714806720614433, -0.05428137257695198, -0.058248624205589294, 0.00236894260160625, -0.03995851054787636, -0.0019884526263922453, 0.006561687216162682, 0.014377119019627571, -0.04096648097038269, -0.012373555451631546, -0.03277771919965744, -0.011891634203493595, -0.003061190713196993, 0.01997484639286995, -0.02444053441286087, 0.04190725460648537, -0.029903119429945946, 0.055249184370040894, -0.04259025305509567, 0.02382632903754711, -0.011353297159075737, 0.004841716028749943, -0.046710941940546036, -0.016963081434369087, 0.006386877037584782, -0.04825000464916229, 0.0005280268378555775, 0.008525416254997253, -0.04997507110238075, -0.02211608551442623, -0.04501112923026085, -0.04270130395889282, -0.001946413773111999, -0.05705666542053223, 0.023046106100082397, 0.00440906872972846, 0.011188413947820663, 0.007157023064792156, -0.037266362458467484, 0.05620163679122925, 0.008372720330953598, 0.013357874006032944, 0.0026134096551686525, -0.009683676064014435, -0.0025061785709112883, -0.019655300304293633, 0.01903744414448738, 0.01782296784222126, -0.018378684297204018, -0.03032953292131424, -0.014287353493273258, -0.027041640132665634, 0.0209746602922678, 0.000783967028837651, 0.0014478168450295925, 0.07732854038476944, -0.04623374342918396, -0.004628793336451054, -0.026412609964609146, -0.02990281581878662, 0.01730361208319664, -0.0040216511115431786, 0.050264857709407806, -0.03490050137042999, 0.036604590713977814, -0.008111813105642796, 0.016988778486847878, 0.022535283118486404, -0.015719162300229073, 0.0035055913031101227, 0.005254271440207958, -0.007845403626561165, -0.08020187169313431, 0.02037084847688675, 0.02429838851094246, -0.03420417383313179, -0.02042166329920292, -0.03602909296751022, -0.06972157955169678, -0.011822412721812725, -0.029106223955750465, 0.04913486912846565, 0.024737410247325897, -0.015944533050060272, -0.016313929110765457, 0.05931296944618225, -0.02160564251244068, -0.03320226073265076, 0.03519124910235405, 0.0222050491720438, 0.06302539259195328, 0.028272420167922974, 0.009610981680452824, 0.07480660825967789, 0.020749593153595924, -0.03324964642524719, 0.011093058623373508, -0.01844022236764431, -0.035538218915462494, 0.017055269330739975, -0.08453299850225449, 0.007249398622661829, -0.04907608404755592, -0.0022460855543613434, 0.012134172953665257, -0.051954638212919235, 0.0335141159594059, -0.0314653143286705, -0.007354298140853643, 0.0030732748564332724, 0.023625094443559647, 0.02544545568525791, 0.04654383659362793, 0.036634232848882675, -0.06352163106203079, 0.01770464889705181, -0.015822555869817734, 0.11407053470611572, -0.05909007787704468, 0.025019608438014984, 0.005896481219679117, 0.013135707937180996, -0.029856905341148376, -0.048687782138586044, 0.007853299379348755, 0.0030310817528516054, -0.0106135793030262, -0.0637650117278099, -0.017313022166490555, -0.04322588071227074, -0.039459943771362305, -0.03215666115283966, 0.005252157803624868, 0.02860432118177414, 0.005655272863805294, -0.004316416103392839, -0.010876494459807873, 0.009528678841888905, -0.02947149984538555, 0.0006467850762419403, -0.05132481828331947, -0.004068105015903711, -0.0026240148581564426, -0.017511092126369476, -0.05049556866288185, 0.028876451775431633, -0.01731649599969387, -0.03974572569131851, -0.0703926533460617, 0.0477992482483387, -0.0017240344313904643, 0.0051946211606264114, -0.04560546576976776, 0.06820851564407349, 0.042879752814769745, 0.05185865983366966, -0.0018096162239089608, 0.03391562029719353, -0.0075288028456270695, -0.01437859795987606, 0.016630323603749275, 0.0850016176700592, 0.031817883253097534, -0.005588958039879799, 0.03959450498223305, -0.011142979376018047, 0.05855194851756096, -0.011983642354607582, -0.026833171024918556, -0.005149226635694504, -0.0898793637752533, -0.06966184824705124, -0.012134249322116375, -0.01437208242714405, 0.04181612655520439, 0.09013050049543381, -0.028558557853102684, -0.07495152950286865, 0.08501631766557693, 0.02462412603199482, -0.01562768965959549, -0.026329495012760162, -0.001091170241124928, 0.013249698095023632, 0.01923407055437565, 0.014349744655191898, 0.009809053502976894, -0.08357471227645874, 0.02656991221010685, -0.007387259509414434, 0.016764380037784576, 0.0715479627251625, 0.0018104828195646405, 0.0348520390689373, -0.017985466867685318, -0.029307270422577858, -0.04312236234545708, 0.026620417833328247, 0.014504743739962578, -0.04298005625605583, 0.015434492379426956, 0.017808498814702034, -0.02266707457602024, -0.022265829145908356, 0.008244103752076626, 0.003583752317354083, -0.02007792517542839, -0.014831140637397766, -0.05770476907491684, 0.007060760632157326, 0.06352134048938751, 0.010310531593859196, -0.04727509245276451, 0.06295905262231827, 0.014241664670407772, -0.011519249528646469, -0.020634189248085022, -0.03518364951014519, 0.03183700889348984, 0.07774358242750168, 0.003160456893965602, -0.1228155642747879, -0.04875664412975311, -0.029604600742459297, -0.035735465586185455, 0.013673746958374977, -0.02743721939623356, -0.10039180517196655, -0.013352260924875736, -0.0636252760887146, -0.03537537157535553, -0.012890088371932507, 0.07950983196496964, -0.01932634226977825, -0.029264047741889954, 0.02720012702047825, 0.016553496941924095, 0.012043226510286331, -0.040389709174633026, -0.017957167699933052, 0.01588185504078865, -0.000936455384362489, -0.05384817719459534, 0.0016298122936859727, -0.014711380004882812, 0.03295879811048508, 0.0017750861588865519, 0.02264469861984253, 0.003199090249836445, -0.022987203672528267, -0.01874515227973461, -0.006608118303120136, -0.01158121321350336, 0.01906413584947586, 0.0011394001776352525, -0.03808564692735672, 0.015834497287869453, 0.03932658210396767, 0.008893795311450958, -0.003911424428224564, -0.03038089908659458, 0.004244478885084391, 0.027214055880904198, 0.03166281804442406, 0.019797373563051224, 0.015641195699572563, -0.0289717148989439, -0.010272428393363953, -0.03119748644530773, -0.040250323712825775, 0.010650770738720894, -0.05436832457780838, -0.034294743090867996, -0.007031696382910013, -0.007463017012923956, 0.03090033121407032, -0.048315566033124924, -0.0010256299283355474, 0.005899331998080015, -0.009158358909189701, -0.02171841263771057, 0.02104507014155388, 0.00379477278329432, 0.019132820889353752, -0.02918630838394165, 0.043249502778053284, -0.002916752127930522, 0.01117031928151846, -0.009509132243692875, 0.06446459144353867, 0.04210684448480606, 0.001394081860780716, 0.026030218228697777, 0.030991628766059875, 0.0325092189013958, -0.04001069441437721, -0.028535423800349236, 0.04479988291859627, -0.05979800969362259, 0.03307370841503143, 0.00289316289126873, -0.012070370838046074, -0.019040865823626518, 0.04290034994482994, -0.0008222483447752893, -0.0696951150894165, 0.03224998712539673, 0.04122048243880272, 0.00905658956617117, -0.03339275345206261, 0.014616626314818859, -0.004786935169249773, -0.025425050407648087, 0.02335534617304802, -0.05989788845181465, 0.00029112427728250623, -0.017635008320212364, -0.04217047244310379, -0.06258846819400787, -0.01053580828011036, -0.05127343907952309, -0.018367430195212364, -0.02365449070930481, 0.05384077876806259, -0.005266241263598204, -0.04032674431800842, -0.0566234216094017, -0.08199889212846756, -0.02154979668557644, -0.0005446239956654608, -0.014977503567934036, 0.007078529801219702, 0.044571589678525925, -0.004239864181727171, 0.028535207733511925, -0.02833249792456627, -0.018751436844468117, -0.015326306223869324, -0.06629516929388046, -0.01317064743489027, 0.046290263533592224, 0.023373959586024284, -0.030136048793792725, -0.028440658003091812, -0.027183299884200096, -0.03841622918844223, 0.06349752843379974, -0.008306129835546017, 0.03344221040606499, 0.035011790692806244, -0.014140491373836994, -0.021334046497941017, 0.04840349778532982, -0.04050271213054657, 0.04580794647336006, -0.0038352133706212044, 0.024568526074290276, -0.01434986013919115, -0.019339147955179214, -0.061044808477163315, -0.007362077012658119, 0.07122436165809631, -0.056619446724653244, -0.018589118495583534, 0.02966841123998165, -0.034907788038253784, 0.012618419714272022, 0.057716675102710724, -0.06125263869762421, 0.011663700453937054, 0.03222838416695595, 0.04079446569085121, -0.05642735958099365, -0.03805004060268402, -0.03005317412316799, -0.03442995995283127, 0.044891178607940674, -0.03552370145916939, 0.0036322432570159435, 0.046887192875146866, -0.027013618499040604, -0.03869646415114403, -0.02232912741601467, 0.06736505031585693, 0.012680789455771446, -0.04201337695121765, 0.02549007534980774, 0.014214782044291496, 0.0011051238980144262, -0.018891947343945503, -0.0384615994989872, -0.09645611047744751, 0.042556535452604294, 0.01732839085161686, 0.05537690222263336, 0.0019148718565702438, -0.009304404258728027, 0.04181024059653282, 0.02625826932489872, 0.0120480852201581, 0.030770661309361458, 0.04134536534547806, -0.01994580402970314, 0.019673796370625496, -0.0376007966697216, -0.01531617809087038, -0.002326033543795347, 0.009020580910146236, 0.04681127518415451, -0.028250165283679962, -0.021395722404122353, -0.02158328890800476, -0.03871558979153633, 0.004425944294780493, -0.01308983750641346, 0.11070850491523743, 0.005766584072262049, -0.03381725400686264, 0.01013775821775198, 0.051739469170570374, 0.034867919981479645, 0.015034059062600136, -0.009039345197379589, 0.07344325631856918, 0.013268467038869858, 0.03322826698422432, 0.00395977683365345, 0.0007895339513197541, 0.020589550957083702, -0.07822243124246597, -0.010557970032095909, 0.02330326847732067, 0.005461500026285648, 0.013591277413070202, -0.026714324951171875, 0.019518515095114708, -0.01434861309826374, -0.010724568739533424, 0.05312127247452736, -0.011782053858041763, -0.03517480939626694, -0.00020659710571635514, 0.01862962171435356, 0.05743429437279701, 0.019139420241117477, 0.030990291386842728, -0.006564863491803408, 0.011855470947921276, -0.08188159018754959, -0.0034039667807519436, 0.06025737524032593, 0.000967297179158777, -0.029735766351222992, -0.0035171450581401587, 0.0525868758559227, -0.023828847333788872, 0.02753867208957672, 0.017820747569203377, -0.029755964875221252, 0.03383837267756462, -0.012455384247004986, -0.029130781069397926, 0.05088367313146591, 0.05373784154653549, 0.004547253251075745, 0.004308008123189211, 0.021245893090963364, -0.004290963988751173, -0.04273713007569313, 0.02012043446302414, -0.02288486808538437, 0.0023843080271035433, 0.02783004194498062, 0.03858199343085289, 0.041658394038677216, 0.010857452638447285, 0.025332864373922348, -0.013407072052359581, -0.017166541889309883, -0.007859651930630207, -0.003814510302618146, 0.02371799573302269, -0.018451111391186714, 0.02164999209344387, -0.0026666673365980387, -0.019870057702064514, -0.019507188349962234, 0.004523789044469595, -0.030645228922367096, -6.623527161851634e-33, -0.009516255930066109, -0.010515589267015457, -0.001081965398043394, -0.008134938776493073, -0.03127550706267357, 0.04459017515182495, -0.02345995604991913, -0.02144595794379711, 0.0010637764353305101, -0.03371366858482361, 0.013449900783598423, -0.0022788685746490955, 0.009433806873857975, 0.03492431715130806, 0.06994229555130005, 0.02505568042397499, 0.021103335544466972, -0.008471735753118992, 0.04159168899059296, -0.0046372245997190475, 0.013153603300452232, 0.0185918640345335, 0.021595241501927376, -0.037475887686014175, -0.06462475657463074, -0.011879878118634224, 0.012449233792722225, -0.052037496119737625, 0.06473834812641144, 0.009378233924508095, -0.015887489542365074, -0.00975167565047741, 0.0037659613881260157, -0.0521148219704628, -0.04518847540020943, -0.033637162297964096, -0.013633261434733868, -0.05221756547689438, -0.07227773219347, 0.012777552008628845, -0.04992818459868431, 0.009090529754757881, 0.0025447707157582045, -0.007163507863879204, -0.01199911255389452, 0.005949023179709911, 0.04716644063591957, -0.013891419395804405, -0.03322936221957207, -0.03826666623353958, -0.00923842005431652, 0.03020077757537365, -0.04914052039384842, -0.006738858297467232, 0.014571430161595345, 0.0154713224619627, -0.002086982363834977, 0.01993660442531109, -0.016203565523028374, 0.043641552329063416, 0.04383108764886856, 0.08006022870540619, 0.04928351938724518, 0.01658879593014717, 0.05930102989077568, 0.037163421511650085, 0.012749765999615192, -0.06480132043361664, -0.045195627957582474, -0.0007299600401893258, 0.0031125477980822325, 0.023408707231283188, 0.05493202432990074, 0.013023319654166698, 0.11783725023269653, -0.09651920944452286, -0.013131204061210155, 0.004091169685125351, -0.04395834729075432, 0.06708982586860657, -0.013694681227207184, 0.014187902212142944, 0.04183695465326309, -0.0012836905661970377, 0.010497810319066048, -0.028276659548282623, -0.004863342270255089, -0.027818504720926285, 0.02427452616393566, 0.020626423880457878, 0.034309808164834976, 0.10570558160543442, -0.008700135163962841, -0.023229731246829033, 0.0006585295195691288, 0.059938304126262665, 0.008455774746835232, 0.012923391535878181, 0.0467364676296711, 0.029971517622470856, -0.04574495926499367, -0.008221911266446114, 0.05334049463272095, 0.013492869213223457, -0.02767045795917511, 0.0025605298578739166, 0.006774173118174076, 0.0557650551199913, 0.011630234308540821, -0.04784626513719559, -0.009931977838277817, -0.011977252550423145, 0.013340380974113941, -0.0292217880487442, 0.0025263165589421988, -0.025076892226934433, -0.011218131519854069, 0.05650211498141289, -0.02688869647681713, -0.017668064683675766, 0.024683428928256035, -0.02008233033120632, 0.04164690151810646, 0.05572975426912308, -0.029403435066342354, -0.016183994710445404, -0.09646255522966385, -0.05695681646466255, -0.040347564965486526, -0.02979913540184498, -0.010212350636720657, 0.052274711430072784, 2.9501245535357157e-07, -0.030179038643836975, 0.03925858438014984, 0.026300152763724327, -0.007067701779305935, -0.05407959595322609, 0.0034613467287272215, -0.00656913174316287, 0.014174590818583965, -0.006966255139559507, 0.010373908095061779, 0.03200719133019447, -0.03907604143023491, 0.00043333080247975886, 0.009382489137351513, -0.007460181135684252, 0.04340608790516853, -0.04982663318514824, 0.01321068312972784, -0.04988840967416763, 0.0005381364026106894, 0.10766109079122543, 0.09077130258083344, -0.01275983639061451, 0.003110668156296015, 0.07934223860502243, -0.029855499044060707, -0.023889487609267235, 0.0298224538564682, -0.01084194052964449, -0.006986704189330339, -0.00728528993204236, 0.04493953660130501, 0.008609538897871971, 0.03570159152150154, -0.04596446827054024, -0.010919828899204731, 0.04368298500776291, -0.0197406318038702, -0.02357354387640953, -0.049589455127716064, 0.03568131476640701, 0.017480896785855293, 0.019983652979135513, -0.022245829924941063, 0.04902581125497818, -0.01871328428387642, -0.02740657888352871, 0.05155184119939804, -0.029755327850580215, 0.09351395070552826, 0.030894948169589043, 0.0038114129565656185, -0.008874630555510521, -0.019137082621455193, 0.012023832648992538, -0.012743883766233921, -0.0037218439392745495, -0.0359928272664547, 0.06191499903798103, 0.029325660318136215, 0.010305164381861687, 0.024616606533527374, -0.07064055651426315, -0.020077411085367203, 0.08685942739248276, 0.07087574154138565, -0.018067380413413048, 2.249643639859424e-34, -0.018441347405314445, 0.007598694879561663, -0.01864529959857464, -0.06482692807912827, -0.055894333869218826, -0.021559007465839386, 0.037762600928545, 0.04208584502339363, -0.008186141029000282, -0.020663321018218994, -0.03207783028483391]
698
698
['Wellington Pinheiro dos Santos', 'Ricardo Emmanuel de Souza', 'Plínio B. dos Santos Filho']
1712.00712v1
Alzheimer's disease is the most common cause of dementia, yet hard to diagnose precisely without invasive techniques, particularly at the onset of the disease. This work approaches image analysis and classification of synthetic multispectral images composed by diffusion-weighted magnetic resonance (MR) cerebral images for the evaluation of cerebrospinal fluid area and measuring the advance of Alzheimer's disease. A clinical 1.5 T MR imaging system was used to acquire all images presented. The classification methods are based on multilayer perceptrons and Kohonen Self-Organized Map classifiers. We assume the classes of interest can be separated by hyperquadrics. Therefore, a 2-degree polynomial network is used to classify the original image, generating the ground truth image. The classification results are used to improve the usual analysis of the apparent diffusion coefficient map.
Evaluation of Alzheimer's Disease by Analysis of MR Images using Multilayer Perceptrons and Kohonen SOM Classifiers as an Alternative to the ADC Maps
2,017
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1712.00712v1
Title Evaluation Alzheimers Disease Analysis MR Images using Multilayer Perceptrons Kohonen SOM Classifiers Alternative ADC Maps Summary Alzheimers disease common cause dementia yet hard diagnose precisely without invasive technique particularly onset disease work approach image analysis classification synthetic multispectral image composed diffusionweighted magnetic resonance MR cerebral image evaluation cerebrospinal fluid area measuring advance Alzheimers disease clinical 15 MR imaging system used acquire image presented classification method based multilayer perceptrons Kohonen SelfOrganized Map classifier assume class interest separated hyperquadrics Therefore 2degree polynomial network used classify original image generating ground truth image classification result used improve usual analysis apparent diffusion coefficient map Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[-0.04594212397933006, 0.01745085045695305, -0.030492210760712624, 0.013584626838564873, 0.01706668548285961, 0.012701579369604588, 0.02677692100405693, 0.022421682253479958, 0.09287978708744049, 0.026735689491033554, 0.018283044919371605, 0.016190290451049805, 0.02528703771531582, 0.01034840289503336, 0.03909936919808388, -0.02712489664554596, -0.024665867909789085, 0.019033318385481834, 0.022487906739115715, -0.02040003053843975, -0.01826302893459797, -0.06269478052854538, -0.021220572292804718, 0.007425766903907061, -0.030553579330444336, -0.03442702069878578, 0.056777749210596085, -0.052589576691389084, 0.02562575973570347, -0.002420119708403945, -0.03449906036257744, -0.02020341157913208, 0.009332487359642982, -0.04411827772855759, 2.4725486582610756e-06, -0.059944938868284225, 0.030741171911358833, 0.026891453191637993, 0.04988741874694824, 0.008557465858757496, -0.011648641899228096, 0.07487727701663971, 0.021597132086753845, -0.007456752005964518, -0.041048940271139145, 0.015578558668494225, 0.03282688185572624, 0.06375617533922195, 0.014064916409552097, 0.04247506707906723, -0.004503652919083834, -0.03458292409777641, 0.028274154290556908, 0.005721734371036291, 0.023323269560933113, -0.03380070626735687, 0.051493313163518906, 0.027871839702129364, -0.06345371156930923, -0.06892047077417374, -0.005006834398955107, 0.06540463119745255, -0.003176259808242321, -0.018413379788398743, 0.0026997909881174564, 0.05585109442472458, 0.08040464669466019, -0.01152477040886879, -0.05668105557560921, 0.005672366824001074, -0.020768949761986732, 0.04857915639877319, -0.002812105929479003, 0.021992294117808342, -0.001616197288967669, 0.04691525176167488, -0.015372434630990028, -0.006237203720957041, 0.019388072192668915, -0.006951774936169386, -0.07991927117109299, 0.012072652578353882, 0.03364994749426842, -0.013733995147049427, -0.023203467950224876, 0.015194982290267944, -0.027968987822532654, 0.02182619459927082, 0.047330234199762344, -0.034219227731227875, -0.09027323126792908, 0.01541981566697359, 0.061982057988643646, -0.005254908464848995, -0.004393087234348059, -0.001457149744965136, 0.036483120173215866, -0.045666031539440155, 0.0691489577293396, -0.08392070978879929, 0.04031646251678467, -0.03602024167776108, -0.050551895052194595, 0.012220311909914017, -0.07604102790355682, 0.0547853522002697, -0.05949704349040985, 0.0773775652050972, -0.024980274960398674, 0.03582897409796715, -0.02577739581465721, 0.029612993821501732, -0.04737481847405434, 0.06502611935138702, 0.028127215802669525, -0.020459989085793495, -0.06868671625852585, 0.02558326907455921, 0.03505079075694084, -0.06169099360704422, 0.08013994246721268, 0.057593125849962234, 0.044137489050626755, 0.03481331095099449, -0.055481888353824615, 0.03130970895290375, -0.013277232646942139, 0.013501419685781002, 0.010725639760494232, 0.04912150651216507, 0.02458229660987854, 0.0460607074201107, -0.04397556185722351, -0.010399849154055119, 0.022268911823630333, 0.08151204138994217, 0.0052275764755904675, 0.014791177585721016, -0.06777328997850418, 0.030438749119639397, -0.017557799816131592, -0.009401258081197739, 0.024556824937462807, 0.0048764548264443874, 0.026127655059099197, 0.023601310327649117, -0.002162463031709194, 0.02235087752342224, -0.015880955383181572, -0.023417694494128227, -0.01779545284807682, 0.015808600932359695, -0.06497710943222046, -0.023779289796948433, 0.13660508394241333, -0.005611905362457037, -0.042060595005750656, -0.006586739793419838, 0.08005533367395401, -0.0018647444667294621, -0.014955696649849415, -0.016942275688052177, -0.021719174459576607, -0.00231539667584002, -0.023419002071022987, -0.05215610936284065, -0.030919160693883896, -0.019426297396421432, -0.00758564006537199, 0.03731260076165199, 0.03204065561294556, 0.04137272387742996, 0.011563865467905998, -0.035173509269952774, 0.005807791370898485, 0.03068656660616398, 0.0007770417141728103, 0.016460362821817398, -0.02941535785794258, -0.01804596371948719, -0.01884450949728489, -0.004234825726598501, 0.07800720632076263, 0.03178166225552559, -0.0034661623649299145, -0.009919678792357445, 0.006465437822043896, 0.0033133369870483875, 0.0009073955588974059, -0.06907469034194946, 0.032813675701618195, -0.019777609035372734, 0.04347045347094536, -0.014309288933873177, -0.001125612179748714, -0.02240418829023838, -0.0025703818537294865, -0.023550914600491524, -0.016163276508450508, 0.039344754070043564, -0.05279400944709778, -0.05805447697639465, -0.0008449021843262017, -0.025130679830908775, -0.020375503227114677, -0.029653996229171753, 0.04899059981107712, 0.011572971940040588, 0.04303606227040291, -0.024819225072860718, -0.014991408213973045, 0.03140575438737869, 0.05561395362019539, -0.05689486116170883, 0.01786985620856285, -0.01313553936779499, 0.009858929552137852, 0.012593633495271206, -0.05998162925243378, -0.012804086320102215, -0.037368301302194595, -0.005676318891346455, -0.009278694167733192, -0.013751794584095478, -0.009229754097759724, 0.037210866808891296, 0.05817755311727524, 0.02062770538032055, -0.022034533321857452, -0.03218134120106697, 0.002564649097621441, -0.022579777985811234, -0.017706165090203285, -0.023030761629343033, -0.06978229433298111, -0.07546883821487427, -0.044575657695531845, -0.02152404934167862, -0.01734342984855175, 0.018615495413541794, 0.035952791571617126, -0.07704455405473709, -0.03375029191374779, -0.01089354045689106, 0.008437692187726498, 0.009429552592337132, 0.001241662772372365, -0.013943103142082691, 0.007486923132091761, -0.00047294620890170336, 0.02502046525478363, -0.018105316907167435, 0.05697517842054367, -0.03149104863405228, -0.047551579773426056, 0.04135727137327194, -0.04929669573903084, 0.06825795024633408, 0.036606285721063614, -0.04690559208393097, -0.048062484711408615, -0.05494247376918793, -0.008579954504966736, -0.03246187046170235, 0.0003490256203804165, 0.033276431262493134, -0.018447721377015114, 0.02233034186065197, -0.003240985097363591, 0.033440183848142624, -0.007153681013733149, 0.002925387816503644, 0.007658688351511955, 0.00813341699540615, -0.02520032413303852, 0.010757031850516796, 0.06660448014736176, 0.010550222359597683, -0.037623368203639984, 0.08212220668792725, 0.027122637256979942, 0.020328136160969734, -0.006080827210098505, 0.001729205483570695, -0.012921172194182873, 0.02990151010453701, -0.0008030897006392479, -0.08901745080947876, -0.001157265854999423, -0.0034176993649452925, -0.012328710407018661, 0.048045121133327484, 0.030872197821736336, -0.05716050788760185, -0.03534448519349098, 0.005536780692636967, -0.028681879863142967, 0.09348072856664658, 0.0206274576485157, 0.05163988843560219, 0.009964469820261002, 0.07521167397499084, 0.043653152883052826, -0.00900865439325571, -0.0064057111740112305, 0.05352799966931343, -0.0014576602261513472, 0.028957733884453773, 0.021490326151251793, 0.0518316812813282, 0.06267032027244568, 0.018948711454868317, 0.031728629022836685, -0.018648482859134674, -0.006407210137695074, -0.007117094472050667, -0.0297956932336092, -0.025979435071349144, -0.03195171058177948, -0.03727767989039421, -0.0316709466278553, -0.017562495544552803, 0.04503680020570755, -0.0012896200641989708, 0.0045271203853189945, -0.04080333560705185, -0.051180869340896606, 0.01466208416968584, -0.042732834815979004, 0.009628057479858398, 0.04114595800638199, -0.07091481238603592, -0.019886977970600128, 0.011046367697417736, -0.0521283783018589, -0.01680281199514866, -0.014586730860173702, 0.026542747393250465, -0.011970196850597858, 0.005603431724011898, 0.03752269595861435, 0.024098863825201988, -0.01746739260852337, 0.04946909099817276, 0.07034499198198318, -0.003366744378581643, -0.06445033103227615, 0.016979480162262917, -0.048839349299669266, 0.012054625898599625, 0.01572347991168499, 0.010600561276078224, -0.034659918397665024, -0.017566820606589317, 0.016226233914494514, 0.0535905659198761, 0.008143004961311817, 0.0004383153573144227, -0.06564714014530182, 0.006022149231284857, 0.08686672151088715, 0.011667211540043354, -0.0758325383067131, 0.005810593720525503, -0.057021331042051315, 0.0011980450944975019, -0.07002618163824081, 0.0066075571812689304, -0.009886205196380615, -0.0030739211943000555, 0.0025135898031294346, 0.0340641513466835, 0.04454360157251358, 0.014159969985485077, 0.011104111559689045, -0.10172299295663834, -0.043381962925195694, -0.024076009169220924, -0.05051203444600105, 0.00398777611553669, -0.015581442043185234, 0.008726919069886208, 0.0057179792784154415, -0.056372273713350296, -0.019033780321478844, -0.015352893620729446, -0.0005009020678699017, 0.010763058438897133, 0.044932492077350616, 0.021202346310019493, -0.04449987784028053, -0.06659574806690216, 0.03001752868294716, -0.04310134798288345, -0.01191624440252781, -0.014189332723617554, -0.009925219230353832, -0.06406863033771515, 0.054328519850969315, -0.06181832030415535, 0.040703173726797104, -0.01140966173261404, -0.00842171348631382, 0.020625263452529907, -0.04978003352880478, -0.02369930036365986, 0.02939823642373085, 0.02540581114590168, -0.010769802145659924, -0.10561289638280869, -0.01819617860019207, 0.0011044976999983191, 0.05897940695285797, -0.03885743394494057, 0.08268370479345322, 0.045695871114730835, -0.0010919044725596905, -0.01195903867483139, 0.03136487677693367, 0.02262439765036106, 0.05484452098608017, -0.018034858629107475, 0.06558773666620255, -0.018257541581988335, -0.009599233977496624, -0.031223103404045105, -0.003380837617442012, 0.0403079055249691, -0.028498409315943718, -0.012083788402378559, -0.001441960223019123, -0.008719237521290779, -0.008055326528847218, 0.0976351797580719, 0.02419394627213478, 0.01470947451889515, -0.016703085973858833, -0.036862172186374664, -0.01848495751619339, -0.02487342804670334, 0.04707739129662514, -0.007130587473511696, 0.06110240891575813, 0.03760876879096031, -0.009000231511890888, 0.038429420441389084, -0.024329908192157745, -0.029350915923714638, -0.026346081867814064, 0.07437077909708023, -0.023460453376173973, -0.0071691772900521755, -0.032703645527362823, 0.027190877124667168, 0.0187548641115427, 0.005221209954470396, -0.036603521555662155, 0.009198613464832306, 0.02548369951546192, 0.04001506045460701, 0.03224259242415428, -0.003579710843041539, -0.04774058982729912, -0.029924608767032623, -0.06209123507142067, 0.09970281273126602, -0.013115675188601017, 0.03352881968021393, -0.011740238405764103, 0.005252588540315628, -0.0175558403134346, -0.012983408756554127, -0.0285381767898798, -0.00365386507473886, 0.04004785791039467, -0.027195215225219727, -0.051267318427562714, -0.01702132076025009, 0.03787095099687576, 0.006783044897019863, 0.0049541364423930645, 0.07568787783384323, 0.03145059570670128, 0.052698664367198944, -0.015513120219111443, 0.03730978071689606, -0.0085733812302351, 0.018777428194880486, 0.00972055085003376, -0.02154463343322277, 0.06017381325364113, -0.008896231651306152, -0.008058176375925541, -0.07402564585208893, 0.01611742377281189, -0.05904119089245796, 0.06195000931620598, -0.00021289830328896642, -0.002187247620895505, 0.012616562657058239, -0.027725806459784508, 0.029431665316224098, -0.03334948047995567, -0.019597744569182396, 0.03611784428358078, 0.013878115452826023, 0.027859846130013466, 0.05901526287198067, -0.03670673444867134, 0.018759502097964287, -0.0022429206874221563, 0.01043669879436493, 0.014507143758237362, -1.7818350897869095e-05, 0.00416357908397913, 0.045919761061668396, 0.020452305674552917, 0.004770265426486731, 0.016227811574935913, 0.026232093572616577, 0.033431410789489746, -0.035150229930877686, -0.03909238800406456, -0.005945790093392134, 0.0004356062563601881, 0.051994264125823975, -0.013831562362611294, 0.02774665504693985, 0.009995932690799236, 0.030860206112265587, -0.07482651621103287, -0.036571379750967026, -0.023854469880461693, -0.04291880130767822, -0.025720607489347458, -0.026703165844082832, 0.0521407350897789, -0.023693682625889778, -0.03798910975456238, -0.015285179018974304, 0.03438889607787132, -0.0006971976836211979, 0.002018533181399107, -0.019812671467661858, 0.023677801713347435, 0.022086426615715027, -0.053449008613824844, 0.02999982051551342, 0.003617221722379327, -0.04096381366252899, 0.00014616211410611868, -0.01766136847436428, -0.0714750811457634, -0.013932612724602222, 0.0014956427039578557, -5.735882724870924e-33, 0.0032003368251025677, 0.0011260241735726595, 0.02392756938934326, -0.04412614554166794, 0.01504184864461422, 0.013799273408949375, -0.005890060681849718, -0.02326935902237892, 0.01191391609609127, 0.038335274904966354, -0.006719640456140041, -0.03011484257876873, 0.015240627340972424, 0.07115118950605392, 0.004944184795022011, 0.014304234646260738, -0.03611506521701813, -0.033267270773649216, 0.0497841015458107, -0.03150594234466553, -0.033396631479263306, -0.005038012284785509, 0.0010494774905964732, -0.026805894449353218, -0.061623044312000275, 0.0670768991112709, -0.017595889046788216, -0.007442738860845566, 0.0002818591601680964, -0.002263534814119339, -0.033466096967458725, 0.0006882238085381687, -0.008607964031398296, 0.03345741704106331, 0.0025726319290697575, -0.0014746241504326463, 0.006233333609998226, -0.039725273847579956, 0.025907866656780243, -0.015550320968031883, -0.0003192824078723788, 0.023325415328145027, 0.025763245299458504, -0.006562795490026474, 0.022113492712378502, 0.06929299980401993, 0.051858071237802505, -0.010070335119962692, 0.007948019541800022, 0.020091863349080086, 0.04547308385372162, 0.002974300179630518, -0.016711946576833725, 0.045077189803123474, -0.0191716980189085, -0.04651046171784401, -0.05815701186656952, 0.023203454911708832, -0.0874444842338562, 0.016011765226721764, -0.02583331987261772, -0.020287970080971718, 0.005485821049660444, 0.011028830893337727, 0.06135903298854828, 0.05483202263712883, 0.08190079778432846, -0.004278100095689297, 0.007979695685207844, -0.019490212202072144, -0.025608906522393227, 0.027321944013237953, 0.03363107144832611, -0.07273309677839279, 0.03332599624991417, -0.04721909388899803, -0.02248285338282585, 0.0124965226277709, -0.05317087098956108, 0.013060783967375755, -0.03133338317275047, -0.032162413001060486, -0.008600096218287945, -0.00395834818482399, 0.05393315479159355, 0.0008674777345731854, -0.02347990870475769, -0.05290791392326355, -0.00041282246820628643, -0.06815902888774872, 0.011254629120230675, 0.004674664232879877, -0.012113257311284542, -0.019987259060144424, 0.024816442281007767, -0.07820224016904831, 0.04079466313123703, 0.03175332397222519, 0.046122241765260696, 0.011700769886374474, 0.004189548082649708, -0.023180199787020683, -0.008736546151340008, -0.005823089275509119, 0.03731268271803856, 0.0029797179158777, 0.01405390165746212, -0.0015918186400085688, 0.004992918111383915, -0.01566912792623043, 0.024487275630235672, -0.03508351743221283, 0.013193070888519287, 0.03497236222028732, -0.05975186824798584, -0.01012198906391859, -0.034667108207941055, 0.031031804159283638, 0.010013316757977009, 0.014563452452421188, 0.015679648146033287, -0.024080652743577957, -0.011523107066750526, 0.0486433207988739, -0.0614989697933197, 0.0068786353804171085, -0.046443160623311996, -0.007719048298895359, -0.0025957098696380854, -0.0809350535273552, -0.017449386417865753, 0.005256743170320988, 3.0851666110720544e-07, 0.016641654074192047, 0.05691186711192131, -0.02653520740568638, 0.004877986386418343, -0.003112497041001916, -0.05791079252958298, -0.042336639016866684, 0.010603893548250198, -0.028948264196515083, -0.04927835986018181, 0.057820748537778854, 0.010332874953746796, -0.033595990389585495, -0.03916798159480095, -0.0186589527875185, -0.012200990691781044, -0.02603147365152836, 0.016507692635059357, -0.012804951518774033, 0.04602961987257004, 0.031860508024692535, -0.02365577220916748, -0.01244322769343853, -0.035118017345666885, 0.02063177525997162, 0.0015258750645443797, 0.0018495396943762898, 0.0029986200388520956, 0.06446781009435654, -0.011702232994139194, 0.06039103865623474, -0.032683685421943665, 0.04183003306388855, 0.045880600810050964, -0.0027219061739742756, 0.015374312177300453, 0.00310497242026031, -0.01139498595148325, -0.021883370354771614, -0.05328560248017311, 0.060096416622400284, 0.0364249162375927, 0.06206897646188736, 0.030571451410651207, 0.003293347544968128, -0.0051836590282619, -0.06714605540037155, -0.03098531812429428, 0.010787748731672764, 0.003764105960726738, 0.09326600283384323, -0.05476611480116844, 0.006526431068778038, -0.06338641792535782, -0.0016035635489970446, -0.04262624680995941, 0.037224236875772476, 0.008467637002468109, 0.03383278846740723, -0.004432555753737688, -0.025164082646369934, 0.011894305236637592, 0.004352642223238945, -0.04275888949632645, 0.07783243060112, -0.010293783619999886, -0.026820704340934753, 2.31244763979447e-34, 0.012375912629067898, -0.030543066561222076, 0.001956414198502898, -0.017203135415911674, -0.02576390467584133, -0.026522144675254822, 0.0560535304248333, -0.050599534064531326, -0.05659671500325203, -0.023710772395133972, -0.03684278205037117]
699
699
['Cheston Tan', 'Tomaso Poggio']
1406.3793v1
Faces are a class of visual stimuli with unique significance, for a variety of reasons. They are ubiquitous throughout the course of a person's life, and face recognition is crucial for daily social interaction. Faces are also unlike any other stimulus class in terms of certain physical stimulus characteristics. Furthermore, faces have been empirically found to elicit certain characteristic behavioral phenomena, which are widely held to be evidence of "holistic" processing of faces. However, little is known about the neural mechanisms underlying such holistic face processing. In other words, for the processing of faces by the primate visual system, the input and output characteristics are relatively well known, but the internal neural computations are not. The main aim of this work is to further the fundamental understanding of what causes the visual processing of faces to be different from that of objects. In this computational modeling work, we show that a single factor - "neural tuning size" - is able to account for three key phenomena that are characteristic of face processing, namely the Composite Face Effect (CFE), Face Inversion Effect (FIE) and Whole-Part Effect (WPE). Our computational proof-of-principle provides specific neural tuning properties that correspond to the poorly-understood notion of holistic face processing, and connects these neural properties to psychophysical behavior. Overall, our work provides a unified and parsimonious theoretical account for the disparate empirical data on face-specific processing, deepening the fundamental understanding of face processing.
Neural tuning size is a key factor underlying holistic face processing
2,014
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1406.3793v1
Title Neural tuning size key factor underlying holistic face processing Summary Faces class visual stimulus unique significance variety reason ubiquitous throughout course person life face recognition crucial daily social interaction Faces also unlike stimulus class term certain physical stimulus characteristic Furthermore face empirically found elicit certain characteristic behavioral phenomenon widely held evidence holistic processing face However little known neural mechanism underlying holistic face processing word processing face primate visual system input output characteristic relatively well known internal neural computation main aim work fundamental understanding cause visual processing face different object computational modeling work show single factor neural tuning size able account three key phenomenon characteristic face processing namely Composite Face Effect CFE Face Inversion Effect FIE WholePart Effect WPE computational proofofprinciple provides specific neural tuning property correspond poorlyunderstood notion holistic face processing connects neural property psychophysical behavior Overall work provides unified parsimonious theoretical account disparate empirical data facespecific processing deepening fundamental understanding face processing Authors 0 Ahmed Osman Wojciech Samek 1 Ji Young Lee Franck Dernoncourt 2 Iulian Vlad Serban Tim Klinger Gerald Tesau 3 Sebastian Ruder Joachim Bingel Isabelle Aug 4 Iulian V Serban Chinnadhurai Sankar Mathie 40995 Vitaly Feldman Pravesh Kothari Jan Vondrák 40996 Orly Avner Shie Mannor 40997 Ran Zhao Deanna Needell Christopher Johanse 40998 Zongyan Huang Matthew England David Wilson 40999 Imen Trabelsi Dorra Ben Ayed Name author Length 41000 dtype object
[0.016153737902641296, -0.029728543013334274, -0.04741014167666435, 0.016164788976311684, 0.02687034383416176, 0.053367383778095245, 0.05962429940700531, 0.01388290524482727, -0.018673652783036232, 0.012384072877466679, -0.03280370309948921, -0.0035295968409627676, 0.045720186084508896, 0.08104520291090012, 0.08253713697195053, -0.07396651059389114, -0.011659919284284115, 0.03237862139940262, 0.016120702028274536, -0.0033651937264949083, 0.021536458283662796, -0.013288314454257488, 0.024247318506240845, 0.017701586708426476, -0.03845677524805069, -0.022785646840929985, -0.014312902465462685, 0.0016512838192284107, 5.6869786931201816e-05, 0.029066767543554306, 0.0134937958791852, 0.04094846546649933, -0.017877325415611267, 0.024545276537537575, 2.1922960513620637e-06, -0.06745773553848267, 0.015009385533630848, -0.027608569711446762, 0.01871596835553646, 0.009281310252845287, 0.07178950309753418, -0.04184151068329811, 0.006864193361252546, -0.0341157428920269, -0.035515423864126205, -0.029107006266713142, 0.05277256667613983, 0.09398925304412842, -0.058143723756074905, 0.03403092920780182, -0.021024713292717934, -0.04040932655334473, -0.005563513375818729, 0.014020252972841263, 0.037128936499357224, 0.05393612012267113, 0.007472562603652477, -0.0469290055334568, -0.05803487077355385, -0.06383973360061646, -0.05775352939963341, -0.02719936892390251, 0.04043303057551384, 0.03558279573917389, 0.06938106566667557, 0.03348160907626152, -0.0622640997171402, -0.05339014530181885, -0.016714727506041527, 0.044624216854572296, -0.004401228856295347, 0.0020292242988944054, -0.0018128989031538367, 0.008001002483069897, 0.0006415515090338886, -0.008655075915157795, -0.015274686738848686, 0.01598011702299118, 0.012240099720656872, 0.02659323625266552, -0.050929296761751175, 0.017021404579281807, 0.020897071808576584, -0.023368151858448982, -0.005346579011529684, -0.019106509163975716, 0.006371933501213789, 0.04304835945367813, -0.0026710082311183214, -0.022030895575881004, 0.007083780597895384, -0.017864780500531197, 0.043352533131837845, -0.011092711240053177, 0.013678265735507011, -0.05058649927377701, -0.010425583459436893, -0.02555139921605587, 0.02858446165919304, -0.04540533944964409, 0.0472576878964901, 0.009254999458789825, -0.061827559024095535, -0.020262105390429497, -0.0003060239541810006, 0.09299532324075699, -0.03562769293785095, 0.0018913953099399805, -0.03732302784919739, 0.03390158712863922, -0.011101947166025639, 0.018569190055131912, 0.0528104230761528, -0.003617273410782218, 0.018791405484080315, -0.03583776205778122, -0.06274160742759705, 0.021514078602194786, 0.0021749744191765785, -0.02950149215757847, -0.025178337469697, 0.029608163982629776, 0.0019333328818902373, -0.009892446920275688, -0.009668905287981033, 0.06041167303919792, -0.015288755297660828, 0.005966442171484232, 0.01318974606692791, -0.04768114909529686, 0.01683821901679039, -0.02584178000688553, 0.010920874774456024, 0.012660142034292221, 0.0007199665997177362, 0.05663895234465599, 0.025121809914708138, 0.02249843440949917, 0.005888882093131542, 0.028112780302762985, 0.026972545310854912, 0.014190372079610825, 0.04404566437005997, -0.011114033870398998, -0.016603464260697365, -0.0003824146988335997, -0.02201816812157631, 0.0007361462921835482, -0.020745983347296715, -0.02524043619632721, 0.015256237238645554, 0.04647207260131836, -0.02636554092168808, 0.00691707618534565, 0.07928694039583206, 0.013257629238069057, 0.018290242180228233, 0.009224602952599525, 0.026897171512246132, 0.02576996013522148, 0.015935508534312248, -0.04831903427839279, 0.022067848592996597, -0.011248544789850712, -0.016459297388792038, -0.045170705765485764, -0.032349251210689545, -0.05140077322721481, 0.03782108053565025, -0.013507152907550335, 0.030542103573679924, 0.008854399435222149, -0.02041018381714821, -0.01254762802273035, 0.04531693831086159, 0.0640384703874588, 0.04346103221178055, 0.048314619809389114, -0.04636376351118088, -0.039999235421419144, 0.009373682551085949, 0.06708720326423645, -0.04618911072611809, 0.09712761640548706, -0.0693008080124855, -0.016708873212337494, -0.01798703521490097, 0.02688649483025074, -0.02449468895792961, -0.04907148331403732, -0.006187754217535257, -0.01007041335105896, -0.016801469027996063, -0.0421464778482914, -0.0003966770600527525, 0.0010785895865410566, 0.03781601041555405, -0.07708676159381866, 0.020864425227046013, 0.0031302713323384523, -0.008175487630069256, -0.05247962847352028, -0.011443210765719414, -0.014619313180446625, -0.04038926586508751, 0.010634046047925949, 0.030653050169348717, -0.021358400583267212, -0.01853310503065586, 0.02518598921597004, 0.018134811893105507, 0.017743606120347977, 0.06067386269569397, -0.041970040649175644, 0.006756751332432032, -0.03515741601586342, 0.0019911029376089573, 0.03154608979821205, -0.07691819965839386, 0.006697528995573521, -0.005929239094257355, 0.09724894165992737, -0.005626719444990158, 0.014226395636796951, -0.033159039914608, -4.2202911572530866e-05, -0.007009448949247599, 0.04016441851854324, -0.012878487817943096, -0.03825444355607033, 0.0188570786267519, 0.0023517212830483913, 0.004949693102389574, -0.040333494544029236, 0.014920113608241081, -0.008913518860936165, -0.011366549879312515, 0.04057495668530464, 0.026008836925029755, -0.03403257578611374, 0.03201736509799957, -0.004745674319565296, 0.028364762663841248, -0.050603654235601425, 0.04135642200708389, -0.01382039301097393, 0.0058785006403923035, -0.011802553199231625, 0.011793453246355057, -0.02391427382826805, 0.06354553252458572, -0.014482137747108936, 0.043878860771656036, 0.03807000815868378, -0.026763351634144783, -0.019542021676898003, -0.022718332707881927, 0.006397439632564783, -0.07502739876508713, 0.01618342474102974, 0.03609747812151909, -0.01579226367175579, -0.021290164440870285, -0.023003697395324707, 0.022466108202934265, -0.07177138328552246, -0.008442009799182415, -0.037973932921886444, -0.019982563331723213, 0.03814858943223953, -0.04805896431207657, 0.009299823082983494, -0.021972564980387688, 0.00398074509575963, -0.007163050584495068, -0.026791812852025032, 0.07054182142019272, -0.015563543885946274, 0.023164810612797737, 0.030443638563156128, -0.00753004802390933, -0.017798351123929024, -0.050588686019182205, -0.02658184804022312, -0.009699334390461445, 0.05596040561795235, 0.06082964688539505, -0.038649458438158035, -0.0028002962935715914, 0.016474343836307526, -0.01414735708385706, 0.031188277527689934, 0.017198484390974045, -0.0520569272339344, 0.0021480051800608635, -0.006072505842894316, 0.05644189938902855, 0.12394663691520691, 0.024038556963205338, 0.004971017129719257, 0.014747957699000835, 0.032567474991083145, -0.006399738136678934, -0.039959926158189774, -0.043584614992141724, 0.033727794885635376, -0.02192394621670246, -0.030978702008724213, -0.01963558979332447, 0.014968698844313622, 0.04209740832448006, -0.002336616860702634, -0.04290208965539932, 0.07921286672353745, 0.03322970122098923, -0.030246667563915253, -0.049911435693502426, -0.03633255884051323, -0.009599415585398674, 0.05033303052186966, -0.03489693999290466, -0.03613058105111122, 0.03773292899131775, 0.04150626063346863, -0.00854008924216032, 0.048642776906490326, 0.021821219474077225, 0.023592552170157433, 0.045464418828487396, 0.007888942956924438, 0.035265978425741196, 0.02961863949894905, -0.030823159962892532, -0.053332649171352386, 0.04527154564857483, 0.009772750549018383, -0.021875491365790367, -0.03581440821290016, -0.019452370703220367, -0.07449156790971756, -0.03308955579996109, -0.01922593265771866, -0.02063850872218609, 0.04956953972578049, -0.017046378925442696, 0.007135886698961258, -0.07179427891969681, 0.005284018814563751, 0.006367853842675686, -0.031439948827028275, 0.05479831621050835, 0.018932152539491653, -0.05799524858593941, -0.0014329097466543317, 0.01407365407794714, -0.05652844160795212, 0.02282203733921051, 0.05713751167058945, 0.018112948164343834, -0.011405745521187782, 0.050833579152822495, 0.014661476947367191, -0.00784449651837349, -0.01657046191394329, -0.044292155653238297, 0.06883365660905838, -0.0054961699061095715, 0.052713632583618164, -0.044159919023513794, -0.01924288272857666, 0.02295978181064129, -0.019954107701778412, 0.028091877698898315, 0.044188547879457474, -0.022104226052761078, -0.07704347372055054, 0.010656219907104969, -0.08531193435192108, -0.07162054628133774, 0.026277245953679085, 0.01052149012684822, 0.044933684170246124, 0.04311969131231308, -0.024810848757624626, -0.039428796619176865, -0.00662032887339592, 0.002356851240620017, 0.04817800968885422, -0.013364916667342186, 0.0319470539689064, 0.008940351195633411, -0.08337794989347458, -0.034322965890169144, 0.049355100840330124, 0.0028566415421664715, 0.011041852645576, 0.005954487714916468, 0.019437888637185097, -0.01242756936699152, -0.00413076626136899, 0.04260125383734703, 0.08594118803739548, 0.014414433389902115, 0.03553367778658867, -0.057079315185546875, -0.013380293734371662, 0.017140768468379974, 0.02911895141005516, 0.015011715702712536, -0.10875382274389267, 0.0017674779519438744, 0.015766404569149017, 0.04137183725833893, -0.04174467548727989, 0.05019102990627289, 0.031992994248867035, 0.0039557041600346565, -0.03247058391571045, 0.05668991059064865, -0.011498049832880497, 0.008663753047585487, -0.007410187739878893, -0.03978356346487999, 0.016268307343125343, 0.017879733815789223, -0.0020124430302530527, 0.009287084452807903, -0.08406437188386917, -0.047258246690034866, 0.03888385370373726, -0.05199549347162247, 0.0053648273460567, -0.00634990818798542, 0.06400474905967712, 0.004224664997309446, -0.08443882316350937, 0.03589823096990585, 0.03787977620959282, -0.08590056747198105, -0.04675571992993355, 0.029805650934576988, -0.04900432750582695, 0.04032221809029579, 0.020278997719287872, -0.0585428923368454, 0.006055035162717104, -0.016839366406202316, -0.004597430117428303, 0.05548938363790512, 0.06811337172985077, -0.03196476772427559, -0.01157119870185852, -0.0120370639488101, -0.028138376772403717, -0.05774275213479996, -0.00557414535433054, -0.05984119698405266, 0.011717052198946476, -0.04559468850493431, 0.04461795464158058, 0.03183237090706825, 0.016072964295744896, 0.02208494208753109, 0.00487362127751112, -0.09586245566606522, -0.01468568854033947, 0.0007949983701109886, 0.020011907443404198, 0.0639878511428833, 0.018184885382652283, -0.02316100150346756, -0.009932008571922779, 0.004045731388032436, 0.009555733762681484, -0.0047877137549221516, 0.05615350976586342, -0.0570494569838047, 0.003944851458072662, -0.003223938401788473, 0.03000977821648121, 0.001986341318115592, 0.07161099463701248, 0.04427216574549675, 0.05493059754371643, -0.0418182834982872, 0.0040672821924090385, 0.0011385983088985085, 0.018167413771152496, -0.021931413561105728, -0.0645010843873024, 0.02778834104537964, 0.05769570544362068, -0.018781619146466255, -0.05837490037083626, 0.013562159612774849, 0.019232841208577156, -0.044157639145851135, -2.371927439526189e-05, -0.01653057150542736, 0.0031321896240115166, -0.043179869651794434, 0.07057545334100723, 0.0008668156806379557, 0.029560765251517296, 0.007596187759190798, 0.01582327112555504, 0.0025831228122115135, 0.02494710497558117, 0.01630265824496746, -0.014694330282509327, -0.06280037015676498, -0.0010906766401603818, -0.023461729288101196, -0.008679108694195747, -0.009205679409205914, -0.03547355532646179, 0.025366341695189476, -0.051112256944179535, -0.009578096680343151, 0.020678002387285233, -0.00528147304430604, -0.021004803478717804, 0.025405559688806534, -0.03870024159550667, -0.016199326142668724, 0.031016580760478973, 0.013486504554748535, -0.007075649220496416, -0.05193369463086128, 0.007372985128313303, -0.010027079842984676, -0.007372722029685974, -0.036591947078704834, -0.00044468382839113474, -0.008667923510074615, 0.019178524613380432, 0.04260534793138504, 0.012849352322518826, -0.03730352595448494, -0.002607284113764763, -0.04170362651348114, -0.0192384235560894, 0.012428751215338707, 0.0169677734375, 0.05350663140416145, 0.0021823050919920206, 0.005775259342044592, 0.003514825366437435, -0.010306688956916332, -0.09116493910551071, 0.00875574629753828, 0.033521778881549835, -0.0107980752363801, 0.029634026810526848, 0.007858073338866234, -6.353279541229652e-33, -0.017301099374890327, 0.0246705524623394, -0.01520987506955862, -0.010275662876665592, -0.0373399555683136, 0.01768401823937893, -0.018772300332784653, 0.027262119576334953, -0.025909172371029854, 0.015365795232355595, -0.003981489688158035, 0.02744855359196663, 0.009958494454622269, -0.0366194061934948, 0.043957848101854324, 0.022575775161385536, -0.01857002079486847, -0.02924082987010479, 0.005758104845881462, -0.03513858839869499, 0.01812494732439518, -0.006257995963096619, 0.06781493872404099, -0.0752672478556633, -0.06598686426877975, 0.03449982777237892, -0.01964755356311798, -0.02678765170276165, -0.04309411719441414, 0.015770323574543, -0.024864329025149345, -0.0053664217703044415, 0.019825031980872154, 0.0024220950435847044, 0.01680574379861355, 0.03059508092701435, -0.013240888714790344, -0.03591051325201988, -0.03872049227356911, -0.005630974192172289, -0.04969756305217743, 0.011985760182142258, 0.06463741511106491, -0.05273235961794853, -0.06819025427103043, 0.011380508542060852, 0.03089285083115101, -0.044384319335222244, 0.028345633298158646, 0.04344205558300018, -0.04109489917755127, -0.02453635074198246, 0.01756875216960907, 0.020795807242393494, 0.004464080557227135, -0.04310435801744461, -0.052102502435445786, 0.06682711839675903, -0.02690308541059494, 0.04646962508559227, -0.01625131256878376, -0.013546488247811794, 0.0006149833207018673, 0.10045814514160156, 0.08067284524440765, 0.03130829334259033, 0.09389467537403107, 0.0193629153072834, -0.04410458728671074, -0.03603968396782875, 0.052324142307043076, 0.04085160419344902, 0.0470103994011879, 0.04002771154046059, 0.05031943693757057, -0.06960035860538483, -0.023322617635130882, 0.010114426724612713, -0.03009193018078804, 0.033999066799879074, -0.03690805286169052, 0.017613934352993965, -0.0009864249732345343, 0.03802831843495369, 0.03669475391507149, -0.021840834990143776, -0.06102582439780235, 0.009613120928406715, -0.023930596187710762, -0.037022799253463745, 0.025449348613619804, -0.0024601377081125975, -0.030601052567362785, -0.023975998163223267, 0.05425470694899559, -0.0531737245619297, 0.012275515124201775, 0.015228817239403725, 0.0671139657497406, -0.04514084383845329, -0.031647779047489166, 0.0018987345974892378, 0.006843667943030596, 0.03520924970507622, 0.03763403743505478, -0.019786817952990532, 0.01359346229583025, -0.004888609983026981, 0.011999518610537052, -0.01152731291949749, -0.013264951296150684, -0.04338753595948219, 0.07339102774858475, 0.022684285417199135, -0.012066440656781197, -0.03701061010360718, -0.016351962462067604, -0.035177573561668396, 0.039976783096790314, 0.005519389640539885, -0.07061117887496948, -0.0028922553174197674, -0.0015842854045331478, 0.06836008280515671, -0.04620439186692238, -0.000441500247688964, -0.06437744945287704, -0.033057089895009995, 0.07700769603252411, -0.018819481134414673, -0.016513021662831306, -0.015793098136782646, 2.895152135806711e-07, -0.07538914680480957, 0.05649443715810776, -0.00883650965988636, -0.05693960562348366, 0.09156179428100586, 0.03141941502690315, 0.0045966519974172115, 0.04319896548986435, 0.029685769230127335, -0.05615353584289551, -0.005673614796251059, 0.02529243752360344, -0.003919960930943489, -0.01629563421010971, 0.021766195073723793, -0.00012169707770226523, 0.020186083391308784, 0.023410765454173088, -0.0014907573349773884, 0.04523580148816109, -0.007893004454672337, 0.027516355738043785, 0.022316057235002518, -0.02915859967470169, 0.03798186406493187, 0.03959793597459793, 0.0028072174172848463, -0.013809870928525925, 0.06664969772100449, -0.042811110615730286, -0.06734608858823776, -0.011430960148572922, 0.020635366439819336, 0.02495931275188923, 0.0009351037442684174, 0.01906599849462509, 0.008987920358777046, 0.00491899810731411, -0.041153497993946075, 0.022583475336432457, 0.02132350020110607, 0.053145650774240494, 0.0028296178206801414, -0.04081704840064049, 0.03529635816812515, 0.0020543502178043127, -0.04543150216341019, -0.009056520648300648, 0.00637802155688405, -0.008239628747105598, 0.029905304312705994, -0.035451389849185944, -0.015488631092011929, -0.008843546733260155, -0.015602792613208294, -0.0502844899892807, -0.008844424039125443, -0.02768208272755146, 0.006872095633298159, -0.025211401283740997, -0.0243043415248394, 0.004249929916113615, -0.02789824828505516, -0.03224853798747063, 0.05201730877161026, 0.04674888402223587, -0.044962622225284576, 2.54257224030953e-34, -0.029883356764912605, -0.0003865938924718648, 0.019324520602822304, -0.06502805650234222, -0.0014270120300352573, -0.055308759212493896, -0.04175538197159767, 0.0037918484304100275, 0.04232637211680412, -0.06477578729391098, -0.04156191647052765]