Datasets:

QGEval2024

/

QGEval

like 0

Follow

QGEval 1

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who directed the 2013 crime thriller film \"Spring Breakers\" starring James Franco, Vanessa Hudgens, Selena Gomez, Ashley Benson, and Rachel Korine?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Ashley Benson portrayed Brit in a 2013 crime thriller film written and directed by who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who directed the 2013 crime thriller film in which Ashley Victoria Benson played Brit?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Ashley Benson portrayed Brit in a 2013 crime thriller film written and directed by who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who directed the film Spring Breakers?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who directed the 2013 crime thriller film that stars Ashley Benson?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Ashley Victoria Benson portrayed Brit in a 2012 American crime thriller film written and directed by who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who wrote and directed the 2012 American crime film \"Spring Breakers,\" which starred James Franco and Ashley Benson?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who directed the 2013 crime thriller film \"Spring Breakers\" in which Ashley Benson portrayed the character Brit?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who directed the 2013 crime thriller film in which Ashley Victoria Benson portrayed Brit?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who wrote and directed the 2012 American crime film \"Spring Breakers,\" which stars James Franco, Vanessa Hudgens, Selena Gomez, Ashley Benson, and Rachel Korine?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who directed the film in which Ashley Benson played Brit?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who directed the film that starred Ashley Benson?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Ashley Victoria Benson, is an American actress, known for portraying the role of Brit in the 2013 crime thriller film \"Spring Breakers\", a 2012 American crime film written and directed by who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Ashley Benson portrayed the role of Brit in the 2012 crime film directed by whom?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Hawaiian Poi Dog is an extinct breed of pariah dog from Hawaiʻi which was used by Native Hawaiians as a spiritual protector of children and as a source of food. What is the breed of dog in the terrier family that has a very long body, short legs, and a distinctive topknot of hair on the head?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which dog breed is extinct, Dandie Dinmont Terrier or Hawaiian Poi Dog?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which dog breed is extinct, Dandie Dinmont Terrier or Hawaiian Poi Dog?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Is the Hawaiian Poi Dog or the Dandie Dinmont Terrier extinct?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which dog breed is extinct, Hawaiian Poi Dog or Dandie Dinmont Terrier?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which dog is extinct, Dandie Dinmont Terrier or Hawaiian Poi Dog?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which dog is from Hawaii, Dandie Dinmont Terrier or Hawaiian Poi Dog?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the extinct breed of pariah dog from Hawaiʻi that was historically used by Native Hawaiians as a spiritual protector of children and also as a source of food?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the Hawaiian Poi Dog and how was it used by Native Hawaiians?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which dog is extinct, Dandie Dinmont Terrier or Hawaiian Poi Dog?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the extinct breed of pariah dog from Hawaiʻi that was used by Native Hawaiians as a spiritual protector of children and as a source of food?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which dog is extinct, Hawaiian Poi Dog or Dandie Dinmont Terrier?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which dog breed is a pariah dog from Hawaii?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which dog breed is extinct, Hawaiian Poi Dog or Dandie Dinmont Terrier?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which breed of dog is extinct, the Hawaiian Poi Dog or the Dandie Dinmont Terrier?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Genaro Hernández was a Mexican-American professional boxer who competed from 1984 to 1998, he was a two-time super featherweight world champion, having held the WBA title from 1991 to 1995, and the WBC and lineal titles from 1997 to 1998, in addition to challenging for which title in 1995?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jimmy Garcia lost a unanimous decision to a Mexican-American professional boxer who challenged for what title in 1995?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jimmy Garcia lost a unanimous decision to a Mexican-American professional boxer who challenged for what title in 1995?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jimmy Garcia lost a unanimous decision to a boxer who challenged for what title in 1995?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which title did Genaro Hernandez challenge for in 1995?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jimmy Garcia lost a unanimous decision to a boxer who challenged for what title in 1995?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What title did the boxer who defeated Jimmy Garcia in the Ruelas match challenge for in 1995?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which boxing title did Genaro Hernández challenge for in 1995?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who did Jimmy Garcia lose to in his second successful title shot, before losing to Gabriel Ruelas and subsequently dying from brain damage?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jimmy Garcia lost a unanimous decision to a boxer who challenged for what title in 1995?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Genaro Hernández, a Mexican-American professional boxer, challenged for which title in 1995?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jimmy Garcia lost a unanimous decision to a Mexican-American professional boxer who challenged for what title in 1995?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What title did Genaro hold in 1995?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jimmy Garcia lost a unanimous decision to a Mexican-American professional boxer who challenged for what title in 1995?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jimmy Garcia lost by unanimous decision to a professional boxer that challenged for what title in 1995?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Andrew Shearer Gehling is best known for his role as Dr. Pomatter in the Broadway musical \"Waitress\" and as the voice of Gord in which 2006 video game?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the video game in which Andrew Gehling voiced Gord released?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Andrew Shearer Gehling is the voice of Gord in a video game released on what date?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Andrew Shearer Gehling, is an American stage and screen actor, best known for his role as Dr. Pomatter in the Broadway musical \"Waitress\", Garry Marshall's \"Billy & Ray\", and as the voice of Gord in the 2006 video game Bully from Rockstar Games, released on which date?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was Bully released?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Andrew Shearer Gehling is an American stage and screen actor, best known for his role as Dr. Pomatter in the Broadway musical \"Waitress\", Garry Marshall's \"Billy & Ray\", and as the voice of Gord in the 2006 video game Bully, originally released in the PAL region as Canis Canem Edit, is an action-adventure video game developed by Rockstar Vancouver and published by Rockstar Games", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the game in which Andrew Gehling voiced Gord released?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "When was the original version of the video game \"Bully\", in which Andrew Shearer Gehling voiced the character Gord, first released for PlayStation 2?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the original version of Bully released for PlayStation 2?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the video game released in which Andrew Gehling voiced Gord?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Andrew Shearer Gehling voiced Gord in the video game \"Bully\" from Rockstar Games, which was originally released on what date for PlayStation 2?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the video game released in which Andrew Shearer Gehling was the voice of Gord?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the name of the game that Andrew Shearer Gehling voiced in 2006?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the video game released in which Andrew Shearer Gehling was the voice of Gord?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the game, in which Drew Gehling voices Gord, released for PlayStation 2?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.3333, "prediction": "\"Domino Dancing\" is a song recorded by the British synthpop duo Pet Shop Boys, released as the lead single from their 1988 album, \"Introspective\". It reached number 7 on the UK Singles Chart, which month was the album \"Introspective\" first released?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In what month was the album that contained the song \"Domino Dancing\" released?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Domino Dancing is a song from an album that was first released in what month?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Domino Dancing was released as the lead single from an album that was first released in what month?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What month was Domino Dancing released?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 1.6667, "prediction": "Domino Dancing is a song recorded by the British synthpop duo Pet Shop Boys, released as the lead single from their 1988 album, Introspective, is the third studio album by English synthpop duo Pet Shop Boys, it was first released on 11 October 1988, and is the Pet Shop Boys' second-best-selling album, released in which month?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In what month was the album that contained the song Domino Dancing first released?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In which month was the Pet Shop Boys' album \"Introspective\" first released?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the release date of Pet Shop Boys' \"Introspective\" album, and how does its sales compare to their other albums?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In what month was the album that contained the song \"Domino Dancing\" released?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Pet Shop Boys released their third studio album \"Introspective\" in which month of 1988?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Domino Dancing was the lead single from the album released in what month?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the lead single from the album Introspective?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In what month was the album that Domino Dancing was on first released?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What month was the album released whose lead single was\"Domino Dancing\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who wrote the song \"Fairytale of New York\" as a duet with Kirsty MacColl?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In what year was the writer of \"Fairytale of New York\" born?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "\"Fairytale of New York\" is a song written by Shane MacGowan and a musician born in what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "\"Fairytale of New York\" is a song written by Shane MacGowan and an English musician born in what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, Jem Finer or Shane MacGowan?", "relevance": 2, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What year was the English musician, artist and composer who wrote \"Fairytale of New York\" born?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In what year was the writer of Fairytale of New York born?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In what year was Jem Finer, one of the founding members of The Pogues and co-writer of \"Fairytale of New York,\" born?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was Jem Finer born and what was his role in The Pogues?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In what year was the writer of \"Fairytale of New York\" born?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "\"Fairytale of New York\" was co-written and released as a single by The Pogues with what English musician, who was one of the founding members of the band, born on 25 July in what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Fairytale of New York was written by a musician born in what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What year was the song \"Fairytale of New York\" released?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Fairytale of New York was written by the English musician born in what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What year was the alphabetically first writer of Fairytale of New York born?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the name of the programming block on Cartoon Network that featured the Cartoon Cartoons?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the Friday night programming block that features the animated television series \"What Happened to... Robot Jones?\"", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 2, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Whatever Happened to... Robot Jones?, is an American animated television series created by Greg Miller for Cartoon Network, and the 12th of the network's which Friday night programming block?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What Friday night programming block featured the series that Whatever Happened to... Robot Jones is the 12th of?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the name of the programming block that featured the Cartoon Cartoons?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the Friday night programming block that features the 12th of the network's original series from 1997 to 2003?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the programming block that featured the 12th of the network's original series from 1997 to 2003?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the name of the programming block on Cartoon Network where original series like \"Whatever Happened to... Robot Jones?\" were featured on Friday nights during the height of the Cartoon Cartoons era?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What programming block did the Cartoon Cartoons eventually become a part of, and on what night of the week did it air?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What block of programming did the show Whatever Happened to... Robot Jones? appear on?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What was the name of the programming block on Cartoon Network where the original series \"Whatever Happened to... Robot Jones?\" was featured, which was also the collective name used for the network's original series from 1997 to 2003?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the Friday night programming block that featured the 12th of the network's Cartoon Cartoons?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the name of the Friday night programming block that featured Cartoon Cartoons?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What Friday night programming block featured the series \"Whatever Happened to... Robot Jones?\"", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What Friday night programming block included what collective series that includes\"Whatever Happened to... Robot Jones?\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "\"The New York World\" Building was a skyscraper in New York City designed by whom?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which building is proposed to have more floors, The New York World Building or The Spiral?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which skyscraper is being designed by Bjarke Ingels Group, The Spiral or The New York World Building?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The New York World Building and The Spiral are both skyscrapers, which is being designed by Bjarke Ingels Group, the architectural firm behind One57?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which skyscraper is under construction, The New York World Building or The Spiral?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which skyscraper is being designed by Bjarke Ingels Group, The Spiral or The New York World Building?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which skyscraper is proposed to be taller, The Spiral or The New York World Building?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the proposed 65-floor skyscraper located in the Hudson Yards neighborhood of Manhattan, designed by Bjarke Ingels Group?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the proposed 65-floor skyscraper being designed by Bjarke Ingels Group in the Hudson Yards neighborhood of Manhattan, New York City, and who announced the project in 2016?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which skyscraper is being designed by Bjarke Ingels Group, The Spiral or The New York World Building?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the proposed 65-floor skyscraper located in the Hudson Yards neighborhood of Manhattan, announced in 2016 and designed by Bjarke Ingels Group?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which skyscraper is proposed, The Spiral or The New York World Building?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the skyscraper that was razed in 1955?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which building is proposed, The New York World Building or The Spiral?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which building is newer, The Spiral, or the New York World Building?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who joined the Un-Americans stable towards the end of their existence?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What Canadian professional wrestler was part of the Un-Americans?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Un-Americans (originally known as The Anti-Americans) were a villianous professional wrestling stable in World Wrestling Entertainment who were active throughout mid-2002, the stable was originally composed of three anti-American Canadian wrestlers: Lance Storm, Christian and which Canadian professional wrestler?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Un-Americans (originally known as The Anti-Americans) were a villianous professional wrestling stable in World Wrestling Entertainment who were active throughout mid-2002, the stable was originally composed of three anti-American Canadian wrestlers: Lance Storm, Christian and which Canadian professional wrestler?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who died later, Lance Storm or Andrew Martin?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Un-Americans were a villianous professional wrestling stable in World Wrestling Entertainment who were active throughout mid-2002, the stable was originally composed of three anti-American Canadian wrestlers, which Canadian professional wrestler, was best known for his time with the World Wrestling Federation/Entertainment under the ring name Test and for his time in Total Nonstop Action Wrestling under the ring name \"Andrew Martin\"", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which of the three anti-American Canadian wrestlers in The Un-Americans stable was best known for his time with the World Wrestling Federation/Entertainment under the ring name Test?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which Canadian wrestler, known for his time in the World Wrestling Federation/Entertainment under the ring name \"Test,\" was a member of the villainous stable The Un-Americans in WWE in 2002?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 1.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the Canadian wrestler that joined The Un-Americans towards the end of their existence and later became known as \"Andrew Martin\" in Total Nonstop Action Wrestling?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which Canadian professional wrestler was part of the Un-Americans stable?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Andrew James Robert Patrick Martin, known for his time in the World Wrestling Federation/Entertainment under the ring name Test, was a member of which villainous professional wrestling stable active in WWE throughout mid-2002 that originally consisted of anti-American Canadian wrestlers?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 1.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the real name of the wrestler who was part of the Un-Americans?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the last member of the Un-Americans?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, Test or The Un-Americans?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Un-Americans contained which wrestler who also went by what TNA Wrestling name?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Was Fred Niblo a British film and television director and screenwriter?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Peter Duffell and Fred Niblo both directors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Fred Niblo and Peter Duffell both directors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Fred Niblo and Peter Duffell both directors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which director was born first, Fred Niblo or Peter Duffell?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Are Peter Duffell and Fred Niblo both film directors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Fred Niblo and Peter Duffell both directors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Did Fred Niblo and Peter Duffell both work as film directors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Did Fred Niblo work in the film industry during the same time period as Peter Duffell?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Fred Niblo and Peter Duffell both directors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.3333, "prediction": "Fred Niblo and Peter Duffell were both involved in the film industry as directors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Fred Niblo and Peter Duffell both film directors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which director was born later, Fred Niblo or Peter Duffell?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Fred Niblo and Peter Duffell both directors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Were both Peter Duffell and Fred Niblo actors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Spencer Plaza is a shopping mall located in which country?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Alsa Mall and Spencer Plaza, are located in which country?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Alsa Mall and Spencer Plaza, are located in which country?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Alsa Mall and Spencer Plaza are both located in what country?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which mall was established first, Spencer Plaza or Alsa Mall?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Alsa Mall and Spencer Plaza are both located in what country?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Alsa Mall and Spencer Plaza, are located in which country?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "In which country are Spencer Plaza and Alsa Mall, two of the oldest shopping malls in Chennai, located?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What is the oldest shopping mall in India and one of the biggest shopping malls in South Asia when it was built, located on Anna Salai in Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What country are both the Spencer Plaza and Alsa Mall located in?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Spencer Plaza, known as one of the modern landmarks of Chennai and the oldest shopping mall in which country, was originally built during the British Raj and reconstructed in 1985 on the site of the original Spencer's departmental store?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Alsa Mall and Spencer Plaza are both located in what country?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the shopping mall that was reconstructed in 1985?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What country are both Alsa Mall and Spencer Plaza located in?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which country is home to Alsa Mall and Spencer Plaza?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who created the comic book series Molly Danger and is known for his work on books such as \"Supergirl\" and \"Firestorm\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Jamal Yaseem Igle is an American comic book artist, editor, art director, marketing executive and animation storyboard artist, he is also known for his pencilling, inking and coloring work on books such as which name of several fictional superheroes appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Jamal Yaseem Igle is an American comic book artist, editor, art director, marketing executive and animation storyboard artist, he is also known for his pencilling, inking and coloring work on books such as which name of several fictional superheroes appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Jamal Yaseem Igle is an American comic book artist, editor, art director, marketing executive and animation storyboard artist, he is also known for his pencilling, inking and coloring work on books such as which name of several fictional superheroes appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the fictional superhero appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Jamal Yaseem Igle is an American comic book artist, editor, art director, marketing executive and animation storyboard artist, he is also known for his pencilling, inking and coloring work on books such as which fictional superheroes appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What fictional superheroes appeared in American comic books published by DC Comics and was pencilled, inked and colored by Jamal Igle?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the shared alias of the fictional superheroes Ronnie Raymond, Martin Stein, and Jason Rusch, who appear in American comic books published by DC Comics and have been depicted by artist Jamal Yaseem Igle?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who are the creators of the modern update of Firestorm, and when did it debut?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jamal Yaseem Igle is known for his pencilling, inking and coloring work on which DC Comics superheroes?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the superhero character associated with both Ronnie Raymond and Martin Stein, as well as being a comic book series that Jamal Yaseem Igle has worked on as a penciller, inker, and colorist?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What fictional superheroes appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics did Jamal Yaseem Igle work on?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the comic book series that Jamal Yaseem Igle is known for his pencilling, inking and coloring work on?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of several fictional superheroes appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics, that Jamal Yaseem Igle is known for his pencilling, inking and coloring work on?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jamal Igle was known for illustrative work on which DC Comics publication?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Arnold Mærsk Mc-Kinney Møller was a longtime figure at A.P. Moller – Maersk Group, which was founded by whom?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Mller Centre is a dedicated, residential executive training and conference centre in Cambridge, it was founded with a gift of approximately £10 million to Churchill College, donated by the A.P. Mller & Chastine Mc-Kinney Mller Foundation, a Danish institution, set up in 1953 by which shipping magnate?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Møller Centre is named after the son and successor of which Danish shipping magnate?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Møller Centre is named after the son of which shipping magnate?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the father of the person who was a longtime figure at A.P. Moller – Maersk Group?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 1.6667, "prediction": "The Mller Centre is a dedicated, residential executive training and conference centre in Cambridge, it was founded with a gift of approximately £10 million to Churchill College, donated by the A.P. Mller & Chastine Mc-Kinney Mller Foundation, a Danish institution, set up in 1953 by shipping magnate, who was a longtime figure at A.P. Moller – Maersk Group,", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Mller Centre is a dedicated, residential executive training and conference centre in Cambridge, it was founded with a gift of approximately £10 million to Churchill College, donated by the A.P. Mller & Chastine Mc-Kinney Mller Foundation, a Danish institution, set up in 1953 by which shipping magnate?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the Danish shipping magnate that the A.P. Møller & Chastine Mc-Kinney Møller Foundation was named after, and who also played a significant role in the founding of the Møller Centre at Churchill College, University of Cambridge?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the A.P. Møller & Chastine Mc-Kinney Møller Foundation and who founded it?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the father of the man who founded the Mller Centre?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Arnold Mærsk Mc-Kinney Møller was a Danish shipping magnate associated with which company, founded by his father, that also made a significant donation to establish The Møller Centre at Churchill College, University of Cambridge?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Mller Centre is a dedicated, residential executive training and conference centre in Cambridge, it was founded with a gift of approximately £10 million to Churchill College, donated by the A.P. Mller & Chastine Mc-Kinney Mller Foundation, a Danish institution, set up in 1953 by which shipping magnate?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the full name of the person who founded the A.P. Mller & Chastine Mc-Kinney Mller Foundation?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Mller Centre is a dedicated, residential executive training and conference centre in Cambridge, it was founded with a gift of approximately £10 million to Churchill College, donated by the A.P. Mller & Chastine Mc-Kinney Mller Foundation, a Danish institution, set up in 1953 by which shipping magnate?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of shipping magnate Mærsk Mc-Kinney Møller' father?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who appeared in the 1989 American comedy thriller film \"The 'Burbs\" alongside Tom Hanks, Bruce Dern, Carrie Fisher, Corey Feldman, Wendy Schaal, and Henry Gibson?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The 'Burbs starred which Canadian actor and comedian?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The 'Burbs is a 1989 American comedy thriller film directed by Joe Dante starring which Canadian actor, comedian and writer who appeared in films and television?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The 'Burbs is a 1989 American comedy thriller film directed by Joe Dante starring which Canadian actor, comedian and writer who appeared in films and television?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who starred in The 'Burbs?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The 'Burbs is a 1989 American comedy thriller film directed by Joe Dante starring which Canadian actor, comedian and writer who appeared in films and television?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which Canadian actor, comedian and writer starred in The 'Burbs?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who played a supporting role in the 1989 comedy thriller \"The 'Burbs\" alongside Tom Hanks and Carrie Fisher?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who starred alongside Tom Hanks, Bruce Dern, and Carrie Fisher in the 1989 comedy thriller film The 'Burbs, which was directed by Joe Dante and written by Dana Olsen, and also featured a cameo by the writer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which Canadian actor, comedian and writer starred in the 1989 American comedy thriller The 'Burbs?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the Canadian actor and comedian who starred alongside Tom Hanks in the 1989 American comedy thriller film \"The 'Burbs\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What Canadian actor starred in The 'Burbs?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the actor in The 'Burbs?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The 'Burbs is a 1989 American comedy thriller film directed by Joe Dante starring which Canadian actor, comedian and writer who appeared in films and television?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 1, "prediction": "What star if the Burbs was Canadian?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Lodewijk Fluttert, best known by his stage name Bakermat, is a Dutch DJ and music producer known for his mix of electronic, deep and tropical house music. What summer festival often features artists of this genre?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Bakermat's music consists of a mix of electronic, deep and a subgenre of deep house that is often featured at summer festivals such as what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Bakermat's music consists of a mix of electronic, deep and a subgenre of deep house, with elements of dancehall and Balearic house often featured at various summer festivals such as what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": " Bakermat's music consists of a mix of electronic, deep and a subgenre of deep house, with elements of dancehall and Balearic house, that is often featured at summer festivals such as what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What festival is Bakermat often featured at?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Bakermat's music consists of a mix of electronic, deep and tropical house, a subgenre of deep house, with elements of dancehall and Balearic house, artists of the genre are often featured at various summer festivals such as which festival?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Bakermat's music consists of a mix of electronic, deep and a subgenre of deep house, with elements of dancehall and Balearic house, artists of the genre are often featured at various summer festivals such as what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Which summer festival frequently features artists from the tropical house genre, a subgenre that Bakermat, a Dutch DJ known for his minimalist electronic music with jazz and soul influences, might perform at?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is a popular summer festival where artists of the tropical house genre, such as Thomas Jack and Kygo, are often featured?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Bakermat's music consists of a mix of electronic, deep and a subgenre of deep house that is often featured at what summer festival?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Artists of which subgenre, known for its mix of electronic, deep and tropical house with jazz and soul influences, are often featured at various summer festivals such as which event?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Bakermat's music consists of a mix of electronic, deep and a subgenre of deep house that is often featured at various summer festivals such as what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the festival that Bakermat is often featured at?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Bakermat's music consists of a mix of electronic, deep and a subgenre of deep house that is often featured at what summer festival?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "At what summer festival might you find music by Bakermat?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Brian Newman is most known for his performances with Lady Gaga and her surprise appearances at his performances in New York City, and he is married to a performer in which genre of variety show?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Brian Newman is married to Angie Pontani, who performs what genre of variety show?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Brian Newman is married to Angie Pontani in what genre of variety show?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Brian Newman (born June 10, 1981) is an American jazz musician, singer, and trumpet player, Newman currently holds a residency at the Rose Bar at the Gramercy Park Hotel in New York City and is married to Angie Pontani, a performer of which genre of variety show, that became popular in the 1860s and evolved to feature ribald comedy (lewd jokes) and female striptease?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.3333, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What is the name of the genre of variety show that Brian Newman is married to?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Brian Newman is married to a performer of what genre of variety show?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Brian Newman is married to Angie Pontani, who performs what variety show?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What genre of variety show is Brian Newman's wife, Angie Pontani, associated with in her performances?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is American burlesque and how is it related to Brian Newman, the American jazz musician who holds a residency at the Rose Bar at the Gramercy Park Hotel in New York City and is married to American burlesque performer Angie Pontani?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Brian Newman is married to Angie Pontani, who performs what genre of variety show?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Brian Newman, known for his jazz performances and collaborations with Lady Gaga, is married to a performer from which genre of variety show that evolved in America to feature ribald comedy and female striptease?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Brian Newman is married to a performer of what genre of variety show?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the genre of variety show that Brian Newman is most known for?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Brian Newman is married to a performer of what genre of variety show?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Brian Newman's wife performs for what genre of variety show?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the monthly international magazine of the Seventh-day Adventist Church published by the Review and Herald Publishing Association?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine is published more frequently, Baseball Digest or Adventist World?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine is published more frequently, Baseball Digest or Adventist World?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 1.3333, "fluency": 1.3333, "prediction": "Baseball Digest is a baseball magazine resource, published in Evanston, Illinois by Grandstand Publishing, LLC, which is a monthly international magazine of the Seventh-day Adventist Church published by the Review and Herald Publishing Association, Adventist World or Baseball Digest?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine is published more frequently, Baseball Digest or Adventist World?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine is published by the Review and Herald Publishing Association, Adventist World or Baseball Digest?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine is published by the Review and Herald Publishing Association, Baseball Digest or Adventist World?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the monthly international magazine of the Seventh-day Adventist Church?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the monthly international magazine of the Seventh-day Adventist Church that is published by the Review and Herald Publishing Association and has editors based in Silver Spring, Maryland and Seoul, Korea?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine is published by the Review and Herald Publishing Association, Baseball Digest or Adventist World?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the monthly international magazine of the Seventh-day Adventist Church that is published by the Review and Herald Publishing Association with editors in Silver Spring, Maryland, and Seoul, Korea?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine is published in Korea, Adventist World or Baseball Digest?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine is published in Evanston, Illinois?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine is published by the Review and Herald Publishing Association, Baseball Digest or Adventist World?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine is based out of more countries, Adventist World or Baseball Digest?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who served as Secretary of Defense under Democratic President Bill Clinton?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The 1984 United States Senate election in Maine was held on November 7, 1984, incumbent Republican U.S. Senator William Sebastian Cohen won re-election to a second term, Cohen served as which position, under Democratic President Bill Clinton?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The winner of the 1984 United States Senate election in Maine served in what post from 1997-2001?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What position did the winner of the 1984 United States Senate election in Maine hold from 1997-2001?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What office did William Cohen serve in?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What position did the incumbent Republican U.S. Senator win in the 1984 United States Senate election in Maine?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What position did the incumbent Republican U.S. Senator who won re-election to a second term under Democratic President Bill Clinton hold?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What position did William Cohen hold in the U.S. government from 1997 to 2001?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What position did William Cohen hold under President Bill Clinton and what was his party affiliation during his time in the Senate when he won re-election in 1984?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What position did the Republican who won re-election to a second term in the 1984 United States Senate election in Maine hold under Bill Clinton?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "William Sebastian Cohen is an American politician who served as both a member of the United States House of Representatives and Senate, and held what position under Democratic President Bill Clinton from 1997 to 2001?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The 1984 United States Senate election in Maine was held on November 7, 1984, incumbent Republican U.S. Senator William Cohen won re-election to a second term, William Sebastian Cohen (born August 28, 1940) is an American politician and author from the U.S. state of Maine, a Republican, Cohen served as both a member of the United States House of Representatives and Senate, and as what, under Democratic President Bill Clinton?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What office did Cohen hold under Clinton?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The 1984 United States Senate election in Maine was won by a Republican who served as what post under Bill Clinton?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The winner of the 1984 United States Senate election in Maine took on what political role from 1997-2001?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was an associate and friend of Jakob Lukas Schabelitz in the late 1840s and early 1850s?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jakob Schabelitz was an associate and friend of which German philosopher, economist, political theorist, sociologist, journalist and revolutionary socialist?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jakob Lukas Schabelitz was an associate and friend of which German philosopher and economist?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": " Jakob Lukas Schabelitz was born in Switzerland in 1827, he joined the Communist League and was an associate and friend of which German philosopher, economist, political theorist, sociologist, journalist and revolutionary socialist?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, Jakob Lukas Schabelitz or Karl Marx?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jakob Schabelitz was an associate and friend of which German philosopher, economist, political theorist, sociologist, journalist and revolutionary socialist?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jakob Schabelitz was an associate and friend of which German philosopher, economist, political theorist, sociologist, journalist and revolutionary socialist?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the German philosopher, economist, and revolutionary socialist that Jakob Lukas Schabelitz associated with in the late 1840s and early 1850s?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was an associate and friend of Jakob Lukas Schabelitz in the late 1840s and early 1850s?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jakob Schabelitz was an associate and friend of which German philosopher, economist, political theorist, sociologist, journalist and revolutionary socialist?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jakob Lukas Schabelitz was a publisher and bookseller born in Switzerland who joined the Communist League and was an associate and friend of which German philosopher, economist, political theorist, sociologist, journalist, and revolutionary socialist?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jakob Schabelitz was an associate and friend of which German philosopher?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the profession of the person who was born in 1827?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Jakob Lukas Schabelitz was an associate and friend of which German philosopher, economist, political theorist, sociologist, journalist and revolutionary socialist?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What German philosopher, economist and political theorist was Jakob Lukas Schabelitz a friend and associate of?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the first Filipino to win a formula race in Europe and is currently driving for Lotus F1 Team Juniors in the 2013 World Series by Renault?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Matthieu Vaxivière is a French racing driver, in 2014 he was assigned as one of the drivers for the Lotus F1 Junior team, while competing in the Formula Renault 3.5 series alongside which Filipino-Swiss driver, who raced for Status Grand Prix in the 2012 GP3 Series and currently driving for Lotus F1 Team Juniors in the 2013 World Series by Renault?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Matthieu Vaxivière is a French racing driver, in 2014 he was assigned as one of the drivers for the Lotus F1 Junior team, while competing in the Formula Renault 3.5 series alongside which Filipino-Swiss driver?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Matthieu Vaxivière competed in the Formula Renault 3.5 series alongside which Filipino-Swiss driver?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the first Filipino to win a formula race in Europe, Marlon Stöckinger or Matthieu Vaxivière?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Matthieu Vaxivière is a French racing driver, in 2014 he was assigned as one of the drivers for the Lotus F1 Junior team, while competing in the Formula Renault 3.5 series alongside which Filipino racing driver, who raced for Status Grand Prix in the 2012 GP3 Series and currently driving for Lotus F1 Team Juniors in the 2013 World Series by Renault?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Matthieu Vaxivière was assigned as one of the drivers for the Lotus F1 Junior team, while competing in the Formula Renault 3.5 series alongside which Filipino-Swiss driver, who raced for Status Grand Prix in the 2012 GP3 Series and currently driving for Lotus F1 Team Juniors in the 2013 World Series by Renault?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the Filipino-Swiss driver that competed alongside Matthieu Vaxivière in the Lotus F1 Junior team during the 2014 Formula Renault 3.5 series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who did Matthieu Vaxivière compete alongside with in the Formula Renault 3.5 series in 2014 while being assigned as one of the drivers for the Lotus F1 Junior team?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Matthieu Vaxivière competed in the Formula Renault 3.5 series alongside which Filipino-Swiss driver?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the first Filipino to win a formula race in Europe and is currently driving for Lotus F1 Team Juniors in the 2013 World Series by Renault?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which driver born in Manila competed in the Formula Renault 3.5 series alongside Matthieu Vaxivière?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, Marlon Stöckinger or Matthieu Vaxivière?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which Filipino racing driver competed alongside Matthieu Vaxivière in the Formula Renault 3.5 series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which driver has been in less races, Marlon Stöckinger or MatthieuVaxivière?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Bazooka is the common name for a man-portable recoilless anti-tank rocket launcher weapon, widely fielded by which organization?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The RL-83 Blindicide is primarily an antitank rocket launcher but other rounds could be fired, it was produced by Mecar SA of Belgium and was an improved derivative of the M20A1 Bazooka, Bazooka is the common name for a man-portable recoilless anti-tank rocket launcher weapon, widely fielded by which organization?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The RL-83 Blindicide was an improved derivative of a man-portable recoilless anti-tank rocket launcher weapon widely fielded by who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The RL-83 Blindicide was an improved derivative of a man-portable recoilless anti-tank rocket launcher widely fielded by who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What branch of the military used the Bazooka?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The RL-83 Blindicide is an improved derivative of a man-portable recoilless anti-tank rocket launcher weapon, widely fielded by which organization?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The RL-83 Blindicide was an improved derivative of a man-portable recoilless anti-tank rocket launcher weapon widely fielded by who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which military force widely fielded the man-portable recoilless anti-tank rocket launcher weapon commonly known as the bazooka?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What organization widely fielded the man-portable recoilless anti-tank rocket launcher weapon commonly known as the Bazooka?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The RL-83 Blindicide was an improved derivative of a man-portable recoilless anti-tank rocket launcher weapon widely fielded by who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the common name for the man-portable recoilless anti-tank rocket launcher weapon that was widely fielded by which military force, and also referred to as the \"Stovepipe\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The RL-83 Blindicide is an improved derivative of a man-portable recoilless anti-tank rocket launcher weapon, widely fielded by who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the weapon that was widely fielded by the United States Army?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The RL-83 Blindicide was an improved derivative of a man-portable recoilless anti-tank rocket launcher weapon widely fielded by who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "RL-83 Blindicide was an improved derivative of a weapon launcher widely fielded by which army?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "3rd Bass was an American hip-hop group that released how many studio albums in their initial career, both of which were certified gold by the RIAA?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many albums did the group who released the album \"The Cactus Al/Bum\" release in their initial career?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Cactus Al/Bum is the debut album by a hip hop group that released how many studio albums?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Cactus Al/Bum is the debut album by a hip hop trio that released how many studio albums?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many studio albums did 3rd Bass release?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Cactus Al/Bum is the debut album by a group that released how many studio albums in their initial career?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many albums did the group that released The Cactus Al/Bum release in their initial career?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many studio albums did 3rd Bass release during their initial career before splitting up in 1992, and what was the certification status of these albums by the RIAA?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many studio albums did 3rd Bass release during their initial career and what was their certification status?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many studio albums did the hip hop trio that released the album \"The Cactus Al/Bum\" release in their initial career?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many studio albums did the American hip-hop group 3rd Bass release in their initial career before splitting up in 1992, both of which were certified gold by the RIAA?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many studio albums did the group that released \"The Cactus Album\" release in their initial career?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many studio albums did 3rd Bass release?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many studio albums did the group that released The Cactus Al/Bum release?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many Studio albums did the group that released the debut album The Cactus Al/Bum release in their initial career?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Eyes Wide Shut is a 1999 erotic drama film directed, produced, and co-written by Stanley Kubrick, based on which novella by Arthur Schnitzler?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Vinessa Elizabeth Shaw starred in a 1999 erotic drama film based on what novella?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Vinessa Shaw starred in a 1999 film based on what novella?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Vinessa Elizabeth Shaw was in a 1999 erotic drama film based on what novella?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the novella that Eyes Wide Shut is based on?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Vinessa Shaw was in a 1999 film based on what 1926 novella?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Vinessa Elizabeth Shaw was in a 1999 erotic drama film based on what novella?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the title of the 1926 novella by Arthur Schnitzler that Stanley Kubrick's film \"Eyes Wide Shut\" is based on?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the novella that Stanley Kubrick's \"Eyes Wide Shut\" is based on?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Vinessa Elizabeth Shaw was in a 1999 erotic drama film based on what novella?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Eyes Wide Shut is a 1999 erotic drama film directed by Stanley Kubrick, which is based on which Arthur Schnitzler's novella, that was originally set in early 20th century Vienna but transferred to 1990s New York City for the film?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Vinessa Elizabeth Shaw starred in a 1999 erotic drama film based on what 1926 novella?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the novella that Eyes Wide Shut is based on?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Vinessa Shaw was in the 1999 erotic drama film based on what novella?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What novella was\"Eyes Wide Shut,\" starring Vinessa Elizabeth Shaw, based on?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was honored in 1884 by Emperor Alexander III and awarded a lifetime pension, and is also mentioned in the dedication of Igor Stravinsky's opera \"Mavra\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mavra is a one-act opera buffa composed by Igor Stravinsky, the dedication on the score is to the memory of Pushkin, Glinka and which Russian composer of the romantic period, some of whose works are among the most popular music in the classical repertoire?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mavra is a one-act opera buffa composed by Igor Stravinsky, the dedication on the score is to the memory of Pushkin, Glinka and which Russian composer of the romantic period?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mavra is a one-act opera buffa composed by Igor Stravinsky, the dedication on the score is to the memory of Pushkin, Glinka and which Russian composer of the romantic period, some of whose works are among the most popular music in the classical repertoire?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the first Russian composer whose music made a lasting impression internationally?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was honored in 1884, by Emperor Alexander III, and awarded a lifetime pension, Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky or Igor Stravinsky?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mavra is a one-act opera buffa composed by Igor Stravinsky, the dedication on the score is to the memory of Pushkin, Glinka and which Russian composer of the romantic period, some of whose works are among the most popular music in the classical repertoire?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the first Russian composer to make a lasting international impression and was later commemorated by Igor Stravinsky in the dedication of his opera \"Mavra\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the Russian composer honored by Emperor Alexander III and also dedicated to the memory of in the score of Igor Stravinsky's opera buffa, Mavra?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mavra is a one-act opera buffa composed by Igor Stravinsky, the dedication on the score is to the memory of Pushkin, Glinka and which Russian composer of the romantic period, some of whose works are among the most popular music in the classical repertoire?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mavra is a one-act opera buffa by Igor Stravinsky that has been characterized as an homage to Russian writers. The dedication on the score is to the memory of Pushkin, Glinka, and which famous Russian composer known for his works in the classical repertoire and who made a lasting international impression?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 1, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which Russian composer of the romantic period, often anglicized as Peter Ilich Tchaikovsky, was a guest conductor in Europe and the United States, and was honored in 1884, by Emperor Alexander III, and awarded a lifetime pension, and composed Mavra?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the first Russian composer whose music made a lasting impression internationally?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mavra is a one-act opera buffa composed by Igor Stravinsky, the dedication on the score is to the memory of Pushkin, Glinka and which Russian composer of the romantic period, some of whose works are among the most popular music in the classical repertoire?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who has a dedication on the score of the one-act opera buffa, Mavra, and whose music made a lasting international impression as a Russian composer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In the animated film \"The Incredibles,\" who provided the voice for the character Violet?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Radio On: A Listener's Diary is a book by an author who was the voice of what character in \"The Incredibles\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Radio On: A Listener's Diary is the first book by an American author who was the voice of what character in the animated film \"The Incredibles\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Radio On: A Listener's Diary is the first book by an American author who was the voice of what character in the animated film \"The Incredibles\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the character that Sarah Vowell voiced in The Incredibles?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Radio On: A Listener's Diary is the first book by an American author who was also the voice of what character in the animated film \"The Incredibles\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Radio On: A Listener's Diary is the first book by an American author who was the voice of what character in the animated film \"The Incredibles\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What role did Sarah Vowell voice in the animated film \"The Incredibles\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What character did Sarah Vowell voice in \"The Incredibles\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Radio On: A Listener's Diary is the first book by an author who was the voice of what character in the animated film \"The Incredibles\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Sarah Jane Vowell is known for her work as a contributing editor on \"This American Life\" and for writing about American history and culture. In addition to her literary and journalistic work, which character did she voice in the animated film \"The Incredibles\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Radio On: A Listener's Diary was written by the voice of what character in The Incredibles?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the character that Sarah Vowell voiced in The Incredibles?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Radio On: A Listener's Diary is the first book by an author who was the voice of what character in the animated film \"The Incredibles\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Radio On: A Listener's Diary is the first book by an author that voiced what character in the film\"The Incredibles\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.3333, "prediction": "Sir William Turner Walton was an English composer, his best-known works include \"Façade\", the cantata \"Belshazzar's Feast\", the Viola Concerto and the First Symphony, who was an Italian composer that was a leading composer of the \"bel canto\" opera style during the first half of the nineteenth century and was undoubtedly an influence on other composers such as Giuseppe Verdi?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, Gaetano Donizetti or William Walton?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, William Walton or Gaetano Donizetti?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Gaetano Donizetti and William Walton, are English composers?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which composer was older, William Turner Walton or Domenico Gaetano Maria Donizetti?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which composer was born first, William Walton or Domenico Donizetti?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, Gaetano Donizetti or William Walton?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the English composer known for works such as \"Façade\", \"Belshazzar's Feast\", the Viola Concerto, and the First Symphony, and had a career spanning sixty years?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was a leading composer of the \"bel canto\" opera style during the first half of the nineteenth century and influenced other composers such as Giuseppe Verdi?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, Gaetano Donizetti or William Walton?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was an English composer known for works such as \"Façade,\" the cantata \"Belshazzar's Feast,\" and the Viola Concerto, and had a career spanning sixty years?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, William Walton or Domenico Donizetti?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which composer was born first, William Turner Walton or Domenico Gaetano Maria Donizetti?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, Gaetano Donizetti or William Walton?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which composer was born later, Gaetano Donizetti or William Walton?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Erich Friedrich Wilhelm Ludendorff was the leader of the German war efforts during World War I until his resignation in October 1918, just before the end of hostilities, along with whom?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Carl Adolf Maximilian Hoffmann, was a German military strategist, Hoffmann, along with Hindenburg and which German general, the victor of the Battle of Liège and the Battle of Tannenberg, masterminded the devastating defeat of the Russian armies at Tannenberg and the Masurian Lakes?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Carl Adolf Maximilian Hoffmann masterminded the devastating defeat of the Russian armies at Tannenberg and the Masurian Lakes along with which Quartermaster general?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Carl Adolf Maximilian Hoffmann masterminded the defeat of the Russian armies at Tannenberg and the Masurian Lakes with which Quartermaster General?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was older, Erich Friedrich Wilhelm Ludendorff or Carl Adolf Maximilian Hoffmann?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Carl Adolf Maximilian Hoffmann, was a German military strategist, along with Hindenburg and which German general, the victor of the Battle of Liège and the Battle of Tannenberg, masterminded the devastating defeat of the Russian armies at Tannenberg and the Masurian Lakes?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the leader of the German war efforts during World War I, Carl Hoffmann or Erich Ludendorff?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the German general known for his victories at the Battle of Liège and Tannenberg, and later became the leader of the German war efforts during World War I as Quartermaster general alongside Paul von Hindenburg?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the leader of the German war efforts during World War I alongside Paul von Hindenburg, and resigned just before the end of hostilities?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Carl Adolf Maximilian Hoffmann masterminded the defeat of the Russian armies at Tannenberg and the Masurian Lakes, along with which German general, the victor of the Battle of Liège and the Battle of Tannenberg?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was a German general known for victories at the Battle of Liège and the Battle of Tannenberg, and became the leader of German war efforts during World War I until his resignation in October 1918?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Carl Adolf Maximilian Hoffmann, was a German military strategist, along with Hindenburg and which German general, the victor of the Battle of Liège and the Battle of Tannenberg?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the leader of the German war efforts during World War I?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Carl Adolf Maximilian Hoffmann, was a German military strategist, Hoffmann, along with which German general, the victor of the Battle of Liège and the Battle of Tannenberg, masterminded the devastating defeat of the Russian armies at Tannenberg and the Masurian Lakes?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which of the people that helped Max Hoffmann do defeat the Russia army was born on 9 April 1865?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Nadezhda Tolokonnikova is a Russian conceptual artist and political activist, she has a history of political activism with which controversial street art group?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Pyotr Verzilov and Nadezhda Tolokonnikova are both involved in what type of activism?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 2, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Pyotr Verzilov is married to a Pussy Riot member who has a history of what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Pyotr Verzilov and Nadezhda Tolokonnikova are both what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, Nadezhda Tolokonnikova or Pyotr Verzilov?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Pyotr Verzilov and Nadezhda Tolokonnikova, are Russian artists and activists, of which type?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 1.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Pyotr Verzilov is married to a Russian conceptual artist and what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What type of activism is Nadezhda Andreyevna Tolokonnikova, a member of Pussy Riot, known for?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is Nadezhda Tolokonnikova's history of activism and what group was she a member of before joining Pussy Riot?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Pyotr Verzilov is married to a Russian conceptual artist and activist of what political ideology?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Nadezhda Andreyevna Tolokonnikova is known for her involvement with the Anarchist Feminist group Pussy Riot and has a history with the street art group Voina. What type of activist is she?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Pyotr Verzilov and Nadezhda Tolokonnikova, are both what type of activists?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the full name of the person who was convicted of hooliganism motivated by religious hatred?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Pyotr Verzilov and Nadezhda Tolokonnikova are both what kind of activists?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.3333, "prediction": "Pyotr Verzilov is married to a Russian conceptual artist and what kind of activist?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mitchell Duggan previously had a loan spell at which English football club?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What English football club based in Warrington, Cheshire did Mitchell Duggan have loan spells at?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mitchell Duggan previously had loan spells at what English football club that was established in 1949 under the name of Stockton Heath?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mitchell Duggan previously had loan spells at which English football club based in Warrington, Cheshire?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which team did Mitchell Duggan play for first, Warrington Town or Marine?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What English football club based in Warrington, Cheshire did Mitchell Duggan have loan spells at?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mitchell Duggan had loan spells at which English football club based in Warrington, Cheshire?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Which English football club, based in Warrington, Cheshire, and established in 1949 as Stockton Heath, did Mitchell Duggan have a loan spell with before playing for Tranmere Rovers?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the name of the football club that Mitchell Duggan had a loan spell at before joining Tranmere Rovers, and where is it based?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What English football club based in Warrington, Cheshire did Mitchell Duggan have a loan spell at?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mitchell \"Mitch\" Duggan, a footballer born on March 20, 1997, who plays as a midfielder or wing back for Tranmere Rovers, had loan spells at which English football club that was established in 1949 and is based in Warrington, Cheshire?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What English football club based in Warrington, Cheshire did Mitchell Duggan have loan spells at?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What team did Mitchell Duggan play for before he joined Tranmere Rovers?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mitchell Duggan had loan spells at which English football club based in Warrington, Cheshire?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "For which football club, established in 1949, did Mitch Duggan have a loan spell prior to joining Tranmere Rovers?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is widely credited as the originator of techno music, specifically Detroit techno, along with Derrick May and Kevin Saunderson, and attended high school in Belleville, Michigan?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Metroplex was founded by a musician who attended high school in what Michigan city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Metroplex is a techno record label founded by an American musician who attended high school together in what city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Metroplex is a techno record label founded by a pioneer who attended high school in what city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the originator of techno music?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Metroplex is a techno record label in Detroit, founded in 1985 by techno pioneer Juan Atkins, an American musician, he is widely credited as the originator of techno music, specifically Detroit techno along with Derrick May and Kevin Saunderson, the three, sometimes called the Belleville Three, attended high school together in which Michigan city, near Detroit?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Metroplex was founded by the man who attended high school in what Michigan city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the hometown of the group known as the Belleville Three, which includes techno pioneer Juan Atkins?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the high school that Juan Atkins attended with Derrick May and Kevin Saunderson, who are also credited as the originators of Detroit techno and known as the Belleville Three?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Metroplex was founded by the musician who attended high school in what Michigan city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Juan Atkins, credited as an originator of Detroit techno music along with Derrick May and Kevin Saunderson, is part of a group sometimes referred to as the \"Belleville Three\" because they attended high school in which location?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Metroplex is a techno record label founded by a musician who attended high school in what Michigan city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the person who is credited as the originator of techno music?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Metroplex was founded by the techno pioneer who attended high school in what Michigan city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The founder of the Metroplex record label attending high school in what city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Since 2009, Adam Lambert has sold over 3 million albums and 5 million singles worldwide, Josh Abraham has produced and co-written songs accounting for sales of more than how many albums worldwide?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Josh Abraham is an American record producer, songwriter, and music executive, having worked with some of the music industry's most successful artists over the past 15 years including Adam Lambert, an American singer, songwriter and stage actor, he has produced and co-written songs accounting for sales of more than how many albums worldwide?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Josh Abraham is an American record producer who has worked with an American singer who has sold over 3 million albums and 5 million singles worldwide, and has produced and co-written songs accounting for sales of more than how many albums worldwide?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Josh Abraham is an American record producer, songwriter, and music executive, having worked with some of the music industry's most successful artists over the past 15 years including Adam Lambert, he has produced and co-written songs accounting for sales of more than how many albums worldwide?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many more albums has Josh Abraham sold than Adam Lambert?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Josh Abraham has produced and co-written songs accounting for sales of more than how many albums worldwide, including 3 million albums by an American singer, songwriter and stage actor?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Josh Abraham has worked with an American singer, songwriter and stage actor who has sold over 3 million albums and 5 million singles worldwide and has produced and co-written songs accounting for sales of more than how many albums worldwide?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many albums worldwide have been sold that feature songs produced or co-written by Josh Abraham?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many albums worldwide have Josh Abraham's produced and co-written songs accounted for, including Adam Lambert's music?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Josh Abraham has produced and co-written songs accounting for sales of more than how many albums worldwide?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Josh Abraham is an American record producer who has worked with various successful artists. How many albums worldwide have sales been accounted for through the songs he has produced and co-written?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Josh Abraham has worked with an American singer, songwriter and stage actor who has sold over 3 million albums and 5 million singles worldwide, and has produced and co-written songs accounting for sales of more than how many albums worldwide?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many albums has Adam Lambert sold?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Josh Abraham is an American record producer, songwriter, and music executive, having worked with some of the music industry's most successful artists over the past 15 years including Adam Lambert, an American singer, songwriter and stage actor, he has produced and co-written songs accounting for sales of more than how many albums worldwide?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "With the help of Adam Lambert, Josh Abraham has sold how many albums worldwide?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the free jazz drummer known as Muhammad Ali?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the birth name of the drummer on the album Center of the World?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Center of the World is the eponymous album by the free jazz quartet consisting of saxophonist Frank Wrigth, pianist Bobby Few, bassist Alan Silva and drummer Muhammad Ali, born on which day?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the birth name of the drummer on Center of the World?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the drummer in the Center of the World quartet?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the birth name of the drummer of the free jazz quartet that recorded the album Center of the World?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the birth name of the drummer who played on the album Center of the World?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the drummer for the free jazz quartet that recorded the live album \"Center of the World\" in 1972, also known by his birth name Raymond Patterson?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the birth name of the free jazz drummer who played on the Center of the World album alongside saxophonist Frank Wright, pianist Bobby Few, and bassist Alan Silva?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 1.3333, "prediction": "Center of the World is the eponymous album by the free jazz quartet consisting of a drummer born in 1936, and who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the birth name of the free jazz drummer known as Muhammad Ali, who performed in the quartet that recorded the live album \"Center of the World\" in 1972?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the birth name of the drummer on the album Center of the World?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, Muhammad Ali or Alan Silva?", "relevance": 2.3333, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the birth name of the drummer who was part of the quartet that recorded the album Center of the World?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the real name of the free jazz drummer on the album\"Center of the World\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Wake Island is an unorganized, unincorporated territory of the United States Minor Outlying Islands that is also claimed by which country?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the other name for the island that is near Minami-Tori-shima?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mami-Tori-shima is nearly on a straight line between mainland Tokyo and which coral atoll in the western Pacific Ocean?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Minami-Tori-shima, also known as Marcus Island, is an isolated Japanese coral atoll in the northwestern Pacific Ocean, located some 1848 km southeast of Tokyo and 1267 km east of the closest Japanese island, South Iwo Jima of the Ogasawara Islands, and nearly on a straight line between mainland Tokyo and the United States' Wake Island, also know as what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which is further from Tokyo, Wake Island or Minami-Tori-shima?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the coral atoll in the western Pacific Ocean in the northeastern area of the Micronesia subregion, which is 1415 km further to the east-southeast of Minami-Tori-shima?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Minami-Tori-shima is near what coral atoll in the western Pacific Ocean?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the coral atoll located in the western Pacific Ocean that is an unorganized, unincorporated territory of the United States and is also claimed by the Republic of the Marshall Islands?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the distance between Wake Atoll and Minami-Tori-shima?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Minami-Tori-shima is near which coral atoll in the western Pacific Ocean in the northeastern area of the Micronesia subregion?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is another name for Wake Island, an unorganized, unincorporated territory of the United States Minor Outlying Islands located in the western Pacific Ocean and claimed by the Republic of the Marshall Islands?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the other name for the island that is 1415 km further to the east-southeast of Minami-Tori-shima?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which island is closer to Tokyo, Wake Island or Minami-Tori-shima?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Minami-Tori-shima is near what coral atoll in the western Pacific Ocean?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the nickname of the island that is 1,415 km further to the east-southeast of Tokyo?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What test series followed the \"Operation Aqueduct\" series and preceded the \"Operation Julin\" series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The United States's Julin nuclear test series was a group of 7 nuclear tests conducted in 1991–1992, these tests followed the \"Operation Sculpin\" series, and preceded the \"Operation Julin\" series, the United States's Sculpin nuclear test series was a group of 7 nuclear tests conducted in 1990-1991, these tests followed which series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The United States's Julin nuclear test series followed what series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Operation Sculpin nuclear test series and the last before negotiations began for the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty followed what series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which series was conducted first, Operation Aqueduct or Operation Sculpin?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What series preceded the series that was followed by the last before negotiations began for the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The United States's Sculpin nuclear test series was a group of 7 nuclear tests conducted in 1990-1991, these tests followed which series, and were the last before negotiations began for the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the name of the series of nuclear tests conducted by the United States that preceded the Sculpin series and followed the Julin series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What were the nuclear tests that followed the Operation Aqueduct series and preceded the Operation Julin series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The United States's Julin nuclear test series followed the \"Operation Sculpin\" series, which followed what series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The United States's Sculpin nuclear test series, which was a group of 7 nuclear tests conducted in 1990-1991, followed which series of nuclear tests?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What series preceded the United States's Julin nuclear test series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which series of nuclear tests was conducted first, Operation Sculpin or Operation Julin?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.3333, "prediction": "The United States's Julin nuclear test series followed the series that followed what other series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What test preceded Operation Julian before negotiations began for the Coprehensive Test Ban Treaty?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In the Boudougate scandal, how much money did the shell corporation \"The Old Fund\" give to Ciccone Calcográfica?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the amount of money given to Ciccone by a shell corporation representing Alejandro Vandenbroele?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Boudougate is a political scandal in Argentina involving Vice President Amado Boudou and the printing house Ciccone Calcográfica, a shell corporation named \"The Old Fund\", represented by Alejandro Vandenbroele, gave how much to Ciccone?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Boudougate is a political scandal in Argentina involving Vice President Amado Boudou and the printing house Ciccone Calcográfica, a shell corporation named \"The Old Fund\", represented by Alejandro Vandenbroele, gave him how much money to Ciccone?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "How much money did Alejandro Vandenbroele give to Ciccone?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How much money was given to Ciccone by a shell corporation that was represented by Alejandro Vandenbroele?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the amount given to Ciccone by the shell corporation that represented the AFIP in the scandal involving Vice President Amado Boudou?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How much money did \"The Old Fund\" provide to Ciccone Calcográfica during the Boudougate scandal in Argentina?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the amount of money given by \"The Old Fund\" to Ciccone Calcográfica, resulting in Alejandro Vandenbroele becoming its president, during the Boudougate scandal in Argentina?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.3333, "prediction": "How much did the company that gave Ciccone the money subdivided into 100 centavos give to Ciccone?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "During the Boudougate political scandal in Argentina, how much money did the shell corporation \"The Old Fund\" give to Ciccone Calcográfica, which led to Alejandro Vandenbroele becoming its president?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What amount of currency did Alejandro Vandenbroele give to Ciccone?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How much did The Old Fund give to Ciccone?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How much money was given to Ciccone by a shell corporation in the Boudougate scandal?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How much Argentina currency was involved in Boudougate?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When did the owner of Skateboarder Magazine announce that the publication would cease production?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When did the magazine that featured the winner of \"Skateboarder\"s Amateur of the Year award cease production?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Hudson Riley Hawk, better known as Riley Hawk is an American professional skateboarder, as of August 2013, Skateboarder Magazine is primarily a digital skateboarding publication that produces a limited run of hard copy versions that are sold in skateboard shops, on August 19, 2013, the magazine's owner GrindMedia announced that the publication would cease production on which date?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "American professional skateboarder Riley Hawk won the Amateur of the Year award for a magazine whose owner GrindMedia announced that it would cease production on what date?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When did Skateboarder Magazine cease production?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Hudson Riley Hawk was the winner of the Amateur of the Year award from a magazine that will cease production on what date?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When did the magazine cease production of the magazine that Riley Hawk won \"Skateboarder\"s Amateur of the Year award?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When did Skateboarder Magazine cease production?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When did GrindMedia announce that Skateboarder Magazine would cease production?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When did the magazine that Hudson Riley Hawk was the winner of \"Skateboarder\"s Amateur of the Year award cease production?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Skateboarder Magazine, the United States' first skateboarding magazine, ceased production on what date in 2013, as announced by its owner GrindMedia?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When did the magazine cease production that awarded Riley Hawk the Amateur of the Year award?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the person who is the editor of Skateboarder Magazine?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When did the magazine that awarded Hudson Riley Hawk the Amateur of the Year award cease production?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which date occurred first the end of Riley Hawk's amateur career or end of production of Skateboard Magazine?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Traveling Wilburys were a British-American supergroup consisting of which musician?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the member of the British-American supergroup that covered \"Nobody's Child\"?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "\"Nobody's Child\" is a song written by Cy Coben and Mel Foree, the band recorded two albums, the first in 1988 and the second in 1990, though Orbison died before the second was recorded, The Traveling Wilburys' 1990 version made it to #44 on the UK charts, a British-American supergroup consisting of who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "\"Nobody's Child\" is a song written by Cy Coben and Mel Foree, The Traveling Wilburys' 1990 version made it to #44 on the UK charts, the 1990 version was by a British-American supergroup consisting of George Harrison, Jeff Lynne, Roy Orbison, Tom Petty, and who else?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was in the band that recorded two albums, the first in 1988 and the second in 1990, though Orbison died before the second was recorded?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the member of the band that covered Nobody's Child in 1990?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the British-American supergroup that made it to #44 on the UK charts in 1990?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which member of the British-American supergroup The Traveling Wilburys also had a successful solo career and is known for songs like \"Blowin' in the Wind\" and \"Like a Rolling Stone\"?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which member of The Traveling Wilburys contributed to the recording of \"Nobody's Child\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the member of the British-American supergroup that covered \"Nobody's Child\" in 1990?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Traveling Wilburys, a British-American supergroup, included which notable musician among its members, who is also known for his solo career and influential work in the music industry?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was in the British-American supergroup that covered Nobody's Child in 1990?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the first person to cover Nobody's Child?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the member of the British-American supergroup that covered Nobody's Child in 1990?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Name a member of a British-American supergroup who recored a version of Nobody's child in 1990", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are the two categories of European vehicle categories for four-wheeled microcars?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are the two categories of the non-electric version of the Neighborhood Electric Vehicle?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 1.6667, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.3333, "prediction": "A Neighborhood Electric Vehicle (NEV) is a U.S. denomination for battery electric vehicles that are usually built to have a top speed of 25 mph, and have a maximum loaded weight of 3,000 lb, two categories are defined; knowingly what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2, "prediction": "A Neighborhood Electric Vehicle (NEV) is a U.S. denomination for battery electric vehicles that are usually built to have a top speed of 25 mph, and have a maximum loaded weight of 3,000 lb, the non-electric version of the neighbourhood electric vehicle is the Motorised quadricycle, Quadricycles are European vehicle categories of four-wheeled microcars defined by limitations in terms of weight, power and speed, two categories are defined; knowingly known as?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are the two categories of quadricycles?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are the two categories of the non-electric version of the Neighborhood Electric Vehicle?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are the two categories of vehicles that are defined by limitations in terms of weight, power and speed, and are the non-electric version of the neighbourhood electric vehicle?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are the two categories of quadricycles as defined by European vehicle regulations?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are the two categories of quadricycles defined in Europe based on limitations in terms of weight, power, and speed, that are different from Neighborhood Electric Vehicles (NEVs) in the U.S.?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are the two European vehicle categories of four-wheeled microcars defined by limitations in terms of weight, power and speed, that are the non-electric version of the Neighborhood Electric Vehicle?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are the two categories defined within the European vehicle categories for four-wheeled microcars, which are defined by limitations in terms of weight, power, and speed?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are the two categories of the non-electric version of the Neighborhood Electric Vehicle?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are the two categories of quadricycles?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are the two categories of the non-electric version of the Neighborhood Electric Vehicle?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are the two categories of the non-electric version of the neighbourhood electric vehicle?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The 2011 Washington Huskies football team played their final home game at which stadium due to a planned renovation of Husky Stadium?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The 2011 Washington Huskies football team represented the University of Washington in the 2011 NCAA Division I FBS football season, they were defeated by Baylor 56–67, the 2011 Baylor Bears football team represented Baylor University in the 2011 NCAA Division I FBS football season, the team was coached by Art Briles and played their home games at which location in Waco, Texas?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where did the team that beat the 2011 Washington Huskies football team play their home games?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where did the team that defeated the 2011 Washington Huskies in the Alamo Bowl play their home games?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where did the Baylor Bears play their home games?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where did the 2011 Baylor Bears football team play their home games?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where did the 2011 Washington Huskies football team play their home games?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where did the 2011 Baylor Bears football team play their home games during the NCAA Division I FBS football season?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What stadium did the 2011 Baylor Bears football team play their home games at?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where did the team that defeated the Washington Huskies football team in the 2011 Alamo Bowl play their home games?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The 2011 Baylor Bears football team, coached by Art Briles, played their home games at which stadium in Waco, Texas during the 2011 NCAA Division I FBS football season?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where did the team that beat the 2011 Washington Huskies football team in the Alamo Bowl play their home games?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which team won the Alamo Bowl?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where did the team that defeated the Washington Huskies in the Alamo Bowl play their home games?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Huskies football team were invited to the Alamo Bowl where they were defeated by a team coached by Art Briles and who played their home games at what statium?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are some traditional Hawaiian foods that are typically served at a luau, which is a traditional Hawaiian party or feast?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Hawaiian Cottage included a show that included what type of food?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Hawaiian Cottage is known for its atmosphere that includes a feast that may feature food such as what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Hawaiian Cottage's exterior was known for its vivid yellow, pineapple-shaped dome, burning Polynesian torches at the entrance, and a Hawaiian atmosphere that included a show of a feast that may feature food such as what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What are some of the foods that may be served at a luau?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What food may be served at a traditional Hawaiian party or feast that is usually accompanied by entertainment, and is a type of event that The Hawaiian Cottage was known for?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What food items are featured in the Hawaiian Cottage?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are some traditional dishes that might have been served at a luau show at The Hawaiian Cottage in Cherry Hill, New Jersey?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are some traditional Hawaiian foods that are typically served at a luau party?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What food is featured in the Hawaiian atmosphere of the Hawaiian Cottage?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Hawaiian Cottage was known for its luau show which would likely feature what traditional Hawaiian foods?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What foods may be featured in a traditional Hawaiian party or feast that is usually accompanied by entertainment and is served at a restaurant in Cherry Hill, New Jersey?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are some of the foods that are served at a luau?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What food was featured in the show at the Hawaiian Cottage?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What are some foods that may have been served at the Hawaiin Cottage?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "A pine is any conifer in the genus Pinus, , of the family Pinaceae. How many species names of pines are accepted as current according to the Plant List compiled by the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew and Missouri Botanical Garden?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which genus has more species, Butea or Pinus?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which genus has more species, Pinus or Butea?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "While Butea is a genus of flowering plants belonging to the pea family, what is the sole genus in the subfamily Pinoideae?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which genus has more species, Pinus or Butea?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which genus has more species, Butea or Pine?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which genus has more species, Butea or Pine?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the genus name for the conifers that belong to the family Pinaceae and are commonly referred to as pines?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the subfamily that \"Pinus\" belongs to and how many species names of pines are currently accepted by The Plant List compiled by the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew and Missouri Botanical Garden?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which genus has more species, Butea or Pinus?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the sole genus in the subfamily Pinoideae, which belongs to the family Pinaceae and includes species accepted by the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew and Missouri Botanical Garden?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which genus has more species, Butea or Pinus?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which genus of flowering plants has more species, Butea or Butea?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which genus has more species, Butea or Pinus?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Between Pine and Butea, which genus has the greatest number of species?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the MVP of the 2009 St. Petersburg Bowl presented by Beef 'O' Brady's, catching 4 passes for 97 yards and a touchdown in addition to rushing 14 times for 47 yards and two touchdowns?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What American football wide receiver for the Atlanta Falcons of the National Football League (NFL) caught 4 passes for 97 yards and a touchdown in the 2009 St. Petersburg Bowl?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The 2009 St. Petersburg Bowl featured which Atlanta Falcons wide receiver?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The 2009 St. Petersburg Bowl presented by Beef 'O' Brady's, was the second edition of the college football bowl game, Rutgers defeated UCF 45–24 in a game where which American football wide receiver for the Atlanta Falcons of the National Football League (NFL), was the game's MVP?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the MVP of the 2009 St. Petersburg Bowl?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What American football wide receiver for the Atlanta Falcons of the National Football League (NFL) was the game's MVP in the 2009 St. Petersburg Bowl?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the MVP of the 2009 St. Petersburg Bowl who played college football at Rutgers?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was named the MVP of the 2009 St. Petersburg Bowl after an outstanding performance for Rutgers, catching passes and rushing for touchdowns?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What team did Mohamed Sanu Sr. play for during the 2009 St. Petersburg Bowl and how did he perform in the game?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What player drafted by the Cincinnati Bengals in the third round of the 2012 NFL Draft played in the 2009 St. Petersburg Bowl?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the MVP of the 2009 St. Petersburg Bowl, where he caught 4 passes for 97 yards and a touchdown and rushed 14 times for 47 yards and two touchdowns, and is also known as an American football wide receiver for the Atlanta Falcons?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which American football wide receiver for the Atlanta Falcons was the MVP of the 2009 St. Petersburg Bowl?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the MVP of the 2009 St. Petersburg Bowl?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The 2009 St. Petersburg Bowl presented by Beef 'O' Brady's, formerly known as the St. Petersburg Bowl, was the second edition of the college football bowl game and was played at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg, Florida, Rutgers defeated UCF 45–24 in a game where which American football wide receiver for the Atlanta Falcons of the National Football League (NFL), caught 4 passes for 97 yards and a touchdown in addition to rushing 14 times for 47 yards and two touchdowns?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "During the 2009 St. Petersburg Bowl on December 19, 2009, which future Atlanta Falcons wide receiver was the game's MVP?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who played Captain Clayton in John Ford's \"The Searchers\" and also appeared in the film \"Operation Pacific\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Operation Pacific is a 1951 World War II submarine film starring John Wayne and Patricia Neal, featuring which American film character actor whose rugged appearance and easygoing charm were featured in more than two hundred films and the NBC television series \"Wagon Train\" from 1957 to 1960?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Operation Pacific is a 1951 World War II submarine film starring John Wayne and Patricia Neal, featuring which American film character actor whose rugged appearance and easygoing charm were featured in more than two hundred films and the NBC television series \"Wagon Train\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Operation Pacific is a 1951 World War II submarine film starring John Wayne and Patricia Neal, featuring which American film character actor whose rugged appearance and easygoing charm were featured in more than two hundred films and the NBC television series \"Wagon Train\" from 1957 to 1960?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the actor that starred in the 1951 World War II submarine film Operation Pacific?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Operation Pacific is a 1951 World War II submarine film starring John Wayne and Patricia Neal, featuring which American film character actor whose rugged appearance and easygoing charm were featured in more than two hundred films and the NBC television series \"Wagon Train\" from 1957 to 1960?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which actor in Operation Pacific was also in \"Wagon Train\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who played supporting roles alongside John Wayne in the 1951 World War II submarine film \"Operation Pacific\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the technical advisor for the 1951 film \"Operation Pacific\" that starred John Wayne and Patricia Neal and featured Ward Bond and Philip Carey?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which actor in Operation Pacific was also in \"It's a Wonderful Life\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who starred alongside John Wayne and Patricia Neal in the 1951 World War II submarine film \"Operation Pacific,\" which was directed by George Waggner?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which actor in Operation Pacific also played Bert in It's a Wonderful Life?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the name of the character played by Ward Bond in It's a Wonderful Life?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which actor in Operation Pacific was born on April 9, 1903?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who co-starred alongside John Wayne in the 1951 World War II submarine film Operation Pacific?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Is \"Gael\" a United States-based women's magazine?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Fitness and Gael both published in the United States?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Fitness and Gael both women's magazines?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Fitness and Gael published in the same country?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine is not based in the United States, Fitness or Gael?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Fitness and Gael both published in the United States?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Fitness and Gael both magazines?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Is \"Gael\" magazine focused on health and exercise like \"Fitness\" magazine?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Does Gael magazine have any connection or affiliation with Fitness magazine?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Gael and Fitness both magazines published in the United States?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are both \"Gael\" and \"Fitness\" magazines published in the United States?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Fitness and Gael both based in the United States?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 1.6667, "prediction": "no", "relevance": 1, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Fitness and Gael both based in the United States?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Gael and Fitness published in the same country?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Graptopetalum plants native to Mexico and Arizona?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Couroupita and Graptopetalum both types of plants?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Graptopetalum and Couroupita both plants?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Graptopetalum and Couroupita both plant genera?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which genus is older, Graptopetalum or Couroupita?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Graptopetalum and Couroupita both plants?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Couroupita and Graptopetalum both plants?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Is Graptopetalum a genus of perennial succulent plants native to Mexico and Arizona, distinct from the Couroupita genus, which is native to tropical South America and Central America?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are there any similarities between Graptopetalum and Couroupita plants?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Couroupita and Graptopetalum both types of plants?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Graptopetalum plants native to Mexico and Arizona?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Couroupita and Graptopetalum both native to the same continent?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 1.6667, "prediction": "Answer: no", "relevance": 1, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Couroupita and Graptopetalum both plants?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Couroupita and Graptopetalum plants both native to central America?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Federico García Lorca was a Spanish poet, playwright, and what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 2, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "José Rubia Barcia published a great number of books and articles on a Spanish poet, playwright, and what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 2, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "José Rubia Barcia published a great number of books and articles on a Spanish poet, playwright, and what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.3333, "prediction": "José Rubia Barcia (1914–1997) was born in Ferrol (Galicia), where a cultural center dedicated to him now houses his library and a collection of his papers, Barcia published a great number of books and articles on Federico García Lorca, was a Spanish poet, playwright, and what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the occupation of the person who died in 1936?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 1.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "José Rubia Barcia published a great number of books and articles on a Spanish poet, playwright, and what other occupation?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 2, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "José Rubia Barcia published a great number of books and articles on a Spanish poet, playwright, and what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was one of Federico García Lorca's professions besides being a poet and playwright?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was Federico García Lorca and what was his profession?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 2, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "José Rubia Barcia published a great number of books and articles on a Spanish poet, playwright, and what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What profession did Federico García Lorca have in addition to being a Spanish poet and playwright?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 2, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "José Rubia Barcia published a great number of books and articles on a Spanish poet, playwright, and what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the profession of the person who studied Arabic and Hispano-Arabic literature at the University of Granada?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "José Rubia Barcia published a great number of books and articles on Valle Inclán, Unamuno, Federico Garca Lorca, a Spanish poet, playwright, and what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 2, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "José Rubia Barcia published a great number of books and articles on a Spanish poet, playwright, and what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The 8th Military Police Brigade is a military police brigade of the United States Army based at Schofield Barracks, Hawaii, which is located in the City and County of Honolulu and in the Wahiawa District of the American island of Oʻ ahu, Hawaiʻ i.", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The 8th Military Police Brigade is a military police brigade of the United States Army based at Schofield Barracks, a United States Army installation and census-designated place (CDP) located in the City and County of which city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In what city is the 8th Military Police Brigade based?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The 8th Military Police Brigade is a military police brigade of the United States Army based at an installation and census-designated place (CDP) located in the City and County of what city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the place where the 8th Military Police Brigade is based?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The 8th Military Police Brigade is a military police brigade of the United States Army based at Schofield Barracks, Hawaii, Schofield Barracks is a United States Army installation and census-designated place (CDP) located in the City and County of which city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The 8th Military Police Brigade is based at a United States Army installation and census-designated place located in the City and County of what city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the city and county where Schofield Barracks, the location of the 8th Military Police Brigade, is situated in Hawaii?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the city and county where Schofield Barracks is located, and what is the name of the island it is on?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The 8th Military Police Brigade is based at a United States Army installation and census-designated place located in what city and county?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The 8th Military Police Brigade, responsible for military police units in the Pacific Ocean region, is based at an installation located in the City and County of which American location?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The 8th Military Police Brigade is based at a United States Army installation located in what city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the town that is separated from most of Schofield Barracks by Lake Wilson?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The 8th Military Police Brigade is based at a barracks located in what city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In which county does the 8th Military Police Brigade of the United States Army's Barracks located?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who portrayed the character of Steven Quincy Urkel on the sitcom \"Family Matters\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Steven Quincy Urkel is a fictional character on the ABC/CBS sitcom \"Family Matters\" who was portrayed by which American actor, born November 27, 1976?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Steven Quincy Urkel is a fictional character on the ABC/CBS sitcom \"Family Matters\" who was portrayed by which American actor, born November 27, 1976?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Steven Quincy Urkel is a fictional character on the ABC/CBS sitcom \"Family Matters\" who was portrayed by which American actor, born on November 27, 1976?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who played the role of Steve Urkel on Family Matters?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which actor portrayed the character Steven Quincy Urkel on the ABC/CBS sitcom \"Family Matters\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What actor played the role of Steve Urkel on the ABC/CBS sitcom Family Matters?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who played the character of Steve Urkel on the sitcom \"Family Matters\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who portrayed the character of Steve Urkel on the sitcom \"Family Matters\" and also provided the voice for Sonic the Hedgehog in various animated series and a fan film?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Steven Quincy Urkel is a fictional character on the ABC/CBS sitcom \"Family Matters\" who was portrayed by which American actor, in 1989, he was cast in the role of Steve Urkel on the sitcom \"Family Matters\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who portrayed the character Steve Urkel on the sitcom \"Family Matters,\" which was originally intended to be a one-time guest appearance but became a regular role due to the character's popularity?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Steven Quincy Urkel was portrayed by which American actor?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who played Steve Urkel on Family Matters?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Steven Quincy Urkel is a fictional character on the ABC/CBS sitcom \"Family Matters\" who was portrayed by which American actor, in 1989, he was cast in the role of Steve Urkel on the sitcom \"Family Matters\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which American actor portray Steve Urkel in\"Family Matters\"", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "PPA, Pattugliatore Polivalente d'Altura is a new Frigate class of the Italian Navy, a frigate is any of several types of warship, what is PPA an abbreviation for?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the new Frigate class of the Italian Navy?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 1.6667, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.3333, "prediction": "PPA, Pattugliatore Polivalente d'Altura, is a new Frigate class of the Italian Navy, a frigate is any of several types of warship, the term having been used for ships of various sizes and roles over the last few centuries, is called?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "PPA, Pattugliatore Polivalente d'Altura (Offshore Multipurpose Patrol Ship) is a new class of which class of several types of warship, the term having been used for ships of various sizes and roles over the last few centuries?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the full name of the ship that is a new Frigate class of the Italian Navy?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the new class of warship that is used for ships of various sizes and roles over the last few centuries?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the new class of the Italian Navy that is any of several types of warships?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What does the acronym PPA stand for in the context of the new Frigate class of the Italian Navy?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is PPA and what role does it play in the Italian Navy's fleet of frigates?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the new Frigate class of the Italian Navy, which is a type of warship?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What does PPA stand for in the context of a new Frigate class of the Italian Navy?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the new class of warships in the Italian Navy?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the ship that is a new Frigate class of the Italian Navy?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the new class of warships in the Italian Navy?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of one the Italian Navy's new warship?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who voices the character Zola in the \"Blue Dragon\" series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Cindy Robinson voices Zola in what anime adaptation of a video game series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Cindy Robinson is an American voice actress who voices in anime, cartoons and video games, her major roles are Zola in which anime adaptation of the \"Blue Dragon\" video game series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Cindy Robinson voiced Zola in what anime adaptation of the \"Blue Dragon\" video game series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the anime that Cindy Robinson voices in?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Cindy Robinson is an American voice actress who voices in anime, cartoons and video games, some of her major roles are Zola in which anime adaptation of the \"Blue Dragon\" video game series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Cindy Robinson has a major role in which anime adaptation of the \"Blue Dragon\" video game series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What series does Cindy Robinson voice the character Zola in?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the anime adaptation of the \"Blue Dragon\" video game series, and which character did Cindy Robinson voice in the series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Cindy Robinson is an American voice actress who voices in anime, cartoons and video games, some of her major roles include Zola in which anime adaptation of the \"Blue Dragon\" video game series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Cindy Robinson is an American voice actress known for voicing characters in various anime, cartoons, and video games. Which character does she voice in the anime adaptation of the \"Blue Dragon\" video game series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Cindy Robinson is an American voice actress who voices in anime, cartoons and video games, some of her major roles are Zola in which anime adaptation of the \"Blue Dragon\" video game series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the anime that Cindy Robinson voiced?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Cindy Robinson is an American voice actress who voices in anime, cartoons and video games, some of her major roles are Zola in which anime adaptation of the \"Blue Dragon\" video game series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which of the role of Cindy Robinson was an anime adaptation of the\"Blue Dragon\" video game series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Roger Taylor is best known as the drummer for which rock band?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older, Roger Taylor or Jennifer Nettles?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older, Roger Taylor or Jennifer Nettles?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Roger Taylor and Jennifer Nettles, are American?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which singer is younger, Roger Taylor or Jennifer Nettles?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which singer was born first, Roger Taylor or Jennifer Nettles?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older, Roger Taylor or Jennifer Nettles?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the lead singer of the duo Sugarland, known for charting as a duet partner on the country version of Bon Jovi's 2006 single \"Who Says You Can't Go Home\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who did Jennifer Nettles chart as a duet partner with on the country version of Bon Jovi's 2006 single \"Who Says You Can't Go Home\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older, Jennifer Nettles or Roger Taylor?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is best known as the lead singer of the duo Sugarland alongside Kristian Bush, and also charted as a duet partner on the country version of rock band Bon Jovi's 2006 single \"Who Says You Can't Go Home\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is younger, Jennifer Nettles or Roger Taylor?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which singer was born first, Roger Meddows Taylor or Jennifer Nettles?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older, Roger Taylor or Jennifer Nettles?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which singer is in the duo Sugarland, Jennifer Nettles or Roger Taylor?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Braehead is a commercial development located at the former site of Braehead Power Station in Renfrew on the south bank of which river?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The Scottish Maritime Museum has a third museum located on the south bank of what river?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The third museum at the Scottish Maritime Museum is located on the south bank of what river?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The Scottish Maritime Museum has a third museum located on the south bank of what river?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What river is Braehead located on?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Scottish Maritime Museum was located at a commercial development on the south bank of what river?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Scottish Maritime Museum has a museum on the south bank of what river?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What river is the commercial development of Braehead located on?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What river is Braehead located on the south bank of in Renfrewshire, where the Clydebuilt museum was closed in 2010 due to lack of funding?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Scottish Maritime Museum has a third museum, \"Clydebuilt\" at a commercial development located on the south bank of what river?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Braehead, known for its shopping centre, arena, and leisure facilities, is a commercial development located on the south bank of which river in Renfrewshire?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 1.6667, "prediction": "The Scottish Maritime Museum currently has collections located at two sites in the West of Scotland, both with strong maritime connections, a third museum, \"Clydebuilt\" at Braehead, originally opened in 1999 but was closed indefinitely during October 2010 due to lack of funding, Braehead (Scots: \"Braeheid\", Gaelic: \"Ceann a' Bhruthaich\") is a commercial development located", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the river that runs through Braehead?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The Scottish Maritime Museum has a third museum located on the south bank of what river?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "\"Clydebuilt\" is on the south bank of what river?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Baroness Karen Christenze von Blixen-Finecke is best known under her pen names Isak Dinesen and Tania Blixen, who is best known under the pen name \"Woody\" Allen?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who has a wider scope of profession, Woody Allen or Karen Blixen?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, Karen von Blixen or Woody Allen?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Karen Blixen-Finecke and Woody Allen, have which mutual occupation?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which author was born first, Baroness Karen Christenze von Blixen-Finecke or Heywood \"Woody\" Allen?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who has a longer career, Woody Allen or Karen Christenze von Blixen-Finecke?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who has more scope of profession, Karen Christenze von Blixen-Finecke or Woody Allen?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the real name of the American filmmaker and comedian better known as \"Woody\" Allen?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the American filmmaker, writer, actor, comedian, and musician whose career spans more than six decades and is known as Woody Allen?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who has more scope of profession, Karen Christenze von Blixen-Finecke or Woody Allen?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Which American filmmaker, writer, actor, comedian, and musician, known for a career spanning more than six decades, was born Allan Stewart Konigsberg on December 1, 1935?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who has more scope of profession, Woody Allen or Karen Blixen?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which author was born first, Karen Christenze von Blixen-Finecke or Woody Allen?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who has a wider scope of profession, Woody Allen or Karen Blixen?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which writer, Karen Blixen or Woody Allen, has a broader range of artistic talents?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Is the Larnaca Salt Lake considered one of the most important wetlands of Cyprus?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Larnaca Salt Lake and Milk Lake both located in Taiwan?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Milk Lake and Larnaca Salt Lake in the same country?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Milk Lake and Larnaca Salt Lake in the same country?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which lake is smaller, Larnaca Salt Lake or Milk Lake?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Larnaca Salt Lake and Milk Lake both in the same country?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Larnaca Salt Lake and Milk Lake in the same country?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Is the Larnaca Salt Lake the largest salt lake in Cyprus?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Is the Larnaca Salt Lake considered an Important Bird Area (IBA)?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Milk Lake and Larnaca Salt Lake located in the same country?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are the Larnaca Salt Lake and the Milk Lake both located in Cyprus?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Larnaca Salt Lake and Milk Lake both located in the same country?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 1.6667, "prediction": "no", "relevance": 1, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Larnaca Salt Lake and Milk Lake both located in Taiwan?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Milk Lake, Taiwan and Larnaca Salt Lake both located in Asia?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Republican Alex M. Clark became the youngest mayor of Indianapolis in 1951, he served one term and later ran again in 1967, losing in the primary to eventual winner Richard Lugar, who served as a United States senator representing Indiana until what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Alex M. Clark lost in the primary to a man who served as a United States senator, representing Indiana from 1977 to what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In what year did Alex M. Clark lose in the primary to an American politician and member of the Republican Party?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Alex Clark lost the primary to a United States senator who represented Indiana from 1977 to what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When did the person who defeated Alex M. Clark in the primary for the mayor of Indianapolis die?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Alex M. Clark lost in the 1967 primary to a Republican who served as a United States senator from 1977 to what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Alex M. Clark lost in the 1967 primary to a politician who served as a senator from 1977 to what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When did Richard Lugar's tenure as a United States senator representing Indiana end?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When did Richard Lugar finish his term as a United States senator representing Indiana?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In what year did the winner of the 1967 primary of the Republican primary of Indianapolis run for United States senator?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Richard Green \"Dick\" Lugar, a member of the Republican Party, served as a United States senator representing Indiana until what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Alex M. Clark lost in the primary to a politician who served as a United States senator until what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What party did Alex M. Clark belong to?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Alex M. Clark, was an American politician, he served one term and later ran again in 1967, losing in the primary to eventual winner Richard Green \"Dick\" Lugar, an American politician and member of the Republican Party who served as a United States senator, representing Indiana from 1977 to which year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What year did the person who beat Alex Clark for mayor in 1967 stop serving as a US senator?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is a retired American baseball pitcher who played 17 seasons in Major League Baseball (MLB) for the St. Louis Cardinals, was nicknamed \"Gibby\" and \"Hoot\", and had his uniform number 45 retired by the Cardinals?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Race for the Pennant was hosted by which retired American baseball pitcher?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 1.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Race for the Pennant is a weekly sports show that focused on Major League Baseball and premiered on Home Box Office (HBO) in 1978, it was hosted by Len Berman, Tim McCarver, Barry Tompkins, Maury Wills and others, including which retired American baseball pitcher, who played 17 seasons in MLB (1959–75)?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 1.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Race for the Pennant is a weekly sports show that focused on Major League Baseball and premiered on Home Box Office (HBO) in 1978, it was hosted by Len Berman, Tim McCarver, Barry Tompkins, Maury Wills and others, including which retired American baseball pitcher who played 17 seasons, for the St. Louis Cardinals (1959–75)?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the host of Race for the Pennant?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which retired American baseball pitcher who played 17 seasons in Major League Baseball (MLB) for the St. Louis Cardinals hosted Race for the Pennant?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Race for the Pennant was hosted by which retired American baseball pitcher who played 17 seasons in Major League Baseball (MLB) for the St. Louis Cardinals?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the retired American baseball pitcher, known for playing with the St. Louis Cardinals, that also served as one of the hosts for HBO's 'Race for the Pennant'?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was one of the hosts of the weekly sports show Race for the Pennant that focused on Major League Baseball and premiered on Home Box Office (HBO) in 1978?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Race for the Pennant was hosted by which retired American baseball pitcher?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the retired American baseball pitcher, nicknamed \"Gibby\" and \"Hoot\", who played for the St. Louis Cardinals and was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1981, also known for hosting HBO's \"Race for the Pennant\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which host of Race for the Pennant was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1981?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the nickname of the player who played for the St. Louis Cardinals?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which host of Race for the Pennant was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1981?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the one of the hosts of the Race for the Pennant sports show who is a retired american baseball pitcher?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Is Donny Armstrong currently the president and CEO of Mind Vision Productions?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Lasse Hallström and Dionciel Armstrong both film directors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Dionciel Armstrong and Lasse Hallström both film directors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Dionciel Armstrong and Lasse Hallström, are in the film industry?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which director was born first, Lars Sven \"Lasse\" Hallström or Dionciel (Donny) Armstrong?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Donny Armstrong and Lars Hallström both film directors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Lasse Hallström and Dionciel Armstrong both film directors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Is Dionciel Armstrong an American involved in the film industry?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Did Dionciel Armstrong work with Lars Hallström on any film projects?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Donny Armstrong and Lasse Hallström both directors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Was Dionciel Armstrong born and raised in Detroit, Michigan?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Lasse Hallström and Donny Armstrong both film directors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Answer: Which director was born first, Donny Armstrong or Lars Sven \"Lasse\" Hallström?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Are Dionciel Armstrong and Lasse Hallström both film directors?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Has Lasse Hallström gotten more Academy Award nominations than Dionciel Armstrong?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Bain Capital is a global alternative investment firm based in which city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where is the investment firm that acquired TI Automotive based?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "In 2015 TI Automotive was acquired by a global alternative investment firm based where?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where is the company that acquired TI Automotive in 2015 based?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where is Bain Capital based?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In 2015 TI Automotive was acquired by a global alternative investment firm based in what city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where is the global alternative investment firm based that acquired TI Automotive in 2015?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where is Bain Capital, the global alternative investment firm that acquired TI Automotive in 2015, based?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is Bain Capital and where is it based?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where is the global alternative investment firm based that acquired TI Automotive in 2015?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Bain Capital, a global alternative investment firm that acquired TI Automotive in 2015 and manages a significant amount of investor capital, is based in which American city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In 2015 TI Automotive was acquired by a global alternative investment firm based in what city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the company that acquired TI Automotive in 2015?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where is the investment firm that acquired TI Automotive based?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where is the investment firm that acquired TI Automotive in 2015 headquartered?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Kevin Antony Rowland is an English born singer-songwriter of Irish descent and frontman for which pop band?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Kevin Rowland and Lauri Ylönen, have which mutual occupation?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Lauri Ylönen and Kevin Rowland, have which mutual occupations?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What do Lauri Ylönen and Kevin Rowland have in common?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which musician is younger, Kevin Antony Rowland or Lauri Ylönen?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What do Kevin Rowland and Lauri Ylönen have in common?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What do Kevin Rowland and Lauri Ylönen have in common?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What profession do Kevin Rowland and Lauri Ylönen share?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is Kevin Antony Rowland and what is his profession?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Lauri Ylönen and Kevin Rowland, have which mutual occupation?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Kevin Antony Rowland, known for hits like \"Geno\" and \"Come On Eileen\" with Dexys Midnight Runners, holds what profession?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What do Lauri Ylönen and Kevin Rowland have in common?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which singer-songwriter was born later, Kevin Antony Rowland or Lauri Ylönen?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Kevin Rowland and Lauri Ylönen, have which mutual occupation?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Kevin Rowland and Lauri Ylönen both share what occupation?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What kind of diet does Dr. Joel Fuhrman advocate in his book \"Eat to Live: The Amazing Nutrient-Rich Program for Fast and Sustained Weight Loss\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Eat to Live is a book written by a doctor who advocates what type of diet?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Eat to Live is a book written by an American celebrity doctor who advocates what diet?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Eat to Live: The Amazing Nutrient-Rich Program for Fast and Sustained Weight Loss was written by an American celebrity doctor who advocates what diet?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What kind of diet does Joel Fuhrman advocate?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Eat to Live: The Amazing Nutrient-Rich Program for Fast and Sustained Weight Loss is a book written in 2003 by Dr. Joel Fuhrman, an American celebrity doctor who advocates what he calls what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Eat to Live is a book written by a celebrity doctor who advocates what diet?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What type of diet does Dr. Joel Fuhrman advocate for in his book \"Eat to Live\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is Dr. Joel Fuhrman's dietary philosophy, as described in his book Eat to Live: The Amazing Nutrient-Rich Program for Fast and Sustained Weight Loss?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What diet does the author of Eat to Live advocate?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What type of diet does Dr. Joel Fuhrman, the author of \"Eat to Live: The Amazing Nutrient-Rich Program for Fast and Sustained Weight Loss,\" advocate for?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What kind of diet does the author of Eat to Live advocate?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What does the book written by Dr. Joel Fuhrman call a micronutrient-rich diet?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Eat to Live is a book written by a celebrity doctor who advocates what diet?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What type of diet does the author of Eat to Live: The Amazing Nutrient-Rich Program for Fast and Sustained Weight Loss advocate?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What term was first coined by fans of Manchester United to disparage Liverpool's achievements and success in the League Cup?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the subjective term used in football, particularly in English football, to negatively describe a cup, league, or other competition as being of a lower standard, importance or significance to a football club or manager relative to other competitions, that was first coined by fans of Manchester United as a way of disparaging their rivals Liverpool's achievements and success in the League Cup?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is a subjective term used in football, particularly in English football, to negatively describe a cup, league, or other competition as being of a lower standard, importance or significance to a football club or manager relative to other competitions, the term was first coined by fans of Manchester United as a way of disparaging their rivals Liverpool's achievements and success in the League Cup?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The North-West Derby is considered to be one of the biggest rivalries in the football world along with the Old Firm derby in Scotland, which term was coined by fans of Manchester United as a way of disparaging their rivals?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the competition that Manchester United fans use to disparage Liverpool's achievements?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the subjective term used in football, particularly in English football, to negatively describe a cup, league, or other competition as being of a lower standard, importance or significance to a football club or manager relative to other competitions, that was first coined by fans of Manchester United as a way of disparaging their rivals Liverpool's achievements and success in the League Cup?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What is the subjective term used in football, particularly in English football, to negatively describe a cup, league, or other competition as being of a lower standard, importance or significance to a football club or manager relative to other competitions, that is a high-profile inter-city rivalry between English professional football clubs Liverpool and Manchester United?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What derogatory term, originating from the rivalry between Manchester United and Liverpool fans, is used to belittle the significance of certain football competitions, and what does it reference in terms of its original association with supporters from Liverpool?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the origin of the term \"Mickey Mouse Cup\" and how has it been applied in football competitions?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What subjective term used in football, particularly in English football, to negatively describe a cup, league, or other competition as being of a lower standard, importance or significance to a football club or manager relative to other competitions, was coined by fans of Manchester United as a way of disparaging their rivals Liverpool's achievements and success in the League Cup?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What derogatory term used in English football, particularly to describe competitions seen as less significant, was first coined by Manchester United fans to belittle Liverpool's success in the League Cup?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 1.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the cup that is considered to be one of the biggest rivalries in the football world along with the Old Firm derby in Scotland, Superclásico in South America, El Clásico in Spain, and Derby della Madonnina in Italy, and is considered the most famous fixture in English football?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the competition that is referred to as the \"Mickey Mouse Cup\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the subjective term used in football, particularly in English football, to negatively describe a cup, league, or other competition as being of a lower standard, importance or significance to a football club or manager relative to other competitions, used to disparage the rivalry between Liverpool F.C.–Manchester United F.C.?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What term was used in the North-West Derby to disparge their rivals?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Great South Bay is situated between Long Island and Fire Island, in which state?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Oak Beach is a small community located on the eastern end of Jones Beach Island, a barrier island between the Atlantic Ocean and the Great South Bay, actually a lagoon, is situated between Long Island and Fire Island, in which state?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Oak Beach is a small community located on the eastern end of Jones Beach Island, a barrier island between the Atlantic Ocean and the Great South Bay, actually a lagoon, is situated between which location?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Oak Beach is a small community located on the eastern end of Jones Beach Island, a barrier island between the Atlantic Ocean and the Great South Bay of which location?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the place that is situated between Long Island and Fire Island?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Oak Beach is a small community located on the eastern end of Jones Beach Island, a barrier island between the Atlantic Ocean and the Great South Bay of which island?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Oak Beach is a small community located on the eastern end of Jones Beach Island, a barrier island between the Atlantic Ocean and the Great South Bay, actually a lagoon, is situated between Long Island and Fire Island, in the State of New York, Oak Beach is a small community located on the eastern end of Jones Beach Island, a barrier island between the Atlantic Ocean and the Great South Bay of which location?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which island is situated between the Great South Bay and the Atlantic Ocean in the State of New York?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the lagoon situated between Long Island and Fire Island in the State of New York, which is approximately 45 miles long and protected from the Atlantic Ocean by Fire Island, a barrier island, as well as the eastern end of Jones Beach Island and Captree Island?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 1.6667, "prediction": "Oak Beach is a small community located on the eastern end of Jones Beach Island, a barrier island between the Atlantic Ocean and the Great South Bay, actually a lagoon, is situated between Long Island and Fire Island, in the State of New York, it is approximately 45 mi long and protected from the Atlantic Ocean by Fire Island, a barrier island, as well as the eastern end of Jones Beach Island and Captree Island, Oak Beach is a small community located on the eastern end of Jones Beach Island, a barrier island between the Atlantic Ocean and the Great South Bay, actually a lagoon, is situated between Long Island and Fire Island, in the State of New York?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Great South Bay is a lagoon situated between which island and Fire Island, in the State of New York?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1.3333, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Oak Beach is a small community located on the eastern end of Jones Beach Island, a barrier island between the Atlantic Ocean and the Great South Bay, actually a lagoon, is situated between Long Island and Fire Island, in the State of New York, it is approximately 45 mi long and protected from the Atlantic Ocean by Fire Island, a barrier island, as well as the eastern end of Jones Beach Island and Captree Island?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the barrier island that protects Great South Bay from the Atlantic Ocean?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Oak Beach is a small community located on the eastern end of Jones Beach Island, a barrier island between the Atlantic Ocean and the Great South Bay, actually a lagoon, is situated between Fire Island, and which location?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Oak Beach, New York and Great South Bay are both situated between what same island?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Steel Venom is a steel Inverted Impulse roller coaster located at Valleyfair in Minnesota, it is similar to which roller coaster at Cedar Point?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Steel Venom is similar to which second generation steel Inverted Impulse roller coaster at Cedar Point in Sandusky, Ohio?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Steel Venom is similar to what second generation steel Inverted Impulse roller coaster at Cedar Point in Sandusky, Ohio?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Steel Venom is similar to which roller coaster in Sandusky, Ohio?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which roller coaster is taller, Steel Venom or Wicked Twister?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Steel Venom is a steel Inverted Impulse roller coaster located at Valleyfair in Minnesota, it is similar to which second generation steel Inverted Impulse roller coaster at Cedar Point in Sandusky, Ohio, as of 2017, it is the tallest and fastest inverted roller coaster in the world?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which roller coaster is taller, Steel Venom or Wicked Twister?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the roller coaster at Cedar Point that is similar to Steel Venom at Valleyfair and is known as the tallest and fastest inverted roller coaster in the world as of 2017?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the height and speed of Steel Venom at Valleyfair, and how does it compare to Wicked Twister at Cedar Point and Possessed at Dorney Park & Wildwater Kingdom?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Steel Venom is similar to which second generation steel Inverted Impulse roller coaster at Cedar Point in Sandusky, Ohio?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Steel Venom, a steel Inverted Impulse roller coaster at Valleyfair, is similar to which roller coaster at Cedar Point that, as of 2017, is the tallest and fastest inverted roller coaster in the world?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Steel Venom is similar to which roller coaster at Cedar Point in Sandusky, Ohio?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which roller coaster is taller, Wicked Twister or Steel Venom?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which roller coaster is taller, Steel Venom or Wicked Twister?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which is farther north, Steel Venom or Wicked Twister?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The 442nd Regimental Combat Team, a fighting unit composed almost entirely of American soldiers of Japanese ancestry, fought in World War II primarily in Europe beginning in what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Only the Brave is a 2006 independent film about an infantry regiment of the United States Army, part of the Army Reserve, beginning in what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 1.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Only the Brave is a film about an infantry regiment of the United States Army, part of the Army Reserve, beginning in what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1.6667, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Only the Brave is a 2006 independent film about the 100th Infantry Battalion/442nd Regimental Combat Team, a segregated World War II fighting unit primarily made up of \"Nisei\" Japanese Americans, beginning in what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What year did the 442nd Regimental Combat Team begin fighting in Europe?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 1.3333, "prediction": "Only the Brave is a 2006 independent film about the 100th Infantry Battalion/442nd Regimental Combat Team, an infantry regiment of the United States Army, part of the Army Reserve, the regiment was a fighting unit composed almost entirely of American soldiers of Japanese ancestry (mostly from Hawaii) who fought in World War II, beginning in which year, the regiment fought primarily in Europe during World War II, in particular", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Only the Brave is a 2006 independent film about a fighting unit that began in what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In what year did the 442nd Regimental Combat Team, primarily made up of Japanese American soldiers, begin their combat operations in Europe during World War II?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What year did the 442nd Regimental Combat Team fight primarily in Europe during World War II?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Only the Brave is a 2006 independent film about a unit that began fighting in Europe in what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What year did the 442nd Regimental Combat Team, a unit composed almost entirely of American soldiers of Japanese ancestry, begin fighting in Europe during World War II, as depicted in the independent film \"Only the Brave\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Only the Brave is a 2006 independent film about a segregated World War II fighting unit primarily made up of \"Nisei\" Japanese Americans, which for its size and length of service became the most decorated unit in U.S. military history, the 442nd Regimental Combat Team is an infantry regiment of the United States Army, part of the Army Reserve, the regiment was a fighting unit composed almost entirely of American soldiers of Japanese ", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What year did the regiment begin fighting primarily in Europe?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1.6667, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Only the Brave is a 2006 independent film about a segregated World War II fighting unit primarily made up of \"Nisei\" Japanese Americans, which for its size and length of service became the most decorated unit in U.S. military history, the 442nd Regimental Combat Team is an infantry regiment of the United States Army, part of the Army Reserve, began in which year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 2, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What year did the infantry regiment featured in the 2006 film\"Only the Brave\" begin?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What city was 10 Years formed in?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Minus the Machine is the sixth studio album by a band formed in what city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where was the band that released Minus the Machine formed?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where was the band that released the album Minus the Machine formed?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What city is 10 Years from?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Minus the Machine is the sixth studio album by an American alternative metal band formed in 1999, in which city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where was the band that released the album Minus the Machine formed?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where was the American rock band 10 Years formed?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What is the origin of the band 10 Years?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where was the band that released the album Minus the Machine formed?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "10 Years is an American alternative metal band known for their album Minus the Machine, which was released through their own independent label. In what city was this band formed?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where was the band that released the album \"Minus the Machine\" formed?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the band that released minus the machine?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where was the band that released the album Minus the Machine formed?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Minus the Machine is the sixth studio album by a band formed in which city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 2, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Stone Temple Pilots is an American rock band from San Diego, California, that originally consisted of Scott Weiland (lead vocals), brothers Dean (guitar) and Robert DeLeo (bass, backing vocals), and Eric Kretz (drums), who replaced the previous lead vocalist of which band in 2013?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which band has more members, Milky Chance or Stone Temple Pilots?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which band was formed first, Stone Temple Pilots or Milky Chance?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which band has more members, Milky Chance or Stone Temple Pilots?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which band is older, Stone Temple Pilots or Milky Chance?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which band has more members, Milky Chance or Stone Temple Pilots?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which band Milky Chance or Stone Temple Pilots has more members?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Which American rock band, formed in 1989 and known for hits like \"Plush\" and \"Interstate Love Song,\" originally featured Scott Weiland as the lead vocalist before his departure and subsequent replacement by Linkin Park's Chester Bennington?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the American rock band from San Diego that launched an online audition for a new lead vocalist in 2016, after the firing of Scott Weiland in 2013 and the departure of Chester Bennington in 2015?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which band was formed first, Stone Temple Pilots or Milky Chance?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What American rock band from San Diego, originally consisting of Scott Weiland, Dean and Robert DeLeo, and Eric Kretz, remained unchanged until 2013 and held online auditions for a new lead vocalist in 2016?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which band has more members, Stone Temple Pilots or Milky Chance?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which band was formed first, Stone Temple Pilots or Milky Chance?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which band has more members, Milky Chance or Stone Temple Pilots?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which band originated from the United States, Milky Chance or Stone Temple Pilots?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When did the Kreisky-Peter-Wiesenthal affair occur?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Kreisky–Peter–Wiesenthal affair was a political and personal feud in which decade, fought between the then Austrian chancellor Bruno Kreisky and the Nazi hunter Simon Wiesenthal, a Jewish Austrian Holocaust survivor, Nazi hunter, and writer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Kreisky–Peter–Wiesenthal affair was a political and personal feud in which decade, fought between the then Austrian chancellor Bruno Kreisky and the Nazi hunter Simon Wiesenthal, a Jewish Austrian Holocaust survivor, Nazi hunter, and writer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The Kreisky–Peter–Wiesenthal affair was a political and personal feud in the 1970s fought between the then Austrian chancellor Bruno Kreisky and the Nazi hunter Simon Wiesenthal arising from Kreisky's ministerial appointments and the SS past of Freedom Party leader Friedrich Peter, which had been revealed by Wiesenth, in the personal feud, in which time period?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When did the Kreisky–Peter–Wiesenthal affair take place?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Kreisky–Peter–Wiesenthal affair was a political and personal feud in which decade fought between the then Austrian chancellor Bruno Kreisky and the Nazi hunter Simon Wiesenthal, a Jewish Austrian Holocaust survivor, Nazi hunter, and writer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Kreisky–Peter–Wiesenthal affair was a political and personal feud in which decade, fought between the then Austrian chancellor Bruno Kreisky and the Nazi hunter Simon Wiesenthal, a Jewish Austrian Holocaust survivor, Nazi hunter, and writer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "During which decade did the Kreisky–Peter–Wiesenthal affair, involving Austrian chancellor Bruno Kreisky and Nazi hunter Simon Wiesenthal, take place?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the timeframe of the Kreisky-Peter-Wiesenthal affair?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Kreisky–Peter–Wiesenthal affair was a political and personal feud in the 1970s fought between the then Austrian chancellor Bruno Kreisky and the Nazi hunter Simon Wiesenthal, a Jewish Austrian Holocaust survivor, Nazi hunter, and writer, in which decade?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "During which decade did the political and personal feud known as the Kreisky–Peter–Wiesenthal affair, involving Austrian chancellor Bruno Kreisky and Nazi hunter Simon Wiesenthal, take place?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.3333, "prediction": "The Kreisky–Peter–Wiesenthal affair was a political and personal feud in which decade, fought between the then Austrian chancellor Bruno Kreisky and the Nazi hunter Simon Wiesenthal, was a Jewish Austrian Holocaust survivor, Nazi hunter, and writer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What year did Simon Wiesenthal die?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Kreisky–Peter–Wiesenthal affair was a political and personal feud in which time period, fought between the then Austrian chancellor Bruno Kreisky and the Nazi hunter Simon Wiesenthal, a Jewish Austrian Holocaust survivor, Nazi hunter, and writer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.3333, "prediction": "As a Nazi hunter, Simon Wiesenthal, was apart of a fued in what time frame?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The BMW E70 is the second-generation BMW X5 mid-size luxury crossover SUV, it replaced the BMW X5 (E53) in November 2006, alongside what other BMW model at BMW's Greer, South Carolina plant in the U.S. and BMW's facility in Toluca, Mexico?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which mid-size luxury crossover by German automaker BMW is manufactured alongside the BMW E70?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The BMW E70 is manufactured alongside which mid-size luxury crossover by German automaker BMW?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The BMW E70 is manufactured alongside what mid-size luxury crossover by German automaker BMW?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which car is newer, BMW E70 or BMW X6?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the mid-size luxury crossover by German automaker BMW that is manufactured alongside the BMW E70?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the mid-size luxury crossover by German automaker BMW that is manufactured alongside the BMW E70?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the model name of the mid-size luxury crossover by German automaker BMW that is manufactured alongside the second-generation BMW X5 at BMW's facilities in the U.S. and Mexico?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is manufactured alongside the BMW E70 at BMW's Greer, South Carolina plant in the U.S. and BMW's facility in Toluca, Mexico?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the mid-size luxury crossover by German automaker BMW that was manufactured alongside the BMW E70?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which mid-size luxury crossover by German automaker BMW is manufactured alongside the second-generation BMW X5 at BMW's Greer, South Carolina plant in the U.S. and BMW's facility in Toluca, Mexico?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What mid-size luxury crossover by German automaker BMW is manufactured alongside the BMW E70?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which vehicle is manufactured at BMW's Greer, South Carolina plant?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What mid-size luxury crossover by German automaker BMW is manufactured alongside the BMW E70?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "BMW X5 is a mid-size version that was produced alongside which newer model, produced in 2009?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Charlie Ross ran for Congress in Mississippi's 3rd congressional district in 2008 but was defeated in the primary by whom?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What Republican Party member defeated Charlie Ross in the primary?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Charlie Ross ran for Congress in Mississippi's 3rd congressional district, but was defeated in the primary by Rankin County Republican Chairman who is the U.S. Representative for Mississippi's 3 congressional district, serving since 2009?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Charlie Ross is an American politician and attorney who lives in Brandon, Mississippi, in 2008, Ross ran for Congress in Mississippi's 3rd congressional district, but was defeated in the primary by Rankin County Republican Chairman who, which U.S. Representative for Mississippi's 3 congressional district, serving since 2009?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the current representative for Mississippi's 3rd congressional district?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Charlie Ross was defeated in the primary by which U.S. Representative for Mississippi's 3 congressional district, serving since 2009?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Charlie Ross ran for Congress in Mississippi's 3rd congressional district, but was defeated in the primary by which Rankin County Republican Chairman?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who defeated Charlie Ross in the primary for Congress in Mississippi's 3rd congressional district in 2008?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who defeated Charlie Ross in the primary for Congress in Mississippi's 3rd congressional district in 2008?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which Republican politician defeated Charlie Ross in the 2008 Mississippi Congressional District primary?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who defeated Charlie Ross in the primary for Congress in Mississippi's 3rd congressional district in 2008?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the U.S. Representative for Mississippi's 3 congressional district who defeated Charlie Ross in the primary?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the person who defeated Charlie Ross in the primary?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which Republican representative from Mississippi defeated Charlie Ross in 2008?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which Republican Chairman was born June 1, 1956?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was Joe Dever's occupation before becoming a fantasy author and game designer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2, "prediction": "What was the creator of Freeway Warrior originally a musician?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 2, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Freeway Warrior is a series of 4 gamebooks, created by a British fantasy author and game designer who was what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Freeway Warrior is a series of 4 gamebooks created by a British fantasy author and game designer who was originally what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was Joe Dever's occupation before he became a fantasy author and game designer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 1.6667, "prediction": "Freeway Warrior is a series of 4 gamebooks, created by Joe Dever, also known as Joe Dever, also known as Joe Dever, was a British fantasy author and game designer, originally a musician, Dever became the first British winner of the \"Advanced Dungeons & Dragons\" Championship of America in 1982, Dever was a British fantasy author and game designer, originally a musician?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the occupation of the creator of Freeway Warrior?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was Joe Dever's profession before he became a renowned fantasy author and game designer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What did Joe Dever do before becoming a game designer and author, and what was his achievement in 1982?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the profession of the creator of Freeway Warrior?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Joe Dever, the British fantasy author and game designer who created the Freeway Warrior series of gamebooks, had what initial career before becoming the first British winner of the \"Advanced Dungeons & Dragons\" Championship of America in 1982?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the original occupation of the creator of the Freeway Warrior series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was Joe Dever's first occupation?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the original profession of the creator of Freeway Warrior?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the author of Freeway Warrior's original occupation?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Marilyn Martin is best known for her hit duet \"Separate Lives\" with which artist?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Through His Eyes is the third studio album from an American singer best known for her 1985 hit duet with who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Through His Eyes is the third studio album from an American singer best known for her 1985 duet with who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Through His Eyes is the third studio album from an American singer best known for her 1985 hit duet with who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the singer that Marilyn Martin is best known for her 1985 hit duet with?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Through His Eyes is the third studio album from an American singer best known for her 1985 hit duet with who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Through His Eyes is the third studio album from an American singer best known for her 1985 hit duet with who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who did Marilyn Martin collaborate with on the 1985 hit duet \"Separate Lives\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who did Marilyn Martin have a hit duet with in 1985 on the song \"Separate Lives\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Through His Eyes is the third studio album from an American singer best known for her 1985 duet with who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Marilyn Martin is known for her 1985 hit duet with which artist, on the song \"Separate Lives\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Through His Eyes is the third studio album from an American singer best known for her 1985 hit duet with who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the person who recorded Through His Eyes?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Through His Eyes is the third studio album from an American singer best known for her 1985 hit duet with who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which male singer performed together with a female American singer, who was born in 1954 and whose third studio album was named Through His Eyes, have a hit duet with in 1985?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the birthdate of Virginia Bruce?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Let Freedom Ring starred the actress who was born on September what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Let Freedom Ring is a 1939 film starring Nelson Eddy and an American actress and singer who was born in 1910, and was how old?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Let Freedom Ring is a 1939 in Sepiatone Western directed by Jack Conway, starring Virginia Bruce, was an American actress and singer, born on September 29, 1910, and was how old?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the full name of the person who died in 1982?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 1.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Let Freedom Ring starred an actress and singer born at what age?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How old was the actress who starred in Let Freedom Ring with Nelson Eddy?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What day in September was Virginia Bruce, the actress from the 1939 film \"Let Freedom Ring,\" born?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the birthdate of Virginia Bruce, the American actress and singer who starred in Let Freedom Ring?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Let Freedom Ring starred the actress and singer who was born in what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Virginia Bruce, an American actress and singer who starred in \"Let Freedom Ring,\" was born on which date in September?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How old was the American actress and singer who starred in Let Freedom Ring with Nelson Eddy?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What year did Virginia Bruce die?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Let Freedom Ring starred the actress and singer who was born on September 29th of what year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How old was Virginia Bruce when she starred in Let Freedom Ring?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was an American contralto who had a long and celebrated career at the Metropolitan Opera in New York City from 1962 through 1986 and often chose to sing oratorios from memory?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first Lili Chookasian or Constantine Orbelian?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first Constantine Orbelian or Lili Chookasian?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2, "fluency": 3, "prediction": " Constantine Orbelian, Jr. and Lili Chookasian are both American composers, who was born first?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was older, Lili Chookasian or Constantine Garrievich Orbelian Jr.?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which singer was born first, Lili Chookasian or Constantine Orbelian?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, Lili Chookasian or Constantine Orbelian?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the American contralto that gained prominence in the 1960s and 1970s and had a notable tenure at the Metropolitan Opera from 1962 to 1986?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the name of the American contralto who had a long and celebrated career at the Metropolitan Opera in New York City from 1962 through 1986 and was admired for her sonorous, focused tone as well as her excellent musicianship, and often chose, against tradition, to sing oratorios from memory, and who is Constantine Orbelian named after?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, Constantine Orbelian or Lili Chookasian?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which American contralto, known for her sonorous, focused tone and excellent musicianship, began her career as a concert singer in the 1940s and later had a celebrated career at the Metropolitan Opera from 1962 through 1986?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, Lili Chookasian or Constantine Orbelian?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the first name of the person who began her career in the 1940s as a concert singer but did not draw wider acclaim until she began singing opera in her late thirties?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, Constantine Orbelian or Lili Chookasian?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which musician was born first, Constantine Orbelian or Lili Chookasian?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Kerwin Swint is known for his research and writing in the fields of political campaigns, mass media, and political history. In which media company has his work appeared?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Kerwin Swint's work has appeared in which American digital, print, and e-commerce media company focused on millennials?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Kerwin Swint has appeared in which digital, print, and e-commerce media company focused on millennials?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Kerwin Swint has appeared in what digital, print, and e-commerce media company that is owned by Dennis Publishing and based in New York City?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the media company that teamed with the National Geographic Channel for its first televised special?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which media company is owned by Dennis Publishing and based in New York City, Kerwin Swint or Mental Floss?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Kerwin Swint has appeared in which digital, print, and e-commerce media company focused on millennials?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which media company, known for presenting facts, puzzles, and trivia with a humorous tone, has featured the work of American political scientist Kerwin Swint and also collaborated with the National Geographic Channel for a televised special?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the media company that teamed up with the National Geographic Channel for the first-ever live broadcast of brain surgery in 2015?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Kerwin Swint has appeared in what American digital, print, and e-commerce media company focused on millennials?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Kerwin Swint is known for his research and writing in the fields of political campaigns, mass media, and political history, and his work has appeared in various media outlets including an American digital, print, and e-commerce media company focused on millennials that presents facts, puzzles, and trivia with a humorous tone. What is the name of this media company where his work has been featured?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which American digital, print, and e-commerce media company focused on millennials has Kerwin Swint written for?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the magazine that has a circulation of 160,000 and publishes six issues a year?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Kerwin Swint, is an American political scientist and author, known for his research and writing in the fields of political campaigns, mass media, and political history, he or his work has appeared in a number of national and international media, including which American digital, print, and e-commerce media company focused on millennials?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where has Kerwin Swint's work appeared that draws 20.5 million unique visitors a month?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Shirley MacLaine received the 40th AFI Life Achievement Award from the American Film Institute in 2012, and received the Kennedy Center Honors for her lifetime contributions to American culture through the performing arts in 2013, she was born on what date?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the American film, television and theater actress, singer, dancer, activist and author born who starred in The Matchmaker?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the birthdate of this American film, television and theater actress, singer, dancer, activist and author, who starred in The Matchmaker?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The Matchmaker is a 1958 American comedy film directed by Joseph Anthony, the film stars Shirley MacLaine, an American film, television and theater actress, singer, dancer, activist and author, born on which date?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the date of birth of the person who received the 40th AFI Life Achievement Award from the American Film Institute in 2012?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the American film, television and theater actress, singer, dancer, activist and author who starred in The Matchmaker born?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the American film, television and theater actress, singer, dancer, activist and author born who starred in The Matchmaker?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was Shirley MacLaine, the star of the 1958 film \"The Matchmaker,\" born?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is Shirley MacLaine's birthdate and what was her role in The Matchmaker?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the American film, television and theater actress, singer, dancer, activist and author born who was starred in The Matchmaker?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the birthdate of Shirley MacLaine, the American actress who starred in the 1958 film \"The Matchmaker\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the American film, television and theater actress, singer, dancer, activist and author born who starred in The Matchmaker?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What year was Shirley MacLaine born?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the American film, television and theater actress, singer, dancer, activist and author born who was a star in The Matchmaker?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the American film, television and theater actress born who was a star in the film the Matchmaker and also received the 40th AFI Life Achievement Award?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The recorded History of Texas begins with the arrival of the first Spanish conquistadors in the region of North America now known as Texas in 1519, who found the region populated by numerous Native American /Indian tribes, who is known in Texan history as the \"mother of Houston\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Charlotte Baldwin Allen is known in Texan history as the \"mother of Houston\", she was the wife of Augustus Chapman Allen, who used her inheritance to finance the founding of this city, during which period of recorded history from A.D. 1519 to 1848?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Charlotte Baldwin Allen, is known in Texan history as the \"mother of Houston\", she was the wife of Augustus Chapman Allen, who used her inheritance to finance the founding of this city, which begins with the arrival of the first Spanish conquistadors in the region of North America now known as Texas in 1519, who found the region populated by numerous Native American /Indian tribes?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Charlotte Baldwin Allen, is known in Texan history as the \"mother of Houston\", which begins with the arrival of the first Spanish conquistadors in the region of North America now known as Texas in 1519, who found the region populated by numerous Native American /Indian tribes?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the first event in the history of Texas?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What began with the arrival of the first Spanish conquistadors in the region of North America now known as Texas in 1519, and Charlotte Baldwin Allen is known in Texan history as the \"mother of Houston\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 1.3333, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Charlotte Baldwin Allen is known in Texan history as the \"mother of Houston\", what recorded history begins with the arrival of the first Spanish conquistadors in the region of North America now known as Texas in 1519, who found the region populated by numerous Native American /Indian tribes?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What does the recorded history of Texas encompass, and who is recognized as the \"mother of Houston\" for her financial contributions to the founding of the city?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who financed the founding of Houston and what is the recorded history of Texas?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Charlotte Baldwin Allen is known in Texan history as the \"mother of Houston\" in which historical event that began with the arrival of the first Spanish conquistadors in the region of North America now known as Texas in 1519, who found the region populated by numerous Native American /Indian tribes?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What marks the beginning of the recorded history of Texas, which saw the arrival of Spanish conquistadors and found the region populated by numerous Native American tribes?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Charlotte Baldwin Allen is known in Texan history as the \"mother of Houston\", she was the wife of Augustus Chapman Allen, who used her inheritance to finance the founding of this city, in which recorded history of Texas, begins with the arrival of the first Spanish conquistadors in the region of North America now known as Texas in 1519, who found the region populated by numerous Native American /Indian tribes?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the first country to claim Texas?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Charlotte Baldwin Allen, is known in Texan history as the \"mother of Houston\", she was the wife of Augustus Chapman Allen, who used her inheritance to finance the founding of this city, which began with the arrival of the first Spanish conquistadors in the region of North America now known as Texas in 1519, who found the region populated by numerous Native American /Indian tribes?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What record officially started in 1519 in the same state that holds the city Augustus Chapman Allen used his inheritance to fund the founding of?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is a commercial document issued by a seller to a buyer, relating to a sale transaction and indicating the products, quantities, and agreed prices for products or services the seller had provided the buyer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the commercial document issued by a seller to a buyer that is able to be used by TimeCamp?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "TimeCamp is an example of time tracking software, which enables which commercial document issued by a seller to a buyer, relating to a sale transaction and indicating the products, quantities, and agreed prices for products or services the seller had provided the buyer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "TimeCamp is a web-based application launched in 2009 by Kamil Rudnicki, a programmer and founder of Time Solutions, to track the activity of computer users and it is dedicated either to freelancers or teams, the tool is an example of time tracking software, which enables invoicing the employees' work based on an hourly rate, measuring the work effectiveness and project management, which commercial document issued by a seller to a buyer, relating to a sale transaction and indicating the products, quantities, and agreed prices for products or services the seller had provided the buyer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the commercial document issued by a seller to a buyer, relating to a sale transaction and indicating the products, quantities, and agreed prices for products or services the seller had provided the buyer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the commercial document issued by a seller to a buyer, relating to a sale transaction and indicating the products, quantities, and agreed prices for products or services the seller had provided the buyer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "TimeCamp is a web-based application launched in 2009 by Kamil Rudnicki, a programmer and founder of Time Solutions, to track the activity of computer users and it is dedicated either to freelancers or teams, the tool is an example of time tracking software, which enables invoicing the employees' work based on an hourly rate, measuring the work effectiveness and project management, what is a commercial document issued by a seller to a buyer, relating to a sale transaction and indicating the products, quantities, and agreed prices for what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What type of commercial document can TimeCamp generate to indicate the details of a sale transaction, such as the products, quantities, and agreed prices for services provided?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the purpose of the invoicing feature in TimeCamp?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "TimeCamp is a web-based application launched in 2009 by Kamil Rudnicki, a programmer and founder of Time Solutions, to track the activity of computer users and it is dedicated either to freelancers or teams, the tool is an example of time tracking software, which enables invoicing the employees' work based on an hourly rate, measuring the work effectiveness and project management, a commercial document issued by a seller to a buyer, relating to a sale transaction and indicating the products, quantities, and agreed prices for products or services the seller had provided the buyer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "TimeCamp, a web-based application launched in 2009, helps track computer user activity and is used by freelancers and teams for what purpose, which is based on an hourly rate and enables measuring work effectiveness and project management?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What commercial document issued by a seller to a buyer, relating to a sale transaction and indicating the products, quantities, and agreed prices for products or services the seller had provided the buyer, is TimeCamp a web-based application launched in 2009 by Kamil Rudnicki, a programmer and founder of Time Solutions, to track the activity of computer users and it is dedicated either to freelancers or teams?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the difference between an invoice and a bill?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "TimeCamp is a web-based application launched in 2009 by Kamil Rudnicki, a programmer and founder of Time Solutions, to track the activity of computer users and it is dedicated either to freelancers or teams, the tool is an example of time tracking software, which enables invoicing the employees' work based on an hourly rate, measuring the work effectiveness and project management, what is the commercial document issued by a seller to a buyer, relating to a sale transaction and indicating the products, quantities, and agreed prices for products or services the seller had provided the buyer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "TimeCamp enables what type of commercial documents from a seller to a buyer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Thunderbirds is a 1952 war film featuring the exploits of which infantry division in the Italian campaign of World War II?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Thunderbirds is a 1952 war film directed by John H. Auer, featuring the exploits of which infantry division of the United States Army, part of the Oklahoma Army National Guard, from 1920 to 1968?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Thunderbirds is a 1952 war film, featuring the exploits of which infantry division of the United States Army, part of the Oklahoma Army National Guard?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Thunderbirds is a 1952 war film directed by John H. Auer, featuring the exploits of which infantry division of the United States Army, part of the Oklahoma Army National Guard, from 1920 to 1968?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What military unit was Thunderbirds based on?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Thunderbirds is a 1952 war film directed by John H. Auer starring John Derek, John Drew Barrymore, Mona Freeman, Gene Evans, Eileen Christy and Ward Bond, featuring the exploits of which infantry division of the United States Army, part of the Oklahoma Army National Guard, from 1920 to 1968?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Thunderbirds is a 1952 war film featuring the exploits of which infantry division of the United States Army, part of the Oklahoma Army National Guard, from 1920 to 1968?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which U.S. Army infantry division is featured in the 1952 war film \"Thunderbirds,\" which portrays their involvement in the Italian campaign during World War II?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the lineage of the 45th Infantry Division and in which wars did they fight?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Thunderbirds featured the exploits of which infantry division of the United States Army, part of the Oklahoma Army National Guard, from 1920 to 1968?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Thunderbirds is a 1952 war film that features the exploits of which infantry division in the Italian campaign of World War II?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Thunderbirds is a 1952 war film directed by John H. Auer, featuring the exploits of which infantry division of the United States Army, part of the Oklahoma Army National Guard, from 1920 to 1968?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the name of the division that fought in both World War II and the Korean War?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Thunderbirds is a 1952 war film directed by John H. Auer starring John Derek, John Drew Barrymore, Mona Freeman, Gene Evans, Eileen Christy and Ward Bond, featuring the exploits of which infantry division of the United States Army, part of the Oklahoma Army National Guard, from 1920 to 1968?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Thunderbirds was a film featuring the exploits of what part of the Oklahoma Army National Guard?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Last Lions is a 2011 African nature documentary film by National Geographic Society, it follows in the tradition of other National Geographic big cat films, such as \"India: Land of the Tiger\" and \"Eye of the Leopard\", what genre is this film?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Andrew and Jeremy Get Married and The Last Lions, are which type of film?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Andrew and Jeremy Get Married and The Last Lions are both what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Last Lions and Andrew and Jeremy Get Married, are which type of film?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which film is older, The Last Lions or Andrew and Jeremy Get Married?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Andrew and Jeremy Get Married and The Last Lions, are which type of film?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Andrew and Jeremy Get Married and The Last Lions, are which type of film?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What genre of filmmaking do \"The Last Lions\" and \"Andrew and Jeremy Get Married\" belong to?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is The Last Lions and how does it compare to other National Geographic big cat films?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Andrew and Jeremy Get Married and The Last Lions, are which type of film?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What genre of film is \"The Last Lions,\" a 2011 film by National Geographic Society directed by Dereck and Beverly Joubert, and \"Andrew and Jeremy Get Married,\" a 2004 British film written and directed by Don Boyd for the BBC?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Andrew and Jeremy Get Married and The Last Lions, are which type of film?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which documentary film was released first, The Last Lions or Andrew and Jeremy Get Married?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Andrew and Jeremy Get Married and The Last Lions, are which type of film?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Both Andrew and Jeremy Get Married and The Last Lions are what type of films?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The American Athletic Conference features how many member universities?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many member universities are in the conference that the Connecticut Huskies baseball team competes in?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Connecticut Huskies baseball team competes in an American collegiate athletic conference featuring how many member universities?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Connecticut Huskies baseball team competes in a conference that has how many member universities?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many member universities does the American Athletic Conference have?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many member universities does the conference in which the Connecticut Huskies baseball team competes have?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many members are in the conference in which the Connecticut Huskies baseball team competes?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many universities are members of the American Athletic Conference in which the Connecticut Huskies baseball team competes?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many member universities are there in the American Athletic Conference and which university does the Connecticut Huskies baseball team represent?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many member universities are in the conference that the Connecticut Huskies baseball team competes in?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many member universities are part of the American Athletic Conference, which includes the University of Connecticut's baseball team?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many member universities are in the conference in which the Connecticut Huskies baseball team competes?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many member universities does the American Athletic Conference have?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many member universities are in the conference that the Connecticut Huskies baseball team competes in?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many member universities are there in this conference of which the Connecticut Huskies baseball team is a competing member?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Genre magazine was a New York city-based monthly periodical written for whom?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine is published more frequently, Allure or Genre?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine is published more frequently, Genre or Allure?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Genre and Allure are both what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine is not written for gay men, Allure or Genre?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine was founded first, Allure or Genre?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine was founded first, Genre or Allure?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is Allure, and can you provide some details about its publication and significance in the beauty industry?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the annual Best of Beauty awards and who gives out the accolades?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine is published by Conde Nast, Allure or Genre?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What type of magazine is Allure, and by which company is it published monthly?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine was founded first, Allure or Genre?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine was founded first, Genre or Allure?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine is aimed at women, Genre or Allure?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which magazine was founded first, Allure or Genre?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was the bassist for the music duo Hall & Oates and provided backing vocals on two songs on Mutlu Onaral's debut album?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mutlu Onaral's album \"Livin' It\" was produced by a musician who was a bassist for what music duo?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mutlu Onaral's debut album was produced by an American musician and bassist for what music duo?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": " Mutlu Onaral's debut album \"Livin' It\" was produced by a bassist for what music duo?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who died first, Tom Wolk or Mutlu Onaral?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mutlu Onaral's debut album was produced by the bassist for what music duo?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mutlu Onaral's album \"Livin' It\" was produced by a musician who was a bassist for what duo?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which famous music duo was Tom \"T-Bone\" Wolk a bassist for, who also produced Mutlu Onaral's debut album \"Livin' It\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who produced Mutlu Onaral's debut album \"Livin' It\" and also provided backing vocals on two of the songs?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mutlu Onaral's debut album was produced by the bassist for what music duo?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Tom \"T-Bone\" Wolk was known as the bassist for which music duo and also a member of the \"Saturday Night Live\" house band?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mutlu Onaral's debut album was produced by a bassist for what duo?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the band that Tom Wolk was a member of?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Mutlu Onaral's debut album was produced by the bassist for what music duo?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Mutlu Onaral album\"Livin' It\" was produced by the bassist for what duo?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1.6667, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 2.3333, "prediction": "Robert Lane \"Bob\" Saget is known for his adult-oriented stand-up routine, he also provided the voice of the future Ted Mosby on the CBS sitcom \"How I Met Your Mother\" from 2005 to 2014, who is the highest paid film-maker in India among his contemporaries?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older, Bob Saget or Shankar Shanmugam?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older, Bob Saget or Shankar?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Sshankar Shanmugam and Bob Saget, have which mutual occupation?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older, Shankar or Bob Saget?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older, Shankar Shanmugam or Bob Saget?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older, Shankar Shanmugam or Bob Saget?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the American stand-up comedian and actor known for his role as Danny Tanner on the sitcom \"Full House\" and for hosting \"America's Funniest Home Videos\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is Robert Lane \"Bob\" Saget and what are his notable television roles and stand-up comedy routines?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older, Bob Saget or Shankar Shanmugam?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is known for his roles as Danny Tanner on the sitcom \"Full House\" and as the host of \"America's Funniest Home Videos\" from 1989 to 1997, as well as for providing the voice of future Ted Mosby on \"How I Met Your Mother\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older, Shankar or Bob Saget?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the first name of the person who was born in 1956?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older, Bob Saget or Shankar Shanmugam?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older out of Bob Saget, the American comedian, and Indian director S. Shankar?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the title of the 2006 documentary film directed by Jon Gustafsson that tells the story of the dramatic circumstances Canadian director Sturla Gunnarsson and his crew had to go through during the making of the film \"Beowulf & Grendel\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which documentary was released first, My Kid Could Paint That or Wrath of Gods?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which documentary was released first, Wrath of Gods or My Kid Could Paint That?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Was Wrath of Gods or My Kid Could Paint That released first?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which documentary was released first, Wrath of Gods or My Kid Could Paint That?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which documentary was released first, My Kid Could Paint That or Wrath of Gods?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which documentary film was released first, My Kid Could Paint That or Wrath of Gods?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the title of the 2006 documentary film that chronicles the challenging production of \"Beowulf & Grendel\" and includes insights from the cast and crew, including Gerard Butler and Stellan Skarsgård?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the 2006 documentary film directed by Jon Gustafsson that tells the story of the making of \"Beowulf & Grendel\" and features Gerard Butler, Stellan Skarsgård, and Sarah Polley among others?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which documentary film was released first, Wrath of Gods or My Kid Could Paint That?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the title of the 2006 documentary directed by Jon Gustafsson that depicts the challenging production of \"Beowulf & Grendel\" and includes participants such as Gerard Butler and Stellan Skarsgård?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which documentary was released first, Wrath of Gods or My Kid Could Paint That?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What year was the film that follows the early artistic career of Marla Olmstead released?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which documentary was released first, My Kid Could Paint That or Wrath of Gods?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which movie is a documentary about\"Beowulf & Grendel\", between My Kid Could Paint That and Wrath of Gods?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Marie Gisèle Eleme Asse won two medals at the 2017 Jeux de la Francophonie, which city hosted the 2017 Jeux de la Francophonie?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Marie Gisèle Eleme Asse won two medals at a 2017 event held in what city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Marie Gisèle Eleme Asse won two medals at a competition held in what city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Marie Gisèle Eleme Asse won two medals at a competition held in what Ivory Coast city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What city is Marie Gisèle Eleme Asse from?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Marie Gisèle Eleme Asse won two medals at the 2017 Jeux de la Francophonie, also known as \"VIIIèmes Jeux de la Francophonie\", will be held in which city, Ivory Coast?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.3333, "prediction": "Marie Gisèle Eleme Asse won two medals at the 2017 Jeux de la Francophonie, also known as \"VIIIèmes Jeux de la Francophonie\" (French for \"8th Francophone Games\"), will be held in which city, Ivory Coast, from July 21–30?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the host city for the 2017 Jeux de la Francophonie where Cameroonian sprinter Marie Gisèle Eleme Asse won two medals?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where were the 2017 Jeux de la Francophonie held?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Marie Gisèle Eleme Asse won two medals at the 2017 Jeux de la Francophonie, also known as \"VIIIèmes Jeux de la Francophonie\", in which city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Marie Gisèle Eleme Asse, a Cameroonian sprinter who won two medals at the 2017 Jeux de la Francophonie, participated in an event hosted in which city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Marie Gisèle Eleme Asse won two medals at a 2017 event held in what city?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What country was Marie Gisèle Eleme Asse born in?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In what city did Marie Gisèle Eleme Asse win two medals?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.3333, "prediction": "what city will host the event in which marie gisele eleme asse won twoo medals in 2017", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "\"My Chick Bad\" is a song by Ludacris featuring which female rappers on the official remix?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What other female rappers were featured in the official remix of Ludacris' song \"My Chick Bad\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which female rappers were featured in Ludacris' remix of \"My Chick Bad\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "American rapper and member of the group Crime Mob was featured on Ludacris' remix of \"My Chick Bad\" along with which other female rappers?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who are the female rappers that appear on the official remix of \"My Chick Bad\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What other female rappers were featured in the remix of the song \"My Chick Bad\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What female rapper from Crime Mob was featured in Ludacris' eighth album?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which female rappers were featured on the official remix of Ludacris' song \"My Chick Bad\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who were the female rappers featured on the official remix of \"My Chick Bad\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who were the female rappers featured in the remix of the song My Chick Bad?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which female rappers are featured on the official remix of Ludacris' song \"My Chick Bad\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What other female rappers were featured in the remix of the song \"My Chick Bad\" by Ludacris?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which rappers were featured in the official remix to \"My Chick Bad\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who else was featured in the remix of \"My Chick Bad\" by Ludacris?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What other female rappers appeared Brittany Nicole Carpentero in the official remix to My Chick Bad?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Lafayette Pence was a U.S. Representative from which chamber of the United States Congress?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Lafayette Pence was a member of what lower chamber of the United States Congress?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Lafayette (Lafe) Pence, was a U.S. Representative from Colorado, and was a member of which lower chamber of the United States Congress?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Lafayette Pence was a U.S. representative from Colorado in what lower chamber of the United States Congress?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the lower chamber of the United States Congress?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Lafayette Pence was a member of what lower chamber of the United States Congress?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Lafayette Pence was a U.S. Representative from Colorado, and was a member of what lower chamber of the United States Congress?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What legislative body did Lafe Pence serve in as a representative from Colorado?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was a U.S. Representative from Colorado and served in the lower chamber of the United States Congress, which along with the Senate composes the legislature of the United States?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Lafayette Pence was a U.S. Representative from Colorado, in which lower chamber of the United States Congress?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Lafayette Pence, who served as a U.S. Representative from Colorado, was a member of which chamber of the United States Congress?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Lafayette Pence was a member of what lower chamber of the United States Congress?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the body that Lafayette Pence was a member of?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the lower chamber of the United States Congress that Lafayette Pence was a U.S. Representative from Colorado?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Lafe Pence was a member of which lower chamber of the United States congress?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who composed the song \"Misty Morning, Albert Bridge\" for the British-Irish folk rock band The Pogues?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What instrument did the composer of the 1989 single \"Misty Morning, Albert Bridge\" play?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2, "prediction": "\"Misty Morning, Albert Bridge\" is a 1989 single by the British-Irish folk rock band The Pogues, it was composed by Jem Finer, an English musician, artist and composer, and composed by who?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 1.3333, "prediction": "\"Misty Morning, Albert Bridge\" is a 1989 single by the British-Irish folk rock band The Pogues, it was composed by Jeremy Max \"Jem\" Finer, an English musician, artist and composer, and what instrument?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was Jem Finer's occupation when he composed \"Misty Morning, Albert Bridge\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the occupation of the English musician who composed the song \"Misty Morning, Albert Bridge\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What instrument did the composer of the song \"Misty Morning, Albert Bridge\" play?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who composed \"Misty Morning, Albert Bridge,\" the 1989 single by The Pogues?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who composed \"Misty Morning, Albert Bridge\" and what instrument did they play?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the profession of the composer of the 1989 single \"Misty Morning, Albert Bridge\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "\"Misty Morning, Albert Bridge\" is a 1989 single by The Pogues, featured on their fourth album \"Peace and Love.\" Who composed this song and also played an instrument in the band?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What instrument did the composer of \"Misty Morning, Albert Bridge\" play?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was Jem Finer's occupation?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What instrument was played by the English musician, artist and composer who was one of the founding members of The Pogues?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What intrusment did Jem Finer play in the band The Pogues?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Boules was featured in the unofficial programme of which international multi-sport event in 1900?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Boules was featured in what international multi-sport event that is hosted by a different city every four years?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What international multi-sport event that is hosted by a different city every four years featured Boules?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Boules was featured in which international multi-sport event that is hosted by a different city every four years?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What event was first held in 1896?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What international multi-sport event that is hosted by a different city every four years featured Boules in 1900?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What international multi-sport event that is hosted by a different city every four years, featured Boules in the unofficial programme in 1900?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "In which international multi-sport event, first held in 1896 and occurring every four years, was boules featured as an unofficial sport in 1900?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What was the name of the event in which Boules was featured in the Summer Olympic Games unofficial programme in 1900?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the international multi-sport event that is hosted by a different city every four years, in which Boules was featured in the unofficial programme in 1900?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Boules was featured in which international multi-sport event's unofficial programme in 1900?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What international multi-sport event that is hosted by a different city every four years featured Boules in its unofficial programme in 1900?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What sport was featured in the Summer Olympic Games unofficial programme in 1900?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Boules was featured in the unofficial programme in 1900 of which international multi-sport event that is hosted by a different city every four years?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 1.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which Olympic game featured Boules and happened right before medals started to be awarded?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Stephanie March is best known for her role as Alexandra Cabot in which long-running NBC series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Innocence is a 2013 American horror drama film directed by Hilary Brougher, the movie stars which American actress, best known for her role as Alexandra Cabot in the long-running NBC series, \"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Innocence is a 2013 American horror drama film directed by Hilary Brougher, who co-wrote the film with Tristine Skyler, the movie stars which American actress, best known for her role as Alexandra Cabot in the long-running NBC series, \"\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": " Innocence is a 2013 American horror drama film directed by Hilary Brougher, the movie stars which American actress, best known for her role as Alexandra Cabot in the long-running NBC series, \"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who starred in the 2013 American horror drama film Innocence?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Innocence is a 2013 American horror drama film directed by Hilary Brougher, the movie stars which American actress, best known for her role as Alexandra Cabot in the long-running NBC series, \"?\"", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Innocence is a 2013 American horror drama film directed by Hilary Brougher, the movie stars which American actress, best known for her role as Alexandra Cabot in the long-running NBC series, \"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is an American actress born on March 23, 1974, known for her role as Alexandra Cabot in a long-running NBC series and also appeared in the 2013 film \"Innocence\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who starred in the 2013 American horror drama film \"Innocence\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Innocence is a 2013 American horror drama film directed by Hilary Brougher, the movie stars which American actress, best known for her role as Alexandra Cabot in the long-running NBC series, \"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who stars as Alexandra Cabot in the long-running NBC series and also features in the 2013 American horror drama film \"Innocence\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which actress starred in Innocence and also played Alexandra Cabot in the long-running NBC series, \"\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the actress who starred in Innocence?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Innocence is a 2013 American horror drama film directed by Hilary Brougher, the movie stars which American actress, and is best known for her role as Alexandra Cabot in the long-running NBC series, \"\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the American actress that stars in the movie\"Innocesnce\" and is best known for her role as Alexandra Cabot in a long-running NBC series?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the American cartoonist best known for the comic strip \"Peanuts\" and was nicknamed Sparky?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the nickname of the cartoonist who created the comic strip that inspired the movie The Peanuts Movie?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the nickname of the creator of the comic strip on which The Peanuts Movie was based?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The Peanuts Movie was based on the comic strip by the cartoonist with what nickname?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the nickname of the cartoonist who created the comic strip Peanuts?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "The Peanuts Movie is based on the comic strip by the cartoonist who was nicknamed what?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What was the nickname of the cartoonist who's comic strip \"Peanuts\" was the basis for the movie \"The Peanuts Movie\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the nickname of Charles Monroe Schulz, the American cartoonist famous for creating the \"Peanuts\" comic strip?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is Sparky and what is he best known for?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the nickname of the cartoonist who created the comic strip that the film The Peanuts Movie was based on?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the nickname of Charles Monroe Schulz, the American cartoonist best known for creating the comic strip \"Peanuts\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the nickname of the creator of the comic strip that inspired the 2015 American 3D computer-animated comedy film The Peanuts Movie?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the nickname of the man who created the comic strip Peanuts?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the nickname of the creator of the comic strip that inspired the 2015 animated comedy film The Peanuts Movie?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the nickname of the author of the comic strip on which a a 2015 American 3D computer-animated comedy film produced by Blue Sky Studios and distributed by 20th Century Fox was based?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Prisoner of the Caucasus is an opera composed by César Cui, the libretto is based on a poem by which author?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the composer of Prisoner of the Caucasus born?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the composer of Prisoner of the Caucasus born?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the composer of Prisoner of the Caucasus born?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "What is the date of birth of the person who composed the opera Prisoner of the Caucasus?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Prisoner of the Caucasus is an opera in three acts, composed by a Russian composer and music critic of French, Polish and Lithuanian descent, born on which date?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the composer of Prisoner of the Caucasus born?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the birthdate of César Cui, the composer of the opera \"Prisoner of the Caucasus\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the birthdate of César Cui and what was his profession besides being a composer?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the composer of Prisoner of the Caucasus born?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "César Antonovich Cui, the composer of the opera \"Prisoner of the Caucasus,\" was born on which date according to the Old Style (Julian) calendar?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Prisoner of the Caucasus is an opera in three acts, composed by César Cui, a Russian composer and music critic of French, Polish and Lithuanian descent, born on which date?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the full name of the person who composed Prisoner of the Caucasus?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the composer of Prisoner of the Caucasus born?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the Russian composer who composed\"Prisoner of the Caucasus\" born?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Chelmsford Cathedral is dedicated to St Mary the Virgin, St Peter and St Cedd, while the Metropolitan Cathedral Church and Basilica of Saint Chad is dedicated to whom?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which cathedral is located in central Birmingham, Chelmsford Cathedral or Metropolitan Cathedral Church and Basilica of Saint Chad?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which cathedral was built first, Chelmsford Cathedral or Metropolitan Cathedral of Saint Chad?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Celtmsford Cathedral and Metropolitan Cathedral Church and Basilica of Saint Chad, Birmingham are both located in England, but which was built by Augustus Welby Pugin and substantially complete by 1841?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which cathedral was built first, Chelmsford Cathedral or Metropolitan Cathedral Church and Basilica of Saint Chad?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which cathedral is located in a public greenspace near St Chad's Queensway, Chelmsford Cathedral or Metropolitan Cathedral Church and Basilica of Saint Chad?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which is dedicated to Saint Chad of Mercia, Metropolitan Cathedral or Chelmsford Cathedral?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the mother church of the Archdiocese of Birmingham, which is dedicated to Saint Chad of Mercia and was one of the first Catholic churches constructed after the English Reformation?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the Metropolitan Cathedral Church and Basilica of Saint Chad, and where is it located?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which cathedral is located in Birmingham, Chelmsford Cathedral or Metropolitan Cathedral Church and Basilica of Saint Chad?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.3333, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which church, one of the first four Catholic churches constructed after the English Reformation and raised to cathedral status in 1852, is the mother church of the Archdiocese of Birmingham and is dedicated to Saint Chad of Mercia?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which cathedral was built first, Chelmsford Cathedral or Metropolitan Cathedral Church and Basilica of Saint Chad?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which of the two churches is dedicated to Saint Chad of Mercia?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which cathedral is located in a public greenspace, Chelmsford Cathedral or Metropolitan Cathedral of Saint Chad?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which became a Cathedral first St Chad's Cathedral, Birmingham or Chelmsford Cathedral?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1.3333, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Sir Thomas Daniel Courtenay is an English actor who came to prominence in the early 1960s with a succession of films, including \"The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner\" (1962), \"Billy Liar\" (1963), and \"Doctor Zhivago\" (1965), he starred in a 1965 World War II film directed by Bryan Forbes, and starring George Segal as Corporal King and James Fox as Marlowe, two World War II prisoners of war in a squalid camp near Singapore, who played the supporting role of Tom Courtenay in the film \"King Rat\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "King Rat is a 1965 World War II film directed by Bryan Forbes, and starring George Segal as Corporal King and James Fox as Marlowe, two World War II prisoners of war in a squalid camp near Singapore, among the supporting cast were John Mills and which English actor who came to prominence in the early 1960s with a succession of films, including \"The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner\" (1962)?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 2.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "King Rat is a 1965 World War II film directed by Bryan Forbes, among the supporting cast were which English actor who came to prominence in the early 1960s with a succession of films?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "King Rat is a 1965 World War II film directed by Bryan Forbes, among the supporting cast were which English actor who came to prominence in the early 1960s with a succession of films, including \"The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner\" (1962), \"Billy Liar\" (1963), and \"Doctor Zhivago\" (1965)?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Who was born first, Sir Thomas Daniel Courtenay or James Clavell?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "King Rat is a 1965 World War II film directed by Bryan Forbes, and starring George Segal as Corporal King and James Fox as Marlowe, two World War II prisoners of war in a squalid camp near Singapore, among the supporting cast were which English actor who came to prominence in the early 1960s with a succession of films, including \"The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner\" (1962), \"Billy Liar\"", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "King Rat is a 1965 World War II film directed by Bryan Forbes, among the supporting cast were John Mills and which English actor who came to prominence in the early 1960s with a succession of films, including \"The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner\" (1962)?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the English actor, born on 25 February 1937, known for his roles in films such as \"The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner\" and \"Doctor Zhivago,\" and who also starred in the 1965 film \"King Rat\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was Tom Courtenay's role in the 1965 film \"King Rat\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "King Rat is a 1965 World War II film directed by Bryan Forbes, among the supporting cast were John Mills and which English actor who came to prominence in the early 1960s with a succession of films, including \"The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner\" (1962), \"Billy Liar\" (1963), and \"Doctor Zhivago\" (1965)?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is an English actor who gained early film prominence with roles in \"The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner\" and \"Billy Liar,\" received an Academy Award nomination for \"The Dresser,\" and was knighted in 2001 for his contributions to cinema and theatre, also appearing in the 1965 film \"King Rat\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 1.6667, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 1.3333, "prediction": "King Rat is a 1965 World War II film directed by Bryan Forbes, and starring George Segal as Corporal King and James Fox as Marlowe, two World War II prisoners of war in a squalid camp near Singapore, among the supporting cast were John Mills and which English actor who came to prominence in the early 1960s with a succession of films, including \"The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner\" (1962), \"Bil", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2, "clarity": 2, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What actor was born in 1937?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.6667, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "King Rat is a 1965 World War II film directed by Bryan Forbes, among the supporting cast were John Mills and which English actor who came to prominence in the early 1960s with a succession of films, including \"The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner\" (1962), \"Billy Liar\" (1963), and \"Doctor Zhivago\" (1965)?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was a supporting cast member of King Rat and was knighted in February 2001?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 2.6667, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Liam Cunningham is known for playing Davos Seaworth in the HBO epic-fantasy series \"Game of Thrones\", he shared a BAFTA with which actor for their crime-drama short film \"Pitch Black Heist\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which Irish actor shared a BAFTA with an actor who played a Spartan warrior in \"300\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older, Liam Cunningham or Michael Fassbender?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is known for playing Davos Seaworth in the HBO epic-fantasy series \"Game of Thrones\", Liam Cunningham or Michael Fassbender?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older, Liam Cunningham or Michael Fassbender?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who shared a BAFTA with the actor who played Bobby Sands in Hunger?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who shared a BAFTA with an actor who played Davos Seaworth in Game of Thrones?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the Irish actor known for his role as Davos Seaworth in the HBO series \"Game of Thrones\" and has shared a BAFTA with Michael Fassbender for the short film \"Pitch Black Heist\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who did Liam Cunningham share a BAFTA with for their crime-drama short film \"Pitch Black Heist\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who shared a BAFTA with an actor who played Davos Seaworth in the HBO epic-fantasy series \"Game of Thrones\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is the Irish actor known for playing Davos Seaworth in the HBO series \"Game of Thrones\" and shared a BAFTA with Michael Fassbender for the short film \"Pitch Black Heist\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older, Michael Fassbender or Liam Cunningham?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the birth date of the actor who played Davos Seaworth in Game of Thrones?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who is older, Liam Cunningham or Michael Fassbender?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was born first, Liam Cunningham or Michael Fassbender?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who were the two escorts charged and convicted for the murder of Bryan Kocis, the director of Cobra Video?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who were the escorts of the director of Schoolboy Crush?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who were two escorts charged and convicted for the murder of the director of Schoolboy Crush?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 2.6667, "prediction": "Who were charged and convicted for the murder of the director of Schoolboy Crush?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who were the two escorts that were charged and convicted for Bryan Kocis' murder?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who were the two escorts who were charged and convicted for the murder of the director of Schoolboy Crush?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who were the escorts charged and convicted for the murder of the director of Schoolboy Crush?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who were the two individuals convicted for the murder of Bryan Charles Kocis, the founder of Cobra Video?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who were the escorts charged and convicted for the murder of Bryan Kocis in an attempt to disguise the circumstances of his death?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who were escorts charged and convicted for the murder of the director of Schoolboy Crush?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who were the two escorts charged and convicted for the murder of Bryan Charles Kocis, the founder of Cobra Video?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who were the escorts who were charged and convicted for the murder of the director of Schoolboy Crush?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was convicted for Kocis' murder?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who were the escorts charged and convicted for the murder of the director of Schoolboy Crush?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Who was convicted of murdering the director of Schoolboy Crush?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How long is the Nashua River, a tributary of the Merrimack River?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How long is the river that the Atherton Bridge spans?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How long is the river that the Atherton Bridge spans?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Atherton Bridge spans the South Branch of a river that is how long?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How long is the Nashua River?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How long is the river that the Atherton Bridge spans?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How long is the river that the Atherton Bridge spans?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How long is the Nashua River, which flows through Massachusetts and New Hampshire and is a tributary of the Merrimack River?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the length of the Nashua River? How long has the Atherton Bridge been on the National Register of Historic Places?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Atherton Bridge is a historic iron truss bridge in Lancaster, Massachusetts, spanning the South Branch of a river that is how long?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Nashua River, which is a tributary of the Merrimack River in Massachusetts and New Hampshire, is how many miles long?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How long is the river that the Atherton Bridge spans?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How many miles long is the Nashua River?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The Atherton Bridge spans the South Branch of a river that is how many miles long?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "How long is the river The Atherton Bridge spans?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What does the abbreviation \"Tribeca\" stand for?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the neighborhood in which the building at 359 Broadway between Leonard and Franklin Streets is located?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the neighborhood where the building at 359 Broadway between Leonard and Franklin Streets is located?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the meaning of the name of the neighborhood where the building at 359 Broadway is located?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What does Tribeca stand for?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the neighborhood in which the building at 359 Broadway between Leonard and Franklin Streets is located?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the neighborhood in which the building at 359 Broadway between Leonard and Franklin Streets is located?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 2, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What does the name \"Tribeca\" stand for, and how is it derived from the neighborhood's geographical boundaries in Manhattan?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the meaning of the syllabic abbreviation used for the Tribeca neighborhood in Manhattan, New York City?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the neighborhood in Lower Manhattan, New York City in which the building at 359 Broadway between Leonard and Franklin Streets is located?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the origin of the name \"Tribeca\" for the neighborhood in Lower Manhattan, New York City?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the neighborhood where the building at 359 Broadway is located?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the origin of the name of Tribeca?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.3333, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the neighborhood in which the 359 Broadway building is located?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the origin of the name of the neighbourhood in which the building at 359 Broadway is located?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In which season of \"Once Upon a Time\" was Zelena, also known as the Wicked Witch of the West, first introduced as the new main antagonist?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the character portrayed by Rebecca Mader in the American ABC fantasy-drama \"Once Upon a Time\" first introduced?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Rebecca Mader and Sean Maguire were promoted to series regulars for the fifth season, portraying a fictional character first introduced in what season?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The fifth season of the American ABC fantasy-drama \"Once Upon a Time\" was ordered on May 7, 2015, the promotion of Rebecca Mader and Sean Maguire to series regulars was announced for the fifth season, portraying their characters Zelena, a fictional character first introduced in the second half of the third season, serving as the new main antagonist, in which season?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was Zelena first introduced?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.6667, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the character that Rebecca Mader and Sean Maguire portrayed in the fifth season of \"Once Upon a Time\" first introduced?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 1.3333, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The fifth season of the American ABC fantasy-drama \"Once Upon a Time\" was ordered on May 7, 2015, the promotion of Rebecca Mader and Sean Maguire to series regulars was announced for the fifth season, portraying their characters Zelena / Wicked Witch of the West, is a fictional character in ABC's television series \"Once Upon a Time\", she is portrayed by Rebecca Mader and was first introduced in which time frame?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the character Zelena, the Wicked Witch of the West, first introduced in ABC's television series \"Once Upon a Time\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "In which season of \"Once Upon a Time\" was Zelena, the Wicked Witch of the West, introduced as the new main antagonist?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1.6667, "answerability": 2.3333, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.6667, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the character that was portrayed by Sean Maguire first introduced?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 2.6667, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Rebecca Mader, who portrays Zelena / Wicked Witch of the West in ABC's television series \"Once Upon a Time,\" was first introduced as a new main antagonist in which part of the show's timeline?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 1, "conciseness": 1, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 1, "prediction": "The fifth season of the American ABC fantasy-drama \"Once Upon a Time\" was ordered on May 7, 2015, the promotion of Rebecca Mader and Sean Maguire to series regulars was announced for the fifth season, portraying their characters Zelena, also known as the Wicked Witch of the West, is a fictional character in ABC's television series \"Once Upon a Time\", she is portrayed by Rebecca Mader and was", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 1, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What was the first season of Once Upon a Time?", "relevance": 2.6667, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 2.3333, "answerability": 1.6667, "clarity": 1.3333, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the character first introduced in the ABC fantasy-drama that aired on September 27, 2015?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "When was the female character that on June 9, 2015 was promoted to a series regular first introduced on\"Once Upon a Time\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]

[ { "answer_consistency": 1, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Coalwood is an unincorporated community coal town in McDowell County, West Virginia, United States, it is the setting of the best-selling memoir \"October Sky\" by whom?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What unincorporated community coal town in McDowell County, West Virginia, United States is the setting of the best-selling memoir \"October Sky\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What unincorporated community coal town in McDowell County, West Virginia is the setting of the best-selling memoir \"October Sky\"?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "The first memoir in a series of three, by Homer Hickam, Jr. is about growing up in what town in West Virginia?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_BART-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Which town is the setting of the best-selling memoir \"October Sky\" by Homer Hickam?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the unincorporated community coal town in McDowell County, West Virginia, United States, that is the setting of the best-selling memoir \"October Sky\" by Homer Hickam, Jr.?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What unincorporated community coal town in McDowell County, West Virginia is the setting for the memoir \"October Sky\" by Homer Hickam, Jr.?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_T5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 2.3333, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the West Virginian coal town that serves as the setting for Homer Hickam's memoir \"October Sky,\" which details his life and amateur rocketry pursuits?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 2.6667, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the setting of the best-selling memoir \"October Sky\" by Homer Hickam and the movie based on the book?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-3.5-turbo_zeroshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What unincorporated community coal town in McDowell County, West Virginia, United States is the setting of the best-selling memoir \"October Sky\" by Homer Hickam, Jr.?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-base_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the coal town in McDowell County, West Virginia, that serves as the setting for Homer Hickam's best-selling memoir \"October Sky\" and the movie based on the book?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_GPT-4-1106-preview_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the unincorporated community coal town in McDowell County, West Virginia, United States, that is the setting of the best-selling memoir \"October Sky\" by Homer Hickam?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xxl_lora" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the town that is the setting of the best-selling memoir \"October Sky\" by Homer Hickam?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-xl_fewshot" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "What is the name of the unincorporated community coal town in McDowell County, West Virginia, United States, that is the setting of the memoir October Sky?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_FlanT5-large_finetune" }, { "answer_consistency": 3, "answerability": 3, "clarity": 3, "conciseness": 3, "consistency": 3, "fluency": 3, "prediction": "Where was the set for the winner of the WD Weatherford Award in 1998?", "relevance": 3, "source": "HotpotQA_reference" } ]