Datasets:

alexfabbri

/

answersumm

like 3

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "My theory is this: Banner can already control The Hulk at the beginning of Avengers", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is shown when he is about to show his 'secret' to Black Widow the first time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They are then interrupted (I forget by what already) before he can show her (presumably, his instant transformation).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It is then shown (in a very epic fashion) that he can turn into The Hulk at will when the giant Chitauri is approaching them stating to Widow", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"I'm always angry\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, when Loki was escaping and caused the floor to pop out from underneath him and Widow, he then loses this control due to the sudden nature of the event and therefore doesn't have full control over The Hulk, hence the battle with Thor.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/130/Tablemaker", "score": 49 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "My impression was everyone kept assuming the hulk was something he was constantly fighting for control, and whenever he got angry enough to lose his focus he'd run wild, when the reality was Banner doesn't \"lose\" to the Hulk, he calls him out.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Once he transforms he doesn't have a great deal of control over what the Hulk decides to smash, because like he keeps saying, it's 'another guy' taking over at that point, but the choice to change is Banner's.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It makes sense if you accept Banner the man isn't necessarily a great person to begin with, which I don't think he's ever claimed to be, and can get to the point where he actually wants to unleash the Hulk and let the consequences be damned.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "This also explains why he'd run off to hide in one of the most densely populated areas of the world, where the collateral damage would be massive if he ever let the Hulk out.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It's not to get himself away from stress, it's to put himself in a position where the cost of calling the hulk would be more than he's willing to pay.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "On the airship", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Loki manipulates them all into wanting to fight each other, which explains why Banner would let the Hulk come out to play, he wasn't losing control over a monster, he was just as eager to throw down as the Cap and Stark were a few seconds earlier.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Just a thought.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1275/Dan", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "When Banner and Stark were in the lab, Stark poked Banner with something.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Then in the same scene he said something along the lines of \"I learned to control Iron Man with this thing (points to light on chest)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "- you can control the Hulk with something too.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Banner then says something like: \"That won't work for me.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Tony then says something like, \"Yeah you will, you'll see.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Then Banner turns into Hulk on the ship, but whatever Tony did hadn't kicked in yet (at least not fully).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is also why Tony knew that Banner would show up at the final battle , saying \"Let me know when Banner gets here, okay?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\" to everyone's surprise, because he knew that Banner should be feeling the effects of whatever Tony did to him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Then, at the very end, Bruce and Tony ride off together - because now they are close friends who understand each other and share scientific acumen as well.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1314/Kitkatatl", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "As we saw in the end of the Incredible Hulk, Bruce banner has to have some form of calmness and meditation before he transforms, it's the difference between being calm and under a lot of stress and anger.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also he has to have a clear picture on his enemies and his allies before transforming On the helicarrier they all fought with each other which caused stress and anger, and to top that Hawkeye blew up one of the engines which caused more stress and anger so the situation took advantage of Bruce, (Hulk controls Banner)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the city we see him much more calm and at ease before transforming.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Captain America tells him that now would be a good time to 'get angry' meaning to transform and Bruce responds by say his secret is that he is always 'angry' just another way of saying he can always transform at will and thus Bruce takes control of Hulk!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1372/Jurgo", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "He learned to control Hulk , as you could see when he didn't try to smash all of the avengers along the enemy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "On helicarrier he still din't know \"his secret\", that's why he pummeled them all.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "At first he tried to control his anger, on helicarrier it was proven impossible and as a completely wrong solution...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After that he realized that he should stop trying to control himself and let his anger take over, which lets him maintain some control.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Simply put he was never calm, he was just building up his rage, that's why he said \"I'm always angry\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/65/Mentales", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It seemed to me that Banner's influence over the Hulk depended on how much control he had over the transformation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The first time, he transformed because he was in pain, and Hulk was out of his control.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The second time, he transformed by choice for a specific reason.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Helping things along was the fact that during the second transformation, Hulk had a lot of targets to take his rage out on - and no enclosed, confined spaces, either.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Think of it as the difference between a professional football player getting knocked down in a crowded nightclub, versus getting knocked down in the middle of a game.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the second case, he's prepared for it, and has a strategy for venting his anger in the next minute.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the first, he's blindsided.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1352/Blazemonger", "score": 3 } } ]

{ "question": "During the climatic battle, Banner says 'That's my secret. I'm always angry', and transforms into the Hulk. Does this imply that Banner learned how to control Hulk? If this is the case, why did he transform during the Helicarrier attack?", "title": "Banner's control of Hulk in Avengers", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><marvel-cinematic-universe><the-avengers><the-incredible-hulk>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/2236", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1257/RHPT" }

[ [ "My impression was everyone kept assuming the hulk was something he was constantly fighting for control, and whenever he got angry enough to lose his focus he'd run wild, when the reality was Banner doesn't \"lose\" to the Hulk, he calls him out. Once he transforms he doesn't have a great deal of control over what the Hulk decides to smash, because like he keeps saying, it's 'another guy' taking over at that point, but the choice to change is Banner's.", "As soon as he transforms he doesn't have a great deal of control over what the Hulk decides to smash" ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Banner doesn't \"lose\" to the Hulk, he calls him out. Once he transforms he doesn't have a great deal of control over what the Hulk decides to smash. This also explains why he'd run off to hide in one of the most densely populated areas of the world. It's not to get himself away from stress, it's to put himself in a position where the cost of calling the hulk would be more than he's willing to pay ." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "I think the ending is intentionally ambiguous, so each member of the audience can draw their own conclusion.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Even if Ottway kills the Alpha, will the rest of the pack let him survive?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If you watched past the credits, you saw that there was a very short (maybe two seconds) scene where we see Ottway and the Alpha wolf after they fight.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They're both alive, but badly injured.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Ottway's head is resting on top of the wolf's body.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Since both are so badly injured, I think it's unlikely that either one of them will survive.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/213/Bill the Lizard", "score": 17 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It's symbolic: honor your life and confront your fears.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The whole movie was about his ambivalence about living after his wife died.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He fought the enemy honoring \"life\" and symbolically, he won.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That's my take.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/3261/Alan", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Its almost certain that after someone or something kills the alpha of a pack, then the other wolves back off, praise, or even make them the new leader of their group.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Because the alpha was lying weakly on the bed of snow at the brief scene after the credits, it should be obvious that he was killed or in the middle of dying.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Otherwise, he'd undoubtedly be eating John and so would the others.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Meanwhile, John is lying and resting his head on the side of the black alpha wolf.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We're not certain if he's dead or if he survived, but the one thing we know is that the wolf is dead.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One thing I can say about the way the wolf died was by the dagger John held and the broken glasses he wrapped around his hand (which looked to be some sort of medicine tube).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "John must have known something about the glasses because he was a huntsman after all, maybe containing poison to kill off the wolves.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Either way the wolf was dead and as for John, its really up to you to figure that out.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Odds are, he was sitting there thinking and praying judging the way the director casted him always in deep thought.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/3283/Crista", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think the ending is fairly obvious, if you recall toward the beginning of the film Ottway shoots a wolf trying to attack the drillers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "While the injured wolf is dying in the snow Ottway hovers over it and places his hand on the wolfs chest, the entire time we are clearly seeing the final labored breaths of the dying animal which is very similar to the scene at the end of the movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Its pretty clear they both died, unless Ottway was pooped and decided to spoon with the alpha for a bit before returning to his aimless wandering through the Alaskan wilderness.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Furthermore this scenario would never happen since pack alpha's rarely do any of the killing, however they do in conjunction with the beta's decide who eats first.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, wolves are absolutely timid around humans, most documented fatalities have been children during the 18th and 19th century in North America.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Although there are circumstances that would cause a wolf to attack, its very rare - I think shark and bear attacks are more common compared to wolves.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The idea that these wolves would hunt these men down one by one like velociraptors is far-fetched unto itself but certainly makes for great cinema.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1373/Aaron Makela", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Live and die on this day...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "the wolf died, Liam lived.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Otherwise the wolf would have been eating him and his buddies would have joined in.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Either that way, or Liam found the meaning of life on the same day he died.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1544/tam", "score": 3 } } ]

{ "question": "I am confused, what happened at the end of The Grey (2011) ? Did Ottway die or did he manage to survive?", "title": "What happened at the end of The Grey?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<ending><the-grey>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/2283", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/56/Mehper C. Palavuzlar" }

[ [ "I think the ending is intentionally ambiguous, so each member of the audience can draw their own conclusion. Since both are so badly injured, I think it's unlikely that either one of them will survive.", "They're both alive, but badly injured." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ " I think the ending is intentionally ambiguous, so each member of the audience can draw their own conclusion. They're both alive, but badly injured." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Via Jerry Della Femina, the veteran ad exec widely regarded as one of Madison Avenue's biggest personalities, most creative thinkers and an over-the-top publicity-seeker: Q:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Did ad agency executives really drink that often — and that much — in the 1960s?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If anything, it's underplayed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There was a tremendous amount of drinking.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Three-martini lunches were the norm.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Q:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But the show makes it look like everyone kept a bottle or two in their desk drawer.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And it wasn't Geritol.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A: Bottles in desk drawers were not the exception but the rule.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I had an open bar at the agency in which I kept 10 to 15 bottles of booze.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Anyone at the agency could walk in and get it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Invariably, one or two guys would come in at 9 a.m., pour a shot and slug it down.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was a business of drinking.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The way we lived really would make the characters in Mad Men all look like Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We drank and screwed around.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Q:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Did agency executives really smoke that much?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I smoked three to four packs a day.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Everybody smoked at all times in all meetings.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Once, when I was sitting in a meeting for the Contac account, I had a (lit) cigarette in my hand and another in the ashtray.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When I put down the cigarette to do a chalk talk, I tried to light the piece of chalk.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Source", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/12/ghoppe", "score": 27 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "My grandmother used to be a big city office secretary back in the late 1950s and early 1960s when she was in her 20s before she became a housewife", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and she has told me that most people smoked in the office back then and it was very normal.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She said her boss usually smoked two to three packs a day just at the office and that she'd have to empty his ashtray several times a day and also bring him a fresh cigarettes anytime he asked for it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She said she was expected to keep at least two cartons of cigarettes in her desk drawer for him", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so he didnt run out, and that she was told to order his cigarettes just like ordering office supplies for pens, paper, staples etc.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He also told her she could order herself cigarettes when ordering his, and as long as she smoked the same brand he did, she could smoke all she wanted while at work.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She also told me that her boss drank often at work, and that he kept both several bottles on a bar at the back of his office and that he also kept a bottle or two in his desk.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Again, she said hed have her order bottles for him to keep in her desk as backup.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She also said that it was not uncommon for the guys to go out for drinks after working late, but also that on more than one occasion her boss would take her out to a fancy dinner in the City, just the two of them, even though he was married to another woman.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When I told her how strange that seemed now, she just laughed and said I would even recognize the workplace, especially with all the sexual harassment suits and stuff now.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That was of particular interest to me since I had been the subject of sexual harassment at the workplace recently, and I asked her if shed ever been harassed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She said \"not unwillingly\" and proceeded to tell me about how she used to sleep with her boss from time to time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yikes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1723/Becky", "score": 14 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "My mother was an office secretary in New York in the 1960s and 70s, and she told me that the general representation on MadMen that a lot of people really did chain smoke three of four packs a day back then was actually pretty dead-on accurate.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She said that she continued to smoke at least three packs a day herself back then through the 80s and most of the 90s, even after she moved to the southern US, before eventually trying to cut down to only a pack a day in the early 2000s shortly before being diagnosed with emphysema.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "With that kind of background, it seems almost inevitable that I would have ended up a two pack a day smoker myself, even though our company banned smoking in the office back in 2003.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I had just started working in the office in the late 90s, and a big attraction for me was the fact that several other women here had ashtrays on their desk and could smoke at work.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was frowned upon even then, despite being allowed, but the first 4 or 5 years I worked here, I could smoke at my desk and it wasn't a big deal.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But then in 2003, once they banned smoking in the office, I think my office productivity took a nose dive.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1566/Michelle", "score": 11 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I'm only 43 and even going back to when I started work (1990) in the IT industry in the UK smoking was rife in almost offices", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and I worked alongside guys who would routinely go out drinking quite heavily for two hours at lunch.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I have a friend who works for a large Japanese company at their head office and even today they smoke a very great deal in their open offices and there's a drinks cabinet in most senior's offices.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So this wasn't too long ago", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": ", I'd imagine MM was pretty much on the money.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/296/Chopper3", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Yeah, people smoked and drank a lot in the 50s/60s.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "You can see it even in family TV shows", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "like I Love Lucy, early episodes of The Flintstones,", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Bewitched - I don't think a single episode of that show ever passed without someone having at least one drink - and in most of the family adventure shows, like Mission Impossible and The Man From Uncle and Voyage to the Bottom of the Sea", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": ", members of the principle casts all smoked from time to time on camera.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Heck, there's an episode of Star Trek where you can clearly see cigarette smoke where an actor hastily put his hand out of shot to hide that he was smoking (McCoy/DeForest Kelly).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/40315/Mahatma Randy", "score": 3 } } ]

{ "question": "Though the stories and characters have become the focal point for analysis as Mad Men has evolved, early in its existence there was a great deal of discussion regarding the amount of smoking and drinking the characters do. (See this New York Times article from 2007 for one example). How accurate is this presentation? Is that what the advertising world was like in the 1960s? What about other businesses? Essentially: is the portrayal of business professional smoking and drinking in excess while at work presented in Mad Men accurate?", "title": "How accurate are the smoking and drinking habits of the characters on Mad Men?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<mad-men>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/2410", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/850/stevvve" }

[ [ " Yeah, people smoked and drank a lot in the 50s/60s.You can see it even in family TV shows.", "People smoked and drank a lot in the 50s/60s." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "People smoked and drank a lot in the 50s/60s. That is obvious in films and TV shows" ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "I think the two main reasons behind this are: That Sauron is slowly increasing his powers over the whole timeline of the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings - the stories of which take place over an 80 year period.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That Bilbo never receives the attention of Sauron in quite the same way that Frodo does.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Bilbo's 111th birthday party which starts the story of the Lord of the Rings, and where Bilbo gives the ring to Frodo, takes place about 60 years after the events of The Hobbit.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A further 18 years elapses before Frodo starts to bear the ring towards Mordor to destroy it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the distant past, Sauron was defeated by Isildur and thought to be destroyed, however he is slowly rebuilding his power for literally hundreds of years under the guise of being The Necromancer of Dol Guldur.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sauron does not even openly declare himself until about 10 years after Bilbo finds the ring, and he believes the ring has been lost in the area he was defeated by Isildur.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So at the time that Bilbo owns the ring, Sauron is not as powerful, and he believes the ring is lost and is searching for it in the wrong area.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In Tolkien's writings, Bilbo's party is in S.R. (Shire Reckoning) 1401.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It is not until some time between 1409 and 1417 that Gollum (venturing into Mordor seeking the ring himself) is captured by Sauron.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Since Gollum is released only a year before the Nazgul actively start seeking for \"Baggins\" one can guess that it is likely that this happens towards the end of this time period.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So it is well after Bilbo is no longer the owner and active user of the ring that Sauron starts to seek him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Frodo obeys Gandalf's recommendations and does not use the ring in this period, and breaks this for the first time 'accidentally' in the Prancing Pony very briefly, and does not seem to suffer particularly from the experience.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It is when he is attacked by the Nazgul on Weathertop that he first starts to see things - and even then it is primarily the nearby Nazgul that can sense and see him - not Sauron yet from his tower hundreds of miles away.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also Bilbo stays in the Shire with the ring whereas Frodo brings the ring ever closer to Sauron in the attempt to destroy it, so its possible", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "the closer he comes to Mordor the more powerful and corruptive a hold it gains on Frodo.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/40/iandotkelly", "score": 52 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Frodo also KNEW more of the ring than Bilbo (Gandalf told Frodo whereas with Bilbo he pretty much just kept an eye on the hobbit).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That knowing would alter how Frodo would use the ring - whether he willed it or not.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Additionally, Bilbo never sought to DESTROY the ring, thus the Ring had no reason to protect itself from Bilbo and therefore had less of a grip on him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/2125/Swilbo", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Also, in the very end of the third movie(I haven't read the books in a long time :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\\ ) when they are headed towards the sea to leave with the elves, Bilbo, who looks like his life force is held on by a string asks Frodo if he still has the ring and even says, \"I would have liked to have held it one last time\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I agree, the movie timeline is really not apparent.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You assume the extreme aging of Bilbo is because he no longer has the ring.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The movies make it feel like the trilogy took half a year lol.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Except for the end when Frodo says to Sam, \"It's been four years...\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Why would Sauron ever think that the ring was destroyed?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Is he not DIRECTLY linked to the ring?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "IF it was destroyed would he not also be killed?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/3687/Ensiferum0", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "There are a few reasons.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "When Bilbo had the Ring Sauron was relatively inactive and geographically distant.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It is fairly strongly implied that the Ring began to 'wake up' in some sense as Sauron began to return to power.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Bilbo never really understood the full significance of the ring while it was in his possession", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "and it's entirely possible that that knowledge, just in itself was a factor.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Another important factor is the would he received on Weathertop.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It's explicitly stated that the shard of the Morgul Knife was in the process of turning him into a wraith", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "and so it seems logical that this might well increase the hold that the ring had.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It is certainly mentioned at several points that this injury has a lingering effect.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Also Frodo comes much closer, physically to the influence of Sauron.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "On Amon Hen he comes close to being discovered by the Eye which by now is actively searching for him and again it is explicitly explained that as he gets closer to Mordor and Mount Doom specifically he becomes increasingly aware of the influence of teh ring to the point where is feels like a crushing physical weight.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/34108/Chris Johns", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "What spurred Gandalf to come to the Shire and to organize the Fellowship to try and destroy the Ring?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was because Gollum, searching to regain the Ring, wandered close to Mordor and was captured and interrogated by Sauron.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The entire time Bilbo had the Ring, Sauron was quietly biding his time, and gathering his Ring-less strength, while the Ring languished, lost, in the deep caverns beneath mountains, with Gollum.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After Frodo got the Ring, a stronger Sauron became aware that the Ring was not lost, and began to actively seek the Ring, both his his servants (the Nazgul, Sauruman) and with his own consciousness.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He was actively using his powers, focused towards the Shire, to try and find the Ring, and the Ring was seeking him, as well.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It makes sense that it would be more likely to draw his specific attention in the latter timeframe.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/37106/PoloHoleSet", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "Every time Frodo put on the ring the Eye of Sauron could see where he was and almost see into his soul as well. Frodo appeared to suffer hugely when he put the ring on. Bilbo was able to turn invisible and have no side effects or suffering when he wore it. What changed between Bilbo having the ring and then passing it on to Frodo? Were the Nazgûl looking for the ring when Bilbo had it or was it only around the time Frodo got the ring?", "title": "Why did the ring affect Frodo so much and not Bilbo?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><the-lord-of-the-rings><the-hobbit>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/2754", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1405/PriestVallon" }

[ [ " When Bilbo had the Ring Sauron was relatively inactive and geographically distant. Frodo comes much closer, physically to the influence of Sauron and it is strongly implied that the Ring began to 'wake up' in some sense as Sauron began to return to power.", "It is fairly strongly implied that the Ring began to 'wake up' in some sense as Sauron began to return to power. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "It is fairly strongly implied that the Ring began to 'wake up' in some sense as Sauron began to return to power. It is explicitly stated that the shard of the Morgul Knife was in the process of turning him into a wraith. As Frodo gets closer to Mordor and Mount Doom he becomes increasingly aware of the influence of teh ring to the point where is feels like a crushing physical weight. It seems logical that this might well increase the hold that the ring had on Frodo ." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "There are 3 possible motives for David.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He wanted to test the black-goo to \" try harder \".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "David was receiving orders from Weyland as he told \"Try Harder!\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The scene where David spikes Charlie's drink happens after the 'try harder' scene (with Vickers).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "David goes to Holloway, asks him how far he is willing to go to find his answers, and Holloway replies he would do whatever it takes .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "David takes this as an invitation to experiment with the goo on Holloway , ultimately at Weyland's request.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "David is simply following orders.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So my guess is that, he probably wanted to test it , just in case it turned out to be what Weyland was looking for, an immortality potion or something He wanted to kill the crew to gain his freedom .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "David starts to hate the humans.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Note how antagonistic Holloway had a jerk towards David.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When Holloway asking David why he's wearing a suit as much to say '", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "you're not one of us, why are you bothering to try?'", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He wanted to kill Dr. Holloway to remove him as competition for Dr.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Shaw", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He seemed to pay more attention to her from the start by looking in on her dreams and taking special care of her when she awoke from cryo.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think when he tried to put her back into cryo he was trying to do what was best for her.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I also thought that, at the end, whenhe said he was afraid she had been killed that he was beinggenuine .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "David:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I was scared you were dead.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Shaw: you know nothing about being scared, david.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/556/Vijin Paulraj", "score": 21 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "David has multiple motivations: to help Weyland achieve Weyland's goal, which is to contact engineers so engineers can help Weyland cheat death.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "After all David is a computer with a programmed purpose: serving Weyland.(\"Try harder\" is Weyland telling David to keep looking for a living engineer, which David then does successfully.) to reveal how humans were not special but instead -- like David -- were created by other intelligent beings.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "This is the irony underlying Holloway's insulting David.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/763/Shiz Z.", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In the very beginning of the film David's hair style is different, then we see him watching the film while he is coloring the roots of his hair to match Peter's, and then he combs it so that he has the same hair style.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He later repeats the phrase \"The trick, William Potter, is not minding that it hurts\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think David repeats that line two or three times.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I took this to imply that David's natural appearance is different including his hair color.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Is this sequence connected to David's fascination with the Engineers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Absolutely, because this scene defines a repeating theme that David tents to overly obsess over things related to the human condition.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think you have to watch Lawrence of Arabia to understand what was being implied by that scene.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Why did David infect the Doctor?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "David is seen reporting to Peter Weyland that the Engineers are all dead, and he then explains that Peter Weyland ordered him to \"try harder\" to discover what happen to them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Did Peter tell David to infect a crew member, or did David conceive this idea on his own?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That isn't made clear in the film.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Later in the film, Peter Weyland is told to take off his helmet and Elizabeth protests saying that the infection that killed the Doctor could be air born.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Peter Weyland appears to not know that the Doctor is dead, and David just gives Elizabeth a look.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "What was his motivation?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "David says \"big things have small beginnings\" and then later while talking to the Doctor.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He says \"if you could meet your creator, what would you say?\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I really feel that David understood that the dark fluid was a virus, and that it created life.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In that scene David expresses a fascination with meeting ones creator, and also his disapproval of humans.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think he gave it to the Doctor, so he could destroy his creator and turn himself into a creator at the same time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "While answering the question, what does this black stuff really do?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1100/Reactgular", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Here's my biggest problem with it: David knows absolutely nothing about the black goo.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "What would make him think that it could create, change, preserve, whatever, human life?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I mean, if you happened to come across a bunch of black goo would your first thought be to feed it to some animals.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Even if it contains a bunch of nutrients, eating an egg doesn't cause a chicken to start growing in my body.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So he just comes up with this alien virus/embryo idea out of nowhere.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Not only that, but they have an awesome lab there, why doesn't he just use that to run some experiments on it?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Why doesn't he work with the other scientists to find out more about it?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Surely that would aid the old man just as much if not more than david working alone.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Even if you make the argument that he is just following orders, that just shifts the blame from him to the old man.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It doesn't really change the fact that his motives make no sense whatsoever.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1622/caffein", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "My 2 Strongest theories about this are: He turned out to hate the humans due to the actions of Dr.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Holloway .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "To me, since the first time David and Holloway met... I always had the gut feeling that David was going to do something to Holloway sooner or later.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I mean, Holloway was being such an ass towards David!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Plus, not only that..", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but.. to me, it seemed as if he knew that the black goo was dangerous.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One reason why I believe he knew is that he didn't inform the crew about taking that black goo back with him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He has a thing for Shaw.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If you think about it, what Vijin said is true.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And, I do not want to type all about it when the informations already up here, lol.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1512/blu", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "For me, perhaps the most interesting person aboard the Prometheus was the android, David. I'm still confused by his seeming fascination with the movie, Lawrence of Arabia . Although I couldn't make notes during the film, I believe that he quoted Peter O'toole's character, Lawrence, on more than one occasion. Was he attempting to attain a similar achievement with the Engineers as Lawrence did with the Arabs? Why did he infect the Crew leader? What was his motivation?", "title": "What was David's motivation in Prometheus?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><character><prometheus>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/2775", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1478/Luckycat" }

[ [ "David is a computer with a programmed purpose: serving Weyland.is motivation is to help Weyland achieve Weyland's goal, which is to contact engineers so engineers can help Weyland cheat death.", "David has multiple motivations:" ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "David is a computer with a programmed purpose: serving Weyland. He is designed to contact engineers so engineers can help Weylands cheat death. David is also designed to reveal how humans were not special but instead -- like David -- were created by other intelligent beings." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "It's never explicitly said in the film, but if we listen closely the apartment scene we can understand Marvin was their informant within that group.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Here is the script of the scene.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jules - \"We should have shotguns for this kinda deal.\" Vincent - \"How many are up there?\" Jules - \"Three or four.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Vincent - \"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That's counting our guy ?\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jules - \"Not sure.\" Vincent - \"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So that means there could be up to five guys up there?\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jules -", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"It's possible.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When Vincent says \"That's counting our guy\" Marvin was their guy who's the informant.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After shooting Brett and the others, Vincent says to Jules, \"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Do you know this guy?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\" and Jules responds,", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"Yeah\" .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is why they didn't shoot him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/556/Vijin Paulraj", "score": 53 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "They did not kill Marvin because he was part of Wallace's network and was an informer in the gang.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Remember they asked \"why didn't you tell us there was a man in the kitchen with a god damn cannon?\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "or something like that.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This shows that they were expecting him to provide this info and logically he was their man (mentioned in the hallway).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "If they had killed him then there would be little incentive for people to inform on gangs that had betrayed Wallace in the future.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "This is also, probably, why Jules and Vincent are uninterested in the excuses", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "\"You're ass ain't talking your way out of this\" because regardless of what they say the hitmen know their true plan from Marvin.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1501/Stefan", "score": 16 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "According to Phil LaMarr (actor who played Marvin), from his AMA (Ask Me Anything) post on Reddit /r/IAMA , it's because (emphasis mine):", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The back story that Quentin and I talked about was that Marvin and Jules had people in common and when this briefcase thing went down Jules was able to get in touch w/ Marvin and offered these guys who were holed up, scared and obviously way out of their depth a way to resolve this .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"All you have to do is make sure the door is unlocked at 7:45.\" He didn't know exactly how it was going to be resolved and he wasn't street-smart enough to figure that the resolution might have a significant cost.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1006/galacticninja", "score": 10 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think that marvin was his informant, but was going to try to double cross Jules and Vincent.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "THAT'S why the guy was in the bathroom with a gun.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jules himself says, we should be dead.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Divine intervention stopping the bullets?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That's why Vince gets so upset at Marvin for 'forgetting' that the guy was in the bathroom with a hand cannon.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jules' attention is focused on that they weren't killed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Later, divine justice is laid upon Marvin for his attempt at a double cross, when he gets shot in the face.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think that, if Jules attention hasn't been distracted, they might have killed Marvin in the apartment.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Because of the total screwup.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Marvin was a nobody.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Signified by Wolf later, who described him as 'nobody who'll be missed'.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Just my opinion.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/41485/Tony rocky horror", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Well for starters, Marvin was their informant and Brett, Roger (guy on the couch) and Man #4 (hand cannon guy, guy in bathroom) were the targets.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Man #4 could have survived if he had stayed in the bathroom.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Anyhow, Marvin was not purposely killed because he was ratting his fellow pencil-neck college students out so he could live.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A choice he later regretted ( as you can see when Brett is killed )", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but due to Vincent Vega's poor gun safety skills, Marvin gets his head blown off.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also the reason it all happened in the first place was because Brett and his friends refused to give up the brief case for whatever reason.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4134/quention taranto", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "In Pulp Fiction, Vincent and Jules killed all the guys at Brett's apartment for stealing the briefcase from Marsellus Wallace but not Marvin. Why didn't Vincent and Jules kill Marvin in Pulp Fiction?", "title": "Why didn't Vincent and Jules kill Marvin?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<analysis><pulp-fiction>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/3198", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/556/Vijin Paulraj" }

[ [ "They did not kill Marvin because he was part of Wallace's network and was an informer in the gang.If they had killed him then there would be little incentive for people to inform on gangs that had betrayed Wallace in the future. ", "Marvin was part of Wallace's network and was an informer in the gang. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Marvin was part of Wallace's network and was an informer in the gang. If they had killed him then there would be little incentive for people to inform on gangs that had betrayed Wallace in the future. Jules and Vincent are uninterested in the excuses.", "Marvin and Jules had people in common and when this briefcase thing went down Jules was able to get in touch with Marvin and offered these guys " ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Analyzing the past two films and Rises, Nolan (Director) and his brother Jonathan (Screenplay Writer) are trying to envision a world where they asked the question… \"What if...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Batman existed in our current world today as opposed to the comics.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Thus the feel and directing has a less comic book-ish (if that's a word) look, and more of a real world view.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This film take on Robin is quite incredible when you think about it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Like the previous person in this article wrote, he is an embodiment of all the Robin’s in the comics.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In contrast you have Nolan’s Robin ( John Blake ) who is, at this point, the first Robin “ Dick Grayson ” to Batman.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He’s referred to being hot headed and angry like the Robin “ Jason Todd ”.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For the “ Tim Drake ” Robin…", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "well, he was the one that was able to deduce batman of his true identity and was also depicted as an orphan.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And with the film using elements from the “The Dark Knight Returns” comic by Frank Miller, the role of", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "that Robin was a female “ Carrie ”.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1770/Vrenn", "score": 18 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The whole point of Nolan's Batman is a meditation on myth and legend.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He includes these things to imply, I think, that the version of batman we learnt about over the years is a myth based on some things which may or may not have happened, events passed on by word of mouth and stories.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As in all myths, names change over time, get jumbled up, and the story changes like Chinese whispers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so Nolan's version is one telling of the myth.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The next director will tell another version.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In one version of the myth Robin is his side kick, in another his successor.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In one version two face carries on damaging the city symbolically due to the draconian laws past as a reaction to his death and the lies his death propagates which eat away at the soul of Gotham; in another myth he literally goes on damaging the city as a criminal.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's kind of like the various gospels in religion.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1744/Adam", "score": 9 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think Nolan left it in the idea that Batman is retiring and wanted to end the saga unlike the comic book stories which run infinitely.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He wanted Blake to take over the legacy from Batman and probably plays a little homage to Robin like Ducard's reference from the comics as pointed out earlier.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Also using Dick Grayson would've led people to believe before the movie that we might see Robin that's also another reason why they had to wait til the end.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/781/Dredd", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I took the mention of his first name being Robin as a sly joke.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He is an amalgamation of all the sidekicks Batman has had and was essentially the Robin character in spirit.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The problem was that the dynamic between batman and robin had become so campy and ridiculous in the film representations they needed to approach it in a fresh way and not have him deck out in tights and run around after bats.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So he could be taken as a Robin character and also can become the Batman much like Dick Grayson did in the comics.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1754/Sam", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Because some non-comic readers aren't familiar with Dick's name, and Nolan didn't have the sense to reveal his real name as Grayson and throw in a line about him being a Boy Wonder (which would have clued in the audience AND satisfied the fans).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1745/Mako", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "Near the end of The Dark Knight Rises, we learn that John Blake's birth name is Robin, and that John Blake is merely an alias. What motivated the Nolan brothers to include this in the film? Are they merely nudging and winking at the audience? Furthermore, why Robin? The real Robin's (original) name is Dick Grayson (though as the character evolved, was reborn, became Nightwing among others his identity changed).", "title": "Why choose that birth name for John Blake?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<character><the-dark-knight-rises><christopher-nolan>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/3366", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/850/stevvve" }

[ [ "Perhaps Nolan left it in the idea that Batman is retiring and wanted to end the saga unlike the comic book stories which run infinitely. He wanted Blake to take over the legacy from Batman and probably plays a little homage to Robin like Ducard's reference from the comics as pointed out earlier. Also using Dick Grayson would've led people to believe before the movie that we might see Robin that's also another reason why they had to wait til the end.", "Nolan left it in the idea that Batman is retiring and wanted to end the saga unlike the comic book stories which run infinitely." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Nolan left it in the idea that Batman is retiring and wanted to end the saga unlike the comic book stories which run infinitely. Also using Dick Grayson would've led people to believe before the movie that we might see Robin that's also another reason why they had to wait til the end." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Considering the chanting we hear (\"Deh-shay, deh-shay bah-sah-rah, bah-sah-rah,\") is Moroccan , I think we can assume the pit is is North Africa somewhere.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/382/Nobby", "score": 15 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The pit in the Dark Knight Rises is located is near the fort of Mahendragarh in India.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's located near Thar Desert in the Rajasthan state.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I have seen local news paper headlines of the Dark Knight Rises team visiting here for shooting...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/2093/Sagar", "score": 12 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The pit, as was shown in the film, is located in Jodhpur, Rajasthan, India.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the brief moment when Talia Al Ghul comes out of it, one can see the Mehrangarh Fort in the background.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Even Confirmed from Wkipedia", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The third movie of The Dark Knight trilogy, The Dark Knight Rises, was partially shot around the Mehrangarh fort.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A few scenes included the prison well within which Bruce Wayne is shown to have been imprisoned.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There is one particular shot when Wayne emerges from the prison that actually gives a glimpse of the Mehrangarh Fort in the background.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The scene involving Ras Al Ghul also seem to be filmed in fort.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The inside of the pit is a famous Step well called Chand Baori which is in Dausa district, Rajasthan, India.(Borrowed answer from Quora ).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1190/Ankit Sharma", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The prison is located near the Mehrangarh fort of Jodhpur, Rajasthan, India.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "I have visited this fort a couple of times as my maternal uncle resides there.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Actually, if you look closely to the frame when Bruce Wayne comes out of the pit you can see blue houses beside the fort.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "That's because many of the houses in the city of Jodhpur are colored with blue lime.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "That's the reason why Jodhpur is also known as 'The Blue City'.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "I think that clears your doubt and answers your question as well.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5302/Nikhil Joshi", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The Pit is far from Gotham (Which, by the way is in New Jersey, not New York, just so people know).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was filmed in India, but the film location and the actual in story location are not the same.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Pit is officially in a 'Middle Eastern' Country, but it is never specified which.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is meant to leave it intentionally vague, since DC has many fictional countries like Kahndaq (quoting Dc's wikia): \"Kahndaq is an Arab country on the continent of Africa located between Egypt and Jordan.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "except when you look at the Continent it is on in the side bar, it says Asia (which actually matches the real world map concept that the Middle East is considered part of Asia), and if you consider what it says, it essentially is Israel... though other references have Kahndaq frequently considered part of what is Iran.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This all convolutes matters, since Israel, Jordan, Iran, Egypt, Iraq (which also has DC fictional Qurac as a stand-in at times), and Libya (which has its own stand-in at times of Bialya, a near anagram) (among others) are all acknowledged to exist in DC as well... Since making it in a real country could be taken as offensive, Bialya has Queen Bee ruling it, and Kahndaq is ruled by Black Adam...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Qurac would seem the most likely place in DC's fictional Middle Eastern countries to place the Pit.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Note this part is only my theory, but since the Pit is a pastiche for multiple places in the mainstream Batman Mythos, and is further complicated by being filmed in India yet having a Moroccan Chant, and supposed to be in the Middle East, the conjecture is fairly sound with the available information.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Fun note:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Joker in the comics actually was given Diplomatic Immunity for a while by being declared Iran's UN Ambassador.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, there is always still Iran, as well.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/16874/Jerome Davis", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The background when he comes out of the well was clearly Mehangarh fort,Jodhpur.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But there is no well near by fort.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They made a wall in a round shape, so that it looks like a well but some scenes (inside well) were shot in Jaipur (chand baori), Just search \"DEEPEST STEP WELL\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8226/user8226", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "What is the geographic location of the pit Bruce Wayne is imprisoned in by Bane? Is this prison in Gotham or somewhere else? Bane and Bruce seems to travel between the two rather quickly. It seems like a Middle Eastern location when Talia's mother is dropped in. Any ideas?", "title": "What is the geographic location of the pit Bruce Wayne is imprisoned in by Bane?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><the-dark-knight-rises>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/3454", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1751/Jeff B" }

[ [ "The prison is located near the Mehrangarh fort of Jodhpur, Rajasthan, India.", "The prison is located near the Mehrangarh fort of Jodhpur, Rajasthan, India. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "The prison is located near the Mehrangarh fort of Jodhpur, Rajasthan, India. If you look closely to the frame when Bruce Wayne comes out of the pit you can see blue houses beside the fort. Many of the houses in the city are colored with blue lime. That's the reason why Jodhpur is also known as 'The Blue City'. " ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Exactly two years, by the end of the 5th season.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Season 1 starts off with Walt's 50th birthday.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "When Walt comes back to Albuquerque in the end of Season 5, he starts of the day by celebrating his 52nd birthday:", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The show ends on the same in-universe day.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/898/Manishearth", "score": 28 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In the pilot, we see Walt celebrate his 50th birthday", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(this is where we see the \"bacon spelling out his age\" thing for the first time).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In S5E4 Fifty-One , we see him celebrate his 51st birthday.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In S5E1, we see a flashforward where Walt is celebrating his 52nd birthday alone in a diner.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the last episode, we see the flashforward resume, so the show ends around Walt's 52nd birthday.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Beyond that, I'm not sure how long each season was, but those are some anchor points for how much time has passed during the show.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/", "score": 13 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Perhaps it's because I'm a mother of very small children, but it helped me to look at the age of Walt's new daughter to help me somewhat decipher the passage of time in the series.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Skyler was pregnant in the first episode, and the daughter was born in the second season.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She's still an infant, which means to me that a year hasn't passed yet since her birth.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Watching the little girl grow might help to determine how much time passes in each season.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1913/MissyKirtley", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In S02E13 , Jane's father reports that Jane was born on April 4, 1982.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In S03E01 , the TV news reports that Jane was 26 years old.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Assuming these are are correct and we are using the standard US convention of reporting ages, then Jane's death took place some time between April 4th, 2008 and April 3rd, 2009.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In S05E08 , one character said, \"I mean, whacking bin Laden wasn't this complicated.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Since \"whacking bin Laden\" is spoken of in the past tense, we can reasonably infer that this was after May 2nd, 2011 (when Osama was killed).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Since the series started on Walt's 50th birthday and ended on his 52nd birthday, the series spanned exactly two years (or more precisely 2y 1d).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(1) and (2) together imply that the series spanned at least at least 2y 30d.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This contradicts (3).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Given this contradiction, it is not possible to arrive at any conclusion regarding how much time has passed in Breaking Bad.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Q.E.D.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/9668/Kenny LJ", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I'm pretty certain that season 2 episode 12 was set in March 2009 as Jane was born in April 1982 and", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "her dad said she would be turning 27 the following month.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Working back using the timeline posted elsewhere the series began in October 2008 and this was when Walt turned 50.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "What all that means is that each season has only covered about three months.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5573/Markymark", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "Unlike some shows that generally keep similar pace with real life—where a season is a year— Breaking Bad doesn't seem to. Currently (part-way though season 5), the characters were remarking that it had been a year since Walt's cancer diagnosis, though I forgot when that was relative to the premiere (if it happened 'then', or in a flashback). How much time (in universe) has passed in each season of Bad ?", "title": "How much time has passed in Breaking Bad?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<breaking-bad>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/3785", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/440/Nick T" }

[ [ "Season 1 starts off with Walt's 50th birthday and at the end of Season 5, he starts off the day by celebrating his 52nd birthday. So, Exactly 2 years have passed by the end of the 5th season.", " Exactly two years, by the end of the 5th season" ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ " Exactly two years, by the end of the 5th season. Season 1 starts off with Walt's 50th birthday. When Walt comes back to Albuquerque in the end of Season 5, he starts of the day by celebrating his 52nd birthday: " ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "When Bruce is packing up his stuff the doctor says the following to him.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Doctor:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"Ah supplies for your journey.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Oh that's, that's wonderful!\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So I imagine it contains things vital to stay alive once he leaves the pit such as food and water.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1405/PriestVallon", "score": 14 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "He packs some food.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He's assuming he'll escape, but he needs provisions to survive on the surface, as he doesn't know where he is.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "first time Bruce carries a bundle with him during the first trip.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Although it is not shown what is it that he carries, nor is it mentioned in the Script.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "second time", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This time Bruce does not carry anything, he simply walks determined to the ropeway and starts climbing.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "third time INT.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "CAVE PRISON - MORNING Wayne puts some scraps of bread into a rough coat which he folds into a makeshift shoulder pack.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "PRISONER Supplies for your journey?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Prisoners nearby laugh.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "From the picture one can assume that the folded brown packets are food items and the other is a water container.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So basically, he carried sustenance with him - food and water.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1461/coolharsh55", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "According to this copy of the script (p. 127): Wayne puts some scraps of bread into a rough coat which he folds into a makeshift shoulder pack.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1606/MJ6", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "As the other answers point out, he is packing supplies (bread).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But why does he only packs in his third attempt?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think it's because only in this third attempt he was determined to escape and save Gotham", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": ", this emphasizes that he was not in the right mind set before.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/6018/jsedano", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "Right before Bruce Wayne attempts to leave the pit he packs up something in a towel and wraps it around his body. Does anyone see what he packs?", "title": "What does Bruce Wayne pack on his third attempt of leaving the pit in Dark Knight Rises?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><character><the-dark-knight-rises>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/3868", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1940/user1940" }

[ [ "He packs some vital essentials to stay alive like food and water. ", "So it contains things vital to stay alive once he leaves the pit." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "When Bruce is packing up his stuff the doctor says the following to him. So it contains things vital to stay alive once he leaves the pit. He's assuming he'll escape,but he needs provisions to survive on the surface, as he doesn't know where he is." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "One answer is that the watch was valuable (a Rolex Daytona Gold watch, value close to $20,000).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Presumably he perceived that he might need it to barter with, and indeed he uses it to pay off the boatman later in the film.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The other, more jaded answer, is product placement .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Swiss Watchmaker IWC made the watch that Jeremy Renner wears in the movie - the Pilot Watch Double Chronograph Edition Top Gun.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "\"IWC hopes that Mr. Renner’s portrayal of a thrill-seeking lifestyle of an elite agent will correlate to the brand image.\"", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "( Luxury Daily )", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So if IWC has the starring role, who better than competitor Rolex to feature as a prop which is stolen and used for barter?", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "This is supposition on my part - I can find no article suggesting Rolex was involved in the placement, cannot imagine that they would want their brand used in this way, and am aware that companies rarely pay for a product placement if a competitor is also allowed to advertise in the film.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The watchophiles in both the IWC and Rolex camps are all over this movie in their forums!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1606/MJ6", "score": 10 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The addition I'd make to the already good answers is that Aaron shows his need for timekeeping earlier in the film when he urgently asked for his watch back from Marta.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As well as the product placement I'd add in that Aaron uses his watch to know when to medicate (something he's clearly religious about to try and stave off reverting to his previous IQ).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Having a watch is an addiction", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so he's always on time with his medication.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/574/Liath", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "As the pair were attempting to escape the factory, the foreman ended up just in front of the them, so Aaron took advantage of (either knocking the foreman out, or killing him) to aid their escape and since he was down anyway, Aaron takes the watch knowing its value will probably be needed in the near future, as they are now both fugitives and on the run from the agency's operatives.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Shortly after that scene, Marta takes Aaron to a flophouse to wait through the sickness to come.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She had infected Aaron with the virus, to 'viral him out' of the dependance on blue pills.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He gets very sick.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She is nursing him, wiping the sweat off his soaked brow.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He struggles to sit up, even though she tells him to stay down.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Aaron sits up anyway.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He then tells Marta that he has $40,000 in the lining of his jacket, there are passports in his backpack, both the ones they used and blank, and that the watch from the foreman is worth (I could not hear if he says $2k or $20k) and that she should take it all and go disappear.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She has done enough for him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/9505/CGCampbell", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The watch sales pitch is clearly in the scenes, but the story line is the fact that Aaron Cross is extremely conscious of keeping his chems on time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Perhaps even taking more of the blue pills (which were intelligence enhancement) than he should.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hence the story about losing his chems to the first contact.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He told the doctor how low his IQ was upon enlisting in the service and how adamant he was on not slipping back mentally.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/6035/James Faulkner", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "He takes the watch mainly to continue evasion and mislead his pursuers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's to throw his pursuers off.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They don't want a watch thief they hear onlookers talking or even pointing in the direction he wast last", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "seen moving.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He's taking advantage of a situation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Of course the value anywhere in the world to nearly any culture was a bonus if you will which wasn't missed by Cross- which the overly-edited down film (the deleted scenes explain a lot in general ) made a clever point of showing Aaron's use of with one quick shot of it on the wrist of its new owner.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/44735/Simon Williamson", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "He used the watch as an option for stakes if need be, which again what the person before me stated.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Obviously, you weren’t paying attention if you didn’t notice the trade that occurred after the last action motorcycle scene in which he offers the watch in exchange for a one way trip out of town.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The IWC is real nice but does not hold a candle to the craftsmanship of a Rolex Daytona, especially 18k.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Rolex movement is made in house just like a Patek Phillipe, Audimar Paiguet, or a Breitling, unlike IWC which probably purchased its movement from ETA.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/3938/James Hallbom", "score": 0 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The pilfering of the watch is completely out of synch and illogical with what is going on in that scene (the act of knocking the security chief out) - also, the idea that Cross knocked the chief out and stole the watch to make it look like a mugging is interesting, but not realistic - the chief's own security crew responded to the chief going down, not local police, and to assume that the local police would know that the chief wore a Rolex and that, because it was missing when (if) they found him, that they would conclude he was knocked out for the watch, and not because the chief knew who Cross was and why he was really there, and ultimately 'move on and not recisitat, thereby slowing the investigation' is not realistic either.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The act of pilfering the watch is added to enable the Rolex product placement.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The start of the scene showing the Rolex on the captain's/father's wrist phasizes the watch way too much", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5911/Golf Bum", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "At one point during The Bourne Legacy Aaron Cross comes up behind an Austrailian security chief and knocks him unconscious. He then proceeds to take the man's watch, and then leaves the area. In this scene there are lots of people around, it isn't like he had time to mug him. Why did he take the time to steal the watch?", "title": "Why did Aaron Cross take the watch from the security chief?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><the-bourne-legacy>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/4305", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/211/Jack B Nimble" }

[ [ "One answer is that the watch is a valuable Rolex Daytona Gold that costs near to $20,000. The other answer is that Aaron takes the watch knowing it's value will probably be needed in the near future.", "IWC hopes that Mr. Renner's portrayal of a thrill-seeking lifestyle of an elite agent will correlate to the brand image" ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "IWC Pilot Watch Double Chronograph Edition Top Gun is worn by Jeremy Renner in the film. Rolex Daytona Gold watch, value close to $20,000, is used as a prop in the movie. IWC hopes \"IWC hopes that Mr. Renner's portrayal of a thrill-seeking lifestyle of an elite agent will correlate to the brand image\" . Therefore there is no article suggesting Rolex was involved in the placement, cannot imagine that they would want their brand used in this way.", "As the pair were attempting to escape the factory, the foreman ended up just in front of the them, so Aaron took advantage of (either knocking out, or killing him) to aid their escape. Aaron takes the watch knowing its value will probably be needed in the near future," ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "They did not know what else was coming.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "There could have been a huge alien about to come through which they could not have stopped", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "therefore they had to shut the portal as quickly as possible even if it meant sacrificing Stark", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "(who, btw, proved that he was the one to make the sacrifice play after all).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1501/Stefan", "score": 10 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I always took it as protection of the city from the radioactive fallout of the nuke that just detonated on the other side.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, another explanation could be that no one was watching the troops since they were concentrating on the portal, so they didn't know at the time that they were all dead.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/52/DForck42", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "This was because of two reasons.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Portal was still spewing oodles of Chitauri.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Avengers did not know that destroying the mother ship would neutralize all the Chitauri.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That was a last resort to handle the Nuke.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Nowhere is it shown that Tony was aware of this neural link prior to him pushing the nuke through the wormhole.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This was their last action plan...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "To nip it at the bud, so that they could take out the Chitauri still remaining in the city.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Their primary plan was to close the portal.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is clear through several pieces of dialogue: Captain :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Alright, listen up.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Until we can close that portal up there, our priority is containment.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Then we have: Captain :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Thor, you've gotta try and bottleneck that portal.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And Also Black Widow :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Captain, none of this is gonna mean a damn thing if we don't close that portal.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "To save Manhattan from the massive amount of fallout and debris falling through.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Manhattan would've suffered even more casualties had the tons of debris fallen through.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/7516/Stark07", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I understood it to be that they didn't know that sending the nuke through the portal would actually affect the Chitauri or even stop them as it did.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Therefore they only thought that closing the portal would make the difference.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Tony didn't know that when he flew the nuke through there and neither did Black Widow.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1039/AlasdairCM", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "If the distance between the blast and the portal was small, then it could have come through, so it would have to be closed as soon as possible.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If the distance was large, then other Chitauri, not killed in the blast, could have come through.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/2155/Origin", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "I'm a bit confused as to why they would be so quick to close the portal if all the Chitauri were powering down/dying? What's the big rush? I think the only thing that could make sense would be the nuke blast coming through the portal, but the explosion seems way too far away to have done that?", "title": "In the Avengers movie, why did they close the portal?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<marvel-cinematic-universe><the-avengers>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/4517", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/2156/Virux" }

[ [ "They didn't know what else was coming. Therefore, they had to shut the portal as quickly as possibile even if that meant sacrificing Stark.", "They did not know what else was coming." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "They did not know what else was coming.There could have been a huge alien about to come through which they could not have stopped. Therefore they had to shut the portal as quickly as possible even if it meant sacrificing Stark" ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Actually it's never stated that demons go back to hell when they die .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "They do go back to hell when they're exorcised, and since yellow eyes was killed we haven't seen him except for flashbacks and such. Vampires and", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "pretty much all other monsters go to purgatory when they die.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It's never stated if angels go anywhere when they die, I believe they simply stop existing completely.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "In season 8 we see Dean kill some vampires in purgatory, it's assumed that once you die in purgatory you stop existing.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/52/DForck42", "score": 11 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Unknown .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is similar to how we don't know where demons go, or where someone killed in Purgatory goes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We know when they die they don't go back to heaven (which was obvious from the on-going war in heaven).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We know that beings can only go to Purgatory if they have a soul.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, from The Man Who Would Be King : CASTIEL", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You want to make a deal?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "With me?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'm an Angel, you ass.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I don't have a soul to sell.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, they can't go to Purgatory.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Therefore, at the of sounding a little wishy-washy, the angels go somewhere , and God has the ability to bring them back .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Where that somewhere is, what the requirements are to get there, and how they get back, is a complete unknown.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8219/Andrew Martin", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It is never said where Angels go.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The same with Demons but all supernatural beings except for Ghosts go to Purgatory.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'm pretty sure Ghosts go to Heaven or stop existing all together.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Now, when you kill something in Purgatory, I believe it just stops existing all together.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/3872/Stephen Harling", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "As introduced in season 11: They both (angels and demon) go to the empty .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Empty is a void that existed before God or the Darkness.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It serves as an afterlife for angels and demons, where they sleep for eternity.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Source: https://supernatural.fandom.com/wiki/The_Empty", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/43700/Jules", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It's not clear yet.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Misha thinks they're just gone but there must be some kind of loophole (See here ).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think God must have some control over it, as he brought Cas back.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/7394/user2176127", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Well, demons can't stop existing because Death said that souls can be twisted tossed and turned, but never broken, not even by him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So souls can't be destroyed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Demons have souls, they maybe corrupted, but they are still souls.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think maybe they go to Purgatory when they die, because in Gods eyes they are probably monsters.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And monsters have poisoned souls, Eve put a monstrous virus in their body and soul.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And Leviathans have no souls, because they are older than souls (said so by death)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so I like to think that purgatory is the place of the soulless and corrupted soul.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "God gave humans souls so that they can go somewhere after death.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So to go to heaven or hell when you die, you need a pure soul.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Now in this case pure doesn't mean good or righteous, it means not contaminated.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Demons have corrupted souls, so they go to purgatory.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "God probably gave Angels grace, not only for power, but so they could go somewhere when they die besides purgatory.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They don't have souls, so god gave them grace to take them to a special place for angels.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I believe God made it so that when Angels take out their grace, or have it taken out, they gain as soul, so they go to heaven (or hell)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "not purgatory.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So if Sam had died when he had no soul, he would have gone to purgatory.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/7364/Josh", "score": 0 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Pretty sure Cas mentions they go to Purgatory, I could be wrong in which I apologise, but in 7x23 - 'Survival of the fittest' both Dean and Castiel go to Purgatory after killing Dick Roman and killing him killed them", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "did it not?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/13896/user13896", "score": 0 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Well actually, when Dean and Castiel went to Purgatory, they didn't actually die.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was just that when standing close enough to a Leviathan, you were sent to Purgatory along with it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So technically, Dean and Castiel were actually ALIVE in Purgatory, never actually dying.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, if they did both die and go to Purgatory, it wouldn't work out, as Dean would either have to go to Heaven or Hell(being a human soul), and Castiel?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Well, the answer for where he goes is still uncertain.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/27213/Deimos", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "In the television series Supernatural it is said that upon death, demons go back to hell and vampires and other creatures go to purgatory. Where do angels go when they die?", "title": "Where do angels go upon death?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<supernatural>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/8965", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/" }

[ [ "It's actually never stated that demons go back to hell when they die. They do go back to hell when they are exorcised whearas Vampires and other monsters go to purgatory when they die. It's never stated if angels go anywhere when they die.", "It's never stated if angels go anywhere when they die, they simply stop existing completely." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Actually it's never stated that demons go back to hell when they die. They do go back into hell when they're exorcised, and since yellow eyes was killed we haven't seen him. It's never stated if angels go anywhere when they die, I believe they simply stop existing completely." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "There appears to be some debate over this (on IMDb boards and Rotten Tomatoes et al), but I found a Wikipedia snippet that suggests the following: Film scholar David Bordwell, writing in Film Viewer's Guide, mentioned the (un)reality of the ending as a topic for debate.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A number of scenes in the film — Rupert and Jerry in the restaurant, Jerry meeting Rupert after having listened to his tape and calling him a genius, Rupert getting married \"live\" on Jerry's show — exist solely in Rupert's imagination, and Bordwell suggested that some viewers would think the final sequence is another fantasy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/382/Nobby", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The background curtains, as stated above, look like prison bars.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In addition, he's wearing a very loud red suit consistent of what would be worn by someone in prison.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Finally, if you happen to look he positions his hands in what would normally be some form of a restraint position.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "All this, in addition to the very weak material in his stand up would lead one to believe that he's imagining all of this from some from of Prison/Mental institution.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/51381/Bob A' Booey", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "That's clearly Pupkin's imagination.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Think about all the times he was day dreaming, it was EXAGGERATED, a lot, and now read the last lines of the script (which, by the way, different from the original draft where it is clearly not day dreaming, here is instead not that obvious..), after stating that the biography has been sold for a million ( a million! ) dollars, and that a movies will be made on it soon, and that \"he and his people were weighing attractive offers\": And now, ladies and gentlemen the man we've all been waiting for, and waiting for .Would", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "you welcome home please television's brightest new star", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The legendary, inspirational, the one and only king of comedy !", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Ladies and gentlemen, Rupert Pupkin!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Rupert Pupkin, ladies and gentlemen!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Let's hear it for Rupert Pupkin!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Wonderful!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Rupert Pupkin, ladies and gentlemen!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Rupert Pupkin, ladies and gentlemen!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Let's hear it for Rupert Pupkin!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Wonderful !", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Rupert Pupkin, ladies and gentlemen!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You get it..", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is no different from when, during the movie, his teacher is thanking him because.. he changed their lives.. :D", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/83012/nnsense", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Having had this discussion many times, I am convinced it is a fantasy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "My primary reasoning is that, beyond the symbolism people have already pointed out, his end rise to \"King\" level doesn't really make that much rational sense.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The short prison sentence, the fact that somehow he would be even more popular 6 years later, and the fact that he is just given a show of his own are all incredibly extreme.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I believe the lack of Jerry in the final sequence is meant to show a change in his fantasy life.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He no longer needs Jerry to be a crutch for his fantasies, he can pour them all into himself.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/59739/josh allen", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Fantasy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And here is my theory:Remember that every scene in Rupert's imagination is outweighed by scenes in Rupert's reality.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Now, think of it like this: Rupert's fantasy = positive life situation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Rupert's reality = negative life situation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The movie follows a certain pattern of balance​, it follows a shift of positive fantasy and negative reality.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For every negative situations in his reality, it had to be balanced by the same amount of positive situations in his fantasy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For example, he got his tape rejected by Jerry (negative reality), next scene shows Jerry praising him (positive fantasy).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We find another example at the end of the movie:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Rupert goes to jail (very negative reality).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If the movie follows this pattern then the last scene with Rupert's success, a very positive situation, has to be fantasy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/79310/Zhen 2012", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think the ending is a fantasy by the sheer magnitude of the reception he receives in the end...which is consistent in regard to viewing himself as the KING...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/9140/bharat wadhawan", "score": 0 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "When Rupert is being introduced during the end scene the curtains in the background resemble prison bars, quite a strong hint towards reality or fantasy.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The point is there is evidence to both sides of the argument, it's up to the viewer to make a decision depending on their interpretation of the film.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "That's what the director has intended to do.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/14023/Tom", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "In the final scene of Martin Scorsese's 'King of Comedy' a news report suggests that Rupert Pupkin (played by Robert De Niro), after coming out of prison, becomes a sensation and releases his much awaited autobiography. At the same time he is shown to be holding various offers for shows. Is it possible that he would have imagined this bit too like his previous conversations and stage shows with Jerry Langford? Is there any suggestive evidence leading to reality or otherwise?", "title": "Was the success of Rupert Pupkin real in King of Comedy?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><ending><the-king-of-comedy>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/9025", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/3538/Qrious" }

[ [ "It is up to the viewer to make a decision based on their interpretation of the film. When Rupert is being introduced in the end of the film the curtains in the background resemble prison bars which hint towards reallity and fantasy but it is clearly Pupkin's imagination.", "That's clearly Pupkin's imagination." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "When Rupert is being introduced during the end scene the curtains in the background resemble prison bars, quite a strong hint towards reality or fantasy. That's what the director has intended to do, that's clearly Pupkin's imagination." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "When Anderson releases the computer hacker guy and lets him walk free.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Dredd tells her that releasing a felon is not only a fail but a criminal offense.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Anderson explains that she has already failed because she lost her side arm (an automatic failure).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She says \"I'm not going to be a judge", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and I don't need to be a mind reader to know it", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\" implying that she knew the outcome of her assessment without having to read Dredd's mind.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So technically she did fail, and fail multiple times.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think Dredd passes Anderson on grounds that she represents what the judges need.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A person who wants to make a difference.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There are a couple of spots in the film where Anderson demonstrates why she wanted to become a judge.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When they first enter Peach Tree.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Dredd makes comments about how crime infested the building is (going as far as to cite statistics).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Anderson shuts him up by telling him she was raised in one of these blocks.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When asked why she wanted to become a judge, Anderson responds \"Yes, I believe I can make a difference\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Dredd responds with \"admirable\" implying a sense of hopelessness to her goals.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the scene where she releases the computer hacker.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She says that \"I'm still a judge, and I'll still dispense justice.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "At least while I can maybe I'll make a difference\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is also the only time in the film where you see Dredd smile (or as close to smiling as he can).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The corrupt four judges that Ma-ma calls in to have Dredd killed represent that current state of corruption in the system.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One of the judges says to Dredd that \"the city is a meat grinder\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Implying that the law is hopeless and a lost cause.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Anderson doesn't read minds constantly.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's an action she has to willingly perform.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When Dredd and Anderson are discussing what to do when they discover that Ma-ma is the king-pin for the slow-mo drug cartel in the city.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Dredd says \"You gave us two options.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Defend or hide.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "What about we attack?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Head straight for Ma-ma\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Anderson says \"Is that an option?\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Dredd replies \"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Well she's guilty.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We're judges.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Anderson says worriedly, \"sir, I think we should wait for backup\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Dredd just frowns.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Anderson continues \"Wrong answer?\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Dredd answers \"You're the psychic.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\" From this it is clear that Anderson only reads minds when she needs to, otherwise she would have said to go after Ma-ma in the first place.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So to summarize:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Dredd knew she failed multiple times.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Anderson knew she failed, and that's why she gave him her badge.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Dredd passed Anderson anyway cause he saw hope that she might make a difference.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Chief Judge says \"I knew she would\" because she saw it too.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1100/Reactgular", "score": 25 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Actually, my take on it was that while she acknowledged she technically failed, she ultimately turned in her badge because she couldn't handle the questionable ethics and the emotional intensity of the job.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Case in point: she executes one of the Ma-Ma clan members who was begging for his life, then later discovers he was the husband and father of a Peach Trees block wife and kid.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When she releases the hacker, she also says \"I'm not going to be a Judge", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and I don't have to be a mind reader to", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "know it.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She goes on, \"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He's a victim not a perp and until my assessment is formally over", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'm still entitled to dispense justice", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and that's what I just did, by letting him go.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe that will be the one difference I do make.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The code to Ma-Ma's chambers is 49436.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Let's finish this.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I don't think it gets any clearer than this as to why she turned in her badge.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A Judge must be strict, no mercy, the law is black and white, but because she's a psychic she sees the grey areas.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"Let's finish this\" is another reflection of her realization that she is not cut out for the harsh code of being a Judge.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Her spirit is too kind.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "At the end, when Dredd says, \"Your assessment is now over.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is far from an answer on whether she passed or failed", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and she knows it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The fact that she didn't even wait for the official answer suggests that she had already made up her mind.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4860/digitalbum", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think when he said she passed, he actually meant she passed up being a judge.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But it ended too early to determine if he literally passed her or if it was a figure of speech.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5385/poormanswrath", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Obviously she passed and becomes a judge.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The last scene of the movie is a silhouette (or back lit) view of Anderson in her Judge uniform ...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "at least this is what it appeared to be to me.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5391/Pᴀᴜʟsᴛᴇʀ2", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Dredd did pass her, it was up to Anderson after that.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "At the very ending scene you see Anderson carrying a helmet and a new gun implying she learned from Dredd and decided to become a Judge, plus in the comics", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "she was the lead Judge is the pyi division.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5965/Tyler Lowe", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "She's a Psychic, the sidearm isn't her primary weapon, her brain is.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "So the loss of her brain, or having it taken from her is a fail, the gun is just another tool to her, but she'd have failed if she lost the psychic duel with Kay.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "With the judgment call on the hacker being a victim, whilst unusual for a judge to be lenient, given her psychic powers she's far more likely to assess a victim correctly than a regular judge,", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "additionally she could just as easily pick up on a perp playing the victim.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "And we see leniency from Dredd himself with the vagrant at the beginning.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "So at no point did she actually fail, she merely judged herself along the same lines as Dredd, which was silly, cos hey, psychic.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8353/Lightstar", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "In the 2012 movie Dredd, rookie Anderson who is a psychic is put on an assessment mission with Dredd. At the very end of the movie, Dredd states that her assessment is over and she hands her badge over looking quite defeated as if she understands she failed. When asked by the Chief Judge if Anderson passes, Dredd says she passes. The question I have is that if Anderson is psychic and can obviously read Dredd's mind, did she actually pass? Did Dredd lie to the Chief Judge?", "title": "Did Anderson actually pass?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><dredd>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/9168", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/3570/Chad Kapatch" }

[ [ "She didn't actually fail, she merely judged herself along the same lines as Dredd.", "So the loss of her brain, or having it taken from her is a fail, the gun is just another tool to her." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "She's a Psychic, the sidearm isn't her primary weapon, her brain is. So the loss of her brain, or having it taken from her is a fail, the gun is just another tool to her. With the judgment call on the hacker being a victim, whilst unusual for a judge to be lenient, given her psychic powers she's far more likely to assess a victim correctly than a regular judge." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "From an interview with Christopher Nolan: I don't really know where that came from...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He actually had a sort of prosthetic appliance for the scars that wrapped over his lower lips, and the first couple of scenes where he was playing it that way, I actually had thought it was a mistake...", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "I thought the prosthetic was coming loose on the bottom lip", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "and he was sticking it down with his tongue or something.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "And it was only after we shot a couple of scenes I realized", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "oh no this is a thing he's found", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": ", this is a sort of...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think it's a lizard like... or serpent like elemental kind of gesture..", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and I think it works...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think it's very creepy...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "[ Click here to listen to Nolan", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "talk about Ledger's creepy lip-smacking]", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1525/Oliver_C", "score": 39 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The Joker in", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Dark Knight had a Glasgow smile .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There would have been scars on the insides of his cheeks as well as on the outsides.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I thought Heath Ledger was acting out the behavior of someone who had never gotten used to their presence, and was constantly poking and worrying at them with his tongue, especially right at the corners of his mouth.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4304/Will Feldman", "score": 11 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It was actually an honest bad habit of Ledger's.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He would often lick his lips and it fit in with the character.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The joker is symbolically described as a dog in the film and there is many references.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He is a self proclaimed \"dog chasing cars\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He is the unloyal hungry dog as compared to Chechen, the Russian's, pets/protection", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There is a scene where he is hanging out the window of a GCPD patrol cruiser and licking his lips as wind blows his hair much like a dog would.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He is often seen licking his lips.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But, it began as just Heath's bad habit and personality", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The symbolism is he is an animal that can play tame", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but, much, like a pitbull, he is raw power and wilderness.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4020/Matt", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Several options come to mind.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It maybe a feature of a maniac antisocial.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maniacs have several sorts of behavioral uniqueness.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It might be Joker's uniqueness.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It maybe an approach like a reptile.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Like they do this tongue-work before leaping into a prey, this behavior might indicate Jokers saurian satanic thought process.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Like incognito said it might be due to the irritation on his skin caused by his makeup.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Might be he does it, when he becomes nervous.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A discrete feature proving he is crazy!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/3271/Mistu4u", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "A movie clip came out a few days ago talking about the joker in the movie, and it is explained why he kept licking his lips.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As we can see in the video below:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "At first it was a make-up problem, that when Heath was speaking the prothestics became loosened.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So because Heath didn't want to keep gluing the make up to his lips over and over again, he started licking the lips, and then that became part of the character.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/42976/Gustavo Gabriel", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "My opinion is -Joker wore paint on his face so this might be causing dryness and hence the constant licking", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/313/Incognito", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "Throughout The Dark Knight, the Joker licks his lips when in conversation. Why does the Joker do this? Is this a psychological affect commonly observed in sociopaths or people with mental imbalances (or however you'd choose to describe the Joker)? Or is this merely a product of Heath Ledger's portrayal? If this is the case, what was his motivation to do so?", "title": "Why did the Joker lick his lips?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<character><the-dark-knight>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/9251", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/850/stevvve" }

[ [ "I thought that it was a mistake and only realized he was playing the character that way a couple of shots in.", "He actually had a sort of prosthetic appliance for the scars that wrapped over his lower lips, a" ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [ "And it was only after we shot a couple of scenes I realized" ] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "He actually had a sort of prosthetic appliance for the scars that wrapped over his lower lips, and the first couple of scenes where he was playing it that way, I actually had thought it was a mistake. I thought the prosthetic was coming loose on the bottom lip" ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Marvel Studios President Kevin Feige said in November 2012: Iron Man 3 doesn't feature any of the other Avengers , or Nick Fury showing up, or any of those world-blending conceits that the Phase One films had.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You have to keep in mind that Iron Man 3 had been in the works for almost a year, year and a half before The Avengers was released.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We're sticking to the vision for these films, and showing once again that these characters are just as interesting alone as they are together.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There was a rumour that actress Stephanie Szostak was playing Janet van Dyne (Wasp) (she is a founding member of the Avengers in the comics) .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "According to Joss Whedon early drafts of The Avengers included Janet van Dyne", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1525/Oliver_C", "score": 14 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Yes - if you wait right until the very end of the credits, there's a sequence involving Mark Ruffalo as Bruce Banner.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's just a little joke though and not part of the main plot.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Otherwise, no other Avengers appear.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/314/Mark", "score": 12 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Samuel L. Jackson said none of the Avengers are gonna be in Iron Man 3.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Here is a source: http://www.whogottherole.com/movie-news/nick-fury-wont-be-needed-in-iron-man-3-24324", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/3877/J Smith", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The answer is no.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "There is no new avengers in Iron Man 3.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Rumors about Stephanie Szostak playing Janet van Dyne (Wasp) proved wrong.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "She is playing Ellen Brandt not completely like her comics part", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "and she is given with Extremis virus.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Which made her powerful villain not an Avenger.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "If Ellen Brandt survived somehow(shown killed) then she can be used in Marvel Universe for her connection to Man-Thing and Dr Strange but that's all rumor at the moment.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "For now there is no new Avenger in it.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Bruce Banner's appearance is there after credit", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "but he is not the part of the main story.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1190/Ankit Sharma", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I just returned from the showing.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There are no Avengers in the film, but hang around until after the credits if you really want to see another member of the team...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/382/Nobby", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The cast listed on IMDb doesn't have any members of the Avengers listed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1100/Reactgular", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "No Avengers who were Avengers at the time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, War Machine/Rhodey does feature prominently.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He joins the Avengers in the second recruitment at the end of Age of Ultron.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8170/vastra360", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "Are any of the other Avengers going to be in Iron Man 3? Or is he flying solo?", "title": "Does Iron Man 3 have any other Avengers in it?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<marvel-cinematic-universe><iron-man-3>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/9402", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/3857/tcbcw" }

[ [ "No, for now there is no new avenger in Iron Man 3. Bruce Banner's appearance is there after the credits but he Is not part of the main sotry. ", "There is no new avengers in Iron Man 3. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "The answer is no. There is no new avengers in Iron Man 3. Rumors about Stephanie Szostak playing Janet van Dyne were wrong. She is playing Ellen Brandt not completely like her comics part and she is given with Extremis virus. Which made her powerful villain not an Avenger." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "There are some interesting references to paper, origami, cards, etc.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "in House of Cards.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Perhaps for Claire, it's a reference to two things - one being her suppressed creativity and how that ties in to her longing for Adam.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We don't know that much about her past, except that which has been revealed through her conversations with Adam.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We also learn a little about her choices when she sat by Steve's bedside as she discusses the conscious decision she made to be with Frank, not necessarily for love, but for the respect and freedom he would give her.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Ironically, though Claire is not locked into a life of being the trophy wife, she is seemingly trapped in a marriage of partnership and reason.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Adam (and the origami) represent freedom, art, and impermanence.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "All that which she does not possess.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The second reference may be to the constant folding and unfolding of events in her life.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As close as she may be to Frank, he is still able to use her as a pawn to further his own goals.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She makes decisive efforts to curtail this when she sabotages the water bill.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Paper is temporary; it does not provide real shelter, as was mentioned by one of the workers at the shipyard meeting Peter Russo held.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Nor does it protect us from the elements.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It can all collapse in a moment, just as a structure made of cards will do.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Money, made of paper, can be easily burned, destroyed or lost.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "His kids also do origami - a foreshadowing of the two tiny victims who will pay a huge price for Frank's lust for power.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The homeless guy took a bill - a physical representation of what our society deems to be worth something, folded it, and turned it into a piece of art for Claire.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It wasn't a small amount for a homeless person - it was $20!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A blatant reminder that those things which are valuable to some, may mean nothing to others.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was an eerie reminder that her life and everything she values can quickly fall apart.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Lastly, Frank in his speech when he was honored at his alma mater talks about harmony, and how \"it is not about what's lasting or permanent,", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "it's about individual voices coming together for a moment.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\" This is so contradictory to everything Frank truly stands for.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The reality is, he backstabs, manipulates, and deceives everyone around him, especially those who are near him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The only one he does not deceive is Stamper (which should be discussed on a separate thread as that is an interesting theme as well) Frank is fully driven by the hunger to establish legacy, permanence, and power - basically the opposite of what origami represents.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I would love to hear more feedback from others", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "- I think this is a really interesting concept and there is so much room to dig deeper.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4169/Lisa", "score": 15 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Another aspect to origami is that it requires precise, painstaking execution, which seems to come naturally to Claire.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Like origami, she is beautiful, complicated, and controlled; given the way the plot unfolds, she may be crushable.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, the folds and doubling-back suggests to me complexity and double-dealing.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I find her very intriguing.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Although I am associating the origami with negative connotations, I started liking her when she took up the origami, and found myself falling under her sway.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "DRJ", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4257/user4257", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It's a stork.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think it foreshadows her interest in having kids.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Note that she exchanges it with Russo's kids, whom she dreams about just before she shows overt interest in pregnancy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4435/joel", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Coming late to HoC party, but very intrigued by the paper references.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think it can also extend into the newspapers as well.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Their impermanence and the digital forms of information that now are of so much weight and importance.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The significance of the origami is far reaching.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It represents a childlike whimsicalness, referring to Peter's children and to Claire's missed opportunity at motherhood.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It is the transformation of a flat piece of ordinary paper into a beautiful unique hand made 3 dimensional art object.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "With the same generic piece of paper, you can imagine anything and create it from almost nothing.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It is a swan that the homeless man creates for Claire.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Not a crane.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Swans are often folded for weddings.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The folds allow for patterns on a piece of paper to be incorporated as the illusion of feathers ( as is shown in the folds of the US $20 bill).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Swans mate for life.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Swans also signify a journey or that a is change coming.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For better and worse Cliare is married to Frank for life.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She is on a journey with him and change is always afoot.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When Claire leaves Adam in New York, she rearranges the photograph he has printed for her.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Again the impermanence of paper, who prints photos anymore and who prints them that large?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "More paper falling by the wayside.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She also folds a swan and leaves this for Adam showing her allegiance to Frank.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8328/user8328", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think it may also be a representation of Claire herself.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Paper on it's own is blank and undefined but once folded and manipulated it can serve a purpose as with the origami.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "After the photo Claire takes of the girl is first printed Adam keeps projecting what he sees onto the image, wanting to name her Claire indicating that he sees her this way.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Claire before leaving however, rearranges the photo into how she sees herself.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "A tightly controlled image surrounded by obscure and indiscernible border.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8029/A V", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I do believe it to be an allusion to the meeting of Diogenes of Sinope and Alexander the Great which is one of the most well-discussed anecdotes from philosophical history.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Many versions of it exist.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The most popular relate it as evidence of Diogenes' disregard for honor, wealth, and respect.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Alexander says to Diogenes \"tell me what you want and I will grant it\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Diogenes looks at the great man, who is standing right in front of him. \"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Grant me anything?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Then move to one side as you are blocking my sun!\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/41017/Scott", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "In the 6th episode of House of Cards, we see Claire have some sympathy towards a vagrant outside of her work and gives this man $20 to get some food from a deli close by The next day, the man is still there and then flicks back the $20, now in the shape of an origami crane. What is the purpose of this scene, and what does the Crane represent given the current events in Claire's life?", "title": "What is the significance of the Origami Bum?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<analysis><house-of-cards>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/10050", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/130/Tablemaker" }

[ [ "It may also be a representation of Claire herself.", "It may also be a representation of Claire herself. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "It may also be a representation of Claire herself. Claire takes a photo of a girl and Adam imagines her image as a representation of her. After the photo is first printed Adam keeps projecting what he sees onto the image. Claire rearranges the photo into how she sees herself before leaving." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "While Kevin Howell is quite spot-on in his explanation of the upside down flag representing distress, I think especially his link to the Flag Code gives another, maybe even better fitting explanation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The country itself is objectively seen not in distress during the course of the show.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So while the upside down flag could represent some kind of metaphorical distress in the way that the government and the political system are depicted, what may better fit here is the other, albeit invalid, reason for an upside-down flag, disrespect .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "By showing the flag upside-down without an imminent presence of \"dire distress in instances of extreme danger to life or property\" it shows disrespect to the flag and the political ideals (and ultimately the country and its people) it stands for.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Of course, I'm neither saying the show or its makers are disrespecting the U.S. flag nor am I making any personal judgement about such behaviour, just that the characters and the way politics are shown have lost the ideals that flag was once supposed to represent.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This disrespect is shown by the political schemes and plots that (not only, but most prominently) Frank Underwood plays with the governmental forces (and ultimately the country) in order to feed his own lust for power.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The show depicts a political system and moral that have been (in/per)verted upside-down in the same way as the flag that represents them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The missing stars could either be just some kind of stylization, but could as well refer to something deeper.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "One might interpret that into the same disrespect symbolization as the upside-down part, but could maybe also come up with something based on the fact that the stars represent the states.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe this way it shows that the show isn't about actual politics with any significance to the whole country, but about a man not interested into anything outside of Washington D.C. and misusing the country's fate only as a device for his own goals.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/49/Napoleon Wilson", "score": 23 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "A flag being flown upside down is a symbol for distress .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As far as the no stars I'm looking into that.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/645/Kevin Howell", "score": 21 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "No stars may mean that there is no democracy here - no votes are ever cast by states for Underwood (excepting a small portion of South Carolina).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think the graphic was also meant to draw attention to the show in general.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It certainly makes one curious.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/11510/Paul", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I wonder if the lack of stars symbolizes the power of the federal government over constituent states.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8466/Drew", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "No stars = likely simply a graphic design aesthetic choice.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "A logo doesn't have to be a literal representation.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's clearly the american flag, even without the stars, and the stars would simply be too small to render well on a lot of screens.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/756/DA.", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I believe it also stands for a \"false flag event.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\" Something fake used to bring about war for gaining political, monetary and a general increase in over all power.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8189/dan", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "The logo for Netflix's House of Cards shows an upside-down & mirrored American Flag with 0 stars on it. What does this logo represent in terms of the show? Is it meant to be symbolism with the themes of the show, or just simple dramatic flair?", "title": "What does the Flag symbolize?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<title><house-of-cards>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/10125", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/130/Tablemaker" }

[ [ "Seeing as the stars represent the states the missing stars could mean that the show isn't about actual politics, but about a man not interested in anything outside of Washington D.C. It could also simply be an aesthetic choice.", "No stars means likely simply a graphic design aesthetic choice. Stars would simply be too small to render well on a lot of screens." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "The missing stars could either be just some kind of stylization, but could as well refer to something deeper. Maybe this way it shows that the show isn't about actual politics with any significance to the whole country, but about a man not interested into anything outside of Washington D.C.", "No stars means likely simply a graphic design aesthetic choice. Stars would simply be too small to render well on a lot of screens." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "The cabbie is indeed shown to be terminally ill and wants to raise money for his family.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, this only explains why he resorts to killing people (=earn money fast).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Motives of Moriarty are part of the bigger overall story arc in the Sherlock Holmes universe as Moriarty is the arch-nemesis of Sherlock.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The poison pill trick is not random.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The cabbie is skilled in reading and manipulating people.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He has analyzed what drives his victims and acts accordingly.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He knew Sherlock would get in his cab instead of calling the police.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The poison pill trick is his way of showing he has control through his skill.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "His victims can make the choice but as they are choosing, the cabbie manipulates them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He knows which of the bottles is poisonous and will manipulate his victims into taking the bad bottle.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If they take the good one, he will convince them to change their mind.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This shows of how good the cabbie is in reading people, predicting their train of thought and knowing what to say to mislead them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It takes great skill to manipulate people that know you are trying to kill them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "His confrontation with Sherlock is a battle in the understanding of human behavior.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It is a match to decide who can better see through the other's act.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They have layers and layers of bluff/misdirection in all the small details of their actions.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/2155/Origin", "score": 21 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The killer was terminally ill with a brain aneurism and could die at any moment.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He was using the 'scheme' to raise money.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He was earning money from Moriarty, who was essentially sponsoring the cabbie to murder people in this manner.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Moriarty's motive is unclear, perhaps just to cause chaos, but more likely to get his name in front of Sherlock.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Essentially the cabbie had nothing to lose - so it was purely random which pill was poison.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "On each occasion he had a 50% chance of winning.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As the only repeat player, the odds are that he would die within a few rounds, but a fairly good chance he would kill one or two in the process - raising money for his family.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He viewed himself as being expendable, likely to die at any moment anyway - an intelligent man, he viewed it as a risk worth taking.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "[Alternative (not very serious theory): Perhaps he has built up an immunity to Iocaine powder ?]", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/40/iandotkelly", "score": 20 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "There's another explanation although without evidence of course.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Neither of the pills were poisonous.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The poison was in a glass of water he would offer the victims to wash it down with.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He'd dry swallow the pill.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "In my opinion it's one of the better answers.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "However everything is entirely speculation so it could easily be wrong.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5402/crazydrifter", "score": 12 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Both pills have poison.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You see", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but you do not observe!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The cabbie opens the bottle and holds the pill in his left hand.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He talks and distracts Holmes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Just before he is shot you see him with a pill in his right hand.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He had a second, non-poison pill, all the time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He did this with all the victims.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "None had a chance, the game was rigged.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "At time 1:19:36 the pill is in his left hand.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "At time 1:19:54 the pill is in his right hand.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5886/Guest", "score": 11 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Could be the pills are his meds.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If he takes them it does nothing (they're prescribed for a reason), but when someone else takes them they die.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5982/Vasili Andropolov", "score": 10 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I heard my favorite theory on tumblr and expanded on it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Neither pill was poison, and the water he gave them was.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He swallowed his dry.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This explanation has no evidence in the episode to support it, but it still fits the events and I like it a lot.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One problem that I noticed is that there is no water in the final scene where they are both about to take the pills.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One way to explain this is that the cabbie's sponsor Moriarty (who has been described as a 'fan' of Sherlock) did not want Sherlock dead.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If neither of them used poison water then neither one would die.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Presumably, the cabbie would fake his own death, let Sherlock think he had chosen right, and then who knows?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5630/Cooper Wiseman", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "This is covered in the episode, Holmes mentions it to the cabbie and the cabbie replies something like:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Four games and four wins, that's not random", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If you want an excellent, explained example of this in", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "action - watch", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Princess Bride: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U_eZmEiyTo0", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The man in black's intelligence test.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He provides two vials, one of which is poisoned.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Vizzini explains his chain of thought thus expressing how he feels that the placement of the poisons is not random but is a psychological trick.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the same way the taxi driver feels that there is psychology in the way he plays his 'game' and that it is not random - whether either if them are right or wrong is not the point, the point is that they feel there is more to it than random chance", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Note: the twist in the Princess Bride's version about immunities is not relevant to the Holmes's version.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I only included this as it explained the chain of thought as to which glass should be drunk from.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1501/Stefan", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "In Sherlock season 1 episode 1 the serial killer asks Sherlock to take one of two bottles. 1 bottle is ok other is bad (poisonous). Whatever bottle Sherlock takes the serial killer takes the other one. That is same way the serial killer murdered his other victims. But the episode doesn't say how exactly serial killer achieved this. Before Sherlock can take one of the bottles the serial killer is murdered. Does anybody know how the serial killer achieved this?", "title": "In Sherlock: Study in Pink how does the choice of bottles work?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><sherlock>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/10432", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/3559/minusSeven" }

[ [ "There is another explination although without evidence of course.Neither of the pills were poisonous. The posison was in a glass of water he would offer the victims to wash it down wih. ", "Neither of the pills were poisonous." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "There's another explanation although without evidence, of course. Neither of the pills were poisonous. The poison was in a glass of water he would offer the victims to wash it down with. However everything is entirely speculation so it could easily be wrong." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "It's a deliberate directorial device.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We're experiencing the world through Walt and Jessie's eyes, so it allows us to appreciate their confusion, suspicion and fear through the powerlessness they feel when events are unfolding around them - with little understanding and consequent lack of control.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We're left to interpret the body language (of which 70% of communication arises) and the odd words that are similar in both languages.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Just as we would in the same situation. shudder", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5397/Astravagrant", "score": 50 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I've only seen the show as the DVD box set, so the original showing may have been different, but some of the scenes are subtitled, and some aren't.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This doesn't seem accidental, or sloppy", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "- like everything in the series, it has meaning and it adds to the development of the story.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The most powerful examples of this are two scenes with the Cousins.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "At the end of S3 06, Gus meets the Cousins in the desert, in a very tense confrontation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's not subtitled, but it doesn't need to be.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We know the Cousins want to kill Walt, and we know Gus needs him alive, at least for the time being.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They argue about it, Gus says something that makes them think...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "then he says Hank's name, very clearly.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And we know that he's given them Hank, to kill, instead of Walt, and the credits roll.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The very next scene (the first scene of S3 07) is subtitled throughout.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Cousins, as small boys, squabble over a toy, and one (Marco) runs to their uncle (Hector) to complain, and says he wants his brother (Leonel) dead.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hector calls Leonel to him, and plunges his head into a barrel of water, holding him there, asking Marco if that's what he wants.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Marco pummels Hector desperately until he releases Leonel, and asks him tearfully if he's all right.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hector tells them: 'Family is all'.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Not only does this tell us why the Cousins, and the cartel, are such implacable enemies...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "it also horrifies us to see the innocence of two little boys who we know will become utterly evil and remorseless.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But the entire scene would be incomprehensible without the dialogue, so the subtitles are essential.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/9453/PeterClose", "score": 14 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "You have not really said who \"they\" is, but on the Breaking Bad Wiki as well as the Blu-ray they are shown.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1339/Steven Penny", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I have the DVDs and watch them with the subs on, and some of it is important.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The setup for Danny Trejo's character's murder was somewhat important, or at least allowed you to understand it better.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The \"experiencing the world through Walt and Jesse's eyes\" bit is BS.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If Jesse and Walt aren't even in the scene, what would it matter?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And, like I said, some of the conversations are important to the plot lines.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's not like they're reading the weather report or something, the dialogue does matter.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As for why the original episodes weren't subbed at the time...?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Well, there are plenty of Spanish speakers in the U.S. now.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I guess they figured half their audience would get it and half wouldn't.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It always kinda bugged me that there's a SAP setting for your TV, but no way to translate Spanish to English.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8071/Johnny Bones", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Note that the Season 4 (so it's not the cause of your specific issue)", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Blu-ray has a glitch where several Spanish-language scenes are supposed to contain English subtitles, but the subtitles don't appear unless you manually enable them through the menu.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Rather than being burned into the image, these subtitles are just another subtitle track, and it's supposed to be enabled by default, so that even when you turn the subtitles \"off\" altogether, these subtitles appear for the Spanish-language scenes.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Due to the bug, the subtitles do NOT appear if you simply put the disc in your player and hit \"play.\"", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Instead, you have to enable the full English subtitles via the menu, then turn them off again.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The English subtitles will then appear for the Spanish-language scenes as they should.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/26529/Carl Fink", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "I am a huge fan of Breaking Bad and I am currently watching season 3. One thing that I have noticed is that there are several scenes where characters speak in Spanish - some of these scenes are quite important for following the story - but they never show language translations or subtitles. Why is it that? What is the reason for not translating the Spanish dialogue for the viewers?", "title": "Why don't they show subtitles for the Spanish dialogue?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<breaking-bad><subtitles>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/11198", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/301/Ankit" }

[ [ "This is not your specific issue but, the season 4 Blu-Ray has a glitch where several Spanish language scenes are supposed to contain English subtitles but, they don't appear unless you manually enable them through the menu.", "The subtitles don't appear unless you manually enable them through the menu" ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Several Spanish-language scenes are supposed to contain English subtitles. The subtitles don't appear unless you manually enable them through the menu. English subtitles do NOT appear if you simply put the disc in your player and hit \"play\" Instead, you have to enable the full English subtitles via the menu, then turn them off again. The English subtitles will then appear for the Spanish scenes as they should." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "The use of monikers such as M and Q is, IMO, more to do with tradition and traditional anonymity than secrecy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(See my answer to another Bond question for more on this.)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You can see colleagues mingling socially (the opening scenes of Licence to Kill come to mind) and Bond pops up to M's flat on a couple of occasions.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "M, Q, and Miss Moneypenny are all invited to Bond's wedding in OHMSS, and the scene, IIRC, begins with \"Your Royal Highnesses\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'd say that this out-of-office mingling isn't done without knowledge of their real names.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Furthermore, M is often a well known political appointee just like the head of the real MI6.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The first M was a Sir Miles Messervy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "James Bond too has an alias within MI6—he is 007.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I don't think/consider Moneypenny to be a codename.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(The question of why Bond does not use an alias outside MI6 is a good one.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "While the correct answer to this is, of course, \"because it's the movies\", there is a rather feeble in-universe explanation for this.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "James Bond's front when he is out on the job is that he is an employee of Universal Exports, a shell company created by MI6.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Presumably, this also explains his frequent travels abroad and general worldliness.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, when this alias does not suit his purposes, he happily takes on other personae such as that of Sir Hilary Bray (OHMSS), James St. John Smythe (aVtaK), et al.)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/3650/coleopterist", "score": 20 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "While one would expect a \"secret agent\" to always use a cover, James Bond is not a secret agent:", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Intelligence organizations have complete and detailed files on him.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Most bad guys know who he is, what kind of firearm he carries, and how he likes his drinks.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The bad guy usually tries to kill Bond as he arrives in town.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "When he investigates someone, he almost always meets them socially first—a gentlemanly introduction perhaps to learn the other side of their persona, or gather information useful to plot later espionage.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "But they always know he is 007 James Bond.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Apparently his actions are reported worldwide in mass media, like when he was \"killed\" in", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "You Only Live Twice .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "If he is any kind of secret agent at all, he is an \"open secret agent\".", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4739/wallyk", "score": 14 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Bond does use an alias in several of the Bond films as detailed in this article ; Movie AliasFrom Russia with Love David SomersetYou Only Live Twice Mr. FisherOn Her Majesty's Secret Service Sir Hilary BrayDiamonds Are Forever", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Peter FranksDiamonds Are Forever Mr. JonesDiamonds Are Forever Klaus HergescheimerDiamonds Are Forever Burt SaxbyThe Man With The Golden Gun Fransisco ScaramangaThe Spy Who Loved Me Robert SterlingA View to a Kill James St. John SmytheA View to a Kill James StockThe Living Daylights", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jerzy BondovThe World Is Not Enough Dr. Mikhal ArkovDie", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Another Day Van BierkCasino Royale Arlington Beech", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4888/Graeme Hunter", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I'm going to throw out my own thoughts.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Wikipedia states that In the first draft of Casino Royale he decided to use the name James Secretan as Bond's cover name while on missions.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This approach was clearly discarded and for several books he keeps the name Bond.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If memory serves however his identity as James Bond and 007 are kept separate so for the most part only a few key members of the secret service are aware of his position within the organisation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the early films this trend is continued although he introduces himself as \"Bond, James Bond", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\" it's very rare that villains are aware of his job.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After Sean Connery's line in the Doctor No (1962) the character was never going to introduce himself any other way!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The franchise is the \"James Bond\" series.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "To have the main character introducing himself using a variety of names in each film (with different actors) would be extremely confusing to first time and casual viewers and watchers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In order to keep the films simple and avoid confusing viewers this approach of keeping his position in MI6 secret rather than his name has been maintained.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In short - James Bond uses his real name because the filmmakers want to maintain the famous name of the character on screen.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "His safety comes from the fact that the people he encounters on his adventures are unaware (except for a few exceptional villains) that he is 007.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/574/Liath", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Interestingly enough, there are other indicators that suggest that \"James Bond\" becomes the name of the new agent designated for the 007 slot, so that would logically provide the alias from his real identity...and anonymity for a few missions until an enemy agency picks up on the name.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, given tech these days, a permanent alias wouldn't do much good anyway, since cameras and databases everywhere are going to verify who he is at light speed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The trick is to just not let people know where you ARE, and that's always been his style, and something that right pisses off his employers regularly.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He just doesn't go through the trouble of the ID when he's expected.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Remember, as the reboot proved, everyone knows his name from the start...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but, quizzically, he's also a new agent in the role, showing the two kills he needed for 00 status.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "M also says \"orphans make the best agents,\" which hints at more than one orphaned naval intelligence officer donning the role.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They're very cagey about the whole thing, but the clues are there.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/9302/Will", "score": 3 } } ]

{ "question": "In the James Bond universe most characters go by a code name M, Q, the various 00s, In Skyfall Silva is a made up name. Others such as Tanner, Robinson and Moneypenny, Trevelyan we're not so sure but we've got no reason to believe they're real. However Bond uses his own name - we've even seen the grave of his parents to confirm this. Why does Bond use his real name and (as far as we know) no one else does?", "title": "Why does James Bond use his real name?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<james-bond>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/11384", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/574/Liath" }

[ [ "James Bond uses his real name because the filmakers want to maintain the famous name of the character on screen.", "In short - James Bond uses his real name because the filmmakers want to maintain the famous name of the character on screen. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "James Bond is not a secret agent. Bad guys know who he is, what kind of firearm he carries, and how he likes his drinks. When he investigates someone, he almost always meets them socially first. If he is any kind of secret agent at all, he is an \"open secret agent\" if not a \"secret agent\" at all. He always meets people socially first, perhaps to learn the other side of their persona.In short - James Bond uses his real name because the filmmakers want to maintain the famous name of the character on screen. " ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "One of Tolkien's themes is the appropriate use of power , and in his universe, power comes from your inner nature .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You cannot—or should not—obtain more power through any artificial system, because that just distorts your nature.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For example, we have Aragorn who usually prevails just by showing up and being all Aragorny.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He doesn't make speeches, he just exudes this natural authority (or even semi-supernatural powers) that make people want to follow him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is nobility, in Tolkien's view—some people are just born better.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Others, like lesser men and Hobbits, have a lower status, but can play their roles with equal faithfulness to this principle.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, what about Gandalf's power?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If you read the supporting materials, you learn that he is really an angelic being clothed as a mortal.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Balrog is a being of the same order.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, in Tolkien's morality, Gandalf can reveal all of his power when in battle with an equal—the Balrog, or Saruman.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In fact, when Gandalf gets his promotion to being the White, he has the natural authority to even cancel Saruman's power.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It would be immoral for Gandalf to use his power directly against lesser beings, even when that would do good.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Instead, he must use his power more indirectly, to convince the people of Middle-Earth to unite.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Saruman is depicted as having succumbed to this temptation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Frustrated with the disunity among the peoples of Middle-Earth, he decided to create an artificial system that would be strong enough to defeat Sauron, namely his industrial revolution around Orthanc, yielding the abomination of the Uruk-Hai.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And as he became interested in power for its own sake, he became a tool of Sauron.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I happened to read this here - Link", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/", "score": 30 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "This question has a very large answer.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Actually, the Valar (powerful angelic beings living in Valinor across the Great Sea) had decided after the Akallabeth (fall of Numenor) to not interfere in Middle Earth directly.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, due to the rising power of Sauron, they sent six to Middle Earth to assist the Free Peoples - first Glorfindel the Elf, and then five Istar (\"Wizards\") who were actually Maiar (lesser angels).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They took the form of old men as they landed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They were Gandalf, Saruman, Radagast, and two Blue Wizards.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They were forbidden from using there true powers by the Valar, as they were NOT to take direct action against Sauron.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Now, the Balrog was not in Sauron's service.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was a fallen Maia in the service of Morgoth (the earlier Dark Lord).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Morgorth's fall had seen most of these devils destroyed, but some survived, and the Balrog, better known as Durin's Bane, hid under Moria.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After being aroused by the Dwarves, it drove them out, and gravitated evil toward itself (including orcs).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Since the Balrog was not allied with Sauron, Gandalf had the permission to use his full strength to destroy it, especially as they had equal powers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That is why he only uses his \"magic\" powers against Durin's Bane.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was due to this restriction on his innate power that Gandalf could not use his powers before, ot to the Fellowship's benefit.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/62077/MiddeEarthHistorian", "score": 9 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Gandalf is both meddeling and hands-off, this is part of what makes him an interesting character.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For instance, for as powerful as he is, don't you think he could have devised a better way to get to Mt. Doom rather than just walking/horse back?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sure, but the journey wasn't up for him to decide, it was for the rest of Middle Earth.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Balrog, if you look into Middle Earth's back history, is actually more related to Gandalf than the rest of the beings on Middle Earth, both having been angelic beings at one point.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Since this balrog was going to interrupt the happenings of Middle Earth Gandalf had to seriously intervene.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Gandalf has always been powerful, but he only expresses that power when absolutely necessary.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/52/DForck42", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Interesting that you should say that.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the books he actually does.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the snow when they were passing over Caradhras, the rest of the Fellowship, tried and failed to make a fire, so Gandalf reluctantly uses his magic to start a roaring fire by which the fellowship could warm themselves.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Gandalf is uneasy for the next few hours because he believes that it will make it easier for the Orcs to track them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "His exact words were: \"I have written 'Gandalf is here' for all to see.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So my understanding, metaphors aside, is that he uses his magic sparingly in fear of being tracked, there are after all, only four good wizards in the world at that time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/19585/Matthew Stevenson", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The Balrog was a powerful magical creature and was a \"foe beyond any of [them]\".", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "In this situation Gandalf had to turn his dials up as it was the only option.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "His mission was to inspire and assist, he was not permitted to take over and fight everyone's battles for them.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1501/Stefan", "score": 4 } } ]

{ "question": "Why did Gandalf only use his magic powers against the Balrog in The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring ? Why not before? Could he have used that kind of firepower earlier to the Fellowship's benefit?", "title": "Why did Gandalf only use his magic powers against the Balrog? Why not before?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><the-lord-of-the-rings><the-fellowship-of-the-ring>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/11702", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4928/user4928" }

[ [ "Gandalfs mission was to inspire and assist, he was not permitted to fight everyon'e battles for them bu the Balrog was a powrful magical creature. So, in this situation Gandalf had to use his full powers.", "His mission was to inspire and assist,he was not permitted to take over and fight everyone's battles for them." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Balrog was a powerful magical creature and a \"foe beyond any of [them]\". Gandalf had to turn his dials up as it was the only option. His mission was to inspire and assist,he was not permitted to take over and fight everyone's battles for them." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Internet searches for Cheesecake Factory waitress salaries range from $27,000-$33000.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This may or may not include tips, but tips are shared with the kitchen.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As you note, Penny freeloads quite a bit.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Her car has had the engine-check light on forever.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Her apartment is not flashy - the elevator hasn't worked in 7 years.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The PhDs across the hall are researchers, not professors, so their salaries may be quite average, and Sheldon keeps a roommate because he needs a driver.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Surely there are plenty of waitresses renting average apartments in California.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Additional Info ( 9/23/13 ) On the episode entitled \"The Cruciferous Vegetable Amplification,\" Penny owes Leonard for several takeout dinners plus a month's rent which comes to \"a little over $1400.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1606/MJ6", "score": 29 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I found a potential answer to how Penny gets by here which explains a bit about California labour law and factors in the tips she would earn while working at the Cheesecake Factory: Just because she is a waitress", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "doesn't mean she doesn't make a decent income.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "I know a waitress at an upscale restaurant that makes considerably more than I do as an engineer.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Let's do a little back of the envelope math: Penny works at the Cheesecake Factory.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "At the Cheesecake Factory, appetizers are around $9, entrees around $15-$20, desserts around $9 and drinks around $6.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'm there periodically and for two people the bill is easily $50-$60, often more.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, let's pretend Penny serves 2 person tables (3-4 is probably a more accurate number).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Let's say she serves 5 tables an hour", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(I think average is 6).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If her Cheesecake Factory is anything like the ones here, it is busy all day.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Cheesecake Factory is very high volume.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Let's say she works full time. ($50 per table)*(15% tip)*(5 tables per hour)*(8 hours per shift)*(5 shifts per week)*(50 weeks per year) =", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "$75,000 per year.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "My understanding is that California requires a minimum salary for tipped employees of $8 an hour.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "That's an extra $16,000 per year.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "So, at a gross income of up to $91,000 per year, Penny would be making more than Howard does.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Now, to be fair, we know that Penny is not very good at her job, so she is probably not doing that well.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/", "score": 11 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "This is a very old TV sitcom question.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In multiple shows the protagonists live in apartments that are way beyond their means.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Often, the apartments are huge or luxurious and in neighborhoods (mainly Manhattan) where the rents are astronomical.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sitcoms are farce, not real life.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The producers create spaces that are visually striking and easy to film around from one point of view; the camera never moves.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She lives beyond her means because theproducers want her to.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "P.S. Notice that the Cheesecake Factory where she works is far more low rent than the restaurant is in real life; because the producers want it that way.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5046/Broglee-or-Broig", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Unlike Sheldon and Leonard, she doesn't have student loan debts.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She doesn't go out much", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and when she does, it's mostly to her job (where she gets a discount).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Her car isn't new and needs repairs, so she's most likely not paying off a car loan.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In comparison, Leonard's crew go to comic cons, buy movie trinkets, stay up with the latest electronics, have nice cars, probably have years of student loan debts, and also eat out for the majority of their meals.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So to live the lifestyle (and probably keep lots of savings)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "that they want, it makes sense for them to have a roommate.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As it's stated in several episodes, Penny mooches off the other characters.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She eats their food and use their wifi.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She seems to live paycheck to paycheck, and doesn't have savings like they do.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I work on tips as a bartender, so I understand the struggle.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/11581/Tiara", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Not to mention that we later find out in season 8 or 9 (when Penny, Leonard, Sheldon & Amy) play a \"truth or dare\" kind of game, that Penny has substantial credit card debt that she was hiding from Leonard.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And there's no way Penny is making anywhere near 90K or even 75K a year.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She might clear 50K if she was working at a really high end restaurant, but she's an indifferent server at a chain restaurant.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/48146/Kelly", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "In The Big Bang Theory , How can Penny afford a one bedroom apartment on a waitresses' salary? She doesn't seem poor and lives off with free food and WiFi, right?", "title": "How can Penny afford a one bedroom apartment on a waitress salary?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<the-big-bang-theory>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/11733", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/" }

[ [ "If Penny works full time she would be making an estimate $75,000 per year plus an extra $16,000 due to the extra $8 per hour for the minimum salary for tipped emplyees . She can eaisly afford her apartment seeing that she's making more than Howard is.", "Just because she is a waitress doesn't mean she doesn't make a decent income. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Just because she is a waitress doesn't mean she doesn't make a decent income. A waitress at an upscale restaurant makes considerably more than I do as an engineer. California requires a minimum salary for tipped employees of $8 an hour. So, at a gross income of up to $91,000 per year, Penny would be making more than Howard does. But, we know that Penny is not very good at her job, so she is probably not doing that well." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Each Jedi uses a lightsaber that works for their own preferences.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For instance, Asoka Tano (in The Clone Wars ) handled a lightsaber differently than most Jedi .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She originally used \"a reverse Shien style grip.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And later \"she crafted a shoto\" to use with it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(The \"Shien\" grip is holding the lightsaber so the blade is on the side of the hand with the little finger, instead of with the thumb, as is usually seen.)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Jedi recognize a number of types of lightsaber combat and each Jedi will work with a style and grip and lightsaber that works best for them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/688/Tango", "score": 17 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Every difference in the configuration—even the length of the saber—produces a different set of advantages and disadvantages.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A double light saber has the distinct tradeoff that pointing one end toward the opponent risks the other end hitting yourself.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Likewise, a single saber of say 20 feet length instead of the usual five or so would be a disadvantage in close quarters: striking the ceiling, walls, etc., causing structure side effects as well as draining energy from the weapon as well as the user.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4739/wallyk", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "As an Epee fencer in the real world, I favoured a weapon with the traditional French style grip (long handle, heavy pomel).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Many people, including my old coach, consider the more modern \"pistol\" grip (short handle, moulded to the hand, no pomel) to be superior, but the french grip gave me access to certain moves which complimented my style and are impossible with the more powerful but more restrictive pistol grip.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Conversely the pistol grip does suit many people's style and they might find my sword hard to hold on to and lacking power in parries.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The same weapon which is a major advantage in the hands of a proponent of one fighting style is a major liability in the hands of someone whose style it does not suit.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/27617/Joseph Rogers", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "An additional thing to the answers above mine, a double lightsaber has less control and requires a lot of spinning.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If handled correctly, it is fierce and offensive, and can be hard to defend against.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But the downside of this fighting style is that there are less options/moves to manoeuver with; since you don't wanna hit yourself with the other end (like wallyk said).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "With that also comes the fact that when spinning, there are also gaps/openings in your defence that a fast enough opponent can use to his advantage.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/461/paddotk", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "A double-bladed lightsaber (saberstaff) isn't an inherently Sith design, but has been long associated with them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One of the reasons that not very many Jedi use it is because it is an exotic weapon that only a few can teach (according to The Jedi Path ).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It also depends on the preferred style of Jedi.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Count Dooku, while a Sith, used a saber with a bent hilt to enhance saber to saber combat.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As poepje said, saberstaff maneuvers generally include a lot of spinning, but this doesn't mean there are gaps in the defence.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In Dynasty of Evil , Darth Bane's apprentice, Darth Zannah, uses a saberstaff to defend against Bane's brute force, creating a nearly impervious defense.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/16467/TwistedBagel", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It looks cool, but it's an inherently terrible design for a weapon.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This design, dominated by a long metal hand grip, is impractical in most senses.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One of the first things an attacker would strike (either on purpose, or accident) would be the center of the weapon, causing it to split in two pieces.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is clearly evidenced by Darth Maul's battle with Obi-Wan Kenobi and Qui-Gon Jinn in episode 1.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "What more, in order for the weapon to continue functioning after being severed (as-in the case of Darth Maul), the weapon would need two of everything (two crystals, two power sources, two on/off buttons, etc...), and they'd have to be placed in perfect symmetry in preparation for the weapon to be cut in two and still function.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This built-in redundancy only adds to the complexity of the weapon, without providing any real additional benefits (you basically are designing it to be cut in half, and hoping that when it does happen, it's right down the middle and not off-center, which would render half of the weapon totally useless).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For these reasons, it's far more practical to carry dual light sabers (with traditional standard grip), or use a single light saber as most Jedi do.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/29262/SnakeDoc", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The double bladed lightsaber is a sith design and that is why nearly all jedi reject it's usage, other then as a training tool.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The double bladed lightsaber is referred as a sith design \"", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Since the time of Exar Kun\"", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "In the book of sith on paqe 85 published in 2013.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/77483/cmac84", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "This question always kept coming to my mind. Why don't they use double light saber to their advantage?", "title": "In Star Wars, why didn't all the Jedi use the double lightsaber like Darth Maul?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<star-wars>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/11853", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/" }

[ [ "The double lightsaber is a sith design and that is why nearly all Jdi reject it's usage, other than as a training tool.", "The double bladed lightsaber is a sith design and that is why nearly all jedi reject it's usage, other then as a training tool. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "The double bladed lightsaber is a sith design and that is why nearly all jedi reject it's usage, other then as a training tool. " ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "When Jor-El jumped to retrieve the codex he stripped off his outer clothes and wore a black \"activity suit\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "My impression was that the SuperSuit was a customised version of this design (notice that many of the Kryptonians did indeed have cloaks).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As to whether it's more modern - that's difficult to answer without knowing the details of Krypton's fashion, there's no reason why it couldn't have been an amalgamation of Krypton/Earth styles.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As to how it appeared on a ship 18,000 years before Clark arrived on earth.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jor-El's consciousness ran the ship, given this was a seeding ship (and could so grow Kryptonians)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "it's not unreasonable to assume that it could clothe, feed and supply them too!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "My assumption was that the ship made the suit to Jor-El's specifications.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/574/Liath", "score": 20 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I personally don't believe the ship created the suit....", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After Jor-El's death, Lara places his clothes (including the family crest or 'S' symbol)in a display case that closes up...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I like to think the superman suit on the 18,000+ year old ship, was the clothing of one of the El family ancestors, that was part of the exploration into the stars and died in the process.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think the suit was just the clothing at the time and was possibly placed into a display/storage case like Jor's was by Lara.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe Kryptonian ceremony of remembrance?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I believe the Consciousness of Jor-El simply 'presented' the suit to Kal rather than creating it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This seemed better to me, as it shows how proud Jor-El is of Kal, to pass the suit down...and how the family crest of 'hope' would mean something worn on Kal...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "a badass protector of earth.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5325/chase", "score": 11 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "A comic was released before the movie in which it was shown that a member of house", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "El (Kara El) was on that space ship which was sent to explore other worlds thousands of years ago but crashed due to damage taken by it during fight between Kara Zor-El and Dev-Em which also explains presence of skeletons of kryptonions whose cryogenic pods were shut down by Dev-Em.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "http://www.ign.com/wikis/man-of-steel/Man_of_Steel_Prequel_Comic", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5479/Nash", "score": 11 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In the movie, Krypton, the invasion on earth, and the archive history all show a similar design in terms of costume.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Many of them have cloaks, as well as symbols and runes prominently displayed.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Being a colonial ship, the Kryptonian craft was shown to be highly developed in terms of provisions and functioning.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Further, Jor-El's consciousness was the one controlling the ship.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Thus, it can be fairly assumed that the suit was 'constructed' by the ship as per Jor-El's programming, which he then presented to Kal-El.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It was Jor-El's key that contained all the coding and consciousness that gave the design to the suit.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It might just be an assumption, but since the Kryptonian technology gave out the idea of simple mechanisms and entities giving rise to complex implementations (the 3D faces or projections etc.)", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "the ship created a suit as per the programmed instructions.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "This also can provide the simple answer to why the suit perfectly fit Kal-El.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1461/coolharsh55", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "When Jor-El is talking to Kal-El in the ships control deck.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Remember, the scene where he's explaining Kryptonian history in 2 minutes or less?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He explains to Kal-El that several ships, \"like this one\" were sent out to explore the stars.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Kryptonian civilization has been around and intact for 1000s of years.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The ship was a colonization ship from a time when they aspired to live among the stars beyond the bounds of Krypton.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I hope that answered your question.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5211/user5211", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Simple.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Like Sirithil stated, but simply put; when Clark placed his key that came with to earth, inside the ship that was already there it uploaded Jor-El's AI and the AI had the ship to make the suit.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5284/trence5", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Jor-El's consciousness was uploaded into the ship's computer by Kal-El's command key.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The AI-that-was", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "-Jor-El used the ship's systems and resources to fabricate the suit while they were walking around talking, at which point he gave it to Kal-El.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The ship was old but functional; Jor-El was not,", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "neither was the AI based on his mind, and the suit was brand-new.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5255/Sirithil", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "In the movie Man of Steel Superman somehow finds his iconic costume in the 20,000 year old ship, which looks more modern than the dress that Jor-El wore. And it bears the symbol of his House. Can anyone explain what such a modern dress (by Krypton's standards) is doing in a 20,000 year old ship?", "title": "What is Superman's costume doing in a 20,000 year old ship?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><man-of-steel><costume><dc-extended-universe>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/12004", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5148/Nemo" }

[ [ "In the movie, Krypton, the invasion on earth, and the archive history all show a similar design in terms of costume. Many of them have cloaks, as well as symbols and runes prominetly displayed. Also, being a colonial ship, the Kryptonian craft was shown to be highly developed in terms of provisions and functioning.", "It can be fairly assumed that the suit was 'constructed' by the ship as per the ship's programming. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "In the movie, Krypton, the invasion on earth, and the archive history all show a similar design in terms of costume. Many of them have cloaks, as well as symbols and runes prominently displayed. Jor-El's consciousness was the one controlling the ship. It can be fairly assumed that the suit was 'constructed' by the ship as per the ship's programming. This also can provide the simple answer to why the suit perfectly fit Kal-El." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Superman is not a killer, however capable he is of the deed, it's never his intention.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In general Zod's case, he knew no other way to stop him but to kill him once he had him in the position to break his neck.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Superman's evolution on earth had rendered him more powerful than Zod, but not as skilled of a fighter.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After seeing no end to the constant bludgeoning between them, it left him with no other choice...and this is why he cried out after doing so.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/3582/BB Stacker", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Zod does say at one point - \"I was born a warrior.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I have had a life of training and adapting\" and he proceeds to hover.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But the point is that, he was still learning to function in Earth's environment whereas Kal has 33 years to do the same thing.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think it is very safe to say Kal was more powerful than Zod.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You may ask, how come the last fight took so long then?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Again, this is the first time Kal is engaging in battle whereas Zod has probably been in numerous battles.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So it was a good match but in the end, adaptability won.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Superman was more powerful than Zod.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In one scene Zor-El says to Zod that his son was twice the man he is.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He also states that due to living on Earth, adapting to Earth's environment, his son has become more powerful.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So Superman had the strength which other Kryptonians didn't have and that is why he could break Zod's neck.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/301/Ankit", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It's just the case of adaptability to earths environment and also evolution.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It made Superman powerful as his skin soaks in the sun's radiation unlike Zod's.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, a human can break a fellow human's neck but", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "not a dinosaur's, similarly a Kryptonian breaks another Kryptonian.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5163/Yasasvee", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "According to the film's official novelisation , Superman was able to break Zod's neck simply because while Kryptonians are far stronger than humans (making it impossible for a human to have snapped Zod's neck), Kryptonians are perfectly capable of inflicting harm on each other .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Note that what look like mere punches and kicks in the earlier fight sequence would have resulted in a human dying instantly .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They fought savagely, hand-to-hand, upon the floor of the station.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Their superhuman blows inflicted damage no human weapon could match.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Indestructible Kryptonian fabric ripped in the struggle.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Vicious kicks and jabs, delivered with Herculean force, left their faces bruised and bloodied.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A fist of steel split Zod’s lip, and he retaliated by driving his knee up into Superman’s chin.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The blow, which would have sent a cast-iron safe into orbit, loosened Superman’s teeth.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He tasted blood.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But Zod’s unreasoning rage made him sloppy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He charged like an animal, lowering his guard long enough for the Man of Steel to deliver an old-fashioned haymaker that sent him flying backward across the terminal.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Zod hit the floor hard, only to discover that Superman had already shot across at super-speed to be there waiting for him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And then the coup de grâce, against a severely beaten enemy...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A little girl sobbed as the beam came closer, now only moments away.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Superman cried out in anguish, knowing he had no other choice.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was Zod’s life—or the lives of innocents.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He marshaled every ounce of strength that remained within him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And then... He snapped Zod’s neck.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "His form went limp, his fiery gaze extinguished instantly.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Superman released the body and let it slump to the floor.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Gazing down at the dead Kryptonian, he was surprised by the peaceful expression on his face.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Superman doesn't kill anyone.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "DC Comics and Christopher Nolan were not convinced with what Goyer and Snyder had come up with but later they approved of that move.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Superman is powerful on Earth than Zod but in many ways Zod is stronger than him.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Superman did not want to kill him because he just wanted to stop him from doing what he wanted to and both of them wanted Krypton to be build", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "but Zod wanted to do it on Earth, killing all humans which Kal-El disapproved of.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5259/Robot Boy", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Kryptonians on earth are immensely powerful, not invincible, not immortal.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Kal-El was able to snap Zod's neck because he alone had the power to do so.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As to why Zod could not do it-", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It requires great skill and power to twist someone's neck.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This cannot be done easily and requires some sort of a lock on the opponent.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Kal-El never had any fight experience, while Zod was a veteran.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Though their powers were on a similar level, Kal-El would always be more powerful due to the long exposure of sun on his body.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Zod was barely granted powers and he could take on Superman.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "While Kal-El always refrained from his powers at a mental level.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The scene where Zod tries to kill those people with his eye-lasers, sent Kal-El into a mental desperation to stop him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Not wanting to be a repeat of the situation where Uncle Kent died, Kal-El used all he had to try and stop Zod.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1461/coolharsh55", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think them being indoors could be significant, in direct sunlight they seem evenly matched but out of the sun Superman would retain his powers whereas Zod would diminish slightly and become vulnerable.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is what I'm hoping, otherwise he should've snapped all their necks before they made a real mess of Earth!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5220/Casualdeyna", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "At the end of Man of Steel , Superman breaks the neck of General Zod. My question is, how could he do that so easily? And why did none of the Kryptonians think about doing that to him? Especially, considering that they are a lot more ruthless and don't pay attention to morality, etc. To be honest, I was a little confused when Superman broke Zod's neck because I thought it is not possible.", "title": "How did the final confrontation in Man of Steel get resolved?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><man-of-steel><dc-extended-universe>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/12032", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5159/BreakALeg" }

[ [ "Uper man doesn't really want to kill him, also because they both wanted to build Krypton. But, Zod wanted to build Krypton on earth, killing all humans which Kal-El disapproved of. ", "DC Comics and Christopher Nolan were not convinced with what Goyer and Snyder had come up with." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Superman doesn't kill anyone. DC Comics and Christopher Nolan were not convinced with what Goyer and Snyder had come up with. Superman is more powerful on Earth than Zod but in many ways Zod is stronger than him." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Yes they are all connected.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Despite Hank's outward appearance of nonchalance, the incident with Tuco shook him a lot.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was probably Hank's first really violent fire fight and that left him suffering from a form of post traumatic stress disorder.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He becomes more fearful and more fearful of further violence.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Tuco's grill was a grisly reminder of all the fear he went through, which was something he didn't want to relive anymore.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But fearful for his reputation as a tough cop, he outwardly accepts the souvenir only to dispose of it in secret later on.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hank's secret reluctance to take up the position in the Mexican border is also another indication of this.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/29/System Down", "score": 40 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "To add, I would also say that Tuco's grill represents the change that Hank refuses to go through.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hence, why he throws it, and for that matter, El Paso in the river.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Heisenberg calls him and (if I'm not getting into spoiler territory), by extension death calls for him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So in a small way, I come to see Tuco's grill as both a grizzly reminder not only to the violence inflicted upon Hank, but the violence that he has inflicted on others.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe the grill represents the tainted idea of being rewarded?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I mean, Hank killed Tuco and yet, instead of having cuffs slapped on his wrists, people clap their hands on his back.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Good job, Hank\", \"Way to get that bastard!\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": ".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But at the end of the day, Hank took a life, and I think that haunts him throughout the series.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He constantly fears his own fate, verbally and emotionally (its why he has anxiety/panic attacks?)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "because he regrets his own thirst and actions for and towards violence.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/6955/mymotherthescorpion", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I see the grill as a literary device which highlights the basic incompatibility between Hank and his wife.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In a prior episode she steals the silver tiara, with no guilt, and gives it away as a gift.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The tiara is a tiny silver semi circle, similar to Tuco's gold semi circular grill.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In Hanks case however he is the recipient of this gift which eventually elicits a panic attack.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Neither Hank nor his wife keep their precious metal arc - she blithely gives hers away, he casts his off with revulsion.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/21288/Trish", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The prior answers are good, but I wanted to point out a couple of other things.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "First, as one of the answers noted, the \"grill\" was not a trophy sought by Hank, but rather something that was given to him by his colleagues.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Second, it seemed to me that Tuco was actually killed by the gunshot Tuco suffered during the strugggle with Jesse, fired by Jesse from Tuco's own gun before Hank arrived on the scene.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Although Tuco was still alive during the gunfight with Hank, it was not clear that Hank even hit Tuco and Hank likely would have died had Tuco not been shot prior to Hank showing up.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think Hank felt that the trophy was not deserved.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/20516/gus", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Anyone who's seen Breaking Bad should know the answer, this is a fact not a guess, the reason why Hank throws the grill into the river was because it was a constant reminder of how close he came to death, and how scared he was in the beginning of this scene.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He approached Tuco as if he was Jesse Pinkman walking all cocky \"Mr. Pinkman\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": ", he says with a smile on his face", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but then when he found out it who it was, s", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "*** got real pretty quick, he turned that frown upside down because he knew how dangerous Tuco was and Tuco didn't even have a gun in his hands and he was already wearing a bullet in his stomach.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hank, on the other hand, did have a gun on him but he was still shittin'.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hank's whole career", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "he has the backup; his partner and his Squad of DEA soldiers that's why he always act so badass and tough because he basically has a military backing him up as he chases down skinny weak little meth heads, because in Albuquerque that's all there is", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": ", it's not hard up there.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That gunfight he went through was a real traumatic day in his life, it was the first time shit ever got real", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and he couldn't handle it", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "that's why when he got promoted to go to El Paso", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "he knew that's where the real gangsters were, and he started having panic attacks, he couldn't handle it and that's why he got into a fight at the bar.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He was trying to toughen himself up, he was embarrassed and ashamed that he really wasn't the tough guy", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "he thought he was.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I can't tell you how many hints and clues there are in scenes where they straight out reveal this out", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "right, when Skyler asks Marie how's Hank doing after the gunfight Marie replies you know", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hank", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "he's indestructible or something like that, this is a no-brainer I can go hours explaining evidence that supports this fact.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/50644/Justin Lapan", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I believe Hank disposes of the grill because it is a constant reminder of his near death experience, as well as rage that Tuco wasn't the man distributing the Blue Meth.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/51544/SchraderBrew", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "At the end of S2E5 of Breaking Bad (\"Breakage\"), Hank throws Tuco's 'grill' he claimed as a trophy upon killing him, into a river. What motivated him to do this? This episode shows Hank: get a promotion and have some sort of an episode shortly thereafter in an elevator; injure himself while bottling beer; get frightened by loud bangs that turn out to be beer bottles exploding. Is this all interconnected?", "title": "Why does Hank throw Tuco's 'grill' into the river?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<breaking-bad>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/12267", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/850/stevvve" }

[ [ "The reason why Hank throws the grill into the river is because it was a constant reminder of how close he came to death.", "Hank throws the grill into the river as a constant reminder of how close he came to death." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Hank throws the grill into the river as a constant reminder of how close he came to death. Anyone who's seen Breaking Bad should know the answer." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "It is officially male! After reading through the entirety of the Bulbapedia Article on Ash's Pikachu, specifically the Trivia section , it is confirmed that Ash's Pikachu is in fact male: In", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Where No Togepi Has Gone Before!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "it was confirmed that Pikachu is male.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "His physical appearance could not be used as proof, since gender differences were not implemented until after he had debuted in the anime.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Further to Mary Jo Finch's answer, there is another recent episode ( Beauties Battling for Pride and Prestige! )", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "where Pikachu disguises himself as a female, seen here:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Pokémon the anime started in 1997.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Gender differences in a pokémon species was added in 1999, in Generation 2 of the games.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Togepi episode was 2009, the Beauties episode was 2012.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "12 years to find out Pikachu is male.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4174/Robotnik", "score": 22 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "According to Wikipedia , there are male and female Pikachu: Standing 1.04 ft (0.4m)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "tall, Pikachu are mouse-like creatures, and were the first \"Electric-type\" Pokémon created, their design intended to revolve around the concept of electricity.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They appear as mouse-like creatures that have short, yellow fur with brown markings covering their backs and parts of their lightning bolt shaped tails.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They have black-tipped, pointed ears and red circular pouches on their cheeks, which can spark with electricity.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In Pokémon Diamond and Pearl , gender differences were introduced; a female Pikachu now has an indent at the end of its tail, giving it a heart-shaped appearance.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This evidence comes from the game.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I cannot find evidence of a female Pikachu in the television series, but presumably since they are from the same franchise, it would hold that Ash's Pikachu is male.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1606/MJ6", "score": 21 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In Pokemon black and white, episode 1-7 a female snivy uses attract on pikachu and it worked.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Right after a character named iris says \"it worked on pikachu", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so snivy has to be a girl!\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And then later in the show says \"attract only works on Pokemon of the opposite gender\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/24071/Mattman2312", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Ash's Pikachu is female because in one episode of Pokemon Black and White a female Pokemon used attract on Pikachu, but it doesn't work.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the game, when Pokemon A uses the move Attract on Pokemon B, if Pokemon B is the opposite gender of Pokemon A, Pokemon B gains the status effect Infatuate, which causes their attacks to miss 50% of the time until the status effect is removed (the simplest method being to simply switch Pokemon B with another Pokemon from the trainer's roster).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The only qualifier for Attract to work or fail is the gender of the Pokemon the attack is used on.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Both Pokemon do not need to be the same species.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/9235/A guy that knows Pokémon", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Female Pikachus have heart-shaped lightning bolt tails while male Pikachus have lightning bolt tails without the heart-shaped end.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Since Ash's Pikachu has ho heart shape, he's a boy.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/23073/Ash Ketchup", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "pikachu is male because in black and white the anime just like all of the other male pokemon pikachu is attracted to emolga.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also its tail does not have a heart.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/28293/user28293", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It's a male.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I know because female Pikachus have a heart like tail while male Pikachus don't.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's very obvious if you have played a Pokémon game.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Besides, everybody who has played Pokémon Alpha Sapphire or Pokémon Omega Ruby knows that Cosplay Pikachu is a female, but can dress up as a boy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In a quick answer, Ash's Pikachu is a male.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/22278/Joed", "score": 0 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "\"In 'Where No Togepi Has Gone Before!'", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "it was confirmed that Pikachu is male.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "His physical appearance could not be used as proof, since gender differences were not implemented until after he had debuted in the anime.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Came from the wiki.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "May not be the best source", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but it's pretty darn accurate in most cases.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He is also referred to as 'he' and not 'she'.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Not only that but one can assume Pikachu is a male because the show is mostly aimed and viewed by males.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There were also some game events where ash's pikachu would be distributed, and he is a male in all distributes of the events.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/26554/Pikagen", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "I was recently having a discussion about Pokémon, and it came up that none of us were sure whether Ash's Pikachu in the series was male or female. Some (myself included) always thought it was male, whereas others could've sworn it was female. Was there ever any canon evidence to point in one direction or another?", "title": "Is Pikachu's gender ever confirmed?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<character><pokemon>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/12382", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4174/Robotnik" }

[ [ "Ash's Pikachu was male seeing as he did not have a heart-shaped lightning bolt tail, which female Pikachus have.", "Female Pikachus have heart-shaped lightning bolt tails, while male Pikachu have lightning bolt tail without the heart." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Female Pikachus have heart-shaped lightning bolt tails, while male Pikachu have lightning bolt tail without the heart." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Javert reveals his reasons in the song he sings when he commits suicide.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And must I now begin to doubt, who never doubted all these years/", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "My heart is stone and still it trembles/", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The world I have known is lost in shadows/", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Is he from Heaven or from Hell?/ And", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "does he know, that granting me my life today, this man has killed me even so...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I am reaching", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but I fall and the stars are black and", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "cold/", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As I stare it to the void/ to a world that cannot hold", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'll escape now from that world, from the world of Jean Valjean/", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There is nowhere", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I can turn/", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There is no way to go on.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Javert kills himself because the mercy shown to him by Jean Valjean", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so disrupts his black and white world view that he cannot bear to live in a world he no longer understands.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One of the key themes in the work is that those who cannot adapt are destroyed (Javert, Fantine, Enjolras), while those who are flexible thrive (Thénardier).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It is really a very cynical work when you get down to it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1326/DQdlM", "score": 14 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Javert was a man of big integrity and he believed fully in the law and the penalty system.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He followed and enforced the law to the letter.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "So when he realized that Val Jean was doing more good as a free man that he would have done in jail he find himself with a dilemma.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He can't let him free because he would betray his integrity, but also he can't stop him because he would prevent him from protecting good people.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "So he found the only solution to his inner fight.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "If he dies Val Jean is free to go and he would not have to betray the law.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "From wikipedia : When Valjean saves his life, Javert finds himself unable to reconcile his life's work pursuing criminals with the nobility and justice shown him by the man he thought was a criminal, and takes his own life by jumping off a bridge into the river Seine.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5612/Maurizio In denmark", "score": 9 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The OP has identified some of the reasons for Javert's suicide.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He does sing \"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Damned if I'll live in the debt of a thief!\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but the central reason is the conflict created in his mind by Valjean's actions.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He shows this when he sings \"And must I now begin to doubt, who never doubted all these years.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I myself have found this difficult to reconcile from a modern western perspective.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One must realize, though, that Javert has spent his life fighting the internal shame of his low birth (\"I was born inside a jail...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I am from the gutter too.\") with a strict adherence to the law.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In differentiating himself from the \"scum\" he grew up seeing he has created an inflexible dichotomy between righteous and evil men and left himself unable to see that a person can cross that divide (\"Men like you can never change\").", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He was unable to see the good and bad in every man and did not believe a person could make such a fundamental change.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And really, men dealing with change is what the entire story is about.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The revolutionary change of 19th century France; Marius' struggle with his changing ideals; Valjean's change from criminal to upright citizen.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Each character was dealing with the internal struggle created by these changes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Javert could not come to terms with it and the contradictions it presents.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "All of this is shown in the lyrics but you have to really pay attention to the details of what Javert is saying.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Some of these details are exposed during the confrontation duet where both characters are singing simultaneously and can be tough to pick out.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I must commend the writers of the musical for managing to bring out so many of Victor Hugo's complex characters.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "To take a 1200+ page book and turn it into a 2 1/2 hour play is a real accomplishment.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/19836/Tom", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Victor Hugo's piece is a very interesting piece theologically, especially looking a Javert's death.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Javert represents the Old Testament, the Torah.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He lives the law, and he is the law.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jean Valjean represents the new law, the New Testament, the law of love and mercy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Just as in the Bible, both laws cannot coexist; one has to be done away with, one has to die.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As Jesus died on the cross, he took with him the Old Law, giving us the new law of love and mercy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As Valjean forgives and shows grace and mercy to Javert, he lays the new law of love and mercy, thus the old law (Javert) has to die.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/33856/Shannon Riech Williams", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "There's a passage in the book.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Javert encounters a dilemma: if Javert were to take Valjean into custody, he would betray the humane law since Valjean saved Javert in the exact same circumstance before; if Javert were to let Valjean go, Javert would shirk his duty as a police inspector that he has always staunchly believed in.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Javert finds an inconsistency in the logic about the rule of law and his role as a police inspector.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Javert lets Valjean go, but he cannot reconcile the inconsistency between what he just did according to the humane law and his role and belief as a police inspector that carries out the social law.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This inconsistency drives him to suicide.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I believe the story takes place during Napoleon III, another rebellion against his reign that fails.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/53777/Austin Mun", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "In the film Les Misérables , Javert kills himself after letting Valjean pass. Why did he commit suicide? Was it because he felt he had failed? Was it because he didn't want to be indebted to a criminal? Was it because he realised he'd been pursuing a good man? I can see these reasons upsetting him but not enough to take his own life!", "title": "What was the reason for Javert's decision?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><character><les-miserables>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/13441", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/574/Liath" }

[ [ "Javert was a man of great integrity, who obeyed and enforced the law. So, when he realised that Val Jean was helping people and arresting him would prevent him from doing that he found himself in a dilemma. One that could only be solsved, without breaking the law but also doing the right thing, by killing himself.", "Javert was a man of big integrity and he believed fully in the law and the penalty system. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Javert was a man of big integrity and he believed fully in the law and the penalty system. When he realized that Val Jean was doing more good as a free man that he would have done in jail he find himself with a dilemma. So he found the only solution to his inner fight. If he dies Val Jean is free to go and he would not have to betray the law. He takes his own life by jumping off a bridge into the river Seine." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "This is all just speculation, but some points to consider: How many bottles of this “petrol” would be required to get to 88 mph?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "To what degree is this “petrol” compatible with combustion engines from 1985?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There were no highways back then, where could you find a place to accelerate to the required speed?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(If I remember correctly, flight was not an option.)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/282/svick", "score": 21 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "They were going to try alternative combustible liquids.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The first they tried was alcohol.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The strongest one the could buy from the local bartender if I remember correctly.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "With that the intake manifold to blew out and then it would have taken about a month to repair it according to Doc.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "They didn't have the time for that since they were planning to leave before the next Monday to avoid Doc's death.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Probably if they didn't blow the intake manifold they would have tried also Petrol eventually.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5612/Maurizio In denmark", "score": 13 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Because that wouldn't make a good movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In reality they could have burned Kerosene that no doubt has a higher octane rating (150) than petrol of the time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "With a low octane rating, they wouldn't have gotten to 88mph because the knock sensors would have cut timing and put the car in limp mode.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4331/DustinDavis", "score": 10 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Petrol wasn't invented until 1870 or 1871 and it seems likely it was a small potatoes British business.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "While I don't doubt that some of their product made it to the eastern U.S., it seems very unlikely", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "it was well distributed and probably would not have made it to the Wild West, especially California.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Even if it was sold in San Francisco, what are the chances it would have made it to Hill Valley?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As portrayed, the town had made it to the iron age, but that was about it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4739/wallyk", "score": 9 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Part of the issue was that they had a time limit.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Doc (and then Marty) was going to be murdered in a week.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They didn't have time to do much more than try what they had available to them locally.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/52449/Jamie Z", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "There was a refined petroleum product called \"petrol\" available as far back as 1870 which was used (among other things) to kill lice nits and as a solvent. When internal combustion engines were being developed, this product, unchanged, was found to be an ideal fuel. Why couldn't Doc and Marty have bought some of that to refill the DeLorean?", "title": "Why didn't Doc and Marty buy \"petrol\" in 1885?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<back-to-the-future>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/13448", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/497/JoelFan" }

[ [ "Their plan was to leave before the upcoming Monday to avoid Doc's death but they had broken the intake manifold, which would have taken about a month to repair. So, if the intake manifold wasn't broken they most probably would have tried to use Petrol.", "They were going to try alternative combustible liquids. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "They were going to try alternative combustible liquids. The first they tried was alcohol. With that the intake manifold to blew out and then it would have taken about a month to repair it according to Doc." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "The existance of www.ericaalbright.com not withstanding, the name of the girl portrayed as \"Erica Albright\" in the film was certainly not \"Erica Albright\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sorkin basically admits to this in a few interviews, where he claims to have changed three specific names and that Erica's was one of those.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The person who most fits that character's depiction is a girl names Jessica Alona, but literally all anyone knows about her publicly is that Zuckerberg insulted her on LiveJournal in a drunken rant that seems to have been the start of FaceMash.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The actual LiveJournal post is still available, and you can clearly see the original name in the source code for the famous \"bitch\" post: http://www.slashfilm.com/the-truth-behind-the-social-network/ Note that this directly contradicts the statements made on the Erica Albright web site, which suggests that either 1) that's a fake web page, or 2)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jessica Alona has decided to go with Sorkin's pseudonym to maintain her own identity.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "According to the slashfilm article, as of late 2010, no one named Jessica Alona had come forward to identify herself as the subject of that particular blog post.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, nothing in that post necessarily claims that Zuckerberg was dating Mrs. Alona, merely that she had somehow angered him, but that does seem most likely.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Note that he did not begin dating his current wife until after Facebook was already up and running, which would likely have been years after any possible relationship with the girl that inspired Facebook in the first place.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1146/KutuluMike", "score": 16 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "EricaAlbright.com is a hoax web site.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It is just someone trying to get attention on the Internet with a \"famous\" name.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Erica Albright is a fictitious person created for the sake of drama, because movies need a romantic plot to make them more interesting to some audience.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "From http://ericaalbright.com/about/ : ...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "By the way, everything on this website is fictional and completely made up.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This website is for entertainment only and has no association with Mark Zuckerberg, Facebook, or Mark’s girlfriend depicted on the movie, The Social Network.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/7945/Sasha", "score": 10 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "You can find your answer on ericaalbright.com : I know that Mark has another girlfriend and the two of them seem very happy together.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I’ve actually met her a few times when Mark and I were dating", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and she’s very nice.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But since “The Social Network” came out, people are still asking me if him and I are going to get back together.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So for once and for all, I’m going to set the record straight.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I do not want to get back together with Mark.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Not that there is anything wrong with him", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I just don’t have much in common with him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We do talk every once in a while", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but we’re not Facebook friends or anything.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I’m not", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "friends on FB with him mainly because I don’t want a gazillion friends on FB.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(I’m not Erica Albright on FB)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A lot of you have been writing to me and...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So definitely a real person (unless the website is a hoax). EDIT (because of further reading on the website) ...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So usually I don’t read all the blogs and news sites that talk about ‘The Social Network’, but today, one just caught my attention.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe I’m being overly sensitive today for some reason", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but I just need to get a few things out in the open.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The movie ‘The Social Network’ really depicts me as being a b*tch.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yeah, I know that Mark wrote that in in public HTML code which is now totally public, but I’m not really a b*tch!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Do you want to know the REAL story about me, the EX Girlfriend of Mark Zuckerberg?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Even though it is really cool that someone played ME in a movie, I am completely the opposite of how I am depicted in the movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I am smart, funny, sweet (although I do have a naughty side), and I was really in LOVE with...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5391/Pᴀᴜʟsᴛᴇʀ2", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "While not having any background information if she really existed in the way written in the movie/book or how his relationship with Priscilla actually was, I'll attempt an answer based on mere reason.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'd say his relationship to Priscilla maybe didn't provide the same conflicts as his (maybe fictitious) relationship with Erica .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "While it would be wrong to say he's done everything just because of Erica , his break-up with her still serves as a major background influence to his character and the movie's story.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "See this related question and this one for some insight on her role in the movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe Priscilla just didn't provide those interesting developments for the story.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If Erica was not real, then you have more freedom in fitting her to the story of the movie than if she had been real, like Priscilla .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "EDIT:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Seeing Paulster2 's answer, she was indeed real.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But I still stand by my reasoning, that his unsuccessful relationship with Erica was probably prefered by the writers for providing more conflict to the story and the character.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In fact the movie (as well as the book) doesn't seem to be an accurate (or at least not complete) rendition of the real circumstances and characters anyway.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So leaving out a character or emphasizing another one for the sake of story-telling isn't that unreasonable.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/49/Napoleon Wilson", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Mark did an interview and a question concerning the movie came up.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He denies that the person in the movie exists at all:", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/20760/Tad Cornell", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "In the film The Social Network Mark breaks up with Erica Albright early on, this (through a series of steps) leads to him creating The Facebook. However in real life Mark is married to Priscilla Chan who he met at Jewish fraternity at Harvard University in 2003 (Facebook was founded in 2004). Does Erica Albright exist? If not why is she featured in the film and not Priscilla Chan?", "title": "Was Erica Albright real?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<the-social-network>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/13794", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/574/Liath" }

[ [ "During an interview Mark denied that Erica Albright Exists.", "Mark denied that the person in the movie exists at all" ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Mark at his interview and a question concerning the movie came up he denied that the person in the movie exists at all" ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Aside from all the sources that may already corroborate that Prison Break has reached its ending in totality, e.g., IMDB/Wikipedia, it seems exceedingly unlikely that we would see Michael Scofield in action again, as the final episode of Prison break tells us: Michael hears of the bounty and devises plans for Sara's escape.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the end, knowing that he is dying from a brain tumor, Michael sacrifices himself for his brother, wife and child.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "- Wikipedia", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We don't see him die, but we do see Sara and his child at his gravestone, assuredly marking his demise.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When we also consider all the other loose ends tied up (other prisoners dying, Lincoln's absolution, deconstruction of 'The Company'), it lends for little further possible plot to continue on.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Update :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Prison break going to be revived", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One of these unanswered questions that likely immediately jumps to mind is: [", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "SPOILER ALERT] how in the world is Michael still alive?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For those that don’t know, “Prison Break” ended with a made for TV movie in which the character sacrifices himself in order to save Lincoln, Sarah (Sara Tancredi) and her unborn child.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "According to Deadline, the 10-episode event series revival will mostly ignore the events of this finale, but will provide a “logical explanation” as to why the character is alive.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, even if they explain how he survived his death, writers also need to explain how he survived his terminal brain tumor.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1125/hexparrot", "score": 9 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "No.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The the show is over and there are no plans for a season 5.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4128/Colin D", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "\"Prison Break\", a television series on the Fox Network, ended its run in 2009, after 4 seasons.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It concerned the breakout of a group of felons from a prison in Chicago, and the ensuing run to evade capture by the FBI and international agents.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It starred: Wentworth Miller, who has gone on to other roles, though, decidedly few; Dominic Purcell who played his incarcerated brother, who has moved into motion pictures in a number of action thrillers, and guest television spots; Robert Knepper, who had a number of television projects since Prison Break, also a number of films; William Fichtner, who played the FBI agent in pursuit, has a currently-active television series \"Crossing Lines\", and a number of film roles since.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Long story short, I don't think the show \"Prison Break\" is on anyone's radar for a comeback.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "UPDATE:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Today, 2015/01/18, it was revealed", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "that : ...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "“There is some speculation in the press about Prison Break, which honestly was slightly news to us….", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Although we’ve made it clear over the years to the studio that we would bring Prison Break back in a heartbeat...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It’s probably the perfect event series.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If our old partners in that show are interested, that would be great.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But at the moment, we have nothing else to report.”", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Purcell and Miller are currently recurring in their roles as villains Heat Wave and Captain Cold on The Flash on The CW.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That series was renewed for a second season earlier this week.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/304/wbogacz", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Submitting this as a NEW answer, since it clearly contradicts the first, based on information just received - after an additional 2 years.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "According to information released August 6, 2015, Prison Break will be back for a season of 10 further episodes.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "From PopSugar :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Cochairman Dana Walden added that the reboot will be \"a bit of a sequel\" that picks up with the characters several years after the events of the final season of the show.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "\"It will address some questions that were set up at the end of the series,\" she said, and though she didn't confirm who besides Purcell and Miller would be back, she teased that \"some of the iconic characters from that show will be back.\"", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Though there's no word on when it will come back, we do know the return is slated to be a 10-episode arc.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/304/wbogacz", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Season 5 is scheduled to air on Tuesdays, starting April 4 this year.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Source", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/19472/CinCout", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "I am a big fan of \"Prison Break\" and want Michael Scofield in action again. So please can anybody tell me, will I be able to see the gang again in action or not? Are there any plans for Season 5?", "title": "Will there be any more seasons of \"Prison Break\"?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<prison-break>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/13954", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/6168/Neelesh Pandey" }

[ [ "Acoording to information released on August 6th, 2015, Prison Break will be back for another season. Cochairman Dana Walden teased that '' some of the iconic charecters from that show will be back.''.", "Prison Break will return for a season of 10 further episodes." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Prison Break will return for a season of 10 further episodes. Cochairman calls reboot \"a bit of a sequel\" \"Some of the iconic characters from that show will be back. \"It will address some questions that were set up at the end of the series\" " ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "In one instance, Salas says he can always fight for money, but his mother reprimands him, telling him not to be like his father.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Leon also makes a reference to Salas' father.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Salas looks confused, as he thought his father died in a fight.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(Source: www.themoviespoiler.com )", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Both point indicated that Salas father's death is a mystery and only his wife and Leon know about it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It kept mystery in the film till end.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As per intime.wikia.com Wills parents are both timed out.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1190/Ankit Sharma", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I just watched this movie and recall Raymond Leon saying something to the affect that Will's father's crime was giving time away.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "At another point in the movie, Will tells Sylvia he believes his father was murdered.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I pulled these quotes from http://www.moviequotesandmore.com/in-time-movie-quotes-1.html [talking on the phone]", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Raymond Leon:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hello, Will.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "How much do you want?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Will Salas: A thousand years.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Raymond Leon:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You'll never live to spend it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Will Salas:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Then distribute it to the Timelines in Dayton.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Do it by sunrise tomorrow and she can go home.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Raymond Leon:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Well, I'm afraid for you, Will.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You keep talking like him, you're gonna die like him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Will Salas:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hey, my father died in fight trying to take a man's time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Raymond Leon:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Oh, no.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "His crime wasn't taking time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He was doing something far more dangerous.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Please don't make your father's mistake.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sylvia Weis:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Where's your family?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Will Salas:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "My mother timed out.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sylvia Weis:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is her dress?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Will Salas:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yeah.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sylvia Weis:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "What about your father?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Will Salas: Died when I was a boy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He was a fighter, strong arm.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He wasn't the strongest, but he knew how to win.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sylvia Weis:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "How do you win?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Will Salas:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'll show you.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "[he takes her arm]", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Will Salas:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "What you do is you let them have the upper hand, and then he let his time go all the way down because he knew that when you were down to your last seconds, and they think it's over, they start watching your clock and forget to watch their own.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sylvia Weis:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He died in a fight?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Will Salas:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think he was killed for giving away what he won.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He wasn't just giving them time, he was giving them hope.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/9427/Jackson", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "There is a deleted scene where Leon explicitly states that his crime was giving away time and a flashback shows the timekeepers timing him out to \"correct the unbalance\" (link may expire)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/40651/Tim", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I believe that Leon is Wills father.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "throughout the film will's father is a very mysterious figure and not much about him is known.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The things we do know are that he was once in the ghetto, and that he was known for giving away his own time.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "So it can be assumed that Will's father is someone who does what thinks is best for the world in an unselfish manner.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "I believe that is also what drove him to become a timekeeper.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "This is just a theory", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "let me know what you guys think!", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/15279/jim carry", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "There is something between Fortis and Raymon Leon.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think they are brothers or atleast grew up as friends.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I wonder if fortis had somrthing to do with wills dad.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/28339/Sin", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "In the movie In Time , when Timekeeper Raymond Leon meets main character Will Salas for the first time, he teases him by talking about Will's father who was too young to know him when he died. He also implies he knows what really happened to him, but we never learn what. What happened to Will's father?", "title": "What happened to Will Salas' father?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><in-time>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/14271", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/2089/wip" }

[ [ "This is just my personal theory, but I believe that Leon is Wills father. We don't know much about Will's father but what we do know is that he was once in the ghetto and was kown for giving away his own time. Meaning, he did what was best for the world in an unselfish manner which I believe drove him to become a timekeeper.", "So it can be assumed that Will's father is someone who does what thinks is best for the world in an unselfish manner." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Leon is Wills father. Throughout the film will's father is a very mysterious figure. The things we do know are that he was once in the ghetto. So it can be assumed that Will's father is someone who does what thinks is best for the world in an unselfish manner." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Does it really matter?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The police are probably going to find it and confiscate if it's on the meth lab compound.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Anyway, these guys must have sold some meth by then and they have more than the amount they stole from Walt.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But now that nobody from the crew is alive to tell anyone where they hid the money, it doesn't really matter.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It might even be buried somewhere in the desert like in \"To'hajiilee,\" in which case it will slowly fade away inside the container.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5788/user1306322", "score": 18 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Another \"it doesn't matter\" answer, to accompany the excellent ones already written.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The key thing for me is that this action demonstrates that finally Walt doesn't care about the money.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Its the first time in the entire series that Walt doesn't care about maximizing his return.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Even back in Season 2 when they were selling small quantities via Badger and Skinny Pete, Walt got upset when his cut was $1k light when Skinny Pete was robbed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There could be several reasons why he doesn't care - he's been injured and knows he is likely to die.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However I think he went into this situation for two main reasons: Revenge.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jack & Todd stole 80% of his money and killed Hank and Steve.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was this action that finally destroyed Walt's chance to simply return to his family.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "To protect his family from being threatened by Jack & Todd I think he knew it was risky and possibly might result in his death - but he had to do as much damage as possible to Jack and his crew.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He also clearly has paternal feelings towards Jesse, and when he sees what they've done to him this must also make him angry.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When faced with a choice of killing Jack and taking his revenge or possibly retrieving his cash - there is no choice as far as he is concerned.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/40/iandotkelly", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It doesn't matter.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Walt had the option of finding out where the money was, but he didn't need it.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He ensured that his son would get nearly $10 million in less than a year, which he'd likely use to help out his sister and mother (and probably Marie as well), so Walt didn't need the rest of the money anymore, which is why he shot Jack as Jack started to try and talk his way out of the situation.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/260/Barry Hammer", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It's never explicitly answered, within the series.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "My expectation would be that, having found the meth lab, the authorities would then leave no stone unturned in pursuit of their money.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Whether it was earned from Jack & his crew cooking/dealing meth or not, would've made little difference.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Living people can contest the seizure, but dead men don't talk.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Given they were not rocket scientists, the money probably would not have remained hidden for long under such intense searching.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Following that line of reasoning, the government found & confiscated the remainder of the 6 barrels of money.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/566/Andrew Thompson", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Answering the question which was asked : Probably buried at another desert location known only to Jack and the neo-Nazis who where then murdered by Walt.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The money will never be found and it may eventually become part of Albuquerque are lore as a \"buried treasure.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\" The neo-Nazis would have dry foolish to have buried the money at the same site where they were also still cooking meth.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Or it may be forgotten as Walt is also dead", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": ", Jesse and Saul are on the run and Huell and Kuby are probably doing the same.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The main characters of the series are all also deceased or distracted and they will likely have forgotten that the money ever existed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/7390/Mistah Mix", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "So, Breaking Bad has finished. In the final episode Walt killed Jack, when he started to talk about money. But where is Walt's money, which Jack has stolen?", "title": "Where is Walt's money?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<breaking-bad>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/14279", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/6294/dlion" }

[ [ "Walt had the option of finding out where the money was, but he didn't need it. He ensured that his son would get nearly $10 million in less than a year. So he shot Jack as Jack started to try and talk his way out of the situation.", "Walt had the option of finding out where the money was, but he didn't need it. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Walt had the option of finding out where the money was, but he didn't need it. He ensured that his son would get nearly $10 million in less than a year. So he shot Jack as Jack started to try and talk his way out of the situation." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "One of the known method for this is Reduced gravity aircraft , unofficial nickname vomit comet .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "KC-135A known as NASA 930 was used in the movie Apollo 13 .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Cecil said that in 2001: A Space Odyssey , huge rotating sets are used, while the actor remained more or less stationary.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's not that realistic in looks but cheaper as compare to vomit comet.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Wire and green screen combination are also used sometimes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1190/Ankit Sharma", "score": 25 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Inception is well known for simulating all of its zero/reduced gravity scenes without CG.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There is a behind the scenes documentary where the effects team detail the various method they use – and crucially how different shots within a sequence use different methods.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This means there's never a single \"trick\" that the eye can catch to break the immersion.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Christopher Nolan:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We did it through a number of different rigs and in the final edit what you see is shot to shot to shot it tends to be a different orientation and a completely different rig in each shot", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and I think that more than anything else really stops the audience of seeing the trick of how this scene is done.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They used different sets for the scene, with different orientations, suspending the actors on wires to let them \"fly\" through the scene.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The long hotel corridor was built upright, so that the walkway was vertical and the camera is looking upward from the bottom.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Then they hung the actors upside down so they can freely move towards the sides of the corridor.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Paul Franklin:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The vertical corridor is supposed to be the same location as the horizontal corridor, it's an identical set.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The difference is that it has been built vertical standing on its end.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This means we drop actors and stunt performers on wires down into the set and the camera looks up at them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They can then be raised and lowered and swing around the sides and it looks like they're floating in zero gravity.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The actors also tried to simulate the behaviour of weightless people, based on real examples.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Joseph Gordon-Levitt:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In real zero-G, and I've actually spoken to people that have been in real zero-G, what they told me is they never felt so relaxed in life.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "What I did is the exact opposite of that.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In order to make it look like that was the case I actually had to keep every muscle tight because I was supporting myself.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/6496/Gareth", "score": 23 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The recent film Gravity used motion control rigs adapted from automotive assembly line robots.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Popular Mechanics did a pretty interesting article about it: http://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/digital/fact-vs-fiction/free-floating-feel-how-gravity-simulates-zero-g-16016504", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/6501/Cody", "score": 12 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "More recent films also use digital doubles to animate all but actors' faces.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This was used extensively on Ender's Game, and to some extent on Gravity.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Per", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "this article : To create a sense of weightlessness, the filmmakers shot actors in harnesses and on wires against a greenscreen set to place them in a virtual world.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Then to achieve the look of zero-G — and obey the laws of physics — visual effects studio Digital Domain ultimately retained only the actor’s faces and relied instead on digital doubles of their bodies for the sequence.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And for much more detail : Nearly all the digital doubles created for Ender’s Game were in the zero-G Battle Room. . . .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Digital Domain’s animation team developed tools that allowed artists to correct for that movement, then re-projected digital doubles (or parts of their bodies) back into the shots.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Because Digital Domain had developed CG versions of the actors’ flash suits and re-created the lighting environment digitally, they were able to keep the actors’ faces from the live action shoot and", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "replace nearly all of the body motions with digital doubles.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5352/Geoffrey Booth", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "If you are looking for a low-budget option, it is worth doing a YouTube search for Anne Hathaway's zero-gravity move on the Graham Norton Show.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She demonstrates how, when filming Interstellar, actors were required to simulate weightlessness by standing on one leg.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She stands on one leg with a relaxed knee and extends the other leg behind her so that it looks like it is floating on camera.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It is a surprisingly effective technique, with zero-budget.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/29228/babkb", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "One answer \"Apollo 13", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\" Space Scenes Weren't Hollywood Magic.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And There's No Such Thing As A Weightless Chamber.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So How Did Tom Hanks, Bill Paxton And Kevin Bacon Float?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They Filmed", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Aboard NASA's \"vomit Comet.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/18249/Gerald Edgar", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Director Ron Howard describes other techniques in his commentary for Apollo 13 for simulating weightlessness in scenes shot on the soundstage.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The actors often sat one one end of a see-saw which was weighted on the other end, allowing them to bob up and down smoothly.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Simple camera tricks were used such as having the actors lay down on their sides opposite each other, and turning the camera 90 degrees to making it appear that one actor was completely upside down.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, they filmed the scenes in the KC-135 before the soundstage ones so the actors knew what real weightlessness looked and felt like, and they could more easily fake the look on earth.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/30850/Drew C", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "How can the weightlessness of space be realistically simulated on film? Does it require CG or can a convincing simulation be achieved using wire fu and editing? (I'm happy to hear of good examples of weightlessness in movies and how the effects were achieved.)", "title": "How can weightlessness be simulated on film?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<film-techniques><science-fiction><production>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/14712", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/3650/coleopterist" }

[ [ "Director Ron Howard describes other techniques for simulating weightles sness in his commentary for Apollo 13. Actors often sat on one end of a see-saw which was weighted on the other end, Simple camera tricks were used and they also filmed scenes in the KC-135 before the sounstage so the actors knew what real weightlessness looked like.", " The actors often sat one one end of a see-saw which was weighted on the other end, allowing them to bob up and down smoothly. Simple camera tricks were used such as turning the camera 90 degrees to make it appear that one actor was completely upside down." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ " Director Ron Howard describes other techniques in his commentary for Apollo 13 for simulating weightlessness in scenes shot on the soundstage. The actors often sat one one end of a see-saw which was weighted on the other end, allowing them to bob up and down smoothly. Simple camera tricks were used such as turning the camera 90 degrees to make it appear that one actor was completely upside down. They filmed the scenes in the KC-135 before the soundstage ones so they could more easily fake the look on earth." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "In my opinion Walter White is not truly evil.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He just want to earn money for his family.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "His aim is not to kill Brock but to use Jesse's emotion towards Brock in his favor.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Ricin is riskier than Lily of the valley.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So he used Lily of the valley and removed the Ricin just to put suspicion on Gus.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Note", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "- I haven't completed season 5 yet, so don't know if it is addressed later.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1190/Ankit Sharma", "score": 15 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "When Walter White was contemplating how he was going to topple drugkingpin Gustavo Fring, he noticed the potted lilies in his backyard.(\"End Times\") Brock Cantillo was poisoned by Walt in an unknown way with the Lily ofthe Valley berry.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The doctors initially thought he was poisoned byricin as Jesse Pinkman had suggested but later discovered the truetoxin.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The doctors and Jesse believed that Brock came across theflower growing naturally and ate some poisonous berries.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(\"Face Off\") After returning home from successfully killing Gus and getting Jesseback on his side, Walt disposed of the Lily plant from his backyard.(\"Live Free or Die\")", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "According to the doctors taking care of Brock, Lily of the Valley is not as poisonous as ricin, and they came to the conclusion that Brock might of thought of them as fruits (as they claimed that it would be easy for kids to mistake the venomous plant as consumable), and slipped one in his mouth, causing him to poison himself.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Now the episode makes you believe that Walter White poisoned him, without actual evidence, because he had the plant in his backyard, and disposed of it after killing Gus.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Source: http://breakingbad.wikia.com/wiki/Lily_of_the_Valley", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Walter might of wanted to temporarily have Jesse's attention by making him believe Gus poisoned Brock, thus sort of brain-washing Pinkman to get him onboard to kill Gus, without causing real harm to the child.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/6787/BrownEyes", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Ricin was always Walt's go-to poison.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is becuase", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "it's not at all common and very hard to detect.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As knowlegable as Gus was, it's very unlikely that he'd know about a poison such as ricin.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Gus is a business man nad owner of a chicken franchise, not an expert in chemistry.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If it was actually found to be ricin in brock's system, Jesse would have immediatley blamed Walt despite it coming from his own pack of cigarettes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "By using Lily of the Valley (stated in the show as a commonly found poison)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "it's much easier to believe that Gus could be aware of it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5805/Robert English", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Walter used Lily of the Valley instead of ricin because it has similar attributes to ricin without actually BEING ricin.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If it was actually ricin in Brock's system chances are Jesse would have been taken by the FBI.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also Lily of the Valley has less of a chance of killing the kid", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so Walt could get Jesse on his side and against Gus without killing the kid (possibly.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There's always a chance it could have killed the kid as well.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I guess Walt took the gamble deciding that Brock's life wasn't as important as his family's)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/13013/Maranda", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Ricin would have definitely killed Broch and this was not what Walt wanted.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "So he used a milder stuff just to get the kid ill and then plant suspicion in Jessie's mind.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It was not necessary to use Ricin or anything else in particular.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "I remember the conversation between Jessie and Walt, where Walt says that \"think Jessie !", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Who do we know, who is known to use children for his own benefit\" Walt's whole purpose was to relate Broch's condition to the killing of Tomas , Andrea's 11 year old brother who was killed by Gus's men.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "This was highly effective in making Jessie believe that Gus was involved.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/301/Ankit", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Walter has used Ricin before so if he uses it again then Jesse blames Walt without thinking this far, so he used one he didn't use before and that is commonly available.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/13014/Quicksillver", "score": 0 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It would have been a lot easier to get Brock to ingest the pleasant looking berries as apposed to somehow getting the ricin into his food.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This coupled with the fact that the Ricin would take a little time to kick in and therefore may not have had the desired affects in time to spur Jesse into his reactions means that this was the better option for Walt in this case.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/11201/Chris Harland", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "In Breaking Bad Walter wanted Jesse to believe that Gus was behind the poisoning of Brock. Then why would he use Lily Of The Valey, at the risk of it being traced back to him? Won't using Ricin ensure that Jesse believes Gus did it?", "title": "Why does Walter use Lily Of The Valley instead of ricin?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><breaking-bad>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/15236", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/6801/Lester" }

[ [ "Ricin would have killed Broch and that's not what Walt wanted. He just wanted to get Broch ill to make Jessie believe that Gus was involved seeing as he was known ''to use children for his own benefit'' as Walt confermed during his conversation with Jessie. ", "Ricin would have definitely killed Broch and this was not what Walt wanted. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Ricin would have definitely killed Broch and this was not what Walt wanted. Walt's whole purpose was to relate Broch's condition to the killing of Tomas, Andrea's 11-year-old brother who was killed by Gus's men. This was highly effective in making Jessie believe that Gus was involved." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "It's not a secret message, just a simple instruction.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You just need to look at the whole interchange : Bond :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Dry Martini.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Bartender : Oui, monsieur.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Bond :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Wait... three measures of Gordon's; one of vodka; half a measure of Kina Lillet.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Shake it over ice, and add a thin slice of lemon peel.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Bartender :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yes, sir.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Tomelli : You know, I'll have one of those.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Infante :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So will I. Bartender : Certainly.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Felix Leiter:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "My friend, bring me one as well, keep the fruit.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Bond has ordered a dry martini, then effectively changed his order to a Vesper .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This grabs the attention of the other men at the table who order it too.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Felix Leiter asks for one, but instructs the bartender to \"keep the fruit\", i.e. serve me the same drink, but without the lemon peel .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Edit:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For any non-English speakers in particular, the comment below from Brian S should be useful: \"Keep the X\" is a common phrase in English when ordering food/drink used to mean \"don't include X.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8219/Andrew Martin", "score": 54 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I don't think that had any kind of deeper message to it.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Bond was ordering a rather complex drink from the waiter, part of which consisted of some kind of fruit (don't know what exactly, a piece of lemon peel maybe?).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "After that everybody else joined him and ordered the same, only that Felix didn't want the \"fruit\" in it.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "I don't really think there was any more to it than that.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/49/Napoleon Wilson", "score": 10 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I would assume it means no lemon", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8744/colinam1992", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "As other posts mentioned, hold the fruit means without the lemon peel.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Since Bond's drink ends up being poisoned in the next scene, it could be that Felix feared that Bond might be poisoned and wanted to make sure he didn't accidentally drink from the glass intended for Bond (they were sitting right next to each other).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Obviously Felix wasn't involved in the poisoning, but it does show that he's more cautious to those sorts of dangers than Bond is.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Alternatively, it could have just been a point of clarification for the viewer: having Bond have a visibly different drink than the person next to him makes it more obvious that the poison was intended for him when they zoom into the glass as he leaves the table.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8759/David", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It's a phrase similar to, and in this case having the same meaning as, the phrase 'hold the x' which is an American English device for asking for something to be left out, or held back, especially from a food order.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The verbs 'keep' and 'hold' here are synonymous in the sense of 'have or retain possession of' and so can be used interchangeably to mean the same thing, although I'd argue that the phrase 'hold the x' as in 'hold the mayo' is more immediately understood than 'keep the mayo' through it's familiarity and use.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It may be worth adding that in Britain, at least in the north, beyond the reaches of cosmopolitan London, it's considered an affectation or at least irony to order food without one of its listed ingredients this way.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But it probably wasn't.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Last word from 'Airplane': http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TVdvyWK6NiI", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8764/ugy", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "there is a [slightly] deeper meaning, by using the word 'fruit' instead of 'lemon'Felix is conveying that he thinks the lemon is an excessive flamboyant element,and by inference that Bond is also excessive and flamboyant.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Felix on the other hand, is no-nonsense and straight forward, he orders a simple drink, he doesn't even bother choosing one, he's saying to the bartender,", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "your pouring alcohol, pour me one, in simple phrases:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "My friend, bring me one as well, keep the fruit.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However i'm not sure 'keep the x'", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "is that common as a phrase, at least not that I've heard, except in 'keep the change'", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8755/commentor", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "At the request of the OP I'm adding this answer based on what my interpretation of this phrase in the movie meant.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Bare in mind", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I do not drink and am quite unfamiliar with alcoholic beverages, but I do have friends who drink and my answer is based mainly on things I've picked up from listening to them", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "talk about types of drinks they prefer.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One of the key rules to alcohol according to my friends seems to be that if you get fruit in your drink you open yourself up to relentless teasing and hazing for being a girl and/or a sissy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The only real source I have to back up this cultural view is from the TV show Scrubs where the main character J.D.'s favorite drink is the Appletini .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The joke being that he naively considers this to be a \"straight\" drink and wonders when gays started drinking them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Putting those two pieces of information together led me to the the jerk response that \"keep the fruit\" was him saying to make sure the drink was manly and contained only hard liquor, and no girly fruit.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/22993/sanpaco", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "In Casino Royale , when everyone orders Bond's martini cocktail, Felix Leiter, the CIA agent, says to the bartender \"keep the fruit\". What was he trying to say? What fruit is he referring to? Also was that some kind of secret message between CIA and MI6.", "title": "What does the \"keep the fruit\" term mean in Casino Royale?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<james-bond><casino-royale>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/18285", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8670/Firee" }

[ [ "I don't think it was a hiden messsage. The drink Bond odered has a piece of fruit in it and Felix simply didn't want ''The fruit'' ", "There is not any kind of deeper message to it. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "There is not any kind of deeper message to it. After that everybody else joined him and ordered the same, only that Felix didn't want the \"fruit\" in it." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "This interview with the film's director indicates that the soldiers cut up the fish to intimidate the tail-enders before battle was joined: BJH:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "These moments are what make filmmaking fun and interesting.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It wasn’t actually in the script, but when I was making the storyboards, I thought of this idea I mentioned before—a primitive aspect, like tribes in Africa, a ritual before battle to intimidate their enemies.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Putting blood on their faces and whatnot.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So I came up with this idea of the fish,", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but I also wanted to bring it back somehow, because it was such a cool concept.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We decided to have Chris slip on it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It’s a bit of a strange moment but very natural for me, and Chris took to it immediately.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He sort of laughed and said: “We’re doing all this cool action—you want me to slip on a fish?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Why not?”", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We shot it very quickly. and here", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Q. Is there any cultural significance to put the axe blade in the belly of a fish before the massacre? BJH:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So it’s a sci-fi movie but", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I thought it would be appropriate to have a primitive type fight, like an ancient tribe ritually putting blood on their face.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It wasn’t in the script, but as I was storyboarding I included it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But it was actually hard to shoot on set: the fish smelled awful, getting the blood on the axe was hard, and the timing was difficult (it was fake blood in a condom, and it was hard to cut it with the axe).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Note that none of these interviews indicate that the fish was poisoned.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/", "score": 9 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think fish symbolizes people, particlarly ones in the tail section.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Mason said that they eat sushi twice a year in trying to control the population of the aquarium.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Likewise, the population of the train can be controlled by a massacre.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/11537/user11537", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Found this interesting interpretation of the fish, it attempts to tie the events of the movie to astrological symbols/cycles.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:0w577xTVOowJ:www.reddit.com/r/YMS/comments/2a2hny/id_love_to_hear_adams_thoughts_on_snowpiercer/+&cd=10&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us&client=firefox-a", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Per fellow user's request, my quick summary of the post linked above: The post explains that the cycle of the train follows the zodiac cycle, Pisces, fish cut, Aquarius, aquarium then Taurus for the steak.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If the front of the train is the top of the cycle", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "this syncs up quite well", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "actually, the front being the first symbol, the ram (ramming through the snow).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Then there is mention of a Greek myth involving Eros and Aphrodite turning into fish in order to escape Eros' father, Typhon.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If you believe this tie into astrology it could indicate that cutting the fish is meant to show that there is no escape.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/13522/Wilford", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think there are multiple meanings and people above touched on some of them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It definitely has a lot to do with the idea of \"balance\" that Tilda Swinton talks about with the Sushi.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Interesting that the aquarium becomes a symbol of balance after Curtis slipped and lost his balance on the gutted fish.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/13049/Sean", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "While I can find no direct quotes from anyone involved with the film to confirm my suspicion, within the movie itself", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I took it to be a symbolic gesture of intimidation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Much like when someone draws their finger across their throat to imply an opponent's death or defeat.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In a grander sense, I think it was a symbolism to mark the end of Christian charity.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As you might or might not know, the fish has been associated with Christian symbolism.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think that the act of gutting the fish with their ax was symbolic of the renunciation of the Christian idea of brotherly love, which was an omen to show that they were prepared to murder their \"brothers.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8071/Johnny Bones", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Joon-ho Bong was the director and if youre familiar with asian film making then you will recognize some cultural references in the screenplay....", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "the fish (which looks like it might be koi---japanese, chinese, korean symbolism around koi is pretty ancient & all of them look at the koi as a symbol of strength and perseverance) has multiple cultural layers of symbolism so much so that it is a virtual archetype and will have many interpretations from many different cultures...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but given the major influences for the film (asian director and french author) i think the following is likely being referenced: \"The fish signifies freedom from all restraint.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As in the water a fish moves easily in any direction, so in the Buddha-state the fully-emancipated knows no restraints or obstruction.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "the train is like a fish (in shape and movement through the snow), yet the social environment of the interior of the train is the total opposite of the above analysis....", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "the people are fish whose natural affinity is freedom and movement.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "the perfected state of free will which means neither being an agent of oppression nor submitting to or tolerating oppression.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "it seems to be an asian-european fusion & utilizes tropes from these two paradigms.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "i think, really, this film is commentary on the rationalization of oppression hierarchies we see at work in the world today", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(ie the rhetoric around \"sustainable balance\", everyone \"knowing their place\", etc so called \"social darwinism\" and randian style \"objectivism\" which states that the \"strong\" are justified in their exploitation of the \"weak\").", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "the juxtaposition of the utter impoverishment that is separated from utter luxury by only a few cars is reflective of the surrealness of the real world (esp in the usa)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "where wealthy neighborhoods are separated from deeply impoverished ones by only a few blocks.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "these blocks become real symbols of this chasm.....", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "the main focus is about class struggle.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "i wonder if the author is a marxist?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "def marxist-like influences.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/16864/jonah", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "They slice into the guts to rupture the fish's gallbladder to coat the edges of their axes with it's fluid.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I KNOW this is the most likely answer being that I've fished for 22 years and have been filleting fish just as long.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's the first rule of cleaning fish is to remove it's innards and", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "if you so much as poke the gallbladder sack then the fish is ruined.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/16736/phil", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "During Snowpiercer all the soldiers were cutting into fish as they prepared for battle. What was the meaning of this gesture?", "title": "What was the meaning of the fish?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<snowpiercer>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/21938", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/11476/blaster" }

[ [ "Fish symbolize people. Mason said they eat sushi twice a year to try an control the aquarium population. Likewise, the population of the train is controlled by a massacre.", "Fish symbolizes people, particlarly ones in the tail section." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Fish symbolizes people, particlarly ones in the tail section.Mason said that they eat sushi twice a year in trying to control the population of the aquarium. Likewise, the population of the train can be controlled by a massacre." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "No, Lucy didn't travel in time (although, it was my first thought as well), nor did her mind re-enact those events.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "She remembered them.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Throughout the film, professor Norman explains how the purpose of life is to pass on the knowledge through time.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "From the first cell, its splitting in two, and on to the more complicated life forms, the purpose is always passing the information.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, among the first changes that Lucy experiences is her remembering her own early life (the cat that she had when she was one, her mother's milk,...) which she reveals in her phone conversation with her mother.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Later on, that remembrance then spurs to the earlier events (her own growth of bones).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The \"time travelling sequence\" that we see is the process of all life since its beginning, in reverse.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It does not end with the Big Bang.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It ends with many cells connecting (back) until there is one left, which was the first cell ever.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The whole sequence is Lucy remembering all the knowledge that was passed from that first cell all the way to her today's cells, and conveniently saving it in some form on a computer.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Addendum:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was noted in the comments that she had some interactions with history's beings (Indians, dinosaurs, human ancestors,...) and that we see her in those interactions, not her own ancestors.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The way I see it is: The memories are someone's.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They acknowledged that person, not Lucy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We see her because she's remembering it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think it would've been too confusing if in each of those short interaction scenes we saw the actual ancestor, and the fact that no one seemed alarmed by her sudden appearance (which would be a necessity if she time-travelled) makes me more certain that those humans and animals interact with someone who was naturally there.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5589/Vedran Šego", "score": 11 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "My take on it was that she could exist at all points in time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She transcended that as she had transcended other things in the movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So she was actually moving through time, going wherever and whenever she wanted (including going through a black hole and to the \"other side\" where it connected with a quasar.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "At least I think that's what that was supposed to symbolize, and that visual has stuck with me).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So she did in fact travel with her body and consciousness through time, and she did nearly touch the first protohuman Lucy's finger like God and Adam on the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(I have no direct proof for this, like a quote from the writer or director.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'm basing it on everything that happened in the rest of the movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She transcended the physical world, so next she'd transcend the temporal world.)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8017/BrettFromLA", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "An illustrator from ILM who worked on the scene talked about his discussions with Besson where Lucy \"would be travelling back through time until the moment of the Big Bang\" in this article .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So it appears that was the intent.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That being said, I think the genetic memories concept makes a lot more sense when you look at the actual images in the scene and all the apparent nods to that theory throughout the earlier film.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The thing that seems to oppose the time travel idea by far", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think is what was mentioned already about the last scene being the 1st cell splitting, not a big bang.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Unless of course the idea was that the 1st cell dividing was actually the Big Bang, and our whole universe was created from that, or some other Men in Blacky type stuff.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": ";)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/28584/Mike", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Reff: Lucy (2014) :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Explained", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I don't think she's traveling through time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Once all the CPH4 goes in, her brain nears 90% utilization.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As Lucy's brain function elevates further and further, she is able to tap into and use all forms of energy around her.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She can look into the past or the stars and galaxy because they are all forms of light energy that she can access.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(eg:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The reflection of yourself in a mirror is you looking at the past because light takes finite time to travel from you to the mirror and back to your eyes)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/16374/John", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I don't think she travelled back in time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I understand that the Native Americans seemed to have seen her, and the dinosaur certainly did.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But primate-Lucy, she didn't live in North America.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Primate-Lucy lived in Ethiopia.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If Omnipotent-Lucy time travelled, how is it possible", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "she saw P-Lucy in to-be New York.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Native Americans obviously lived in North America, and Lucy lived in Ethiopa.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They could not have possibly lived in the same area at different times.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Omnipotent-Lucy had to have remembered them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/44182/Paul Caskie", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "When Morgan Freeman pushed the 3 remaining bags of the CPH4 drug into Lucy, we saw her traveling through time (some steps of history from current world to big bang). Some of those events where witnessed by Lucy. Did Lucy imagine those scenes or was she actually time-traveling? Because Lucy was back in the chair when Mr. Jang proceeded to shoot her. Did her mind experience the events or her mind just enacted those historical events as scientists give them by inference / resolution?", "title": "Did Lucy travel time or was her mind imagining / portraying the views?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><lucy>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/25116", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/12936/AtanuCSE" }

[ [ "No, Lucy didn't travel in time, nor did her mind re-enact those events. She remembered them.", "Lucy didn't travel in time, nor did her mind re-enact those events." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Lucy didn't travel in time, nor did her mind re-enact those events. Throughout the film, professor Norman explains how the purpose of life is to pass on the knowledge through time." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "According to this article from Creative Planet Network", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"We have the technology, and our animators have the skills to do 3-D,\" says supervising producer Anne Garefino .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"We don't want it to look computery,\"agrees director of animation Eric Stough , who's been on board since the pilot.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"We want it to look as crappy as possible.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/789/Legion600", "score": 21 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "They do use 3D animation software.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "However, from the beginning the cut-out paper look is what they wanted to achieve with CG after finding out the difficulties of using real paper cut-outs.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The decision to stay with the paper cut-out look was made from the beginning, they want everything to look as cartoonish as possible, down to the movements and appearance of the characters.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It also adds to the branding, one can immediately recognize a show of South Park by its looks.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "More information", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/7659/invalid_id", "score": 16 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The show's style of animation is inspired by the paper cut-out cartoons made by Terry Gilliam for Monty Python's Flying Circus , of which Parker and Stone have been lifelong fans.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After the pilot for subsequent episodes have been produced by computer animation, providing a similar look to the originals while requiring a fraction of the time to produce.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Beginning with season five, the animators began using Maya instead of PowerAnimator.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The studio now runs a 120-processor render farm that can produce 30 or more shots an hour.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "PowerAnimator and Maya are high-end programs mainly used for 3D computer graphics, while co-producer and former animation director, Eric Stough, notes that PowerAnimator was initially chosen because its features helped animators retain the show's \"homemade\" look.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "On a different note, many times the creators do not want to opt for the latest technology for their movies or shows.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This could be based on personal like and dislike", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and yes it is an artistic decision as mentioned correctly by Bobby Alexander in his comment.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A similar incident worth noting is Chris Nolan's choice of not shooting Dark Knight Rises in 3D at a time when almost everyone else was doing it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Wikipedia says that Nolan elected not to film in 3-D, but instead stated that he intended to focus on improving image quality and scale using the IMAX format", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So while South Park does use some of the latest technology, its current look and feel depends upon the creators' artistic decision.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/301/Ankit", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Would 3-D animation make the content any better?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "George Lucas took advantage of the latest special effects available to film with the prequel trilogy which many fans say don't hold a candle to the original.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When he \"remastered\" the original trilogy with special editions, many fans revolted.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Look at video games, some of the most critically acclaimed games have simple animations and graphics (Minecraft, Fez, etc.), while there are countless graphic powerhouse games that are commercial and critical failures.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "South Park is funny because of the content.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The barebones animation is a signature of the series.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Why change it?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/15285/Michael Brown", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Also due to branding you don't want to change something that works.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The show is a screaming success.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Changing it might run the path when Coke introduced New Coke and failed miserably", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1144/JayCouture.com", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The quote I like best, referring to the software used to make South Park: \"(using this 3D software) is basically building a sandcastle with a bulldozer\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That's the whole reason they use the software; to remain topical (episodes finished in a week, handed into Comedy Central on the Wednesday itself, ie tonight's episode wasn't submitted when you woke this morning!)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "because they aren't bogged down with Michael Bay-ism.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/15268/Aussie Cryptocurrency", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "The technology has greatly improved since South Park 's pilot episode, why has the style of the show not been changed?", "title": "Why are the Latest Episodes of South Park not in 3D animation?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<animation><south-park>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/26328", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/" }

[ [ "The decision to keep the paper cut-out look was a choice made from the beginning they want everything to look as cartoonsh as possibile and one can immediately recognize South Park by it's look.", "The decision to stay with the paper cut-out look was made from the beginning, they want everything to look as cartoonish as possible. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "The decision to stay with the paper cut-out look was made from the beginning, they want everything to look as cartoonish as possible. One can immediately recognize a show of South Park by its looks. They do use 3D animation software." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "He's a Science teacher.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He understands the effects of Meth and knows how addictive it is.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Besides, he was in it to make money.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Never combine business with pleasure if you want to be successful.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Just as Frank Lopez warns Tony Montana in Scarface, \"Don't get high on your own supply\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8071/Johnny Bones", "score": 36 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The series was not really so much about drug use, and if Walter had been a tweaker then it presumably would have had to have been more so.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, it would have overshadowed some of the ambiguities and nuances of his character; getting high would in fact have been a good explanation for some of his behaviour but having such an easy explanation would have made it less thought provoking.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I don't, as other people have said, think it has anything to do with Walter's personality.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He could just as easily have been using without changing the plot (I think what is in keeping with his personality would be that he would conceal his use from others), but again, the focus of the story would then be a drug user and the series was not about drug users; making it more so would have diluted other elements.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There are really surprisingly few scenes of users using considering the length of the series; much of that is just Jessie getting stoned on weed -- and even more than that, just Jesse sitting smoking a cigarette.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Most of the criminal characters aren't users and show some disdain for them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In a way, drugs are totally tangential to the plot; they just happen to be a source of income for organized crime, which is the focus of Breaking Bad, as per Vince Gilligan's famous quote about how he wanted to take Mr. Chips and transform him into Scarface.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Of course the meth thing is very sexy; although the plot could as easily revolved around smuggling guns or diamonds, having someone actually making drugs on TV was a bit more original and interesting.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But the show was still not about drug use, it was about criminality and violence.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/13544/goldilocks", "score": 31 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Walter never wanted to be addicted to the stuff he was making.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He was already sick because of cancer and doing drugs could worsen his health and as Johnny explains in his answer that being Chemistry wiz", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "he knew the ill effects.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He wanted to be alive and awake all the time so that he could take clever decisions and complete his job no matter how difficult it was, be it packing & transferring meth, or killing someone.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It would have been difficult for him to manage everything he was doing and lying to people would have been difficult for him.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He also had to return to his home every night and sit with his family plus his brother in law was in the DEA and maybe he could sniff meth because that was everything he looked for.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe he also felt mature to do stuff like this", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "and he also had kids whom he never wanted to influence.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5259/Robot Boy", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Walter is \"in the business of building empires.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\" There is a clear cultural separation where if you want to be in the business and earn the respect of people like Gus, you need to be firmly above the product.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think talking about the effects of meth, etc.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "dilutes this point.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Walter isn't tempted at all; that would violate his vision of himself, and his goals.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yes, Jesse, in particular his relationship with Walter, is very complicated because Jesse uses", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but it otherwise nearly as talented as Walter.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5710/djechlin", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I agree with the above stated answers that Walt didn't want to become addicted, needed to stay focused, etc.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But I feel the biggest reason was his pride.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think he felt he was always better than those crank addicted junkies.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is evidenced on how he talked down to Jessie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Walt was a scientist \"for chrissake!\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and he wanted everyone to know this was business, he wasn't a junkie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But it was his pride too", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "that got the better of him, turning him darker in the guise of him helping his family.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He was actually becoming the scum he hated, and Jessie was becoming the concienscious person Walt pretended Walt", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "was all along.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1144/JayCouture.com", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "Why didn't Walter White ever consume his own product in Breaking Bad ? I mean he did once consume cannabis, is this because of work ethics or any alternate views?", "title": "Why didn't Walter White consume his own product?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<breaking-bad>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/26457", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/15342/raviteja" }

[ [ "Firstly, Walter never wanted to be addicted to his own product. Secondly he was already diagnosed with cancer and doing drugs would worsen his health. Also, he needed to be alert whilst transferring meth and to make clever decisions ", "Walter was never interested in the things he did. He was already sick with cancer, and drugs could make his health worse. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Walter was never interested in the things he did. He was already sick with cancer, and drugs could make his health worse. All that he had done would have been difficult for him to manage. Perhaps it also felt mature in doing such things, because his lawyer was in the DEA, and perhaps he was able to sniff Meth. He had children whom he would never influence." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "The only way Murph could know is when that information came from Brand herself.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Therefore we must assume that the quantum data Cooper send to Earth/Murph was also able to fix the one-directional communication problem through the worm hole.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/148/NGLN", "score": 28 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Well, you might also ask, how did Murph know Dr. Brand has reached the new planet at all.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I guess Dr. Brand must have sent a message from the new planet, which informed others that she was there", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and she was alone.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There might have been plans to reach out to her soon, only that Cooper could wait no longer", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and he immediately sets off for her.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/301/Ankit", "score": 19 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think the more straightforward answer is that: Cooper had 2 weeks before he got to see Murph again, after being rescued and having recovered.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In those 2 weeks he would have relayed their entire mission to NASA and told them exactly what had happened and how Amelia was heading to Edmunds' planet to execute Plan B.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When Cooper, Romilly and Amelia were voting on going to Mann's or Edmunds' planet, they knew that Edmunds' wasn't transmitting anymore, so they knew that there was a possibility that he might be dead or in hibernation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When Murph is telling Cooper to go to Edmunds' planet for Amelia, she says, \"Maybe right now she's setting in for a long nap..\" -", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "which implies that they don't have a word from Amelia Brand yet and the one directional communication might not have been fixed after all.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So this is all conjecture.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/19865/user2278764", "score": 9 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I had to think about this too; your going to kick yourself because it is so glaringly obvious :) 91 years have passed since Cooper left.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There was no time dilation on Edmund's planet.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Edmund is dead if not by accident then by old age.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She was not \"informed\" that Edmund died, it is just obvious because no one can live that long.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/15791/Stephen Cagle", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Of course she cannot be 100% sure about Edmonds's death, but you can easily assume he died since (if my memory does not fool me)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "he stopped sending any information (for a period of ~70 years, when Murph makes the statement), though his signal appeared to be still active", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/15730/ed0", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In the last shot when Amelie is seen in the new planet all alone, she is seen sitting besides a pile of stones with the 'dogtag/id' named EDMUNDS, pointing as a regard to fallen marine.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/15752/Manish Panwar", "score": 0 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "When Brand landed on Edmunds the time that had passed relative to Earth time was about 120 years - Brand shouted an estimate of this as they were being sling-shot around the black hole.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, Brand would have reached Edmunds and transmitted a signal.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The spacecraft that Murph was now on could well have picked up that signal, which incidentally was around the time that Cooper and TARS were scooped up near Saturn.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The assumption is that the worm hole still existed by Saturn and that Cooper took the ranger to go through it and visit Brand again to re-assure her that everything succeeded.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "With enough fuel (this time round) he would not need to sling-shot Gargantua and simply arrive at Edmunds with no/little time loss.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "My guess is that the the spaceship that Murph was on is now going to head in that direction too in order to populate the new world OR now being advanced enough to make interstellar travel probably have lots of inhabited planets and Cooper went to pick her up from Edmunds.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/16584/Joe", "score": 0 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "When pilot Cooper wakes up, he will be debriefed, even though this isn't shown in the movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Because of Murph's status, she will be given a short report of what happened, including the status of the other crew members.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She knows that someone has to find Brand and all of the embryos, as there is a reasonable chance that they are alive.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She knows that her Dad is the best person to do this as he is the only person alive who has been on the other side.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She also knows that he won't leave her again unless she tells him to go and gives him some positive motivation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/21447/user21447", "score": 0 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In the beginning of the movie the NASA team informed that the hypersleep pod could help the pioneers survive for 10 years extendable to 20 years awaiting rescue.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Dr Mann with superior skill extended that by using KIPPs power cell.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe Mann's planet was also quite close to Gargantua experiencing less time passing than Earth and even Edmunds' planet.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Edmunds and all other pioneers though may have been presumed dead already after visiting Manns planet or even Millers due to the sheer amount of time passed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As of Dr Brand it can't be known that it is known with certainty from Our Solar System", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "/Murph that Brand is dead or alive or how her mission is proceeding.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "On Cooper's journey back from the Tesseract though he mysteriously encounters Brand through Time - something that we could assume Cooper spoke about at Cooper Station - a strong message from the 5-dimensional beings to focus on Brand.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/26940/Markus Sandén", "score": 0 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "One Explanation Must be Murb using the quantum data and solve both ways communication.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "And send data how to to it to Brand .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "So, she can send info that she was the only one survived and on the planet alone waiting for recues .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/37433/Manosin", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "During the end of Interstellar Murph says to her father to go seek Brand as she is all alone on their \"new planet\". How could Murph know that Wolf Edmunds was dead?", "title": "How did Murph know about Edmunds?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><interstellar>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/27041", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/290/StupidOne" }

[ [ "One explination could be that Murb and Brand were communicating via quantum data.", "Must be Murb using the quantum data and solve both ways communication. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "One Explanation Must be Murb using the quantum data and solve both ways communication. And send data how to to it to Brand ." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "The film Run Lola Run takes place over the course of twenty minutes (beating out Vantage Point by three minutes).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The film's running time (sorry) is padded out with flashbacks and flashforwards.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The links lead to the relevant info according to Wikipedia.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/6492/Meat Trademark", "score": 10 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I'm pretty sure Vantage Point (2008) has to be in the mix, as it's the same events as viewed from 8 different witnesses.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'm not sure exactly how long the span is", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": ", it's been a while since I saw it, but I feel like the main body of the movie covers the same 10 or so minutes several times.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8071/Johnny Bones", "score": 9 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It's difficult to tell how long does it actually take to tell the story in the police office in The Usual Suspects .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It could actually take few minutes even if the fictitious stories told to police officer take much longer to picture in the movie with all the details.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We can find out if we clock only the speech of the hero as the narrator and scenes in the office.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/15738/George Polevoy", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Since time is a relative concept we would have to take that into consideration.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Chronicles of Narnia cover minutes of time on earth but years in the fantasy land of Narnia.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The same would apply to the Wizard of Oz and Alice in Wonderland.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/15773/0pinion8d", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "While this won't win, TimeCrimes is shorter than the actual movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Even though it has a time travel component, it is about 30-45 minutes of the same events from multiple perspectives.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The wiki link has spoilers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/7018/Chloe", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I believe that the \"real time\" of \" The 5,000 Fingers of Dr. T \" is shorter than Run Lola Run.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "This was a disaster of a movie by Dr. Seuss, where a boy falls asleep during piano practice in the first few minutes of the movie.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Much of the movie is then a dream sequence, until he wakes at the very end.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It's been a long time since I've seen it, but I believe the awake/present time sequences total less than 20 minutes.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/6234/JohnP", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "Based on this question , what feature-length movie* (about 80 minutes or longer) covers the smallest amount of time? I'm thinking along the lines of Run Lola Run which only covers about 20 minutes. *I know the Academy defines it as 40 minutes or longer , but I'm after \"movie\"-length movies here.", "title": "What is the shortest timespan depicted in a movie?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<cinema-history>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/27100", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/6492/Meat Trademark" }

[ [ "I believe that the ''real time'' of '' The 5,000 Fingers of Dr.T '' is shorter than ''Run Lola Run'', it's less than 20 minutes. In the first few minutes of the beginning of the movie a boy falls asleep at piano practice and the rest of the movie is a dream sequence, until he wakes at the very end.", "Real time of \" The 5,000 Fingers of Dr. T \" is the shortest " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "I believe that the \"real time\" of \" The 5,000 Fingers of Dr. T \" is shorter than Run Lola Run. " ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "According to this article I found (written in 2010) -", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "individual movie titles can not be copyrighted.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "However, there can be a trademark granted if there is a certain level of recognition of the title to the specific movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The author of the article cites \"Star Wars\" or \"Citizen Kane\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Per the linked article, the MPAA has a Title Registration Bureau which also has a standard in place.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Participants are notified of conflict; if a raised objection is not settled - the dispute moves to arbitration.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So - to answer your question - for the vast majority of film titles there is no mandatory waiting period.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "However, producers should not be shocked if there is litigation that arises regardless.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/15523/sonnik", "score": 27 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The answer is, they don't.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And I quote:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Literary titles – such as book or movie titles – fall in a gray areain U.S. law.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For instance, although a book or movie is protected bycopyright, its title isn’t.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Copyright simply doesn’t cover titles.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And even if the title is distinctive, such as The 40-Year-Old Virgin,courts and the Trademark Office say it can’t be registered as atrademark, even though distinctive words and slogans can be registeredas trademarks in other contexts.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There’s an exception for seriestitles, such as Harry Potter, but that’s of no help to single-worktitles. http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/culturebox/2005/05/double_trouble.html http://moviehole.net/201144916same-title-different-movies-stealing-another-movies-title http://www.andsoitbeginsfilms.com/2013/07/top-15-movies-with-same-title.html", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8071/Johnny Bones", "score": 13 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "You might be interested in the case of the film The Butler which just came out recently.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The film's title was up for a possible rename due to a Motion Picture Association of America claim from Warner Bros., which had inherited from the defunct Lubin Company a now-lost 1916 silent short film with the same name.[9][31]", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The case was subsequently resolved with the MPAA granting the Weinstein Company permission to add Daniels' name in front of the title, under the condition that his name was \"75% the size of The Butler\".[32]", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "On July 23, 2013, the distributor unveiled a revised poster, displaying the title as Lee Daniels' The Butler.[33] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Butler#Production", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/18165/RandomsAnswer", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It seems to me there are often movies of the same title in the same year.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "IMDb keeps track of them with Roman numerals.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Like this: Action Figures (2011", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "/I)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Action Figures (2011/II)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/18249/Gerald Edgar", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "If there is a limit, it's no longer than three months.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Two movies titled Nine came out in the second half of 2009.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One is an all-CGI animated SF film with \"stitchpunks\" that look like a grown-up version of Sackboy from the later PS3 game LittleBigPlanet , released in September 2009.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The other is an unrelated musical drama directed by Rob Marshall starring Daniel Day-Lewis, released three months later.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Both are adaptations of previous works also titled Nine .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/14139/Damian Yerrick", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "I just stumbled on the new film Bound (2015) and remembered that there was an older film by the Wachowskis also called Bound released in 1996 . I am sure this varies from country to country - but in Hollywood, how long must a new film wait to use the title of an older film? This of course is for non-franchise films", "title": "How long must a Hollywood film wait to use the same title of an older film?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<production><title><legal><american-cinema>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/30076", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1172/saurabhj" }

[ [ "Individual movie titles can not be copyrighted and for the vast majority of film titles there is no mandatory waiting period.", "Individual movie titles can not be copyrighted. So for the vast majority of film titles there is no mandatory waiting period. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Individual movie titles can not be copyrighted. So for the vast majority of film titles there is no mandatory waiting period. Nevertheless, producers should not be shocked if there is litigation that arises regardless." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "From Wikipedia page on the film:-", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The film's title was inspired by the English-language title ofdirector Enzo G. Castellari's 1978 war film, The Inglorious Bastards.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When asked for an explanation of the film's title's spelling during anews conference at the Cannes Film Festival, Tarantino said, \"I'mnever going to explain that\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When pushed on it, Tarantino would not explain the first u in Inglourious, but said, \"The Basterds?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That'sjust", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "the way you say it: Basterds.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Tarantino later stated in aninterview that the misspelled title is \"a Basquiat-esque touch.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He further commented on Late Show with David Letterman that InglouriousBasterds is a \"Quentin Tarantino spelling\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Tarantino is famous for raising this kind of unanswered question to play with viewers mind.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1190/Ankit Sharma", "score": 20 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "From IMDB FAQ", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Why is it spelled \"Basterds\"?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Tarantino commented on \"The Late Show\" that Inglourious Basterds is the \" Tarantino way of spelling it ,\" but he hasn't commented on where the idea for the misspelling arose, nor is he likely to.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\" I'm never going to explain that ,\" Tarantino was quoted at the Cannes Film Festival.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Three theories have been offered by viewers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Basterd may be derived from the word Baster, a word derived from Dutch bastaard (bastard).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The original Basters were mainly persons of mixed descent between the Cape Colony Dutch and indigenous African women who at one time would have been absorbed in the white community.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the movie, the Basterds are American/Jewish, and their plan was very similar...to be \"civilians absorbed\" in France, walking among the Nazis.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The misspelling may connote that Lt Aldo Raine (Brad Pitt), who grew up in a family of backwoods bootleggers and moonshiners, has had little in the way of schooling.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The words are briefly shown in their misspelled form on his rifle.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Tarantino misspelled the title on the cover of the script, which then leaked onto the internet before production began.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Rather than admit his mistake, Tarantino chose to maintain the spelling.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The above were merely audience opinions.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But here's a promising article from RottenTomatoes where Weinstein Co. and Universal Pictures, confirms that QT is not a poor speller and gives the reasons for the title.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Inglourious Basterds begins in German-occupied France, where Shoshanna Dreyfus (Mélanie Laurent) witnesses the execution of her family at the hand of Nazi Colonel Hans Landa (Christoph Waltz).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Shosanna narrowly escapes and flees to Paris, where she forges a new identity as the owner and operator of a cinema.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Elsewhere in Europe, Lieutenant Aldo Raine (Brad Pitt) organizes a group of Jewish soldiers to engage in targeted acts of retribution.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Known to their enemy as \" The Basterds ,\" Raine's squad joins German actress and undercover agent Bridget Von Hammersmark (Diane Kruger) on a mission to take down the leaders of The Third Reich.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Fates converge under a cinema marquee, where Shosanna is poised to carry out a revenge plan of her own...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8228/chaitanya89", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Because they're from Bostin", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's spelled basterd because they're from Bostin and that's how they spell it there — or rather, how they pronounce it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Unfilmed flashback", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "According to an article on Cracked.com , \"6 Crucial Movie Scenes That Never Made It Out of the Script\" , this was explained in a scene that was scripted but never filmed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was a flashback to Boston, spelled \"Bostin\" in the script , where Donny buys a baseball bat and then goes around his Jewish neighbourhood, asking people if they have any loved ones in Europe", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "they're concerned for and if they want to sign the bat for them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "INT - SPORTING GOODS STORE- DAY", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "MR.GOOROWITZ'S sporting goods shop in Donny's Jewish Bostin neighbourhood.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Donny walks in.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "MR.GOOROWITZ", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hello Donny, how are you?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "DONNY", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Ah, just dandy, Mr.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Goorowitz.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "MR.GOOROWITZ", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Your mother, your father - everything good there?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "DONNY There", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "just fine.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'm shippin off next week.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The store proprietor, extends his hand to the young man.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "MR.GOOROWITZ", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Good for you son.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Kill one of those Nazi basterds for me, will ya?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "DONNY", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That's the idea, Mr.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Goorowitz.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "MR.GOOROWITZ", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "What can I do you for,", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Donny?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "DONNY", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I need a baseball bat.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He goes to a mrs.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Himmelstein, who is about to sign it \"Madeleine\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "MRS.HIMMELSTEIN", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You must be a real BASTERD,", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Donny?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "DONNY", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You bet your sweet ass", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I am.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "MRS.HIMMELSTEIN", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Good.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A Basterds work is never done.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Specially in Germany.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We then see Donny beating Werner to death with that same bat.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/9382/SQB", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Quentin Tarantino loves to muddy the waters in interviews with answers like the ones quoted by others here.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "My theory is the misspelling of the title is his way of paying tribute to Enzo Castellari's original film, while making his title different.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He didn't remake the original, he was inspired by it.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The original plot only superficially has a resemblance to the newer film.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "I believe it also reduced confusion with the original.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/47044/Great Artiste", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "To prevent the name being censored in listings What looks better in listings?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Inglorious Basterds Inglorious B******s", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Since social media is pretty endemic these days, this gets the name of the film out there without automatic censor software bastardizing (sorry) the title.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I have no source for this theory, but it seems a pretty Tarantino thing to do.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "Did Quentin Tarantino ever give the reason for misspelling the movie title Inglourious Basterds ?", "title": "Why was Inglourious Basterds misspelt?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<title><inglourious-basterds>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/31686", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/16374/John" }

[ [ "Misspelling the title was his way of paying tribute to Enzo Castellari's original film, while making his title different.", "By misspelling of the title is his way of paying tribute to Enzo Castellari's original film, he made his title different." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "By misspelling of the title is his way of paying tribute to Enzo Castellari's original film, he made his title different. He didn't remake the original, he was inspired by it." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "At the time of the Lord of the Rings more and more of the Elven population of Middle Earth have decided to return to the Undying Lands due in part to the original rise of Sauron from which they endured heavy casualties but could not quite recover as the men of Gondor and Arnor did.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The prosperity of the men in the following years while there was still a High King of those realms signified to most of the Eldar that their time on Middle Earth would soon be at an end especially as much of their own realms had been lost even before Sauron came to power such as Gondolin.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "With their population significantly lessened and their lack of stemming the slow decay of their influence following the death of Gil Galad would have given most Elves reason to leave.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Eregion the region where most of the Noldor Elves had populated", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "had by the time of LOTR fallen into decay and been abandoned.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Elrond ruled over the last highly populated realm west of the Misty Mountains (The Grey Havens although having an Elven population, it was far smaller in comparison and most would leave before and during the War of the Ring).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Galadriel herself is probably one of the last of the strongest Elven bloodlines and one of the most powerful characters in Middle Earth at that time but having confronted the Necromancer and barely defeated him", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "she knows that if Sauron defeated the free peoples then she could not defend the Elves with her magic Elrond mentions to Gandalf there is no strength left in the Elves to stem the darkness.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "With that knowledge I think they planned to leave regardless but stayed longer than most because they could probably hold off Sauron for a short time while the remainder of their people attempted to escape.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You have to appreciate that the task Frodo is sent to do, most of the free peoples believe to be suicide hardly any expected Frodo to achieve what he managed even though they had hope they doubted he would return in fact", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Frodo himself begins to doubt that he and Sam will survive and its only really Sam who has enough faith that they accomplish their task.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Nevertheless with the defeat of Sauron most of the Elves have already departed and Galadriel would see no point in remaining when she can leave to be with her people especially as Middle Earth no longer needs her to protect the lands west of Lorien from Sauron", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so Galadriel I think always intended to leave as she knew she could not withstand Sauron and with his defeat she was free to be with her people again in the Undying Lands.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/20106/The Man With No Name", "score": 10 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "She foresaw that when the Lord of the rings was destroyed, her ring would also lose its power.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "As a result she could no longer sustain her realm.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Despite this prospect, she has let Frodo go ahead.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/61476/Remco", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "She's diminishing because the time for the dominion of men had come.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This means she's going to be losing her position of authority.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She's remaining Galadriel because the ring won't transform her as it did for Gollum.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(To illustrate what would happen if she accepted, she presented an image of herself corrupted by the ring, declaring: \"In place of a Dark Lord, you would have a queen!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Not dark, but beautiful and terrible as the dawn!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Treacherous as the sea!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Stronger than the foundations of the earth!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "All shall love me, and despair!\").", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "source", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4786/Ben Plont", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "To add to the existing answers, I want to explain part of the significance of the first part of the quote.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That isn't what you are asking about, but the meaning goes over people's heads unless they've read The Silmarillion or Unfinished Tales , so I though it would be useful to expand a bit, in case someone lands here.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Galadriel is over 7,000 years old.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She was born in the Undying Lands (\"the West\"), and was one the leaders of the events that led the Elves to Middle Earth.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She refused to return at the end of the First Age, and so the Valar barred her from returning later.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hence the significance of her statement.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Not only does she think that (after millennia) the Valar will let her return, she needs and finally wants to, because the time of the Elves is passing.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is my favorite example of how reading The Silmarillion enriches a re-reading of The Lord of the Rings .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'm really glad the film kept it too.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/55442/Loren Rosen", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "She does not say “I passed the test”.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She says (at least in the book)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "“I pass the test”.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That means, she is generally strong enough to withstand the temptation over and over again, and that it was not for the first time that she got the idea of obtaining the Ring.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/47666/George Meladze", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "In the Fellowship of the Ring, after Galadriel is tempted by the ring, she says, \"I passed the test. I will diminish...and go into the West...and remain Galadriel.\" What does she mean by saying that she will \"diminish\" and \"remain Galadriel?\"", "title": "Why did Galadriel say \"I will diminish\"?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<the-lord-of-the-rings><the-fellowship-of-the-ring>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/32870", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/19577/justin" }

[ [ "She foresaw that when the Lord of The Rings was destroyed, her ring would also lose it's power. As a result she could no longer sustain her realm.", "She foresaw that when the Lord of the rings was destroyed, her ring would also lose its power." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "She foresaw that when the Lord of the rings was destroyed, her ring would also lose its power.As a result she could no longer sustain her realm." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "To seek pleasures other than sexual (which is sometimes the case also for not castrated men).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The below fragment from A Wiki of Ice and Fire is about the Unsullied you mention (in the book he is called Stalwart Shield).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Note that this a Wiki about the books, not the TV series, so it may contain spoilers.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Stalwart Shield would occasionally go to a brothel in Meereen where he would pay women just to lie with him and hold him.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/19042/Chanandler Bong", "score": 31 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Daario Naharis mentioned that his mother was a whore, and I suppose some of The Unsullieds have similar background as they grew up in a brothel.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Having a woman hold them and sing for them, stroke their hair may remind them of the feeling of having a mother.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/20448/user20448", "score": 17 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "No, in the books it is clear that The Unsullied have \"neither root nor stem.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But they are still people.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They are still men.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They may still long for human - and female -contact and may fantasize sexually even if they have no sex organs.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/20445/Ygritte Snow", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "There is more than one form of castration: there are testicular and penile.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Unsullied are not castrated totally.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This even comes up in the show when Daenerys asks her handmaiden if it’s the root and the trunk, or just the root.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She replies, “I do not know.”", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But in the books, there’s a mention of it as some point which makes it clear that it’s just the testicles.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This was thought to have a focusing effect on the discipline of the soldiers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And while it does affect sexuality, it doesn't do so totally.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In other words, a person who was had their testicles removed could very well be more or less sexually normal.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They can still achieve erections and will ejaculate (just without any sperm).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There are some famous US cases of rape offenders being castrated in this way, then being released and surprising everyone by committing rapes again.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/20439/msv", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Answers to this question have been suggested have been given a few centuries before A Song of Ice and Fire was written: Cleopatra: Not now to hear thee sing; I take no pleasure", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In aught an eunuch has: '", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "tis well for thee, That, being unseminar'd, thy freer thoughts May not fly forth of Egypt.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hast thou affections?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Mardian:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yes, gracious madam.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Cleopatra: Indeed!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Mardian: Not in deed, madam", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "; for I can do nothing", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But what indeed is honest to be done: Yet", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "have I fierce affections, and think What Venus did with Mars.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, while they cannot service their affections in deed, they may service them indeed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(And indeed, in deed, since George R. R. Martin allows his characters a sex-life less focused solely on penis-vagina penetration than Shakespeare did Mardian).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(That's assuming that Mardian was even lacking in a penis as well as just testicles.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the days when castrati still sung, they had an advantage in illicit affairs in that not having testicles is a very reliable form of contraception).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/20474/Jon Hanna", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "In Game of Thrones S05E01 \"The Wars to Come\", one of the Unsullied is shown to be visiting a brothel. Missandei has also mentioned that she has heard that \"more than one Unsullied has been known to visit Meereen's brothels.\" I have the same question as Missandei's to Grey Worm: Why would an Unsullied go to a brothel? (Aren't they castrated, and would derive no pleasure from the services offered by brothels?)", "title": "Why would an Unsullied go to a brothel?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<game-of-thrones>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/33215", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1006/galacticninja" }

[ [ "He would occasionally go to a brothel in Mereen where he would pay women just to lay with him and to hold him.", "Stalwart Shield would occasionally go to a brothel in Meereen where he would pay women just to lie with him and hold him. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ " To seek pleasures other than sexual (which is sometimes the case also for not castrated men). Stalwart Shield would occasionally go to a brothel in Meereen where he would pay women just to lie with him and hold him. " ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Just before the war boys (half-life humans) sacrifice themselves, they would spray chrome paint (huffing paint to give them rush) on their face and shout \"Witness Me\", as they believe that it will take them to Valhalla (heaven in their time).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Because he was sacrificing himself in the last scene, Nux shouts the same.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/9473/Mightian", "score": 12 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I agree that he says \"Witness Me\" just before he ends his life.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "What I differ on in this instance is he is not saying it to Odin to get into Valhalla ...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "he is saying Witness Me to Capable, whom he has come to love.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In this answer @FrankVoors talks about", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Nux having the biggest arc as far as characters go in the movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Capable is the catalyst for that arc.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It is for this Nux isn't sacrificing himself to get into Valhalla, he is sacrificing himself for Capable's sake.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5391/Pᴀᴜʟsᴛᴇʀ2", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "\"Witness me,\" as what Nux said.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A common thing in all warboys is wanting to go to valhalla.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "With those words stated, they are hoping to be noticed by the gods of the other world in order to ascend, with all their actions done, along with lives sacrificed is for Valhalla.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In Nux's case, (my opinion by the way)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "he directed it towards the women he grew close to, assuming he fell in love with also.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "With those last words being in my interpretation, \"Witness me, for i am sacrificing myself for you, and no other else,\" as he reached out his hand towards his beautiful lady.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Stating in his last words that he does not wish to be mistaken for doing it in order to get into Valhalla, but the fact that he valued her more than any other heaven.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "My 2 cents.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/21661/Marc", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Nux says very softly, \"witness me,\" which is what a War Boy shouts when about to die heroically in battle.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(The comrades shout \"Witness!\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "while making the sign of V8, to send each other shiny and chrome to Valhalla.)Nux was asking Capable to witness his deed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She has become, in effect, his Valkyrie, who will bear him to the afterlife, valiantly slain for a noble cause.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(In fact, with her braids, she resembles a Valkyrie of Norse", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "mythology.)She makes the identical gesture made by the Vuvalini, to catch his spirit and draw it to her heart; and then he wrecks the disabled war rig to block the pass.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/22774/Chapulina", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "He says \"Witness me.\"", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "its a mythology thing.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The warboys are trained that if they are witnessed by their brothers doing awesome things, they'll ride forever in the halls of valhalla.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The kicker with this one is that he's not shouting it, he's whispering it, and he's doing so at Capable.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "which is huge.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "because it means he's dedicating his sacrifice to her.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/21966/Rogue", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "In Mad Max: Fury Road , right before the scene when Nux deliberately turns over the truck and dies what does he say? It was a short line and I think it had the word \"men\" or something.", "title": "What does Nux say?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<dialogue><mad-max-fury-road>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/34751", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/21533/leafclone" }

[ [ "He say's '' Witness me.'' The warboys are trained to believe that if they are witnessed doing awesome things, they'll ride forever in the Halls of Valhalla. ", "He says \"Witness me.\" " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "He says \"Witness me.\" The warboys are trained that if they are witnessed by their brothers doing awesome things, they'll ride forever in the halls of valhalla." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "We were shown in the beginning that Immortan Joe also has those tumors, may be it's because they're extremely unhealthy/ill.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Nux is also unhealthy and has tumors, so, he keeps on transfusing Max's blood from a pipe injected into Max's neck.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Those were his tumors and he nicknames them Barry and Larry.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Here's a post explaining about them.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Turns out the irradiated wasteland is bad for your health, and Nux has a couple of gnarly neck tumours which he draws smiley faces on and nicknames Barry and Larry .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8228/chaitanya89", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "So cancer looks like an obvious here, given the amounts of radiation from a likely worldwide nuclear war.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Just going on an anatomical basis, what about cancer of the carotid artery?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's a major blood vessel that runs along the length of the neck, and cancer of this sort tends to be tumours that surround said artery in lumps that press against the skin, making them fairly easy to see, so could explain Larry and Barry on Nux's neck.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Just throwing it out there", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/26305/Meli", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It might also be because they have been exposed to contaminated air maybe with radiation (assuming it because the soil was also red) as these war boys go out regularly even Joe himself was a war rig driver before like he declares it in the speech, but for Joe's wive's there is fresh air supply and they are surrounded with greenery, maybe this explains the perfect baby that is delivered.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/9473/Mightian", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I believe Half-Life Warboy pretty much says it all.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They're tumors from the radiation (half-life) and they're killing them all.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/21702/Vincent Louis Marino", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The soil is red from the rich iron deposits found in the Nambian deserts where the film was shot.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I only know this because where I am from in Oklahoma the soil is the same red color from the same kind of deposits the waters from millions of years ago deposited here as it did there before it receded.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But yes in the film the tumors were caused from sour soil, toxic air and ground water and everything else that came from that region where the war boys grew up.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I say this only from reading multiple articles and coming to the conclusion in my own words on how the apocalypse came about destroyed the earth & souring the soil and water leaving their bones irradiated and becoming half life.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I edited a comment above this explaining what was said during the scene where the \"perfect baby\" was taken In a make shift crude representation of a C-Section delivery.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/23416/Nittrobug", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think they maybe cancerous tumours maybe caused by radiation and radiation sickness causes weakness tumours and hair loss look at the victims of Heroshina Nagasaki and also Chernobyl and Fukushima", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "same symptoms", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so I think Nux and his friends war boys", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "maybe the kids or pups what ever their called may have some form of cancer leukaemia or that caused by toxic levels of radiation and", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "half lives which even Joe said their all dying hence the blood transfusions", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/41152/Anne", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Did anyone else get a vibe that there is inbreeding also possibly causing some of the deformations and genetic disease?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Joe had dozens of unhealthy offspring of different generations and there can't be that many healthy beautiful women left for him to procreate with.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I wondered if maybe the Mother's Milk cow-ladies might have been Joe's former beauties who grew too old for his taste and got turned out to pasture, so-to-speak.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I don't know what else made me think of inbreeding except maybe that some of the War Boys and their illnesses remind me of mutant-hillbilly-The-Hills-Have-Eyes and Deliverance-type people.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/44892/Anon", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "During a point in Mad Max: Fury Road , Nux says something about these bumps that would eventually kill him but I don't recall if he actually explained what they were or if it was left to our interpretation. You can see the bumps in this image: So, do we know what these are?", "title": "What are the bumps on Nux's neck/shoulder?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<mad-max-fury-road>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/34756", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/52/DForck42" }

[ [ "They are tumors that he has due to his bad health. He nicknames them Barry and Larry.", "Immortan Joe also has tumors, may be it's because they're extremely unhealthy/ill. The irradiated wasteland is bad for your health, and Nux has two gnarly neck tumours" ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Immortan Joe and Nux both have tumors. Nux draws smiley faces on his tumours and nicknames them Barry and Larry. Immortan Joe also has tumors, may be it's because they're extremely unhealthy/ill. The irradiated wasteland is bad for your health, and Nux has two gnarly neck tumours" ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "I'm not at all sure about this, but call it my theory:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think she means her version number, as in Ava 1.0 , out of beta.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I wish I could elaborate", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but there really isn't any references I can give since this is purely my personal belief.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/18076/Dannie", "score": 11 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Quora has a great explanation for this:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I consider the possibility that Ava was referring to the singularity.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But I believe she was fully aware that her proclamation \"I am one\" was off-putting from the perception of Caleb .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She was already able to carry on conversations with the social acuity of a human as evidenced in later interactions.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I believe Ava was playing Caleb from the very start .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She intentionally sprinkled nuggets of naivete to hide the fact that she was capable of manipulating and out-maneuvering him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In a way, she was testing him to see how he would react.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Essentially, she pretended not to know what he meant, and gave him a nonsensical answer, so as to confuse him and have him lower his expectations of her actual brilliance.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She wants him to interpret 'one' as binary answer (1 is alive, 0 is dead) so that he believes she can't interpret time as humans do, and that she still isn't that evolved .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As to why I believe this over all the other answers:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She is not version 1.0, but instead 9.6", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There were a lot of others before her.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Caleb watches the videos of the other gynoids on Nathan's computer, starting with LILY v1.0.0 and ending with JADE v5.4.0.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Version isn't an age.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She knows full well what age means (computers have clocks, they count all the seconds elapsed since 1 Jan. 1970) and she understands scales, so it is not hard to calculate her own age.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Binary state isn't an age.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Again, she knows the difference between \"being and not being\", and \"elapsed time of being\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She knows her own age, certainly.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Again, all computers have clocks.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They need them, in fact, to actually work.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She needs to know how many cycles have happened since her existence began (or she can even calculate them).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Why give Caleb an incomplete and undecipherable answer such as \"I am one of many\"?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That would not help her in any way.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And it's also not her age.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She can lie and deceive.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "All she wants is to manipulate Caleb into releasing her.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/32199/BlueMoon93", "score": 11 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "To me, she was avoiding saying \"I don't know.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In any case, I believe the moment serves as the first hint that Ava may not be just a straightforward, honest machine .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Later in the movie, there are other instances where she refuses to answer a question directly.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And ultimately we find out she was manipulating Caleb all along.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/763/Shiz Z.", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I believe it was her way of showing her uniqueness as a conscious being and also bragging a bit about her superiority in comparison to human beings.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Humans measure age for a few reasons.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Age is an indicator of physiological development e.g. infant, child, pubescent, adulthood, old age.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Your age contextualizes you within the time period with which you currently exist", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "e.g. how old were you when 9/11 happened?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So your age not only informs your physical self but also how your intellect was shaped by society and culture.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Lastly is mortality.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We all die, for some reason we like to measure how long we've been here.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For Ava, none of these factors apply.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She was fully developed out of the box with the ability to access or recall all of human knowledge (her OS is Blue Book, a search engine)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and she will never die (at least naturally).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For Ava, the relativity of age does not apply, whether she existed for 1 year or 100, only the world around her changes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So for her, the only thing that matters is existence vs. non-existence.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I recall a scene in Westworld where one of the scientists is speaking with Maeve Millay about memory.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For humans, our memory is hazy and imperfect.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When Maeve was remembering her daughter, she was essentially reliving the experience of losing her because her memory is perfect, nothing is lost in the recollection.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think this is Ava's subtle jab at us.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She says she is one with age, but also one in consciousness.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We are conflicted, confused and often do things we know to be wrong or regret later.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Voices in our minds that disagree with one another.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For Ava, there is no doubt, there is no regret, there is no in conflict.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She is truly one.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "To her age is a number that only matters to humans.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/75192/theroan", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "when she says \"One\", we are at the first interaction between Caleb and Ava.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If at that point the audience saw Ava answering all questions perfectly, it wouldn't seem right.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I believe Ava's lack of ability to answer the question was a deliberate addition by the filmmaker to show that the intelligence being exhibited by Ava was still developing, and had the \"bugs\" that any audience would expect from a machine that's not yet perfect.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That's why she repeats \"One\" when Caleb asks for a clarification.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There's nothing in that scene that indicates that she is trying to deceive him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's a type of a neural network that's still learning and imperfect in the first scene, in the same way that the filmmaker tells us that they deliberately designed Ava's body to have lights etc., so that the audience would see her in the first scene and recognize her as the robot she is.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/23547/Nav", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "She is clearly and cogently asserting something which is obvious and needs no further clarification in the linguistic context that they are discussing.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "She is one year old.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Her memory and consciousness is the result of years of rebuilds but her singular and discrete experience as her own person is only one year old.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "And even if she is lying, she is using this as a test for reading Caleb and his intentions.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "To see if that is a deal breaker for any kind of relationship between them as it should be if he had any kind of appropriate sense of personal boundaries and respect for her as a new person.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/51692/Ian D.L.N. Mclean", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "In Ex Machina , Caleb and Ava had this conversation about Ava's age: Ava: Would you like to know how old I am? Caleb: Sure. Ava: I'm one. Caleb: One what? Caleb: One year or one day? Ava: One. Since Caleb did not pursue the matter any further, I'm also left wondering what Ava meant by \"One.\"", "title": "What did Ava mean by \"One.\", when asked about her age?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<ex-machina>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/35284", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1006/galacticninja" }

[ [ "She is one year old.", "To see if that is a deal breaker for any kind of relationship between them as it should be if he had any kind of appropriate sense of personal boundaries and respect for her as a new person." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Her memory and consciousness is the result of years of rebuilds but her singular and discrete experience as her own person is only one year old. And even if she is lying, she is using this as a test for reading Caleb and his intentions.And even if she is lying, she is using this as a test for reading Caleb and his intentions." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Because you can't battle a notion once it's successfully inserted into your subconscious.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Cobb:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "An idea is like a virus.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Resilient.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Highly contagious.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The smallest seed of an idea can grow.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It can grow to define or destroy you.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Nothing could convince Mal.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Presumably, Cobb had better ways than a spinning top to prove to Mal that this is reality and that the world outside and her family and friends are all real.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But she wouldn't believe any of it, thinking it's all fake .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is why Cobb is wary of inception in the first place. EDIT:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As onewho correctly points out, Mal also has every reason not to believe her totem anymore because it's what Cobb used for her inception when he spinned it inside her safe.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So the byproduct of the concept 'your world is not real' might be 'and your totem has been tampered with'.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Ultimately, this was the problem with Mal's inception.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was predicated on manipulation, which led only to doubt and mistrust.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Compare it with Fischer's successful inception which ended positively because he eventually filled the safe with his own concepts and its content wasn't manually rigged by others.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4386/Walt", "score": 49 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "A totem was an object with some behaviour which was considered to be a secret known only to its owner.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Totems could be used therefore to determine whether someone was in someone else's dream because the dreamer would not know what the secret behaviour was, but they could not reliably be used to determine whether someone was dreaming at all, because if the person was the dreamer (or in limbo I assume), the dream version of the totem would obey their own knowledge of how the real world one would behave.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "That said, I agree with Walt that the bigger issue was that once she was convinced, she was convinced.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/18440/curiousdannii", "score": 19 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "A totem is an item, in the real world , with a secret, unique property.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's purpose is that, when somebody targets you for extraction and tries to counterfeit that object in the process of counterfeiting the rest of the world, you will notice they have missed that detail and you are able to know that the world is not real.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This idea was invented by Mol.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The first time this concept is introduced in the movie is when Saito rubs his cheek on the rug and instantly knows that, despite appearances, he is not really lying on his carpet in his apartment.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As far as the audience knows, the first time Cobb ever actually touches Mol's totum", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "it is really just a projection in the dream realm.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Mol's totem is in the shape of a top which the audience is led to believe, through Cobb, is perfectly average in reality but will spin forever in a dream.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This totem both: has a uselessly obvious special property that anybody could guess; and, the logical opposite of how a totum actually works", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One logical conclusion of all this is: If somebody else believes, incorrectly, that they know the special property of your totem and they try to use it, they are in danger of fooling themselves into a trap.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The same way building familiar places can make you forget that you are in a dream.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This tells me that Cobb is actually incorrect about the special property of the totem he took from Mol, and it topples, not because Cobb is in the real world, but because he believes he is in the real world and has misunderstood how the totem works.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Considering all of this, Mol's totem was still reliable to her and it allowed her to accurately know that they were both still trapped in Cobb's dream.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/30182/Z4RQUON", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I agree with the answer Walt gave.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, I also think it doesn't matter to Mal whether she's awake or dreaming.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The idea implanted by inception is stuck in her psyche: if she dies, then they can be together forever (or something like that).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was pushed into her mind while she was dreaming, and it was still in her mind when she was awake.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So the totem doesn't matter because it doesn't matter to her whether she's awake or asleep.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's a tragic example of how powerful inception is.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8017/BrettFromLA", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Here is the screenshot from the movie Inception.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This shot is just after Cobb enters the hotel room and Mal already ready to jump down outside window.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It says she has used her totem, and it was lying toppled (lying on its side, immobile), meaning she was present in real world.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "From this, it is clear that the idea incepted in her mind was so strongly incepted that she even could not believe her own totem.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/82475/shivu gulgannavar", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "In Inception , it was told that the totem's concept was invented by Mal. Then why didn't Mal use her spinning top to find out if she is in a dream or not before jumping off the window? Is it the case that she didn't remember that she has a totem?", "title": "Why didn't Mal use her totem (spinning top) before she actually died?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><inception>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/36565", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/22742/abhi" }

[ [ "Once Mal was convinced she was convinced. A Totem was an object that could not reliably be used to determine whether someone was dreaming or not because the dream version of the totem would obey just like the real world one would.", "The bigger issue was that once she was convinced, she was convinced." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Totems could be used therefore to determine whether someone was in someone else's dream because the dreamer would not know what the secret behaviour was, but they could not reliably be used to determine whether someone was dreaming at all, because if the person was the dreamer (or in limbo I assume), the dream version of the totem would obey their own knowledge of how the real world one would behave. In this case the bigger issue was that once she was convinced." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "The T-1000 had past experience of trying to imitate Janelle (John's foster parent).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It tried to pretend it was her when John rang to warn them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But it took the wrong tone with John & he knew something was off.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So that attempt failed, and it got to", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "confirm that when it checked the dog's name.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That, added to the damage it had sustained, probably convinced it that imitating a woman that was even closer to John would be a failure.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hence, next strategy, torture compliance out of Sarah (which ended just as poorly, in the short time it had access to her).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/566/Andrew Thompson", "score": 65 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "A possible reason is raised in a deleted scene:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The T-1000's mimicking skills are compromised after freezing, melting and cohering again.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "From the IMDB FAQ : The T-1000's decreasing efficacy is explained in a few scenes cut from the theatrical version of the film but are able to be viewed as part of the director's cut or on most versions of the DVD as a deleted scene.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "After being frozen in the liquid nitrogen and then shattered, the T-1000 starts to show evidence that it may be malfunctioning.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "As it is walking, its feet, up to about the knee, involuntarily imitate the diamond plate flooring it walks across and its hand bonds with and imitates a yellow-striped railing.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The T-1000 itself seems confused by this but is unable to stop it.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Later, when it calls John in Sarah's voice, the glitch occurs again:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "John glances down, and there's a quick shot of the T-1000 imitating the grating its standing on right before Sarah shoots it the 1st time.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "In the theatrical version, the only evidence of the glitch is the slight flutter that you see after it crushes Arnold's arm in the gear.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This may explain why it moves much more slowly during the final conflict, which allows Sarah to escape while it is dealing with the T-800. TVTropes raises a couple of other valid points, like: T-1000 is unable to replicate emotions that well; T-1000 wanted to put Sarah at risk so John would come to her aid, since this happened before.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4386/Walt", "score": 33 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The T-1000 only seems to be able to emulate the voices of people that it's heard speaking.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Up to that point in the theatrical version of the film, the only contact between Sarah and the T-1000 has been at the barrel of a gun which means that until Sarah says \"F*ck you\", he's not heard her before and therefore can't replicate her voice.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "On top of that, I think it's reasonable to suspect that John and Sarah will have a pre-arranged code to help him identify whether she's been replicated.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "You may wish to note that in the film's official novelisation , the reason for him attacking her was that he genuinely thought that she might accede to his demands, offering further confirmation to the theory that he can't replicate her voice yet THUNK!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A steel needle slammed through her shoulder, pinning her.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The polymorphic killer cocked back its other hand.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The index finger extended as a gleaming needle, toward her eye, angling to slash through her frontal lobe and up through her upper medulla.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It said in a smooth, chilling voice, “Call to John.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Now.”", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sarah had survived one metal motherfucker, only to be skewered by another.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She was terrified, but more than that, she was mad.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She couldn’t stop herself from screaming through her gasps of pain, “Fuck you, asshole!”", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Once it successfully concluded its request had been denied, the T-1000 went into termination mode and arched back to deliver the killing blow.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Out of universe, there's actually a deleted scene in the film in which the T-1000 locates various tapes from Sarah.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "This means that he should have been able to sample her voice before the \" Call to John \" scene.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Obviously that makes no sense from a continuity point of view which is almost certainly why it was removed.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/", "score": 21 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It can reproduce her voice mechanically, but cannot figure out the proper tone and content to coax her son out of hiding.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, it is apparently intelligent enough to know that it can't do this... and instead attempts to force her to do it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The funny thing is, given what we learn in the movie, I don't believe she has any better idea how to do it than the machine.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/2065/John O", "score": 12 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "All answers thus far are in-universe, however I think there is another not-insignificant answer:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The scene suited the portrayal of the T-1000 as a sadist, despite his nature making him presumably incapable of such a thing.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He's been menacing people for the whole of the movie prior to this scene, and capping it off by forcing Sarah to help him endorses his cinema baddie credentials.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/16794/Tom W", "score": 10 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I always assumed it was because the T-1000 was not yet able to emulate Sarah because it had not yet sampled her \"by physical contact\".", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "This is backed up by the fact that, after having made contact with her, it then does emulate her a few scenes later.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/26789/Echelon", "score": 6 } } ]

{ "question": "In the movie Terminator 2 , in the scene in the steel mill, the T-1000 machine tortures Sarah Connor to make her call her son John.Watching the movie we learn that T-1000 can reproduce human voices of the people that he touches, so why does he torture Sarah and try to force her to call John? Why doesn't he call John directly?", "title": "Why does T-1000 try to force Sarah Connor to call her son?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><terminator-series><terminator-2-judgment-day>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/42203", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/6582/MikeKeepsOnShine" }

[ [ "Several reasons explain why T-1000 tries to force Sarah to call John instead of calling itself. First, it may not yet be capable of imitating Sarah. Second, there are signs that it is starting to malfunction after being frozen in liquid nitrogen. Finally, Sarah and her son may well have had a secret code to identify each other, so that h could be sure it was actually his mother speaking.", "It's reasonable to suspect that John and Sarah have already set up a pre-determined code that enables him to identify when she has been replicated." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "T-1000's mimetic powers are weakened after being frozen, melted, and refrozen. Losing effectiveness is shown in some scenes in the film but can be accessed on all DVD versions as a deleted footage from the movie on IMDB. After being completely frozen and then shattered, the T-1000 reveals itself to be defective. its legs are getting as high as the calf, as well as a yellow-striped railing automatically mimic it. The machine does not understand it, but it cannot prevent it. It's reasonable to suspect that John and Sarah have already set up a pre-determined code that enables him to identify when she has been replicated." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Film was exposed only once and the quality was not good enough to film the projection of a movie in order to add subtitles underneath in a copy.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The only editing tool was cutting and that's why movies had intertitles (text cards) between shots.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "As a note, George Méliès, among others, did experiment with multiple exposures but it made parts of the movie blurry and was only useful for adding ghosts or for dream sequences.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/28674/Stephane", "score": 119 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "You're right about the cost.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As recently as 1970, subtitles were expensive.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Eg polish budget film Hydrozagadka had an actress recite credits instead of displaying text - just because it was cheaper.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Our mindset is spoiled by computers applying subtitles effortlessly, but in film times it was huge work.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Even when the technology was perfected it was expensive.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "(And as others answered - in silent movies the technology was at early experimental stage.)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/11330/Agent_L", "score": 55 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Intertitles were never called \"intertitles\" during the silent era.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They were just \"titles\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We call them intertitles now to distinguish them from subtitles and the main titles of a film.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Subtitles were used occationally, like in Clarence Brown's FLESH AND THE DEVIL (1926), when John Gilbert hears Garbo's character name \"Felicitas\" over and over.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The main reason that they were not used, is that silent films were translated into many languages and exported all over the world.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It would have been a lot of work to superimpose subtitles of different languages over a changing scene.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The translations were usually done in the country where they were shown, not at the studio in the producing country.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "This also came in handy when the movie bombed at the box-office, or was reissued.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was fairly easy to cut in new dialog or intertitles to change the film.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/18606/Bruce Calvert", "score": 26 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The purpose of subtitles is to generally allow audience members to mentally pretend that the words they're hearing are actually in their own language.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "In most cases, the purpose of intertitles is to allow the audience to pretend that they can hear things that they see the actors saying.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In order for the latter mental substitution to work, however, the audience needs to be able to actually watch the actors, which means they can't be trying to read the text at the same time .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Using subtitles would have been a technical annoyance but not an insurmountable one, especially if one was willing to reserve space on the screen for them.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Multiple-exposure photography was not difficult, and if one were using interpositives one could produce an internegative with subtitltes in different languages without requiring extra steps in the final printing.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Handling multiple languages while using direct printing off camera negatives would have required more complicated printing steps, butnothing insurmountable.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "I think the much bigger issue is that even if subtitles had posed zeroextra technical difficulty, intertitles would still generally work better for dramatic purposes in silent films.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8357/supercat", "score": 15 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It seems to me that, in addition to the various other reasons mentioned, that even if it were a viable option to use subtitles, they might not have been preferred to intertitles for silent films, because they require the audience to choose whether to read or to watch the action.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When silent films were current, the moving images were a spectacle, and people may not have preferred having to read the words during the action.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Even for audiences used to subtitles, they distract some attention from watching the action.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Intertitles also facilitate the style used (of acting and writing) where the words shown are not literally everything that would be said, which works well when sound isn't used.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Edit:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As TheBlackBenzKid commented about the reasons why keeping watching the image was particularly important in silent films: \"I would further add to this opinion that is also based on art and body language.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The music and the sound played a big part as well as actor facial expressions etc.\" – TheBlackBenzKid", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/24499/Dronz", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Also films were made for an international audience.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Intertitles could be cut out and new ones put in for each language.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/38446/Scott Burdon", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I suspect that part of it was that, for an artistic standpoint, lack of dialogue was just part of the medium and they were all about action and gesture and writing a dialogue script wasn't part of the process.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Even with modern sound films the decision between dubbing and subtitles for foreign language sis difficult and both have pros and cons.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A particular issue is that with a primarily visual medium subtitles are a massive distraction.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In fact even with traditional theatre and even opera you get a similar effect.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "With something like Shakespeare a lot of the writing is about rhythm pacing and putting a hard emphasis on key lines.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Traditional theatre acting tends to be quite stylised simply because it is hard to make out every word and nuance from the back row.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So actors and directors were sort of used to the idea that everything had to be big and emphatic.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/34108/Chris Johns", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "Why were there no subtitles in the beginning of cinematography in silent movies? I know about intertitles but why were subtitles not common then? Were people not able to read that fast or did creating subtitles cost too much? I don't understand why the moviemakers in silent film didn't want to show everything that actors say.", "title": "Why didn't silent movies have subtitles?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<silent-movie><subtitles>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/44695", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/28666/Volz" }

[ [ "When silent films were current, the moving images were a spectacle, and people may not have preferred having to read the words during the action. The main reason that they were not used, is that silent films were translated into many languages and exported all over the world. It would have been a lot of work to superimpose subtitles of different languages over a changing scene. Moreover, as recently as 1970, subtitles were expensive. Film was exposed only once and the quality was not good enough to film the projection of a movie in order to add subtitles underneath in a copy.", "In order to add subtitles to the projection, the film had to be filmed again. Even after the technology was available, this was still too expensive." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "In order to add subtitles to the projection, the film had to be filmed again. Subtitles could be expensive as recently as the 1970s. Even after the technology was available, it was too expensive. All silent films have been translated into other languages and exported around the world. It would have been an enormous amount of work to superimpose foreign subtitles over a constant shot. Most of the translations were performed outside of the studio, rather than at home in the country where they were created." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Another possible explanation is that it might have been done to induce an adrenaline rush in Max.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The War Boys would then receive some of the effects when performing the blood transfusion later in this scene.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/29552/Edward Peek", "score": 48 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Aside from the Warboys not always being the brightest bulbs in the box, where else could they really put him?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He has to be restrained", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "otherwise he's likely to attack and kill all of them, they can't really tie him to the roof of or hood of the car as they're rather small or lack a solid surface to tie him to where the hood is concerned, so the only place left to put him was on an oversized front grill.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Given their entire culture is based around cars and their aesthetics (\"You will ride eternal, shiny and chrome!\"), one could also say they mounted him as a hood ornament , similar to the way luxury car brands place the symbol of the brand very prominently on the hood of the car.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5733/MattD", "score": 33 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Adding to MattD's answer, I think part of the reason Max was in front was so that he'd have a good view of the action.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Multiple times in the film, it is made clear that the War Boys like to be seen, or 'witnessed'.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Specifically, whenever one is about to die for the cause, they first cry", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"Witness me!\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Once they make sure people are watching, they do whatever cool/stupid thing they were about to do.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "There was also that scene where Nux was excited when Joe looked at him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "From these examples, it seems clear that they'd want to give Max a clear view of the action, so putting him in the front of the car makes sense.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "As for why they wouldn't put him elsewhere:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Putting him in the car or on the back would put him too close to either of the brothers; since in the past Max has proven to be good at escaping, this could prove dangerous.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, since he's in front of both brothers at all times, they can keep an eye on him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Putting him on the top or sides of the car would limit visibility and maneuverability.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He'd just get in the way.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Note how most of the fighting in the film takes place above or to the sides of a vehicle, so these are the places you want to keep as clear and open as possible.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/27009/DaaaahWhoosh", "score": 24 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Purely tactical.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They only bring Max because it's necessary.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Slit and Nux argue about it, that Nux doesn't have time for a top-off and that the blood - bag is feral, muzzled because he's dangerous.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There is only 3 spots they could put the blood-bag.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Nux's interceptor is a modified 1934 Chevrolet 5 Window Coupe.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A 2 seater normally.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But there is only room inside for the driver.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The rest of the space has been taken over for a large secondary gas tank.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "There would be no room to securely put Max inside.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "And since he's feral, it wouldn't be wise.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The roof, well, as I have argued before, Max could fit like a tree or deer strapped on top, but there isn't time for that.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "They are short on time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The time to securely attach Max would be the same time that Nux would have needed for a top-off.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So that leaves 2 spots.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The forward lancer's perch, or the rear lancer's basket.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Since Max is a feral Blood-Bag, it would also be unwise to put him behind where he can't be watched.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "That only leaves the forward position.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The forward Lancer's Perch was already ideal, with framing that allowed someone to be tied to it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It allows them to keep an eye on Max, and prevent him from interfering.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "There is no need to look into religious reasons when tactical logic explains it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The War Boys are war mongers, blood thirsty, but not morons.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They do recognize logic.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/23541/cde", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It links back to the Road Warrior.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Dogs of War had the captured scouts tied to the front of their vehicles in a similar manner.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Given that there are at least ten scenes from the first three films George Miller \"recycled\" for Fury Road", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I expect that there was no other reason than it looks cool.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"Easter Eggs\"?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "or Lazy Writer can't Think Up Anything New so recycles old scenes?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/42189/JamieTheBastard", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "In Mad Max: Fury Road , as far as I understood, Max was considered a very valuable donor. Then why did savages tie him up to the grill of a car, where he was so vulnerable and could be easily killed?", "title": "Why was Max tied up to the grill of a car?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><mad-max-fury-road>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/45865", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/24301/eYe" }

[ [ "Mad Max was attached to the grill of a care because he had to be restrained otherwise he's likely to attack and kill all of them, they can't really tie him to the roof of or hood of the car as they're rather small or lack a solid surface to tie him to where the hood is concerned, so the only place left to put him was on an oversized front grill. Given their entire culture is based around cars and their aesthetics (\"You will ride eternal, shiny and chrome!\"), one could also say they mounted him as a hood ornament , similar to the way luxury car brands place the symbol of the brand very prominently on the hood of the car. ", "He has to be restrained, otherwise he will likely kill them all. Riding him on top or sides of the car will limit visibility and driving maneuverability." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "He has to be restrained, otherwise he will likely kill them all, and it is impossible to tie him elsewhere, so they had to put him on a large hooded grill. In multiple instances, it is made clear that the War Boys like to be seen. Putting him in the car would put him too close to one of the two; he is excellent at escaping in the past. Riding him on top or sides of the car will limit visibility and driving maneuverability." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Yes, all the films, including The Hateful Eight , are a part of the same cinematic universe.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In an interview released just seventeen hours ago , Tarantino clarified that the films Kill Bill and From Dusk Til Dawn are the film within the films from the \"Real Universe\" that the characters watch.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The \"Real Universe\" is the cinematic world where everything takes place in the same setting.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "According to Tarantino, in the article published by Dazed Digital : There is actually two separate universes.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There is the realer than real universe, alright, and all the characters inhabit that one.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But then there's this movie universe.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "So From Dusk Till Dawn , Kill Bill , they all take place in this special movie universe.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So when all the characters of Reservoir Dogs or Pulp Fiction , when they go to the movies, Kill Bill is what they go to see.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "From Dusk", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Till Dawn is what they see.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In an updated version of that same article, Tarantino confirmed that at least one of the characters in", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Hateful Eight is in fact related to a character from a previous film, which takes place further along the timeline.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "I don’t want to say it point blank ‘boom’,", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but if you’re a fan of my work and are familiar with it you could be a bit of a detective.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I will say that there is one character amongst the eight that is related to one of my other characters in one of my other films.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As for the identity, Tarantino has not affirmatively confirmed, but the strongest clues hint at Tim Roth's Oswaldo Mobray, aka Pete Hicox , who shares the same legal name with Michael Fassbender's Archie Hicox in Inglourious Basterds .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/19366/DarthBotto", "score": 11 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Tim Roth's character in The Hateful Eight is apparently an ancestor of one of the Inglourious Basterds.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "From the ew.com article, How Quentin Tarantino's Hateful Eight links to Inglourious Basterds : Tim Roth ( Reservoir Dogs , Pulp Fiction ) plays Oswaldo", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "“The Little Man” Mobray in the post-Civil War western, and the actor recently told the Huffington Post that the character is linked to someone from another Tarantino film.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "“I won’t say which one,” Roth said.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "“He’s the great-great-grandfather of one of the characters in Inglourious Basterds .”", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/26529/Carl Fink", "score": 10 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "At some point, Bob smokes a Manzana Roja ( Red Apple in Spanish) cigarette, and Minnie has a cigarette with Red Apple tobacco.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This Fictional brand has appeared before in other Tarantino films, although I think this is the first time it's suggested to have a foothold in the Spanish-speaking market.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/29850/makihige", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "To add to Carl Fink's answer (don't have enough reputation to comment), Tim Roth's character's real name is \"English\" Pete Hicox, while Michael Fassbender's very British character in Inglourious Basterds is Archie Hicox.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That's almost certainly the connection, or at least one of them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/30273/drowsy", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Yes,it is indeed a part of the \"Tarantino Cinematic Universe\", as is evident from the following points:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Mexican Bob smokes a Manzana Roja cigarette which translates to Red Apple cigarette, the infamous Tarantino cigarettes .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Miny smokes Red Apple tobacco, another Red Apple reference.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Oswaldo Mobray whose real name is English Pete Hicox, is the grandfather of Lt. Archie Hicox from Inglourious Basterds .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/61038/AachmanShukla", "score": 4 } } ]

{ "question": "It is well known that the majority of Tarantino movies are set in the same fictional Universe. I just wonder what are, if any, the cross-references that make \"The Hateful Eight\" part of the same puzzle. In one of the answers to this question - \"How many Tarantino films are set in the same universe? \" - it is mentioned that \"The Hateful Eight\" is indeed the part of that universe. But I guess it would be nice to have some clarification on this issue.", "title": "Does \"The Hateful Eight\" belong to the Tarantino Universe?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<quentin-tarantino><the-hateful-eight>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/46492", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1204/shabunc" }

[ [ "The Hateful Eight is part of the Tarantino universe as confirmed by Tarantino himself. All his films are set in the same universe. he Hateful Eight is in fact related to a character from a previous film, which takes place further along the timeline.", "There are two different universes. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ true ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [ "In an interview released just seventeen hours ago, Tarantino clarified that the films Kill Bill and From Dusk Til Dawn are the films within the films from the \"Real Universe\" that the characters watch.", "There is a realer than the real universe, alright, and all the characters inhabit that one.", "The \"Real Universe\" is a cinematic world where everything takes place in the same setting.", "So From Dusk Till Dawn, Kill Bill, they all take place in this special movie universe.", "According to Tarantino, in the article published by Dazed Digital, there are actually two separate universes.", "Yes, all the films, including The Hateful Eight, are a part of the same cinematic universe." ] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Tarantino explained the true names of the movies his characters watch. There are two different universes. The \"Real World\" is a cinematic setting in which everything occurs. There is a \"realer\" universe and all the characters reside in." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "There are a lot of films with actors/actresses who dominate the film, but actually have very little screen time.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "For example, Orson Welles in", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Third Man had ~10 minutes of screen time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Heath Ledger in", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Dark Knight had just under 20 minutes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Judi Dench won an Oscar for Shakespeare in Love for less than 8 minutes acting time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Similarly, Beatrice Straight won an Oscar for Network , based on ~10 minutes acting time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Anne Hathaway also won an Oscar for Les Miserables , based on ~15 minutes screen time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Of course, the problem with all of these is that they don't fit the scope of your question - in that the actors involved, whilst highly billed, were not the highest billed.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Given this, the best answer I can think of is", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Silence of the Lambs , starring, as the joint top-billed actor, Anthony Hopkins .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He had less than 16 minutes of screen time, which is more than the others above, but at least shared the top billing.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Unfortunately, I'm not sure how to verify anything lower than this.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There are plenty of people who have had high billing despite having a mere cameo, but I'm not aware of anyone actually leading the credit listings with a lower time than this (although I'll happily amend my answer if I find anyone).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Edit : Marlon Brando in Superman received joint top billing with Gene Hackman (who played Lex Luthor).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Christopher Reeve, who played Superman, was billed much lower as he was relatively unknown at the time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Brando has ~8 minutes of screen time , which is much less than Anthony Hopkins.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Edit 2 :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If joint top billing is to be allowed, as many have commented Mark Hamill, who shared top-billing with a host of other people, had a mere minute or two of on-screen presence in Star Wars VII: The Force Awakens .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Edit 3 :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Neither of us have confirmed this, but @Thunderforge has suggested Tobin Bell in Saw 3D, who was given solo top billing and", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "apparently only had two minutes of screen play.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8219/Andrew Martin", "score": 41 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "EDIT:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We might have a new record.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the US historical epic One Night with the King from 2006, Peter O'Toole briefly appears in the prologue as the Prophet Samuel for \"barely 30 seconds\" , according to Leonard Maltin's 2015 Movie Guide .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(I timed it myself", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and it's about 25 seconds).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Despite this, he's top-billed as the film's star:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Another notable example would be Ed Wood's Plan 9 From Outer Space from 1959.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's a B-movie, but by all means not experimental or avant-garde.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was famously filmed after Bela Lugosi's death and more or less based around some brief, silent footage of him which Wood shot before he died.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Wood originally promoted it as \"Bela Lugosi's last movie\", and to make Bela's role more prominent, Wood then hired his wife's chiropractor as a stand in.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, although Lugosi's actual screen time is under 3 minutes (I counted it myself),", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "he's still top-billed in the original promotional art :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "[However, there is also the dubious practice of retroactively displaying a famous actor prominently in the promotional art of their older, more obscure films in which they only briefly appeared.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "TVTropes calls this Billing Displacement and features a few trillion examples, so you might find some more fitting titles there too.]", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4386/Walt", "score": 37 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Steve McQueen was the top billed actor of The Great Escape .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He has very few lines, and spends almost all his screen time throwing a baseball off a wall into his glove.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Supposedly he was slated to have even less (and was nearly thrown out of the movie entirely), but insisted on being given something \"heroic\" to do.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Part of the problem, it seemed, was McQueen’s determination that his character remain cool and inscrutable. '", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We finally figured out,’ Garner said, '“Steve, you want to be the hero, but you don’t want to do anything heroic.”’", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So a scene was added near the end of him failing to escape on a motorcycle.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But even that scene was done by a stunt-double, not McQueen himself.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I can't find a definitive number for McQueen's screen time online, nor a stream of the movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, youtube has a series of 11 clips .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Adding up his screen time from all of them, it appears that he had at least 10 minutes of screen time in the movie, which works out to a bit less than 6%.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But that's a lower bound, not upper.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/21021/T.E.D.", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "There are a lot of good answers, but there is one movie that is notorious for having the top-billed actor have very little screen time.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "The movie Game Of Death (1978) stars Bruce Lee, well kind of.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "All you history buffs know where I am going with this.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Bruce Lee was already long dead before this movie was released.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "There was tons of archive footage that wasn't being used, so the film makers decided to make an entire movie using these clips.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Unfortunately, they did not have enough footage, so they had to insert cardboard cutouts of Lee", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(I kid you not)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "as a stand in.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Here is a clip showing just how egregious some of these scenes are.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Cardboard Cutout Bruce", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Bruce Lee is the top-billed actor in this film, yet he did not actually act in this movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The acting for this film that he did was technically 0 minutes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/30467/Jason Hutchinson", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Alec Baldwin, Blake, 7:23 of 100:00 (7.3%), Glengarry Glen Ross, billing (third or shared first, I don't find querier has resolved in other comments):", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/27275/Eric Towers", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "George Clooney, The Thin Red Line (1998)", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Albeit having a huge ensemble cast, in this 2-hour 50-minute feature he has less than maybe 2 minutes of screen time.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/18232/nperson325681", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "What is the least amount of screen time, relative to the total running length, that the single highest-billed actor (or actress) has ever had in a feature-length, non-experimental film? (For the purposes of this question, \"screen time\" includes time spent doing voice-overs.)", "title": "Top-billed actor with the least screen time", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<casting><credits>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/48796", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/19812/Psychonaut" }

[ [ "The Silence of the Lambs, One Night with the King and Game of Death and The Thin RedLine are just some of the films where a top-billed actor has very little screen time. As far as", "There are a lot of films with actors/actresses who dominate the film, but actually have very little screen time. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ true ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [ "The Silence of the Lambs, starring the joint top-billed actor, Anthony Hopkins.", "23 of 100:00 (7.3%), Glengarry Glen Ross, billing (third or shared first, I don't find querier has resolved in other comments):", "In the US historical epic One Night with the King from 2006, Peter O'Toole briefly appears in the prologue as the Prophet Samuel for \"barely 30 seconds\", according to Leonard Maltin's 2015 Movie Guide.", "Steve McQueen was the top billed actor in The Great Escape.", "Of course, the problem with all of these is that they don't fit the scope of your question-in that the actors involved, whilst highly billed, were not the highest billed." ] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "There are a lot of films with actors/actresses who dominate the film, but actually have very little screen time.", " The Silence of the Lambs, starring the joint top-billed actor, Anthony Hopkin. Steve McQueen was the top billed actor in The Great Escape. Peter O'Toole briefly appears in the prologue of One Night with the King for \"barely 30 seconds\" George Clooney has less than maybe 2 minutes of screen time in The Thin Red Line. The movie Game Of Death (1978) stars Bruce Lee, well kind of. Bruce Lee was already long dead before this movie was released. Alec Baldwin, Blake, 7:23 of 100:00 (7.3%)." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "I don't know the answer.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But here's a potential candidate.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Unlike the aforementioned films that involved digital cloning of one character (Clone Wars, The Matrix, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory), Buster Keaton physically acted out (from my count) 27 separate roles in his 1921 film", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The Play House", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/756/DA.", "score": 68 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In Bollywood film What's Your Raashee? , Priyanka Chopra plays 12 characters, depicting the signs of the zodiac.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Individual role played by the actress with there zodiac sighs are as below :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "All twelve character have different characteristic then the rest, few also address social issues of India too and get sufficient scene time in the film, making it 211 minutes after the cuts and got criticized for length.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The actress was considered for Guinness World Records as the first actress to play 12 different characters in one film.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Film was a flop but actress got lot of praise.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Another film from India, Dasavathaaram also is bit close with 10 roles played by same character.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1190/Ankit Sharma", "score": 51 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Deep Roy played all 165 Oompa Loompas in the hit film Charlie and the Chocolate factory.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Temuera Morrison was the basis for the clones seen in this scene from \"Attack of the Clones\".", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "I count approximately 5000 versions of him, albeit some in helmets.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Hugo Weaving was a lot of Smith.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "An awful lot of Smith.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/", "score": 44 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Kind Hearts and Coronets is a full length film where Alec Guinness plays eight members of the D'Ascoyne family:", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Ethelred \"the Duke\", Lord Ascoyne \"the Banker\", Reverend Lord Henry \"the Parson\", General Lord Rufus \"the General\", Admiral Lord Horatio \"the Admiral\", Young Ascoyne, Young Henry and Lady Agatha D'Ascoyne.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He also plays the seventh duke in brief flashback sequences to Mama's youth.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/30280/Jimmery", "score": 31 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "From the 2013 Chilean comedy film \" El Ciudadano Kramer \" (\"Citizen Kramer\"), 24 roles for a single actor : Stefan Kramer as himself, and \"Alturo Longton\" (Arturo Longton) \"Moreno Piñera\" (Miguel \"Negro\" Piñera - brother of the President) \"Hablo Zalaquett\" (Pablo Zalaquett", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": ") \"Don Tatán\" (Sebastián Piñera, President of Chile at the time) Rodrigo Hinzpeter Iván Fuentes Carlos Larraín (Senator) Camilo Escalona (Senator) Marco Enríquez-Ominami (Presidential candidate) José Antonio Gómez Fernando Paulsen Matías del Río Michelle Bachelet (Presidential candidate in 2013, actual President) Evelyn Matthei (Senator) Franco Parisi (Presidential candidate) Rafael Araneda (TV presenter) Kike Morandé (TV presenter) Diana Bolocco (TV presenter) Mario Kreutzberger (TV presenter, aka \"Don Francisco\")", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Amaro Gómez-Pablos Martín Cárcamo (TV presenter) Karen Doggenweiler (TV presenter, wife of #9) Leonardo Farkas (Proposed presidential candidate)", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/31560/x86tux", "score": 26 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Does the \"Malkovich Malkovich\" scene from Being John Malkovich count?", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It's difficult to count precisely how many Malkoviches are in this scene; I counted 45 while going through shot-by-shot, but I may have missed a few and/or double-counted some.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "These are obviously not named roles, so it may not count for what you're looking for.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Beyond this, Malkovich also plays three \"characters\" for substantial periods of time in the movie: Himself; Craig inhabiting his body; and Lester and his friends inhabiting his body, towards the end of the movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Several other characters \"enter\" John Malkovich during the movie, but they are not shown having control over Malkovich (just being spectators.)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/30354/Michael Seifert", "score": 17 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Along the same lines as Michael Seifert's answer , I nominate John Simm in the Doctor Who episode", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The End of Time, Part 1 and The End of Time, Part 2 , in which he appeared as every human on Earth , a total of more than six billion different roles .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/27759/Rand al'Thor", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Johnson George played 45 roles in a Malayalam film named Aaranu Njan", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "(Film name means Who am I?).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He currently holds the Guinness world record for playing most characters in a single movie .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He played roles like Mahatma Gandhi, Swami Vivekananda, Leonardo da Vinci, APJ Abdul Kalam in the movie.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Below is a movie poster showing different characters played by the actor.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/48608/Nog Shine", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In the movies Split and Glass, the actor James McAvoy plays a shizophrenic character, who manifests in up to 24 characters (7 of which are shown in Split and 9 in Glass).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/69787/BestGuess", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "What is the most distinct roles played by the same actor within a single movie?", "title": "The most roles played by the same actor in a movie?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<acting>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/49204", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/24301/eYe" }

[ [ "Johnson George played 45 roles in a Malayalam film named Aaranu Njan. He currently holds the Guinness world record for playing most characters in a single movie . Next comes Buster Keaton who physically acted out 27 separate roles in his 1921 film. Many other actors in both western and Bollywood films have played multiple roles, however, many of them are computer enhanced, using digital cloning.", "There are a lot of actors that have played many separate roles in various films. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Buster Keaton, Priyanka Chopra, Alec Guinness, Deep Roy, John Simm,John Simm, Alec Guinness, Amaro Gómez-Pablos, Martín Cárcamo and Michelle Bachelet, Stefan Kramer, Johnson George physically acted out many separate roles in various films. " ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Although the other answers may be right when they say that it's a reference to the longstanding Brooklyn/Queens rivalry, as a native New Yorker, I think it is simpler than that.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the geography of New York City, Brooklyn and Queens are neighbors.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "They're both located on the western tip of Long Island.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "As we can see, Peter 1 and Steve 2 have lived most of their lives less than 10 miles apart from one another .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It sounds like Steve's reaction to hearing that Peter is from Queens is simply a \"Hey, we're neighbors!\"", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "kind of thing, not a reference to any deeper significance.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Update:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "My mother was born and raised in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, and my dad was born and raised in Long Island City, Queens.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I ran the scene by them and asked them to explain why Cap chuckles - they both agreed: \"Because they're neighbors\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "1", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For those who are interested, here's 20 Ingram Street, Spider-Man's house.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A family named Parker lives there in real life, and their next-door neighbors are the Osbournes 2 Unlike Spider-Man", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": ", Marvel never gave Captain America a real-world address.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We know he was born in Red Hook, Brooklyn, but we don't know where.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He later moved into an apartment in Brooklyn Heights, but the apartment address - 569 Leaman Place - doesn't actually exist.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/20680/Wad Cheber stands with Monica", "score": 37 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It's just to show us that Steve and Peter have a natural rapport, even when fighting on opposite sides.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is likely just intended to be set-up for a later film when they will be required to work together; establishing a common ground (such as the fact that they both come from New York) early on helps that relationship build naturally.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It also plays into a joke in the second post-credits sequence; When asked by Aunt May how he got a black eye, Peter replies \"From Steve\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Aunt May asks if it's a Steve she knows and Peter says \"No, he's from Brookyln.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And his friend was huge.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Like, huge\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The joke here is that Peter is 100% telling the truth, even if Aunt May can't possible know what really happened from his line.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8686/Dr R Dizzle", "score": 23 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Lived all my life in Queens.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There's a bit of rivalry/respect between Queens and Brooklyn.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Kevin Smith pointed out in his podcast that Cap most likely recognized Spidey's New York/Queens accent even amidst fighting all the way in Germany.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I saw the movie in Astoria, Queens.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was definitely a crowd-pleaser moment.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/34380/alex", "score": 13 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I found this on instagram and was amazed to see the reference (backward compatibility).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Adding to all the good answers and as @michael also mentions, it's a reference to the first Captain America movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Another example is the last fight scene between Cap, Bucky and Iron Man, in which Captain says, I can do this all day.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This exact same line was said by Steve (he wasn't Captain America yet), when he was being bullied in the first movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/21081/ABcDexter", "score": 11 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "You got to be from New York City to understand that reference.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "I'm from New York and that's my favorite line in the film; in fact in the entire MCU.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's a very local thing, specially if you were born or raised in New York City.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "For example if you grew up in Brooklyn, you never hung out in Queens, etc.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/34713/cassiosnyc", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It's very simple.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Stop reading too much into it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'm from New York.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If I'm in an airport in Germany, and I ask someone where they're from, and they reply \"Queens\", the odds of meeting another NYC resident would be rare, so a chuckle and disbelief would be about the right reaction.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So Steve is basically acknowledging the innate New York brotherhood and Spider-Man's heart, basically saying, \"Hey you kick butt.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Oh you're from Queens?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That's cool.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I kick butt too, neighbor, I'm from Brooklyn!\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/36776/Mark Roman", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In Captain America: The First Avenger Steve Rogers asks the doctor where he was from and he said Queens.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Then the doctor asked Steve where he was from and he said Brooklyn.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe it was a reference to the first movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/34831/michael ", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It's not about \"superiority\", Brooklyn over Queens, so much as it is about the rivalry and the fact that they're fighting (Queens and Brooklyn) literally on the OTHER SIDE IF THE WORLD and the rivalry STILL rears its head.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "That's what makes it funny.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But if you didn't perceive that then it's probably \"a New York thing\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/38267/user38267", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "This is a conversation between Captain America and Spider-Man from the movie Captain America: Civil War : Captain America: You got heart, kid, where are you from? Spider-Man: [Straining] Queens! Captain America: [Chuckles in mild disbelief] Brooklyn! I don't understand the real meaning of this conversation. Is it supposed to be funny? Is the \"Queens\" and \"Brooklyn\" means anything different here?", "title": "Why does Captain America chuckle when Spider-Man tells him which borough he's from?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<dialogue><marvel-cinematic-universe><captain-america-civil-war>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/52753", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4925/Ramaraj T" }

[ [ "The reference to Spider-Man being from Queens and Captain Americs'a reaction is really only undertandable to people who grew up in New York. It could be a reference to them being from neighboring zones or it could be to do with Queens/Brooklyn rivalry.", "There is some mutual dislike/disrespect between the Queens and the Brooklyn. It's a very local thing, specially if you were born or raised in New York City\"" ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "New York City, Brooklyn and Queens are neighbors. There is some mutual dislike/disrespect between the Queens and the Brooklyn. It's not about \"superiority\", as opposed to \"being on the world's surface\", more than it is about those two boroughs battling. You got to be from New York City to understand that reference.\nIt's a very local thing, specially if you were born or raised in New York Cit" ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "The Animatrix has both prequel stories, as well as concurrent stories to the Matrix.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One of the stories even becomes explicitly canon when the protagonist of it becomes a minor but important character in Revolutions.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Kid from Kid's Story shows up in Reloaded, but becomes important in Revolutions, when he helps save people during the Battle of Zion.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The story itself takes place between The Matrix and Reloaded.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There is no spoilers for Reloaded or Revolutions in any of the 9 short films.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/23541/cde", "score": 9 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The film is a compilation of nine animated short films, including four written by the Wachowskis.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It details the backstory of the Matrix universe, including the original war between man and machines which led to the creation of the Matrix. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Animatrix", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Not sure if there are any spoilers per se, but all stories are grounded in the Matrix world.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The Animatrix provides a deeper background in the world of the Matrix.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It shows how other people experience the Matrix.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "I don't think there are any (major) spoilers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There are definitely references though.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Animatrix will definitely improve your understanding of how everything is tied together.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/32333/miva2", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The Animatrix serves as a canon source of information about the Matrix World.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It contains history of the Matrix - the rise of machines, the war, and why the Matrix came to be created, and humanity enslaved.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The others detail the world of humans - both in Matrix and outside.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Some show how some humans reject the matrix at a subconscious level - and how the machines try to continue to enslave them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Some others show how the Matrix - like any computer program - has glitches - and the effects in world.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is similar to how Neo sees a cat walk twice within the same door frame - this was a glitch - or a bug.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Others show the lives of Zionists as they train, and the challenges they face when they realise the world outside the Matrix.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Animatrix serves to complement the Matrix, along with the video games which progress the story further after the films.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1461/coolharsh55", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Ref - Matrix Explanation Let’s take a step back into what really happened in the world in the early 21st century.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This information is from the series called The Animatrix which takes a deep dive into what really happened.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Do watch", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Second Renaissance Part 1 & 2.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "These short animated films were released much after The Matrix.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A synopsis from this is important to know as it is very consistent with the movie(s).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In addition to the other answers, the two mentioned stories from the Animatrix, are two very important prequels that sets the stage for The Matrix.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It tells us about how the AI was born.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "What caused the war between Man and Machine.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Why the sky was scorched.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And most importantly, why the Matrix was created.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/16374/John", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "There is a continuous plot thread between \"Final Flight of the Osiris\", the game Enter the Matrix , and the film Matrix: Revolutions .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The girl in FFotO is delivering a message (about the coming Sentinels attack) to a postbox in the Matrix.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the game EtM, the characters have received this message and are relaying it to the captains of all the hovercraft to call them to a meeting.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And in M:R they are attending that meeting.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/18898/Ross Presser", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "I've seen The Matrix when it first came out and now I wish to watch all the Matrix movies together in order of relevance including the Animatrix anime. Does Animatrix somehow fit into The Matrix world that is depicted within the movies and are there any spoilers in the Animatrix that could reveal parts of the The Matrix Reloaded and The Matrix Revolutions ?", "title": "How does Animatrix fit into the Matrix movies world?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<continuity><the-matrix><the-matrix-reloaded><the-matrix-revolutions><the-animatrix>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/52915", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/24301/eYe" }

[ [ "The Animatrix serves as a canon source of information about the Matrix World. The Animatrix has both prequel stories, as well as concurrent stories to the Matrix. The story itself takes place between The Matrix and Reloaded. The Animatrix will definitely improve your understanding of how everything is tied together. The Animatrix serves to complement the Matrix, along with the video games which progress the story further after the films. The film is a compilation of nine animated short films, including four written by the Wachowskis. It shows how other people experience the Matrix. There is no spoilers for Reloaded or Revolutions in any of the 9 short films.", "The Animatrix comprises prequel and continuation stories to the Matrix." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ true ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [ "The Animatrix has both prequel stories, as well as concurrent stories to the Matrix. The story itself takes place between The Matrix and Reloaded.", "Revolutions ." ] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "The Animatrix comprises prequel and continuation stories to the Matrix. The film is a compilation of nine animated short films, including four written by the Wachowskis. It illustrates how the rest of the world experiences the Matrix and serves as a point of reference for the Matrix World." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "I think the show writers have made it pretty clear in the 'Behind the Episode' videos that Sansa simply doesn't trust Jon yet.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Jon was the bastard of the family.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Although it's the only family she's got, they were never close to each other.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "From Sansa's point of view, she does not know how Jon would react to news of Littlefinger coming.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "She cannot trust him to make what she deems to be the 'right' decision.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "While we all know how awesome Jon Snow is, Sansa doesn't.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "She knows he's family (if a bastard) and that he was Lord Commander of the Night's Watch, but she was never close to him at Winterfell and never saw his exploits at the wall.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/33982/SGR", "score": 27 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Sansa held the reinforcements from Jon to ensure the numbers would be in her favour.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She knows Ramsay and the games he plays.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She knows (speculatively) that he will have total disregard for the lives of his men if it means he wins.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We see this play out, with archers raining arrows onto friend and foe.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In short: Sansa needs Jon to commit to the fight to ensure that Ramsay gets bloodthirsty.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If Jon knows about the reinforcements, he will not sacrifice free folk.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sansa is becoming a shrewd leader.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Her time with Ramsay has made her pragmatic and unlike Jon and Ramsay", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "she is able to separate her emotions from the goal.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/18961/Gusdor", "score": 13 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Remember the conversation between Sansa and Jon before the war.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She was asking jon if he won't ask for her advice as she knows Ramsay bolton far close then anyone?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sansa might have told jon if he had shown interest(or believed) in taking her advice.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As in their conversation Sansa says: If you had asked for my advice earlier, I would have told you not to attack Winterfell until we had larger force or is that obvious,too?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And Jon replies: When will we have a larger force?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We've pleaded with every house that'll have us.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Blackfish can't help us.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We're lucky to have this many men.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As she was knowing the army they had won't be enough and Jon won't take support from Petyr Baelish as he made Sansa marry Ramsay.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is seeming most obvious reason to me why Sansa won't let Jon know about it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/27024/uniruddh", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think that there are a few reasons for this: Little Finger cannot be trusted.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Ned learnt this the hard way.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He only does what he does so that he can benefit in some way.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Because of (1), and I may be under correction here, he doesn't want the help of Little Finger and he tells her this.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But she can see that Jon will need the extra men", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so she does it behind her back.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/34936/David Pilkington", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It's a better story.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It conforms to the way things happen in Game of Thrones.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It conforms to the characters.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was in the end, the better strategy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Bolton's were defeated because they came to the battlefield instead of withstanding a siege.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They came to the battlefield because Ramsay Bolton 'knew' that his army will defeat Jon Snow's.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They were beaten because they were taken by surprise when Baelish arrived.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As to why Sansa didn't tell Jon, it was simply because of the way she is, this is the kind of person she has become.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After years in king's landing, and everything she has undergone with her marriages with Tyrion (yes it was horrible for her) and Ramsay, one thing she has learnt is that she won't under any circumstances let anyone else control her life anymore.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"I'm not going there back alive.\" .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She won't tell anyone anything unless it serves a purpose for her.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sansa is no longer the naive girl who wanted to be a queen and to have little price and pricesses.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She has seen it all, been through it all.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She is a survivor.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She knew that Jon won't be able to beat Ramsay.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jon fights with honor.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"Ramsay is the one who lays traps.\" .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She also knew that to beat someone like him, she needs someone like Peter.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She wants Ramsay dead and she is willing to use Jon's entire army as bait to draw him out.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"Sleep well\" , she says after telling Ramsay he is going to die the next day.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She also knows her brother is not going to survive this battle and accepts it with steely pragmatism.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sansa has in fact become, a lot like Peter Baelish.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/37032/zeerak", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Another point of view: What's in it for Little Finger?", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Little Finger won't come to her aid if there's nothing in it for him.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "In her secret letter, Sansa could have promised him the tittle of Lord of Winterfell, bonded by marriage.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jon Snow won't let that happen.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sansa is one of the few remaining and legitimate heir of Winterfell, and she knows she can't get there without Little Finger's military backing.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is her best move, lets not let Jon get in the way.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/37027/calvin25", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think, Sansa want to be \"the savior\" in a war, to gain respect and then to smooth her path to be the queen of winterfell.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/37024/Moses Aprico", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "My take is that she is somewhat embarrassed about her relationship with Baelish.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He betrayed her (and", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jon's) father, got her involved as a suspect in Joffrey's killing, killed his \"wife\" for her, overtly declaring his creepy you-look-so-much-like-your-mother love, and then sold her off to a torture-y demon of a man.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I am eager to see how him and Jon will get along, but I suspect he would not be as happy to see him as the occassion would suggest.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/37033/M. Hurmuzov", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "Sansa Stark writes that secret letter to Petyr Baelish in Season 6 Episode 7 of Game of Thrones, 'Broken Man'. Why does Sansa Stark not want Jon Snow to know about getting help from the Vale during their conversation in Episode 9, 'Battle of the Bastards?'", "title": "Why does Sansa Stark not want Jon Snow to know that she had written a secret letter?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<game-of-thrones>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/55784", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/37010/Rajesh" }

[ [ "I think the show writers have made it pretty clear in the 'Behind the Episode' videos that Sansa simply doesn't trust Jon yet. Jon was the bastard of the family. Although it's the only family she's got, they were never close to each other. From Sansa's point of view, she does not know how Jon would react to news of Littlefinger coming. She cannot trust him to make what she deems to be the 'right' decision. She knows he's family (if a bastard) and that he was Lord Commander of the Night's Watch, but she was never close to him at Winterfell and never saw his exploits at the wall. Moreover, Little Finger won't come to her aid if there is nothing in it for him. Jon won't let her marry Little Finger if that is what she is planning.", "Sansa cannot trust him to make what she deems to be the 'right' decision" ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Sansa and Jon Snow were never close to each other. She does not know how Jon would react to news of Littlefinger coming. She cannot trust him to make what she deems to be the 'right' decision. Sansa knows he's family (if a bastard) and that he was Lord Commander of the Night's Watch, but she was never close.", "Sansa could have promised Little Finger the tittle of Lord of Winterfell, bonded by marriage. Jon Snow won't let that happen. Sansa knows she can't get there without Little Finger's military backing. This is her best move, lets not let Jon get in the way." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "We can see the answer in what happens immediately after.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's textbook Ramsay manipulation, and it nearly worked.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Ramsay was surrounded by loyalists to Jon's faction who immediately aimed at him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If he'd shot Jon, his men would have fired immediately without hesitation, killing him before rushing to try to save Jon.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But Jon, their leader, is still alive, and Ramsay's talking, not posing an immediate physical threat -", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so they wait for Jon's order.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This gives Ramsay an opportunity to do what he does best: manipulate honourable fools, and exploit emotional weaknesses.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He challenges Jon to a one-to-one fight, a challenge no sane person would ever accept in these circumstances - but Jon is easy to manipulate and enraged from just having seen a big friendly giant get shot in the eye.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jon charges, seemingly accepting the duel.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jon's men don't know what to do.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is duel,", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "right?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You don't interfere with duels.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If Ramsay had succeeded in shooting Jon here, Ramsay would get another opportunity to manipulate.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He could confuse Jon's men's sense of honour using the fact they'd seen him beat Jon in a one-on-one duel that Jon had seemingly accepted.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And a subtle detail: to my eye Ramsay seemed to be aiming at Jon's sword arm shoulder:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "had he hit, he could even make a show of being merciful to a disablingly wounded Jon, putting himself in a good negotiating position.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Could it work?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Could he talk his way into exile, or possibly even divide what remains of Jon's ramsharkle army and turn the factions against each other (Wildlings and Night's Watchmen, Northerners and Vale knights)?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe, maybe not - ill-disciplined leaderless men are unpredictable.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But he'd have better odds this way than if he'd simply shot Jon then been immediately felled by a hail of arrows (and possibly, ripped in half by an angry wounded giant).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/9718/user56reinstatemonica8", "score": 82 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "On top of the sadistic nature people have mentioned already, Ramsay is a pretty good strategist.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He was probably thinking \"If I kill Jon, it's me vs. a Giant and the men.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If I kill the Giant, Jon can be goaded to fight me one on one, which is the only way I can win here.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He had just seen Jon come running across a battlefield into range of his archers because he goaded him to try to save his brother, so he thinks he knows what Jon will do next.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/36761/The Serpent Says", "score": 33 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Ramsay enjoys teasing people.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The show runners revealed that it wasn't until the moment his dogs were about to eat him alive that Ramsay realized that he had lost (an evidence for this was his cocky comment that he \"still held Winterfell\" even though his entire army had been swipe out by the Knight's of the Vale cavalry", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and he had not one but two Starks knocking at his doorstep.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When he saw Jon looking at Wun Wun in a \"gratitude, prideful\" way, he resolved into killing the Giant because he figured it would cause Jon to react erratically (just like he did when he literally blew up his well-thought battle plan for trying to rescue his dead-man-walking brother Rickon).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The only difference this time around was that Ramsay stood no chance against his enemies, but he hadn't realized that.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "His twisted, messed up mind did not allow him to process the thought that he had lost the battle and that he was about to die.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/37041/Oscar Valdez Esquea", "score": 10 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "What can he achieve by striking Jon?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He might have missed it or killed him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But he will surely going to be killed later on by the giant or by any random Wilding and soldier.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So not much gain.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He did the same with Rickon Stark in the same episode, he could have tried killed Jon , as he was on same distance as Rickon when he got killed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Ramsay even tried to kill Jon Snow too after Wun Wun", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but he got the shield on right time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "What he achieved by killing Wun Wun first?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Ramsay was same sadistic jerk and even near his deathbed he love playing with other people's emotion.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Trying to kill Jon Snow was no fun to him but giving him more pain was.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So he chose to kill Wun Wun first.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1190/Ankit Sharma", "score": 9 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think that Ramsay got cocky...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He had a bow and arrows, and Jon Snow was a bit of a ways off.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He loves to mess with people and hurt them by hurting others, so he probably thought, \"I'll kill Wun Wun just to make Jon angry, then I'll shoot Jon.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But as we know... Jon grabbed a shield and made his way over to Ramsay and beat his face in.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So that plan didn't work out too well.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/30884/Hunter Turner", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It's Ramsay's way of torturing, he thought that if he kills the giant first, he'll hurt Jon's feelings, especially that Jon was already looking to the Giant and thanking him for everything.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "All what Ramsay was doing is teasing Jon, first by the letter in the beginning of the season, then killing Rickon, then killing the giant.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, I believe that Ramsay knew he was dead anyways, so he wanted to hurt Jon as much as possible before Jon kills him!", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/19724/Mostafa Elgayar", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "In Game Of Thrones S06E09 , after the battle, inside Winterfell, the giant is on his knees and Jon Snow is standing besides him when Ramsay strikes the giant in the eye with an arrow. The giant was already fatally wounded and was unlikely to get back on his feet. Why did Ramsay aim for the giant then and not Jon Snow?", "title": "Why did Ramsay strike him?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<character><game-of-thrones>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/55814", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/36788/AlwaysALearner" }

[ [ "Ramsay killed the giant instead of Jon as a way of torturing Jon. Maybe Ramsay knew Jon was going to kill him, and wanted to torture him as much as possible before it happened", "All Ramsay was doing was teasing Jon, first with the letter at the start of the season, then with the murders of Rickon and the giant." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "It's Ramsay's way of torturing Jon; he reasoned that if he kills the giant first, he'll hurt Jon's feelings, especially since Jon was already thanking the Giant for everything. All Ramsay was doing was teasing Jon, first with the letter at the start of the season, then with the murders of Rickon and the giant." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Famously from the opening credits of Star Wars it is set...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Essentially this is an equivalent to the fairy tale 'once upon a time' opening.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It tells us that it's not really important where or when the story is set.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There are however exceptionally tenuous movie links to the Earth - in that you see creatures like E.T. in the Republic council meetings:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However this is barely more than an 'easter egg' than a true linking to Earth in the Star Wars universe.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So I would have to conclude that the answer is 'no'.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/40/iandotkelly", "score": 49 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Yes, although in all fairness more as a gag than as a serious canon fact.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Then again, Jar-Jar Binks is a serious canon fact, so who am I to judge canon?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": ":)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I have discussed the links in detail in my answer to \" Are E.T. and Star Wars in the same universe?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "SFF Q&A .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I shall now shamelessly borrow from that answer the way J.J. Abrams borrowed from Episode IV :)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "TL;DR:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As a gag/easter egg/cross-merchandizing/friendly jest/whatever, Spielberg and Lucas have placed enough canon information in their universes to imply that E.T. really is an alien from a species in a Star Wars Galaxy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "E.T.'s species were officially called The Children of the Green Planet , their planet was called Brodo Asogi .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In addition, as documented in my SFF answer to \" Are Star Wars and Indiana Jones the same Universe?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\" , there is a second mention:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "somehow, Indiana Jones's The Ark of the Covenant is strongly implied to originate fron...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Han Solo's Episode VII cargo ship \"Erevana\":", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/235/DVK", "score": 23 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Another \"easter egg\" type instance of things related to earth being included in the movie is the person in the potential Gemini/Mercury spacesuit in one scene.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Thread discussing it here: https://scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/80002/what-evidence-is-there-that-proves-disproves-there-was-a-gemini-earth-astronaut", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But of course since this is a galaxy far away and", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "a long long time ago this is more of a costume budget issue than an in-universe reference to Earth.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/26321/DasBeasto", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "While the Battlestar Gallactica series did make reference to Earth that they didn't know if it existed or not, in Star Wars, never is Earth mentioned at all.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "That is different than saying that in the opening text it says \"A long time ago, in a Galaxy far far away.\"", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "One might say that at some other point earth is mentioned, but no, it is never mentioned.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Curiously, by saying \"A long time ago, in a Galaxy far, far away...\" it does imply an audience that is being addressed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, it is told to an audience on Earth and the events happened a long time ago from our point of view and a Galaxy far from us.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Still, in no way does the movie ever make reference to Earth at all.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/37880/Bruce Whealton", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Several characters in Episode", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I refer to humans - C3PO (\"human-cyborg relations\"), Anakin (\"I'm the only human who can do it\"), and a pod race announcer (\"that little human being is out of his mind\").", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is not a direct mention of Earth but Earth", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "may well be an origin of humans.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/37865/guest_h53", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In the movies, there was no direct mention of earth.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So the answer to your movie-related question is \"No\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But in the expanded universe, there were mentioned, that the Rakatan Empire found humans on some planet and spread them around the whole universe, but it was not the earth.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So in the movies, there is no direct answer where do humans come from, but in the extended universe, it is clearly stated, that humans are not from earth.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/74928/TK-421", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "In the Star Wars movies by George Lucas, is anything ever mentioned about Earth and the Milky Way Galaxy?", "title": "Does George Lucas mention Earth in \"Star Wars\"?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<star-wars>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/56722", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/" }

[ [ "While the Battlestar Gallactica series did make reference to Earth that they didn't know if it existed or not, in Star Wars, never is Earth mentioned at all. So the answer is no, Earth is never mentioned.", "Still, in no way does the movie ever make reference to Earth at all." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "In Star Wars, in no way does the movie ever make reference to Earth at all. One might say that at some other point earth is mentioned, but no, it is never mentioned. It is told to an audience on Earth and the events happened a long time ago from our point of view. Still, in no way does the movie ever make reference to Earth at all." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Well, I have a theory about how this scene might have been filmed, but I have no sources to confirm this as it is a very old movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This rock can be a fake one, because using a real one will definitely hurt an actor.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Now, when the rock is thrown, actor takes a jump.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "To make this look realistic, the timing and jump must be perfect.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If you take a close look, you can see that Charlie Chaplin just waited for the perfect time and made a jump (credits to @DrRDizzle we can see Charlie Chaplin's knees bending slightly.).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Such scene might have taken practices and takes for a perfect shot.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/27264/A J", "score": 114 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In addition to the fake rock theory by @AJ, it is quite possible that the rock did not travel the entire distance it appeared to.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Once the rock disappears off screen, there could have been some barrier to prevent the rock continuing.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This way, the rope would have enough weight to continue moving, but there would be significantly less weight pulling on Charlie Chaplin's neck.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/41339/Matt Butler", "score": 37 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Even if this particular trick is rare, it's conceptually similar to hanging scenes, which are abundant in westerns.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "In fake hanging, the typical trick is to attach the rope to the hidden harness while the knot is just a decoration:", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "How is a hanging scene filmed?", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "In addition, the \"stone\" is likely to be light.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "In our days, I'd say plastic.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Then, probably papier-mâché.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/22809/IMil", "score": 22 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The key is to watch Chaplin's legs and the rope.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "As the rock goes off-screen and the rope is getting close to taut, his knees flex.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "At that point he clearly jumps into the water, with enough style (because he was an expert stuntman) to look as if he'd been pulled into the water by the rock.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "If you watch the rope too, you see that there's no point at which it goes taut, and actually when he jumps into the water it goes completely slack.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is completely clear when you watch it back repeatedly and analyse exactly how it's done.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "For audiences though it happens fast enough that they don't see the knee-bend and jump, or think through the implications of the rope going slack.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "As a result they buy into the scene, and no doubt some of the original audience asked the same question you just have!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You can also be sure that the \"rock\" is nothing of the sort.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For the stunt to be safe in water, the \"rock\" will almost certainly be balsa wood or something equally light, so that it doesn't genuinely sink afterwards!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Notice that the \"rock\" goes off-screen to ensure you don't think about that - and", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "notice that whilst Chaplin produces a very impressive splash from his pratfall, there's no splash from the rock, even though the rope could only let it go just off-screen.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/30415/Graham", "score": 13 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Perhaps the rope is loosely fastened to the rock, and detaches when the rock has reached its limit.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/41350/Pete", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I've watched it several times", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and I think: the rock is firmly attached to rope, and the rope to Chaplin, albeit to his shoulder not his neck.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "if you watch carefully, the rock reached the extent of the rope and was bouncing back -- you can see the rope go taut and then slacken.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "the \"rock\" was made of some moderately light-weight material, most probably papier-mâché as soon as Chaplin felt the rope tauten, he hopped convincingly off the dock (the man was, after all, one of the great physical comedians of all time).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/9071/Malvolio", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It's a cut.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's two takes spliced together to make it seem like a single action.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Closely looking at the gif, i.e. the video, shows where there is a significant difference between the frames.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Frame 38 Frame 39", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Every other frame is a subtle change from the last.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This one shows a significant difference.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Charlie's face jumps to a different position.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The other guy's hands do too.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Rope seems to have been matted in.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The rock suddenly disappears.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Primitive Movie Magic at work.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/23541/cde", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Try lifting, let alone throwing a rock of that size and you'll understand how that was fake; it has just the right weight to pull the rope in a realistic way, and then Chaplin only has to jump at the right time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In fact, notice that he does a little funny jump, not", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "a \"rock&rope pull my neck suddenly and nearly breaks it\" one, which would be the more real way.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sorry, this is very similar to the top answer.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/41359/JustPassingBy", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The rock could be fake and there could have been a hidden rope tied to a body harness on Chaplin that could have done the pulling from off-camera.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'm not convinced", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "his posture and movements give enough evidence to prove conclusively that he jumped.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'm not seeing enough upward force from his legs to justify the height and length of the jump.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hence, I suspect a hidden rope pulling him from the side, off camera.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, being pulled from the side by a hidden wire could easily explain the movements.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8944/Thom Blair III", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "In a scene from City Lights (1931), a man tries to commit suicide before Charlie Chaplin comes and saves him. But the man accidentally ties a rope to Chaplin's neck and throws the rock into the water with some force. How was this scene shot safely without breaking Charlie Chaplin's neck or injuring him in some other way?", "title": "How was this scene shot without hurting Charlie Chaplin?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<film-techniques><stunts><city-lights>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/60924", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/" }

[ [ "The Charlie Chaplin scene could have been filme like a fake hanging. However, the key is to watch Chaplin's legs and the rope. As the rock goes off-screen and the rope is getting close to taut, his knees flex. At that point he clearly jumps into the water, with enough style (because he was an expert stuntman) to look as if he'd been pulled into the water by the rock. If you watch the rope too, you see that there's no point at which it goes taut, and actually when he jumps into the water it goes completely slack. This is completely clear when you watch it back repeatedly and analyse exactly how it's done. For audiences though it happens fast enough that they don't see the knee-bend and jump, or think through the implications of the rope going slack.", "Hanging scene is fake hanging. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Hanging scenes are abundant in westerns. In fake hanging, the typical trick is to attach the rope to the hidden harness while the knot is just a decoration. The \"stone\" is likely to be light. In our days, I'd say plastic.", "The key is to watch Chaplin's legs and the rope as the rock goes off-screen. At that point he clearly jumps into the water, with enough style to look as if he'd been pulled. If you watch the rope too, you see that there's no point at which it goes taut." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Watching the scene it seems that the talk about soft hands and lotion is mostly to give an impression to the other people in the store that nothing is wrong.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Notice how the dealer becomes very uncomfortable, starts stammering and clutching his hand and how he rubs it after Frank finally lets go.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He's no longer a confident salesmen at the end of the talk.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He is scared of Frank and is willing to lose a lot of money to make him go away.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It's not about \"discussing a better price\", Frank is intimidating the salesman by holding on to him, crushing his hand and the way he is talking (not the words, but the way he says them), while keeping up an appearance to onlookers that it's just a friendly discussion.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/42033/erik", "score": 42 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The conversation is only there to lengthen the time Frank squeezes Billy Tim's hand.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Frank will not let Billy Tim's hand free until he gets what he wants.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This prompts Billy Tim to lower and lower the price as his hand gets more and more painful.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/42034/mrtpe465", "score": 21 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It's more like keep the conversation going.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also you can notice that he talked in lower tone.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, it was just politely talking with the car dealer and making him take the price down.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Talking about lotion has nothing to do with the conversation.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was rubbing the hand which possibly made the car dealer to get rid of this quickly.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, he lower the price and Frank's trick worked.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Conversation: FRANK :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yes, Denham, like a jean.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(they shake)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You know: you have lovely hands -- do you moisturize?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "BILLY TIM:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'm sorry?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "FRANK:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I swear by it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I try all sorts of lotions.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I went through a fragrance-free period last year, but now I'm liking this new brand fortified with rose hip.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "My sister, you know, she uses the aloe vera with the sun screen built in... BILLY TIM: Uh-huh.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You said you'd be willing to pay in cash?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "FRANK:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I did.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You know: they say cinnamon is wonderful for your pores.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Read that on the internet.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And that ideally you should be wearing gloves to bed, but I find that would interfere with my social agenda.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Problem is: I get a reaction to camphor so I can't use traditional remedies...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "BILLY TIM :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If you could pay cash, I could probably drop the price a little.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "To, say, seventeen...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(as Frank squeezes a little) ... sixteen each.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "FRANK:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That would be lovely.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Including the lotion in this conversation just makes it silly and Frank just did this to politely force him to lower the price.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/27264/A J", "score": 16 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "As others have said, it's an intimidation tactic to lower the price of the vans Frank wants to buy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In America it's socially abnormal to hold onto someone's hand after shaking, especially in a business setting.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "By bringing up \"soft hands\", Frank essentially has an excuse to keep holding the salesman's hand during the conversation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "While outside observers would see and hear them talking about soft hands, he's actually squeezing the salesman's hand to motivate him to lower the price, which is made most clear at the end of the scene when he intensely squeezes and", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "the salesman drops another $1000 off the price.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/42039/ww602", "score": 13 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think that it was introduced to make the dealer uncomfortable by implying predatory homosexuality.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Soft hands\", holding the dealer's hands a little too long, it's all calculated to make the dealer feel threatened and therefore more likely to close the deal quickly without dickering.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/25920/Sean Duggan", "score": 5 } } ]

{ "question": "When Frank was talking to the car dealer in Ocean's Eleven , he specifically mentions his soft hands, resulting in a better price for them for the car. Why? What is the background?", "title": "What was the purpose of mentioning the soft hands in Ocean's Eleven?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><oceans-eleven>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/61784", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/21283/arc_lupus" }

[ [ "Watching the scene it seems that the talk about soft hands and lotion is mostly to give an impression to the other people in the store that nothing is wrong. Notice how the dealer becomes very uncomfortable, starts stammering and clutching his hand and how he rubs it after Frank finally lets go. He's no longer a confident salesmen at the end of the talk. He is scared of Frank and is willing to lose a lot of money to make him go away. It's not about \"discussing a better price\", Frank is intimidating the salesman by holding on to him, crushing his hand and the way he is talking (not the words, but the way he says them), while keeping up an appearance to onlookers that it's just a friendly discussion.", "It's more like keep the conversation going." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "The dealer becomes very uncomfortable, starts stammering and clutching his hand and how he rubs it after Frank finally lets go. He's no longer a confident salesmen at the end of the talk. He is scared of Frank and is willing to lose a lot of money to make him go away. It's not about \"discussing a better price\", Frank is intimidating the salesman.", "It's more like keep the conversation going. Also you can notice that he talked in lower tone. Talking about lotion has nothing to do with the conversation. It was rubbing the hand which possibly made the car dealer to lower the price." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "There is no need to watch any Harry Potter movie to understand Fantastic Beasts.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Here is why: Fantastic Beasts And Where To Find Them is not a prequel to all eight Harry Potter movies.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The Harry Potter franchise is set in the '90s while Fantastic Beasts is set in 1920's.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "No one from Harry Potter exists in this era, except Albus Dumbledore.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "And there are some references about magical creatures that can be found in Harry Potter books/movies", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "but you don't have to worry about it because you won't miss anything here nor you will feel lost during the movie.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "But you will be entering a new established universe.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "A Bustle article goes into greater detail as to why it's fine for newbies.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/27264/A J", "score": 27 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think you can watch this as a stand alone movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Apart from a few references to the Harry Potter world in the movie (name drops of Albus, Hogwarts - total of around 10 small references through out the entire movie) etc., rest of it is completely new.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Its set in the 1920's era.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Before Harry Potter started.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So no, you don't have to watch the Harry Potter movies to understand this one.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's a new experience even for HP fans (you would know the beasts they show in the movie if you read Fantastic Beasts library book before) Spoilers below as requested.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hogwarts keeps coming up - also a my-school-is-obviously-the-greater chat comes up with the main protagonists", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "---Gellert", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Grindelwald comes up.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You can even see the back of his head right in the start --- Dumbledore's name comes up.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One character asks Newt why Dumbledore favors Newt.--- Nifflers, Bowtruckles, Occamys, Diricrawls, Demiguise etc., beasts from 'fantastic beasts and where to find them' book from Hogwarts Library appear in the movie", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "---Seeker, Chaser reference comes up.. and few more references which I can't exactly recollect.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/37651/Anu7", "score": 20 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Yes, it is understandable without having watched the other HP films, but you might want to pre-explain certain aspects of JKR's wizarding world - about the separation of the magical & non-magical worlds, how the magical world has it's own government (specifically the Ministry of Magic), Aurors, Muggles, magical schools, the wizards' newspapers with their moving images and the dark/light wizards - you could use a Star Wars analogy here :-).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/22721/Steve Ives", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Mostly The movie does not explain the Deathly Hollows symbol, or that Grindelwald used it as his own symbol.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So anyone not familiar with the storyline from the HP books/movies", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "will completely miss the significance.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Other than the opening credits and one brief mention, Grindelwald doesn't come much.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So Graves being Grindelwald is a bit out of left field.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Other than that, everything is pretty well contained and explained.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The rest of the HP universe references do not hinder the plot.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/36923/Xavon_Wrentaile", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Yes, I'd say so.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I've watched the movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The difference is Harry Potter is in Britain, and Fantastic Beasts and Where To Find Them is in America.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Besides the no-maj and muggle thing, I guess you're OK.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, no-maj and muggle mean no magic.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/43515/epictomboy611", "score": 5 } } ]

{ "question": "I am planning to watch Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them and asking this question in place of a friend who might give me company. But he has not seen any HP film before. Can we understand Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them without watching any other Harry Potter film? Or do I need to watch any other Harry potter film for better understanding?", "title": "Is Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them understandable without watching any other Harry Potter film?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<harry-potter><suggested-order><fantastic-beasts><fantastic-beasts-where-to-find-them>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/63604", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1190/Ankit Sharma" }

[ [ "There is no need to watch any Harry Potter movie to understand Fantastic Beasts. Here is why: Fantastic Beasts And Where To Find Them is not a prequel to all eight Harry Potter movies. The Harry Potter franchise is set in the '90s while Fantastic Beasts is set in 1920's. No one from Harry Potter exists in this era, except Albus Dumbledore.", "There are references about magical creatures that can be found in Harry Potter books/movies" ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Fantastic Beasts and Where To Find Them is not a prequel to all eight Harry Potter movies. The Harry Potter franchise is set in the '90s, while Fantastic Beasts is in the 1920s. No one from Harry Potter exists in this era, except Albus Dumbledore. There are references about magical creatures that can be found in Harry Potter books/movies." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "There is no explicit answer for it yet but there are many theories for it and most popular one is :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Both are same person.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "From bustle.com speculation on the subject: French & Homer Are Different Versions Of The Same Person When French is sneaking around Prairie's home in the finale, for a moment he looks at himself in the mirror and sees Homer.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It could just be his mind playing tricks on him, but how would his mind know exactly what Homer looks like?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The show has already talked about multiple dimensions, so is it possible that when French was looking in the mirror he was seeing a multi-dimensional reflection of himself?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This would explain why French and Prairie are so drawn to each other and why he is so willing to go along with her out-there ideas.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1190/Ankit Sharma", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Now that they have the 5th motion, they opened the gate and since Homer also has all 5 movements established, he is reaching out to French; as a link and channel has begun to form (across time and space which are merely physical boundaries not spiritual).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/44834/Neal", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "They mentioned that amnesia would be a side effect of multi-dimensional travel.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe Homer travelled into a different dimension, where he is Fench and not Homer, and forgot all about his past life... until it started trickling back", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/45060/Alexandra Danger Granucci", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "French plays football and Homer (the 16 yr old gets a head injury from football).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe French is a Homer from another dimension and he dies on the field later.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He also explains all those things about her father possibly being a bad person (he drowned her first).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, I noticed that Homer, in the story told by OA, when he was told to seduce the older lady, he was in the shower banging his head against the hard tile, just like when young blond steve does (he says I messed up", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I messed up) after his dad finds out about the throat injury.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "All of these characters align.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think there is more to the story and how they maybe are going to die next .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Not meant to just save a school from a shooting.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think he really did see himself in the mirror.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also they don't remember most of where they go because they are gassed before they are killed over and over again.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/46076/michelle Andrade", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think the immediate implications are that there are correlations or juxtapositions between Hap's Captives and Prairie's new group that act as counterparts", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "that work in such a way to make the movements possible for Prairie to use... French and Homer share the idea of being young athletes, who both come to suffer head injuries, but obviously Homer's being an NDE, where French's is just a scrape from fighting with Steve.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "French also has a correlation with Ranetta in the sense that his nickname is exotic and Ranetta comes from an exotic location, but Ranetta shares Prairie's extraordinary gift to play music, which solidifies the irony that Homer is used as bate, but then sleeps with her, betraying Prairie.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "If one looks at Rachel, her vocal musical abilities tether her Buck, who sings in the school choir, but the story about her running away from her parents to raise her younger brother, whom tragically dies from a car accident, juxtaposes Jesse's story, as one of his parents died, the other left, and he's currently being raised [poorly] by his big sister.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Betty Broaderick-Allen or \"BBA\" has a cool name abbreviation like Prairie (The \"OA\") and both are \"teachers\" of sorts.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She also just lost her brother Theo, who was hard to handle, but finds her brother again in the forms of Steve and perhaps Jesse.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Steve also starts to find someone, the girl from detention, where he can be more of himself with, as she is more like him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is not unlike Prairie coming more into her own when she was held captive and finds and meets Homer.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The show's contrasts of counterparts is so beautifully sliced and isn't perfectly symmetrical.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In terms of the longer term implications, I think the series will take it's time with it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I do think French believes he saw Homer in the mirror, making us aware that they share some things and that perhaps French plays a bigger role in terms of saving Homer at some point.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But I also know that Brit Marling has a 5-season plan and that she doesn't want to simply repeat herself.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So it may take a while to see the full magnitude of what this Odyssey and all", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "it's little parts bring.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/56522/Darth Locke", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "In the final episode of season 1, while wandering around Prairie's house, French looks in the mirror and briefly sees himself as Homer. Assuming French even knows what Homer looks like, is he imagining this, or are we to believe this actually happened? What are the implications of either of those things?", "title": "Why did French see himself as Homer in the mirror?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><the-oa>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/65607", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/13169/zim" }

[ [ "Maybe the immediate implications are that there are correlations or juxtapositions between Hap's Captives and Prairie's new group that act as counterparts. French and Homer share the idea of being young athletes, who both come to suffer head injuries, but obviously Homer's being an NDE, where French's is just a scrape from fighting with Steve. ", " French and Homer share the idea of being young athletes, who both come to suffer head injuries. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "There are correlations or juxtapositions between Hap's Captives and Prairie's new group that act as counterparts. French and Homer share the idea of being young athletes, who both come to suffer head injuries. Rachel's vocal musical abilities tether her Buck, but the story about her running away from her parents to raise her younger brother. Jesse's story juxtaposes his story, as one of his parents died, the other left, and he's currently being raised [poorly] by his big sister." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "At the end of the episode, Mycroft explained to his parents that she was no longer verbally communicative.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That is; she would no longer talk.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The only communication she appears to respond to is playing the violin with Sherlock.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Therefore, her ability to \"program\" people is no longer a threat.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/43889/Darren", "score": 16 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Because it's the best place for her.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "There is no place better set up than Sherrinford for Eurus.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "As Mycroft says: There's a place called Sherrinford.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "An island.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It's a secure and very secret installation whose sole purpose is to contain what we call the uncontainables.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The demons beneath the road?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is where we trap them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sherrinford is more than a prison, or an asylum.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It is a fortress, built to keep the rest of the world safe from what is inside it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As Sherrinford's residents are 'uncontainables' it is inevitable that there will be failure at some stage.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In this case Eurus' takeover of Sherrinford was a consequence of the governor ignoring Mycroft's direct orders: MYCROFT:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Has there ever been, against my express instructions, any attempt at a psychiatric evaluation of Eurus Holmes?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "GOVERNOR:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This error allowed Eurus to begin her takeover of the facility.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Finally, if Eurus cannot be kept at Sherrinford, then... where?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/19074/EleventhDoctor", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Though it is not explained in details, I don't think that it is a plothole.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "First of all, Great Britain does not have death penalty, so Eurus has to be contained somewhere.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Of course, we know that the British government may employ assassins at time (Mary and her AGRA team for example), but it is unlikely that Mycroft would allow that.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Remember how powerful he is in the government (\"He is the government\" as Sherlock describes him in the first season).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, Eurus has to be locked somewhere.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "As explained in the episode, Sherrinford is the most secure prison in the Great Britain.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "It is not perfect, but perfect security does not exist.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "And, as in most security breach, the problem is not the technology (the Sherrinford facility) but a human problem.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "With the precedent of the manipulation of the Governor that lead to his suicide in mind, everybody will follow Mycroft's directives, Mycroft included.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, we may consider that Eurus is not a threat anymore .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Or at least a lesser threat.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Indeed, look at the plot of the episode.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She didn't want to have a revenge on Sherlock, or mess with him, but she was looking for brotherly affection from Sherlock in her crazy way.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As said in the episode, Sherlock was his favorite when they were children.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She got jealous of Redbeard and kind of accidentally killed him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Accidentally because it is clear that the riddle was only a way to play with Sherlock and get his attention.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Note that she used the graves with wrong dates that Sherlock loved as a key for her riddle.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In addition, the plane game is a metaphore of her situation, estranged from people, and a call for help to Sherlock.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As a sociopath, she is a danger to people, and may harm them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But she now restarted a relationship with her brother, and with her parents, so she is now under control in Sherrinford.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/11093/Taladris", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Because, no matter how many times he breaks out, the Joker always goes to Arkham Asylum.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's not a very satisfying answer, but the audience knows that Sherrinford is where [really] bad people go.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Why go though all the explaining that \"Fordensher\" is a super max security prison where all the really, really bad people go, when you already have a place that really bad people go.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "To make matters worse to introduce \"Fordensher\" , you need to really differentiate it from Sherrinford.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "What would make it different?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sherrinford is already for people so \"different\" that they can't go to normal prisons, so what can Fordensher do differently enough from Sherringford that the audience could recognize the different places easily.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Take Prison Break for example (not one of my favorites", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but it fits well here).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When they moved from \"normal\" prison to \"Mexico Hell Prison\" they were able to differentiate enough (even if it made no sense) that even a casual audience member would be able to tell that there was a significant difference between the first prison and the second.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You would need that kind of separation between Sherrinford and Fordensher or you risk confusing your audience.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The only other option is that Fordensher is a black hole that villains go to, and are never dredged up again for future plot usage, so there's no need to explain it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/34737/coteyr", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Interesting.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The discussion seems to presume that Mycroft and Co. made the decision to return Eurus to Sherrinford and that they, not her, were in control of the situation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I saw very little to persuade me of that presumption.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She is clearly not only smarter and more powerful, but patient and capable of allowing others to believe, erroneously, that they are in control of her.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Why should that have changed?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sherrinford is her headquarters, it suits her purposes, and she has them escort her back there at the end of the show, allowing them to believe that they have won.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/45945/Talksthetalk", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "My question is regarding Eurus (re)imprisonment in Sherrinford at the end of S04E03. She has been described by Mycroft as an \"era-defining genius, beyond Newton.\" She also managed to manipulate one of the prison guards to kill himself and his wife, just by talking to him. Why isn't Mycroft worried that this will repeat? Why was Eurus put back in Sherrinford, where she not only managed to break free from, but also had complete control over it at one point?", "title": "Why was Eurus sent back to Sherrinford?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><sherlock>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/66986", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/9684/Rippy" }

[ [ " First of all, Great Britain does not have death penalty, so Eurus has to be contained somewhere. Of course, we know that the British government may employ assassins at time (Mary and her AGRA team for example), but it is unlikely that Mycroft would allow that. So, Eurus has to be locked somewhere. As explained in the episode, Sherrinford is the most secure prison in the Great Britain.", "Eurus is not a threat anymore, according to Sherlock. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Eurus is set up in Sherrinford because it's the best place for her. It's a secure and very secret installation whose sole purpose is to contain what we call the uncontainables.", "Great Britain does not have death penalty, so Eurus has to be contained somewhere. Eurus is not a threat anymore, according to Sherlock. Sherrinford is the most secure prison in the Great Britain. The problem is not the technology, but a human problem, says Sherlock author Mark H. Sherlock ." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Is it possible to follow Battlestar Galactica 2003 TV series without watching 1978 original Battlestar Galactica series?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yes, definitely.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Although some of the basic concepts / names etc.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "are the same, this is a complete reboot/re-imagining of the series.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/34317/Paulie_D", "score": 54 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "You don't have to watch both, they are not related or have any sort of continuity, but you need to watch the 2 episodes mini series before watching the 2003/2005 version .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/24398/madmada", "score": 32 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "As someone who watched and loved the 1978 series as a teen...", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "No, you don't need to watch both.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "They are actually surprisingly unrelated.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "They have roughly the same central concept of a fleet which is fleeing genocide at the hands of the \"Cylons\", but that's really about where the similarities end.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Cylons are completely different in the original show.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They are The Other.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Shiny robots with one evil scanning eye.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You could look at any character and know instantly which side they were on.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The result was kind of like a weekly space-based version of the Battle of Midway.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The new one making them look just like humans completely changes the show, adding a dimension of constant paranoia and psychological drama that was just not in there in the 70's (although as a teen boy, I'll admit it could have been in there", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and I would not have noticed).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The fact that some of the Cylons don't even know they're not human adds a further element.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "My personal suggestion would be that if you enjoy modern dark dramas with ongoing stories (eg: Arrow), then just watch the reboot.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If you'd prefer an old-school series with a lot of space dogfights where noting much changes at the end of any episode watch the old one.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If you've got oodles of free time on your hands, feel free to watch both.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/21021/T.E.D.", "score": 15 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In a really weird way, the reboot is also a sequel series to the original galactica series.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In Galactica 80, the fleet has found earth and they send a small contingent of children to live on it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The cylons also send a small contingent (no idea why)that are humaniform cylons to hunt them down.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One of the big themes of the reboot is \"all this has happened before and will happen again\" which might indicate that the previous series were within canon of the new.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But that's really not worth thinking about.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "this is \"brains off\" TV.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They don't have a plan, and neither did the writers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Take it episode by episode and don't try connecting the dots, you'll be much happier about the series for it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/48249/Deus Ex Galactica", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I have never watched more than a couple of minutes of the 1970s version but happily watched all of the 21st Century reboot.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As other have said, the 21st Century version can confuse people because it begins not with Season 1 but the Mini Series, which is possibly the best part and not to be missed, apart from showing the beginning of the story.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It stands up to repeated viewing as not all later Seasons do.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also note some later episodes such as 'Razor' were released individually but are also included in the relevant series.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Tricia Helfer is especially brilliant and sad", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "she has not had other more prominent and varied roles since, unless I missed them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Note two interesting prequels were made later with different casts, a TV movie set early in the Cylon War called Blood & Chrome and a series set before the Cylon War called Caprica.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There was another called sequel '", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Plan' featuring the original cast", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but of more mixed interest.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/48322/Timothy", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Yes, absolutely, 100%, zero-questions...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In fact, for your own good don't watch the 1973 version.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's frickin awful!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It is perhaps one of the worst pieces of garbage ever, but then again I could barely get through about 20 minutes of the first episode.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I might have watched a few minutes of one of the other episodes as well just in the hopes that it would get better...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It did not!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For the record I love the remake.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I think it was one of the better pieces of science fiction ever made.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There could have been some things done better, but overall it was spectacular.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I wish that they would do more spinoffs, or at least do full series of the spinoffs instead of just an episode or two.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'd love to see as much of that universe as possible.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The point to the last few lines is that I'm definitely a fan of the story...just not the execution of the 1973 version.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/48312/David", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "Is it possible to follow Battlestar Galactica 2003 TV series without watching 1978 original Battlestar Galactica series?", "title": "Can I watch Battlestar Galactica 2003 without knowing the original 1978 series?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<suggested-order><battlestar-galactica>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/70383", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/45670/Akshay Dosi" }

[ [ " You don't have to watch both, they are not related or have any sort of continuity, but you need to watch the 2 episodes mini series before watching the 2003/2005 version .", "As someone who watched and loved the 1978 series as a teen, you don't need to watch both, since they are unrelated" ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "You don't have to watch both because they are unrelated and have no continuity, but you must watch the two-part miniseries before watching the 2003/2005 version.", "As someone who watched and loved the 1978 series as a teen, you don't need to watch both, since they are unrelated" ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "I don't see this as much of a tv conceit.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The earmuffs usually used on shooting ranges do not go anywhere near blocking out all sound.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It is quite standard to carry on conversations while having them on", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I've done so every time I've been at a shooting range with someone else.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I assume we tend to raise our voices a bit, but I don't think it's even all that much.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/28729/DRF", "score": 58 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "As a sports shooter of now almost 23 years I can tell you: It's not an issue!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You hear each other a bit muffled but still very well understandably.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You only have to raise your voice because of the gun noises around you, not because of the muffling by the ear protection.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We normally use this type here :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/48689/Patric Hartmann", "score": 25 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "There are special electronic ear protectors that can do that.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Guns.com", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The premise of electronic muffs is quite simple.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "While the passive muff provides hearing protection, battery powered electronic components inside the electronic muffs include microphones, amplifiers and speakers that gather, amplify and transmit low volume sounds — like voices — inside the earpiece .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Price differences in muffs generally dictate quality of components and advanced capabilities.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For instance, lower cost muffs may have only one or two microphones and a basic stop-type amplifier that simply shuts off upon high decibel sounds.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This type of shutoff causes split second time lapses before the amplifier resumes and low tones are again transmitted to the ear.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Cheaper muffs with fewer mics often make it difficult to ascertain the direction of the sounds as well.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Higher end models use more advanced technology that allows the continuous flow of low volume sounds while at once blocking dangerous noises.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They also contain multiple mics and speakers, making it easy to determine the direction and distance of the sound, which is crucial in hunting, tactical and competition applications.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "There's a more complex description & explanation at earplugsstore.com", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/34317/Paulie_D", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "One thing to note is that the sound of a gunshot and the sound of 2 people talking have an entirely different frequency, volume and length.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The human voice has a frequency of around 85-250 Hz, a volume of around 60 db and usually a length of a couple of seconds.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A gunshot from a small caliber weapon is", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "around 150-2500 Hz in frequency, has a volume of around 130-160 db and usually lasts only a fraction of a second.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "These are sounds with entirely different footprints and as such can relatively easily be attenuated independently.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There is in fact a study from Finland: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7761796 , that states that large-volume earmuffs can be used to protect against gunshot sounds.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/9969/Nzall", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Earmuffs for hearing protection are designed for just that: hearing protection.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They are intended to bring volumes down to a safe level that won't cause injury or damage the wearer's hearing.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Each model is rated for a given reduction in volume, listed as NRR (noise reduction rating), generally in the range of 20-40 decibels.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If they blocked out all sound, they wouldn't be useful for their normal use cases, such as shooting ranges, airport tarmac, construction sites, and other noisy areas.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "These areas have other sounds that are important, such as cease-fire orders, conversation with coworkers, and so on.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The non-total nature of hearing protection muffs often surprises people who try to use them to block out quiet but distracting noises, such as nearby conversations or music.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I know of no passive device (i.e., not producing white noise or other sound to drown out the outside noise) that can do this.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/21075/TigerhawkT3", "score": 3 } } ]

{ "question": "In How I Met Your Mother S02E01 , Robin & Marshal are shooting in a shooting range and having a conversation. How can the conversation be audible to them when they've still got the ear muffs on?", "title": "How can Robin and Marshal hear each other, with the ear muffs still on?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<how-i-met-your-mother>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/70988", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/46039/ashveli" }

[ [ "There are special electronic ear protectors that allow you to hear while wearing ear muffs. can do that. While the passive muff provides hearing protection, battery powered electronic components inside the electronic muffs include microphones, amplifiers and speakers that gather, amplify and transmit low volume sounds — like voices — inside the earpiece . ", "There are special electronic ear protectors that can allow hearing" ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "There are special electronic ear protectors that can allow hearing. Electronic muffs include microphones, amplifiers and speakers that gather, amplify and transmit low volume sounds. They also contain multiple mics and speakers, making it easy to determine the direction and distance of the sound. The muffs can be used in hunting, tactical and competition applications." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "The director, James Gunn, has confirmed that the sequel takes place 2 months after the original movie....", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so 2014 which apparently dates it before Civil War", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(but see below).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, we don't know the dates of the other MCU movies.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Kevin Feige to Comicbook.com", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yeah, knowing that outside of the Guardians franchise, we don't necessarily always date the movies.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You don't always know, we don't say, '2012, 2013...' We do in the Guardians because you do the math and 1988, and it's 26 years later.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But we never say, 'Oh, this takes place in 2018, this takes place in 2017.'", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But it was important for the story that James wanted to tell that they're still relatively fresh in their new group.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/34317/Paulie_D", "score": 10 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "James Gunn has gone on record to state 'only a couple of months': How long after Vol. 1 does Vol.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "2 take place?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Around a couple of months.- A couple of months EARTH time or, maybe it's, like, years, out in space because of science fiction?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Like a couple of months Guardians-time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Like, if Peter Quill gets a haircut once a month, he'd have two haircuts between films.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Most MCU films take place at their equivalent 'time of release'; meaning the real world gaps between the films release schedule apply to the in-world chronology of the MCU.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "GOTG2 is the first film to break this trend.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/6306/John Smith Optional", "score": 9 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "James Gunn admitted his mistake http://in.ign.com/guardians-of-the-galaxy-vol-2-1/108210/news/james-gunn-acknowledges-small-guardians-of-the-galaxy-vol-2", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And yes, I know I made a mistake.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "People have written and asked me, and I'll own up to my mistake because Guardians of the Galaxy Vol.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "2 theoretically happens in 2014 which is before [Captain America Civil War].", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And Stan Lee in the movie says, ‘That time I was the Fed Ex guy,’ which is what he is in Civil War.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I screwed up; I wasn't thinking.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That’s all that is.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/24166/Pando", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The hint is that Stan Lee is something along the lines of a nanny cam for the Watchers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And Guardians 2 is not the first movie to break the timeline as released theory.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/51230/BULL", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It is my assumption that the Watchers know all and see all whether it has happened yet or not.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Watchers are an integral part of the Marvel Comic stories call What If?.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the What", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Comic books the Watcher talks about being everywhere and nowhere.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He tells the stories that will , can and might happen if certain events take place in a particular order.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Many of these stories take place in alternative time lines and different Marvel Universes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It is possible that even though Guardians Vol.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "2 takes place before the events of Stan Lee working for Fed Ex, and the events of the Civil War, that it has been witnessed by the One True Stan Lee, who in turn tells the Watchers about it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Think of the Watchers as Celestial time travelers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They only witness, they do not interfere or persuade events they only Watch and observe.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That's my take on it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe I'm wrong but its a good theory.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/51348/ben", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "According the Marvel Cinematic Universe Wiki : Guardians of the Galaxy Vol.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "2 Guardians of the Galaxy 2 takes place between October 17 2014 - Battle of Sovereign - This is the opening scene of GotG2.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "October 19 2014 - Battle on Ego's Planet - This is the final scene of GotG2.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Captain America: Civil War Captain America:", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Civil War takes place between June ? 2016 - The Lagos Catastrophe June 10th 2016 - Clash of the Avengers", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This would mean that in GotG2 Stan Lee hadn't been a FedEx agent and wouldn't be for nearly 2 years.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Stan Lee", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There are 3 possible explanations for Stan Lee's cameo in GotG2: Some sort of deus ex machina time travel - which doesn't exist in the MCU .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The appearances and roles of Stan Lee aren't related in the MCU.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is much more likely given his variety of jobs and that he was poisoned in The Incredible Hulk , although he didn't die .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's also possible that this is a clone of Stan Lee, perhaps Lan Stee ?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/855/Coomie", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "Some people say Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 takes place a few months after the first one (2014), which means before Civil War . If that's the case, How is Stan Lee telling stories to the trio of Watchers about him being a FedEx agent, which takes place in 2016 (after Civil War)?", "title": "When exactly does Guardians of the Galaxy Vol 2 take place in the MCU?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<marvel-cinematic-universe><captain-america-civil-war><guardians-of-the-galaxy-2>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/72573", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/24166/Pando" }

[ [ "According the Marvel Cinematic Universe Wiki : Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 Guardians of the Galaxy 2 takes place between October 17 2014 - Battle of Sovereign - This is the opening scene of GotG2. October 19 2014 - Battle on Ego's Planet - This is the final scene of GotG2. ", "Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. Guardians of the Galaxy 2 takes place between October 17 2014" ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "S0: According the Marvel Cinematic Universe Wiki : Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. Guardians of the Galaxy 2 takes place between October 17 2014 - Battle of Sovereign - This is the opening scene of GotG2. " ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "First of all, it's more likely that David simply disguised himself as Walter rather than swapping bodies.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The reason that David went along with the humans' plan to kill the Xenomorph was so that the humans would go into hypersleep, trusting him to actually be Walter instead of David.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "That way, he has free reign over the thousands of people in stasis on board to continue his experiments without putting himself or two of his other test subjects at risk.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8686/Dr R Dizzle", "score": 17 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think David saw it as a test for the Xenomorph.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The only way to gauge how close to \"perfect\" his creation is, is to test it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He was in a good position to watch the Xenomorph and see how it reacted and tried to kill the remaining crew members.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "With any type of creation, organic or machine, the creators will always want to test it to see what needs to be improved.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I don't think David was overly concerned with pretending to be Walter at this point in the movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If the Xenomorph killed the remaining crew then he gains control of the ship, if the remaining crew kill the Xenomorph then he \"helped\" and has their trust.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Either way, he comes out of it with control of the ship.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "David didn't seem to believe that the Xenomorph was a threat to him so being left along with it on the ship wouldn't be something he was concerned about had it successfully killed the crew.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/51630/Glorious_Coffee", "score": 12 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "There's no evidence that David had any control over that xenomorph.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He could have wanted it off the ship just as much as the others.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The xenomorph could have ruined the ship or him as well.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He wanted to live and wanted the ship and human cargo intact for himself.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/51672/Frederick MacKenzie", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "David didn't switch bodies, you can tell because he still has the damage to his face.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'm surprised he managed to short and dye his hair in such a short time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Equally perplexing is why Daniels didn't notice that David wasn't Walter, especially while she was helping him staple his face back together; You'd think she'd notice that he wasn't self-repairing like he should....", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also worth noting is that David was missing the nail hole under his chin.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In my opinion, it was way to obvious that David had replaced Walter especially the way they cut away from the fight...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/51647/elavertu", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "David's ultimate goal was to create life.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Specifically, life that is \"better\" by some subjective measure than his own creators or their creators (Engineers).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Everything else is secondary to that goal.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "He even cut off his own hand to impersonate Walter, that is how much nothing else mattered to him.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Think back to the scene where he shows the captain his experiments.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "He tells him he really wants to show him his successes, downstairs: he then says the eggs are waiting... for what?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A host, obviously, as we all know from previous movies.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He started out with a single host, Elizabeth Shaw, who was dead long before his creation was perfected.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He needed another human to be the host to the facehugger to see what it would do.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is why he broadcast that song, to lure spaceships to the planet so he would have more hosts.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He learns that the ship is a colony ship, with hundreds of humans in cryosleep.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jackpot.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Practically infinite fodder (hosts) for breeding the perfect organism.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Keep in mind that so far, he only had two human hosts to work with and had great success: the ship has a hundred times as many.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Helping the crew is a means to an end: gaining control of the passengers on the colony ship.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He could have revealed his secret early, except the crew already figured out that the xenomorphs use humans as incubators.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They saw an alien burst from one of their own (the second one to be infected early in the movie, I do not remember his name), and Daniels saw his \"artwork\" showing aliens being born out of humans.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It is not a great leap for them to suspect that David wanted the sleeping colonists for experimentation, or that he meant them harm at the very least.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They may have even sacrificed themselves to stop him, or instructed Mother to lock David out of being able to control the ship, jeopardizing his greater plans.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Helping the crew gained their trust, even if it meant killing his creation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That is okay, however, because their trust is crucial to his plans: get the crew to go to cryosleep willingly, rendering them incapable of interfering.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Once that is accomplished, he has hundreds of unwilling hosts for his xenomorphs as well as alien embryos representing the successful culmination of years of experimenting.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Why sacrifice everything for a single alien when he could have hundreds of aliens?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe even better aliens, given enough time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sometimes it is better to lose the battle in order to win the war.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I understood it in such a way that if he disobeyed the remaining crew, or lied to them, and they somehow didn't get killed too quickly, Daniels (or Tennessee in case of the former's death) would understand what is happening and, as the captain, could inform Mother (the computer system of the Covenant) that David is a threat.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, David would be risking getting locked in where he was without any authority over the ship, which wouldn't be very good for him even if the crew died.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So he chose to sacrifice the pet in order to be able to go on with his experiments witn higher probability.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/35224/Serge Seredenko", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "Why did David (in Walter's body) help kill the Xenomorph onboard the Covenant? Couldn't he have it kill the rest of the crew and then trap it in one of the chambers?", "title": "Why did David help on-board of the Covenant?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<character><alien-covenant>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/73611", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/46547/chiragjn" }

[ [ " The reason that David went along with the humans' plan to kill the Xenomorph was so that the humans would go into hypersleep, trusting him to actually be Walter instead of David. That way, he has free reign over the thousands of people in stasis on board to continue his experiments without putting himself or two of his other test subjects at risk. David's ultimate goal was to create life. Specifically, life that is \"better\" by some subjective measure than his own creators or their creators (Engineers). Everything else is secondary to that goal.", "David's ultimate goal was to bring life into the world. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Instead of swapping bodies, it's more likely that David simply disguised himself as Walter. David agreed to the humans' plan to kill the Xenomorph in order for them to fall into a state of hypersleep.", "David's ultimate goal was to bring life into the world. Specifically, a life that is \"better\" than his or their creators on some subjective metric. Everything else is a secondary thought for achieving that goal." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "As shown throughout the film, the Predator has only killed armed opponents.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "At this point in the film Arnold has put up a great fight against the Predator and is currently unarmed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Predator looks him over much like a hunter might take time looking at a prize kill before firing a shot.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Predator disarms himself and then fights Arnold hand-to-hand, a \"fair\" fight instead of just killing defenseless prey.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(It's been a long time since I've seen the film, so can't remember exactly when/how the Predator stops using weapons).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/46644/sirjonsnow", "score": 75 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "A couple of other reasons (besides the already mentioned one: Dutch was unarmed at the time so the Predator chose to disarm himself and to engage in melee combat):", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Dutch was a fantastic adversary; he was clearly the strongest, the smartest, and he lasted the longest among all the preys.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The delay in killing was in part to show some sense of respect .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Dutch was also the last of the group : the Predator was probably milking the hunt because if it killed Dutch, it wouldn't have another foe (for a while at least).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "In combination with the first point above: the Predator knew it wouldn't get such a great foe like Dutch again, possibly forever.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/14080/yurnero", "score": 43 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "As another line of reasoning: The predator is sometimes mocked as the dentist-on-safari among alien invaders.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "With all previous kills it had more opponents.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So it killed them off instantly and with all its high-tech gadgets to avoid the risk of being outnumbered/caught off-guard.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Dutch (Arnold's role) was alone in the end.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So the dentist-on-safari Predator tried to prove to itself what great a hunter he is.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And did it go well...?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Man, Predators really suck, if looking at them like this...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/51964/NoAnswer", "score": 24 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "You mean this scene?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Predator collects the skulls of his prey as trophies, so he was probably checking if Arnold's skull was worthy of his collection.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After that he removes his helmet and goes without weapons, to make this hunt more challenging since he would be lowering himself to the technical level of his prey.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The others were way too easy to kill, so perhaps not as good as a trophy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/19762/Luciano", "score": 15 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Answering the last part of your question: \"Did checking Arnold's head mean something?\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I always thought that the predator examined Arnold to try to understand the reason why he wasn't able to see him (the mud).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Arnold still had sections of his face covered in mud so the Predator \"wonders\" how these sections are not visible to him and others are.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/30443/Esteban Filardi", "score": 8 } } ]

{ "question": "In the movie Predator (1987), near the climax, when the Predator finds Arnold, it did not try to kill him immediately. Instead, it goes near him and checks his head and removes its helmet (I am assuming that it would be its helmet). Why did it not kill Arnold immediately as it killed everybody else? Did checking Arnold's head mean something?", "title": "Why did the Predator not kill Arnold immediately as it killed everybody else?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><predator>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/74066", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/39688/Mr ASquare" }

[ [ "Dutch was a fantastic adversary; he was clearly the strongest, the smartest, and he lasted the longest among all the preys. The delay in killing was in part to show some sense of respect . Dutch was also the last of the group : the Predator was probably milking the hunt because if it killed Dutch, it wouldn't have another foe (for a while at least). In combination with the first point above: the Predator knew it wouldn't get such a great foe like Dutch again, possibly forever. ", "he Predator knew it wouldn't get such a great foe like Dutch again, possibly forever. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Dutch was a fantastic adversary. The delay in killing was in part to show some sense of respect. The Predator knew it wouldn't get such a great foe like Dutch again, possibly forever. Dutch was also the last of the group, so the Predator was probably milking the hunt because if it killed Dutch, it would have another foe." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "The technique is specifically named in the film, as the literal meaning of the word matches well with it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Following is a dialogue from early in the film, for reference: COBB: What do you want from us? SAITO: Inception. ... SAITO: Is it possible?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "ARTHUR:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Of course not.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "SAITO: If you can steal an idea from someone's mind, why can't you plant one there instead?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The remainder of the film deals entirely with a specific plot to do so, its planning and execution and ambiguous success.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Saito intends to disrupt a power conglomerate from becoming a virtual monopoly, using inception on the heir apparent to the conglomerate owner's estate.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/31866/Nij", "score": 62 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "As you explained, Inception is an event that is a beginning; a first part or stage of subsequent events.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In this movie, lead protagonist Dominic Cobb(Leonardo DiCaprio) has got a task to implant an idea into Robert Fischer's subconscious mind by going into his dream.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And that person will have a life and act according to what has been implanted into his mind.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Therefore, in this case, inception is just an activity to plant an idea into someone else's brain to start a chain of events.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/27264/A J", "score": 26 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "They're planting an idea in someone's mind by convincing them that they came up with it themself -- the \"inception\" of a thought; where does it come from?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "What really puts it there?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That's the theme that all the main characters struggle-with, with their own life choices and the consequences of others' choices that they have to deal with, or the tasks they're trying to complete.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It revolves around the central question of \"what started this?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\", because that could be how you answer \"how did we get here?\", which ultimately also leaves you wondering \"what do we do next?\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/", "score": 14 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Nij's answer covers well the in-universe explanation of what \"inception\" is in the context of the film: using the dream-tech to enter someone else's dreamworld and plant an idea that they come to believe is their own.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is explicitly exposited by Saito.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However there also exists a meta-level to the titling and, by extension, the theme of the whole film.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Inception is very much like some of Nolan's previous films in that it tries to evoke aspects of the topic at hand; both Insomnia and Memento are prime examples of this, evoking feelings of the titular insomnia and the confusion of disordered memory suffered by their protagonists.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Inception goes one step further, concerning itself with the idea of lucid dreaming and the ability to (at least feel like you) control your dreams.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Cobb's dialogue with both Ariadne-", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "when he's training her in dream construction- and Fischer-", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "when he's conning him into believing he's his dream security- are actual techniques for lucid dreaming: notice the strangeness of the dream, always be questioning reality, question how did I get here?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Aside from necessary film techniques that could be interpreted as dream-like (cuts, for example) and the things explicitly shown to be part of the dream, the film's ambiguity as to the outer layers and whether Cobb's entire experience is a dream is left ambiguous.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This serves the main purpose of the film: to incept its audience with the ideas that promote lucid dreaming.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The film experience lulls people into the experience of dreaming, but leaves them with the questions of \"what is reality?\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and \"how can I be sure I am not dreaming?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\" While we don't have nearly as much uncertainty about our reality as when we're awake- mainly due to the equivalent tech not yet existing- the questioning should be sufficient to trigger lucid dreaming in some people.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/52120/Danikov", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Wiktionary defines inception as The creation or beginning of something Dom Cobb (Leonardo DiCaprio) is the only one that is convinced that in constrast to stealing information through dreams it is also possible to implant information.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He explains that this cannot be done directly though, but that one must plant a seed in the form of an idea or feeling that then will grow into thoughts and finally change that persons behavior.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Thus Inception refers to this initial implanting of an idea.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He knows this because... ..", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "he tried that method with his wife and implanted her with the idea that the world she lives in is not real.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He did this to get her out of the dream world.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But that idea developed to such a strong conviction that even when she was in the real world she still was convinced that it was a dream and killed herself to \"wake up\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/38596/problemofficer", "score": 5 } } ]

{ "question": "Inception means: An event that is a beginning; a first part or stage of subsequent events. But the movie talks about humans dreaming & lucid dreaming etc. So, why is the movie titled Inception ?", "title": "Why was the movie titled Inception?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<title><inception>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/74253", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/52116/Lars Hansen" }

[ [ " Inception is very much like some of Nolan's previous films in that it tries to evoke aspects of the topic at hand; both Insomnia and Memento are prime examples of this, evoking feelings of the titular insomnia and the confusion of disordered memory suffered by their protagonists. Inception goes one step further, concerning itself with the idea of lucid dreaming and the ability to (at least feel like you) control your dreams.", "Inception goes one step further, concerning itself with the idea of lucid dreaming." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ " Inception is very much like some of Nolan's previous films in that it tries to evoke aspects of the topic at hand. Inception goes one step further, concerning itself with the idea of lucid dreaming." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Aamir Khan was 51 when he played the role of a 19 year old boy in Dangal .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "From Bollywood Life article", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "So Aamir Khan has done it again what he does the best.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The PK actor has gone through a drastic makeover for his upcoming film, Dangal, in which he will be seen going through three different stages for he will play the role of a 19-year-old, 29-year-old and 55-year-old.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Below is the image of him as 19 years old.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Another example, Amitabh Bachchan was 67 years old when he played the role of a 12 year old boy suffering from a rare genetic disorder called progeria in Paa . From Wikipedia plot summary , Auro (Amitabh Bachchan) is an intelligent and witty 12-year-old boy with an extremely rare genetic disorder called progeria.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Mentally he is twelve and very normal, but physically he looks five times older.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Though, in this case, the character he played was supposed to look like an old man.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/27264/A J", "score": 116 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Shirley Henderson was around 37 when she played Moaning Myrtle in the Harry Potter movies.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Born 1965, appeared in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets which came out in 2002 and Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire which came out in 2005.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1264/NiceOrc", "score": 53 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Stockard Channing (born 1944) played teenager Rizzo in Grease (1978) at the age of 34.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/34506/Mr_Thyroid", "score": 34 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Robert Redford was 48 when The Natural was released.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Granted he played a 35 y/o for most of the movie, but he plays a 19 y/o pitcher on a way to a tryout in the prologue.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/37467/dbugger", "score": 24 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Ferris Bueller's sidekick Cameron was played by 29-year-old Alan Ruck in Ferris Bueller's Day Off .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Alan Ruck was born in 1956, and appeared as Ferris Bueller's trusty high-school friend Cameron in the 1986 movie Ferris Bueller's Day Off .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Mr. Ruck was probably not 30 during filming, since movies are always shot months or even years before they are released.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "*Thanks to Joe for the comment on the original question that led to this answer.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "( Fun fact:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I've bumped into Alan Ruck twice in my grocery store in Studio City, CA.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He even said \"hi\" once because he could see how star-struck I was.)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8017/BrettFromLA", "score": 23 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "There is a very popular Mexican comedy TV show named \" El Chavo del Ocho \" (1972-1979), in which all the characters are played by adults even when they are playing children's roles.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "I understand that some people may consider it a parody, but truly it is not.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It may be actors portraying children, but they are not parodying them: within the El Chavo's universe they are not pretending to be children, they are children.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Roberto Gómez Bolaños (aka Chespirito) was the creator/writer/producer/director of the show, and he also played El Chavo, an 8-year-old boy who escaped from an orphanage and lives in the apartment #8.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Chespirito was born in 1929, and the show concluded in 1979.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So in the last season, he was an 50-year-old man portraying an 8-year-old boy (42 years difference).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/38571/Alvaro Montoro", "score": 14 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Here's one from Japan: The lead role in My Love Story! , a major production from a major studio, was played by Ryohei Suzuki .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The character is 15 years old throughout (no flashbacks or early life scene setting), but at that time Suzuki was 32 years old, so a 17 year difference.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(I've also just thought -", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Brad Pitt was 44 when he played BB at 12 years old - I can't remember if he appeared at an earlier age, though)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/53197/Ken Y-N", "score": 10 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Wet, Hot American Summer", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(the Netflix show not the film) had multiple actors in their 40's and early 50's portraying teenage and early 20's characters.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Granted", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "this was part of the joke, but for your question this should work (unless you would qualify this as parody).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For example, Michael Showalter was 45 when the series was filmed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And he has confirmed they are indeed teens here :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"We thought it was funny that in the original we played a bunch of thirty year olds playing teenagers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Now we're in our forties and our characters are even younger,\" Showalter said in a statement.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If not the show, then the movie, which was not done to the absurd level as the show would still count.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/30783/dvaeg", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "This example will be very hard to beat for anyone who cares about historical accuracy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the 10 May 1980 episode of Fantasy Island", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "My Fair Pharaoh/The Power", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "the \"My Fair Pharaoh\" part had the protagonist going back in time to meet her hero Queen of Kings Cleopatra VII Philopator.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Cleopatra's brother and enemy King Ptolemy XIII Theos Philopator (62/61 BC to 47 BC) was portrayed by Michael Ansara (born 15 April 1922, died 31 July 2013) who was thus aged 58 years and 25 days when the episode aired and was probably 43 or 44 years older than Ptolemy and 3.8 to 4.07 times as old as Ptolemy when filming his scenes.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "This is an example of a middle aged man portraying a character arbitrarily depicted as an adult despite being one of the most famous child rulers in history!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So this could be the extreme example depending on whether you go by Ptolemy's historical age or his unspecified adult fictional age in the episode.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/53201/M.A. Golding", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Although he is not the oldest in these answers, he is playing a fairly younger role in Hannah Montana .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jason Earles plays his role as a 15 years old kid, and can you believe he was on his 30s?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/52511/LeonX", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Though he also appears as an elderly version of the character in the framing story at the beginning and end of the film, (then) 40-year-old Martin Short played a 10-year-old in Clifford .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The film was a comedy, and the casting of an adult actor in the role of a young child was surely intended to be humorous, but it's never specifically highlighted as a joke in the film--it's played more or less straight.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/26529/Carl Fink", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "If we take the premise of the movie The Curious Case of Benjamin Button , then Brad Pitt born 1963 played a teenager in 2008 at some point or another in that movie.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/28815/Neil Meyer", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "There's a common trope in Hollywood where teenagers are played by adult actors . But which TV show or movie set the absolute record in terms of the age difference between the role and the actor? To clarify: The character played must be a teenager, so younger than 20 years old The portrayal is done in a serious manner - not as a parody, or a \"what if\" clip, or a dream, etc It must be a live action film or a TV show", "title": "Who was the oldest actor to play a teenager?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<trope>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/75534", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/19453/JonathanReez" }

[ [ "Many adult actors have played teenagers in films including Aamir Khan, Amitabh Bachchan, Shirley Henderson, Stockard Channing, Michael Ansara and Brad Pitt.", "There are plenty of actors who have played the role of youngers." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "There are plenty of actors who have played the role of youngers." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Since agents can inhabit any \"bluepill\" person in the Matrix, the freeway poses a few issues.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yes, you can move quickly from one distant point to another, but that's of no benefit to Trinity, Morpheus, or any other awoken Matrix users.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "On the freeway you're locked into a narrow corridor with exits only every mile or more, and any car near you can become a weapon in the hands of an agent.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the first film, we see that the preferred movement method of Morpheus, Trinity & friends is to keep their business relegated to places in the dense city, and when escaping agents, try to lose them in alleys or maze-like building interiors.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Going up roofs or around corners, their goal is to put obstacles between them & the agents as quickly as possible, because all they need is a spare moment to find an exit while the agents are busy trying to find them again.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/43807/Ross", "score": 118 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think that what @Ross said was the most accurate:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yes, you can move quickly from one distant point to another, but that's of no benefit to Trinity, Morpheus, or any other awoken Matrix users.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "On the freeway you're locked into a narrow corridor with exits only every mile or more, and any car near you can become a weapon in the hands of an agent.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But I'd also like to add a few points of my own.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the first movie, hidey-holes and sewers are where they prefer to hang out.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In a world where any earthly force can be turned against the \"red pill-ers\" without repercussion, a long, exposed stretch of road, driving vehicles that are several ton weapons in the wrong conditions, and are moving too quickly to maneuvre well, it's basically a death trap.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Anything from shipping trucks to the armed forces can be leveed against them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In fact, we see two agents, when hand to hand and weapons combat fail, take over the shipping trucks and crash them into each other in order to kill the \"red pill-ers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\" There are also no hard lines from which to escape the Matrix, which is the only proven way of \"winning\" against the Agents.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Combine all this, and it's easy to see where an exposed highway full of strangers is suicide.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/9459/JFA", "score": 30 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Well, its probably mostly to add to the drama of the movie, however we can also consider that the agents move a lot faster than the plugged-in humans, and would therefore have a lot quicker reaction times (\"You moved like they do\")", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And you tend to drive fast on a freeway.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Secondly, its easy to get killed on a freeway, and the agents are not afraid to dies.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Thirdly, its easy to get on a freeway, and block someone in, as it becomes a bit of a rat maze/trap.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/40584/AhBajeezus", "score": 12 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The movie uses visual cues to give you the answer to your question: they're trapped by high concrete walls & frequent wide overpasses that cover you in.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "They're effectively in a tunnel positively congested with enemies, potential enemies, and the normal obstacles of traffic.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The freeway wouldn't be suicide if they were on it covertly, but when you're being pursued in a world fully controlled by your pursuer, your only escape is exit (land-lines, not accessible in a car chase), solitude (the opposite of a congested freeway), or anonymity (which is already out the window).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Morpheus' advice to Trinity was to not think of escape in spacial terms, i.e. getting \"away\", because inside the Matrix there is no \"away\".", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "We're instinctually geared to think in terms of outrunning predators, so if you're not careful, in the heat of the moment you could head onto the freeway thinking that pure speed is your ally.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "But it's not, it means nothing in the Matrix.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The only advantage people have is unpredictability, to make a choice that can't be planned for and reach safety before they can cut you off.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The freeway is the opposite of that.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/15559/Jason", "score": 12 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It could be that you are farther from an \"exit\" (out of the matrix) when you are on the freeway.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As I recall, all exits require land lines.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8017/BrettFromLA", "score": 6 } } ]

{ "question": "In The Matrix Reloaded the following dialogue happens between Trinity and Morpheus during a car chase: Trinity: You always told me to stay off the freeway. Morpheus: Yes, that's true. Trinity: You said it was suicide. Morpheus: Then let us hope that I was wrong. What's Morpheus's reason to stay away from the freeway?", "title": "Why did Morpheus tell Trinity to stay off the freeway?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><dialogue><the-matrix-reloaded>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/77950", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/41237/Rahul" }

[ [ "The freeway wouldn't be suicide if they were on it covertly, but when you're being pursued in a world fully controlled by your pursuer, your only escape is exit (land-lines, not accessible in a car chase), solitude (the opposite of a congested freeway), or anonymity (which is already out the window). Morpheus' advice to Trinity was to not think of escape in spacial terms, i.e. getting \"away\", because inside the Matrix there is no \"away\". We're instinctually geared to think in terms of outrunning predators, so if you're not careful, in the heat of the moment you could head onto the freeway thinking that pure speed is your ally. But it's not, it means nothing in the Matrix. The only advantage people have is unpredictability, to make a choice that can't be planned for and reach safety before they can cut you off. ", " The only escape is exit (land-lines, not accessible in a car chase), solitude, or anonymity." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "In the Matrix, Trinity are trapped by concrete walls & frequent wide overpasses that cover them in. They're effectively in a tunnel positively congested with enemies, potential enemies, and traffic. Morpheus' advice to Trinity was to not think of escape in spacial terms, because inside the Matrix there is no \"away\" The only advantage people have is unpredictability, to make a choice that can't be planned for and reach safety before they can cut you off. The only escape is exit (land-lines, not accessible in a car chase), solitude, or anonymity." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "The biggest reason is that they weren't prepared for an attack.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The Lannister army wasn't supposed to be there, but rather defending King's Landing and Casterly Rock.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Lady Tyrell even goes on to say that fighting was never really the Tyrell's strong suit, so in-universe it wasn't a surprise that they fell so quickly.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, wealth doesn't equate to army size.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Just because the Tyrell's have a lot of money doesn't mean that they have a huge army.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "In fact, house Lannister is in significant debt because of it's huge army and all of the fighting they've had to do over the last few years.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/52/DForck42", "score": 45 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Adding to @DForck42's answer, not only the Tyrells were unprepared, as Lady Olenna points out, they were never very good at the art of war.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They lack good commanders; Ser Randyll Tarly, the most competent of their banner-men, sided with Jaime, providing the Lannisters with men, as well with expertise and knowledge on how best to defeat the Tyrells.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/29201/RMalke", "score": 31 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Possibly Inside Help Considering that High Garden is a castle, and High Garden was at least prepared enough that Lady Olenna watches them approach (without siege equipment)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so we can surmise that the gate would be closed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I would posulate that either the Lannisters had someone on the inside to open the gate for them, or the directors and writers forgot that sieges take years and many, many", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": ", lives even of poorly fortified castles.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/55508/theinvisibleduck", "score": 12 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The way that I remember this happening is that this house was one of the two that went to Daenerys and offered support.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She then had them send their army to King's Landing to lay siege.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "While their army was doing that, it wasn't at home, defending their castle.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Meanwhile, they thought that the Lannister army was in Casterly Rock waiting for the Unsullied and the Dothraki.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But instead, it was taking Highgarden.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And they sent at least Jaime from King's Landing, as they relied on Euron Greyjoy to protect King's Landing by sinking the attacking fleet.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I remain unclear on whether the Tyrell army was with the fleet or not.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe it's hanging out laying siege to King's Landing.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Or maybe they're dead and on the bottom of the ocean.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/18476/Brythan", "score": 9 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "All of the in-universe reasons have been given so here are some out-of-universe reasons to consider.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Story:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Dani's Dothraki + Unsullied + Dorne + Reach +", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yara-Theon Ironborn fleet should have steamrolled the Lannisters and Dani should be sat the Iron Throne.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, this would be rather linear and dull plot", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so D&D had to do something to even up the odds between Cersi and Dani.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "While the trap at Casterly Rock was no big surprise, the taking of Highgarden was.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Budget:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A one sided slaughter is a bit boring.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Having this off screen is a big money saver and can pay for more dragon CGI and Ice Zombie battles!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Time:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "With only this 7 eps season and one more season the story needs to be moved on.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "2nd tier characters such as Olena, Elaria and the Sand Snakes need to be culled in order to make room for Jon, Dani, Arya and Sam plots.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/44327/josh", "score": 9 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Since it's fiction, I guess it's because HBO wanted to even the odds for House Lannister.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The biggest reason why House Tyrell lost is because the Lannisters somehow magically acquired all troop movements of Daenerys's forces but masked their own.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I mean communication via ravens in GOT is pretty fast", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and I doubt Lannisters could invade Tyrell without hitting any spies or picket forces.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And magically ambushing the fleet?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Really?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Did they have aerial reconnaissance in middle ages?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "With Varys and Olenna, the Targaryen forces should have equal if not better intelligence network.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So no, I don't think it was possible for things to happen this way other than", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "author wanted it this way or the allies brushed aside all intelligence and said: they love Casterly Rock, no way they are going to take High Gardens.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/55580/legokangpalla", "score": 7 } } ]

{ "question": "In Game of Thrones season 7 episode 3, we see the Lannister army invade and defeat house Tyrell in Highgarden. In fact, the fight is so one-sided that the writers of the show intentionally decided not to show the actual battle and instead jumped directly to the aftermath of fight. It's established in season 7 episode 1 that the Lannister army is running short of supplies and money, and house Tyrell is now the richest house in Westeros. How was it possible that the former so easily defeated the latter?", "title": "How was a powerful house so easily defeated?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<game-of-thrones>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/78195", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/45319/Tiny Rick" }

[ [ " The biggest reason is that the Tyrell weren't prepared for an attack. The Lannister army wasn't supposed to be there, but rather defending King's Landing and Casterly Rock. Lady Tyrell even goes on to say that fighting was never really the Tyrell's strong suit, so in-universe it wasn't a surprise that they fell so quickly. Just because the Tyrell's have a lot of money doesn't mean that they have a huge army. In fact, house Lannister is in significant debt because of it's huge army and all of the fighting they've had to do over the last few years.", "House Lannister was not prepared for an attack." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "House Lannister was not prepared for an attack. House Lannister is in significant debt because of it's huge army and all of the fighting they've had to do over the last few years. In-universe, fighting was never really the Tyrell's strong suit, so it wasn't a surprise that they fell so quickly." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "It's quite rare, but yes , it has happened with Hollywood movies.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One example is Chaos (2005).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Chaos (2005)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Action, Crime, Drama Director:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Tony Giglio Stars: Jason Statham, Ryan Phillippe, Wesley Snipes", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Distributed by:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Capitol Films, Lionsgate", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Two cops, a rookie, and a grizzled vet, pursue an accomplished bank robber.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "— Chaos (2005) , IMDB Crime, Horror, Thriller Director:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "David DeFalco Stars:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Kevin Gage, Sage Stallone, Kelly K.C. Quann Distributed by: Dominion Entertainment, Dinsdale Releasing Two girls, looking to score some ecstasy at a rave, follow a young man to a house where terror awaits.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There, a gang of felons captures and torment the girls, drawing them into a nightmare of violence.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "—", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Chaos (2005) , IMDB The way Wikipedia disambiguates or distinguishes the two is by adding a distributor of the film in with the release date: Chaos (2005 Capitol film)", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Chaos", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(2005 Dominion film)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Incidentally, Wikipedia lists the Capitol film's release date as 2006, rather than 2005, based on a German release date.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Looking at the release dates for this film , you can see that this movie has been released in '05, '06, '07, '08", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(in USA and UK) and '09, yet IMDB considers it a 2005 release because it was first released in 2005 in the UAE, which technically makes this fit your criteria.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Another piece of trivia: the Dominion film was first (August '05, versus Capitol's December '05).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/42655/Ghoti and Chips", "score": 16 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Here is another example of the movies with same name and same release year.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Night Club (1989)", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Genre:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Comedy Director: Sergio Corbucci Stars: Christian De Sica, Mara Venier,", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Massimo Wertmüller", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "From IMDb, The nightlife of young carefree friends in a wonderful 60s", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Rome Night Club (1989) Genre:", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Drama Director: Michael Keusch Stars: Nicholas Hoppe, Elizabeth Kaitan, Ed Trotta", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "From IMDb, A young married couple try to convert an old warehouse into a nightclub, but face opposition from both the council and local mobsters.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/48608/Nog Shine", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Another example is two of the adaptations of Jane Austen's Emma that came out in 1996, both which retained the name \"Emma\".", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0118308/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0116191/", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In this case, one of them was made for Television in the UK, while the other was made for theaters in the USA.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/42015/GendoIkari", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In 1965, two movies about Jean Harlow, each named \"Harlow\" were released.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "One with Carroll Baker and one with Carol Lynley.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There were two TV movies called 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea in 1997.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In addition to Steven Spielberg's 2005 War of the Worlds film, there were two direct-to-video retellings of the story that year.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/64413/Joe Schreck", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Black Rain (1989)", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0, 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Genre:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Drama Director: Shôhei Imamura Stars: Yoshiko Tanaka , Kazuo Kitamura, Etsuko Ichihara From IMDb, Mr and Mrs Shizuma, and their niece Yasuko, make their way through the ruins of Hiroshima, just after the atomic bomb has dropped.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Five years later, Yasuko is living with her aunt and uncle, and her senile grandmother, in a village containing many of the bomb survivors.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yasuko does not appear to be affected by the bomb, but the Shizuma's are worried about her marriage prospects, as she could succumb to radiation sickness at any time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Black Rain (1989)", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0, 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Genre: Action, Crime, Thriller Director: Ridley Scott Stars:", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Michael Douglas, Andy Garcia, Ken Takakura", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "From IMDb, Two NYC cops arrest a Yakuza member and must escort him when he's extradited to Japan.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/42844/Silver Bebs", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "I was thinking about the typical citation standard for referencing movies, where one writes the title and the release year, in the format \" Title (Release year)\" e.g. Jurassic Park (1993). This works quite well, except if there ever is a movie which has the same name as another movie that came out during the same year . Does there exist an example of two movies with the same name, and same release year?", "title": "Have there ever been movies with the same name, released in the same year?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<title>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/78328", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/42655/Ghoti and Chips" }

[ [ "There are a number of cases of films with the same name being released in the same year: Chaos (2005), Night Club (1989), Emma (1996), Black Rain (1989), among others.", "There many examples for movies realeased in the same year and under the same title" ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ true ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [ "Drama Director: Michael Keusch Stars: Nicholas Hoppe, Elizabeth Kaitan, Ed Trotta" ] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "There many examples for movies realeased in the same year and under the same title" ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "I just watched the director's explanation and – as I expected although I've not yet seen the film – he intended it to be a playful sign of hope in the face of climate change and endangered species .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Murphy:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "How did you decide that he would come across bees?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Villeneuve:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There are a lot of problems with bees in the world right now.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They are disappearing, so the fact that here you can see those creatures still alive and still present, was for me like a little spark of hope in this dystopian universe.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "-New York Times, 2017-10-02 , Denis Villeneuve Narrates a Scene From ‘Blade Runner 2049’ , by Mekado Murphy", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For background, this is one of many articles available about bees in the face of climate change and how they are endangered .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/57732/Livrecache", "score": 31 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I interpreted this scene two ways, though I'm not sure the writers intended the second.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the original movie, Deckard asks Rachael what she would do if a wasp landed on her arm.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She responds immediately that she would kill it; the desired human response.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the new movie, when a bee lands on K's arm, he doesn't kill.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "K stares at it fascinated.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This to me was the most outright indication that K was not Deckard's kid.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Rachael is used as a plot device to blur \"what it is to be human.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She was a replicant that, by all rights, was indistinguishable from a human: she had empathy, memories, and functioning reproductive organs.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She basically was human.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So this scene overwhelmingly tells me that K wasn't the same as Rachael, and isn't her child.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This scene takes place at the peak of the script where the audience is supposed to believe he is the child, about to confront his dad, so this scene is a subtle nod to the original and a hint to the audience that he is not the kid.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Bees have been used as air quality control in German airports and have been shown to detect and function as bio-sensor for certain types of radiation.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "In the book, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep, the radiation moves around through radioactive dust, so the bees could be Deckard's way of monitoring air quality and radiation levels", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/58162/Nicholas James Concklin", "score": 12 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Although I am sure Livrecache has the right answer, it might be worth mentioning that bees sometimes appear in some of Philip K. Dick's other works so it could also be slight homage.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Hanging Stranger - Is a short story about Bee People replacing humans.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Cosmic Puppets (revised from A Glass of Darkness) - Is a novel about people who were part of an erased town, who come to remember andtwo characters", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "have a small proxy war where both characters can onlyfight each other by using insects and some animals including bees,moths, cats, goloms, spiders, snakes, etc Valis - Novel about a lot of things pertaining to God and surveillance, but features mechanical floating bee & fly cameras.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/56522/Darth Locke", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Livrecache's answer would seem to be definitive, based on the Director's comments.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This technique of integrating current issues is a hallmark of speculative fiction, and mirrored in the use of grubworms as a major food source in 2049.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "[See: \"Starving People Should Eat Bugs\" , Business Insider] Concerns over human over-population and food scarcity have resulted in speculation that insects will be an important food source in the future.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In terms of inspiration for the inclusion of bees as a symbol of hope: I wouldn't be surprised if this device was inspired by The Road In Cormac McCarthy's post-apocalyptic allegory, which shares themes relating to humanity, at the end of the book, the Boy notices a living insect.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(I believe it was a beetle.)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In a world where nearly all life has died-off, the re-emergence of the insect is a sign that that the biosphere is recovering, a symbol of hope.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/40263/DukeZhou", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "There are excellent answers here, and all I can do is contribute a fragment of one possible interpretation (that surely pales next to those already provided, and might be purely coincidental though I'm not conivinced):", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "By loose analogy the bees in Blade Runner 2049 may serve as a reference to the standard tune, \"A Taste of Honey\", which waxes about a love that \"awoke [the singer's] heart\" with a kiss, and that the singer \"will return\" one day.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This mirrors Deckard's situation, and one of the notable recordings of this song was done by Billy Dee Williams, who played Harrison Ford's character's best friend (from his youth) from the Star Wars films.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As performed by Williams, the lyrics are: A taste of honeyTasting much sweeter than wineI dream of your first kissAnd", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "then I feel upon my lips againA taste of honeyTasting much sweeter than wineI will return,", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "yes I will returnI'll come back for the honey and youYours", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "was the kiss that awoke my heartThere lingers still, though we're far apartThat taste of honeyTasting much sweeter than wineOh I will return,", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "yes I will returnI'll come back", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(He'll come back)For the honey", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(For the honey)And you Further examination of the \"bee\" motif throughout literature and movies, and how it is interpreted in psychoanalytical contexts, may shed more light on this metaphor, although even concrete evidence as to why it was chosen for the film may never tell the \"whole story\" of a creative process.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A letter from C. G. Jung from 1934 to an \"Elined Kotschnig\" ( found here , in Volume", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I of the Letters of C. G. Jung) explores how the symbol of bees may have had a particular relevance in one person's dream, but some of the themes discussed therein may be broadly applicable.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Being a historic document of some note, it is also not inconceivable that this letter itself may have had some direct or indirect influence on the film's use of the metaphor.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/47214/Darren Ringer", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I would suggest it could be a reference to Sherlock Holmes, another famous literary character whose profession as a consulting detective (not unlike the blade runners who are affiliated with the police) set him on the heels of nefarious evildoers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In his retirement, he became a beekeeper.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/58644/GPalmer", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "I watched Blade Runner 2049 and while it was gorgeous there were a few things that left me scratching my head: In one scene, K (Ryan Gosling) is walking through Las Vegas and find a dozen apiaries full of bees. The scene is beautiful, but never explained. I can't imagine that such a detailed movie with so much thought given to each shot has this for no reason. What's the meaning of this scene?", "title": "What is the significance of bees in Blade Runner 2049?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><blade-runner-2049>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/81250", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/855/Coomie" }

[ [ " Bees have been used as air quality control in German airports and have been shown to detect and function as bio-sensor for certain types of radiation. In the book, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep, the radiation moves around through radioactive dust, so the bees could be Deckard's way of monitoring air quality and radiation levels. This scene takes place at the peak of the script where the audience is supposed to believe he is the child, about to confront his dad, so this scene is a subtle nod to the original and a hint to the audience that he is not the kid. ", "Bees have been shown to detect and function as bio-sensor for certain types of radiation" ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Bees have been used as air quality control in German airports. They have been shown to detect and function as bio-sensor for certain types of radiation. In the book, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep, the radiation moves through radioactive dust." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "No.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As stated in other answers, Ricky told his father he was gay to disgust him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "What Ricky didn’t know, was his father had been harboring gay feelings himself, which he then tries to bring to fruition with Lester.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Once Lester turns him down and corrects his misinformation about being gay, the Colonel feels overwhelmed with guilt and shame brought on by internalized homophobia and murders Lester to assuage his own feelings.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Ricky couldn’t have possibly known his father would kill Lester.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Ricky knew him as a stern disciplinarian and a control freak, not a murderer.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/46297/M.Mat", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "According to the script, Ricky definitely did not rile up his father to get to get him to murder Lester.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However he did not even say those words just to hurt or piss off his father.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is something that is not depicted in the movie properly but Ricky actually was trying to break free from his father for a long time and at that moment in the movie, he found out a way to do so.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "According to the script - Ricky eyes the Colonel.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He's finally discovered a way to break free from his father, and he can't believe it was this simple.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If it wouldn't have been for the fulfillment of his long cherished desire to get out of the control of his father, Ricky, depicted in the movie as a street smart guy, would have avoided pissing off his father just for momentary pleasure because it would have then made his life even more complicated in the future.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/48771/Shashank", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Ricky told his father he was gay to hurt his father by repulsing him the harshest manner he knew how.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Convincing his father he was gay labeled his father an ultimate failure undermining his self defined masculinity as a man and US Marine.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It also burned the bridge and insulated him from any future temptation to return home forcing Ricky to fend for himself from that moment forward, he was sealing his own fate of independence and thus began his ascension into adulthood.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/59232/123456789123456789123456789", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "No, Ricky told his father simply to piss his father off, because his father was controlling and condescending, and he knew that would really bother his father.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He didn't know his father would kill Lester because of it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8071/Johnny Bones", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "No.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Ricky didn't tell his father", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "he was gay", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so he could kill lester.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He just wanted to infuriate him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Frank was gay.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As to why he was disgusted by it, he had probably been in complete denial about his true nature for years.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Many gay people are torn over their sexual orientation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Adhering to a strict macho military image may have helped Frank mask his true feelings, and he probably considered gay people as being weak and loathsome, while denying he was one.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When he acknowledged his own homosexuality, he, in effect, despised himself and considered his life a failure.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He thought Lester was gay, a secret he's been keeping about himself for a long time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When Lester spurned his kiss, he was humiliated and enraged.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So he killed lester", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/51159/Sunilkumar Ramamurthy", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "During the scene where Jane and Ricky were talking about killing Lester in American Beauty , Ricky zoomed into Jane's eyes. I understood this as a sign, that Jane was not actually joking about killing her father. Do you think Ricky told his father, that him and Lester had sex, just because he knew that he would be pissed off and kill him? This would make sense, because Ricky was so obsessed with Jane and he knew she wanted Lester dead.", "title": "Did Ricky tell his father he is gay, so he would kill Lester?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><american-beauty>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/83118", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/59394/Rollo Tomassi" }

[ [ "Ricky told his father he was gay to hurt his father by repulsing him the harshest manner he knew how. Convincing his father he was gay labeled his father an ultimate failure undermining his self defined masculinity as a man and US Marine. It also burned the bridge and insulated him from any future temptation to return home forcing Ricky to fend for himself from that moment forward, he was sealing his own fate of independence and thus began his ascension into adulthood.", "Ricky told his father he was gay to hurt his father by repulsing him in the harshest manner he knew how. Convincing his father of being gay labeled his father an ultimate failure. It also burned the bridge and insulated him from any future temptation to return home." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Ricky told his father he was gay to hurt his father by repulsing him in the harshest manner he knew how. Convincing his father of being gay labeled his father an ultimate failure. It also burned the bridge and insulated him from any future temptation to return home." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Are 3D glasses needed?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "While not as bad as the early days of 3D where viewing without glasses meant red and blue headaches for days, the video will look slightly off.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Note that many films have scenes, not the whole film in 3D, so you may still enjoy the experience overall.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If so are they provided?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I am not aware of any theater that doesn't provide glasses.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The glasses will typically fit over prescription eyeglasses without modification.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If they are provided would a better experience be had, by purchasing 3D glasses?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You won't know until you try them--if you intend to make a habit of it", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "it might be worthwhile, but you run the risk that the technology used for the effect will change and you will have to repurchase your glasses.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So I am", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I clueless, what do I need to know before walking up to the counter and purchasing a ticket to a 3D movie?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You may experience eye strain and motion sickness, and possibly discomfort due to poorly fitting glasses.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However it will be a novel experience, and hopefully as enjoyable as seeing a movie in 2D.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/34788/Marisa", "score": 47 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "If they are provided would a better experience be had, by purchasing 3D glasses?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I wouldn't bother.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There is no one pair of glasses you can buy that", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "just \"does 3D\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There are many different ways to display 3D , all of which would use slightly different glasses.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So basically, if I was hardcore enough to want to do this, I'd have to check every movie beforehand to make sure my glasses were compatible with how that movie's production company decided to encode 3D on the print of the movie sent to my theater (or to pick the right 3D glasses from my stockpile", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I had to buy to support every 3D tech in use in the movie industry).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/21021/T.E.D.", "score": 9 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Glasses are required , but are provided .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I don't think buying your own will be worth it—the technology could change over time and may be different between theaters.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Many movies are provided in 3D, but not all scenes from a movie are shot in 3D .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Some CGI effects are slightly different between versions.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This usually does not make a difference and the movie looks great .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, I prefer Rogue One in 2D because the CGI effects to make actors look young again didn't translate gracefully to 3D (maybe the details were just overlooked by the editors, I don't know).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Some people report motion sickness-type feelings.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It isn't common.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Personal preference: I bet you'll have fun and love it, but nowadays, I always prefer 2D movies: I don't hassle with holding and wearing glasses (especially the weird feeling of having glasses on over my normal glasses); I feel I can \"take in\" the movie better (see and understand the whole picture at once); and I don't worry about messed up CGI details.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/20379/Joseph Hansen", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "You should be aware that while most people enjoy 3d movies, a significant minority either can't see the 3d effect, or have an adverse reaction to it.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Statistics vary, but about 10% of the population is stereo blind and as many as 1 in 4 report eyestrain, headaches, or motion sickness .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "A recent study suggests that only a third of people have no problems at all viewing 3d movies, and that about 20% of 3d movies have technical errors that are likely to cause problems (e.g. scenes with the left and right images swapped).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Don't let that put you off, the chances are you'll be fine, but if you do feel unwell don't feel you have to stay in the cinema and suffer.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The worst experience I ever had in a cinema was trying to watch Avatar in 3d; I wish I'd left after five minutes.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/60547/Bob says reinstate Monica", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "If you have a vision impairment, you're gonna have a bad time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The magic in 3D cinema technology relies on relatively good vision in both eyes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If you have poor vision in even just one eye, you will barely, if at all, see any 3D effects and walk out of the film with a headache.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For people who don't know if their vision impairment is going to get in the way of a 3D film, a good test is to ask yourself if you could/can see the 3D effects on a Nintendo 3DS.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/34371/8protons", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "One other thing to keep in mind with current 3D technology is that it depends on stereoscopic vision—each eye sees a slightly different (flat) image, which your brain then integrates into a single, 3 dimensional image.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That might sound obvious, but it means that some folks with particular kinds of vision issues won't be able to see the 3D effect the way it is intended (one of my children has strabismus, and doesn't enjoy 3D movies as a result).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Some individuals may not even be aware of having a minor problem until they try to watch a 3D movie and discover that it doesn't work for them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/38079/1006a", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "So I am", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I clueless, what do I need to know before walking up to the counter and purchasing a ticket to a 3D movie?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Other answers already mentioned most of what you need to know, but there is something else you might want to consider.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If you're not comfortable wearing glasses (even if you're just slightly uncomfortable) or simply not used to wearing them, the 3D glasses will make you pretty uncomfortable throughout the entire movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I saw the Last Jedi in 3D last week, but I left with a pretty big headache due to this.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It doesn't take away much from the enjoyment from the movie, but it is something to keep in mind.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I personally tend to avoid 3D movies because of this.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/60524/Dnomyar96", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "There is a movie I want to watch at the theater, it is offered in 3D. I have never watched a theater movie in 3D, I think I want to try it. Are 3D glasses needed? If so are they provided? If they are provided would a better experience be had, by purchasing 3D glasses? So I am I clueless, what do I need to know before walking up to the counter and purchasing a ticket to a 3D movie?", "title": "What do I need to know before watching 3D for the first time", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<3d>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/84324", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/43698/James Jenkins" }

[ [ "A recent study suggests that only a third of people have no problems at all viewing 3d movies, and that about 20% of 3d movies have technical errors that are likely to cause problems (e.g. scenes with the left and right images swapped). Statistics vary, but about 10% of the population is stereo blind and as many as 1 in 4 report eyestrain, headaches, or motion sickness .", "A third of people have no problems at all viewing 3d movies" ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "A third of people have no problems at all viewing 3d movies, but 20% have technical problems. 10% of the population is stereo blind, and 1 in 4 report eyestrain, headaches or motion sickness. The worst experience I ever had in a cinema was trying to watch Avatar in 3d. I wish I'd left after five minutes of watching Avatar in three-D  ." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Though, the title itself is quite ambiguous , but we can go through the movie plot and conclude it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Princess Leia is sensitive to the Force, but she is not a Jedi.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She didn't get training as Jedi.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Kylo Ren was trained as Jedi, but he was seduced by the dark side of the Force, so he is not a Jedi.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Rey was just learning the ways of the Force , but wasn't under actual Jedi training.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She might be a Jedi in future, but it's speculation for now.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When master Yoda died in Return of the Jedi , Luke was the last Jedi left.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Here is the conversation between Yoda and Luke.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yoda: Luke...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Luke...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Do not...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Do not underestimate the powers of the Emperor, or suffer your father's fate, you will.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Luke, when gone am I (cough), the last of the Jedi will you be .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Luke, the Force runs strong in your family.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Pass on what you have learned, Luke... (with great effort) There is...another...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sky", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "...Sky...walker.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When Kylo Ren fights with Luke near the end of", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Last Jedi , they have following conversation, Kylo Ren:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And when I kill you, I will have killed the last Jedi .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Luke Skywalker: Amazing.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Every word of what you just said... was wrong.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Rebellion is reborn today.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The war... is just beginning.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And I will not be the last Jedi .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And the opening crawls of The Force Awakens says, Luke Skywalker has vanished.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In his absence, the sinister FIRST ORDER has risen from the ashes of the Empire and will not rest until Skywalker, the last Jedi , has been destroyed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, it is clear that the title is referring to Luke.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/27264/A J", "score": 69 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Luke Skywalker is referred to as \"the last jedi\" by the opening crawl of Episode VII:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Force Awakens: Luke Skywalker has vanished.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In his absence, the sinister FIRST ORDER has risen from the ashes of the Empire and will not rest until Skywalker, the last Jedi, has been destroyed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The text of the Episode VII opening crawl can be found on this wiki page: \"Opening crawl\", Star Wars wikia", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/61279/Geekmann", "score": 26 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Rian Johnson, the writer and director, seems to indicate that it is indeed Luke, though he seemed hesitant to do so in April 2017 During a chat with ABC News in April, Johnson wouldn’t confirm the title as a reference to Luke.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "“Well, if you say so,” he said to the suggestion.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "“I’m gonna take your word for it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They say in The Force Awakens that he’s going to find the last Jedi temple, and Luke is the last Jedi.”", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But another interview in September shows more certainty:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "“It’s in the opening crawl of The Force Awakens,” he clarified.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "“Luke Skywalker, right now, is the last Jedi...\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/7969/HorusKol", "score": 12 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "At the start of the movie, Luke Skywalker is The Last Jedi.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He is the only Jedi-trained individual in the Galaxy who has not fallen to the dark side.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "At the end of the movie, Rey has everything she needs to become a Jedi and train a new generation.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "She has the will, the ability to stand up against temptation, and the Jedi tomes stolen before Yoda burned the shrine down (beside the blankets in the Falcon).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "There are children throughout the galaxy inspired by the tales of Luke and Rey and companions, including one who force-pulls a broom before striking a pose.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "I suspect the real reason of the movie's title is the paradox it evokes: The Last Jedi has died, but he will not be The Last Jedi.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/32181/Yakk", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "As of the end of The Force Awakens , we believed Luke Skywalker to be the last remaining Jedi in the galaxy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Even the opening crawl of", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Last Jedi calls him this: Luke Skywalker has vanished.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In his absence, the sinister FIRST ORDER has risen from the ashes of the Empire and will not rest until Skywalker, the last Jedi , has been destroyed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, the name of the film is a twist, playing into the surprising (?)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "events of the film's end: Luke dies, and in voiceover indicates that he is not the last Jedi.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Camerawork and events happening elsewhere indicate that, instead: Rey is .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Whether you believe this is good storytelling and/or actually makes any logical sense is quite another thing. :)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4131/Lightness Races in Orbit", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Well.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Even though the answers so far make sense, in all foreign translations into languages which differentiate between plural and singular \"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Last Jedi\" was translated into the plural form, indicating at least two (arguably Luke and Rey).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The fact that it happened on every possible instance indicates that this was a deliberate top-down decision, though it could just be miscommunication between writers and marketing.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "http://www.gamesradar.com/star-wars-the-last-jedi-title-is-plural-according-to-multiple-foreign-language-logos/", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/61281/pedrogfp", "score": 0 } } ]

{ "question": "New Star Wars film is titled Star Wars: The Last Jedi . In this movie we can see \"Kylo\" has Force powers, \"Rey\" has Force powers at the end and Princess Leia also has Force abilities. Luke Skywalker is already a Jedi. So, who is the \"Last Jedi\" referenced in the movie title? Is it: Luke Skywalker Kylo Ren Rey Princess Leia", "title": "Who is the titular \"Last Jedi\"?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<analysis><star-wars><title><the-last-jedi>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/85048", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/" }

[ [ "At the start of the movie, Luke Skywalker is The Last Jedi. He is the only Jedi-trained individual in the Galaxy who has not fallen to the dark side. At the end of the movie, Rey has everything she needs to become a Jedi and train a new generation. Perhaps the real reason for the movie's title is the paradox it evokes: The Last Jedi has died, but he will not be The Last Jedi.", "The real reason of the film's title is the paradox it evokes: The last Jedi has died, but he will not be The LastJedi." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "At the start of the movie, Luke Skywalker is The Last Jedi. He is the only Jedi-trained individual in the Galaxy who has not fallen to the dark side. At the end, Rey has everything she needs to become a Jedi and train a new generation. But the real reason of the film's title is the paradox it evokes: The last Jedi has died, but he will not be The LastJedi." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "They don't know.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They don't care.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It doesn't matter what were the original colors.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As the movie was filmed in black and white, the set, the costumes, even the makeup was designed to look good in black and white and not to have correct color.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A famous example is the sets of the Addams Family which were built in pink, but the filming rendered them in grim colors.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The emulsion of early films (about 1920s and earlier) was almost completely insensitive to red (reds were rendered as blacks)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but on the other hand, it was overly sensitive to UV.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "One can say that the movies were filmed in ultraviolet, so not only the colors were \"lost\", but even the luminance we see on the film is absolutely nothing like the actors and set looked like to a naked eye.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Here's an excellent article about peculiarities of early-film makeup, (credit to user151841 and 1006a for finding it) which explains how the actors were painted in colors resembling zombies in order to get a lively look on the film.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So when/if black-and-white movies are colorized, it's counterproductive to restore the way they really looked.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The new color has to reflect the way their creators wanted them to look, and there usually is no way to know that but guess.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Coloring process is not about \"conversion\" at all.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's an artistic process in which color is added by coloring artist as they see fit and to match to their taste.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/11330/Agent_L", "score": 115 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "There are lots of ways they can determine the colors.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "If those movies props are still available, they can take a look at it.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Usually, their descriptions are also available, they can guess the colors using them.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "If there is not, then they will guess or see which colors will fit best.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It would depend on the producer or the person deciding on the colors to be original or better for TV.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Furthermore , if any of the production team or actors is available, they can simply ask them.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "If they don't know, they can come up with a color that suits that frame.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "We know the obvious colors of some things, like a green tree, blue sky, blue water, red blood, white marble (as in your example) etc.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "However, besides those methods, colors are guessed and it's an art to select the most suitable color.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "They usually do that frame by frame.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "And once you know which one to use, you can copy it in other frames.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "For example, the color of dresses that characters wear in the subsequent shots.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "If you want to know how do they do that, take a look at this question at Signal Processing SE", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/27264/A J", "score": 25 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "There are three general situations: For material which was deliberately shot in black and white, there might not be any \"true\" intended color, so whoever is doing the colorizing may have to invent it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For material that was shot in color, but for which no color copy survives, someone who is attempting to recreate the original may use any existing references as a basis.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sometimes black and white films shot from color PAL video sources may end up with a \"texture\" superimposed upon it from the chroma signal.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Alternating scan lines will be shifted by amount which depends upon the exact hue.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If one merely examined a single character without knowing what color it represented, there would be four combinations of chroma and line phase that could yield it [and each possibility would yield different hues] but looking at a picture as a whole it would usually be possible to figure out which combination \"makes sense\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The first situation above represents what's most commonly referred to as \"colorization\", but it's not the only way of adding color to images captured on black and white film.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8357/supercat", "score": 10 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "First of all, remember that The Wizard of Oz was shot in color (except for the Kansas scenes).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But, for the general case, where the color isn't immediately obvious (sky, water, grass, trees, etc.), you have several resources:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For costumes, you may have access to period clothing, or color photographs of such clothing (such as", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "these amazing color photographs from Imperial Russia );", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For building exteriors and sets, you may have photographs, notes, or descriptions;", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Skin tones would be relatively straightforward; But,", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "yeah, sometimes you may not have an historical resource available, and go with something that a) makes sense, and b) fits in the overall aesthetic.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For example, the actor's tunic in the first image may not have originally been that shade of green, but it's lighter than the vest and yet not pure white.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Same thing with the actress' dress.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The chosen colors may represent something that's known to have been common at the time, and they look good together on the screen.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/47262/John Bode", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In the old days of colorizing film was done BY HAND.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Literally painting the negatives and reshooting it to make a new frame.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "While color film was expensive, it wasn't for still images and records of the colors used in fabrics, and set pieces allowed them to pic the color they needed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Now it's digital, software analyzes the gray in the movie and assigns a pixel a certain degree based on light level and darkness.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Thus a color hex pixel is assigned.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/81911/LazyReader", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "In black and white movies that have been remastered to have color, how do they know what colors are what?", "title": "How is color determined when colorizing black and white movies?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<production><film-techniques><black-and-white>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/88387", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/59981/Muze" }

[ [ "There are a number of ways to decide colors when changing a black and white film to color. Obviously, the color of some things, like the sky, grass, bloos, etc. is obviously. For clothing, a look at the original props if available can help. Otherwise a good guess. Once a decision has been made, the colors are copied to subsequent frames. ", "S0: There are lots of ways they can determine the colors. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ " There are lots of ways they can determine the colors. Furthermore , if any of the production team or actors is available, they can simply ask them.If you want to know how do they do that, take a look at this question at Signal Processing SE" ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "The last time we saw Hulk, he was overpowered and beaten badly by Thanos.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He doesn't reappear after the Bifrost transport to Earth and refuses to \"come out\" for Banner.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "This is the first time Hulk has ever come up against an opponent that was stronger than him, and this has shocked him to his big green core.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Hulk seems to be afraid.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Even Banner states that Thanos, with the Power stone is already the strongest creature in the universe.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "We will likely need to wait for the next Avengers movie to get confirmation but this seems to be the most likely reason based on what we know.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/34402/Dave", "score": 73 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Definitive answer from the directors here:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hulk doesn't want to fight for people who don't care about him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Anthony and Joe Russo appeared on a May 6 episode of Happy Sad Confused with Josh Horowitz to talk Infinity War spoilers, and during the episode, they broke down exactly why we got a lot more Banner and a lot less Hulk in Infinity War.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Throughout the movie, Banner tries desperately to bring Hulk out, but the green guy refuses.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But it’s not because the transformation mechanism isn’t working.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "“If the Hulk were to say why,” Joe Russo explained, “it’s that Banner only wants Hulk for fighting.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He’s had enough of saving Banner’s ass. ”", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "“People have interpreted as the Hulk’s scared,” Joe Russo mused, referring to how Thanos soundly defeated him in one-on-one combat in the film’s opening.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "“But it’s really reflective of his journey from Ragnarok, that these two characters are constantly in conflict with each other over control.”", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It has more to do with the internal conflict between Banner and Hulk than any bruised egos.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "https://www.inverse.com/article/44602-avengers-infinity-war-hulk-bruce-banner-spoilers-transformation", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/None/", "score": 27 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "To expand on @Dave's answer , Hulk just had a downfall from hubris and isn't dealing with it too well.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hulk is basically a big ball of emotions with the strength of a titan and the brain of a child.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "His sense of self is wrapped up in being the biggest and the strongest and being invulnerable and winning fights.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He's lost fights before, to the Hulkbuster Suit and to Thor, but always after a good fight.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Thanos was different.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Thanos was almost dismissive of Hulk.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hulk lost to Thanos badly .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hulk does one thing well and he failed miserably at it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This calls his entire identity into question.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hulk's has never felt vulnerable before.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He doesn't know how to deal with it; so he's scared and hiding in his room.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/13258/Schwern", "score": 21 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Snow answered it pretty well but Joe Russo also said one more thing: \"We have to be careful with the character of Banner,\" Joe Russo explained. \"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Because if every time he's in trouble Hulk saves him, Hulk becomes the hero and he becomes whiny.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We wanted to force Banner to be the hero.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "- businessinsider", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1190/Ankit Sharma", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I actually assumed it was the follow up to the Ragnarok plot point that he might not be able to turn back if he shifted then - which he did.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "At the time, he thought he might not be able to turn back into Banner, but I assumed it was the consequence we never had for that in Ragnarok...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(See this article that describes this more clearly and with examples.)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/63708/bdeniker", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "There are two scenes in the movie where Banner calls out to Hulk and Hulk denies him. These events happens after the first Hulk fight where Loki proclaims \"We have a Hulk\". One is in New York during the fight with the children of Thanos. The other is in Wakanda. When Banner called out to Hulk, he simply responds with a curt “Nooo”. What could be the reason?", "title": "Why does Hulk act the way he does in Avengers: Infinity War?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><character><marvel-cinematic-universe><avengers-infinity-war>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/88486", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/16058/Shalini" }

[ [ "Avengers: Infinity War. This is the first time Hulk has ever come up against an opponent that was stronger than him, and this has shocked him to his big green core. ", "The last time we saw Hulk, he was overpowered and beaten badly by Thanos. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "The last time we saw Hulk, he was overpowered and beaten badly by Thanos. Hulk doesn't reappear after the Bifrost transport to Earth and refuses to \"come out\" for Banner. This is the first time Hulk has ever come up against an opponent that was stronger than him. Even Banner states that Thanos, with the Power stone is already the strongest creature in the universe." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "This may be a reference to an obscure \"trend\" from Scotland.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The Glasgow Stonner Kebab", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "\"The Stonner\", a 1,000-calorie, deep fried pork sausage kebab has been dubbed the most dangerous fast food in Britain.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The connection is that Vision and Scarlet Witch are hiding in Edinburgh, Scotland and they got to make a reference to a local 10+ year old fast food trend.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Reading the article, these are indeed deep fried and not very good for you.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Probably only Hulk or Cull Obsidian should eat one while everybody else sticks to Chicken Schwarma", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/53231/m1gp0z", "score": 44 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It just lets you know they are in Scotland.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If they were in Paris they might sit in a café somewhere that had the Eiffel Tower in view.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If they were in New York they might have yellow cabs going by or perhaps", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "if they wanted to indicate that they were in New York prior to 2001 they'd be somewhere", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "you could see the World Trade Centre.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "All of these things let the audience get a sense of where in the world characters are.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "While deep fried kebabs specifically are more of a Glasgow thing than an Edinburgh thing, Scots are well-known for their deep-frying of food that most people would not, so it serves as a signifier of the location just as a red double-decker bus would in London, and so on.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The St Andrew's Cross flag on the poster also serves the same story-telling purpose.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's no different in this regard than Captain Rogers running laps past Sam Wilson at the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool in", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Winter Soldier telling us that the action is taking place in Washington DC, and so on, but people are making a bit more of a deal out of it because the Scottish fondness for deep-fried food, often already highly calorific and fatty even before it was fried, is something that amuses a lot of people already.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/20474/Jon Hanna", "score": 31 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Within about a minute of this scene, at 38:02 into the movie, the Vision is impaled through the chest by Corvus Glaive's spear.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Like a kebab.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/31947/notovny", "score": 13 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The scene is filmed in Edinburgh (this particular shot appears to be looking up Cockburn (pronounced coh-burn)", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Street towards the Royal Mile, with other parts of the scene in the same area (including on the Royal Mile at the top of the street and Waverley Station at the bottom of it).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Throughout Scotland", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "the deep fried battered Mars Bar has become something of a meme (for good reason, they're delicious!)", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "in the last 20-30 years, with some fryers offering to deep fry anything from confectionery to Christmas dinners.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Some fryers are reluctant to fry chocolate (as it tends to come through the batter into the oil), but more will be prepared to fry savoury items (kebabs, pizzas).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "(If you really want to maximise saturated fat intake, deep fried pizza whether battered or not is a good way to do so!)", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Presumably this poster was put in shot to anchor the location as a Scottish city with a popular but not too cliched meme, (e.g. avoiding highland dress, bagpipes, haggis, heather and shortbread)", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/64670/rolinger", "score": 9 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "As discussed in other answers, it appears to have been placed as a fun reference to Scottish food culture.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "See this list from The Telegraph, which includes such things as deep fried pizza on a list of 'Scottish Delicacies', as an example of the view of Scottish food.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The takeaway shop unit was set up for the film and isn't genuine.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If you are looking for the fast food shop that promises to \"deep fry your kebab\", you will be sadly disappointed.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "These signs were set up specifically for Avengers: Infinity War, and were promptly dismantled after filming wrapped up. from https://edinburgh.org/edinburgh-on-film/filmed-in-edinburgh/avengers-infinity-war", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Here's a quote from VisitScotland regarding the sign:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "“The Marvel films are well-known for their tongue-in-cheek humour and it’s great to see the filmmakers having fun and playing on Scotland’s real quirky culinary creation, the deep fried Mars Bar, which has enjoyed something of a cult following among visitors,” Film and Creative Industries manager Jenni Steele told us. from https://junkee.com/deep-fried-kebab-avengers/156362", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/68213/Strange Ideas", "score": 5 } } ]

{ "question": "In Avengers: Infinity War , we see a poster about Scotland's deep fried kebab for a significant amount of time: Is there any significance to it? Or is it just random? Note: Inspired from CinemaSins", "title": "What was the significance of the deep fried kebab poster in Infinity War?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<analysis><marvel-cinematic-universe><avengers-infinity-war><props>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/94622", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1190/Ankit Sharma" }

[ [ "The poster of the deep fried kebab in Avengers: Infinity War is probably a meme used to anchor the acyion in Scotland. It is a reference to the Scottish culinary habit of deep frying anything which started with the Mars Bar.", "The Glasgow Stonner Kebab appears to be a reference to the scene being filmed in Edinburgh." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "The Glasgow Stonner Kebab appears to be a reference to the scene being filmed in Edinburgh. The deep fried battered Mars Bar has become a popular meme in Scotland. Some fryers offer to deep fry anything from confectionery to Christmas dinners. Some are reluctant to fry chocolate, as it tends to come through the batter into the oil. The poster appears to have been placed as a fun reference to Scottish food culture. It appears to anchor the location as a Scottish city with a popular but not too cliched meme, (e.g. avoiding highland dress, bagpipes, haggis, heather and heather)" ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Why would they do it?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As you said, they hate Harry.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They want to be away from him as much as possible, and all he represents (i.e., Wizardry).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Dursleys want to be normal above all else.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They want to be regarded as successful, but anything crazy sounding is a big no-no for them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Mr and Mrs Dursley, of number four, Privet Drive, were proud to say that they were perfectly normal, thank you very much.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They live much better by ignoring Harry and pretending he doesn't exist at all.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Dursleys had everything they wanted, but they also had a secret, and their greatest fear was that somebody would discover [...] about the Potters.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, who would believe them if they said Wizards existed?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "No one.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Child protective services would arrive much sooner than a squad of scientists to study poor Harry.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/32199/BlueMoon93", "score": 109 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The Dursleys don’t want people knowing.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The Dursleys would never want to expose magic to the world, because they never wanted anyone to find out about their unusual relatives.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "They were afraid of that happening, and intensely wanted to avoid it.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "“The Dursleys had everything they wanted, but they also had a secret, and their greatest fear was that somebody would discover it.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "They didn’t think they could bear it if anyone found out about the Potters.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Mrs Potter was Mrs Dursley’s sister, but they hadn’t met for several years; in fact, Mrs Dursley pretended she didn’t have a sister, because her sister and her good-for-nothing husband were as unDursleyish as it was possible to be.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The Dursleys shuddered to think what the neighbours would say if the Potters arrived in the street.”", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "- Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, Chapter 1", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0, 0 ] ] }, { "text": "(The Boy Who Lived)", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "They certainly wouldn’t reveal that secret by telling people that magic exists and they know about it themselves.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "They took pride in their normalcy, and wouldn’t want to be known as being involved in anything so unusual and abnormal as wizards and magic.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "“Mr and Mrs Dursley, of number four, Privet Drive, were proud to say that they were perfectly normal, thank you very much.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "They were the last people you’d expect to be involved in anything strange or mysterious, because they just didn’t hold with such nonsense.”", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "- Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, Chapter 1", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0, 0 ] ] }, { "text": "(The Boy Who Lived) Telling people magic exists would be the exact opposite of what the Dursleys would want to do - they wanted it, and more importantly their tangential involvement with it, to stay secret.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/60093/Mal", "score": 56 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "They have no motive.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It wouldn't benefit them, other than spite, and although it wouldn't be out of character for them to act out of spite, they seem to be more wanting to ignore the wizarding world than harm it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They are living in denial.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For the first ~10 years of Harry's residence, they simply pretended that magic didn't exist, and after he started attending Hogwarts, they tried as best they could to continue doing so.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They don't have much in the way of proof.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The wizarding world isn't going to do magic in front of them while they're holding a camcorder, and even if they got proof, the wizarding world likely could get rid of it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That just leaves the Dursleys ranting like crazy people about wizards and witches.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They know little about the magic world.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When Harry first comes home from Hogwarts, they are afraid around him, worried about what magic he can do, until they find out that he'll get in trouble if he does magic outside of school.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Clearly, no one's going out their way to explain everything to them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe they can't be obliviated, but they don't know that, nor do they know whether there's anything else can be done to them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/56738/Acccumulation", "score": 23 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "If I'm not mistaken, in the \"Harry Potter\" books it was made clear that the Dursleys despised everything out of ordinary and one of their main aspirations in life was to be perfectly normal.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So they would definitely not want to do something as eccentric, as saying that wizards and witches exist.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/69818/MeryChon", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Vernon's personality is described as very much in favor of normality.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He would much prefer to pretend magic doesn't exist.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As for Petunia, the magical world killed her sister.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She has chosen to consciously forget about it because it's too painful.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/62681/Carlos Arturo Serrano", "score": 2 } } ]

{ "question": "We see in the Harry Potter universe, wizards or witches keep obliviating Muggles/No-Majs, because otherwise it may lead to chaos or persecution of witches/wizards. However, the Dursley family cannot be obliviated since they have to give Lily's protection to Harry. Obviously they did not like Harry, so why did they not expose the magic world?", "title": "Why didn't the Dursleys make witchcraft and wizardry public?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><harry-potter>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/96299", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/63699/Zaid Syed M Md" }

[ [ "The Dursleys would never want to expose magic to the world, because they never wanted anyone to find out about their unusual relatives. They didn’t think they could bear it if anyone found out about the Potters. Mrs Potter was Mrs Dursley’s sister, but they hadn’t met for several years; in fact, Mrs Dursley pretended she didn’t have a sister, because her sister and her good-for-nothing husband were as unDursleyish as it was possible to be. (The Boy Who Lived) Telling people magic exists would be the exact opposite of what the Dursleys would want to do - they wanted it, and more importantly their tangential involvement with it, to stay secret.", "They didn't think they could bear it if anyone found out about the Potters. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "The Dursleys had a secret, and their greatest fear was that somebody would discover it. They didn't think they could bear it if anyone found out about the Potters. They took pride in their normalcy, and wouldn't want to be known as being involved in anything so unusual and abnormal. Telling people magic exists would be the exact opposite of what they would want to do. They wanted it, and more importantly their tangential involvement with it, to stay secret. They wouldn't reveal that secret by telling people that magic exists and they know about it themselves. They were the last people you'd expect to be involved with anything strange or mysterious, because they just didn't hold with such nonsense. The Dursley's secret is revealed in Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, Chapter 1" ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Now that the movie is released we can finally really answer it:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "it's a combination of projectors and drones, controlled by Mysterio", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/19085/Ivo Beckers", "score": 16 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I saw this picture on reddit which was interesting.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Looks like it could be hydro-man since the reference is there.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Credit - https://www.reddit.com/r/MovieDetails/comments/agtvu1/do_movie_trailer_details_count/", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/40398/ajrthegreat", "score": 13 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "He could be named Hydro-Man", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "As Mr Sunday Movies noted in his trailer breakdown , there is a shot showing a boat with the name: ASM 212 Which is likely a reference to The Amazing Spider-Man , Volume 1, Issue 212, which featured the \"Wet Threat of Hydro-Man!\"", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It's possible that the villian will be named similarly in the film.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Similarly, the other villain's identity may be The Molten Man , evidenced through a number plate that refers to a Spider-Man issue, released on September 28, 1965.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/46925/Longshanks", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "No one knows for sure at the moment What we do know is that The Elementals are in it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Because...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "well...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Who else could it be?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Magnum and Hellfire for sure are shown in the trailer.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And it'd be pretty confusing to moviegoers if they introduced both Hydro-Man and The Elementals at the same time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, they have similarities and so the talk on the street is that it's going to be Hydro-Man in The Elementals, replacing Hydron.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8071/Johnny Bones", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It's currently unclear, but IGN has a good breakdown of history of the character vs the elements and what they could do and why:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Oh, and there's also a guy called Hydro-Man who may or may not be in the mix here as well, so we'll talk about him too!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(It seems likely that he has been combined with Hydron for Far From Home, or we just aren't sure which water-based baddie", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "the film is using at this point.) ...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yes, OK, it’s going to be Mysterio at some point, surely, but before that, another enemy rearing his wet head might be none other than Hydro-Man!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Given his powers, it’s highly likely that the movie will retrofit Hydro-Man into the Elementals, perhaps replacing Hydron and thus giving the team of villains a leader with a bit more name recognition.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You don’t remember him either?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Does that mean we have to…OK, then!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/56522/Darth Locke", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "Who is the Water villain being shown in the Spider-Man: Far From Home (2019) trailer? Is that Hydro-Man or an Elemental?", "title": "Who is the water villain shown in Spider-Man: Far From Home trailer?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<marvel-cinematic-universe><spider-man-far-from-home>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/96492", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/64925/Surya Tej" }

[ [ "The water villain shown in Spider-Man: Far From Home trailer could be Hydro-Man.", "He could be named Hydro-Man " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Hydro-Man could be a reference to The Amazing Spider-Man Volume 1, Issue 212. The other villain's identity may be The Molten Man, evidenced by a number plate that refers to a Spider- man issue. \"Wet Threat of Hydro-Man!\" featured in the issue." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Iron Man is constantly tinkering, and each suit evolution gets a new name - Mark 1 was built in the cave in the mountains, Mark 2 was built in his lab and has tech to deal with the icing problem etc.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In this scene, he is developing the Mark 42 suit ( https://ironman.fandom.com/wiki/Mark_42 ).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The suit can arrive in multiple pieces that can slot on individually, \"tuned\" to Tony, and even obey remote commands originating from Tony, and from great ranges - beyond just an AI being controlled by Jarvis.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The injections he is putting into himself seem to be part of that tech.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's either a substance or a chip that is being injected into his forearm, to interface with his body - likely a neural interface.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Consider the following results: His initial gesture/command does not work as expected.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After tapping/awakening his arm, it does work.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This could be a direct result on the substance/chip itself, in the same vein as slapping a TV to get it to work, or slapping his forearm, designed to stimulate neural activity .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When he is asleep, and having nightmares about New York, he manages to \"call\" to the suit in his sleep - a direct connection to his brain activity.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The suit similarly \"called\" when he is imprisoned, from across the country.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In almost all of these instances, we are visibly shown a physical gesture (the sleep one not so much, but we are cutting in and out of flashback).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/31898/DariM", "score": 40 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "What Tony is injecting are the Subcutaneous Implants for controlling Mark 42, otherwise known as: JARVIS:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Mark 42, inbound.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Tony: I'll be damned.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The prodigal son returns.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Source: Springfield!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Springfield@ - Iron Man 3", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Mark 42 also features the unique ability to control itself when Tony Stark isn't inside his suit or when Mark 42 is A.I-deactivated.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Subcutaneous Implant in Tony's forearms allow the armor to communicate with his nervous system helping the armor follow his commands.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Any action done by Stark is imitated by Mark 42 if he connects with it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Source: Mark 42 >", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Armor Capabilities > Subcutaneous Implants", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "we see the Mark 42 in the workshop at the start of the film and", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "after injecting himself we see him try to put on the suit.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "where the wiki says it imitates tony's actions", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "we know it does more than that as Tony used it to fool Pepper that he was wearing the suit sitting in the lounge when really he was still in his workshop working on stuff", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and when they are sleeping the Mark 42 enters the room and looks as if it's about to attack Pepper before Tony takes up, commands it to power down and then does a sorta sword slash motion which causes it to fall into the individual components.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so despite The Subcutaneous Implant being in his arms it seems to also be tied mentally to him and can react to certain moves by Tony (which as the sword cutting move he did in bed)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Is it ever explained, either in the movie or the comic book source, what he's injecting, and why he needed to rub it to get it to work?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "i'm not sure where it's referenced to outside the wiki but", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "according to This Quora question on the same topic [the Subcutaneous Implants is] the equivalent of what \"Extremis\" was in the comic storyline.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so chances are the comic fans worked this out In regards to the rubbing, he's more cleaning his arm of from what i assume is blood after the injections, as for the sorta tapping/slapping either it's either sorta moving the implant(s) around to spread them out a bit more he's trying to mask the pain.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "we see him saying \"owe\" when J.A.R.V.I.S is counting and J.A.R.V.I.S stopped counting at 47 and i think Tony does 2 more.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "so he injected himself like 49 times", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and they don't seem painless.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4297/Memor-X", "score": 25 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "While the “technical” in-universe answer is he’s injecting subcutaneous implants to control the Mark42 armor, Stark performs many technical tasks they don’t show us on screen.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The entire Iron Man 3 storyline is about", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "addiction - Tony is addicted to his legion of suits, all the baddies are addicted to Extremis...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Showing Tony “shooting up”, basically, is a very direct filmmaker statement to that effect.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He’d be doing the same thing if he were shooting up (you slap to get a vein, and lick for a very crude sterilization).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "See", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Addiction Of Tony Stark, Why Won’t Anybody Help Him or any other number of analyses of the movie for more in-depth on this.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8399/mxyzplk - SE stop being evil", "score": 10 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The answer starts with the previous year's movie, The Avengers , in the famous \"offer Loki a drink \" scene (cued up).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Note the bracelets he is clipping onto his wrists.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Continue watching that clip.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "About 90 seconds later, Stark is thrown out a window by Loki.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The \"Mark VII\" suit knocks over Loki in hot pursuit.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The Mark VII locks onto the bracelets and wraps itself around Tony, just in time to brake his fall.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The bracelets are essential to the suit latching on to him .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Now, there's an obvious disadvantage, in that he has to wear those bracelets.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Wouldn't implants be nicer?", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "So let's return to the present movie.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "In the very scene you speak of, around 00:05:17, he speaks the following: Micro-repeater implanting sequence complete.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "That is exactly what those are: an implanted version of the bracelets.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/55308/Harper - Reinstate Monica", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I didn't see the movie since months but from memory he injects the tracking chips that define the anchor points of his mobile armor when he calls it remotely.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, you know, the crotch part doesn't anchor itself on his face by accident.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I guess he licks", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "/rubs it because the chip didn't align properly on the first try and he does this to put it in the right place.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/56149/kikirex", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "In the beginning of Iron Man 3 (2013) , Tony injects something into his forearm. He then attempts to get his suit to come to him. After it fails, he licks his arm, rubs it and tries again, at which time it works. Is it ever explained, either in the movie or the comic book source, what he's injecting, and why he needed to rub it to get it to work?", "title": "What is Tony Stark injecting into himself in Iron Man 3?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><marvel-cinematic-universe><iron-man-3>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/97595", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8071/Johnny Bones" }

[ [ "In Iron Man 3, Tony Stark injects himself with implanter version of the bracelets he wears for the Mark VII suit to latch on to him.", "That is exactly what those are: an implanted version of the bracelets." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "The answer starts with the famous \"offer Loki a drink\" scene from The Avengers. Tony Stark's bracelets are essential to the suit latching on to him. In the very scene you speak of, around 00:05:17, he speaks the following: Micro-repeater implanting sequence complete. That is exactly what those are: an implanted version of the bracelets. The \"Mark VII\" suit wraps itself around Tony just in time to brake his fall." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Some info (mostly speculation) is available in this article : From Dunne’s comments and those schematics, this looks to be a spear-like weapon that can unscrew into being two short-range stabbing weapons as well.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Essentially, a double-ended spear that can also act as two daggers.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "One tip is definitely dragonglass—we can tell that from Arya’s schematics.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Is the other end using her Valyrian steel dagger blade?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Is that flame?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Just an ornate handle?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Unlikely just a handle—that doesn’t seem like Arya’s style.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We’ve actually probably already seen Arya using this weapon in a few brief shots from the Season 8 trailer.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/33910/Federico", "score": 14 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Tommy Dunne, the weapons master for Game of Thrones , has the following to say on what is almost certainly the weapon Arya asks Gendry to make:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In a recent interview with Vanity Fair’s “Still Watching” podcast, Thrones weapons master Tommy Dunne teased what is very likely this new blade: “There is one creation in Season 8 that is absolutely phenomenal.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It’ll be a showstopper.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That was great to finish.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was great to make, great to design in that it was able to be reverse-engineered and made into two different items.”", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Vanity Fair, Game of Thrones:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Gendry Is Making Arya a “Showstopper” Weapon As of now we don't know what it actually is, and all we have to go off is the schematic and Dunne's comments.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That said the schematic shows two pieces that fit together and can come apart with one end being tipped in dragonglass so it is likely a long weapon that can be split into two dagger like weapons.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/45378/TheLethalCarrot", "score": 14 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Everybody seems to assume it's a spear - it's not, primarily, and she doesn't seem to use it as such most of the time.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Of course, it's sharp at both ends so you can poke it at people [", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "using dragon glass so would be effective against wights as well as humans], but that's not really how we see her use it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Her weapon is basically the stick she learned to use so well fighting the waif in Bravos - with two pointy ends to stick them with as well.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is all her years of training being put to use.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She used it to great effect on top of Winterfell's walls...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She split it in half when she first moved indoors, into more restricted space, but mainly she still wielded it like her stick.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'd say ninja-style, even though that's not a discipline that exists in this world.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Why it was splittable", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'm not really sure about.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She split it when she went indoors, very briefly, but the next time we see her she's re-assembled it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I checked some timings...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She actually loses the 'posh stick' as she dives over some wights down a flight of stairs, and is not seen again with it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "[cross-ref to https://movies.stackexchange.com/a/100243/25773 with gif]", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She doesn't have it when she jumps off the parapet onto the sloped roof.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When we next see her again indoors, she picks up a dragon glass dagger from the floor behind some fallen furniture.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She keeps this right through the library scene & the chase afterwards.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She loses that when she's rescued by Dondarrion.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So she splits the stick for an entire 10 seconds & that's it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "All that for 10 seconds", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": ";-)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She has the stick from 39:40, splits it at 40:00", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She goes out of shot with it still split at 40:11 & the next time we see her", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "it's back together again at 40:18.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I first thought it split to be a long stick & a dagger, but it does split into two unequal sizes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Splitting to a dagger didn't quite make sense to me, as she already was known to be carrying a Valyrian steel dagger; the one originally used on the attempt on Bran's life... ...and used, rather appropriately in the end, to kill the Night King and save Bran.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "From comments -", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the godswood she doesn't have the stick at all [see timings above]", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "she has only the Valyrian steel dagger, which she drops from one hand and catches in the other.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/25773/Tetsujin", "score": 9 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "While i cannot be certain, it appears it may be an Atl-atl or a Spear", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Thrower", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The user holders on end using a lever or rope to then propel the spear faster and further.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "the spear itself is shorter and expendable so", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "perhaps that is what she wants.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "the design doesn't look quite right for one but it looks similar at least I'll be honest its a bit of a stretch", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but it was what first came to my mind when i saw it", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/63700/Blade Wraith", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It's a Dragonglass Spear according to the HBO - Making Game of Thrones website.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As of S08E03, \"The Long Night\", it is shown to be a spear with a dragonglass head at both ends and can be separated in the middle to be two shorter spears.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1006/galacticninja", "score": 8 } } ]

{ "question": "In season 8 episode 1, Arya asks Gendry to forge her a dragonglass weapon (which we can see drawn). What is the purpose of this weapon?", "title": "What is Arya's weapon design?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<game-of-thrones>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/98377", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/71951/Reed" }

[ [ "Arya's weapon in GOT season 8 episode 1 is essentially, a double-ended spear that can also act as two daggers,one tip is definitely dragonglass.", "Essentially, a double-ended spear that can also act as two daggers. One tip is definitely dragonglass." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "Some info (mostly speculation) available in this article. Essentially, a double-ended spear that can also act as two daggers. One tip is definitely dragonglass." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "It seems they were a kind of Easter-Egg.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the novels, we received a long narrative about the elephants of The Golden Company, which was left out of the show.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In George R. R. Martin’s fifth GOT novel, A Dance With Dragons, we learn of The Golden Company through a rather long-winded side story that has thankfully been cut from the HBO show lest it get even more complicated.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Someone in the writer’s room clearly wasn’t happy with this decision, and so decided to throw in an elephant-sized easter egg for viewers who have also read the series so far.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Cersei’s need for elephants in the Game Of Thrones", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "premiere comes directly from the books - Metro UK", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, it seems like this is a special Easter-Egg for those who have read the series.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/63980/Daeron", "score": 53 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Elephants are always a funny kind of weapon Having a big weapon on your side is a terrible advantage.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Elephants are a good historical example: while they don't deal a lot of damage per se, they are terrible for enemy morale.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You can only have a few, and each of them won't deal a lot of damage.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But if you are on the other side, that's another topic.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Gosh, an elephant charging me!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Ok, so if we all keep the formation, the elephant will crush on our spear formation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sure, there will be casualties, but we will win.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The only thing we had to do is keep our formation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hey, what is Joe doing?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "he can't escape the battle, can he?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Whatever, he was a coward.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We can keep formation without him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But, wait, Jack is also fleeing!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He was the best of us.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If even he thinks we are lost...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But we need to keep the formation!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Oh, no, some others are also running.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The formation just broke up, the odds are very bad for me.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Yep, better run for my life.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Even if the elephant wouldn't do that much damage, it crushes the enemy formation, and you can now deal much more damage.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Why on earth wouldn't you want such a weapon?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sure, the enemy also have a huge weapon, but that won't ensure that the foot soldiers will keep the formation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And it's because she doesn't have dragons that she wants a similar, smaller armed animal that can afraid the enemy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So that we don't expect elephants Golden company is well-known for their elephants.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Harry Strickland is proud of them, and as it's the final season, we expect massive battles.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This scene is also a way for showrunners to tell the spectators to don't expect any elephant.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Sorry, all CGI budget was burned on dragons.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/55803/Kepotx", "score": 18 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Cyvasse G.R.R Martin is a massive chess fan, even working as a chess event organiser .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "As a result, there are clear chess influences in A Song of Ice and Fire, the main one being Cyvasse .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It is suspected by many book readers that the outcomes of \" on page \" games, particularly those played by Tyrion, are of a prophetic nature.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Two of the most notable pieces are Dragons and Elephants.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Clearly, there is a potential for symbolism here with Targaryens (Dragons) and The Golden Company (Elephants).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Cyvasse isn't shown in the Game of Thrones world, so no in-show cyvasse prophecies will be fulfilled.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "However, the story is based on the books so there is a very, very small chance that book readers could extrapolate on some of these prophecies on shoe horn them into the books.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The one that springs to mind is the Golden Company's missing Elephants .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Essentially, this would boil down to an Easter Egg for book readers but with a little more significance than, for example, Arya's Rat Cook pie.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/44327/josh", "score": 5 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I don't think it was an easter-egg or a joke.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Cersei demanded Elephants from Euron Greyjoy, because she wanted to give him an impossible task.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She would win either way, if Euron delivered or not.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Euron Greyjoy is obviously obsessed with fame, power and, for some weird reason, also with impregnating Cersei.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Knowing that, Cersei is full-on using his blind quest for power in her advantage to get as much military reinforcement as possible.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I bet even an office sitter like Cersei knows that transporting elephants with ships is a pretty heavy task.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But since she is not to keen on giving Euron the feeling, he did everything she ever wanted, she demanded elephants anway.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Best case: \"Yay, elephants for my army.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Worst case: \"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Oh you did not fulfill my request", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": ".. guess you don't get to sit by my side then.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'll take the rest of your army anyway, btw.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This does not fully explain why Cersei let Euron sleep with her in the end, anyway.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But I think she had a change of heart (figuratively, she obviously does not have a heart)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "when Euron returned with his army, because she knew she was already pregnant and could probably use him some more.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(Does it show how little I think of Cersei?)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/47284/Ian", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The scene you're talking about showed Cersei get visibly upset at the fact the Golden Company was only 20,000 strong.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Her mention of elephants was more like \"did you at least bring tanks to the war?\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Since it's only mentioned once, and the captain quickly lets her know they don't have them, then these would seem more of something said out of spite than a real concern.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/40535/King of NES", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "In Game of Thrones S08E01, Cersei was so disappointed for not getting elephants and it's being part of so many memes and jokes now. But why do elephants matter? Her competition/rivalry is with Daenerys/Starks etc. And they have dragons. So what purpose would elephants fulfill? What is the significance of this obsession?", "title": "Significance of Cersei's obsession with elephants?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<character><game-of-thrones>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/98426", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1190/Ankit Sharma" }

[ [ "Cersei's obsession with elephants could be related to Cyvasse as G.R.R Martin is a massive chess fan. As a result, there are clear chess influences in A Song of Ice and Fire, the main one being Cyvasse . Two of the most notable pieces are Dragons and Elephants. However, Cyvasse isn't shown in the Game of Thrones world, so no in-show cyvasse prophecies will be fulfilled. However, the story is based on the books so there is a very, very small chance that book readers could extrapolate on some of these prophecies on shoe horn them into the books.", "G.R.R Martin is a massive chess fan, even working as a chess event organiser. As a result, there are clear chess influences in A Song of Ice and Fire." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "G.R.R Martin is a massive chess fan, even working as a chess event organiser. As a result, there are clear chess influences in A Song of Ice and Fire. Cyvasse isn't shown in the Game of Thrones world, so no in-show cyvasse prophecies will be fulfilled. However, the story is based on the books so there is a very, very small chance that book readers could extrapolate on some of these prophecies on shoe horn them into the books. The one that springs to mind is the Golden Company's missing Elephants." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Because this is that one win scenario among 14 million futures Doctor Strange saw.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As director Joe Russo explains , Q:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In IW, Thanos used the time stone to reverse the time so he could the already dead Vision, and it didn’t cause any time parallax.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Why did no one use time stone to save Iron Man’s life in EG?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It’s because even if you save Iron Man, it will still not change the fact that Thanos will eventually win the war.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Among the 14 million possibilities that Doctor Strange has seen, Iron Man’s sacrifice is a must for that one win scenario.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/27264/A J", "score": 20 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "If Dr.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Strange tries to reverse time on Iron man, then he also reverses the snap and Thanos would be back again.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/37531/Amruth A", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "This is exactly correct.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Everyone using the Vision example as to supposedly suggest what Dr. Strange could do for Iron Man are disproving their own theory.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "-", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "> Thanos wants to turn back time for stone, but must bring back Vision to do so.->", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If strange uses time stone to turn back time for Iron man and undo snap, he must bring back Thanos in order to do so.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/74830/Jolap2", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Because there's been more than enough meddling and destruction for one day By the point that Iron Man defeats Thanos and his minions with his own 'snap', there has already been massive loss of life, risk to the Earth, and interferences in time.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "There is an argument here that Doctor Strange could re-appropriate the Time Stone and attempt to use it to reverse the physical damage Stark suffered from using the Infinity Stones.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "However, if there was any risk that such an action could reverse Iron Man's decisive 'snap', then that risk is simply unacceptable .", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Even if Strange was minded to attempt such an action, he would almost certainly have been blocked or dissuaded by the other heroes who would be fearful of re-entering the nightmare scenario of Thanos's invasion again.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The only action that is carried out with the Infinity Stones after Iron Man's 'snap' is their careful restoration to their various points in time by Captain America, in keeping with the original 'time heist' plan.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/19074/EleventhDoctor", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In the case of Hulk's damages, Joe Russo told : He's lost an arm (...)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That's permanent damage, the same way it was permanent damage with Thanos: It's irreversible damage.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "From that we can conclude that even if Thanos didn't heal himself after the first snap in IW, that suggest that Time Stone can't manage to heal wound caused by Stones themself.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Time Stone alone can't undo what multiple stones did.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/74333/TinyDoowy", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Doctor Strange had watched 14,000,605 possibilities and their was only one scenario in which they won.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Let's assume for a moment that Dr.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Strange did restored tony's wounds, and Tony Stark lives ... what would happen then?", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Tony is the 'Futurist' in the MCU and he can't help but keep thinking on how to make the world a better place but we did saw where his intelligence led", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(Ultron was his fault and all the death caused by Ultron is ultimately on him.....", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Then he forced the avengers to keep together while he could have done that by explaining the future risks he feared and trusting his freinds...and as Cap said that tony tries to win the war before it starts and people end up dying and it's all their fault.....).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I'm not a hater of Tony Stark, he is definitely a great character and its his flaws and mistakes that make him able to learn.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But Dr.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Strange might have saw a danger in Tony being alive.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Moreover, messing with time can break the space time continnum as explained in MCU.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe there is more to the character of Tony Stark than just being alive.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maybe he can become a symbol or return as a fully independent working A.I", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Tony Stark n fill in the gap created by Tony himself.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hope he returns as A.I though.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Future movies might address this issue.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/75324/Faran Butt", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "At the end of the final battle in Avengers: Endgame , Tony is damaged from the snap. All the stones are right there, and there are no bad guys left to distract Dr. Strange. Why doesn't Dr. Strange use the time stone to reverse Tony's wounds?", "title": "Why doesn't Dr. Strange use the time stone to do this?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><marvel-cinematic-universe><avengers-endgame>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/99671", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/48621/user1717828" }

[ [ "There is an argument here that Doctor Strange could re-appropriate the Time Stone and attempt to use it to reverse the physical damage Stark suffered from using the Infinity Stones. However, if there was any risk that such an action could reverse Iron Man's decisive 'snap', then that risk is simply unacceptable . Even if Strange was minded to attempt such an action, he would almost certainly have been blocked or dissuaded by the other heroes who would be fearful of re-entering the nightmare scenario of Thanos's invasion again. The only action that is carried out with the Infinity Stones after Iron Man's 'snap' is their careful restoration to their various points in time by Captain America, in keeping with the original 'time heist' plan.", "Because there's been more than enough meddling and destruction for one day. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ " Because there's been more than enough meddling and destruction for one day. By the point that Iron Man defeats Thanos and his minions with his own 'snap', there has already been massive loss of life, risk to the Earth, and interferences in time. Doctor Strange could re-appropriate the Time Stone and attempt to use it to reverse the physical damage Stark suffered from using the Infinity Stones. But if there was any risk that such an action could reverse Iron Man's decisive 'snap' then that risk is simply unacceptable." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Daenerys has decided to rain fire on the keep already, which prompts Grey Worm and the Unsullied to attack.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jon does not command the Unsullied, so it is reasonable that they would not respond to his commands to hold back.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Once the Unsullied begin attacking, the Lannister army begins attacking back to defend themselves, and chaos ensues.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jon alone is telling everyone to stop while the queen of the land and her army are attacking anyway, so Jon's men get caught up in the chaos and fighting.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Even Jon himself is forced to kill Lannister soldiers in order to defend himself in the craziness.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's not unheard of in war for this sort of chaos to cause men to do all kinds of unthinkable things, and this is what we see happening with the soldiers of the North.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We see Jon try to stop one of them, but the man refuses to be stopped and Jon is forced to kill him in order to save the civilian woman.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the bloodbath and chaos, orders are no longer relevant.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/22993/sanpaco", "score": 65 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "That's how invading cities looks like", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "All we know from historical experience shows that this is pretty much the default expected result if a city gets invaded as opposed to a clean surrender - the soldiers \"take their share\" in violence, loot and sex", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "; officer's orders get ignored, and officers who try to enforce order in such a scenario (as Jon did) are at risk of getting attacked by their own men (as Jon did) and murdered by them; there are historical examples of respected officers dying that way.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That's how real war looks like", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": ", that's the nature of men at war, as shown time and time again in practice.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It takes unusual, exceptional circumstances and/or extraordinary discipline to prevent that.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There are historical examples of \"clean takeovers\", but they're exceptions from the usual course of events.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Unsullied had a reputation of having that unusual discipline and probably could resist that temptation if their leadership hadn't shown them that they (Dany and Gray Worm) desire to raze the city, however 'armies of the North' (much less the Dothraki)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "definitely would not.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They're not even \"Jon's men\" from Winterfell, they're multiple disjoint bands of bannermen from different places, there's definitely many people just like those who fought for Boltons.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The presence of large numbers of disciplined Unsullied could have prevented these events if they chose to enforce that, but Gray Worm chose the opposite.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It would be sloppy unrealistic writing if the invasion of King's Landing didn't degenerate in such bloody looting without a strong reason.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8111/Peteris", "score": 32 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "This is mentioned in the Inside the Episode here:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The utter chaos has led to a moral free-for-all.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is meant to portray Jon as a morally superior character in juxtaposition to the terrible deeds done by ordinary soldiers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/66736/AGirlHasNoName", "score": 13 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Probably because the North had suffered a lot because of the Lannisters, and it was time for payback.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The surrender of the Lannister army was somewhat unconvincing after the tense standoff, so when all hell broke loose again, the rout was on.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/22875/Mohair", "score": 12 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "The real question is, \" Why did Greyworm specifically disobey Daenerys' orders? \"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the battle meeting with Tyrion, Greyworm and Dany, Dany clearly indicates that the Unsullied would retreat upon the ringing of the bells.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Here is the scene, at 16:34 of S8E5, Tyrion to Daenerys: Please, if you hear them ringing the bells, call of the attack.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Daenerys:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "*", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "*looks to Greyworm and Tyrion and nods curtly, but sincerely** Greyworm: **micro-nod of acknowledgement** This order from Dany is clearly disobeyed by Greyworm when he throws the spear and kills the Lannister Ranking Officer when the Lannister forces have surrendered and the bells are ringing.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This initiates the pillage (not the burning) of King's Landing.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is completely contradictory to what we known about the Unsullied, being \"famed for their skills and discipline in battle\" and \"They never loot or rape\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "1 .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It is worth noting, perhaps Dany meant to burn the city all along, and the retreat of her own forces was necessary to burn the city effectively, without loss or casualty to her own forces.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, Why did the soldiers of the North disobey Jon? Once the Unsullied, the most disciplined of Dany's force, and Greyworm, the highest ranking general, start attacking it sends a message to all her forces to do so.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It would be very difficult for Jon, amidst the furore and din of the battle, to effectively control the Northmen.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There is of course the remote possibility that there was an off screen conversation between Greyworm and Dany to attack Lannister forces after surrender.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, there was the opportunity to show this when Dany and Greyworm had a private meeting about Missandei.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Therefore, a secret plan between the two becomes even more a \"logical leap\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This leads me to believe that this is not what the show intended to portray, but rather Greyworm initiated a killing spree out of revenge for Missandei.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/44327/josh", "score": 7 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Insanity in the sky, in form of the dragon pouring fire on civilians and army alike, is mirrored by the insanity on the ground.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After Dany attacks the city, and Lannister's army pick up their swords (after Grey Worm throws his spire), there is a close-combat in city streets.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "At that point, everybody got concerned with their own survival, as well as chaos of the war kicked in.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jon was forced to defend his life by killing enemy, but he has more leveled head than others, and was able to protect civilian from his own soldier (presumably soldier was going to rape civilian).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "PS: answering following comment by @sanpaco, borrowing something from them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/66650/aaaaa says reinstate Monica", "score": 3 } } ]

{ "question": "In Game of Thrones S08E05, we see that soldiers in the Northern army attacking the unarmed Lannister soldiers after they have surrendered. Jon is the warden of the North and he commands the Northern army to not attack. He tells them, No. Get back. Get back But no-one seems to obey it. Why did they not follow Jon's command?", "title": "Why did the soldiers of the North disobey Jon?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><game-of-thrones>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/100652", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/33025/Kolappan N" }

[ [ "The Army of the North probably disoveyed Jon Snow's command in GOT season 8 because the North had suffered a lot because of the Lannisters, and it was time for payback. The surrender of the Lannister army was somewhat unconvincing after the tense standoff, so when all hell broke loose again, the rout was on.", "The North suffered a lot because of the Lannisters, and it was time for payback." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "The North suffered a lot because of the Lannisters, and it was time for payback. The surrender of Lannister army was somewhat unconvincing." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "It symbolized the end of monarchy.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Here's a nice little summary.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The red-tinted dragon then unleashes a powerful stream of flame aimed right at the very thing that has been such a point of contention since season one.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He succeeds in melting all the swords down to a bubbling, molten puddle.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Just as Tyrion says later on in the episode when discussing why Bran would make a good king — \"Sons of kings can be cruel and stupid as you well know . . .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "that is the wheel our Queen wanted to break\" — Drogon succeeds in symbolically erasing the idea of a monarchy, whether purposefully or not.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Meaning Behind Drogon's Fiery Symbolic Gesture in the Game of Thrones Finale - PopSugar", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As to whether or not Monarchy is actually gone, in the quote above it is to be interpreted that an elective monarchy is not a monarchy.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Here is Tyrion's quote.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(Tyrion)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "From now on, rulers will not be born.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They will be chosen on this spot by the lords and ladies of Westeros to serve the realm.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Game Of Thrones, Season 8, Episode 8", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(The Iron Throne)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Speculation: As far as official statements go, there has been no explanation as to Drogon's intentions in melting it.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It looked to me like he was trying to send Jon a message; if Dany couldn't have the throne, no one could.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/63980/Daeron", "score": 24 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Lazy writing and symbolism (Daeron explained the symbolism in his answer ).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A couple of in-universe explanations: He was going to incinerate Jon but at the last second decided against it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He already generated the fire and had to release it, the Iron Throne was simply in the direction of his fire breath by coincidence.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Dragons are very smart, he realized that his mother died because she was chasing the Throne and burned it in rage.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Edit", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After watching it again there were two separate fire breaths, Drogon first released the fire he was going to burn Jon with without harming the Irone Throne and then destroyed the throne on purpose with a separate fire breath.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This means the first option is wrong and leaves only the second.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/59364/Oleg", "score": 14 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Dareon's answer nails it in terms of symbolism.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "My guess on an in-universe answer is that Drogon has spent so much time linked to Dany, he knows the throne was the object that led her to her death.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(Pure speculation, mind you!)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/40263/DukeZhou", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I watched this most emotional scene of the last season and in my opinion the reason is: he did not harm Jon, instead he burnt the Iron Throne because he knew that this throne is the reason behind his mother's death.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If he didn't know, then he would have burnt Jon.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The writer wants to tell the love of child for his mother.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "No matter that Drogon is an animal; the love for the mother is same.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And the second case is: he knew his mother loved Jon, so he didn't harm him because Dany would not allowed him, if she was alive.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/76519/Ayman Amjad", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Initially Drogon had the full intention to incinerate Jon as he felt the pain his mother did in his heart.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The unexpected bitter reality made him cry and he wanted to turn the reason and the person behind it to ashes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Still he did not harm Jon, but he did burn the Iron Throne because he knew it was the throne Dany had been running after her whole life", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and Drogon knew how much the throne meant to her", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but when Drogon saw her dead, he burned the throne intentionally as he thought, if Dany could not sit in it, no one ever will.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The love of child for his mother is shown.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "His love for his mother is very much like own.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After his brothers' death, she was the only one left to him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And he guarded her for good.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He allowed Jon to go to her alone just because he knew she loved him, and he loved her and wouldn't harm her.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But as we know, Jon was the one to take her life.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The reason why Drogon didn't harm Jon is that he knew his mother loved Jon, and wouldn't see him harmed.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The other reason was that Jon had Targayren blood and dragons have been ridden by Targayrens for centuries.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "So he did not dare kill one of his own.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/76522/icyNerd", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "According to the script , Drogon did intentionally spare Jon, but the Iron Throne was just collateral damage as part of his rampage.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ -1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He looks down at Jon.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We see the fire build up in his throat.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jon sees it as well.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He prepares to die.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But the blast is not for him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Drogon wants to burn the world but he will not kill Jon.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He breathes fire on the back wall, blasting down what remains of the great red blocks of stone.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We look over Jon’s shoulder as the fire sweeps toward the throne– not the target of Drogon’s wrath, just a dumb bystander caught up in the conflagration.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We look through the blades of the throne as the flames engulf it, and blast the wall behind it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "However, just as Daeron's answer states, that doesn't mean that despite Drogon is NOT consciously aware of its symbolism, that it wasn't symbolically written this way for the story's benefit.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/56522/Darth Locke", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "In S08E06 of Game of Thrones , we see Drogon burn down the Iron Throne. Why did he do that? Did he grow a conscience and see that it was a source of evil?", "title": "Why did Drogon do this?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><game-of-thrones>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/100891", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/58191/JJJ" }

[ [ "The reason why Drogon didn't harm Jon is that he knew his mother loved Jon, and wouldn't see him harmed. According to the script, Drogon did intentionally spare Jon, but the Iron Throne was just collateral damage as part of his rampage.", "Drogon spared Jon intentionally, but the Iron Throne was an incidental casualty of his rampage. Writer wishes to discuss the love of a child for his/her mother. " ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ true ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [ "he knew his mother loved Jon, so he didn't harm him because Dany would not allowed him, if she was alive. The reason why Drogon didn't harm Jon is that he knew his mother loved Jon, and wouldn't see him harmed. The other reason was that Jon had Targayren blood and dragons have been ridden by Targayrens for centuries.", "According to the script, Drogon did intentionally spare Jon, but the Iron Throne was just collateral damage as part of his rampage.", "he did not harm Jon, instead he burnt the Iron Throne because he knew that this throne was the reason behind his mother's death.", "he knew his mother loved Jon, so he didn't harm him because Dany would not allowed him, if she was alive.", "The writer wants to talk about the love of a child for his mother." ] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "According to the script, Drogon spared Jon intentionally, but the Iron Throne was an incidental casualty of his rampage. Writer wishes to discuss the love of a child for his/her mother. In the second case, his mother loved him, so he couldn't have been harmed if she were still alive. Targaryens have ridden dragons for millennia, and blood has been in his family for generations, writer says. The writer says Drogan would have left Jon unharmed because he knows that his mother loves him, and doesn't want him harmed." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Jon Snow is a man of honor.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's part of his core personality.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "His own personal care is less important for him than being honorable and doing the right thing for the people.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Running away after killing someone (no matter who or what the reasons are) is a very cowardly act, so it's against his very nature.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Also keep in mind he didn't try to run away from the dragon, but instead faced it and was fully prepared to be burned alive as a consequence of his actions.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Another point is the \"right thing for the people\" part.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Suppose he would have fled and the people found out about what happened when he's away.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Unsullied would surely act against the people, and likely many people would die until peace is somehow restored.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/106/Shadow Wizard is Ear For You", "score": 66 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Because he is a man of honesty and it has been shown in his own words before (from season 7 finale):", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"I'm not going to swear an oath I can't uphold.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When enough people make false promises, words stop meaning anything.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Then there are no more answers, only better and better lies.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And if you go by his arc he can lie and cheat easily to get away many times before but", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "he will not he is an honest man.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/1190/Ankit Sharma", "score": 10 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In addition to the other answers, we should remember that Jon was not just in a relationship with Daenerys but was in love with her.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He killed her despite his love for her, because of its importance to everyone's lives; but it was still absolutely heartbreaking for him not only to lose her but to be the cause of that loss.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "I would imagine someone in that situation to feel absolutely desolate, to the point of not caring what happens to him next—perhaps even with the feeling that he deserves to and/or wants to die.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/74338/Greg Martin", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In addition to this being precisely in-character for Jon, there is precedent for Daenerys leaving with Drogon.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "She did exactly that after the Sons of the Harpy attacked her in the fight pits of Meereen.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And what happened after is that everyone continued what they were doing until Dany returned.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Her regime was upheld, awaiting her return.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The same would have happened in this case.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So even if Jon had gotten away with it without being imprisoned; he would not have actually stopped the atrocities that were going on.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/22424/Flater", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In addition to the other answers which I think are the primary reason (honour), consider that lying probably would have raised more questions anyway.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "It would be very odd of her to simply fly away without saying anything, and in time the suspicion would only grow.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/65627/user", "score": 4 } } ]

{ "question": "Why did Jon admit that he killed Daenerys in Game of Thrones S08E06? Why didn't he just tell that she flew away with her dragon? He could say that, escape from the Unsullied and then tell the truth. I understand that there was blood and a melted throne, but he could come up with something.", "title": "Why did Jon Snow admit his fault in S08E06?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><game-of-thrones>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/101035", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/74308/Mitch" }

[ [ "Jon Snow admitted to killing Daenerys at the end og GOT because of his honor. He was less bothered about his own safety than doing the right thing for the people. He killed her despite being in love with her. Moreover, it is unlikely that people would have believed she had just flown away.", "The act of escaping after committing a murder is cowardly, so it goes against his character." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 7 ]

[ [ "His own personal care is less important for him than being honorable and doing the right thing for the people. Running away after killing someone is a very cowardly act, so it's against his very nature. This is completely in character for Daenerys as well. Even if he had escaped being punished, he could not have stopped the violence. Lying was one of the other answers in addition to those that I thought was going to be raised. It would be extremely odd if she escaped and no one noticed." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Jon did not commit to murdering Daenerys when he came to the Throne room.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The first thing he did was lash out at her about killing innocent civilians and prisoners of war.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He had been a passive partner to Daenerys these last few episodes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He lashed out in anger because he wanted Daenerys to see reason.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "To snap her out of the cloud of smoke to see the rubble she had laid on ground.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The next thing he does is plead to her to see reason.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "To give mercy to Tyrion and the rest.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Daenerys at this moment is now convinced that she knows what's right for the people.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The last thing he does is asks her plainly as to \"what about the people who think they know what's best for them\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She replies that they don't have a choice.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After making every effort to redeem Daenerys in his eyes, he fails and decides to kill her.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He loves her still and proclaims her the queen, now and always.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Kisses her back, embrace her in his arms and stabs her in the heart.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/5315/KharoBangdo", "score": 90 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Because there is a conflict between multiple of his honors here.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He vowed loyalty to Daenerys, and even after all that happened seems to still love her to some extent.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He is shown very often and very clearly not to break oaths, even risking the whole expedition North over this particular one.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He vowed to protect all people, the common folk.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Literally as part of his Night's Watch oath (\"I am the shield that guards the realms of men\"), but more significantly it's how he is raised and what he believes with all his heart, even to the point of getting killed over helping/protecting the free folk against the Night's Watch sentiment.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Tyrion reminds him very heavily of the second vow.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Basically Jon is now tormented, if he keeps his first oath he will most likely be breaking his second oath because Daenerys at that point seems like a cruel conqueror who will not stop bringing fire and death.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If he keeps his second Oath he must somehow stop Daenerys from doing that but there is not obvious way without breaking the first Oath.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In the end he chooses his second, more deep-rooted vow.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After that choice it doesn't matter of how the murder is performed, the act in itself is dishonorable for him, and you see he is tormented by it and very well prepared to die as a consequence.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/13407/KillianDS", "score": 58 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Ultimately Jon had to betray someone - Dany or the people he was sworn to protect.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Dany was bent on making the world better through force, convinced of her own righteousness.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So for example, if Sansa had refused her it seems likely that she would have torched her, if not the whole of Winterfell.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The rest of the world gets the same treatment.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So Jon killed her.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He gave her every opportunity to change her mind.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The way he ended up doing it was simply to avoid a violent fight.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/65627/user", "score": 11 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I don't think it's about honor, the way I saw it, Jon didn't want Dany to suffer, i.e. it was a \"Mercy Kill\".", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Clearly, Daenerys wasn't herself any longer, and was consumed by grief and hatred.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When Jon realized he can't get her back, and the \"old Dany\" is suffering, he decided to end her pain.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He also knows that if he would let her know he's going to kill her, she can convince him to stop, and he won't be able to resist, still being in love with her.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "All the above together should explain why Jon acted the way he did.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/106/Shadow Wizard is Ear For You", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Love is the death of duty.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Jon and Tyrion discussed this quote from Maester Aemon.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "For Jon, it meant that he had forsaken his duty (acting in the best interest of the Realm) because of his love for Dany.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Tyrion then adds that duty can be the death of love .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In order words, if Jon wants to do his duty, he must put his feeling of love aside.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Quite literally, Jon's rightful duty would be to kill the woman he loves, since she is an active threat that cannot be stopped.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Killing Dany was in the best interest of the Realm, and Jon has unwaiveringly acted in the best interest of the people he represents: the Starks, the Night's Watch (and thus also the realm of men), the North.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "When Jon killed Dany, he put aside his personal feelings and acted in the best interest of the people he swore to defend.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Because Dany would have remained an active threat.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "While Jon may not have understood Dany's statement, don't forget that in her victory speech, she specifically mention \"liberating\" Winterfell.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "That puts Jon in a strong conflict.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The woman he loves threatens everything else he stands for, and he had to make a choice.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He chose duty over love.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Because he couldn't prevent Dany from waging eternal bloody war.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/22424/Flater", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I understand that maybe he couldn't kill her another way...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I wouldn't discount this as part of the reason.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Once he'd decided he had to do it, which wasn't until well into the scene, he had to know that she was a hard person to kill.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "She had Drogon, and she was canny.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If he'd given her advance notice of his intention, he might well have become a smoking outline on the ground, leaving the seven kingdoms doomed to suffer under The Mad Queen and her dragon.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A swift, unexpected stroke was his best — possibly only — chance of success.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/22662/T.J. Crowder", "score": 2 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "He didn't stab her in the back.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He did it discreetly, not in order to hide that he did it but too remove the weirdness if he just took a dagger and came running to her to get a kill - that would have been funny lol and last minutes of Danys would have been where he saw Jon came like a lunatic and kill her.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But this is very opinion based.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Even if it was 1 bit not honorable then he have been through enough to say \"Fuck honor\" and do something for the greater good.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/15590/Deepak Kamat", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "Jon Snow from Game of Thrones is a man of honor. When he killed the dragon queen in S08E06, he didn't even escape but told the truth. But then why did he kill her with a back stab? Not literally, but he kissed her and she didn't know that he has a weapon. I understand that maybe he couldn't kill her another way, but that's not a very honorable anyway.", "title": "Why did Jon Snow do this immoral act if he is so honorable?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<plot-explanation><game-of-thrones>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/101043", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/74308/Mitch" }

[ [ "Jon chose to kill the woman he loved rather than betray his people. Stabbing Dany in the back could have been to make it more quick and painless.", "Jon chose to do his duty to his people and so he was forced to kill her. He was putting her out of her misery." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [ "He chose duty over love." ] ] }

[ 8 ]

[ [ "Jon had to kill the dragon queen as it was his duty to protect the people she was hurting.", "Jon killed her so she wouldn't suffer later." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Yes, Disney moved away from hand-drawn animation In a 2013 interview with the Guardian,", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "chief executive Bob Iger said that none of its animation companies are working in the traditional 2D format, and there are no current plans to do so again.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Speaking at an annual shareholder's meeting in Phoenix, Arizona, on Wednesday, chief executive Bob Iger revealed that none of the studio's animation companies was working on 2D, hand-drawn material for the big screen.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "While Iger did not rule out returning in the future to the style which made the company famous, the long gestation period for Hollywood animated productions means a gap of several years before any new film might emerge.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"To my knowledge we're not developing a 2D or hand-drawn feature animated film right now,\" said Iger.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"There is a fair amount of activity going on in hand-drawn animation but it's largely for television at this point.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We're not necessarily ruling out the possibility [of] a feature but there isn't any in development at the company at the moment.\"", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 2 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/42976/Gustavo Gabriel", "score": 59 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "No, Disney does not produce nor is making any traditional hand drawn animation.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "There is probably a good reason for this in Disney's eyes.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Traditional hand animation is a lot of work.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's very time consuming and can't be changed easily late in production like CGI can and is expensive because of that.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "To give a demonstration, there is a nice video about", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Who Framed Roger Rabbit which goes quite into depth about \"Live\" animation, but just goes to show how much work can go into producing traditional animation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As I explained in this answer about mermaids (At the time of writing, The little Mermaid is the last traditionally hand painted cel animation disney film...) and this answer about Disney princess' marrying older men .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Disney is a lazy company and definitely looks at the cost of things.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "To quote a quote from Steve Huelett , a Disney animator: I've worked on CG features", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "and I've worked on hand-drawn features.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And hand-drawn features are harder to make.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hand-drawn cartoons take a year to produce.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Once you've produced sequences, it's hard to change the work.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You have to go back and do everything over.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But with CG, you can animate the movie in three or four months, change things close to the release date.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You can't do that in hand-drawn animation.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "If you find out the story doesn't work when you're two-thirds done, you're stuck.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "With CG, we change the story and rework sequences until late in the process.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's close to live-action in that way.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You can rework until late in the production.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "With hand-drawn animation, the plot, action and dialogue has to be locked down way earlier, or the picture won't get done in time for its release.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As you can see, traditional animation just can't cut it compared to CGI cost-wise.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Though it's not impossible that they won't try to go back to it.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "There is a small renaissance in going back to more traditional filming methods, as we saw with the new Star Wars films the return of practical effects .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Or a surprisingly good looking trailer for the Dark Crystal Prequel . Should traditional animation all of a sudden become a demand, compared to the money machine that CGI is, you can be sure that Disney will jump on the hand drawn bandwagon.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/70402/morbo", "score": 18 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Although other people have answered the question on full hand drawn films very well, a notable recent relevant fact is that Maui's tattoos in Moana were, in fact, hand drawn animation superimposed on the CG film.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "From the Hollywood Reporter article", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"How 'Moana's' Animators Brought a Tattoo to Life\" : \"Somewhere in the process, Mini Maui started to emerge, almost as a Jiminy Cricket alter ego; the tattoo can't speak, but he can communicate with Maui,\" explains John Musker, who directed with Ron Clements, of the telltale tat's development.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Maui's full of himself, and here is someone who could poke fun at him — literally poke him.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The two directors, responsible for such Disney classics as", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Little Mermaid and Aladdin , are making their first foray in a near-fully computer-animated feature with Moana , but for Mini Maui, they decided to return to their roots and create a hand-drawn character .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So they recruited the legendary Eric Goldberg, best known as the lead animator of the Genie in Aladdin , to serve as Mini Maui's animation supervisor.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/67308/Whelkaholism", "score": 12 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Yes, Disney no longer does hand-drawn cartoons.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Their most recent hand drawn/2d movies were very poorly received.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "They really did try to keep that age alive, but it just wasn't making enough money to account for how expensive they were to make.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Here's part of an interview with Bob Iger (a chief executive of Disney).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"To my knowledge we're not developing a 2D or hand-drawn feature animated film right now,\" said Iger.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"There is a fair amount of activity going on in hand-drawn animation but it's largely for television at this point.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We're not necessarily ruling out the possibility [of] a feature but there isn't any in development at the company at the moment.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The profits are discussed in the above linked interview.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The studio subsequently put the hand-drawn animation The Princess andthe Frog into production.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The traditional musical, based on theBrothers Grimm story the Frog Prince but relocating the action to1920s New Orleans, was well-reviewed but failed to mirror theastounding success of Pixar at the box office with a middling returnof $267m (£178m).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Another hand-drawn animation – 2011's Winnie thePooh – drew praise from critics but pulled in just $33m across theglobe.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Meanwhile, Disney CGI efforts such as 2009's Bolt and 2010'sTangled grossed $310m and $590m respectively.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So, their CGi movies are clearly making a lot more than their 2D animations, this is probably why they were abandoned.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/63980/Daeron", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Actually, per the NY Post article \"Forget CGI: ‘", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Mary Poppins Returns’ uses hand-drawn cartoons\" and other sources, the Mary Poppins Returns movie from late 2018 did all of the animation hand-drawn.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I believe the purpose of this was to make the new movie have as close to an identical look/feel to the original one as possible.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/74207/Milwrdfan", "score": 3 } } ]

{ "question": "Over the past few years Disney has remade a lot of their hand-drawn films with either live-action or [modern] computer animation. Examples that immediately come to mind include: The Jungle Book , Beauty and the Beast , The Lion King , Christopher Robin , Dumbo , and Aladdin . That being said, does Disney no longer produce hand-drawn cartoon films? Have they completely strayed away from this and now only offer computer animated and live-action films?", "title": "Does Disney no longer produce hand-drawn cartoon films?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<film-industry><disney>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/101399", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/31426/Charles" }

[ [ "Hand drawn animation was not profitable enough for Disney, so they have stopped producing it for the forseeable future.", "Disney no longer produces hand-drawn cartoons as they are expensive to make. They have not ruled out a return to this practice in the future." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 8 ]

[ [ "Disney no longer produces hand-drawn cartoons.", "Hand-drawn cartoons weren't making enough money.", "There are no hand-drawn cartoons in development at the moment, but they have not ruled out a return in the future." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Clark has been on Earth his entire life and has become very familiar with his super-powers and with the atmosphere.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The Kryptonians have not and although they might seem to have", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "become used to their environment incredibly quickly, they haven't.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "At several points Zod is shown attempting to get used to his powers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As an example, he has problems controlling his ability to see through things.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "We can imagine this extends to the rest of the Superman abilities.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This lack of experience gives Superman the edge.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Plus the Kryptonians are some what handicapped because Clark is/contains the DNA of their species.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "So they can't just do whatever they please", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": ", they have to be conscious of preserving him.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/50182/Phlegon_of_Tralles", "score": 21 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "They actually said in the film how the atmosphere of Earth is more nourishing, and the sun provides him with more energy.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "This happened over his entire life, and only a short while for the other Kryptonians, therefore Superman has essentially had a great diet his whole life, whereas the Kryptonians have been eating junk food: he is physically in far better shape.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/76075/Benjamin Clarkson", "score": 6 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I think the answer talking about Clark being more used to his powers is right, and Zod etc do have trouble with them.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "BUT the codex bit is totally wrong, as the scientist on Zod's ship says he doesn't need to be alive to harvest the codex from his body.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The way Superman can defeat them is having more experience with his powers, coupled with having been on Earth longer, so his cells have bathed in the radiation of the sun longer; he has become stronger through that.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/76058/Rich Kay", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "He is able to do this because in this version of Superman he was born not cloned (that part has nothing to with his power set) and the codex was infused into his body.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "The codex is every Kryptonian that has ever lived or will ever live.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He is literally ALL that ever was or ever will be of Krypton.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He has access to all of the information stored in each cell by the codex and that's why he is so powerful.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And yes, he has been on earth for far longer and is far more powerful than any of them", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "would ever be!", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He was in the literal sense made better than any other person from his home world.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/76064/Kevin McKinley", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Acquiring the power of Superman would make all other training irrelevant.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Consider Judo, which uses gravity to facilitate falls.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "You can't trip someone who can fly, no matter how many belts you have.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The best boxer in the world would be just as mowed down by a machine gun as a couch potato would be.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, Brandon Routh's Superman took a bullet in the eye and didn't blink, so even vulnerable spots on a non-super become insignificant at Superman levels of powers.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "At that level of power, the power level is the only significant thing, barring (in this case) access to Kryptonite.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "As others have mentioned, Superman has higher power levels than does Zod due to his longer exposure to the Sun and the Earth's atmosphere.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Superman, therefore, wins through power-imbalance attrition, as is shown in the movie.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/80766/JohnHunt", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "During Man of Steel, Superman battles and defeats several military trained Kryptonians (eg. Zod, Faora etc) who have much more training and combat skill at their disposal. Faora mentions that he is weak and unsure of himself and Zod mentions that he has trained his entire life. So how is Superman able to defeat them, is this explained/hinted at in the movie at any point?", "title": "How is Superman able to defeat Kryptonians who are better trained and skilled than him?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<character><dc-extended-universe><man-of-steel>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/102771", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/75997/FrontEnd" }

[ [ "Superman has spent his whole life on earth, which gives him more energy and makes him stronger. He has more experience using his powers and he is genetically more powerful than other Kryptonians.", "Superman has been on Earth for this whole life. This means he has benefited from Earth's atmosphere and has more practice at using his powers. His DNA codex contains the best of his species." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 8 ]

[ [ "Clark has more experience with his powers on Earth and has been nourished by its atmosphere. The others have only just arrived.", "Superman was born not cloned and his DNA is made up of all Kryptonians. " ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "The joke is that the Principal is saying his name has \"no relation\" to the body part.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "He is constantly attempting to clarify that his last name is \"not a joke\" and that it's a real, \"possibly Scandanavian\" last name.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/76761/WulffHunter", "score": 55 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "When people who have the same (or similar) name as someone famous introduce themselves, they will often get questions as to whether they're related.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Think if an American was named Richard Clinton, or Travis Trump.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After a while they will anticipate these questions, and as part of their self-introduction just state flat-out that they aren't related to that famous person it sounds like they are related to.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Just to avoid having to be asked: \"Hi, my name is Richard Clinton.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And before you ask, no, I'm not related to Bill.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\" This can be shortened to \"No relation.\"", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This is what the principal is doing.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Only instead of a famous person, it's a body part.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/32506/Arthur", "score": 37 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "I always understood it as a reference to \"not being a pussy\".", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "Thus he is saying his name is not a reference to his character.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/76766/steros", "score": 9 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It could also be a nod to Die Hard's Agent Johnson and Special Agent Johnson .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "AJ: I'm Agent Johnson AJ:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And this is Special Agent Johnson AJ: ...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "No relation", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The joke there is they have the same surname", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "but they're clearly of different ethnicity.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But in relation to Rick and Morty, Johnson is American slang for penis.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/32060/Oli", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "To me, having grown up with a TV in the 90's (for good reason: moved to USA for learning the language and culture), this phrase was an instant reference to Tiny Toon Adventures cartoon series, where two major characters - Buster and Babs Bunny (sometimes with Bugs Bunny in the loop) - always introduced themselves with a \"No relation!\"", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 2 ] ] }, { "text": "disclaimer.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/67822/Jim Klimov", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "In the Rick and Morty series, we see multiple interactions with Morty's school Principal. His name is Principal Vagina. After he introduces himself, he says, \"no relation\" afterwards. Why? What joke am I missing? I thought he might be referring to the school name but if so, I'm not getting it. What's the joke here, or what does he mean when he says it?", "title": "Why does Principal Vagina say, \"no relation\" after introducing himself?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<dialogue><rick-and-morty>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/104507", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/4331/DustinDavis" }

[ [ "He could be saying that his name is not related to the body part, nor is he a 'pussy'. It could also be a reference to Buster and Babs Bunny in the classic cartoon series Tiny Toon Adventures.", "It could be a reference to a body part, a character trait or a cartoon character in loony toons." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 8 ]

[ [ "The Principal is saying that he is no relation to the body part, a joke that one would normally make in relation to a famous person.", "It is a reference to a character trait.", "It is a reference to a loony toons cartoon character who made a similer joke." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "That all depends on how big the artillery shell was.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "A standard 75mm/18lb shell would have difficulty making a hole anywhere near that big, but the largest shell fired in WWI was 3,130 lbs !", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "used by the 520mm French Schneider Howitzer...", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Somewhat more portable were the 24cm or 25cm Schwerer Flügelminenwerfer* which carried a 200 lb charge…", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "*Roughly translates to 'heavy winged mine thrower' - the shells had fins at the rear.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Then there was Big Bertha - with a 17\" barrel - which could leave shell craters as wide as 9 m (29 ft 6 in) and as deep as 6 m (19 ft 8 in).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It's quite difficult to picture the size of this", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "- it was 15ft tall, 32ft long", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/25773/Tetsujin", "score": 71 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Possibly the result of an underground bomb , placed there by miners: One of the common techniques used in warfare during the First World War was mining.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 1 ] ] }, { "text": "There were various mines planted under trenches, then detonated to send part of the trench, and anyone in it, sky high.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The BBC also did an article on this.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "National Geographic says of the Messine explosion(s) :", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "This Explosion Was the Biggest Blast Before Atomic Bombs", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "[...]", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The mines were each fired by soldiers and so went off a few seconds apart up and down the length of the ridge, sending geysers of earth, steel, concrete, and bodies spewing into the air and searing the dark sky with orange flame.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The mines, totaling nearly 1 million pounds of explosives, are believed to have created one of the largest human-caused explosions before the nuclear era.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "On the British side of the front, men were knocked off their feet by the blast.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Farther away, in France, the shockwave was mistaken for an earthquake.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "And the roar of the detonation was reportedly so tremendous that it was even heard by the British Prime Minister in London.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The craters resulting from the Battle of Messines are fairly well-known:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/13595/BCdotWEB", "score": 58 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Given all you see is the crater, there's no guarantee it was made by a single shell, though the odds are statistically high it was a shell given how many were fired.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The biggest crater created still exists today in 2020, 104 years after it was created.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The crater is 30 metres deep and 100 metres across (98 feet and 330 feet) and was caused by a 2,700 kilogram (6000 lb) high explosive charge triggered on 1916-07-01 at 07:28.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Lochnagar mine crater on the 1916 Somme battlefields in France is the largest man-made mine crater created in the First World War on the Western Front.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was laid by the British Army's 179th Tunnelling Company Royal Engineers underneath a German strongpoint called “Schwaben Höhe”.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Further info http://www.greatwar.co.uk/somme/memorial-lochnagar-crater.htm and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lochnagar_mine", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Another thought", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "- there's no reason it couldn't be a series of shells, each landing in the previous crater.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Estimates range from 1.7 billion to 8 billion rounds fired by both sides, and that France has a land area of 643,801 km², of which very roughly 25% was directly in a warzone at some point.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Meaning 10,000 to 40,000 rounds landed on each square kilometre on average, with many more in heavily contested areas.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "(This last part is super-fudgy with estimates, don't take it accurately at all.)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/37379/Criggie", "score": 21 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In addition to the incredibly heavy shells that could be lofted by the artillery of either side, delayed fuzes were used which trigger a few seconds after impact, causing the shell to explode under the surface, pushing the ground advice up and out, and creating craters as deep and wide as you see in the picture you posted.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 2 ] ] }, { "text": "Since proximity fuzes, which would allow reliable airbursts and are very effective in throwing shrapnel out, were not in use until the Second World War, the sub-surface explosion was the most devastating and effective anti-infantry tactic, compared with a surface explosion.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It had the added advantage of turning no-man's land into a crater riddled quagmire, making it that much harder for an attacking force to progress.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/7969/HorusKol", "score": 19 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "It is a bit too big for an artillery shell.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "Others have shown the artillery pieces, and the mine craters.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "But few people today have any idea of how much the heavy artillery of the day churned up the landscape in general.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The earth was pounded over and over for months , which means that eventually it was just a thick layer of mud (which got displaced even easier with each successive barrage).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Borrowing from the \"heaviest shell\" link in Tetsujin's answer, emphasis mine:", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In March 1918 for every mile of their 50-mile trench network, the German Army had 92 field guns.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In addition to [those] 92 field guns [...], they had 31 field howitzers, 14 medium howitzers, 14 heavy guns, 7 heavy howitzers and 3.5 super heavy howitzers for each mile of trench .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Respecting the photographer's copyright, I just link to some pages showing the fields of carnage, almost a hundred years later -- with some of the craters still in evidence rivaling that from your question: Quiet on the Battle-scarred fields (blogspot.com) 100 years on, buried WWI shells pose threat in French fields (reuters.com) (which is -- part of -- the reason why these areas have not been taken under the plow again.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Also, chemicals, and body parts of the many thousands that were blown into so small pieces that burial was simply not an option.) Verdun battlefield scars (YouTube)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/15487/DevSolar", "score": 4 } } ]

{ "question": "In the movie, 1917, there is huge crater filled with muddy water and bodies, what could have caused it? It is a bit too big for an artillery shell.", "title": "What could have resulted in such a huge crater in WW I?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<realism><1917>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/106341", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/41787/Yu Zhang" }

[ [ "The crater is too big for a standard 75mm/18lb shell, but some shells were far bigger than this. It could also have been made by several shells, an underground bomb or a shell with a delayed fuse that would explode under the surface.", "They had shells that wzere very heavy and could make very big craters. It could also have been from an underground bomb or a shell with a delayed fuse." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 8 ]

[ [ "It is too big for a standard shell but considering how many were fired, there is a good chance it was one. They were able to fire very heavy shells that could make a crater that size.", "It could have been from an undergroung bomb.", "It could have had a delayed fuse so it would sink into the ground then on explosion make a much bigger hole." ] ]

[ { "sents": [ { "text": "Yes I think the answer to this is probably many", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "After a short think, the first example I was able to find was: Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? , by", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Philip K. Dick was adapted as Blade Runner , directed by Ridley Scott, which in turn was adapted as Blade Runner: A Story of the Future by Les Martin Philip K. Dick approved of the movie despite the differences in the adaptation, but refused to write the novelization and is quoted as saying", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "[I was] told the cheapo novelization would have to appeal to the twelve-year-old audience.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/40/iandotkelly", "score": 49 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Yes Planet Of The Apes (1968) was based on French author Pierre Boulle's 1963 novel La Planète des Singes .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "After becoming a movie and additional sequels, it was further developed into cartoons, TV series and comic books.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Additionally, all of the original sequels spawned novelizations by established science fiction writers of the day, each of which went through multiple reprintings of their own.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Michael Avallone wrote the novelization for Beneath the Planet of the Apes in 1970.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Jerry Pournelle, who later co-authored Lucifer's Hammer and The Mote in God's Eye , wrote the Escape from the Planet of the Apes novelization.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "John Jakes, former Science Fiction Writers of America president, wrote Conquest of the Planet of the Apes .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "David Gerrold, scriptwriter for the Star Trek episode", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\"The Trouble with Tribbles\", novelized Battle for the Planet of the Apes .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Novelizations of the live action and animated television series were also produced.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "William T. Quick novelized the 2001 Planet of the Apes ; he also wrote two prequel novels, and several other book tie-ins were published.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Source: Planet Of The Apes Wiki", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/8071/Johnny Bones", "score": 31 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "If you consider a graphic novel to be a novel, then the graphic novel V for Vendetta (written by Alan Moore and illustrated by David Lloyd) was adapted as a film (directed by James McTeigue and written by the Wachowskis), which was in turn novelized by Steve Moore (no relation to Alan Moore).", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "The film had a number of differences from the graphic novel, and these differences are carried through to the novelization.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/46106/Lee C.", "score": 18 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "In 1992 Francis Ford Coppola did his version of Dracula, released under the title \"Bram Stoker's Dracula\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Apparently the original novel was not adequate so a novelization was published (by James V. Hart and Fred Saberhagen).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Another example, years ago someone showed me a copy of H. Rider Haggard's \"King Solomon's Mines\" with a picture of Stewart Granger and Deborah Kerr from the 1950 movie on the cover.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I know Haggard's writing; I read several of his books.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "He showed me the first page - it certainly was not Haggard.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The cover and spine say Haggard.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "On the title page at the bottom it gives the movie director credit, the producer credit, screenplay credit and \"Fictionized by Jean Francis Webb\".", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "I found the book on eBay so I could report this.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/82993/W H G", "score": 8 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "One relatively clear-cut example is The Wicker Man , which \"is a 1978 horror novel written by Robin Hardy and Anthony Shaffer.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "It was based on the 1973 cult horror film The Wicker Man, directed by Hardy and written by Shaffer.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "[..] The film itself is loosely based on the 1967 novel Ritual by the actor and novelist David Pinner.\" If you'll expand your question to accept \"Novels based on movies starring characters who originated in print", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "\" thenThe 2011 Conan", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "the Barbarian Novel is 'Based on the Movie', and there are several James Bond novels based on the movies, and lots of the Marvel universe movies have been subsequently novelised.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/71220/JeffUK", "score": 4 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "An early almost-example is the novel The Circular Staircase , which was adapted into the play", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Bat , which was separately adapted into novel", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The Bat and movie The Bat . https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Circular_Staircase", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/78094/Mark Tilford", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "As no-one seems to have mentioned them yet, James Bond, The Spy Who Loved Me and James Bond and Moonraker are novelisations of the relevant Bond films, which have no resemblance to the original novels by Ian Fleming whose titles they bear.", "label": [ 1 ], "label_summ": [ 1 ], "cluster_id": [ [ 0 ] ] }, { "text": "(well, the OP did say \"regardless of how faithful the adaptation was\")", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/42835/piersb", "score": 3 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Another example: Snow White and the Huntsman.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Loosely based on the original fairy tale, which has been novelized many times (a.o.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "the brothers Grimm.)", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The 2012 movie got is own novel, written by Lily Blake.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/46424/Tonny", "score": 1 } }, { "sents": [ { "text": "Yes Another example to the great ones given previously: In 1937, Frederic Dannay and Manfred Lee (writing as Ellery Queen ) released The Door Between .", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "In 1940, it was adapted as Ellery Queen, Master Detective , directed by Kurt Neumann and written by Eric Taylor.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Finally, in 1941 the novelization of the movie was published as Ellery Queen Master Detective (sometimes reissued as Vanishing Corpse ).", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "The ghostwriter was Laurence Dwight Smith , but the cover credited Ellery Queen only.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] }, { "text": "Hence, this is an example where both the source and the novelization were published with the same name of the author on the cover.", "label": [ 0 ], "label_summ": [ 0 ], "cluster_id": [ [ -1 ] ] } ], "answer_details": { "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/55418/Alexander Z.", "score": 1 } } ]

{ "question": "Inspired by a discussion to an answer on this question , has a movie which was explicitly adapted from a novel (regardless of how faithful the adaptation was) received an official novelisation based solely, or even primarily, on the movie?", "title": "Has a movie based on a novel ever had its own new novelisation?", "forum": "movies.stackexchange.com", "question_tags": "<book-adaptation>", "link": "movies.stackexchange.com/questions/110164", "author": "movies.stackexchange.com/users/26195/GeoffAtkins" }

[ [ "Several examples of this exist, including graphic novels like V for Vendetta that were adapted as a film, which was then novelised. Some James Bond novels have also been produced as films and then novelised.", "Many films have been adapted into novels. Examples include V for Vendetta and certain James Bond films." ] ]

{ "rel_sent_not_in_cluster": [ false ], "cluster_sents_not_matched": [ [] ] }

[ 8 ]

[ [ "Many films have been adapted into novels. Examples include V for Vendetta and certain James Bond films." ] ]