id
stringlengths
33
34
doc_url
stringlengths
33
34
title
stringlengths
10
211
publication_date
timestamp[s]
update_date
timestamp[s]
authors
stringlengths
5
20.1k
category_primary
stringclasses
78 values
category_all
stringlengths
5
138
abstract
stringlengths
123
3.09k
embeddings
sequencelengths
768
768
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.03813v4
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.03813v4
Robustness of Learning from Task Instructions
2022-12-07T17:54:59
2023-05-23T13:39:39
Jiasheng Gu, Hongyu Zhao, Hanzi Xu, Liangyu Nie, Hongyuan Mei, Wenpeng Yin
cs.CL
cs.CL
Traditional supervised learning mostly works on individual tasks and requires training on a large set of task-specific examples. This paradigm seriously hinders the development of task generalization since preparing a task-specific example set is costly. To build a system that can quickly and easily generalize to new tasks, task instructions have been adopted as an emerging trend of supervision recently. These instructions give the model the definition of the task and allow the model to output the appropriate answer based on the instructions and inputs. However, task instructions are often expressed in different forms, which can be interpreted from two threads: first, some instructions are short sentences and are pretrained language model (PLM) oriented, such as prompts, while other instructions are paragraphs and are human-oriented, such as those in Amazon MTurk; second, different end-users very likely explain the same task with instructions of different textual expressions. A robust system for task generalization should be able to handle any new tasks regardless of the variability of instructions. However, the system robustness in dealing with instruction-driven task generalization is still unexplored. This work investigates the system robustness when the instructions of new tasks are (i) manipulated, (ii) paraphrased, or (iii) from different levels of conciseness. To our knowledge, this is the first work that systematically studies how robust a PLM is when it is supervised by instructions with different factors of variability.
[ 0.0653905347, -1.0149949789, 0.4767991006, 0.3362721503, -0.3244452775, -0.2532216012, -0.472494334, -0.1662518084, -0.2943106592, 0.4506784678, -0.5923339128, -0.5929360986, -0.8654900789, 0.1911830902, -0.3633796275, 1.2917960882, -0.2176746577, -0.1706789136, -0.3153348863, -0.1277179867, -0.6454657316, -0.6927425861, -0.3755381405, -0.2280953825, 0.2153463066, 0.4186657071, 0.53323102, 0.7286752462, 0.6495829225, 0.3921594918, 0.1294873655, 0.0770895109, -0.1990477145, 0.3790364861, -0.075873524, -0.7316203713, -0.3920199275, -0.0009995358, 0.3963372707, 0.7507397532, -0.0740300491, 0.2455647439, 0.8269410133, 0.3549605012, -0.6759620905, 0.6716694832, -0.5001854897, -0.2464050502, -0.2321822196, -0.1679805964, -0.5126162171, -0.0717039481, 0.2990656793, -0.8929196596, 0.3953791261, -0.3985314667, 0.814442575, 0.3041599095, -0.0903666615, -0.6275725365, -0.7141063213, 1.0289850235, -0.5587131977, 0.0096025821, 0.6523954868, 0.3614876866, -0.0286646541, -0.803161025, -0.0119654275, -0.3277348876, -0.2347765267, -0.1260481328, -0.0692501292, 0.1014253572, 0.4463900626, 0.0387100615, -0.434874773, 0.0548015349, 0.0232131705, -0.1749748737, 0.2560425401, 0.1955371648, 0.3051751256, -0.1822645515, -0.4970147014, -0.1320008785, -0.265096724, 0.4847041667, 0.4318284392, 0.4381254017, -0.2298259735, 0.3603093922, -0.3813749254, 0.7193003297, 0.3976212442, -0.4478775859, 0.188967824, -0.3970911503, -0.364443928, -0.4142408371, 0.7219164968, 0.1402242184, 0.1922022551, -0.3428055644, -0.3069341183, 0.2207845151, 0.5152207613, -0.4753062725, -0.2254468054, 0.0400754586, -0.7405062318, -0.2126106918, 0.1392202377, -0.50521487, 0.0393046029, -0.4178645611, 0.4558795989, -0.5296276212, 0.306607157, 0.0128778517, 0.2680094242, 0.2187560201, 0.3794724941, -0.9390525818, 0.3949137628, 0.7963757515, 0.6178343892, -0.4677650034, -0.5115910769, -0.7467930317, -0.0012584297, -0.0756745189, 0.4370524883, -0.331880182, -0.3276334703, 0.0299386736, 0.2570654452, -0.4028691649, -0.5238563418, 0.602455616, -0.3662726283, 0.1534765363, -0.151554957, -0.3761934042, 0.0267101675, 0.1587586105, -0.4248390198, 0.7310711741, 0.2362283468, -0.9751312137, 0.450725913, -0.3592346907, -0.6066998839, -0.1017586514, -0.0613541417, -0.5587117672, -0.0539961345, 0.1663832664, 0.6479961276, 0.102000542, 0.2245944887, -0.326654464, -0.5424303412, 0.2282400578, -0.4566432536, 0.7870842814, 0.2017248571, -0.5867611766, 0.0840659291, -0.562684834, -0.0952592418, -0.1545929313, -0.6682912111, -0.4428132772, 0.1022676528, -0.3179758489, -0.0099616526, 0.4466314912, -0.2297501266, 0.0991776511, -0.190039739, 0.3178583086, 0.7577406764, -0.0427064709, 0.5443419218, -0.4239723682, 0.5417933464, -0.0067478982, 0.3792744875, -0.3991465867, -0.4074243903, -0.5243844986, -0.1230208501, 0.0122742699, 0.8927292824, -0.8385779858, 0.247203052, -0.0574305356, -0.1946817636, -0.0899748802, 0.5515158772, 0.7683887482, 0.4826885462, 0.4192999303, -0.2176301628, -0.4522745609, -0.8127164841, -0.3320732713, -0.059309572, -0.1731817126, 0.0008855753, 0.3977488875, -0.1950582266, 0.4118193686, -0.1328883618, 0.0715643242, -0.170891732, 0.3463387191, 0.2052303106, 0.8090367317, 0.3747282624, -0.5684051514, -0.6173653007, -0.121990934, -0.782730341, -0.1640476733, -0.35445714, -0.1401439458, -0.0286447313, 0.4904720783, -0.6797235608, 0.5648105741, 0.3059424162, -0.0741298944, 0.5863227844, -0.3535518348, -0.0136810383, -1.0719873905, -0.0192228928, 0.089689292, -0.2085110843, -0.6180350184, 0.261845082, -0.0325811207, 0.0359133594, -0.2870458663, -0.1619966477, -0.4576969147, 0.2347834706, -0.447679311, -0.2876655459, -0.1323428154, 0.7703860402, -0.2229197621, 0.5513080955, 0.9036872983, -0.7170856595, 0.2690138519, 0.2424257994, -0.2317237109, 0.6692690253, -0.8161519766, 0.2051483542, -0.0580664799, -0.0355149321, -0.6516919732, -0.255309999, 0.3188553751, -0.264831692, 0.5545797944, -0.0285850298, -0.3638682961, -0.0792127401, -0.1248413622, 0.2087466717, 0.5857813954, -0.2563028932, 0.4600020051, 0.0450850725, -0.1929220557, -0.7834294438, -0.5622169375, -0.3081849217, -0.2858772874, -0.2946546078, 0.1418052167, -0.0683726668, -0.2861109972, -0.1480409652, -0.5235576034, -0.3868206441, 0.4718997777, 0.7203254104, 0.3017120361, -0.0935140625, -0.169653222, 0.0768956766, 0.0790031925, 0.168725282, -0.1752627343, 0.2483568639, -0.0401010364, -0.5699700713, -0.9529910088, 0.5016499758, 0.521307826, -0.1177768707, 0.6175834537, 0.4599799514, -0.3233574629, -0.4746480882, -0.1531946808, -0.276920259, -0.4627100825, 0.273065269, -0.3894806504, -0.8840415478, 0.3620502949, 0.0523478091, 0.2590422332, 0.0741822422, 0.2910269499, -0.4418728352, 0.9661613107, 0.7059619427, 0.1556057483, 0.4291671515, -0.0634033084, -0.2399462163, -0.399879396, -0.1556033641, -0.6409463882, -0.3030635118, -0.5924496651, -0.325435549, -0.014695649, 0.2055669129, -0.1045461446, 0.5431809425, -0.4065711498, 0.2463347316, 0.935649991, 0.5053172708, -0.0772698596, 0.0120071769, -0.1456586272, 0.2082171738, -0.4947689474, -0.8546029925, 1.1291326284, 0.3088155985, 0.8855372071, -0.2935003042, 0.6525784731, 0.4179497659, 0.0774963945, -0.4499951303, 0.5645498037, -0.477519244, -0.342169106, -0.2102838308, -0.3396138549, -1.1776297092, -0.0448762402, -0.1467133015, -0.8032593727, 0.1667429656, 0.3697411418, -0.3544265926, 0.124086909, -0.8429818153, 0.9322841763, 0.0590867363, -0.2473742366, 0.1709163636, -0.9138045311, 0.1023828834, -0.2008063644, 0.0798400715, 0.1671709716, -0.0138239982, 0.818716228, -0.3747337162, 1.2225840092, -0.2781686187, 0.0954793841, 0.4288850129, 0.0969064832, 0.5580872893, -0.0818572566, 0.1606566012, -0.102540493, 0.072946988, -0.7819010019, -0.6544569135, 0.5841081738, -0.7215199471, -0.8384587169, -0.065728642, -0.8697499633, -0.2758802176, 0.0111635746, 0.3674164712, 0.5977534056, 0.169896856, 0.3853613138, 0.8234286308, -0.1759040952, 0.4148981869, 0.2078537345, 0.226937592, 0.036945913, 0.6669690013, -0.0046389056, 0.4182967544, 0.5875638723, 0.0948521495, 0.1095113531, -0.8296793103, -0.122077778, -0.2501394451, -0.6915040612, -0.0673286691, -0.3393040597, 0.1771179885, -0.3119720519, -0.1157933176, 0.0139648551, -0.1714853793, -0.5009643435, -0.09985625, -0.2650452852, 0.6642551422, 0.2298175842, 0.5066592097, -0.7249453664, 0.2770115733, 0.7295498848, 0.083375439, -0.283290118, -0.5238916278, -0.3469097018, 0.1576576233, -0.3352700174, -1.0737704039, 0.0616237745, 0.2794578075, 0.8840981722, 0.5913443565, 0.1637748778, 0.3717667162, -0.303447634, 0.6480419636, -0.0407444872, -0.9329583049, 0.6686243415, -0.4043382704, 0.4183332622, 0.4762846231, 0.4136854112, 0.228672877, -0.7475374341, -0.4776216745, -0.539246738, 0.7908733487, 0.0810523182, 0.3002254069, 0.0326918624, 0.5135096908, 0.6817783117, 0.1818849146, -0.5970571637, -0.1929907948, -0.3831145763, -0.3550611436, -0.146431461, -0.233801946, -0.2631127536, 0.0688597113, 0.2575710714, -0.1153020263, 0.279718101, -0.0249441843, -0.2880569696, 0.1061621606, 0.4306398332, 0.4580742121, 0.6877712607, -0.0632123351, 0.4956982136, 0.1724814028, -0.5288450122, 0.0928272307, 0.1600182503, -0.4091165662, 0.056816943, 0.8003697395, 1.0001624823, 0.3438623846, -0.5129364729, 0.5265178084, 0.1573471576, -0.3561485112, 0.2128564119, 0.3832098246, -0.2042780071, 0.2975612581, 0.1317188144, 0.4753701091, -0.0543709919, -0.5283226967, 0.1642564535, 0.3729379177, -0.2507740259, -0.5840709805, 0.6834990978, -0.0831006169, -0.1557259262, 0.3678673804, -0.2263785452, -0.2834219635, 0.446393013, 0.4992469549, 0.6501944661, -0.2192454338, 0.3476761878, 0.1129697859, 0.3115159571, -0.1573659182, 0.268440932, -0.3517252803, -0.405900389, -0.5742583275, -0.5881829262, -0.3800503612, 0.00359187, -0.9634056091, -0.2295354754, -0.5572247505, -0.2928874195, -0.3379794061, -0.3877313733, -0.6968286037, 0.237055406, -0.0476544574, 0.6040893197, -1.0356081724, 0.855676949, 1.013204217, -0.2797387838, -0.9951745868, 0.1018683687, -0.3395940661, -0.6796047091, 0.7408413291, 0.2138280421, 0.1824718118, -0.5694825053, -0.6469461322, -0.4157801569, 1.0007071495, 0.6313994527, -0.3455063105, -0.3458425105, 0.1981377155, 0.4715543985, -0.1457505822, -0.2140668631, 0.2522455454, 0.1134052426, -0.2401631325, -1.0989391804, 0.1577640772, -0.1575393975, 0.079688251, -0.0668356344, -0.2426804751, 1.2083553076, -0.1024465561, -0.2743824422, 0.1605482548, 0.5608620048, 0.1199086308, 0.416436553, 0.5542989373, 0.4226731658, 0.6349872947, -0.1894416511, 1.0751229525, -0.2553324103, 0.1574213654, 1.2764846087, 0.078128837, 0.6670037508, 0.4734546244, -0.1863906235, 0.7504617572, 0.4306265116, 0.1485653967, 0.5158188939, -0.0286140535, -0.1510610282, -0.4555724859, 0.2172425985, -0.0543648116, 0.3939177394, 0.1033772156, -0.4820781648, -0.2020026743, 0.2277963609, -0.0498424433, 0.3106590807, -0.4397321045, 0.7372096181, -0.0051874546, -0.9377997518, 0.5390692353, -0.0707698092, 0.7952660918, -0.7011710405, 0.0381721072, 0.0951666459, 0.2053638846, -0.2887594402, -0.5334029198, 0.2846592069, 0.1728269309, -0.3494914174, -0.5635275841, 0.8726437092, -0.1021862924, -0.2741759419, -0.0156288259, 0.6617193818, 0.0486632772, 0.0312475562, -0.5769307613, -0.0953354612, 0.0029918333, -0.1650615335, 0.6472294331, 0.4554042816, -0.1677138209, 0.7684174776, 0.4543814361, -0.0667017624, 0.4364040792, -0.4610284865, 0.6780285835, -0.0122452192, -0.4168395102, -0.7317550182, 0.3858138025, 0.1486991644, -0.205462575, 1.000988245, 0.1618650109, 0.8678488731, -0.4023387134, 0.8179411888, -0.0215467643, 0.3963305652, -0.4944754541, 0.285233736, -0.1862890124, 0.2583009303, -0.1179211736, -0.7405368686, -0.1547828168, 0.4909215868, -0.3007118702, 0.0292739142, 0.8257029653, 0.6281501651, -0.1527655572, 0.0591479242, 0.163257122, -0.179939881, -0.114609696, 0.6321849227, 0.5939992666, 0.0308977813, 0.8456337452, -0.6061534286, -0.239283666, 0.0169343799, -0.7083998919, -0.9374837279, -0.5875330567, -0.4679560363, -0.2316015661, 0.2808885574, 0.6657651663, 0.7549313903, -1.0075860023, -0.197648719, -0.2915842831, 0.0070554018, -0.8030090332, -0.1695588082, 0.4137782454, -0.6899668574, -0.6495702863, 0.3585722148, -0.0567340553, 0.0337954871, 0.0402854569, -0.0915029123, 0.0420934707, -0.1168561503, 0.3627090454, 0.3006791174, -0.5313112736, -0.3613947332, 0.1244562939, -0.3629966676, -0.1046810076, 0.7880190611, -0.3636753857, 0.4125007689, 0.4826390147, 0.7089238167, 0.10045138, 0.0602168143, 0.467957139, -0.871170342, -0.049073834, 0.0537943579, 0.4132884741, 0.2874310017, -0.1355334818, 0.0516592637, 0.3114337623, -0.6732081771, -0.6030103564, 0.2249232382, -1.1591095924, -0.3034716845, 1.0788301229, -0.9379720092, -0.2473564148, -0.2996892333, -0.226606518, 0.5187324882, -0.1443975419, 0.7717092037, 0.659160614, -0.2701394558, 0.0625083596, -0.5165172815, 0.2722762823, 0.4755224288, -0.7554203272, -0.0744212195, 0.1822085381, 0.4324489534, 0.112957418, 0.2031147629, 0.165884465, 0.4025035799, 0.008235611, -0.3364982009, -0.2343420237, -0.0940813124, -0.1354508251, 0.6578145623, 0.1389382929, -0.7120833993 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.03869v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.03869v1
Pre-Training With Scientific Text Improves Educational Question Generation
2022-12-07T17:17:58
2022-12-07T17:17:58
Hamze Muse, Sahan Bulathwela, Emine Yilmaz
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.IR, cs.LG, stat.ML, H.3.3; J.1; I.2.0
With the boom of digital educational materials and scalable e-learning systems, the potential for realising AI-assisted personalised learning has skyrocketed. In this landscape, the automatic generation of educational questions will play a key role, enabling scalable self-assessment when a global population is manoeuvring their personalised learning journeys. We develop EduQG, a novel educational question generation model built by adapting a large language model. Our initial experiments demonstrate that EduQG can produce superior educational questions by pre-training on scientific text.
[ -0.5750786066, -1.1101056337, 0.3676655889, -0.2552350461, -0.0910321027, 0.0610474572, 0.0957903415, -0.3486667871, -0.0352382064, 0.5176400542, -0.597871244, -0.1877368391, -0.2861850262, 0.4249358773, -0.2804042399, 0.9652938843, 0.226755023, 0.14841187, -0.8019682765, 0.2061116099, 0.0596986562, -0.5791541934, -0.8312018514, -0.1954779327, 0.4081588686, 0.4843998551, 0.3148485124, 0.2312162668, 0.424365133, 0.3044950366, 0.3137781322, 0.1613453329, -0.3774778545, 0.2589862049, -0.1235597059, -0.7121856809, -0.1054389104, 0.0529383756, 0.704862833, 0.7608374953, -0.2387381345, 0.3880739212, 0.102372162, 0.5274433494, -0.2444701195, -0.207210049, -0.4981232882, 0.2481559813, 0.1822370142, -0.3012608588, -0.1444346756, -0.4295041263, 0.1428548247, -0.7773979306, 0.3146874309, -0.0680042803, 0.7924969196, 0.6028752327, -0.5236623287, -0.1774415225, -0.5518621802, 0.4028728604, -0.4612380266, 0.4318618774, 0.4994146824, 0.1667535454, -0.2396912128, -1.4005428553, -0.6458183527, -0.1614011526, 0.0661222041, 0.4315540493, 0.4020805955, -0.1541675478, 0.3494683802, 0.1569527239, -0.8108448386, -0.1139812395, -0.6038075686, 0.1352416724, 0.7060821652, 0.1402542591, 0.3233450353, -0.2590717673, -0.253315717, -0.2332018316, -0.8937319517, 0.1656691879, 0.5728679299, -0.1147701964, 0.4535136223, 0.2368180156, -0.1908958852, 0.802816391, 0.4623172581, 0.3525668383, -0.0078575071, -0.5207368135, 0.1813892275, 0.1747368872, 0.8991473317, 0.3378381431, 0.2268837541, 0.4775341749, 0.2628515065, -0.1637295187, 0.3783141375, -1.1156001091, -0.5174275041, 0.2882451117, 0.2648338079, -0.1686834991, 0.0341777317, -0.6737491488, 0.0387177728, -0.0737192854, 0.3376297057, -0.2199770808, -0.1594999135, 0.319496274, 0.0917716175, 0.1922684312, 0.4327814281, -0.9954965711, -0.2281588167, 0.1768620014, 0.1307344735, 0.1166109741, -0.1859620512, -0.2310511768, 0.0655922741, -0.3647821248, 0.9394712448, -0.5960444808, -0.6263086796, -0.2434103489, -0.1336835325, -0.1418761313, -0.4655255079, 0.0668257251, -0.743717134, 0.9876425862, -0.1604928225, -0.5357708931, 0.0017903966, 0.5110969543, -0.2573528886, 1.4137593508, 0.1889305562, -0.7490459085, 0.5821123719, -0.8608370423, -0.1280784756, 0.8097510934, -0.4651834965, -0.2857348919, -0.4934733212, 0.3949797153, 0.3683791459, -0.4163107276, 0.4814679027, 0.0298415497, -0.0251571517, 0.0464360118, -0.1054826677, 0.7756017447, 0.3533545434, -0.3846422732, -0.1074103117, -0.6971012354, 0.6932832599, 0.3088531494, -0.489813447, -0.6073566079, -0.1179393157, -0.3435072601, 0.0408571474, 0.407346189, -0.4639932811, 0.3755080104, -0.3769198358, 0.3624914587, 0.3605771959, 0.3009290397, 0.182297796, 0.0152912876, 0.7695405483, -0.2062551826, 0.164035067, -0.1967956424, -0.5388900638, -0.4011332393, 0.3182810545, 0.5261889696, 0.5029962659, -1.0057555437, 0.4243327081, 0.2369492501, -0.6002343297, -0.6003200412, 0.2080270499, 0.2002018094, 0.750143826, 0.2976890206, -0.0638860911, -0.2483225763, -0.3466245532, -0.1832292825, -0.428483367, -0.2424938381, 0.5761609674, 0.6813690066, -0.3163565993, 0.8176003695, -0.8373125196, 0.3199010193, -0.0952804759, 0.4179837108, -0.2683649659, 0.6384130716, 0.356792748, -1.1695358753, -0.6586890817, -0.1654122174, -0.9550317526, -0.0955640599, -0.2972486317, -0.2144846767, -0.2473119944, 0.7017953992, -0.606570363, -0.059114635, 0.090443939, -0.5130672455, 0.6941627264, -0.4985298812, 0.6186654568, -1.2382854223, -0.089475438, -0.2909586132, -0.1393453777, -0.5301253796, 0.3381526172, 0.1668342054, -0.2908866704, -0.5696861148, 0.5121880174, -0.2264170498, 0.3950091004, -0.010323612, 0.3330662847, 0.1980549991, -0.1016368568, -0.1475274414, 0.8364899755, 0.4080580771, -0.9663750529, 0.3359284997, 0.6498188376, -0.2563284934, 0.6355243921, -1.0062398911, 0.3371502161, -0.207504034, 0.1369976699, -0.8737637997, -0.4482592642, -0.0070393202, -0.6895721555, 0.3603481352, 0.3127387166, -0.1898038834, -0.7666564584, -0.1475699246, 0.645211935, 0.4987003207, -0.8107563257, 0.4281089008, 0.1896007359, -0.6424546838, -0.5551815033, -0.1161604151, -0.0169354398, -0.0942367315, -0.5454397202, 0.0730831921, -0.5808750391, -0.1989064366, -0.1113767102, 0.1998921782, 0.0267617218, 0.3699333966, 0.0296083111, 0.334261924, -0.3103107214, 0.3841083944, 0.5105845928, 0.2427964061, 0.4773395956, -0.4296014607, 0.4214889407, -0.0520752184, -0.2586432993, 0.0436904468, 0.4531956613, 0.3188601136, -0.4218623638, 0.446416676, 0.3652282059, -0.1241986081, -0.4596605003, -0.2598536909, -0.6682369113, -0.5812113881, 0.6002260447, -0.2876601517, -0.9319533706, 0.2162011713, -0.4017420411, 0.034031637, 0.5411171913, 0.3752754629, -0.4998957515, 1.2603524923, 0.6342989206, 0.5825948715, 0.2826581299, -0.3247807324, 0.018587647, -0.5161759257, -0.5171155334, -0.4961958528, 0.0863700882, -0.5067977309, -0.2703670561, 0.5291977525, 0.29122594, -0.4663392305, -0.0592855923, -0.7294160128, 0.6311822534, 0.759057045, 0.0262092222, 0.0951275378, -0.0701818243, -0.3174087405, 0.057632748, -0.9886674285, -0.7087250352, 1.3464833498, -0.1168720722, 0.5026962757, -0.5230141878, 1.0037560463, 0.1740823686, 0.4888510108, -0.4036045372, 0.5433061123, 0.325732708, -1.0801461935, -0.7824330926, -0.4599458277, -1.1600248814, 0.3649258018, -0.3955332637, -0.023477966, -0.1991795897, 0.2262334228, -0.9313659668, 0.2265313715, -0.5060293078, 0.6967187524, -0.6067613363, -0.4056630433, 0.0343324356, -0.7924410105, 0.1665848047, -0.4002141654, 0.0257604718, 0.3833766282, 0.3490243554, 1.2584495544, -0.2262112051, 0.4413546026, -0.1357322186, -0.0128658088, 0.9468829632, -0.1888287663, 0.0652825162, 0.2165641785, 0.1714832634, -0.111756891, 0.2279151827, -0.437327683, -0.4771472812, 0.559943676, -0.9672176242, -1.2042752504, -0.5519709587, -0.5433641076, -0.174937129, 0.3409421742, 0.4097546041, -0.0112383999, -0.3983921111, 0.156167686, 0.9368754625, -0.5044820905, 0.240177229, 0.7719071507, -0.3759600222, -0.2676372826, 0.6997834444, 0.1825404912, 0.4232740998, 0.0080675362, 0.3310151398, -0.5908657312, -0.239894256, -0.6569626927, 0.3037905991, -0.7019795775, -0.0892614052, -0.9390518069, -0.2842435241, -0.7131153345, -0.1909816265, -0.2432935089, -0.2932510972, -0.6464791298, -0.611246109, 0.1050434336, 1.055991888, -0.0125886528, 0.3310863376, -0.8831300139, 0.2118537128, 1.0525105, -0.1553616971, -0.481444031, -0.5832114816, -0.0715398416, 0.2714537382, -0.562253356, -0.6619172096, 0.3011365831, 0.4328133464, 0.4937885404, 0.5004563332, 0.2946497798, 0.2128596753, -0.5558090806, 1.178899765, 0.2976699173, -0.5043907166, 0.6771551371, -0.3838104308, 0.2933791876, 0.4957821071, 1.1522990465, -0.2021194249, -0.2526618242, -0.7677838206, -0.8662225604, 0.2018705159, -0.3258863389, 0.3093384802, -0.1826665103, 0.6637399793, 0.4286743999, 0.2920814753, -0.6149953604, -0.1976230145, -0.6522646546, -0.2554079294, -0.2358753383, -0.0939317644, -0.1599356383, -0.5694001913, 0.4878509045, -0.3220680058, -0.0075432635, 0.3586002886, 0.0225594472, -0.2713085413, 0.3681380451, 0.4601148665, 0.5988093019, -0.0587491542, -0.0889422596, 0.1260669529, -0.6928188205, 0.3489130437, 0.1247633025, -0.5242608786, -0.3201089203, 0.0372257531, 0.4271404445, -0.0959908292, -0.6025392413, 0.1801891923, -0.2846887708, -0.7241062522, -0.3694013953, 0.4025128186, 0.1908741593, 0.0655503199, 0.6016495228, -0.4703490138, -0.0403768905, -0.6030097604, 0.5247728229, 0.3398950398, -0.1675210297, -0.27511397, 1.2616279125, 0.2715583444, -0.3758256435, 0.6941524744, -0.1509243101, -0.7331143618, 0.8247895837, 0.661675036, 0.4278742075, -0.8226172328, 0.7667979598, 0.7155373693, 0.293129921, -0.1014612839, 0.836476028, -0.2433301657, -0.6322036982, -0.0983704329, -0.6225146055, -0.6344954371, 0.0362603441, -0.5049107671, -0.0038087673, -0.4936978519, -0.2566524446, -0.2130225003, -0.1137813106, -0.8446996808, 0.9353185892, -0.0222133249, 0.402510494, -0.7186011672, 0.6178135872, 1.0738824606, -0.4469831884, -1.1447986364, -0.3099595606, -0.7392617464, -0.5391253829, 1.0521104336, 0.0466073453, 0.1633026153, 0.6447730064, -0.9451730847, -0.9814115167, 1.0826977491, 0.0948539153, -0.6023144722, -0.1051972955, 0.4178839028, 0.5582669973, -0.3497512341, 0.6005899906, 0.3760625124, 0.484559983, 0.1902983338, -0.512783587, -0.2040047944, -0.3581226468, -0.708693862, 0.1589811444, -0.4489011765, 1.1265267134, -0.6082849503, -0.2126527429, -0.364327848, 0.7788617611, 0.1073167026, 0.5086922646, 0.2833381593, 0.5403313041, 1.1730768681, -0.1518041342, 1.0614725351, -0.5119652152, 0.1286751181, 0.8965442777, -0.1827885509, 0.7231711745, 0.3844669461, -0.3267226517, 0.5123633742, 0.9966847897, -0.1283840686, 0.3810276985, 0.2554540634, -0.2803809941, -0.3828589916, 0.0323702842, -0.8667160273, 0.4611328244, 0.3190882504, -0.0699098557, 0.0881168246, 0.3041671813, -0.3135751784, 0.2017274201, -0.5687574744, 0.6954046488, 0.1014313921, -0.9746694565, 0.6366852522, -0.4679946899, 0.3799625933, -0.7142540216, -0.0522592999, -0.1808587164, -0.1084997132, -0.0227336586, -0.4781419337, -0.3693489134, -0.137108475, 0.1719515622, -0.2398921847, 0.5123307109, -0.9194970131, -0.5224789977, -0.1010781378, 0.7642436624, 0.2361490577, 0.0109094176, -0.7181783319, -0.8870376945, -0.0575075038, -0.6356783509, 0.4546596706, 0.4240629375, 0.136837706, 0.8647592068, 0.7944835424, -0.0402787104, 0.4570942521, -0.1570140272, 0.7792059183, -0.6660265326, -0.8214828968, -0.3442310691, 0.6102069616, 0.0157152265, -0.3855472505, 0.8926790953, 0.2474573702, 1.1070607901, -0.2313148677, 0.9916856885, 0.144684732, 0.1825661361, -0.149483785, 1.0349861383, -0.6522302032, -0.1092558727, -0.2171818316, -0.8537241817, -0.0262696501, 0.6583985686, -0.3385756612, 0.1247650087, 1.019744277, 0.3954881728, 0.5100882649, 0.1573075652, 0.4969900846, -0.0363136791, 0.457487464, 0.2661807835, 1.0043780804, -0.6003741622, 0.2832818627, -0.0078490581, -0.1216622293, 0.0753795803, -0.463311255, -1.2850852013, -0.6055004597, -0.5789762139, -0.1219586506, -0.154054895, 1.0682288408, 0.2978759706, -0.7004933953, 0.1375808865, -0.0068778354, -0.2167385817, 0.3013294637, -0.2016792297, 0.3709234595, -0.2129491866, -0.6131634712, 0.3401558101, -0.1271913201, 0.418997705, -0.3527211249, -0.0006490641, -0.3525966406, 0.4713847041, 0.5454114676, 0.4222774804, -0.0705194101, -0.241957888, 0.1173663884, -0.0728245676, -0.148709774, 0.689355433, -0.7491905093, 0.5509501696, 0.3240661621, 0.8393850923, 0.4433020651, 0.2586247027, 0.4579277635, -0.3494938612, -0.1457176507, 0.5908455849, 0.0139370998, 0.350951463, -0.8613877892, 0.2671838403, 0.1795455068, -0.830681026, -0.7334781289, 0.1461623907, -0.2933108509, -0.3131460547, 0.833607614, -0.2506079972, -0.1601141691, -0.0893101841, -0.2047943771, 0.1683719754, 0.0637656003, 1.2033369541, 0.4778546095, -0.039799232, 0.0707791895, -0.5429854989, 0.6354681253, 0.8006908894, -1.1354027987, -0.3664607406, 0.4018592834, 0.3407019973, 0.0376330651, 0.463679105, 0.0773266256, 0.3952494562, 0.028540371, 0.3131195605, -0.4217681289, -0.4675664604, 0.1277384609, 0.5996382833, -0.1204107925, 0.0258661006 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.03760v5
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.03760v5
Pivotal Role of Language Modeling in Recommender Systems: Enriching Task-specific and Task-agnostic Representation Learning
2022-12-07T16:31:14
2023-05-13T08:16:21
Kyuyong Shin, Hanock Kwak, Wonjae Kim, Jisu Jeong, Seungjae Jung, Kyung-Min Kim, Jung-Woo Ha, Sang-Woo Lee
cs.IR
cs.IR, cs.CL
Recent studies have proposed unified user modeling frameworks that leverage user behavior data from various applications. Many of them benefit from utilizing users' behavior sequences as plain texts, representing rich information in any domain or system without losing generality. Hence, a question arises: Can language modeling for user history corpus help improve recommender systems? While its versatile usability has been widely investigated in many domains, its applications to recommender systems still remain underexplored. We show that language modeling applied directly to task-specific user histories achieves excellent results on diverse recommendation tasks. Also, leveraging additional task-agnostic user histories delivers significant performance benefits. We further demonstrate that our approach can provide promising transfer learning capabilities for a broad spectrum of real-world recommender systems, even on unseen domains and services.
[ -0.0499419235, -0.4765660465, 0.6684715748, -0.2198244184, 0.1764863133, -0.0388594121, -0.1187742874, -0.484431833, -0.0088425241, 0.7748830318, -0.4039211273, -0.2286399603, -0.3915661871, -0.3742326796, -0.7151010633, 1.0765900612, 0.0214484297, 0.0325794071, -0.318467021, -0.0904166028, -0.749751091, -0.8506207466, -0.47294873, -0.6152610183, 0.3082190454, 0.2595689595, 0.7735074162, 0.4531063139, 0.2644709945, 0.2451779991, 0.1672969759, 0.0216203574, -0.6181081533, 0.4609335959, -0.4490565956, -0.2505643964, -0.3755814135, -0.1159202754, 0.4783793986, 1.1690411568, -0.3133541942, 0.0419526286, 0.3144573271, 0.4942957163, -0.4042279124, 0.1649428755, -0.3566861451, -0.1349117756, -0.0923086554, -0.0431955382, -0.4844564199, -0.0358238257, 0.6984013915, -0.7197017074, 0.2937100828, 0.4096346498, 0.6442123055, -0.2416763455, -0.563570857, -0.3359012604, -1.221511364, 0.8493388295, -0.4656072259, 0.5844407082, 0.5223078728, 0.3397204876, -0.2377282083, -0.6546827555, -0.2298787683, -0.3614389002, -0.3192862868, -0.3773348927, -0.524471581, -0.1058177873, 0.1637202948, 0.4352075458, -0.3648515046, -0.1680953205, -0.4386589229, -0.4378057122, 0.3128657937, 0.3510837853, 0.6298412681, -0.0033424571, -0.3370142281, -0.1404854208, -0.6638033986, 0.4735924304, 0.3381603062, 0.5606712699, 0.0492337421, 0.3786872625, -0.0595476367, 0.7438157201, -0.1425830722, 0.2097582072, -0.160377726, -0.3440098464, -0.082972616, -0.417095691, 0.5794989467, 0.2928730845, 0.6284355521, -0.5276604891, -0.0361345708, -0.0143894609, 0.5610824227, -0.697560668, -0.3459878564, -0.312243849, -0.4227651358, 0.0323315561, 0.3484499454, -0.4305515587, -0.4973771274, -0.2717968225, 0.0464083031, -0.50559479, -0.3274287581, 0.2308325917, -0.0400381535, -0.3650434017, 0.3446496427, -1.1014775038, 0.7850016952, 0.4970349967, 0.5166777968, -0.4917244613, -0.3686212599, -0.4628995061, 0.1203219816, -0.0825778469, 0.6598543525, -0.8873990178, -0.7851212621, 0.3846964538, 0.1340883672, 0.1158770397, -0.4997969866, 0.4005011618, -0.5915000439, 0.0325960033, -0.3042143881, -0.6006659269, -0.541775167, -0.082870394, -0.7018696666, 0.9795957804, 0.303738296, -0.1516654491, 0.2498093247, -0.5055744648, -0.6693447828, -0.0188986398, 0.0973852426, -0.0475982614, 0.1832158267, -0.068943046, 0.7555695176, -0.1272670776, 0.5595477223, -0.4888651967, -0.6053574681, 0.1467538923, -0.1808357388, 0.5705981851, 0.3063975275, 0.0908253565, 0.1891692877, -0.3747890294, -0.4220435917, -0.0327601694, -0.2348874062, -0.6148226261, -0.0825499445, 0.5995694995, -0.0613664538, 0.164928183, -0.3499969542, 0.3273368776, -0.3579989374, 0.3517711759, 0.4560665786, -0.1573056728, 0.7638303041, -0.4239020348, 0.7176330686, -0.0117756706, -0.2777267098, -0.4749976099, -0.3422260582, -0.5267370939, 0.1145071089, 0.2539619803, 0.4298145175, -0.3729014099, 0.1862752587, -0.0898559466, -0.3352009952, -0.2289049327, 0.3100585938, 0.3231901824, 0.3278230727, 0.2759803236, -0.5357394814, -0.8289859295, -0.7314119935, -0.4739489555, -0.49089396, 0.0634152442, 0.6649632454, 0.0400061011, -0.4264839292, 0.9141159654, -0.4971149862, -0.246571824, -0.4333646595, -0.0557319969, 0.1601908058, 0.1841858774, 0.6942989826, -0.5276114941, -0.4025501907, 0.0565646105, -0.5442153811, -0.0024986216, 0.0510714985, -0.0820626318, 0.0118124755, 0.1716329157, -0.1459975094, 0.3056593537, 0.4649851918, -0.7583018541, 0.4619447589, -0.5360075831, 0.2256057709, -1.045489192, 0.1662250459, 0.3469039202, -0.6040202975, -0.8097794652, -0.32603845, -0.0282124784, -0.2479018569, -0.3205041289, 0.8702994585, -0.3065995574, -0.050046064, -0.4990591109, -0.3037206531, -0.2671089172, 0.4821807444, -0.0212470964, 0.743522346, 0.7713068724, -0.806221962, -0.0996438935, 0.2304891199, -0.2564630508, 0.381218195, -0.4170905352, -0.0031940283, 0.192453891, 0.1021862924, -1.0224910975, -0.004047147, 0.0917719156, -0.0212447625, 0.1901767254, -0.2229914963, -0.2069752812, -0.1171266884, -0.0480461642, 0.2208565027, 0.5292001367, -0.3824433982, 0.5680660009, 0.6813921928, -0.1975955814, -0.5226163864, -0.1083928272, -0.0590736903, -0.0917138979, -0.2403575033, 0.6352158189, -0.2807859182, -0.2021575868, 0.086784713, -0.1425998062, -0.1854960322, 0.2262779474, 0.7475096583, 0.5760217905, -0.0012826134, 0.2889769375, -0.1906134337, -0.1284125298, -0.255614996, -0.4762906432, 0.5309737325, -0.2809090614, -0.1710647047, -0.4062812626, 0.2892064154, 0.4898298979, 0.0865961835, 0.3968313336, 0.6032341123, -0.3444193602, -0.1966370493, -0.5029111505, -0.447503984, -0.4376647472, 0.3893622458, -0.2847658694, -1.4425176382, 0.4321810603, -0.0682609528, -0.0692632794, 0.3457642198, 0.4879261851, -0.32163468, 0.8370357752, 1.3250652552, -0.4195262492, 0.8012634516, -0.126595512, 0.1692122221, -0.5213556886, 0.1861753762, -0.3654956222, -0.2499510348, -0.3773359954, 0.1199372262, 0.0972714201, 0.0578380264, -0.1939074695, 0.5694198012, -0.1853581667, 0.2565104067, 0.4415881038, -0.0167715773, 0.4509975016, 0.3316907585, -0.0507534333, -0.1014623493, -0.3472547829, -0.7488899231, 1.1152000427, 0.1867021024, 0.8129028082, -0.1350907832, 0.3407286704, 0.8897254467, 0.1910915524, -0.5839474201, 0.4443617165, -0.582454145, -0.457467705, -0.310169667, 0.038872622, -1.0431792736, 0.1270069033, -0.2650122643, -0.932844162, 0.2085872293, 0.4437598884, -0.5054454803, 0.3660998642, -0.5214187503, 0.7244693041, 0.0781661645, -0.2484051734, -0.3067459464, -0.2648832202, 0.022659827, 0.1455820203, 0.2200150639, -0.1980511844, 0.216433689, 0.9159423113, -0.2127978802, 0.9976808429, -0.1945720315, 0.1989330798, 0.1787671447, 0.5298956633, 0.3790884614, -0.1421662271, -0.0805076957, 0.086104013, 0.0669765621, -0.1514407694, -0.4893884063, 1.113216877, -0.6441656351, -0.8431155682, -0.1000221968, -0.7693453431, -0.3780867159, 0.220350787, -0.3296258748, 0.4564802945, -0.4712075591, 0.2769210041, 0.2957890928, 0.3753501773, 0.3509815037, 0.6389514804, -0.4107760787, 0.1006712392, 0.8713297844, -0.1592372209, -0.2928090394, 0.2117601484, 0.1740270704, -0.2808415592, -0.533618331, -0.5167358518, 0.3359483778, -0.6062165499, 0.248875916, -1.0147066116, 0.3476391435, -0.2778903544, -0.1188503951, 0.029625129, -0.4637708962, -0.2892219722, -0.2629891932, 0.370664537, 1.1110447645, 0.2875297666, 0.4260931611, -0.5439255238, 0.0976249725, 0.2941759825, 0.4574893713, 0.0916766077, -0.5198296905, -0.4524984062, -0.1831605285, -0.2829817533, -0.8266303539, 0.5488101244, 0.1663467139, 0.7583842278, 0.280595988, -0.1602651477, 0.5261535048, -0.6448046565, 0.929166913, 0.058090426, -0.8091965318, 0.4033757448, -0.3539211452, 0.1124819592, 0.4841979146, 0.5726518035, -0.7148584127, -0.0917821079, -0.4597567916, -0.5391187072, 0.8868592978, -0.1043717489, 0.4412639439, 0.3330932558, 0.5135272741, 0.5121490359, -0.0083300127, -0.4602017105, -0.3847801387, -0.0573796034, -0.0125058768, -0.3766871393, -0.3778368831, 0.3012075126, -0.12649858, 0.7502313852, -0.0031996388, -0.0483408235, -0.1769828647, -0.2795524001, -0.2832510471, 0.3560746908, 0.3002764583, 0.7410520911, -0.1640162766, -0.138634786, 0.0918709114, -0.3504396081, 0.1682764143, 0.0669982582, -0.0588365905, -0.0605510771, 0.0158663727, 0.8098327518, 0.5833497047, -0.6647331119, 0.4534660876, -0.0947415531, 0.0895217285, -0.1055105701, 0.2218083143, 0.169411689, 0.179047823, 0.4172869623, 0.4189251363, 0.4792093635, -0.8073678613, 0.2864853442, 0.3723600209, -0.9378178716, -0.5952391028, 0.5374333262, 0.1335083544, -0.3949052095, 0.3437619209, 0.4538334608, -0.0821277127, 0.134695068, 0.751360774, 0.7829993367, -0.335811466, 0.0768986642, 0.2894399762, -0.2507482469, -0.3594054878, -0.0336901173, -0.5045709014, -0.7831994891, -0.0496942736, -0.6268719435, -0.4583058655, -0.1873191595, -0.7168889046, 0.3152604699, -0.1784082353, -0.3696922064, 0.0297805499, -0.3594514728, -1.0038795471, 0.0144292628, 0.1237968877, 0.3691186905, -0.9159215689, 0.9556117654, 1.0392216444, -0.3168250322, -0.3565984666, -0.1325702369, -0.0431495607, -0.5985959768, 0.7642951608, -0.0804075003, -0.502151072, -0.1153898686, -0.1221936494, -0.6233986616, 1.022546649, 0.4596779346, -0.5425531864, -0.175190866, -0.0957459435, 0.7629723549, -0.6986610293, 0.3190280795, 0.3448428214, 0.1183582619, 0.0437313654, -1.0168174505, 0.1659463048, -0.2994235754, 0.3416720927, 0.1105932295, 0.0377511047, 0.5080533624, -0.2605707347, -0.3590982854, 0.1172830537, 0.8117013574, 0.0142848566, 0.094952926, 0.6198980212, 0.0871636868, 0.6507319808, 0.1007634848, 1.3571555614, -0.2400631458, 0.142186299, 0.8287688494, -0.4133059084, 0.926225543, 0.3375914395, -0.3821784854, 0.7484636307, 0.3033286333, 0.2904448807, 0.4125833511, -0.0066223778, 0.0941221267, -0.4754712582, -0.2472880036, -0.1785084009, 0.1698743403, 0.2909032106, -0.4315525889, -0.2558222711, 0.1931453645, 0.0135838846, 0.3868544996, -0.1034037545, 0.8067355752, 0.0883022994, -0.7757185102, 0.4006691575, -0.1775807291, 0.9199761748, -0.5760182738, -0.2840181887, -0.0142405611, 0.1124016419, -0.0192297716, -0.6338299513, 0.2997600138, -0.1168151647, -0.6997397542, -0.6742933989, 1.2367873192, -0.3819561899, -0.3225564659, 0.4829386175, 0.7705178857, 0.0758842304, -0.0039464054, -0.3609233201, -0.1810651273, 0.1073031574, -0.0233039651, 0.4821387231, -0.2090939879, -0.3992342651, 0.8643532991, 0.7313806415, 0.0225177333, -0.3123951256, 0.1582951546, 0.5609954596, -0.8763932586, -0.6197007895, -0.828594327, 0.4190354645, 0.2122178823, -0.0667135268, 0.7401503325, 0.3073376119, 0.9000749588, -0.318873167, 0.9449568391, 0.2330436856, 0.6214258671, -0.0322936662, 0.8136712313, -0.4359546602, 0.4264066815, 0.0792943537, -0.7519825101, -0.3304997385, 0.048448123, -0.3235733807, 0.1584209502, 0.4046636224, 0.6496595144, -0.1622683853, 0.1634411067, 0.6233380437, -0.105319567, 0.2799954414, 0.230200395, 0.6798450351, -0.3345141411, 0.5790237784, -0.2022963166, -0.0387746207, -0.4821298122, -0.5308958292, -0.968170166, -1.0878036022, -0.1585881561, -0.1846721917, 0.3693621755, 0.8498189449, 0.9431787729, -1.0968472958, -0.7707427144, 0.2068929374, -0.1129570603, -0.5002161264, -0.1772405654, 0.2040727288, -0.143034324, -0.826551795, 0.632779479, 0.1795762181, 0.0456974767, -0.4861933589, -0.246771574, 0.1058242992, -0.1887731999, 0.4939594567, 0.4678284228, -1.0528203249, -0.1434976608, 0.1410516053, -0.0973475203, -0.0674397424, 1.2848120928, -1.0418214798, 0.5946639776, 0.4613477886, 0.4463655949, 0.6460740566, -0.13840729, 1.0591255426, -0.5350133777, -0.3190330565, -0.0362811126, 0.8146888614, 0.3858519793, -0.5142176151, 0.3509870768, 0.1195417866, -0.3782370985, -0.6203110814, 0.1019337624, -1.0128749609, -0.1937970519, 1.0724774599, -0.2108997107, 0.0020126491, -0.4552960396, -0.3445271552, 0.0996057242, -0.7275984287, 0.5796135068, 0.80852741, -0.1660642326, -0.0266578365, -0.5345693231, 0.4493873715, 0.4280886948, -0.3088269532, 0.1428026706, 0.4343387187, 0.3778776526, 0.0556463189, 0.586109221, 0.0266528744, 0.3118510842, -0.6749618649, 0.0630236939, -0.2823174596, -0.3832812309, -0.27026847, 0.2770425975, 0.2124022543, 0.1611390859 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.03749v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.03749v2
Memorization of Named Entities in Fine-tuned BERT Models
2022-12-07T16:20:50
2023-10-10T14:32:43
Andor Diera, Nicolas Lell, Aygul Garifullina, Ansgar Scherp
cs.CL
cs.CL
Privacy preserving deep learning is an emerging field in machine learning that aims to mitigate the privacy risks in the use of deep neural networks. One such risk is training data extraction from language models that have been trained on datasets, which contain personal and privacy sensitive information. In our study, we investigate the extent of named entity memorization in fine-tuned BERT models. We use single-label text classification as representative downstream task and employ three different fine-tuning setups in our experiments, including one with Differentially Privacy (DP). We create a large number of text samples from the fine-tuned BERT models utilizing a custom sequential sampling strategy with two prompting strategies. We search in these samples for named entities and check if they are also present in the fine-tuning datasets. We experiment with two benchmark datasets in the domains of emails and blogs. We show that the application of DP has a detrimental effect on the text generation capabilities of BERT. Furthermore, we show that a fine-tuned BERT does not generate more named entities specific to the fine-tuning dataset than a BERT model that is pre-trained only. This suggests that BERT is unlikely to emit personal or privacy sensitive named entities. Overall, our results are important to understand to what extent BERT-based services are prone to training data extraction attacks.
[ -0.4355195761, -0.8772716522, 0.2738810182, 0.0138776144, -0.2231796086, 0.066740185, -0.5071439147, -0.5971159935, -0.1447179615, 0.6789722443, -0.6113520861, -0.5887595415, -0.6730189919, -0.0602249578, -0.6209687591, 1.3942658901, 0.1958648562, -0.1384606659, 0.1183899194, 0.0375437513, -0.1073605716, -0.7013678551, -0.6952029467, 0.112560831, 0.777843833, 0.1969555616, 0.2840174735, 0.5195969939, 0.4858547747, 0.2774502039, -0.2603499591, 0.2661221325, -0.6170967221, 0.2600782216, -0.1516167223, -0.3067764044, -0.2318374962, -0.1111853197, 0.8239786625, 0.7379420996, 0.1218688712, 0.3584704399, 0.1618349701, 0.7754710913, -0.7954369783, 0.0937344581, -1.0520305634, -0.0272362698, -0.1521947235, -0.0774202347, -0.5398302674, -0.5210882425, 0.4674079716, -0.2809098363, 0.5326277018, -0.1035354063, 1.0143252611, 0.2853671908, -0.0961586609, -0.2180563211, -0.9087326527, 0.6982614398, -0.3675444722, 0.3960343897, 0.416328311, 0.106610097, -0.1033779904, -0.6870917082, -0.3948630691, -0.0720381811, 0.0013315401, -0.1688127965, -0.2505776882, 0.1700686961, 0.4127624631, 0.1465758234, -0.1109069884, 0.3933997452, -0.3143035471, -0.2550452948, 0.6721373796, -0.1209084392, -0.0702561662, 0.0889600143, -0.4743262231, 0.0020545966, -0.6291505098, 0.0700079128, 0.6472125053, 0.5043626428, 0.25959149, 0.2154200673, -0.05688316, 0.3425699472, 0.1258890182, 0.1334867328, -0.0379588753, 0.2306224406, -0.4916112721, 0.2759474218, 0.5523870587, 0.0920820236, 0.6238240004, -0.6012979746, -0.1020655856, -0.3433903158, 0.36365363, -0.8404537439, -0.6152397394, 0.0610652454, -0.4219074249, -0.2555799782, -0.0033442152, -0.4986225069, -0.4232388139, -0.3233102262, 0.2857567966, -0.6362086535, 0.0851448923, -0.0998432115, -0.0788639262, -0.2423760891, 0.2889571786, -1.2172596455, 0.4855696857, 0.712661922, 0.2138334662, -0.1629805267, -0.2925024033, -0.3020878136, 0.2444041073, -0.0691235811, 0.3742300272, -0.5197030306, -0.2659013569, 0.0355518535, 0.0673130751, -0.1231661811, -0.5443711877, 0.275071919, -0.8335639238, 0.0801311359, -0.2890152633, -0.934820056, -0.2493072301, 0.0855909809, -0.5820887685, 0.6141887307, -0.2290216833, -0.8141041398, 0.5749049187, -0.3154717386, -0.610308826, -0.0041548652, -0.1908584535, -0.8345251083, 0.2296681404, 0.1699378043, 0.8373284936, 0.1975595504, 0.2283437997, -0.3926791847, -0.2789409161, 0.3927051127, -0.4438830614, 0.7286501527, 0.247259438, -0.4182752967, -0.3798064888, -1.0849057436, 0.1917764395, -0.04787343, -0.4608259499, -0.6652417183, -0.0023865902, -0.2195128351, -0.1579632312, 0.2864960432, -0.5000309348, 0.0506923981, -0.2015552819, 0.3715483844, 0.9927720428, 0.3514958918, 0.5369954109, -0.1924526393, 0.0676822886, 0.192693904, -0.0337324366, -0.0290746819, -0.4324732721, -0.6863966584, -0.5582260489, 0.7608498335, 0.3229232132, -0.2285384536, 0.5693283081, -0.3054810166, -0.4494631588, -0.4228669703, 0.0384838395, 0.4897632897, 0.5138846636, 0.2152851224, -0.1311691403, -0.3571955264, -1.075075388, -0.5155091882, 0.0942964181, 0.0971759707, 0.7364007831, 0.4076999128, -0.1923875958, 0.8060089946, -0.2811419964, -0.3203468919, 0.2342418581, 0.1959469765, -0.1663654149, 0.6912719011, 0.5534656644, -0.8835175037, -0.4439568818, -0.4239714742, -0.3492925465, 0.2277794629, -0.356662631, -0.0782252476, 0.3000688255, 0.0750777796, -0.5763026476, 0.2670313716, 0.2457695007, 0.0711331144, 0.0228488687, -0.3315960467, -0.3272567391, -0.8447277546, 0.1442013383, -0.1176853478, -0.2446329892, -0.7035319209, -0.0685965642, 0.3190128207, -0.0879090652, -0.4571058154, 0.2741952837, -0.5275067091, -0.0378690362, -0.0563723594, -0.1378190666, -0.1630102098, 0.4968055487, 0.1066123098, 0.6119099855, 0.6953494549, -1.1662566662, -0.132821843, 0.3384552598, -0.4539584219, 0.0300867092, -0.2350947708, 0.4695735872, -0.1174765602, -0.1078169793, -0.6561676264, -0.0608402826, 0.1861098558, -0.4316158593, 0.7662235498, -0.0663883165, -0.6659417152, -0.0033460956, -0.1263339818, -0.0866099074, 0.5092634559, -0.6686237454, 0.0832314715, 0.5068539977, -0.1128768772, -0.7186671495, -0.7943249345, -0.1966121495, -0.2433784902, -0.2010541558, 0.3515052199, 0.0090824906, 0.037471287, -0.0558334514, -0.3827542365, -0.4760926068, 0.6120055318, 0.3606384695, -0.0170230661, 0.1345038712, 0.3349973261, 0.380869627, 0.089739114, 0.3258812129, -0.2717472613, 0.3170623481, 0.0385365225, -0.0916079208, -0.6085652113, 0.2400003821, 0.0665472001, -0.2432362735, 1.023678422, 0.5314166546, -0.5926111937, -0.4284490645, -0.511038363, -0.4229595661, -0.4524732828, 0.1727604419, -0.266036123, -0.8961971402, 0.6185730696, -0.1764564961, 0.1155198589, 0.1616444141, 0.3902209699, -0.366553843, 0.7447356582, 0.7879257202, -0.2818901241, 0.6324330568, -0.2058892101, 0.1989958584, -0.7615173459, -0.2762705088, -0.4695597887, -0.5520156026, -0.9809045792, 0.3461931348, -0.104111366, -0.0371805467, -0.1229503825, 0.4331053495, -0.686496973, 0.5107631683, 0.7284662127, 0.398087889, 0.127196148, 0.2849024236, -0.000383733, -0.0832305551, -0.3135214746, -0.6105887294, 1.1723841429, 0.510948956, 0.857213974, -0.0611544251, 1.357935071, 0.192663461, -0.0251360349, -0.2943445742, 0.6361111403, -0.472989887, -0.9638361335, -0.3234412968, -0.5889911652, -0.9842754006, -0.2134230733, -0.1053349301, -1.1590145826, 0.4151652157, 0.3277508318, -0.4855330586, 0.2535832822, -0.7767987251, 0.482578814, -0.2127258182, -0.342348963, -0.0324576274, -0.784520328, 0.2448161989, -0.2701672316, -0.2016240209, -0.2596856654, 0.1929076016, 0.6858365536, 0.1346018165, 0.9129920006, -0.430581212, -0.1768089086, 0.0038711822, 0.0737577528, 0.5343591571, 0.4243493676, 0.0564336963, 0.3213441968, -0.1627422422, -0.1236169189, -0.203546837, 0.8914716244, -0.7232071757, -0.4936375022, -0.1261753589, -0.420681268, -0.146576792, 0.5555173159, 0.4641546905, -0.0790958554, -0.1536337286, 0.4251456857, 1.2645089626, -0.2505173087, 0.4409368932, 0.7324227095, 0.3219231367, -0.0272686742, 0.8578022122, 0.3006366789, 0.1114427, 0.6139170527, -0.1269469708, -0.2138613909, -0.8256730437, -0.1461555958, -0.0055359094, -0.6469778419, -0.183919996, -0.7575756907, -0.3388994932, -0.4787252247, 0.3471516371, -0.4348556995, -0.5846857429, -0.7425091267, -0.0576996654, 0.2361442745, 0.2828314304, 0.0475782976, 0.1151331514, -0.8986803293, 0.3887011707, 0.3342530131, 0.5316906571, -0.2214144021, -0.2340658456, -0.0788345709, 0.1600477844, -0.2493989468, -0.6605213284, 0.1681186855, 0.5759509206, 0.5446996689, 0.3184586167, 0.344414562, 0.62577492, -0.703291893, 0.6441426873, -0.3031033278, -0.7934493423, 0.5858760476, -0.2250835896, -0.1022857949, 0.8181481957, 0.2976923585, -0.0736060515, -0.5859826803, -0.8878676295, -0.8594189286, 0.8497098088, 0.3305274546, 0.541205883, -0.1240119636, 0.57481426, 0.4258194566, 0.5974816084, -0.5630604029, -0.5813487768, 0.1962208599, 0.0073943157, 0.1074709743, -0.3504627943, -0.2189284116, -0.1726438403, 0.679895401, 0.3232665956, 0.4782319963, 0.0615158342, -0.1801608205, 0.0632791072, 0.2541851401, 0.506582737, 0.3009328842, -0.2899002135, -0.094417274, 0.0855674371, -0.517144382, -0.1899873912, 0.6058296561, -0.472677052, 0.172645539, -0.0238881018, 0.7946838737, 0.2840944827, -0.2617284954, 0.2360420972, -0.2008903623, -0.2671695352, -0.4545078576, 0.4643851221, -0.085240595, 0.2408738732, 0.1413468421, 0.1341294795, 0.3136147559, -0.2496233881, 0.2540423274, 0.5428703427, -0.0938811675, -0.2135596275, 0.7732962966, 0.0842066631, -0.2258846164, 0.8158392906, -0.0618202053, -0.2540592253, 0.5543209314, 0.3402883708, 1.0112740993, -0.080751054, -0.0065073404, 0.0513911732, 0.2620840073, 0.1120769978, 0.2711147666, -0.4521324337, -0.5536545515, 0.2673059404, -0.4701086879, -0.4170515537, 0.3843104541, -0.969329834, 0.0747752935, -0.6614522338, -0.3214772046, 0.3576455414, 0.0838857442, -0.8811021447, 0.3146039844, 0.6148815155, 0.707162261, -0.4038852751, 1.1321774721, 0.6322205067, -0.0238823686, -0.7352333069, 0.2362900823, -0.3285650313, -0.6526318192, 0.7538743615, 0.4090450406, 0.1289329529, 0.1082451418, -0.4422424436, -0.7028619647, 0.8916761279, 0.5750304461, -0.8176037669, -0.1090361252, 0.2645942569, 0.7172483206, -0.0084089115, -0.3862861991, 0.5117173791, 0.2735614479, -0.5195103884, -0.8082116246, -0.0784775615, 0.1061102524, 0.1094459444, 0.2857242227, -0.6563990712, 0.8394156098, -0.0889942646, -0.4794595242, 0.139040947, 0.4222132564, -0.0714695901, 0.2845963538, 0.2957363427, 0.5411502123, 1.1574339867, -0.1247222275, 0.8303597569, -0.2864974737, 0.5763986111, 1.1902066469, -0.2427639961, 0.5527995229, 0.4810801148, 0.1725461781, 0.2496776283, 0.5433146358, -0.2717503309, 1.0155718327, 0.2795737982, -0.1860825717, 0.0203380212, 0.1595040709, -0.3447256088, 0.3721910715, 0.2787026167, -0.9688786268, -0.0663738921, 0.0193427503, 0.0353211872, -0.017763691, -0.1462008208, 1.1487562656, 0.0510556176, -0.5632146001, 0.4928252399, -0.123050727, 0.2396605611, -0.4395236969, 0.3003281653, 0.0188670568, 0.6395516396, -0.0754543766, -0.49834162, 0.1754820645, 0.1016584113, -0.3244247437, -0.3856351674, 0.7394044995, -0.463946104, -0.23522605, 0.0823402107, 0.0779458806, 0.2343509495, -0.1128702015, -0.7046915293, -0.3603043258, 0.0552661903, -0.5710049272, 0.505869031, 0.5458207726, 0.1922002137, 0.6069556475, 0.4523311257, 0.0290556662, 0.35987553, 0.1702003777, 0.9300661683, -0.4854253232, -0.51582551, -1.126229763, 0.3080151081, -0.1696219444, -0.3038790226, 0.8225290179, 0.5379348993, 1.0452394485, -0.2659913599, 0.7629472017, 0.1134047955, 0.7756587863, -0.6581559181, 0.9636437893, -0.240266338, 0.5308591723, -0.102011621, -0.843944788, -0.1973534524, 0.3799095154, -0.2519054115, -0.0360404179, 0.4005324244, 0.4097193778, 0.0176353175, 0.1754561812, 0.1052372828, 0.0151670184, 0.3468021154, 0.3800284564, 0.5687689781, -0.4006452858, 0.4155062437, -0.8345972896, 0.2222474068, -0.074559629, -0.8359488249, -1.3106956482, -0.4465478063, -0.4170182049, 0.0081808362, 0.2894017994, 0.4022328854, 0.8032848835, -0.996183455, 0.5121452212, -0.2761470079, 0.0144140134, -0.0942109227, -0.1777674109, 0.3787162006, -0.3919060528, -0.8562325835, 0.1235010624, -0.0590706952, 0.3263213038, -0.0148819517, 0.3443114161, 0.126339823, -0.1346960515, 0.1499053836, 0.3121335208, -0.644539237, -0.412604332, 0.033392366, -0.2080351263, -0.1585875303, 0.6128593087, -0.6888306141, 0.4747874737, 0.1345116347, 0.9022037387, 0.5224091411, -0.0029696457, 0.2749624848, -1.422126174, 0.1519411653, 0.4477751255, 0.2451820374, 0.2422996312, -0.8665312529, 0.057906244, -0.2509533167, -0.7307974696, -0.8104090691, 0.1293220073, -0.6971304417, -0.1967887878, 0.9529846907, -0.5098389983, -0.078240864, 0.1642101258, 0.0283187404, 0.4558419287, -0.5767927766, 1.1957051754, 0.675567925, -0.0405140445, 0.0102501297, -0.3547673821, 0.711535275, 0.3956578076, -0.5453202128, 0.2834747732, 0.2067822218, 0.4155831933, 0.1127479076, 0.3353116214, 0.1250252575, 0.1972734183, -0.3624729216, -0.3204460144, -0.2108438164, -0.56592381, -0.4278025329, 0.0263691247, -0.1476534456, -0.7407883406 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.03747v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.03747v1
Harnessing Knowledge and Reasoning for Human-Like Natural Language Generation: A Brief Review
2022-12-07T16:18:19
2022-12-07T16:18:19
Jiangjie Chen, Yanghua Xiao
cs.CL
cs.CL
The rapid development and application of natural language generation (NLG) techniques has revolutionized the field of automatic text production. However, these techniques are still limited in their ability to produce human-like text that is truly reasonable and informative. In this paper, we explore the importance of NLG being guided by knowledge, in order to convey human-like reasoning through language generation. We propose ten goals for intelligent NLG systems to pursue, and briefly review the achievement of NLG techniques guided by knowledge and reasoning. We also conclude by envisioning future directions and challenges in the pursuit of these goals.
[ -0.5109455585, -0.7584338784, 0.661379993, 0.0006341389, -0.1137793511, 0.0802954435, -0.2401145697, -0.591445148, 0.0187001005, 0.8596716523, -0.7227902412, -0.430552721, -0.3289038241, 0.486759454, -0.4638659954, 0.9062114358, 0.3860182166, -0.3110252321, -0.1501520127, 0.2624254525, -0.5509625077, -0.4087626338, -0.82504493, -0.6299168468, 0.3538720906, 0.3806820512, 0.7724719048, 0.8028582335, 0.2604466081, 0.2492031157, 0.0214378014, 0.5585089326, -0.0549662597, 0.4033901095, -0.1802573055, -0.6120608449, -0.1548596472, 0.0643005744, 0.4968692362, 0.8105816245, 0.0447015353, -0.0392347127, 0.0955774263, 0.8553424478, -0.1660674363, -0.2254543006, -0.5107713938, 0.1710633188, -0.2490573376, -0.4180576801, -0.2495739013, -0.739138186, 0.3043223619, -0.788230598, 0.359026432, 0.6648671031, 0.6988936067, 0.2370076627, -0.4671499431, -0.7819407582, -0.7633492351, 1.0076342821, -0.9653317928, 0.1694139987, 0.3894408941, 0.2707515061, -0.5088878274, -0.7120006084, -0.678407371, -0.1834111065, -0.0404572748, 0.1099725887, 0.0375803001, 0.106606245, 0.2977711558, 0.1685720384, -0.6465120316, -0.1942671388, -0.2955825925, -0.1351736635, 0.9329810143, 0.0691342503, 0.5279453397, -0.3316670656, -0.5076751709, 0.0374570526, -0.6993792057, -0.1368451416, 0.6201074719, 0.0725550652, 0.5104251504, 0.4414564669, -0.586810112, 1.0611897707, -0.0335979387, -0.2470111847, -0.1861571968, -0.3535583913, -0.0344857164, 0.4029913843, 0.7311611772, 0.4311105907, 0.6873990893, -0.3288514018, -0.1816111654, 0.007938399, 0.5134400725, -0.3361166418, -0.1289443374, -0.0527097583, -0.2816410661, -0.4899643064, 0.0322871581, -0.6818092465, -0.3533402979, -0.6959061623, 0.0375637412, -0.6761187911, -0.161292851, 0.3277322352, -0.5037309527, 0.3666673303, 0.5175606608, -1.2988644838, 0.1622145176, 0.7015230656, 0.2572427988, 0.0034225744, -0.1334632486, -0.0629856214, 0.4380259812, -0.5098170042, 1.0434068441, -0.1652499884, -0.0995314494, -0.0793703943, -0.5554878116, 0.1076568067, -0.4719771147, 0.6342942119, -0.2276336849, 0.5844492912, -0.4688698947, -0.6936777234, -0.412299782, 0.4643462598, -0.2585202456, 0.7473846674, -0.1451849341, -0.6308647394, 0.5411759019, -0.6609382033, -0.7440347672, 0.3674889505, -0.262642622, 0.0688976124, 0.0437906012, 0.1476376504, 0.4236683846, -0.7956341505, 0.5108457208, 0.156818077, -0.0692351237, 0.0954671651, -0.1539022774, 0.7930706739, 0.3819841743, -0.5123204589, -0.1460603178, -0.8561461568, 0.3799732924, 0.0908105597, -0.557045579, -0.1358146071, 0.2920112014, -0.2001181394, 0.0831054822, 0.1270583868, -0.4264791906, 0.2058595717, -0.4563450217, 0.4099338949, 0.3844100535, 0.0617052205, 0.7475894094, -0.5040450096, 0.5116567016, -0.5230638981, 0.0779612362, -0.1219707727, -0.756845355, -0.7118729353, 0.5191065669, 0.1123650819, 0.5647109747, -0.8395843506, 0.7437521815, 0.1370384693, -0.5346881151, -0.3793550134, 0.2760329247, 0.1740855128, 0.7751248479, 0.2514735758, -0.0443881713, -0.7369630933, -0.7726119757, -0.624058187, -0.1964329928, -0.1876851469, 0.0381156132, 0.0179131068, -0.192523405, 1.0882334709, -0.4322175086, -0.312133491, -0.6246029735, 0.3284915984, -0.0087201241, 0.4979172349, 0.4934015572, -0.8983553648, -0.4048705399, 0.1553441137, -1.1607221365, -0.2567170858, -0.2932483256, -0.2550398707, 0.0849850997, 0.8203419447, -0.5357627273, 0.2535325587, 0.1564794481, -0.1533469707, 0.7435102463, -0.1833950877, 0.000853501, -0.8500117064, -0.006882722, 0.0102188941, -0.2268622071, -1.0811685324, -0.2242980897, -0.3400555253, -0.1001470536, -0.1554446816, 0.758028388, -0.3704226315, 0.2266556621, -0.4918942153, 0.4500691295, 0.1871904433, 0.2977828681, 0.1475412399, 0.3740410507, 0.3481940031, -0.8134887815, 0.6950613856, 0.2287788391, -0.2617675662, 0.5637793541, -0.5649704933, 0.017907491, -0.1386739463, 0.0819803104, -0.3310254514, -0.4333583415, 0.1887061745, -0.5444397926, 0.1656996608, 0.4191950262, -0.6296339035, -0.4856310785, 0.0770259872, -0.0854961276, 0.6897912025, -0.3238470256, 0.3960959911, 0.246185407, -0.1555134058, -0.2863385677, -0.6915626526, 0.2651008964, -0.4101985693, -0.7510617971, 0.1778343916, 0.1231963038, -0.4797507823, -0.0549925677, 0.1051124856, 0.3694338799, -0.0305848122, -0.1748786867, -0.122015819, -0.0716942102, 0.4028573036, 0.1171049699, -0.2403741628, 0.245325312, -0.7704054713, 0.4024161696, -0.1165455282, -0.1509220898, -0.1318032295, 0.5671178699, 0.0211645886, -0.2225899547, 0.356187582, 0.7985903621, -0.3684355319, -0.4186832309, -0.6289103031, -0.3385040164, -0.4614155293, 0.1033108458, 0.0303353984, -0.7872311473, 0.078924641, -0.4130687118, 0.1445815414, 0.4771955311, 0.2759667635, -0.5099306107, 1.0555773973, 0.5819177032, 0.536847651, 0.27826792, 0.1191185564, 0.4173757136, -0.6493853927, -0.2762770653, -0.3581371903, -0.3252183795, -0.5540056229, 0.1093223542, 0.1880215257, 0.5774128437, -0.0845602602, 0.2864460349, -0.8626167774, 0.254243046, 1.0547391176, -0.2189193964, 0.3659928143, -0.2058943957, -0.1953392327, 0.0173546094, -1.0735442638, -0.9751344919, 0.6982933283, -0.1465400755, 0.4608187079, -0.2003035545, 0.8314103484, 0.3699969649, 0.0921821594, -0.5396765471, 0.7552332282, 0.0354928896, -0.8493457437, -0.4754966795, -0.2716917992, -0.8642251492, -0.2268220037, -0.4106790423, -0.5545479655, -0.2124424577, 0.2700382769, -0.2955186069, 0.2477516681, -0.77767694, 0.515058279, -0.3341880143, 0.0872162506, -0.0224226192, -0.9591311812, 0.4253185987, 0.1309926659, 0.1744013578, -0.1038486809, 0.2465704829, 0.8568124771, -0.3060269952, 0.5472733974, -0.0711918995, 0.0940987691, 0.9170240164, -0.1685668081, 0.2457433939, -0.2998403311, 0.0122206854, -0.4515606165, -0.4674522281, -0.2775029838, -0.6165291071, 0.4338917732, -0.3752998412, -0.9482375979, -0.1432806551, -0.5831807852, -0.1407351792, 0.4665854275, 0.4333468676, 0.2324393094, -0.0592958368, 0.1467386782, 0.8967820406, -0.4421981275, 0.6276878715, -0.2079407275, -0.4217233658, -0.3152968884, 1.0385786295, -0.0407971516, 0.4583335817, 0.3995520473, 0.4652061462, -0.4857999384, -0.4264701307, -0.7084633112, 0.1196925715, -0.584028542, -0.2740016878, -0.5641466975, -0.1467461139, -0.5341948271, -0.448745966, -0.014909761, -0.457051456, -0.5676575899, -0.0912551284, 0.4792279899, 1.1680395603, -0.1470088214, 0.2519316673, -0.7729984522, 0.4050978124, 0.8032802939, 0.0302533209, -0.0041399319, 0.0274582393, -0.109891355, 0.1418894678, -0.50043118, -0.7605993152, 0.4271093309, 0.1822299212, 0.4459735155, 0.4409732819, 0.1157424673, 0.2776713073, -0.5204640627, 0.6921405792, 0.4363960326, -0.8402400613, 1.0359749794, -0.5306500196, 0.4405469, 0.3198699951, 0.1796555966, -0.7959192395, -0.4742811918, -0.7631186247, -0.6412483454, 0.6456931829, 0.2108637094, -0.1464838088, -0.2371734083, 0.4094025195, 0.1292027831, 0.1620909572, -0.4481881857, 0.0127359182, -0.3314595222, -0.0516789556, 0.2532626688, 0.1682686955, -0.0630208179, 0.05642372, 0.7171066999, -0.3730806708, 0.068149589, 0.3284547627, 0.1405158192, -0.02247498, 0.5321891308, 0.6858547926, 0.336889118, 0.1664767116, 0.0338683873, 0.1127445772, -0.1240294054, 0.1088573337, -0.1918402165, -0.5168265104, -0.1912266761, 0.2938742042, 0.7094518542, -0.1373503804, -0.7078008652, 0.1270264089, 0.121184729, -0.5347971916, -0.2458548099, 0.6121510267, 0.3506042659, 0.2518253624, 0.7813580036, 0.3977202773, -0.1294689327, -0.5170209408, 0.1222364306, 0.3509522378, -0.3850393891, -0.1139546335, 0.9010916352, 0.2588189244, -0.7021605372, 0.5336165428, -0.5211452842, -0.5113592148, 0.4545930624, 0.6424869895, 0.5814845562, 0.1552747786, 0.0321926661, 0.2707751691, 0.3235437572, -0.3999403417, 0.289806813, -0.1597939879, -0.7917137742, -0.4481844306, -0.663525641, -0.3232232928, -0.2769770026, -0.3209592104, 0.2220416814, -0.4655255973, -0.2883495688, -0.1730879247, 0.0761033297, -0.4826105535, 0.6591616273, 0.173668623, 0.8112324476, -0.4342902303, 0.6018141508, 0.7361789942, -0.1882286072, -0.9573469758, -0.2426128983, -0.0201052018, -0.4631033242, 0.5665705204, 0.1073799357, -0.1451227665, 0.3957738876, -0.7120034099, -0.3982627392, 1.1951168776, 0.299579829, -0.2819842696, -0.3756457865, 0.3033444285, 0.5808295012, -0.3404628634, -0.3054006696, 0.6636832952, 0.8887059689, -0.0786089078, -0.5602041483, -0.1380744129, -0.1202417761, -0.0527075566, 0.2437624484, -0.3360920548, 0.4020950794, -0.2782329023, -0.2882790565, -0.1008151621, 0.8466585875, 0.4158325791, 0.1037353948, 0.3819055259, 0.5701816082, 0.671292901, -0.3047512472, 1.1350260973, 0.1179571152, -0.166711688, 0.5645941496, 0.0050239735, 0.2175043076, 0.3358727098, 0.0372818895, 0.3903797865, 0.1783925742, 0.0987991914, 0.1365303546, 0.1964837909, -0.3749593496, -0.4329001904, -0.4048008025, -0.205811739, 0.5900278091, 0.3524418473, -0.320268482, -0.1012853384, 0.0705653876, -0.0412789546, 0.6093203425, -0.1915164292, 0.960521996, 0.1122839004, -0.9981957674, 0.2958126664, -0.1910506934, 0.7136537433, -0.4633440971, -0.1390836686, 0.0961760804, -0.2144026011, -0.1796563268, -0.7492609024, 0.5451008081, 0.091444917, -0.1382133514, -0.8287370801, 1.2710177898, -0.4140845239, -0.1877544075, 0.0389428325, 0.6809008718, 0.0958143547, -0.0556679629, -0.367464155, -0.4850288332, 0.4628741741, -0.2964476049, 0.2440701276, 0.8339210749, 0.0342476033, 0.894426465, 0.732606411, 0.3072351813, 0.3604430556, 0.0181632377, 0.4154921174, -1.0917998552, -0.2984361351, -0.6212260723, 0.3530547619, -0.088488251, -0.3451807201, 0.6409283876, 0.1046066135, 0.6932928562, -0.0155120324, 1.0362491608, -0.3678138256, 0.7552492619, -0.3857860565, 0.9003130198, -0.1158866584, -0.1086400747, -0.0347926281, -0.8719050884, -0.6600028872, 0.506198585, -0.2292444557, -0.0607627034, 0.487608552, 0.4309092164, 0.4700610638, 0.3469349444, 0.4257880747, -0.4077287316, 0.5028866529, 0.3505881727, 0.8683348894, -0.2735147178, 0.6695439816, -0.2235702574, -0.0952618495, 0.0849660188, -0.9012182355, -0.8355495334, -0.4700545073, -0.0564362295, 0.1852758378, -0.0205003582, 0.9120286107, 0.633130312, -0.4865309, -0.1533376426, -0.7977786064, 0.1644427478, -0.0880143717, -0.2900900245, 0.0174145568, -0.5307898521, -0.7056236863, 0.3247522712, 0.4553900659, 0.0767072365, -0.3691540658, -0.2041852623, -0.4836883545, -0.0278620236, 0.6612459421, 0.4890930057, -0.6899636388, -0.4528684914, 0.1258119345, -0.1800798625, -0.1722136736, 0.8919634223, -1.0531461239, 0.3360502422, 0.4772735536, 0.6323540807, 0.0988901928, 0.069651559, 1.0097366571, -0.79492414, -0.1781046093, 0.6606515646, -0.0062207612, 0.5371185541, -0.2316809446, 0.4170031846, 0.0828796104, -0.82537359, -0.3772983849, 0.4857971072, -0.5608657002, -0.1037682667, 1.0524978638, 0.1644438058, 0.0003318753, -0.4574449956, -0.4674706161, 0.6050431728, -0.366514951, 0.7303808928, 0.589169383, -0.5577662587, -0.282009691, -0.5520418286, 0.9315192103, 0.3859662712, -1.2752766609, 0.007290767, 0.3430598676, -0.3125287592, 0.4813121855, 0.4801643491, 0.0908902287, 0.1969431192, 0.0338673852, 0.2229056805, 0.1617252827, -0.2444622368, 0.2693007588, 0.1399322748, 0.0854234397, 0.2910658121 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.03657v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.03657v1
M3ST: Mix at Three Levels for Speech Translation
2022-12-07T14:22:00
2022-12-07T14:22:00
Xuxin Cheng, Qianqian Dong, Fengpeng Yue, Tom Ko, Mingxuan Wang, Yuexian Zou
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
How to solve the data scarcity problem for end-to-end speech-to-text translation (ST)? It's well known that data augmentation is an efficient method to improve performance for many tasks by enlarging the dataset. In this paper, we propose Mix at three levels for Speech Translation (M^3ST) method to increase the diversity of the augmented training corpus. Specifically, we conduct two phases of fine-tuning based on a pre-trained model using external machine translation (MT) data. In the first stage of fine-tuning, we mix the training corpus at three levels, including word level, sentence level and frame level, and fine-tune the entire model with mixed data. At the second stage of fine-tuning, we take both original speech sequences and original text sequences in parallel into the model to fine-tune the network, and use Jensen-Shannon divergence to regularize their outputs. Experiments on MuST-C speech translation benchmark and analysis show that M^3ST outperforms current strong baselines and achieves state-of-the-art results on eight directions with an average BLEU of 29.9.
[ -0.7654612064, -0.7210476398, 0.0655653924, 0.2226041555, -0.691612184, 0.1769881397, -0.2209240496, -0.5798761249, 0.0327027738, 0.550186336, -0.6288769245, -0.4861771166, -0.7325940132, 0.3086903393, -0.3697560132, 0.9411324859, -0.1298658103, 0.2466372699, 0.2955064774, -0.2394968271, -0.6988561749, -0.4435213804, -0.7364515066, -0.0708221644, 0.3782922328, 0.8797933459, 0.8008766174, 0.8111122847, 0.4599546194, 0.2399475724, -0.3836413026, 0.6556120515, -0.6628796458, 0.2733272314, 0.0342865475, -0.2466456443, -0.5548629165, -0.0935251489, 0.991681695, 0.6541611552, 0.0413186699, -0.0194561929, 0.4289752543, 0.729978025, -0.4373617768, -0.2847212851, -0.5704227686, -0.0429705381, -0.3887054324, -0.2582573295, -0.0147972787, -0.0431983471, -0.0363941826, -0.3438498676, 0.1275538206, 0.1821624339, 0.4795903862, 0.3819157183, -0.4378952682, 0.1832718104, -0.9135524035, 0.7274367809, -0.7483995557, 0.4574079514, 0.4638814032, 0.2734238207, -0.1444846839, -0.2380988449, -0.804174304, -0.0292338803, 0.3843550384, 0.0552088507, -0.0991767794, 0.0426976532, 0.1001330763, 0.6770405769, -0.5625260472, 0.1387077123, -0.5786235332, 0.0881367624, 0.4601204693, 0.1351391226, 0.1433029771, 0.1131413057, -0.3121625483, -0.227342993, -0.6537696719, -0.3464986384, 0.5449153185, 0.5291544199, -0.0460387021, 0.9708229303, -0.4761350453, 0.7714921832, -0.1214249358, 0.0273535512, 0.5218800902, -0.7765539289, -0.3092098832, 0.1509327292, 0.56186831, 0.2810759544, 0.1204945967, 0.1655951142, -0.2827751338, -0.4204169214, 0.0165508911, -0.728592217, 0.0969155058, 0.3215419948, -0.0978607163, -0.1678024828, -0.3877224624, -0.3496985137, -0.1922951192, -0.6514739394, 0.528023839, -0.7343019247, -0.3394013047, 0.1084576845, 0.1227738485, -0.0396950133, 0.1875441521, -0.9928278327, 0.3897670209, 0.6403025985, 1.0983400345, -0.2623983324, -0.4173224568, -0.6295736432, 0.1664685905, -0.3925615251, 0.5792071223, -0.2427363694, -0.3532352448, -0.3613858223, -0.37337026, -0.0333988369, -0.716522336, 0.815931499, -0.072055079, 0.2900415957, 0.1215448156, -0.6165856123, -0.0817766488, 0.0302661583, -0.4890577495, 1.1410168409, 0.2584095299, -0.6297947168, 0.4026559889, -0.5940209627, -0.5621033907, 0.0126555627, 0.1094068736, -0.4477160871, 0.0841173306, 0.6453099847, 0.4179954827, -0.1433913857, 0.2232449949, -0.2162185162, -0.5494698286, 0.0568058379, -0.5072496533, 0.6446169019, 0.4496381581, -0.1446844339, 0.3543060124, -0.8038476706, -0.203122437, -0.3518235385, -0.3709327877, -0.1700975299, -0.123239167, 0.2499188483, 0.3701738715, 0.091174297, -0.4964346588, -0.1464931071, -0.6313891411, 0.3688121736, 0.5278225541, -0.0045541259, 0.4259160459, -0.5133612752, 0.2368366867, 0.3702190518, 0.0407971963, -0.0529992096, -0.5727015138, -0.8488240242, -0.4337455928, 0.4120063484, 0.7488647699, -0.7044333816, 0.5700102448, -0.4299912751, -0.4071370661, -1.1630885601, 0.2299841046, 0.0377590768, 0.5199764967, 0.9523459673, 0.0519231223, -0.7716414332, -0.9991854429, -0.1777707338, 0.271707803, -0.295303762, 0.1158877909, 0.301127404, -0.3363482952, 0.65285182, 0.0375003442, -0.4469203949, -0.3550459445, 0.0949836373, 0.3903027475, 0.9588506222, -0.0072732018, -0.6648825407, -0.2000343949, 0.2741052806, -0.3288522363, 0.0179321803, 0.0482336879, -0.1237861961, 0.0531162433, 0.3581661284, -0.2988848686, -0.0019733068, 0.5762878656, -0.0186548568, 0.1628345549, -0.0771486312, 0.231952101, -1.4438765049, -0.1503035128, -0.2141520083, -0.4808181524, -0.7904604077, -0.0774803236, 0.1033803001, -0.3380237222, -0.6411719322, 0.2147674859, -0.2582595348, -0.0934234113, -0.4679473042, 0.2956498265, -0.2348056138, 0.413049221, -0.2745110393, 1.0178580284, 0.4323619902, -0.7364522219, 0.2776470482, 0.2311609387, -0.2697787881, 0.5903809667, -0.5400073528, 0.0225186292, 0.0188692827, 0.1472695023, -0.8749864101, -0.1583605707, 0.3276796639, -0.6087443233, 0.3655611277, -0.1230708361, -0.7462866306, -0.247541979, 0.0156052392, 0.4114454687, 0.3205658495, -0.4271547794, 0.2947227955, 0.3699218929, -0.3835406899, -0.4864220619, -0.7681661844, 0.3160217106, -0.303622216, -0.9184866548, 0.4638231099, -0.2134607136, 0.1588775218, -0.2554553449, -0.2284535319, 0.0432688817, -0.0474101864, -0.141357109, 0.0121440943, -0.2212171257, -0.3546482623, 0.3882243037, -0.206181705, -0.3550287187, -0.5733155012, 0.5206785202, -0.0915310085, -0.2818238139, -0.4534229338, 0.6616412401, 0.3433190286, 0.0938082188, 0.5436418056, 1.0013487339, -0.4691213965, 0.2455431074, -0.4800724387, 0.0641894788, -0.4423768222, 0.4682869613, -0.6607975364, -1.2556005716, 0.311021775, 0.2159060985, 0.1604488194, 0.5477519035, 0.6088871956, -0.1553735882, 1.3524160385, 0.37378034, -0.0466592424, 0.5225369334, -0.1153051853, -0.0576629043, -1.09973979, 0.0454103053, -0.3694833219, -0.5257343054, -0.7408382297, -0.5705395341, 0.3811558187, 0.4138570726, -0.2205460072, 0.4402536452, -0.2453809679, 0.5049145818, 0.6398953795, 0.1429847181, 0.287634939, 0.2053522766, -0.0170779172, 0.0240238048, -0.564931035, -0.22984308, 0.983669579, 0.4485803545, 0.2134500742, 0.3445525765, 0.8574700952, -0.0080777733, 0.0327416435, -0.630456388, 0.3058959246, -0.2572940886, -0.3882792592, -0.3532838523, -0.7151371837, -0.6882648468, 0.6954520345, -0.2997772992, -0.3062315285, 0.2469672412, 0.0143511975, -0.1313356012, 0.152287662, -0.596010983, 0.5431094766, 0.0731892884, -0.3391650617, -0.2831515074, -0.8831784725, 0.4446572065, -0.1278459132, 0.2642639279, -0.2096303403, 0.0321829319, 0.8485170007, -0.4705118835, 0.3484108746, -0.0218881294, -0.1557794511, 0.0137085728, -0.0388282947, 0.5885148048, 0.0133729698, -0.0516863875, 0.1138594598, -0.1908557266, -0.6529693007, -0.3776429594, 0.5469807386, -0.9145909548, -0.3835679591, -0.0612173751, -0.7338559628, -0.5465590954, 0.2670639753, 0.3884732127, 0.4263568223, 0.0390406661, 0.3943439424, 0.651270926, 0.1962065101, 0.2909394205, 0.2600949407, -0.0733622238, -0.9117034674, 1.0585654974, 0.0052088839, 0.4503105581, 0.3850305676, 0.1389324665, -0.3205806911, -1.0298153162, -0.7908391356, -0.054248292, -0.5052213669, -0.261146158, -0.7878530025, -0.2438203394, -0.4507441521, 0.0707600191, -0.5257777572, -0.6090877652, -0.5086556673, -0.0600922555, 0.3868865669, 0.4718685448, -0.4315407276, 0.8251607418, -0.8384144306, 0.4475383461, -0.0585993566, 0.3491043448, -0.5516760349, -0.938151598, -0.63207829, 0.4371724129, -0.1597335637, -0.7518211603, 0.5073898435, 0.1517953277, 0.3164211214, 0.194088906, -0.39918378, 0.9840899706, -0.4374787807, 0.6097885966, 0.2104225606, -0.9806268811, 0.4368418157, -0.6574727893, 0.3040770292, 0.7949015498, 0.0655129924, -0.5287065506, -0.5872514248, -0.5256722569, -1.166626215, 0.6994105577, 0.6991301775, 0.0286362432, 0.1744285077, -0.1218637899, 0.0072805006, 0.1814842075, -0.4821887016, -0.3141658008, -0.2262094617, -0.2245978117, -0.3825366199, -0.1571614444, -0.0977611765, -0.393751651, 0.7214660048, 0.1576038748, 0.081478931, 0.0698407292, -0.1278587878, -0.0326155759, 0.47336936, 0.959659636, 0.3828159869, -0.5935361385, 0.1958334446, 0.4417663217, -0.4971317053, 0.1281266361, 0.3280806243, 0.2210829109, -0.0191811211, 0.007964422, 1.110018611, 0.1914766431, -0.2549959421, 0.3449441791, 0.1128547192, -0.5100871921, 0.0574644729, 0.0221026763, -0.0051398058, 0.1599651873, 0.384624511, 0.5124022365, 0.2822127938, -0.0895227045, 0.3330594897, -0.0241159294, -0.3363254368, 0.2628396153, 0.5582972765, 0.2948474884, -0.1374489069, 0.4864181876, -0.2535484731, -0.2627873421, 0.2072233558, 0.7442336082, 0.8390825987, -0.2932065129, -0.2094917148, 0.1842676401, 0.5867115259, -0.1315908432, 0.5146464109, -0.1119062677, -0.4434243441, -0.8131912947, -0.5620154738, -0.493188858, 0.1987438053, -0.4033775926, 0.403131336, -0.0258491561, 0.0805633888, -0.324809134, -0.0496575795, -0.5025326014, 0.2551713884, 0.2345135808, 0.7423774004, -0.5602163076, 0.8252266645, 0.1332399696, -0.3542007506, -0.5853694677, -0.2057468444, -0.1676897258, -0.657351613, 0.3017935157, 0.0564126, -0.3293935955, 0.3915095031, -0.4572085142, -1.0714610815, 0.8595333695, 0.1607421637, -0.6775921583, 0.37558043, 0.2630730271, 0.3370503485, -0.6007401347, 0.0696629211, 0.6511836052, 0.3382374048, 0.2229320854, -0.7920253873, -0.2378939837, -0.4025604129, 0.0783398002, 0.1448454261, -0.0282884836, 0.8556775451, -0.0268263202, -0.2004029155, -0.1034888402, 1.0659151077, 0.3531836271, 0.0772690251, 0.5781160593, 0.5494445562, 0.6299761534, 0.0637012199, 0.7584249973, -0.2009557486, 0.0481200963, 1.2831972837, -0.0617543645, 1.0654941797, 0.4314929247, -0.0431789421, -0.076900512, 0.9104869366, 0.1102416962, 0.4501313567, 0.3082045019, -0.3650213182, 0.0320492201, 0.0033328685, -0.6721709371, 0.2183670551, 0.6148828268, -0.0646447837, -0.0406797118, 0.3045417368, -0.0663909316, -0.385648936, -0.2736359835, 0.7688742876, 0.0235462356, -0.3347385824, 1.0111572742, 0.1983324438, 0.5918284059, -0.2156607658, 0.1592526883, -0.3954493701, 0.005805579, -0.2059526592, -0.9098525047, 0.4721314013, -0.0886855945, -0.1361674517, -0.2133162171, 0.3097809851, -0.7864788175, -0.3560929596, 0.0148031833, 0.6520437598, 0.2913224995, -0.2533275783, -0.5937071443, -0.0244213268, 0.0873750746, 0.052136343, 0.2025772929, 0.4866580963, 0.1591020972, 0.5127223134, 0.9080075026, 0.2355473787, 0.1693746448, 0.3283695877, 0.8577457666, -0.4707423151, -0.6124247909, -0.9469235539, 0.4470371902, -0.1112386212, -0.435064882, 0.5308078527, 0.782658577, 0.9390876293, 0.1916246116, 0.7189723253, 0.2672730684, 0.7340397239, -0.5845034122, 0.2876242995, -0.4874333441, 0.254986167, -0.2960805297, -1.0766465664, -0.4387481511, 0.3438392878, 0.0154548604, 0.0061486191, 0.6783750057, 0.7661387324, -0.3222889602, 0.3431510031, 0.4010939896, 0.0303645488, 0.1204731539, 0.321057409, 0.8380156159, -0.5862516165, 0.7417020202, -0.2367320359, -0.2397161573, -0.3858427107, -0.4175171256, -0.5361372828, -0.5067616701, -0.062952511, -0.4315766394, 0.0502913333, 1.1009807587, 0.7858144641, -0.654261291, -0.2940771282, -0.3096725941, 0.0924573913, -0.3993211687, -0.1504993588, 0.1391042173, -0.4163482487, -0.7791294456, 0.9424132109, 0.2694861293, 0.4844514132, 0.0328163616, -0.0643352047, -0.2820278406, -0.1537796855, 0.659711659, -0.1108635589, -0.470480442, -0.0317299031, -0.2372628301, -0.0303824246, 0.2953505218, 0.8603700399, -0.4006696641, 0.4623527825, 0.5073451996, 0.7697790861, 0.7926195264, 0.0882366225, 0.7534928322, -1.08763659, 0.0604960434, 0.2793157697, 0.3774861693, 0.5972064734, -0.1415032893, 0.4908289909, 0.1523501426, -0.5516427159, -0.7275590301, 0.1843304485, -1.0587383509, -0.077690199, 1.0523570776, 0.4221465886, 0.0925828069, -0.3007833064, -0.4450045526, 0.6768831611, -0.542257309, 0.2853145599, 0.6125484705, -0.2237626165, -0.245230034, -0.9542184472, 0.5948528051, 0.6583735943, -0.7390658855, 0.0519560128, 0.454108119, 0.008079892, -0.1868855655, 0.5803725123, 0.0002102343, -0.0754117668, -0.0982080847, -0.2355584055, -0.158010006, -0.3117222786, -0.4235887527, -0.1349810064, -0.1267720312, -0.5100502372 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.03613v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.03613v3
G-MAP: General Memory-Augmented Pre-trained Language Model for Domain Tasks
2022-12-07T13:07:24
2024-02-17T19:31:47
Zhongwei Wan, Yichun Yin, Wei Zhang, Jiaxin Shi, Lifeng Shang, Guangyong Chen, Xin Jiang, Qun Liu
cs.CL
cs.CL
Recently, domain-specific PLMs have been proposed to boost the task performance of specific domains (e.g., biomedical and computer science) by continuing to pre-train general PLMs with domain-specific corpora. However, this Domain-Adaptive Pre-Training (DAPT; Gururangan et al. (2020)) tends to forget the previous general knowledge acquired by general PLMs, which leads to a catastrophic forgetting phenomenon and sub-optimal performance. To alleviate this problem, we propose a new framework of General Memory Augmented Pre-trained Language Model (G-MAP), which augments the domain-specific PLM by a memory representation built from the frozen general PLM without losing any general knowledge. Specifically, we propose a new memory-augmented layer, and based on it, different augmented strategies are explored to build the memory representation and then adaptively fuse it into the domain-specific PLM. We demonstrate the effectiveness of G-MAP on various domains (biomedical and computer science publications, news, and reviews) and different kinds (text classification, QA, NER) of tasks, and the extensive results show that the proposed G-MAP can achieve SOTA results on all tasks.
[ -0.4916910827, -0.9110229015, 0.5589989424, -0.0670298114, -0.3274866343, 0.168591246, -0.2810854018, -0.3798279762, 0.3721026778, 0.5506874919, -0.3144362271, -0.5722145438, -0.7289314866, -0.3753888905, -0.175597474, 1.0512530804, -0.207994014, -0.0748092756, -0.6269605756, -0.1272156537, -0.5841102004, -0.9649650455, -0.4677837193, -0.2802285254, 0.1262418777, 0.3076102734, 0.5737048388, 0.33853513, 0.3925628066, 0.2984080613, 0.3592104018, 0.3548192978, -0.4673621058, -0.1869781911, -0.2681306899, -0.2185234278, -1.0155277252, -0.0953451842, 0.6666998863, 0.5864322782, -0.0553479008, 0.0938255489, 0.0530557744, 0.3824473917, -0.7686145306, 0.1180963889, -0.7597034574, -0.3555635512, -0.0303957071, -0.552277863, -0.269330442, -0.0038539367, 0.3150402009, -0.8982554078, 0.4454851151, 0.1462186724, 0.7503956556, 0.0679284334, -0.048396498, -0.3321191072, -0.8400986791, 0.7427095771, -0.3136654794, 0.1692304313, 0.6150698066, 0.3242792487, -0.1400838345, -0.5501104593, -0.4581626058, -0.1936935633, 0.1179652885, 0.216961354, 0.1379631013, 0.0121464059, -0.0289032087, 0.4399944246, -0.64069134, -0.223434478, -0.2101236731, -0.0880251154, 0.3729640245, 0.0018482272, 0.7473113537, 0.6504797339, -0.5466387272, 0.1677735448, -0.8072213531, -0.2846728563, 0.0169409942, 0.2385079414, -0.024001129, 0.0489531904, -0.0133451223, 0.9251965284, -0.0593445264, 0.0843261331, 0.384043932, -0.2107963413, -0.2742611766, -0.1645502597, 0.4389992952, 0.134385258, 0.5708813667, -0.3783482015, 0.0672191158, 0.2679271698, 0.4678025544, -0.7164453864, -0.5046880841, -0.0196525045, 0.0075564948, 0.3758606911, -0.2913891375, -0.4019287527, -0.1184216291, -0.2073017955, 0.6919972897, -0.6562009454, -0.3302115202, 0.3998143673, 0.2990140021, -0.1997160316, 0.352927655, -1.0102962255, 0.6234100461, 0.3951931894, 0.5886995792, -0.2771930099, -0.5378172994, -0.5008712411, 0.4309276342, -0.086976856, 0.9392074943, -0.8144025803, -0.4372668266, 0.0478526987, -0.1723367274, -0.3717612624, -0.7213404179, 0.29258129, -0.733432889, 0.4330564737, -0.2128658295, -0.6756717563, -0.3766892254, 0.3726437688, -0.542224586, 0.7227279544, 0.1854703724, -0.5036469698, 0.2710968554, -0.6760157347, -0.431042403, 0.120203644, -0.1270641088, -0.4892464876, 0.0250339769, 0.4598711133, 0.4154439569, -0.4590550065, 0.2557516694, -0.1107753515, -0.6739851832, -0.053960938, 0.2136890143, 0.4205788672, -0.1329089105, -0.0387247168, 0.0750923529, -0.6101021171, 0.1692691445, 0.1698591262, -0.466357857, -0.5310634375, 0.0579367504, -0.1058917046, 0.1084818691, 0.3502335548, -0.1969275475, 0.5189138055, -0.1922813952, 0.3217339814, 0.3869556487, -0.0733262077, 0.7983506322, -0.3343375325, 0.5642299056, 0.322925508, 0.0287920292, -0.1571133435, -0.6418962479, -0.6190662384, -0.5064564347, 0.4364430308, 0.6750816703, -0.8145738244, 0.3414648175, -0.4210239947, -0.2589514852, -0.5212012529, 0.2952770591, 0.385345757, 0.5001556277, 0.9273589253, -0.59654814, -0.5486367345, -0.4349477887, -0.26744169, 0.0190403108, -0.0266408063, 0.2266382426, 0.4861654639, -0.5451971292, 0.9697467685, -0.5524075031, -0.688710928, -0.2681106329, 0.1333483607, -0.1312301159, 0.5667639375, 0.6119681597, -0.7908954024, -0.4479092658, -0.2076864541, -0.4257704616, -0.0306583084, -0.068812035, -0.0677208826, 0.1721864194, 0.2230266482, -0.6603093147, 0.1012547985, 0.5848755836, -0.3423804641, 0.6705326438, -0.5800233483, 0.1822766513, -0.8576723933, 0.1055120304, -0.222896561, -0.1064533889, -0.9878444672, 0.0760454535, 0.0617246218, -0.0659959912, -0.3720407784, 0.8041508198, -0.6924035549, -0.0576259457, -0.6065817475, 0.0897162408, -0.0674481764, 0.6992072463, 0.1627250761, 0.9067844748, 0.8412234187, -0.8465359807, -0.1495053768, 0.1712615043, -0.2477498502, 0.268769592, -0.2560999095, 0.4399682581, -0.1341678351, 0.0771829709, -0.7653090358, 0.1798872352, 0.3392106593, -0.344188571, 0.4880939722, -0.0502601936, -0.4097343385, -0.1837231964, 0.1363701373, 0.6620804667, 0.6046416163, -0.3659942746, 0.8419097066, 0.6270022392, -0.2085744739, -0.3004517555, -0.5040000081, -0.0660118312, -0.0623358749, -0.3850321472, 0.7141144276, -0.2552982271, 0.3405762315, 0.3411351144, -0.0303476546, -0.37336573, 0.1045495942, 0.1988795102, 0.3882581592, -0.2213885337, 0.0785833448, -0.3097903728, -0.1846889257, -0.205512315, -0.4922784269, 0.8021605611, -0.2304693907, -0.3445905447, 0.1330163181, 0.464318037, 0.2844462097, -0.3687277436, 0.5590932965, 0.4426857233, -0.5086749792, -0.1345228404, -0.5287907124, 0.1498258561, -0.4404414296, 0.4178213179, -0.3429492414, -1.1247348785, 0.5910620093, -0.4264161885, -0.4302584529, 0.3598956466, 0.5939632654, 0.0726579353, 0.7691796422, 0.7842772603, -0.5222757459, 0.2596643269, -0.3243456483, 0.1544901431, -0.8328967094, 0.0847068131, -0.2329333425, -0.2742511332, -0.0339827798, -0.7186574936, 0.0530013964, 0.4291288555, -0.3071481586, 0.1434212476, -0.4379043579, 0.4862445295, 0.6098765135, -0.1055324823, 0.1484223902, 0.1135620698, -0.1306193918, 0.2096523643, -0.691955328, -0.2953236401, 1.0496020317, -0.0428267419, 0.5034559965, -0.3386488557, 0.7099930644, 0.2481240928, 0.4606185853, -0.305944711, 0.6965953112, -0.3864593506, -0.5306833982, -0.0565557592, -0.330740869, -0.7682586908, 0.1197859198, -0.144859463, -0.6820370555, -0.0780523866, 0.5240285993, -0.4807100892, 0.3916559815, -0.822122097, 0.8341313004, -0.3973209262, -0.127990976, -0.1731457859, -0.3247661889, 0.1956446469, -0.1755343825, 0.1622419059, -0.0569758564, -0.0173221976, 0.6300145388, -0.0572845414, 0.7198449373, -0.6260463595, 0.2415449172, 0.5910176635, -0.1466709375, 0.4121731222, -0.1756937653, 0.3119641244, 0.205963254, -0.3658038378, -0.5507079363, -0.6114797592, 0.6087877154, -0.7805453539, -0.8107934594, -0.34037292, -0.7763931751, -0.5661376119, 0.1696888208, 0.1059073657, 0.2098130435, -0.4177803397, -0.3195187449, 0.6626918912, -0.3689801693, -0.0024992251, 0.6382505298, -0.3432664275, -0.4268487394, 1.1764506102, 0.2605729401, 0.2224328518, 0.4884526432, -0.1345729232, -0.1198614985, -0.8803992867, -0.2905846536, 0.0305086877, -0.352570504, -0.1328472048, -0.557697475, -0.3757971227, -0.3542699814, -0.2573215067, -0.0735916495, -0.1793981045, -0.3933384717, 0.2061381042, 0.3763799667, 0.2773916423, -0.0138663482, 0.5177718997, -0.6806503534, 0.7851727009, 0.458424747, 0.3903256357, -0.2310438156, -0.4034356475, -0.5301347971, 0.0762049258, -0.2294840515, -0.5188759565, 0.5185142756, 0.6380878687, 0.5986919403, 0.1429610401, -0.2964015603, 0.7371085882, -0.9603825212, 0.6235843301, 0.2671748698, -0.7776201963, 0.4738014042, -0.2986807525, 0.5524793863, 0.3793632686, 0.5138802528, -0.2113502473, -0.3869376481, -0.5749857426, -0.9063370228, 0.3815964758, -0.2733319998, 0.1179499403, -0.0122187315, 0.3100382984, 0.0996284932, 0.2647503912, -0.2049787939, -0.1849915534, -0.2957611084, -0.1247568727, -0.3826159835, -0.5576435328, -0.0007094091, -0.274261415, 0.6218434572, -0.2173464596, 0.6959280372, 0.053875763, -0.4759824574, 0.0319906734, 0.3942579329, 0.7814803123, 0.6150875688, -0.3954846859, 0.3118100464, 0.2261298895, -0.9282612801, 0.2546088398, 0.1662855893, -0.2429535985, -0.3062768281, 0.0726544186, 0.8213304877, 0.2025226504, -0.4946167767, 0.348271817, 0.202106297, -0.3378966153, -0.0438638851, 0.2329390645, 0.320556581, -0.007420972, 0.5472573638, 0.2640402317, -0.0498979241, -0.5656349063, 0.3780409098, 0.3438463211, -0.0610211939, -0.5799720287, 0.7794719338, -0.0483960211, -0.1614042372, 0.3620292842, -0.2953226268, -0.8009959459, 0.2193434089, 0.9309622645, 0.8632826209, -0.532469213, 0.1756723225, 0.0268359631, 0.1980516315, -0.101256676, 0.6936329007, 0.139110893, -0.9225741029, -0.7305760384, -0.5878199339, -0.3050001264, 0.3599439859, -0.3688600063, -0.167449221, -0.5999631882, -0.270318836, -0.4987463355, 0.2125142515, -0.9408269525, 0.6211202145, 0.0545173734, 0.7709500194, -0.7643909454, 1.3140997887, 0.875146687, -0.2507948279, -0.2564634681, 0.0048664873, -0.4690844715, -0.9788832068, 0.5732462406, -0.0647531226, -0.0885110721, 0.050462652, -0.2422664016, -0.9801112413, 0.8440674543, 0.5856587291, -0.4097772241, -0.075334914, 0.4278627634, 0.6061727405, -0.750033915, -0.0776117966, 0.3190617561, 0.1898926198, -0.1383698881, -0.7027845383, 0.0692327172, -0.5243615508, 0.0596174262, 0.1384144723, -0.3515768945, 0.9690642357, -0.1304943413, -0.3254662752, -0.0816768631, 0.7333857417, 0.3090219796, 0.2658151388, 0.5131300092, 0.9230180979, 0.8013520241, -0.1094514504, 0.9362236857, -0.3860286474, 0.0486079231, 1.4151548147, -0.4999771416, 0.825217247, 0.2677161098, 0.100922294, 0.4532896876, 0.2099246085, 0.0958983824, 0.98268646, 0.210833922, -0.2955791652, -0.390168339, 0.1046732664, -0.6571100354, 0.1793193221, 0.5682379603, -0.0532196499, -0.1400278658, 0.2162154466, -0.2093736827, 0.0815226808, -0.5491064787, 0.5066552162, 0.0398332477, -0.3899250925, 0.8666064143, -0.1664765477, 0.5751583576, -0.6512680054, 0.054128442, 0.0970091745, 0.2051754147, 0.1527724117, -0.3752540052, 0.3199252188, -0.1996397674, -0.4935210347, -0.3024420738, 1.1900901794, -0.7176917195, -0.2596090436, 0.4772517681, 0.5948190093, -0.0683873594, -0.3770597577, -0.5760840178, 0.0577945001, -0.4130898714, -0.13252832, 0.7406532168, 0.2001844049, -0.0801304206, 0.625431776, 0.4801109135, 0.2954282761, 0.163354069, 0.0406406969, 0.9253147244, -0.5804390907, -0.6284758449, -0.5762031078, 0.4183856547, 0.0803417563, -0.2017260343, 0.5892221332, 0.5816599727, 0.8591811061, -0.4050287306, 1.0540940762, 0.2684764862, 0.6030433178, -0.6022030711, 0.8286374211, -0.4914058745, -0.0993262455, -0.1068958119, -0.8684492111, -0.5248654485, 0.4705989659, -0.6065359116, 0.1339386404, 0.601510644, 0.6461240649, -0.1704056263, -0.1281668693, 0.3676832914, 0.0641036555, 0.0528582372, 1.0177916288, 0.7094196081, -0.4124118686, 0.2937753797, 0.267908901, -0.1772743315, -0.1832263768, -0.723795712, -0.8611632586, -0.8346492052, -0.4923521578, 0.0523729064, 0.3121036887, 0.4075041413, 0.6364552379, -0.9362537861, -0.0090020876, 0.0040537342, -0.1425981373, -0.3679921329, -0.0701319054, 0.6321732402, -0.450715512, -0.4904436469, 0.5142428279, 0.4213675857, 0.0776056349, -0.0471593589, -0.1819825917, -0.3522560298, -0.0591675676, 0.4448394775, 0.5334787369, -0.3191955388, -0.3852955699, -0.0712537915, 0.0027698877, 0.1514376104, 0.9054865837, -1.0973229408, 0.3377011716, 0.240088135, 1.0049716234, 0.4216839969, -0.1012310535, 0.5907453895, -0.7790759206, 0.0769750923, 0.121418938, 0.3813741803, 0.3331536353, -0.2029584199, 0.2861284912, 0.2313624024, -0.6774709821, -0.4293859899, 0.2200942934, -1.0189677477, -0.3323867619, 1.0117255449, -0.178180173, -0.2399338037, -0.2549064457, -0.1041912362, 0.1234525964, -0.0164796002, 0.9627934694, 0.4739248157, 0.2165252715, 0.0464883372, -0.4998894036, 0.6716638207, 0.3662133217, -0.7846441865, -0.1101122499, 0.3238860667, 0.2370722294, 0.3483763039, 1.3604513407, 0.0987567604, 0.2620272934, -0.2549716234, 0.1248067096, -0.2544444501, -0.7152091265, 0.0541982576, 0.4468757212, 0.028979348, -0.4287572801 ]