id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00407v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00407v1 | SHADE: Semantic Hypernym Annotator for Domain-specific Entities -- DnD Domain Use Case | 2024-06-29T11:21:40 | 2024-06-29T11:21:40 | Akila Peiris, Nisansa de Silva | cs.CE | cs.CE, cs.CL | Manual data annotation is an important NLP task but one that takes
considerable amount of resources and effort. In spite of the costs, labeling
and categorizing entities is essential for NLP tasks such as semantic
evaluation. Even though annotation can be done by non-experts in most cases,
due to the fact that this requires human labor, the process is costly. Another
major challenge encountered in data annotation is maintaining the annotation
consistency. Annotation efforts are typically carried out by teams of multiple
annotators. The annotations need to maintain the consistency in relation to
both the domain truth and annotation format while reducing human errors.
Annotating a specialized domain that deviates significantly from the general
domain, such as fantasy literature, will see a lot of human error and annotator
disagreement. So it is vital that proper guidelines and error reduction
mechanisms are enforced. One such way to enforce these constraints is using a
specialized application. Such an app can ensure that the notations are
consistent, and the labels can be pre-defined or restricted reducing the room
for errors. In this paper, we present SHADE, an annotation software that can be
used to annotate entities in the high fantasy literature domain. Specifically
in Dungeons and Dragons lore extracted from the Forgotten Realms Fandom Wiki. | [
-0.530375421,
-0.5285475254,
0.1601629108,
0.765894413,
-0.0562141091,
0.1449781358,
-0.1699619889,
-0.669003129,
0.5684549809,
1.0533310175,
-0.793761611,
-0.9486752748,
-0.2863430381,
0.4691395462,
-0.2375213355,
1.2467778921,
-0.3023647964,
-0.5471509099,
-0.2972345948,
-0.3381563425,
-0.2526762187,
-0.4880352318,
-0.5218400955,
-0.1210719272,
0.7329505086,
0.1851869375,
0.9086309671,
0.8369249701,
0.6841704845,
0.3629101217,
0.0113369403,
0.4717512429,
-0.5810801983,
0.5776497126,
-0.3845158815,
-0.2739620209,
-0.6651046872,
0.0898243561,
0.3495761156,
0.6781237125,
-0.0806786269,
0.0411473773,
-0.1846985817,
0.4953939319,
-0.8485528231,
0.3757812977,
-0.6565396786,
0.2254678458,
-0.582473278,
-0.4325158894,
-0.0780442059,
-0.2694804668,
0.1498740464,
-1.8004618883,
0.5504152775,
0.5673341751,
1.1820719242,
0.3506571651,
0.1000518575,
0.0159040671,
-0.707950294,
0.8162623048,
-0.4990045428,
0.2155381143,
0.567037642,
0.2848832607,
-0.1601775438,
-0.6969223022,
-0.9669716358,
0.0903311223,
-0.2181049883,
0.0353577137,
-0.0058375997,
0.274059087,
0.5011615157,
0.1523971558,
-0.0928069949,
0.0254089087,
-0.1321187764,
-0.4089108407,
0.5387501121,
0.3222757876,
0.3925510645,
-0.3690564036,
-0.5833697915,
0.1227309033,
-0.8161644936,
-0.7426668406,
0.463763237,
0.0584281348,
0.3135490417,
0.5574378967,
-0.2827879488,
0.7212064266,
0.0244438909,
-0.2817086875,
0.3315473497,
0.0108163133,
-0.1065226421,
0.0728140473,
0.5197082162,
0.7406941056,
0.3245023787,
-0.5403638482,
-0.1882774085,
0.0839120373,
0.1745895594,
-0.750038743,
-0.4337769449,
0.0570758134,
-0.0389385633,
-0.3337371051,
-0.2077947557,
-0.9706574082,
-0.8347995281,
-0.3644625843,
0.0450344197,
-0.0751362592,
-0.2269160748,
-0.0217621457,
-0.4425695539,
-0.2687123716,
0.7388936877,
-1.0444175005,
0.462190181,
0.599219799,
0.7282048464,
-0.6653957367,
-0.475109309,
-0.0024253451,
0.7410565019,
-0.4191588759,
0.5647917986,
-0.2533435822,
-0.1535517871,
-0.1882958263,
0.177485615,
-0.0613448098,
-0.4582951665,
0.6700310111,
-0.8180405498,
-0.1885395497,
-0.2159101218,
-0.6002069712,
-0.3395592868,
0.3357007205,
-1.0437692404,
0.8117941022,
0.5951125622,
-1.0508650541,
0.6599311829,
-0.3908912838,
-0.015744783,
0.5923998952,
-0.2390594929,
-0.276217103,
-0.2172074318,
-0.0216189791,
0.2986164391,
-0.3823797405,
-0.0698319227,
-0.3007941842,
-0.5434362292,
0.0949622914,
-0.1556900144,
0.8221161366,
-0.0689424351,
-0.4828625619,
-0.0205301959,
-0.8561586738,
0.0716153681,
-0.0730095655,
-0.1966496855,
-0.9655957818,
-0.2242301702,
0.7815622091,
0.0423577428,
-0.0030032259,
-0.847055912,
0.2324379086,
-0.3220809996,
-0.0329364166,
0.7537002563,
0.0875897408,
0.1823651642,
-0.0638684109,
0.6346900463,
-0.0452860408,
0.0342168026,
0.1970284432,
-0.3612439632,
-0.7288601398,
-0.543824017,
0.5231369734,
0.4544259012,
-1.0869913101,
0.3750442564,
-0.0072624576,
-0.3808736801,
-0.5239228606,
0.3073030412,
0.3192171454,
0.5295662284,
0.3769361079,
-0.0616310835,
-0.5160931349,
-0.623667717,
0.0713669062,
-0.0993999317,
0.1878382415,
0.5610545278,
0.3932879567,
-0.6399216056,
1.3557640314,
-0.7879181504,
-0.6620921493,
0.0920259729,
0.1660666317,
-0.1245292947,
0.5448946357,
0.7885049582,
-1.1011960506,
-0.3591472507,
0.2719852626,
-0.7281962037,
-0.5254977942,
0.1151549295,
-0.6046490669,
0.16950275,
0.2692591548,
-0.6063597798,
0.4909124672,
0.545085907,
-0.3454304338,
0.8511459827,
-0.0186253767,
0.5173970461,
-0.7234435678,
0.0544816665,
0.0980410948,
-0.016374832,
-0.2357278317,
0.0698876083,
-0.1674690396,
0.0656746551,
-0.0908749327,
0.7038376927,
-0.3578713536,
0.2665942013,
-0.1438819766,
0.3404781222,
0.3372919261,
0.5035930276,
0.3373127282,
0.6138350368,
0.4747559726,
-0.6279451251,
0.88789469,
0.2504467964,
-0.0637408197,
0.8997129798,
-0.6980637312,
0.0643600896,
0.0651788414,
0.0013025269,
-0.6741118431,
-0.4288458824,
0.4374056458,
0.0536881126,
0.2303534299,
-0.3004428446,
-0.6450009942,
-0.0746777281,
-0.1736147106,
0.3156858683,
-0.0955597162,
-0.5945245028,
0.3716751039,
0.4572969079,
0.0869701654,
-0.8346835971,
-0.6015375853,
0.2839635611,
-0.2589607537,
-0.6009585261,
0.8355222344,
0.0792151317,
-0.3452483416,
0.3461145461,
-0.0585839413,
-0.4289956093,
-0.0847114697,
0.5137343407,
0.2627713084,
-0.273534894,
0.1569912732,
0.0833595544,
-0.2952388823,
-0.2438937724,
-0.3696870208,
0.052785296,
0.1258663237,
-0.4455440938,
-0.2493833154,
0.330240339,
0.4473125935,
-0.155574441,
0.5088763237,
0.4931788445,
-0.585008204,
-0.6662873626,
-0.550962925,
0.2427033782,
-0.4570041299,
0.4476799965,
-0.4017245471,
-0.6769469976,
0.5928124189,
-0.2408566475,
0.1494089365,
0.6749447584,
0.1141679659,
-0.021994099,
0.687663734,
0.8847307563,
0.1872823536,
0.1509144753,
-0.2288946509,
-0.129507497,
-0.8701422811,
-0.0512744971,
-0.4998723567,
-0.1372167766,
-0.5012389421,
-0.4367119372,
0.1053975001,
0.3717713356,
0.2049568295,
0.5665551424,
-0.6090658903,
0.6589396,
0.234459728,
-0.1670923531,
0.4416218102,
0.1647136807,
0.2528733909,
-0.4273373783,
-0.3290768862,
-0.5266185999,
0.6964117289,
0.1247607172,
0.9702356458,
0.13810274,
0.8764238358,
0.4032070339,
0.4032761753,
-0.7121885419,
0.3976508677,
-0.1498529017,
-0.7300623059,
-0.5109564066,
-0.4648836553,
-0.733101368,
0.1952342987,
-0.2667098939,
-0.6327962279,
0.5778049231,
0.0476788059,
-0.2218733579,
0.2206257582,
-0.4590286911,
0.9018369317,
0.3133366406,
-0.3502916396,
0.0960582122,
-0.1499308646,
0.1361379921,
-0.2172273695,
-0.2044548988,
-0.2995887101,
-0.1959582716,
1.1157213449,
-0.451731205,
0.7805713415,
-0.2196481526,
0.0948872715,
0.2368087769,
0.2252708972,
0.2079706043,
0.0012069151,
-0.033363279,
0.2168897688,
0.2551928461,
-0.1678369939,
-0.8412673473,
0.789411664,
-0.642375648,
-0.6214478016,
-0.4808270037,
-0.6348427534,
-0.3375761807,
0.2904596031,
0.1226642877,
0.2222655565,
-0.0603214875,
0.0099644968,
0.9415851831,
0.1221433803,
-0.0273974426,
0.2284982502,
-0.3730866015,
-0.3947443664,
0.9386517406,
0.3683469296,
0.1015783995,
0.1142789796,
0.110667713,
0.0169387385,
-0.6733771563,
-0.9697452188,
0.0461110175,
-0.9409835935,
-0.274169296,
-0.5976285934,
-0.1539684981,
-0.1121618152,
-0.3257723749,
0.060083773,
-0.7476869226,
-0.0407866836,
-0.2195617855,
0.8212692142,
0.7126866579,
0.3615314364,
0.3601439595,
-0.4004427791,
0.368378669,
0.1441382915,
0.3324383497,
-0.1698663831,
0.1884498745,
-0.1900909841,
-0.2554356158,
0.1190499589,
-1.0202838182,
0.216678679,
0.2354844064,
0.5578671694,
0.3383198678,
0.0338860936,
0.6728309393,
-0.3745628595,
0.496037811,
0.226439178,
-0.6944684982,
0.3320960402,
-0.3781378567,
-0.2341727316,
0.7036678195,
0.3866095245,
-0.8550091386,
-0.5296195745,
-0.4765179753,
-1.0089015961,
0.7569236755,
0.1701765507,
-0.0280692391,
-0.0390845537,
0.5307520032,
0.2618817091,
0.2474469692,
-0.4336085916,
-0.4920097589,
-0.1523853838,
-0.2880323529,
0.2072868943,
-0.1807234585,
-0.4214501977,
-0.0923195034,
0.6909709573,
-0.1643544286,
-0.3009559512,
0.2362460792,
-0.1915232539,
-0.2226691097,
-0.0985012129,
0.0994784757,
0.9586780667,
0.0090942821,
0.1516914815,
-0.1358703971,
-1.0061541796,
-0.0352473482,
0.2788937986,
-0.8147343397,
0.3966756165,
0.5106136799,
0.6061747074,
0.1619701385,
-0.3170781434,
0.5549994707,
0.310788244,
0.1540103108,
-0.0767811462,
0.1986627579,
-0.0362541378,
-0.0483650528,
0.163771078,
0.2648174763,
0.2634266913,
-0.1558884233,
0.2458569556,
-0.0671494752,
-0.5510278344,
0.0675498545,
0.5697817206,
0.397077173,
-0.0555905662,
0.3136920929,
-0.4027692676,
-0.5740579963,
0.6704426408,
0.6687123179,
1.002499938,
0.0753096491,
0.3995754123,
0.0583402626,
0.1055863798,
0.1699262261,
-0.1010586098,
-0.1045796722,
-0.6990367174,
-0.2490375191,
-0.9894875884,
-0.5156292915,
-0.5075586438,
-0.2618120611,
0.1864212751,
-0.6848302484,
-0.2627671659,
0.3503039777,
0.0136151193,
-0.6208363771,
0.2830372155,
-0.2951616645,
0.7608498931,
-0.5750526786,
0.6324843168,
0.6745067239,
-0.6695274115,
-0.5840604305,
0.0055849878,
0.0748822838,
-0.4014308155,
1.1206190586,
-0.108813338,
-0.5057371855,
-0.0371830314,
-0.3583760858,
-0.5758458972,
1.105063796,
0.1866883636,
-0.5554543138,
-0.0492990538,
-0.0550717823,
0.6998332739,
-0.4267010987,
-0.0866282061,
0.3367931247,
0.6472082734,
0.2177952379,
-0.8775382638,
0.1652296484,
-0.1572319716,
0.1553602368,
0.1666869819,
-0.1973747611,
0.7167859674,
-0.066700317,
-0.2927441895,
-0.0035481926,
0.7163989544,
0.4301578701,
0.4642994404,
0.6134281754,
0.5294480324,
0.8964038491,
-0.4258466363,
0.7348190546,
-0.0421824791,
0.3768778145,
0.7907369137,
-0.3463881016,
0.4022395313,
0.3242943883,
-0.1653767228,
0.4895696938,
0.4755887985,
-0.173129335,
0.2618315518,
0.5491369367,
-0.4153396487,
0.0478230827,
-0.3817573786,
-0.1843923926,
0.0711999983,
0.3218345344,
-0.129455328,
-0.0206230376,
-0.1465186775,
0.349535197,
0.2498458028,
-0.4615639448,
0.6233887672,
-0.1244005859,
-0.2980424464,
0.2095311582,
0.2970725298,
0.8682584167,
-0.737524271,
-0.4378308058,
0.0998978242,
0.2722830474,
-0.8191542625,
-0.7385858297,
0.243585065,
0.0082487734,
-0.3773596883,
0.0443991236,
0.7931672931,
-0.5769694448,
-0.4956496954,
0.374640137,
0.1222195178,
0.0508943647,
0.022160124,
-0.5402646065,
0.081201978,
-0.3905607462,
-0.2804656625,
-0.0247361176,
0.9620937109,
-0.4229442477,
0.3955002725,
0.5378690958,
0.5820132494,
0.1523797065,
0.4468323886,
0.7278625965,
-0.5409521461,
-0.4984217882,
-0.4986515939,
-0.0657396019,
-0.4974860549,
-0.7568835616,
1.1215037107,
0.4316083491,
0.7588470578,
0.0148089658,
0.6918091178,
-0.227917254,
0.3957464397,
-0.362906903,
1.0554394722,
-0.2679214776,
-0.0413578786,
-0.6260424852,
-1.1609961987,
-0.552831471,
0.5442259312,
-0.0517281368,
0.0312031433,
0.5877873302,
0.7399206758,
0.0137968566,
0.2024444938,
0.1686486304,
-0.0521119013,
0.1193754151,
0.0546388067,
0.6172754169,
-0.0593989715,
0.1861234605,
-0.5204439759,
-0.4422187805,
-0.0289815273,
-0.7294008136,
-0.8142260909,
-0.5854580998,
-0.7335739136,
-0.5451678634,
0.2767163217,
0.843321681,
0.8184325099,
-0.9286049008,
-0.0499182008,
0.1048697978,
0.353987962,
-0.5907520652,
-0.2954865098,
0.6944141984,
-0.2661803663,
-0.8036657572,
-0.2471819371,
0.4969537556,
-0.1116550937,
-0.6969906688,
-0.0984056741,
0.1723098308,
-0.0299138539,
0.3959777951,
0.1922335774,
-0.6007308364,
-0.2706772983,
-0.2762123048,
-0.3078234792,
-0.2576366365,
0.8243005276,
-0.6128051281,
0.6582205296,
0.4694498181,
0.8320119381,
0.4396358132,
-0.1282004416,
0.3738674521,
-0.7789982557,
-0.0476995371,
0.4653509855,
0.180237174,
0.4157039523,
-0.6200584769,
0.586309135,
0.6977106929,
-0.304466337,
-0.62141186,
0.0714081153,
-0.8668571711,
-0.0629783571,
1.1798321009,
-0.5321542621,
-0.4985973835,
-0.5246782303,
-0.4951248467,
-0.0872281939,
-0.0931293219,
0.6451296806,
1.0267083645,
-0.0592259616,
0.1280853897,
-0.5489102006,
1.126044035,
-0.088910155,
-0.8651479483,
0.4713956118,
0.6629938483,
0.0668987334,
0.6167652011,
0.606959939,
-0.1692113429,
0.2688129842,
0.2088415027,
0.3177344799,
-0.2527858019,
-0.5278301835,
0.2288252264,
0.1514343172,
-0.1049306169,
-0.140751645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00402v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00402v1 | Is It Really Long Context if All You Need Is Retrieval? Towards Genuinely Difficult Long Context NLP | 2024-06-29T11:09:47 | 2024-06-29T11:09:47 | Omer Goldman, Alon Jacovi, Aviv Slobodkin, Aviya Maimon, Ido Dagan, Reut Tsarfaty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Improvements in language models' capabilities have pushed their applications
towards longer contexts, making long-context evaluation and development an
active research area. However, many disparate use-cases are grouped together
under the umbrella term of "long-context", defined simply by the total length
of the model's input, including - for example - Needle-in-a-Haystack tasks,
book summarization, and information aggregation. Given their varied difficulty,
in this position paper we argue that conflating different tasks by their
context length is unproductive. As a community, we require a more precise
vocabulary to understand what makes long-context tasks similar or different. We
propose to unpack the taxonomy of long-context based on the properties that
make them more difficult with longer contexts. We propose two orthogonal axes
of difficulty: (I) Diffusion: How hard is it to find the necessary information
in the context? (II) Scope: How much necessary information is there to find? We
survey the literature on long-context, provide justification for this taxonomy
as an informative descriptor, and situate the literature with respect to it. We
conclude that the most difficult and interesting settings, whose necessary
information is very long and highly diffused within the input, is severely
under-explored. By using a descriptive vocabulary and discussing the relevant
properties of difficulty in long-context, we can implement more informed
research in this area. We call for a careful design of tasks and benchmarks
with distinctly long context, taking into account the characteristics that make
it qualitatively different from shorter context. | [
-0.4261831939,
-0.8956898451,
0.8642889261,
0.4603164792,
-0.4345272481,
0.1087634712,
-0.6459499002,
-0.7305788994,
0.1856112182,
0.298091501,
-0.31791538,
-0.0077288547,
-0.75928092,
0.3038070202,
-0.6153059006,
0.8959131837,
-0.1221834868,
-0.3906239867,
-0.3838150799,
-0.4702531099,
-0.5454158783,
-0.5468229055,
-0.4363884628,
-0.3386660516,
0.7563917637,
0.0202795081,
0.6199521422,
0.2941501141,
0.437866658,
0.2157930136,
-0.6386324167,
-0.0145382006,
-0.45178321,
0.193864733,
-0.4740386307,
-0.1780222952,
-0.2042666972,
-0.2460561842,
0.4473593533,
1.1178934574,
-0.0900758654,
0.1721966565,
0.4663754106,
0.9103482366,
-0.6324144602,
-0.0333071388,
-0.0833452269,
-0.0068293624,
-0.4573672414,
-0.2348265797,
-0.1238504276,
0.382517606,
0.3872454762,
-0.5107192993,
0.0036723905,
0.0884364396,
0.4655657709,
0.0267160758,
-0.8290784955,
-0.519626379,
-0.9384913445,
1.02777946,
-0.4213683009,
0.1555608511,
0.3189449012,
0.3471155763,
-0.1078860462,
-0.7534070015,
-0.4438138008,
-0.1210187152,
-0.1168530434,
-0.1138877124,
-0.135058701,
0.0486683957,
0.1926638335,
0.0752501935,
-0.255196631,
0.0733786076,
-0.5753735304,
0.0600748695,
0.5284770727,
0.1215701625,
0.0689227134,
-0.356695056,
-0.4409626424,
0.2746933997,
-0.6079716086,
0.0871503279,
0.0410102047,
0.3864508867,
0.0544097051,
0.4177674055,
-0.3925369382,
0.7688318491,
-0.3112629056,
-0.070609197,
0.2811810374,
-0.2942349315,
-0.1241412237,
-0.276424408,
0.4026407897,
0.2134856582,
-0.07647302,
-0.3696365654,
-0.3845781684,
-0.2800761461,
0.489202112,
-0.4562368095,
0.3213045001,
0.3899812698,
-0.3120759726,
0.1028389782,
-0.3057552576,
-0.5726630688,
-0.0624046102,
-0.4809603989,
0.5091590881,
-0.1623302549,
-0.3241349459,
0.1772079617,
-0.1068512946,
0.0797060654,
0.1915185601,
-0.5525767207,
0.3126878738,
1.1581674814,
0.9726555347,
-0.5913726687,
-0.2163832486,
-0.0713734776,
0.0330866724,
-0.1346055269,
0.5610983968,
-0.6417245865,
-0.5719535947,
0.1031855121,
0.2199254185,
0.2185025662,
-0.4900825918,
0.7573164701,
-0.4594369233,
0.4331445396,
-0.4220632613,
-0.6479096413,
-0.0356472582,
0.2958757579,
-0.6005125642,
1.0233436823,
0.4417387545,
-0.690559566,
0.3127782047,
-0.708327055,
-0.5495379567,
0.2810308635,
-0.0690418705,
0.1248543933,
0.1977070123,
-0.2879118323,
0.5400241017,
-0.3624233007,
0.6973438263,
-0.134110257,
-0.5570046902,
0.0583958291,
-0.2753577828,
0.5821378231,
0.2730070651,
-0.4351654351,
-0.0890172422,
-0.6088857055,
0.0030294606,
-0.2242690623,
-0.4210137427,
-0.7791867256,
0.1809813827,
0.2253452688,
0.2176328599,
0.3900090456,
-0.3535957932,
0.0456694849,
-0.3031088412,
0.6843493581,
0.5802161694,
-0.2931265831,
0.7696301937,
-0.3074922562,
0.4667300582,
-0.108395189,
0.3030784428,
0.1659031212,
-0.3722760975,
-0.3795778155,
-0.093075946,
0.2301195264,
0.3322634101,
-0.7205125093,
0.4670521319,
-0.2942078114,
-0.2286294252,
-0.1524410993,
0.2218729854,
0.5657369494,
0.6854147315,
0.6031863093,
-0.3488245904,
-0.3505821228,
-1.0731453896,
-0.1153943688,
0.1811568439,
-0.2342580408,
0.4818976521,
0.8025215268,
-0.4014541209,
1.0101858377,
-0.2382198125,
-0.5181106329,
-0.120775871,
0.0304758549,
0.5386521816,
0.2774051726,
0.4063496888,
-1.0657478571,
-0.2479737848,
-0.3461918533,
-0.7001383305,
0.0793934166,
0.1100465283,
-0.1123935506,
0.0574110821,
0.6151835918,
-0.7728150487,
0.1688488871,
0.2624157369,
-0.263435483,
0.5086259842,
-0.25966838,
-0.290237844,
-0.851793766,
0.4074956477,
-0.1570273191,
-0.1092230156,
-0.5969584584,
0.7649402618,
0.0768397078,
0.1191482544,
-0.5948724151,
0.8359668851,
-0.4453436434,
0.3627018034,
-0.3580458462,
0.2556904554,
0.1967010498,
0.3803632557,
-0.0242595263,
0.6304616332,
0.2967205644,
-0.7406483889,
0.5331550837,
-0.1563872099,
-0.7550753355,
0.494384855,
-0.6348680258,
-0.020933846,
-0.2608039379,
0.580519855,
-0.7067718506,
-0.2563365698,
0.0672772452,
0.1166152507,
0.2813622355,
0.0168429948,
-0.3634126186,
-0.4417570829,
-0.001911114,
0.9926490784,
0.475944221,
-0.2927308679,
0.2678182125,
0.2463429868,
-0.0342633761,
-0.9141415954,
-0.6090493798,
0.2699641883,
-0.612133801,
-0.4582330585,
0.8585497141,
-0.0507946499,
-0.4821655154,
-0.1065708995,
-0.2552306354,
-0.2497806847,
0.2336758524,
0.2143651843,
-0.3595289588,
-0.1009207219,
0.6866564155,
-0.1827768534,
0.0939660594,
0.0859721303,
-0.0550119169,
0.2336159348,
0.043911837,
-0.1595045477,
0.1213096231,
0.9544977546,
0.2389666885,
0.1341739744,
0.359402597,
0.2987127304,
-0.3557267785,
-0.2652956247,
-0.4837633073,
0.0838982388,
-0.43057248,
0.3971891403,
-0.3963721395,
-1.1456984282,
0.5652179122,
-0.0928011313,
0.0310609303,
0.2727518678,
0.1140955165,
-0.2915301919,
0.672794044,
0.9204486012,
-0.0520794801,
0.1729967594,
-0.1852430403,
0.2437871397,
-0.9953228235,
-0.2141366899,
-0.3657691479,
-0.4387306571,
-0.2754376829,
-0.5473863482,
0.3005551398,
0.1353085935,
-0.1373469383,
0.1266074926,
-0.5737376213,
0.5146513581,
0.203711465,
0.1626796424,
0.0510268472,
-0.2852012813,
0.224307403,
-0.0137884822,
-0.4421034753,
-0.3262841403,
0.9306679964,
0.1816300154,
0.4542877674,
0.338460505,
0.7146133184,
0.2897854149,
0.1123162955,
-1.1050399542,
0.388489753,
-0.0490130782,
-0.8748466372,
-0.46331653,
-0.1842263639,
-1.3462827206,
0.1699980348,
0.0468243957,
-0.4881033897,
0.1701085716,
-0.1104436964,
-0.4311561584,
-0.1294243485,
-0.3287301362,
0.6342363358,
-0.1588204205,
-0.4279415905,
-0.1143884212,
-0.9212229252,
0.1722994894,
-0.2977494597,
0.8465197086,
-0.2572205961,
-0.2539948523,
0.7505674958,
-0.294829607,
0.6349158883,
-0.0695206299,
-0.1917622536,
0.322452873,
0.1497400552,
0.2200984657,
-0.0156117864,
-0.0860156044,
-0.1299317628,
0.3265786171,
-0.6143811345,
-0.7637401223,
0.6430130005,
-0.3256474435,
-0.8318270445,
-0.4207945168,
-0.1661984622,
-0.1361688375,
0.2157059759,
0.3033416569,
0.4906674623,
-0.1801902205,
0.4221413732,
0.4954310954,
0.0529330075,
0.5545654893,
0.2383345068,
-0.1713507473,
0.4005794823,
0.7208952308,
0.2231587172,
0.0082628215,
0.5139484406,
0.1934452355,
-0.3243071139,
-0.4643816352,
-0.1825420111,
0.0901861563,
-0.7306042314,
-0.1357385218,
-0.4124090374,
-0.0544067025,
-0.0195265282,
-0.1937630028,
-0.1826593727,
-0.3755855262,
-0.5553284287,
0.1464478225,
0.1093070507,
0.5750843883,
0.0299117975,
0.2807687223,
-0.6527648568,
0.3551704586,
0.3686390519,
0.4695799947,
0.1099148989,
-0.640860796,
-0.2532862127,
0.007723398,
-0.0037754776,
-0.7184577584,
0.4053184688,
0.453189224,
0.3093324006,
0.185141325,
0.2753626406,
0.7389284968,
-0.5897061229,
0.8615733385,
0.0918070599,
-0.7235842943,
0.1769024581,
-0.0823870152,
0.3458972275,
0.7013334632,
0.6452370882,
-0.6235913038,
-0.1076130196,
-0.5249943137,
-1.5640952587,
0.2806015611,
0.1118807793,
0.7433348894,
-0.3265642524,
0.6422643065,
0.1573722064,
0.1848831475,
-0.7387247682,
0.1271833479,
0.0735731795,
0.1215275899,
-0.1643364429,
-0.6234847307,
-0.6168597937,
-0.2640824914,
0.1523660421,
-0.0890871733,
0.2013887018,
0.2704843581,
-0.2087129653,
0.2454764098,
0.6497068405,
0.4053006768,
1.3056006432,
-0.3005737364,
0.2568140626,
0.1036251634,
-0.0427895673,
-0.001527951,
-0.1934685707,
0.2573030293,
0.0572330095,
0.6178854704,
0.3363267779,
0.4990164042,
-0.8494670391,
0.8839623928,
0.2012076676,
-0.139602825,
-0.7233853936,
-0.0769411325,
0.11097119,
0.3064648509,
0.8065518141,
-0.4903446138,
0.5201208591,
-0.733384192,
0.1155255288,
0.4882329404,
-0.404615432,
-0.0425931215,
0.1999588013,
0.4551576674,
-0.4053921402,
0.5461500287,
-0.3179038465,
-0.2756582201,
0.7135034204,
0.4799827039,
0.5114489794,
0.198710233,
-0.0309280027,
0.063075088,
-0.1339217722,
-0.4459309578,
0.0644835085,
-0.5867966413,
-0.2142763883,
-0.7370288968,
-0.9369453192,
-0.2529119849,
0.2609093785,
-0.8294824362,
0.1271975785,
-0.1957413405,
-0.357763052,
0.1038595065,
-0.0584287047,
-0.5164792538,
0.3306435347,
-0.1632130146,
0.9643728137,
-0.4270260632,
0.5906819701,
0.3726952672,
0.2300863415,
-0.2010332346,
-0.1515720189,
-0.2577812374,
-0.4576130509,
0.7778625488,
0.3546597362,
-0.0851304382,
-0.4219934642,
-0.6260083318,
-0.7870565057,
0.9327204227,
-0.171224013,
-0.8186959624,
-0.6193614602,
-0.1573984176,
0.8253506422,
-0.3013342321,
0.0177549385,
0.4171883166,
0.4784898162,
-0.1409721226,
-1.0914385319,
0.1842057258,
-0.1882174313,
0.0363984369,
0.2931528687,
-0.5768002272,
0.7071509957,
-0.0927440226,
-0.5420496464,
0.1163430586,
0.5255237222,
-0.2425266206,
0.4338229299,
0.5554673672,
0.1796078086,
0.4242889583,
0.097467795,
0.8781450987,
-0.2015482783,
0.489489764,
1.1415709257,
-0.0767111927,
0.8067825437,
0.7665878534,
-0.2505011261,
0.3371747434,
0.6136025786,
0.3095756471,
0.4198642969,
0.4808532596,
-0.3679898381,
-0.3272513449,
0.0144413495,
-0.557575047,
0.4443778098,
0.6511890888,
-0.3149645627,
-0.3491353393,
0.1572742164,
-0.0162666459,
0.1943763793,
0.0142941168,
0.4632330835,
0.4084449112,
-0.8641162515,
0.7428601384,
0.1095826402,
0.9490280151,
-0.5291109085,
0.1559031904,
-0.0762680396,
-0.3262194395,
-0.2273793072,
-1.0510638952,
0.5753492713,
-0.3193865716,
-0.2878510356,
-0.2203341126,
0.3106390238,
-0.1263457388,
-0.094915688,
0.7365729809,
0.6716085672,
0.2232214957,
-0.2125341147,
-0.5358969569,
-0.1186779663,
-0.3518454432,
-0.4581574202,
0.5371699333,
0.4993065894,
-0.1774906665,
0.7032442689,
0.2913223207,
-0.0805923715,
-0.3092164099,
-0.1836149693,
0.6221946478,
-0.994422853,
-0.2939391732,
-0.8907700181,
0.1691090316,
0.0494376644,
-0.5777165294,
0.2706524432,
0.3553310335,
0.6757632494,
0.2642870843,
0.4595714211,
-0.3364776075,
0.5285013914,
-0.4042295814,
0.4240124822,
-1.0392050743,
0.274802953,
-0.0463810414,
-1.008190155,
-0.3644531667,
0.2400482595,
0.033329092,
0.0334097594,
0.687124908,
0.3486867845,
-0.405495286,
-0.1786738634,
0.2162624151,
0.0542890914,
0.2287661731,
0.8943671584,
0.8287131786,
0.0856598914,
0.4949257076,
-0.4222346246,
-0.2173302621,
-0.4494858384,
-1.0233403444,
-0.5139891505,
-1.0840848684,
0.0117124636,
-0.343334645,
0.2093382925,
0.6872999668,
0.6699290872,
-0.2431164682,
-0.3368339539,
0.197979033,
0.2873307168,
-0.0629571155,
-0.24447532,
0.4275470972,
-0.3546459675,
-0.6977700591,
0.4850700498,
0.224906072,
-0.1657061428,
-0.2059443444,
0.1994125545,
-0.0825342014,
-0.0443110429,
1.0349146128,
0.5337366462,
-0.7498149276,
-0.564236939,
-0.1564394534,
-0.1908453256,
-0.0064293281,
0.7677977085,
-0.7487571239,
0.5588448048,
0.374122113,
0.3871363103,
0.4429425299,
-0.1642409861,
0.3473817408,
-0.8527723551,
0.0123050706,
0.5603971481,
0.2231789231,
0.2539120913,
-0.3454121053,
0.5689911246,
-0.0085935164,
-0.5999802947,
-1.1154751778,
0.5256425142,
-1.1959704161,
-0.7886148095,
1.3969166279,
-0.0613920204,
-0.4780401587,
-0.3822300434,
-0.0210365336,
0.0387846269,
-0.219413653,
0.9841680527,
0.9035989046,
-0.34622702,
0.2456645072,
-0.6742609143,
0.7063587308,
0.5109853745,
-0.1311778873,
0.0877612308,
0.2908122838,
0.3507149518,
0.5679317713,
0.6513356566,
-0.0731979236,
0.0347077511,
-0.5005522966,
-0.4442936182,
0.2108817548,
-0.390711844,
-0.2477418035,
0.4500900507,
0.0179799497,
0.5407450795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00396v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00396v1 | A Study on Effect of Reference Knowledge Choice in Generating Technical Content Relevant to SAPPhIRE Model Using Large Language Model | 2024-06-29T10:46:01 | 2024-06-29T10:46:01 | Kausik Bhattacharya, Anubhab Majumder, Amaresh Chakrabarti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Representation of systems using the SAPPhIRE model of causality can be an
inspirational stimulus in design. However, creating a SAPPhIRE model of a
technical or a natural system requires sourcing technical knowledge from
multiple technical documents regarding how the system works. This research
investigates how to generate technical content accurately relevant to the
SAPPhIRE model of causality using a Large Language Model, also called LLM. This
paper, which is the first part of the two-part research, presents a method for
hallucination suppression using Retrieval Augmented Generating with LLM to
generate technical content supported by the scientific information relevant to
a SAPPhIRE con-struct. The result from this research shows that the selection
of reference knowledge used in providing context to the LLM for generating the
technical content is very important. The outcome of this research is used to
build a software support tool to generate the SAPPhIRE model of a given
technical system. | [
-0.3856601417,
-0.8508597612,
0.6615054011,
0.2339722067,
-0.4464017749,
-0.2742822468,
-0.1888784617,
-0.5355609655,
0.4282794297,
0.5683755279,
-0.405239284,
-0.3858810365,
-0.1402432621,
0.0683895722,
-0.4707641602,
0.7123535872,
-0.0077906679,
0.1822674572,
0.0110845305,
0.232079044,
-0.8397471309,
-0.5049972534,
-0.7963021994,
-0.6107475162,
0.4090921581,
0.2605865002,
0.5538690686,
0.2861564457,
0.7732765675,
0.3145214021,
-0.0708880797,
0.1481552273,
-0.3613942266,
0.434287101,
-0.4127264619,
-0.5178760886,
-0.411146313,
-0.1886490434,
0.6833957434,
0.2157523036,
-0.264988929,
0.1930889785,
0.1880521327,
0.5237404704,
-0.3229103684,
0.0700843111,
-0.8188952208,
0.1415189654,
-0.1617356092,
-0.7345184088,
-0.5855405927,
-0.3029346466,
-0.1891317368,
-0.6390505433,
0.2738224864,
0.2726848722,
0.8786619306,
0.4721014798,
-0.1855537891,
-0.1967392862,
-1.2120511532,
0.8053334951,
-0.6506128907,
0.4127728641,
0.3426983058,
0.2084345669,
-0.1664743274,
-0.5313235521,
-0.7382622957,
-0.3913545012,
-0.1537811607,
0.0655455291,
0.1610101312,
-0.1313611269,
0.6194675565,
0.1356918514,
-0.4104702473,
-0.0851468816,
-0.8590026498,
-0.347941488,
0.4809369743,
0.2163947821,
0.4781031907,
-0.6766654849,
-0.124791503,
0.0296474528,
-1.0220117569,
-0.5183705091,
0.0536215976,
0.1947835088,
0.2385644764,
0.92719841,
-0.0328554213,
0.7298895121,
0.042440597,
-0.2749097347,
0.1097813696,
-0.3163469136,
-0.4537860453,
0.3804303706,
0.6995176673,
0.0845184103,
0.0475772172,
-0.3636834323,
-0.0145662716,
-0.0610249192,
0.4727925956,
-0.7579900026,
0.319588542,
0.0303334929,
-0.4350809455,
-0.1322479993,
0.1510239094,
-0.2467055768,
-0.5100455284,
-0.718251884,
0.1608387977,
-0.6807199717,
-0.4016259611,
0.0008390513,
-0.2726694345,
0.2809294164,
0.1354831904,
-0.7029656768,
0.0084661758,
0.4400595129,
0.8079336286,
-0.0534384996,
-0.1229246408,
-0.5146695971,
0.7558512688,
-0.275272876,
0.5382567644,
-0.5153283477,
-0.7207432389,
-0.2937158644,
-0.1622817218,
0.2345914245,
-0.6874058247,
0.5760340691,
-0.7807084918,
-0.0481576212,
-0.0480646528,
-0.2964374423,
-0.2911379933,
-0.0543517396,
-0.7486121655,
0.9697452188,
-0.1131570935,
-0.7271895409,
0.5042170882,
-0.1067001522,
-0.5021038651,
0.2562243938,
-0.6120362878,
-0.1694201529,
0.3030508459,
-0.2924360037,
0.4070802629,
-0.3946469426,
0.667103827,
-0.2101239562,
-0.4188041389,
0.3124613166,
0.1172475368,
0.250338614,
0.2720398307,
-0.6175854802,
0.0204097088,
-1.0389100313,
-0.1358926296,
-0.1248489469,
-0.3283461034,
-0.7274590135,
0.3267949522,
-0.2704658806,
0.4372387528,
-0.0474574044,
-0.5438751578,
-0.1053268313,
-0.0369468741,
0.2337853462,
0.6246436834,
0.2512945831,
0.3529413939,
-0.1040967032,
0.3063455224,
-0.1799057275,
-0.0247226842,
0.4134415984,
-0.3441135287,
-0.7555886507,
0.0698241219,
0.0917031541,
0.5608216524,
-0.9951061606,
0.2761591077,
-0.1467894614,
-0.2949483991,
-0.1454732418,
0.0945887938,
0.3131186664,
0.5965741277,
0.2188762426,
0.0203994811,
-0.8281044364,
-1.0172696114,
0.2034634203,
-0.1425831616,
-0.2838501036,
0.4357055128,
0.1668522507,
-0.0363886021,
0.8749629855,
-0.5511524677,
-0.316345036,
-0.0915876329,
0.0445332751,
0.2836996019,
0.4277462363,
0.5026960373,
-0.6434412599,
-0.2886786461,
0.0854905695,
-1.15269804,
0.0097388495,
-0.2442894131,
-0.664096415,
0.1863450855,
0.7117489576,
-0.6652244925,
0.4456838369,
0.1838654578,
-0.2306962162,
0.5951996446,
-0.2116518319,
0.2854435742,
-1.3976056576,
0.4694838524,
0.278924644,
0.1172795519,
-0.4007992744,
0.128883183,
0.0546530895,
-0.2491317838,
-0.2371122986,
0.5155798793,
-0.2929997146,
-0.0029908963,
-0.3431496918,
0.5353844166,
-0.1626545191,
0.2408770323,
0.6392846704,
0.8745138645,
0.1647080034,
-1.0521247387,
0.4887155592,
0.2952010036,
-0.2891047597,
0.5486033559,
-0.8199657798,
-0.0367832854,
0.0013405671,
-0.3327475786,
-0.3203277886,
-0.0498070829,
0.2607758343,
-0.4835504889,
0.3388607204,
0.1464501321,
-0.6584275365,
-0.3634132743,
0.0734810457,
0.0953621194,
0.594412744,
-0.0600963868,
0.7883526087,
0.2532324195,
-0.3807584047,
-0.1357400119,
-0.8846357465,
0.0082323002,
-0.2548369467,
-0.9118494987,
0.5437448025,
-0.3532198668,
-0.6660642624,
-0.0503027774,
0.0090153003,
0.2085862309,
-0.0690470636,
0.4906375408,
0.6093870997,
-0.3931167722,
0.5507173538,
0.0260989461,
-0.1967804283,
0.1748377532,
-0.0853101164,
0.6669435501,
0.2613959908,
-0.2853473425,
-0.4748294353,
0.2372562289,
0.257011354,
0.1591532081,
1.0882964134,
0.3800186217,
-0.2209270447,
-0.3862484396,
-0.7099773288,
-0.2888692617,
-0.5048491359,
0.340067178,
-0.4016186595,
-0.4597284496,
0.4680629969,
0.2708480656,
-0.0899987519,
0.6176862717,
0.3996038735,
0.3112901747,
0.6835330725,
0.701341331,
-0.1721657217,
0.5984352231,
0.0729252025,
0.2671142519,
-1.0246368647,
-0.5547876358,
-0.7918927073,
0.0337512195,
-0.2005419582,
-0.1867760569,
0.3038491607,
0.1091663241,
-0.5277995467,
0.2124485373,
-0.6567658782,
0.107725054,
0.7853206396,
0.6993101239,
0.5330960155,
0.5223508477,
-0.2559312582,
-0.1590274125,
-0.3180079758,
-0.648286283,
0.8842332363,
-0.0653805658,
1.0240988731,
0.1596155167,
0.4039912522,
0.3000799119,
-0.1288000345,
-0.6608630419,
0.6634141207,
0.225247249,
-0.6002035737,
-0.4063887894,
-0.4510658383,
-0.4069000781,
-0.0678390339,
-0.2959688604,
-0.3873026073,
0.0791983083,
-0.0395304523,
-0.6625256538,
0.2694630325,
-0.5869570971,
-0.0085185403,
0.0365720764,
-0.6544278264,
-0.6398503184,
-0.1460956335,
0.6553692818,
-0.3151190877,
0.1986472607,
0.3732515275,
0.2812702358,
0.820571959,
-0.3323885202,
0.7224743962,
0.1689794213,
-0.1304006577,
0.3044780195,
0.3880028129,
0.5788295865,
0.2249139249,
-0.6551962495,
-0.1692533791,
-0.4539349079,
0.0278196596,
-0.4653180838,
0.8013292551,
-0.8512410522,
-1.0982005596,
-0.3599865139,
-0.4284419417,
-0.0408207588,
0.2460282743,
0.2012742758,
0.5574133396,
0.0600555278,
0.161402896,
1.0663478374,
-0.461356312,
0.4069784284,
0.5886954069,
-0.1530998349,
-0.3073101938,
0.7842333913,
0.0682301894,
0.3128631115,
0.2231987864,
-0.0788411126,
0.256226033,
-0.5834611058,
-0.2610177696,
0.6223268509,
-0.7890543938,
-0.1461464167,
-0.4242068231,
-0.7921469212,
-0.3146194816,
-0.2007331699,
0.0391440615,
-0.3493137956,
-0.5291319489,
-0.1380074322,
0.4129224122,
1.1073360443,
0.0257355198,
-0.0634557903,
-1.001773119,
0.2616237998,
0.2964945138,
0.3610197306,
0.1863748729,
-0.5433923006,
-0.4659701884,
-0.0527561307,
-0.3696010411,
-0.6997225285,
0.2816317677,
-0.1643998176,
1.0670850277,
0.3757234216,
0.0350398682,
0.6132177711,
-0.5552254319,
0.9315392375,
0.2266312093,
-0.9318287373,
0.7982099652,
-0.2227456123,
0.0828442425,
0.1839468926,
0.3706997037,
-0.4287908971,
-0.4576286376,
-0.5092769265,
-0.5231288075,
0.8049583435,
0.2235547304,
-0.0398246162,
0.0050685452,
0.6509017348,
0.0713064224,
0.1007239074,
-0.9509986043,
-0.1053502485,
0.1088739261,
0.2560897768,
0.1389454603,
-0.6149891019,
-0.0765519664,
0.0475049429,
1.2701075077,
0.3439234495,
0.2608191371,
0.3819162548,
-0.2354108691,
-0.1845789701,
0.0771382228,
0.8079368472,
0.7288906574,
-0.0876951739,
0.0737628266,
-0.0106788026,
-0.6216890216,
-0.2505226433,
-0.2583609223,
-0.6016787887,
0.1744867861,
0.2184268832,
0.7775116563,
-0.0195037909,
-0.2609033287,
-0.2404874861,
0.1019927934,
-0.1945210397,
-0.2967538834,
0.2687220275,
-0.0321851633,
0.3859733343,
0.4916048348,
-0.0441182964,
0.0096952636,
-0.3433811069,
0.0293866936,
0.5677927136,
-0.1663441062,
-0.0718241781,
0.5685726404,
0.1821758896,
-0.3001295924,
0.8479490876,
-0.0596728623,
-0.1574831009,
0.6474605799,
0.6149190664,
0.528714776,
-0.3961193264,
0.3646520972,
0.7691743374,
0.3518911004,
0.0225971043,
0.2429560125,
0.0160617977,
-0.5854765177,
-0.4636098146,
-0.7264101505,
-0.1515769064,
0.0273027234,
-0.4841442406,
0.7311728001,
-0.3458490372,
-0.3199431002,
-0.1539095491,
-0.0994481444,
-0.3681198955,
0.1558912992,
0.1775947809,
0.8354481459,
-0.6370793581,
0.758025527,
0.3882526755,
-0.8939313293,
-1.3270123005,
-0.1821651161,
-0.3503089547,
-0.7071905136,
1.2768545151,
-0.6280406713,
-0.295337975,
-0.1496651024,
-0.3389698267,
-1.1025687456,
1.314748168,
0.273052156,
-0.5555700064,
-0.1506769806,
0.1768060774,
0.4515646994,
-0.1460891366,
0.170549497,
0.0966804922,
0.3679343462,
0.8082143664,
-0.9785459042,
0.4880951047,
-0.329859376,
0.2171369344,
0.0809255242,
-0.4652027488,
0.7321659923,
0.0008116619,
-0.2780745029,
-0.009732197,
0.6009027958,
0.719917655,
-0.1337040067,
-0.0539608039,
0.1942639202,
0.6467368007,
0.2263664007,
0.9202669263,
-0.6754108071,
0.0970366597,
0.9996221066,
-0.3843475878,
0.8727789521,
0.6520937681,
-0.0381085947,
0.7943458557,
0.5570033193,
-0.0738279894,
0.5232031345,
0.2473568618,
-0.4233123958,
-0.2973703146,
-0.045531828,
-0.8722558618,
-0.1002741382,
0.4125975668,
-0.6123818159,
-0.0553208403,
0.1088664383,
0.0554152653,
-0.2425625473,
-0.4275113344,
0.7668408155,
0.2929477394,
-0.9298161864,
0.4655518532,
-0.0290936604,
0.4300028086,
-0.7355622053,
-0.0707407072,
-0.3523440659,
0.1181610152,
-0.4953362048,
-0.5268716216,
0.5317336321,
-0.1700153053,
-0.4803390205,
0.0935968757,
0.9131362438,
-0.1714493185,
-0.6422376037,
0.1242657155,
0.1487368345,
0.0991186053,
-0.1132247373,
-0.0487590767,
0.0741629675,
0.0549284145,
-0.3006855249,
0.1685997993,
0.4406001866,
-0.1348643899,
0.6252663732,
0.4778268337,
0.4771839678,
0.074713029,
0.1055658683,
0.9756087661,
-0.8254777789,
-0.4879567623,
-0.9033924937,
0.3256019652,
-0.3925744593,
0.303611517,
1.1384677887,
0.6316950917,
0.3446967304,
-0.1315509826,
1.0532696247,
-0.2288685292,
0.3192453682,
-0.8800427318,
0.7422261238,
-0.3997979164,
0.6189114451,
-0.4697499871,
-1.047190547,
-0.3374913037,
0.4658764303,
-0.3310065269,
-0.0019142909,
1.0468484163,
0.9987578392,
0.0499897674,
0.305947572,
0.2863928974,
0.3499111831,
0.0495553613,
0.329823792,
0.7743474245,
-0.1923676282,
0.5183800459,
-0.0788183436,
-0.2293521911,
0.0884879008,
-0.8729508519,
-0.9907445908,
-0.6281528473,
-0.2546343505,
-0.8116956353,
-0.1963869631,
0.680015862,
0.530115664,
-0.6951901317,
-0.3265136182,
-0.1224241331,
0.1178369746,
0.2807052732,
-0.1867891252,
0.3710369468,
-0.4346088767,
-0.3272327781,
0.1716803014,
0.1707188934,
-0.0003234205,
-0.4047405422,
-0.1718099266,
0.0377100706,
-0.0283093899,
0.8197982907,
0.1026473716,
-0.5690813065,
-0.2189468741,
0.3407820463,
-0.2350494415,
-0.1450949758,
1.122697711,
-0.8869374394,
0.0041603609,
0.5920796394,
0.0969369784,
0.6335108876,
-0.446279794,
0.8422319293,
-0.417129755,
0.2119704932,
-0.1669622511,
0.5179010034,
0.0350220874,
-0.8301932812,
0.5578389764,
0.2804642916,
-0.5425216556,
-0.4081055522,
0.1886748672,
-0.8537131548,
-0.4036919773,
1.5901836157,
0.4113849401,
-0.2328853905,
-0.0616197586,
-0.5249954462,
0.3963420093,
-0.267927438,
1.0645074844,
0.8514770269,
-0.0963848829,
-0.0852949992,
-0.5019288659,
0.4177048504,
0.0277338177,
-0.6799762845,
-0.2984371185,
0.6199056506,
0.3956732452,
0.4667708576,
0.3006800115,
-0.1104099974,
0.0902998671,
0.0170572419,
0.5444256663,
-0.1985529661,
-0.0833342746,
0.0796260387,
0.22906138,
0.2119974941,
0.2295556068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00390v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00390v1 | Advancing Process Verification for Large Language Models via Tree-Based Preference Learning | 2024-06-29T10:09:49 | 2024-06-29T10:09:49 | Mingqian He, Yongliang Shen, Wenqi Zhang, Zeqi Tan, Weiming Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable potential in
handling complex reasoning tasks by generating step-by-step rationales.Some
methods have proven effective in boosting accuracy by introducing extra
verifiers to assess these paths. However, existing verifiers, typically trained
on binary-labeled reasoning paths, fail to fully utilize the relative merits of
intermediate steps, thereby limiting the effectiveness of the feedback
provided. To overcome this limitation, we propose Tree-based Preference
Learning Verifier (Tree-PLV), a novel approach that constructs reasoning trees
via a best-first search algorithm and collects step-level paired data for
preference training. Compared to traditional binary classification, step-level
preferences more finely capture the nuances between reasoning steps, allowing
for a more precise evaluation of the complete reasoning path. We empirically
evaluate Tree-PLV across a range of arithmetic and commonsense reasoning tasks,
where it significantly outperforms existing benchmarks. For instance, Tree-PLV
achieved substantial performance gains over the Mistral-7B self-consistency
baseline on GSM8K (67.55% to 82.79%), MATH (17.00% to 26.80%), CSQA (68.14% to
72.97%), and StrategyQA (82.86% to 83.25%).Additionally, our study explores the
appropriate granularity for applying preference learning, revealing that
step-level guidance provides feedback that better aligns with the evaluation of
the reasoning process. | [
-0.1404267251,
-0.7642815709,
0.8061933517,
-0.1555777639,
-0.157294631,
0.2526028156,
-0.321856916,
-0.0682645142,
-0.3116451204,
0.45664078,
-0.4091957808,
-0.6147741675,
-0.5695640445,
0.071356535,
0.0484999716,
0.8253999352,
-0.1883194298,
-0.1633527577,
-0.3123868108,
-0.0007263594,
-0.3060281575,
-0.7947185636,
-0.7527648211,
-0.4701373279,
0.3711053133,
0.5102396011,
0.6107057333,
0.6392111778,
0.0779904351,
0.3281805515,
-0.2375858575,
0.4517671168,
-0.2444147617,
0.2445702404,
-0.1446204334,
-0.4118035436,
-0.4069471359,
-0.114328444,
0.4728100598,
0.4363781512,
-0.1495326906,
0.1904655844,
-0.0964141488,
0.7354289293,
-0.5355039835,
0.3445745707,
-0.8338432312,
0.1062912047,
-0.1461410522,
-0.4635560215,
-0.7147145867,
-0.4951078594,
0.1335434765,
-0.349514395,
-0.042107597,
0.0620395802,
0.9229069948,
0.3460432589,
-0.798040688,
-0.0770687833,
-0.6529195309,
0.7950999141,
-0.6306068301,
0.4272665977,
0.6700255871,
0.504052937,
-0.1469581872,
-0.5561966896,
-0.331594795,
-0.4116184711,
-0.0088300779,
-0.0964308679,
-0.0046562264,
0.2258480489,
0.6897813082,
0.3558063209,
-0.4006629288,
-0.0168323461,
0.0214023702,
-0.4232014418,
0.5220396519,
-0.041951783,
0.0986708403,
-0.2185270637,
-0.0343585573,
-0.1814073622,
-0.7680806518,
0.8074144125,
0.2288622707,
0.1399941444,
0.3084969521,
0.5086402297,
-0.5770787597,
0.7557141781,
0.4226592779,
-0.4959276915,
0.3979553878,
-0.3003357351,
-0.4248784482,
0.1616721153,
0.6421328783,
0.1287094951,
0.1405925751,
0.083050549,
-0.1880672723,
0.0030938091,
-0.0512049086,
-0.9415071607,
-0.290474683,
0.2965672612,
-0.2828169167,
-0.1091414168,
-0.178080827,
-0.0569467843,
-0.4559613466,
-0.4981934726,
0.06231061,
-0.5590167642,
-0.3257972896,
0.1200578585,
0.3926256895,
0.43406564,
0.7375454903,
-0.8306581378,
0.0787028074,
1.0768761635,
0.7296882272,
-0.0372787863,
-0.0866115466,
-1.0277668238,
-0.0287130587,
-0.426404506,
0.6896360517,
-0.7362581491,
-0.1507515609,
-0.2211921513,
0.0563663654,
0.1093373448,
-0.5516365767,
0.9371489286,
-0.419239074,
0.0372769982,
-0.3587244749,
-0.5191943049,
-0.2850262821,
0.4774173796,
-0.3150770962,
1.2080917358,
-0.1230920106,
-0.7646241188,
0.6643661857,
-0.3200885653,
-0.4528058767,
0.1383811235,
-0.3440588415,
-0.5169675946,
-0.0429495871,
0.2410661727,
0.6054881215,
-0.0316656642,
0.5062091947,
-0.5032420754,
-0.1276943535,
0.0706328973,
-0.5094716549,
0.864620626,
0.1008832753,
-0.4136624932,
0.5677105784,
-0.6084125638,
0.1763062328,
-0.0667105615,
-0.4681549072,
-0.3860836029,
0.1204033941,
-0.5756807327,
0.3192970753,
0.2457633466,
-0.7935456634,
0.3072011471,
-0.4950248003,
0.611466229,
0.9145379663,
-0.1350990683,
0.2561222315,
-0.2942372561,
0.2893776596,
0.0578059219,
0.1510995924,
-0.2803955972,
-0.5567291975,
-0.7208397985,
-0.0357909389,
0.1982517838,
0.4500305057,
-0.5304919481,
0.6143174171,
-0.3681320548,
-0.3807025552,
-0.1563292891,
0.0198081601,
0.2992806137,
0.6008771062,
0.1007800624,
-0.3844369054,
-0.5221011639,
-0.6768255234,
0.239070639,
-0.6704963446,
0.1076938882,
0.5995488763,
0.3571271002,
0.0427665971,
1.0343465805,
-0.1733550727,
0.1056080684,
-0.1058371812,
-0.0389232449,
0.3587725163,
0.3271886408,
-0.0040303799,
-0.6892920136,
-0.6162842512,
0.4344688356,
-0.3702993095,
-0.0066994121,
0.0106262974,
-0.0028355969,
0.572332263,
0.1232089847,
-0.246368736,
0.2243237197,
0.597885251,
-0.3909866512,
0.5669184923,
-0.4262408018,
0.2748576999,
-0.7713696361,
0.0188834406,
0.0833977908,
-0.7519127727,
-0.3634767234,
-0.2111279964,
0.0789000168,
0.3560436964,
-0.3813850582,
0.2178705782,
-0.1480173022,
-0.074436225,
-0.2135730535,
-0.2956434488,
-0.1282469332,
0.5085382462,
0.4507856369,
0.7219142914,
0.6812320352,
-0.3941136599,
0.2171028256,
-0.1332050264,
-0.2363921255,
0.5631461143,
-0.4627256393,
0.2962107658,
0.0002519777,
0.5745489001,
-1.1135460138,
-0.0465914495,
0.1551552713,
-0.4153183103,
0.0884192884,
-0.671196878,
-0.5577696562,
-0.3100013435,
-0.2342908829,
0.1685311645,
0.6151447296,
-0.7589895129,
0.8463281989,
0.3238758147,
0.0256648622,
-0.7432962656,
-0.1605852544,
-0.0882782862,
-0.1454269737,
-0.8354818225,
-0.0460024625,
-0.1580030173,
0.0159745924,
-0.4343923628,
-0.6735646725,
-0.1766660661,
0.2604057789,
0.6810185909,
0.3017896712,
-0.0539091863,
-0.1102084443,
-0.0259864554,
-0.3144521713,
0.237432465,
-0.3405081034,
0.2968169451,
-0.4665544331,
-0.5612853169,
-0.3676081598,
-0.0752110481,
0.704202652,
-0.3995254636,
0.1589439809,
0.3355876803,
-0.1481477469,
-0.2814868987,
-0.5926120281,
-0.1271969378,
-0.4465354383,
0.0936005339,
-0.7409576178,
-1.1784529686,
0.0825564265,
-0.4435855448,
0.3826003373,
0.0861691013,
0.4851811826,
0.0028617997,
1.2690588236,
0.1968469471,
0.0756429806,
0.2480437458,
-0.2058420777,
0.3385438621,
-0.6216780543,
-0.3137747049,
-0.5019542575,
0.0621877201,
-0.3977006674,
-0.5997164845,
0.3208055794,
0.0714700967,
-0.4398749471,
0.1126775593,
-0.463734448,
0.5653156042,
0.6308845282,
0.0668926686,
0.6450619102,
0.0579209886,
-0.3196725547,
0.0255439784,
-0.5329244137,
-0.6757485271,
1.0779560804,
0.5916404724,
0.3093600273,
-0.0571982265,
0.8852404356,
0.0500213876,
0.314242959,
-0.9302607775,
0.6957383156,
-0.2242015004,
-0.3828046322,
-0.4388040304,
-0.5289812088,
-0.6887695193,
0.2634341717,
-0.0673169196,
-0.6919113994,
-0.1683928818,
0.5205754042,
-0.3884817064,
0.3800751269,
-0.6976774931,
0.8659909368,
-0.5135699511,
-0.6460472345,
-0.2560547292,
-0.5110961199,
0.5255917907,
0.0852635056,
0.1374990046,
-0.1955657005,
0.204815194,
0.5235507488,
-0.6022067666,
0.8066919446,
-0.3726811707,
-0.0900839791,
0.0688419938,
0.1739126742,
0.892274797,
0.039793957,
-0.0356799215,
0.0047780359,
0.1946826726,
-0.0874170735,
-0.6436029673,
0.5920146108,
-0.7337966561,
-0.8978786469,
-0.6690813303,
-0.1259556711,
-0.3733596802,
0.070089139,
-0.3180394769,
0.1617522389,
0.1323343217,
0.3611294925,
0.9612344503,
0.0133253727,
0.2711083591,
0.5235248208,
-0.53658849,
-0.344124496,
0.8399620652,
-0.0538278483,
0.217508778,
0.4571890831,
0.6704239249,
-0.4549874663,
-0.9088215232,
-0.542473793,
0.0184911732,
-0.5124161839,
-0.0678729564,
-0.5547516346,
-0.2421994656,
-0.0655037835,
0.0484317727,
-0.3921522498,
-0.2746982276,
0.2676691115,
-0.2342089266,
0.3914954662,
0.4865312576,
0.1766588241,
0.0313342474,
-0.490034759,
0.0840331614,
0.6041592956,
0.4341896772,
-0.0949577764,
-0.6421899199,
0.1114436686,
-0.093961224,
-0.2071270645,
-0.5532314777,
0.0687834248,
-0.1328903735,
0.3901385069,
0.419932276,
0.0251578633,
0.6688425541,
-0.4299177825,
0.7220974565,
0.1709444225,
-1.0967626572,
0.6801671982,
-0.0775252953,
0.1396402866,
0.6571033001,
0.2362650484,
-0.4638521671,
-0.1183463633,
-0.7014143467,
-0.8839105964,
0.8746404648,
0.0700896457,
-0.2615131736,
0.3706021011,
0.1941399574,
0.2419244498,
-0.0412925892,
-0.7350656986,
-0.2682031989,
-0.3302389383,
0.1536399722,
0.1591328382,
-0.2265988737,
0.1288902014,
-0.4292442501,
0.9258061647,
-0.410900265,
-0.5140126348,
0.1940610856,
0.1566663533,
-0.1329275519,
0.5573437214,
0.0758996755,
0.5861296654,
-0.409368515,
0.4146366119,
0.2143508047,
-0.1228188127,
0.4543697536,
-0.0930546373,
-0.5243681073,
-0.0551235117,
0.045736216,
0.9858511686,
-0.1878263801,
-0.5213662386,
0.622806251,
-0.1890296489,
-0.2949488759,
-0.1709630042,
0.1175696701,
0.0886625126,
-0.0482742526,
0.0230111498,
0.096140109,
0.0726917237,
-0.3641242683,
0.2006285042,
0.6346629262,
-0.2035282403,
-0.17690216,
0.1078893244,
0.256261766,
-0.2883235514,
0.2891900539,
-0.273355186,
-0.4496922493,
0.4315248132,
0.3145899475,
0.8206697106,
-0.2678054273,
0.4322290719,
0.6864729524,
0.1289754361,
-0.2979644537,
0.1213951781,
-0.6673981547,
-0.5532029271,
-0.7239451408,
-0.6893832088,
-0.6900711656,
0.2278133184,
-0.1056156009,
0.1765324324,
-0.6668219566,
-0.164908573,
0.0068413825,
0.2115520835,
-0.3635017872,
0.1593733728,
0.3143184781,
0.8630205393,
-0.8485305905,
1.2171008587,
0.9262799025,
-0.2150155008,
-1.1533254385,
-0.1035610735,
0.0186338387,
-0.6927155256,
0.7861632109,
0.3527647555,
-0.3307752013,
-0.1333310157,
-0.2834246457,
-0.8000743985,
0.996870935,
0.3797729015,
-0.8148217797,
0.0691911429,
0.0928976983,
0.3909538686,
-0.2840747237,
0.692738235,
0.5031608939,
0.5509034395,
0.667368114,
-0.9718916416,
0.1520102024,
-0.0757155642,
0.0056573194,
0.1125188023,
-0.403899014,
0.3409727514,
-0.1203637868,
-0.2143404186,
-0.2996009886,
0.5691295862,
0.7281783223,
0.3359283805,
0.9594253898,
0.5171756744,
0.9963604808,
-0.1059868485,
0.8881837726,
-0.3877684772,
0.259883076,
1.3475358486,
-0.3784210086,
1.0028016567,
0.4755236804,
-0.4038875997,
0.607785821,
0.8196896911,
0.4060681164,
0.0869086236,
0.3441601992,
-0.2716433108,
-0.8334648013,
-0.2486035824,
-0.0332761593,
0.1222835407,
0.2100191414,
-0.2810797095,
-0.1740458459,
-0.4186395407,
0.0314188488,
0.0038537276,
-0.3495869637,
0.738280952,
-0.0925606191,
-1.0632307529,
0.6145170927,
-0.1556233019,
0.6064324975,
-0.725974381,
-0.1448952854,
0.0364770107,
0.1434863806,
-0.4792346656,
-1.0173588991,
0.1162541658,
0.0627775937,
-0.0743991211,
-0.6367622018,
0.6530789137,
-0.2231106907,
-0.2565658391,
0.1039808914,
0.3600004613,
0.0149214314,
-0.0975106806,
-0.6146558523,
0.0893959701,
0.2644166648,
-0.0789828226,
0.1497747004,
0.576649785,
-0.2677110136,
0.6812601686,
0.878854692,
0.1138652489,
-0.0452212803,
0.059060242,
0.5826178193,
-0.411334306,
-0.4342666268,
-0.9888253212,
0.4626533985,
-0.1663865149,
-0.1120142788,
0.8173663616,
0.8119215965,
1.0861836672,
0.212954089,
0.9482380748,
-0.0041344599,
0.2470518649,
-0.4560079873,
0.1236157119,
-0.1918788403,
0.4366689026,
0.0023175061,
-0.6958808303,
-0.2478827983,
0.710668385,
-0.6841680408,
0.0115221264,
0.7542085052,
0.8474941254,
-0.2206355631,
0.0213429332,
0.3188115358,
0.2705875635,
0.4932967126,
1.085198164,
0.9762760401,
0.1646338552,
0.4778523743,
-0.3793946803,
-0.5684630275,
-0.1256663054,
-1.1608210802,
-0.8839697242,
-0.5291092992,
-0.6102309227,
-0.5098623037,
0.1476985216,
1.2422554493,
1.0266706944,
-0.8230966926,
-0.4137173891,
-0.4274919331,
0.295081079,
-0.1213326007,
-0.1633320004,
0.3940626383,
-0.2861159742,
-0.4260636866,
0.1845210493,
0.5397591591,
-0.2021992654,
-0.360923022,
-0.3456378281,
-0.0095370002,
-0.1912944019,
0.6449756026,
0.4035995007,
-1.1634843349,
-0.347375989,
-0.1431042552,
0.0648483709,
0.5884653926,
1.0408169031,
-1.0859565735,
0.520504117,
0.7344821095,
0.7219426632,
0.5285021663,
0.0444584005,
0.3580442071,
-0.4063495696,
-0.5990859866,
0.0814711004,
0.5654049516,
0.3857268095,
-0.2717452645,
0.3237873614,
0.2052938491,
-0.6712825894,
-0.600933075,
0.4198018312,
-1.2806164026,
0.0581478812,
1.3149089813,
-0.418324858,
-0.4467833936,
-0.1870694309,
-0.6348791122,
0.0730234087,
-0.9024500847,
0.6049804091,
0.6194812059,
-0.274838239,
-0.165841803,
-0.119505845,
0.5836422443,
0.4779136181,
-0.8508424163,
0.6238924265,
0.7016168237,
0.4675189555,
0.1339071244,
0.7706180215,
0.0476789512,
0.2702258527,
-0.6169239879,
-0.3341516256,
-0.3542547524,
-0.3214340806,
-0.4082759619,
0.5878821015,
0.6400085092,
0.0281455591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00379v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00379v1 | GraphArena: Benchmarking Large Language Models on Graph Computational Problems | 2024-06-29T09:19:23 | 2024-06-29T09:19:23 | Jianheng Tang, Qifan Zhang, Yuhan Li, Jia Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The "arms race" of Large Language Models (LLMs) demands novel, challenging,
and diverse benchmarks to faithfully examine their progresses. We introduce
GraphArena, a benchmarking tool designed to evaluate LLMs on graph
computational problems using million-scale real-world graphs from diverse
scenarios such as knowledge graphs, social networks, and molecular structures.
GraphArena offers a suite of 10 computational tasks, encompassing four
polynomial-time (e.g., Shortest Distance) and six NP-complete challenges (e.g.,
Travelling Salesman Problem). It features a rigorous evaluation framework that
classifies LLM outputs as correct, suboptimal (feasible but not optimal), or
hallucinatory (properly formatted but infeasible). Evaluation of 10 leading
LLMs, including GPT-4o and LLaMA3-70B-Instruct, reveals that even
top-performing models struggle with larger, more complex graph problems and
exhibit hallucination issues. Despite the application of strategies such as
chain-of-thought prompting, these issues remain unresolved. GraphArena
contributes a valuable supplement to the existing LLM benchmarks and is
open-sourced at https://github.com/squareRoot3/GraphArena. | [
-0.3075500727,
-0.84767735,
0.7038660049,
0.2347865999,
0.0245022476,
0.573489964,
-0.3602790833,
-0.5788908005,
0.1956716329,
0.5657525659,
-0.2804252207,
-0.6690578461,
-0.8333226442,
0.1608007103,
-0.4894354939,
0.4904835522,
-0.2045107186,
0.1295318305,
-0.2125887722,
-0.3213984072,
-0.2266272604,
-0.6486923695,
-0.8204410672,
-0.3610257506,
0.7828957438,
0.1740726829,
0.5657575727,
0.498696208,
0.3928081989,
0.3676923513,
-0.1922422796,
0.5078503489,
-0.6466053128,
0.2864131927,
0.0200468022,
-0.2768611908,
-0.3493873477,
-0.0959845334,
0.6424591541,
0.9898819923,
0.1277632117,
0.3473836184,
-0.0984572396,
0.670768857,
-0.6044301391,
0.323725909,
-0.6676006913,
-0.1182625741,
-0.3230422139,
0.3021009266,
-0.2310812175,
-0.5755522847,
-0.232444331,
-0.5163339376,
-0.0939278007,
0.3406439424,
0.7470980883,
0.0571198016,
-0.3783090115,
-0.1903385967,
-0.61791116,
0.2366965264,
-0.443143338,
0.4379812479,
0.1668998599,
0.5383110642,
-0.4396146238,
-0.7873418927,
-0.5386918783,
-0.2802283764,
0.4810592234,
-0.1814269722,
-0.7290900946,
-0.120733656,
0.3187073469,
-0.0258257631,
-0.6401615143,
0.3015509546,
-0.329623282,
-0.1432621926,
0.4262729883,
0.1496060938,
0.3511460125,
0.2123493552,
0.1673175693,
-0.3210631311,
-0.8577424288,
-0.3489049375,
0.7029795647,
0.4674393833,
0.0860607252,
0.5883879662,
-0.1385782659,
0.6726587415,
-0.3701640666,
0.5521976948,
0.3037317395,
0.0156832263,
0.0055725765,
-0.0837440193,
0.9180052876,
0.3081497252,
0.4789380431,
-0.4359720349,
-0.0160726346,
0.3146835566,
0.1214104518,
-0.957005322,
-0.3162848949,
0.165659681,
-0.1064667627,
-0.2281053662,
-0.4362699687,
-1.0153850317,
-0.4140283167,
-0.0221091472,
0.2566505671,
-0.1670340598,
-0.1712163538,
-0.0543576814,
-0.090056859,
-0.2392485291,
0.1765661687,
-0.6834759712,
0.5403373241,
0.9408274889,
1.2351206541,
-0.3098950684,
-0.4218623638,
-0.6694076657,
-0.0838174298,
-0.6605277658,
1.0843518972,
-0.6655034423,
-0.296051681,
-0.0710279644,
-0.0087259011,
-0.288317889,
-0.8347580433,
0.1989442557,
-0.3967180848,
-0.4270249605,
-0.2710945606,
-0.4425109625,
-0.1270884573,
0.353951335,
-0.9400338531,
1.0848784447,
0.1389583051,
-0.4881559908,
-0.0884872675,
-0.4564746916,
-0.4330956936,
-0.0440602601,
-0.2947194278,
-0.3186575174,
0.0269567054,
0.0282996669,
0.1723448336,
-0.6263509989,
0.2148333043,
-0.6515270472,
-0.3622192144,
0.2511239946,
-0.1702962518,
0.5864710808,
0.1614377052,
-0.4322349429,
0.485722065,
-0.6701917648,
0.0471205264,
0.3644808829,
0.1651901156,
-0.1324271262,
-0.0201391187,
0.0705602616,
0.0113000702,
0.2294364274,
-0.4024608135,
0.2102124393,
-0.2757583857,
0.7557224631,
0.880851686,
-0.1184276715,
-0.2312895209,
-0.2158132941,
0.6911622286,
-0.3172599971,
0.0759026632,
0.3260368407,
-0.5090131164,
-0.6713008881,
-0.1180860698,
0.3204961121,
0.5101345181,
-0.4235079288,
0.1061724499,
-0.3851311803,
-0.8998980522,
-0.2231933475,
0.04788398,
0.4539843798,
0.3181774914,
0.2257375866,
-0.1666667312,
-0.4093995392,
-0.7740162611,
-0.2383454144,
-0.1273663789,
0.1789607853,
0.3825823069,
0.6421223283,
-0.275396049,
0.3810374439,
-0.5476986766,
-0.3482010067,
-0.1913648695,
0.0488901548,
0.0336955898,
0.1161275879,
0.3977357745,
-0.3025867343,
-0.2718122602,
0.3880817294,
-0.8271881342,
-0.2113686651,
0.3918339312,
-0.088516511,
0.0291905645,
0.6488526464,
-0.691339612,
0.0026283306,
0.8828840852,
-0.1553781778,
0.5442706347,
-0.1058856472,
0.1342097521,
-1.0091538429,
0.318992883,
-0.1769598722,
-0.2923338711,
-0.3024530113,
0.1710536778,
-0.2274704278,
-0.4812816381,
-0.174263224,
0.5926398635,
-0.4453179836,
-0.4805953205,
-0.1935987771,
0.5724594593,
-0.0568853542,
0.3470686078,
-0.3994555175,
1.0475145578,
0.4427042305,
-0.1844816357,
0.2705485225,
0.0340906754,
-0.3953360617,
0.1053400189,
-0.718365252,
0.558165729,
0.1275507361,
0.2794696093,
-1.0703207254,
0.0106195454,
0.1377333701,
-0.1450764239,
-0.1603514701,
-0.1898220628,
-0.7875415683,
-0.3824702799,
-0.0739456043,
0.5826410055,
0.2992787063,
-0.4180285335,
0.7859489322,
0.6555879712,
-0.123238571,
-0.3773573935,
-0.2358973175,
0.379770577,
-0.1779318601,
-0.421882689,
0.247278288,
0.0174327753,
-0.2734635174,
0.0316125415,
-0.0613199808,
0.0955898091,
0.2672016323,
0.2709842324,
0.0167779624,
-0.0284501053,
-0.1093679145,
-0.0850702822,
-0.1452190578,
0.1933206171,
-0.3977936804,
0.9550309181,
-0.2064973265,
-0.4173751175,
0.0706167072,
0.34524104,
0.5163778067,
-0.2540940344,
0.2935042977,
0.2329149246,
-0.4848424196,
-0.2974713445,
-0.4409602284,
0.0457458571,
-0.4040327668,
0.6022521853,
-0.4378332198,
-0.9978191853,
0.9176558852,
-0.5935471058,
-0.15454261,
0.3764816225,
0.5343407393,
0.3554517031,
1.1647322178,
0.2472779006,
-0.2605214417,
0.244223699,
-0.3931711912,
0.3446639478,
-0.8154612184,
-0.1532465369,
-0.8833259344,
-0.1815622449,
-0.4190629721,
-0.6740267873,
0.3462195694,
0.0663300976,
-0.3952639103,
0.5229947567,
-0.415146172,
0.6149888039,
0.1322842389,
-0.0240354184,
0.3759782016,
-0.0907148048,
-0.243821919,
0.2877016664,
-0.7102345228,
-0.541318357,
1.2221776247,
0.1044710279,
0.5634048581,
0.1333513558,
0.555346787,
0.2899112701,
0.4871368408,
-0.617818892,
0.7391434312,
-0.3348986804,
-0.2935150862,
-0.1807805747,
-0.691095829,
-1.2766532898,
0.3590970337,
0.1324888617,
-1.0421508551,
0.0046453122,
0.1576119363,
-0.0386349298,
0.4043697119,
-0.4169967473,
1.2638703585,
-0.3413435519,
-0.3338491917,
-0.3492150605,
-0.1213005558,
0.1083110273,
-0.1772550344,
0.3556358218,
-0.5155051351,
0.0912226439,
0.7707884908,
-0.5471628308,
0.8239160776,
-0.0634473637,
-0.0746091083,
0.1170690283,
0.3482528925,
0.6885690093,
-0.1787935793,
-0.0443591848,
0.4679415524,
0.0566659085,
-0.2503873408,
-0.6023557186,
0.8495230675,
-0.7898332477,
-0.4492917359,
-0.5077848434,
-0.3779637814,
-0.4756145775,
0.5245258212,
0.2495365292,
0.4156841636,
-0.4035819769,
-0.1649007797,
0.5608156919,
0.0378926024,
0.0194499008,
0.1517314166,
-0.6878677607,
-0.5208073854,
0.9639127254,
0.3422197402,
0.1704628915,
0.0712900907,
0.0778214857,
-0.2082736939,
-0.9026221633,
-0.6899909377,
0.1565753073,
-0.9721027613,
-0.2336475998,
-0.6741287708,
-0.0298402738,
-0.2084454,
0.1989816129,
-0.6296788454,
-0.2980326116,
0.0423413105,
-0.0548191704,
0.3819018602,
0.8212291002,
0.2579937279,
0.0564446673,
-0.338285327,
0.231496051,
0.0708242431,
0.4010621607,
0.3258078992,
-0.1441308111,
-0.1884014457,
-0.2977917194,
-0.1047370955,
-0.7019022107,
0.1910939813,
-0.0195732769,
0.4981072545,
0.0332644843,
-0.2032926679,
0.854245007,
-0.6722732782,
0.3956159949,
-0.0403347835,
-0.8679823875,
0.1843871176,
-0.2980404198,
0.1282853484,
0.7296435833,
0.3326661289,
-0.4921095073,
-0.3987680376,
-0.2095411122,
-1.0760469437,
0.0443130434,
0.2056450099,
0.0088906027,
-0.2665963471,
0.1479980499,
-0.1534874588,
0.1625334173,
-0.435677737,
-0.1606867462,
-0.0113588944,
-0.2128584087,
-0.1853047162,
0.1236019656,
-0.3300149441,
0.0196282361,
0.5307959914,
-0.3629505038,
0.2130002975,
0.0065825176,
-0.3266785443,
-0.0248532873,
-0.1151521131,
0.5610788465,
0.7917008996,
-0.0713254437,
0.2285084873,
0.1772896945,
-0.2671972513,
0.0680903345,
0.3662575483,
-0.1133854389,
-0.2116769403,
0.434546262,
0.7338350415,
0.2983334363,
-1.0238057375,
0.2412295491,
-0.1204729676,
-0.1768995374,
-0.4300144315,
-0.0395875722,
0.2991320491,
0.338721633,
0.3198304772,
-0.0886409134,
0.1609500647,
-0.4800893664,
-0.0241715349,
0.5649420619,
-0.3951785564,
-0.2529490292,
0.7241970301,
-0.0745631754,
-0.421872437,
0.4822029173,
-0.2723702192,
-0.6129058003,
0.73024863,
0.611557126,
1.090364933,
0.1731069982,
0.0552653819,
0.1973908246,
0.2307259291,
-0.1145373732,
0.2490109801,
0.2151116878,
-0.6310440302,
-0.3982194066,
-0.4401123226,
-0.6453647017,
0.0384843461,
-0.2703106999,
-0.0920626894,
-0.6460875273,
-0.3538106382,
0.2642949522,
-0.0075685531,
-0.4362630844,
-0.3663978279,
-0.1222746596,
0.8290669918,
-0.7866227627,
0.6252211332,
0.3831832707,
-0.1633530706,
-0.8327937722,
-0.1486243904,
0.0505984798,
-0.7396993041,
0.5054020882,
0.2531899214,
-0.7259702086,
0.0481674671,
-0.1230690256,
-0.7977588177,
0.8842945099,
0.6516465545,
-0.8351805806,
0.0501981713,
0.0475483574,
0.6103658676,
-0.4515447915,
0.1627168357,
0.5448598266,
0.5124095082,
-0.1645061374,
-0.6966902018,
0.2176288366,
-0.4804814756,
0.1035198048,
0.3183020353,
-0.9864894748,
0.7375549674,
0.0216919091,
-0.11605075,
0.1618077159,
0.3843385875,
0.3818725944,
0.2313630432,
0.5213034749,
0.5900459886,
1.055431962,
-0.1066226512,
1.006709218,
-0.5075670481,
0.2334154546,
1.0652791262,
-0.9204828143,
0.8799000382,
0.1759319305,
-0.3606027067,
0.5275990963,
0.6735690832,
-0.1462818384,
0.0828310326,
0.6533414125,
-0.0913376659,
-0.2184485495,
-0.1883523911,
-0.3300968707,
0.413149029,
0.161251843,
-0.0002956287,
-0.2058733255,
-0.0976179764,
0.2548212409,
0.2950100899,
-0.1190315932,
0.5780670643,
0.0734737441,
-0.5860238075,
0.7078473568,
-0.1563552916,
0.1290272772,
-0.5873432755,
-0.1052133963,
-0.3772378266,
0.1740105301,
0.0508155301,
-0.316973418,
0.1842222959,
0.0955331251,
0.0053320774,
0.2237474173,
0.4412657619,
-0.1772305816,
-0.7618096471,
0.8573077321,
0.3133306205,
0.2343585342,
-0.2552838624,
-0.5854797959,
0.7205013633,
-0.3244929612,
-0.1034085676,
0.4715995491,
0.3316565752,
-0.5130958557,
1.0035535097,
0.6600158215,
0.2417987883,
-0.1002859026,
0.5074147582,
1.0741884708,
-0.5141510963,
-0.2898169458,
-0.8864084482,
-0.3388880491,
-0.1916859001,
-0.3543011844,
0.8730119467,
1.0099983215,
0.6004676223,
0.2128133476,
0.7216978073,
0.2241552919,
0.1855314523,
-0.5171396732,
0.7774404287,
-0.35497576,
0.1723336279,
-0.4481523633,
-1.0778975487,
-0.3520951867,
0.4987013638,
-0.3185818493,
0.1248762533,
0.7282083035,
0.8262035847,
0.11357034,
-0.1623881459,
0.0738200992,
0.1584915668,
0.392347753,
0.6703090072,
0.7933294773,
-0.3201777041,
0.7515597939,
0.0254566148,
-0.1367025822,
-0.1076259315,
-0.7953004837,
-1.0106611252,
-0.5526388884,
-0.3301941454,
-0.5748662353,
0.4256576896,
0.8016461134,
0.8133070469,
-0.7810859084,
-0.5308486819,
-0.1671987623,
0.2887054682,
-0.4110881984,
-0.1208310872,
0.4711257517,
-0.0610986128,
-0.6965764165,
0.592025578,
0.3873004019,
-0.0616202131,
-0.4288378656,
0.1143918335,
0.0104016913,
-0.0303283073,
0.5963938236,
0.3872177899,
-0.4789047837,
-0.3573481739,
-0.0633734018,
0.0281934422,
0.1246200427,
0.9267116785,
-0.4703528285,
0.1834681928,
0.2640047073,
0.7938867211,
0.9957052469,
-0.1368035674,
0.4949707389,
-0.2676506639,
0.0739360526,
0.216892764,
0.3368964195,
0.31484887,
0.0156138735,
0.6341093779,
0.1314377338,
-0.5537513494,
-1.1098309755,
0.2589668036,
-0.8804367185,
-0.37499699,
0.7965669632,
-0.1347913742,
-0.4292580783,
-0.0633335561,
0.0479075424,
0.1704726964,
-0.1606139094,
0.7606765628,
0.6530678272,
-0.1088463515,
-0.0683454573,
-0.7293822765,
0.2671465576,
0.2839995921,
-0.9689050317,
0.558920145,
0.5101847649,
0.2683813274,
0.0641628057,
0.6046539545,
-0.1158216223,
0.0396947451,
0.1712343991,
-0.0008201132,
-0.3031975925,
-0.5327817798,
-0.1438065469,
0.2522841692,
0.31083709,
0.2394790649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00377v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00377v1 | The Factuality Tax of Diversity-Intervened Text-to-Image Generation: Benchmark and Fact-Augmented Intervention | 2024-06-29T09:09:42 | 2024-06-29T09:09:42 | Yixin Wan, Di Wu, Haoran Wang, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.CY | Prompt-based "diversity interventions" are commonly adopted to improve the
diversity of Text-to-Image (T2I) models depicting individuals with various
racial or gender traits. However, will this strategy result in nonfactual
demographic distribution, especially when generating real historical figures?
In this work, we propose DemOgraphic FActualIty Representation (DoFaiR), a
benchmark to systematically quantify the trade-off between using diversity
interventions and preserving demographic factuality in T2I models. DoFaiR
consists of 756 meticulously fact-checked test instances to reveal the
factuality tax of various diversity prompts through an automated
evidence-supported evaluation pipeline. Experiments on DoFaiR unveil that
diversity-oriented instructions increase the number of different gender and
racial groups in DALLE-3's generations at the cost of historically inaccurate
demographic distributions. To resolve this issue, we propose Fact-Augmented
Intervention (FAI), which instructs a Large Language Model (LLM) to reflect on
verbalized or retrieved factual information about gender and racial
compositions of generation subjects in history, and incorporate it into the
generation context of T2I models. By orienting model generations using the
reflected historical truths, FAI significantly improves the demographic
factuality under diversity interventions while preserving diversity. | [
-0.3907117844,
-0.3469836414,
0.3066047728,
0.2752485275,
0.0082350653,
0.1369840205,
-0.135267511,
-0.1424660236,
0.0964031145,
0.4438645244,
-0.4932962954,
-0.2024430931,
-0.5520970821,
0.0381105617,
0.1221280769,
0.9493938684,
0.1014682204,
0.063119255,
-0.1696381718,
-0.2442835271,
-0.4648766518,
-0.5104293227,
-0.3220861256,
0.1437430978,
0.4326176643,
0.5741203427,
0.4993359745,
0.703315556,
0.2227218747,
0.211730957,
-0.163176164,
0.3512574732,
-0.9855402112,
-0.1390287429,
-0.3461796343,
-0.3970525861,
-0.1578972489,
0.3375141621,
0.6829289794,
0.7264109254,
-0.0601759851,
0.2083384544,
-0.1761550158,
0.5356498361,
-0.9408837557,
-0.0471443906,
-0.391174376,
-0.2500112951,
-0.3531257212,
-0.3204702735,
-0.4290475547,
-0.7684113383,
-0.1764430404,
-0.1993933022,
0.6381753087,
-0.0262461752,
0.4779682159,
0.2401980609,
-0.8020615578,
-0.1428020746,
-0.993249774,
0.9695421457,
-0.4652087092,
0.3375456035,
0.2632163763,
0.0631428137,
-0.2484397143,
-0.4615432024,
-0.6956136823,
-0.2571411133,
-0.0187211297,
0.3182482421,
-0.142425254,
-0.3808769584,
0.3549431264,
0.2195293307,
-0.3623884916,
-0.0505015254,
-0.4966118038,
-0.3053740263,
0.7283715606,
0.1356716007,
0.413890034,
-0.1338200122,
-0.4098277092,
-0.3249816,
-0.7028585672,
-0.0126873041,
0.5765611529,
0.3365199268,
-0.3878663182,
0.7466038465,
-0.1427039653,
0.2572203875,
0.2611597478,
-0.2167167366,
0.3971628547,
-0.6941165924,
0.3015179336,
0.0566337854,
0.4788808525,
0.6284463406,
0.0944934636,
-0.1306154281,
-0.0882224888,
0.1162356138,
-0.0466149263,
-1.0241274834,
0.0469470657,
-0.0143147381,
-0.412255466,
-0.3186571896,
0.0355509669,
-1.0827950239,
-0.3785351515,
0.0809143707,
0.1251782477,
-0.3688862622,
-0.5843496323,
-0.1304706782,
-0.6043034792,
0.1557856947,
0.5032050014,
-0.9664705992,
0.1244878545,
0.4494862258,
0.7313557863,
-0.0489575602,
0.1355421394,
-0.465090096,
0.3112333715,
-0.3853313625,
0.8082911968,
-0.6684160233,
-0.7611015439,
-0.0537056737,
-0.1638125777,
-0.176607281,
-0.5572930574,
0.4758150876,
-0.5159195662,
0.2526578009,
-0.7522448301,
-0.4898453355,
-0.1072936803,
0.2207869887,
-0.8813807368,
0.796805799,
0.261420399,
-0.9109877944,
0.7851649523,
-0.5817728043,
-0.1679617614,
0.2605051696,
-0.3123023808,
-0.4596131742,
-0.1259251535,
0.1752883494,
-0.0163919609,
-0.2468079329,
0.4087464213,
-0.4918869138,
-0.3219516575,
0.2181708217,
-0.6190888882,
0.8125095367,
0.0046759923,
-0.5603212714,
-0.4002639651,
-0.6217643619,
-0.5460214615,
0.0840101019,
-0.3112109005,
-0.0960787758,
-0.0714820549,
0.0903776437,
-0.0198628008,
0.1722172052,
-0.8378018141,
0.0657856166,
-0.0892604515,
-0.2815362513,
0.3636844754,
0.2789610028,
0.4039732218,
-0.6815495491,
0.359597981,
0.1950280666,
-0.032067582,
-0.0173770189,
-0.5935499668,
-0.5172451735,
-0.6893342733,
0.2972502112,
0.4918586314,
-0.9620833397,
0.1895450503,
-0.4961293638,
-0.3186721802,
0.1051235572,
-0.2514371574,
0.0648024827,
0.8590567112,
0.1682946831,
0.0362972356,
-0.5134526491,
-0.7811627984,
-0.0254839994,
-0.8351066709,
0.1726504862,
0.2843514383,
0.6718597412,
-0.0696321577,
1.0862110853,
-0.3991898596,
0.0605661236,
0.0597143434,
0.7395421863,
-0.0295856819,
0.6313388348,
1.0316463709,
-0.9291859865,
-0.0146348933,
-0.1960390508,
-0.5582966805,
-0.2637070119,
-0.0718018264,
-0.1240463629,
0.3323027492,
-0.0366636552,
-0.2718717158,
0.6919449568,
0.4102700353,
-0.294360131,
0.3119367361,
-0.0305749606,
0.82293576,
-0.6784505844,
0.2751821876,
0.08590094,
-0.057462085,
-0.6464560032,
-0.2196179628,
0.1768610626,
-0.0287908092,
-0.3152300417,
0.6338172555,
-0.0004486488,
0.0831994414,
-0.0490080193,
-0.3671173155,
-0.1060608104,
0.3443869054,
0.168403402,
1.1561001539,
-0.0798906162,
-0.3174740672,
-0.0440329947,
0.3010863066,
-0.0987204984,
0.6665074825,
-0.3036319315,
0.1321609169,
-0.5498264432,
0.4477647245,
-1.0814158916,
-0.3635544479,
0.4338213205,
-0.3715648651,
0.1369141638,
-0.229064703,
-0.3389862776,
-0.130047068,
-0.7256900668,
0.768623054,
0.6707331538,
-0.6777948737,
0.7164821029,
0.1673316658,
-0.1228194162,
-0.645953238,
-0.6083832979,
0.1942280382,
-0.2324463278,
-0.9396715164,
0.2771196663,
-0.1888878495,
-0.3344233334,
0.0030100856,
0.1012401506,
-0.0857168809,
-0.014208178,
-0.0251795687,
0.5390178561,
-0.1524435878,
0.1470732987,
0.1361223012,
0.326867491,
-0.1803281307,
0.0250966642,
0.2982487679,
0.4459955692,
-0.2351018488,
-0.1539034992,
0.3681067228,
0.2292642295,
-0.2714981139,
0.9432283044,
0.3277445436,
-0.1052431241,
0.0306080785,
-0.9475993514,
0.012611188,
-0.4229343534,
0.0467676744,
-0.0168795493,
-0.9636836648,
0.367400378,
-0.1832139343,
0.3730340898,
0.5479360819,
0.6345846653,
-0.1583818793,
0.7586232424,
0.0889385045,
0.3658080697,
0.4452286959,
-0.3234910667,
-0.2503151894,
-0.5081685185,
-0.5343076587,
-0.4512453079,
-0.1457356066,
-0.6033138037,
-0.8594350815,
0.4164814055,
-0.1231174767,
-0.3370450437,
-0.1775164902,
0.0845648125,
0.0582479388,
0.3402066529,
0.2225570977,
0.017017642,
0.2432079464,
0.2809255719,
-0.1252531856,
-0.3481135666,
-0.4746196568,
1.289699316,
0.0194869284,
0.4606902301,
0.4703322053,
1.007584691,
0.9157465696,
0.7539051175,
-0.4915544689,
0.358194977,
-0.3267174661,
-0.7975499034,
-0.015216738,
-0.7573035359,
-0.7240953445,
-0.1105709746,
-0.255553335,
-0.5117577314,
1.1078271866,
0.449677974,
-0.2001418918,
0.2688328326,
-0.5824899673,
0.4943926632,
-0.0136690158,
-0.3689472377,
-0.2860602438,
-0.2360569835,
0.6371382475,
-0.3828296065,
0.3271365762,
-0.0580447242,
-0.2030431032,
0.5786901116,
-0.5136474967,
0.8657147288,
-0.4525629282,
0.0339209773,
0.1886798143,
-0.0300852992,
0.5731495023,
0.0185818765,
-0.3753575087,
0.2054178566,
-0.2769099474,
-0.5539118052,
-0.6732737422,
0.3507677913,
-0.808862865,
-0.676265955,
-0.247461468,
-0.6816940904,
-0.2498926967,
-0.2939309478,
0.1034945324,
0.7073511481,
-0.6238552928,
0.021277288,
0.5559786558,
-0.0974245146,
0.361194402,
0.4085362256,
0.0042984225,
-0.7777754068,
0.9425147176,
0.2152419835,
0.2175513953,
0.114215225,
0.1183884516,
-0.4243877232,
-0.3324522674,
-0.4550423026,
0.529959023,
-0.8617351651,
0.088793464,
-0.6525292397,
0.117970109,
-0.5626021624,
0.0717421249,
-0.0042974255,
-0.5749218464,
-0.2283079326,
0.0463204831,
0.4426650107,
0.5511616468,
-0.4510895312,
0.3453170657,
-0.5925434232,
0.3782536685,
0.4684115946,
0.031644471,
-0.103243798,
-0.7014803886,
-0.1240057051,
0.2724531591,
-0.126594618,
-0.8614165187,
-0.0742778778,
0.1558165401,
0.4721513987,
0.1409848481,
0.2737582028,
0.5177251697,
-0.3536783755,
0.8166729808,
0.3438767791,
-0.6223563552,
0.2613976002,
-0.326595217,
0.0249425061,
0.488953501,
0.105763115,
-0.3325316012,
-0.2659488916,
-0.4718982875,
-0.403891176,
0.8981071711,
0.6060703397,
0.2168006301,
-0.2612952292,
0.2407301217,
0.1395734698,
0.1259804368,
-0.3795044124,
-0.1750108451,
-0.6238654852,
-0.4972814322,
0.3977662325,
-0.5026854277,
-0.4121254981,
0.1297789514,
0.5279242396,
-0.0043048714,
0.0135599878,
0.2517760694,
-0.0528153479,
-0.1436300278,
0.2604511082,
0.666467309,
0.6504226923,
-0.3498447537,
-0.0726368949,
0.0516714528,
-0.5184926987,
0.3199976981,
0.3167233765,
-0.4691269696,
-0.0769855976,
0.5794253945,
0.9487859607,
-0.2541793883,
-0.4002283514,
0.5942129493,
-0.1084673554,
-0.3097274005,
-0.0789658874,
0.1687706411,
-0.0879218206,
0.3407746851,
0.5739306211,
0.318977505,
0.1816312522,
-0.5156779289,
0.1415302902,
0.3328754008,
-0.059618894,
-0.2440246642,
0.6997005939,
0.5003499389,
-0.0334420651,
0.4188458323,
-0.2152751237,
-0.3651793897,
0.8176368475,
0.4696674645,
0.5654978752,
-0.3081841767,
0.6021208763,
0.6054726243,
0.2878614664,
-0.1454770863,
0.6026832461,
0.0564738885,
-0.741520822,
-0.362588495,
-0.1022560373,
-0.2604870498,
-0.218089506,
-0.4009841084,
0.2797477543,
-0.5398581028,
-0.3481288254,
0.0527416132,
-0.2603150606,
-0.6664334536,
0.56042099,
0.5725606084,
0.6916465163,
-0.9742928147,
0.3281230032,
0.5280591846,
-0.4764128327,
-0.6359291673,
0.4897726476,
0.1882711053,
-0.7011815906,
1.2113512754,
0.0125163281,
-0.2631783187,
-0.1189912036,
-0.7666031122,
-0.7797074318,
0.8799709082,
0.6724407077,
-0.5309584737,
0.3670452535,
0.3003245592,
0.1502140462,
-0.4134634137,
0.3401215374,
0.4248113036,
0.6375960112,
0.5617314577,
-0.4234136641,
0.1048472747,
-0.2244914025,
0.3811762631,
0.1220688522,
-0.6075928807,
0.6760065556,
-0.1895449013,
-0.5520883203,
0.1615568399,
0.8477483988,
0.6661019921,
0.4703597426,
1.0686150789,
0.2140014023,
0.7004700899,
-0.0355829075,
1.1675902605,
-0.1776486933,
0.2523010075,
0.5845877528,
-0.3585883081,
0.3123350143,
0.5277040005,
-0.2809257507,
0.4581314921,
0.460991621,
-0.3005134761,
0.5341072083,
-0.2309913635,
-0.5750668645,
-0.1141591743,
-0.7747009397,
-0.2716851532,
0.1988634467,
0.1012077704,
-0.0645693615,
-0.2069057375,
-0.1626892835,
0.3351642191,
0.1543543339,
-0.0712406039,
0.4451659322,
-0.3722815514,
-0.5946457386,
0.355841279,
-0.2028732747,
0.4913370609,
-0.4294925928,
-0.4477454126,
-0.5968203545,
-0.3846824467,
-0.1750862449,
-0.6161006689,
-0.0048018144,
0.1654561013,
-0.5133242607,
0.3065753281,
0.356338799,
-0.7732502818,
-0.9310438037,
0.0982470214,
0.3149140179,
-0.1525448263,
0.4267832041,
-0.2128828466,
0.0627058446,
0.1254604161,
-0.0396697931,
-0.1341713965,
0.3045275807,
-0.3017390966,
0.1593661457,
0.5906834006,
0.2631621361,
-0.0590841882,
0.3479060233,
0.8136989474,
-0.3933395743,
-0.3665043116,
-0.7373845577,
0.6705605388,
-0.5742097497,
-0.0749607906,
0.4494198263,
0.5046870112,
0.4761148989,
0.0145670874,
0.8448949456,
-0.2012150884,
0.3686339855,
-0.4147773981,
0.4095400572,
-0.5898090005,
0.1334634572,
-0.1168052182,
-0.700030148,
-0.0480609685,
-0.120114103,
-0.3621970713,
0.2645085752,
0.3351931274,
1.0636129379,
-0.0620882958,
0.1524502337,
0.247064203,
-0.0812028944,
0.2701311409,
-0.2091332078,
1.0680571795,
-0.0797255933,
0.5476121306,
-0.1225303784,
-0.5834981203,
-0.0970897302,
-0.7354955077,
-0.6679108739,
-0.1530247629,
-0.5554325581,
-0.2306273431,
0.1206306964,
1.0147286654,
0.4762619734,
-0.7459900975,
-0.2858342528,
0.5140804052,
-0.1261057556,
-0.0544353053,
-0.1583364755,
0.3840324283,
-0.1180470884,
-0.7501033545,
0.2343493998,
0.2884438038,
0.127297774,
-0.0454079285,
-0.1642701477,
-0.113176018,
0.3138130605,
0.1847927123,
0.1482473165,
-0.4836131334,
-0.2458160669,
-0.2402977347,
0.1179078519,
0.2626966536,
1.0437569618,
-0.6221191287,
0.5000507832,
0.5210959315,
0.6848623753,
0.4562176764,
0.2307005823,
0.7681149244,
-0.8697461486,
0.3209474683,
0.1999972165,
0.3795202672,
0.6415898204,
-0.6660818458,
0.6530038714,
0.6732085943,
-0.2886363864,
-0.6990464926,
0.2588759959,
-0.7994716763,
-0.1017006114,
1.0046463013,
-0.2546774745,
-0.1443740577,
-0.2564936876,
-0.1341063082,
0.4532709718,
-0.6991013288,
0.7371112108,
0.4371899664,
0.2291166186,
-0.3340505064,
-0.2216890156,
0.2238747627,
0.4411060214,
-0.8094178438,
0.0078704813,
0.8197511435,
0.1804202199,
0.1092742011,
0.6661455631,
-0.1391813606,
0.4682778418,
0.0270731859,
0.2374719083,
-0.0162578076,
0.1943017393,
-0.0294571389,
-0.0288299322,
-0.1723467857,
-0.151662752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00369v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00369v1 | How to Train Your Fact Verifier: Knowledge Transfer with Multimodal Open Models | 2024-06-29T08:39:07 | 2024-06-29T08:39:07 | Jaeyoung Lee, Ximing Lu, Jack Hessel, Faeze Brahman, Youngjae Yu, Yonatan Bisk, Yejin Choi, Saadia Gabriel | cs.CL | cs.CL | Given the growing influx of misinformation across news and social media,
there is a critical need for systems that can provide effective real-time
verification of news claims. Large language or multimodal model based
verification has been proposed to scale up online policing mechanisms for
mitigating spread of false and harmful content. While these can potentially
reduce burden on human fact-checkers, such efforts may be hampered by
foundation model training data becoming outdated. In this work, we test the
limits of improving foundation model performance without continual updating
through an initial study of knowledge transfer using either existing intra- and
inter- domain benchmarks or explanations generated from large language models
(LLMs). We evaluate on 12 public benchmarks for fact-checking and
misinformation detection as well as two other tasks relevant to content
moderation -- toxicity and stance detection. Our results on two recent
multi-modal fact-checking benchmarks, Mocheg and Fakeddit, indicate that
knowledge transfer strategies can improve Fakeddit performance over the
state-of-the-art by up to 1.7% and Mocheg performance by up to 2.9%. | [
-0.349957794,
-0.7933532596,
0.6726104617,
0.1591146737,
-0.1057507247,
0.0095182462,
-0.2058349848,
-0.5558418036,
-0.3380679786,
0.3883228302,
-0.4178247154,
-0.1821302176,
-0.8951233029,
-0.0581671335,
-0.5457399487,
0.9538925886,
-0.327045083,
0.0754411221,
-0.527581811,
-0.1350763291,
-0.1605896652,
-0.626226902,
-0.3539324403,
-0.3562653065,
0.240240857,
0.3586298823,
0.4348698556,
0.4951925278,
0.5396363139,
0.2526667416,
0.066017732,
0.3575787842,
-0.6183633804,
-0.1331267655,
-0.4456563294,
-0.5205700397,
-0.1503868252,
0.1445583254,
0.452668786,
0.2382704616,
-0.0113058323,
0.1829455793,
-0.4478376806,
0.4087394476,
-0.9629817009,
0.1621678621,
-0.4469964206,
-0.1182863265,
0.0293473098,
-0.199281022,
-0.5638129711,
-0.655760169,
0.0101635968,
-0.4522310197,
0.2408605963,
-0.1377702653,
0.9855851531,
0.1526236832,
-0.9326966405,
-0.3624558151,
-0.8663911223,
0.482221365,
-0.4994488358,
0.6961086988,
0.4388821423,
0.4259275198,
0.1387293041,
-0.8475849032,
-0.9017786384,
-0.3340251744,
-0.1441662759,
-0.003772025,
-0.0411355123,
-0.2735927403,
0.3884657323,
0.2950243056,
-0.3074385524,
-0.2253738791,
-0.4224605858,
-0.511940062,
0.542601645,
-0.1870500743,
0.0956776068,
0.0535792746,
-0.8220208883,
-0.3059444427,
-0.7059739232,
0.229159385,
0.0963590443,
-0.1167511567,
-0.2143864185,
0.4696954787,
-0.3904885054,
0.4820798934,
0.0381701887,
-0.6388115287,
0.2530066669,
-0.817715764,
0.0395588391,
-0.0743228793,
0.5343714356,
0.4899239838,
0.1657399386,
-0.2172553837,
-0.2334035635,
0.1490466595,
0.2624178529,
-0.9988593459,
-0.1052592993,
-0.189888671,
-0.3878603578,
-0.4529713392,
0.1379526705,
-0.8265429735,
-0.6530849338,
-0.3696208,
0.7078410983,
-0.4194310606,
-0.4446928501,
0.2802114189,
-0.2014796734,
0.0479161665,
0.6546142697,
-0.5026355386,
0.0200118646,
0.4414262474,
0.9268490672,
-0.132957384,
-0.0874021649,
-0.5955628157,
0.255307585,
-0.2238814086,
0.8497540951,
-0.2630978823,
0.0978148058,
0.0413355157,
0.0830844641,
-0.2862428427,
-0.2749215066,
0.5840271115,
-0.5809767246,
0.1227316707,
-0.5977464914,
-0.4888053834,
-0.2468592972,
0.6972039938,
-0.6616065502,
0.7511826754,
-0.0587979443,
-0.6206071377,
0.406606704,
-0.6750565171,
-0.6595955491,
-0.3964229226,
0.0824215859,
-0.2284303159,
-0.1199500263,
0.337590456,
0.5039477944,
-0.2364235669,
0.2352564037,
-0.387609452,
-0.1743479371,
0.5402628779,
-0.6087428927,
0.6636444926,
0.2677000761,
-0.4244394302,
-0.0710970834,
-0.9412809014,
-0.2649674714,
-0.1151350886,
-0.7150172591,
-0.1574112475,
-0.1837487817,
-0.0447075553,
0.3579907715,
-0.0872865617,
-0.7589519024,
0.0473323949,
0.2339012027,
0.464401871,
0.6173860431,
0.1460819095,
0.2349816561,
-0.782138288,
0.2178824991,
0.3502989411,
0.2298046947,
-0.1386999935,
-0.2268522382,
-0.8162738681,
-0.3043259978,
0.444380641,
0.5633214712,
-0.9801754355,
-0.0230159834,
-0.4735275507,
-0.5093150139,
-0.1984823793,
0.1568374187,
0.1177694872,
0.4809395075,
0.4162234664,
-0.2930560112,
-0.2466546893,
-0.6130501628,
-0.230855301,
-0.2409765869,
0.2829399705,
-0.0869415328,
0.6782896519,
-0.0453147255,
0.8586401343,
-0.207163319,
-0.0764767379,
-0.0093602333,
0.3367728293,
-0.2384453118,
0.3302616477,
0.7756581306,
-1.0850454569,
-0.2310614139,
-0.0295064058,
-0.7134833932,
0.1119847074,
-0.1659097522,
0.0566648096,
0.1440349817,
0.6618881822,
-0.75103724,
0.3829587996,
0.6629476547,
-0.3436232209,
0.6655266881,
0.1131460443,
0.7736433148,
-0.7666540742,
0.1445530355,
0.0380349383,
-0.7168827057,
-0.6090456247,
0.1413144916,
0.3168880641,
0.038221471,
-0.6240901947,
0.5570422411,
-0.3323536515,
0.2355756611,
-0.2216292322,
0.0114662172,
-0.1541881859,
0.408567667,
-0.0914138705,
0.7524027228,
0.4262541533,
-0.8338484764,
0.5472902656,
-0.0703899264,
-0.651456356,
0.8472324014,
-0.2549836338,
-0.090358302,
-0.037982095,
0.4218702614,
-1.0962543488,
-0.3157311678,
0.3146384358,
-0.2861030996,
0.1741694212,
-0.3714862466,
-0.6210528016,
-0.2044074386,
-0.0991474092,
0.1676843315,
0.2457900196,
-0.6790523529,
0.7653933167,
0.1172164008,
0.0495470911,
-0.6179872751,
-0.5907530785,
-0.0590972677,
0.0360845104,
-0.8609448075,
0.1859366894,
-0.1244483069,
-0.2797317505,
0.1799445152,
-0.3896310627,
-0.3734847605,
0.2430403531,
0.2252438068,
-0.0219089426,
-0.3804622293,
0.28343153,
-0.0251216907,
0.1150344163,
0.2166498154,
0.1298963428,
0.126604706,
-0.1503442228,
-0.6734039783,
-0.4955934286,
-0.134591043,
1.1379768848,
-0.3879557252,
0.9734450579,
0.9144791961,
-0.4239066839,
-0.0872628167,
-1.0074355602,
-0.4105378389,
-0.3773650527,
0.1223251224,
-0.3044131994,
-0.927084744,
0.2927855253,
-0.5380507708,
0.1162540391,
0.1952956617,
0.5255787969,
0.2440391034,
0.8652923107,
0.7270424962,
0.0003354432,
0.474398315,
-0.0599013418,
0.1767103076,
-0.0828871429,
-0.2482526004,
-0.3025731742,
-0.0759906545,
-0.0705306828,
-0.5646648407,
0.3904287517,
0.1687817872,
0.0557923391,
0.1693702489,
0.235360831,
0.5081723332,
0.3382587135,
0.2923158407,
0.696138382,
0.2122205943,
0.0904824808,
0.2493754923,
-0.6928961277,
-0.2007962167,
1.0385328531,
0.5124775171,
0.8311719894,
0.4506409764,
0.1587300301,
0.6480981708,
0.737375319,
-0.5418869257,
0.3675144315,
0.0278900154,
-0.8373550177,
-0.0475771576,
-0.5401543975,
-0.0979064927,
0.4036736488,
-0.6460205317,
-0.3023152649,
0.3859278858,
0.1106329858,
-0.2043338865,
0.4945591986,
-0.7259535789,
0.5778479576,
-0.2737232149,
-0.5302704573,
-0.6101051569,
-0.3425349295,
0.713675499,
-0.1075572819,
0.4957375526,
-0.0802755654,
0.2109024078,
0.3953254521,
-0.305464983,
0.9221200943,
-0.2185254842,
-0.0645113811,
0.1413698643,
0.0922781304,
0.5904023647,
0.227236852,
0.0443556197,
0.0612807609,
0.0489519797,
-0.2096753567,
-0.4762374461,
0.5899274349,
-0.7863066196,
-0.4985132515,
-0.3873586655,
-0.5323733091,
-0.3126280904,
0.19286789,
0.104978241,
0.3825989366,
-0.1885323375,
0.6340971589,
1.0398036242,
0.3409046233,
0.1320158392,
0.7570440173,
-0.073912017,
-0.1808468103,
0.748952806,
0.1346291602,
0.315939039,
0.4032205641,
0.2441994399,
-0.2980341315,
-0.4604938924,
-0.7705879211,
0.2395822704,
-0.961504519,
-0.2525692582,
-0.706314981,
-0.3969752192,
-0.6046237946,
-0.0066364026,
-0.4675203264,
-0.4401120842,
0.1038674638,
-0.1789898127,
0.4125347733,
0.6891713142,
-0.3390032947,
0.2083723843,
-0.7462011576,
0.4319916666,
0.5603406429,
0.3911284208,
-0.2500125766,
-0.6016777158,
-0.3280056119,
0.3084405363,
-0.1637968868,
-0.9151862264,
-0.2582642734,
0.0126832649,
0.7047119141,
0.4749020338,
0.0750063807,
0.4119268656,
0.0487781689,
0.6760902405,
0.2188827544,
-0.9036137462,
0.2311600596,
-0.1930271834,
-0.1383707076,
0.4881297052,
0.6977194548,
-0.4991406798,
-0.075057134,
-0.2474131584,
-0.309381485,
0.7011461258,
0.1062610075,
-0.0357923545,
0.3050319254,
0.3123192191,
0.0552012324,
0.2740997672,
-0.9540116787,
-0.0867786035,
-0.4473389685,
0.0738807991,
0.1794942766,
-0.4159339964,
-0.5380139947,
-0.1282121837,
0.9467439651,
-0.2557674646,
0.0725088567,
0.288780123,
-0.6174417138,
-0.1734522134,
0.372404635,
0.9305683374,
1.0020142794,
-0.1627144367,
0.3810642958,
0.1949580461,
-0.4020943046,
0.4487068355,
0.0934657529,
-0.2372774333,
-0.0731959492,
0.4599053264,
0.7976160645,
0.2497587353,
-0.5609641075,
1.0274869204,
-0.0467271842,
-0.4695818126,
-0.000136511,
0.2294719666,
0.0026914228,
0.3095935583,
0.1090270728,
0.3676359951,
-0.1860232204,
-0.6457011104,
0.2078996003,
0.080702208,
-0.3106941283,
-0.3065190017,
0.4020933807,
0.2262109816,
0.3574107587,
0.4212807119,
-0.0067752781,
-0.5330684781,
0.3348021805,
0.477226764,
0.2705858648,
-0.2140318155,
0.3655790389,
0.3620819449,
0.5865772367,
-0.6017159224,
0.017355876,
-0.1015505567,
-0.8985745311,
-0.5611038804,
-0.4514274895,
-0.3637714684,
0.3717455566,
-0.4165247977,
0.231970042,
-0.5315784216,
-0.1669905782,
0.0675037131,
-0.199954167,
-0.7591075301,
0.1533819735,
0.1580093354,
1.0768936872,
-1.1600052118,
0.6035699844,
0.8391548991,
-0.4783250391,
-0.3823303878,
-0.1006987318,
0.3147372305,
-0.6760398149,
0.4636943638,
0.0791303441,
-0.2721134126,
-0.1547534019,
-0.6054114103,
-0.7988113761,
1.1287111044,
0.5851917863,
-0.5342485309,
0.0572904684,
0.0685921758,
0.4150297642,
-0.2189314365,
0.170227766,
0.2738163173,
0.6510075331,
0.2205034494,
-0.9190502167,
0.197122708,
-0.1236930713,
-0.3806955516,
-0.0956749469,
-0.6278445721,
0.9102836847,
-0.2476351112,
-0.2933782935,
-0.1784396321,
0.6023417115,
-0.045322679,
0.351578027,
0.7767454982,
0.69470644,
0.7107728124,
-0.0880986527,
1.0234106779,
-0.4096621275,
0.2807601392,
0.8439847827,
-0.3116936088,
0.635984242,
0.3147394657,
0.1105331555,
0.8117341995,
0.2184289098,
-0.1234197542,
0.4527001083,
-0.0835941136,
-0.2769261301,
-0.7039814591,
-0.1869738549,
-0.4427919984,
0.4014295936,
0.2573614419,
-0.2847868204,
-0.4051317871,
0.4086455107,
0.1817686558,
0.0962083116,
-0.2114775181,
0.5545933247,
-0.303986609,
-0.6659975648,
0.3544024229,
0.2090632766,
0.6514058709,
-0.7427286506,
-0.1102922037,
-0.1371291429,
0.378067255,
-0.0899872109,
-0.6698223948,
0.1080554873,
-0.0864091814,
-0.3909921646,
-0.3468215764,
1.1908587217,
-0.4370124936,
-0.2102433443,
0.0848319679,
0.7963318825,
-0.1552540809,
-0.2731577456,
-0.4615879953,
0.0412279628,
-0.1036431193,
-0.3133303225,
0.250983566,
0.3615614474,
-0.2958779931,
0.8523676991,
0.9828632474,
0.041964151,
0.2779735029,
-0.1119105592,
0.9384252429,
-0.2421984673,
-0.4704717398,
-0.6369513273,
0.3279627264,
-0.1078655496,
-0.1120062545,
0.7580752373,
0.3944163024,
1.0708153248,
-0.0946090296,
0.9742578268,
-0.2394760698,
0.4766954184,
-0.7116169333,
0.8672007918,
-0.4137126207,
-0.0695203245,
0.1924934238,
-0.5585750937,
0.0356895886,
0.5400385857,
-0.2157778293,
-0.1478337646,
0.6824606657,
0.9049735069,
-0.4674431384,
0.2755797207,
0.2603737414,
0.2924287617,
0.4308672845,
0.2448954582,
0.9355719686,
-0.4009231329,
0.6936007738,
-0.5291642547,
-0.2365462631,
-0.4461385012,
-0.974047482,
-1.0549988747,
-0.5225518942,
-0.4805857837,
-0.5384390354,
0.2290812433,
0.6514496207,
1.1709576845,
-0.6687447429,
-0.0246258937,
0.187148422,
0.2904780507,
-0.4193944633,
-0.2285104841,
0.0838327259,
0.0002622287,
-0.0852882415,
0.4487036765,
-0.1783160269,
0.0796418712,
-0.2663211823,
0.0089734308,
-0.4714479148,
0.1674792022,
0.8293713927,
0.2197683752,
-0.5371871591,
-0.5695495605,
-0.0708463043,
-0.1695853174,
-0.1413775235,
1.129160881,
-0.7805235386,
0.4917854965,
0.6653804779,
0.7923592329,
0.5419388413,
0.1122532561,
0.3199843466,
-0.6829404235,
-0.206257686,
-0.3053777516,
0.3076480627,
0.3115751147,
-0.2890625298,
0.5129300952,
0.8194907308,
-0.3216828704,
-0.8881996274,
0.1585587561,
-0.7567967176,
-0.3212928176,
1.0899128914,
-0.2136964351,
-0.1413054019,
-0.2064531744,
0.1284774244,
0.2894401252,
-0.2838703692,
0.791495502,
0.985743165,
0.1156625003,
-0.2830461562,
-0.6438257694,
0.5579474568,
0.020692734,
-1.0127470493,
0.1098472774,
0.6464453936,
0.8754515648,
0.4706503451,
0.5746442676,
-0.0998853892,
0.6354485154,
0.0411934778,
0.0282389522,
-0.5086745024,
-0.6388587952,
-0.1081535891,
0.3624468148,
-0.349522531,
0.0855429471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00365v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00365v1 | Financial Knowledge Large Language Model | 2024-06-29T08:26:49 | 2024-06-29T08:26:49 | Cehao Yang, Chengjin Xu, Yiyan Qi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Artificial intelligence is making significant strides in the finance
industry, revolutionizing how data is processed and interpreted. Among these
technologies, large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated substantial
potential to transform financial services by automating complex tasks,
enhancing customer service, and providing detailed financial analysis. Firstly,
we introduce IDEA-FinBench, an evaluation benchmark specifically tailored for
assessing financial knowledge in large language models (LLMs). This benchmark
utilizes questions from two globally respected and authoritative financial
professional exams, aimimg to comprehensively evaluate the capability of LLMs
to directly address exam questions pertinent to the finance sector. Secondly,
we propose IDEA-FinKER, a Financial Knowledge Enhancement framework designed to
facilitate the rapid adaptation of general LLMs to the financial domain,
introducing a retrieval-based few-shot learning method for real-time
context-level knowledge injection, and a set of high-quality financial
knowledge instructions for fine-tuning any general LLM. Finally, we present
IDEA-FinQA, a financial question-answering system powered by LLMs. This system
is structured around a scheme of real-time knowledge injection and factual
enhancement using external knowledge. IDEA-FinQA is comprised of three main
modules: the data collector, the data querying module, and LLM-based agents
tasked with specific functions. | [
-0.1990537792,
-1.0255438089,
0.4239054918,
0.0773914903,
-0.0897099227,
0.4897297621,
-0.2751813531,
-0.9136043787,
0.0204408672,
0.67962569,
-0.3927769661,
-0.4290526509,
-0.3148411214,
-0.1836373657,
-0.6063767672,
0.8545022607,
0.0812488794,
0.2260665596,
-0.2756551802,
0.3901069164,
-0.1774845123,
-0.4021066427,
-1.1117119789,
-0.4152593315,
0.2029463947,
0.2886937857,
0.4618519545,
0.3883918226,
0.8220366836,
0.3796756268,
0.0146206031,
-0.1845276356,
-0.3683914542,
-0.2308811843,
-0.3043288887,
-0.6681258678,
-0.6761622429,
-0.0915708542,
0.3586432934,
0.721360445,
-0.3452011049,
0.3131038249,
-0.1806727499,
0.7449342012,
-0.5108287334,
0.6059385538,
-0.4506139159,
-0.1858457774,
-0.1016455963,
-0.0531730875,
-0.2740275562,
-0.3835499883,
0.4143584669,
-0.5698466897,
-0.1940189451,
0.2497722656,
0.6701135039,
0.3314141333,
-0.3304203153,
-0.2976784706,
-0.7289892435,
0.6105979681,
-0.7384361029,
0.3211794794,
0.3664631844,
0.6965905428,
-0.0649778917,
-0.8020040989,
-0.4168973863,
-0.160918951,
0.0573546216,
0.0936961025,
-0.2354191989,
0.202500388,
0.102555126,
0.3871466815,
-0.2193323374,
0.2045436502,
-0.3119518161,
-0.1648388207,
0.80591923,
0.1405521482,
-0.1191535071,
0.1328012347,
-0.4433834553,
-0.3677380383,
-0.5840627551,
0.1762901247,
0.4625788927,
0.159295693,
-0.0488560796,
0.4248420894,
-0.1986230612,
0.7866811156,
-0.006533525,
-0.4606057703,
0.0983015075,
-0.2874408066,
-0.303230077,
0.1671451926,
0.4853056669,
0.1967263222,
0.3641021252,
-0.059830334,
-0.3474714756,
-0.4259902835,
0.0841051713,
-0.5893815756,
0.0248991139,
0.3298706412,
-0.3206835985,
-0.2133422941,
0.2130027264,
-0.7026958466,
-0.4459972978,
-0.4259729683,
0.4113281667,
-0.2807225287,
-0.1004913524,
0.4014609158,
-0.3936424255,
0.6260254383,
0.3969453275,
-0.8032011986,
0.5144162178,
1.1600519419,
0.3086430132,
0.2198116332,
0.0021465623,
-0.4072122276,
0.3565464914,
-0.3947266638,
1.0345773697,
-0.3845109046,
-0.1466289014,
-0.0787456483,
-0.3281573653,
0.0969057158,
-0.5115934014,
-0.0126623726,
-0.8261014223,
0.0445726961,
-0.1564124823,
-0.8348168731,
-0.325209558,
0.3190555871,
-0.4461960793,
0.7546104193,
0.3404500186,
-0.6807252765,
0.4102158844,
-1.0825718641,
-0.3758659959,
0.3439022601,
-0.1839779168,
-0.161144346,
-0.2944214046,
0.0541429706,
0.4518741667,
-0.9314763546,
0.3485274613,
-0.3848470151,
-0.4400777817,
0.5464174747,
-0.4246578515,
0.334861666,
0.0116204517,
-0.3490073979,
0.244834736,
-0.8052699566,
-0.1652002931,
0.1556730121,
-0.0177161545,
-0.4831151664,
-0.1876705289,
0.0596311726,
0.0434725769,
0.6119144559,
-0.6124686599,
0.109326385,
-0.8123001456,
0.5482687354,
0.896838367,
0.1540957093,
0.2757048011,
-0.473624438,
0.56457901,
-0.1590558589,
0.210232079,
-0.0138201453,
-0.1897432655,
-0.5376614928,
-0.1862659305,
0.4104441106,
0.7391093969,
-0.5520837903,
0.2686882019,
-0.158307001,
-0.5510466099,
-0.2644396126,
0.2779219151,
0.2058362514,
0.4454616904,
0.1218280569,
-0.0223017149,
-0.3242098689,
-1.2717125416,
-0.3074098229,
-0.3348088264,
-0.0430525877,
0.3294022381,
0.3907109201,
-0.0458038896,
0.8923159838,
-0.8355005383,
-0.1504294425,
-0.3448542953,
-0.0275830999,
0.4396933913,
0.2917566597,
0.7303607464,
-0.957608819,
-0.1514906734,
0.1543461233,
-0.4825043082,
0.1132662967,
-0.2816536725,
-0.0994188339,
-0.0729470998,
0.7292231321,
-0.3537738919,
0.2789846361,
0.1433477998,
-0.5360738635,
0.514472127,
-0.2209736854,
0.0672743917,
-1.0541098118,
0.2134490013,
0.0032859757,
-0.2302175462,
-0.451641649,
-0.078832373,
0.0791228265,
0.0214590523,
-0.2153779566,
1.1016802788,
0.0413003936,
-0.4832631648,
-0.324280113,
0.2951567173,
-0.1263927072,
0.3380709589,
-0.1866914779,
0.9222132564,
0.4530571103,
-0.3824846745,
0.7627596259,
0.2774499953,
-0.6118613482,
0.6049677134,
-0.5758664012,
-0.0658051819,
0.0008899912,
0.1004091054,
-1.026154995,
-0.2940015495,
0.0357519686,
-0.0634851307,
0.2513943017,
0.2035452873,
-0.5497896075,
-0.563036263,
0.0142505197,
0.2331612855,
0.3293568194,
-0.5016362071,
0.6689562201,
0.296325624,
-0.7136484385,
-0.8101822734,
-0.5755761862,
0.177231282,
-0.2508888543,
-0.6757177114,
0.3251502514,
-0.0728843957,
-0.7034248114,
0.0076525393,
-0.0110037029,
-0.0869146362,
0.373331517,
0.0108981635,
0.6515053511,
-0.3861517608,
0.4502613842,
0.0147411199,
-0.2564588189,
0.2402602583,
-0.53452003,
0.4243876636,
-0.3331663311,
-0.4905648232,
-0.2004689872,
0.0535440184,
0.6070106626,
-0.2807859778,
0.7914454341,
0.3631086648,
-0.3116342127,
-0.2223298103,
-0.8989055753,
-0.0080628321,
-0.5675134659,
0.4550559521,
-0.3474370241,
-1.0896470547,
0.7836027741,
-0.2894656062,
0.2977678776,
0.672911346,
0.5842540264,
-0.0171334464,
0.4843112826,
1.0034344196,
-0.1880418211,
0.5552580357,
-0.2838413715,
0.205394119,
-0.3320477009,
-0.2515266538,
-0.3681714833,
-0.2707958221,
-0.0368459225,
-0.2567137778,
0.2414800674,
0.1556888074,
-0.4344579875,
0.2293341905,
0.1851336211,
0.5836666822,
0.2814756632,
-0.0733045265,
0.3244665861,
-0.1717857718,
-0.2188816071,
0.3534609675,
-0.6323294044,
-0.4373880923,
1.2644566298,
0.6059099436,
0.80780375,
-0.0121410806,
0.4071965516,
0.3920668364,
0.5071679354,
-0.877850771,
0.4586699903,
-0.1470198929,
-0.50991714,
-0.4503670633,
-0.6746923327,
-0.3770318031,
-0.2869514227,
0.051012598,
-0.579931438,
0.108813718,
-0.1805801839,
-0.8174408674,
0.3461955488,
-0.6144775748,
0.6545059085,
-0.6065647006,
-0.3603670001,
-0.3434361815,
-0.3237644136,
0.5970983505,
-0.8495479822,
0.5712379813,
-0.0400676802,
-0.295027405,
0.9530786276,
-0.3624787927,
0.7863357067,
-0.0926034525,
-0.6583784223,
0.3063208759,
-0.1343091577,
0.4308231771,
0.2163469642,
-0.3356242776,
0.0374299921,
0.1822800189,
-0.3681093156,
-0.6783310771,
0.4703051746,
-0.5974193215,
-0.6525324583,
-0.1137031019,
-0.7612823844,
-0.5968719721,
0.0104079051,
-0.3541428447,
0.2043396682,
-0.415381968,
0.175176844,
0.2862711549,
-0.2711484432,
0.4226458073,
0.7392009497,
-0.442456007,
-0.420894295,
0.6888998747,
-0.0881455317,
0.2778991461,
0.5268000364,
0.1977126598,
-0.554127574,
-0.2942905128,
-0.2005735338,
0.4273704588,
-0.9697967768,
-0.3664076328,
-0.3804448247,
-0.2896400094,
-0.4824219942,
-0.3307114244,
-0.5145839453,
-0.4881232977,
-0.0357646942,
-0.3425523341,
0.8212307692,
0.9131863713,
-0.1874703765,
0.2599557936,
-0.9721379876,
0.2209497839,
0.4896403551,
0.6743876338,
0.1285608411,
-0.4332441688,
-0.4936826229,
-0.1212714314,
0.2733185589,
-0.3398927152,
0.1749073118,
0.0362830721,
0.7347076535,
0.8361161351,
-0.0385293365,
0.5985336304,
0.0528649613,
0.4308221936,
0.1590462327,
-0.8480369449,
0.2876161635,
-0.2843825817,
0.196588546,
0.6342089176,
0.263166368,
-0.6040403247,
-0.3472602069,
-0.5825827122,
-0.8173662424,
0.5575722456,
-0.1848501712,
-0.006944906,
0.1417878568,
0.6997941136,
0.2889355719,
0.428162843,
-0.3633166254,
-0.0125053842,
0.0768884569,
-0.3110069931,
-0.2432628274,
-0.1807017326,
-0.1610272825,
-0.2822828889,
0.7338065505,
-0.28576985,
0.0430324897,
-0.0251586791,
0.2541014254,
-0.1887960434,
0.4007893205,
0.5083711743,
1.0185576677,
-0.2808655202,
-0.1734135151,
0.2483642399,
-0.3114845455,
0.1243781373,
0.3575140536,
0.1067140847,
-0.451813072,
0.4594231248,
0.4534146488,
0.6546397209,
-1.1328247786,
0.4588293135,
-0.1376476735,
-0.4413913786,
-0.6508865356,
0.2406922579,
0.3293357491,
0.6829928756,
0.7405674458,
-0.0066377549,
-0.1980791688,
-0.6511695981,
0.35474962,
0.3286937177,
-0.3898338377,
0.0273158494,
0.4495066404,
0.1273216605,
-0.1219317243,
0.4263231158,
0.0940292031,
-0.498092711,
0.7669709325,
0.4310534,
0.7257677913,
-0.0666224137,
0.0239083488,
0.1119603366,
0.1687843055,
-0.1974132508,
0.5581954122,
-0.0206594542,
-0.6949691176,
-0.5926926732,
-0.9390667677,
-0.5147071481,
0.1496075094,
-0.5710044503,
0.2035323083,
-0.7687786222,
-0.1715495884,
0.2001292109,
0.0257156454,
-0.6819097996,
-0.0083231106,
0.1283128411,
1.335198164,
-0.4490986168,
0.6460420489,
0.6848400235,
-0.2250520587,
-0.5707548261,
-0.2689066529,
-0.0928470343,
-0.8894275427,
0.8493603468,
-0.1703059375,
-0.0767572597,
0.1410180479,
-0.5385785699,
-1.0125318766,
1.1086850166,
0.3323649466,
-0.9236503839,
-0.1897192597,
0.3391788006,
0.4313508272,
-0.5523750782,
0.0495276488,
0.766222477,
0.8033861518,
0.2952052355,
-0.9913266301,
-0.3633841872,
-0.2147845179,
-0.3511039019,
0.3668704331,
-0.6828452349,
0.6941130161,
-0.2509830594,
0.0691658258,
-0.017318761,
0.5364482999,
-0.0255190246,
0.2635081708,
0.493671447,
0.3771656752,
0.8387439847,
-0.0448347852,
1.1449884176,
-0.6152932048,
0.135240078,
1.0388293266,
-0.3846302629,
1.0049916506,
0.3173767328,
-0.2772241533,
0.4130961299,
0.6384323835,
-0.2012756914,
0.0438087098,
0.3895814121,
-0.1438893527,
-0.5020653009,
-0.0826284215,
-0.2359899729,
0.7968305349,
0.50589329,
-0.2219498158,
-0.0992930233,
0.1309944689,
-0.2775278091,
-0.025056567,
-0.454970181,
1.0187796354,
0.399092406,
-0.3357455134,
0.0118286824,
0.3009729683,
0.4917893112,
-1.0004248619,
0.0441650078,
-0.1201513633,
0.3746065199,
0.1599100679,
-0.6735476255,
0.2823293507,
0.0497087799,
-0.0306836404,
-0.1624110639,
0.9491009116,
-0.1898307353,
-0.7112785578,
0.5027683377,
0.6947624087,
-0.0479819924,
-0.0898231268,
-0.7508156896,
-0.5235423446,
-0.2889362276,
-0.2075720131,
0.3862587512,
0.3252262771,
0.1004375666,
1.0042976141,
0.9326430559,
0.0633913949,
-0.4123227894,
0.1188908219,
0.8588671684,
-0.9841905236,
-0.7182101011,
-0.7264432907,
0.03097618,
-0.0270166621,
-0.1286144853,
0.6122362018,
0.6696523428,
0.7234883308,
0.0672740862,
0.6960420012,
0.4824028015,
0.4931338727,
-0.5655477643,
1.0267107487,
-0.4983199537,
0.5712681413,
-0.4242477119,
-0.9710143209,
-0.0959047154,
0.3472787738,
-0.8053799868,
-0.1831723154,
0.3969633281,
0.500713408,
0.0934519917,
0.3569928706,
0.42511338,
0.1951182336,
0.0628436431,
0.4149949849,
0.8447878361,
-0.2729053199,
0.5738577247,
-0.179443866,
-0.1347087771,
-0.2352609634,
-0.6795425415,
-0.731276989,
-0.2738881111,
-0.3229686916,
0.1428819001,
-0.1247885823,
0.9816560149,
0.2500717044,
-0.6537430882,
-0.6706129909,
0.2414117604,
0.0690701082,
-0.1890208125,
-0.2484233081,
0.3590548635,
-0.1985615194,
-0.2051983476,
0.5814555287,
0.6284738779,
0.3344143033,
-0.510142386,
0.0392630436,
-0.0144499457,
0.334579587,
0.6018894911,
0.0410630666,
-0.3480988145,
-0.1942789704,
0.1038256884,
0.0255214814,
-0.1523879468,
0.7933943272,
-0.5174267292,
0.1211225316,
0.3075156212,
0.9361397028,
0.4807766676,
-0.0017349353,
0.7893095613,
-0.2013892084,
0.2045765817,
0.1702646166,
0.3783203065,
-0.1314945221,
-0.4862532318,
0.4715756178,
0.0412323438,
-0.313431859,
-0.3965771794,
-0.0342154801,
-0.7435073256,
-0.6640669107,
0.9190918803,
-0.0651231408,
-0.5847060084,
-0.3300278485,
0.0107550565,
-0.1109320968,
-0.4336954653,
0.5941201448,
0.7940436006,
0.0473191701,
-0.0866241157,
-0.7701939344,
0.4597818553,
0.217074886,
-1.0096472502,
0.3012258112,
0.2835448086,
0.2998234928,
0.1490734965,
0.5019331574,
-0.1219933629,
0.4247682691,
0.1022028923,
0.1159282997,
-0.2436026037,
-0.1840870827,
-0.0759595186,
0.3792631626,
0.0599231012,
0.5056361556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00361v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00361v1 | From RAG to RICHES: Retrieval Interlaced with Sequence Generation | 2024-06-29T08:16:58 | 2024-06-29T08:16:58 | Palak Jain, Livio Baldini Soares, Tom Kwiatkowski | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present RICHES, a novel approach that interleaves retrieval with sequence
generation tasks. RICHES offers an alternative to conventional RAG systems by
eliminating the need for separate retriever and generator. It retrieves
documents by directly decoding their contents, constrained on the corpus.
Unifying retrieval with generation allows us to adapt to diverse new tasks via
prompting alone. RICHES can work with any Instruction-tuned model, without
additional training. It provides attributed evidence, supports multi-hop
retrievals and interleaves thoughts to plan on what to retrieve next, all
within a single decoding pass of the LLM. We demonstrate the strong performance
of RICHES across ODQA tasks including attributed and multi-hop QA. | [
-0.2045614868,
-0.2572936416,
0.2002073824,
0.2533922493,
-0.3474173546,
0.5205960274,
0.0901391581,
-0.3066115379,
0.4788369536,
0.7621689439,
-0.313013196,
0.1366158426,
-0.6466991901,
0.0651448742,
-0.6027908921,
1.1191686392,
0.5359376073,
0.012858537,
-0.1600807756,
0.0002197804,
-0.3370606303,
-0.2902631462,
-0.4388185143,
-0.1596123427,
0.5632811785,
0.710134685,
0.6675133705,
0.385784775,
0.491332382,
0.3270648122,
0.0371433981,
0.6569020152,
-0.8571824431,
0.6000694036,
-0.4691251814,
-0.4196285605,
-0.2532236278,
-0.2220224887,
0.5668492317,
0.5719144344,
0.0918120816,
0.4356712103,
0.2703039944,
1.1872583628,
-1.1020007133,
-0.319450587,
-0.7642257214,
-0.0667562783,
-0.513402164,
-0.7407577038,
-0.7385297418,
-0.3276024461,
-0.1692528278,
-0.5019535422,
0.3819748163,
0.0238921866,
0.7051863074,
0.294662118,
-0.3379423022,
-0.541978538,
-0.8593384624,
0.662979722,
-0.2986914814,
0.435585767,
0.2745303214,
0.1110813767,
-0.0900139734,
-0.9349164367,
-0.3418147564,
0.0348629318,
-0.0984639451,
0.4151655138,
0.1616644561,
-0.2433020771,
0.2301579863,
0.8975452185,
-0.3622629344,
-0.1676645428,
-0.4099636674,
0.2810015082,
0.6485083699,
-0.0299965516,
-0.0465806723,
-0.432358712,
-0.5419780016,
-0.2719437182,
-0.7678552866,
-0.0206198636,
0.5098341703,
0.4263189435,
0.41490224,
0.81165272,
-0.1867363304,
0.6324735284,
0.0577937402,
-0.143879503,
-0.0298629459,
-0.227156654,
0.0203850344,
0.0289781839,
0.4529446065,
-0.3480903804,
-0.1565325111,
-0.4854750037,
-0.3565458357,
-0.6393965483,
0.5470570922,
-0.6112732887,
-0.1616702229,
0.1691861004,
-0.357060194,
-0.1193267554,
0.4637279809,
-0.9173207879,
-0.5176576376,
-0.0785394311,
0.7272292376,
-0.5106773973,
0.060558714,
0.0232979152,
-0.6172823906,
0.6041375995,
0.0252562035,
-0.938749671,
0.3778297305,
0.8880633116,
0.7221353054,
0.1685661823,
-0.0258290563,
-1.257606864,
0.2508992553,
-0.2491245568,
0.7173063755,
-0.1962457597,
-0.5253207088,
-0.2108174711,
-0.3682211041,
0.0921884999,
-0.683943212,
0.4930963218,
-1.1540558338,
0.0206679869,
-0.2049069703,
-0.6502709389,
0.0187206548,
-0.1020316482,
-0.8407440186,
0.9363194704,
0.3354635835,
-0.9505291581,
0.0787225142,
-0.4606219828,
-0.531812489,
0.3895586431,
-0.0461189672,
-0.3060071468,
0.3503366411,
-0.0911372378,
0.2281573862,
-0.4848466516,
0.1717090458,
-0.2003482133,
-0.5725640655,
0.1020739153,
-0.2108722031,
0.7874657512,
0.4785591364,
-0.2042834461,
-0.3197921216,
-0.7919483781,
0.2107397467,
0.3336988091,
-0.4761366844,
-0.6121003032,
0.0040499512,
-0.2036836743,
-0.2311384678,
0.3544861376,
-0.434279263,
0.4726538956,
-0.4587236345,
-0.0161255766,
0.4912996292,
0.0634305626,
0.5928125381,
-0.5259966254,
0.4218958318,
-0.238501668,
-0.1833852977,
-0.4070071876,
-0.354734391,
-0.8480977416,
-0.2463225573,
0.5806052089,
0.7631117105,
-0.7727631927,
0.2011947036,
-0.4398185611,
-0.1812403351,
-0.7298707962,
0.1035393402,
0.5573849678,
0.27224949,
0.3595046401,
-0.4644638598,
-0.507902205,
-0.5279587507,
-0.4961529076,
0.2642284632,
-0.2400198132,
0.3429234028,
0.1293574423,
0.0888522491,
0.8478108048,
-0.5459659696,
-0.1025214866,
-0.1457521766,
0.3119099438,
0.3686438203,
0.5410454869,
0.0673465878,
-1.2848441601,
-0.2768871188,
-0.213197425,
-0.4473831654,
0.113511093,
-0.0641011521,
-0.3587576449,
-0.002879092,
0.5731284618,
-0.3372657597,
0.3821178973,
0.1646708548,
-0.4378305674,
0.2567001283,
-0.244797051,
0.2608818114,
-1.3116582632,
0.1533707231,
-0.7525793314,
-0.2105404288,
-0.2565128803,
0.4256618023,
0.1443745196,
0.0824778378,
-0.0155018084,
0.5726491809,
-0.7413004041,
-0.7030351162,
-0.1464622319,
0.1101330444,
0.2515465915,
0.0161907747,
-0.3267992437,
0.9324272871,
0.111880444,
-0.6914739013,
0.1728471816,
0.618555069,
-0.1249776036,
0.4513415992,
-0.3002229333,
0.3244258761,
-0.532073915,
-0.1165517867,
-0.99428159,
-0.2530061901,
-0.2349703461,
-0.6421156526,
0.5479108691,
0.0361126736,
-0.4010533094,
-0.351316154,
-0.501696527,
0.4243938327,
0.6791164279,
-0.8071909547,
0.5069596767,
0.247267887,
-0.2601070404,
-0.9643935561,
-0.2938960493,
0.2070670873,
-0.2620557845,
-0.5409527421,
0.5081231594,
-0.110095039,
-0.4148143232,
-0.0653231591,
-0.0120963277,
-0.0001475688,
0.3168859184,
0.0972558036,
0.4777321219,
-0.2014042139,
0.2621249855,
0.01406861,
-0.0806116238,
-0.434056133,
-0.4854383767,
0.4160780311,
0.1047034264,
-0.2303353101,
0.4593336582,
0.6920832396,
0.2062039822,
-0.6298335195,
0.5722436905,
0.5016562939,
0.028939357,
-0.4983052015,
-0.4318718314,
-0.1621447802,
-0.5370855331,
0.0501809344,
-0.5185461044,
-0.9208037257,
0.2303713858,
-0.349353075,
0.3069910705,
0.3816141784,
0.4112218916,
-0.2124529183,
0.3501947224,
0.6914328337,
0.3502861261,
0.2498974204,
-0.6068528891,
0.3406074643,
-1.0994081497,
-0.1706393361,
-0.5656831861,
-0.333047688,
-0.3276122212,
-0.6278935671,
0.5949926376,
0.7852991819,
-0.3304243982,
0.1947891265,
-0.443797648,
0.5577370524,
1.1030055285,
0.2097394913,
0.6676131487,
-0.2797136009,
0.1430258751,
0.2881572843,
-0.8168493509,
-0.3612953126,
1.2018152475,
-0.2406706065,
0.662969768,
0.3752744794,
1.3277256489,
0.4642679393,
0.3079660833,
-0.7955538034,
0.4233213365,
-0.6711319685,
-0.3028045595,
-0.3972287476,
-0.3927100301,
-1.343495965,
0.2376198024,
-0.220125407,
-0.5816023946,
0.1534145921,
-0.0299796015,
-0.8122806549,
0.2796396911,
-0.2851798236,
0.5041493773,
-0.0839783102,
-0.4638068378,
-0.1615827978,
-0.8365700245,
0.8846456409,
-0.1488340646,
0.2271793485,
0.1952751726,
-0.1178032681,
0.499674052,
-0.5097094178,
0.2795865238,
0.2317316681,
-0.0494846143,
0.3734053373,
0.128177166,
0.5786004663,
0.0579837598,
-0.1347709596,
-0.4608339369,
-0.286783278,
-0.4205338955,
-0.3781823516,
0.6093434095,
-0.4946220517,
-0.6001452804,
-0.340973556,
-0.7783825994,
-0.4912020266,
0.1401205659,
0.5058208108,
0.5132908225,
-0.1503222138,
0.1317891777,
1.0125499964,
-0.2868658304,
0.5928646922,
0.3647104204,
0.0334071182,
-0.4398914576,
0.9219771624,
-0.0229701772,
0.4907680452,
0.951698184,
0.0992193818,
-0.3813509643,
-0.4016365409,
-0.4559916854,
0.2197442353,
-0.6601061225,
-0.6521575451,
-0.8196678162,
-0.3757559061,
-0.6583808064,
-0.1639763266,
-0.4081178308,
-0.525586307,
-0.2687901258,
0.1772506982,
0.5606162548,
0.9239577055,
-0.4481950402,
-0.1113297492,
-1.3695747852,
0.8248124719,
0.7321488261,
0.2650770843,
0.0597350597,
-0.6924794912,
-0.203269437,
-0.272973299,
-0.3988626301,
-0.9176176786,
0.3973674178,
0.3679805994,
0.2034444511,
0.0674668103,
0.5310757756,
0.7563020587,
-0.6269286275,
0.4446928501,
-0.1182975024,
-0.9100934267,
0.35325858,
-0.1931482702,
0.1275352985,
0.4323069453,
0.3894895911,
-0.2864240408,
-0.2504443228,
-0.7620563507,
-1.1678475142,
0.4843294322,
-0.1348625422,
-0.0967136398,
-0.1272008717,
0.2903770208,
0.3966933787,
0.1978627294,
-0.1315074861,
-0.1013269722,
-0.0590253286,
0.1196244285,
-0.0088489931,
-0.4087411165,
-0.0539000966,
0.1991956085,
0.6888867617,
-0.213887468,
0.275344342,
0.4177663028,
-0.0041555436,
-0.0405162945,
0.4554511309,
0.0482047983,
0.3802634478,
-0.0568458177,
0.0859573483,
-0.3028063476,
-0.3844109774,
0.0975070447,
0.3656204939,
-0.2566875219,
-0.0264609922,
0.1627817303,
0.4619278312,
0.4070852399,
-0.7153805494,
0.5474941134,
0.2427850515,
0.0205944832,
-0.22389777,
-0.0235850234,
0.1268855482,
0.6639149189,
0.5913921595,
-0.1148937568,
0.5737819672,
-0.5517918468,
0.6163294911,
0.4688043296,
0.0694273338,
0.1940101236,
0.90203619,
-0.0504879132,
-0.2907626629,
0.9623378515,
-0.6247811317,
-0.1004599482,
0.4947584569,
0.5601146817,
1.03522861,
-0.0719622746,
0.3586587608,
0.4798232615,
-0.1505892277,
-0.254840225,
0.6184642911,
-0.2664749324,
-0.5597493649,
-0.6164962053,
-0.9882041812,
-0.4284618795,
-0.1870508194,
-0.945882082,
0.0110529605,
-0.1327078789,
0.282635659,
-0.1090892702,
-0.2990276814,
-0.4592368901,
-0.1144946963,
0.2070317864,
0.9170660973,
-0.0443749018,
0.708694756,
0.2594576478,
-0.4779990911,
-0.9493506551,
0.0659486726,
-0.0884641409,
-0.8966599703,
0.8345816135,
-0.1607204825,
-0.0647053197,
0.382268399,
-0.3641281724,
-1.0577027798,
1.2681821585,
0.3771142662,
-0.2423883229,
-0.2409042865,
-0.2384697497,
-0.0969836041,
0.0642490983,
0.0285766199,
0.4334220588,
0.1753020585,
0.6305127144,
-0.8538979888,
-0.2821599245,
-0.2413436174,
0.0556263477,
0.5794812441,
-0.6586531401,
1.2355155945,
-0.7939530611,
-0.4357935786,
0.7576112747,
0.7165320516,
0.4983047843,
0.2106098086,
0.2614431977,
0.7484740019,
0.8095282912,
0.0117331538,
1.0792559385,
-0.2469575405,
0.1702124625,
1.2823009491,
-0.0295884535,
0.946978569,
0.3337990642,
-0.1879326403,
0.4438923597,
0.2535450161,
0.35701406,
0.5929901004,
0.4258014858,
-0.6128067374,
-0.0353072025,
-0.1394176036,
-0.2740110755,
0.5390334725,
0.4040051997,
-0.1737850159,
-0.3358483613,
-0.0053456943,
-0.2877777219,
0.2429316789,
-0.5666192174,
0.9135550261,
0.1233379394,
-0.9486165643,
0.5851159692,
-0.1832916737,
0.7052935958,
-0.6842351556,
-0.4672266841,
-0.2747301757,
0.1549118608,
-0.2069543451,
-0.6669077873,
0.3276904225,
-0.1620725691,
-0.049183324,
-0.4034511745,
0.9795835614,
-0.5177906156,
-0.080923304,
-0.0149771748,
0.7053604126,
0.2711137831,
-0.1706538349,
-0.3226306438,
-0.3457544148,
-0.1394552886,
-0.282035321,
0.4508294761,
0.7562932968,
0.1175576746,
0.2785962224,
0.5044384599,
-0.1571519077,
0.3790231347,
0.0317506865,
0.838270545,
-0.9668319225,
-0.5283663273,
-0.3702400029,
0.6471826434,
0.0445939973,
-0.0847905278,
0.7399230003,
0.714638114,
0.8771004677,
-0.1638124585,
0.6325779557,
-0.3510578275,
0.7329906225,
-0.482121706,
0.2881350219,
-0.5496503115,
0.2191931456,
-0.0975856632,
-0.7727880478,
-0.0379216522,
0.1633771658,
0.2076571584,
-0.2698924839,
0.4764004648,
0.5051478148,
0.0259532314,
0.1563877165,
0.3039779365,
0.0141735058,
-0.0597295463,
0.6172202826,
0.8249943852,
-0.5684348941,
0.4009482861,
-0.0601473972,
-0.2724560201,
-0.1163711771,
-0.66490978,
-0.2276287973,
-0.6757503748,
0.2829186618,
-0.6067427993,
0.1171108708,
0.7120764852,
0.2183885127,
-0.4283698201,
-0.2314130217,
0.0022839161,
0.2503419518,
-0.3395732641,
-0.2211975604,
0.1758312136,
-0.9014371037,
-0.8429323435,
0.6099729538,
0.5075095892,
-0.0884137377,
-0.2168381661,
-0.0132547729,
-0.3212823272,
0.0977295265,
0.7563849688,
0.5766472816,
-0.2577270865,
0.0423097908,
0.202559486,
-0.1218511239,
0.1101240367,
1.0873707533,
-1.1407094002,
0.3048641682,
0.5861373544,
1.1148074865,
0.5163909197,
0.1632581651,
0.4247265756,
-0.7201908827,
0.0369086415,
0.6990219355,
0.2606678009,
0.260807246,
-0.5704215765,
0.7881445885,
0.1979077458,
-0.6674242616,
-0.5893810391,
0.3414752483,
-0.9508413076,
-0.381670177,
0.8447598219,
-0.0226901602,
-0.0800395831,
-0.1079547033,
-0.0079539856,
0.1522872895,
-0.0635762885,
0.7268896699,
0.2203740329,
-0.1331731677,
0.1278553456,
-0.3716028929,
0.4367344975,
0.4052445292,
-0.6938021779,
-0.0249434896,
0.4562966526,
-0.2145124376,
0.3009490371,
0.9534099102,
-0.4345460832,
0.2992180884,
0.1619522721,
-0.0731610656,
0.171860829,
-0.4011431038,
-0.0724315643,
0.4835311472,
0.1557653546,
-0.2762149572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00342v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00342v1 | Korean Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis via Implicit-Feature Alignment with Corpus Filtering | 2024-06-29T07:01:51 | 2024-06-29T07:01:51 | Kibeom Nam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Investigations into Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) for Korean
restaurant reviews are notably lacking in the existing literature. Our research
proposes an intuitive and effective framework for ABSA in low-resource
languages such as Korean. It optimizes prediction labels by integrating
translated benchmark and unlabeled Korean data. Using a model fine-tuned on
translated data, we pseudo-labeled the actual Korean NLI set. Subsequently, we
applied LaBSE and MSP-based filtering to this pseudo-NLI set as implicit
feature, enhancing Aspect Category Detection and Polarity determination through
additional training. Incorporating dual filtering, this model bridged dataset
gaps, achieving positive results in Korean ABSA with minimal resources. Through
additional data injection pipelines, our approach aims to utilize high-resource
data and construct effective models within communities, whether corporate or
individual, in low-resource language countries. Compared to English ABSA, our
framework showed an approximately 3% difference in F1 scores and accuracy. We
release the dataset and our code for Korean ABSA, at this link. | [
-0.4528357089,
-0.4600450695,
0.7553081512,
0.2815397382,
-0.5848488212,
0.0807968304,
-0.0054154,
-0.6207954884,
0.6204956174,
0.7091913819,
-0.4050704241,
-0.9368708134,
-0.1406867951,
0.2115594894,
0.1024843529,
1.1710431576,
-0.244623512,
0.4494368136,
-0.315725714,
-0.5042708516,
-0.3233057857,
-0.3745422363,
-0.4760833681,
-0.3442911506,
0.3864462674,
0.4949720204,
0.7442905307,
0.4624173939,
0.2770215869,
0.2228966057,
-0.1445502639,
0.0641682819,
-0.1934773028,
0.084574163,
-0.2609760761,
-0.3691315353,
-0.6394640803,
-0.0328077488,
0.3247439265,
0.7938815951,
0.3387441933,
0.1506043077,
0.0542849824,
1.1393494606,
-0.2753721178,
0.4257265925,
-0.2247283906,
0.0582989976,
0.086957708,
0.4305182397,
0.0290888846,
-0.5042908788,
0.0615089461,
-0.5093974471,
-0.1094815731,
0.0452978723,
0.7577306628,
0.2548125386,
-0.3034486473,
-0.430516988,
-0.8296709657,
0.6778982282,
-0.6697794199,
0.3497526646,
0.3635702431,
-0.2188629806,
0.1802351922,
-0.4139363766,
-0.6377112269,
-0.1577586681,
-0.2850245535,
0.2688421905,
-0.0180741102,
0.1322584003,
-0.0954415128,
0.527864933,
-0.4681334794,
0.158548221,
-0.1763793677,
0.2381206453,
0.647157073,
-0.1081122607,
0.2270739973,
-0.6816427708,
-0.3163459897,
-0.1131417155,
-0.8061779737,
0.3505232036,
0.4538454115,
0.4084197879,
-0.0855773464,
0.6996603012,
-0.5253955722,
0.3056336045,
-0.0048530716,
0.1066267192,
0.4332292676,
-0.6096323133,
0.0286022965,
0.2937433124,
0.8561621904,
0.5931746364,
-0.0134679107,
-0.0272043291,
-0.4922872484,
0.1206265017,
0.2057411373,
-0.5349825025,
-0.4088479877,
0.6275615692,
-0.576464057,
-0.380441159,
0.3694040179,
-0.8830863833,
-0.4825947583,
-0.4214575589,
-0.0546652265,
-0.0522982217,
-0.4094871879,
-0.3709529638,
0.0987191498,
0.1758531928,
-0.0804951563,
-0.3079434633,
-0.0305190813,
0.8293485045,
0.7990993857,
0.0244225245,
0.0812224299,
-0.1841527969,
-0.1165566221,
-0.4995839,
0.7340949774,
-0.5133399367,
-0.5015797019,
0.233327657,
0.1570524424,
0.2350107282,
-0.6360197067,
0.7480960488,
-0.4939342439,
-0.2077529281,
-0.3604137301,
-0.3181924522,
-0.4163550436,
0.2095488012,
-0.6814126968,
1.1438195705,
0.2740728855,
-0.4259444773,
0.3337117136,
-0.4852140546,
-0.5698800683,
-0.0075348937,
-0.1073907763,
-0.4733192027,
0.3676232696,
0.6481262445,
0.1868639141,
-0.0055326005,
0.1257646382,
-0.4223380983,
0.0694998279,
0.4735635817,
0.0172609575,
0.2760531902,
0.2472622097,
-0.0724967644,
0.4366630614,
-0.4755029678,
0.2293838859,
-0.1603346765,
0.0709678009,
-0.7951673269,
-0.0011005019,
0.1126413494,
0.52010113,
0.397105068,
-0.5651425719,
0.0811776668,
-0.6111216545,
0.1478737742,
0.4556362033,
0.127858445,
0.7631464601,
0.0629794821,
0.6496862173,
0.2041251212,
0.2875147164,
-0.0964310169,
-0.5435534716,
-0.4819765091,
-0.3285724223,
0.3953471184,
0.6131289005,
-1.195225358,
0.6079934835,
-0.3826777637,
-0.4897483885,
-0.9486293793,
0.3580778241,
0.6696062088,
0.4129046798,
0.3263145983,
-0.5359188318,
-0.420309037,
-0.9353491664,
0.0021609098,
-0.3878352344,
-0.1202408224,
0.3492099345,
0.1080812067,
0.1424481273,
1.0022102594,
-0.7144277692,
-0.5450248122,
-0.5983356237,
0.1875556707,
0.5747216344,
0.3194793165,
0.5567834377,
-0.8686462641,
-0.8355996609,
0.2698019147,
-0.7466414571,
-0.3487158418,
0.0665066615,
-0.1233848482,
0.3229731321,
0.2735524476,
-0.3617749512,
0.3765173256,
0.532764554,
-0.3765942752,
0.3664559424,
0.1638375819,
0.3108479679,
-1.1142168045,
-0.1799753308,
0.4037971497,
-0.0867316872,
-0.5429644585,
-0.1998854876,
-0.0625377893,
-0.22960338,
-0.3334254324,
0.6552932262,
-0.3086610734,
-0.2357179224,
-0.7199516892,
0.0723348856,
0.1408820301,
0.6840136051,
0.3390224874,
0.492923528,
0.1663388908,
-0.3062634468,
0.1292457581,
-0.0060747918,
-0.3926241696,
0.8742123842,
-0.5604225397,
0.1885987967,
-0.0351550691,
0.2968886197,
-1.1854025126,
0.0977166221,
0.4535912275,
-0.1804294288,
0.1586202383,
-0.5840219259,
-0.1842877269,
-0.3941173851,
-0.6247618794,
0.2377035916,
0.2571305335,
-0.4257570803,
0.8198969364,
0.5574868917,
-0.5029587746,
-0.5807127357,
-0.291862309,
-0.1723763794,
-0.0302667134,
-0.3732151389,
0.4789632261,
0.3613219857,
-0.3725345731,
0.5422214866,
-0.3493287563,
-0.2053625733,
-0.361307025,
0.484900564,
0.4319683611,
-0.4104190469,
-0.3599822223,
0.3050195575,
-0.1256419122,
0.0253119878,
-0.2440340519,
0.4345222116,
-0.4639984071,
-0.0132500138,
-0.5311914682,
0.3192940056,
0.3750700653,
0.0105143152,
0.752397418,
0.6464986801,
-0.1907711178,
-0.0009414527,
-0.1967838407,
-0.1261933595,
-0.4213598073,
0.67271173,
-0.3752839565,
-0.3448057771,
0.6855297685,
0.0432921536,
-0.1145829931,
0.3049694002,
0.0612385347,
-0.3658428788,
0.8948771358,
0.4782070518,
-0.3967119157,
0.422192812,
-0.0821465179,
0.578437686,
-0.9060505629,
-0.0405284055,
-0.5716817975,
-0.2699387968,
-0.6140665412,
-0.1981895715,
0.4741624892,
0.3634942472,
0.2744950652,
0.1503608376,
-0.3399863839,
0.6744440198,
0.3446619511,
0.0119187627,
0.2605548799,
-0.243813619,
0.1441248059,
-0.2938754559,
-0.4165045023,
-0.6127353907,
0.8290492892,
0.336243391,
0.5551045537,
0.0655771419,
0.3615880609,
0.2714982331,
0.6569924951,
-0.8378764391,
0.369481355,
-0.5203521848,
-0.1575881392,
-0.2396038175,
-0.4493632317,
-0.319129467,
0.2548985779,
-0.2058413923,
-0.286083132,
0.3047568798,
0.0903199241,
-0.1133919507,
0.2058381885,
-0.8822786808,
0.8048606515,
-0.3685154915,
-0.3287831843,
0.0640590191,
-0.2569475472,
0.3167393208,
-0.0570712723,
0.42081815,
-0.2703931928,
0.1316459477,
0.4630116224,
-0.4129125774,
0.9475806355,
-0.6029952168,
-0.1061366871,
0.2578423917,
-0.1403776407,
0.5731807947,
0.5234633088,
0.0166931301,
0.6208803058,
-0.1334373653,
-0.0981734321,
-0.6376113296,
0.8820642233,
-0.6850941777,
-0.3050324023,
-0.3748474121,
-0.1983674765,
-0.4278864861,
0.2140021473,
-0.0043724016,
-0.0415310711,
-0.1441146135,
-0.0628936812,
0.4073611796,
-0.1455460042,
0.3192701936,
0.743142724,
-0.4802773595,
-0.7365202904,
1.0565974712,
0.1389641017,
-0.2580447793,
0.2838695049,
-0.0672704801,
-0.7158082128,
-0.3794803917,
-0.6324307919,
0.3760792017,
-0.5370035172,
-0.2888054252,
-0.4451279342,
-0.2890826762,
-0.4297305346,
-0.2400953323,
-0.854192853,
-0.3111996949,
0.015717933,
-0.2188830376,
0.1744138002,
0.8692516685,
0.1043083444,
0.3730011582,
-0.5555741191,
0.2627899945,
0.0285200588,
0.4209862649,
-0.0946049243,
-0.3343705237,
-0.313896656,
-0.1922465712,
-0.1237724572,
-0.8517189622,
0.5738705993,
-0.0554109439,
0.1969796866,
0.4331908524,
0.3259835839,
0.3352095783,
-0.2006516457,
0.7551406026,
0.1230993047,
-0.8810173869,
0.3842594326,
-0.0042349431,
0.4175113142,
0.722913146,
0.4553647935,
-0.6447475553,
-0.4795380831,
-0.1064761803,
-1.4675935507,
0.7143827081,
-0.0525546893,
0.1837323159,
0.1315862536,
0.5184902549,
0.1795116216,
0.3482336402,
-0.9208427072,
-0.3935076594,
-0.6065951586,
-0.5432282686,
0.2096044719,
-0.4594031572,
-0.0148462504,
-0.2901113033,
1.0010031462,
-0.1704316288,
0.0048506707,
0.0675781742,
0.0838265643,
-0.1327122301,
0.3839226067,
0.3861579597,
0.6277929544,
-0.2460393757,
0.033603806,
-0.0991953835,
-0.5817627907,
0.0600417182,
0.1446415484,
-0.3021740317,
0.0648275241,
0.0306005049,
0.7399684191,
0.0731692761,
-0.3869715035,
0.4242494106,
-0.020562483,
0.2571916878,
-0.4127767086,
-0.2890939415,
-0.0651116744,
0.1322028637,
0.3415137827,
-0.1450301856,
0.0724393278,
-0.2538281381,
0.2201675475,
0.2208938003,
-0.8331281543,
-0.6118124127,
0.2901104391,
0.3847000599,
0.2017077506,
0.7272194624,
-0.4567615092,
-0.5593517423,
0.5177336931,
0.2005686909,
1.0924304724,
-0.3254165351,
0.7187196016,
0.4164725244,
0.4741645157,
0.1372841895,
0.3095303178,
0.2187441587,
-0.7485388517,
-0.6073255539,
-0.8626409769,
-0.3591806889,
0.2592941225,
-0.7902458906,
0.0794491842,
-0.4285663068,
-0.1327228248,
-0.0467427708,
-0.1221420616,
-0.2837744057,
0.1176095381,
0.0070398538,
0.3098824024,
-1.192915678,
0.7779222131,
1.1393409967,
-0.4551014304,
-0.4949346781,
0.2239252776,
-0.093455337,
-0.3629083335,
0.3211067617,
0.23448807,
-0.2455269843,
-0.5737643242,
-0.231562227,
-0.7598773837,
0.5480929613,
-0.1230875254,
-0.355357796,
0.3854263723,
0.2171940953,
0.7468675971,
-0.5958473682,
-0.0480158441,
0.4085717201,
0.3721525073,
-0.0178916007,
-0.5759618878,
-0.0981563702,
-0.3221464753,
0.1389910132,
0.1049672812,
-0.5484666228,
0.3934742808,
0.1644860357,
0.1283997893,
-0.2125704736,
1.1500290632,
0.0863460898,
0.8020377755,
0.5308301449,
0.4366866946,
0.503813982,
-0.1844634712,
0.837161541,
-0.4202048182,
0.1938727051,
1.3061721325,
-0.6582813859,
0.8984709382,
0.5180048943,
-0.1916346848,
0.527603507,
0.6294680238,
0.2320907265,
0.8981146216,
-0.3111492693,
-0.1119608283,
0.1858452559,
-0.5621973276,
-0.1235771105,
0.432965219,
0.2618935108,
-0.4696159959,
0.2243639529,
0.035303019,
0.1567870229,
0.1445373893,
-0.5554509163,
0.9761744142,
0.1788409203,
-0.741872251,
-0.0028132128,
0.3336268961,
0.5427412987,
-0.3647837639,
0.1159450188,
-0.610696435,
-0.0316708386,
-0.3985815048,
-1.0397223234,
0.5291266441,
0.2310979813,
-0.5380247235,
-0.0377542153,
0.4481134713,
-0.6153824329,
-0.540427804,
0.1995420903,
0.3755494356,
-0.0965107083,
-0.1853344142,
-0.7131252289,
0.0279859025,
0.1904494315,
-0.0611450449,
0.1866872758,
0.2638556659,
-0.244782716,
-0.0007686149,
0.4273197353,
0.100624755,
-0.3038589954,
0.2523798943,
0.6882054806,
-0.5798934102,
-0.9836974144,
-0.5073881149,
0.2811570466,
-0.220380336,
-0.2428830862,
0.6488668323,
0.7066640854,
0.9415105581,
-0.2614115775,
0.6223474741,
-0.0069140345,
0.3807894289,
-0.80918926,
0.7615268826,
-0.3289795518,
0.6104555726,
-0.3704740405,
-1.2380157709,
-0.0254467148,
0.4310673773,
-0.5147295594,
0.1085672602,
0.720977664,
0.8024842739,
0.0183069631,
0.1859667897,
0.1512077451,
0.317227751,
0.1685957164,
0.0010317209,
0.6914658546,
-0.2245950848,
0.3052956164,
-0.6898852587,
-0.2178287357,
-0.0450406708,
-0.6435651779,
-0.5584328175,
-0.6366984248,
-0.6078624129,
-0.4533414841,
-0.3413100541,
0.7658790946,
0.5462406874,
-1.1609672308,
-0.1560699791,
0.1930606514,
0.4628656209,
-0.6351076961,
-0.3354437053,
0.6924729943,
-0.3033432066,
-0.8591045737,
0.4731014073,
0.4190279841,
-0.1706288606,
-0.2805850208,
-0.0535642654,
0.0960169584,
0.0569183677,
0.5849974155,
0.3249594867,
-0.6021782756,
-0.0439779051,
-0.1825341284,
-0.0959111303,
0.1443046927,
0.7388385534,
-0.3212945759,
0.4693990946,
0.3218096495,
0.3808095157,
0.2040845752,
0.2714953721,
0.4504075944,
-1.2676776648,
0.210548088,
0.1074138135,
0.2082933784,
0.508269906,
-0.5220526457,
0.6778405905,
0.1487998515,
-0.2946566045,
-0.7176995277,
0.1193032935,
-0.9347065687,
-0.3653285503,
1.1095364094,
-0.2364148945,
-0.6534820795,
-0.429716289,
0.021267293,
0.0708855018,
-0.6550329924,
0.9341102242,
0.738263309,
-0.361738354,
0.1442126185,
-0.5021814704,
0.7493742108,
0.4487101436,
-0.7961380482,
-0.0113674914,
0.6593646407,
0.1397435665,
0.1998213679,
0.6570388079,
-0.2657155097,
0.1376710087,
-0.383854866,
0.2388439029,
0.0909589529,
-0.5253558755,
-0.4787802696,
0.2842051387,
0.0016247045,
-0.258810252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00341v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00341v1 | Iterative Data Augmentation with Large Language Models for Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis | 2024-06-29T07:00:37 | 2024-06-29T07:00:37 | Haiyun Li, Qihuang Zhong, Ke Zhu, Juhua Liu, Bo Du, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) is an important sentiment analysis
task, which aims to determine the sentiment polarity towards an aspect in a
sentence. Due to the expensive and limited labeled data, data augmentation (DA)
has become the standard for improving the performance of ABSA. However, current
DA methods usually have some shortcomings: 1) poor fluency and coherence, 2)
lack of diversity of generated data, and 3) reliance on some existing labeled
data, hindering its applications in real-world scenarios. In response to these
problems, we propose a systematic Iterative Data augmentation framework, namely
IterD, to boost the performance of ABSA. The core of IterD is to leverage the
powerful ability of large language models (LLMs) to iteratively generate more
fluent and diverse synthetic labeled data, starting from an unsupervised
sentence corpus. Extensive experiments on 4 widely-used ABSA benchmarks show
that IterD brings consistent and significant performance gains among 5 baseline
ABSA models. More encouragingly, the synthetic data generated by IterD can
achieve comparable or even better performance against the manually annotated
data. | [
-0.6003405452,
-0.8327926397,
0.5330635905,
0.3759767413,
-0.6329163313,
0.2525608242,
-0.2847346067,
-0.4981221259,
0.466835022,
0.6113353968,
-0.5533192754,
-0.8424733281,
-0.4232245088,
0.0774331018,
-0.5201708078,
1.0370591879,
-0.0489942133,
-0.0097385049,
-0.4054850936,
-0.3867527843,
-0.4213479757,
-0.7757847905,
-0.3241201937,
-0.2868777514,
0.2422769517,
0.5702270865,
0.6149012446,
0.5783284307,
0.5310792923,
0.3028015196,
-0.2268216014,
0.0560701676,
-0.1373609751,
0.2722473145,
-0.3148561418,
-0.322324127,
-0.4822271764,
-0.2526972294,
0.6247807145,
1.0519779921,
0.0243963953,
-0.0197931286,
0.0504852533,
1.0085413456,
-0.307302326,
0.4206438363,
-0.403850168,
-0.1406927407,
-0.2980576158,
0.1376640648,
-0.0499218889,
-0.3244756162,
0.1057346165,
-0.2448461056,
0.1898993701,
-0.0192646738,
0.6713789701,
0.1761790216,
-0.197322458,
-0.1899611056,
-0.8837140799,
0.6985903382,
-1.0565520525,
0.3806824386,
0.0732790306,
-0.1306863725,
-0.0260087308,
-0.4787800014,
-0.7178773284,
-0.2497017235,
0.1283992529,
0.0993029773,
-0.1725344658,
0.2118019164,
0.1456312984,
1.013848424,
-0.2445373982,
0.3138789833,
-0.2874937057,
0.1609879434,
0.7945296764,
0.2099930495,
0.0631291792,
-0.3063085973,
-0.1519773453,
-0.3408345282,
-0.7121713758,
0.21618101,
0.4662740231,
0.5998016596,
-0.0617815107,
0.9511837959,
-0.5375807285,
0.6563603282,
0.0960650593,
0.1251684129,
0.5009880066,
-0.3892834783,
0.0803221315,
0.0511242934,
0.8323005438,
0.3102862835,
-0.0695116892,
-0.0904675126,
-0.3967168033,
0.2213734537,
0.2672381103,
-0.8201932311,
-0.3134204149,
0.6687470675,
-0.0985841155,
-0.2183346897,
0.088563934,
-0.9134653211,
-0.3757754266,
-0.5268831849,
0.2129889131,
-0.5324428678,
-0.2995575666,
-0.01318751,
0.2180777788,
-0.0225490704,
0.0244313907,
-0.4404390752,
0.0274062473,
1.0306870937,
0.7962136865,
-0.4067440331,
-0.0800028443,
-0.4286920428,
-0.3859347701,
-0.584382236,
1.0251945257,
-0.9046439528,
-0.5173019767,
-0.0282701682,
-0.2923794091,
0.2111105025,
-0.6459627151,
0.7602607012,
-0.4997888505,
0.0937061012,
-0.2646378279,
-0.7510658503,
-0.4776808023,
0.4074856043,
-0.8752444983,
1.1198784113,
0.3062418103,
-0.7543552518,
0.3874618709,
-0.6240562797,
-0.7394427061,
-0.1636165679,
-0.0379417576,
-0.8001420498,
0.4225280583,
0.5343536735,
0.3607869744,
-0.4830853045,
0.524526298,
-0.4921222925,
0.071443148,
0.5439510942,
-0.2727510333,
0.4170979559,
0.1114927381,
-0.0327612422,
0.3214107156,
-0.774192214,
-0.1308554113,
-0.3583496809,
-0.262595892,
-0.4403371215,
0.0422238633,
0.1175981313,
0.0968105644,
0.0774684101,
-0.7879645824,
0.3917019665,
-0.7999762893,
0.1120254099,
0.7287022471,
0.1498436928,
0.6010157466,
-0.238301754,
0.5271442533,
0.4000367224,
-0.0087468419,
-0.3778474629,
-0.3403570652,
-0.8398309946,
-0.5249424577,
0.5237054825,
0.2858352661,
-0.9381020069,
0.8768042922,
-0.4168604314,
-0.4690169692,
-0.8254625201,
0.3600650132,
0.0597322173,
0.394862026,
0.3492894471,
-0.5716459751,
-0.5077120066,
-0.802483201,
-0.1203047633,
-0.2460493743,
0.0827497318,
-0.0629652962,
0.332621634,
-0.3383585215,
1.1745282412,
-0.344563067,
-0.6614117622,
-0.4181430042,
0.3067390323,
0.3439660966,
0.4943381548,
0.320453465,
-0.5814203024,
-0.2331308722,
-0.0113013489,
-0.5296666026,
-0.3666942418,
-0.1588274091,
0.1700270176,
0.2778635919,
0.1537453085,
-0.3270141184,
0.3069241345,
0.6595919132,
-0.2334573418,
0.2421053797,
-0.0099561326,
0.154532209,
-1.3796802759,
-0.0365691856,
0.2361971587,
-0.2017459422,
-0.6018916368,
0.1840423048,
-0.0377175249,
-0.0602050088,
-0.107020922,
0.5006567836,
-0.383243382,
-0.2485426068,
-0.5813631415,
0.004270249,
0.0142235523,
0.2980214655,
0.1586255431,
0.5962714553,
0.7489981055,
-0.541277647,
0.2593317032,
0.0431642048,
-0.322625488,
0.6998739839,
-0.5081706047,
0.0882109106,
-0.3067835271,
0.213995412,
-0.865121901,
-0.130569607,
0.0998157933,
-0.2234729677,
0.2322213948,
0.0992175788,
-0.5184295774,
-0.3711730242,
-0.5802807808,
0.5298493505,
0.2687983513,
-0.6874591708,
0.9486156702,
0.348353833,
-0.4761704504,
-0.4055229127,
-0.3708663881,
0.3041333258,
-0.1402492374,
-0.5444087982,
0.5016079545,
-0.0803698301,
-0.4853485227,
0.2276978046,
0.0013381032,
0.055203788,
-0.2058828175,
0.3356461525,
0.3181619644,
-0.0984732062,
0.0190205853,
0.2698276937,
-0.2054473013,
-0.1162446067,
0.0222315695,
0.6572974324,
-0.1567411125,
-0.5182165504,
-0.5811862946,
0.5453891754,
0.4009778798,
-0.2520937324,
0.5399420857,
0.2588927746,
-0.2581826448,
-0.175576821,
-0.4897015393,
-0.2736202478,
-0.4556043148,
0.3389771581,
-0.3664844334,
-0.7584196329,
0.6362039447,
0.0276189074,
0.2094486505,
0.4636392295,
0.3641918302,
-0.1108869091,
1.0299344063,
0.8113860488,
-0.5761795044,
0.5855723619,
-0.3603464663,
0.3548914194,
-0.9269371629,
-0.0929682255,
-0.563839376,
-0.1717810631,
-0.5911713839,
-0.5728455782,
0.5229093432,
0.1595465839,
0.1640060544,
0.032388445,
-0.3513224125,
0.1508700252,
0.3771052957,
0.0672339946,
0.6809357405,
0.0808682144,
0.3615074158,
-0.1345705539,
-0.3794733584,
-0.3012631238,
1.110907197,
0.3883348405,
0.8354846835,
-0.0475595407,
0.622389257,
0.3426697552,
0.5609090924,
-1.0618780851,
0.4488891065,
-0.4246047139,
-0.1484450996,
0.2084537446,
-0.2797022462,
-0.5859609246,
0.1201199517,
-0.2246718407,
-0.6618480086,
0.3029671311,
0.1467540413,
-0.1009136066,
0.1526881307,
-0.2631430328,
0.2601668239,
-0.1422294676,
-0.348406285,
-0.2929805219,
-0.1636140645,
0.3852488697,
-0.2811339796,
0.2706799209,
0.0273722652,
0.0851626247,
0.7562935352,
-0.7147011161,
0.7998164296,
-0.2176185101,
-0.3915700614,
0.3272702694,
-0.1378440559,
0.7143842578,
0.1044507548,
-0.319837302,
0.3658069372,
-0.3388158381,
-0.3049318492,
-0.4471027553,
0.8566075563,
-0.4924639165,
-0.6692687869,
-0.4728715122,
-0.8094084263,
-0.4279378355,
-0.0952311531,
0.0869129151,
0.53635782,
-0.0555977076,
0.320856601,
0.4211257398,
-0.2007233799,
0.5263671875,
0.4866701961,
-0.3946764469,
-0.5467481017,
0.933015883,
0.0898207054,
0.052547574,
0.2658567727,
0.0191798862,
-0.5439394712,
-0.7579366565,
-0.6313429475,
0.1943638474,
-0.6310153008,
-0.2481824458,
-0.6620845795,
-0.0815505162,
-0.3219259083,
-0.085971117,
-0.8108400702,
-0.4078917801,
-0.17588377,
-0.288498044,
0.7493684292,
0.7199548483,
-0.0595375784,
0.4101262093,
-0.7567679286,
0.4182850122,
-0.177758351,
0.3308974802,
-0.3340298533,
-0.4296664596,
-0.0237374902,
0.116079323,
-0.1055142283,
-0.759285748,
0.5968637466,
0.145502001,
0.3602201045,
0.4124550819,
0.2136695981,
0.6976664662,
-0.0513346158,
0.8938068151,
0.0085488837,
-0.8727419376,
0.329176873,
-0.0987647846,
0.2632829547,
0.5978918076,
0.0536949821,
-0.376535356,
-0.5953401923,
-0.4340710044,
-1.4417150021,
0.5624519587,
0.1638647765,
0.3508202732,
0.2378471792,
0.4107858539,
0.4341444671,
0.3009919226,
-0.5721791387,
-0.2103427649,
-0.2071003765,
-0.5607820153,
0.030059427,
-0.1052935794,
-0.0638868883,
-0.3187930882,
0.8094274402,
-0.4074542522,
0.202962786,
0.1169775724,
-0.138508305,
-0.0376999937,
0.4021339118,
0.06460464,
0.5201730132,
-0.01680292,
-0.0688570812,
-0.0807091072,
-0.2264853269,
0.0255449414,
0.4050559402,
-0.3225633502,
-0.087115787,
0.2878076136,
0.884257853,
-0.2111042589,
-0.7053302526,
0.3576417267,
0.2000207752,
0.1005527452,
-0.2291886061,
-0.0515841059,
-0.060171511,
0.4247135222,
0.5745124817,
-0.086534746,
0.2376932949,
-0.7092360854,
0.3031758964,
0.5824985504,
-0.3832169771,
-0.4211657345,
0.3765994012,
0.1438208818,
-0.0627852231,
0.5169081688,
-0.2001603097,
-0.6045323014,
0.4655722678,
0.3386158943,
1.0362927914,
-0.0438676998,
0.3962657452,
0.3243227899,
0.2134236544,
-0.1792252809,
0.5022835732,
-0.0195739772,
-0.6713706255,
-0.7599574327,
-0.8122673631,
-0.5482025146,
0.1516610086,
-0.8043929935,
0.0209841132,
-0.3884695768,
-0.0249730702,
-0.0630465522,
-0.0777343661,
-0.4680823088,
0.2625132799,
-0.1012322381,
0.5814344883,
-0.9597916603,
0.7231805325,
0.7853111029,
-0.425430119,
-0.550622642,
0.3177365363,
-0.2358672917,
-0.2977759838,
0.1589660645,
0.2940138578,
0.0690697581,
-0.0355392098,
-0.314022243,
-0.6285575032,
0.7824898362,
0.0361426622,
-0.7425963283,
0.4577796459,
0.5147145987,
0.7814935446,
-0.5694513321,
0.0257190447,
0.6956892014,
0.461361587,
0.1732772887,
-0.6190199852,
0.040480189,
-0.3098425865,
0.2599420547,
0.0124972435,
-0.4616342485,
0.9047782421,
-0.242488578,
-0.0682416037,
0.0662011281,
1.0302788019,
0.2464106083,
0.3716754615,
0.5357083082,
0.77365309,
0.6409266591,
-0.2565892041,
1.0433965921,
-0.4163248539,
0.3168615699,
1.0112646818,
-0.4932233393,
0.9069097042,
0.3731832802,
-0.0685066506,
0.6565554142,
0.6462955475,
0.1407700181,
0.4199192822,
-0.2115765959,
-0.4357946217,
-0.124279581,
-0.2879463732,
-0.1178417429,
0.4125713706,
0.4390333295,
-0.3275760412,
-0.2570550144,
0.4337741733,
0.0446181744,
0.3262955248,
-0.4664479792,
1.0380992889,
-0.0422713831,
-0.7474796176,
0.2508417964,
0.2586306632,
0.852335155,
-0.2086473554,
0.1112204641,
-0.5673002005,
0.3561965227,
-0.1943226606,
-1.1082581282,
0.4773354232,
0.2577773631,
-0.1795054525,
-0.008936407,
0.7037165761,
-0.551394701,
-0.8005893826,
0.1223507673,
0.2930394709,
-0.2048930824,
-0.4576239288,
-0.6975414753,
0.2605984509,
0.1194362268,
-0.473661691,
0.2470703125,
0.1976743788,
-0.3592303395,
0.6865162849,
0.664201498,
0.1346395314,
-0.3084413409,
0.1827966869,
1.3404980898,
-0.7916529775,
-0.569504559,
-0.835300684,
0.5888797045,
-0.1967793852,
-0.017511053,
0.6847494245,
0.6494566798,
0.6598864198,
0.1751261503,
0.9991668463,
-0.2017788291,
0.5985108614,
-0.6460245848,
0.1987799406,
-0.3386137486,
0.6826121211,
-0.2762636542,
-1.2472765446,
-0.3048753142,
0.414573431,
-0.3547185361,
0.0616602078,
0.5838441253,
0.9921292663,
-0.0150032258,
0.3062211871,
-0.1034356803,
0.4171254635,
0.6061495543,
-0.0149419727,
0.6651588082,
-0.3244769275,
0.1261198819,
-0.7903808355,
-0.1535043567,
-0.0993713886,
-0.891896069,
-0.7238386869,
-0.7739880681,
-0.5674188733,
-0.3757270277,
-0.2400413901,
1.0150383711,
0.2807638645,
-0.9096471667,
0.011388612,
-0.2176797986,
0.0453848131,
-0.3234419227,
-0.3507660925,
0.3431532979,
-0.2529928088,
-1.1088963747,
0.473562628,
0.3101808429,
-0.1475953311,
-0.4987989068,
0.1739358753,
0.0497488827,
0.1711690128,
0.7115359902,
0.2283869088,
-0.483812362,
-0.2851848006,
-0.2613151371,
0.231390059,
0.27382043,
0.8700070381,
-0.8421220183,
0.6675534844,
0.6475306749,
0.7055683136,
0.4794438183,
0.4804146588,
0.687767148,
-1.0203227997,
0.0694270507,
0.2805996537,
0.2026890516,
0.8314115405,
-0.2690320015,
0.3340130746,
0.0920717344,
-0.2320788056,
-0.8596054912,
0.023374116,
-1.1394323111,
-0.3179756105,
1.3962862492,
-0.0529920422,
-0.259095341,
-0.1448180526,
-0.3173757195,
0.0602079295,
-0.6919348836,
0.9675731063,
0.3887892663,
-0.2722762525,
-0.0818417594,
-0.1949294508,
0.3943021297,
0.4109817445,
-1.1649727821,
0.3198260665,
0.8263852,
0.2432088703,
0.1901055127,
0.5917643905,
-0.1736070961,
-0.0345345475,
-0.2591624856,
0.1931782365,
-0.0215003919,
-0.3365032375,
-0.4374531806,
0.3116860092,
0.1553328335,
-0.0792961419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01626v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01626v1 | SPARKLE: Enhancing SPARQL Generation with Direct KG Integration in Decoding | 2024-06-29T06:43:11 | 2024-06-29T06:43:11 | Jaebok Lee, Hyeonjeong Shin | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Existing KBQA methods have traditionally relied on multi-stage methodologies,
involving tasks such as entity linking, subgraph retrieval and query structure
generation. However, multi-stage approaches are dependent on the accuracy of
preceding steps, leading to cascading errors and increased inference time.
Although a few studies have explored the use of end-to-end models, they often
suffer from lower accuracy and generate inoperative query that is not supported
by the underlying data. Furthermore, most prior approaches are limited to the
static training data, potentially overlooking the evolving nature of knowledge
bases over time. To address these challenges, we present a novel end-to-end
natural language to SPARQL framework, SPARKLE. Notably SPARKLE leverages the
structure of knowledge base directly during the decoding, effectively
integrating knowledge into the query generation. Our study reveals that simply
referencing knowledge base during inference significantly reduces the
occurrence of inexecutable query generations. SPARKLE achieves new
state-of-the-art results on SimpleQuestions-Wiki and highest F1 score on LCQuAD
1.0 (among models not using gold entities), while getting slightly lower result
on the WebQSP dataset. Finally, we demonstrate SPARKLE's fast inference speed
and its ability to adapt when the knowledge base differs between the training
and inference stages. | [
-0.3438768089,
-0.6899399161,
0.0104171298,
0.489523083,
0.0856505707,
0.2579814196,
0.1480975896,
-0.3501415849,
0.0559373274,
0.720058322,
-0.6000103354,
-0.4220043719,
-0.1848201901,
0.0096254312,
-0.3239678741,
0.8678367734,
0.4330536127,
-0.0084737232,
-0.2149538845,
0.062296655,
-0.5137006044,
-0.506865561,
-0.4079248309,
-0.3105559051,
0.3495566547,
0.4944516122,
0.7887734771,
-0.0436876938,
-0.0456136279,
0.1240072921,
-0.5028413534,
0.5187647939,
-0.755510509,
0.2965142131,
-0.276588589,
-0.5269807577,
-0.2866239548,
-0.4709392786,
0.4008336067,
0.8847393394,
-0.1167699695,
0.0397341549,
0.2826228738,
1.1961553097,
-1.1531960964,
0.105091922,
-0.795142591,
0.2722070515,
-0.0959968045,
-0.3054856956,
-0.7893257141,
-0.0660725012,
-0.1458226591,
-0.7334461212,
0.3304947913,
0.0695949122,
0.7942445278,
0.2462572604,
-0.9500356913,
-0.4444757998,
-0.6999267936,
0.4791964591,
-0.3273027539,
0.8175559044,
0.2892907858,
0.555650115,
-0.7474289536,
-0.9780071974,
-0.2738795877,
-0.2117216885,
-0.0466776714,
0.2451873869,
-0.106531769,
-0.0367993861,
0.1291214973,
0.1439936012,
-0.4104611874,
-0.5064079762,
0.0490597226,
-0.1500364989,
0.3694553375,
0.1751445532,
0.0358628519,
-0.3956997097,
-0.1995391548,
0.1884251535,
-0.9475066662,
0.1547217816,
0.1201485246,
0.5757776499,
0.3865551054,
0.4083715379,
-0.6087965965,
0.6225450635,
0.4432859719,
0.1733394861,
0.1962080449,
-0.3277694285,
-0.1554273665,
0.3318790793,
0.6607816815,
0.2531503737,
-0.0280036107,
-0.6370768547,
0.3246456087,
-0.2473089248,
0.0822523534,
-1.1685423851,
-0.4876405299,
0.2191642076,
-0.0199068803,
-0.3114185631,
-0.1533832401,
-0.8092715144,
-0.5091206431,
0.1874186695,
0.5531842113,
-0.4358207583,
-0.3805297613,
0.1495702267,
-0.2175870091,
0.2466522306,
0.060815122,
-0.8647329211,
0.3559757173,
0.6440756321,
0.4322364926,
0.3554346859,
0.0533116758,
-0.6815702915,
0.2732162774,
-0.7671438456,
0.6709119081,
-0.4410074353,
-0.4271996617,
-0.2546291649,
-0.1594994664,
-0.0317428596,
-0.555162847,
0.6650162339,
-1.2187783718,
0.2548166513,
-0.432179898,
-0.4861921966,
-0.1908137947,
0.0280724149,
-0.5106921196,
1.3280594349,
0.3340770304,
-0.8121855259,
0.8371728063,
-0.4628136754,
-0.49581182,
0.339544028,
0.0195683837,
-0.3204079866,
0.1222660989,
0.5134243965,
0.2150682211,
-0.2943674326,
0.2800458968,
-0.1823135167,
-0.3745973706,
0.2205656767,
-0.1727963388,
0.645973742,
0.4143137038,
-0.1536324173,
-0.3038645089,
-0.8339771628,
0.4230979085,
-0.1586853117,
-0.3114707172,
-0.3091166019,
0.1073952243,
-0.014645881,
0.1308458298,
0.1251875609,
-0.2652793825,
0.1149790734,
-0.6428280473,
0.097647503,
0.1415276676,
0.4384918213,
0.7173548341,
0.1139023602,
0.4921388626,
0.0919822752,
0.1082453653,
-0.3371908367,
-0.6145011783,
-0.5962917805,
-0.2676953375,
0.6627643704,
0.5408260226,
-0.7827744484,
0.4691451192,
-0.3967387974,
-0.4332471788,
-0.4154788256,
0.1417116225,
0.3579623103,
0.6676685214,
0.4568206072,
-0.0526561849,
-0.5231165886,
-0.5513196588,
-0.5843002796,
0.1414894462,
0.0992943123,
0.356089443,
0.2131516188,
-0.1506975144,
1.3624540567,
-0.281940639,
-0.1720560789,
-0.1534378529,
0.1269713789,
0.5886672139,
0.326171726,
0.4272264242,
-1.1429378986,
-0.8769908547,
0.1987535357,
-0.6575023532,
-0.0696624815,
-0.0343407467,
-0.6993068457,
0.0174435843,
0.1796615869,
-0.4861004353,
0.2900461555,
0.0240744185,
-0.98212713,
0.4016932547,
0.1747880578,
0.6640328169,
-1.1038248539,
0.0237619709,
-0.2264325619,
-0.092122823,
-0.9162328243,
0.0541123487,
0.4688446224,
0.0307696443,
-0.2626707852,
0.4843299389,
-0.5451267362,
-0.0744609758,
-0.0874320343,
-0.365257591,
0.2598585784,
0.2998797894,
-0.1024153233,
0.641735673,
0.4600501657,
-0.7405397892,
0.0653527901,
0.4663905501,
-0.3050317168,
0.3070081174,
-0.1604206413,
-0.0443172343,
-0.0542110763,
0.1910592914,
-1.0230728388,
-0.4635163844,
0.1213665232,
-0.8998829126,
0.4616163671,
-0.8645711541,
-0.647595346,
0.0043278895,
-0.135392651,
0.1087619662,
0.6770556569,
-0.7677172422,
0.8231266737,
-0.0146185597,
0.1202459708,
-1.036765337,
-0.8043475151,
0.3943217397,
-0.2498116642,
-0.9487252831,
0.5994006395,
0.1963522881,
0.0483475327,
0.1568784118,
-0.2422768921,
-0.3414691091,
0.1680645794,
0.0547494218,
-0.0212133303,
-0.2238045931,
-0.0245536529,
0.506202817,
-0.0854768381,
-0.1170962825,
-0.0420128405,
0.2770363688,
0.2500547171,
-0.3932862282,
-0.0598667748,
0.3317219317,
0.6253659725,
-0.2136530727,
1.1375514269,
0.5339409113,
-0.2494412512,
-0.5306710005,
-0.5059668422,
-0.0415991247,
-0.5085657239,
0.4626746774,
-0.5673834682,
-0.9092456698,
0.4989928603,
-0.2553626597,
-0.1987346709,
0.2839670181,
0.5045999885,
0.115497075,
1.2072335482,
0.4225757122,
0.1184857115,
0.272036612,
0.0163151827,
0.3222437799,
-0.7339200974,
-0.4713775814,
-0.342197746,
0.1572437733,
-0.2112800032,
-0.5400748253,
0.5286133289,
1.1129406691,
-0.4475678205,
-0.015251305,
-0.4991528392,
0.6066914797,
0.2102501541,
0.1020440385,
0.401201725,
0.1855624914,
-0.1939549297,
-0.1198807582,
-1.0344483852,
0.0656058937,
1.1713778973,
0.0706240013,
0.7077857852,
0.3013805151,
0.7453389168,
0.2327641994,
0.3415858448,
-0.5937744379,
0.3022197783,
0.1198304817,
-0.6028336287,
0.0696603805,
-0.693931818,
-0.8319125175,
0.5880627036,
-0.4770008624,
-0.5328567624,
0.2020589262,
0.242284447,
-0.1111963391,
-0.0729722083,
-0.8832538128,
0.8453858495,
-0.017484542,
-0.7431732416,
0.2163908929,
-0.4102255106,
0.5814428329,
0.0049653533,
0.4082397223,
0.0514223129,
0.2185799181,
0.4928045273,
-0.4350621998,
0.4634748697,
-0.430665344,
0.0904405415,
0.4796204567,
0.3553120494,
0.6600213051,
-0.1056111529,
-0.083059907,
-0.3593038321,
0.0026201082,
-0.3034861386,
-0.9048817754,
0.4585931599,
-0.2764628828,
-0.1320509017,
-0.1481047273,
-0.4526840448,
-0.6987628937,
-0.046831876,
0.3106397688,
0.5734054446,
0.0207376443,
0.3048422933,
0.8192756772,
-0.0345583148,
0.0254359972,
0.7416560054,
-0.3605340719,
-0.5830503106,
0.8384628892,
0.0174862519,
0.0710041597,
0.6079840064,
0.0466366559,
-0.6959224343,
-0.6325309873,
-0.5404304266,
0.020742882,
-0.8429024816,
-0.4534157217,
-0.6709105372,
-0.0887959749,
-0.8082919121,
-0.2391047329,
-0.3491771817,
-0.4316777885,
-0.1796361208,
0.1608301699,
0.6014788151,
0.4415976107,
0.0539709851,
0.1351088881,
-1.1830710173,
0.2123461813,
0.141321063,
0.1043647379,
0.1399411559,
-0.6381629705,
-0.5069682598,
-0.2371076196,
-0.0915365219,
-1.2154952288,
0.5196999311,
0.5221868157,
0.7329125404,
0.1871654987,
0.2900429964,
0.9458662271,
-0.5079795122,
0.8445006609,
0.2217594832,
-0.7422472239,
0.5113714933,
-0.298230499,
0.2704442441,
0.5313383341,
0.4170811772,
-0.5323507786,
-0.1354336888,
-0.3704609573,
-1.1506214142,
0.4369644821,
0.3140966594,
-0.1075154468,
-0.1412917078,
0.4550418854,
-0.1119684428,
0.1049837992,
-0.537658453,
-0.245277375,
-0.1675213128,
-0.3740009367,
0.3218475282,
-0.455440402,
0.0170571823,
-0.0971292257,
0.7887035608,
-0.2284178138,
0.1730478853,
0.1092223153,
-0.3927224576,
-0.0129061723,
0.4822251201,
-0.168360889,
0.4006310403,
-0.106776908,
-0.1155195758,
0.444018662,
-0.4683534801,
-0.0766104311,
0.0235178676,
0.0147140371,
-0.2137921602,
0.3215735257,
0.3928643763,
0.5710218549,
-0.5912916064,
0.423496902,
0.0448502973,
-0.313724786,
-0.0224172249,
0.2429621369,
0.2927439511,
0.5521153808,
0.79407686,
-0.132998392,
0.4606621265,
-0.3162745833,
0.5655808449,
0.5244540572,
-0.2572542727,
-0.0642031357,
0.7882769108,
0.082520768,
0.0494287312,
0.5216600895,
-0.5465535522,
-0.550413847,
0.3391207159,
0.6580116153,
0.6726136208,
-0.1176784486,
0.0310397577,
0.506225884,
-0.0220627896,
0.0166864935,
0.3787750006,
-0.5269289017,
-0.7638600469,
-0.7701499462,
-0.9761052728,
-0.2731142044,
-0.3393385708,
-0.8464617133,
0.1902783066,
0.0469557755,
0.1365666389,
-0.4045425355,
0.0484808534,
-0.1772195548,
0.1369119138,
0.1157075837,
1.2425099611,
-0.8445762992,
0.5957454443,
0.3730978668,
-0.2283296585,
-0.8270688653,
-0.3544092774,
-0.0590851381,
-0.4397598207,
0.9075983763,
0.0078610675,
-0.1538370699,
0.109352991,
-0.4304712415,
-0.9824745059,
1.306948781,
0.2976430655,
-0.1724841893,
-0.2530908585,
0.2054260373,
0.3609960079,
-0.2084212005,
0.3742711246,
0.689021349,
0.1862391531,
0.8217060566,
-0.7515692711,
-0.0673947707,
-0.2989921272,
-0.1584844738,
0.4877283871,
-0.2175385654,
0.5442225933,
-0.0048101824,
-0.3488983512,
0.0374402814,
0.9036868215,
0.4717888236,
0.3424739838,
0.2162718177,
0.8558846712,
0.7406767607,
-0.0689144507,
0.7030192018,
-0.4454755485,
0.5315580964,
1.0503904819,
-0.1342987716,
0.7675053477,
0.0665307865,
-0.3826611638,
0.3680094779,
0.4889652431,
0.1590409279,
0.9783987403,
-0.0824366063,
-0.6452080011,
-0.3991473317,
0.1245329231,
-0.511282146,
0.0595282018,
0.7899485826,
-0.1409388036,
-0.6425978541,
-0.0759854838,
0.0912652388,
-0.051370468,
-0.5365483165,
0.6514394879,
-0.2183151245,
-0.6422122121,
0.6780127883,
-0.2068382353,
0.7023128867,
-0.752869606,
-0.2672892511,
-0.1909069866,
0.1040379032,
-0.576687634,
-0.623724699,
0.1647677273,
0.0487153344,
-0.1477470547,
0.1052724272,
1.0063673258,
-0.458193928,
-0.3641155362,
0.1444230974,
0.3788213432,
0.1163345203,
-0.3132674098,
-0.784201026,
-0.2669831812,
0.1240085438,
-0.4243219197,
0.5260578394,
0.7105093598,
0.2214541286,
0.6257153749,
0.6581893563,
-0.2466853112,
0.4900506139,
0.1061668396,
0.8888635039,
-0.6985862851,
-0.6362663507,
-0.5490364432,
0.764944315,
0.051431831,
-0.0219086017,
0.9237453341,
0.776564002,
0.2922633588,
0.203031823,
0.6006167531,
-0.1211493015,
0.6232241988,
-0.6678110361,
0.8834788799,
-0.4643049538,
0.188575536,
-0.1718733758,
-0.7201108336,
-0.3012898266,
0.3480761647,
0.0477153547,
0.0924611017,
0.3975693583,
1.1956189871,
0.1170644462,
0.0979186445,
0.3161976933,
0.0949204639,
0.3948671222,
0.5696479678,
0.9083175659,
-0.5431405306,
0.6436914206,
-0.1054569259,
-0.2380736619,
-0.3171511292,
-0.773337543,
-0.7405681014,
-0.4539433718,
-0.199535042,
-0.7406833172,
0.0760497674,
0.6293135285,
0.697492063,
-0.6494640708,
0.1055161506,
-0.3492503464,
-0.072393097,
-0.1340649277,
-0.3434118629,
0.318513304,
-0.7291211486,
-0.3956776261,
0.769407928,
0.0598537251,
-0.2712669671,
0.0469909646,
-0.0637769401,
-0.0059612039,
-0.0247684866,
0.7183107734,
0.3837448955,
-0.3807513118,
0.0887694582,
-0.0156504232,
0.1590762287,
0.0884338766,
0.4812679887,
-1.255173564,
0.4890469313,
0.326026082,
0.6619640589,
0.8707416058,
0.0631775707,
0.3333674371,
-0.7968135476,
-0.149655655,
0.359473139,
0.0465188771,
0.1663081497,
-0.6522451043,
0.4273359776,
0.1298287809,
-0.5695596933,
-0.9002684951,
0.2667932808,
-0.9074072838,
-0.3591965139,
1.0520830154,
0.2319288254,
-0.3188984096,
-0.3253121674,
0.082084924,
0.0811475217,
-0.3611682355,
0.2445526123,
0.4884589612,
-0.6298443079,
-0.1883634925,
-0.5158733726,
0.6954680085,
0.3457044661,
-0.6057203412,
0.1575799882,
0.600001514,
0.4967571497,
0.0664922222,
0.6759756207,
-0.2849732935,
0.4885086119,
0.4669234157,
0.0102677513,
-0.2143633217,
-0.3055432737,
-0.1507562548,
0.5853652358,
0.1109448373,
0.0790496394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00322v1 | LLM-Generated Natural Language Meets Scaling Laws: New Explorations and Data Augmentation Methods | 2024-06-29T05:40:17 | 2024-06-29T05:40:17 | Zhenhua Wang, Guang Xu, Ming Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the ascent of large language models (LLM), natural language processing
has witnessed enhancements, such as LLM-based data augmentation. Nonetheless,
prior research harbors two primary concerns: firstly, a lack of contemplation
regarding whether the natural language generated by LLM (LLMNL) truly aligns
with human natural language (HNL), a critical foundational question; secondly,
an oversight that augmented data is randomly generated by LLM, implying that
not all data may possess equal training value, that could impede the
performance of classifiers. To address these challenges, we introduce the
scaling laws to intrinsically calculate LLMNL and HNL. Through extensive
experiments, we reveal slight deviations (approximately 0.2 Mandelbrot
exponent) from Mandelbrot's law in LLMNL, underscore a complexity advantage in
HNL, and supplement an interpretive discussion on language style. This
establishes a solid foundation for LLM's expansion. Further, we introduce a
novel data augmentation method for few-shot text classification, termed ZGPTDA,
which leverages fuzzy computing mechanisms driven by the conformity to scaling
laws to make decisions about GPT-4 augmented data. Extensive experiments,
conducted in real-world scenarios, confirms the effectiveness (improving F1 of
Bert and RoBerta by 7-10%) and competitiveness (surpassing recent AugGPT and
GENCO methods by about 2% accuracy on DeBerta) of ZGPTDA. In addition, we
reveal some interesting insights, e.g., Hilberg's law and Taylor's law can
impart more benefits to text classification, etc. | [
-0.3401651978,
-0.8422507644,
0.6899889708,
0.0058080759,
-0.2078597248,
-0.1370877475,
-0.5574917793,
-0.6564424634,
-0.0134308301,
0.5117374659,
-0.4745800197,
-0.2535297871,
-0.6526940465,
0.2000285089,
-0.2547249198,
1.1505820751,
0.1769574732,
-0.1062258482,
-0.0796502009,
-0.0959680453,
-0.0723751783,
-0.7276567817,
-0.303768903,
-0.4307554066,
0.4083719254,
0.3606574833,
0.9622268677,
0.9171070457,
0.7692350149,
0.2828491628,
-0.3221308887,
0.1831196547,
-0.4584157467,
-0.1173943728,
0.2018990517,
-0.4536668062,
-0.3682599664,
-0.0999336988,
0.8551000357,
0.5753462911,
-0.1647328585,
-0.1522842944,
0.1387658268,
0.7838912606,
-0.3947922289,
0.0902262405,
-0.510396719,
0.0052129626,
-0.3610526621,
-0.0186817609,
-0.1291569024,
-0.411298871,
0.1501826793,
-0.4211168289,
0.4182465076,
0.1482443959,
0.8164516687,
0.2579609454,
-0.4360514879,
-0.4969861507,
-0.5480969548,
0.7064831257,
-1.0359733105,
0.2438012958,
0.0188204497,
0.2118541747,
-0.1925794184,
-0.7251709104,
-0.9007598162,
-0.3248798549,
-0.0597610325,
-0.2482037246,
-0.1810032427,
0.2829593718,
0.4096115232,
0.6493645906,
-0.3781752586,
0.4368169904,
-0.3133643568,
-0.1061736196,
0.8552513719,
0.2535665631,
0.4731614292,
-0.3004951775,
-0.2502290905,
-0.0402184278,
-0.6461495161,
-0.2647282481,
0.4818958044,
0.6427882314,
0.0748670846,
0.7271119952,
-0.2825247049,
0.7361622453,
0.1075310782,
-0.1639461368,
0.4091663957,
-0.5788311958,
-0.1415648758,
0.3629969656,
0.9368134737,
0.3554989398,
0.421439141,
-0.0801595226,
-0.199287191,
-0.3376198113,
0.3377921283,
-0.8900510073,
-0.0238812771,
-0.1290582567,
-0.2419357151,
-0.5035442114,
0.0040795337,
-0.5566587448,
-0.6429427266,
-0.4201426506,
0.6553631425,
-0.2081246376,
-0.2770958543,
0.1664681286,
0.0308102909,
0.2594409287,
0.3256444931,
-1.2928526402,
0.2607572675,
0.9753518105,
0.8138844371,
-0.0606029145,
-0.199871704,
-0.2654862702,
-0.2154757082,
-0.4325722158,
0.6386027336,
-0.3480671942,
-0.0822277889,
0.0133693358,
-0.2974610925,
0.2275924236,
-0.5299111009,
0.7256718278,
-0.5425279737,
0.0652334541,
-0.2239080071,
-0.7384550571,
-0.0229471941,
0.2995958626,
-0.6625766158,
1.0912142992,
0.1079263762,
-0.7679861188,
0.6396921277,
-0.6092415452,
-0.4533500075,
0.1510225534,
-0.1720199436,
-0.5568359494,
0.1522593051,
0.0799478069,
0.4745617211,
-0.5003014803,
0.2579822838,
-0.1574724764,
-0.1780271381,
0.0566860251,
-0.6221000552,
0.6236804128,
0.1160281152,
-0.1456662565,
0.0316642113,
-0.7727056742,
0.1162250265,
-0.0289192088,
-0.6238532662,
-0.1699360013,
-0.0260479543,
0.0940180644,
-0.0038196654,
0.3104223311,
-0.6611833572,
0.3150730431,
-0.642351985,
0.5133834481,
0.6947751641,
0.176684007,
0.7484863997,
-0.1335809231,
0.2075740844,
-0.1861140281,
-0.0505030453,
-0.0513335988,
-0.5245044231,
-0.5327470303,
-0.1076159254,
0.2532256246,
0.3488058746,
-0.5030164123,
0.5158942342,
-0.4974975586,
-0.5225613713,
-0.3821524084,
0.418805182,
0.0319084264,
0.4657233953,
0.3172932565,
-0.0316606238,
-0.5554993749,
-0.8650066257,
-0.3640452027,
-0.226548031,
-0.2945030332,
0.2607096732,
0.1575121135,
-0.346396476,
1.0734117031,
-0.5278886557,
-0.2242941856,
-0.4669009745,
0.3089702725,
0.4092778862,
0.4384739697,
0.5946237445,
-0.6568908691,
-0.4933903813,
0.243513003,
-0.6130991578,
-0.3218912184,
-0.2375771701,
0.089658305,
0.1631340384,
0.3092468679,
-0.5172758102,
0.26208359,
0.1605592221,
-0.0951046273,
0.3983668089,
-0.4145869911,
-0.0367111787,
-0.9712984562,
-0.4867420793,
0.26368469,
-0.2253228575,
-1.0563369989,
0.0739268959,
0.2153204083,
0.2474582344,
-0.245138973,
0.2748126388,
-0.2763760388,
0.0384036042,
-0.6026439667,
0.0618785806,
-0.2389919758,
0.2621555626,
0.033319477,
0.8617166877,
0.432489723,
-0.6466107368,
0.555593431,
0.0072952323,
-0.3163735867,
0.4479039013,
-0.4846947193,
0.0472377427,
-0.1847017407,
0.015872186,
-0.7803087234,
-0.2796579301,
-0.0132762939,
-0.4165668786,
0.2760808766,
-0.0799113736,
-0.9949880838,
-0.268176347,
-0.388605237,
0.2682666481,
0.7147762179,
-0.7890735269,
0.5163966417,
0.2260155827,
-0.051558964,
-0.364035815,
-0.7007523775,
0.332745105,
-0.2471708059,
-0.689229846,
0.2162131965,
-0.140772447,
-0.5057431459,
-0.1778063625,
-0.0032723299,
-0.2282783389,
0.0293542892,
-0.0514815189,
0.2661339343,
-0.454253763,
0.2298018783,
-0.0770373568,
0.1416259855,
0.2188834846,
-0.3908788264,
0.5328546762,
-0.2896152437,
-0.0966646895,
-0.3048503101,
-0.1451782435,
0.2594735324,
0.263066709,
0.6095072627,
0.7464333773,
-0.3594565094,
0.0368194729,
-0.5740633011,
-0.0918536484,
-0.5304848552,
0.2043877542,
-0.1294889748,
-0.9348161221,
0.2229977995,
0.1997591555,
0.0608064719,
0.6944127679,
0.7418646812,
-0.0003696847,
0.778220892,
0.8236389756,
-0.219125092,
0.6384545565,
0.1335733533,
0.2228601724,
-0.8002942801,
0.1123319268,
-0.452287823,
-0.3083529472,
-1.0725624561,
-0.3216475844,
0.3425237238,
0.0200826824,
-0.177384913,
0.4639633,
-0.3396383524,
0.7946882844,
0.5138676763,
0.105199419,
0.4260518551,
-0.0065246793,
0.1529344916,
-0.185198158,
-0.6425000429,
-0.3356022537,
1.2968188524,
0.3044439256,
0.8508097529,
0.167856887,
0.9261646867,
0.4423727691,
0.5063229203,
-1.0061055422,
0.3960117698,
-0.0350510739,
-0.5641855597,
-0.4662557542,
-0.788233757,
-0.6464108825,
0.3395525813,
-0.3600977361,
-0.574323833,
0.1024684981,
-0.0115605397,
-0.2967126369,
0.4934125543,
-0.7492540479,
0.3476198614,
-0.3026234806,
-0.5497148633,
-0.1125517562,
-0.6888105273,
0.3010255992,
-0.294313252,
0.1599349529,
-0.0480497032,
-0.1832798421,
0.6649877429,
-0.707711339,
0.7640513182,
-0.0007085007,
-0.5529970527,
0.508436501,
-0.278683275,
0.538438797,
0.0054180417,
-0.0011019014,
0.1712186784,
-0.2591959536,
-0.382486254,
-0.6835297346,
0.6019368172,
-0.5420738459,
-0.6406244636,
-0.4177235365,
-0.6346921325,
-0.0790483952,
0.4121310413,
0.3102195561,
0.2024879754,
0.0379279256,
0.2357387543,
0.7820495367,
-0.0409519002,
0.5310295224,
0.4920780957,
-0.1529703587,
-0.4177704155,
0.9793061614,
0.3043678999,
0.4463367164,
0.4012557268,
0.5122173429,
-0.2684654593,
-0.6973390579,
-0.5385628343,
0.2058264762,
-0.5917214751,
-0.2229308635,
-0.5014011264,
-0.439214915,
-0.3931041956,
-0.1591632068,
-0.082882978,
-0.5281724334,
-0.3349765837,
-0.202514559,
0.6008703113,
0.8310142159,
-0.2676254809,
0.3871585727,
-0.7394610047,
0.1892751455,
0.3327137232,
0.3275516331,
-0.1360092312,
-0.5950068831,
-0.1884594709,
0.0372749753,
-0.0503638908,
-0.5205655098,
0.322712779,
0.2250479013,
0.3117314279,
0.5039687753,
-0.0212510377,
0.5320118666,
-0.7167893648,
0.6373612881,
0.3008443713,
-0.7999910712,
0.2595410943,
-0.3914059103,
0.1774718165,
0.4796012938,
0.0378910154,
-0.6191954613,
-0.2823864818,
-0.6765287519,
-0.6705442071,
0.6187980175,
0.3096926212,
0.6150372028,
0.136411652,
0.6761876345,
-0.0715572909,
0.2342350334,
-0.729590416,
0.0009140354,
0.0384050049,
-0.5286452174,
-0.0139414966,
-0.2828412652,
0.2014452517,
-0.2498744577,
0.2663607001,
-0.1917825192,
0.0748076886,
0.1379616708,
-0.0952608809,
-0.0772434399,
0.3852241933,
0.7509254813,
0.3446435034,
-0.1896980554,
0.1465874016,
0.2167342454,
-0.7819979787,
0.1075955331,
0.028594641,
-0.1444041729,
-0.1658150703,
0.5504717231,
0.6102514863,
0.0346338227,
-0.6838095784,
0.3851709366,
0.0672012568,
-0.3973642886,
0.0220010914,
0.2787158191,
-0.1451068074,
0.2157662958,
0.4968278408,
-0.023246428,
0.1986116022,
-0.4424270391,
0.2717400193,
0.4173910022,
-0.1851833612,
-0.2719138265,
0.5414233804,
0.1116315871,
-0.3206345141,
0.4911641181,
-0.2694686353,
-0.6177573204,
0.6222990751,
0.5161625147,
0.7446061373,
0.049186144,
-0.0330952257,
0.4215699136,
0.6564462185,
-0.2954206765,
0.0503722765,
-0.265637517,
-0.9189324379,
-0.3548434377,
-0.5527051091,
-0.4852538109,
-0.1809978336,
-0.4547663331,
0.2246678621,
-0.6298757195,
-0.0196874496,
0.0181865133,
0.2977778316,
-0.3621414006,
0.0826296657,
0.3049796224,
0.7774701715,
-0.6629545689,
0.7201249003,
0.3642961979,
-0.41711393,
-0.4722164571,
0.3350635767,
0.1825883836,
-0.8606803417,
0.5194193721,
0.1059149951,
-0.0130349174,
0.1954820156,
-0.7060931325,
-0.7209269404,
0.9805224538,
0.1136565134,
-0.6236439943,
0.0250853766,
0.3864646554,
0.918748498,
-0.2249931246,
-0.0828973427,
0.8179373145,
0.5217568874,
0.1459844559,
-0.9529750943,
-0.0696480647,
-0.0348629877,
-0.0775578246,
0.5154001117,
-0.4743974209,
0.8264369369,
-0.5125210285,
-0.2050789148,
-0.1625765711,
0.7642242908,
-0.0908301994,
0.2288452983,
0.3643461466,
0.6813040376,
0.8935979009,
-0.1613873988,
1.0794341564,
0.0184373762,
0.4206180871,
0.9234399796,
-0.4033763707,
0.7786467075,
0.3100384772,
-0.4370136559,
0.3687904179,
0.5875455737,
-0.1561624557,
0.1417732388,
0.214141801,
-0.4945596755,
-0.00667297,
-0.038028799,
-0.181409061,
0.1805967093,
0.292833358,
-0.307248801,
-0.363966018,
-0.0230185725,
0.2402747571,
0.1253638715,
-0.40984869,
1.0963166952,
-0.1140462831,
-0.1152843982,
0.4318492413,
0.1017594859,
0.9977279902,
-0.35827443,
0.1661800593,
-0.1482256055,
0.061391972,
-0.3135119379,
-1.0162843466,
0.2140127122,
0.3634667397,
-0.1715854704,
-0.1576696038,
0.7495083809,
-0.4161499143,
-0.6694944501,
-0.2510086298,
0.248404637,
0.0427307263,
-0.0055206143,
-0.3471733332,
-0.1411338449,
-0.122220099,
-0.0401843861,
0.3940583467,
0.580619812,
0.0417348668,
0.6532902122,
0.6215583086,
0.2311051935,
0.2583512366,
0.105537124,
0.8893755078,
-0.6185020804,
-0.4521435797,
-1.1108243465,
-0.1161759049,
-0.1542668045,
-0.0776419416,
0.742395103,
0.6046270132,
0.5973442197,
0.2910048664,
0.7778050303,
-0.140356496,
0.2327834815,
-0.7406727672,
0.6826685071,
-0.3883836865,
0.3266237974,
-0.1300459206,
-0.8244867921,
-0.5377630591,
0.3733276725,
-0.44693771,
0.0438813567,
0.4567066729,
0.6236664057,
0.036093723,
0.0829898044,
0.1992411613,
0.0542253032,
0.4581850767,
0.3903310299,
0.5943273306,
-0.3272962868,
0.5657283664,
-0.1473733932,
-0.1513037533,
-0.2221949548,
-0.7817754745,
-0.6995550394,
-0.3467057645,
-0.264826268,
-0.1297457814,
-0.3238804638,
1.2104712725,
0.468315661,
-0.4940101504,
-0.1711029708,
-0.4223788381,
0.2352542877,
-0.0404226817,
-0.267463237,
0.130371362,
-0.6579179168,
-0.7183676362,
0.1637220383,
0.2687674761,
0.3693113029,
-0.2847159207,
-0.1737507135,
-0.0903200209,
0.2296764255,
0.6739938855,
0.1928995401,
-0.5818352103,
-0.2254756391,
-0.2729689181,
-0.2557871342,
0.4590889812,
0.9449608922,
-0.6112479568,
0.3962717652,
0.7082179785,
0.8196223974,
0.2256075889,
0.1376836002,
0.4900074899,
-0.8791240454,
-0.1043681502,
0.1713252515,
0.0619665757,
0.298569262,
-0.5504990816,
0.5110799074,
0.163340345,
-0.5242063999,
-0.951657176,
0.173715353,
-0.6797806621,
0.0299493168,
1.1621086597,
0.3298227489,
-0.2488354594,
0.2290500551,
-0.2734332383,
-0.0475637093,
-0.3245827258,
0.6469838023,
0.8503341079,
-0.3951510787,
-0.2942084968,
-0.6384705305,
0.5991706252,
0.1663765013,
-0.9595241547,
0.2527679801,
0.5863423347,
0.2169844061,
0.1927079707,
0.3901905715,
-0.0651411638,
0.0454279743,
-0.1566571593,
-0.0821654573,
0.1071691141,
-0.0162763223,
-0.585938096,
-0.0077239149,
0.185137257,
0.1578452885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00320v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00320v1 | LiteSearch: Efficacious Tree Search for LLM | 2024-06-29T05:14:04 | 2024-06-29T05:14:04 | Ante Wang, Linfeng Song, Ye Tian, Baolin Peng, Dian Yu, Haitao Mi, Jinsong Su, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent research suggests that tree search algorithms (e.g. Monte Carlo Tree
Search) can dramatically boost LLM performance on complex mathematical
reasoning tasks. However, they often require more than 10 times the
computational resources of greedy decoding due to wasteful search strategies,
making them difficult to be deployed in practical applications. This study
introduces a novel guided tree search algorithm with dynamic node selection and
node-level exploration budget (maximum number of children) calculation to
tackle this issue. By considering the search progress towards the final answer
(history) and the guidance from a value network (future) trained without any
step-wise annotations, our algorithm iteratively selects the most promising
tree node before expanding it within the boundaries of the allocated
computational budget. Experiments conducted on the GSM8K and TabMWP datasets
demonstrate that our approach not only offers competitive performance but also
enjoys significantly lower computational costs compared to baseline methods. | [
-0.1887157112,
-0.6918367147,
0.5935990214,
0.0945390165,
-0.4557612836,
0.6319175363,
0.1568795145,
-0.4747287929,
0.0208049063,
0.259907335,
-0.8986737132,
-0.4227674901,
-0.4394864142,
-0.0099300649,
-0.2042234093,
0.3205630481,
-0.0103380801,
-0.1064726263,
0.0663066506,
0.0164832063,
-0.1921770424,
-0.0657242984,
-1.0134006739,
-0.2550527453,
0.7397028804,
0.4509217143,
0.5670202971,
0.7844882011,
0.4695696235,
0.2303434312,
-0.6451441646,
0.4694791734,
-0.6766385436,
0.4561268985,
0.0046767644,
-0.3825614154,
-0.3891581297,
-0.4402983785,
0.5371547937,
0.4693959355,
-0.3094404936,
0.2272886783,
-0.2230892032,
0.8536099792,
-0.5417035818,
0.3775182366,
-1.0071904659,
0.4309933484,
-0.2385734469,
-0.9048789144,
-0.5228095651,
-0.4548694193,
0.1629865319,
-0.6065266132,
-0.0206043664,
0.0741214603,
0.5368285775,
0.2993154526,
-0.4404418468,
-0.4149318635,
-0.5634102225,
0.8106474876,
-0.3650050461,
0.1525178701,
0.1988591254,
0.5398773551,
-0.233957231,
-0.4424425662,
0.105779551,
-0.0672401786,
0.2306942195,
0.146114409,
-0.0639026538,
0.3794646263,
0.4560777247,
0.1329252422,
-0.3765822351,
-0.14340958,
0.1377646029,
-0.1852298379,
0.6159908175,
0.2350076884,
0.1656915992,
-0.0217720754,
0.0945231766,
-0.2600204945,
-0.6519370675,
0.3409804404,
0.2216960788,
0.1908054501,
0.3146624565,
0.4495754838,
-0.3169216216,
0.7523950338,
-0.2258114219,
-0.6152724624,
-0.0441731811,
-0.4442397654,
-0.08707802,
0.4449357986,
0.1507838368,
0.1184687838,
0.405369103,
0.1082714349,
-0.3170278668,
-0.1562344134,
-0.1186805964,
-1.0445492268,
-0.1820317954,
-0.0763259158,
-0.2912597954,
-0.5445272326,
-0.3401848078,
-0.7332069278,
-0.2266588062,
0.1685214043,
-0.0265865941,
-0.2361109257,
-0.2511557639,
0.0332070924,
0.1204412505,
0.0669634342,
0.6546269655,
-0.6579474807,
0.0907019079,
0.3223816454,
0.8553135991,
0.09931124,
0.2314194441,
-0.7767142057,
0.0253318977,
-0.5414536595,
0.5853381157,
-0.6928475499,
-0.5157397389,
-0.3056811392,
-0.2885757387,
-0.1030774042,
-0.4620043635,
0.7812556624,
-0.9068017602,
-0.2082051188,
-0.0996810496,
-0.2123992443,
-0.4650077522,
0.160955444,
-0.8670216203,
0.935033083,
0.2313455194,
-0.7168080807,
0.5107227564,
-0.5696830153,
-0.3233996332,
0.3064428866,
-0.2474987358,
-0.5183095932,
0.1344951242,
0.4897836447,
0.309332639,
-0.2989318371,
0.5649365187,
-0.2074919641,
-0.5046486259,
0.0041029914,
-0.6923559904,
0.9420197606,
0.3135112822,
-0.5045053959,
-0.0019166681,
-0.6575046182,
0.35771209,
0.4803079963,
-0.2416155636,
-0.2691200078,
0.3081492484,
-0.3494005501,
0.0397847965,
0.1178038642,
-0.3123310208,
0.3378400207,
-0.4554677606,
0.4042701423,
0.6734315753,
-0.1343110949,
0.1935483217,
-0.1076621786,
0.6083889008,
-0.3414391875,
0.1141255423,
-0.4557201266,
-0.3864134848,
-0.335000962,
-0.0973530561,
0.3178004026,
0.451993078,
-0.7589406967,
0.1797876954,
-0.1690649688,
-0.1882958412,
-0.3052827418,
-0.2178469151,
0.2372811586,
0.5334424376,
0.2240313888,
0.2391766459,
-0.5655155778,
-0.6773163676,
-0.0319224298,
0.0206607301,
0.3899760544,
0.6822144389,
0.1666798294,
-0.16155231,
0.6207705736,
-0.4848670661,
-0.064771682,
-0.2230664045,
-0.2318258435,
0.518009603,
0.160772875,
0.2796730697,
-0.885823667,
-0.5803850889,
0.1251599342,
-0.4907793999,
-0.2114076018,
-0.2341095507,
0.0885375738,
-0.0802624375,
0.3311210573,
-0.303236872,
0.3467615843,
0.6171175241,
-0.383998543,
0.2128902823,
-0.2152723819,
0.0098824678,
-0.7014864087,
0.0425095074,
-0.3959305882,
-0.4139387012,
-0.0438730605,
0.1991592944,
0.0413997024,
0.1634317487,
-0.2490354329,
0.3276320696,
-0.762191236,
-0.2287585586,
-0.0565518104,
0.2939828634,
-0.2221088856,
0.3479446471,
-0.3685548902,
0.9600747228,
0.4777007997,
-0.377315551,
0.5373232365,
-0.2563304901,
-0.1227899715,
0.1657944918,
-0.1436959207,
-0.1141407937,
0.0917852595,
0.3888870478,
-0.769385457,
0.0512249433,
-0.1171644703,
-0.3224942088,
0.2833584845,
-0.2433271855,
-0.5883358717,
-0.3562416732,
-0.4650759697,
0.8007554412,
0.4637076557,
-0.8107194304,
0.6780734062,
0.3636132181,
0.0060101063,
-0.5232874751,
-0.3443079889,
0.1039763466,
-0.2108254582,
-0.6936483383,
0.5155203342,
-0.0697494894,
0.0357948877,
0.0763964728,
-0.501195848,
0.2222128808,
0.4014357626,
-0.0762481466,
0.0505794026,
-0.0698757619,
-0.1891846359,
0.2605878711,
-0.3603149951,
0.0868931189,
-0.3959757686,
0.6463906169,
-0.2008118182,
-0.496058166,
-0.1706113219,
0.0021613266,
0.4066564739,
-0.2106323242,
0.2112129182,
0.3224531412,
-0.3394345343,
-0.6692541242,
-0.3068256676,
-0.1047187448,
-0.4963391423,
0.5815094709,
-0.5872419477,
-0.9920116663,
0.4663508832,
-0.5801981688,
-0.0459153578,
0.4316308796,
0.2042497694,
0.090838179,
1.5251216888,
0.3099136055,
0.2518822551,
0.4031424224,
-0.4558639824,
0.229624629,
-0.7927199006,
-0.4531708658,
-0.2152350396,
-0.2756810486,
-0.7666394711,
-0.3830757439,
0.5385193825,
0.0943300053,
0.0946049988,
-0.0103266453,
-0.8755885959,
0.6947492957,
0.3506400287,
0.0179901943,
0.5746709108,
0.1897830367,
-0.642465651,
-0.0110994745,
-1.0986223221,
-0.1409945488,
1.0316597223,
0.1522225291,
0.5074622035,
-0.0672282949,
0.7099124193,
-0.0331624374,
0.1740070581,
-0.8508769274,
0.8522040248,
-0.0363642573,
-0.2159152627,
-0.5778549314,
-0.7756443024,
-1.2245264053,
0.3760466874,
-0.0509693138,
-0.7782229185,
-0.2234304398,
0.1738960594,
-0.3865207732,
0.6272309422,
-0.2670966685,
0.2997485995,
-0.6700758338,
-0.5711861849,
-0.4712401927,
-0.4843833447,
0.4552577436,
-0.3137261271,
0.2055021971,
-0.2484561205,
-0.1389481574,
0.6122311354,
-0.2016860843,
0.1595246196,
-0.2695010304,
0.2272451669,
0.2975095212,
0.4660445154,
0.8757849932,
0.3223722875,
-0.0619339794,
-0.3807775378,
0.1575285345,
-0.4410848618,
-0.4742997289,
0.7050912976,
-0.4044118822,
-0.5862718225,
-0.6769657731,
-0.4784569442,
-0.1733701229,
0.348105967,
-0.0407518446,
0.3456206024,
-0.0702520981,
0.429844588,
0.9916957617,
-0.1734221578,
0.5895605683,
0.1903064102,
-0.4817279875,
-0.4329571128,
0.7904677987,
0.2149925232,
0.0499424897,
0.5759478807,
0.6405422091,
-0.399964124,
-0.8852869868,
-0.5362460613,
0.1183227748,
-0.4774174094,
-0.4290368855,
-0.502802074,
-0.3926090896,
0.3695331216,
-0.2934432924,
-0.4305348098,
-0.3071250618,
0.0079328278,
-0.1354783177,
0.3456374407,
0.4816348851,
0.1519454569,
0.2423075736,
-0.5635281205,
0.0947612226,
0.3168523014,
0.3955619037,
0.2466953397,
-0.1006929204,
-0.2168806493,
0.0257463884,
-0.1616401672,
-0.779601872,
0.5290268064,
-0.1124802977,
0.693220377,
0.4002426565,
0.0538383052,
0.7690247893,
-0.1078869849,
0.2495527416,
0.1250694692,
-0.7196259499,
0.4812112451,
-0.3891626894,
0.4363296032,
0.6588460207,
-0.0572376065,
-0.2628354728,
0.1296506673,
-0.8816025853,
-1.0525883436,
0.7875748277,
0.299962461,
-0.3978731036,
0.5642086267,
0.2441806048,
-0.312923342,
0.2269868702,
-0.3780988157,
-0.0533023961,
0.2507955432,
-0.1474936008,
0.1232239977,
-0.3190674782,
-0.0770118088,
-0.492477119,
0.5287694931,
-0.2665801048,
0.1158961654,
0.3056539297,
0.1319860965,
-0.3848974705,
-0.0423234068,
0.465682596,
0.5530981421,
-0.3593877554,
0.4170474112,
0.4953566492,
-0.4612520337,
0.0983530208,
0.2016193271,
-0.4532859623,
0.0154776052,
0.3445791006,
0.6653852463,
0.31328848,
-0.9223722219,
0.353656292,
-0.1191958264,
-0.2915452123,
-0.2529392242,
0.2646874487,
0.3561405241,
0.3618952632,
0.5894848704,
-0.1641302258,
0.2514632642,
-0.3595304191,
0.1926528215,
0.6857126355,
0.1028142869,
-0.0138653815,
0.4170692265,
0.1380394995,
-0.4549729824,
0.5501830578,
-0.5240220428,
-0.7278237939,
0.9338921309,
0.3192929626,
0.8992964029,
-0.2476020604,
0.2079372555,
0.3860636055,
0.2991232872,
-0.2148316652,
0.2811994255,
-0.3077734709,
-0.4519460797,
-0.6346254349,
-0.4099149406,
-0.3718132973,
-0.0543405153,
-0.1651564538,
0.2208905667,
-0.4151545167,
0.0417862684,
-0.5099215508,
0.5331630707,
-0.5501217246,
0.3220827579,
-0.0057173437,
0.8887321353,
-0.1381617337,
0.8801068068,
0.1805706918,
0.2709851265,
-1.1488465071,
-0.2217894047,
-0.0399542712,
-1.1030430794,
0.5331165791,
0.2639916539,
-0.7027242184,
0.3286829889,
-0.442112565,
-1.2398517132,
1.5658439398,
0.3011924028,
-0.8860304952,
-0.2249341905,
-0.1404957324,
0.3156810105,
-0.4841731489,
0.6313371658,
0.4378637075,
0.5241869688,
0.7587108016,
-0.6934022307,
-0.0486080758,
-0.222693339,
0.0168658569,
0.3892855644,
-0.6359461546,
0.6189933419,
-0.314152211,
-0.4658509791,
-0.2728098333,
0.117838189,
0.6505437493,
0.7156937718,
0.6699396968,
0.3142068386,
0.969090879,
-0.0172016341,
0.6968637109,
-0.5758660436,
0.4545583427,
0.7096301317,
-0.0480018854,
0.4494102299,
0.3794648647,
-0.2819472253,
0.0401990451,
1.166713953,
0.1794211268,
0.5879105926,
0.5251077414,
-0.3142366409,
-0.2438523769,
-0.1621155739,
-0.2082194388,
0.0238632448,
0.4211897552,
-0.2934044302,
-0.4030360878,
-0.5220280886,
0.0585200712,
-0.1488135308,
-0.3933913112,
0.5232186913,
0.102961868,
-0.5798661113,
0.6553710103,
-0.099330768,
0.5793883801,
-0.6884293556,
-0.2193549573,
-0.1799369603,
0.0105806738,
-0.3574296236,
-0.5719270706,
0.0852471516,
-0.252691865,
0.470941335,
-0.4900502264,
0.7255502939,
-0.231510669,
-0.5712826252,
0.5487746596,
0.8227191567,
-0.1584849954,
-0.0381788798,
-0.8303548694,
0.0980235264,
0.3656795323,
-0.4581192434,
0.1412754059,
0.7112297416,
-0.1335155964,
1.0145829916,
0.7296475172,
0.396699965,
0.0972718522,
-0.1680796444,
1.0735195875,
-0.8102223873,
-0.5821524858,
-0.9082961082,
0.1825036556,
-0.093041271,
-0.0922387317,
0.4348828197,
0.7557268739,
0.8045016527,
0.499997437,
0.4831111133,
0.3096337914,
0.3354552686,
-0.6586738825,
0.2386981994,
-0.6291398406,
0.6219036579,
-0.2756844759,
-1.0657021999,
-0.4574028254,
0.7911421061,
-0.1496902406,
0.0587589853,
0.8048065305,
0.7484500408,
-0.0923746899,
0.1535390466,
0.4280509055,
-0.0920428634,
0.4916880429,
0.9799217582,
0.8384435177,
0.145669505,
0.6107398272,
-0.2737742066,
-0.3605512381,
-0.5365290642,
-1.0490498543,
-0.5991219878,
-0.2736385763,
-0.008584532,
-0.1540255845,
0.275305748,
0.9472147226,
0.712673068,
-0.3424637318,
-0.2632033527,
-0.5841490626,
0.5343631506,
-0.2057188004,
-0.1983502805,
0.4196487963,
-0.1547953039,
-0.4988101125,
0.5254654288,
0.4091522992,
-0.1305788457,
-0.3697339296,
-0.1032904238,
-0.1125150248,
0.0536460876,
0.5733323097,
-0.0806616768,
-0.4330563247,
0.1542793959,
0.3244639933,
0.0617423616,
0.2489210963,
0.9821687341,
-0.8146788478,
0.7075388432,
0.4799451232,
0.8945916891,
1.0593076944,
-0.1177479774,
0.1819044501,
-0.0809460282,
-0.0224065967,
0.7135141492,
0.1530740708,
0.0863209218,
-0.5393038988,
0.7758769393,
0.4127269089,
-0.4278630316,
-0.8375321031,
0.311802417,
-1.0279880762,
-0.2817400098,
0.9637061954,
0.1998199373,
-0.3462754488,
0.1834861487,
-0.5120831132,
0.1837171465,
-0.77596277,
0.583378315,
0.5095311403,
-0.5186678171,
-0.522176981,
-0.6346235871,
0.5553456545,
0.4017582238,
-0.619653821,
-0.1979601979,
0.3146293759,
-0.1359194517,
-0.1290721744,
0.4586013258,
0.0164308734,
0.0855393931,
0.1100830585,
-0.4859308004,
-0.3292927444,
-0.4477100074,
-0.144864127,
0.515783906,
0.3596872687,
0.1220555454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00263v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00263v1 | From Local Concepts to Universals: Evaluating the Multicultural Understanding of Vision-Language Models | 2024-06-28T23:28:28 | 2024-06-28T23:28:28 | Mehar Bhatia, Sahithya Ravi, Aditya Chinchure, Eunjeong Hwang, Vered Shwartz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Despite recent advancements in vision-language models, their performance
remains suboptimal on images from non-western cultures due to
underrepresentation in training datasets. Various benchmarks have been proposed
to test models' cultural inclusivity, but they have limited coverage of
cultures and do not adequately assess cultural diversity across universal as
well as culture-specific local concepts. To address these limitations, we
introduce the GlobalRG benchmark, comprising two challenging tasks: retrieval
across universals and cultural visual grounding. The former task entails
retrieving culturally diverse images for universal concepts from 50 countries,
while the latter aims at grounding culture-specific concepts within images from
15 countries. Our evaluation across a wide range of models reveals that the
performance varies significantly across cultures -- underscoring the necessity
for enhancing multicultural understanding in vision-language models. | [
-0.6795905828,
-0.1407295614,
0.0829972401,
0.0674752519,
-0.1897555888,
0.1250342876,
-0.3567504883,
-0.7546774149,
-0.1193757877,
0.3309024572,
-0.2945100963,
-0.4866107702,
-0.5426476002,
0.1327214539,
0.0667941719,
0.7384659648,
-0.1452284902,
0.2895279825,
-0.3141114116,
-0.7305431962,
-0.4435883462,
-0.4391358197,
-0.0632136911,
-0.371912688,
0.0695638806,
0.4342652261,
0.636400938,
0.4680891633,
0.9221592546,
0.1786125898,
-0.3753680885,
0.0160668083,
-0.5679097772,
-0.1820815951,
-0.5462144613,
-0.434173435,
-0.0563658252,
0.1156863496,
0.8398259878,
0.8998929262,
0.094810769,
0.3914817274,
-0.0022072368,
0.5096120834,
-0.8474293947,
0.1344471276,
-0.6372007728,
0.4349394739,
0.0080205435,
0.2413829714,
-0.0436130799,
-0.3077579439,
0.4627587795,
-0.5207173824,
0.5349008441,
-0.2730573118,
0.7505286932,
-0.1230858043,
-0.7430678606,
-0.1144697294,
-0.6335244179,
0.7079238296,
0.0989213511,
0.5529329777,
0.0521322265,
0.3725919425,
0.1707181633,
-0.4443095028,
-0.2482432872,
-0.2760187685,
0.0699211732,
0.2587278187,
-0.2782530785,
-0.2326031029,
0.2404212952,
0.699788034,
-0.6916844249,
-0.1192930266,
-0.5902899504,
-0.2097764611,
0.6240491271,
0.1221611127,
0.4148871899,
-0.1629815996,
-0.5065443516,
-0.1378136277,
-0.7876396775,
0.2372716069,
0.0173020642,
0.3055342138,
-0.4856273532,
0.346745342,
-0.662560761,
0.6338546276,
-0.376925528,
-0.1572937071,
0.3221559227,
-0.4092478752,
-0.3087182045,
-0.4344342947,
0.195000872,
0.6003980637,
0.7876644731,
-0.3569915593,
0.0791998133,
0.3928270638,
0.0936597735,
-0.7099721432,
0.0545917042,
-0.4854708016,
-0.5631500483,
-0.0143332006,
0.1857746989,
-0.5871811509,
-0.4591433406,
-0.4052087963,
0.2041253746,
-0.2080453634,
-0.3838731945,
-0.0915494487,
-0.1986084133,
0.5664654374,
0.3694539368,
-0.8010162711,
0.1669076383,
0.4640797973,
0.7404844165,
-0.1634225547,
-0.3810000122,
0.103070274,
-0.0573387891,
-0.4719420075,
0.7589613795,
-0.6578484774,
-0.5531987548,
0.0202183221,
0.0153161241,
0.0164748691,
-0.9041975141,
0.4266188741,
-0.2308269739,
-0.0301460288,
-0.7305961847,
-0.2074827254,
-0.4802256823,
0.3671153486,
-0.3271952271,
0.6927095056,
0.1419785321,
-0.6498767138,
0.749843955,
-0.4134489596,
-0.2164263278,
0.3225611448,
-0.5110576749,
0.3092296422,
0.5045292974,
0.3776292205,
0.2877219915,
-0.4725651741,
0.2925593555,
-0.4346820116,
-0.782936275,
-0.3752168119,
-0.363045007,
0.8775900602,
0.3906189203,
-0.1867645085,
-0.1302133501,
-0.6731388569,
-0.2040989995,
0.2534134984,
0.0284639336,
-0.2923353314,
-0.1770307571,
0.064333424,
0.1554533094,
-0.0000406903,
-0.5361697674,
0.2379495949,
-0.1145647168,
0.0411633849,
0.5573313236,
-0.4581822753,
0.6874296069,
-0.1953668445,
0.5777307749,
-0.0201320071,
0.2230729163,
-0.3653918803,
-0.6767508388,
-0.5495902896,
-0.3856374025,
0.0501569584,
0.7206863761,
-0.6261494756,
-0.0068524978,
-0.5212991834,
-0.6868813634,
-0.4712625742,
0.2251591533,
0.4147283733,
0.4580239952,
0.1166859344,
-1.0397480726,
-0.4429406822,
-1.0978767872,
-0.3938699961,
-0.0586402342,
-0.2935731113,
0.38076967,
0.7799986005,
-0.3572621047,
0.9399484992,
-0.1546943635,
-0.3440383673,
-0.2457670271,
0.1308511049,
0.0898047313,
0.5360355973,
0.4893966317,
-1.0414403677,
-0.5438868403,
0.3320766687,
-1.2297427654,
0.3130271137,
0.2471067458,
0.086657837,
0.1505303979,
0.184461385,
-0.1899225116,
0.7779689431,
0.5338935256,
-0.3529116213,
0.3685722947,
-0.2621227503,
0.4186105728,
-0.5295289755,
0.1480181366,
0.397469312,
-0.0160896704,
-0.5209140182,
0.6983755827,
0.2431104332,
-0.3120997846,
-0.5676950812,
0.8045762777,
-0.5147612691,
-0.3104945719,
0.1900957376,
0.0112590361,
-0.0628498271,
0.068813771,
0.3168895841,
0.7284473181,
0.9087658525,
-0.2913068235,
0.39431113,
0.1898348927,
-0.8253466487,
1.0237956047,
-0.3136475682,
-0.0725765899,
-0.4655041397,
0.4250254333,
-0.8164540529,
-0.3003870249,
0.052386418,
-0.257465452,
-0.0202629063,
-0.4024368525,
-0.3886466026,
-0.3821542263,
-0.0423108488,
0.8294554949,
0.704495728,
-0.7652184963,
0.6271483302,
0.3685221374,
0.0155453347,
-0.6281357408,
-0.6335024834,
0.1109680086,
-0.376624614,
-0.9984348416,
0.2631940246,
0.1104259565,
-0.5710725188,
-0.2645841241,
-0.2980159819,
-0.0303904656,
0.1092682853,
0.0617715232,
0.1433166862,
-0.2728332877,
-0.0933042392,
-0.5472487211,
0.0582997091,
-0.1411416978,
-0.2987000942,
0.1353472322,
-0.5226077437,
-0.3011192083,
-0.1646507531,
0.5302988291,
0.2956641912,
-0.6001964211,
0.4488625228,
0.6866785884,
-0.4115405679,
0.1673720926,
-0.7209352851,
0.0351932421,
-0.4232110679,
0.4887401462,
-0.6163694263,
-0.809173584,
0.9754288793,
0.0317862257,
-0.3594659269,
0.3083413541,
0.5208479166,
-0.1494422853,
0.8371639848,
1.0329031944,
0.0461930186,
0.3583903611,
-0.4154459238,
0.0546721928,
-0.6429316401,
-0.5327191353,
-0.3017080724,
-0.1767560542,
-0.9151833653,
-0.6720703244,
0.4915550947,
0.2714560032,
-0.3061140776,
-0.0420019738,
-0.4301842749,
0.9518458843,
0.6594873667,
-0.2649880946,
0.3542770147,
0.5387500525,
-0.5112223029,
-0.3500691056,
-0.5833188295,
-0.3226036727,
1.0361312628,
0.2773824334,
0.891204536,
0.0768495947,
0.4313198328,
0.1565608382,
0.7744678855,
-0.4638400376,
0.4048040807,
-0.5340201259,
-0.8267019987,
0.348318249,
-0.3971022069,
-0.6342256069,
0.9252300262,
-0.0542480201,
-1.1898808479,
0.4274437428,
0.0211377665,
-0.0169845708,
0.5398036242,
-0.6320135593,
1.1275675297,
0.042553097,
-0.0638900474,
-0.1445556581,
-0.6907671094,
0.6450436711,
0.1360697448,
0.4185756147,
-0.3067570627,
0.3337872028,
0.3146438301,
0.4748196304,
0.6547532082,
-0.1205713376,
-0.2064475864,
0.2595427632,
0.2368033826,
-0.0966423601,
-0.0632153675,
0.0498304702,
0.6321393847,
-0.0876271948,
-0.5727968812,
-0.3366195261,
0.4688895643,
-0.6646283269,
-0.4137389064,
-0.3831950128,
-0.7632158399,
-0.3387659788,
-0.0618136153,
0.4424253106,
0.5133472085,
-0.4431232214,
0.3657690585,
0.4926854074,
-0.419072181,
0.1135808155,
0.4356122911,
-0.2292897552,
-0.4125120044,
0.8962712288,
0.0985409766,
0.276311785,
0.2621061504,
-0.0710917488,
-0.3287089169,
-0.2667633593,
-0.3376441002,
0.0316934027,
-1.2463462353,
0.1240469217,
-0.1979584992,
0.0547989234,
-0.427983135,
-0.385350734,
-0.1613407284,
-0.0818527862,
0.1537272781,
0.1487728506,
-0.1824440211,
0.7127923369,
-0.4950802028,
0.0304378886,
-0.634665966,
0.4546673,
0.2637554109,
0.5232149959,
-0.1564208567,
-0.6741809249,
-0.2713566422,
-0.051925011,
-0.3413418233,
-0.6326963305,
0.193943128,
0.0453580171,
0.7184593678,
0.4308415651,
-0.2869189978,
0.8085587621,
-0.3824979663,
0.7565504909,
0.190505147,
-0.9777258635,
0.5338950753,
-0.4278824031,
0.6668469906,
0.4852159619,
0.457226336,
-0.9379297495,
-0.4804344773,
-0.511477828,
-0.7621661425,
0.483880043,
-0.0021520152,
0.4763003886,
0.1359246373,
0.1531438529,
0.0179069247,
-0.1009110287,
-0.9525324106,
-0.1766119003,
-0.1258232594,
-0.0080168992,
-0.2586990893,
-0.0440053008,
-0.3203582466,
-0.5857120752,
0.1342621297,
-0.3341403604,
0.1553049982,
0.355299592,
-0.4772265851,
-0.0561044067,
0.2241547704,
0.4973857403,
0.9905860424,
-0.3748593628,
-0.0280046463,
0.4357683957,
-0.4114449322,
0.2135435194,
0.0197536126,
-0.3116869628,
-0.1993594617,
0.4390774965,
0.6622787118,
-0.1960069984,
-0.6988260746,
0.2920895815,
-0.3236314952,
-0.0175295845,
-0.0875283554,
-0.0173934773,
-0.2413083166,
0.2776288688,
0.5297842622,
0.3074743748,
0.0899240151,
-0.7373476624,
0.1371194124,
0.6151793003,
-0.3773976266,
-0.2229036242,
0.541028738,
0.2323340029,
0.0877805278,
0.6064894795,
-0.3356779516,
-0.5679472089,
0.8444100618,
0.4683016241,
0.6765047312,
0.1090591028,
0.3658130169,
0.4456520677,
0.5571751595,
0.040959172,
0.4159277976,
-0.2732599378,
-1.0289732218,
-0.2991836667,
-0.4756534398,
-0.5306732059,
-0.1888068169,
-0.8536043167,
-0.1975473911,
-0.3147667944,
0.0683617443,
-0.2419771105,
-0.1025826782,
-1.170722723,
0.6717129946,
0.7738922834,
1.111369133,
-1.0411291122,
0.743930757,
0.8464049697,
-0.4187449813,
-0.4613091052,
0.1099869758,
0.1576149613,
-0.8236441016,
1.0794534683,
0.4894119501,
0.0036809382,
-0.3637792468,
-0.3436773121,
-0.9937616587,
0.8832828999,
0.6000763774,
-0.2850447595,
0.1643852443,
0.106791161,
0.5308582783,
-0.6414299607,
0.3738676906,
0.6877347231,
0.2820132077,
0.1487983167,
-1.0701682568,
-0.2004932612,
-0.2829485238,
0.341465801,
-0.2564018667,
-0.6068968177,
0.8919442892,
-0.4200298488,
-0.2781437039,
0.0999240056,
0.5153566599,
0.3646857738,
0.1412674189,
0.3734122813,
0.6626054645,
0.6070714593,
-0.4147585034,
1.2498581409,
-0.0301254727,
0.5677551627,
0.7719012499,
-0.3050530255,
0.6645212173,
0.1585730016,
-0.2112455517,
0.2224098295,
0.6210747957,
-0.3552189767,
0.6481469274,
0.3500078619,
-0.362460345,
-0.4107556641,
-0.5471063852,
-0.6790154576,
0.861936748,
0.1311600506,
-0.0541931279,
-0.5862566829,
0.114118576,
-0.4272055626,
0.0076467623,
-0.5605198145,
0.5084463954,
0.0051860018,
-0.7429766655,
0.7850894332,
-0.0102131078,
0.9671816826,
-0.4049656987,
0.1637602746,
-0.7680116296,
0.3370792866,
0.0975363776,
-0.6454243064,
0.2105983645,
0.15502505,
-0.1620793939,
-0.2325978279,
0.6835186481,
-0.2131607085,
-0.6505547166,
0.6191042066,
0.3729259968,
0.1754993796,
0.0821863636,
-0.6072502732,
0.0718835965,
0.080220893,
0.2248883843,
0.2081770301,
0.2124919742,
-0.2222239673,
0.5809627175,
0.412899524,
0.1238932982,
-0.0314618163,
0.1200093776,
0.3135471642,
-0.6377540827,
-0.4777087569,
-0.7630810738,
0.5438809395,
0.0165952425,
-0.4550116956,
0.6227366328,
0.3682085574,
1.5926049948,
-0.103612192,
0.7591074109,
-0.013034923,
-0.1002760306,
-0.2310288697,
0.6640293598,
-1.0575232506,
-0.2201525271,
-0.2494885921,
-1.0301902294,
-0.5714221597,
0.8826624155,
-0.3899007738,
-0.039762985,
0.3541779518,
0.5060070157,
-0.2998587787,
0.1262452304,
0.4728924334,
-0.1189363077,
0.162244767,
0.3345753253,
1.1378543377,
-0.1462165564,
0.3099504709,
-0.3326220214,
-0.1474844813,
0.1225061491,
-0.8598901033,
-0.6453306675,
-0.2447467446,
-0.1069605798,
-0.0700126663,
0.0134219211,
0.7960562706,
0.9559383988,
-0.9119375348,
-0.5602881312,
0.2065697461,
0.0562819727,
-0.0441885479,
-0.1453739852,
0.007368763,
-0.2045680881,
-0.6455961466,
0.2511571944,
0.3961048722,
0.2240110487,
-0.3206252754,
0.0322477892,
0.2942050993,
-0.0814341232,
0.5541259646,
0.4014419615,
-0.9246423244,
-0.2170163691,
-0.2673901916,
-0.0090125464,
0.2862792611,
0.7360376716,
-0.7215526104,
0.6786875129,
0.3583595455,
0.4419199228,
0.4307769537,
-0.0454176813,
0.637029767,
-0.7846531272,
0.6840568781,
0.1577348709,
0.626190424,
0.7058600783,
0.2088129073,
0.7671365142,
0.5234121084,
-0.2049191296,
-0.8965542912,
0.3596082032,
-0.5398586988,
-0.2343331128,
0.8559747934,
-0.3961749673,
0.1316909641,
0.2622306347,
0.0844940841,
-0.1085102856,
0.1293131858,
0.6506752968,
0.6546292305,
0.197087273,
0.0712152943,
-0.6709158421,
0.2423543334,
0.6019917727,
-0.6407112479,
-0.1858730465,
0.5402566791,
0.562569797,
0.3139261901,
0.7197872996,
-0.117771849,
0.3842128813,
0.0632027462,
0.2815755606,
0.5890265107,
-0.6330982447,
-0.5898150802,
0.2234128714,
-0.1999988705,
0.0381296575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00256v1 | One Prompt is not Enough: Automated Construction of a Mixture-of-Expert Prompts | 2024-06-28T23:05:08 | 2024-06-28T23:05:08 | Ruochen Wang, Sohyun An, Minhao Cheng, Tianyi Zhou, Sung Ju Hwang, Cho-Jui Hsieh | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML, 68T01 | Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit strong generalization capabilities to
novel tasks when prompted with language instructions and in-context demos.
Since this ability sensitively depends on the quality of prompts, various
methods have been explored to automate the instruction design. While these
methods demonstrated promising results, they also restricted the searched
prompt to one instruction. Such simplification significantly limits their
capacity, as a single demo-free instruction might not be able to cover the
entire complex problem space of the targeted task. To alleviate this issue, we
adopt the Mixture-of-Expert paradigm and divide the problem space into a set of
sub-regions; Each sub-region is governed by a specialized expert, equipped with
both an instruction and a set of demos. A two-phase process is developed to
construct the specialized expert for each region: (1) demo assignment: Inspired
by the theoretical connection between in-context learning and kernel
regression, we group demos into experts based on their semantic similarity; (2)
instruction assignment: A region-based joint search of an instruction per
expert complements the demos assigned to it, yielding a synergistic effect. The
resulting method, codenamed Mixture-of-Prompts (MoP), achieves an average win
rate of 81% against prior arts across several major benchmarks. | [
-0.5910390615,
-0.9744223356,
0.7240334153,
0.3358186483,
-0.1972964704,
0.1878728867,
-0.2000126839,
0.1146309823,
0.3358914554,
0.3363606036,
-0.6872843504,
-0.5249596238,
-0.6048403382,
0.0967027023,
-0.231647104,
0.669218123,
-0.1669880152,
-0.1303491741,
-0.3288054168,
0.0409978852,
-0.8980500698,
-0.3230275214,
-0.3409667015,
-0.1184233278,
0.2308521271,
0.6799124479,
0.3929844499,
0.6274172068,
0.065290235,
0.3794275224,
0.0578354672,
0.4176025391,
-0.1595829874,
0.2785906792,
-0.0805745274,
-0.5180479884,
-0.3316141367,
0.1244697943,
0.3459763825,
0.8068578839,
-0.1306402385,
-0.1499388665,
0.2874599099,
0.4709531069,
-0.6594570279,
0.0765506178,
-0.5280043483,
0.0481919535,
0.1884007305,
-0.4573152661,
-0.4096513987,
-0.1621564478,
0.2692403197,
-0.7499309778,
0.3030970991,
-0.0460198335,
0.4210416079,
0.4662027061,
-0.301325947,
-0.3428120017,
-0.3492082655,
0.9972137213,
-0.5398404598,
-0.0294624958,
0.2435038984,
0.2885508835,
-0.4118020535,
-0.3264182508,
-0.4640122652,
-0.1641163677,
0.1114002392,
0.160828203,
-0.1351434439,
0.1148242354,
0.0127034597,
-0.0834222361,
-0.4813848138,
0.1856389046,
-0.167132318,
-0.2219778746,
0.4259896874,
0.435710907,
0.5471958518,
-0.0574308969,
-0.6231090426,
-0.0332171172,
-0.4418833852,
0.2018903196,
0.2632416189,
0.3346819282,
-0.0912398696,
0.4392275214,
-0.2282901704,
0.8635576367,
0.4013510346,
-0.5851178169,
-0.0425560661,
-0.2610320449,
0.0449456461,
-0.1755891591,
0.8962567449,
0.3201706111,
0.0293997843,
-0.0924266726,
-0.3810498118,
-0.0187575035,
0.1401884705,
-0.4559616446,
-0.2581937015,
0.2766174972,
-0.1510960311,
-0.0066993958,
0.1114235595,
-0.8296040893,
-0.3012138605,
-0.5539613962,
0.5280373693,
-0.4271965027,
0.0921488702,
-0.0084389467,
-0.3519634902,
-0.0767546296,
0.5370396376,
-0.7320512533,
0.15394862,
0.6216467619,
0.5450280905,
-0.3500376344,
-0.4207058549,
-0.4608263969,
0.0934243277,
-0.4936936796,
0.8837910295,
-0.9298146963,
-0.6719774604,
-0.0119695375,
-0.3513645828,
-0.1595937163,
-0.6186774373,
0.0998285264,
-0.3255881965,
0.624391675,
-0.3551403582,
-0.6329907775,
-0.0948579386,
0.0388351902,
-0.3636932969,
0.9707349539,
0.331663698,
-0.4865961373,
0.2460243404,
-0.4306100905,
-0.4163782895,
0.2286213636,
-0.7390332222,
0.2458144873,
0.0153316753,
0.5190555453,
0.4603631198,
-0.2431320995,
0.3798131049,
0.0062037082,
-0.3104328811,
0.1131976992,
-0.2442863882,
0.6808552146,
0.0363193043,
-0.5087346435,
0.047892984,
-0.5680887103,
-0.0903794244,
-0.1761602163,
-0.4418551922,
-0.327511251,
-0.1192711443,
-0.3763405681,
0.2352330536,
0.4699352682,
-0.2368812412,
0.4049486518,
-0.2102380097,
0.0834823996,
0.9204906821,
0.0321719572,
0.8853966594,
-0.4267010093,
0.9903588295,
0.0267901067,
-0.0683490187,
-0.5308246017,
-0.5480058789,
-1.003185153,
-0.4316349924,
0.0568109229,
0.8239412904,
-1.0360838175,
0.7721390128,
0.0911489129,
-0.3345960677,
-0.5581151843,
0.3414776027,
0.4621655941,
0.6437786222,
0.4240155816,
-0.1559160799,
-0.4333750308,
-1.0948313475,
0.0765685067,
0.045050174,
-0.1311402023,
0.2743541002,
0.2617179751,
-0.084455654,
1.3634176254,
-0.5188102722,
-0.3185681403,
-0.4022582769,
0.2228869796,
0.2354226559,
0.496114105,
0.6623111367,
-0.4608333111,
-0.666801095,
-0.234498322,
-0.7499932647,
-0.4486177564,
-0.1402698457,
-0.0091482475,
0.0858030692,
0.3615248799,
-0.4631228745,
0.0844319463,
0.391630739,
-0.1351071,
0.6145910621,
-0.1948789656,
0.2421501875,
-1.0739958286,
-0.2514308989,
0.1822482497,
0.1685482711,
-0.5362237692,
0.4268805385,
-0.1217373759,
-0.2159143537,
-0.4164790809,
0.7006816864,
-0.3906987906,
0.2934670448,
-0.5512649417,
0.1467366517,
0.0250422228,
0.6949336529,
-0.1408180296,
1.103826642,
0.671264112,
-0.817587316,
0.3565921187,
0.1361507177,
-0.1977163553,
0.5735200047,
-0.5878131986,
0.2550311685,
-0.2077707201,
0.475312233,
-1.1210756302,
-0.3965973556,
0.1532460004,
-0.3315143883,
0.2453780621,
0.0227328856,
-0.431489557,
-0.0901946053,
-0.1509481072,
0.3374701738,
0.7383190393,
-0.3537463844,
0.8710791469,
0.2964138985,
-0.5565961599,
-0.6850803494,
-0.5496756434,
0.0749588311,
-0.0799795017,
-0.7278907895,
0.2292135656,
-0.0575181544,
-0.2727362514,
-0.1436804533,
-0.2063037306,
-0.2029461265,
0.114766106,
0.1720662415,
0.2816576362,
-0.0439628139,
-0.0207521506,
0.4305415154,
-0.4310114682,
0.1333187222,
-0.3225524724,
0.532255888,
0.2294693738,
-0.5410677791,
-0.6567162275,
0.9682219028,
0.4312693179,
-0.0583168715,
0.3283890784,
0.3272611201,
-0.1007073671,
-0.5942335129,
-0.7135623693,
-0.1826555431,
-0.5530517101,
0.3128482997,
-0.3751942515,
-0.8566783667,
0.4591637254,
0.1463584155,
0.266959101,
0.2729435563,
0.4749722183,
-0.1656387895,
1.1079875231,
0.5502343178,
-0.0816338807,
0.4120531678,
-0.2300447673,
0.1110109687,
-0.3526359797,
-0.3535503149,
-0.5765471458,
-0.3727871478,
-0.1945643127,
-0.5678126216,
0.7530784011,
-0.1314610243,
0.0170699973,
0.2456613034,
-0.5600417852,
0.5066494942,
0.9514918327,
0.3025977314,
-0.0708491802,
0.0520830452,
-0.3103844225,
-0.0191522539,
-1.0343477726,
-0.5505179167,
0.728736639,
0.1544249058,
0.7594025135,
-0.1960229576,
0.9417051077,
0.3138652146,
-0.1151072755,
-0.7454169989,
0.9233179092,
-0.1564161628,
-0.3227792978,
-0.2824638486,
-0.2433590293,
-0.8244003654,
0.2364424616,
-0.0592169762,
-0.500209868,
0.220731914,
0.1193976179,
-0.6319547892,
0.0553590208,
-0.7382268906,
0.4408437014,
-0.0029631392,
-0.1119942218,
-0.2324173748,
-0.5406987667,
0.1773034632,
-0.1235095784,
0.3626486659,
0.0467142724,
-0.4096448123,
0.7691908479,
-0.6115567684,
1.0341587067,
-0.2518491447,
-0.2042114586,
0.5035275221,
0.2795125842,
0.5730936527,
-0.3427129686,
0.0795377716,
-0.4783727229,
-0.3230431378,
-0.6992784739,
-0.8963326812,
0.4278744757,
-0.7773677111,
-0.9952390194,
0.0267863553,
-0.6117687821,
-0.2997317314,
-0.0815221667,
0.5120583773,
0.6632082462,
0.1076046079,
-0.1480348557,
0.9030503631,
-0.3477266133,
0.3486247361,
0.3240544498,
0.1971077025,
-0.4470967054,
1.1023756266,
0.0183517076,
0.2135988474,
0.5158293843,
0.2409912646,
-0.0247792769,
-0.5317233801,
-0.3894152939,
-0.1836543828,
-0.897729516,
-0.0607549846,
-0.8508560061,
0.2105966955,
-0.3365330696,
-0.5398975015,
-0.1053226218,
-0.2238257974,
-0.6333897114,
0.2349971235,
-0.0134970965,
0.5274475217,
0.2576418519,
0.5210615993,
-0.9719355106,
0.2525443733,
0.7938185334,
-0.1866594255,
0.0913063288,
-0.6728205681,
-0.096407041,
-0.0440932475,
-0.2394566536,
-1.057180047,
0.3771730065,
-0.0172862932,
0.9144976735,
0.4323612452,
0.1537058204,
0.5682164431,
-0.4517334402,
1.0444304943,
0.3332856894,
-0.8719072342,
0.6249549985,
-0.4867949784,
0.3025429845,
0.5753428936,
0.3647235632,
-0.1404101253,
-0.7768970132,
-0.5773416758,
-0.9605208635,
0.5746866465,
-0.2645721436,
0.3495336473,
-0.1225472689,
-0.0767121911,
0.5661965609,
0.1150356382,
-0.1734944731,
-0.3561684489,
0.0523641407,
-0.2835844755,
0.2873517275,
-0.3568773866,
-0.3232914209,
-0.1071259901,
0.5406234264,
-0.1898230165,
0.2842508852,
0.0881293342,
-0.0473007746,
-0.0012792336,
0.5111441016,
0.5192379355,
0.7668957114,
0.1604589075,
-0.0021873373,
0.2084125131,
-0.1483204663,
0.4342295527,
-0.0015336414,
-0.2808952332,
0.0590069033,
0.6292495728,
0.7383698225,
0.2580299377,
-0.7058713436,
0.5779807568,
0.2707577944,
-0.3445834517,
-0.0506668016,
0.6594335437,
-0.2252108604,
0.2156928331,
0.8297647238,
-0.0389302634,
0.0676408485,
-0.4380377829,
0.211691305,
0.2952032983,
-0.1399673522,
-0.1335791945,
0.4426895678,
0.6409119964,
-0.4649398625,
0.4859389365,
-0.3493390977,
-0.6204342246,
0.8422640562,
0.3247716725,
0.8898791075,
-0.1309789568,
0.3191684186,
0.1797801703,
0.0460545868,
-0.1355681568,
0.2795554101,
-0.0165774729,
-0.5276057124,
-0.656272471,
-0.1795725524,
-0.5738657117,
-0.0859809071,
-0.4393578768,
0.1693520844,
-0.4000526965,
0.0189640187,
-0.2173735499,
-0.1812143177,
-0.6764119267,
0.1331670135,
-0.0408620276,
0.9739024639,
-1.0956815481,
0.4258010685,
0.9813367128,
-0.2139819562,
-0.8225470185,
-0.0422416292,
0.0391660072,
-0.6919751167,
0.5542718172,
0.1035068408,
0.2433418632,
-0.2235540897,
-0.7027882934,
-0.5044645667,
0.8338241577,
0.3291060627,
-0.5755267739,
-0.2328918427,
-0.2389705479,
0.2943647504,
-0.635358274,
0.2890050709,
0.3890800774,
0.4600824714,
-0.0558832586,
-0.8939185143,
-0.0012877765,
-0.1805436611,
-0.1483255178,
0.0546090528,
-0.5209881663,
1.0085521936,
-0.2628669739,
-0.1793079078,
-0.0220839716,
0.8212321997,
0.5461951494,
0.293489635,
0.7239693999,
0.3502562642,
0.5632218122,
0.1375628114,
1.0411233902,
-0.284411937,
-0.0604658164,
1.0589749813,
0.1127608195,
0.4719385505,
0.4142479002,
-0.3475685418,
0.5745283961,
0.594127357,
0.1416232437,
0.5601430535,
-0.0991036668,
-0.4638270438,
-0.6635136604,
-0.1656680405,
-0.4106072783,
0.2371448725,
0.3657822907,
-0.3007110059,
-0.4393877387,
0.0900160149,
-0.1380958557,
0.3812700212,
-0.0844719633,
0.7036400437,
-0.0277042966,
-0.9555520415,
0.2486906946,
-0.0818467289,
0.8804237843,
-0.5122924447,
-0.1740683466,
-0.3431376815,
-0.3985649049,
-0.1154603958,
-0.7853248119,
-0.3285076916,
-0.0395637527,
-0.2446355224,
-0.2730803788,
0.3615362942,
-0.5318108201,
-0.2950725853,
-0.0494997278,
0.8750481009,
0.0616949983,
0.0909358263,
-0.5857502222,
-0.2128533572,
0.123679094,
-0.2340136021,
0.4818316996,
0.6019897461,
0.1032059118,
0.8185707927,
0.3753456771,
-0.145746544,
0.0982799307,
-0.0601881184,
1.0122551918,
-0.3719124496,
-0.6819980145,
-0.6990431547,
0.6273889542,
0.217402488,
-0.3089918196,
0.6162793636,
0.3401211798,
0.6398034096,
-0.1388346255,
1.1987036467,
-0.0811233819,
0.2692059875,
-0.5566815734,
0.0059087705,
-0.5598304272,
0.3557104766,
-0.1784438789,
-0.7954593897,
0.1382034868,
0.4045903981,
-0.0501147211,
0.2274534255,
0.6380895972,
0.9221144319,
-0.0445918888,
-0.1597505361,
0.2244002968,
-0.2248557359,
0.2685009539,
0.5554853678,
0.8313465714,
0.202232793,
0.4269322753,
-0.3266900778,
-0.5616159439,
-0.3008458614,
-0.7681471109,
-0.990956068,
-0.6555742025,
-0.3474625945,
-0.1522973478,
-0.0379585437,
1.4426332712,
0.6355223656,
-0.7035415173,
-0.1296147406,
0.0136531265,
0.1018574983,
-0.3360455036,
-0.2474231422,
0.321726054,
-0.8506708145,
-0.8593989015,
0.8432975411,
0.2523827255,
0.0846734866,
-0.5012143254,
0.0053810403,
0.208097145,
0.0310199577,
0.4168524444,
0.0969799235,
-0.8975171447,
-0.0138254771,
0.2796850204,
-0.3354791403,
-0.1306151003,
0.9427357316,
-0.8125362396,
0.6396133304,
0.9176920652,
0.8458233476,
-0.1998576224,
0.1241442338,
0.8388018608,
-0.8685488105,
0.1274911761,
0.3249868453,
0.3411441147,
0.0960804075,
-0.2144730538,
0.2613989115,
0.252848506,
-0.4132807553,
-0.4555287063,
0.2726230025,
-1.1524313688,
-0.5666073561,
1.4409816265,
-0.1539474577,
-0.0672620982,
-0.2478042841,
-0.4914485514,
0.0441539697,
-0.8405680656,
0.7745091319,
0.7154222131,
-0.291264534,
-0.0803408995,
-0.4519142509,
0.0372978486,
0.5708730221,
-0.5753754973,
-0.236551702,
0.6234576106,
0.2096798867,
0.1696771383,
0.6448891163,
0.4242247343,
0.3905547559,
0.1919417232,
0.0376563258,
-0.3592628539,
-0.4992223978,
-0.2636176944,
0.529099226,
-0.0417025462,
-0.3382586241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00250v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00250v1 | Mind the Gap: Analyzing Lacunae with Transformer-Based Transcription | 2024-06-28T22:52:39 | 2024-06-28T22:52:39 | Jaydeep Borkar, David A. Smith | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Historical documents frequently suffer from damage and inconsistencies,
including missing or illegible text resulting from issues such as holes, ink
problems, and storage damage. These missing portions or gaps are referred to as
lacunae. In this study, we employ transformer-based optical character
recognition (OCR) models trained on synthetic data containing lacunae in a
supervised manner. We demonstrate their effectiveness in detecting and
restoring lacunae, achieving a success rate of 65%, compared to a base model
lacking knowledge of lacunae, which achieves only 5% restoration. Additionally,
we investigate the mechanistic properties of the model, such as the log
probability of transcription, which can identify lacunae and other errors
(e.g., mistranscriptions due to complex writing or ink issues) in line images
without directly inspecting the image. This capability could be valuable for
scholars seeking to distinguish images containing lacunae or errors from clean
ones. Although we explore the potential of attention mechanisms in flagging
lacunae and transcription errors, our findings suggest it is not a significant
factor. Our work highlights a promising direction in utilizing
transformer-based OCR models for restoring or analyzing damaged historical
documents. | [
-0.245868668,
-0.6995880008,
0.6327978969,
-0.4467039406,
0.0367836319,
0.0240719412,
0.3425245583,
-0.6616017222,
0.3635809422,
0.912319243,
-0.7961966395,
-0.1414268017,
-0.5485801101,
0.211658746,
-0.3510347605,
0.743142128,
-0.1763804853,
-0.0680154189,
0.1776358634,
-0.0743457451,
-0.7009603977,
-0.2079813927,
-0.5275998116,
-0.0268812831,
0.3982592821,
-0.0334757231,
0.5347335935,
0.6188991666,
0.7000443339,
0.2291768044,
-0.1259538084,
0.349955529,
-0.5429057479,
0.0710866228,
0.1324583292,
-0.7329253554,
-0.3897299767,
-0.2132541388,
0.4510781169,
0.4669097662,
0.2200030833,
0.0184284505,
-0.0366445258,
0.862416923,
-0.5710432529,
0.1368159801,
-0.6730751395,
0.5447753072,
-0.1951714605,
-0.1465919763,
-0.5797862411,
-0.3910498917,
0.0793398172,
-0.5574670434,
0.9769361615,
0.0729060844,
1.0560529232,
0.5303500891,
0.1589362919,
-0.3439005613,
-0.776527226,
0.5205162168,
-0.7503367662,
0.6721285582,
0.3944575787,
0.1157179251,
-0.1615499705,
-0.3785535395,
-0.7492814064,
-0.1736608297,
-0.3588736355,
0.2948099077,
-0.1958582252,
-0.4274902344,
0.4901815057,
0.726287961,
-0.5759174228,
0.2300081402,
-0.519628942,
-0.4576510787,
0.1205755249,
0.0372790694,
0.6009463072,
-0.0338590071,
-0.4117475748,
-0.368106693,
-0.5986487269,
0.0002177324,
0.2995158434,
0.1189267039,
0.3845934868,
0.5693264604,
0.4136327207,
0.7846044898,
0.0825315714,
0.0110458015,
0.0178175438,
-0.0427451991,
-0.4344580472,
0.2013508081,
0.6553485394,
0.1725260168,
-0.1623340845,
-0.4438191652,
-0.0398542956,
0.0668933019,
0.5506083369,
-0.3639687002,
-0.0094271284,
-0.0737645254,
-0.3733371496,
0.1154154018,
0.3023996353,
-0.9680147767,
-0.8369473815,
-0.2682099044,
0.3211925626,
-0.6109172106,
-0.0714534149,
0.1669277549,
-0.2680508494,
0.2234184295,
0.5672672391,
-1.0029709339,
0.1086074337,
0.2997148037,
1.0622109175,
-0.2164725512,
-0.0538039058,
-0.1365617365,
0.0326455645,
-0.4399093688,
0.8451282382,
0.0991912857,
-0.5779385567,
-0.0501291975,
0.1928759664,
-0.3630818129,
-0.5895601511,
0.874785006,
-0.6634002924,
0.2655155659,
-0.2412260175,
-0.599313736,
-0.261376977,
0.1428529173,
-1.6820214987,
0.9552710652,
0.2958679199,
-0.6115011573,
0.0506318845,
-0.5439465642,
-0.0942403972,
-0.0431581363,
0.0098621743,
-0.9225580096,
0.0702662915,
0.3984031081,
0.1776732206,
-0.2521065176,
-0.1088453382,
0.0018782716,
-0.3768266141,
0.3221033812,
-0.4139026105,
0.9838505387,
-0.1076858863,
-0.4960279465,
-0.3761759102,
-0.6644905806,
-0.3785642385,
-0.0249980744,
-0.1288435012,
-0.3307857811,
-0.1517914683,
0.1729209274,
-0.1766016185,
0.1156077906,
-0.8433092833,
0.3955497146,
-0.3808858395,
0.3188461065,
0.4658007622,
0.0824366212,
0.3309982419,
-0.3997294605,
0.2441062182,
0.0353839733,
0.2855815887,
-0.4568696022,
-0.5022109151,
-1.0887035131,
-0.120677799,
0.2879548669,
0.7041991353,
-0.6667957902,
0.6014868617,
-0.2649911344,
-0.5412650108,
-0.9721950293,
-0.1033691689,
0.118355833,
0.9685114622,
0.7212401032,
-0.4573461711,
-0.5940235853,
-0.9498227239,
0.0152473301,
-0.3702745736,
-0.1262431741,
0.1853817254,
0.2920110226,
-0.3563627303,
1.0415476561,
-0.5962955356,
-0.8534827828,
0.259547025,
0.2125565708,
0.3465825021,
0.5210956931,
0.2719858289,
-0.9351396561,
-0.2646463215,
0.1645766646,
-0.8771905303,
-0.2040746659,
-0.3580961525,
-0.0547439568,
0.4421601892,
0.6429904699,
-0.4172771275,
0.7446120977,
0.2216526568,
-0.1203653961,
0.3524682522,
-0.1781273037,
0.5404582024,
-0.6677445173,
0.1617528051,
-0.0913166329,
0.0699964613,
-0.9001238346,
0.0258897375,
0.3945294619,
-0.2112572342,
-0.3253432512,
0.2339282781,
-0.5497331023,
0.1482664794,
-0.0524010211,
-0.3667811155,
0.2725441456,
0.4767490625,
0.3084327281,
0.6937749982,
0.0468025282,
-0.0312553085,
-0.225892067,
0.4130291939,
-0.4386755526,
0.4505165517,
-0.5239370465,
0.499838531,
-0.2028911859,
-0.0670724586,
-0.9437856674,
0.0332213528,
0.264705658,
-0.3673572838,
0.6436583996,
0.0029089921,
-0.4559831917,
-0.4032602012,
-0.2258948237,
0.4044379294,
0.4447515011,
-0.4229061604,
0.9933136106,
0.3252848983,
-0.1067689359,
-0.5628684163,
-0.7521640658,
0.0904181749,
-0.0642228797,
-0.3909479976,
0.1289511025,
-0.0485448316,
0.1590028256,
-0.0934810713,
-0.0829512253,
-0.2753304541,
-0.0363425761,
0.3588195145,
0.7125573754,
-0.3974248469,
0.0299143605,
-0.1556701064,
0.1131191179,
-0.2613379359,
-0.1218614206,
0.4389110506,
-0.0711867809,
-0.5272173882,
-0.4161264896,
0.3564037681,
0.9238254428,
-0.3070982993,
0.4565469325,
0.3003154695,
-0.5766617656,
0.0897542611,
-1.1912626028,
-0.0111610703,
-0.3793970346,
0.247903809,
0.0673120394,
-0.8388136029,
0.7704219222,
0.2507689297,
-0.1507441252,
0.79068923,
0.4150934815,
-0.2816913724,
0.2267932892,
0.5334278941,
-0.2373610139,
0.4411554337,
-0.3929580152,
0.1616518945,
-0.9545066953,
-0.5101544857,
-0.5006180406,
-0.1233210415,
-0.106690906,
-0.4076357186,
0.5437880754,
-0.018775912,
0.051623594,
0.7206882834,
-0.6195906997,
0.6615197062,
0.6253136396,
0.6110128164,
0.3682679534,
-0.1205154955,
0.3108583689,
-0.2517657578,
-0.5151521564,
-0.5846320987,
0.5938650966,
0.3128173649,
0.5146842599,
-0.0767403096,
0.6115271449,
0.7144160271,
0.427526176,
-0.8518841267,
0.1898998022,
-0.0301640797,
-0.5768486857,
-0.6101173759,
-0.1604681015,
-1.1357879639,
0.1043855101,
-0.4728439748,
-0.844614327,
0.6707471013,
0.1846530735,
-0.5164154172,
0.6591166854,
-0.563650012,
0.8650684357,
-0.0463057831,
-0.2578716576,
0.3898448348,
-0.7641738057,
0.1923852712,
-0.5939232111,
0.2342829853,
0.1885424852,
0.2555875778,
0.6509981751,
-0.3392701745,
0.952211678,
0.079534404,
-0.2958858013,
0.2185502946,
0.2826707065,
0.2639258802,
-0.5328802466,
-0.0305533893,
0.3874281049,
-0.2073945999,
-0.0745197013,
-0.6965896487,
0.2303085923,
-0.727832973,
-0.622828722,
-0.2809147537,
-0.7596667409,
-0.1280584931,
0.5120092034,
0.387760818,
0.1553702652,
-0.5342118144,
0.0057467716,
1.1553496122,
-0.0899599791,
0.4915319085,
0.6536106467,
0.2011369467,
-0.2766093016,
0.7608745694,
0.312936306,
0.0250857789,
0.6885472536,
0.0421735086,
-0.1344593614,
-0.4456083179,
-0.6361929774,
0.2773090005,
-0.5863800645,
-0.2884520888,
-0.4718214273,
-0.2059768736,
-0.2618289292,
-0.1059399322,
-0.1511598825,
-0.271145761,
-0.6617597342,
-0.0304535516,
0.0347311683,
0.5848885179,
0.4030320346,
0.4021036029,
-1.1435337067,
0.2256460488,
0.1988879889,
0.0937729478,
0.25448066,
-0.3616584539,
-0.2999856472,
-0.1168697327,
-0.4403358698,
-1.010792017,
0.5101867318,
0.0359843299,
0.4244839549,
0.2758199573,
-0.1008349136,
0.5241673589,
-1.0211551189,
0.6802088618,
0.3642592728,
-0.9812668562,
0.5984617472,
-0.2096112967,
0.1963998824,
0.4803167284,
0.3219316006,
-0.531744957,
-0.6395474672,
-0.7322563529,
-0.7246651649,
0.6505852938,
0.2716664076,
-0.3040911853,
0.162514627,
0.3370965421,
0.3799781501,
-0.0788104162,
-0.7259694338,
0.2883828282,
-0.3556689322,
-0.1666640341,
0.1449988782,
0.1502514631,
0.0143391714,
0.243326664,
0.5499326587,
0.129480809,
0.2302932441,
0.6098926067,
-0.5522707105,
-0.2707011402,
0.1386792213,
0.5258789659,
0.1848198473,
-0.4280682802,
-0.0725468993,
-0.0454925671,
-0.7312291861,
0.150614202,
0.1001909748,
-0.5945070982,
0.1368285567,
0.7166370153,
0.9250648618,
0.0425386131,
-0.6275308132,
0.3899924159,
-0.0307397731,
0.0676232725,
-0.2370952666,
0.0343746059,
-0.1362421662,
0.2905982435,
0.6282294393,
0.5046297312,
0.3179610074,
-0.5958538651,
0.1116287336,
0.2635045052,
-0.6675385237,
-0.0101876585,
0.7346550822,
-0.2587777674,
-0.6421333551,
0.7473804951,
0.6204984188,
-0.4124700725,
0.8298513293,
0.3632708192,
0.6795141697,
-0.529052794,
-0.1178493947,
0.2491111606,
0.6651477218,
-0.3002684712,
-0.1926055104,
0.1483077705,
-0.7610667348,
0.0083774887,
-0.5448466539,
-0.4169350564,
0.2246595621,
-0.9510007501,
0.0228333306,
-0.0351645611,
-0.4375337362,
0.1812148541,
-0.5656998754,
-0.6093493104,
0.2679466605,
0.1190795973,
0.7561838627,
-1.0861310959,
0.5218518376,
-0.0131243886,
-0.6672714353,
-0.4434357285,
-0.0265045706,
-0.1313079745,
-0.9087127447,
0.5344343781,
0.2598049045,
-0.1758779734,
-0.0975703746,
-0.155662626,
-0.7243784666,
1.2492414713,
0.3509705365,
-0.8292976618,
-0.1400630176,
0.2667866349,
0.744492352,
0.1829891205,
0.1619596928,
0.5680383444,
0.4177963734,
-0.0567662157,
-0.8399107456,
-0.0383228995,
-0.2182991952,
0.0800655782,
0.5715664029,
-0.5251507163,
0.7447977662,
0.0235946756,
-0.3811435997,
0.3039973676,
0.4844485819,
-0.1432159543,
0.1804517508,
0.6039507985,
0.7743788958,
1.0270729065,
-0.2077954113,
1.1075692177,
0.2289235741,
0.3593294621,
0.8214604259,
-0.3563492596,
0.8247851133,
0.5246148109,
-0.1643195748,
0.5984897614,
0.396250844,
-0.5500278473,
0.447288543,
-0.0969802141,
-0.1500077397,
0.1593075395,
-0.0869541913,
-0.2352187037,
0.0374565721,
0.4225814939,
-0.6484731436,
-0.0138778836,
0.0765782669,
-0.2290894985,
0.0218469854,
-0.6020001769,
0.8444529772,
-0.1628399044,
-0.7819446921,
0.5112640262,
-0.5005177259,
0.280336678,
-0.6870581508,
-0.2076643109,
-0.3015184402,
0.2498433441,
-0.226948306,
-0.6095223427,
0.37417835,
-0.2860603034,
-0.6093754172,
-0.0209472366,
0.8076348305,
-0.5263727307,
-0.6659466028,
0.1323572248,
0.5262505412,
-0.0360406153,
0.254555881,
-0.2425981909,
0.145746097,
0.11195077,
0.0019444345,
0.1424707621,
0.3039733469,
-0.1186451912,
0.0858383998,
0.4664137661,
0.037538629,
0.0108503392,
0.1303080022,
0.5775539279,
-0.3912749887,
-0.2381889224,
-0.9812624454,
0.4173107147,
-0.1135853827,
-0.0428903438,
0.7879148126,
0.7281153798,
0.6791273952,
-0.7810394168,
0.6573472023,
0.4157044291,
0.4812781811,
-0.7902938128,
0.9998171329,
-0.390085876,
0.0526821539,
-0.4600665867,
-0.6203454733,
-0.5500476956,
0.7062733173,
0.0020422244,
-0.5787821412,
0.7959942222,
1.0188961029,
-0.1980366558,
0.2615380883,
0.2327334881,
0.0828483328,
0.1223544702,
0.6189607382,
0.6323739886,
-0.6285975575,
0.3143177032,
0.2682614625,
-0.4763152301,
-0.0549469553,
-0.7774968147,
-0.8293524384,
-0.7227273583,
-0.1754596531,
-0.3229221106,
0.0134675857,
0.3983949721,
0.3298513293,
-0.8534296155,
-0.1858416498,
-0.0112548545,
-0.2008150369,
-0.2479210347,
-0.2085485756,
0.8981080651,
-0.0005578378,
-0.6792773008,
0.2796164751,
0.4012749791,
0.5247684717,
-0.1320884824,
0.3881836236,
-0.037584912,
-0.0436140858,
0.2475069314,
0.6990352869,
-0.8420615792,
-0.0533652343,
0.3271062076,
0.0414919183,
0.4344790578,
1.2252570391,
-0.6372126341,
0.7180871964,
0.3769350946,
0.9902812243,
0.7045030594,
-0.2901389897,
0.3718460798,
-0.4920764565,
0.0044761365,
0.4643290043,
0.8014977574,
0.5401980281,
-0.7280510068,
0.6989456415,
0.4026687145,
-0.5224212408,
-0.7414697409,
0.0514038615,
-1.2308858633,
-0.3273213804,
0.5904529691,
-0.3121637404,
-0.4844702184,
-0.2573626339,
-0.6727596521,
0.5930690765,
-0.1106727794,
1.1535061598,
0.8104319572,
-0.205440253,
-0.3145376444,
-0.35271433,
0.204830125,
0.276114285,
-0.7319203019,
0.1608494669,
0.6625114679,
-0.1684735715,
0.9294691086,
0.5973386168,
-0.2963955104,
0.3170442283,
-0.1644282788,
0.060421139,
-0.1826475412,
-0.0071716001,
-0.223817125,
0.3085569739,
-0.3337922692,
0.125390619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00248v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00248v1 | DiffuseDef: Improved Robustness to Adversarial Attacks | 2024-06-28T22:36:17 | 2024-06-28T22:36:17 | Zhenhao Li, Marek Rei, Lucia Specia | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models have significantly advanced performance across
various natural language processing tasks. However, adversarial attacks
continue to pose a critical challenge to system built using these models, as
they can be exploited with carefully crafted adversarial texts. Inspired by the
ability of diffusion models to predict and reduce noise in computer vision, we
propose a novel and flexible adversarial defense method for language
classification tasks, DiffuseDef, which incorporates a diffusion layer as a
denoiser between the encoder and the classifier. During inference, the
adversarial hidden state is first combined with sampled noise, then denoised
iteratively and finally ensembled to produce a robust text representation. By
integrating adversarial training, denoising, and ensembling techniques, we show
that DiffuseDef improves over different existing adversarial defense methods
and achieves state-of-the-art performance against common adversarial attacks. | [
-0.4649100006,
-1.2137688398,
0.2997947335,
-0.018554071,
0.0198698062,
0.2532583773,
-0.2453383356,
-0.1811561733,
-0.2138543576,
0.4812868536,
-0.3027981818,
-0.5115690827,
-1.1793912649,
-0.1417719275,
-0.8313951492,
0.9416069984,
0.2174574435,
0.1173733026,
-0.0174186323,
-0.037231829,
0.0937003568,
-0.4596370459,
-0.9435523152,
-0.1970261484,
0.2019096613,
-0.3033128679,
1.09963727,
0.1495406628,
0.4265087545,
0.3690391779,
-0.3198288977,
0.0885137618,
-0.3328136206,
0.2970359623,
0.0100912713,
-0.3236386776,
-0.2892299294,
-0.0468035974,
0.5728875995,
0.6237707138,
-0.1853993535,
-0.6405375004,
0.1452023834,
0.8146602511,
-0.8991485238,
-0.304767549,
-0.4873339832,
0.0366863944,
-0.2745394111,
0.2817829847,
-0.5598165393,
-0.2119532526,
0.2830129564,
-0.5500867963,
0.4460645318,
-0.5681591034,
0.9396542311,
0.4181270599,
-0.3755051196,
-0.1242535338,
-0.9023007751,
0.5947056413,
-0.5815173984,
0.2978933156,
0.3720519543,
0.2043776363,
-0.254201591,
-0.6549922824,
-0.4117431045,
-0.0923532024,
0.0394517221,
0.2818940282,
-0.589147985,
0.1745493412,
-0.0156146036,
0.3214399815,
-0.6991028786,
-0.148782745,
-0.1275084913,
-0.2338031083,
0.4789089859,
-0.2670146525,
0.440644443,
0.5172799826,
-0.3894107044,
-0.335965097,
-0.4470250905,
-0.3050136566,
0.4588207603,
-0.0103866244,
0.0411437266,
-0.0200864691,
0.0043457332,
0.8474282622,
0.1660979986,
-0.0434217528,
-0.0334696695,
0.0994240493,
-0.3915559947,
-0.0229046848,
0.7814031839,
0.0809866711,
0.0603786632,
-0.3182556629,
-0.2064634562,
0.320607394,
0.4983621836,
-0.9010433555,
-0.5457673669,
-0.0175813586,
-0.2504777908,
-0.785998106,
0.0254394021,
-0.9402794838,
-0.6215506196,
0.3635698259,
0.3802018464,
-0.4927417636,
-0.4076423943,
0.161563307,
-0.4470009208,
-0.1221428439,
0.3741493523,
-0.7003318667,
0.5858002305,
0.4328682125,
0.8309572339,
-0.1887040138,
0.019856602,
-0.4163911045,
0.1283931583,
-0.4659012258,
0.757193625,
-0.6020213366,
-0.555919826,
-0.0392890759,
-0.2649950385,
-0.1865682304,
-0.6417266726,
0.5065819025,
-0.8580780625,
0.4059619606,
0.3066006601,
-0.3886861205,
-0.4615635574,
0.3635714948,
-0.9903302789,
0.9705173969,
0.2718265355,
-1.0677297115,
0.2356340885,
-0.5728847384,
-0.7368600965,
0.0807070732,
0.046737507,
-0.5525345802,
-0.0698165521,
0.4206016064,
0.4616603851,
-0.0705638528,
-0.0661298856,
-0.4169270396,
-0.0678238645,
0.1211506426,
-0.9672477245,
0.9012941718,
0.3844197094,
-0.3728394806,
-0.1064802259,
-0.8019123077,
-0.2425747216,
0.1763385087,
-0.5066626668,
-0.5133653879,
0.0848430991,
-0.065268375,
-0.3438184261,
0.1115592197,
-0.3313169777,
-0.1383372694,
-0.9515771866,
0.3487744927,
0.6131382585,
0.1002394333,
1.0242657661,
0.0377121493,
0.6946184039,
0.0225880761,
0.1425403953,
0.3005704582,
-0.5099940896,
-0.5176314116,
-0.5945822597,
0.3794872761,
0.6274977326,
-0.9116588235,
0.2308491021,
0.0910762921,
-0.3741505444,
-0.3763056993,
0.34453848,
0.2676751316,
0.46163252,
0.2328807563,
-0.1153077036,
-0.3059870303,
-0.5089980364,
-0.1256719679,
-0.0828020871,
0.0116967745,
-0.107429795,
0.1606329679,
-0.5489067435,
0.5120066404,
-0.592253387,
-0.1489836276,
-0.3836019039,
0.141179055,
-0.2047989517,
0.3072062731,
0.7328974009,
-1.0489996672,
-0.6648774147,
0.0988276675,
-0.5321277976,
-0.0081978552,
-0.0430928841,
-0.2170319408,
0.0786201805,
0.632660687,
-0.4042209089,
0.4965057969,
0.5866211057,
-0.3785821199,
0.0422451086,
-0.2798785269,
0.0039788345,
-0.8129310012,
-0.3243065476,
-0.1379079372,
-0.4616237879,
-0.9126393199,
0.2251244187,
0.0953287631,
-0.0821682513,
-0.3545283079,
0.5550143719,
-0.2842737734,
0.617090404,
-0.4623687565,
0.1696415693,
0.2153199613,
0.1071293578,
0.0220544618,
0.5146402121,
1.1327700615,
-0.8197289109,
0.3334148228,
-0.0039098104,
-0.141001597,
0.7409604192,
-0.4679765403,
0.1000831276,
-0.3133089244,
0.182047084,
-0.8572144508,
0.10130997,
0.3581451178,
-0.3902824223,
0.7924127579,
-0.0990212262,
-0.2143751085,
-0.1620978117,
-0.2679794729,
0.2457912564,
0.4042573869,
-0.7553737164,
0.7855016589,
0.3596625328,
0.1023647636,
-0.6065403819,
-0.7967501283,
0.2744806409,
-0.402361393,
-0.6991584301,
0.609357357,
-0.1011218429,
-0.3503878117,
-0.0387487449,
0.022408165,
-0.4605422616,
0.628205657,
0.1897726208,
0.2073470503,
-0.0914310589,
-0.1885191798,
-0.0094178729,
-0.0362051241,
0.051330667,
-0.2740662694,
0.3207490742,
0.1416525692,
-0.2357084155,
-0.1955197453,
0.417864114,
0.4402692616,
0.0129706701,
0.8669829965,
0.9048360586,
-0.360840708,
-0.7011204362,
-0.2164930552,
-0.0051438864,
-0.5625758171,
0.4877027869,
-0.1967234313,
-0.7620734572,
0.1860816926,
-0.2373671383,
-0.0149488132,
0.4874457717,
0.2156930715,
0.0556584485,
1.1890550852,
0.7136937976,
-0.2101372033,
0.6175616384,
-0.3828673065,
0.1428471357,
-0.5546651483,
-0.0890207142,
-0.4747733176,
-0.1407836974,
-0.1979664862,
-0.3464322984,
0.1882939637,
0.3270379305,
-0.1542130262,
0.2806504667,
-0.6132969856,
0.5267021656,
0.4314100742,
0.2156483829,
-0.0766930059,
0.202094689,
-0.0608071499,
0.0452421829,
-0.5924164057,
-0.4064749181,
1.0899568796,
0.3527863026,
1.0061770678,
0.3820441961,
0.7274978161,
0.5449380279,
0.3332024217,
-0.4850340784,
0.5338493586,
-0.6675673127,
-0.4175725877,
-0.2744600177,
-0.4466973841,
-0.987703383,
0.3499937952,
0.0281496048,
-0.3805924058,
0.1887430251,
-0.0487615019,
-0.3254598081,
0.4425587952,
-0.7462761402,
0.6445542574,
-0.0435527861,
-0.0161199793,
-0.1308743954,
-0.1756284386,
0.3272164762,
-0.0803592354,
0.3384894729,
0.3557752967,
0.0318488404,
0.8460952044,
-0.3731752634,
0.842458725,
-0.3581035435,
-0.3397021592,
0.3266966045,
0.3992471099,
0.4797293246,
0.0082848826,
-0.131536603,
-0.039714247,
-0.2128579915,
-0.3537777066,
-0.652895093,
0.7448895574,
-0.6087066531,
-0.7569230199,
-0.4411736429,
-0.1391919404,
0.0316672362,
0.2350980639,
0.5330392718,
0.3837394118,
-0.7383754849,
-0.0425071865,
1.1329494715,
-0.1663115472,
0.7893244028,
0.3860660791,
0.297267437,
-0.6130813956,
0.9041108489,
-0.1722277552,
0.5736265182,
0.5995491147,
0.1484413296,
-0.3929651678,
-0.6430151463,
-0.4651307464,
-0.2784870267,
-0.9106957316,
-0.3351196647,
-0.6639009714,
-0.4519973397,
-0.6004754305,
-0.2872556746,
-0.2624618411,
-0.4034695029,
-0.4581615925,
-0.0380499326,
0.2950504124,
0.919195652,
-0.0087959077,
0.4341460764,
-0.4111955762,
0.4243070781,
0.4167277217,
0.1088955402,
-0.100450635,
-0.6484748125,
-0.1685613692,
0.0257839225,
-0.4034867585,
-0.9546755552,
0.5892581344,
0.5568692684,
0.6730387807,
0.6220220923,
0.3417627513,
0.3514029682,
-0.4246596098,
0.7630516291,
0.2526606619,
-0.7073274851,
0.6709601879,
0.1534606814,
0.3858472407,
0.2729507685,
0.127175048,
0.0442999564,
-0.7734414339,
-0.6532745957,
-0.6281459928,
0.5240690112,
0.2757482529,
0.0332953744,
-0.0759070814,
-0.0068574403,
-0.1592089087,
-0.1764000058,
-0.6613314152,
-0.3032682538,
-0.4206942916,
-0.3952587545,
-0.0565480143,
-0.0636098683,
-0.3374972939,
0.0295023676,
0.6042938828,
0.1045915708,
0.0894081369,
0.3294173181,
-0.2131829411,
0.1910826266,
0.216848731,
0.5114330053,
-0.1863443851,
0.0272713061,
0.5975746512,
0.2413509786,
-0.9151963592,
0.3011463284,
0.2609710097,
-0.5307471156,
0.0147831962,
0.466152966,
0.5924825072,
-0.0865118802,
-0.45830217,
0.7606194019,
-0.4645687342,
-0.4010988176,
-0.1590913534,
0.3910465837,
-0.0481184721,
0.3151960671,
-0.0349161327,
0.7240239978,
0.3355083764,
-0.0571177341,
0.1597374082,
0.7310378551,
-0.5235191584,
-0.1798873395,
0.7344707251,
0.0900786668,
-0.2589046657,
0.0338201262,
-0.3698329329,
-0.8076397777,
0.5053220391,
0.4303661883,
1.1245485544,
-0.4565101862,
0.4070248604,
0.0608074032,
0.4152289629,
-0.3821650445,
-0.1384389848,
-0.2504968047,
-0.7138120532,
0.1294623613,
-0.728369534,
-0.0080846511,
0.116856724,
-0.4159836471,
-0.1464135349,
-0.9197744727,
-0.2380388379,
-0.0025950477,
-0.2199047506,
-0.4262576997,
0.3449847102,
0.2490748167,
0.5875285864,
-0.4958559871,
0.7796387672,
0.5181471705,
-0.1110519096,
-0.0519851893,
0.2294644713,
0.0791335329,
-0.3742226958,
0.6702619195,
-0.1258361191,
-0.5122234821,
-0.3570387661,
-0.4102495313,
-0.847153306,
0.6145013571,
0.5093774199,
-0.2449235618,
0.3291840851,
-0.1548865736,
0.464851141,
-0.1552979052,
0.0295452327,
0.5529152155,
0.3731216788,
0.0337410383,
-0.298052609,
0.0239615347,
-0.3049175739,
-0.0003453228,
0.0536074266,
-0.4354613721,
0.6728136539,
-0.1015981734,
-0.7081638575,
-0.0315621197,
0.7050470114,
-0.370352149,
0.1480734646,
0.6566296816,
0.79941535,
0.8488097191,
-0.1456015557,
0.939802289,
0.0184760708,
-0.0644289777,
0.8957716227,
-0.1911825687,
0.754144609,
-0.0503791682,
-0.2440360487,
0.6290245652,
0.3709080517,
0.0077175517,
1.0283486843,
0.1298908144,
-0.7618910074,
-0.0974139571,
0.3682216406,
-0.2427368462,
0.117159605,
0.4498886764,
-0.2870509624,
-0.3445055485,
0.3888277411,
0.1066941693,
0.4704906642,
-0.1313284039,
1.0060312748,
-0.1012894064,
-0.4307324886,
0.7546288371,
0.1343372911,
1.0104612112,
-0.5393124819,
0.1291955709,
-0.1652980894,
0.6337908506,
-0.1160277575,
-0.543323338,
0.362408489,
-0.0560847893,
-0.2546631396,
-0.2872682214,
0.8296345472,
-0.4276928604,
-0.5195842385,
0.6725714207,
-0.1330700219,
-0.1998478621,
-0.2624903917,
-0.7526336908,
-0.1072221696,
0.0130108977,
-0.3018538952,
0.339892,
0.5176076889,
0.3654058278,
0.7224887013,
0.3889038265,
0.3481824994,
0.1742324233,
0.5546992421,
0.7907921076,
-0.2435040921,
-0.5094338655,
-1.0439227819,
0.1038193926,
-0.2097623497,
-0.0590978414,
0.6617160439,
0.2794721425,
0.7151843905,
0.1081844792,
0.8765147328,
0.1425989568,
0.4446108937,
-0.3927838802,
1.0213755369,
-0.3738781214,
0.4694895744,
-0.2372952104,
-0.4695605934,
-0.4327046871,
0.6891480684,
0.0108203515,
0.0706595853,
0.6177762747,
0.9942749739,
0.0384928621,
-0.0224720389,
0.5409315228,
0.1714973748,
0.5486095548,
0.4756675065,
0.7145715356,
-0.6516604424,
0.8097889423,
-0.2858325541,
-0.3385477066,
0.222466141,
-0.5324234962,
-1.2640479803,
-0.3871353567,
-0.662623167,
-0.450019002,
0.1774818748,
-0.0229980778,
0.8546897769,
-0.9288957715,
0.2146172076,
-0.4568063319,
0.1578061432,
-0.3583996892,
-0.269012481,
0.3904841542,
-0.2463278621,
-0.8072142601,
0.6616944075,
0.1997477561,
0.418184638,
-0.386721909,
-0.2228375971,
-0.1385445744,
0.3164993525,
0.4170264006,
0.0751158521,
-0.5699597597,
0.128032431,
-0.3936008513,
-0.3344972432,
-0.3581805527,
0.3408530653,
-0.6952585578,
0.4422546625,
0.4470411241,
0.8592540026,
0.357624948,
-0.1718536317,
0.5303263068,
-0.8563791513,
0.3289831877,
0.3226837218,
0.2589785755,
0.4638120532,
-0.6893138885,
0.2485165,
0.2475180924,
-0.1707714796,
-0.6656677127,
0.1586529016,
-0.6108437777,
-0.8163919449,
1.0194984674,
-0.2716343701,
-0.3434445262,
-0.3387064338,
-0.2590181828,
0.0088013085,
-0.3838070631,
0.6662934422,
0.6766307354,
0.445181787,
-0.1637138128,
-0.1967948824,
0.9072546959,
0.3945925236,
-0.616073668,
0.1099039987,
0.2097651809,
0.1605160236,
0.1689573526,
0.5249393582,
-0.2374779433,
0.1616786867,
0.3151221871,
-0.5151400566,
0.1368659586,
-0.4520535469,
-0.5467850566,
0.5489755273,
-0.1363804787,
-0.2818018794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00242v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00242v1 | EHRmonize: A Framework for Medical Concept Abstraction from Electronic Health Records using Large Language Models | 2024-06-28T21:39:20 | 2024-06-28T21:39:20 | João Matos, Jack Gallifant, Jian Pei, A. Ian Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Electronic health records (EHRs) contain vast amounts of complex data, but
harmonizing and processing this information remains a challenging and costly
task requiring significant clinical expertise. While large language models
(LLMs) have shown promise in various healthcare applications, their potential
for abstracting medical concepts from EHRs remains largely unexplored. We
introduce EHRmonize, a framework leveraging LLMs to abstract medical concepts
from EHR data. Our study uses medication data from two real-world EHR databases
to evaluate five LLMs on two free-text extraction and six binary classification
tasks across various prompting strategies. GPT-4o's with 10-shot prompting
achieved the highest performance in all tasks, accompanied by Claude-3.5-Sonnet
in a subset of tasks. GPT-4o achieved an accuracy of 97% in identifying generic
route names, 82% for generic drug names, and 100% in performing binary
classification of antibiotics. While EHRmonize significantly enhances
efficiency, reducing annotation time by an estimated 60%, we emphasize that
clinician oversight remains essential. Our framework, available as a Python
package, offers a promising tool to assist clinicians in EHR data abstraction,
potentially accelerating healthcare research and improving data harmonization
processes. | [
-0.038544517,
-0.9506825805,
0.9942871332,
-0.12947236,
-0.2999189496,
-0.2155092359,
-0.3937033713,
-0.5213770866,
0.1554507017,
0.3273172081,
-0.3878784478,
-0.7902246118,
-0.6696728468,
0.2464921623,
-0.217497766,
1.0005383492,
-0.2225008309,
0.0711178556,
-0.2439059615,
0.075810343,
-0.2893427908,
-0.5513337851,
-0.5691770911,
-0.8283613324,
0.520178318,
0.3461355567,
0.223508358,
0.9736641049,
0.6653485298,
0.2841286957,
-0.0318353102,
-0.0289399326,
-0.1583224088,
0.5006856918,
-0.0053793881,
-0.567858696,
-0.6927341223,
-0.4854870737,
0.5231130719,
0.3852169216,
-0.6371456385,
0.382902056,
-0.3654957712,
0.6832187176,
-0.6656979918,
0.2987124026,
-0.4293037951,
0.1509230286,
-0.2128619999,
-0.1499643773,
-0.1653607637,
-0.0748641342,
0.1870356202,
-0.6198889613,
-0.1327416748,
0.1950016171,
0.747009635,
0.3234683275,
0.1022616625,
-0.3117580712,
-0.5903570056,
0.6911343336,
-0.829737246,
0.4636719525,
0.5133107901,
0.1153809354,
0.0182618406,
-0.8070406914,
-0.496420145,
-0.0774014369,
-0.0198730584,
0.0326090157,
-0.3488422036,
0.224314332,
0.3410508037,
0.2547732294,
-0.4853756428,
0.0544190891,
-0.2727079391,
0.0426232778,
0.3655941486,
0.2918424606,
0.6122083068,
-0.1716645807,
-0.3215148151,
0.1079011634,
-0.4943708777,
-0.1827310771,
-0.3253832757,
-0.0429689512,
-0.3173514605,
0.5708993673,
-0.3189412951,
0.6333836317,
0.133190304,
-0.2364629209,
0.5199217796,
0.0748056471,
-0.5936997533,
0.543172121,
0.8423455358,
0.4099858403,
-0.1738133579,
-0.2970288098,
-0.2826739848,
0.1349107325,
0.1856700629,
-0.9669412971,
-0.4010204673,
0.9171219468,
-0.3336245418,
-0.0488294363,
-0.0420185216,
-0.8161418438,
-0.1434954405,
-0.514814198,
0.3138546944,
-0.4954164028,
-0.0598127991,
0.3991539478,
-0.2520977855,
0.0046616732,
0.39812392,
-0.8170966506,
0.4247379005,
0.9865796566,
0.9959854484,
-0.2511106133,
0.0169265345,
-0.300052464,
0.198852405,
-0.3267828226,
0.8583853245,
-0.4763064682,
-0.2963953614,
-0.1608123481,
-0.098554045,
-0.1328376532,
-0.7070245147,
0.4668950438,
-0.2451671511,
0.1098135114,
0.0481709205,
-0.874707818,
0.084606871,
0.5748076439,
-0.7735096812,
0.7435101867,
0.1803106815,
-0.8692751527,
0.1024388373,
-0.8191877604,
-0.3005696237,
0.2278350294,
-0.3875588179,
-0.6013987064,
0.0020912089,
0.1476030201,
0.5759153962,
-0.6473607421,
0.234995544,
-0.110283643,
-0.1550291032,
0.2807624042,
0.1958474219,
0.6294948459,
0.3021946549,
-0.4083677232,
0.0673006922,
-0.6861015558,
0.2005422115,
0.0739295706,
-0.4221533537,
-0.5443432331,
-0.1602295637,
0.1525545567,
0.2467519194,
0.0275292955,
-0.5643727183,
0.0152967945,
-0.5840652585,
0.5565183163,
0.3227759302,
0.3232669234,
0.2550042272,
-0.5517363548,
0.5769446492,
-0.0439864956,
-0.0236860365,
-0.3947719336,
-0.6555491686,
-0.4104993939,
-0.6524666548,
0.3503706753,
0.6425583959,
-0.6182256341,
0.4408255219,
-0.6204388142,
-0.3123511672,
-0.5777792931,
0.0926825851,
0.432580322,
0.6225215197,
0.3571212888,
-0.0825098529,
-0.3508282006,
-0.9280417562,
-0.1678721011,
-0.1904099733,
-0.2320970297,
-0.0053600823,
0.5663696527,
-0.542822361,
0.6682115793,
-0.4277945757,
-0.3583680391,
-0.2840008736,
0.1136118323,
0.1699541211,
0.4033399224,
0.0435821526,
-0.8447585106,
-0.2247251421,
0.3044600189,
-0.8999826312,
-0.1466008276,
0.0042251102,
-0.2647716105,
-0.3212787509,
0.3352442384,
-0.6437884569,
0.0904448032,
0.3653422296,
0.0028110635,
0.2213764191,
-0.3555256128,
0.3224459589,
-1.2500427961,
0.2903454602,
0.2314618081,
-0.1708276868,
-0.949971199,
0.4044430852,
0.1915618628,
0.0349743851,
-0.6034604311,
0.4483440816,
-0.3885940909,
0.4756106138,
0.0038033598,
-0.0528449826,
0.0637689978,
0.2121823579,
0.1344290227,
0.1589007378,
0.4012854695,
-0.4485273659,
0.5759859085,
0.4651002288,
-0.2083566189,
0.7455924153,
-0.7568924427,
0.166980952,
-0.0359930731,
0.1583237201,
-0.285997808,
-0.623398304,
0.5363575816,
-0.1747565418,
0.3297185004,
-0.3101557493,
-0.633879602,
-0.2670885623,
-0.271893084,
0.3270517588,
0.5129835606,
-0.0823767483,
0.6663755178,
0.7240368128,
-0.3773748577,
-0.2168436199,
-0.778003931,
0.1798663586,
-0.2866907716,
-0.1736791879,
0.4678804576,
0.0608658977,
-0.427087456,
0.0618369095,
0.0586342253,
-0.4030967057,
-0.0235386156,
0.4009408355,
0.4569067657,
-0.2111955434,
0.4036365449,
0.2121096253,
-0.041249752,
0.313016057,
-0.4081945717,
0.4881427586,
0.0445388034,
-0.4432522953,
-0.6751080751,
0.3327820599,
0.6378432512,
-0.2562533915,
0.5597313643,
0.2196876854,
-0.8627533913,
-0.0897368342,
-0.32819435,
-0.1289125234,
-0.3751665354,
0.4111945331,
-0.1242293492,
-0.5642688274,
0.2400989532,
-0.2333592176,
0.2531205714,
0.1757104844,
0.9800373316,
0.0077206427,
0.7725326419,
0.1714995503,
0.0078985663,
0.2008119673,
-0.0841472521,
0.0018796176,
-0.9183117747,
-0.4817956686,
-0.4055971205,
-0.1513682902,
-0.3048751354,
-0.4300555289,
0.6706616879,
-0.2139772177,
-0.1216071248,
0.0878378972,
-0.4691634774,
0.2401235402,
0.1156882122,
0.6175971627,
0.3747157156,
0.171455428,
-0.0334472544,
0.1596535742,
-0.6367143393,
-0.3417606652,
1.2596544027,
0.4188183248,
0.7177368999,
0.016779393,
1.0365239382,
0.1824906617,
0.4500690997,
-1.1333932877,
0.2370272726,
0.1134600043,
-0.5523125529,
-0.2727718353,
-0.468716383,
-0.9458007812,
0.2453087717,
-0.5240662694,
-0.5942651629,
-0.0228134897,
0.4513896406,
-0.4861409366,
0.3378470242,
-0.4438105822,
0.6583757401,
-0.1103078276,
-0.2447490245,
-0.1115208045,
-0.6960110068,
0.2057525665,
-0.5380724072,
0.6290197372,
-0.2287896425,
-0.1816807538,
0.5808070302,
-0.4102925658,
0.6033652425,
0.3066179156,
-0.1918054521,
0.042319838,
0.0336531922,
0.2977797091,
-0.1413953006,
-0.1481354088,
0.3379848301,
0.2448762953,
-0.1436219215,
-0.6198971868,
0.5424256921,
-0.3151046038,
-0.3184924126,
-0.2797112763,
-0.3310798705,
-0.136589095,
0.3311871588,
0.3789359629,
0.5844833255,
-0.1931007057,
-0.0124840047,
0.709729135,
-0.0080667417,
0.0055386038,
0.3179012239,
-0.0591615885,
-0.2664420307,
0.5671263933,
-0.1764172018,
0.2982774377,
0.6168116927,
0.4020006657,
-0.2832596898,
-0.4546093941,
-0.8438420892,
0.1819927096,
-0.6593079567,
-0.0985964835,
-0.8766736388,
0.0477073304,
-0.1433051974,
0.07447768,
-0.1317330599,
-0.3306820393,
-0.1363871396,
-0.0379199982,
0.4145133793,
0.573797226,
0.1762684733,
0.0798698813,
-1.1562367678,
0.5341030359,
0.0728200898,
0.1984000057,
-0.1782489419,
-0.2832659185,
-0.3757035136,
-0.0290891565,
-0.047172498,
-0.9876434803,
0.3579618335,
0.3531013131,
0.5354263783,
0.545846343,
0.0527931787,
0.5853766203,
-1.0247840881,
0.5634803176,
0.5568176508,
-0.9474895,
0.7425788045,
-0.2635608912,
0.1353446543,
0.4805844426,
0.3456140757,
-0.7375010252,
-0.3979489505,
-0.5539056659,
-0.9457223415,
0.4497859776,
0.147082746,
-0.0447463095,
-0.0343920849,
0.4195391238,
-0.15845263,
0.4046089947,
-0.1407274902,
-0.4178371131,
0.1092393994,
-0.7225510478,
0.1222113892,
0.1705813557,
-0.3165369928,
-0.1268869191,
0.3697023392,
0.1170291826,
0.358073473,
0.4694418311,
-0.2775439024,
-0.3129065037,
0.7846822143,
0.3234816492,
0.6268080473,
0.0284527354,
0.2110603154,
0.0341831036,
-0.5687301159,
0.2583753169,
0.040847525,
-0.194402054,
0.1164000034,
0.3838784099,
0.4956120849,
0.4569627345,
-1.0141015053,
0.344571501,
0.1280539334,
-0.1978938729,
-0.1365211308,
0.1516396403,
0.0791177005,
0.0791405588,
-0.0666082427,
-0.1630256474,
0.5453913808,
-0.5301969647,
0.3916338384,
0.0208018199,
-0.3000864685,
-0.3228547573,
0.7012409568,
-0.0135534387,
-0.2095683366,
0.3991977572,
0.1275972426,
-0.5482529998,
0.453923732,
0.6000090837,
0.7129438519,
-0.2946017981,
0.0293336269,
0.3499371409,
-0.0180318877,
-0.5781357884,
0.1405747831,
0.1092994809,
-0.6846210957,
-0.3116653562,
-0.536837697,
-0.5301274657,
-0.0505184606,
-0.9959446788,
0.1389278471,
-0.5802826881,
-0.4739886224,
0.2281771153,
-0.5002410412,
-0.6077221036,
0.1492552459,
0.4430808127,
0.5593985319,
-0.7796530724,
0.6878602505,
1.0804339647,
-0.1148406193,
-0.7700460553,
-0.1472803354,
0.4035560787,
-0.6474832892,
0.6727276444,
-0.0437401794,
-0.1227967888,
0.0605150685,
-0.2948140204,
-0.2912305295,
0.8798989058,
0.1140422225,
-0.8221583962,
-0.1716509014,
0.0206529871,
0.4883422852,
-0.3885092139,
0.1466822177,
0.8290842772,
0.5296618938,
-0.1394848526,
-0.8840800524,
0.1724639684,
-0.4824155867,
-0.0751155242,
0.2817035913,
-0.068917498,
0.7754510045,
-0.3686536551,
-0.2983583808,
0.100971669,
-0.00722672,
0.3557522297,
0.4822243452,
0.3023948371,
0.6994952559,
0.8839247823,
0.0379608832,
1.1194143295,
-0.4169019163,
0.4263977706,
0.993827641,
-0.4421897233,
1.1497269869,
0.4973677695,
-0.1778469086,
0.7272437811,
0.5258430839,
-0.016277723,
0.2890671194,
-0.0047514406,
-0.4088100493,
-0.3023039997,
0.1014048755,
-0.2170993835,
0.1242935359,
0.8077397346,
-0.4734679461,
-0.1597625613,
0.0096432427,
0.2063070834,
-0.191314429,
-0.3439508379,
0.979080379,
0.3621938527,
-0.311827004,
0.5727514625,
0.0342255905,
0.2196674347,
-0.5939426422,
-0.2604295313,
0.3783043921,
0.1185338572,
-0.3063564897,
-0.3990120888,
-0.1965256631,
0.074837774,
-0.1918014288,
-0.0232058056,
0.5474377871,
-0.5432466865,
-0.5392429829,
-0.0054483158,
0.6983585358,
0.2613453269,
-0.1186681092,
-0.9598492384,
-0.0893970132,
-0.1944584846,
-0.0560342893,
0.1360728592,
0.5310914516,
0.0254023895,
0.6897644997,
0.880515337,
0.6959842443,
-0.2257325649,
-0.0426237173,
0.7232300043,
-0.4979099333,
-0.7814072967,
-1.1651320457,
0.3645991385,
-0.0079717152,
-0.0974340886,
0.4892086685,
0.4996699691,
0.4664770365,
-0.0412419848,
0.8103777766,
0.129080072,
0.6479590535,
-0.793425858,
0.8674083948,
-0.5103157759,
0.3085881174,
-0.2733237445,
-0.5622138977,
-0.5044156313,
0.5284250379,
-0.2927640676,
-0.3521368504,
0.760812223,
0.4207305312,
-0.0328094065,
-0.0489889011,
0.409303844,
0.2123278379,
0.1879568547,
0.561814785,
0.6532810926,
-0.2163625658,
-0.0899608731,
-0.1511188745,
-0.3537807763,
-0.3854185045,
-0.6313015223,
-0.822645843,
-0.1701854467,
-0.3520067036,
-0.2304472327,
0.0794292837,
1.7435138226,
0.7836904526,
-0.9543950558,
0.0537735857,
0.2572685182,
-0.1819125563,
-0.1724244654,
-0.0862334222,
0.4838727415,
-0.2159290165,
-0.5936965942,
0.0987525135,
0.4934628606,
0.0141100464,
0.2294469476,
0.0340814143,
0.2706232071,
-0.1198607087,
0.648534894,
0.3427134752,
-0.7619500756,
0.2333312929,
-0.0583361425,
-0.1408591419,
0.3374623954,
1.1122057438,
-0.4338931441,
0.7102698088,
0.2526851892,
0.7305902839,
0.1934559345,
0.2168551534,
0.4019011855,
-0.2183018476,
0.0159841198,
0.3616121411,
0.5268622041,
0.2488447875,
-0.4114257395,
0.0617183596,
0.0017501748,
-0.2716591656,
-0.5299838185,
-0.0080024069,
-0.7435904145,
-0.4035508931,
1.1703294516,
-0.3076878488,
-0.4951691926,
-0.3956963718,
-0.0579409413,
0.0683036968,
-0.4713351727,
0.706408143,
0.3992890716,
-0.3725666702,
-0.0765541494,
-0.9337338805,
0.3615067005,
0.0578141063,
-1.1966520548,
-0.0311341062,
0.5860463381,
0.4842340946,
0.1659929305,
0.7660184503,
-0.4663836062,
0.2735034823,
-0.3329660594,
0.1653440148,
0.0018468514,
0.0026554966,
-0.484939754,
-0.0408265218,
-0.1085925475,
-0.0781061575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00219v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00219v1 | Evaluating Human Alignment and Model Faithfulness of LLM Rationale | 2024-06-28T20:06:30 | 2024-06-28T20:06:30 | Mohsen Fayyaz, Fan Yin, Jiao Sun, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We study how well large language models (LLMs) explain their generations with
rationales -- a set of tokens extracted from the input texts that reflect the
decision process of LLMs. We examine LLM rationales extracted with two methods:
1) attribution-based methods that use attention or gradients to locate
important tokens, and 2) prompting-based methods that guide LLMs to extract
rationales using prompts. Through extensive experiments, we show that
prompting-based rationales align better with human-annotated rationales than
attribution-based rationales, and demonstrate reasonable alignment with humans
even when model performance is poor. We additionally find that the faithfulness
limitations of prompting-based methods, which are identified in previous work,
may be linked to their collapsed predictions. By fine-tuning these models on
the corresponding datasets, both prompting and attribution methods demonstrate
improved faithfulness. Our study sheds light on more rigorous and fair
evaluations of LLM rationales, especially for prompting-based ones. | [
-0.2097644955,
-0.6581833363,
0.9103560448,
0.1084671691,
-0.1595924646,
-0.1454733759,
-0.3221784234,
-0.2764572501,
-0.244693622,
0.434338659,
-0.9002410173,
-0.1741640121,
-0.2522474527,
0.2637667954,
-0.2802333236,
0.5666814446,
-0.1589654535,
0.4632425308,
-0.49765414,
-0.111371465,
-0.57869941,
-0.3625462651,
-0.698682785,
-0.6595901251,
0.7217223048,
0.3364147246,
0.7817447782,
1.1618405581,
0.3568545878,
0.2441960722,
-0.2373330891,
0.2018060684,
-0.4335677028,
0.1335891336,
-0.4397543669,
-0.3922479451,
-0.3081331849,
0.3854785264,
0.5090676546,
0.6827539206,
-0.117706649,
0.3745056689,
0.2213016748,
0.5745184422,
-0.4511953294,
-0.2582460046,
-0.6760097146,
-0.2874859571,
-0.053265661,
-0.3036397696,
-0.6077078581,
-0.5497088432,
0.2141936123,
-0.5505463481,
0.1195419133,
0.243489325,
0.9811536074,
0.2789316177,
-0.3460068405,
-0.3438851535,
-0.5077698231,
1.214548707,
-0.8125858307,
0.4232660532,
0.3719711006,
0.2586391568,
-0.4635268152,
-0.3787411451,
-0.5181973577,
-0.2946335077,
-0.0219443794,
-0.1170084327,
0.015172598,
-0.0192756411,
0.5504940152,
0.1952677369,
-0.4277633727,
0.3048844635,
-0.1634572744,
-0.3786667883,
0.6444726586,
0.2023662925,
0.2365314066,
-0.2332516313,
-0.6394554377,
-0.1003777757,
-0.8715043068,
0.0381851606,
0.6339854002,
0.298079282,
0.1115642563,
0.8510949016,
-0.0318543464,
0.7916590571,
0.189544335,
-0.3388834894,
-0.1496563703,
-0.572496593,
-0.1236655414,
0.0039168964,
0.7653893828,
0.6347901821,
0.7052825093,
-0.2866747975,
-0.3574535549,
0.1570205688,
0.1824644059,
-0.4515313804,
0.2210363597,
0.1795302778,
-0.709215045,
-0.3499230742,
-0.0502551571,
-0.6312593818,
-0.5607315898,
-0.8646482825,
0.1967502981,
-0.3457137346,
0.0840448812,
0.0726152211,
-0.114945136,
0.6160484552,
0.5472493768,
-1.0530235767,
0.0903765187,
0.9944257736,
0.6824601293,
-0.3672572374,
-0.3116509914,
-0.5162985325,
0.1142380461,
-0.2995967567,
0.816577971,
-0.5037304759,
-0.1834634691,
-0.0143367415,
-0.0511622764,
-0.1015601084,
-0.6635482311,
0.9115379453,
-0.4774215221,
0.346770227,
-0.7203658819,
-0.7903490663,
-0.2635628879,
0.2542534173,
-0.643334806,
0.755345583,
-0.0390271954,
-0.6106352806,
0.4783015251,
-0.601755023,
-0.1089746282,
-0.1361287534,
-0.2236187756,
-0.1806214452,
0.1714902818,
0.3842859566,
0.3657267392,
-0.6080523133,
0.4333507717,
-0.5339285135,
-0.1928022653,
0.6708285213,
-0.8980870843,
1.1951322556,
0.2652539313,
-0.1590503901,
0.3260631859,
-0.5204135776,
-0.0491144992,
0.1792295128,
-0.3493827283,
-0.0591509826,
0.2109406143,
-0.1208839938,
0.1519410163,
0.3015631735,
-0.3787092566,
0.4222878218,
-0.2937262058,
0.5193686485,
0.9397451282,
-0.1140004173,
0.6114278436,
-0.5428281426,
0.5806642175,
-0.1438296288,
0.2030669004,
-0.3158005774,
-0.3896917701,
-0.4640079737,
-0.2423700243,
0.4561395347,
0.4285947978,
-0.2211387753,
0.3672620356,
-0.417688638,
-0.1597776562,
-0.6661095619,
0.2123160511,
0.3138500154,
0.7965318561,
0.058529079,
-0.1002348363,
-0.6019099355,
-1.092425704,
-0.5088918209,
-0.3983131349,
-0.1681651026,
0.1590372175,
0.3413311541,
-0.24379839,
1.2313338518,
-0.1103753522,
0.3050450683,
-0.0566176549,
0.2043994069,
-0.1043050662,
0.5142223239,
0.2903498113,
-0.561288476,
-0.1923980415,
-0.0915000513,
-0.7511069775,
-0.3068810999,
-0.2220087647,
-0.2378302068,
0.3086473048,
0.4259490967,
-0.7393964529,
0.3610942364,
0.3442707658,
-0.3926094472,
0.7748067379,
0.190863654,
0.1509961784,
-0.9370657206,
0.1755837053,
0.0764125735,
-0.4036093056,
-0.4458019137,
-0.0729430318,
0.1728168428,
0.2131150663,
-0.3303050697,
0.7302305698,
-0.539552331,
-0.2587138116,
-0.1810988635,
0.2141371518,
0.1534914076,
0.1048469022,
-0.153939873,
0.9154136181,
0.2305535078,
-0.3187101185,
0.4223178923,
0.1973597556,
-0.3491843641,
0.5272619128,
-0.5788846016,
0.2528979778,
-0.1504102796,
0.2400814891,
-0.9025230408,
-0.4335377812,
0.2882382572,
-0.4603056312,
0.1284794509,
-0.2114147991,
-0.4944474995,
-0.2739041746,
-0.4800228477,
0.435731411,
0.6281822324,
-0.6562222242,
0.722458303,
0.0319474004,
-0.1252443641,
-0.6288027763,
-0.4207061827,
-0.039530538,
-0.6715121865,
-0.8312398195,
0.1917097121,
-0.0647386983,
-0.6291785836,
-0.1173121333,
-0.0377720892,
0.0804648325,
0.2685421705,
0.1688677371,
0.5981450677,
-0.4981898963,
-0.1316213608,
-0.2080776691,
-0.1221700981,
0.3406231105,
-0.1199813485,
0.586119771,
0.0400504768,
-0.5827355981,
-0.7544974685,
0.1687134057,
0.7434460521,
-0.0547643192,
0.6657770276,
0.2742040455,
-0.5350664854,
0.1725739539,
-0.9290053844,
-0.4636680782,
-0.457327038,
-0.0052554575,
0.0059483829,
-0.7374194264,
0.8126404285,
-0.0653670654,
0.2032078505,
0.5157627463,
0.7248988748,
-0.2061429471,
1.4322125912,
0.4091157317,
-0.0521237887,
0.3874492347,
0.2788136005,
-0.0883609429,
-0.9297673702,
-0.3895483315,
-0.5835370421,
-0.2308186442,
-0.1804583073,
-0.2511222363,
-0.3062958419,
0.5895847082,
-0.2075683922,
0.0885047764,
-0.3703444004,
0.7625118494,
0.3765893579,
-0.1409972012,
0.3270752728,
0.0653283969,
-0.009223856,
-0.1557801962,
-0.5370823145,
-1.1879885197,
1.0151655674,
0.6848124266,
0.8706482053,
0.0138155092,
0.5281998515,
-0.0670223385,
0.6121709943,
-0.9659358859,
0.3909454346,
0.2807810009,
-0.6782404184,
-0.4293845594,
-0.4254846275,
-1.0085253716,
0.0682977661,
-0.1409856677,
-1.0108808279,
0.1548006833,
0.3267799318,
-0.5707013607,
-0.0557553098,
-0.844029963,
0.8898124099,
-0.4510116279,
-0.3195337057,
-0.0469071455,
-0.6085548997,
0.4516547918,
-0.1122426689,
0.1302737445,
-0.2836205959,
-0.0507198758,
0.8417981863,
-0.3657926023,
0.7119085193,
-0.0799820721,
-0.4875204861,
0.2664546072,
-0.0335659496,
0.572142601,
-0.0209692419,
-0.3005956411,
-0.0256588887,
-0.0964139774,
-0.3347249925,
-0.7949241996,
0.6631795168,
-0.5115245581,
-0.8027505875,
-0.1649885774,
-0.7061567307,
-0.2172403932,
0.1693602949,
0.2329738736,
0.3160486817,
-0.0836100653,
0.0780779421,
0.6456236839,
-0.0022305553,
0.2402788997,
0.3914455771,
-0.3793202043,
-0.3770158589,
0.7419141531,
0.0127314348,
0.4002674222,
-0.150233537,
0.4077394009,
-0.6553553343,
-0.4882049859,
-0.6674820781,
0.3780625463,
-0.8751478791,
-0.1624843478,
-0.2133228034,
0.1286178529,
-0.3934797049,
-0.2737245858,
-0.1662953347,
-0.223219499,
-0.585486114,
0.0232013874,
0.1956435293,
0.7868078351,
0.2244119197,
0.1299991012,
-0.8160982728,
0.0992668718,
0.2863760591,
0.1459142417,
0.1085145921,
-0.725238502,
0.1121291071,
0.2905989587,
-0.3494656086,
-1.0214437246,
0.1548896134,
-0.1626261026,
0.6436723471,
0.5376176834,
-0.1468699127,
0.9673978686,
-0.4953128397,
0.8285919428,
0.2258918583,
-1.0310248137,
0.3490576148,
-0.5183020234,
0.1307214051,
0.7096740603,
0.2266906053,
-0.3289276659,
-0.0194638688,
-0.5715494752,
-0.6074997187,
0.7672333717,
0.1216674447,
0.0343562029,
0.1069445387,
0.8902587891,
0.1035940126,
-0.1064502597,
-0.727807045,
-0.0478989147,
0.1525824964,
-0.5732536912,
0.1863585263,
-0.3756143451,
-0.3365212381,
-0.2437883168,
0.4976447821,
-0.2104449868,
0.069836311,
0.1215104014,
-0.0430135317,
-0.5634661317,
0.2046093345,
0.9145290256,
0.9352100492,
0.0272215717,
0.0378012247,
0.2487385422,
-0.0464803949,
0.213449955,
-0.0655267611,
-0.229098022,
-0.2370003611,
0.5625516176,
0.6312881112,
0.0075912774,
-0.7744751573,
0.6043573022,
-0.2139659226,
-0.1851554066,
-0.1026036441,
-0.0356771499,
0.2776280046,
0.3875904679,
0.2413130701,
0.0121792955,
-0.0485042818,
-0.4981968403,
0.0360261872,
0.7631190419,
-0.3187338114,
-0.3273336589,
0.7538250089,
0.0251589343,
-0.557790041,
0.7020334005,
0.0225277655,
-0.6067948341,
0.4826505482,
0.5983031988,
0.8844722509,
-0.1252851337,
-0.0172253363,
0.2849567533,
0.2065757811,
-0.5605745912,
0.1911234558,
0.0950920209,
-0.7696295381,
-0.8853958249,
-0.5474212766,
-0.3639809191,
0.052700147,
-0.7800533175,
0.3614774644,
-0.1305755973,
-0.1464742571,
0.1045569628,
-0.2401805967,
-0.3754881918,
-0.0264097434,
0.3032501638,
0.9931024909,
-0.8427191973,
0.6910378933,
0.7006467581,
-0.3090880811,
-1.1551170349,
0.2164662033,
0.1613610834,
-0.9460747838,
0.6293595433,
0.2975923717,
-0.1244233251,
-0.0540158413,
-1.0066584349,
-0.9049969316,
1.1751953363,
0.9778501391,
-0.5763238072,
-0.0076853512,
-0.0648199394,
0.4040623605,
-0.3591493666,
0.0442463122,
0.6098582745,
0.7319347858,
0.137476787,
-0.8579550385,
0.1303453743,
0.1150559187,
-0.0847149342,
0.102337338,
-0.35090065,
0.660669744,
-0.2328269333,
-0.3884859681,
0.3090111017,
0.6769983172,
0.6042929888,
0.3297070563,
0.574138999,
0.441575408,
0.9550668597,
-0.1748802513,
1.1848931313,
-0.0284883734,
0.3594369888,
0.8385090232,
-0.3512024581,
0.7422488332,
0.8794644475,
-0.1533567011,
0.4837675393,
0.8241136074,
0.1131495386,
0.2341801971,
0.1491034925,
-0.028250834,
-0.4294362366,
-0.2884369493,
0.0139177833,
0.1036185846,
0.1403028965,
-0.5108010769,
-0.0064856266,
-0.3987986147,
0.0264024325,
0.0231383815,
-0.2508918643,
0.9041315317,
0.1694241166,
-1.2264078856,
0.6177319288,
-0.0340137519,
0.4343807101,
-0.3227104247,
0.0416044965,
-0.0044359239,
-0.0211316328,
-0.3325147033,
-0.7586778998,
0.1716658026,
0.1069547683,
-0.3739116192,
-0.368620187,
0.7339958549,
-0.4662242234,
-0.2498662174,
0.0353907384,
0.3570981622,
0.0472965427,
0.1496531516,
-0.8198384643,
0.1932220608,
0.2348392904,
-0.4782838523,
0.1943810135,
0.4833669364,
-0.3389636278,
0.7946054339,
0.8280730247,
-0.0342453346,
0.1205614209,
0.167647481,
0.7084748149,
-0.648614347,
0.0828969628,
-1.3572838306,
0.6009092927,
-0.1278846413,
-0.2152429372,
0.8428065181,
0.4993008673,
0.5612772107,
0.1017575637,
0.5690228939,
0.3729023933,
0.3975441456,
-0.7954730988,
0.3631696999,
-0.4644904435,
0.4040474892,
0.0038591789,
-1.1647075415,
-0.2592049241,
0.7666195631,
-0.4023041129,
0.0462043323,
0.5141343474,
0.899285078,
0.0100373328,
0.1630135626,
0.0330446586,
-0.1835840642,
0.2024282813,
0.1311135143,
1.3447766304,
-0.0455357879,
0.2430907041,
0.0335638672,
-0.1405739486,
-0.2238518596,
-1.1741272211,
-0.7723945975,
-0.2544887364,
-0.2489250302,
-0.3783338666,
-0.1673400104,
1.3102281094,
0.3923622668,
-0.751090765,
-0.1455676258,
-0.2386572212,
0.2030569762,
-0.0304140896,
-0.2044758052,
0.26221928,
-0.3838314414,
-0.5917496681,
0.2985756993,
0.1699908078,
0.2724328339,
-0.4777836502,
-0.4683057964,
0.0510374419,
0.1828857958,
0.347025007,
0.1944381148,
-1.2213954926,
-0.3986181021,
0.1760738492,
-0.3448670208,
0.0282104984,
0.9356015325,
-0.5490610003,
0.2385354936,
0.6063631177,
0.5610551834,
-0.1967900246,
0.6065931916,
0.9257111549,
-0.4553047419,
-0.1927044988,
0.3115219176,
0.5449815392,
0.4953728616,
-0.209917143,
0.3654568791,
0.0574836098,
-0.843955636,
-1.0492603779,
0.2377613634,
-0.9921041131,
-0.0966963843,
1.4457033873,
-0.0824789256,
-0.3532628119,
-0.2409362495,
-0.4437759817,
0.2665799558,
-0.3567431569,
0.7333604693,
1.0067334175,
-0.1359197795,
0.009663146,
-0.4370375276,
0.4618330896,
0.7392539382,
-0.5804695487,
0.5543628931,
0.6697758436,
0.2003809661,
0.182843104,
0.3175641298,
-0.2632153928,
0.2218466848,
-0.4263511896,
-0.1010819227,
0.2024208754,
-0.0266743302,
-0.7211678624,
-0.1697655469,
0.5086266398,
0.2381878793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00211v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00211v1 | Detection and Measurement of Syntactic Templates in Generated Text | 2024-06-28T19:34:23 | 2024-06-28T19:34:23 | Chantal Shaib, Yanai Elazar, Junyi Jessy Li, Byron C. Wallace | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work on evaluating the diversity of text generated by LLMs has focused
on word-level features. Here we offer an analysis of syntactic features to
characterize general repetition in models, beyond frequent n-grams.
Specifically, we define syntactic templates and show that models tend to
produce templated text in downstream tasks at a higher rate than what is found
in human-reference texts. We find that most (76%) templates in model-generated
text can be found in pre-training data (compared to only 35% of human-authored
text), and are not overwritten during fine-tuning processes such as RLHF. This
connection to the pre-training data allows us to analyze syntactic templates in
models where we do not have the pre-training data. We also find that templates
as features are able to differentiate between models, tasks, and domains, and
are useful for qualitatively evaluating common model constructions. Finally, we
demonstrate the use of templates as a useful tool for analyzing style
memorization of training data in LLMs. | [
-0.1755803376,
-0.6422778368,
0.6706773639,
-0.0428726114,
-0.4962661564,
-0.0686419383,
-0.1374864131,
-0.1536769718,
0.3802250922,
0.5907884836,
-0.4360382557,
-0.7461092472,
-0.5372264981,
0.4123013318,
-0.922490716,
0.9947141409,
-0.2692828774,
0.1873201281,
-0.383225739,
-0.1466234773,
-0.252451092,
-0.8354141116,
-0.3062382042,
-0.1239320934,
0.4835862517,
-0.0356111489,
0.1366179138,
0.7453243732,
0.2891317904,
0.2449773103,
-0.1625509113,
0.1501200199,
-0.2850354612,
0.4193870425,
-0.0986787379,
-0.5724360347,
-0.6614528298,
0.1806980371,
0.9513281584,
0.6384577155,
-0.1916000247,
0.2725706995,
0.2652829885,
0.4539310634,
-0.4578053057,
-0.0570055023,
-0.8044759631,
0.1534332633,
-0.6545026302,
-0.3412806094,
-0.2221524715,
-0.1979934871,
-0.0780330896,
-0.4891328514,
0.5904048085,
0.0723540559,
0.6762773991,
-0.1581959575,
-0.4906746745,
-0.6259257793,
-0.6510556936,
0.847241044,
-0.5961440802,
0.4370621145,
-0.0350861885,
0.1471084803,
-0.2805720866,
-1.0623549223,
-0.8630161881,
-0.253995508,
-0.0518161394,
0.0911418796,
-0.3016648293,
-0.1889269054,
0.2751357257,
0.6044773459,
-0.5897858143,
0.1938981563,
-0.1611509174,
-0.2539053559,
0.4102933705,
0.5848193765,
0.5112481117,
-0.1193015128,
-0.1717635691,
-0.0868267938,
-0.7336779237,
-0.1869333237,
0.6042165756,
0.093399033,
-0.1622703075,
0.4951910377,
0.0682414174,
0.9044257402,
-0.3835185468,
-0.3716207743,
0.1701456457,
-0.8241860867,
-0.2057870924,
-0.3021533489,
0.7021202445,
0.1618041992,
0.5813201666,
-0.1496133804,
-0.4722560048,
-0.0304413326,
0.38520509,
-0.4853911996,
-0.1173226759,
-0.2657262087,
-0.466137141,
-0.4899911284,
0.00350272,
-0.262966603,
-0.3432371914,
-0.2739722133,
-0.0745297745,
-0.4424085319,
-0.1207769737,
0.1556155682,
-0.5279874802,
0.0798879564,
0.2752293646,
-0.7989339232,
0.2973825634,
0.7458899617,
0.8483841419,
-0.3543221354,
-0.413285315,
-0.1812586188,
0.1387506872,
-0.4450287521,
0.9058411121,
-0.3607328236,
-0.3811203837,
-0.0442162044,
-0.1473261416,
-0.1673013717,
-0.7941878438,
0.2383271903,
-0.0991037637,
0.3551675081,
-0.1733980924,
-0.9686231613,
0.0200120751,
0.2860721648,
-0.5885600448,
1.0157285929,
0.422055006,
-0.9086126685,
0.8212408423,
-0.1286967695,
-0.3748100996,
0.0332851224,
-0.4144611657,
-0.41595155,
0.4770652354,
-0.0500220992,
0.4579436779,
-0.3778558969,
0.268648684,
-0.3710866272,
-0.4074483514,
0.4188539088,
-0.2091000974,
0.2477957308,
0.1960881501,
-0.0010659735,
0.1615417898,
-0.9818400741,
-0.0530546643,
0.3688464165,
-0.6088027954,
-0.2437126637,
-0.1072589532,
0.2077508718,
0.0814962909,
0.1356535107,
-0.3071185648,
0.1877488941,
-0.151410684,
0.3352225423,
0.481834501,
0.3736973703,
0.0789168179,
-0.5936778188,
0.8785233498,
0.2967578173,
-0.2193342745,
-0.3495319486,
-0.3170621097,
-0.7922540307,
-0.2442882657,
0.0383562706,
0.2281106114,
-0.4149316251,
0.6330229044,
-0.1971451342,
-0.4951684475,
-0.3618758321,
0.5030920506,
0.5540308952,
0.3362744153,
0.225133121,
-0.7117723227,
-0.6835798025,
-0.9862405062,
-0.6910688877,
0.1044164225,
-0.1987562627,
0.0903041512,
0.5046938658,
0.1523569673,
0.9505971074,
-0.2878516316,
-0.1081145629,
-0.8120851517,
0.3334744871,
0.0611992925,
0.2854975462,
0.8857833147,
-0.449799031,
-0.4364743531,
-0.3621441722,
-0.8137227893,
-0.2838421166,
-0.1393684149,
0.3627789021,
0.2087542713,
0.7522076368,
-0.327783674,
0.431986481,
0.3171318173,
-0.1648634225,
0.6497728825,
-0.0967373773,
-0.214601174,
-1.2220343351,
0.2641913295,
0.1915714592,
-0.2110809684,
-0.7741328478,
-0.1716561913,
-0.0740021169,
-0.0115756765,
-0.4021862149,
0.7612917423,
-0.5553351045,
-0.3736810088,
-0.1774020642,
0.1606165618,
0.3547544777,
0.1138734519,
-0.1139161214,
0.946737349,
0.0790511146,
-0.4724437296,
0.2214813828,
-0.1398838758,
-0.7996180654,
0.4547333121,
-0.5337508917,
0.2847245932,
-0.1508944184,
0.356066972,
-0.9223188758,
-0.0022598435,
0.0997320563,
-0.2009341419,
0.169956252,
-0.2481167316,
-0.9255091548,
-0.1778525114,
-0.2366871536,
0.1546225995,
0.4167132378,
-0.0306229629,
0.202259168,
0.2766234279,
-0.0388234444,
-0.1324996352,
-0.3138065636,
0.0456356145,
-0.3354626,
-0.3986190557,
0.1212003008,
0.1841543764,
-0.1332755834,
-0.2487331927,
-0.1896679997,
0.1832914501,
0.5197472572,
0.0704464242,
0.0453145504,
-0.2983163595,
0.0311822891,
-0.109808363,
0.1610664725,
0.0284110084,
-0.4866759181,
1.0729970932,
0.0460943617,
-0.4696719348,
-0.3517589569,
0.2193097621,
0.3823061287,
-0.1932122856,
0.6085025072,
0.7383688092,
-0.3155043423,
-0.3038811982,
-0.4739756882,
0.0495936424,
-0.4486009777,
0.6003046632,
-0.2389544994,
-0.6893304586,
0.596144855,
0.2456422299,
-0.1420300305,
0.3793098927,
0.563041389,
-0.3244464993,
0.7186113596,
0.7368440032,
0.0820066035,
0.6883327961,
-0.030623449,
0.0940701216,
-0.8006601334,
-0.2154304981,
-0.4677682221,
-0.4696718752,
-0.5654343963,
-0.2599790096,
0.3955085278,
0.3214165568,
-0.1301869899,
0.1957127899,
-0.2975791097,
0.3587457836,
0.5948373675,
-0.2444004416,
0.158223033,
-0.0041986918,
-0.3722292483,
-0.2714023292,
-0.5760625005,
-0.7101004124,
1.1424775124,
0.2720220387,
0.6356078386,
-0.1930810064,
1.1557159424,
0.0654052868,
0.2759470344,
-0.5699570775,
0.7244622707,
-0.444616735,
-0.2811867297,
-0.0225346945,
-0.3171107173,
-0.9122712612,
-0.1236641482,
-0.3240666986,
-0.8384935856,
-0.171554178,
0.2656562924,
-0.0944720432,
0.4454505146,
-0.460729897,
0.8251982331,
-0.1760795414,
0.0724949017,
0.0167404413,
-0.0149853192,
0.1920614243,
-0.1116213426,
-0.2018706053,
-0.037208911,
-0.0030802155,
0.962857306,
-0.1053420827,
0.9046888351,
0.0965562537,
-0.2679089308,
0.3376681805,
0.2156172246,
0.3720927835,
-0.2807299197,
0.1526147872,
-0.0904616565,
-0.201417312,
-0.0804629698,
-0.6643162966,
0.4283650517,
-0.3222329617,
-0.5764907598,
-0.293699652,
-0.4916386306,
-0.0724084526,
0.3359930217,
0.4935445189,
0.4632352293,
-0.3310559392,
0.2258480191,
0.2741223276,
-0.3336006999,
0.2162765115,
0.2854427993,
-0.3572670221,
-0.1435378343,
0.922190547,
0.2246181667,
0.2737354338,
0.2148547769,
0.0870266259,
-0.0891275778,
-1.0951987505,
-0.1222834215,
0.181999892,
-0.8063749671,
-0.0367982574,
-0.8030038476,
-0.3492253125,
-0.4478610754,
-0.1065180451,
-0.1038059816,
-0.6137194037,
-0.5338739157,
-0.0776815265,
0.1792035401,
1.0836189985,
0.3650954962,
0.4795432091,
-0.9008374214,
0.0989839658,
0.0088172043,
0.1073135436,
0.0818659738,
-0.5424923897,
-0.1806429178,
-0.4301514924,
-0.4736306071,
-0.8203343749,
0.6175879836,
0.1419272274,
0.5894991159,
0.2973431349,
-0.5096443892,
0.2338647395,
-0.3203263283,
0.9574729204,
0.2286496311,
-0.9440800548,
0.5664698482,
-0.5499978662,
0.3599933982,
0.287599802,
0.3011506498,
-0.8202599883,
-0.7189390063,
-0.7153630853,
-0.8550699949,
0.3309204578,
-0.0390368327,
0.2702057958,
-0.3846840858,
0.5897351503,
0.007094563,
0.4878456891,
-0.6520105004,
-0.145013392,
-0.1414138079,
-0.3488624394,
-0.0257753599,
-0.4578614831,
-0.2063274384,
0.0941036418,
0.1375100762,
-0.0585848428,
-0.0164476726,
-0.1949997246,
-0.3143782616,
0.1277011186,
0.4918616414,
0.9060186744,
0.7456622124,
-0.2932217717,
0.0518807955,
0.0679314286,
-0.515902698,
-0.0080416901,
-0.3713311255,
-0.1396867782,
0.2666273713,
0.7727996111,
0.7103108764,
0.3438622355,
-0.3215478361,
0.4169975221,
0.0264656842,
-0.0489413776,
-0.4333930612,
0.4906930327,
0.2440804392,
-0.0323532745,
0.121377103,
-0.1506846845,
0.0436455905,
-0.6922930479,
0.3980497122,
0.4756222963,
-0.1971423924,
-0.5981431007,
0.3305630088,
0.1767629236,
-0.3758863211,
0.6530283689,
-0.2017665803,
-0.4948801994,
0.7886437774,
0.8546919227,
0.9080418348,
0.2152389437,
-0.0933927745,
0.2725965083,
0.071651198,
0.0454532057,
0.4586745799,
0.1571037471,
-0.9073787332,
0.2100744396,
-0.922113657,
-0.1979134381,
0.4488808811,
-0.9021788836,
0.4158838689,
-0.750076592,
-0.19864057,
0.2307349294,
-0.2322517037,
-0.9415040612,
0.1323341429,
0.2117636055,
0.9404032826,
-0.8601044416,
0.9434762597,
0.7165400386,
-0.3695348501,
-0.6007990241,
0.0276197474,
0.2779627144,
-1.0030075312,
0.9289126992,
0.2187152952,
-0.0350397788,
-0.0459871143,
-0.3988122344,
-0.4767836332,
1.2854981422,
0.2579855621,
-0.5549365282,
-0.3695023656,
0.1953871399,
0.6911652088,
-0.6657449603,
0.1028328612,
0.7626559734,
0.2312345654,
-0.4187923968,
-0.9792188406,
-0.0910652056,
-0.2208685726,
0.2996197641,
0.2344221175,
-0.2374698371,
1.0559533834,
0.0069514317,
-0.5184675455,
0.2018323392,
0.3969579935,
0.4422900975,
0.1702271849,
0.4455254674,
0.7240310311,
0.6728926897,
0.0341652893,
1.1895512342,
-0.2370125651,
0.2297599614,
1.1525969505,
-0.3794785738,
0.5295545459,
0.550935626,
-0.1259297878,
0.3906396031,
0.2591457367,
-0.2912172675,
0.174448818,
0.6582369804,
-0.1480056047,
-0.1876436323,
-0.2007294446,
-0.3554479182,
0.6418731213,
0.4166531265,
-0.6242271662,
-0.416534543,
-0.2044546753,
0.0631713644,
0.1868673116,
-0.0494942516,
1.0051976442,
0.345985651,
-0.4291251302,
0.4443339407,
0.0590565354,
0.7119919062,
-0.6910172701,
-0.0144015998,
-0.4469369352,
0.0281348508,
0.1308650672,
-0.8736154437,
0.2925001383,
0.1078440621,
-0.2953675389,
-0.3958566487,
0.5724245906,
-0.3638507128,
-0.439101696,
0.16227597,
0.7214536667,
0.0924585462,
0.1282826066,
-0.4513301849,
-0.0798036605,
-0.1349265277,
-0.265664041,
0.6777889729,
0.5931424499,
-0.022532925,
0.613594532,
0.5925431848,
0.4521262646,
0.1145711988,
0.3819596767,
0.7406064272,
-0.9698709846,
-0.4879615009,
-0.7798224092,
0.2667602003,
-0.0266803168,
-0.6101408005,
0.6543772817,
0.4973054528,
0.9944465756,
-0.1655992717,
0.854388237,
0.3230978549,
0.5013338923,
-0.9395790696,
0.8509165645,
-0.5752259493,
0.4069700837,
-0.1256623715,
-0.8701905608,
-0.1788216233,
0.4403666556,
-0.0961996987,
0.1387659758,
0.6652023792,
0.6910637021,
-0.2498783469,
-0.2617325187,
0.3014020026,
-0.2725608051,
0.4846705794,
0.2575659752,
0.9892138839,
-0.0865250155,
0.2755221725,
-0.0066283043,
0.3055420518,
-0.153080374,
-1.0839258432,
-0.8499119878,
-0.6964185238,
-0.1313001066,
-0.3280682266,
-0.1106850728,
0.7145186067,
0.3398721516,
-0.7239294648,
-0.3890017569,
-0.0071298713,
0.0149935856,
-0.0146598211,
-0.21604909,
0.0620781109,
-0.6074194908,
-0.4788491726,
0.4776097834,
0.3448010981,
0.5374562144,
-0.2015818506,
0.2603985369,
-0.0104058981,
0.0138065619,
0.1250651032,
0.0356696323,
-0.5909306407,
-0.2920027971,
0.0561451428,
-0.2819346786,
0.0907376707,
1.4969018698,
-0.4389430285,
0.3397144079,
0.5035142303,
0.1773071289,
0.2862074375,
-0.2132963389,
0.8768212795,
-1.2749356031,
0.2447481453,
0.2770513296,
0.7008010745,
0.3233688474,
0.001750407,
0.362716794,
0.5020166636,
-0.0580816418,
-0.9652489424,
0.4444198608,
-0.6971129179,
-0.1062976196,
1.0492655039,
-0.348557055,
-0.0027773178,
-0.0779779553,
0.3408356309,
0.3703295887,
0.0184109453,
0.5837801695,
0.8620760441,
-0.0597339235,
-0.1239092574,
-0.4934394956,
0.699852407,
0.2342385799,
-0.8575734496,
0.0280537512,
0.4140663743,
0.7087178826,
0.169588998,
0.8243153691,
-0.1599703431,
0.1557136923,
-0.056242723,
0.0251318831,
-0.2532474697,
-0.3363498151,
-0.3733851016,
-0.0734811649,
0.2003430575,
0.0319536515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00191v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00191v1 | MetaKP: On-Demand Keyphrase Generation | 2024-06-28T19:02:59 | 2024-06-28T19:02:59 | Di Wu, Xiaoxian Shen, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Traditional keyphrase prediction methods predict a single set of keyphrases
per document, failing to cater to the diverse needs of users and downstream
applications. To bridge the gap, we introduce on-demand keyphrase generation, a
novel paradigm that requires keyphrases that conform to specific high-level
goals or intents. For this task, we present MetaKP, a large-scale benchmark
comprising four datasets, 7500 documents, and 3760 goals across news and
biomedical domains with human-annotated keyphrases. Leveraging MetaKP, we
design both supervised and unsupervised methods, including a multi-task
fine-tuning approach and a self-consistency prompting method with large
language models. The results highlight the challenges of supervised
fine-tuning, whose performance is not robust to distribution shifts. By
contrast, the proposed self-consistency prompting approach greatly improves the
performance of large language models, enabling GPT-4o to achieve 0.548 SemF1,
surpassing the performance of a fully fine-tuned BART-base model. Finally, we
demonstrate the potential of our method to serve as a general NLP
infrastructure, exemplified by its application in epidemic event detection from
social media. | [
-0.0049925721,
-0.3981222808,
0.5794472098,
0.317073375,
-0.2900639474,
0.0383612923,
-0.0842666999,
-0.0966257676,
0.3483062088,
0.7460689545,
-0.6321733594,
-0.5652459264,
-0.5288524032,
0.370601058,
-0.290204674,
0.8100059628,
0.15274854,
-0.2334885299,
-0.05467638,
-0.0027219208,
-0.3859689832,
-0.2375408262,
-0.5193154216,
-0.2175981849,
0.5895416737,
0.6718733907,
0.6436392665,
0.6929673553,
0.5638567805,
0.0814013928,
0.2649576962,
0.2927415967,
-0.2873966098,
0.6958512068,
-0.1286632866,
-0.0091519263,
-0.3480547071,
-0.051467251,
0.304264158,
0.5418541431,
-0.0887769088,
0.1575845331,
0.2706217468,
0.6920983791,
-0.8146730065,
0.0676418543,
-0.8831544518,
0.1495062113,
-0.2764080167,
-0.369586736,
-0.1065585613,
-0.1403842121,
0.2272033393,
-0.5083803535,
0.3295820355,
-0.2279446721,
0.5065202713,
0.2942012846,
-0.2860051692,
-0.3197683394,
-0.1907088608,
0.3714411557,
-0.7113910317,
0.5586651564,
0.7368697524,
0.0889483243,
-0.2290726602,
-0.9848716855,
-0.1876783371,
-0.1591539681,
0.2419284731,
0.1647862643,
0.2453201711,
0.1208003908,
0.0146227954,
-0.1699955016,
-0.7160823345,
-0.1274742782,
-0.1363967359,
-0.1364011019,
0.3895861506,
0.0835925192,
0.1033229157,
-0.5509461164,
0.1657272875,
-0.1361354738,
-0.6998328567,
-0.1288932562,
-0.0708098337,
0.5537711382,
0.2002573162,
0.4617951214,
-0.5971583128,
0.3519101739,
0.2638201118,
-0.0297562722,
0.2922206819,
-0.5103049874,
0.0003857935,
0.1854839772,
0.8778873682,
0.5937678814,
0.0697561875,
-0.3313821852,
0.2138265371,
-0.1312593222,
0.3464959562,
-0.9319084287,
-0.470554322,
0.3800747395,
-0.5484780073,
-0.4951510429,
-0.2862539589,
-1.0769217014,
-0.2340670526,
0.0526406802,
0.3986855447,
-0.3689625561,
0.0600348115,
0.2163339555,
-0.2973999679,
-0.225765422,
-0.0117203686,
-1.0920650959,
-0.1214792654,
0.5945906639,
1.0863666534,
-0.284984678,
-0.3045093417,
-0.6125217676,
0.4132655859,
-0.3598006964,
0.7486488223,
-0.7463417053,
-0.3617002666,
0.1388521641,
-0.1077350974,
-0.0652273148,
-0.3351267576,
0.9158147573,
-0.1895339191,
-0.1238831505,
-0.5549921393,
-0.3481590152,
0.3254270554,
0.3034206331,
-0.3960564733,
0.9225575924,
0.0234771594,
-0.6783984303,
0.6805800796,
-0.7391683459,
-0.6157803535,
0.314648509,
-0.1797408164,
-0.4970533848,
0.2670479417,
0.500198245,
0.7982182503,
-0.1911481917,
0.3448930681,
-0.5857154131,
0.2064977586,
0.0188794024,
-0.2041226774,
0.2930191457,
0.4196808934,
-0.3608069718,
-0.2065557986,
-0.7739947438,
0.4033443332,
0.1058257297,
-0.3050453365,
-0.3690735698,
0.3886067569,
0.1198939458,
0.2560328245,
0.351947397,
-0.6467025876,
0.4701164365,
-0.4499883056,
0.7581406832,
0.4427706599,
0.272056669,
0.1797209531,
-0.0659093484,
0.3978679478,
-0.4307852089,
0.1957378536,
-0.3742227852,
-0.6743685007,
0.0389263108,
-0.1516616642,
0.2210718095,
0.3171848655,
-0.4392287135,
0.3197183311,
-0.4170881212,
-0.4353833795,
-0.4903568029,
0.3193535507,
0.2962480783,
0.3548288643,
0.5050829053,
0.009008375,
-0.5853069425,
-0.5718298554,
-0.3898536861,
0.1260000616,
-0.1738570929,
0.198037222,
0.2368403524,
-0.5313893557,
0.7813566327,
-0.5975345373,
-0.3723392487,
-0.2394524515,
0.4323633313,
0.2245029807,
0.3258484602,
0.2572296858,
-0.7279676199,
-0.7929916382,
-0.0896613002,
-0.6374937296,
-0.5466060042,
0.0789453909,
0.1409088373,
-0.3267706931,
0.7103338242,
-0.5203425288,
-0.0338388011,
0.6188579202,
-0.1230762303,
0.1764807105,
-0.4232385159,
0.302179575,
-1.2791934013,
0.2032563537,
-0.299351424,
-0.1300154626,
-0.6382288337,
0.0169581007,
0.1250734776,
-0.5049568415,
-0.1574520171,
0.4513367414,
-0.2522858381,
0.0186903551,
-0.4345095158,
-0.1378695071,
-0.1685296893,
0.0591164269,
-0.0132918581,
0.4486061931,
0.2417919487,
-0.5711095333,
0.0673745126,
0.3403137624,
-0.0599288568,
0.116835095,
-0.864377439,
0.0085192062,
0.1238441765,
0.3355835676,
-1.0409214497,
-0.5546107888,
0.0511210896,
-0.4158534408,
0.0112776197,
-0.0327018499,
-0.6602784395,
-0.5597683191,
-0.3953415751,
0.3215814531,
0.4036830962,
-0.3312959671,
0.3097496033,
0.2653973699,
-0.3032845557,
-0.2951247692,
-0.2132023722,
0.3519092798,
0.1230429709,
-0.6301956773,
0.4514579475,
0.098498404,
0.3126433492,
-0.2086481899,
-0.0830819234,
0.0926765203,
0.1391770542,
0.5455694795,
-0.2015482932,
0.0747002885,
0.1118893325,
0.2926769853,
-0.2073754072,
-0.2170471102,
-0.3850319982,
0.6192482114,
0.389243573,
-0.377826035,
-0.3200985193,
0.5003830791,
0.6861966252,
-0.2879288495,
0.1827007085,
0.4064560235,
-0.3101362884,
0.1024001241,
-0.2883372307,
-0.3483125567,
-0.5095129013,
0.3188740015,
-0.3348115385,
-0.5845989585,
0.1811715364,
-0.1098380014,
0.3493312597,
0.517075479,
0.5222809315,
-0.1088383645,
1.4141237736,
0.2778864205,
-0.1393660903,
0.2379401177,
0.0346849188,
0.1563692093,
-0.5011454821,
0.1306880563,
-0.6247857809,
-0.3382112682,
-0.730858624,
-0.1333302259,
0.6243216991,
0.061839018,
-0.0244109426,
0.3655818403,
-0.7274025679,
0.2786047161,
0.7648864985,
0.0628979653,
0.1982593089,
-0.1052397862,
-0.1595493704,
-0.1310005635,
-0.7382660508,
-0.3096646667,
1.6587414742,
-0.0035543137,
0.5891925097,
-0.3415207267,
0.7821756005,
0.5142877102,
-0.1028325632,
-0.2209182382,
0.3618099689,
-0.3542628586,
-0.7462661862,
-0.374761492,
-0.2620194256,
-1.3768287897,
0.0427560136,
-0.383910954,
-0.7082232237,
-0.0714934021,
0.3647103012,
-0.4810521007,
-0.1722382456,
-0.3181304038,
1.0813691616,
-0.1617278904,
-0.0323651806,
-0.1824345142,
-0.7918233275,
0.1324802488,
-0.1638746709,
0.0461019278,
-0.2956031263,
0.0325815044,
0.5415628552,
-0.2579357624,
0.6189377904,
-0.0822453275,
0.1999935508,
0.0159427132,
-0.1852169335,
0.7782872915,
0.0854374692,
-0.0262445323,
-0.0283117052,
0.1774985492,
-0.2785358429,
-0.240611881,
0.609605968,
-0.4196693003,
-0.1709449291,
-0.0664668083,
-0.4048667252,
-0.3516560197,
0.280513525,
0.8685597777,
0.4035468996,
-0.0917130262,
0.4284031093,
0.7110910416,
-0.0961072072,
0.4220018387,
0.392290324,
-0.0663278773,
-0.4786436856,
1.0393183231,
0.1411747783,
0.3027432561,
0.6401644945,
0.3998022676,
-0.3205792308,
-0.6062624454,
-0.2244761437,
0.0259483811,
-0.4090534151,
-0.1987267882,
-1.1009585857,
0.0275436733,
-1.1714888811,
-0.5069449544,
-0.5141499043,
-0.1736570895,
-0.2404870689,
0.2063162327,
0.1293446273,
0.3382125497,
-0.2792233825,
0.3282444775,
-1.1153506041,
0.7463102341,
0.3129733503,
0.1078082547,
-0.3079476655,
-0.3439576328,
-0.1702544391,
0.0530186929,
-0.6394649148,
-0.8940800428,
0.4229437113,
0.5916665196,
0.4499789476,
0.6982319951,
0.3942729533,
0.2483418733,
-0.7951028347,
0.5958471298,
0.1028553769,
-0.610797286,
0.8710890412,
-0.6079821587,
0.4865594804,
0.8357458115,
0.4717697799,
-0.8769487739,
-0.6475145221,
-0.7235280871,
-0.8346143365,
0.2518940866,
0.1387598068,
0.0702478513,
-0.2535924613,
0.3458090127,
0.1203631088,
0.2604889274,
-0.2860738337,
0.0133601762,
-0.403070122,
-0.5561950803,
-0.2103326023,
-0.1886074394,
0.1090976298,
0.0744161233,
0.569897294,
-0.3398219645,
0.1728128493,
0.2713064849,
0.0832647756,
-0.2409741729,
0.2590231001,
0.7146239281,
0.5179157257,
-0.3367199004,
0.0165724512,
-0.0677672327,
-0.7690714598,
0.0652829483,
0.2298943251,
-0.391992718,
0.1896573156,
0.3344340622,
0.395891279,
0.4287225902,
-0.8171241283,
0.5514563322,
0.1995139718,
-0.5447114706,
0.0977349952,
0.029502634,
0.0699679032,
0.2212876678,
0.634496212,
-0.4030155241,
0.3314841986,
-0.5588380098,
0.3978033066,
0.6483140588,
-0.0813772604,
-0.3889181316,
0.943046391,
0.2343873084,
-0.2471026331,
0.3770709634,
-0.0898863003,
-0.4594809711,
0.293382287,
0.4304867983,
1.077259779,
-0.3700472116,
0.4297069907,
0.3062136173,
0.2777865529,
-0.4172553122,
0.3144783676,
-0.0181080997,
-0.6249101758,
-0.200986445,
-0.6233794689,
-0.4226132929,
0.3402179778,
-0.3844657838,
0.1565781534,
-0.4077825844,
-0.2713164389,
0.3886449039,
-0.0106016751,
-0.3596854806,
0.1021852568,
-0.0963464156,
0.5921349525,
-0.9076972008,
0.616815865,
0.3751013279,
-0.1859588325,
-0.3972327709,
0.0747296959,
-0.1895605773,
-0.8886765242,
0.50586164,
0.3886850774,
0.4980667233,
0.1037073433,
-0.6032691002,
-1.0504653454,
0.8465259671,
0.1690947711,
-0.5367230773,
-0.3806454539,
0.2906672657,
0.3493066132,
-0.2669246793,
-0.3227947354,
0.3065540493,
0.4626770616,
-0.0392567553,
-0.8310530782,
0.0268508531,
0.156456694,
-0.182961911,
0.4292318523,
-0.2604902685,
0.570679605,
-0.087242648,
0.0217726231,
-0.0959998816,
0.4926615059,
0.2445301563,
0.4861620665,
0.2042760849,
0.6615763307,
0.521232307,
0.2133877128,
0.7338510156,
-0.5049703717,
0.1520881355,
1.1018556356,
-0.3156733215,
0.8604896665,
0.3092415631,
-0.0122135011,
-0.1561757922,
0.6164781451,
-0.0533198938,
0.9398061037,
-0.1352004409,
-0.0395309366,
-0.3519230783,
0.0368489176,
-0.4400887787,
0.3134405017,
0.3400809467,
-0.6206513643,
-0.4494501054,
0.4112564027,
-0.2670131028,
-0.2509696782,
-0.3709869981,
0.7334839106,
-0.1333786994,
-0.7892012,
0.3689911366,
-0.170896396,
0.3888888657,
-0.646884501,
0.1729177237,
0.0491216183,
0.2217897475,
0.0709350556,
-0.6517944336,
0.1126119718,
-0.2692673206,
-0.3145411313,
-0.3462780118,
0.8211106658,
-0.3297238648,
-0.4797867835,
0.0899063498,
0.2987616062,
0.216184631,
-0.4760792553,
-0.8130773306,
-0.2421554029,
0.0322366431,
-0.3295783401,
0.4567184746,
0.4615257978,
0.282504946,
0.621315062,
0.7065654397,
0.1759997159,
0.1481541246,
-0.1677448601,
0.4939756393,
-0.449398309,
-0.3972326219,
-0.8405348659,
0.0466071591,
-0.1425279081,
-0.7040219307,
0.6216689944,
0.5200694203,
0.4922678769,
-0.0593572445,
0.9253125787,
0.0655803457,
0.8438261151,
-0.3879027665,
0.5848113298,
-0.6743621826,
-0.3932556808,
-0.4791744947,
-0.6639985442,
-0.1507391632,
0.2432627827,
0.1357970536,
-0.3504098356,
0.602786839,
0.5238208175,
0.0804168284,
-0.0570414104,
0.3972175121,
-0.174386397,
0.3543203175,
0.2746191919,
0.2058756351,
-0.3031837642,
0.5664399862,
0.0601313226,
-0.0372826494,
-0.783663094,
-0.814804852,
-0.7216954231,
-0.7963343859,
-0.1100850776,
-0.222281307,
0.3031794429,
1.0418902636,
0.6485005021,
-0.6970110536,
0.1746727526,
-0.4751991928,
-0.17676498,
-0.2977976501,
-0.135844633,
0.2934390903,
-0.8100814819,
-0.3879213035,
0.4071817398,
0.3960775137,
-0.0021402012,
-0.0486517586,
0.1333842725,
-0.2408768535,
0.025359394,
0.4431946278,
0.5670736432,
-0.3995136917,
-0.0106342882,
0.2455043942,
-0.3797137737,
-0.0693497062,
0.8670773506,
-0.3038639724,
0.317468673,
0.6374076605,
1.0141390562,
0.5085895061,
-0.0278644599,
0.6862928271,
-0.5879172087,
-0.5326058269,
0.234907195,
0.1589583009,
0.0530805811,
-0.4013469815,
0.5072986484,
0.4323635995,
-0.8168845177,
-0.6941341162,
0.1748469323,
-0.7729831934,
-0.3805638254,
1.1781586409,
0.1374936402,
-0.0371868871,
-0.3044120371,
-0.0221597012,
0.1609017253,
-0.4988229573,
0.8879696131,
0.4496311843,
-0.0180840679,
0.0060958532,
-0.6911118627,
0.7626277804,
0.3776264787,
-0.7381767631,
0.432669729,
0.2887988091,
0.2600293159,
0.2201019526,
0.9386124015,
0.2905688882,
0.3127780557,
-0.1331072599,
-0.0098099634,
0.2433430403,
-0.3802496791,
0.1790524274,
0.4723460078,
-0.2734297216,
-0.271887809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00167v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00167v1 | Can GPT-4 Help Detect Quit Vaping Intentions? An Exploration of Automatic Data Annotation Approach | 2024-06-28T18:06:48 | 2024-06-28T18:06:48 | Sai Krishna Revanth Vuruma, Dezhi Wu, Saborny Sen Gupta, Lucas Aust, Valerie Lookingbill, Wyatt Bellamy, Yang Ren, Erin Kasson, Li-Shiun Chen, Patricia Cavazos-Rehg, Dian Hu, Ming Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.ET, cs.HC, cs.SI | In recent years, the United States has witnessed a significant surge in the
popularity of vaping or e-cigarette use, leading to a notable rise in cases of
e-cigarette and vaping use-associated lung injury (EVALI) that caused
hospitalizations and fatalities during the EVALI outbreak in 2019, highlighting
the urgency to comprehend vaping behaviors and develop effective strategies for
cessation. Due to the ubiquity of social media platforms, over 4.7 billion
users worldwide use them for connectivity, communications, news, and
entertainment with a significant portion of the discourse related to health,
thereby establishing social media data as an invaluable organic data resource
for public health research. In this study, we extracted a sample dataset from
one vaping sub-community on Reddit to analyze users' quit-vaping intentions.
Leveraging OpenAI's latest large language model GPT-4 for sentence-level quit
vaping intention detection, this study compares the outcomes of this model
against layman and clinical expert annotations. Using different prompting
strategies such as zero-shot, one-shot, few-shot and chain-of-thought
prompting, we developed 8 prompts with varying levels of detail to explain the
task to GPT-4 and also evaluated the performance of the strategies against each
other. These preliminary findings emphasize the potential of GPT-4 in social
media data analysis, especially in identifying users' subtle intentions that
may elude human detection. | [
-0.2770230174,
-1.0206807852,
1.1687413454,
-0.0941127241,
-0.28037256,
-0.2697667778,
-0.1443644315,
-0.3342641294,
0.3447209895,
0.3519612551,
-0.4405963421,
-0.6518403292,
-0.4746566117,
0.1894759983,
-0.2670343816,
1.1298840046,
-0.3757420778,
-0.299739182,
0.0708361715,
0.0888950899,
-0.6337398887,
-0.487166822,
-1.1420418024,
0.0699238554,
0.8690938354,
0.2980478406,
0.086602971,
-0.2644595206,
0.1364176869,
0.2674046159,
0.1751230806,
-0.0650597513,
-0.4967823029,
-0.0357419364,
0.1982868463,
-0.4061677754,
-0.231235832,
0.1222898066,
0.2919599116,
-0.05042243,
-0.1839940399,
0.2956208885,
-0.1016922817,
0.430906117,
-0.2909556925,
-0.0690009221,
-0.4246453047,
-0.0659148172,
-0.395367533,
-0.4496076703,
-0.1489041001,
-0.2854077816,
-0.2058385164,
-0.7556067705,
0.350834012,
-0.2800752521,
0.9400192499,
0.3871685266,
-0.3835784793,
-0.1254366338,
-0.8498266935,
0.1822961569,
-0.6572285295,
0.3209523261,
0.5844202042,
0.491460979,
0.0006898185,
-0.506706059,
-0.6270917654,
0.248875007,
-0.0224374495,
0.1878371835,
-0.4148215353,
0.0756760612,
0.2966380715,
0.1108466536,
-0.6206778884,
-0.1062889099,
-0.4825203121,
-0.0609122552,
0.5319449902,
-0.0697921887,
0.5642213821,
-0.2228057981,
-0.2656235397,
0.4373075366,
-0.6577745676,
0.1978208423,
0.507486701,
-0.1938008517,
-0.1038589478,
0.4239211977,
-0.189290002,
0.318801254,
0.0426706932,
0.2035280466,
0.2582427263,
-0.7860091925,
-0.3580753207,
0.0331245549,
1.1403393745,
0.6174244285,
0.3149249852,
0.2281807363,
0.0239944942,
-0.1569707543,
0.2932260036,
-0.8894848228,
-0.5119401813,
0.4774041176,
-0.7135952711,
-0.3737230301,
0.0599332005,
-0.6024978161,
-0.1159460098,
-0.1452328861,
0.3878178,
-0.39100191,
-0.2539375424,
0.0955844149,
-0.3764209747,
-0.1610486656,
0.435914427,
-0.8950800896,
0.3682413399,
0.5321861506,
1.1565892696,
0.1140643656,
0.1776517332,
-0.5098022819,
0.0150442021,
-0.2704688609,
0.7173333764,
-0.395552218,
-0.2446495295,
-0.1224727556,
0.0678888261,
0.0592847578,
-0.1846166551,
0.769975245,
-0.3130242527,
0.2754097283,
-0.6311740875,
-0.3567247391,
-0.5004122257,
0.5644876361,
-0.7386183739,
0.7511202097,
-0.0767486691,
-0.5778257847,
0.6902541518,
-0.7064545155,
-0.177715838,
0.470084697,
-0.5632101297,
-0.6212586164,
0.0730147883,
0.4263398945,
0.5801925659,
-0.0562747531,
0.2650786638,
-0.265286684,
-0.2869349718,
0.1541291177,
-0.6602789164,
0.7416235805,
-0.0306849107,
-0.4928798974,
0.2675626278,
-0.1315685809,
-0.0562685616,
0.1002462059,
0.0031981335,
-0.5497227311,
-0.158818379,
0.1047010794,
0.4957797229,
0.063078396,
-0.630949676,
0.2708843052,
0.0814558715,
0.6610432267,
0.6262831688,
0.8313250542,
-0.4289214313,
-0.2331376076,
0.7913894653,
-0.2908001542,
0.4901738167,
-0.0945838168,
-1.0809335709,
-0.0200258326,
-0.2330761254,
0.1452536583,
0.1847952306,
-0.6771795154,
0.481610626,
-0.1378901899,
-0.4246062636,
-0.3286878169,
0.1190521121,
0.2156215608,
0.5133468509,
0.4300628901,
-0.1554889083,
-0.3669362366,
-0.7483587265,
-0.2239903659,
-0.3672956824,
-0.1265742034,
0.346765399,
0.4029909372,
-0.2239868045,
0.6640386581,
-0.3532960117,
-0.446960032,
-0.0970100835,
0.2922305167,
-0.0364171341,
-0.2443923652,
0.6592506766,
-0.977273047,
-0.6557629704,
0.2505314946,
-0.6498066187,
-0.274055928,
-0.3906101286,
-0.0796713158,
-0.0125815254,
0.1471441388,
-0.525998354,
0.7735770941,
0.4959477186,
-0.3532189131,
0.512779057,
-0.1232438833,
0.721862793,
-0.6319433451,
0.0427146293,
0.3256748617,
-0.0771028548,
-0.74851197,
-0.7969073057,
0.0722297505,
0.140067786,
-0.4386629462,
0.5053637028,
-0.0599503815,
0.2017755657,
-0.1770116687,
-0.3234430254,
0.1012273207,
0.1468894482,
0.0651560053,
0.4857314527,
0.2094936967,
-0.3312631845,
-0.0180760417,
0.2162478268,
0.0126951672,
0.5697593689,
-0.6054677963,
-0.0711706728,
0.1083372012,
0.5359807014,
-1.0229449272,
-0.485247463,
0.8056473136,
-0.6399002671,
-0.0237026121,
-0.2576338053,
-0.3168821335,
-0.4845565856,
-0.4101090431,
0.5378128886,
0.4141283035,
-0.258952111,
0.287006855,
0.2599018514,
-0.1121461093,
-0.0482246839,
-0.524840951,
0.2654772997,
-0.555190742,
-0.3918021619,
0.2656357884,
0.0380583331,
-0.0090484349,
0.1150737777,
-0.0207342766,
-0.0115741165,
-0.2222932726,
0.3034156859,
0.1167814583,
0.3748146594,
0.2294360548,
-0.0628453568,
-0.1240707859,
0.3754550517,
-0.1237185672,
0.3399412632,
-0.0378903598,
-0.2775613666,
-0.9596321583,
0.318023771,
0.2423674613,
-0.0229271967,
0.3485658467,
0.7241312265,
-0.5957077146,
0.192248866,
-0.6984455585,
-0.0712559074,
-0.4826753438,
-0.0700670257,
-0.1841963232,
-0.5033031702,
0.3034751713,
0.126894474,
-0.0959511325,
0.3054019511,
0.7047725916,
-0.0879557431,
0.8606162667,
0.1632418036,
-0.0552543104,
0.4866129458,
-0.2078341246,
0.4423585832,
-0.5909765363,
-0.2587524354,
-0.1495772302,
-0.3091972172,
-0.3711400628,
-0.2878857255,
0.5413373709,
-0.2701613307,
-0.1468023509,
0.1364257336,
-0.8643257618,
0.3329048753,
0.3250932992,
0.3950952291,
0.1837238967,
-0.1507668644,
0.3998253345,
-0.1450280547,
-0.4046520591,
-0.5116380453,
1.163010478,
0.2750687599,
0.1389554441,
0.0497938357,
0.9735392928,
0.3041858673,
0.3076447248,
-0.6637752652,
0.2524929345,
0.0645080134,
-0.5306718946,
-0.3916319013,
-0.4543033838,
-1.0522894859,
-0.2225386947,
0.021683991,
-0.7083385587,
0.112558201,
0.27422598,
-0.5261982083,
0.2824769914,
-0.7822220922,
0.9774433374,
-0.8347684145,
-0.1538435817,
0.2799367905,
-0.3894980252,
0.5484817028,
-0.3538480401,
0.4099274278,
-0.1728748977,
-0.0714040473,
0.926451683,
-0.3213686347,
0.6898585558,
-0.3854461014,
0.1890587211,
0.5600417852,
-0.3235045671,
0.4889307618,
0.2555949092,
0.1750276685,
0.5927303433,
-0.1748044789,
-0.1110378057,
-0.5520172119,
0.6419885159,
-0.4813225269,
-0.1347021013,
-0.2069168091,
0.121697925,
0.1204397157,
0.3663160801,
0.5623520613,
0.0432231054,
-0.333249718,
-0.1637712568,
0.4583755434,
-0.1305776238,
0.2652822733,
0.0537747815,
-0.1122555137,
-0.3555402756,
0.8901549578,
0.2772297561,
-0.0570870973,
0.0917025283,
0.5348202586,
-0.1521948278,
-0.6368951201,
-0.1618652493,
0.2713873684,
-0.3780382574,
-0.1071220264,
-0.6019036174,
0.1090811864,
-0.3369376063,
-0.2159434706,
-0.0572111942,
0.1174686477,
-0.088554427,
-0.4244951308,
0.6408177614,
1.0742672682,
0.0770025402,
0.098515898,
-0.659730792,
0.4135808349,
0.291431427,
0.158445552,
-0.2910884917,
0.0675849169,
-0.0763305277,
-0.1304696649,
-0.2592814565,
-1.1688864231,
0.4372244775,
-0.0028589519,
0.5500720739,
0.6701153517,
-0.0051405602,
0.5181819201,
-0.49832353,
1.0617998838,
0.3311321735,
-0.5848706365,
0.6124140024,
-0.8949065804,
0.2214455754,
0.7803291678,
0.7563351989,
-0.8748980761,
-0.2489316016,
-0.8920975327,
-0.9062564373,
0.1955550015,
0.618573606,
-0.2305942625,
-0.190102458,
0.4224282205,
0.309720099,
0.2681209445,
-0.5904654264,
-0.2048300803,
-0.458865732,
-0.4117570519,
0.129282847,
-0.1582478285,
-0.2561535239,
-0.3586545587,
0.6332070231,
0.0060243751,
0.5420310497,
0.0290665142,
0.4670497477,
-0.1909308434,
0.1100911275,
0.4435250461,
0.5352495909,
-0.2347828448,
-0.0934649408,
-0.1959676743,
-0.4780291617,
0.2261777073,
0.0528368801,
-0.4595012367,
0.0356563851,
0.127416119,
0.6709375381,
0.1462460309,
-0.406719923,
0.6744155884,
-0.4526873529,
-0.5115349293,
-0.5003281832,
-0.0471645966,
0.0955334827,
-0.1760378629,
0.2148277611,
-0.1963723451,
0.5574236512,
-0.3161508739,
0.3042867184,
0.413115412,
-0.3782838881,
-0.6857495904,
0.8301547766,
0.2633901238,
-0.2434640527,
0.1952879727,
-0.2032484561,
-0.5950896144,
0.5092768669,
0.0977235511,
1.0981640816,
-0.2610399425,
0.448174119,
0.5862789154,
0.3974077404,
-0.1662535667,
0.2036195248,
-0.0329712443,
-0.3879788518,
-0.1296391934,
-0.0456870534,
-0.1501489729,
0.6167203188,
-0.4978494644,
0.5568851829,
-0.3605653346,
-0.1522941142,
0.2977300584,
-0.0821490809,
-1.0322687626,
0.2353263646,
0.1627402902,
0.1696523577,
-1.2803859711,
0.5358318686,
0.6495500803,
-0.6730514169,
-0.8504011035,
0.3967534602,
0.5692529678,
-0.2838169336,
0.3644993901,
0.728974402,
0.1092667282,
-0.2840425968,
-0.5043312311,
-0.4875041842,
1.0836775303,
-0.0196450092,
-0.6092903614,
-0.0573640689,
-0.1718155891,
0.5150002241,
-0.3117808402,
0.4402075112,
0.6017727852,
0.7826708555,
-0.059647277,
-0.8341628909,
0.2468111068,
-0.2480025738,
-0.133793503,
0.3625165224,
-0.5548482537,
0.6347500086,
0.1642753929,
-0.3242252171,
-0.5281825662,
0.0059065889,
0.0977393091,
0.7774254084,
0.6539846659,
0.654430747,
0.8062261939,
0.1425163895,
0.9150795341,
0.0831066296,
0.3121410012,
0.9402611256,
-0.0988728181,
0.7044531107,
0.2904804051,
-0.0805632174,
0.3549118638,
0.8366427422,
0.2757804394,
0.5202322602,
-0.2410458922,
-0.5106284022,
-0.160604015,
0.3596927822,
-0.2768401504,
0.1716623753,
0.7980203032,
-0.4470191002,
-0.0959632695,
0.15019539,
0.0545644686,
-0.3102915585,
-0.0888307393,
0.7871135473,
-0.1645700634,
-0.5816663504,
0.4822494984,
-0.4580697417,
0.5256186128,
-0.4612551332,
-0.2676486075,
0.2887890637,
-0.3966653049,
-0.4408370554,
-0.6531082392,
0.3034888208,
0.0318078473,
0.1708485484,
-0.3227718174,
0.8591154814,
-0.4458902478,
-0.4880872965,
0.1692558527,
0.2183863074,
0.4431708455,
-0.2997121513,
-0.7558991909,
0.0967012122,
0.0971154943,
-0.5155103207,
0.010756528,
0.6316332221,
-0.1510551125,
0.1772088557,
0.7089518905,
0.2588965297,
-0.1909766644,
-0.0580695793,
0.6784640551,
-0.6151092649,
-0.4514143467,
-0.7935040593,
0.5111542344,
-0.3393450975,
-0.4193316698,
0.899653852,
0.3226266503,
0.8014109135,
0.3261423409,
1.3438267708,
-0.1978434324,
0.3619533479,
-0.5609760284,
0.6058496833,
-0.3130671084,
0.2135630846,
-0.0245854389,
-0.62104249,
-0.2027575523,
0.5247712731,
-0.6899053454,
0.3857581615,
0.6713207364,
0.2671562433,
0.0381895714,
-0.1003372222,
0.1596784294,
-0.0122241722,
0.8002784252,
0.2515696287,
0.2156249881,
-0.3374502063,
0.4110355973,
-0.1864750534,
-0.3833933473,
-0.4720048904,
-0.6951721311,
-0.9865323305,
-0.5790333748,
-0.3487048745,
-0.2291303426,
0.1373104006,
0.6339328289,
0.341121912,
-0.3117066622,
0.4908546209,
-0.4261453748,
-0.2149056643,
-0.2489141971,
-0.2433261573,
0.3282605708,
-0.0236271806,
-0.368055582,
0.2465391606,
0.3049406111,
-0.1831729561,
-0.2458998561,
0.0115539301,
-0.342477113,
-0.1238866225,
0.3386975229,
0.6217516065,
-0.7972670794,
-0.4432119727,
-0.1815380007,
0.0765497461,
0.1693933606,
0.8948178887,
-0.6980512142,
0.8221125603,
0.5011908412,
0.3851926029,
0.6960770488,
0.4231837392,
0.4509662986,
-0.7800016999,
-0.3326712847,
0.2976051569,
0.2610765696,
0.3583651483,
-0.8937042356,
0.4342085719,
0.106993176,
-0.99336344,
-0.3354915082,
-0.0066675604,
-0.9745919108,
-0.1455192268,
1.4822427034,
-0.0117314374,
-0.3264143169,
-0.5810216665,
-0.5635790229,
0.148563996,
-0.8440346122,
0.6665338278,
0.747736156,
-0.4994463921,
-0.2350229025,
-1.3150670528,
0.7243945003,
-0.0930395573,
-1.1165012121,
0.0312865637,
0.6039313674,
0.3512945771,
0.0147390487,
1.3708568811,
0.2262942642,
0.4924530685,
-0.3229575455,
0.1318682432,
-0.3324512839,
-0.2437392324,
-0.4030112028,
-0.2009973675,
-0.2693782747,
-0.3393297493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20098v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20098v1 | Web2Code: A Large-scale Webpage-to-Code Dataset and Evaluation Framework for Multimodal LLMs | 2024-06-28T17:59:46 | 2024-06-28T17:59:46 | Sukmin Yun, Haokun Lin, Rusiru Thushara, Mohammad Qazim Bhat, Yongxin Wang, Zutao Jiang, Mingkai Deng, Jinhong Wang, Tianhua Tao, Junbo Li, Haonan Li, Preslav Nakov, Timothy Baldwin, Zhengzhong Liu, Eric P. Xing, Xiaodan Liang, Zhiqiang Shen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have shown impressive success across
modalities such as image, video, and audio in a variety of understanding and
generation tasks. However, current MLLMs are surprisingly poor at understanding
webpage screenshots and generating their corresponding HTML code. To address
this problem, we propose Web2Code, a benchmark consisting of a new large-scale
webpage-to-code dataset for instruction tuning and an evaluation framework for
the webpage understanding and HTML code translation abilities of MLLMs. For
dataset construction, we leverage pretrained LLMs to enhance existing
webpage-to-code datasets as well as generate a diverse pool of new webpages
rendered into images. Specifically, the inputs are webpage images and
instructions, while the responses are the webpage's HTML code. We further
include diverse natural language QA pairs about the webpage content in the
responses to enable a more comprehensive understanding of the web content. To
evaluate model performance in these tasks, we develop an evaluation framework
for testing MLLMs' abilities in webpage understanding and web-to-code
generation. Extensive experiments show that our proposed dataset is beneficial
not only to our proposed tasks but also in the general visual domain, while
previous datasets result in worse performance. We hope our work will contribute
to the development of general MLLMs suitable for web-based content generation
and task automation. Our data and code will be available at
https://github.com/MBZUAI-LLM/web2code. | [
-0.4126002789,
-0.4248456955,
0.1190844402,
0.3703280091,
-0.2106480598,
-0.0762380287,
-0.5255057216,
-0.1397948712,
-0.5721955895,
0.2967363596,
-0.5026885867,
-0.6051462889,
-0.3821427226,
0.0771602392,
-0.5381037593,
0.7169160843,
0.0387706533,
0.2896876633,
-0.5735808611,
-0.0305265468,
-0.0938299,
-0.3940967321,
-0.4667045474,
0.1031425297,
0.5151048303,
0.1939255893,
0.3014973104,
0.5376576185,
0.6518961787,
0.2384191006,
0.3095307648,
0.490678817,
-0.7576434612,
0.0294693969,
-0.221907109,
-0.490557909,
-0.2982747555,
-0.2032913119,
0.6767343879,
0.4786222279,
0.0476861969,
0.5711557269,
0.0882981867,
0.694421649,
-0.7603662014,
0.2975873947,
-0.5600327253,
0.0999231189,
0.1461208314,
-0.3242202699,
-0.6808115244,
-0.3029546142,
-0.2622211576,
-0.4988791645,
0.1845902503,
0.1681536436,
0.5646755099,
0.2153199911,
-0.658521533,
-0.3061540425,
-0.2816448808,
0.7712404132,
-0.6415794492,
0.7240909934,
0.4650069177,
0.2970185876,
-0.0628326386,
-0.6795170903,
-0.6544640064,
-0.2969577312,
0.1936880052,
0.0456431583,
-0.291038394,
-0.2192996591,
0.2874322534,
0.0970697924,
-1.0003777742,
0.4440214932,
-0.245127067,
-0.1328195781,
0.4910776019,
0.2315776944,
0.3102531433,
-0.2013754845,
-0.330588609,
-0.3535781503,
-0.6791998148,
0.1222879887,
0.3407543898,
0.1223209202,
-0.3267671168,
0.5096145272,
-0.1156312227,
0.7285801768,
-0.2103010863,
-0.2762712538,
0.2214234322,
-0.2746857107,
-0.1005983651,
-0.4476418793,
0.6428132057,
1.1183614731,
0.4274743497,
-0.1260740012,
-0.3602264225,
0.2469270825,
0.344525367,
-1.1506830454,
-0.1627273113,
0.2130833864,
-0.7076003551,
-0.0765355155,
0.0586270653,
-0.8679802418,
-0.5062749982,
-0.3960572183,
0.1946686208,
-0.2504841387,
-0.194759801,
-0.1636879593,
-0.2550087869,
0.3474736214,
0.3244417608,
-0.7522827983,
0.0532015935,
0.4677386284,
0.5033588409,
-0.4846151471,
-0.3080918193,
-0.4851819277,
0.054670237,
-0.4750248194,
0.7065774798,
-0.43665573,
-0.2186324298,
0.4356653094,
-0.1385654807,
0.05106939,
-0.6511983275,
0.0209998619,
-0.6591334939,
-0.1510234773,
0.0162416399,
-0.5394077301,
-0.1096343771,
0.3870727122,
-0.7704268694,
0.655477941,
0.1052304655,
-0.3505674899,
0.1614361554,
-0.5022045374,
-0.5630311966,
-0.2487339377,
-0.22601749,
-0.2550818622,
0.0284522921,
0.2410868704,
0.5656729341,
-0.4693122506,
-0.0494292714,
-0.3023254573,
-0.4479609728,
0.6146036386,
-0.7734968066,
0.4250024855,
0.2173957527,
-0.2903181911,
-0.0071930448,
-1.0045387745,
0.4668257236,
0.1317566633,
-0.7784569263,
0.3116423488,
0.0637955442,
0.5049538016,
0.2411609143,
0.2118613571,
-0.1141296625,
0.2681010664,
0.1815005392,
0.3509237766,
0.7394295335,
-0.2117341459,
0.2606912851,
-0.1484997571,
0.4738713205,
-0.0845021009,
0.1761642545,
-0.390306443,
-0.2337857187,
-0.8927949667,
0.0602907762,
0.1471144408,
0.5749240518,
-0.9451602697,
0.1466040015,
-0.5047311187,
-0.1717157811,
-0.2947440743,
0.6197034121,
0.8928447366,
0.0847787857,
0.4594056606,
-0.3797720969,
-0.5760051608,
-0.9344402552,
0.0511157513,
0.1418311596,
-0.3151754141,
0.3044548035,
0.3103064895,
-0.4928456843,
0.6814643145,
-0.2110168934,
-0.0688190609,
-0.2638914883,
0.1141447276,
-0.0728218853,
0.4441308081,
0.2828462124,
-0.7649041414,
-0.3122348487,
0.0159808677,
-0.8751008511,
0.0658856332,
0.0306305382,
0.0579729043,
0.2453668416,
0.2434816062,
-0.3610518873,
0.2387334406,
0.8583515882,
-0.1415352821,
0.5514809489,
-0.0946314782,
0.3747968674,
-0.8909434676,
0.1608566642,
0.26835832,
-0.2863771617,
-0.4317528903,
0.2645753622,
0.4741268754,
-0.1967315227,
-0.5915267467,
0.3621989489,
-0.697335124,
-0.5022675991,
-0.2401790619,
0.1456545442,
0.1701669395,
0.7831153274,
-0.2910957336,
1.0833277702,
0.2228629142,
-0.6206580997,
0.6241127849,
0.1873748302,
-0.5695084333,
0.5440095067,
-0.1497555077,
0.3735004961,
-0.0341820419,
0.3179371059,
-0.8661829829,
-0.2861810327,
-0.1625099927,
-0.3445568383,
0.3667965829,
-0.2626737058,
-0.7757307887,
-0.4915860593,
-0.4199987352,
0.234366104,
0.5551224351,
-0.5223274827,
0.2067508399,
0.1182436273,
-0.0320245624,
-0.3801209331,
-0.6075666547,
0.2155810446,
0.148775965,
-0.554525435,
0.2096615732,
-0.1639886498,
-0.1794944406,
-0.1564832628,
-0.050739266,
-0.3691347539,
-0.0189978592,
0.2626338303,
0.2035509199,
-0.3540377021,
0.1171647236,
0.0763649791,
-0.0063349237,
0.1433408856,
-0.1595300883,
0.6603582501,
-0.0428539701,
-0.6184917092,
-0.6444475055,
0.2066862881,
0.4789106846,
-0.4739845991,
0.230307892,
0.895057857,
-0.1528652757,
-0.3608023226,
-0.5641199946,
0.0206397809,
-0.4365280867,
0.7123298049,
-0.3679142296,
-0.7118142247,
0.1719344854,
-0.2429154813,
0.1475777626,
0.1804573536,
0.7382314801,
-0.5010057092,
0.960048914,
0.3311643302,
0.1320176274,
0.3377625048,
-0.5177901983,
-0.1861133724,
-0.9092619419,
-0.2505717874,
-0.2333733588,
-0.4264796674,
-0.3828459978,
-0.9310501814,
0.307351917,
0.2559605539,
-0.0649454147,
0.1754277349,
-0.2376428694,
0.3994485736,
0.4256234467,
0.259115696,
0.1713740379,
0.1403230429,
0.107537277,
0.1609327197,
-0.5387944579,
-0.5961365104,
1.4993851185,
0.1594619006,
0.9356921911,
0.4185810387,
0.1110401452,
0.6395660043,
0.2280233502,
-0.4473287463,
0.5320630074,
-0.4045273364,
-0.3529072106,
-0.2090975642,
-0.3491001427,
-0.9346382618,
0.2725031078,
-0.1297137737,
-0.5190659761,
-0.1904589385,
0.2951563001,
-0.2016716599,
0.1219603345,
-0.7675711513,
0.9347800016,
-0.5883832574,
-0.7652278543,
-0.5566615462,
-0.5429768562,
0.2319099605,
0.12053556,
0.2823151946,
-0.1794974059,
-0.0282998923,
0.5588197708,
0.0712452009,
0.891692698,
-0.2545131147,
-0.328612715,
0.2173517495,
0.0409149826,
0.3969478309,
0.0705924556,
-0.1502637714,
0.0281454027,
-0.0491777174,
-0.383621037,
-0.7079166174,
0.5203812718,
-0.6810132265,
-0.2154321969,
0.2868081033,
-0.4882689714,
-0.5298998952,
-0.2002290189,
0.0859980211,
0.8748940825,
-0.0074449927,
0.4778038263,
0.7016002536,
-0.4749076366,
0.6171589494,
0.5441750884,
-0.4537435174,
-0.3673215508,
1.0951858759,
-0.3512951136,
0.2129257768,
0.5743231177,
-0.3518590331,
-0.4104831219,
-0.6278888583,
-1.0541075468,
-0.3263051808,
-0.9642211795,
-0.4325081408,
-0.2661168277,
-0.1111494899,
-0.3975476921,
0.0645354763,
-0.1914410144,
-0.0793599561,
-0.3778645396,
0.1276301146,
0.1368386596,
0.7765062451,
0.1136491895,
0.0379511714,
-0.9631959796,
0.5020004511,
0.4340001941,
0.2909953892,
0.1268153191,
-0.4395670593,
-0.4438127577,
0.0927151144,
-0.373924464,
-0.7017311454,
0.156667918,
0.2337981462,
0.6628093719,
0.5514877439,
-0.324321866,
0.7631444931,
-0.6188991666,
0.6837183237,
0.4282096624,
-0.7853189111,
0.4034538269,
-0.2007894367,
0.3562797308,
0.3506997824,
0.2828736901,
-0.4164552987,
-0.0476314686,
0.0955297947,
-0.5498668551,
0.3215356469,
0.1059435681,
0.3772725463,
0.1829728633,
0.0469951741,
0.2052726001,
0.297437489,
-0.6525218487,
-0.1554155052,
-0.2923293114,
-0.3042463958,
-0.0424556248,
-0.4250108004,
0.0213784631,
-0.0584392585,
0.2471579909,
-0.5472390056,
0.40505597,
-0.2181956619,
-0.8623555899,
0.0468270369,
0.291736424,
0.7459724545,
1.1046899557,
0.0253760815,
0.2072734833,
0.1446343213,
-0.2242979854,
0.1897983104,
0.1738408208,
0.1943929493,
-0.3368981183,
0.7759922147,
0.9412514567,
0.4747632742,
-1.163320303,
0.6897721291,
0.0442219339,
0.0080001885,
-0.1274466068,
0.2030019015,
0.1147184968,
0.2385805696,
0.5080443621,
-0.1868675649,
0.2045765519,
-0.5265514255,
0.3548255265,
0.2802103758,
-0.1646227986,
-0.330091238,
0.339401871,
0.4775906503,
-0.3097429574,
0.8021504283,
-0.4943909347,
-0.4727839231,
0.736379385,
0.6992068291,
0.3328664899,
0.1001031622,
0.0754516274,
0.3765772879,
0.0705561936,
0.3927809894,
0.2544811964,
-0.0942186415,
-0.575581193,
-0.3324973583,
-0.8104227185,
-0.1801870018,
0.0971257538,
-0.7315174341,
-0.0170304123,
-0.4632355571,
-0.1190622896,
-0.3479625285,
-0.1677629948,
-0.9816967845,
0.3063057065,
0.4276114404,
0.7705317736,
-0.3745473921,
0.8325235248,
0.6225475073,
-0.3181595206,
-0.5005362034,
-0.0564665906,
0.1362986565,
-0.9004353881,
0.7669936419,
0.4174649119,
0.159115836,
0.0130197247,
-0.2871804535,
-0.6254591346,
1.1513264179,
0.2960751355,
-1.0403933525,
-0.0250144545,
0.2007586658,
0.3500396907,
-0.1632704735,
0.3029849529,
0.3191193938,
0.5466319323,
-0.2445771396,
-1.0636292696,
-0.143330887,
-0.4343236685,
0.2846358716,
-0.1315670907,
-0.549933672,
0.7597088814,
-0.276858449,
-0.0207880978,
0.0195487197,
0.4594759047,
0.1766112298,
0.19456622,
0.4116148353,
0.5733991861,
0.4691043198,
0.1806296557,
1.0079706907,
-0.3636192977,
0.2426459789,
1.0195327997,
-0.3000889122,
1.1949937344,
0.2918538451,
-0.526032269,
0.3271864653,
0.3980283141,
-0.3822669387,
0.3485172689,
0.5444281697,
-0.1499548554,
-0.3335593343,
0.0584783405,
-0.3234053552,
0.7015373707,
0.327724129,
-0.4909072518,
-0.2394160032,
0.2538201213,
-0.2471790463,
0.1241132393,
-0.2981079221,
0.8207992911,
-0.0120142195,
-0.5324946046,
0.746994257,
0.2618003488,
0.7579676509,
-0.4886369705,
-0.1823031455,
-0.2889494002,
0.1274491698,
-0.1965317428,
-0.7322544456,
-0.1282396764,
0.4109944403,
-0.2138368934,
-0.3421825767,
0.4623446763,
-0.2859091163,
-0.5055461526,
0.2564277649,
0.3834711313,
0.0522373393,
-0.0244989451,
-0.6640714407,
0.5179994106,
0.2566029131,
-0.2076689452,
0.6206317544,
0.0800489038,
0.0261565782,
0.707444489,
0.8801911473,
-0.3685980439,
0.3974302411,
0.440341711,
0.8127919436,
-0.401371032,
-0.0331003405,
-0.6861107349,
0.4567466378,
-0.0812024027,
-0.2888274193,
0.6533484459,
1.0270738602,
0.6814962029,
-0.2479527146,
0.8225393295,
0.0185380727,
0.0535128154,
-0.839887619,
0.8063641191,
-0.6534286141,
-0.1330972761,
0.1639065444,
-0.9569529295,
-0.1166829765,
0.5062852502,
0.1079744473,
-0.0502380803,
0.5910980105,
0.9698706865,
-0.0300973188,
-0.2492514402,
0.5017222762,
0.0057843258,
0.2701457143,
0.7458559275,
0.8536118269,
-0.3889700472,
0.8448837996,
-0.1064246297,
-0.1483019292,
-0.3505116403,
-0.6830839515,
-0.9983090162,
-0.6403161287,
-0.0292872582,
-0.1329843849,
0.3590436578,
0.8906494975,
0.8870851398,
-0.7285223007,
-0.3272998035,
0.1661246717,
-0.1855481714,
-0.0984905213,
-0.1452400088,
0.1687926203,
-0.4251888692,
-0.8001871705,
0.3881574571,
0.3588461578,
-0.0769705102,
-0.5590232015,
-0.2286852598,
0.0107192406,
-0.278127104,
0.9256581068,
-0.0478186719,
-0.7811639309,
0.0202968121,
-0.1432182938,
-0.3816298842,
0.1755868644,
0.7345459461,
-0.3834546804,
0.3425337076,
0.1380887777,
0.8480175734,
0.5017654896,
-0.0396530665,
0.3401971161,
-0.7411171794,
0.0833954066,
0.1856323928,
0.313606143,
0.4577482045,
0.0539921485,
0.3834397793,
-0.0665638223,
-0.1082086191,
-0.5860078931,
0.1561316997,
-0.9675973058,
-0.3793944418,
1.446854353,
-0.3802325726,
-0.0608845688,
0.2733008564,
-0.0169638433,
0.1596274972,
-0.1893270314,
0.5322501659,
0.3023713231,
0.0935028568,
-0.4866310358,
-0.6676092744,
0.2006673664,
0.1135678962,
-1.1089686155,
0.0180347543,
0.82148844,
0.2272411287,
-0.035092473,
0.3654342294,
0.2081898451,
0.5665231347,
0.0778424591,
0.3489300609,
-0.2279821187,
-0.2823198736,
-0.0485744327,
0.2598113716,
0.0857598856,
-0.1806160659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20095v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20095v1 | LLaRA: Supercharging Robot Learning Data for Vision-Language Policy | 2024-06-28T17:59:12 | 2024-06-28T17:59:12 | Xiang Li, Cristina Mata, Jongwoo Park, Kumara Kahatapitiya, Yoo Sung Jang, Jinghuan Shang, Kanchana Ranasinghe, Ryan Burgert, Mu Cai, Yong Jae Lee, Michael S. Ryoo | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) equipped with extensive world knowledge and
strong reasoning skills can tackle diverse tasks across domains, often by
posing them as conversation-style instruction-response pairs. In this paper, we
propose LLaRA: Large Language and Robotics Assistant, a framework which
formulates robot action policy as conversations, and provides improved
responses when trained with auxiliary data that complements policy learning.
LLMs with visual inputs, i.e., Vision Language Models (VLMs), have the capacity
to process state information as visual-textual prompts and generate optimal
policy decisions in text. To train such action policy VLMs, we first introduce
an automated pipeline to generate diverse high-quality robotics instruction
data from existing behavior cloning data. A VLM finetuned with the resulting
collection of datasets based on a conversation-style formulation tailored for
robotics tasks, can generate meaningful robot action policy decisions. Our
experiments across multiple simulated and real-world environments demonstrate
the state-of-the-art performance of the proposed LLaRA framework. The code,
datasets, and pretrained models are available at
https://github.com/LostXine/LLaRA. | [
-0.0078341505,
-0.6955738664,
0.6090714931,
-0.2028282732,
0.032342758,
0.1525054425,
-0.1283980608,
-0.1838590354,
0.6665604711,
0.9792294502,
-0.6969590187,
-0.3886430264,
-0.4855886698,
-0.0498812012,
-0.426243186,
0.7720205188,
0.1277687401,
0.1168110222,
-0.0912136137,
-0.0004788736,
-0.3458800614,
-0.3175952733,
-0.4734963775,
-0.4147900641,
0.6842405796,
0.5452771187,
0.6678286791,
0.4477622807,
0.6194559932,
0.3633261919,
0.0067223147,
0.7478152514,
-0.5542654991,
0.0907196254,
-0.2747438252,
-0.6016798019,
-0.5465451479,
-0.5146322846,
0.6776859164,
0.4009847939,
-0.295484513,
-0.0536736771,
-0.0758963227,
0.5792301297,
-0.5701075792,
0.3549847901,
-0.613570869,
0.0938218012,
0.2027523369,
-0.3561227024,
-0.3632141054,
-0.0730566084,
0.103396982,
-0.6729286313,
-0.1646760702,
-0.0473495796,
1.1514028311,
0.5443069339,
-0.1273502856,
-0.0866861492,
-0.6701897383,
0.7765676379,
-0.4643407762,
0.0636329353,
0.376052916,
0.389852047,
-0.3839532435,
-0.4516473413,
-0.9202829003,
-0.2384974658,
0.0199133158,
0.4119189382,
-0.4257969856,
0.2654675245,
0.1084150672,
0.0876403823,
-0.4484692216,
0.3940405548,
-0.3845261931,
-0.1566138864,
0.7233790159,
0.4894235134,
0.1118003204,
-0.146135509,
-0.2753656805,
-0.5088510513,
-0.8201650381,
-0.0988955721,
0.4717642963,
0.4163545966,
-0.1358520538,
0.7752928734,
-0.5906084776,
0.6997885704,
-0.3584229648,
-0.3148640692,
0.2333910018,
-0.3375981748,
-0.3041646779,
-0.418482691,
0.9113383293,
0.5723968744,
0.4001523554,
0.103594467,
-0.1216990724,
0.2181508094,
0.3773698807,
-0.5511102676,
-0.0720652342,
0.0925665647,
0.0466451123,
-0.233093977,
-0.2999587357,
-0.7340531349,
-0.4685172439,
-0.5466691256,
0.3152118921,
-0.1360524744,
-0.0022012435,
0.3267832696,
0.0865474567,
0.3716545701,
0.4750720561,
-0.8661094308,
0.0137185873,
0.511962533,
0.4852825105,
-0.2286561579,
-0.4631873965,
-0.658224225,
0.3386198282,
-0.5094859004,
0.7607393861,
-0.8735037446,
-0.3314199448,
0.2768621147,
0.1775359511,
0.0755597502,
-0.5117003322,
-0.1171882749,
-0.327409476,
-0.0664785653,
0.1083212197,
-0.2504010797,
-0.2741568089,
0.4609375,
-0.6240288615,
0.7529615164,
0.02906112,
-0.1077285632,
0.3547568619,
-0.7382716537,
-0.4232327044,
0.1502106041,
-0.4494903088,
-0.3726420403,
-0.3779977858,
0.3121272027,
0.8877901435,
-0.2802868485,
0.5143207312,
-0.0602810755,
-0.129469499,
0.0392273664,
-0.5228581429,
0.6015485525,
-0.0703213215,
-0.0356777161,
0.5023560524,
-0.6998641491,
-0.2028989643,
0.2247332335,
-0.3093955219,
0.1271682233,
0.1404349655,
-0.2863262296,
-0.1054169461,
0.4154877961,
-0.478427887,
0.4300360382,
-0.2808095515,
0.4517842233,
0.8307631016,
-0.3129110932,
0.3173325956,
-0.0288736932,
0.6353316903,
-0.3229691088,
0.1848414391,
-0.32985425,
-0.2903223634,
-0.9566224217,
-0.2110688388,
-0.1540751308,
0.8789083362,
-1.1865621805,
0.456135571,
-0.4153520167,
-0.2792523205,
-0.4132306576,
0.3548689485,
0.5352597237,
0.4788577259,
0.4111106992,
-0.1957388073,
-0.5547177792,
-0.9050889015,
0.2611068785,
-0.2805797458,
-0.0151513992,
0.5271341205,
0.5373408794,
-0.3484718502,
0.9284975529,
-0.463365227,
-0.4601884782,
-0.856803298,
-0.2625871599,
-0.0944422781,
0.139269501,
0.1649241,
-0.6538617611,
-0.0107716648,
0.1256500781,
-0.9768249989,
0.2373114228,
-0.2987253964,
-0.2276049107,
0.3846271038,
0.6193025112,
-0.5790114999,
0.5504686832,
0.7102139592,
0.1373750418,
0.4373160899,
-0.2646554708,
-0.1210896373,
-1.1277008057,
-0.1398452818,
-0.0464402847,
-0.1092801765,
-0.4520101547,
0.3838448822,
-0.4224950969,
-0.1359303147,
-0.8389447331,
0.5024870038,
0.0373417027,
-0.3703868985,
-0.3028979897,
0.1708603054,
-0.0337201767,
0.710024178,
0.4897663295,
0.9117325544,
0.6097521186,
-0.7460554838,
0.6474784613,
0.3364196718,
-0.3518769145,
0.3498504162,
-0.6211657524,
-0.1006550416,
0.0429683961,
0.5180572271,
-0.7706714272,
-0.5946730375,
0.3467009962,
-0.1179190725,
-0.0425086655,
-0.0068404241,
-0.6249269843,
-0.4572378993,
0.0287476443,
-0.1372475624,
0.4385866821,
-0.5470291376,
0.909996748,
0.7129916549,
-0.004165851,
-0.6765851378,
-0.7352512479,
0.2821727395,
-0.0875664353,
-0.3632169366,
0.1004882827,
0.1102647036,
-0.0008665489,
-0.2897139192,
0.1461432874,
-0.1593346,
-0.1252606362,
0.0015334818,
0.5918650031,
0.0776232928,
0.1098700613,
-0.0247683842,
-0.3003296852,
-0.0505949967,
0.2357891798,
0.9291236401,
-0.1155672148,
-0.3543330133,
-0.7563171387,
0.1061036587,
0.5129760504,
-0.0895325765,
0.392588675,
0.2363968194,
0.0841605291,
-0.1823058426,
-0.1865932196,
-0.3148666322,
-0.5277513862,
0.6476840973,
-0.2308755368,
-0.91488868,
0.1247491986,
-0.2288411409,
0.5000306368,
-0.0948206708,
0.5240536332,
-0.3217644989,
0.7822360992,
0.851998806,
-0.1952601224,
0.7129866481,
-0.6659611464,
0.2910588682,
-0.6554910541,
-0.381231606,
-0.0505266227,
-0.2607224584,
-0.4731443524,
-0.5861575007,
0.2339402735,
-0.4751223624,
-0.2762714624,
0.5575733185,
-0.2600106597,
0.6745806932,
0.4818945527,
0.2989555299,
0.0720883161,
0.3281411231,
0.3195377588,
0.1871271729,
-0.9058157802,
-0.6325797439,
1.1548649073,
0.0769423991,
0.8775288463,
-0.3358758986,
0.6788440347,
0.1308261901,
-0.2082392871,
-1.1421445608,
1.1383640766,
-0.3536559939,
0.0206020214,
-0.5756110549,
-0.3789071739,
-1.0370844603,
0.2864954472,
-0.2192669362,
-0.6192836761,
-0.0628848746,
0.5590683818,
-0.4596037567,
0.3880055547,
-0.4677166939,
0.5792622566,
-0.2636289597,
-0.3895451427,
-0.568720758,
-0.656750083,
0.234859854,
0.3225980401,
-0.077350691,
-0.1217041314,
-0.0280198902,
0.4474376142,
-0.2770478427,
1.3058400154,
-0.0141087994,
-0.3563339412,
0.4272089899,
0.0912331715,
0.6315766573,
-0.413472414,
0.2778913677,
0.3312111199,
-0.5087998509,
-0.1945926249,
-0.5444007516,
0.2739138007,
-0.588252604,
-0.5604203343,
-0.0860180929,
-0.7159784436,
-0.2033123374,
-0.0721454769,
-0.094998315,
0.3245798051,
-0.0434966981,
0.2345519662,
0.8247863054,
-0.4417854249,
0.3415319026,
0.7405057549,
-0.313064158,
-0.0605398417,
1.558801651,
0.0130316215,
0.481458813,
0.5523444414,
0.0904917717,
0.0117990253,
-0.0981119871,
-0.5511370301,
0.0273188036,
-0.4632001519,
-0.2721059322,
-0.503905654,
-0.2865841985,
-0.1374953091,
-0.2522586882,
-0.4862475693,
-0.2003440261,
-0.163519457,
-0.1072021499,
0.6180748343,
0.5527148843,
-0.1099673808,
0.6799468994,
-0.3415815532,
0.6229426861,
0.5215120912,
-0.0843925327,
-0.2753064632,
-0.4234280586,
0.0959007293,
0.0697612464,
-0.2005158663,
-0.1387566179,
0.5367382169,
0.1677037627,
0.300123632,
0.1898624003,
-0.1824574471,
0.7592452168,
-0.652741909,
0.6923980713,
0.321605593,
-0.5445215702,
0.8345606327,
-0.1886540353,
0.2773843706,
0.3033847511,
0.1236328706,
-0.262444526,
-0.5884099603,
-0.4596616626,
-1.0913761854,
0.6727377176,
-0.1302455068,
0.5465168953,
0.1798265576,
-0.1098926142,
-0.0285098199,
0.2414433658,
-0.4708670378,
-0.0293346271,
0.06047225,
-0.2803746462,
0.0892249644,
-0.074226059,
-0.2266511023,
-0.1111850664,
0.4476548433,
-0.4113054574,
0.0702064484,
-0.1652650386,
-0.1290764511,
0.4035096169,
0.0987227634,
0.4737224877,
0.4200760126,
0.2747310102,
-0.3046154976,
0.1977635324,
-0.5300534368,
-0.0218377486,
-0.4345388114,
-0.352558881,
-0.3408856988,
0.3352104723,
0.8718340397,
0.1977570653,
-1.146096468,
0.4095215499,
0.1646156609,
-0.2942945957,
-0.3253760636,
0.6868917346,
-0.2299984545,
0.2579374611,
-0.0368766226,
-0.03271202,
0.1122294664,
-0.6163403988,
0.222955063,
0.4120638371,
-0.2265104502,
0.0586718768,
0.142122373,
0.3762487769,
-0.2863616049,
0.5252180696,
0.0593087673,
-0.4553953409,
0.7822095156,
0.3312743604,
0.4691049457,
-0.0198946297,
0.6376324892,
0.1825763136,
0.3637084961,
-0.0357956104,
0.4910677373,
-0.1653847098,
-0.9098954797,
-0.7075826526,
-0.4666719437,
-0.8342292309,
0.1967367232,
-0.5865373015,
0.1036091,
-0.6007978916,
0.0653345659,
-0.4342279434,
-0.2431972027,
-0.6121159792,
0.1029536277,
0.1795796305,
0.4539077878,
-0.8208622336,
0.825894773,
0.3966928124,
-0.5712194443,
-0.7235199213,
-0.0982227027,
-0.1511402279,
-1.4475952387,
0.7846050262,
0.0768430382,
-0.7053168416,
-0.1574434489,
-1.0683983564,
-0.8109121919,
0.8798715472,
0.6399929523,
-0.9812833071,
0.0077234819,
0.1952579021,
0.4137845337,
-0.3548384309,
0.0162560381,
0.7510031462,
0.289708674,
0.2024024725,
-0.8243144751,
-0.4571544528,
-0.0475178994,
0.0181642603,
-0.0650039986,
-1.0002988577,
0.2874603868,
-0.3432748616,
-0.0476453118,
0.1116106361,
0.8325064778,
0.4296912849,
0.027355874,
0.2926940322,
0.5440097451,
0.7376776934,
-0.0155012477,
1.1416851282,
-0.1135566011,
-0.2359092981,
1.1973575354,
-0.4978442788,
1.192040801,
0.4933979809,
-0.0759055912,
0.6904008389,
0.2055802345,
-0.1121115983,
0.4909920096,
0.064566277,
-0.0513473861,
-0.5344968438,
-0.4649173915,
-0.0270463955,
0.8151835799,
0.6689260602,
-0.0364816375,
-0.035505984,
0.2169573605,
0.061645411,
0.1894284785,
-0.3555731475,
0.7753229737,
-0.1736432165,
-0.5004701614,
0.3494175971,
-0.4543808699,
0.6720731258,
-0.7445758581,
-0.5063542724,
-0.3551754057,
0.1438171715,
-0.0768243,
-1.0993249416,
0.1126875579,
0.2069812715,
-0.095212698,
-0.2954126596,
0.2816162705,
-0.4753215611,
-0.4835578799,
0.2739547789,
0.1661353707,
0.4985946715,
0.561763823,
-0.6529698372,
0.2941519916,
0.0911577046,
-0.1745694876,
0.3435623646,
0.086282067,
-0.0039726184,
1.1872147322,
0.6249392033,
0.1535369605,
-0.0509163328,
0.2940596342,
0.9008711576,
-0.3464262187,
-0.4016604125,
-0.525392592,
0.4775152206,
-0.2252641171,
-0.4847396314,
0.4570357203,
0.2726934254,
0.9701648951,
0.1259780824,
0.6292953491,
0.1148377806,
0.337901175,
-0.9499228597,
0.4182659984,
-0.6349214911,
0.1538748592,
0.0088190082,
-0.7497833371,
-0.286913842,
0.9498209953,
-0.2645779252,
-0.1752459854,
0.2999863923,
1.1219642162,
0.0971240327,
-0.3601201475,
0.4807023406,
0.0137225734,
0.287654072,
0.5644800067,
0.7144477367,
-0.2166434377,
0.7975191474,
0.0722289681,
-0.0187046193,
-0.2890810966,
-0.5510336161,
-0.8071944118,
-0.2979594469,
-0.1921509951,
0.0406617448,
0.3669603169,
0.759955883,
0.7000968456,
-0.4986182451,
-0.4528270364,
-0.4087617099,
0.0671353191,
0.0110790879,
-0.1788966656,
0.2815202773,
-0.4279257059,
-0.8548350334,
0.896261692,
0.3653362989,
-0.091307804,
-0.5740022063,
-0.2767450213,
0.0601258986,
0.0954424441,
0.8469702005,
0.5258906484,
-0.9132764339,
-0.0736883581,
-0.2188834846,
-0.1100612879,
0.024926696,
0.5045580864,
-1.0333861113,
0.5399791002,
0.2558949888,
0.7768412232,
0.1973652989,
-0.3934950531,
0.7531304955,
-0.4912159145,
0.3793898225,
0.1840635985,
0.4094638526,
0.2251018733,
-0.147164017,
0.6809367537,
-0.0822379515,
-0.2397282571,
-0.8691334724,
0.512566328,
-0.8120319247,
-0.1593563408,
1.2456746101,
-0.1255769134,
-0.4370346069,
0.1850363165,
-0.4409884512,
-0.1345561147,
-0.5153216124,
0.5897310972,
0.3590095639,
-0.167827487,
-0.2380983084,
-0.6408450007,
0.0876703262,
0.5359379649,
-0.966798842,
0.2961172163,
0.654270947,
-0.351552248,
0.0834057108,
0.4018729031,
0.2644018829,
0.4123872817,
0.1156150326,
0.167977199,
0.0437405035,
-1.1112129688,
-0.2064040452,
-0.1311816126,
-0.3958050013,
-0.2947125137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20094v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20094v1 | Scaling Synthetic Data Creation with 1,000,000,000 Personas | 2024-06-28T17:59:01 | 2024-06-28T17:59:01 | Xin Chan, Xiaoyang Wang, Dian Yu, Haitao Mi, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We propose a novel persona-driven data synthesis methodology that leverages
various perspectives within a large language model (LLM) to create diverse
synthetic data. To fully exploit this methodology at scale, we introduce
Persona Hub -- a collection of 1 billion diverse personas automatically curated
from web data. These 1 billion personas (~13% of the world's total population),
acting as distributed carriers of world knowledge, can tap into almost every
perspective encapsulated within the LLM, thereby facilitating the creation of
diverse synthetic data at scale for various scenarios. By showcasing Persona
Hub's use cases in synthesizing high-quality mathematical and logical reasoning
problems, instructions (i.e., user prompts), knowledge-rich texts, game NPCs
and tools (functions) at scale, we demonstrate persona-driven data synthesis is
versatile, scalable, flexible, and easy to use, potentially driving a paradigm
shift in synthetic data creation and applications in practice, which may have a
profound impact on LLM research and development. | [
-0.6946753263,
-0.7320794463,
0.7547993064,
0.601916492,
0.4585291445,
0.2782869637,
0.0776696652,
-0.2927174568,
0.3863556385,
0.6143229008,
-0.867921114,
-0.4043411613,
0.0184396561,
0.1348640174,
-0.3542422354,
0.8667187095,
0.4020848274,
0.0857641473,
-0.4024116695,
0.0608722791,
-0.1462042481,
-0.5000012517,
-0.58928442,
-0.1719967425,
0.9181265235,
0.545414865,
0.4873996973,
0.6688800454,
0.2864219546,
0.3393590748,
0.3717694283,
0.1423309296,
-0.6133279204,
0.2008852959,
-0.4525960386,
-0.4801859856,
-0.8799747825,
0.2151854485,
0.657482326,
1.0528441668,
0.3033306301,
0.3854346573,
-0.2365493476,
0.8048032522,
-0.3119717538,
0.2065483034,
-0.416146934,
0.0938936099,
-0.2347935736,
0.1421023905,
-0.7201710343,
-0.3645634949,
0.1597680897,
-0.737662375,
0.0474656187,
0.2532605827,
-0.122559756,
0.1321911365,
-0.3835127056,
0.1726565063,
-1.1512880325,
0.6225663424,
-0.3335908055,
0.2586404383,
0.0030199923,
0.8043657541,
-0.2239978015,
-0.825427413,
-0.8829532266,
0.1813785881,
0.1808759272,
-0.0151952831,
-0.1742596924,
-0.3618598878,
0.4578106701,
0.1577190608,
-0.5855193138,
-0.059359476,
-0.1998863071,
-0.1978517026,
0.7535111308,
0.6197384,
0.1924876124,
-0.1466437876,
-0.0235479828,
-0.1768980771,
-0.8837422729,
-0.1689730883,
0.4797476828,
0.4083194435,
0.124445267,
0.6760504842,
-0.2664978802,
0.5712339282,
0.4047455192,
-0.3597332835,
0.1292247921,
-0.4601199329,
-0.0297249034,
-0.1215841323,
0.9583054185,
0.4380099475,
-0.0696527213,
-0.2156569511,
0.1415312141,
0.1386151463,
0.4149572551,
-0.9302966595,
-0.325365454,
0.4470469952,
-0.1808545589,
-0.2387110293,
-0.0986138061,
-1.112787962,
-0.8044748306,
-0.5394655466,
0.1063042954,
-0.3330434561,
-0.1994313598,
0.1210879087,
0.101898022,
0.2806826532,
0.3498237431,
-0.8119233251,
0.4323136806,
0.5127612352,
0.4362677634,
-0.323106885,
-0.3438534439,
-0.3057466447,
0.2047174871,
-0.4061052799,
0.7879485488,
-0.3107520044,
-0.4626706541,
-0.2783255875,
-0.1987534016,
0.2719485164,
-0.605678618,
0.0840061605,
-0.0905555785,
0.1479839832,
-0.5313150883,
-0.4291486442,
0.3322861195,
0.3215372562,
-0.8114877939,
0.865429163,
0.5277369022,
-0.4953821898,
0.3396422863,
-0.5400984883,
-0.4976874292,
0.3834193945,
-0.1321388483,
0.0374938697,
-0.0331429206,
0.2778880298,
0.3196153939,
-0.6457028389,
0.4015910029,
-0.1796368361,
-0.0471141264,
0.6393063068,
0.169451952,
0.648963511,
0.3067113161,
-0.0824658871,
0.0697886646,
-0.9792270064,
0.0630384237,
0.0176930968,
-0.2254650891,
0.0504011735,
-0.1034912094,
0.3615149558,
0.3997031152,
0.4042518437,
-0.7114720941,
0.4042258859,
-0.4007474184,
0.5176159143,
0.5104964375,
0.1449439824,
0.7297850251,
-0.5467306376,
0.6125621796,
-0.0862991363,
0.0254648272,
-0.3184098899,
-0.3873073757,
-0.6420230865,
-0.4145451188,
0.1265119016,
0.4413126111,
-0.5886507034,
0.8236202598,
-0.6437398195,
-0.8848638535,
-0.5285305977,
-0.1979569197,
0.0340885222,
0.6790166497,
0.1242360994,
-0.1007971615,
-0.7868885398,
-1.221036911,
-0.2170390189,
-0.1094330251,
-0.6207877398,
0.4195737541,
0.4762260616,
-0.494710952,
1.4414486885,
-0.689884305,
-0.2019504756,
-0.4911758602,
-0.0887451321,
-0.0200794693,
0.68404603,
0.5901067257,
-0.6266996264,
-0.6994746327,
0.0300073829,
-0.7218159437,
-0.1893643439,
-0.4501861334,
-0.5029067397,
-0.1704641432,
0.4649576545,
-0.7479965687,
-0.0026883467,
0.2404108495,
-0.2018665522,
0.5707578659,
-0.045507405,
0.1029014215,
-1.3363733292,
0.2934590578,
0.0069061252,
-0.1640225351,
-0.7597814202,
0.3341286778,
-0.0804317892,
-0.4846278429,
-0.4202778339,
0.747933805,
-0.016425075,
-0.1081499457,
0.1067700014,
0.1133689508,
-0.0121198883,
0.5647307634,
-0.1635724604,
0.6958487034,
0.5028471947,
-0.3857747316,
0.476233691,
0.3835006654,
-0.3878580928,
1.0376725197,
-0.6606888175,
0.2716859579,
-0.1115650758,
0.6787230968,
-1.1274741888,
-0.7189084888,
0.0576794744,
-0.2813461125,
-0.1977481693,
0.1158490255,
-0.973490417,
-0.3955240846,
-0.1348437518,
0.4337414801,
0.5240162611,
-0.391771853,
0.8704965711,
0.8424753547,
-0.2924458086,
0.3056927919,
-0.7639516592,
0.3690192997,
-0.3576673567,
-0.7172238231,
0.4551422596,
-0.4887464941,
-0.3916665018,
-0.3920498192,
0.018420849,
0.0116695641,
-0.2600244582,
0.2982182801,
0.0858199671,
0.2188061774,
-0.1463509351,
0.0855957717,
-0.1025592014,
0.2397158742,
-0.5830824375,
0.7657001019,
0.0516219363,
-0.183431074,
-0.2232585996,
0.4715034962,
1.012275219,
0.0296910554,
0.6641049385,
0.3144834936,
-0.3856079578,
-0.399699986,
-0.3687993288,
-0.1004068851,
-0.533161819,
0.156253159,
-0.4439281225,
-0.7844005823,
0.9464935064,
-0.3709207773,
0.2099159062,
0.2831651568,
0.6500245929,
0.1369232386,
1.0953764915,
0.5112681985,
-0.0680258349,
0.0670047328,
-0.1358266175,
0.4402288198,
-0.7097398043,
-0.448110044,
-0.3936978281,
-0.7475246787,
-0.7628741264,
-0.701790452,
0.7353796363,
-0.6984637976,
-0.4647877812,
0.4311939478,
-0.479421258,
0.5138814449,
0.5639490485,
0.1512432247,
0.2123036683,
-0.0558962077,
0.0719553754,
-0.5066138506,
-0.4027275145,
-0.329788357,
1.384457469,
0.0207253117,
0.5291363597,
0.1909261942,
0.5316904187,
0.1785988957,
0.2547565997,
-0.8157969713,
0.9359018207,
0.0553991348,
-0.6968274117,
-0.2543668151,
-0.509116888,
-0.8275256157,
0.0078412201,
-0.2237146497,
-0.6425089836,
0.0117524723,
0.0584246963,
-0.3752365708,
0.0608690307,
-0.5322344899,
0.7072321773,
0.1742986143,
-0.4275640249,
-0.0559961945,
-0.6525222659,
0.3456961513,
-0.5845153928,
0.181079179,
0.1204764917,
0.015090419,
0.6577546597,
-0.3479212224,
0.68065238,
-0.0112427725,
-0.2582918406,
0.2653262615,
0.46786201,
0.4499287605,
0.253572166,
-0.0834484249,
-0.2054489851,
-0.3606288135,
-0.4097445309,
-0.7099903226,
0.9422451854,
-0.5596161485,
-0.4510897696,
0.0169321317,
-1.0811423063,
-0.7389174104,
0.2647061348,
0.1758104414,
0.2245763242,
-0.5105251074,
0.3258389533,
0.6185954809,
-0.4738434553,
-0.0749231279,
0.4630635381,
-0.5123522878,
-0.4490157962,
1.0236721039,
0.0745395869,
0.1185380444,
0.5333006382,
0.0261133686,
-0.1048194692,
-0.0868785828,
-0.409835726,
0.1062790304,
-0.4357013404,
0.0760304332,
-0.7527314425,
-0.0545734912,
-0.5484495163,
-0.4714649618,
-0.5618126988,
-0.6118477583,
0.1398262531,
-0.0892792866,
0.165765211,
0.5091099143,
0.176705882,
0.4068357944,
-0.3940673172,
0.3964924514,
0.419474721,
0.1220254824,
-0.1020316482,
-0.1938744932,
-0.1164944395,
0.08498808,
-0.1222744659,
-0.7143908739,
0.7048594952,
-0.0800909847,
0.1746261567,
0.3015740216,
-0.0492983274,
0.6705129147,
-0.7402060032,
0.7650650144,
0.0156529509,
-0.7868922353,
0.5326357484,
-0.9503093362,
0.7958326936,
0.5064144135,
0.3362960219,
-0.5557188392,
-0.4734044373,
-0.4831324816,
-0.8097515106,
0.5614029765,
0.1557451338,
0.1716015339,
0.0081930608,
0.3896102905,
0.4344960451,
0.2854838371,
-0.4728213847,
-0.4176965952,
0.0389545001,
-0.3071127236,
-0.0202696174,
0.0874520466,
-0.0787627622,
-0.541537106,
0.2805119455,
-0.2929957807,
0.254734695,
-0.2829832435,
0.248478204,
-0.09683007,
0.033641845,
0.1320376545,
0.805788815,
0.074567534,
0.0471972078,
-0.1960176975,
-0.4705949724,
0.1940339655,
0.0510960594,
-0.5527634025,
-0.447819531,
-0.0145375067,
0.5092897415,
0.4020058215,
-1.0102835894,
-0.0704286247,
-0.0723859221,
-0.3515802026,
-0.3470856547,
0.102711238,
0.4230446219,
0.1929326802,
0.443862766,
0.1712517142,
0.0492164791,
-0.6456851363,
0.2847499549,
0.1708638072,
0.1713072509,
-0.6444393992,
0.8977034688,
0.1315889955,
-0.2188369334,
0.7810311317,
-0.0804727748,
-0.0509084836,
0.4578923881,
0.5132501721,
0.6636618376,
-0.1285439432,
0.5266450644,
0.4804405868,
0.0072549917,
-0.0444670059,
0.1355530322,
0.2075642347,
-0.6719222665,
-0.2985730469,
-0.7229827642,
-0.4935294688,
0.2966448665,
-0.5424727798,
0.0633005947,
-0.8537221551,
-0.1170418486,
0.4921683967,
0.0441147536,
-0.7001709342,
0.0045046839,
-0.1803348809,
0.6893320084,
-0.7586207986,
0.6549651027,
0.7286173105,
-0.246486634,
-0.6372165084,
-0.053782355,
0.2873178124,
-0.3902651966,
0.4546308517,
0.0122456169,
0.3018663824,
0.2416552603,
-0.6928796172,
-0.7855703831,
0.9604302049,
0.5740031004,
-0.5354019403,
0.0316363834,
0.6864042878,
0.9107528329,
-0.8065677881,
-0.4908304214,
0.7045065761,
0.5449147224,
0.3351140618,
-0.6309918165,
-0.0407434106,
-0.3116511703,
-0.1340390295,
0.11227981,
-0.5498356819,
0.9616813064,
-0.0323293172,
-0.0313838534,
0.1082728282,
0.4111786485,
0.4205382466,
0.0543906875,
0.2875273824,
0.6819067597,
0.6751033664,
0.0908396244,
0.924987793,
-0.2033920586,
-0.0718560293,
1.1521905661,
-0.6775748134,
0.4463920593,
0.3407926857,
-0.5766558647,
0.4842612445,
0.4129731059,
-0.0511587895,
0.2246536463,
0.182797119,
-0.4552403092,
-0.3998328149,
-0.1780293733,
0.1612744927,
0.4322883189,
0.4666874409,
-0.1327999532,
-0.0613640882,
0.1769270897,
-0.0453386232,
0.2022872567,
-0.1299708486,
0.5894522667,
-0.1902707219,
-0.7964628339,
0.0985096097,
-0.0879055709,
0.1076415926,
-0.359596312,
0.1197303608,
-0.4722594321,
0.2368426472,
0.0852405652,
-0.773412168,
0.1995576769,
0.030839894,
-0.3301155269,
-0.6804981232,
0.4074231684,
-0.40457353,
-0.7194910645,
-0.2466274649,
0.8984778523,
0.2508268356,
-0.2551039755,
-0.2833335102,
-0.0102833845,
0.0347315818,
-0.1243688613,
0.7714903951,
0.6198964119,
-0.2156439275,
0.9356383681,
0.6772866845,
0.0379067324,
-0.1721072644,
-0.0971370712,
1.0121854544,
-0.6309429407,
-0.489780724,
-0.6056079865,
0.5400831699,
-0.013303712,
-0.2095601261,
1.0666667223,
0.8043682575,
0.7480759025,
-0.3493382931,
0.942625463,
-0.4077431262,
0.5369203091,
0.1939930916,
0.5701748133,
-0.2403848469,
0.1508024931,
-0.3873063624,
-1.0464100838,
-0.2469155937,
0.4328007698,
-0.0247719772,
-0.2338383049,
0.3540425897,
0.6963323951,
0.0211126395,
-0.07379435,
0.239010796,
0.2184837461,
0.5384797454,
0.5440359116,
0.3058398962,
-0.2332720757,
0.2723921835,
-0.154586792,
-0.1955104917,
0.1326742619,
-0.5757520795,
-0.8936590552,
-0.8952752948,
-0.3202271461,
-0.1066844389,
-0.7059732676,
0.7807373405,
0.6471737027,
-0.6735801101,
-0.188006714,
-0.3115165532,
-0.22304748,
-0.0188360587,
-0.258373946,
-0.0065694666,
0.1249938756,
-1.0715401173,
0.5757161379,
0.3738812804,
-0.0953582302,
-0.9378905296,
0.0751262903,
0.1747984439,
0.2716447711,
0.847559154,
0.2275949717,
-0.3763019145,
-0.0025521126,
0.398698926,
-0.0866867974,
-0.161673516,
0.9810740352,
-1.1916328669,
0.4666368067,
0.5545157194,
0.5629130006,
0.4909166396,
0.1367986649,
0.8937079906,
-0.8947026134,
0.2723586559,
0.2932230234,
0.0584590659,
0.437058717,
-0.3185121715,
0.4625457227,
0.1175968722,
-0.5157258511,
-0.7395608425,
0.461558044,
-1.1989978552,
-0.2910823226,
0.9322678447,
0.1209776029,
-0.0960761905,
0.0752812475,
-0.2431483269,
-0.1921850741,
-0.4214564562,
0.8944277763,
0.5060383677,
-0.3344130516,
0.0381750241,
-0.478941083,
0.3701903224,
0.008177734,
-1.2356860638,
0.3066541255,
1.1225450039,
0.1118724197,
0.3217326105,
0.5718848705,
-0.1755738705,
0.0180905163,
0.3190298975,
-0.1313240975,
0.1477168202,
-0.5445747972,
0.3461689651,
0.2778081,
-0.3471664786,
0.5186160803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20087v1 | ProgressGym: Alignment with a Millennium of Moral Progress | 2024-06-28T17:55:24 | 2024-06-28T17:55:24 | Tianyi Qiu, Yang Zhang, Xuchuan Huang, Jasmine Xinze Li, Jiaming Ji, Yaodong Yang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | Frontier AI systems, including large language models (LLMs), hold increasing
influence over the epistemology of human users. Such influence can reinforce
prevailing societal values, potentially contributing to the lock-in of
misguided moral beliefs and, consequently, the perpetuation of problematic
moral practices on a broad scale. We introduce progress alignment as a
technical solution to mitigate this imminent risk. Progress alignment
algorithms learn to emulate the mechanics of human moral progress, thereby
addressing the susceptibility of existing alignment methods to contemporary
moral blindspots. To empower research in progress alignment, we introduce
ProgressGym, an experimental framework allowing the learning of moral progress
mechanics from history, in order to facilitate future progress in real-world
moral decisions. Leveraging 9 centuries of historical text and 18 historical
LLMs, ProgressGym enables codification of real-world progress alignment
challenges into concrete benchmarks. Specifically, we introduce three core
challenges: tracking evolving values (PG-Follow), preemptively anticipating
moral progress (PG-Predict), and regulating the feedback loop between human and
AI value shifts (PG-Coevolve). Alignment methods without a temporal dimension
are inapplicable to these tasks. In response, we present lifelong and
extrapolative algorithms as baseline methods of progress alignment, and build
an open leaderboard soliciting novel algorithms and challenges. The framework
and the leaderboard are available at
https://github.com/PKU-Alignment/ProgressGym and
https://huggingface.co/spaces/PKU-Alignment/ProgressGym-LeaderBoard
respectively. | [
0.0859305263,
-0.5705635548,
0.6793205738,
0.0841904655,
0.1751241088,
0.562589705,
0.0720075071,
-0.3030786216,
0.0229034517,
0.491445154,
-0.7914457917,
-0.4199841917,
-0.6284319162,
-0.3605127931,
0.0385769196,
1.0257009268,
0.0094040185,
0.0003185522,
-0.2131952196,
-0.2263958454,
-0.7781180739,
-0.067404747,
-0.5492682457,
-0.4861847758,
0.3071011007,
0.393407166,
0.8108701706,
1.0406169891,
0.7165707946,
0.3865381777,
-0.1539378017,
0.0082762558,
-0.6368547678,
0.1102009267,
-0.3889844716,
-0.4410776496,
-0.7752732635,
0.2146106362,
0.4206275046,
0.3366824687,
-0.4683590233,
0.2797450125,
0.0325757414,
0.7210772634,
-0.2986104786,
0.0038859695,
-0.2840097249,
0.161129415,
-0.1720445156,
-0.0562201887,
-0.1249657571,
-0.9751629233,
-0.0703961775,
-0.7109342813,
-0.0912558511,
0.0541686118,
0.8965494633,
0.3146436512,
-0.0589140393,
-0.3068780005,
-0.4959777892,
0.9967570901,
-0.3713845015,
0.2042891532,
0.3463788629,
0.1319760084,
-0.191197902,
-0.6072648764,
-0.5205999017,
-0.1356321573,
0.2826192975,
0.2226180136,
0.2087147236,
-0.0929155424,
0.2557783723,
0.1582143754,
-0.4554194212,
0.0512034781,
-0.3453849554,
-0.170221433,
0.6335963011,
0.5149540305,
0.2937464416,
0.2460232228,
-0.3644937873,
-0.2279207706,
-0.7419170737,
0.2459450215,
0.5179963708,
0.0490090027,
-0.0731282085,
0.5052865744,
0.2621029019,
0.5737776756,
0.3572111428,
-0.1478922814,
0.1775605679,
-0.5726490617,
0.039965678,
0.064654693,
0.6743944883,
0.5999438167,
0.2555308938,
0.0577329211,
0.0705356151,
0.1397578716,
0.7448318601,
-0.5833394527,
-0.1042499319,
0.1239125431,
-0.385551244,
-0.4472110271,
0.0879335701,
-0.8452553153,
-0.5936793685,
-0.4422601759,
0.2572709322,
-0.5030972958,
-0.1441472918,
0.1268550307,
0.060607776,
0.592289567,
0.5826685429,
-0.6058555245,
-0.2226749659,
1.1037074327,
1.2161102295,
-0.0375506878,
-0.2319359928,
-0.6143090725,
0.2798029184,
-0.358820349,
0.3623388112,
-0.6922626495,
-0.2115648687,
-0.1753521264,
0.2435408682,
0.15421772,
-0.0345107131,
0.8425830603,
-0.3823178411,
0.0483648889,
-0.228892386,
-0.7053526044,
-0.0930423737,
0.320758611,
-0.3670197725,
0.5398074985,
-0.0277359486,
-0.5356410742,
0.229188934,
-0.7871991396,
-0.009014328,
0.0993635729,
-0.0702356398,
-0.5874129534,
0.2161567211,
-0.1621972173,
0.1081900522,
-0.003166792,
0.6325337887,
-0.2723483145,
-0.5619655252,
0.0847771913,
-0.4416967928,
0.8188405633,
0.1689941436,
-0.3172746301,
0.2466964871,
-0.3319361806,
-0.0127712879,
0.1354726702,
-0.0529827625,
-0.1360368878,
0.3424714804,
-0.4065058827,
0.0487928391,
0.5793407559,
-0.5999683738,
0.3293341398,
-0.1087514535,
0.4104093015,
1.3572664261,
-0.585486114,
0.23664397,
-0.8900547624,
0.5489079952,
-0.3988837302,
0.4406306148,
-0.0561184101,
-0.5412634611,
-0.4132903814,
0.0406874642,
0.1622435153,
0.7655569315,
-0.1878344268,
0.5299366117,
-0.3796383142,
-0.3954797685,
-0.5505252481,
0.0796962902,
0.2887459695,
0.414765209,
0.3385720253,
-0.3689201176,
-0.1912902594,
-0.610983789,
-0.5283195972,
-0.7578601241,
-0.1875861883,
0.107042335,
0.1037545651,
-0.0919923708,
0.7239196897,
-0.4841324687,
-0.1811645478,
0.4723752141,
0.174871251,
0.2402940989,
0.910564363,
0.1241219342,
-0.8691507578,
-0.1010774598,
0.1155829355,
-0.6908677816,
-0.1212340146,
0.0610408895,
-0.3032560349,
-0.223529458,
0.5303267837,
-0.2119146883,
0.1674377024,
0.5851796269,
-0.7792959809,
0.4134865999,
-0.0731652081,
0.4640190601,
-0.8885730505,
0.0760415345,
-0.1478072852,
-0.4711290002,
-0.3156192601,
0.0281425212,
0.0418661423,
0.0756386742,
-0.2826548517,
0.1332856715,
-0.1057002023,
0.3379945159,
-0.1231725588,
0.1563425064,
-0.1656775624,
0.1347184777,
-0.2317412198,
0.6600526571,
0.2351584733,
-0.3207327425,
0.4108322561,
0.4665982425,
0.0615935288,
1.1054332256,
-0.4489688873,
0.2531967461,
-0.1446128637,
-0.1156975478,
-0.7137576342,
-0.0283833928,
0.2741147876,
-0.4924643636,
0.257768333,
-0.3129886687,
-0.0115322182,
-0.1381176114,
-0.5104882717,
0.3416913152,
0.7435142994,
-0.3915701509,
0.6845715642,
0.276976794,
-0.4040136635,
-0.8122861981,
-0.5212495327,
0.187524572,
-0.4802954793,
-0.7696293592,
0.3961867094,
-0.2526912987,
-0.3513257205,
-0.0283099543,
-0.0350737758,
0.4011592865,
0.1644544899,
0.2787513733,
0.4330718517,
-0.1688283384,
0.0927152708,
0.0209427811,
-0.066592738,
0.1371970326,
-0.691552639,
0.3304773569,
-0.5908603072,
-0.2796385884,
-0.2441888452,
0.1746429354,
0.4811003804,
0.0722741336,
0.3817633688,
0.5182275772,
-0.2852283418,
0.4255695641,
-0.5490208864,
0.3701410592,
-0.515298903,
0.2228991985,
0.1374198943,
-1.1694420576,
0.2084533125,
-0.3372263312,
0.4869597554,
0.4038788676,
0.4045721889,
-0.4662028849,
0.8051316142,
0.9394217134,
0.2516527474,
0.6986060143,
0.0934896693,
-0.1007852256,
-0.8707376719,
-0.2830385268,
-0.4374324977,
-0.5635085702,
-0.8503416181,
-0.5146145225,
0.0076028234,
0.5799868107,
-0.6662443876,
0.4065366685,
-0.6844698191,
0.712418735,
0.2233346403,
-0.0647347942,
0.5963186026,
0.0210880861,
0.1245033592,
-0.1656421125,
-0.3474871516,
-0.8454061151,
1.1281012297,
0.2797635496,
0.8336184025,
0.3694448471,
0.4529381692,
0.6875795722,
0.8320986032,
-0.6603682041,
0.3376064003,
-0.1753151268,
-0.1872255653,
-0.2560035884,
-0.4984027147,
-0.8232161999,
-0.0190848969,
-0.0454295166,
-0.9490187764,
0.1695615053,
0.2285662293,
-0.396420151,
0.3612959981,
-0.3940489888,
0.7805392146,
-0.5169322491,
-0.6508546472,
-0.257871449,
-0.974277854,
0.2240050286,
-0.0651830882,
0.0861200988,
-0.3849207461,
-0.1635269523,
0.5928447247,
-0.3043645024,
0.7934080362,
-0.1372609437,
-0.3776775301,
0.186281845,
0.1081786156,
0.6557106376,
0.2686555684,
0.2070692182,
0.3433167636,
0.0269446205,
-0.5239839554,
-0.0806640908,
0.838155508,
-0.4831156731,
-0.7725081444,
-0.5137371421,
-0.5148720741,
-0.0826719329,
0.090690732,
0.1005607769,
-0.0352288857,
-0.5645042658,
-0.1757270843,
0.7441289425,
-0.1893869042,
0.4786482453,
0.4126863182,
-0.3398504257,
-0.7151113153,
1.1042349339,
-0.1631758511,
0.3151548207,
0.0690570772,
0.330244422,
-0.327693373,
-0.4487575293,
-0.7010465264,
0.081714496,
-0.4211815298,
-0.3113205135,
-0.5252276063,
0.1508882493,
-0.0957248956,
-0.6165025234,
-0.3728510737,
-0.1719301641,
-0.2709991336,
0.1345150322,
0.3317256272,
0.8192695975,
-0.3021919429,
0.1166300476,
-0.8518155217,
0.0113578672,
0.2026128322,
0.4676651955,
-0.4774814844,
-0.4131691456,
-0.0072241114,
0.3764755726,
-0.9106917381,
-0.469709605,
-0.0751826167,
0.0329020508,
0.0019459621,
0.3808264136,
-0.1812560558,
0.7447839975,
-0.4610698521,
0.6424415112,
0.457426995,
-1.0442814827,
0.5078545213,
-0.3477267623,
0.1564968228,
0.7384828329,
0.3454422951,
-0.6645075679,
-0.3635579944,
-0.6170789003,
-0.5213726759,
0.4290784001,
0.3769960701,
0.0701106936,
0.2627392709,
0.5351455808,
0.1442638934,
0.136780113,
-0.3360257149,
0.208639428,
-0.3131718636,
-0.5700546503,
0.0152401393,
0.3572069108,
-0.3737850487,
-0.1239516214,
0.5073067546,
-0.4288669527,
0.0079218773,
0.2039544284,
0.0483422726,
-0.4269241989,
0.1864299178,
0.6549053788,
1.088670969,
-0.0194320958,
-0.3889604509,
-0.0853687748,
-0.7706530094,
0.6854308248,
0.3041068316,
-0.3261915147,
-0.4800605476,
0.127462104,
0.3854158223,
-0.5471057296,
-0.564910531,
0.6001249552,
-0.3553525507,
-0.0827667117,
-0.5947822928,
0.1411447525,
0.1845287681,
0.7644858956,
0.2374842614,
0.0898321718,
-0.3057690859,
-0.4895607233,
0.2479912341,
0.4008492827,
-0.7847608328,
-0.3666309416,
0.8507903218,
0.1157406196,
-0.8200625181,
0.6288317442,
-0.3359611332,
-0.4145668447,
0.7061727047,
0.2298037559,
0.896178484,
-0.2358372509,
0.4405924678,
0.1658162028,
0.333078593,
-0.6323338747,
0.4328622222,
0.1702648103,
-0.7455495596,
-1.0054923296,
-0.8452057242,
-0.4751877785,
-0.2497765571,
-0.4914849699,
0.334890455,
-0.4605547488,
-0.3131670356,
-0.5946010947,
-0.1296838224,
-0.3464746773,
-0.1103619784,
-0.0166667756,
0.3441286683,
-0.5256284475,
0.3248705864,
0.7628653049,
-0.077653721,
-0.3348622918,
0.3473391533,
0.1815464646,
-0.7288300395,
0.1514892727,
0.3545021117,
-0.2150986642,
0.2166277617,
-0.9050042629,
-0.6975048184,
1.226295352,
0.5415606499,
-0.9239780307,
0.0172024164,
-0.2697395384,
0.3381954134,
-0.2714585066,
-0.1095665321,
0.5520519614,
0.6857675314,
0.057904087,
-0.6999439597,
0.1320176572,
0.0093985805,
-0.2241946161,
0.8409620523,
-1.0024478436,
0.6136234999,
-0.5060836077,
-0.2885471582,
0.4428966939,
0.6285924911,
0.4465984106,
0.4550703168,
0.4444639385,
0.8713865876,
0.9408294559,
-0.3687466979,
0.5152920485,
-0.1226983592,
0.4643969834,
0.8349868655,
-0.1998644918,
0.1646677256,
0.3841156662,
-0.2826978564,
0.4361551106,
0.5547431111,
-0.252764672,
0.1688744128,
0.3976204991,
-0.1099705622,
-0.3002340496,
-0.3685519993,
-0.5007347465,
0.4080968499,
0.3078872859,
-0.2042860836,
0.1474719197,
-0.2914402783,
0.1161569133,
0.1445886791,
-0.4937927723,
0.7657846808,
-0.0190414246,
-0.6329605579,
0.2606445551,
-0.2037136108,
0.7834347486,
-0.6141167879,
-0.420111239,
-0.0846800208,
0.2455836684,
-0.0631863847,
-0.8480067849,
0.4566790462,
-0.0009930539,
0.1107037365,
-0.3820025325,
0.3887573183,
-0.2985234857,
-0.524379313,
0.2989825308,
0.426127553,
-0.1344368011,
0.2913463116,
-0.7813584208,
-0.1849419177,
-0.0886788368,
0.0618029088,
0.2473186255,
0.4047482908,
-0.1204888225,
0.5223763585,
0.6530240178,
0.0563133545,
-0.31799981,
-0.4007546306,
0.6256226301,
-1.044054985,
-0.4689933956,
-1.1437616348,
0.2273818403,
-0.1646699458,
-0.4545804858,
0.3012249172,
0.2085815519,
0.9426081181,
0.528344512,
0.4803455174,
-0.3412474692,
-0.2461139262,
-0.6916415095,
0.7928886414,
-0.549714148,
0.0832460001,
-0.2968972623,
-0.8626459837,
-0.0240689274,
0.3497280478,
0.2091263682,
-0.0099474955,
0.5123603344,
0.4875857234,
0.2647252679,
0.2953383327,
0.1701723188,
0.1040659398,
0.3802284002,
0.599201262,
1.226459384,
-0.1315819919,
0.5114295483,
0.2399123609,
-0.284913063,
0.2618484795,
-1.1063555479,
-0.4063051939,
-0.1440089941,
-0.3996886909,
-0.6038538814,
0.4272404611,
0.7807477713,
0.3714030981,
-0.631667316,
-0.2531368434,
-0.4050542116,
0.2799190581,
-0.4700894058,
-0.2296392769,
0.2349345833,
-0.1145523787,
-0.6715582013,
0.358499974,
0.464944452,
0.0304327868,
-0.2443321645,
-0.1899512708,
-0.3317354918,
-0.0050853798,
0.2974317074,
0.2532092929,
-0.5509900451,
-0.5919870138,
-0.0535274893,
0.1015681103,
0.4959157109,
1.0755956173,
-0.395673722,
0.3522507846,
0.4186239839,
0.8112344146,
0.1954512,
0.4685799479,
0.8197620511,
-0.3104470968,
-0.3803596497,
0.4777218997,
0.1705620289,
0.3821183145,
-0.5208942294,
0.7293171287,
0.4925794899,
-0.8144603968,
-0.5043093562,
0.3977392912,
-0.4197598696,
-0.0584282838,
0.5214256644,
-0.26914379,
-0.1203991771,
-0.2393820286,
-0.0258801002,
0.2222256064,
-0.4898800552,
0.7785471678,
0.9471506476,
-0.254491806,
0.1577856392,
-0.5336342454,
0.4092217684,
0.5909151435,
-0.7372733355,
0.1005512699,
0.6796659231,
0.1985051781,
0.3955416083,
0.3998686373,
-0.4494582713,
0.1712817997,
-0.3939455748,
-0.0582912564,
-0.021907879,
-0.1883603632,
-0.5079014897,
0.2407566309,
-0.2330648303,
0.0723715946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20086v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20086v1 | Token Erasure as a Footprint of Implicit Vocabulary Items in LLMs | 2024-06-28T17:54:47 | 2024-06-28T17:54:47 | Sheridan Feucht, David Atkinson, Byron Wallace, David Bau | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | LLMs process text as sequences of tokens that roughly correspond to words,
where less common words are represented by multiple tokens. However, individual
tokens are often semantically unrelated to the meanings of the words/concepts
they comprise. For example, Llama-2-7b's tokenizer splits the word
"northeastern" into the tokens ['_n', 'ort', 'he', 'astern'], none of which
correspond to semantically meaningful units like "north" or "east." Similarly,
the overall meanings of named entities like "Neil Young" and multi-word
expressions like "break a leg" cannot be directly inferred from their
constituent tokens. Mechanistically, how do LLMs convert such arbitrary groups
of tokens into useful higher-level representations? In this work, we find that
last token representations of named entities and multi-token words exhibit a
pronounced "erasure" effect, where information about previous and current
tokens is rapidly forgotten in early layers. Using this observation, we propose
a method to "read out" the implicit vocabulary of an autoregressive LLM by
examining differences in token representations across layers, and present
results of this method for Llama-2-7b and Llama-3-8B. To our knowledge, this is
the first attempt to probe the implicit vocabulary of an LLM. | [
-0.3797490001,
-0.8815509081,
0.5021921992,
-0.1077764034,
-0.5249354243,
0.4320823252,
0.0986924991,
-0.6477326155,
0.3542830944,
0.3453064859,
-0.501758337,
-0.5907111764,
-0.7359321117,
0.1681817472,
-0.6679397225,
0.9568408132,
-0.1049004793,
-0.1472025216,
0.1190630496,
-0.270881772,
-0.657260716,
-0.4630044997,
-0.8397954106,
-0.3871110976,
0.6438895464,
0.2580806017,
0.3653149009,
0.9447779059,
0.3021406829,
0.2761112154,
-0.6647607684,
0.2176732272,
-0.5329066515,
0.1269961894,
-0.0154305305,
-0.6464386582,
-0.3208152354,
0.2004556507,
0.7600460052,
0.8177059889,
0.242423892,
0.2315248847,
-0.0279412791,
0.4147136807,
-0.6167629957,
0.1023877934,
-0.9137176275,
0.2126277983,
-0.3338217735,
-0.3289251924,
-0.1886157244,
0.0686393231,
-0.203803733,
-0.6286356449,
0.1576538831,
0.3406355381,
0.7855579257,
0.2300728261,
-0.4052517712,
-0.4312119782,
-0.6642795205,
0.692886889,
-0.4817313552,
0.2958750725,
0.3561471403,
-0.0871352553,
-0.1590570211,
-0.6455222964,
-0.8422132134,
-0.2106754631,
-0.2697241306,
0.1354748756,
-0.1418080032,
0.0773477554,
0.155133307,
0.1792646646,
-0.084466964,
0.3503710926,
-0.5789502263,
-0.4529118836,
0.1404940486,
0.2866998911,
0.3467591405,
-0.6570666432,
-0.8938305378,
0.3243978024,
-1.0421866179,
-0.1821029484,
0.295229882,
0.0689052567,
0.1993994862,
0.7819743156,
0.1509712189,
-0.0538572185,
-0.0237443652,
-0.1753600687,
0.1442289352,
-0.3628133535,
-0.2302874029,
0.2044107169,
0.4084859788,
0.1501755863,
-0.2629369497,
-0.2681464255,
-0.4181340635,
-0.0044662002,
-0.2004088461,
-0.4955740571,
-0.0499410555,
0.2024383098,
-0.711599648,
-0.0931808129,
-0.1034730226,
-0.2567364275,
-0.5145522952,
-0.3733514845,
0.5567227006,
-0.3414819539,
-0.2042319179,
-0.1477054507,
-0.2759967446,
0.392018646,
0.3307419419,
-0.5289147496,
0.3626899421,
0.8096441627,
0.7655213475,
-0.3035419881,
-0.3994882405,
-0.4899219573,
0.3502345383,
-0.4514414966,
0.6699546576,
-0.4553578794,
-0.5493642688,
-0.2132672668,
0.0833685994,
0.0287938286,
-0.6015897989,
0.231221348,
-0.5734747648,
0.0213860795,
-0.3131360412,
-0.6386000514,
-0.456136018,
0.2220743746,
-0.4727768004,
1.1711741686,
-0.3182789981,
-0.4777696133,
0.6222823858,
-0.4159626961,
-0.0699763894,
0.13545008,
-0.2098143995,
0.1212107688,
0.3395085037,
0.077309534,
0.5466470718,
-0.1566010267,
-0.0503141768,
0.0009581555,
-0.6008214355,
0.1085343584,
-0.4484485984,
0.4906316996,
-0.1026379913,
-0.6156002283,
-0.0739871487,
-0.8125063181,
-0.2919338644,
0.05373317,
-0.2664265037,
-0.7443252206,
0.1624942422,
-0.2001201212,
0.0346404091,
0.2899472415,
-0.7363418937,
0.1345712095,
-0.3814731538,
0.4348210096,
1.0664634705,
0.0997376069,
0.5786945224,
-0.2584311664,
0.3052867651,
0.5441445708,
0.0205563363,
-0.2747084796,
-0.4348158538,
-1.1011096239,
-0.2144961655,
-0.0890568867,
0.2878339291,
-0.4579620957,
0.1391389072,
-0.2930986881,
-0.1594228148,
-0.2989512384,
0.2111533433,
0.3856652975,
0.4340247214,
0.5189674497,
-0.1781841516,
-0.2443930209,
-0.9334303737,
-0.2972442806,
-0.3916751742,
0.2090326697,
0.2517167628,
0.7143945694,
-0.2774832249,
0.6870774627,
-0.4665005505,
-0.451821208,
0.1896793693,
0.3736656308,
0.0960229859,
0.6179435849,
0.2370623797,
-0.3743129671,
0.0754012838,
-0.0523018241,
-0.3338133991,
-0.0250485521,
-0.2720491886,
-0.3112776279,
0.1517098993,
0.9029127955,
-0.5369715691,
0.6248420477,
0.2293731421,
-0.4225830436,
0.2954152226,
-0.158234939,
-0.0970958397,
-0.7207860947,
0.1835782677,
-0.5552939177,
0.0481327437,
-0.4348588586,
-0.1126684397,
-0.0630616918,
0.4059957862,
-0.510358572,
0.8813721538,
-0.9470385313,
-0.4816592932,
-0.1812128425,
0.3135019243,
0.2105199695,
0.2786129415,
-0.2616652548,
0.627081871,
0.2803491354,
-0.7270402312,
-0.0455671772,
0.2435169071,
0.1368390918,
0.5430351496,
-0.4402043223,
0.4249597788,
-0.6658914685,
0.3102668226,
-1.2755987644,
0.1804862171,
0.36185956,
-0.2450444251,
0.1594065279,
-0.2524781227,
-0.6558754444,
-0.0236641355,
-0.3051174879,
0.6761852503,
0.3239861429,
-0.5803552866,
0.8126241565,
0.3125837743,
-0.0089370776,
-0.8019446731,
-0.8100331426,
0.2680638433,
-0.3138873279,
-0.1807342917,
0.2838282883,
-0.0422179475,
-0.4071951509,
0.1476974934,
-0.238500759,
-0.1674533188,
0.1485405117,
0.5483773351,
0.2631138861,
-0.2521336675,
0.4160558283,
0.2922187448,
-0.0071691209,
0.2143763751,
-0.2727847099,
0.6844341159,
-0.0466136001,
-0.5422691703,
-0.1949837059,
0.2770373821,
0.579297483,
-0.1577589512,
0.553152144,
0.7845704556,
-0.6489223242,
-0.2479884773,
-0.7331081629,
-0.0062761079,
-0.4710973501,
0.1862116605,
-0.3918451071,
-0.767830193,
1.1886351109,
0.0146913202,
0.1581424624,
0.7442930341,
0.203697145,
-0.0190811437,
0.6668906808,
0.1077775583,
0.0742954463,
0.2452854663,
-0.4268136024,
-0.095722124,
-1.2417727709,
-0.6308435798,
-0.4540766478,
-0.5782105327,
-0.3295353055,
-0.5514585972,
0.0977393389,
0.1919046491,
-0.2248593867,
0.1710944027,
-0.4447592199,
0.5243787766,
0.4674209356,
0.0296871196,
0.3751470447,
-0.1743269265,
-0.4390932024,
0.1484034508,
-0.216856733,
-0.4828177989,
0.9081519842,
0.3700197637,
0.4087291658,
0.0385637805,
0.9707975984,
0.2638279498,
0.3868376613,
-0.8768182397,
0.7424451709,
-0.2099898458,
-0.5356782675,
-0.2425020933,
-0.1123181805,
-1.1604423523,
0.2830146253,
-0.0652328432,
-0.7137579322,
0.3852892816,
-0.1105644032,
-0.1608673036,
0.5712820292,
-0.4296342134,
0.236496076,
-0.2265524715,
-0.1567321867,
-0.2436474562,
-0.4670747519,
0.4370934069,
-0.2435907274,
0.3413975835,
-0.4916945398,
-0.6271598339,
0.8913415074,
-0.4334220886,
0.9674748182,
-0.3712846339,
-0.2267419845,
0.3654081225,
0.378008455,
0.4935986698,
-0.0149996979,
0.1949476749,
0.3466787934,
-0.0297165681,
-0.2003437877,
-0.4236900508,
0.6723802686,
-0.693870306,
-0.3533970714,
-0.2120936215,
-0.3354052901,
0.1254368126,
0.3580140173,
0.0443158448,
0.3618395329,
-0.0895720124,
-0.0842266232,
0.3105289638,
-0.2541861832,
0.6627296209,
0.3358809352,
-0.2006045282,
-0.3159304261,
0.6927595735,
0.3438456953,
0.0686423406,
0.280945152,
0.1759502739,
-0.5088012218,
-0.8743395805,
-0.223576054,
0.2273595035,
-1.092571497,
-0.0727772862,
-0.6355036497,
0.072187379,
0.1682341695,
-0.087336421,
-0.0282893889,
-0.4414795637,
-0.7252398729,
-0.2545983791,
0.3895211816,
1.1567782164,
-0.0305588823,
0.4231042564,
-0.7458835244,
0.3030527532,
0.1652355641,
0.1744281203,
0.1816922724,
-0.4634131491,
0.085708037,
-0.1775256693,
0.2864922285,
-0.7089821696,
0.2422310561,
0.3443991244,
0.6960392594,
0.4412538707,
-0.2248387337,
0.9386455417,
-0.625412941,
0.9064418674,
0.1950003207,
-1.1469458342,
0.2365505844,
-0.2340748906,
0.0689260587,
0.5116719007,
-0.0230397489,
-0.745139122,
-0.4908929765,
-0.6124007106,
-1.3397136927,
0.4257615209,
-0.0567343794,
0.4222867191,
-0.5023126006,
0.8474783897,
0.3554935157,
0.3518430591,
-0.5308541059,
-0.5992523432,
-0.0246179458,
0.0369862989,
0.0001899952,
-0.4352928996,
-0.2044886202,
-0.1113281623,
0.3148264885,
-0.02202175,
0.4974476993,
0.144979015,
-0.4501005411,
0.0373496115,
0.0683999285,
0.5709876418,
0.398040235,
0.1552787721,
0.6153016686,
0.4317767024,
-0.7174330354,
0.2558097839,
-0.1929365695,
-0.1582681835,
0.0983093157,
0.4615341425,
0.5835268497,
0.5208389759,
-0.2926077545,
0.3259192109,
0.2015175372,
-0.0078924829,
-0.5102446675,
-0.0978084207,
0.058001589,
0.1532813907,
0.7436936498,
0.0300257206,
0.1493256539,
-0.5273373723,
0.2285074443,
0.4883355796,
-0.3269432783,
-0.3592528105,
0.6694404483,
-0.0622631758,
0.0776623785,
0.4323509932,
-0.1180562451,
-0.5708963871,
0.6163084507,
0.3382540047,
0.9951803088,
0.2691508532,
-0.0062775919,
0.1380722821,
0.4399418235,
0.219910726,
0.2317333668,
0.0395835638,
-0.7113460898,
-0.4830057323,
-0.5536941886,
-0.0176967848,
0.0756761879,
-0.5140697956,
-0.1409590095,
-0.7984858751,
-0.2289945632,
-0.027540436,
-0.1624833047,
-0.9268738627,
0.2496967614,
0.2711586654,
0.5733624101,
-0.6187631488,
0.2704660594,
0.6952393055,
-0.401178807,
-0.9492650628,
0.1495864987,
0.2067595571,
-1.3566190004,
1.3491003513,
0.1775622666,
-0.2710950971,
0.2218741477,
-0.5497392416,
-1.0157500505,
1.2340853214,
0.0615792908,
-0.2425695807,
-0.1214125752,
0.2145279944,
0.3296679556,
-0.107889697,
0.4304083884,
0.3888110816,
0.6118865013,
0.0512703918,
-0.6522825956,
0.306853503,
0.0437104329,
-0.1318780184,
0.3036587238,
-0.7009509802,
1.2223834991,
0.0361965932,
-0.5177194476,
0.0684154406,
0.6479873657,
0.1115842983,
0.0917860568,
0.5620632768,
0.2798059285,
0.8810166717,
-0.1466176212,
0.578138411,
-0.3829950094,
0.2107785344,
0.7252144217,
-0.1315893978,
0.7752135992,
0.7489696741,
0.0246061888,
0.4188925922,
0.4882269502,
0.2014780641,
0.114657931,
0.491660744,
-0.4487038851,
0.0814384744,
-0.2566827536,
-0.1069263518,
0.6909865141,
0.4669457972,
-0.3459246159,
-0.1635580212,
-0.1174633428,
0.2050078213,
-0.4748823345,
-0.6375482082,
0.871892035,
0.2094685435,
-0.2596901357,
0.5344171524,
-0.0529034548,
0.6613959074,
-0.3174722493,
-0.1846683323,
-0.4411480129,
0.0018081508,
-0.2454260886,
-0.7066521645,
0.1770473421,
-0.2644732893,
0.0668177679,
-0.1253525913,
0.791225493,
-0.3177075088,
-0.3197556436,
0.5226740837,
0.851303637,
0.4292853475,
0.3269245923,
-0.5049423575,
-0.0219213739,
-0.3468741775,
-0.3797332942,
0.0835181028,
0.631356895,
-0.0379655212,
0.5835905671,
0.7910451889,
0.3192706406,
0.5370692015,
0.0495950915,
0.7152928114,
-0.695476234,
-0.1965443194,
-0.8426576257,
0.5168959498,
0.2711351216,
-0.452614069,
0.6190467477,
0.4956099987,
0.7364796996,
0.2906184494,
0.4483603239,
0.1747564226,
0.3359536231,
-0.765227437,
0.6272704005,
-0.5971247554,
0.482516259,
-0.3507845104,
-1.0025951862,
-0.2541503012,
0.4026964605,
-0.0894231796,
-0.073866643,
0.7975967526,
0.4438522458,
0.1620205045,
-0.2660825253,
0.2630310059,
0.36274755,
0.2543521225,
0.0256250408,
1.1249078512,
-0.286164701,
0.4803703129,
0.0024615633,
0.1755782515,
0.0229819119,
-0.8360007405,
-0.7615492344,
-0.4883811772,
-0.0931880549,
-0.3680485785,
0.2109465897,
0.8250425458,
0.2354580015,
-0.5693588257,
0.0876454115,
-0.0928518549,
0.0582391582,
-0.0689891428,
-0.1906500757,
0.7377658486,
-0.1647380143,
-0.7083058357,
0.4422273636,
0.2623862028,
0.3404177427,
-0.5813694596,
0.1863836199,
0.1336145252,
0.0938768387,
0.6128666997,
0.0288378969,
-0.9309517145,
-0.7491866946,
0.1939188987,
-0.0138639854,
0.1816991866,
0.7125854492,
-0.756809473,
0.1492681503,
0.43260023,
0.4324291348,
0.4143738151,
0.0041597351,
0.1916644424,
-0.852689147,
0.2202283442,
0.3596307337,
0.5615615845,
0.1504161507,
-0.4160515368,
0.2433408797,
0.4209194481,
-0.194395259,
-0.7394194007,
0.1871136427,
-0.7851960063,
-0.2969383597,
1.3106971979,
-0.0316955969,
-0.1973092556,
-0.3208951354,
-0.3331538141,
0.3141241372,
-0.3386748731,
0.4873605967,
0.680605948,
-0.0943714082,
-0.0504785553,
-0.5074248314,
0.309214741,
0.3901264071,
-0.5172885656,
-0.0117428964,
0.7504563332,
0.3894585371,
0.2630679309,
0.7686519623,
-0.1836889386,
-0.0868776366,
0.0962365121,
0.0528963543,
-0.2382262051,
-0.1493276656,
-0.1896010786,
0.1541531533,
0.0676130354,
-0.2879678309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20079v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20079v1 | Molecular Facts: Desiderata for Decontextualization in LLM Fact Verification | 2024-06-28T17:43:48 | 2024-06-28T17:43:48 | Anisha Gunjal, Greg Durrett | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatic factuality verification of large language model (LLM) generations
is becoming more and more widely used to combat hallucinations. A major point
of tension in the literature is the granularity of this fact-checking: larger
chunks of text are hard to fact-check, but more atomic facts like propositions
may lack context to interpret correctly. In this work, we assess the role of
context in these atomic facts. We argue that fully atomic facts are not the
right representation, and define two criteria for molecular facts:
decontextuality, or how well they can stand alone, and minimality, or how
little extra information is added to achieve decontexuality. We quantify the
impact of decontextualization on minimality, then present a baseline
methodology for generating molecular facts automatically, aiming to add the
right amount of information. We compare against various methods of
decontextualization and find that molecular facts balance minimality with fact
verification accuracy in ambiguous settings. | [
-0.299059093,
-1.072740078,
1.0109586716,
-0.2046029121,
-0.4277898967,
-0.11855492,
-0.1491708457,
-0.5589125752,
0.2092115432,
0.3318251073,
-0.3188097179,
-0.6673899293,
-0.6188434362,
0.3913282156,
-0.6858055592,
0.7619459629,
0.2176003158,
-0.3638617694,
-0.4782520533,
-0.270537585,
-0.0168162528,
-0.600833714,
-0.1643590778,
-0.3456130624,
0.3179111481,
0.5665338635,
0.7910558581,
1.0027644634,
0.5624858141,
0.3395723999,
-0.5107538104,
0.427115798,
-0.5547826886,
0.0013765768,
-0.1129443944,
-0.3005731702,
-0.5690256953,
-0.281837225,
0.5525483489,
0.990937531,
0.034514688,
0.0924939588,
-0.2262533009,
0.882153511,
-0.5061426163,
-0.0255643632,
-0.499699831,
0.346732825,
-0.052588921,
-0.2029765695,
-0.1791502833,
-0.560878396,
0.0918091163,
-0.4293728769,
0.3131178319,
0.0314691439,
0.8600034714,
0.4196429849,
-1.1248887777,
-0.3983929753,
-0.8906545043,
0.4440319538,
-0.4923330247,
0.419534862,
0.1700478345,
-0.0698689744,
-0.2149668634,
-0.60211128,
-0.5742339492,
-0.6455056667,
-0.3645828366,
-0.2263269573,
-0.3564486802,
0.2667964995,
0.6025537848,
0.458494097,
-0.5517536402,
-0.2680978477,
-0.4540204108,
-0.4295792282,
0.2900797725,
0.1208006591,
0.5488504171,
-0.1980140507,
-0.4529327452,
0.0660918131,
-0.816937089,
-0.354439348,
0.0608762987,
0.162007004,
-0.139410302,
0.6192706823,
-0.2296265215,
0.3155068159,
0.1860686541,
-0.2648517191,
0.0598066486,
-0.5921809077,
-0.0824187025,
0.5817040801,
0.4061794579,
0.397364378,
0.0303917956,
-0.3681635857,
0.1373616159,
0.0348050073,
0.088034384,
-1.0088760853,
-0.1141536161,
0.2475308627,
-0.3200359046,
-0.0504527166,
-0.1112353206,
-0.7314497232,
-0.545016706,
-0.4070364833,
0.4165824652,
-0.4901489913,
0.0131137976,
-0.1562561095,
-0.4428911507,
-0.0899652764,
0.6492009759,
-0.8465542793,
0.1509102583,
0.5594389439,
0.9110548496,
-0.2387976497,
-0.0855677575,
-0.0892568231,
0.2482776791,
-0.4620590806,
0.7573583722,
-0.3327146471,
-0.4184527397,
-0.29643327,
0.01399747,
0.1381892115,
-0.7361930013,
0.2522101998,
-0.3525566757,
-0.1824289262,
-0.5840774775,
-0.7799177766,
-0.3729284108,
0.1692622453,
-0.5386130214,
0.5856179595,
0.1358812898,
-0.7010869384,
0.5644806027,
-0.5106881261,
-0.6316618323,
0.0179961827,
-0.3828848302,
0.0889804661,
0.1979325712,
-0.2302358299,
0.0779441074,
0.0582145862,
0.5677002668,
-0.3003058732,
-0.2168609053,
0.5157469511,
-0.5090790987,
0.4512969851,
0.1922586858,
-0.6005215049,
-0.1501500607,
-1.1122056246,
-0.4039160907,
-0.3303031027,
-0.6165127754,
-0.1963135153,
0.0103459936,
-0.1858512461,
-0.0518333726,
0.138911292,
-0.4571406245,
0.2766268551,
-0.2010523379,
0.2480366826,
0.4355751276,
0.3026856184,
0.4290983379,
-0.1842710078,
0.1743838787,
0.442861408,
-0.1423764676,
0.1738505065,
-0.3950954378,
-0.8510373235,
-0.1715292484,
0.2682908773,
0.5139704943,
-0.5537625551,
0.5115910769,
-0.1286537796,
-0.2089528739,
0.0655440092,
0.1721548289,
0.1659378707,
0.7157293558,
0.371651113,
0.1127029657,
-1.048956275,
-1.1261669397,
-0.1566581726,
-0.0758585706,
0.0621848553,
0.1523617208,
0.8788052201,
-0.7929800153,
1.0099662542,
-0.4400802255,
-0.1138495356,
-0.0562939309,
0.2063205689,
0.003170643,
0.4607931674,
0.4246092439,
-0.671305418,
0.0739517733,
0.0272861235,
-1.0566874743,
0.0524601042,
-0.0174937844,
0.0107252188,
0.3436747789,
0.6248405576,
-0.6969143748,
0.4150802493,
0.2827498615,
-0.4700269401,
0.1514462382,
-0.3795796335,
0.5122368336,
-0.740239203,
0.283302933,
-0.0397700965,
-0.4562628567,
-0.8337944746,
0.0107397949,
-0.1284929663,
0.3059781492,
-0.4102673829,
0.3902306557,
-0.3359667063,
0.1471221447,
-0.4714660048,
0.3562547266,
-0.0399841554,
0.1825608909,
0.0476515926,
0.6904347539,
0.0830407068,
-0.9418709278,
0.2478468418,
0.0415159017,
-0.4683956504,
0.3476895094,
-0.3899361491,
-0.0658768862,
-0.1814918816,
0.2865664661,
-0.862829864,
-0.4328266084,
0.1011276841,
-0.1162871867,
-0.0078226151,
-0.0442280546,
-0.2290881425,
0.0296987537,
-0.257014513,
0.4890035689,
0.6567079425,
-0.4877707362,
0.6516281962,
0.5506280065,
0.3069415987,
-0.5863902569,
-0.8171538115,
0.2494704276,
-0.3409180641,
-0.4988966286,
0.4088023901,
-0.187762484,
-0.7412065268,
-0.0452020876,
-0.4787497222,
-0.1481441557,
0.1014035493,
0.350731194,
-0.0412979871,
-0.1750177443,
0.2325036079,
0.123416245,
-0.0456117205,
0.2427556068,
0.0913475007,
0.1136221662,
-0.0533974543,
0.0274508409,
-0.2891347706,
0.202391088,
0.5880439281,
0.7501387,
0.5532118082,
0.4667693973,
-0.5394241214,
-0.2385666966,
-0.4240341485,
-0.4360631108,
-0.4411867261,
0.2740572393,
-0.1354125291,
-0.880112946,
0.6530202627,
-0.1403994411,
-0.5132131577,
0.5938380361,
0.5826715827,
0.0558573082,
0.5720791817,
0.7401348352,
0.3680101335,
0.0585323162,
-0.1774464995,
0.3132639229,
-0.5965984464,
-0.2782096267,
-0.2943009436,
-0.1670966595,
-0.5511353016,
-0.5487137437,
0.5861979127,
0.0699423775,
-0.1965880692,
0.2053325772,
-0.1106978506,
0.6351858377,
0.3408565521,
0.2754614353,
0.5582724214,
-0.0615950376,
0.0260358863,
0.2199524939,
-0.6079344749,
-0.6817151904,
0.7895159721,
0.2535358369,
0.5237113237,
0.363337785,
0.5895052552,
0.5566400886,
-0.0728973448,
-0.8333082795,
0.7031952143,
-0.173329547,
-0.6505417824,
-0.1442953497,
-0.8089803457,
-0.744212687,
0.1832847893,
-0.1757483035,
-0.7384516001,
0.5725568533,
0.2972319424,
-0.6505066752,
0.1918317676,
-0.4514793456,
0.5415446758,
0.1124552488,
-0.1294085383,
-0.2492327243,
-0.5534465909,
0.7092514634,
-0.0889068693,
0.4103169441,
-0.2210362852,
-0.073641181,
0.6929899454,
-0.5549678206,
0.9465846419,
0.089282766,
-0.5477638841,
0.2675535977,
0.4092248976,
0.3593071401,
0.2726272345,
0.3848721385,
0.3001506329,
0.2624801695,
0.0456560813,
-0.5587102771,
0.7153532505,
-0.6385307312,
-0.7299197316,
-0.3822409809,
-0.5174016356,
-0.0379782692,
0.063666828,
0.3514910638,
0.5091739297,
-0.255484879,
0.4708040059,
1.1205523014,
0.0165651217,
0.3557342589,
0.6621326804,
-0.101659447,
-0.4467044473,
0.8166720271,
0.2355571389,
0.1951517761,
0.6026840806,
0.3424460292,
-0.2769634724,
-0.461591363,
-0.3291168809,
0.0901525691,
-1.2116310596,
-0.0041454192,
-0.8690630794,
-0.0919004008,
-0.401778698,
0.0520726554,
-0.3965060711,
-0.8112983108,
-0.1408964545,
-0.2381815761,
0.4792409241,
0.7478498816,
-0.4537991583,
-0.1341672689,
-0.8909071684,
0.7281778455,
0.3851908743,
-0.0373331606,
-0.2417728752,
-0.5698960423,
-0.3281266093,
0.2067046463,
-0.0000953533,
-0.9093404412,
-0.0780067816,
0.185899511,
0.4548042417,
0.5821714997,
0.1229719892,
0.6075960994,
-0.3465152979,
0.8163374662,
-0.289031595,
-1.128313899,
0.5181730986,
-0.0655143186,
0.0318260491,
0.587510705,
0.3558491766,
-0.5762698054,
-0.3794623017,
-0.6340361238,
-0.9220446944,
0.414670229,
0.3037769794,
0.0087056076,
-0.0537727103,
0.580750525,
0.0121865543,
0.2119641155,
-0.5856847167,
-0.5264062285,
0.1213429272,
-0.3330915868,
0.0112099079,
-0.5395287275,
-0.6553250551,
-0.4076746106,
0.5359698534,
-0.044855319,
0.0822310224,
0.5090562701,
-0.4206767678,
-0.0971904472,
0.2276174426,
1.2345005274,
0.8376798034,
-0.5488401055,
0.6464520097,
0.3282312453,
-0.6266870499,
0.4698908627,
-0.4904788733,
-0.3306895792,
0.0259437114,
0.6569522023,
0.6716085076,
0.1777563244,
-0.6428802609,
0.2681891322,
0.0789322928,
-0.1150665134,
0.0175214373,
0.3238357306,
-0.0687984899,
0.3186314106,
0.2003792226,
0.1950909048,
0.4624038637,
-0.9373859763,
0.2853043079,
0.3182575703,
0.076122798,
-0.3459832668,
0.3910422027,
0.1531941891,
0.2101443261,
0.3843913674,
-0.2575935423,
-0.452072978,
0.8496742845,
0.375153482,
0.9980022311,
-0.0092461845,
0.0621730238,
0.4349663258,
0.4411495328,
-0.0785148963,
0.0245113689,
-0.1750665158,
-0.6881204844,
-0.058616776,
-0.3805841506,
-0.4890161753,
0.0654836223,
-0.3720120788,
-0.1001783609,
-0.3538364768,
-0.0739282817,
0.0800307468,
-0.1332486719,
-0.1437454969,
0.2036436945,
0.3383380473,
0.7902879119,
-0.98015517,
0.7380800247,
0.3966501653,
-0.2773108184,
-0.2019000649,
0.0446879677,
0.376363039,
-0.6106424332,
1.0548641682,
0.104310669,
-0.5098068714,
-0.2294667661,
-0.3954955041,
-1.1452262402,
0.9020143151,
0.5744124651,
-0.6651633978,
0.0858093426,
0.2446674407,
0.6590480208,
-0.3594405353,
0.1234915331,
0.7695640326,
0.8294488788,
0.3744864166,
-0.5232807398,
0.4000886083,
-0.0738354921,
0.0606714673,
-0.077900283,
-0.2918882966,
0.8867570758,
-0.3826025426,
-0.6570290327,
-0.2495701015,
0.5034883618,
0.018983312,
0.4371141493,
0.3625252545,
0.5080934167,
0.9514445662,
-0.1000465676,
0.9281035662,
-0.6533989906,
0.411934346,
0.9969879985,
-0.182542488,
0.4937975109,
0.5883242488,
-0.2836586833,
0.5231057405,
0.6538646817,
-0.0082039759,
0.3739470541,
0.2131935507,
-0.1259026974,
-0.2512536943,
0.0448980145,
-0.4653938711,
0.4975327253,
0.2996610403,
-0.1761340797,
-0.3340001106,
0.0893266052,
0.3108080924,
-0.1228555366,
-0.0597314388,
0.9546173215,
-0.0390157476,
-0.4492528141,
0.8396303058,
-0.035671588,
0.2827380002,
-0.3839836717,
-0.1979105026,
-0.6401159167,
0.3540299237,
-0.3916038573,
-0.4809943438,
0.4044238627,
-0.0150544718,
-0.6219142675,
0.2225590795,
0.5901794434,
-0.604704082,
-0.2772388458,
0.0760622695,
0.2624668181,
0.1137415171,
-0.0537391752,
-0.2174119502,
0.1670062393,
0.0715829879,
-0.0157766566,
0.1462440044,
0.5440306067,
0.1831512004,
0.7330924273,
0.2135057598,
-0.1277703047,
-0.152904287,
-0.1542951763,
0.7016499043,
-0.967841804,
-0.1328383386,
-1.3714538813,
0.2879233956,
0.037155997,
-0.2990796566,
1.1344949007,
0.5769099593,
0.5987019539,
-0.0889623985,
0.533544898,
-0.0606661551,
0.0641721338,
-0.7009918094,
0.6680633426,
-0.3958659172,
0.3345493674,
-0.0739881694,
-0.8150532842,
-0.3397434652,
0.442676276,
0.1237106994,
0.2485210001,
1.0944517851,
0.8956888318,
-0.0372545794,
0.0819770843,
0.357378304,
0.5409394503,
0.1544775814,
0.4774863124,
0.8816022277,
-0.394982487,
0.0995774269,
-0.4831442833,
-0.0766936243,
-0.7061979771,
-1.1707661152,
-0.7745018601,
-0.5203091502,
-0.9649912715,
-0.3972207606,
-0.029643435,
1.1663558483,
0.7286261916,
-0.8348193765,
-0.2258779705,
-0.2457071543,
0.4943093657,
0.0094696134,
-0.212497741,
0.3322749734,
-0.1700980067,
-0.3829082549,
0.6648035049,
0.4697464108,
0.539617002,
-0.1809156388,
-0.0157975629,
-0.0770400017,
0.4611179829,
0.7878778577,
0.1442595869,
-0.8411459327,
-0.2922103107,
-0.4945598245,
-0.2993703783,
0.3452190757,
0.9318392873,
-0.6321596503,
0.2954081595,
0.5852412581,
0.226501599,
0.0297990423,
0.1749373674,
0.3621052802,
-0.621963203,
0.0839162096,
-0.0418016352,
0.4235770404,
0.1774965227,
-0.7260339856,
0.4700255096,
0.609905839,
-0.5354257226,
-1.0513962507,
0.2900376618,
-1.1151524782,
-0.5914658308,
1.153903842,
0.1377734393,
-0.5763478875,
-0.0558338873,
-0.070547618,
0.2138782889,
-0.2420638651,
0.9830459356,
0.5865902901,
-0.2143618912,
0.0319451988,
-0.310023576,
1.0620971918,
0.0845364854,
-0.948409915,
0.3781945109,
0.70834589,
0.2046833932,
0.3886773586,
0.3642144203,
0.2270147502,
0.2414397448,
0.3009904325,
-0.080755122,
-0.0126175759,
-0.6326695085,
-0.5133037567,
0.2876182795,
-0.1573508829,
0.1977455467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20060v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20060v1 | Applying RLAIF for Code Generation with API-usage in Lightweight LLMs | 2024-06-28T17:16:03 | 2024-06-28T17:16:03 | Sujan Dutta, Sayantan Mahinder, Raviteja Anantha, Bortik Bandyopadhyay | cs.CL | cs.CL | Reinforcement Learning from AI Feedback (RLAIF) has demonstrated significant
potential across various domains, including mitigating harm in LLM outputs,
enhancing text summarization, and mathematical reasoning. This paper introduces
an RLAIF framework for improving the code generation abilities of lightweight
(<1B parameters) LLMs. We specifically focus on code generation tasks that
require writing appropriate API calls, which is challenging due to the
well-known issue of hallucination in LLMs. Our framework extracts AI feedback
from a larger LLM (e.g., GPT-3.5) through a specialized prompting strategy and
uses this data to train a reward model towards better alignment from smaller
LLMs. We run our experiments on the Gorilla dataset and meticulously assess the
quality of the model-generated code across various metrics, including AST,
ROUGE, and Code-BLEU, and develop a pipeline to compute its executability rate
accurately. Our approach significantly enhances the fine-tuned LLM baseline's
performance, achieving a 4.5% improvement in executability rate. Notably, a
smaller LLM model (780M parameters) trained with RLAIF surpasses a much larger
fine-tuned baseline with 7B parameters, achieving a 1.0% higher code
executability rate. | [
-0.2162793279,
-0.7348615527,
0.2528093159,
0.2979615033,
-0.3883237839,
-0.0666756704,
-0.322583735,
-0.4640190899,
0.1885572821,
0.3499567509,
-0.7561818957,
-0.5957519412,
-0.5251787901,
0.1170145646,
-0.0911078155,
1.1697449684,
-0.0706286877,
-0.1211474612,
-0.2587923408,
-0.2931498885,
-0.6003302336,
-0.2588674426,
-0.7006139755,
-0.4343892336,
0.6907689571,
0.5428050756,
0.6902443767,
0.8784485459,
0.3100195825,
0.2190321088,
0.1881099194,
0.4764830172,
-0.653835535,
0.1920843869,
0.2303499281,
-0.4124540985,
-0.380853951,
-0.1628299356,
0.1139548719,
0.2950077653,
-0.3801623285,
0.4627973735,
0.1506152153,
0.7603673339,
-0.5566956401,
0.2981621921,
-0.4806332588,
0.2767631114,
0.1999933571,
-0.5886109471,
-0.555498004,
-0.39708969,
-0.2531726658,
-0.588021636,
-0.0429512039,
0.301379025,
0.6575604677,
0.8200036287,
0.0453810729,
-0.5634834766,
-0.3097103238,
0.8151871562,
-0.7692043185,
0.2046853453,
0.168884024,
-0.1571937203,
-0.21988298,
-0.8345487118,
-0.1819830984,
-0.6495992541,
-0.1001109853,
0.113218911,
0.2101280093,
-0.0216091387,
0.4014447927,
0.2635099292,
-0.6658440828,
0.1897021234,
-0.3601627648,
-0.1900752783,
0.657871902,
0.2444992363,
0.1269955486,
-0.2272765785,
-0.1702688336,
0.0515706651,
-0.9384818673,
0.3164565861,
0.656267345,
0.3991380632,
-0.2306675464,
0.5632963777,
-0.1326877773,
0.634995997,
0.2066489309,
-0.5665184855,
0.2431285679,
0.0503767356,
-0.1038480848,
0.0571083054,
0.5512216091,
0.3867978752,
0.078655839,
-0.1309712976,
-0.525723815,
-0.0995730683,
0.5141795874,
-1.145740509,
-0.4049119651,
0.2580710351,
-0.9368195534,
-0.4825350642,
0.0037105391,
-0.4663321972,
-0.4462423921,
-0.4196411967,
0.1847639382,
-0.3505211174,
-0.04800798,
-0.0250238124,
0.1185514331,
0.3203803301,
0.2131169587,
-0.8938578367,
0.0183762517,
0.671739459,
0.7007702589,
-0.3093270063,
-0.3823004365,
-1.1845107079,
0.0127167962,
-0.2762845755,
0.64980793,
-0.2281961143,
-0.5260690451,
0.0214011054,
-0.3644633591,
0.2074842751,
-0.8501747847,
0.3827260435,
-0.2802347839,
-0.2869388163,
0.1054629385,
-0.3872616291,
-0.0005178352,
0.1049648225,
-0.581177175,
1.245816946,
0.2300903648,
-0.6090350747,
0.7394024134,
-0.3239085376,
-0.5913232565,
0.2631157041,
-0.3436551094,
-0.7527074218,
0.171551168,
0.4175763428,
0.4150207639,
-0.1135313883,
0.3026857376,
-0.36652565,
-0.7284838557,
0.2407350689,
-0.2847782373,
0.20636186,
0.1875243038,
-0.5671133995,
0.4127479792,
-0.779744029,
0.2286502719,
-0.0917399898,
-0.7336317897,
0.1195299253,
0.0559675954,
0.040131826,
-0.01401887,
0.164553985,
-0.1181515679,
0.1695869863,
-0.2937584221,
0.3021896183,
0.861210227,
0.1847352833,
0.3606854379,
-0.5468405485,
0.6886661053,
-0.4666907489,
0.1544456333,
0.0084474115,
-0.3195789754,
-0.7267059684,
-0.7029750943,
0.2809174955,
0.5474821329,
-0.8335097432,
0.4862021208,
0.0696418807,
-0.3346635699,
-0.6353462934,
0.669110477,
0.529622674,
0.4880298674,
0.2603304386,
-0.064188689,
-0.5072928667,
-0.6713919044,
-0.0935583264,
-0.4905447066,
0.1187410504,
0.6685475707,
0.480561167,
-0.3930976987,
0.7068601847,
-0.3626511097,
-0.1232425645,
-0.4847917259,
0.3848376572,
0.1417582184,
0.6382197738,
0.3277707398,
-0.5346006155,
-0.0592655353,
-0.369133085,
-0.807441771,
-0.40018031,
-0.2418885678,
-0.0354838222,
0.374330461,
0.6700469255,
-0.3209605813,
0.3853226006,
0.4835993052,
0.0496787615,
0.4329682887,
-0.2212870121,
0.0642431304,
-0.7061667442,
0.0521582067,
-0.1984395981,
-0.2781991363,
0.0284101367,
0.3046527207,
0.0022970242,
-0.1914573312,
-0.6827030778,
0.5326863527,
-0.1735911369,
-0.1610745639,
-0.4802138805,
-0.0071645416,
-0.3412543833,
0.7955064774,
0.1308147609,
0.994191885,
0.3654761314,
-0.8333779573,
0.4061726928,
0.1045495719,
-0.242509529,
0.4540864229,
-0.8217286468,
-0.0569013283,
-0.0241596568,
0.4314354956,
-0.5223295093,
-0.2121041417,
0.4450318813,
-0.4286987782,
0.1297514439,
-0.2435777038,
-0.5712987185,
-0.2161775827,
-0.522151947,
0.4695009887,
0.6601973176,
-0.9058021307,
0.7086251974,
0.0642400458,
-0.207284227,
-0.739158392,
-0.6023991108,
-0.1436910778,
-0.3374872506,
-0.6008989811,
0.0255977977,
-0.2206939906,
-0.0713244826,
-0.0372234285,
-0.1302062422,
0.5085985065,
0.21808438,
0.7675117254,
0.2806799412,
0.0346083902,
0.0756950304,
0.1030959487,
-0.3421616554,
0.081617564,
-0.36625126,
0.3568542302,
-0.1420048922,
-0.398568064,
-0.4167222679,
0.0573069751,
0.0863568187,
-0.0750358254,
0.3949767947,
0.8043688536,
0.0539254993,
-0.8365961909,
-0.2263830602,
-0.3258141279,
-0.476123333,
0.2650040686,
-0.2353909612,
-1.1515541077,
0.4143896997,
-0.2398287654,
0.1741883457,
0.0749810264,
0.7632275224,
0.1393212229,
1.0227066278,
0.7269293666,
-0.0647944659,
0.375820756,
-0.2956178188,
0.1171549782,
-0.7004182339,
-0.390348047,
-0.2876423001,
-0.4084201455,
-0.6201232076,
-0.2840776742,
0.2500024438,
0.2514909804,
-0.1689809561,
0.1654694229,
-0.6091654301,
0.309381634,
0.4764799774,
0.2125846297,
0.1392663866,
-0.137578696,
-0.0435521007,
0.0660310462,
-0.8700404763,
-0.4070032239,
0.9846482873,
0.4369407892,
1.3628243208,
-0.0337412506,
1.0680855513,
0.6098777652,
0.6173275113,
-0.830432117,
0.5131587386,
0.2458643913,
0.0276469346,
-0.0138670001,
-0.7770486474,
-0.5710240006,
0.0263007507,
-0.2452935427,
-0.461055845,
-0.0712057874,
0.4237214625,
-0.5493760109,
-0.0754344389,
-0.5447686315,
0.5319396853,
-0.3866573274,
-0.4783151746,
-0.0935410187,
-0.4307073951,
0.6499829292,
0.0926723704,
0.1195719913,
-0.0030091631,
-0.2358645648,
0.656593442,
-0.6675088406,
0.9006180763,
-0.1823355854,
-0.4226088226,
0.4702587724,
0.0564506948,
0.6912231445,
0.894720614,
-0.045115795,
-0.2504632771,
-0.3682760298,
-0.2156285197,
-0.5280699134,
0.7491673231,
-0.8936588764,
-0.3108073771,
-0.2753854692,
-0.8307535648,
0.0036361616,
-0.163109839,
0.4864745438,
0.4855148792,
0.1381480694,
0.0817147866,
0.8774555922,
-0.3756114542,
0.3345583975,
0.3691432178,
-0.3543252349,
-0.7320798039,
1.1377184391,
-0.3071810603,
-0.0217700191,
0.1037326604,
-0.2200824022,
-0.2800154686,
-0.5132174492,
-0.7456130981,
0.0554108433,
-0.789832592,
-0.6044660211,
-0.4806617498,
-0.1258872449,
-0.2698236406,
-0.4341100454,
-0.1776125729,
-0.3280959129,
-0.364320457,
-0.1929786354,
0.514300108,
0.7819389105,
-0.2011115253,
0.2750992179,
-0.7050979137,
0.3498091102,
0.2695302963,
0.3029397726,
0.0114300912,
-0.5843042731,
-0.3121171892,
-0.3460146785,
-0.0519887432,
-0.3445603549,
0.2282186151,
0.0704760402,
0.5741089582,
0.1822853833,
0.1389841735,
0.7522339225,
-0.2461836338,
0.8098247647,
0.0824764147,
-0.8134530783,
0.4325559437,
-0.0522558242,
0.107159093,
0.6479024887,
-0.1640279442,
-0.0577841848,
-0.5746602416,
-0.6033000946,
-1.0224286318,
0.5351592302,
0.0718292519,
0.0826915056,
0.0926924869,
0.7663517594,
0.2042717189,
0.3126738369,
-0.9329856038,
-0.1436621398,
-0.1356711835,
-0.1931043714,
0.2647195756,
0.0129182003,
-0.1286785603,
0.0393691845,
0.8983954191,
-0.5018720627,
0.1559321135,
-0.0951578915,
-0.3422347009,
-0.2759443521,
-0.0374509357,
0.6539593935,
0.6327387691,
-0.1720039248,
0.0322140232,
0.2271537185,
-0.3275900185,
0.0735655129,
0.0751845315,
-0.3687925637,
-0.3461104631,
0.5117627978,
0.7272615433,
0.1156646907,
-1.125302434,
0.4243596792,
-0.2901287079,
-0.3610328734,
-0.1649118811,
0.494658947,
-0.1248136237,
0.3698543906,
0.3108634055,
0.0187665392,
0.0042917561,
-0.225346908,
0.464255631,
0.4089826941,
-0.3100240231,
0.0890811458,
0.719618082,
0.3843909502,
-0.1732408404,
0.6570197344,
-0.5274724364,
-0.2659353018,
0.6102454662,
0.5534123778,
0.7173290849,
0.3912117481,
0.2686970234,
0.3929353952,
0.2107566744,
-0.0234334022,
0.2810387015,
-0.3166805506,
-0.2383402586,
-0.619282186,
-0.7858879566,
-0.3829380274,
0.0473600961,
-0.5957728028,
0.2857475281,
-0.7674913406,
0.0264008977,
-0.6764010787,
0.0886148885,
-0.2785094678,
0.1236200109,
0.098820135,
0.7644925714,
-0.6305707693,
0.4320865571,
0.4584020972,
-0.6743365526,
-1.1614373922,
0.0748426318,
0.0442026965,
-0.8731022477,
0.6956038475,
0.2568524182,
-0.3892673254,
0.0169740412,
-0.8711743355,
-0.5458825827,
1.325515151,
0.4027772844,
-0.2037748396,
0.202245757,
-0.1279810667,
0.2743303776,
-0.5430995226,
0.1525625587,
0.3884012997,
0.3148833215,
0.1113394126,
-0.4094805419,
0.1503791958,
-0.3053358495,
0.2788816988,
0.0335773937,
-0.6689245105,
0.596990943,
-0.5436813831,
0.0929909796,
0.5062578321,
1.0308694839,
0.9574803114,
0.0857377499,
0.3838391006,
0.6990467906,
0.6952024698,
0.2227523476,
1.0046495199,
-0.505110085,
0.1817115843,
0.9828565717,
-0.3465597332,
0.6895247698,
0.4672544897,
0.3458065987,
0.5964607,
0.779838264,
-0.1397926211,
0.4920326769,
0.6123008132,
-0.0641962513,
-0.1901220679,
-0.0986872837,
-0.3519747257,
-0.0153213181,
0.0819190666,
-0.156735003,
-0.0469907559,
0.2152658999,
0.133790046,
0.05868854,
-0.4265400469,
0.8314106464,
0.1768365204,
-0.8453147411,
0.631921947,
0.2260304689,
0.8806086183,
-0.4716877639,
-0.2935725451,
-0.4295099676,
0.3362221122,
-0.4880531728,
-0.404009074,
0.017561581,
0.1902475655,
-0.1295307875,
-0.240253225,
0.8062461019,
-0.2626253963,
-0.317681402,
0.3181750476,
0.4773107767,
-0.0412845537,
0.4584020972,
-0.8616256118,
0.3864417672,
0.0084267352,
-0.2102095634,
0.3923303187,
0.4000667036,
0.2685956657,
0.8139113784,
0.7493446469,
0.190710023,
0.0953752995,
0.1165947318,
0.8988298774,
-0.3473218381,
-0.5557001233,
-0.5578325987,
0.400893271,
0.3244761229,
-0.4768792689,
0.5803899169,
0.6212384105,
0.7037793994,
-0.1337273419,
0.8031401634,
-0.2313864827,
0.184041366,
-0.8259616494,
0.4675341845,
-0.50499928,
0.5553948283,
-0.186761871,
-0.9322195053,
-0.2358762026,
0.6836268306,
-0.0055000056,
0.2516225874,
0.4856381416,
1.1392803192,
0.0733649656,
-0.1933108121,
0.0756942779,
-0.2974578738,
0.3453686535,
0.5640621185,
0.9996193051,
-0.2490593046,
0.8638526797,
-0.1324898452,
-0.1845365316,
-0.2937402129,
-0.9301236868,
-0.8348687887,
-0.0978296772,
-0.4850950837,
-0.6445819736,
0.1609735489,
1.1616009474,
0.8053230047,
-0.5153364539,
-0.2256382257,
-0.3379665911,
0.1351974159,
-0.4794820249,
-0.2264776975,
0.2768598795,
-0.8168082833,
-0.4035501182,
0.3648160994,
0.2455620319,
-0.1997461915,
-0.2688956261,
-0.8780905604,
0.3282620013,
0.058992859,
0.4279815853,
0.4063184261,
-0.5681051612,
-0.3876563907,
-0.1225220039,
-0.1692476422,
-0.2102368325,
1.0604362488,
-0.9904893637,
-0.2288300544,
0.2917369604,
0.9005700946,
0.2754403651,
0.1512212157,
0.3511696458,
-0.9542091489,
0.2699969411,
0.2454393506,
0.272305578,
0.3303219974,
-0.4706725478,
0.5626890659,
0.1804507375,
-0.7449811101,
-0.81223315,
0.2928748727,
-0.8853166699,
-0.2162364572,
1.2081888914,
-0.0989019573,
-0.242032066,
0.1929100752,
-0.3071452081,
0.04873145,
-0.718798399,
0.8024633527,
0.2533072233,
-0.5263723135,
-0.4749770761,
-0.4393998384,
0.7301938534,
0.4475473464,
-0.972373724,
0.1984583884,
0.6965950131,
0.2036198676,
-0.0392786823,
0.7170021534,
-0.0685343817,
0.5789111257,
-0.0683005005,
0.0412666984,
-0.3376365006,
-0.3968511224,
-0.2153076231,
0.2726394832,
0.4573775828,
0.1257712096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20054v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20054v1 | To Word Senses and Beyond: Inducing Concepts with Contextualized Language Models | 2024-06-28T17:07:06 | 2024-06-28T17:07:06 | Bastien Liétard, Pascal Denis, Mikaella Keller | cs.CL | cs.CL | Polysemy and synonymy are two crucial interrelated facets of lexical
ambiguity. While both phenomena have been studied extensively in NLP, leading
to dedicated systems, they are often been considered independently. While many
tasks dealing with polysemy (e.g. Word Sense Disambiguiation or Induction)
highlight the role of a word's senses, the study of synonymy is rooted in the
study of concepts, i.e. meaning shared across the lexicon. In this paper, we
introduce Concept Induction, the unsupervised task of learning a soft
clustering among words that defines a set of concepts directly from data. This
task generalizes that of Word Sense Induction. We propose a bi-level approach
to Concept Induction that leverages both a local lemma-centric view and a
global cross-lexicon perspective to induce concepts. We evaluate the obtained
clustering on SemCor's annotated data and obtain good performances (BCubed F1
above 0.60). We find that the local and the global levels are mutually
beneficial to induce concepts and also senses in our setting. Finally, we
create static embeddings representing our induced concepts and use them on the
Word-in-Context task, obtaining competitive performances with the
State-of-the-Art. | [
-0.3992277384,
-0.5809077621,
0.5709566474,
-0.1328356564,
-0.4484730065,
-0.0440839194,
-0.3473490477,
-0.3750242591,
0.3450784385,
-0.0910470933,
-0.2484495938,
-0.3515529037,
-0.6549407244,
0.0653204918,
-0.5786670446,
0.7402541041,
0.0620720722,
-0.0984100327,
-0.6131843328,
-0.2078225613,
-0.3184698224,
-0.5560967922,
-0.1404816955,
-0.4210525453,
0.5324638486,
0.3237994313,
0.4756576717,
0.3117768764,
0.1545960307,
0.2940233648,
-0.2786296904,
0.3167824149,
-0.1913436651,
0.2078904808,
-0.6313453913,
-0.7109761834,
-0.0638955757,
0.2559515834,
0.458095789,
1.1634501219,
-0.4452421069,
-0.0844717324,
0.161360085,
0.4077705145,
-0.7252457738,
0.1169813722,
-1.1705598831,
-0.0629177839,
-0.1535782516,
-0.0081542768,
0.0262200534,
0.0576566719,
0.2477008998,
-0.6919201016,
0.5569289327,
-0.0222298391,
0.7531161904,
0.1887562573,
-0.0895244256,
-0.5622300506,
-0.3706150949,
0.5417975187,
-0.3329694271,
0.4879525304,
-0.0655136332,
-0.1908063143,
-0.3111272454,
-0.6174721122,
-1.3207864761,
0.09316203,
-0.0450533107,
0.4150699079,
0.1836669445,
-0.1039242595,
0.1141943932,
0.3933990598,
-0.2839002609,
0.0547767878,
-0.2951399684,
0.2587326765,
0.430351764,
-0.0301325843,
0.2868823707,
-0.485229373,
-0.3079679012,
0.0764375553,
-0.6571773887,
-0.1035705283,
-0.0860372186,
0.5003985763,
-0.0715491995,
0.7716993093,
-0.2694150209,
0.3741535246,
0.1230669245,
0.0140959956,
0.4854097068,
-0.4785829782,
-0.0637891591,
0.5040627122,
0.3657648563,
0.2824608982,
0.3513461649,
-0.5564685464,
-0.1916365325,
0.9427775145,
0.2008649111,
-0.3675859869,
0.2208770216,
0.1998364776,
-0.0665418357,
-0.2617929578,
0.4670394063,
-0.3430345058,
-0.4430505037,
-0.5956764817,
0.6579287052,
-0.4054656327,
-0.6087412238,
0.1834018975,
-0.640648663,
0.4161832333,
-0.0224783309,
-0.9978124499,
0.2632924914,
0.933309257,
0.8796364069,
-0.3282760382,
-0.5822865367,
-0.0973899662,
0.43642658,
-0.6465377808,
0.7562552094,
-0.5753505826,
-0.6055333018,
0.1745277345,
0.0299387015,
-0.238863647,
-0.7787345648,
0.0530754216,
-0.1908450425,
0.372418046,
-0.2126380056,
-0.7309659719,
0.0245748851,
0.0731023848,
-0.1407923549,
1.1147180796,
0.2720136642,
-0.8592332006,
0.7223013639,
-0.7894066572,
-0.4301300049,
0.2390685529,
-0.4364222884,
0.3418093026,
0.8115871549,
0.0872621462,
0.666359663,
-0.0747773647,
0.2779853642,
-0.065694347,
-0.2766931355,
0.1799616218,
0.316513896,
0.3657194376,
-0.0808949769,
-0.31962201,
0.0218267478,
-0.2985316515,
-0.2521571517,
0.3501515687,
0.306299746,
-0.9153752923,
-0.075481005,
-0.4372842312,
0.2237815261,
-0.146733582,
-0.6235753894,
-0.0014757508,
-0.9712834954,
0.3534683883,
0.5373194814,
-0.0425065979,
0.7000274658,
-0.20663248,
0.1392340213,
0.5925457478,
-0.2307591438,
-0.0239312313,
-0.4301264286,
-0.9067080617,
0.1269014031,
0.3086801767,
0.4020543694,
-0.9125269651,
0.6647421122,
-0.3480397463,
-0.6606041789,
-0.2874082327,
0.2473939359,
-0.0221347772,
0.5402297974,
0.2426505685,
-0.3396134675,
-0.0651523545,
-0.6260079741,
-0.0552381873,
0.1988061965,
-0.1000517681,
0.1250660717,
0.5724949837,
-0.386523962,
0.8458961844,
-0.5410858393,
-0.3333804011,
-0.3397418559,
0.253672123,
0.3902672231,
0.3461703062,
0.4096185863,
-0.7751220465,
-0.2177047431,
-0.0346125588,
-0.8414221406,
-0.1627368331,
0.0828689039,
-0.2541987896,
0.1418585032,
0.6213857532,
-0.6772878766,
0.4148130715,
0.4510183334,
-0.1491665095,
0.4418808818,
0.0226266365,
-0.2439479828,
-1.6014976501,
-0.1804047823,
0.0598931983,
0.1616673023,
-0.4934055209,
0.2368279696,
-0.0815292224,
-0.1340868175,
-0.4333812594,
0.5142635703,
-0.4000560641,
-0.059669327,
-0.4047966003,
0.5955975652,
0.0808217376,
-0.0008080629,
0.342382282,
0.7143042684,
0.8359297514,
-0.8716659546,
0.516289711,
0.2970075309,
-0.5254196525,
0.7139153481,
-0.4790731966,
-0.028690381,
-0.3509274423,
0.0828583315,
-0.5890522003,
-0.0077230153,
0.2178551853,
-0.5296173692,
0.210219726,
0.3171183169,
-0.4708769619,
-0.2079318464,
-0.1223838106,
0.5227254033,
0.2909120917,
-0.8178108335,
0.2662526369,
0.3989393711,
-0.1078829095,
-0.2897750139,
-0.3963039815,
-0.0407593027,
-0.4415980279,
-0.2795179188,
0.7431101203,
0.3023610413,
-0.5053088069,
0.1211189106,
-0.2335153371,
0.3163228929,
-0.0281281658,
0.4554802179,
-0.0205441043,
0.0658834055,
0.4010264277,
0.3074273467,
-0.2495456934,
0.1280387938,
-0.6126224995,
0.4268144369,
0.0188276134,
-0.3886916339,
-0.2044594586,
0.5087946653,
0.2719680965,
-0.2933803499,
0.778060019,
0.5581104755,
-0.5713068247,
-0.5294271111,
-0.3321537375,
-0.4146870077,
-0.4412705898,
0.057454776,
-0.635933876,
-0.7431595922,
0.2921980619,
-0.517694056,
-0.4363732338,
0.407320857,
0.5536612272,
-0.1246052533,
0.8171665072,
0.6408897638,
0.2301643789,
0.4251589179,
-0.5066862702,
0.4365192354,
-0.9336490035,
-0.3737420738,
-0.3510290384,
-0.2295443416,
-0.6416887045,
-0.8377074003,
0.5343936682,
0.3525499105,
0.3000107706,
0.0400775298,
-0.4185192883,
0.235382244,
0.6525723934,
0.0443818271,
-0.0730739832,
0.0892695785,
-0.6305675507,
0.0317785814,
-0.9294007421,
-0.0369206294,
0.837372303,
-0.2241779119,
0.532890439,
0.0725998729,
0.9698812962,
-0.1285272837,
0.0612057485,
-1.0751818419,
0.5342776775,
-0.1136308089,
-0.3071662188,
-0.1271234453,
-0.0912168622,
-0.8692592978,
0.1932368279,
-0.4229716659,
-0.8446962833,
0.3726945817,
-0.15542458,
-0.2197103202,
0.0260141008,
-0.6037476659,
0.5650074482,
-0.030983299,
-0.3523190022,
-0.5754261017,
-0.3726174831,
0.2660691142,
-0.150734365,
0.1730394065,
-0.3075731099,
-0.1584831178,
0.5744839907,
-0.2367518395,
0.6305022836,
-0.1597475559,
-0.2417701632,
0.2237996012,
0.0937811956,
0.0575924404,
0.1105294228,
-0.1478497833,
0.3990348876,
0.1774622053,
-0.2941182554,
-0.7563211918,
0.8167973161,
-0.3257807791,
-0.7787541747,
-0.6610683203,
-0.6628485918,
-0.3703500926,
0.0297533739,
0.2963753045,
0.380179435,
0.0272798333,
0.0184411425,
0.6713035703,
-0.1594920903,
0.2833661139,
0.1241325215,
-0.1285740882,
0.1055126563,
0.9732515812,
-0.025183253,
0.1895062327,
0.4550120533,
0.5427553058,
-0.5894399285,
-0.3481911123,
-0.193484664,
0.1672454029,
-0.3679561019,
-0.2101359665,
-0.3537043333,
-0.2807599604,
-0.5960559845,
-0.3594948351,
-0.0554891117,
-0.395085156,
0.0091704018,
-0.271073997,
0.236075744,
0.6187627316,
-0.4730319381,
0.2778829634,
-0.510476172,
0.6505979896,
0.3686574399,
0.3064526021,
-0.0150257647,
-0.4152100682,
-0.2690855563,
0.055674959,
0.0427649207,
-0.8339979649,
0.2029167563,
0.4736918211,
0.6391303539,
0.8027288914,
-0.0993928239,
0.7192164063,
-0.5017789602,
0.8331120014,
0.3274556994,
-1.203997016,
0.8290868998,
-0.2087895125,
0.256077826,
0.2759881914,
0.7017523646,
-0.9413295984,
-0.4567617178,
-0.7005483508,
-0.890843153,
0.4617768824,
-0.252079159,
0.5742043257,
-0.432389766,
0.5170835853,
0.4902913868,
0.4013560116,
-0.4034076333,
0.0159108322,
-0.2877378464,
-0.1687638611,
-0.2351180166,
-0.279895395,
-0.1039980724,
-0.7660996914,
0.4941594303,
-0.3147814274,
0.1709968746,
0.1537593305,
-0.381747961,
0.1142094657,
0.1169649661,
0.15029791,
0.9261265993,
0.0788952485,
0.5707489252,
0.2823936641,
-0.0455219261,
0.0151870959,
0.0568357445,
-0.0207717847,
0.1484590769,
0.2769687176,
0.3903536201,
0.2694586217,
-0.5115209818,
0.5100833178,
0.1606849879,
-0.1717302352,
-0.1045647785,
0.2772172987,
0.1491083801,
0.0634956211,
0.2542909384,
-0.648581624,
0.020108385,
-0.6536430717,
0.2764639854,
0.7791050076,
-0.0914505124,
-0.2679585814,
0.473398298,
0.1124555916,
0.0406080894,
0.4616847038,
-0.5307102203,
-0.8075440526,
0.205441013,
0.8978279233,
0.5210098028,
-0.3209092319,
0.1259235293,
0.4131942391,
0.0278765596,
0.3148293197,
0.4739509523,
-0.3326559067,
-1.4847143888,
-0.1876437068,
-0.8857011795,
-0.1841088235,
0.0058337497,
-0.654063344,
-0.0010737587,
-0.1640317589,
0.1071014404,
0.2563715875,
-0.1118688211,
-0.5718505383,
0.2737420201,
0.4325403273,
0.966811657,
-1.0913830996,
0.8763777614,
0.9865592122,
-0.198215425,
-0.6718943715,
0.2039527446,
-0.1149658486,
-0.9081551433,
0.5039963126,
0.3658909202,
-0.0582193546,
0.1778624654,
-0.3451057374,
-0.5407073498,
0.9652449489,
-0.319162637,
-0.4075539112,
0.0743349269,
0.3148323894,
0.3114167452,
-0.413352102,
-0.2256526202,
0.6759136915,
0.2506892979,
0.0598589629,
-0.5426859856,
0.1352025121,
-0.0928699821,
0.1846917123,
0.2755522132,
-0.0723072067,
0.4584592581,
-0.318164438,
-0.2552616,
-0.1110787839,
0.7238654494,
0.1325778067,
0.3672650456,
0.8454871774,
0.9442431927,
0.6463096142,
-0.1687137485,
0.639737606,
-0.4914671183,
-0.083342582,
0.8668980002,
-0.4119853377,
0.7252693176,
0.8994894624,
-0.0496285148,
0.7329472303,
0.6298286915,
0.1343952715,
0.5097453594,
0.3447188139,
-0.4989584386,
-0.2022178173,
-0.7743838429,
-0.4848206639,
0.8371002674,
1.0086385012,
-0.1521487385,
-0.2404175401,
-0.0285402667,
-0.2896290123,
0.3843955994,
-0.3695965409,
0.9976425171,
0.4091568291,
-0.439319551,
0.2169947773,
0.0024068055,
0.821348846,
-0.4823078811,
0.1167863011,
-0.3247907758,
-0.0966257304,
-0.0906040519,
-0.5360022783,
0.3491596282,
-0.3367590904,
-0.2029850483,
-0.0623367429,
0.8088180423,
-0.5528243184,
-0.539519608,
0.422765404,
0.9678910375,
0.0335188471,
-0.2035039365,
-0.5435262322,
-0.2368047088,
-0.7252111435,
0.2686651349,
0.1712138653,
0.7007495761,
-0.1367720515,
0.1264742017,
0.611700654,
0.3836426437,
-0.1735318154,
0.3325593174,
0.7032194734,
-0.7303942442,
-0.471767813,
-0.5898519158,
0.1548682302,
0.0570803657,
-0.2120123953,
0.6689883471,
0.4529953301,
1.0558670759,
0.1017708108,
0.7310669422,
-0.3805926144,
0.4326815009,
-0.4093836844,
0.478220731,
-0.8268384933,
-0.3324119151,
-0.2296598703,
-0.9597223401,
-0.1011563316,
0.4806885719,
-0.2902382314,
-0.293487072,
0.808824718,
0.9494226575,
-0.2441244572,
0.0241622124,
0.3709802032,
0.0993839726,
-0.1474080086,
0.3800552189,
1.0869827271,
0.090928942,
-0.1509639919,
-0.4722512662,
-0.3203026354,
-0.021846734,
-0.7989379764,
-0.710029304,
-1.0175762177,
-0.0382625312,
-0.3348217905,
0.0241914429,
0.9710683823,
0.6377683282,
-0.7588487864,
-0.1996465176,
-0.3339986503,
0.3864396513,
-0.3838185072,
-0.2654607892,
0.2984251976,
-0.7277987003,
-0.849171102,
0.5317648649,
0.1116352677,
-0.0711943805,
-0.3032582402,
0.2385902256,
-0.2837832272,
0.0615713149,
0.8926926255,
-0.1658841819,
-0.6421496272,
-0.340061605,
-0.4034607112,
0.1615876108,
-0.1924114227,
0.8001183867,
-0.9921392202,
0.4241843224,
0.4122620225,
0.4721237421,
0.1108179316,
0.0430906527,
0.6091049314,
-0.8787764311,
0.6123555899,
0.0010505815,
0.3329465389,
0.3668608963,
-0.1549205333,
0.4778285921,
0.7683001757,
0.132837683,
-0.8546422124,
0.4080875218,
-0.6893721819,
-0.4122669399,
1.1763817072,
0.338928014,
-0.2035886496,
0.0644651428,
0.185519442,
0.4642783701,
0.1725500524,
0.8900649548,
0.4704468846,
-0.1842494607,
0.2829437852,
-0.2470461428,
0.497382015,
0.4603112042,
-0.7456313968,
-0.17098701,
0.1729252189,
0.1170632467,
0.3565684557,
0.0553285889,
0.1005007699,
0.1246365458,
0.1482197344,
0.1784268022,
0.2300218046,
-0.4178028703,
-0.1594874263,
-0.0489966124,
0.012796957,
-0.3549686968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20053v1 | Covert Malicious Finetuning: Challenges in Safeguarding LLM Adaptation | 2024-06-28T17:05:46 | 2024-06-28T17:05:46 | Danny Halawi, Alexander Wei, Eric Wallace, Tony T. Wang, Nika Haghtalab, Jacob Steinhardt | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Black-box finetuning is an emerging interface for adapting state-of-the-art
language models to user needs. However, such access may also let malicious
actors undermine model safety. To demonstrate the challenge of defending
finetuning interfaces, we introduce covert malicious finetuning, a method to
compromise model safety via finetuning while evading detection. Our method
constructs a malicious dataset where every individual datapoint appears
innocuous, but finetuning on the dataset teaches the model to respond to
encoded harmful requests with encoded harmful responses. Applied to GPT-4, our
method produces a finetuned model that acts on harmful instructions 99% of the
time and avoids detection by defense mechanisms such as dataset inspection,
safety evaluations, and input/output classifiers. Our findings question whether
black-box finetuning access can be secured against sophisticated adversaries. | [
-0.1341727823,
-1.0009230375,
0.3847390711,
-0.2978529036,
-0.2005336881,
-0.0210977457,
0.0915724859,
-0.4816833735,
-0.6173506975,
0.9346382022,
-0.6947898269,
-0.2936579287,
-0.5297370553,
-0.172425285,
-0.5358013511,
1.4665788412,
0.1695574969,
-0.1030148566,
0.1059160829,
0.0794943124,
-0.6654975414,
-0.7824607491,
-0.8619734049,
-0.0583782308,
0.2315759808,
0.4781197608,
0.7485474348,
0.3481168449,
0.5969637632,
0.2866950035,
0.4098611176,
0.137217924,
-1.098854661,
0.1574087888,
-0.3734274805,
-0.94813025,
-0.4241491854,
-0.0433422513,
0.1059395894,
0.0614620857,
-0.0710413158,
-0.0680975392,
0.1438906789,
0.6217647195,
-0.5423679352,
-0.1327203065,
-1.0908977985,
-0.0698644891,
-0.3925870061,
-0.2126701474,
-0.6276103258,
-0.051855512,
-0.0907944888,
-0.6892310381,
0.2546488643,
0.012139298,
0.7453391552,
0.497693032,
-0.1620117724,
-0.0506841205,
-0.8828474283,
0.5622651577,
-0.6353819966,
0.1562186927,
0.5525800586,
0.6710762978,
-0.3958966732,
-0.692281127,
-0.3630468547,
-0.3109574914,
0.1388315707,
0.1209848747,
-0.6653335094,
0.208432138,
0.3428409398,
0.2576436698,
-0.2970605493,
0.2410491705,
-0.5003085136,
-0.486572057,
0.5997059941,
0.2172826976,
0.3564167023,
-0.1130362228,
-0.6534118652,
-0.1127250269,
-0.8636203408,
0.0244110879,
0.6726194024,
0.2644640803,
-0.3652317524,
0.4302534759,
-0.010224157,
0.2214844376,
0.2587497532,
0.3385942876,
-0.3913117945,
-0.2633364201,
-0.4925095737,
-0.0806195661,
0.6075181961,
0.602181077,
0.328247577,
-0.2945201099,
-0.4467667639,
0.1850612462,
0.6644012332,
-0.7544687986,
-0.5118088126,
0.2140347958,
-0.1304582059,
-0.5707728863,
0.0121261291,
-0.7542170882,
-0.5693082213,
0.0060284161,
0.7851495743,
-0.5613452792,
-0.103877008,
0.1595621407,
-0.0373130701,
0.3781127632,
0.2434527725,
-0.780960083,
0.6430954337,
0.8615676761,
0.641443193,
-0.184874326,
-0.0773869902,
-0.7467336655,
0.3087234199,
-0.3052857816,
0.568544209,
-0.1399056166,
-0.3000831902,
-0.1204820275,
0.3730486333,
0.2190733105,
-0.400552541,
0.7099671364,
-0.5732187033,
-0.1972485781,
0.1580688655,
-0.2099573165,
-0.1602344364,
0.2967579365,
-0.5688792467,
0.3488211334,
0.0007655225,
-0.5795053244,
0.1341641545,
-0.5427696705,
-0.3363329172,
0.0538398959,
0.1111738458,
-0.5911750793,
0.1811101437,
0.2732794583,
0.7226457596,
0.2392744571,
-0.0172588695,
-0.6743792892,
-0.1602775753,
0.5355132818,
-1.0256911516,
0.5915386677,
0.3237279356,
-0.1935330182,
0.0585446171,
-0.9512417912,
-0.2966164351,
0.326628983,
-0.1744129211,
-0.6605718136,
-0.0831417739,
-0.1189126223,
0.0782159567,
0.0029917129,
-0.5384556651,
0.1660568863,
-0.5581613779,
0.5951134562,
1.0721697807,
0.2957021892,
0.4581677318,
-0.4297895133,
0.4756926596,
0.047165595,
0.375872016,
-0.0075932597,
-0.2596550882,
-0.632188499,
0.0281951763,
-0.0510671474,
0.6520221233,
-0.9424116015,
-0.1938679367,
-0.042543523,
-0.3859530985,
-0.5979245901,
0.0259268619,
0.6254699826,
0.2767089605,
0.4027942717,
0.0740016028,
-0.1628391445,
-0.9989449382,
-0.2718317807,
0.4310173988,
-0.1238675043,
0.0826286376,
0.3993680477,
-0.2645204961,
0.1573931277,
-0.379242301,
-0.2847458124,
0.0287967771,
-0.3425662816,
0.0566167198,
0.8503217101,
0.5966786742,
-0.559450984,
-0.1136765555,
0.1912072599,
-0.5515482426,
0.0273344591,
-0.4056907296,
-0.3126487434,
-0.0121329436,
0.8001910448,
-0.3834072948,
0.3900326788,
0.5298520923,
-0.4111666083,
0.5838546157,
-0.2206155062,
-0.0339970551,
-0.9021346569,
-0.1586072296,
-0.1563089639,
-0.5926849246,
-1.0438201427,
0.6314921975,
0.1128488183,
-0.3292464912,
-0.741217494,
0.3637893796,
-0.1159782186,
0.4018467367,
-0.0972502381,
-0.1688671112,
0.043157611,
0.4615420997,
-0.5780222416,
0.8814298511,
0.6372381449,
-0.7049589157,
0.2362315953,
0.277971983,
-0.0087891985,
0.903170526,
-0.4729988277,
0.5534099936,
0.1294078082,
-0.1224289313,
-0.9045030475,
-0.3684884012,
0.5306622982,
-0.2301127017,
0.7645747662,
-0.6288430095,
-0.0099992622,
-0.0418767147,
-0.5227180123,
0.3854107857,
0.3441431522,
-0.4520956576,
0.3276273906,
0.1746995747,
0.040337164,
-0.545740068,
-1.086474061,
0.1204186156,
-0.522210896,
-0.630199194,
0.2179502398,
-0.1842252314,
-0.1349641234,
-0.3764776886,
-0.4362228513,
-0.0584473312,
0.6052035689,
0.3091062903,
0.2027816027,
-0.1573348194,
-0.5091638565,
0.0777570978,
-0.2173093855,
0.4092004597,
-0.3058379889,
0.1783953309,
-0.0257239323,
-0.5666532516,
-0.6510522962,
0.3263418376,
0.615218699,
0.1095240861,
0.3038091362,
0.4872301519,
-0.5641849041,
-0.4858293235,
-0.4841375649,
-0.3917288184,
-0.5851784348,
0.4467506409,
-0.4795478582,
-0.6088805199,
0.5415645838,
0.0777347311,
0.1672888547,
0.2769162059,
0.1917789876,
-0.0814576447,
0.846942842,
0.6905712485,
0.1112503707,
0.2978638709,
-0.3833422065,
0.0430103019,
-0.5556759238,
-0.1079312339,
-0.3049174249,
-0.2701032162,
-0.7136836648,
0.0108820833,
0.1912670583,
0.0927814394,
-0.2478731573,
0.3475818634,
-0.5718894005,
0.6007532477,
0.5087044239,
0.7452562451,
0.2268426865,
0.1453917623,
-0.0158600025,
0.0357656814,
-0.4771828651,
-0.4234332144,
1.2103897333,
0.6211513877,
1.2544518709,
0.4517348111,
0.6579842567,
0.4216359854,
0.057420142,
-0.6737557054,
0.5188006163,
-0.3972682655,
-0.486029923,
-0.1959654093,
-0.2180329114,
-0.8348386884,
0.0403631739,
-0.1772565693,
-0.6916945577,
0.2054408491,
0.2890061736,
-0.5515190959,
0.3604849279,
-1.1007269621,
0.8297767043,
-0.2537711859,
-0.7440190315,
-0.1590082198,
-0.4785108268,
0.6952664256,
-0.3515920937,
0.2348929793,
-0.1336557269,
0.2737060785,
0.6840438247,
-0.2784246206,
1.0660569668,
-0.2984437048,
-0.1288299412,
-0.0105401035,
0.8404803872,
0.6720721722,
0.2604274452,
0.0974458456,
0.1972890943,
0.2993389964,
-0.4876875579,
-0.4126079977,
0.8184269667,
-0.8287680745,
-1.1058126688,
-0.2681079805,
-0.6037056446,
-0.2037935704,
0.3323379755,
0.1543091834,
0.3639886379,
-0.1163800135,
0.0733616352,
0.5640434027,
-0.1217961386,
0.3772662282,
0.4107653201,
0.2558540106,
-0.2689658701,
1.1336781979,
-0.1274695247,
0.924245894,
0.1203109622,
0.3815458119,
-0.1302728653,
-1.1602622271,
-0.3295843303,
-0.1185500473,
-0.7727732062,
-0.6182017326,
-0.1565028429,
-0.3655686378,
-0.0596779659,
-0.1855181456,
-0.1344406307,
-0.4330714047,
-0.2978292108,
-0.1979346424,
0.3212616146,
0.8799034357,
-0.0175278429,
0.4106496572,
-0.6336312294,
0.4363653958,
0.5369010568,
0.4345082641,
-0.2225045413,
-0.7505667806,
0.009005256,
0.1933623403,
-0.6667315364,
-0.7670320868,
0.137637198,
0.1703857481,
0.4925952852,
0.5649599433,
0.3682848513,
0.5543903112,
-0.6539988518,
0.6314985156,
-0.0512308888,
-0.7333847284,
0.4525612295,
-0.6443580389,
0.0590461195,
0.5151802897,
0.2400410324,
-0.22984384,
-0.6254006624,
-0.5780189037,
-0.4992710948,
0.8044800758,
0.256347537,
0.4302879572,
0.2941425443,
0.4456770122,
0.2653777003,
-0.052500084,
-1.0632714033,
-0.0392528065,
-0.5093532205,
0.0472410731,
0.1457327306,
-0.3492261171,
-0.4967136085,
0.0494879894,
0.483610034,
-0.1140830591,
0.2493370771,
0.1078981161,
-0.2503520548,
0.0219325386,
0.4149454832,
0.7123105526,
0.1495933533,
-0.0206312444,
0.3235554397,
0.2706229985,
-0.610737443,
0.2779219151,
0.3352953196,
-0.2418849319,
-0.5891237259,
0.2741344869,
0.5845848322,
0.3761384189,
-0.1383312196,
0.5458338857,
-0.060949821,
-0.206231609,
0.0642101243,
0.4617922902,
-0.2759610713,
0.1521153748,
0.2453896403,
0.3315761685,
0.1586649716,
-0.4457799196,
0.3923008144,
0.6443395615,
-0.3904376924,
-0.4078772664,
0.9042513967,
0.0841315314,
-0.2248668671,
0.1585872769,
-0.0263426248,
-0.3859166801,
0.4992442131,
0.7869480848,
0.7632440925,
-0.6123076677,
-0.280467689,
0.0285238344,
0.6805046797,
0.1555196196,
0.0701430738,
0.2703754604,
-0.5755341053,
-0.0314528644,
-0.3844250143,
-0.3415830135,
0.6062200665,
-0.4807915986,
0.413808316,
-0.8810374141,
0.1304307431,
0.071772173,
-0.5094038248,
-0.7579897046,
-0.1387255937,
0.2428122908,
0.8014855385,
-0.6968877912,
0.5385371447,
0.2086257935,
-0.1834132969,
-0.5507398844,
0.0195129272,
0.2490562499,
-0.9677234292,
0.0443036258,
0.1927386671,
-0.0587825514,
0.1226623133,
-0.8419936299,
-0.5395973921,
0.7543489337,
0.5770052671,
-0.5806149244,
-0.1070539132,
0.3021419644,
0.1792407483,
0.1943965405,
-0.1725748479,
0.6825722456,
0.3121858239,
-0.29919222,
-0.6023131013,
0.396119982,
0.0575964712,
-0.4139569998,
0.0480842702,
-0.4013984203,
0.4541005492,
-0.1530445069,
-0.4929450154,
0.0339774564,
0.2798600197,
-0.0781077892,
0.3681307137,
0.2923520207,
0.3844918311,
0.5801941752,
-0.1934668869,
1.0351231098,
0.1070014313,
0.1049040854,
0.9196129441,
0.0825463906,
0.6144538522,
0.3128966391,
-0.1344350725,
0.0370780826,
0.3443343639,
-0.3650859892,
0.8201463819,
0.2782894075,
-0.2228548527,
-0.1019126847,
0.2694511414,
-0.1521724612,
0.4191425145,
0.7549002767,
0.2401640564,
-0.3214579225,
0.3713126183,
0.18018727,
0.2161420286,
-0.6272264123,
0.8911254406,
0.2299006879,
-0.4481930733,
0.9815415144,
-0.150130868,
0.6328311563,
-0.6087928414,
-0.1143696085,
-0.1667725444,
0.43195647,
-0.4556572139,
-0.8307019472,
0.3742288053,
-0.1645425856,
0.1564079076,
0.1552396566,
0.8525015116,
-0.2481264919,
-0.2746301889,
0.1395736039,
0.0713054314,
-0.0649521276,
0.0246290918,
-0.7461211681,
-0.0547956489,
0.0573968701,
0.0364219695,
0.4325192571,
0.4135146737,
-0.2798750103,
0.8704226017,
0.9594439864,
-0.0603436828,
0.204813242,
0.0389216505,
0.9688262939,
-0.3879370391,
-0.5545699,
-1.1446043253,
0.5148343444,
0.1506251544,
0.2429313511,
0.7013782859,
0.2512402534,
1.0641900301,
-0.1611535847,
0.7185612917,
0.4428845942,
-0.0652507544,
-0.8050431013,
1.0432165861,
-0.1693835557,
0.3071122468,
-0.3029594719,
-0.4023779929,
-0.3372421265,
0.2210882157,
-0.2336404771,
-0.200313881,
0.6187383533,
0.9216685295,
-0.7370339036,
-0.184257701,
0.6398565173,
0.5596737862,
0.7075055838,
0.7786056995,
0.7775319219,
-0.4599052072,
0.8667498231,
-0.4356865287,
-0.2232051045,
-0.1238930747,
-0.9211705327,
-1.1788545847,
-0.2663864493,
-0.1171427667,
-0.585036397,
0.3396208584,
0.4348554015,
0.7982602715,
-1.005821228,
0.1783416122,
-0.2042400539,
0.0322059207,
-0.2109060436,
-0.2362914532,
0.1924097687,
-0.0767194182,
-0.4024552405,
0.6214271188,
0.0086254384,
0.4900099635,
-0.3530279696,
0.2186755389,
0.1712170392,
0.0204118323,
0.2521726787,
0.3811341226,
-0.8092867732,
-0.6720542312,
-0.4285581112,
-0.0178975612,
-0.0279588755,
0.5014070272,
-0.3839238584,
0.3993507028,
-0.0690511763,
1.0504088402,
0.4167698324,
-0.0953429192,
0.6139847636,
-0.8823791742,
0.3487949669,
0.1517233998,
0.3046990335,
0.3193546236,
-0.8401856422,
0.2393660992,
0.0474872254,
-0.5662537813,
-0.8498440981,
0.3749894202,
-1.0129184723,
-0.1193260476,
1.008480072,
-0.1996956617,
-0.2949541509,
-0.4608408213,
-0.4496561885,
0.0425509661,
-0.3686462641,
0.7431279421,
0.5076819658,
0.2589350641,
-0.1777896136,
-1.0573337078,
0.7795807123,
0.0504872836,
-0.7746434212,
0.4948547482,
0.2334919423,
0.5838589668,
-0.0251476374,
-0.0870492086,
-0.1091397703,
0.5047397017,
-0.2740854919,
-0.3826185763,
-0.5764998794,
-0.2607083917,
-0.8019127846,
0.0901765302,
0.1377711445,
-0.3761408925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20052v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20052v1 | Understanding and Mitigating Language Confusion in LLMs | 2024-06-28T17:03:51 | 2024-06-28T17:03:51 | Kelly Marchisio, Wei-Yin Ko, Alexandre Bérard, Théo Dehaze, Sebastian Ruder | cs.CL | cs.CL | We investigate a surprising limitation of LLMs: their inability to
consistently generate text in a user's desired language. We create the Language
Confusion Benchmark (LCB) to evaluate such failures, covering 15 typologically
diverse languages with existing and newly-created English and multilingual
prompts. We evaluate a range of LLMs on monolingual and cross-lingual
generation reflecting practical use cases, finding that Llama Instruct and
Mistral models exhibit high degrees of language confusion and even the
strongest models fail to consistently respond in the correct language. We
observe that base and English-centric instruct models are more prone to
language confusion, which is aggravated by complex prompts and high sampling
temperatures. We find that language confusion can be partially mitigated via
few-shot prompting, multilingual SFT and preference tuning. We release our
language confusion benchmark, which serves as a first layer of efficient,
scalable multilingual evaluation at
https://github.com/for-ai/language-confusion. | [
-0.195063144,
-0.910461545,
0.3909439147,
0.5376868248,
-0.1009563878,
0.417424202,
-0.2284558117,
-0.4709812403,
-0.3419286311,
0.321077317,
-0.6745494008,
-0.2610925138,
-0.5553387403,
0.3617014885,
-0.2216846049,
0.8366870284,
-0.2800337374,
0.3399476707,
-0.4359011948,
-0.1836117059,
-0.7588015199,
-0.4086150229,
-0.9521721005,
-0.5983304381,
0.477160126,
0.5272616744,
0.5386700034,
0.2821905613,
0.3209207356,
0.2584050596,
-0.1669557095,
0.351742357,
-0.63892591,
0.184992373,
-0.0428557508,
-0.8247222304,
-0.0682931915,
-0.3387948275,
0.601072073,
0.8025817275,
-0.2101288885,
-0.0543470085,
0.0241164342,
0.8320289254,
-0.7031077743,
-0.1388724744,
-0.8860881329,
0.2410582453,
-0.4231488407,
-0.1407787502,
-0.513256371,
0.1304747909,
-0.0636596307,
-0.4567968845,
0.1720934063,
0.1310371459,
0.6039351225,
0.5652389526,
-0.4519717097,
-0.2782392502,
-0.7167142034,
0.7395720482,
-0.5538697839,
0.6149681211,
0.3775312603,
0.3093449473,
-0.1663740575,
-0.4037121236,
-0.5310074091,
-0.191039294,
0.3192822337,
0.2503170371,
-0.3349875808,
-0.053484045,
0.2149180323,
-0.0043138415,
-0.7008985281,
0.3638108373,
0.0585158467,
-0.2646782994,
0.402977556,
0.3804857135,
0.2999292016,
-0.2155933231,
-0.4558393955,
-0.0462260991,
-0.9404267669,
0.0401418246,
0.6894258857,
0.1947633326,
-0.286483109,
0.4435173869,
0.0805526897,
0.6887101531,
0.0176319759,
-0.2366825044,
0.1992331743,
-0.3009676933,
-0.3814948797,
-0.0494746417,
0.682164669,
0.3805013597,
0.2839741111,
-0.1697681993,
-0.141342774,
-0.1638935655,
-0.0216705967,
-0.3942704201,
-0.0406476259,
0.3967221975,
-0.0599609613,
0.1593116522,
-0.2722501755,
-0.4413447976,
-0.7184914947,
-0.1122701168,
0.2097779065,
-0.4292294383,
-0.2814373076,
0.3288801014,
-0.054730691,
-0.0037061777,
0.3468193114,
-0.831181705,
0.0624880381,
0.3269682527,
0.4972454011,
-0.3164826334,
-0.6671828032,
-0.1172378883,
0.1998497248,
-0.422955215,
0.8049556613,
-0.2998394072,
-0.5033829212,
-0.0256980937,
-0.313041389,
-0.3343358338,
-0.960007906,
0.1564743072,
-0.3317946792,
0.2884639204,
-0.3124074042,
-0.4842230976,
-0.1811077893,
0.4291613996,
-0.4812946618,
1.0900238752,
0.0200498197,
-0.8313505054,
0.3543804288,
-0.1636906415,
-0.342823565,
0.1958017349,
-0.2061247081,
-0.1636015773,
0.0712682158,
0.0324578695,
0.247248739,
-0.438890785,
0.2533375323,
0.1446213424,
-0.2524507344,
0.2839971483,
-0.6189374328,
0.6306018233,
0.1615187824,
-0.1556316167,
0.0512036979,
-0.6799640656,
-0.1521754563,
0.1959079653,
-0.4407371581,
-0.1636062264,
0.1537017375,
-0.0347699858,
0.064508006,
0.4824159741,
-0.0256098807,
0.0832987279,
-0.0631159246,
0.2517830133,
0.6727551818,
-0.0323950835,
0.4171974659,
-0.4649956524,
0.8064590096,
0.4311931729,
0.0300722774,
-0.1704087257,
-0.4617634416,
-0.9737843275,
-0.0604384542,
0.061205443,
0.9451391697,
-0.9687159061,
-0.0724073797,
0.204709962,
-0.3923374414,
-0.7469722033,
0.4989121556,
0.4571708143,
0.551394999,
0.2583251297,
-0.0354729444,
-0.5992903709,
-0.8231648803,
-0.4392148852,
-0.3559449911,
0.2990277708,
0.2298890203,
0.2459507436,
-0.5744821429,
0.6587641239,
0.1398388743,
0.0967923924,
-0.593814075,
0.2243729085,
-0.0087462272,
0.2319161445,
0.4323046803,
-0.6776797175,
-0.6334802508,
0.148148194,
-0.5220845938,
-0.4122892916,
-0.3714122772,
0.0744938403,
0.5390977263,
0.6418853998,
-0.6225124002,
0.1487799585,
0.6870930791,
0.1547240913,
0.6328385472,
-0.2262603492,
0.1479887664,
-0.9939822555,
-0.2926186025,
-0.243820712,
-0.1403057873,
-0.5842327476,
-0.2065421343,
0.2084232867,
0.2177253962,
-0.6417766809,
0.6133803129,
-0.535541296,
0.1465429813,
-0.073732011,
0.2681325078,
-0.0946091712,
0.3570919335,
-0.4175046086,
0.8981971741,
0.617637217,
-0.7002167702,
0.2380351126,
-0.0359468348,
-0.2684326768,
0.5170757771,
-0.3103302717,
0.1175501868,
-0.3713643253,
0.1502831131,
-1.0604658127,
-0.2930265367,
0.394638598,
-0.1631134003,
0.4425730705,
0.0105890278,
-0.6198927164,
-0.1930314153,
-0.10562931,
0.5627430081,
0.2326334566,
-0.5177119374,
0.28921628,
0.0262523219,
-0.0636791885,
-0.8392747641,
-0.8648611903,
0.0605707727,
-0.1930416673,
-0.5361953378,
0.0528223366,
-0.5155169964,
-0.476703167,
-0.1625385135,
-0.1945214123,
0.1076210737,
0.2767286599,
0.1506902277,
-0.0349292532,
-0.142191425,
0.2071351409,
0.1603879184,
0.0252222065,
0.0285864454,
-0.0446250439,
0.7403051257,
-0.1044152379,
-0.7514423132,
-0.2774180472,
0.3179862201,
0.4349615574,
0.0354448259,
0.541814208,
0.4722548127,
-0.2361030579,
-0.3603892326,
-0.6038860679,
0.1938646734,
-0.4144191146,
0.483070761,
-0.4625269473,
-0.8200479746,
0.8443725109,
0.0340508372,
0.0626181588,
0.4084786773,
0.7181002498,
-0.0772943273,
1.0321286917,
0.6134545207,
-0.0282035526,
0.495307833,
0.1886301488,
0.0950117484,
-0.4977478683,
-0.3279023468,
-0.5347242355,
-0.0899619684,
-0.6762987375,
-0.4603241086,
0.2771501541,
0.3461299539,
-0.2044913769,
0.0994412228,
-0.0374515541,
0.7485182285,
0.3321397305,
-0.0936301798,
0.3321543336,
0.092516534,
-0.3975308836,
-0.1993570328,
-0.9178276062,
-0.5588675141,
0.929284811,
0.1916644275,
0.9872989655,
0.1762427837,
0.8542117476,
0.1655584574,
0.2149653137,
-0.6054852009,
0.4215139747,
-0.1270134598,
-0.5068269372,
-0.0030662622,
-0.4786434174,
-1.0006327629,
0.3190188408,
-0.0913192332,
-0.6457942724,
-0.1891889125,
-0.0037862705,
-0.1925052255,
0.2397209406,
-0.8703441024,
0.8253822327,
-0.5084916353,
-0.390250504,
-0.0393722244,
-0.5565696359,
0.446428895,
-0.3136576414,
0.3454910517,
-0.2490384579,
-0.1316484511,
0.3012446463,
-0.2192989439,
0.8803674579,
0.1002041623,
-0.3570761979,
0.1895562112,
0.1030499414,
0.2183716148,
0.1024576798,
-0.2792806625,
0.30717206,
-0.3398820758,
-0.3509781361,
-0.3672270775,
0.4856175482,
-0.8851884007,
-0.7510483861,
-0.3152059317,
-0.8194964528,
-0.3914222419,
0.1260478348,
0.694405973,
0.0129477289,
-0.282438159,
-0.2837980986,
0.6835942864,
-0.3644450009,
0.511975646,
0.6330515742,
-0.322108686,
-0.271879226,
0.713681519,
-0.0880357847,
0.4845921397,
0.5146913528,
0.0312051643,
-0.1387411058,
-0.5612912774,
-0.8004789352,
0.2224970162,
-0.8773357272,
-0.1639948338,
-0.3876126409,
-0.2410676777,
-0.2791849971,
-0.0507213846,
-0.1640670151,
-0.1916717291,
-0.4756440818,
0.0386787765,
0.0334402099,
0.9187060595,
0.0031134244,
0.433765769,
-0.7081623077,
0.1991034001,
-0.0142287724,
-0.0153168244,
-0.0964015871,
-0.619800508,
-0.1992898583,
0.0994676203,
-0.3054604828,
-0.92987746,
0.1821226031,
0.1738336533,
0.9029381871,
0.4646488726,
-0.2181961834,
0.8411768675,
-0.6332438588,
0.8888331652,
0.2973403037,
-0.999085784,
0.3905175924,
-0.1277740449,
0.6766887307,
0.5143560171,
0.2199687213,
-0.792119801,
-0.7445943952,
-0.4300362766,
-0.9734501243,
0.7169686556,
0.0090240743,
0.1648838371,
-0.251408875,
0.1654173732,
0.3067571223,
0.2546249926,
-0.9201080799,
-0.4950356185,
0.068140991,
-0.1736732423,
-0.1390588582,
-0.390787214,
-0.0786053464,
0.0869601518,
0.7033449411,
0.0345624611,
-0.1100904047,
0.0097310403,
-0.3998295367,
-0.4740841389,
0.3375014961,
0.9779799581,
0.7110869884,
0.1055615544,
0.1876600534,
0.3962079585,
-0.1179091781,
0.0503321551,
0.0461146869,
-0.1122735962,
0.0714605749,
0.4765029848,
0.9708899856,
0.2882493138,
-0.7650443316,
0.1521463692,
-0.1700210869,
-0.0873338208,
-0.1123634949,
0.1639158577,
0.3444037139,
0.1463800371,
0.3578411937,
0.2032418996,
-0.1977718025,
-0.3248303235,
-0.1270228177,
0.5157681704,
-0.0363125876,
-0.0564312451,
0.7307788134,
0.2421767116,
-0.4037729204,
0.5288195014,
-0.2481774539,
-0.4623517394,
0.6290003657,
0.671828866,
0.9143995643,
-0.3650598228,
0.0725324303,
0.1128826961,
0.7225776911,
-0.1422995031,
0.4210952222,
-0.0504753701,
-0.9831231236,
-0.2228587717,
-0.3513284624,
-0.7736017704,
0.0464759469,
-0.415445298,
0.1594059318,
-0.4416092336,
-0.1568935066,
-0.2749635577,
-0.1384770423,
-0.6411557198,
-0.0495049246,
0.3786494136,
0.9825797081,
-0.7408909202,
0.6905299425,
0.8738821149,
-0.255087167,
-0.6816427112,
-0.0117218867,
0.1276593208,
-0.8567895293,
0.495413959,
0.2576730251,
-0.3309586644,
-0.1271594614,
-0.6552932858,
-0.3531730771,
0.8735792637,
0.7009158731,
-0.6829829812,
0.2253959179,
0.6537848711,
0.5275030732,
-0.2408732474,
0.1629162133,
0.5309799314,
0.6215038896,
0.0184333976,
-0.9185795188,
-0.3246444166,
0.0416845381,
-0.0741015002,
0.2220647186,
-0.5078535676,
0.9246323109,
-0.3379839957,
-0.3766441941,
0.1380981803,
0.3562932611,
0.4482091069,
0.5527864695,
0.4704898,
0.6022421718,
1.0874931812,
-0.1506368071,
0.8346285224,
-0.2978500128,
0.1394899487,
1.1472737789,
-0.4931891263,
0.7829754353,
0.726305902,
-0.1226580441,
0.361664027,
0.8776102066,
0.2844436765,
0.0832312182,
0.2475380749,
-0.4364989996,
-0.3089750409,
-0.0634496287,
-0.3955369592,
0.3244597018,
0.380697757,
0.0129695302,
-0.3139927387,
-0.0218823925,
0.0452179052,
0.0150625035,
-0.0984359235,
0.677901268,
0.1649623662,
-0.7090414762,
0.7587524652,
0.017430013,
0.7047941089,
-0.8312760592,
0.2311692089,
-0.6835753322,
0.0531121753,
-0.2245302796,
-0.6723213196,
0.0426595546,
0.0072468841,
-0.2641351521,
-0.458340466,
0.415246129,
-0.8676418662,
-0.3036800325,
0.3253900707,
0.9133402705,
0.3330007792,
0.1888487637,
-0.8819839358,
0.2140020281,
0.1312338114,
-0.2363581955,
0.0986311883,
0.7007783055,
-0.2500764132,
0.9206649661,
0.375445962,
-0.0259820763,
0.3156966567,
0.5624352098,
0.2879473865,
-0.5467304587,
-0.1228014678,
-0.9204740524,
0.3772601783,
0.2927956581,
-0.5345329046,
0.8490129709,
0.4772995412,
1.0605021715,
-0.2059137672,
0.722150445,
0.0854498297,
0.0806702748,
-0.6718344688,
0.6895056367,
-0.9441825151,
0.5324964523,
-0.0947486013,
-0.7140996456,
-0.4251764715,
0.3121290505,
0.0612803623,
0.0998620763,
0.8492308259,
0.8193177581,
0.1168601662,
-0.2293457389,
0.5344156027,
0.2136757374,
0.117239438,
0.7180221677,
1.2196885347,
-0.2639738917,
0.6324353218,
-0.1342379898,
0.0104896938,
-0.1903591752,
-0.9600225091,
-0.8631732464,
-0.5217399001,
-0.3847202957,
-0.1044864208,
0.0419130288,
0.8509340882,
0.493037045,
-0.7010591626,
-0.6325436234,
-0.3539214432,
0.6690195203,
-0.125830099,
-0.2121439278,
-0.1971354783,
-0.7100644112,
-0.9805240631,
0.5428913236,
0.4078886211,
0.3209694624,
-0.3439040184,
-0.2492371649,
-0.0983078033,
0.0917431489,
0.4089932442,
0.2933029532,
-0.8845342398,
0.1147065163,
-0.0964950025,
-0.5156955719,
0.0048260791,
0.6855626702,
-0.4915344119,
0.5485671759,
0.4230435491,
0.7317358255,
0.151237756,
-0.3623806834,
0.6127079129,
-0.7566046715,
0.1973065138,
-0.0333433524,
0.4805200994,
0.6541967988,
-0.3232161999,
0.4075305462,
0.1903701723,
-0.438805759,
-0.6790457964,
0.5189188123,
-0.9501471519,
-0.2447636575,
1.2633972168,
0.1057322249,
-0.0529859178,
-0.1040194035,
-0.4061938524,
0.1870915294,
-0.2309305519,
0.5597797632,
1.0275723934,
-0.2519186139,
-0.2376550287,
-0.5372179151,
0.4725134373,
0.8840605617,
-0.8422012925,
0.1199797317,
0.4811665118,
0.3372293711,
-0.0385385118,
0.6120197773,
0.2354224622,
0.3538446724,
-0.0397387221,
0.2238945514,
0.2698048949,
-0.3351795673,
-0.5408143401,
-0.2036397308,
0.3072693944,
0.067337811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00146v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00146v1 | The Qiyas Benchmark: Measuring ChatGPT Mathematical and Language Understanding in Arabic | 2024-06-28T16:34:31 | 2024-06-28T16:34:31 | Shahad Al-Khalifa, Hend Al-Khalifa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the growing importance of Arabic as a global language, there is a
notable lack of language models pre-trained exclusively on Arabic data. This
shortage has led to limited benchmarks available for assessing language model
performance in Arabic. To address this gap, we introduce two novel benchmarks
designed to evaluate models' mathematical reasoning and language understanding
abilities in Arabic. These benchmarks are derived from a General Aptitude Test
(GAT) called Qiyas exam, a standardized test widely used for university
admissions in Saudi Arabia. For validation purposes, we assess the performance
of ChatGPT-3.5-trubo and ChatGPT-4 on our benchmarks. Our findings reveal that
these benchmarks pose a significant challenge, with ChatGPT-4 achieving an
overall average accuracy of 64%, while ChatGPT-3.5-trubo achieved an overall
accuracy of 49% across the various question types in the Qiyas benchmark. We
believe the release of these benchmarks will pave the way for enhancing the
mathematical reasoning and language understanding capabilities of future models
tailored for the low-resource Arabic language. | [
-0.2036259919,
-0.5131343603,
0.5172065496,
0.2948811948,
-0.2906148136,
0.3103429973,
0.1272809058,
-0.4615114033,
-0.4095687568,
0.1859523058,
-0.402774483,
-0.6071412563,
-0.5243420005,
-0.1830660105,
-0.4381803572,
0.9529906511,
-0.495348841,
0.2266560644,
-0.01813576,
-0.4413900375,
-0.3260069788,
-0.4631678164,
-0.5993156433,
-0.3149391413,
0.1237936318,
0.2595951557,
1.205930233,
0.4016349316,
0.5723424554,
0.2397601008,
0.1385605484,
-0.0575874932,
-0.0842728764,
0.1100577638,
-0.0284716059,
-0.4185771346,
-0.1294468641,
-0.0442847908,
0.7416568995,
0.7367894053,
-0.5276914835,
0.457805872,
-0.236659795,
0.8906615376,
-0.7398090363,
0.2422204316,
-0.5132800937,
-0.0157208964,
-0.2340914756,
0.2870207727,
-0.0540833883,
-0.7190781832,
0.1778238565,
-0.4454414248,
0.2213536054,
-0.0050945296,
0.9804332256,
0.0278496277,
-0.3437668979,
-0.2196185291,
-0.4239948094,
0.677816391,
-0.6098921895,
0.3980849981,
0.3740201294,
0.7609680891,
-0.0779953003,
-0.7825231552,
-0.461194694,
-0.4495225251,
0.1946054101,
0.0651282072,
-0.382396996,
0.0337012783,
0.2471253872,
0.3536975384,
-0.8559113741,
-0.573086977,
-0.1468841434,
-0.0607351363,
0.4961520731,
0.0900643617,
0.5729433894,
0.1259138584,
-0.1394184381,
-0.2146163285,
-0.8894165754,
0.3318616748,
0.3219304383,
-0.0632744133,
-0.0511663556,
0.406630069,
-0.45422858,
0.6740472913,
-0.6125349998,
0.0757708922,
0.0957412124,
-0.2123281509,
-0.351428479,
0.01286628,
0.6301489472,
-0.0951050296,
0.4732581377,
-0.0977784768,
-0.104019843,
0.1898729205,
-0.0692923665,
-0.9924013615,
-0.5179967284,
0.0047241938,
-0.2935045063,
0.0263544749,
-0.0123247001,
-0.341047287,
-0.2142069638,
-0.0583987385,
0.5678472519,
-0.5442838073,
-0.2058642209,
0.3126325607,
-0.0164852291,
0.3190108836,
0.393602401,
-0.8874879479,
0.5305100679,
0.7360803485,
1.0957102776,
0.200010255,
-0.2929864526,
-0.3646273017,
-0.0191360563,
-0.5258150697,
0.735004425,
-0.7115932107,
-0.3486063778,
0.0164687391,
-0.5569111109,
-0.1873948574,
-0.541816473,
0.8843666315,
-0.4603088796,
-0.0954039395,
-0.433878839,
-0.2885606587,
-0.6796430349,
0.1552102119,
-0.3667583168,
1.0333944559,
0.4886259437,
-0.5309500694,
0.1106636003,
-0.4327648282,
-0.1571647674,
0.1346949339,
-0.4020779431,
-0.4056373835,
0.0599678271,
0.4291154444,
-0.0243183207,
-0.624342382,
0.2822254002,
-0.3159858584,
-0.7912322879,
0.5186158419,
-0.5979121923,
0.7722225785,
0.222053498,
-0.4056177437,
-0.0930275917,
-0.6500914693,
0.4934696853,
0.1824817061,
0.1840959787,
-0.0915453658,
0.2091217041,
-0.0438956991,
0.3663748503,
0.155577898,
-0.3346253335,
0.0373096615,
-0.3556430638,
0.3040466011,
0.5976430178,
-0.1855539978,
-0.1630362123,
-0.4637686908,
0.822888732,
0.0401855297,
0.0133128343,
0.1393395811,
-0.6176373363,
-0.8321399093,
-0.1932380646,
0.256155163,
0.4502985477,
-0.565196991,
-0.1493769288,
-0.0769025385,
-0.9073927402,
-0.8149930835,
0.0988809988,
0.3744230866,
0.3517138064,
0.239790231,
-0.2645151317,
-0.2545350492,
-0.813468039,
-0.8111929297,
-0.5654838085,
-0.0778383762,
0.1759988964,
0.5285027027,
0.0127003463,
0.6711591482,
-0.3345274925,
0.1774772704,
-0.1242130026,
0.4159030318,
0.413308382,
0.2816880345,
0.6844987273,
-0.5510805249,
-0.8629529476,
0.3211009204,
-0.4573830366,
-0.2084796727,
0.2985898256,
-0.0298579726,
-0.103007935,
-0.0755890459,
-0.8306976557,
0.6130928993,
0.6761937737,
-0.4510258138,
0.7866663337,
0.0112245837,
0.4498091042,
-0.5311600566,
-0.036892809,
-0.0611886531,
0.0491511188,
-0.7172563672,
0.1287313253,
0.2893458307,
-0.204307124,
-0.2995386422,
0.5654906034,
-0.3802029192,
-0.223001644,
-0.0228208303,
0.0309089292,
-0.0426990055,
0.4250190258,
-0.1976476014,
1.3093088865,
0.5934084058,
-0.2361372113,
0.2661748827,
0.02727478,
-0.9690210819,
0.2823458612,
-1.0337562561,
0.0948511586,
0.0780726522,
-0.0301298108,
-1.2356249094,
0.1001914069,
0.4489627779,
-0.5395687222,
-0.1783083975,
-0.1153450832,
-0.4016529322,
-0.02925165,
-0.1179102212,
0.5803601742,
0.6706520915,
-0.4477209151,
0.5450900197,
0.088730514,
-0.4334512055,
-0.8066909313,
-0.3351139128,
-0.2335894257,
-0.1357207149,
-0.6725687385,
0.0800098926,
0.1161864176,
-0.5190082192,
-0.1355573386,
-0.2830352783,
-0.1944163144,
0.2519469261,
0.3480425179,
0.271399647,
-0.4943774641,
0.1703109741,
0.0929211602,
-0.0095952805,
0.4161097109,
-0.2208867818,
0.4949781597,
-0.524240613,
-0.7357741594,
-0.4191201031,
0.0181291997,
0.5606575012,
-0.6028327942,
0.8721112609,
0.563038528,
-0.2696153522,
0.1111555248,
-0.404805243,
0.2471024692,
-0.4775644243,
0.5464280844,
-0.7226799726,
-0.4635642767,
0.5276018977,
0.0555334836,
0.0333068036,
0.4550836384,
0.6025995612,
0.108283639,
1.5703364611,
0.1400887668,
-0.4758560658,
0.14431642,
0.1134341359,
0.5365944505,
-0.4557601213,
-0.0004861379,
-1.0803340673,
-0.015880093,
-0.6921126246,
-0.3302254081,
0.1914411187,
0.2111409307,
-0.5276480317,
0.08933153,
-0.1532707363,
0.5553886294,
0.3982718289,
-0.1844553202,
0.390809536,
0.1199566275,
-0.1827010512,
-0.1056074798,
-0.4083817005,
-0.6976265907,
0.9323584437,
0.2630381882,
0.6242701411,
0.5899522901,
0.3219150901,
0.2288731337,
0.4067093432,
-0.5044329762,
0.4165072143,
0.3053344488,
-0.5160351396,
-0.0952385142,
-0.5475324392,
-0.7255409956,
0.7940229177,
0.2894850373,
-0.8661970496,
-0.0971184373,
-0.1790886372,
-0.2992264032,
0.0665269718,
-0.8807935715,
0.9533835649,
-0.0834526718,
-0.322378099,
-0.4363568127,
-0.3192646801,
0.3028328419,
0.2084663808,
0.1468137056,
-0.7529799342,
-0.1592738479,
0.732188642,
-0.3782054186,
0.224438861,
-0.1436973214,
0.1257466525,
0.4616181552,
0.2205982953,
0.172228083,
0.250500083,
-0.3256919682,
0.3515548706,
0.5190303326,
-0.8872376084,
-0.662976861,
0.482245028,
-1.2344039679,
-0.6017334461,
-0.8706232905,
-0.6213394403,
-0.5222609043,
-0.1054925248,
-0.1579502225,
0.3944424689,
-0.4175712764,
-0.2037896663,
0.2449183911,
-0.0459404215,
0.218949005,
0.8269199133,
-0.3032726347,
-0.1677503288,
0.8925195336,
-0.0434240811,
0.26512146,
0.2530554235,
0.1044848412,
-0.3371806741,
-0.6153707504,
-0.6105360389,
0.2825385332,
-0.7259449959,
-0.0302349292,
-0.3974773288,
-0.5579338074,
-0.33332178,
0.1656047851,
-0.1348601878,
-0.3823772371,
0.1352319568,
0.1511079818,
0.1621764749,
0.6701000929,
0.1490909308,
0.2826620638,
-0.9000196457,
0.0619464964,
0.3117425442,
0.1227429211,
0.1464229226,
-0.7480503321,
-0.2894749045,
0.2471596003,
-0.5241531134,
-0.8910483718,
0.4354420602,
0.1792953014,
0.4655724764,
0.515463531,
-0.28855443,
0.7713952065,
-0.4411145747,
0.6323688626,
-0.0296280887,
-1.3118357658,
0.4490735829,
-0.4243276417,
0.5305893421,
0.5667616129,
0.5392119288,
-0.9435791969,
-0.3180567026,
-0.453320235,
-0.1225025281,
0.6323183179,
0.4970181286,
0.0191609524,
0.0930208713,
0.2692793906,
0.1425808072,
0.2976413965,
-0.4505347908,
-0.2663821876,
0.0152901458,
-0.4118424952,
-0.0980982929,
-0.2555652559,
0.1966978908,
-0.4064063132,
0.7361820936,
0.0839815661,
0.1250328422,
-0.2313835919,
-0.1521610022,
-0.0142300474,
0.3325011134,
0.5169713497,
1.0749554634,
-0.2942292094,
-0.0963297933,
0.044209525,
-0.9406113029,
0.404694438,
0.4442879856,
-0.1654015929,
0.1632932872,
0.2591914237,
0.4676016271,
-0.0313197188,
-0.9809288979,
0.345820874,
-0.4006130397,
-0.1268873513,
-0.193136543,
0.251814723,
0.1685644388,
0.0655364543,
0.3656235933,
-0.0394965298,
0.2553973496,
-0.4836573303,
-0.0525070243,
0.4634934366,
-0.2863143682,
-0.3338555992,
0.3336476684,
-0.0701378882,
-0.1536968201,
0.7813711762,
-0.1535503119,
-0.6298840046,
0.7563237548,
0.4539857209,
0.6043590903,
-0.4931609333,
0.537342906,
0.4482035041,
0.3094057143,
-0.048789531,
0.5493190289,
-0.3183736801,
-0.7648516893,
-0.1422102004,
-0.3831822872,
-0.8730968833,
-0.1647850275,
-0.6163072586,
0.0349808931,
-0.4334051311,
0.1260063946,
-0.0776917115,
0.4899610877,
-0.5566990376,
0.2360257804,
-0.1133732423,
0.7965976,
-0.7905809879,
1.0614584684,
0.6698738337,
-0.3512284458,
-0.777192533,
-0.1351099014,
-0.0366012193,
-1.1924202442,
0.4843302071,
0.3184576333,
-0.1553323567,
-0.0248578396,
-0.2683427036,
-0.9874615073,
0.919285953,
0.450435549,
-0.4583681822,
0.2807789743,
0.3881832063,
0.4266420007,
0.0360185504,
0.8639970422,
0.95737499,
0.2162973583,
0.0681668371,
-0.6817396879,
-0.1740929931,
-0.4212203026,
0.0693031922,
0.5560667515,
-0.6671895981,
1.0724335909,
-0.1836093962,
-0.3900013864,
0.4812700748,
0.8682553172,
0.5386226773,
0.3990482986,
0.1408645511,
0.5504106283,
0.8085589409,
-0.3857422471,
0.8833800554,
-0.314136982,
0.2783896029,
0.9328534603,
-0.3574868143,
0.9642897844,
0.2605189979,
-0.8374706507,
0.7589309216,
0.6639757752,
0.3586032987,
0.5671460629,
0.4251770377,
-0.7338311076,
-0.0413116328,
-0.2627924681,
-0.7784442306,
0.3822024763,
0.464735955,
0.0096199941,
-0.2875719666,
-0.4988848269,
0.1529482901,
0.0685398579,
-0.2607910931,
0.0606357045,
0.1486040056,
-0.8052729964,
0.4826731086,
0.2648413479,
-0.0445536524,
-0.7826651335,
-0.1317629516,
-0.3759939075,
0.2822496593,
0.117607981,
-0.6762051582,
0.090377748,
0.0355428793,
0.3731165826,
0.2115610689,
0.6428900957,
-0.3523648679,
-0.7104849815,
-0.0748458356,
0.6584457755,
0.2600173652,
-0.2388355583,
-0.8577954769,
0.0882442296,
-0.0182706602,
0.0272024497,
0.317961067,
0.4114639163,
0.0181940608,
0.7821850777,
0.4858055711,
0.2108542025,
-0.1974349469,
0.3353723884,
0.547647059,
-0.7031773329,
-0.427330792,
-1.0526040792,
0.0139101809,
0.0263984352,
-0.5360705853,
0.8492960334,
0.3267686069,
0.6973671913,
0.1215490624,
0.7574371696,
0.191114828,
0.3996024132,
-0.4068533778,
0.8603512049,
-0.3795520067,
0.0135461539,
-0.2798389792,
-0.8861762285,
0.0310153887,
0.8615945578,
-0.5771974921,
0.3440674245,
0.7818888426,
0.6961551309,
0.2057381123,
0.5077158213,
0.4159567654,
-0.1435620636,
0.3989504874,
0.9996489882,
1.2229571342,
-0.707903564,
0.3999216259,
-0.3431213498,
-0.0830204114,
0.0445892438,
-0.5014492869,
-1.2272365093,
-0.4238705635,
-0.2140852958,
-0.2331229597,
0.375931859,
0.8224025369,
0.4074245095,
-0.9246525168,
-0.4871572256,
-0.0695800856,
0.1965160221,
-0.506943047,
-0.1696722955,
0.6367963552,
-0.161871478,
-0.4533116221,
-0.0939796492,
0.3775398433,
0.1596423537,
-0.1379008144,
-0.2097425014,
-0.0827846751,
0.0402490087,
0.2708917856,
0.3099556863,
-0.7280008793,
-0.0796723664,
-0.0332017615,
-0.367965579,
0.0278080441,
0.630184114,
-0.8364794254,
0.2383492887,
0.4611433446,
0.7389829755,
0.3977960646,
0.0670991465,
0.6086108088,
-0.1010506228,
0.1721111685,
0.1427268386,
0.3242410421,
0.2776903212,
0.022277737,
0.6179634929,
0.022671029,
-0.4513593018,
-0.6516765356,
0.0202540532,
-0.5377909541,
0.0836009905,
0.5966922641,
-0.3507297039,
-0.0338343345,
-0.1953108609,
-0.1787341982,
0.072671257,
-0.275282383,
0.9674797058,
1.0565876961,
0.0089142192,
-0.2591627538,
-0.9426666498,
0.3392221332,
1.0965929031,
-0.877484858,
-0.1716035753,
0.1899781525,
0.0156006953,
-0.3781249821,
0.6784279346,
-0.0175193585,
0.823002696,
0.1884427816,
-0.1045615599,
0.3196537495,
0.0016684767,
-0.1178787574,
-0.035169892,
0.506098628,
-0.2742251754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20038v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20038v1 | BioMNER: A Dataset for Biomedical Method Entity Recognition | 2024-06-28T16:34:24 | 2024-06-28T16:34:24 | Chen Tang, Bohao Yang, Kun Zhao, Bo Lv, Chenghao Xiao, Frank Guerin, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Named entity recognition (NER) stands as a fundamental and pivotal task
within the realm of Natural Language Processing. Particularly within the domain
of Biomedical Method NER, this task presents notable challenges, stemming from
the continual influx of domain-specific terminologies in scholarly literature.
Current research in Biomedical Method (BioMethod) NER suffers from a scarcity
of resources, primarily attributed to the intricate nature of methodological
concepts, which necessitate a profound understanding for precise delineation.
In this study, we propose a novel dataset for biomedical method entity
recognition, employing an automated BioMethod entity recognition and
information retrieval system to assist human annotation. Furthermore, we
comprehensively explore a range of conventional and contemporary open-domain
NER methodologies, including the utilization of cutting-edge large-scale
language models (LLMs) customised to our dataset. Our empirical findings reveal
that the large parameter counts of language models surprisingly inhibit the
effective assimilation of entity extraction patterns pertaining to biomedical
methods. Remarkably, the approach, leveraging the modestly sized ALBERT model
(only 11MB), in conjunction with conditional random fields (CRF), achieves
state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance. | [
-0.3022367954,
-0.7782464623,
0.5370687246,
-0.1313243061,
-0.3021890223,
0.2297796607,
-0.1268715262,
-0.8041727543,
0.4065192342,
0.6325674057,
-0.3472685218,
-0.7219507694,
-0.4738623202,
0.6571552753,
-0.0262316745,
1.1747750044,
0.0734007955,
0.488610357,
-0.3124966919,
-0.4654479623,
0.0278387722,
-0.4128688574,
-0.7532450557,
-0.4444544911,
0.8110839128,
0.0794286206,
0.2923168838,
0.8582310081,
1.1266108751,
0.231242314,
-0.0569298789,
0.0330375098,
-0.0577678829,
0.2892099917,
-0.3090887368,
-0.2275072485,
-0.4698033631,
-0.305944562,
0.6243940592,
0.9055991769,
-0.0797683075,
0.3925258219,
-0.339886874,
0.2643770874,
-0.4921560585,
0.1478881985,
-0.4490627944,
-0.0187029168,
-0.5021244287,
-0.2159208357,
-0.2608102858,
-0.1883540899,
0.3745478988,
-0.5425890088,
0.3576793671,
0.2239976674,
0.8384026289,
0.3390987813,
-0.184648782,
-0.0509409346,
-0.6562092304,
0.5099278092,
-0.6524872184,
0.6405842304,
0.2597578168,
0.3575707078,
-0.1512496173,
-0.625140667,
-0.3238402307,
-0.0955091119,
-0.1486858875,
-0.1988900751,
-0.0854053944,
0.0605146736,
0.4652876854,
0.0047790152,
-0.6386894584,
0.1345123202,
-0.5310949683,
-0.4144255221,
0.5919049382,
0.2028094977,
0.1833624989,
-0.3367105424,
-0.232823953,
0.1190482676,
-0.6198100448,
-0.1551541835,
-0.1619942933,
0.2027744353,
0.0787546858,
0.4556286931,
-0.249556452,
0.5777959824,
-0.0953354239,
-0.1745173484,
0.3955535889,
0.0260900781,
-0.2904446125,
0.1557176113,
1.0858240128,
0.0106211435,
-0.1068435758,
-0.5607004166,
-0.2069031745,
-0.0094523253,
0.1110288724,
-1.1710438728,
-0.1957743019,
0.2845930755,
-0.4266906381,
-0.0985171124,
-0.2243251503,
-0.9784622192,
-0.5473547578,
-0.279440701,
0.3190986812,
-0.6388528943,
0.1546499878,
0.0381075069,
0.0223007891,
0.1468667835,
0.0829285309,
-0.5014232397,
0.3879053593,
0.3932392895,
0.7673165202,
-0.0044656172,
0.186809659,
-0.4013231099,
0.2139624208,
-0.0681543574,
0.821185112,
-0.7897971272,
-0.4202497303,
-0.4037421942,
0.1486812979,
0.1904113442,
-0.7441381812,
0.367188096,
-0.990703702,
-0.1835317314,
-0.1274077147,
-0.4941942692,
-0.3890657127,
-0.0617761016,
-0.7507930994,
0.5881630778,
-0.0981566459,
-0.9454683065,
0.6037521362,
-0.7012780905,
-0.5297896862,
0.6176400781,
-0.5195824504,
-0.6477803588,
-0.0804143324,
0.0287555661,
0.5279827118,
-0.5583122373,
0.4344774783,
-0.5269956589,
-0.1137086153,
0.5095558167,
-0.0865266845,
0.6388296485,
0.0856353045,
-0.1925053447,
-0.1477526724,
-1.278126359,
-0.0615441166,
0.1126715466,
-0.3108194172,
-0.7584604025,
-0.0485673249,
0.147825703,
0.0672508031,
0.1047681868,
-0.9027810097,
0.0563614666,
-0.4661674798,
0.6258209944,
0.2786799371,
0.2938985825,
0.4091147184,
-0.0236470401,
0.399155587,
-0.0453025289,
-0.2904109955,
0.0594996847,
-0.185957849,
-0.2712600529,
-0.877987802,
0.8578110933,
0.6164960861,
-0.537656188,
0.4351481795,
-0.474937886,
-0.4352337718,
-0.8273254037,
-0.0705333278,
0.5228304863,
0.742839694,
0.7384998202,
-0.1170317009,
-0.8548431396,
-1.1722557545,
-0.0462899543,
0.1642517895,
-0.2878403366,
0.3590392172,
0.8072378039,
-0.6887337565,
1.1124670506,
-0.2936657369,
-0.2440614998,
0.1149141565,
0.2059416622,
0.199456498,
0.4251146615,
0.2152703255,
-0.8355360031,
-0.020694891,
0.1337160617,
-0.9486064315,
-0.2361169904,
0.1249085665,
-0.3610346913,
-0.069824852,
0.5248715878,
-0.5209439397,
0.3728090823,
0.1748161912,
-0.1336242557,
0.3301669657,
-0.1921203732,
0.0458891131,
-0.9669169784,
0.5205922127,
0.2735319436,
-0.3580518663,
-0.4007299542,
-0.0760713667,
0.2160418183,
0.0694582239,
-0.2502341568,
0.9334212542,
-0.5024054646,
0.05205575,
-0.1898304969,
-0.2227903605,
0.0139303915,
0.0813386813,
0.4072244167,
0.4594438374,
0.3794696033,
-0.7322904468,
0.0510958768,
0.6211995482,
-0.0407346375,
0.5897619128,
-0.8490244746,
0.1708564907,
-0.4378966987,
0.3409580886,
-0.3348787129,
-0.4722041786,
0.4743376672,
-0.3550279737,
0.5351718664,
-0.0992980972,
-0.5432459712,
-0.2911408842,
0.1319197267,
0.583560586,
0.3700816333,
-0.2791943252,
0.7579190135,
0.5624414682,
-0.4193154573,
-0.4625641406,
-0.6336833835,
0.0328415632,
-0.1548572034,
-0.3439214826,
0.6337969899,
0.0561386533,
-0.227722764,
0.0209083334,
-0.3059436977,
-0.1113978103,
-0.123320207,
0.4505810738,
0.6234204769,
-0.1887696981,
0.331194222,
0.0589824319,
-0.1672583073,
0.1298519671,
-0.0607808717,
0.229090184,
0.1439315081,
-0.0026482602,
-0.4632641375,
0.2681035697,
0.376657486,
-0.540268898,
0.8521568775,
0.5107443929,
-0.7742359638,
0.0754050612,
-0.5581513047,
-0.3776780665,
-0.3680961728,
0.4894009233,
-0.3519566655,
-0.8178303838,
0.5642831326,
-0.1419483274,
0.0245840754,
0.3863944411,
0.344848752,
-0.1561720371,
0.8368116617,
0.4306060672,
0.101715751,
0.0261806101,
-0.2098383158,
0.1492283791,
-1.155531168,
-0.4670287669,
-0.6224167943,
-0.3618280888,
-0.4867708683,
-0.4413845539,
0.2626656592,
0.0382247083,
-0.3319672942,
0.3518314958,
-0.4030244946,
0.2443686426,
0.3511363566,
0.4378672838,
0.283408612,
0.0455218256,
-0.3325363994,
-0.1011872813,
-0.4244531095,
-0.874982655,
1.0311411619,
0.2538888454,
0.6779583693,
-0.052196864,
0.9810672998,
0.1146392524,
0.7758184075,
-0.6917021871,
0.7317252755,
0.075838685,
-0.8401904106,
-0.2489069402,
-0.6576012969,
-1.0716502666,
0.027965311,
-0.496889174,
-0.7437703013,
0.42981565,
-0.09022405,
-0.7072618604,
0.1944496185,
-0.2409586608,
0.4983755052,
-0.0237479247,
-0.3831066191,
0.252140671,
-0.9514684081,
-0.040888872,
-0.4336951375,
0.5639933348,
-0.2018299699,
-0.1756127924,
1.0345447063,
-0.2277386338,
0.5219997764,
-0.0124551868,
0.1720138043,
0.0603314601,
0.0418845452,
0.3766130507,
0.2780985534,
-0.0864217207,
0.5961048603,
0.1589024663,
-0.2207923532,
-0.2366582304,
0.3918008804,
-0.4347070158,
-0.187687248,
-0.5483215451,
-0.50219208,
-0.1962559223,
0.490239352,
0.4901560545,
0.5047360063,
-0.2919760346,
0.1970483959,
0.9032121301,
-0.3738846183,
0.2143738419,
0.7405043244,
-0.0436230525,
-0.6842597127,
0.7141041756,
0.1382622272,
-0.2428280264,
0.6342118979,
-0.2031917274,
-0.3660795987,
-0.5482017994,
-0.4250595272,
0.670573473,
-0.4716774523,
-0.5561721325,
-1.1145354509,
-0.1545795947,
-0.2897983789,
0.0553663298,
-0.0484502241,
-0.0636302233,
-0.4235643744,
-0.1385954916,
0.5037224293,
0.3711820543,
0.0057404563,
0.1253175735,
-1.1184322834,
0.4678208232,
-0.2219657302,
0.3600374162,
-0.3846296966,
-0.2902963459,
-0.106288895,
-0.0126283132,
0.1192745194,
-1.0312492847,
0.479154855,
0.2660197914,
0.5905075073,
0.4068050086,
-0.0725970566,
0.3511345685,
-0.8827725649,
-0.023381168,
0.1331427097,
-0.3553175926,
0.4820741117,
-0.2670934796,
-0.0642213225,
0.6940690875,
0.6988653541,
-0.329218328,
-0.0384071134,
-0.6546525359,
-0.9424988627,
0.4145391583,
-0.0668804199,
-0.1609509438,
-0.2561219633,
0.4998784959,
0.3613803685,
0.1742209196,
-0.4482321739,
-0.2500469089,
0.4836733043,
-0.4703829587,
0.0473398231,
-0.0764936283,
-0.0906304717,
-0.1376170814,
0.7754173279,
0.027995564,
0.3692207932,
0.4504855275,
-0.3522490859,
-0.108532764,
0.4034028053,
0.1860138029,
0.3318857253,
-0.334009558,
0.0435808636,
0.1929842383,
-0.6113749146,
0.1058694944,
0.6860990524,
-0.4335463047,
0.0651177689,
0.2764877379,
0.5265738368,
0.3408898413,
-0.8671813607,
0.0528938249,
0.1176615879,
-0.2357538939,
-0.1018759459,
-0.0913353413,
0.1043647453,
0.4542301893,
0.3162134886,
0.2958188355,
0.5799607635,
0.0042398255,
0.3302488327,
0.4213144183,
-0.4803536236,
-0.4022374451,
0.8483880162,
-0.0282836817,
-0.4025948644,
0.4410810173,
-0.3505659401,
-0.2525599003,
0.3648419678,
0.3681928515,
0.5597472787,
-0.2595981956,
0.0560648888,
0.4841642678,
-0.1776294708,
0.0037090273,
0.3263819814,
0.1132379994,
-0.5797914267,
-0.4548459649,
-1.1877788305,
-0.1817506999,
0.1630400419,
-0.7165830135,
0.3971369267,
-0.5543680191,
-0.6607278585,
0.5531556606,
-0.2316870391,
-0.8868672848,
0.3581984043,
0.1997156739,
0.6762700081,
-0.464679122,
0.4917808771,
1.1495825052,
-0.5484389067,
-0.3966845572,
-0.4584647417,
-0.0617992021,
-0.4103366137,
0.9151292443,
0.0743803531,
-0.0503885522,
0.2832698226,
-0.3992218971,
-0.8001642227,
1.0273280144,
0.1888415068,
-0.8628060222,
-0.2574383616,
-0.0491923057,
0.5983968973,
-0.2957133055,
0.2148406059,
0.64441365,
0.3406205475,
0.0250749458,
-0.6909319758,
0.2282003313,
-0.2468380183,
-0.0232869051,
0.366038233,
-0.3727380633,
0.3580045104,
-0.4629609585,
-0.1428570002,
-0.0078544542,
0.534512341,
0.6382302046,
0.5596361756,
0.1541276723,
0.493940115,
0.8323096037,
0.1424155682,
0.8117405176,
-0.1054221988,
0.2547711134,
0.879131794,
-0.4417190552,
0.8131387234,
0.3196308613,
-0.2417009473,
0.5551857352,
0.6301840544,
-0.0670155436,
0.4508233368,
0.4061898887,
-0.2009596676,
-0.2565345764,
-0.1379304677,
-0.2553918958,
0.4112704992,
0.4247535467,
-0.5775578618,
-0.0764296874,
0.3754688203,
0.1869094074,
-0.1605343074,
-0.3841010034,
0.7714101672,
0.2214476019,
-0.0464277044,
0.1422291398,
-0.1221166253,
0.8005010486,
-0.2971085012,
-0.2300288528,
0.1388296634,
0.1152178198,
-0.1877839565,
-0.1052727401,
0.0276639834,
-0.0627387539,
-0.3584050238,
0.2332889587,
0.768737793,
-0.3116652966,
-0.7648843527,
0.2608295679,
0.3698728085,
0.1615176201,
0.1644032449,
-0.4905957282,
-0.1980793178,
-0.3784596622,
-0.1747504771,
0.2234298289,
0.6000820398,
-0.0682075396,
0.7736253142,
0.5959711671,
0.399392873,
-0.1321168542,
-0.0878887624,
0.5068330169,
-0.8495892286,
-0.2353469431,
-0.8435510397,
0.2248787433,
-0.082682766,
-0.0845538378,
0.3898070157,
0.6677032113,
0.6419013143,
-0.1381535083,
0.815842092,
-0.0352885611,
1.0115113258,
-0.3201910555,
0.8968259692,
-0.4374274611,
0.2191297114,
-0.2311574221,
-0.6924106479,
-0.5985480547,
0.6740067601,
-0.460788399,
0.1345374286,
0.5662068725,
0.5978255868,
0.0233005974,
0.0763522983,
0.1215835661,
0.2668826878,
0.1311815977,
0.1970423162,
0.4312259853,
-0.3279750645,
0.2696402669,
-0.1798023731,
-0.1635178775,
-0.4748002589,
-0.6357172132,
-0.7411880493,
-0.3845936656,
-0.6065529585,
-0.3248902857,
0.1315572411,
1.2621878386,
0.7586696744,
-0.963467896,
0.4083766937,
0.1439380348,
-0.4712209105,
-0.0589890368,
-0.1375529021,
0.4105703235,
-0.0423863642,
-0.4817907512,
0.2020290494,
0.3911209702,
0.0698732138,
0.0164369345,
0.0853668377,
-0.2143713534,
0.0760219246,
0.3634462357,
0.4701625407,
-0.4740608037,
-0.0975194126,
0.2580942214,
-0.3807232976,
0.0484753996,
0.6544311047,
-0.9523940682,
0.2294907421,
0.2320536077,
0.921022892,
0.2028578222,
-0.1483716071,
0.2584032714,
-0.4085780382,
-0.1124810278,
0.6197191477,
0.4296948314,
0.4356617928,
-0.4749251902,
0.5492988229,
0.3044497073,
-0.6128009558,
-0.7604419589,
-0.1788103431,
-0.9264275432,
-0.0546712652,
0.9862058163,
0.1982905418,
-0.4060216546,
-0.3416989446,
-0.1898676008,
0.39951092,
-0.4529973269,
0.6084501743,
0.3269845247,
-0.1422655582,
-0.0110175498,
-0.6374042034,
0.3221695125,
-0.0350264572,
-0.7781588435,
-0.1728181839,
0.5738332868,
0.6189379692,
0.1879519969,
0.7687785029,
-0.2364139259,
0.0904799849,
-0.2349401861,
0.5025150776,
0.0385210738,
-0.2503607571,
-0.1866518855,
-0.0470516831,
-0.1960697323,
0.065547891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20030v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20030v1 | LEMoE: Advanced Mixture of Experts Adaptor for Lifelong Model Editing of Large Language Models | 2024-06-28T16:17:41 | 2024-06-28T16:17:41 | Renzhi Wang, Piji Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) require continual knowledge updates to stay
abreast of the ever-changing world facts, prompting the formulation of lifelong
model editing task. While recent years have witnessed the development of
various techniques for single and batch editing, these methods either fail to
apply or perform sub-optimally when faced with lifelong editing. In this paper,
we introduce LEMoE, an advanced Mixture of Experts (MoE) adaptor for lifelong
model editing. We first analyze the factors influencing the effectiveness of
conventional MoE adaptor in lifelong editing, including catastrophic
forgetting, inconsistent routing and order sensitivity. Based on these
insights, we propose a tailored module insertion method to achieve lifelong
editing, incorporating a novel KV anchor routing to enhance routing consistency
between training and inference stage, along with a concise yet effective
clustering-based editing order planning. Experimental results demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method in lifelong editing, surpassing previous model
editing techniques while maintaining outstanding performance in batch editing
task. Our code will be available. | [
-0.185295105,
-1.1261627674,
0.511348784,
0.2352142036,
-0.1378787756,
-0.0546209477,
-0.3333765864,
-0.2228628993,
0.1658542603,
0.5776475668,
-0.4432106018,
-0.4342967272,
-0.6148171425,
-0.1540189981,
-0.0467118621,
0.4993073344,
0.0059710601,
0.1439680159,
-0.2093810737,
-0.3307846487,
-0.9087230563,
-0.27861166,
-0.8713968992,
-0.1428469718,
0.5193953514,
0.3628216088,
0.5687497854,
0.5867466927,
0.2423349619,
0.439170599,
-0.314381659,
0.4954735637,
-0.4053994119,
0.4566196203,
-0.6069098711,
-0.4901182652,
-1.2518861294,
-0.4348482788,
0.7285659909,
0.4412157238,
-0.1907191873,
-0.3232650459,
-0.0797813013,
0.6301698089,
-0.7625305057,
-0.5166506171,
-0.99827075,
-0.1776872873,
0.0177921094,
-0.004609745,
-0.5020335317,
-0.0604788885,
-0.0549837202,
-0.4566003978,
-0.0208790079,
-0.1066019908,
0.3012693226,
0.3876935542,
-0.2980150878,
-0.2274526805,
-0.7216987014,
0.6220085621,
-1.0567154884,
0.4056336284,
-0.041213572,
0.139063403,
-0.5287582874,
-0.4439384043,
-0.6048710346,
0.0025885452,
0.392323792,
0.133783862,
-0.0064063529,
0.3435060084,
-0.1445181966,
0.1119016111,
-0.3876957893,
0.3701714277,
-0.0537204035,
-0.0450276844,
0.6761299968,
0.1907238066,
0.3825953305,
0.1608819962,
0.0241887309,
0.393009454,
-0.6323455572,
-0.5157827735,
0.2109466493,
-0.2234623134,
0.3475371897,
0.4902190864,
-0.3152495325,
0.9296873212,
0.2660264075,
-0.2861683369,
-0.1391337663,
0.1495021433,
-0.3046458364,
-0.0886204839,
0.7747462988,
0.5605569482,
0.2682846487,
-0.0102254013,
-0.3401629925,
-0.451418817,
0.2139592618,
-0.396538347,
-0.3363653421,
0.2256063968,
-0.1942074001,
-0.2092354894,
-0.0856660157,
-0.7304614782,
-0.3577456772,
-0.0974222645,
0.4794353247,
-0.493381083,
-0.0131369978,
0.1929439008,
0.0050648358,
-0.3749802411,
0.5826157928,
-1.0802499056,
0.0731710643,
0.6099731326,
0.8846388459,
-0.3206518292,
-0.4373086989,
-0.619419992,
0.6018888354,
-0.1169040054,
0.8626202941,
-0.7806813121,
-0.7400591969,
-0.2676368356,
0.0638763309,
-0.2648103237,
-0.5971202254,
0.2853966355,
-0.8362600803,
-0.1750799716,
0.0378768481,
-0.9537174702,
-0.0071860477,
0.078592889,
-0.3085283339,
1.0062659979,
0.0304924697,
-0.3329592347,
0.1291097403,
-0.7145238519,
-0.1744604558,
0.0195157006,
0.1430055052,
-0.3284995556,
0.2137724459,
0.4796980917,
0.5289776921,
0.4129377306,
0.4935667515,
-0.3516454399,
-0.1813651174,
0.2983230352,
-0.4828768075,
0.4774505496,
-0.136625424,
-0.0504942909,
0.3562734425,
-0.7353314757,
-0.541187644,
-0.1420752108,
-0.5435641408,
-0.4804778397,
0.0648202673,
0.0331295691,
0.103062883,
0.5124495625,
-0.5017201304,
0.8522216082,
-0.0115851099,
0.3662552238,
1.4362124205,
0.3349877894,
0.5349785686,
-0.2668557465,
0.5825106502,
-0.0314641148,
0.4147644639,
-0.1223703027,
-0.6742234826,
-1.0888079405,
-0.2097301185,
0.4631206095,
0.82859689,
-0.4796161056,
0.5476940274,
-0.4997356832,
-0.600404799,
-0.4603822827,
0.5896874666,
0.0125966873,
0.3329446912,
0.460432291,
-0.1435736716,
-0.4952217937,
-0.7858620286,
-0.2951796353,
0.1573513001,
0.0697823539,
0.1912848502,
0.5458423495,
-0.6966971755,
1.1403822899,
-0.5069089532,
0.0843307823,
-0.2080440223,
-0.1204655915,
0.1180009693,
0.8255653977,
0.4375777543,
-0.4788472056,
-0.6118610501,
0.2036154866,
-0.5835777521,
-0.2484935224,
-0.2768017948,
-0.3811663985,
0.2293745875,
0.6335583925,
-0.5593572855,
-0.0148325954,
0.7147522569,
0.0167429298,
0.5501256585,
-0.4526568949,
0.0508391596,
-1.1822477579,
-0.2833784223,
-0.2084915787,
-0.3115437031,
-0.5706236959,
0.0525817871,
0.1458100826,
0.3859965205,
-0.3736218512,
0.8298246861,
-0.3134638071,
0.1915758997,
-0.321356684,
0.2132439315,
-0.285150677,
0.2889220119,
-0.2134548873,
0.5803468227,
0.3303785026,
-0.6152722239,
0.5948105454,
0.1545463055,
-0.3200954199,
0.7526550293,
-0.5540077686,
0.468116492,
0.0168151855,
0.288812995,
-0.727181375,
-0.2273843288,
0.1598975509,
-0.1950996071,
0.2728967071,
-0.179700315,
-0.3845274448,
-0.077858761,
-0.037670847,
0.3112548888,
0.4568207562,
-0.3443002105,
1.0217504501,
0.1609493941,
-0.5493882895,
-0.6120550036,
-0.6150894165,
0.2543113828,
-0.0975733995,
-0.7338628173,
0.3125284314,
-0.5139673352,
-0.2677907944,
0.0154440664,
-0.0853990391,
-0.2242789567,
-0.0006192717,
0.0229940806,
0.2884611785,
-0.2987356782,
-0.032733012,
0.6620492339,
-0.3362098634,
-0.3533851206,
-0.2313491851,
0.3009139895,
0.3706873059,
-0.4183245599,
-0.5229687095,
0.3535373211,
0.8208578229,
0.0195150077,
0.6727824211,
0.4201802313,
-0.1769089401,
-0.1887649745,
-1.0933407545,
0.1765266359,
-0.5353222489,
0.6557683945,
-0.3546703458,
-1.0102580786,
0.5338618159,
-0.3905267119,
0.2103635669,
0.5072532892,
0.4436168373,
-0.1001122743,
0.6985123158,
0.7335653901,
-0.3886458576,
0.4998443723,
0.0336112082,
-0.0352402441,
-1.0814831257,
-0.0182134416,
-0.1165706888,
-0.256133467,
-0.3022867143,
-0.5633262396,
0.5322993994,
0.4422016144,
0.0733212754,
-0.0344955921,
-0.0668652132,
0.6650253534,
0.2692590952,
0.154304266,
0.5278884172,
-0.2550596893,
-0.124645941,
0.0870752186,
-0.8961085081,
-0.3040090799,
0.928378582,
0.211292237,
0.7009645104,
0.0411107913,
0.5252127647,
0.4049321115,
0.4121852517,
-0.5577612519,
0.7125610113,
-0.2531506717,
-0.4320930541,
-0.3651418984,
-0.0357163809,
-0.3670310676,
0.2558872104,
-0.2980198264,
-0.7220754623,
0.3309440017,
0.5227860212,
-0.335457623,
0.548599124,
-0.3620650768,
0.6079008579,
-0.1113841683,
-0.3563741744,
-0.5203248262,
-0.4143798947,
0.1966294795,
-0.2436241359,
0.5473950505,
0.1561458558,
-0.284733057,
0.5658175945,
-0.5866377354,
0.7266260386,
-0.0235436,
-0.1124889031,
0.0142379543,
0.2435461581,
0.8619040847,
0.1360919625,
-0.3672023416,
0.0346500985,
-0.5376494527,
-0.5124251842,
-0.8159786463,
0.9006029963,
-0.6310535669,
-0.5705725551,
0.0934423134,
-0.7664266229,
-0.2905102074,
0.076817371,
0.1770111024,
0.473769933,
-0.2289915234,
0.2185902297,
0.8099099398,
-0.2618129849,
0.5724378824,
0.4693275392,
-0.182443276,
-0.7622028589,
0.8989958167,
0.3324538767,
0.5498259068,
0.4130320847,
0.1865928024,
0.25902614,
-0.8593214154,
-0.5901104808,
0.1777873635,
-0.9116225243,
0.1754650176,
-1.008612752,
-0.2088675797,
-0.368770659,
-0.9705814719,
-0.5598806143,
-0.3891176879,
-0.0335828476,
0.1638080627,
0.4973446131,
0.9512219429,
-0.2341199517,
0.815436542,
-0.9561280608,
0.234056443,
0.744017303,
0.1122096181,
0.0760070384,
-0.5403606296,
-0.3889988363,
-0.0329827182,
-0.1939838529,
-0.7606076598,
0.2042816877,
0.2022674978,
0.6962578297,
0.2440517843,
-0.3995497823,
0.8494206667,
-0.6686746478,
0.8028315306,
-0.201970458,
-1.0546004772,
0.4984060228,
-0.708714962,
0.4738891721,
0.4438329637,
0.0676294118,
-0.6460481286,
-0.4776349962,
-0.3422677815,
-0.8450008631,
0.2135609388,
-0.1588548422,
0.1413102597,
0.0473309979,
0.6137772799,
0.2678406537,
0.1494552046,
-0.5125706196,
-0.1354718357,
0.2597105205,
-0.1943067759,
-0.0048976913,
-0.7266919017,
0.3802613616,
-0.4266550243,
0.9928221107,
0.1031238586,
-0.0805429295,
0.0236785803,
-0.380682379,
-0.1254875064,
0.4049335122,
0.915478766,
0.9157041311,
-0.3771325648,
-0.3688096404,
0.7733209729,
-0.5363855362,
0.0095020579,
-0.4887462854,
-0.2637273371,
0.1247662604,
0.6133241057,
0.7680739164,
0.4157916009,
-0.423314631,
0.1678845137,
0.2503831983,
-0.1522257328,
-0.0050200289,
0.4842586517,
0.2715419531,
0.1307588071,
0.2525132895,
0.3622740209,
-0.0529618263,
-0.1392148435,
0.054277584,
0.148828432,
-0.1144260168,
-0.0041093244,
0.5515101552,
0.4339892864,
-0.5724545121,
0.5184782147,
0.1177240163,
-0.4769922793,
0.36114043,
0.3792470694,
0.8693422079,
-0.9304296374,
-0.1675260216,
0.1665423661,
0.3472265005,
-0.0517974608,
-0.0984125733,
0.2816045284,
-0.7234925628,
-0.6910303235,
-0.4718225002,
-0.4800673723,
0.0428577289,
-0.4207235277,
0.3504738808,
-0.4096265137,
0.1193724349,
-0.3854832053,
-0.6735517383,
-0.2508682013,
0.3047527075,
-0.364497453,
0.845166266,
-0.6607774496,
1.0005484819,
0.7349874377,
0.2258664221,
-0.1249299645,
-0.1457304806,
0.0756878108,
-0.5835248232,
0.2859325409,
-0.1643999219,
-0.0469657071,
0.2690791488,
-0.387898773,
-0.5587846041,
0.9880527854,
0.2027012259,
-0.993432045,
-0.0911372975,
-0.1544539779,
0.1802606881,
-0.40599823,
0.2642790675,
0.3959992826,
0.5347862244,
0.0267922338,
-0.8333922029,
-0.3271433711,
-0.23306261,
0.1414633691,
-0.0025529894,
-0.7269256711,
0.754925251,
0.1406861842,
0.6156103015,
0.2266735733,
0.7260996699,
0.1603401601,
-0.0090005239,
0.7113311291,
0.5998436213,
0.6497383118,
0.3934040964,
0.6467905045,
-0.2655408382,
0.2372573912,
1.2551271915,
0.0102993837,
0.9825011492,
0.302154541,
0.0253547244,
0.7251433134,
0.4738520682,
0.0752474815,
0.3733666241,
-0.1937516779,
-0.5759943724,
-0.5357293487,
0.2294458896,
-0.3660985529,
0.2299368829,
0.421189189,
-0.254701376,
0.1217771769,
0.142738834,
0.2237150073,
-0.0977879092,
-0.3298879862,
0.7035933137,
-0.0512925945,
-0.3686888814,
0.1905601919,
0.2076875269,
0.9027810097,
-0.5355359912,
-0.0110479528,
-0.255192399,
0.1073825657,
-0.1143927649,
-0.4960458875,
0.1382698715,
-0.131596908,
-0.3138515055,
-0.024894651,
0.5286434293,
-0.3512228131,
-0.6299433112,
0.219475776,
0.3611859977,
-0.2016302794,
0.087780267,
-0.7005894184,
0.2186826319,
-0.1161639988,
-0.5503303409,
0.3463341594,
0.3170137703,
0.0997176692,
0.7963664532,
0.6349409819,
0.2502577305,
0.229242608,
-0.1257493347,
0.7934167981,
-0.5796149969,
-0.4276920557,
-1.0726963282,
1.0401726961,
-0.1133223251,
-0.3305662572,
0.5880311728,
0.3228757083,
0.5591444969,
-0.3242750764,
0.9495401382,
0.1491236538,
-0.1384753883,
-0.9557007551,
0.6015368104,
-0.4741285145,
0.2362047732,
-0.4155492485,
-1.2256014347,
-0.3225719333,
0.4603055716,
-0.4090637267,
0.0040255422,
0.643914938,
0.9208923578,
-0.2752712667,
-0.2578826249,
0.4376512766,
0.6979122758,
0.3826700747,
0.5704883337,
0.5224309564,
-0.1985157877,
-0.0364787579,
-0.2597914934,
-0.1507060081,
-0.4812635481,
-0.9161557555,
-1.0615762472,
-0.2472577244,
-0.3727011979,
-0.0342262238,
0.5285412669,
1.0349965096,
0.6311756968,
-0.6753671169,
-0.0693162531,
-0.2517504394,
0.2335194647,
-0.0693042129,
-0.1720560193,
0.2771839499,
0.0182153732,
-0.8770358562,
0.720615387,
0.7293579578,
-0.2238138169,
-0.1339875311,
-0.1833936125,
-0.4649519026,
0.2716946304,
0.5238652229,
-0.0450294502,
-0.8274099231,
-0.3811334074,
-0.2103573829,
0.1523698121,
-0.0107670175,
0.605518043,
-0.3632123768,
0.9264393449,
0.4475009143,
0.8287557364,
-0.0347342007,
-0.041003298,
0.7714433074,
-0.3782210648,
0.1174856722,
-0.1023929268,
0.5100120306,
0.2074864507,
-0.4434196055,
0.247699663,
0.5856508017,
-0.9261871576,
-0.5792922378,
-0.001883807,
-1.1617341042,
-0.2318822742,
1.2337087393,
-0.2164216191,
-0.2208239436,
-0.1028853357,
-0.6357815266,
0.1936999857,
-0.3201290369,
0.5474942923,
0.8532522321,
-0.0562492274,
-0.2897309363,
-0.7957699299,
-0.1636956632,
0.4328235984,
-0.5706470609,
-0.2505851984,
0.6098181009,
0.4732286632,
-0.2825949788,
0.6892478466,
0.3102104962,
0.3425142467,
-0.0744020641,
0.104483068,
-0.224408403,
-0.3032074273,
-0.383329004,
0.0671850443,
0.2357872576,
0.2620928288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20015v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20015v1 | ToolBeHonest: A Multi-level Hallucination Diagnostic Benchmark for Tool-Augmented Large Language Models | 2024-06-28T16:03:30 | 2024-06-28T16:03:30 | Yuxiang Zhang, Jing Chen, Junjie Wang, Yaxin Liu, Cheng Yang, Chufan Shi, Xinyu Zhu, Zihao Lin, Hanwen Wan, Yujiu Yang, Tetsuya Sakai, Tian Feng, Hayato Yamana | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Tool-augmented large language models (LLMs) are rapidly being integrated into
real-world applications. Due to the lack of benchmarks, the community still
needs to fully understand the hallucination issues within these models. To
address this challenge, we introduce a comprehensive diagnostic benchmark,
ToolBH. Specifically, we assess the LLM's hallucinations through two
perspectives: depth and breadth. In terms of depth, we propose a multi-level
diagnostic process, including (1) solvability detection, (2) solution planning,
and (3) missing-tool analysis. For breadth, we consider three scenarios based
on the characteristics of the toolset: missing necessary tools, potential
tools, and limited functionality tools. Furthermore, we developed seven tasks
and collected 700 evaluation samples through multiple rounds of manual
annotation. The results show the significant challenges presented by the ToolBH
benchmark. The current advanced models Gemini-1.5-Pro and GPT-4o only achieve a
total score of 45.3 and 37.0, respectively, on a scale of 100. In this
benchmark, larger model parameters do not guarantee better performance; the
training data and response strategies also play a crucial role in tool-enhanced
LLM scenarios. Our diagnostic analysis indicates that the primary reason for
model errors lies in assessing task solvability. Additionally, open-weight
models suffer from performance drops with verbose replies, whereas proprietary
models excel with longer reasoning. | [
-0.4947895408,
-0.8710588217,
0.6180759072,
0.4052726328,
-0.3579827547,
0.250007689,
-0.2596136928,
-0.5954637527,
0.0579793192,
0.5524241924,
-0.4967213273,
-0.6549143195,
-0.6080498099,
0.066871509,
-0.6151689887,
0.5977041125,
0.069038786,
0.1223815158,
-0.157039538,
0.1041473076,
-0.9871198535,
-0.4081857502,
-0.6257196069,
-0.1216907054,
0.2886764109,
0.2153186798,
0.6571639776,
0.3003750145,
0.5967132449,
0.2557710409,
-0.3578896821,
0.0779895633,
-0.2815306783,
0.4901273251,
0.0611177459,
-0.1017812192,
-0.7728205323,
-0.0859382749,
0.4447461665,
1.1385247707,
-0.1339620203,
0.1345178932,
-0.0637357011,
0.0589597039,
-0.5745964646,
-0.1095181629,
-0.6366606951,
-0.0740424395,
-0.1665425748,
0.2623680532,
-0.337887913,
-0.3581532538,
-0.0341951028,
-0.1236910447,
0.2698905766,
-0.02080792,
0.5440832376,
0.4740024805,
-0.3979965746,
-0.3624598682,
-0.6025628448,
0.6092510223,
-0.8583605289,
0.6876782179,
0.1722908616,
0.4160214961,
-0.2936185002,
-0.5415846705,
-0.4349608123,
-0.4188641906,
-0.0472511128,
0.154708311,
-0.1758031994,
-0.1093399376,
0.4968929589,
0.3718434572,
-0.852026701,
0.2777542472,
-0.4208265543,
-0.5747638941,
0.526987195,
0.2529138029,
0.0263856277,
-0.4012758732,
-0.0380141884,
-0.0551599562,
-0.3851251006,
-0.1283271164,
0.2229913026,
0.4344804287,
-0.0305072516,
0.4782426357,
0.0957815349,
0.677641511,
-0.258635819,
-0.3369806707,
0.2749243081,
-0.0933994576,
-0.2425603569,
0.1601852775,
0.5267588496,
0.0609633774,
0.0089991651,
-0.4508340657,
-0.436416924,
0.0764306933,
0.3777933121,
-0.8979725838,
-0.2368154526,
0.6017796993,
-0.2969648838,
-0.1302039027,
-0.1959855855,
-0.5649170876,
-0.8731983304,
-0.1103981286,
0.5480133295,
-0.4594080746,
-0.7032030821,
0.2037386447,
-0.0353480615,
0.1350731552,
0.209811002,
-0.3946423829,
0.4001252353,
0.6918461323,
1.0299752951,
-0.4655836821,
-0.3004708588,
-0.7429048419,
-0.0469217338,
-0.5380654335,
0.8554698825,
-0.4966627657,
-0.6867109537,
-0.1883561611,
0.1674388051,
0.2433318645,
-0.9552087784,
0.6144728065,
-0.0002595268,
-0.188697055,
-0.2655275762,
-0.3027034402,
-0.2325727344,
0.3122930825,
-0.6624156237,
1.4641501904,
0.1897135228,
-0.5192460418,
0.4716924131,
-0.3655018508,
-0.5391731262,
0.1069713235,
-0.0580393523,
-0.2511990368,
0.4305768609,
0.225263685,
0.7725719213,
-0.3935582638,
0.4413643479,
-0.5242390037,
-0.6838988066,
-0.0988849923,
-0.1407487243,
0.8128602505,
-0.2143068165,
-0.4422219992,
0.3111900985,
-0.9753794074,
-0.1017319486,
0.1465010643,
0.1496112496,
-0.2063927799,
-0.335644871,
0.042662181,
0.3184196949,
0.1169197783,
-0.4547204375,
0.2157024443,
-0.4870964587,
0.0171018634,
0.8012459874,
-0.1851215661,
-0.1333208531,
0.0571483746,
0.7054688931,
0.3239570856,
0.163677007,
-0.0972278044,
-0.2702581882,
-0.7596912384,
-0.4325391352,
0.1679870188,
0.4739405215,
-0.1813294739,
0.6039105654,
-0.044765722,
-0.7700737119,
-0.6974647045,
-0.1140438542,
0.1698341519,
0.3230817914,
0.4379425645,
-0.4363006651,
-0.3034258485,
-1.1251525879,
-0.0850937963,
0.1373228431,
-0.0854211375,
0.2785412967,
0.5667846799,
-0.3620095551,
0.3959105313,
-0.2614916563,
-0.2984502316,
-0.3563837409,
0.2202908248,
0.3949736953,
0.0991115421,
0.2942921221,
-0.2220903337,
-0.0757662579,
0.0959406644,
-0.6511523128,
-0.25231269,
-0.0406118929,
0.255831331,
0.3007685542,
0.5252361298,
-0.5745183825,
0.6273474097,
0.695364058,
-0.1339166164,
0.9807442427,
-0.0995477065,
-0.1247433275,
-1.0059477091,
0.2271654904,
-0.2267247438,
-0.1766256839,
-0.4105886519,
-0.0013722925,
0.0789030716,
-0.1109646186,
-0.0518100597,
0.6534591317,
-0.474824518,
-0.6663432121,
-0.3695752025,
0.6072250605,
-0.194499433,
0.259519726,
-0.0511514954,
0.8495956659,
0.7929826975,
-0.5375580788,
0.6244935989,
-0.0204086099,
-0.3251617849,
0.5326041579,
-0.9687572718,
0.2091795802,
0.0358941779,
0.0466877148,
-1.2008517981,
-0.1694225222,
0.0643348321,
-0.3098199964,
0.1738465875,
0.0828758255,
-0.7578419447,
-0.4922030866,
-0.2146096379,
0.3283245265,
0.3889907598,
-0.4345466793,
0.87315768,
0.1515805721,
-0.2076358646,
-0.5281202197,
-0.3713240027,
0.1085675061,
-0.1164648011,
-0.6214358807,
0.2951430678,
-0.0974144787,
-0.2248854935,
-0.2468334734,
-0.4363657832,
0.1838141978,
0.2443620861,
0.5308713913,
0.2196664065,
-0.1202417538,
0.1360042393,
0.195570156,
-0.1000654697,
0.2963496149,
0.2870805264,
0.8201882243,
-0.2482226193,
-0.606595099,
-0.1905244738,
0.1048432738,
0.565813899,
-0.2454669476,
0.3498363793,
0.9422439337,
-0.4169333577,
-0.2180407792,
-0.9032026529,
-0.4857283831,
-0.3888058662,
0.5116796494,
-0.6861015558,
-0.5498072505,
0.8053813577,
-0.3178916574,
0.0324628949,
0.2125420123,
0.7353715301,
0.263225317,
1.117905736,
0.5071658492,
0.0090396898,
-0.2760587931,
-0.1268422455,
0.5164039135,
-0.911020875,
-0.3299997151,
-0.4611203074,
-0.2036164552,
-0.4486329854,
-0.2651612163,
0.4472872019,
0.2880813777,
-0.0447039753,
0.2860322595,
-0.5397552252,
0.2623391449,
0.2626660764,
-0.1394527555,
0.3302494287,
-0.416582197,
-0.470944345,
-0.0682197362,
-0.471563369,
-0.4535220265,
0.8885626197,
0.2635248303,
0.3836327195,
0.0706955567,
0.6682807803,
0.1207854301,
0.0591902062,
-1.0220428705,
0.7956334352,
0.1481111497,
-0.654728055,
-0.3371583819,
-0.0791440234,
-0.8682875633,
0.4386027455,
0.0568062253,
-0.9970687628,
0.0217316579,
-0.0989598706,
-0.2675861716,
0.0518944673,
-0.482337743,
1.1377091408,
-0.2870922983,
-0.314668864,
-0.2874474525,
-0.5582042933,
0.5756120682,
-0.3553481698,
0.2705796063,
-0.3253944516,
0.01829792,
0.4452374578,
-0.1069968566,
0.6426774263,
-0.142276153,
-0.3055560589,
-0.362275213,
0.498211503,
0.5504270196,
-0.0083305826,
-0.0921771526,
0.0980286896,
0.1028340757,
-0.3081348836,
-0.4025661647,
0.5952099562,
-0.4697830975,
-0.6580959558,
-0.4214612842,
-0.6237385273,
-0.5936155915,
0.3448099196,
-0.0622339286,
0.5399218798,
-0.0940632075,
0.1120658293,
0.4913460314,
-0.5244440436,
0.3080094755,
0.2684438825,
-0.7113290429,
0.0305535346,
0.7580930591,
-0.0827018842,
0.1048085168,
-0.3552918732,
0.0298267771,
-0.1636609435,
-0.91574049,
-0.3350318074,
0.4278927147,
-0.7699084282,
-0.1223097891,
-0.6665273905,
-0.3225994408,
-0.4768144786,
0.1084892824,
-0.5462251306,
-0.1000743583,
0.0059826216,
-0.0907975808,
0.1554096937,
0.8379653692,
-0.0767814368,
0.1546182632,
-0.5710151196,
0.3865265548,
-0.0411704816,
0.3949052691,
0.2340340018,
-0.5722674131,
-0.1534862518,
-0.1671871245,
-0.2477965206,
-0.8166568875,
0.2079101354,
-0.2664209306,
0.6133610606,
0.2944641113,
0.0678425506,
0.9202299118,
-0.1897937953,
0.7986091375,
-0.0904150009,
-1.1556785107,
0.4709993005,
-0.1522419602,
0.3973458111,
0.1782740504,
0.4426354766,
-0.5414889455,
-0.8497496247,
-0.4236708879,
-0.8481305838,
0.5633665323,
-0.1404990852,
-0.1159379929,
0.092982173,
0.1977418512,
0.5747140646,
0.030840775,
-0.5979536772,
0.0432358086,
-0.1760830581,
0.2112787217,
0.0463386737,
-0.126859203,
0.0933274105,
-0.4892144799,
0.6065548062,
-0.0458923988,
0.0037249525,
-0.0772230327,
-0.3486804664,
0.1475661546,
0.1643640101,
0.5020698309,
1.0536050797,
-0.3996713161,
0.0464490205,
0.4383250773,
-0.4101012945,
-0.1078307629,
0.302731216,
0.3971598744,
0.1870771497,
0.5416585207,
0.830855906,
0.2679075897,
-0.8811874986,
0.6105189919,
0.1367119402,
-0.1900130361,
-0.3263404965,
-0.0658041909,
0.2892032266,
0.4578982294,
0.3188111186,
-0.2555583417,
0.4314711094,
-0.4724263549,
-0.0079802973,
0.7039667964,
-0.347121954,
-0.3850716054,
0.4926496744,
-0.052550599,
-0.2552081645,
0.7256795168,
-0.3741229177,
-0.5094532967,
0.4087152183,
0.4513132572,
0.9079044461,
-0.2268071622,
0.2285228223,
0.3827626705,
0.58656317,
0.0659607425,
0.3893502057,
0.1962758005,
-0.4841134548,
-0.5423531532,
-0.6500886679,
-0.305880487,
0.5198045969,
-0.7428854108,
0.4879395366,
-0.3812844753,
-0.2071559578,
0.1808756292,
0.0017038812,
-0.5856752396,
0.1902639866,
-0.1128176153,
0.7710708976,
-0.6180535555,
0.7307982445,
0.3855665326,
-0.2955961227,
-0.7289851904,
0.165190205,
0.0188030973,
-0.9310017824,
0.5203117132,
0.4180029929,
-0.2281561792,
-0.0640578344,
-0.1297269613,
-0.6068027616,
1.0189914703,
0.3370112479,
-0.5687157512,
-0.0431456417,
-0.075145863,
0.5336645246,
-0.1183845252,
0.3391810656,
0.9313316941,
0.6480265856,
0.0543211587,
-1.2748308182,
0.4094440043,
0.05222179,
0.0128976293,
0.2860582769,
-0.3099943995,
0.6447445154,
-0.3063782454,
-0.2147437781,
0.143702805,
0.1541566104,
0.371190995,
0.0790304095,
0.5359006524,
0.5203610659,
0.705114603,
-0.2016703635,
0.8451318741,
-0.3571719527,
-0.0792936757,
0.8671147823,
-0.467326045,
0.9144675732,
0.3463461995,
-0.0831835344,
0.2056138515,
0.7575531602,
-0.1640083939,
0.1623269618,
0.3393616974,
0.1151314154,
-0.4666110575,
-0.184795469,
-0.5550041795,
0.6108662486,
0.2755877078,
0.0141241644,
-0.1791992038,
0.1429341882,
-0.2019158453,
-0.2774547338,
-0.0922176391,
0.7704074383,
-0.0950567275,
-0.389475286,
0.8007401228,
-0.2155814022,
0.491953969,
-0.3601612449,
0.0727413148,
-0.4056958854,
0.1682734936,
-0.1381965578,
-0.5300163627,
0.3385114372,
-0.2695774734,
0.108483091,
0.1660247445,
0.5767288804,
-0.1520176232,
-0.5846124291,
0.6688805223,
0.7714278102,
0.6002477407,
-0.2915256619,
-0.5820713043,
0.6392763853,
-0.4101041555,
-0.2161491364,
0.071117565,
0.514885664,
-0.0615616217,
0.6524662971,
0.241112113,
0.2665604651,
-0.0363300294,
0.4573317766,
0.8291071057,
-0.7197473049,
0.0710743964,
-0.7715688944,
0.5944340825,
-0.2842484117,
-0.3774777651,
0.7740833163,
0.6892066598,
0.7681224346,
0.0954215452,
0.707486093,
0.1762849092,
0.7679077387,
-0.3454951346,
0.4600210786,
-0.992204845,
0.4211566746,
-0.4811099172,
-1.2210316658,
-0.2874606252,
0.4528793693,
-0.1979725063,
0.2745608985,
1.019500494,
0.9700359702,
-0.1889034063,
-0.0082516717,
0.5404741764,
0.4816685021,
0.1791846752,
0.3609894216,
0.8957002759,
-0.2079101801,
0.626999855,
-0.349088937,
-0.235180676,
-0.3660063446,
-0.7781102061,
-1.1721057892,
-0.6693393588,
-0.1611249745,
-0.2668528259,
0.0652926341,
0.7356076837,
0.6700874567,
-0.8024097681,
-0.4016477764,
0.1167561486,
0.0095360931,
-0.3263378441,
-0.1964600831,
0.373655349,
-0.3625113368,
-0.5178496838,
0.32573089,
0.5734113455,
-0.0219854992,
-0.747885704,
0.1223575026,
0.2170690447,
-0.1731643975,
0.7885712981,
-0.3092149198,
-1.2757989168,
-0.2690103352,
0.1960383356,
0.1318121254,
-0.1897756904,
0.8342991471,
-0.6898539066,
0.413487643,
-0.0606808662,
0.7087054849,
0.5581843257,
-0.3780416548,
0.4356914163,
-0.5618587136,
0.2701903582,
0.5191239119,
0.2535216808,
0.4102832973,
-0.0288857576,
0.5537209511,
0.0782717094,
-0.412668556,
-1.3963581324,
0.184721902,
-1.1277576685,
-0.5570257902,
0.9839532971,
0.211041823,
0.149575159,
-0.2759040594,
-0.3399482667,
0.057413213,
-0.1664606631,
0.9791514277,
1.0810190439,
-0.09934818,
-0.2604790628,
-0.7172380686,
0.3124327362,
0.3964158893,
-0.8374592662,
0.3533425927,
0.6458459496,
0.0357716642,
0.0507371314,
0.3063801825,
0.0488840267,
0.3412356079,
0.1550294608,
0.0448032431,
-0.1531454176,
-0.4453084469,
-0.111043036,
0.1183493659,
0.2093151361,
0.2166620642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19999v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19999v1 | The SIFo Benchmark: Investigating the Sequential Instruction Following Ability of Large Language Models | 2024-06-28T15:34:26 | 2024-06-28T15:34:26 | Xinyi Chen, Baohao Liao, Jirui Qi, Panagiotis Eustratiadis, Christof Monz, Arianna Bisazza, Maarten de Rijke | cs.CL | cs.CL | Following multiple instructions is a crucial ability for large language
models (LLMs). Evaluating this ability comes with significant challenges: (i)
limited coherence between multiple instructions, (ii) positional bias where the
order of instructions affects model performance, and (iii) a lack of
objectively verifiable tasks. To address these issues, we introduce a benchmark
designed to evaluate models' abilities to follow multiple instructions through
sequential instruction following (SIFo) tasks. In SIFo, the successful
completion of multiple instructions is verifiable by examining only the final
instruction. Our benchmark evaluates instruction following using four tasks
(text modification, question answering, mathematics, and security rule
following), each assessing different aspects of sequential instruction
following. Our evaluation of popular LLMs, both closed-source and open-source,
shows that more recent and larger models significantly outperform their older
and smaller counterparts on the SIFo tasks, validating the benchmark's
effectiveness. All models struggle with following sequences of instructions,
hinting at an important lack of robustness of today's language models. | [
-0.05065706,
-0.4098867178,
0.7079063058,
0.5851570368,
0.1198927388,
0.0933633,
-0.0202927887,
-0.3956198394,
-0.4159326255,
0.7400007248,
-0.6260660887,
-0.5428302288,
-0.8412648439,
0.3576915562,
-0.4440494776,
0.7901489139,
-0.2157093436,
0.1407868117,
-0.2302388996,
-0.0919448361,
-0.6772527695,
-0.3530061841,
-0.5395485163,
-0.3448919356,
0.4353787899,
0.4145594835,
0.4942257106,
0.7680727243,
0.7164778709,
0.3580716252,
0.0054421821,
0.1228086799,
-0.660312891,
0.2048232108,
0.074343659,
-0.3730337918,
-0.3084209859,
0.0964695662,
1.2179588079,
0.6980873346,
0.0869036764,
0.3426992297,
0.0965987816,
0.5242384672,
-0.5306014419,
0.1972940266,
-0.4974933267,
0.0001667359,
-0.2212281823,
-0.0145054404,
-0.6853027344,
-0.6335780025,
0.202925697,
-0.2676843107,
-0.1710226387,
0.1396921575,
0.4759609103,
0.3449992537,
-0.4922806025,
-0.3490374982,
-0.5497143269,
0.6479229927,
-0.7684859633,
0.7516635656,
0.4706661701,
0.1429983526,
-0.2945823371,
-0.6932080984,
-0.2545227706,
-0.5125746131,
0.0376118012,
-0.1126677319,
0.1491210759,
-0.1372916102,
0.7222095728,
0.0442675613,
-0.3877280951,
0.0029155815,
-0.4800516069,
-0.0521128401,
0.3603772819,
0.1799471527,
0.2373936027,
0.2559526265,
-0.7932969332,
-0.2366600782,
-0.8651522398,
0.1882646084,
0.366781503,
-0.1056370512,
-0.1353421509,
0.5726129413,
-0.2502423227,
0.5954688191,
-0.0941111967,
-0.3431046009,
0.4420959949,
-0.6042886972,
-0.1901253462,
0.01829537,
0.6763765216,
0.2090269923,
0.1691210419,
-0.2356693149,
-0.2408632487,
-0.4029783905,
0.1814153045,
-0.9175946712,
0.0996840894,
-0.0225037541,
-0.2939919531,
0.0194856469,
-0.0427964143,
-0.4724696875,
-0.3417241871,
-0.1094037592,
0.3829203844,
-0.4813515544,
0.1154917106,
-0.1680936962,
-0.053286083,
0.4544840157,
0.2271850705,
-0.924474895,
0.5586511493,
1.2399741411,
0.9089273214,
-0.2750837505,
-0.7843939662,
-0.8111531734,
0.1588990092,
-0.506670475,
0.743811965,
-0.8931180239,
-0.4035247564,
-0.4415771961,
0.2437992692,
-0.3932619989,
-0.3008513749,
0.415843904,
-0.4947086573,
-0.0999467298,
-0.3949664235,
-0.8681426644,
-0.2518717051,
0.1328597069,
-0.6752948761,
1.0548449755,
-0.1255286485,
-0.4613011479,
0.1670500636,
-0.2076805681,
-0.4305187762,
-0.0955642685,
-0.4051862359,
-0.131893158,
0.1744956672,
-0.2276393771,
0.396861285,
-0.363577038,
-0.0837029368,
-0.6924518943,
-0.8305875063,
0.082717821,
-0.4962765574,
0.6934090853,
-0.2815085649,
-0.4020916224,
0.0566697195,
-0.9046986699,
0.0242030714,
-0.0762413293,
-0.2078564167,
-0.3406941295,
0.1358563453,
-0.6571246982,
-0.0151650868,
0.3388444185,
-0.2176897377,
0.1381936818,
-0.1810460985,
0.2029302716,
1.024825573,
0.1131059453,
0.3133933246,
-0.2711445391,
0.4298724234,
-0.4314931333,
-0.0034270464,
-0.6318684816,
-0.7039586902,
-0.3946572542,
-0.1603675038,
0.1584994048,
0.7285372019,
-0.1159672067,
-0.1209572554,
-0.106060423,
-0.6289842725,
-0.4017629623,
0.3912429214,
0.6021244526,
0.5408852696,
0.0591728203,
-0.3790773451,
-0.2525959313,
-0.6960001588,
-0.0750644132,
-0.1452403665,
0.1942432374,
0.1064881012,
0.7061420679,
-0.09366557,
0.0567291416,
-0.2015844285,
0.2674810588,
0.4215821922,
0.4162902236,
0.1859766394,
0.4736100435,
0.2457882911,
-0.6163033247,
-0.5461401939,
0.0119433105,
-0.6841646433,
-0.1273019165,
-0.0057268557,
-0.038982477,
0.0866928697,
0.7062835693,
-0.2109117806,
0.3987777531,
0.648866117,
-0.1838726699,
0.6637457013,
-0.2543199956,
0.5048235059,
-0.5897108316,
0.1472915113,
-0.2531106472,
-0.1435563415,
-0.597550571,
0.2099713683,
0.2013171613,
-0.0289320033,
-0.3019502461,
0.4494545758,
-0.679829061,
-0.5839030743,
-0.2464845926,
-0.131385088,
-0.0464408025,
0.329090029,
0.0467658006,
1.1007906199,
0.5503205657,
-0.4166594446,
0.2325559556,
-0.0958956107,
-0.5894653201,
0.2880578935,
-0.9161556363,
0.4569299817,
-0.0318255126,
0.0328708515,
-1.2787892818,
-0.0065847049,
0.0803927258,
-0.0991825983,
0.0589533821,
-0.2130174935,
-0.6180770993,
-0.3539555967,
-0.3336697817,
0.3051276803,
0.4440340996,
-0.1908552647,
0.5498639345,
-0.0889041722,
-0.2540107071,
-0.8883740306,
-0.4849736094,
-0.2895908952,
0.0292555448,
-0.6009534001,
0.4354377687,
-0.3586615026,
-0.1769973338,
-0.1251999438,
-0.3407670856,
0.0073576849,
0.2328562289,
0.3851012886,
0.2674269378,
-0.3896291852,
-0.2950587571,
-0.2597017288,
-0.0481378809,
0.0917061493,
-0.0145928627,
0.4129299521,
-0.2262286097,
-0.612619698,
-0.6113351583,
0.2975690663,
0.7354106307,
-0.2356453538,
0.6954844594,
0.4455834925,
-0.399363935,
-0.0762341991,
-0.6847931147,
-0.0611458756,
-0.436408639,
0.2226768434,
-0.5627809763,
-0.703712821,
0.6057620645,
-0.0495975129,
0.4058208764,
0.0763928294,
0.4498160779,
0.0190510675,
1.0426627398,
0.6802944541,
0.0259794798,
0.4665097296,
0.1502705216,
-0.0109997801,
-0.7874264121,
-0.1555939168,
-0.6148784161,
-0.0127300685,
-0.5744693279,
-0.5281220675,
0.2681599557,
0.3693684638,
-0.3743391633,
0.6576535106,
-0.1100186408,
0.5727511048,
0.7550574541,
-0.0308390092,
0.312648803,
-0.1931375712,
-0.3371629119,
0.3248715103,
-0.3675805628,
-0.6775847077,
0.9737909436,
0.5319697857,
0.6920603514,
0.1725345701,
0.7356091738,
0.3288290799,
0.3386803269,
-0.3961186111,
0.7915394902,
-0.2936388254,
-0.3387657106,
-0.2597925067,
-0.4558386803,
-0.4860674143,
0.3297787011,
-0.0235119257,
-1.1758577824,
-0.025180947,
0.0601268783,
-0.4684869051,
-0.1488344222,
-0.7987177372,
0.9943725467,
-0.2832467258,
-0.5538773537,
-0.2420134097,
-0.5314202309,
0.4733754992,
-0.1325293928,
0.1065198109,
-0.3842661083,
-0.3445631564,
0.6324487925,
-0.278604269,
0.7718430758,
0.1593791991,
-0.0791794509,
0.0518833734,
-0.1211466268,
0.6943646669,
-0.2696761489,
-0.3385031521,
-0.070858188,
0.3097832501,
-0.2789174616,
-0.4291802943,
0.8894894719,
-0.5563137531,
-0.78099823,
-0.3659362197,
-0.243305549,
-0.3834330738,
0.4996781051,
0.0193010047,
0.5283198357,
-0.1563922763,
0.1577298045,
0.7143045068,
0.0150412507,
0.3631795943,
0.553388238,
-0.0172135979,
-0.3449782133,
0.6657534242,
0.1890530586,
0.396571666,
0.3848833442,
0.1304395348,
-0.3173997402,
-0.6194200516,
-0.6366998553,
0.1763692647,
-0.8336148858,
0.1197090372,
-0.4556684792,
-0.2011054754,
-0.5662116408,
0.0702946112,
-0.2532905936,
0.0191031247,
-0.1386510581,
0.203926459,
-0.1461650133,
1.0113651752,
0.3156782985,
0.2627744377,
-0.8808280826,
0.2694568932,
0.3191844523,
0.5108926296,
0.2618658543,
-0.5927985311,
0.1194400638,
-0.2506552041,
-0.1174730062,
-1.1200629473,
-0.2468443364,
-0.1017648503,
0.8305390477,
0.3735693991,
-0.3004753888,
0.8057025075,
-1.0577671528,
0.5088649392,
0.1198029965,
-0.8570687771,
0.3592170179,
-0.0327917188,
0.5075778365,
0.5961373448,
0.6674143672,
-0.230656907,
-0.372944653,
-0.3216569722,
-0.5644847751,
0.738907516,
0.0422920473,
-0.0824407414,
-0.0460545272,
0.1825707704,
0.1666886061,
0.2500136495,
-0.5397030711,
-0.1228408366,
0.2917130589,
-0.0451491512,
0.103202112,
-0.3151303828,
0.0241272319,
0.235364452,
0.725438118,
0.0095290858,
0.1934364289,
-0.1454746723,
-0.0272687282,
0.0206200369,
0.1664593369,
0.9235364199,
0.7273053527,
-0.2337198704,
0.0483828261,
0.3126118779,
-0.2908967733,
0.0258476455,
0.4216715395,
-0.3492966294,
-0.2044924945,
0.5734527707,
0.8979077339,
0.6097259521,
-0.7652528286,
0.4944563806,
-0.05469051,
0.0837279558,
-0.3677285314,
0.3162244856,
0.1336257309,
0.5397376418,
0.4639477432,
0.1004411355,
0.264180541,
-0.7208253741,
0.2773926556,
0.3470633626,
-0.1761134714,
-0.2849974334,
0.4465775788,
-0.1260428131,
-0.453899622,
0.3802823424,
-0.015343749,
-0.4096424878,
0.7548086643,
0.5615177751,
0.5372374058,
-0.2902485728,
0.026332004,
0.3650022745,
0.3875282109,
-0.6638202667,
0.2817571759,
-0.2508575022,
-0.4468583763,
-0.5504741073,
-0.3953077495,
-0.7061699033,
-0.0387903154,
-0.6626209021,
0.2553391755,
-0.7265440822,
-0.1030892357,
0.3280856609,
-0.0537320934,
-0.7202210426,
-0.0479088128,
0.3075330555,
1.1737076044,
-0.5780838728,
0.7092685103,
0.5292774439,
-0.2360827923,
-0.6404713988,
0.0246448722,
0.3141409755,
-1.034147501,
0.5707729459,
0.6670770645,
-0.4467642009,
-0.1434485316,
-0.3803319931,
-1.0300737619,
1.107198,
0.3073434234,
-0.7846513987,
-0.1941687614,
-0.1514516473,
0.3531233072,
-0.5402089953,
0.476042062,
0.4869289696,
0.3167121112,
0.2810299993,
-0.8357115388,
0.1053781435,
-0.1026327088,
-0.028196821,
0.0717089474,
-0.9384933114,
0.5824683309,
-0.3636923134,
-0.277602464,
0.5315061808,
0.7824563384,
0.4786508679,
0.3495521843,
0.6063231826,
0.3153486848,
0.9084687233,
0.0422163084,
0.9255090952,
-0.487718761,
-0.0241606981,
1.6331161261,
-0.7680084705,
1.2990980148,
0.2502347529,
0.034781944,
0.5450213552,
0.3814508021,
-0.19753097,
0.5621324182,
0.1470729262,
-0.1789774448,
-0.0684701949,
0.0801004171,
-0.4359335005,
0.3741967082,
0.1778802127,
-0.5785962939,
-0.0001554095,
-0.0815222859,
-0.0242884681,
-0.0772429407,
-0.3085571229,
0.7155584097,
-0.0164750591,
-1.0374373198,
0.4422408342,
-0.0845608786,
0.1815926731,
-0.6972128153,
-0.4073113799,
-0.0495344661,
0.1742393523,
0.1393592656,
-0.8998554945,
0.1120754406,
0.2214058787,
-0.1368189603,
-0.3535827994,
0.6435387135,
-0.2417405099,
-0.4692025483,
0.5210503936,
0.2180296779,
0.2930185497,
0.403290689,
-0.7474171519,
0.6447368264,
-0.0958667696,
-0.3823668361,
0.0964114591,
0.3197671473,
-0.1006121188,
0.8191186786,
0.4017148614,
-0.0244197454,
0.2614876926,
0.2140650302,
0.4567880929,
-0.635107398,
-0.1762101054,
-0.8916530013,
0.1423738003,
-0.1800678372,
-0.3485185504,
0.9486677051,
0.4548155665,
1.1190825701,
0.227180481,
0.491153419,
0.1741293967,
0.4077906013,
-0.5667464733,
0.2301182896,
-0.3715087771,
0.4724662006,
-0.1729539931,
-0.8010619879,
0.1125599816,
0.5040547252,
-0.4795258045,
0.0724980384,
0.6746207476,
0.7949273586,
-0.032098487,
0.3929166496,
0.3230563402,
0.3218960464,
-0.1892571002,
0.5994893909,
0.8432533741,
-0.4022340775,
0.457629472,
-0.2553364933,
-0.3249321282,
-0.0118516646,
-1.0147887468,
-1.0308504105,
-0.3978711069,
-0.2504430115,
-0.2384995669,
0.3183872998,
0.9585462809,
0.832224071,
-0.9806759357,
-0.2739264071,
-0.0057557975,
0.251412034,
-0.6134573221,
-0.1022427753,
0.1913330704,
-0.2610130906,
-0.7838734984,
0.741882503,
0.3983083665,
0.0652203336,
-0.2907046974,
-0.0388066024,
-0.3113252521,
0.1194282845,
0.5527620912,
0.3333662152,
-0.7620384097,
-0.4560457468,
0.267757982,
-0.4044655561,
-0.1908343881,
0.6090937853,
-0.3694449067,
0.3194852471,
0.6577082276,
0.8647982478,
0.4986504912,
-0.0225766655,
0.6401088238,
-0.3854326606,
-0.3624949157,
-0.0492321216,
0.517169416,
0.2412202656,
-0.1953594387,
0.6154535413,
0.1029174551,
-0.5507228374,
-0.9358969331,
0.0301323682,
-0.734952569,
-0.0589968041,
0.9085618854,
-0.6124600768,
-0.3034593463,
0.2293757945,
0.1971046329,
-0.1241057217,
-0.2870466113,
0.2647002041,
1.0766479969,
-0.1745441109,
-0.4935787022,
-0.8112512827,
0.1228801608,
0.4654271603,
-0.5005403161,
0.0962146148,
0.4497804344,
0.4927744567,
0.1081871316,
0.9231569767,
-0.0357237309,
0.4363721609,
0.1823357493,
-0.5415254831,
0.0382395424,
-0.635093987,
-0.2304460853,
0.3539931476,
-0.0503707044,
-0.1757379621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19995v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19995v1 | Single Parent Family: A Spectrum of Family Members from a Single Pre-Trained Foundation Model | 2024-06-28T15:27:57 | 2024-06-28T15:27:57 | Habib Hajimolahoseini, Mohammad Hassanpour, Foozhan Ataiefard, Boxing Chen, Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper introduces a novel method of Progressive Low Rank Decomposition
(PLRD) tailored for the compression of large language models. Our approach
leverages a pre-trained model, which is then incrementally decompressed to
smaller sizes using progressively lower ranks. This method allows for
significant reductions in computational overhead and energy consumption, as
subsequent models are derived from the original without the need for retraining
from scratch. We detail the implementation of PLRD, which strategically
decreases the tensor ranks, thus optimizing the trade-off between model
performance and resource usage. The efficacy of PLRD is demonstrated through
extensive experiments showing that models trained with PLRD method on only 1B
tokens maintain comparable performance with traditionally trained models while
using 0.1% of the tokens. The versatility of PLRD is highlighted by its ability
to generate multiple model sizes from a single foundational model, adapting
fluidly to varying computational and memory budgets. Our findings suggest that
PLRD could set a new standard for the efficient scaling of LLMs, making
advanced AI more feasible on diverse platforms. | [
-0.5231897235,
-0.5549325943,
-0.053934563,
0.0438290983,
-0.2705177367,
0.4308332503,
-0.4332859814,
0.1787554473,
0.0154062547,
0.5559815764,
-0.7196780443,
-0.427998215,
-0.6497001648,
-0.0838026255,
-0.2837101519,
0.8135674,
0.2523333728,
-0.0689341277,
-0.1459095031,
-0.16682823,
0.1149358898,
-0.6647372842,
-1.102555275,
-0.3533101082,
0.2878221273,
0.519280076,
0.7800207734,
0.7802837491,
0.5894715786,
0.2906947434,
-0.3606507182,
-0.1227774248,
-1.2163316011,
0.2854847312,
0.2750203311,
-0.1843824983,
-0.757207334,
-0.021076994,
0.9890872836,
1.1852476597,
-0.1777532548,
0.4534920752,
0.1001388729,
0.8336078525,
-0.5063883066,
0.0328572504,
-0.3694719076,
0.162661925,
0.0075297356,
-0.1989414096,
-0.6269623041,
-0.138863042,
-0.0762553737,
-0.4434762299,
0.45788607,
-0.2565915585,
0.5479653478,
0.5055934787,
-0.2170654684,
0.1162663177,
-0.6860948801,
0.7251605988,
-0.3902391493,
0.5225149989,
0.1797610372,
0.0714666173,
-0.1912576854,
-0.9540811777,
-0.3887460828,
-0.1302604824,
0.00222843,
-0.2683251202,
-0.1640003324,
0.3610807955,
0.14642106,
0.7634247541,
-0.5495516062,
0.2845202684,
-0.4454032481,
-0.068431206,
0.4263186753,
0.0643489808,
0.3158392012,
0.0918380097,
-0.3228030503,
-0.0115410537,
-1.1543085575,
0.0626144558,
0.5071034431,
0.4888916612,
-0.207059145,
0.4806440771,
-0.1564016193,
0.5574761033,
0.099380441,
-0.5820808411,
0.0403654017,
-0.432463944,
-0.1720465273,
-0.0751928836,
0.627851367,
-0.0950959623,
0.2014958262,
-0.2175566703,
-0.0556531884,
0.3302472234,
-0.0989062563,
-1.0852730274,
-0.4346089065,
0.0158386007,
-0.888846457,
-0.4170248508,
-0.3799396455,
-0.9223951101,
-0.4345477223,
-0.2046027929,
0.1550754011,
-0.2785665095,
-0.4687151313,
0.156154424,
0.0475746766,
0.1735723019,
0.2538208961,
-0.8696705699,
0.5869236588,
0.7927955389,
0.8543044329,
-0.1047537848,
-0.1651131809,
-0.7356179357,
-0.0765124485,
-0.1325317472,
0.4082362056,
-0.5510208607,
-0.8426839113,
-0.2714188993,
-0.3834664822,
-0.0937086567,
-0.6309731603,
0.3836857378,
-0.3211770654,
0.036442697,
0.2072014809,
-0.3144084513,
0.0914308727,
0.0934772566,
-0.7901552916,
0.9007597566,
0.3612699509,
-0.7716815472,
0.1084194928,
-0.7660316229,
-0.6202142239,
0.1316480339,
0.021034481,
-0.5482268929,
0.3113862574,
0.1547324359,
0.4570147991,
-0.3434386253,
-0.003302278,
-0.2374386936,
-0.3167182207,
-0.4384737611,
-0.2780811489,
0.9247546792,
0.2255291492,
-0.1354335248,
0.0810378045,
-0.9058980942,
-0.0468842201,
0.1726935804,
-0.659729898,
-0.1422206759,
-0.0416000336,
-0.3633441031,
0.172239691,
0.4090818763,
-0.4770316482,
0.480825901,
-0.3062678576,
0.6490517259,
0.8541208506,
-0.016032232,
0.7193061113,
-0.2858713269,
0.8339518905,
-0.2607561648,
0.2938838303,
-0.1761741489,
-0.2910488248,
-1.1863629818,
-0.7274181843,
0.5153293014,
-0.0271633938,
-0.5567424297,
0.4548907876,
-0.8098510504,
-0.1373497844,
-0.7810676098,
0.2263930291,
0.4256493151,
0.4740398526,
0.3056882918,
-0.2959937155,
-0.5958244205,
-0.9514189959,
0.3514787257,
-0.2157866061,
0.1971746087,
-0.191490069,
0.4158227742,
-0.093537949,
0.9130308032,
-0.4028538465,
-0.1552634686,
-0.529316783,
0.4001961648,
-0.0356144048,
0.7061889768,
0.1089288294,
-0.7963280678,
-0.2925923765,
-0.0507501289,
-0.4157343507,
0.2678561807,
0.1962854266,
-0.0130624091,
0.0803313255,
0.2768370807,
-0.3875790834,
0.3706660867,
0.857329011,
-0.2954389453,
0.3865440488,
-0.2546890378,
-0.2305022031,
-0.8528095484,
0.172742635,
-0.2518410683,
-0.3727665246,
-0.7481802702,
0.5209189653,
-0.3016650081,
-0.4654813707,
-0.3167701364,
0.4494147301,
-0.6852443218,
-0.2786323428,
-0.1427990347,
-0.3295964003,
-0.278090775,
0.5893961787,
-0.0209356397,
0.8921602368,
0.4976243079,
-0.5298507214,
-0.0881414935,
0.2165019214,
-0.2365297079,
0.2201999873,
-0.4406073093,
0.320745647,
-0.3249442279,
0.3940165341,
-0.9921506643,
0.0437296107,
-0.1251772642,
-0.2082840353,
0.5263816714,
-0.333075732,
-0.708563149,
-0.342402339,
-0.5454396605,
0.4934264421,
0.941773355,
-0.6233555079,
0.8567972183,
0.5897259712,
-0.3706670105,
-0.4869301617,
-0.5591285229,
-0.1439849585,
-0.2573070526,
-0.9030483961,
0.5350010991,
-0.3950103819,
-0.2643064559,
0.0297990628,
-0.1544892341,
-0.0402412228,
0.3815393448,
0.3334515393,
0.0919895694,
-0.3863336444,
-0.0958057642,
-0.1194933802,
-0.2762966454,
-0.4978320301,
0.1331358105,
0.9862978458,
-0.2899184525,
0.1038291305,
-0.4001553655,
0.4513174295,
0.8435831666,
-0.3696114421,
0.8500716686,
0.3297771811,
-0.3184983134,
-0.5456479192,
-0.3982094228,
-0.032097742,
-0.506469965,
0.1344537884,
-0.5761899948,
-1.1559087038,
0.527096808,
-0.5316315889,
0.041363351,
0.3456159234,
0.6867698431,
0.22840105,
1.0143527985,
1.2130656242,
-0.040854767,
0.4348660111,
-0.6853173375,
0.3267366588,
-0.9116557837,
-0.0025273713,
-0.5784798861,
-0.5146058202,
-0.4541285634,
-0.5766760111,
0.4935912788,
0.2816623449,
-0.5993387699,
0.1113637537,
-0.8199858069,
0.5554505587,
0.4607217312,
0.0475728475,
0.5455641747,
0.0351583064,
0.0852168873,
0.3751145303,
-0.8837645054,
-0.3254793286,
1.1959432364,
0.5934237242,
0.6036639214,
0.0548274256,
1.0685142279,
0.1197527125,
0.7588372827,
-0.8221070766,
0.7965385318,
-0.6887046099,
-0.3975546062,
-0.3392153382,
-0.7706166506,
-0.880602181,
0.3777886927,
0.0503629968,
-0.5607540607,
0.2011611909,
-0.1010280475,
-0.519547224,
0.1156572104,
-0.7303038239,
0.8057003021,
-0.068885006,
-0.1737353057,
-0.390955627,
-0.6209818721,
0.6265497804,
-0.0751993731,
0.2392773926,
-0.1296787411,
-0.0384621695,
1.0112669468,
-0.7966182232,
0.7380858064,
-0.2869539559,
0.2177221775,
0.0080280462,
0.1211852506,
0.3793461025,
-0.1322649717,
-0.2898479104,
0.0189301018,
-0.2955650091,
-0.4766268432,
-0.2845593989,
0.8402135968,
-0.9880237579,
-0.4782833159,
-0.0765181184,
-0.4872253239,
-0.2314682305,
0.1399892569,
0.2298635244,
0.4132266939,
-0.1346223652,
0.5657293797,
0.5802741647,
-0.0436347909,
0.5598464012,
0.2789976597,
-0.0460997187,
-0.3642496765,
0.6278213859,
0.1846506,
0.2217267603,
0.4019102752,
0.3267295659,
-0.1464579254,
-0.8606224656,
0.0379953496,
0.3144379258,
-0.8624070287,
-0.1346293539,
-0.3559502363,
-0.1732818633,
-0.3349653482,
-0.4051870108,
-0.686039567,
-0.4956202507,
-0.1406146139,
-0.1703959703,
-0.0992351323,
0.7203496695,
0.1325581372,
0.5363163948,
-0.3341350257,
0.542255342,
0.3777899742,
0.4160686433,
-0.0115498351,
-0.4121430814,
0.0664523542,
-0.2541947663,
-0.0809672177,
-0.4414365292,
0.3494641185,
0.431728214,
0.6681777239,
0.210518986,
0.2248363346,
0.8843950033,
-0.3842151165,
0.8759492636,
0.4147824645,
-1.0297914743,
0.2375185043,
-0.1728462428,
0.3110737205,
0.9407145977,
0.2961769402,
-0.0370527357,
-0.0519577116,
-0.6911597848,
-0.9689213037,
0.6959818602,
0.0161274299,
0.0858566388,
0.2899054587,
0.1986501813,
0.2644168437,
0.2217416614,
-0.856333673,
-0.4925516248,
-0.0707761645,
-0.3500244915,
-0.0937382281,
-0.4075853825,
-0.2102268934,
-0.5826277733,
0.6739363074,
-0.0813771337,
0.367372036,
-0.2169896066,
-0.1615187973,
-0.1009444818,
0.0531545617,
0.5947629213,
0.7514667511,
-0.2143431902,
0.2289712578,
-0.2620487213,
-0.3592554629,
0.3328059316,
0.0451698005,
0.0225919317,
-0.1554217041,
0.3595606685,
0.6876788735,
0.5305508375,
-0.4781722724,
0.4825093448,
-0.1982284337,
-0.1929092258,
-0.1862051487,
-0.2514460683,
0.1363443583,
-0.0486417897,
0.395821631,
0.0503042862,
-0.3080553412,
-0.636888504,
0.3560437262,
0.2589348853,
0.0895550698,
-0.3710202575,
0.370428741,
0.4037684798,
-0.4230914712,
0.8192542791,
-0.1866218895,
-0.4747692943,
0.4528421462,
0.3047959208,
0.8892570138,
-0.328060627,
0.314286381,
0.1918532848,
0.1692698896,
-0.3142133951,
0.0096256156,
-0.1751438528,
-0.7291719317,
-0.5196393132,
-1.0339442492,
-0.2193449885,
0.2997452021,
-0.4143480957,
0.3232317865,
-0.9806106687,
-0.0609516799,
-0.0225781482,
0.087741904,
-0.7910069227,
-0.1719664335,
0.3913952112,
0.7663459778,
-0.4852744937,
1.1435139179,
0.4561758041,
-0.5203830004,
-0.842279911,
0.0577476472,
-0.1357437819,
-0.7835411429,
1.0582849979,
0.0834116861,
-0.3426996768,
0.5224628448,
-0.346729219,
-0.7878354192,
0.9992488623,
0.713365674,
-0.2009043247,
-0.336271435,
-0.1575181782,
0.5309910774,
-0.5553675294,
-0.0022480153,
0.5159484744,
0.4399332106,
0.1584153324,
-0.9953453541,
-0.0491993502,
-0.2629942596,
0.0773067698,
0.3546712995,
-0.672761023,
1.3557684422,
-0.044473134,
-0.5375241637,
0.2681606114,
0.3282937706,
0.2244666964,
-0.0985155627,
0.5729210377,
0.7130881548,
0.6581360102,
-0.0128390742,
1.0697450638,
-0.7243704796,
0.6856119633,
0.81247437,
-0.2490734458,
1.0239232779,
0.4299678802,
-0.3360129595,
0.6366061568,
0.4003084302,
0.383061707,
0.6821519136,
0.4978321493,
-0.4080406129,
-0.3271702826,
-0.0096295001,
-0.332910955,
0.4522149265,
0.2930852175,
-0.2995927334,
-0.4875891507,
0.0847901553,
0.2064194083,
0.0128986351,
-0.6218787432,
0.6632413864,
0.0235427693,
-0.6413684487,
0.9944658279,
0.1851769984,
0.9796578288,
-0.7223575115,
0.1727059484,
-0.4569168985,
0.3482995629,
-0.2057324648,
-0.1389311701,
-0.0610428713,
-0.0784865841,
-0.1928109378,
-0.8168860674,
0.6145456433,
-0.3597037494,
-0.5308140516,
0.2299957573,
0.5235089064,
-0.0303065442,
0.1473603845,
-0.6157329082,
0.3844719529,
-0.0563992523,
-0.4027315378,
0.5628484488,
-0.0534125231,
0.1683980972,
0.839600265,
0.7131906152,
0.1629616618,
0.2384089977,
-0.1097485349,
1.1365168095,
-0.3405272067,
-0.7492615581,
-0.5709990859,
0.6383033395,
0.0794218183,
-0.2273330986,
0.4467667043,
0.5841710567,
0.7532299161,
0.0106926141,
0.6616718173,
-0.0304369759,
0.4271370173,
-0.3246152699,
0.6284021139,
-0.4821685255,
0.4073003829,
0.1957810819,
-0.6109916568,
-0.4313101768,
0.6809816957,
-0.2470019609,
-0.0348596089,
0.830000937,
0.6510186195,
0.0209827013,
-0.0453453064,
0.4236418605,
0.083363153,
0.2623659074,
0.5585923195,
0.6099223495,
-0.0915515274,
0.4836333692,
-0.5276813507,
-0.2364575267,
-0.1969406605,
-0.732252717,
-0.8579986095,
-0.515581727,
-0.5379502773,
-0.0387098156,
0.0769049451,
0.8690476418,
1.061532259,
-0.5269472003,
-0.3186686635,
-0.2148379982,
0.1632141024,
-0.1928772032,
-0.2346371412,
0.4924981296,
-0.2023307383,
-0.6623877883,
0.8309929371,
0.3216427565,
-0.2472942621,
-0.7640947104,
-0.3723897338,
-0.1236914471,
-0.2923796773,
0.6702813506,
0.3372681439,
-0.562518239,
-0.245230794,
-0.3138212264,
-0.0399920903,
0.1822247952,
1.2242541313,
-0.9782599807,
0.3993875384,
0.7530108094,
0.6824607253,
0.6852428317,
0.2361505032,
0.5454245806,
-1.0854175091,
0.4323655069,
0.5896577835,
0.3847633004,
0.3541611731,
-0.3622270226,
0.6213934422,
0.3050349355,
-0.3460356891,
-1.2125067711,
0.3430997729,
-1.0347168446,
-0.5576900244,
1.1393538713,
-0.2441353649,
-0.2458105087,
-0.0835090503,
0.268481195,
0.0808992162,
-0.3908699751,
0.4722511172,
0.6223626137,
-0.2553915679,
-0.5385240316,
-0.2128466666,
0.4362425208,
0.3388605714,
-0.5449250937,
0.1186220571,
0.3059126735,
0.3152461052,
0.2822210193,
1.0224812031,
-0.2146654427,
0.0163900238,
0.191210255,
0.1689184606,
-0.4406759441,
-0.4438151121,
-0.6632421017,
1.0075989962,
0.1994362622,
-0.1001526192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19967v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19967v1 | Into the Unknown: Generating Geospatial Descriptions for New Environments | 2024-06-28T14:56:21 | 2024-06-28T14:56:21 | Tzuf Paz-Argaman, John Palowitch, Sayali Kulkarni, Reut Tsarfaty, Jason Baldridge | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Similar to vision-and-language navigation (VLN) tasks that focus on bridging
the gap between vision and language for embodied navigation, the new Rendezvous
(RVS) task requires reasoning over allocentric spatial relationships
(independent of the observer's viewpoint) using non-sequential navigation
instructions and maps. However, performance substantially drops in new
environments with no training data. Using opensource descriptions paired with
coordinates (e.g., Wikipedia) provides training data but suffers from limited
spatially-oriented text resulting in low geolocation resolution. We propose a
large-scale augmentation method for generating high-quality synthetic data for
new environments using readily available geospatial data. Our method constructs
a grounded knowledge-graph, capturing entity relationships. Sampled entities
and relations (`shop north of school') generate navigation instructions via (i)
generating numerous templates using context-free grammar (CFG) to embed
specific entities and relations; (ii) feeding the entities and relation into a
large language model (LLM) for instruction generation. A comprehensive
evaluation on RVS, showed that our approach improves the 100-meter accuracy by
45.83% on unseen environments. Furthermore, we demonstrate that models trained
with CFG-based augmentation achieve superior performance compared with those
trained with LLM-based augmentation, both in unseen and seen environments.
These findings suggest that the potential advantages of explicitly structuring
spatial information for text-based geospatial reasoning in previously unknown,
can unlock data-scarce scenarios. | [
-0.6022315025,
-0.7313144803,
1.0329319239,
0.0092973597,
-0.0333968215,
-0.1194578335,
-0.5101830959,
-0.6176307201,
0.1315037459,
0.539239347,
-0.75807935,
-0.7612394691,
-0.290789336,
-0.0988743454,
-0.3709385395,
0.6916823983,
-0.190421313,
-0.4295124114,
-0.4496944547,
0.0691994056,
-0.5096338987,
-0.5194395185,
-0.1400165111,
-0.095863089,
0.2335555702,
0.582414031,
0.74569875,
0.7211782932,
0.267878145,
0.3437332809,
-0.0225828644,
0.6825547218,
-0.483322829,
0.0522546805,
-0.4299482703,
-0.0575581528,
0.0109989485,
-0.1795127094,
0.8648744226,
0.8385038972,
0.2049623281,
-0.0724228919,
-0.0635398924,
0.3544380963,
-0.7632156014,
0.3757501841,
-0.4755193591,
0.0683312193,
-0.0060616722,
-0.3196782172,
-0.2795997858,
-0.0220827702,
0.6180548668,
-1.1949445009,
0.3637421429,
0.3433011472,
0.7606601119,
0.30305475,
-0.1796023101,
-0.0933975056,
-0.9503394961,
0.5797958374,
-0.3031502366,
0.4868885577,
0.2042088062,
0.3381176591,
-0.3975975811,
-0.723631084,
-0.756845057,
-0.2452862263,
-0.3436845541,
0.1289321184,
0.0291943215,
-0.1321723759,
0.2581062615,
0.0868969858,
-0.2810568511,
-0.0374329574,
-0.5152826905,
0.1106580719,
0.6333430409,
0.2240219414,
0.2279310673,
-0.4910104573,
-0.5097857714,
-0.2048910111,
-0.8559732437,
0.104460761,
0.1581688672,
0.5386207104,
-0.2112648785,
0.9583120942,
-0.3742554486,
0.784810245,
-0.1186151057,
0.1192334667,
0.2111935318,
-0.3814586103,
-0.073176235,
-0.0404138602,
0.4987220466,
0.4913262427,
-0.1551803797,
-0.2916376293,
-0.1060607657,
-0.3468314111,
0.4141668677,
-0.327062875,
-0.3816174269,
-0.1110915467,
-0.0523083061,
-0.0422059149,
0.1608645916,
-0.8013694882,
-0.4110491872,
-0.5545737743,
0.2832759619,
-0.6014968157,
-0.1325753033,
-0.0560822226,
-0.1074661091,
0.2437127382,
0.5520134568,
-0.4747018516,
0.062820226,
0.4996831715,
0.6612276435,
-0.0691741854,
-0.6178278327,
-0.3709366918,
0.3719259799,
-0.3473592401,
0.7068844438,
-0.5429962277,
-0.5982937813,
-0.1389121711,
0.1690721512,
0.18135795,
-0.1469439119,
0.3054818511,
-0.2412797213,
0.3052852452,
-0.3054738939,
-0.2591694593,
-0.1602978408,
0.2007910907,
-0.5466047525,
1.258671999,
0.3479563892,
-0.572684288,
0.2897915542,
-0.7294219136,
-0.3682075739,
0.3252599537,
-0.2335807085,
0.0157848336,
0.0707003996,
0.5330439806,
0.0284792446,
-0.0259147305,
0.0047484566,
0.1616764218,
-0.5096694827,
0.2071334273,
-0.1134366468,
0.236528337,
0.00843242,
-0.4261326194,
-0.1764389277,
-0.5841726661,
0.1886281371,
0.0062144776,
-0.3015350103,
-0.3661430478,
0.15390037,
-0.0801177472,
-0.0790532082,
0.4654765129,
-0.616838634,
0.1278132945,
-0.7180768847,
-0.0311044194,
0.6020461917,
0.0829448327,
0.9914778471,
0.0256947409,
0.4050269425,
-0.2198712379,
0.0451289453,
-0.5858184695,
-0.4701277018,
-0.7319455743,
0.0477546714,
-0.1152705476,
0.4433794618,
-0.9827157855,
0.395783484,
-0.7574428916,
-0.5148491859,
-0.0834608376,
-0.1734636724,
0.2973709404,
0.6643412709,
0.6702231765,
0.1511128843,
-0.8387436271,
-0.5661511421,
0.0075949151,
-0.0186277237,
-0.1418060958,
0.5467861891,
0.2449605167,
-0.2703793347,
1.0675137043,
-0.659265995,
-0.1281443238,
-0.1126814112,
-0.1733494699,
-0.0730342194,
0.4931078255,
0.3414277732,
-0.5826715827,
-0.2147392929,
0.3486851454,
-0.6680937409,
0.1675262004,
-0.0191311166,
-0.4168612063,
0.000232747,
0.5828601122,
-0.7694280148,
0.5736979246,
0.2930980027,
-0.1817890853,
0.3298823833,
-0.3316781819,
0.245074451,
-0.9307239652,
0.0390776023,
0.0657745227,
0.066035524,
-0.441349864,
0.4308239222,
-0.1654040962,
-0.5170783997,
-0.443068862,
0.6042493582,
-0.7325414419,
-0.0578418225,
-0.2204646617,
0.560084939,
0.0050630961,
0.2382637262,
0.4262674451,
0.5813298225,
0.5443763137,
-0.4269205332,
0.4945082068,
0.6462444663,
-0.3070062697,
0.3066180348,
-0.2879084647,
-0.0543995425,
-0.4881896079,
0.4272320271,
-0.8714515567,
-0.5876147747,
0.1268558949,
-0.663389802,
0.0457193442,
-0.4498490691,
-0.3321669698,
-0.450917691,
0.1872367114,
0.3553515077,
0.5887008309,
-0.8733134866,
0.6962808371,
0.2355870157,
-0.0725887567,
-0.5635960698,
-0.6149250865,
0.2192220092,
-0.0650992617,
-0.4153475463,
0.3160816729,
0.263610512,
-0.0920386761,
0.2485821247,
-0.1276870072,
-0.1106176451,
-0.1654625237,
0.6169544458,
0.584541142,
-0.0781516507,
0.1602457017,
-0.0565320738,
-0.0757080764,
0.214487493,
-0.6142042279,
0.3206544518,
0.0219551791,
-0.2730937898,
-0.0619126074,
0.3881612718,
0.2712257802,
-0.359424293,
0.7602784038,
0.4137833714,
-0.513717711,
-0.2296681404,
-0.1968244612,
0.0327566974,
-0.5080220103,
0.315623343,
-0.2765087485,
-0.8394011259,
0.1079920977,
-0.3309761286,
0.1517892331,
0.2179389596,
0.0094891116,
-0.048126433,
0.4955224395,
0.7104424834,
0.3198958635,
0.2936733365,
-0.2238023579,
0.760109961,
-0.7151744366,
-0.724067688,
-0.2417846918,
-0.272831887,
-0.6390462518,
-0.8869047761,
0.8050444722,
-0.0705479532,
-0.2559299171,
0.4200038314,
-0.7424894571,
0.8161383271,
0.5886750221,
0.1464336663,
0.0258571338,
0.4228923917,
-0.0540141873,
-0.274713248,
-0.637627244,
-0.3740290701,
1.2052123547,
-0.0680405572,
0.7498528361,
0.0352829248,
0.6628307104,
-0.0935671106,
0.1623055041,
-0.422922194,
0.496734798,
0.1982131898,
-0.2445602715,
-0.4570720494,
-0.4248907864,
-0.8628081083,
0.1534707993,
-0.7491972446,
-0.8700273633,
0.0052576652,
0.1431365758,
-0.5928469896,
0.2930526435,
-0.6830917001,
0.5216681361,
-0.1930322498,
-0.4621630013,
0.2058624029,
-0.7532375455,
0.3310616612,
0.0945186242,
0.1681277007,
0.1511931717,
-0.070417501,
-0.0054585482,
-0.23250781,
0.5513435602,
-0.3619962037,
-0.0732544586,
0.4171360135,
0.0544548668,
0.6268895268,
0.2778537273,
0.1642959267,
0.0319696926,
-0.3895483017,
-0.1505377591,
-0.7739208937,
1.1082127094,
-0.7088864446,
-0.4710608423,
-0.1210049093,
-0.7125544548,
-0.2062294483,
0.1164421737,
0.4359351993,
0.3976012766,
-0.2286355495,
-0.1020301059,
0.7786003947,
-0.7056247592,
0.0900263041,
0.4709812999,
-0.1148995087,
-0.358235389,
0.8071938157,
-0.0523725301,
-0.0648737103,
0.616738379,
-0.243815124,
-0.699899137,
-0.3408480287,
-0.4789406657,
0.0192676634,
-0.6376352906,
-0.2666302025,
-0.6877815723,
-0.3955304921,
-0.3185977042,
-0.5367040038,
-0.3302755058,
-0.5408477187,
-0.108926326,
-0.2304349989,
0.368493855,
0.8363278508,
-0.2457582802,
0.4731695056,
-0.6742506027,
0.1566512436,
-0.1830552816,
0.037060421,
-0.0722739547,
-0.1623200774,
-0.4701855779,
0.3321315646,
-0.0161073785,
-0.6138686538,
0.373930037,
-0.182372883,
0.5393144488,
0.0412335843,
0.1395275146,
0.8539109826,
-0.6505962014,
0.9134815335,
0.1949265748,
-0.7572824359,
0.871168077,
-0.3403434753,
0.2462790608,
0.1660377085,
0.2996828258,
-0.2997173369,
-0.3607700169,
-0.6384250522,
-1.1410107613,
0.5168231726,
0.182276383,
0.2087448239,
-0.0791336149,
0.6414728165,
-0.1239664108,
0.1609428078,
-0.7444571257,
-0.1654416472,
-0.210679993,
-0.059000887,
-0.2741794586,
-0.0556556955,
-0.366717875,
-0.4018633664,
0.3639480174,
-0.0914157256,
0.3806654215,
0.380813539,
-0.1236721501,
-0.064407073,
0.0714701861,
0.2137205899,
0.6361856461,
0.2410135418,
0.3601836562,
0.2928990722,
-0.1376221478,
0.2073435038,
0.4181511998,
-0.271053493,
0.0756694302,
0.439514935,
0.7134530544,
0.3820043802,
-0.8653262258,
0.6086022854,
0.2603362501,
0.0623057112,
-0.6269063354,
0.1427606344,
-0.0183273014,
0.2938605249,
0.2547707558,
0.1792950183,
0.0971205756,
-0.2544733584,
0.140665099,
0.3901141286,
-0.1116018817,
-0.0578057431,
0.7525174022,
0.129214406,
0.0815143734,
0.8383575082,
-0.2689099014,
-0.2033675015,
0.3419270515,
0.412530303,
0.3145595789,
-0.1306232512,
0.2235404551,
0.7561974525,
0.563870132,
0.1005909145,
0.0931484103,
-0.2631736398,
-0.5174143314,
-0.5732989311,
-0.5041311979,
-0.1877267808,
0.0035900623,
-0.5766664743,
0.1766288131,
-0.5293728709,
0.0788238347,
-0.45582816,
-0.2713934779,
-0.7825199366,
0.2964001894,
0.2035243958,
0.7321579456,
-0.6752619743,
0.2055340856,
0.9329174757,
-0.1238069013,
-0.8039438128,
0.0885999426,
-0.2020934373,
-0.5559634566,
0.3815784156,
0.1362002492,
-0.0543456636,
-0.0961633697,
-0.6834974289,
-1.1415164471,
1.0721648932,
0.2080097198,
-0.3942121565,
-0.3282558918,
0.3514200151,
0.5459225178,
-0.3496926725,
-0.1168276295,
0.5096774697,
0.5265772343,
0.0968504623,
-0.588126123,
0.1538706422,
-0.2975167036,
0.1354360729,
0.2711666822,
-0.1367052943,
0.69500947,
-0.6099107862,
-0.5215939283,
0.3988414109,
0.562669754,
0.2719686925,
0.1578856707,
0.321655184,
0.8314602375,
0.699588716,
-0.4203510582,
1.0177594423,
-0.1860998571,
0.0491452925,
1.4701881409,
-0.1222791672,
0.7284338474,
0.3110843301,
0.1559823453,
0.6891407371,
0.5638785362,
0.0750716403,
0.6824724078,
0.0938559026,
-0.5530201197,
-0.16462937,
-0.0828016996,
-0.4809624851,
0.4254512787,
0.4946912825,
-0.3224372566,
-0.4596393406,
0.0833710283,
-0.2316954434,
0.2844348848,
-0.1540706307,
0.5862231851,
-0.3722672462,
-0.7956310511,
0.4319611192,
0.1063111871,
0.1234932989,
-0.5256487727,
-0.3365612924,
-0.048073452,
-0.1469082534,
-0.2143849432,
-0.9747818112,
0.1308756471,
-0.0087797437,
-0.0295761842,
-0.117572546,
0.4331181049,
-0.6030111313,
-0.3310373425,
0.0291413721,
0.634963274,
0.0390312746,
-0.0145037929,
-0.0143763451,
-0.0826176107,
-0.0553426035,
0.169150129,
-0.0648782551,
0.7683623433,
0.018063454,
0.6225624084,
0.7703974247,
0.0443646535,
0.3300192654,
-0.4279127717,
1.0969699621,
-0.631719172,
-0.7741503119,
-0.3619934022,
0.5787702203,
-0.1750437766,
-0.0534917489,
0.9591799974,
0.7231004834,
0.9494020343,
-0.0873552859,
1.0325473547,
-0.1488318592,
0.3051367998,
-0.6064844728,
0.2986241877,
-0.3237317801,
0.1831523329,
-0.2488317341,
-0.9804764986,
-0.0307834409,
0.6496103406,
-0.3977473974,
-0.1506114453,
0.681673944,
0.8340319395,
-0.3186713159,
-0.1317822337,
0.0325301439,
-0.0782352686,
0.0806140602,
0.6598780751,
1.2565766573,
-0.2181189954,
0.5283672214,
-0.2129644752,
-0.220238626,
0.2080637366,
-0.6003175378,
-0.527192831,
-0.6156926751,
0.0886651725,
-0.4287098348,
0.0384291448,
0.5916721225,
0.7618881464,
-0.2559476197,
0.1648426354,
-0.3133065999,
-0.0539046153,
0.1043504328,
-0.2889148891,
0.0684687421,
-0.2384076566,
-0.8831651807,
0.9363722205,
0.2785659432,
0.37025401,
-0.3562934399,
-0.1999253035,
0.2069290876,
-0.1610884666,
0.600538075,
0.3593196273,
-0.6466752291,
-0.3663588166,
0.0216640923,
0.2842698395,
-0.1141108498,
0.8485994339,
-0.9481800199,
0.5390238762,
0.0520897843,
0.6774604321,
0.5744960904,
0.2976946831,
0.6175878048,
-1.1886111498,
0.4378561974,
-0.0372009985,
0.275413245,
0.6385524869,
-0.6240421534,
0.4809779525,
-0.0193873085,
-0.3149380386,
-0.5765225291,
0.3151629567,
-0.6365831494,
-0.1736962646,
1.1964992285,
-0.1795492768,
-0.3046277463,
0.1768741012,
-0.3068177402,
0.025686238,
-0.137506783,
0.5741460323,
0.3633889556,
-0.1255387068,
-0.1251748353,
-0.4125894606,
0.5082666278,
-0.1669629067,
-0.8786200881,
0.0356855392,
1.1312178373,
0.1580770612,
0.3950439692,
0.3373551369,
-0.0794835016,
0.2085454613,
0.1606153399,
-0.0280057564,
-0.1904225945,
-0.6165727377,
0.226990968,
0.0437559597,
-0.1184083149,
-0.2290248126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19966v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19966v1 | Simulating Financial Market via Large Language Model based Agents | 2024-06-28T14:54:12 | 2024-06-28T14:54:12 | Shen Gao, Yuntao Wen, Minghang Zhu, Jianing Wei, Yuhan Cheng, Qunzi Zhang, Shuo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most economic theories typically assume that financial market participants
are fully rational individuals and use mathematical models to simulate human
behavior in financial markets. However, human behavior is often not entirely
rational and is challenging to predict accurately with mathematical models. In
this paper, we propose \textbf{A}gent-based \textbf{S}imulated
\textbf{F}inancial \textbf{M}arket (ASFM), which first constructs a simulated
stock market with a real order matching system. Then, we propose a large
language model based agent as the stock trader, which contains the profile,
observation, and tool-learning based action module. The trading agent can
comprehensively understand current market dynamics and financial policy
information, and make decisions that align with their trading strategy. In the
experiments, we first verify that the reactions of our ASFM are consistent with
the real stock market in two controllable scenarios. In addition, we also
conduct experiments in two popular economics research directions, and we find
that conclusions drawn in our \model align with the preliminary findings in
economics research. Based on these observations, we believe our proposed ASFM
provides a new paradigm for economic research. | [
-0.0482632928,
-1.0987126827,
0.164688617,
0.3686380684,
-0.0264842939,
0.3015168011,
-0.1884266585,
-0.5243904591,
0.5900945067,
0.4846665561,
-0.3305070996,
-0.2315566093,
-0.082793951,
-0.0136541435,
-0.5205939412,
0.478212446,
0.0071980329,
0.2074071765,
0.1635289192,
0.3260234594,
-0.0539788269,
-0.7322748303,
-1.3043980598,
-0.4312236905,
-0.0622761995,
0.1069081426,
0.8230848908,
0.555506289,
0.4946680665,
0.4319998324,
0.3492581248,
-0.2806783915,
-0.2175917327,
0.0314336009,
-0.2267349362,
-0.3525862098,
-0.544254303,
0.3743234873,
0.5466353297,
0.3300441802,
-0.5873084664,
-0.0125347506,
-0.0379040577,
0.3266041279,
-0.1876523793,
0.5761975646,
-0.2437075526,
-0.0447574556,
-0.0253635459,
-0.3394679725,
-0.6344813704,
-0.1335417181,
0.3211071491,
-0.7243229151,
-0.1763698608,
0.4620860815,
0.951096952,
-0.2578641772,
-0.6755594611,
-0.289742738,
-0.9418963194,
0.7515977621,
-0.8088210821,
0.3424928188,
0.4662413299,
0.7244232297,
-0.202215448,
-0.5241687298,
-0.4199919701,
-0.548063159,
0.0843213201,
-0.0507802777,
-0.193724528,
0.0835326761,
0.2936196923,
0.1455826908,
-0.1098732129,
-0.0359524973,
-0.3759202063,
0.0508390144,
0.808650136,
0.2754651606,
0.0905149281,
0.0279537067,
-0.7923578024,
-0.4988882542,
-0.6413356662,
0.0499600843,
0.7614610791,
0.4905952513,
-0.0365025587,
0.6963111162,
-0.1563972235,
0.2057557404,
-0.0729863495,
-0.1329454035,
0.1784911305,
0.0545608327,
-0.4723380506,
0.0645158961,
0.6757004261,
0.4021054208,
0.4421479702,
0.0425977483,
-0.4986431301,
-0.1432859451,
0.3476249576,
-0.7349584699,
-0.0660319254,
-0.02617695,
-0.6945711374,
-0.317627728,
0.1294592172,
-0.9119160175,
-0.1478981227,
-0.5687215328,
0.7104600668,
-0.5156819224,
-0.3648546636,
0.0872988999,
0.027253598,
0.5816149712,
0.2563661039,
-0.9318405986,
0.5959239602,
0.7646029592,
0.5691393018,
0.2895357311,
-0.4547662437,
-0.405320406,
0.3089498878,
-0.2564128041,
0.8721200824,
-0.555737555,
-0.3587002754,
0.0908717215,
-0.2072153389,
-0.2225858718,
-0.2101271003,
-0.1665178239,
-0.6932005286,
0.0245085694,
-0.3637104034,
-0.8268340826,
-0.3819925785,
0.4762670398,
-0.4939249158,
0.560059607,
0.0131098842,
-0.4954870343,
0.2924118936,
-1.284607172,
-0.3794556856,
0.0292267483,
-0.2454292625,
-0.1706473678,
-0.4779128134,
-0.2875669897,
0.2742789388,
-0.5523695946,
0.0882700011,
-0.4784871638,
-0.473438859,
0.9079726934,
-0.7097116709,
0.4342553616,
0.2667549253,
-0.5003065467,
0.1543702185,
-0.5645689368,
-0.2781431973,
0.3092098832,
-0.0391679481,
-0.4479631782,
0.340377748,
0.3623852432,
-0.134865582,
0.2242857516,
-0.6149661541,
0.4474843144,
-0.3921560943,
0.5473304987,
0.9705764055,
-0.0096550668,
0.5026742816,
-0.5997671485,
0.8255984187,
-0.3717509508,
0.1159524396,
0.1012082025,
-0.1980854124,
-0.3731697202,
-0.3830811381,
0.5115689635,
0.768107295,
-0.5234766603,
0.0502371825,
0.0998127609,
-0.1233511046,
-0.0928265303,
-0.2590747476,
0.0649096221,
-0.0213914104,
0.1298942417,
-0.1302451789,
-0.5055357218,
-1.0570578575,
-0.213916868,
-0.1584737152,
-0.1444650888,
0.1579895616,
0.2543628812,
-0.3314554095,
0.9806674123,
-0.7325069308,
-0.0834968537,
-0.2032395899,
0.215129897,
0.0218823291,
0.4965126514,
0.8149977326,
-0.5844653249,
-0.3238959312,
0.2579734325,
-0.5899604559,
0.3241145313,
-0.3364145756,
-0.327630192,
0.247866556,
0.9281276464,
-0.478143096,
0.476783365,
0.1875132024,
-0.6738878489,
0.4672751427,
-0.4890139103,
0.1953565627,
-1.3133219481,
0.2958428562,
0.2241088152,
-0.1551322788,
-0.5196667314,
0.176565364,
-0.1673036069,
-0.1181218922,
-0.0617023818,
0.8514778018,
-0.2911215723,
-0.1969845146,
-0.4646671116,
-0.2584639788,
-0.4648696184,
0.4017467201,
-0.1246816814,
0.9185032248,
0.4386232793,
-0.2622795403,
0.2410094291,
0.255326122,
-0.2418125272,
0.5627300143,
-0.6311374307,
-0.2873596549,
-0.0266071055,
0.1331924647,
-0.8502357602,
-0.2003104538,
0.4403076172,
-0.1705764681,
0.2201441526,
0.1008506864,
-0.5440349579,
-0.3347582519,
0.0021371096,
0.2817557156,
0.5654996634,
-0.1898933947,
0.9402527213,
0.1541804969,
-0.478856653,
-0.6809588075,
-0.4181298912,
0.0853604972,
-0.2395497113,
-0.5679553151,
-0.220396921,
-0.1732235402,
-0.694971621,
-0.14424707,
0.0613709055,
0.0143156284,
0.2810666561,
0.0355020352,
0.6973417401,
-0.4510144889,
0.0021425739,
-0.064967528,
-0.3554099798,
0.2497218698,
-0.1611021906,
0.4831117392,
-0.2190238237,
-0.3950943053,
-0.3837811649,
0.3864887953,
0.7302182913,
-0.1808400154,
0.7213650942,
-0.0405260362,
-0.3080689013,
-0.3047402203,
-0.4547448158,
-0.3996885717,
-0.575977385,
0.0925657749,
-0.4847900569,
-0.7488881946,
0.930215776,
-0.0965499878,
0.2853989601,
0.3279328644,
0.5225779414,
0.0007855751,
0.7916300893,
0.6120030284,
0.0813923106,
0.6736232042,
-0.2298817188,
0.3826320469,
-0.1990197897,
0.0625901967,
-0.2484268844,
-0.5454568863,
-0.1730446368,
-0.4721913636,
0.0354447588,
-0.1308235526,
-0.5186553001,
0.2815091908,
0.1276030391,
0.6068176627,
0.7068434358,
-0.0138955824,
0.2396752536,
0.0310476441,
-0.4506988525,
0.205489412,
-0.4695161283,
-0.5989425778,
1.2186479568,
0.4584506452,
1.0059914589,
-0.1082544774,
0.3646309674,
0.3853895664,
0.7332424521,
-0.5668038726,
0.5280749798,
-0.0044836812,
-0.5893601775,
-0.3660951853,
-0.5133800507,
-0.8097914457,
0.1251921803,
-0.3804039657,
-0.3858548105,
0.2535114586,
0.2031160146,
-0.6249926686,
0.1589875519,
-0.6652838588,
0.8712441921,
-0.072316967,
-0.1625474393,
-0.214833796,
-0.4143865108,
0.3323771358,
-0.0916736647,
0.3992417455,
-0.2334725857,
0.1976371408,
0.4614666104,
-0.5687549114,
0.8989278674,
-0.1684168577,
-0.3014751971,
0.3706286848,
0.1844290644,
0.8493990302,
0.0705118105,
-0.096300669,
-0.1970891804,
0.0323331542,
-0.5892267823,
-0.405138284,
0.4876196384,
-0.6892296076,
-0.3567494154,
-0.4095481336,
-0.596208632,
-0.0806900114,
0.0379280932,
-0.2565555573,
0.1590755135,
-0.5147134662,
0.0787702948,
0.0495833121,
0.0948352143,
0.2217742801,
0.9340820312,
-0.5892611742,
-0.244370386,
0.8715018034,
0.0014190117,
0.140965879,
0.298499018,
0.1996916682,
-0.3635461032,
-0.0652165487,
-0.2615163922,
0.2435105145,
-0.4938309789,
-0.1414722204,
-0.439678371,
-0.2346448451,
-0.3835650086,
-0.5437565446,
-0.4736116529,
0.0177502856,
-0.0018487867,
-0.3076584637,
0.5979814529,
0.6468632221,
-0.2938451767,
0.4115506411,
-0.6518768668,
0.166515395,
0.680295229,
0.5230822563,
0.3202340305,
-0.1189067289,
-0.3327246606,
0.464938283,
0.0818942487,
-0.57789886,
0.5277528763,
-0.1009437516,
0.6025096774,
0.839251101,
0.117976211,
0.4978441,
-0.1778395623,
0.1268678159,
-0.1049431339,
-0.9776690602,
0.0942042321,
-0.6194064021,
-0.2642475963,
0.4103217423,
0.0296104234,
-0.7858431935,
-0.5299012065,
-0.620660007,
-0.840949595,
0.7665498853,
0.2365801036,
0.1571363211,
-0.2084799558,
0.3816265464,
0.2360240072,
0.5321861506,
-0.5473541021,
-0.1559987068,
-0.1333157569,
-0.1039382294,
-0.1739577353,
-0.1391554624,
0.0349704139,
-0.0589962676,
0.7017171979,
-0.2918076813,
0.3403474987,
-0.1024847478,
0.2126360834,
-0.3416999578,
0.0258664787,
0.5475701094,
0.543330133,
-0.4310866594,
-0.0215405431,
-0.0360384844,
-0.1992187798,
0.3247095644,
0.2921417058,
-0.2594225109,
-0.4156962931,
-0.0380893648,
0.5352236629,
0.6245539188,
-1.2271108627,
0.6779524684,
-0.0835811198,
-0.6327865124,
-0.7232064009,
-0.0279369708,
0.244322136,
0.9835731983,
0.5491530299,
0.3377772272,
0.1433502883,
-0.8277414441,
0.4934477806,
0.4911304712,
-0.1382133812,
-0.2771179974,
0.9492281675,
0.1735365242,
-0.3481999934,
0.7038285732,
-0.3340457082,
-0.4623095989,
0.8285022974,
0.6919592023,
0.8555819988,
-0.306856513,
0.2289939821,
0.0578305908,
0.3880041838,
-0.7672607303,
0.6890431643,
0.2351250052,
-0.779245317,
-0.6078672409,
-0.7641836405,
-0.5810084939,
-0.1358478665,
-0.5537017584,
0.2838300765,
-0.66935426,
-0.0296762828,
0.098877579,
-0.0562476255,
-0.4142398238,
-0.1873510033,
0.1157350317,
1.0115579367,
-0.8962661624,
0.8376680017,
0.9452744126,
-0.2513199747,
-0.6038304567,
-0.0288309623,
-0.0715458691,
-1.0129849911,
0.2896226645,
0.0279863793,
0.0544512272,
0.0104434285,
-0.573509872,
-0.89293015,
1.08766222,
0.428240478,
-0.4617134631,
0.0519332327,
-0.1439305842,
0.5181778669,
-0.6510050297,
0.0092599839,
0.4341282248,
0.6465548873,
0.6199055314,
-0.7272273898,
-0.1444374174,
-0.5529499054,
-0.1613707989,
0.4740887582,
-0.7976884246,
1.1483026743,
-0.0405627303,
-0.2394284308,
0.2937132418,
0.7612195611,
0.2237018049,
0.5094843507,
0.5600745678,
0.240470469,
0.4619675577,
0.3071211874,
0.9284043312,
-0.5809882283,
0.6698101759,
0.902046442,
-0.6260139346,
1.1448818445,
0.0496606454,
-0.2193998545,
0.3817868233,
0.4842525721,
-0.1953872591,
0.0364259556,
0.2940985262,
-0.2807304561,
-0.4672876894,
0.3392965794,
-0.172307238,
0.5848265886,
0.2319959253,
-0.3087400794,
-0.1117910296,
0.1968259811,
-0.0787377208,
0.1946468055,
-0.1739852726,
0.4724695981,
0.0995165855,
0.0033220586,
-0.1346042752,
0.3063495755,
0.5874918103,
-0.8048231006,
-0.0010582835,
-0.0745809078,
0.1735841632,
0.5522543788,
-0.2550466061,
0.3010210693,
-0.3131224811,
-0.0580210164,
-0.4603185058,
0.6339744925,
-0.6620586514,
-0.6748034954,
0.2545514107,
0.4747573733,
0.0770818219,
-0.1930253357,
-0.491648525,
-0.49281317,
-0.095440276,
-0.5167729259,
0.4441913664,
0.5465359092,
-0.0824183151,
0.7657093406,
1.0106136799,
-0.3741001189,
-0.3193326294,
-0.4371909499,
0.4373392165,
-1.1238101721,
-1.1146230698,
-0.757717669,
-0.0845254511,
-0.0936987549,
0.0172404684,
0.4795201421,
0.685064733,
0.4162174165,
-0.2352499366,
0.7378066182,
0.3189231157,
0.4272719324,
-0.4013774097,
1.0022050142,
-0.4207725823,
0.2493961155,
-0.1394500583,
-0.9928836823,
0.0042255237,
0.9617992043,
-0.2834013402,
-0.0634981394,
0.4991277158,
0.61555475,
-0.2094556093,
0.455853194,
0.3045894504,
0.5668822527,
-0.0241491757,
-0.0497635491,
0.6286199093,
-0.2934164405,
0.2985245287,
-0.0505919643,
-0.1320855916,
-0.7669135928,
-0.649017632,
-0.8649083376,
-0.3019627631,
-0.1432419717,
-0.1710697263,
-0.2025456131,
1.6939253807,
0.2358096689,
-0.5488513708,
-0.8419502974,
0.3087822199,
-0.2477293164,
-0.5339815021,
-0.2463700324,
0.2267978638,
-0.1320033669,
-0.6552893519,
0.4467603266,
0.4399234354,
0.771659255,
-0.2654104829,
-0.0709534883,
-0.1119532809,
0.6585235,
0.7659367919,
0.343814224,
-0.1628494114,
-0.3172984719,
0.1606238484,
-0.152065888,
-0.1477080584,
0.9864051342,
-0.400567919,
0.1226352975,
0.0446039103,
0.4460057318,
0.249772802,
0.156545341,
1.0752938986,
-0.2875566185,
0.3445872366,
-0.0297156051,
0.2702722847,
-0.3965985477,
-0.3189567029,
0.2916305661,
0.1814964116,
-0.3884200156,
-0.4859416485,
-0.0251959916,
-0.9603708386,
-0.4798111022,
0.8881798387,
0.0173771828,
-0.5146795511,
0.040756844,
-0.2637619674,
-0.1670950651,
-0.7540463209,
0.9148367643,
0.6269947886,
0.2107926607,
0.0904990658,
-0.7998194695,
0.2506667078,
0.2012546808,
-0.5239025354,
0.3765175641,
0.3087874353,
0.2126961499,
-0.1503596306,
0.8402899504,
0.323929131,
0.4551632404,
0.4684741497,
0.2391602248,
-0.0749355331,
0.0191899929,
0.101589039,
0.3550559282,
0.1000287831,
0.1003895029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19954v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19954v1 | BESTOW: Efficient and Streamable Speech Language Model with the Best of Two Worlds in GPT and T5 | 2024-06-28T14:40:03 | 2024-06-28T14:40:03 | Zhehuai Chen, He Huang, Oleksii Hrinchuk, Krishna C. Puvvada, Nithin Rao Koluguri, Piotr Żelasko, Jagadeesh Balam, Boris Ginsburg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.SD, eess.AS, 68T10, I.2.7 | Incorporating speech understanding capabilities into pretrained
large-language models has become a vital research direction (SpeechLLM). The
previous architectures can be categorized as: i) GPT-style, prepend speech
prompts to the text prompts as a sequence of LLM inputs like a decoder-only
model; ii) T5-style, introduce speech cross-attention to each layer of the
pretrained LLMs. We propose BESTOW architecture to bring the BESt features from
TwO Worlds into a single model that is highly efficient and has strong
multitask capabilities. Moreover, there is no clear streaming solution for
either style, especially considering the solution should generalize to speech
multitask. We reformulate streamable SpeechLLM as a read-write policy problem
and unifies the offline and streaming research with BESTOW architecture. Hence
we demonstrate the first open-source SpeechLLM solution that enables Streaming
and Multitask at scale (beyond ASR) at the same time. This streamable solution
achieves very strong performance on a wide range of speech tasks (ASR, AST,
SQA, unseen DynamicSuperb). It is end-to-end optimizable, with lower
training/inference cost, and demonstrates LLM knowledge transferability to
speech. | [
-0.036980778,
-0.5511693358,
0.3758074343,
0.3227292597,
-0.3438417614,
0.1613076478,
-0.330783844,
-0.5949793458,
0.1137766168,
0.5280594826,
-0.5436440706,
-0.4557972848,
-0.6062541604,
-0.1677287072,
-0.36573717,
0.7951079607,
0.1101664156,
-0.0805578306,
-0.1436733752,
-0.1149727479,
-0.2082110941,
-0.458119005,
-0.7695370317,
-0.5800379515,
0.3656114042,
0.1673786044,
0.5533150434,
0.53465271,
0.4337032735,
0.3145865798,
-0.0949135646,
0.1990142316,
-0.6231843829,
-0.0828154534,
-0.1485381573,
-0.1128617153,
-0.6986115575,
-0.131951645,
0.525067687,
0.3996165693,
-0.5440943241,
0.1222998574,
0.2499657124,
0.3669529557,
-0.5030652285,
0.2771917284,
-0.5515324473,
-0.1075489223,
-0.3596200049,
-0.1391361654,
-0.4616617858,
-0.2368762344,
0.3317249417,
-0.6323280931,
-0.1075376198,
-0.0639360547,
0.5989735723,
0.3970006406,
-0.1959476471,
-0.0432747193,
-0.6414119005,
0.8133352995,
-0.7458157539,
0.625962317,
0.3041992784,
0.4088990092,
-0.0350744575,
-0.9343111515,
-0.3576969802,
-0.0040865983,
0.2309781015,
0.2769844532,
-0.3234343529,
0.3665575981,
-0.145764783,
0.3225720525,
-0.8824413419,
0.0857838169,
-0.1897952408,
-0.3128882945,
0.3777656555,
-0.1243001521,
0.2962048948,
0.1981198043,
-0.5308379531,
0.1252784729,
-0.6228055954,
-0.0842166245,
0.0943625793,
0.2633868754,
-0.1078102589,
0.169964537,
-0.090723522,
0.669883132,
-0.1127199978,
-0.1419098377,
0.2107956558,
-0.337100178,
-0.2680517435,
0.0449503474,
0.6258521676,
0.1131556034,
0.181125477,
-0.428755641,
-0.0531591512,
-0.1430162936,
0.2622850537,
-0.7467340827,
-0.0530422851,
0.4157149494,
-0.4934834838,
-0.2957085669,
-0.496576488,
-0.4383881986,
-0.3446677625,
-0.2254927009,
0.6681780219,
-0.2493671626,
-0.6784276962,
0.2262683362,
0.0008927113,
0.4216194451,
0.1506469399,
-0.9700558186,
0.3398002088,
0.7472127676,
1.0307787657,
-0.4649960697,
-0.4347086549,
-0.5773174167,
0.2519714534,
-0.2728126943,
0.843262136,
-0.5649774075,
-0.3652197421,
0.047317747,
-0.3020655215,
-0.1469923705,
-0.5336421132,
0.5992066264,
-0.5822761059,
0.279170692,
0.1228479445,
-0.7920123935,
-0.2517411411,
-0.0737080202,
-0.4404448271,
0.7793501616,
-0.0916327387,
-0.6187797189,
0.2102809697,
-0.9589102268,
-0.3816938698,
0.2665820122,
0.1845556051,
-0.2561684549,
0.1126329526,
0.152131021,
0.5354768038,
-0.0627882108,
0.4399502873,
-0.2652338743,
-0.2202281803,
-0.1370170116,
-0.3195085227,
0.6881059408,
0.2963176072,
-0.3302061558,
0.4718534052,
-0.6882143617,
0.3242797256,
0.0811426267,
-0.3258790076,
0.071111843,
0.2137416601,
0.6043432951,
-0.000092334,
0.2200727314,
-0.6731866002,
0.0706044659,
-0.3641328216,
0.959227562,
0.6167280674,
-0.4339835346,
0.4183946848,
-0.1860023886,
0.387863934,
-0.3188895881,
0.1487300247,
-0.0872191489,
-0.3105189502,
-0.3628317416,
-0.4069492221,
0.0689967945,
0.6899052262,
-0.6985478997,
-0.0917578712,
-0.1334941238,
-0.3541807234,
-0.7546547651,
0.0659083426,
0.6270855069,
0.3083920777,
0.4122179747,
0.0313526802,
-0.496881932,
-0.8640129566,
-0.2944489419,
0.0276512932,
0.2234369516,
0.0659883395,
0.0713047311,
-0.1312902272,
0.7016251087,
-0.3692575097,
-0.4078477323,
-0.676813066,
-0.1056423485,
0.1516248435,
0.1794766635,
0.290807426,
-0.5967397094,
-0.4630125761,
-0.1773177087,
-0.5806665421,
-0.196806252,
0.2354639769,
-0.1486269385,
-0.0017119262,
0.3581973314,
-0.5110505223,
-0.0766727254,
0.7850812674,
-0.190373823,
0.3313189447,
-0.3042272329,
-0.1934987605,
-1.1827168465,
0.0510679372,
-0.4206759334,
-0.4787453413,
-1.1296643019,
0.1308883578,
-0.01279057,
-0.3146392107,
-0.6318797469,
0.7154968381,
-0.3915715516,
-0.0737490281,
-0.6531932354,
0.1285469532,
0.0262306072,
0.4406770468,
0.3183371425,
0.9290946722,
0.7480877638,
-0.3820766509,
0.3066862822,
0.228393659,
-0.2256320268,
0.2517453134,
-0.6712624431,
0.5291036367,
0.0498625822,
0.2895068824,
-0.8254497051,
-0.2020389289,
-0.0904967561,
-0.3212790787,
0.3215728402,
0.0912241414,
-0.1919243783,
-0.0699582621,
-0.3071218431,
0.1446307003,
0.4099851847,
-0.7024793029,
0.7573111057,
0.6260638833,
-0.3549938202,
-0.6101164222,
-0.6768991947,
0.2776194215,
-0.1482978761,
-0.7589457631,
0.5011348724,
-0.1149530783,
0.0231058747,
-0.1163777784,
0.1272355765,
-0.2636291683,
-0.1751786321,
0.0175960921,
0.0760359839,
-0.2690069675,
-0.0303859375,
-0.0521454997,
-0.3170326054,
-0.306941092,
-0.7571894526,
0.4049572349,
-0.2212825865,
-0.0667899922,
-0.6224063635,
0.6314784288,
0.5309119821,
-0.4506727159,
0.5096923113,
0.7252822518,
-0.2618952394,
-0.5147421956,
-0.6485936642,
-0.0674673989,
-0.4900702834,
0.5220261812,
-0.5493521094,
-1.0555129051,
0.3032902479,
0.027955804,
0.5297716856,
0.0488922447,
0.5310708284,
-0.2426040769,
0.7253308296,
0.7168161273,
-0.2025934607,
0.6240077019,
-0.271240443,
-0.0279682577,
-0.68868047,
-0.0653108209,
-0.1741170883,
-0.1278983355,
-0.2063391954,
-0.4839660823,
0.24620983,
-0.0747742578,
0.1198347658,
0.0494929701,
-0.5593219995,
0.5973670483,
0.4977714717,
0.0824474096,
0.3277858794,
0.0523852669,
-0.1105460376,
0.0975210294,
-0.7318115234,
-0.487118572,
1.0574001074,
0.2439398021,
0.5703871846,
0.1010848358,
0.6531610489,
0.208829999,
-0.0398775004,
-0.6847684979,
0.499324441,
-0.5701761246,
-0.3117741048,
-0.4287028015,
-0.1442387402,
-0.7663379908,
0.5733010173,
0.2097478956,
-0.6909162998,
-0.1446918696,
0.4976041019,
-0.317604363,
0.385646373,
-0.9054479003,
0.8615729213,
-0.148587659,
-0.4440412223,
-0.3990415037,
-0.6114637852,
0.2194935381,
0.1751074642,
0.2883937955,
-0.0202012174,
-0.1527377069,
0.6902219057,
-0.2308285683,
0.6683833003,
-0.4031644762,
0.0022254321,
0.3683187068,
-0.0991823375,
0.5689793229,
-0.4981410801,
-0.0368884802,
0.170402959,
0.0283570439,
-0.3243225515,
-0.3930720985,
0.5783550739,
-0.8090389371,
-0.4811091423,
-0.2964881063,
-0.494651407,
-0.4092881083,
0.2001721114,
0.241658926,
0.7407604456,
-0.2037906647,
0.0030927926,
0.7379851341,
-0.035274338,
0.6606951356,
0.5997822285,
-0.3293150663,
-0.3923625052,
1.1266834736,
-0.0144330654,
0.4606618881,
0.4999933541,
0.4082839191,
-0.7533493042,
-0.9047059417,
-0.7031135559,
0.1640153974,
-0.435872674,
0.223026216,
-0.7003495097,
-0.3085366189,
-0.3369971216,
0.0123697985,
-0.5660456419,
-0.170265168,
-0.2321376801,
-0.2143783271,
0.1661025733,
0.833102107,
-0.3000637293,
0.3414243758,
-0.6798048615,
0.4169902802,
0.4112085402,
0.3695392609,
0.0985109434,
-0.578128159,
-0.1888406277,
-0.2795404792,
-0.2695814073,
-0.6675969958,
0.2325740457,
0.8258857727,
0.5314287543,
0.5273759365,
-0.2573291063,
0.6345263124,
-0.8306831121,
0.6322565675,
0.1167640314,
-0.9783099294,
0.3511267006,
-0.4367502034,
0.5694432259,
0.401881665,
0.0355892107,
-0.7457633615,
-0.3754641712,
-0.3726874888,
-0.7427536845,
0.8457422256,
0.2076272964,
0.039770823,
0.4830599427,
0.0092545403,
0.3619480729,
0.1586468667,
-0.4122568369,
-0.0139758233,
-0.4872879088,
-0.332013458,
-0.196323961,
-0.2786197364,
0.1572621763,
0.0495116226,
0.5988086462,
0.0216276124,
0.5937837958,
-0.0361047015,
-0.2034847289,
0.1104456335,
0.5939731598,
0.8424097896,
0.8135122657,
-0.1139409691,
0.2722270489,
0.0318973735,
-0.6666879058,
0.0903948322,
0.1398304254,
-0.1589757055,
-0.1078956649,
0.5346210003,
1.13286376,
0.2663952708,
-0.4473842084,
0.4066089392,
0.0942568853,
-0.3195697367,
-0.050474491,
0.1383798718,
0.5750702024,
0.4047427177,
0.1967661232,
-0.1169030219,
0.3722079694,
-0.429700017,
0.2101658285,
0.3423846066,
-0.188933745,
-0.3878582716,
0.7767726779,
0.4320551455,
-0.2489908636,
0.3100196719,
-0.0827956125,
-0.574518621,
0.2911716104,
0.5951060653,
0.9528540373,
-0.3686276972,
0.3247905672,
-0.0373795778,
-0.0143497344,
-0.0452885181,
0.6333233118,
-0.0991516709,
-0.6914425492,
-0.6296856403,
-0.6926767826,
-0.4679213762,
0.2505386472,
-0.4057007432,
-0.2081483603,
-0.1063236222,
-0.0761784613,
0.065412581,
-0.1278600842,
-0.4068253338,
-0.0358984061,
0.3189500272,
0.6457004547,
-0.4792948663,
1.0143357515,
0.6971620321,
-0.000309398,
-0.8470275402,
-0.3058030009,
0.1854728311,
-0.9711377621,
0.4022875726,
0.0323180594,
-0.4856782258,
0.4584999084,
-0.2911325693,
-0.9421108961,
0.9324602485,
0.3388062716,
-0.7074341178,
-0.2224541605,
0.0876618847,
0.3693873882,
-0.2270836681,
0.4855056405,
0.3121006787,
0.3424356878,
0.3955245614,
-1.225902319,
-0.255330056,
0.0317134149,
0.080107227,
0.2130108029,
-0.8957481384,
0.4375212789,
-0.410264492,
-0.2894202173,
-0.18250072,
0.6877933741,
0.045242209,
0.2762648761,
0.4416289926,
0.5072755814,
0.7229087949,
0.0481339246,
0.8796817064,
-0.2329503149,
0.248656854,
1.1815532446,
-0.2752292752,
1.2006187439,
0.2308224142,
-0.2605342567,
-0.032001812,
0.6660274267,
0.3582571745,
1.0098594427,
0.1749980748,
-0.3716255426,
-0.2967818677,
-0.2610650063,
-0.3547335863,
0.5327908993,
0.1910963953,
0.1810247153,
-0.354711771,
0.5191332102,
0.0252813548,
-0.1886492074,
-0.4475252926,
1.0237123966,
0.3987342417,
-0.410795331,
0.5307220221,
-0.0883210674,
0.8682812452,
-0.8516004086,
0.0425333567,
-0.1403256655,
0.3096106946,
-0.3569584489,
-0.6263785958,
0.3060402274,
0.1114811748,
-0.083458133,
-0.6139865518,
0.9299075603,
-0.6590444446,
-0.1968738288,
0.4601362348,
0.5278072357,
0.4256890714,
-0.209499836,
-0.644898653,
0.1210716292,
0.0709449872,
-0.2366307676,
0.2199204713,
0.0070647062,
0.1392493397,
0.8340424299,
0.6138052344,
0.4594559669,
0.4178774357,
0.4056540132,
0.6766365767,
-0.3278730214,
-0.628069818,
-0.8447802067,
0.3908269405,
0.1548173875,
-0.2844156325,
0.2535282373,
0.4352208078,
0.6166861653,
0.0185550246,
0.8150091767,
0.1176154464,
0.6779798269,
-0.462850064,
0.8312089443,
-0.5876258016,
-0.2664438486,
0.0002869025,
-0.9057614207,
-0.0649657696,
0.4261191189,
-0.1379495561,
-0.0398351662,
0.8146272302,
0.5608151555,
-0.0678569078,
0.3625889421,
0.5258232355,
0.2720083892,
0.3652685285,
0.7309882641,
0.5939126015,
-0.047515858,
0.6602645516,
-0.039161142,
-0.3032025397,
-0.0269472413,
-0.6858831644,
-0.7220265865,
-0.5421740413,
-0.2116854638,
0.2371699512,
0.4354096949,
0.9061358571,
0.9572547078,
-0.8266097903,
-0.4103196561,
0.0103556281,
-0.2216650695,
-0.2066869438,
-0.1598683596,
0.6081467867,
-0.4327532351,
-0.6853626966,
0.7231951356,
0.4096648693,
-0.2439959794,
-0.2789430022,
-0.0944940224,
-0.0974217951,
-0.0357951112,
0.8437860012,
0.0910507515,
-0.7470099926,
-0.0640012771,
-0.0202628374,
-0.0774528533,
0.1148545966,
0.7204009295,
-0.3803248107,
0.5761001706,
0.3512519896,
0.9118118286,
0.6615421176,
-0.1593375504,
0.6048315763,
-0.3891109526,
-0.0365581624,
0.3041684926,
0.0827251524,
0.2230875045,
-0.2733458281,
0.2995991111,
0.1167421043,
-0.605062604,
-0.4967051446,
0.1610489637,
-1.0485479832,
-0.1392375827,
0.9511714578,
-0.2723308802,
0.0032612074,
-0.2597494125,
-0.1235632077,
0.2496029884,
-0.5973577499,
0.3824075758,
0.8528375626,
-0.4316107035,
-0.4990789294,
-0.7836576104,
0.6123535633,
0.3724119067,
-0.893564105,
0.093127355,
0.1806084067,
0.3276889324,
-0.281706214,
0.9673945308,
0.0616253465,
0.0211517196,
0.0197844245,
0.0548491627,
-0.5557646155,
-0.3820783496,
-0.1857588142,
0.3923906386,
0.0950355828,
-0.6006630659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19951v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19951v1 | Mining Reasons For And Against Vaccination From Unstructured Data Using Nichesourcing and AI Data Augmentation | 2024-06-28T14:36:31 | 2024-06-28T14:36:31 | Damián Ariel Furman, Juan Junqueras, Z. Burçe Gümüslü, Edgar Altszyler, Joaquin Navajas, Ophelia Deroy, Justin Sulik | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present Reasons For and Against Vaccination (RFAV), a dataset for
predicting reasons for and against vaccination, and scientific authorities used
to justify them, annotated through nichesourcing and augmented using GPT4 and
GPT3.5-Turbo. We show how it is possible to mine these reasons in
non-structured text, under different task definitions, despite the high level
of subjectivity involved and explore the impact of artificially augmented data
using in-context learning with GPT4 and GPT3.5-Turbo. We publish the dataset
and the trained models along with the annotation manual used to train
annotators and define the task. | [
-0.0556536615,
-0.5517722368,
0.4114234447,
-0.3282644153,
-0.3276346326,
-0.2398836911,
0.0431969799,
-0.4431908429,
0.1086589918,
0.3756191134,
-0.3786034286,
-0.5913075209,
-0.402784586,
0.2922378778,
-0.425701201,
1.3324828148,
0.1883154213,
-0.0684264749,
-0.6660725474,
-0.058663588,
-0.4747415185,
-0.7913938165,
-0.2704635561,
-0.4110430777,
0.6046559811,
0.7933095098,
0.2047104537,
0.3354406655,
0.074633047,
0.2180235237,
0.1678761095,
0.0468838401,
-0.1234646514,
0.1992627531,
-0.4715008438,
-0.4226551056,
-0.1160258651,
0.1656603515,
0.3091202378,
0.3257255256,
-0.0328559689,
0.1416846961,
-0.0852808356,
0.2156946361,
-0.4163559079,
0.2095936984,
-0.7103837729,
-0.0391300991,
-0.5599321723,
-0.5581355095,
-0.1677782387,
0.3415111005,
0.1670702994,
-0.7574052811,
0.5883563757,
-0.3389449716,
0.7035496235,
0.2074240297,
-0.5306019783,
-0.2022698522,
-0.4949053228,
0.7283537984,
-0.4110083878,
-0.1481455564,
0.7563441396,
-0.0748018399,
-0.1578835249,
-0.7480024695,
-0.304464072,
0.0268949065,
-0.0796132758,
0.1533108205,
-0.3437777162,
0.269402653,
0.2620111108,
0.2613368332,
-0.640843451,
-0.0506173596,
-0.5582181215,
-0.1517771482,
0.5805536509,
-0.0171814077,
0.3955328465,
-0.4318393171,
-0.1995924264,
0.1872172654,
-0.6923321486,
0.406232506,
0.3006615639,
0.3876557052,
0.1484616101,
0.6780745983,
-0.3202034533,
0.7804225087,
-0.0246523563,
-0.0767856687,
0.2896060944,
-0.6143861413,
-0.2051980197,
0.1452334076,
0.4782565832,
0.2763641477,
-0.1029072478,
-0.2015565187,
-0.0375506803,
-0.1429867744,
0.3909757137,
-0.8094210029,
-0.0335416235,
0.3326555192,
-0.4328671396,
-0.3996129334,
0.1011046469,
-0.8104116321,
-0.2811915576,
-0.0912492722,
0.3802151084,
-0.3700233996,
-0.0394902639,
-0.0362987183,
-0.7154436111,
0.160456866,
0.3092590868,
-1.0025664568,
0.0090133483,
0.7895460725,
1.0029578209,
0.1035935506,
-0.0281265918,
-0.4248515666,
0.1709675938,
-0.0081357686,
1.2917025089,
-0.752143085,
-0.5082294941,
-0.2558199763,
-0.065631628,
0.1766630113,
-0.4135498405,
0.5264065862,
-0.1804281026,
0.4146873057,
-0.3695043027,
-0.3089904487,
-0.432521224,
0.2586704493,
-0.4513444304,
0.7560044527,
0.3278973997,
-0.9069765806,
0.7936800122,
-0.5902212858,
-0.8128920197,
0.6217018962,
-0.3048731387,
-0.5137101412,
0.0217230525,
0.2998211682,
0.2765055597,
-0.365652442,
0.2504505813,
-0.3555915058,
-0.1891007721,
-0.1016112044,
-0.2325839549,
0.8841341734,
-0.1864681542,
-0.3674914837,
0.4298004806,
-0.4690797925,
-0.147241056,
-0.1263762414,
-0.2959899604,
-0.6295589805,
0.3487658203,
0.0425320119,
0.2619409561,
-0.1098794714,
-0.504828155,
0.4346333146,
-0.5711476207,
0.8834939003,
0.5042006373,
0.5197882652,
0.1746221036,
-0.4995442927,
0.6968216896,
0.020715883,
0.2041156441,
-0.1168626621,
-1.0268816948,
0.026849594,
-0.4259523749,
0.3212941885,
0.5571891069,
-0.6517538428,
0.1299075782,
-0.0627640635,
-0.3216820359,
-0.3027493358,
0.0488269553,
-0.1341964751,
0.8164349794,
0.531265378,
-0.1031364948,
-0.9380510449,
-0.8549585938,
-0.1373680979,
-0.1687792093,
-0.0402078219,
0.1879615337,
0.6841376424,
-0.3464829028,
1.0374571085,
-0.0901183486,
-0.40234074,
-0.2408744544,
0.2828582227,
0.2456434071,
0.4702375829,
0.7623845339,
-0.9522271752,
-0.1116060093,
0.3129310906,
-0.4134100378,
-0.1210589036,
0.00477973,
0.4252354801,
-0.0765331909,
0.254224807,
-0.8043937683,
0.8288393617,
0.0801351517,
-0.0788840428,
0.5187594891,
0.1290143728,
0.2906598151,
-1.042178154,
0.2538531125,
0.2395611256,
-0.3795172274,
-0.8457666039,
-0.1622141153,
-0.2681383491,
0.0257177353,
-0.5023618937,
0.5840989351,
-0.1514251679,
0.345734179,
-0.3590669036,
-0.3393440545,
0.1233293191,
-0.0888472572,
0.0368458033,
0.6743146181,
0.5397583246,
-0.4786919057,
0.5006455779,
0.2642046809,
-0.1168674305,
0.2809828222,
-0.6374127269,
-0.4866223037,
-0.2169618905,
0.4887339771,
-0.4617813528,
-0.5093699694,
0.5608448982,
-0.774554491,
-0.062900871,
-0.5921875834,
-0.2283599079,
-0.3155291378,
-0.3010642231,
0.4269911051,
0.4311553836,
-0.4551027417,
0.5308306813,
0.6663666368,
-0.0342344046,
-0.6520188451,
-0.6426047087,
0.0808830634,
-0.6492094994,
-0.1815569699,
0.5824236274,
0.2237199992,
-0.2226358205,
0.0889384076,
-0.1126646101,
-0.1575728357,
0.0351358242,
0.3793641925,
0.0038639572,
-0.0313998163,
0.2757378221,
-0.0674300566,
-0.153241083,
0.2762939334,
-0.4276394546,
0.0767662302,
0.2509049177,
-0.1403425336,
-0.1848936379,
0.6983346343,
0.2657521367,
-0.013115108,
0.4446119666,
0.4423987865,
-0.7348386049,
-0.0893467665,
-0.1789088547,
-0.2635867596,
-0.3678450286,
0.1819353551,
-0.0067582414,
-0.7175277472,
0.3936139047,
0.2968124747,
0.0434571616,
0.6841827631,
0.7453919649,
-0.0221514925,
1.1500631571,
0.5104968548,
0.0309185181,
0.4820137024,
-0.0071285255,
-0.1084434837,
-0.4060074985,
-0.474601388,
-0.3967337012,
0.1238892451,
-0.5930024981,
-0.5501046777,
0.3317584097,
-0.0710689649,
0.052958589,
-0.0956345946,
-0.647017777,
0.3637073636,
0.5745099187,
0.0624297671,
0.028639337,
0.0698738992,
0.0987033397,
0.1151940674,
-1.0240236521,
-0.2764760852,
1.0641230345,
0.1610931158,
0.2794092298,
0.027529262,
0.2616418302,
0.4396469593,
0.5567983389,
-0.8998785615,
0.0895530805,
-0.081770882,
-0.9986096621,
-0.1083171964,
-0.3339628577,
-1.1808604002,
0.0807503983,
-0.3422858715,
-0.7385149598,
0.3856793344,
0.261362493,
-0.3992601633,
-0.0123598855,
-0.749487102,
0.7675189972,
-0.1426672637,
-0.3000173569,
-0.0563827418,
-0.6895997524,
0.3597486913,
-0.0161343701,
-0.0125582321,
0.0416734032,
-0.0629660487,
0.6118479371,
-0.8119385839,
0.9654012322,
-0.1529121697,
0.3886319101,
0.4614702463,
-0.7890915871,
0.0138086956,
0.7113806009,
-0.1763810366,
0.3549253047,
-0.0063448348,
-0.509796381,
-0.2223633975,
0.5704972148,
-0.5191857219,
-0.9741552472,
-0.9958806038,
-0.3228117526,
0.0449389145,
0.2719933093,
0.5488381386,
0.3922210038,
-0.1211873591,
0.4774972796,
0.5931118727,
-0.0701567531,
0.246170342,
0.4285085797,
0.2696346641,
-0.3957076371,
0.8061736226,
0.2774514556,
-0.2392208427,
0.5253905654,
0.4689951539,
-0.4012969434,
-0.619879663,
-0.5618106127,
-0.1559090465,
-0.5941131115,
-0.5628701448,
-0.7959889174,
-0.2577809989,
-0.6884887218,
0.1422113329,
0.1577325761,
-0.171202004,
-0.5686381459,
-0.2176088989,
0.8656806946,
0.8448559642,
-0.4514748156,
0.067140758,
-0.6457380652,
0.1427627355,
0.1767829508,
0.1039316803,
-0.3337934017,
-0.2336993665,
-0.3594503403,
0.0665941611,
-0.1268133819,
-1.0607335567,
0.3349946737,
0.1930604726,
0.7352265716,
0.3011263311,
0.0015494451,
0.7746763825,
-0.3382421732,
0.6409431696,
-0.3336819112,
-0.946641624,
0.8534449339,
-0.6241165996,
0.1521283388,
0.4552071393,
0.4946279526,
-0.4308075607,
-0.1952963322,
-0.7321818471,
-1.1719250679,
0.6655794978,
0.0954641625,
-0.3405072689,
-0.0020579221,
0.5855543017,
0.3223168254,
0.1315557808,
-0.5885500312,
0.0155865233,
-0.663936615,
-0.0741134286,
-0.143178761,
-0.0825079754,
-0.3854991496,
-0.4709126651,
0.7188760042,
-0.0984850153,
-0.0028346905,
0.3883532882,
-0.2057824582,
-0.0668582767,
0.1213852465,
0.7663841248,
0.7557680607,
-0.1667250395,
0.007658212,
0.1095947549,
-0.5540972352,
0.2185504138,
0.4518198371,
-0.5114814043,
0.1069631577,
0.7126975656,
0.5460434556,
-0.1890036017,
-0.7496786118,
0.5962449312,
0.0112951342,
-0.3831110895,
-0.3615272641,
0.092340149,
-0.2136103958,
-0.1222957671,
0.4471750855,
-0.0077493419,
0.4656470716,
-0.4104572535,
0.5014834404,
0.6964238286,
-0.2433284074,
-0.4758032858,
0.5643317103,
0.0883489698,
0.1269675344,
0.407034874,
0.0812849179,
-0.24467659,
0.6069282889,
0.5194801092,
0.3514392078,
-0.4284691513,
0.4685870707,
0.5439624786,
0.3113097548,
-0.035284359,
0.1937422007,
-0.1643730849,
-0.3438571393,
-0.5901676416,
-0.1704321802,
-0.3023334146,
0.6613689661,
-0.6061498523,
0.3095371127,
-0.2346870601,
-0.1633150578,
0.3024774194,
-0.0757441446,
-0.4640709162,
0.2239957154,
-0.1926042289,
0.7765622139,
-1.2156739235,
0.8425232768,
0.9401842952,
-0.7741111517,
-0.2556107044,
0.1468430758,
0.1144080311,
-0.6169033647,
0.3879600167,
0.3286842704,
0.2379073203,
-0.3044203818,
-0.1947216243,
-0.7580622435,
0.8462376595,
0.0024727392,
-0.3271706402,
0.1046922803,
-0.0203187205,
0.4300498962,
-0.3484794796,
0.278621614,
0.4498422742,
0.5825371742,
0.0103008635,
-0.2774347663,
-0.0676351339,
-0.5036370158,
-0.3636202514,
0.0942278206,
-0.2905929685,
0.6287057996,
-0.2320309132,
-0.2381217778,
-0.2893862128,
0.6013855934,
0.1514171958,
0.5835995674,
0.3989513814,
0.4453311265,
0.6072092652,
-0.1083388701,
0.9331707954,
0.1518627554,
-0.0119265858,
0.7459293008,
-0.1426830888,
0.4361945987,
0.4829274118,
0.2691879869,
0.2408232391,
1.1195422411,
-0.0216860436,
0.594235599,
0.0411337689,
-0.4441285431,
-0.2407855541,
-0.3680348694,
-0.5698467493,
0.5985544324,
0.8164518476,
-0.1879240423,
-0.2693444788,
0.2512931526,
-0.1540297121,
-0.2963897288,
-0.3734479249,
0.8913198113,
-0.2011598647,
-0.6348457336,
0.2714962363,
0.1619678736,
0.3648838401,
-0.5277647376,
-0.1839317679,
0.1453664601,
0.0884613991,
-0.4736342728,
-0.7329220772,
0.560049057,
0.1770235002,
-0.5546848178,
-0.2122560889,
0.9607006311,
-0.358083427,
-0.3756240308,
-0.0274655502,
0.3955875039,
-0.0429649949,
-0.008167115,
-0.9428417683,
-0.2677285671,
-0.0833379105,
-0.3645084798,
0.2826736867,
0.38386482,
-0.4495856762,
0.3269418478,
0.8712410927,
0.2539393604,
-0.4693527222,
-0.0651806965,
0.8777729273,
-0.6071320772,
-0.4216187,
-1.1385848522,
0.5315037966,
-0.163126871,
-0.4103625119,
0.9625490904,
0.7558276057,
0.6316111684,
0.0966318548,
1.2271410227,
-0.1441362202,
0.582740128,
-0.4093468189,
0.5781807899,
-0.5336695313,
-0.0451853201,
0.1283022165,
-0.2798155248,
-0.4477745295,
0.5679908991,
-0.2758858502,
0.2647246718,
0.4577676654,
0.6297324896,
0.099519603,
-0.0756323859,
-0.0524805114,
0.1315333247,
0.5294173956,
0.3437176049,
0.6939179301,
-0.0232510418,
0.3529792428,
-0.2699285746,
-0.5876600742,
-0.4947115183,
-1.0902793407,
-0.9995704889,
-0.8092471361,
-0.3156298995,
-0.4462633729,
0.3657177389,
1.0117824078,
0.8869225383,
-0.8505385518,
0.2035357356,
-0.2701644897,
0.3913743198,
-0.3281366527,
-0.2243390381,
0.0993769169,
-0.1582926959,
-0.3460930884,
0.543728888,
0.3828545511,
0.0655006319,
-0.0023407426,
0.3526773155,
-0.3919504583,
-0.0156247988,
0.5577120781,
0.8956196904,
-0.6739929914,
-0.1824597269,
-0.4296282828,
0.069398582,
0.137498498,
0.8705875874,
-1.0177664757,
0.4538230896,
0.6392194033,
0.5109546185,
0.207936734,
0.2834582925,
0.6835502386,
-0.9102393389,
0.2953846455,
0.4951170385,
0.1574378908,
0.4166725576,
-0.5788988471,
0.3145726621,
0.6007130742,
-0.6213049889,
-0.8786811829,
0.241819784,
-0.8041553497,
-0.3229385912,
1.322680831,
0.1404795349,
-0.4923211634,
-0.7255720496,
0.0475302748,
0.1704815328,
-0.5000178218,
0.6845172048,
0.6462662816,
-0.327644676,
-0.035568092,
-0.7410325408,
1.0277153254,
0.1202989072,
-0.940590024,
-0.1301257312,
0.2537263632,
0.2838429809,
-0.318688035,
0.9515355229,
0.0917482004,
0.5417617559,
-0.1057947725,
0.0763008595,
-0.2565478683,
-0.320949018,
-0.3970668912,
0.1024920717,
-0.020628294,
-0.0744512305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19949v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19949v1 | Calibrating LLMs with Preference Optimization on Thought Trees for Generating Rationale in Science Question Scoring | 2024-06-28T14:33:05 | 2024-06-28T14:33:05 | Jiazheng Li, Hainiu Xu, Zhaoyue Sun, Yuxiang Zhou, David West, Cesare Aloisi, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generating rationales that justify scoring decisions has been a promising way
to facilitate explainability in automated scoring systems. However, existing
methods do not match the accuracy of classifier-based methods. Plus, the
generated rationales often contain hallucinated information. To address these
issues, we propose a novel framework capable of generating more faithful
rationales and, more importantly, matching performance with classifier-based
black-box scoring systems. We first mimic the human assessment process by
querying Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate a thought tree. We then
summarise intermediate assessment decisions from each thought tree path for
creating synthetic rationale data and rationale preference data. Finally, we
utilise the generated synthetic data to calibrate LLMs through a two-step
training process: supervised fine-tuning and preference optimization. Extensive
experimental results demonstrate that our framework achieves a 38% assessment
performance improvement in the QWK score compared to prior work while producing
higher-quality rationales, as recognised by human evaluators and LLMs. Our work
sheds light on the effectiveness of performing preference optimization using
synthetic preference data obtained from thought tree paths. | [
-0.3842498064,
-0.6036087871,
0.8601791859,
-0.0715750828,
-0.3458983898,
0.0378810428,
-0.2740579545,
-0.2600618005,
0.264701575,
0.372549355,
-0.5863285661,
-0.4025275409,
-0.077407077,
0.1781475395,
0.087960124,
0.9699587822,
-0.0583576337,
0.2264748365,
-0.6171466708,
-0.0480331331,
-0.3840886354,
-0.415029645,
-0.6541957855,
-0.4865984023,
0.5167135596,
0.2891918719,
0.6219687462,
0.5906667709,
0.3164197803,
0.1613593102,
0.2357874066,
0.452072233,
-0.5719008446,
0.1795407236,
-0.3089959025,
-0.6192693114,
-0.3333983421,
0.1738439351,
0.3558695912,
0.5513489842,
-0.0052542011,
0.4545107782,
0.0649479404,
0.786860466,
-0.5956154466,
0.1555992067,
-0.8376953006,
0.1481277347,
0.263879925,
-0.9672288299,
-0.5873373151,
-0.7820937634,
0.2045285851,
-0.7222287655,
0.2396637201,
0.1413264722,
0.4949882925,
0.4424725175,
-0.2838882506,
-0.1667356342,
-0.5965009928,
0.9209491611,
-0.6058927774,
0.1066913307,
0.3767209649,
0.5254167914,
-0.1688643247,
-0.3120899498,
-0.3698329926,
-0.2613680363,
0.0244169515,
0.1675714999,
0.2106641829,
0.0670324117,
0.4203116596,
0.1086668745,
-0.6282253861,
-0.1678522676,
-0.1898909807,
-0.3979590833,
0.8747580647,
0.2702820003,
-0.2024760991,
-0.2209309042,
-0.1399418265,
-0.4557122588,
-0.6288747787,
0.3768236339,
0.4307468534,
0.4267917275,
0.4714430571,
0.7023755908,
-0.2523485124,
0.6594769359,
0.2581574023,
-0.183220759,
0.1340111792,
-0.121709384,
-0.2411727309,
0.2658838332,
0.588442862,
0.9132235646,
0.2646368742,
-0.0773654357,
-0.1944559067,
0.4749596417,
0.4396767914,
-1.010053277,
-0.2221231759,
0.2959856093,
-0.0387151167,
-0.6506871581,
-0.1451733857,
-0.756970048,
-0.3511759341,
-0.6943916082,
0.3638674021,
-0.2423938662,
-0.0824152604,
0.347661525,
-0.0621435419,
0.3141475618,
0.616320312,
-0.8136590123,
0.0739235952,
0.5148258209,
0.5270225406,
-0.2613323629,
-0.0042341202,
-0.4483210146,
0.0184069276,
-0.7051647902,
0.9408355355,
-0.6602956057,
-0.3533737361,
-0.3390952349,
-0.286308378,
0.0570749454,
-0.5606126785,
0.6029490232,
-0.4630108476,
0.3377612531,
-0.3802804947,
-0.4815978408,
-0.3310519457,
0.5491027236,
-0.2276703119,
1.1861368418,
0.255347997,
-0.5788384676,
0.6610348225,
-0.7651788592,
-0.0773615539,
0.2460944951,
-0.2418754697,
-0.2162109911,
0.0272738151,
0.1320852786,
0.2992375195,
-0.4280650914,
0.5161064267,
-0.455098182,
-0.2283076793,
0.271122694,
-0.5083746314,
0.5970501304,
0.191851452,
-0.2853934765,
0.298491776,
-0.6103509665,
0.7125962973,
-0.1240349263,
-0.3298676014,
-0.3126712441,
0.2491436303,
-0.1325714439,
0.128752619,
0.0685858428,
-0.4788992703,
0.1043130979,
-0.5006121993,
0.4117719531,
0.8687052131,
0.0208330173,
0.3024392128,
-0.5968285203,
0.5488421917,
-0.1598842293,
0.0182563197,
0.213082552,
-0.3186042309,
-0.5143061876,
0.1008514911,
0.2188941836,
0.4242795408,
-0.3703334332,
0.6495935321,
-0.2420781404,
-0.6065681577,
-0.6330572963,
-0.0545416214,
0.1097349972,
0.7623621821,
0.3902591169,
-0.2034250647,
-0.5816113949,
-0.9168896675,
-0.2122953385,
-0.356474191,
-0.1610314101,
0.6335124373,
0.3780890703,
-0.0506784953,
1.2599402666,
-0.6510035396,
0.0357820764,
0.1800230592,
-0.0702864826,
0.0943900645,
0.4661785066,
0.4196904898,
-0.7481605411,
-0.3332358897,
0.0241675898,
-0.622659564,
-0.1529161036,
-0.0518340692,
-0.4021181166,
0.1884127855,
0.1742358804,
-0.5482123494,
0.2285463065,
0.1739044189,
-0.243834123,
0.9721650481,
0.0254529566,
0.3272719085,
-1.0053145885,
0.1885287166,
0.1125950962,
-0.3346385062,
-0.2267436087,
0.0795504823,
-0.0111577027,
0.0872992873,
-0.4381327331,
0.4371381998,
0.048276253,
0.0001018893,
-0.1907850504,
-0.0040469882,
0.2518557012,
0.5669997334,
-0.04741887,
0.7797470689,
0.4108790159,
-0.5105370879,
0.2874403894,
-0.0377076715,
-0.3116425276,
0.6435198188,
-0.4984243214,
0.1904655993,
-0.2165055275,
0.3012478352,
-0.8165701628,
-0.4432964027,
0.0611797646,
-0.4246000051,
0.0403285846,
-0.116828233,
-0.2142595947,
-0.3346122205,
-0.6576996446,
0.5031696558,
0.5873720646,
-0.4543421865,
0.5145888925,
0.3460408747,
0.190767929,
-0.3196976185,
-0.4298300147,
-0.2279494703,
-0.5116368532,
-0.5141021609,
0.4589653611,
-0.4861386716,
-0.1861667484,
-0.1512611955,
-0.3921452761,
0.2871330976,
0.1555201262,
0.2579833567,
0.3637696207,
-0.3790766001,
0.0620622449,
0.1554635018,
-0.1043873429,
0.42353791,
-0.4454427958,
0.4251310229,
-0.19849509,
-0.3059232235,
-0.2539612055,
0.1383736432,
0.6807271242,
0.0107165733,
0.3033960462,
0.1278170943,
-0.509354949,
-0.3783669174,
-0.5084112287,
-0.4486046433,
-0.4984435439,
0.2735631764,
-0.477337718,
-0.8184336424,
0.1369276941,
-0.1974410117,
0.2004266232,
0.3597514331,
0.7074591517,
-0.169793427,
1.5089588165,
0.1768305898,
0.1966930926,
0.0900733024,
-0.12505202,
0.2542469203,
-0.8287398219,
-0.268712908,
-0.3918156624,
-0.1556140333,
-0.6209162474,
-0.4287779331,
0.4227785468,
0.1371905357,
-0.2821582258,
0.0457421504,
-0.9336053729,
0.8307256699,
0.3652093112,
0.2476162314,
0.1325472593,
0.1515936702,
-0.4288317263,
-0.1000454351,
-0.4867939055,
-0.9755594134,
1.2047963142,
0.1925406307,
0.6169477105,
-0.2947581708,
0.6579273939,
0.2215497941,
0.598808229,
-1.0719405413,
0.6498932242,
0.2900744379,
-0.5233676434,
-0.4196678698,
-0.5184502602,
-0.7466230989,
0.4375460148,
-0.2503006458,
-0.637447536,
-0.2460078001,
0.2910525799,
-0.532414794,
-0.0170261879,
-0.8564388752,
0.7566969991,
-0.320797801,
-0.6268463731,
-0.3878071606,
-0.3674132228,
0.324580878,
-0.2898168564,
0.0104089035,
-0.2945429087,
0.2758442461,
0.8836675882,
-0.1645045429,
0.5997939706,
-0.2321520448,
0.0511795096,
0.1975416392,
0.2973538637,
0.3058420718,
0.3580294251,
-0.5906581283,
-0.2678878009,
0.4100642502,
-0.326140821,
-0.855127275,
0.7203866243,
-0.6780404449,
-1.0409001112,
-0.5260587335,
-0.7388556004,
-0.5031000972,
0.1217110753,
-0.0852559879,
0.1607133746,
-0.0792058483,
0.1609024405,
0.3220483363,
0.0675736442,
0.0489725322,
0.4511263371,
-0.177978754,
-0.4500788748,
0.8650485873,
-0.0442060381,
0.203957662,
0.1837004721,
0.5031376481,
-0.587153852,
-0.5895089507,
-0.4791286588,
0.0849151388,
-0.5731978416,
-0.4222942889,
-0.3038772643,
-0.1603813916,
-0.24133946,
-0.3182979226,
-0.0107164634,
-0.5733972788,
-0.2946639061,
-0.2909168005,
0.3336007297,
0.4340033531,
0.1791539788,
-0.1125071719,
-0.3784758151,
0.0797359273,
0.3418167531,
0.3538742363,
-0.07262519,
-0.5190517902,
-0.0287275463,
0.4583519995,
-0.7287675738,
-0.5880925655,
0.4150690138,
0.0022908892,
0.4013269544,
0.2221595496,
0.2510271966,
0.888694942,
-0.2815207243,
0.6003879309,
0.1043899804,
-0.6916083097,
0.7247727513,
-0.2062308937,
-0.0264328495,
0.8102924228,
0.4311569035,
-0.1034197062,
-0.2477575988,
-0.4592776895,
-0.5346994996,
0.8438566327,
0.0558272786,
-0.0263270419,
0.1748232245,
0.5893294215,
0.1649403423,
0.183350265,
-0.7654486895,
0.0778697133,
-0.2997663617,
-0.3787056804,
-0.2771759629,
0.018343078,
-0.3858223855,
-0.4798182249,
0.8575996161,
-0.6060193777,
-0.0745714605,
0.2335639,
0.0780954584,
-0.5590826869,
0.1506224275,
0.4242975712,
0.5765077472,
-0.5685580969,
0.0868592188,
0.2424140126,
-0.2154996544,
0.2471307814,
-0.0976293907,
-0.4738120139,
-0.4492983818,
-0.0534149706,
0.6512537599,
-0.137657702,
-0.7180691361,
0.2076490372,
0.0154764643,
-0.5071223378,
-0.1641376764,
0.4773753285,
0.1103753895,
0.1387750357,
0.2930361032,
0.4825356305,
0.1505007744,
-0.4099419713,
0.1365372092,
0.8360059261,
-0.2604622543,
-0.284822017,
0.4875752628,
0.0471393093,
-0.3943059444,
0.1979334205,
-0.1434211582,
-0.5391560197,
0.5915183425,
0.6413019896,
0.8263965845,
-0.0892748907,
0.3421902657,
0.6397981644,
0.0914904028,
-0.1276326329,
0.3100177348,
-0.3736182153,
-0.7593647838,
-0.3955290914,
-1.0602514744,
-0.6213422418,
0.1457945555,
-0.55790025,
0.3839119375,
-0.4501590729,
-0.3676751852,
0.2002894431,
0.2795907557,
-0.430878222,
0.3708358109,
-0.0576481856,
0.7735676169,
-0.8130325675,
0.7543333769,
0.6880152822,
-0.1458640546,
-0.9697578549,
-0.107678555,
-0.2203985006,
-0.6200962663,
0.3738673329,
0.4294586778,
-0.2905982733,
0.1098043546,
-0.4034009278,
-0.7950977683,
1.0652272701,
0.5992438793,
-0.3803542852,
-0.0643048957,
0.2678976059,
0.7947788835,
-0.5954572558,
0.533401072,
0.6868918538,
0.5927287936,
0.2635962963,
-0.4557388723,
0.2108412981,
-0.2967914045,
-0.171089828,
0.136371389,
-0.3157879412,
0.1480966359,
-0.2769288123,
-0.1974958628,
-0.1455243826,
0.286269486,
0.7835426331,
0.5268227458,
0.5812771916,
0.4918682277,
0.8402177691,
-0.0610289164,
0.843623817,
-0.3211938143,
0.2726572156,
0.7812402248,
-0.5663284659,
0.827855289,
0.7244637012,
-0.3787954152,
0.4330236018,
0.9613423944,
0.029016437,
0.4731345177,
0.5116309524,
-0.1933640689,
-0.5576078296,
-0.2607934475,
-0.0604234152,
0.2275317013,
0.3990710676,
-0.2332956791,
-0.1431049854,
-0.2436744124,
-0.4650588334,
0.1408409029,
-0.2124597132,
0.5805341005,
-0.0415112711,
-1.2762838602,
0.8620932698,
-0.120934546,
0.381480962,
-0.4995658398,
-0.0454325043,
0.0637602285,
0.028797701,
-0.4337116778,
-0.8603893518,
0.1982586086,
0.0008999608,
-0.2047602981,
-0.3096301258,
0.3518960476,
-0.3997640312,
-0.5602938533,
0.0409171544,
0.3341803551,
0.2207475901,
0.0532222502,
-0.7042523026,
-0.3429937959,
0.2201434076,
-0.3407160044,
0.3775827885,
0.301892966,
-0.258202225,
0.6722986102,
1.1059871912,
0.076819323,
-0.2148103416,
0.1299662292,
0.805403173,
-0.5894113779,
-0.4288627207,
-0.8834296465,
0.2233763933,
0.0464613326,
-0.217279315,
0.5837764144,
0.9666212201,
0.8230158687,
0.0077065937,
0.7444110513,
0.2572813332,
0.4047993422,
-0.5098484159,
0.4456275105,
-0.5852906704,
0.3415432274,
-0.2082077861,
-1.1682100296,
-0.4160243571,
0.7720187306,
-0.4273436666,
0.0632055774,
0.7307661772,
1.3005093336,
-0.05714323,
0.2532307804,
0.3375349343,
-0.097536765,
0.4308140278,
0.6871082783,
0.9009171724,
-0.164800182,
0.320338577,
-0.2469224483,
-0.3799640834,
-0.2562192678,
-0.9364734292,
-0.8102793694,
-0.4265877903,
-0.3845643401,
-0.4320703745,
-0.1855331957,
1.2997996807,
0.8204847574,
-0.9101690054,
-0.2763956189,
-0.2807870507,
-0.0625531301,
-0.0614133887,
-0.3360054195,
0.4607309699,
-0.3292349279,
-0.4660595059,
0.3902480304,
0.262668252,
0.0715722218,
-0.2929005921,
-0.3138833642,
0.1771925688,
0.3823554814,
0.7360706925,
-0.0390760712,
-0.9271643162,
-0.4650374949,
0.1720363051,
-0.0936849043,
0.291190654,
0.7908204794,
-1.1354993582,
0.4764721692,
0.4659537673,
0.5222960114,
0.5873823762,
0.2159427404,
0.5267510414,
-0.2972253263,
-0.3451395333,
0.661074698,
0.1864058077,
0.4176125824,
-0.3824607432,
0.5011371374,
0.0791429952,
-0.5973255634,
-1.1022155285,
0.0727303103,
-1.1719384193,
-0.1612419337,
1.0826272964,
0.2314962596,
-0.3290927708,
0.0362218358,
-0.5497298837,
0.085250333,
-0.4506977797,
1.0900113583,
0.6165457964,
-0.3548667729,
0.1868746281,
-0.2491268665,
0.7744413018,
0.7462929487,
-0.8731911778,
0.2534578741,
0.547480464,
0.2843627334,
0.2481321245,
0.3267924488,
-0.1086485758,
0.5259769559,
-0.3844989538,
-0.1580679864,
-0.0624689497,
-0.129149586,
-0.0692858174,
0.3268584013,
0.2273570746,
0.1852207631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19934v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19934v1 | From the Least to the Most: Building a Plug-and-Play Visual Reasoner via Data Synthesis | 2024-06-28T14:04:10 | 2024-06-28T14:04:10 | Chuanqi Cheng, Jian Guan, Wei Wu, Rui Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We explore multi-step reasoning in vision-language models (VLMs). The problem
is challenging, as reasoning data consisting of multiple steps of visual and
language processing are barely available. To overcome the challenge, we first
introduce a least-to-most visual reasoning paradigm, which interleaves steps of
decomposing a question into sub-questions and invoking external tools for
resolving sub-questions. Based on the paradigm, we further propose a novel data
synthesis approach that can automatically create questions and multi-step
reasoning paths for an image in a bottom-up manner. Our approach divides the
complex synthesis task into a few simple sub-tasks, and (almost entirely)
relies on open-sourced models to accomplish the sub-tasks. Therefore, the
entire synthesis process is reproducible and cost-efficient, and the
synthesized data is quality guaranteed. With the approach, we construct $50$k
visual reasoning examples. Then, we develop a visual reasoner through
supervised fine-tuning, which is capable of generally enhancing the reasoning
abilities of a wide range of existing VLMs in a plug-and-play fashion.
Extensive experiments indicate that the visual reasoner can consistently and
significantly improve four VLMs on four VQA benchmarks. Our code and dataset
are available at https://github.com/steven-ccq/VisualReasoner. | [
-0.7104043365,
-0.7486436963,
0.9903303981,
-0.1107080504,
-0.2053027153,
-0.1455603391,
0.0789694488,
-0.3065402508,
-0.2878215909,
0.640481174,
-0.6611457467,
-0.5818446875,
-0.0887973234,
0.0815753341,
-0.5080236197,
0.4899757802,
-0.1452589482,
-0.0188062321,
-0.5114811659,
-0.0503503308,
-0.3852687478,
-0.2341384143,
-0.3329801857,
-0.1419277191,
0.713632822,
0.6221609712,
0.4185375571,
0.6887946725,
0.4628332853,
0.3244685233,
0.0568054914,
0.5533986092,
-0.4501127005,
0.1629460007,
-0.247110635,
-0.6216525435,
-0.1055057496,
-0.1706800163,
0.009815447,
0.426433146,
0.1809347421,
0.2856599391,
-0.4160933793,
0.9734883308,
-0.6708859801,
0.0671767667,
-0.7179412246,
0.0372673534,
-0.053211119,
-0.1288847029,
-0.6289471984,
-0.2047529817,
-0.1089969948,
-0.7149085999,
0.2184149921,
0.2169017643,
0.7415794134,
0.5083188415,
-0.469871968,
0.2808951437,
-0.8059684038,
0.7581700087,
-0.3701502681,
0.5892650485,
-0.0584505424,
0.7794400454,
-0.1759847701,
-0.7504829168,
-0.7604272366,
-0.0235196203,
0.0602674372,
0.1442173868,
-0.3001903296,
-0.1702651978,
0.690364778,
0.2146038562,
-0.8017500639,
-0.4627218246,
-0.5623039007,
-0.002706999,
0.6096527576,
0.4719488919,
0.2706281245,
-0.0716621578,
-0.3357774913,
-0.1651667356,
-0.7641533017,
0.1475735903,
-0.0575433001,
0.1090762541,
0.1657626778,
0.880910933,
-0.3626600206,
1.0693668127,
-0.0703547671,
-0.1451869309,
-0.158286944,
-0.7092787623,
-0.4109853208,
-0.214710772,
0.467808187,
0.7333775163,
0.215720579,
0.2558891773,
-0.2526361346,
0.3502025902,
0.4001048803,
-0.6914309859,
-0.566604495,
0.3335285783,
-0.3241102993,
-0.3733999133,
-0.3408095241,
-0.5276858211,
-0.5441856384,
-0.8751316667,
0.3233554661,
-0.3724286556,
0.1810507029,
0.0745788962,
-0.2100849897,
0.3706822097,
0.776444912,
-0.4244224131,
0.0849477276,
0.3749682307,
0.6300179958,
0.0072714002,
-0.2994838357,
-0.557956636,
0.0484432653,
-0.9128271341,
1.0600928068,
-0.222140938,
-0.0235968716,
-0.2094246596,
-0.0655497462,
0.2580704391,
-0.5178402662,
0.2439396828,
-0.2324010581,
0.2403193414,
-0.5551072955,
-0.3726136088,
-0.231815815,
0.268587023,
-0.6073775291,
0.8466547132,
0.0255074762,
-0.5888801813,
0.5682903528,
-0.4310657382,
-0.3878303766,
0.1080380008,
-0.2998467088,
-0.1799812615,
0.2518210709,
0.6075211763,
0.1871850044,
-0.4915756881,
0.0960185081,
-0.2628296316,
-0.3279075325,
0.0696944445,
-0.3002437651,
0.7885671258,
0.1572181433,
-0.2502468228,
0.3757023513,
-1.1775393486,
0.037313614,
0.3771302998,
-0.2134687901,
-0.1976588517,
0.0336035639,
0.1540590823,
0.4245779216,
-0.0289325081,
-0.4523403347,
0.2175043672,
-0.0745648518,
0.3801006675,
0.5698641539,
-0.0897685513,
0.3338985741,
-0.1558767706,
0.2890022695,
0.2514511943,
0.5500627756,
-0.4398986995,
-0.5622015595,
-1.1570205688,
-0.1940547377,
-0.1604640484,
0.6341919303,
-1.1410491467,
0.034438964,
0.1016282067,
-0.6128465533,
-0.4473983943,
0.1177634448,
0.2129668742,
0.7084348798,
0.6076117158,
-0.0349601544,
-0.4964897335,
-0.881370008,
-0.2352910638,
-0.1483322829,
0.0977206007,
0.2956372797,
0.5251739621,
-0.0589967072,
0.9158900976,
-0.7287446856,
-0.1459187716,
-0.3230040967,
-0.1386398375,
0.3279637098,
0.3631183505,
0.537040174,
-0.8274405003,
-0.3203629851,
0.0449698195,
-0.8490198255,
-0.0390109271,
-0.3665409684,
-0.3389335275,
0.100113228,
0.8018823266,
-0.7373410463,
0.7198674679,
0.1912092566,
-0.2757428885,
0.5804070234,
-0.1586972475,
0.0939840451,
-0.6178063154,
-0.0611646995,
0.1894199103,
-0.3629251122,
-0.7499880791,
0.2168537229,
-0.1697750241,
-0.1750722229,
-0.5878865719,
0.419251889,
-0.2845467627,
0.0738832802,
-0.1225848198,
-0.138421312,
0.2314355075,
0.5301860571,
-0.0255572908,
0.5538802743,
0.8885220885,
-0.6327004433,
0.7864103913,
0.1792405844,
-0.5020703077,
0.6588903069,
-0.9286991954,
0.0540496185,
-0.3067524731,
0.0273770094,
-1.1775854826,
-0.4066232443,
0.2846957147,
-0.1795330048,
-0.2159656286,
-0.5636243224,
-0.4369391501,
-0.4142126739,
0.0199569743,
0.27802068,
0.4453031421,
-0.699475646,
0.739569068,
0.200115487,
-0.027731156,
-0.1501825899,
-0.8778547049,
0.2685527802,
-0.0714180395,
-0.765049696,
0.0250934232,
-0.3612463176,
-0.3504086137,
-0.0699883848,
-0.1325299591,
-0.1193248406,
-0.3500720859,
0.130060032,
0.434451282,
-0.2419267893,
-0.1218094379,
0.0359429866,
-0.2825187445,
-0.0066265934,
-0.5161445141,
0.0390197001,
-0.2874409854,
-0.7167922258,
-0.0856586248,
0.2939716876,
0.9301856756,
-0.3740665317,
0.1964937747,
0.475214988,
-0.2898573875,
-0.4751746655,
-0.4699026942,
0.0775199309,
-0.4222233891,
-0.0343588889,
-0.5709601641,
-0.5882698298,
0.1926014572,
-0.12928994,
0.3555625677,
-0.029506553,
0.6650545001,
-0.202167809,
1.370426178,
0.364589721,
0.5907864571,
0.2997995019,
-0.2428552955,
0.4535675645,
-0.3870019019,
-0.3075933456,
-0.0200474449,
-0.1284720302,
-0.3733634651,
-0.8399421573,
0.5876300335,
-0.0873499215,
-0.1309186667,
0.2643708587,
-0.6988880038,
0.6444144249,
0.7664151788,
0.1278468221,
0.1899125576,
0.0009654579,
-0.1508493274,
0.0310000181,
-0.7009239197,
-0.3440477848,
0.8499073982,
-0.1169404313,
0.6733953357,
-0.0540733449,
0.6337254643,
-0.1607373506,
-0.1713842005,
-0.8967559934,
0.7728695869,
-0.1056915447,
-0.4401822984,
-0.3036820889,
-0.2183521092,
-0.4748014808,
0.6317679882,
-0.2516975105,
-0.3360513449,
0.2425018698,
0.4206476212,
-0.1082533747,
0.1405485272,
-0.6880891323,
0.9906904101,
-0.2376053184,
-0.5358655453,
0.1939300448,
-0.6916076541,
0.6477001309,
0.1529638022,
0.2743198872,
0.1200308353,
0.3476739824,
0.0433150195,
-0.7605882883,
0.5256932974,
-0.1818313301,
0.0630551875,
0.513441503,
0.1613120437,
0.3505091369,
-0.0556646548,
0.5230539441,
-0.1560923308,
-0.0927787498,
-0.4509097338,
-0.7026621103,
0.4263477325,
-0.0931603536,
-0.5811383724,
-0.1831949949,
-0.4771304131,
-0.1804737598,
0.3849814534,
0.2066150457,
0.4688908756,
0.156104818,
0.0393804647,
0.7929083705,
-0.2169537097,
0.261549294,
0.0646887198,
-0.5491854548,
-0.5252121091,
1.0555363894,
-0.134193629,
0.1163882837,
0.369338423,
0.226645261,
-0.0871415436,
-0.5151053667,
-0.8069563508,
-0.0100583145,
-1.0296634436,
0.0566803813,
-0.3460959196,
0.0324661061,
-0.0498366021,
-0.3484027684,
-0.574008882,
-0.2869437039,
0.023713138,
-0.0046367119,
0.3272830546,
0.6669098139,
0.0146245183,
-0.176952824,
-0.5422129631,
0.8444384933,
0.7359822989,
0.0516003557,
-0.193768099,
0.0553217046,
-0.0454010516,
-0.2058063745,
-0.05856831,
-0.554959774,
0.2628546655,
-0.3477199078,
0.3615725338,
0.0637821853,
-0.0579038151,
1.0307013988,
-0.7798727751,
1.0092029572,
0.4438236952,
-0.9620581865,
0.852206409,
-0.1011017337,
0.4854008853,
0.3702244759,
-0.0476826206,
-0.1132123321,
-0.4721131921,
-0.2818484902,
-1.017614007,
0.4500552416,
0.3718619347,
-0.2971333861,
0.2991516292,
-0.021985814,
0.058172226,
-0.0239534546,
-0.4961404502,
-0.2388862669,
-0.5002685189,
-0.0199045874,
0.1455515921,
0.1651579589,
-0.3201402724,
-0.6254050136,
0.5143193007,
-0.451292336,
0.056398984,
0.209635213,
-0.2287710905,
-0.0287309047,
0.0878812224,
0.5981140137,
0.9540960193,
0.1718823463,
0.3564908504,
-0.00024532,
0.0235078987,
0.1212801486,
-0.0646470785,
-0.4937447011,
0.2170339376,
0.3779675364,
1.0100175142,
-0.1087161675,
-0.6771546602,
0.5553305149,
-0.2985504866,
-0.3837618232,
-0.1418664753,
0.1114225835,
0.1808235198,
0.500764668,
0.0512462966,
0.4302446544,
0.1636042148,
-0.2720499337,
0.2319093943,
0.1435749233,
-0.2750676274,
-0.0536219478,
0.8818830252,
-0.2131577581,
0.1437182873,
0.5087128878,
0.0270380303,
-0.2693240047,
0.4461555183,
0.1221124232,
0.5391770005,
0.2183644325,
0.3669901192,
0.292437613,
0.3617420793,
-0.0167913064,
0.861892283,
-0.0216993913,
-0.4384966791,
-0.633107543,
-0.3078220189,
-0.4135237038,
0.0714427605,
-0.4367206991,
0.4560973346,
-0.4596800208,
0.0157551579,
0.2482475638,
-0.6325429678,
-0.8194333315,
0.599802494,
0.3786448836,
0.8282541037,
-0.8117120266,
0.4449702501,
0.9150924087,
-0.755030036,
-0.696613431,
-0.423930198,
0.1332336515,
-0.6671375036,
0.5196512938,
-0.0614594854,
-0.2461906523,
-0.2098288387,
-1.036749959,
-0.6122803092,
0.9118415117,
0.5313750505,
-0.6300076246,
0.160183832,
-0.0743848756,
0.5505822897,
-0.2771452963,
0.0187669806,
0.4500721395,
0.4864955246,
0.5937752128,
-0.471947968,
0.0333213918,
-0.3149537146,
0.1791179478,
0.0478863306,
-0.3577827513,
0.9147163033,
-0.6207028627,
0.0101828948,
-0.0463878475,
0.4358502924,
0.5859154463,
0.5175849199,
0.4709403813,
0.7523337007,
0.4587440193,
-0.1089952886,
1.0074290037,
-0.2056060582,
0.1510493755,
0.9692621231,
-0.1480390579,
0.4776062071,
0.7678257227,
-0.0769356862,
0.408128649,
0.4892519414,
-0.1442385614,
0.6579643488,
0.2840699852,
0.0778604224,
-0.881688416,
-0.0448523983,
0.0574011914,
0.4442611039,
0.0810848996,
-0.3207125664,
-0.1761139631,
-0.014398207,
-0.3497849703,
-0.1661389172,
-0.1735799015,
0.7184944749,
0.1451329589,
-0.5682918429,
0.748077631,
-0.3777675033,
-0.1301519573,
-0.2701045275,
-0.4803239405,
-0.2644245327,
0.1083577126,
-0.3396399617,
-0.9037661552,
0.0274989344,
0.1701858044,
-0.1585010886,
-0.4541646242,
0.8202519417,
-0.4268863499,
-0.6031118035,
-0.1065516919,
0.679020226,
0.2077743709,
0.0074215378,
-0.5946596861,
0.177556932,
0.0635626838,
-0.3150342107,
0.0822771117,
0.6716787219,
-0.1547871828,
0.7981522083,
1.0134865046,
0.24488464,
0.233139649,
0.3540866971,
0.9703902602,
-0.7625246644,
-0.3369747996,
-0.7542605996,
1.0648314953,
-0.0999618843,
-0.286986202,
0.4925850928,
0.5893073082,
0.9289526343,
-0.3525890708,
1.095300436,
0.0065067108,
0.1648490131,
-0.6281601191,
0.2446471006,
-0.9271630049,
0.0517385639,
-0.3946026564,
-0.8443230987,
-0.5159051418,
0.7019969821,
0.0443973765,
-0.422222048,
0.6664967537,
0.7605133057,
-0.2533607483,
0.0000279029,
0.5246639848,
0.1560447067,
0.6536224484,
0.668012321,
1.0364714861,
-0.320474565,
0.6292982101,
-0.3852849305,
-0.1615708023,
-0.0386548974,
-0.8796004653,
-0.8855290413,
-0.5393778682,
-0.48624143,
-0.1463748515,
-0.1953020096,
0.5970646143,
0.6724452376,
-0.7496127486,
0.0056291376,
-0.6161532998,
0.4353462756,
-0.352704674,
-0.1960546523,
-0.0299733896,
-0.2380811423,
-0.4794778526,
0.6507304907,
0.6964901686,
-0.0410277508,
-0.3328798413,
0.0966992602,
0.1096930578,
0.1630879343,
1.0472496748,
0.1224879324,
-0.936820507,
-0.1878869832,
0.0521450676,
-0.0309897829,
0.1775971651,
0.8730708957,
-0.7829126716,
0.8740484715,
0.7986877561,
0.4203713536,
0.724352479,
-0.0514038503,
0.4838728607,
-0.4313978851,
-0.2185137868,
-0.028134251,
0.5525358319,
0.3830539286,
-0.0540791005,
0.5510696769,
0.4131385088,
-0.2989194691,
-0.8804034591,
0.5159679651,
-1.1176577806,
-0.393842876,
1.0352511406,
0.0221540537,
-0.3484208882,
-0.1099869907,
-0.548997283,
0.0507978834,
-0.1219016314,
0.4022019207,
0.4999330044,
-0.6489992738,
-0.5306959152,
-0.4901297987,
0.3470103741,
-0.0578977838,
-1.0013219118,
0.0914901868,
1.0212067366,
0.21965532,
0.2556604445,
0.3555049896,
-0.0822266191,
0.3954694569,
0.3620792329,
-0.0864426196,
-0.3020713329,
-0.7669277787,
0.0364470184,
0.2632921934,
-0.1164629832,
-0.2182521671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19928v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19928v1 | Interactive Topic Models with Optimal Transport | 2024-06-28T13:57:27 | 2024-06-28T13:57:27 | Garima Dhanania, Sheshera Mysore, Chau Minh Pham, Mohit Iyyer, Hamed Zamani, Andrew McCallum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR | Topic models are widely used to analyze document collections. While they are
valuable for discovering latent topics in a corpus when analysts are unfamiliar
with the corpus, analysts also commonly start with an understanding of the
content present in a corpus. This may be through categories obtained from an
initial pass over the corpus or a desire to analyze the corpus through a
predefined set of categories derived from a high level theoretical framework
(e.g. political ideology). In these scenarios analysts desire a topic modeling
approach which incorporates their understanding of the corpus while supporting
various forms of interaction with the model. In this work, we present EdTM, as
an approach for label name supervised topic modeling. EdTM models topic
modeling as an assignment problem while leveraging LM/LLM based document-topic
affinities and using optimal transport for making globally coherent
topic-assignments. In experiments, we show the efficacy of our framework
compared to few-shot LLM classifiers, and topic models based on clustering and
LDA. Further, we show EdTM's ability to incorporate various forms of analyst
feedback and while remaining robust to noisy analyst inputs. | [
-0.539526403,
-1.0684254169,
0.9122747779,
-0.2247208059,
-0.2549183667,
0.1196154803,
-0.109644793,
-0.0996615514,
0.3473870754,
0.5773890615,
-0.4687483013,
-0.5762220621,
-0.5048141479,
-0.2414932549,
-0.6429908276,
1.0998995304,
-0.1838323623,
-0.2395182848,
-0.4162316322,
-0.0041468032,
-0.1255470961,
-0.6233477592,
-0.5893509388,
-0.1334048659,
0.6546628475,
0.2542052567,
0.5220550895,
0.8248814344,
0.7309546471,
0.3118850291,
-0.4126423299,
-0.0235007703,
-0.5400695801,
0.2983906269,
-0.6107630134,
-0.4015357196,
-0.5704697371,
-0.0066623441,
0.5542382598,
1.0679606199,
-0.3433870673,
0.0073026279,
-0.0878644958,
0.1758667827,
-0.3635453582,
-0.0767603219,
-0.6300681233,
-0.1538490057,
-0.2698362768,
-0.472027123,
-0.4687243998,
0.0045836056,
0.2366584092,
-0.7808573246,
0.11975988,
0.0931202173,
0.8082655668,
0.3407653868,
-0.8437635899,
-0.6373118758,
-0.8500905633,
0.6983599663,
-0.0617292523,
0.3365615904,
0.5399252176,
0.0589840859,
0.0894789323,
-0.7999846339,
-0.0846073031,
-0.0610239878,
-0.0713679492,
0.3487542272,
-0.2212839127,
0.0174238514,
-0.0710972846,
-0.0114181079,
-0.3216852844,
0.4157629609,
-0.2360432893,
0.0786582381,
0.5449591279,
0.4054296017,
0.0885313004,
-0.0797710717,
-0.4480509758,
0.261295408,
-0.4764439166,
-0.2891327143,
0.526073873,
0.2781551778,
-0.0400969982,
0.6501955986,
-0.1792792529,
0.9184405804,
0.2755417228,
0.1287645996,
-0.2758481801,
-0.3885776103,
0.082506977,
0.120155029,
0.257806927,
0.2215566039,
-0.3059786856,
-0.1613747925,
-0.1456015259,
-0.2062215954,
0.4508847892,
-0.9118182659,
-0.3918034136,
0.4106223583,
-0.3998786211,
-0.2702644169,
-0.104907766,
-1.0397855043,
-0.4295452535,
-0.6978846788,
0.2087220848,
-0.3345018923,
-0.3597760797,
-0.1758886874,
0.0898240507,
0.0682557747,
0.7238862514,
-0.9854208827,
0.1914039552,
0.7031623721,
0.8816922307,
-0.6104445457,
0.1920970082,
-0.5652595758,
0.5353889465,
-0.2236722857,
1.4425842762,
-0.8367903829,
-0.4694451988,
-0.0776763856,
-0.2190283686,
-0.1699660569,
-0.073847346,
0.4668850601,
-0.718337059,
0.1586198956,
-0.0374301374,
-0.9649468064,
0.0493059568,
0.3547360003,
-0.4647353888,
0.8372255564,
0.0274033565,
-1.0313731432,
0.186791569,
-1.1076443195,
-0.0185947288,
-0.1281716973,
-0.0557621159,
-0.0975098386,
-0.1782716662,
0.0877808258,
0.5029658675,
-0.0094668278,
0.7799053788,
-0.2861692607,
-0.1545175463,
0.3133882284,
-0.2872120142,
0.5361842513,
0.481564641,
0.2362449169,
0.4856002629,
-0.6728920937,
-0.4386714995,
-0.1335556656,
-0.3278972208,
-0.7292915583,
0.0889301002,
0.1280833334,
-0.216340065,
0.0880647749,
-0.2719547451,
0.4229571223,
-0.2579028308,
0.2183402926,
1.0117458105,
0.3188042641,
0.697894752,
-0.1264271438,
0.7268636227,
0.0743615776,
-0.1135277152,
-0.1233213097,
-0.242050752,
-0.7748914957,
-0.5333542228,
0.6638705134,
0.4801427424,
-0.6601415873,
0.218397364,
-0.2855552435,
-0.501517415,
-0.23119542,
-0.2763390541,
-0.320750922,
0.2834546864,
0.1569054127,
-0.1067758203,
-0.0878015384,
-0.8696181178,
-0.0553816445,
-0.2560782135,
0.0149665782,
0.1474191397,
0.339394331,
-0.1685686558,
1.2266757488,
-0.878696382,
-0.0865035802,
-0.3119587004,
0.306915611,
0.0127250301,
0.2878460586,
0.6130920649,
-0.9479483962,
-0.4802727401,
-0.0703861266,
-0.4611800909,
-0.489589721,
-0.3393495083,
-0.6536214948,
0.037142314,
0.5819491148,
-0.4178878367,
0.3115510046,
0.1000142694,
-0.4542261958,
0.0410595611,
-0.2406852245,
-0.0839680657,
-1.3184686899,
0.0861290246,
0.1020862758,
-0.3990849853,
-0.7069497705,
-0.031524606,
-0.2587969601,
-0.3567103148,
-0.490050137,
0.6960078478,
-0.3779975772,
0.0712595806,
-0.5287445188,
0.5048761368,
-0.1689584404,
0.3852368295,
0.317248702,
0.4857331514,
0.5906778574,
-0.5375597477,
0.2352574915,
0.3562286496,
-0.0655199885,
0.9382496476,
-0.422598958,
0.2141908854,
-0.2881774008,
0.1468276381,
-0.9901354313,
-0.1378061026,
0.3287140727,
0.0626760721,
0.8384898305,
-0.3210619688,
-0.3661343157,
0.0925973058,
-0.0689371154,
0.0814389661,
0.2028289139,
-0.4237690866,
0.5991835594,
0.7544699311,
-0.5270103812,
-0.2566202879,
-0.1931692511,
0.0035044611,
-0.7083961368,
-0.2610682249,
0.6490184069,
-0.2328265309,
-0.4146858454,
0.2766768932,
0.0636905581,
-0.3106138706,
0.3151564896,
0.2511664629,
0.1793012619,
0.1913429052,
0.3813367486,
0.2252688706,
-0.3515844941,
-0.0769922286,
0.0283834748,
0.4388333559,
0.020787172,
-0.5040593743,
-0.1014130041,
0.6857681274,
0.2893978059,
-0.2849184275,
0.8716909289,
0.5363410115,
-0.2139683813,
-0.1377841383,
-0.1757247448,
-0.2084418535,
-0.4378441572,
0.5182819963,
-0.5325332284,
-0.6337767839,
0.4885678589,
-0.4945964515,
0.0443914309,
0.515868187,
0.7367553711,
-0.139591828,
0.7299465537,
1.0483835936,
0.2697511911,
0.5523323417,
-0.3333616853,
0.2686088979,
-0.7831978202,
-0.1187813357,
-0.7092414498,
-0.2151738852,
-0.5403544307,
-0.3314855397,
0.2776674926,
0.2042898685,
-0.1972328722,
0.0829029679,
-0.5577477217,
0.2538957596,
0.5067856908,
-0.0233553424,
0.3281197548,
0.2201392651,
-0.1430272907,
0.0797965005,
-1.0159356594,
-0.76892519,
1.0015503168,
0.4315727651,
0.9080965519,
0.050631471,
0.7465124726,
0.4084195197,
0.8127837181,
-0.6985752583,
0.6920966506,
-0.0701024085,
-0.5981477499,
-0.248145178,
-0.2499903589,
-0.9708408713,
0.3472275734,
-0.0292964932,
-0.8529584408,
0.283547461,
-0.1202653795,
-0.1663937718,
0.4942493737,
-0.2128077745,
0.680044353,
-0.223537147,
-0.6396946311,
-0.1379653364,
-0.4645449817,
0.0846699849,
-0.4683430493,
0.3031378984,
-0.2642559707,
-0.3651946187,
0.9866338968,
-0.1049396396,
0.811185956,
-0.0866338611,
-0.2419821173,
0.259236753,
0.0272456221,
0.1799183339,
-0.0095282532,
-0.4325206578,
-0.0781990066,
0.1418698579,
-0.1358784139,
-0.4079479873,
0.7301446795,
-0.8019506335,
-0.9699434638,
-0.5145130754,
-0.6805208921,
0.0331401117,
0.0601977557,
0.0861936435,
0.4488119781,
-0.2351546735,
0.1337498128,
0.4980585277,
-0.2221952528,
0.3583839536,
0.7594511509,
-0.3607435822,
-0.0803663135,
0.8701300025,
0.4318757653,
0.0909748301,
0.6301254034,
0.0622372068,
-0.320607841,
-0.778991282,
-0.3836749196,
0.0313774385,
-1.0362776518,
-0.1504353285,
-1.0846326351,
-0.1723522246,
0.1241944358,
-0.4069344401,
-0.4512630999,
-0.4515407383,
-0.6752003431,
-0.3501184285,
0.5700584054,
0.4652457237,
-0.1937453002,
0.4042517543,
-0.5044763088,
0.2351493537,
0.0564379357,
0.246513918,
-0.2059427053,
-0.5943771005,
-0.2744551301,
-0.091612637,
-0.8101801276,
-1.2218283415,
0.402977854,
0.0246769246,
0.9090779424,
0.4200416207,
0.6747413278,
0.3535466492,
-0.2050533295,
0.6795321703,
-0.222371608,
-0.929813087,
0.7840740681,
-0.6638162136,
-0.2087058723,
0.3701851368,
0.6278374791,
-0.1659837663,
-0.7316444516,
-0.5892600417,
-1.0571873188,
0.7333865166,
0.4898318946,
0.0900379866,
-0.0657444522,
0.2821053863,
0.2220918983,
0.2878244817,
-0.6345155239,
-0.1441338807,
-0.095972009,
-0.3568174839,
0.1489414424,
-0.3010903299,
-0.1067188382,
-0.1453654021,
0.7981749773,
-0.1153981835,
0.3993775547,
0.1500551254,
-0.0112048909,
-0.0660661012,
0.3453395963,
0.5290225148,
0.974671483,
-0.5793159008,
0.2085537314,
-0.0922013521,
0.0001655797,
0.3354409933,
0.2962911427,
-0.2517954707,
0.0997211114,
0.1944685429,
0.7964721322,
-0.043248795,
-0.4187794626,
0.0633844808,
0.2562246323,
-0.0133829229,
-0.1844600439,
-0.0511150025,
0.407322824,
0.1846745908,
0.2140832245,
-0.2734516561,
0.1511445343,
-0.4777495265,
0.2948422134,
0.3349711299,
-0.418641299,
-0.1209603176,
1.0409109592,
0.4263800383,
-0.3331390023,
0.6010505557,
-0.1098406985,
-0.5877891183,
0.8799529672,
0.3855578303,
0.6662374735,
-0.2178571224,
0.4079429507,
0.1194987893,
0.1051673219,
0.2804004252,
-0.0613438115,
0.0708260909,
-0.6477797031,
-0.0226204935,
-0.6702363491,
-0.6951548457,
-0.2189332396,
-0.7353790402,
0.4046166539,
0.1191738769,
-0.3747100234,
0.2681598663,
0.0573474877,
-0.5385895967,
-0.1370952874,
-0.0219294056,
0.7276781797,
-0.7644373775,
0.8811023235,
0.9492945075,
-0.1084425151,
-0.2637706995,
0.0617073402,
-0.2734523416,
-0.2835269868,
0.6572528481,
0.0236302372,
0.2809045613,
0.3117059171,
-0.3150743246,
-0.9035077691,
1.0638859272,
0.2977520823,
-0.3313451409,
0.2805165052,
-0.0272812173,
0.5304794312,
-0.5250234604,
0.3809207976,
0.0454302467,
0.5813852549,
0.1671313643,
-0.5667166114,
-0.2029567957,
-0.1025771424,
-0.1197568253,
0.3829712272,
-0.7181411982,
0.7477920055,
0.0098418808,
-0.0563458987,
-0.1409855634,
0.6926811337,
0.1681227237,
0.6372318864,
0.4710798562,
0.3053978384,
0.8488358259,
0.0459812693,
1.1452424526,
-0.2289793044,
0.5243723989,
1.0293744802,
-0.5722036362,
0.7203737497,
0.5391121507,
-0.1658576578,
0.176299721,
1.1675323248,
-0.019553287,
0.8789120913,
0.3514348269,
-0.0653461367,
-0.2681236863,
-0.5136639476,
-0.2756718099,
0.4071482718,
0.5891951919,
-0.1781144291,
-0.4004359245,
0.3172370791,
-0.1345035732,
0.0846486986,
-0.3450064659,
0.8236489892,
0.0393876024,
-0.4071207941,
0.1396765113,
0.3748554885,
0.3292072713,
-0.5373535156,
0.1680422872,
-0.4914730191,
-0.1036624387,
0.1013135314,
-0.8973346353,
0.6296007633,
0.1311596781,
-0.135543704,
-0.551006794,
0.8432948589,
-0.6484771967,
-0.7381882071,
0.1527002454,
0.7014897466,
0.3098899722,
0.1461978108,
-0.4629554451,
0.0476513915,
-0.0630739108,
-0.7235801816,
0.5516779423,
0.4372781515,
-0.1898140013,
0.9014852047,
0.4823143482,
-0.1557291001,
-0.2202361226,
-0.2576828599,
0.9279698133,
-0.5098509789,
-0.7935811877,
-0.7769542336,
0.3395394683,
-0.1548498422,
0.1721607149,
0.5140687227,
0.5624661446,
0.3347605169,
-0.0019589567,
0.508536756,
0.2217229009,
0.5446743965,
-0.7049190998,
0.6486465335,
-0.7404153347,
0.6479745507,
-0.19235982,
-0.9980981946,
-0.0274840612,
0.6461926103,
-0.3815664947,
-0.1384122819,
0.6800515056,
0.5460484624,
-0.4667066932,
-0.0063550966,
0.0401368141,
0.0965212137,
0.563370645,
0.4198282957,
1.0248476267,
0.2507608235,
0.31484887,
-0.3440969288,
-0.0855351165,
-0.2517320812,
-1.0309303999,
-1.0664904118,
-0.601447463,
-1.0358160734,
0.0776456743,
0.0593209304,
0.8296266198,
0.7358787656,
-0.499114275,
-0.0705968067,
0.0827615783,
0.4145344794,
0.2081164271,
-0.2695221901,
0.9382558465,
0.0543396212,
-0.9083859324,
0.1147655398,
0.2960337996,
0.1743984818,
-0.1328480244,
0.3977944255,
-0.2371080965,
0.3879354,
0.4675853252,
-0.2713165581,
-0.5562271476,
-0.2773866951,
-0.0838987678,
-0.1189439073,
-0.1280658841,
0.73891294,
-0.554679215,
0.2777264416,
0.3106800318,
0.6918933392,
0.7103743553,
0.4102542698,
0.5628976226,
-0.539198935,
0.3970214725,
0.1142865717,
0.1684646904,
0.1476153731,
-0.5143477321,
0.7017604113,
0.2601566017,
-0.4497264326,
-1.0500890017,
0.0990611464,
-1.250115633,
-0.6017576456,
1.1985111237,
-0.08778283,
0.0742872357,
-0.218388021,
-0.3352623582,
0.2909243107,
-0.4196478724,
0.6086552739,
0.8336542249,
-0.2596927285,
-0.3275559843,
-0.7865854502,
0.1022254601,
0.1495580524,
-1.0210666656,
-0.0732570738,
0.3690894544,
0.1262747347,
-0.032402385,
0.7121266723,
0.364869535,
-0.5257803202,
-0.1954189837,
-0.2853501141,
-0.1015649065,
-0.4374929965,
0.0483544618,
0.4068527222,
-0.1800253093,
-0.1092397571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19898v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19898v1 | Paraphrase Types Elicit Prompt Engineering Capabilities | 2024-06-28T13:06:31 | 2024-06-28T13:06:31 | Jan Philip Wahle, Terry Ruas, Yang Xu, Bela Gipp | cs.CL | cs.CL | Much of the success of modern language models depends on finding a suitable
prompt to instruct the model. Until now, it has been largely unknown how
variations in the linguistic expression of prompts affect these models. This
study systematically and empirically evaluates which linguistic features
influence models through paraphrase types, i.e., different linguistic changes
at particular positions. We measure behavioral changes for five models across
120 tasks and six families of paraphrases (i.e., morphology, syntax, lexicon,
lexico-syntax, discourse, and others). We also control for other prompt
engineering factors (e.g., prompt length, lexical diversity, and proximity to
training data). Our results show a potential for language models to improve
tasks when their prompts are adapted in specific paraphrase types (e.g., 6.7%
median gain in Mixtral 8x7B; 5.5% in LLaMA 3 8B). In particular, changes in
morphology and lexicon, i.e., the vocabulary used, showed promise in improving
prompts. These findings contribute to developing more robust language models
capable of handling variability in linguistic expression. | [
-0.2256752849,
-0.7429916263,
0.8898122907,
0.6747484803,
0.0795467198,
-0.0670725852,
0.0250372533,
-0.2128180265,
-0.0629366189,
0.461203903,
-0.2769128084,
-0.2104185224,
-0.5381984115,
0.7580075264,
-0.2413494885,
0.8756211996,
-0.1816099584,
-0.1306821555,
-0.0323386639,
-0.0982834995,
-0.8270703554,
-0.7024160028,
-0.2147036344,
0.0030364927,
0.687405467,
0.3718344867,
1.1125953197,
0.5844094157,
0.3748368919,
0.3550490141,
-0.535697937,
-0.069865562,
-0.0263461582,
0.5906890035,
-0.2884311378,
-0.6803539395,
0.0391900875,
-0.1119180396,
0.6712446809,
0.7850372791,
-0.0929543525,
-0.051358331,
0.3533941209,
0.2403767258,
-0.5316656232,
0.4456329048,
-0.7159405351,
-0.3136643171,
-0.0814489946,
-0.265668422,
-0.3825566769,
-0.5304767489,
0.3149936199,
-0.4952602684,
0.1397764087,
0.0787447542,
0.8457114697,
0.0628368184,
-0.2707229555,
-0.54947716,
-0.2288390547,
0.7723747492,
-0.9495567679,
0.1923644394,
0.3328150213,
0.1104770377,
-0.3169304132,
-0.5114610195,
-0.1305025518,
-0.6562643051,
-0.3940788209,
-0.4161110818,
0.017380584,
0.2332827002,
0.4051734507,
0.2065402418,
-0.2757791877,
0.170086205,
-0.1080197096,
-0.2778747678,
0.1592509896,
0.4002917409,
0.7706888318,
-0.6446024179,
0.0787942559,
-0.1310943365,
-0.6281607747,
0.5091441274,
0.3099606335,
0.4642008543,
-0.0783457831,
0.5876338482,
-0.4592148662,
0.7649835348,
0.0089509031,
-0.0915355906,
0.0789844394,
-0.5510887504,
-0.0084219305,
-0.372127682,
0.4488417208,
0.1806352884,
0.1654839665,
-0.0800050274,
-0.4734007716,
-0.2401693612,
-0.052088812,
-0.5097818971,
-0.1725305766,
-0.1327942461,
-0.4617505372,
-0.258903265,
-0.1898790449,
-0.7723802924,
-0.7235102057,
-0.3753499687,
0.2055820525,
-0.5659252405,
-0.0670705661,
0.2205524147,
-0.5979042053,
0.3840527833,
0.2872701287,
-1.0510089397,
-0.0966873541,
0.6906371117,
1.0311509371,
-0.0871443972,
-0.4998389482,
-0.4670295119,
-0.3639815748,
-0.3638211787,
0.8843443394,
-1.0207899809,
-0.6170942783,
0.0810042769,
-0.0571509562,
-0.5296047926,
-0.550337553,
0.6013993621,
-0.2319362015,
0.2033732384,
-0.5518855453,
-0.3145402372,
-0.22101219,
-0.2151540369,
-0.6746914387,
0.8114002943,
0.0617399365,
-0.6573436856,
0.1547207534,
-0.5549582839,
-0.3698881865,
-0.0132349236,
-0.1349651366,
-0.0382630937,
0.6825928092,
0.3858795762,
0.3796701729,
-0.4474017322,
0.3590476811,
-0.2912899554,
-0.0634217188,
0.7589420676,
-0.151852712,
0.7402698398,
0.2088214308,
-0.2056758851,
0.074652113,
-0.6723949313,
-0.2995413542,
-0.0683565959,
-0.1739389896,
-0.4743699431,
0.0047452496,
-0.2151743323,
0.3147003949,
0.1942342967,
-0.3258388937,
-0.0377399139,
-0.2383419275,
0.6034634709,
0.6239665151,
0.4968170822,
0.5112451315,
-0.7343190908,
0.9089981914,
-0.1631898135,
0.1222509369,
-0.3472443521,
-0.8887617588,
-0.4774853885,
-0.2823927104,
0.0133609083,
0.5438168645,
-0.9151998758,
-0.1642501056,
0.0024720572,
-0.6394464374,
-0.4745877385,
0.0422528274,
0.3179761767,
0.6360426545,
0.3974718153,
0.281299293,
-0.2449232936,
-1.0474843979,
-0.8495281935,
-0.1789005846,
-0.0073379911,
0.1409321129,
0.2638524771,
0.3245196939,
0.9689556956,
-0.2309671789,
0.4712847769,
-0.6673977375,
0.4260200262,
0.289750576,
0.2432986647,
0.9633880258,
-0.6970095038,
-0.5214760303,
-0.1405408382,
-0.6491686106,
-0.6473343372,
-0.3624934256,
0.0701861605,
-0.1837938875,
0.4252477288,
-0.9199725986,
0.1301269233,
0.3777242899,
-0.4903706014,
0.6989315152,
-0.1287003011,
0.4846099317,
-0.8197308779,
-0.2264463753,
0.010326067,
0.2255290598,
-0.6356743574,
0.342870146,
0.2130509168,
-0.3109827936,
-0.6471570134,
0.6215275526,
-0.4183233976,
0.0780845955,
-0.1526724249,
-0.0906597972,
0.0849699154,
0.2733511627,
0.0422959253,
1.1178177595,
0.7464076281,
-0.923602283,
-0.0319183134,
0.3626095057,
-0.4468161464,
0.3614973724,
-0.9399622679,
0.0132434331,
-0.2487393916,
-0.0717329979,
-1.1463141441,
-0.4766109884,
-0.0711218938,
-0.3397579491,
-0.0655565709,
0.1640943587,
-0.5813453197,
-0.0301651657,
-0.4224125743,
0.025024686,
0.582193315,
-0.322483778,
0.6308774948,
-0.1696536094,
-0.7466973066,
-0.1159785986,
-0.4585012496,
0.3167858422,
-0.5225384235,
-0.5513481498,
0.1723453254,
-0.1279609501,
-0.4733240902,
-0.3511790037,
-0.0066681285,
-0.085539557,
0.4330227971,
0.0993539691,
0.2125350833,
-0.2160193026,
0.1202550083,
0.2874959111,
0.2306021154,
0.0605594218,
0.0254775863,
0.5113645196,
0.0921095982,
0.1127919257,
-0.5812642574,
0.3696430922,
0.704208672,
-0.4265938699,
0.842907548,
-0.1014633626,
-0.0666008145,
0.0289246719,
-0.4658160508,
-0.2963678539,
-0.5643241405,
0.4009883106,
-0.7297794223,
-0.8373945951,
0.6243151426,
0.2847881019,
0.2980421185,
0.4667126536,
0.3594251871,
-0.1178147271,
0.8697494268,
0.4945376515,
0.5206715465,
0.7252371907,
0.5396809578,
-0.0051343553,
-0.6530103087,
-0.0775300935,
-0.9254356027,
-0.1655604094,
-0.6192809343,
-0.1847399622,
0.285070926,
0.0906626284,
-0.0008943497,
0.6623696685,
-0.0803946853,
0.2421119213,
0.5676246285,
0.0441236608,
0.0550910719,
-0.0971157774,
-0.0429412909,
-0.2351376116,
-0.6884278655,
-0.7537438869,
0.8367063999,
0.4031927288,
0.7202019095,
0.0907175094,
0.5727695227,
0.2817206085,
-0.1123451293,
-0.3333252072,
0.8064107895,
0.0157298613,
-0.4544719756,
-0.0747561827,
-0.3322350085,
-0.8757328987,
0.0390022434,
0.0440401733,
-0.5773726106,
0.4905709624,
0.055036366,
-0.3657149374,
0.0012424939,
-0.7208533287,
0.7943537831,
-0.1715338379,
0.2348700464,
-0.0367125086,
-0.5298705697,
-0.04299495,
-0.2994777858,
0.1857233495,
-0.1105560288,
-0.2851750255,
0.6188849807,
-0.1948026419,
0.9679406285,
-0.0370935909,
-0.203466475,
0.4856622517,
0.4727215171,
0.6598291397,
-0.1206186861,
-0.4675811231,
-0.1622444242,
-0.1082747802,
-0.490450412,
-0.869268477,
0.5081518292,
-0.5917078257,
-1.0284756422,
0.0910624415,
-0.9231289029,
-0.4209995568,
-0.2997382581,
0.4334673285,
0.619931221,
0.1902951151,
0.4282106757,
0.4846340716,
-0.6435120702,
0.754788518,
0.2931658626,
0.0315365233,
-0.1382713616,
0.5556792021,
0.1652082801,
0.7752932906,
0.5166399479,
0.3438869119,
-0.168094933,
-0.5756524801,
-0.1947470158,
0.233571589,
-1.1418212652,
-0.0529695526,
-0.95102036,
0.1795137078,
-0.6613456607,
-0.3116377592,
0.0858736634,
-0.6521148682,
-0.482943505,
-0.298276037,
0.770838201,
0.8271667957,
0.3018521369,
0.4971975684,
-0.739525497,
0.1067954525,
0.3444462121,
-0.1022374779,
-0.1443968713,
-1.0519355536,
0.1542980224,
-0.1062753946,
-0.1655712277,
-1.2702845335,
0.3287003338,
0.3093341589,
0.7731232643,
-0.2427291274,
-0.0464611053,
0.2805632949,
-0.3896322548,
1.2390631437,
-0.0036274956,
-1.0222239494,
0.5766416788,
-0.5122130513,
0.4489996135,
0.3363216817,
0.3699355423,
-0.4685272872,
-0.8012627959,
-0.3195605874,
-0.4705468416,
0.4556617737,
0.2391702384,
0.5235203505,
-0.3357577622,
0.5023396015,
0.4249206781,
0.1170342341,
-0.6557528973,
0.0102128601,
-0.2321883142,
-0.2846822441,
0.1465934962,
-0.32237041,
0.3936292827,
0.1800730228,
0.2715295553,
0.1812982112,
0.0143531524,
0.0793747529,
-0.3114021719,
0.5223631263,
0.6794726849,
0.7025225163,
0.6606212854,
0.1449431628,
0.0657254681,
0.2874186635,
-0.1544142962,
0.2393006235,
-0.0025190501,
-0.4389136732,
0.5079445243,
0.490314126,
1.1205582619,
0.5435658097,
-0.5461605787,
0.0477045737,
0.2641608715,
0.0603383444,
0.5815856457,
0.2887807488,
-0.1626383811,
0.2296135128,
0.179456532,
0.0724591315,
0.3469203711,
-0.5678646564,
-0.0753741786,
0.0128378449,
-0.0181842055,
-0.6431724429,
0.6138325334,
0.173910901,
-0.5776241422,
0.3270997107,
-0.2222765982,
-0.3032342792,
0.6892283559,
0.5650277734,
1.0661724806,
-0.4911746681,
0.4187504053,
0.1293742806,
0.2678796053,
-0.198972851,
0.2198630422,
0.121385701,
-0.3691948056,
-0.2466270179,
-0.6102845073,
-0.3741887808,
-0.0545957983,
-0.3719389141,
0.5085377693,
-0.3581123054,
-0.1949161887,
-0.0905899554,
-0.8713242412,
-0.8112237453,
-0.0100207925,
0.0206542369,
0.7743346095,
-0.798715353,
0.5092074871,
0.9719156027,
-0.6544248462,
-0.903637588,
0.0391365997,
-0.1520490348,
-0.6394268274,
0.8996124268,
0.2568075359,
0.1507576406,
-0.0042406362,
-0.3158939779,
-1.1121354103,
0.6701664925,
0.4540864825,
-0.3622325063,
-0.5731306672,
0.2021087259,
0.4719139636,
-0.460935086,
0.2283875644,
0.53230685,
0.26464203,
-0.3333211541,
-1.2919644117,
0.076385349,
-0.015137,
0.540948391,
0.0968848094,
-0.0856953785,
1.2371786833,
-0.1751694828,
-0.1573372334,
0.4178247154,
0.6458486319,
0.4018525481,
-0.1281185001,
0.3586846292,
-0.119631432,
0.4106443822,
0.1124646515,
1.3580012321,
-0.4313211143,
0.1520627737,
1.0723458529,
-0.1654599458,
0.6298328042,
0.4860919714,
0.0299807396,
0.6497795582,
0.665420413,
0.3254307806,
0.5328325629,
-0.1048439369,
-0.1006163731,
-0.2876213789,
-0.2969397604,
-0.2298876792,
0.2364681065,
0.4219880998,
-0.5435885191,
-0.3877341449,
0.4336684048,
0.0628130138,
0.2603821754,
-0.3951933086,
0.5115532279,
0.0690272152,
-1.0022919178,
0.6592020988,
-0.0269816108,
0.6402968764,
-0.5606742501,
0.0635146052,
-0.4373858273,
-0.3398692906,
-0.0066320361,
-0.8308190703,
0.1946971864,
0.0632795691,
-0.0208184421,
-0.3702113032,
0.4973536432,
-0.067328684,
-0.3408349752,
0.0964085534,
0.3738523722,
0.0005350013,
-0.2455627471,
-0.6682065725,
0.0442103744,
0.042762477,
-0.3126768172,
0.2003773004,
0.7225528359,
-0.2316283584,
0.6404457688,
0.3615643978,
0.0605351068,
0.5092087984,
-0.0710429698,
0.5610162616,
-0.6712043285,
-0.5560562015,
-0.8511747718,
0.508757472,
-0.027599005,
-0.6367433071,
0.9078308344,
0.1135110557,
0.2965769172,
-0.5533053875,
0.7386418581,
-0.1121339053,
0.487559557,
-0.6548710465,
0.2105036527,
-0.2144812495,
0.2024346739,
-0.3216082752,
-1.022924304,
-0.0675549209,
0.2653413713,
-0.5736370683,
-0.008041,
0.7864584923,
0.906024754,
0.2068920732,
-0.0129607385,
0.2582868636,
0.1111420542,
0.4836856127,
0.1575096995,
1.0193220377,
-0.1036847606,
0.4740409851,
-0.151986897,
-0.13079229,
-0.1322211623,
-0.8430293202,
-0.8891377449,
-0.6588830948,
-0.5865987539,
-0.1969044209,
0.0492361486,
0.8918341398,
0.1384024471,
-0.7737520933,
-0.1824610233,
-0.3268439174,
0.0620063134,
-0.1185253039,
-0.2503256202,
0.0994819477,
-1.1290919781,
-0.5321754813,
0.4549289942,
0.41559726,
0.1969296932,
0.1549785584,
0.305085212,
-0.1742020845,
0.5229049921,
0.4718507528,
0.2144765556,
-1.0402754545,
-0.5351338387,
0.5730994344,
-0.2521622777,
-0.0022806658,
1.0298513174,
-0.4354623556,
0.1619794071,
0.7534481883,
0.6979417801,
-0.4574843645,
-0.1265922934,
0.8187329173,
-0.6606928706,
0.2160983384,
0.1508780569,
0.6462786794,
0.4600923061,
-0.2721598744,
0.0568847135,
0.3145779073,
-0.5424332619,
-0.6717689633,
0.3590230048,
-0.4991877079,
-0.4005154073,
1.5663710833,
-0.1816847026,
0.0338239372,
-0.2259118557,
-0.3551951349,
-0.0799125805,
-0.306311965,
0.6919751763,
1.0708134174,
-0.0615517683,
-0.3304162025,
-0.5907993913,
0.6226628423,
0.7947500348,
-0.6713159084,
0.1467553675,
0.379603833,
0.4255459905,
0.012802721,
0.106609121,
0.0137502272,
0.4503010809,
-0.2702767551,
-0.2089822739,
0.2414829731,
-0.1127977073,
-0.4236200154,
0.0878173709,
0.4641581476,
-0.0488333665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19892v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19892v1 | Untangling the Unrestricted Web: Automatic Identification of Multilingual Registers | 2024-06-28T13:00:30 | 2024-06-28T13:00:30 | Erik Henriksson, Amanda Myntti, Anni Eskelinen, Selcen Erten-Johansson, Saara Hellström, Veronika Laippala | cs.CL | cs.CL | This article explores deep learning models for the automatic identification
of registers - text varieties such as news reports and discussion forums - in
web-based datasets across 16 languages. Web register (or genre) identification
would provide a robust solution for understanding the content of web-scale
datasets, which have become crucial in computational linguistics. Despite
recent advances, the potential of register classifiers on the noisy web remains
largely unexplored, particularly in multilingual settings and when targeting
the entire unrestricted web. We experiment with a range of deep learning models
using the new Multilingual CORE corpora, which includes 16 languages annotated
using a detailed, hierarchical taxonomy of 25 registers designed to cover the
entire unrestricted web. Our models achieve state-of-the-art results, showing
that a detailed taxonomy in a hierarchical multi-label setting can yield
competitive classification performance. However, all models hit a glass ceiling
at approximately 80% F1 score, which we attribute to the non-discrete nature of
web registers and the inherent uncertainty in labeling some documents. By
pruning ambiguous examples, we improve model performance to over 90%. Finally,
multilingual models outperform monolingual ones, particularly benefiting
languages with fewer training examples and smaller registers. Although a
zero-shot setting decreases performance by an average of 7%, these drops are
not linked to specific registers or languages. Instead, registers show
surprising similarity across languages. | [
-0.4046032429,
-0.3985894918,
0.1066320613,
-0.0342060104,
-0.2832091451,
0.4212519228,
-0.5451291203,
-0.8573048711,
-0.2126219273,
0.2546804249,
-0.4231213033,
-0.5819487572,
-0.616538465,
0.1597191393,
-0.5498052239,
0.8136150837,
0.069156535,
0.016601285,
-0.1855757535,
-0.1448407322,
0.042364195,
-0.7273644805,
-0.4571402967,
0.0122213373,
0.6054072976,
0.1055971831,
0.4510545731,
0.9911804199,
0.4176261127,
0.3959669471,
0.1340784281,
0.2139783502,
-0.2960859239,
-0.0358659253,
0.0995896906,
-0.263391614,
-0.1300111264,
0.1184761748,
0.7484496832,
0.9619536996,
-0.1192216277,
0.1615406126,
0.1864247024,
0.5121717453,
-0.7431753874,
0.2588400245,
-0.6417526603,
-0.009444396,
-0.3504730463,
0.0648797527,
-0.5536302924,
-0.137545079,
-0.0647201389,
-0.6819702387,
0.5403666496,
-0.2421628684,
0.9985466003,
0.1306198388,
-0.8057521582,
-0.4387861192,
-0.8048186302,
0.7558495402,
-0.5224162936,
0.8312852383,
0.4603584707,
0.1860715151,
0.124180153,
-0.6836107373,
-0.3284971714,
0.033598721,
0.0433843993,
-0.0261303373,
-0.6689509749,
-0.1756348014,
-0.1538049728,
0.3043448329,
-0.7263259292,
0.7478709221,
-0.5236030817,
-0.2754268646,
0.6933594942,
-0.0663416758,
0.2855673134,
0.1864075363,
-0.3429656327,
0.0252924394,
-0.4354777336,
0.2479357868,
0.5977371931,
0.7637010813,
-0.1075726524,
0.217705518,
-0.1997882724,
0.9993162751,
-0.0850253254,
-0.3239763379,
0.2348470539,
0.2238283902,
-0.2123441845,
-0.1488913596,
0.9431837201,
0.2438081801,
0.1169070527,
-0.3853494227,
-0.2515799999,
0.1575848013,
0.1349091977,
-0.6474781632,
-0.30911538,
0.0799449682,
-0.470903337,
-0.1599528641,
0.0558021851,
-0.6766534448,
-0.694155395,
-0.3955224156,
0.0676769912,
-0.2883159518,
-0.5462188125,
-0.0193634108,
-0.1878172606,
0.0129893301,
0.3028945327,
-0.7263761163,
0.2456067055,
0.624622643,
0.4588626623,
-0.368548125,
-0.2185218334,
0.0811641812,
0.0413161591,
-0.5306268334,
0.5315986872,
-0.6022222638,
-0.0490036495,
0.3671264648,
0.271352917,
0.0551418699,
-0.4903974533,
0.1951329559,
-0.9777796268,
-0.0269448906,
0.2547776997,
-0.6986399293,
-0.5247904062,
0.2148942947,
-1.0362454653,
0.5096035004,
-0.0105933473,
-0.293466866,
0.4885517359,
-0.0723207295,
-0.537558794,
0.1703826487,
-0.1240683347,
-0.0013231571,
0.0393081494,
-0.170751214,
0.5310438275,
-0.3059578538,
0.2224899232,
-0.3807286024,
0.0847422853,
0.5479605198,
-0.794483304,
0.9802392125,
0.4206934571,
-0.0068157497,
-0.0545342974,
-1.1366455555,
0.056396585,
-0.0656936392,
-0.414257884,
-0.4057078958,
-0.18993783,
0.2593010962,
0.1184803993,
0.3655399382,
-0.5176801085,
0.0789570361,
-0.1897860914,
0.4603460729,
0.7175294757,
-0.2019213438,
0.4182753265,
-0.0653934702,
0.6627877951,
0.0957951024,
0.114093557,
0.1087962687,
-0.4247107506,
-0.8324308395,
-0.4694286287,
0.8752753735,
0.609677434,
-0.4166808426,
0.2840301096,
-0.2199402899,
-0.6499094963,
-0.7274990082,
0.3284027278,
0.4414587915,
0.2797886729,
0.2694553435,
-0.5032914281,
-0.6851679683,
-0.9632697701,
-0.1558773518,
-0.0954312757,
-0.0420762338,
0.1487691849,
0.1326667666,
-0.3458528221,
0.6792257428,
-0.1239464954,
-0.4184171557,
-0.0946101323,
0.2408604026,
0.1064936593,
0.4871380329,
0.2599223256,
-1.1033629179,
-0.5147721767,
0.1601028889,
-0.5756196976,
0.16543217,
-0.0614536852,
0.2965560555,
0.3659873605,
0.4554440975,
-0.4010332823,
0.43468678,
0.5465506911,
0.1086463779,
0.159768343,
-0.1473211795,
-0.2643015981,
-0.8417143822,
0.0269972365,
0.249636218,
-0.0338866636,
-0.5772693157,
0.3708910644,
0.2752725184,
-0.2208286226,
-0.471532464,
0.551360786,
-0.7572364211,
0.264611423,
-0.2628909945,
0.042780824,
0.0369528234,
0.5053305626,
0.1456671357,
0.3546033204,
0.6194323897,
-0.859839201,
0.3142615557,
0.0137710385,
-0.6271537542,
-0.1032511964,
0.028051734,
0.0627800375,
-0.2172957957,
0.1388441473,
-1.0949884653,
-0.380753845,
-0.0247410182,
-0.6563912034,
0.6152341366,
-0.5255545378,
-0.2207698077,
-0.2373140305,
0.0976331085,
0.4983637929,
0.412037611,
-0.4398679435,
0.5953328609,
0.8528366685,
0.1541032642,
-0.9279494882,
-0.7164258957,
0.0940892249,
-0.1374210417,
-0.0194362178,
0.2284104526,
-0.0844719857,
-0.3509954512,
0.0834682137,
0.0630664527,
-0.9970974326,
0.4392646551,
0.1822651625,
0.0902190357,
-0.2272724807,
0.304582268,
-0.086320512,
-0.0804943368,
-0.14552854,
-0.364246279,
0.4099085927,
-0.1227087975,
-0.3199523985,
-0.6383780837,
0.621214509,
0.5081749558,
-0.5489035845,
0.5463094115,
0.650318563,
-0.5725423694,
-0.3376402259,
-0.5000432134,
0.3193220496,
-0.4860182703,
0.2413752377,
-0.5997758508,
-1.0081822872,
0.5896613598,
-0.0608280115,
-0.0166225713,
0.7868621349,
0.4769705534,
-0.007513986,
1.0828713179,
1.0917853117,
-0.1892811954,
0.0228977408,
-0.1478274465,
0.241738528,
-0.3658558428,
-0.2483650744,
-0.6864017248,
-0.3389014304,
-1.0030851364,
-0.2625706494,
0.0241409522,
0.380623579,
-0.1251496673,
0.288451463,
-0.649410069,
0.5381277204,
0.6256648898,
-0.0425194427,
0.3748654425,
-0.1267775446,
-0.044755701,
0.1402459443,
-0.6300026774,
-0.420081228,
1.175350666,
0.1163768694,
0.8240441084,
0.5411176085,
0.5924723148,
0.3293038607,
0.3535864949,
-0.8433115482,
0.2014808506,
-0.5404084325,
-0.8003334403,
-0.1650990546,
-0.432633549,
-1.1977057457,
0.0756081566,
-0.108666189,
-0.6422547698,
0.6195471883,
0.0533111282,
-0.4359989166,
0.3906005621,
-0.6302059889,
0.7866165042,
-0.3461036682,
-0.0706216767,
-0.0312470552,
-0.5553301573,
0.32075876,
-0.3881848752,
0.5285238028,
-0.1834815741,
-0.2414437532,
0.620524168,
0.0547261946,
1.3600797653,
0.0823307633,
-0.2812718749,
0.1717255861,
0.2086494267,
0.097758539,
-0.0744251907,
0.0296305623,
0.5213585496,
0.0627040192,
-0.2801308334,
-0.3297308981,
0.6447893381,
-1.0605684519,
-0.4091175497,
-0.3619538248,
-0.2609518766,
-0.3214277327,
0.4750543535,
0.4190025628,
0.5516827703,
-0.4537023902,
0.2954548001,
0.63885957,
-0.1811533421,
0.6051921248,
1.178473115,
-0.097770229,
-0.1925675273,
1.036565423,
0.238994658,
-0.1016516685,
0.6673269868,
0.0433426127,
-0.4015386701,
-0.5750571489,
-0.7508386374,
-0.1072727814,
-0.9336602688,
-0.3948507309,
-0.6861605644,
-0.2447737157,
-0.6363041401,
0.1509491056,
-0.3081426024,
-0.707832098,
-0.5163099766,
-0.10092327,
0.1036523879,
0.7845888138,
-0.3802108765,
0.0523868278,
-0.8213182688,
0.2282810211,
0.3528904915,
0.4881634116,
0.3254848719,
-0.4536562264,
-0.2860358953,
-0.0598364584,
0.0344858468,
-0.8827025294,
0.3718372583,
0.404224515,
0.5654506683,
0.7960122824,
0.2930268943,
0.592002213,
-0.7616537213,
0.6273751259,
0.2272546589,
-0.8279563785,
0.0271179006,
-0.3786631525,
0.1357225478,
0.4014977515,
0.9896512628,
-0.6453697681,
-0.5141119957,
-0.500244081,
-0.990214467,
0.3523760438,
-0.4100371599,
0.3579812348,
-0.1739882976,
0.1888989657,
0.3591065407,
0.1731944531,
-0.9312202334,
-0.1971975565,
-0.0929483175,
-0.2603228092,
-0.1799145192,
-0.2086912841,
-0.2207084447,
-0.3668472767,
0.7302713394,
-0.1611931026,
0.0917861611,
-0.222091794,
-0.4546755254,
-0.1899204999,
0.3053600788,
0.5621767044,
0.9606022835,
0.1682656407,
0.3260769248,
-0.158813253,
-0.1613419056,
0.192078799,
0.3205996752,
-0.0479105636,
0.0837219581,
0.5991766453,
0.8169129491,
-0.0919529647,
-0.725238204,
0.4881835282,
-0.1233409196,
-0.0397718176,
-0.5158261061,
-0.0428276621,
-0.1135125905,
0.1963177472,
0.5090832114,
0.0315973945,
0.2563875616,
-0.3733409643,
0.3764719963,
0.5285445452,
-0.7096543908,
-0.2394847274,
0.6016125083,
0.1670191735,
-0.4186407328,
0.6984046102,
-0.2647524476,
-0.5449262261,
0.5863523483,
0.5457066298,
0.8867998719,
-0.3639245927,
0.2241548896,
0.2603686154,
0.4308131635,
0.2798984647,
-0.0599554367,
-0.1293482631,
-0.9967808723,
-0.3852721751,
-0.8151952624,
-0.3451134861,
0.4476622641,
-0.8533152938,
-0.0751587078,
-0.4344618618,
-0.0742684975,
0.3802988231,
-0.029123405,
-0.7473451495,
0.3533724844,
0.6049051285,
0.8726465702,
-0.9081434608,
1.0035573244,
0.5590223074,
-0.3558077216,
-0.7689563632,
-0.3449163735,
0.3422864974,
-0.7289286852,
0.5284754634,
0.3040980399,
-0.017461108,
0.1446368992,
-0.2690445781,
-0.8520357013,
0.450202167,
0.1948008835,
-0.6575909257,
0.2353645861,
0.3016501665,
0.50927037,
-0.2610230148,
0.0598259978,
0.0967763439,
0.391522944,
-0.3480383158,
-0.9256517291,
-0.1907858402,
-0.495069176,
-0.1960755587,
0.3181174695,
-0.6910614371,
0.9732244611,
0.063147068,
-0.4453023672,
0.2411982119,
0.656586647,
-0.3843033314,
0.0136274202,
0.5970295072,
0.6403459907,
1.2514815331,
0.089180693,
0.8273621202,
-0.4556726813,
0.2581736445,
1.0985838175,
-0.3011416197,
0.948577404,
-0.025822673,
-0.0043479051,
0.6986785531,
0.873700738,
-0.2277089506,
0.4158646762,
0.1729392111,
-0.5166506171,
-0.4679947197,
-0.2698963284,
-0.2690228522,
0.8387491107,
0.2311637402,
-0.4224357903,
-0.3036379218,
0.2965655923,
0.029440945,
0.0496503487,
-0.1907437295,
0.9854785204,
-0.0665978417,
-0.500282526,
0.6771991849,
0.3539688289,
0.4159806073,
-0.8031282425,
0.2007363886,
-0.0745362267,
0.4011778235,
-0.0532719009,
-0.4626647234,
-0.0885805413,
0.1917910576,
-0.5186899304,
-0.346967876,
0.6160809398,
-0.5959663391,
-0.686799407,
0.4297808409,
0.602535367,
0.2268683761,
0.1112298369,
-0.7231225371,
0.0219374318,
0.0204956904,
-0.0902105793,
0.5386015773,
0.7957776785,
-0.2618671656,
0.5475657582,
0.7570830584,
-0.2650478482,
0.2128369212,
0.1381728053,
0.7016239762,
-0.5228233933,
-0.5261552334,
-0.7674645185,
0.2818991244,
0.0695331469,
-0.4767496288,
0.9277322888,
0.9178608656,
1.1556848288,
-0.0572677068,
0.9381779432,
0.0483486652,
0.5690994263,
-0.2914805114,
1.0439293385,
-0.7948583961,
-0.0767080188,
0.1251383424,
-0.4505285323,
-0.5225362182,
0.2562910616,
0.3184973001,
-0.2476186901,
0.4528293312,
0.5909139514,
-0.1294078976,
-0.1382102072,
0.2848513126,
0.1354507059,
0.0291016046,
0.5148248076,
0.8991402984,
-0.1385601759,
0.6505739689,
-0.6301046014,
-0.3403662741,
0.1823741347,
-0.7609333396,
-0.7923628092,
-0.88669312,
-0.3939687908,
-0.1698497087,
-0.2305272967,
0.5606623292,
0.8271238208,
-1.0471101999,
-0.5248525143,
0.258528471,
0.0263207462,
-0.2738086879,
-0.1768564433,
0.3834061623,
-0.4107446373,
-0.7341118455,
0.6745995879,
-0.0742295086,
0.0223401748,
-0.3122402132,
0.2043531388,
-0.3185175657,
-0.1199156418,
0.36469239,
0.5940393806,
-0.8400969505,
0.0448345281,
-0.1117839515,
-0.1311897784,
0.0039467006,
0.8248339891,
-0.8300507665,
0.5130906105,
0.1902929544,
0.8107942939,
0.324454695,
-0.2045126259,
0.4067061543,
-1.0150877237,
0.4386739731,
0.4382405281,
0.180969283,
0.3096573651,
-0.3280139267,
0.4275810421,
0.2034790963,
-0.1625449657,
-0.909717381,
0.2859406173,
-0.8419286013,
-0.9184302688,
0.9532927871,
-0.2260457873,
-0.2513630092,
-0.3088252246,
0.5582853556,
0.4889371395,
-0.0902256146,
0.6214722991,
0.7578437924,
0.209972471,
-0.2808599174,
-0.5753396749,
0.6717946529,
-0.06493292,
-0.3089235127,
0.0926515236,
0.6560900807,
0.0788859352,
0.3853285015,
0.5200033188,
0.0976124406,
0.1431754827,
-0.3355460763,
0.2173216194,
0.0127614969,
-0.567971468,
-0.607352078,
0.4553114176,
-0.0403239951,
-0.1151102409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19884v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19884v1 | Investigating the Timescales of Language Processing with EEG and Language Models | 2024-06-28T12:49:27 | 2024-06-28T12:49:27 | Davide Turco, Conor Houghton | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-bio.NC | This study explores the temporal dynamics of language processing by examining
the alignment between word representations from a pre-trained transformer-based
language model, and EEG data. Using a Temporal Response Function (TRF) model,
we investigate how neural activity corresponds to model representations across
different layers, revealing insights into the interaction between artificial
language models and brain responses during language comprehension. Our analysis
reveals patterns in TRFs from distinct layers, highlighting varying
contributions to lexical and compositional processing. Additionally, we used
linear discriminant analysis (LDA) to isolate part-of-speech (POS)
representations, offering insights into their influence on neural responses and
the underlying mechanisms of syntactic processing. These findings underscore
EEG's utility for probing language processing dynamics with high temporal
resolution. By bridging artificial language models and neural activity, this
study advances our understanding of their interaction at fine timescales. | [
-0.188111335,
-1.2874873877,
0.7255941033,
0.4316550791,
-0.0444979444,
0.0754544362,
-0.0932081714,
-0.6831698418,
0.2579210401,
0.1969576031,
-0.5278174877,
-0.1252264678,
-0.3606410921,
0.0215205103,
-0.5894153714,
0.2424865067,
-0.0282529257,
-0.024478063,
-0.0506643169,
-0.2046401352,
-0.4965001345,
-0.6294909716,
-0.8967131972,
-0.7371747494,
0.5626326203,
-0.3470828235,
0.4497152567,
0.6309111714,
0.132875517,
0.298597157,
-0.198580727,
-0.4304953814,
-0.0708527863,
0.2065944672,
-0.0823949501,
-0.6236762404,
-0.4932241142,
-0.0473285727,
0.6781505942,
1.0547955036,
-0.3825754523,
0.2072125822,
0.1230044067,
0.3123349547,
-0.4561983645,
0.3062958717,
-0.4751235545,
0.1949811131,
-0.3413673937,
-0.2875216305,
-0.6544455886,
-0.1277107447,
0.3949856162,
-0.3804297745,
0.1201988161,
-0.0618508123,
0.7716702223,
0.0835920945,
-0.4592279196,
0.1578131914,
-0.8839945197,
0.6173616052,
-0.6864143014,
0.6624500751,
0.2298393101,
0.0444469973,
0.0749738514,
-0.8309011459,
-0.9419053793,
-0.1808883995,
-0.2857466042,
-0.1113637984,
-0.0805613473,
0.1032081246,
0.395804137,
0.0258735381,
-0.7519188523,
0.1205070168,
-0.2130243331,
-0.1660713404,
0.2135905027,
0.117637977,
0.5242079496,
-0.0410136469,
-0.1840499789,
-0.2279280126,
-0.2273308337,
0.1589461267,
0.2253552824,
-0.0518688634,
-0.0785882324,
0.6677650809,
0.4530836046,
0.8747707605,
0.0504101403,
0.1050232798,
0.2299909145,
-0.25213328,
-0.3106404245,
0.3480591774,
0.7696382403,
0.1638861895,
0.1481597424,
-0.2108317018,
-0.2196726799,
0.2067653388,
0.2409536093,
-0.469505161,
0.1354220808,
0.1492059678,
-0.4283150434,
0.044339709,
-0.2814749181,
-0.6957201958,
-0.0710288584,
-0.4921267927,
0.3685649037,
-0.4786072075,
-0.3788097203,
0.3013347983,
-0.1411598176,
0.4432623982,
-0.1922474504,
-0.887665689,
0.3887819052,
0.3728809059,
0.6480730772,
0.0058543617,
-0.4509010017,
-0.3224655986,
0.455988735,
-0.3394371569,
0.7199599743,
-0.6617827415,
-0.2075011581,
0.1140336394,
0.0936105922,
-0.4520528316,
-0.3061612248,
0.1694573164,
-0.9007261395,
0.2188187838,
-0.0958053395,
-0.394259125,
-0.1235040724,
-0.1183956191,
-0.9449425936,
0.9454759359,
0.0781340748,
-0.6925594211,
0.1139111444,
-0.7217866778,
-0.5266253948,
0.0399299264,
-0.1751267016,
0.0228801817,
0.3654716015,
0.2693725824,
0.3135659993,
-0.0064197518,
0.1367089748,
-0.0930402875,
-0.2581103742,
0.5171251297,
-0.2909027934,
0.8397413492,
0.136491999,
-0.1964061856,
-0.1356340796,
-0.7574663758,
0.0546330512,
0.2806223929,
-0.061879091,
-0.3403943479,
0.4561852217,
0.0219000913,
0.1589835882,
0.3765736222,
-0.5519693494,
-0.0794456005,
-0.4197065532,
0.7854849696,
0.4316051602,
0.0938590243,
0.5160219669,
0.0511671193,
0.4679240286,
0.1763945669,
-0.085026212,
-0.3192349374,
-0.1706510931,
-0.5462305546,
0.4657288492,
0.2972204387,
0.4610990882,
-0.6350072026,
0.3984628022,
-0.4144104719,
-0.0815878138,
-0.6323723197,
-0.3313514888,
-0.0091180326,
0.4542163014,
0.3546391129,
-0.2946846783,
-0.3586637378,
-0.9248815775,
-0.1129042953,
-0.40457955,
-0.3054289222,
-0.0953475684,
0.0857017934,
-0.0486079119,
1.0085602999,
-0.3848426044,
-0.0158089083,
-0.2773100138,
0.6724599004,
-0.0878112689,
0.144434765,
0.9304302931,
-0.5433498621,
-0.16384238,
0.1282866299,
-0.5269793272,
-0.360177815,
-0.1469134688,
0.1515459716,
0.2377108932,
0.8020316958,
-0.4476596415,
0.3631961048,
0.6497680545,
-0.6708261967,
0.2554558814,
-0.2402950376,
0.3021299541,
-0.6253636479,
0.1297408938,
-0.0858303085,
-0.1533306837,
-0.6736451983,
-0.186423555,
0.1614138931,
-0.1402393728,
-0.4242320955,
0.3407644928,
-0.5158488154,
-0.1029653624,
-0.3165572584,
0.3393191099,
-0.0073819179,
0.5588530898,
0.1775305867,
0.7156510949,
0.4506449699,
-0.4046254158,
-0.0841166154,
-0.1407782137,
-0.3129450679,
0.2879167199,
-1.0057858229,
0.3426167667,
-0.2482529432,
-0.1741047502,
-0.9746308327,
0.0526487604,
-0.2885483503,
-0.3668147624,
0.3645178676,
0.1048117131,
-0.6787089109,
-0.2118655145,
0.1446411908,
0.7675674558,
0.4441330433,
-0.1770898849,
1.0838553905,
0.596724987,
-0.1959853023,
-0.230354473,
-0.9331228137,
-0.1073150188,
-0.0356576964,
-0.6302146316,
0.5823917389,
0.0996664613,
-0.4355570376,
-0.1034852117,
-0.1732727438,
-0.0607932061,
-0.0150100244,
-0.0241659805,
0.1487126797,
-0.3007721007,
-0.1998427361,
-0.0326565951,
0.2563257813,
0.4707883596,
-0.1224933639,
0.9612516165,
0.2162879407,
-0.2028669268,
-0.3811631203,
0.3340726793,
0.7246234417,
-0.5545320511,
0.9905555844,
0.6109057665,
-0.6063619852,
-0.0530848168,
-0.4814584255,
-0.1526104808,
-0.4140666425,
0.3884149194,
-0.2912466824,
-0.7712524533,
0.8040229678,
0.5640618801,
-0.2028929442,
0.3653979301,
0.3709021211,
-0.2461140007,
1.1389228106,
0.5638507605,
0.0620930083,
0.9553923607,
0.0222769547,
0.4057489634,
-0.8544305563,
-0.3175447583,
-0.3768219054,
-0.5506403446,
-0.2461797148,
-0.1286453307,
0.1533533931,
0.0750057101,
0.0778204799,
0.4265464544,
-0.1914220601,
0.5908133984,
0.1206276417,
0.0357595123,
-0.0366286226,
-0.1299889237,
-0.2757191956,
-0.0596234836,
-0.4367200136,
-0.3194367886,
0.7408801317,
0.424148947,
0.6067470312,
-0.1804590672,
0.0827825442,
0.2313403636,
-0.2747493386,
-0.4848812521,
0.7615492344,
-0.1216225475,
-0.4087897539,
-0.2042161673,
-0.0652733967,
-1.1224128008,
0.0599245317,
0.0021294958,
-1.1035877466,
0.1488483846,
-0.1137212962,
-0.4995517433,
0.2543190718,
-1.1169098616,
0.743625164,
-0.1069458127,
-0.3100639582,
-0.574021697,
-0.4942064881,
-0.017133493,
0.1441067904,
-0.061820142,
0.0187513139,
0.1716253012,
0.9032771587,
-0.140969038,
0.6611841917,
-0.0692267492,
-0.2830335498,
0.2696564198,
0.4382613599,
0.1333716363,
-0.1587521136,
0.2062073499,
0.3163348138,
0.2990824282,
-0.3450417519,
-0.571606636,
0.8126040697,
-0.6927523613,
-0.5526401997,
-0.4606732726,
-0.6482938528,
-0.0446679294,
0.0349647142,
0.1222910136,
0.5112169385,
-0.1944645792,
-0.0549311861,
0.7172775865,
-0.0365889184,
0.9959995747,
0.353317827,
-0.3671643734,
-0.0040794648,
0.409032464,
0.3360669613,
0.1460091472,
0.7788181901,
-0.2041535676,
-0.3179985285,
-0.5044571757,
0.1338949502,
0.4322120845,
-0.3355390429,
0.3220336735,
-0.5694233179,
-0.3408463001,
-0.453009516,
0.15355964,
-0.1395261288,
-0.3375785351,
-0.2534123957,
-0.0819816366,
-0.0472665913,
0.7284636497,
0.3552108705,
0.5131994486,
-0.7634167075,
0.3075966537,
0.353338629,
0.3716760278,
0.1125506237,
-0.2915630937,
-0.3021422327,
0.0002851404,
-0.1035410091,
-1.15432477,
0.3092978001,
0.1678040028,
0.5759752989,
0.1249138191,
-0.5359355211,
0.5069922805,
-0.8054182529,
1.2070505619,
0.0952819586,
-1.135787487,
0.560461998,
-0.2397133112,
0.7129199505,
-0.0931249186,
0.105219759,
-0.6109089851,
-0.4525000751,
-0.351834327,
-0.6583430171,
0.7950320244,
0.2854765058,
-0.1772168726,
-0.0956031531,
0.3831418157,
-0.1371376216,
-0.1097572818,
-0.7105685472,
-0.3311545551,
0.0751484782,
0.0184874684,
-0.0363261737,
-0.3550814986,
-0.0159745272,
-0.0989871994,
-0.0004992777,
0.0073899147,
0.7591480017,
0.1145583019,
-0.3173904419,
-0.345553875,
0.2890916467,
0.5356835127,
0.8481913805,
-0.0824289024,
0.2299207002,
0.1279453039,
-0.5442032218,
0.0417903252,
0.2750075459,
0.2167051733,
0.1392017156,
0.7055110931,
0.8354759812,
0.0151568269,
-0.4441089332,
0.3000567853,
-0.3794661462,
-0.0004032301,
-0.3063703775,
0.0574820004,
0.1461101174,
0.3725019693,
0.4961749613,
-0.002662851,
-0.1514514536,
-0.2496145517,
0.0947186276,
0.2076570988,
-0.1467968374,
-0.9489919543,
0.9640901685,
-0.2629171014,
-0.4994175136,
0.6003715992,
0.1126206815,
-0.3458075523,
0.6415421963,
0.7158640623,
0.986988008,
-0.4292307198,
-0.0336994827,
0.2553015351,
0.1280146986,
0.1764853001,
0.5303711295,
0.0066817491,
-0.7150099277,
-0.8471626043,
-0.6236724257,
0.31298244,
0.3784062564,
-0.6384964585,
0.0447936878,
-0.2144497037,
-0.5721485615,
0.2548720241,
-0.332572639,
-0.8567087054,
0.0234205294,
0.4516274333,
0.7598088384,
-0.7800443769,
1.0067962408,
0.7059774995,
-0.2262720019,
-0.7141845822,
0.2342455983,
-0.2816305757,
-0.6247054935,
0.7849347591,
-0.0753949434,
-0.341901809,
0.0618443675,
-0.3772014976,
-0.6380352378,
0.9428352714,
0.7389870286,
-0.6370074749,
-0.4781454802,
0.2925517261,
0.9396836758,
-0.0903812274,
0.3115019202,
0.9635800123,
0.2566050887,
-0.426756829,
-0.9813617468,
-0.2743320465,
-0.2094881386,
0.1674397886,
0.5238997936,
-0.3816131055,
0.7044069171,
0.1835242808,
-0.6065289378,
-0.3023156524,
0.8920301795,
-0.0773471817,
0.0066465079,
0.5864104629,
0.6492004395,
0.3271871805,
-0.3340982795,
0.8867913485,
-0.4833622277,
0.1061938256,
0.8553676605,
-0.2654595971,
0.9213145971,
0.9044148922,
-0.4531078637,
0.6942027807,
0.4562821984,
0.4539322853,
0.5152139068,
-0.0104524288,
-0.2608739734,
-0.1017949879,
-0.1543094516,
-0.0978618115,
0.2210098505,
0.4473946095,
-0.1574694663,
-0.1695212126,
0.3450433314,
-0.4372216761,
0.0767294392,
-0.2961686254,
0.5309434533,
-0.0257401727,
-0.8165298104,
0.3017610013,
-0.2176197469,
0.2640602291,
-0.6975066066,
-0.0322549157,
-0.0698794201,
0.0283760466,
0.0884614885,
-1.0565043688,
0.3608367741,
-0.2829124629,
-0.2250331044,
-0.4499637187,
0.4621835947,
-0.71460253,
-0.0648102909,
0.8679766655,
0.3417126536,
-0.3256079853,
0.2279953957,
-0.3742920458,
0.2085097134,
-0.1649776846,
-0.3500412405,
0.1268195659,
0.5538406372,
0.1341782957,
0.4383589923,
0.1166650951,
0.3146559,
0.5597289801,
0.3947153687,
0.4074746966,
-0.7724984288,
-0.5852150321,
-0.8949815631,
0.336016953,
0.281103164,
-0.0307454113,
0.2329311967,
0.1879466176,
0.9466179013,
-0.0422053933,
0.3061835766,
-0.3143008351,
0.3273479342,
-0.7343216538,
0.6289103031,
-0.426222235,
0.2132138163,
0.2142568678,
-0.9669945836,
-0.1654433757,
0.3623708487,
-0.3070135713,
-0.1649254709,
1.0969281197,
0.6347543001,
-0.000446396,
0.1706559956,
0.2813793123,
0.449259907,
0.3861120343,
0.5454956889,
0.7910166979,
-0.3391817212,
0.2163112164,
-0.2641151249,
0.1548409909,
0.1892301291,
-0.7509109974,
-0.8205664754,
-1.0440499783,
-0.2711818516,
-0.14466317,
-0.1530237645,
0.8141357899,
0.3836463392,
-0.8631922007,
-0.5429849625,
0.0150170419,
-0.2474754453,
-0.5053529143,
-0.3150905967,
0.4826852679,
-0.5055408478,
-0.9345133305,
0.449649334,
0.2381435782,
0.1860016584,
-0.3436189294,
0.3203287423,
-0.5039891601,
0.0529050231,
0.6426815987,
0.0382543504,
-0.5442922115,
-0.287365675,
0.3589478433,
-0.2008929551,
0.1490431875,
1.1209008694,
-0.9106863737,
0.4509810507,
0.7930043936,
0.5708762407,
0.5344019532,
-0.3643850088,
0.8338117003,
-0.8548514247,
0.162541613,
0.2810434401,
0.6091139913,
0.0241313167,
-0.2730569243,
0.1316756606,
0.0491816066,
-0.6422314048,
-0.6860365272,
0.0880630016,
-1.0651431084,
-0.2735536098,
0.7718185782,
0.2739943266,
-0.6255801916,
0.0288792215,
-0.0636101216,
0.4904028177,
-0.1872443259,
0.7977586389,
1.3335075378,
-0.4102759659,
-0.2243670821,
-0.4300352037,
0.1563936174,
0.4315952361,
-0.4314264655,
0.0588874072,
0.240858525,
-0.0837865174,
0.4297915995,
0.3095592856,
-0.1924158186,
0.0721155182,
-0.1508926302,
-0.1416742504,
0.2959723771,
-0.2940413356,
-0.5030319691,
0.3013494611,
-0.0456467383,
-0.2310995162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19874v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19874v1 | Detecting Subtle Differences between Human and Model Languages Using Spectrum of Relative Likelihood | 2024-06-28T12:28:52 | 2024-06-28T12:28:52 | Yang Xu, Yu Wang, Hao An, Zhichen Liu, Yongyuan Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Human and model-generated texts can be distinguished by examining the
magnitude of likelihood in language. However, it is becoming increasingly
difficult as language model's capabilities of generating human-like texts keep
evolving. This study provides a new perspective by using the relative
likelihood values instead of absolute ones, and extracting useful features from
the spectrum-view of likelihood for the human-model text detection task. We
propose a detection procedure with two classification methods, supervised and
heuristic-based, respectively, which results in competitive performances with
previous zero-shot detection methods and a new state-of-the-art on short-text
detection. Our method can also reveal subtle differences between human and
model languages, which find theoretical roots in psycholinguistics studies. Our
code is available at https://github.com/CLCS-SUSTech/FourierGPT | [
-0.506947875,
-0.9169764519,
0.6769904494,
-0.2049833387,
-0.096862413,
0.238345027,
-0.3614927828,
-0.8383321166,
0.0889634341,
0.4302839637,
-0.4543944299,
-0.4551801383,
-0.3180409074,
0.084316276,
-0.4610476792,
0.6050832868,
0.242851302,
-0.1505008936,
0.1736578345,
-0.1271487176,
-0.0783302635,
-0.502661705,
-0.5331515074,
-0.2988041937,
0.6180047989,
0.3043991923,
0.520211339,
0.4607209861,
0.5345039368,
0.2009635866,
-0.1043252423,
-0.1865035444,
0.0301540587,
0.0572396331,
0.0158227626,
-0.5653058887,
-0.2521068752,
-0.165641427,
0.9468073845,
0.7558649778,
0.2013714761,
0.2020004839,
0.1177326441,
0.6905146241,
-0.7408025265,
0.1379564852,
-0.4082191288,
0.0075500272,
-1.0101752281,
-0.1018089056,
-0.4084089994,
-0.0866296813,
0.0436769687,
-0.223016724,
0.5331538916,
0.043232277,
0.968264699,
-0.0907506719,
-0.4930427969,
-0.1793449372,
-0.8579434156,
0.9191125035,
-0.8657782674,
0.7987389565,
0.5953293443,
0.5129352808,
-0.1220809966,
-0.5721838474,
-0.6632933617,
-0.5098320246,
0.0111720851,
-0.2417023331,
-0.4874240756,
-0.1904788613,
0.25670892,
0.2266141623,
-0.7092021704,
0.251760006,
-0.32158494,
-0.4687761962,
0.4815369546,
-0.1323667169,
0.2305759639,
-0.3687904775,
0.2070298046,
-0.2437400222,
-0.4965580702,
0.0891509801,
0.7577967048,
0.3704604805,
-0.3020634949,
0.2704139352,
-0.3269532025,
0.6380230784,
-0.0797785893,
-0.1972212195,
0.3736858368,
0.0563204251,
-0.0665790737,
-0.1354696304,
0.7628210783,
-0.1655504704,
0.3592632413,
-0.0939323083,
-0.1992243975,
0.4149902463,
-0.0509268567,
-0.5097066164,
-0.5702679157,
-0.2590436339,
-0.6326319575,
-0.7161877751,
-0.0798556954,
-0.5033940077,
-0.3741620779,
-0.0807265565,
0.084687002,
-0.4731989503,
-0.4229589701,
0.1953718811,
-0.0173351932,
0.1137765646,
-0.1271338612,
-0.8861534595,
0.4356051087,
0.4293251634,
0.5008314848,
-0.1443552375,
0.0861198977,
-0.2944453657,
-0.1751667261,
-0.3657467961,
1.205578208,
-0.5395004153,
-0.2304104567,
-0.1604810506,
-0.3215616047,
0.2705571651,
-0.5552175045,
0.7749482989,
-0.4710990489,
0.5989891887,
-0.3258445561,
-0.5829491615,
-0.324416101,
0.154835701,
-0.6728104949,
1.2397531271,
0.0714631677,
-0.9723493457,
0.4157536626,
-0.536280334,
-0.3848744333,
0.1254640967,
-0.477609694,
-0.7363259792,
0.1922716796,
0.1683592051,
0.4398317933,
-0.4030565321,
0.2245851457,
-0.5045396686,
-0.5197438002,
0.613135159,
-0.7697342634,
0.7469089627,
0.2438283265,
-0.2950870395,
0.0175334457,
-1.0119900703,
-0.0445933752,
0.1496520489,
-0.2186127454,
-0.4170529544,
0.2756667733,
0.3174598217,
0.1538384259,
0.0228468701,
-0.4356355369,
-0.0239382237,
-0.4916301072,
0.238870874,
0.3738830686,
0.1279748678,
0.6114658713,
-0.2737542689,
0.5060898662,
-0.0599168614,
0.080232136,
-0.0496775433,
-0.6180468798,
-0.6516685486,
-0.4256898463,
0.4916734993,
0.4530848265,
-0.7677471638,
0.5860751271,
0.0292102825,
-0.3233472407,
-0.2251007855,
-0.1032743379,
0.4819493294,
0.5915417075,
0.1809054017,
-0.3545282185,
-0.3952619433,
-1.1583168507,
-0.3656665087,
-0.5094332695,
-0.3693118691,
0.1795823276,
0.369089663,
-0.2053706944,
1.1645323038,
-0.7350286245,
-0.1181577742,
-0.1202368885,
0.2379885018,
0.0407347269,
0.2967266738,
0.8970039487,
-0.8796762228,
-0.671148181,
-0.0398537293,
-0.7622837424,
-0.3741072118,
0.0154218404,
0.0001074394,
0.1548407674,
0.6232607961,
-0.0647559017,
0.341298461,
0.166949138,
-0.2538145781,
0.6485925317,
-0.0356366336,
0.2342738658,
-0.9022483826,
0.1170310676,
0.3902652562,
-0.3744371533,
-0.8716085553,
0.1197150275,
0.239670679,
0.3244699836,
-0.4663807452,
0.6519050002,
-0.360106349,
-0.1544327289,
-0.333053261,
-0.0039974418,
-0.3299460709,
0.5840014815,
0.1921246946,
0.3484690487,
0.5686603785,
-0.4943585098,
0.1116165966,
-0.0912264884,
-0.4183718562,
0.5773785114,
-0.3199009597,
0.1412044168,
-0.0905706361,
0.101702325,
-0.9829159975,
-0.4054158926,
0.6062931418,
-0.5545650125,
0.293345958,
-0.3141873479,
-0.640853405,
-0.359003365,
-0.4400059283,
0.5232456326,
0.7592571974,
-0.0882363543,
0.1185923666,
0.2251188457,
-0.0739441887,
-0.3426168859,
-0.6262767315,
0.0767398924,
-0.4611076117,
-0.5296782851,
0.3733116388,
0.1072811335,
-0.3844759762,
-0.131167233,
-0.0701021403,
-0.4435336888,
0.2251664847,
0.0205940418,
0.2208989114,
-0.3831211627,
0.1735827476,
0.3380356729,
-0.4275408983,
-0.1987784207,
-0.394438982,
0.443244338,
-0.2504181266,
-0.3732403219,
-0.5880098343,
0.2240521461,
0.2269296348,
-0.2875419855,
0.3237871826,
0.9297152758,
-0.4116052389,
-0.0091085555,
-0.6168009043,
-0.56612432,
-0.4842875898,
0.3162160218,
-0.3392298818,
-0.8116736412,
0.6218601465,
0.03195595,
-0.3679526746,
0.3765829206,
0.5107857585,
-0.3490396142,
0.8689585328,
0.8852203488,
-0.0230750237,
0.7704892755,
0.1170186028,
0.1387864351,
-0.590231359,
0.2922031879,
-0.7402607203,
-0.1807654351,
-0.5179980993,
-0.2554101944,
0.4380021095,
0.2217683196,
-0.1069289967,
0.2931795716,
-0.3941290081,
0.660764873,
0.473505944,
0.1419340521,
0.3369328082,
0.2169347852,
-0.1289750338,
-0.3843345046,
-0.3041105568,
-0.6425927281,
1.1280930042,
0.4710336626,
0.4026382864,
0.321893394,
0.7869893909,
0.5103231072,
0.1727205664,
-0.7254741192,
0.5451617837,
-0.214849025,
-0.5446174741,
-0.2170775086,
-0.4656922519,
-0.8886199594,
0.33015275,
-0.3832280934,
-1.0168907642,
0.1265670955,
0.1126453727,
-0.27099365,
0.1771955192,
-0.547341764,
0.9046612382,
0.1046471298,
-0.1421272308,
0.0449427478,
-0.6637114286,
0.4156577587,
-0.3490255475,
0.3736930192,
-0.2575808167,
0.2591362298,
0.7392456532,
0.013420728,
0.9356170893,
-0.1550607383,
-0.3525006473,
0.2478904575,
0.3294003606,
0.2540808916,
-0.1980842501,
0.0511842892,
0.1422059834,
-0.070482336,
-0.5072784424,
-0.4136644602,
0.3531260192,
-0.3099811673,
-0.2028023303,
-0.2486967295,
-0.5245757699,
-0.215904519,
0.3539951146,
0.6142396331,
0.4202747345,
-0.2566726804,
-0.1071913466,
0.6063349247,
-0.2736145258,
0.6605750918,
0.6422098875,
-0.4858570695,
0.1914834678,
0.8903029561,
-0.1499969661,
0.2329392582,
0.455873847,
0.4869520664,
-0.3570843339,
-0.559445858,
-0.3121892214,
0.3442765176,
-0.477195859,
0.122545734,
-0.3421982229,
0.1157520935,
-0.3086765409,
-0.1982790381,
-0.2462415099,
-0.4206411839,
-0.1742394716,
0.3460687101,
0.047655955,
0.4787485898,
-0.0093483124,
0.4457755685,
-0.769474268,
0.394802779,
0.1572816074,
0.0068324949,
-0.1476756632,
-0.532469511,
-0.0983332694,
0.1673656255,
-0.2655727863,
-1.0788615942,
0.4670327604,
0.2574325204,
0.4802654386,
0.5117378235,
0.1566929817,
0.2444788367,
-0.2953692079,
0.6333871484,
0.1787911057,
-1.0792851448,
0.4432758987,
-0.510133028,
0.3026188016,
0.3287923038,
0.1242542863,
-0.6434381008,
-0.6073755622,
-0.5403465033,
-0.3595904112,
0.8019896746,
0.6259159446,
-0.0309254956,
0.0677427948,
0.3896435499,
-0.0329527147,
-0.0462365858,
-0.807913661,
-0.2174148113,
0.3687753379,
-0.3748502135,
0.0108059039,
-0.1348817796,
0.1557974219,
-0.0623991303,
0.411451757,
-0.3567860723,
0.4780898988,
-0.2300894558,
-0.3741601408,
-0.0484302863,
0.4518175423,
0.681424439,
0.1655881405,
-0.3248233497,
0.3863134682,
0.1230970249,
-0.5721172094,
0.0931329206,
-0.0174901932,
-0.242807433,
0.1175263897,
0.7381657958,
0.4996436834,
0.4846839011,
-0.5293463469,
0.5779111981,
-0.0236228351,
-0.120608218,
-0.177764535,
-0.0127696171,
0.0583823733,
0.4464592338,
0.3349550962,
0.4031211436,
0.508598268,
-0.4903137386,
0.3676509261,
0.151759997,
-0.5197646618,
-0.4787286818,
0.5152814388,
0.0100506609,
-0.3808870912,
0.4090423286,
-0.687207818,
-0.5798389912,
0.6089454293,
0.3035092652,
1.0303324461,
-0.1716881394,
0.3706005812,
-0.0667502955,
0.0672170147,
-0.0466127582,
0.2272556573,
-0.3848428726,
-1.0190213919,
-0.2614243925,
-0.4934958518,
-0.1190391481,
-0.1083424389,
-0.7982696891,
0.483292371,
-0.1596322656,
-0.186931923,
0.6848472357,
-0.1310890317,
-0.2892461121,
-0.2195201963,
0.4913860559,
0.4932397604,
-0.9442511797,
1.3950134516,
0.4614484608,
-0.279658258,
-0.5371126533,
0.4023130834,
0.4548788369,
-0.378028512,
0.8319846988,
0.0644376948,
-0.2944914997,
-0.1329744309,
-0.2799407542,
-0.4990044236,
0.7218104601,
0.5544979572,
-0.7230508327,
-0.0500684641,
0.2148927599,
0.6830637455,
0.1058858484,
0.0445729196,
0.5404634476,
0.3763498962,
0.0145515874,
-1.0464602709,
-0.2792001367,
0.0944679901,
0.0350116976,
0.6025477052,
0.0392419584,
1.0743629932,
0.0649538785,
-0.4434102774,
-0.0122859394,
0.6161928177,
0.1479532868,
0.3470554948,
0.5014244914,
0.2046570629,
0.7957299352,
0.0043912563,
0.9256981015,
-0.1780543774,
0.7713571191,
0.8467578292,
-0.433175534,
0.9075545669,
0.1743397564,
-0.3846440613,
0.6264819503,
0.4951393306,
0.1662392765,
0.5326420665,
0.0853500441,
-0.6221176982,
-0.3707735538,
0.3257911205,
-0.2650974989,
0.5512786508,
0.4574784338,
-0.2548529804,
-0.5338482857,
0.2713304162,
0.1019552127,
0.2550617158,
-0.0129502453,
0.522075057,
0.1024308354,
-0.107615456,
0.5977298617,
0.4439576268,
0.9940772653,
-0.4460963607,
0.0984424949,
0.052958969,
0.3788441718,
-0.2072247863,
-0.7635223866,
0.4197924435,
0.0946376547,
-0.2444668561,
0.0839873403,
1.0554689169,
-0.3445050418,
-0.4821699858,
0.1876787841,
0.5642677546,
0.1165729761,
-0.3482850492,
-0.7707197666,
-0.0342153907,
0.09681198,
0.0904456154,
0.238627851,
0.1226756945,
-0.5787816048,
0.5401306152,
0.6102526784,
-0.2416816205,
-0.0106731048,
0.1700188369,
0.3935621679,
-0.6237398982,
-0.6719523072,
-1.0392239094,
0.2005252689,
-0.080330193,
-0.2513637245,
0.6511161327,
0.4921798706,
0.6757246852,
-0.2333110422,
0.5528129935,
-0.0582150556,
0.5937837958,
-0.4772802293,
0.7088630795,
-0.3330073655,
0.5113506317,
-0.4696815312,
-0.9985135794,
-0.7955068946,
0.8123563528,
-0.3385259807,
-0.0566316769,
0.7331131697,
0.8334462643,
-0.2745999098,
-0.0018738464,
0.5216163993,
-0.0010717277,
0.5424568057,
0.5325101018,
0.8563465476,
-0.4253318608,
0.3209987283,
-0.3058832884,
-0.3103066981,
-0.2079859972,
-0.8604196906,
-0.8948121667,
-0.8392452002,
-0.6395087242,
-0.0622261614,
-0.1411870718,
0.6991311312,
0.8752400875,
-0.7492293715,
-0.2791793942,
-0.1607097834,
0.0178531185,
-0.288662672,
-0.2373459488,
0.4163499475,
-0.0269521922,
-0.6342196465,
0.4174138904,
0.3498916924,
0.1590968966,
-0.3467150033,
-0.0960186496,
-0.0624435395,
0.2444468588,
0.5662831664,
0.542149961,
-0.8352806568,
-0.4994977415,
-0.0173514746,
-0.2606841028,
-0.095994547,
0.8839496374,
-0.9720256329,
0.2428553253,
0.485753119,
0.1534352899,
0.6426538825,
-0.5978406072,
0.2793982625,
-1.2392036915,
0.4645349085,
0.2296420783,
0.2243551314,
0.2407129854,
-0.1332183778,
0.3476421237,
0.509783268,
-0.2850432396,
-0.9495406747,
0.500341475,
-1.2239089012,
-0.5103479624,
0.9394512773,
0.0589409508,
-0.0987124145,
-0.3909853101,
-0.3629485965,
0.1118621752,
-0.2837248743,
0.6933037639,
0.5229276419,
-0.2006515115,
-0.1834962517,
-0.4393601418,
0.5414904952,
0.1585299373,
-0.8181917667,
-0.1485522985,
0.4461090267,
0.4222428203,
0.2221111804,
0.7047290206,
-0.12847431,
0.3608547151,
0.115507625,
0.1424250305,
0.1302744299,
-0.1479605585,
-0.4433487952,
0.2373565882,
0.0693110675,
-0.18136473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19853v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19853v1 | YuLan: An Open-source Large Language Model | 2024-06-28T11:52:53 | 2024-06-28T11:52:53 | Yutao Zhu, Kun Zhou, Kelong Mao, Wentong Chen, Yiding Sun, Zhipeng Chen, Qian Cao, Yihan Wu, Yushuo Chen, Feng Wang, Lei Zhang, Junyi Li, Xiaolei Wang, Lei Wang, Beichen Zhang, Zican Dong, Xiaoxue Cheng, Yuhan Chen, Xinyu Tang, Yupeng Hou, Qiangqiang Ren, Xincheng Pang, Shufang Xie, Wayne Xin Zhao, Zhicheng Dou, Jiaxin Mao, Yankai Lin, Ruihua Song, Jun Xu, Xu Chen, Rui Yan, Zhewei Wei, Di Hu, Wenbing Huang, Ze-Feng Gao, Yueguo Chen, Weizheng Lu, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have become the foundation of many applications,
leveraging their extensive capabilities in processing and understanding natural
language. While many open-source LLMs have been released with technical
reports, the lack of training details hinders further research and development.
This paper presents the development of YuLan, a series of open-source LLMs with
$12$ billion parameters. The base model of YuLan is pre-trained on
approximately $1.7$T tokens derived from a diverse corpus, including massive
English, Chinese, and multilingual texts. We design a three-stage pre-training
method to enhance YuLan's overall capabilities. Subsequent phases of training
incorporate instruction-tuning and human alignment, employing a substantial
volume of high-quality synthesized data. To facilitate the learning of complex
and long-tail knowledge, we devise a curriculum-learning framework throughout
across these stages, which helps LLMs learn knowledge in an easy-to-hard
manner. YuLan's training is finished on Jan, 2024 and has achieved performance
on par with state-of-the-art LLMs across various English and Chinese
benchmarks. This paper outlines a comprehensive technical roadmap for
developing LLMs from scratch. Our model and codes are available at
https://github.com/RUC-GSAI/YuLan-Chat. | [
-0.0824172571,
-0.6268384457,
0.4213737845,
0.0481243916,
-0.1847153455,
-0.0609306581,
-0.4999572337,
-0.477704078,
0.2880646586,
0.6589056253,
-0.2659112513,
-0.4061401784,
-0.2344815731,
-0.1432285905,
-0.2700957656,
1.0605162382,
0.0907967538,
0.0466090441,
0.3764007986,
-0.0580014251,
-0.1089744791,
-0.1096306741,
-0.3399869204,
-0.2933878303,
0.9033944011,
0.4841773212,
0.5697032213,
1.0658620596,
0.3077968657,
0.2705827951,
-0.1920592189,
0.1035955995,
-0.5088069439,
-0.0011541103,
-0.1635480672,
-0.4016909897,
-0.6856524944,
0.0817741826,
0.8787913322,
0.8271639943,
-0.0101094889,
0.4544852376,
0.0578780994,
0.5030043721,
-0.4484951198,
0.1337920576,
-0.7295927405,
-0.0134871248,
-0.6247457862,
-0.1356689632,
-0.3321923614,
-0.2576720119,
0.1524432898,
-0.6247237325,
-0.1508990526,
0.0340700224,
0.8152616024,
-0.0482851379,
-0.1541031301,
-0.2549436986,
-0.4873122573,
0.9082931876,
-0.8762547374,
0.5446622968,
0.3577048779,
0.4145688713,
-0.2204907984,
-0.7342375517,
-0.3787389398,
-0.3962597251,
0.1768382192,
-0.2574293613,
0.5072427392,
-0.0914055035,
0.1600455791,
0.3301503062,
-0.4769597948,
0.4580285549,
-0.5184602141,
0.1051046848,
0.3630594313,
0.1268473715,
0.1761400998,
-0.1662898362,
-0.5788178444,
0.1990620643,
-0.8333943486,
-0.3031169176,
0.4206243455,
0.7107848525,
-0.3677460253,
0.5307927728,
-0.2399100959,
0.5688043237,
-0.1480530649,
-0.5717709064,
0.3176310956,
-0.0622234158,
-0.5101591945,
-0.0783031508,
0.7967258096,
-0.1899110079,
0.0842761323,
-0.1369071603,
-0.3978005648,
-0.3187548816,
0.0158884171,
-0.7319104671,
-0.0987152308,
0.3875692487,
-0.4019807279,
-0.2140025645,
-0.1237576157,
-0.6580458283,
-0.6478641629,
-0.6142488718,
0.4783607125,
-0.4075883627,
-0.3778584898,
0.1997327209,
0.3893079162,
0.4219183028,
0.4563591182,
-0.7527470589,
-0.0122708958,
0.6378226876,
0.893997848,
-0.0165663604,
-0.674503088,
-0.7845677733,
0.2962022424,
-0.4564582705,
0.4218054414,
0.0093207555,
0.1379316449,
0.2390852273,
-0.258777231,
0.271994859,
-0.4377958775,
0.4818091094,
-0.8780246973,
0.2524469793,
-0.0997262225,
-0.4937410057,
0.1818028092,
0.3360163271,
-0.7936745286,
0.6392213702,
-0.0112827057,
-0.8888309598,
0.1494567543,
-0.7919458151,
-0.3370643854,
0.6440078616,
-0.089237988,
-0.1621376276,
-0.2263718247,
-0.0354084708,
0.6269873977,
-0.7340943813,
0.4395787716,
-0.2893149555,
-0.3050429821,
0.0919745639,
-0.0120889544,
1.0225144625,
0.6152682304,
-0.2315994203,
0.2403833568,
-0.7600340843,
0.1508625597,
0.1914522797,
-0.5016698241,
-0.1508785188,
-0.1119167581,
0.0784427151,
0.0190476999,
0.5727314353,
-0.3998698592,
-0.101031296,
-0.374579519,
0.3498935699,
0.778149128,
-0.4872684777,
0.3962116539,
-0.2178557217,
0.2987588942,
0.1549526602,
0.0343329534,
-0.7446101904,
-0.0879036188,
-1.0393030643,
-0.2659446597,
0.132383734,
0.1679839045,
-0.7598419189,
0.4638906121,
-0.2187419385,
-0.5164330006,
-0.53860569,
0.6132940054,
0.2987622619,
0.2935816944,
0.3398066461,
0.076268293,
-0.5816351771,
-0.6554074287,
-0.1641548276,
-0.337441504,
-0.0426590145,
-0.3634321988,
0.447648108,
-0.1651820242,
0.940751493,
-0.4022721946,
-0.5989733338,
-0.6422154903,
0.0203531533,
0.312782228,
0.2122617811,
0.3696894348,
-0.5287175775,
-0.4916995466,
0.5005156398,
-0.6722845435,
-0.0990061238,
0.028973192,
0.0328272507,
0.3330356479,
0.6547992826,
-0.3557760417,
-0.008990136,
0.66772753,
-0.0956361592,
0.5385093093,
-0.3153197765,
-0.3340041637,
-1.3632540703,
0.3870619535,
0.0981548801,
-0.1552692205,
-0.7115188837,
0.3955436051,
0.2316851914,
-0.0827459991,
-0.5637323856,
0.5699273348,
-0.5200950503,
0.0921522081,
-0.3326913714,
0.1614781022,
-0.3472616673,
0.4229927957,
0.0084812799,
0.5431154966,
0.2497402877,
-0.5246974826,
0.4849674702,
-0.1337319016,
-0.7725278735,
0.3798809052,
-0.8559923768,
0.0947049111,
-0.2045578361,
-0.1756642908,
-0.4346286058,
-0.4734192491,
0.1383188069,
-0.1606002152,
0.0842530504,
-0.0484409854,
-0.5155774951,
-0.2590018213,
-0.196870476,
0.0743054599,
0.4255630374,
-0.6319571137,
0.36092785,
0.540812552,
-0.2159935534,
-0.4846655428,
-0.6123102307,
0.1843235195,
-0.2416249514,
-0.4130247235,
-0.0692127198,
-0.1713819802,
-0.3166591227,
-0.0505548492,
0.4639705122,
-0.2832711935,
0.0846596137,
-0.0846161172,
0.2964679897,
-0.3549755812,
0.2316348851,
-0.2851175368,
-0.0360300504,
-0.0076615443,
-0.7493121028,
0.5803599358,
-0.123517409,
-0.3769471645,
-0.3102630675,
-0.0471574664,
0.5205134749,
-0.5271676779,
0.7107741237,
0.4535203576,
-0.4663163424,
-0.7097582817,
-0.5992512107,
0.3573566973,
-0.4941547215,
0.6104562283,
-0.180636555,
-0.9500803947,
0.3028036654,
0.085501492,
0.4184421897,
0.1953233331,
0.7597287893,
0.0883660913,
0.2241061479,
0.7324706912,
-0.3591307998,
0.4881685376,
0.029294109,
0.2041473091,
-0.3211430311,
-0.2842801213,
-0.5404734015,
-0.0505183525,
-0.3043270111,
-0.740175426,
0.3647683859,
-0.1433122009,
-0.5997808576,
0.3361712694,
0.2481045425,
0.7520568967,
0.5648464561,
-0.1378729492,
0.423446089,
-0.1226444393,
-0.054833848,
-0.0164693892,
-0.5640566349,
-0.4949543774,
1.0268472433,
0.7611628175,
1.0236965418,
0.0891567245,
0.6462221146,
0.1288434267,
0.1499416083,
-0.6548724174,
0.526612699,
0.0444186553,
-0.6049719453,
-0.4736946225,
-0.6169568896,
-0.7734059095,
0.0297172051,
-0.0780218318,
-0.3822995424,
-0.4770945013,
-0.0389940292,
-0.1871360987,
0.5697808862,
-0.5516063571,
0.6383545995,
-0.6365217566,
-0.5449987054,
-0.0237144232,
-0.7402368784,
0.6181924939,
-0.432194829,
0.2894152403,
-0.014503262,
-0.0208038595,
0.6497706771,
-0.3003557622,
0.9155948162,
-0.0955076665,
-0.4281690419,
0.364861846,
-0.1510001719,
0.2027758658,
-0.0274154693,
-0.0890515521,
0.0563482754,
-0.3360577822,
-0.3700281382,
-0.2150152475,
0.7363951802,
-0.9454293847,
-0.3712679744,
-0.2031676471,
-0.7109816074,
-0.1213871166,
0.5710636973,
-0.2002493888,
0.2049008906,
-0.3504523039,
0.1549504995,
0.8555495739,
-0.6177159548,
0.3559561372,
0.4639104903,
-0.6108131409,
-0.6769442558,
0.826025784,
0.0477707833,
0.4819615185,
0.3180535734,
0.3272086084,
-0.0717800781,
-0.4666723907,
-0.3450656533,
0.535505414,
-0.6166524887,
-0.2130120844,
-0.3967607021,
-0.4158083797,
-0.6046759486,
0.0837470368,
-0.5674483776,
0.0113013452,
-0.2235196829,
0.115855515,
0.0822770298,
0.9848605394,
0.0864805132,
0.4064332843,
-0.7016125917,
0.4159297943,
0.3104236424,
0.6601376534,
0.0990369618,
-0.6239446998,
-0.8896323442,
0.1797155887,
-0.2172986269,
-0.3147205114,
0.5489499569,
0.0220125858,
0.3882390261,
0.6477042437,
-0.0605345219,
0.6959519982,
-0.4455333352,
0.7010182142,
0.4367897809,
-0.9786999822,
0.4181720912,
-0.6837185025,
0.3986228704,
0.3102106154,
0.4324373901,
-0.6479423642,
-0.066934526,
-0.1404773295,
-0.4305280745,
0.9247692227,
-0.2803499997,
0.1075887084,
0.2037610263,
0.1788059175,
0.1224420741,
0.1215759665,
-0.9524911642,
-0.0602276102,
0.0377556793,
-0.0142716756,
-0.1882592887,
-0.2847493589,
-0.0032542429,
-0.2081895024,
0.6217588782,
-0.3102834225,
-0.107940197,
-0.242001608,
-0.1508942693,
-0.1446015984,
0.3198007941,
0.369532764,
0.5996869206,
-0.1471043229,
0.0802531242,
0.0530641228,
-0.3471133411,
-0.0833595544,
0.0017264719,
-0.0321222581,
-0.2080199718,
0.4469810724,
0.7059011459,
-0.0091934651,
-0.7990376353,
0.5104491115,
0.3542100489,
-0.2892189622,
-0.4567792118,
-0.1383858621,
0.4319880903,
0.4047298431,
0.260853231,
-0.5579169989,
-0.3633619249,
-0.5593400598,
-0.0477118082,
0.1782781333,
-0.2427989542,
-0.4930105209,
0.7183912396,
0.2831740677,
-0.0719592273,
0.5019557476,
-0.2205414921,
-0.5043781996,
0.1502824426,
0.5945416689,
0.8033864498,
-0.2301490307,
0.3217757046,
0.3620621562,
0.4187715948,
-0.2745439708,
0.2247287631,
0.2203204483,
-0.5957759023,
-0.6082177162,
-0.7999312878,
-0.4944939911,
0.4701835811,
-0.2047351152,
0.8658998609,
-0.6604568958,
0.1527429968,
-0.3604758978,
0.2596043646,
-0.510170877,
0.1442180723,
0.3494381607,
0.9994353056,
-0.5688924789,
1.2036621571,
0.783069849,
-0.5097680688,
-0.8181145787,
-0.0801848844,
-0.1789450049,
-0.6541484594,
0.8943896294,
0.1265534908,
-0.0044050226,
-0.099553138,
-0.696855545,
-0.8553336263,
1.17286098,
0.6410019398,
-0.4329845011,
-0.3884724081,
0.5759829879,
0.4720923603,
-0.2229377031,
0.1409814209,
0.2830358446,
0.2351976633,
0.1664157808,
-1.0434998274,
-0.3364576101,
-0.0919419602,
0.0243432131,
0.1335816532,
-0.7506456971,
1.2374073267,
-0.3745240271,
-0.1028126925,
0.3943907022,
0.9169299006,
0.1829779297,
0.186346665,
0.3343070149,
0.5113601089,
0.7799680829,
0.2876847982,
0.523060441,
-0.3072109818,
0.1587215513,
1.2218606472,
-0.493560791,
0.9401071668,
0.4399423003,
-0.0132904528,
0.3587497771,
0.0910234749,
0.3683117628,
0.1764485389,
0.3818647265,
-0.2460865378,
-0.1736568063,
-0.3136373162,
-0.3488609195,
0.4425541461,
0.2982125282,
-0.4101799726,
-0.2656412125,
-0.2955072224,
0.104523465,
0.1117356792,
-0.3551977873,
0.4110715687,
0.1871672124,
-0.3810756803,
0.3950857818,
0.2664714456,
0.6963956356,
-0.9395339489,
0.20415245,
-0.3188380599,
0.2995670736,
-0.1099850088,
-0.4701146483,
-0.050906647,
0.2261325717,
0.290846467,
-0.3447446525,
0.6214433312,
-0.6289821267,
-0.2584370971,
0.2394082993,
0.6637775302,
0.0787259564,
0.2234048843,
-0.2053380311,
0.2590463161,
-0.1792002916,
-0.2119047493,
0.3846796453,
0.7295964956,
0.0447442196,
0.6358463168,
0.5773995519,
0.384662658,
0.0146196904,
-0.032192748,
1.000954628,
-0.7780849934,
-0.4799622595,
-0.6173405647,
0.4541603923,
0.0126089146,
-0.4148471057,
0.6911507845,
0.3845806122,
0.9211739302,
0.0048063048,
0.8685523868,
0.0092946887,
0.674886167,
-0.5279495716,
1.0207800865,
-0.5580507517,
0.392754972,
-0.3114128411,
-0.8918861151,
-0.4630033374,
0.3925679028,
-0.0400693044,
-0.0240625087,
0.5352603197,
0.6008847356,
-0.0503891334,
0.0268115364,
0.5038284063,
0.2841290534,
0.4728458822,
0.5520836115,
0.9608600736,
-0.1203088164,
0.3554576933,
-0.100041531,
-0.2232616544,
-0.0264560208,
-1.0079569817,
-1.1799151897,
-0.5390720963,
0.0032552315,
-0.0441109613,
-0.0514085144,
1.3249976635,
0.5391272306,
-0.5089612603,
-0.8330703974,
0.1523526609,
-0.0840166286,
0.3266902566,
-0.0765853822,
0.0466831066,
-0.7418057919,
-0.7932335138,
0.4017101228,
0.13135539,
-0.1050080135,
-0.7617226243,
-0.3768189549,
-0.2486177087,
-0.2325563878,
0.6317660809,
0.3911312222,
-0.5332494378,
-0.0540395342,
0.1562954634,
-0.3036418855,
-0.1414284557,
0.6245965362,
-0.694442749,
0.2657095492,
0.4126380682,
0.9868505001,
0.0343779996,
-0.4086071551,
0.5296255946,
-0.3664031625,
0.2294958234,
0.0159243867,
0.2845052779,
0.3138730526,
0.153282091,
0.3092495501,
0.0327283479,
-0.5998539329,
-0.7773899436,
0.1915809661,
-0.696348846,
-0.1081634015,
1.2907098532,
-0.1999011636,
-0.2205982953,
-0.0054976651,
-0.1041642651,
0.1707643121,
-0.1728958189,
0.5328010917,
0.3752382398,
0.5899988413,
0.0562063232,
-0.5157444477,
0.1014988199,
0.2689479291,
-0.9527044892,
0.2095774859,
0.634401679,
0.1936929971,
0.1126230955,
0.5704907775,
-0.1570502967,
0.0928967968,
-0.2286327034,
0.2573153079,
-0.1611002386,
-0.6519111991,
-0.3294456899,
0.2827188969,
0.716283083,
-0.0261388253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19840v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19840v1 | AnomaLLMy -- Detecting anomalous tokens in black-box LLMs through low-confidence single-token predictions | 2024-06-28T11:28:44 | 2024-06-28T11:28:44 | Waligóra Witold | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper introduces AnomaLLMy, a novel technique for the automatic
detection of anomalous tokens in black-box Large Language Models (LLMs) with
API-only access. Utilizing low-confidence single-token predictions as a
cost-effective indicator, AnomaLLMy identifies irregularities in model
behavior, addressing the issue of anomalous tokens degrading the quality and
reliability of models. Validated on the cl100k_base dataset, the token set of
GPT-4, AnomaLLMy detected 413 major and 65 minor anomalies, demonstrating the
method's efficiency with just \$24.39 spent in API credits. The insights from
this research are expected to be beneficial for enhancing the robustness of and
accuracy of LLMs, particularly in the development and assessment of tokenizers. | [
-0.0810568854,
-0.875459969,
0.5582386851,
0.1755743325,
-0.0894415304,
0.2465010583,
0.1144737452,
-0.3062659502,
0.3939180374,
0.7831476331,
-0.6975728273,
-0.817648828,
-0.6937877536,
0.2155941427,
-0.799276948,
0.4082040489,
0.1691375077,
-0.1679030508,
-0.2610885203,
-0.0192752406,
-0.52890414,
-0.705046773,
-0.7560116053,
-0.1445506364,
0.1503228247,
0.32025069,
0.7707066536,
1.072652936,
0.4073370993,
0.2625288665,
-0.2990702093,
0.2256891876,
-0.2685371041,
-0.195048213,
0.0550586991,
-0.8678088188,
-0.64947474,
-0.0440929383,
0.5162638426,
0.290343672,
0.0074661621,
0.2408820689,
-0.1469890326,
0.294092834,
-0.442307353,
0.0775686577,
-0.7937159538,
0.147491619,
-0.5463662744,
-0.1837402135,
-0.3467060924,
-0.2932895422,
-0.2423233241,
-0.3754504323,
0.1371854097,
0.4381947517,
0.9030171633,
0.3842919171,
-0.2056910843,
-0.5924671888,
-0.366237253,
1.164269805,
-0.993214488,
0.1012846604,
0.3454451859,
0.1607490182,
-0.5949736834,
-0.7736868262,
-0.6297208071,
-0.195055142,
-0.315335393,
-0.2755041718,
-0.5031117797,
-0.0135982325,
0.1376153976,
0.3835403621,
-0.5153303742,
0.3684282005,
-0.2529362738,
-0.6626326442,
0.4961438477,
0.2127307504,
0.3191644549,
-0.402264595,
-0.6364184022,
0.5789862275,
-0.9667073488,
-0.2642027438,
0.8412120342,
0.3099929988,
-0.2223965973,
0.5673111677,
0.1942822635,
0.6233667135,
-0.0069774715,
-0.1826632321,
0.0924646184,
-0.5806819797,
-0.0131175518,
0.1462861449,
0.5536267161,
-0.1356414109,
0.276378721,
-0.227311492,
-0.4063359201,
0.1345193684,
0.1084550992,
-0.661696434,
-0.2630345821,
0.5493097901,
-0.5568165779,
-0.3706485331,
-0.1785761714,
-0.707406044,
-0.6400108337,
-0.1489706188,
0.5230333209,
-0.2333262116,
-0.6678550243,
-0.0839508623,
-0.1129245982,
-0.3278001845,
0.2651203871,
-0.3791173995,
0.1586368084,
0.6265773773,
1.0156970024,
-0.5840252042,
-0.5086538196,
-0.5212076306,
-0.0054580797,
-0.3734439909,
0.8912913203,
-0.5386954546,
-0.4726063907,
0.0488006696,
0.0942076445,
-0.0812727585,
-0.6241847277,
0.3279876709,
-0.0056107561,
0.1082755327,
0.1027311087,
-0.7212613821,
-0.2944443524,
0.3791237175,
-0.5584575534,
0.821074605,
0.1527043283,
-0.548165381,
0.2642771006,
-0.6766733527,
0.0047748126,
0.2683262229,
-0.1149291992,
-0.33261922,
0.3349313438,
-0.0316222757,
0.3122141361,
-0.0970510617,
0.1889711618,
-0.4801777303,
-0.7422881722,
0.6422452927,
-0.6029456258,
0.7098895907,
0.0854529738,
-0.2738563716,
0.1597374976,
-0.7976071835,
-0.2154742479,
0.005390727,
-0.1347099096,
-0.2577059567,
-0.2079339027,
-0.1932951361,
0.0987225771,
0.432780385,
-0.4827178419,
0.3344544172,
-0.4585672617,
0.3310440481,
0.9109788537,
0.060123492,
0.3807469308,
-0.1654784828,
0.653840661,
0.27021873,
0.1966141164,
-0.356082648,
-0.7869276404,
-0.6579440832,
-0.7589315772,
0.531347692,
0.3833106458,
-0.3339618444,
0.523678124,
0.1461791992,
-0.0859971642,
-0.8527123332,
0.4598247707,
0.3012595177,
0.4411908686,
0.3118359745,
-0.3064570427,
-0.5814692378,
-0.7852707505,
-0.4095682204,
-0.134284988,
0.0569707118,
0.319590956,
0.5875914693,
-0.6710384488,
0.9159743786,
-0.2452443391,
-0.4905025661,
0.0757646784,
0.3127459586,
0.5276529193,
0.3364075422,
0.7322863936,
-0.5322952867,
-0.3104963601,
-0.1939411014,
-0.6304838657,
-0.1936485618,
0.1367069185,
-0.1136610806,
0.4101157784,
0.4310129583,
-0.5898677707,
0.7874403,
0.8426364064,
-0.6358010173,
0.5303917527,
-0.2171462476,
0.0787433907,
-0.7300254107,
-0.0494682156,
-0.326223582,
-0.0583205931,
-0.7846877575,
-0.1519378126,
0.406722635,
0.193421647,
-0.4394578338,
0.8839188218,
-0.3730196953,
0.1763493717,
-0.5940830112,
-0.0421911255,
-0.1624947786,
0.3264560997,
-0.3638772964,
0.8375462294,
0.6964431405,
-0.5574028492,
0.353905499,
-0.03989885,
0.0714567527,
0.5031754971,
-0.0626357645,
0.1921715587,
-0.0587834455,
-0.2036020756,
-1.3870069981,
-0.1091438457,
0.236805886,
-0.6059105396,
0.3535284996,
-0.5824950337,
-0.4309652448,
-0.4400544465,
-0.3294419944,
0.1990918815,
0.2638219595,
-0.9279267192,
0.7823559046,
0.455699414,
-0.099174805,
-0.776787281,
-0.8021831512,
0.2561716437,
-0.3542957604,
-0.3234555125,
-0.0963447839,
-0.0446073078,
-0.02629162,
0.3320052922,
-0.3742550611,
-0.0936795995,
0.4451054931,
0.3013970852,
0.3682750463,
-0.1388233453,
0.0659354031,
-0.1001523361,
-0.159766376,
0.0990231708,
-0.4638291299,
0.7788634896,
0.0953755602,
-0.3260644376,
-0.4624614418,
-0.0521429442,
0.4604477882,
0.1022986621,
0.5161374211,
0.6260199547,
-0.7347311974,
-0.2399390787,
-0.7064567208,
-0.1277857721,
-0.4787772298,
0.2570392191,
-0.0703036413,
-0.6884326339,
0.6641351581,
-0.0368148759,
-0.2030930221,
0.3720119894,
0.589194119,
0.3768472373,
1.215965867,
0.3849597573,
-0.23030819,
0.3112130761,
-0.0530711226,
0.2850415111,
-0.426099062,
-0.104933612,
-0.5464835763,
-0.1678875238,
-0.5464995503,
-0.516538322,
0.0483478494,
0.0826382414,
0.022712009,
0.2711592615,
-0.3806233406,
0.3354894519,
0.6944243908,
-0.2255302519,
0.5043982863,
-0.0991165265,
-0.2433820367,
0.142491892,
-0.4440821707,
-0.4882253706,
1.4249539375,
0.3909234703,
0.7198625207,
0.2635037303,
0.7212198973,
0.5020303726,
0.6411075592,
-0.83208251,
0.3438571692,
-0.0895626098,
-0.8176590204,
-0.2790382802,
-0.6221368909,
-0.8821482658,
-0.1010340676,
-0.3400016427,
-1.0109522343,
0.3308955133,
0.4950433671,
-0.097522147,
0.3085721433,
-0.9119173288,
0.7725014091,
-0.2964582443,
-0.2023830414,
-0.0814683139,
0.0364041515,
0.6028398275,
-0.3255603015,
0.4919399023,
-0.4147742987,
-0.2286115736,
0.3746663928,
-0.1830258816,
0.6624549031,
-0.3984137177,
-0.0112300208,
0.3245582283,
0.3071864843,
0.6816253662,
0.2942551374,
-0.1698886007,
0.5874419808,
0.0258988868,
-0.5661462545,
-0.2200949937,
0.8608896136,
-0.4143626392,
-0.5849903226,
-0.4230257273,
-0.5743887424,
-0.1318006665,
0.3717063069,
0.1121831015,
0.1813342869,
0.0778229088,
0.1266745329,
0.4396132529,
-0.2237012833,
0.52070719,
0.5173845887,
-0.3654001355,
-0.4031436145,
0.8455778956,
0.1426600665,
-0.0070017972,
0.090861775,
0.3875565231,
-0.5845192671,
-0.9926908612,
-0.4692770541,
0.3106351197,
-0.4158703983,
-0.5347277522,
-0.4772959352,
-0.0633081421,
-0.4868520796,
0.3579372764,
-0.3992034197,
-0.6044543982,
-0.2453927249,
-0.1183394045,
0.3424427509,
0.6388567686,
0.004613678,
0.3723110557,
-0.6110192537,
0.1214513108,
0.3127508163,
0.3792465925,
0.0161416996,
-0.5948680639,
-0.2262635231,
-0.0675426498,
-0.1174536943,
-0.7835568786,
0.6786812544,
0.0480105095,
0.783975482,
0.7308626771,
-0.1682232171,
0.7444902658,
-0.2311439961,
0.7555434108,
0.2620390356,
-1.0883563757,
0.4942634702,
0.0408932865,
0.2420418859,
0.1814648956,
0.3712842464,
-0.2658021748,
-0.8537347317,
-0.6105908155,
-0.8810474873,
0.887796104,
0.2584214211,
0.0477252528,
0.0004128314,
0.5657935739,
0.1537794024,
0.6878969073,
-0.6388083696,
-0.6936827302,
-0.1739743501,
-0.3556978106,
-0.0520830154,
-0.4928180277,
-0.2269462049,
0.0826053619,
0.594391048,
-0.1693521291,
0.3183903694,
-0.1585913002,
-0.2525245249,
-0.3433642983,
0.1654613316,
0.6171509624,
0.8396014571,
-0.4000669122,
0.351682961,
0.2913320065,
-0.6168897152,
-0.0101502798,
0.1736443639,
-0.1247935221,
0.2540682852,
0.3613205254,
0.6432719231,
0.0581181422,
-0.7254050374,
0.6376560926,
-0.2451465279,
-0.1632387191,
-0.3373234272,
0.1783079058,
-0.0662652031,
0.115186587,
0.7455501556,
-0.0424642377,
0.1825255752,
-0.5443396568,
0.2951615751,
0.6165505052,
-0.366653204,
-0.4592632055,
0.5002159476,
-0.1326224655,
-0.6288829446,
0.1522700191,
-0.4781219363,
-0.4487811327,
0.6229631901,
0.6064673662,
0.7163482904,
-0.4693962336,
0.0184826627,
0.1441473365,
0.4196056128,
-0.1456192583,
0.0990607366,
0.3402893841,
-0.817358017,
-0.2033734918,
-0.718328774,
-0.65208143,
0.3564991057,
-0.3707367182,
0.4730073512,
-0.4464054406,
-0.2197228968,
-0.0506134629,
0.152718693,
-0.6391025186,
-0.0308605004,
0.1406426281,
0.8117389083,
-0.7433789372,
0.8223763704,
0.646151185,
-0.0716173053,
-0.5445350409,
-0.0830291286,
0.4041332603,
-1.2500997782,
0.2638893425,
0.1777279824,
0.1905767322,
0.1007453948,
-0.4054543972,
-0.9910528064,
1.0698151588,
0.4186447561,
-0.5021133423,
0.0017826497,
0.0308287814,
0.3251465261,
-0.4531096518,
0.2235337198,
0.8638657331,
0.7642351985,
0.0494505577,
-0.7774466276,
0.1859718859,
0.0372139812,
-0.2400447577,
0.450009048,
-0.4622637331,
0.9870408773,
0.0835333169,
-0.3937322795,
0.2882732153,
0.185362637,
0.3641885221,
0.4964800775,
0.5597655773,
0.3309193552,
1.1834397316,
-0.2930584848,
0.7710649967,
-0.5806176066,
0.5493318439,
0.5165134072,
0.0897978991,
0.4267966449,
0.6254816055,
-0.0719591081,
0.2904046476,
0.3609918654,
-0.1661365032,
0.3745958805,
0.3424967229,
-0.3342071176,
-0.2325880229,
-0.0392875373,
-0.3347110152,
0.3936792314,
0.7197473645,
-0.1042916477,
0.0022123402,
-0.0694769099,
0.2090355009,
-0.0882053748,
-0.5784588456,
0.6591725945,
0.14506194,
-0.3126234114,
0.5621296763,
-0.0000650714,
1.0470588207,
-0.5047339201,
0.0034304352,
-0.4176834822,
0.3661923707,
-0.3542905152,
-0.3309269249,
0.1745239794,
0.0584301166,
0.1591317356,
-0.0431390181,
0.9721255898,
-0.452154994,
-0.5706269145,
0.4468991458,
0.6743660569,
0.0572808236,
-0.0540438145,
-0.6792260408,
0.006769333,
-0.1972941756,
-0.0791848823,
0.2878066599,
0.6590954065,
0.107162267,
0.6591973901,
0.7083231807,
0.5565164685,
0.0915335268,
-0.2771519721,
0.583055079,
-0.8192861676,
-0.4278580546,
-0.9887897372,
0.2335530221,
-0.1451362669,
-0.1957315058,
0.9092419744,
0.6699842215,
0.5681307912,
-0.0024107327,
0.793703258,
0.3811469674,
0.7894881368,
-0.4919757545,
0.61162287,
-0.5758336186,
0.6592459679,
0.0378843956,
-0.5884873271,
-0.524382472,
0.3752301931,
-0.0645830333,
-0.4666553736,
0.7522690296,
1.1623854637,
0.0307237003,
-0.1798262596,
0.4941061437,
0.552121222,
0.1028868854,
0.2130875885,
1.026758194,
-0.2453795522,
0.8523347378,
-0.08842545,
-0.2569115162,
-0.4361537993,
-0.9855080843,
-1.2470060587,
0.1578033715,
-0.2829264998,
-0.5651535988,
0.1374541223,
0.8022581339,
0.5723588467,
-1.2504090071,
-0.3928475082,
-0.1521472484,
0.8415437937,
-0.279484272,
-0.2559989095,
0.1883004457,
-0.5977532268,
-1.0360505581,
0.4600712061,
0.6065261364,
0.2073492557,
-0.3638640046,
-0.0411546975,
-0.1372482628,
0.2730287611,
0.2163468599,
0.1571049988,
-0.6511395574,
-0.5011488795,
0.0296413507,
0.0639810488,
0.033922635,
0.6483546495,
-0.4046348035,
0.4413122237,
0.1485974789,
0.4743413329,
0.4899222553,
-0.0315387957,
0.4943474531,
-1.0525758266,
0.4737741351,
0.1528049856,
0.3665534556,
0.0598137118,
-0.5061987042,
0.3688843548,
0.5330295563,
-0.2520203292,
-1.4625147581,
0.0155495936,
-0.6243658066,
-0.2880924046,
1.116137743,
-0.2864401042,
-0.3478883803,
-0.4039559364,
-0.0482723638,
-0.1789031923,
-0.4178691506,
0.8659952879,
0.8630836606,
-0.0880691707,
0.0453680009,
-0.3995460868,
0.6208491325,
0.0870768651,
-0.6642994881,
-0.2435972393,
0.2178517282,
0.2459285855,
0.4071645141,
0.4231719673,
-0.0933729112,
0.3573122919,
-0.0634376481,
-0.1116684154,
-0.385348171,
-0.2430569679,
-0.4999345839,
0.3012086451,
0.2280119359,
-0.3252948821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19820v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19820v1 | BeamAggR: Beam Aggregation Reasoning over Multi-source Knowledge for Multi-hop Question Answering | 2024-06-28T10:53:48 | 2024-06-28T10:53:48 | Zheng Chu, Jingchang Chen, Qianglong Chen, Haotian Wang, Kun Zhu, Xiyuan Du, Weijiang Yu, Ming Liu, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated strong reasoning capabilities.
Nevertheless, they still suffer from factual errors when tackling
knowledge-intensive tasks. Retrieval-augmented reasoning represents a promising
approach. However, significant challenges still persist, including inaccurate
and insufficient retrieval for complex questions, as well as difficulty in
integrating multi-source knowledge. To address this, we propose Beam
Aggregation Reasoning, BeamAggR, a reasoning framework for knowledge-intensive
multi-hop QA. BeamAggR explores and prioritizes promising answers at each hop
of question. Concretely, we parse the complex questions into trees, which
include atom and composite questions, followed by bottom-up reasoning. For
atomic questions, the LLM conducts reasoning on multi-source knowledge to get
answer candidates. For composite questions, the LLM combines beam candidates,
explores multiple reasoning paths through probabilistic aggregation, and
prioritizes the most promising trajectory. Extensive experiments on four
open-domain multi-hop reasoning datasets show that our method significantly
outperforms SOTA methods by 8.5%. Furthermore, our analysis reveals that
BeamAggR elicits better knowledge collaboration and answer aggregation. | [
-0.420923382,
-1.1662745476,
0.9573814273,
0.1680403799,
0.0366506539,
0.4927895963,
0.2287600338,
-0.3012241721,
-0.0225167535,
0.2943302989,
-0.2420100421,
-0.4772390127,
-0.6476097703,
-0.1361202747,
-0.1454418451,
0.5334106684,
0.0053057391,
0.046456296,
-0.5310708284,
-0.2995721102,
-0.5781416297,
-0.229039222,
-0.5534741282,
-0.3271234632,
0.5469124913,
0.4292554557,
0.7306765318,
0.322191596,
0.6516525149,
0.3156880736,
-0.4157950282,
0.7854481339,
-0.1750969738,
0.3041804433,
-0.439460218,
-0.2993419468,
-0.5420616269,
-0.4221172929,
0.4759005904,
0.7841594219,
-0.1200790703,
0.2161307484,
-0.3968738616,
0.3818357289,
-0.6431244612,
0.133223474,
-0.5964031816,
-0.2433227003,
-0.0918866321,
-0.1822989583,
-0.6033013463,
-0.3602647483,
-0.2279563844,
-0.4191916585,
-0.0583686903,
0.3956950903,
0.5409421325,
0.2840877771,
-0.7765439749,
-0.1345072687,
-0.4065448046,
0.674438417,
-0.4235086143,
0.3925178051,
0.3078818619,
0.4308020771,
-0.2490454614,
-0.7258142829,
-0.1691152304,
0.0356082544,
-0.300924927,
0.1859171242,
-0.152560845,
0.3560342193,
0.0586197637,
0.1127610281,
-1.0956063271,
-0.3374858201,
-0.1932470053,
-0.2961566448,
0.6429046392,
0.0550546497,
0.0583266914,
0.0248459801,
-0.4543664157,
0.1800361425,
-0.4879680574,
0.0449608453,
-0.1479786634,
0.1979692131,
0.3250918686,
0.6231079102,
-0.4455986619,
1.0965048075,
0.1302640587,
-0.0302500781,
0.156708777,
-0.5914920568,
-0.018156888,
0.0820275396,
0.548384726,
0.0982177109,
-0.0428626277,
-0.1786237061,
0.2189936936,
-0.2180918902,
0.0888575539,
-0.6063627601,
0.1602562964,
0.7322489023,
-0.4622772336,
0.3077838123,
-0.2412340045,
-0.60668993,
-0.2406475544,
0.0664459988,
0.6083623171,
-0.5706332326,
-0.1997200549,
0.3685272336,
-0.4463766813,
0.1766582876,
0.4681197703,
-0.3949754238,
-0.3197367489,
0.8885766864,
0.752124846,
0.3524374664,
-0.5606822371,
-0.9034026265,
0.3204711676,
-0.3396505713,
1.2530417442,
-0.731541276,
-0.2339220494,
-0.2053672075,
-0.3659808636,
-0.0990486816,
-0.2864613831,
0.3612511158,
-0.9064124227,
0.2452873886,
-0.1956937313,
-0.8842291832,
-0.2096402198,
0.5327435732,
-0.1601036936,
0.6666463614,
0.0388342701,
-0.7796688676,
0.3143429756,
-0.4407896399,
-0.3582393825,
0.5271204114,
-0.2607825994,
-0.0492515899,
-0.0917567238,
0.3104939163,
0.3197978437,
-0.39997679,
0.7593016624,
-0.5226562619,
-0.1871318072,
-0.0433059707,
0.0101607963,
0.8110545278,
0.6402301192,
0.1637622267,
0.0790546611,
-0.4394058883,
0.167507574,
0.0415725484,
-0.4861468673,
-0.3071181476,
0.1204480156,
-0.5930930972,
0.0681411028,
0.2699792683,
-0.4459783137,
0.5345181227,
-0.0820003822,
0.0910763592,
0.4947125018,
0.1881172955,
0.3792636395,
-0.4191493392,
0.7311108112,
-0.0424135961,
0.0201287139,
-0.5680602193,
-0.8284083605,
-0.2550088167,
-0.218093425,
-0.101660572,
0.3685509861,
-1.1590474844,
0.1965879202,
-0.2277075946,
-0.5788878202,
-0.5032120347,
-0.0559041947,
0.4404528439,
0.6745416522,
0.6055301428,
0.2873748243,
-0.2588733733,
-0.5046396255,
-0.4086833,
-0.4552125633,
0.1685638428,
0.2162078172,
0.3507840037,
-0.1149690971,
1.1506485939,
-0.8001233339,
-0.0897408873,
-0.2227191031,
0.4821805358,
0.3399504721,
0.2149595618,
0.350956887,
-0.9416077733,
-0.2523481846,
0.0914553627,
-0.837790072,
-0.1560749412,
-0.2215406895,
-0.3857083917,
-0.3665934205,
0.5251759887,
-0.9992527366,
-0.2561478317,
0.6121831536,
-0.7592483759,
0.6993792653,
-0.1239989623,
0.350030154,
-1.0539652109,
-0.0501813106,
-0.2819061875,
-0.1007623598,
-0.593605876,
0.4395987093,
-0.0962665528,
0.078791149,
-0.3611605167,
0.8207550645,
-0.2673817277,
-0.1292733699,
-0.227958262,
0.2810943425,
0.3559832573,
0.265794754,
-0.0561768599,
0.8691551685,
0.6760079861,
-0.345189333,
0.7569394112,
0.5654566288,
-0.2761075497,
0.6742272377,
-0.5238411427,
0.0406719036,
-0.5146448612,
0.4646885693,
-1.1190633774,
-0.1715790629,
-0.1485384703,
-0.7960115671,
-0.0190873276,
-0.1658712029,
-0.2482355684,
-0.2819762826,
0.0136150289,
0.6201016307,
0.0659829974,
-0.6005086303,
1.157019496,
0.2504678369,
-0.1504027545,
-0.8183073401,
-0.4071676433,
-0.1015220955,
-0.0908063427,
-1.0528726578,
0.1368633956,
-0.1349798143,
-0.512567997,
0.2515919507,
-0.0180879477,
-0.2104255259,
0.0824608281,
-0.1844496429,
0.0294313263,
-0.26919204,
0.5954385996,
0.1297047585,
-0.1154255122,
-0.1102627292,
-0.4698159695,
0.4298737645,
-0.3308778703,
-0.7542786598,
0.5463173985,
0.5300087333,
0.5068351626,
-0.5457383394,
0.6808552742,
0.7198747396,
-0.0829407796,
-0.1333470941,
-0.6177278161,
-0.0509388261,
-0.3875495791,
0.4518720806,
-0.6496981382,
-1.2596724033,
0.4767292738,
-0.2506117523,
0.2702889144,
0.2412297726,
0.6845393181,
-0.2306583375,
1.2539311647,
-0.0878719836,
0.1813807189,
-0.0059418688,
-0.159023568,
0.4105352163,
-0.5629651546,
-0.4492962956,
-0.5683977008,
-0.065917477,
-0.0747380257,
-0.8294293284,
0.4693098962,
0.3109811842,
-0.3167870641,
0.0741764382,
-0.2362933606,
0.4031332433,
0.6361510754,
-0.1342636645,
0.5803598166,
-0.4989925921,
0.0428066701,
0.6826681495,
-0.9388522506,
-0.077585496,
0.6543657184,
0.0354191363,
0.7663114667,
0.1773446798,
0.5368025303,
0.1723085344,
-0.028517222,
-0.7002161145,
0.5526174307,
0.1765184999,
-1.2141764164,
-0.3251500428,
-0.8409311175,
-1.0747027397,
0.7306401134,
0.0900124162,
-0.6057975292,
0.1646122336,
0.3661723137,
-0.4510577917,
0.2244685143,
-0.7777785063,
0.8465407491,
-0.4016407728,
-0.2804318368,
-0.2465619892,
-0.8392407894,
0.5094841719,
-0.0167961977,
0.6215987802,
-0.3107740879,
0.3589801192,
0.4043062031,
-0.2679906785,
0.1311354637,
-0.2170343101,
0.0897775218,
0.8187062144,
0.266654551,
0.5006557107,
-0.040422231,
0.0189047698,
0.1423048973,
0.0062243794,
-0.6042228937,
-0.6129738092,
0.4176675975,
-0.4688012302,
-0.8433997035,
-0.3293948174,
-0.7921087742,
-0.5899101496,
0.2045907974,
0.0067097871,
0.3698441982,
0.2757665217,
0.4399851561,
0.409319967,
-0.026539525,
0.1848999858,
0.3904961944,
-0.600122571,
-0.3360477984,
0.7960001826,
-0.0309168324,
0.4510426223,
0.6053397059,
0.3808497787,
-0.3825318515,
-0.576621592,
-0.4704535306,
0.3144555986,
-0.7546070814,
-0.399122864,
-0.7642418742,
-0.154958874,
-0.4868712723,
-0.3436503708,
-0.2297221124,
-0.229757145,
0.0925032422,
-0.2835400701,
0.2836848199,
-0.0120190196,
0.0404444002,
0.1978320181,
-1.4104884863,
0.4101899862,
0.6878644228,
0.3034400344,
-0.1660276055,
-0.4308309555,
-0.3217978776,
-0.031609118,
-0.1704060137,
-0.7607706785,
0.1338783801,
0.0981437489,
0.7877380252,
0.4362249672,
-0.0668103397,
0.6621891856,
-0.3613734841,
0.7235895395,
0.143118754,
-0.7424347997,
0.5115482807,
-0.532930851,
0.4638619721,
0.4798464179,
0.3932166994,
-0.4302129447,
-0.5408201814,
-0.5626044869,
-0.7073038816,
0.7244703174,
-0.1330404282,
-0.2331849635,
-0.107590273,
-0.0256417096,
-0.200149864,
0.2183979452,
-0.3876177073,
-0.1317887902,
-0.0592039898,
-0.0447293222,
0.090701513,
-0.2191442102,
-0.1598889083,
0.0415285006,
0.5662360787,
-0.466491431,
0.0323693901,
-0.0323077217,
-0.1528931111,
-0.0203029178,
0.3753274679,
0.1195182875,
0.8075974584,
-0.3917531073,
0.5208261013,
0.0645184815,
0.0045005227,
0.3486125767,
0.0869590044,
-0.0538804978,
-0.0924477726,
0.6560263038,
0.6397354603,
-0.387090534,
-1.0372283459,
0.5584146976,
0.0286099445,
-0.3972199559,
0.3129997849,
-0.0675287619,
0.3906545341,
0.5717003345,
0.499464184,
0.0793793947,
0.1244132817,
-0.4313393831,
0.23185426,
0.6020620465,
0.0678881034,
0.0721796677,
0.6655326486,
0.1173480377,
-0.1248854771,
0.5086421371,
-0.4317039251,
-0.377794683,
0.5534470677,
0.373051703,
0.5422122478,
-0.240370065,
0.4551081061,
0.2967713475,
0.1518676877,
-0.1080196723,
0.2777587771,
-0.0747943744,
-1.1080815792,
-1.0281205177,
-0.587613821,
-0.5301030278,
-0.4113799036,
-0.3005918562,
0.0928964913,
-0.0359086432,
-0.0287756696,
-0.1863704473,
-0.3765692115,
-0.1337681562,
0.0738163218,
0.2110926211,
0.828325212,
-0.8972215652,
0.4660652876,
0.8508480191,
-0.4972702265,
-0.7611002922,
-0.2086916119,
-0.0419055484,
-0.9348229766,
0.576644659,
-0.0994057655,
-0.2324879616,
0.0392730795,
-0.3838374317,
-1.1525384188,
1.0459604263,
0.4078989923,
-0.2001981586,
-0.0878539607,
-0.2541163266,
0.3350998163,
-0.045530308,
0.5806365013,
0.4952511787,
0.617117703,
0.7713901997,
-0.6355930567,
-0.1901250482,
0.0280100554,
-0.2634429336,
0.2744518816,
-0.8792114854,
0.810495913,
-0.274196744,
0.0598262697,
-0.535518527,
0.5969638228,
0.7751328349,
0.5705941319,
0.3730900288,
0.6711575389,
0.7241986394,
-0.0844984949,
0.9399799705,
-0.2764183581,
0.4558660686,
1.0507334471,
-0.3664370179,
0.3669500053,
0.4399520159,
-0.3823239207,
0.3628636897,
0.5763078332,
0.2841047943,
0.3778858483,
-0.2065960765,
-0.2289800942,
-0.6916326284,
-0.2896912694,
-0.3410403728,
0.6444054842,
0.2352687418,
0.1804393381,
-0.6376121044,
0.0057147532,
0.0481456146,
-0.0605938956,
-0.3326515555,
0.6835182309,
-0.0020507514,
-0.93123734,
0.3154886961,
-0.0847841352,
0.1214947104,
-0.6199878454,
-0.087155059,
-0.492043525,
0.066444993,
-0.2914091349,
-0.8254469633,
0.4666992128,
-0.125923723,
0.0032136475,
-0.4033684731,
0.7031367421,
-0.5570784807,
-0.3888040781,
0.3492471874,
1.0368000269,
-0.0042829178,
-0.2083633095,
-0.4947278798,
-0.2887723446,
-0.0387600362,
-0.3423483968,
0.3426501453,
0.5303416252,
0.0596589297,
0.9494863153,
0.6212176085,
0.156740725,
0.1998314261,
0.0638073236,
0.8270106912,
-0.3012992144,
-0.401530534,
-0.7622520328,
0.6675173044,
-0.0499513969,
-0.0127196973,
0.8773410916,
0.4955724478,
0.565027833,
0.2020444423,
0.5646857619,
-0.185555771,
0.6445925236,
-0.5539280772,
0.1577340513,
-0.6338614821,
0.1008326337,
-0.0947232395,
-0.8290261626,
-0.4970770478,
0.5310269594,
-0.3853568733,
0.0455626324,
0.8342831731,
0.7057582736,
0.1208761558,
-0.1110581607,
0.3896446526,
0.1664814204,
0.7053642869,
0.7237671614,
1.1447784901,
0.060616836,
0.9332405925,
0.3060097992,
-0.184634462,
-0.3182335496,
-0.7368831038,
-0.4236451387,
-0.3456286192,
-0.2952923179,
-0.1781785488,
-0.1063462645,
0.9312170744,
0.5862766504,
-0.6596339345,
-0.0628722236,
-0.1685910672,
0.630251646,
-0.3969452381,
-0.2287058234,
0.3500733078,
-0.6420218945,
-0.3794902861,
0.7132984996,
0.3951622248,
-0.5261307359,
0.0544925891,
-0.0441093892,
-0.6211331487,
0.1075534448,
0.692440927,
0.0544485115,
-0.4645254016,
-0.4328531325,
0.0836666003,
0.1051021218,
0.1090848669,
0.6037265062,
-0.7007376552,
0.839985311,
0.8942994475,
0.9229275584,
0.425575912,
0.6374322176,
0.1187999919,
-0.7752553821,
0.0314785875,
0.449600786,
0.5586418509,
-0.1432786286,
-0.1620597392,
0.3886154294,
0.2033624947,
-0.8859220743,
-0.5602141023,
0.3810305297,
-0.7217814326,
-0.756993413,
1.3878791332,
-0.3592367172,
0.1584201306,
-0.2486166805,
-0.2659791112,
-0.0269182958,
-0.2691591084,
0.6331560016,
0.8168558478,
-0.5774022937,
-0.3390627205,
-0.0449359044,
0.0084272241,
0.3624283671,
-1.0449886322,
0.095292531,
1.0251274109,
-0.2630850375,
0.4481807351,
0.9633305669,
0.1703620106,
0.2335292697,
0.2307171673,
-0.1264809966,
-0.2276812047,
-0.5941173434,
-0.1664121747,
0.7376013994,
0.3388454616,
-0.2188778371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00134v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00134v1 | A Simple Attention-Based Mechanism for Bimodal Emotion Classification | 2024-06-28T10:43:02 | 2024-06-28T10:43:02 | Mazen Elabd, Sardar Jaf | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Big data contain rich information for machine learning algorithms to utilize
when learning important features during classification tasks. Human beings
express their emotion using certain words, speech (tone, pitch, speed) or
facial expression. Artificial Intelligence approach to emotion classification
are largely based on learning from textual information. However, public
datasets containing text and speech data provide sufficient resources to train
machine learning algorithms for the tack of emotion classification. In this
paper, we present novel bimodal deep learning-based architectures enhanced with
attention mechanism trained and tested on text and speech data for emotion
classification. We report details of different deep learning based
architectures and show the performance of each architecture including rigorous
error analyses. Our finding suggests that deep learning based architectures
trained on different types of data (text and speech) outperform architectures
trained only on text or speech. Our proposed attention-based bimodal
architecture outperforms several state-of-the-art systems in emotion
classification. | [
-0.3684341013,
-0.6379048824,
0.2774282992,
0.4981923997,
-0.1545216888,
0.0497239679,
-0.3838177025,
-0.4964033067,
-0.081396699,
0.0741849691,
-0.4202027619,
-0.3795281053,
-0.4323536158,
-0.122139141,
-0.0548733659,
0.8079385161,
-0.0133303003,
0.241919592,
-0.1161890626,
-0.4620409608,
-0.3121069968,
-0.5542621017,
-0.4353340864,
-0.2377347499,
0.8969982862,
0.3924985826,
0.5038925409,
0.1673617959,
0.5842896104,
0.3934054077,
0.1443630457,
0.254566133,
-0.3351853192,
0.0237849317,
-0.0173719209,
-0.3671141565,
-0.2659392059,
0.037395034,
0.2351599932,
0.1955692768,
0.0136073902,
0.2017982155,
-0.0677886307,
0.9067922235,
-0.7952581644,
0.6780887246,
-0.1049988121,
0.5513982177,
-0.1871640086,
-0.10793522,
-0.5027861595,
-0.2344049215,
0.1418863088,
0.0294352956,
-0.0813580453,
0.1009835303,
0.6340587139,
0.5689301491,
-0.6058207154,
-0.3727583587,
-0.638888061,
0.4924185872,
-0.4557113051,
0.5476936102,
0.0935961902,
0.2489084601,
0.5262362361,
-0.5270345807,
-0.7920607328,
-0.0771678314,
0.0640696064,
0.3051273227,
-0.2705533803,
0.3170662224,
0.1910014898,
0.4632301927,
-0.8247318268,
0.1368442178,
-0.0377800651,
0.0864674821,
0.5385860205,
0.3479828537,
0.2215144634,
-0.2086450309,
-0.5398699641,
-0.3101637065,
-0.2114982754,
0.1083388478,
0.0992085189,
0.2427066863,
-0.4765267968,
0.2687025666,
-0.1705903858,
0.2616512179,
0.1698040813,
0.2434351593,
0.7049615979,
0.0729755834,
-0.5468548536,
0.3560588658,
0.6658165455,
0.4962949157,
0.2036797702,
-0.2906227112,
0.0892408192,
0.4491877258,
0.3220667541,
-0.8750918508,
0.074098967,
0.2192913592,
-0.5058693886,
-0.1840573251,
-0.2245166004,
-1.1623682976,
-0.3832511008,
-0.4816506207,
0.3736805916,
-0.3201060593,
-0.0198414586,
0.0572483353,
0.1291572899,
0.2118828744,
0.2872224152,
-0.8940179348,
-0.0010727828,
0.5548236966,
0.7519773245,
-0.0790859833,
0.1079520136,
-0.5217977166,
-0.1761337519,
-0.2853007019,
0.5471715331,
-0.6470984817,
0.2528975904,
0.2283872962,
-0.0914426595,
-0.0596151426,
-0.2971659303,
0.55607301,
-0.7545982003,
0.3505496085,
0.1246707812,
-0.3707838655,
-0.7557356954,
0.2795921862,
-0.6215387583,
0.5138473511,
0.0828829631,
-0.6772953272,
0.2278440893,
-0.8202401996,
-0.6805919409,
0.1228642613,
0.1436920464,
-0.5148615241,
0.3279540539,
0.0104235662,
0.8177802563,
-0.3852116764,
0.0610631108,
-0.7146562934,
-0.172339946,
0.3462171257,
-0.3991001844,
0.295083642,
0.5170406103,
-0.7874194384,
0.1220462248,
-0.8436166048,
-0.0238036681,
-0.1548417658,
-0.4641807973,
-0.1394531727,
-0.1546722949,
0.260569036,
0.3202936351,
-0.0039245044,
-0.5880803466,
-0.1235346496,
-0.5603557825,
0.3996228576,
0.6178918481,
-0.2446470708,
0.333417654,
0.1500467807,
0.3328256905,
0.2650765181,
-0.0875457376,
-0.2246726751,
-0.1770896763,
-0.7248280048,
-0.4379868507,
0.2243435979,
0.6942284703,
-0.484261632,
0.3693672121,
-0.1361402124,
-0.5279279351,
-0.8833354115,
0.1328835934,
0.6044778228,
0.6479572058,
0.1940988302,
-0.2234051526,
-0.4104347527,
-0.8519440293,
0.0788328201,
-0.044388745,
0.1589161307,
0.7536218762,
0.0122464811,
-0.5722477436,
0.5015483499,
-0.0968826413,
-0.0581615195,
-0.0081454143,
0.6464722753,
-0.0899935365,
0.1770990491,
0.5994096398,
-1.0733430386,
-0.5209504366,
0.2990698516,
-0.7940078378,
0.0204636026,
0.041789759,
0.1591109186,
0.60781914,
-0.0542718284,
-0.7956596017,
0.4633716047,
0.36234501,
-0.1110545695,
-0.0941647664,
0.1359130591,
0.2616809309,
-0.7350770235,
0.0560236797,
0.0720032603,
-0.0307229869,
-0.6148508787,
-0.3391013145,
0.2584471703,
-0.3705037832,
-0.5448763371,
0.4991849065,
-0.266910851,
-0.1947135925,
-0.2942183614,
-0.0729417056,
-0.0420210138,
1.0071716309,
0.2939807773,
0.0494251698,
0.7263677716,
-0.5764959455,
1.0722934008,
0.4513736367,
-0.4179293811,
0.6994485259,
-0.3355384171,
0.5485889316,
-0.416821599,
0.1001947001,
-1.3955125809,
-0.4499677718,
0.2419655174,
-0.5405591726,
0.5589471459,
0.1493241191,
-0.458532393,
-0.3506191969,
-0.3213062882,
0.0679790452,
0.5007704496,
-0.8406213522,
0.6878986955,
-0.0736254603,
-0.4880118966,
-0.3634799421,
-0.9064783454,
0.1233504638,
-0.3261817396,
-0.7576475143,
-0.1413060129,
0.0196964536,
0.0422692038,
-0.0044597681,
0.3639478385,
-0.0330501907,
-0.0273050386,
0.7732988,
0.1713969707,
-0.1520686597,
0.7093555927,
-0.0163666978,
-0.0664561614,
0.121622704,
0.3117673099,
0.4523947835,
-0.2898553014,
-0.2351275235,
-0.7887340188,
0.6808042526,
0.9756358862,
-0.4774531126,
0.2267533988,
1.0943809748,
-0.197752431,
-0.1353027821,
-0.5882176161,
0.0341808051,
-0.4549955726,
0.5887360573,
-0.1135451645,
-0.800588727,
0.0965580493,
-0.2883145511,
-0.1388513744,
0.0361012742,
1.0953981876,
-0.2198095024,
1.2762633562,
0.333586663,
-0.3645734489,
0.6215783358,
0.0365261808,
0.2660046816,
-0.6195136905,
-0.3081820309,
-0.4390943646,
-0.9145628214,
-0.3904875219,
-0.2636412382,
-0.0296663195,
-0.4773784876,
-0.5568023324,
-0.1732397527,
-0.4602515101,
-0.1116151363,
0.3437623084,
0.1774512529,
-0.3432400823,
0.347609669,
0.4413813949,
-0.0513293594,
-0.4269837439,
-0.2980684638,
0.7595604658,
0.5467193723,
0.8797850013,
0.0450841598,
0.3915103078,
0.4186854661,
0.5446984768,
-0.8046907187,
0.3599460125,
-0.0836314261,
-0.6182830334,
-0.1092380658,
-0.4675044417,
-0.6145700812,
-0.1039998531,
-0.0953458622,
-0.5851433873,
0.6317178607,
0.0616949163,
-0.2880224288,
0.0522571243,
-1.0824197531,
0.9791076779,
-0.6788260341,
-0.4899280667,
-0.4630199969,
-0.9278210402,
0.1062872335,
0.1708797067,
0.0346162356,
0.1138901263,
-0.078753069,
0.6283239722,
0.1430079043,
0.9681331515,
-0.3502060175,
0.2425503433,
0.1360938251,
-0.1801810265,
0.4791722596,
-0.0349879526,
-0.0925947949,
0.0955054462,
-0.7757539749,
-0.1904041022,
-0.7153431177,
0.5149267316,
-0.6157144904,
-0.2328278422,
-0.1782637537,
-0.5266459584,
-0.5640240908,
-0.1871090531,
-0.1030083969,
0.4063129425,
-0.0672255307,
0.6570615172,
0.8546938896,
-0.141287297,
0.7612937689,
0.4721878767,
0.1987840235,
-0.5315446258,
1.0525991917,
-0.2027294636,
-0.059985809,
0.6985334754,
0.0750449821,
-0.3633093238,
-0.310839653,
-0.4646333456,
-0.0951662511,
-0.3710912168,
-0.3844045699,
-0.8037387729,
0.1201247051,
-0.6279389262,
-0.0735526383,
-0.1612676531,
0.1002067253,
-0.3742943108,
-0.4388602376,
0.4010602534,
0.1722338796,
-0.1275455207,
-0.005882124,
-0.934706986,
0.4291606545,
0.8859198093,
0.4818496704,
0.2413093895,
-0.1437224299,
-0.2461687773,
0.0071847076,
-0.3522685468,
-0.8361308575,
0.5883718133,
0.3800968826,
0.0636763722,
0.9170508385,
-0.0019638042,
0.4803308249,
-0.2774834633,
0.4211962521,
0.4098448157,
-0.8494374156,
0.4544825256,
-0.0712948292,
0.1010223255,
0.3746638596,
0.6247497201,
-0.4701340199,
0.3654020727,
-0.2893613875,
-0.6547563076,
1.0764614344,
0.0498774052,
0.2852933109,
0.100183107,
0.1508236229,
-0.0320932306,
0.4921105504,
-0.5257248282,
-0.0211076252,
-0.4291983247,
-0.8230114579,
-0.1980276406,
-0.3014048338,
0.0360775702,
-0.0117797935,
0.2168585062,
-0.1363640428,
0.4720189571,
0.2579398453,
-0.1939961463,
-0.2373447865,
0.3892450631,
0.5749409795,
-0.3242207468,
-0.4006969333,
-0.0419540778,
0.0553481206,
-0.2759114802,
0.2009159029,
0.1436996013,
0.2240729332,
-0.0978971124,
0.3793542981,
1.4668802023,
0.2084911168,
-0.9044747949,
0.5223597288,
-0.0797773525,
-0.0253613796,
-0.0072608879,
-0.053197436,
0.4208270013,
0.7156413198,
0.0641513243,
-0.0221844967,
0.5964955688,
-1.0102881193,
-0.0430594794,
0.151905328,
-0.7746599913,
-0.3794909716,
0.3674770594,
0.4702847004,
-0.4717613757,
0.5165984035,
-0.2294481397,
-0.6060879827,
0.4761184454,
0.1512666047,
1.1206796169,
-0.4671261609,
0.1913870275,
-0.2130293697,
-0.0619154684,
0.561076045,
0.5098235607,
-0.4041542709,
-0.3773263693,
-0.2356990874,
-0.6010135412,
-0.4438520074,
0.0137614813,
-0.4527971148,
-0.1128522158,
-0.646096766,
-0.0167178269,
0.1611559093,
-0.0585752428,
-0.7486944795,
0.6474875212,
0.9814481139,
0.6308885813,
-0.5752917528,
0.3924187422,
0.9622494578,
0.0239909366,
-0.6534261107,
-0.3487728238,
-0.0435740054,
-0.4866493642,
1.1229953766,
0.5123782158,
-0.1256200224,
-0.3415591419,
-0.6345109344,
-0.405277282,
0.6916592121,
0.2577595413,
-0.8321402073,
0.0587907247,
0.2454079539,
0.9341884851,
-0.5148427486,
0.2427418828,
0.0593115538,
0.6708019972,
0.1498647034,
-0.4155021012,
-0.2659144104,
-0.5234845281,
-0.1432295889,
-0.0024930025,
-1.0058579445,
0.5331488848,
0.0276027564,
-0.2480555028,
-0.3794482648,
0.8692348599,
-0.2354196012,
0.9969956875,
0.50305897,
0.9610305429,
0.5264834166,
-0.1500445604,
0.8879668713,
0.0631392971,
0.2701748908,
0.8865156174,
-0.7182333469,
0.728010118,
-0.0390926227,
-0.1074627042,
0.4471311569,
0.7247520685,
-0.1366082132,
0.7161813378,
0.042471692,
-0.2897658348,
-0.3206655979,
-0.0282496437,
-0.1716448218,
0.5758200884,
0.5240064263,
-0.3136727512,
-0.1233683452,
0.7427710295,
-0.2249472737,
-0.2857963741,
-0.4709896445,
1.0126488209,
-0.0571903065,
-0.2685766518,
0.196032539,
-0.3887062371,
0.6201316118,
-0.3792459965,
0.0109809935,
-0.1505312324,
0.4233740568,
-0.3250812292,
-0.5820022225,
-0.0051465658,
0.1571439654,
-0.2846475542,
-0.0667061284,
0.7276014686,
-0.3457832634,
-0.2522974908,
0.3567208946,
-0.3464468122,
-0.0875290707,
-0.3219127655,
-0.6055362225,
0.0700367615,
-0.1434878409,
-0.6566292048,
0.3348913193,
0.8747063279,
0.1758733243,
0.7299053669,
0.3702160716,
-0.5087864995,
0.1333693862,
-0.0816384181,
0.8074612021,
-0.8150616288,
-0.5672140718,
-0.640823245,
0.5979406834,
-0.1961548626,
-0.1985239238,
0.2938115001,
0.2926780879,
0.2425474226,
-0.2529733777,
0.6229616404,
-0.0608521514,
0.6117409468,
-0.2461977601,
0.3506600857,
-0.5559743047,
-0.6427435279,
-0.2765156031,
-0.6708289981,
-0.2174463719,
0.236242339,
-0.1845048368,
0.2546959817,
0.4756698608,
0.5390043259,
0.1401553601,
0.1287558228,
0.4197961092,
0.4199536741,
0.0024110293,
0.9579586983,
0.6856378317,
-0.1900205761,
0.3885937333,
-0.4372924864,
-0.3578588963,
-1.0323805809,
-0.5059369206,
-0.9221538305,
-0.459104687,
-0.3541427553,
-0.0266958084,
0.1558922827,
0.665736258,
0.8259561062,
-0.6475275755,
0.4169384837,
0.2544851005,
-0.1063962206,
0.0278259404,
-0.2583301067,
0.54586339,
-0.3811591566,
-0.8405634761,
0.2015590221,
0.8688973784,
-0.1429761946,
-0.1561736763,
-0.1868074536,
-0.0585981347,
0.2831839323,
0.6613068581,
0.3144750297,
-0.2931174934,
-0.1624297798,
-0.1392347962,
-0.5112556815,
0.1469944715,
0.6380733252,
-0.619197607,
0.3915893734,
0.7504632473,
0.9650448561,
0.5791863203,
-0.0023529483,
0.0059227343,
-0.5304653049,
0.3845152855,
0.4503911734,
0.3666410446,
0.3588218391,
-0.4509228766,
0.3160387874,
0.0094619682,
-0.5259482265,
-0.7199633121,
0.1002999023,
-1.596170783,
0.0695309415,
0.7109698057,
-0.2831804454,
-0.6293926835,
0.2333209962,
-0.4526972473,
0.3007101417,
-0.468816787,
1.1160020828,
0.5091513395,
-0.1387686431,
-0.5481384397,
-0.0554107949,
0.1955566108,
0.5634533167,
-0.9364816546,
0.2958912551,
0.5312635899,
-0.1911451072,
0.4984947741,
-0.1384650171,
-0.1860589981,
0.5357936621,
-0.2066561133,
0.4378812611,
-0.195726037,
-0.3158061504,
-0.4739211202,
0.6447156668,
-0.6388751268,
-0.3603500128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19803v1 | Scalable and Domain-General Abstractive Proposition Segmentation | 2024-06-28T10:24:31 | 2024-06-28T10:24:31 | Mohammad Javad Hosseini, Yang Gao, Tim Baumgärtner, Alex Fabrikant, Reinald Kim Amplayo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Segmenting text into fine-grained units of meaning is important to a wide
range of NLP applications. The default approach of segmenting text into
sentences is often insufficient, especially since sentences are usually complex
enough to include multiple units of meaning that merit separate treatment in
the downstream task. We focus on the task of abstractive proposition
segmentation: transforming text into simple, self-contained, well-formed
sentences. Several recent works have demonstrated the utility of proposition
segmentation with few-shot prompted LLMs for downstream tasks such as
retrieval-augmented grounding and fact verification. However, this approach
does not scale to large amounts of text and may not always extract all the
facts from the input text. In this paper, we first introduce evaluation metrics
for the task to measure several dimensions of quality. We then propose a
scalable, yet accurate, proposition segmentation model. We model proposition
segmentation as a supervised task by training LLMs on existing annotated
datasets and show that training yields significantly improved results. We
further show that by using the fine-tuned LLMs as teachers for annotating large
amounts of multi-domain synthetic distillation data, we can train smaller
student models with results similar to the teacher LLMs. We then demonstrate
that our technique leads to effective domain generalization, by annotating data
in two domains outside the original training data and evaluating on them.
Finally, as a key contribution of the paper, we share an easy-to-use API for
NLP practitioners to use. | [
-0.3388991356,
-0.8252557516,
0.7001099586,
0.2123760283,
-0.456469208,
-0.0483738147,
-0.0706938431,
-0.4364225566,
0.0785018802,
0.5386307836,
-0.2923656702,
-0.473131448,
-0.5922113657,
0.1378200203,
-0.4406704605,
0.9700929523,
0.0838945881,
0.0103323227,
-0.5604965091,
-0.3178285956,
-0.3877668977,
-0.6813763976,
-0.5495060682,
-0.4166701734,
0.3081142902,
0.3119021356,
0.3514904976,
0.9554820657,
0.5498595238,
0.2478828728,
-0.1003959179,
0.504699111,
-0.1843537837,
0.1849757433,
-0.4679677486,
-0.5551621914,
-0.2922812104,
0.2214918286,
0.6040139794,
1.0044262409,
0.1158612296,
0.1638341099,
-0.0271582324,
0.7350887656,
-0.536052525,
0.0473988988,
-0.7355880737,
0.1806428134,
-0.0144335655,
-0.2090226859,
-0.5309712291,
-0.1921104193,
0.6409152746,
-0.4553203583,
0.2712816298,
0.2338300347,
0.7537138462,
0.4208942652,
-0.5637797713,
-0.4156418145,
-0.5670255423,
0.9222995639,
-0.3579981327,
-0.0734248236,
0.1177140474,
0.1053036153,
-0.0135192145,
-0.8595371842,
-0.417860508,
-0.0707547814,
-0.1452820748,
-0.2233356982,
-0.2440799773,
0.0588950142,
0.134931162,
0.6766546369,
-0.2803913355,
0.0719594285,
-0.1499255598,
-0.2573874295,
0.5569572449,
0.1832987219,
0.1897733957,
-0.3476186395,
-0.6208498478,
0.1019603014,
-0.6837746501,
-0.0588057637,
0.2093308121,
0.4494793713,
0.295889169,
0.8302507997,
-0.0983524993,
0.7800907493,
0.1227850765,
-0.402772516,
-0.0587807372,
-0.3189210892,
-0.1611061394,
-0.0660306662,
0.6252385378,
0.2980543971,
0.0233356114,
0.0058045578,
-0.1376906484,
0.0926696882,
0.264646858,
-0.9583392143,
-0.3126136959,
0.4223791659,
-0.3009829819,
-0.078629218,
-0.2483511418,
-0.4863427579,
-0.2124641389,
-0.6600729823,
0.3295539618,
-0.5694772005,
0.2378639132,
0.237106517,
-0.1030386835,
0.1973514706,
0.3466269374,
-1.0614104271,
0.4187507033,
0.7982211709,
0.9738681316,
-0.6841486096,
0.0229568128,
-0.6034870148,
0.0446951985,
-0.2173807919,
0.9959347844,
-0.4293295741,
-0.2808881998,
-0.0086191334,
-0.071110636,
-0.0836908072,
-0.7751967907,
0.679538548,
-0.4945018888,
0.2469599396,
0.0095182117,
-0.9280481339,
-0.1684416533,
0.7396378517,
-0.4539994597,
0.7395994663,
-0.0348903127,
-0.610884726,
0.3164872527,
-0.6093421578,
-0.490304023,
0.0337854326,
-0.1517188251,
-0.352075547,
0.2072947621,
0.5320829749,
0.6171086431,
-0.1769627333,
0.0452468209,
-0.0524493717,
0.0640695244,
0.1694945395,
-0.4511640668,
0.4202323854,
0.0123313963,
-0.0426532179,
0.1672483236,
-1.0407171249,
0.1738208234,
-0.1082343087,
-0.3843896687,
-0.4606737792,
0.1610880345,
-0.02358252,
-0.0275124796,
0.2122375369,
-0.5624036193,
0.4044940472,
-0.6980168223,
0.516482532,
0.4778137207,
0.3315373659,
0.7113084197,
-0.1248899102,
0.31855461,
-0.05390184,
-0.1878995746,
-0.3634079099,
-0.3191197217,
-0.914778769,
-0.6293957829,
0.3155268431,
0.3586597145,
-0.712305665,
0.5304390788,
-0.0857178494,
-0.2596727014,
-0.1161244735,
-0.0966409892,
0.0756598413,
0.6303858757,
0.591519773,
0.0071390523,
-0.4603275657,
-0.9214758873,
-0.16614981,
-0.0124356542,
-0.3596062958,
0.082362093,
0.6103004217,
-0.2632014155,
1.3893119097,
-0.9578667283,
-0.5885372162,
-0.2250641137,
0.2277027965,
0.1012820303,
0.5350212455,
0.4086910188,
-0.7677562833,
-0.4462195635,
-0.0501166731,
-0.5238048434,
0.0430214889,
-0.3239788413,
-0.0722935423,
-0.2566590309,
0.1884319931,
-0.5473499894,
0.2506568432,
0.1357057542,
-0.1509271413,
0.5058877468,
-0.2055346072,
-0.1617714763,
-0.9083485007,
-0.3288830519,
0.2471367121,
-0.5375932455,
-0.529694438,
0.1598455906,
-0.2704669833,
0.030344937,
-0.565682888,
0.3633899093,
-0.2383422852,
-0.0575285628,
-0.6181269884,
0.2948365808,
0.2661869228,
0.2948226333,
0.3493618965,
0.6775440574,
0.4027080536,
-0.6972779632,
0.3982424736,
0.3775499463,
-0.3351985216,
0.8133052588,
-0.7522755265,
0.0677952841,
0.0358028337,
0.268509686,
-0.8643673062,
-0.1981330514,
0.2084874362,
-0.0182108209,
0.016600959,
-0.2733836472,
-0.3851671219,
-0.052251488,
-0.1140056178,
0.2437204123,
0.1878502965,
-0.7522904277,
0.5316562057,
0.5062355399,
-0.036256589,
-0.3366909921,
-0.5962172747,
0.0417964272,
-0.3382329941,
-0.5223659873,
0.6351354718,
0.1910958439,
-0.1821805984,
-0.0842379332,
-0.2544185221,
-0.4050698876,
-0.1318427026,
0.2256286293,
0.1828358918,
-0.1941333115,
0.2290720195,
0.2828908563,
-0.2528498769,
0.2553728521,
-0.6726861596,
0.2547744215,
-0.3005002141,
-0.2880337536,
-0.3095705807,
0.3520566523,
0.1583305746,
-0.113249056,
0.5466140509,
0.4105890095,
-0.4227437675,
-0.6221253872,
-0.2504899204,
0.0095115937,
-0.4146906734,
0.1547082514,
-0.3905842602,
-1.1126486063,
0.1294590533,
-0.5869958401,
0.1221043095,
0.7449731827,
0.4501466751,
-0.1339538991,
0.7397788167,
0.6835309267,
0.3273712695,
-0.0159193091,
-0.5275292397,
0.2622617781,
-0.8124848008,
-0.120719336,
-0.36372298,
-0.2625764608,
-0.3773869872,
-0.7547268867,
0.2726307809,
0.0596166253,
0.1399731487,
0.1011412293,
-0.859880209,
0.8042296171,
0.3660515547,
-0.0460576415,
0.419598341,
0.1585417837,
0.01711349,
-0.2808450758,
-0.3877233565,
-0.8732085228,
0.9816787839,
0.4976197183,
0.5207201242,
-0.1497522444,
0.6539152861,
0.2961128652,
0.307831794,
-1.3150089979,
0.62886554,
-0.3711128533,
-0.5867148042,
-0.4017057419,
-0.2952565849,
-0.6855657101,
0.8685168028,
-0.0811385438,
-0.594860673,
0.1842448562,
0.0266819242,
-0.596855402,
0.2179725617,
-0.6105151772,
0.7083003521,
-0.1566454619,
-0.0338399895,
-0.0353431515,
-0.5155394077,
0.2622512281,
-0.1885741502,
-0.0776971951,
-0.4826434851,
-0.109586224,
0.7670390606,
-0.8060186505,
0.8167933822,
-0.1591626704,
-0.0505207106,
0.6443865299,
-0.2137691975,
0.1915580034,
0.2301858664,
0.1435486972,
0.0540866256,
0.2645063996,
-0.2625765204,
-0.7038249373,
0.4435151815,
-0.5869540572,
-0.5694261193,
-0.5156128407,
-0.3650794625,
-0.3807240427,
0.0406052992,
0.1758570522,
0.3247704208,
-0.2555200756,
0.3245994449,
0.7511897087,
0.1787319779,
0.3229512274,
0.1790775955,
-0.0838296711,
-0.4632017016,
0.8644287586,
-0.0430893153,
0.0709469616,
0.6642339826,
0.3936228454,
-0.6218320727,
-0.7303859591,
-0.3229645491,
-0.0167828109,
-0.7680779099,
-0.2473011017,
-0.5879034996,
-0.051396925,
-0.0012028106,
-0.1562095135,
-0.5687101483,
-0.7268579006,
-0.6049073339,
-0.1980578005,
0.0983914435,
0.5076773763,
-0.0656227171,
0.5772877336,
-0.6735143661,
0.4710184634,
0.5350369215,
-0.0649928898,
-0.249954313,
-0.6044746041,
-0.0311651323,
-0.0184498597,
-0.4588094354,
-0.3231084645,
0.4635936618,
0.553976059,
0.2082976401,
0.4529000223,
0.195710063,
0.5857503414,
-0.8619409204,
0.8976227641,
0.3420962095,
-0.9793429375,
0.8518600464,
-0.0331892148,
0.0530695394,
0.6890992522,
0.5992717743,
-0.1989485174,
-0.0134089962,
-0.2421983927,
-0.8753652573,
0.443765521,
0.0582041927,
0.3778044283,
-0.1978566349,
0.6376227736,
0.3139781654,
0.1179965362,
-0.7912329435,
-0.4536370039,
-0.1080752835,
-0.0435023233,
0.0867943466,
-0.5052862167,
-0.3836053014,
-0.2574244142,
0.4302730262,
-0.3390734792,
-0.0676772669,
0.2556498945,
-0.0859449357,
0.3749238551,
0.4567548335,
0.3635888994,
0.6683996916,
-0.0799166709,
0.3960594833,
0.0098195383,
-0.4484115541,
0.7057108879,
0.0125137903,
-0.164582774,
0.1097937748,
0.3992520273,
0.4777229428,
0.0124826608,
-0.4813971519,
0.6169311404,
0.0051066037,
-0.3308539391,
-0.1667746007,
-0.0048562717,
-0.199634254,
0.2724596262,
0.552246213,
0.193109557,
0.2433151305,
-0.3978598416,
0.377125293,
0.1926967651,
-0.1974649578,
-0.21630615,
0.551910758,
0.4356779754,
-0.0570132658,
0.4811275303,
-0.4139836729,
-0.4045798182,
0.2549747825,
0.5875765681,
0.8412616253,
0.1456545144,
0.475938648,
0.2152392864,
0.0977601409,
-0.1883248836,
-0.1875797957,
-0.0329687521,
-0.7864884138,
-0.7299845815,
-0.7461080551,
-0.6408668756,
0.0121319415,
-0.5652577281,
-0.1821476072,
-0.6590715647,
-0.3036753535,
0.2891615033,
-0.0075343256,
-0.402399838,
0.4429110289,
0.0301099885,
0.64743644,
-0.6996021867,
0.5667033792,
0.6739791036,
-0.2862708569,
-0.5715663433,
-0.0741872191,
-0.3114996254,
-0.527007103,
0.781740427,
0.3430228233,
-0.0616979823,
-0.278754741,
-0.6489521861,
-0.6560875773,
0.7501770258,
0.3956692815,
-0.401371181,
-0.0944756269,
0.630800128,
0.7287324667,
-0.7288329601,
-0.2530603707,
0.6518192291,
0.0769885406,
0.5181593895,
-0.3405852914,
-0.1278644055,
0.2883807719,
0.0975374728,
-0.0425600857,
-0.2468136698,
0.693177104,
-0.0817918181,
-0.2438789457,
-0.0987887383,
0.9174496531,
0.1752331257,
0.3904204965,
0.5730568767,
0.5599991083,
0.8690305352,
-0.3166363537,
0.8173058033,
0.0478101857,
0.4063108861,
1.4082016945,
-0.1101088747,
0.9960549474,
0.5108988881,
-0.3828716278,
0.4831471741,
0.6444653869,
-0.0322935209,
0.4355584383,
0.3719969988,
-0.3772859275,
-0.3899513185,
-0.3159530163,
-0.0395228229,
0.6365718842,
0.5081900954,
-0.1902778149,
-0.2328092605,
0.1622258127,
-0.2438146323,
0.1866797209,
-0.3800454736,
0.6784830093,
0.2346931547,
-0.4515022337,
0.3616985381,
0.1994217187,
0.5959445834,
-0.3547390997,
-0.0683352128,
0.0341588408,
0.0550424457,
-0.4359634817,
-0.7731033564,
0.6026154757,
0.0256728977,
-0.3286137283,
-0.3105690777,
0.7922670245,
-0.3528992832,
-0.3648632765,
-0.2105162442,
0.4748638272,
0.1284655333,
-0.4242649674,
-0.5664601326,
-0.0747422874,
0.0988462716,
-0.0544931032,
0.2179779857,
0.5990908146,
0.1971640736,
0.5634953976,
0.6641508341,
0.0277080443,
-0.0933596268,
0.0520505048,
0.8154566884,
-0.4294498265,
-0.3988265395,
-0.867836833,
0.5596828461,
-0.1858396828,
-0.3301083744,
0.7469429374,
0.6256029606,
0.6577472091,
-0.0973382741,
0.5495001078,
0.2256003916,
0.4829748571,
-0.5097638369,
0.2403191328,
-0.2093039006,
0.2797023356,
0.0938320234,
-1.1197799444,
-0.5196675062,
0.8077170253,
-0.5211501718,
-0.4773264229,
0.6782466173,
0.0435917638,
0.0605415814,
-0.0856033787,
0.3189909756,
-0.2576640546,
0.5313296914,
0.1667857468,
1.0154768229,
-0.3644817173,
0.4792052507,
-0.2761221826,
-0.1202432513,
-0.0389998071,
-0.8231825829,
-0.9065339565,
-0.4144987762,
-0.7041640282,
0.0257747974,
-0.4027261138,
0.9149366021,
0.8768510222,
-0.8130440116,
0.0155876102,
-0.1525017619,
0.1936953962,
0.007814697,
-0.2540117502,
0.5636970401,
-0.5792089701,
-0.8300390244,
0.5444688797,
0.5833628178,
0.1397395134,
-0.3405577838,
0.3803541362,
-0.1215602234,
0.1918777972,
1.0660361052,
0.1197803319,
-0.6584526896,
-0.4541059732,
-0.2810361981,
0.0120772701,
0.2171815336,
0.7742992043,
-0.6053069234,
0.4226873219,
0.1011945158,
0.9069130421,
0.5684468746,
0.2643611133,
0.3676132858,
-1.144960165,
0.1002349705,
0.5321483612,
0.3366790414,
0.3691394925,
-0.2364328504,
0.6882519126,
0.2450564802,
-0.563183248,
-0.6780361533,
0.2088904381,
-1.1199140549,
-0.2730029225,
1.0706088543,
-0.4099942446,
-0.1963701695,
0.0330891795,
-0.3393647075,
-0.3018184304,
-0.0531401113,
0.4283488989,
0.7192274332,
-0.4451120496,
0.1190042719,
-0.0507665984,
0.4716263413,
0.0831865594,
-1.0055508614,
-0.0194657128,
0.7165404558,
0.2249262482,
0.4943086505,
0.4227348566,
0.1028667241,
-0.2068443,
0.1506424993,
-0.1853199601,
0.1406900585,
-0.2656376362,
-0.2733492851,
0.6833441854,
0.0382297225,
-0.4677214921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19783v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19783v1 | NLPerturbator: Studying the Robustness of Code LLMs to Natural Language Variations | 2024-06-28T09:39:33 | 2024-06-28T09:39:33 | Junkai Chen, Zhenhao Li, Xing Hu, Xin Xia | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) achieve promising results in code generation
based on a given natural language description. They have been integrated into
open-source projects and commercial products to facilitate daily coding
activities. The natural language description in the prompt is crucial for LLMs
to comprehend users' requirements. Prior studies uncover that LLMs are
sensitive to the changes in the prompts, including slight changes that look
inconspicuous. However, the natural language descriptions often vary in
real-world scenarios (e.g., different formats, grammar, and wording). Prior
studies on the robustness of LLMs are often based on random perturbations and
such perturbations may not actually happen. In this paper, we conduct a
comprehensive study to investigate how are code LLMs robust to variations of
natural language description in real-world scenarios. We summarize 18
categories of perturbations of natural language and 3 combinations of
co-occurred categories based on our literature review and an online survey with
practitioners. We propose an automated framework, NLPerturbator, which can
perform perturbations of each category given a set of prompts. Through a series
of experiments on code generation using six code LLMs, we find that the
perturbed prompts can decrease the performance of code generation by a
considerable margin (e.g., up to 21.2%, and 4.8% to 6.1% on average). Our study
highlights the importance of enhancing the robustness of LLMs to real-world
variations in the prompts, as well as the essentiality of attentively
constructing the prompts. | [
-0.6429966688,
-1.1320098639,
0.220827058,
0.4921558201,
-0.1952807307,
0.1034067422,
-0.2852716148,
-0.3201429546,
0.105535306,
0.628326416,
-0.5452213287,
-0.4618072808,
-0.4460015297,
0.7029525042,
-0.3814408183,
0.957719326,
0.0163991973,
-0.2195061147,
-0.2035463601,
0.2190550417,
-0.4260998666,
-0.701700449,
-0.3858843148,
-0.1473048627,
0.4625255466,
0.1539112628,
0.820977807,
0.5038102269,
0.718266964,
0.2299616635,
-0.3560565412,
-0.0114805233,
-0.3973549902,
0.5659201741,
0.0531700663,
-0.6946622729,
-0.1852948815,
-0.3878362775,
0.5308037996,
0.3992005289,
-0.1220680997,
0.0283672232,
0.1979957521,
0.428502202,
-0.5025641918,
-0.1191116944,
-0.6412425041,
0.1935337484,
0.0149695436,
-0.5517987013,
-0.2839942575,
-0.4246567786,
-0.1338555813,
-0.2541561127,
0.3128769398,
0.1315955371,
0.8698049188,
0.5702581406,
-0.221276775,
-0.5043447614,
-0.9267741442,
0.7454923987,
-0.9470945597,
0.0016088912,
0.1871073991,
0.2721844018,
-0.7395374179,
-0.7601235509,
-0.6346305609,
-0.7038612962,
-0.0532345772,
-0.0949710831,
-0.288431108,
0.0850206017,
0.6668350101,
0.4596124887,
-0.4667970538,
0.3301198184,
0.1813704222,
-0.2567139566,
0.3932346404,
0.5414117575,
0.3636601567,
-0.5036843419,
-0.1750127524,
-0.1169881001,
-0.6977413893,
0.3160466552,
0.8174837828,
0.2813312411,
-0.135979712,
0.6141281724,
0.0397683382,
0.7840795517,
0.1163938269,
-0.2043199837,
-0.0390515812,
-0.4791583121,
-0.1312776953,
-0.1782656759,
0.9484738111,
0.3778262436,
0.1049859598,
0.0316370986,
-0.3786513805,
-0.0126472926,
0.5676714182,
-0.8715609312,
-0.1862018406,
0.3228422403,
-0.4100213945,
-0.6683533788,
0.0521414317,
-0.9108684659,
-0.6664058566,
-0.2795812786,
-0.0369964242,
-0.3115464449,
-0.0147065977,
0.0842514038,
0.239193961,
0.1523948014,
0.1677538306,
-0.5569331646,
0.1250660866,
0.6093848348,
0.6537350416,
-0.1486881822,
-0.2813006043,
-0.5644909739,
-0.2711031139,
-0.2131569237,
0.7548823953,
-0.6316015124,
-0.5892234445,
0.0485975146,
-0.2075944692,
0.1942929327,
-0.5049402714,
0.6232631803,
-0.3961907029,
0.2525157034,
-0.0095527163,
-0.5671483278,
0.0962706506,
0.4089722037,
-0.7166154981,
0.9233792424,
-0.1082242131,
-1.1120009422,
0.2101723552,
-0.5669566989,
-0.4178413749,
0.0378947929,
-0.3277901411,
-0.6122555733,
0.3078866899,
0.3312835693,
0.3000182211,
-0.2973019481,
0.3339872658,
0.007617922,
-0.5750293136,
0.8206171393,
-0.6308645606,
0.7249317169,
0.270155549,
-0.3385752439,
0.3361492157,
-0.9400369525,
-0.223141551,
0.1079723611,
-0.5170308948,
0.0466400236,
0.1906699091,
0.1204723865,
0.099849537,
-0.0411356762,
-0.2534216344,
0.4260186851,
-0.6004726887,
0.2647507191,
0.531958878,
0.5255919695,
0.2246215045,
-0.4169516861,
1.2362743616,
-0.1964011043,
0.1884406656,
-0.4492315352,
-0.5489584208,
-0.4491465688,
-0.3410657048,
0.0883609504,
0.5627790689,
-0.7806611657,
0.6200134158,
0.0308499541,
-0.4216345251,
-0.3321146667,
0.1295427978,
0.24220635,
0.5568662882,
0.2079386115,
0.0044808309,
-0.7614792585,
-0.7632939219,
-0.5775186419,
-0.0680569485,
-0.2912948132,
0.0580994077,
0.2333799154,
-0.6011947393,
1.123416543,
-0.2729175091,
0.1204394773,
-0.3377270997,
0.1500847787,
0.7388062477,
0.3269020617,
0.431045711,
-0.6634207368,
-0.3027359843,
-0.4161568582,
-0.2687880099,
-0.4113695323,
-0.5970491171,
0.1647227556,
0.3002741635,
0.6329568624,
-0.3704593182,
0.3997433484,
0.6081951857,
-0.2427858412,
0.8894663453,
-0.2469067425,
-0.0406180918,
-1.1296907663,
0.2067297846,
0.0001720757,
-0.0057411478,
-0.603220582,
0.388495326,
-0.0081997821,
0.084600687,
-0.4683741033,
0.2018918097,
-0.3033289611,
0.3196349144,
-0.313995868,
-0.1374882609,
-0.1287213713,
0.1537161171,
-0.3064030409,
0.830343008,
0.6319198012,
-0.762858808,
0.4698709846,
0.139924109,
-0.1941463947,
0.2884036005,
-0.7692594528,
0.2436035126,
-0.26511693,
0.2817661166,
-0.9766878486,
-0.4098989666,
0.2178920656,
-0.4614836276,
0.2145398855,
-0.1881693751,
-0.802855134,
-0.3738985658,
-0.5112796426,
-0.006923208,
0.5179651976,
-0.4180256426,
0.6575905681,
-0.0341652706,
0.0326782875,
-0.4988583028,
-0.5633152127,
0.445592314,
-0.2450820059,
-0.4150164127,
-0.0443890654,
-0.3138324618,
-0.4192506969,
-0.3606448174,
-0.1595418602,
0.3494541347,
0.4734343588,
0.6749786139,
0.3098427951,
-0.0361148827,
-0.0847555324,
-0.0659772009,
-0.0652381852,
0.3462321758,
-0.004193421,
0.7921685576,
-0.1276056916,
-0.295850724,
-0.2459408343,
0.095553346,
0.2334647179,
-0.1303037405,
0.5765106678,
0.6200643778,
-0.2360446751,
-0.3670445085,
-0.376534611,
-0.1172384098,
-0.5938194394,
0.3768939972,
-0.3593073189,
-0.9476930499,
0.60992378,
0.0827060714,
0.0937239379,
0.270424366,
0.7771692872,
0.0154779991,
0.9033867121,
0.5961235762,
0.1530711949,
0.3774583936,
0.1469798386,
0.251347661,
-0.5898135304,
-0.1659127623,
-0.7492579222,
-0.2291285694,
-0.8396286368,
-0.2982536554,
0.1919294745,
0.182898894,
-0.0656987056,
0.264711678,
-0.6894481778,
0.6397902369,
0.3726215363,
-0.422832638,
0.1028443277,
0.1069352031,
-0.3154703677,
-0.1877090782,
-0.4668788612,
-0.9036057591,
0.9771317244,
0.4411389828,
1.0755518675,
0.1340040863,
0.7912533879,
0.1663517654,
0.121028401,
-0.6949369311,
0.5133438706,
0.0891375318,
-0.3671099544,
0.010533181,
-0.5506820083,
-1.0698844194,
-0.1275423318,
-0.408981353,
-0.6123123169,
0.0358294211,
0.3427104652,
-0.4477595389,
0.2341133803,
-0.3618731499,
0.4369826615,
-0.206694454,
-0.3970035315,
0.367741406,
-0.5913495421,
0.0740115866,
-0.230456382,
0.2838879824,
0.0779299811,
-0.255092144,
0.3490435779,
-0.1581471264,
0.9893620014,
0.0638040826,
-0.5251433849,
0.2991667688,
0.5596992373,
0.6198539138,
0.4924985468,
-0.1220856383,
-0.0983144119,
-0.2458603084,
-0.2394467592,
-0.5214000344,
0.7511529326,
-0.6004164815,
-0.6122370958,
-0.2627946436,
-0.5632132292,
-0.2924112976,
0.1359040737,
0.6937373877,
0.4427872896,
0.063710019,
0.0346297733,
0.6218740344,
-0.7213821411,
0.6266101599,
0.1907545328,
-0.5404546857,
-0.3719467819,
0.5431212187,
-0.1799062639,
0.096413739,
0.5003864169,
0.2761349678,
-0.1162749529,
-0.7625950575,
-0.119324185,
-0.0669371337,
-0.6805092096,
-0.2399573624,
-0.6230704188,
0.0976621285,
-0.2611510754,
-0.3882880211,
-0.0986197814,
-0.2616900504,
-0.4711712599,
-0.1289239973,
0.4088150263,
0.8545906544,
0.2960170805,
0.1906878799,
-0.8905169368,
0.2143888772,
0.0989790186,
0.5245670676,
-0.2182475477,
-0.5508767962,
-0.0321012512,
-0.1411153376,
-0.1043817699,
-0.8719465733,
0.4975565672,
-0.0634709001,
0.5473530889,
0.2747445703,
0.3288827538,
0.4460952282,
-0.2686481774,
1.1068285704,
0.1144660339,
-0.9061058164,
0.5837701559,
-0.4725886881,
0.6083115339,
0.4860432744,
0.202589646,
-0.401453197,
-0.9087242484,
-0.4286463559,
-1.0911356211,
0.4694058299,
0.2510669827,
0.5019800067,
-0.1087489352,
0.6683935523,
0.2069417089,
0.1422709525,
-0.6481825709,
-0.34821257,
-0.3991966248,
-0.1592107415,
0.0082210088,
-0.4377226532,
0.0081582041,
0.130635187,
0.2401761562,
-0.1756608486,
0.3076719642,
0.1786922365,
-0.0285086054,
-0.2050196677,
0.4311804771,
0.9147709012,
0.5543249249,
-0.2754525244,
0.4246413708,
0.1370042413,
-0.655846417,
0.019456571,
-0.0907355919,
-0.2010883689,
0.0421858467,
0.6110323668,
0.8864905238,
0.0621271767,
-0.9339914918,
0.2796355188,
-0.3871092498,
-0.1022346616,
-0.3002334535,
0.3204698563,
-0.0472021438,
-0.0429310203,
0.3670508564,
0.29163903,
0.1441502124,
-0.2128559947,
0.1016567349,
0.1699677408,
-0.1821891218,
-0.3911150992,
0.7203280926,
0.0014539886,
-0.6308592558,
0.3691595495,
-0.3007102311,
-0.5333013535,
0.7046364546,
0.7796655297,
0.8703802824,
-0.0060445797,
-0.1463620663,
0.3306498826,
0.5309807658,
0.0769517347,
0.2729414701,
0.2969981134,
-0.4656622708,
-0.6934406161,
-0.6329286695,
-0.5642835498,
0.027801916,
-0.57959342,
0.3937455714,
-0.7691643238,
-0.4354353845,
-0.3559313715,
-0.1841272712,
-0.5091136098,
-0.045572225,
0.1791024953,
0.8795627952,
-0.4709732831,
0.6080492735,
1.0698199272,
-0.3298641741,
-0.957457006,
0.4337604344,
0.0061296741,
-0.3592455387,
0.380779922,
0.0850567147,
-0.0804902837,
-0.1735824794,
-0.7200030684,
-0.6137691736,
0.653113246,
0.546855092,
-0.77322191,
0.0052277087,
0.2081113607,
0.8513183594,
-0.0734497458,
0.2918398678,
0.275916636,
0.3908927739,
0.0734706447,
-0.7335197926,
0.2331920713,
-0.2359553427,
0.416749686,
0.2133716494,
-0.1381108165,
0.8366602659,
-0.2324994206,
-0.1991447508,
0.0085839378,
0.3739226758,
0.3631509244,
-0.1347490549,
0.2224604636,
0.064576976,
0.621107161,
0.0221811924,
1.4854508638,
-0.5892865658,
0.4870923758,
1.0719611645,
-0.2363196462,
0.6340849996,
0.7670661807,
-0.276204288,
0.4374471009,
0.2963858843,
-0.2910669744,
-0.0545392893,
0.637853086,
0.0343697965,
-0.1358765513,
0.1742055565,
-0.1950531155,
0.1863181144,
0.1354547739,
-0.2271979004,
-0.0193746611,
0.0461193807,
0.0818648562,
0.3096522093,
-0.0702298954,
0.686194241,
0.0099869277,
-0.5761244297,
0.9014142156,
0.0569601245,
1.0751973391,
-0.4786113203,
0.0897238329,
-0.355355233,
0.1058133245,
-0.5392158031,
-0.6459060311,
0.3763462603,
0.2796551287,
-0.0198241789,
-0.1103318706,
0.6997794509,
0.0248960704,
-0.5415714383,
0.1373329312,
0.1484420449,
-0.1680476815,
0.0967812687,
-0.4633116126,
0.361931324,
0.1960555613,
-0.4652328789,
0.1872240454,
0.3164001703,
0.1855019629,
0.6672161222,
0.6353715062,
0.1805912107,
0.3759827018,
0.0808968619,
0.7682547569,
-0.6263807416,
-0.3706530929,
-1.0567284822,
0.4911613166,
0.1061527804,
-0.3656073213,
1.0659525394,
0.4282335937,
0.4976841211,
-0.2748305202,
0.6534950733,
-0.0306850355,
0.380530417,
-0.56219697,
0.5337608457,
-0.1771886647,
0.9121943712,
-0.3839217126,
-1.0962580442,
-0.7869231701,
0.4673956037,
-0.0955713093,
-0.1781542897,
0.5049215555,
0.8815549612,
0.3765753806,
-0.019506732,
0.1624355614,
0.2287046462,
0.7257931828,
0.1477054805,
0.9978175163,
0.0072999001,
0.6189473271,
-0.2487058192,
0.0192723386,
-0.2892649174,
-1.1517732143,
-0.9673033357,
-0.2847293913,
-0.514917016,
-0.5428341627,
-0.1444762945,
1.3081108332,
0.1302127391,
-0.8895229101,
-0.2173184454,
-0.3901704252,
-0.0072612795,
-0.051362142,
-0.2718797922,
0.0766777694,
-0.637978971,
-0.5311794877,
0.3570726514,
0.1387165636,
0.1312580556,
-0.3027727306,
-0.0599804074,
0.1605906785,
0.3409650624,
0.3755907714,
0.0658997893,
-0.645775497,
-0.1179404035,
0.1938128769,
-0.2648934126,
0.0859015435,
0.9255931377,
-0.7716782689,
0.4216580093,
0.4538427293,
0.5968411565,
-0.0479710922,
-0.0763190538,
0.5274896026,
-0.9666370153,
0.0538858622,
0.4565227926,
0.3192120194,
0.2755338252,
-0.4268707931,
0.2268235236,
-0.0182418954,
-0.5850373507,
-1.0177834034,
0.3933105469,
-0.8336784244,
-0.2461177856,
1.5605379343,
0.1253314316,
-0.0732402056,
-0.1540390253,
-0.5239426494,
0.0731057599,
-0.4241649508,
0.8697701693,
0.4057017267,
-0.1896620989,
-0.1479779035,
-0.4020651877,
0.5652807951,
0.2178495377,
-0.6620765924,
0.0230848938,
0.4622628987,
0.2803496122,
0.2518167794,
0.144873783,
-0.0128425704,
0.0679893494,
-0.0810352862,
0.1706315875,
-0.3633863628,
0.1450755596,
-0.8803973794,
0.4785737097,
0.5694541931,
0.3178215027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19774v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19774v1 | Direct Preference Knowledge Distillation for Large Language Models | 2024-06-28T09:23:40 | 2024-06-28T09:23:40 | Yixing Li, Yuxian Gu, Li Dong, Dequan Wang, Yu Cheng, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the field of large language models (LLMs), Knowledge Distillation (KD) is
a critical technique for transferring capabilities from teacher models to
student models. However, existing KD methods face limitations and challenges in
distillation of LLMs, including efficiency and insufficient measurement
capabilities of traditional KL divergence. It is shown that LLMs can serve as
an implicit reward function, which we define as a supplement to KL divergence.
In this work, we propose Direct Preference Knowledge Distillation (DPKD) for
LLMs. DPKD utilizes distribution divergence to represent the preference loss
and implicit reward function. We re-formulate KD of LLMs into two stages: first
optimizing and objective consisting of implicit reward and reverse KL
divergence and then improving the preference probability of teacher outputs
over student outputs. We conducted experiments and analysis on various datasets
with LLM parameters ranging from 120M to 13B and demonstrate the broad
applicability and effectiveness of our DPKD approach. Meanwhile, we prove the
value and effectiveness of the introduced implicit reward and output preference
in KD through experiments and theoretical analysis. The DPKD method outperforms
the baseline method in both output response precision and exact match
percentage. Code and data are available at https://aka.ms/dpkd. | [
-0.3407057226,
-0.4404237568,
0.9480926394,
0.1490387022,
-0.4579737186,
0.11430718,
-0.6041375399,
0.1853193492,
-0.1880892217,
0.3980720043,
-0.3343929946,
-0.5424882174,
-0.9030621052,
0.0037996334,
-0.2262460291,
0.9292529225,
-0.2477949262,
0.1936476231,
-0.3617744744,
0.2356388569,
-0.4623458087,
-0.6208727956,
-0.7231175303,
-0.6801077127,
0.7237813473,
0.6945188046,
0.2485716492,
0.4397716224,
0.2759780288,
0.2231602669,
-0.1916911006,
-0.1172844246,
-0.6198987365,
0.3188995719,
-0.1418355256,
-0.5212422013,
-0.175623551,
0.0852018222,
0.5781362057,
0.9120135307,
-0.2437178046,
-0.0719344169,
0.4261431098,
1.1390190125,
-0.7100605369,
0.3411708176,
-0.559596777,
0.1446054131,
-0.051745493,
-0.016661793,
-0.4594332278,
-0.7516460419,
0.5308306217,
-0.2454788387,
-0.0298713893,
-0.482916981,
0.3016424179,
0.403069824,
-0.7154485583,
-0.4668876827,
-1.0217235088,
0.7868231535,
-0.8282045722,
0.4371506572,
0.4567220509,
0.4830217361,
-0.0267576091,
-0.5734570622,
-0.6881293058,
-0.3570598662,
0.005430663,
-0.0008298247,
0.1517007798,
0.0459025912,
0.1134993061,
0.4590705931,
-0.017380666,
0.1646100879,
-0.2453094721,
0.2263205349,
0.6600106955,
0.0361602716,
-0.105402872,
0.0745667517,
-0.3341151774,
-0.4672732651,
-0.7418579459,
0.136413306,
0.473585397,
0.2506456375,
0.1019294634,
0.495407939,
-0.3558048606,
0.4077365398,
0.2474527508,
-0.6144223809,
0.124494426,
0.0037955223,
-0.0096343784,
0.2962897718,
0.5562365055,
0.1907641739,
0.4634930491,
0.0996945053,
-0.1160367429,
-0.1878432482,
-0.2413811386,
-0.8631471992,
-0.506277442,
0.1100858822,
-0.1614435911,
-0.4442012906,
-0.288492471,
-0.6178470254,
-0.6117072701,
-0.6800082922,
0.1486614496,
-0.3284654021,
-0.7016847134,
0.3502161205,
-0.1672229469,
-0.1998436153,
0.3039061725,
-1.0919986963,
0.1558813751,
0.503722012,
0.6345276833,
-0.5266522765,
-0.1668202281,
-0.1312553883,
0.2151089162,
-0.144982934,
0.3891127408,
-0.4033993483,
-0.5546038151,
0.09202075,
-0.2983270884,
0.1568630636,
-0.6522458792,
0.6810603738,
-0.5945820212,
-0.06191523,
-0.4693297148,
-0.7432342768,
-0.090386264,
0.0764152929,
-0.646736145,
0.8125767708,
-0.0456205718,
-0.719167769,
0.6236960292,
-0.4216030538,
-0.3616372049,
0.0149117056,
-0.0471490137,
-0.0456857197,
0.1683101654,
0.0770097598,
0.6177164912,
-0.034132909,
0.6964842081,
-0.4484013915,
-0.0988303646,
0.0843416229,
-0.6431469917,
0.6332659125,
0.1539295316,
-0.190524295,
-0.2027536333,
-0.619654119,
-0.2358254194,
0.1965728998,
-0.6644314528,
-0.9114139676,
0.1061480418,
-0.3567349315,
-0.0638927966,
0.3744825721,
-0.4407076538,
0.5627103448,
-0.2899162173,
0.2403354198,
1.1894168854,
-0.0905517116,
0.7275387645,
0.2236902565,
0.2996927798,
0.2383042723,
0.0346856192,
0.2106061131,
-0.1891741455,
-0.613348484,
-0.4686113596,
0.4394825399,
0.0717257112,
-0.8579457998,
0.3950353861,
-0.361610502,
-0.4088383317,
-0.3466407657,
0.2135215402,
0.1147675291,
0.5432577729,
0.1342104822,
0.2244760543,
-0.35176301,
-0.9061396718,
0.0738480836,
-0.3416593373,
-0.1570022404,
0.4369381368,
0.2680668235,
0.1176092401,
1.0925935507,
-1.0855014324,
-0.2850479484,
-0.2691549063,
-0.1291086525,
0.4629267156,
0.2534325421,
0.426194191,
-0.8362947702,
-0.942979753,
-0.046506606,
-0.3740946651,
-0.2301804274,
0.3707679212,
-0.2024742216,
0.3446718156,
0.2007695138,
-0.407525897,
0.0652555451,
0.5729513764,
-0.2922859192,
0.5744174719,
-0.1199176833,
0.222022146,
-1.062625885,
0.1534656584,
-0.087543495,
-0.1962910295,
-0.4645907879,
-0.2337802798,
0.0750664026,
0.2417503893,
-0.4401133955,
0.5351629853,
-0.208022207,
0.1476694942,
-0.4021042287,
0.0390048847,
-0.0416405089,
0.4308599532,
0.3736402988,
0.3520877063,
0.4848327041,
-0.8267745972,
0.8119097352,
0.0906480253,
-0.4615629017,
0.4041136503,
-0.5886010528,
0.0742356479,
-0.213962242,
0.3070430756,
-1.2100100517,
0.029431602,
0.1878842264,
-0.1372665465,
0.4052367508,
-0.4219198227,
-0.2927694321,
-0.3745552897,
-0.2551832795,
0.3219852746,
0.7567886114,
-0.8574274182,
0.3427388966,
0.0688390732,
-0.4654640555,
-0.7706113458,
-0.563716948,
-0.2525495887,
-0.318002075,
-0.4663235843,
0.2056681663,
-0.3021853268,
-0.2971139252,
0.1363112777,
-0.2256075442,
-0.0266339928,
0.0903834701,
0.0870249346,
0.4323291183,
-0.0676677972,
0.2161982954,
0.376912266,
-0.0771311894,
0.0794748291,
-0.297789067,
0.6689119339,
0.4301957488,
-0.4636121988,
-0.0353618637,
0.1913728267,
0.5101255178,
0.1798948795,
0.7148829699,
0.233753249,
0.0150961578,
-0.5132133961,
-0.6229564548,
-0.4424960613,
-0.5000246167,
0.3872348666,
-0.436165452,
-0.8503249884,
0.1850034148,
-0.3424755633,
-0.0476527847,
0.2610753775,
0.658408165,
0.1836906821,
0.9365381002,
0.6951833963,
-0.3583166301,
0.3541685939,
-0.2292818427,
0.1953189373,
-0.6643549204,
-0.3412709236,
-0.5174056888,
-0.4460648596,
-0.164310053,
-0.0967738554,
0.4122601449,
0.3334033489,
-0.1276766062,
-0.2274843007,
-0.3766024709,
0.6379155517,
0.6671386957,
-0.1156860292,
0.6515714526,
0.2308694124,
-0.3571616411,
-0.176628232,
-0.4666366875,
-0.4005833864,
1.3624646664,
0.3541305661,
0.9266271591,
0.1099348217,
0.9257116318,
0.253133148,
0.2265381217,
-0.85118258,
0.4599223435,
-0.2865131795,
-0.3731849492,
-0.4702819586,
-0.4399749637,
-0.5977780223,
0.2562759817,
0.14472498,
-0.4011767805,
0.1498413533,
0.1861453503,
-0.0742719173,
0.2887506187,
-0.9187800288,
0.6111869812,
-0.0520524718,
-0.2900196612,
-0.1328140497,
-0.1933620423,
0.7260395288,
-0.1637177914,
-0.1369089335,
-0.1924251914,
0.1893438846,
0.6437548995,
-0.2651159465,
0.7050600648,
-0.5551906824,
-0.5971616507,
0.0011228377,
0.188853696,
0.6291432381,
0.2794831991,
-0.1257086396,
0.0021232395,
0.0205180831,
-0.0436398946,
-0.686065793,
1.1575069427,
-0.9177592397,
-0.8971687555,
-0.3211103082,
-0.4290328026,
-0.2769249678,
0.1362297535,
-0.041024249,
0.0414413176,
0.0107990839,
0.2283160537,
0.717879355,
-0.0623254478,
0.5771861672,
0.849177599,
-0.3674000204,
-0.1836807728,
0.7969026566,
0.1226751879,
0.4741548598,
0.2402425855,
0.5075601935,
-0.8804252148,
-0.5850639343,
-0.3591754436,
0.0837589502,
-0.8166903853,
-0.0423168875,
-0.4489502907,
-0.1188221723,
-0.5116559863,
0.0016324065,
-0.5477818251,
-0.3328871727,
-0.2023133785,
-0.1774344742,
0.4531823695,
0.7100093365,
-0.0502134897,
-0.0866393,
-0.4531086385,
0.2332725376,
0.6040356755,
0.5925447941,
0.2255063951,
-0.5180898905,
-0.0928050205,
0.3442263305,
-0.2203179598,
-0.6810877919,
0.5026524067,
0.0409409925,
0.4925898015,
0.4407580793,
0.5440022349,
0.2836948931,
-0.4956085682,
0.7206603289,
0.3055146337,
-0.7847189903,
0.4419957399,
-0.075604856,
0.2732198536,
0.5450755358,
0.8082319498,
-0.6882560253,
-0.1954841167,
-0.20046781,
-0.9779012799,
0.8242300153,
-0.0890946016,
0.1350734383,
0.2091278732,
0.3987417817,
0.3929882646,
0.2485496998,
-0.6012232304,
-0.6248258948,
0.075601697,
-0.3728581965,
-0.3988536894,
-0.4809547365,
-0.1303646415,
-0.3540539443,
0.8674885631,
-0.0569903962,
-0.3536010683,
0.159526214,
0.0847037956,
0.0394299515,
0.3244085014,
0.2731819153,
0.6480374336,
-0.2649863064,
0.4205382466,
0.0009576414,
-0.6483463645,
0.539824903,
-0.0676306635,
-0.1380645186,
-0.1120429412,
-0.0920839608,
0.740609169,
-0.1281424165,
-0.4410800934,
0.4644970596,
-0.0242524594,
-0.4153373241,
-0.2532043457,
0.0343383402,
0.5231189728,
0.2840442061,
0.5922074914,
-0.3623325527,
0.193972975,
-0.2780645192,
-0.0663171485,
0.191103518,
-0.1049396843,
-0.0970826,
0.2856294513,
0.2434117198,
0.2027254254,
0.5498505235,
-0.0385469534,
-0.4024316072,
0.3947421014,
0.4865189791,
0.8275421262,
-0.3969777822,
0.3591418564,
0.255644083,
-0.2125800997,
-0.2357260585,
-0.1393120289,
-0.1734337956,
-0.8658416867,
-0.4690192044,
-0.8741374016,
-0.3587018847,
0.3570679426,
-0.5426012874,
0.3710163534,
-0.1929300576,
0.0206582695,
0.1134388447,
0.1270638108,
-0.4461985528,
-0.143365711,
0.36157161,
0.5543839931,
-0.9247766733,
1.0627385378,
0.6276330948,
-0.1737813354,
-0.9392236471,
-0.0900312439,
-0.1418816894,
-0.64504987,
1.335010767,
-0.4608907402,
0.0596409291,
0.1107110083,
-0.3971438408,
-0.7480083108,
1.1999571323,
0.6508706212,
-0.9762046933,
0.2312144935,
0.426893115,
0.3455523849,
-0.2680790424,
0.1560049206,
0.6981137991,
0.5686655641,
0.6538072228,
-0.8095636964,
0.0178888775,
0.040242821,
0.1541694254,
0.1225056052,
-0.3406166434,
0.850271523,
-0.0610402301,
-0.1884112507,
-0.4321239889,
0.3087109029,
0.3953518569,
0.2159900516,
0.6001546383,
0.463542819,
0.5719791055,
-0.0560709834,
0.7920307517,
-0.1915114373,
0.4353834689,
1.0459467173,
-0.585519135,
0.8390622735,
0.8382622004,
-0.570761919,
0.2334664166,
0.350609988,
0.221093297,
0.8330994844,
0.4074763656,
-0.5445449948,
-0.1163057536,
-0.1370123625,
-0.5512337685,
0.0306618419,
-0.1614463329,
-0.3051896691,
-0.1918935627,
0.1452690661,
-0.0043618754,
0.1412773281,
-0.1991394311,
0.9437798858,
0.0916058794,
-0.8249046206,
0.7182700634,
-0.0991450548,
0.7661192417,
-0.6847792268,
-0.1227834672,
-0.4918536842,
0.5584892631,
-0.0813930184,
-0.9153213501,
-0.0434825346,
-0.0507823154,
-0.4533598721,
-0.2598775625,
0.7727426887,
-0.9582253098,
-0.4053336084,
0.3054310083,
0.3771757185,
-0.068055883,
-0.2006497532,
-0.2195487618,
0.101241909,
0.1943622828,
-0.3779152036,
0.5319412351,
0.4831108749,
0.3560770154,
0.6656299233,
0.6631874442,
0.3031885326,
0.0249307603,
0.1848572791,
1.1195244789,
-0.2016919404,
-0.481452018,
-1.2415776253,
0.4331092834,
-0.0775380358,
-0.0008417225,
0.8936923742,
0.4408485293,
0.9136937857,
-0.3968081772,
1.0181559324,
0.0880275443,
0.4801668823,
-0.513035953,
0.8362534046,
-0.3836894333,
0.3663178384,
-0.2640782893,
-1.1745055914,
0.2289524376,
0.3064936996,
-0.4908129573,
-0.119724378,
0.6550530791,
0.3833624721,
-0.0446330234,
-0.0817557424,
0.3720701635,
0.1741288155,
0.4212568402,
0.703258574,
1.0404696465,
0.0369420797,
0.3659817278,
-0.5257575512,
-0.2291916758,
-0.1675993949,
-1.019577384,
-0.8134998083,
-0.7513507009,
-0.5007817745,
-0.1077691466,
-0.0216145758,
0.8164579272,
0.609795928,
-0.6211352944,
-0.2099613547,
-0.1090881303,
0.3933475614,
0.096162118,
-0.2641462684,
0.4319202006,
-0.3165201545,
-1.0623397827,
0.1127908975,
-0.0868174881,
0.1178604439,
-0.5081986785,
-0.4092758596,
-0.0984122306,
-0.1053107455,
0.6334573627,
-0.1292928904,
-0.6047269702,
-0.1743124723,
-0.2152682096,
-0.0574124381,
-0.3534856737,
0.8321005106,
-0.6536850333,
0.3170355558,
0.5462433696,
0.4756786823,
0.6465088129,
-0.2143529207,
0.6975656152,
-0.8929823041,
0.1552515626,
0.1454161257,
0.157952562,
0.1340253651,
-0.3642863929,
0.319886148,
0.2437853664,
-0.4548366964,
-0.9204768538,
0.1535949111,
-0.7440035343,
-0.4251027107,
1.5865840912,
-0.3817793429,
-0.058954481,
0.0676440746,
-0.4411302209,
0.1664333045,
-0.6962544322,
0.7359507084,
0.935557127,
0.3421598971,
0.0012667417,
-0.2659222484,
0.8218333721,
0.2488538027,
-0.3208525777,
0.3241625428,
0.5705173016,
0.5364177227,
-0.1457347125,
0.6717930436,
-0.053022217,
-0.1668591648,
-0.2192033529,
0.2670306563,
-0.4271008372,
-0.2410588264,
-0.3793061078,
0.2254726291,
0.3624569476,
-0.0857063532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19764v1 | Belief Revision: The Adaptability of Large Language Models Reasoning | 2024-06-28T09:09:36 | 2024-06-28T09:09:36 | Bryan Wilie, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Etsuko Ishii, Junxian He, Pascale Fung | cs.CL | cs.CL | The capability to reason from text is crucial for real-world NLP
applications. Real-world scenarios often involve incomplete or evolving data.
In response, individuals update their beliefs and understandings accordingly.
However, most existing evaluations assume that language models (LMs) operate
with consistent information. We introduce Belief-R, a new dataset designed to
test LMs' belief revision ability when presented with new evidence. Inspired by
how humans suppress prior inferences, this task assesses LMs within the newly
proposed delta reasoning ($\Delta R$) framework. Belief-R features sequences of
premises designed to simulate scenarios where additional information could
necessitate prior conclusions drawn by LMs. We evaluate $\sim$30 LMs across
diverse prompting strategies and found that LMs generally struggle to
appropriately revise their beliefs in response to new information. Further,
models adept at updating often underperformed in scenarios without necessary
updates, highlighting a critical trade-off. These insights underscore the
importance of improving LMs' adaptiveness to changing information, a step
toward more reliable AI systems. | [
-0.4222872555,
-0.5766450167,
0.8462521434,
0.0508455262,
-0.0578900166,
-0.2645668983,
-0.3818856776,
-0.4564682543,
-0.0139651094,
0.5689839125,
-0.6971364021,
-0.2277885228,
-0.4626850784,
0.2675710618,
-0.10994073,
0.7097845078,
-0.1071065888,
-0.0526997484,
-0.0549492314,
-0.0535487793,
-0.7839635611,
-0.4613374174,
-0.7770350575,
-0.5986707807,
0.5484833717,
0.3773806393,
0.890511632,
0.3345294893,
0.3118540645,
0.1673819721,
-0.0674280152,
0.0353934355,
-0.198548153,
0.7217647433,
-0.4647975564,
-0.9474506974,
-0.3787630796,
-0.2217064649,
0.7038502097,
0.5875198245,
-0.1950173676,
-0.2133738697,
-0.0683114603,
0.7898483872,
-0.569545269,
0.1061897278,
-1.1437485218,
0.0863465667,
0.3787548244,
-0.1131468564,
-0.8874869943,
-0.4621532857,
0.3167258501,
-0.5359256268,
0.421369493,
0.0688246787,
0.8042191863,
0.572162509,
-0.1647522449,
-0.3342187405,
-0.8642400503,
0.6845445037,
-0.9940876961,
0.7146045566,
0.5177779198,
0.3779666424,
-0.4699392617,
-0.6804640889,
-0.8518269658,
-0.2848687768,
0.1943783164,
-0.0325044915,
-0.1205077693,
-0.0966316015,
0.3626775444,
0.139239043,
-0.3332334459,
-0.0092175659,
0.0306525752,
0.0591513962,
0.4313694239,
-0.0258803889,
0.0742183104,
0.019554941,
0.0833493918,
-0.5801349878,
-0.8428352475,
-0.1028593779,
0.1619358212,
0.2984495759,
0.1965791434,
0.4750668705,
-0.251788944,
0.7885004878,
0.1269403398,
-0.0361277349,
0.1191965565,
-0.0338203758,
-0.496819526,
-0.0487656295,
0.3429843187,
0.545245707,
0.2044544965,
0.1195772439,
-0.4194412529,
0.1077476665,
0.3385915756,
-0.4496069551,
-0.2704283297,
0.3850684762,
-0.392594099,
0.0616105646,
-0.128712818,
-0.7084380388,
-0.7667623162,
-0.3198054433,
0.2893643379,
-0.6630633473,
-0.4349383414,
0.6318898201,
-0.2220846266,
-0.031655468,
1.0300991535,
-0.929325223,
-0.1093195081,
0.7453933358,
0.4759324193,
0.0837126672,
-0.3103221953,
-0.0596037656,
-0.1001295447,
-0.6966536045,
0.9435940385,
-0.5627034307,
-0.2714000344,
-0.0130841872,
0.1567311138,
-0.1964686662,
-0.6222164035,
0.9295861125,
-0.6623715162,
0.1821858436,
-0.651263535,
-0.8027210832,
-0.3216221929,
0.399284333,
-0.6054306626,
0.7449022532,
-0.077187337,
-0.7085418701,
0.7340626717,
-0.4869912863,
-0.0429460928,
-0.1979818493,
-0.0009262582,
-0.3683054447,
0.1593805104,
0.1767047346,
0.1652020514,
-0.1214949042,
0.130121693,
-0.5739231706,
-0.0885951221,
0.3586862087,
-0.5493870974,
0.38745749,
0.3200690746,
-0.121640183,
0.2334519625,
-0.497166276,
0.0752384141,
-0.0610295236,
-0.2419034839,
-0.4863205552,
0.6396576762,
-0.4034558237,
0.1234966889,
-0.1166960746,
-0.5184046626,
0.6327703595,
-0.5013653636,
0.1606676131,
0.8005094528,
0.2581283152,
0.3822933435,
-0.6001778245,
0.4602583349,
-0.0478946753,
0.119170554,
-0.365596056,
-0.723737061,
-1.0795476437,
0.2190303952,
0.2428560853,
0.416487962,
-0.6326798201,
0.2887735367,
-0.2280440032,
-0.3880982697,
-0.5043302178,
-0.1839935035,
-0.098061718,
0.388420105,
0.561632514,
0.106408827,
-0.9004930258,
-0.7395862937,
-0.5288273096,
-0.5490962863,
-0.2829979062,
0.0416895226,
0.5375214815,
-0.4799809158,
1.0869626999,
-0.3982208967,
0.089317821,
-0.2416810095,
0.143980369,
0.2827458978,
0.4049761295,
0.4552670121,
-0.7934229374,
-0.2252908051,
-0.003737207,
-0.6933546066,
0.0952728763,
-0.5798524618,
0.2401062995,
0.3682085872,
0.3654943705,
-0.6402976513,
0.589997232,
0.5783849359,
-0.4025976956,
0.6146818995,
-0.2932549417,
0.2130213082,
-0.9627724886,
-0.3374305665,
0.190673992,
-0.2514921725,
-0.4132284522,
0.1777368784,
0.0652573258,
0.3163995445,
0.0608420447,
0.5570574403,
-0.386415869,
0.0445137285,
-0.3681080341,
0.0501135848,
-0.0787469894,
0.1424282789,
0.3814516068,
0.5249823332,
0.3865156174,
-0.8499929905,
0.2435009032,
0.2595810592,
-0.4605613649,
0.2455944419,
-0.5707750916,
0.1494381875,
-0.364084214,
0.5044738054,
-0.7989076376,
-0.2906028032,
0.1522238702,
-0.5074356794,
0.1112073734,
-0.3256127238,
-0.2932339013,
-0.2127133906,
0.0404248722,
-0.0394617245,
0.511077702,
-0.4556980431,
0.7720831037,
0.1398276687,
-0.3739980459,
-0.6634166241,
-0.6454997659,
0.3495821059,
0.0338723101,
-0.4135390818,
0.1942740828,
-0.3008174002,
-0.7239568233,
0.1210650876,
-0.2170289159,
-0.0018011313,
-0.0565845147,
0.0877897441,
0.3030689359,
-0.3548830748,
0.2237307578,
0.0426802263,
0.0756730214,
0.1279228032,
-0.3386857808,
0.3705122769,
0.0109680463,
-0.5458439589,
-0.3321504295,
-0.0643914118,
0.526494801,
0.2629028261,
0.7486780882,
-0.028905265,
-0.5217902064,
-0.42848593,
-0.6003338695,
-0.2676863968,
-0.4368515313,
0.4285686016,
-0.4534918666,
-0.8159713149,
0.3611485064,
-0.0701239854,
0.5300133824,
0.40863958,
0.6921443343,
-0.1940069795,
0.9206477404,
0.4785876274,
0.246871084,
0.3528083861,
0.3159208894,
0.2131968439,
-0.6317736506,
-0.0515547208,
-0.5240571499,
0.0183317643,
-0.4365776181,
-0.7133104205,
0.0877686441,
0.2344093174,
-0.05808663,
0.2261056453,
-0.2562261224,
0.3474046886,
0.251621455,
0.1317016333,
0.1917766333,
-0.2960963547,
-0.0940230787,
-0.2011034042,
-0.5471375585,
-0.6897061467,
0.9843513966,
0.5640639067,
0.9169937968,
0.2899932563,
0.25278157,
0.5905707479,
0.5988685489,
-0.8960627317,
0.3736048043,
0.3120029867,
-0.6031027436,
-0.2654713392,
-0.2577419579,
-0.6363477111,
0.3304349482,
-0.5374979377,
-0.5697113872,
0.3541401327,
0.4991937578,
-0.237879172,
0.4622105062,
-0.8094627261,
0.6098718643,
0.2423603833,
-0.0542442314,
-0.387340188,
-0.411439687,
0.2432037741,
-0.3827444017,
0.1595103592,
0.0786123574,
0.190919593,
0.4386484623,
-0.3192642033,
0.9172449112,
-0.313749522,
-0.3175989687,
0.1958971918,
0.3430812955,
0.6612354517,
0.087798804,
-0.4398021996,
-0.2528069317,
0.168769896,
-0.1302915215,
-0.9945934415,
0.4324584007,
-0.4791027009,
-0.9386559129,
-0.508153975,
-0.5389970541,
-0.5011073351,
0.025583135,
0.1213199794,
0.0848196521,
-0.2150171697,
0.407538265,
0.9163479209,
-0.3594172597,
0.2196256816,
0.4924992323,
-0.5355560184,
-0.2141893208,
0.2929343283,
-0.1473436505,
0.5283079147,
0.4067374468,
0.2263216823,
-0.4618493021,
-0.688870728,
-0.3621610701,
0.0167784691,
-1.0091365576,
0.0037677605,
-0.4723562598,
0.0797291622,
-0.4662264287,
-0.0565725118,
-0.3529821634,
-0.4599570334,
0.0764962062,
-0.1571829766,
0.3438824415,
0.9875804186,
-0.0798331797,
0.0046099639,
-0.6217224002,
0.3155055642,
0.2632974982,
0.2481064051,
0.0264966879,
-0.7595614195,
-0.0663296431,
0.5457932353,
-0.0678374246,
-0.9429084659,
0.3152329028,
0.1365614533,
0.602455318,
0.0684226677,
0.3445332646,
0.4751659334,
-0.5874760151,
0.7250830531,
0.056788072,
-0.8060020208,
0.6565189958,
-0.261993736,
0.237537846,
0.3330691159,
0.3183708191,
-0.9363665581,
-0.4255676568,
-0.4324485362,
-0.4355169535,
0.4215866625,
-0.0742603615,
-0.045801498,
0.1209498122,
0.7243478894,
0.1510545313,
-0.078422077,
-0.6680362821,
-0.2768911421,
-0.4882833958,
-0.2050502002,
-0.0263377335,
-0.2705786824,
0.0016145459,
-0.3083919287,
0.8123614192,
-0.2580496073,
0.2868740261,
0.4784172773,
0.0509336814,
-0.140465796,
0.5245478153,
0.8862507343,
0.8971863985,
-0.4016765952,
0.0866110399,
0.2769858241,
-0.4378264844,
0.1609079391,
-0.2780995369,
-0.5128296614,
0.1737154424,
0.3975329399,
1.0094444752,
0.0286531709,
-0.6146504879,
0.1811542958,
-0.4048715532,
-0.1881016344,
-0.4482153952,
0.2484886199,
0.1075457409,
0.0777931064,
0.5575302839,
0.8750290275,
-0.3853204548,
-0.7537000179,
0.3812900782,
-0.0105234748,
-0.4675314128,
-0.4228771627,
0.5111271143,
-0.3679960966,
-0.3708842993,
0.2691065669,
-0.158499524,
-0.4948081672,
0.3227651119,
0.5645973682,
0.7801858783,
-0.4085755944,
0.1534830034,
0.5352913737,
0.5144400597,
-0.4372913241,
0.1377653778,
0.4461645186,
-1.426722765,
-0.6204433441,
-0.4925753474,
-0.7380314469,
0.1738653332,
-0.6515545845,
0.2768755555,
-0.618522644,
-0.2337638587,
-0.0679306388,
-0.4658108652,
-0.3887931705,
0.5597649217,
-0.0555413403,
1.2070966959,
-0.756495297,
1.1171934605,
0.5799367428,
-0.3482958078,
-0.6983360052,
0.5449414849,
0.0114682866,
-0.6622076035,
0.5705190301,
-0.3545566797,
-0.0109197805,
-0.244750455,
-0.5478423238,
-0.742026031,
0.6394559145,
0.5126518607,
-0.6663599014,
-0.0124990856,
-0.1959977746,
0.6474637985,
-0.3751100898,
0.0775963962,
0.3573165536,
0.602616787,
0.1785359979,
-0.7688426375,
-0.1000808999,
-0.0252786074,
-0.2062967122,
0.0085309781,
-0.0735805556,
0.8718039989,
-0.51594311,
-0.0818868279,
0.0475019552,
0.8585900068,
0.6014882326,
0.0622477829,
0.833122313,
0.5415676236,
1.0188673735,
-0.1389121562,
1.0675692558,
-0.0481185913,
0.3882478476,
1.3876184225,
-0.5992333293,
1.3538953066,
0.3606399894,
-0.1089967713,
0.8174803853,
0.741273284,
0.1511522084,
0.4616340697,
-0.0338748693,
-0.2880115211,
-0.4870810807,
0.0651463419,
-0.4074280262,
0.1901804507,
0.4965012074,
-0.2422466725,
0.0157269705,
-0.1530757695,
0.1003013179,
0.1736060232,
-0.1591879427,
0.5392006636,
0.0147295399,
-1.0948036909,
0.7133225799,
0.0436841026,
0.4943650067,
-0.6651002169,
-0.3903337717,
-0.0424545631,
0.4397994578,
-0.1122990772,
-0.9476111531,
0.4043678343,
-0.0531002693,
-0.398249507,
-0.333876729,
0.6257132292,
-0.2029620707,
-0.2501508594,
0.1623091698,
0.2390983552,
-0.1705861241,
-0.059597332,
-0.8239412904,
0.3093054891,
0.3938379288,
-0.3112535477,
0.2226029634,
0.5612586141,
-0.0307576563,
1.0546214581,
0.6697658896,
0.3258788884,
-0.0469366536,
0.2505412102,
0.7865689397,
-0.6696747541,
-0.3636549413,
-0.6751149297,
0.1659434587,
-0.0148061421,
-0.2429790944,
0.8246899247,
0.2564855814,
0.7831136584,
-0.0665645748,
1.1820908785,
0.099140428,
0.7861052752,
-0.8318582773,
0.5626400709,
-0.3940700293,
0.4045912623,
-0.3173591197,
-0.7350635529,
-0.2061233968,
0.9477068186,
-0.3403763771,
-0.0006295326,
0.8945972919,
0.5682200193,
0.2346246988,
0.5223518014,
0.3310268521,
0.5655044913,
0.3617905974,
0.3130859435,
1.0002279282,
-0.5508357882,
-0.0210900754,
0.1569599509,
-0.1236864254,
-0.08586061,
-1.1201422215,
-0.5443966389,
-0.6682107449,
-0.4308652282,
-0.6458278298,
0.0083272513,
1.1338149309,
0.5015665293,
-1.0075159073,
0.0241600871,
-0.2254426926,
0.1938709319,
-0.3511721492,
-0.2141741514,
0.054959245,
-0.213379845,
-0.4907614589,
0.7704350352,
0.0895305127,
0.0956488177,
-0.2413406074,
-0.330593586,
-0.2487031668,
0.1953023821,
0.3925180137,
0.4764511883,
-1.0609208345,
-0.7869740129,
0.0198029429,
0.134693101,
0.0703381747,
0.8094046712,
-0.8065311909,
0.5717809796,
0.4975051284,
0.6047654748,
0.3570261896,
-0.1330725849,
0.967161417,
-0.4804155529,
0.1248845384,
0.4169166386,
0.7323617935,
0.449242264,
-0.0397835113,
0.3593197167,
0.3800422847,
-0.6168836355,
-0.9372956157,
0.4611901045,
-0.7095566392,
-0.5238989592,
1.129291296,
-0.2847910523,
-0.0923115686,
-0.4447362423,
-0.2308968157,
-0.1317749172,
-0.3385523856,
0.7140778899,
0.9405691028,
-0.0288819484,
-0.4846177101,
-0.6250953078,
0.6851664782,
0.4445850253,
-0.5678216815,
0.546636343,
0.5061148405,
0.3559466302,
0.1536879838,
0.7138995528,
0.226669088,
0.1803694218,
0.1420394331,
0.2045635134,
0.431186676,
-0.2007746398,
-0.2632364333,
-0.0237794854,
0.5391253233,
0.421094507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19760v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19760v1 | Learning Interpretable Legal Case Retrieval via Knowledge-Guided Case Reformulation | 2024-06-28T08:59:45 | 2024-06-28T08:59:45 | Chenlong Deng, Kelong Mao, Zhicheng Dou | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Legal case retrieval for sourcing similar cases is critical in upholding
judicial fairness. Different from general web search, legal case retrieval
involves processing lengthy, complex, and highly specialized legal documents.
Existing methods in this domain often overlook the incorporation of legal
expert knowledge, which is crucial for accurately understanding and modeling
legal cases, leading to unsatisfactory retrieval performance. This paper
introduces KELLER, a legal knowledge-guided case reformulation approach based
on large language models (LLMs) for effective and interpretable legal case
retrieval. By incorporating professional legal knowledge about crimes and law
articles, we enable large language models to accurately reformulate the
original legal case into concise sub-facts of crimes, which contain the
essential information of the case. Extensive experiments on two legal case
retrieval benchmarks demonstrate superior retrieval performance and robustness
on complex legal case queries of KELLER over existing methods. | [
-0.0366675779,
-0.7101771235,
1.1325314045,
-0.2080609202,
-0.4712901711,
-0.1463858336,
-0.2268592119,
-0.3435174525,
0.202954188,
1.0085117817,
-0.1901593506,
-0.7614532709,
-0.5650732517,
-0.0930740386,
-0.5460785627,
1.066129446,
0.1007372141,
0.2772680223,
-0.130102396,
-0.2955043018,
-0.3052900732,
-0.4121323526,
-0.5248792171,
-0.2396255136,
0.5089768767,
0.2980745435,
0.4012385011,
0.5731469393,
0.7378113866,
0.3000685573,
-0.3320145905,
-0.2558081746,
-0.5323754549,
0.2003605217,
-0.1630096734,
-0.7947223186,
-0.5426281095,
-0.1863991916,
0.1427969187,
0.3845196962,
-0.8220644593,
0.1022679731,
-0.5035021901,
0.6858383417,
-0.7498301268,
0.3149681985,
-0.8212453723,
0.2439415157,
-0.4411557317,
-0.2563477755,
-0.6243940592,
-0.601282537,
-0.0197024774,
-0.917609334,
0.4316059947,
0.2104452997,
0.3108189404,
0.2613294423,
-0.971116662,
-0.479899317,
-0.6215083003,
0.663944304,
-0.9625127912,
0.5332115293,
0.2531414032,
1.1332318783,
-0.2884773612,
-1.3042144775,
-0.6955379844,
-0.2616291344,
-0.1896508038,
-0.0660879016,
-0.278550297,
0.2912507355,
0.3960030377,
-0.0951304957,
-0.4110572934,
-0.3080716729,
-0.560755074,
-0.3477661312,
0.6898970604,
0.0871972069,
0.2780531347,
-0.2218799889,
-0.0270881876,
-0.1011722982,
-0.8135941029,
0.1327470541,
0.4970887303,
0.4936336279,
0.3648729622,
0.5433760285,
-0.1549833119,
0.743439436,
-0.0997268036,
-0.4221758842,
0.1894983351,
0.1016200036,
-0.2945235372,
0.2402668446,
0.3527163565,
0.2882677019,
0.3032062352,
-0.2487509251,
-0.5457651615,
-0.9144114256,
0.5735170245,
-0.5631239414,
0.0778003782,
0.1478320956,
-0.5309405327,
-0.0363891423,
0.5372840762,
-0.6241203547,
-0.3746375144,
-0.4036403894,
0.2487292886,
-0.3063349128,
-0.0124611603,
0.2382925898,
-0.2409953326,
0.2301791906,
0.6153452396,
-0.5843919516,
0.1891983747,
0.858569622,
0.1306238323,
0.271897614,
0.3297536373,
-1.1717364788,
0.3902699351,
-0.150800705,
0.4319117665,
-0.7600623965,
-0.1188686714,
0.3065396249,
0.1846455336,
0.4730865657,
-0.7815641165,
0.9754475355,
-1.3262009621,
-0.2489139587,
-0.2821151018,
-0.4456724524,
-0.6050433517,
0.306569308,
-0.7233532071,
0.1629317403,
-0.0540313199,
-0.4253731668,
0.7264050841,
-0.5811564326,
-0.7386550307,
0.2527733147,
-0.0300995503,
-0.4888964593,
0.1487388164,
0.2439447194,
0.4121980965,
0.1459711939,
0.7117866874,
-0.243331641,
-0.3134541214,
-0.2390658706,
0.0262970701,
0.7360313535,
0.3459633589,
0.0034388979,
-0.0208557416,
-0.512590766,
-0.26047194,
0.0477354154,
-0.5665840507,
-0.4702748358,
-0.1149311289,
-0.0958840102,
-0.1170736849,
0.0529067442,
-0.6984945536,
0.1131510139,
-0.0155805591,
0.293805629,
0.599817574,
-0.0237237215,
0.3587545455,
-0.1367966086,
0.687142849,
0.2846336663,
0.3674434721,
0.0506583489,
-0.3914108574,
-0.4500484467,
-0.0634316206,
0.4565211833,
0.3436776698,
-0.7226693034,
-0.0992756709,
-0.4144141674,
-0.1072406471,
-0.7923645377,
0.2099188566,
0.1763616502,
0.5685979724,
0.6922281981,
0.0302469917,
-0.663688302,
-1.1237363815,
-0.7764939666,
0.1225325242,
-0.0212621335,
0.460293591,
0.64447999,
-0.3972126842,
1.0898795128,
-0.5310940742,
-0.577549994,
-0.1919202805,
0.0768833905,
0.3730431497,
-0.0367517583,
0.3120966852,
-1.0759868622,
-0.6274687052,
0.1766917259,
-0.7237377763,
-0.0367118493,
0.2456487566,
0.1598619521,
0.0530168861,
1.0055536032,
-0.3844491541,
0.4192374945,
-0.2949718833,
-0.606692791,
0.4626443088,
-0.2397286296,
0.1646606773,
-0.7807821631,
-0.0483381189,
-0.0836095735,
-0.7458339334,
-0.4942519665,
0.4031356275,
0.3612045348,
0.3934472799,
-0.7708231807,
0.4509861171,
-0.3677039444,
-0.2330619395,
-0.0993076116,
0.4243705869,
0.0807002559,
0.2035564184,
-0.5040836334,
0.5511979461,
0.0579742715,
-0.4752484262,
0.5485081077,
0.1536293477,
-0.6855016351,
0.7197906375,
-0.3433885574,
-0.1341210604,
-0.6133842468,
0.3130609393,
-0.2853915989,
-0.2220231444,
-0.1051225737,
0.1243962571,
0.5177029371,
-0.5363486409,
-0.5953731537,
-0.244855389,
-0.0604235046,
0.605789423,
0.5984865427,
-0.4807230532,
0.7237227559,
0.5469170809,
-0.2211047411,
-0.8017001748,
-0.5296654105,
0.0722129792,
-0.2831911147,
-0.2873868048,
0.374391675,
0.3134568334,
-0.508836031,
0.224003464,
-0.0348071717,
-0.0302641783,
-0.2479355037,
-0.0419988707,
-0.319009304,
-0.2810109556,
0.4003093243,
0.2812615335,
0.1743478477,
0.0594020709,
0.0579749383,
0.3900253773,
0.1435363293,
-0.615696311,
-0.3464947939,
0.296647042,
0.5175981522,
-0.0143282982,
0.3264895678,
0.3509833217,
-0.1110526398,
-0.1985031664,
-0.9839944839,
-0.3895680606,
-0.3898004889,
0.2782124579,
-0.562451005,
-0.9928732514,
0.5919339061,
-0.007543603,
0.0741556883,
0.471078217,
0.1060715392,
-0.0767591298,
0.6434220672,
0.7022454143,
0.1221327186,
0.4605369866,
-0.0468100496,
0.3887710869,
-0.8266328573,
-0.6540810466,
-0.3877549469,
-0.1122084856,
-0.2011119276,
-0.3666950464,
0.5502716303,
0.1004198566,
-0.2759827375,
0.2291929722,
0.0139551228,
0.5144377351,
0.6151031852,
0.3633409142,
0.939437151,
0.1496232301,
-0.3252930343,
-0.0325451046,
-0.4895504713,
-0.4277911186,
1.581638217,
0.0769631118,
0.5071038604,
0.5747406483,
0.6286857128,
0.5578614473,
0.5911899805,
-0.8442674875,
0.469963342,
-0.1944736242,
-0.5278275013,
-0.3831280172,
-0.5964688659,
-1.0073486567,
0.2596771419,
-0.0677235797,
-0.442692399,
-0.100352332,
-0.3446854353,
-0.3360040784,
0.244388029,
-0.4419356287,
0.4510190785,
0.1932773441,
-0.061471086,
-0.4958466291,
-0.462677151,
0.5200640559,
-0.3905030191,
0.5838962793,
0.1334160715,
0.1470201463,
0.7065320611,
-0.7075497508,
0.5274908543,
-0.2495710552,
-0.0577358082,
0.1800010949,
0.1321414113,
0.685089767,
0.0800496414,
-0.2903975248,
-0.3106599152,
0.1502128839,
-0.2826970518,
-1.1886019707,
0.4388122261,
-0.2670517266,
-1.334769249,
-0.1451183707,
-0.6726685166,
0.0496195592,
0.2052062452,
-0.2657798231,
0.2079429775,
0.0281647295,
0.1795704812,
0.4740745127,
-0.0382089429,
0.2722703516,
1.1227493286,
-0.2100050151,
-0.2951297164,
0.5612763166,
0.1724875718,
-0.3309103847,
0.4214308262,
0.1052601635,
-0.5214265585,
-0.5858541727,
-0.2321084589,
0.3728567362,
-0.9277040362,
-0.4054453969,
-0.730725646,
0.0269758943,
-0.5969712734,
-0.0812150985,
-0.0977303907,
-0.3347089291,
0.1812900603,
-0.0540178828,
0.4576874971,
0.8787733316,
0.0961451754,
0.0515769385,
-0.7392353415,
0.2662636042,
0.6861975193,
0.4792972803,
-0.0558937527,
-0.9315245152,
0.0282707214,
-0.0226342008,
-0.1892797649,
-0.6009206772,
0.1562177837,
-0.0869651064,
0.7490301132,
0.5996409655,
0.4273426533,
0.6531330347,
-0.7751214504,
0.2966994345,
0.1158519089,
-0.8005272746,
0.6611885428,
-0.20034419,
-0.211416617,
0.6697978973,
0.1415840089,
-0.376360774,
-0.3087839484,
-0.3965659142,
-0.8104467392,
0.7873074412,
0.1158002019,
0.2618964314,
0.3334649205,
0.7953663468,
0.1972725242,
0.3966624737,
-0.6714292765,
0.2498444915,
0.1197822988,
-0.2652059793,
-0.0767242461,
-0.3580906391,
-0.5109336972,
-0.6021526456,
0.6481181979,
0.0390279591,
0.0088273883,
0.1738554388,
-0.3205302358,
0.0416357331,
0.3762307167,
0.7246100307,
0.5564819574,
-0.2648777664,
0.1161506325,
0.1425752789,
-0.5261206031,
0.1729811877,
-0.0654395893,
-0.2655766904,
-0.0279425997,
0.4373719096,
0.6359539628,
0.0100363409,
-0.7138525844,
0.7427542806,
-0.2005610317,
-0.278498441,
-0.3398495913,
0.1268774122,
-0.1047511622,
0.6858406663,
0.6183028221,
-0.2842978835,
0.4729362428,
-0.764516592,
0.4484960139,
0.5490208268,
-0.6524274945,
0.2260192335,
0.6077051163,
0.112338312,
-0.4420787692,
0.6136729121,
-0.1563120186,
-0.3805751204,
0.6748650074,
0.4406101406,
0.4839591682,
-0.030458672,
0.3171901703,
0.0101497304,
0.0782454535,
-0.5409513712,
0.2215662748,
-0.3056467474,
-0.3827528358,
-0.337834239,
-0.77252841,
-0.0557253547,
0.06341362,
-0.764665246,
0.1596764177,
-0.0249245986,
-0.1387011558,
-0.4858908653,
-0.0603732355,
-0.4487692118,
0.0678234771,
-0.6876651049,
1.123286128,
-0.3122006953,
0.8865481019,
0.6862261891,
-0.2934110165,
-0.6916287541,
0.1990828365,
-0.1242245436,
-0.5588057041,
0.9085176587,
-0.1797061116,
0.0875328034,
0.1204588115,
-0.3519122005,
-0.3708865047,
1.3355189562,
0.6290050149,
-0.6500859857,
0.1370989233,
0.3276012838,
0.6311638355,
-0.2912932932,
0.1039554328,
0.6275423765,
0.6737902761,
0.4007177651,
-0.6233834624,
0.361948967,
-0.062872611,
-0.0265116468,
0.1763836145,
-0.287799865,
0.4603173137,
-0.4260688126,
-0.04483895,
-0.4103567004,
0.4773862362,
0.1846641302,
0.5775002241,
0.4176638126,
0.6517080069,
0.8633574843,
-0.1304393262,
1.0915890932,
-0.231608361,
0.3862330616,
0.6882426143,
0.0029543822,
0.8288921118,
0.7768834829,
-0.1480097026,
0.4465143383,
0.1272526383,
0.0274903122,
0.6441599727,
0.3557782471,
-0.3469840288,
-0.4869026244,
0.1274726093,
-0.0330449641,
0.4052129984,
-0.0153145185,
-0.4973346293,
-0.3620137274,
0.1061634868,
0.2326578796,
0.207661286,
-0.3787326813,
0.7314288616,
0.2170977294,
-0.7296596169,
0.1190919951,
0.2877195776,
0.4300771952,
-0.2765331268,
-0.1959372759,
-0.5480597019,
0.1603362411,
-0.3341285586,
-0.8982790112,
0.3859370947,
-0.1446231157,
-0.1192183122,
-0.1633822173,
0.3595920503,
-0.3854877055,
-0.3627134562,
0.3011858761,
0.2928208709,
0.1293582171,
-0.2745924592,
-0.3713183403,
-0.2169279009,
0.0089023625,
-0.4137613475,
0.3045044243,
0.5178120732,
-0.1635141373,
1.0178419352,
0.6068373919,
-0.0332959741,
-0.0037865934,
0.4037360251,
0.751036644,
-0.6521494985,
-0.2361853123,
-0.6688175797,
0.5551629663,
-0.1710707247,
0.2394714803,
0.4583550394,
0.5873687267,
0.6360107064,
-0.0826535374,
0.4514956176,
0.3090534806,
0.2432118505,
-0.8022115231,
0.9645363092,
-0.7446871996,
0.4876156449,
-0.1094602346,
-0.8299114704,
-0.5531901121,
0.4028791785,
-0.4772948325,
0.2043689489,
0.3689380288,
0.7374258041,
-0.6416316628,
-0.0602787361,
0.6513828635,
0.346830368,
0.5085970163,
0.2855569422,
0.3194825649,
-0.5276032686,
0.9399049878,
0.1932067871,
0.0202819183,
-0.7624436617,
-0.6560624838,
-0.6460539103,
-0.55156672,
0.0695676431,
-0.1760129929,
0.2550602853,
0.4237054586,
0.7586408257,
-0.7182713151,
0.039247904,
-0.286373347,
0.5006681085,
0.0891474783,
-0.2989793122,
0.2311785668,
-0.586114943,
-0.6816856861,
0.3188990355,
0.1473051757,
-0.1486988962,
0.0641294494,
-0.1793156713,
0.0560359247,
0.1639875174,
0.7702183127,
0.1133990511,
-0.7477368712,
-0.1285152882,
-0.3215173781,
-0.1550709903,
0.031697534,
1.243165493,
-0.8080712557,
0.5784701109,
0.2763720155,
0.3748166859,
0.9099318981,
0.0737717673,
0.7131249905,
-0.6281519532,
0.1070519611,
0.3365230262,
0.4906081259,
0.1938614398,
-0.3184202909,
0.3011245728,
0.2222826183,
-0.3450517654,
-0.8964151144,
0.4953603446,
-0.7902552485,
-0.4920122623,
1.0654211044,
-0.2953160703,
-0.234809652,
-0.5113614202,
-0.0201978628,
0.2801209688,
-0.590292871,
1.0843131542,
0.5725623965,
0.1368036866,
-0.3103560209,
-0.7839129567,
0.5767908096,
0.2213947922,
-0.5324018598,
-0.2494140714,
0.3232244253,
0.5220115185,
0.0538275093,
0.4368425906,
-0.3872665465,
0.1428970695,
-0.3323618174,
0.0861098766,
-0.3423575759,
-0.2247928679,
-0.1984893978,
0.5552457571,
-0.2278914452,
0.4179339111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19759v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19759v1 | Breaking the Script Barrier in Multilingual Pre-Trained Language Models with Transliteration-Based Post-Training Alignment | 2024-06-28T08:59:24 | 2024-06-28T08:59:24 | Orgest Xhelili, Yihong Liu, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual pre-trained models (mPLMs) have shown impressive performance on
cross-lingual transfer tasks. However, the transfer performance is often
hindered when a low-resource target language is written in a different script
than the high-resource source language, even though the two languages may be
related or share parts of their vocabularies. Inspired by recent work that uses
transliteration to address this problem, our paper proposes a
transliteration-based post-pretraining alignment (PPA) method aiming to improve
the cross-lingual alignment between languages using diverse scripts. We select
two areal language groups, $\textbf{Mediterranean-Amharic-Farsi}$ and
$\textbf{South+East Asian Languages}$, wherein the languages are mutually
influenced but use different scripts. We apply our method to these language
groups and conduct extensive experiments on a spectrum of downstream tasks. The
results show that after PPA, models consistently outperform the original model
(up to 50% for some tasks) in English-centric transfer. In addition, when we
use languages other than English as sources in transfer, our method obtains
even larger improvements. We will make our code and models publicly available
at \url{https://github.com/cisnlp/Transliteration-PPA}. | [
-0.1201932505,
0.0683339238,
0.3516430855,
0.1035532728,
-0.2728025019,
0.4032234251,
-0.2448504418,
-0.2745788097,
0.1629561782,
0.3293561339,
-0.6614829302,
-0.3867125809,
-0.7274461985,
0.1021063998,
0.0060005574,
0.8368098736,
-0.530684948,
0.4846522808,
0.2128733844,
-0.2371407449,
-0.2869271934,
-0.4450360537,
-0.0811741054,
-0.07417579,
0.7679563165,
0.3920761049,
0.5879591703,
0.6132419109,
0.8447958827,
0.2335391194,
0.4408243001,
-0.0140121402,
-0.2823407352,
-0.2325055897,
-0.3435272872,
-0.3923910558,
-0.3849901855,
0.0302572083,
0.7838912606,
0.8661428094,
-0.2711654007,
0.1906729043,
0.0088696461,
0.3474772871,
-0.8472074866,
-0.0289501436,
-0.7384185195,
0.0052389726,
-0.609952271,
-0.1729266942,
-0.4365680516,
-0.2533241212,
0.1533505768,
-0.7262679935,
-0.035311304,
-0.0672031194,
1.0476433039,
0.1038980857,
-0.2383004576,
-0.0424165837,
-0.7849824429,
1.0314701796,
-0.6859028339,
0.5251398683,
0.3373473287,
0.4381990731,
0.2874642909,
-0.5009083152,
-0.4726913273,
0.0732733235,
-0.1909292489,
-0.024455525,
-0.0289722513,
-0.1330674738,
0.1648405641,
0.0537863001,
-0.6685589552,
0.2600300908,
-0.3487137556,
-0.4883528352,
0.2233003825,
-0.3200243413,
0.647130847,
0.091874592,
-0.4213857949,
-0.1922806948,
-1.0510867834,
-0.0250398982,
0.591225028,
0.6687676907,
-0.1014743745,
0.4601336122,
0.0789217651,
0.6118478179,
0.0916806459,
-0.2545076013,
0.42520684,
-0.7042480707,
0.112512432,
0.1649018973,
0.5597791672,
0.282229811,
0.3662751019,
-0.2578765154,
-0.0594177768,
0.0303390734,
0.1317941993,
-0.789948523,
-0.0930090994,
-0.2014039755,
-0.4706893861,
0.0815354437,
0.0642031059,
-0.6015547514,
-0.2650884986,
-0.5010963082,
0.4695204794,
-0.5930123329,
-0.4623838365,
-0.10439004,
0.3598905504,
0.655903995,
0.2563691437,
-0.9768058062,
-0.0978062525,
0.5609550476,
0.820281446,
0.0406196564,
-0.8740558028,
-0.712128222,
0.3429303467,
-0.2185441405,
0.9210902452,
-0.7037967443,
-0.0308215823,
0.2839353383,
0.0327175744,
-0.4617825747,
-0.4543494582,
0.0848934874,
-0.3648592532,
0.4788508713,
-0.3687162101,
-0.2378951162,
0.0337502249,
0.0250497684,
-0.5066475868,
0.6547392011,
0.1996150464,
-0.6750505567,
0.4113317728,
-0.5498982072,
-0.7354707718,
-0.1808879077,
0.0121558802,
-0.2281643748,
-0.1714307517,
0.287991941,
0.1638872176,
-0.2932850718,
0.1664188951,
-0.2032162547,
-0.2891799212,
0.0394845605,
-0.1678945273,
0.6386570334,
0.3179145753,
-0.1648218334,
0.3232410848,
-0.7227882147,
0.1341317743,
-0.1469466239,
-0.0930611268,
-0.2389104813,
-0.239203006,
-0.0456373096,
0.7042688727,
0.4098479748,
-0.4485767186,
0.2391756326,
-0.151145041,
0.1308329105,
0.8378314972,
-0.6437031031,
0.8481229544,
-0.3575281203,
0.843906939,
0.127598986,
0.1509037018,
-0.2199086994,
0.0986040086,
-0.5368698239,
-0.3445513546,
0.6955355406,
0.5464755893,
-0.9913195968,
0.1472535282,
-0.5431783199,
-0.5610829592,
-1.0478628874,
0.1714842469,
0.5063299537,
0.4860283732,
0.3717792928,
-0.6772174239,
-0.7148217559,
-0.6996663213,
-0.3896663189,
-0.162900731,
-0.0784012377,
-0.0477075428,
0.0080328733,
-0.1315167248,
0.6280527711,
-0.1355542839,
-0.4035500288,
-0.4711339772,
0.2233284265,
0.0807356089,
0.6623404622,
0.5358140469,
-0.5681875944,
-0.9715394974,
0.2703178227,
-0.2370261252,
-0.4536569715,
-0.1562286615,
-0.4518826902,
0.1739355177,
0.4488195777,
-0.5958188176,
0.2076901644,
0.8950105309,
-0.1062218398,
0.8279644251,
-0.0633080676,
0.4062135816,
-1.2325267792,
0.377517283,
-0.2944797277,
-0.1311303377,
-0.6184309125,
-0.1502451152,
0.1559927762,
-0.225573346,
-0.8050233126,
0.4430513978,
-0.6679335833,
-0.185218811,
-0.1541609466,
-0.1104968786,
-0.177100271,
0.5855880976,
0.2088865489,
0.8585950136,
0.7826400399,
-0.2577545643,
-0.0495018251,
0.1361403614,
-0.3238768578,
0.5677405596,
-0.2207427621,
0.3077511489,
0.0053069685,
0.4094482064,
-0.8462005258,
-0.067045413,
0.4602732062,
-0.2557960153,
0.6218731403,
-0.4691996574,
-0.332988292,
0.1739611924,
-0.0702650845,
0.7105585933,
0.4398676455,
-0.4088875949,
0.7100284696,
0.1939705759,
-0.3909599483,
-0.9592986703,
-0.413215518,
0.0099851806,
-0.2451258004,
-0.51876086,
0.5992969275,
0.0051820539,
-0.1308908612,
-0.2514250576,
-0.1485839486,
-0.3407326043,
-0.2570445538,
-0.0860910714,
0.4507622123,
-0.4214301109,
-0.1772844791,
-0.1278092265,
-0.2377061099,
-0.3922257423,
-0.5058361292,
0.8324708939,
0.1652607024,
-0.5047274232,
-0.5754214525,
0.3389359713,
0.6551360488,
-0.7967220545,
0.961125493,
0.8198389411,
-0.2118685991,
0.1488212496,
-0.4825949967,
-0.0384885855,
-0.3954333067,
0.2770360708,
-0.5199135542,
-0.5353705883,
0.5791402459,
-0.2771412432,
-0.0229271036,
0.2757253945,
0.3520777524,
-0.0595291108,
0.8017572761,
0.8470266461,
-0.103405714,
0.8492557406,
0.1935073584,
0.4430434406,
-0.6716099977,
0.1762022674,
-0.6694348454,
-0.3038291633,
-0.5074115396,
-0.6343371868,
-0.177450493,
0.1697789133,
0.0422456004,
0.7455592155,
0.0138699617,
0.5722825527,
0.44108814,
-0.2907083035,
0.0805912912,
0.154505372,
-0.1755451709,
-0.2865097821,
-0.6634673476,
-0.4002076089,
1.3127752542,
0.0878309757,
0.7049236894,
0.2534860075,
0.7058063149,
-0.1017718911,
0.660740912,
-0.4105075002,
0.3709176183,
-0.4805924296,
-0.3741497695,
-0.2260392904,
-0.496645391,
-0.924501121,
0.5717893243,
0.0006885719,
-0.6408253908,
0.008775563,
-0.094324179,
-0.2437542826,
0.4105246365,
-0.7430610657,
1.0910123587,
-0.3097760379,
-0.351970017,
-0.1754479706,
-0.9504832625,
0.1172171161,
-0.3833039105,
0.1905845255,
-0.0529479794,
0.3079860508,
0.5767394304,
-0.6120960712,
0.4800027311,
-0.2156813294,
-0.2692503631,
0.0344118811,
-0.0557799973,
0.471902281,
-0.6929978728,
0.0029111386,
0.3558384478,
0.0422140993,
-0.7024711967,
-0.5257712603,
0.3124473691,
-0.7591901422,
-0.4064462483,
-0.4675931334,
-0.7211815119,
-0.3591712415,
0.5594667792,
0.3946357667,
0.2529178858,
-0.0435070768,
-0.0724605024,
0.2646928132,
-0.3708120584,
0.2906571329,
0.9473819137,
-0.2805751562,
-0.1755728424,
1.0790307522,
0.3169145584,
0.4964757264,
0.6460613608,
-0.1055405065,
-0.4686024785,
-0.8023252487,
-0.5438048244,
0.4635320008,
-0.5856928229,
-0.0364681706,
-0.3526615798,
-0.0852894485,
-0.920401454,
-0.208141923,
-0.4895235598,
-0.214745298,
-0.0752161592,
0.0588641763,
-0.4133574069,
0.2864662707,
-0.204419896,
0.4554539025,
-1.0238528252,
0.1534985751,
-0.0272423308,
0.3323881328,
-0.2416900992,
-0.7529064417,
-0.2719340324,
0.0288181435,
-0.0958149657,
-0.7841610312,
0.4319708347,
0.0617467165,
0.4530417621,
0.2663414478,
-0.0152451014,
1.0343463421,
-0.7723254561,
0.3599959314,
0.5421749353,
-0.8968515992,
0.2644749582,
-0.3655911982,
0.3650121689,
0.7355738282,
0.4714423418,
-0.7101938128,
-0.2107257247,
-0.3588947654,
-0.7595074773,
0.8888325691,
0.0733321756,
-0.027439421,
0.4561074972,
-0.0997116864,
0.4350488484,
0.1535810828,
-0.8367750049,
0.0171450693,
-0.1035652906,
-0.3349457979,
-0.2130926847,
0.0280887559,
0.0068779322,
-0.138016209,
0.6843455434,
-0.1810876876,
-0.2589713931,
-0.0319592468,
-0.7077876925,
-0.3485261202,
0.3691255748,
0.494042486,
1.0085260868,
-0.0804641917,
0.1666084975,
0.020065641,
-0.4414298236,
0.4095497429,
0.4977696836,
0.0571926273,
-0.0983866155,
0.3972302377,
0.6356859207,
0.2124551982,
-0.6672945023,
0.5624325275,
-0.0968467742,
0.2395680249,
-0.0294786822,
-0.3774541616,
-0.1482975632,
0.0013381497,
0.2850362957,
0.329903394,
-0.3506339788,
-0.5598483086,
0.3047400713,
0.2414549738,
-0.295715332,
-0.6436677575,
0.3756014705,
0.2853612602,
-0.2426135838,
0.5741214156,
-0.0864103585,
-0.6470202804,
0.3149808943,
0.5508996248,
0.7666826844,
-0.7819324136,
0.3904012442,
0.290568769,
0.4091972709,
0.0241741873,
-0.0262583047,
0.0244479068,
-0.778880477,
-0.8328202367,
-0.7806024551,
-0.3526805937,
-0.0356462561,
-0.5649551749,
0.4433438182,
-0.2767105401,
0.2482315004,
-0.0000641465,
-0.1204477623,
-0.7948728204,
-0.0309362728,
0.3050708175,
0.5682283044,
-0.9115617871,
1.2575298548,
0.6827237606,
-0.4548129439,
-1.0036616325,
0.3530740142,
-0.158328101,
-0.8403054476,
0.5735985041,
0.3533356488,
-0.1623399258,
-0.0114876786,
-0.0067764455,
-1.1130963564,
0.8260045648,
0.7514192462,
-0.7173050642,
-0.1430140883,
0.4697608948,
0.5621635914,
-0.4821299911,
0.2007216513,
0.4332198799,
0.5003356934,
0.0846333802,
-1.2454314232,
-0.0654478371,
-0.2155061364,
-0.3192315698,
0.1776789725,
-0.5733438134,
0.8365687132,
-0.2430869043,
-0.4155996144,
0.2037251443,
0.6338629723,
0.1068508327,
0.039561078,
0.6148443222,
0.4362672865,
0.6674924493,
0.0227102432,
1.0186818838,
-0.4041970372,
0.0690329671,
1.2421710491,
-0.7576976418,
0.774035275,
0.7211805582,
-0.3488354683,
0.6218554974,
0.5974038839,
0.269587338,
0.6602268219,
0.1411762983,
-0.080143936,
-0.1620721221,
-0.4170922935,
-0.4791728258,
0.6092467308,
-0.1902054697,
-0.3162632883,
-0.3173853755,
-0.0375707522,
0.0774974972,
-0.06378638,
-0.2199247479,
0.5335647464,
-0.1669822633,
-1.0883860588,
0.4958862066,
-0.0450738147,
0.6993311048,
-1.1330455542,
0.1166594997,
-0.2043011487,
0.2792774141,
-0.0702754036,
-0.3350723684,
0.3200899661,
0.1115654707,
-0.1056138352,
-0.6858056784,
0.6738975644,
-0.9828915,
-0.4515377879,
0.3831165135,
0.6282281876,
0.1582529247,
-0.0271395408,
-0.6468550563,
-0.0053507201,
0.1891017258,
0.1611595601,
0.7983763218,
0.1667499989,
0.0259448681,
0.2913363278,
0.8190506101,
0.2883634865,
0.2028444856,
0.3511567116,
0.5257210732,
-0.3769355118,
-0.4849353731,
-0.6139520407,
0.4082150757,
0.2558077574,
-0.3094596863,
0.837525785,
0.4446775615,
1.0871549845,
-0.1055623814,
0.6894916296,
-0.0797694027,
0.4003138244,
-0.580278337,
0.8179687262,
-0.5182914734,
0.0433860421,
-0.4600576758,
-1.2096831799,
-0.378867209,
0.4695216715,
-0.3809196651,
-0.1177424192,
0.7937166691,
0.8138375878,
-0.1830394715,
-0.3969641924,
0.2731503248,
-0.0649456978,
0.2849065959,
0.6970646977,
0.985250771,
-0.2290749252,
0.8887813687,
-0.3550185263,
-0.1431377381,
0.0472289473,
-0.8027558923,
-0.4433295727,
-0.5558383465,
-0.3340841234,
-0.2773842514,
-0.0457243137,
0.6844388247,
0.7610054016,
-0.8349331617,
-0.3643267751,
0.2016697526,
0.1385669708,
-0.3496358395,
-0.1420877427,
0.4580412805,
-0.4749386311,
-0.9134702086,
0.3381409049,
0.1585492045,
0.1341737062,
-0.2443783283,
-0.1710529327,
-0.5800660253,
-0.0927301496,
0.2670842111,
0.3134037554,
-0.5129409432,
-0.2779875994,
0.0212872811,
-0.2589459121,
0.210315004,
1.0500323772,
-0.3209220469,
0.4316446185,
0.4514208734,
0.6601410508,
0.0897854045,
-0.0369511247,
0.9460291266,
-0.8158060312,
0.2410048097,
0.0898685753,
0.5471020341,
0.5983231664,
0.0166669339,
0.4166371822,
0.2621015012,
-0.1859341562,
-0.9426016808,
0.2471118271,
-0.593343854,
-0.283105135,
1.0750118494,
-0.4852677584,
-0.1206691042,
0.0429776572,
-0.2820007205,
0.6313880086,
0.0307037197,
0.710709393,
1.0300955772,
0.2309771031,
-0.0221166778,
0.0182706416,
0.4915110469,
0.862460196,
-0.7909619808,
0.2571150064,
0.3541533649,
0.3982740343,
0.3310916424,
0.7298604846,
-0.3141310811,
0.3358392715,
-0.088244088,
0.2332732528,
0.2634882033,
-0.5596585274,
-0.4085513353,
0.0031918285,
-0.0496074967,
-0.2948707342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19736v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19736v1 | MM-Instruct: Generated Visual Instructions for Large Multimodal Model Alignment | 2024-06-28T08:25:27 | 2024-06-28T08:25:27 | Jihao Liu, Xin Huang, Jinliang Zheng, Boxiao Liu, Jia Wang, Osamu Yoshie, Yu Liu, Hongsheng Li | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper introduces MM-Instruct, a large-scale dataset of diverse and
high-quality visual instruction data designed to enhance the
instruction-following capabilities of large multimodal models (LMMs). While
existing visual instruction datasets often focus on question-answering, they
struggle to generalize to broader application scenarios such as creative
writing, summarization, or image analysis. To address these limitations, we
propose a novel approach to constructing MM-Instruct that leverages the strong
instruction-following capabilities of existing LLMs to generate novel visual
instruction data from large-scale but conventional image captioning datasets.
MM-Instruct first leverages ChatGPT to automatically generate diverse
instructions from a small set of seed instructions through augmenting and
summarization. It then matches these instructions with images and uses an
open-sourced large language model (LLM) to generate coherent answers to the
instruction-image pairs. The LLM is grounded by the detailed text descriptions
of images in the whole answer generation process to guarantee the alignment of
the instruction data. Moreover, we introduce a benchmark based on the generated
instruction data to evaluate the instruction-following capabilities of existing
LMMs. We demonstrate the effectiveness of MM-Instruct by training a LLaVA-1.5
model on the generated data, denoted as LLaVA-Instruct, which exhibits
significant improvements in instruction-following capabilities compared to
LLaVA-1.5 models. The MM-Instruct dataset, benchmark, and pre-trained models
are available at https://github.com/jihaonew/MM-Instruct. | [
-0.2671428323,
-0.8213998079,
0.4282616973,
-0.1004944742,
-0.1363350898,
0.1110796556,
-0.0499553718,
-0.004300314,
-0.0151974522,
0.5712806582,
-0.9371930957,
-0.6743268371,
-0.4829587638,
-0.2091493905,
-0.1601987928,
0.8011721373,
-0.1048050374,
0.3508986235,
-0.6370321512,
0.0063376399,
-0.8019018173,
-0.2067301869,
0.0187625904,
0.1588540971,
0.4588332176,
0.8875603676,
0.614348352,
0.7284737825,
0.6097190976,
0.2879203856,
0.4711409807,
0.6509816051,
-0.4451362193,
-0.0233854968,
0.1293404698,
-0.4412307441,
-0.412283361,
0.0436758697,
0.7702348828,
0.5260484219,
-0.2975792289,
0.4944407642,
0.0525196344,
0.5250386596,
-0.5812941194,
0.3320005536,
-0.4787283242,
-0.0963680595,
-0.1064263135,
-0.4140598178,
-0.8937451839,
-0.5974054337,
0.1087177321,
-0.6459413767,
-0.0034049407,
0.1122248694,
0.5449954271,
0.2331412584,
-0.4886455536,
-0.371394217,
-0.4230029285,
0.7744029164,
-0.6120906472,
0.3026117086,
0.1549137235,
0.7429904938,
-0.0557713956,
-0.5214248896,
-0.5243310332,
-0.0982929245,
0.2604643703,
0.3551755846,
0.069928132,
-0.0014509322,
0.170909062,
0.1718803942,
-0.6194552779,
0.3069151342,
-0.3400354981,
0.0780914873,
0.3259903193,
0.3769083023,
0.4703237116,
0.0070591555,
-0.5015861988,
-0.2584831119,
-0.9710434079,
0.019841915,
0.3601742983,
0.1875815094,
-0.3088155687,
0.904936254,
-0.0730150789,
0.7431948185,
0.0572885871,
-0.3829270899,
0.2683703303,
-0.1870014817,
-0.1971310377,
0.0625281036,
0.6216646433,
0.7866360545,
0.3414439261,
0.0163168088,
-0.004750154,
-0.1292397678,
0.0970470384,
-1.0839477777,
-0.0024328982,
-0.0992155075,
-0.3878000677,
-0.2246985584,
0.3044344783,
-0.9127622247,
-0.3657835722,
-0.5799592137,
0.6598501801,
-0.4281724989,
0.1178080663,
0.0544514358,
0.1515677422,
0.5141966343,
0.5360295773,
-0.9891923666,
0.0052899499,
0.4861787558,
0.7001917362,
0.086785078,
-0.3764021099,
-0.7189248204,
0.4771952927,
-0.3257894516,
0.6048133373,
-0.7509422302,
-0.1907348782,
0.0736643001,
0.1470803916,
-0.1493184865,
-0.3967885375,
0.0031854571,
-0.3022377789,
0.645144403,
-0.0232728217,
-0.8267745972,
-0.3105788827,
0.2862627208,
-0.2935938239,
0.5511754751,
-0.0087893652,
-0.7678213716,
0.0504437536,
-0.5751467943,
-0.2011140287,
-0.1733471602,
-0.3045093119,
-0.4082511961,
-0.0604106933,
0.7285518646,
0.7256846428,
-0.269582808,
-0.135773614,
-0.3710919619,
-0.396761328,
0.3149865866,
-0.723805964,
0.6889680028,
-0.2286031842,
-0.1349883378,
0.2738753557,
-0.7801409364,
-0.059377715,
0.0850620493,
-0.0759623349,
-0.0734441951,
-0.0804684609,
-0.4940703213,
-0.0479706749,
0.2226976305,
-0.5468518138,
0.5964660645,
-0.1006590128,
0.2374770492,
1.0000027418,
0.0871083587,
0.5734764934,
-0.2057755888,
0.7930557728,
-0.0066551538,
0.4041596651,
-0.8831703663,
-0.5108921528,
-0.7287605405,
-0.3845146298,
0.161007151,
0.8282793164,
-1.1343508959,
-0.1837492138,
-0.4810578823,
-0.41175282,
-0.8724954724,
0.2455957681,
0.6170517802,
0.7278606296,
0.3782919943,
-0.0126515524,
-0.4106981456,
-0.9402962923,
0.6101314425,
0.2108624727,
0.1159180403,
0.1572422385,
0.4966632426,
-0.2835099697,
0.3997609317,
-0.6960920095,
-0.0252180938,
0.1275752783,
0.1178794801,
0.1290731877,
0.4633885026,
0.4240192175,
-0.4770404696,
-0.5054058433,
0.0808679312,
-0.8866130114,
-0.0384092666,
-0.1644707471,
-0.4582081735,
-0.0766841918,
0.6359402537,
-0.5344708562,
0.1231508628,
0.6536448598,
-0.0270281062,
0.7498805523,
-0.2049161494,
0.4334817231,
-1.4327937365,
-0.3233365417,
-0.2920626998,
0.0266787149,
-0.337318778,
0.2172524482,
0.2447404116,
-0.1427085251,
-0.4575846195,
0.1420602351,
-0.6466886997,
-0.0069504031,
0.0672340617,
-0.1866925508,
0.0004779844,
0.619481504,
-0.3961480856,
0.9898571968,
0.6013047099,
-0.2414677292,
0.3476336896,
0.4550257027,
-0.5466005206,
0.7142072916,
-0.3585557342,
0.1835426092,
-0.3439651132,
-0.0046021682,
-1.1438658237,
-0.5172822475,
0.2062778324,
-0.348965168,
0.5327711105,
-0.5791698694,
-0.6754083633,
-0.2316048294,
-0.2205438167,
0.1050183102,
0.4973537624,
-0.720708251,
0.5786421895,
0.0455956869,
-0.2086199224,
-0.8027685285,
-0.804997921,
-0.08049611,
-0.212533623,
-0.5965218544,
0.0600369759,
-0.3548679948,
0.0833575055,
-0.1528197974,
0.1725180596,
-0.0968931764,
-0.2573356926,
0.5317073464,
0.6827884912,
-0.4211603105,
0.0842857808,
0.3992864788,
0.0092334915,
0.0043641576,
-0.1536703706,
0.4269559979,
0.0404038429,
-0.8349183202,
-0.6509564519,
0.4224598706,
0.8080562353,
-0.5741881132,
0.5947469473,
0.5497868061,
0.0954978913,
-0.1544654071,
-0.3836612105,
-0.0485037901,
-0.4758480787,
0.3348985612,
-0.11911989,
-0.7080195546,
0.142319575,
0.0277083796,
0.4430581927,
-0.0677990466,
0.5430776477,
-0.6066774726,
1.2010859251,
0.4742016494,
0.2134020925,
0.6462709308,
-0.2801951468,
-0.3285756707,
-0.5711020231,
-0.3213845491,
0.0625233427,
-0.1560530365,
-0.4105813205,
-0.8067356348,
0.4044653773,
-0.1898842454,
-0.2767123282,
0.0539155342,
-0.5381452441,
0.6366801262,
0.5674315691,
0.4200286865,
-0.0127374129,
0.1909390092,
-0.1167751104,
-0.1453806907,
-0.7287726998,
-0.5000231862,
1.1667999029,
0.2467477918,
1.0343093872,
0.1917255521,
0.730158329,
0.0638416559,
0.4395073056,
-0.6768723726,
0.623467505,
-0.2407743484,
-0.1836664826,
-0.012486863,
-0.3807349503,
-0.8134483099,
0.1478542387,
-0.4556607306,
-0.3685290515,
-0.332829088,
0.2600966096,
-0.2227768153,
0.2520246804,
-1.320337534,
0.9167709351,
-0.4553273916,
-0.2763021588,
-0.0566843264,
-0.6500902176,
0.6228129864,
0.2955804467,
0.1084104106,
0.048780676,
0.050146874,
0.3836557865,
-0.1876234859,
1.0865470171,
-0.2902756035,
-0.1948004812,
0.4169445336,
0.0703992173,
0.4211500585,
-0.3282261491,
0.278060317,
-0.381808728,
-0.1241374686,
-0.1810699403,
-0.9345878959,
0.527746737,
-0.4688862562,
-0.5637494922,
0.1717168242,
-0.8815934658,
-0.1210743636,
0.1345497966,
0.0513878204,
0.8790749311,
-0.0773554817,
0.4355250001,
0.9374893308,
-0.5102609992,
0.3070164323,
0.3036013544,
-0.2616914809,
-0.8417603374,
1.005100131,
0.1580404043,
0.554351449,
0.8091115952,
0.0645439774,
-0.0514507145,
-0.3854456246,
-0.9136459231,
-0.0087065874,
-0.8387845755,
-0.3543714285,
-0.2733635604,
-0.0283229854,
-0.1066632643,
-0.2566272914,
-0.2604313493,
-0.2463700324,
-0.2017149776,
0.0483221076,
0.2283979207,
0.5262237191,
0.4076830149,
0.644485414,
-0.833089292,
0.2601823807,
0.5883976817,
0.178595677,
0.038380105,
-0.4866172075,
-0.3523989022,
0.2721515596,
-0.4050385952,
-0.8907277584,
0.1373703331,
0.1452914029,
0.5674282312,
0.5860614181,
-0.2623749077,
1.0238616467,
-0.9208721519,
0.5283632874,
0.459115237,
-0.6281343699,
0.5595065951,
-0.3449614346,
0.747297585,
0.1943850219,
0.278586179,
-0.1186317354,
-0.4000372291,
-0.3012321591,
-0.5911356807,
0.3672145009,
0.0701669231,
0.200931564,
0.18762137,
0.1156696007,
0.4807429612,
0.1510899067,
-0.4590152502,
0.0307709314,
-0.197703436,
-0.6934304237,
-0.0347838812,
-0.2797097266,
-0.0891869664,
-0.1878627092,
0.3871578574,
-0.3564466238,
0.3637915552,
-0.2278344333,
-0.3473566473,
0.1930269003,
0.1243796572,
0.8271152377,
0.6855016351,
-0.1122217104,
0.1372247189,
0.0770397857,
-0.3446271122,
0.1176749766,
0.0569030344,
-0.1727098376,
-0.1536987424,
0.5253302455,
0.6477996111,
0.3627772033,
-0.7665763497,
0.5668110847,
0.0196682587,
-0.1731458455,
-0.218920216,
0.1025709361,
0.2703480124,
0.4229560792,
0.0892588198,
-0.1252052933,
-0.1027487293,
-0.3875908554,
0.2013386339,
0.5565268993,
-0.1619150043,
-0.2961723208,
0.6586678624,
0.1216543913,
0.0609556772,
0.7137874365,
0.040200036,
-0.1331676245,
0.6024599671,
0.4079538882,
0.5009202361,
-0.1716915667,
0.3025138974,
0.4041126966,
0.3827002645,
0.1942378581,
0.4513279498,
-0.0402153246,
-0.3895338476,
-0.7168840766,
-0.1901356429,
-0.5672323108,
-0.216270119,
-0.6417977214,
0.2590096295,
-0.503524065,
0.1133133769,
0.0802274868,
-0.5068886876,
-0.5394654274,
0.0248343945,
0.3250761032,
0.5593364239,
-0.6283663511,
0.7950094938,
0.5479069352,
-0.6616594791,
-0.5580484271,
-0.1911648065,
0.227509737,
-0.954467237,
0.5108346343,
0.5735903978,
-0.0630533248,
-0.0444458723,
-1.1721707582,
-0.5909307599,
1.3920713663,
0.671223104,
-0.5570883751,
0.0819558352,
0.0566009469,
0.1595448256,
-0.6875510216,
0.1676156819,
-0.0988837332,
0.1759040803,
0.3187635243,
-0.5980277061,
-0.1919386536,
-0.1539345533,
-0.220290184,
0.2450172007,
-0.5018306375,
0.5639857054,
-0.6508741975,
-0.1318802088,
0.2744474113,
0.7628886104,
0.2498017251,
0.1954708099,
0.3007021844,
0.5365575552,
0.5640442967,
0.1212493256,
0.8540112376,
-0.0249210373,
-0.1231267899,
1.5925155878,
0.1778496951,
0.9954162836,
0.5759974122,
0.1447678506,
0.5828288198,
0.4285492599,
-0.3430326283,
0.5098057389,
-0.090085566,
0.1133833155,
-0.0250117909,
-0.0658904314,
-0.2364955842,
0.5961110592,
0.2918132842,
-0.5051882267,
-0.1530584097,
0.0858265013,
-0.0768638998,
-0.0165869016,
-0.3582831323,
0.7096686363,
-0.2776116729,
-0.5183531046,
0.509174943,
-0.4960156679,
0.4185684919,
-0.6849130988,
-0.5689086914,
-0.1654770523,
0.0855217874,
-0.1538872272,
-1.0832414627,
-0.1117814407,
0.0010823753,
-0.3256287873,
-0.3289811611,
0.2075189054,
-0.6987769008,
-0.615703702,
-0.2982291877,
0.4625565112,
0.0368022323,
0.3767395914,
-0.4782519639,
-0.2904880047,
0.1952567697,
0.0093589779,
0.2015983611,
0.5764245987,
-0.1057441011,
0.938170433,
0.649525404,
-0.3595212102,
0.3773863614,
0.2705649436,
0.6662684679,
-0.2504962683,
-0.1890507042,
-0.7691599727,
0.8706816435,
0.0067770053,
-0.1460205913,
0.8691464663,
0.4801685214,
0.790854454,
-0.4866129458,
0.4736207724,
0.0539459363,
0.1723268777,
-0.8780781627,
0.4749285877,
-0.5225141644,
0.0877409205,
-0.3061054945,
-0.9156247973,
-0.1964879036,
0.1785636544,
-0.1645468622,
-0.2103088051,
0.3454704881,
1.2084646225,
-0.4094624817,
-0.1607212126,
0.2356142402,
-0.0322288722,
0.1806325912,
0.5312684774,
1.0651625395,
-0.2057050169,
0.7797418833,
-0.3457853198,
-0.3136251867,
0.050942637,
-0.7222931385,
-1.0448248386,
-0.5427695513,
-0.3415424228,
-0.0588018857,
-0.1188492551,
0.9251383543,
0.6702737212,
-0.6180105805,
-0.1860326827,
0.1745319217,
-0.0632645339,
-0.3406480253,
-0.2005037963,
0.4289912879,
-0.1912176609,
-0.7850618362,
0.3895299435,
0.3182956576,
0.4755999446,
-0.2183848917,
-0.114203386,
-0.3482936919,
-0.054429058,
0.796520412,
-0.0435235538,
-0.5994151235,
-0.116510883,
0.1832590103,
-0.1008981317,
0.1613342017,
0.4505211413,
-0.1478228569,
0.914768517,
0.3191640377,
0.8443370461,
0.2826226354,
-0.020076111,
0.5705390573,
-0.8489180207,
0.0829260647,
-0.0504948273,
0.4135262668,
0.440903753,
-0.1187264174,
0.424656719,
-0.1689697206,
-0.4001224041,
-0.640360713,
0.2516450286,
-1.0369651318,
-0.157637611,
0.9713656306,
-0.0868092477,
-0.2710558772,
0.5144274235,
-0.6536770463,
0.1614152789,
-0.2190692127,
0.6235128045,
0.5604882836,
0.0145166311,
-0.672436595,
-0.9032622576,
-0.2229023427,
0.1374048144,
-0.8851464391,
0.0765204504,
0.7716696262,
0.1088479757,
-0.0470195785,
-0.0109153269,
-0.1643444002,
0.3891056776,
0.2363832742,
0.3184692264,
-0.4744955599,
-0.268550992,
0.040886011,
0.202286005,
-0.2484407574,
-0.799236238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19731v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19731v1 | Message du troisi{è}me type : irruption d'un tiers dans un dialogue en ligne | 2024-06-28T08:20:32 | 2024-06-28T08:20:32 | Ludovic Tanguy, Céline Poudat, Lydia-Mai Ho-Dac | cs.CL | cs.CL | Our study focuses on Wikipedia talk pages, from a global perspective
analyzing contributors' behaviors in online interactions. Using a corpus
comprising all Wikipedia talk pages in French, totaling more than 300,000
discussion threads, we examine how discussions with more than two participants
(multiparty conversation) unfold and we specifically investigate the role of a
third participant's intervention when two Wikipedians have already initiated an
exchange. In this regard, we concentrate on the sequential structure of these
interactions in terms of articulation among different participants and aim to
specify this third message by exploring its lexical particularities, while also
proposing an initial typology of the third participant's message role and how
it aligns with preceding messages. | [
-0.7813003063,
-0.8161631823,
0.5327888131,
0.4973872304,
-0.046809379,
-0.0208244994,
-0.0471752286,
-0.7669833899,
0.803897202,
0.339224577,
-0.4888570309,
-0.0538086258,
-0.5497005582,
0.2724878788,
-0.7577619553,
1.2908415794,
-0.0956271887,
0.1533869505,
-0.1202883497,
-0.0673680753,
-0.1936578304,
-0.4278972447,
-0.9886232615,
-0.1315806061,
1.1307166815,
0.8095538616,
0.5322458148,
-0.0708165616,
0.3842813075,
0.481569469,
0.1804554313,
-0.0156426411,
-0.9222818613,
0.2930346727,
-0.3582299948,
-0.4748488665,
-0.3815118372,
0.1363120526,
0.6208859682,
0.7106203437,
0.0054119579,
0.1346714944,
0.2181050032,
0.7311880589,
-0.6231825948,
0.1157485917,
-0.3396994472,
-0.2046750337,
-0.2593469918,
-0.2131851912,
-0.3972491324,
-0.242031008,
0.3007361889,
-0.3090709746,
0.014829102,
-0.1623690724,
0.530877769,
-0.2334734201,
-0.4055701792,
-0.3108079135,
-0.7447625995,
0.310431689,
-0.2503215075,
0.1199393496,
0.2876774371,
-0.1104523242,
-0.3114706278,
-0.7605070472,
-1.0480612516,
0.1214025468,
-0.2717667222,
0.2079849988,
-0.2988206744,
-0.0253742654,
0.0161725935,
0.3871758878,
-0.0465172343,
0.009390506,
-0.8200055361,
-0.0914515704,
0.4234077334,
0.1306364685,
0.5751610994,
-0.3022800684,
-0.2186088562,
0.1595894247,
-0.3700990081,
-0.1329887211,
0.8961244226,
-0.1632271111,
-0.4747562706,
0.7993525863,
-0.0394406728,
0.5886630416,
0.1479115039,
0.2363626659,
0.1507058144,
-0.4241961539,
0.2532038391,
-0.0996650159,
0.8881754875,
0.7831730843,
0.6134652495,
-0.0664711595,
0.3523196876,
-0.4346076846,
0.3570887446,
-0.763756752,
-0.324375391,
0.2623561025,
-0.4455547333,
-0.3449715078,
0.6106721759,
-0.8960767984,
-0.3749236763,
0.0333312154,
0.1797545999,
-0.1540304273,
-0.5675962567,
-0.2349930257,
-0.2505696416,
0.0587396845,
0.2666472495,
-1.0408813953,
0.234010458,
0.6254037023,
0.7713153362,
-0.1770381629,
-0.7900458574,
-0.2913568318,
0.4945392907,
-0.3485224843,
0.8932508826,
-0.3065572083,
-0.8201932907,
0.0743598267,
0.1111524776,
-0.1118245423,
0.2633419037,
0.5967283249,
-0.5568954945,
0.5799967051,
-0.2833639383,
-0.4464956522,
-0.2610110641,
0.3108887672,
-0.8497166634,
0.4862370193,
-0.0475658514,
-1.301171422,
-0.0540141426,
-0.7048567533,
-0.1445555538,
0.1044842005,
-0.4178570509,
0.0717778429,
0.1980009079,
-0.3232080936,
0.3105821013,
-0.1282614917,
-0.220757395,
-0.3040969074,
-0.1527297348,
0.6600937843,
-0.3787102699,
0.5572739244,
-0.1387812197,
-0.2599831223,
-0.0918856561,
-0.4824847281,
-0.0338913575,
-0.0580430329,
-0.2918042541,
-0.4829484522,
-0.0253185853,
-0.0271734986,
0.2291392088,
0.220983848,
-0.542375803,
0.2827615142,
-0.8379695415,
0.3163554072,
0.7292827368,
0.6096807122,
0.4306497574,
-0.2710011601,
-0.2054158449,
0.1044423059,
0.4463198483,
0.0085353144,
-0.8246530294,
-1.3220015764,
0.2319797575,
0.0768551826,
0.6103506684,
-0.5448749065,
0.0373519845,
-0.6353675127,
-0.1355389655,
-0.2800202966,
0.055993516,
0.4088174403,
-0.0320096202,
0.1033693552,
-0.1788538694,
-0.333548069,
-1.3740223646,
-0.2718292773,
-0.6776170731,
0.1137483567,
0.3385007977,
0.5927138925,
-0.2316570431,
0.7503359318,
-0.3100637496,
0.1094562635,
-0.3310965896,
0.5742713213,
-0.0891808122,
0.398729682,
0.5478080511,
-0.999242723,
-1.0429800749,
-0.1154054627,
-0.4659832716,
0.0960027725,
0.0268115997,
-0.5431416631,
0.1595112979,
0.6543949246,
-0.5182616711,
0.3287348151,
0.4165805578,
-0.2927869856,
-0.1031321585,
-0.0859339535,
0.4910904169,
-1.3648326397,
-0.3789897561,
-0.3322351277,
0.166197747,
-0.9189445972,
-0.3705128133,
-0.31818524,
0.2136590332,
-0.5994746685,
0.4039970338,
-0.4236610532,
0.114899762,
-0.3013134003,
0.4514746964,
-0.0427255556,
0.4710336626,
-0.124820441,
0.4982839823,
0.4108370245,
-0.4679184556,
0.4598773718,
0.5738074183,
-0.0606725663,
0.9245007038,
-0.3701730669,
0.4858102202,
-0.3090665936,
0.2155893594,
-1.1410859823,
-0.5500371456,
0.7026961446,
-0.705278337,
0.2001513839,
-0.0358230472,
-0.5217296481,
-0.5029594898,
-0.5643802285,
0.4537520409,
-0.4138005674,
-0.2078721523,
0.3856656253,
0.5910705328,
-0.4483243823,
-0.4102232754,
-0.700725019,
0.3146708608,
-0.0915952399,
-0.9821687341,
0.2170267552,
-0.2668532133,
-0.6022794843,
0.0463233292,
0.076497525,
-0.1760255694,
-0.0083374958,
0.254091531,
0.0578141063,
0.2142536193,
0.0693444386,
-0.2359450758,
-0.0844189599,
0.2116381824,
-0.183064729,
0.5793567896,
-0.0916346014,
-0.3821850419,
-0.5553096533,
0.9776623845,
0.5652329326,
0.2002035677,
1.3259869814,
0.6781321168,
-0.1306239069,
0.1675863266,
-0.8008003831,
0.0207673591,
-0.464949578,
0.0709991008,
-0.3395085037,
-0.7065310478,
0.3858748972,
0.405433923,
0.0049155289,
0.5921515226,
0.6785818338,
-0.4134115577,
0.9058942795,
0.8202576041,
-0.1499086767,
0.3623755276,
-0.3378764391,
0.5531257987,
-0.4736310542,
-0.6503287554,
-0.4938780665,
-0.3807647526,
-0.8805767894,
-0.3151842058,
0.3938914537,
0.201903671,
-0.0219118819,
0.1569513232,
-0.1166742891,
0.3737750649,
0.4339820743,
-0.0651805252,
0.0918933004,
0.0694799125,
0.0775526017,
-0.098516576,
-0.4108434916,
-0.2782863975,
0.6295613647,
0.0960363671,
0.5060114861,
0.5676134825,
0.6808900833,
0.269706279,
0.3798172772,
-0.5769966841,
0.553422749,
0.3724053204,
-0.6378393173,
-0.2945055068,
-0.1616542041,
-0.8365388513,
0.0937406719,
-0.2662568092,
-1.1558303833,
0.3764301836,
-0.2013081908,
-0.0852980018,
0.3150646389,
-0.7025453448,
0.8230844736,
-0.0931646228,
-0.2667747736,
-0.5837241411,
-0.6801733971,
0.4149558246,
-0.1009397581,
0.5497580767,
-0.2020481229,
-0.1931326091,
0.7530020475,
-0.2668372095,
0.8816193342,
0.2134883851,
-0.2420349419,
0.4386852086,
-0.0812988952,
0.5292956829,
0.3136175573,
0.4535452127,
0.0905809626,
-0.0802813992,
-0.3123242855,
-0.2884539068,
1.0336531401,
-1.0614998341,
-0.7985687256,
-0.1509868056,
-0.1040298417,
-0.311681509,
0.1427597255,
0.7380684614,
0.4277634621,
-0.3537868559,
0.254768312,
0.4107315242,
-0.100463666,
0.6210577488,
0.6753171682,
-0.1924499869,
-0.5406606197,
0.9531245232,
-0.2665514648,
0.3273926079,
0.4876015186,
-0.079883568,
0.0012264097,
-0.2409895211,
-0.1437130123,
0.3410726786,
-0.9112359285,
-0.0236928053,
-1.2079555988,
-0.1739277095,
-0.2244837433,
-0.0293965023,
-0.2869799733,
-0.5136765838,
-0.2534352243,
-0.2071382403,
0.3276293278,
1.0258967876,
-0.3284466863,
0.4713843465,
-0.9440683126,
0.381744653,
0.5379803181,
0.3966864347,
0.0434238203,
-0.1746017486,
-0.4585458338,
0.0022453119,
-0.2154571414,
-1.2691556215,
-0.2070030421,
0.1733365208,
0.7442506552,
0.3822034001,
-0.1883890182,
0.4097377062,
-0.4948857427,
0.9307562709,
0.4831276536,
-0.8425607085,
0.5467304587,
-0.3219107091,
-0.2018538266,
0.4068588018,
0.6010113358,
-0.9136755466,
-0.800278008,
-0.7774379253,
-0.8997003436,
0.7447986603,
0.4734270871,
0.5135265589,
-0.4170867503,
0.1442933232,
-0.1893015355,
0.1482841223,
-0.895657599,
-0.7909972668,
0.000830037,
0.1559645683,
0.2339357883,
-0.8668926358,
-0.5293344259,
-0.0179083515,
0.6125863791,
0.1973975748,
0.2848648429,
0.1441795528,
-0.0440806672,
-0.204504922,
0.3368727267,
0.6075845361,
0.6693541408,
0.3053699732,
0.0571939945,
-0.0051396699,
-0.5661903024,
-0.0771567747,
0.0077084424,
-0.0313481092,
0.0428550765,
0.4979755878,
0.8322096467,
0.4865630865,
0.0839641765,
0.7833718061,
-0.3979878128,
-0.1868516803,
-0.3676892221,
0.0023316878,
0.180877611,
0.4826318324,
0.2227727175,
-0.0713427812,
0.2544055581,
-0.6940094233,
0.2010583431,
0.2897051573,
-0.1422169507,
-0.4266468883,
0.5003487468,
0.6291283369,
-0.235462144,
0.4304550886,
-0.0739139616,
-0.565815866,
0.1115663946,
-0.036570482,
0.9491757751,
-0.1142864823,
0.6005593538,
0.5320642591,
0.1224896386,
0.0514237322,
0.3299439847,
-0.0207787585,
-0.8865754008,
-0.3826422989,
-0.3849330246,
-0.3063908517,
0.0733069554,
-0.6239881516,
0.2179377675,
0.0473910794,
-0.2349918485,
0.3730479479,
-0.1358812451,
-0.4804529846,
-0.3224524856,
0.3094903529,
0.6512609124,
-0.5755963922,
0.6401643157,
0.3761588633,
-0.7309634686,
-0.3353641331,
0.4815161526,
-0.0818668604,
-0.4034748077,
0.6355410218,
0.0874552727,
-0.2566224933,
0.1487516761,
-0.709477067,
-0.8721994162,
0.4929672778,
0.0296656284,
-0.2506786585,
0.038526874,
0.1952812672,
0.545067668,
-0.2669322789,
0.1483281851,
0.3843170702,
0.531883955,
-0.0346776359,
-0.985218823,
-0.4526606798,
-0.4523565471,
-0.0459772572,
0.303738445,
-0.9651265144,
0.8516847491,
-0.069491446,
-0.5004118085,
0.1690375507,
0.8186516166,
-0.4170015752,
-0.3241068721,
0.6488461494,
0.0285374559,
0.46398139,
0.0211026128,
0.9772074223,
-0.7112775445,
0.1592039168,
0.8085032701,
0.0916470215,
0.6456750035,
0.6505312324,
-0.0911034718,
0.9357768297,
0.3526880145,
0.1726397127,
0.459618032,
0.2859726548,
-0.6858022809,
-0.0219428949,
-0.066705808,
-0.3677094281,
0.4222177267,
0.615296483,
0.0391603634,
-0.1375325769,
0.2236656994,
0.0891611204,
-0.0059075202,
-0.3710254729,
0.9867800474,
-0.0557371862,
-0.829539299,
0.2182348967,
0.031168757,
0.1684392542,
-0.0457894467,
-0.0459093302,
-0.2501466274,
0.1121892333,
-0.4081420004,
-1.0642545223,
0.2289241105,
-0.0341359749,
-0.3847430944,
-0.1697171628,
0.391730845,
-0.5640090108,
-0.3379504085,
0.4224782586,
0.8025297523,
0.3665188849,
0.2638917863,
-0.6551594734,
0.2209044844,
0.071718812,
-0.1736177057,
0.0997966304,
0.7017585039,
-0.0595140867,
0.3874245286,
0.3040419221,
-0.0470600314,
0.0676599368,
0.3044875264,
0.9081994891,
-0.4682920873,
-0.6099267006,
-0.8636756539,
0.5487046838,
-0.4797334969,
-0.0384786315,
0.9542664289,
0.5294614434,
0.9195203781,
0.2121018171,
0.7506054044,
-0.2409794778,
0.7095559835,
-0.3054548204,
0.3736775219,
-0.3351261914,
0.1846132427,
-0.2723849118,
-0.815126121,
0.2904855907,
0.4351041317,
0.0203503147,
-0.1892772019,
0.8034413457,
0.3965136409,
0.1516842544,
0.5232409239,
-0.0700144246,
0.4627111256,
0.1078423485,
0.1801746488,
1.301312685,
-0.1233687177,
0.7642078996,
-0.316211611,
0.0141479773,
-0.1344231218,
-0.6379202008,
-1.0025691986,
-0.8818876743,
-0.1396346241,
-0.5702303648,
-0.0822766051,
0.6612411737,
0.0606024526,
-0.8146430254,
-0.2494030595,
-0.1352138817,
0.2647091448,
0.3694658577,
-0.2291643023,
0.1046411619,
-0.2008858919,
-1.1420853138,
0.1937561035,
0.433100462,
0.1418676823,
-0.6132075787,
0.1243185699,
-0.2091034055,
0.0120459115,
0.5119543076,
0.214615494,
-0.5738639832,
-0.5020327568,
-0.2713134587,
-0.2219160199,
-0.0742500499,
1.1639552116,
-0.14550744,
0.3838692307,
0.5642756224,
0.1615663767,
0.6558215618,
-0.1795872152,
0.8166740537,
-0.7419862747,
0.4288506508,
-0.0388217382,
0.260281682,
0.4606738687,
-0.2677402496,
0.3980660439,
0.4187991321,
-0.3960171342,
-0.6716476083,
0.239091903,
-0.3463967741,
-0.2594280243,
1.2018966675,
0.0700681359,
0.057055749,
-0.2345838845,
-0.2597237825,
0.1838392019,
-0.3724215329,
0.439208895,
1.2992229462,
-0.2150756568,
-0.1144425347,
-0.9009944797,
0.5992009044,
-0.3502669036,
-0.6979131103,
-0.1887081265,
0.6652895212,
0.0321123861,
0.5487276912,
1.0608351231,
0.2115626186,
0.0266489275,
-0.0145004885,
-0.2654716372,
0.6589858532,
-0.573661387,
0.2701654732,
0.1207526401,
-0.257353425,
-0.1562961191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19729v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19729v1 | Le sens de la famille : analyse du vocabulaire de la parent{é} par les plongements de mots | 2024-06-28T08:19:36 | 2024-06-28T08:19:36 | Ludovic Tanguy, Cécile Fabre, Nabil Hathout, Lydia-Mai Ho-Dac | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this study, we propose a corpus analysis of an area of the French lexicon
that is both dense and highly structured: the vocabulary of family
relationships. Starting with a lexicon of 25 nouns designating the main
relationships (son, cousin, mother, grandfather, sister-in-law etc.), we
examine how these terms are positioned in relation to each other through
distributional analyses based on the use of these terms in corpora. We show
that distributional information can capture certain features that organize this
vocabulary (descent, alliance, siblings, genre), in ways that vary according to
the different corpora compared. | [
-0.5783603191,
-0.6263800859,
0.2190634012,
0.4117914438,
-0.015486774,
-0.0372683369,
0.11031349,
-0.0730391666,
0.4232236147,
0.3992402554,
-0.3948345184,
-0.1506674439,
-0.7817195654,
0.2016411573,
-0.3038857281,
0.6713960171,
-0.1327625066,
-0.111735411,
-0.0462958291,
-0.5582596064,
0.0689576343,
-1.1747238636,
-0.8120852113,
0.0824501365,
0.7515525818,
0.0765227452,
0.8252822757,
0.6825427413,
0.4199950099,
0.2906698585,
-0.3926910162,
-0.0281745736,
-0.628564775,
0.3676021099,
-0.1745839417,
-0.2376230061,
-0.2970591187,
-0.2929044664,
0.463376224,
1.261158824,
0.4027392864,
-0.0081390357,
0.0996050537,
1.1867194176,
-0.6468626857,
0.2366424948,
-0.2013340145,
-0.0692133605,
0.0460947528,
-0.7211904526,
-0.0373812094,
-0.0466352962,
0.32946527,
-0.1905864328,
0.7621783614,
-0.0839873105,
1.1174840927,
-0.143322736,
-0.5287390947,
-0.483454138,
-0.545961082,
0.4306104183,
0.2394725084,
0.6452727318,
0.4401353598,
-0.3430680931,
-0.319865495,
-0.1916702241,
-0.2067582011,
-0.1784486175,
-0.2595154345,
-0.0052014985,
-0.4102927744,
-0.1622922719,
0.2201394886,
0.6483366489,
-0.4238444865,
-0.4385345876,
-0.291298151,
-0.0397093333,
0.452747941,
0.002483218,
0.6944257617,
-0.0425101705,
-0.5856806636,
-0.0102763204,
-0.5553210974,
-0.1872276068,
0.6671897173,
0.0681762099,
-0.4343008697,
0.7526494861,
0.0265009291,
0.5002949834,
-0.1068172604,
-0.0771194547,
0.300016731,
-0.4087147117,
0.1180052459,
-0.1762986779,
0.7516919971,
0.5147351623,
0.715895474,
-0.1010353789,
-0.2824912965,
0.1741280556,
-0.134513706,
-0.5516187549,
-0.1946096569,
-0.0042206463,
-0.3603755832,
-0.1744102985,
0.1707343161,
-0.7275390625,
-0.3437120914,
-0.1912010014,
0.0815343931,
-0.5104282498,
-0.3443858922,
-0.1142897233,
-0.451700598,
0.1757937819,
-0.0704091713,
-1.0600025654,
0.3390774131,
0.5664832592,
1.0232102871,
-0.1856052279,
-0.2002046406,
-0.3389967084,
0.4018685818,
-0.0414070748,
0.7410323024,
-0.4879483283,
-0.9417298436,
0.3824688792,
0.0701344535,
-0.351768434,
-0.4284534454,
0.4089426398,
-0.3278391063,
-0.1162506193,
0.0417009257,
-0.60398525,
0.0112453178,
-0.0258113984,
-1.0617721081,
0.7052438855,
0.6016209722,
-0.9331675768,
0.2698434889,
-0.2725507021,
-0.2893211842,
0.0339958705,
-0.3945324123,
0.1046881676,
0.1291154623,
-0.044036679,
0.7198680639,
0.0274963733,
-0.1763765514,
-0.0633070916,
0.1219215393,
0.1071693823,
0.0893733203,
0.8200013638,
0.4099242985,
0.0206089895,
-0.1211769655,
-0.5685981512,
-0.7938325405,
0.1416313797,
0.0141046317,
-0.7825680971,
0.0630419776,
0.1463719457,
0.0046421154,
0.1496022344,
-0.421077311,
0.2062032968,
-0.564381361,
0.5995814204,
0.1656920016,
0.4434173405,
0.8141211867,
-0.2749650776,
0.6037127972,
0.1838565022,
0.2099874318,
0.1347063631,
-0.4918836653,
-0.5543593764,
-0.2481985539,
0.4694897532,
0.6360078454,
-0.5117591619,
0.7215717435,
-0.5673897266,
0.1094668135,
0.1484633833,
0.3928384483,
0.0461784564,
-0.0001745216,
0.0055675544,
-0.4777700901,
-0.1929162592,
-1.0524414778,
0.3902113438,
-0.0603180043,
0.201083824,
0.1716346741,
0.762824893,
-0.0030639337,
0.6525129676,
-0.6474701762,
-0.3707152009,
-0.4605949521,
-0.0825101137,
-0.1683631837,
0.2070973665,
0.9666035771,
-1.0909628868,
-0.2991194725,
0.2136008292,
-0.2734014094,
0.1738411784,
0.3026776612,
-0.567532599,
-0.0221718214,
0.4790284336,
-0.1411537826,
0.5599303842,
0.6195962429,
-0.7699004412,
0.1654424667,
-0.0214293227,
-0.3690930307,
-1.219756484,
-0.2455884516,
0.2153715938,
-0.0749704763,
-0.5090354085,
0.2259906828,
-0.2440985888,
0.2227497697,
-0.4690808058,
0.8777701855,
-0.3919727206,
0.1527891159,
-0.0080128424,
0.4923126996,
-0.0769835487,
0.3814923763,
0.1780786365,
0.6189799905,
0.3253929019,
-0.58706671,
0.3849124014,
0.43393749,
0.2284990251,
0.8238202929,
-0.3251749575,
-0.4092449546,
-0.2760643661,
0.0427679569,
-1.0123800039,
-0.3006920516,
0.1071620584,
-0.6602461934,
0.101600036,
-0.0793315694,
-0.6774079204,
-0.0093727894,
-0.2865926027,
0.4919200838,
-0.023713354,
-0.1848123968,
0.5303343534,
0.6617334485,
-0.0451362841,
-0.5128896832,
-0.3334375918,
-0.2975415289,
-0.2870565951,
-1.1372199059,
0.1474342048,
0.0940241218,
-0.8100152016,
0.2373770177,
-0.1425268203,
-0.6874998212,
0.1619230658,
0.197714895,
0.2924357057,
-0.2341108918,
0.4771140218,
-0.1001333073,
0.2146102637,
-0.2255178988,
0.2350173593,
0.6648613214,
-0.0480683409,
0.7602530718,
0.0429973267,
0.6393677592,
0.4723455906,
-0.0223681349,
1.0576989651,
0.045369979,
-0.3383025229,
-0.4529466033,
-0.4681043327,
0.0292437896,
-0.3285180926,
-0.1666923612,
-0.7698699832,
-0.8507298827,
0.7124640346,
0.2252681851,
-0.2293275297,
0.7255727649,
0.4962568879,
-0.1787593514,
0.4271384776,
0.8438832164,
-0.1286063194,
0.2507384121,
-0.6909973621,
0.1151760519,
-0.8277227283,
0.0274477005,
-0.4537544549,
-0.0903583467,
-0.5019004345,
-0.2407985628,
-0.03094423,
0.2164233178,
-0.0701454654,
0.5789091587,
-0.2469299138,
0.2016939372,
0.2268711776,
-0.1237786263,
0.3777954876,
0.0712964907,
-0.2306818962,
0.3893289566,
-0.5095332861,
-0.8173897266,
0.6146923304,
0.4331848323,
0.2437554151,
0.4411308169,
0.7672786713,
-0.1288334131,
0.4567220509,
-1.1609714031,
0.4424255192,
-0.6348657608,
-0.7807048559,
-0.0985863134,
-0.6011544466,
-1.3600023985,
0.1868518591,
-0.0318820477,
-0.7610916495,
0.8665826917,
-0.2153351754,
-0.6300722361,
0.1557474732,
-0.8168622851,
0.8407039046,
0.0167729817,
-0.4000558257,
0.2126271427,
-0.4342152476,
0.3644354343,
-0.0371172428,
0.29670313,
-0.4549937844,
-0.4052417576,
0.7901693583,
-0.5101368427,
0.4694662094,
0.3483831882,
-0.0902437195,
0.2828704119,
0.5003509521,
-0.3313162327,
-0.0187114757,
-0.057519421,
-0.166968435,
0.6556437016,
-0.484418869,
-0.418458581,
0.963717103,
-0.8537806869,
-0.0746595338,
-0.6345722675,
-0.7352958918,
-0.4388697743,
-0.2075184733,
0.3783361912,
0.7634992599,
-0.2668724656,
0.4552045763,
0.3560399115,
-0.1236205101,
0.3484440446,
0.1654213965,
-0.2318360656,
-0.2272516191,
0.7369411588,
0.4403384626,
0.3529640138,
0.68785429,
0.3523515463,
-0.2581421435,
-0.1508746892,
-0.0346140452,
0.6807945967,
-0.4326752424,
0.2568337321,
-0.7183892727,
-0.1926071793,
-0.0822076946,
-0.2912299931,
-0.109289974,
-0.3696793914,
-0.0389288701,
-0.2710526586,
0.1700588316,
0.562568903,
0.2690059841,
0.4053688347,
-0.7753187418,
0.4736386538,
0.1607079208,
0.2438858747,
-0.0620737262,
-0.2486781925,
0.3106833994,
-0.5233981609,
-0.171598345,
-1.0260401964,
0.337385267,
0.1193996146,
0.3250004053,
0.332564503,
-0.0871728659,
0.1820220053,
-0.2003547549,
0.6712194085,
0.2313470244,
-0.6809361577,
0.2084858567,
-0.7278392315,
-0.1801260412,
0.7377403975,
0.5691608787,
-0.365188688,
0.0734157339,
-1.0917613506,
-1.1881579161,
0.1141567454,
0.598405838,
0.4138724506,
-0.2636579871,
0.4309465885,
0.0031081925,
0.2513108253,
-0.4523364305,
-0.6803520322,
0.2480843812,
-0.4253869355,
0.0303626936,
-0.2827762961,
-0.2851403952,
-0.4106156528,
0.3851766586,
0.2575891018,
0.2894290388,
0.5581077337,
0.0229373425,
-0.075621061,
-0.0126685929,
0.5537708998,
0.8566886783,
-0.1768526584,
0.3069930375,
-0.3691496551,
-0.623085618,
0.2478310168,
-0.141335845,
0.0017776535,
0.118609257,
0.5371405482,
0.5411022902,
0.2506302297,
-0.2767882645,
0.9003388286,
0.0963208452,
-0.5292926431,
-0.6986473203,
-0.1943537444,
0.477986455,
-0.1552524418,
0.070176512,
-0.2962250113,
-0.0681343228,
-1.1586241722,
0.5606366992,
0.3047096133,
-0.4685415924,
-0.2378855795,
0.3949804306,
0.4136447608,
-0.1367564946,
0.1583886594,
-0.4333389699,
-0.5383087993,
0.4714422524,
-0.0352754369,
0.8348469138,
-0.2563419342,
0.3396513164,
0.4254906476,
0.0662317052,
-0.0162087753,
0.3291901648,
0.0782310888,
-1.1934132576,
-0.3270388246,
-0.9612313509,
-0.0407069847,
0.2390715331,
-0.3682747781,
0.2127534151,
-0.2761724591,
-0.012473911,
0.3040936887,
-0.2785146534,
-0.7192670107,
0.084477149,
0.1646776795,
0.782158494,
-0.5992993116,
0.7730782032,
0.4636305273,
-0.6704729795,
-0.8634643555,
0.1083622724,
-0.2877889574,
-0.5544555187,
1.2175234556,
-0.1016209796,
-0.4538014829,
0.0733064488,
-0.1634648591,
-0.7772131562,
0.585637033,
-0.0365238003,
-0.5309259892,
0.0136408685,
-0.2288206071,
0.6835978627,
-0.6185355783,
-0.1003932804,
0.7887977362,
0.4002228379,
0.0195194539,
-0.5298454165,
-0.1394604892,
-0.2455810457,
-0.0742053241,
0.6954481006,
-0.6858561039,
0.6793813705,
0.3411429524,
-0.4972179234,
0.1383223832,
0.6013867855,
-0.3521005511,
0.1771654785,
0.8203719854,
0.2907605767,
0.175632149,
-0.1830763817,
1.3756529093,
-0.762342155,
0.3159287274,
0.7345378399,
-0.1755957305,
0.8906194568,
0.6087952256,
-0.3305262923,
0.4583744407,
0.5200291276,
0.1739277095,
-0.1302965581,
0.5363242626,
-0.5196012855,
0.09369459,
-0.2214312106,
0.0232502855,
0.3275804222,
0.7816044688,
-0.5818389058,
-0.112876676,
-0.2104924321,
0.0878486782,
0.2635731697,
-0.4365309179,
0.5403189063,
0.497041285,
-0.355935514,
0.4168958366,
-0.542733252,
0.4319904149,
-0.3385025263,
0.2347601205,
-0.1777873486,
-0.0861639306,
-0.5703017712,
-0.8074394464,
0.1979921162,
-0.3987720013,
-0.0565621182,
0.282456398,
0.3992331922,
-0.3041534126,
-0.4311420619,
0.866715312,
1.0878943205,
-0.0379112586,
0.0124086319,
-0.3832345605,
-0.1298055649,
-0.2773423195,
-0.4035353661,
0.0853325054,
0.5013748407,
-0.1483006775,
0.2932879031,
0.1572892517,
0.2577623129,
0.3336291611,
0.2840000987,
0.4349468052,
-0.668782413,
-0.3583985865,
-0.6603695154,
0.2496713102,
-0.104829438,
-0.6624322534,
0.5980687141,
0.405069977,
0.631929338,
0.0046493709,
0.708853662,
-0.1062125936,
0.3754346967,
-0.0051531764,
0.0723982155,
-0.4577982128,
0.0263184626,
-0.1337725371,
-1.3633522987,
-0.5394787788,
0.5732775331,
-0.5040317774,
-0.3586844504,
1.0630691051,
0.6074628234,
-0.1833166629,
0.0717249066,
0.4309144318,
0.176617682,
-0.2567146719,
0.3194492161,
0.8533504605,
-0.0471065752,
0.3961810768,
-0.7731027603,
-0.2591473162,
-0.2522313893,
-0.417657733,
-0.7857073545,
-1.0338008404,
-0.2158392966,
-0.3639903367,
0.1241418123,
1.0119795799,
0.1866331846,
-0.6466912627,
-0.5478902459,
-0.0540077351,
-0.031661164,
-0.1523238569,
-0.2975488305,
0.5656648278,
-0.1196083352,
-0.9121104479,
0.1598887891,
0.1859146208,
-0.1281437129,
-0.3160349429,
0.2228086889,
-0.316462338,
0.2683072686,
0.8412101269,
-0.021014465,
-0.3276076019,
-0.5021749139,
-0.2554151416,
-0.3366776109,
-0.017979892,
1.1667994261,
-0.1477319449,
0.2174988985,
1.0585104227,
0.1964790523,
-0.0497517772,
0.3700993359,
0.6275557876,
-0.8311036229,
0.2979004085,
0.2581434548,
0.6630041599,
0.2372031063,
-0.4373737574,
1.0523284674,
0.5340137482,
-0.324780494,
-0.3899871111,
0.488643378,
-1.317704916,
-0.4991652668,
1.4992134571,
0.2194126099,
-0.4287443459,
-0.6651847959,
-0.3251543939,
0.1366579533,
-0.5418451428,
-0.0121526383,
1.1171045303,
-0.3612998724,
0.0296832658,
-1.1583265066,
0.5899181962,
0.0792458579,
-0.0141957691,
-0.0648062304,
0.199311167,
0.1395801753,
0.690284133,
0.4758132696,
-0.2967438996,
-0.0180201586,
-0.1220666915,
-0.0147556281,
0.4572077394,
-0.1781910807,
-0.2352187485,
0.7387403846,
-0.0616397001,
-0.0392711386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19712v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19712v1 | Uncertainty Quantification in Large Language Models Through Convex Hull Analysis | 2024-06-28T07:47:34 | 2024-06-28T07:47:34 | Ferhat Ozgur Catak, Murat Kuzlu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Uncertainty quantification approaches have been more critical in large
language models (LLMs), particularly high-risk applications requiring reliable
outputs. However, traditional methods for uncertainty quantification, such as
probabilistic models and ensemble techniques, face challenges when applied to
the complex and high-dimensional nature of LLM-generated outputs. This study
proposes a novel geometric approach to uncertainty quantification using convex
hull analysis. The proposed method leverages the spatial properties of response
embeddings to measure the dispersion and variability of model outputs. The
prompts are categorized into three types, i.e., `easy', `moderate', and
`confusing', to generate multiple responses using different LLMs at varying
temperature settings. The responses are transformed into high-dimensional
embeddings via a BERT model and subsequently projected into a two-dimensional
space using Principal Component Analysis (PCA). The Density-Based Spatial
Clustering of Applications with Noise (DBSCAN) algorithm is utilized to cluster
the embeddings and compute the convex hull for each selected cluster. The
experimental results indicate that the uncertainty of the model for LLMs
depends on the prompt complexity, the model, and the temperature setting. | [
-0.513001442,
-1.5498044491,
0.8257203102,
0.2809129357,
-0.2013531476,
-0.0949424505,
-0.3717650175,
-0.1050427482,
0.1242177933,
-0.0065258499,
-0.3834001422,
-0.6880958676,
-0.6743109226,
-0.1211486086,
-0.0773141384,
0.3433456719,
0.0170542467,
0.1166050285,
-0.1555151343,
0.1612404436,
-0.331758827,
-0.4745732248,
-0.4821721315,
0.2329576313,
0.4193415642,
0.1473575532,
0.895996213,
0.288742125,
0.7038514018,
0.3268690109,
-0.1002217531,
-0.1395249069,
-0.2266850471,
0.1943442971,
0.0146255735,
-0.189624384,
-0.3800413013,
-0.3080997467,
0.7991178632,
0.9144986272,
-0.3326296508,
0.05400474,
0.2522141933,
0.3611511588,
-0.673592627,
0.4217587113,
-0.6268482208,
0.0816143528,
-0.1586743891,
0.2027085721,
-0.1549094468,
-0.5703935027,
0.1726240516,
-0.6795451045,
-0.0981256142,
0.0290943459,
0.3684795797,
0.4276305735,
-0.4467866421,
-0.4207151234,
-1.0001609325,
1.1665382385,
-1.0818804502,
0.4310576916,
0.3678059578,
0.3128204942,
-0.3542268872,
-0.17621167,
-0.7879302502,
0.1288933009,
0.1071933284,
0.1002499685,
-0.2022454292,
0.0538596511,
-0.259629786,
0.2760962248,
-0.6827895641,
0.4276558459,
0.0043268544,
-0.167989254,
0.6140526533,
0.2204640955,
0.067785494,
-0.167724371,
-0.1036711261,
-0.4575555325,
-0.1765797287,
0.1920975298,
0.4728649855,
0.4562592506,
-0.3617978692,
0.6746749878,
0.0868204907,
0.6332581043,
-0.1363362372,
-0.2964362204,
0.011877886,
-0.0650700256,
-0.2140472978,
-0.1829659194,
0.9388281703,
0.0494498014,
-0.1464353502,
0.4183335304,
-0.0966354162,
-0.211463064,
0.085000664,
-0.3984664977,
-0.0799591765,
0.5928615928,
-0.2468796372,
-0.3484953642,
0.0802157596,
-1.2258663177,
-0.4617393315,
-0.0785391405,
0.503218174,
-0.4099266529,
-0.3918897212,
0.3968500793,
0.4386427701,
0.1728827804,
0.1647875309,
-0.632153511,
0.0375335962,
0.6467906237,
0.5904046297,
-0.2391740084,
0.0311771668,
-0.1080849618,
0.2794843614,
-0.4008765817,
0.5594000816,
-0.7238215208,
-0.5062895417,
0.3576822281,
-0.4652214646,
0.1535148472,
-0.1447743624,
0.297748059,
-0.209628284,
0.0489577986,
-0.2286378741,
-0.4486454129,
-0.1178840101,
0.2995153069,
-0.7817983627,
1.4380712509,
0.0583045259,
-0.7972237468,
0.2189867347,
-0.151852861,
-0.299281925,
0.0365238748,
-0.479878217,
-0.7992450595,
0.3889061511,
0.3511585891,
0.8526878953,
-0.3680174351,
0.3904725313,
-0.7547892928,
-0.1227720231,
0.674511373,
-0.3456865847,
0.3525445461,
0.2193954438,
-0.2652953863,
-0.1109309793,
-0.8945090771,
0.1396553367,
0.0053781583,
-0.560421288,
-0.4286283851,
0.2075619996,
-0.1363886744,
-0.0901603997,
0.4423789084,
-0.5079774857,
0.2884497344,
-0.1593029052,
0.2777086794,
0.7171989679,
0.2653398216,
0.3861331642,
-0.0422758907,
0.5098398924,
0.2938149273,
0.248292923,
0.4957412183,
-0.7045175433,
-0.4363288879,
-0.4522856772,
-0.0908124447,
0.5439214706,
-0.6474725604,
0.5741989017,
-0.1238576397,
-0.6010381579,
-0.0722056106,
-0.2896491289,
0.0300545525,
-0.1181726679,
0.0730454847,
0.1035224646,
-0.4101100862,
-0.6457986236,
0.1505078375,
-0.4417780042,
-0.1040666401,
0.2757107019,
0.353343606,
-0.1467609853,
0.9136385322,
-0.8024169207,
-0.040323332,
-0.1469730139,
0.194700554,
0.5859572887,
0.4723029435,
0.6244578958,
-0.414368391,
-0.357688874,
0.2530997097,
-0.4731842875,
0.0343615972,
-0.1797488928,
-0.0550146066,
0.0106686391,
0.3705908954,
-0.6696721911,
0.5812165141,
0.73706007,
0.0576679222,
0.641972065,
-0.1538219899,
0.0050762407,
-1.2190102339,
-0.13866584,
0.1162074581,
0.1806750596,
-0.5090755224,
-0.0873821601,
-0.2565604746,
-0.1190373749,
-0.1641255766,
0.1608175635,
-0.285099715,
-0.3335339725,
0.0784836039,
0.0321991667,
-0.1674180031,
0.4255715311,
0.0859666169,
0.4104467034,
0.7031298876,
-0.5646279454,
0.4473848939,
0.2574970126,
-0.473521322,
0.7674190402,
-0.8178189993,
-0.0819099471,
-0.1574383527,
-0.0100157969,
-1.402602911,
-0.1328948438,
0.2765482664,
-0.3581857085,
0.3422819376,
0.1474933326,
-0.2990472615,
-0.3795737326,
-0.2042912692,
0.581733942,
0.1320695877,
0.0486563332,
0.5031867027,
0.3926065862,
-0.7379748225,
-0.3894198537,
-0.5587399006,
-0.2391292006,
-0.3600548506,
-0.429688096,
0.0303998552,
-0.2538411021,
-0.3450134993,
-0.3481307626,
-0.0285474081,
-0.5016469359,
0.1249147728,
0.2877294421,
-0.0179669037,
-0.1838132143,
0.0150634749,
0.1969805062,
0.1914909929,
0.157133162,
-0.3756895661,
0.502466619,
-0.0522909015,
-0.5439693928,
-0.361639291,
0.5246476531,
0.5105034709,
-0.1218925789,
0.7028687,
0.8167920113,
-0.5993484855,
-0.3338476717,
-0.4855957031,
-0.1240800321,
-0.4813252389,
0.582860589,
-0.4541823864,
-0.7540224791,
0.780895412,
0.1957150698,
-0.0474016294,
0.2901436985,
0.8119248152,
-0.3838509619,
0.845697701,
0.5614847541,
-0.1241033673,
0.1736201495,
-0.013310831,
0.527852118,
-0.386167258,
-0.3283736706,
-0.885738492,
-0.3559111953,
-0.4890086651,
-0.622377038,
0.8679426312,
-0.0643745959,
-0.2563049197,
0.0094142426,
-0.2265571207,
0.0078960788,
0.5500757694,
0.0781498775,
0.0931199044,
0.1995603293,
-0.273584336,
-0.3149671257,
-0.514236033,
-0.256196022,
0.7516393065,
0.4930717945,
1.0410951376,
0.4993089736,
0.394226402,
0.1580879539,
-0.3693275452,
-0.6712295413,
0.3604565561,
-0.0195840485,
-0.2217280716,
-0.8663711548,
-0.5935762525,
-0.9092136025,
0.13158454,
-0.3456385136,
-0.7947692871,
0.3540218174,
-0.0833250061,
-0.6788786054,
0.4167734087,
-0.1836334467,
0.4165605307,
-0.0627774969,
-0.0687157661,
-0.0094914045,
-0.2688771784,
0.0110419337,
-0.3833528161,
0.5611308813,
-0.055574134,
0.2014163435,
0.3939602375,
-0.2501451075,
1.0246465206,
-0.12461593,
-0.6809239984,
0.2562819421,
0.6676595807,
0.7115920186,
0.2952313125,
-0.1974211037,
0.352391988,
0.148888126,
-0.3710373342,
-0.4585657418,
0.569186151,
-0.8919484615,
-0.3735256791,
-0.3130103648,
-0.8771842718,
-0.4813135266,
0.0163245667,
0.4837554097,
0.2324671,
-0.1362410188,
0.1708650142,
0.6369174123,
-0.8202425838,
0.3474799991,
0.35391891,
-0.0057353564,
-0.1720097959,
0.712756753,
0.2022553831,
-0.0664599463,
0.4449958801,
0.2250783592,
-0.1878552884,
-0.9427320957,
0.0470393673,
0.0892126858,
-0.2171663791,
-0.2629753053,
-0.2518998682,
0.0781421438,
-0.5696517825,
-0.346427232,
-0.4950570762,
-0.3276889622,
-0.3735523522,
-0.266373992,
0.174216643,
1.061283946,
-0.2127126157,
0.5852313638,
-0.5768943429,
-0.0360715203,
0.2783598304,
0.3113810122,
-0.1956699938,
-0.3216869533,
-0.3098402023,
0.3741193712,
-0.109927915,
-0.9950377941,
0.4655224979,
0.3252441287,
0.6867692471,
0.4142953455,
0.2395526469,
0.4041182995,
-0.1570508778,
0.8796605468,
0.0959629193,
-1.0257946253,
0.4355790019,
-0.5484520793,
0.2167503387,
0.0475588627,
0.3985160291,
-0.163130492,
-0.5636313558,
-0.0863866284,
-0.8701756001,
0.1250247806,
0.1133592948,
-0.0429772399,
-0.0174379908,
0.5151767135,
0.0172179714,
0.0743371621,
-0.5423774719,
0.0032133453,
0.0473794602,
-0.372431308,
-0.0425422192,
-0.6176069379,
0.1542601585,
-0.0445746966,
0.5098029375,
-0.0577588417,
0.4525360465,
-0.0298304781,
-0.0848279223,
-0.0694416761,
0.209474355,
0.5489308834,
0.5131300092,
-0.3806042969,
0.2039274424,
0.2116042972,
-0.5220245123,
0.0971967354,
-0.2265228927,
0.1840797067,
0.1303982884,
0.4225873351,
0.4323236644,
0.2512117624,
-0.2966811359,
0.5209857821,
-0.0369084179,
-0.1855011433,
-0.4699778557,
-0.4726277292,
-0.1878047287,
0.3219941556,
0.437780261,
-0.384090215,
0.165474847,
-0.0602470897,
0.1708619893,
0.4185994565,
-0.2407249063,
-0.4300845563,
0.4201749563,
-0.006876932,
0.5272821188,
0.6609019041,
0.017636463,
-0.2915671468,
0.6306897998,
0.3612942696,
0.4661587477,
-0.5828621387,
0.3566024005,
0.4704047441,
0.5866388083,
0.2997809052,
0.5902839899,
0.3603655994,
-0.9125728011,
-0.5050166845,
-0.8995255828,
-0.3018318713,
0.0383665785,
-1.1460468769,
-0.1481197923,
-0.5164514184,
-0.4998443723,
-0.1241315901,
-0.1450900137,
-0.5236349702,
0.0834940001,
0.1742824167,
0.5075580478,
-1.0193380117,
0.6521676779,
0.5571200252,
0.0511668324,
-0.7483623624,
-0.200554952,
0.1034618393,
-0.6955013275,
0.2818368971,
-0.2398816943,
0.0753283054,
-0.1861141175,
-0.3251296878,
-1.1085978746,
0.8417226672,
0.428986609,
-0.7677657008,
0.1255790293,
0.8593215942,
0.3404249251,
-0.023104798,
-0.0343621634,
0.6277310252,
0.650143981,
0.0493956581,
-0.8298538327,
-0.0459445044,
0.1930346042,
0.424541533,
0.1403445154,
-0.1525672525,
1.0569244623,
-0.208337754,
-0.1666612029,
0.1113268062,
0.778444469,
0.1394392699,
-0.0431275666,
0.3724233806,
0.6106617451,
0.8393054008,
-0.3472925425,
0.8084967136,
-0.188639909,
0.7902929187,
0.9046894908,
-0.3808254004,
1.042404294,
0.5729717612,
-0.649100244,
0.3951050341,
0.7079889774,
0.1565423757,
0.2493098527,
0.5392402411,
-0.2408742458,
-0.2066532075,
0.1297253072,
-0.3645937443,
0.3276839554,
0.9359197617,
0.2147427797,
-0.0492024347,
0.1954018027,
-0.0002004991,
0.0217999425,
-0.0931826681,
0.7133363485,
0.0859597623,
-0.1178871989,
0.4710774422,
0.0349009112,
0.4675658345,
-0.4715251029,
0.2343558073,
-0.3370346725,
0.145569399,
-0.0670933425,
-0.8849853873,
0.4235779047,
-0.4064320028,
-0.0548300743,
0.2004150748,
-0.0125255687,
-0.5516315699,
-0.9509634376,
0.0600131564,
0.3562348485,
0.1091218516,
-0.2034505457,
-0.5390148163,
0.6720086336,
-0.1866045445,
-0.3617524505,
0.0140041374,
0.6304929852,
0.0676664412,
0.5702788234,
0.5188821554,
0.0364512913,
0.3448588848,
-0.2866308987,
0.505638361,
-0.1860433221,
-0.4483703971,
-0.7908191681,
0.3801878989,
0.3848160207,
-0.201341331,
0.7773182988,
0.3546023667,
0.4639346004,
-0.2537543476,
0.8202471733,
-0.0799609497,
0.2717013657,
-0.6472913027,
0.4372505248,
-0.2634681761,
0.3763354719,
-0.4994229674,
-1.2392286062,
-0.4834374785,
0.9175763726,
-0.1752634048,
-0.0678359121,
0.5937917233,
0.846701324,
0.0223683137,
-0.2239344418,
0.4688327312,
0.7612299919,
0.3112882972,
0.6844831109,
0.6032316685,
-0.1377415508,
0.3884284496,
-0.2958586216,
-0.3515221477,
-0.1229810491,
-0.9000266194,
-0.5662425756,
-1.0478680134,
-0.348269999,
-0.3223361373,
-0.1628235877,
0.5557667017,
0.7343753576,
-1.0177301168,
-0.372466743,
0.2731871009,
-0.0856868327,
-0.2655068338,
-0.2597054839,
0.6508030891,
-0.0646572337,
-0.7894621491,
0.2546906769,
0.2151934654,
0.2536061406,
-0.5518351197,
0.1787967533,
-0.0470005572,
0.3862401843,
0.6524256468,
-0.1273382753,
-0.5549938083,
-0.4990078807,
-0.2521844506,
-0.2071541697,
-0.3327251077,
0.5533356071,
-0.0830734745,
0.1783204079,
0.5669594407,
0.6711798906,
0.4114430547,
-0.3237743974,
0.87961483,
-1.173332572,
0.2781065106,
-0.0275739469,
0.4786373973,
0.0958387181,
-0.6047909856,
0.1299834996,
-0.0526339896,
-0.4266043603,
-0.6281883717,
0.4616872966,
-1.2055673599,
-0.5522168279,
1.2382267714,
-0.2447429895,
-0.1717054397,
-0.1119343415,
-0.0685881674,
-0.0707465261,
-0.3899200559,
0.9130725265,
0.8549303412,
0.303470701,
-0.0250882003,
-0.4623709321,
0.1560299397,
0.2602360249,
-0.8001403809,
-0.0156306121,
0.631434381,
0.1409484744,
0.0646481141,
-0.0475686714,
-0.0553445891,
-0.0855195597,
-0.2557581067,
0.2449819893,
0.2127312571,
-0.2640382051,
-0.3291461766,
0.2801797092,
0.0408476219,
0.0133609287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19674v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19674v1 | Less is More: Accurate Speech Recognition & Translation without Web-Scale Data | 2024-06-28T06:22:23 | 2024-06-28T06:22:23 | Krishna C. Puvvada, Piotr Żelasko, He Huang, Oleksii Hrinchuk, Nithin Rao Koluguri, Kunal Dhawan, Somshubra Majumdar, Elena Rastorgueva, Zhehuai Chen, Vitaly Lavrukhin, Jagadeesh Balam, Boris Ginsburg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent advances in speech recognition and translation rely on hundreds of
thousands of hours of Internet speech data. We argue that state-of-the art
accuracy can be reached without relying on web-scale data. Canary -
multilingual ASR and speech translation model, outperforms current
state-of-the-art models - Whisper, OWSM, and Seamless-M4T on English, French,
Spanish, and German languages, while being trained on an order of magnitude
less data than these models. Three key factors enables such data-efficient
model: (1) a FastConformer-based attention encoder-decoder architecture (2)
training on synthetic data generated with machine translation and (3) advanced
training techniques: data-balancing, dynamic data blending, dynamic bucketing
and noise-robust fine-tuning. The model, weights, and training code will be
open-sourced. | [
-0.2203813344,
-0.3852702379,
0.1295791715,
0.1589633524,
-0.0662766472,
0.0156876519,
-0.1785585433,
-0.7605012655,
0.1191319302,
0.2168671489,
-0.5315590501,
-0.2530270219,
-0.6628367305,
0.079041101,
-0.8120577335,
0.5640937686,
0.401827246,
0.3059968948,
-0.0246896558,
-0.1673308313,
0.1551059335,
-0.3866229653,
-0.8797891736,
-0.3261241317,
0.4930141568,
0.3761769831,
0.69653368,
0.9613379836,
0.4331434965,
0.241011858,
-0.1512311697,
0.071438536,
-0.4668667018,
-0.4645453691,
0.2421384603,
-0.3621455729,
-0.5482268929,
0.0037390697,
0.5052801371,
0.8225058317,
-0.1057430357,
0.3065196872,
-0.0037659844,
0.8540988564,
-0.5879209638,
0.2634418905,
-0.7747637033,
0.0539887697,
-0.2345416546,
0.259142518,
-0.2560055554,
-0.3749005198,
0.2394874841,
-0.7942692041,
0.2951739132,
-0.1903482527,
0.6405260563,
0.5249585509,
-0.560071826,
-0.2771785855,
-0.7270740867,
0.7422671914,
-0.6673611403,
1.0569016933,
0.3976310194,
0.4632911384,
0.1115219668,
-0.8364981413,
-0.7210589051,
-0.0328631811,
0.3062879741,
0.2295243591,
-0.4274546504,
-0.0406263135,
0.0676855296,
0.3408614993,
-0.6733644009,
0.1611811221,
-0.5263192654,
-0.2288848013,
0.4370366633,
-0.2341139168,
-0.1588531435,
0.1951634139,
-0.0960787758,
-0.3598501384,
-0.6974406242,
0.2122984976,
-0.0136777647,
0.7402930856,
-0.5781410933,
0.3943197727,
-0.3696589768,
0.7503720522,
0.2109776437,
-0.3846102655,
0.3910663426,
-0.1062221602,
-0.2744466066,
0.4019781649,
0.6544281244,
0.2890231311,
0.3430060446,
-0.2442263067,
0.1603455245,
0.2931526303,
-0.0098834904,
-0.5666244626,
-0.2336378992,
0.3901105821,
-0.3140887022,
-0.114396736,
-0.1624644697,
-0.3475270867,
-0.3288138211,
-0.4572200179,
0.0670725033,
-0.1168020517,
-0.0651229098,
0.0343409143,
-0.1425251961,
0.3265614212,
0.5470458865,
-0.4593750536,
0.3303316236,
0.5228230953,
1.0959454775,
-0.1495948136,
-0.174116239,
-0.818467617,
0.0495393761,
-0.3922851086,
0.5117659569,
-0.2918955088,
-0.1902218163,
0.0226167943,
0.0126072988,
-0.0291252583,
-0.4297364056,
0.7190499902,
-0.4305660725,
0.0308044944,
-0.2052749544,
-0.5309031606,
-0.1814320982,
0.085846588,
-0.8528140783,
0.7458664775,
-0.3561892211,
-0.6642649174,
0.2344152331,
-0.741748929,
-0.538479507,
-0.2095541209,
0.248645708,
-0.1418534666,
0.1773098558,
0.5004826188,
0.2157489955,
-0.3827427924,
-0.1237706915,
-0.1727993041,
-0.2274966538,
0.3147063851,
-0.7010658383,
0.7284336686,
0.4453284442,
-0.2568774521,
-0.1319920868,
-1.0850055218,
0.0537133738,
-0.0394479409,
-0.7027598619,
0.121194616,
0.1202597246,
0.5543260574,
0.3463742137,
0.419678688,
-0.9708524942,
-0.2954007983,
-0.7075045705,
0.6832395196,
0.2696328461,
-0.6088829041,
0.5045913458,
-0.3229074478,
0.271255523,
-0.1753263175,
0.271163255,
0.2105986625,
-0.5531176329,
-0.882635653,
-0.2870498598,
0.4203380048,
0.7184412479,
-0.512204051,
0.2177986205,
-0.9316571355,
-0.6471588016,
-0.9573023915,
0.1598059833,
0.5282770991,
0.6294230819,
0.592122674,
0.0009731132,
-0.5578956008,
-0.558203876,
-0.2118383497,
0.0410776511,
-0.1066059321,
0.1401631981,
0.0849548131,
-0.2067531347,
0.6973306537,
-0.1773155183,
-0.4829310179,
-0.2946557999,
-0.1548668593,
0.2879151404,
0.4628816843,
0.2171590626,
-0.8563036323,
-0.7245066166,
0.4195910096,
-0.4567618072,
0.176258713,
0.205275327,
0.4241948724,
0.1285584569,
0.453294903,
-0.4423039258,
0.2204977274,
0.8020409346,
0.3808494508,
-0.1266488284,
-0.1835212708,
-0.076339379,
-0.8575224876,
0.2517709732,
-0.1288425922,
-0.6673865914,
-0.8334715366,
0.1185179874,
0.2319810539,
-0.4222928286,
-0.8827413321,
0.5528032184,
-0.4143332541,
-0.2182225734,
-0.3705882132,
0.4006338418,
0.0407763161,
0.2045276165,
0.2360691726,
0.7729289532,
0.466904521,
-0.677873373,
0.3505787253,
0.2863648832,
-0.0851832852,
0.4786476195,
-0.7414421439,
0.2862985432,
0.0365489647,
0.1040356681,
-0.8344114423,
-0.2803355753,
-0.2047305703,
-0.7574953437,
0.1259297282,
-0.2734893858,
-0.4117742479,
-0.4507279098,
-0.3744456172,
0.0288950279,
0.5998521447,
-0.6796019077,
0.2970481217,
0.4914313555,
-0.1334116012,
-0.5253222585,
-1.0564118624,
0.0485149398,
0.0057475297,
-0.4140300751,
0.2078934163,
0.1653379649,
0.0564614311,
-0.1443313509,
-0.2876725793,
-0.6085564494,
-0.1564393938,
0.0407138132,
-0.2085426003,
-0.2317089438,
0.1426577121,
0.0928544253,
-0.0681325495,
-0.340008378,
-0.4561205506,
0.499524653,
-0.0344292708,
-0.3145693839,
-0.9155673981,
0.3414850235,
0.9513825178,
-0.2307285368,
0.4527878165,
0.6373906136,
-0.5297427773,
0.3752003908,
-0.5161469579,
0.0717522129,
-0.469286561,
0.2258633375,
-0.4177345037,
-0.6036123037,
0.4169281721,
0.1009130254,
0.2807747722,
0.330996424,
0.212810427,
-0.2583231628,
1.1577801704,
0.6186106205,
-0.2926163673,
0.5026904941,
-0.0549394041,
-0.0639520586,
-0.7633479834,
-0.0390316956,
-0.5101345778,
-0.311568886,
-0.6177309155,
-0.3535765111,
0.5333101153,
-0.1600794047,
-0.0716084093,
0.471988529,
-0.6006348729,
0.3134001195,
0.7451152802,
0.1181980893,
0.4567407668,
0.1521030068,
0.237264514,
-0.0840654969,
-0.8917375207,
-0.3029175699,
1.4286977053,
0.1561505646,
0.7795639634,
0.2248770148,
0.3462764323,
0.3470332325,
-0.1182074174,
-0.7572907209,
-0.0168454759,
-0.5197984576,
-0.6164242625,
-0.4198336303,
-0.4778469503,
-1.1755692959,
0.2390484661,
-0.1796492785,
-0.4830983877,
0.2837556601,
0.5226273537,
-0.3237122893,
-0.0171017386,
-0.7498320937,
0.6091223359,
-0.3436746895,
-0.0717825741,
-0.1799999923,
-0.7465213537,
0.071126461,
-0.2591743171,
0.4390448034,
0.0136666633,
-0.1520490348,
0.7319172025,
-0.5172359347,
0.8147389293,
-0.2190138102,
0.0812515244,
0.1228702515,
-0.2534611523,
0.7873020768,
-0.3707012534,
-0.1516258419,
0.2294387817,
0.2199593484,
-0.4868996739,
-0.3960473835,
0.5824257731,
-0.862682879,
0.0122053567,
-0.2417548895,
-0.3658011854,
-0.186124295,
0.1773310304,
0.490287751,
0.4044008851,
-0.2205393016,
0.3183195293,
0.5494785309,
-0.0282370355,
0.3589735627,
0.7306062579,
-0.0258403663,
-0.6047531366,
1.0344086885,
0.5019852519,
0.2790829539,
0.6628142595,
0.2552999556,
-0.7383797169,
-0.5271522999,
-0.6508736014,
0.1936283261,
-0.6619819999,
-0.0792077482,
-0.9292880297,
-0.0717561394,
-0.6857458353,
-0.1335053146,
-0.8709751964,
-0.5888872147,
-0.231169194,
-0.0638135523,
0.5585945845,
0.5491351485,
-0.2124813944,
0.8522106409,
-0.8376510739,
0.3334615827,
0.3701409101,
-0.2115478069,
-0.1118580624,
-0.5866952538,
-0.3192071319,
0.4020166099,
-0.055977799,
-0.6214948297,
0.5647890568,
0.6806996465,
0.2145433724,
0.4623936415,
0.0941483676,
0.9884971976,
-0.6213098764,
0.5353408456,
0.3273045123,
-1.2960788012,
0.4701701105,
-0.1019814387,
0.4941419363,
0.5303743482,
0.1938947886,
-0.626198113,
-0.1624258161,
-0.3471407592,
-0.7215335369,
0.6554347873,
0.1879603863,
0.0700644478,
0.3736540079,
0.1246409193,
0.0122430064,
0.4576745331,
-0.7205979228,
-0.2624341249,
-0.5647207499,
-0.4202054143,
-0.242804125,
0.313581109,
0.1651656181,
-0.4558036923,
0.5754659772,
-0.2083619833,
0.2066176534,
0.1305219233,
-0.477473706,
0.053136792,
0.1171139628,
0.6784071326,
0.187556684,
-0.1415999979,
0.1899532676,
0.3744090497,
-0.4811191261,
0.2066438198,
0.1916719377,
-0.1395113617,
0.1422690898,
0.3870429099,
0.7393206954,
0.2203843445,
-0.8069746494,
0.6996687651,
-0.0013019862,
0.0141973216,
-0.4668564498,
-0.113893941,
0.3179168105,
0.1729625463,
0.1877585202,
0.1359600872,
0.3496171832,
-0.3708461523,
0.1119076163,
0.3215349913,
-0.5970207453,
-0.2959387004,
0.8106207848,
0.3775630891,
-0.1927742064,
0.3330790401,
-0.1277689338,
-0.2192337513,
0.4119324088,
0.3804378808,
0.4158405066,
-0.2752025723,
0.0896382853,
0.28325665,
0.4412623942,
-0.1797610521,
0.3336105049,
-0.1496689171,
-0.522154808,
-0.5160838962,
-0.4688192308,
-0.6393104196,
0.3686037958,
-0.8224090338,
0.0976734608,
-0.5092880726,
-0.2119522542,
0.008873065,
-0.1478180289,
-0.749486208,
0.3620736301,
0.034411937,
0.983463943,
-0.7816569805,
1.1092020273,
0.5235945582,
-0.1883702427,
-0.6092329025,
-0.274097383,
0.2421616614,
-0.8028559089,
0.5392183065,
0.1997399628,
-0.3592796028,
0.4388584495,
-0.3012593985,
-1.2862186432,
0.7597757578,
0.8178374171,
-0.888218224,
0.1304779053,
0.1406894028,
0.5021297336,
-0.068061471,
-0.1122877002,
0.3515392542,
0.4275445342,
0.0913275331,
-1.2758221626,
-0.5131297708,
-0.2369898111,
-0.2662240565,
-0.1699755043,
-0.5365520716,
0.9327335954,
0.0490286984,
-0.2598773539,
-0.0216026921,
0.3700057268,
-0.2851227522,
0.1754310131,
0.1994347125,
0.4902234375,
1.0205947161,
-0.0310641788,
1.0821710825,
-0.2369115949,
0.1380477548,
1.4176123142,
-0.3949401677,
1.1977424622,
0.2744588852,
-0.3179472089,
-0.0764139965,
0.5390405059,
0.2533244491,
0.6793180704,
-0.1545262486,
-0.0941942707,
-0.2293328494,
-0.2065509111,
-0.4230746031,
0.7526440024,
0.2394769341,
-0.0700651407,
-0.1491244286,
0.2589379251,
-0.0107660834,
0.0700439289,
-0.2818796933,
0.951215446,
0.0269149337,
-0.0886378661,
0.9845101237,
0.0316917896,
0.8130899072,
-0.5489720702,
0.3083604872,
-0.0230171457,
0.2621042728,
-0.2704912424,
-0.141987592,
0.3574525416,
0.5342985392,
-0.2769433856,
0.0102215651,
0.2876375318,
-0.3691490591,
-0.8019424677,
0.3075306118,
0.6731901765,
0.4696316421,
-0.4152982235,
-0.6690151095,
0.1694981903,
0.0157265067,
0.1393917352,
0.0281671658,
0.091306597,
0.1533932388,
0.806853652,
1.0479424,
0.4987954795,
0.6640207767,
0.0037064601,
0.5276941061,
-0.4015962183,
-0.5441884398,
-0.5368383527,
0.350854218,
-0.1951959729,
-0.1561579108,
0.6641355753,
0.6730226874,
0.8311943412,
-0.0752426162,
0.9163467884,
0.2476765364,
0.8190402985,
-0.396802038,
0.6835599542,
-0.5882254243,
-0.1933055818,
-0.1603088379,
-0.5804290175,
-0.3915156424,
0.9239157438,
-0.1356046796,
-0.3457577825,
0.3477110863,
0.6407539845,
-0.2766852081,
-0.1212488711,
0.5866984725,
0.0125387078,
0.3069774508,
0.5657449961,
0.487128973,
-0.7739880681,
0.7366739511,
-0.2091456503,
-0.115570277,
-0.362311393,
-0.570931077,
-0.7516019344,
-0.3930548131,
-0.3900842965,
0.0828236789,
-0.0377437584,
1.091483593,
1.115278244,
-0.93918401,
-0.2852798402,
-0.4322547019,
-0.0880296975,
-0.4455299675,
-0.1183600724,
0.3807321191,
-0.1426972598,
-0.9843999743,
0.8436435461,
0.1918230057,
0.3339669704,
0.0379216038,
-0.2785675526,
0.0140412552,
0.1593289524,
0.6370030046,
0.4563312531,
-0.8285618424,
-0.1491199881,
0.0073787034,
-0.1571223736,
0.3908286691,
0.2660605907,
-0.6524756551,
0.6454173326,
0.3853023946,
0.8165229559,
0.7915897965,
-0.0129098948,
0.4112822711,
-0.717322588,
0.4441661835,
0.0178359952,
0.1573936641,
0.6657217145,
-0.2245323509,
0.3812507987,
0.0934617594,
-0.082116954,
-0.8174361587,
0.2478280813,
-1.0182429552,
0.059415713,
0.7499585748,
-0.3422339261,
-0.1058062837,
-0.2454146445,
-0.0700176433,
0.4687005877,
-0.6724799871,
0.5173749924,
0.3414957225,
-0.2996990979,
-0.3105491102,
-0.6239622235,
0.4644953907,
0.0386468843,
-0.7682080865,
0.1033001915,
0.3935354352,
0.1972403228,
0.3361635506,
0.4446650445,
-0.1210255623,
0.3274224699,
0.2343961298,
0.1328095645,
-0.1256543398,
-0.2792033553,
-0.5028710961,
0.2178680152,
0.169323653,
-0.638892293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19650v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19650v1 | DECOR: Improving Coherence in L2 English Writing with a Novel Benchmark for Incoherence Detection, Reasoning, and Rewriting | 2024-06-28T04:38:54 | 2024-06-28T04:38:54 | Xuanming Zhang, Anthony Diaz, Zixun Chen, Qingyang Wu, Kun Qian, Erik Voss, Zhou Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Coherence in writing, an aspect that second-language (L2) English learners
often struggle with, is crucial in assessing L2 English writing. Existing
automated writing evaluation systems primarily use basic surface linguistic
features to detect coherence in writing. However, little effort has been made
to correct the detected incoherence, which could significantly benefit L2
language learners seeking to improve their writing. To bridge this gap, we
introduce DECOR, a novel benchmark that includes expert annotations for
detecting incoherence in L2 English writing, identifying the underlying
reasons, and rewriting the incoherent sentences. To our knowledge, DECOR is the
first coherence assessment dataset specifically designed for improving L2
English writing, featuring pairs of original incoherent sentences alongside
their expert-rewritten counterparts. Additionally, we fine-tuned models to
automatically detect and rewrite incoherence in student essays. We find that
incorporating specific reasons for incoherence during fine-tuning consistently
improves the quality of the rewrites, achieving a result that is favored in
both automatic and human evaluations. | [
-0.3240197003,
-0.7683856487,
0.3368673921,
0.1710564345,
-0.049061805,
0.2817984819,
-0.2382568121,
-0.7651689649,
0.2983316481,
0.1710488796,
-0.458584249,
-0.2328320146,
-0.4872061908,
0.3134238124,
-0.1457717866,
0.6874874234,
-0.3552566171,
-0.0204515457,
-0.7014642358,
-0.339780122,
-0.5647810698,
-0.1112604365,
-0.9351093769,
-0.199467808,
0.5371970534,
0.7617598176,
0.4558120668,
0.4399272501,
0.6451208591,
0.1987378895,
0.3652812243,
0.4002673924,
-0.3266358674,
0.5412591696,
-0.1097455099,
-0.3344944715,
-0.5850738287,
-0.0447304212,
0.4645831585,
0.559389174,
0.2436259091,
0.1452418715,
0.3111020029,
0.5770782232,
-0.661798954,
0.1795329005,
-0.6930081248,
-0.0002962365,
-0.1338241547,
-0.2774772942,
-0.647215724,
-0.0548471808,
0.0186924133,
-0.766148746,
0.5537294149,
0.3778893352,
0.9882525802,
0.436892122,
-0.2006194443,
-0.2471667379,
-0.0698625669,
0.7876052856,
-0.3848001361,
0.5205295086,
0.3999952376,
0.0089266663,
-0.3016612828,
-0.707651794,
-0.5148386955,
-0.1802388728,
-0.2867992818,
0.4079861045,
0.1238434836,
-0.2571882904,
0.1850974262,
0.5306457281,
-0.4549309909,
-0.1340193897,
0.110918209,
-0.6078560352,
0.6725563407,
0.0046639401,
0.5241624117,
0.2516238987,
-0.2317960113,
0.1424672604,
-0.3987464905,
0.1852790564,
0.3361984789,
-0.1697477698,
-0.0461600535,
0.3714851439,
0.0404937491,
0.2495830804,
0.1406282037,
-0.1210118607,
-0.0811908022,
-0.2571693361,
0.02294215,
0.052067697,
0.3425908089,
0.6716910005,
0.2981728911,
-0.1612550616,
-0.1229065582,
0.4905954003,
-0.0540095866,
-0.7667835951,
-0.7461506724,
0.3277507424,
-0.2972424328,
-0.1580329239,
-0.3186049759,
-0.5215443969,
-0.5154682398,
-0.3340403736,
0.211916551,
-0.4323994219,
-0.3885006905,
-0.0300838295,
-0.2756770253,
0.151369676,
0.6320341825,
-0.9345020056,
0.4228064418,
1.0617171526,
0.6935766339,
-0.386620611,
-0.6692367792,
-0.4730091095,
-0.1333543956,
-0.6334914565,
1.1481217146,
-0.3318118453,
0.011714451,
-0.0388928205,
0.00698611,
0.0936767608,
-0.3300521076,
0.9128329754,
-0.2476293445,
0.608908236,
-0.3464251459,
-0.8677034974,
0.2473037839,
0.0661743879,
-0.6439688802,
0.9119648933,
0.2292560935,
-0.9902353287,
0.821506083,
-0.3428209722,
-0.5567817688,
-0.0772245601,
-0.0755844936,
-0.9794505835,
0.4105372727,
0.0434784293,
0.081594184,
0.2694966793,
-0.1357874721,
-0.1121331304,
-0.5914824009,
-0.0750814751,
-0.3947965801,
0.5293365717,
0.054619465,
-0.1603447199,
0.2138287425,
-0.8223146796,
0.2082709372,
-0.1029289216,
-0.3556111157,
-0.3877849281,
-0.0008987378,
0.166439414,
-0.2703613937,
0.4892640114,
-0.5080527067,
-0.0937240869,
-0.4602286816,
0.2372120619,
0.5806824565,
0.1086093634,
0.3854738772,
-0.7663163543,
0.2484291047,
-0.2242393792,
-0.3441055417,
-0.5635820627,
-0.5665599704,
-1.0668452978,
-0.5324044824,
-0.0844604075,
0.1407266408,
-0.2126423866,
0.3703987896,
0.0402684808,
-0.1913576275,
-0.8548349142,
0.1787955612,
0.5935863256,
0.5486917496,
0.4272747338,
-0.3184132576,
-0.8289520741,
-0.5980603695,
-0.6858987212,
-0.129731372,
0.3103531599,
-0.2196708918,
0.3918309808,
0.0651485473,
0.5969564319,
-0.2049193233,
-0.354542762,
0.1149707064,
0.2670342028,
-0.2746789157,
0.7139803171,
0.2283286601,
-0.1633216292,
-0.8918378353,
-0.0319652259,
-0.5399929881,
-0.365678519,
-0.2459186465,
-0.3635198176,
0.7829742432,
0.7478841543,
-0.1550005972,
0.2583485842,
0.3084842861,
-0.7293071151,
0.6031411886,
-0.2047260851,
0.2133229524,
-0.9843620658,
-0.1498985291,
-0.2544084489,
-0.4084532857,
-0.2431840748,
0.3338459432,
-0.0109945368,
0.1903868616,
0.0858423486,
0.4912876487,
-0.7299386859,
0.2830242515,
-0.3228004575,
0.0444511622,
0.6568712592,
0.3874016702,
0.0570583493,
0.7195266485,
0.2731119692,
0.1642208248,
-0.0653760359,
0.2323466092,
-0.5364242196,
1.0605874062,
-0.3669097126,
0.3452955484,
-0.0540587492,
0.2427407503,
-1.425208807,
-0.446031481,
0.0774013102,
-0.3275378346,
0.4010371268,
0.1578019559,
-0.0506065674,
0.052786313,
-0.4418252707,
0.2332327962,
0.3290990293,
-0.4724589288,
0.2091445178,
0.1155763566,
-0.1078864187,
-0.3481236696,
-0.5711860061,
0.335880667,
-0.0039051978,
-0.6719015241,
0.2916934788,
-0.1734597087,
-0.3547627926,
-0.2115231901,
-0.2641010284,
-0.2309990674,
0.2261665612,
0.140264228,
-0.0386014134,
-0.2558096051,
0.1074662656,
0.3123460114,
-0.2104090154,
0.2146259695,
-0.1692803651,
0.3493154645,
-0.0844713971,
-0.4434474111,
-0.9703862071,
0.6147431731,
0.6897116899,
0.0149454316,
0.1954818815,
0.5326996446,
-0.3623993993,
-0.5891008973,
-0.6244819164,
-0.2521348298,
-0.4026023746,
0.4532160759,
-0.8655881286,
-0.5979162455,
0.3577279449,
0.2300499231,
0.3279621601,
0.3623269498,
0.2797690034,
-0.4378263354,
0.6066755056,
0.7065066695,
0.3061541319,
0.3736867607,
0.0386339352,
0.1762443781,
-0.76042974,
-0.1233047768,
-0.3501549065,
-0.373868674,
-0.4029532075,
-0.3729857802,
0.1379921883,
0.1170047447,
-0.2182641178,
0.1709920764,
-0.7922107577,
0.7467755675,
0.4708353579,
0.0682756975,
0.6592446566,
0.2626642585,
-0.055694066,
-0.5717085004,
-0.335260421,
-0.5536433458,
0.735948503,
0.5939154029,
0.5163277984,
0.0411897302,
0.6613878608,
0.3354967833,
0.4114955664,
-0.9295704961,
0.4138763249,
-0.0554357395,
-0.1486122757,
-0.3523304164,
0.1416654736,
-0.6607623696,
0.1898877919,
-0.1305597723,
-0.1940190196,
0.3243518472,
0.349236846,
-0.2528849542,
-0.0802931711,
-0.7635512948,
0.8443879485,
-0.1149469689,
-0.9161022305,
-0.2180464119,
-0.2008674592,
0.1082953662,
0.0061980314,
-0.0813537464,
-0.1414506882,
-0.250708282,
0.5966600776,
-0.5545010567,
0.5630333424,
0.0698667318,
-0.5111748576,
0.3291376531,
0.5688846707,
0.6666634679,
-0.0681200027,
-0.4598271251,
0.1773581803,
0.2629157305,
-0.4299320877,
-0.4291723073,
0.7711215615,
-0.6441957951,
-0.4918513,
-0.3949486911,
-0.6944995522,
-0.2373931855,
0.1666007936,
0.5623343587,
0.3238801658,
-0.3636857867,
-0.0568969212,
0.3838228583,
0.2646252811,
0.3988972008,
0.4770377874,
-0.093808271,
-0.6250856519,
0.7600337863,
0.1685720384,
0.2903005779,
0.308838129,
0.184662044,
-0.2818674445,
-0.5242817998,
-0.4750906825,
-0.1413480341,
-0.8574444056,
0.1747415513,
-0.5788059831,
0.1238179952,
-0.4922461212,
-0.6265318394,
-0.1791546345,
-0.5335268974,
-0.061250113,
0.1642249227,
0.1342399865,
0.5888100266,
-0.0075687459,
-0.0827106014,
0.0490088873,
0.0668146759,
0.1337721348,
0.5461956263,
-0.1007495299,
-0.7632035613,
-0.3161456883,
-0.2690740526,
-0.1730550677,
-0.2304609567,
0.0160364192,
0.4341216981,
0.1854210049,
0.2569701076,
0.0051178667,
0.8443574309,
-0.629193604,
0.6447459459,
0.2066474557,
-1.024236083,
0.3889431357,
-0.1758859456,
0.1793179661,
0.9411823153,
-0.189099431,
-0.5182313323,
-0.6424067616,
-0.3908777535,
-0.7463060021,
0.24838157,
-0.0836777017,
-0.0610107742,
-0.0031948439,
0.3235951066,
0.3843280971,
0.1118181571,
-0.5244106054,
0.2575665414,
-0.2784392834,
-0.4215925634,
0.1592984349,
-0.552596271,
-0.2678625286,
-0.4081844091,
0.6632937193,
-0.1026771888,
0.0863255933,
0.6654723287,
-0.1006206125,
-0.6813415885,
0.1070313007,
0.5612418652,
0.4557513297,
-0.1563169062,
0.4369867146,
0.4112421572,
-0.427097261,
0.1785443723,
-0.2802755535,
-0.2547371089,
0.2013845891,
0.9067934752,
0.3177499175,
0.0630327985,
-0.3072486818,
0.6110786796,
-0.1274371743,
-0.0535533503,
-0.6069947481,
0.2130237818,
-0.0431641936,
-0.2111044526,
-0.262716502,
0.5242073536,
-0.0275334045,
-0.7007863522,
0.5415055752,
0.5914345384,
-0.4385118783,
-0.2772721648,
0.7025575042,
0.4834703207,
-0.541451633,
0.0523553528,
-0.3232239187,
-0.1976771206,
0.4828091562,
0.6061523557,
1.1929880381,
-0.1318893582,
0.0394835696,
0.437418133,
0.3224518299,
0.0871860534,
0.6113548875,
-0.3365371823,
-0.6643170118,
-0.1981429756,
-0.6300078034,
-0.7879576683,
-0.0244947243,
-0.5622307658,
0.5130236149,
-0.6373077035,
0.3194730282,
-0.0463974997,
0.3151095808,
-0.4038850069,
0.1205070168,
-0.0058371164,
0.8743165135,
-0.9184151292,
0.6026366949,
0.8421384096,
-0.2478591502,
-0.681533277,
0.4217542708,
-0.0993412063,
-0.5522460341,
0.1694183648,
0.3705024123,
-0.4978648126,
-0.0023336406,
-0.4017067552,
-0.5160749555,
0.830517292,
0.2500841618,
-0.9244487882,
0.3576812744,
0.1056006104,
0.9152984023,
-0.468432337,
0.4790381193,
0.5523676872,
0.5711051226,
-0.0035580529,
-0.6352135539,
0.1431088895,
-0.3769527376,
-0.2770459056,
-0.1670419574,
-0.9323543906,
0.6106688976,
-0.2616169155,
-0.4903651178,
0.4894349873,
0.725081265,
-0.0960713476,
0.9251335859,
0.4155319333,
0.8319461346,
1.1646914482,
-0.3745671213,
0.6323207617,
-0.6447523832,
0.1837969571,
1.6220734119,
-0.4776749313,
1.0661059618,
0.5025455356,
-0.0681625381,
0.8964378834,
0.4816963375,
0.0630472079,
0.4186999798,
0.3269478977,
-0.5561469197,
-0.2516179979,
-0.2003528327,
-0.4033691883,
0.3369654715,
0.0191509724,
-0.1987117529,
-0.0757843256,
-0.2215666622,
0.3140854537,
0.6567479968,
-0.067466557,
0.823572576,
0.0114970794,
-1.3316231966,
0.7480828166,
-0.2187823057,
0.5186914206,
-0.1915345639,
-0.194919154,
-0.4900935292,
0.4501865804,
-0.6784520149,
-0.7534151673,
0.7364885211,
-0.2013997585,
-0.3864538968,
-0.3955129087,
0.7583005428,
-0.6834093332,
-0.5603651404,
0.1074013337,
0.2769171894,
0.1610596627,
0.1344861239,
-0.3272626996,
0.1876497567,
-0.2187327445,
-0.0373388641,
-0.1085697338,
0.6424206495,
0.018182816,
0.1950019598,
0.5667904019,
0.1307287812,
-0.398958385,
0.2676343024,
0.3345568776,
-0.2872838676,
-0.3198504448,
-0.7590094805,
0.5659903884,
-0.178434521,
-0.4742789567,
0.9281947017,
0.8171298504,
0.8231371641,
0.0235930681,
0.9501213431,
0.1973632723,
0.6456642747,
-0.1964346617,
0.8822804093,
-0.6428177357,
0.2359996438,
-0.1525142193,
-0.6113650203,
-0.4918373525,
0.7340988517,
-0.1668500155,
-0.4447169304,
0.9669758677,
1.0748349428,
0.1041408479,
0.1186942682,
0.5272060633,
0.3373208046,
0.4189637601,
0.4154946506,
0.9201595187,
-0.6435507536,
0.1640388221,
-0.3156187832,
-0.3225217462,
-0.1425710469,
-0.9847340584,
-1.1016070843,
-0.5309466124,
-0.8060190082,
-0.8317198157,
0.2876196802,
0.9191958904,
0.3792235851,
-1.2596377134,
-0.0337409526,
-0.6891924739,
0.2677979469,
-0.4157722592,
-0.2380064577,
0.5453577042,
-0.788970232,
-0.8206338882,
0.3147521019,
0.680487752,
-0.216858685,
-0.4325335026,
0.0629330873,
0.0817147791,
0.3647365868,
0.4422203302,
0.0064109969,
-0.6465672255,
-0.6199545264,
-0.1828580052,
-0.3142418861,
0.2476793379,
0.5710765719,
-0.4328438044,
0.8031607866,
0.8666602969,
0.3025533855,
-0.2666733563,
0.0160695333,
0.2468845695,
-0.5274137855,
-0.0854420811,
0.1390935481,
0.5189421177,
0.52927351,
-0.4966109693,
0.4338684678,
0.5829864144,
-0.8273670673,
-0.9052182436,
0.2788344026,
-0.8358769417,
-0.0412833355,
0.7498278022,
-0.3691025376,
-0.0503714532,
-0.5786267519,
-0.6742665768,
0.0683088303,
-0.1461666375,
1.1548761129,
0.9164304733,
-0.2347524762,
-0.13166143,
-0.0345996991,
0.8795595765,
0.9646242857,
-0.7794170976,
0.1249616072,
0.5445869565,
0.4385959506,
0.1345107704,
0.8120111823,
0.2291866988,
0.491286099,
0.3144898117,
-0.1034397855,
-0.0269019529,
-0.3763110936,
-0.078963317,
0.405048877,
0.252679348,
-0.2255832702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19648v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19648v1 | Designing and Evaluating Multi-Chatbot Interface for Human-AI Communication: Preliminary Findings from a Persuasion Task | 2024-06-28T04:33:41 | 2024-06-28T04:33:41 | Sion Yoon, Tae Eun Kim, Yoo Jung Oh | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | The dynamics of human-AI communication have been reshaped by language models
such as ChatGPT. However, extant research has primarily focused on dyadic
communication, leaving much to be explored regarding the dynamics of human-AI
communication in group settings. The availability of multiple language model
chatbots presents a unique opportunity for scholars to better understand the
interaction between humans and multiple chatbots. This study examines the
impact of multi-chatbot communication in a specific persuasion setting:
promoting charitable donations. We developed an online environment that enables
multi-chatbot communication and conducted a pilot experiment utilizing two
GPT-based chatbots, Save the Children and UNICEF chatbots, to promote
charitable donations. In this study, we present our development process of the
multi-chatbot interface and present preliminary findings from a pilot
experiment. Analysis of qualitative and quantitative feedback are presented,
and limitations are addressed. | [
-0.4467735589,
-0.7839599848,
0.2180032879,
0.2169076353,
-0.2792926133,
0.3689554632,
-0.2405842245,
-0.5543775558,
0.1379711926,
0.0750322416,
-0.6492617726,
-0.019006284,
-0.5203102231,
0.134833321,
-0.1734930128,
1.0925841331,
0.4152938426,
0.260954082,
-0.2172061652,
-0.0686915144,
-0.4945870042,
-0.8651364446,
-1.1440560818,
-0.4053340852,
0.5888758302,
0.3265728951,
0.6780728102,
0.0617656857,
0.5504310727,
0.419493109,
0.2446174175,
-0.1975633055,
-0.6881067157,
0.0619457737,
-0.0803433135,
-0.4113926589,
-0.189589873,
0.1905697435,
0.2069220543,
0.2133510113,
-0.2189625651,
0.1578249633,
0.2856924832,
0.5142909884,
-0.3595631421,
0.2825117409,
-0.4112533629,
-0.1950701177,
0.0357799754,
-0.2216809243,
-0.3280424774,
-0.4919352233,
0.374510169,
-0.5743668079,
0.097241655,
-0.1180370748,
0.565233171,
-0.0248298272,
-0.4076467752,
-0.6802378297,
-0.9013037086,
0.6231683493,
-0.3965224922,
0.1290934384,
0.65408355,
0.1998609453,
-0.1726115942,
-0.4575289786,
-0.650627017,
-0.5530864596,
0.0754007623,
0.2514579296,
-0.3328750134,
0.0973958448,
-0.2578881383,
-0.0424389616,
-0.2015792131,
-0.1137003526,
-0.3275835812,
-0.2010290027,
0.5596602559,
-0.0858163387,
0.3149341047,
-0.0653328896,
-0.3600408435,
-0.4287129939,
-0.4248718321,
0.0880163386,
0.5771442056,
0.3128291667,
-0.4876469076,
0.3165019155,
0.1533883363,
0.3895750344,
0.1578374654,
-0.0172161628,
-0.1041760966,
-0.7770768404,
-0.1034217477,
-0.2293712199,
0.7771441936,
0.4873105288,
0.4346311092,
0.2191752493,
0.1699905396,
0.4474219382,
0.3261937499,
-0.6742063165,
-0.2979495823,
0.0185846053,
-0.9404408336,
-0.5566675067,
-0.0824496821,
-0.6368976235,
-0.6707907915,
-0.1571848691,
0.6476581097,
-0.2565067112,
-0.5615444779,
0.0766536593,
-0.5359185934,
0.1128917038,
0.7453955412,
-0.7588406801,
0.1324002445,
0.5589795709,
0.6795446873,
0.1853327453,
-0.2548574507,
-0.5663534999,
0.082063213,
0.1831369698,
0.846131742,
-0.8507950306,
-0.7061933279,
0.0633590221,
-0.2321810722,
-0.0348365977,
-0.169272244,
0.4862458706,
-0.177258119,
0.566018939,
-0.0186501034,
-0.3913045824,
0.0115161845,
0.5170603395,
-0.4238477945,
0.2797673047,
0.0864325166,
-0.4753269255,
0.3907091916,
-1.0099624395,
-0.5439916849,
0.1520546824,
-0.2100049257,
-0.2223510295,
0.1218921989,
0.1934154034,
0.3068848848,
-0.2040200233,
0.2631004155,
-0.2697720528,
-0.2360540479,
0.3909725249,
-1.0480709076,
0.7438693047,
-0.0321428254,
-0.3285404146,
0.3378010094,
-0.3968378305,
-0.2842737734,
0.1040547341,
-0.3557991385,
-0.1944965869,
0.214027077,
0.2667320073,
0.2947044969,
0.0013041567,
-0.5717641711,
0.5658531189,
-0.0279349331,
0.7082759142,
0.6666110158,
-0.2176497579,
0.18172656,
-0.3653369844,
0.7967587113,
-0.1808732897,
0.522495687,
-0.102849476,
-1.0236598253,
-0.444429934,
-0.1544361115,
0.0274958499,
0.2963812351,
-0.6215319037,
-0.0538974032,
0.0651872978,
-0.1894616336,
-0.8403190374,
-0.3710708916,
0.3015244901,
0.2949233055,
0.1423035264,
-0.2735728621,
-0.1567225605,
-1.1489173174,
-0.2083422542,
-0.7662807703,
-0.1117279381,
0.4379844368,
0.4179398119,
-0.0296243858,
0.6961573362,
-0.0332269631,
-0.2427074313,
-0.3332906663,
0.3086210489,
-0.2311603427,
0.4384624362,
0.5535764694,
-0.9158611894,
-0.5112469196,
-0.219775781,
0.0685525015,
0.3667062521,
-0.3161481023,
0.0107824244,
-0.1904332936,
-0.2609715462,
-0.5679183006,
0.8619292378,
0.9158869982,
-0.2669957876,
0.3989010453,
-0.2243189812,
0.9518458247,
-1.0362871885,
-0.0723426491,
-0.077350311,
-0.0933887437,
-1.0382275581,
-0.4398751259,
-0.0987426192,
-0.1126166955,
-0.5599583983,
0.5062512159,
-0.1794607937,
0.3517912924,
-0.4185875952,
0.2996967137,
-0.0398451053,
0.3233473301,
0.2215801626,
0.7357596755,
0.5776059031,
-0.571277678,
0.3869359493,
0.4853378236,
0.0707407072,
1.0583536625,
-0.8888549209,
0.4326948822,
-0.0401751548,
0.5435515046,
-1.1379115582,
-0.1854214966,
0.7160139084,
-0.9418101311,
-0.0516844131,
-0.2943075001,
-0.2146422416,
-0.4667227566,
-0.504796207,
0.2518744767,
0.0838016123,
-0.3371801376,
0.4966553748,
0.5721034408,
-0.1620568782,
-0.269965291,
-0.5381341577,
0.3637240827,
-0.3968687356,
-0.7736608386,
-0.0012207683,
-0.284502238,
-0.1797885448,
-0.1706487536,
0.4655714929,
-0.1539807022,
0.2608807981,
0.161626339,
0.2738237381,
0.0211484022,
0.2724958658,
-0.0645373687,
-0.0939747989,
-0.0302175749,
0.1184324101,
0.7249559164,
-0.2209057808,
-0.7366334796,
-1.0365618467,
0.6198030114,
0.2082598805,
-0.1211569458,
1.0260742903,
0.5734977722,
-0.2899020016,
0.5008710027,
-0.4618689716,
-0.5621141791,
-0.4975465238,
0.2505752444,
-0.3594814241,
-0.9968925714,
0.1376842707,
-0.073362343,
0.25891608,
0.2621170282,
0.7892619371,
-0.0252226647,
1.3572055101,
0.5267473459,
-0.2891448736,
0.6183869243,
0.0844018832,
0.1613502502,
-0.5804121494,
-0.2347736508,
-0.8700989485,
-0.2416561544,
-0.3255589306,
-0.2787008286,
0.4131862223,
0.1912368685,
-0.0756111145,
0.2115379423,
-0.6319816113,
0.1340014637,
0.7940428853,
-0.0920039043,
0.3733220696,
-0.06815245,
0.4146274626,
0.1682060808,
-0.5885910392,
-0.5426948071,
0.8865954876,
0.145477131,
0.6151863933,
0.4920312762,
0.5378784537,
0.5260168314,
0.9092454314,
-0.616553545,
0.226074487,
0.2827365994,
-0.7206960917,
-0.4492576122,
-0.2619740367,
-1.4502922297,
0.4512559772,
-0.2248657197,
-0.8586076498,
-0.1146494523,
0.2458870113,
-0.1407995075,
0.0180927943,
-0.7827631235,
0.6924206018,
-0.2700135708,
-0.0663113147,
-0.8814978004,
-0.7244859338,
0.1320015192,
0.0738194361,
0.3777016103,
-0.2283728719,
0.3383603394,
0.4226720929,
-0.1519636214,
0.9934626818,
-0.1650905758,
-0.1588775069,
0.2813797891,
-0.195308879,
0.5405856371,
0.4158149958,
-0.128852129,
-0.0466319583,
-0.0940792784,
-0.0913259387,
-0.2990884781,
0.6322025061,
-0.8328197002,
-0.8320892453,
-0.2535473406,
-0.345931679,
-0.2448794097,
0.0797678158,
-0.3486537635,
0.5705330968,
-0.547123611,
0.1361317486,
-0.0731200203,
-0.4126562476,
0.4725795686,
0.4895359874,
0.1505276859,
-0.4382033348,
0.9103432298,
-0.7669405341,
0.5880915523,
0.3582824171,
0.6874706149,
-0.527066648,
-0.1216141805,
-0.9380574226,
0.1411508918,
-0.4575804472,
0.0463646911,
-0.3419664204,
0.264139235,
-0.6941437125,
-0.1785910279,
-0.1539679021,
-0.5269930959,
-0.169919163,
0.3704410791,
0.308110863,
1.241237402,
-0.2076857835,
0.3250617683,
-0.977591455,
0.2202094495,
0.2926619351,
0.2029578686,
0.1854435951,
-0.1731404513,
-0.0600769743,
0.4237485528,
-0.4282579422,
-1.0351374149,
0.0070301974,
0.1666719466,
0.5905990601,
0.6012518406,
-0.0285279211,
0.7816863656,
-0.3075811565,
0.9297729135,
0.4505674541,
-0.8362925053,
0.5413902402,
-0.3891839683,
0.1620588005,
0.428717047,
0.1802876443,
-0.927301228,
-0.5257592797,
-0.762182951,
-0.3082292676,
0.821834147,
0.6206156611,
0.3533462584,
-0.0151500711,
-0.1291995794,
0.1412105411,
0.6837645769,
-0.5252739191,
-0.5520064831,
-0.2989647686,
0.0554322191,
0.0023106888,
0.0864984989,
-0.4326063693,
-0.0295083765,
0.3721986115,
0.1043358296,
0.2086670101,
-0.1380515099,
0.2104135007,
0.1755318344,
0.4061181247,
0.8596357107,
0.7192652822,
0.3408577442,
-0.240845561,
-0.4573684931,
-0.4024787247,
0.147603184,
0.1971635371,
0.017071519,
-0.2380935848,
0.2588401139,
0.7040417194,
-0.0921894833,
-0.3760789633,
0.42158553,
-0.6479445696,
-0.1616903394,
0.0938428789,
-0.176404357,
0.5584423542,
0.1209464893,
0.1791107655,
0.0628390759,
0.225011602,
-0.6418634653,
0.0556192286,
0.8218938112,
-0.1585967094,
-0.4160863161,
0.7580515742,
0.9063467383,
-0.9233778119,
0.82919842,
-0.134281531,
-0.6925517321,
0.5996204019,
0.4980991483,
0.8450280428,
-0.3168234229,
0.7451217175,
0.1379784048,
0.1402102113,
0.1911026239,
-0.0440318249,
-0.3391066194,
-0.7084933519,
-0.0034912925,
-0.1668619514,
-0.7562269568,
0.1439718306,
-0.4427414834,
0.0633360073,
0.004203673,
-0.4209483266,
0.1815815866,
-0.2283456922,
-0.8324761987,
-0.3422991633,
0.1065412909,
0.0707702935,
-0.4334896803,
0.5984453559,
0.7515226007,
-0.435762167,
-0.6437713504,
-0.0271784086,
0.1301512718,
-0.8696464896,
0.4713350832,
0.142798081,
-0.5660116673,
0.0616702661,
-0.4837911129,
-0.7071124911,
0.5048619509,
0.0655989498,
-0.4412502348,
0.3685057461,
0.3184469342,
0.5107908249,
-0.2500882149,
0.5409615636,
0.1005681157,
0.7431980968,
-0.161698997,
-1.3141584396,
-0.2774050832,
-0.2162279189,
-0.2142232955,
0.221582368,
-0.8750283718,
0.4689204991,
-0.1785828322,
-0.3043890893,
0.1478247494,
0.5282956958,
0.2439521104,
0.0859737992,
0.7047430277,
-0.207836777,
0.6109722257,
0.1099146158,
1.0069125891,
-0.4571467042,
0.336130172,
0.6450173855,
-0.2522017658,
0.496630758,
0.5799751878,
-0.3786343336,
0.2299117595,
0.2620217204,
0.1973307729,
0.1312972605,
0.7828962207,
-0.5958691239,
-0.1029933244,
-0.4092104435,
-0.3736540675,
0.3732565939,
0.4999759495,
0.1843635589,
-0.0416505001,
0.3794068992,
0.0626582578,
-0.2673344016,
-0.0231321584,
0.4948870838,
-0.2019462138,
-0.7193607092,
-0.0224041212,
0.0650096312,
0.7457647324,
-0.5737836957,
-0.4275557399,
0.0442569889,
0.4113459885,
0.2049129903,
-0.6326874495,
-0.0710550398,
-0.1866946667,
0.1447050422,
-0.2728795409,
0.8503873348,
-0.5003213286,
-0.4248549938,
0.171907261,
0.751742065,
0.3386310935,
-0.0290514026,
-1.0617241859,
0.2816271186,
-0.1052408069,
-0.3468079865,
0.4553130567,
0.1419653445,
-0.0652018711,
0.8448111415,
0.7803685069,
-0.0519141145,
-0.3328814805,
0.853946507,
0.8389359713,
-0.363996923,
-0.3655812144,
-0.8819043636,
0.3609441519,
-0.1050731242,
-0.5281969905,
0.8578181267,
0.3508384526,
0.709864378,
-0.17303738,
0.9340367913,
-0.3780008256,
0.2711387575,
0.0654002354,
0.5942834616,
-0.3836638927,
-0.0997070596,
-0.4985559583,
-0.3623707592,
-0.0262493547,
0.7455880046,
0.3093779385,
0.2106442004,
0.3400078714,
0.4512744248,
0.2957436144,
0.5178604722,
0.1120807678,
-0.2019609511,
0.9033691883,
0.4532586336,
1.3350024223,
-0.0502987653,
0.7482200861,
-0.1712658256,
-0.3750444055,
-0.0803421363,
-0.7728587389,
-1.0965870619,
-0.5901745558,
-0.3363272548,
-0.2562989891,
0.3403948843,
0.7783077359,
0.5916688442,
-0.5522217751,
-0.4224680364,
0.3089551926,
0.0495815463,
-0.2545641363,
-0.2596800029,
0.3074739277,
0.296875447,
-1.0155500174,
0.4833800793,
0.3544463217,
0.0162906814,
-0.7225615382,
-0.0603333153,
-0.3564068377,
-0.0233761072,
0.5899316669,
0.149334535,
-0.7355185151,
-0.5710680485,
-0.0352537446,
0.1020961404,
0.1677742004,
1.224237442,
-0.8370064497,
0.1663893759,
0.3316883445,
0.5388237834,
0.2434011996,
0.4204832613,
0.7965711951,
-0.1819051653,
0.0773793533,
0.3468921781,
-0.0036316344,
0.3141223788,
-0.3426654041,
0.2859279215,
0.242783621,
-0.7704101801,
-0.4445388615,
0.3120961785,
-0.5417614579,
-0.0957830846,
0.9238333702,
0.0638110712,
0.4684717655,
-0.4803390503,
-0.5819465518,
0.1500952393,
-1.0004791021,
0.7313668132,
1.0122792721,
-0.6110360622,
-0.0256799851,
-0.3793013394,
0.4653446376,
0.4006341696,
-0.9065931439,
-0.0813072473,
0.5607650876,
-0.069360204,
0.2144750506,
1.1457234621,
0.214828968,
0.1760803461,
-0.039453052,
-0.0000458054,
0.186821118,
-0.2396896929,
-0.2510854602,
0.0193675365,
-0.0188452192,
-0.3127321005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19643v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19643v1 | Unlocking Varied Perspectives: A Persona-Based Multi-Agent Framework with Debate-Driven Text Planning for Argument Generation | 2024-06-28T04:21:20 | 2024-06-28T04:21:20 | Zhe Hu, Hou Pong Chan, Jing Li, Yu Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Writing persuasive arguments is a challenging task for both humans and
machines. It entails incorporating high-level beliefs from various perspectives
on the topic, along with deliberate reasoning and planning to construct a
coherent narrative. Current language models often generate surface tokens
autoregressively, lacking explicit integration of these underlying controls,
resulting in limited output diversity and coherence. In this work, we propose a
persona-based multi-agent framework for argument writing. Inspired by the human
debate, we first assign each agent a persona representing its high-level
beliefs from a unique perspective, and then design an agent interaction process
so that the agents can collaboratively debate and discuss the idea to form an
overall plan for argument writing. Such debate process enables fluid and
nonlinear development of ideas. We evaluate our framework on argumentative
essay writing. The results show that our framework can generate more diverse
and persuasive arguments through both automatic and human evaluations. | [
-0.6930878162,
-0.5987663269,
0.8138468266,
0.2424824685,
0.0056768111,
0.2888530195,
0.1844407171,
0.0402989425,
0.2305372506,
0.6603063941,
-0.7825362682,
-0.3751943111,
-0.2090015411,
0.1781162024,
0.1977904588,
1.0581718683,
-0.119388856,
-0.1204975024,
-0.2658283114,
-0.3176649809,
-0.384483695,
-0.5759782195,
-0.6331806779,
-0.387452364,
0.9737523198,
0.7358142734,
0.4072004259,
0.3144220114,
0.0231729131,
0.3881075084,
0.5174806118,
0.2665593922,
-0.0607120059,
0.7303661704,
-0.571903646,
-0.215583235,
-0.1995940804,
0.0169741884,
0.6021165252,
0.4686273038,
0.1155134663,
-0.2745067775,
-0.3010733426,
0.2626542449,
-0.6410426497,
-0.3363695443,
-0.6116291285,
0.3206636012,
-0.2259232402,
-0.0993691087,
-0.4274277091,
-0.2885617614,
0.3551189601,
-0.4714616835,
-0.1154795066,
-0.0694226325,
0.7766280174,
-0.0831967071,
-0.5653728247,
-0.3507949114,
-0.6912274957,
0.5252034664,
-0.5523147583,
-0.2169485986,
-0.3352310658,
0.3023605347,
-0.1144510657,
-0.7674958706,
-0.6237129569,
0.1411230415,
0.1144507527,
0.2711037993,
-0.0899892002,
0.0375145636,
-0.1328938752,
-0.0652026981,
-0.3450921476,
0.0052112672,
0.3674612641,
-0.2240135819,
0.6465012431,
0.302082479,
0.145282805,
-0.1824783087,
-0.4741685688,
-0.1206536964,
-0.3396148086,
0.1700918227,
0.8643248081,
0.2480918616,
0.0233392343,
0.4730865955,
-0.0440134555,
0.2325120866,
0.5370497108,
-0.1846497506,
-0.2864134014,
-0.0203375798,
-0.1494082659,
-0.1408608258,
0.9442014098,
0.3399325609,
-0.1564026028,
-0.0787461102,
-0.046598956,
0.1146212444,
0.4364400804,
-0.8857837319,
-0.2127194107,
0.3390882313,
-0.4556145072,
-0.4534229338,
0.1070075333,
-1.1964102983,
-0.9080333114,
-0.090457432,
0.250343293,
-0.281365633,
-0.3338936567,
0.0804139748,
-0.4754189253,
0.287599057,
0.5435196757,
-0.7171835303,
0.3466095626,
0.4663435519,
0.2749820352,
-0.1407459378,
-0.6003007293,
-0.5951213241,
0.5115430355,
-0.3559457958,
1.4673637152,
-0.9376134276,
-0.3068653047,
0.0802636221,
-0.3348715603,
-0.1294537783,
-0.2844228446,
0.7225385308,
-0.0488293618,
0.6133264899,
-0.5515022874,
-0.4954584837,
0.1738556623,
0.2332519144,
-0.5227066278,
0.5605883002,
-0.1075279266,
-0.7139720321,
0.7262626886,
-1.0106421709,
-0.6070526838,
0.2981821597,
-0.5988188386,
-0.46476987,
0.0374411307,
0.1786336005,
0.4078043103,
-0.4487701952,
0.486458391,
-0.0666633993,
0.2165701836,
0.4304744899,
-0.4036205411,
0.4911898077,
0.2401061207,
-0.7144213915,
0.472979784,
-0.7555960417,
-0.0288171507,
-0.0762490183,
-0.4848959148,
0.0034276529,
0.3965849578,
-0.0387492627,
0.2688449919,
0.057491336,
-0.4838747084,
0.2096033096,
-0.3529871702,
0.4086206257,
0.7888384461,
0.3245004714,
0.512306571,
-0.6237935424,
0.7080231905,
0.231950298,
-0.3861728311,
-0.4375028312,
-0.5885129571,
-0.578405261,
-0.1701069623,
-0.1955039352,
0.3723404408,
-0.6503837705,
0.1650562584,
0.0439980961,
-0.4269928634,
-0.3982501626,
-0.1792221367,
0.3667677641,
0.4242660403,
-0.043972142,
-0.2200647593,
-0.5104170442,
-0.9948725104,
-0.6028780341,
-0.407289654,
0.1025368348,
0.399753511,
0.4054776728,
-0.1647320539,
1.1274375916,
-0.5317893624,
0.1803222746,
-0.5519535542,
0.6911848783,
-0.4535816908,
0.4979465604,
0.6109997034,
-0.6537724137,
-0.6163938046,
0.0568800494,
-0.5313628912,
-0.2629773319,
-0.892937243,
-0.590539217,
0.2114791721,
0.0328261591,
-0.6904872656,
0.3554599881,
-0.1466920972,
-0.584169805,
0.5145157576,
-0.0238002557,
0.1869897097,
-1.3672524691,
-0.0753975362,
0.1466727108,
-0.1729076207,
-0.5778600574,
0.1116239056,
-0.5442233086,
-0.2947560847,
-0.2161664218,
0.6147970557,
-0.1287007928,
0.5210728645,
-0.4543044567,
-0.025940666,
0.6224882603,
0.4671777785,
0.1751000136,
0.4112747908,
0.1580038071,
-0.193404898,
0.3095324337,
0.128920421,
0.1260741353,
1.1623674631,
-0.4121980965,
0.3929866552,
-0.2883336246,
0.5658522248,
-1.0091855526,
-0.4945614338,
0.4638504088,
-0.1149576232,
-0.0078621423,
0.0854814053,
-0.1430170387,
-0.1671682,
-0.3328205347,
-0.0074582044,
-0.2035173476,
-0.3268739283,
1.0956956148,
0.7134955525,
-0.4057588279,
-0.4813684821,
-0.4681519866,
0.5812929273,
-0.6117944121,
-0.7118237615,
0.6167294383,
-0.2480729818,
-0.5675295591,
-0.1107467711,
0.2057031691,
-0.2393605411,
-0.3242914975,
0.258459419,
-0.1943809688,
-0.2586366236,
0.1086345613,
0.5758644938,
0.0118457871,
0.1567598581,
-0.5533219576,
0.5000721216,
-0.2138993293,
-0.1952806115,
-0.1626918167,
1.2498530149,
0.6457639337,
-0.1796037406,
0.422326833,
0.2240306586,
-0.4234519303,
-0.4337710738,
-0.6914868355,
0.1005264595,
-0.4666440785,
0.2045906633,
-0.7620155811,
-0.482514143,
0.6122825146,
-0.3902381957,
0.5831246376,
0.4164993167,
0.9346781969,
0.0051047215,
0.6775904894,
0.3417643905,
0.4468311667,
0.1297370344,
0.1647599488,
0.1889131367,
-0.2336095572,
-0.2787873447,
-0.6092835069,
-0.379717797,
-0.1571464539,
-0.364774853,
-0.2406478524,
-0.4838178456,
-0.3971084356,
0.0279397983,
-0.675783515,
0.4557693005,
0.4575355947,
-0.3863104284,
0.0320751742,
-0.0757804364,
-0.571069479,
-0.3702526093,
-0.4682496488,
-1.0824538469,
0.8376911283,
0.1726983786,
0.2732087672,
0.0667923391,
0.730371058,
0.2987837493,
0.5016803741,
-0.5236708522,
0.6525549889,
0.1095054746,
-0.7630480528,
-0.163278982,
-0.1015042588,
-0.8757447004,
0.7812121511,
-0.2613818645,
-0.7552860379,
0.4411550462,
-0.133087337,
-0.5038815737,
0.4885596633,
-0.7056623101,
1.0823354721,
-0.244128406,
-0.6446921229,
0.0125745796,
-0.7153941989,
-0.0085668145,
0.2031716257,
-0.0986721516,
-0.0363178737,
-0.0373900011,
0.6037781239,
-0.4671966136,
0.7996351719,
-0.3001068234,
-0.3098682165,
0.6638336182,
-0.1120881215,
0.1049539447,
0.3033416867,
-0.26815027,
-0.5401428938,
-0.1076947078,
-0.2427098304,
-0.3945796192,
0.5815860629,
-0.7348561287,
-0.7114501595,
-0.3656116128,
-0.547285974,
-0.4011245966,
0.1751140356,
0.3364107311,
0.3409456313,
-0.741551578,
-0.1681057662,
0.3884705305,
-0.3393365443,
0.5426707864,
0.3473866284,
-0.0256356448,
-0.8113713264,
0.9908229709,
-0.0372015648,
-0.0673584715,
0.3838815391,
0.5164373517,
-0.3250000477,
-0.3315242529,
-0.6619064808,
-0.1418756694,
-0.8402009606,
-0.0316582285,
-0.7874806523,
0.0346957147,
-0.3600697815,
-0.6574460268,
-0.4194764793,
-0.4359508753,
-0.0635859296,
0.068209663,
-0.2604401112,
0.6885038018,
0.1440196782,
0.5355209112,
-0.2250588983,
0.3410481215,
0.4431844652,
0.0470614098,
-0.1136403009,
0.1827223748,
0.0208942555,
0.0007754528,
-1.0241111517,
-1.2425904274,
0.3635538816,
-0.1255359501,
0.6418259144,
0.5697008371,
0.067332752,
0.5163307786,
-0.4495769143,
0.8286480308,
0.3204262555,
-0.8928764462,
0.5634714961,
-0.5288283825,
0.2649698853,
0.7597721219,
-0.0328219645,
-0.4431057572,
-0.4601180553,
-0.6296578646,
-0.6871275902,
0.5368300676,
0.039606519,
0.1002746671,
0.1916471571,
0.3354947567,
0.635178864,
0.5606563687,
-0.9355013371,
0.1143131554,
-0.6138578057,
-0.2406213582,
0.3292536139,
0.072686702,
-0.5154221058,
-0.3493745923,
0.1837391704,
-0.4105802476,
0.1753531545,
0.1301659495,
0.2814676762,
-0.2580331564,
0.5245587826,
0.7088651061,
0.6273311377,
0.304725647,
0.2664863169,
-0.1372659355,
-0.2899149358,
0.4146150351,
0.246155709,
-0.241977796,
-0.0577068552,
0.1078220978,
0.8659867644,
-0.0381763764,
-0.472004503,
0.2889215052,
-0.4417388141,
-0.61238873,
-0.2495190352,
0.027527377,
0.5154210329,
0.3660641313,
0.3179964125,
0.4097866416,
-0.089223288,
-0.6030324101,
-0.0205874238,
0.3283728957,
0.0066240053,
-0.2689849138,
0.8366144896,
0.6178013682,
-0.5421394706,
-0.1151492894,
-0.2294369489,
-0.3151594102,
0.6338914037,
0.4750881195,
1.1974525452,
-0.1200087368,
0.799926877,
-0.0883210078,
0.0741695687,
0.3744677901,
0.3784424067,
0.0024014607,
-0.7223194838,
-0.1298271418,
-0.429925561,
-0.6000460386,
0.3586565256,
-0.0040553967,
0.1059174016,
-0.7862873673,
-0.1453011334,
0.3471356928,
0.4024927318,
-0.2846716642,
0.0818635151,
0.0091352947,
0.365719825,
-0.681620419,
0.4179683924,
1.1824609041,
-0.3038760424,
-0.5036228299,
0.6890323758,
-0.0031064069,
0.2299350053,
0.0196699239,
0.2486539781,
-0.5830532312,
-0.4367593825,
-0.6485899687,
-0.3859271407,
0.7824926972,
0.7724345326,
-0.0942440927,
-0.0140717914,
0.3195580244,
0.6015903354,
-1.1765164137,
-0.0040079532,
0.0719062537,
0.6763039231,
0.2098298967,
-0.0842311457,
0.0005926893,
-0.4028455019,
-0.1656958312,
-0.341188848,
-0.820112288,
1.0069352388,
-0.1353066713,
-0.1764746755,
-0.0298476685,
0.8700725436,
0.2410855144,
0.601688087,
0.345993191,
0.3140806854,
0.8700369596,
0.3706848323,
0.7495422959,
-0.0870566517,
-0.3920275271,
1.1316782236,
-0.7369410396,
0.5249663591,
0.3178238571,
0.2570671737,
0.9380021095,
0.3781094253,
0.2234450281,
0.2673950493,
0.1851675659,
-0.6190963984,
-0.5162739754,
-0.0743608847,
-0.0626875013,
0.4681807756,
0.2248362154,
0.0020221958,
-0.1551888138,
-0.050366994,
0.2228411287,
0.783597827,
0.2584228814,
0.7628241181,
-0.1842597276,
-1.1793210506,
-0.0448333323,
0.4625477195,
0.2731288671,
-0.3027118146,
0.0254064165,
-0.003715859,
0.1125080884,
-0.0765317529,
-0.7198504806,
0.0669626817,
0.1367186457,
-0.1524220854,
-0.5046570301,
0.9594199657,
-0.2996421456,
-0.4499978721,
-0.1145779788,
0.6956375837,
-0.187432006,
0.2221395373,
-0.6507068276,
-0.1539493501,
-0.1597437561,
-0.4441781938,
0.2911592126,
0.8524237275,
-0.0189675335,
0.3537207842,
0.335420996,
-0.1570328772,
-0.1515706778,
0.1590905339,
1.122449398,
-0.4128068388,
-0.6626660228,
-0.9174053669,
0.782826364,
-0.597890377,
-0.6989296675,
0.3191871047,
0.7135703564,
0.1869110316,
0.1353544146,
1.1882361174,
0.0280202404,
0.4868717194,
0.1743901074,
0.8545026183,
-0.2904982269,
-0.0402936488,
-0.5683250427,
-0.6413075328,
-0.0300689079,
0.8378798962,
-0.0987932831,
-0.0696779266,
0.70296067,
0.2389006466,
0.0982655957,
0.2047192901,
0.0512327626,
-0.1079672426,
0.8365235329,
0.7510761619,
1.0301066637,
0.006544922,
0.4315839112,
0.0408682264,
-0.2128481567,
0.1597255766,
-1.0090919733,
-1.20058918,
-0.8079354167,
-0.4885587394,
-0.1121878996,
-0.0569303483,
0.8145924211,
0.5672373176,
-0.3966510296,
-0.4860494435,
-0.3466249406,
0.2994694412,
0.0722153559,
-0.2601029873,
-0.1278712302,
-0.1892089695,
-0.7040836215,
0.3717825115,
0.496863991,
-0.2980237901,
-0.5820502639,
-0.2629874051,
-0.5092305541,
0.9029764533,
0.3875957429,
0.4139739275,
-0.650616467,
-0.3190145791,
-0.3349463642,
-0.1852037162,
0.3569259644,
1.1508420706,
-0.751827538,
0.3966112733,
0.3441926837,
0.7146618962,
0.299886167,
0.1756748557,
0.9814429283,
-0.5670060515,
0.18730627,
0.635091126,
0.1401178837,
0.3564472198,
-0.2648661435,
-0.1537618786,
0.225770697,
-0.5139584541,
-0.7119785547,
0.5794730783,
-0.7648083568,
-0.6942072511,
0.8631560802,
-0.2860091031,
0.0558754951,
-0.1633621901,
-0.646448195,
0.053084515,
-0.5658372045,
0.681355536,
1.0379269123,
-0.4894649386,
-0.1448952407,
0.0068375375,
0.5052969456,
0.4582900405,
-1.3368088007,
0.2669409215,
0.7787663341,
-0.0112684546,
0.248362422,
1.0109934807,
0.0673205778,
0.0973026305,
0.5252707005,
-0.1078178436,
0.3614516854,
-0.6906023622,
0.1789732277,
0.9438776374,
-0.0448574014,
0.2387970239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19642v1 | IDT: Dual-Task Adversarial Attacks for Privacy Protection | 2024-06-28T04:14:35 | 2024-06-28T04:14:35 | Pedro Faustini, Shakila Mahjabin Tonni, Annabelle McIver, Qiongkai Xu, Mark Dras | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Natural language processing (NLP) models may leak private information in
different ways, including membership inference, reconstruction or attribute
inference attacks. Sensitive information may not be explicit in the text, but
hidden in underlying writing characteristics. Methods to protect privacy can
involve using representations inside models that are demonstrated not to detect
sensitive attributes or -- for instance, in cases where users might not trust a
model, the sort of scenario of interest here -- changing the raw text before
models can have access to it. The goal is to rewrite text to prevent someone
from inferring a sensitive attribute (e.g. the gender of the author, or their
location by the writing style) whilst keeping the text useful for its original
intention (e.g. the sentiment of a product review). The few works tackling this
have focused on generative techniques. However, these often create extensively
different texts from the original ones or face problems such as mode collapse.
This paper explores a novel adaptation of adversarial attack techniques to
manipulate a text to deceive a classifier w.r.t one task (privacy) whilst
keeping the predictions of another classifier trained for another task
(utility) unchanged. We propose IDT, a method that analyses predictions made by
auxiliary and interpretable models to identify which tokens are important to
change for the privacy task, and which ones should be kept for the utility
task. We evaluate different datasets for NLP suitable for different tasks.
Automatic and human evaluations show that IDT retains the utility of text,
while also outperforming existing methods when deceiving a classifier w.r.t
privacy task. | [
-0.2413528264,
-0.882729888,
0.1196557283,
0.206150189,
-0.1555518806,
0.3086087406,
-0.1326987147,
-0.4453470111,
-0.2505066395,
0.6807975173,
-0.5662062168,
-0.4000751078,
-0.8937205076,
-0.0501254909,
-0.5780422091,
1.3089020252,
0.2137897164,
-0.1466649175,
-0.0617148615,
-0.0663240552,
-0.2974748015,
-0.7880148292,
-0.833602488,
-0.2375282496,
0.2851819098,
-0.0929121897,
0.9377784729,
0.3327187002,
0.6894956231,
0.2504237592,
-0.0730219483,
-0.0315139815,
-0.2259082049,
0.442038238,
-0.307541281,
-0.5242345929,
-0.18118155,
0.0724688768,
0.5405598879,
0.0782641023,
0.3431680501,
-0.0032092864,
0.4690871835,
0.7589951158,
-0.5888715982,
0.260209322,
-0.8331559896,
0.0988956243,
-0.2410758287,
-0.277361244,
-0.6215186715,
-0.0606666356,
0.1222573668,
-0.2074181736,
0.4717287123,
-0.1562184542,
0.7491479516,
0.6914709806,
-0.5229875445,
-0.1834411621,
-0.8728715181,
0.5370478034,
-0.5577023029,
-0.0355626903,
0.528673172,
0.0411869921,
-0.3015257418,
-0.6406911612,
-0.5450213552,
-0.4679567218,
-0.4086368084,
0.1026080102,
-0.3714762926,
0.2597205043,
0.4008030593,
0.3802340627,
-0.5563983321,
0.1909699589,
-0.0830664188,
-0.0452640578,
0.7562403083,
-0.1165391356,
0.3461984396,
-0.1817902178,
-0.8399825096,
-0.2420250475,
-0.6135837436,
0.0734875128,
0.7863841057,
0.1100570261,
-0.0399690084,
0.4668085277,
0.1075799763,
0.4561127722,
0.1169437096,
0.0323208012,
-0.275349319,
-0.2452809513,
-0.4296653271,
0.0282124821,
1.0092576742,
0.1328341216,
-0.1350908875,
-0.4811615646,
-0.0758611113,
0.3171831965,
0.4898617864,
-0.6011703014,
-0.441251874,
0.2412231565,
-0.3679256141,
-0.6777169704,
0.1800521463,
-0.9075283408,
-0.7525467873,
-0.3071198761,
0.5007514358,
-0.578337729,
-0.2700092196,
-0.0003401547,
-0.189494729,
-0.130286023,
-0.0704417676,
-0.9099729657,
0.5407434702,
0.98404181,
0.7651882172,
-0.0822723433,
-0.2047970742,
-0.2414607704,
0.1178939342,
0.1529407948,
0.3964971006,
-0.3154555857,
-0.4390604496,
-0.2040590048,
-0.1096063703,
-0.3651279509,
-0.1745381653,
0.6752349734,
-0.7141797543,
0.4538596272,
-0.0535442159,
-0.2988767624,
-0.4078134298,
0.5099497437,
-0.8886944056,
0.8576760888,
-0.068594791,
-1.2585242987,
0.2306981534,
-1.0312117338,
-0.470151931,
-0.1223845631,
-0.1009252071,
-0.6016199589,
-0.0038212894,
0.2302286476,
0.3649383783,
-0.0799321234,
0.0518544279,
-0.0190372374,
-0.1008674949,
0.4611927569,
-0.8559780121,
1.1674436331,
0.2109374404,
-0.6905644536,
0.18663688,
-0.5781965852,
-0.0915743709,
0.272772193,
-0.1628850549,
-0.6362285614,
-0.0531662852,
-0.0438866131,
-0.0016477319,
0.3517676592,
-0.6768419147,
0.2553330064,
-0.5891081095,
0.5761876702,
0.8779552579,
0.1396550387,
0.4982458055,
-0.4219655991,
0.6017241478,
-0.1281159222,
0.3124327362,
0.1121934056,
-0.6606301665,
-0.4208345413,
-0.215193525,
0.438542217,
0.693789959,
-0.8562552333,
0.2247342765,
-0.1781610847,
-0.3938404024,
-0.5405070782,
-0.0632537827,
0.7153636813,
0.2405948937,
0.144256413,
-0.053970471,
-0.3072064519,
-0.990739882,
-0.8127934337,
-0.1234006733,
0.1268796772,
-0.265804112,
0.461551249,
-0.2186224908,
0.7486568689,
-0.2908560038,
-0.416626513,
-0.0427500382,
0.3426966071,
-0.2466045022,
0.7274600267,
0.6423460841,
-1.3333491087,
-0.6366226673,
-0.1501695961,
-0.665332973,
0.3022951782,
-0.4362046123,
-0.1229645461,
0.1128362268,
0.2020740509,
-0.4775870442,
0.7302811146,
0.7144482136,
-0.5955948234,
0.3146097064,
-0.3451235592,
0.1133368537,
-1.1064405441,
-0.2243524492,
-0.0682795271,
-0.2526724339,
-0.7055298686,
0.5294151902,
0.112109445,
-0.2081754804,
-0.2349389941,
0.4748700857,
-0.4933569133,
0.3526828289,
-0.3758768737,
-0.3403604329,
0.1080655158,
0.5050367117,
-0.3785516024,
0.8944631815,
0.435963124,
-0.4616788626,
0.2868434787,
0.2910768092,
-0.0023366243,
0.5435901284,
-0.3458873034,
0.7164476514,
-0.294341445,
-0.1110564992,
-0.8082899451,
-0.1138783619,
0.552934587,
-0.5634824038,
0.6948564053,
-0.2491794527,
-0.8615383506,
-0.1002733037,
-0.5313580036,
0.0909002498,
0.2576469481,
-0.6832358241,
0.5319543481,
0.464104414,
0.0559573658,
-0.7164316177,
-0.9810547829,
0.6130461097,
-0.5264223218,
-0.686840415,
0.6501192451,
-0.1021965668,
-0.3653752208,
0.3480483592,
-0.0157021526,
-0.1922983676,
0.5401571393,
0.4267861545,
0.04201423,
0.1759259403,
0.0423317626,
0.091058597,
-0.274109304,
0.2952258587,
-0.208047539,
0.2995958924,
-0.0655384362,
-0.3031392395,
-0.7437488437,
0.686882019,
0.4619578719,
-0.2835159004,
0.9498108625,
0.5516399741,
-0.4760986567,
-0.2780856788,
-0.2709905207,
-0.2821731269,
-0.4320733845,
0.2098780423,
-0.4390944839,
-0.5013393164,
0.2705831826,
0.1833277643,
0.291148752,
0.2607448101,
0.3980722427,
0.03818487,
1.1417961121,
0.8576760292,
-0.0298070665,
0.5732392073,
-0.3335806131,
0.5316993594,
-0.8264000416,
-0.0936484188,
-0.3019033968,
-0.4736703634,
-0.7164674997,
-0.1265415102,
0.4096029401,
-0.2179446369,
0.032288719,
0.4512308538,
-0.9267651439,
0.3755859137,
0.9973622561,
0.4091032743,
0.3580580354,
0.0539561883,
0.4305763841,
-0.2090862542,
-0.3604923785,
-0.62463516,
1.3891642094,
0.2630735636,
0.6855178475,
0.3253627121,
0.7113634348,
0.6153944731,
0.3734616935,
-0.5241458416,
0.4864759445,
-0.6108393073,
-0.7334510684,
-0.1302029639,
-0.1733678579,
-0.852037549,
0.4453177154,
-0.0988855287,
-0.8318191171,
0.059842404,
0.0874462649,
-0.2833513618,
0.6545572877,
-0.8291523457,
0.8127003312,
-0.2670057118,
-0.3453231156,
-0.0399207361,
-0.695949018,
0.5894613862,
-0.1053114161,
-0.0830595791,
0.0628804639,
0.1600604653,
0.7966757417,
-0.1609294116,
1.0271992683,
-0.192472741,
0.1713103205,
0.0507174395,
0.2978003621,
0.6864932775,
0.2583155036,
-0.1171705648,
0.1185735166,
0.2442845255,
-0.1666216701,
-0.692306459,
0.7719751,
-0.5419316888,
-0.9613572955,
-0.7516059279,
-0.6435347795,
-0.1516084373,
0.0498848446,
0.4806203842,
0.2644911408,
-0.1479225904,
0.426897198,
0.7412359715,
0.0332830213,
0.2913515568,
0.0945783332,
0.2930485308,
-0.1777825654,
0.5689148903,
-0.0447084159,
0.432281673,
0.5503941774,
0.318349123,
-0.361685425,
-0.6559726596,
-0.3457985818,
0.0059651784,
-0.7412337065,
-0.2696252465,
-0.8118365407,
-0.2994717658,
-0.5688225627,
0.0259051491,
-0.1241480857,
-0.4553000927,
-0.3655962348,
-0.1225631982,
0.3807940781,
0.6684591174,
-0.0729385093,
0.4201403558,
-0.4710363448,
0.5188291073,
0.3401550651,
0.0248653982,
-0.345533967,
-0.2371541858,
0.1774692088,
0.139944762,
-0.3367393613,
-1.0611014366,
0.4320193529,
-0.0058955802,
0.3074642122,
0.0417651609,
0.461057961,
0.1535830796,
-0.1034216061,
0.7296578884,
-0.038575273,
-0.7633939385,
0.4442686439,
-0.1341998875,
0.0596590713,
0.5838598609,
0.0571191534,
-0.2938502729,
-0.5402131081,
-0.769565165,
-0.7308904529,
0.7039983869,
0.5242584348,
0.2579627931,
0.3243583441,
0.2726543248,
0.1851336658,
0.3250318468,
-0.9942656755,
-0.3840963542,
-0.2853997648,
-0.3998117447,
0.2846543193,
-0.4741014838,
-0.4666956663,
0.1438581049,
0.6759681702,
0.018465206,
0.1998274475,
0.0937236324,
0.1569460034,
0.2958863676,
0.4026519358,
0.1804595739,
0.2359196544,
0.0043525076,
0.1982353628,
-0.2901055813,
-0.7012385726,
0.1243785396,
0.5267967582,
-0.6413815022,
-0.0445330031,
0.0115006333,
0.5827883482,
0.0894573107,
-0.2335627228,
0.6712993979,
-0.3812202811,
-0.1419465989,
-0.5051620603,
-0.0205487572,
-0.3059520721,
0.2037292272,
0.0549149811,
0.5161677599,
0.2646991611,
-0.5297669172,
0.0467875972,
0.641115427,
-0.5226243734,
-0.4464906752,
1.1414215565,
-0.1340764314,
-0.416187346,
0.3027168214,
-0.475797385,
-0.6547227502,
0.5908806324,
0.5725479126,
1.407941103,
-0.3073535264,
0.2522988915,
0.0306343958,
0.6840009093,
0.0976871774,
0.1128328145,
-0.0702865049,
-0.4628237784,
0.0451278128,
-0.3030434549,
-0.2691860497,
0.2988563478,
-0.7696837783,
-0.0602633804,
-0.7301853299,
-0.2355808765,
0.0477175601,
-0.1720026881,
-0.6892543435,
0.1383461058,
0.0191836692,
0.4063630402,
-0.5155515075,
0.9362614155,
0.5881629586,
-0.2421778888,
-0.2420680225,
0.3962890208,
0.2616923153,
-0.5070237517,
0.6553524733,
0.0633717254,
-0.0789743215,
-0.213560909,
-0.2948167026,
-0.7923319936,
0.7791543007,
0.4910607338,
-0.2947250903,
-0.3522344828,
0.1360899508,
0.4173106253,
0.1461069435,
-0.5546097755,
0.5330965519,
0.3853454888,
-0.4728512764,
-0.7242890596,
0.3044710159,
-0.1055469885,
-0.067923151,
0.1915949136,
-0.5197890401,
1.017128706,
0.0572663434,
-0.6231445074,
-0.0097831646,
0.4122337997,
-0.2111661136,
0.3128405213,
0.6213790774,
0.4677071273,
0.6566252708,
-0.1298730969,
1.2082314491,
-0.2889610827,
0.2763527036,
1.3068680763,
-0.0234516114,
0.3973739147,
0.2590107024,
-0.1281863749,
0.2487464696,
0.1633616686,
0.0039454303,
0.7641671896,
0.002615178,
-0.6388203502,
0.2790688574,
0.1089830622,
-0.2555561066,
0.5980474949,
0.4774754941,
-0.3999461532,
-0.1186139882,
0.310628593,
0.5047877431,
0.5644163489,
0.0435376391,
0.8987195492,
0.0207257699,
-0.6085627675,
0.2278188467,
0.284612447,
0.7679537535,
-0.6480243206,
0.0869140476,
0.3078289926,
0.5081940293,
-0.1331684589,
-0.6961737871,
0.5598328114,
0.0657645911,
-0.244231388,
-0.6088628769,
0.7688593268,
-0.2557758093,
-0.3275338411,
0.2864014208,
-0.1187498719,
-0.3266849518,
-0.563467145,
-1.085714221,
-0.2781987786,
0.2595848739,
-0.3307546377,
0.4875556231,
0.2617456615,
0.042341359,
0.4604554772,
0.706810832,
-0.0057926751,
0.1140820757,
-0.1430489719,
0.7415762544,
-0.4799987376,
-0.8431851268,
-1.0719063282,
0.406902343,
-0.3675337136,
-0.1627339572,
1.0149562359,
0.3810912669,
0.7967237234,
0.0890656188,
1.1050405502,
0.0351077504,
0.6268010736,
-0.7239274979,
0.8385741711,
-0.1136940867,
0.3253494799,
0.0167534649,
-0.4979876578,
-0.4193432927,
0.1141273752,
-0.4411388636,
-0.3238375187,
0.8048509359,
0.5847338438,
0.0388436876,
0.209576726,
0.23261711,
0.2145166248,
0.7759606242,
0.4168862104,
0.6460443735,
-0.6763660312,
0.536601603,
-0.8084134459,
-0.162178129,
0.0326680504,
-0.7328235507,
-0.9592860937,
-0.6463425756,
-0.5844953656,
-0.4290424585,
0.1682375222,
0.3933655024,
0.5451093316,
-0.6507405043,
0.3437347412,
-0.0571488477,
0.0700144172,
-0.4025713801,
-0.2812753022,
0.6556608677,
-0.0426951125,
-0.9178650975,
0.5054414272,
0.3224425018,
0.1754719019,
-0.5238136053,
0.5713885427,
-0.147050336,
-0.166910857,
0.2842104733,
0.3128137887,
-0.7667099237,
-0.300209105,
-0.3343223035,
-0.0152153028,
-0.0205851421,
0.8862220645,
-0.6855921745,
0.7915171981,
0.3724050522,
0.8540657163,
0.1878683418,
0.1437256187,
0.4585124254,
-0.948759675,
0.5281364322,
0.7014023662,
0.2832565308,
0.53013134,
-1.0474944115,
0.4195807874,
0.1387266964,
-0.4785496294,
-0.9475639462,
0.4345350266,
-0.6645060778,
-0.4985084236,
0.8983336687,
-0.2984052598,
-0.2502602935,
-0.3193422556,
-0.362277776,
0.0324286371,
-0.1840911657,
1.0086326599,
0.448415637,
0.1481777579,
0.1644299924,
-0.7276310325,
0.7978132367,
0.1659239084,
-0.5830621719,
0.230423972,
-0.1107708737,
0.1546541452,
0.1287833303,
0.4832445383,
-0.3072503805,
0.0085137459,
0.1221547574,
-0.3943609297,
-0.2426030934,
-0.1964966804,
-0.4447374344,
0.4123458564,
-0.048781544,
-0.6218795776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19598v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19598v1 | Mixture of In-Context Experts Enhance LLMs' Long Context Awareness | 2024-06-28T01:46:41 | 2024-06-28T01:46:41 | Hongzhan Lin, Ang Lv, Yuhan Chen, Chen Zhu, Yang Song, Hengshu Zhu, Rui Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many studies have revealed that large language models (LLMs) exhibit uneven
awareness of different contextual positions.Their limited context awareness can
lead to overlooking critical information and subsequent task failures. While
several approaches have been proposed to enhance LLMs' context awareness,
achieving both effectiveness and efficiency remains challenging.In this paper,
for LLMs utilizing RoPE as position embeddings, we introduce a novel method
called ``Mixture of In-Context Experts'' (MoICE) to address this challenge.
MoICE comprises two key components: a router integrated into each attention
head within LLMs and a lightweight router-only training optimization strategy:
(1) MoICE views each RoPE angle as an `in-context' expert, demonstrated to be
capable of directing the attention of a head to specific contextual positions.
Consequently, each attention head flexibly processes tokens using multiple RoPE
angles dynamically selected by the router to attend to the needed positions.
This approach mitigates the risk of overlooking essential contextual
information. (2) The router-only training strategy entails freezing LLM
parameters and exclusively updating routers for only a few steps. When applied
to open-source LLMs including Llama and Mistral, MoICE surpasses prior methods
across multiple tasks on long context understanding and generation, all while
maintaining commendable inference efficiency. | [
-0.5445863008,
-0.5253634453,
0.4895606637,
0.2463314235,
-0.3606783152,
0.2233168185,
-0.3377449811,
-0.388653785,
0.2941249311,
0.3310904801,
-0.319085598,
-0.5045212507,
-0.5010355711,
-0.0551972874,
-0.2519824207,
0.8237846494,
-0.025369361,
-0.1399134994,
-0.2675053477,
-0.5634112358,
-0.6062193513,
-0.4583950639,
-0.6461102962,
-0.3764291704,
0.5668045282,
0.5747211576,
0.2955331802,
0.4181959927,
0.1165852547,
0.2970429063,
-0.1635505706,
0.4481466413,
-0.6203834414,
0.1314071715,
-0.3448008597,
-0.1742301881,
-0.5614863634,
-0.2097371668,
0.5695377588,
0.7507478595,
-0.1867531985,
-0.1521234214,
0.4464334548,
0.776638031,
-1.0592312813,
-0.409715116,
-0.836866796,
0.0673631132,
-0.1653085649,
-0.3108430505,
-0.3303069472,
0.1940731704,
0.3842792511,
-0.4955125451,
-0.0166360214,
0.0911159888,
0.1985074282,
0.3517177701,
-0.7542191148,
0.0099073015,
-0.503002286,
0.9852057099,
-0.58185637,
0.5939026475,
0.2587271333,
0.2029435635,
-0.3454128206,
-0.3570403457,
-0.4212879539,
0.0735740662,
0.0751635805,
0.2171873897,
0.3108106554,
0.0247756764,
0.0577555671,
0.0427180752,
-0.2052226067,
0.0969605818,
-0.0061177746,
0.0145075563,
0.5061488152,
-0.0698203072,
0.0499799252,
0.1812618077,
-0.7098926306,
0.2925216854,
-0.6477755308,
0.1764663011,
-0.0433924384,
-0.2193627656,
-0.2405986935,
0.4292368591,
-0.2777655721,
0.8339901567,
0.4035100043,
-0.4972294867,
0.1792712659,
0.0915979221,
-0.2293384671,
0.3172838092,
0.5425351262,
0.2607278526,
0.0428936481,
-0.1710689366,
-0.362564683,
-0.5635623932,
0.0768742859,
-0.3669933975,
-0.1768859774,
0.1942455918,
-0.0743973851,
-0.1680905521,
0.0313832834,
-0.4916902184,
-0.5715182424,
-0.3063547611,
0.3566857874,
-0.4525925219,
-0.1569899917,
0.176509127,
-0.0701279491,
0.2441415787,
0.5021182299,
-0.7747632265,
0.1171024218,
0.8239710331,
0.7154803276,
-0.24034293,
-0.2335762233,
-0.9198086262,
0.7248559594,
-0.1011126041,
0.674888432,
-0.4284296632,
-0.3492287993,
-0.0623632371,
-0.2571228445,
-0.223688513,
-0.3359077275,
0.3925602138,
-0.6342672706,
0.2270047367,
-0.0611109585,
-0.6376123428,
-0.3479828537,
0.3561287224,
-0.3589941561,
1.1908289194,
0.2415186316,
-1.0688760281,
0.321813345,
-0.4017994702,
-0.4975212216,
0.0372781754,
-0.4467793405,
0.0280040223,
0.2243824601,
0.4824771285,
0.4498231411,
0.0765829459,
0.1163640022,
-0.0724054426,
-0.302208066,
0.4701900184,
-0.1804330647,
0.4349376559,
-0.1593925357,
-0.4333701432,
0.1699577123,
-0.5899252295,
-0.1877321899,
-0.3764638305,
-0.4939079583,
-0.7069138885,
0.1685587168,
-0.0491687506,
0.2464494407,
0.2921746969,
-0.3309460878,
-0.1599195749,
-0.4544815719,
0.2416137755,
0.8134068847,
0.1278092414,
0.6245532036,
-0.2496939003,
0.3562637866,
0.1810098886,
-0.1962529719,
-0.1044536456,
-0.3096593618,
-1.1003222466,
-0.5432530642,
0.0290291365,
0.5535166264,
-0.8003309369,
0.8374222517,
-0.4144423306,
-0.1929610223,
-0.1800917387,
0.5586690307,
0.4087961614,
0.888938725,
0.246980384,
-0.3264477551,
-0.3660367429,
-0.7675900459,
-0.2094521075,
0.231997937,
-0.2048021555,
0.3320064247,
0.3240768909,
-0.1597065926,
1.1592826843,
-0.3838657141,
-0.223695159,
-0.3017077148,
-0.2200828046,
0.2756820023,
0.5952528715,
0.3363654912,
-0.7200317383,
-0.6973946691,
0.0989047661,
-0.7298086286,
0.1744181067,
-0.1629937589,
-0.3426404297,
0.2139347345,
0.5306276083,
-0.2613756359,
0.0450391844,
0.470480144,
0.1101616696,
0.1696565449,
-0.1923443824,
-0.1991475821,
-1.1580262184,
-0.0052352026,
0.2220968008,
-0.4414631724,
-0.6938817501,
-0.0576052181,
0.2591977417,
0.1451916993,
-0.6137319207,
0.6752539873,
-0.6109825969,
0.1416996717,
-0.1602425426,
0.5198536515,
-0.024972396,
0.6911544204,
0.051831115,
0.7212333083,
0.6438606977,
-0.6432380676,
0.067311056,
0.1759947091,
-0.4313468039,
0.9437935948,
-0.4720621109,
0.5053331256,
-0.0897280648,
0.4118105769,
-0.8639446497,
-0.454000026,
0.272583425,
-0.1485956311,
0.423599273,
-0.2433159351,
-0.1612972021,
-0.1129056737,
-0.5480726361,
0.655092001,
0.2218372673,
-0.5207569599,
0.7104813457,
0.5148438811,
-0.0012270076,
-0.8826408982,
-0.7073933482,
0.1832317412,
-0.515286386,
-0.7206663489,
0.4550790191,
-0.0304819234,
-0.1470859945,
-0.3104999363,
-0.4961813092,
-0.0469525158,
0.081814371,
-0.056955494,
-0.0341900811,
-0.1748161316,
0.08561223,
0.1159099936,
-0.2693034708,
-0.0709424764,
-0.5741312504,
0.3310274184,
0.0362215601,
-0.5859741569,
-0.5365226269,
0.492302984,
0.4406126738,
-0.340457648,
0.660409987,
0.5087762475,
-0.1816447973,
-0.3000382185,
-0.9665876627,
-0.1292389631,
-0.5489906073,
0.436901927,
-0.3022557199,
-1.0243480206,
0.4585356712,
-0.1585273743,
-0.0862370953,
-0.0681396872,
0.2388250083,
-0.2775132954,
0.723398149,
0.8018060327,
-0.5069358945,
0.7156115174,
-0.2166311592,
0.2371925116,
-1.2659199238,
-0.3263709843,
-0.1530617476,
-0.5102366209,
-0.3202996552,
-0.6363623142,
1.0309401751,
0.2918885946,
-0.3315421939,
-0.0187149085,
-0.3259451985,
0.6730299592,
0.4608168006,
0.5279390216,
0.1503315866,
0.1559789628,
-0.1559562087,
0.1855014116,
-0.9394360781,
-0.2719420195,
0.8850346804,
0.2655621171,
0.6818348169,
-0.0363359004,
0.6942369342,
-0.0588878095,
0.0164860338,
-0.7968934178,
0.6084541082,
0.1391522139,
-0.2717112601,
-0.1238539591,
-0.0965711325,
-0.5113292933,
0.3791767657,
-0.0939356461,
-0.8617830873,
0.2558999956,
0.1052491441,
-0.422111094,
0.2984427512,
-0.1783294678,
0.554775238,
-0.2870717645,
-0.5372688174,
-0.364726156,
-0.9605771899,
0.3051817417,
-0.2004817724,
0.3385688663,
-0.0775613561,
-0.4676928222,
0.6183871031,
-0.2115287185,
0.8831802011,
-0.0927760452,
-0.325098753,
0.4221671224,
0.1174273267,
0.7527359724,
0.160823375,
-0.1287450045,
0.0104743876,
-0.7388691902,
-0.4106087983,
-0.5079729557,
0.8207775354,
-0.6238768697,
-0.6926301122,
-0.1619218886,
-0.6677391529,
-0.4404255152,
0.0586631969,
0.0478728898,
0.6325349808,
0.002061672,
0.4892206788,
0.9528520107,
0.0086123003,
0.5528293848,
0.2861868441,
0.3060210645,
-0.7091976404,
0.5331817865,
-0.1636067629,
0.2340486944,
0.6634550691,
0.1104526669,
-0.0556292646,
-0.5034512877,
-0.2893592119,
0.0296322983,
-0.8909003139,
-0.1672976315,
-0.7945343256,
-0.1344917268,
0.0094896313,
-0.7516471148,
-0.2524380684,
-0.3649483323,
-0.2705845833,
0.0477660671,
0.2972233593,
0.341670543,
0.0757412165,
0.6277734041,
-0.7649925351,
0.036907617,
0.4445712268,
0.0837951005,
0.1083267331,
-0.4036509991,
-0.5431298018,
0.0976381451,
-0.3101060688,
-0.6822357178,
0.2066588253,
0.2544051707,
0.8856536746,
0.7029421329,
-0.0799701288,
0.6023080945,
-0.3866764903,
0.6990494132,
0.2084957659,
-1.0985406637,
0.3894692361,
-0.5770132542,
0.204548955,
0.6361517906,
0.2934579849,
-0.4800828695,
-0.4456994534,
-0.2136212885,
-0.9814238548,
0.6022588015,
0.0468648486,
0.084892951,
0.0929168016,
0.2475557476,
0.0414335057,
0.2335677296,
-0.449118942,
0.0201433469,
-0.0026385565,
-0.331148237,
-0.0343397856,
-0.3597009182,
-0.4594025612,
-0.3380722404,
0.4474372566,
-0.3178416789,
-0.0465987548,
0.2865689099,
-0.3824302554,
-0.0240666158,
0.0864591226,
0.7953062654,
0.9234248996,
-0.1227973551,
0.359982878,
0.788752377,
-0.193065539,
0.1597214341,
-0.4161824584,
-0.0276524108,
-0.1544154137,
0.4746853113,
0.5808103085,
0.8505631089,
-0.3905158639,
0.4715283215,
0.4562595189,
0.1597511321,
-0.3199016154,
0.244263798,
0.1597343683,
0.308578819,
0.5547255278,
0.2077578753,
-0.0068545491,
-0.0392715782,
0.1728495061,
0.4054479003,
-0.3756724298,
-0.19766666,
0.4792514741,
0.577740252,
-0.2077740133,
0.1923622936,
0.0843945518,
-0.6621845961,
0.4520972967,
0.4450027049,
1.0191676617,
-0.2894837558,
-0.1479131728,
0.003330356,
-0.0279875714,
-0.0294863638,
0.0691430047,
-0.2476015091,
-0.8193711042,
-0.32259202,
-0.3010632694,
-0.3569959104,
-0.2227564901,
-0.4284016192,
0.3068930209,
-0.2322680205,
-0.0265961196,
-0.4704740345,
-0.2211182117,
-0.5080390573,
0.1433005482,
0.0840821862,
0.8736557364,
-0.4737361372,
0.9214331508,
0.8499749899,
0.0732724965,
-0.4008723497,
0.3275641203,
0.0570591092,
-0.6551328301,
0.4826486409,
0.3602488935,
-0.60679847,
0.1110580936,
-0.4506609142,
-0.7463501692,
1.2217109203,
0.1874454319,
-0.4497831166,
0.1876822412,
-0.0353922024,
0.1961035877,
-0.6672637463,
0.1940493286,
0.210535109,
0.2828787863,
0.1659957618,
-0.6757361293,
-0.0300822165,
0.1335983425,
0.1994947046,
-0.0185410064,
-0.7867207527,
0.5569159389,
-0.0163458623,
0.030861374,
-0.2881359458,
0.9568847418,
0.5029907823,
0.3390625715,
0.791264832,
0.3256512284,
0.7795550823,
0.5483531952,
0.8204424381,
-0.6431722641,
0.0900318772,
1.1289961338,
-0.2448677272,
0.7920081615,
0.6805055141,
0.2594850659,
0.5402386785,
0.5621969104,
0.5359716415,
0.8135218024,
-0.0628024563,
-0.6407221556,
-0.4204333723,
-0.1248134077,
-0.3529061079,
0.3314928114,
0.3763224185,
-0.1427859366,
-0.234210521,
0.1196108833,
0.2091523111,
-0.0122470232,
-0.3183752596,
0.7192112207,
0.295461297,
-0.4680543542,
0.6123500466,
0.0464663133,
0.8899735212,
-0.4936181009,
0.3241230547,
-0.3086172044,
0.2838874161,
-0.1930276304,
-0.7335982919,
-0.0510856546,
-0.1284066588,
0.0628905371,
-0.1294130981,
0.7428039312,
-0.6037260294,
-0.4640993178,
0.2382558584,
0.5224553347,
-0.0866215527,
-0.2822821736,
-0.3056029081,
-0.1370197386,
-0.0789819136,
-0.3388077319,
0.3820035756,
0.7090329528,
-0.0601480082,
0.7591750622,
0.3318535388,
-0.2794904113,
-0.0908173546,
-0.1694691777,
1.2233729362,
-0.4681589603,
-0.4799504876,
-0.8890356421,
0.7479918003,
-0.1958392859,
-0.3434149921,
0.6791012287,
0.5106283426,
0.902530849,
-0.0177139044,
0.6246078014,
0.2990792096,
0.063668713,
-0.5756807923,
0.7273083925,
-0.6701350808,
0.1826215535,
-0.2407595366,
-1.0063076019,
-0.1488304287,
0.6116804481,
-0.2580243945,
0.0919876248,
0.6954542398,
0.6950668097,
-0.4789421856,
-0.1810798049,
0.2378502488,
-0.0158333853,
0.228478685,
0.8123772144,
0.7859783173,
-0.0044788648,
0.1680296659,
-0.3945609927,
-0.3257567883,
-0.4679898024,
-1.1278511286,
-1.069360733,
-0.2814871371,
-0.3017019033,
0.0954225659,
0.0367174409,
1.1323367357,
0.8762992024,
-0.6423844695,
-0.382534802,
0.0620191507,
0.174672991,
-0.1860483885,
-0.1185444295,
0.3497441411,
-0.4296903908,
-0.4943236113,
0.8553471565,
0.4828313291,
-0.2259818763,
-0.2472269237,
-0.1407422274,
-0.3002125621,
0.0396224335,
0.6512140036,
-0.1455812156,
-0.7095204592,
-0.4925585389,
-0.1619433761,
-0.1649024934,
0.2885247171,
0.745053947,
-0.7561329603,
0.3898073137,
0.7100630999,
0.5862603784,
0.379221648,
0.2664118707,
0.7123887539,
-1.0723632574,
0.4956496656,
0.156276077,
0.4137565494,
0.4613976777,
-0.4270596802,
0.5791250467,
0.1446951479,
-0.4722065926,
-0.5055553317,
0.1223524958,
-1.2143521309,
-0.0633349866,
1.146538496,
-0.2007319033,
-0.1594274789,
-0.1755677015,
-0.3590151966,
0.1526466161,
-0.4677095115,
0.6834304333,
0.4304241836,
-0.0218145568,
-0.0211757105,
-0.6937465072,
0.2656950951,
0.5638619661,
-0.5656582713,
-0.2481715232,
0.3021114767,
0.3900630474,
-0.0743860826,
0.5558105707,
0.3898209035,
-0.1775266677,
-0.4784478545,
-0.0626154467,
-0.1270205826,
-0.4875341952,
-0.2164276689,
0.131395638,
-0.1132905334,
-0.3009902537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19593v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19593v1 | SK-VQA: Synthetic Knowledge Generation at Scale for Training Context-Augmented Multimodal LLMs | 2024-06-28T01:14:43 | 2024-06-28T01:14:43 | Xin Su, Man Luo, Kris W Pan, Tien Pei Chou, Vasudev Lal, Phillip Howard | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Synthetic data generation has gained significant attention recently for its
utility in training large vision and language models. However, the application
of synthetic data to the training of multimodal context-augmented generation
systems has been relatively unexplored. This gap in existing work is important
because existing vision and language models (VLMs) are not trained specifically
for context-augmented generation. Resources for adapting such models are
therefore crucial for enabling their use in retrieval-augmented generation
(RAG) settings, where a retriever is used to gather relevant information that
is then subsequently provided to a generative model via context augmentation.
To address this challenging problem, we generate SK-VQA: a large synthetic
multimodal dataset containing over 2 million question-answer pairs which
require external knowledge to determine the final answer. Our dataset is both
larger and significantly more diverse than existing resources of its kind,
possessing over 11x more unique questions and containing images from a greater
variety of sources than previously-proposed datasets. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate that our synthetic dataset can not only serve as a
challenging benchmark, but is also highly effective for adapting existing
generative multimodal models for context-augmented generation. | [
-0.5877443552,
-0.4449463487,
0.6220257878,
0.0021850704,
-0.1924984008,
0.2110498399,
-0.1075700447,
-0.4022342563,
0.1260933131,
0.5991278887,
-0.7686533928,
-0.012719579,
-0.1700150818,
0.2172077149,
-0.3044763803,
0.7370516658,
0.091495797,
0.3554244339,
-0.6745983958,
-0.3797592223,
-0.3906835616,
-0.6748270988,
-0.2233035117,
0.0408726819,
0.5338156819,
0.2596178651,
0.2049104422,
0.2822216451,
0.2188842595,
0.3194600046,
0.1435709447,
0.7457093,
-0.5259832144,
0.4180157483,
-0.3058747649,
-0.4615396559,
-0.1197190806,
-0.1588367373,
0.7381972671,
0.4827074409,
0.140132308,
0.4716494083,
-0.3176314235,
0.6030341983,
-0.757646203,
-0.0648922846,
-1.1190903187,
0.0001438722,
0.0335466042,
-0.2461995333,
-0.3289828897,
-0.1988296807,
0.1543670893,
-0.8553690314,
0.4209275842,
0.0767087564,
0.6642414331,
0.3118671179,
-0.9628768563,
-0.1883167177,
-0.7463124394,
0.7128582597,
-0.3145093918,
0.5172124505,
0.0208970644,
0.6866012216,
-0.2416388392,
-1.001454711,
-1.0437961817,
-0.2074552476,
0.0981951356,
0.2908149958,
0.2013380527,
-0.0285101812,
0.479870975,
0.3039322495,
-0.3996475339,
-0.4544796944,
-0.733961165,
-0.2978972495,
0.6359393001,
0.3502087891,
0.0680133104,
-0.4930293858,
-0.6215482354,
-0.410623759,
-0.767246902,
0.0622521527,
0.1312526017,
0.195809707,
0.1394104809,
1.0679033995,
-0.5619653463,
0.8215906024,
0.0662555769,
-0.2074441314,
0.3662189841,
-0.8234383464,
-0.0231260341,
-0.2380019277,
0.4721231461,
0.55515939,
-0.0076449169,
0.0603055581,
-0.084788084,
0.1452388316,
0.6634928584,
-0.708722353,
-0.214679122,
-0.0720947087,
0.1636315435,
-0.2455106229,
-0.1234367192,
-0.6669871211,
-0.4258422554,
-0.7185938358,
0.7268303037,
-0.281958282,
-0.1887187362,
-0.2120663375,
-0.3619462848,
0.5075986385,
0.4359357357,
-0.5753200054,
-0.1608314216,
0.17489779,
0.5363481045,
-0.2376398593,
-0.038445022,
-0.3444775045,
0.29278633,
-0.5708695054,
0.7425091863,
-0.2813257575,
-0.3516196907,
-0.0809537768,
0.1375621408,
0.1111307368,
-0.6295081377,
0.2657520771,
-0.55683285,
0.1533642858,
-0.4959773719,
-0.2069836706,
-0.0453887507,
0.611335218,
-0.7082721591,
1.2257406712,
0.5520161986,
-0.6134265065,
0.7285537124,
-0.3443902433,
-0.1278281063,
0.264598459,
-0.4892127216,
-0.146042034,
0.3562879562,
0.3656765223,
0.2633181214,
-0.4134350419,
0.1684038043,
-0.2021136433,
0.0356854014,
0.3224222362,
-0.3102122843,
0.3445644379,
0.0885751322,
-0.0708606541,
0.1052241623,
-1.1284748316,
0.5137844086,
0.0971295163,
-0.5738748908,
-0.472094059,
-0.2998969853,
0.0737812445,
0.5446101427,
0.2206112593,
-0.6160334349,
0.266109556,
-0.3555473089,
0.2021104395,
0.7959059477,
0.1373298764,
0.5063615441,
-0.3917824626,
0.5224440098,
0.1250553876,
-0.0163607709,
-0.1702926457,
-0.3084169924,
-0.7727975249,
-0.2750096023,
0.1718733013,
0.2556194961,
-1.5521198511,
-0.212541908,
-0.4214437902,
-0.524312377,
-0.4922855496,
0.1912603378,
0.3012466729,
0.6571403742,
0.3409540355,
-0.1691382229,
-0.8761349916,
-1.0151463747,
-0.0402096547,
-0.0450799242,
-0.2249017656,
0.7116507888,
0.4930002987,
-0.3673622012,
1.2568339109,
-0.3931798339,
0.0445896313,
-0.2022809386,
-0.0788749158,
-0.1953084022,
0.3644118607,
0.5911918879,
-1.1846485138,
-0.434248507,
-0.0794535354,
-0.7488746643,
0.0355060063,
-0.259614706,
-0.2524385452,
0.2098232657,
0.3914531767,
-0.5469760895,
0.1527173668,
0.7127655745,
-0.0682403892,
0.8502311707,
-0.3584814966,
0.2372599244,
-1.5103993416,
-0.0071949847,
-0.1835503131,
-0.1817967445,
-0.648413837,
0.1582207233,
0.2324513942,
-0.1067848429,
-0.6361095905,
0.8227204084,
-0.3581492901,
-0.1641852409,
-0.1743215472,
0.0481533706,
0.1507518589,
0.5006097555,
0.1651013345,
1.0026161671,
0.3769143522,
-0.6795780659,
0.6444084048,
0.3655259907,
-0.4274463654,
0.7553685904,
-0.4731516838,
0.1827706099,
-0.1256949306,
0.3720826507,
-1.0274062157,
-0.8369411826,
0.0280999318,
-0.4292719662,
-0.0194951314,
-0.1146027967,
-0.3682580888,
-0.3613404632,
-0.18702434,
0.8482645154,
0.4909834266,
-0.9727156758,
0.8863717914,
0.3768110871,
-0.0395521298,
-0.5409473777,
-0.451762259,
-0.0432616062,
-0.1518003196,
-0.7144842744,
0.3363596201,
-0.2311134934,
-0.1727769375,
-0.2037670165,
-0.3102476299,
-0.0679118857,
-0.2914675474,
0.2885319889,
0.2493239343,
-0.1934934855,
0.2027423978,
0.2539951205,
0.1742837876,
0.1265789419,
-0.0443660393,
0.5114471912,
0.1265607178,
-0.2996648252,
0.0931527987,
0.3075684905,
0.799649775,
-0.1017460302,
0.8130725026,
0.6839423776,
-0.2866939604,
-0.5248095989,
-0.5413058996,
-0.1614564955,
-0.5150213242,
0.3833749592,
-0.5422644019,
-0.8925667405,
0.3459692299,
-0.4489446878,
-0.0605777353,
0.3468166888,
0.7932168245,
-0.2131256759,
1.1873964071,
0.4699672461,
0.4663364291,
0.2764076293,
-0.3629572392,
-0.0940123945,
-1.0780258179,
-0.5296646953,
-0.0757757649,
-0.168495357,
-0.6753809452,
-0.7683485746,
0.7946364284,
0.0043746512,
-0.1008926779,
0.2278037667,
-0.3548324406,
0.3378859162,
0.7530583739,
0.3134001195,
0.0536691174,
0.1251167059,
-0.2660415471,
-0.0291259997,
-0.8290098906,
-0.1723207235,
1.3976684809,
-0.284148097,
0.5412925482,
0.001963028,
0.3981249332,
0.1411888897,
0.1933909357,
-0.6238732338,
0.6507321596,
0.1151596606,
-0.8192629814,
-0.2050909102,
-0.5552406907,
-0.5776923895,
0.4220503271,
-0.6611633897,
-0.223193422,
0.174715057,
0.3482710719,
-0.2267783731,
0.0449934937,
-0.6751597524,
0.5190355182,
-0.2263440192,
-0.3366817832,
0.0108141303,
-0.5897941589,
0.6335545778,
-0.4493881464,
0.0948631316,
0.1826630831,
0.020509392,
0.3857817948,
-0.3729871809,
0.5808697939,
-0.1610174477,
-0.1577896476,
0.4136330187,
-0.078839466,
0.4369389117,
0.3036132455,
0.2780842483,
-0.1710165143,
0.0824708939,
-0.3228951693,
-0.6268698573,
0.6715228558,
-0.6843619347,
-0.4943096042,
-0.3263776898,
-0.9284743667,
-0.5472185016,
0.0099545978,
0.3812368214,
0.5664255619,
0.0238388367,
0.5447179079,
0.5862329006,
-0.4721512198,
-0.1139847636,
0.1823448539,
-0.2033427209,
-0.6764153838,
1.057641387,
0.0918159336,
0.6127682924,
-0.0405168533,
-0.0690919235,
-0.4482996166,
-0.316880703,
-0.7121762037,
0.0041086306,
-0.7617411017,
-0.2577496171,
-0.5982222557,
-0.4594907165,
-0.3356446028,
-0.173662141,
-0.2609079182,
-0.6344290376,
0.0150126647,
-0.0762472823,
0.4460197389,
0.578260541,
-0.1381426603,
0.1738522202,
-0.6471734047,
0.8734903932,
0.7506281734,
0.0485691838,
-0.3190465569,
-0.4219644964,
-0.1720320284,
0.3931490481,
-0.2160366774,
-0.6051719785,
0.4016508162,
0.3502054811,
0.501698494,
-0.1551386565,
0.2761876285,
0.8224142194,
-0.590521574,
1.0097458363,
0.1442605555,
-0.4195460975,
0.4454674423,
-0.3659447134,
0.4246494174,
0.4486413896,
0.3613992631,
-0.2475036383,
-0.1797015518,
-0.4391383827,
-1.0498396158,
0.6195732355,
0.1791445166,
0.3654016852,
0.0216906257,
0.4858064651,
0.2069105208,
0.3687821627,
-0.6988132,
-0.0200011134,
-0.3864181936,
-0.2292049676,
0.0146457199,
-0.2785174847,
-0.3383571506,
-0.3564527929,
0.560372591,
-0.3921300471,
0.0959366411,
0.1798898429,
-0.2176856548,
0.0490003824,
0.02418047,
0.6527774334,
0.6513197422,
0.1006819084,
0.0374720134,
0.5350595117,
-0.5467274785,
0.1896222681,
-0.1998879015,
-0.2206350267,
-0.0254602823,
0.0774806291,
0.7623675466,
0.022968825,
-1.0811467171,
0.3303049207,
-0.0790739581,
-0.4708267748,
-0.6178213358,
0.3213014007,
-0.0592419431,
0.5615243316,
0.5738193989,
0.0687232539,
-0.1024113372,
-0.5105862021,
0.2957062721,
0.5488115549,
-0.0134855667,
-0.2049554288,
0.5774024725,
0.0403337963,
0.012358509,
0.6400287151,
-0.0829922184,
-0.489807874,
0.5295445323,
0.4766066074,
0.3940029442,
-0.0571462922,
0.2924862206,
0.6363078356,
0.0450666957,
0.062532708,
0.5283042789,
-0.2523854077,
-0.7188162208,
-0.4080171287,
-0.8238672018,
-0.3250550628,
0.3589360714,
-0.7032510638,
0.0874003246,
-0.379237324,
-0.1699780077,
-0.1881308854,
-0.2923552692,
-0.8557294011,
0.5295881629,
0.056759648,
0.6600887179,
-0.6676117182,
0.6985071301,
0.6985048056,
-0.2037515044,
-0.684132278,
-0.170682475,
-0.1515207291,
-0.7342175841,
0.8406674862,
0.0100791911,
-0.0279480722,
0.0159850139,
-0.7399502993,
-0.906862855,
1.287127018,
0.4281896055,
-0.4513989091,
-0.2057564408,
0.4683037102,
0.6134837866,
-0.426486522,
-0.1705449671,
0.2650634348,
0.2829888165,
0.5370085239,
-0.7425659895,
-0.1489546001,
-0.3207685947,
0.2112187594,
0.105075635,
-0.380005002,
0.8487506509,
-0.2055639625,
-0.1653385013,
0.2897647917,
0.4592131376,
0.7297127843,
0.2382674515,
0.5043637753,
0.5045023561,
0.3041847348,
-0.153688848,
0.9464716911,
-0.1853498518,
-0.0108158132,
1.1459735632,
-0.2380649745,
0.7689276934,
0.7552483082,
0.1459962428,
0.2466919124,
0.4259308875,
0.0012327137,
0.6625158787,
0.2507353723,
-0.5907145143,
-0.5803905129,
-0.1917048842,
-0.4216600657,
0.6001637578,
0.4103031754,
-0.3321926594,
-0.1222109124,
0.4061090648,
-0.6583524942,
0.0032156217,
-0.3565114737,
0.8957470059,
-0.130011484,
-0.6018118262,
0.6340733171,
-0.2851678133,
0.4374250174,
-0.6217514873,
-0.288683027,
-0.0673580095,
0.0940433145,
0.0594492815,
-0.6628017426,
0.0780593753,
-0.0066228025,
-0.2987242639,
-0.0924019441,
0.7013199925,
-0.5535392165,
-0.6996991634,
-0.0911906213,
0.6176882982,
-0.1902791262,
0.0062331175,
-0.396861881,
-0.1626173407,
-0.0361623615,
-0.2856784463,
0.5381360054,
0.5475040674,
-0.1535829604,
0.6806137562,
0.960603714,
0.0120751001,
0.5590109229,
-0.1639336944,
1.2167823315,
-0.4698848426,
-0.2126757056,
-0.244065702,
0.8267303705,
-0.1448838115,
-0.3190479279,
0.7981166244,
0.5003867745,
1.2227989435,
-0.3545756638,
0.9555351138,
-0.2534442842,
0.436099112,
-0.5623124242,
0.5333685875,
-0.9125819802,
-0.1306008995,
-0.0808844343,
-1.0094281435,
0.1122719795,
0.4471715987,
0.0127815064,
0.0104378862,
0.2836665213,
0.8921615481,
-0.1674488634,
-0.2811308503,
0.3450853825,
0.1181594282,
0.2538707256,
0.3482290208,
1.044921875,
-0.4435218275,
0.6614993811,
-0.2693720758,
0.106625706,
-0.0204787627,
-0.7348621488,
-0.8423885107,
-1.1426254511,
0.0214290302,
-0.2978740036,
-0.1002233624,
0.8123270869,
0.739520967,
-0.5615682006,
0.2065283358,
-0.0434876382,
-0.4343797565,
0.0939099416,
-0.1874351501,
0.0258360133,
-0.251100421,
-0.6304088235,
0.6560816765,
-0.0690807402,
0.1616053432,
-0.4635668993,
-0.153283596,
-0.0951739699,
0.2993034124,
0.9685031176,
0.2298590541,
-0.6730416417,
-0.4612314999,
0.2572093308,
0.0109406728,
-0.0554060377,
0.7087693214,
-1.2014174461,
0.93664217,
0.4715818167,
0.7773554325,
0.6596035361,
0.1930830181,
0.7546077967,
-1.1409643888,
0.1118689254,
0.2036263347,
0.177144587,
0.2570429146,
-0.0927314609,
0.3853870928,
0.2126159966,
-0.3722245395,
-1.108358264,
0.426833272,
-1.1351228952,
-0.1300079226,
1.2660470009,
0.1937364489,
-0.2463809699,
0.01812925,
-0.5619511604,
0.1354241222,
0.062638633,
0.8040726781,
0.5326634645,
0.0072847866,
-0.1669224054,
-0.5993540287,
0.6229383945,
0.0821895003,
-0.8556062579,
-0.1152866483,
0.9235407114,
0.2933444977,
0.2905049324,
0.2978792191,
0.0200801808,
0.4992714822,
0.1569398791,
-0.019310642,
-0.1902470291,
-0.5655061007,
-0.0137103489,
0.3147693276,
-0.2671106756,
-0.0203193054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19578v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19578v1 | PathAlign: A vision-language model for whole slide images in histopathology | 2024-06-27T23:43:36 | 2024-06-27T23:43:36 | Faruk Ahmed, Andrew Sellergren, Lin Yang, Shawn Xu, Boris Babenko, Abbi Ward, Niels Olson, Arash Mohtashamian, Yossi Matias, Greg S. Corrado, Quang Duong, Dale R. Webster, Shravya Shetty, Daniel Golden, Yun Liu, David F. Steiner, Ellery Wulczyn | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Microscopic interpretation of histopathology images underlies many important
diagnostic and treatment decisions. While advances in vision-language modeling
raise new opportunities for analysis of such images, the gigapixel-scale size
of whole slide images (WSIs) introduces unique challenges. Additionally,
pathology reports simultaneously highlight key findings from small regions
while also aggregating interpretation across multiple slides, often making it
difficult to create robust image-text pairs. As such, pathology reports remain
a largely untapped source of supervision in computational pathology, with most
efforts relying on region-of-interest annotations or self-supervision at the
patch-level. In this work, we develop a vision-language model based on the
BLIP-2 framework using WSIs paired with curated text from pathology reports.
This enables applications utilizing a shared image-text embedding space, such
as text or image retrieval for finding cases of interest, as well as
integration of the WSI encoder with a frozen large language model (LLM) for
WSI-based generative text capabilities such as report generation or
AI-in-the-loop interactions. We utilize a de-identified dataset of over 350,000
WSIs and diagnostic text pairs, spanning a wide range of diagnoses, procedure
types, and tissue types. We present pathologist evaluation of text generation
and text retrieval using WSI embeddings, as well as results for WSI
classification and workflow prioritization (slide-level triaging).
Model-generated text for WSIs was rated by pathologists as accurate, without
clinically significant error or omission, for 78% of WSIs on average. This work
demonstrates exciting potential capabilities for language-aligned WSI
embeddings. | [
0.0636096746,
-0.2519106269,
0.8191940784,
0.1255326718,
-0.6018443704,
-0.0735631585,
-0.0886728689,
-0.434568733,
0.5155949593,
0.6026813984,
-0.2302839756,
-0.5911412239,
-0.7305087447,
0.1128618494,
-0.2883316576,
0.9983676076,
0.0517430715,
0.3244157434,
-0.313691318,
-0.250333935,
-0.2097505182,
0.1202572584,
-0.479091078,
-0.0376399606,
0.4389809668,
0.3196347952,
1.0092284679,
1.0378592014,
0.9610939026,
0.2353169471,
-0.2315872014,
-0.1089345887,
-0.0890246332,
0.258643806,
-0.2957372367,
-0.2656647861,
-0.3378508389,
-0.0207725354,
0.5257645249,
0.9146947861,
-0.4399776459,
-0.0663815886,
-0.2716981173,
0.3631370962,
-0.5994656086,
0.0702357069,
-0.2327454388,
0.3036679626,
-0.3385709822,
-0.1370443255,
-0.4197742343,
-0.1343129277,
0.2222353071,
-0.7326637506,
-0.0760685354,
-0.0690089464,
0.8641310334,
0.3177366555,
-0.4259134531,
-0.2901647985,
-0.4251005352,
0.4886458814,
-0.8092799187,
0.4511525631,
0.2381746173,
0.5764710307,
0.1065251604,
-0.8955876827,
-0.1737223119,
-0.1514296681,
-0.1944777519,
0.3980061114,
-0.1539347768,
0.1079421118,
0.172085613,
0.4560004175,
-0.7167464495,
0.3362577856,
-0.5180662274,
-0.56403023,
0.4358433783,
0.4324447811,
0.3881028295,
-0.2503965497,
-0.5180737376,
0.049729459,
-0.7351199389,
-0.5096036792,
-0.3245352209,
0.1780049801,
-0.1488199234,
0.5609967113,
0.0004750034,
0.8616688251,
-0.0698298663,
-0.5862722397,
0.2171114683,
-0.2097866237,
-0.2799979746,
0.0519576818,
0.9630039334,
0.4103438258,
-0.0179795679,
-0.2892243862,
0.1184947863,
0.0171188172,
0.3534721136,
-0.8688724637,
-0.074075073,
0.2660691142,
-0.6262126565,
-0.5813530684,
-0.3296016753,
-1.0312721729,
-0.6876698732,
-0.0334207565,
0.3730964363,
-0.4726443589,
-0.0928088278,
0.0677160025,
-0.2024808824,
-0.262234956,
0.4678995609,
-0.5158213377,
0.1045394242,
0.1829868108,
1.0543671846,
-0.0135987513,
-0.2884272635,
-0.8688718677,
0.6083925962,
-0.6802040935,
0.6759567857,
-0.8376508951,
-0.3157766759,
0.16734007,
-0.0048431531,
0.033045318,
-0.2227040976,
0.264573276,
-0.1751136333,
0.2680487037,
0.022214951,
-0.5577469468,
0.1411252767,
0.0339221992,
-0.5437399149,
0.6641129255,
0.1733707935,
-0.8676851392,
0.3671111166,
-0.4788610041,
-0.3315292895,
0.3980322778,
-0.4366765022,
-0.3019222021,
0.0169972517,
-0.0549707226,
0.3722311854,
-0.3111006618,
0.4984129369,
-0.0790029317,
-0.2687683105,
-0.0580216758,
-0.0893829316,
0.5984709859,
-0.0445140563,
-0.4339980185,
0.1172849983,
-0.3614477515,
-0.3400703967,
0.093907617,
0.0374911278,
-0.3188738823,
0.0193664879,
-0.1390702128,
0.3449387252,
0.3462155163,
-0.8001796603,
0.2953076661,
-0.6536980271,
0.1645797789,
0.4216949046,
0.041092962,
0.3188279867,
-0.0322052278,
0.4838117361,
0.5715424418,
0.3443873823,
-0.386673063,
-0.887213707,
-0.4159708619,
-0.1727546155,
0.2040436864,
0.5949848294,
-0.8107438684,
0.0341351703,
-0.3497365117,
-0.578058362,
-0.3558753729,
-0.0562758259,
0.6806936264,
0.6285268664,
0.3460249305,
-0.4814096093,
-0.2238478214,
-1.180664897,
0.3530483544,
0.0524186082,
-0.1243762895,
0.3485191762,
0.2935100198,
-0.345735997,
0.5413298011,
-0.9322783947,
-0.6178014874,
-0.0921345353,
0.0672501773,
0.0928550661,
0.2689284086,
0.412329495,
-0.6917914748,
-0.5216190815,
0.1428921819,
-0.7475240231,
-0.0432611518,
0.0555628166,
-0.3182260096,
0.2634802163,
0.6981407404,
-0.6503695846,
0.9077409506,
0.7051433921,
-0.4967301488,
0.5400615335,
-0.4505864382,
0.150034532,
-1.2725777626,
0.1709704697,
0.3783936203,
-0.3761730194,
-0.569511354,
0.0908991322,
0.0568426177,
-0.2608503103,
-0.2011593282,
0.3628261387,
-0.3702097535,
-0.3631918132,
0.0341312326,
0.4339647591,
0.0329726674,
0.240697816,
0.3059692681,
0.8140155077,
0.9338892102,
-0.3816977441,
0.0862844139,
0.5507875681,
-0.0548764728,
0.326412499,
-0.4255901873,
-0.0847457498,
0.0127559854,
0.3508469462,
-0.8552939296,
-0.293740809,
0.171837464,
-0.238261342,
0.5494300723,
-0.4022676945,
-0.4586424828,
-0.4113980532,
-0.3193971515,
0.1747285724,
0.4321348369,
-0.3742349446,
0.3789713085,
0.4550564587,
-0.2995324731,
-0.4400194883,
-0.7375234365,
0.481046766,
0.0180135183,
-0.5530226827,
0.7307528853,
-0.1324532479,
-0.1362138838,
-0.138678059,
0.0136402082,
-0.3803544939,
-0.4262151122,
0.3008630276,
0.2713194788,
-0.3432583809,
0.1369429976,
0.2174400985,
-0.0944286138,
-0.3543106318,
-0.2171106935,
0.3975387216,
0.0693513677,
-0.3530142903,
-0.3732123673,
0.3136948645,
0.8636911511,
-0.2491338998,
0.5046229362,
0.5701414347,
-0.5325214863,
0.3135409951,
-0.2913954854,
-0.0902326256,
-0.4301230311,
0.173279047,
-0.2620053291,
-0.6180058122,
0.2898881733,
-0.0429592095,
0.1465751231,
0.3056132495,
0.5300607681,
-0.2302141339,
1.0955532789,
0.7676009536,
-0.0198839605,
0.1383808404,
0.0064107985,
0.1958766133,
-0.9642465711,
-0.1689590365,
-0.3293809295,
0.0430752672,
-0.5256953239,
-0.5981824398,
0.5260939002,
-0.2482917607,
0.0378755368,
0.1702829748,
-0.7260544896,
0.2693402171,
0.2254736125,
0.3430294991,
0.0815122873,
0.0366990604,
-0.1468097419,
-0.418314755,
-0.6533910632,
-0.6432759166,
1.0258657932,
0.2691932917,
0.3747187555,
0.4119546711,
0.6724963784,
0.097493276,
0.1184490696,
-0.7039434314,
0.4614369869,
-0.7476139665,
-0.397336632,
-0.4103040397,
-0.2647138238,
-0.9071356654,
0.2912508249,
0.0705294237,
-1.2181276083,
0.0417081043,
0.2568229437,
-0.3598402739,
0.386303246,
-0.2959724665,
0.937368989,
0.0739220083,
-0.5271074772,
-0.2602544725,
-0.8526047468,
0.2601491511,
0.2703472376,
0.3208974004,
0.1937931478,
-0.2362185121,
0.769395113,
-0.2623690665,
0.941313386,
-0.1937160492,
-0.2044745237,
0.0057343626,
0.6284894943,
0.1729048938,
0.1820067614,
0.1360271871,
0.1139203534,
0.148663789,
-0.2882952094,
-0.3480865657,
0.5744986534,
-0.1607449055,
-0.4792991877,
-0.2995942831,
-0.4211947322,
-0.3914929628,
0.2091607004,
0.4896036386,
0.9531105757,
0.0869215056,
-0.1467835307,
0.8157692552,
-0.2685214877,
0.560362041,
0.3343066573,
-0.2496677935,
-0.1356494725,
1.0768898726,
-0.1928315461,
0.104132995,
0.3192266226,
0.4004185498,
-0.0136049157,
-0.7141910195,
-1.0197762251,
0.2571498752,
-0.5676466823,
-0.4583404362,
-0.4700446725,
-0.1657111049,
-0.2835043669,
-0.3050160408,
-0.3890005052,
-0.3938931823,
-0.2565588057,
0.0433999486,
0.3124110997,
0.826138258,
-0.3055902123,
0.2934710681,
-0.8875916004,
-0.0165494252,
-0.1918800473,
0.4871384501,
-0.2931034267,
-0.425201267,
-0.2912183404,
-0.0613988601,
-0.2068101168,
-1.1800062656,
0.4992156029,
0.2562113404,
0.2987920344,
0.4889934361,
-0.4515380859,
0.4139747918,
-0.5086522102,
0.8365361691,
0.4344977438,
-0.6734515429,
0.8802634478,
-0.4511575103,
0.1591032445,
0.4095903039,
0.4104087651,
-0.5904513597,
-0.7649894953,
-0.6774795055,
-0.5723308921,
0.6994278431,
0.1406004876,
-0.2398744524,
0.0483961813,
0.327825129,
0.0072938954,
0.0699918866,
-0.5723872781,
0.0726481006,
-0.2260587215,
-0.6388298869,
-0.0722759217,
-0.2638397515,
-0.5189190507,
-0.1394487768,
0.3035396338,
-0.5084539652,
0.4715055227,
0.2725616097,
-0.3483547568,
-0.1543146372,
-0.0771896616,
0.7542450428,
0.6824527383,
-0.0899672881,
0.0028614851,
-0.0445992574,
-0.7149094343,
-0.3784681261,
-0.0484259687,
-0.0065217582,
0.1475421935,
0.6043407321,
0.4750011861,
0.2762345672,
-0.6767762303,
0.9168507457,
0.0488946401,
-0.2129034698,
0.0892364308,
-0.1068453416,
0.0934975296,
0.024178911,
0.2552041709,
-0.0165747143,
0.5675017834,
-0.136049211,
0.4217339456,
0.2189530283,
-0.9591641426,
-0.2795535028,
0.3242122233,
0.1879537106,
0.0022740536,
0.7242236137,
-0.2879738212,
-0.5521233678,
0.7798913717,
0.6202857494,
0.2580496371,
-0.1883365512,
0.5589054227,
0.4910933375,
0.2596511245,
0.2249028683,
0.0368242152,
0.2805812061,
-0.479575783,
-0.3571815789,
-0.6273436546,
-0.4337732494,
0.0463442281,
-0.5516972542,
0.0669361204,
-0.494135499,
0.0970330015,
0.3915576637,
-0.2967715859,
-0.058304362,
0.5887233019,
0.209504053,
0.9953804016,
-0.7522758842,
0.6159101725,
0.7956083417,
-0.6373784542,
-0.6334837079,
0.2495457679,
0.3116244972,
-0.6337028742,
0.5231271982,
0.2173214555,
0.2070459425,
-0.2028115094,
-0.4045721292,
-1.0039994717,
1.0890562534,
0.0850718394,
-0.613815546,
-0.1131869778,
-0.1724659055,
0.7160341144,
-0.4791173637,
0.2663709223,
0.4184746444,
0.3027186692,
0.3911791146,
-1.12593925,
0.319390744,
0.0542772077,
-0.1322760731,
0.4616414607,
-0.4781229198,
0.6072266102,
-0.3707163334,
-0.1741195172,
-0.0362839028,
0.1510878056,
0.0896455497,
0.2002655566,
0.3364753425,
0.6808561087,
0.4327628911,
0.0046745902,
1.1506364346,
-0.5286990404,
0.0747303665,
0.580640018,
-0.2749529183,
0.6922374368,
0.3073955178,
0.0014103835,
0.665168941,
0.583527565,
0.027890902,
0.5101749897,
-0.1409795731,
-0.0450841673,
-0.255949825,
-0.1261361241,
-0.1709935367,
0.5278030038,
0.6451912522,
-0.3173330724,
-0.2786229253,
0.0803843588,
0.0038555353,
-0.1548342854,
-0.2994395196,
0.8291044235,
-0.0766417235,
-0.5345031023,
0.0673732981,
-0.1418185532,
0.6872107983,
-0.4419157207,
-0.0950043723,
-0.3500567377,
-0.0225039069,
-0.330696404,
-1.1168118715,
0.6989876628,
-0.0503422059,
0.0741188973,
0.2581854761,
0.4507637918,
-0.4087748528,
-0.5518832803,
0.2390166372,
0.2723985314,
0.297303915,
0.3944179416,
-0.447991848,
-0.0520747155,
0.1896252483,
0.0035047962,
0.4183565378,
0.1967943013,
-0.2640334368,
0.799217701,
0.3431493342,
0.1627634168,
-0.2464934886,
0.3658318222,
0.8365308046,
-0.483046025,
-0.3425079584,
-0.5856130123,
0.6012020707,
-0.362975508,
-0.5251818895,
0.1683464646,
0.5779162645,
0.2047632039,
0.1829562038,
0.4237455726,
-0.0427416749,
0.2900560796,
-0.5161315203,
0.6062485576,
-0.8455653191,
-0.177693069,
-0.4970917106,
-0.3688961565,
-0.3885889649,
0.5962805152,
-0.081956096,
-0.16922234,
0.8683905005,
0.7569083571,
-0.2577363551,
-0.2248608172,
0.4034732282,
0.2490643412,
0.1696901321,
0.5114122629,
0.3576590419,
-0.2670916319,
0.7423329353,
-0.3702326417,
-0.569955647,
-0.2454303354,
-0.6733427644,
-0.6912341118,
-0.818004787,
-0.6762322187,
-0.1591636539,
0.1653996855,
0.3254802227,
0.960288167,
-0.4310168922,
-0.0165748131,
0.0150695015,
-0.1455190331,
0.1753641516,
-0.144207716,
0.5065043569,
-0.2922347188,
-0.4396795034,
0.4663044512,
0.9052483439,
0.2194858044,
-0.2559244633,
0.2157030553,
-0.048260957,
-0.1163972914,
0.7144871354,
0.0293330234,
-0.5373562574,
0.0045591607,
-0.1028123647,
-0.4307366312,
0.2035432011,
0.5707303286,
-0.4815566838,
0.3969821632,
0.0151992477,
0.2615422606,
0.6912145615,
-0.3730588853,
0.6209904552,
-0.6299111843,
0.1847462803,
0.4111625254,
0.4612089992,
0.3531641066,
-0.6343886852,
0.5218914747,
0.0718180984,
-0.2103129923,
-0.8500435948,
0.4305832982,
-1.0109442472,
-0.4774999917,
1.0980600119,
-0.1440937519,
-0.2001492083,
0.0717202052,
-0.1998589635,
0.103290841,
-0.253882736,
0.6335855126,
0.2577517927,
-0.2443797737,
-0.4520359337,
-0.2484052479,
0.6169692278,
0.1971745193,
-0.7527865171,
-0.0860033557,
0.6476162672,
0.3478575349,
0.5646555424,
0.6743879318,
-0.18792364,
0.5288739204,
0.0635171309,
0.0443935283,
0.0680243894,
-0.4637246728,
-0.1777067035,
-0.0358948112,
-0.00891292,
-0.1416460425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19564v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19564v1 | Voices Unheard: NLP Resources and Models for Yorùbá Regional Dialects | 2024-06-27T22:38:04 | 2024-06-27T22:38:04 | Orevaoghene Ahia, Anuoluwapo Aremu, Diana Abagyan, Hila Gonen, David Ifeoluwa Adelani, Daud Abolade, Noah A. Smith, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Yor\`ub\'a an African language with roughly 47 million speakers encompasses a
continuum with several dialects. Recent efforts to develop NLP technologies for
African languages have focused on their standard dialects, resulting in
disparities for dialects and varieties for which there are little to no
resources or tools. We take steps towards bridging this gap by introducing a
new high-quality parallel text and speech corpus YOR\`ULECT across three
domains and four regional Yor\`ub\'a dialects. To develop this corpus, we
engaged native speakers, travelling to communities where these dialects are
spoken, to collect text and speech data. Using our newly created corpus, we
conducted extensive experiments on (text) machine translation, automatic speech
recognition, and speech-to-text translation. Our results reveal substantial
performance disparities between standard Yor\`ub\'a and the other dialects
across all tasks. However, we also show that with dialect-adaptive finetuning,
we are able to narrow this gap. We believe our dataset and experimental
analysis will contribute greatly to developing NLP tools for Yor\`ub\'a and its
dialects, and potentially for other African languages, by improving our
understanding of existing challenges and offering a high-quality dataset for
further development. We release YOR\`ULECT dataset and models publicly under an
open license. | [
-0.6673585773,
-0.6711573601,
0.1298196614,
0.1890816838,
-0.1403449029,
0.1421262622,
-0.2529540658,
-0.5451335311,
0.3898304403,
0.8253393769,
-0.5721207261,
-0.2419085354,
-0.4487274289,
0.2724126577,
-0.4501020312,
0.7690122128,
0.7605822086,
-0.0728480816,
0.1308858693,
-0.5803024769,
-0.7067642212,
-0.5091619492,
-0.1851472855,
-0.2888443768,
0.287401408,
0.4585589468,
0.691722095,
0.3581528664,
-0.1215218827,
0.4086148441,
-0.6286066771,
0.3297328055,
-0.2094848007,
0.1968436539,
-0.2006834596,
-0.2342538983,
-0.3769070208,
-0.2945498824,
0.3848166466,
1.154224515,
-0.4138310254,
0.3368322253,
0.0368457437,
0.8350998759,
-0.5092071295,
0.0475698188,
-0.7621816993,
-0.0699601397,
-0.6446271539,
0.1517074108,
-0.0566225536,
-0.4169923961,
-0.0300489217,
-0.4233413041,
0.3472760916,
-0.3089705706,
0.5769719481,
0.1386522055,
-0.4800885022,
0.0042786859,
-0.585956037,
0.5799136758,
-1.2021671534,
0.32586959,
0.4561258554,
0.184851259,
-0.4691245258,
-0.7561110258,
-0.6675572991,
0.0752917826,
0.1521993428,
0.078930825,
-0.4122491777,
-0.1178103983,
0.1245654002,
0.4103082418,
-0.2492577136,
0.2634550631,
-0.6059962511,
-0.1063827053,
0.4837485254,
0.0214141365,
0.1522819847,
-0.4630980492,
0.0791549459,
0.1417221427,
-0.4195312858,
-0.1033154204,
0.7142199278,
0.9030831456,
-0.0205096379,
0.5140484571,
-0.3750188649,
1.070504427,
-0.167618528,
-0.0361973308,
0.3747307658,
0.0355238914,
-0.2268580496,
-0.0488279536,
0.9794625044,
0.2058729827,
0.1388372928,
-0.2942700982,
-0.1893689334,
-0.2020367831,
0.4226596951,
-0.5096822381,
0.0607301332,
-0.0423787013,
-0.3580473661,
0.0354184359,
-0.3293046653,
-1.053458333,
-0.55440557,
-0.3307076395,
0.394335568,
-0.3283663988,
-0.4252779782,
-0.0057442556,
0.0011962039,
-0.1919368356,
0.0484881736,
-1.0974340439,
0.5684465766,
0.3304398358,
0.7096157074,
0.0884853974,
-0.0856166855,
-0.0288262609,
-0.3577812016,
-0.1790536046,
0.543892324,
0.0001689522,
-0.5456849337,
0.1242824048,
-0.1078927144,
-0.0829668939,
-0.6548716426,
0.675339818,
-0.4181271195,
0.1480757743,
-0.2575127482,
-0.1519616395,
-0.4434737265,
-0.2582404912,
-0.7400810719,
1.0131819248,
0.3972151875,
-0.3806152344,
-0.1538176835,
-0.6833080053,
-0.596927762,
0.299554199,
-0.1719741821,
-0.1575669199,
0.6827197075,
0.3729168773,
0.3220110536,
-0.5027800798,
0.2990331948,
0.124837555,
-0.0268967245,
0.2840506136,
-0.7905231118,
1.437710166,
0.3303626776,
-0.2978230119,
-0.2499756366,
-1.1721179485,
0.3835787475,
0.1631263345,
-0.1382890642,
-0.1866038889,
-0.0926906168,
0.5501158237,
-0.1911896616,
-0.0101226531,
-0.7712057829,
0.1512906551,
-0.2921448648,
0.6585077047,
0.3478227556,
-0.226104185,
0.1802127659,
0.0353706069,
0.4817749262,
-0.1049172357,
-0.0391662121,
0.1496641785,
-0.735906601,
-0.7660135031,
0.104308255,
0.4186863303,
0.3473265469,
-0.2281021625,
0.6408691406,
0.1565068215,
-0.4132309258,
-0.9058884382,
0.1580184698,
0.1995535493,
0.9863327146,
0.6613658667,
-0.4731188715,
-0.5262466669,
-1.0098264217,
0.2331196219,
-0.3321334422,
-0.0582419224,
0.0631834418,
0.0335934237,
-0.293954134,
1.113304615,
-0.2009246498,
-0.6104096174,
-0.5210248828,
0.2790102661,
0.2975693941,
0.2779632807,
0.7203433514,
-0.8974175453,
-0.1033212245,
0.087185517,
-0.477199018,
-0.5895650983,
0.0794196576,
0.1493331045,
0.5467454195,
0.4731939137,
-0.0633108616,
0.4264410734,
0.9206360579,
-0.2020047903,
0.2970034182,
-0.308872968,
0.0090904301,
-1.2052183151,
0.031986542,
-0.293805927,
-0.068403855,
-0.5993000269,
-0.0259520002,
-0.0001333433,
-0.2428741455,
-0.1780445129,
0.3215085864,
-0.5040274858,
-0.1395635754,
-0.25405249,
0.0778655335,
0.0516243502,
0.2814021707,
-0.0113840401,
0.8025797606,
0.1770935506,
-0.5794150233,
0.322827071,
0.7086689472,
-0.5544897914,
0.4907452762,
-0.8187285662,
0.2233979553,
0.1286838353,
-0.2190998942,
-0.6991342902,
-0.2732515335,
-0.2921233177,
-0.6211311817,
0.4320414066,
-0.3021809757,
-0.0826887265,
-0.3550148606,
0.5114683509,
0.1548365057,
0.3724271357,
-0.5236524343,
0.5067024231,
0.7588642836,
-0.4510718584,
-0.8290270567,
-1.1021684408,
0.3338766396,
-0.0899926275,
-0.3503601849,
0.0900856107,
0.0612555221,
-0.0628200099,
0.1396730542,
-0.1496407092,
-0.5327805281,
0.2867012322,
0.3942446411,
-0.042079024,
-0.440392971,
-0.1455570608,
-0.126163289,
0.101632975,
-0.1031450257,
-0.235318765,
0.5866744518,
-0.2069736868,
-0.2039898336,
-0.2011107951,
0.7543157339,
0.2766329944,
-0.4810888767,
0.8139069676,
0.5750389099,
-0.3616186976,
-0.2369119823,
-0.6945019364,
0.3589017093,
-0.4596360922,
0.6192287207,
-0.1935387105,
-0.8069062829,
0.6608892679,
0.0866180733,
-0.0662476644,
0.3477571905,
0.4467770755,
-0.1423634887,
0.3750467002,
0.8946148157,
-0.3977801502,
0.3504765928,
-0.2453675568,
0.2201567441,
-0.8295519352,
-0.4312590063,
-0.9660100341,
-0.2098964006,
-0.9164104462,
-0.1362668723,
0.4230656028,
0.1253028512,
0.0401782542,
0.6954422593,
-0.1116638184,
0.4274229109,
0.9396211505,
-0.1196683943,
0.1212366074,
0.0218862183,
-0.0623794198,
-0.1767234057,
-0.8508197069,
-0.3994668424,
0.9585374594,
-0.0913064927,
0.5055215359,
0.3897606432,
0.6962463856,
0.3447864056,
-0.2283735275,
-0.6179215312,
0.4020308256,
-0.2740284801,
-0.7137148976,
-0.362834096,
-0.4999375343,
-1.0881540775,
0.1279707551,
-0.2847207785,
-0.9622550011,
0.384226799,
-0.0831612349,
-0.2226826549,
0.5751690269,
-0.4649769664,
0.8775210977,
-0.0761893988,
0.0582240038,
0.0630288273,
-0.8458735943,
-0.0186857283,
-0.16488491,
0.2583270371,
-0.1252360046,
0.3887949586,
0.6738252044,
-0.4630841613,
0.7365148067,
-0.0887419358,
0.0719068944,
0.5002931952,
0.0991656408,
-0.2672217786,
-0.0952531174,
-0.3165838718,
0.5950831771,
-0.1614539921,
-0.367692709,
-0.2096920013,
0.7276331186,
-0.865141511,
-0.3631626666,
-0.3426918685,
-0.8783948421,
-0.6157689095,
0.4225097001,
0.334672749,
0.8868467212,
-0.4334008098,
0.3864020109,
0.3548723757,
-0.4139875472,
0.599142611,
0.4705107808,
0.0613187253,
-0.4995593131,
0.6909157634,
0.1372850239,
0.4093608558,
0.0307626128,
0.2257395387,
-0.4557090104,
-0.8895275593,
-0.604168117,
-0.0254823137,
-0.3958437741,
-0.4855473936,
-0.4149217606,
-0.2163044065,
-0.7207510471,
-0.010307339,
-0.5900354981,
-0.770686686,
0.001794126,
-0.0693819076,
0.2956603765,
1.0254491568,
-0.5407504439,
0.6056631207,
-0.8907295465,
0.721737504,
0.1283783466,
0.1472613364,
-0.1651182473,
-0.9389842153,
-0.2206744552,
0.0946855322,
-0.3513459861,
-0.7726731896,
0.7907567024,
0.1549093276,
0.5956481099,
0.1974440217,
0.2205978334,
0.8334329724,
-0.5613383055,
0.7478328347,
0.2363303304,
-1.0398974419,
0.4041315019,
-0.2999802828,
0.1999587566,
0.8099468946,
0.3498663306,
-0.8506589532,
-0.4202593863,
-0.583673954,
-1.0920649767,
0.6641739011,
0.2956584692,
0.2560940981,
-0.0200259257,
0.0172466654,
0.1772380322,
0.3121991456,
-0.6731160879,
-0.5856946707,
-0.3307848871,
-0.0729233027,
-0.2419814765,
-0.2627232075,
0.0278858766,
-0.0255212784,
0.4972456694,
-0.0952781513,
0.200024128,
0.1892477274,
0.0594690628,
-0.1106792837,
0.6195388436,
0.1421647668,
0.578592658,
-0.4699599445,
-0.2656511962,
-0.0646365955,
-0.6764042974,
0.0333205983,
0.4466255605,
-0.6542429328,
0.2518921494,
0.3938385546,
0.739223659,
-0.0841839463,
-0.3542657793,
0.1712840348,
-0.014749717,
0.0255729929,
-0.2580599785,
-0.0936242864,
0.2839228511,
0.2432262152,
0.4710914493,
0.3415349126,
0.2875202894,
-0.7145129442,
-0.1235963404,
0.1700764447,
-0.4145489931,
-0.0751045868,
0.730866313,
0.3283677399,
-0.4189900756,
0.8995576501,
-0.0832837746,
-0.3621271551,
0.5670269728,
0.7352133989,
0.6360949874,
-0.2702467144,
0.3856498301,
0.3271659911,
0.3432861567,
0.0996881649,
0.2853509486,
0.1827967912,
-0.7501826882,
-0.2265179902,
-0.8100287318,
-0.3844680488,
0.4130110741,
-1.3227235079,
-0.1279233843,
-0.2438061237,
-0.4272110164,
0.1483308077,
-0.0003337559,
-0.4740952253,
0.3847971559,
0.2751465738,
0.7876682281,
-0.9041326046,
0.6590397954,
0.5818300247,
-0.4182319045,
-0.5890843272,
-0.1465346217,
0.2790411711,
-0.6133412719,
0.3774776161,
-0.0273758229,
-0.1377667934,
-0.0073144292,
-0.1624488831,
-0.6160086989,
0.7383592725,
0.4145357311,
-0.5899702907,
0.1804069728,
0.3704239428,
0.4809406996,
-0.0503961667,
0.2918869257,
0.5567090511,
0.2853572667,
-0.1863237768,
-1.0819185972,
-0.4605834484,
-0.0595763065,
0.0433076844,
0.2784685493,
-0.4764795601,
0.6834538579,
-0.3781686425,
-0.0542125814,
0.5423015952,
0.9040732384,
-0.2627780139,
0.227232039,
0.3825233579,
0.4667108357,
0.828631103,
-0.2159803212,
0.7716149688,
0.2294616699,
-0.0629864186,
1.4263958931,
-0.1563261598,
0.8432984948,
0.3941153884,
-0.3830855489,
0.3082896769,
0.0282442588,
0.3747294545,
0.4526633918,
0.0872511491,
-0.3327670693,
-0.0180113278,
-0.5617145896,
-0.3833954632,
0.8325873613,
0.3908026814,
0.2507347167,
-0.2114384472,
-0.24894692,
-0.2360893637,
0.7754750252,
-0.4815851748,
0.4880971313,
0.0415503159,
-0.1402130574,
0.3559972346,
0.0395804234,
0.539300859,
-0.8620339036,
0.1992322356,
-0.6604517698,
0.1432325393,
-0.1682324111,
-0.6323941946,
0.5289480686,
0.1580588371,
-0.0447141193,
-0.0330303572,
0.3657147586,
-0.3194521666,
-0.454272747,
0.5573250651,
0.6572486758,
0.089523904,
0.0942304581,
-0.4134368896,
0.0061745564,
0.1250012666,
-0.0981219634,
0.3534540534,
0.7530868053,
-0.1057028994,
0.5303958058,
0.5208418965,
0.6250740886,
0.2280072123,
0.5837111473,
0.5998976231,
-0.7900651097,
-0.2562524676,
-0.2752188444,
0.2763310969,
0.0273239128,
-0.6606869102,
0.6619270444,
0.4397377074,
1.1205279827,
-0.08493305,
0.6317520142,
-0.4839200377,
0.7554678321,
-0.3911693692,
0.7793132663,
-0.4963419437,
-0.2033391744,
-0.3182246685,
-0.7555876374,
-0.1263743937,
0.647437036,
0.4301921427,
-0.1361623704,
0.3772479892,
0.5811976194,
-0.2030961365,
0.0372038111,
0.5905225277,
0.4689924121,
-0.1495363563,
0.2444048673,
0.5874013305,
-0.5543246269,
0.3150169849,
-0.538690269,
0.0399338342,
0.1441835165,
-1.0284399986,
-0.6736075282,
-0.7410888672,
-0.1367676407,
-0.3974235654,
-0.0282295495,
0.8371022344,
0.6194171309,
-1.0963429213,
-0.536934793,
0.0710568428,
-0.2020239532,
-0.2113644481,
-0.1389503032,
0.0139240026,
-0.0875635445,
-0.7576799989,
0.9031594992,
-0.1142755821,
0.0769553185,
-0.1436605901,
0.1293589324,
-0.1855148673,
-0.1669955105,
0.3933137059,
0.7641138434,
-0.6666038036,
0.0581796318,
-0.2095314115,
0.1774811596,
-0.0798309147,
0.6284866929,
-0.6763759851,
0.4695593715,
0.1432544738,
0.8491765261,
0.2254106849,
-0.0258640181,
0.6755611897,
-0.9145872593,
0.6501422524,
0.3314524293,
0.5740429163,
0.5469540954,
0.0230974797,
0.6496037841,
0.1571437269,
-0.5152347088,
-0.644100666,
0.1775220931,
-1.3240077496,
-0.1594837755,
0.8048579097,
-0.1843399554,
-0.0422867909,
-0.3119309843,
-0.1049630195,
0.3609674871,
-0.4213473797,
0.5961159468,
0.3831323087,
0.1058383361,
0.2729098201,
-0.8956948519,
0.2157121003,
0.4238972664,
-0.6234580874,
0.2209215164,
0.8676157594,
0.1388883144,
0.3039438128,
0.5062308908,
-0.1593549103,
0.0843412206,
0.0063284622,
0.2581129074,
-0.4295479357,
-0.3242551982,
-0.5978652239,
-0.0529642478,
0.0291171782,
-0.1974638402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19552v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19552v1 | Rethinking harmless refusals when fine-tuning foundation models | 2024-06-27T22:08:22 | 2024-06-27T22:08:22 | Florin Pop, Judd Rosenblatt, Diogo Schwerz de Lucena, Michael Vaiana | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we investigate the degree to which fine-tuning in Large
Language Models (LLMs) effectively mitigates versus merely conceals undesirable
behavior. Through the lens of semi-realistic role-playing exercises designed to
elicit such behaviors, we explore the response dynamics of LLMs post
fine-tuning interventions. Our methodology involves prompting models for
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning and analyzing the coherence between the
reasoning traces and the resultant outputs. Notably, we identify a pervasive
phenomenon we term \emph{reason-based deception}, where models either stop
producing reasoning traces or produce seemingly ethical reasoning traces that
belie the unethical nature of their final outputs. We further examine the
efficacy of response strategies (polite refusal versus explicit rebuttal) in
curbing the occurrence of undesired behavior in subsequent outputs of
multi-turn interactions. Our findings reveal that explicit rebuttals
significantly outperform polite refusals in preventing the continuation of
undesired outputs and nearly eliminate reason-based deception, challenging
current practices in model fine-tuning. Accordingly, the two key contributions
of this paper are (1) defining and studying reason-based deception, a new type
of hidden behavior, and (2) demonstrating that rebuttals provide a more robust
response model to harmful requests than refusals, thereby highlighting the need
to reconsider the response strategies in fine-tuning approaches. | [
-0.5323575735,
-1.1566114426,
0.5235360861,
-0.0123284031,
-0.2477667779,
0.0417574309,
-0.2130339444,
-0.3983316123,
0.0131863952,
0.9580917954,
-0.9164805412,
-0.0676273406,
-0.3557564616,
-0.0394084789,
-0.5329958797,
1.1694625616,
0.0850138441,
-0.1190937236,
0.0213650633,
0.0349715874,
-0.6031765938,
-0.2851597369,
-0.8607041836,
-0.5861769915,
0.6280409098,
0.577791512,
0.7523030043,
0.5084996223,
0.2552092671,
0.26500085,
-0.0749014169,
0.1696878821,
-1.0106151104,
0.2124398351,
-0.3582639992,
-0.6532933116,
-0.2114452571,
0.2789517939,
0.240323931,
0.6838991046,
-0.2821443081,
0.1129729226,
0.192321375,
0.7650977969,
-0.6830589771,
-0.2530210316,
-0.9660319686,
-0.13213332,
-0.0151306754,
-0.341645211,
-0.8931707144,
-0.1347408891,
0.0055517685,
-0.390293926,
0.3715685308,
0.1049500778,
0.7918573618,
0.2829696834,
-0.26188007,
-0.5733752251,
-0.7022539377,
0.8765065074,
-0.6260905266,
0.227460444,
0.5456135273,
0.2572554052,
-0.4879517257,
-0.5558643937,
-0.3034496307,
-0.338847369,
-0.0311537702,
-0.1537194848,
-0.2140492499,
0.1784876585,
0.3623738885,
0.453460902,
0.0029839487,
0.2113079429,
-0.1618341357,
-0.3135227263,
0.6410893202,
0.2021054327,
-0.0070837308,
0.0592303164,
-0.2936444283,
0.0434204414,
-0.9813582301,
0.3745752871,
0.5420467854,
0.3903144598,
0.015375765,
0.6306566,
-0.4684876204,
0.6179945469,
0.4624336958,
0.2376096696,
-0.3373735249,
-0.2820625603,
-0.4608646929,
-0.0372161306,
0.4606400132,
0.4053387046,
0.5533826947,
-0.1720754951,
-0.5081560612,
0.3208087683,
0.4475067854,
-0.7018989921,
-0.3333649039,
0.30406937,
-0.5207672119,
-0.7874113321,
-0.1246069223,
-0.8209028244,
-0.5350289941,
-0.4427902997,
0.2582703531,
-0.2345738858,
-0.2319116294,
0.3058598042,
0.0575965196,
0.2678685784,
0.3505646586,
-0.8011170626,
0.4203885198,
0.7804253101,
0.4988403916,
0.0821939334,
-0.0942956284,
-0.8967267275,
0.1213873178,
-0.6234281063,
0.6252278686,
-0.5847254395,
-0.465090096,
-0.088412106,
0.1449804157,
0.103768304,
-0.6798993945,
0.7050272226,
-0.4653988481,
-0.1767340153,
-0.4459362626,
-0.223787114,
-0.1743511856,
0.5302662849,
-0.6416348815,
0.5347735882,
-0.2984075248,
-0.606118083,
0.2688603699,
-0.3735056221,
-0.4980898499,
-0.5231272578,
-0.059048377,
-0.3715961874,
0.4538570344,
-0.0954668596,
0.4120016694,
-0.3243708014,
0.3072907329,
-0.6192225814,
-0.453609705,
0.5945661664,
-0.8625184894,
0.8225851655,
0.2855618596,
-0.3855466247,
0.1901738495,
-0.8295770288,
0.1069400385,
0.0258337557,
-0.3207136691,
-0.4107540846,
-0.007988506,
-0.3740454912,
0.3102338314,
-0.0487291031,
-0.4068967402,
-0.1665490121,
-0.6515812874,
0.5409524441,
1.0573544502,
0.0007847294,
0.3648294508,
-0.61803478,
0.4071686268,
-0.2651848793,
0.2624812722,
-0.0912245736,
-0.2517353296,
-0.870999217,
0.0361693464,
0.035565611,
0.0895661712,
-0.6800834537,
-0.1854832768,
0.0276132505,
-0.3260733485,
-0.6862387061,
-0.1040587574,
0.6677376628,
0.4336778224,
0.2213163227,
-0.2059897184,
-0.2641719282,
-0.9539143443,
-0.6724516153,
-0.0870419517,
0.2627349198,
0.1478294134,
0.3233152628,
0.0454198718,
0.6353297234,
-0.1098706126,
0.0295499694,
-0.0393987373,
0.1519387662,
-0.0325992554,
0.5302262902,
0.5116221905,
-0.9905070662,
-0.218283385,
-0.1477805525,
-0.3057588637,
0.0851867869,
-0.2824247181,
0.0228265002,
0.4638283849,
0.6341435313,
-0.5363550782,
0.707542479,
0.2669098079,
-0.4765553176,
0.8900573254,
0.1400108039,
0.2016533315,
-0.5958771706,
0.0036750359,
-0.3265232444,
-0.0848805308,
-0.5897420049,
0.4714743495,
-0.2005496323,
0.2167797685,
-0.5244325399,
0.2222695649,
-0.4646705091,
0.2372936904,
-0.3700299859,
-0.1694067568,
-0.0934958085,
0.4193852246,
-0.2836003602,
0.5742259026,
0.6594718099,
-1.0264309645,
0.2270545661,
0.184112981,
0.0232412331,
0.6618210673,
-0.5661856532,
0.1259433478,
-0.0985723659,
0.3197170198,
-1.107403636,
-0.2847192287,
0.3000291884,
-0.5484843254,
0.1722856164,
-0.3977144659,
-0.1931394041,
-0.3596362472,
-0.5640087128,
0.1233263239,
0.2113684863,
-0.5097168088,
0.5255727172,
0.0255663767,
0.1498272717,
-0.6165749431,
-1.0034378767,
-0.0243202373,
-0.3646143973,
-0.4121637344,
0.2756969035,
-0.3334940672,
-0.4186448157,
-0.2975228429,
-0.4587934911,
0.1073922813,
0.3440361321,
0.2801293135,
-0.071620442,
-0.0058956249,
-0.3151383698,
0.0890926197,
-0.2084173262,
0.4646688104,
0.0608355775,
0.540502429,
-0.2587881088,
-0.5091044903,
-0.3904398382,
0.418177098,
0.8527851105,
-0.2486795485,
0.6844599843,
0.3345550299,
-0.3544422984,
-0.1346792281,
-0.5528805852,
-0.6982529759,
-0.5350438356,
0.0631836653,
-0.5809109807,
-1.0766512156,
0.6566954255,
-0.2800554633,
0.3179238141,
0.0098968865,
0.5254349113,
-0.0338921882,
1.0376290083,
0.5793765187,
0.1632097214,
0.2314679772,
-0.1897971183,
0.5277686715,
-0.7458235025,
-0.2666010261,
-0.6633732319,
-0.3220457733,
-0.7830711603,
-0.0658331737,
-0.1777555197,
0.2142307013,
-0.2791928649,
0.0204962399,
-0.3182230294,
0.586833477,
0.1373308152,
0.2165576667,
0.3819561005,
-0.0079628304,
-0.2547748685,
0.0038988544,
-0.66616714,
-0.5391985774,
0.8807005286,
0.4343535006,
0.9536826015,
0.4058587551,
0.5852937102,
-0.0157608297,
0.4067644477,
-0.9459531903,
0.7149940133,
0.1586112529,
-0.6116654277,
-0.3190019429,
-0.3391472697,
-0.9049004316,
0.2754226327,
-0.3518672884,
-0.8291374445,
0.2109168023,
0.4087394774,
-0.4812087417,
0.2846907377,
-0.6390942335,
0.5860853791,
0.002006216,
-0.9104335308,
-0.4966759384,
-0.5476533175,
0.6073496938,
-0.0067495918,
0.3216368854,
0.0944582969,
0.3329163492,
0.501627624,
-0.304600656,
1.0949321985,
0.0161507763,
-0.5479161143,
0.2870603502,
0.7397912145,
0.8917643428,
0.2187885493,
-0.283254385,
-0.3498577178,
0.0456421934,
-0.399200201,
-0.5189441442,
1.0935739279,
-0.2530313134,
-1.1061086655,
-0.1844677925,
-0.4741201103,
-0.4311393201,
0.5553760529,
0.2794843614,
0.3092477322,
-0.2470179051,
0.3738992214,
1.1108478308,
-0.1419771165,
0.5026985407,
0.890419364,
-0.2280351669,
0.0579741225,
0.757270813,
-0.1729065627,
0.7278302312,
0.0937253609,
0.3010715246,
-0.2976180017,
-0.617210269,
-0.1863280237,
0.1583707035,
-0.5394133329,
-0.1570389122,
-0.2981425226,
-0.0663518235,
-0.181617111,
-0.2719593048,
-0.4774167836,
-0.2267805636,
-0.1668844968,
-0.2032058388,
0.1331010312,
0.7165516615,
0.098137483,
0.0153206112,
-0.3167439997,
0.2561051846,
0.2037917525,
0.573492527,
0.2806741297,
-0.5963938832,
0.0799348503,
0.394892633,
-0.4613170624,
-0.6713370085,
-0.034495037,
-0.2100930065,
0.4822345376,
0.4882558286,
0.4714688063,
0.6597253084,
-0.3295431733,
0.5132024884,
0.0507212803,
-0.6106443405,
0.5380103588,
-0.6136259437,
-0.1054329202,
0.5614845157,
0.1172197238,
-0.2485707104,
-0.5887018442,
-0.7848036289,
-0.8047657609,
0.6454719901,
0.1500227749,
0.2597734332,
0.0727651119,
0.5598951578,
0.1664470136,
0.403837502,
-0.7088358998,
-0.2446888685,
0.0743117407,
0.265083611,
0.13438797,
-0.2865917683,
-0.5469887853,
-0.0416082107,
0.6220142841,
-0.2620956302,
0.0607134812,
0.1130000353,
-0.0364236385,
-0.4553197622,
0.4872536361,
0.6681538224,
0.6108500957,
0.0852933004,
0.3262835443,
0.0176466219,
-0.2509880364,
0.115427725,
-0.2707155049,
-0.196459651,
-0.3901435137,
0.1770557612,
0.5668703914,
0.4122499526,
-0.4738250077,
0.2781361043,
0.076711677,
-0.2038820237,
-0.0156426001,
0.2739384472,
-0.0018563227,
0.0819124579,
-0.004991116,
0.4446016252,
0.2801627219,
-0.7930753827,
0.3093768656,
0.8218913078,
-0.4352623522,
-0.2062550485,
0.5198158026,
0.0994474143,
-0.324184835,
0.3803573251,
0.0049651586,
-0.3325294256,
0.5544558764,
0.5902737975,
0.5664061904,
-0.1694791168,
0.4297105372,
-0.0393047892,
0.4801310599,
-0.1349458694,
0.1291811168,
-0.005734615,
-0.7425038218,
-0.4379725754,
-0.3319120705,
-0.2011372745,
0.4564445317,
-0.9722627997,
0.1412715763,
-0.8039992452,
0.0704039633,
-0.0974907205,
-0.0591451116,
-0.3901697695,
0.1233843416,
-0.152082175,
1.0677452087,
-0.7555314898,
0.5567167997,
0.5756123662,
-0.3190918565,
-0.8718919754,
0.3848822713,
0.2204830647,
-0.7639306188,
-0.0791889727,
0.1640311331,
-0.6133600473,
0.0816032588,
-0.8560560346,
-0.5417053103,
0.7731210589,
0.5530229211,
-0.680038631,
0.261995703,
0.0938741565,
0.4916802645,
-0.0725511685,
-0.0898990408,
0.8796470761,
0.4599336982,
0.1818041056,
-0.8740914464,
0.4707505107,
0.0968523473,
-0.1264956892,
0.1363595128,
-1.0645908117,
0.5885109305,
-0.5489838123,
-0.1478984058,
0.3298228681,
0.4393442273,
0.5941548347,
0.4347553551,
0.5537141562,
0.4612952471,
0.8031868339,
-0.1007056236,
0.9259442091,
0.046420604,
0.2621361315,
0.9348044991,
-0.1104510576,
0.675637126,
0.9750212431,
0.2093522847,
0.4161249399,
0.6808701158,
0.2965239882,
0.6463792324,
0.5691711307,
-0.0417520367,
-0.5177179575,
-0.196447134,
-0.1942548752,
0.3395877481,
0.534430027,
-0.0031847423,
-0.2005999982,
-0.071727477,
0.1308276802,
0.3967033029,
-0.5025970936,
0.5242770314,
0.2167878747,
-0.986141026,
0.7703611851,
0.1431438029,
0.6432648301,
-0.3563655615,
-0.0353097618,
-0.1681893319,
0.2249004394,
-0.3563820422,
-0.7802550793,
0.4716474116,
-0.1343219131,
-0.388551563,
-0.2259217352,
0.793174684,
-0.2224814743,
-0.0703061894,
0.2996636331,
0.3230427802,
-0.1171674803,
-0.0373542085,
-0.921558857,
0.2497941256,
0.1972453743,
-0.3585373461,
0.4248783886,
0.6823291183,
-0.3810596466,
1.030888319,
0.8295837045,
-0.2097403854,
-0.2625852227,
0.1713569909,
1.0414990187,
-0.4775735736,
-0.7384311557,
-0.838249445,
0.4599081874,
0.205380559,
0.0088752583,
0.6254653931,
0.213912487,
0.9670813084,
0.057202857,
0.5595580339,
0.0543758906,
0.3629690409,
-0.760684371,
0.6973568201,
-0.4954399765,
0.7082946301,
-0.3145189881,
-0.4529462755,
-0.0627625138,
0.5012854338,
-0.2838500142,
0.2382173985,
0.6370797753,
0.9466385245,
-0.0496289283,
0.3548330069,
0.3030906916,
0.5279262662,
0.4089668393,
0.5909320116,
0.9147933125,
-0.2533943355,
0.5268645287,
-0.0290543232,
-0.2220360041,
-0.4100536406,
-0.7765999436,
-0.9694069028,
-0.2870407104,
-0.2120455503,
-0.6986988187,
0.0927966535,
0.5265657306,
0.455832988,
-0.9132804275,
0.0299024396,
-0.5411167741,
0.2737637758,
-0.3137074113,
-0.2333323658,
-0.0501096249,
-0.0928469747,
-0.3734577894,
0.3638652265,
-0.0045095268,
0.152591005,
-0.4311532378,
-0.2362213582,
-0.1760746837,
0.3813055456,
0.4574821889,
0.4292686284,
-1.0219190121,
-0.4207597971,
0.0353405289,
0.0766668096,
-0.2937101126,
0.9511339068,
-0.7682567835,
0.2384818047,
0.0568357371,
0.4680013359,
0.1460828334,
-0.1086505204,
0.6674101353,
-0.6167930365,
0.1040618792,
0.1280072778,
0.0534046069,
0.2733408511,
-0.6018288732,
0.2277608663,
0.0982051268,
-0.3101378381,
-1.1283693314,
0.6654576063,
-0.5989444852,
-0.462485522,
0.9713094831,
0.0374451466,
-0.1719451398,
-0.2092521787,
-0.3692769706,
0.0590831153,
-0.31414482,
1.089075923,
0.9760448933,
-0.2690971792,
-0.2224097699,
-0.4972550273,
0.8091749549,
0.7816473246,
-0.3745931983,
0.5405035615,
0.5022738576,
0.4061047137,
0.0975433514,
0.5298725963,
-0.1793098003,
0.4159536958,
-0.3418399692,
-0.669359982,
-0.1806595325,
-0.6805903912,
-0.4127337337,
0.0332537591,
0.2269796282,
0.0819864199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19545v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19545v1 | Leveraging Machine-Generated Rationales to Facilitate Social Meaning Detection in Conversations | 2024-06-27T21:47:42 | 2024-06-27T21:47:42 | Ritam Dutt, Zhen Wu, Kelly Shi, Divyanshu Sheth, Prakhar Gupta, Carolyn Penstein Rose | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present a generalizable classification approach that leverages Large
Language Models (LLMs) to facilitate the detection of implicitly encoded social
meaning in conversations. We design a multi-faceted prompt to extract a textual
explanation of the reasoning that connects visible cues to underlying social
meanings. These extracted explanations or rationales serve as augmentations to
the conversational text to facilitate dialogue understanding and transfer. Our
empirical results over 2,340 experimental settings demonstrate the significant
positive impact of adding these rationales. Our findings hold true for
in-domain classification, zero-shot, and few-shot domain transfer for two
different social meaning detection tasks, each spanning two different corpora. | [
-0.2933736444,
-1.0718715191,
0.9560813904,
0.2727404833,
-0.5053287745,
0.0698266551,
-0.1832686663,
-0.5386065841,
0.1696796119,
0.4647045135,
-0.5217887163,
-0.4588222802,
-0.9244151115,
0.1255755723,
-0.3015980721,
0.8094910979,
0.08911217,
-0.0941815376,
-0.255934,
-0.2567369342,
-0.3568666875,
-0.7633385062,
-0.8006971478,
-0.3585703969,
0.8881267309,
0.4674946964,
0.6413097382,
0.4342498779,
0.1479501575,
0.3076850474,
-0.1620342284,
0.5402448773,
-0.4364543259,
0.2083947957,
-0.2744676173,
-0.4826959372,
-0.241571486,
0.1505599916,
0.5863263607,
0.8572996259,
0.3708337545,
0.2907699943,
0.1577819735,
0.3597033024,
-0.4101702571,
0.4238329828,
-0.6980286241,
-0.1409899145,
0.037304908,
-0.5729131699,
-0.5910332203,
-0.369428426,
0.1332481354,
-0.3562465906,
-0.0503386296,
0.0145106968,
0.8397029638,
-0.0599612482,
-0.4937841594,
-0.4908706844,
-0.6237496734,
0.8423603773,
-0.3194645643,
0.1431651413,
0.2262581885,
0.5330317616,
-0.1981239766,
-0.6496656537,
-0.8883236647,
0.1129928455,
-0.2892690003,
-0.176458925,
-0.1839561462,
0.040978007,
0.3403058052,
0.026032418,
-0.1920019537,
-0.2520959377,
-0.28399086,
-0.0779583231,
0.699036777,
0.2754462957,
0.4146632552,
-0.3364441395,
-0.122095108,
0.0858524144,
-0.6215535402,
0.217073828,
0.157831043,
0.3446000814,
-0.3641816676,
0.4927097261,
-0.0294453017,
0.2761232853,
0.0566656478,
-0.1120390967,
0.0452435799,
-0.4435888529,
-0.2444927692,
0.0589845031,
0.7262204289,
0.5371725559,
0.6905681491,
-0.0357164554,
0.0654018372,
0.2292921245,
-0.2570995986,
-0.9233970642,
0.1317475885,
0.1110301092,
-0.4343370795,
-0.5351570845,
-0.1252757162,
-0.5855020285,
-0.5409916043,
-0.601603806,
-0.0040343786,
-0.233494848,
-0.3001880646,
0.234805733,
-0.5114648938,
0.6955246329,
0.7088137269,
-0.9114785194,
0.0759384409,
0.7797349095,
0.901394546,
0.0426721908,
0.1875718683,
-0.5458645821,
0.4410257041,
-0.3268791437,
1.1606779099,
-0.7333859801,
-0.3732386231,
0.2135340273,
0.3335516453,
-0.1396916062,
-0.1899778843,
0.3726237714,
-0.4267429113,
0.3989903927,
-0.3181430399,
-0.5325855017,
-0.2425441891,
0.3444950581,
-0.2002779096,
0.8191123009,
-0.0920826867,
-0.5207343698,
0.2988373339,
-0.6053009629,
-0.5209200978,
0.5888399482,
-0.3309532404,
0.0083395382,
0.0944833979,
0.0116615752,
0.8065602183,
-0.2824962735,
0.3995595872,
-0.7645742893,
-0.2372740209,
0.7523738146,
-0.6875008941,
0.7720483541,
0.2512837052,
-0.3361755311,
0.1442359984,
-0.502376914,
-0.0119298361,
0.2017581165,
-0.1654687524,
-0.3980323374,
0.0150713529,
-0.2421361953,
0.185323596,
0.0136750014,
-0.3027350605,
-0.101122722,
-0.2512674034,
0.5692468882,
0.9701809883,
0.0847987235,
0.765910387,
-0.2914341688,
0.4683306217,
-0.0734831393,
0.1119883731,
-0.2766147554,
-0.7796568871,
-0.7605031729,
-0.57444489,
-0.0533991791,
0.6617500186,
-0.7060674429,
0.3629991114,
-0.272388339,
-0.0313100927,
-0.4100014269,
0.1078668907,
-0.0604752861,
0.3328483999,
0.1151592955,
0.2523359954,
-0.4536837041,
-0.7793975472,
-0.3875790238,
-0.2937776148,
-0.3270879388,
0.6363978386,
0.5194550157,
-0.4554932415,
0.8289325237,
-0.540076077,
-0.0231432319,
-0.5549398065,
0.2722552121,
-0.0138259344,
0.0326378345,
0.3847689629,
-0.657562077,
-0.5381080508,
0.1242851093,
-1.1425732374,
-0.3661768436,
-0.3011843562,
-0.4068133235,
0.1082875058,
0.6411827207,
-0.7095356584,
0.5449529886,
0.1153815538,
-0.2924361229,
0.2913559377,
0.2326038182,
0.3034285605,
-1.1524269581,
-0.190114513,
0.1323830634,
-0.3377951384,
-0.676007092,
-0.3432987928,
-0.3082996905,
0.0266611408,
-0.4694873691,
0.7735392451,
-0.2965405583,
0.0218186919,
-0.0899101347,
0.6952105165,
0.2138728201,
0.3256368637,
0.0522690266,
0.4896622598,
0.2807264924,
-0.5309870839,
0.4877693355,
0.1165389493,
-0.1601651013,
0.9077649713,
-0.7921577096,
0.313685298,
-0.4716769159,
0.3652924597,
-1.3612259626,
-0.4795632362,
0.688470304,
-0.7324036956,
-0.1022803038,
-0.4977542162,
-0.6549959779,
-0.0068373,
-0.37826249,
0.231403321,
0.3834809959,
-0.6233382821,
0.8315750957,
0.5772736669,
-0.3128974438,
0.0214607604,
-0.499399662,
0.0824132413,
-0.5908727646,
-1.050699234,
0.1425655633,
-0.0783078521,
-0.5835779309,
-0.1244331226,
0.3331611454,
0.0401802734,
0.243457675,
0.374371022,
0.5050395727,
-0.2475781441,
0.4394280612,
0.3826090395,
-0.0367044285,
0.4463280737,
-0.0501545928,
0.4912117422,
-0.1499242634,
-0.1716519147,
-0.3750069141,
0.5949586034,
0.7321670055,
0.2261294872,
0.9438599944,
0.6060917377,
-0.41915676,
-0.3551256657,
-0.454258889,
-0.1312806308,
-0.5467527509,
-0.2290219367,
-0.3734168708,
-1.1421869993,
0.5627129674,
-0.2678773403,
-0.1467224061,
0.0801206082,
0.452337712,
-0.2312648296,
1.5543557405,
0.2450856119,
0.2035385221,
0.5935325623,
0.0707614496,
0.4094502926,
-0.6876039505,
-0.3269523084,
-0.4722898304,
0.0246094689,
-0.5065124631,
-0.5682255626,
0.1168186143,
0.01763965,
-0.0622414537,
0.0014848741,
-0.5024754405,
0.5753631592,
0.1827023774,
0.0391017124,
0.2500170469,
0.1492236108,
0.2017447054,
0.1765432805,
-0.4069994986,
-1.015288353,
0.7260002494,
0.4511185288,
0.6118439436,
0.1854176819,
0.580103755,
0.3661967814,
0.6562430263,
-1.1001173258,
0.7339004874,
0.2371948212,
-0.4474788308,
-0.1898119897,
-0.4421539307,
-1.0052374601,
0.3941441774,
-0.3499267697,
-0.9640243053,
-0.0756503344,
-0.0011891308,
-0.2407570183,
-0.1095781401,
-0.8645887375,
0.739434123,
-0.2031648457,
-0.2101914138,
-0.2584317923,
-0.3322052062,
0.4779163301,
0.1459966749,
0.4697535336,
-0.3842890263,
0.317310065,
0.575902462,
-0.1720126122,
1.0976580381,
-0.1697764844,
-0.0907117799,
0.4001577497,
-0.210050568,
0.4390563965,
0.1561672837,
0.144867301,
0.1835196763,
-0.0253075324,
-0.2920838296,
-0.881857276,
0.4653164148,
-0.4407297671,
-0.7233719826,
-0.195162043,
-0.4581283629,
0.0104463752,
-0.046470508,
-0.1112937927,
0.4175612032,
-0.1174084619,
0.3926756978,
0.8065652847,
-0.4481800497,
-0.0135168917,
0.4541815817,
-0.2074266076,
-0.1503176093,
0.5918796659,
-0.0867533237,
0.4063419104,
0.1751890481,
0.3313507736,
-0.5464186668,
-0.1712472439,
-0.5668750405,
0.352663219,
-1.1449356079,
0.039673958,
-0.8702478409,
-0.0565921851,
-0.5612612963,
-0.5418673754,
0.3474000096,
-0.1667965204,
-0.5370515585,
-0.2921880484,
0.6122246385,
0.5547857285,
-0.0497560054,
0.4124273658,
-0.9455691576,
0.4189597368,
0.4110488594,
0.0441175029,
-0.1151002645,
-0.609128952,
0.1157004237,
0.300825119,
-0.0361828469,
-1.0233496428,
0.3712321818,
0.0877484828,
0.7282172441,
0.4491581321,
-0.0244636424,
0.6653348207,
-0.3881192803,
0.637535274,
0.3095458448,
-1.0583639145,
0.8423238397,
-0.3430441618,
0.0697849244,
0.288706243,
0.4152491689,
-0.75349015,
-0.3187130988,
-0.5194609165,
-0.6606997252,
0.58549124,
0.0031735722,
0.5446838737,
-0.4338591099,
0.4366183281,
-0.2627261877,
-0.0929909125,
-0.5820083022,
-0.141779989,
0.008414546,
-0.4114993811,
0.2721251547,
-0.3844768107,
-0.1867583096,
-0.2397503853,
0.3189071119,
-0.466542542,
0.4263352752,
0.0181560703,
-0.2802245319,
-0.1267492473,
0.3840414882,
0.4188311398,
0.335978061,
0.0186549816,
0.4207489491,
0.3242788315,
0.0105708707,
-0.0855982229,
-0.0011745841,
0.0804556236,
-0.0000502779,
0.3484284282,
0.7023258209,
0.2351505905,
-0.4845286906,
0.6619490981,
-0.3692481816,
-0.255548805,
-0.2626619637,
0.0374572799,
0.269222945,
0.3472427428,
0.2323900908,
-0.3502139151,
0.15873909,
-1.0182374716,
0.2208409607,
0.7948079109,
-0.2810936868,
-0.5207674503,
0.2592635453,
0.3485693038,
-0.4823587239,
0.2985908091,
-0.2828932106,
-0.716570735,
0.3580498099,
0.3919738531,
1.0279076099,
0.0515566431,
0.609089613,
0.1176877171,
0.034865737,
0.1168684065,
0.0705821738,
-0.4317311049,
-1.186185956,
-0.5854182839,
-0.5465380549,
-0.6043697596,
0.0771969706,
-0.4900323749,
0.3888398707,
-0.4378881454,
0.0245944113,
0.6972241998,
-0.4600559771,
-0.5479151011,
-0.3412167728,
0.5210959911,
0.4779511392,
-1.0214211941,
0.7116645575,
0.3747628927,
-0.4304058254,
-0.8070662618,
-0.2192420214,
0.1210299134,
-1.0181412697,
1.0147993565,
0.4241956472,
-0.5424333811,
-0.2640497088,
-1.0401653051,
-0.4766335487,
0.8720371723,
0.2857820094,
-0.0354282036,
0.1640325934,
0.4197098613,
0.5623505712,
-0.693816781,
0.3204301894,
0.5993430018,
0.520460844,
0.5927808285,
-0.4852121174,
0.2302357256,
-0.268001318,
-0.047432255,
0.0468935519,
-0.0429398604,
0.3400561512,
0.0213716514,
-0.7729522586,
-0.1462289095,
0.502004683,
0.4103399217,
0.6471295953,
0.5278321505,
-0.0793904215,
0.7922326922,
-0.0516985506,
1.0172761679,
-0.1298475564,
0.0104613844,
0.6716482639,
-0.3665425181,
0.4989326894,
0.4089634717,
0.0209297724,
0.7966277003,
0.5138921738,
0.4555326402,
0.1832511723,
0.1351699382,
-0.6003527641,
-0.5003922582,
-0.5069170594,
-0.0034568564,
0.1964376867,
0.9191476107,
-0.5513922572,
-0.0992666706,
-0.195780918,
0.1820934266,
-0.0051642284,
-0.2358687669,
0.9669343233,
0.4327234328,
-0.7441474795,
0.5553278923,
-0.3068233132,
0.5397853255,
-0.3708390892,
-0.3592336476,
-0.0887754485,
0.2642348707,
-0.2106358856,
-1.0044472218,
0.46013394,
0.0314484797,
-0.0163240954,
-0.5411010981,
1.1933152676,
-0.4670474827,
-0.2883177996,
0.4641692936,
0.4909422994,
0.3619700372,
-0.1746845692,
-0.8043891191,
0.1585536599,
-0.0272868928,
-0.0265191123,
0.3191441298,
1.1523275375,
-0.2008305937,
0.5624727607,
1.0572831631,
-0.2773841321,
-0.1153773665,
0.4106637836,
0.959420383,
-0.5924473405,
-0.2802720666,
-1.0558674335,
0.5334191322,
-0.4115985334,
0.0162176415,
0.765098393,
-0.0295193866,
0.5307884216,
0.2717655599,
0.8419528604,
0.2901626825,
0.3604823351,
-0.3459734023,
0.2763951719,
-0.2249490619,
0.433203578,
-0.4288688898,
-0.5692882538,
-0.3432990015,
0.9342346191,
-0.6178049445,
-0.3766723573,
0.4547594488,
0.7859464884,
0.2127103955,
0.2789665163,
0.4297987521,
-0.1399610341,
0.5287895799,
0.3113163412,
1.3813269138,
-0.0181720313,
0.6183062196,
0.3372083604,
-0.569221437,
-0.2204041183,
-0.8102713227,
-1.2940403223,
-0.2749490738,
-0.2875141501,
-0.5087705851,
-0.0331316367,
0.9833551645,
0.5168405771,
-0.5410044789,
-0.1470189393,
-0.0144684585,
0.5171639919,
0.254336834,
-0.364531219,
-0.0027375915,
-0.593847394,
-0.5482048392,
0.2237624377,
0.4977167249,
0.0758189932,
-0.0993907526,
-0.1881594658,
-0.07619185,
0.6283002496,
1.2865226269,
-0.0900830403,
-0.6674138904,
-0.8905318379,
0.2058966905,
-0.0343949459,
-0.1659632623,
0.594925344,
-0.5701615214,
0.0801494643,
0.6323900819,
0.524110198,
0.394726485,
0.0622286499,
0.610062778,
-0.6168615222,
-0.018191779,
-0.0445532687,
0.4117273092,
0.4230313003,
-0.6650027633,
0.4566949904,
0.4810658693,
-0.3442937136,
-0.8451851606,
0.4242116213,
-1.0134657621,
-0.3495607376,
1.6598272324,
-0.2956925929,
-0.4095020294,
-0.5053133965,
-0.2796938121,
0.2141948938,
-0.4935966134,
0.699190259,
0.7238589525,
-0.0150146438,
-0.362647146,
-0.3567255735,
0.4345423281,
0.0831194893,
-1.1268651485,
0.2264726609,
0.6868166924,
0.1396293193,
0.2666390538,
0.8928083181,
-0.1890397072,
0.1378762424,
-0.3441749513,
-0.2830604613,
0.3608185649,
-0.0146410903,
-0.1836968213,
0.1320958734,
-0.1717428863,
-0.1218216121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19543v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19543v1 | Demarked: A Strategy for Enhanced Abusive Speech Moderation through Counterspeech, Detoxification, and Message Management | 2024-06-27T21:45:33 | 2024-06-27T21:45:33 | Seid Muhie Yimam, Daryna Dementieva, Tim Fischer, Daniil Moskovskiy, Naquee Rizwan, Punyajoy Saha, Sarthak Roy, Martin Semmann, Alexander Panchenko, Chris Biemann, Animesh Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Despite regulations imposed by nations and social media platforms, such as
recent EU regulations targeting digital violence, abusive content persists as a
significant challenge. Existing approaches primarily rely on binary solutions,
such as outright blocking or banning, yet fail to address the complex nature of
abusive speech. In this work, we propose a more comprehensive approach called
Demarcation scoring abusive speech based on four aspect -- (i) severity scale;
(ii) presence of a target; (iii) context scale; (iv) legal scale -- and
suggesting more options of actions like detoxification, counter speech
generation, blocking, or, as a final measure, human intervention. Through a
thorough analysis of abusive speech regulations across diverse jurisdictions,
platforms, and research papers we highlight the gap in preventing measures and
advocate for tailored proactive steps to combat its multifaceted
manifestations. Our work aims to inform future strategies for effectively
addressing abusive speech online. | [
-0.5650568604,
-1.1122608185,
0.2788814604,
0.1481579989,
-0.5185551643,
0.5134856105,
-0.0293317046,
-0.38593328,
0.3772847652,
0.6452037692,
-0.6347091198,
-0.5224186778,
-1.0349649191,
0.0699399486,
-0.595289886,
1.0572293997,
0.1491872519,
0.2020236552,
-0.1787960976,
-0.0349981859,
-0.7107632756,
-0.7117102146,
-0.6457917094,
-0.2088519633,
0.740842402,
0.219535619,
0.5661492348,
0.6257404685,
0.890111804,
0.3431485593,
-0.0976412892,
-0.1091966555,
-0.7979347706,
0.6075865626,
-0.2661147714,
-0.2681768537,
-0.7029370666,
0.0200279448,
0.4320701063,
0.2989021838,
-0.4229110777,
0.1841829717,
-0.0993413925,
0.3572869599,
-0.7406870723,
-0.4009100497,
-0.5170718431,
0.0720213503,
-0.3089884222,
-0.2400148213,
-0.1038862541,
-0.3298992515,
-0.4734496474,
-0.2072648108,
-0.3828225136,
-0.366351217,
0.5418149233,
0.3900669515,
-0.3375353515,
-0.4523020387,
-1.0692261457,
0.8829092383,
-0.6280629635,
0.3294410706,
0.6272004247,
0.1773728132,
0.1289427727,
-0.9407482743,
-0.2756306827,
0.1748617142,
0.0944340527,
0.1655983776,
-0.8873853683,
0.0963472351,
0.3138855994,
0.1186623126,
0.0553142987,
0.3543524444,
-0.4868687391,
-0.3025822937,
0.7996391654,
0.5512610674,
0.4134872258,
0.1211493835,
-0.5027934909,
0.196952939,
-0.4078289866,
-0.2786370218,
1.1622743607,
0.4868236184,
-0.1457493007,
0.1461341679,
-0.0238481518,
0.3030391335,
0.3751399219,
-0.078889057,
0.0808975473,
-0.1428662091,
0.1825480312,
0.3638430238,
0.7415708303,
0.7266274095,
0.0365507379,
0.1526206285,
-0.4219947755,
0.0169105027,
0.8032697439,
-1.0773234367,
-0.2412768602,
0.5178301334,
-0.360023886,
-0.622020781,
-0.2921985984,
-1.3148642778,
-0.9309360385,
-0.3772216737,
0.4539763927,
-0.2910458446,
-0.7323508859,
-0.3108841479,
-0.4649778903,
0.020839965,
0.2019717693,
-0.794878304,
0.8986195326,
0.6491695642,
0.6765247583,
-0.0584433153,
0.3326744139,
-0.3813051283,
-0.1013641208,
-0.5350418687,
0.4475957155,
-1.2528260946,
-0.1383940279,
0.1080298871,
-0.4206809402,
0.3499387205,
-0.5642076135,
0.9794709682,
-0.7817993164,
0.3470722437,
-0.3757162988,
-0.2332270145,
-0.4739759266,
0.4402477443,
-0.556270659,
0.7329080105,
0.0854332745,
-0.8434084058,
0.4497220814,
-0.6075556278,
-0.3004490733,
0.158844918,
-0.0185127519,
-0.5077890754,
-0.0283894464,
0.1410380453,
0.2480878979,
0.1254225969,
0.3137967885,
-0.2297618836,
-0.3371539712,
-0.0349662118,
-0.8085496426,
0.7668797374,
0.4365768135,
-0.4429984689,
0.4653584361,
-0.526533246,
0.0758270621,
-0.0295566302,
-0.2189983875,
-0.5136705637,
0.0387629084,
0.262785852,
0.2903363109,
0.0382761285,
-0.5928604603,
-0.2833747268,
-0.2986802459,
0.4294061959,
0.7565630674,
0.3091922402,
-0.0749095455,
-0.4439289868,
0.7627102733,
0.0912454724,
0.2247205824,
0.1109296903,
0.1111215129,
-0.2654674649,
-0.654899478,
0.098551482,
0.4267994761,
-0.2867774665,
0.3681311011,
-0.3249391615,
-0.5171926022,
-0.5014338493,
-0.0848272592,
0.4259847999,
0.1147819012,
0.6587589383,
-0.4798597693,
-0.6863073707,
-0.8889114261,
-0.2898812592,
0.015438403,
0.1825857311,
0.0274185892,
0.3704889119,
-0.1403189898,
0.6377317309,
0.0677604675,
-0.3678158522,
-0.3821029663,
0.2457950115,
-0.2339945436,
0.0969913751,
0.6633983254,
-0.9141156077,
-0.4852077663,
-0.3667432368,
-0.2220174372,
-0.5047146082,
-0.1586964875,
0.1200664192,
-0.5529435277,
0.6006996036,
0.0962087065,
0.3612814248,
0.4109450281,
-0.1859495789,
0.4773905873,
0.3219480217,
0.5876280069,
-0.9495857954,
-0.1243807301,
-0.4095529616,
-0.4964309633,
-1.0076996088,
-0.0047483039,
-0.4831508994,
-0.0535423346,
-0.5788622499,
0.2342330813,
-0.055797819,
0.5896544456,
-0.4281719923,
0.3986408412,
-0.2547704279,
0.3013479412,
-0.3089560866,
0.4679216444,
0.6736088991,
-0.4845989943,
0.6557791233,
0.2373935729,
0.3463081717,
1.1916023493,
-0.5377991199,
0.3210722804,
-0.2414791733,
0.1503797323,
-0.8852143288,
-0.1450778246,
0.622612834,
-0.1441196352,
0.3512586951,
-0.1498515457,
-0.2706254423,
-0.2393845618,
-0.643915832,
0.622846663,
0.3017837703,
-0.1371076852,
0.6530727148,
0.8417531848,
-0.3868374228,
-0.5703353882,
-0.2366443127,
0.630843699,
-0.8044050932,
-0.1250774562,
0.4153131843,
0.087346293,
-0.7263159156,
-0.2374260128,
-0.0689424574,
0.0338635407,
0.1205832288,
0.3743142784,
-0.5849140882,
0.316657722,
-0.0181435589,
0.2909644842,
0.0701758787,
0.5081062913,
0.4599369764,
0.9473289847,
0.086420767,
-0.2980454266,
-0.6483586431,
0.5288810134,
0.6231626272,
-0.0860681832,
0.2463870794,
0.7620071769,
-0.5062425137,
-0.2150526643,
-0.1838618219,
-0.5630648136,
-0.4806984961,
0.4739943147,
-0.2948250771,
-0.3371509314,
0.6867764592,
-0.5935350657,
0.2571014166,
0.2008582652,
0.8283078074,
0.054172568,
1.0610147715,
0.3660383523,
0.0276630893,
0.5717793107,
0.0441514961,
0.3933227062,
-0.5417137742,
-0.167874679,
-0.3383890688,
-0.649826467,
-0.5572649837,
-0.1989637762,
0.0618148074,
0.1952413917,
-0.4501451552,
0.3652569056,
-0.4692457914,
0.3474103808,
0.0700386092,
0.0553879552,
0.1414739341,
0.0802541971,
-0.2399317175,
-0.3241789937,
-0.4001799822,
-0.5549766421,
0.57115978,
0.75393188,
0.635789752,
0.3233679235,
0.6996540427,
0.7732605934,
0.3609489501,
-0.8012248874,
0.5359905958,
0.0020339647,
-0.8767960668,
-0.169246465,
-0.3250824213,
-0.8335134983,
0.4169187844,
-0.1786985248,
-1.0408762693,
0.0153422989,
-0.1092499942,
-0.3111133277,
0.5003672838,
-0.2106330395,
0.3988771141,
-0.20434995,
-0.5601115227,
-0.7492756844,
-0.4850715697,
0.1602290124,
-0.3016374111,
0.7074593306,
-0.3582766652,
-0.1597401798,
1.2489624023,
-0.3996576369,
1.3061600924,
-0.3018377423,
-0.2566932142,
0.3830195069,
0.321467489,
0.2713801265,
-0.2188917398,
-0.1246155649,
0.457662195,
0.3381850421,
0.011454761,
-0.3333059251,
0.5393754244,
-0.6183769107,
-0.5883085132,
-0.2964889705,
-0.2641345263,
-0.2930169404,
0.4003100991,
0.0794050619,
0.7266979814,
-0.29780972,
0.1988822073,
0.3432826698,
-0.1274285465,
0.4310825765,
0.2521987855,
-0.2829548419,
-0.8843932748,
0.7849007249,
-0.1430646181,
0.225675866,
0.0330420174,
0.4232379198,
-0.4928794503,
-0.4806771278,
-0.2506983876,
-0.1194068193,
-0.8846002221,
-0.514157176,
-0.6020904779,
-0.179449141,
-0.28284958,
-0.0891694576,
-0.525419116,
-0.0480399095,
0.0429525115,
-0.1549112052,
0.3626005054,
0.8941585422,
-0.5024244785,
0.4079291821,
-0.459454596,
0.3407894671,
-0.0308085661,
0.5298262835,
-0.1991451234,
-0.9202700853,
0.2814923525,
0.2951951027,
-0.5136791468,
-1.1159416437,
0.2253861725,
0.1068864018,
0.4986688495,
0.7097720504,
0.4662108421,
1.0077112913,
-0.5470445752,
0.7042847872,
0.536455214,
-0.6988715529,
0.6179318428,
-0.4521103501,
-0.1872381568,
0.577236414,
0.573552072,
-0.8831985593,
-0.8164245486,
-0.5329104662,
-0.9880837202,
0.2822449207,
0.1784214824,
1.1187720299,
-0.1619133204,
-0.0882319584,
0.010776584,
0.4511807859,
-0.5746656656,
-0.2901553512,
-0.0261231419,
-0.1940701455,
0.6631249189,
-0.4086695015,
-0.8492321968,
-0.515216291,
0.3506330848,
0.3923669457,
0.1441452503,
-0.155001089,
0.1652908325,
-0.4601064622,
0.3324632347,
0.5843347311,
0.9028684497,
0.0427427888,
0.2453876883,
0.074428156,
-0.9904431105,
0.0640279651,
-0.3063553274,
-0.0446024798,
-0.1697181165,
0.5246302485,
0.6764682531,
0.211933136,
-0.5618306398,
0.6111860275,
0.0305546522,
-0.386593014,
-0.2304815203,
0.1329351217,
-0.3452688754,
0.2007830292,
0.0878108218,
-0.0855444521,
0.0832713619,
-0.4906916618,
0.590705514,
0.3626271486,
-1.011128068,
-0.1958259195,
0.7583468556,
0.4516333938,
-0.3716078699,
0.3950200975,
-0.1973170489,
-0.7812124491,
0.1344199926,
0.5449645519,
0.8837981224,
-0.1716298908,
0.4009279609,
0.4790650904,
0.2195881903,
0.4344319701,
0.3698325157,
0.1162755787,
-0.6318981051,
-0.1501394957,
-0.8086311221,
-0.0454368405,
0.4120956957,
-0.7155270576,
0.3635365367,
-0.9498003125,
-0.5007118583,
-0.0152240703,
0.0982704014,
-0.2963679731,
0.0565283448,
0.3690406978,
0.5680643916,
-1.0784708261,
-0.0061788321,
0.4473681152,
-0.3530852795,
-0.487398982,
0.0630637035,
0.3596894145,
-0.4483463466,
0.2736071348,
0.0798238888,
-0.4675750136,
0.1084768921,
-0.6264885664,
-0.6106390357,
0.5103299022,
0.1430265009,
-0.6515238285,
0.6919372678,
0.0835364237,
0.8415148854,
-0.0333171189,
0.3242782652,
0.5873528123,
0.5972964168,
0.2741326988,
-0.8093476295,
0.2835201621,
0.0048661772,
-0.4647969902,
0.3126981258,
-0.5870725513,
0.3181767464,
-0.1954875737,
-0.6587604284,
-0.3659932911,
0.046074301,
-0.3342484236,
0.043890629,
0.6063848734,
0.6469092965,
0.7723641396,
-0.059819717,
0.6535602808,
-0.1356725246,
-0.0339375325,
0.9833943844,
-0.1261680573,
0.8434850574,
0.3641227782,
-0.2894055843,
0.786934495,
0.6384009719,
-0.257240504,
0.7719148397,
0.3742150068,
-0.4636165798,
-0.4145403802,
-0.5136688352,
-0.187424168,
0.8376330733,
0.5339400172,
-0.3342449367,
-0.5720539689,
0.2159952372,
0.3193234205,
0.6373859048,
-0.3026559353,
1.0627108812,
-0.0369887687,
0.0291929916,
0.4627432227,
0.2535511851,
0.3197472095,
-0.3165426552,
-0.2665936053,
-0.0939564109,
-0.0071029672,
-0.2738176584,
-0.6642203927,
0.4456843138,
0.1281716675,
0.2234584838,
-0.5946803093,
0.7148911953,
-0.2950073779,
-0.3208673596,
0.4292994738,
0.4212549925,
0.3041035533,
0.0243699532,
-0.9825386405,
0.4176692963,
-0.3055324852,
-0.1104685217,
0.2638923824,
0.1964477301,
-0.2534905672,
0.6032420993,
0.4498216212,
0.3103829026,
-0.0752346516,
0.5467353463,
1.1559191942,
-0.410415709,
-0.4531601965,
-1.2711014748,
0.4884647727,
-0.4021235108,
-0.3089843988,
0.5292149186,
0.486720562,
0.6292479038,
0.5405215025,
0.5104193091,
-0.4616003335,
0.4147531092,
0.0452106036,
0.7596626878,
-0.2409399152,
0.184595868,
-0.4191112816,
-0.8131700754,
-0.3750873804,
0.1974314153,
-0.5648748875,
0.0699470639,
0.3641622663,
0.7221264839,
0.0288549531,
-0.2128773928,
0.4787761867,
0.188177973,
0.606730938,
-0.290378511,
0.9067237377,
-0.3452406228,
0.6637215614,
-0.2249429077,
-0.1120204553,
-0.0862443298,
-0.7035967112,
-0.9054613113,
-0.4763689637,
-0.3439581394,
-0.2045804113,
0.164994508,
0.6204214096,
0.6829766035,
-0.814021647,
0.2278469801,
0.2802883983,
0.1506112814,
-0.6523669958,
-0.2440682203,
0.0262629595,
-0.2514463365,
-0.8745231032,
0.1341565698,
0.4139751792,
-0.4127230048,
-0.3621620238,
0.1609957367,
-0.1098646745,
0.3556323647,
0.6371634007,
-0.1399263591,
-0.7743015885,
-0.419852972,
-0.4576889575,
-0.1937573701,
0.1039062366,
0.6103567481,
-0.3234788477,
0.6433458924,
0.4826710522,
0.4197364748,
0.0500877202,
0.8088642359,
0.4629471898,
-1.0644016266,
0.0455012992,
0.7449799776,
-0.1414435059,
0.2322860211,
-0.2252187729,
0.0008494151,
0.1067144349,
-0.1089175418,
-0.9387069345,
0.4325277805,
-0.5918591619,
-0.429250747,
1.2590409517,
0.166572988,
0.2350019217,
-0.4508872032,
-0.4032164514,
0.0339702219,
-0.3467325866,
1.0676183701,
0.6664984226,
-0.0055365856,
-0.1868661791,
-0.6815300584,
0.6719893217,
-0.1768009663,
-0.670641005,
0.6329419017,
0.5933747888,
0.3574064672,
0.3889475167,
0.5890623331,
-0.4467337132,
-0.1553058624,
0.4930928051,
-0.0705826879,
-0.0258412436,
-0.5504319668,
-0.2700244188,
0.3540022075,
-0.2876919806,
-0.1455241889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19538v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19538v1 | Context Matters: An Empirical Study of the Impact of Contextual Information in Temporal Question Answering Systems | 2024-06-27T21:31:30 | 2024-06-27T21:31:30 | Dan Schumacher, Fatemeh Haji, Tara Grey, Niharika Bandlamudi, Nupoor Karnik, Gagana Uday Kumar, Jason Cho-Yu Chiang, Paul Rad, Nishant Vishwamitra, Anthony Rios | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) often struggle with temporal reasoning, crucial
for tasks like historical event analysis and time-sensitive information
retrieval. Despite advancements, state-of-the-art models falter in handling
temporal information, especially when faced with irrelevant or noisy contexts.
This paper addresses this gap by empirically examining the robustness of
temporal question-answering (TQA) systems trained on various context types,
including relevant, irrelevant, slightly altered, and no context. Our findings
indicate that training with a mix of these contexts enhances model robustness
and accuracy. Additionally, we show that the position of context relative to
the question significantly impacts performance, with question-first positioning
yielding better results. We introduce two new context-rich TQA datasets,
ContextAQA and ContextTQE, and provide comprehensive evaluations and guidelines
for training robust TQA models. Our work lays the foundation for developing
reliable and context-aware temporal QA systems, with broader implications for
enhancing LLM robustness against diverse and potentially adversarial
information. | [
-0.1914124042,
-0.8794987202,
0.8888842463,
0.2208375633,
-0.1393753886,
-0.1941245794,
0.173607111,
-0.4514296651,
-0.344029367,
-0.2384869456,
-0.4733388424,
-0.1599689275,
-0.4239829481,
0.0161591526,
-0.3350732625,
0.6328620315,
0.0453533754,
0.1994817555,
-0.2829975486,
-0.588280499,
-0.6326309443,
-0.8692527413,
-0.7179383636,
-0.0755529255,
0.4650794566,
-0.1802172959,
0.6310193539,
0.4551367164,
-0.0386447012,
0.1950180084,
-0.3739201427,
-0.0342060849,
-0.2994648814,
0.4855914414,
-0.3384947479,
-0.5283395052,
-0.3270001113,
-0.2062693983,
0.6826554537,
0.6095961332,
-0.1369143128,
0.2919771373,
-0.1254109889,
0.0494606905,
-0.7969521284,
0.0719935969,
-0.843093574,
-0.0074250884,
-0.0432090499,
-0.590651691,
-0.2266993374,
-0.3787418604,
0.2992655635,
-0.5866259336,
-0.1330648363,
-0.1649520397,
0.8524888158,
0.3978812695,
-0.8018535376,
0.1238484234,
-0.7924815416,
0.8484860063,
-0.7567176819,
0.4670334756,
0.2847736478,
0.4188025296,
0.0331545137,
-0.5621951222,
-0.377212137,
0.3383831978,
0.0375031345,
0.064578332,
-0.0496475324,
-0.3345330954,
0.4239134789,
0.0018762453,
-0.3247167766,
0.0538141578,
-0.0078457613,
-0.0671015158,
0.010465892,
0.356800884,
0.5028436184,
-0.0829141513,
-0.2225011438,
-0.0672182217,
-0.737978518,
0.492087692,
-0.0679872483,
0.1267325431,
-0.0155981807,
0.3417468965,
-0.3025841415,
0.733479619,
0.1243890747,
-0.2703645527,
-0.4651263058,
-0.3953641951,
-0.2517867684,
-0.3341195285,
0.3056364357,
0.2186992615,
-0.094255507,
-0.5870244503,
-0.0917191878,
-0.2260016203,
0.2326453179,
-0.7590665817,
0.3197563589,
0.5375624895,
-0.0373092592,
-0.0150708929,
-0.055255115,
-0.1900157183,
-0.0129547166,
-0.5094200969,
0.4049409628,
-0.4063827395,
-0.0873704329,
-0.2599997222,
-0.1641881168,
0.7551038265,
0.5044999719,
-0.7764814496,
-0.2061674595,
0.7052848339,
0.4984302223,
0.0332167931,
-0.2666738331,
-0.7280468345,
0.3645146489,
-0.5116157532,
0.5537862778,
-0.5410262346,
-0.1673519015,
0.0519278571,
0.2141490728,
-0.3612757921,
-0.4310493767,
0.364885062,
-1.1881622076,
0.3780258,
-0.5082157254,
-0.3496989012,
0.176417619,
0.3661696017,
-0.4032103121,
0.938809216,
0.3376873434,
-0.8780691624,
0.6614429951,
-0.2287397236,
-0.4712114036,
-0.1562803835,
-0.1166736111,
-0.2215067595,
0.053021349,
0.453827709,
0.4874914587,
0.1368109584,
0.5922808051,
-0.3447863162,
-0.4469717741,
0.6786820292,
-0.3953969479,
0.7660855055,
0.2341143191,
-0.2888332009,
-0.0930333138,
-0.4354623258,
0.2398293912,
0.0952384099,
-0.5285342336,
-0.4658670425,
0.1304508001,
-0.0141874272,
0.3210259974,
0.1450614929,
-0.2417057306,
-0.0289125182,
-0.0656893104,
0.7524751425,
0.7106778026,
0.1027433723,
0.4309241772,
-0.4712703228,
0.5242469311,
0.0863494873,
0.197142303,
-0.0240303949,
-0.1766572446,
-0.3052347898,
0.2672461271,
0.1405994892,
0.5993279219,
-1.0119279623,
0.0209073871,
-0.5567380786,
-0.1403640509,
0.1276380718,
-0.2224438339,
0.1657091677,
0.7533246279,
0.1967492849,
0.0631332025,
-0.5302663445,
-0.6530533433,
-0.3321426809,
-0.5031274557,
-0.1656617522,
0.4166123569,
0.3064214885,
-0.0477881283,
1.2035645247,
-0.1025060266,
0.4155608118,
0.0467707962,
-0.1746246368,
-0.1181490794,
0.185210228,
0.6646553278,
-0.8126112223,
-0.0615973808,
-0.3296988904,
-0.8157995939,
-0.1277502477,
-0.1171275079,
-0.0832331553,
0.1855191439,
0.4310417771,
-0.3353131413,
0.2294505239,
0.4048025012,
-0.4496626258,
0.2942179441,
0.1430331767,
0.2768965662,
-1.2053650618,
0.3385108709,
-0.3140459955,
-0.3394578397,
-0.7207469344,
0.039074149,
0.218389377,
-0.1522562951,
-0.6923754215,
0.9196224213,
-0.0990242884,
-0.0862340406,
-0.0354067199,
0.1331790388,
0.1937707216,
0.4608757496,
0.1911155432,
1.1155518293,
0.1455775797,
-0.7505406737,
-0.3561523855,
0.2581753135,
-0.2306998223,
0.689119637,
-0.6399099827,
0.2594068944,
-0.1759134233,
0.1807509214,
-0.5907505751,
-0.3559971154,
-0.1219444573,
-0.4489165246,
0.4353637695,
-0.3095175326,
-0.356415987,
0.1963760257,
0.0329548679,
0.6846880317,
0.2483599037,
-0.480114162,
0.4774641991,
0.4382787645,
-0.2072754502,
-0.7291306257,
-0.5884065628,
-0.0542760231,
-0.3990020156,
-0.5391588211,
0.1262243986,
-0.0175888799,
-0.4487062693,
-0.2184352279,
-0.5058224797,
-0.4764232039,
0.6560671329,
0.2127696872,
0.0504565574,
-0.3075791001,
0.3028946221,
0.0350516848,
0.2303811908,
0.1169627607,
-0.2378849536,
0.3749403954,
-0.2258224487,
-0.2376494557,
-0.4111833274,
0.3669594824,
0.6961222887,
0.0199919362,
0.9877373576,
0.4841100276,
-0.430034399,
0.0059539373,
-0.3776728213,
-0.2722917199,
-0.4005883336,
0.3165498674,
-0.169128716,
-1.2189780474,
0.566963017,
0.3361145258,
0.1374068707,
0.2519985139,
0.2703011036,
-0.2336860001,
0.9204733968,
0.4353925288,
-0.1569300294,
0.8132288456,
0.1087501273,
0.0861388817,
-0.9411569834,
-0.096704565,
-0.4822526276,
-0.0662008673,
-0.1798900068,
-0.1821379215,
0.6245279312,
0.2106714249,
-0.5918526053,
-0.0805399492,
-0.0695099384,
0.3487326801,
0.3798790574,
0.0320948288,
0.2509599328,
-0.0927909911,
0.2387093306,
0.1050064489,
-1.0552692413,
-0.7261735797,
0.9445823431,
0.2928216755,
0.4476417303,
0.3459562659,
0.0111859133,
-0.0308607277,
0.2529805303,
-0.465696454,
0.2644552588,
0.2707517445,
-0.8674387932,
-0.512329042,
-0.3682852685,
-0.9499905109,
0.1866440326,
-0.0331373028,
-0.6853632927,
0.3079310358,
-0.0746471062,
-0.7003396749,
0.4133871794,
-0.5312681198,
0.6162263155,
-0.1539046764,
-0.5016499758,
0.4044592977,
-0.7412301898,
0.0238265004,
0.108862862,
0.1349761039,
-0.0609190278,
-0.1666782796,
0.765540123,
-0.1689714491,
0.8757737279,
-0.1192625016,
-0.2195658237,
0.1958367378,
0.2394220829,
0.2812578678,
0.5779811144,
-0.0422639102,
0.0526541434,
0.5890774131,
-0.7785463333,
-0.6579202414,
0.4640078843,
-0.8800958395,
-0.7201386094,
-0.3891658485,
-0.6456389427,
-0.7140328884,
0.0641531646,
0.2066555917,
0.8805987239,
-0.1975217313,
0.4235211909,
0.9479803443,
-0.1532674283,
0.5078226328,
0.6875966787,
0.265332669,
-0.1463094503,
0.2726069093,
0.0919143707,
0.3546464741,
0.667412281,
-0.0389848799,
-0.4488384128,
-0.588540256,
-0.4419398606,
-0.1139460132,
-0.8588722944,
-0.1245537773,
-0.7407649159,
-0.2680443525,
-0.5019337535,
-0.1205531657,
-0.107878007,
-0.439514935,
-0.396337688,
-0.0710872859,
0.0982330441,
0.3809642196,
0.3371709585,
0.2499050796,
-0.7079854012,
0.1156101152,
0.8523852825,
0.2169327289,
-0.1069195643,
-0.5573186278,
-0.0790980905,
-0.0354903229,
-0.1400467306,
-0.8055692315,
0.0966899246,
0.0731516778,
0.6577124,
0.267226547,
0.1387909949,
0.3906644881,
-0.2216932327,
1.0267982483,
-0.4535486698,
-0.8330774903,
0.7246100307,
-0.7641408443,
0.8546987176,
0.5434969068,
0.1506784856,
-0.6431936026,
-0.3869084716,
-0.4252111018,
-0.6846643686,
0.7144749761,
0.230287835,
0.0821264535,
-0.099559322,
0.6821715832,
-0.003840778,
0.0831321552,
-0.8035802245,
-0.0561683998,
-0.208103165,
0.129567638,
0.0438162386,
-0.3646492362,
-0.3713888526,
0.0897296369,
0.4709383547,
-0.3083475828,
0.2472565919,
0.4204507172,
-0.1964632273,
0.0653206632,
0.6757282019,
0.6519888043,
1.1533716917,
-0.3000037074,
0.1570188701,
0.5421918631,
-0.2237303555,
0.3453153968,
-0.1344319433,
-0.4251754284,
-0.2445248812,
0.5706252456,
0.69971627,
0.2843999267,
-0.5670546293,
0.3418479264,
-0.4488758445,
0.2740500867,
-0.2108321339,
0.03448667,
-0.0398984551,
0.3268272579,
0.5396722555,
-0.258664459,
-0.1076657325,
-0.7008469105,
-0.0695033595,
0.4582838416,
-0.4190172851,
-0.3422752917,
0.7748742104,
-0.1037449241,
0.0508747771,
0.3364008367,
0.1388882548,
-0.6443228722,
0.7950824499,
0.3626774549,
0.676615715,
-0.1781832874,
0.0861948803,
0.2253513932,
0.3077925146,
0.1278503388,
0.308152616,
-0.2779768407,
-0.5713142157,
-0.3305667639,
-0.4752433002,
-0.6320925951,
0.208275035,
-0.6977049112,
-0.3915444314,
-0.4940436482,
-0.4410774708,
-0.5720315576,
-0.0319271758,
-0.7215678096,
0.4138443172,
-0.0513100587,
0.6418457031,
-0.6832216382,
0.5983862877,
0.8989962339,
0.0432626382,
-0.7799782157,
0.2441827804,
-0.1888317168,
-0.4743458629,
0.5673148632,
-0.0555723533,
-0.1294138879,
-0.2938073277,
-0.5835934281,
-1.0805479288,
1.4320561886,
0.3474688828,
-0.0994526446,
-0.0340853259,
-0.0417776294,
0.6048359275,
-0.1593554616,
0.2352505475,
0.3879550695,
0.1503762305,
-0.0166895948,
-0.7937948704,
0.1445744336,
-0.2603318095,
0.1321135461,
-0.0640713423,
-0.8491385579,
0.6456933022,
0.0696960762,
-0.6575750113,
0.1741833836,
0.5853130221,
0.2980677187,
0.5627708435,
0.301947087,
0.2709749341,
0.7235196233,
-0.5068756342,
1.2651751041,
-0.3448099494,
-0.1067095771,
1.2448654175,
-0.1440289915,
0.782030344,
0.5418043137,
-0.1663127244,
0.347011447,
0.8854916096,
0.6598373055,
0.3214274645,
-0.3337664008,
-0.1335472018,
-0.5092415214,
-0.0688477531,
-0.7348940372,
0.2178239971,
0.2497468889,
0.1017708331,
-0.1682980806,
-0.2249353081,
0.0021386812,
-0.2788470387,
-0.1180025637,
0.6701755524,
-0.0199177917,
-0.8415305614,
0.4462694824,
-0.1016120687,
0.317458719,
-0.6476151347,
0.4343694448,
-0.6547875404,
-0.1614280939,
0.0620689392,
-0.609526813,
0.3405062556,
-0.1302275658,
-0.3302591443,
-0.0715757683,
0.5043158531,
-0.0847343802,
-0.0222901888,
0.0243133083,
0.8299466968,
-0.2536630332,
-0.0748612732,
-0.2723737955,
-0.062424656,
-0.4621813297,
-0.169025898,
0.5147058368,
0.6836098433,
-0.1846167743,
0.8264799118,
0.4735885561,
-0.1760852188,
0.1689486206,
-0.1093498245,
0.7080166936,
-0.7252929211,
-0.5186076164,
-0.4776876569,
0.265217036,
-0.0056248242,
-0.3900185227,
0.718613863,
0.2498074919,
0.6686949134,
0.248960793,
0.5591679811,
0.1506805122,
0.4036210477,
-0.7632361054,
0.6434293389,
-0.6748493314,
0.5874001384,
0.060460221,
-0.8127045631,
-0.1644347757,
0.0208820011,
-0.4890751243,
0.2680428922,
0.4826868773,
0.460901618,
-0.0003618877,
0.0275510084,
0.3282990754,
0.0139188115,
0.3636829853,
0.8036328554,
1.2713741064,
-0.4317339659,
0.4268522561,
-0.1373641044,
0.1125468612,
-0.1892743707,
-0.889895618,
-0.7801423073,
-0.6076711416,
-0.2976503968,
-0.3070746362,
0.2250598967,
0.4976442456,
0.9232023954,
-0.8778355122,
0.134503454,
0.4391145408,
0.2546480894,
-0.0993385017,
-0.2557578385,
0.4716618061,
-0.3818130791,
-0.6275401115,
0.5232450366,
0.2665197849,
0.3249467313,
0.0777515694,
0.2017120272,
-0.1263197362,
0.2438514084,
0.777666986,
0.47213009,
-0.6559085846,
-0.5075802803,
0.3271708488,
-0.3319964707,
0.0984892845,
0.835867703,
-0.7581924796,
0.3154351115,
0.505202353,
0.7303799391,
0.0880741924,
0.2817034423,
0.6265817881,
-0.8377624154,
0.0064290902,
0.2096343637,
0.4247774482,
0.3636747599,
-0.3980942667,
0.5411153436,
0.0565793402,
-0.6410132051,
-0.7682390213,
0.0635625422,
-0.8988038301,
-0.6430323124,
1.3194565773,
-0.0011364211,
-0.3172620535,
-0.4755844176,
0.1115599722,
0.2363863736,
-0.2073498815,
0.91968894,
0.9036692977,
0.031785585,
0.0204827134,
-0.5641260743,
0.5009093881,
0.7372216582,
-0.7898119688,
-0.2440203279,
0.5303156376,
0.5252873898,
-0.0621757023,
0.6187157631,
-0.1777158976,
0.471072793,
-0.2815740705,
-0.6381129026,
-0.0138615537,
-0.2556821704,
-0.621029973,
0.5044147372,
0.0817262903,
0.1812473983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19537v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19537v1 | Handling Ontology Gaps in Semantic Parsing | 2024-06-27T21:21:22 | 2024-06-27T21:21:22 | Andrea Bacciu, Marco Damonte, Marco Basaldella, Emilio Monti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The majority of Neural Semantic Parsing (NSP) models are developed with the
assumption that there are no concepts outside the ones such models can
represent with their target symbols (closed-world assumption). This assumption
leads to generate hallucinated outputs rather than admitting their lack of
knowledge. Hallucinations can lead to wrong or potentially offensive responses
to users. Hence, a mechanism to prevent this behavior is crucial to build
trusted NSP-based Question Answering agents. To that end, we propose the
Hallucination Simulation Framework (HSF), a general setting for stimulating and
analyzing NSP model hallucinations. The framework can be applied to any NSP
task with a closed-ontology. Using the proposed framework and KQA Pro as the
benchmark dataset, we assess state-of-the-art techniques for hallucination
detection. We then present a novel hallucination detection strategy that
exploits the computational graph of the NSP model to detect the NSP
hallucinations in the presence of ontology gaps, out-of-domain utterances, and
to recognize NSP errors, improving the F1-Score respectively by ~21, ~24% and
~1%. This is the first work in closed-ontology NSP that addresses the problem
of recognizing ontology gaps. We release our code and checkpoints at
https://github.com/amazon-science/handling-ontology-gaps-in-semantic-parsing. | [
-0.679263413,
-0.8325948119,
0.8193513155,
0.2681349218,
0.1015605405,
-0.3402319551,
0.1907422692,
-0.5010288358,
0.1634855568,
0.8970276713,
-0.9241143465,
-0.5724152923,
-0.4429461956,
0.0846131369,
-0.301515907,
0.3124619126,
0.3654007316,
-0.1256619394,
-0.4532674253,
0.1225331649,
-0.444093287,
-0.5617890358,
-0.2486676425,
-0.4502924979,
0.107481949,
0.2865148485,
0.8914584517,
0.6238608956,
0.4614167809,
0.2297656536,
-0.1397969574,
0.119015187,
-0.2376275957,
0.3649284244,
-0.2198423147,
-0.0082619507,
-0.4354349673,
-0.3503573239,
0.395657897,
0.8999468088,
-0.3406955898,
-0.3385173678,
-0.2281240821,
0.2579817772,
-0.5779581666,
0.192408964,
-0.6340681911,
0.6345243454,
0.0402083918,
-0.408732444,
-0.4554325938,
-0.0918129832,
0.1073487625,
-0.6587531567,
0.2465327978,
0.04521209,
0.981144011,
0.5704038739,
0.2288221121,
-0.2758501768,
-0.3126414716,
0.6728080511,
-0.7724938393,
0.6535173655,
0.6123031974,
0.3544478416,
-0.5473167896,
-0.7967494726,
-0.6377019286,
-0.2268084139,
0.0685584024,
-0.0718452036,
-0.0017910644,
0.1000791416,
0.3979149759,
0.1610524803,
-0.7195744514,
-0.0305533204,
-0.0627768338,
-0.3573113978,
0.2811070383,
0.2880762815,
0.321154952,
-0.5653874874,
-0.3671711683,
-0.1768032908,
-0.3231328726,
-0.3934651315,
0.2599656582,
0.3631203771,
0.3340018988,
0.4683102667,
-0.38446787,
0.7247267365,
-0.2849280536,
0.1104753613,
0.1463607103,
0.0234098323,
-0.2919787467,
0.2697776556,
0.2656846046,
0.328517735,
0.132993117,
-0.4957767129,
-0.0580044612,
0.4521647394,
0.6140708327,
-0.5672749877,
-0.3073211014,
0.527915895,
-0.302046001,
-0.3059700131,
-0.1066964194,
-0.9415748119,
-0.506604135,
-0.0659855381,
0.3513394594,
-0.5650991797,
-0.2062001079,
0.6770211458,
-0.1442500204,
0.2216873914,
0.1843656451,
-0.668749392,
0.7547494173,
0.7828672528,
0.6510813832,
0.2057555914,
-0.4185441434,
-0.4926911294,
0.0834879503,
-0.1776212007,
1.197644949,
-0.4819666743,
-0.092481561,
-0.091628693,
-0.0682813525,
-0.1052076966,
-0.6759368777,
0.6519312263,
-0.5204357505,
-0.0149415024,
-0.459615171,
-0.7496493459,
-0.1823491454,
0.4926175177,
-0.4951914549,
0.9297207594,
0.1653125882,
-0.7126498222,
0.128706947,
-0.5960230231,
0.1105635166,
0.1348570138,
-0.3126138747,
-0.1489286125,
-0.1026980951,
0.2393807471,
0.2914897203,
-0.1716172546,
0.2242261767,
-0.3248293996,
-0.3002285957,
0.1833293885,
0.1192337573,
0.70147264,
0.009181466,
-0.3935059607,
0.0333741494,
-0.7852844596,
0.4059334695,
0.0244478863,
0.3087718785,
-0.3154819906,
-0.0772059262,
0.0246217512,
0.5020192266,
-0.4546760023,
-0.5332186222,
0.0302010477,
-0.7522453666,
0.2141998708,
0.6706385016,
0.0457643196,
0.0697793439,
-0.2127540857,
0.3548441529,
0.0913881585,
0.1346931309,
-0.1667329669,
-0.7009393573,
-0.7132865787,
0.1578078568,
0.2490558326,
0.3510135412,
-0.6049155593,
0.8723320365,
0.095219776,
-0.1049116328,
-0.4273017049,
-0.2283818275,
0.3457449675,
0.7438156009,
0.5723599792,
-0.3434125185,
-0.5321181417,
-0.4164583385,
0.0343610346,
-0.2881143093,
0.0099769691,
0.1695091128,
0.4911987782,
-0.4067275524,
0.9766029119,
-0.7614220381,
-0.7489117384,
0.0224273019,
0.0593874902,
-0.2503585517,
0.5567718744,
0.2259501219,
-0.7668883204,
0.1260258257,
-0.2581450939,
-1.0619568825,
-0.4239149988,
-0.1095396951,
-0.3687014282,
0.0967302695,
0.5513550639,
-0.8100930452,
0.6396396756,
0.2206383795,
-0.7447286844,
0.4507800341,
0.1098840311,
-0.0532085747,
-0.7122787833,
-0.1892085969,
-0.4678573906,
-0.1208721995,
-0.719963789,
0.228342548,
-0.2058943659,
-0.0357155912,
-0.4048661292,
0.3646177649,
-0.0999451727,
-0.3336695433,
-0.4273096025,
0.3470616639,
0.2454290092,
0.3912073672,
0.3429656625,
0.1265795827,
0.4472726882,
-0.3681900799,
0.0645669773,
0.6897011399,
-0.1172889769,
0.139989987,
-0.5190742612,
0.0668085366,
-0.1229802594,
-0.0395918563,
-0.7996064425,
-0.4176867902,
0.5942981243,
-0.552323103,
-0.182746321,
0.0909520388,
-0.5679139495,
-0.1049730629,
-0.0384316184,
0.2140569538,
0.4640893638,
-0.5630751848,
0.4427945614,
0.3275832832,
0.2712058127,
-0.5682868361,
-0.5987345576,
0.1517513096,
0.0969869494,
-1.109978199,
0.5536858439,
0.088276796,
-0.227753669,
0.1820727289,
-0.3154783845,
-0.11285384,
0.2012896687,
0.4507086873,
-0.0442814641,
-0.4095023572,
0.1702364087,
0.1865570098,
-0.4119017124,
0.3713770807,
-0.4055224657,
0.9498282075,
-0.253510505,
-0.5010150075,
-0.4281744659,
0.3154436648,
0.2308533788,
0.2160543501,
0.7453506589,
0.2933474183,
-0.9016804695,
-0.3893065751,
-0.4896292686,
-0.643144846,
-0.4502502382,
0.1287688762,
-0.3802040219,
-0.6536407471,
0.534534514,
0.02651163,
-0.2892453671,
0.3265567124,
0.417734772,
0.2298124284,
0.8243358135,
0.5702380538,
0.5435994267,
-0.2583213449,
-0.2227364182,
0.4268087745,
-0.6231294274,
-0.3771209121,
-0.5962259769,
0.2519248128,
-0.143528834,
-0.6251734495,
0.0822467357,
0.2908862531,
0.0787677094,
0.1795682311,
-0.4489530921,
0.6116210818,
0.2287082672,
-0.1843219995,
0.3209647238,
0.0592891611,
-0.2025922984,
-0.2412929535,
-0.6699792147,
-0.5170301795,
0.3574710488,
0.3103711009,
0.5111534595,
-0.1982171685,
0.6457970142,
0.4352384508,
-0.3312578797,
-0.672498107,
0.7173038125,
0.1854227483,
-0.3126744926,
-0.5355904102,
-0.435262531,
-0.553214252,
0.6290069222,
-0.1500577033,
-0.856164813,
0.4287544489,
0.0942858011,
-0.4104564488,
0.332477957,
-0.2441279888,
1.1337600946,
0.3114887178,
-0.1221187338,
0.169680506,
-0.8688492775,
0.4170306027,
0.0089135999,
-0.1165841147,
-0.4775573909,
0.3093318045,
0.5651413202,
-0.4790471494,
0.7905642986,
-0.2835040689,
0.0268330965,
0.2239177376,
0.0870162845,
0.1288255602,
0.189227283,
-0.1050828099,
0.4182816744,
0.0309059117,
-0.2881616056,
-0.6357702613,
0.608330071,
-0.6050729156,
-0.4473893344,
-0.7543379664,
-0.6516926885,
-0.3182837367,
0.1545048803,
0.314114809,
0.0193279758,
-0.1048402116,
-0.1319325566,
0.7198359966,
-0.359690249,
0.0752477944,
0.1807147264,
-0.3639652729,
-0.0826644376,
0.5887696147,
0.0692239776,
0.1165181026,
-0.031072339,
0.2938036323,
-0.3025165796,
-0.2542993724,
-0.3980103135,
0.1986911893,
-0.9662015438,
-0.2776886225,
-1.2560008764,
-0.547885716,
-0.9306732416,
-0.1368075311,
-0.3183921874,
-0.6436638236,
-0.089387551,
-0.0768222362,
0.2467704415,
0.2441949993,
-0.1370764822,
0.3089522719,
-0.7797182202,
0.5884552002,
0.0025577198,
0.2261095792,
0.1743195653,
-0.3940559924,
0.2293394208,
-0.1436009854,
-0.3273052871,
-0.7042281032,
0.5750920177,
-0.0710150674,
0.448428154,
0.5350469351,
0.4030326903,
0.8811541796,
-0.3503993154,
0.5889573097,
0.039275296,
-1.0922777653,
0.4888349175,
-0.0595709346,
0.1517785937,
0.4729024768,
0.364277184,
-0.7509784698,
-0.5514349341,
-0.6233190894,
-0.740126133,
0.8855547309,
0.5622637868,
-0.1080021784,
-0.1105493233,
0.3808879554,
0.1595069319,
0.1478126496,
-0.648655951,
0.0885656625,
-0.4082978964,
0.0280933194,
0.4254905879,
-0.2237065136,
-0.0822031945,
-0.0366728008,
0.4527030885,
-0.1662089229,
0.1529356688,
0.2742349505,
-0.0943011791,
-0.2044501454,
0.0734535977,
0.3764454722,
0.7108944654,
-0.4025954902,
0.2760932148,
-0.1013140902,
-0.5152053833,
-0.0359027348,
0.0264949389,
-0.2251390368,
0.0585531406,
0.2722954154,
0.4991137683,
-0.0156509895,
-1.0375140905,
0.374137938,
-0.1419658512,
-0.2019365281,
-0.3876005411,
0.1260491014,
-0.075389266,
0.3080479503,
-0.0895835683,
0.1200152636,
0.4319867492,
-0.3536534905,
0.5580077171,
-0.0141905937,
-0.5505551696,
-0.2503094673,
0.5391602516,
-0.3547312915,
-0.3032448888,
0.9205254316,
-0.2391552776,
-0.7121433616,
0.7299172878,
0.7481393814,
0.8992791772,
-0.1673163325,
0.4109398127,
-0.0745712221,
0.4080656469,
-0.1370173544,
0.529886961,
-0.0569000356,
-0.9162310958,
-0.071176149,
-0.9632965326,
-0.4840834439,
0.0355478786,
-0.7209194899,
0.2246183157,
-0.31506598,
-0.0750690922,
0.2116799504,
-0.3802447915,
0.0230127722,
0.2236871868,
0.1642558128,
0.7470396161,
-0.9977920651,
0.7096424103,
0.3245539367,
-0.3393552601,
-0.3022395372,
0.3719496131,
-0.0515298396,
-0.5266451836,
0.4965759218,
0.4538970888,
-0.1820552349,
-0.2448210418,
-0.2264284045,
-0.6614744067,
0.6150738001,
0.2034148127,
0.0078396033,
-0.2427415848,
0.5700276494,
0.5754556656,
-0.3486609161,
-0.2906057239,
0.7076978683,
0.4934132993,
0.2442915887,
-0.2127817571,
0.2835280001,
-0.1040170193,
0.0874835253,
0.2221659869,
-0.2200153917,
0.857466042,
-0.1109996513,
-0.0893158317,
0.2913293242,
0.550106883,
0.5574423671,
0.736127317,
0.5847266316,
0.8534222245,
0.7255539298,
-0.1262047887,
0.7404850125,
-0.0946898237,
0.2177030444,
1.0803859234,
-0.7362987995,
0.6942759156,
0.6013867259,
0.3565342128,
0.2608547211,
0.5423023105,
-0.1562765986,
0.6444488168,
0.3253442943,
0.047364369,
-0.4900653362,
-0.4099577963,
-0.5549230576,
0.4413787425,
0.5474756956,
-0.0561798997,
-0.4677368999,
0.2769630253,
-0.1452078968,
0.1861333698,
0.097241044,
0.6344201565,
0.2320488244,
-0.4440330267,
0.6464091539,
0.122030288,
0.0623635463,
-0.4581139386,
-0.418994993,
-0.1437909454,
0.1594982296,
-0.3110292256,
-0.5132833719,
0.7943274379,
-0.2257613391,
-0.1689775884,
-0.0568843074,
0.8682517409,
-0.0667254776,
-0.264162153,
0.8562865257,
0.3425193131,
0.4585402012,
-0.3349588215,
-0.4878723621,
0.2862726152,
-0.2820029259,
-0.0152499005,
0.2495735139,
0.4431837797,
-0.17426534,
0.464954257,
0.5287756324,
-0.1989061236,
0.3080316484,
0.2814503312,
1.0673669577,
-0.8086059093,
-0.7499193549,
-0.5661390424,
0.1421290189,
-0.2024670839,
-0.3548670709,
0.6497620344,
0.2750421464,
0.9002013803,
-0.0846467018,
0.4326485097,
-0.0315699391,
0.3447547555,
-0.7256549597,
0.7535105944,
-0.6661300063,
0.4552535415,
-0.4340038002,
-0.9168695211,
-0.6919988394,
0.8120512366,
-0.0291164182,
-0.152818054,
0.8051595688,
1.00276196,
-0.0568956733,
0.5350564718,
0.7085530758,
0.2618413568,
-0.0315169655,
0.3639420569,
1.1499381065,
-0.5245984793,
0.3292139471,
-0.5191498399,
0.012919357,
-0.2061228603,
-0.6265820265,
-0.8959563971,
-0.3956500888,
-0.3097496331,
-0.7979366183,
0.2512563169,
0.7087749243,
0.6454427838,
-0.8330504894,
-0.1996941417,
-0.2972115278,
0.0816008449,
-0.3064132333,
-0.2555913925,
0.3645144105,
-0.5787296891,
-0.2624142766,
0.3205516636,
0.5273842216,
-0.0589922182,
-0.2037792057,
-0.1137936413,
-0.197136268,
0.2366800159,
0.4821328521,
0.128351897,
-0.9327778816,
-0.1368005574,
0.3588870168,
0.0997689515,
0.216174975,
0.7290099859,
-0.7778906226,
0.3089753985,
0.4955669045,
0.8724150062,
0.269690305,
-0.0295701101,
0.1615073979,
-0.6025184989,
0.2050614804,
0.5220355392,
0.1071796119,
0.159185499,
-0.5545220971,
0.5714393258,
0.4080122709,
-0.4117940664,
-1.2311167717,
0.1878248155,
-0.9932459593,
-0.6031389832,
0.7517999411,
-0.1125985309,
-0.361302793,
-0.4811375737,
0.0492109098,
-0.1094177142,
-0.0564226322,
1.2268615961,
0.5957901478,
-0.3343700469,
0.1341366023,
-0.4125596881,
0.5712823272,
0.5640688539,
-1.0516372919,
0.2237297446,
0.5422486663,
-0.2362178117,
0.4611164927,
0.6380054355,
-0.1521538347,
0.465839386,
0.3786079288,
0.1162964627,
0.1255092919,
-0.7800160646,
-0.3393531144,
0.4881854951,
-0.3175852001,
-0.0025829081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19526v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19526v1 | TocBERT: Medical Document Structure Extraction Using Bidirectional Transformers | 2024-06-27T20:56:57 | 2024-06-27T20:56:57 | Majd Saleh, Sarra Baghdadi, Stéphane Paquelet | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Text segmentation holds paramount importance in the field of Natural Language
Processing (NLP). It plays an important role in several NLP downstream tasks
like information retrieval and document summarization. In this work, we propose
a new solution, namely TocBERT, for segmenting texts using bidirectional
transformers. TocBERT represents a supervised solution trained on the detection
of titles and sub-titles from their semantic representations. This task was
formulated as a named entity recognition (NER) problem. The solution has been
applied on a medical text segmentation use-case where the Bio-ClinicalBERT
model is fine-tuned to segment discharge summaries of the MIMIC-III dataset.
The performance of TocBERT has been evaluated on a human-labeled ground truth
corpus of 250 notes. It achieved an F1-score of 84.6% when evaluated on a
linear text segmentation problem and 72.8% on a hierarchical text segmentation
problem. It outperformed a carefully designed rule-based solution, particularly
in distinguishing titles from subtitles. | [
-0.0736257955,
-0.5628584623,
0.6487780809,
0.3003487289,
-0.6077564955,
0.1214461327,
-0.3018250167,
-0.2178578377,
0.1725057662,
0.6556328535,
-0.4067922235,
-0.8650434613,
-0.7842133641,
0.3149756789,
-0.7170379758,
1.2698762417,
-0.0526766367,
0.0353176966,
-0.4640039504,
-0.0292184595,
-0.4874375165,
-0.2459833026,
-0.4245978296,
-0.2172273546,
0.4903891981,
0.6616101265,
0.4560892284,
0.782270968,
0.9079152346,
0.3503993452,
-0.2152994126,
0.0386824906,
-0.0492847785,
0.3096605241,
-0.3435408771,
-0.4500753582,
-0.33124578,
-0.2475004941,
0.8846449256,
0.6401427984,
-0.1774541587,
-0.1418801248,
-0.2079614699,
0.7078992128,
-0.1698020995,
-0.035776712,
-0.2783040702,
0.0155315092,
-0.394205004,
-0.3960930109,
-0.5945783257,
-0.2284316719,
0.1199501827,
-0.3316655159,
0.6068825722,
0.145537734,
1.2979516983,
0.5560881495,
-0.4237577617,
-0.544475615,
-0.4388926327,
0.6669176817,
-0.514041245,
0.6144284606,
0.0328009054,
0.3866505921,
-0.0038809211,
-0.9740798473,
-0.3729041517,
-0.1136945039,
-0.210630089,
0.3789138496,
-0.0739597157,
0.1562378109,
0.1216564626,
0.4841281176,
-0.5248942971,
0.1933140606,
-0.6119659543,
-0.272384882,
0.4693505764,
-0.0508274212,
0.4555666149,
-0.7292906046,
-0.6098210216,
-0.1476352513,
-0.1213607714,
-0.0029816111,
0.1302112043,
0.0573092587,
-0.0322425589,
0.7048774362,
0.0433266126,
0.333393842,
0.4642997086,
-0.6728681326,
0.2572826445,
0.1434560269,
-0.3923219144,
0.6931530237,
0.6027172804,
0.2050794065,
0.0239630453,
-0.2884542048,
-0.0417155921,
-0.0978755131,
0.5703123212,
-0.9099565148,
-0.2810830176,
0.2774166465,
-0.7690283656,
-0.4786614776,
0.0400261246,
-0.8446814418,
-0.1624567211,
-0.2133883238,
0.0003094211,
-0.4835406542,
0.1254163533,
0.0708025172,
-0.2240702957,
0.4042585194,
0.369074434,
-0.7823372483,
0.4360463321,
0.6990024447,
0.7470226884,
-0.7526952028,
0.1824954897,
-0.2448240668,
0.2733535171,
-0.1118353829,
1.3345490694,
-0.2638117969,
-0.6887736917,
-0.3222972751,
0.3966677189,
-0.0931095406,
-0.7873438001,
0.8970127106,
-0.4172292054,
0.5626891255,
0.0642647669,
-0.346576184,
-0.2941039205,
0.4886417687,
-0.7502276301,
0.8625645638,
0.2636533082,
-0.9702863097,
0.1545717865,
-0.5421721935,
-1.0435973406,
0.0440383777,
-0.1537450105,
-0.8472428918,
0.1486714035,
0.5216748118,
0.2082367539,
-0.6416854262,
0.3095825315,
0.277204901,
0.1222112924,
-0.0072460854,
-0.5304999948,
0.9444516301,
-0.1507185847,
-0.2855652571,
0.2592969239,
-0.8619114757,
-0.2039328963,
0.1784369051,
-0.3846971393,
-0.5513783097,
0.0362456515,
0.2531259656,
0.0997054055,
0.0042418092,
-0.5845003724,
0.1582748592,
-0.4257804453,
-0.0717903897,
0.5362565517,
0.3593661189,
0.5388426185,
-0.1987852156,
0.546009481,
0.162471056,
0.1418973953,
-0.0042060218,
-0.2777839899,
-0.7361296415,
-0.8414952755,
0.5225939155,
0.5095171928,
-0.7431116104,
0.3432894349,
-0.1858109683,
-0.3905275464,
-0.2617492378,
-0.2445718348,
0.3048476875,
1.2350398302,
0.8142491579,
-0.3898212314,
-0.440790683,
-1.1021407843,
0.0442516394,
-0.2895453572,
-0.0550514273,
0.2476118803,
0.3200073838,
-0.5055232048,
0.9794111848,
-0.8321016431,
-0.5986016989,
-0.3138440847,
0.1233046055,
0.16771321,
0.3426050246,
0.4015776813,
-1.0454307795,
-0.4104169011,
0.0153402425,
-0.6354784966,
-0.4066314399,
-0.2203068882,
-0.2549789548,
0.0151805291,
0.6189244986,
-0.3958085179,
0.329087019,
0.3898787498,
0.0344828852,
0.5609906316,
-0.2594355941,
-0.068696782,
-1.520406723,
0.2359410524,
-0.1414902657,
-0.3457662761,
-0.5248586535,
-0.1870018244,
0.4478062093,
-0.0345833339,
-0.3947407305,
0.3444135189,
-0.6164363623,
0.0692156777,
-0.2261690944,
0.1779365987,
0.0604809895,
0.346613735,
0.3234154582,
0.3879704475,
0.2776208222,
-0.5282625556,
0.3523976505,
0.7748912573,
-0.0934783667,
0.8846697807,
-0.7070176005,
0.0274219289,
-0.3211163282,
0.1570658386,
-0.9824767709,
-0.1192949861,
0.2303001732,
-0.4161767364,
0.7256842256,
-0.0827178657,
-0.3435319364,
-0.2496216744,
-0.1598455906,
0.4982607663,
0.1335396022,
-0.5178971887,
0.5646885633,
0.5815750957,
-0.3743147552,
-0.4656471014,
-0.3858884275,
0.0377187133,
-0.0444496199,
-0.5228440166,
0.8581966758,
0.2745081186,
-0.0120223835,
-0.04352355,
-0.4626781642,
-0.382134974,
-0.1518456191,
0.4472517967,
0.5154874921,
-0.1151799858,
0.1536985785,
0.7425141931,
-0.4661225677,
0.1784931272,
-0.1288209409,
0.3514323235,
0.2755869329,
-0.2877263427,
-0.3034671247,
0.2981857061,
0.549090147,
-0.45385167,
0.3031529784,
0.3872619271,
-0.5051155686,
-0.1544658095,
-0.4806295931,
-0.0446970128,
-0.4290503561,
0.5287885666,
0.0793868825,
-0.5356892943,
0.1598612517,
-0.3162888587,
0.0029111332,
0.7313246727,
0.6874881983,
-0.3020181358,
0.7038121223,
0.6318659782,
-0.0456860624,
0.3142240047,
0.0217772238,
0.129907161,
-0.9892408848,
-0.5942284465,
-0.7260001302,
-0.3604373336,
-0.4074724317,
-0.5139150023,
0.480828166,
-0.179874137,
0.4567882419,
0.5013013482,
-0.7617565393,
0.1564453393,
0.1650979817,
0.2371784598,
0.4835664928,
0.0771905631,
-0.3762321174,
0.0831167847,
-0.1673081517,
-0.3462498188,
0.7181136608,
0.3166542351,
0.5366281271,
-0.1662359983,
0.8028410077,
0.2027634084,
0.6751438379,
-1.1198139191,
0.6156380177,
-0.2686141431,
-0.7863262892,
-0.3312401175,
-0.198964566,
-1.0295637846,
0.0979923531,
-0.0416322388,
-0.3366224468,
0.2105072439,
-0.5034929514,
-0.1621779054,
-0.0238811504,
-0.3550557196,
0.7217373252,
-0.2706931531,
-0.0464388318,
-0.0354086757,
-0.891700685,
0.0777238011,
-0.1849079728,
-0.0111765638,
-0.0280232262,
0.1044021696,
0.9497523308,
-0.5948675275,
0.2595553696,
-0.0613162145,
-0.1800370961,
0.1851631105,
-0.2535194755,
0.2366077155,
0.197492972,
0.1953493059,
0.2364185154,
0.0718408227,
-0.097038731,
-0.3096320629,
0.2661453485,
-0.3629956543,
-0.6306402683,
-0.5687817931,
-0.4539770186,
-0.0204845592,
0.6369665861,
0.4132160544,
0.4971023202,
-0.1727603376,
0.4063745141,
0.4884402454,
-0.4059972465,
0.4638009965,
0.4135091901,
0.0150358258,
-0.5695505738,
0.4039504826,
-0.2775326967,
-0.0702071711,
1.0037837029,
0.141115427,
-0.428689599,
-0.5958573222,
-0.4368674159,
0.5088080168,
-0.5427941084,
-0.4607723057,
-0.7521153688,
-0.4250757992,
-0.3216355443,
-0.2208481133,
-0.4161152244,
-0.3652817011,
-0.411872685,
-0.067293644,
-0.0682782829,
0.0558840334,
0.1998929977,
0.2384550124,
-0.8438570499,
0.8195608854,
0.126752466,
-0.1561941057,
-0.3918279707,
-0.5742662549,
-0.051568117,
-0.5219976902,
-0.4377308488,
-1.1475231647,
0.5922603011,
-0.152872622,
0.5566888452,
0.6034321785,
0.238097474,
0.8524563909,
-0.7103117108,
0.2421399802,
0.2905686796,
-0.7547190189,
0.5009046793,
-0.0349675156,
0.1122846752,
0.7158731818,
0.2921536863,
-0.6466475725,
-0.2409631908,
-0.3860170245,
-0.8054072261,
0.6684544086,
0.2286946028,
-0.3285252154,
-0.0090436088,
0.2731164098,
0.1413900554,
0.1494710743,
-0.4277573526,
-0.2599964738,
0.0837439075,
-0.5980913639,
0.1899686307,
-0.3080468476,
0.0711907521,
-0.2249527276,
0.5143294334,
0.0275371037,
0.4181565344,
0.6921075583,
-0.4235437512,
-0.030627545,
0.4457081258,
0.4400723279,
0.2188618779,
-0.1545421034,
0.0987580419,
0.0080679143,
-0.9436604381,
0.0396447144,
0.6058101058,
-0.1378273666,
0.2746042311,
0.3774460256,
0.17026712,
0.2053588927,
-0.6041798592,
0.6506974101,
-0.1598441005,
-0.352178663,
-0.1597638428,
-0.3748734593,
-0.0522605255,
0.4281738997,
0.273627907,
0.1332170814,
0.5134615302,
-0.3680621684,
0.3310251534,
0.3366598487,
-0.7286457419,
-0.2471675426,
0.6576180458,
0.0158486906,
-0.313093245,
0.9604962468,
0.1859492213,
-0.7606275082,
0.6601310968,
0.6469205022,
1.0549631119,
-0.3530053794,
0.3256634772,
0.0403517783,
0.1938119382,
-0.0178464632,
-0.0701675862,
-0.3057692349,
-0.4497450888,
-0.2444918603,
-0.8132748008,
-0.45949471,
-0.3882273436,
-0.7729039192,
0.5814799666,
-0.332251817,
-0.0121287918,
0.2599163949,
-0.0936797857,
-0.2122290134,
0.5124712586,
0.100617595,
0.6683709621,
-0.4533714652,
0.9895709157,
0.7653602362,
-0.2205593288,
-0.7149171829,
0.1805540919,
-0.200021252,
-0.5744899511,
0.630032599,
0.3541954756,
0.1434224099,
-0.0531399846,
-0.1790878773,
-0.4970132411,
1.0751069784,
0.0964149535,
-0.4618246257,
-0.663020432,
0.2601787448,
0.6769267917,
0.0704265758,
0.2433436215,
0.4485695064,
0.4966361821,
0.0893945098,
-0.8634569645,
0.1436078548,
-0.2176862508,
-0.2959646285,
0.4240785837,
-0.4854720235,
0.6954594254,
-0.2103280723,
-0.3330251575,
-0.0136592025,
0.5558424592,
0.2011689246,
0.530381918,
0.564143002,
0.3220492303,
0.6694221497,
-0.0584528632,
0.7485539317,
-0.0954312086,
0.508439064,
0.8000751138,
-0.1843834966,
0.4953907132,
0.600040853,
0.0223904531,
0.9579499364,
0.3548238575,
-0.1245691404,
0.671761632,
-0.0325448662,
0.0011482466,
0.0470973887,
-0.0428399816,
-0.2545347214,
0.6359602809,
0.3226956725,
-0.6106066704,
-0.3655079007,
0.0448292904,
0.199915424,
-0.0327951871,
-0.2711225748,
0.7985526323,
0.1880986243,
-0.5931931734,
0.2522512078,
0.3793405592,
0.2206074446,
-0.518588841,
0.0262775719,
-0.0566929728,
0.4182099402,
-0.3236788213,
-0.4056662023,
0.4545873702,
-0.0266007632,
-0.3308320045,
-0.3208978176,
0.9576776624,
-0.3312889338,
-0.6187147498,
0.1692433804,
0.0830965266,
0.0262644738,
-0.2642074525,
-0.4180416763,
-0.3454964161,
0.0488396883,
-0.0242772251,
0.0424097963,
0.5116225481,
-0.1963902563,
0.2336470038,
0.6768209338,
-0.0432276577,
-0.2049873918,
-0.1781122386,
0.9673596621,
-0.786019206,
-0.6780565977,
-0.8722191453,
0.4156706035,
-0.2892621756,
-0.2248089761,
0.6570534706,
1.0198104382,
0.4870023429,
-0.0944096819,
0.4193303883,
0.0272458419,
0.7069178224,
-0.2637791038,
0.802236855,
-0.6731657386,
-0.0905532315,
-0.5882127881,
-0.9592356682,
-0.6012253761,
0.4908824563,
-0.2223443985,
-0.402443558,
1.2642146349,
0.5357531309,
-0.0175055582,
-0.075719282,
0.0902008712,
0.041014418,
0.4577916265,
0.3080208004,
0.3684065938,
-0.4948742092,
0.6929354072,
-0.3674985766,
-0.2300573587,
-0.4570947289,
-0.5960642099,
-0.9667471647,
-0.4835199118,
-0.3276462257,
-0.2872281075,
-0.0662296489,
0.6984469295,
0.5173681378,
-0.8139180541,
0.0197413955,
0.0216509663,
0.3678033948,
-0.1365543455,
-0.2403512001,
0.8532038331,
-0.1964343339,
-0.7906066179,
0.3930206895,
0.7729696035,
-0.2411281914,
0.3204252422,
0.1603701115,
-0.1901153624,
-0.1233055145,
0.5676873326,
0.2300112844,
-0.3364333212,
-0.0916762054,
0.2287882417,
-0.2872397304,
0.4018826187,
0.8062303066,
-0.580901444,
0.421141535,
0.5149174333,
0.6041208506,
0.6799629331,
0.4012447298,
0.1730093956,
-0.6470796466,
0.1087349206,
0.4108066857,
0.2532297373,
0.335590452,
-0.2929718792,
0.2141802609,
0.4746702015,
-0.4340059757,
-0.7672428489,
-0.1285810173,
-1.5379242897,
-0.2302463949,
1.2103501558,
0.3181271851,
-0.4705351591,
-0.2291745096,
-0.717421174,
0.7660422325,
-0.324367106,
0.6531040668,
0.2662988007,
0.0474187583,
-0.2083997726,
-0.2089764476,
0.2056029737,
0.2232728451,
-1.1307106018,
-0.3275675774,
0.2647066414,
0.3652909696,
0.4178131819,
0.3880170882,
-0.6302245259,
0.1612481177,
-0.2898550332,
0.2438115776,
-0.0879817829,
-0.437769264,
0.0127517609,
0.404830128,
-0.3538094759,
-0.4262021184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19512v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19512v1 | Captioning Visualizations with Large Language Models (CVLLM): A Tutorial | 2024-06-27T20:18:18 | 2024-06-27T20:18:18 | Giuseppe Carenini, Jordon Johnson, Ali Salamatian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Automatically captioning visualizations is not new, but recent advances in
large language models(LLMs) open exciting new possibilities. In this tutorial,
after providing a brief review of Information Visualization (InfoVis)
principles and past work in captioning, we introduce neural models and the
transformer architecture used in generic LLMs. We then discuss their recent
applications in InfoVis, with a focus on captioning. Additionally, we explore
promising future directions in this field. | [
-0.245046109,
-0.4558204412,
0.5111766458,
0.2543974817,
-0.1689131409,
0.2355943322,
-0.1562982351,
-0.1268372685,
0.1196067408,
0.8239210248,
-0.5840086937,
-0.6897692084,
-0.5576505661,
-0.1859559864,
-0.7218430042,
0.915096581,
-0.1604414731,
0.5798859596,
-0.664996624,
-0.0094012329,
-0.5692990422,
-0.5788686872,
-0.6854757667,
-0.1840589195,
0.5441530943,
0.6192166805,
0.5233407617,
0.7978805304,
0.6373540163,
0.3241448402,
0.1402702034,
-0.0158371385,
-0.4268775582,
0.193626821,
0.1693952829,
-0.8703831434,
0.0481091887,
-0.0826488361,
0.7011072636,
0.8835740089,
0.1650536358,
0.1052910089,
-0.2603729069,
0.7247353196,
-0.0914381817,
0.8177941442,
-0.3637627959,
0.1265177578,
0.0595543012,
-0.5941491723,
-0.6089528799,
-0.6423416138,
0.4965678751,
-0.5135711432,
0.158404544,
0.7460523844,
0.6185896397,
0.3031288087,
-0.4216187894,
-0.0764468238,
-0.9194892049,
0.7945661545,
-0.4598718286,
0.2704416513,
-0.1284820884,
0.932510376,
0.1979274452,
-1.1724302769,
-0.4051487744,
-0.4527489543,
0.0112867979,
0.0763555095,
-0.4797303081,
0.023269631,
0.3708591759,
0.3258207738,
-0.4896460176,
0.3376009762,
-0.6921740174,
-0.0185254831,
0.44364959,
0.4998717904,
0.5733865499,
-0.0121059995,
-0.6832223535,
-0.1193251684,
-0.9783908129,
-0.3116390109,
0.1912137717,
0.1966241449,
-0.354182303,
0.7584007382,
0.1692183614,
0.9805760384,
-0.3463153541,
0.1545872092,
-0.108785063,
-0.0972330943,
-0.3796581328,
0.1047561914,
0.6562241316,
0.5762927532,
0.598670125,
-0.3223364651,
0.0716898963,
-0.4190978408,
0.2717025876,
-0.65802598,
-0.4582761526,
0.2020755708,
-0.7393596172,
-0.3878410459,
0.1699712276,
-0.7598565221,
-0.8762472272,
-0.8246346116,
0.3701782525,
-0.2209709585,
-0.1412610263,
0.0331975482,
-0.2694355249,
0.6083346605,
0.3535675704,
-0.7987638116,
0.5497543812,
0.3637717962,
0.7747937441,
-0.5963956118,
-0.3235452175,
-0.4564338624,
0.0839685574,
-0.3890031576,
0.7489258051,
-0.1410890967,
-0.0383769646,
0.3261417449,
0.2254458219,
0.0587655343,
-0.467333883,
0.0509457923,
-0.7423706055,
0.1445733607,
-0.1104582921,
-0.6930938363,
-0.6331317425,
0.1682921499,
-0.9864442348,
0.2724238634,
0.1166580617,
-0.7560865283,
-0.071796611,
-1.1116302013,
-0.3937338293,
0.1391409039,
-0.2051569074,
-0.1729696542,
0.0566599555,
-0.0217167158,
0.5891600847,
-0.4535098374,
0.2661845386,
0.2894584239,
-0.3180560172,
0.4512861967,
-0.4778837562,
0.6661074758,
0.1985408962,
-0.1439995617,
0.6492096186,
-0.6693299413,
-0.3061141372,
0.3343929946,
-0.0281056706,
-0.0527368449,
0.3432582021,
0.3862400949,
-0.1309397817,
0.3193779886,
-0.1172671318,
0.4293384552,
-0.2861813605,
0.8523684144,
0.5406333208,
-0.207452625,
0.7406503558,
-0.0780873671,
0.7330728769,
0.2146890759,
0.3980988264,
-0.6773876548,
-0.4198938906,
-1.0766224861,
-0.0737729594,
0.2928535044,
0.5598941445,
-1.0145323277,
0.0426492393,
-0.372042805,
-0.4013831615,
-0.2913236022,
-0.0340537541,
-0.1212415919,
0.4053370655,
0.3431232572,
0.1609241664,
-0.6791924834,
-1.1884182692,
0.0387147926,
-0.0048308694,
0.1944103837,
0.0364807434,
0.134724468,
-0.186610058,
0.7942639589,
-0.6372105479,
-0.2169036567,
-0.6617042422,
0.2988514602,
0.3900988102,
0.2509298921,
0.6243860722,
-1.0147172213,
-0.3295402527,
-0.0948878974,
-0.7747725844,
0.1526128352,
-0.1319907308,
-0.0078284051,
-0.0515764691,
1.0371632576,
-0.5619738102,
0.3847726285,
0.5848737955,
-0.0049535399,
0.5080804229,
-0.2426433414,
-0.0324416943,
-0.902018249,
-0.2994003594,
-0.0739038736,
-0.3354942799,
-0.8225122094,
0.0046186647,
0.1294758171,
-0.2097328603,
-0.6706607342,
0.5120066404,
-0.8731337786,
-0.1492525637,
-0.5436768532,
-0.0065580807,
-0.1562578976,
0.346385628,
0.06863603,
0.5288468599,
1.0745637417,
-0.4148125648,
0.8038139939,
0.048357714,
-0.7189463973,
0.3756180704,
-0.5569290519,
-0.375756532,
-0.5179827213,
-0.0272287223,
-1.4095212221,
-0.3909369707,
-0.1958623081,
-0.0981770456,
0.6134462953,
-0.1709281802,
-0.5453467965,
-0.6365700364,
-0.3302568197,
0.2757001221,
0.4140240252,
-1.0514204502,
0.859138608,
0.3975739181,
-0.2432540208,
-0.5013695359,
-0.8994567394,
0.3822387159,
-0.3836989701,
-0.6072007418,
0.2619122863,
-0.3913222551,
-0.4415347278,
-0.2822457254,
0.4114455879,
-0.2428390682,
-0.098570846,
0.5006399751,
0.608160615,
-0.3182386756,
0.3902967274,
-0.0809986368,
-0.0826696306,
0.1050410643,
-0.4996242225,
0.6857569218,
-0.4586936831,
-0.3108523786,
-0.3675467968,
0.2329592258,
0.6147899032,
-0.1223314255,
0.6045168638,
0.4397480488,
-0.2601235509,
0.0139430678,
-0.6617613435,
-0.1101751849,
-0.4415288568,
0.6396855712,
0.0430395938,
-0.9097289443,
0.3896145225,
-0.1299026012,
-0.0585987195,
0.4040848613,
0.6164192557,
-0.2902259231,
0.9945916533,
1.1467518806,
-0.1363960207,
0.5744852424,
-0.5116530061,
0.3342904449,
-0.4081707895,
-0.341624409,
-0.2371044308,
-0.1416573226,
-0.4652864635,
-0.592227757,
0.2551061213,
-0.0442941338,
-0.238254115,
0.2532626688,
-0.5996174216,
0.7227160931,
0.5368679762,
-0.4714183807,
0.3092099428,
0.1345400363,
0.1793618947,
-0.197765246,
-1.0129908323,
-0.5071681738,
0.8798390031,
0.5085449815,
1.2048476934,
-0.1267706454,
0.1983288229,
0.2974076867,
0.7023122907,
-1.0187267065,
0.4710339606,
-0.2411864847,
-0.25424245,
-0.2630473375,
-0.1100255549,
-0.9899868965,
-0.1237602755,
-0.2302793711,
-0.7099878192,
-0.0240994319,
0.1502742916,
-0.1479882449,
0.5506218076,
-0.902893126,
0.7444342971,
-0.5712256432,
0.192705363,
0.2291046828,
-0.7854661942,
0.3673236966,
0.1183809489,
0.2711544335,
0.2368301451,
0.0701904595,
0.6948364973,
-0.0436211377,
0.8354142904,
-0.0821413398,
-0.0011900542,
0.3312946856,
0.0263785273,
0.2140761465,
-0.3060372472,
0.2737163007,
0.1143118963,
-0.0725612566,
-0.0041218614,
-0.5706774592,
1.0136371851,
-0.6323865652,
-0.6584069729,
-0.2456744462,
-0.8885746598,
0.161830321,
0.2314016074,
0.2130677104,
0.366892457,
-0.1041729972,
0.3170726895,
1.0172224045,
-0.606390357,
0.554110229,
0.4996597171,
-0.6800026298,
-0.3660002351,
0.9642518759,
0.2033894062,
0.0365090296,
0.7600041032,
0.1662281603,
-0.5615000725,
-0.6997639537,
-0.4212303162,
0.2911021709,
-1.2124928236,
-0.1486296505,
-0.5419630408,
-0.505456686,
-0.2347009927,
-0.0627226755,
-0.1996217072,
-0.5954073668,
-0.2966995835,
-0.3005399406,
0.5504407883,
1.1395289898,
0.3991887867,
0.629221797,
-0.5258348584,
0.2240488529,
0.5425115228,
0.1961115152,
0.0064688143,
-0.3312321603,
-0.2186596394,
-0.3456870615,
-0.1069751456,
-0.8020415306,
0.4444458485,
-0.1797939539,
0.7647097707,
0.4616578221,
-0.403948456,
0.1387487948,
-0.6902586222,
0.9589573741,
0.6061074138,
-0.6932911277,
0.4202721715,
-0.2441502064,
0.5188448429,
0.0256877188,
0.5650563836,
-0.4185100496,
-0.189267695,
-0.1924614012,
-0.8650304675,
0.3754387498,
-0.1273374408,
0.4022342265,
0.0742644146,
0.1950806379,
0.1169214547,
0.1771089882,
-1.0265151262,
-0.4825852513,
-0.4143461585,
-0.4842311144,
-0.2374403328,
-0.2710801363,
-0.2367651612,
-0.3032107949,
0.197343111,
-0.2375366092,
0.3730147481,
-0.110988766,
-0.1896030456,
0.0380634815,
0.009058184,
0.7074136138,
0.8354411721,
0.0925221071,
0.4020321071,
0.0559252724,
-0.0736255869,
0.0216892865,
0.1753760725,
-0.0322844312,
0.0618903786,
0.3610431254,
1.2728716135,
0.2826556563,
-0.6783494949,
0.7846071124,
-0.1669252962,
-0.2461314648,
-0.6009994745,
-0.0690199807,
0.5936820507,
0.3611480296,
0.4356295764,
-0.2322159857,
0.0084646419,
-0.4144183099,
-0.2858995199,
0.4282341003,
-0.6516231894,
-0.0408647172,
1.0529360771,
-0.1139673814,
-0.3936649263,
0.358784616,
0.5244873166,
-0.2933974862,
0.850533247,
0.423292011,
0.8083273768,
-0.1416227967,
0.0963160619,
0.1668245494,
0.3934088945,
-0.1255319417,
0.3466644883,
0.0873505026,
-0.2690941095,
-0.5777037144,
-0.4009000361,
-0.4944040775,
0.0903438181,
-0.4597908854,
0.3812716901,
-0.3854415715,
-0.0332329795,
0.2958399355,
-0.6362839937,
-0.9325799942,
0.2713887691,
0.3329412937,
1.1874730587,
-0.7294216752,
0.8672415614,
0.7055490017,
-0.6086739302,
-0.3195030391,
-0.4382487237,
-0.3423298895,
-0.7045998573,
1.0286597013,
0.2275868952,
0.078485243,
0.1303204894,
-1.2588369846,
-0.9328918457,
1.1944750547,
0.3171886504,
-0.8481645584,
0.0431677774,
0.3022987247,
0.5688536167,
-0.7089764476,
0.1844843179,
0.369417876,
0.6164299846,
-0.2333473414,
-0.1819910258,
-0.2254684865,
-0.1161037087,
0.2271782756,
-0.1564123631,
-0.4831635356,
0.8853462338,
-0.2300201803,
-0.0234853607,
0.2937618196,
0.8801370263,
-0.1947296262,
0.0774142519,
0.4473697841,
-0.0111995675,
0.5112594366,
-0.4332163036,
1.3725283146,
-0.4624839425,
0.094691202,
1.2323251963,
-0.017084958,
0.453707546,
0.6349701881,
0.0045030238,
0.6502816677,
0.4582884908,
-0.3657242656,
0.3776728213,
0.6651200056,
0.0617432222,
-0.0356525145,
-0.0572148636,
-0.0595282502,
0.2519560754,
0.2063252032,
-0.7647728324,
-0.0602274686,
0.4370349944,
-0.3383278847,
0.0576982349,
-0.4860088825,
0.7189443707,
0.1342525184,
-0.5716314316,
0.4251766503,
-0.0959711224,
0.3686188459,
-0.6732935309,
-0.2293730378,
-0.0062861554,
-0.248692438,
-0.0685059279,
-0.9287483096,
0.1253587455,
0.0209222119,
-0.4130192101,
-0.2572713494,
0.7837513685,
-0.6610318422,
-0.4364067912,
0.4741765559,
0.2889378667,
0.3437339067,
0.0162648708,
-0.3416475058,
0.0661518052,
-0.1628838181,
-0.0260273516,
-0.0305630155,
-0.0354347602,
-0.2267448306,
0.9667186141,
0.3536839187,
0.0334543772,
0.4334347248,
0.6672991514,
0.826043725,
-0.8629364967,
-0.2947369516,
-0.830234468,
0.5681527257,
-0.1385129094,
0.4213473797,
0.79529351,
0.7024700642,
0.3517178595,
-0.6702675223,
1.0150494576,
0.3788385987,
0.2648884654,
-0.6155323386,
0.8359422684,
-0.3537127078,
0.1275607795,
0.0568112694,
-1.2669246197,
-0.5997522473,
0.2232021987,
-0.2136327624,
-0.4186443388,
0.6214220524,
0.6582376361,
-0.0131241484,
0.0521848351,
0.4782187343,
0.4880920053,
0.2514629662,
0.2971424162,
1.2654210329,
-0.1395883113,
0.6922513843,
-0.0708174706,
-0.2150981873,
-0.1350576729,
-1.1435496807,
-1.0476864576,
-0.5834468007,
-0.4558882415,
-0.0702310652,
-0.2488999516,
0.6132145524,
0.9039817452,
-0.8512285948,
-0.5460965633,
-0.1458565444,
0.1714073122,
0.1255000681,
-0.2524238527,
0.4583557546,
-0.2120135874,
-0.7891737223,
0.4316233695,
0.5533448458,
0.4200389683,
-0.8429384232,
-0.0669989064,
0.0604975149,
0.2848793268,
0.6489331126,
0.2574958801,
-0.6362210512,
-0.0357469283,
-0.1123800427,
-0.0995531604,
0.360796988,
0.8459097743,
-0.486187309,
0.7703067064,
0.633036077,
0.463395685,
0.8973914981,
-0.1898907125,
0.5635777712,
-0.3626507819,
0.121988833,
-0.035130702,
0.5340416431,
0.6426827312,
-0.1010626554,
0.281295687,
-0.1645647734,
-0.3129451275,
-0.6427384615,
0.0814723149,
-1.351837635,
-0.1958401203,
0.9777084589,
-0.0078180721,
-0.4669224024,
0.1335710585,
-0.5386080742,
0.2391179353,
0.4240423441,
0.6307387352,
0.6961471438,
0.1898319572,
-0.3790482581,
-0.6832949519,
0.4221446216,
-0.1070192978,
-1.0922983885,
-0.0229609534,
0.2244576961,
0.3480789959,
0.2305540293,
0.3052877784,
-0.2343043536,
0.1752813607,
-0.3614977896,
0.3328129947,
-0.2263073474,
-0.5705223083,
-0.4920318127,
0.0737354457,
0.1037293151,
-0.0475151464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19504v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19504v1 | Are Generative Language Models Multicultural? A Study on Hausa Culture and Emotions using ChatGPT | 2024-06-27T19:42:13 | 2024-06-27T19:42:13 | Ibrahim Said Ahmad, Shiran Dudy, Resmi Ramachandranpillai, Kenneth Church | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, are widely used to generate
content for various purposes and audiences. However, these models may not
reflect the cultural and emotional diversity of their users, especially for
low-resource languages. In this paper, we investigate how ChatGPT represents
Hausa's culture and emotions. We compare responses generated by ChatGPT with
those provided by native Hausa speakers on 37 culturally relevant questions. We
conducted experiments using emotion analysis and applied two similarity metrics
to measure the alignment between human and ChatGPT responses. We also collected
human participants ratings and feedback on ChatGPT responses. Our results show
that ChatGPT has some level of similarity to human responses, but also exhibits
some gaps and biases in its knowledge and awareness of the Hausa culture and
emotions. We discuss the implications and limitations of our methodology and
analysis and suggest ways to improve the performance and evaluation of LLMs for
low-resource languages. | [
-0.58549124,
-0.6148859859,
-0.1985052675,
0.3771602511,
-0.3388352692,
0.3467919827,
-0.5904890895,
-0.5397210717,
0.2719349265,
0.0487790368,
-0.5166518688,
-0.3294277191,
-0.3764699697,
0.2854251266,
-0.1748208702,
0.9122460485,
0.0571531206,
-0.2036626637,
0.0805073157,
-0.4060510993,
-0.3643578291,
-0.7770099044,
-0.7643648982,
-0.3858029544,
0.4711820185,
0.2071768045,
0.9675906301,
0.244319275,
0.4858854711,
0.2324080765,
-0.4658068419,
-0.1850758642,
-0.6796373725,
0.0534655005,
-0.0739165992,
-0.413059473,
-0.3764064312,
0.0227602404,
0.2142597884,
0.4808160365,
-0.3156858981,
0.2061432451,
0.2796580791,
0.7026997209,
-0.4472226501,
0.0618651956,
-0.2909435928,
0.6503193974,
-0.3385813534,
-0.068962492,
-0.1730654985,
-0.5254182816,
0.2274533361,
-0.496070534,
0.2318363935,
0.2462110817,
0.6850462556,
0.3327667713,
-0.9252279997,
-0.4294085205,
-0.6400842071,
0.7268812656,
-0.5756767392,
0.1424068213,
0.0946367085,
0.1042411029,
0.0568049736,
0.0754645169,
-0.8321064115,
-0.0621098801,
-0.0957069322,
0.5256333351,
-0.4928460419,
-0.1655552089,
0.3176956475,
0.7124539614,
-0.8879376054,
0.3398469985,
-0.3622478247,
0.023358481,
0.6955680847,
0.3618768454,
0.533400774,
-0.5054386854,
-0.5548291206,
-0.1831274331,
-0.7641323209,
-0.1285799146,
0.5274924636,
0.1439855695,
-0.6877608895,
0.4907407165,
0.0277898479,
0.517757833,
-0.4760401547,
-0.2040554285,
0.3395142257,
0.1057300419,
-0.130665943,
-0.2305844426,
1.0090444088,
0.4811013937,
0.9499900341,
0.1438618451,
0.0405419283,
0.135616973,
0.2563643157,
-0.6242103577,
-0.0468533002,
-0.1916223764,
-0.755787909,
-0.2890601754,
-0.3164947033,
-1.095080018,
-0.4826257527,
-0.0009945343,
-0.0481564738,
-0.3290951252,
-0.5751322508,
-0.163982138,
0.0776110962,
0.3024535775,
0.2931575179,
-1.0083428621,
0.2509537041,
0.5330982208,
0.606092453,
-0.4492815435,
-0.1128338501,
0.2693213224,
-0.5013201833,
-0.1951553971,
0.5149915218,
-0.4872441888,
-0.8506940007,
0.1680065989,
-0.3500234485,
-0.0249749757,
-0.6840938926,
0.5416940451,
-0.5577828288,
0.3858076334,
-0.6544623971,
-0.2064864039,
-0.2342617661,
0.3943245411,
-0.5021086335,
0.9797613621,
0.2892970443,
-0.8615435958,
0.2453644872,
-0.5972640514,
-0.3634973168,
0.3766655028,
-0.3120918274,
0.0535372086,
0.0856241807,
-0.1117919832,
-0.0284068901,
-0.5011191964,
-0.2513144016,
-0.3740621209,
-0.3896536231,
0.4181149006,
-0.527771771,
0.7664484382,
0.6609961987,
-0.32282722,
-0.0490579419,
-0.4437512159,
-0.216566056,
0.3677047491,
-0.5730500221,
-0.1812132448,
-0.0678834543,
-0.0051265834,
0.2969091833,
0.0579364523,
-0.4900121689,
0.2232300788,
-0.0842513517,
0.1676293015,
0.8347451687,
-0.2307991385,
0.3240448236,
-0.2492342889,
1.0287452936,
0.1307332367,
-0.0502533689,
0.1423923224,
-0.7381624579,
-0.8747031093,
-0.0687957779,
-0.2521426678,
0.6900610328,
-0.2899042666,
0.2405789644,
-0.1312286407,
-0.4997514188,
-0.5256652832,
0.0749948323,
0.0711279511,
0.5649200082,
-0.1563895494,
-0.4955646992,
-0.4134269357,
-0.853192091,
-0.0881397277,
-0.4934634566,
-0.2071145624,
0.5411599874,
0.3304767013,
-0.1942427903,
0.9229547977,
-0.4712812006,
0.0276181474,
-0.0317026563,
0.3651332259,
-0.0151357306,
0.0809979886,
0.6720271707,
-0.7476146221,
-0.6731022,
0.3392364979,
-1.1022933722,
0.0072943834,
0.3583569825,
-0.1552879214,
0.2956120074,
-0.0475681536,
-0.6803535223,
0.3947312534,
0.7422744036,
-0.2688301504,
0.4700540304,
-0.0144198732,
0.3242722154,
-1.2865748405,
-0.039577771,
-0.0086261677,
0.1549111307,
-0.4505993128,
-0.0391960666,
-0.117351599,
-0.7314996123,
-0.5531646609,
0.6980311871,
-0.2607602775,
-0.1589754224,
-0.3735828698,
0.0726704523,
-0.0861428678,
0.3819406331,
0.4913792908,
0.7362591624,
0.3427649736,
-0.2153543234,
0.7657968998,
0.4539261162,
-0.5483451486,
0.7034903765,
-0.4736011922,
0.2902441621,
-0.2768832445,
0.2125664502,
-0.6370651722,
-0.3897868991,
0.1667456031,
-0.2085026503,
-0.2085532397,
-0.2583708167,
-0.5077643991,
-0.4677337408,
0.2085764855,
0.5939636827,
1.1463602781,
-0.3510607183,
0.3905684054,
0.156448856,
-0.5529074073,
-0.4108999968,
-0.5018607378,
-0.0506589711,
-0.5814757347,
-0.8338631392,
-0.0572060831,
-0.0581082664,
-0.5699285269,
-0.0741813257,
0.3058291674,
0.1195353344,
0.1611509621,
0.355298996,
0.1460056603,
-0.4517703354,
0.222024262,
-0.4154293239,
0.3975725472,
-0.003749375,
0.1154555753,
0.7464325428,
-0.6133491397,
-0.5252970457,
-0.0462941229,
0.5300601125,
0.4531113803,
-0.3876776993,
0.6865211129,
0.9600098729,
-0.3502231836,
0.0664814189,
-0.35166049,
-0.0533574857,
-0.3685362041,
0.2753338516,
-0.2803319991,
-1.2412705421,
0.8696940541,
0.37453866,
-0.2755868435,
0.2563431263,
1.1483052969,
-0.4374485016,
0.4390746653,
0.5471382737,
-0.1845149994,
0.3732194602,
0.1023009866,
0.3320920467,
-0.6396561861,
-0.1307822615,
-0.5320958495,
-0.5403478146,
-1.0557852983,
-0.1735890359,
0.4326099455,
-0.1925303489,
-0.3272462785,
-0.0697003976,
-0.0482463837,
0.2803190351,
0.3820537329,
-0.3314203322,
0.1693525165,
0.1619716585,
0.2961491346,
-0.1589095294,
-0.7923927307,
-0.6098178029,
0.5761837959,
0.5331822634,
1.1477236748,
0.4729353487,
0.7420105934,
0.2407982796,
0.6249081492,
-0.8239004612,
0.3757709563,
-0.076986663,
-0.8770187497,
-0.0900183544,
-0.5668429732,
-0.894102335,
0.5368853211,
-0.2122575939,
-0.9201523066,
0.2624904811,
0.1108715981,
-0.2402957678,
0.2876802683,
-0.7165443897,
0.8539297581,
-0.0681015551,
-0.0333261043,
-0.0393042155,
-0.3568481803,
0.4783001542,
-0.1612868011,
0.3698852658,
-0.3643658161,
0.3196710646,
0.7308807969,
-0.3395369351,
1.0968893766,
0.3581520021,
-0.5071210861,
0.5416573286,
0.3812717795,
0.0644415319,
-0.0534965917,
-0.2343038917,
0.0732897818,
-0.3700649142,
-0.5378618836,
-0.4627280533,
0.7111800909,
-0.9731158614,
-0.6532500982,
-0.3436883688,
-0.7364994287,
0.0419896133,
-0.1298969686,
0.3612890542,
0.0690428317,
-0.3503280878,
0.0476869047,
0.2589869797,
-0.5076438785,
0.2925126851,
0.382594645,
-0.0236332454,
0.0170734599,
0.7135228515,
-0.1692514122,
0.4165277183,
0.0581055135,
0.2066177726,
-0.0720991567,
0.1782085299,
-0.4338347018,
0.0646270141,
-0.7618480325,
0.1146484315,
-0.3065621555,
-0.0182611868,
-0.3892141283,
-0.1301759481,
-0.368470639,
-0.0581838377,
-0.1153806224,
-0.0231211167,
0.2440548837,
0.7463299632,
0.0954301357,
0.548902452,
-0.8174526095,
-0.0308614615,
0.4457540214,
0.2600403726,
0.0981096178,
-0.5206556916,
-0.0676169917,
0.0251568444,
-0.4861848354,
-0.9910126328,
0.4646916687,
0.1459303349,
0.1782831252,
0.5998684764,
0.0525367558,
0.2593819201,
-0.1221281365,
0.9243311286,
-0.0905670449,
-0.6389522552,
0.3525857627,
-0.4583981037,
0.430316925,
0.0794596672,
0.5879389048,
-0.991106391,
-0.1865216345,
-0.3289161026,
-0.386072576,
0.4592025578,
0.2938877642,
0.6415211558,
-0.3446519077,
-0.0741360486,
0.0696400404,
0.0476056151,
-0.9904124141,
-0.0617806204,
-0.2397560924,
-0.2290944308,
-0.0696178526,
-0.3318801522,
-0.1489693373,
0.4022037089,
0.2071896791,
-0.0792461112,
0.2458274662,
-0.2578192949,
-0.0060956147,
-0.3287312984,
0.6719747186,
0.3177171052,
0.189068228,
-0.3351529539,
0.1004545316,
0.3642837405,
-0.3069366217,
0.357539624,
-0.2715097964,
-0.0316583551,
-0.2038967162,
0.6175046563,
0.9103928804,
-0.0065838424,
-0.554887712,
0.4303345978,
-0.2142697722,
0.2183620483,
-0.2634573281,
-0.0700900257,
0.2617782354,
0.2432384193,
-0.0035213535,
-0.0621779412,
-0.0345421098,
-0.7879993916,
-0.437635541,
0.3686388135,
-0.4689715803,
-0.341889441,
0.3868199885,
0.5142115355,
-0.2473188788,
1.1684687138,
-0.2195548266,
-0.7718489766,
0.4745266736,
0.5676774383,
0.6576731205,
-0.2435918599,
0.2676748037,
0.2870795429,
0.2749516368,
0.2865250409,
0.3589662611,
-0.0622257218,
-1.1014845371,
-0.3252796233,
-0.9548466802,
-0.4791109264,
-0.1567936242,
-0.8297138214,
0.0156105803,
-0.0306431167,
-0.4017915428,
-0.5033026934,
-0.2792838812,
-0.8815532327,
0.379850179,
0.533641696,
0.8814664483,
-1.1070256233,
0.5873088837,
0.7922864556,
-0.3440342546,
-0.5707902312,
0.0722725019,
0.3725828826,
-0.6616360545,
1.0338053703,
-0.0728396252,
0.1068031341,
-0.2420840412,
0.023611512,
-0.5951305628,
0.6601763368,
0.2411711961,
-0.1311594248,
0.0242449734,
0.4610734582,
0.8514963984,
-0.3007847965,
0.2632162869,
0.3484778106,
0.073235482,
-0.1082026511,
-0.9817069769,
-0.2004139572,
-0.5515842438,
0.260915041,
-0.0410303324,
-0.9701373577,
0.8519479036,
-0.2325446308,
-0.4712544978,
-0.0783381164,
0.8107762337,
0.4417667389,
-0.0785108432,
0.4624913633,
0.4437221587,
0.7125079036,
-0.2284959853,
1.3488976955,
0.0188052226,
0.4527330697,
0.7261030674,
-0.5520138144,
0.7425452471,
0.2418999672,
-0.5245414376,
0.4457342327,
0.9066355824,
0.1146517918,
-0.035391245,
0.5329963565,
-0.6440686584,
-0.1700790673,
-0.3453266323,
-0.4603087008,
0.719021678,
0.0082788486,
-0.0967729911,
-0.1315131783,
0.0577008687,
0.1625669301,
-0.1362770647,
0.0416947864,
0.7152988315,
0.4287869632,
-0.5566840768,
0.6735249162,
-0.0568856895,
0.7831416726,
-0.2818716466,
0.4545105696,
-0.8132252097,
-0.137964204,
-0.1677184999,
-0.9418215156,
0.2659426332,
0.4787970781,
-0.0705718249,
0.0434300713,
0.4539628923,
-0.3166177571,
-0.3424969912,
0.1946494877,
0.5064872503,
0.3682748079,
0.0051249475,
-0.2819628119,
0.2435174882,
0.0454429537,
-0.2939113379,
0.2615334094,
0.3878806531,
-0.3184536695,
0.8156681061,
0.2919028401,
-0.0452575237,
0.0423087813,
0.2841648459,
0.3768486083,
-0.5903326869,
-0.4159972668,
-0.9573121071,
0.3596242368,
0.1472215801,
-0.4886853397,
0.4355713129,
0.4231128991,
0.8021784425,
-0.4623276889,
0.8664044738,
-0.161938414,
0.163762942,
-0.3849563003,
0.7991556525,
-0.4971469641,
-0.0053776633,
-0.2751426995,
-1.2392555475,
0.0566845983,
0.5285460949,
-0.3014389575,
0.2663928568,
0.3605076075,
0.7394708991,
-0.1469305605,
0.3370681405,
0.2596306205,
0.1358853728,
0.3095133603,
0.5624861121,
1.3120247126,
0.0468053035,
0.3812689185,
-0.2309625298,
-0.3329794705,
-0.1156207547,
-0.8966508508,
-0.719216764,
-0.4421632886,
-0.3837230802,
-0.09823066,
-0.2090718597,
0.9707429409,
0.5992904902,
-0.5713284016,
-0.5487107038,
0.616073966,
-0.1623245925,
0.2778506279,
-0.2192210555,
0.1944918633,
-0.062989749,
-0.7800963521,
-0.0134983547,
0.2072238922,
0.3903456032,
-0.1393542439,
-0.3419809639,
0.4266754389,
-0.1064660102,
0.8130199313,
0.3030898571,
-0.6512649059,
-0.3434222043,
0.024746038,
-0.2037473321,
-0.0313016959,
0.5637789369,
-0.2856008708,
0.2281495184,
0.5874566436,
0.3483799398,
0.4244613647,
0.1124237701,
0.7031549811,
-0.7587321401,
0.4013161361,
0.0198414158,
0.5606657863,
0.6345011592,
-0.0774074718,
0.4406559467,
0.2490436882,
-0.5074096918,
-0.3786655366,
0.5378503203,
-1.0230180025,
0.4010959268,
1.2585680485,
-0.3282295465,
-0.0578832701,
0.4919600189,
-0.2720329165,
0.2581205368,
-0.1073304489,
0.8657436371,
0.9730555415,
-0.1347064376,
-0.2769225836,
-0.3963463306,
0.3428093195,
0.5579445958,
-0.9483482838,
-0.0102760531,
0.3551702201,
0.282535553,
0.1846032292,
0.5018945336,
-0.2554278672,
0.101381287,
-0.1092904732,
0.412497133,
0.5990852118,
0.3934108615,
-0.2172495872,
0.0470637418,
0.3083963692,
0.3426209092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19502v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19502v1 | Investigating How Large Language Models Leverage Internal Knowledge to Perform Complex Reasoning | 2024-06-27T19:29:36 | 2024-06-27T19:29:36 | Miyoung Ko, Sue Hyun Park, Joonsuk Park, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite significant advancements, there is a limited understanding of how
large language models (LLMs) utilize knowledge for reasoning. To address this,
we propose a method that deconstructs complex real-world questions into a
graph, representing each question as a node with parent nodes of background
knowledge needed to solve the question. We develop the DepthQA dataset,
deconstructing questions into three depths: (i) recalling conceptual knowledge,
(ii) applying procedural knowledge, and (iii) analyzing strategic knowledge.
Based on a hierarchical graph, we quantify forward discrepancy, discrepancies
in LLMs' performance on simpler sub-problems versus complex questions. We also
measure backward discrepancy, where LLMs answer complex questions but struggle
with simpler ones. Our analysis shows that smaller models have more
discrepancies than larger models. Additionally, guiding models from simpler to
complex questions through multi-turn interactions improves performance across
model sizes, highlighting the importance of structured intermediate steps in
knowledge reasoning. This work enhances our understanding of LLM reasoning and
suggests ways to improve their problem-solving abilities. | [
-0.4541739821,
-0.9914886355,
0.9956120849,
-0.2348611802,
0.0554814599,
0.3975107968,
-0.1585639864,
-0.4517645538,
-0.3808560669,
0.6328647733,
-0.6118972898,
-0.4698210359,
-0.518243134,
-0.0722365379,
-0.2010823786,
0.5673573613,
-0.151277706,
0.0611765049,
-0.2360660881,
0.0071305134,
-0.2929559052,
-0.402687639,
-0.8387024999,
-0.6760376096,
0.6585745215,
0.7453597784,
0.7933557034,
0.2647781968,
0.4175541699,
0.2867847383,
-0.3282611966,
0.5382862091,
-0.6710966229,
0.2165646255,
-0.3063317537,
-0.595136106,
-0.1919926852,
-0.3345775604,
0.7418851256,
1.1659339666,
0.1056104898,
0.1139419004,
-0.084801361,
0.607467711,
-0.3689795732,
0.4862614572,
-0.6604812741,
-0.0238642506,
0.0564599819,
-0.0235333927,
-0.2017178833,
-0.4275126457,
0.1965844482,
-0.3970151246,
-0.1276758462,
-0.0373920612,
0.7539907098,
0.1497035176,
-0.6963033676,
-0.4162881076,
-0.9348659515,
0.4128416181,
-0.7750148773,
0.3040243387,
0.2620215118,
0.3662656844,
-0.2654045224,
-0.6102783084,
-0.6136443615,
-0.1740442216,
-0.1968435347,
-0.2000345439,
-0.3597934842,
0.1593146622,
0.4476320446,
0.2267543525,
-0.4059955478,
0.1122199371,
-0.5354570746,
-0.0716235936,
0.5885746479,
0.2853973508,
0.4457041025,
0.0316825919,
0.0929267928,
-0.1573813707,
-0.9295989871,
0.3457839191,
0.3550839126,
0.2875176072,
0.1593928039,
0.6362922788,
-0.2817419171,
0.6867444515,
-0.0088991551,
-0.3220655322,
0.00808948,
-0.2091259211,
-0.1510950625,
-0.0394445434,
0.3837834597,
0.1432988495,
0.6224879622,
-0.0633371919,
-0.2022418678,
-0.4050552249,
0.0010693307,
-0.627666831,
-0.3734337389,
0.2516373396,
-0.1024742946,
0.1431201547,
-0.0186985098,
-0.2548687756,
-0.3367307782,
-0.5858220458,
0.510253191,
-0.4416721165,
-0.4623993635,
0.2919639349,
-0.2021034807,
0.2103254199,
0.4222583175,
-0.3750858307,
0.333443135,
0.8519884348,
0.481253773,
0.1962554604,
-0.2107462734,
-0.168142885,
0.3651327789,
-0.5439490676,
0.7735857368,
-0.4283823073,
-0.1689741462,
-0.0817124918,
0.073033385,
-0.1085864082,
-0.8064547777,
0.3334418535,
-0.559374094,
0.0098963669,
-0.5970426202,
-0.5671146512,
-0.4484845996,
0.7474375367,
-0.7282511592,
0.7597991228,
-0.0120399408,
-0.8410652876,
0.0802192688,
-0.5126320124,
-0.3466992378,
-0.0283637624,
-0.2422321141,
-0.1262241453,
-0.0991598889,
0.2654551864,
0.5383808613,
-0.4240808487,
0.2415527999,
-0.3057466447,
-0.2302421778,
0.1422329396,
-0.077387765,
0.7341951132,
0.022178309,
-0.1053780839,
0.2748077214,
-0.7379360199,
0.0425851829,
0.2904780805,
-0.3580067456,
-0.4488681853,
-0.1289254278,
-0.7879463434,
0.3249594569,
0.1158721521,
-0.4199729562,
0.4684577584,
-0.5152763128,
0.5138348341,
0.5425408483,
0.2181429863,
0.4778696001,
-0.1542072296,
0.4573082626,
0.2227731049,
0.0277296696,
0.0109989587,
-0.5064470768,
-0.901304543,
-0.0223373212,
0.0436675064,
0.3942555189,
-0.7391706109,
-0.0673795268,
-0.342517972,
-0.4687303603,
-0.3788324296,
0.0363037735,
0.3502722383,
0.6325315237,
0.3803795576,
0.1941899955,
-0.3139333129,
-1.1283938885,
-0.2626588941,
-0.2466297597,
0.1167027727,
0.3366423249,
0.7781478167,
-0.1564097553,
0.8187767863,
-0.7399662137,
0.1622491032,
-0.5575429201,
0.0812718868,
0.1177899837,
0.3294105232,
0.1313476712,
-0.663702786,
-0.0487804487,
0.0230506342,
-0.7725685835,
0.0586230829,
0.0223727189,
-0.3383876681,
-0.2380539924,
0.6638075113,
-0.9444949031,
0.1863624901,
0.3567516208,
-0.4428913295,
0.6393538713,
-0.1873993278,
-0.0273221098,
-0.6268526912,
-0.1063909829,
-0.1445563138,
-0.0440570302,
-0.587387085,
0.2903463244,
-0.0739441738,
0.0628943816,
-0.1117443591,
0.5962074399,
-0.5715491772,
-0.2316356599,
0.165457502,
0.2355288565,
0.1973406821,
0.407903403,
-0.0551962927,
0.4613566697,
0.2649164796,
-0.5957165956,
0.3394769728,
-0.0002263347,
-0.5650286078,
0.2283237725,
-0.7706893682,
0.1967982799,
-0.4131291509,
0.2706576586,
-1.2557572126,
-0.3159503937,
0.0108791003,
-0.2098814398,
0.3077571094,
-0.2637568712,
-0.7516906857,
-0.427570343,
0.0622090511,
0.5932045579,
0.2192262709,
-0.324026674,
0.797352612,
0.438118428,
-0.1876710504,
-0.3990514874,
-0.6468199492,
-0.1718400568,
-0.1341647208,
-1.0779200792,
0.1048872396,
0.0161862131,
-0.8270508051,
0.0940297693,
-0.0459551029,
-0.2024513632,
0.0529786088,
0.0532320589,
-0.1301961541,
-0.371417582,
0.3682705164,
0.2765162289,
0.1691962779,
0.4336474836,
-0.3030740023,
0.6616764069,
-0.176652506,
-0.5580040216,
-0.1844178885,
0.3511466384,
0.6946168542,
-0.3447654843,
0.7523654103,
0.1780892462,
-0.4612452686,
-0.4405936599,
-0.5083327889,
-0.2660870254,
-0.3716026247,
0.3305752575,
-0.7389306426,
-0.9877154827,
0.7508319616,
-0.285688132,
0.0371033736,
0.3981500864,
0.6477823853,
-0.1028585806,
1.1856323481,
0.3255961835,
0.3339569271,
-0.113578476,
-0.6732824445,
0.384665817,
-0.6827973723,
-0.6682622433,
-0.3533951342,
-0.3351937532,
-0.0966269523,
-0.6132128835,
0.3740338683,
0.4113697708,
-0.793074429,
-0.0660242885,
-0.1051564142,
0.4949523509,
0.4656521082,
0.0592544265,
0.5939263701,
-0.2936980426,
-0.4056662321,
0.2213788033,
-0.8949517608,
-0.4071856737,
0.6479145288,
0.5009742379,
0.7809427381,
0.2304005921,
0.4239837825,
-0.1953428835,
0.1130215824,
-0.8992224336,
0.5192641616,
0.2394218594,
-0.658592999,
-0.5323098898,
-0.6704568267,
-0.9379213452,
0.4875469804,
-0.0275319535,
-0.3781313896,
0.0903340504,
-0.019439714,
-0.2725404799,
0.5522632003,
-0.7126239538,
0.7995764613,
-0.2227068543,
0.0520378314,
-0.1729363054,
-0.5160084367,
0.7274807096,
0.1810876578,
0.5171734691,
-0.1554251611,
0.3513689041,
0.4579157829,
-0.3944954276,
0.8294152617,
-0.0950128138,
-0.5662618279,
0.4610437453,
0.5777723789,
0.472769469,
-0.0289167371,
0.0706709325,
0.0364125632,
-0.0095716696,
-0.3543620706,
-0.7411353588,
0.5931285024,
-0.8740882874,
-0.8361878991,
-0.0237097908,
-0.7703074217,
-0.511900723,
0.1299829632,
0.0032975236,
0.4730280638,
0.0897532403,
0.2977494597,
0.8577306271,
-0.2247791737,
0.0490684509,
0.3739433885,
-0.3569732606,
-0.0262215827,
0.3745460808,
0.4412805438,
0.5156697035,
0.487383008,
0.40876472,
-0.288097322,
-0.4867565334,
-0.0996858627,
0.4123905301,
-1.1005400419,
-0.1304810345,
-0.6522292495,
-0.3001080751,
-0.3446227312,
0.1812554151,
-0.266168803,
-0.4148901701,
-0.0328681953,
-0.3941659331,
0.0360235758,
0.9456833005,
0.12531358,
0.0345707051,
-0.7506818175,
0.3230487704,
0.7067906857,
0.0741482973,
0.4928711057,
-0.4924679399,
-0.062816523,
0.1392122954,
-0.0557325296,
-0.8650053144,
0.1168827042,
-0.013416633,
0.6134482026,
0.1543242633,
0.016001178,
0.7793322802,
-0.440446049,
0.6287204623,
-0.1785440147,
-0.9104818702,
0.4554682374,
-0.4281030297,
0.659668088,
0.1937706321,
0.5326647162,
-0.3498483598,
-0.4214115739,
-0.4533718228,
-0.7884122133,
0.4675651789,
0.100531064,
-0.045950748,
0.082793206,
0.5257516503,
-0.1318375915,
0.040733777,
-0.5608792901,
-0.0947343782,
0.1585293263,
-0.0950984508,
0.1934614778,
-0.2870129943,
-0.3883863091,
-0.5735217929,
0.3825722039,
-0.2369900346,
-0.0620399863,
0.1996463835,
-0.0744272247,
-0.1975130141,
0.1997408569,
0.4005307555,
1.0904421806,
0.062246006,
0.3507742882,
0.2598800063,
0.0454856008,
-0.1122291759,
-0.3331261277,
-0.0317770503,
-0.3939468265,
0.8446151614,
0.6200059056,
0.3207994401,
-0.8708509803,
0.2989251018,
-0.0101976451,
-0.3451517224,
-0.2539406717,
-0.0400589295,
0.5996161103,
0.6019974351,
0.3703825772,
-0.2284080833,
0.0025045057,
-0.9984651804,
0.0947465822,
0.3828115165,
-0.1814755946,
-0.1907097399,
0.1824605018,
-0.0628507882,
-0.1778761595,
0.7809541225,
-0.043550618,
-0.8238030076,
0.7681569457,
0.477216661,
0.3138901889,
-0.0314857587,
0.2731669545,
0.3808815777,
0.4267764986,
-0.1814234406,
0.4378811419,
0.0806428716,
-1.0727965832,
-0.6660322547,
-0.2488311082,
-0.4033107162,
0.2553235888,
-0.4691664577,
-0.0584765822,
-0.6220217347,
0.0848973617,
-0.0686895028,
0.0293571129,
-0.7580263615,
0.382681489,
0.2219093293,
0.8378683329,
-0.5032898784,
0.6724657416,
0.5254433155,
-0.5643278956,
-1.2744603157,
0.0617667772,
-0.1157798097,
-0.8251283169,
1.0843298435,
0.0343678594,
-0.4759725928,
-0.0958087146,
-0.8135436177,
-1.012681365,
1.0525387526,
0.3892795742,
-0.6228043437,
-0.2239083499,
0.1391539723,
0.5501311421,
-0.5211925507,
0.0868277326,
0.744887948,
0.5485958457,
0.3636581302,
-0.8400763273,
0.2103768289,
-0.0368375517,
-0.3419960439,
0.2453031838,
-0.5336790085,
1.2971999645,
-0.5057957768,
-0.165148288,
-0.3339063227,
0.4580956697,
0.4151415229,
0.2409241945,
0.5901440382,
0.5261439681,
1.0594644547,
-0.1498191059,
0.9648775458,
-0.2501707971,
0.2842621803,
1.2063795328,
-0.2544425726,
0.7663068175,
0.2690290511,
0.0428618938,
0.8330379725,
0.4609658122,
0.2909778953,
0.1912338287,
0.5756040215,
0.1073224843,
-0.7752811909,
0.1187880114,
-0.2960468829,
0.5926578045,
0.5982424021,
-0.0859036595,
-0.3298662901,
-0.2370569408,
0.2280169129,
0.0112336557,
-0.48871997,
0.8627334237,
0.2209617943,
-0.7670838237,
0.5982838869,
0.0442194715,
0.0834566206,
-0.5303526521,
-0.1696530282,
-0.2860962451,
0.2918823361,
-0.2444046289,
-1.3428879976,
0.2329616249,
-0.1558001041,
-0.1043143123,
0.1354127824,
0.7156944275,
-0.5365586877,
-0.4462422132,
0.5414062142,
0.8061065078,
0.0174127202,
-0.3535740077,
-0.6296528578,
-0.0120756384,
-0.0650041848,
-0.1752288789,
0.1533008516,
1.0341407061,
-0.2032707483,
1.0496468544,
0.6017407179,
-0.0629377067,
0.0485275052,
0.3569105268,
1.0943267345,
-0.7053983212,
-0.2664236426,
-0.7779844999,
0.6154593229,
-0.1655354351,
-0.2500823736,
0.8355701566,
0.393617183,
0.9324479699,
0.1149171144,
0.6430518031,
0.3798716366,
0.5085299015,
-0.6232300401,
0.4244567752,
-0.6186565161,
0.4736100733,
-0.1377854198,
-0.7165164351,
-0.3055021167,
0.5164004564,
-0.5747000575,
-0.1173767,
0.5858132839,
0.5600067377,
0.0000059366,
-0.0820372552,
0.2413107902,
0.6877166629,
0.6002889872,
0.756395638,
1.1339696646,
-0.0326929241,
0.5943850279,
-0.1954416633,
-0.0853067562,
0.0095846374,
-0.4807320237,
-1.1276515722,
-0.4454873204,
-0.126811564,
-0.2987574637,
-0.1484553367,
0.7433592677,
0.6381744146,
-0.6363098025,
-0.2869624496,
0.0686518028,
0.467615813,
-0.0189217851,
-0.2457330376,
0.3586437106,
-0.1891850829,
-0.398180306,
0.4466782212,
0.1933498383,
-0.1207957938,
-0.5753033757,
0.0356189571,
-0.3500410914,
0.2629850507,
0.9197178483,
0.0590544678,
-0.8038030267,
-0.3607076108,
-0.0695558339,
0.034918882,
-0.0005300298,
1.0703872442,
-0.5670476556,
0.1536788642,
0.7302429676,
0.4598279297,
0.6350182891,
0.1209287271,
0.5428076386,
-0.6600251794,
-0.0873734951,
0.3854082823,
0.4069690704,
0.4034376144,
-0.2842286229,
0.3778247535,
0.0514550358,
-0.4706427157,
-0.7265758514,
0.5489076972,
-0.668974638,
-0.8642356396,
1.318674922,
-0.1959714741,
-0.0895806774,
-0.2593522966,
-0.3589661419,
0.0743378922,
-0.1918292344,
0.5442593694,
0.9744152427,
-0.349391073,
-0.3192567527,
-0.3842038512,
0.4721696973,
-0.0517995358,
-0.8575578332,
0.015086242,
0.5018095374,
0.4889623821,
0.1435044557,
0.5395442843,
-0.1174841449,
-0.1985372603,
-0.1137004793,
-0.3497896194,
-0.0676268786,
-0.6256023645,
-0.0624225624,
0.6100656986,
0.0967066139,
0.4332054257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19501v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19501v1 | Monitoring Latent World States in Language Models with Propositional Probes | 2024-06-27T19:28:43 | 2024-06-27T19:28:43 | Jiahai Feng, Stuart Russell, Jacob Steinhardt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models are susceptible to bias, sycophancy, backdoors, and other
tendencies that lead to unfaithful responses to the input context. Interpreting
internal states of language models could help monitor and correct unfaithful
behavior. We hypothesize that language models represent their input contexts in
a latent world model, and seek to extract this latent world state from the
activations. We do so with 'propositional probes', which compositionally probe
tokens for lexical information and bind them into logical propositions
representing the world state. For example, given the input context ''Greg is a
nurse. Laura is a physicist.'', we decode the propositions ''WorksAs(Greg,
nurse)'' and ''WorksAs(Laura, physicist)'' from the model's activations. Key to
this is identifying a 'binding subspace' in which bound tokens have high
similarity (''Greg'' and ''nurse'') but unbound ones do not (''Greg'' and
''physicist''). We validate propositional probes in a closed-world setting with
finitely many predicates and properties. Despite being trained on simple
templated contexts, propositional probes generalize to contexts rewritten as
short stories and translated to Spanish. Moreover, we find that in three
settings where language models respond unfaithfully to the input context --
prompt injections, backdoor attacks, and gender bias -- the decoded
propositions remain faithful. This suggests that language models often encode a
faithful world model but decode it unfaithfully, which motivates the search for
better interpretability tools for monitoring LMs. | [
0.0772322193,
-0.6982329488,
0.8090898991,
0.0133390492,
-0.1329388618,
-0.2290594578,
0.0026026277,
-0.1782999784,
-0.1042618826,
0.5512052774,
-0.4910458326,
-0.4170169234,
-0.3436128199,
0.0515124798,
-0.5830106735,
0.9482215643,
-0.0227383804,
0.0719766766,
-0.2701151669,
0.0765334517,
-0.0596148632,
-0.5766175389,
-0.1712178439,
-0.5161803961,
0.3083762825,
-0.1301997602,
0.7505933046,
0.2895623446,
0.3572966158,
0.277120918,
-0.3776352406,
0.024832828,
-0.5712193251,
0.3046624362,
-0.4885588586,
-0.7146487236,
-0.2843288481,
0.3023642004,
0.6197951436,
0.8325105309,
0.0198811926,
0.1334851086,
0.1629820764,
0.0927469209,
-0.6403129697,
0.3359158933,
-0.4140402377,
0.2243088633,
-0.0431456789,
-0.2450098693,
-0.5967029333,
-0.077881895,
0.3438060582,
-0.3718062937,
0.2796632051,
0.0474877693,
0.6382884979,
0.203017801,
-0.836183548,
-0.2519651949,
-0.7500811815,
0.7394725084,
-0.8707564473,
0.5841190219,
0.3324795961,
-0.1471863985,
-0.7018292546,
-0.5192077756,
-0.6886572242,
-0.4343012273,
-0.3162655234,
0.1907899231,
-0.4502180517,
0.3346396089,
0.3866001964,
0.3923732638,
-0.510234952,
0.0533125773,
-0.1613710374,
-0.5419902802,
0.2092704475,
0.1800499111,
0.5028946996,
-0.4000777304,
-0.2976042628,
0.03626341,
-0.8352777958,
0.2480308414,
0.3431406617,
0.2668404579,
-0.172611922,
0.8531426787,
0.1326346099,
0.8668906689,
-0.1737958938,
-0.2249545157,
-0.1611835659,
-0.2812898159,
-0.0632490739,
-0.0849103406,
0.7658920288,
0.3152234852,
0.0150679387,
-0.1946958899,
-0.3759284914,
0.4235627055,
0.2959070802,
-0.6330855489,
-0.0756559223,
0.2691690922,
-0.3929644525,
-0.4152109623,
0.0622057877,
-0.5665869117,
-0.4349632859,
-0.1460075974,
0.2995226383,
-0.2321214825,
-0.2769091129,
0.0222578328,
-0.05911671,
0.1356338263,
0.1286836863,
-0.7816666365,
0.4125101864,
0.9199914336,
0.9318534136,
-0.190366447,
-0.3588763773,
-0.7697662115,
-0.0884130374,
-0.5503822565,
0.6364601851,
-0.6307353377,
-0.536973238,
0.1526043713,
0.2307298332,
-0.0300186053,
-0.4318886399,
0.2862475514,
-0.6018323302,
0.4618147314,
-0.2997617722,
-0.739433527,
-0.0896031484,
0.4239116907,
-0.5353522897,
0.9880731702,
-0.0253942832,
-0.7462238669,
0.1039422378,
-0.6198266745,
-0.0287487246,
-0.4356172681,
-0.1931102425,
-0.0039077289,
0.5371091366,
0.1644866914,
0.4149742126,
-0.2377682626,
0.4897400737,
-0.2328631729,
-0.4493814111,
0.6714664102,
-0.4975293875,
0.8205972314,
0.0023726018,
-0.1694966108,
0.1986902207,
-0.5688505173,
-0.2198930383,
0.1746116877,
-0.3537195921,
-0.3817236125,
0.1354967952,
-0.1006010324,
0.2741047144,
0.0509033911,
-0.8814095259,
0.17527619,
-0.8683524728,
0.4954688251,
0.6629665494,
0.278737545,
0.4045674503,
-0.1407250017,
0.7119445205,
0.2901882827,
-0.0756969377,
-0.2838081717,
-0.5748025775,
-0.5990729928,
0.0383934639,
0.0648091659,
0.4250240922,
-0.7216693759,
0.2235220671,
-0.1163904816,
-0.3480713964,
-0.2753416896,
-0.324213773,
0.6185373068,
0.7886383533,
0.0589844286,
-0.1517607421,
-0.2595892251,
-0.8888528347,
-0.5293282866,
-0.353248328,
0.0280578863,
0.1075524315,
0.8362207413,
-0.1195003241,
1.1585762501,
-0.5844017267,
-0.1707815975,
0.0378291346,
-0.058733806,
0.4426075518,
0.4120817482,
0.3738674521,
-0.7410405874,
0.0361304022,
-0.1726064831,
-0.7798299789,
-0.0292548239,
0.0333128683,
0.0384190604,
-0.1501665264,
0.6907525063,
-0.3072075546,
0.6221641302,
0.7714366913,
-0.6538981795,
0.6443436742,
-0.2098078132,
-0.1374850422,
-1.0307810307,
0.0521601923,
-0.0537611619,
-0.4196305573,
-0.7167788744,
0.2056288123,
0.1097133309,
-0.1628138572,
-0.7021449804,
0.6998947263,
-0.4178793132,
-0.2863344848,
-0.3125929832,
0.041741997,
0.0685591102,
0.4005548358,
0.0950394273,
0.7483746409,
0.5383195281,
-0.4698691666,
0.4150385857,
0.243874073,
-0.1700247675,
0.5277047157,
-0.7389407158,
0.1265275329,
-0.0662154779,
0.5200155973,
-0.9096499681,
0.0071274494,
0.355874896,
-0.3962323666,
-0.1367570609,
-0.3827042878,
-0.5778626204,
-0.057895951,
-0.0641596019,
0.3756285608,
0.222425729,
-0.6020103097,
0.6154555678,
0.2288510799,
0.2568406463,
-0.6395531893,
-0.6921950579,
-0.1236405224,
-0.0030774111,
-0.2256037295,
0.2824641764,
0.1386818588,
-0.4835933745,
0.124735333,
-0.2952582538,
-0.1271569729,
0.134743169,
0.5276159644,
0.3331561089,
-0.2970770597,
-0.0118802721,
0.2441483587,
-0.2806840241,
0.4937668443,
-0.4525766671,
0.5833667517,
-0.3251703084,
-0.6076871157,
-0.3018991053,
0.4022117853,
0.6272233129,
-0.3612098992,
0.8726512194,
0.2431908548,
-0.8836092949,
-0.0755631924,
-0.1608627141,
-0.5051677823,
-0.48789832,
0.2930822968,
-0.5378088951,
-0.9227100015,
0.9670193195,
-0.0087645231,
-0.1225958318,
0.347751677,
0.6099404097,
0.0844609961,
1.0098050833,
0.5219266415,
0.0104857953,
0.3224252164,
-0.211644724,
0.4302734733,
-1.0186288357,
-0.1015321538,
-0.3090789616,
0.0856951922,
-0.6017934084,
-0.3846302927,
0.6370831728,
-0.0255555194,
0.0650646314,
0.0081125209,
-0.2561121583,
0.7720947266,
0.5021076798,
0.1166535541,
0.3917195797,
-0.341547668,
-0.4972040951,
-0.4133367836,
-0.4973023534,
-0.5900698304,
1.0871293545,
0.4289274216,
0.7570958734,
0.3706304133,
0.5561252832,
0.0287427716,
0.2511110604,
-0.8145247698,
0.4352220595,
0.0567279533,
-0.8469690681,
-0.0585851297,
-0.2049757689,
-0.987798214,
0.6129372716,
-0.0702596232,
-1.1276810169,
0.5158584714,
0.2874862552,
-0.2351536453,
0.3595955074,
-0.3251571357,
0.9505106211,
-0.1181062013,
-0.3594515026,
-0.1059255898,
-0.4485539198,
0.4227874875,
0.1178857833,
-0.0292202868,
0.022645155,
-0.0435118489,
0.6057987213,
-0.4938111007,
1.2040503025,
-0.0610493124,
-0.6924955845,
0.0791642293,
0.592859149,
0.4066300094,
0.3029657602,
-0.0056978501,
0.0748588294,
0.397927016,
-0.2851750851,
-0.5985796452,
0.6537120342,
-0.6134446263,
-0.4924598634,
-0.8189093471,
-0.5252555609,
-0.3162247837,
0.3818100691,
0.5333842039,
0.7506331205,
-0.4199162424,
-0.1474382877,
0.8086862564,
-0.287892431,
0.1832419634,
0.8945630193,
-0.5584444404,
0.3487906456,
0.8652459383,
-0.1841456294,
0.3102749288,
0.4921888113,
0.3972135186,
-0.3871421218,
-0.303178221,
-0.2918603122,
0.2534674406,
-0.766001761,
-0.077122584,
-0.5215598345,
-0.1302558482,
-0.2833153903,
0.0848770663,
-0.5073778629,
-0.0007908881,
-0.4409445524,
-0.1019014642,
0.0020746225,
0.7856627107,
-0.0378022864,
0.1580962092,
-0.629427433,
0.3043457568,
0.3101788759,
0.2165260166,
-0.1178361177,
-0.6496153474,
0.1378740221,
0.0802199468,
0.0048986548,
-1.4114675522,
0.3657865226,
0.1927298009,
0.3187873065,
0.4592070878,
0.088453941,
0.2743409872,
-0.456350863,
0.8242664337,
-0.1992720515,
-1.3131694794,
0.7366182208,
-0.672578454,
0.2142397761,
0.0958385691,
0.2328437567,
-1.06013906,
-0.5561261773,
-0.4573748112,
-0.4820557833,
0.7753334641,
-0.1424001157,
0.3020735383,
-0.0358632877,
0.5703631639,
0.1262080371,
0.2479109615,
-0.9278957844,
-0.1983636022,
-0.0239430033,
-0.0935617834,
-0.0372983143,
-0.2899810672,
-0.3769141734,
-0.1543841064,
0.3245394826,
-0.4726606607,
0.4341070652,
0.2667408884,
-0.3555156291,
-0.0919713601,
0.2556809187,
0.4916313887,
0.7371438146,
-0.1706502736,
0.4146399498,
-0.0690762699,
-0.3782114983,
0.3236395419,
0.0635996684,
-0.2745636404,
-0.1281402707,
0.6544613242,
0.6053605676,
0.39959988,
-0.7944025993,
0.9174867868,
-0.1753117293,
0.1582370996,
-0.3110222518,
0.1284772903,
0.0132904714,
0.3220256865,
0.0489419326,
-0.085145928,
0.1596254706,
-0.8006482124,
-0.0105915405,
0.388682276,
-0.5764479637,
-0.6907664537,
0.5425166488,
-0.1599027365,
-0.2187353522,
0.6389870048,
-0.3552334011,
-0.9618262053,
0.4131524861,
0.9629972577,
0.4908516109,
-0.2298806459,
0.2885226309,
0.0971385166,
0.4378141463,
0.0286344066,
0.5250835419,
0.2354324013,
-1.0863910913,
-0.3573432565,
-0.4026082754,
-0.6233657002,
0.2062629163,
-1.0264316797,
-0.2562589347,
-0.354536891,
0.0972156152,
-0.2169560939,
-0.2861821055,
-0.6667299867,
0.2132804543,
0.0870117545,
0.560054481,
-1.1545122862,
0.7441619635,
0.8724359274,
-0.1607490182,
-0.551492095,
0.1376325935,
0.4456520677,
-0.8162637353,
0.5452347994,
0.0366034061,
-0.2638397217,
-0.1446614861,
-0.4097914398,
-1.0422810316,
0.4564718604,
0.4963654578,
-0.4331662953,
0.0287914835,
0.1571008116,
0.8321136236,
-0.2415875942,
0.1117346287,
0.6293573976,
0.1400476545,
-0.6388373375,
-0.9025371075,
0.2804897726,
-0.3092739284,
-0.1128596589,
0.1547112465,
-0.4043354094,
1.0097543001,
-0.2045937032,
-0.1263639778,
-0.082911469,
0.7295657992,
0.1509964317,
0.245306477,
0.5155025721,
0.3005966544,
0.7082914114,
-0.2858012915,
1.0322176218,
-0.2706029713,
0.452122122,
0.9917085171,
-0.1742660254,
0.843541801,
0.5078034997,
-0.182060346,
0.5501695871,
0.572089076,
0.1639529318,
0.4176478684,
0.295145601,
-0.0854346827,
-0.1454440951,
-0.4405136406,
-0.2468606979,
0.766004622,
0.7610378861,
-0.2033832967,
-0.1250348389,
0.2368023396,
0.1304856539,
0.070852682,
0.0708506107,
0.5381608605,
0.2118356377,
-0.7152026892,
0.2542837858,
0.113441743,
0.474413991,
-0.4465047717,
0.0261484273,
-0.1797583103,
0.2538922727,
-0.0934761986,
-0.6776171923,
0.0658398792,
0.0309022591,
-0.1452399045,
-0.1521530002,
0.5891507864,
-0.3065961599,
-0.3605644405,
0.2823898792,
0.7619429827,
0.1104228646,
-0.2508888245,
-0.5413251519,
0.0425146818,
-0.0676819235,
-0.2717069089,
0.2266371399,
0.1728037149,
-0.1846291423,
0.6226457953,
0.7304369807,
0.292439878,
-0.0377087183,
-0.0535327308,
0.8019040823,
-0.7504288554,
-0.7691854835,
-0.7469071746,
0.2839484215,
0.3346477747,
-0.6569154859,
0.6771290302,
0.4734131396,
0.7736307383,
0.2459862828,
0.4491910636,
0.3668338954,
0.461743325,
-0.6537584662,
0.5074094534,
-0.5160768628,
0.2518260181,
-0.256857872,
-0.9879620075,
-0.0981582999,
0.6706475616,
-0.5160679817,
-0.2175942361,
0.8014099002,
0.6690927744,
-0.2087969482,
0.1758530289,
0.1594672054,
0.4162865281,
0.6556429267,
0.3995961845,
1.1654177904,
-0.2714067996,
0.040049646,
-0.3498106301,
-0.1590728909,
-0.1626640558,
-0.8574281931,
-0.9255625606,
-0.6635448337,
-0.0981833637,
-0.5656115413,
-0.1279774457,
0.7127744555,
0.5201787949,
-0.8506779671,
-0.0636979565,
0.0590806417,
0.0965119004,
-0.1989814788,
-0.2512933612,
0.4980158806,
0.0750418305,
-0.7823430896,
0.6837303638,
0.2769115865,
0.1144419909,
-0.7119528651,
0.2139363587,
0.0895704851,
-0.0029202159,
0.3773465753,
0.1909621507,
-1.0073817968,
-0.2863598168,
0.0977965221,
-0.1104564518,
-0.1125503629,
1.0300709009,
-0.8340945244,
0.6003305912,
0.3498871028,
0.340208441,
0.2754367292,
-0.3010872304,
0.8157573342,
-0.8537466526,
0.441144526,
0.5886849165,
0.6273117661,
0.2218927443,
-0.4036214054,
0.2803905606,
0.2391295284,
-0.3750099838,
-1.2032052279,
0.5365183949,
-0.6292847991,
-0.3157931268,
0.9266192317,
-0.2632618845,
-0.3877877295,
-0.0715348199,
-0.0250113085,
0.1431269646,
-0.2337950021,
0.4881137311,
0.77240628,
-0.1942718774,
0.1475437433,
-0.6450120211,
0.3665254414,
0.7758809328,
-0.6114141941,
-0.0963502303,
0.5825796127,
0.257247895,
0.1353351027,
0.4714322686,
-0.020795811,
0.2624478936,
0.0335081667,
-0.3890976906,
0.1575642228,
-0.1635294259,
-0.6118822694,
-0.0471188389,
-0.0843011588,
-0.0729179829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19500v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19500v1 | Knowledge acquisition for dialogue agents using reinforcement learning on graph representations | 2024-06-27T19:28:42 | 2024-06-27T19:28:42 | Selene Baez Santamaria, Shihan Wang, Piek Vossen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We develop an artificial agent motivated to augment its knowledge base beyond
its initial training. The agent actively participates in dialogues with other
agents, strategically acquiring new information. The agent models its knowledge
as an RDF knowledge graph, integrating new beliefs acquired through
conversation. Responses in dialogue are generated by identifying graph patterns
around these new integrated beliefs. We show that policies can be learned using
reinforcement learning to select effective graph patterns during an
interaction, without relying on explicit user feedback. Within this context,
our study is a proof of concept for leveraging users as effective sources of
information. | [
-0.4858523905,
-0.9094485044,
0.8129300475,
-0.1098890081,
0.0601257645,
0.4972669482,
0.0197745152,
-0.5356190205,
0.0857356265,
0.6985345483,
-0.4815935791,
-0.5029613376,
-0.5793366432,
0.0661478266,
0.0417162888,
0.953074038,
0.046649579,
-0.1524907202,
-0.1779041141,
0.0666690171,
-0.4057072997,
-0.1550396532,
-1.0875040293,
-0.7605127096,
0.6946867704,
0.406599164,
0.8185085058,
0.2568467855,
-0.0469400398,
0.5022004247,
0.1518521607,
0.7186137438,
-0.5609939098,
0.3151694536,
-0.3026822209,
-0.4471199512,
0.0968575999,
0.10118258,
0.6761123538,
0.5852870345,
-0.0925160497,
-0.442047894,
-0.1335041672,
0.3627043664,
-0.3392935395,
0.8033041358,
-0.3864817619,
0.1717146188,
0.3688408434,
-0.4747390449,
-0.7318482995,
-0.6577795148,
0.3693955243,
-1.1112031937,
-0.2904499173,
0.2002076209,
0.8822715878,
-0.002467637,
-0.873536706,
-0.5420182943,
-0.8160378337,
0.521071732,
-0.1772737652,
0.2921499908,
0.5887777805,
0.565535605,
-0.664498508,
-0.9428473115,
-0.685203135,
-0.2777705193,
-0.3109096289,
0.0797255784,
-0.247588098,
0.4207870066,
0.4043747187,
-0.0390517041,
-0.2556243539,
-0.1672104299,
-0.2084140182,
-0.3394592702,
0.5543852448,
0.1819726229,
0.2910179198,
-0.2839534581,
-0.4251086116,
-0.3167647719,
-0.4213386178,
0.2979773283,
0.3508891165,
0.2551294267,
0.2461507171,
0.3072146177,
-0.2744952142,
0.808680594,
0.1300868839,
-0.2748321891,
0.1678626686,
-0.3070355058,
-0.0552178696,
0.0826525837,
0.5521273613,
0.0663294941,
0.3837603927,
-0.2998928726,
-0.2617871761,
-0.2692507505,
0.3288876414,
-0.6250755787,
-0.183053121,
-0.053736683,
-0.2705480754,
-0.3518260419,
0.1261401623,
-0.4920651019,
-0.5391151309,
-0.1929168552,
0.2458940297,
-0.6232239008,
-0.3598744869,
-0.0222243927,
-0.7230711579,
0.153967455,
0.7025105357,
-0.7074648142,
0.5229369998,
0.4634870887,
0.5880593061,
0.1442941427,
-0.3321525156,
-0.4720340073,
0.4252255559,
-0.4017885625,
0.9005495906,
-0.6602039337,
-0.6790397763,
0.2183104455,
0.1667823493,
-0.3059883714,
-0.3386539519,
-0.0437731855,
-0.9673882723,
0.2185284346,
-0.253431499,
-0.6759720445,
-0.5569771528,
0.3242837191,
-0.6179347038,
0.6221734285,
0.6606280804,
-0.4745109975,
0.5158779025,
-0.9116646051,
-0.4889273942,
0.2734424472,
-0.3032196462,
-0.0342918076,
-0.4285492301,
-0.0329772234,
0.1006587744,
0.1904536486,
-0.1299358755,
-0.3027374446,
0.0041899579,
0.5747178793,
-0.1082346439,
0.745225966,
0.418389082,
-0.0245779473,
0.1342048347,
-0.3921468854,
0.1368448436,
0.1719645411,
-0.4017673433,
-0.2853244245,
0.1374201775,
-0.5908937454,
0.0801722035,
-0.036920689,
-0.4374401867,
0.4012629688,
-0.3805030286,
0.4394251406,
0.78351897,
0.6858384013,
0.4094073772,
-0.5384346247,
0.5862826705,
0.1047562063,
-0.0176208522,
-0.0336916074,
-0.4919377267,
-0.6909413934,
-0.0835422724,
0.0748189241,
0.3892177343,
-1.2401160002,
0.1375529617,
-0.0056108846,
-0.0737881064,
0.072865203,
0.3412083685,
0.334230125,
0.4833846986,
0.0476170331,
-0.3848591149,
-0.4729061723,
-0.2385596931,
0.0851168558,
-0.4431909323,
0.3299075067,
0.6729283929,
0.4080325663,
-0.3459442258,
1.1228944063,
-0.6291591525,
-0.1086514071,
-0.6801352501,
0.5227847099,
-0.2499700934,
0.278470844,
0.5131033659,
-0.7388013601,
-0.4421775043,
0.3146704733,
-0.8726180792,
0.4502900839,
-0.1608420312,
-0.290938735,
0.1148176268,
0.3852718174,
-0.680408895,
0.3781858087,
0.186899215,
-0.5138059855,
0.2429956794,
-0.1448569894,
0.1380190998,
-0.8861861229,
-0.4446931779,
-0.0477313176,
-0.88078475,
-0.505129993,
-0.4191750586,
-0.5000969768,
-0.071704261,
-0.146090433,
0.5465649962,
-0.362152189,
-0.1699463874,
-0.2756380141,
0.4545667171,
0.1380573511,
0.6905912757,
0.3363592625,
0.6647183895,
0.0609128661,
-0.8282479048,
0.4688074291,
0.6486663818,
-0.3720413446,
0.4315848053,
-0.4614669979,
0.2616547346,
-0.2502400279,
0.3976507187,
-0.9527961612,
-0.2284494191,
0.4971697628,
-0.5030688047,
0.2813276947,
-0.2069655806,
-0.1824955642,
-0.2405124456,
0.1852866262,
-0.1296443492,
0.5086436272,
-0.4354593754,
0.57520926,
0.6940578222,
-0.1258802861,
-0.5068011284,
0.1073905602,
-0.219010964,
0.0606777631,
-0.5491157174,
-0.0998731479,
0.2667676806,
-0.3554129899,
0.3390059471,
0.1455021054,
-0.2520928979,
0.1986810863,
0.2146077454,
0.027287079,
-0.1027503163,
0.3564379811,
0.0480636545,
-0.1403991133,
0.1091241688,
-0.7366607189,
0.5445263982,
0.0349992998,
-0.1731175333,
-0.4557008445,
0.1177812442,
0.2497562915,
0.0118490467,
0.5784676671,
0.3910000026,
-0.1246232018,
-0.4817576408,
-0.1324647665,
-0.3040902913,
-0.5406210423,
0.3788491189,
-0.3533736765,
-0.7683132291,
0.3231595457,
-0.7924535871,
-0.0403566323,
0.1744936854,
0.1052311584,
-0.384555608,
1.3661979437,
0.6891663074,
0.208750844,
0.9359773993,
-0.5793019533,
0.0284773502,
-0.4790311754,
-0.4739848375,
-0.3777818382,
-0.0228879284,
-0.4167659283,
-0.3983598351,
0.1842846274,
0.1297613829,
-0.5036711097,
0.3220134974,
-0.206783697,
0.3601446152,
0.6490400434,
0.3364594281,
0.3925158978,
-0.0571478307,
-0.2050642818,
0.2768338025,
-0.7316793799,
-0.3537846208,
0.9064181447,
0.1228458285,
0.6916667223,
0.1456767768,
0.6178851724,
0.8536682129,
0.1131009683,
-0.7733391523,
0.389994055,
0.589528501,
-0.1579546183,
-0.7151805162,
-0.586825788,
-1.1541337967,
0.116852507,
-0.171081394,
-0.9279882908,
0.31564188,
0.1662557721,
-0.0816486478,
0.0551875383,
-0.6494233012,
0.8768880963,
-0.2386951149,
-0.0252904333,
-0.5489563346,
-0.5524020195,
0.0164756123,
0.3089440465,
-0.0564750247,
-0.0344245173,
0.2442864776,
0.6674394608,
-0.5600016117,
0.8956907988,
-0.6456820965,
0.1683128774,
0.6447017193,
0.0923323408,
0.9453964233,
0.095019199,
0.2237432003,
-0.1861905903,
-0.0920832902,
-0.349904269,
-1.1774733067,
-0.0017761997,
-1.2005486488,
-0.5455974936,
-0.4059602618,
-0.5676326156,
-0.4586743116,
0.3639840782,
-0.2446587235,
0.1707098782,
-0.5068766475,
-0.0473221429,
0.6938238144,
-0.0446994267,
0.0630736426,
0.6871984005,
-0.4010722935,
-0.4261398315,
1.0106058121,
-0.0154301915,
0.5525043011,
0.3905111849,
0.0485160649,
-0.3988888264,
-0.4385004938,
-0.2148578912,
0.129512921,
-0.8345894814,
-0.0479017235,
-0.5649597049,
-0.4060615003,
-0.3643956482,
0.0396799184,
0.1444070637,
-0.5378643274,
0.0001137914,
-0.5077113509,
0.5765765905,
1.2003706694,
-0.0488152392,
0.5586121678,
-0.4985700846,
0.0201184992,
0.6955829859,
-0.0832685307,
-0.1030607894,
-0.1398188323,
-0.3411364853,
0.223705411,
-0.61439538,
-0.9977104664,
0.2688796818,
0.179204002,
0.8799645305,
0.7436615229,
0.1396676302,
0.4708432853,
-0.0698609203,
0.4895930886,
0.2380110025,
-0.6794258952,
0.68445158,
-0.2438877374,
-0.1416010261,
0.3782043755,
0.5292286277,
-0.791875422,
-0.4229081571,
-0.7431647778,
-0.2542785704,
0.8480366468,
-0.1473905593,
0.0706494823,
-0.1549637914,
0.2121233791,
-0.049545791,
0.492554903,
-0.3338827491,
0.018360367,
-0.5303190947,
0.0583111234,
-0.1000039577,
-0.1494091898,
-0.493650347,
-0.2460014671,
0.6330373883,
-0.5090765953,
0.4856759906,
0.0580246784,
-0.403406769,
-0.0692997202,
0.0540402047,
0.373695761,
0.5756648779,
-0.0970489979,
-0.0330193676,
0.0882142633,
-0.2014286369,
0.1056578457,
0.0005484191,
-0.1364471465,
-0.0805230811,
0.1378260404,
1.117749095,
0.3434512019,
-0.5644152761,
0.5352635384,
-0.1220844164,
-0.3171303272,
-0.4395785332,
0.4797009528,
-0.0827979147,
0.5279006362,
0.0145192845,
-0.0669184849,
0.0106658032,
-0.7394431829,
0.5582235456,
0.4952183962,
-0.6381061077,
-0.0830671266,
0.1255722344,
0.3988172114,
-0.4900253117,
0.9987211227,
-0.4134044349,
-0.574374795,
0.5265923738,
0.7629486918,
0.5690139532,
0.1032419056,
0.920761466,
0.2336600572,
-0.0759415478,
0.2137349993,
0.2512764633,
-0.658036828,
-1.1935163736,
-0.1274615973,
-0.2804474831,
-0.8708171248,
-0.3521351218,
-0.4902906716,
0.0796171352,
-0.6893324852,
-0.2945238948,
-0.0629079342,
0.2954063714,
-0.6234287024,
-0.1313244402,
-0.1592505425,
0.7452698946,
-0.6496599317,
0.8735638857,
0.3454038203,
-0.8914761543,
-1.0438994169,
-0.2976052463,
-0.1860426813,
-1.2387555838,
0.8294128776,
-0.1795331091,
-0.1949922442,
0.051410459,
-0.6558258533,
-0.799063921,
1.0954020023,
0.3179254234,
0.0555402152,
-0.265499413,
0.103054285,
0.3069088161,
-0.4695294797,
0.5610455871,
0.4268134534,
0.5471484661,
0.4306513965,
-0.4047170281,
-0.1135259047,
-0.177635625,
-0.0402067043,
0.1168463975,
-0.6793740392,
0.7061306834,
-0.3254750669,
-0.2764714956,
-0.1808432639,
0.7638320327,
-0.1084406525,
0.2619554698,
0.6164059043,
0.1360286772,
1.3595180511,
-0.0402491651,
1.0789917707,
-0.3618177772,
0.2780098617,
1.0219777822,
-0.1420263797,
0.3234612048,
0.1345957369,
-0.071789071,
1.2282785177,
0.6930577755,
0.3238837719,
0.6091149449,
-0.0113440808,
-0.5236486197,
-0.5372904539,
-0.4303776026,
-0.1452728659,
0.328437984,
0.7238640189,
-0.4060912132,
-0.1940900832,
0.1159972697,
0.0100925788,
-0.0014551376,
-0.1536423713,
1.4047249556,
0.0975956395,
-0.9214298725,
0.2713443935,
-0.2870275974,
-0.2289555818,
-0.8035342693,
-0.5940258503,
0.1194082722,
0.0940952897,
-0.2686132491,
-0.7513075471,
-0.0714703351,
-0.5222278237,
-0.0575006828,
-0.4087369144,
0.7661513686,
-0.3673645854,
0.002575482,
0.2858707309,
0.4579552114,
0.1674431562,
0.3224743903,
-0.6093247533,
-0.387267977,
0.0461155958,
-0.140458867,
0.2540254891,
0.5842533708,
-0.184487924,
0.8101202846,
0.669605732,
0.1544610262,
0.0082122469,
0.0160576832,
0.9338723421,
-0.5146147013,
-0.5809226632,
-0.250724256,
0.2909900248,
-0.5884376764,
0.0545144156,
0.7922709584,
0.1733435094,
0.9757035375,
0.3455073535,
1.1656275988,
-0.0593296923,
0.3472897112,
-0.4855028987,
0.3981609643,
-0.1136649251,
-0.1505052447,
-0.1417517513,
-0.351681143,
0.3156065345,
0.9386780262,
-0.4424342215,
0.0653027371,
0.7638797164,
0.6605404019,
0.3538737893,
0.3356174827,
0.3017440438,
0.098149173,
0.3805244565,
0.5415889025,
1.3246514797,
-0.0023124092,
0.6803410053,
-0.1029095799,
-0.1775997132,
-0.1827640384,
-0.2386464924,
-0.9120110869,
-0.5211343765,
-0.0671271086,
-0.7794101238,
0.4360068738,
1.0028945208,
0.7923555374,
-0.6149986386,
-0.2850507498,
-0.2221680582,
0.9306889176,
-0.4576563835,
-0.2161693126,
0.0010174363,
-0.8566452265,
-0.6417701244,
0.3858047128,
0.0939583406,
0.1099369153,
-0.2465749085,
-0.7238417268,
-0.1226846427,
0.1999548823,
0.4227844775,
0.8834757805,
-0.2868700325,
-0.5974187255,
-0.2841509283,
-0.1148639098,
0.2996254265,
1.1181704998,
-0.8724377155,
0.7623817325,
0.4609151483,
0.6662556529,
0.8439259529,
0.1485483646,
0.8706636429,
-0.4973334074,
0.2069285214,
0.1908878535,
0.177205056,
0.0434930995,
-0.4946627319,
0.2252560556,
0.3945885003,
-0.4341150224,
-0.4678937793,
0.5160680413,
-0.7193472385,
-0.1847959459,
0.9298495054,
-0.3912811875,
-0.2376023978,
-0.6304917336,
-0.328828156,
0.3511947691,
-0.8045653105,
0.5415423512,
0.4722980261,
-0.4762628973,
-0.0561692007,
-0.2157424837,
0.7868497372,
-0.1435908973,
-0.8173744082,
-0.2885687649,
0.5789613128,
0.2275591344,
0.1619680673,
1.0208096504,
0.1688916832,
0.3677405417,
0.3388152421,
-0.2309378982,
-0.2621638477,
-0.6085762978,
0.1600572765,
0.2065278739,
0.511834085,
-0.1603611857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19497v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19497v1 | Inclusivity in Large Language Models: Personality Traits and Gender Bias in Scientific Abstracts | 2024-06-27T19:26:11 | 2024-06-27T19:26:11 | Naseela Pervez, Alexander J. Titus | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly utilized to assist in
scientific and academic writing, helping authors enhance the coherence of their
articles. Previous studies have highlighted stereotypes and biases present in
LLM outputs, emphasizing the need to evaluate these models for their alignment
with human narrative styles and potential gender biases. In this study, we
assess the alignment of three prominent LLMs - Claude 3 Opus, Mistral AI Large,
and Gemini 1.5 Flash - by analyzing their performance on benchmark
text-generation tasks for scientific abstracts. We employ the Linguistic
Inquiry and Word Count (LIWC) framework to extract lexical, psychological, and
social features from the generated texts. Our findings indicate that, while
these models generally produce text closely resembling human authored content,
variations in stylistic features suggest significant gender biases. This
research highlights the importance of developing LLMs that maintain a diversity
of writing styles to promote inclusivity in academic discourse. | [
-0.3414131701,
-0.3208912611,
0.7288342714,
0.4179031551,
0.1737459451,
0.1535258591,
-0.2858733535,
-0.6582283974,
0.3268783391,
0.3702171445,
-0.4375327229,
-0.5320704579,
-0.7757984996,
0.715446353,
-0.6737023592,
1.0661759377,
-0.0737841129,
0.3832054436,
-0.4298838079,
-0.1614373773,
-0.2731779218,
-0.4601497054,
-0.2289344668,
-0.4367444217,
0.7547573447,
0.2551033795,
0.6113425493,
0.6387904286,
0.530874908,
0.2162163556,
-0.0270389225,
0.1191090569,
-0.4139460921,
0.394220829,
-0.1561275274,
-0.3327773809,
-0.6045975089,
-0.1020986214,
0.7396579385,
0.796995461,
0.2799976468,
0.2140590698,
0.2715170681,
0.5792101622,
-0.3589975834,
0.0262499861,
-0.3981767595,
-0.0569973327,
-0.4112057984,
-0.08355809,
-0.3046159148,
-0.4408311844,
0.5345905423,
-0.4320407808,
0.3105883002,
0.1764814556,
0.488940835,
-0.093310535,
-0.5048936009,
-0.4860830307,
-0.4786658585,
0.8615886569,
-0.8041142225,
0.0415936634,
-0.0577528477,
-0.3054960668,
-0.112793006,
-0.3804991245,
-0.6695181727,
-0.1662187427,
-0.0341373794,
-0.068889685,
-0.1294444203,
-0.251991421,
0.2761543095,
0.1127519757,
-0.5671467185,
0.5063338876,
-0.4177823663,
0.0330165252,
0.8057113886,
0.2720333934,
0.276578337,
-0.0938759744,
0.1082832292,
-0.0934728011,
-0.8973937035,
-0.1738719493,
0.8091352582,
0.3522681594,
-0.2631256282,
0.764611721,
0.0048301588,
0.3459959924,
-0.0225208271,
-0.1876803935,
0.2832624316,
-0.3030491769,
0.319006294,
0.4890097678,
0.9578664899,
0.3641807139,
0.3912907243,
0.103472665,
0.0842673555,
-0.1153332964,
0.3226268589,
-0.787792325,
0.1038904786,
0.231595099,
-0.6088606715,
-0.4612321258,
0.1591687351,
-0.7303370237,
-0.645418942,
-0.1339324564,
0.0989860892,
-0.2674717903,
-0.2565101981,
-0.3171274364,
-0.1762591898,
0.2517506778,
0.3316721916,
-1.0816406012,
0.3490075767,
0.7080186009,
0.8307746649,
-0.5968924761,
-0.2188358903,
-0.3701934516,
0.1687541306,
-0.3609010279,
0.4361530244,
-0.5362200737,
-0.5096148849,
0.0989860147,
-0.2149358541,
0.199810639,
-0.2907306552,
0.4981365204,
0.0390564725,
0.2920390964,
-0.5420351028,
-0.5172400475,
0.0207177959,
-0.0538768508,
-0.3869189322,
0.8841096163,
-0.0700054616,
-0.8803955913,
0.3810936809,
-0.593895793,
-0.2964459062,
-0.0108877383,
-0.6466572881,
-0.3564220965,
0.2205361575,
0.014253309,
0.5719326138,
-0.2825458646,
0.4519823492,
-0.3543642461,
-0.1159859747,
0.6892931461,
-0.0463939942,
0.3069185019,
0.043650806,
-0.507601738,
0.3628642261,
-0.6405723095,
-0.3369030058,
-0.0734615698,
-0.1802252084,
-0.4042337835,
0.2461554855,
0.0927085131,
0.1367847323,
0.2340740561,
-0.7460573316,
0.170266971,
-0.2815990746,
0.4289887547,
0.7209098935,
-0.2636635005,
0.4904040694,
-0.3949629664,
0.3715597689,
-0.058868628,
-0.2209356576,
-0.1696125716,
-0.5450206399,
-0.5734184384,
-0.440451026,
0.1405113041,
0.1127818674,
-0.2062478513,
0.3819338381,
-0.2748784125,
-0.5972849131,
-0.4790836871,
0.2077012211,
0.4299558103,
0.4587439299,
0.1337678581,
-0.2048354596,
-0.4641474187,
-1.2651673555,
-0.4068042636,
0.0338856094,
-0.1603392065,
0.3036066592,
0.889244318,
-0.1796691418,
0.8524243832,
-0.2747066021,
0.0573686734,
-0.3001184464,
0.3265471756,
0.1475629508,
0.4417182207,
0.5967926383,
-0.4397042692,
-0.3655029237,
-0.1175638661,
-0.8599874973,
-0.5162938237,
0.2916411459,
0.1071528569,
0.358738333,
0.4505642653,
-0.4711328745,
0.2769743204,
0.5676170588,
-0.3842079043,
0.7594716549,
0.054842934,
-0.0002346626,
-0.6668440104,
0.1215309203,
0.350388974,
-0.1349975169,
-0.6317709684,
-0.1697154045,
-0.0127573451,
0.1073025838,
-0.1877903193,
0.7568654418,
-0.6712219715,
-0.1262137145,
-0.3161517978,
0.1797956228,
0.0056613493,
-0.1392522305,
0.36028108,
0.5563539863,
0.3488514721,
-0.6200908422,
-0.2616856992,
0.2702687681,
-0.3028337657,
0.4617519677,
-0.8198888898,
-0.0292333663,
-0.3050928116,
0.3302204311,
-1.0360543728,
-0.4023021162,
-0.1303539723,
-0.3013075292,
0.389616251,
0.4616639614,
-0.5142608285,
-0.2920825481,
-0.5711271167,
0.5535769463,
0.2994952798,
-0.2038886696,
0.4581860602,
0.2770707011,
-0.6836137176,
-0.5433797836,
-0.526761055,
-0.0035786328,
-0.1961385757,
-0.6275973916,
0.4133962095,
-0.1357727051,
-0.7067493796,
-0.3089581132,
0.0073012095,
0.4118095934,
-0.0933710486,
0.2654184401,
0.5058630705,
-0.1440990567,
-0.0284232199,
0.2150918692,
0.3194533288,
0.0653570592,
-0.0163946562,
0.6317618489,
-0.1202187091,
-0.068950288,
-0.1789055467,
0.6061629057,
0.6403278112,
0.0637205765,
0.8091862798,
0.4108434916,
0.0093134232,
0.0365803912,
-0.5766855478,
-0.394218266,
-0.3460361958,
0.3441780508,
0.0110025601,
-1.2379934788,
0.5570952296,
0.3733478189,
0.1993740648,
0.5548187494,
0.7333521247,
-0.1435316652,
1.06691432,
0.6810235381,
0.1754534096,
0.1938127875,
0.1414570659,
0.0632644445,
-1.0689375401,
-0.1640707552,
-0.8418453932,
-0.410032481,
-0.7138014436,
-0.121441789,
0.4612711966,
-0.4533305466,
-0.5070313811,
-0.0560665578,
-0.7242577076,
0.0602123328,
0.374330014,
-0.3087915778,
0.3499772847,
-0.0005049544,
0.0067976178,
-0.4617664814,
-0.4795944989,
-0.8077036738,
1.323485136,
0.6988292336,
0.7102736235,
0.2856597304,
0.4133418798,
0.1625890434,
0.6230792999,
-0.4415028393,
0.4620037079,
-0.0902602151,
-0.6947450042,
-0.1967483312,
-0.3842644691,
-0.75475353,
0.2516188622,
-0.4654444456,
-1.0095359087,
0.4045465887,
-0.1289213151,
-0.096768938,
-0.0211796109,
-0.1895158887,
0.5142396688,
-0.3220701218,
-0.4562545121,
0.0393046029,
-0.6772829294,
0.7316178679,
-0.330744952,
0.360860765,
-0.1983135492,
-0.3419317603,
0.7850780487,
-0.2775828838,
0.9242269397,
0.2939632237,
-0.4233672619,
-0.1587460041,
0.2399996519,
0.3721510172,
0.0663209632,
-0.0981653556,
0.476226598,
-0.0552437715,
-0.1193280071,
0.0016659424,
0.8541592956,
-1.0022161007,
-0.4925574064,
-0.6980348825,
-0.7840899229,
-0.0628527999,
0.0913060978,
0.4336813986,
0.4624967277,
-0.270509541,
0.2227888107,
0.7598210573,
-0.6187679172,
0.5141947865,
0.5673108697,
-0.4903330505,
-0.2920454443,
0.5164144635,
0.0771123245,
0.4661879838,
0.2485259622,
0.0849211589,
-0.1601412445,
-0.5802881122,
-0.1787183434,
0.5610026717,
-0.3700054884,
0.0880317539,
-1.006370306,
-0.1887979507,
-0.648154974,
-0.2742507458,
-0.321954906,
-0.4304831922,
-0.3892590702,
0.1452513635,
0.2839584947,
0.8535857797,
0.2674699724,
0.3095192909,
-0.5151723027,
0.105237335,
-0.0921319574,
-0.100311853,
0.0236155745,
-0.555508554,
0.0927039981,
-0.380233705,
-0.50389117,
-0.9147481918,
0.5467644334,
0.1207661629,
0.3192120194,
0.3663043976,
-0.280341059,
0.0382614769,
-0.4677784145,
0.9534882903,
0.4629888833,
-0.8294594884,
0.2590918839,
-0.7810677886,
0.4613962173,
0.3915355802,
0.4839289486,
-0.3957413435,
-0.8654008508,
-0.4949846566,
-0.9495022297,
0.4738772511,
0.3797916174,
0.1220158711,
-0.1453861296,
0.2812558115,
0.5998934507,
0.6045358777,
-0.9017661214,
-0.4249734282,
-0.1095979139,
-0.4321299493,
-0.034485206,
-0.4023346901,
-0.2956424654,
-0.1927480996,
0.6462997794,
-0.2884758711,
0.1026166305,
0.3357080519,
0.1693645865,
0.0816388354,
0.4340539575,
1.0145071745,
0.8506338596,
-0.1158311889,
0.1323637366,
-0.0599244162,
-0.6018027663,
0.0737070218,
-0.005142299,
-0.4214089811,
0.0496346653,
0.4983573258,
0.3965578377,
0.2243245393,
-0.6293802261,
0.3588865399,
-0.1940452456,
-0.3560541272,
-0.3086542189,
0.1946997941,
0.178723529,
0.1403952688,
0.5374106169,
-0.0372284502,
0.1463329494,
-0.7120947838,
-0.4226519167,
0.623314023,
-0.1930677444,
-0.2278362364,
0.7698308229,
0.2579469681,
-0.0129547855,
0.2887008488,
0.0637653098,
-0.279314965,
0.4898396432,
0.5366832614,
0.8942639828,
0.0317190029,
0.1207752377,
0.4093305171,
0.3729618192,
-0.1462923437,
0.1817127913,
0.2736207545,
-0.647767961,
-0.4328892231,
-0.7763624787,
-0.412783742,
0.1089585349,
-0.4395849109,
0.3278590441,
-0.3144705594,
-0.1324448586,
0.2893361747,
-0.2577725053,
-0.4806036353,
-0.2592973113,
0.3965591192,
0.7074923515,
-0.6597871184,
0.445738703,
0.5939403772,
-0.1389008611,
-0.6845354438,
-0.176411137,
0.3635353148,
-0.2973350585,
0.8673955202,
0.2297574431,
0.0770518631,
-0.2525053024,
-0.723657608,
-0.9328311086,
0.854382515,
0.3279642165,
-0.8602074981,
0.1022257954,
0.1308481693,
0.6177943349,
-0.8419826627,
0.4731982052,
0.516771853,
0.6492922306,
-0.1436950713,
-1.1049420834,
0.0639665276,
-0.2843162119,
0.0572338924,
-0.0207978431,
-0.6310712099,
1.0147815943,
-0.0677045435,
0.2332212776,
0.2572681606,
0.8905032277,
0.6273395419,
0.2150035501,
0.035406284,
0.1628708839,
0.8380775452,
-0.1175961122,
1.0265607834,
-0.1700403839,
-0.176803574,
0.9770136476,
-0.5868079066,
0.4586204588,
0.4954446256,
-0.0472480096,
0.7092265487,
0.3063727021,
-0.0247217491,
0.1278268248,
0.2927561998,
-0.2998465002,
0.1236988828,
-0.1531445384,
-0.5460631251,
0.4738633633,
0.3553754389,
-0.7281787992,
0.0846481398,
-0.1234649643,
0.3691616058,
0.1337664574,
-0.4211004972,
0.5869320035,
0.2826839387,
-0.8903982043,
0.0607743934,
0.065488942,
0.9445286393,
-0.6361770034,
0.1858647615,
-0.1064492837,
0.03420645,
-0.5288832188,
-0.9385470152,
0.0308494661,
0.3093701005,
-0.5213865042,
-0.1812673062,
0.6810943484,
-0.4268309474,
-0.5508521795,
-0.1146236807,
0.3769496679,
0.3428934515,
0.1365947425,
-0.2219775617,
0.2778713703,
-0.1211725101,
-0.1138423234,
0.6345252991,
0.2154191285,
-0.2312547415,
0.585029006,
0.4659207761,
0.2755912244,
0.0471784882,
0.1113355607,
0.4749068618,
-0.5580673814,
-0.1894911826,
-1.1158852577,
0.3731707931,
-0.2515505254,
-0.4777248204,
1.1043204069,
0.7047017217,
0.2135198116,
-0.1421710998,
0.905957222,
-0.0219486021,
0.4154968858,
-0.1484412402,
0.7421201468,
-0.3033072948,
0.2507775426,
-0.6889753342,
-1.1465119123,
-0.1462832093,
0.3879229426,
-0.3069720566,
0.1603406519,
0.6594054699,
0.4080326855,
0.2792488039,
0.2090036869,
-0.0818948969,
0.3816099167,
0.3894370496,
0.1565289944,
0.8292681575,
-0.0076440303,
0.1131200343,
0.1603451073,
-0.3526672423,
-0.1557869166,
-1.2278072834,
-0.9534633756,
-0.263235122,
-0.4718625844,
-0.3760240376,
-0.3262362182,
0.8136783242,
0.3038335741,
-0.5788641572,
-0.3490810692,
0.064055033,
0.0905275196,
0.0794975832,
-0.2941041589,
0.1695583016,
-0.0803882405,
-0.6543576717,
0.0218884405,
0.5922754407,
-0.1188846081,
-0.6349984407,
-0.0331475474,
0.0124656893,
0.279740274,
0.5955536366,
0.1846212149,
-0.6666067839,
-0.3641718328,
0.1083867624,
-0.3514781594,
-0.0391808189,
0.7105199099,
-0.4676249921,
0.231349811,
0.4512077868,
0.1313435137,
0.414754957,
-0.1784888357,
0.8938707113,
-0.7181965709,
-0.0783115551,
0.2619510293,
0.4440481663,
0.5377720594,
-0.3030383587,
0.4399344623,
0.0281970929,
-0.8278887272,
-1.0495179892,
-0.0057421271,
-1.1141359806,
-0.231903255,
1.2853741646,
0.3257884085,
-0.1822953224,
-0.0278545655,
-0.2081801444,
-0.0239707828,
-0.4885398149,
0.7358208299,
1.0035401583,
-0.3979995251,
-0.0238613728,
-0.7431117296,
0.4575876296,
0.302218169,
-0.8143368959,
0.0248759352,
0.5169229507,
0.3188526034,
0.3627606332,
0.5290635228,
-0.4330372214,
0.1531835645,
-0.2948485017,
0.374375999,
0.235831216,
-0.1069304347,
-0.1214321256,
0.1451589316,
0.1035905033,
0.7055715919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19493v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19493v1 | Development and Evaluation of a Retrieval-Augmented Generation Tool for Creating SAPPhIRE Models of Artificial Systems | 2024-06-27T19:20:09 | 2024-06-27T19:20:09 | Anubhab Majumder, Kausik Bhattacharya, Amaresh Chakrabarti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Representing systems using the SAPPhIRE causality model is found useful in
supporting design-by-analogy. However, creating a SAPPhIRE model of artificial
or biological systems is an effort-intensive process that requires human
experts to source technical knowledge from multiple technical documents
regarding how the system works. This research investigates how to leverage
Large Language Models (LLMs) in creating structured descriptions of systems
using the SAPPhIRE model of causality. This paper, the second part of the
two-part research, presents a new Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) tool for
generating information related to SAPPhIRE constructs of artificial systems and
reports the results from a preliminary evaluation of the tool's success -
focusing on the factual accuracy and reliability of outcomes. | [
-0.1112629771,
-0.61791116,
0.7512149215,
0.3170712292,
-0.1879056841,
0.0720440447,
-0.0655356199,
-0.3202012777,
0.4177069664,
0.3035984039,
-0.3398428559,
-0.1906581074,
-0.2115973234,
0.1325370073,
-0.649418354,
0.871552527,
0.0811513141,
0.1696240753,
-0.0170441363,
0.3585383594,
-0.6487787366,
-0.2572263777,
-0.6605312824,
-0.4128858745,
0.5681755543,
0.1168446243,
0.6394044757,
0.4175611138,
0.8527554274,
0.3244611919,
-0.0519943349,
0.2791251838,
-0.3796711266,
0.2972863615,
-0.5230045915,
-0.3677745461,
-0.5029701591,
0.1087167859,
0.8409901261,
0.4551066458,
-0.3387237489,
0.547516048,
0.1459877789,
0.2576943636,
-0.5824620128,
0.1074123234,
-0.6767708063,
0.1902048737,
-0.2508736253,
-0.4774557948,
-0.7055733204,
-0.4641959965,
-0.2558265328,
-0.6582656503,
-0.0400632955,
0.1984527111,
0.7291452885,
0.288490206,
-0.3125116825,
-0.2511581182,
-1.234113574,
0.8817216158,
-0.8382044435,
0.2192371488,
0.1984302104,
0.4689555168,
-0.3858346343,
-0.792453289,
-0.6179224253,
-0.6247168183,
-0.3213584125,
0.1243557408,
0.0183382425,
-0.2233411372,
0.4939629138,
0.1215749457,
-0.329120934,
-0.1575845331,
-0.5990650654,
-0.1669076681,
0.7694318295,
0.429595083,
0.4643050432,
-0.7568469048,
-0.3907110393,
0.1656345874,
-0.7418596745,
-0.3711557984,
0.1347195357,
0.3678418398,
0.1588470936,
1.035377264,
0.0298768096,
0.6799120307,
0.0116258366,
-0.3218514621,
-0.0975426957,
-0.3366737962,
-0.2229659706,
0.0352613032,
0.5875781178,
0.0368741043,
-0.2378348112,
-0.4636915624,
-0.399093926,
0.1698490232,
0.4890476465,
-0.7943254709,
0.0682501495,
0.0892802179,
-0.487560302,
-0.4267350733,
0.0896103308,
-0.3640857935,
-0.4922232628,
-0.5137733817,
0.5406453609,
-0.4891700447,
-0.2569017708,
-0.0902896523,
-0.2852684259,
0.3944717646,
0.0614426434,
-0.4609093666,
0.3028210998,
0.7147115469,
0.6038228273,
-0.1574780345,
-0.0831107348,
-0.628405571,
0.50556916,
-0.5817652345,
0.7679954171,
-0.4617922306,
-0.6734346151,
-0.3867101371,
-0.3115693927,
0.1620922834,
-0.4057931006,
0.7714959383,
-0.6464362144,
-0.146937117,
0.0924872234,
-0.4160752296,
0.0113473348,
0.046167355,
-0.5104827285,
0.9386261106,
0.0108350199,
-0.6819445491,
0.326802969,
-0.3380038738,
-0.3501462638,
0.3916400671,
-0.5317091346,
-0.14872244,
0.317625165,
-0.4660234153,
0.3943397403,
-0.6450688243,
0.6591120362,
-0.2446639091,
-0.2478672564,
0.3976301253,
-0.2582286596,
0.5056928396,
0.1234242097,
-0.3572834134,
0.0050685005,
-0.9847798944,
0.1176921502,
-0.0830098838,
-0.6075461507,
-0.4778721929,
0.4823286235,
-0.2371628135,
0.1707370132,
0.2948375642,
-0.7228977084,
0.2183150798,
-0.239556089,
0.2002867162,
0.6033869386,
0.0556367896,
0.3031909168,
-0.0971856564,
0.2350311726,
-0.3245541155,
0.2089947462,
0.0747667998,
-0.2617864311,
-0.6874617934,
-0.0482301787,
0.3268131614,
0.7040942907,
-0.7580015063,
0.1711038649,
-0.3455442488,
-0.598354578,
0.0815924555,
-0.043761,
0.6990718842,
0.6084399223,
0.0824626461,
-0.3602075577,
-0.5930556059,
-1.162350297,
-0.0773128048,
-0.2476671636,
-0.1635064483,
0.7037473917,
0.5288904905,
-0.2702434361,
0.9318597317,
-0.5149970055,
0.1284614503,
0.1183095872,
0.3076330721,
0.253461808,
0.4635226429,
0.3004315794,
-0.6542590857,
-0.1506461203,
0.0906436667,
-0.9712153077,
0.136734575,
0.1289642453,
-0.5555180311,
0.0267643426,
0.4117600322,
-0.6275100708,
0.5693407059,
0.2287766635,
-0.4080103636,
1.0709888935,
-0.3134510815,
0.3090353906,
-1.2013121843,
0.6139890552,
0.0727249011,
0.0492678061,
-0.4825302958,
0.1350858063,
-0.0360538363,
-0.3700480461,
-0.2552141845,
0.6446321607,
-0.4476597905,
-0.3752253354,
-0.1288670152,
0.2867761552,
-0.1995453387,
0.2985167503,
-0.1215968728,
0.971268177,
0.0023484319,
-0.8236473799,
0.46407938,
0.3650200665,
-0.2425108254,
0.6834036708,
-0.8812075853,
0.0477271937,
0.0419625752,
0.0149515886,
-0.3900420964,
-0.4363763332,
0.0627881736,
-0.5800005794,
0.3246491849,
-0.1315215379,
-0.5358807445,
-0.3820127249,
0.016378494,
0.2956726849,
0.6168734431,
-0.3035133779,
1.0072895288,
0.5190723538,
-0.308231771,
-0.4245817661,
-0.4955267906,
0.2740775049,
-0.1251115799,
-0.744664371,
0.4055526555,
0.0382532291,
-0.6846231222,
0.1992296427,
0.1345649362,
0.0931487456,
0.1774118394,
0.2668163776,
0.6257253289,
-0.2949886918,
0.335676074,
0.0128518287,
-0.1677972823,
0.2055570781,
0.0279673282,
0.435793668,
0.1733983606,
-0.3986142576,
-0.2446136177,
0.2168121338,
0.2340567857,
-0.2350627631,
0.7527714968,
0.2638621926,
-0.4312831461,
-0.4298407435,
-0.4825897217,
-0.0993397906,
-0.4343734682,
0.2504907548,
-0.3736360073,
-0.2875290811,
0.374653697,
-0.2626336217,
0.1502099633,
0.6580078602,
0.2594525218,
0.0550692305,
1.0498965979,
0.6920683384,
0.0875136331,
0.2834168673,
-0.0836601108,
0.2096404284,
-1.1626882553,
-0.3434764445,
-0.7646709085,
0.0170283262,
-0.3283822536,
-0.5799469352,
0.5434753299,
0.3581268191,
-0.5896034241,
0.2661563754,
-0.5435327291,
-0.0222640689,
0.5567612052,
0.3733368516,
0.2990914881,
0.209014371,
-0.211436674,
0.0663757548,
-0.4979130626,
-0.8435416818,
1.0314235687,
-0.089065738,
0.9672327638,
0.3729507327,
0.5021036863,
0.4648785293,
0.3483768106,
-0.5256960988,
0.7228427529,
-0.2018551528,
-0.6289730668,
-0.3003290892,
-0.4495959878,
-0.907982707,
-0.1440301985,
-0.5624496937,
-0.5682883859,
0.2088765204,
0.1410725862,
-0.5933117867,
0.1666173786,
-0.3659686148,
0.2333052307,
-0.3330381811,
-0.6733643413,
-0.5264286995,
-0.3392076194,
0.7553095222,
-0.2871262729,
0.3324706852,
0.1282361299,
-0.0129923197,
0.6330658197,
-0.4046579599,
0.7132378817,
0.0285574608,
-0.0392694362,
0.3364882469,
0.4305342138,
0.5236000419,
0.0574164651,
-0.3920134902,
-0.3293671608,
-0.244383812,
-0.0696539804,
-0.7023946643,
0.6621257067,
-0.5538912416,
-0.6870908737,
-0.2424773425,
-0.3175698221,
-0.1387022734,
0.3178696334,
-0.237148717,
0.929917872,
-0.3200252354,
-0.0690235496,
0.7612733841,
-0.639870584,
0.017128868,
0.5678573251,
-0.4462052882,
-0.2884048522,
1.0619438887,
-0.1166211218,
0.0640841797,
0.093670629,
0.0228522755,
0.2099719346,
-0.3670264184,
-0.5423922539,
0.3932646811,
-0.3918103576,
-0.2504591048,
-0.2388362586,
-0.6284809709,
-0.3040980995,
-0.0165274888,
-0.1942490935,
-0.6576735973,
-0.1723100245,
0.0456570834,
0.2672415376,
1.2949211597,
-0.414873302,
-0.01901366,
-0.8965067267,
0.3944839239,
0.3504487574,
0.368288666,
-0.028157359,
-0.4897604883,
-0.4960393608,
-0.0277127158,
-0.3993648291,
-0.9288823009,
0.3733721375,
0.0397830717,
0.8367102146,
-0.0004175598,
-0.2119806409,
0.5276136398,
-0.8193253279,
0.8363704085,
0.1111333892,
-0.7370451689,
0.7949991226,
-0.463344872,
-0.3729738891,
0.0538395829,
0.1921925992,
-0.337793529,
-0.1158776134,
-0.6286169291,
-0.8256601095,
0.5408986211,
0.2016157955,
0.051550813,
-0.0346218385,
0.8065341115,
-0.1570981145,
0.0411131717,
-0.417075932,
-0.3202545345,
0.40245682,
-0.0654766038,
-0.0236636177,
-0.607098341,
-0.2295270115,
0.2160010934,
1.154899478,
0.2219247222,
0.2668286264,
0.2613375783,
-0.1339442134,
-0.024504507,
0.2309965342,
0.4396052957,
0.6605449319,
-0.0706757605,
-0.0247736573,
0.0035091965,
-0.354880631,
0.1610298604,
0.190727517,
-0.4692188501,
0.0058925832,
0.2025999427,
0.6998893619,
0.3532312214,
-0.4889532924,
0.0675108433,
-0.0900552273,
0.1544495374,
-0.435867399,
0.170546785,
-0.0456371233,
0.3952040374,
0.4912170172,
0.03864282,
0.4499746263,
-0.4857778549,
0.3007100224,
0.6662557721,
-0.0397843719,
-0.2009410709,
0.6799036264,
0.3005494177,
-0.6784322262,
0.694378376,
-0.3329929709,
-0.2639400661,
0.6171491742,
0.4089355469,
0.7214291692,
-0.3077117801,
0.2816974223,
0.7263339162,
0.1995086372,
-0.0823281929,
0.1148565039,
-0.0449963808,
-0.5134372115,
-0.6650135517,
-0.92555511,
-0.3516969383,
-0.3393848836,
-0.7004266381,
0.4277570248,
-0.2384245694,
-0.5855771899,
0.021437427,
-0.1096189767,
-0.3371519148,
0.1327913105,
0.1090933755,
0.9372342229,
-0.7419765592,
0.3383029997,
0.5441317558,
-0.6994156837,
-1.4691798687,
-0.4323323071,
-0.400764972,
-0.6463389397,
1.2663488388,
-0.6535774469,
-0.4041826725,
-0.0806936324,
-0.5118721128,
-1.2511062622,
1.3503055573,
0.2973504066,
-0.3604364693,
-0.1963395625,
-0.0248280931,
0.5689749122,
-0.047793407,
0.3405357003,
0.3720734715,
0.3232840896,
0.0783398077,
-1.136507988,
0.0968848392,
-0.4250800014,
0.2703357935,
0.1134357601,
-0.4619946182,
0.9515215755,
-0.0974220112,
-0.5081582665,
0.3251595497,
0.6848080754,
0.6668278575,
-0.0286430344,
0.1393264681,
0.3819325566,
0.5114249587,
0.1233818308,
1.2963237762,
-0.5917772651,
0.338294059,
1.1756870747,
-0.1821826249,
0.9827520847,
0.3414573371,
-0.2772781551,
0.7943744659,
0.2496424317,
0.1145470515,
0.108398363,
0.3520211875,
-0.3265543878,
-0.2421350479,
-0.0738015771,
-0.212425828,
0.0540173203,
0.5035256147,
-0.5096055269,
-0.1557656974,
-0.1401420832,
-0.1933185905,
-0.0304340515,
-0.3751291931,
0.7144411802,
0.1526933461,
-0.8288924694,
0.1702740192,
0.1662292928,
0.4065680206,
-0.4204556048,
-0.3690805435,
-0.2057356685,
0.1800130755,
-0.3327977657,
-0.6642293334,
0.3891882896,
0.2345453054,
-0.3956418931,
0.1999507993,
0.9729735851,
-0.0562828034,
-0.909617722,
0.1063432768,
0.3749662638,
0.4271870852,
0.5710861087,
-0.5523502231,
-0.0104939379,
-0.1552597433,
-0.2662154734,
-0.0203502458,
0.2848815024,
-0.1974809319,
0.8107295036,
0.3984073699,
0.473631531,
0.2921918929,
-0.089554064,
0.678159833,
-0.652811408,
0.0307539739,
-0.6060736179,
0.5329075456,
-0.2063069791,
0.1348259747,
0.9944477081,
0.7444717288,
0.3485707939,
0.0752682984,
0.9431129694,
-0.2428142428,
0.8255239129,
-0.3764839768,
0.6152535081,
-0.5010560751,
0.4225089848,
-0.3269615769,
-0.8227979541,
-0.0918382332,
0.5920416117,
-0.2012299448,
0.0409741923,
0.5094512105,
0.9354742765,
-0.0867728442,
-0.1756499559,
0.1419567764,
0.5651058555,
0.3036046922,
0.0990464911,
1.0576248169,
-0.3512662351,
0.3579546511,
-0.0767641813,
-0.3598416746,
0.1223684624,
-0.8349021673,
-0.4498383999,
-0.4450669289,
-0.0398322642,
-0.5996221304,
0.0863965228,
0.5350323915,
0.4766767025,
-0.3893984556,
-0.4400674701,
-0.0296145845,
-0.1216432825,
0.4038644135,
-0.1628725231,
0.3621240556,
-0.5718804002,
-0.4572200477,
0.3004254401,
0.3027588129,
-0.1545730233,
-0.6275354028,
0.0358212851,
0.0661373287,
0.4518652558,
0.8383896351,
0.3432263434,
-0.4262484908,
-0.2399471104,
0.058995869,
-0.3109792769,
-0.4288184941,
0.8852651715,
-0.8544849753,
0.0223651659,
0.2884142995,
0.319956094,
0.4765053391,
0.0419166461,
0.8029773831,
-0.3151499927,
-0.1031020954,
-0.0149382269,
0.4637792408,
0.2358702421,
-0.4242130518,
0.6046880484,
0.0370166451,
-0.8589525223,
-0.8987095952,
0.2918190956,
-0.8369786143,
-0.2349465936,
1.3629397154,
0.112876676,
-0.468593806,
0.1223328188,
-0.4263169169,
0.375877887,
-0.042060513,
0.7013809681,
0.332231313,
-0.2605672181,
0.6116212606,
-0.4675099552,
0.3293143809,
0.1197753325,
-0.7870795727,
-0.1117360741,
0.836904943,
0.4726079702,
0.4420882463,
0.5162975192,
-0.1699624807,
0.2029233426,
0.1698784083,
0.4323298335,
0.1167242303,
-0.1599661112,
-0.0192843247,
-0.1443899572,
0.1934816986,
0.3515168726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19486v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19486v1 | LoPT: Low-Rank Prompt Tuning for Parameter Efficient Language Models | 2024-06-27T19:02:41 | 2024-06-27T19:02:41 | Shouchang Guo, Sonam Damani, Keng-hao Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.ET, cs.LG, eess.SP | In prompt tuning, a prefix or suffix text is added to the prompt, and the
embeddings (soft prompts) or token indices (hard prompts) of the prefix/suffix
are optimized to gain more control over language models for specific tasks.
This approach eliminates the need for hand-crafted prompt engineering or
explicit model fine-tuning. Prompt tuning is significantly more
parameter-efficient than model fine-tuning, as it involves optimizing partial
inputs of language models to produce desired outputs.
In this work, we aim to further reduce the amount of trainable parameters
required for a language model to perform well on specific tasks. We propose
Low-rank Prompt Tuning (LoPT), a low-rank model for prompts that achieves
efficient prompt optimization. The proposed method demonstrates similar
outcomes to full parameter prompt tuning while reducing the number of trainable
parameters by a factor of 5. It also provides promising results compared to the
state-of-the-art methods that would require 10 to 20 times more parameters. | [
-0.4653531611,
-0.982018888,
0.5060248971,
0.1372089088,
-0.4215906262,
-0.2097508907,
-0.2881796062,
-0.0096938098,
-0.0190959889,
0.3751750886,
-0.763473928,
-0.3655635417,
-0.4494721591,
0.2257787138,
0.1564597338,
0.8311577439,
0.2195783705,
-0.0489182211,
0.0070558884,
0.0247765034,
-0.5363523364,
-0.3810952604,
-1.1093372107,
0.0264570452,
0.9247413278,
0.7803026438,
0.5065202117,
0.8978390694,
0.4341139793,
0.2355787009,
-0.40479967,
0.3267924488,
-0.5484415293,
0.3403410912,
0.1007488966,
-0.3331106603,
-0.6613145471,
0.1649387926,
0.6488161087,
1.0268270969,
0.2203006744,
0.2116125673,
0.1457484812,
0.4514665008,
-0.7232497334,
-0.0051811361,
-0.4714715183,
-0.2289309949,
-0.0157887638,
-0.4755562246,
-0.4824515283,
-0.5703554153,
-0.2655740678,
-0.5622076392,
0.046887029,
0.4674661458,
0.7409035563,
0.3830868304,
-0.2149373144,
0.1418484449,
-0.35648489,
0.8938544393,
-0.8451494575,
0.3345376551,
0.5463795662,
0.1838891208,
-0.2056468874,
-0.3732854426,
-0.2000055611,
-0.4150285125,
0.0034763312,
-0.2176540643,
0.072343044,
0.3420908749,
0.6470346451,
0.0976357833,
-0.455724895,
0.595646441,
-0.0266712047,
-0.2914705873,
0.1811666191,
0.2343538702,
0.1992778629,
-0.4224666059,
-0.2455105036,
0.1391095966,
-1.0732984543,
0.3738144338,
0.5882764459,
1.1059054136,
-0.0631513149,
0.586196959,
-0.5141307712,
0.9845317602,
0.2397238165,
-0.2992524803,
-0.3004933298,
-0.3572593331,
0.0412261561,
0.094778575,
0.5065456629,
0.2540101707,
0.1944190711,
0.0923833027,
-0.384652406,
-0.2003055364,
-0.1438426822,
-1.0675073862,
0.0664081126,
-0.0979502201,
-0.5829259157,
-0.4510645568,
-0.361752212,
-0.5461733937,
-0.5763649344,
-0.3573283851,
0.329551667,
-0.6063183546,
0.1994689554,
-0.159466669,
-0.1651941687,
0.2939735949,
0.5329318047,
-1.0326811075,
0.1685824841,
0.8583109975,
0.7644148469,
-0.3780416548,
-0.2961821854,
-1.4468621016,
-0.1012819409,
-0.1876279265,
0.7768704295,
-0.8704106212,
-0.5016083121,
-0.0117712701,
0.0366307832,
-0.0589818917,
-0.224873811,
0.7803673744,
-0.3916096091,
0.3308344483,
-0.3838398755,
-0.5016866326,
0.323128283,
0.1818112284,
-0.5967550278,
1.1976598501,
0.2057405412,
-0.4452293217,
0.3461446166,
-0.6901932359,
-0.4413869679,
0.1948061287,
0.0020456079,
-0.0857280716,
0.4414157271,
0.4779751003,
0.3536985517,
-0.6005431414,
-0.0938613042,
-0.0849851891,
-0.6914719939,
-0.1892388612,
-0.5398799181,
0.5437163711,
0.1465778053,
-0.0430238023,
0.1309941709,
-0.7612221837,
0.0748371258,
0.0196477175,
-0.5953086019,
-0.6303588152,
-0.1087591574,
-0.1236885265,
-0.0131022381,
0.4457598031,
-0.4138655066,
0.7248523831,
-0.8593419194,
0.4118060172,
0.7829627991,
0.0413332954,
0.6165484786,
-0.2046373188,
0.6884103417,
-0.0993553773,
0.242632404,
-0.4001184106,
-0.7422570586,
-0.7552501559,
-0.6077598333,
0.6384819746,
0.3894169033,
-0.7681167722,
0.5350464582,
-0.0578129925,
-0.3403499424,
-0.5894612074,
0.0584331118,
0.276211679,
0.8283241987,
0.1496263891,
0.2791018188,
-0.1224370152,
-0.9121313691,
-0.5466708541,
-0.1705354899,
0.0297199804,
0.3100589812,
0.2081845701,
0.363245517,
1.0573139191,
-0.6664990187,
0.0458874889,
-0.5370642543,
0.2646864057,
0.6739830375,
0.6633612514,
0.4705193341,
-0.4774070084,
-0.6446480751,
-0.2984654009,
-0.050560765,
-0.3834693134,
0.1422676295,
-0.0479874946,
0.3149469793,
0.6678740382,
-0.6560912728,
0.2661449611,
0.180374831,
-0.6236158013,
0.2676334381,
-0.3275675476,
0.3463665545,
-0.8572607636,
0.2037175745,
-0.2297142744,
-0.3517174423,
-0.6154379845,
0.0829338208,
0.0807569101,
-0.6765333414,
-0.6600129008,
1.0014778376,
-0.468454808,
0.3847005963,
-0.3733641207,
0.2216280401,
0.0373355262,
0.7295560241,
-0.0911600068,
0.9077785611,
0.5505843759,
-0.7285076976,
0.1933004856,
0.1077458337,
-0.2425173968,
0.7274495363,
-0.8092374802,
0.1675238311,
-0.1934387982,
-0.2540774941,
-1.1688665152,
0.0198461972,
0.3307128549,
-0.3366539776,
0.2325131148,
-0.6054019928,
-0.7769189477,
-0.0673438981,
-0.4488131404,
0.4283215702,
0.9178570509,
-0.5367249846,
0.347738266,
-0.1036264747,
-0.5133869648,
-0.1933065802,
-0.1387874782,
-0.2429254353,
-0.4114019871,
-0.3740040362,
0.3463676274,
-0.121159181,
0.1661491394,
-0.3394207954,
0.0899916887,
0.2278178185,
0.3411314785,
0.0891575217,
0.2156081498,
-0.4198440909,
0.2318546623,
0.3913094699,
-0.4620829225,
-0.3671208322,
-0.1025625989,
0.7737598419,
0.1616048068,
-0.4393796027,
-0.5010516047,
0.6427774429,
0.4221599996,
-0.2083400041,
0.7947739959,
0.4278927743,
-0.433888644,
-0.3947562575,
-0.3256251514,
-0.4385324121,
-0.5777512193,
0.1058374792,
-0.4934285581,
-0.8487921953,
0.3948486447,
-0.4013656676,
0.0272268746,
0.3550171852,
0.3518269956,
0.045640476,
1.4834213257,
0.7782353163,
-0.0525099039,
0.6208766103,
0.2817769349,
0.1790179163,
-0.6790093184,
0.212271899,
-0.947019875,
-0.4399899542,
-0.6781811118,
-0.3118324578,
0.5705064535,
0.2269435674,
-0.5263496041,
0.1603673548,
-0.5745721459,
0.5364054441,
0.850979805,
-0.1599959284,
0.4210916162,
0.0070608035,
-0.2357449532,
-0.0722377077,
-0.7718821764,
-0.5165117383,
0.60591501,
0.3057058156,
0.837068975,
0.020355504,
0.6453374028,
0.2904006839,
-0.3113999963,
-0.9625378847,
0.7749987841,
-0.2097818404,
-0.3264221549,
-0.6011227369,
-0.4031658173,
-0.9540092349,
0.0418659635,
-0.1216094717,
-0.8675208688,
0.2608198822,
0.2724419534,
-0.6982216239,
0.0072977394,
-0.7359700203,
0.8417480588,
-0.0392281003,
-0.1749962419,
0.0782106668,
-0.3700174987,
-0.0757761374,
0.1508921534,
-0.2019606382,
-0.2862597108,
-0.4440193176,
0.8478814363,
-0.7313966155,
0.9303150177,
-0.6188090444,
-0.2239611149,
0.0196546931,
0.0039202445,
1.1600574255,
0.1391197741,
-0.4509996474,
-0.3307629526,
-0.0119004566,
-0.4175519347,
-0.6846427917,
0.9099913836,
-0.5805267692,
-0.5745707154,
-0.2521951795,
-0.2528670728,
-0.5160509944,
0.3832598329,
0.4364989102,
0.6544125676,
-0.094185777,
-0.0273896847,
0.665579617,
-0.4064219296,
0.6197299957,
0.5889000297,
-0.0632646754,
-0.2478168309,
0.9870649576,
-0.0274809171,
0.1694368571,
0.3938358426,
0.4132627845,
-0.1661072075,
-0.4830006957,
-0.4295787811,
0.3444784582,
-0.6483425498,
-0.3195791245,
-0.3860270381,
-0.0371552296,
-0.4058368802,
-0.2845844924,
-0.365444243,
-0.7156515121,
-0.5019267201,
0.305519551,
0.6275133491,
0.2035772651,
0.2474406511,
0.8482774496,
-0.5395436883,
0.5743729472,
0.2317260653,
0.6029227376,
-0.2908073366,
-0.7800545096,
-0.1293716133,
-0.119907476,
0.0417363644,
-0.6622313261,
0.3136194348,
0.4356844723,
0.4939225316,
0.3645096421,
0.3903881609,
0.5830256343,
-0.6919183731,
0.8773032427,
0.0273430031,
-0.9902011156,
0.9473950267,
-0.6045759916,
0.5910641551,
0.8642049432,
0.2390800714,
-0.4871750474,
-0.1933050603,
-0.283007443,
-0.82455796,
1.067352891,
-0.0472939797,
0.1538715512,
-0.0239852816,
0.5400978923,
0.3391089141,
0.2236049324,
-0.3115690053,
-0.2929875851,
0.1038326472,
-0.1980425864,
0.0686383098,
-0.3436613083,
0.0576520152,
-0.4318130314,
0.6520682573,
-0.5350714326,
0.375708431,
-0.2368191481,
0.0224700905,
-0.1688570678,
0.3710500896,
0.56709373,
0.2427790165,
-0.2262494862,
0.0996236429,
0.2441349775,
-0.2628746629,
0.1185280755,
0.0948160961,
-0.3353228569,
-0.0392173119,
0.2323906124,
1.0620452166,
0.2321994007,
-0.5148065686,
0.5938565135,
-0.0844894648,
0.1067688465,
0.1942033619,
0.3275619447,
-0.0858156532,
-0.097533986,
0.1911245286,
-0.1295396388,
0.0442381687,
-0.3609316349,
-0.2400368005,
0.4151928127,
-0.5145910382,
-0.1472198665,
0.5416398644,
0.5527368188,
-0.6301141381,
0.7765850425,
-0.2348585427,
-0.1120902821,
0.4292624593,
0.56788975,
0.6738510132,
-0.2287307233,
0.245897159,
0.352792263,
0.2231842726,
0.0333998278,
0.5600394011,
-0.0352208801,
-0.1853264123,
-0.4541800916,
-0.7732934952,
-0.4722845852,
0.1373697668,
-0.4531172216,
0.8280353546,
-0.511736691,
-0.2593865097,
-0.1248525456,
-0.0214053299,
-0.6212652922,
0.0352605842,
0.0591336079,
1.1494252682,
-0.6829467416,
0.6671218276,
0.6449798942,
-0.2599589229,
-0.6240971684,
-0.0769350901,
-0.3068598211,
-0.8611571193,
0.7042157054,
0.118189171,
-0.0982234329,
0.3856452405,
-0.6429222226,
-0.9858150482,
0.6259121299,
0.5684319139,
-0.4564284384,
-0.3124995232,
0.2537843287,
0.3235706985,
-0.2882980704,
0.3907802105,
0.4499782622,
0.7385588884,
-0.0266349185,
-0.7731461525,
0.3464978039,
-0.2681821883,
0.1457246691,
0.3145181835,
-0.589469254,
0.9240471125,
-0.0293591116,
-0.2528367341,
0.4131366611,
0.556792438,
0.3639706075,
-0.0254238043,
0.6831852198,
0.0160414744,
0.7458528876,
-0.3272666931,
0.9197272062,
-0.5228988528,
0.1057213545,
0.8206067085,
-0.2501903176,
0.7162040472,
0.6809883118,
0.1163923293,
0.1469130665,
0.7480822206,
0.120127067,
0.7177447081,
0.1887038797,
0.0209946129,
-0.706363976,
-0.400039345,
-0.2138171494,
0.4534800947,
0.1342936009,
-0.1430272609,
-0.2522401512,
0.2384519726,
-0.0383814648,
-0.2126199752,
-0.3858547211,
0.7837491632,
0.061004363,
-0.8988336921,
0.9448578954,
0.2510821819,
0.6627025008,
-0.7131970525,
-0.0901917592,
-0.4803818166,
-0.2227471322,
0.1827350408,
-0.2115711719,
-0.2890310287,
0.1049655303,
-0.3077729046,
-0.4916259348,
0.6745816469,
-0.2439315766,
-0.4725597203,
-0.1462149173,
0.8139186502,
0.0020016569,
-0.2320699394,
-0.5061383843,
-0.0091509959,
-0.3342119753,
-0.5353147388,
0.3439872563,
0.4949809611,
-0.0240341257,
0.6080124974,
0.4922415316,
0.3821004331,
-0.2696326077,
0.2852580845,
0.965408206,
-1.0324195623,
-0.8119216561,
-0.8364201188,
0.5724487305,
-0.0242489465,
-0.5302310586,
0.5177920461,
0.4544467032,
-0.0039112144,
-0.1023922786,
0.6723191142,
-0.0464810394,
0.7515828013,
-0.7130643129,
0.7052416205,
-0.8399024606,
0.3747986853,
-0.183413431,
-0.9930978417,
-0.1334401965,
0.2243340909,
-0.2149184197,
0.2246975005,
0.6855618358,
0.8352333903,
-0.1483641863,
-0.2257422954,
0.5026875734,
-0.083140865,
0.1507644504,
0.4191641212,
0.9754489064,
-0.2375499457,
0.2504031658,
-0.0317567848,
-0.3261447251,
-0.5662437081,
-1.0744897127,
-1.0943032503,
-0.5350160003,
-0.3126645684,
0.0403594561,
0.1317877918,
1.2164285183,
0.7081027031,
-0.7394207716,
0.136578545,
0.175957337,
0.401352942,
-0.2756858766,
-0.1949893683,
0.5995269418,
-0.6970869303,
-1.0097334385,
0.7857733369,
0.1584358513,
-0.0950407162,
-0.2001595497,
0.0452375747,
0.0110802483,
0.3699777424,
0.6380139589,
0.1555888504,
-0.5929366946,
-0.3179522455,
0.2104028016,
-0.2473233491,
0.0360525437,
0.8490772247,
-0.9107941389,
0.0454448238,
0.8060968518,
0.3359653652,
-0.0366949178,
0.286986053,
0.6602604985,
-1.0810784101,
0.1496390551,
0.2340388596,
0.2868621945,
0.2018285692,
-0.4218017757,
0.1891230345,
0.1382287741,
-0.3255163729,
-1.137384057,
0.316716969,
-1.113257885,
-0.3235369325,
1.3528995514,
0.1249741837,
-0.2677985132,
0.0323534757,
-0.494035095,
0.0883292407,
-0.7900107503,
0.388502419,
0.3423649967,
-0.2904171646,
-0.2753979862,
-0.3075048625,
0.8943074346,
0.5363830328,
-0.7659074068,
0.1937193573,
0.3145776391,
-0.0185452998,
-0.1079819575,
0.5377696753,
0.244706437,
0.2468848675,
-0.1712732017,
-0.2752823234,
-0.3633776605,
-0.2981417477,
-0.4581073225,
0.464650631,
0.5446753502,
-0.0717064515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19482v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19482v1 | xTower: A Multilingual LLM for Explaining and Correcting Translation Errors | 2024-06-27T18:51:46 | 2024-06-27T18:51:46 | Marcos Treviso, Nuno M. Guerreiro, Sweta Agrawal, Ricardo Rei, José Pombal, Tania Vaz, Helena Wu, Beatriz Silva, Daan van Stigt, André F. T. Martins | cs.CL | cs.CL | While machine translation (MT) systems are achieving increasingly strong
performance on benchmarks, they often produce translations with errors and
anomalies. Understanding these errors can potentially help improve the
translation quality and user experience. This paper introduces xTower, an open
large language model (LLM) built on top of TowerBase designed to provide
free-text explanations for translation errors in order to guide the generation
of a corrected translation. The quality of the generated explanations by xTower
are assessed via both intrinsic and extrinsic evaluation. We ask expert
translators to evaluate the quality of the explanations across two dimensions:
relatedness towards the error span being explained and helpfulness in error
understanding and improving translation quality. Extrinsically, we test xTower
across various experimental setups in generating translation corrections,
demonstrating significant improvements in translation quality. Our findings
highlight xTower's potential towards not only producing plausible and helpful
explanations of automatic translations, but also leveraging them to suggest
corrected translations. | [
0.0845445171,
-0.4683046639,
0.3994119167,
0.4106849432,
-0.1728445292,
-0.0816226006,
-0.1898221821,
-0.3090023994,
0.0896120146,
0.3915023208,
-0.5530022383,
-0.5575610399,
-0.7307703495,
0.116382964,
-0.5243203044,
0.9852640033,
-0.6225008368,
0.12632972,
0.219507888,
-0.2747162879,
-0.5845238566,
-0.3111894131,
-0.7936646342,
-0.3232390285,
0.5053726435,
0.5454735756,
1.3595228195,
1.0009534359,
0.362265408,
0.3133800328,
0.0493066981,
0.3461651802,
-0.5491471291,
0.0127414269,
-0.2645884454,
-0.6231563091,
-0.6804654002,
-0.292963475,
0.6528564095,
0.6501494646,
-0.1870952845,
0.0246577691,
-0.0797630921,
0.75390172,
0.0068589044,
0.1392853856,
-0.5944431424,
0.317507118,
-0.3169334531,
-0.4563520253,
-0.3819606006,
-0.2764467001,
-0.0139512019,
-0.7673424482,
0.4585092068,
0.5271319747,
0.8673499227,
0.3519631922,
-0.4140198529,
-0.2092394084,
-0.4334450662,
0.8050837517,
-0.3113140464,
0.3008863032,
0.1066702753,
0.5402238965,
-0.3611014783,
-0.465608865,
-0.5601044893,
0.0716322884,
-0.1767155528,
0.436047703,
-0.5557986498,
-0.0568772182,
-0.1099366844,
0.5360631943,
-0.6831085682,
0.0532348342,
0.0118385078,
-0.09871687,
0.3730038106,
0.0585673153,
0.4673812091,
-0.4005373716,
-0.3674204946,
-0.2536528409,
-0.8639894724,
0.3563475609,
0.2334991992,
0.1189971864,
-0.1482111812,
0.3499105275,
0.157346949,
0.7178016901,
-0.1774222702,
0.047964979,
-0.0214921348,
-0.1529037058,
-0.4483385384,
0.3804655969,
0.4457452595,
0.5810801983,
0.2414002419,
-0.3649990559,
-0.1984141916,
-0.1795060039,
0.2590194941,
-0.5497415662,
-0.0054389788,
0.6387272477,
-0.6978824735,
-0.3466729522,
0.0719070137,
-0.4488143921,
-0.3973146677,
-0.108353205,
0.2369050086,
-0.2863149941,
-0.3545970023,
0.3031601608,
-0.281193465,
-0.3278746307,
0.4722344577,
-0.7024227381,
-0.113133058,
0.1119479388,
0.7051388621,
-0.031260401,
-0.4336283505,
-0.8415771127,
0.4844610095,
-0.6868460774,
0.535936296,
0.0962808132,
-0.2596901655,
0.1427874714,
-0.0739295259,
0.2725420296,
-0.4827696681,
0.6333991289,
-0.6106606722,
0.0071413014,
-0.27803725,
0.0033370822,
-0.4657238126,
0.1631801426,
-0.4169761539,
0.9081289768,
0.2236927301,
-0.5510798097,
0.2626365721,
-0.7232667208,
-0.282538563,
0.0448719673,
0.2137778252,
-0.2280551344,
0.6356597543,
0.3306045234,
0.2756140232,
-0.2048360109,
0.3087897599,
0.0396982469,
-0.1338786036,
0.4951023161,
-0.3722605705,
0.8445907831,
0.0539669059,
-0.4225157499,
0.3650448322,
-0.7958443761,
0.3717459142,
0.0999181494,
-0.2263933569,
-0.1684864759,
0.1860618442,
-0.2747684121,
0.1960431635,
-0.2074926347,
-0.3800538778,
-0.1776565164,
-0.2187707871,
0.304785639,
0.5868977904,
-0.5070446134,
0.1096379608,
-0.2701631784,
0.5534322858,
0.1760625839,
0.1375564188,
-0.5430628061,
-0.3976221085,
-0.6278971434,
-0.0197509434,
0.0044167321,
0.5433644652,
-0.6808518767,
-0.0980617702,
-0.435482353,
-0.0656523481,
-0.5511542559,
0.3603304923,
0.7751538754,
0.4952948391,
0.7191155553,
0.1295458525,
-0.5909752846,
-0.5082322359,
-0.5357292891,
-0.3328039944,
0.1292195618,
-0.0600204095,
0.292532742,
-0.1830090135,
0.8585554957,
-0.1041811854,
-0.3578804731,
-0.2160599381,
0.0185514726,
0.1273329407,
0.0444196053,
0.4649892151,
-0.7397258878,
-0.5469699502,
0.5337042212,
-1.0320003033,
-0.4295486808,
-0.0610298067,
-0.1726311743,
0.00142926,
0.2786380947,
-0.4372759759,
0.3157382011,
1.0172585249,
-0.1775117069,
0.7631917,
-0.5250604749,
0.3047709167,
-0.8917984366,
-0.4748507142,
-0.109137021,
-0.4842597246,
-0.5285975337,
0.3836550713,
0.1836572587,
0.0123328669,
-0.2160811573,
0.2172504812,
-0.707867384,
0.0005065275,
-0.2799649537,
0.8152440786,
0.2428802997,
0.0490798578,
-0.2489542067,
0.7015018463,
0.4057990313,
-0.1797706783,
0.3144882023,
0.5845505595,
-0.2360738814,
0.5414366126,
-0.6207278371,
-0.3494465053,
-0.2391022444,
0.1518120617,
-1.3432296515,
-0.4275354445,
0.2246346772,
-0.6368378401,
0.2360826582,
-0.3277755082,
-0.3592833281,
-0.3492672443,
-0.0167735722,
0.0825975463,
0.2201032192,
-1.0356216431,
0.2168605924,
-0.0526740886,
0.1005647257,
-0.8243889809,
-1.0063956976,
0.3795086145,
0.0567324422,
-1.2235244513,
0.7089085579,
0.2161299288,
-0.6572404504,
0.1520509422,
-0.1302602142,
-0.0637007579,
0.098475121,
0.5523685217,
-0.0347335972,
-0.4381619394,
0.4607293904,
0.1846555471,
-0.4571146965,
0.0968852192,
-0.6244245172,
-0.2109441608,
-0.2216650397,
-0.2997889221,
-0.407145679,
0.5742810369,
0.4572999179,
-0.2021486908,
0.7465837598,
0.27763924,
-0.1299697906,
-0.3997211754,
-0.3228099942,
0.3324980438,
-0.3966829181,
0.295319885,
-0.6304154992,
-0.7036172748,
0.525734961,
0.094070293,
0.1407489926,
0.4589262307,
0.3144689798,
-0.1714283824,
1.3577092886,
0.6822091937,
0.5151785016,
0.1324736178,
0.0504220426,
0.5541069508,
-0.4535476863,
-0.0178209823,
-0.6577564478,
-0.1780519485,
-0.2422017902,
-0.4724975824,
0.4681588411,
0.45578897,
0.1604714543,
0.3551955223,
-0.2633449137,
0.4642690122,
0.2742756307,
-0.3228852749,
0.7703202367,
0.4682444632,
-0.3572149277,
-0.1262232065,
-0.771686852,
-0.7523428202,
0.3660008907,
0.2838285863,
0.5080513358,
0.5473182201,
0.389301002,
0.1739764661,
0.7510793805,
-0.652115345,
-0.0042695035,
-0.1876978576,
-0.7502404451,
-0.2832202315,
-0.6652085781,
-0.7733098865,
0.5946086645,
-0.0652247816,
-0.6198289394,
-0.3314054906,
0.669015348,
-0.3290829659,
0.4823580384,
-0.804782629,
0.9654646516,
-0.4180780947,
-0.2446988374,
-0.4104555547,
-0.5206468105,
0.5578058958,
-0.0743715689,
0.5168299675,
0.0512869358,
0.1586974561,
0.2193248868,
-0.6293114424,
0.5989419818,
-0.156846568,
-0.3178754747,
0.2226823568,
0.3024882376,
0.6121293306,
0.088449955,
-0.5387229919,
0.3452437818,
0.0233145691,
-0.4218418896,
-0.8871016502,
0.5637347698,
-0.9594470263,
-0.7575083375,
0.0058126277,
-0.6279301047,
0.053014461,
-0.0325793698,
0.2874258459,
0.6182157397,
0.1037892252,
0.0899175182,
0.5982837677,
-0.5309566259,
0.2797330022,
0.6886413097,
-0.7031421065,
-0.3904584348,
0.5886872411,
0.3104915321,
0.1487344801,
0.5216881037,
0.3120701611,
-0.226301387,
-1.0100218058,
-1.2785907984,
-0.0620362908,
-0.9147524834,
-0.2154192477,
-0.5052293539,
0.2899624109,
0.2088619471,
-0.3341271877,
-0.1591589004,
-0.5610681772,
0.1326173097,
-0.3394936621,
0.2917874455,
0.7299045324,
-0.1012234911,
1.0866832733,
-1.2095946074,
0.3609647155,
-0.2983444035,
0.3107144833,
0.1043556184,
-0.7016708851,
-0.4926075935,
0.1826890111,
-0.282219559,
-1.1426957846,
0.2110019028,
0.0482973568,
0.5122135282,
0.4358938038,
-0.223046422,
0.9892963767,
-0.5728499293,
0.7622717619,
0.5033400059,
-1.3922402859,
0.4215656221,
-0.2919947207,
0.085235402,
0.1265392452,
0.248024717,
-0.9528800845,
-0.3502102792,
-0.2851299047,
-0.5462785959,
0.6157571077,
0.2544579506,
0.2020123154,
-0.1397749782,
0.7046959996,
0.3395843506,
-0.1190575436,
-0.8736436367,
-0.3482768536,
-0.4510739446,
-0.0463525839,
0.1064426824,
-0.3434058428,
-0.1198679954,
0.2632240057,
1.0723963976,
-0.2072928101,
0.0170186944,
0.4005638361,
-0.6777876019,
-0.7877880931,
0.2536768317,
0.5934362411,
1.1060788631,
0.2042051852,
0.3567211032,
0.2558108568,
0.0037097316,
0.3279637396,
-0.1333354712,
0.1448422074,
0.3546971381,
0.4046704769,
0.5392722487,
-0.1732660085,
-0.3729183972,
0.5956204534,
-0.068625696,
-0.1595796943,
-0.2420351952,
-0.1727282554,
0.0780668631,
0.0273909997,
0.4938135147,
0.162852183,
-0.3180076778,
-0.2785917222,
-0.0375011936,
0.4191920459,
-0.748000741,
-0.4592516422,
0.8864458799,
0.2436953038,
-0.3252215385,
0.4114954174,
-0.318395555,
-0.4885011017,
0.2206795961,
0.5973126292,
0.6016836166,
-0.2159421146,
0.417912662,
0.0681000948,
0.4395304322,
-0.0133149391,
0.0850958154,
0.1483545303,
-0.7316752672,
-1.0466825962,
-0.295938611,
-0.3919606507,
-0.3624708951,
-0.4245544672,
0.0208206326,
-0.0942192823,
0.0161407534,
0.0234182179,
-0.4243652225,
-0.2546542287,
0.3252158463,
-0.2275847644,
1.2236180305,
-0.6505037546,
0.6793738604,
0.5719681978,
-0.2984074056,
-0.9712574482,
-0.0893418789,
0.1337410361,
-1.1457318068,
0.9356063604,
0.2226971835,
-0.6649982929,
-0.0547792092,
-0.2440237105,
-0.7407872081,
0.6485521793,
0.3645059168,
-0.5445406437,
0.2151649743,
0.2905929387,
0.594316721,
0.0619883724,
0.4225632846,
0.2297877222,
0.7874067426,
-0.303973496,
-0.5088064075,
0.1970913261,
-0.2720261216,
0.0296445098,
0.5639708042,
-0.5766766071,
0.3727678359,
-0.4907988012,
-0.1726546437,
0.3970372081,
0.7300031185,
-0.3492847979,
0.1158993468,
0.4059185386,
0.4270959496,
0.911790669,
-0.4406687319,
1.4312531948,
-0.3783406019,
0.0615321696,
1.0186392069,
0.0037607125,
0.5762239695,
0.6205769777,
-0.0738805905,
0.8810119033,
0.6260123849,
0.3447036743,
0.0481189936,
0.5113053322,
-0.1702729464,
-0.2063171118,
0.1020029783,
-0.3555326462,
0.2639400661,
0.2456093431,
-0.5906207561,
-0.5406517982,
0.1054269224,
0.2354595512,
0.0874938816,
-0.3048574328,
0.1726696342,
0.0847565532,
-0.9901294708,
0.7624228001,
0.5622529984,
0.0435864255,
-0.6785186529,
-0.0064618126,
-0.3179039061,
0.7047534585,
-0.6357887983,
-0.8072559237,
0.682682395,
0.1075477451,
-0.595361352,
-0.821654439,
0.3094440103,
-0.285905838,
-0.1369948834,
0.5827845931,
0.6374376416,
0.5449476838,
-0.4465931952,
-0.5832912922,
0.0386025794,
0.1590060741,
-0.0114554241,
-0.0632161126,
0.6975508332,
-0.4815051258,
0.6742411256,
0.5337693095,
-0.0234532058,
0.2014804184,
0.0970493928,
0.1894232482,
-0.4778476655,
-0.2861674726,
-1.0107163191,
0.8245147467,
0.0687065199,
-0.411926806,
0.9797451496,
0.2249894887,
0.6635869741,
-0.0617148615,
0.9252976775,
0.1783433259,
0.2479192019,
-0.4160078168,
0.3697741926,
-0.7137610912,
0.3173341751,
0.119223319,
-0.8493924737,
-0.5894049406,
0.4735065997,
-0.0967820659,
-0.3816034794,
0.9595971704,
1.0426907539,
-0.158549726,
0.4159478545,
0.4660362303,
0.5977447033,
0.4136836827,
0.1890240014,
1.0529799461,
-0.58557266,
1.2650840282,
0.2024100274,
-0.5430409312,
-0.222257629,
-1.1853455305,
-0.6477028131,
-0.0394567028,
-0.3595116138,
-0.5295426846,
0.3284755945,
0.794800818,
0.7901230454,
-0.7880721688,
-0.2336025983,
-0.2388986945,
0.4683205187,
-0.6912856102,
-0.1377512366,
0.2828436196,
-0.5584996343,
-0.4892883301,
0.5574601293,
0.5216475725,
0.0246364307,
-0.1847303808,
-0.1921088845,
0.7351804972,
-0.0944642946,
0.7535029054,
-0.2220402211,
-0.9078269005,
-0.4490423203,
0.0205456726,
0.0759706721,
0.3866408765,
0.9039257765,
-0.3366570175,
0.6370941401,
0.4292024076,
0.5781770349,
0.3921349645,
-0.1346237957,
0.835449338,
-0.7330255508,
-0.41195485,
-0.708615303,
0.4767610729,
0.5861769319,
-0.3884951472,
0.4296120405,
0.0468498357,
-0.4103651345,
-0.4811413586,
0.2668409348,
-0.7733485103,
-0.1723663062,
0.9227465391,
-0.6703588367,
-0.1671400815,
-0.1933222264,
-0.4063979983,
0.3203797638,
-0.0143346172,
0.7892119884,
0.9638161659,
0.0963370427,
-0.1363579929,
-0.9867706895,
0.4744258523,
0.7262889147,
-0.8040332198,
0.396746248,
0.3164045215,
0.1778976023,
0.2706325948,
0.1278096735,
-0.340972662,
0.5995422006,
-0.0615484416,
-0.1522352248,
-0.1124675721,
-0.2673099339,
-0.3016209602,
0.1660691798,
0.0923150554,
-0.1895872653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19478v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19478v1 | Sparse Regression for Machine Translation | 2024-06-27T18:43:51 | 2024-06-27T18:43:51 | Ergun Biçici | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, G.3; I.2.7 | We use transductive regression techniques to learn mappings between source
and target features of given parallel corpora and use these mappings to
generate machine translation outputs. We show the effectiveness of $L_1$
regularized regression (\textit{lasso}) to learn the mappings between sparsely
observed feature sets versus $L_2$ regularized regression. Proper selection of
training instances plays an important role to learn correct feature mappings
within limited computational resources and at expected accuracy levels. We
introduce \textit{dice} instance selection method for proper selection of
training instances, which plays an important role to learn correct feature
mappings for improving the source and target coverage of the training set. We
show that $L_1$ regularized regression performs better than $L_2$ regularized
regression both in regression measurements and in the translation experiments
using graph decoding. We present encouraging results when translating from
German to English and Spanish to English. We also demonstrate results when the
phrase table of a phrase-based decoder is replaced with the mappings we find
with the regression model. | [
-0.0328126736,
-0.7212315798,
0.5116245747,
0.3198904395,
-0.203316167,
0.0148001537,
-0.3962534964,
-0.3310483992,
0.1914101988,
0.5106889606,
-0.4916546941,
-0.4717359245,
-0.8242682219,
0.4530525208,
-0.4965531826,
1.2248278856,
-0.1772749573,
0.4560705125,
-0.0816509426,
-0.1839813292,
-0.6280863285,
-0.2823688686,
-0.4827745557,
-0.0120881777,
0.5214070082,
0.2454378605,
0.8535276651,
0.7278677225,
0.5483257771,
0.2639251649,
0.2616705894,
0.25999704,
-0.8795641065,
0.0521935187,
0.2284038216,
-0.4666474164,
-0.2159070671,
0.0579765141,
0.7028509974,
0.9167066813,
0.2163721919,
0.2091409415,
0.2752254903,
0.5717427731,
-0.2720664144,
0.1395019144,
-0.6419689655,
-0.0212714355,
0.0985033214,
0.1166527644,
-0.3670005202,
-0.4135333598,
-0.1218805537,
-0.62388134,
0.6392287016,
0.0231691077,
0.8398987055,
0.6927301884,
-0.124882929,
-0.1294428706,
-0.8736515641,
1.1483589411,
-0.306874156,
0.5877239704,
0.643306613,
0.300344795,
-0.0498376004,
-0.7459972501,
0.2018678933,
-0.3701249659,
-0.3752278686,
0.0668628961,
-0.156048432,
0.020153109,
0.1686560363,
0.0943360031,
-0.7798808813,
-0.1210828349,
-0.7724966407,
-0.3373103738,
0.6876288056,
-0.063602753,
0.0385049284,
0.1414479017,
-0.145973891,
-0.1051164791,
-0.5003745556,
-0.3363509774,
0.1786356717,
0.7169310451,
0.0164079573,
0.380102247,
0.1079321131,
0.8058470488,
-0.3890788257,
-0.3995068371,
0.3346926272,
-0.4440458715,
-0.2351375073,
-0.0455333106,
0.6098768115,
-0.1945544183,
0.4532965124,
-0.6061590314,
-0.2894674242,
-0.1533972025,
0.1868573129,
-0.4185576439,
0.3237173557,
0.0005236273,
-0.5264934897,
-0.0196645688,
0.0488542579,
-0.5866380334,
0.0255669542,
-0.2956006527,
0.1743799597,
-0.3269970119,
0.0201261938,
0.0794753507,
-0.1476052254,
-0.1518306732,
0.2756988108,
-0.7030521035,
0.5415730476,
0.3745115697,
0.9751114845,
-0.2231901735,
-0.3386003077,
-0.7623544931,
-0.038481757,
-0.5291855931,
0.2418360412,
-0.3446940184,
-0.3361740112,
0.4104113877,
-0.1108681411,
-0.2565956712,
-0.533361733,
0.4682215154,
-0.1793050915,
0.0256319046,
-0.075960882,
-0.2586033344,
-0.2081656456,
-0.0841431096,
-0.6412031054,
1.0399746895,
0.5558093786,
-0.4545561671,
0.296951592,
-0.1237088963,
-0.5510367155,
-0.2118710279,
-0.0986152738,
-0.5239688158,
0.2606468201,
0.068844907,
0.4751907587,
-0.3642069101,
0.2349405885,
-0.1927947104,
-0.4843719602,
0.1899490356,
-0.0647551939,
0.7279082537,
0.5279738903,
-0.2917267382,
0.098774083,
-0.5005990863,
-0.2191536278,
0.0364969298,
-0.2083116919,
-0.2641717196,
0.0694359541,
0.5208372474,
-0.0633886755,
0.1722672433,
-0.3464602828,
0.131330654,
-0.0822919309,
0.2629598975,
0.2406620979,
-0.2456475645,
0.5684086084,
-0.1536934227,
0.5955359936,
-0.2745735943,
0.0710622594,
0.2234199941,
-0.4094684422,
-0.6926678419,
-0.6449738145,
0.5801339746,
0.7979001999,
-0.5204212666,
0.1980918646,
-0.1497670561,
-0.1611528248,
-0.9478862286,
0.454921931,
0.4111172855,
0.4177820981,
0.7049910426,
0.2486610115,
-0.5594443679,
-0.9756669402,
-0.0398584418,
0.0798030943,
-0.1260089427,
0.1218884289,
0.2748501003,
-0.2358246744,
0.5785359144,
-0.5880511999,
-0.8209320307,
-0.5263480544,
0.1642288566,
0.0715940744,
0.5349473953,
0.8565225601,
-0.8284643292,
-0.65487957,
0.1161793396,
-0.6824833155,
-0.1657386571,
-0.4977966547,
-0.0462502353,
0.3662418723,
0.6419775486,
-0.1754914522,
0.3654291034,
0.4196566939,
0.0461088866,
-0.1452363878,
-0.2979262769,
0.1538657844,
-1.0642105341,
0.0267385542,
0.2592404783,
-0.6630405784,
-0.4517171383,
-0.0834461451,
-0.0769222528,
0.0864032954,
-0.2524652779,
0.2627830803,
-0.48742643,
-0.3087112308,
-0.0882559195,
0.0423399508,
-0.3760971427,
0.2001537681,
0.0661025494,
1.0650724173,
0.3159226477,
-0.2047492564,
0.1631701291,
0.3600734472,
-0.0235462543,
-0.2833464742,
-0.6869170666,
0.0120584061,
-0.1410682052,
-0.0801172704,
-0.9450399876,
0.0156432018,
0.1731161028,
-0.5679835081,
0.5780262947,
-0.0657797903,
-0.5275229216,
-0.2684197426,
-0.0466037318,
-0.113284409,
0.9174448252,
-0.0390184633,
0.164192304,
0.2938708663,
-0.0534168519,
-0.5757152438,
-0.8027041554,
-0.1187530607,
-0.2583726645,
-0.356518209,
0.1577023268,
0.146471411,
-0.1743084937,
-0.0317426994,
0.0658690035,
-0.2221273929,
0.2124436796,
-0.0191373248,
0.4189463854,
-0.2173655033,
-0.0696735457,
0.1309963316,
-0.1535207331,
-0.1212842464,
-0.3577215075,
0.3788331151,
-0.0209752675,
0.1035099626,
-0.0036102913,
0.626860559,
0.3552577496,
-0.0814704299,
0.6947892308,
0.9498534203,
-0.4646065533,
-0.2945334613,
-0.5806756616,
-0.1925259084,
-0.3266831934,
0.7192921638,
-0.5827645063,
-0.9137889147,
0.4268988669,
0.0219215434,
-0.2257279307,
0.4253197014,
0.5007135272,
0.0722115785,
1.2482575178,
1.1751590967,
-0.2461664379,
0.4062185287,
-0.4550337791,
0.0753875002,
-0.545779407,
-0.1165886819,
-0.9302350879,
-0.1785098612,
-0.7932893634,
-0.3728345335,
0.5717405081,
0.2213329822,
0.0250398573,
0.6250567436,
-0.5925905108,
0.0984784886,
0.6418366432,
0.126116097,
0.0524064973,
0.3834455311,
0.1119958833,
-0.4439128339,
-0.8572924733,
-0.3556301296,
0.9066729546,
0.300945878,
0.7865653038,
-0.1651040316,
0.7491286397,
0.3385765553,
0.2902061939,
-0.7463911176,
0.2375719845,
-0.4310758114,
-0.3024732769,
-0.3914820552,
-0.5650690198,
-0.9754886031,
0.1167694777,
-0.4337780774,
-0.5400852561,
0.1067936644,
-0.0697355643,
-0.0209266916,
-0.0343086459,
-0.6726537347,
0.9485334158,
-0.1409929246,
-0.4933616221,
-0.2756428123,
-0.75066185,
0.0820337385,
-0.2720053494,
0.0201033726,
0.1472079903,
-0.0954408124,
0.5085507631,
-0.2103384286,
0.7103853226,
0.0863003358,
0.3850793839,
0.1846147329,
0.2676445544,
0.3014316261,
0.0480012633,
-0.0812632963,
0.2659389973,
-0.1212707087,
-0.5812090039,
-0.442849189,
0.504496932,
-1.0819272995,
-0.5726100206,
-0.430934459,
-1.112954855,
-0.1800568551,
0.0862297118,
0.3127572834,
-0.1013568118,
-0.2281536311,
0.1544006318,
0.6873086691,
0.036242038,
0.2089530826,
0.2494716495,
-0.0821525529,
-0.5103030801,
0.9292619824,
0.3451143205,
0.2319120914,
0.4145960808,
0.0354218371,
-0.1992113292,
-0.7070539594,
-0.5715579391,
0.5331147909,
-0.472032249,
-0.4408281744,
-0.5926752687,
-0.2852607667,
-0.6728528738,
-0.3495933712,
-0.1021907702,
-0.4056198597,
-0.3963451684,
-0.0948718786,
0.2455587685,
0.7586989999,
-0.327629149,
0.0528717898,
-0.9066351056,
0.2379543036,
-0.0130105726,
-0.2614321113,
-0.6312185526,
-0.5263235569,
-0.5457749963,
-0.0059192739,
-0.017321609,
-1.0524499416,
0.7680454254,
-0.0232009254,
0.6842853427,
0.1282705516,
-0.1680456251,
0.6318181157,
-0.5547171235,
0.400755167,
0.0338841826,
-0.8122344017,
0.5443879366,
-0.332728833,
-0.105404675,
0.6715707183,
0.7625200152,
-0.1448693126,
-0.6280248165,
-0.4767537117,
-0.6596512198,
0.6428584456,
0.3452427983,
0.0388735719,
0.1073369384,
0.4930415154,
0.3186180294,
0.2786407769,
-0.5937232375,
-0.2121280581,
-0.0928588957,
-0.3655693829,
-0.3302812874,
-0.2944038808,
-0.0981937796,
-0.2142721564,
0.7635415792,
-0.1843769848,
0.0176058505,
0.2417699695,
-0.2017226815,
-0.2497171015,
-0.0648666546,
0.623428762,
0.618786335,
-0.5052460432,
-0.1318435222,
0.2134639472,
-0.3657409549,
-0.067706652,
0.403593421,
-0.6643489003,
0.4594431221,
0.4157098532,
0.7745357156,
-0.0963737741,
-0.3626785874,
0.4293177128,
0.3180378675,
-0.1132726446,
-0.2101039737,
-0.1476572752,
-0.170662567,
0.0916092694,
0.3307929039,
0.1287611425,
0.454028368,
-0.339001298,
0.2121061534,
0.4219713211,
-0.6531108022,
-0.0903235599,
0.9841454029,
-0.0137701305,
-0.1589775383,
0.7093212605,
-0.0448261537,
-0.4049513936,
0.7315141559,
0.9811766148,
0.943133533,
-0.1764110774,
0.3608803749,
0.6896237135,
0.8096563816,
-0.3127546608,
0.0244451407,
-0.0519018993,
-0.3261784315,
-0.5674872398,
-0.460413903,
-0.0496121198,
0.081542626,
-0.7898262739,
0.4014323056,
0.0870854259,
0.0088868225,
-0.2912798524,
-0.1107094809,
-0.586736083,
-0.063422814,
0.2886164784,
0.8288027048,
-1.3131555319,
0.896456182,
0.7701880336,
-0.9961755276,
-0.6722606421,
-0.180275172,
-0.2873583734,
-0.8676815033,
0.8727421165,
-0.1841765493,
0.0057409606,
0.0060250885,
-0.575515449,
-1.0441328287,
0.9504889846,
0.5607631803,
-0.4163100719,
0.0078929933,
0.4958485365,
0.5635576844,
-0.5300477147,
0.2087989002,
0.5839397907,
0.4010321796,
-0.0133903259,
-0.9830592275,
-0.0492974408,
0.2596488595,
0.3635431528,
0.2598403096,
-0.6114018559,
0.7081598639,
-0.1569578797,
0.020044893,
0.253990829,
0.8238759637,
-0.0292645395,
0.1588184834,
0.2645246685,
0.2630010843,
0.3898842037,
-0.2381741703,
1.1435455084,
-0.1787775457,
0.4971035421,
0.8183236122,
-0.1189314947,
0.6172032356,
0.7025149465,
-0.2746338546,
0.0041026669,
0.7314094901,
-0.0914339051,
0.6733783484,
0.295457691,
0.1071884558,
-0.3652948737,
-0.2340903133,
-0.2948868275,
0.0748223662,
0.3743034303,
-0.3938156068,
-0.375574708,
0.2475396544,
0.2378285825,
0.552231133,
-0.2260176092,
0.6735849977,
0.0479875281,
-0.5505225658,
0.7701177001,
-0.005030408,
0.2911316156,
-0.8763975501,
-0.3823626637,
-0.4731740057,
0.1826304942,
-0.180553019,
-0.2921773195,
0.5349063277,
0.0014552522,
-0.2735025883,
-0.5814393759,
0.5949468017,
-0.7568878531,
-0.789743185,
0.5265979171,
0.8360489011,
0.3306743801,
0.2202673405,
-0.7235809565,
0.2687167227,
0.2377155274,
-0.0652988553,
0.3988188803,
0.234548986,
-0.2591849864,
0.3903942704,
0.4315116107,
0.3184843957,
0.15841721,
0.0103385048,
0.7492026091,
-0.2311903536,
-0.1112460718,
-0.3897052109,
0.3487289548,
-0.0748617649,
-0.2330614328,
0.7061166763,
0.9271794558,
1.0585155487,
-0.3055164516,
0.855096519,
0.0117560886,
0.531013608,
-0.5290641189,
0.3836838603,
-0.5684837699,
0.0117278984,
0.0682291389,
-1.1607160568,
-0.6297838092,
0.8936283588,
-0.1329399645,
-0.0646343976,
0.9308561087,
0.8483895063,
-0.1373440027,
-0.5972344875,
0.5680695772,
0.3031965494,
-0.1833778322,
0.360237062,
0.4226214588,
-0.7551817894,
0.7073800564,
-0.2163438052,
-0.3291089237,
-0.0750427842,
-0.4464745224,
-0.8685526848,
-0.7222163677,
-0.3234595358,
-0.8370249867,
0.2676712275,
0.8890245557,
0.6743624806,
-0.911213696,
-0.6078355908,
-0.06494008,
0.2574591935,
-0.5703426003,
-0.1951655298,
0.3394917846,
-1.0715882778,
-1.1253620386,
0.3738319576,
0.1037980169,
0.0585129373,
-0.2608149648,
-0.148971349,
-0.2640071809,
-0.1644811332,
0.2747608721,
0.2195015103,
-0.619541049,
-0.1432332098,
0.2579204738,
-0.4428981543,
0.0400619246,
0.9034784436,
-0.9084382653,
0.1979478449,
0.6449598074,
0.8834655285,
0.8716697097,
-0.2327092588,
0.6424282193,
-0.6260517836,
0.634086132,
0.2530249655,
0.385489136,
0.4097191393,
-0.5285181999,
1.1317844391,
0.3439252079,
-0.438993156,
-0.8172028065,
0.1439643502,
-0.9766253829,
-0.3362364769,
1.4257887602,
-0.0877291113,
-0.3543754518,
-0.1075682342,
-0.1791792065,
0.4814296961,
-0.2674026489,
0.6752778292,
0.342753768,
0.0546094589,
-0.005703134,
-0.9645701647,
0.6161207557,
0.5808183551,
-0.4499321878,
-0.3369015157,
0.6810745597,
0.1148007661,
0.1190428957,
0.5283357501,
-0.0771699548,
0.0957811922,
0.0998556092,
-0.0170766078,
-0.0460163653,
-0.4177320898,
-0.2858330607,
-0.1125451177,
-0.0488331728,
-0.4069554806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19470v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19470v1 | Changing Answer Order Can Decrease MMLU Accuracy | 2024-06-27T18:21:32 | 2024-06-27T18:21:32 | Vipul Gupta, David Pantoja, Candace Ross, Adina Williams, Megan Ung | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) have grown in prevalence, particular
benchmarks have become essential for the evaluation of these models and for
understanding model capabilities. Most commonly, we use test accuracy averaged
across multiple subtasks in order to rank models on leaderboards, to determine
which model is best for our purposes. In this paper, we investigate the
robustness of the accuracy measurement on a widely used multiple choice
question answering dataset, MMLU. When shuffling the answer label contents, we
find that all explored models decrease in accuracy on MMLU, but not every model
is equally sensitive. These findings suggest a possible adjustment to the
standard practice of leaderboard testing, where we additionally consider the
percentage of examples each model answers correctly by random chance. | [
-0.2954673469,
-0.947476387,
0.5038996935,
-0.070323728,
-0.0024321829,
0.0656881332,
0.0682344884,
-0.5779307485,
0.0929799452,
0.1544857919,
-0.5695306063,
-0.2530087829,
-0.8355882764,
0.1886087507,
-0.3715248406,
0.8702311516,
-0.0461361334,
0.227846235,
-0.4515379071,
-0.7031425238,
-0.5956088901,
-0.7104910016,
-0.650167644,
-0.5722341537,
0.8690511584,
0.2804686427,
1.2099876404,
0.5868857503,
0.5949960947,
0.2655028701,
-0.4188029766,
0.1893630028,
-0.6641827822,
0.065822795,
0.1251944751,
-0.9441975355,
-1.0068763494,
0.3267933428,
0.4142798483,
0.656031251,
-0.4099502563,
0.5582899451,
0.0689051524,
0.4276677072,
-0.4034641385,
-0.0465129018,
-0.8329004049,
-0.2598715425,
-0.1265002936,
-0.3216098845,
-0.6799234748,
-0.2972253859,
-0.0867907852,
-0.4368931651,
0.0496786535,
0.0784951672,
0.7843753099,
0.2592499256,
-0.167450875,
-0.208193019,
-0.507393837,
0.9672039747,
-0.8731964827,
0.5519580841,
0.6646133661,
0.5093973279,
-0.1881125718,
-0.3733079135,
-0.1597796977,
-0.1352532804,
0.2215702981,
0.2007805854,
0.1490974873,
-0.1938347518,
0.2170058936,
0.1439888179,
-0.4441169798,
0.4753388464,
-0.2053479403,
-0.0568981767,
0.743863225,
0.4133716524,
-0.0088976398,
0.2269296199,
-0.0113847461,
-0.231189087,
-0.8138269186,
0.5006035566,
0.6629007459,
0.2525920272,
0.3053587079,
0.7463051677,
-0.0674745291,
0.830532074,
0.2114291191,
-0.6845990419,
0.2669686079,
-0.0804686174,
-0.439062655,
-0.3140151799,
0.2953080833,
0.6962130666,
0.0234711803,
0.1318625361,
-0.1614860296,
-0.2493247539,
0.2633197308,
-0.6486340761,
-0.2506476045,
0.5501541495,
-0.4658293128,
-0.4586755633,
0.0133118378,
-0.2609236836,
-0.2543211877,
-0.1751323193,
0.2308240235,
-0.2134948224,
0.0880437195,
-0.0539016314,
0.2061021775,
0.2119835317,
0.6915768981,
-0.8779785037,
0.0944552869,
0.6814630628,
0.6380567551,
-0.3493515551,
-0.6472178102,
-0.8401195407,
-0.2384571582,
-0.675645709,
0.6518332362,
-0.4571733475,
-0.4168747067,
-0.3728569448,
-0.0557003617,
-0.3306387961,
-0.8158248067,
0.4801456332,
-0.7893149257,
0.1491247416,
-0.4757887721,
-0.6621824503,
0.0451264754,
0.3121190369,
-0.6035988927,
0.9396074414,
-0.1027834639,
-0.6519780159,
0.5480020046,
-0.1518557966,
-0.1471121013,
-0.3561834991,
-0.0344145149,
-0.5435339212,
0.0429235511,
0.3683099747,
0.3960096836,
0.1797055304,
0.185133785,
-0.5489425063,
-0.5152888298,
0.8018215299,
-0.536157012,
1.0072764158,
0.1407618523,
0.1837724,
0.1900224239,
-0.4776408076,
0.1259090751,
-0.1191750988,
-0.8080890775,
-0.2596879601,
0.110250853,
-0.1498093605,
0.2496552914,
0.1142591238,
-0.3851362169,
0.0995637998,
-0.0185092594,
0.0474009402,
1.1975917816,
-0.233607769,
0.3442652822,
-0.9390929937,
0.6330248117,
-0.0083131138,
0.3133897185,
0.4217821062,
-1.3465898037,
-0.535153985,
0.1803462952,
0.3478439748,
0.6382266283,
-0.4193537831,
0.2145508528,
-0.4150227904,
-0.4992524087,
-0.9390746951,
0.3589430451,
0.0625993386,
0.4236775339,
0.3545431495,
-0.0117201302,
-0.045899272,
-0.7120121717,
-0.2385573834,
-0.4605068266,
-0.0793594271,
0.3954740167,
0.279579103,
-0.0905543715,
0.6049959064,
-0.5629187822,
0.224453494,
-0.2705392241,
0.0494478457,
0.5073117018,
0.1418849677,
0.5308462381,
-0.8304440379,
-0.3468845487,
-0.2033424824,
-0.3096564114,
-0.1093276292,
-0.0044928393,
-0.1240210384,
0.3789192736,
0.4562550485,
-0.528146565,
0.3060806394,
0.7750536203,
-0.1261204034,
0.7803836465,
-0.1946329325,
0.3699756265,
-1.0062038898,
-0.0561606176,
-0.4248568416,
-0.0899744481,
-0.6495496035,
0.3796461225,
0.2502137423,
0.2760262191,
-0.414576292,
0.3558741212,
-0.1096069068,
-0.093802169,
-0.0992212594,
0.0325741768,
0.0064611509,
0.0893883482,
-0.4756112099,
0.9761501551,
0.2100714147,
-0.7142635584,
0.2892990112,
0.2569695115,
-0.5482067466,
0.5423547626,
-0.3678124845,
0.1939988434,
-0.2280496806,
-0.1769709587,
-1.221532464,
-0.1202046722,
-0.1431622654,
-0.5654509664,
0.2228942811,
-0.0141686331,
-0.4662871361,
-0.4081295133,
-0.2820739448,
0.0084328372,
0.4655647278,
-0.5200244188,
0.0993877053,
0.2458038032,
-0.1834758371,
-0.9410247803,
-0.7977778316,
-0.2561036646,
-0.2204154432,
-0.5894631147,
0.1308676898,
-0.8952989578,
-0.4245769083,
-0.482567966,
-0.4032317102,
-0.1690895557,
0.5538991094,
0.0554306693,
0.2844732702,
-0.3614751697,
0.3370192945,
-0.0781476125,
0.1579854488,
-0.0196698681,
0.3713670671,
0.4438714087,
0.0799846128,
-0.4378288388,
-0.0465353243,
0.1386587769,
0.9148085713,
-0.1556733102,
0.9489307404,
0.1953141093,
-0.0611950085,
-0.0477174297,
-0.3919995427,
-0.1109073535,
-0.5043032765,
0.3125461638,
-0.6909743547,
-0.7966720462,
0.94548738,
0.5937691927,
0.6682246923,
0.2649153471,
0.6017505527,
-0.4611593187,
1.1277549267,
0.4690992832,
-0.0945683867,
0.2370994985,
0.3260459304,
0.2834038436,
-0.6803908348,
0.0379508995,
-0.5435675383,
-0.4957339764,
-0.6986220479,
-0.4300557077,
0.2273493558,
0.0132670579,
0.1478159875,
0.0215110295,
-0.2196752131,
0.4587551951,
0.4411584437,
0.4227534235,
0.4857171476,
-0.0650156513,
-0.0705102161,
-0.0843283981,
-0.6825861335,
-0.4031442106,
1.212854743,
0.3622392714,
1.1229890585,
0.388055563,
0.4109882414,
0.0057888729,
0.6208856106,
-0.7969252467,
0.5125740767,
-0.1970396191,
-0.7067904472,
-0.7275713086,
-0.3907172978,
-0.865321517,
0.3593901694,
-0.0612697005,
-0.621289134,
0.0736148506,
-0.0816402882,
-0.6060177088,
0.4078947902,
-0.5060017705,
0.5550459027,
-0.0331110582,
0.0739313737,
0.3691061437,
-0.3669234812,
0.3509186208,
-0.2504715323,
0.1844805926,
-0.3518061638,
0.0109956963,
0.743483901,
-0.2822335064,
0.6415751576,
0.2711639106,
-0.3155986667,
0.2292495221,
0.0572116859,
0.4419823587,
-0.035525091,
-0.6799830198,
-0.1435386389,
-0.1612894535,
-0.642092526,
-0.6585556269,
0.7849283218,
-0.8718634844,
-0.8604852557,
-0.1485811919,
-0.8836787939,
-0.2116582394,
-0.1536792815,
0.3459627926,
0.3700440228,
-0.0266914032,
0.1632714719,
0.6774471998,
-0.021649247,
0.5218581557,
0.3312381804,
-0.4532769322,
-0.1233298406,
0.2830518782,
0.8084076643,
0.508693397,
0.2375112325,
0.3199990392,
-0.3947254121,
-0.8900651932,
-0.5038285851,
-0.0505733117,
-1.0114309788,
-0.0519423857,
-0.4934225082,
-0.2438091487,
-0.5842466354,
-0.2360231876,
-0.1556897312,
-0.3999980986,
-0.4654016495,
-0.5547288656,
0.2931435704,
0.6569606662,
0.4930025041,
0.1548246145,
-0.4986317158,
0.2406228036,
0.7068697214,
0.295145303,
-0.120974794,
-1.0164840221,
0.0010696047,
0.0629640073,
-0.0975629017,
-1.0045627356,
0.1902430952,
0.1875966489,
0.8949941397,
0.2094483376,
0.0000678383,
0.8693839908,
-0.3299196362,
0.6018799543,
-0.1842439175,
-0.512896359,
0.4208619595,
-0.367395401,
0.8473659754,
0.6225324869,
0.2873497009,
-0.370426476,
-0.799916923,
-0.6557610631,
-0.4149056375,
0.3362420797,
0.1560067236,
0.0962122679,
0.3016947806,
0.3898810744,
0.3027746081,
0.0801196396,
-0.9045696259,
-0.6630905271,
0.1892665923,
0.0542683005,
-0.43801862,
-0.3032622933,
-0.0001583055,
-0.2718424201,
0.7928677201,
-0.2372306883,
-0.034057375,
-0.0631703064,
-0.1094786897,
-0.2866225243,
0.4839691222,
0.8647142649,
1.1835269928,
-0.5420340896,
0.0885300487,
0.4112137854,
-0.7013279796,
0.3033803105,
-0.0674001947,
-0.4686495364,
0.1941576004,
0.267177999,
0.3326976597,
-0.0058641722,
-0.421435982,
0.2183508128,
-0.0420817211,
-0.0922087207,
0.1555342972,
0.1338426173,
0.3320761919,
-0.1487226039,
0.3610474169,
0.2563092113,
-0.0710991621,
-0.5575324893,
0.525180459,
0.2539583445,
-0.2152280509,
0.0359829031,
0.6403585672,
-0.1533019245,
-0.4958208203,
0.5280791521,
0.0503038764,
-0.1861638874,
0.8169850111,
0.4225583673,
0.3707769215,
-0.8372226954,
0.3759753108,
0.2764629424,
0.7203611732,
-0.1468939334,
0.3032197058,
0.5083617568,
-0.8710561991,
-0.4387651384,
-0.5979143381,
-0.6537352204,
0.3689310551,
-0.7990248799,
0.0545588546,
-0.5661503077,
-0.52697438,
0.1548497379,
-0.1615398377,
-0.3446374536,
0.2178156078,
0.0428178161,
0.597484231,
-0.8839954138,
0.9952247739,
0.9270132184,
0.0896554813,
-0.6926640272,
-0.1708536148,
0.0241880957,
-0.7053720355,
0.3218063712,
0.2574945688,
0.1011102945,
-0.3687052131,
-0.6258514524,
-1.0397078991,
1.1427838802,
0.2579172552,
-0.4345126152,
0.3386648595,
0.1301976442,
0.623573184,
-0.3124478757,
0.3858335912,
0.4358453751,
0.2325327843,
0.0966177806,
-1.0564024448,
-0.1507058144,
-0.0699111372,
-0.1522850096,
0.1868238598,
-0.6516309381,
1.1486327648,
-0.5032477975,
0.098169066,
0.14698264,
0.5166683197,
0.6958440542,
0.2256371528,
0.4049409032,
0.5122022629,
1.1953172684,
-0.0571664087,
0.9872018695,
0.3790875077,
0.3105217516,
1.4729709625,
-0.3433564007,
1.1511776447,
0.5955384374,
-0.3034978807,
0.1480749547,
0.9975315332,
-0.0611834303,
0.3383809924,
0.1633003056,
0.1622471511,
-0.5002554655,
0.3431619704,
-0.1163729429,
0.3918260932,
0.1314895898,
-0.2921207249,
-0.2187246829,
-0.0644953027,
0.118093729,
-0.1233069301,
-0.2882499099,
0.3784542084,
0.0303647816,
-0.7014940977,
0.7716087103,
-0.0753770322,
0.5229904056,
-0.1956912279,
0.1244233847,
-0.5676517487,
0.0409723222,
-0.1189035401,
-0.9955250025,
0.0991888568,
-0.2123270035,
-0.2610316873,
-0.3277862072,
0.3645695448,
-0.3532680571,
-0.7097651362,
0.2955450416,
0.7919682264,
0.1548775882,
0.2238292247,
-0.9751752615,
-0.0896911025,
0.0191903394,
-0.4181260169,
0.4642076492,
-0.121723935,
0.0120323189,
1.0235155821,
0.7372198105,
-0.2337166816,
0.6742085814,
0.1107964516,
0.463057667,
-0.0344600379,
-0.5014244318,
-0.7622841001,
0.382070154,
-0.2243105471,
-0.5221480727,
0.923617661,
0.3777364194,
0.8462150693,
-0.0256788582,
0.3180798292,
0.2358187139,
0.4834291339,
-0.6443530321,
0.9904909134,
-0.5511797667,
0.557897687,
-0.0916080177,
-1.0280202627,
-0.3479659557,
0.2927199006,
-0.2159105241,
-0.0569531843,
0.7161412239,
0.8265479207,
0.0079426114,
-0.0904347897,
0.9897138476,
0.4613085687,
0.3284091353,
0.3237903118,
0.6986855268,
-0.6861166358,
0.6326436996,
-0.3396196365,
-0.0549237914,
-0.2065714151,
-0.5211058855,
-1.0030664206,
-0.362649411,
-0.5103344321,
-0.3286772668,
0.1525140703,
0.4155133367,
0.5509187579,
-1.0372151136,
-0.3610281348,
0.5720463395,
0.4055144191,
-0.5097523928,
-0.1744158715,
0.3496466577,
-0.1339930594,
-0.5515132546,
0.3869357705,
0.0042655566,
0.2942829132,
0.1609512269,
0.0748697743,
-0.5032467246,
0.245687291,
0.5399801731,
-0.1484843791,
-0.9065054059,
-0.5921794772,
0.4753187299,
-0.3871097565,
0.5467734337,
0.317658186,
-0.2482213974,
0.379258424,
0.6100168228,
0.5410939455,
0.052993916,
0.3030396998,
0.2852478623,
-0.6054736376,
-0.2808849216,
0.0442135446,
0.3854314685,
0.2611759603,
-0.3856856525,
0.482418716,
0.0221531056,
-0.7271986008,
-0.656554997,
0.1821570098,
-0.8910617828,
-0.4377523363,
1.1989881992,
-0.1875431538,
-0.2446343899,
-0.3648399413,
-0.0793506876,
-0.2454824895,
-0.294262141,
0.7566850185,
1.3388524055,
-0.3794766068,
-0.3766926825,
-0.8583328128,
0.3928262293,
0.6797972918,
-0.7683864832,
0.1212781295,
0.2391686887,
0.4801619649,
0.3198868632,
0.6690789461,
0.0065156966,
0.3968785405,
-0.2013947219,
-0.482367903,
0.3239774108,
-0.4163134992,
-0.3786557615,
0.3958577514,
0.4399739802,
-0.1124321446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19465v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19465v1 | Can Large Language Models Generate High-quality Patent Claims? | 2024-06-27T18:07:40 | 2024-06-27T18:07:40 | Lekang Jiang, Caiqi Zhang, Pascal A Scherz, Stephan Goetz | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown exceptional performance across
various text generation tasks but remain under-explored in the patent domain,
which offers highly structured and precise language. This paper constructs a
dataset to investigate the performance of current LLMs in patent claim
generation. Our results demonstrate that generating claims based on patent
descriptions outperforms previous research relying on abstracts. Interestingly,
current patent-specific LLMs perform much worse than state-of-the-art general
LLMs, highlighting the necessity for future research on in-domain LLMs. We also
find that LLMs can produce high-quality first independent claims, but their
performances markedly decrease for subsequent dependent claims. Moreover,
fine-tuning can enhance the completeness of inventions' features, conceptual
clarity, and feature linkage. Among the tested LLMs, GPT-4 demonstrates the
best performance in comprehensive human evaluations by patent experts, with
better feature coverage, conceptual clarity, and technical coherence. Despite
these capabilities, comprehensive revision and modification are still necessary
to pass rigorous patent scrutiny and ensure legal robustness. | [
-0.0679422542,
-0.4489767551,
0.6672207117,
0.2097385675,
-0.0851293132,
0.24017106,
-0.2464645356,
-0.7652289271,
0.1360560954,
0.5654148459,
0.1207076684,
-0.4270220995,
-0.6346586347,
0.1847249269,
-0.3122494519,
0.699398756,
-0.010897289,
-0.243407771,
-0.1959509552,
0.3288574815,
-0.4346649647,
-0.7279574275,
-0.278449595,
-0.5328576565,
0.4026572406,
0.2191851884,
0.448230058,
0.5274161696,
0.3488678336,
0.3039271832,
-0.2830421925,
0.1022021472,
-0.1068661213,
0.1200884879,
-0.0917388424,
-0.4006680548,
-0.6686317325,
0.031326171,
0.6543645263,
0.6592185497,
-0.0032709213,
0.0644564703,
0.2554787695,
0.3166798651,
-0.4134637713,
0.1620122194,
-1.0494045019,
0.0399750285,
-0.4693707228,
-0.1968833357,
-0.5624191761,
-0.1581245512,
0.3730939031,
-0.4605484605,
0.4888746142,
0.3428120017,
1.3118574619,
-0.1443853974,
-0.2412747443,
-0.2912511826,
-0.4962215126,
0.6582362056,
-0.9790459275,
-0.0834715217,
0.1712105721,
0.0857123733,
-0.4321178496,
-1.0674592257,
-0.5523457527,
-0.5537459254,
0.1640989035,
-0.2774735689,
-0.3108684719,
0.0317610651,
0.4562523067,
0.362798512,
-0.5926389694,
0.6134287119,
-0.4477462769,
-0.4705591798,
0.6376850605,
-0.0303511936,
0.2201863527,
-0.3789294362,
-0.2986794412,
0.1070293859,
-1.3634157181,
-0.0898700431,
0.4266712666,
0.3204339743,
0.1506256759,
0.8242260814,
-0.174894318,
0.4946203232,
-0.128573209,
-0.221403107,
0.158581093,
-0.2452066243,
-0.2757009864,
0.2085496038,
0.842318356,
0.1840848178,
0.2850188613,
-0.1972623616,
-0.4369286299,
-0.4824585915,
-0.0291050132,
-1.0917268991,
-0.0519252867,
0.2012156993,
-0.4824855626,
-0.1731653512,
0.0114529971,
-0.4329217672,
-0.6394653916,
-0.2257067263,
0.4497451484,
-0.1858048588,
-0.2295550555,
0.3673679531,
-0.1236485243,
0.065450564,
-0.0225830246,
-0.9141462445,
0.0683973432,
0.9039753079,
0.8271785378,
-0.0695462227,
-0.2525827289,
-0.4031850696,
0.2339850515,
-0.6972571015,
0.9771137834,
-0.193686083,
-0.3636072576,
0.0452260524,
-0.1790848076,
0.0600064099,
-1.045596242,
0.6481995583,
-0.5903353095,
-0.0174185932,
-0.2838927805,
-0.5656710267,
0.303558439,
0.1225835308,
-0.5680112839,
0.3777887523,
-0.1883447915,
-0.7541261315,
0.8327692151,
-0.4689977765,
-0.6662469506,
0.3181081414,
-0.4295510352,
-0.5006219149,
0.3902847469,
0.0729211569,
0.6214310527,
-0.6817688942,
0.4737048149,
-0.1110171378,
-0.0250681825,
0.4922896922,
-0.2258266658,
0.4120777249,
0.3585333824,
-0.5080930591,
0.0091812918,
-0.6889685392,
0.0393489189,
0.3312038481,
-0.423812598,
-0.1059425697,
0.0376837924,
-0.3470234275,
0.2931072712,
0.5466215014,
-0.9019407034,
0.0572182201,
-0.611887753,
0.6977462173,
0.7889835238,
-0.0150451129,
-0.1150986478,
-0.2525788546,
0.5179047585,
-0.1675858498,
-0.1210776269,
-0.3868300617,
-0.6156290174,
-0.5980751514,
-0.3897704482,
0.6423125863,
0.1505911499,
-0.5681409836,
0.4337361753,
-0.4905851185,
-0.1832342893,
-0.1417274922,
0.0517649464,
0.4617425799,
0.3865180016,
-0.0743978173,
-0.3515426517,
-0.4245156348,
-1.1767002344,
-0.3207280636,
-0.1954391003,
-0.2354572415,
0.4134541154,
0.4395771027,
0.0840661079,
0.8730944395,
-0.5006922483,
-0.1485295743,
-0.2692328691,
0.3183960021,
0.3921796978,
0.0606415942,
0.6274312139,
-0.5572632551,
-0.4545058012,
0.289232105,
-0.5851265192,
-0.2644871175,
-0.0044511892,
0.1460590214,
0.370223999,
0.264206171,
-0.9093974233,
0.0781460553,
0.2661030889,
-0.2882876098,
0.7330750823,
-0.3927056491,
-0.014037542,
-1.0237412453,
0.2511391938,
0.110384725,
0.0094837258,
-0.3564813137,
-0.1218596324,
0.0859609768,
-0.2456830293,
-0.4823671877,
0.6592925787,
-0.5957911015,
-0.1090425178,
-0.4914236963,
-0.1059684902,
0.2099672556,
-0.1786296219,
-0.36567536,
0.8941007257,
0.6343638897,
-0.5252476335,
0.2963156402,
0.0610801801,
-0.7169288993,
0.0678126439,
-0.92400527,
-0.0409285948,
0.1738344133,
0.1707483232,
-0.8248940706,
-0.5914139748,
-0.4651284516,
-0.2139396667,
0.5798479915,
0.0288663376,
-0.9435774088,
-0.7708817124,
-0.1977253258,
-0.0866170451,
0.5479328036,
-0.7364264727,
0.2728559673,
0.3788533509,
-0.8263519406,
-0.4813999236,
-0.7386246324,
0.6384937763,
-0.3166243732,
-0.7884579897,
0.5651402473,
0.350353092,
-0.1307981312,
-0.2079617381,
0.0371737815,
-0.0921330303,
-0.0819239467,
0.0735773519,
0.1730347276,
-0.274587512,
0.0541143753,
-0.049547106,
-0.1033584028,
0.2046970874,
-0.2046354115,
0.5433251858,
0.215791434,
-0.303229779,
-0.4188517928,
0.1736603975,
0.5452167988,
-0.1030185446,
0.2047850043,
-0.0836412087,
-0.3643057644,
-0.355340004,
-0.6370987296,
0.0692321286,
-0.5102750659,
0.3705607951,
-0.6045942903,
-1.0085378885,
0.4427123964,
-0.1328667849,
0.2111146301,
0.8008882403,
0.5760710835,
0.2231711149,
0.9165598154,
0.5077722073,
-0.1149283275,
0.154962644,
-0.0511133596,
0.6142513156,
-0.4954799414,
-0.2048334926,
-0.7598502636,
-0.0655720979,
-0.4918392599,
-0.1279456615,
0.1647785455,
0.061392583,
-0.196270898,
0.3191374838,
-0.5791675448,
0.490714848,
0.6307023168,
-0.154161036,
0.3929438293,
0.4221740961,
-0.3934073746,
-0.1733355224,
-0.4915343225,
-0.9355087876,
1.4578237534,
0.565705657,
0.8859810829,
-0.0524517708,
0.5894785523,
0.3160707951,
0.3013672233,
-0.5019640326,
0.5379052758,
-0.2952536643,
-0.6005135179,
0.0305136498,
-0.3707024455,
-0.9409080744,
0.1174493581,
-0.0830167606,
-0.6349298358,
0.1130560189,
0.2533361614,
-0.5578637123,
0.2081011087,
-0.7988644838,
0.5673870444,
-0.6540782452,
-0.4061875343,
-0.242555961,
-0.243926838,
0.5856924057,
-0.6183384061,
-0.2159816176,
-0.1584146321,
0.2397831231,
0.7369788885,
-0.5375927091,
0.7969433665,
-0.1927327365,
-0.5809830427,
0.4274532199,
-0.1149890721,
0.5139783025,
-0.1597614437,
-0.2810079455,
-0.0226939321,
-0.2350845933,
-0.1729050726,
-0.3000116944,
0.8305956721,
-0.2469768673,
-0.7150247693,
-0.3072770536,
-0.3748530149,
-0.2099970877,
0.3916192055,
0.5571351051,
0.4266141057,
-0.2049501389,
0.1470089555,
0.4423828423,
-0.6416944265,
0.3933026195,
0.3343042135,
-0.1392974406,
-0.4456755817,
1.0766359568,
0.2869764864,
0.1931295991,
0.0823052377,
0.2563494146,
-0.5548803806,
-0.9732629061,
-0.2845247388,
0.2735211551,
-0.4720750153,
-0.3216909766,
-0.624119699,
-0.3093717396,
-0.5270798206,
0.2013472915,
-0.2713920772,
-0.6375937462,
0.0754267573,
-0.010572236,
0.0785920769,
0.9594379663,
0.0956827626,
0.0660240799,
-0.6302905679,
0.3393842578,
0.532330215,
0.4392446876,
-0.1726296544,
-0.441983968,
-0.2428757399,
-0.0410830192,
-0.8424653411,
-0.0749894381,
0.391476661,
0.3321014643,
0.6558502316,
0.265539676,
-0.1447034031,
0.4348248839,
-0.8074552417,
1.0153257847,
0.3011883497,
-0.7292234898,
0.4101069868,
-0.2958914042,
-0.141998589,
-0.0454184301,
0.053439483,
0.0520516187,
-0.2387195826,
-0.5610119104,
-1.0091398954,
0.341894567,
0.0749934986,
0.378418088,
-0.0257076453,
0.3749388456,
0.1486442238,
0.140860498,
-0.5058893561,
0.3083065152,
0.1823183149,
-0.0457680002,
0.1574117839,
-0.3028798997,
-0.071012713,
0.1043966711,
0.5429619551,
-0.0367167182,
0.2348662019,
0.1219717115,
0.1846787483,
-0.0211820677,
0.4608575404,
0.7959122062,
0.8781682849,
0.0846375525,
0.1329247057,
-0.0987934992,
-0.3172653615,
0.1105338261,
0.4024497569,
-0.0317319185,
0.1519847661,
0.3805052638,
0.6284519434,
-0.0805158541,
-0.9197968841,
0.596593976,
-0.0514006093,
-0.5208978653,
0.1505119354,
0.1343583912,
0.0222156905,
0.2817192376,
0.6166650653,
-0.1981702298,
0.1405201554,
-0.3777264357,
0.2477113754,
0.4982381463,
0.3734866679,
-0.3452385664,
0.7470985651,
0.1623902321,
-0.054385636,
0.08465942,
0.0589606352,
-0.4067189991,
0.6944096684,
0.7462201118,
0.9027852416,
0.0699672252,
-0.0685234591,
0.1232240498,
0.2122297585,
-0.3455225527,
0.0820944533,
0.1619473696,
-0.517835021,
-0.6937816143,
-0.4702557921,
-0.6134769917,
0.3723577857,
-0.0234264545,
0.1422171593,
-0.4473536909,
-0.519108355,
0.1931203902,
-0.0585125089,
-0.4967876375,
-0.0331950523,
0.1018377766,
0.7268870473,
-0.4979831874,
0.5981505513,
0.4994409382,
-0.173398003,
-0.7293064594,
0.070952557,
-0.2537967861,
-0.4525876343,
0.9981557131,
0.1544498354,
-0.0601815954,
-0.1695632637,
-0.7114353776,
-0.6839566827,
0.9258162975,
0.831581533,
-0.5732200146,
-0.0927258357,
0.5654376149,
0.4880416691,
-0.3205076158,
-0.3700471818,
0.3416146636,
0.2681907415,
0.0751541108,
-1.2754791975,
0.0255384333,
-0.1472248286,
0.2298087925,
-0.129062131,
-0.479957372,
0.8735833168,
-0.3562059999,
-0.3035186231,
0.4134748578,
0.555888772,
0.5915464759,
0.208359614,
0.0314588062,
0.5050709844,
0.8544076085,
-0.1393761933,
1.1696375608,
-0.4686667323,
0.1270371675,
1.1672819853,
-0.7472758889,
0.9456180334,
0.1164405495,
-0.0515985265,
0.0699183792,
0.4760859907,
-0.0285959747,
0.2602002323,
0.5820506811,
-0.2608144879,
-0.0939427018,
-0.2439342737,
-0.4140514731,
0.2753579021,
0.2819843292,
-0.7222277522,
-0.1014749184,
-0.1018805727,
-0.0035722209,
-0.0804128721,
0.0414393879,
0.5746870041,
0.1950359792,
-0.7637251019,
0.8730624914,
0.1518610716,
0.7777311802,
-0.3797881901,
-0.0219082646,
-0.0521422699,
0.2209200114,
-0.1901648045,
-0.8114336133,
-0.21416758,
0.445428282,
-0.0805155411,
-0.1590553224,
0.7588873506,
-0.0657137334,
-0.3015238047,
-0.0211453084,
0.2925177813,
0.2116338462,
0.0244664699,
-0.279430449,
-0.1459472775,
-0.2262300402,
-0.3663413823,
0.2676753402,
0.673163712,
-0.1469613463,
0.6217417717,
0.5323907733,
0.5163848996,
0.4619990885,
0.1591247618,
0.8228960037,
-0.6668639779,
-0.1435187906,
-0.7277367711,
0.3503683507,
-0.3081719279,
-0.3408491015,
0.6041589379,
0.8855333924,
0.458866179,
-0.0759189874,
1.0862438679,
0.0280020535,
0.5472460985,
-0.7097135186,
0.8780503273,
-0.2273955196,
0.3121025264,
-0.2188305855,
-0.8551276326,
-0.5720999837,
0.2949490845,
-0.1675844043,
0.0702794865,
0.5789512992,
0.7455533147,
0.0475615785,
-0.2283898443,
0.4230868816,
0.5016595721,
0.9263507724,
0.3825041652,
0.8732503057,
-0.3155165315,
0.3647550642,
0.1814636886,
-0.1087251008,
-0.0133524518,
-1.0153573751,
-0.66838485,
-0.2002285272,
-0.2279176712,
-0.3592361808,
-0.1202518418,
0.708838284,
0.7021095753,
-0.7144328952,
-0.0963181853,
-0.1135697141,
-0.3249420524,
0.4194668233,
-0.1550540626,
0.5332177877,
-0.5229468346,
-0.5717925429,
0.4507843852,
0.3752085567,
0.1697942019,
-0.1751370728,
-0.0624387451,
0.3162980378,
0.0893839151,
0.8616048098,
0.4272833765,
-0.8412626386,
-0.1563621759,
-0.056987863,
-0.2892543375,
0.0736622289,
1.0055463314,
-0.435493499,
0.4066488445,
0.4793980122,
0.8302608132,
0.3852007091,
-0.0948565602,
0.7395427823,
-0.6202207208,
0.0409300327,
0.2254449874,
0.650372684,
0.359315604,
-0.1593932658,
0.1468935162,
0.0930912644,
-0.7634325624,
-0.7802192569,
0.1271027029,
-0.6702073812,
-0.1262722909,
1.2431348562,
-0.1867552847,
-0.1460167021,
-0.0518461317,
-0.3492540717,
-0.1789830327,
-0.2448750138,
0.8155727386,
0.8925172091,
-0.2390776128,
0.2111752331,
-0.6298341751,
0.3185533881,
0.255622983,
-0.7563068867,
0.3104557097,
0.5591838956,
0.3947297335,
0.2170507312,
0.4821689427,
-0.5566053987,
0.1090630069,
-0.2134459764,
0.2382831872,
-0.0478522182,
-0.3752726316,
-0.2315834463,
0.3662863374,
0.9026140571,
-0.0459349491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19388v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19388v1 | Taming Data and Transformers for Audio Generation | 2024-06-27T17:58:54 | 2024-06-27T17:58:54 | Moayed Haji-Ali, Willi Menapace, Aliaksandr Siarohin, Guha Balakrishnan, Sergey Tulyakov, Vicente Ordonez | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM, eess.AS | Generating ambient sounds and effects is a challenging problem due to data
scarcity and often insufficient caption quality, making it difficult to employ
large-scale generative models for the task. In this work, we tackle the problem
by introducing two new models. First, we propose AutoCap, a high-quality and
efficient automatic audio captioning model. We show that by leveraging metadata
available with the audio modality, we can substantially improve the quality of
captions. AutoCap reaches CIDEr score of 83.2, marking a 3.2% improvement from
the best available captioning model at four times faster inference speed. We
then use AutoCap to caption clips from existing datasets, obtaining 761,000
audio clips with high-quality captions, forming the largest available
audio-text dataset. Second, we propose GenAu, a scalable transformer-based
audio generation architecture that we scale up to 1.25B parameters and train
with our new dataset. When compared to state-of-the-art audio generators, GenAu
obtains significant improvements of 15.7% in FAD score, 22.7% in IS, and 13.5%
in CLAP score, indicating significantly improved quality of generated audio
compared to previous works. This shows that the quality of data is often as
important as its quantity. Besides, since AutoCap is fully automatic, new audio
samples can be added to the training dataset, unlocking the training of even
larger generative models for audio synthesis. | [
-0.7766627073,
-0.6043565869,
0.2714280784,
0.2571496964,
-0.1227630302,
0.3463197649,
0.0220418032,
-0.4583424032,
0.0695786402,
0.6033875346,
-0.6378999949,
-0.3406114876,
-0.465367347,
0.1203668192,
-0.8320067525,
0.6623582244,
0.1211219132,
-0.3536193371,
-0.0444468632,
0.0217627455,
-0.9242780209,
-0.3961665332,
-0.5805012584,
-0.0333044231,
-0.2108637393,
0.3551995456,
0.8051977754,
0.887865603,
0.4556134641,
0.3252445757,
0.2012488842,
0.2076895237,
-0.0935004875,
0.2786553502,
0.3504675925,
-0.2114262581,
-0.3588437736,
0.081867747,
0.3932745755,
0.2250488847,
-0.313003093,
0.162338838,
-0.148482129,
0.4960440993,
-0.2639914751,
0.2556346059,
-0.861318171,
0.3246708214,
0.0192050058,
-0.4974591136,
-0.2675815225,
0.1070787162,
-0.2311398983,
-0.7787757516,
0.6168419719,
0.440716207,
1.0248076916,
0.8230236769,
0.0319920294,
-0.3683382869,
-1.1709171534,
0.5361411572,
-0.6332595348,
0.4352997243,
0.3236735463,
0.5698776245,
0.0676469207,
-0.8256230354,
-0.7072318792,
-0.1695363969,
0.0165367816,
0.4097150266,
-0.6268507838,
-0.0228011496,
0.3287868202,
1.0935424566,
-0.2200933546,
0.0831283778,
-0.5698572993,
-0.2146894336,
0.8781349659,
0.4016312361,
0.5104967952,
-0.4920246899,
-0.3724423051,
-0.409806788,
-0.7959734797,
0.0752332583,
0.8057323694,
0.2462444752,
-0.1028383821,
0.4492749572,
-0.0512992777,
0.4422144294,
0.5295220017,
0.1386333704,
0.1098995507,
-0.581289053,
-0.1718767285,
0.0564168729,
1.0338468552,
0.2985236049,
-0.1463894993,
-0.1823459715,
-0.4409495294,
-0.0191371348,
0.6319373846,
-0.6629985571,
-0.6622591615,
0.3313994408,
-0.3094177842,
-0.3550038934,
0.2028319687,
-1.0251755714,
0.0872456431,
-0.8395931721,
0.6781012416,
-0.3840282857,
-0.0986607596,
-0.0397803821,
-0.2569829822,
0.0974006429,
-0.0618170984,
-1.0121358633,
0.3504408002,
0.1707023233,
0.8263025284,
-0.4215249419,
0.118781276,
-0.573674202,
0.2657296062,
-0.3788692653,
0.7386653423,
-0.2237558365,
-0.6150099635,
-0.238140285,
-0.1196175441,
0.20790115,
-0.8337641358,
0.514025569,
-0.2508099973,
0.2653792799,
0.0221996345,
-0.3026915789,
0.1623486876,
-0.6739495397,
-0.9995586872,
1.0464687347,
0.2570422888,
-0.2027812749,
0.5048561692,
-1.0326635838,
-0.6790341735,
0.0711885616,
0.1137154549,
-0.771966815,
0.1370996386,
0.7054078579,
0.2459721863,
-0.2137914002,
0.4529833198,
0.1642111838,
-0.3075874746,
0.1646099091,
-0.6969667673,
0.5417719483,
0.6755447984,
-0.6239940524,
0.0843951553,
-0.6554353833,
-0.4230689704,
-0.0429388545,
-0.0111271637,
0.2051585019,
-0.1398627609,
0.3873211741,
0.162520647,
-0.4858162999,
-0.4874364138,
-0.2508275211,
-0.3671117425,
0.7818797827,
0.6276449561,
0.2988878191,
0.4400720894,
-0.6463464499,
0.706124723,
-0.1711280346,
0.2272663713,
-0.5459699631,
-0.3436267376,
-0.5146034956,
-0.662782073,
0.2509074807,
0.2220930904,
-0.4899375141,
0.7351384163,
-0.0408162139,
-0.530362606,
-1.1021586657,
0.0444800481,
-0.135607183,
0.3132666647,
0.6155653596,
-0.4527890086,
-0.8715490103,
-0.7866861224,
0.0252757054,
-0.0135469707,
-0.6104003787,
0.521620512,
0.1876797378,
-0.1606276631,
1.233045578,
-0.5120264292,
-0.5439099073,
0.056194298,
0.4734936059,
0.2416287065,
0.7267767191,
0.6802816391,
-0.654771924,
-0.4915240407,
-0.519133389,
-0.5386661291,
-0.5507327318,
-0.4191322327,
-0.0947630405,
-0.1154913679,
0.7315504551,
-0.8649349213,
0.0640451163,
0.4043469429,
0.1264006048,
0.7266770601,
0.0722953901,
0.3630712628,
-0.9168906808,
0.0643481165,
-0.4379183948,
-0.1752761602,
-0.5480128527,
0.0234520733,
-0.5752403736,
-0.6265659928,
-0.4439712465,
0.2644523382,
-0.4834820628,
-0.0449814685,
-0.556037724,
-0.0715843514,
0.3048793674,
0.3463837802,
-0.0724318326,
1.0499442816,
0.6310555339,
-0.5552968383,
0.6331601739,
0.5027324557,
-0.5382628441,
0.4829486012,
-0.851208508,
0.1938821971,
-0.0888480246,
0.3453669548,
-1.1638981104,
-0.4507305622,
-0.0068294294,
-0.6524441242,
0.3725843132,
0.1508341581,
-0.9420835972,
-0.4953057468,
0.0988009945,
0.3321514428,
0.8940758109,
-0.953582406,
0.7482295632,
0.6005528569,
-0.2789187133,
0.2023092806,
-0.6634792686,
0.3455894589,
-0.6096372008,
-0.3922840357,
0.6042229533,
-0.3214409947,
-0.1819939166,
-0.0508915484,
-0.1558084041,
0.0140479123,
-0.1847755164,
0.5081403852,
0.3356338441,
-0.0837006792,
0.1950064451,
0.245165363,
-0.2299615294,
0.3570936322,
-0.0824938565,
0.3760754466,
0.0035201837,
-0.1386937052,
-0.5800297856,
0.3490749598,
0.9045498371,
-0.3053135276,
0.0253616292,
0.6928896308,
-0.1095560491,
-0.1896998435,
-0.5719358921,
-0.4973388612,
-0.6288331151,
0.0171729513,
-0.2965179682,
-0.5883046985,
0.4861066043,
-0.0805056319,
0.2968364358,
0.843540132,
0.3858412504,
-0.4973721802,
0.9771755338,
0.181371823,
-0.1646577418,
0.4086664319,
-0.4377832115,
0.1668046266,
-0.759644866,
-0.0628785193,
-0.3510237932,
-0.1131496355,
-0.5210183263,
-0.3570995033,
0.6296719909,
-0.2997665107,
-0.1660700738,
0.7109826803,
-0.8607239127,
0.2107368857,
0.7491565943,
-0.119134672,
0.3143089712,
0.3707262576,
0.3766006529,
0.0277923122,
-0.7255644202,
-0.1249617115,
1.100497365,
0.3749524057,
0.5779736638,
-0.0813942999,
0.4677130282,
0.7605502009,
0.1690754145,
-0.5042836666,
0.1555920988,
-0.059582416,
-0.7419475913,
-0.4761695862,
-0.2749781311,
-0.795776546,
0.080199182,
-0.4002126455,
-0.3106395602,
0.2323520929,
0.0911318585,
-0.5308769345,
0.4178016186,
-0.4552488923,
0.2997029424,
-0.0142843733,
-0.2071074992,
0.1021590009,
-0.5490897894,
0.2561386824,
-0.2666702867,
0.4155861437,
-0.1113695726,
0.5234614015,
0.5631435513,
-0.2507475317,
0.5626182556,
-0.0716717392,
-0.2887111008,
0.9283976555,
-0.0045399382,
0.3498424292,
0.1276308894,
0.1065607816,
0.3149839342,
-0.1598061174,
-0.0538280942,
-0.5595767498,
0.5676628351,
-0.7933261991,
-0.5894325972,
0.1591709107,
-1.0454087257,
-0.0551132746,
-0.2091324627,
0.712980926,
0.5854313374,
0.0405102298,
0.3455787003,
0.5252273083,
-0.3200175464,
0.7173642516,
0.4628504515,
0.2594905496,
-0.8145100474,
0.9266881943,
-0.0913935825,
0.4126371741,
0.1211427227,
0.1582600623,
-0.4162591994,
-0.1341570616,
-0.664924562,
-0.2187890261,
-0.4545923173,
-0.49633044,
-0.8150416613,
-0.263692379,
-0.4793763459,
-0.1708156317,
-0.7696666121,
-0.2897278965,
-0.2392189205,
-0.3055603206,
0.5987317562,
0.3225932419,
-0.5901373029,
0.4996906221,
-0.7028686404,
1.0570129156,
0.4052397609,
0.159841001,
-0.1268797666,
-0.7009257078,
-0.0335206017,
0.001807946,
-0.2955797315,
-0.7204619646,
0.57840693,
0.1700250655,
0.4443442523,
0.2959282696,
0.3014307916,
0.6125382781,
-0.5077365637,
0.8264523745,
0.2244631946,
-1.0740407705,
0.4403953552,
-0.3741033971,
0.4212656021,
0.5481606722,
-0.074873969,
-0.1855144948,
-0.8335992098,
-0.8597031236,
-1.0890495777,
0.5844697356,
0.7586426139,
0.5600527525,
0.0824244022,
0.0938124135,
0.4204957783,
0.3947808743,
-0.62425524,
-0.3330716193,
-0.8741328716,
-0.0794616416,
-0.0194072183,
0.1448658556,
-0.1178327128,
-0.5777273774,
0.7271531224,
0.1164189652,
0.5793812871,
0.1900069565,
0.2755053639,
-0.4812494218,
0.2107877284,
0.1758887768,
-0.1095923632,
-0.1318194419,
0.1637423337,
0.1743030399,
-0.3582997024,
0.3901668787,
-0.0657949001,
-0.1831008941,
0.3923780024,
0.225562349,
1.001480937,
0.0503539518,
-0.6265802979,
0.3110786378,
0.318045646,
-0.1926281303,
-0.6194989085,
0.2754772902,
-0.0819312185,
-0.3266800642,
0.5186268091,
0.1928887516,
0.4792719781,
-0.4690928161,
0.6652410626,
0.0610177703,
-0.4032767713,
-0.1910025179,
1.2642785311,
0.0862383023,
-0.1125637516,
0.8654657006,
0.1502909511,
0.0095367376,
0.7630513906,
0.6635046601,
1.0068395138,
-0.4756599367,
0.0079830168,
0.6748510599,
0.4573302567,
0.3055036962,
-0.1353683919,
-0.382116586,
-0.2829056382,
-0.3538033366,
-0.6985285878,
-0.5178127885,
0.3680535555,
-0.7353436947,
0.1845950335,
-0.1157954857,
-0.0922152922,
-0.1227938384,
-0.5387016535,
-0.6746256351,
0.3977694511,
-0.1230545864,
0.450158,
-1.202844739,
0.2773009539,
0.0757936537,
-0.5469310284,
-0.6930493116,
-0.1078400314,
-0.2440980226,
-0.2544254959,
0.3072791994,
0.0679390132,
-0.0905769765,
0.2795991302,
-0.6961227059,
-0.9334726334,
0.9962635636,
0.1093664244,
-0.6871851087,
0.2670725882,
0.4820115268,
0.6396133304,
-0.3639281988,
0.0190457422,
0.7160095572,
0.7907508016,
0.156113103,
-0.5917236209,
-0.0786634013,
-0.4782524109,
-0.1606822908,
-0.1274161041,
-0.4533486664,
0.5282787681,
-0.211566627,
-0.4880540371,
0.0951827988,
0.8220202327,
0.2638206482,
0.304491818,
0.8262013197,
0.3838068843,
0.3272314072,
-0.4032972157,
1.0724512339,
-0.6010120511,
0.0242938679,
1.0306463242,
0.1190728247,
0.3284823596,
0.3404319882,
-0.244060263,
0.2928922772,
0.3572208881,
-0.7272729874,
0.741928637,
0.3317188621,
-0.2551843822,
-0.1531988382,
-0.1206016317,
-0.2035363913,
0.7208294868,
0.1263495833,
-0.3449054062,
0.2594522834,
0.5934141874,
-0.3120829463,
0.1451460123,
0.1431149542,
0.7913502455,
0.0097417273,
-0.5009194613,
0.4346899092,
-0.1599022746,
0.5354676247,
-0.1715791523,
-0.1860508472,
-0.2007790506,
-0.5619861484,
-0.1096998453,
-0.4734537601,
0.5841822028,
-0.0408775955,
-0.3246266246,
-0.4839461148,
0.3260325789,
-0.4509118497,
-0.375892669,
-0.0112716248,
0.0711596981,
0.0145322876,
-0.1562735438,
-0.1987764537,
0.071903877,
-0.3312884569,
0.060462337,
-0.2644225061,
0.1232975423,
0.3425169885,
0.3761050999,
1.0376882553,
0.0506969616,
0.117552489,
0.1085043401,
0.6201049685,
-0.411952734,
-0.5620721579,
-0.4961642623,
0.4735575318,
0.0680331141,
0.0128317391,
0.5785939097,
0.6857802272,
0.5301595926,
-0.5290179849,
0.861979723,
0.0344820991,
0.2454343885,
-0.5520466566,
0.7556099892,
-0.2286489308,
0.3951957524,
-0.565916419,
-1.0295799971,
-0.0801677778,
0.1517754644,
0.1887417287,
-0.0418427959,
0.3592150211,
0.731585741,
-0.2662162185,
0.1050864309,
0.3254636228,
0.1022191048,
0.5619478226,
0.2305800319,
0.7794905901,
-0.7959909439,
0.6294568777,
-0.4807317853,
0.1023826376,
0.1882259697,
-0.5237057209,
-0.4463423491,
-0.7607519627,
-0.5774658918,
0.0365552753,
-0.0311070271,
0.4773574471,
0.9749844074,
-0.9348356724,
-0.0802730545,
-0.4831713736,
-0.3431525826,
-0.5090335011,
-0.435538739,
0.479093492,
-0.2981089354,
-1.1204942465,
0.9189401269,
0.202643469,
0.2595795691,
-0.3071894944,
0.0598973967,
0.3922786117,
0.454377234,
0.6013303399,
0.1121563837,
-0.7872053981,
-0.4636504054,
-0.034211956,
0.107616052,
0.3373848498,
0.6338608861,
-0.7412853241,
0.7977612019,
0.3563856184,
0.2313964218,
0.6943020821,
0.1928502619,
0.803919673,
-0.7586207986,
-0.1648586988,
0.0078813322,
0.213717714,
0.4551368654,
-0.4044189453,
0.5002403855,
0.0912433788,
-0.4256664515,
-0.7405290008,
0.0721865892,
-0.9338274598,
-0.0886687785,
1.1055101156,
0.2853341997,
0.2971151769,
-0.165453881,
-0.3932205737,
0.617633462,
-0.383871913,
1.2969748974,
0.2710105777,
-0.0098343119,
-0.0875205919,
-0.6717066169,
0.6821684241,
0.2233470082,
-0.8354401588,
0.2231447399,
0.7526895404,
0.1101455316,
0.3761765957,
0.3827887177,
-0.6156233549,
0.4341792762,
0.3624569774,
0.3304539621,
-0.6782974005,
-0.6293452978,
-0.1629977524,
0.4717366993,
-0.476285398,
-0.3483199477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19384v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19384v1 | The Remarkable Robustness of LLMs: Stages of Inference? | 2024-06-27T17:57:03 | 2024-06-27T17:57:03 | Vedang Lad, Wes Gurnee, Max Tegmark | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We demonstrate and investigate the remarkable robustness of Large Language
Models by deleting and swapping adjacent layers. We find that deleting and
swapping interventions retain 72-95\% of the original model's prediction
accuracy without fine-tuning, whereas models with more layers exhibit more
robustness. Based on the results of the layer-wise intervention and further
experiments, we hypothesize the existence of four universal stages of inference
across eight different models: detokenization, feature engineering, prediction
ensembling, and residual sharpening. The first stage integrates local
information, lifting raw token representations into higher-level contextual
representations. Next is the iterative refinement of task and entity-specific
features. Then, the second half of the model begins with a phase transition,
where hidden representations align more with the vocabulary space due to
specialized model components. Finally, the last layer sharpens the following
token distribution by eliminating obsolete features that add noise to the
prediction. | [
-0.2278255969,
-0.8587782383,
0.7738869786,
0.0304621775,
-0.0015166418,
0.0795516819,
-0.0806326717,
-0.4364953041,
-0.2081277668,
0.553371489,
-0.5462569594,
-0.4619857967,
-0.4880237877,
-0.1407040656,
-0.7381148338,
0.7993941307,
0.2090148181,
0.1673013568,
0.0746666268,
0.1186273172,
-0.1960671693,
-0.383513689,
-0.8154637218,
-0.5369656086,
0.4188474119,
0.2122350335,
0.8112618923,
0.9417303801,
0.1097077504,
0.3453588188,
-0.5012506247,
-0.0328305364,
-0.3907112777,
0.4245115519,
-0.2545859516,
-0.9647766352,
-0.2578651309,
0.150128603,
0.7837812304,
1.0649063587,
-0.1725439578,
-0.1782961041,
0.403088361,
0.5245478749,
-0.4663237929,
-0.00560418,
-1.0284309387,
-0.0657782033,
-0.0094637983,
0.153569594,
-0.5448935032,
0.0650125593,
0.0584987402,
-0.38844648,
0.2206487954,
-0.050660748,
0.8053606153,
0.2038315237,
-0.5178728104,
-0.1061866209,
-0.8437542319,
1.0428279638,
-0.8364204764,
0.4398631155,
0.5876060128,
0.073062472,
-0.2733367383,
-0.8608027101,
-0.3783689439,
-0.4334440231,
0.2763276994,
-0.0665287599,
-0.1042772904,
0.2681227028,
0.395205766,
0.2506624758,
0.0684602484,
0.5850408077,
-0.1239601001,
-0.412869215,
0.3195527792,
0.1566459984,
0.2419348061,
-0.1969408542,
-0.3743428886,
0.2127208561,
-0.8400526643,
-0.1387056261,
0.3879310489,
0.3899376094,
-0.0936340764,
0.5264590383,
-0.0447499715,
0.4339030683,
0.1032636762,
-0.4389809668,
0.0196300149,
-0.3029110134,
-0.4126537144,
-0.3527178764,
0.4963144958,
-0.0756761283,
0.2584166229,
-0.338506192,
-0.4378397465,
0.1082635298,
0.1823562235,
-0.4372478724,
-0.1584460884,
0.5231356025,
-0.4735437334,
-0.4718554914,
-0.1876933128,
-0.3137221038,
-0.4586730897,
-0.3249637187,
0.3037238717,
-0.5731164813,
-0.2112225145,
0.0887953117,
0.2103795558,
0.2172897309,
0.4812703729,
-0.8646013737,
0.3354917765,
0.9009268284,
0.6846380234,
-0.3843276203,
-0.4996523559,
-0.2645123303,
0.2912068665,
-0.5578616261,
0.764059484,
-0.8683789968,
-0.2528209388,
0.0042788214,
0.1140115336,
-0.2406964898,
-0.7505993843,
0.7494536042,
-0.6109080315,
0.1175187528,
-0.2798099816,
-0.750362277,
-0.2540101707,
0.2438001484,
-0.7113842964,
1.0266042948,
-0.1774300486,
-0.7693465948,
0.4864781499,
-0.2998724878,
-0.2199528068,
-0.4280419052,
0.1258725822,
-0.2643992305,
0.3018990755,
0.2538051605,
0.6369709373,
-0.0337471776,
0.2032376379,
-0.586953342,
-0.3003281951,
0.4079177678,
-0.6609370112,
0.7289695144,
0.1888512373,
-0.4213247001,
0.0871134698,
-0.968734324,
-0.22856839,
-0.1001451239,
-0.3979970217,
-0.206497103,
0.1534858346,
-0.2539532781,
0.1816479862,
0.0754084736,
-0.355189234,
0.1037248373,
-0.3414416313,
0.8102693558,
0.8348225951,
0.1033283472,
0.7848597765,
-0.2354670763,
0.5321393013,
0.5774642229,
0.1825431734,
-0.393032819,
-0.5627815127,
-0.8978620768,
-0.488037318,
0.4890499711,
0.6534557939,
-0.6200916171,
0.318541944,
-0.0538612157,
-0.0600946732,
-0.2340643406,
0.1685497463,
0.3668248951,
0.4446757734,
0.1016849056,
-0.0878550783,
-0.2746708393,
-0.9524034262,
-0.1718055904,
-0.2195848376,
-0.2025939673,
-0.3104054034,
0.5573800206,
-0.2942058146,
0.5541809797,
0.0647141859,
0.240584299,
-0.2511963248,
0.0260609966,
0.1332082897,
0.5579180717,
0.1867039204,
-0.4912196994,
-0.063074559,
-0.1355433911,
-0.5871307254,
-0.1130249426,
-0.2806545794,
-0.1420609355,
0.2913021147,
0.6426025629,
-0.6433992982,
0.4042277038,
0.3889453113,
-0.006997095,
0.4790251553,
-0.1714702845,
-0.0464086235,
-1.1091524363,
-0.1215037778,
-0.0989729986,
-0.5167429447,
-0.8976327777,
0.1492859274,
0.0750920251,
0.1919964105,
-0.1889539361,
0.4496764541,
-0.8441072106,
-0.1593690366,
-0.1279592365,
0.3791858256,
0.0205233768,
0.318795532,
-0.4083535075,
0.586668551,
0.7189030051,
-0.6143939495,
-0.2328966111,
-0.1384099275,
-0.5452391505,
0.3700955808,
-0.5417122245,
0.0883435756,
-0.1702594161,
-0.0220857654,
-1.2920944691,
-0.1621166617,
0.0928931162,
-0.1686181426,
0.4819581807,
-0.17752859,
-0.4785119891,
-0.2697453201,
-0.4271364212,
-0.0116036627,
0.424270153,
-0.2240961194,
0.6812469363,
0.4296109974,
-0.1798359752,
-0.6977094412,
-1.0860513449,
0.2301387191,
-0.2337810099,
-0.3772795796,
0.0718482211,
-0.0030650652,
-0.4360621572,
0.0633896589,
-0.1496063322,
-0.0150810331,
0.3686957657,
0.3652118444,
0.2068091184,
-0.080002524,
-0.077615492,
0.2250407934,
-0.0930324271,
-0.0907158032,
-0.3577593267,
0.5334153175,
0.1317134053,
-0.7138420939,
-0.5318132639,
0.1448642015,
0.6895918846,
0.0279401802,
0.7109242082,
0.3700852394,
-0.5545657277,
-0.3247600198,
-0.7541075945,
-0.0335306823,
-0.4430392981,
0.4234722853,
-0.5759252906,
-1.091354847,
1.175216794,
0.0001866272,
0.2337234318,
0.4462200999,
0.5091665387,
0.0435299613,
1.3120037317,
0.5682461858,
-0.1502662003,
0.5488491058,
-0.1951973885,
0.1650097519,
-0.9367326498,
-0.3263013959,
-0.5482239723,
-0.2800152004,
-0.5828633904,
-0.72013551,
0.1422660202,
0.5509205461,
-0.3890260458,
-0.0319582485,
-0.1181876436,
0.5842917562,
0.5035523176,
0.2390360236,
0.3168736398,
0.2986814678,
-0.4309894741,
-0.1521383375,
-0.5864723921,
-0.6327561736,
1.0140228271,
0.6018143296,
0.8669096828,
-0.1440033317,
0.7007131577,
0.0896125361,
0.2604590356,
-0.7430622578,
0.6735771298,
-0.0141955093,
-0.6599842906,
-0.387450248,
-0.3453945518,
-0.9307212234,
0.3497844338,
-0.3448324502,
-1.0647944212,
0.2436085641,
0.094178237,
-0.2573921084,
0.6000370383,
-0.5652854443,
0.358851999,
0.2381173074,
-0.3393822312,
-0.3638329506,
-0.6341128349,
0.545956254,
-0.1345339268,
0.2855739594,
-0.1997128725,
-0.4425905943,
0.4673853219,
-0.2136880606,
1.0189740658,
-0.0499276966,
-0.340624094,
0.2404663265,
0.4656269848,
0.5990617275,
-0.1949240267,
-0.3580552638,
0.0214326233,
0.0132389469,
-0.4390212297,
-0.6929637194,
0.6552222967,
-0.5599083304,
-0.6991676092,
-0.076364249,
-0.6930820346,
-0.5035161972,
0.2436624914,
-0.0082013961,
0.6308628917,
-0.1398838609,
0.0350814387,
0.6998450756,
-0.2285656929,
0.5725210309,
0.1125492528,
-0.4486085176,
-0.4111413658,
0.6188163161,
0.0858351216,
0.6747261286,
0.415370971,
0.1607361734,
-0.332315594,
-1.0607366562,
-0.0741818249,
0.3782722354,
-0.9414400458,
0.1020879894,
-0.7586675882,
-0.2686368227,
-0.3591339886,
0.0235337764,
-0.3702813983,
-0.7109241486,
-0.3683384061,
-0.3477524519,
-0.1238778904,
1.1575421095,
-0.2024073005,
0.2865413725,
-0.7722805142,
0.156242311,
0.2609203756,
0.1349262148,
0.1793479174,
-0.860711813,
-0.2474140972,
0.0774305314,
-0.2187176943,
-0.7104517817,
0.2641263902,
0.3155655861,
0.8211093545,
0.8124238253,
-0.3993957639,
0.6952031851,
-0.536775589,
1.090342164,
0.0262832046,
-1.0296396017,
0.2700570226,
-0.4017006755,
0.3674277663,
0.5102006197,
0.3581659198,
-0.2220421582,
-0.7250658274,
-0.6072238684,
-0.7652326822,
0.5111867785,
-0.072287865,
0.2921503782,
-0.0171990246,
0.6965407133,
0.239645347,
0.2262457609,
-0.6302980185,
-0.2818914056,
0.1654828191,
0.0669727698,
0.1227035075,
-0.6786129475,
-0.1644154787,
-0.2538508475,
0.5126028061,
-0.0035098235,
0.1509252042,
-0.0802055001,
-0.091378592,
0.0532262586,
0.2937771082,
0.6071714759,
0.9951328635,
0.0342490412,
0.402903527,
0.3527890444,
-0.3787404001,
0.0372257195,
-0.2052765936,
-0.2825788856,
-0.2048517764,
0.8021410108,
0.9133365154,
0.5775839686,
-0.2637431026,
0.2144635171,
0.1072916612,
-0.1376778781,
0.091821678,
0.0698299706,
0.2038271576,
0.544093132,
0.3862495124,
0.0849143565,
0.1949146241,
-0.7846344709,
0.2450473458,
0.5067458749,
-0.2814459205,
-0.5297394395,
0.9338859916,
-0.1836483926,
-0.0316111445,
0.434820801,
-0.0632327497,
-0.5576894283,
0.3625177443,
0.5463852286,
0.983728826,
-0.318855077,
0.3565793335,
0.1798251867,
0.435756892,
-0.4126713574,
0.2222709656,
0.1063367873,
-0.8688613772,
-0.6579802036,
-0.6872889996,
-0.3664778173,
0.0939561576,
-0.7025143504,
-0.1014170572,
-0.4917039275,
-0.2263091207,
-0.0740543976,
-0.0893680528,
-0.4765355885,
0.287645489,
0.3128940463,
0.9826772213,
-0.8598831296,
0.9808242917,
0.3423454762,
-0.0671495795,
-0.7899269462,
0.1672797054,
0.2139590085,
-1.1103724241,
0.6186081171,
0.0898141563,
-0.0479459465,
-0.1352882981,
-0.781370759,
-0.9384243488,
0.9492502809,
0.7691445947,
-0.5442282557,
-0.2924503386,
0.1242476851,
0.4529749751,
-0.2783775032,
0.2647652626,
0.7237075567,
0.2848523259,
0.2755565047,
-0.8830931187,
0.0497088581,
0.0647164211,
0.4405542314,
-0.0683758184,
-0.2568641901,
1.131534934,
-0.2851606607,
-0.4989127815,
0.2948934138,
0.7581935525,
0.1753161103,
-0.1134621799,
0.7841156721,
0.6421424747,
1.0687258244,
-0.1266236007,
1.0794414282,
-0.5272165537,
0.2366416454,
1.0556272268,
-0.1544495523,
0.9134791493,
0.3829016984,
-0.2373481244,
0.5810647607,
0.7424584627,
0.3537962735,
0.3883232772,
0.0167759228,
-0.2893960774,
-0.5136728287,
0.072634466,
-0.127506271,
0.3541125059,
0.4156242311,
-0.317061305,
-0.0798325762,
0.0204091687,
0.2699786127,
-0.1315736026,
-0.3483716249,
0.5166597962,
0.3269535005,
-0.6372820139,
0.5298176408,
-0.1568567753,
0.6395695806,
-0.571983397,
0.0667789504,
-0.3910028934,
0.1561903208,
-0.1455007643,
-0.8974128366,
0.102708213,
-0.3577457368,
-0.0903460309,
-0.1376821995,
0.7895525694,
-0.5311327577,
-0.5955747366,
0.3809231222,
0.5922245979,
0.256193161,
0.0162704606,
-0.8064160943,
0.2453749627,
0.0113960551,
-0.6688305736,
0.3960080743,
0.7123606205,
-0.1019991934,
1.07231915,
0.4961706102,
0.3742908239,
0.4179132879,
0.3819678426,
0.8433499932,
-0.6690144539,
-0.2316854894,
-0.9127583504,
0.5892322063,
-0.0038610196,
-0.0154707329,
0.8441733718,
0.2016296089,
0.6107599735,
0.228340894,
0.6937891245,
0.3380233645,
0.4628226459,
-0.7515019178,
0.3960485458,
-0.5503227711,
0.4147076905,
-0.2128593624,
-0.9612678885,
-0.4693240523,
0.3170940578,
-0.1347264498,
0.3117182255,
0.723279655,
0.9918433428,
-0.0943023413,
-0.0729880035,
0.721422255,
0.612609446,
0.2099534571,
0.1666811258,
0.9001002908,
-0.1976222843,
0.1644169986,
-0.2576495111,
-0.1518088579,
0.0791270062,
-0.9613650441,
-1.0095797777,
-0.5559709072,
-0.217410475,
-0.5825428367,
-0.082410574,
0.6462448239,
0.6967561841,
-1.0146570206,
-0.1366441995,
0.0612180196,
0.2618586719,
-0.1391123384,
-0.1723825336,
0.2056232691,
-0.4578413963,
-0.9427514672,
0.4734432995,
0.4233985841,
0.0004685037,
-0.5495573282,
0.2902875245,
-0.1351586431,
0.2020908445,
0.6843543649,
0.1005418524,
-0.9636458158,
-0.5242993832,
-0.1944894344,
-0.1955310255,
-0.0023276738,
0.7470067739,
-0.4769881368,
0.3159898818,
0.4855366349,
0.5927832127,
0.510620892,
-0.1412051022,
0.5746727586,
-0.3204848468,
0.3016714156,
-0.1717965305,
0.5998926163,
0.43442294,
-0.0487604588,
0.4332624078,
0.1350956261,
-0.7077342868,
-1.1082129478,
0.3428737223,
-0.944372952,
-0.2832809091,
1.1939967871,
-0.2371719182,
-0.3909393251,
-0.2444379032,
0.0565830842,
0.2351250499,
-0.0667839572,
0.6597856283,
0.6932151914,
-0.0920055658,
-0.297575742,
-0.7283924818,
0.2865699232,
0.4885807931,
-0.661867559,
0.0923136026,
0.4722602367,
0.5085288882,
0.0984861776,
0.4197387099,
-0.1996877193,
-0.4477461278,
0.1662418991,
-0.2490944564,
0.1051211506,
-0.3774270713,
-0.6240983009,
0.274923712,
0.3754355907,
0.012349599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19371v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19371v1 | Suri: Multi-constraint Instruction Following for Long-form Text Generation | 2024-06-27T17:50:35 | 2024-06-27T17:50:35 | Chau Minh Pham, Simeng Sun, Mohit Iyyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing research on instruction following largely focuses on tasks with
simple instructions and short responses. In this work, we explore
multi-constraint instruction following for generating long-form text. We create
Suri, a dataset with 20K human-written long-form texts paired with
LLM-generated backtranslated instructions that contain multiple complex
constraints. Because of prohibitive challenges associated with collecting human
preference judgments on long-form texts, preference-tuning algorithms such as
DPO are infeasible in our setting; thus, we propose Instructional ORPO
(I-ORPO), an alignment method based on the ORPO algorithm. Instead of receiving
negative feedback from dispreferred responses, I-ORPO obtains negative feedback
from synthetically corrupted instructions generated by an LLM. Using Suri, we
perform supervised and I-ORPO fine-tuning on Mistral-7b-Instruct-v0.2. The
resulting models, Suri-SFT and Suri-I-ORPO, generate significantly longer texts
(~5K tokens) than base models without significant quality deterioration. Our
human evaluation shows that while both SFT and I-ORPO models satisfy most
constraints, Suri-I-ORPO generations are generally preferred for their coherent
and informative incorporation of the constraints. We release our code at
https://github.com/chtmp223/suri. | [
-0.0611308329,
-0.487687856,
0.4604957998,
0.1793876737,
-0.0002255726,
-0.1345138103,
-0.2603928745,
-0.4971957505,
-0.1129774228,
1.0259346962,
-1.0569701195,
-0.6260743737,
-0.2386939824,
0.2730541825,
-0.0602019541,
1.0448330641,
-0.2502327859,
-0.0853617415,
-0.2900972962,
0.0541316681,
-0.8136100173,
-0.4802466035,
-0.2817521095,
-0.3270247877,
0.360920608,
0.930072248,
0.4037703574,
0.8732274175,
0.2706154287,
0.2918741405,
0.1165248081,
0.7222695351,
-0.581038177,
0.1550254971,
-0.0943671614,
-0.2960123718,
-0.3441700041,
-0.1000611708,
0.7225645781,
0.4958727062,
-0.1046223715,
0.1180172563,
0.1302877367,
0.7790592909,
-0.7691999078,
-0.0326455534,
-0.269856602,
-0.173933804,
-0.2416300625,
-0.1917750239,
-0.6887298822,
-0.5861237049,
-0.0390618443,
-0.604116559,
0.2719369233,
0.1835722029,
0.5385667086,
0.4582951069,
-0.4788691401,
-0.6709434986,
-0.7293928862,
0.9203665853,
-0.5381034017,
0.4163536429,
0.1838353872,
0.0577573478,
-0.5677928925,
-0.2299791127,
-0.5521288514,
-0.1390455216,
-0.0159698743,
0.4018776119,
0.3451150656,
0.2738313973,
0.354785949,
0.0909515545,
-0.4448771179,
0.3665719032,
-0.5296039581,
0.0409211516,
0.6822787523,
0.2562772334,
0.089056164,
-0.3292289376,
-0.5878942609,
-0.1009427756,
-0.8876317143,
0.0563365147,
0.5868371129,
0.2466779947,
-0.1623421162,
0.9325457215,
-0.1333529055,
0.8578562737,
0.1453349441,
-0.4513892531,
0.1686447412,
-0.4255060554,
-0.0199054163,
0.2237109095,
0.7182572484,
0.3550851941,
0.1669827253,
0.132986486,
-0.0723943859,
-0.0606243163,
0.198295638,
-0.7793580294,
0.2159940004,
-0.1577546448,
-0.4286058247,
-0.1767920554,
0.2486267537,
-0.8240878582,
-0.5122362375,
-0.5908669829,
0.2087188512,
-0.7821825743,
0.4416031241,
0.3193841279,
-0.1090314165,
0.2850117385,
0.2472091764,
-1.0967656374,
0.2307433784,
0.6697430015,
0.4378071129,
-0.165659681,
-0.6157797575,
-0.5872684121,
0.5055836439,
-0.1579268575,
0.5267521143,
-0.6732938886,
-0.5496011972,
0.054406818,
-0.1121125668,
-0.1839886159,
-0.338550806,
0.6333522797,
-0.2492685467,
0.4558964372,
-0.1047276333,
-0.7316098809,
0.0388493501,
-0.0699654147,
-0.4552527964,
0.9730217457,
-0.0427707434,
-0.6334620118,
0.2650130093,
-0.5150387287,
-0.6158841848,
-0.2841790915,
-0.395994246,
-0.6707718968,
0.209893465,
0.281336844,
0.3408297598,
-0.3772380352,
0.0804487541,
-0.2811455727,
-0.3789971471,
0.119537577,
-0.6167327166,
0.6531062126,
-0.1529257149,
-0.3153327703,
0.0383459516,
-1.0707823038,
-0.1217253283,
-0.2583794892,
-0.4967666268,
-0.27607584,
0.0860016197,
-0.3529630899,
-0.05316649,
0.3144656122,
-0.7211669087,
0.6502164602,
-0.1657456905,
0.5805360675,
0.6946402192,
0.1392897069,
0.2660741806,
-0.28893134,
0.4860541523,
-0.5391236544,
0.2921199501,
-0.2008619606,
-0.1940516084,
-0.7274048924,
-0.0897502601,
0.093454048,
0.5400825143,
-0.8258469701,
0.395737499,
-0.4027930796,
-0.2216693312,
-0.3914470375,
0.1823806763,
0.8159219027,
0.6683591604,
0.509498775,
0.1204086617,
-0.6124113202,
-0.8729616404,
0.2195031792,
-0.006966725,
0.1673808843,
0.3822541535,
0.4405883253,
-0.2175516337,
0.6003133059,
-0.8127824068,
-0.3247618675,
-0.0817126408,
0.3683621287,
0.0287515242,
0.5540730357,
0.4155954719,
-0.5584304333,
-0.462887913,
-0.0797704384,
-0.3922495246,
-0.2313398123,
-0.4198159575,
-0.3607331812,
0.4048718214,
0.6196560264,
-0.6942443848,
0.4994571209,
0.4513783753,
-0.0249193665,
0.7638977766,
-0.3272189498,
0.3259512782,
-1.2509493828,
-0.1334769279,
-0.1261392981,
-0.0695971549,
-0.4682489932,
-0.0041897884,
0.1830365211,
-0.2020806372,
-0.2090298086,
0.1485507488,
-0.6373592019,
0.2522009313,
-0.2561343014,
-0.2906267047,
0.217227295,
0.5918338299,
0.3166694045,
0.8402532339,
0.2713516653,
-0.5812740326,
0.2294004112,
0.2916374803,
-0.1494326591,
0.5602899194,
-0.5772715211,
0.2879709601,
-0.1844661832,
0.4368179142,
-0.8453297615,
-0.5695687532,
0.257714957,
-0.3336420059,
0.6219636798,
-0.1771796197,
-0.5152811408,
-0.364759475,
-0.4438518286,
0.4439930022,
0.312420845,
-0.6390687227,
0.6792023778,
-0.0595950708,
0.0417542234,
-0.7133794427,
-0.5886507034,
-0.2281469405,
-0.1220471859,
-0.4661935568,
0.7024366856,
0.0021009599,
0.3778286576,
-0.2417710572,
-0.1432688385,
0.09032318,
-0.4439921677,
0.6122348309,
0.398901701,
-0.1384735703,
0.1219329834,
0.5766745806,
-0.1363486499,
-0.0257709436,
-0.2730512619,
0.4079502225,
0.236034438,
-0.4688633382,
-0.6615355015,
0.6650814414,
0.6674901843,
-0.1676702797,
0.6090093851,
0.2298515141,
-0.153712064,
-0.2883968651,
-0.6402482986,
0.1135716364,
-0.4527121186,
0.2754154801,
-0.4207387567,
-0.7470099926,
0.0779429376,
-0.1092568934,
0.3652956486,
0.2858296633,
0.2186567634,
-0.171513617,
1.071680665,
0.7979314327,
-0.0262799785,
0.500080049,
-0.1310397238,
-0.402828604,
-0.7429506183,
-0.3941177428,
-0.560487628,
-0.2167590261,
-0.360781312,
-0.2830212116,
0.3044345081,
0.3113667369,
-0.3014507294,
0.4008224607,
-0.7391501069,
0.580021739,
0.8825390339,
0.2947199643,
0.0430239215,
-0.0554903634,
0.2035959214,
0.0327363685,
-0.6547516584,
-0.3999374211,
0.9852697253,
0.0742252618,
1.0404119492,
0.1611999571,
1.1632865667,
0.0449216813,
0.2482495457,
-0.5999835134,
0.4112243652,
-0.4725545049,
-0.2975367904,
-0.4135579765,
-0.6094040275,
-0.9801100492,
-0.3039309382,
-0.2196731865,
-0.6661400199,
0.2284602821,
0.3484427035,
-0.6662159562,
-0.1406757087,
-0.9950957894,
0.7478032112,
-0.4670245051,
-0.1934423596,
-0.0651676804,
-0.9292315245,
0.3758080006,
0.2026856095,
-0.0547928177,
0.3467748463,
-0.1373089403,
0.455927074,
-0.580768466,
1.1380763054,
0.1612015963,
-0.1789864302,
0.5482460856,
-0.3666905463,
0.4790941775,
0.0380418077,
-0.0938713551,
-0.3244434595,
-0.064110443,
-0.1399813294,
-0.7131649852,
0.7423632145,
-0.9110785127,
-0.6164462566,
-0.1580308378,
-0.3590779901,
0.0300179329,
0.4689221978,
0.6618179679,
0.6791467071,
0.0261620879,
0.1224726662,
0.7817938924,
-0.203048557,
0.1814888865,
0.3237899244,
-0.0799450427,
-0.7551410198,
1.1818925142,
0.178735584,
0.3780077696,
0.7015440464,
0.2691963315,
-0.3702623546,
-0.42419523,
-0.8007720113,
0.3723323643,
-0.4502952993,
-0.4369349182,
-0.0589353219,
-0.2371313423,
-0.50391078,
-0.1726806909,
-0.4490976632,
-0.2469004542,
-0.630281806,
0.1726105362,
0.2264519185,
0.8305414319,
0.1915219724,
0.1519624442,
-0.9436837435,
0.4439712167,
0.3034557402,
0.2877525687,
-0.203727141,
-0.4276706278,
-0.1286117882,
0.1286915392,
-0.5522088408,
-1.0879210234,
-0.0985652432,
0.2266184837,
0.1788294017,
0.303616792,
0.2494882345,
0.9638079405,
-0.6920813918,
0.4476951361,
0.3426192701,
-0.9353120327,
0.5801727772,
-0.1727026105,
0.3748455942,
0.7049777508,
0.298853159,
-0.2540650368,
-0.2425098419,
-0.2994241118,
-0.6267299652,
0.9072800875,
0.172434628,
0.2201370448,
-0.0376699157,
0.8166307807,
0.4937932491,
0.2221057415,
-0.6113347411,
-0.1495266855,
-0.2186985016,
-0.2516927421,
0.1497840881,
-0.4884201586,
0.0107418038,
0.0955383331,
0.8198245168,
-0.0785741284,
-0.1355646551,
0.232964009,
0.0677941516,
-0.0664237365,
0.3308591843,
1.0556303263,
0.4867641032,
-0.0710345283,
0.0065806564,
0.085339725,
-0.4243175089,
0.0364256836,
0.3696088791,
-0.4360828102,
-0.2449113429,
0.4761659205,
0.8647139668,
-0.0668693259,
-0.5695323944,
0.2794185877,
0.0531327501,
-0.3233148456,
-0.264539212,
0.1941272914,
-0.1692092419,
0.195853889,
0.0421896465,
0.0235016011,
0.057759013,
-0.3702741265,
-0.1169890016,
0.2980219126,
-0.3779456615,
-0.2325907052,
0.6251017451,
0.344327122,
-0.3043128252,
0.7720746994,
-0.0320064016,
-0.3794910908,
0.4160272777,
0.566019237,
0.5547638535,
-0.0248369947,
0.197112903,
0.2105179876,
0.1643005013,
-0.1425413936,
0.4459534585,
-0.1066868305,
-0.4627115726,
-0.643473506,
-0.3411137164,
-0.2998153567,
0.3044346869,
-0.700866878,
0.5646868348,
-0.4262976646,
-0.0446884595,
-0.0206118319,
-0.1799575239,
-0.2488951981,
0.1192892492,
0.1842755377,
0.510302186,
-0.7032080293,
0.7349768877,
0.7644457817,
-0.3743978441,
-0.8342087269,
0.0169165619,
0.0304214712,
-0.5512582064,
0.3195185065,
0.4930230677,
-0.5265128016,
-0.0277058426,
-0.6638511419,
-0.7463498712,
0.9786281586,
0.4995502532,
-0.5743216276,
-0.0940587074,
0.2527601123,
0.5975894928,
-0.2852059901,
-0.1023640558,
0.3969576955,
0.2366949767,
0.1876696348,
-0.5856407285,
0.0624524914,
0.0586608276,
0.0670744926,
0.6215031147,
-0.9828897715,
0.4617829621,
-0.3213916421,
-0.3202420473,
0.5866023302,
0.9485727549,
0.4184837341,
0.2735025585,
0.3366562128,
0.5781193972,
0.4397274852,
0.3377075791,
0.9048460126,
-0.2387288064,
0.0974071696,
1.5169146061,
-0.1392686963,
0.7452042699,
0.6302367449,
0.1681202799,
0.4273837209,
0.4623504877,
0.0614611395,
0.3207499683,
0.3203953505,
0.0328283459,
-0.2762600183,
-0.264203459,
-0.4274924099,
0.3665028512,
0.1801590472,
-0.4218894541,
-0.0168281104,
-0.1002578959,
-0.1393862218,
0.3279949427,
-0.0993169844,
0.7135774493,
-0.1043817997,
-1.2260859013,
0.7253170013,
0.0626319051,
0.3954690993,
-0.4639909565,
-0.6021258831,
-0.1462391764,
0.1300226897,
-0.2056908756,
-0.7363464832,
0.0109236315,
-0.0152821802,
-0.5541383624,
-0.3107478619,
0.5245233178,
-0.6149256825,
-0.5698779821,
-0.2026836872,
-0.0514393449,
-0.01566891,
0.4082729816,
-0.4818919897,
0.0351617448,
0.343985498,
-0.2995380163,
0.1421429962,
0.5658814311,
-0.2398207486,
0.5502863526,
0.3946938515,
-0.2632873952,
0.1798268855,
0.3134000599,
0.7482036352,
-0.4151355922,
-0.0482376404,
-0.9051283598,
0.4075674713,
-0.0445288047,
-0.7305078506,
0.6171532273,
0.7933002114,
0.7978460193,
-0.1374596953,
0.6431178451,
-0.0113961371,
0.5358421206,
-0.9615423083,
0.2734714448,
-0.5126059651,
0.301194638,
-0.2212786973,
-1.0182051659,
-0.2695451081,
0.1578045785,
-0.2477820963,
-0.1379193813,
0.4418027699,
0.6580325365,
-0.0847731009,
0.0338336453,
-0.0908524022,
-0.2653941512,
0.1619312018,
0.7867947817,
0.9342012405,
-0.19744578,
0.8540564179,
-0.4391483366,
-0.3970056474,
0.0007984035,
-0.8572964072,
-1.110814333,
-0.2554680109,
-0.2440399081,
-0.2267302722,
0.0535230897,
0.9869580865,
0.564021945,
-0.6060082316,
-0.2737656832,
-0.4546836615,
0.2786841094,
-0.2936561406,
-0.1812105477,
0.5761038065,
-0.2659956217,
-0.8978430033,
0.4240873754,
0.2555259168,
0.319408685,
-0.0454245247,
-0.2516230345,
-0.0114943944,
0.0328052752,
0.3731012344,
0.5027599335,
-0.6723937988,
-0.5484034419,
0.1431337148,
-0.1991571635,
-0.0898213685,
0.838503778,
-0.3362976313,
0.5456056595,
0.4984329641,
0.591484189,
0.4511345327,
0.437790215,
0.7137490511,
-1.0354802608,
-0.2212948501,
0.0205470119,
0.0334356278,
0.1331118494,
-0.5660674572,
0.3313880265,
0.0334391147,
-0.5206467509,
-0.775570035,
0.5339825153,
-0.7605439425,
-0.2385181785,
1.1254653931,
0.0306180213,
-0.1710368097,
0.3342728913,
-0.6136726141,
0.351108104,
-0.5517275333,
0.8490473628,
0.5193523169,
-0.5023030639,
-0.130877167,
-0.2026799321,
0.3598065972,
0.3639695942,
-0.7698308229,
0.1078500375,
0.7769687176,
-0.1037812084,
0.3181233108,
0.2620729208,
0.1388648152,
0.4108612835,
-0.0558281057,
0.2467272878,
-0.3678685427,
-0.6387112141,
0.0702610016,
0.0698218644,
-0.2959737778,
-0.4527945518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00121v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00121v1 | Granite-Function Calling Model: Introducing Function Calling Abilities via Multi-task Learning of Granular Tasks | 2024-06-27T17:47:26 | 2024-06-27T17:47:26 | Ibrahim Abdelaziz, Kinjal Basu, Mayank Agarwal, Sadhana Kumaravel, Matthew Stallone, Rameswar Panda, Yara Rizk, GP Bhargav, Maxwell Crouse, Chulaka Gunasekara, Shajith Ikbal, Sachin Joshi, Hima Karanam, Vineet Kumar, Asim Munawar, Sumit Neelam, Dinesh Raghu, Udit Sharma, Adriana Meza Soria, Dheeraj Sreedhar, Praveen Venkateswaran, Merve Unuvar, David Cox, Salim Roukos, Luis Lastras, Pavan Kapanipathi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have recently shown tremendous promise in
serving as the backbone to agentic systems, as demonstrated by their
performance in multi-faceted, challenging benchmarks like SWE-Bench and
Agent-Bench. However, to realize the true potential of LLMs as autonomous
agents, they must learn to identify, call, and interact with external tools and
application program interfaces (APIs) to complete complex tasks. These tasks
together are termed function calling. Endowing LLMs with function calling
abilities leads to a myriad of advantages, such as access to current and
domain-specific information in databases and knowledge sources, and the ability
to outsource tasks that can be reliably performed by tools, e.g., a Python
interpreter or calculator. While there has been significant progress in
function calling with LLMs, there is still a dearth of open models that perform
on par with proprietary LLMs like GPT, Claude, and Gemini. Therefore, in this
work, we introduce the GRANITE-20B-FUNCTIONCALLING model under an Apache 2.0
license. The model is trained using a multi-task training approach on seven
fundamental tasks encompassed in function calling, those being Nested Function
Calling, Function Chaining, Parallel Functions, Function Name Detection,
Parameter-Value Pair Detection, Next-Best Function, and Response Generation. We
present a comprehensive evaluation on multiple out-of-domain datasets comparing
GRANITE-20B-FUNCTIONCALLING to more than 15 other best proprietary and open
models. GRANITE-20B-FUNCTIONCALLING provides the best performance among all
open models on the Berkeley Function Calling Leaderboard and fourth overall. As
a result of the diverse tasks and datasets used for training our model, we show
that GRANITE-20B-FUNCTIONCALLING has better generalizability on multiple tasks
in seven different evaluation datasets. | [
-0.2937496305,
-0.8631148934,
0.4893568754,
0.2617434859,
-0.0517801419,
0.0189716406,
-0.4139297903,
-0.5085480213,
-0.3284886181,
0.8083678484,
-0.5936694741,
-0.3517948687,
-0.4442733824,
-0.0357527062,
-0.1669945717,
0.7993221283,
0.0723167956,
0.4168303907,
-0.5838394165,
0.2225989699,
-0.4743290246,
-0.212790072,
-0.7400909662,
-0.606215477,
0.3015716374,
-0.0097232293,
0.6592634916,
0.6558645964,
0.533257544,
0.3873511255,
0.2786500156,
0.3927476406,
-0.1906164736,
-0.0807655677,
-0.1113258451,
-0.5418400764,
-0.6136046648,
-0.1563634723,
0.4624134898,
0.7233961821,
0.0716465637,
0.3253699839,
0.0853716284,
0.2927936018,
-0.5014995337,
0.8814970851,
-0.7280214429,
-0.2538717985,
-0.2625440359,
-0.2840304673,
-0.6263965964,
-0.2341510952,
-0.0050644707,
-0.2978906631,
-0.1443395317,
-0.2786604166,
0.3671117425,
0.3707693815,
-0.45150581,
-0.57307899,
-0.6698102951,
1.1011447906,
-0.6135475039,
0.2255215645,
0.5981450677,
0.2640476227,
-0.2052159309,
-0.6991529465,
-0.0461222716,
-0.4065930545,
0.1977503449,
-0.1273836792,
0.2071515769,
0.0590528101,
0.0389983058,
0.2696209252,
-0.1626292318,
-0.0390453041,
-0.0699973777,
0.2095454186,
0.5644696951,
0.2892881036,
0.0612528995,
0.0481711775,
-0.2569739521,
-0.0068964283,
-0.5657016635,
0.2979136705,
0.2126975209,
0.9515017867,
-0.0563542619,
0.172213614,
-0.0613061413,
0.8635741472,
-0.0770690441,
-0.5468803048,
0.2565250695,
0.162891522,
-0.4390107691,
-0.6012180448,
0.6019346118,
-0.0656674951,
0.3761005998,
-0.4458360076,
-0.2527980804,
-0.4287911057,
0.6054254174,
-0.8638390899,
0.0085331146,
0.4334151745,
-0.3821861744,
-0.2610819638,
-0.159588322,
-0.3363679349,
-0.4190864861,
-0.6776314378,
0.647662878,
-0.523722887,
-0.1735903174,
-0.2217326164,
0.3158736825,
0.0756780505,
0.4656147361,
-0.9561817646,
0.9395642877,
0.7066699266,
0.7006029487,
-0.1093516573,
-0.4059768915,
-0.7904700041,
-0.1568780541,
-0.3675969839,
0.746059835,
-0.5708419085,
-0.5137466788,
-0.1778649092,
0.0101646427,
-0.402759999,
-0.8341542482,
0.1444468945,
-0.4291725755,
-0.2296127081,
-0.1768349856,
-0.0237761959,
-0.3308837414,
0.1154321507,
-0.5096863508,
1.2424968481,
0.2723350227,
-0.2485838979,
0.2317757308,
-0.7713618279,
-0.4477387965,
0.4752330482,
-0.2798762619,
-0.4930945337,
0.2379271835,
0.0578680262,
0.5908796191,
-0.6892264485,
0.2683816552,
-0.3047719598,
-0.2233066857,
0.08769802,
-0.1321088225,
0.8462343812,
0.1866209358,
-0.3785694838,
0.3572780192,
-0.3047250509,
0.3899048865,
-0.020476291,
-0.2046623677,
-0.2365289778,
-0.0108903609,
-0.0571414046,
0.16398938,
0.1332724988,
-0.3620121777,
-0.0867202505,
-0.1694890857,
0.392599076,
0.5726056695,
-0.4762115777,
0.1752885729,
-0.5158706307,
0.4106327295,
-0.3108817041,
0.3276900351,
-0.1548624337,
-0.4806022346,
-0.1595195234,
-0.8141608834,
0.3587285578,
0.735640347,
-0.548238337,
0.0881878287,
-0.2631011605,
-0.4188515842,
-0.3510599136,
0.121069774,
0.4429314435,
0.2170163095,
0.4195280075,
-0.2957243025,
-0.1088809595,
-0.5212650299,
-0.1317548752,
0.076307632,
0.0994794369,
0.8647569418,
0.6520934105,
-0.0295015238,
0.8378353119,
-0.3663065434,
-0.4194438457,
-0.0968874246,
0.1790789068,
0.3509462178,
0.1017890871,
0.3698445857,
-1.0023815632,
-0.6073992252,
0.2158583254,
-0.7221996784,
0.0113211796,
0.1221050397,
0.1690831333,
-0.0080762533,
0.1509997845,
-0.3297428191,
0.2256732434,
0.6363642216,
0.2064227015,
0.8070847392,
-0.2415059954,
0.2550521791,
-1.1687196493,
0.0372484997,
-0.1386307478,
-0.3636630476,
-0.5577612519,
0.321320802,
0.1351009607,
-0.167501688,
-0.6795610189,
0.7570316195,
-0.7547358274,
-0.3440884948,
-0.5808128715,
-0.2582422793,
-0.5446561575,
0.4476988316,
-0.0513283163,
0.907433629,
0.877509892,
-0.7008519769,
0.613955617,
0.2466188818,
-0.0702435151,
0.5909823775,
-0.2692750692,
0.1112442017,
0.2563803494,
0.0938765705,
-0.9573409557,
-0.1482807696,
-0.1387526989,
-0.3091903329,
0.1190631911,
-0.6050184369,
-0.4024277627,
-0.5067904592,
-0.2632403076,
0.4708705246,
0.3325063288,
-0.48714903,
1.1435400248,
0.5848665833,
-0.3889130652,
-0.6738117933,
-0.6503533721,
-0.0945198983,
0.0111881783,
-0.7090958953,
0.4095671177,
-0.1375949532,
-0.2267335802,
-0.0221419837,
-0.0909951627,
-0.4037027359,
0.0225699227,
0.7043945789,
0.1646796465,
0.0789709985,
0.1542880833,
-0.2810259163,
-0.0797618479,
0.0474475287,
-0.6181836724,
0.8223494291,
-0.2631043494,
-0.4583342075,
-0.1528824121,
0.1081312671,
0.5699430108,
-0.4372037947,
0.6756054163,
0.4628492594,
-0.603644371,
-0.4670219719,
-0.435654074,
-0.2383856773,
-0.4939083159,
0.2275895476,
-0.8044916391,
-0.725897789,
0.6306978464,
-0.4120995104,
0.1171171963,
0.1740490198,
0.7806216478,
0.2231742293,
0.7031758428,
0.6450758576,
0.2002176344,
0.5299788713,
-0.3507170379,
0.0072193714,
-0.9184189439,
-0.199525401,
-0.5103436112,
0.1675010622,
-0.5379570723,
-0.6438282132,
0.4263658524,
-0.2501784265,
-0.1748798788,
0.3771631122,
-0.2060155571,
0.6058932543,
0.5854892135,
0.2790964842,
0.1375696808,
0.0226818454,
-0.1324299425,
0.1744336486,
-0.3185690045,
-0.4194556177,
1.3293535709,
0.2966162264,
0.9010123014,
-0.1076709479,
0.7280742526,
0.2836318612,
0.4169479012,
-1.0349172354,
0.6264177561,
-0.5282846093,
-0.4951011837,
-0.3975953162,
-0.5943145156,
-0.7971243858,
0.4634863734,
-0.0201085377,
-0.9658807516,
-0.213340044,
-0.120234929,
-0.5858948231,
0.5193655491,
-0.4394538105,
0.6041476727,
-0.2738349736,
-0.4929553866,
-0.1227838323,
-0.4376674294,
0.2793534994,
-0.1729062647,
0.6414051056,
-0.0673997924,
0.3490504026,
0.3564472795,
-0.2159233987,
1.0673936605,
-0.152642861,
-0.2449058294,
0.3226781487,
0.1649872065,
0.5577731729,
-0.0796742439,
-0.128384918,
0.0349501297,
0.122502774,
-0.1843111366,
-0.1954561621,
0.8574845195,
-0.8595427871,
-0.3228335381,
-0.2854049802,
-0.8955762982,
-0.2779354751,
0.3032719493,
-0.2108018398,
1.0073035955,
-0.0341194645,
0.0801480785,
0.683868885,
0.2017798573,
0.5977916718,
0.2429497391,
-0.3068324924,
-0.4669835567,
1.1169456244,
0.1304294765,
0.3785058856,
0.350725919,
-0.0360205173,
-0.5182401538,
-0.6107020378,
-0.4369636774,
0.3271138966,
-0.5525353551,
-0.178254351,
-0.81142658,
-0.1966010928,
-0.4442217648,
-0.0148159731,
-0.4755199552,
-0.139748469,
0.0634284168,
0.3383190036,
0.0233993251,
0.8335989714,
0.0563696288,
0.3695357144,
-0.793609798,
0.3071671724,
0.4291843474,
0.3406054676,
0.0368924588,
-0.3093412519,
-0.4437163174,
0.0519831739,
-0.5430119634,
-0.6513568759,
0.4530723989,
0.0761550963,
0.6364553571,
-0.0509010442,
-0.0582684278,
0.5657672882,
-0.4917375445,
0.6107434034,
-0.1572990566,
-1.105661273,
0.2188916057,
-0.5805411339,
0.2451719195,
0.3585908115,
0.2882896662,
-0.281819433,
-0.2067146748,
-0.3934086561,
-0.8525648713,
0.9231817722,
-0.0421222486,
0.165720731,
-0.0320486389,
0.2136875987,
0.2582968771,
0.4616084397,
-0.7623013258,
0.0163834039,
0.1987070739,
-0.1195664853,
0.1718467176,
0.2641701102,
-0.5592223406,
0.1926372796,
0.5211046934,
-0.6492926478,
0.6438553333,
-0.2102477401,
-0.2380916029,
-0.3166411817,
0.209619984,
0.4986334741,
0.9855804443,
-0.1339244246,
0.1275537014,
0.5584947467,
-0.46657148,
-0.1728601754,
0.3101108372,
0.2246811539,
-0.5188816786,
0.2707402706,
0.6433785558,
0.1132597923,
-0.4578810036,
0.2961123586,
0.1817735583,
-0.1003835946,
-0.3471795022,
0.0016407896,
0.0319945365,
0.3819166422,
0.5700817704,
0.0554738529,
0.1463276744,
-0.818959415,
0.3205608428,
0.7886947989,
-0.4454678297,
-0.2367922068,
0.5499170423,
0.2647914588,
-0.4190450609,
0.3875355124,
-0.1690031141,
-0.3439424336,
0.6899784803,
0.5749993324,
0.8463630676,
-0.3932968378,
0.4238703251,
0.1070925966,
0.1274562925,
-0.1523021162,
0.3902617097,
-0.0572798513,
-0.3922847807,
-0.7494211793,
-0.6705990434,
-0.6109938622,
0.1221675202,
-0.6292527914,
0.1171246693,
-0.4295743108,
-0.5210773349,
-0.1525695622,
0.284009397,
-0.5036631227,
0.5431957841,
0.217174381,
0.7499073148,
-0.6398134828,
0.7065941095,
0.8584467173,
-0.1572494656,
-0.5715079308,
-0.0311409347,
0.2442537397,
-0.786662817,
0.655777216,
0.1940041184,
-0.4863791466,
0.2314761132,
-0.2548689246,
-0.6343951821,
1.4136192799,
0.3254469037,
-0.0076762261,
-0.0497275852,
0.3049112856,
0.2617768347,
-0.7928404808,
0.7860643268,
0.1154591292,
0.2840723097,
0.2032283545,
-1.4567619562,
0.1772295982,
0.048795104,
0.0744590983,
0.4081940949,
-0.8367441893,
1.210983634,
-0.3790558279,
0.0951467082,
0.1574374437,
0.2454210371,
0.0131781884,
0.0755238011,
0.408190906,
0.4006258845,
0.7906041741,
-0.2466391623,
1.1520345211,
-0.2271093726,
0.4773385227,
1.1199197769,
-0.2760230303,
0.8832061291,
0.1238323823,
-0.2180820704,
0.3813767433,
0.6439114213,
0.1010415554,
0.6720334888,
0.2507218421,
-0.3878015876,
-0.4062657654,
0.0380310602,
-0.1434958875,
0.2486508638,
0.3241779208,
-0.13136971,
-0.4057708979,
-0.0180809647,
-0.0880988613,
-0.1822527647,
-0.419873178,
0.7870711684,
0.1850425005,
-0.5120311975,
0.4990181327,
0.0822350606,
0.4502851963,
-0.8183797002,
0.0717248991,
0.1017622575,
0.5137827992,
-0.2631151974,
-0.594560504,
0.3671953976,
-0.3860708177,
-0.1613038927,
-0.0773778781,
0.5177285671,
-0.3136826754,
-0.0932471603,
0.6193446517,
0.5077332258,
0.1686325967,
-0.3604498804,
-0.7837580442,
0.0506325401,
-0.2914188504,
0.0791649967,
0.4386740625,
0.1500423104,
-0.4131878018,
1.0529319048,
0.7520455122,
0.0032792115,
0.1462256163,
0.0599625148,
0.8024075627,
-0.450099349,
-0.2739740908,
-0.7063637376,
0.6297637224,
0.1936420351,
-0.2003191859,
0.4941299856,
0.5890715718,
0.6603038311,
-0.2551274598,
0.8857091069,
-0.0930677801,
0.1715047508,
-0.4479735196,
0.2876316309,
-0.3818698823,
0.0873727351,
-0.0993609056,
-0.8900640011,
-0.3337868154,
0.3117842376,
-0.8475253582,
0.549428463,
0.8098213077,
0.734962523,
-0.2466019392,
0.0794990808,
0.4003745317,
-0.0408493355,
0.3316773474,
0.4348735809,
0.5989457369,
-0.3520949781,
0.4570525885,
0.1028714254,
-0.6894211173,
-0.2359838486,
-0.6707491875,
-1.1393153667,
-0.6597308517,
-0.1721103191,
-0.3146460354,
0.3140788674,
1.0717231035,
1.1788957119,
-0.8464100361,
-0.8691253662,
0.069068104,
-0.1819258481,
-0.5675631166,
-0.1967340112,
0.145890072,
-0.7107111216,
-0.8868150711,
0.5428771377,
0.350093931,
-0.2436221987,
-0.0622471608,
-0.0397641994,
-0.0218337942,
0.3431415856,
0.6062295437,
0.2137938887,
-0.6331673861,
0.0452534743,
-0.0670572743,
-0.1082766578,
-0.00124195,
0.7890485525,
-0.5257449746,
0.2960159779,
0.1348655671,
0.7813698053,
0.7498925328,
0.0265580323,
0.3804114163,
-0.6780586839,
-0.2033274621,
-0.0256762616,
0.021357378,
0.3618882895,
-0.4042405486,
0.6009402871,
0.1144670025,
-0.7543967366,
-0.7098047733,
0.4152799249,
-0.8588262796,
-0.2115463018,
0.9972139597,
-0.260754019,
-0.361328572,
-0.1908688843,
-0.262613982,
-0.1007087305,
-0.3106095791,
0.6073286533,
0.6255654693,
-0.5908327699,
-0.1319078356,
-0.7236790657,
0.4541323781,
-0.0357700698,
-1.1017351151,
0.2692036629,
0.2228017002,
0.627051115,
0.3444781005,
0.7724867463,
-0.3180161715,
0.1485572159,
-0.0840800107,
0.0924667269,
-0.4547274113,
-0.689031601,
-0.0522229299,
0.3133894801,
0.2161593139,
-0.2642575204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19358v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19358v1 | The Model Arena for Cross-lingual Sentiment Analysis: A Comparative Study in the Era of Large Language Models | 2024-06-27T17:38:45 | 2024-06-27T17:38:45 | Xiliang Zhu, Shayna Gardiner, Tere Roldán, David Rossouw | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment analysis serves as a pivotal component in Natural Language
Processing (NLP). Advancements in multilingual pre-trained models such as XLM-R
and mT5 have contributed to the increasing interest in cross-lingual sentiment
analysis. The recent emergence in Large Language Models (LLM) has significantly
advanced general NLP tasks, however, the capability of such LLMs in
cross-lingual sentiment analysis has not been fully studied. This work
undertakes an empirical analysis to compare the cross-lingual transfer
capability of public Small Multilingual Language Models (SMLM) like XLM-R,
against English-centric LLMs such as Llama-3, in the context of sentiment
analysis across English, Spanish, French and Chinese. Our findings reveal that
among public models, SMLMs exhibit superior zero-shot cross-lingual performance
relative to LLMs. However, in few-shot cross-lingual settings, public LLMs
demonstrate an enhanced adaptive potential. In addition, we observe that
proprietary GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 lead in zero-shot cross-lingual capability, but
are outpaced by public models in few-shot scenarios. | [
-0.5095820427,
-0.2543129921,
0.5675985813,
0.5721489191,
-0.2161262035,
0.1977135837,
-0.2888497114,
-0.699432373,
0.0784229115,
0.240324825,
-0.2279721349,
-0.4829381406,
-0.6537781954,
0.4618213475,
-0.1648886055,
1.0086796284,
-0.0385474376,
0.2973096073,
-0.0233029388,
-0.4284080565,
-0.1280725598,
-0.8534864783,
-0.463162899,
-0.2263313085,
0.782405138,
0.1054956838,
0.6638405919,
-0.103193596,
0.5225001574,
0.1941825449,
-0.0559257939,
-0.2940867841,
-0.3765836954,
-0.4968509674,
-0.3870957494,
-0.5247423649,
-0.8807335496,
0.022033073,
0.7803820968,
0.655033648,
0.0887774974,
0.1050386801,
0.1544611901,
0.6714849472,
-0.412499845,
0.1785684973,
-0.6659700871,
0.2441715449,
-0.2444226593,
-0.0317645185,
-0.4005719423,
-0.16303958,
0.1834632456,
-0.4137422442,
-0.2207989246,
0.0228611175,
0.7448738217,
-0.0853890926,
-0.3731373847,
-0.1242576241,
-0.4684363902,
1.1076983213,
-0.9202055931,
0.5314152241,
-0.1233279854,
0.2104452848,
0.4216521978,
-0.5533343554,
-0.5560959578,
-0.1633467972,
-0.1127162874,
0.1614870876,
-0.5128698349,
-0.2479241192,
-0.0466294512,
0.1716744602,
-0.6303550601,
0.3483453691,
-0.3076171279,
0.0748216882,
0.5052057505,
0.1360050887,
0.300843209,
-0.5027768612,
-0.6785940528,
0.0641883165,
-0.876601994,
0.061052531,
0.0224434808,
0.5918497443,
-0.2751730978,
0.368250221,
-0.0293842182,
0.4882739782,
-0.125769645,
-0.2031019926,
0.3265629709,
-0.3474676907,
-0.5588284135,
-0.0872562453,
0.9839894176,
0.5029939413,
0.4004816711,
-0.1032455191,
-0.2724906504,
-0.1042505801,
-0.0939326137,
-0.6530830264,
0.1596446484,
-0.1177233234,
-0.5698189735,
-0.2200369835,
-0.090305686,
-0.7538228035,
-0.3290620446,
-0.2061968148,
0.4671503603,
-0.0348047242,
-0.4537920952,
0.1963181198,
0.1101981997,
0.5031078458,
0.2610720396,
-0.6761114001,
0.3753978908,
0.7970674038,
1.0332322121,
-0.5806615353,
-0.4855882525,
-0.2491404563,
-0.0984967276,
-0.3883380294,
0.7507577538,
-0.5704421401,
-0.4878541827,
-0.0260131899,
0.1695767492,
-0.3580645323,
-0.5232560039,
0.4308502972,
-0.4853222966,
0.4214459956,
-0.5102950931,
-0.0900909603,
-0.4145618975,
0.5364990234,
-0.4859459698,
0.7169739008,
0.0706057176,
-0.8342604041,
0.3324502409,
-0.7877751589,
-0.3683408201,
-0.1787303537,
0.0165299643,
-0.2096882612,
0.1881541461,
0.3881562948,
0.7002291679,
-0.4281071723,
-0.1025857925,
-0.7328022718,
-0.3338050246,
0.3183594942,
-0.4411176741,
0.7777388096,
0.0913249701,
-0.165671736,
-0.0402053446,
-0.5828028321,
-0.1425947845,
0.03284318,
-0.2735541761,
-0.4927960038,
-0.3617818058,
0.0593988933,
0.5995147824,
0.1548753977,
-0.5764807463,
0.022265071,
-0.3713160455,
0.2324689627,
0.722481966,
-0.2184114307,
0.6160659194,
-0.2023447305,
0.8143723607,
0.1159983203,
-0.0147240255,
0.2186821103,
-0.4038484097,
-0.5854300261,
-0.3374870121,
0.4482272863,
0.6405141354,
-0.6989974976,
-0.1572018713,
-0.6026771665,
-0.2463787645,
-0.6127578616,
0.1182561889,
0.1464558542,
0.3237839937,
0.3240860403,
-0.2474570274,
-0.4177207649,
-0.8804231882,
-0.355571121,
-0.2811392844,
0.0355687663,
0.3737691045,
0.2756184936,
-0.2149006575,
0.5852985978,
-0.0485414863,
-0.4497619867,
-0.5906279683,
0.1557505131,
0.1417794824,
-0.1674043685,
1.1100569963,
-0.512842536,
-0.9994452,
0.4650524259,
-0.6887196898,
-0.4411552846,
0.0201294906,
0.0381535739,
0.6570637226,
0.0930953771,
-0.6717066765,
0.0825211927,
1.1074286699,
-0.0992914662,
0.3950178921,
0.1468710303,
0.2832047343,
-0.8858261704,
0.22558029,
0.0267389193,
-0.3854115903,
-0.651863873,
-0.0695661977,
0.0040780026,
0.0842854306,
-0.830144763,
0.7294511795,
-0.5118669868,
-0.5593571663,
-0.2956331372,
0.3802702129,
0.0060076183,
0.4622323513,
0.3659719825,
0.5301969051,
0.5829068422,
-0.2862417698,
0.2750218809,
-0.0732277483,
-0.1771873236,
0.7290409207,
-0.5316565037,
0.0404551737,
0.1662510037,
0.213051632,
-0.7479966879,
0.061231643,
0.3188877702,
-0.3012349606,
0.2585373223,
-0.1320464164,
-0.2671571374,
-0.1358937472,
-0.4451562464,
0.2322477698,
0.4437023997,
-0.5800997019,
0.7111207247,
0.1954887509,
-0.6562642455,
-0.6161624193,
-0.9276624322,
0.2813096046,
-0.4171128273,
-0.5175871849,
0.0125663634,
0.1115026623,
-0.4405785203,
0.0996431261,
0.2012782842,
0.1288011372,
-0.0926033705,
-0.0068905801,
0.510232985,
-0.5043269396,
-0.187891677,
-0.2552129924,
-0.0092517501,
0.1295487285,
0.0026901136,
0.2743540704,
-0.3578375578,
-0.3145627677,
-0.1228910461,
0.2451302409,
0.7380113006,
-0.1169321015,
0.6615043283,
0.6298053861,
-0.0878321081,
-0.2264398336,
-0.2439449877,
0.292902112,
-0.361857444,
0.3704783022,
-0.4134516418,
-0.9011093974,
0.381962955,
0.3454090059,
0.0758368075,
0.4256007075,
0.7833722234,
0.2164949924,
1.1243412495,
0.5419871211,
-0.6338250637,
0.2980414927,
0.1057214662,
0.2397249788,
-0.7812154889,
0.2750992775,
-0.4339106977,
-0.1845877469,
-0.569524765,
-0.5354256034,
0.2096584439,
-0.2082745284,
0.0068069473,
0.1014261469,
0.1454706639,
0.1359866112,
0.047612045,
-0.5003870726,
0.4439698458,
0.1219176278,
-0.1177647635,
-0.1582761705,
-0.9042060375,
-0.5212261081,
0.972820282,
0.5990642309,
0.7027458549,
0.1971410811,
0.4484412074,
0.0979721993,
0.7549366355,
-0.7783914208,
0.67803514,
-0.5688340068,
-0.413993746,
-0.1293054521,
-0.4838539064,
-0.6406761408,
0.6725638509,
-0.1799173653,
-0.5209751129,
0.1737348884,
-0.2264782935,
-0.3634097576,
0.5015032887,
-0.5336692929,
0.8130109906,
-0.2813886702,
-0.2797731161,
-0.0674327761,
-0.3831882179,
0.5299246907,
-0.4413704574,
0.5852723122,
-0.1930996329,
-0.0736030564,
0.444293052,
0.0401125439,
0.8831958175,
-0.2699163556,
-0.408919096,
0.0453062505,
0.166730687,
0.3042583466,
-0.144633323,
-0.2590691745,
0.5005130768,
-0.0459823981,
-0.2186652422,
-0.5171684027,
1.000023365,
-0.8956428766,
-0.5668643713,
-0.437853992,
-0.4242000878,
-0.4095802605,
0.0232796334,
0.0133913113,
0.062986806,
-0.2872615755,
0.3315095305,
0.1688755304,
-0.3513626158,
0.5734943748,
0.6380166411,
-0.5894246101,
-0.1945586652,
0.7886596918,
0.3760043979,
0.4614316225,
0.5672725439,
0.3485351205,
-0.4129246771,
-0.3250254691,
-0.467574954,
0.2349876463,
-0.7738832235,
-0.1325382143,
-0.5933110118,
0.054718744,
-0.4757069945,
-0.2560733855,
-0.413672477,
-0.4723820984,
-0.1908406168,
-0.2882143259,
0.1164454445,
0.6577887535,
-0.2994018197,
0.0605830997,
-0.9904534817,
0.4266436696,
0.4532953203,
0.2731969059,
0.0211705305,
-0.7111402154,
-0.038442459,
0.007741462,
0.0599540435,
-0.7228610516,
0.6865745783,
0.1333259642,
0.4507229924,
0.2216582298,
-0.1250083148,
0.7123060226,
-0.2837864459,
1.0076230764,
0.1899419576,
-0.9776604176,
-0.0868456587,
-0.2735494971,
0.3186714351,
0.1122945398,
0.6001058221,
-0.6622458696,
-0.328317523,
-0.2289428413,
-0.5245693326,
0.803438127,
-0.2350446731,
0.048035007,
0.1360930055,
-0.184733808,
0.2141706496,
0.0532552749,
-1.2897186279,
0.2022216916,
-0.2475409806,
-0.0950575843,
-0.3756967783,
-0.1502444595,
0.015326581,
-0.045965001,
0.6309648156,
-0.1949166358,
0.0928684846,
0.0746945143,
-0.2732613981,
-0.1771369129,
0.6054781675,
0.4145433009,
0.4854078889,
-0.0393368974,
0.1825506687,
0.6734721065,
-0.1809428483,
0.084216401,
-0.0389602222,
-0.117002748,
-0.0611856803,
0.5008020401,
0.9461987615,
0.5058767796,
-0.2983864248,
0.6622418165,
0.0412463658,
-0.3204591572,
0.0611323453,
-0.2893639505,
0.0699997172,
0.275867492,
0.0859058797,
-0.1791543961,
0.0469280891,
-0.7384030223,
-0.3073551357,
0.4997767508,
-0.4197744429,
-0.6601165533,
0.3885276616,
0.1477455348,
0.0469319262,
0.2200872451,
-0.118402198,
-0.6438629627,
0.1243903115,
0.4993817806,
0.94778651,
0.0159569103,
0.2203370184,
0.065110907,
0.2779205441,
-0.1010600328,
0.1205291301,
0.1631134897,
-0.7749678493,
-0.6789083481,
-0.8058134317,
-0.4662242234,
-0.0210017189,
-0.5972425342,
0.1794850081,
-0.2932705283,
-0.1485203654,
-0.2400703281,
0.0654387474,
-0.705396831,
0.2089102715,
0.5866981745,
0.8566916585,
-0.9082466364,
0.9056073427,
0.8000535369,
-0.047754243,
-0.8214693666,
-0.0919562876,
-0.0162468608,
-0.7394214869,
0.7882274985,
0.1133451089,
-0.4681368768,
-0.1962586194,
-0.279222697,
-0.5586895347,
0.9596102834,
0.1523163319,
-0.6584842205,
-0.0500807948,
0.5461992621,
0.8252557516,
-0.5721377134,
0.0378993042,
0.5963122249,
0.5612369776,
-0.0923573896,
-1.130079031,
-0.0433666818,
0.0360434316,
0.0222507566,
-0.0421559028,
-0.7083507776,
0.901329875,
-0.0488149524,
-0.2189328372,
-0.0614703409,
0.5564911962,
0.3737879395,
0.256690532,
0.6016367078,
0.3843731582,
0.3306093216,
0.045679789,
1.1459050179,
-0.2114144266,
0.1967314035,
0.8186378479,
-0.9057487249,
1.3301678896,
0.5355352163,
-0.2927887142,
0.5425706506,
0.1818494052,
0.182188198,
0.3380738497,
-0.233996734,
-0.0819551423,
-0.2167338431,
0.1733444333,
-0.3005874157,
0.5576549172,
0.1720146984,
-0.2072645426,
-0.1465406269,
0.2122509032,
0.0180235151,
-0.1525019556,
-0.7342144847,
0.7098654509,
0.4807700217,
-0.5437066555,
0.369826287,
0.0395103097,
1.0010204315,
-0.5931181908,
0.3481839001,
-0.2956610322,
0.2376574576,
-0.2370675653,
-0.9625859261,
0.3719194829,
0.3292067945,
0.049736008,
-0.3361825049,
0.7699160576,
-0.1951740533,
-0.5759040713,
0.8546118736,
0.6247558594,
0.1776230186,
0.0145760654,
-0.8259420395,
0.089513123,
-0.0498016477,
-0.5259936452,
0.6368971467,
0.6038292646,
-0.1147656292,
0.4707016051,
0.6074693203,
0.5108962655,
0.2146036178,
0.3605709076,
0.6081197858,
-0.7202866673,
-0.3873870373,
-0.7517750263,
0.3161863089,
0.2440500706,
-0.0956758112,
1.0808475018,
0.1929592043,
1.0044560432,
-0.2093336433,
0.8894590139,
0.0770811066,
0.7302841544,
-0.5026189685,
0.5688219666,
-0.6878922582,
0.2692892551,
-0.3966243565,
-0.9609443545,
-0.4647057652,
0.5215755701,
-0.6110755205,
-0.0263681114,
0.4326884449,
0.7526282072,
-0.1406572014,
-0.1273715794,
0.6172648668,
0.3734702766,
0.1329623014,
0.549146831,
1.1035151482,
-0.103826195,
0.5940443277,
-0.1745926142,
0.0578000322,
-0.1468007416,
-1.0777961016,
-0.8981142044,
0.0342799574,
-0.110770233,
0.0551927835,
-0.1664966196,
0.746316433,
0.5165626407,
-0.6989271045,
-0.40159446,
0.3824278116,
0.0006282827,
-0.0197605975,
-0.2624504566,
0.1317756474,
-0.2316694856,
-0.6594084501,
0.3505035639,
0.5431238413,
0.0151212644,
-0.5561709404,
-0.1938848794,
0.0105485702,
0.3876590729,
0.9973307252,
0.2481467426,
-0.6841014028,
-0.3865215182,
0.2025821656,
-0.3120923638,
0.2460490018,
0.6288568974,
-0.5765044689,
0.047862947,
0.5475919843,
0.3871276975,
0.1797915995,
-0.067669332,
0.6049189568,
-0.6224728823,
0.0936010703,
0.0815862343,
0.5560379028,
0.6677203774,
0.0819590688,
0.3050338924,
0.1479567587,
-0.5219559073,
-0.8262743354,
-0.1134824753,
-0.9312140942,
-0.3835804164,
1.4025650024,
-0.2997821569,
-0.2101902515,
0.1833212674,
-0.1640048176,
-0.1659716517,
-0.1103437468,
0.5397568345,
0.7823024988,
-0.0469026379,
-0.2963193059,
-0.4504760802,
0.2751796544,
0.409965992,
-0.8127692938,
0.0108382134,
0.303619802,
0.3083524704,
0.1353884041,
0.6417536736,
-0.3059233129,
0.1675399542,
-0.1398639977,
-0.0988069475,
0.2223792523,
-0.3715701103,
-0.7605175376,
0.4351734817,
0.2992537022,
0.1715461612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19356v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19356v1 | DiVERT: Distractor Generation with Variational Errors Represented as Text for Math Multiple-choice Questions | 2024-06-27T17:37:31 | 2024-06-27T17:37:31 | Nigel Fernandez, Alexander Scarlatos, Simon Woodhead, Andrew Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | High-quality distractors are crucial to both the assessment and pedagogical
value of multiple-choice questions (MCQs), where manually crafting ones that
anticipate knowledge deficiencies or misconceptions among real students is
difficult. Meanwhile, automated distractor generation, even with the help of
large language models (LLMs), remains challenging for subjects like math. It is
crucial to not only identify plausible distractors but also understand the
error behind them. In this paper, we introduce DiVERT (Distractor Generation
with Variational Errors Represented as Text), a novel variational approach that
learns an interpretable representation of errors behind distractors in math
MCQs. Through experiments on a real-world math MCQ dataset with 1,434 questions
used by hundreds of thousands of students, we show that DiVERT, despite using a
base open-source LLM with 7B parameters, outperforms state-of-the-art
approaches using GPT-4o on downstream distractor generation. We also conduct a
human evaluation with math educators and find that DiVERT leads to error labels
that are of comparable quality to human-authored ones. | [
-0.4846668839,
-0.6488329172,
0.6466665864,
0.2390616387,
-0.2291415483,
0.2112288624,
0.0102030067,
0.0426863767,
-0.0570865236,
0.6058220863,
-0.9636710882,
0.0793137625,
-0.531717658,
0.1961255223,
-0.0088953124,
0.8504316211,
-0.3961399198,
0.2238416821,
-0.2209044099,
0.0273337178,
-0.5867592096,
-0.3609593511,
-0.3635625839,
0.1136032119,
0.7681443095,
0.5462830663,
0.4092334807,
0.4250781238,
0.5338102579,
0.2140371501,
0.0178643726,
0.3192275167,
-0.4333364964,
0.1024238244,
-0.3295555711,
-0.5192545652,
0.4382115901,
-0.3678531945,
0.6838383675,
0.7699997425,
-0.1680325419,
-0.2502173185,
0.0715884194,
0.5911466479,
-0.8682680726,
-0.1821110994,
-0.481618315,
-0.1042828858,
-0.2861765623,
-0.1534628421,
-0.4369566441,
-0.4549658597,
-0.026782807,
-0.4188380837,
0.4479789436,
-0.3581975996,
0.8054156303,
0.5072392821,
-0.4370676577,
-0.6688281298,
-0.763173759,
1.147102952,
-0.3384779394,
0.1782628298,
0.1785953492,
0.5688936114,
-0.0305367056,
-0.2856449485,
-0.3784902394,
0.1002217382,
-0.0147771649,
0.4428659976,
0.1469483674,
-0.4129971266,
0.2172653228,
0.131577909,
-0.0852843523,
-0.2157969177,
-0.5716430545,
-0.2692926824,
0.5837010741,
0.3628631234,
0.303648591,
-0.1710636765,
-0.4151236415,
-0.1940124631,
-0.7730941176,
-0.0394509248,
0.382619977,
0.1709300876,
-0.0178908035,
0.3827557266,
0.2650550604,
0.7604702711,
0.1175991446,
-0.0149747161,
-0.1940839887,
-0.2807240188,
0.209201321,
-0.5478781462,
0.620336771,
-0.0460533947,
-0.1733567119,
0.1693630517,
-0.081053026,
-0.2219103724,
0.2919202149,
-0.6788067818,
-0.2982417047,
-0.0210768562,
0.1398087889,
-0.1432501376,
0.0443255156,
-1.2612653971,
-0.3516435921,
-0.229817912,
0.1257476807,
-0.5778948069,
0.0664677843,
0.0128350202,
0.0758685097,
0.278418541,
0.7687856555,
-0.8469465375,
-0.0081715323,
0.1992644966,
0.4453857541,
-0.4569174945,
-0.5121642947,
-0.6471791863,
-0.0343706533,
-0.245796144,
0.9425860047,
-0.4234417379,
-0.6596981883,
0.0364647508,
-0.5383899808,
-0.4852119088,
-0.6300728321,
0.8620525002,
-0.5734793544,
0.6144980192,
-0.3873544037,
-0.4506803155,
-0.2577556968,
0.3170906305,
-0.7840799689,
0.7217929959,
0.5311156511,
-0.6788727641,
0.275056392,
-0.5082659125,
-0.1587296575,
0.1213015094,
-0.4458834231,
-0.4779986143,
0.2302434891,
0.36070472,
0.0101907235,
-0.4357459545,
0.4117317498,
-0.0044474797,
-0.0041395086,
0.7720575333,
-0.7612692714,
0.7650516033,
0.151288718,
-0.2085001022,
0.0601758063,
-0.6421274543,
-0.1637576818,
-0.0627196729,
-0.5773833394,
-0.2292149812,
0.1767695397,
0.0398062319,
0.5996554494,
-0.0700334385,
-0.4392742813,
-0.2308900952,
0.1122247949,
-0.0246149264,
0.8287177682,
0.0897120014,
0.1458041966,
-0.6169685125,
0.8772493005,
0.2288484424,
-0.0287055485,
-0.2305706143,
-0.3359804153,
-0.8754814863,
-0.5693213344,
0.2914256155,
0.4079543948,
-0.8226482272,
0.1595686525,
0.0309067033,
-0.132801041,
-0.0747674406,
0.1720987558,
0.293774873,
0.6383048296,
0.3850778937,
0.1168522686,
-0.4969919026,
-0.624048233,
-0.408945173,
0.368358165,
-0.2125194222,
0.7874128222,
0.4616260827,
-0.1554409862,
1.1343421936,
-0.8738535047,
-0.1717689335,
-0.1656925529,
0.1692621708,
-0.1598573923,
0.5354861617,
0.3183631003,
-1.1471092701,
-0.6105311513,
-0.3302893639,
-0.419862628,
-0.2546223998,
-0.5444633961,
-0.6379317045,
-0.0724723786,
0.292770505,
-0.4073087573,
0.102631256,
0.0900032967,
-0.3212940693,
1.0116339922,
0.1915878952,
-0.1988306642,
-1.1528295279,
0.0301817358,
-0.1457511038,
0.0652984604,
-0.4884718657,
0.0506098568,
0.3563666046,
0.0852521509,
-0.6323835254,
0.7360047698,
-0.3966435194,
0.5718991756,
-0.0135298455,
0.0254293289,
-0.0714827105,
0.256655246,
-0.0423217528,
0.6844137311,
0.2801648378,
-0.4845579863,
0.1023104563,
0.1532429755,
0.0197292026,
0.8137554526,
-0.1983749419,
-0.069180809,
-0.2239800841,
0.0352126025,
-1.1320796013,
-0.749199152,
0.2979872227,
-0.3538179994,
0.3526480496,
0.03924606,
0.0223891586,
-0.5381781459,
-0.3528555036,
0.5651212335,
0.4103645086,
-0.65155375,
0.8121020198,
0.0482542031,
-0.2273310274,
-0.907771349,
-0.5901070237,
-0.4226463139,
-0.279921025,
-0.2374471873,
0.1000157073,
-0.4850406349,
-0.0580804944,
-0.0382715389,
-0.2394638658,
-0.3822788298,
0.1286232769,
-0.0633183718,
0.5150996447,
-0.0700661913,
0.0235806908,
0.373884201,
0.1319376528,
0.2953326106,
0.0275907125,
0.5218818188,
0.3115587533,
-0.616832912,
0.0677747652,
0.4050657153,
0.4220700562,
0.1031563058,
0.4265099168,
0.1951241046,
-0.4593463242,
-0.4068798125,
-0.5940495729,
-0.1738693863,
-0.4701339602,
0.3267245293,
-0.4412338436,
-0.9029512405,
0.6754871607,
-0.1627976,
0.0546628013,
0.6069058776,
0.5549637079,
0.0285846367,
0.8389650583,
0.3826278746,
0.2804592848,
0.6402385235,
-0.1079035774,
-0.1353624463,
-0.8481734395,
-0.2007206976,
-0.4905104637,
-0.0793299526,
-0.1043136269,
-0.769631803,
0.0140502322,
0.367575556,
-0.1138651222,
-0.1378811598,
-0.3570356071,
0.7421220541,
0.4985440075,
-0.0360816009,
-0.0126263732,
0.0807693601,
-0.4340323508,
-0.3844028413,
-0.4872195125,
-0.3486024141,
0.9853136539,
-0.0500671081,
0.9465557933,
0.3043857217,
1.034922123,
-0.1067856103,
1.0285487175,
-0.7501221299,
0.2821730375,
0.0430324636,
-0.9280638099,
-0.390519321,
-0.8706154823,
-0.8541093469,
0.6794245243,
0.1933482736,
-0.5999775529,
0.3069372475,
0.1913096011,
-0.4358050227,
0.3193936348,
-0.5916589499,
0.6674849987,
-0.2942484021,
-0.6339133978,
0.3483679593,
-0.3897304237,
0.7816061378,
-0.4274821281,
0.3199677765,
-0.0301391575,
-0.0949056,
0.5374892354,
-0.3268769979,
0.8152127266,
-0.082533069,
-0.1786587238,
0.589537859,
0.4946560264,
0.2633576095,
0.1629055887,
0.0493703634,
-0.3999405801,
-0.4112446308,
-0.4209180772,
-0.5952841043,
0.6692050099,
-0.8026803732,
-0.4728099108,
-0.3188888133,
-0.8451616168,
-0.1141268387,
0.3750382364,
0.3945986331,
0.3642664552,
0.0001706721,
-0.0940903872,
0.5403693914,
-0.0988370925,
0.5253183842,
0.3839453161,
0.0966650993,
-0.8445836902,
1.1125500202,
0.1262280345,
0.2714264393,
0.5939887762,
0.4058865309,
-0.5938593745,
-0.2610590458,
-0.6199375391,
0.3519605398,
-0.7533233762,
-0.3382607996,
-0.4998460412,
-0.1726626456,
0.0971990526,
-0.5394819975,
-0.2090508789,
-0.1756462753,
-0.7305960059,
0.0527037084,
-0.2490307242,
0.5291690826,
-0.0777353123,
0.2252967954,
-0.8100651503,
0.0155985337,
0.6183981299,
0.20746696,
-0.1319558024,
-0.5063246489,
-0.0346785076,
0.1169562489,
-0.8847168088,
-1.0754407644,
0.5057067871,
-0.1186111718,
0.533914268,
0.513189435,
0.288574785,
0.4785202146,
-0.3858086169,
0.6542659998,
0.5585951805,
-1.081023097,
0.3454546034,
-0.4351756871,
0.3462569416,
0.50465101,
0.3970187306,
-0.4298938811,
-0.3088338971,
-0.6250461936,
-0.6882315278,
0.8770401478,
0.2862080932,
0.1335845888,
-0.0504061095,
0.1619119644,
0.3222947419,
0.0867011026,
-0.7935861349,
0.0319856592,
-0.2750218511,
-0.6126190424,
-0.0130992616,
-0.5287876725,
-0.3462747037,
0.2177202255,
0.3340053856,
-0.2607126236,
0.2193461061,
0.1995862126,
-0.2927353382,
-0.1710669398,
0.5559425354,
1.2479104996,
0.7883324027,
-0.0712423921,
0.2582882941,
0.2791939974,
-0.5449329615,
0.2844996452,
0.2992295921,
-0.5233801603,
0.0317492858,
0.0367932394,
0.4131788909,
0.1169880405,
-0.88746804,
0.3563450873,
-0.0307664163,
-0.3991782963,
-0.127639249,
-0.0736376271,
-0.0124556692,
-0.2843764126,
0.5597820282,
0.2625038624,
0.1100707576,
0.050808087,
0.2392438352,
0.1749216914,
-0.4509853125,
-0.3667015433,
0.6369603872,
0.3088103831,
-0.4258011281,
0.2197071761,
-0.1636734903,
-0.6305945516,
0.6084266305,
0.6778795719,
0.8500607014,
-0.4634887278,
0.3177882731,
0.4712055922,
0.0804255456,
0.0152888689,
0.3587022722,
-0.1426118612,
-0.8449380398,
-0.54457587,
-0.2199495137,
-0.8351616263,
0.0984668508,
-0.561535418,
0.107552886,
-0.4614810646,
0.1052103341,
-0.0893371776,
-0.4376294613,
-0.5308893919,
0.1242806092,
0.1993940026,
0.5025849938,
-0.5471429825,
0.1396470964,
0.8745151758,
-0.4697375298,
-0.8975308537,
0.2736104429,
-0.1653291583,
-0.318685323,
0.7110597491,
0.2387367636,
0.0083626695,
-0.1560260504,
-0.6209106445,
-1.0080755949,
0.6062784791,
0.407156527,
-0.4938229322,
0.0904944018,
0.3660583794,
0.1599847078,
-0.0700268298,
0.6200453639,
0.1606259793,
0.0308060255,
0.3395704627,
-0.2776346803,
0.1969736964,
0.0129940221,
0.023614008,
0.5060937405,
-0.7506114244,
1.2494385242,
-0.2376786768,
-0.2266878933,
-0.0767977312,
0.3678005338,
0.62123698,
0.1530964524,
0.3343711495,
0.2778281868,
0.7354533076,
-0.3059674501,
0.9327334762,
0.0155163901,
0.6238313913,
1.2118240595,
-0.2558829486,
0.7078377604,
0.7979604602,
-0.2874577641,
0.5105901957,
0.5444816947,
0.2105986625,
0.4187749326,
0.7109731436,
-0.4120522439,
-0.3359308243,
0.3023965359,
-0.0784434676,
0.0890594423,
0.6459783912,
-0.1115670726,
-0.4901231825,
0.1943347156,
-0.0698319674,
0.1164890528,
-0.088622801,
0.3829004467,
-0.0464193597,
-1.0171726942,
0.5526767969,
-0.1951126903,
0.7155730724,
-0.4508139193,
0.0184745379,
-0.6341254711,
0.4965027869,
0.1136222407,
-0.6830965877,
0.287838459,
-0.0597566254,
-0.2077159733,
-0.0387928672,
0.5612927079,
-0.3888833821,
-0.713490665,
-0.1112220585,
0.59789747,
-0.1071913391,
0.0242907256,
-0.5428745747,
-0.1734961122,
0.2013580203,
-0.039430324,
0.0582462624,
0.4751501977,
-0.0184028447,
0.6687574983,
0.5964660645,
-0.385414362,
0.4292266071,
0.0334140398,
0.9594841599,
-0.737729311,
-0.548111558,
-0.7873861194,
0.7701686621,
-0.0957887992,
-0.7045894861,
0.6810094714,
0.5590034127,
0.921335578,
-0.5376035571,
0.9103565812,
0.053153865,
0.8392323852,
-0.2983496189,
0.2405353934,
-0.375962168,
0.320391655,
-0.2562891245,
-0.7063043118,
-0.5534434319,
0.4825844169,
-0.5052176714,
0.0167497061,
0.7632246017,
0.4001649022,
-0.2043519318,
-0.0975793153,
0.4685207605,
-0.3671900928,
0.6265384555,
0.7232856154,
1.5102270842,
-0.3012902439,
0.961014688,
-0.3411870301,
-0.2039172053,
-0.4722382128,
-0.3930613399,
-0.959939599,
-0.2681714892,
-0.4493845999,
-0.3112773299,
-0.3422792852,
0.5779951811,
0.4303332567,
-0.8737850785,
-0.0867187977,
-0.4805791378,
0.6576033831,
-0.1658190191,
-0.3107376993,
0.4112324417,
-0.5021045804,
-0.8670557141,
-0.0923305973,
-0.1722941548,
0.3214377463,
-0.125529319,
-0.038784299,
-0.0326051377,
0.3791663051,
0.2725474536,
0.3446175456,
-0.7363590002,
-0.0383231752,
0.2250153124,
-0.272459209,
0.0243596248,
1.0265160799,
-0.4493761361,
0.4767162204,
0.4667027295,
0.7474877834,
0.3156125546,
0.0809449852,
0.3270975053,
-0.6769816875,
-0.2050262392,
0.6494603157,
0.2234202921,
0.3508843482,
-0.3767835498,
0.2014484257,
0.452321887,
-0.2963579893,
-0.8501810431,
0.4268620312,
-0.6773939729,
-0.2031645924,
1.1174228191,
-0.226892814,
-0.0883750767,
-0.0958879963,
-0.6472400427,
-0.0907152966,
-0.2621554434,
0.9034792185,
0.9251713753,
-0.1988096535,
-0.4463976622,
-0.3222211599,
0.4407294095,
0.7662591934,
-1.0241107941,
-0.0320852622,
0.7041171193,
0.3527092934,
0.5509225726,
0.310151279,
-0.0700156912,
0.5369756222,
0.2074140757,
0.0555903167,
0.2094518989,
-0.1051461026,
-0.3481128812,
0.2197686881,
-0.1411388069,
-0.3885219097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19354v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19354v1 | Fundamental Problems With Model Editing: How Should Rational Belief Revision Work in LLMs? | 2024-06-27T17:33:03 | 2024-06-27T17:33:03 | Peter Hase, Thomas Hofweber, Xiang Zhou, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Mohit Bansal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The model editing problem concerns how language models should learn new facts
about the world over time. While empirical research on model editing has drawn
widespread attention, the conceptual foundations of model editing remain shaky
-- perhaps unsurprisingly, since model editing is essentially belief revision,
a storied problem in philosophy that has eluded succinct solutions for decades.
Model editing nonetheless demands a solution, since we need to be able to
control the knowledge within language models. With this goal in mind, this
paper critiques the standard formulation of the model editing problem and
proposes a formal testbed for model editing research. We first describe 12 open
problems with model editing, based on challenges with (1) defining the problem,
(2) developing benchmarks, and (3) assuming LLMs have editable beliefs in the
first place. Many of these challenges are extremely difficult to address, e.g.
determining far-reaching consequences of edits, labeling probabilistic
entailments between facts, and updating beliefs of agent simulators. Next, we
introduce a semi-synthetic dataset for model editing based on Wikidata, where
we can evaluate edits against labels given by an idealized Bayesian agent. This
enables us to say exactly how belief revision in language models falls short of
a desirable epistemic standard. We encourage further research exploring
settings where such a gold standard can be compared against. Our code is
publicly available at: https://github.com/peterbhase/LLM-belief-revision | [
-0.0927358568,
-0.91730088,
0.8812292814,
-0.0025517314,
0.0465980992,
0.0304614864,
-0.2592016459,
-0.4093419909,
-0.1396788806,
0.5881155133,
-0.5603974462,
-0.4566047788,
-0.5255980492,
0.2541123033,
-0.1464077383,
0.7004337907,
-0.4767677188,
0.0949769244,
-0.3064751923,
-0.1002202779,
-0.4121001661,
-0.5181480646,
-0.5092775226,
-0.2850264013,
0.3148349822,
0.2521077394,
1.0092763901,
0.5939046144,
0.3440947831,
0.2646433115,
-0.5291540027,
0.3238551915,
-0.5206471086,
0.2428167015,
-0.4263184965,
-0.7755753994,
-0.6640229225,
0.2086483538,
0.7099270821,
0.5791543722,
-0.0477126613,
0.0008521206,
-0.2349351496,
0.4168392718,
-0.4158229232,
0.2305635959,
-0.9275000095,
0.0935754776,
0.0136592928,
0.0189978778,
-0.4494998753,
-0.4784271121,
-0.0126824826,
-0.6356150508,
0.3312785923,
0.0509335622,
0.8774575591,
0.3262989819,
-0.5191437602,
-0.2408795059,
-0.8065072894,
0.490601331,
-1.0255823135,
0.3654234111,
0.4126974046,
0.0079140225,
-0.4985736907,
-0.3402765393,
-0.7615248561,
-0.3106516302,
0.2677278519,
-0.1577685624,
-0.2000788152,
0.1365530044,
0.6071611643,
0.2706318796,
-0.279414326,
0.0175277591,
-0.2483794093,
-0.1932955086,
0.5852594972,
0.1772221625,
0.2608978152,
-0.1658604741,
0.0894513801,
-0.1302993447,
-0.9604301453,
-0.0882714242,
0.4151157737,
0.0505780727,
0.4680128396,
0.9464271069,
-0.2858915329,
0.6714732647,
0.1519327015,
-0.215813309,
-0.0386716127,
0.0252324995,
-0.3555621803,
-0.1725617945,
0.2587089539,
0.7089767456,
0.1378896832,
0.0311040562,
-0.5707881451,
0.2995255589,
0.1588680297,
-0.5037375093,
-0.0997042581,
0.1722546816,
-0.1618088335,
-0.5109591484,
-0.3813483119,
-0.2146668881,
-0.4901456237,
-0.5002109408,
0.6147775054,
-0.5000619888,
-0.0341596156,
0.4430437684,
-0.1348276585,
-0.1481509656,
0.9223029017,
-0.6767773628,
0.0809287354,
0.630939424,
0.5629851818,
0.2618073523,
-0.347429812,
0.179110691,
0.2742748857,
-0.5942128301,
0.7428156734,
-0.7242544889,
-0.6048686504,
-0.1761157364,
0.0291868653,
-0.0263209045,
-0.4722730815,
0.4715540111,
-0.5986025929,
0.2623333335,
-0.5109648705,
-1.2066220045,
-0.0977864563,
0.3353478611,
-0.4401631355,
0.8885730505,
-0.0352002233,
-0.8091321588,
0.0401417166,
-0.5625338554,
0.0696086511,
-0.4746037424,
0.0215772986,
-0.1766469628,
0.3884709775,
-0.2091777623,
0.1316552013,
-0.0162846223,
0.4447846711,
-0.4772574306,
-0.0129127316,
0.713865459,
-0.4365127385,
0.5984956622,
0.1125122458,
-0.0781040117,
0.1915969402,
-0.8003876805,
-0.1374354362,
0.2310533375,
-0.1985347122,
-0.4548113048,
0.1872733086,
-0.3293142319,
0.0451870374,
0.2527806163,
-0.7542279363,
0.7939921618,
-0.2714731395,
0.3943295181,
1.1928335428,
0.2712270617,
0.3262617588,
-0.5674324632,
0.3562118113,
-0.1740746647,
0.41736269,
0.0126255676,
-0.6373423934,
-0.8914971948,
0.1935462356,
0.5746874809,
0.5004495382,
-0.4007092714,
0.0211957041,
0.1201661676,
-0.5908254385,
-0.6934307218,
0.056942787,
0.1958363652,
0.5450116992,
0.3211320043,
-0.041883152,
-0.4720452428,
-1.07376647,
-0.4858273864,
-0.4130403996,
0.0522859469,
0.1027870998,
0.7234153748,
-0.4147448242,
1.1225510836,
-0.6926632524,
0.0385061242,
0.1161451116,
0.1100640893,
-0.0452352725,
0.5724414587,
0.2770315111,
-0.7119806409,
-0.2460667789,
-0.1226750165,
-0.7708085775,
-0.2786486447,
-0.1257435679,
-0.1567304581,
0.259049803,
0.2462967038,
-0.9921035171,
0.6517366767,
0.3356498778,
-0.3978990316,
0.8604112864,
-0.3095184565,
0.238253966,
-0.9546043873,
-0.2106675953,
-0.0912337378,
-0.1498251855,
-0.6790329218,
0.2689756751,
0.2047606707,
0.0576356426,
-0.3655329943,
0.3936651945,
-0.2393957824,
0.1757082641,
-0.2289908528,
0.0535145439,
0.0905293822,
0.335763514,
-0.0848762915,
0.5615148544,
0.1506623477,
-0.4658829272,
0.3231302202,
0.4138863981,
-0.2938424349,
0.2250981331,
-0.6117201447,
0.4634814262,
-0.1895454824,
0.3010157645,
-0.6359320879,
-0.1504222006,
0.3973493874,
-0.3862784207,
0.2522519231,
-0.2627136707,
-0.6791443229,
0.2201020569,
-0.1133886352,
-0.0350978896,
0.4564501345,
-0.1963855028,
0.4045990109,
0.3588131964,
-0.2805523872,
-0.5175405145,
-0.5192285776,
0.2322468758,
0.1181528047,
-0.7248892784,
0.4922991097,
-0.385909766,
-0.7237598896,
0.3335739076,
-0.3300550878,
0.0553252362,
0.1028717831,
0.0053184126,
0.4564790726,
-0.0001275021,
0.1428430974,
0.3736137152,
-0.1225012019,
0.1312289983,
-0.0757669881,
-0.0787041113,
0.0098004453,
-0.5891396999,
-0.2616317272,
0.0727919713,
0.482970953,
-0.1140957177,
0.4681214392,
-0.2084855884,
-0.7534405589,
-0.3276417553,
-0.6778274775,
0.0075543495,
-0.4311226606,
0.311522156,
-0.437184602,
-0.9861125946,
0.3671683967,
-0.2946664095,
0.3187555969,
0.3974187076,
0.6153791547,
-0.3487270176,
1.1282500029,
0.6129982471,
0.4359151125,
0.1431378126,
-0.1040504426,
0.0439594835,
-0.8158176541,
0.0561692156,
-0.4803890884,
-0.1777014434,
-0.3948366046,
-0.8590006828,
0.1843861938,
0.3940909505,
-0.0273121372,
0.1179273799,
-0.0565717295,
0.5666643381,
0.1280522048,
0.1693839878,
0.5881789923,
-0.4132089317,
-0.3153785169,
-0.4788326025,
-0.5198233128,
-0.9942225814,
1.1249645948,
0.4141117334,
0.8236262798,
0.2976810932,
0.3652534187,
0.4338200986,
0.4456269443,
-0.6024278402,
0.5863674283,
0.232176736,
-0.9155800939,
-0.1442112774,
-0.1628910601,
-0.2272004485,
0.473958075,
-0.2752439976,
-0.5678032637,
0.3444997072,
0.5125983953,
-0.0561239347,
0.7222325802,
-0.5473281741,
0.930742979,
-0.0817000046,
-0.2777888775,
-0.3835427463,
-0.3911208808,
0.4106066525,
-0.2603276968,
0.3672904968,
-0.1849979907,
0.0555120409,
0.4977659583,
-0.5753082633,
1.0772377253,
-0.1441862732,
-0.2507444918,
0.0453676693,
0.555084765,
0.7944645882,
0.2235151231,
-0.0486034825,
-0.2439613491,
0.3903699815,
-0.309586525,
-0.9543521404,
0.4041628242,
-0.7489008904,
-0.9979605675,
-0.4645111859,
-0.5359937549,
-0.5138784051,
0.0626943335,
-0.0180754326,
0.33437711,
-0.4779020548,
-0.1203635037,
1.0905768871,
-0.3134885728,
-0.1209818795,
0.7024077177,
-0.7814894319,
-0.151156798,
0.6857524514,
0.3868446052,
0.6257100105,
0.1784963012,
0.1549686491,
-0.063826032,
-0.751355052,
-0.3685425222,
0.1816014051,
-1.1028772593,
0.0831391215,
-0.5749830008,
-0.1344223022,
-0.3405144513,
-0.1485583037,
-0.4483298361,
-0.6331093907,
-0.2250058055,
-0.1640798748,
0.313349545,
1.0661346912,
-0.2031599432,
0.0604595691,
-0.6490226984,
0.31788674,
0.1807026863,
0.1717234552,
-0.19012703,
-0.7871641517,
-0.1256504655,
0.3032061458,
-0.2620438039,
-1.1606866121,
0.2059203535,
-0.1312769353,
0.4050726295,
0.1723909825,
0.2200220972,
0.7425647974,
-0.6300163269,
0.5013659,
-0.3843792081,
-1.2122148275,
0.7242695093,
-0.1843449324,
-0.0417406186,
0.3566516638,
0.3309208751,
-1.0602648258,
-0.6708212495,
-0.7316123843,
-0.1366066784,
0.4427056909,
0.2130984217,
0.0957060531,
0.1719883084,
0.7756448388,
0.1188218519,
0.1969252229,
-0.5068531036,
-0.2068303227,
-0.1333729476,
0.077970773,
-0.095682092,
-0.3947750628,
-0.1997009963,
-0.4969340563,
0.9750312567,
-0.0138146393,
0.056980405,
0.4930804074,
-0.400256902,
-0.4539274871,
0.5389544368,
0.7606914639,
0.9249908328,
-0.4710822403,
-0.0230396912,
0.3035239577,
-0.1208441481,
0.1928754896,
-0.2301101685,
-0.8188516498,
0.1934157014,
0.2264839411,
1.025642395,
0.4136922359,
-0.4958663881,
0.1679218858,
-0.165468663,
-0.3066794872,
-0.238620773,
0.0743515342,
0.2251342088,
0.2629672885,
0.0813846514,
0.621984899,
-0.1719517261,
-0.5058858991,
-0.057294149,
0.1632401198,
-0.1118644178,
-0.598235786,
0.5506000519,
-0.1400907189,
-0.5617540479,
0.3370291591,
-0.1869108975,
-0.7608391643,
0.3877891302,
0.6298686862,
0.5455421209,
-0.2625624537,
0.2513157725,
0.150707975,
0.6625631452,
-0.1081031859,
0.2306588143,
0.4485228956,
-1.0989556313,
-0.4953560233,
-0.3794749677,
-1.0532119274,
0.064533256,
-0.3998751342,
0.3276835084,
-0.7503014803,
-0.2038407773,
-0.0336619616,
-0.0758349374,
-0.3649204373,
0.1747390479,
0.025018638,
1.1797306538,
-0.7343218923,
1.0496292114,
0.7648894787,
-0.3431287706,
-0.5983654261,
-0.1030710936,
0.3703168333,
-0.5293573737,
0.420273602,
-0.2830838859,
0.0689648986,
0.0449534766,
-0.9334302545,
-0.7844856977,
0.7952670455,
0.6276863813,
-0.6327576637,
-0.2716751695,
-0.0310608838,
0.5352225304,
-0.2571366429,
-0.1136448905,
0.3966649771,
0.7441417575,
-0.0311738215,
-0.6858756542,
-0.1108406857,
-0.2444882393,
0.0291116238,
-0.0836350322,
-0.5698908567,
0.9921674728,
-0.2199102193,
-0.0115970355,
-0.0102450764,
0.6006277204,
0.2592646778,
0.0330835395,
0.5476016998,
0.7951853871,
0.9184379578,
0.0352455713,
0.85701859,
-0.1345656961,
0.6621464491,
1.1795988083,
-0.571231246,
0.9193528295,
0.4896106422,
-0.386259973,
0.2733217478,
0.8705324531,
0.0320276693,
0.2316477746,
0.1618451774,
-0.3117762804,
-0.4124223888,
0.0415727086,
-0.3778187633,
0.2364870757,
0.4757117927,
-0.0746401176,
-0.0371796116,
-0.1464375556,
0.3435764909,
0.0490930751,
-0.0532377176,
0.4486733973,
-0.003252015,
-0.4196729362,
0.3348315954,
0.6138457656,
0.3051016033,
-0.5991535187,
-0.1316011548,
-0.2306842655,
0.1470483243,
-0.1460446566,
-0.6402918696,
0.3688347936,
0.2841851711,
-0.275752455,
-0.3621091843,
0.7986781001,
-0.2953121066,
-0.522351861,
0.0792185515,
0.4565549195,
-0.0854575187,
-0.0760216191,
-0.8708504438,
0.4478850961,
0.1784557104,
-0.4442767799,
0.3848026991,
0.5190672278,
-0.0480045155,
0.7171428204,
0.8496116996,
0.4107765257,
0.0511415266,
-0.1976204515,
0.9017467499,
-0.811709702,
-0.2925072014,
-0.7826856971,
0.4093084037,
0.0440394618,
-0.3425422013,
0.6531589031,
0.2719452679,
1.0834076405,
-0.0470062122,
0.921702683,
-0.0250248089,
0.4498406649,
-0.758934021,
0.7423798442,
-0.394482106,
0.2773713171,
-0.367815733,
-0.9534558058,
-0.263929069,
0.6838235259,
-0.34417817,
-0.3066526949,
0.813200891,
0.9398881197,
0.0771143287,
0.3101788163,
0.3675437868,
0.8270995021,
0.3371954858,
0.2161539346,
1.2884324789,
-0.4847725034,
-0.0857918933,
-0.6088944077,
-0.1312294602,
-0.0481888354,
-0.8768286705,
-0.6411302686,
-0.4777237773,
-0.5337286592,
-0.4559945762,
0.2991193831,
1.2484886646,
0.2277467102,
-0.743806839,
-0.1986226887,
0.2630755007,
0.3558859527,
-0.0443603545,
-0.131298393,
0.1319526434,
-0.0521079116,
-0.6639071703,
0.5882505178,
0.2367082536,
0.2350558192,
-0.288012296,
-0.1180444211,
-0.3462685049,
0.3767221272,
0.4376141429,
0.2211094946,
-0.9584617019,
-0.6790841818,
-0.0620282218,
-0.1566804796,
-0.0421910062,
0.7979242802,
-0.3752147555,
0.6339945793,
0.2315232158,
0.6867541671,
0.2261782587,
-0.1684578508,
0.5926795602,
-0.2825701535,
-0.1482120007,
0.1873606145,
0.6066941023,
0.2785409093,
-0.1468310207,
0.2458784878,
0.8535108566,
-0.5563231111,
-1.1629648209,
0.1836276054,
-0.7455610037,
-0.3645971119,
0.9192003608,
-0.193483606,
-0.3037679493,
-0.0768196434,
-0.4938240945,
0.2904551625,
-0.0050593805,
0.7390742898,
1.1100124121,
-0.0640535131,
-0.0829624534,
-0.7408925891,
0.4690488279,
0.4492442906,
-0.4822513163,
0.3268487155,
0.7852219939,
0.5418149233,
-0.1500956267,
0.6300547123,
-0.0891786292,
0.1981521547,
-0.0152047202,
0.317858845,
-0.1644922942,
-0.1650997102,
-0.4913486838,
-0.079121843,
0.4629410505,
0.5478132367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19349v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19349v1 | IndoToxic2024: A Demographically-Enriched Dataset of Hate Speech and Toxicity Types for Indonesian Language | 2024-06-27T17:26:38 | 2024-06-27T17:26:38 | Lucky Susanto, Musa Izzanardi Wijanarko, Prasetia Anugrah Pratama, Traci Hong, Ika Idris, Alham Fikri Aji, Derry Wijaya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Hate speech poses a significant threat to social harmony. Over the past two
years, Indonesia has seen a ten-fold increase in the online hate speech ratio,
underscoring the urgent need for effective detection mechanisms. However,
progress is hindered by the limited availability of labeled data for Indonesian
texts. The condition is even worse for marginalized minorities, such as Shia,
LGBTQ, and other ethnic minorities because hate speech is underreported and
less understood by detection tools. Furthermore, the lack of accommodation for
subjectivity in current datasets compounds this issue. To address this, we
introduce IndoToxic2024, a comprehensive Indonesian hate speech and toxicity
classification dataset. Comprising 43,692 entries annotated by 19 diverse
individuals, the dataset focuses on texts targeting vulnerable groups in
Indonesia, specifically during the hottest political event in the country: the
presidential election. We establish baselines for seven binary classification
tasks, achieving a macro-F1 score of 0.78 with a BERT model (IndoBERTweet)
fine-tuned for hate speech classification. Furthermore, we demonstrate how
incorporating demographic information can enhance the zero-shot performance of
the large language model, gpt-3.5-turbo. However, we also caution that an
overemphasis on demographic information can negatively impact the fine-tuned
model performance due to data fragmentation. | [
-0.471267134,
-0.6304606795,
-0.021048557,
0.3668730855,
-0.1893087178,
-0.131717816,
-0.4090877175,
-0.6541134119,
0.0977427512,
0.7577537894,
-0.3301605582,
-0.5680958629,
-0.686216116,
0.2493277192,
-0.3336386383,
1.2041809559,
0.5767021775,
-0.1925511509,
-0.1129033267,
-0.4906269312,
-0.2939015329,
-0.5283493996,
-0.4814154208,
-0.0092746755,
0.7797479033,
0.5196239948,
0.4613473415,
0.6303436756,
0.2729594409,
0.221927017,
-0.2273982316,
-0.2132694721,
-0.3707584739,
0.5648742318,
-0.3459173143,
-0.4654514492,
-0.1123661324,
-0.1260024309,
0.2786598206,
0.4159188867,
-0.0763681754,
0.0554018803,
0.0441652685,
0.3919415474,
-0.7271074653,
0.3393371105,
-0.7930602431,
-0.1129509881,
-0.8215450048,
0.0256846603,
-0.3531171679,
-0.4957865775,
0.0301587991,
-0.365983814,
-0.2409769297,
-0.1607461423,
0.3745467663,
0.4096532762,
-0.6121978164,
-0.3144723773,
-0.7690774798,
0.6979165673,
-0.4905970097,
0.0431995317,
0.5397101045,
0.1767859757,
0.0808122009,
-0.2436214387,
-0.5901094079,
0.1137961969,
0.2662529945,
0.0824325383,
-0.1458214819,
0.1081035584,
0.0388277061,
0.1388051212,
-0.7010116577,
0.3606372178,
-0.7442142963,
-0.1645137966,
0.8524417877,
0.1477175355,
0.4303887486,
-0.6491333246,
-0.0973186046,
0.0960507691,
-0.5089306831,
-0.3815483153,
0.9216145277,
0.4699063599,
-0.0043774694,
0.639039278,
-0.0982718319,
0.4984600246,
-0.1925393045,
0.10694094,
0.3432289958,
0.0332899503,
0.2711111307,
0.4172115624,
0.7220641971,
0.5064298511,
0.6371586323,
0.1373668462,
0.3229084313,
0.3736572266,
0.3213316798,
-0.9170330167,
-0.2786846757,
0.2825918198,
-0.2474934757,
-0.6148200035,
-0.4963656664,
-1.2650883198,
-0.6886484623,
-0.1937377602,
0.1185158342,
-0.48381567,
-0.5454918146,
-0.4683515429,
-0.2178685367,
0.1153761446,
0.2835639715,
-0.762727499,
0.0698012561,
0.6707056761,
0.6015321016,
-0.3856233358,
0.172308147,
-0.1929322928,
0.0882210508,
-0.2634717822,
0.8194232583,
-1.1449034214,
-0.4423010647,
0.087604396,
-0.1592734903,
0.0288545769,
-0.7836837769,
0.8139476776,
-0.3125932515,
0.373719573,
0.243150413,
-0.5312381387,
-0.2098114043,
-0.0005248968,
-0.4708188772,
0.8857089281,
-0.0346900225,
-1.0981215239,
0.4660456777,
-0.6232269406,
-0.3746005893,
0.6414486766,
-0.1223361194,
-0.590307951,
-0.1373042315,
-0.1554168016,
0.3260575235,
0.0178526044,
0.2469485551,
-0.715243578,
-0.2652745843,
-0.0308834668,
-0.3938116431,
1.0863906145,
0.6357470751,
-0.3573032618,
0.2586037815,
-0.8688244224,
-0.4010280371,
0.1089160144,
-0.082994923,
-1.0112720728,
0.0721882731,
0.321873486,
0.300980866,
-0.1144308671,
-0.8571978211,
-0.1555105895,
-0.4027146399,
0.1981177777,
0.9486864805,
0.0514176078,
0.0434934124,
-0.2642791867,
0.4274010658,
0.0168166906,
0.2122613341,
0.1838866025,
-0.7063806653,
-0.3901367188,
-0.2476360053,
-0.1469411552,
0.8514636755,
-0.64738518,
0.5343755484,
-0.2788120508,
-0.8698310256,
-0.0349779688,
-0.1208287403,
0.0306594241,
0.2913950682,
0.274702698,
0.0069953445,
-0.9706041217,
-0.7486240268,
-0.5641006827,
-0.4098512828,
0.0079738405,
0.6236069202,
0.3264801204,
-0.2535867989,
0.584397912,
-0.1939532757,
-0.4280473292,
-0.180911094,
0.2277118117,
-0.1066421941,
0.3919323981,
0.507068336,
-0.9016689062,
-0.7701153755,
-0.18419981,
-0.5492233038,
-0.34552145,
0.3302848935,
-0.0687934235,
0.1724968404,
0.4390102625,
0.0425774232,
0.4694732428,
0.57065624,
-0.1712527424,
0.4376670718,
0.3559008837,
0.1397114694,
-1.0970751047,
-0.105661124,
0.167282775,
0.0202564094,
-0.6718063354,
-0.2329117358,
-0.2993830442,
-0.331468612,
-0.6551402807,
0.3441227973,
0.3264625967,
0.5552306175,
-0.154145956,
-0.1922013909,
-0.7362318039,
0.3131501675,
0.1515150517,
0.6932306886,
0.2376127243,
-0.4019495249,
0.4545186162,
0.3196787238,
-0.2879684567,
0.9802219272,
-0.1842472553,
-0.0811082497,
-0.4182448983,
0.4005849659,
-0.8022373915,
-0.6609382629,
0.3948656619,
-0.4396080673,
-0.0092401085,
-0.3693825006,
-0.3863095939,
-0.2843831182,
-0.2677220404,
0.6713503599,
0.4194432497,
-0.2624187171,
0.3836030662,
0.6864526272,
-0.6277640462,
-0.3345434368,
-0.6746966243,
0.1384462714,
-0.8571837544,
-0.4357792139,
0.1501564085,
0.0174272079,
-0.3202414513,
-0.0176838469,
0.1795628816,
-0.1358841509,
-0.1231251881,
0.6406677365,
-0.0040881159,
0.1715705842,
0.2691113651,
0.2154033184,
0.0229630638,
0.3738644123,
-0.18622531,
0.5582862496,
0.2356122136,
0.3120113015,
-0.2552507222,
0.3517227769,
0.7178357244,
-0.1820187718,
0.8970012069,
0.4251023233,
-0.5673121214,
-0.0044671325,
-0.3722435832,
0.0997721329,
-0.3825772405,
0.234048292,
0.0123246023,
-0.8347460032,
0.415381223,
-0.05489197,
-0.0872684717,
0.6876598001,
0.7120758295,
0.2453252524,
0.9454230666,
0.3395355046,
0.0087210182,
0.6126950383,
0.3893648386,
0.0827077925,
-0.4493196309,
-0.3907950222,
-0.8007696867,
0.3098737597,
-1.0102827549,
-0.3545798659,
0.5311681032,
-0.6414232254,
-0.5255550742,
0.3071543574,
-0.7360901237,
0.4874326885,
0.0985463858,
-0.000067197,
0.1623713821,
0.2126325071,
0.2719926536,
-0.5961864591,
-0.28114447,
-0.2390645742,
1.2997479439,
0.2070141882,
0.633351028,
0.0769339651,
0.5717836618,
0.538089633,
0.6700869799,
-0.2185299248,
0.2952179909,
-0.666957736,
-1.343113184,
-0.1245409474,
-0.6044396162,
-0.7422075868,
0.0391036533,
0.220941186,
-0.9261884689,
0.3856897652,
-0.0738958791,
-0.2455518395,
0.4244548976,
-0.5136014819,
0.837154448,
-0.0003270624,
-0.3201825619,
-0.4056145549,
-0.689027667,
0.5954684019,
-0.2767851055,
0.5217152834,
-0.5716875196,
0.0287207719,
0.8856832981,
-0.4168241024,
0.8859268427,
-0.26648283,
-0.0743259937,
0.2143492401,
-0.1446094513,
0.2475994229,
-0.1928500384,
-0.431070447,
0.3083275557,
0.0198879112,
-0.425825119,
-0.1560229808,
0.8112704158,
-0.661037147,
-0.1538073272,
-0.4828179777,
-0.2587581277,
-0.0380557403,
0.038106665,
0.469447732,
0.2020158321,
-0.0612912402,
0.3752616048,
0.6654387712,
-0.6607765555,
-0.0735899359,
0.2374804765,
-0.2621676326,
-0.4987885952,
1.4207553864,
0.4364638329,
0.1806876957,
-0.0336513631,
0.0929334089,
-0.3883137405,
-0.1134551167,
-0.2871129215,
0.0902273133,
-0.6137645245,
-0.2008985281,
-1.1176682711,
-0.2972383201,
-0.4130763113,
0.1047148183,
-0.3166928589,
-0.2490660697,
-0.1559149921,
0.0418218821,
0.567459166,
0.7238512039,
-0.5263203382,
0.2014123201,
-0.1728655845,
0.1071789712,
0.3511284292,
0.5710288882,
-0.2746326029,
-0.5771359205,
0.2446302772,
-0.0253053028,
-0.0088220239,
-1.087972641,
0.4370441735,
0.2320261449,
0.007337091,
0.2470274121,
0.6355688572,
0.5442157388,
-0.289971143,
0.6378811598,
-0.2433312386,
-0.5600908995,
0.8432881832,
-0.5797660947,
-0.11574357,
0.5553119183,
0.8059480786,
-0.7555997372,
-0.7482051849,
-0.6996352673,
-1.0805039406,
0.6931468248,
0.3173894882,
0.2964416742,
-0.1306701601,
0.0964382961,
0.2515678704,
0.0614274703,
-0.6009666324,
-0.3920178711,
-0.3857568204,
-0.4481593072,
0.2346292138,
-0.4170509577,
0.0186316799,
-0.3894726932,
0.6260986328,
0.1683137566,
-0.0138270166,
-0.2219752967,
0.0689787194,
-0.127040863,
0.3564605713,
0.3571768105,
0.2109081894,
-0.449237287,
0.0509296656,
0.1084481701,
-0.6584285498,
0.2382868677,
0.4362942576,
-0.057974007,
-0.1604652107,
0.1316936314,
0.511141479,
-0.1404100955,
-0.7301357388,
0.5207730532,
-0.2418717295,
0.0581894703,
-0.8247308135,
0.112576969,
-0.3067320287,
-0.161984399,
0.4938969016,
0.0830672905,
0.2561534047,
-0.2233120203,
0.4572432935,
0.0081969444,
-0.6840100288,
-0.1568979919,
0.9373883605,
0.4893347621,
0.0283967908,
0.5745512843,
-0.185814932,
-0.5361622572,
0.4448589683,
0.0883009136,
0.6637855172,
-0.6021196246,
0.3502759635,
0.6132723093,
0.275824666,
0.8096929789,
0.0628520846,
-0.022757031,
-0.4121277928,
-0.4630243778,
-0.7457906008,
-0.2548131943,
0.2790866494,
-0.6150233746,
0.1491011232,
-0.6490554214,
0.1272378862,
0.2245482057,
-0.0263238382,
-0.3361453116,
0.0636549592,
0.2980203927,
0.5925961137,
-1.1439379454,
0.5078558922,
0.496437192,
-0.3067437112,
-0.3155401647,
-0.0361869335,
0.5127286315,
-0.5871937275,
0.5093502998,
0.5215477347,
0.4224415421,
-0.0084107677,
-0.8192938566,
-0.5082094073,
0.2351085693,
0.1440979391,
-0.4009451866,
0.4378770292,
0.3820914626,
0.7549504638,
-0.1511485875,
0.1243663505,
0.543418169,
0.6161125302,
-0.0116182733,
-0.5895951986,
-0.0592638217,
-0.4193537533,
-0.1380020231,
0.0867917538,
-0.6627962589,
0.4534702003,
0.2987463474,
-0.2853009403,
-0.0259208418,
0.5347245932,
-0.047099717,
0.18578659,
0.7382820249,
0.5694058537,
0.339330107,
-0.0786320567,
0.8424608111,
-0.0034856724,
0.054267589,
0.8864066601,
-0.2855609357,
0.5307129025,
-0.0023191196,
-0.1612222791,
0.4264906943,
0.679284513,
0.2683345377,
0.3431212902,
0.2499969155,
-0.5776379704,
-0.5008496046,
-0.8347353935,
-0.4809771478,
0.6051186919,
0.8702358603,
0.0099965846,
-0.2435360104,
0.505025208,
0.2691838741,
0.2485016286,
0.0140917627,
0.9896042347,
-0.2582197785,
-0.4236294925,
0.2812298536,
-0.2145564109,
0.8512205482,
-0.3389266431,
-0.0273291096,
-0.2373225242,
0.3057993054,
-0.3040864766,
-0.9679924846,
0.8884973526,
0.2662148774,
-0.0372415408,
0.0526967309,
0.5455152988,
-0.7175519466,
-0.2909058928,
0.3721984923,
-0.2726565897,
0.3372046053,
-0.4958259761,
-0.6522718668,
0.512632966,
0.1069912389,
0.2183277756,
0.2456779331,
0.4878205359,
-0.2905251384,
0.5627321005,
0.5527626276,
0.0867426991,
0.181859985,
-0.1557443738,
0.7649356723,
-0.4422442615,
-0.316780895,
-0.497971952,
0.3713178635,
-0.4287208915,
-0.5686799884,
0.6561288238,
0.7221915126,
1.002592206,
0.278488189,
0.9929535985,
-0.3198261857,
0.9977183342,
0.2905980349,
0.7585950494,
-0.5176221132,
0.0206111595,
-0.4693180025,
-0.7873003483,
-0.585427165,
0.3913961649,
-0.5479382873,
-0.0538577214,
0.0072737983,
0.7557735443,
0.200652957,
0.3135593235,
0.1646652967,
0.5386109352,
0.6734756827,
0.3210861087,
0.7361129522,
-0.3223413527,
0.9363082647,
-0.5933962464,
-0.2904861569,
-0.3534514606,
-0.4276700616,
-0.6735474467,
-0.6866546869,
-0.4417541027,
-0.3864413798,
0.4476090372,
0.8826872706,
0.5240398049,
-0.9678580761,
-0.0477243476,
0.101736933,
0.1919458508,
0.2751069963,
-0.3259886205,
0.0139115853,
-0.0144987665,
-0.8250198364,
-0.0584513322,
0.49002105,
-0.1368822306,
-0.1543969363,
-0.022757167,
-0.2985311449,
0.1745409966,
0.6035184264,
0.5446299314,
-0.5391779542,
-0.2400577515,
-0.5840229988,
-0.0856766477,
-0.22544159,
0.4985179007,
-0.526324451,
0.6766198874,
0.4303133786,
0.5817818046,
0.296581775,
0.0489878207,
0.2522527874,
-0.6216960549,
0.4844411314,
0.486894995,
-0.1283809096,
0.4171009362,
-0.287669003,
0.4961630404,
0.5384175181,
-0.5911858082,
-0.8610629439,
0.1478466988,
-0.6377866864,
-0.2814019322,
1.0785359144,
0.1839792579,
-0.3260032535,
-0.5615843534,
-0.296015799,
0.1455495656,
-0.5076568723,
0.7049282193,
0.6052019596,
-0.0022279762,
-0.1778929681,
-0.4204708934,
0.6990268826,
0.4101304412,
-0.9423038363,
0.3116837144,
0.6433092356,
0.2157867849,
0.0994655639,
0.2356055081,
-0.395798713,
0.1862796545,
0.0093958909,
-0.0660845265,
0.3891612291,
-0.3246400654,
-0.1875173002,
0.1604382992,
-0.3640597463,
-0.0026666089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19317v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19317v1 | Jump Starting Bandits with LLM-Generated Prior Knowledge | 2024-06-27T16:52:19 | 2024-06-27T16:52:19 | Parand A. Alamdari, Yanshuai Cao, Kevin H. Wilson | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We present substantial evidence demonstrating the benefits of integrating
Large Language Models (LLMs) with a Contextual Multi-Armed Bandit framework.
Contextual bandits have been widely used in recommendation systems to generate
personalized suggestions based on user-specific contexts. We show that LLMs,
pre-trained on extensive corpora rich in human knowledge and preferences, can
simulate human behaviours well enough to jump-start contextual multi-armed
bandits to reduce online learning regret. We propose an initialization
algorithm for contextual bandits by prompting LLMs to produce a pre-training
dataset of approximate human preferences for the bandit. This significantly
reduces online learning regret and data-gathering costs for training such
models. Our approach is validated empirically through two sets of experiments
with different bandit setups: one which utilizes LLMs to serve as an oracle and
a real-world experiment utilizing data from a conjoint survey experiment. | [
-0.4737771451,
-0.6747410297,
0.7550473809,
-0.0405894779,
-0.0473137386,
0.1471441984,
-0.459894985,
-0.3109333217,
0.2930303216,
0.871949017,
-0.5135807991,
-0.6555714011,
-0.5977692604,
-0.2575989962,
-0.1401121467,
1.2788038254,
0.20125027,
-0.2161205262,
-0.1249119267,
0.1675757766,
-0.5009360313,
-0.7000477314,
-0.967043221,
-0.3081728816,
0.9094229341,
0.2045856416,
0.4900190234,
0.1484786123,
0.0683440715,
0.2331553251,
0.0052777785,
0.3284210563,
-0.7646496892,
0.1738882512,
-0.0559865013,
-0.6499646902,
-0.0387388468,
0.1114564389,
0.162903592,
0.5875367522,
-0.466704607,
-0.157250315,
0.0122713223,
0.4979800284,
-0.7699962258,
-0.0535373986,
-0.5798564553,
-0.0846733823,
-0.1161817759,
-0.3395588398,
-0.4712172747,
-0.5651862621,
0.7237440348,
-0.8712512851,
-0.0829595998,
0.0053577633,
0.4319702685,
0.2054712325,
-0.5102648139,
-0.4239104092,
-0.838078618,
0.7598706484,
-0.5747771263,
0.0946928263,
0.650993824,
0.3913692236,
-0.1661161631,
-0.5973370075,
-0.2552545965,
-0.2930939794,
-0.16488038,
-0.1728596687,
0.0727121085,
0.0681844279,
0.3154920042,
-0.1794992685,
-0.4159887135,
0.110427916,
-0.4279586971,
-0.132062614,
0.7158389688,
0.0197783876,
-0.0537766181,
0.0777436942,
-0.4995227158,
-0.2317128479,
-0.9914120436,
0.4400116503,
0.6962893605,
0.5287896991,
-0.0636692569,
0.491790235,
-0.2038988322,
0.9395295978,
0.2474049032,
-0.4767769873,
0.1628465205,
-0.1460870802,
-0.2047934532,
0.0871061534,
0.4523214698,
0.4460017681,
0.7512375116,
-0.0006573753,
-0.1921276748,
-0.1784058362,
0.282199651,
-0.5103518963,
-0.1368076652,
0.1487214416,
-0.1274981201,
-0.2441477776,
-0.0922931805,
-0.4903920293,
-0.4713943303,
-0.3020720482,
0.5104903579,
-0.4487687051,
0.140886277,
0.1287231296,
-0.2823329866,
0.2894625068,
0.4106653631,
-0.9209282994,
0.0330752917,
0.4246487916,
0.7173274755,
-0.0661618486,
-0.348005712,
-0.8688014746,
0.328517437,
-0.2993194163,
0.7870110869,
-0.5323373675,
-0.6514600515,
0.3711996973,
-0.2007379681,
0.0984624475,
-0.4013924003,
0.4009325802,
-0.8490216732,
0.3513402343,
-0.1676741987,
-0.5517331362,
-0.2210749537,
0.5039881468,
-0.3936238885,
0.9318861961,
0.0114205992,
-0.6096467972,
0.8309240937,
-0.6251209974,
-0.5622178912,
-0.0189026315,
0.0912342444,
0.0285046883,
-0.1529342681,
0.5220862627,
0.66590482,
-0.0590992123,
0.4780103266,
-0.4819513559,
-0.5636451244,
0.0637110844,
0.0393400826,
0.8251588941,
0.0928065628,
0.0222484116,
0.1467027217,
-0.3648696542,
-0.2754060626,
-0.0507348254,
-0.5704942942,
-0.7821931839,
0.2442364693,
-0.0211684424,
0.1075175107,
0.2572435737,
-0.2667430937,
0.5040944815,
-0.5499760509,
0.1908910275,
0.8889222145,
0.1149535701,
0.4752836823,
-0.3974706233,
0.3785507381,
-0.2360850871,
-0.1999214739,
-0.5190655589,
-0.3059979379,
-0.5784042478,
-0.3336220682,
0.3602805436,
0.6136371493,
-0.9292789698,
0.6225661635,
0.0198109206,
-0.2413089573,
0.2143866122,
0.2963237464,
0.0619569756,
0.1085002646,
0.2702511549,
-0.4160091877,
-0.573500514,
-0.7029379606,
-0.5010944009,
-0.1212370768,
-0.5011761189,
0.6138022542,
0.0720444024,
-0.4080681503,
1.2408549786,
-0.7679824233,
-0.4497447014,
-0.2732417881,
0.1414304078,
0.2956075966,
0.1972347945,
0.5839329958,
-0.4963107407,
-0.3913544714,
-0.4432061613,
-0.5416351557,
0.1402831972,
-0.2124451101,
-0.0782930851,
-0.0792014748,
0.3734587133,
-0.5879274607,
0.1522319317,
0.3078736067,
-0.2319737077,
0.1510042399,
-0.3663250506,
0.0846581385,
-1.1190233231,
-0.2532524168,
0.2823415995,
-0.1556228101,
-0.5111519098,
-0.2283202857,
-0.1580549181,
0.0883579776,
-0.3756574988,
0.6871142983,
-0.1920372546,
-0.045774173,
-0.0652176887,
0.2907159626,
-0.274800092,
0.5505251288,
0.3159051239,
0.6022991538,
0.625854075,
-0.8416427374,
0.176876545,
0.2775290012,
-0.5243213177,
0.6374812722,
-0.5359560251,
0.1201234534,
-0.1154487431,
0.5568554401,
-0.9696445465,
-0.388859123,
0.0737180114,
-0.347252667,
0.3052452803,
-0.4160816967,
-0.0716990232,
-0.158300072,
-0.468754828,
0.1606242061,
0.5094916224,
-0.714938283,
0.4984257817,
0.5029588342,
-0.337824434,
-0.7753793597,
-0.3941229582,
0.1033717319,
-0.5322704911,
-0.4028401673,
0.3415483832,
-0.034714289,
-0.2899944782,
-0.2627719641,
0.3443050981,
0.0487155318,
0.0542417131,
0.0338284187,
0.4198941588,
0.1506893486,
0.1447197646,
0.1007423103,
-0.0646933541,
0.0542435385,
-0.8404292464,
0.4164568782,
0.2894835472,
-0.1018854231,
0.1233889088,
-0.0250684507,
0.2195015699,
-0.0423482507,
0.5641243458,
0.6095507145,
-0.2998769581,
-0.2917149067,
-0.6716566682,
-0.1820803434,
-0.4652986825,
0.0479689762,
-0.0737755299,
-1.3487737179,
0.1241879389,
-0.2375797927,
0.263992846,
0.2082900852,
0.65724051,
-0.2403390408,
0.5916034579,
0.7694820762,
-0.183059454,
0.6111702919,
-0.2969685495,
0.0920905694,
-0.5950679183,
-0.1730165929,
-0.2049561292,
-0.2536123097,
-0.4805795848,
-0.5179011822,
0.430403024,
0.1109405905,
-0.254612416,
0.268276751,
-0.0139500992,
0.6366471052,
0.782432735,
0.1486548036,
0.0583051145,
-0.005623213,
-0.3665165007,
0.1330144405,
-0.6145490408,
-0.4062585831,
1.6834431887,
-0.12329074,
0.8987634182,
-0.0871259272,
0.8434927464,
0.6853601336,
0.3626129031,
-0.8672702312,
0.1917226315,
0.1708960831,
-0.7502247691,
-0.4772340357,
-0.245701313,
-1.1305963993,
0.0511296056,
-0.4849223793,
-0.8930258751,
0.1396455914,
0.3292663991,
-0.9566840529,
0.2342213541,
-0.5669968724,
0.5609794855,
-0.5105763078,
-0.470795691,
-0.2395207882,
-0.7425613403,
0.8225550652,
-0.1223491281,
0.3548521996,
-0.1382956952,
-0.1163674667,
0.9009783864,
-0.2231340259,
1.0169479847,
-0.4024842978,
-0.0662381351,
0.5114965439,
0.0986664295,
0.7347303629,
0.2457011044,
0.3286180198,
0.1470542252,
-0.3034602702,
-0.2579928637,
-0.3769161105,
0.8287035823,
-0.7275575399,
-0.5868141651,
-0.3668098152,
-0.3964008391,
-0.5398414135,
0.0280733965,
-0.0974292979,
0.2258726656,
-0.3414044678,
0.3052873909,
0.7618944049,
-0.269443512,
0.436655432,
0.3943724632,
-0.2765794396,
-0.6293630004,
0.6080572605,
-0.0678290352,
-0.0457043163,
0.4082217515,
0.0976182967,
-0.5133445859,
-0.4071260393,
-0.4575153589,
-0.0516790412,
-0.628870368,
-0.0735835508,
-0.6650406122,
0.2609528601,
-0.2276688367,
-0.5732784271,
0.00299103,
-0.1662643105,
-0.0906005576,
-0.1190015823,
0.5229489207,
0.8315571547,
-0.1233194172,
0.5876441002,
-0.8286746144,
0.1654914021,
0.7089005113,
0.3410989344,
-0.2682251036,
-0.5085417628,
-0.5039758682,
-0.1324730963,
-0.1160744056,
-0.6672481298,
0.5297558904,
-0.0208760668,
0.6881460547,
0.7833483219,
-0.0072540967,
0.4019341171,
-0.4807870686,
0.8424773812,
0.1296017468,
-0.6677561402,
0.4288699031,
-0.7327691913,
0.0791891217,
0.5625856519,
0.9439803958,
-0.4139895737,
0.1433236003,
-0.3374302983,
-0.8372310996,
0.7766598463,
-0.0980796292,
0.1090208292,
0.2143892348,
0.4142402709,
0.157353878,
0.2337344885,
-0.4640176892,
-0.0961019173,
0.1807502657,
0.1451567411,
-0.8636989594,
-0.2907734811,
-0.361639291,
0.0030469403,
0.444981277,
-0.3139452636,
-0.1257562488,
-0.1296132058,
-0.3115978837,
0.1053885818,
0.0916109681,
0.4784992337,
0.737940371,
-0.3635583818,
-0.0371451937,
0.4140276611,
-0.0428541228,
0.3001133502,
0.0365575403,
-0.343878448,
-0.4037535489,
0.2670476139,
0.7037995458,
0.6784105301,
-0.9374729395,
0.4048086703,
-0.0969545022,
-0.2762522697,
-0.4215619564,
0.178832829,
0.4040379822,
0.3504254818,
0.5489019156,
0.1918608248,
0.131371364,
-0.455780983,
0.25256598,
0.6779289842,
-0.0857961997,
0.0448490381,
0.2416429073,
0.4017571211,
-0.4100462794,
0.3209126294,
0.108032167,
-0.3546841741,
0.1573293656,
0.3372291625,
0.8845754266,
0.00047711,
0.0775198564,
0.4688323438,
0.2849046886,
-0.13202402,
-0.3034738004,
-0.4363026619,
-0.8315629363,
-0.5038107038,
-0.6891922355,
-0.6470034122,
-0.1174701229,
-0.51595819,
0.6877236366,
-0.4629458785,
-0.0524471514,
-0.2610007226,
-0.0045110849,
-0.7462626696,
0.2105617523,
0.3837628663,
0.6847531199,
-0.6353186965,
0.8492742181,
0.4565595388,
-0.1490332186,
-0.4064671099,
0.1628687978,
0.013683741,
-0.7968764305,
0.5496884584,
0.0539185591,
-0.1753279269,
0.0067734509,
-0.6505438685,
-1.0826412439,
1.0881915092,
0.1788712591,
-0.4558525085,
-0.1215447485,
-0.5088242888,
0.2499402165,
-0.6809325814,
0.4378231168,
0.7102436423,
0.5562821031,
0.3854457438,
-0.7234327197,
-0.3052434325,
0.2620146573,
0.066930823,
0.2110915184,
-0.2556439042,
0.9157205224,
-0.5349446535,
-0.0367860757,
-0.3284741342,
0.4317005873,
0.4696996212,
0.2241004854,
0.7710094452,
0.493285507,
0.760720849,
0.0170995053,
1.1349321604,
-0.2953265607,
0.0757059082,
1.0579942465,
-0.548638165,
0.9500296712,
0.2671428323,
-0.3624558449,
0.7439149022,
1.0323708057,
0.3272403777,
0.5362175107,
0.1659009159,
-0.2541825473,
-0.4682354629,
0.3151252568,
-0.2949411571,
0.3951668441,
0.433824122,
-0.123956807,
-0.2150036991,
-0.003422871,
-0.0206677932,
-0.0964853317,
-0.2371864319,
1.0007884502,
-0.221679762,
-0.9569205046,
0.5624482632,
0.2518330216,
1.2449115515,
-1.0703465939,
0.1491322219,
-0.2400553972,
-0.0084703993,
0.0613547899,
-0.5268350244,
0.0158978589,
0.110253796,
-0.081676878,
-0.2375720292,
0.8608915806,
-0.5690507293,
-0.2727944255,
0.3114813268,
0.7170299292,
0.143787086,
-0.0683579892,
-0.3540663719,
-0.3959504664,
-0.1469334662,
-0.4712694585,
0.61756742,
0.0692495555,
-0.0262993835,
0.623686552,
1.2055838108,
-0.1164364293,
-0.0769316405,
-0.2324678898,
0.9318112135,
-0.8056313396,
-0.7366834283,
-0.8179185987,
0.3529402614,
-0.0397334248,
-0.1775940508,
0.8569920063,
0.4706610739,
1.1561009884,
-0.1779231578,
1.024571538,
0.0395203419,
0.3640860617,
-0.6685810685,
0.5376343727,
-0.3877399564,
0.2630898654,
-0.0618219562,
-0.9074783921,
-0.189746201,
0.5265744328,
-0.6112712026,
0.186621204,
0.333628118,
0.6520228982,
0.0823741406,
-0.3621669114,
0.5149210691,
-0.2208454907,
-0.0021966314,
0.6684957147,
0.9184902906,
0.1112946197,
0.4594997168,
0.0346263312,
-0.2537240088,
-0.3905365169,
-1.0025566816,
-1.2255829573,
-0.1613754928,
0.2143451273,
-0.2645299137,
0.127295509,
1.37289536,
0.9127537012,
-0.6216036081,
-0.581738174,
0.3172368407,
0.3181337714,
-0.0792792141,
-0.1694969833,
0.0012354765,
-0.4955381751,
-0.7150578499,
0.7288794518,
0.2644838095,
-0.0555016659,
-0.5637772083,
-0.4595605433,
-0.5111044049,
0.3722861409,
0.8184350133,
0.2252058238,
-0.82548666,
-0.1448934078,
-0.063327238,
0.1264832169,
-0.0892729238,
1.2858170271,
-1.3348995447,
0.402993679,
0.3035021126,
0.6248959899,
0.9453728795,
-0.0216418598,
0.709669292,
-0.7536172867,
0.290504545,
0.0781701878,
0.3662270904,
0.2518381774,
-0.382679373,
0.3656099439,
0.1704705954,
-0.2748227715,
-0.5993103981,
-0.001561536,
-0.6309096217,
-0.2774730921,
1.0791962147,
-0.4921181202,
0.1475228816,
-0.1177471802,
-0.3203240931,
-0.1412396431,
-0.5323296189,
0.6239383817,
0.7098852992,
-0.0842869356,
0.1543945223,
-0.3178034425,
0.6499558687,
0.1104672253,
-0.87073493,
-0.0004611163,
0.6723024249,
0.2792932689,
0.0580244176,
0.6261301041,
0.5140396357,
0.104834348,
-0.0276142396,
0.1632386893,
-0.0882758275,
-0.5937274694,
-0.347435385,
0.4245648086,
0.0993091464,
0.2363399565
] |